You are on page 1of 4

FEATURE

Green hydrogen: water use


implications and opportunities
Marcus Newborough & Graham Cooley
ITM Power PLC

Substituting green hydrogen for conventional fuels will serve to decarbonise the energy system and reduce its water
consumption. Benefits will also accrue for the water sector, including improving the efficiency of wastewater treatment,
oxygenating hypoxic water bodies, improving the provision of drinking water supplies in arid regions, and making better
use of the seawater resource. Accordingly it is recommended that national ‘net zero’ strategies address renewable electricity,
green hydrogen and water use in a more integrated manner.

Water savings from from the steam turbine to maximise cycle function of whether the crop is rain-fed or
efficiency. For example, thermal power plant irrigated. For example, values of >200t/MWh
green hydrogen account for 41% of all freshwater withdrawals apply in some regions for ethanol produced
Water consumption has been increasing at in the USA.4 By comparison, wind and solar from irrigated sugar beet and >1400t/MWh for
over twice the rate of population growth over power generation have zero or minimal water biodiesel produced from irrigated soybean.10
the past 100 years, with about 70% now footprints, so their increased adoption will Accordingly, depending on the biomass
being used by agriculture, 19% by industry yield large water savings. In the chemical and source, the water footprints of commonly
and 11% in buildings.1 Although there is no food-and-beverage-processing sectors, it has available transport fuels (e.g. blended petrol
water shortage globally, fresh water scarcity recently been estimated that water savings of containing 10% ethanol, or diesel containing
threatens food security and nutrition for about nearly 60% can be achieved if the purchase of 5% biodiesel) can be much higher than those
25% of the world population and, on average, renewables is increased by 50%.5 based solely on petroleum. In the transport
only two in three people have access to safe Water withdrawal rates by power stations sector, the water savings realised by preferring
drinking water.2,3 vary widely and are a strong function of the green hydrogen to hydrocarbon fuels are further
Rather than being directly consumed by end cooling technique employed, but the rates enhanced by using fuel cell electric vehicles,
users, the majority of water use today occurs of water consumption relate mainly to the because these typically consume <50% of the
within the supply chains that serve each sector efficiency of generation, including CO2 capture energy to travel the same distance as equivalent
of the economy. Most existing industrial and and sequestration CCS) where applicable. vehicles with engine-driven powertrains.
transport activities have large water footprints, Consumption values have been estimated as
because of their dependency on hydrocarbon 1.9t/MWhe for combined-cycle gas turbines
fuels and/or electricity generated by thermal
power plants. It is therefore important to
with cooling towers and CCS, 2.0t/MWhe for
integrated gasification combined cycle coal
Effect of green hydrogen
consider the impact on water use of switching power stations with cooling towers and CCS, on the global water
to renewable electricity and green hydrogen.
The water consumption rate for electrolysis
and 2.5t/MWhe for nuclear power stations with
cooling towers.6 Hence the water footprint of
resource
is 9kgH2O/kgH2, which may be expressed as electrolytic hydrogen is heavily influenced by An important question is: do we have enough
0.27t/MWh (LHV). However, irrespective of the power source. For example, an electrolyser water to satisfy our future demand for green
the source, the input water to an electrolyser of 70% efficiency will produce hydrogen with hydrogen? This is analogous to the long
stack must first be cleaned and deionised. a water footprint of about 4.1t/MWh if established, but no longer relevant, question as
The reverse osmosis purification process is powered by nuclear electricity (assuming to whether we have enough oil and gas reserves
commonly used prior to deionisation to ensure 2.5t/MWhe) versus 0.51t/MWh if powered by to satisfy our future energy demand.
the electrolyser receives water of a sufficiently wind electricity (assuming 0t/MWhe). The total mass of water on Earth is about
low electrical conductivity. A proportion The water savings achieved by adopting 1.4x1021kg. Approximately 2.5% of this is fresh
of the water withdrawn from the supply is green hydrogen depend on the fuel that is being water, of which only 9.3x1016kg is classified
therefore rejected. For fresh water, the required displaced and whether a combustion device, as accessible surface water in lakes and rivers –
withdrawal rate ranges from about 0.3t/MWh engine or fuel cell is being used. The volume of glaciers and groundwater account for >99.7%
for very clean input water to approximately water used in the extraction of crude oil usually of the fresh water resource. We currently
1.5t/MWh for river water. At present, a amounts to 6-8 times that of the oil produced, use about 4.6x1015kg of water p.a.11,12 and
typical value for a commercially available PEM or up to 12 times if enhanced oil recovery estimates suggest that we produce about
electrolyser connected to the mains water techniques are applied (such as injecting water, 3.6x1014kg of wastewater p.a., which needs to
supply is 0.51t/MWh (17kg/kgH2). steam or CO2 into the well).8 Because of this be treated before being returned to rivers or
Thermodynamic cycles for converting fuel and the need to use water (steam) for refining used for human consumption.13 Interestingly
to electricity tend to use substantial amounts of crude oil, the overall water footprint of petrol is the current annual loss of glacier ice due to
water for producing superheated high-pressure estimated to lie in the range 0.3-1.3t/MWh.8,9 global warming is of a similar magnitude to
steam and for cooling the low-pressure exhaust For biofuels the water footprint is a strong this, about 3.4x1014kg.14 Accessible fresh water

12
Fuel Cells Bulletin December 2021
FEATURE

and wastewater can enable green hydrogen


production, but electrolysers will need to use
21
desalinated seawater in arid regions and at 10
offshore wind/solar farms. Fortunately the
seawater resource on Earth is approximately
39 times greater than the fresh water resource. 20
10
Together these respective amounts frame the
water resources available for satisfying both
established uses and the new demand associated 19
10
with green hydrogen production (Figure 1).

MASS OF WATER, kg (LOG SCALE)


At present, global consumption of molecular
energy in the form of oil, natural gas and coal 18
10
amounts to approximately 162,000TWh p.a.15
Predictions of future requirements for green

SEAWATER RESOURCE
TOTAL RESOURCE
hydrogen vary but, put simply, if all this fossil 17
10
fuel consumption were replaced with green
hydrogen, the annual water use for electrolysis
(assuming 0.51t/MWh) would be 8.3x1013kg, 16
10

ACCESSIBLE FRESH WATER RESOURCE


or approximately 28kg per person per day.
This is equivalent to using 0.000006% of the

CURRENT ANNUAL WATER CONSUMPTION


seawater resource, or 0.09% of the accessible
15
fresh water resource. It amounts to 1.8% of 10
current global water consumption. Alternatively

ANNUAL GLACIER ICE MELT


it may be expressed as approximately one

ANNUAL WASTEWATER
14
quarter of our current annual rate of wastewater 10

PRODUCTION

CONSUMPTION FOR
production, or of the fresh water added to the

ELECTROLYSIS*
ocean due to glacier ice melt. This outlines

ANNUAL
13
the potential scale of water consumption in 10
a future ‘net zero’ scenario involving a multi-
terawatt deployment of electrolysers. Clearly
the new load placed on Earth’s water resource
would be very small compared with our current
* Assuming all existing fossil fuel consumption is replaced with green hydrogen (162,000 TWh)
consumption and it would be counteracted by
water savings achieved by reducing the use of
hydrocarbon fuels and electricity generated by Figure 1: Annual water requirement of green hydrogen production relative to Earth’s water resources

thermal power plant.


Water use due to electrolysis should, hydrogen will be required as a feedstock (e.g. exploit this, because it has scope to:
however, not be viewed as gradually using for ammonia and methanol production) rather • Provide the necessary water for electrolysis;
up the water resource, because when green than as a fuel, and some of the green oxygen Process the water stream rejected by the
hydrogen is oxidised (by combustion or via a will be applied to industrial processes and electrolyser system;
fuel cell) it yields the same amount of water as water oxygenation as opposed to being vented • Utilise green oxygen for wastewater treatment
was originally electrolysed. This may enter the to the atmosphere.14 For instance, hydrogen to improve process efficiency;
atmosphere as water vapour, or be condensed at and nitrogen will be carried into plants in • Recover heat from the electrolyser to improve
the point of use and recovered as liquid water. the form of ammonium, and oxygen will be process efficiency;
Moreover the production of green hydrogen used by the steel industry.17 It is therefore • Use waste-to-energy or renewable power
simultaneously produces oxygen in the exact important to identify synergies between the sources on site to provide electricity;
amount required to oxidise the hydrogen: electrolyser’s need for water and the use of • Export green hydrogen.
this is an important characteristic, because both green hydrogen and oxygen, because these Wastewater treatment results in the emission
atmospheric oxygen depletion is contributing to could accelerate the deployment of electrolysis of three global warming gases (nitrous oxide
global warming.16 Consequently the widespread in the limited period we have left to combat (N2O), methane (CH4) and CO2).18 Cleaning
production and use of green hydrogen is climate change. wastewater is essential for ensuring water of
expected to have a comparatively neutral effect sufficient quality is produced for returning to
upon Earth’s water and oxygen resources, and rivers and the ocean, or for use as drinking
the increased adoption of renewable energy (as
electricity and hydrogen) will serve to reduce
Wastewater as a water. Aeration of active sludge is the most
critical part of the energy-intensive wastewater
global water consumption. hydrogen feedstock treatment process, where microorganisms
Green hydrogen is therefore widely viewed The use of oxygen as well as hydrogen improves and oxygen work together to break down the
as the ‘net zero’ fuel for our future energy the commercial viability of electrolysis. When a organic matter. Achieving adequate dissolved
system, with green oxygen replenishing the guaranteed demand for oxygen exists, some of oxygen levels is key to this biological process,
associated consumption of atmospheric oxygen. the costs of hydrogen production can be offset. otherwise degradation of the sludge can
However, it should be noted that some of the The water industry is particularly well placed to occur only under septic conditions, which is

13
December 2021 Fuel Cells Bulletin
FEATURE

very slow, malodorous and yields hydrogen Table 1: Water requirements for households using green hydrogen for home heating and
sulphide, methane and organic acids. Air is fuelling cars
conventionally used, but supplementing it with One-person Four-person
oxygen improves the efficiency of waste water Average UK
household (modern household (old
household using
treatment, and this manifests as savings in apartment) using detached house)
one car
capital equipment and energy costs. one car using two cars
The water industry has the potential to Current average water consumption,
154 349 534
use electrolysers to meet its own oxygen kg/day29
requirements, while simultaneously producing Approximate energy demand for space 26 34 64
green hydrogen for other applications including heating and hot water,* kWh/day30
vehicle refuelling and/or injection into Water requirement for making
nearby gas distribution networks or industrial hydrogen for a fuel cell car travelling 8.5 8.5 17
processes. Because wastewater treatment plants 50km/day, kg/day
tend to be located relatively close to towns, Water requirement for making
they offer numerous possibilities for creating hydrogen for heating the home
14.0 18.3 34.4
(assuming a hydrogen boiler efficiency
decentralised hydrogen hubs and driving
of 95%), kg/day
the deployment of electrolysers. There are
Total water footprint, kg/day 176.5 375.8 577.9
approximately 34,000 wastewater treatment
plants in the US and Europe.19 Also there Increase in household’s water
footprint due to use of green 15 8 10
are now over 400 hypoxic zones in the world
hydrogen, %
(including 165,000km2 in the Gulf of Oman
*Heat demand is a function of several factors, including dwelling age, size, orientation, glazing area, insulation level, local climate, preferred
and 20,000km2 in the Gulf of Mexico,20) indoor temperature, occupancy patterns and tenure.
where large scale electrolyser facilities could be
used to help raise dissolved oxygen levels as well environment by altering light levels and causing electrolyser facility, a contribution can be made
as produce green hydrogen. hypoxic and anoxic conditions on the sea bed.26 to supplying clean drinking water. In general,
To reduce this, before the brine is discharged an integrated approach to providing green
back into the ocean it may be diluted with hydrogen and water could assist public health,
Seawater as a hydrogen seawater, oxygenated with green oxygen and
mined to recover minerals.
as well as decarbonisation, objectives in many
regions of the world.
feedstock In general the implementation of green In developed countries, the existing water
Seawater consists of numerous minerals and hydrogen production from seawater affords consumption per household far exceeds that
metals, ranging from sodium to gold, which an interesting set of secondary opportunities, needed to produce green hydrogen for fuelling
have an estimated total mass of 5x1019kg.21 including: a fuel cell car or heating a house. For example,
Seawater may be mined for elements such as • The integration of an electrolyser and its for an average UK household with a water
magnesium (1272ppm), calcium (400ppm), desalination plant with a renewable power consumption of 349kg/day,29 a water overhead
bromine (65ppm), lithium (0.1ppm) and source as an engineering product27,28; of 27kg/day would be sufficient to produce
iodine (0.05ppm). For example, 63% of • The provision of a rainfall-independent enough green hydrogen for space heating, hot
magnesium production in the USA is sourced drinking water supply by oversizing the water and travelling 50km/day in a fuel cell
from seawater and brine.22 desalination plant relative to the water car. Household water use and heat demand
It has been estimated that approximately requirement of the electrolyser; vary across the building stock, but in general
2.4x1013kg of desalinated water is produced • Use of green oxygen for oxygenating the amount of water required for switching
annually and that demand is increasing at >9% desalination effluents and hypoxic zones in heat and mobility to green hydrogen equates to
p.a.23 There are now >21,000 desalination estuaries and coastal areas; only a small percentage of existing use (Table
plants in at least 174 countries, which are used • Extraction of minerals from the desalination 1). Furthermore it should be remembered that
mainly for supplying drinking water, irrigating effluent; water savings will be achieved by households
crops and oil and gas extraction.24 They operate • Off-grid production of hydrogen, oxygen and switching away from purchasing conventional
thermally by distillation or mechanically via drinking water in regions where the electricity fuels to buying renewable electricity and
reverse osmosis, with the latter being more grid is weak or non-existent. green hydrogen.
common. Reverse osmosis has a relatively Where feasible, it is desirable to recover
low electricity requirement for desalination liquid water from hydrogen use (for example,
of approximately 0.003kWh/kgH2O25, so an
electrolyser system consuming 17kgH2O/kgH2
Water use and recovery from hydrogen boilers, combined heat-and-
power systems and fuel cells). This will reduce
will incur an additional electricity consumption In developing countries, the high demand the amount of water vapour that would
of about 0.05kWh/kgH2. This equates to an placed on traditional water sources is causing otherwise be ejected to the atmosphere due to
energy overhead upon the electrolyser of only communities to increasingly use rainwater, fuel use, which will help reduce global warming
0.1% relative to producing green hydrogen stormwater, brackish water and seawater. By and enable the latent heat of vaporisation
from fresh water. implementing green hydrogen production, to be recovered in thermal applications (and
The brine effluents produced by desalination a new impetus could be established for hence the higher heating value of hydrogen
plant are ion rich and of relatively high density, resolving water supply problems. By oversizing to be utilised – 39.4kWh/kgH2 HHV versus
so their disposal effects the local marine the water purification plant required by an 33.3kWh/kgH2 LHV).

14
Fuel Cells Bulletin December 2021
FEATURE

Conclusions 3. 1 in 3 people globally do not have access to safe


drinking water – UNICEF, WHO,
Electrolysers for producing net-zero heat, https://
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
Energy is used in two forms (electrons https://www.unicef.org.uk/press-releases/1-in- S1464285921003564
and molecules) and it is now critical that 3-people-globally-do-not-have-access-to-safe-
18. Campos, J.L. et al, Greenhouse Gases
both electricity and fuel are produced in drinking-water-unicef-who/
Emissions from Wastewater Treatment
an environmentally sustainable manner. If
4. Kenny, J.F.; Barber, N.L.; Hutson, S.S.; Linsey, Plants: Minimization, Treatment, and
all existing fossil fuel use were switched to
K.S.; Lovelace, J.K.; Maupin, M.A. Estimated Prevention, https://www.hindawi.com/journals/
green hydrogen, the water requirement for
Use of Water in the United States in 2005. U.S. jchem/2016/3796352/
electrolysis would amount to 1.8% of current
Geological Survey Circular 1344. Reston, VA:
global water consumption. This new demand 19. Environmental Protection Agency, Primer for
USGS, 2009; p. 52.
would be counterbalanced by water savings Municipal Wastewater Treatment Systems, https://
achieved by not having to produce fuels from 5. McKinsey & Company, Managing water and www3.epa.gov/npdes/pubs/primer.pdf
petroleum or biomass and by reducing the climate risk with renewable energy, https://www.
20. Howard, J., Dead zones explained, https://
use of conventional thermal power plant. mckinsey.com/industries/electric-power-and-
www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/
Furthermore, when green hydrogen is oxidised natural-gas/our-insights/managing-water-and-
dead-zones
by combustion equipment and fuel cells, the climate-risk-with-renewable-energy
same amount of water that was originally 21. https://www.miningweekly.com/article/
6. NREL, A Review of Operational Water
consumed by electrolysis is released back over-40-minerals-and-metals-contained-in-
Consumption and Withdrawal Factors for
into the environment. Therefore, in general, seawater-their-extraction-likely-to-increase-in-the-
Electricity Generating Technologies, https://www.
a massive deployment of electrolysis will future-2016-04-01
nrel.gov/docs/fy11osti/50900.pdf
have a relatively neutral impact on the global 22. Campbell, K., Over 40 minerals and metals
water resource. 7. Shah, Y.T., Water for Energy and Fuel
contained in seawater, their extraction likely to
The water required by electrolysers can be Production, https://library.oapen.org/
increase in the future, https://www.miningweekly.
sourced from accessible fresh water, seawater viewer/web/viewer.html?file=/bitstream/
com/article/over-40-minerals-and-metals-
and wastewater. In each case it must be handle/20.500.12657/40074/9781482216189.
contained-in-seawater-their-extraction-likely-to-
purified and deionised prior to electrolysis. pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
increase-in-the-future-2016-04-01/rep_id:3650
In dry regions, islands and offshore locations, 8. Lampert, D.J., Cai H. and A. Elgowainy, Wells
electrolysers will rely mainly on the seawater 23. IRENA, Water Desalination Using Renewable
to wheels: water consumption for transportation
resource and this must first be desalinated Energy, https://www.irena.org/-/media/Files/
fuels in the United States, https://www.osti.gov/
(either at scale or by integration within IRENA/Agency/Publication/2012/IRENA-
pages/servlets/purl/1392949
the electrolyser system). Accordingly there ETSAP-Tech-Brief-I12-Water-Desalination.pdf
are distinct opportunities for deploying 9. We, M. et al, Water Consumption in the
24. Berenguel-Felices, F. et al, Requirements for
electrolysers, ranging from decentralised Production of Ethanol and Petroleum Gasoline,
the Construction of New Desalination Plants
hydrogen hubs at wastewater treatment plants http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00267-009-9370-0
into a Framework of Sustainability, https://doi.
to gigawatt-scale hydrogen production at 10. Gerbens-Leenes, W. et al, The water org/10.3390/su12125124
offshore wind/solar farms. footprint of bioenergy, https://www.pnas.org/
Several additional benefits are obtainable 25. Pinto, J.M., Energy consumption and
content/106/25/10219
for the water industry, including improving desalination, https://uh.edu/uh-energy/
the provision of drinking water in developing 11. https://www.worldometers.info/water/ educational-programs/tieep/content/energy-
countries and oxygenating hypoxic zones in recovery-presentation-2020-water-forum.pdf
12. Boretti, A. and Rosa, L., Reassessing the
lakes, rivers and coastal regions. Therefore it is projections of the World Water Development 26. P. Sadhu, A comprehensive review of saline
recommended that electrolysis should play a Report, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41545- effluent disposal and treatment: conventional
more central role in future policies concerning 019-0039-9 practices, emerging technologies, and future
energy and water: achieving a multi-terawatt potential, https://iwaponline.com/jwrd/
electrolyser capacity by mid-century would 13. Jones, E.R. et al, Country-level and gridded
article/11/1/33/77601/A-comprehensive-review-of-
yield massive positive benefits. estimates of wastewater production, collection,
saline-effluent-disposal
treatment and reuse, https://essd.copernicus.org/
articles/13/237/2021/ 27. https://oysterh2.eu/

References 14. European State of the Climate, Glaciers 28. Langeraar, J.W., Double the energy from wind,
and sea level rise, https://climate.copernicus.eu/ with hydrogen as primary energy carrier, https://
1. The United Nations world water development ESOTC/2019/glaciers-and-sea-level-rise hy-gro.net/en/newsitem/double-the-energy-from-
report 2018: nature-based solutions for wind-with-hydrogen-as-primary-energy-carrier
water, https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/ 15. Global Energy Statistical Yearbook 2021,
pf0000261424 https://yearbook.enerdata.net 29. Energy Saving Trust, At home with water,
https://www.energysavingtrust.org.uk/sites/default/
2. CHA Occasional Policy Briefing Series: Water 16. Newborough, M. and Cooley, G., Green
files/reports/AtHomewithWater%287%29.pdf
Scarcity and Humanitarian Action: Key Emerging hydrogen: The only oxygen and water balanced
Trends and Challenges, https://www.unocha.org/ fuel https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/ 30. Sansom, R., Domestic heat demand study,
sites/unocha/files/Water%20%20Scarcity%20 pii/S1464285921001693 https://esc-production-2021.s3.eu-west-2.
and%20Humanitarian%20Action%20 amazonaws.com/2021/07/Domestic-Heat-
17. Newborough, M. and Cooley, G.,
Nov10%20fnl.pdf Demand-Study.pdf

15
December 2021 Fuel Cells Bulletin

You might also like