Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00170-016-9130-2
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 17 April 2015 / Accepted: 4 July 2016 / Published online: 13 July 2016
# Springer-Verlag London 2016
gears. The use of micro-EDM has many advantages in micro- with different tool electrodes, e.g., copper, brass, and tungsten
parts, the main advantage is that it can machine complex shapes carbide. Gap voltage, discharge current, and duty factor with
into any conductive material with very low forces. The forces different process levels were selected as input parameters and
are very small because the tool and the workpiece do not come effect was studied on material removal rate, electrode wear rate,
into contact during the machining process. This property pro- and surface roughness. Copper was reported to be the best ma-
vides advantages to both the tool and the workpiece. For exam- terial for EDM because of its high electrical conductivity [8].
ple, in EDM, a very thin tool can be used because it will not be The discharge current, pulse interval, pulse width, and gap volt-
bent by the machining force. The other advantages of micro- age were optimized for EDM machining of S-03 stainless steel
EDM include low set-up cost, high aspect ratio, enhanced pre- using L9 orthogonal array-based grey relational analysis [9].
cision, and large design freedom. In addition, EDM does not Prihandana et al. reported a significant increase in the material
make direct contact between the tool electrode and workpiece removal rate and surface quality by suspending micro-MoS2
material, hence eliminating mechanical stress, chatter, and vibra- powder in dielectric fluid. The ultrasonic vibration was used
tion problems during machining. Micro-EDM is very effective during micro-EDM processes and optimization was done using
to machine any kind of holes such as small-diameter holes down Taguchi [10]. The grey relational analysis was used for optimiz-
to 10 μm and blind holes with 20 aspect ratio. Although micro- ing feed rate, spindle speed, resistance, capacitance, and voltage
EDM is a very efficient process in micro-hole machining and for micro-EDM hole drilling [11]. Mhatre et al. determined op-
having many advantages, it has also some disadvantages. One of timized levels of process parameters viz. duty cycle, pulse cur-
them is that it is a rather slow machining process; the other is that rent, pulse on time, electrode type, and gap voltage for output
while the workpiece electrode is being machined, the tool elec- parameters MRR, tool wear rate (TWR), and surface roughness
trode also wears at a rather significant rate. This tool-wear leads (SR) using grey relational analysis [12]. Experiments were con-
to shape inaccuracies. Another drawback is the formation of a ducted using Taguchi L18 orthogonal array. From grey relational
heat-affected layer on the machined surface. Since it is impossi- analysis, the optimum values were 8 % for duty cycle (8 %),
ble to remove all the molten part of the workpiece, a thin layer of 18 A for pulse current, 200 μs of pulse on time, and voltage of
molten material remains on the workpiece surface, which re- 40 V. Experimental results revealed that the copper electrode
solidifies during cooling [2]. Physical model developed for gives the optimum performance in terms of higher MRR and
micro-EDM is slightly different from that of conventional lower TWR and SR. Balasubramanian and Senthilvelan used
EDM. The use of resistance capacitance pulse generator, an response surface methodology for optimizing machining param-
advanced controller for machining in smaller inter-electrode eters in EDM process using cast and sintered copper electrodes
gaps and with lower discharge energies than in EDM, makes [13]. The selected process parameters were peak current, pulse
the material removal characteristics of a single discharge in on time, die electric pressure, and tool diameter. The pulse cur-
micro-EDM different from that of the EDM [3]. Another signif- rent and pulse duration were optimized for hole dilation and
icant point of micro-EDM is the inverted polarity of the tool taper ratio for micro-EDM hole drilling in Inconel 718 nickel-
electrode. Due to polarity effect in conventional EDM with long based superalloy [14]. The study showed pulse current as more
pulse duration, the tool electrode is usually charged as an anode efficient on performance characteristics than pulse duration.
to increase material removal rate and to reduce electrode wear. Zhang et al. optimized output objectives processing time and
At short pulse durations as used in micro-EDM, this effect is electrode wear by optimizing the input parameters peak current,
reversed. Therefore, in micro-EDM, the tool electrode is usually pulse duration, pulse off time, capacitance, electrode rotating
charged as cathode [4]. speed, and servo reference speed using multi-objective genetic
Careful selection of input parameters and their optimization algorithm [15]. Meena and Azad used grey relational analysis of
plays a great role in successful achievement of results. Ti6Al4V alloy and reported voltage as the most significant pa-
Optimization of process parameters of EDM has been treated rameter affecting output parameters MRR, TWR, and OC [16].
as single-objective optimization process and multi-objective op- Central composite design with response surface approach was
timization problem. Somashekhar et al. optimized micro-EDM used for optimizing voltage, capacitance, and feed rate of micro-
input parameters for metal removal rate (MRR) using artificial wire electrical discharge machining (micro-WEDM) for param-
neural network [5]. Pradhan and Bhattacharyya combined re- eters MRR, Kerf width, and surface for Ti6Al4V alloy [17].
sponse surface methodology along with artificial neural network Tiwari et al. also used central composite design with response
for optimizing MRR, TWR, and overcut (OC) for pulse on time, surface approach to find optimized level of input parameters of
peak current, and flushing pressure for titanium alloy; effect of pulse on time, peak current, gap voltage, and flushing pressure
polarity changing technique for micro-electrode discharge ma- with output parameters MRR, TWR, OC, and taper for Ti6Al4V
chining on Ti6Al4V for the fabrication of straight-through mi- alloy [18]. The process parameters discharge current, gap volt-
cro-holes was also studied [6, 7]. Muthuramalingam and Mohan age, lifting height, negative polarity, and pulse duty factor were
used grey relational analysis for multi-response optimization of optimized for electrode wear rate (EWR), MRR, and surface
the electrical discharge machining for AISI 202 stainless steel roughness as objective parameters for Ti6Al4V alloy; however,
Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2017) 89:897–904 899
Elements C Fe H N O Ti
the dielectric used for tap water with decreased operation cost
and no harmful effects [19]. Rahman et al. used copper electrode
with positive polarity for optimizing Ti6Al4V alloy and used
response surface methodology for optimizing peak current,
pulse on time, and pulse off time levels for surface roughness
[20]. Long et al. used Taguchi method for optimizing EDM Fig. 2 Hole image captured
parameters for SKD61, SKD11, and SKT4 die steels using tita-
nium powder for MRR and found that electric current, electrode shown in Table 1. The machining was done using side flushing
material, and powder concentration were the most significant technique along with electrode rotation, on high precision micro-
parameters that influenced the MRR [21]. Selvarajan et al. used EDM machine, from Sarix, Model SX-100 (Fig. 1). The ma-
grey relational analysis for optimizing EDM parameters for im- chine is equipped with a wire dressed unit. A Marcel-Aubert-Sa
proving circularity, cylindricity, and perpendicularity while ma- make optical microscope (model MA-705-Z1) was used for
chining Si3N4–TiN composite [22]. A technique for order pref- measurement of hole diameter. The microscope is attached on
erence by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) was used by Z-axis of the machine as shown in Fig. 2. The eroded length was
Manivannan and Kumar for multi-response optimization of measured using the Z-axis movement of the machine and the
micro-EDM output process parameters, such as the material erosion time was noted from the MMI display of the machine.
removal rate, electrode wear rate, overcut, taper angle, and cir- The cylindrical tungsten carbide (WC) rod with 0.4 mm diam-
cularity at entry and exit points on AISI304 alloy [23]. eter was used as a tool electrode and was rotated at constant
In the present work, efforts are made to find the effect of value of 200 rpm for all the experiments.
various micro-EDM input parameters on performance charac- The values of other parameters viz. voltage, energy index,
teristics MRR, TWR, and OC for machining of commercially gain, and gap were kept constant at 100 V, 105 (index), 80
pure (Cp) titanium with tungsten carbide electrode using grey (index), and 100 (index), respectively. The hydrocarbon oil
relational analysis combined with Taguchi method-based de- (HEDMA 111) having kinematic viscosity of 2.4 cSt was used
sign of experiments has been used to obtain significant pro- as dielectric and experiments were performed at room temper-
cess parameters and their optimal combination level for effec- ature. No wear compensation was used to adjust the electrode
tive micro-hole drilling in Cp titanium. path accordingly to the gap and the wear. The chosen response
parameters were MRR, EWR, and OC. MRR, EWR, and OC
were determined using standard equations mentioned in re-
2 Experimental spective subsections. The current, pulse width, and frequency,
with three levels of each parameters, were selected as input
The commercial pure titanium (Cp-Ti), grade 2, having thick- process parameters. The levels are shown in Table 2.
ness of 1.12 mm was used for machining. The substrate was
locally purchased and the chemical composition of Cp-Ti is
3 Design of experiment
Table 3 L9 orthogonal
array S. no. Frequency Current Width
1 150 20 0.5
2 150 50 1
3 150 35 2
4 125 20 1
5 125 50 2
6 125 35 0.5
7 100 20 2
8 100 50 0.5
9 100 35 1
maxx0i ðk Þ− x0i ðk Þ
x*i ðk Þ ¼ ð8Þ
max x0i ðk Þ−min x0i ðk Þ
Fig. 5 Schematic of overcut
where
4.3 Overcut x*i ðk Þ is the value after grey relational generation;
min x0i ðk Þ is the smallest value of x0i ðk Þ;
The schematic of overcut of the micro-holes is shown in Fig. 5
max x0i ðk Þ is the largest value of x0i ðk Þ.
and can be measured using
The grey relational coefficient [ξi(k)] can be calculated as
Da−De follows:
OC ¼ mm ð6Þ
2
Where Da is the average diameter of the hole after machin- Δmin þ ς Δmax
ξ i ðk Þ ¼ ð9Þ
ing, and De is the diameter of the electrode. Δ0i ðk Þ þ ς Δmax
where
x*0 ðk Þ denotes the reference sequence;
5 Grey relational analysis x*j ðk Þ denotes the comparability sequence;
ς ∈ [0 − 1] is the distinguishing coefficient, 0.5 is widely
In grey relational analysis, data pre-processing is the ini- accepted;
tial step and is carried because the units and target direc- Δ0i ¼ x*0 ðk Þ−x*i ðk Þ is the difference in absolute value
tion of one data sequence, i.e., experimental result of out- between x*0 ðk Þ and x*i ðk Þ;
put parameter may differ from that of others, e.g., the unit
Δmin ¼ min min x*0 ðk Þ−x*j ðk Þ is the smallest value of
of MRR and EWR is cubic millimeters per minute where- ∀ j∈i ∀k
as for overcut is millimeter. During this step, the output Δ0i;
parameters are normalized in the range between zero and Δmax ¼ max max x*0 ðk Þ−x*j ðk Þ is the largest value of
one. Grey relational coefficient is calculated from the nor- ∀ j∈i ∀k
MRR EWR OC
Frequency 0.522735741 0.564888781a 0.509881871 0.05500691 where γi is the grey relational grade and n is the number of
Current 0.544363309 0.570320191a 0.482822892 0.087497299 performance characteristics. Table 4 shows the experimental
Pulse 0.539004717 0.554258934a 0.504242741 0.050016193 and data pre-processed results. Table 5 shows the grey rela-
width tional coefficients and corresponding grey relational grade for
each experiment.
Mean value of grey relational grade, 0.064173
a
Among nine experiments, the experiment no. 9 has the
Optimal level of parameter
highest grey relational grade, and the level of parameters in
Table 7 Grey relational grade obtained with optimized parameters and optimization of input parameters, i.e., current, frequency,
Input parameter setting Grey relational grade and pulse width, are the primary aims of the present study. The
effect of input parameters on output parameters, i.e., material
Frequency 100 kHz 0.60962 removal rate, electrode wear rate, and overcut was studied.
Current 35 Based on the study performed, the following conclusion
Pulse width 1 μs may be drawn:
Frequency 125 kHz 0.69281
Current 35 a. Micro-EDM process has enough potential for generating
Pulse width 1 μs micro-features in commercially pure titanium, which is
very difficult to machine by conventional tool-based mi-
Improvement in grey 0.08319 cro-operation like micro-drilling and micro-milling.
relational grade
b. Current is the most influential parameter among current,
frequency, and pulse width for micro-EDM machining of
the experiment no. 9 (frequency 100 kHz, current 35, pulse commercially pure titanium.
width 1 μs) are closest to the best performance of micro-EDM c. Grey relational analysis can be effectively utilized in si-
hole drilling in Cp-Ti. Further, it is possible to find out the multaneous optimization of parameters for getting the de-
optimal set and their effects on selected output parameters. sired results. Accuracy of results depends on the effective
Table 6 shows the mean of grey relational grades of all param- setting of parameters.
eters at different levels as well as the difference between the
Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge the financial support re-
maximum and minimum value of the grey relational grade of ceived from the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR),
the EDM machining parameters, which shows the importance New Delhi, for its network project “BIOCERAM,” under its XIIth Five
of individual factor in EDM machining. Year Plan.
The highest grey relational grade shows the optimal level
of parameter viz; frequency 125 kHz, current 35, and pulse
width 1 μs, for the better performance of micro-EDM drilling. References
Importance of the EDM machining parameters are in the fol-
lowing order: current, frequency, pulse width. Figure 6 shows 1. Moylan SP, Chandrasekar S, Benavides GL (2000) High-speed micro-
the effect of parameters on grey relational grade. electro-discharge machining, in Sandia Report, Sandia National
Laboratories, SAND2005–5023. 2005.
2. Masuzawa T (2000) State of the art of micromachining. CIRP Ann
Manuf Technol 49(2):473–488
3. Dhanik S, Joshi SS (2005) Modeling of a single resistance capacitance
6 Verification experiment pulse discharge in micro-electro discharge machining. J Manuf Sci Eng
127(4):759–767
Verification experiment was performed using optimized set of 4. Uhlmann E, Piltz S, Doll U (2005) Machining of micro/miniature
parameters, i.e., frequency 125 kHz, current 35, and pulse dies and moulds by electrical discharge machining—recent devel-
opment. J Mater Process Technol 167(2–3):488–493
width 1 μs. The values obtained for MRR, TWR and OC were
5. Somashekhar KP, Ramachandran N, Mathew J (2010) Optimization of
0.006495 mm3/min, 0.005959 mm3/min and 0.048 mm, re- material removal rate in micro-EDM using artificial neural network and
spectively. These values were used again for normalization, genetic algorithms. Mater Manuf Process 25(6):465–475
grey relation coefficient and grey relational grade calculation. 6. Pradhan BB, Bhattacharyya B (2009) Modelling of micro-
electrodischarge machining during machining of titanium alloy Ti–
The relational grade got improved by 0.08319 with optimized
6Al–4V using response surface methodology and artificial neural net-
parameter settings (Table 7). work algorithm. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part B: J Eng Manuf 223(6):683–
693
7. Pradhan BB, Bhattacharyya B (2009) Improvement in microhole
machining accuracy by polarity changing technique for microelec-
7 Conclusion trode discharge machining on Ti–6Al–4V. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part
B: J Eng Manuf 222(2):163–1732008
Micro-electrical discharge machining process is a widely used 8. Muthuramalingam T, Mohan B (2014) Application of Taguchi-grey
multi responses optimization on process parameters in electro ero-
micro-fabrication technique for the production of micro-parts sion. Measurement 58(0):495–502
and micro-features, finding application in micro-mechatronic 9. Tang L, Guo YF (2014) Electrical discharge precision machining
systems, automobile, surgical tools, etc. Its low cost of oper- parameters optimization investigation on S-03 special stainless
ation and ability to machine any conductive material irrespec- steel. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 70(5–8):1369–1376
10. Prihandana GS, Mahardika M, Hamdi M, Wong YS, Mitsui K
tive of its hardness is one of the reasons for its popularity in (2009) Effect of micro-powder suspension and ultrasonic vibration
micro-machining processes and is discussed extensively of dielectric fluid in micro-EDM processes—Taguchi approach. Int
among researchers. The micro-hole drilling in Cp titanium J Mach Tools Manuf 49(12–13):1035–1041
904 Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2017) 89:897–904
11. Jung J, Kwon W (2010) Optimization of EDM process for multiple 19. Tang L, Du YT (2014) Experimental study on green electrical dis-
performance characteristics using Taguchi method and Grey rela- charge machining in tap water of Ti–6Al–4V and parameters opti-
tional analysis. J Mech Sci Technol 24(5):1083–1090 mization. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 70(1–4):469–475
12. Mhatre MS, Sapkal SU, Pawade RS (2014) Electro discharge ma- 20. Rahman MM, Khan AR, Kadirgama K, Maleque MA, Bakar RA
chining characteristics of Ti-6Al-4V alloy: a grey relational optimi- (2011) Parametric optimization in EDM of Ti-6Al-4V using copper
zation. Proc Mater Sci 5(0):2014–2022 tungsten electrode and positive polarity: a statistical approach, in
13. Balasubramanian P, Senthilvelan T (2014) Optimization of machin- Proceedings of the 13th WSEAS international conference on math-
ing parameters in EDM process using cast and sintered copper ematical and computational methods in science and engineering.
electrodes. Prog Mater Sci 6(0):1292–1302 World Scientific and Engineering Academy and Society
14. Ay M, Çaydaş U, Hasçalık A (2013) Optimization of micro-EDM (WSEAS): Catania, Sicily, Italy 23–29.
drilling of Inconel 718 superalloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 66(5– 21. Long BT, Phan NH, Cuong N, Jatti VS (2016) Optimization of
8):1015–1023 PMEDM process parameter for maximizing material removal rate
15. Zhang L, Jia Z, Wnag F, Liu W (2010) A hybrid model using by Taguchi’s method. Int J Adv Manuf Tech, 1–11.
supporting vector machine and multi-objective genetic algorithm 22. Selvarajan L, Narayanan CS, JeyaPaul R (2016) Optimization of
for processing parameters optimization in micro-EDM. Int J Adv EDM parameters on machining Si3N4–TiN composite for improv-
Manuf Technol 51(5–8):575–586 ing circularity, cylindricity, and perpendicularity. Mater Manuf
16. Meena VK, Azad MS (2011) Grey relational analysis of micro-EDM Process 31(4):405–412
machining of Ti-6Al-4V alloy. Mater Manuf Process 27(9):973–977 23. Manivannan R, Kumar MP (2016) Multi-response optimization of
17. Sivaprakasam P, Hariharan P, Gowri S (2014) Modeling and anal- micro-EDM process parameters on AISI304 steel using TOPSIS. J
ysis of micro-WEDM process of titanium alloy (Ti–6Al–4V) using Mech Sci Technol 30(1):137–144
response surface approach. Eng Sci Technol 17(4):227–235
24. Pham DT, Ivanov A, Bigot S, Popov K, Dimov S (2007) An inves-
18. Tiwary AP, Pradhan BB, Bhattacharyya B (2015) Study on the
tigation of tube and rod electrode wear in micro EDM drilling. Int J
influence of micro-EDM process parameters during machining of
Adv Manuf Technol 33(1–2):103–109
Ti–6Al–4V superalloy. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 76(1–4):151–160