Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Theories to
Healthcare Practice
Presented by Group 3
Learning:
A relatively permanent change in mental processing, emotional functioning, and
behavior as a result of experience. It is the process by which individuals gain new
knowledge or skills and change their thoughts, feelings, attitudes, and actions.
Although people in every culture have beliefs about how teaching and learning
should occur, there are several major theories of learning that have been tested with
research. Learning allows individuals to adapt to demands and changing
circumstances and is crucial in health care—whether for patients and families
struggling with ways to improve their health and adjust to their medical conditions,
for students gaining the information and skills necessary to become a healthcare
professional.
Learning Theory:
A coherent framework of integrated constructs and principles that describe,
explain, or predict how people learn. It is a logical framework describing,
explaining, or predicting how people learn. Whether used singly or in
combination, learning theories have much to offer the practice of health care.
Increasingly, health professionals.
-This chapter reviews the psychological and motor learning theories that are useful to
health education and clinical practice. Behaviorist, cognitive, and social learning
theories are most often applied to patient education as an aspect of professional
nursing practice. This chapter also treats psychodynamic and humanistic perspectives
as learning theories because they encourage a patient-centered approach to care and
add much to our understanding of human motivation and emotions in the learning
process. Emotions and feelings, it is argued, are critical to understanding learning
(Goleman, 1995)
Contribution of learning theories:
• It provide information and techniques to guide teaching and learning
A neutral stimulus (NS)—a stimulus that has no particular value or meaning to the learner
—is paired with a naturally occurring unconditioned or unlearned stimulus (UCS) and
unconditioned response (UCR) . After a few such pairings, the neutral stimulus alone (i.e.,
without the unconditioned stimulus) elicits the same response. Often without thought or
awareness, learning occurs when the newly conditioned stimulus (CS) becomes associated
with the conditioned response (CR)
EXAMPLE: Someone without much experience with hospitals (NS)
may visit a relative who is ill. While in the relative’s room, the visitor
may smell offensive odors (UCS) and feel queasy and light-headed
(UCR). After this initial visit and later repeated visits, hospitals (now
the CS) may become associated with feeling anxious and nauseated
(CR), especially if the visitor smells odors similar to those
encountered during the first experience
Respondent conditioning highlights the importance of what is going on in
the environment in health care. Often without thinking or reflection,
patients and visitors make associations as a result of their hospital
experiences, providing the basis for long-lasting attitudes toward medicine,
healthcare facilities, and health professionals. Principles of respondent
conditioning may be used to get rid of or eliminate a previously learned
response, which is especially useful in teaching people to reduce their
anxiety or break bad habits.
Operant conditioning focuses on the behavior of the organism and
the reinforcement that occurs after the response. A reinforcer is a
stimulus or event applied after a response that strengthens the
probability that the response will be performed again. Praise, hugs,
money, and prizes are examples of positive reinforcers. When specific
responses are reinforced on the proper schedule, behaviors can be
either increased or decreased.
The best way to increase the probability that a response will occur again is to apply positive
reinforcement or rewards after the behavior occurs.
There are many different types of positive reinforcers that can be used to increase behaviors, but
it is important to note that the type of reinforcer used depends on the individual and the situation
According to this theory , learning is heavily influenced by the culture and occurs as a
social process in interaction with others.
A person’s knowledge may not necessarily reflect reality, but through collaboration and
negotiation, new understanding is acquired.
Social learning theory is largely based on the work of Albert Bandura (1977, 2001), who
mapped out a perspective on learning that includes consideration of the personal
characteristics of the learner, behavior patterns, and the environment. In early discussions of
this theory, Bandura emphasized behaviorist features and the imitation of role models; later,
the focus shifted to cognitive considerations, and more recently, Bandura’s attention has
turned to the impact of social factors and the social context within which learning and
behavior occur. According to Bandura, personality is shaped by interaction among cognitive
factors, behaviors, and environmental factors. This interaction is termed reciprocal
determinism.
Cognitive factors § Behavioral factors § Environmental factors §
Our dispositional Our skills, practice Our social, political, and
factors: beliefs, and self efficacy § Self cultural influences and
expectations, values, efficacy: Similar to personal learning
intentions, social roles, confidence. The belief experiences
emotional makeup and that one is capable of
biological and genetic performing a certain
influences behavior to attain a
certain goal
Role modeling is a central Vicarious reinforcement is another concept
from social learning theory and involves
concept of the social viewing other people’s emotions and
learning theory. As an determining whether role models are perceived
example, a more as rewarded or punished for their behavior.
Reward is not always necessary, however, and a
experienced nurse who learner may imitate the behavior of a role
demonstrates desirable model even when no reward is available to
either the role model or the learner.
professional attitudes and
Nevertheless, in many cases, whether the
behaviors sometimes serves model is viewed by the observer as rewarded or
as a mentor for a less punished may have a direct influence on
learning. This relationship may be one reason
experienced nurse, while
why it is difficult to attract health professionals
medical students, interns, to geriatric care. Although some highly
and residents are mentored impressive role models work in this field,
geriatric health care is often accorded lower
by attending physicians.
status with less pay in comparison to other
specialty areas
-It emphasizes the importance of the individual and the individual's
perceptions of his/her personal capabilities as key determinants of successful
outcomes. Self-efficacy theory, and the broader social cognitive theory in
which self-efficacy is encompassed, therefore clearly endorses a democratic
ideal that suggests that all individuals are competent and capable of being
successful, provided they have the opportunities and self-efficacy necessary to
pursue their goals.
•People learn through •The most human behavior is •Social learning theory explains human
observing others’ learned observation-ally through behavior in terms of continuous
behavior, attitudes and modeling: from observing others, reciprocal interaction between cognitive
outcomes of those one forms an idea of how new behavioral and environmental influences.
behaviors. behaviors are performed, and on The social learning theory has sometimes
later occasions this coded been called a bridge between behaviorist
information serves as a guide for and cognitive learning theories because it
action” (Bandura) encompasses attention, memory and
motivation.
Factors that may influence learning
Humanistic theory is especially compatible with nursing’s focus on caring and patient-centeredness—an
orientation that is increasingly being challenged by the emphasis in medicine and health care on science,
technology, cost efficiency, for-profit medicine, bureaucratic organization, and time pressures. Like the
psychodynamic theory, the humanistic theory is largely a motivational theory. From a humanistic
perspective, the motivation to act stems largely from each person’s needs, feelings about the self, and the
desire to grow in positive ways. Remembering information and transferring learning to other situations are
helped by encouraging curiosity and a positive self-concept, as well as having open situations where people
respect individuality and freedom of choice. Under such conditions, flexibility in problem-solving and
creativity is enhanced.
The humanistic theory has its
At the bottom of Maslow’s
weaknesses as well. Research has not
Although
hierarchy arethisphysiological
model is been able to substantiate some of its
needs (food,appealing,
intuitively water, warmth,
research strongest claims, and the theory has
hasOne
sleep); of
notnext the
beencome best
able toknown
safety needs;
support been criticized for promoting self-
then the need
Maslow’s for belonging
hierarchy and
of needs centered learners who cannot take
humanistic theorists is criticism or compromise. The touchy-
love; much
with followed by self-esteem.
consistency. For At
theAbraham Maslowis(1954,
top of the hierarchy the feely approach of humanism makes
example, although some some learners and educators feel
1987),
need whoneeds
identified
for self-actualization
people’s basic may
a
not truly uncomfortable. Moreover,
(maximizing one’s potential).
be hierarchy
met,this
they of needs to
may information, facts, memorization,
Within model, it is assumed drill, practice, and the tedious work
explain
nonetheless
that human
basic-levelengage in be
needs must sometimes required to master
creative
met activities,
motivation.
before individualsextend
can be knowledge, which humanists
themselves
concerned with to other
learningpeople,
and minimize and sometimes scorn, have
been found to contribute to
and enjoy learning.
self-actualizing.
significant learning, knowledge
building, and skill development
To summarize, humanistic theory suggests the
following principles of learning:
• Focus on the learner’s desire for positive growth, subjective feelings, needs,
selfconcept, choices in life, and interpersonal relationships.
• The teacher’s role is to assess and encourage changes in the learner’s needs,
selfconcept, and feelings by providing support, freedom to choose, and
opportunities for spontaneity and creativity
Applying Learning Theories to Health Care
In practice, psychological learning theories can be used singly or in combination to help
nurses and other health professionals teach patients or themselves to acquire new
information and alter behavior. As an example, patients undergoing painful procedures are
first taught relaxation exercises (behaviorist) and while experiencing pain or discomfort are
encouraged to employ imagery, such as thinking about a favorite, beautiful place or
imagining the healthy cells gobbling up the unhealthy cells (cognitive). Staff members are
highly respectful, upbeat, and emotionally supportive of each patient (humanistic) Waiting
rooms and lounge areas for patients and their families are designed to be comfortable,
friendly, and pleasant to facilitate conversation and interaction, while support groups may
help patients and family members learn from one another about how to cope with illness
or disability and how to regulate their emotions so that their health is not further
compromised (social learning).
PSYCHODYNAMIC LEARNING THEORY
Although not typically treated as a learning theory, some of the constructs from
psychodynamic theory (based on the work of Sigmund Freud and his followers) have
significant implications for learning and changing behavior (Hilgard & Bower,1966; Slipp,
2000). Largely a theory of motivation that stresses emotions rather than cognition or
responses, the psychodynamic perspective emphasizes the importance of conscious and
unconscious forces in guiding behavior, personality conflicts, and the enduring effects of
childhood experiences. As Pullen (2002) points out, negative emotions are important to
recognize and assess in nurse–patient-physician–family interactions, and psychodynamic
theory can be helpful in this regard.
A central principle of this theory is that behavior may be conscious or unconscious
—that is, individuals may or may not be aware of their motivations and why they
feel, think, and act as they do. According to the psychodynamic view, the most
primitive source of inspiration comes from the id. It is based on libidinal energy (the
basic instincts, impulses, and desires humans are born with), which includes two
components: eros (the desire for pleasure and sex, sometimes called the “life
force”) and Thanatos (aggressive and destructive impulses, or death wish). Patients
who survive or die despite all predictions to the contrary provide illustrations of
such primitive motivations. The id, according to Freud, operates based on the
pleasure principle—to seek pleasure and avoid pain. For example, dry, dull lectures
given by nurse educators who go through the motions of the presentation without
much enthusiasm or emotion inspire few people (patients, staff, or students) to
listen to the information or heed the advice given. This does not mean, however,
that only pleasurable presentations are acceptable
The id (primitive drives) and superego (internalized societal values and standards,
or the conscience) are mediated by the ego, which operates on the basis of the
reality principle—rather than insisting on immediate gratification, people learn to
take the long road to pleasure and to weigh the choices or dilemmas in the conflict
between the id and the superego. Healthy ego (self) development, as emphasized
by Freud’s followers, is an important consideration in healthcare fields. For
example, patients with ego strength can cope with painful medical treatments
because they recognize the long-term value of enduring discomfort and pain to
achieve a positive outcome. Patients with weak ego development, in contrast, may
miss their appointments and treatments or engage in short-term pleasurable
activities that work against their healing and recovery. Helping patients develop ego
strength and adjust realistically to a changed body image or lifestyle brought about
by disease and medical interventions is a significant aspect of the learning and
healing process.
Health professionals also require personal ego strength to cope with the numerous
predicaments in the everyday practice of delivering care as they face conflicting
values, ethics, and demands. Professional burnout, for example, is rooted in an
overly idealized concept of the healthcare role and unrealistic expectations for the
self in performing the role. Malach-Pines (2000) notes that burnout may stem from
nurses’ childhood experiences with lack of control. When the ego is threatened, as
can easily occur in the healthcare setting, defense mechanisms may be employed to
protect the self. The short-term use of defense mechanisms is a way of coming to
grips with reality. The danger arises from the overuse or long-term reliance on
defense mechanisms, which allows individuals to avoid reality and may act as a
barrier to learning and transfer.
As an example of defense mechanisms in health This defense mechanism may contribute to the
care, Kübler-Ross (1969) points out that many reported tendency of oncologists to often ignore,
terminally ill patients’ initial reaction to being rather than address, the emotions that patients
told they have a severe threat to their health express during communication (Friedrichsen & Strang,
and well-being is to employ the defense 2003; Friedrichsen, Strang, & Carlsson, 2000; Pollak et
mechanism of denial. Patients typically find it al., 2007). One study found that oncologists, in
too overwhelming to process the information responding to patients expressing fear, more often
addressed the topic causing the anxiety rather than
that they are likely to die. Although most
addressing the emotion itself (Jennifer et al., 2009).
patients gradually accept the reality of their
Telford, Kralik, and Koch (2006) report that nurses may
illness, the dangers are that they may not seek strive to buttonhole terminally ill patients within a
treatment and care if they remain in denial. If denial–acceptance framework too quickly and, as a
their condition is contagious, they may not result, may not listen to patients as they attempt to
protect others against infection. In turn, a tell their stories and interpret their illness experiences.
common defense mechanism employed by Protecting the self (ego) by dehumanizing patients and
healthcare staff is to intellectualize the treating them as diseases and body parts rather than
significance of disease and death rather than to as whole individuals (with spiritual, emotional, and
deal with these issues realistically at an physical needs) is an occupational hazard for other
emotional level. health professionals.
For example, some staff members and patients feel an inordinate need to control the self, other people, and
certain social situations. This behavior may be rooted in their inability to resolve the crisis of trust versus mistrust
According
at the to the
earliest stage of life.psychodynamic
In working with these view, personal
individuals, difficulties
it is essential to buildarise andrelationship
a trusting learning and
is to
encourage them to gradually relinquish , past conflicts, especially during childhood, may interfere with the ability
limited when individuals become fixated or stuck at an earlier stage of personality
to learn or to transfer learning. What people resist talking about or learning—a process termed resistance is an
development.
indicator of underlyingTheyemotionalthendifficulties,
must work whichthrough their
must be dealt previously
with unresolved
for them to move crises to
ahead emotionally and
developFor
behaviorally. and mature
instance, emotionally.
if a young, pregnant teenager refuses to engage in a serious conversation about
sexuality (e.g., changes the subject, giggles, looks out into space, expresses anger), this behavior indicates that
she has underlying emotional conflicts that need to Be addressed.
One study explored psychodynamic sources of resistance among nursing students and examined how they engaged
with or resisted the learning process. A number of factors requiring consideration surfaced in this research,
including childhood struggles, a history of over adaptation, self-image, and learning climate (Gilmartin,
2000).Serious problems in miscommunication can occur in health care as a result of childhood learning
experiences. For example, some physicians and nurses may have had the childhood experience of standing
helplessly by watching someone they loved and once depended on endure disease, suffering, and death. Although
they could do little as children to improve the situation, they may be compensating for their childhood feelings of
helplessness and dependency as adults by devoting their careers to fending off and fighting disease and death.
These motivations, however, may not serve them well as they attempt to care for, communicate with, and educate
patients who are dying and their families.
The concept of transfer has special meaning to psychodynamic theorists.
Transference occurs when individuals project their feelings, conflicts, and reactions
—especially those developed during childhood with significant others such as
parents—onto authority figures and other individuals in their lives. The danger is
that the relationship between the health professional and the patient may become
distorted and unrealistic because of the biases inherent in the transference
reaction. For example, because patients are sick, they may feel helpless and
dependent and then regress to an earlier stage in life when they relied on their
parents for help and support. Their childhood feelings and relationship with a
parent—for better or worse may be transferred to medical professionals or
physician taking care of them. While sometimes flattering, the love and
dependency that patients feel may operate against the autonomy and
independence they need to get back on their feet. A particular patient may also
remind a staff member of someone from his past, creating a situation of
countertransference.
The psychodynamic perspective is
helpful in more fully understanding
learning and teaching, however,
because it highlights a number of
underlying considerations and
subtleties in the process, such as
motivations, emotional development,
and conflicts in learning, and focuses
on identifying problems in learning or
with the teacher-learner relationship.
Principles of Learning
1. Focusing 6. Imitation
2. Organization 7. Active participation
3. Repetition 8. Motivation
4. Association 9. Individual styles
6. Learner control 10. Spacing
Laws of learning By 4.) Law of primacy
Things learned first create a strong
Q2. In what factors our dispositional factors: beliefs, expectations, values, intentions, social roles, emotional
makeup and biological and genetic influences?
Q3. What factors our social, political and cultural influences and personal learning experiences?
Q5. In what theory continues to be considered useful in nursing practice for the delivery of health care?