Working Paper 3

Public Libraries and Social Class

John Pateman

"

# $%%%&

! " ! # $%&&'( )
*
+

26
! " $%&&'(

, *
-
- -
.

*
-
-
$ (

) ! 0 ,1
2

3 ! $%&&4( 5

+6

# $%&&7( '%
77 %8 $%&&'( 7'
. 9%: .
5 /+

! ! $%&&4( , "
2 ;

* ! .
<% <9 = , -
> )

? @
%&%%< *! -. -<% -
<9 -= -,

27
 2 > A
, A ? < 9BB%<
*% # -%% ,
-%9 # -9 )
-C 6 -D A -
8 ) -7 A -4
?

)
$ . ( $ % (
6

A
$ %&&7(
. $" ? %&&'( 5 / $.
" %&&4(

! E
$%&&'( "

" 1
0 > )

$ %&&'(

; " , $%&74-
%'D'( . ? A $%&&D(

! " $%&&'(

28
< * =
%&&B
$)@" . %&&8(
.

) $%&&7( 1
0
*A 1

! ) $%&&7(
1

) $%&&7(

. $%&&4(
6
1 1
6 5 /$ (

$
5 /(

29
;
!
, < $%&&D(
$ (

! 0 FDBB )
> 2 ; $>2;(
1 G 6 > @
) $# %&&'(

; 7B:
7B: 6

1 G 6
> @ )

"

! ) @ " . $%&&8(

>2;
1

" $%&&4(
*

30
 1 "
$%&&4( < < *!
*A 0
<E0 <E+ +

" $%&&4(

! 1 < <

! )" @. $%&&8(

$ (
$ 1 (

< @ $%&4'(
@
! A =

$%&C8( *
6

" $%&88(
1

# $%&7C(

31
 !
$%&&4( * E ,

H $%&44( ) ! %'8B
$ (
!

) %'7& D&
99: 0
2 99 %C97 84 &%9

$
(
1 < @ $%&4'( 1
*A 1 6
6 A
6 /

# $%&8'( *
$ (

H $%&&9( *
0 6

. 60
/

! 9BBB >
G @<A,
%'8 -
9&9- D%4
$A G %&&C( A *

32
# $%''&( )
2

$%&C8(
0
$%&C4(

@ $%&7D(
G $%&4B(

H $%&4B(

) $%&4%(

I $%&49( !
$ (
# *
/- J
-
; = $%&49( 0

6
# $%&4C( *
$ (
1

I $%&4C(

# $%&48(
+6

! = , A $%&4'(
8B: !
G $%&'%(

33
 , $%&&9(
# D7:
C':
$79:( 8D:

? 6 $%&&C(
!.J<%
<9J=,
< $%&&D(

, $%&&D(
!.

< A $%&&8(
. .

) . A
H < 98:
8B: # # 98:
. ) > C8:

. " ) $%&&8(
49: !. 77: < . 89: <9
D4: =, , A $%&&8( 8D:
!. 8&: < 0 D9:
<9 DD: =,0
=,
%&&8 %&'& "

! $%&&8(
!. <%
; !. %8:
D%: 1 - =,
C%: 978: 1

) ! $%&&8(

@ < < > 6 $%&&8(

34
. " ) $%&&4( 7B:
48: <% 'D: !.
*7%: <9 88: =, ." )
"
$ ( ! # $%&&4(

< 1
K
98 ! 'B: !
78:
= , 5A K /$< %&&&(

$%&&7(
!

) ? @ $%&&4(

) 6 < ? < $%&&4(

)6A
+ .
1

H H $%&&4( -) G $%&&'(
- G A L $%&&7(
A -? " $%&&'(
L -" $%&&4(
-" H $%&&4(
- # $%&&4(
> " 0 $%&&'(

35
 "
1
1
.
1 # A
$ (
1

K A

A %8B
!
A
1 ?

+
*

%
6
5 /
5 /5 /
5 /
"

36
9 ; I
" K 5 / . K
$
( 6
. K 2
5 / 5 /
"

%'D'

C
< 5 / 5 /

C,
9, 1 1
D

6 *

%
* - - -

9 60
* $ (
- $ (- $
( - $
( - $
(

37
C *

<
1
1
$" %&&4(

D J

* -
- -
-

$ %&&7(
8 1 *

4 6

' 1

&

%B

38
! ! A $%&&4( ) *

! $%&&8( ' ( ) *
+ , ) *!

. ! " = $%&&4( - ! *
!

. " ) $%&&8( . ) *." )

. " ) $%&&4( / ) *." )

. ' 0 $%&&D( < . < .

. = $%&&4( 5A * /
1 0 2 %4%$8B 8C(94 8%

< " $%&&&( 1 ) *?

< $%&&C( . 34 -5 . @
A *<

< @ E $%&4'( 1 . *
I )>

< < A I $%&&8( * 4 * (

/ ( $)6AG
2 %B( ) *) 6 A G =
6 ) A ) G

= , A $%&4'( ) *#" A2

= > # $%&&7( 2 ) *= >

#

= " $%&49( 5) / / 78$%%(%4B %4C

, ) $%&&9( . ) *. " )

, ) $%&&D( ) *. " )

, ) A I $%&&8( 2 ) *
) 6 A G = 6 ) A
) G

, < $%&&D( ( ) *<

, < ) 2

39
@ < < > 6 $%&&8( 4
. *@<<>6

@ . $%&7D( / ) *? 6
< !

# A $%''&( ) ) *? %''&

# $%&48( 5 / / 7'$9(98 7

# H $%&&'( 6 4
$. ) ? 6 ? ''( ) *<
= ;

# @ $%&4C( 5 / /
77$4(%%B %%C

# ; $%&7C( 5 // '
I %&7C

# = $%&&7( 5A +/ 6 $/ ( C%" %&&7 9D

# ? $%&8'( # * %&8'

# ! $%&&'( 0
$= < " A ( %= %&&' ) *=<" A

I $%&49( 5A / /
78$C(C' D%

H A $%&4B( 5< / / 7C$D(8B 8%

H H , $%&44( . 2 4 .
) *=

H I $%&&9( 0 A *!H

H , H " $%&&4( 4
$. ) ? 6 ? '8( ) *. ) ?
6 <

) ? $%&&7( 5 = /
1 0 2 %7 %$D7(8 9B

) ! $%&&8( 2 ) *) !

40
) 6 < ? < $%&&4( 2 !
) *)6<

) ? G . $%&&'( + 4
$. ) ? 6 ? '&( A *=
6 A G A

) @ " . $%&&8( 1 ) *)@" .

) . $%&4%( ) *) !

" H ) @ ! # H $%&&4( /
$. ) ? 6 ? '7( ) *. )
? 6 <

" H , ; $%&74( 1 # *

" ; $%&&'( . 4 " $.

) ? 6 ? '4( ) *<

" ; $%&&'& / 4
$. ) ? 6 ? %%D( ) *<

" " $%&&4( 5 /1

0 2 %4$89(

" < $%&&'( 7 ) *2 "

" $%&88( 5 // ' A %&88

I $%&&7( 5! 1 // ' &'$4(C79 C

A I $%&&7( ) 3) *) @ "
.

I $%&&'( , ) *E

I ? $%&&7( ' 4 "

' 2 / $. ) ? 6 ? '( ) *
. ) ? 6 <

? G ?< A L @ $%&&7( )
3 0 $.
) ? = ? 799D( ) *.)?==

41
 ) ? @ $%&&4( 0
)?@

? 6 $%&&C( ! >2

? " " $%&&'( 2 8 $.

) ? 6 ? 47( < *<,=!? G

A $%&&C( 0 - %&&C

I> I 6" $%&4C( 2 ) *#" A2

A # $%&&7( 5G
/1 0 2 %7 %$D7(9% DC
$%&&7( 0 ) *) @
" .

! $%&&'( 5. / 9 4I %&&'

G . $%&4B( 5A 1 / / ! %&4B

G . $%&'%( ) *) !

E $%&&'( 5. / %= %&&'
8

I $%&C8( 5A //
' ! %&C8

I $%&C4( 5 //
' I %&C4

42