Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Key choices
generalizability with respect to populations
realism for the participants
McGrath, 1982
Methodological Tradeoffs
Large sample surveys can maximize generalizability
Laboratory Experiments can maximize precision of
control
Field experiments can maximize realism
Qualitative Methods can maximize depth of
understanding ( the “why”)
“Triangulation” or multiple methods maximize overall
validity of results
Replication of results in different settings provides
generalizability
Questionnaire Data (1993- 1996
completed project)
Total Responses (sometimes partial):
Virtual Classroom + video: 698
VC + FtF: 463
No VC: 268
Question Form: Please compare online
classes to your previous experiences with
“face to face” college - level courses. To
what extent do you agree with the following
statements...
14
Taking Online Classes is More
Convenient (73% agree)
37
40 36
35
30
25
Percentage
17
(%)
20
15
10 7
4
5
0
Strongly A. Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly D.
N = 624
15
Having the computerized conferencing system available
provided better access to the professor(s). (65% agree)
42
45
40
35 29
30
Percentage
25
(%)
17
20
15
8
10 4
5
0
Strongly A. Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly D.
16
Did use of the system increase the quality
of your education? (58% agree; +22%
Same)
30 27
25 22
19
20
Percentage
(%)
15 12
10 7 7
5
5
0
1 2 3 Unsure 5 6 7
17
“Virtual Classroom Overall”
Index Items included:
1. VC Increases Quality
2. Better learning
3. Learned More
4. Would not take another VC
5. Would have gotten more from a
traditional class
6. VC increases efficiency of learning
Chronbach’s Alpha = .85
18
Correlations with VC Overall
(Pearson’s)
All significant at least at .01 level;
n= about 523
Collaboration Index .30
Better Access to Professor .46
Felt more involved in taking active
part .54
19
Conclusions based on field trials
LNs DO tend to increase access to educational
opportunities, efficiency (speed of completion)
of the degree, and quality of educational
experience as subjectively reported
This is conditional on a number of factors, including active
participation by the student, and communicating/
collaborating with classmates
No Significant Differences in Course Grades
between traditional and LN sections
20
Replication: Similar results from
U. of Illinois, Drexel, SUNY, U. of Central
Florida, etc.
E.g. Drexel: 95% felt they had better access to Prof
Vast majority of students report that LN courses
are “better” in terms of access and learning
Student evaluations strongly correlated with
amount on online interaction with professor and
with other students
BUT:
In terms of the relationship between
Collaborative Learning and the effectiveness
of LNs, “correlation is not causation”
Triangulation: One course in the project,
Computers and Society, was selected for a field
experiment
Effects of Computer-Mediated Communication on
Learning, Performance and Satisfaction: A
Comparison of Groups and Individuals Solving
Ethical Scenarios, A thesis by: Raquel Benbunan
TASK SELECTION RESEARCH METHODS
23
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
Distribution of Subjects across Conditions
MANUAL ONLINE
24
Mean Final exam scores on ethics,
(GPA as covariant)
Manual On-line
72.90 67.42
25
Length of the Reports
Mean Words by
Condition
Manual Online