Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vascular Handlebar Syndrome With Blunt Injury of Common Femoral Artery
Vascular Handlebar Syndrome With Blunt Injury of Common Femoral Artery
Review
Summary: Vascular handlebar syndrome with blunt injury of the common femoral artery is a rare vascular trauma
mechanism, with high possibility of being missed or delayed. We present two cases of vascular handlebar syndrome treated in
our hospital and a systematic review of the literature using MEDLINE and SCOPUS databases. Literature review identified
20 similar cases. The median age of patients was 18 years, and in vast majority males in gender. In most cases, the common
femoral artery injury was an intimal flap and lumen occlusion with intramural thrombosis followed by transection and intimal
injury without occlusion or thrombosis. The median time between injury and diagnosis/treatment was half an hour. Clinical
presentation ranged from asymptomatic to acute limb ischemia. The grade of acute ischemia was mostly Rutherford class I
(n=14), while acute IIa (n=4), chronic ischemia (n=3), and no ischemia (n=1) were also noticed. The correct diagnosis was
revealed by clinical examination only (n=1), or by the combination of clinical and imaging techniques including computed
tomography angiography (n=7) and duplex ultrasonography (n=4) or both (n=10). Management of the handlebar trauma
syndrome injuries was surgical in most cases. Outcome was favorable in all patients. Vascular handlebar syndrome is
extremely rare and high suspicion is required for early diagnosis and definitive treatment, as the early management is
effective and crucial for averting the devastating consequences. An individualized approach to the vascular trauma patient
is to be applied with considerations taken to the age of the patient, the mechanism of the injury, the anatomy of the lesion,
and symptomatology of the case.
Keywords: Handlebar syndrome, vascular injury, blunt trauma, common femoral artery, limb ischemia
Case report B
The second case refers to a 21-year-old male college stu-
dent who had an accident with his bicycle which led to left
groin blunt injury by the handlebar and acute ischemia of
his left limb. The patient was stable with good motor func-
tion and sensation of his injured limb. On physical exami-
nation of the lower extremities the left leg was pale and
there was a bruise on the left groin. On palpation the limb
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4
Discussion
always the predominant symptom leading the patient seek-
ing for medical help. In the current report, we describe two cases of vascular
In Table II, interval to diagnosis, examination revealing handlebar trauma syndrome and blunt traumatic injury of
the correct diagnosis and treatment choice and outcome CFA caused by the handelbar of a bicycle and present a
are presented. The median time until the diagnosis was half systematic review of the literature. A favorable outcome
an hour in a total number of 21 cases; no such information was mostly observed, likely a result of limited vascular
Identification of studies via databases and registers Identification of studies via other methods
Identification
Reports sought for retrieval Reports not retrieved Reports sought for retrieval Reports not retrieved
(n = 14)
Screening
(n = 0) (n = 7) (n = 0)
Table I. Clinical characteristics, type of injury and presentation of the 22 cases described in this review
First author (year) Age Gender Vehicle Vascular injury Ischemia grade* Presentation
Hadeed et al., 49 Male All-terrain-vehicle/ CFA, intimal injury-occlusion Acute IIa Acute limb ischemia
2005 [3] vehicle with handlebar on superimposed underlying
calcific atherosclerosis
Sarfati et al., 13 Male Bicycle CFA, intimal injury-occlusion Acute IIa Acute limb ischemia
2002 [4]
Sarfati et al., 9 Male Bicycle CFA, intimal injury-occlusion Chronic Thigh and calf claudication,
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4
Notes. CFA: common femoral artery. *Ischemia grade in accordance with Rutherford classification for limb ischemia.
injury and the lack of atherosclerosis in a young population age [9, 24]. Lesions caused by blunt direct trauma may
group. easily be missed in young patients due to the lack of symp-
toms and the extensive pattern of collateral construction
Age and gender that may occur in this age.
Table II. Interval to diagnosis, examination revealing the correct diagnosis and treatment choice and outcome of the 22 cases described in this
review
Hadeed et al., 2005 [3] 48 hours later Clinical and CT angiography PTFE bypass grafting, aorta Good
to SFA and jump graft to
deep femoral artery
Sarfati et al., 2002 [4] 5 hours later Clinical and CT angiography Hypogastric artery Good
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4
interposition grafting
Sarfati et al., 2002 [4] 10 weeks later Clinical and CT angiography Dacron bypass grafting Good
Bean et al., 1968 [5] 8 hours later Clinical and CT angiography Primary closure of Good
longitudinal arteriotomy
Baker et al., 1996 [6] Immediately anticoagulation, Doppler and CT angiography Saphenous vein patch Good
next day surgery angioplasty
Hassan et al., 2002 [7] Immediately Clinical, colour Doppler, CT Resection and primary end- Good
angiography to-end anastomosis
Madan et al., 2003 [8] Immediately Clinical and Doppler Interposition of prosthetic Good
graft between external iliac
and CFA
Paling et al., 1999 [9] Half an hour later Clinical (no pulses), Doppler, CT Saphenous vein patch Good
angiography angioplasty
Waikittipong, 2009 [10] 2 months later Clinical, CT angiography Interposition of PTFE graft Good
between external iliac and
superficial femoral artery
Kioumehr et al., 1989 [2] 8 months later Clinical (loud systolic bruit, no Saphenous vein bypass Good
pulses) and CT angiography grafting
Ophir et al., 1968 [11] 4 hours later Clinical Saphenous vein patch Good
angioplasty
Chadha et al., 2003 [12] 4 hours later Clinical (no pulses), Doppler, CT Primary end-to-end Good
angiography anastomosis
Rose et al., 2016 [13] Immediately Clinical, CT angiography Saphenous vein Good
interposition graft
Yoshimura et al., 2019 Later that day anticoagulation, Clinical, Doppler, CT Saphenous vein patch Good
[14] next day surgery angiography angioplasty
Taneva Zaryanova et al., Immediately Clinical, Doppler, CT Interposition of PTFE graft Good
2017 [15] angiography
Leo et al., 2012 [16] 3 days later Clinical, colour Doppler, CT Anticoagulation therapy Good
angiography only (duration: 30days)
Jones et al., 2016 [17] 2 days later Clinical and Doppler Common femoral artery Good
patching
Sandri et al., 2003 [18] Immediately, 24 hours later Clinical and Doppler Saphenous vein Good
surgery interposition graft
Hussain et al., 2021 [19] Immediately Clinical, Doppler, CT Resection of right CFA and Good
angiography an end-to-end anastomosis
with common femoral patch
angioplasty
Patoulias et al., 2021 Immediately Clinical and Doppler Resection and major Good
[20] saphenous vein
interposistion graft
Case A, 2015 2 hours later Clinical, Doppler, CT PTFE patch angioplasty Good
angiography
Case B, 2010 Immediately Clinical, Doppler, CT PTFE patch angioplasty Good
angiography
Notes. CT: computed tomography; CFA: common femoral artery; SFA: superficial femoral artery; PTFE: polytetrafluoroethylene.
and abduction which leaded to CFA injury [25]. Studies intima leading to blood flow mediated dissection of the torn
have reported similar blunt trauma with CFA injury caused intima and thrombus formation along the denuded artery
by the fall of heavy objects on the pelvis or thigh [26, 27]. In [11]. More specifically, the handlebar of a motorcycle or
our review, we strictly included vascular handlebar syn- bicycle as the rider falls forwards strikes the groin, causing
drome caused by a vehicle as those mentioned above, sim- a direct blow at the level of the inguinal ligament. A seem-
ilar to our two cases. ingly trivial injury can result in significant force being
applied to the artery [10]. The mechanism is that of blunt
force over the femoral vessel as it is compressed on the
The mechanism of the injury
bony pelvis [25]. It is the location and position of the CFA
Ophir et al. first described the mechanism of injury attribut- that renders it vulnerable to injury from high-impact
ing the vascular injury in the formation of a tear at the CFA trauma, as the one mentioned [1, 12, 16, 28]. At the level
of the inguinal ligament, the femoral neurovascular bundle, or pseudo-aneurysmal dilation [25, 32]. For blunt trauma
thus the femoral artery seems to be relatively immobile as it and CFA injury, intimal disruption is the most common
passes anterior to the superior pubic ramus and femoral type of vascular damage, followed by intramural hema-
head to its most superficial position. The CFA maintains toma, subintimal fibrosis and simple contusion [3, 4, 16,
a fixed position in the groin area in the fibro-osseus canal 33]. In our study, CFA transection occurred in 3 cases
formed by its multiple branches, periadventitial connective (14%). As before mentioned, the relatively sharp anterior
tissue, and the femoral sheath. This immobility renders the lip of the acetabulum lies posterior to the CFA. Conse-
CFA more vulnerable to compression against the underly- quently, a direct impact in the inguinal region with a blunt
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4
ing osseous structures [3, 4, 10, 12, 16, 25]. surface can result in the CFA being crushed against the
anterior lip of the acetabulum, leading to complete transec-
tion of the CFA, without any associated bony injury as
The mechanism of vascular occlusion Chadha et al. described [12].
In blunt vascular trauma, complete transection may lead
In our review, the vascular injury was most of the times
to retraction, vasoconstriction, and thrombosis of the ves-
CFA intimal injury with occlusion (n=18, 82%). Blunt forces
sel, presenting with limiting hemorrhage, as in the case of
or excessive stretching of the arterial wall can lead to struc-
Suliman et al. [23]. In the case reported by Yoshimura
tural changes and then to a gradual but progressive occlu-
et al. it was presumed that the damaged intima had necro-
sion [14, 29]. The outer layers of a healthy artery are more
tized or retracted because of the complete circumferential
elastic than the intima which presumably accounts for the
dissection leading to thrombosis and obstructive blood flow
selective layer rupture on blunt trauma [5]. The intimal tear
[14]. Partial lacerations of the injured vessel may result in
or the intramural dissection owing to a blunt trauma has the
persistent bleeding as well, a potentially much more severe
potential to mechanically obstruct the arterial flow. A pro-
condition for the patient, especially when large vessels as
posed mechanism is that of shearing forces transmitted
the CFA are involved [25].
through the affected vessel so that a tear in the endothe-
lium and other layers of the intima is formed. The piece
of intima still attached to the media project into the lumen Clinical presentation
of the artery as an intimal flap, which can then lead to the
thrombosis of the vessel [3, 11, 30]. The vascular occlusion Blunt arterial injury in the absence of associated bone frac-
is presumably either by thrombus formation entirely as ture has been usually overlooked leading to devastating
Byun et al. described [29] or, by intimal dissection and consequences. In case the patient is presented with classic
downward prolapse associated with some thrombus forma- signs of acute limb ischemia on initial assessment, the diag-
tion as in the case of Bean et al. [2, 5] and Yoshimura and nostic approach is unchallenging for an expert. However,
Hamamoto [14]. Whether only occlusion due to the pro- there are cases where signs indicative of the need for fur-
lapse of inner arterial layers or thrombosis following the ther clinical and imaging examination are not apparent,
vessel injury, or both take place, the upcoming blood flow and therefore they are neglected. During physical examina-
obstruction occurs in either case. tion the presence of signs of acute limb ischemia, including
The presence of an atherosclerotic plaque may predis- pain, decreased or absent pulses, pallor, coolness, or paral-
pose toward intimal disruption when subjected to shearing ysis suggest possible vascular injury. In acute peripheral
forces due to not only intimal weakening but also loss of artery occlusion, clinical presentation usually begins sud-
compliance and elasticity that occur [3]. In cases of preex- denly with symptoms as severe groin pain and swelling,
isted peripheral arterial disease (PAD) even a moderate often accompanied by ecchymosis and hematoma, cool-
speed compressive trauma can lead to an intimal split. ness, and loss of normal color [3, 16, 34]. While the most
What is more, as the upcoming physiological adaptation common sign of vascular injuries is pulse deficits, in 25%
to PAD is to remodel and increase the collateral blood sup- of the cases normal pulses may be present on the initial
ply to the extremity suffered, when blunt trauma occurs, examination [3, 34]. Thus, diagnosis of vascular injury sec-
collateral circulation may mitigate acute interruption of ondary to blunt trauma might be missed on initial exam in
axial flow after the main vessel has been damaged. As a the presence of a normal pulse [3].
result, there may be negligible or no signs of acute limb Of all the cases reported, in 18 out of 22, the patients are
ischemia, as in the cases of Karachentsev [23] and Peck presented with signs and symptoms of acute limb ischemia
and Rasmussen [31]. such as pulse deficit on clinical and DUS examination, pain,
numbness, pale skin color, and low temperature of the
limb. When the presentation was as above mentioned,
Intimal disruption and vascular the diagnosis was made in a short amount of time; immedi-
ately or few hours after the incident. It is highly rare for the
transection
right diagnosis to be made before complete occlusion of the
Although it was originally described as leading to vessel injured vessel occurs. In two of the studied cases, the inju-
thrombosis, intimal damage owing to a blunt trauma may ries were detected in the immediate postinjury phase
also result in subintimal hemorrhage, complete transec- before ischemic symptoms emerged [6, 13]. Both of these
tion, partial avulsion, complete artery stenosis, aneurysmal cases were presented with local swelling and associated
thrill and bruit [6, 13]. For patients presenting no signs [13, 33, 36]. In the majority of the reviewed cases, it was
indicative of vascular injury in the initial examination, per- the CTA that confirmed the diagnosis and demonstrated
sistent pain and claudication revealed the vascular injury the exact location of the vascular injury, in order to
within a certain amount of time after the incident. In all plan the best surgical approach and management, underly-
cases of chronic clinical characteristics, calf claudication ing the utility of this examination technique.
was always the predominant symptom. In some cases,
authors have documented normal distal pulses in the
immediate postinjury phase in patients who developed
Interval to diagnosis and intervention –
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4
bypass with the anastomosis below the knee should be femoral artery and conducted a review of the literature of
avoided because this could lead to limb disparity, which this specific syndrome. It mainly concerns males of young
can also occur if stenosis remains after reconstruction age and children. Clinical presentation ranges from acute
[9]. With all these in mind, the long-term efficiency of pros- limb ischemia to complete lack of signs. It is the high index
thetic grafts in pediatric extremity injuries is unknown, of suspension that can lead to thorough clinical and imag-
thus, when grafting is required, the literature agrees on ing evaluation averting the devastating consequences of
generally favor autogenous conduits [4, 9, 14, 24]. In our delayed diagnosis of such vascular injury. The treatment
reported cases, synthetic grafts were preferred over autoge- is often proportional to the extent of the injury and the
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4
nous grafts. Even though, the one patient was only 15 years- age of the patient. Surgical treatment is often required,
old, we concluded to this choice of graft since the patient’s sometimes with vascular reconstruction using autogenous
body size was almost the same as that of an adult. or synthetic graft. Conservative approach has also been dis-
The role of endovascular intervention in the pediatric cussed. Regardless of the chosen treatment, early recogni-
population has previously been documented more as a tem- tion and appropriate treatment are necessary elements for
porizing measure for revascularization rather than a treat- a good outcome, rescue, and normal development of the
ment option [35, 37]. Angiletta et al. treated a 13-year-old limb.
patient with the use of a stent in the distal superficial
femoral artery, after estimating that vessel’s caliber at the
time of injury was of inappropriate size for traditional References
surgical reconstruction [35]. The main disadvantage of
1. Deutsch V, Sinkover A, Bank H. The motor-scooter-handlebar
endovascular interventions in pediatric patients is similar
syndrome. Lancet. 1968;2(7577):1051–3.
to the disadvantage of prosthetic grafts. Because of the con- 2. Kioumehr F, Yaghmai I, Bakody P. Delayed common femoral
stant growth of the child’s organs and tissue, the conse- artery stenosis due to blunt trauma. Can Assoc Radiol J.
quent enlarging of the vessels will not conform with the 1989;40(6):324–5.
3. Hadeed JG, Albaugh GK, Alexander JB, Ross SE, Ierardi RP.
fixed stent length and diameter. This may predispose to
Blunt handlebar injury of the common femoral artery: a case
complications such as restenosis, stent fracture, stent dislo- report. Ann Vasc Surg. 2005;19(3):414–7.
cation and acute to chronic ischemia and lower limb length 4. Sarfati MR, Galt SW, Treiman GS, Kraiss LW. Common femoral
discrepancies due to increased caliber of the treated artery artery injury secondary to bicycle handlebar trauma. J Vasc
Surg. 2002;35(3):589–91.
[14, 35, 37]. As a result, future vascular reconstruction may
5. Bean AR, Weston TS. The motor-scooter handlebar syndrome:
be required [37]. report of a case. Aust N Z J Surg. 1968;41(2):137–9.
6. Baker WE, Bilimoria MM, Victor MG. Motor-scooter handle;
bar syndrome: blunt traumatic injury of the femoral artery.
J Trauma. 1996;40(6):1017–20.
Rarity of cases 7. Hassan I, Rasmussen TE, Cullinane DC, Panneton JM. Motor
scooter handlebar syndrome. J Trauma. 2002;53(4):806.
In a retrospective study of our hospital including patients
8. Madan AK, Raafat A, Hewitt RL. Complete femoral artery
with arterial trauma for the 30-year period between 1989 transection from blunt trauma. J La State Med Soc. 2003;155
and 2018, blunt trauma accounted for 29% of the cases (4):215–6.
(83 cases out of 285), and 22% (65 cases out of 285) if 9. Paling AJ, Viersma JH. Blunt trauma of the common femoral
artery. J Pediatr Surg. 1999;34(10):1557–8.
excluding the iatrogenic causes. What is more, only 2 of
10. Waikittipong S. Traumatic occlusion of common femoral
these cases were caused due to handlebar syndrome corre- artery secondary to motorcycle handlebar injury. Thai J Surg.
sponding to a rate of 3.5% for such cases, underlying the 2009;30:39–41.
rarity of the syndrome [40]. 11. Ophir M, Shulemson M, Laufer M, Sinkower A. Acute periph-
eral arterial occlusion due to blunt traumatic rupture of the
intima. Isr J Med Sci. 1968;4(4):905–7.
12. Chadha M, Balain B, Dhal A, Kumar S, Arora A. Isolated,
closed rupture of the common femoral artery resulting from
Limitations blunt trauma. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2003;123(5):245–6.
13. Rose E, Hardasmalani M. The motor-scooter handlebar
The syndrome is rare, so our review research identified a syndrome: right common femoral artery occlusion secondary
limited amount of cases which were included. Thus, a lim- to blunt trauma. J Emerg Med. 2016;50(4):674–5.
14. Yoshimura K, Hamamoto H. Traumatic right common femoral
ited number of cases were used to extract generalized con-
artery occlusion caused by blunt bicycle handlebar injury:
clusions. Nevertheless, we believe that our reasonable and a case report. Surg Case Rep. 2019;5(1):64.
well justified conclusions may contribute to better under- 15. Taneva Zaryanova GT, Arribas Díaz AB, Baeza Bermejillo C,
standing and treating such cases. Aparicio Martínez C, González García A. Complete femoral
artery transection following handlebar trauma. Trauma Case
Rep. 2017;9:1–4.
16. Leo LA, Grigoratos C, Spontoni P, Violo C, Balbarini A. An
unusual case of traumatic occlusion of the left common
Conclusions femoral artery. J Cardiovasc Med. 2012;13(3):222–4.
17. Jones SD, Fischer J, Kwan C, Tessaro M. Traumatic femoral
artery thrombosis diagnosed by point-of-care ultrasonogra-
In conclusion, we reported two interesting cases of vascular phy in the pediatric emergency department. Pediatr Emerg
handlebar syndrome with blunt injury of the common Care. 2016;32(12):885–7.
18. Sandri JL. CFA injury secondary to bicycle handlebar trauma. 35. Angiletta D, Impedovo G, Pestrichella F, Marotta V, Perilli F,
J Vasc Bras. 2003;2(3):281–3. Regina G. Blunt femoropopliteal trauma in a child: is stenting
19. Hussain B, Sitto TM, Sethuraman U. Thrombosis of external a good option? J Vasc Surg 2006;44(1):201–4. discussion 205.
iliac and common femoral arteries secondary to blunt trauma 36. Skinner RA. A case of unusual blunt peripheral artery injuries:
due to handlebar injury. Am J Emerg Med. 2021;49:291–3. The expanded use of CT and endovascular embolization. J
20. Patoulias I, Panopoulos I, Pitoulias G, Feidantsis T, Patoulias Trauma. 2006;61(6):1532–5. discussion 1535.
D. Femoral artery thrombosis in an 11-year old boy due to a 37. Singla AA, McPherson D, Singla AA, Cross J, Leslie A. External
blunt trauma. Folia Med Cracov. 2021;61(4):115–9. iliac artery occlusion in a paediatric patient following han-
21. Sugrue M, Caldwell EM, Damours SK, Crozier JA, Deane SA. dlebar trauma. J Surg Case Rep. 2015;2015(3):rjv015.
Vascular injury in Australia. Surg Clin North Am. 2002;82(1): 38. Parry NG, Feliciano DV, Burke RM, Cava RA, Nicholas JM,
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/pdf/10.1024/0301-1526/a001054 - Friday, March 08, 2024 5:12:53 PM - IP Address:2800:370:cb:88d0:8861:6fbd:2dc6:cae4