Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00170-009-2466-0
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 25 November 2008 / Accepted: 23 November 2009 / Published online: 5 January 2010
# Springer-Verlag London Limited 2009
helicopter transmissions, motorcycle gears, reducers, and in manufactured with the industrial three-axis CNC milling
other branches of industry. As far as manufacturing is machine; (3) this method is more economical than using the
concerned, the gears are machined by a special type of special machine tool. One of the main points which
machine tools, such as gear hobbing and shaping machines. separate our work from previous ones is developing an
Recently, special CNC-based gear manufacturing machine automatic computer model in order to simulate the process
tools are used in industrial practice. This may be why literature entirely and obtain machining parameter. All previous
on gear manufacturing is sparse in the open research domain. studies have been engaged in calculating complicated
Recently, CNC-based gear manufacturing machine tools have mathematical equations and designing geometric models.
been developed and increasingly used in industrial practice. In view of the above, special attention is given to
However, their kinematic structure is still inherently different experimental tests rather than presenting geometrical or
from the industrial CNC milling machine, as the former is mathematical model of SBGs. This is the first time that
designed for a special type of cutter. mechatronic tools and a three-axis CNC milling machine
Previous studies on gears have been mainly concerned are being used simultaneously in manufacturing a special
with the design and analysis of gears. The geometric gear and even a mechanical element.
characteristics and design parameters of gears have been
studied [4–8]. Tsai and Chin [4] presented a mathematical
surface model for bevel gears (straight and SBGs) based on 2 Geometric specifications of the spiral bevel gears
basic gearing kinematcis and involute geometry along the
tangent planes. Later, this method was compared with Most of the time, the geometric parameters of a gear are
another model based on exact spherical involute curves by provided with an engineering drawing. Some parameters
Al-daccak et al. [5]. Shunmugan et al. [6, 7] presented a (principal parameters) are required for defining the geom-
different model, and its accuracy (compared with the spiral etry. Figure 1 shows module, spiral angle, and number of
bevel gear manufactured by special machine tools) was teeth of gear. Table 1 summarizes these parameters
verified in terms of nominal deviation. including relationships among parameters for the gear
For crown gears, a few results are available. Litvin and which has been manufactured in our test. To calculate
Kim [8] suggested a generation method for an involute these parameters, we have used “drive component devel-
curve from a modified base circle for a spur gear. Umeyama opment software” called GearTrax.
[9] designed a standard profile at the pitch circle and a The design of spiral bevel gear requires high-accuracy
modified profile at the top/bottom face gear with a mathematical calculations, and the generation of such gear
determination of the modification value for transmission drives requires not only high-quality equipment and tools
error of helical gear. Tamura et al. [10, 11] studied a point for manufacturing of such gear drives but also the
contact model for a bevel gear using a flat surface tooth. development of the proper machine-tool settings. Such
These studies are concerned with the generation of the tooth settings are not standardized but have to be determined for
profile for special gear machines, such as gear hobbing and each case of design (depending on geometric parameters of
shaping machines, which are specially designed for the gear drive and generating tools) to guarantee the
manufacturing gears. Suh et al. [12] investigated the required quality of the gear drives.
possibility of a sculptured surface-machining method for
the manufacture of spiral bevel gears and verified the
possibility by presenting tool-path generation using a four- Fig. 1 Module, spiral angle,
and number of teeth of gear
axis CNC milling machine interfaced with a rotary-tilt
table. A model-based inspection method for the spiral bevel
gears was also presented [13].
In this paper, we attempt to present a new manufacturing
procedure of SBGs by using a three-axis milling machine
interfaced with a PLC module which operates as an
indexing table. In terms of production rate, it is obvious
that this method will be lower than that of the special
machine tool. Other than production rate, this method is
advantageous in the following respects: (1) the convention-
al method requires a large investment for obtaining various
kinds of special machinery and cutters dedicated to a very
limited class of gears in terms of gear type, size, and
geometry; (2) by this method, various types of gears can be
Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2010) 49:1069–1077 1071
Fig. 4 Simulation of cutting gear Fig. 6 Motor torque diagram achieved by CAE system
Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2010) 49:1069–1077 1073
Fig. 15 A photograph of the experimental cutting Fig. 17 An overall picture of cutting spiral bevel gear
Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2010) 49:1069–1077 1077
equal to diametral pitch, and all the above stages will simple and inexpensive, and standard CNC milling ma-
be repeated again. The diametral pitch is measured chine is used. So, it does not need skilled operator to set up
by a 1,024-pulse/revolution rotary encoder. the system. Compared to the conventional gear cutting
method in which dedicated machine tools is required, the
The traditional procedure (Fig. 9) is quite slow, and presented method can easily be modified to produce any
considerable care is required by the operator. Likewise, the type and size of SBGs or any other types of gears. In
procedure utilized is essentially the same as on a universal comparison to manual cutting machine, it is a complete
milling machine. In contrast, after setup, the various automatic method in which all machining parameters are
operations are completed automatically. The machining derived from the computer model. It is also a multi-
configuration and a photocopy of the experimental cutting deception system (use of mechatronic and CNC systems)
are shown in Figs. 15 and 16. which is a dynamic and constant evolving technology.
In an advantageous embodiment of the method accord-
ing to the present invention, machining time is one of the
most factors which have been greatly noted. For example, it References
took only 2 min to cut one tooth space completely. While,
in traditional method, it took more than half an hour to cut 1. De Garmo EP, Black JT (1957) Materials and processes in
same tooth space. manufacturing. Prentice–Hall, New York
In a further advantageous embodiment of the present 2. Shigley JE (1986) Mechanical engineering design. McGraw-Hill,
New York
invention with respect to manual cutting, the instant for the
3. Maitra GM (1994) Handbook of gear design. McGraw-Hill, New York
angular compensation of the cutter head is set shortly 4. Tsai Y, Chin P (1987) Surface geometry of straight and spiral
before the end of the plunge process. bevel gears. ASME J Mech Trans Autom Des 109(4):443–449
5. Al-daccak M, Angeles J, Gonzalez-Palacios M (1994) The
modeling of bevel gears using the exact spherical involute. ASME
J Mech Des 116:364–368
4 Machining strategy 6. Shunmugam M, Narayana S, Jayapraksh V (1998) Establishing
gear tooth surface geometry and normal deviation: part 1—
The workpiece is wood, and the blank material is prema- cylindrical gears. J Mech Mach Theory 33(5):517–524
7. Shunmugam M, Rao B, Jayaprakash V (1998) Establishing gear
chined as a conic (face angle of the gear) form by turning
tooth surface geometry and normal deviation: part 2—bevel gears.
operation. Standard cutter No. 5 used in our experiment is J Mech Mach Theory 33(5):525–534
mounted on the machine spindle, and the gear blank is 8. Litvin F, Kim D (1997) Generation and simulation of meshing of
mounted on outward shaft of worm gearbox. The tool is fed modified involute spur gears with localized bearing contact and
reduced level of transmission errors. ASME J Mech Des 119:96–100
subsequently (around 30 machining sequences to prevent
9. Umeyama M (1995) Effects of tooth surface modifications on the
spoiling work) toward the center of the gear blank to the transmission error of a helical gear pair and its opimization. Trans
desired tooth depth. When one tooth space has been Jpn Soc Mech Eng C 61(582):8–15
completed, the tool is withdrawn; the gear blank is indexed 10. Tamura H, Tanaka K (1992) A method of cutting spiral bevel
gears using a quasi-complementary crown gears. Trans Jpn Soc
using the AC motor based on explained procedure and then
Mech Eng C 58(547):202–208
is followed by cutting the next tooth space. 11. Tamura H et al (1997) Method for cutting straight bevel gears
Having looked at all the mentioned stages above, the using a quasi-complementary crown gears. Trans Jpn Soc Mech
following diagram can be considered as an overall picture Eng C 63(606):259–264
12. Suh S, Ji W, Chung D (2001) Sculptured surface machining of
of this invention (Fig. 17).
spiral bevel gears with CNC milling machine. Int J Mach Tools
Manuf 41:833–850
13. Suh S, Lee E, Kim H (2002) Geometric error measurement of
5 Conclusions spiral bevel gears using a virtual gear model for STEP-NC. Int J
Mach Tools Manuf 42:335–342
14. Krenzer TJ (1990) Face-milling or face hobbing, AGMA.
In this paper, we attempted to manufacture the spiral bevel technical paper, 90 FTM 13
gear using a three-axis CNC milling machine based on 15. Pitts LS, Boch MJ (1997) Design and development of bevel and
form milling method. For such a purpose, we investigated a hypoid gears using the face hobbing method. Cat. No. 4332, The
Gleason Works
CAD/CAM model of cutting procedure and also tool path
16. Suh S, Kang J (1995) Process planning for multi-axis NC
computing algorithm. All previous works have been machining of free surfaces. Int J Prod Res 33:2723–2738
concerned with the design aspect using complicated 17. Dudley DW (1962) Dudley’s gear handbook. The design,
mathematical procedure, and experimental manufacturing manufacture and application of gears. McGraw-Hill, New York
18. Jaeschke R (1978) Controlling power transmission systems.
methods have not been explicitly focused. Basically, form
Penton/IPC, Cleveland, pp 210–215
cutting uses a simple and flexible method of machining of 19. Campbell S (1987) Solid-state AC motor controls. Marcel Dekker,
gears. The equipment and cutters required are relatively New York, pp 79–189 ISBN 0-8247-7728-X