The document discusses the debate over whether the Cry of Balintawak or Cry of Pugadlawin started the Philippine Revolution. It lists arguments favoring each location, including references to historical texts and accounts that mention meetings in Balintawak on August 24-26 or Pugadlawin on August 23 to plan the revolution. The document concludes by noting orders from Bonifacio for attacks on Manila starting August 29-30.
The document discusses the debate over whether the Cry of Balintawak or Cry of Pugadlawin started the Philippine Revolution. It lists arguments favoring each location, including references to historical texts and accounts that mention meetings in Balintawak on August 24-26 or Pugadlawin on August 23 to plan the revolution. The document concludes by noting orders from Bonifacio for attacks on Manila starting August 29-30.
The document discusses the debate over whether the Cry of Balintawak or Cry of Pugadlawin started the Philippine Revolution. It lists arguments favoring each location, including references to historical texts and accounts that mention meetings in Balintawak on August 24-26 or Pugadlawin on August 23 to plan the revolution. The document concludes by noting orders from Bonifacio for attacks on Manila starting August 29-30.
‘Revolt of the Masses’ (1956) • Guillermo Masangkay’s Account – meeting at Apolonio Samsom’s house in Caloocan, dated August 24. • Renato Constantino’s Book ‘The Philippines: A Past Revisited’ – the place of the meeting was in the yard of Melchora Adatedquino’s son in Pugadlawin, August 23. ARGUMENTS FAV O R I N G B A L I N TAWA K
• Gregorio Zaide’s History of
the Filipino People – the Katipuneros had an emergency meeting in Balintawak, dated August 26. • Emilio Aguinaldo’s Memoir – on August 22, the Magdalo Faction received a letter from Supremo Ander Bonifacio providing that a meeting shall be held in Balintawak on August 24. Aguinaldo sent Domingo Orcollo and Crispulo Aguinaldo as representatives of the Magdalo Faction. • Accounts of Lt. Olegario Diaz • Orders of Bonifacio – August 29 shall be the start of the revolution, where they will attack Manila. • Blair and Robertson’s ‘The Philippine Islands’ Narration – the Katipunan shall attack Bulakan, Manila, and Cavite on August 30.