Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Oil Palm Genetic Improvement and Sustain
Oil Palm Genetic Improvement and Sustain
Benoît COCHARD Abstract: Genetic improvement of the oil palm may have a role to play in the sustainability of this crop.
Philippe AMBLARD Given the criticism aimed at this commodity chain, notably due to the extension of oil palm plantations
Tristan DURAND-GASSELIN to the detriment of forests, providing very high-yielding planting material might be a solution,
particularly as world demand is continually increasing. This crop is mostly managed by agroindustria-
CIRAD, Département des cultures pérennes, lists, but the smallholder sector is developing. It happens that this sector is classed as a sustainable type
TA 80/03, Avenue Agropolis, of agriculture by numerous NGOs, which are also asking plant breeders to take the specificities of
34398 Montpellier Cedex 5, France smallholdings into consideration.
Oil palm genetic improvement takes numerous criteria into account, many of which fit in with
sustainable agriculture. For example, this crop is subject to pressure from different pests and diseases. In
each case, a genetic hence eco-friendly approach has been taken and, in particular, vascular wilt-
tolerant planting material has been a successfully produced. Moreover, for the future of this crop,
planting material needs to be developed that requires fewer inputs, and consideration has to be given to
extending this crop in less favourable zones, by developing planting material that consumes less water.
Lastly, it is important to disseminate genetically diversified planting material.
Key words: Elaeis guineensis, genetic improvement, sustainable development
Introduction in its breeding strategies. If we refer to the one of the main causes of primary forest des-
Leipzig declaration, increasing yields must truction in those countries. It is true that the
Sustainable development has been defined as remain a very important criterion for genetic expansion of oil palm areas in the 1990s often
meeting present needs whilst not jeopardizing improvement. Oil palm genetic improvement took place in forest zones, thereby appearing
the ability of future generations to meet their has endeavoured to make optimum use of to threaten the biodiversity of the ecosystems,
own needs. In the field of agriculture, this has available genetic diversity in its variety creation and giving rise to numerous disputes with local
led to concepts of an ecological and social programmes, notably by working on introdu- communities.
nature (greater respect of resources, maintai- cing new populations into the improved plan- World demand for fats and oils is continually
ning quality of life, taking the harmony of ting material, and on a related species, Elaeis increasing, and one rapid way of satisfying that
landscapes into account, etc.), and to econo- oleifera (HBK) Cortes. IPM strategies are being demand is to extend the areas planted to oil
mic concepts (economic viability, agricultural developed against the main pests and diseases crops (table 1). Oil palm growing gives by far
feasibility). Agronomists have sought to take of the oil palm, be they of a known nature such the best oil production per unit area planted
these concepts into consideration by designing as Fusarium oxysporum sp elaeidis and Gano- (table 2). If current trends are confirmed, and
appropriate crop management sequences: derma, by using sustainable genetic resistan- there is nothing to indicate that things are
lower cost cropping systems, non-chemical ces, or of unknown nature such as bud rot. going to change, the oil palm commodity
control of endemic diseases, optimization of New ″varieties″ are being produced and care is chain will have to continue its efforts in order to
fertilizer and water management, etc. In this being taken to disseminate mixtures of ″varie- meet world demand through the sustainably
approach, the planting material grown is a ties″. intensified production.
factor to be considered.
With the will to promote sustainable agricul- Breeding and genetic improvement work for
ture, by focusing on the role of genetic impro- Importance the crop began in the 1920s in Africa and
vement, the Leipzig declaration (1996) defined of yield improvement Southeast Asia. To date, the African popula-
a global action plan to conserve and sustaina- tions have undergone two to three generations
bly utilize plant genetic resources for food and Following the devastating fires in Indonesia of improvement. Those in Southeast Asia gene-
agriculture [1]. The long-term objective is to and Malaysia in 1997, many NGOs severely rally have four to five generations, taking into
reduce genetic erosion and any genetic vulne- criticized oil palm cultivation, pointing to it as account the generations of multiplication from
rability by diversifying agricultural production
and increasing the genetic diversity of cultiva- Table 1. Changes in cultivated area for the main oil crops (in hectares x 1000). Source Oil World.
ted plants, whilst keeping in mind the need to
increase productivity. 1990 1995 2000 2003
Cultivation of the oil palm, Elaeis guineensis Oil palm 3 560 4 690 6 560 7 950
Jacq., is regularly criticized for its environmen-
Soybean 54 910 61 960 75 260 88 800
tal aggressiveness (destruction of primary
Sunflower 16 200 20 230 19 740 22 500
forests, water pollution, etc.). Yet this crop
Rapeseed 17 790 24 520 25 260 25 620
already integrates numerous criteria associated
Cotton 33 920 35 150 32 210 32 240
with sustainable agriculture. Apart from agro-
nomic aspects [2], oil palm genetic improve- Groundnut 19 910 20 590 22560 22 190
ment has long taken into account this concept Coconut 8 940 9 210 9 570 9 410
individuals introduced in the Bogor Botanical Utilization sons & Crosfield groups, which enabled a
Garden (Indonesia) in 1848 [3]. After a period of genetic resources major exchange of materials between several
of slow progress that soon levelled off, linked to countries (Cameroon, Colombia, Indonesia,
mass selection, considerable progress of Malaysia, Papua New Guinea, Thailand and the
Strengthening genetic diversity
around 30% was achieved with the discovery Democratic Republic of Congo) [16]. Since the
of shell thickness heredity [4]. Thereafter, in the In the first half of the 20th century, breeders 1990s, planting material exchanges have been
1950s, a further 10% was gained by exploiting provided growers with selected materials deri- more intermittent, such as between IOPRI2 in
heterosis in the crosses carried out between the ved primarily from local populations, but little Indonesia, Ivory Coast and Benin in 1991. To all
populations created in Asia and in Africa [5]. In progress had been achieved from those popu- intents and purposes, current exchange proto-
the 1960s, researchers launched a reciprocal lations, which is why an offer was made to cols limit genetic mixing, thereby limiting the
recurrent selection scheme at the African sta- several research institutes to exchange planting diversity in the different breeding program-
tions. The first selection cycle led to a 15% materials, which led to the International Expe- mes. We are therefore seeing a degree of
increase in yields [6], then a second cycle in riment [5]. The exchange involved 4 African contradiction between the decisions taken at
turn provided progress of a further 15% [7,8]. stations in Ivory Coast, Benin, and the two the Rio summit in 1992 which, due to the use
For example, in a Malaysian company with Congos, along with a station located in Malay- made by countries, has led to a virtual halt in
favourable conditions, oil yields increased from sia. The Sabah Department of Agriculture exchanges, and the determination expressed
1.3 tonnes of oil per hectare in 1950 to 5.4 in (Malaysia) also organized some exchanges, in the Leipzig declaration in 1996 to promote
1990, but apparently only half the progress involving materials from Cameroon and Nige- the diversity of the plants and the varieties
was due to selection [9]. Under less suitable ria. Numerous exchanges took place between used.
conditions in Ivory Coast, the planting material stations in the 1970s and 80s, between Benin,
marketed had a yield potential of 2.9 tonnes of Ivory Coast and Nigeria. A joint breeding pro-
2
oil/hectare/year in 1950. In 1998, yield poten- gramme was set up by the Unilever and Harri- IOPRI: Indonesian Oil Palm Research Institute.
tial was 4.1 [10].
1
″Unselected″ material: seeds harvested from plan-
tations. Figure 1. The aim of oil palm breeding is to secure production (Photo : T. Durand-Gasselin).
142 DOSSIER
often prove to be disappointing. Conse-
quently, specific breeding programmes have to
be implemented before it is possible to incor-
porate this genetic diversity into the selected
populations [22]. It has been possible to intro-
duce the best individuals into the recurrent
populations [23]. Individuals derived from the
Yocoboué populations [24] and an individual
from the Angola population [22] have proved
worthwhile and have been introduced into the
pool of improved parents.
Another strategy developed by MPOB [18]
consists in assessing the different surveys on
their own merits, and then disseminating the
most promising materials to breeders.
144 DOSSIER
sium that are required. Applications of the Is it more a problem of access to seeds, in terms material marketed, for which there could be
other nutrients, phosphorus and magnesium, of availability, cost, the impossibility of farmers vulnerability problems.
are absolutely necessary on occasions [49, 50]. producing their own seeds? To avoid these problems, the planting material
Fertilization is currently based on leaf analyses, In terms of dissemination, there is not a breeder marketed needed to be diversified. The crosses
which have been designed in such a way as to in every country, and in many countries there chosen to be marketed have been grouped by
adjust application rates to what is strictly neces- are no nurseryman/distributor networks. This origin to form ″hybrid categories″. The current
sary, thereby matching production require- encourages the planting of ″unselected″ oil seed production programme being implemen-
ments to socio-economic conditions, whilst palms, to the economic detriment of the far- ted by CIRAD’s partners comprises 18 different
remaining eco-friendly. This can no doubt be mer, but also of the entire commodity chain. categories [10]. As far as possible, several
improved by taking the genotype into account. Agroindustrialists, on the other hand, have no unmixed categories are supplied on each deli-
Indeed, differences in susceptibility have been problem obtaining supplies directly from plant very.
found between progenies and between clones breeders, even if they are on another conti-
for different minerals [49-51]. However, it is not nent. Conclusion
known whether those differences express diffe- In cost terms, seeds amount to 5 to 10% of the
price of a plantation for an agroindustrialist, Oil palm genetic improvement has always fit-
rent needs; that remains to be demonstrated.
but 15 to 20% for a smallholder, since he ted into a sustainable agriculture context. This
In the case of oil palm, there are technical primarily arises from the perennial nature of
constraints to defining fertilizers depending on invests less in fertilizers, infrastructures, etc.
Consequently, breeders are often criticized for this crop, which is intended to last 25 to 30
the germplasm involved. Studying fertilization years, and the plantation even longer if several
requirements taking continental specificities the high cost of seeds for the smallholder sec-
tor. The solution to this problem is political, cropping cycles are undertaken. Consequently,
into account would mean setting up unrealistic for both smallholders and agroindustrialists, it
trials. At the moment, given the selection economic as regards access to credit, but it is
not for breeders to risk their own profitability is necessary to provide certain guarantees
methods used, seeking a fertilization pro- when seeds are purchased. Seed purchases can
gramme adapted to a genotype can only be and the quality of the research they have to
conduct and fund. It is worth noting that in amount to 15 to 20% of the initial investment
done using commercially available planting in a plantation for a smallholder (not to men-
material, running the risk of defining fertilizers many countries where the price of seeds pro-
duced by the public sector is low, to encourage tion his work time). Plant breeders need to
adapted to material that is set to become obso- guarantee the quality of their planting mate-
lete. Might it not be appropriate to seek farmers to buy them, seed quality often suffers.
In such cases, everyone is a loser. rial, by guaranteeing its legitimacy (this is a
methods for the early assessment of nutritional fundamental aspect for oil palm), high yields,
requirements? Farmers cannot harvest their seeds from their
own palms. The differences in yields between resistance to the main diseases (vascular wilt,
this so-called ″unselected″ material and impro- Ganoderma, bud rot), and be able to advise on
Coelaenomenodera minuta control ved material are such that it would be unfair to the most appropriate material for a given pedo-
recommend such material. climatic environment.
This Coleoptera causes major damage episodi- Oil palm breeders must continue to improve
cally in West African oil palm plantations. Dif- If a farmer intends to formally participate in the
oil palm commodity chain, delivering his FFB to the yields of this crop, given the continually
ferences in susceptibility have been found increasing demand for fats and oils and the
between origins. Selection criteria need to be a mill, or by producing oil, he has every interest
in possessing the same planting material as the substantially reduced possibility of increasing
defined for setting up genetic improvement the areas planted to oil palm. They need to
programmes based on resistance to this pest. agroindustrialists. It is therefore difficult to
speak of specificity in the smallholder sector. pursue genetic control of the different diseases,
Elaeis oleifera provides such resistance. focusing on durable resistances of a horizontal
The main differences would seem to be linked
more to agricultural practices, such as promo- nature, as is the case for vascular wilt (40 years
Specificity of the smallholder sector ting intercrops in immature plantings, etc. of proven resistance). Lastly, they must take
In Africa, oil palm is a traditional crop. Seeds care to maintain as much genetic diversity as
The oil palm commodity chain is dominated by possible, not only in variety creation program-
an agroindustrial sector. The smallholder sec- and unrefined oil, called ″red oil″, are much
appreciated in numerous dishes. For this tradi- mes, but also when distributing commercial
tor, which was initially supervised by the seeds.
agroindustrial sector, is also developing consi- tional use of oil palm, it is not essential to have
derably outside that influence. Oil palm small- improved material, since it does not necessarily
holdings are considered to be sustainable far- possess the culinary qualities sought. Palms REFERENCES
ming models by numerous NGOs [52], which from semi-wild groves can be used. In this case, 1. LEIPZIG DECLARATION. Global action plan for
are asking whether the specificity of the small- breeders could easily develop a specific ″niche″ the preservation and sustainable utilization of
holder sector can or ought to be taken into material which would be more specific to the plant genetic resources for food and agricul-
account from an agronomic point of view and desired culinary qualities. ture. FAO. Leipzig. 17-23 June 1996.
for planting material selection. 2. CALIMAN JP, BERTHAUD A, DUBOS B,
What problems might be specific to the small-
Variety dissemination TAILLIEZ B. Agronomy, sustainability and good
holder sector? The aim of any breeder is to be able to distri- agricultural practices. OCL 2005 ; 2 : 134-40.
For a breeder, what type of specific oil palm bute germplasm to farmers that offers new 3. CORLEY RHV, TINKER B. The Oil Palm 4th Edi-
should be developed? Palms that are easier to qualities as rapidly as possible. tion. 2003. Oxford : Blackwell Science LTD :
harvest, easier to maintain, higher yielding, Several dissemination strategies can be consi- 562.
requiring few inputs? If these criteria are consi- dered. In variety creation programmes, only 4. BEIRNAERT A, VANDERWEYEN R. Contribution
dered, they clearly concern both sectors. And the best two or three crosses identified could à l’étude génétique et biométrique des variétés
we have already touched upon these subjects be used. That avenue was not chosen as it d’Elaeis guineensis Jacquin. Pub Inst Nat Etude
above. would lead to excessive homogeneity in the agron Congo Belge Ser Sci 1941 ; 27 : 1-101.
146 DOSSIER
47. CORLEY RHV. Oil Palm yield components and 49. CALIMAN JP, DANIEL C, TAILLIEZ B. Oil palm 51. DUBOS B, CALIMAN JP, CORRADO F,
yields cycles. In : DA Earp, W Newall ed, Oil mineral nutrition. Plantation Recherche Dévelop- QUENCEZ P, SISWO SUYANTO, TAILLIEZ B.
palm. Kuala Lumpur. Incorp. Soc Of planters, pement 1994 ; 1 : 36-54. Importance of magnesium nutrition in oil
Malaysia : 116-29. palm. Plantation Recherche Développement
50. JACQUEMARD J CH, TAILLIEZ B, DADANG K, 1999 ; 6 : 313-25.
48. CORNAIRE B, DANIEL C, ZUILY-FODIL Y,
LAMADE E. Le comportement du palmier sous OUVRIER M, ASMADY H. Oil palm (Elaeis gui-
stress hydrique. Données du problème, pre- neensis Jacq.) nutrition: Planting Material 52. RSPO Factsheet. Round Table on Sustainable
miers résultats et voies de recherche. Oléagi- effect. In: 2002 International Oil Palm Confer- Palm Oil. November 2004. www.sustainable-
neux 1994 ; 49 : 1-12. ence. 8-12 July 2002. Nusa Dua, Bali, Indonesia. palmoil.org.