Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Toru OKA , Hirotsugu FUJIWARA , Kazuo TAKASHIMA , Teruo USAMI &
Yoshikazu TSUTAKA (1998) Development of Fiber Optic Radiation Monitor using Plastic
Scintillation Fibers, Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology, 35:12, 857-864, DOI:
10.1080/18811248.1998.9733958
We have developed a radiation monitor by using plastic scintillation fibers (PSF), which we call the fiber
optic radiation monitor. For wide-area radiation monitoring, the detection part needs to be longer, therefore
we have produced a prototype monitor by combining the PSF and the silica fiber for optical propagation.
In this paper we first explain the characteristics when silica fiber of 100m long is connected to the PSF.
We found that in this case, the position resolution would drop. In order to determine the cause, we observed
the aspects of optical pulse propagation. It was found that the light is transmitted through the silica fiber
and is detected at fiber end as single photons, and the resolution deteriorated due to the difference in the
Downloaded by [CEA Saclay] at 08:28 23 February 2016
857
858 T. OKA et al.
Radiation Source
MCA
Scintillation Fiber
p
z = {v(At - Td) + L}/2,
2500 I I
(1)’
I I
1
where v: Speed of light in the optical fiber
L: Optical fiber’s length
Td:Delay time set by the delay circuit. ( T d must
be set so that At is more than 0.)
Therefore, the radiation incident position (z) may be
Downloaded by [CEA Saclay] at 08:28 23 February 2016
-
monitor with a single PSF.
Therefore, we decided t o construct a long fiber optic
radiation monitor by combining a PSF with a silica fiber
Numerical Aperture ( NA ) :sin 6 featuring minimum propagation loss.
Fig. 2 Definition of NA
1. Position Detection by Using a PSF Connected
with a Silica Fiber
PSF First, position detection was carried out by using a
PSF connected with a silica fiber. A schematic drawing
of this experiment is shown in Fig. 5. The PSF used was
Topreamplifier I
/ 1m long, and the silica fibers used were of two lengths,
50 m and 100 m. The silica fibers’ diameter was 1mm,
7 radation To preamplifier
and the propagation loss was approximately 15dB/km
Fig. 3 Schema of position detection experiment (at 440 nm) .
7 radiation
Fig. 5 Schema of position detection experiment using a PSF connected with a silica fiber
4000
3000
Downloaded by [CEA Saclay] at 08:28 23 February 2016
2000
1000
0
-100 -50 0 50 100 150 200 -100 -50 0 50 100 150 200
As described in Chap. 111, the ?-rays from 6oCowere propagating in the maximum mode (the path of light
irradiated at the center of the PSF. propagating by reflection at almost the critical angle in
The results when a 50 m long silica fiber was connected the optical fiber) becomes large. For this reason, when
and a 100 m long silica fiber was connected axe shown in the light is propagated over a long distance, the differ-
Figs. 6(a) and (b), respectively. ence in arrival time between the light to arrive first and
These position resolutions (FWHM) were about 92 cm the light to arrive at last may grow. The phenomenon
and 178 cm, respectively. These were somewhat larger of difference produced in the arrival time is called mode
than that of the PSF alone (25cm, see Fig. 4). dispersion (Fig. 7). The position resolution is thought
to drop due to this mode dispersion.
2. Optical Characteristics In order to analyze the mode dispersion status, we de-
As mentioned above, it was found that the position res- cided to first observe the optical fiber output when a
olution deteriorated when the silica fiber was connected. laser diode (LD) was used. A schematic drawing of the
This was due presumably to the mode dispersion of the experiment is shown in Fig. 8. A 50 m long silica fiber
light propagating through the optical fiber. is connected to one end of a PSF and the optical pulse
(1) Mode Dispersion from the LD is entered to the other end of the PSF. At
Since the quantity of the optical pulse generated by ra- this time, the optical pulse is branched by using a half
diation in the PSF is only a trace amount, it is necessary mirror in order to observe the incident pulse. The inci-
t o minimize the connection loss between the PFS and dent light and the output light are detected by PMTs,
the silica fiber. One method of reducing the connection whose outputs were observed by an oscilloscope. The
loss would be to reduce the difference in the numerical wavelength of the LD was 690nm, and the pulse width
aperture between the PSF and the silica fiber. Since the was about 8ns and the LD was repeatedly driven at a
numerical aperture of the PSF used was about 0.6, we cycle of 4 0 p . The light entering the PSF was then nar-
decided to use a silica fiber with the numerical aperture rowed down by a lens to less than the PSF’s acceptance
of 0.5, which was as close as possible to the above value. angle. An expanded view of the light’s entrance is shown
However, when the numerical aperture is as large as in Fig. 9.
0.5, the optical path difference between the light propa- The results of the measurements are shown in Fig. 10.
gating in the fundamental mode (the path of light prop- In this figure, the upper waveform is the input pulse,
agating straight along the optical fiber) and the light while the lower one is the output pulse from the 50m
I ztime
cladding optical fiber
- / \
output light
Fig. 7 Schematic view of mode dispersion
9 ACqS 9 AWS
+t I i I
I :T: I
[' ' j CtiZZoob i.OXVirt 1d.OXHbn j j j
.. .. .. .. .. ... .
..
.. ..
.._ .. .
. .... \.: ....................
.. .. .. .. .
2. r (
r""'""'
.,
.
..
,
..
.
T" .. ' . ...
B " " " . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . ... . . . . .. .
.. .. .. ..
. . .
0 : ". .
m
_.. . . ... . . . . ...
.
L..
.. .. .. ..
................
..
..
.
...
.....
.
...
....
...
...
z ; ..
_.. . .. . . . ..
..
.. .. ..
L. ................
. . . .
f ......... I
.
..
.
..
.
.. .
. . . ..
Time Time
(4 (b)
12 +cqs
I T I
Downloaded by [CEA Saclay] at 08:28 23 February 2016
j. C t i Z Z o o ~ : d.SXVert
. . . l
1d.OXHbn
.
j j :.
. . . I . . . . . . .. .. .. .
.. ... .. .. .. .. . ... ... ... .
I+.
..
. .
. . . . . . . . . . t 4
. . . . . . . . .
.. .. .. .
. . .
. . . . . .
Time Time
(c) (4
Vertical axis: 1 V/div, Horizontal axis: 10 ns/div
Fig. 11 Output pulse from PSF (a), typical output pulses from 100m silica fiber (b)-(d)
W =z At1 - At2,
= ((221 - L)/v +T d } - ((222 - L)/v+ Td},
= 2(Sl - 22)/v, (3)
where Atl and At2 are the arrival times at the half max-
imum in Fig. 12, and (21 - 22) is the position resolution.
When the position resolution of 178 cm obtained in
Fig. 6(b) is substituted in Eq. (3), we obtain W=17.8 ns.
This value almost agrees with the FWHM of distribution
Arrival Time (ns) in Fig. 12.
From the results shown in Figs. 11 and 12, it was found
Fig. 12 Histogram Of arrival time Of the 'Om 'O0
that the output signal from the 100 m long fiber did not
long silica fiber after triggering
spread as in Fig. 10 and the arrival times of the signals
fluctuated. These cause the deterioration of the position
resolution.
value (3211s). And the FWHM is presumed to be in We estimated the number of photoelectrons emitted
the range from 10 to 20ns. from the photocathode of the PMT to consider the cause
Letting W t o be this FWHM, I.V can be transformed of the fluctuatioll explained above.
to the position resolution by use of Eq. (1). as follows: When a 6oCo y-ray which has an average energy of
1.25 MeV interacts with the PSF and all of the energy is
deposited in the core, the number of photoelectrons(N) photoelectrons reduces depending on the wavelength of
emitted from the photocathode of the PMT is given by the emission light from the PSF, because the quantum ef-
ficiency of the photocathode depends on the wavelength
N = 1 . 2 5lo6
~ x Es/Pex E x~Lp x L,xL, x L, x Q , (4)
of the incident light.
where E, : Scintillation efficiency of the PSF=0.024 Also from Eq. (2), the arrival time of light from 100 m
P, : Average photon energy=3 eV silica fiber, in other words the generation time of each
Et : Trapping efficiency (efficiency of light trap of these photoelectrons, is considered t o fluctuate in the
by total reflection in the core of the range from 0 to 32 ns.
PSF)=0.03 These estimates allow us to determine that the results
L, : Propagation loss in the PSF in Figs. ll(b) t o (d) are the observations of single pho-
=1.5 (dB/m)x0.5 (m)=0.75 (dB)=0.84 toelectron events. On the other hand, if the quantity of
L,: Connection loss between the PSF and the light input into the photocathode is as large as the LD
silica fiber=l.7 (dB)=0.68 light used in Sec. IV-2(1), the number of photoelectrons
L, : Propagation loss in the silica fiber increases and they are superimposed on each other. As a
=15 (dB/km)xO.l (km)=1.5 (dB)=0.71 result, a pulse which has spread width is fed as in Fig. 10.
L,: Connection loss between the silica fiber and As mentioned above, the fluorescent light which is
the PMT=0.46 (dB)=0.90 emitted inside the PSF and propagated through the sil-
Q: Maximum quantum efficiency of the photo- ica fiber is detected as single photons. The arrival time
cathode of the PMT=0.23. of each photon fluctuates because of the optical path
Therefore, we obtain difference in the silica fiber. These cause a drop in the
Downloaded by [CEA Saclay] at 08:28 23 February 2016
(a) EGS4/PRESTA calculating model (b) Energy deposition spectra in the core of the PSF
Fig. 13 Energy deposition spectra calculated by the EGS4/PRESTA Monte Carlo code
1.o
h
v)
n
-
0
2c2
0.5
a
30 5 I I I
Downloaded by [CEA Saclay] at 08:28 23 February 2016
0 20 _........................................................................ .....................
10 _................................................................................................................
B
8 5
_............................................................................................................... -
Photo. 1 External view of the prototype monitor 0 5 10 15 20
(detection cable) Sensor Position ( m )