Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.huawei.com
【 Object 】
Technical Service Engineer
【 Content 】
Chapter 1. Technology comparison of LTE TDD/FDD
Chapter 2. Hardware comparison of LTE TDD/FDD
Chapter 3. Data configuration comparison of LTE TDD/FDD
PDCP
The main difference lies in the physical layer.
RLC
MAC
Scalable bandwidth
1.4M,3M,5M,10M,15M,20M 1.4M,3M,5M,10M,15M,20M
configuration
DL:OFDM DL:OFDM
Multi-access
UL:SC-FDMA UL:SC-FDMA
Power Control Combination of open loop & closed loop Combination of open loop & closed loop
Supports a maximum speed of 350 km/h Supports a maximum speed of 350 km/h
Mobility
Supports inter/intra-RAT handovers Supports inter/intra-RAT handovers
Voice service
CSFB/SRVCC CSFB/SRVCC
solution
Synchronization The position of PSS/SSS in LTE TDD are different from those in LTE FDD
Require a T/R transistor with 1.5dB insertion Require a duplexer with 1dB
RRU
loss and delay insertion loss
Beamforming Support (based on channel reciprocity) Not support (no channel reciprocity)
DL: Both UE-specific and cell-specific RS DL: only cell-specific RS applied now
Reference supported UL: both DMRS and SRS
Signal UL: both DMRS and SRS supported.SRS supported.SRS is carried on data sub-
can be carried on UpPTS frame.
MIMO Mode Support Mode 1~8 Support Mode 1~8
Different spectrums are used in DL
and UL, the guard bandwidth can
Strict synchronization is required in the
Interference avoid the interference,
whole network.
synchronization requirement is not
strict.
2.3/2.6G: global main frequency band for LTE TDD, band 38/40; including Japan, Saudi Arabia,
India, South Africa, China and so on.
Band42 and 43 is added in R10, mainly used in U.K and Spain.
Bandwidth of Band 42-44 are more than 100M, which can deploy eRelay.
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD. Huawei Confidential Page 10
Duplex
TDD FDD
Guard
Period
Time Time
Downlink Uplink Downlink Downlink/Uplink
Guard
Frequency
band
Frequency Frequency
Downlink/Uplink Downlink Uplink
TDD
1 ms
#0 #2 #3 #4 #5 #7 #8 #9
Frame type 2 defined by 3GPP is for LTE TDD. Each 10ms frame is divided into two 5ms
half-frames. Each half-frame is consist of 4 data subframes and 1 special subframe.
A special sub-frame consists of the downlink pilot timeslot (DwPTS), GP, and uplink pilot
timeslot (UpPTS). The total length of DwPTS, GP, and UpPTS is 1 ms.
One radio frame, Tf = 307200Ts = 10 ms
One slot, Tslot = 15360Ts = 0.5 ms
FDD
#0 #1 #2 #3 #18 #19
One subframe
Frame type 1 defined by 3GPP is for LTE FDD . Each 10ms frame is divided into two 5ms
half-frames.
Each subframe consist of 2 time slot with 0.5ms.
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD. Huawei Confidential Page 12
Uplink-Downlink Subframe Configurations
in LTE TDD
Configur UL : Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra Subfra
ation DL me #0 me #1 me #2 me #3 me #4 me #5 me #6 me #7 me #8 me #9
100
90
90 0 3:1 DL S UL UL UL DL S UL UL UL
80
70 1 2:2 DL S UL UL DL DL S UL UL DL
70
Throughput(%)
60 DL
50 50
UL 2 1:3 DL S UL DL DL DL S UL DL DL
50
40
30 3 1:2 DL S UL UL UL DL DL DL DL DL
30
20
10 4 2:7 DL S UL UL DL DL DL DL DL DL
10
0 5 1:8 DL S UL DL DL DL DL DL DL DL
Download Video Call Online Game
6 5:3 DL S UL UL UL DL S UL UL DL
The advantages of FDD are typically observed in situations where the uplink and downlink data
transmissions are symmetrical (such as voice call), which means uplink-downlink subframe configuration
for LTE FDD is only one: 1:1.
On the contrary, uplink and downlink data transmissions in LTE TDD are unsymmetrical, which is better at
reallocating traffic than LTE FDD such as Internet or other data centric services.
There are totally 7 uplink-downlink subframe configurations defined in 3GPP. Carrier can select proper
configuration based on traffic type.
So far, Huawei eNodeB support configuration 0, 1, 2 and 5.
3 11 2
2 OFDM symbol used for Short RACH or
Sounding RS
4 12 1
8 11 1
Interference
At eNB
DL UL DL
+ =
ARQ
FEC: Forward Error Correction. The transmitter adds ‘check bits’ or redundant bits to the data stream
and coded into the data in a very special way, which allows for efficient error correction by the
receiver. Because FEC does not require handshaking between transmitter and receiver, and that
means if there is an error, the receiver can not inform transmitter, so reliability of FEC is low.
ARQ: Automatic Repeat reQuest. When receiver detects an error in a packet, it automatically
requests the transmitter to resend the packet. So the efficiency of ARQ may be low.
HARQ: Hybrid Automatic Repeat reQuest. It’s an effective combination of ARQ and FEC. Both
reliability and efficiency is high.
Disadvantages:
Interval is not fixed, which makes the algorithm much more complex.
The max interval for DL HARQ is 13 TTI, which increases HARQ process RTT greatly and
challenges the storage capacity of UE’s physical layer.
FDD
Information carried on PSS/SSS is same for both LTE TDD and LTE FDD.
The location of PSS and SSS is different in LTE TDD and LTE FDD frame.
For FDD, the PSS neighbors SSS. The PSS is transmitted in the last symbol of sub-frame #0 and #5.
the SSS is transmitted in the next to the last OFDM symbol of sub-frame #0 and #5.
For TDD, there are 2 OFDM symbol between PSS and SSS. The PSS is transmitted in the first
symbol of DwPTS and the SSS is transmitted in the last symbol of sub-frame #0 in each 5ms radio half
frame.
Since the relative position of the PSS/SSS is different for TDD and FDD the UE can identify whether
the cell is FDD or TDD in the cell search.
Interferers
Desired Signal
AAS calculates the weight of beam shaping based on the reliable estimation of channel.
For FDD, DL channel estimation from UE must feedback to eNodeB rapidly. When UE
moves at a high speed, signal cost of channel estimation is great for the channel changes
fast. Besides, there is no guarantee for the channel estimation because of UE feedback
delay.
For TDD, eNodeB can use the UL channel estimation as DL channel estimation for the
channel reciprocity.
Therefore, AAS is more suitable for LTE TDD.
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD. Huawei Confidential Page 19
Beamforming
Beamforming
Beamformingscheme
schemeisismainly
mainlybased
basedon
onanan
Cell B
adaptive beam patterns that acts to make the
adaptive beam patterns that acts to make the
strongest
strongestpoint
pointofofmain-lobe
main-lobeofofthe
thesystem
system
output
output always be toward the directionofofthe
always be toward the direction the
Cell A expected UE.
expected UE.
Beamforming
Beamformingutilize
utilizechannel
channelstate
stateinformation
information
Cell C
totoachieve array processing SINR gain.
achieve array processing SINR gain.
Transmit antenna
(narrow antenna separation) Channel
Channelstate
stateinformation
informationmainly
mainlyinclude:
include:
RB#NRB Fast fading channel coefficient
Fast fading channel coefficient
Transmitted
data
RB#1 Direction
Directionofofarrival
arrival(DoA)
(DoA)ofofsignal
signal
Packet frame CQI information
CQI information
generation
……
Channel
Channelstate
stateinformation
informationcancanbe
beobtained
obtainedbyby
Antenna weight
UE different way, including:
different way, including:
RF circuitry Antenna weight DOA
Feedback
Feedbackfrom
fromreceiver
receiver
calibration controller estimation Estimation
Estimation fromreverse
from reverselink
linkassuming
assuming
Transmitter channel reciprocity
channel reciprocity
beam-forming
TDD
FDD
For LTE FDD, signal transmission and reception are on the different frequency band, which
need a duplexer to separate transmission and receive, and that will introduce 1dB insertion loss.
For LTE TDD, signal transmission and receive on the same frequency band but different time,
need a T/R converter to make the transmission and receive path connect to antenna system in
different time periods, and that will introduce 2~2.5dB insertion loss and T/R switch delay.
CRS
DRS
Uplink reference signals are classified into demodulation reference signals (DM RSs) and
sounding reference signals (SRSs).
DM RS
Demodulation reference signal, transmitted with PUSCH or PUCCH and used for data
demodulation.
SRS
Sounding reference signal, is not transmitted with PUSCH and PUCCH, scheduling by high
layer signal, used for UE channel measurement to realized UL frequency selection
scheduling.
Difference
LTE FDD: SRSs are only transmitted on ordinary subframes.
LTE TDD: To raise the spectral efficiency, SRSs can be transmitted on both ordinary
subframes and special subframes.
2#终端
1#终端
1#终端 2#终端
Sync Error +
DL Interfering DL
eNB
Interference
At DL UL DL
eNB
Benefits Weakness
LTE TDD UL
GSM、WCDMA、 GSM、WCDMA、
Coexist analysis
LTE TDD 终端发
CDMA、LTE FDD终端发 CDMA、LTE FDD终端收
18 1.8
spectral efficiency(bps/Hz)
14 1.4
Throughput(Mbps)
12 1.2
6 0.6
4 3.53 0.4
2 0.2
0 0
DL UL DL UL
Band Width: FDD (DL 10 MHz + UL 10MHz), TDD (UL + DL = 10MHz), LTE TDD Config=2:2, UL 1x2, DL 2x2
Special subframe configuration=11:1:2 (DwPTS: GP : UpPTS)
The spectral efficiency of LTE TDD is slightly lower than LTE FDD
due to the GP in special subframe.
Page 27
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.
LTE TDD/FDD Performance——Peak throughput
Peak Throughput
120
Throughput(Mbps)
40
19 Uplink SIMO(1x2) 16QAM
20
0
DL UL TDD Config DL:UL=2:2
Page 28
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.
LTE TDD/FDD Performance——Latency
Access latency Ping latency(32bytes)
120 12
110
110
100 10
100 10
90
8
Access latency(ms)
Ping latency(ms)
80 8
70
TD-LTE TD-LTE
60 6
LTE FDD LTE FDD
50
40 4
30
20 2
10
0 0
RTT of LTE TDD is slightly longer than LTE FDD for UL-DL
subframe configuration may cause information feedback delay (such
as HARQ ACK/NACK, CQI).
Page 29
HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES CO., LTD.
Contents
Notes:
LTE FDD: LBBPc, LBBPd1/d2/d3;
LTE TDD: LBBPc, LBBPd2/d4, LBBPd4 only for China
LTE TDD do not support bandwith 1.4M and 3M
In fact, LTE FDD usually use 2T2R, LTE TDD usually use 4T4R, 8T8R only used in China and Brazil.
Note :
LTE FDD select ‘FREQ’, ie frequency synchronization
LTE TDD select ‘TIME’, ie time synchronization
Frequency band: for FDD cell, the value can be 1~14, 17~21; for TDD cell, the value can be 32~43, 64.
Uplink earfcn indication: For an FDD cell, if no UL EARFCN is configured, the UL EARFCN equals the
sum of the DL EARFCN and 18000 by default. For a TDD cell, the UL EARFCN equals the DL EARFCN.
Cell FDD TDD indication: FDD cell select ‘CELL_FDD(FDD)’, TDD cell select ‘CELL_FDD(FDD)’.
Subframe assignment & Special subframe patterns: Only for TDD cell
Mode of Multi-RRU Cell: ‘SFN’ and ‘CELL_COMBINATION’ is only for TDD cell; ‘DIGITAL_COMBINATION’
is only for FDD cell.
Details please refer to ‘LTE TDD Baseline Parameter and Common Feature Configuration Principles’
For eRAN2.2
http://support.huawei.com/support/pages/kbcenter/view/product.do?actionFlag=detailProductSimple&web_d
oc_id=SE0000615371&doc_type=123-2&doc_type=123-2&saveBrowserLoged=true
For eRAN3.0
http://support.huawei.com/support/pages/kbcenter/view/product.do?actionFlag=detailProductSimple&web_d
oc_id=SE0000627832&doc_type=123-2&doc_type=123-2&saveBrowserLoged=true
For eRAN3.1
http://support.huawei.com/support/pages/kbcenter/view/product.do?actionFlag=detailProductSimple&web_d
oc_id=SE0000636317&doc_type=123-2&doc_type=123-2&saveBrowserLoged=true