LITERATURE MATRIX

Tenorio, Cheanne

Author/s Year Title Methodology* Results & Conclusion Key Points/Takeaways

Ivan July Artificial neural Journal articles were The data examines the use of Artificial Neural ● Researchers looked at how
Henderson 2020 networks for identified in order to Networks (ANN) across the Sustainable Artificial Neural Networks
V. Gue, sustainable obtain reliable Development Goals (SDGs). While some (ANN) are used to support
Aristotle T. development: a analysis with the time goals like No Poverty and Good Health have Sustainable Development
Ubando, critical review frame before 2019 seen limited ANN applications, others such as Goals (SDGs).
Ming-Lang Midyear. The journal Zero Hunger and Life Below Water hold
Tseng & articles used potential for further exploration. Notably, ANN ● ANN is applied in various ways
Raymond amounts to 145 for has been extensively used in areas like Clean across different SDGs. Some
R. Tan the content analysis. Water and Sanitation, Affordable and Clean goals have more research
The descriptive Energy, Sustainable Cities, and Responsible using ANN compared to others.
analysis were based Consumption. However, there are research
on the temporal gaps and limitations, including the need for ● Overall, ANN is commonly
growth of publication, more comparative analysis with other used in areas such as Clean
citation trend among techniques and refining search methodologies Water, Affordable Energy,
countries and to capture all relevant documents. Overall, Sustainable Cities, and
journals and while ANN shows promise in addressing Responsible Consumption. The
clustering of journal SDGs, further research is needed to fully study also identified some
articles. leverage its potential across all areas of issues in the research, like not
sustainable development. comparing ANN with other
methods often.
 ● More research to ensure ANN
is effectively contributing to
sustainable development
overall.

The study modeled

Timothy April Modeling the consumer The study explores consumer preferences ● The study looked at what
James P. 2023 consumer preference between between single-use plastic shampoo sachets people prefer: single-use
Edoria, Jan preferences on single used plastic and refillable shampoo bottles, identifying key plastic shampoo packets or
Paul A. refillable shampoo sachet and demographic and socioeconomic factors refillable shampoo bottles, in
Pabilonia, shampoo bottles refillable shampoo influencing these preferences. Parameters Metro Manila.
Jasper for circular bottles. The like age, gender, education, and ● They found that factors like
Aldwin M. economy in researchers gathered environmental awareness significantly affect age, education, and caring
Palapar, Metro Manila, data within the 16 consumer choices, with younger, about the environment affect
Charles Philippines cities in metro Manila environmentally aware, and higher-educated what people choose.
Dean E. with 457 sample size. consumers more likely to opt for refillable ● Younger, more educated, and
Quiambao, Which are based on bottles. Retailer choice also plays a significant eco-conscious people are more
Ivan their socio economic role, with mall goers showing a preference for likely to choose refillable
Henderson and demographic refillable bottles. However, local convenience bottles.
V. Gue, characteristics. store variations, called "sari-sari" stores, pose ● Also, where people shop
Monorom a barrier to the penetration of refillable bottles, matters – those who go to
Rith & The survey suggesting the need for tailored circular malls prefer refillable bottles,
Alexis responses were business models. Future research could but local corner stores are a
Mervin T. Sy analyzed through explore post-pandemic consumer behavior challenge for this.
binary logistics shifts, employ more advanced modeling ● The study suggests businesses
regression in order to techniques, and investigate alternative need to adjust their strategies
produce a discrete packaging options beyond refillable bottles. for different types of stores.
choice for the ● In the future, more research is
variables. needed to understand how
consumer behavior changes
after the pandemic and to
 explore other eco-friendly
packaging options.

Anthony Septe Can disruptive The authors used a Disruptive events, like the accelerated digital ● The authors investigate if
S.F. Chiu, mber events trigger systematic-design–b transformation during mobility restrictions, disruptive events can prompt
Kathleen B. 2020 transitions ased poka yoke or highlight vulnerabilities in our current way of shifts towards sustainable
Aviso, towards “foolproof designing” life. While the shift towards online activities consumption.
Jonna sustainable sustainable such as e-commerce and telemedicine is ● They use a systematic design
Baquillas & consumption? consumption option evident, the tangible nature of products and method called "foolproof
Raymond to reach several infrastructure remains. Designing sustainable designing" to develop
R. Tan priority sustainable products and services presents an opportunity sustainable consumption
targets. for lasting transitions, aligning with the options.
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). ● Disruptions, like the
Sustainable consumption can be promoted accelerated digital
through systemic analysis, poka-yoke system transformation during
design, and product/service design. Systemic lockdowns, reveal weaknesses
analysis involves considering both producers in current lifestyles.
and consumers, while poka-yoke system ● While online activities rise,
design aims to nudge consumption patterns physical products and
towards sustainability. Similarly, poka-yoke infrastructure remain largely
product and service design ensure that unchanged.
emerging digital markets cater to sustainable ● Designing sustainable products
choices, emphasizing the importance of and services offers a chance
consumer education and sustainable product for lasting transitions, aligning
design. with Sustainable Development
Goals (SDGs).
● Promoting sustainable
consumption involves systemic
analysis, foolproof system
design, and prioritizing
sustainability in product/service
design.
Jonna C. 2024 Just energy The researchers The study looks at four main players in ● The study focuses on guiding
Baquillas, Transition developed a causal transitioning electric cooperatives (ELCOs) to electric cooperatives (ELCOs)
Jayne Lois among electric loop diagram (LCD) more sustainable energy practices: the toward more sustainable
San Juan & cooperatives: A and was government, ELCOs themselves, energy energy practices, known as
Ivan systems thinking conceptualized producers, and the community. It shows how Just Energy Transition (JET).
Henderson approach through literal government policies and community pressure Researchers use a method
V. Gue reviews of journal can influence ELCOs' decisions. For example, called systems thinking,
articles, government government policies can encourage creating a diagram based on
reports, national investment in renewable energy, while research and consultations with
agency policies and community demands for better services can ELCOs. They outline five steps:
non government push ELCOs to improve power availability. reviewing literature, consulting
case study reports. In The study predicts that as ELCOs invest more experts, mapping relationships,
order to achieve JET in renewable energy, power reliability will creating diagrams, and
(Just Energy improve, but initially, prices might be higher projecting outcomes.
Transition) the due to the cost of setting up renewable energy
methodological infrastructure. Overall, the study emphasizes ● The main players involved are
framework of the the importance of government support and the government, ELCOs,
study is community engagement in helping ELCOs energy producers, and the
compromised with 5 shift to more sustainable energy sources. community. Government
steps combining policies and community
literature review and demands strongly influence
expert consultations ELCO decisions. For instance,
(STEP 1: Literature government policies can
Review, STEP 2: encourage ELCOs to invest in
Expert Consultations renewable energy, while
with ELCO’s, STEP community needs can push
3: Initial roles, them to improve power
mechanisms and services.
relationships, STEP
4: Causal Loop ● The study predicts that as
diagrams and STEP ELCOs invest more in
5: Projected renewable energy, power
 performance of reliability will increase, but
ELCOs- RE mix) initial costs may be higher.
Overall, it stresses the
importance of government
support and community
involvement in helping ELCOs
transition to sustainable energy
sources.

Jonna C. 2022 Strolling The researcher used The study examined perceptions and ● The study dug into 359
Baquillas Between a qualitative research experiences of tourists on Smokey Tours' reviews of Smokey Tours' slum
and Brian Shanties: approach in order to slum tour in Manila, based on 359 TripAdvisor tour in Manila on TripAdvisor.
C. Gozun Tourists’ analyze the second reviews. Overwhelmingly positive ratings ● Almost all the reviews (98.3%)
Perceptions and web based data from (98.3%) were reported, with most mentioning were glowing, with folks
Experiences of TripAdvisor an online key words like "people," "guide," "living," praising aspects like the people
Manila’s Slums platform where users "see," and "experience." The cognitive they met, the guides, and the
can share their component of destination image, focusing on overall experience.
reviews and look for factual aspects, was prominent (44%),
potential followed by affective (35%) and cognitive ● They talked a lot about the
destinations. The (21%) components. Sub-themes emerged, sights, the tour itself, and the
focus of the study is emphasizing place, tour experience, social vibe of the community. Most of
to understand the environment, and infrastructure. Positive them felt really positive, with
perception and emotions dominated the affective component, many saying they'd
experiences of with tourists recommending the tour and recommend the tour or even go
visitors to Manila expressing a desire to revisit or help. back again.
slums located in Memorable tourism experiences highlighted
BASECO (Smokey multi-sensory immersion, social interactions, ● It's clear from the reviews that
Mountain) the date and emotional reflections. The study suggests people see this tour as a
used are reviews that reviews shape a positive image of genuine and enlightening
posted from February Smokey Tours' slum tour, offering an authentic experience.
2014 to March 2020 and educational experience appreciated by
with a total of 562 tourists. Future research could explore
reviews. With Non-
English Reviews
equaling to 109 comparative analyses and marketing
(Chinese, Dutch, implications.
Japanese, German,
French, Italian and
Serbian) and 453
reviews in English.
Copied and
transferred to
Microsoft word with
the total of 359
reviews qualified for
the research.

On the other hand

the data analysis
used a deductive
approach using
destination image
components as the
basis of classifying
and coding user
generated reviews.
NVivo for mAc was
also used in order to
reveal the frequency
of words (“slum”
“tour” and “manila”).
Memorable Tourism
Experience was also
determine for insights
and ambiance. In
addition, the data
were coded twice in
order to achieve a
consistent and
 accurate thematic
coding.

*indicate the following, if applicable: data used, sampling design, research design (quantitative, qualitative, mixed), data analysis