Finite Element Analysis on the Structural

Behavior of a Precast Frame Connection Using

Confined Splice Technique

Review of
Related
Literature
MARK CHRISTIAN D.
ESGUERRA
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

Based on the test results conducted by

the previous researchers it was found
out that bond failure splices are The study conducted by the
Behavior and Splice always failed by the pullout of the previous researcher is
Length of Deformed
Bars Lapping in pre-embedded bar other than the grouted somehow similar to the
Yongfeng Spirally Confined bar. As the spiral pitch distance is research of the present
Zheng , Quantitativ not greater than 75 mm, the tensile researcher. Both of the study
Zhangfeng Zhu , Grout-Filled e & strength generally improves with the of the previous and present
Zhengxing Guo, Corrugated Duct Analytical increment of volumetric spiral researcher uses confined
& Peng Liu reinforcement ratio due to the higher splice method. But the
Volume
2019 Article ID confinement provided by the spiral bar. present study does not use
5280986 Compared with the spiral bar diameter, spiral reinforcement unlike
the spiral pitch distance provides more the previous study.
dominant effect on the tensile strength
of the connection.
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue No. Study
pp. and year

In the study conducted by

Thonstad, Bao, Weigand, Main,
Lew uses 5 different types of
connections that were developed
by NIST in coordination with an
industry review committee of
PCI members where in one these
The results of the computational modeling connection design is somehow
NEW CONNECTIONS FOR
Thonstad, Bao, ENHANCING ROBUSTNESS of the new connection details have similar to the research of the
Quantitative suggested that they would provide improved present researcher and that
Weigand, Main, OF PRECAST CONCRETE & Analytical strength and deformation capacity in developing a new precast
Lew FRAME STRUCTURES
comparison with the prototype connection to provide improved
(2021)
configuration. structural robustness. But the
research of the present day
researcher differs beacuase non
of the 5 new connections uses
the conifne splice method but
rather it foucses more on ink
plates, threaded rods, or
deformed bar reinforcement
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The Study of the previous

researcher is quite similar
to the present day researcher
Seismic evaluation Based on the results of the both of researcher aims to
of grouted splice experimental evaluation of the column– emulate the capacity of the
M. J. Ameli, sleeve connections to–cap beam joint tests conducted in cast-in-plcae concrete using
Joel E. Parks, for reinforced Quantitativ this research provided qualitative and precast connection. But the
Dylan N. Brown, precast concrete e & quantitative measures to evaluate the present researcher found out
Chris column–to–cap beam Analytical specimens under lateral cyclic loads that the previous researcher
Pantelides joints in were desirbale This is desirable and used grouted splice sleeve
accelerated bridge closely emulates cast-in-place where as the present
construction(2015) concrete construction. researcher intend to use
confined spliced method for
the connection precast
connection design
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The researcher found out that

the present study is quite
similar to this previous
study. Both study focused on
Seismic behavior of improving the design of
two exterior beam– The improvement made from the precast precast connection for small
column connections connection of the industrial and structure. But they differ
Ercan Yuksel , made of normal- residential structural model found out in terms of methods and
H. Faruk
Karadogan , I. strength concrete Quantitativ to be effective on the strength and application of the precast
Engin Bal , developed for e & displacement capacity of the connection. The previous
precast
Alper Ilki , construction Analytical connection. The analysis results are study focused on enchancing
encouraging to accurately model the the capacity of beam–column
Ahmet Bal ,
Pınar Inci September nonlinear behavior of the connections connection using normal-
2015Engineering with varying dimensions and strength concrete and through
Structures 99:157- reinforcement details. the use of corbels and plates
172 . But the present study is
focused on the use of confine
splice method and aims to
limit the use of corbels in
the precast connection.
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

Grouted sleeve
connections used in The study conducted by the
precast reinforced Based from the finding of the previous previous researcher is
concrete authors the proposed connection system similar to the research of
construction – for precast columns, designed in the present day researcher
Experimental accordance with the provisions given both of the researcher aims
investigation of a in European Committee for to improve the precast
Nerio column-to-column Quantitativ Standardization. EN 1992-1-1:2004, connection design. But the
TULLINIa , joint e & Eurocode 2,is effective in terms of present researcher differs
Fabio MINGHINIb Analytical Ultimate Limit State capacity. The with the previous researcher
same connection system, but used for a interms of the materials used
Engineering column-to-foundation joint tested in the previous researcher used
Department, cyclic bending combined with axial grouted sleeve connection
University of compression, will be the subject of a where as the present day
Ferrara, Via subsequent research. researcher aims to use
Saragat 1, Ferrara, confined splice.
Italy
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The Study of the previous

researcher is similar to the
Based from the test results conducted present day researcher both
of researcher aims to design
by Andrea Belleri & Paolo Riva it a precast connection in
Seismic performance showed that grouted steelsleeves are
and retrofit of Quantitativ suitable as column-to-foundation seismic regions. But the
Andrea Belleri precast concrete e & connections in seismic regions. The present researcher found out
& Paolo Riva grouted sleeve Quantitativ high ductility of the grouted steel that the previous researcher
e usedgrouted corrugated steel
connections sleeve connections is related to the
confining effect of the corrugated sleeve connections where as
steel sleeves on the grout. the present day researcher
intend to use confined
spliced method for the
precast connection design.
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The Study of the previous

researcher is quite similar
to the present day researcher
both of researcher aims to
Based from the results of the previous
Kristiyanto Beam-to-Beam researcher it was found out that the emulate a more resilliant
precast connection beam to
Hery , Connection of beam to beam connection of precast beam connection. But the
Triwiyono Precast Concrete Descriptive concrete show more growth with the use present researcher found out
Andreas , Structures MATEC of steel plates and bolts. The that the previous researcher
Muslikh and Web of Conferences connection design can be design
used steel plates and bolts
Saputra Ashar 258, 04002 (2019) according to code for use in areas where as the present
with high seismic hazards researcher intend to use
confined spliced method for
the connection precast
connection design
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The researcher found out that

the present study is quite
similar to this previous
Seismic Based from the rest of the researchers study. Both study focused on
experimental study it was found out that the fabricated developing a of precast
connection for beam to column
on a precast samples were subjected to a plastic connection. But they differ
Zhiwei Lua , concrete beam- hinging deformation at the end of the
Jun Huanga , column connection Quantitativ beam and the grouted sleeve splices in in terms of methods and
Shaobin Daia , with grout sleeves e & all of the samples were not subjected application of the precast
Jixiong Liua , Quantitativ to a bond slip or fracture failure. connection. The previous
e study focused on using double
Mingzhong Zhang These in indicates that it is possible
Engineering for a double grouted splices to grouted sleeve splices to
Structures · connect two disconnected precast connect two disconnected
November 2019 members. precast members . But the
present study is focused on
the use of confine splice
method for the precast
connection.
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The study of the previous

researcher is almost simliar
In this study of the previous to the present researcher.
Experimental Cyclic researcher, experimental cyclic Both of the study aims to
Behavior of Precast response of hybrid (emulative-welded) develop and ivestigate the
Hybrid Beam-Column
Connections with precast beam- column connections were behaviour of precast
Sadik Can investigated. Based on the results of connection during seismic
Girgin, Ibrahim Welded Components Quantitativ the test it was found out that activities. But the differ in
Serkan Misir, Vol.11, No.2, e & revising some the relivant terms of methods and
and Serap pp.229–245, June Quantitativ requirements in the design codes application on the design of
2017 DOI e
Kahraman showed and specimen showed an improved the precast connection. The
10.1007/s40069-017- seismic behavior thanks to unbonded previous researcher uses
0190-y ISSN 1976- length approach and the additional welded components where as
0485 / eISSN 2234- ties to prevent early buckling of the present researcher aims
1315
longitudinal bars. to use confined splice as an
alternative to precast
connection.
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The Study of the previous

researcher shows a similar
Seismic Performance goal with the present day
of Precast Concrete researcher. Both of the
Columns with researcher aims to develop
Improved U-type Based from the test results of the new design of precast
Zhiwu Yu, Reinforcement previous researcher. The test results connection which can surpass
Xiaoyong Lv, Ferrule Connections Quantitativ indicated that the columns with the the capacity of cast in place
Yujie Yu, e & improved URF connection displayed columns. But the differ in
Faxing Ding, Quantitativ better lateral strength and ductility terms of methods and
and Xiaodan Yu et al. Int J e performance than the column with the application on the design of
Peng Concr Struct Mater previous URF connection and the cast the precast connection. the
(2019) 13:54 in place column. previous researcher uses U-
https://doi.org/10. type longitudinal
1186/s40069-019- reinforcement ferrule
0368-6 connections while the present
researcher aims to use
confined splice method.
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The Study of the previous

researcher shows a similar
Based on the test results of the goal with the present-day
Amin Einea et al. Grout-Filled Pipe
previous researcher. They have found researcher. Both researcher
(ND), Takashi Splices for Quantitative aims to develop an
out that inexpensive grout filled splice for field
Yamane et al.(ND), Precast Concrete & alternative precast
connection of precast concrete members can be
Maher K. Tadros et Construction ( PCI Quantitative connection which is much
Joural ) fabricated from standard steel pipe. cheaper unlike the
al.(ND) alternative grouted sleeve
and both researcher used
hallow steeltube
 Title of the Paper
Name of the Similarity, Differences, or
Author Publication Methodology Findings Originality of the Proposed
Volume No. Issue Study
No. pp. and year

The Study of the previous

Behavior of Grouted Quantitative
Feng Lin and Peng Sleeve Splice for & out that inexpensive grout filled splice for field
Zhao Steel Profile under Quantitative
Tensile Loadings
researcher shows a similar
Based on the test results of the goal with the present-day
previous researcher. They have found researcher. Both researcher
aims to develop an
alternative precast
connection of precast concrete members can be connection which is much
fabricated from standard steel pipe. cheaper unlike the
alternative grouted sleeve
and both researcher used
hallow steeltube