Professional Documents
Culture Documents
According to the United Nations 2/3 countries now call themselves Liberal state should be democratic Liberalism Core ideas KO
‘liberal democracies’(x7 since 1945) Laws based on natural rights – life, liberty, property
Pervasive ideology: Associated with both right + left Oldest of the Limited government – entrenched constitution and
three core ideologies - constrained by strong laws
Origins in Reformation, Enlightenment. Separation of powers with 3 branches that should control Core Ideas of Liberalism:
each others powers: legislature, executive and judiciary State methods:
Belief in reason over faith, promoted debate + inquiry, individuals have
Foundational equality – everyone born with same natural
free will and best judge of own interests. Move away from ‘divine right rights. Rejection of ‘traditional’ state
of kings’ and acceptance of the governed towards logic + rational
thinking. Government by consent (of the governed)
Locke: “Gov should always be the servant, not
Core Ideas of Liberalism: Core Ideas of Liberalism: Core Ideas of Liberalism: the master of the people”. Social contract
Human Nature Society Economy Promotion of natural rights ensuring they
John Locke and refined by later thinkers would be more safely + easily exercised than in a
As well as shaping its view of society Liberalism’s state of native.
(John Stuart Mill) Locke believed ‘natural society’ with
devotion to private property informs approach
Rejected Medieval notion of mankind as natural laws + natural rights precedes the Promotion of tolerance. Voltaire: “I detest
to the economy.
flawed (and only God can forgive.) state.
what you say but will defend unto the death your
“Right to life, liberty + the pursuit of right to say it”. John Stuart Mill: State should
Liberal thinkers had a more optimistic view happiness” Property ‘natural right’ inevitable that liberals tolerate all actions + opinions unless shown to
of Human Nature, huge capacity to bring should support capitalism
about progress, ability to forge human violate the harm principle
Emphasis on the individual
happiness. Mid C19th thinker John Stuart Mill Liberal economist Adam Smith (Wealth of Meritocracy – Political power should be exercised
Guided by reason + rationalism(through only by those who show themselves worthy of it.
believed main purpose of civilised society Nations 1776) Liberalism strongly associated
debate + discussion of ideas + opinions)
is to facilitate individualism. Individuals are with private enterprise + private ownership of
Equality of opportunity All individuals are born
Individuals have capacity to ‘plan’ own rational in their pursuit of self-interest the economy (Capitalism = Economic
equal (Foundational equality)
future + effect their outcome. Human nature seeks freedom from dependency on Liberalisation)
All individuals have equal opportunity to develop
allows us to shape our own destiny’. others.
their potential + achieve control of their own
Problems are merely challenges awaiting Linked with positive view of human nature:
lives. If an individual fails to achieve their
reasoned solutions & reasoned discussion Liberals believe the default setting of any
Free market economics invisible hand of potential must assume total responsibility for
leads to consensus. society is the focus on individual freedom
market forces wealth ‘trickled down’ to this failure.
any society, which seeks to deny this is
For liberals the natural condition of human everyone.
dysfunctional - The right to property is an Justice (linked to above) State should embody justice
nature is one of self-aware individuals, living important, tangible, expression of an Reflects optimistic tone of Liberalism’s core + treat individuals fairly.
in peace, harmony + mutual understanding. individual within society. values.
Classic liberalism Modern/New liberalism
Four distinctive features Mill Left Q’s unanswered esp. what is the precise nature of liberty? In order to liberate an
1. Revolutionary potential individual’s potential was it REALLY enough to just leave them alone? (negative freedom)
GovT by consent of people new revolutionary Led modern liberal thinkers to produce a new + radical interpretation of what liberty involved which in turn
thinking / associated with Glorious Revolution (1688) + led to very different form of liberalism with a number of distinguishing characteristics.
American War of Independence+ Constitution (1787) Positive Freedom/ Social Justice
Rationalism (reason + logic) – Mary Wollstonecraft
(1759-97) argued that the treatment of women was an Individuals increasingly subject to social – economic forces beyond their control. So social justice as well as
affront to reason argued individuals (men + women) legal justice now required if individuals were to fulfil their potential.
required a formal education to realize powers of - Positive Freedom More cooperative + altruistic concept – “Help other to help themselves”.
reason.
New Liberals assessed that individuals had to be enabled in order for them to be free from socio-economic
2. Negative Liberty Strands of problems (e.g. poor health care, unemployment, lack of education) + for social justice to be secured.
Freedom involves individuals being left alone to pursue
their destiny. (absence of restraint)
Liberalism Enlarged + Enabling State - Modern Liberalism has no qualms about justifying a substantial extension of
the state in the name of individual liberty (strongly linked to collectivism)
Individuals are naturally free until something or Modern Liberals (such as John Rawls) argued only an enlarged state could guarantee the equality of
someone put a brake on their actions.
Potentially autonomous + self-reliant this idea
You MUST opportunity to enable individual freedom.
would have consequences for both size of state + interweave Want to improve the lot of society least fortunate remained indifferent to inequality of outcome. (see it as
economics.
with the an inevitable side effect of individual freedom Key difference with socialism)
3. Minimal State
Governments should be limited in terms of both how
key Most important
they could act + what they could do. thinkers! Completing the link between liberal core values and universal adult suffrage. Liberal PM oversaw the
Linked with core belief of the dispersal of political Representation of the Act (1918) giving votes to the working class and (most) women. Since 1945 they have
power (checks + balances.) championed the lowering of the voting age. (First to 18 in 19169 and more recently to 16)
Social Liberalism.
4. Laissez-Faire Capitalism (‘Let it happen’) Attempt to update classical liberalism stress on tolerance (esp. of minorities)
Adam Smith – Wealth of Nations (1776) Capitalism, Mid C20th onwards – modern liberalism strongly linked with calls for greater racial + sexual toleration).Belief
via ‘invisible hand’ of market forces had limitless
that too many individuals held back due to innate factors (ethnicity/gender)
capacity to enrich society+ those within it state should
pursue a ‘free-trade’ economy by ending
Solution further legislation, sometimes ‘positive discrimination’ e.g. Race Relations Act/ Sex Discrimination
protectionism via duties and tariffs. These ideas were
radical in 1776 but became widespread in following Act. (1970’s)
century. Betty Friedan (1921-2006) Insisted such reforms consistent with Liberal tradition.
Classical- Freedom is the Absence of Rules Modern- Freedom is achieving self
realisation.
Neo Liberalism:
State The role of the state is State Enabling state, state
This is an important
security, fragmented power,
constitutionalism, minimal
intervention to support
weaker groups, welfare,
development which developed
state, little regulation, some
representational democracy.
large government,
democratic.
in the late 20th century and
Society Collection of individuals, Society Society needs support to be
sought to reconnect liberalism
atomistic, self reliant, self
determination, no government
fulfilled, individuals need
support from a community to
with its classical past. Hayek is
intervention except harm
principle. Belief in equality of
flourish, self reliant to an
extent. Belief in equality of
the key economic thinker of this
opportunity. opportunity but also period arguing for free markets,
supporting weaker groups to
achieve. small government, and self
Economy Private property, free trade,
capitalism, Laissez – faire, no
Economy Private property, free trade,
capitalism, regulated by the
reliance. Neo liberalism
state intervention. government, managed responded to the large
economy to support
employment, international governments of the social
trade agreements.
Wollstonecraft Friedan
Mill Mill
Liberalism Timeline:
Modern Neo
Classical Liberalism Liberalism Liberalism
Human frailty and fallibility Disciplinary role – provide order, security Tradition – Oakeshott – ‘Just as a plant’s new Noblesse oblige - The duty of the wealthy and
Human nature is fixed and constant and authority (Whereas Lib and Soc see leaves are connected to, and dependent on and privileged to look after those less fortunate
Hobbes ‘nasty, brutish and short’ But he state as serving ‘progressive’ roles) explained by the plants roots, so a society’s
does allow for a cold rationalism which puts present stems from its past’ Anti-permissiveness - A rejection of permissiveness,
him close to Liberalism Without order no liberty (Hobbes) which is the belief that people should make their
Thus Burke is father of conservatism – man Property – Those with property have a stake in own moral choices, suggesting there is no objective
The State precedes Society (Libs see it the society and a link to its roots. New Right Tories
cannot plan a near-perfect society right and wrong
other way) more zealous about property.
Burke does not think humans are as ‘brutish’
as Hobbes alleged; fallible yes, terrible no. Organic origins of the State (Not pro- Laissez-faire- A preference towards minimal
Neo-Liberals reject hierarchy and paternalism
Plus Burke thinks humans are capable of written constitution) government intervention in business and the state
(interfering in lives even if for good e.g seatbelts
kindness and altruism (selfless concern for
the welfare of others). And he thinks Hierarchical structure (Burke) Empiricism -The idea that knowledge comes from
humans are naturally communal (Hobbes Core ideas of conservatism real experience and not from abstract theories
Nation states Economy
says they are ruthlessly individualistic.)
Oakeshott – life without laws would be New Right paradox – to strengthen the Conservative defend inequality. Burke supported Human imperfection – belief that humans are
‘noisy, foolish and flawed’ Nation state by ‘rolling back its frontiers’. Adam Smith – Laissez-Faire. morally, intellectually and psychologically flawed and
Rand/Nozick highlighted Human nature’s BUT One-Nation Tories support some not to be trusted
Explained by Rand (‘when the state
yearning for freedom ‘freedom loving pack intervention as this will lead to order and
becomes flabby, it also becomes feeble’)
animals’ (Nozick) So state still needed – not stability. Free markets are tempered by state Change to conserve – adapt as society changes to
and Nozick – if state is burdened by
Anarchists intervention (Keynesian) avoid revolution. Don’t change for something new
Nationalisation and welfare it is harder for New Right – Free markets –Thatcherism,
Hobbes and New Right = Human nature
driven by self-interest but must be it to focus on its ‘true’ function of order Friedman and Hayek Authoritarian – those in higher positions of society
constrained to provide peace and stability and security best placed to make decisions on society's behalf
Neo liberalism
Traditional conservatism
Economics – Laissez-Faire. Adam Smith,
Very authoritarian. Purpose was to protect
Strands of Conservatism
Friedman, Hayek, Nozick, Thatcher
social order (Burke) Privatisation
Organic Friedman (Monetarism) control inflation by You MUST interweave
Noblese Oblige – nobility and privilege controlling money supply – cuts in public with the key thinkers!
bring with them social responsibilities , spending
mostly the duty and obligation to care for Welfare state created ‘dependency culture’
those less fortunate Nozick – welfare itself was a violation of
Soft paternalism property rights
Cut taxes (Tax Payers’ Alliance!)
‘Trickle-down’ economics Neo-conservatism
One nation conservatism
Atomistic individualism
Against Councils – pro localism and interest Reaction to social changes (1960s 1970s.)
Paternalistic conservativism. (Disraeli)
groups (Academies) Anti-permissiveness as this challenges
Cameron’s Big Society
authority and breaks down morality and
Bring together individualism and
New right structure and order
collectivism and respond to capitalism
Social Authoritarians – limited but strong
Organic society and a rejection of laissez-
A mix of reactionary and radical state in relation to law and order
faire economics for Keynesianism
Roll back the state but also (Neo-Cons) Tax breaks for ‘families’
Paternalism (Noblesse Oblige)
importance of order and hierarchy Oppose multiculturalism and immigration
Patriotism and tradition
New Right Cons believe that individual as it weakens national unity and patriotism
Cameron (Compassionate conservative)
must be free from state interference but Thatcher’s ‘Victorian values’
and May (shared society)
humans behaviour must be restricted by
family, nation and morality
New Right thinking 1970s and 1980s.
What type do we Profoundly different from other forms of
have today??!!! conservativism as it is clearly ideological
One Nation Conservatism –The state must New Right Conservatism- everyone must
support the working classes. stand on their own two feet.
State Support idea of those “born to State Strong police, strong military,
Burke defined traditional
rule” hierarchy, paternalism, meritocratic, hostile to conservatism in response to the
strong military, strong police, aristocratic rule, reject
order is key, grow the state if hierarchy. Property owning liberal challenge of the French
it’s pragmatic. Tradition is key. Republican
important. Royalist Revolution.
Society Society is organic, naturally a Society Atomistic, individualistic,
class system, built of small meritocracy, no welfare,
communities such as families, individual responsibility,
importance on tradition, and selfish approach, reject
continuity, paternalism, inherited class systems in
importance of nation state. favour of disruptive social In response to industrialisation and the rise of
Judeo Christian beliefs mobility.
socialism and the extension of the franchise
Economy ONC are suspicious of free Economy The new right see the free
market economics which they market as a positive, wealth
conservatives moved to ONC to bring the
see as unpredictable and generating, and problem working classes on board. This meant an appeal
unstable, globalisation is a solving economy. Low
threat to the nation state; free taxation, low regulation, no to nationalism and to supporting the poor more.
market economics can create protectionism or tariffs. Hayek
too much inequality and and Adam smith approach.
breakdown the social fabric.
Higher taxes, more
redistribution, more regulation.
Human
Nature
Human nature is fixed and
imperfect. It is negative and
Human
Nature
The new right see human
nature as more positive, that if
Following a period of strong state growth under
people without regulation will “unleashed” individuals will the socialist government during the 1950s and
act aggressively, violently, and achieve their aims, be self
selfishly. Socialism and reliant, and selfish in a 70s conservatism reconnected with its past and
liberalism over estimate human positive wealth acquiring way.
potential.
with classical liberalism to usher in a more
Key Hobbes Key Thinkers Rand
economically dynamic policy keeping a strong
Thinkers focus on family values.
Burke Nozick
Oakeshott Oakeshott
Core Ideas of Socialism: Core ideas of Socialism:
State Socialism Core ideas KO
Economy
Key socialist thinkers from Marx/Engels onwards argued that social Socialists believe that without a strong state it will be
class is determined by economic system underpinning society. impossible to bring about a fairer and more equal society (in Core Ideas of Socialism:
short term at least)
Recognise the problems of economic system based on private property Society
Some socialists (Marxists and Orthodox Communists) see this
and capitalism, rather than common ownership. a temporary and that the state will eventually ‘wither away’
(Marx – ‘the end of history’) For socialists, individuals are the product of the
Free market capitalism encourages competitiveness and ruthless society into which they were born
BUT for the foreseeable future a strong state is essential-
egotism and generates huge inequalities of outcome so…. They seek to However they reject the idea of a monarchical state ,a
rectify the problems caused by capitalism Socialist argue that if society can be improved there
theocratic state or an aristocratic state.
will be a corresponding improvement in the
Greater workers’ control in employment prospects of its individuals
Socialists advocate a state where political power and
‘Redistribution doctrine’ → Politics of Robin Hood – taking from the economic power has been redistributed and decision making Argue that an individual’s status and prospects are
rich giving to the poor reflects the principle of equality and empowerment of the shaped by the social class into which they are born.
people i.e. democracy?
Rejection of laissez faire capitalism Demand greater collectivism However between socialists there are still significant → Many key thinkers (Marx, Antony Crossland)
Economic Collectivism differences about the structure of ideal state, its extent and noted that society’s classes tend to be profoundly
how it emerges unequal in terms of power and influence
Progressive taxation so rich contribute much more than poor
Certain sections of society will have more
•Progressive public spending state uses economic resources to Core Ideas of Socialism: opportunities to exploit their potential than others.
enhance the less fortunate elements e.g. state benefits for Human Nature Seek a narrowing of the gap between Society’s
unemployed or elderly
poorer and richer classes
•Extensive public services e.g. healthcare and education Optimistic view (as with Liberalism)
Socialists contest that to have equality of
•Extensive state regulation of capitalism e.g. legal minimum wage, Liberals believe individuals are self -reliant and self sufficient opportunity there must first be greater equality of
equal pay legislation outcome. irrespective of character, ability and
Socialists believe individuals are naturally co-operative, generous intelligence an individual born into working class
•State/Common ownership recommended when private enterprise is and altruistic background will have fewer opportunities than a
seen to fail parts of the economy e.g. post war nationalisation of ↓ similar individual born into a higher class
industries – coal, iron and steel. Naturally seek solidarity, fraternity and comradeship – John Donne background.
(1571 – 1631) ‘no man is an island’
Primary Aim is redistribution of a society’s wealth and resources
until a society has greater equality of outcomes
Other benefits is society seen as more co-operative society, with See human nature as malleable rather than fixed at birth → believe society will continue to lack fraternity, co-operation
greater social justice human nature can be adjusted → ensuring that men and women and solidarity and instead foster greed, envy,
fulfil their true potential whilst contributing to a more co-operative resentment and division.
community
Revolutionary/classic:
Origins of: Marx and Engels - capitalism must disappear before socialism and then
Similarities with Liberalism
communism could be established.
Optimistic view of human nature
Belief in reason over faith Revolutionary Socialism - Belief in Revolution. Agreed when capitalism
Progressive - challenge Status Quo became unsustainable it was necessary to ‘smash’ capitalism via revolutionary
Desire to liberate human being from oppression violence. Strands of Socialism
Belief in fundamental equality and equality of opportunity
Reject ‘traditional state’ (Divine Right of Kings Insisted that new economy, new stage must be forged by revolution - lead to
Reject anarchism (state important to secure freedom and equality) ‘Dictatorship of the Proletariat’ which would pave way for stateless communist You MUST interweave
HOWEVER they do not share the Liberal belief in private property society based on common ownership represent the peak of human with the key thinkers!
as a natural right. achievement and ‘the end of history’
Associated with Fabian Society & bourgeois intellectuals - GB Shaw, Therefore for most fundamental socialists today, Rosa Luxemburg’s ideas are a
Sidney and Beatrice Webb. more compelling brand of revolutionary socialism.
Vital to the development of the Labour Party – Clause IV of 1918
constitution – need to secure “common ownership of the means of
Third way:
production”
Associated with ‘New Labour’ governments of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown in the UK – emerged in the 1990s
Rejection of ‘big bang’ revolutionary change - For Fabians the
mayhem associated with revolutions did not seem the ideal starting
Anthony Giddens - widely credited as the main author of Third Way socialism
point for a bright and orderly future - believed the extension of
- desire to ‘triangulate’ social democracy’s wish for more equality within capitalist economy which was less Keynesian and more
suffrage in late 19th Century had facilitated a more orderly, election
neo-liberal
based progression towards a post-capitalist society.
-Aimed to reconcile task of socialist parties seeking office (Labour in the UK) with an electorate which was increasingly propertied,
suburban and individualist.
“Inevitability of gradualism” - Belief that democratically elected
- Urged modern ‘leftist’ to go with the flow by encouraging further privatisation and deregulations – best way to boost economic
socialist governments would steadily transform society via existing
growth and therefore tax revenue – which could increase government spending in the name of greater equality.
parliamentary system, gradually replacing a society based on
private ownership with one based on common ownership and
Most important (and controversial) aspect was revised attitude to equality of outcome
public control.
• Belief – greater equality of opportunity probably required more, not less, inequality of outcome
Fundamental Socialism (Capitalism must be Revisionist Socialism (Capitalism must be
destroyed) reformed)
Socialism was developed in response to the dire working conditions of the industrial revolution. At
Marxism, Leninism, Stalinism, Democratic Social Democracy, Third way that time it seemed that there was no legitimate way for the workers to change their condition
centrism, democratic socialism.
because the franchise had not been extended. This led the thinkers to adopt a more radial
State The state is authoritarian, State State should intervene to
focusing on dictatorship of the support weaker groups, work revolutionarily approach.
proletariat, capitalist state with capitalist systems,
should be destroyed. New democratic, and change the
collectivised state. constitution not revolution.
Society Society is the core determiner Society Society needs to be changed In 1917 The Russian Revolution took place which brought Lenin and the Bolsheviks to power.
of our personality and human slowly through democracy and
nature, society should be evolution. Equality can be
They believed in accelerated socialism and set about rapid and forced changes in Russia. Lenin was
revolutionary, requiring a achieved by slowly through very dictatorial. In 1924 Stalin took over brining in socialist nationalism and further entrenching the
dictatorship of the proletariat to redistribution and sharing
force through change, equality wealth more equally. Equality authoritarian nature of socialism.
of outcome of outcome to some extent.
Human HN is plastic a malleable by Human Everything as fundamental, With the fall of the USSR in 1991 socialism in its more radical form had been totally
Nature society, it is therefore Nature expect they believe human
changeable. HN is social, nature can flourish in a
discredited. Socialists now sought to embrace the free market economy as the only way to create
altruistic, selfless, and co- capitalistic society and is not enough money to run public services. This was called the third way under Tony Blair. Increasingly
operative. HN can be easily corrupted by it, but can adapt
corrupted by capitalism and capitalism.
with Corbyn democratic socialist ideas are returning to mainstream politics.
lead to false conscious.