Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MATA KULIAH
PSIKOLOGI PENDIDIKAN
DISUSUN OLEH :
PENDIDIKAN BISNIS
FAKULTAS EKONOMI
2
KATA PENGANTAR
P u ji s yu k u r p e n u lis u c a p k a n k e p a d a T u h an Y an g M a ha E s a, k a re n a b e rk a t
d a n r ah m a t- N ya p e nu lis d a p a t m e ny e le s aik a n tu g a s C R IT IC A L J U R N A L R E P O R T ,
m a ta k u lia h P s ik o lo g i P e n d id ik a n . P e n u lis ju g a b e rte rim a k a s ih k e p a d a Ib u D o s e n
( R in a S u ry a n i S .P d ., M .Pd.) s e la k u do sen pengam p u m a ta k u lia h P s ik o lo g i
P e n d id ik an .
D id a la m C R IT IC A L J U R N A L R E P O R T in i m e m b a n d in g k an ju rn a l y a n g b e rju d u l
P e n e ra p a n M o d e l P e m b ela ja r an P ro b le m B a s e d L e ar n in g U n tu k M e n in g k a tk a n
K em am puan B e rp ik ir K ritis S is w a . P e m b u a ta n C R IT IC A L JU RN AL RE PORT in i
b e rtu ju a n u n tu k p e m e n u h a n s a la h s a tu tu g a s K K N I m a ta k u lia h P s ik o lo g i P en d id ik a n .
P e n u lis ju g a m en y a d a ri b a h w a tu g a s in i m a s ih te rd a p a t k e k u ra n g a n , o le h
k a re n a itu p en u lis m in ta m a a f jik a a d a k e s a la h a n d a la m p e n u lis a n , s e rta p e n u lis
ju g a m e n g ha r ap k ritik d an s a ra n ya n g m e m b a n g u n g u n a k e s e m p u rn a an tu g a s ini.
A k h ir k a ta p en u lis u c a p k a n te r im a k as ih , s e m o g a d a p a t b er m a n fa a t d a n b is a
m e n a m b a h p e n g eta hu a n b a g i p e m b a c a .
M e d a n , M a r et 2 0 2 4
P e n u lis
i
DAFTAR ISI
1 .1 L a ta r B e lak a n g ................................................................................ 1
1 .2 R u m u s a n M a s a la h ......................................................................... 1
1 .3 T u ju a n ............................................................................................ 1
2 .1 Id e ntita s J u rn a l ............................................................................... 2
2 .1 .1 Id e n tita s J ur n al U ta m a (1 ) .................................................. 2
2 .2 Is i R in g k a s J ur n al ........................................................................... 3
2 .2 .1 Is i R in g k a s J u rn a l U ta m a ( 1 ) .............................................. 3
2 .2 .2 Is i R in g k a s J u rn a l P e m b a n d in g ( 2 ) ................................... 5
3 .1 P e m b a h a s a n Is i J u rn a l / P e rb a n d in g a n ......................................... 7
3 .2 K e le b ih a n d a n K e k u ra n g a n J u rn a l ................................................. 8
4 . 1 K e s im p u la n .................................................................................... 10
4 . 2 S a ra n ............................................................................................. 10
LAMPIRAN
ii
BAB I
PENDAHULUAN
D a la m m e n g k ritik ju rn a l te rs e b u t, m a k a p e n u lis d ap a t m e n g e ta h u i p e r b e d a a n
a n ta ra kedua jur n al. Dan ju g a m e n g e ta h ui k e le b ih a n dan k e k u ra n g a n d a ri
m a s in g - m a s in g ju rn a l. P e m b u a ta n C r itic a l J u rn a l R e p o rt in i b e rtuju a n u n tu k
m e m e n u h i tu g a s ind iv id u K K N I. S e m o g a u s a h a in i d a p a t b e rm a n fa a t b a g i p e m b a c a
u m u m n ya d a n b a g i p e n yu s u n k h u s u s n ya .
1 . B ag a im a n a re vie w m a u p u n rin g k a s a n ju rn a l te rs e b u t?
2 . B ag a im a n a p e rb an d in g a n is i d a ri s e tia p ju rn a l?
3 . B ag a im a n a k e le b ih a n d a n k e k u ra n g an ju rn a l te rs e b u t?
1.3 Tujuan
1
BAB II
Ju du l Ju rn a l P en e ra p a n M o del P e m b e la ja ra n P ro b le m B a sed
L e a rn in g
U n tu k M e n in g k a tk a n K e m a m p u a n B e rp ik ir K ritis D a n
H a s il B e la ja r M a te m a tik a S is w a K e la s 4 S d
V olum e V o lu m e 5 N o m o r 1
P e n ulis 1. A na s tas ia N a nd h ita A s rin in g ty a
2 . F iro s a lia K ris tin
3 . In d ri A n u g ra h e n i
Ta h u n Te rbit 1 A p ril 2 0 18
A la m a t S itu s h ttp://ju rn a l.u nim us.a c.id /in de x.ph p/ JP M a t/ artic le /v ie w / 33
5 4/ 319 3
P u blik a si P G S D F KIP U n ive rsita s Kriste n S a ty a W a ca n a
IS S N 2339-244 4
Ju du l Ju rn a l P en e ra p a n M o d e l P ro b le m B a s ed L e a rn in g U n tu k
M e n in g k a tk a n K e m a m p ua n B e rp ik ir K ritis S is w a S m p
H ala m a n 5 2 -56
P e n ulis 1. U . S e ty o rin i, S .E .
2 . S uk is w o
3 . B . S u b a li
Ta h u n Te rbit J a n u a ri 2 0 1 1
A la m a t S itu s h ttp://jou rna l.u n ne s.a c.id /n ju / in de x.ph p/JP F I/a rticle / vie w /1
0 7 0 / 9 79
P u blik a si U n iv e rs ita s N e g e ri S e m a ra n g ( U n n e s )
IS S N 1 6 9 3 - 12 4 6
2
3
2.2 Isi Ringkas Jurnal
T u ju an P e n e litia n T u ju a n ya n g te rd a p a t d i d a la m ju rn a l in i a d a la h u n tu k
m e n d e s k rip s ik a n la n g k a h - la ng k a h p e n e ra p a n m o del
p e m b e la jar a n d a la m m e n in g k a tk a n
k e m a m p u a n b er p ik ir k ritis d a n ha s il b e la ja r s is w a m en g e n a i
p e n y ele s a ia n s o a l c e rita k e la s 4 S D N e g e r i S u ru h 0 1 d a n
ju g a u n tu k m e n g e tah u i p e n in g k a ta n k e m a m p ua n b e rp ik ir
k ritis d a n h a s il b ela ja r s is w a m e la lu i m o d e l p e m b e la ja ra n
pada p e n ye le s a ia n s o a l c e rita
k e la s 4 S D N e g e ri S u ru h 0 1.
S u b je k P e n e litia n S u b je k p e n e litia n ya n g te rd a p a t d a la m ju rn a l in i a d a la h
s is w a k ela s 4 S D N e g e ri S u ru h 0 1 T a h u n A ja ra n 20 17 / 20 18
d e n g a n ju m la h s is w a s e b a n ya k 3 6 s is w a ya n g ter d iri d a ri 1 9
p e re m p u a n d an 1 7 la k i- la k i.
) . D a la m P e n e litia n T in d a ka n K e la s ( P T K ) , te rd a p a t
b e b er a p a s iklu s . D a la m p e re n c a n a a n p e n e litia n ya n g a k a n
p e n e liti
la ku k a n te rd a p a t 2 s ik lu s y a itu s ik lu s I d a n s ik lu s II. D a la m
4
s ik lu s I, d a ri p e rm a s a la h a n ya n g d id ap a tk a n d ila k u k a n
p e re n c an a a n tin d a ka n I, p e la k s a n a a n tin d a k a n I,
p e n g a m a tan I dan re fle k s i I. K e m u d ia n , p ad a s ik lu s II
te rd a p a t b e b e ra p a p ro s e s d a ri p e rm a s a la h a n b a ru h a s il
re fle k s i I, y a itu p e re n c a n a a n tin d a k a n II, p e la k s a n a a n
tin d a ka n II, p e n g a m a ta n II d a n re flek s i II. D a la m p e n e litia n in i,
p e n e liti m e n g g u n ak a n m o d e l p e n elitia n tin d a k a n d a ri m o d e l
, ya itu p e re n c a n aa n , tin d a k a n ,
p e n g a m a tan / p e ng u m p u la n d a ta , r e fle k s i.
5
L a n g k a h P e n e litia n 1. P e rta m a , p e n e liti m e n e n tu k a n s a m p le p e n e litia n .
K e m u d ia n p e n e liti m e ng u m p u lk a n d ata s e c a ra te s
d a n n o n te s . D a ta y a n g d ip e ro le h d a ri h a s il te s y aitu
s o a l c e rita b e rb e n tu k u ra ia n . S e d a n g k a n d a ta y a ng
d ip e ro le h d a r i h a s il n o n te s y a itu w a w a n c a ra , le m b a r
k u e s io n e r d a n le m b a r o b s e rva s i.
2 . S e la n ju tn y a te rd a p a t 2 s ik lu s d a ta y a itu s ik lu s I d a n
s ik lu s II. D a ta - d a ta y a n g d id a p a tk a n p a d a s ik lu s I d a n
s ik lu s II d ia n a lis a k e m u d ia n d ib a n d in g k a n .
H a s il P e n e litia n P e n e ra p a n m o d e l p e m b e la ja ra n
d a p at m e n in g k a tk a n k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis d a n h a s il
b e la ja r s is w a d a la m m e n ye le s a ik a n s o a l c e rita p a d a m a ta
p e la ja ra n m a te m a tik a k e la s 4 S D N e g e ri S u ru h 0 1 . H a l
te rs e b u t d ib u k tik a n d e n g an k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis y a ng
m e n g a la m i p en in g k a ta n d a ri n ila i k o n d is i a w a l k e m a m p u a n
b e rp ik ir k ritis s is w a s e b e s a r 6 0 ,8 2 ( tid a k k r itis ) m e n in g k a t
m e n ja d i 7 4 ,21 ( c u k u p k ritis ) p a d a k o n d is i a k h ir. P e rs e n ta s e
ju m la h s is w a y an g b e rp ik ir k ritis p a d a k o n d is i a w a l ya itu
3 3 ,3 3 % k e m u d ia n m e n in g k a t p a d a k o n d is i a k h ir m e n ja d i
8 3 ,3 3 % . S e la in itu , h a s il b e laja r s is w a ju g a m e ng a lam i
p e n in g k a ta n d a ri k o nd is i a w a l ra ta - ra ta s e b e lu m d ila k u k a n
p e n e litian y a itu 6 1,8 5 d engan p e rs e n ta s e k e tu n ta s a n
4 4 ,8 4 % . S ete la h d ila k u k a n p e n e litia n p a d a s ik lu s I d ip e ro le h
n ila i ra ta - ra ta p a d a s ik lu s I m e nc a p a i 6 9 d e n g a n p e rs e n ta s e
k e tu n ta s a n s is w a m e n c a p a i 6 9 ,4 4 % . K e m u d ia n d ila n ju tk a n
k e s ik lu s II ra ta ra ta m en in g k a t m e n ja d i 8 0 d e n g a n
p e rs e n ta s e k e tu n ta s a n s is w a m e n c a p a i 8 8 ,8 9 % .
6
2.2.2 Isi Ringkas Jurnal Pembanding (2)
T u ju an P e n e litia n T u ju a n ya n g te rd a p a t d a la m ju r na l in i a d a la h u n tu k
m e n g e ta h u i p e n e ra p a n m o d e l p ada
s u b p o k o k b a h a s a n g e ra k lu ru s b e ru b a h b e ra tu ra n y a n g
d a p at m e n ing k a tk a n k e m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis s is w a .
S u b je k P e n e litia n S u b je k p e n e litia n ya n g te rd a p a t d a la m ju r na l in i
m e n g g un a k a n P e n g a m b ilan s a m p e l s e c a r a
s is w a S M P k e la s V II D d a n k e la s V II E s e b a n ya k 8 0
o ra n g s is w a .
2 . S e la n ju tn y a p e n e liti m e m b ag i s a m p le y a itu k e la s
e k s p e rim en dan k e la s k o n tro l. P e n e litia n yang
d ila k u k a n pad a k ela s e k s p e r im e n m enggunakan
m o d e l P B L d a n k e la s k o ntro l y a n g m e n e ra p k a n m o d e l
D I d e n g a n m e to d e c e ra m a h .
7
H a s il P e n e litia n H a s il p e n e litia n b e ru p a k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis , a s p e k
a fe k tif d a n a s p e k p s ik o m o to rik d ala m p e m b e la ja ra n y a n g
m e n g g un a k a n m o del PBL d is a jik a n p ad a ta b e l- ta b el di
b a w a h in i. A n a lis is tia p a s p e k k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis
k e la s e k s p e rim e n dan k e la s k o n tr o l d ap a t d ilih a t p ada
G am b a r 1 . B e r d a s a rk a n h as il u ji- t d ip e ro le h n ila i th itu n g
sebesa r 4 ,8 6 dan tta b e l seb esa r 1 ,99 4 . H a s il ter s e b u t
m e n u n ju k k a n b a h w a ke m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis s is w a d a ri
k e la s ek s p e rim e n d an ke la s k o n tro l m e n in g k a t, s e b a b t > t .
S e la in itu , h a s il u ji g ain (g ) d ip e ro leh n ila i h itu n g ta b le u n tu k
k e la s e k s p e rim e n s e b e s ar 0 ,4 3 te rg o lo n g seda ng,
s e d a n g k a n u n tu k k e la s k o n tro l d ip e ro le h n ila i s e b e s a r 0 ,2 8
te rg o lo n g re n d a h . H a s il k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis s is w a
m e n g a la m i p e n in g k ata n se ca ra s ig n ifik a n a n ta ra k e la s
e k s p e rim en y an g m e ng g u n a k a n m o d e l P B L d a n k e la s k o n tr o l
ya n g m e n e ra p k a n m o del DI d engan m e to d e c e ra m a h .
M e n in g k a tn y a k e m a m p ua n b e rp ik ir k ritis s is w a p a d a k e la s
e k s p e rim en d ik a r en a k a n p e ru b a h a n m o d e l p e m b e la ja ra n
ya n g m e n c a k u p k e g ia ta n u n tu k m e la tih k e m a m p u an b e rp ik ir
k ritis s is w a . M o d e l p e m b e la ja ra n P B L m e n g a ja k s is w a s e c a ra
la ng s u n g a k tif te rlib a t d a la m p r o s e s p e m b e la ja ra n . S e b a b
d a la m m o d e l P B L te rd a p at 8 la n g k a h ya n g d ap a t m e n g a ja k
s is w a u n tu k tu ru t ak tif d a la m p ro s e s p e m b e la ja ra n . K e a k tifa n
s is w a d a la m p ro s e s p e m b e la ja ra n d ap a t m e la tih
k e m a m p u a n b e rp ikir k ritis s is w a . S ed a n g k a n p a d a k e la s
c o n tro l m e n g g u n a k a n m o d e l D I d e ng a n m e to d e c e ra m a h
d im an a m odel te r s eb u t s e rin g d ite ra p k a n p ada sa a t
p e m b e la jar a n b e rla n g s u n g . D a la m m o d e l D I in i s is w a h a n ya
m e n d e n g a rk a n p e n je las a n d a ri g ur u , s e h in g g a s is w a b e rs ifa t
p a s if d a la m p e m b e laja ra n . M a k a s is w a d a la m b e la ja r h a n ya
b e rs ifa t ing a ta n s a ja tid a k d a p a t m e n g a p lik a s ik a n k o n s e p
d a la m d u n ia n y a ta . S ed a n g k a n k e a k tifa n s is w a itu s a n g a t
d ip e rlu k a n d a la m p ro s e s p e m b ela ja r an , te ta p i d a la m m o d e l
DI k e a k tifa n s is w a tid a k ta m p a k k ar e na p e m e b e la ja ra n
8
b e rp u s a t p ada hal in i yang m e n ye b a b k a n kem am puan
b e rp ik ir k ritis s is w a p ad a k e la s k o n tro l m e n d ap a tk a n h a s il
ya n g le b ih re n d a h d ib a n d in g k a n k e la s e k s p e rim e n .
D a p a t d is im p u lk a n b a h w a m o d el P B L d a p a t m e n in g k a tk a n
k e m a m p u a n b e r p ik ir k ritis s is w a p a d a p e m b e la ja ra n G L B B .
H a l in i d a p at d ilih at b a h w a 7 5 % s is w a m e m ilik i k e m a m p u a n
b e rp ik ir k ritis , 7 ,5 % s is w a m em ilik i k e m a m p u a n s a n g a t k r itis ,
p s ik o m o to rik s is w a m e m ilik i n ila i re r ata 8 2 ,7 5 d a la m k a te g o ri
s a n g a t a k tif d an a fe k tif s is w a m e m p u n y a i n ila i re ra ta s e b e s a r
7 3 ,3 8 y a n g te rm a s u k d a la m k a te g o ri b a ik . S e h in g g a p a ra
g u ru d ih a ra p k a n m am pu m e m va ria s ik a n m odel
p e m b e la jar a n ya n g d apat m en g h in d a ri ra s a bo sa n dan
te rc ip ta sua sa na ya n g m e n y en a n g k a n. M odel
d a p a t d ijad ik a n s o lu s i u ntu k m e n in g k a tk a n
k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k r itis p a d a s u b p o k o k b a h a s a n G L B B .
S e la in itu , G u ru d iha r ap k a n d a p a t m e nc o b a m o d e l P B L p a d a
m a te ri y an g b e rb e d a .
9
BAB III
PEMBAHASAN
10
h a s il b e la ja r s is w a ju g a m e n g a la m i d ija d ik a n s o lu s i u n tu k m e n in g k a tk a n
p e n ing k a ta n d a ri k o n d is i a w a l ra ta - ra ta kem am puan b e rp ikir k ritis pada sub
s e b e lu m d ila k u k a n p e ne litia n y a itu 6 1,8 5 p o k o k b a ha s a n G L B B . S e la in itu , G u ru
d e n g a n p e rs e n ta s e k e tu n ta s a n 4 4 ,8 4 % . d ih a ra p k a n d a p at m e n c o b a m o d e l P B L
S e te la h d ila k u k a n p e n e litia n p a d a s ik lu s I p a d a m a te ri y a n g b e rb e d a .
d ip e ro le h n ila i ra ta - ra ta pada s ik lu s I
m e n ca p a i 69 d engan p e rs e n ta s e
k e tu n ta s a n s is w a m enc apai 6 9 ,4 4 % .
K e m u d ia n d ila n ju tk a n k e s ik lu s II ra ta ra ta
m e n in g ka t m en ja d i 80 dengan
p e rs e n tas e k e tu n ta s a n s is w a m e n c a p a i
8 8 ,8 9 % .
3.2 Kelebihan dan Kelemahan Jurnal
ya n g d ig u n a k a n d a la m k es e lu ru h a n ju rn a l ini
p e n e litian s a n g a t k u a t s e b a g a i s a ng a t b agus h a n ya s a ja
a cu a n . T e rd a p a t teo ri p e n u lis h a ru s le b ih
p e m b e la jar a n P B L, te o ri deng an m e m b er ik a n
p e n d a p a t a hli.
(te rd a p a t p a d a H a la m a n 2 5 )
re le va n k a re n a a d a n ya
p e n je la s a n m engenai
k e u n g g u la n h a s il p e n e litia n
te rh a d a p p en e litia n te rd a h u lu
11
ya n g m e m b a h a s k a jian ya n g
sa m a . ( te rd a p at pada
H a la m a n 3 0 p a ra g ra f k e lim a .)
● S e la in itu m e to d e ya n g
d ig u n a k a n d a la m p e n e litia n in i
suda h te p a t te rh a d a p tu jua n
d a ri p e ne litia n u n tu k
m engukur b a g a im an a
p e n g a r uh p e n e ra p a n m od el
p e m b e la jar a n p ro b le m ba sed
le ar n in g un tu k m e n in g k a tka n
k e m a m p u a n b e rp ik ir k ritis d a n
h a s il b e laja r m a te m a tik a s is w a
k e la s 4 S D N e g e ri S u ru h 0 1 .
● K e m u d ia n d ala m jur n al u ta m a
in i m em ua t in d ik a to r te rh a d a p
p e n ila ia n m e n g e n ai b e rf ik ir
k ritis s e rta in d ik a to r d a la m
m e n g e ta h u i b a g a im an a
p e n e ra p a n P B L te rh a d a p h a s il
b e la ja r s is w a .
12
Pembanding ●K e le b ih a n y a n g te rd ap a t p a d a ●K e k u ra n g a n ya n g te rd a p a t
2 ju rn a l in i a d a la h m e m u a t ta b le p a d a ju rn a l in i tid a k d i m u a t
ya n g m e m b a ntu p e m ba ca s e c a ra jela s d im a n a s u b je k
●J u rn a l in i m em uat b a n ya k h an y a m e n e liti s is w a S M P
d a fta r p u s ta k a s eh in g g a ta n p a m e m u a t s e c a ra je la s
p e m b a c a m e n g e ta h u i s e c a ra d im a n a p e n e litia n itu
re le va n a sa l d a ta ya n g d ia d a ka n .
d ig u n a k a n d ala m ju rn a l in i. ●K u r an g n ya te o ri ya n g
ba ha sa y a itu B a ha s a p e m b e la ja ra n P B L .
Ind o n e s ia d a n B a h a s a In g g ris .
13
BAB IV
PENUTUP
4.1 Kesimpulan
S e te la h m e n g a n a lis a se ca ra k e s e lu ru h a n , m e nu r ut s a ya kedua ju rn a l
s in k ro n d e n g a n tu ju a n d a ri p e n e litia n te rs e b u t. D a n d a lam k e d u a ju rn a l in i ju g a
te rh a d ap b e rp ik ir k ritis d a n h a s il b e la ja r s is w a ..
4.2 Saran
D a ril h a s il k e d ua ju rn a l y a n g s a ya re v ie w te rd a p a t k e le b ih a n m a s in g - m a s in g .
la g i. D a n m e n g e n a i k e k u ra n g an y a n g te rd a p a t p a d a k e d ia ju rn a l a g a r le b ih d iteliti
la g i a g a r m e n c a p a i h a s il y a n g le b ih m a k s im a l.
14
DAFTAR PUSTAKA
15