Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Iris H. Tuan
Pop with Gods, Shakespeare, and AI
“Iris Tuan’s book is wide ranging in scope and diversity, examining theatre, music,
film and television productions from both Western and Asian countries. Tuan also
surveys an extensive range of critical and theoretical perspectives, especially from
performance studies and popular cultural studies, to offer context for her descrip-
tions of the many different works. Some of her examples are well-known
(Shakespeare’s Romeo & Juliet, Disney’s The Lion King) while others little known
outside their place of origin (such as the Hakka Theatre of Taiwan)—all are
approached by the author with enthusiasm.”
—Susan Bennett, Professor of English, University of Calgary, Canada
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Singapore Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore
189721, Singapore
This monograph is dedicated to my parents
Father Tuan Shi-Ge (1924–2004)
Mother Yang Shu-Yu (1938–2002)
Acknowledgements
vii
viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
for several years in the soon future to achieve great research results to
educate, entertain and benefit more people in the world.
Last but not least, the sustainable support and encouragement from my
friends, family and relatives is highly appreciated. Especially, I am grateful
for my daughter Angela who has accompanied me to stay up late doing
research and writing at nights for so many years. Sometimes, I have to
make myself feel better by thinking in an alternative positive way that
maybe those bad people’s oppression and obstruction in the past is another
way to push me to go forward to continue to make significant progress.
Except continuously doing deep research on my fields of theatre perfor-
mance studies, film studies, and cultural creative industry, I have also
learned law, passed, and got the law courses credits certificates. Listening
and singing the song You Raise Me Up, I express my gratitude to thank
God, Buddha, heaven and all of you, for “you raise me up: To more than
I can be.” To be the light of the world!
Contents
xi
xii Contents
10 Conclusion199
Main Points in Each Chapter 200
Future Research Plan 205
Works Cited 206
Index207
About the Author
xvii
List of Figures
Fig. 2.1 Adapting from Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, West Side Story
(1961) contains the race conflicts. (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo
Co., Ltd.) 14
Fig. 2.2 The musical film West Side Story (1961) was directed by
Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins. Natalie Wood and Richard
Beymer star in this film. The two protagonists sing the theme
song “Tonight.” (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 15
Fig. 2.3 Romeo and Juliet. Olivia Hussey as Juliet, and Leonard
Whiting as Romeo makes the movie a huge hit and becomes a
classic. (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 16
Fig. 2.4 Romeo and Juliet (1996) contains with postmodern collage,
spectacles and hyper-reality. (Photo: Courtesy of 20th Century
Fox/Photofest)18
Fig. 2.5 Romeo and Juliet (1996) presents the postmodern spectacles,
full of fetished images, carnival vulgarity, and hyper-reality.
(Photo: Courtesy of 20th Century Fox/Photofest) 19
Fig. 2.6 Director Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo and Juliet (1996) playfully
converts Juliet into Romeo’s “bright white beautiful angel.”
(Photo: Courtesy of 20th Century Fox/Photofest) 20
Fig. 2.7 Romeo and Juliet (1996). Romeo (plays by Leonardo
DiCaprio) loves Juliet at the first sight. (Photo: Courtesy of
20th Century Fox/Photofest) 21
Fig. 2.8 Romeo and Juliet (1996). Juliet (plays by Claire Danes), an
innocent beauty, while she looks, under the male gaze, is also a
pleasure to be looked at. (Photo: Courtesy of 20th Century
Fox/Photofest)22
xix
xx List of Figures
Fig. 2.9 Italian Film Director Carlo Carlei’s Romeo & Juliet (2013)
stars Douglas Booth as Romeo and Hailee Steinfeld as Juliet.
(Photo: Courtesy of Relativity Media/Photofest) 24
Fig. 2.10 Romeo and Juliet (2013) imbues the classical milieu. (Photo:
Courtesy of Relativity Media/Photofest) 25
Fig. 3.1 Along with the Gods: The Two Worlds (starring Ha Jung-woo,
Cha Tae-hyun, Ju Ji-hoon, and Kim Hyang-gi). In the
beginning of the film, Director Kim Yong-hwa designs the
protagonist as a firefighter who dies for saving a young girl
falling from the high building. His soul is welcomed by the
two messengers/attorneys from Hell to accompany him to
pass through the trials before ascending to Heaven. (Photo:
Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 45
Fig. 3.2 The three messengers/attorneys from Hell accompanies the
protagonist to conquer the dangers that they didn’t expect to
encounter for the protagonist’s soul is a rare saint. The
extraordinary spectacle of the seven-layer judgments and
punishments in Hell, such as the big fire everywhere on the
Rocky Mountains, is shown in Along with the Gods: The Two
Worlds. (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 46
Fig. 3.3 The extraordinary spectacle of the seven-layer judgments and
punishments in Hell is shown in Along with the Gods: The Two
Worlds. (Photo: Courtesy of Well Go USA Entertainment) 50
Fig. 4.1 In the scene of the musical Classic of Mountains and Seas,
Huangdi and Chiyou had war in the battle of Zhuolu. (Photo:
Courtesy of National Taiwan Normal University) 69
Fig. 4.2 The film poster of the Chinese Film The Monkey King: Kingdom
of Women (2018). (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 73
Fig. 5.1 The makeup, animality, and costumes in the musical stage
performance Cats. (Photo: Courtesy of Joan Marcus
Photography)87
Fig. 5.2 Playwright David Henry Hwang (at left) won his third Obie
Award in Playwriting& Francis Jue (at right), an American
actor and singer, got the acting Obie Award for his role in
Yellow Face at the Public Theater (2008) at the Obie. (Photo:
Courtesy of Playwright David Henry Hwang) 90
Fig. 5.3 The Asian American actor and the white American actress play
to present the issue of race in Yellow Face. (Photo Credit: Joan
Marcus. Courtesy of Playwright David Henry Hwang) 92
Fig. 5.4 In the scene, the trio play to show the complexity of face, race,
and politics in Yellow Face. (Photo Credit: Joan Marcus.
Courtesy of Playwright David Henry Hwang) 95
List of Figures xxi
Fig. 5.5 Theater Director & Costume Designer Julie Taymor in The
Lion King in 1997 the premiere performs visual culture about
makeup, masks, and headdresses, combining human acting
and animality theatricality in the musical. (Photo: Courtesy of
Aflo Co., Ltd.) 97
Fig. 5.6 The stage design and costume design of using the pink and
white colors are to show the cosmetics brands of Elizabeth
Arden and the cosmetics products of Helena Rubinstein for
packaging and marketing by the pink and white colors
separately. (Photo: Courtesy of Joan Marcus Photography) 100
Fig. 5.7 The noble woman visits her fiancée, Dr. Jekyll, in his lab. His
assistant stands on the up left stage on the stairs. Stage design
with the stairs to present the two floors and the top roof (with
the two musicians playing the live music) vertically to show
the three performing space. (Rehearsal News Conference.
Photo Credit: Chang, Zhen-Zhou. Courtesy of National
Theater and Concert Hall) 104
Fig. 5.8 Actress Yuka plays the role of Dr. Jekyll’s fiancée and Actor
Takashi Fujii plays the role of Mr. Hyde in Jekyll & Hyde & So
On. (Rehearsal News Conference. Photo Credit: Chang,
Zhen-Zhou. Courtesy of National Theater and Concert Hall) 105
Fig. 5.9 With sexual arousal, the actress uses the special makeup,
including the black dark patches under her eyes, the black
necklace and the costume for performing to show the
exaggerative animal sexual instinct inhibited by the social
morality and the noble aristocracy high-class norm. (Rehearsal
News Conference. Photo Credit: Chang, Zhen-Zhou.
Courtesy of National Theater and Concert Hall) 106
Fig. 5.10 After the arousal of the magic portion and brainwash, the
actress (who sits on the comic actor who plays the role of Mr.
Hyde) transforms from the timid noble lady into the wild girl
taking the active aggression with strong sexual arousal.
(Rehearsal News Conference. Photo Credit: Chang, Zhen-
Zhou. Courtesy of National Theater and Concert Hall) 107
Fig. 5.11 The Japanese director particularly designs to let the actress and
the actor add the dialogue “fried bread stick” (油條) in Chinese
pronunciation customized for the local audience members in
Taiwan. (Rehearsal News Conference. Photo Credit: Chang,
Zhen-Zhou. Courtesy of National Theater and Concert Hall) 109
Fig. 6.1 Chita Rivera, Broadway musical star, in The Visit (2015), plays
the role of Claire Zachanassian, one of the world’s wealthiest
women. Claire, a superrich widow, sings with her Eunuch
xxii List of Figures
Fig. 7.8 The success of Story of Yanxi Palace creates the color fashion.
Wei dresses in pink as a young maid in the palace in the
beginning, which is in comparison with the 2nd Empress’
dressing in dark blue. (Courtesy of Huanyu TV) 145
Fig. 7.9 The female protagonist Wei, Yin-Luo’s different costumes
colors. “This Chinese TV drama Story of Yanxi Palace is
acclaimed for its costumes design in High-End Gray Color”
(莫蘭迪色). (Courtesy of Huanyu TV) 146
Fig. 7.10 Wei has her unique way to get noticed by the Emperor and
quickly climbs up the social class ladder to be promoted higher
first as imperial concubine, and eventually imperial Honored
Consort Ling wearing in the colors symbolizing high position.
(Courtesy of Huanyu TV) 147
Fig. 8.1 The protagonist Lyuu, Heh-Ruo (played by Actress Mo,
Tzu- Yi) performs German and Italian opera singing as a
vocalist Tenor in Zhong Xian Hall in Taipei. (Photo: Courtesy
of Hakka Affairs Council) 152
Fig. 8.2 The protagonist Lyuu, Heh-Ruo and his wife Lin (played by
Supporting Actress Yang, Shiao-Li). (Photo: Courtesy of
Hakka Affairs Council) 153
Fig. 8.3 Lyuu and his mistress Su (played by Lead Actress Huang
Peijia) are on bed. (Photo: Courtesy of Hakka Affairs Council) 156
Fig. 8.4 Due to the shortage of the budget, Director Lo Lou, Yi-An
and Stage Team Crew use simple stage and props to show the
characters’ hard working in the rice field to grow crops on the
stage. (Photo: Courtesy of Hakka Affairs Council) 159
Fig. 8.5 American planes throw bombs on Taiwan under Japanese
colonialization to try to defeat Japan during World War
II. (Photo: Courtesy of Hakka Affairs Council) 160
Fig. 8.6 Episode 10 shows the young Taiwanese doctor’s helplessness
while drinking in the disturb era of turbulent unsettlement
under Japanese colonialization. (Photo: Courtesy of Hakka
Affairs Council) 161
Fig. 8.7 Actor Mo, Tzu- Yi in the role of Lyuu Heh-Ruo plays the
piano. (Photo: Courtesy of Hakka Affairs Council) 162
Fig. 9.1 2015 Taipei Arts Festival. Japan SEINENDAN Company x
Osaka University Robot Theater Project Metamorphosis
Android Version. (Courtesy of SEINENDAN. Photo Credit:
Photographer Madoka Nishiyama) 170
Fig. 9.2 The cast (the European actor and actresses and the Japanese
robot) stands with the stage design added by the lighting
design. Japan SEINENDAN Company x Osaka University
xxiv List of Figures
Fig. 9.11 Director Tim Miller’s The Terminator 6: Dark Fate (2019), a
direct sequel to be included in the franchise, reunites the
actors after 28 years, including starring Linda Hamilton
returning in the role of Sarah Connor and Arnold
Schwarzenegger reprising the role as a T-800 Terminator yet
now aging. (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 184
Fig. 9.12 Bicentennial Man (1999) presents the nice AI robot
housekeeper Andrew with creativity and craftsmanship would
rather become a real man than have immortality. (Photo:
Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 185
Fig. 9.13 Nicole Kidman stars The Stepford Wives (2004) to expose the
secret of the men’s club in the small town in the film. (Photo:
Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 188
Fig. 9.14 In Ex-Machina (2014), Eva, the female advanced humanoid
AI robot, is Turing tested by the program engineer to evaluate
her (its) human qualities. (Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 189
Fig. 9.15 In the film Her (2013), the man can even loves the AI virtual
female voice who does not have a female sexy body. (Photo:
Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 191
Fig. 9.16 In the Simone (2002), the fans in the world are infatuated
madly with the charms of the unreal false image synthesis.
(Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 192
Fig. 9.17 The beautiful woman in Simone (2002) actually does not exist,
but is created by the director by the marvelous computer
program to be presented by the holography. (Photo: Courtesy
of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 193
Fig. 9.18 Blade Runner 2049 (2017) is the sequel of Blade Runner
(1982). Blade Runner 2049 (2017) stars Harrison Ford and
Ryan Gosling. The director is Denis Villeneuve, and the
producer is Ridley Scott. The AI replicant blade runner (stars
by Ryan Gosling) loves the fictional holographic simulacra.
(Photo: Courtesy of Aflo Co., Ltd.) 194
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
Facing the pandemic thread of COVID-19 in 2020, most people in the
world nowadays since March are asked by their governments to stay at
home being locked down. How do people, while trying to survive, keep
healthy and safe, find something meaningful to do, and make progress
without feeling bored to death? Without the burden and pressure of the
sophisticated advanced scholarly complex theories in the higher educa-
tion, more and more people choose to enjoy Shakespeare, history, reli-
gion, literature and philosophy through seeing films, theater performances,
and TV drama. This interdisciplinary monograph, walking out from the
academic Ivory Tower, leads you to the fascinating and intriguing world
of popular film, (musical) theatre, and TV Drama.
This interdisciplinary, well-crafted monograph leads you to the fasci-
nating and intriguing world of popular film, (musical) theatre, and TV
Drama. This monograph is in the international field of Performance
Studies and Film Studies, in arenas ranging from theatre, film, literature,
TV drama, and AI, to theories of culture, humanities and media, inspiring
the readers to know the scholarly exchange between the East and the West
and bring the populace critical thought. Each chapter contains its issues,
and all connects with the common thematic vein of performance practice
in life represented via theatre and films. You’ll find contemporary and clas-
sical literature works, Eastern and Western, adapted, represented and
For many centuries Italy has been known as producing the opera
of the world. Of late years opera has not been considered the highest
form of musical art, so with the coming of the 20th century, a group
of composers has been working in Italy, trying to get away from the
old opera writing and to develop along the line of orchestral and
chamber music.
Alfredo Casella (1883) is perhaps responsible for this movement
for he lived in Paris for many years and came in contact with
Debussy’s music and the modern movement there. One of his earliest
works to attract attention in America was War Films, a series of
orchestral pictures that were very real. He has written piano pieces,
chamber music and orchestral works and one of his latest is a ballet,
in which it looks as though he were leaving his path of dissonance for
in this he has used folk song as a basis for a new and delightful
expression.
G. Francesco Malipiero (1882) has written two string quartets, one
of which received the Coolidge Prize of the Berkshire Chamber Music
Festival; in these he has broken away from the large sonata form. He
has also written lovely songs.
Ildebrando Pizzetti (1880) has written two operas on texts by
Gabrielle d’Annunzio called La Nave (The Ship) and Fedra. His most
recent work, Fra Ghirardo was performed at the Metropolitan in
1929.
Ottorino Respighi (1879) wrote operas in true Italian fashion, but
deserted them for chamber music and orchestral works. Pines of
Rome and Fountains of Rome, we hear often. His Violin Concerto in
Gregorian Mode was played by Albert Spalding. His latest opera, La
Campana Sommersa (The Sunken Bell) was given at the
Metropolitan in 1928.
All these men show the traces of the Italian love of melody, with
the influence of French impressionism, and German romanticism.
Two or three of these modern Italians now live in Paris, among
them Santoliquido and Vincenzo Davico, both song writers.
And now Noah’s Ark has been put to music by a young Italian,
Vittorio Rieti with wit and humor, in a work for orchestra, played in
May, 1925, at the Prague Festival.
Manuel de Falla
In Spain, one man who has continued along the lines of Albeniz
and Granados is Manuel de Falla (1876). He studied first with Felipe
Pedrell, the father of the modern Spanish school. In 1907 he went to
Paris where he met Debussy and Dukas. He wrote a ballet El Amor
Brujo (Love, the Magician). He combines a picturesque Spanish folk
style with a modern way of writing music. One of his most attractive
works is a scenic arrangement from a chapter in Don Quixote,
Cervantes’ masterpiece, as Spanish as a Spanish fandango. It is a
marionette ballet called El Retablo de Maese Pedro (Master Pedro’s
Puppet Show). It is a charming work and you will like it. His writings
have simplicity, and freshness, which can come only from deep study
and so perfect a mastery of art that there is no self-consciousness. He
is a true nationalist delighting in Spanish color; his music has
nobility and humanness as well as charm.
The Netherlands
In America we not only hear the works of all the people of whom
we have spoken in this chapter, but among our composers are a few
who show marked twentieth century ways of composing. Some of
them are American born, some have adopted the country, but all are
working for the advancement of American music: Loeffler, our first
impressionist, Bloch, Carpenter, Gruenberg, Whithorne, Morris,
Jacobi, Marion Bauer, Eichheim, Carl Engel, Ornstein, Varese,
Salzedo, Ruggles, Cowell, Antheil, and Copland.
Several organizations have worked for the cause of modern music
by presenting concerts devoted to works by contemporary Europeans
and Americans. The Pro Musica Society has been responsible for the
visits to this country of Maurice Ravel, Bela Bartok, Darius Milhaud,
Alexandre Tansman and Arthur Honegger.
The League of Composers (founded 1923) has had many notable
“first performances” of compositions by Schoenberg, Bloch, Bartok,
Stravinsky, Gruenberg, Malipiero, Hindemith, Copland, de Falla,
Whithorne, Carrillo, etc.
Our Good-Bye
This book has been longer than it should have been, yet our sins
have been of omission rather than commission. But if we have only
made you realize that the world cannot stand still, that music is
always growing whether we understand it or not, and the good is
handed on to the next generation even though much “falls by the
wayside,” we will not have written in vain.
SOME OF THE BOOKS WE CONSULTED
(12th Century)
Guillaume d’Aquitaine
Bernart de Ventardorn
Bertran de Born
Richard the Lion-Hearted (1169–99)
Peire Vidal
Le Moine de Montaudon (The Monk of)
Guiraut de Borneil (Maestre dels trobadors)
Gaucelm Faidit (Jongleur)
Peire Cardinal
(13th Century)