Technical Meeting - May 16th, 2011

ENGLISH DEBATE
COMPETITION
Harmony of Indonesian Food Heritage
 GENERAL
There are 40 minutes for every round that consists of :
•Rules & Roles (read only at Preliminary Round I)
•Introduction = ± 5 minutes
•Debate = ± 25 minutes
•Verbal Adjudication = + 10 minutes

•16 participants from 9 high schools

•Preliminary Round IA/ IB preliminary round II 
Semifinal Final
•Competition use KNOCKOUT system
•Full English
 Themes (1)
• Preliminary Round 1A :
– Utilization of artificial sweetener in traditional foods is not
recommended

• Preliminary Round 1B:

– The use of banana leaf sa packaging for traditional foods
cannot be substituted by plastic
 
• Preliminary Round II :
– The industrialization of traditional foods should be
encouraged
 
 Themes (2)
• Semifinal :
– The habit of consuming junk food can threaten the
existence of traditional foods
 
• Final (motion preferences) :
– Fresh traditional beverages are better than instant
traditional beverages
– GMP (Good Manufacturing Process) should be applied
in traditional food manufacture
– Food diversification can reduce rice consumption
effectively
 RUNDOWN
• 07.30-08.30 = Registration
• 08.30-09.00 = Opening Ceremony
• 09.00-09.40 = Preliminary round IA
• 09.50-10.30 = Preliminary round 1B
• 10.50-11.30 = Preliminary round II
• 12.00-12.40 = Semifinal
• 12.40-13.30 = Lunch Time
• 13.30-14.00 = Motion Preference +
Case Building
• 14.00-14.50 = Final
 RULES & ROLES
• No statement about SARA, abuse, dan pornograph
during debate
• Debate held in full english
• Affirmative : supoorting themes, negative : rejected
themes
• Good behave during debate
• No interruption while another team say their arguments
• Standing when share the statement
• No interaction between participant and audience during
debate
• Audience may not disturb debate competition
• Applause only given when debate ends
• Konfirmasi hanya akan diakomodasi setelah hasil
lomba keluar
• No cellular phone during debate
• Participants must come 5 minutes before debate start
• Peserta diharap menunggu di gedung Thomas
Aquinas dan harus hadir 5 menit sebelum lomba
berlangsung
• Bagi peserta yang belum bertanding, harus menunggu
di ruang isolasi.
• The final decision from jury can’t be refused
 ADJUDICATOR MARK SYSTEM
Matter (jumlah 20 point)
• Matter meliputi argument yang disajikan peserta debat. Materi yang baik meliputi
argument yang logis dan difukung contoh yang relevan.

Manner (jumlah 20 point)

• Manner meliputi cara peserta menyampaikan argumennya. Manner yang baik
harus dapat menarik bagi pendengar, sehingga dapat membuat argumennya lebih
meyakinkan. Peserta harus memiliki eye contact dengan pendengar, berbicara
dengan jelas.

Method (jumlah 10 point)

• Method meliputi struktur penyampaian argument dari speaker. Struktur yang baik
harus mengidentifikasi key issues, menghubungkannya, penyampaian yang
konsisten dan koheren, dan peserta harus dapat mengalokasikan waktu dengan
baik.
 SPEAKERS ROLE
1st affirmative speaker
• Define the topic: explain the issue of the debate
briefly describing the argument that each side must
present
• Present the pro statements. Summarize the main
argument of the team briefly

1st negative speaker

• Clarify the issue established by the pro definition
• Present a rebuttal (response that the debater makes
to the arguments of the opposing team).
• Summaries the arguments reised in her/his speech
briefly
2nd affirmative speaker
• Present a rebuttal: the speaker rebuts the main points raised by
the first negative speaker and support the arguments made by
the first affirmative speaker
• Present argument
• Summarized not only the points made in their own speech, but
also the main points raised by their team as a whole

2nd negative speaker

• Present a rebuttal: the speaker rebuts the main points raised by
the first affirmative speaker and support the arguments made
by the first negative speaker
• Present argument
• Summarized not only the points made in their own speech, but
also the main points raised by their team as a whole
3rd affirmative speaker
• Present a rebuttal: thematic rebuttal should address the key
issues of the debate, relating arguments and counter
arguments of the pro and contra
• Summarize: the third speaker should allow time for a careful
and convincing summary their team’s main arguments and
significant issues in the debate
• Note: the third speaker are not allowed to introduce any new
matter into the debate

3rd negative speaker

• Present a rebuttal: thematic rebuttal should address the key
issues of the debate, relating arguments and counter
arguments of the pro and contra
• Summarize: the third speaker should allow time for a careful
and convincing summary their team’s main arguments and
significant issues in the debate
• Note: the third speaker are not allowed to introduce any new
matter into the debate
 ADJUDICATOR
• Jumlah: 12 juri
• Penyisihan I, II, dan semifinal dihadiri oleh 3
juri @ ruangan
• Final dihadiri oleh 7 juri
• Juri merupakan dosen dari Fakultas Sastra
Inggris, Fakultas Hukum, Fakultas Teknologi
Pertanian, dan Fakultas Psikologi
 CHAMPIONSHIP
• Winner :
Rp 1.000.000 + gold medal + certificate
• Runner-up :
Rp 750.000 + silver medal + certificate
• 2nd runner-up :
Rp 500.000 + bronze medal + certificate
• Great debater :
Rp 200.000 + “great debater” medal + certificate
 PARTICIPANTS
• Tritunggal : 4 team
• Kebon Dalem : 2 team
• Regina Pacis : 2 team
• SMA Terang Bangsa : 2 team ?
• SMK Terang Bangsa : 2 team ?
• De Britto : 2 team
• Sedes : 1 team
• Nusa Putera : 1 team
• Theresiana 01 : 2 team ??

• TOTAL : 16 team
 2
1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
 DETERMINED
• 1 : • 9 :
• 2 : • 10 :
• 3 : • 11 :
• 4 : • 12 :
• 5 : • 13 :
• 6 : • 14 :
• 7 : • 15 :
• 8 : • 16 :
PRELIMINARY ROUND 1A

R. 3.2

R. 3.2

R. 3.2

R. 3.2
PRELIMINARY ROUND 1B
R. 3.2

R. 3.2

R. 3.2
PRELIMINARY ROUND 2
R. 3.2

R. 3.2

R. 3.2
SEMI FINAL

R. 3.2

R. 3.2
FINAL

Vs
 THANK YOU
DO YOUR BEST