Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Analysis of The Stages of Scaffolding Life'' With
The Analysis of The Stages of Scaffolding Life'' With
ScienceDirect
Article history: The paper presents the attempts at determining the reasons for the hazardous incidents
Received 20 May 2014 which threaten the safety of people working on scaffolds, as well as in their vicinity. The
Accepted 29 September 2014 article is divided into two parts, the former referring to the information on the accident rate
Available online 30 December 2014 involving scaffoldings as well as the research on the likelihood of the occurrence of perilous
situations, the inspection of their technical state and the breaches of the OSH Regulations
Keywords: included. The latter part is devoted to the thorough analysis on the particular stages of the
Scaffolding scaffold operation life, the special attention being paid to the practices, errors and failures
Hazard identification while designing scaffolding. Moreover, it concerns the selection of the scaffold elements, the
Accidents on building sites assembly and disassembly of scaffolding as well as their usage which can result in an
Building disasters accident or a building collapse. The range of activities that contribute to the decrease in or
even the avoidance of risky situations involving scaffolds is hereby presented in conclu-
sions.
# 2014 Politechnika Wrocławska. Published by Elsevier Urban & Partner Sp. z o.o. All
rights reserved.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: e.blazik@pollub.pl (E. Błazik-Borowa), jacek.szer@p.lodz.pl (J. Szer).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acme.2014.09.009
1644-9665/# 2014 Politechnika Wrocławska. Published by Elsevier Urban & Partner Sp. z o.o. All rights reserved.
archives of civil and mechanical engineering 15 (2015) 516–524 517
Fig. 1 – Façade scaffolding at building works in Lublin Fig. 2 – Unanchored scaffolding at Scheibler Chapel in Lodz
(Poland). (Poland).
Fig. 3 – The number of building disasters in the years 2008–2013 (based on Refs. [12–17]).
¾ of scaffolds were erected on the edge of the risk. The analysis Inspectorate [7–11]. In Fig. 4 there is a percentage juxtaposition
presented in the paper [4] shows that there is no correlation of violations of the HSE (the Health and Safety Executive)
between the level of work safety on scaffolding and a region in regulations on building sites where scaffolds were used.
which a scaffold was assembled. Unfortunately, in The National Labour Inspectorate reports
In Poland, there are three sources of information on the life- (comp. [12–17]) there is information about the violation of
threatening situations – the reports of The National Labour regulations exclusively, not the real state of accidents.
Inspectorate on the inspection of safety conditions on building However, it appears that such substantial percentage of
sites (comp. [7–11]), the reports of The General Office of situations in which safety regulations were neglected
Building Control referring to the building disasters (comp. [12– increases the hazard of accidents occurrence at the working
17]) and the statistical yearbooks of The Central Statistical area.
Office (comp. [18,19]) including information about accidents
such as falls from heights, they being almost in 100% falls from
scaffolds. 3. The impact of scaffolding operation stages
In the reports of The General Office of Building Control on the possibility of accidents and building
there is some data on building disasters. The number of them disasters occurrence
together with disasters connected with scaffolding are
displayed in Fig. 3. Depending on the year the occurrence of From the above presented information it becomes apparent
accidents oscillates between 6% and 14%. Failures of scaffold- that in Poland the statistics of accidents related to the use of
ing are most commonly classified as 'others', which means scaffolds is not kept. More importantly, the analysis concern-
that their precise number is not possible to determine. It ing the hazard of working on scaffolding shows that all stages
should also be stated that the statistics do not include failures of scaffolding ‘‘life’’ (Fig. 5) can result in an accident or a
outside building sites as well as failures which were not building disaster.
reported as building disasters. Such situations frequently
occur when there are no casualties. Nevertheless, if there are 3.1. The preparation of scaffolding design documentation
some, safety supervisors record the event only in their
statistics without classifying it as a building disaster. The first and vital stage of erecting scaffolding is the
Most of the information associated with works on preparation of documentation that determines the safety of
scaffolding can be found in the reports of The National Labour work on a scaffold (Fig. 6). According to the Regulation of the
Fig. 4 – The juxtaposition of violations of the HSE regulations at building sites related to the use of scaffolds in years 2007–
2011 (based on Refs. [7–11]).
archives of civil and mechanical engineering 15 (2015) 516–524 519
Fig. 7 – The exemplary static schemes of scaffolding: (a) for renovation works at the relay bridge, (b) scaffolding at Scheibler
Chapel in Lodz (Poland) (see Fig. 4), (c) supporting structure of the formwork of the church ceiling in Rzeszow (Poland), (d)
scaffolding with the visualisation of the foundation and gas tank in Emmen (The Netherlands).
the places in which the construction is overloaded, which in of constructions or even throwing elements from heights
consequence may lead to local plasticity or another invisible result in the damage of elements. Further assembling of such
damage and the weakening of an element. Such potential elements increases the hazard of the failure of a construction.
damaged elements can be withdrawn from use. Whereas, if According to Ref. [3], scaffolding in Great Britain is in a poor
unusual scaffolding is not controlled in terms of its strength, technical condition. It appears that there is a similar problem
there exists every probability of damage such as a slight in Poland. As it emerges from The National Labour Inspector-
change of shape and material properties that reduces the load ate reports [9,10], small companies apply cheaper technolo-
capacity of an element. Due to the fact that the damage while gies, and are unwillingly to introduce innovative and safe
visually assessed may give an impression of not being that solutions e.g. purchasing or supplying modern scaffolding.
severe, the damaged element may be used in another Even though they decide to buy new scaffolding, it is heavily
assembled scaffolding, which consequently increases the exploited for a long time and in consequence, with the rise in
possibility of occurrence of failure; hence it increases the the scaffolding operation life, they become more hazardous.
hazard related to the work on a scaffold. In Poland there is a problem of mingling elements of
different systems, the unified joints being the best example in
3.2. The selection of the set of elements to assembly this case. Affluent companies purchase joints of materials
scaffolding with certificates, whereas, smaller ones purchase cheaper
joints. If there work several subcontractors on the same
Another stage of creating scaffolding concerns the selection of building site, it turns out that the joints are mingled after the
the set of elements (Fig. 8). The safety of workers on scaffolding completion of the construction. Assembly workers from
is conditioned by a good technical state of particular elements. renting companies are conscious of the importance of the
The multiple use of elements, the improper storing, overloads material the joins are made of, which results from their
archives of civil and mechanical engineering 15 (2015) 516–524 521
[2] M. Pieńko, E. Błazik-Borowa, Scaffoldings used to work at [13] The Report of the General Office of Building Control, Building
height during repairs of industrial facilities, Materiały Disasters in 2009 Year, 2010 Available from: http://www.
Budowlane 10 (2012) 58–60 (in Polish). gunb.gov.pl (in Polish).
[3] S.M. Whitaker, R.J. Graves, M. James, P. McCann, Safety with [14] The Report of the General Office of Building Control, Building
access scaffolds: development of a prototype decision aid Disasters in 2010 Year, 2011 Available from: http://www.
based on accident analysis, Journal of Safety Research 34 gunb.gov.pl (in Polish).
(2003) 249–261. [15] The Report of the General Office of Building Control, Building
[4] K.M. Halperin, M. McCann, An evaluation of scaffold safety at Disasters in 2011 Year, 2012 Available from: http://www.
construction sites, Journal of Safety Research 35 (2004) 141–150. gunb.gov.pl (in Polish).
[5] D. Fang, Q. Shenb, S. Wu, G. Liu, A comprehensive framework [16] The Report of the General Office of Building Control, Building
for assessing and selecting appropriate, scaffolding based on Disasters in 2012 Year, 2013 Available from the Internet:
analytic hierarchy process, Journal of Safety Research 34 http://www.gunb.gov.pl (in Polish).
(2003) 589–596. [17] The Report of the General Office of Building Control, Building
[6] H. Laitinen, M. Marjamäki, K. Päivärinta, The validity of the Disasters in 2013 Year, 2014 Available from: http://www.
TR safety observation method on building construction, gunb.gov.pl (in Polish).
Accident Analysis and Prevention 31 (1999) 463–472. [18] Yearbooks of Labour Statistics 2010, Central Statistical Office,
[7] B. Borys-Szopa, Executive Summary of the Chief Labour Warsaw, 2011, Available from: http://www.stat.gov.pl/gus/
Inspector's Report on the National Labour Inspectorate's 5840_2175_ENG_HTML.htm.
Activity in 2007, 2008 Available from: http://www.pip.gov.pl/ [19] Statistical Yearbook of the Regions – Poland 2011, Central
html/en/html/01050007.htm. Statistical Office, Warsaw, 2011, Available from: http://www.
[8] J. Zając, Executive Summary of the Chief Labour Inspector's stat.gov.pl/gus/5840_2176_ENG_HTML.htm.
Report on the National Labour Inspectorate's Activity in 2008, [20] Regulation of the Minister of Infrastructure of 6.02.2003 on
2009 Available from: http://www.pip.gov.pl/html/en/html/ Health and Safety During Construction Work (Dz. U. 2003, Nr
01050008.htm. 47, Item 401), 2003 (in Polish).
[9] J. Zając, Executive Summary of the Chief Labour Inspector's [21] EN 12810-1 Façade Made of Prefabricated Components – Part
Report on the National Labour Inspectorate's Activity in 2009, 1: Products Specifications, European Committee for
2010 Available from: http://www.pip.gov.pl/html/en/html/ Standardization, 2003.
01050009.htm. [22] EN 12810-2 Façade Made of Prefabricated Components – Part
[10] J. Zając, Executive Summary of the Chief Labour Inspector's 2: Particular Methods of Structural Design, European
Report on the National Labour Inspectorate's Activity in 2010, Committee for Standardization, 2003.
2011 Available from: http://www.pip.gov.pl/html/en/html/ [23] EN 18211-1 Temporary Works Equipment – Part 1: Scaffolds –
01050010.htm. Performance Requirements and General Design, European
[11] A. Tomczyk, Executive Summary of the Chief Labour Committee for Standardization, 2003.
Inspector's Report on the National Labour Inspectorate's [24] EN 1991-1-4 Eurocode 1: Actions on Structures – Parts 1–4:
Activity in 2011, 2012 Available from: http://www.pip.gov.pl/ General Actions – Wind Actions, European Committee for
html/en/html/01050011.htm. Standardization, 2005.
[12] The Report of the General Office of Building Control, Building [25] D. Gawęcka, P. Kmiecik, The supervision of construction and
Disasters in 2008 Year, 2009 Available from: http://www. exploitation of scaffolds as safety guarantor, Przegląd
gunb.gov.pl (in Polish). Budowlany 10 (2011) 16–18 (in Polish).