8'.  
3ULPTHQR

POLITICAL REVIEW
(XVI) IV vol=6



   
 

 10-7:,7  

3ULKYD`HQR

 10-7:,7  



 


PU 6DZD >XTDJL`


 

  






        

 

  

 
 
   
   Clio  !!"

 
 
 


   
Wolfgang Schmale     
 

 

 

!
"


#
$
% #
"
$
  



 

&   "
$
    "
 


 "
 '
 ( 
& " )( 

 
"
 
$   
*

+
$     %
,   
 


 
 
 

 
 -

 % ! 
 
"



  
+
)
&  ./  0///% 
   ( 
( 
$(
%
! "  
 


 
 


  
 " 

 &  
  
  $ 


 
 "
 "$(  &
 


 $(   
 +( 
( )
 
$(  

( 
)   

% 1

(
+ - "
   





 &


 

   

  -

2 


$ 



 
  
  &


2
 -


 


% 
  +
-*

 

 





 
( / %
3- 4
    

2

( 



$   
+   (+ "
  
  " 

&
% !  " 
 

 


 
  & 


 & "$(
 ) 

 
*
 

" "' "- 

 

6DZD >XTDJL`

,675$-$9$:( ,6725,-6.( ,'(-( (9523( 

   


       
     
   


    
    
 


 
 
  
     
      
    !    
  

 
 
"       
 
  
 
#

    
  $     
    "  
     

     %


            
 
  
   

  
  
 
   
  
     
 

 &  '  (  ) 
  
 )

&      *   +  
   
 
          

 
    



     
 


$      
 !   
   
 %
 ,  
       
  
   
 
    
  
   

   
 
     

     
 

  %
  -
  
   
     
    " 
   %
       
  

.  

  
   


        /  /  . 
   

   "
 


  $

 %
.     ! 


   

   "
  
     

   %

- 
 
  0#
 

   0   
! 
  !  %
    
 
   
 
 
  


     1 
" 
       2    
  



       - 
 
 



  3 


 


      



   


     
    
!
   
      
 $  %
   
 
   


7DM SURVWRU VH GDQDV SR SUDYLOX GHILQL^H JUDQLFDPD  QD LVWRNX

SODQLQD L UHND 8UDO .DVSLMVNR PRUH MH]HUR SODQLQD .DYND] &UQR
PRUH PRUHX] %RVIRU 0UDPRUQR PRUH PRUHX] 'DUGDQHOL L (JHMVNR
PRUH QD VHYHUX 6HYHUQL OHGHQL RNHDQ QD MXJX 6UHGR]HPQR PRUH L QD
]DSDGX $WODQWVNL RNHDQ GR OLQLMH $]RUVND RVWUYD L RVWUYR ,VODQG

 



     (XVI) IV vol = 6

 

7DMLGHQWLWHWEL LPDR ]DVYUKX]EOLDYDZHaDN LRQLKQDURGDaLMD]D

MHGQLaND GRLYTHQD LVWRULMD PRGD QLMH GXD RG QHNROLNR GHFHQL
MD 7DNR VH L >PDOH ]DODH GD VH HYURSVND LVWRULMD QH VYRGL QD ]ELU
QDFLRQDOQLK LVWRULMD L WUDL VSRQX NRMRP TXGL QD MHGQRP NRQWLQHQ
WX SRaLZX GD XVSRVWDYTDMX RVQRYQH YH]H
>PDOH SRaLZH VYRMH GHOR SUHGVWDYRP (YURSHX +HURGRWRYRM,V
WRULML L]  JRGLQH SUH +ULVWD 3UHPD +HURGRWRYRM ,VWRULML
SRG JHRJUDIVNLP SRMPRP (YURSH NRML MH RQ VPDWUDR PQRJR YH`LP RG
$]LMH L /LELMH $IULND SRGUD]XPHYD VH GHR JUaNRJ MXQRLWDOLMDQ
VNRJ L SHUVLMVNRJNXOWXUQRJSURVWRUD8]+HURGRWRYR SRLPDZH(YUR
SH NRML MH NDR L DXWRU RYH NZLJH SUH LVWUDLYDR QHJR GDYDR JRWRYH
GHILQLFLMH MHGQRJ NXOWXUQRJ SURVWRUD L]QRVH VH ]DSLVL JHRJUDID
3LWHDVD L]GRED $OHNVDQGUD 9HOLNRJ ]DWLPVODYQRJ JHRJUDID L LVWR
ULaDUD VWDURJ YHND 6WUDERQDWH ]DSLVL L] GRED ULPVNRJFDUD 'LRNOH
FLMDQD 8 UD]PDWUDZX PLWD R (YURSL X VWDURP YHNX >PDOH LVWLaH GD
MH RQSUHQR^HQX WRPSHULRGXNUR]LNRQRJUDILMX LNZLHYQRVWXPQR
JLP UD]OLaLWLP YHU]LMDPD 2VQRYD SULaH JODVL GD VH =HYV ]DTXELR X
)HQLNRYX VWDULMD YHU]LMD RGQRVQR $JHQRURYX N`HU (YURSX L SUH
WYRULR VH X ELND 8 WRP REOLaMX SULYROHR MH (YURSX NDG VH LJUDOD QD
IHQLaDQVNRM PRUVNRM REDOL GD PX VHGQH QD OH_D L WDNR V ZRP SUH^DR
PRUH VYH GR .ULWD JGH MRM VH XND]DR X SUDYRP REOLaMX NDR =HYV (YURSD
PX MH WDGD URGLOD WURMH LOL GYRMH X ]DYLVQRVWL RG SUHGDZD VLQRYD D
NDVQLMH VH SRYHY^L VLQRYH ]D VRERP XGDOD ]D NULWVNRJ NUDTD $VWH
ULRVD NRML MH NDVQLMH ]DYH^WDR VYRMH NUDTHYVWYR ZHQLP VLQRYLPD
>PDOH NUR] ]DQLPTLY RGDELU WHNVWRYD L LOXVWUDFLMD SULND]XMH UD]
OLaLWH LQWHUSUHWDFLMH WRJ PLWD NUR] YHNRYH L SURVWRUH 8 SUHGKUL
^`DQVNRP VWDURP YHNX WD MH SULaD VWLOL]RYDQD L SRHWVNL L LNRQR
JUDIVNL 7LPH (YURSD RG JUaNRJ L ULPVNRJ VWDURJ YHND SD QDGDTH X
OLNRYQLP L X MH]LaNLP PHGLMLPD RG $IULNH GR (QJOHVNH QH SUHGVWD
YTD VDPR PLW R RVQLYDZX NRQWLQHQWD QHJR L PLW R VUH`LL]DEUDQRVWL
L SORGQRVWL
>PDOH X QDUHGQLP SRJODYTLPD QDYRGL LVWRULRJUDIVNR L NDUWR
JUDIVNR SRLPDZH (YURSH NUR] UD]OLaLWH SURVWRUH L SHULRGH L ]DX
VWDYTD VH QD SUREOHPX SULSDGQRVWL 5XVLMH (YURSL 'RN VX TXGL L]=D


8 WRP SHULRGX VH SRG (YURSRP SRGUD]XPHYDOD 7UDNLMD X NRMX VH XEUD

MDOD L ]DOH_LQD &DULJUDGD RG $LQRVD QD HJHMVNRM VHYHUQRM REDOL GR
REDOH &UQRJ PRUD QD VHYHURLVWRNX
7RP SULSRYHWNRP VH L]UDDYDOD PHWDIRUD ]D VUH`X RELTH KUDQH L ]D
SORGQRVW 2G QDMVWDULMLK DQWLaNLK SULND]D X NRMLPD (YURSD VHGL QD
ELNX GR SULND]D WRNRP YHNRYD KUL^`DQVWYD (YURSL VX GRGDYDQL HURW
VNL DWULEXWL LOL MH SDN =HYV VLPEROL]RYDQ NDR RUDR WDNR GD VX SR
YUHPHQR (YURSD L RUDR SULND]LYDQL L NDR /HGD L ODEXG WR MHVW =HYV
  

6DZD >XTDJL`

,675$-$9$:( ,6725,-6.( ,'(-( (9523( 

   
 
       
                 
       
     
  

        !
  
 
  
  "

   
# $%      
   & 

 
  
   

 '(
     ) * ( +    , (-

  '( +
    
 ,    '   
.Alexis de Tocqueville/         
 0&   
' ,0
  %  
($ 
 '   
 (        -   
 ) 
% (
 1  & 2   3
  ./

   
 4  ( 5  
(
 (     
  5   


   

+ 
    4   (

    
     6 , 
 7 8  1$    
 
,  
 4   -  9   $
         
5,
       
   
    (
(  $  
   
  

9  $9   8       
 

  
    
     -
    
  

 
  (   :

   ,
  
       9
9
(, 9  
  

 
 
  
         8    ) &   ;< 
0*
0 =    ;>     0
  

0  ;?  @A  +(   (   9
9  
%9   
  ;B  @A   ( 
   
 
( (
       ,  
 4
     '  ( ;>>C  (   (,
'  
     
(
    
9
 5  
 7  (    $ 


  ,   
  (
 
 (   
 

 
 $   $ 4 ,   
, 

*  7     
," ;D<?      

 
(
(   
 0
9 
9  50
 5   
9      ,

   " ,     (  4 
    " ( "   ,   E   
    
       $    (  
  



     (XVI) IV vol = 6

 

MQL SULYUHGQLFL UDGQLFL WM UDGQLaNH RUJDQL]DFLMH GLSORPDWL

XPHWQLFL QDXaQLFL L SLVFL ^LURP (YURSH
2G 7RPD^ *DULJD 0DVDULND X AHKRVORYDaNRM 5HSXEOLFL GR $O
EHU 'HPDQRQD L (GXDUG (ULMD X )UDQFXVNRM LOL GDQVNRJ OHNDUD +HU
IRUWD L OHYRJ NULOD QHPDaNH 6RFLMDOGHPRNUDWVNH SDUWLMH LQWHOHN
WXDOFL ^LURP (YURSH VX VYH YL^H ]DJRYDUDOL LGHMX HNRQRPVNRJ L SR
OLWLaNRJ SRYH]LYDZD (YURSH QD RVQRYDPD PLUD KXPDQRVWL L SUL
YUHGQRJ SRYH]LYDZD 8 LVWRaQRP GHOX VUHGZH (YURSH MDYTDOL VX VH
SUYL SR]LYL QD UHJLRQDOQH IHGHUDOL]DFLMH RG $OHNVDQGUD 6WDPER
OLMVNRJ X %XJDUVNRM GR ]DODJDZD )UDQFXVNH L 1HPDaNH ]D MDaDZH HN
RQRPVNH VDUDGZH X 6UHGZRM (YURSL >PDOH ]DSDD L GD MH SUYLP NRQ
NUHWQLP NRUDFLPD ND VWYDUQRM SROLWLaNRM LQWHJUDFLML (YURSH X 
YHNX SUHWKRGLOR SULYUHGQR SUHSOLWDZH (YURSH ^H]GHVHWLK JRGLQD
 YHND NDR L QDJOL QHREMD^ZLY NDNR QDYRGL >PDOH SRUDVW SRSX
ODUQRVWL PLWROR^NH SUHGVWDYH R SRUHNOX (YURSH RG  JRGLQH
2Q ]DWLP L]QRVL LVWRULMDW NRQNUHWQLK SUDYQLK L SROLWLaNLK
LQLFLMDWLYD ]D VWYDUDZH GDQD^ZH (YURSVNH XQLMH ,VWLaH GD VX 0DU
^DORYRP LQLFLMDWLYRP L RVQLYDZHP (YURSVNH SDUODPHQWDUQH XQLMH
 JRGLQH WH VWYDUDZHP FDULQVNH XQLMH %HQHOXNVD  JRGLQH
VWYRUHQH RVQRYQH SUHWSRVWDYNH ]D GDTH MDaDZH SULYUHGQH SROLWLaNH
L NXOWXUQH VDUDGZH PH_X GUDYDPD =DSDGQH (YURSH 1DNRQ RVQLYDZD
2UJDQL]DFLMH ]D HYURSVNX HNRQRPVNX VDUDGZX  JRGLQH L 6DYHWD
(YURSH  JRGLQH ]DWLP >XPDQRYRJ SODQD ]D HNRQRPVNR ]EOLDYD
ZH 1HPDaNH L )UDQFXVNH RVQLYDZD (YURSVNRJ VXGD ]D TXGVND SUDYD
 JRGLQH L (YURSVNRJ XGUXHZD ]D VORERGQX WUJRYLQX 

EFTA

 JRGLQH VWHaHQL VX NRQNUHWQL XVORYL ]D SUHWYDUDZH LGHMH R

MHGLQVWYHQRP HYURSVNRP HNRQRPVNRP SROLWLaNRP L NXOWXUQRP SUR
VWRUX X SUDNVX 1DNRQ RVYUWD QD QDVWDQDN L XORJX FHQWUDOQLK LQVWL
WXFLMD (YURSVNH XQLMH NDR ^WR VX (YURSVNL VDYHW 0LQLVWDUVNL VD
YHW .RPLVLMD 3DUODPHQW L 6XG >PDOH ]DMHGQLaNL SURJUDP VWYDUD
ZD SUDYRVXGQRJ VLVWHPD (YURSH RSLVXMH NDR MHGDQ YL^H LOL PDZH
UDYQRPHUQR WNDQL SUDYQL WHSLK aLMD MH VYUKD XMHGQDaDYDZH SUDYQLK
L XSUDYQLK SURSLVD GUDYD aODQLFD X FLTX VX]ELMDZD GLVNULPLQDFL
MH PH_X TXGLPD 2Q XRaDYD GD X RNYLUX WRJ SURFHVD GROD]L GR L]YHVQRJ
VWUXNWXUQRJ SUHREUDDMD SROLWLaNLK PLTHD LDNR MH L GDTH XRaTLYD
GYRNODVQD ^HPD UDGQLN  JUD_DQLQ
3RVOH SUHJOHGD QHJDWLYQRJ XWLFDMD QDFLRQDOVRFLMDOLVWLaNLK
SDUWLMD L 3UYRJ L 'UXJRJ VYHWVNRJ UDWD QD ]DSRaHWL SURFHV HNRQRP
VNLK SROLWLaNLK L NXOWXUQLK LQWHJUDFLMD X (YURSL >PDOH LVWLaH
GD X SHULRGX SRVOH 'UXJRJ VYHWVNRJ UDWD SRMDP LGHQWLWHWD HYURS
VNRJ aRYHND QLMH YL^H LPDR UDVLVWLaNX NRPSRQHQWX YH` NXOWXUROR
^NR ]QDaHZH (YURSD VH VYH YL^H VKYDWD NDR ]ELU NXOWXUQRJ L LVWRUL

  

6DZD >XTDJL`

,675$-$9$:( ,6725,-6.( ,'(-( (9523( 

 
 


 
   

  

    
   

   

   
   
  

 




  
     
    
! "

 

#!
"  

$    
""  


  !  
!
  

 !
    %&   
 
  
'  


  

 

 (  
 % 
  

   
         


!

 
 )   
 
#
!   *

  

 
  
    "
   
 


 " 
 "  
        

    +

 

   


 
"    
  
*
  
 , 
 - 
 

  )
  ./
 .0 
 
   !  
 *
    
 
  
 "    
 !""  
   

   #!

    
1 
!
  
 

  

 
   


! 
  #

   
 
#



  !
  
 %

    
!%  

 1    

  

  *

 
 
 
 !
 

    
#
 

 2   

  "      #  


 "        
 
 
  #    
 "   
   


 

#! !" 
 


!






 
 
 
#! #   
   


#  
 



 

 -

!

 
   

 3 
  

 ! 

       

!
!
 





  !   

       
  
   
%

  
 
"        
   "  "
  " 


   % 1       


! 
 %
 
!%  !
*

 
 




"   #  
  

!


" %
 " %  "  

  
 
   

  !  *

    

    
         
 
   +

 $
         

 
 

 #  
  2  
 


- 4





 
!
 




     (XVI) IV vol = 6

 

 
   
      
          
  

  
       

 !    

"

 " # $         % &
'
 ((
) "#$ 

" !  
 &  *  +!
  ,! " - .. !
/ !/ 

 


 
 
 /
#%  
&
   
!  
  
    '
   

 " /" # 0!     
  /& 

&
     
 "! "! &
1 "! "
/" "
!&
" "  
     &   
  
  '

&  #
) /  
  
 

    #-21
 "

    1 /   '
#
3 
 
    1  
    '
!
 
 
      
  '
!    
       &  

#3/  
 

 

   '
# 3
! &
 
  
 
// '
!  

/     4 
 
 ! 

!  
     
 '
 &   !
    
  "   # 

  
   5    
/ 
'
 
*&! 
   "
!   $ 

   
 ! 
 
  '
!
  
 
#,
"!/
 


   !    ! ! !
1  /  !  
 

  &
" "  " /#    &  

 /    &

  " ! "




6DZD >XTDJL`

,675$-$9$:( ,6725,-6.( ,'(-( (9523( 

  
      
     
   
 
 
  
 

 
       
   
 


            !
             
!