Professional Documents
Culture Documents
XM Qualitative
XM Qualitative
TERMS OF USE
https://xmphysics.com/terms/
DISCLAIMER
This compilation of qualitative questions is provided on an “as is” basis for your reference only. Your
exam paper is set and marked by your own teachers. There is no guarantee that every teacher is on
the same wavelength as the author. The author accepts no responsibility if his answers do not score
full marks in your school’s examinations.
Kinematics ........................................................................................................................................ 4
Dynamics .......................................................................................................................................... 4
Forces .............................................................................................................................................. 5
Circular Motion.................................................................................................................................. 6
Gravitation ........................................................................................................................................ 7
Oscillation ......................................................................................................................................... 9
Superposition .................................................................................................................................. 10
Thermal .......................................................................................................................................... 14
CoEDC ........................................................................................................................................... 16
EM .................................................................................................................................................. 17
EMI ................................................................................................................................................. 18
AC .................................................................................................................................................. 21
Quantum ......................................................................................................................................... 21
Nuclear ........................................................................................................................................... 26
The intention of this compilation of qualitative questions is to help you learn to verbalize your
responses, to the level of clarity and detail required. You may also use this compilation to identify your
knowledge gaps or misconceptions.
Tempting as it may be, DO NOT memorize the answers. This compilation is not exhaustive. New
questions are being written every year. Even if the same question is asked, the level of detail required
in the answer also depends on the total marks allocated. The flow or context of the question may also
result in different emphasis leading to different marking points in the marking scheme.
So, use this compilation as a revision aid to hone your verbalization skill and test your understanding,
not as a bible to be quoted and recited. By the way, the skill of verbalization is useless (even not
dangerous), if you have no knowledge and understanding of the subject content. Speak your mind.
Don’t be a parrot. Cheers!
2. Explain how one can deduce from the graph that the stone experiences increasing air resistance
R as it falls.
DYNAMICS
3. Explain why the stopping distance for a car is longer on a downward slope (despite the same
constant braking force).
- The component of weight of car along the slope
- acts forward in opposite direction to the braking force,
- reducing the net force and thus deceleration.
4. Explain why it is not possible for both nuclei to stop at the same instant (during the “collision”).
5. Use momentum considerations to explain how a rocket can produce a forward force.
- The net change in momentum of a system is zero if there is no net external force.
- Since the propellant experiences a backward change in momentum, the rocket must experience
a forward change in momentum.
FORCES
6. Explain the origin of upthrust.
- The fluid exerts pressure forces perpendicularly against every point on the (submerged) object.
- Since Fluid pressure increases with depth ( p = h g )
- the upward forces acting on the lower surfaces (of an object immersed in the fluid) is always
stronger than the downward force acting on the upper surfaces,
- resulting in a net upward force called upthrust.
8. Body is in equilibrium. Explain why forces T and mg cannot be the only two forces acting on it.
T
mg
CIRCULAR MOTION
9. Explain why uniform circular motion requires a non-zero resultant force.
- Even though the speed is constant, the direction of velocity is changing continuously.
dv
- Since acceleration is the rate of change of velocity (a = ) , acceleration is non-zero.
dt
- Resultant force is proportional to acceleration. ( F = ma )
10. Explain why the net force acting on a body undergoing uniform circular motion must be in the
centripetal direction.
- Acceleration is non-zero since the direction of velocity changes continuously.
- Since the speed is constant, there is no acceleration in the tangential direction.
- Hence acceleration must be in the centripetal direction only.
11. In a pendulum swing, why is the tension in the string largest at the lowest point of the swing?
- The required centripetal force is provided by the tension force minus the component of weight in
the centrifugal direction.
- At the lowest point, the swing is at its highest speed, so the required centripetal force is largest.
v2
(Fc = m )
r
- Also, at the lowest point, the entire weight acts in the centrifugal direction.
(Fnet = T − mg )
• COMMENT: At other positions, the tension force only needs to overcome the component of weight
in the centrifugal direction. At the lowest point, the entire weight is in the centrifugal direction.
• COMMENT: Please remember that the tension in the string is NOT equal to the weight (since
acceleration is not zero). At the lowest point,
(Fnet = ma )
v2
T − mg = m
r
v2
T = mg + m mg
r
13. Why is the acceleration of free fall g at the equator smaller than that at the poles?
- Unlike objects at the poles, objects at the equator are undergoing circular motion.
- Part of the gravitational pull is “used” to provide the required centripetal force for circular motion
• COMMENT: In fact, the acceleration of free fall is decreased by an amount equal to the centripetal
acceleration. g ' = g − r 2
20. A satellite is moved from a higher orbit to a lower orbit. State and explain the effect on GPE, KE
and TE of the satellite.
- GPE decrease (becomes more negative) since it is now nearer to the centre of the Earth.
GMm
(GPE = − )
r
21. A satellite orbiting close to the Earth’s atmosphere is undergoing orbital decay due to resistive
forces. State and energy conversion(s) taking place during the decay.
- GPE is continuously converted into KE and heat.
• COMMENT: Note that a satellite actually speeds up during an orbital decay, just like any mass
falling towards the ground.
OSCILLATION
22. Explain how it may be deduced from the graph that the oscillation is simple harmonic?
- (To be shm, a = − 2 x .)
- Graph is a straight line passing through the origin. This shows that a is directly proportional to x.
- Graph has a negative gradient. This shows that a is opposite in direction to x.
• COMMENT: The “through the origin” part is necessary because a straight line merely implies a
linear relationship, i.e. y = kx + c .
23. Explain how it may be deduced from the expression below that the oscillation is simple harmonic?
Ag
a=− x
m
- (To be shm, a = − 2 x .)
Ag
- is a constant. This shows that a is directly proportional to x.
m
- The negative sign shows that a is opposite in direction to x.
Fnet
- But with the larger inertia, the acceleration (at each x) is lower. (a = )
m
- Period is longer, since it takes longer for the mass to accelerate from the extreme position to the
equilibrium position, and decelerate from the equilibrium position to the extreme position.
1
- Since f = , this results in a lower frequency of oscillation.
T
k
• COMMENT: You may not be allowed to quote the = formula, unless it is presented earlier
m
in the question.
SUPERPOSITION
25. State the conditions for 2 waves to produce observable interference pattern.
- The 2 waves (of the same kind) must overlap,
- be coherent,
- and have comparable amplitudes.
- (For polarised waves, the direction of polarisation of the 2 waves must not be perpendicular to
each other.)
26. State two situations when 2 waves superpose but do not produce interference pattern.
- The 2 waves are incoherent.
- The 2 (polarised) waves are polarised perpendicularly to each other.
27. Explain why 2 wave do not produce a distinct interference pattern if they do not have comparable
amplitudes.
- The minima does not have zero amplitude.
- The percentage difference in the amplitudes of the maxima and minima may be too small.
28. State the conditions for two waves to undergo constructive and destructive interference.
- Constructive interference occurs if the phase difference between them is ϕ =2nπ, n=0,1,2,..
- Destructive interference occurs if ϕ =(2n+1)π, n=0,1,2,….
29. Explain how waves emitting from two wave sources can give rise to an interference pattern.
31. As the sliding tube is moved outward, the sound intensity at D fluctuates. Explain.
- Two coherent sound waves arrive and superpose at D through two different paths A and B.
33. As the microphone is moved along XY, fluctuations in loudness is detected. Explain.
34. As the water is drained out, loud sound is heard only when the water level is at particular levels.
Explain.
35. When a guitar string is strummed, only sounds of particular pitches is heard. Explain.
- When the string is strummed, waves of an entire range of wavelengths travel along the length of
the string.
- These waves are reflected at both (fixed) ends of the string.
- Multiple incident and reflected waves travelling in opposite directions superpose to result in a
standing waves along the string.
- Resonance occurs only for wavelengths λ such that the length of the string is equal to nλ/2,
n=0,1,2….
- (This is because both ends of the string must form displacement nodes)
- Since v = f , resonance occurs only for certain frequencies (pitches).
36. Explain how a guitarist plays different notes by pressing his finger against the guitar string at
different points along the string.
- The finger changes the position of (one of) the fixed end, allowing us to change the vibrating length
of the string L.
- This allows us to change the resonant wavelengths, since resonance occurs only when L
corresponds to integer number of half-wavelengths. (L = n )
2
- The speed of the wave travelling along the string is constant. So having different resonant
v
wavelengths result in different resonant frequencies (and pitches) (f = )
37. Explain how a guitarist tunes the guitar to a higher pitch by tightening the guitar string.
- Resonance occurs when L corresponds to integer number of half-wavelengths. (L = n )
2
- Since the length of the guitar string L is unchanged, the resonant wavelengths remain unchanged
- However, increasing the tension in the string increases the speed v at which the wave travels
along the string.
v
- For the resonant same wavelength, the resonant frequency is now higher. (f = )
39. Use the kinetic theory to explain why pressure of a gas increases with temperature (for a constant
volume).
3
- Higher temperature means higher average KE of the gas molecules ( KE = kT ).
2
- Since the gas molecules collide with the wall at higher speeds, the change in momentum per
collision is larger.
- Since the time between collisions is shorter, the number of collisions per unit time is higher.
- These result in a higher average rate of change of momentum, and a higher pressure force (on
p F
the wall). ( F = , p= )
t A
40. A gas contained in a cylinder with a frictionless piston is heated and undergoes isothermal
expansion. Use the first law of thermodynamics to explain why the temperature of the gas can
remain constant.
U = Q + Won
-
- As the gas expands, work done on the gas is negative.
- Even though an amount of heat is supplied to the gas,
- An equal amount of work was done by the gas as it expands.
- The change in internal energy is zero (so no change in temperature).
42. The graph below shows the variation of electric field strength between two charged spheres P
and Q. State and explain whether the two spheres have charges of the same, or opposite sign.
|E|
0 P Q x
- Opposite signs.
- If they had the same sign, their electric fields will be acting in opposite directions in the region
between them
- and there ought to be point between them where the resultant field is zero.
43. The graph below shows the variation of electric field strength between two charged spheres P
and Q. State and explain whether the two spheres have charges of the same, or opposite sign.
|E|
0 P Q x
- Same signs.
- If they had different signs, their electric fields will be acting in the same directions in the region
between them
- and there should not be a point between them where the resultant field is zero.
COEDC
45. Explain why resistance of a filament increase with voltage applied.
- The higher voltage results in higher current and power dissipation,
- causing the filament to reach a higher temperature.
- The lattice thus vibrates more vigorously,
- resulting in higher frequency of collisions between the drifting electrons and the lattice (and thus
higher resistance).
46. The temperature of the thermistor is increased. Explain the change to the value of Vout.
47. The sensitive ammeter shows a zero reading when the jockey contacts the slide wire PQ at J.
Explain why there is a reading on the ammeter when J is moved towards P.
48. Explain why there is a reading on the ammeter when J is moved towards Q?
- The p.d. between PJ (VPJ) must be equal to the voltage across cell C (Vt), since they are directly
connected together.
- If the currents in circuit remain as before, VPJ would be would be higher than Vt, since PJ is longer
than the balance length.
- So some current must be diverted from PJ into cell C so that VPJ is decreased until it matches Vt.
EM
49. Explain why a charge moving under the influence of a magnetic field moves at a constant speed.
- The magnetic force acting on a moving charge (if not zero) is always perpendicular to the direction
of velocity. (FLHR)
- The force does zero work, so the KE of the charge does not change.
50. Explain why the path of the particle in the magnetic field is circular.
EMI
51. Explain why the induced e.m.f. across CD is sinusoidal if the coil is rotated at a constant speed.
52. Use Faraday’s Law to explain why the oscillation is damped when the switch is closed.
- As the sheet oscillates, it cuts the magnetic flux of the solenoid perpendicularly. This leads to an
induced emf in the sheet. (Faraday’s Law)
53. Use Faraday’s Law to explain why the oscillations are damped.
- As the ring approaches or leaves the electromagnet, it experiences a changing magnetic flux
linkage. This leads to an induced emf in the ring. (Faraday’s Law)
- Since the ring provides a closed conducting path, an induced current flows in the sheet.
- Since the cause of the induction is the motion of the ring, the induced current must result in the
ring experiencing a magnetic force that retards and damps the motion of the sheet. (Lenz’s Law)
OR
Since electrical energy (in the ring) is being converted from the KE of the oscillating ring, the
oscillation loses energy over time.
54. Use Faraday’s Law to explain the direction of induced current in the copper ring as it is entering
the magnetic field.
- As ring enters the field, its magnetic flux linkage increases This leads to an induced emf in the
ring. (Faraday’s Law)
- Since the ring provides a closed conducting path, an induced current flows in the ring.
- To oppose the increasing flux linkage, the induced current is anti-clockwise so as to produce a
magnetic flux that is in opposite direction to the flux linkage. (Lenz’s Law)
56. Use Faraday’s Law to explain the direction of induced current in the entire copper ring is moving
in the magnetic field.
- When the entire ring is in the field, the ring experiences a constant magnetic flux linkage. Since
the rate of change of flux linkage is zero, there is no induced emf in the ring. (Faraday’s Law)
57. By considering the energy changes taking place as the ring enters/leaves the field, explain why
Lenz’ Law is a manifestation of the principle of conservation of energy.
- When the ring enters/leaves the field, the induced emf and current results in a retardation force
on the ring.
- This slows the ring down. The gain in electrical energy in the ring (and ultimately heat energy) can
thus be accounted for by the loss in KE of the ring.
OR
- An external force in the direction of motion is required to keep the ring moving at a constant speed.
The gain in electrical energy (and ultimately heat energy) can thus be accounted for by the positive
work done by the external force.
58. Explain how a constant emf can be induced in the search coil.
- If the current in the solenoid is increasing at a constant rate, the magnetic flux density of the
solenoid’s magnetic field will be increasing at a constant rate.
- The search coil will experience a magnetic flux linkage that increases at a constant rate.
- The magnitude of the induced emf is directly proportional to the rate of change of flux linkage
(Faraday’s Law).
- Since the flux linkage is increasing at a constant rate, the emf induced is constant in magnitude.
AC
60. Explain the significance of root-mean-square value of an alternating current.
The RMS value of an AC current is the equivalent (constant) DC current which dissipates the same
average power (as the AC current) in a given resistive load.
61. Explain how an emf is obtained across the secondary coil (of a transformer)
- The alternating voltage in the primary coil sets up an alternating magnetic flux in the core.
- The secondary coil experiences an alternating magnetic flux linkage (since it is wrapped around
the core).
- (By Faraday’s Law, an alternating emf is induced across the secondary coil.)
62. Explain why the voltage across the secondary coil of a step down transformer is lower than the
primary voltage.
- Both the primary and secondary coils experience the exact same changing magnetic flux (since
they are wrapped around the same iron core).
- But the secondary coil has a smaller changing magnetic flux linkage (compared to the primary
coil) because it has fewer turns. ( = N )
- With a lower rate of change of magnetic flux linkage, the induced emf is also lower compared to
d d
the primary coil. ( = =N )
dt dt
- For an ideal transformer, the induced emfs are equal to the input and output voltages.
QUANTUM
63. Describe how the double slit experiment provides evidence for the wave nature of EM radiation
- When light is shone through two narrow slits, alternating bright and dark fringes are observed.
64. Describe how photoelectric effect provides evidence for the particulate nature of EM radiation
- No photoelectron is ejected if EM radiation is below the threshold frequency, regardless of
intensity.
- The maximum KE of ejected electrons depends on the frequency of EM radiation and not its
intensity.
- Electrons are ejected with zero time delay, regardless of intensity.
- All these provide evidence that photoelectric effect occurs when one electron absorbs the energy
of one photon, whose energy is dependent on its frequency (E=hf)
65. Explain why photoelectric effect does not occur if the frequency of illumination is too low.
- Energy of a photon is directly proportional to frequency. (E=hf)
- Below the threshold frequency f0, each photon carries energy less than the work function, which
is the energy required to liberate the least tightly bound electron. (hf0=Φ).
- Since one electron absorbs the energy of one single photon only, not a single electron can be
liberated (regardless of the rate of arrival of photons).
68. Explain why even at very low intensity of light, photoelectrons are still ejected without noticeable
delay.
- Lowering intensity (without changing the wavelength) only lowers the number of photons arriving
at the metal surface per unit time, but does not change the energy of each photon.
- The moment one photon arrives, one electron can absorb the energy of that one photon and
become liberated.
69. Explain why photoelectrons are ejected with a range of KE even though a monochromatic light
source is used.
- Each photon in a beam of monochromatic light does contain the same amount of energy E.
(E=hc/λ)
- However the electrons in the metal surface are bound to different degree, and different amount of
energy W is required to liberate them.
- The KE of the emitted photoelectron, which is equal to E – W, is thus a range of values.
70. Explain why increasing the positive bias cannot increase the photoelectric current beyond the
saturation current.
- A positive potential on the collector attracts photoelectrons from the emitter towards the collector.
- Once the positive bias is strong enough, every single photoelectron is already collected at the
collector.
- The maximum (saturation) current is thus limited by the number of photoelectrons leaving the
emitter per unit time.
• COMMENT: Increasing the positive bias after saturation current is reached merely increases the
KE at which the photoelectrons arrive at the emitter, but it does not increase the number of
photoelectrons arriving per unit time.
• COMMENT: At saturation current, the number of photoelectrons leaving the emitter n is the same
as the number of photoelectrons arriving at the collector n. So n = Isat e
71. Explain why increasing the negative bias reduces the photoelectric current.
- A negative potential on the collector sets up an electric field which repels photoelectrons from the
collector.
- As such, photoelectrons must lose KE in order to gain EPE as they travel towards the collector.
- Only those photoelectrons which are ejected at high enough initial KE are able to overcome the
potential energy barrier to arrive at the collector.
• COMMENT: At the stopping potential Vs, even the most energetic photoelectrons do not have
sufficient initial KE to overcome the potential energy barrier. The photoelectric current drops to
zero. By the principle of conservation of energy, we can calculate KEmax by equating it to the
electric potential energy gained by the electron as it moves from the emitter to the collector.
( KEmax = eVs )
72. State and explain the effect on Isat and Vs, of increasing the intensity of illuminating light.
73. Explain why the line emission spectrum provide evidence for the quantization of energy levels in
atoms.
- When an atom de-excites from a higher energy level EH to a lower energy level EL,
- a photon with energy Ephoton = ΔE = EH-EL is emitted.
- If an atom has discrete allowable energies levels, it can explain why the atom can only emit
photons of particular energies.
- (Since E=hc/λ, it can explain why only light of particular wavelengths are emitted)
74. A beam of white light shines through a cloud of gas. The spectrum of the transmitted light contains
a number of dark lines. Explain why these dark lines occur.
- White light consists of photons with a continuous spectrum of photon energies.
- A gas atom has discrete energy levels.
- It can only absorb photons whose energy matches one of the energy gaps between two energy
levels of the atom. (E photon = EH − EL )
- The dark lines in the absorption spectrum correspond to the particular wavelengths that
hc
correspond to those photon energies. (E photon = )
75. Explain the significance of the negative signs in the energy levels of a hydrogen atom.
- The negative total energies correspond to the fact that the electron is still bound to the proton.
- Energy must be supplied to increase the total energy to zero in order to free the electron from the
atom.
• COMMENT: The energy levels represent the total energy. Based on the Bohr’s model, which has
the electron orbiting the proton at specific radii, the total energy would be the KE of the orbiting
electron plus the (negative) EPE of the electron-proton system.
78. Explain the formation of the background radiation in the X-ray spectrum.
- In the X-ray tube, highly energetic (>10keV) electrons are directed towards a target metal.
- Some of these electrons get very close to the nuclei (of the target metal) and experience very
strong acceleration.
- Charged particles undergoing acceleration must emit EM radiation. So these electrons undergoing
such extreme acceleration emit X-ray photons.
- Since each electron can lose any fraction (between 0% and 100%) of its initial KE, this process
produces photons with a continuous range of energy.
• COMMENT: The most energetic (and thus cut-off wavelength) X-ray photon, is produced when
hc
an incoming electron converts all its KE to produce one single X-ray photon. ( = eVA )
min
79. Explain why the view that all molecular motion ceases at absolute zero temperature violates the
Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle.
- If motion ceases, it is implied that momentum is exactly zero.
- This implies zero uncertainty in the momentum of the molecules, which is forbidden by the HUP.
80. An outdated model of the hydrogen atom is that of an electron orbiting around the proton at fixed
radii. Use the HUP to explain why this is not possible.
- According to this model, the electron has a precise position and momentum at any point in time.
- Having precise knowledge of both the position and momentum at the same time is forbidden by
the HUP.
82. Considering the mass of nuclei, describe the energy changes taking place during a beta decay.
87
37 Rb → 38
87
Sr + −10
- The total mass of the daughter nucleus and the alpha particle is smaller than the mass of the
parent nucleus.
- By the principle of mass-energy equivalence, the decrease in rest-mass implies energy is released
by the beta decay.
- The energy is released as the KE of the beta particle, the KE of the recoiling daughter nucleus
(and the anti-neutrino).
83. Considering the binding energy, describe the energy changes taking place during an alpha decay.
239
44 Pu → U + 24
235
92
- The total BE of the daughter nucleus and the alpha particle is larger than the BE of the parent
nucleus.
- The increase in BE represents the energy released during the alpha decay.
- A large portion of the energy is released as KE of the alpha particle, with the remaining going to
the KE of the recoiling daughter nucleus.
84. Describe the energy changes taking place during a gamma decay.
- Many nuclear reactions produce nuclei which are in an excited state.
- When the nucleus de-excite, energy E is released as a gamma photon.
E
- By mass-energy equivalence principle, the mass of the nucleus decreases by .
c2
85. Explain why the daughter nucleus of a beta decay has the same mass number as the parent.
- During beta-decay, a neutron in the parent nucleus transforms into one proton (which remains in
the nucleus) and one electron.
- Since the parent nucleus loses one neutron but gains one proton, the number of nucleons does
not change.
86. Explain why the observation that beta-radiation has a range of energy suggests a third particle
(later found to be the anti-neutrino) is emitted.
- If the beta-particle and the daughter nucleus are the only two particles, then they must have equal
but opposite momentums, as dictated by PCOM.
- This constrains the beta-particle to always get the same fraction of the total energy released.
- If there is a third particle, the total momentum and thus total energy released can be shared
differently each time among the three particles, allowing for the beta-particle to have a range of
momentum and KE.
• COMMENT:
• Since total momentum before decay is zero, PCOM dictates that pd = p .
pd 2 p 2
• Since the total energy released during a beta-decay E is fixed, PCOE dictates E = +
2md 2m
• Together, the PCOM and PCOE equations can have only one possible solution, meaning the
beta-particle can only have one specific energy.
87. Explain how the BE/A graph indicates that fission of large nuclei releases energy.
- During fission, a very large nucleus undergoes fission to form two smaller nuclei.
- The binding energy per nucleon of the fission product nuclei are larger than that of the parent
nucleus.
- Since the total number of nucleons is unchanged, this implies the total binding energy of fission
product nuclei are larger than that of the parent nucleus.
88. Explain how the BE/A graph indicates that fusion of small nuclei releases energy.
- During fusion, two very small nuclei undergo fusion to form a larger nucleus.
- The graph shows that the binding energy per nucleon of the fusion product nucleus is larger than
that of the parent nuclei.
- Since the total number of nucleons is unchanged, this implies the total binding energy of fission
product nuclei are larger than that of the parent nucleus.
- A larger total binding energy implies a larger total mass defect and thus a smaller total mass.
(BE = m.c 2 )
- By the mass-energy equivalence principle, the decrease in mass implies that energy is released
in such a reaction.
90. Explain why the binding energy of neutrons need not be taken into account when calculating
energy released during nuclear fission.
- The BE of neutrons are zero.
- Neutrons are already the constituent particles.
91. Explain why hydrogen fusion can only happen at very high temperature.
2
1 H + 31H → 24H + 01n
- The two positively charged hydrogen nuclei must overcome the repulsive forces in order to come
close enough for fusion to occur.
- This requires a large initial kinetic energy to overcome the large electric potential energy barrier.
- A large KE implies a high temperature since the average kinetic energy is directly proportional to
temperature (<KE> = 3kT/2).