Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Precision Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/precision
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Recently, surface texturing has received much attention as a method of enhancing the tribological prop-
Received 10 August 2016 erties of a cutting tool surface. However, effective texture patterns and dimensions on a tool surface are
Received in revised form 2 December 2016 still difficult to obtain and suitable textures can be obtained only by trial and error. In order to overcome
Accepted 17 December 2016
this problem, we newly develop cutting tools with dimple-shaped textures having different dimensions
Available online 20 January 2017
and arrays, generated on the tool rake face. In addition, we evaluate their crater wear resistance and cut-
ting forces in steel material cutting. Furthermore, under various cutting conditions, the performances of
Keywords:
the cutting tools with dimple-shaped textures are compared with those of tools with groove-shaped tex-
Cutting
Cutting tool
tures in order to establish a guideline for designing appropriate surface textures on cutting tool surfaces. A
Tribology series of cutting experiments demonstrate that the dimple textures significantly improve the crater wear
Crater wear resistance and the tribological behavior on the tool rake face, and they exhibit a superior performance
Texture compared with those with groove textures, especially in a severely lubricated environment.
© 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.precisioneng.2017.01.009
0141-6359/© 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
T. Sugihara, T. Enomoto / Precision Engineering 49 (2017) 52–60 53
Fig. 1. Developed cutting tool with a microdimple textured rake face (DT-01).
Table 1
Developed cutting tools with micro stripe textures.
Tool name Ddep (m) Ddia (m) Din (m) Ew (m) Array Ar (%)
Conventional – – – – 0
DT-01 5 50 75 30 Linear 35.0
DT-02 5 50 75 30 Zigzag 35.0
DT-03 5 30 75 30 Linear 12.6
DT-04 5 30 75 30 Zigzag 12.6
DT-05 5 70 75 30 Linear 68.3
DT-06 5 70 75 30 Zigzag 68.3
DT-07 5 50 95 30 Linear 22.0
Fig. 2. Parameters of dimple textures.
DT-08 5 50 95 30 Zigzag 22.0
DT-09 5 50 55 30 Linear 64.9
DT-10 5 50 55 30 Zigzag 64.9
texture and to establish a guideline for selecting the appropriate
texture for a cutting tool surface.
2. Experimental details
Fig. 4. Geometry of the cutting tool. 3.1. Wear resistance under the wet cutting condition
Fig. 5. Maximum depth of crater wear of conventional and developed tools under the wet cutting condition (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate: 0.20 mm/tooth).
Fig. 6. Profiles of the rake face of cutting tools after wet cutting for 300 m (left: 3-dimensional profile; right: cross-section profile, Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate:
0.20 mm/tooth).
T. Sugihara, T. Enomoto / Precision Engineering 49 (2017) 52–60 55
Fig. 7. Relationship between the amount of crater wear and the area ratio of the textured rake face under the wet cutting condition (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate:
0.20 mm/tooth).
Fig. 8. Maximum depth of crater wear of conventional and developed tools under the dry cutting condition (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate: 0.20 mm/tooth).
Fig. 9. Relationship between the amount of crater wear and the area ratio of the textured rake face under the dry cutting condition (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate:
0.20 mm/tooth).
tool after cutting for 300 m under the wet cutting condition. In this cantly suppressed the crater wear compared with the conventional
figure, the depths of the crater wear are the average values cal- cutting tool. Fig. 6 shows the 3-dimensional images and sectional
culated from five different profiles obtained by the measurement profiles of the conventional tool and DT-05, which shows one of the
results of the laser microscope. As shown in this figure, severe crater most excellent wear resistances among the developed tools. These
wear, approximately 9 m deep, occurred on the rake face of the results confirm that DT-05 reduced the maximum depth of the
conventional tool without a surface texture. On the other hand, crater wear from 9 m, obtained in the conventional tool (Fig. 6(a)),
Fig. 5 clearly indicates that some of the developed tools signifi-
56 T. Sugihara, T. Enomoto / Precision Engineering 49 (2017) 52–60
Fig. 10. SEM images of the rake faces of DT-05 and DT-09 after dry cutting (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate: 0.20 mm/tooth).
Fig. 11. Fn and Ff of conventional tool and DT-05 under wet and dry cutting conditions (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate: 0.20 mm/tooth).
to 3 m (Fig. 6(b)), and the microdimples at the tool-chip contact 3.2. Wear resistance under the dry cutting condition
area still remained even after cutting for 300 m.
Moreover, Fig. 7 indicates the relationship between the area Fig. 8 summarizes the depth of the crater wear of the conven-
ratio of the textured rake face and the amount of the crater wear tional tool and that of each developed tool after cutting for 300 m
under the wet cutting condition. In this figure, the area ratio is con- under the dry cutting condition. As shown in this figure, the crater
sidered to be zero for the conventional tool. This figure suggests wear depths of the conventional and the developed tools were
that the wear resistances of the developed cutting tools strongly increased compared with that in the wet cutting condition (Fig. 5).
depend on the area ratio of the textured surfaces. When the area This is because the cutting temperature was increased and the
ratio is less than approximately 20%, the dimple textures are inef- lubricity at the tool-chip interface was decreased without the use of
fective for improving the crater wear resistance. On the other hand, the cutting fluid. On the other hand, Fig. 8 also indicates that some
when the area ratio is more than 20%, the wear resistance of the of the dimple textures are still effective for improving the crater
dimple-textured rake face is improved in proportion to the increase wear resistance even under the dry cutting condition, whereas the
of the area ratio of the textured rake face. Furthermore, comparing difference of the wear amount between the conventional and the
Fig. 7(a) with Fig. 7(b), it is confirmed that the array patterns have developed tools was diminished.
little influence on the amount of the crater wear of the developed In addition, Fig. 9 indicates the relationship between the area
tools under the cutting condition of this experiment. ratios of each textured rake face and the amount of the crater wear
T. Sugihara, T. Enomoto / Precision Engineering 49 (2017) 52–60 57
Table 2
Cutting conditions.
Fig. 13. Developed cutting tool with micro stripe textured rake face (MS-01) [7].
Fig. 14. Profiles of the rake face of MS-01 after wet cutting for 300 m (left: 3-dimensional profile; right: cross-section profile, Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate:
0.20 mm/tooth).
Fig. 17. SEM images of the rake faces of DT-05 and MS-01 (Cutting speed: 200 m/min, Feed rate: 0.20 mm/tooth).
smaller than the friction coefficient of the conventional tool under tion with the ratio between the concave and convex area of the
the wet cutting condition. MS-01 showed slightly better tribolog- textured rake face.
ical properties compared to DT-05, even though area ratio Ar of (2) From the analysis of the cutting forces, it was clarified that the
MS-01 (50%) is smaller than that of DT-05 (68.3%). This might be textured surface improves the crater wear resistance by serving
because, in the case of the grooved rake face, the cutting fluid pene- as (i) a micro-reservoir for a cutting fluid, and (ii) a micro-trap
trates into the tool-chip interface from the end of the grooves while for wear debris.
the tool rake face is in contact with the chips, because the grooved (3) The cutting performances of a tool with dimple texture and
rake face has an “open shape” structure. In addition, microgrooves that with grooved texture under various lubricating condi-
can supply the retained cutting fluid evenly to the tool-chip inter- tions were investigated. The experimental results show that
face due to their continuous shape. These results suggest that open “closed shape” structures, such as microdimples, can exhibit
shape structures, such as microgrooves, have a potential to show superior performance, especially under a severe lubricating
superior lubricity compared to closed shape structures with the environment, although “open shape” structures, including
use of an adequate amount of cutting fluids, due to their excellent microgrooves, also perform satisfactorily when using a great
in-flow property of the cutting fluids. quantity of flooded cutting fluid.
On the other hand, under the paste cutting condition, DT-05,
which has the dimple texture, exhibits the lowest friction coeffi- Acknowledgments
cient. In the case of paste cutting, the effect of retaining lubricants
in the surface textures becomes more important, because the lubri- We thank everyone at L.P.S. Works Co., Ltd., and Neos Co., Ltd.,
cant is not supplied to the cutting tool during the contact period of for their invaluable assistance and advice.
the tool surface with the workpiece material. Therefore, the rake
face with the microdimples, which are “closed shape” structures,
shows better tribological behavior. On the contrary, microgrooves References
have a risk of a flowing-out of lubricant from the structure. Fur-
[1] Evans CJ, Bryne JB. Structured. textured or engineered surfaces. Ann CIRP
thermore, Fig. 17 shows enlarged SEM images of the worn areas 1999;48:541–56.
on the rake faces of DT-05 and MS-01, indicating that the work- [2] Bruzzone AAG, Costa HL, Lonardo PM, Lucca DA. Advances in engineered
surfaces for functional performance. Ann CIRP 2008;57:750–69.
piece material was locally adhered to the edge of the microgrooves
[3] Etsion I. Improving tribological performance of mechanical components by
(Fig. 17(b)). Ma et al. reported that a surface texture on a tool laser surface texturing. Tribol Lett 2004;17:733–7.
rake face can act as a microcutter of chips during cutting process [4] Sugihara T, Enomoto T. Development of a cutting tool with a
[24], which leads to the increase of friction and local chip adhe- nano/micro-textured surface—improvement of anti-adhesive effect by
considering the texture patterns. Precis Eng 2009;33:425–9.
sions at the edge of surface textures. The SEM image indicates that [5] Sugihara T, Enomoto T. Improving anti-adhesion in aluminum alloy cutting by
the microgrooves particularly provide this adverse effect without micro stripe texture. Precis Eng 2012;36:229–37.
the use of the cutting fluid compared to the microdimples, and [6] Enomoto T, Sugihara T, Yukinaga S, Hirose K, Satake U. Highly wear-resistant
cutting tools with textured surfaces in steel cutting. Ann CIRP 2012;61:571–4.
the advantages of the surface texture might be diminished by the [7] Sugihara T, Enomoto T. Crater and flank wear resistance of cutting tools
local chip adhesion. In conclusion, these results indicate that closed having micro textured surfaces. Precis Eng 2013;37:888–96.
shape structures, including microdimples, exhibit superior perfor- [8] Kawasegi N, Sugimori H, Morimoto H, Morita N, Hori I. Development of
cutting tools with microscale and nanoscale textures to improve frictional
mance, as compared to open shape structures, especially in a severe behavior. Precis Eng 2009;33:248–54.
lubricating environment. [9] Obikawa T, Kamio A, Takaoka H, Osada A. Micro-texture at the coated tool
face for high performance cutting. Int J Mach Tool Manuf 2011:966–72.
[10] Koshy P, Tovey J. Performance of electrical discharge textured cutting tools.
Ann CIRP 2011;60:153–6.
5. Conclusions [11] Chang W, Sun J, Luo X, Ritchie JM, Mack C. Investigation of microstructured
milling tool for deferring tool wear. Wear 2011;271:9–10, 2433–2437.
[12] Zu W, Jianxin D, Yang C, Youqiang X, Jun Z. Performance of the self-lubricating
In this study, cutting tools with microdimple textured surfaces
textured tools in dry cutting of Ti-6Al-4V. Int J Adv Manuf Technol
on their rake face were developed in order to improve the wear 2012;62:9–12, 943–951.
resistance in cutting of steel materials. In addition, a compara- [13] Xie J, Luo MJ, Wu KK, Yang LF, Li DH. Experimental study on cutting
tive evaluation between the microdimples and microgrooves was temperature and cutting force in dry turning of titanium alloy using a
non-coated microgrooved tool. Int J Mach Tool Manuf 2013;73:25–36.
conducted, with the following findings: [14] Fatima A, Mativenga PT. Assessment of tool rake surface structure geometry
for enhanced contact phenomena. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2016;2013:771–6.
[15] Xing Y, Deng J, Li S, Yue H, Meng R, Gao P. Cutting performance and wear
(1) Microdimples on the rake face of a cutting tool effectively sup- characteristics of Al2O3/TiC ceramic cutting tools with WS2/Zr soft-coatings
and nano-textures in dry cutting. Wear 2014;318:12–26.
press the crater wear in cutting medium carbon steels, and the
[16] Kim DM, Lee I, Kim SK, Kim BH, Park HW. Influence of a micropatterned insert
effect can be obtained even under dry cutting conditions. The on characteristics of the tool—workpiece interface in a hard turning process. J
wear resistance of the textured rake face has a strong correla- Mater Process Technol 2016;229:160–71.
60 T. Sugihara, T. Enomoto / Precision Engineering 49 (2017) 52–60
[17] Wakuda M, Yamauchi Y, Kanzaki S, Yasuda Y. Effect of surface texturing on [21] Hamilton DB, Walowit JA, Allen CM. An investigation of the flow and effect of
friction reduction between ceramic and steel materials under lubricated a cutting oil in machining operation. Trans ASME 1966;88:177–85.
sliding contact. Wear 2003;254:356–63. [22] Suh NP, Saka N. Surface engineering. Ann CIRP 1987;36:403–8.
[18] Xing Y, Deng J, Wang W, Ehmann K, Cao J. Experimental assessment of laser [23] Suh NP, Sin H-C. The genesis of friction. Wear 1981;691:91–114.
textured cutting tools in dry cutting of aluminum alloys. J Manuf Sci Eng [24] Ma J, Duong NH, Chang S, Lian Y, Deng J, Lei S. Assessment of microgrooved
2016;138:071006. cutting tool in dry machining of AISI 1045 steel. J Manuf Sci Eng
[19] Etsion I. State of the art in laser surface texturing. Trans ASME J Tribol 2015;137:031001.
2005;127:248–53.
[20] Romer GRBE, in’t Veld AJH, Meijer J, Groenendijk MNW. On the formation of
laser induced self-organizing nanostructures. Ann CIRP 2009;58:201–4.