You are on page 1of 3

Digitally signed by Joseph Zernik DN: cn=Joseph Zernik, o, ou, email=jz12345@earthli nk.net, c=US Date: 2012.01.

26 17:33:15 +02'00'

January 26, 2012 Sarah Lifschitz Clerk of the Court Supreme Court of the State of Israel Tel: 02-675-9666 Fax: 02-675-9648 By fax Response within 14 days is kindly requested.

RE: Request for comments, corrections, regarding draft report electronic record systems of the Supreme Court Dear Clerk Lifschitz: Attached is a two-page draft table, [1] summarizing survey of the electronic records of the Supreme Court over the past decade. The results should raise concern with any person, who is familiar with the proper administration of the courts. Additional data regarding the systems is provided in additional reports, link below. [2] I would be grateful for any comments/corrections that you may offer, prior to completion of the report, particularly regarding the apparent failure of the Office of the Clerk to certify any decisions of the Supreme Court after January 2003.

______________ Dr Joseph Zernik PO Box 31440, Jerusalem 91313 Tel: 052.508.3014 jz12345@earthlink.net LINKS:
[1] 12-01-25 Certification, or Lack Thereof, in Judicial Records of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel (2000-2012) Table Summary s http://www.scribd.com/doc/79389235/ [2]11-12-04 Simulated Records, Simulated Litigation Enabled by the Electronic Record Systems of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel (English) http://www.scribd.com/doc/73239491/

12-01-25 Indices of Cases, Lists of Decisions, and Certifications in ELYON1 and ELYON2, the electronic record systems of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel (2000-2012)
II. Table Summary*
# 1. Case #

Top
Certification Notes
Prior to 2001 - typical certification statement during the tenure of Shmaryahu Cohen as Clerk of the Court.

001/00

Decision Date (per docket**) Jan 3, 2000

00/1

The basic elements: a) certification statement True copy of

the original, b) listing of the original electronic file name / Q02.00000010, c) name of the certifying individual Shmaryahu Cohen, and d) his authority Clerk of the Court.

________ True copy of the original Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court

/Q02.00000010
2. 100/01 Jan 21, 2001
100/01 In 2001 - the original certification statement (1.) was partially undermined Version subject to editing changes prior to publication in the Compiled Decisions of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel. However, the version in the Compiled Decisions was defined as the final version.

The decision is dated Jan 18, 2001 in the body of the record.

________ True copy of the original Version subject to editing changes prior to publication in the Compiled Decisions of the Supreme Court of the State of Israel. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court //A01.01001000

3.

001/02

Jan, 2002
No decisions found.

Jan-Feb 2002 numerous (hundreds?) new case files are missing.

4.

1582/02

Feb 28, 2002

20/2851-
________ Issued this date, February 14, 2007 Boaz Okon Magistrate

United Nations reports list missing court records a cardinal sign of judicial corruption. Feb-Sep 2002 - large number of decisions include a false and deliberately misleading certification box. These decision records are opined as fraud.

No certification statement and no original electronic file name are listed (a pattern that started around Jan 2003, long after the death of Shmaryahu Cohen. This particular decision is opined as a falsified court record. Falsification was probably perpetrated at a date later than date of Feb 28, 2002. By the date of Feb 14, 2007, Cohen was no longer among the living, and Magistrate Okon was no longer with the Supreme court. Case number on the decision:

________ Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Shmaryahu Cohen Clerk of the Court

2851-20-

5. 6.

100/02

March 7, 2002 March 21, 2002

Shmaryahu Cohen dies

On March 27, 2002 - Complaint of murder was filed by a friend/relative of Shmaryahu Cohen with the police. However, no clear motive was listed. March-Dec 2002 - following the death of Shmaryahu Cohen, an unnamed Magistrate starts certifying the decisions.

Most decisions are still certified against an original electronic file (not a .doc). No mention is made of the office of Clerk of the Court.

________ True copy of the original /Q04.02001000 Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Rasham [Magistrate-jz]

7.

2754/02

Apr 04, 2002

April 2002 the April 4, 2002 decision is missing in both ELYON1 and ELYON2

United Nations reports list missing court records a cardinal

DRAFT

8.

1582/02

Apr 23, 2002

sign of judicial corruption. Feb-Sep 2002 a subset of (dozens?) decisions include a false and deliberately misleading certification statement. These decision records are opined as fraud.

This particular decision is opined as a fraud: It is certified, like numerous other records, against the COURT.DOT file.

________ True copy of the original COURT.DOT Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Rasham [Magistrate-jz]

9.

2754/02

Nov 13, 2002

Nov-Dec, 2002 - Sarah Lifschitz certifies decisions for a few weeks against .doc files.

________ True copy of the original 02027540_L05.doc Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. Sarah Lifschitz Clerk of the Court

10. 1578/02

Dec 17, 2002


________ Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 02015780_L10. Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website

Jan 2003 to this date - no certification of Supreme Court decisions.


Sarah Lifschitz Clerk of the Court

Only a disclaimer, but no certification statement appears on the decisions No mention of the Clerk of the Court, only Information Cetner.

11. -

Sep 6, 2010

In this specific record, a non .doc file was still listed. Sept 2010 - Sarah Lifschitz still holds the office of Clerk of the Court and signs an official letter as such. Hand signature, name and title of Clerk of the Court appear on a holiday letter to the Israeli Bar Association.

12. 001/12

Jan 1, 2012

21/1-

During the period of Jan 2003-January 2012 Clerk of the Court Sarah Lifschitz has not certified the records of the Court. Jan 2012 - continued pattern of no valid certification of court decisions.

________ Version subject to editing and phrasing changes. 12000010 _S03.doc Information Center, Tel: 02-6750444, Website

No certification statement, only a disclaimer. A word .doc file is listed, but with no claim of authenticity. " "-added to case number on the decision. " "added on the decision docket line.

* **

ELYON1: http://elyon1.court.gov.il/verdictssearch/HebrewVerdictsSearch.aspx ELYON2: http://elyon2.court.gov.il/ Decision dates, derived from ELYON1 and ELYON2, should be considered unreliable

DRAFT

You might also like