Critical Appraisal

ANALYSIS OF THE KEY FACTORS

AFFECTING THE FUTURE OF MEDICAL
EDUCATION DISCIPLINE IN 2025 BASED ON
STEPV MODEL: A QUALITATIVE STUDY

Faghihi A., et al. Advances in Medical Education and Practice 2020:11 191–201
 HELLO!

Achcia Thema Maliny | Mira Ayu Dian Raharjo | Rifda Savirani

 #1

IS THERE CONGRUITY BETWEEN THE

STATED PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVE
AND THE RESEARCH METHODOLOGY?

Yes.
There is congruity beetween
Yes the stated philosopical perspective (STEPV Model has
been used to identify and categorized key factor
affecting future med. Education discipline) and
No the research methodology (Qualitative study)

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #2

IS THERE CONGRUITY BETWEEN THE

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY AND THE
RESEARCH QUESTION OR OBJECTIVES?

Yes.
Yes There is congruity between the research methodology
(qualitative study) and the research objective (the aimed ti
identify key factor of affecting the future of the discipline
No from the viewpoint of stakeholders)

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #3

IS THERE CONGRUITY BETWEEN THE

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY AND THE
METHODS USED TO COLLECT DATA?
Yes
Yes.
There is congruity beetween
the research methodology (Qualitative approach based on
constructivist paradigm) study) and the methods used to
collect data ( data were collected through semi-structured
interview and analyzed using directed content analysis)

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #4
IS THERE CONGRUITY BETWEEN THE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY AND THE
REPRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS OF
DATA?
Yes.
There is congruity beetween
the research methodology (Qualitative approach based on
constructivist paradigm) study) and the presentation and
analysis of data

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #5

IS THERE CONGRUITY BETWEEN THE

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY AND THE
INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS?

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #6

IS THERE A STATEMENT LOCATING THE

RESEARCHER CULTURALLY OR
THEORETICALLY?

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #7
IS THE INFLUENCE OF THE RESEARCHER
ON THE RESEARCH, AND VICE- VERSA,
ADDRESSED?

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #8

ARE PARTICIPANTS, AND THEIR VOICES,

ADEQUATELY REPRESENTED?

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #9
IS THE RESEARCH ETHICAL ACCORDING TO
CURRENT CRITERIA OR, FOR RECENT STUDIES,
AND IS THERE EVIDENCE OF ETHICAL
APPROVAL BY AN APPROPRIATE BODY?

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 #10

DO THE CONCLUSIONS DRAWN IN THE

RESEARCH REPORT FLOW FROM THE
ANALYSIS, OR INTERPRETATION, OF THE
DATA?

Yes

No

Unclear

Not Applicable
 Overall Appraisal

INCLUDE EXCLUDE SEEK FURTHER

INFO
Thank You For Your Attention

Any Question?