Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WOMEN AND
MEDIA COLLECTIVE
Women, quota and the press:
Media coverage of the 2018
local government elections
Published by:
ISBN 978-624-5868-01-8
2
Content
Preface…..................................................................................................................................... 04
Introduction……………………………………………………………………………................................... 08
Methodology…………………………………………………………………………..................................... 09
Key Findings……………………………………………………………………………................................... 10
List of Tables
List of Figures
3
Preface
The Local Government elections, which were held sincerely thank Iromi Perera for unpacking the
in February 2018 was a significant one. It is the first research findings and writing it. A special thanks
elections to be held under the new hybrid electoral to Kshama Ranawana, Thushari Madahapola and
system introduced at local government level in 2012 H.Inthumanthy for their efforts in finding the
as amended in 2017. It is also significant for another articles and analyzing them. Many thanks are also
reason. It is the first election to be held which puts owed to Kumudini Samuel for conceptualizing
into operation a mandatory 25% quota for women and editing the research. Thank you to Inoka
This resulted in the total number of representatives for translating this research to Sinhala and Tamil.
at local government to be increased from 4486 For proofreading this research, our thanks go out
to around 8356 members. In terms of Section 27F to Seetha Ranjani and Kuhanithy. Thanks to M.S.T
of the Amendment, 25% of the total number of Gowry for the layout of this publication.
members in each local authority shall be women The research was published with the support of
members. This is a significant achievement in the Royal Norwegian Embassy. We would specially
comparison to the 1.8% of women representation in like to thank Monica Svenskerud and Sundari
Local Government from the previous years. Jayasundara for their corporation and support.
Against this backdrop, this research looks at WMC has used many strategies to increase women’s
newspaper reporting on operationalizing the representation particularly at local level over the
historic women’s quota. The research looks at past 20 years. At present, WMC is working towards
newspapers in three stages. First, the period during building an ethical political culture in Sri Lanka by
which the Local Authorities Elections (Amendment) strengthening women’s political representation.
Act No. 16 of 2017 was passed in Parliament and This research was conducted with the objective of
the announcement of the 2018 Local Government protecting the mandatory 25% quota for women at
that surfaced during the campaign period and the Sanchia Brown
2018. The third stage covers, the post-election Women and Media Collective,
2018.
4
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
• This research was conducted on newspaper articles, 242, were news reports. This was followed
of the legally mandated 25% quota for women in pieces and 23 editorials. Out of the 415 articles
local government, for the purpose of knowledge written during the research period, 30 articles
building and knowledge sharing on women’s appeared on the front page and 15 of these were
representation in politics and the need to enhance published in English newspapers with 10 articles
• The study covered newspaper reporting newspapers with 6 articles appearing in February
for the period September 2017 - December 2018. 2018 and 6 in Tamil newspapers with 3 articles
Four newspapers, two daily and two weekly, in appearing in January 2018. It is noteworthy that
each of the language groups - Sinhala, Tamil and none of the weekly newspapers had a front-page
English were selected for this research study. The article during this period with the exception of the
newspapers were identified with the objective of Sunday Veerakesari that had a page one article in
and private media. The selected newspapers were • When looking at the newspaper reporting
the Sunday Times, Sunday Observer, Daily Mirror, from September 2017 - December 2018 the coverage
Daily News (English language; Dinamina, Silumina, of the implementation of the women’s quota can
Sunday Lankadeepa and Lankadeepa (Sinhala be divided into three key stages. The first is the
language); Sunday Veerakesari, Veerakesari, Sunday September - November 2017 period which covers
Thinakaran and Thinakaran (Tamil language). the Local Authorities Elections (Amendment) Act
• During the research period of September No. 16 of 2017 and announcement of the February
2017 - December 2018, a total of 415 articles 2018 Local Government elections which was the first
relevant to or about the women’s quota were election where the 25% quota was implemented.
published across all three languages in the twelve The second is the December 2017 - February 2018
newspapers that were tracked. 117 of these were period which covers the election campaigning and
in English newspapers, 148 in Sinhala and 150 in associated issues in the lead up to the election,
Tamil. The number of articles referring to or about and the actual election itself in February. The third
the women’s quota were high in the months right is post-election where much of the coverage is on
before the February 2018 election (December 2017 the issues around implementation of quota and
and January 2018) and peaked in February 2018 some challenges in ensuring all councils have 25%
• When looking at the type of articles • Following the passage of the Local Au-
published during this period, over half of the thorities Elections (Amendment) Act No. 16 of 2017
5
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
by Parliament in August 2017, the coverage in the lighted the challenges that female candidates were
newspapers reported in detail what changes this facing in the campaign period in addition to vio-
Act would bring with many of those interviewed lence. These challenges ranged from actually get-
hailing it as progressive. Minister of Local Govern- ting nominations to the culture of impunity that
ment and Provincial Councils, Faizer Mustapha is made it difficult for women to contest, to the lack of
quoted or interviewed the most in these articles support from political parties, the difficulty in get-
where he calls on all political parties to protect the ting their names on the relevant lists and specific
spirit of the amendments. Several articles also fea- issues faced by Muslim female candidates. This re-
tured interviews with other members of the Govern- porting was mainly driven by statements and press
ment who spoke on the importance of the women’s updates by the election monitoring bodies as well as
quota. There were no women interviewed regard- civil society groups who provided examples of chal-
ing the passage of the Act, and those quoted in all lenges and issues in specific areas in order to high-
three languages were male Members of Parliament light the challenges women candidates were facing.
commenting on the importance of the quota. Many • In the lead up to the election, there was a lot
articles in all three languages also pointed out that of coverage in the Sinhala and Tamil media about
despite Sri Lanka having the first female Prime Min- the women candidates who were contesting the
ister in the world and also a female President, rep- election. This coverage included profiles of some
resentation of women at all levels – local, provincial candidates, interviews or features where they spoke
and parliamentary – were extremely poor especially about why they are contesting and what their plans
compared to the South Asia region. are should they be elected. This sort of coverage was
• In the lead up to the Local Government notably absent in the English newspapers. These ar-
election, during the period of campaigning, much ticles also discussed women’s representation in gov-
of the coverage, especially in the English media was ernance in Sri Lanka compared to other countries,
about election violence. These included reports of women’s history of politics in Sri Lanka and why the
incidents, statements and updates from election quota is important for Sri Lanka.
monitoring bodies - People’s Action for Free and Fair • The Tamil media in particular highlighted the
Elections (PAFREL), Centre for Monitoring Election importance of women from the tea plantation sector
Violence (CMEV) and Campaign for Free and Fair contesting elections and that they were encouraged
Elections (CaFFE) as well as detailed analysis from to contest in order to change the political culture and
civil society groups such as the Women’s Action represent the plantation sector. Some interviews and
Network (WAN). There were also several statements features highlighted the fact that the quota alone will
from the Election Commission reporting on inves- not help women contest from the plantation sector,
tigations into violence against female candidates as the patriarchal society they live in has never given
and warnings of actions that could be taken against them any leadership positions, not just in politics, and
such violence. The statements from the Election therefore parties will have to invest in leadership de-
Commission also included warnings that elections velopment. Overall there were more interviews with
will be postponed in those areas where there was political parties and women politicians in the Tamil
violence against women. media about the importance of quota and/or issues
• Coverage in all three languages also high- faced by women contesting for elections.
66
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
• Majority of the post election coverage was should be taken were reiterated by these groups
regarding the difficulty in implementing the quota and reported accordingly. However, the reporting
as a few councils were unable to meet the 25% was more frequent in the English media compared
quota according to the provisions of the Act and to the Tamil media, which means that monitoring
therefore unable to proceed with the formation of bodies need to ensure information flows in all three
the council. The two list system was blamed for this languages and Tamil media outlets must make
conundrum in statements and interviews with the more use of independent monitoring bodies when
Election Commissioner. As the days passed by, the reporting during election periods.
coverage revolved around the future of the quota. • There is very little analysis that is done by
Some discussions noted that lessons must be the newspaper reporters themselves and most of
learnt from this election before implementing the the substantial analysis comes from civil society
quota for the next election. They noted that the law organisations or through interviews with activists/
must be amended for clarity. Others averred that policy makers. For example, statements from
the quota was impractical while key persons such the Women’s Action Network (WAN) which was
as Minister Mustapha and Mayor Rosy Senanayake published extensively in the English newspapers
issues statements in support of the quota, with discusses ways in which violence against female
Minister Mustapha even indicating that they will candidates in particular should be viewed,
not bow down to reduce the 25% quota for women. especially of Muslim candidates and of online hate
The Election Commission Chairman, Mahinda speech. Such in depth analysis is not to be seen
Deshapriya stated that he had warned the Attorney outside of such statements and interviews.
General of these legal snags from the beginning. • In reporting about women candidates
• In the Sinhala and Tamil media, most where qualifications and suitability of candidates
notably, in the Lankadeepa (7 articles), Veerakesari were discussed, a majority of those interviewed
(16 articles) and Thinakaran (6 articles), there was a spoke of the fact that the women candidates should
lot of follow up on how the quota implementation be qualified and educated and not the mother,
was working out in local councils after the inaugural sister or wife of a politician. However, in none of
meetings, including specific reports from various the interviews or articles was there a different
local councils from around the country. Reports narrative or analysis discussing whether men are
from these meetings included decisions made, held to the same standard and about questioning
how women councilors expressed their views, and the suitability of men in office or male candidates,
their participation in general. Tamil media also or on the topic of existing nepotism that is deeply
had many interviews with newly elected women entrenched in the political culture.
councilors and civil society activists about post- • In certain months in the lead up to the
election experiences and the success of the quota. election, most weekly newspapers had very little
organisations in general benefit hugely from representation. As people tend to read more
election monitoring bodies. Most of the coverage weekly newspapers compared to daily newspapers
regarding election violence, as well as information there should be more in depth analytical articles as
about which laws were broken and action that well as features in weekly newspapers.
7
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
INTRODUCTION
This report is one element of the work towards An amendment to the Local Authorities Elections
‘Changing Minds: Strengthening Inclusive Act in 2017 (The Local Authorities Elections
Governance and Affirmative Action to Increase (Amendment) Act No. 16 of 2017) ensured that local
by the Women and Media Collective (WMC). This representation system where 60% of members
newspaper research was conducted on the response represent single member or multi member
to, and the implementation of, the 25% quota for wards and 40% are returned from a list termed
women in local government (Local Authorities) for the ‘additional persons’ list without a ward based
the purpose of knowledge building and knowledge constituency. The total number of members in
sharing on women’s representation in politics and local government was increased from 4486 to
the need to enhance affirmative action. approximately 8356 members. In terms of Section
The overall work on women in politics undertaken members in each local authority shall be women
1
by WMC seeks to deal with three key challenges to members . These affirmative provisions in the Local
building a democratic and ethical political culture Authorities Elections Act of 2017, which ensured
in Sri Lanka in relation to women’s representation women 25% of Local Authority seats, shall be termed
in political institutions. The first is the under the women’s quota or quota in this research study.
representation of women in politics and the need With the quota in place, the number of women in
to build a public discourse in favor of an increase in Local Authorities or local councils increased from 89
2
women’s political representation. The second deals to 1991 following the Local Government elections
with the issue of women’s political participation on February 10, 2018. The 2018 elections also saw
and perceptions of women’s capacity to engage in the appointment of the first female mayor to the
3
politics, including legislative politics, and therefore Colombo Municipal Council, Rosy Senanayake .
women’s engagement in the legislature. The third The research for this report was conducted by
seeks to enhance the capacity of the increased Kshama Ranawana, Thushari Madahapola and
number of women representatives who will be Viluthu, Center for Human Resource Development.
to local government.
1. https://groundviews.org/2018/02/07/the-significance-of-the-25-quota-for-women-in-local-government/
2. https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/governments-womens-quota-a-total-success/
3. https://www.democracyspeaks.org/blog/empowering-female-councilors-sri-lanka
88
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
METHODOLOGY
The study covered newspaper reporting for the Public Library did not stock newspapers after one
period September 2017 - December 2018. Four year of publication c) the National Library only
newspapers, two daily and two weekly, in each allowed a person to read a predetermined number
of the language groups - Sinhala, Tamil and of newspapers following which a payment had to
English were selected for this research study. The be made to access more newspapers d) While both
newspapers were identified with the objective places initially allowed laptops inside the building,
of capturing mainstream media reporting across following the April 21st 2019 bomb blasts, this
State and private media. The selected newspapers practice was discontinued. Neither of the places
Table 1: Selected newspapers from state and private media *State media
From January 2019 - September 2019, three that after collating the information, the researcher
researchers assigned to collecting information from had to check for the stories online at home.
published during the research period, per using The information gathered from the newspapers
a total of approximately 2900 newspapers. These were entered into an excel database as they looked
newspapers were accessed at the Public Library, at the articles. The excel database gathered the
at the Women and Media Collective office as well a) Basic information such as name of newspaper,
as copies available at other organisations, such as date of publication, type of article (whether news
Viluthu and online versions of newspapers. article, feature, interview etc.), page number.
Researchers had to acquire a membership card to as a summary of each article, whether any of the
use the newspaper archives at the Public Library information in the article fell into the following
and National Library. Some of the challenges categories and what was said - key quotes, election
they faced when using the archives at these two violations, information regarding campaigning,
institutions included a) that newspapers for only issues regarding quota, implementation of the
one month could be accessed at a time b) the quota, future of the quota.
9
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
KEY FINDINGS
During the research period of September 2017 - When looking at the number of articles by
December 2018, a total of 415 articles relevant to or newspaper, weekly newspapers in all three
about the women’s quota were published across languages reported in similar numbers while in
all three languages in the twelve newspapers that the daily newspaper reporting, Tamil newspapers
were tracked. 117 of these were in English, 148 in contained more articles about or referring to
Sinhala and 150 in Tamil. The number of articles the women’s quota, closely followed by Sinhala
referring to or, that were about the women’s quota newspapers (Refer Chart 2). When looking at
were the highest in the months right before the the type of articles published during this period,
February 2018 election, peaking in February 2018 over half of the articles were news reports (242
and decreasing in the months following. articles). This was followed by 79 feature articles, 43
50
40
30
20
10
0
September November January March May July September November
10
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
43
44
16
14
61
62
14
60
68
16
Out of the 415 articles written during the research articles appearing in January 2018 (Refer chart 4). It
period, 30 articles appeared on the front page. is noteworthy that none of the weekly newspapers
15 were published in English newspapers with had a front-page article during this period with the
10 articles appearing during February 2018, 9 in exception of the Sunday Veerakesari that had a
Sinhala newspapers with 6 articles appearing in page one article in April 2018 which was a feature
February 2018 and 6 in Tamil newspapers with 3 of the first female Pradeshiya Sabha Chairman in
Maskeliya.
Chart 3: Type of articles
In English newspapers, most of the articles that
11
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
January 2018) the front-page articles included news regarding the violence and abuse faced by women
items relating to election violence, about holding in the run up to the election. In Tamil newspapers,
of elections, the gazetting of the Local Authorities news items quoting the Executive Director of CaFFE
Elections (Amendment) Act No. 16 of 2017. In about the importance of prioritizing women for
February there was also a front page news article political parties in the North as well as about the
about the appointment of the first female ‘Adivasi’ low prevalence of violence against women, as well
4
councilor, W.M Shiromala from Dehiattakandiya . as news items quoting female candidates on the
Sinhala frontpage articles were mostly about the importance of women getting elected to office in
issues in setting up councils after the elections the North were featured in the front page.
4 http://www.dailymirror.lk/article/Shiromala-first-Adiwasi-public-representative-145742.html
12
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
HOW DID
NEWSPAPERS
REPORT?
When looking at the newspaper reporting from cultural constraints on women’s political activities.
September 2017 - December 2018 the coverage It has done away with the notorious preferential
of the implementation of the women’s quota can or ‘manape’ system and retained the advantages
be divided into three key stages. The first is the of proportional representation through a hybrid
September - December 2017 period which covers system combining the latter with the First-past-
the Local Authorities Elections (Amendment) Act the Post system. The abolition of the preferential
No. 16 of 2017 and announcement of the February vote makes electioneering much cheaper and
2018 Local Government elections which was the first accessible to poor candidates. It also reduces the
election where the 25% quota was implemented. dependence on money-bags.” - Daily News feature,
5
The second is the December 2017 - February 2018 September 2017
associated issues in the lead up to the election, The Local Authorities Elections (Amendment) Act
and the actual election itself in February. The third No. 16 of 2017, which legislated the 25% quota for
is post-election where much of the coverage is on women at the level of local authorities was followed
the issues around operationalizing of the quota by the passage of the Provincial Councils Elections
and the difficulty in ensuring all councils have 25% (Amendment)by Parliament in September 2017.
Stage one (September - December 2017) bring with many of those interviewed hailing it
“New legislation that replaced the earlier Local Provincial Councils, Faizer Mustapha is quoted or
Government election law is an advance in interviewed the most in these articles where he
democracy. For the first time it has ensured 25% calls on all political parties to protect the spirit of
women representation in local government bodies. the amendments. Several articles also interview
Such a mandatory quota is necessary in the other members of the ruling Government who
context of male dominated political parties and spoke on the importance of the women’s quota.
5 http://www.dailynews.lk/2017/09/08/features/127589/lg-polls-and-local-interests
6 In this study we concentrated particularly on reportage of the Amendments to the Local Authorities Act.
13
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
“Women who are the main component of the under a patriarchal political and political party
economy have been elevated in the economic system. This was mostly in the Sinhala and English
field. Women will strengthen the political power newspapers. There were also some articles quoting
just as they have the economy. This is the goal of opposition ministers or opposition politicians, or
the government. Will give women’s representation opinion pieces of senior journalists and academics
25% and give them strength in the political regarding what they considered the downside
arena.” – Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe of quota - such as the increase in expenditure to
event on September 1, 2017, quoted in Lankadeepa to have ‘suitable’ candidates who have village
There were no women interviewed regarding the politicians fulfill this criteria on suitability.
languages were male Members of Parliament “This need for women’s representation did not come
commenting on the importance of the quota. Many from provincial administrators or women, but by
articles in all three languages also pointed out that Colombo centric discussions. The end result is that
despite Sri Lanka having the first female Prime political parties have to make a great effort to find
Minister in the world and also a female President, women to contest from the villages. Therefore it is
representation of women at all levels – local, foolish to think that it will give a boost to women’s
poor especially compared to the South Asia – Opinion piece by the former editor of Silumina,
region as well. The Sunday Observer in an article Chamara Lakshman Kumara, Silumina, December
media briefing where she had stated that she had “Instead of making special arrangements, an
insisted for 25% for women and had threatened to electoral system that is beneficial for all should
vote against the previous provision which allocated be worked out. Under the existing system not
only 1400 seats or 16% for women. only women, even upright people cannot win.
“If women’s representation will increase in the place. Therefore, if the electoral system can be
local government, the change will be enabled in changed to reflect the good, then, women’s
the country. Women’s political representation is representation too could be strengthened. That
high in other countries, but unlike other countries is where we should head to. If not, the women
women’s political participation is low in Sri Lanka.” who get elected are those connected to worthless
–Thinakaran news article, November 2017 men, not other women. Therefore I don’t believe
There were several articles also discussing the Anurudda Pradeep Karanasuriya, Senior Lecturer,
challenges that women would face in contesting Political Science, Sri Jayawardenapura University,
14
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
Interviews with Election Commission Chairman and other parliamentarians while the Tamil press
Mahinda Deshapriya regarding the Local covered the importance of quota and its effect
Government elections of February 2018 included on up country Tamil politics. There was in depth
details of how the quota would work as well as coverage in newspapers like the Lankadeepa on the
information about how to avoid confusion around history of women’s politics in Sri Lanka as well as
the implementation of the quota. It was also the benefits of quota through coverage of speeches
reported that in order to ensure the numbers and interviews with the then Prime Minister Ranil
were not confusing, the Election Commission had Wickremesinghe, academics and parliamentarians.
specified the exact number of female candidates There was no coverage of public opinion around the
to be entered in the nominations list for each local passage of the Act or the importance of quota.
7
government body . Information from election
monitoring groups that was reported also explained “I have never heard about violence against women
the fundamental changes to the election system. and threats during the LTTE period. But the abuse is
There was also reporting around the fact that increasing and women’s participation in the politics
through the new amendments the youth quota is needed to bring the changes from a woman’s
had been removed and that now it would be up to perspective” –Interview with Ananthi Sasitharan,
the parties to ensure they make adequate space for Member and Minister of Women’s Affairs, Northern
“It’s not possible to do everything by law. We “With access to education women have entered
have already given 25 percent quota to female all spheres, however their representation in politics
representatives and we cannot give another 25 is still not enough. Even though they are able to
percent for youth again. The political parties too vote to change a government, there aren’t enough
have social responsibilities, therefore, they should women in parliament. As a pilot project to change
allocate a quota for youth from the party level,” - this situation, a bill to include a minimum number
Minister Faizer Mustapha, Daily News, September of women in local government has been passed.
8
2017 Some say they cannot find women to contest; that
The Tamil media did not cover statements or news election won. In the Norwegian parliament 50% are
items that quoted the Election Commission or women, and that is without any legislation. In some
election monitoring groups and mostly quoted European cabinets at least 50% or the majority are
Tamil Parliamentarians or Minister Faizer Mustapha. women. Such changes must be effected through
The Sinhala press had more articles regarding how Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe speaking at the
the quota would work and its importance compared 100th anniversary of Visakha Vidyalaya, quoted in
to other newspapers. English press mainly covered the Dinamina, September 10, 2017
7 http://www.sundayobserver.lk/2017/12/10/news/female-candidates-minimum-number-mandatory
8 http://www.dailynews.lk/2017/09/25/features/129195/exclusion-youth-politics
15
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
Stage two (December 2017 –election day, parties, the difficulty on getting their names on the
violence and other issues faced by women during “There are no women contestants accused of
the campaigning period, such as lack of support criminal charges or who have got remanded.
from the political parties.Election violence related However, they face challenges to enter politics
reports included reports of incidents, statements due to patriarchy. In their own ward itself, male
and updates from election monitoring bodies contestants defame women’s name during the
People’s Action for Free and Fair Elections (PAFREL), election campaign. So then women are afraid
Centre for Monitoring Election Violence (CMEV) to come out and get involved in the elections
and Campaign for Free and Fair Elections (CaFFE) campaigns.” – article in the Thinakaran, January 14
were also several statements from the Election “Last week, a group of policemen barged into her
Commission that were reported with details of residence on the pretext of searching for illegal
investigating incidents of violence against female weapons. When they noticed her election brochures,
candidates and warnings of acting on complaints they asked her about her candidacy. The police said
of violence. The statements from the Election the house search was due to an anonymous 119 call
Commission also included warnings that elections about weapons and printing of counterfeit currency
will be postponed in those areas where there was notes. By that time, the whole village had gathered
“If there are any barriers preventing the freedom to sling mud at me and my family members,’’ Rinuza
District officers are also studying the areas closely Many other women candidates in her area had
and are expected to inform the Secretariat if earned the wrath of powerful men including
additional security is needed for female candidates religious leaders soon after they decided to contest,
Coverage in all three languages also highlighted the political parties have decided to go door-to-door
challenges that female candidates were facing in in small groups, taking into account the risks. “We
the campaign period in addition to violence. These used to tell them that we all are from one party —
challenges range from actually getting nominations the ‘women’. We should all have our say in local
to the culture of impunity that made it difficult for governance as we do in our homes,” Rinuza said,”
them to contest, to the lack of support from political Kader Ibrahim Rinuza, a candidate contesting from
16
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
the Sri Lanka Muslim Congress for the Kalpitiya this election. Previously under the proportional
Pradeshiya Sabha in Puttalam quoted in a Sunday representation system the parties would have to
Times article regarding violence and issues faced include female candidates name on the list so they
9
by women candidates, January 28 2020 would include the names at the very end of the list.
Reporting was mainly driven by statements and 10% compulsory inclusion women have got a very
press updates by the election monitoring bodies as important place. Due to this, women have had to
well as civil society groups who provided examples face different challenges. Some women who are
of challenges and issues in specific areas in order to well known in their electorates have been put into
highlight the challenges women candidates were other electorates. Names of women who are active
facing. For example, a WAN statement that was and bright have been pushed further down the list
carried in the Sunday Times newspaper in January and those whose names are placed at the top are
2018 pointed out the silence of institutions such as women who are known or are related to organisers.
the police and the Election Commission, as well as In order to protect the quota system we have to work
the political parties themselves, on hate speech hard to overcome these challenges. Women have
against women candidates online, the character problems in some areas. Women are being used in
assassination faced by many women candidates some instances to cook food and provide alcohol
and specific issues faced by Muslim candidates in the night to people working on the campaigns.
particularly due to Moulavis. There are some who don’t even have money to
“WAN also observed that it is a painful and system a success we have to work to overcome these
problematic fact that so far, none of the political challenges. We plan to recommend that female
parties these woman candidates belong to, the organisers should also be appointed along with male
police who are responsible to uphold the law, the organisers.” – Executive Director of the Women’s
Election Commission, or any political party leaders Resource Centre Sumika Perera quoted at a press
have condemned the open, public, and disgusting conference organized by the Women and Media
hate speech towards women candidates or verbal Collective (WMC) a, Dinamina, January 27 2018.
and political backgrounds towards them. “Their Some of the reporting based on press conferences
silence makes one question whether women’s or statements by election monitoring groups were
participation in politics is truly welcomed, or merely not only about violence, for example in the Sinhala
a formal act,”the coalition of women’s organisations there was some coverage quoting CMEV that some
noted that women continue to be subjected to subtle, political parties were not fully supportive of women
silent, and hidden forms of violence, and as such candidates and their campaigns, with some even
these violent acts violate their rights and negatively going to the extent of telling people not to vote for
affect the credibility of the election.” them. Furthermore there was some coverage about
- WAN statement reported in the Sunday Times mud-slinging and the lack of support from male
9 http://www.sundaytimes.lk/180128/news/intimidation-insults-attempt-to-deter-women-poll-candidates-278866.html
17
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
During this period there were many articles in would be elected to office and the belief that policies
all three languages regarding the importance would benefit from having women champion them
of quota as well as how the quota system would or working on them as there are some issues or
function, explaining how the nominations period aspects that only women would be sensitive to.
and interviews some positive aspects of the quota “Rajani welcomes the move to allocate a quota
and the women candidates that were discussed for women and said having women in politics will
included that it will enable rural and urban women facilitate other women to come forward and talk
across the board to get into more active politics about the various problems they face. “There are
and into political life, that the culture of political things women cannot or do not want to discuss
parties acting as gatekeepers will change, and that with men, as men will not understand them,” she
with a champion for women’s quota among the Having studied at the Batticaloa Hindu College,
candidates, Colombo Mayor Rosy Senanayake is the her knowledge in politics so far has been text book-
most visible in the reporting with several interviews based having taken up political science for her
“While ensuring that more women will join politics, more active role in politics. “I see a need for strong
the next has to be a quota for parliamentary seats. female representation. The 30-year war has made
In Parliament, I strongly believe that it is the PR us strong and we can meet the challenges we have
system that is depriving women of their rightful to confront in the political sphere. Be it better street
access. You need an enormous amount of money lighting, an efficient drainage system, children’s
for an election. A lot of women who want to enter clinics and parks or upgrading cemeteries, all
politics are being discouraged as they have to of which come under the purview of the local
go through character assassination. For me, authorities, she said.”, interview with ITAK candidate
affirmative action is the only way forward and 25% from Batticaloa Lakshmi Rajani Jeyprakash,
10
is not enough. That should be the minimum, but Sunday Times January 14, 2018
mandatory and use affirmative action with regard Interestingly there was much discussion about the
to the electoral systems in this country. The women’s ‘suitability’ of women candidates and that they
movements have to be stronger and advocate for should be qualified and not a politician’s mother,
this.”, interview with Rosy Senanayake, Daily Mirror sister or wife. This was also a point emphasised by
Interviews with citizens about women’s Silumina, Chamara Lakshman Kumara in December
representation and the importance of quota showed 2017 wrote that the quota won’t work and used as
that there were high expectations from women who an example what he saw as the ineffectiveness of
10 http://www.sundaytimes.lk/180114/news/people-gutted-by-war-drought-speak-out-277078.html
18
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
the 13 women Members of Parliament and that they generating programmes.”, Nanda Wickremanayke,
only “open their mouth to eat or yawn” and that candidate from the UPFA who contested for the
some have not opened their mouth in Parliament in Kuliyapitiya Municipal Council, interview translated
five years. While such misogynistic comments can from Dinamina, January 25, 2018
and women politicians, the reporting of counter “As a Muslim woman, I had to convince my husband
narratives to this – questions about whether men and the extended family to allow me to contest. I
are held to the same standards, the efficiency of want to be a role model for other Muslim women and
male politicians thus far etc. – is seriously absent in let them know that women can make a difference.
the print media. Women should come forward and enter public life
In the lead up to the election, there was a lot of regarding the problems they face,”A.G.S.Naleema,
coverage particularly in the Sinhala and Tamil media candidate from the Muslim National Alliance (MNA)
with women candidates who were contesting for who contested for the Kattankudy Urban Council,
elections. This coverage included profiles of some Sunday Times January 14, 2018
about why they are contesting and what their plans The Tamil media in particular highlighted the
are should they be elected. These articles also importance of women from the tea plantation
discussed women’s representation in governance contesting for elections and that they were
in Sri Lanka compared to other countries, women’s encouraged to contest in order to change the
history of politics in Sri Lanka and why the quota political culture and represent the plantation sector.
is important for Sri Lanka. Sinhala media such as Some interviews and features highlighted the fact
Dinamina also interviewed or quoted Sri Lankan that quota alone will not help women contesting
academics and civil society regarding quota. from the plantation sector, as the patriarchal society
“I am contesting not only because I make up the 53% positions, not just in politics, and therefore parties
of the population, but also to challenge the existing will have to invest in leadership development.
It is a proven fact that women are less corrupt “We appreciate this 25% quota system, because
than men. I am contesting to show that there are of the denial of the plantation sector women’s
paths to the new political tradition and to change leadership because of patriarchal system. They can
to this dirty political system we must begin from utilise this opportunity to enter into mainstream
village to village”, Disna. Ranjani Mahaarachchi, politics and achieve development,” – Interview with
candidate from the UNP who contested for the P. Muthulingam, Director of the Institute for Social
Kegalle Municipal Council, interview translated Development, Thinakaran, December 10, 2017
“I will work to reduce the unbearable cost of opportunity for women to lead the society even
living, corruption, and waste propose new income temple trustees, school development societies or
19
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
cooperative societies. Then how will they improve In Puttalam, the Sri Lanka Muslim Congress (SLMC)
their leadership? The decision making capacity will convinced Bisleah Bhutto (31) to run for office for the
not be able to build without leadership. Therefore, Puttalam Pradeshiya Sabha at the eleventh hour
if we want to talk about women’s representation, as the party simply struggled to fill the female
firstly we’ll have to build-up their leadership. If not quota in their nomination lists. The party had
it will be just talk during political time to promote nominated her to an area where the party had little
December 2017
“When we were in Mullivaikkal no one raised their canvassing for the opposition party in the area, so
voice for us and nobody was with us at the end. that the people would not vote for women from
Our women candidates’ priority is justice for the their own party”, explained Bhutto who had to face
Tamil community. To show our solidarity we have the additional ‘cultural’ burden in the area.
candidate, quote translated from a front page news Moreover, in the present crisis, many of her male
article in the Thinakaran, January 26, 2018. colleagues have asked that the party not give
Some of the post election coverage continued to “My colleague was pregnant when she campaigned
be on issues faced by women candidates including for the party from Kalpitiya to Puttalam. The
about how they were deceived by political parties organiser who gave us his van to campaign now
even until the day of election and were unable to says that politics is no place for a woman. And that
run for election or win in the ward, or that women we should not ask for a seat”, she added.” – Daily
with good grassroot level experience were put in News article with several activists and women
the additional list and did not get a seat as a result. candidates about their election and post-election
quota was misused by some parties to making However majority of the post election coverage
recommendations on how to improve how seats are was regarding the difficulty in implementing the
11
allocated . quota as some councils were unable to meet the
“Soma Dissanayke, an entrepreneur running Act could not constitute the necessary numbers,
a successful business in Moneragala stood for and therefore unable to proceed with the formation
the SLFP in the area and she too was put on the of the council. Election Commissioner Mahinda
additional list, despite having popular support in Deshapriya stated that “because of a lacuna in
11 http://www.dailynews.lk/2018/03/01/features/144220/women-betrayed
20
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
representation could not be maintained in at least “As one of the driving forces behind the provision, I
12
ten local government bodies . There was a total can say with certainty that the law on the minimum
of 340 Local Councils contested at Municipal and representation of women is clear-cut. Under section
Pradeshiya level.The two list system was blamed 27F of the amended Ordinance “not less than
for this confusion in statements and interviews twenty five per cent of the total number of members
with the Chairman of the Election Commission who in each local authority shall be women members”
also in other interviews stated that the 25% cannot The section is unambiguous and straightforward;
be implemented due to practical issues in the new it is not open to interpretation,”, Mayor Rosy
electoral system. There was some pushback to these Senanayake in a press release issued to the media
statements, for example Mayor Rosy Senanayake urging the EC Chairman to take steps to implement
in a statement issued to the media said that “to the 25% Quota for Women in LG polls immediately,
now say that this minimum 25 percent of women Daily Mirror, February 16 2018
disingenuous and in bad faith” and went on to say “The parties with overhung seats, will not be able
that the Commission of Elections nor the Political to accommodate more female members, other
Parties should consider adhering to this law to be than the ones already elected.”Therefore, in case
“unfair” or “burdensome.” She also stated “The law of a party that should have three female members
cannot be set aside nor the clear intent of the law but has only one elected female member, the other
be defeated just because some Parties now have to parties in the Council are compelled to appoint the
nominate more women from their Lists than they two excess females to pass the legal barrier. It may
expected to. To disregard the law would not only be contribute to exceed their 25% Party quota. “However
discriminatory towards women but also circumvent much we support the 25% rule this is not fair by those
the democratic process and the expectations of the parties,” the Commission Chairman said. The new
As the days passed by, the coverage revolved around the Council.” - Mahinda Deshapriya reported in the
the future of the quota with some discussing that Sunday Observer, February 2018
implementing it for the next election and that the law The coverage continues on to March 2018 with
must be amended for clarity, to Minister Mustapha’s election monitoring groups expressing concern
statements that they will not bow down to reduce about the delay and noting concerns around
the 25% to Election Commission Chairman Mahinda the possibility of unelected candidates getting
Deshapriya stating that he warned the Attorney through. Statements from PAFREL during that time
General of these legal snags from the beginning. suggested that since majority of the councils met the
Minister Mustapha and Mayor Rosy Senanayake 25% quota that they should be formed without delay
were key figures who made several statements in and that the rest should be sorted out later. Most of
support of the quota in the weeks following the the articles during this period included interviews or
12 http://www.dailymirror.lk/article/-women-reps-not-possible-in-LG-bodies-146205.html
21
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
election monitoring groups and civil society as well vote, are completely blocked from coming to the
as politicians. Some articles discussed the delays council from the PR list in cases such as Dikwella
in setting up the councils and that there is no easy where all the candidates from the PR list should be
solution, and questioned whether quota worked in women. This is a huge problem because they would
this election or whether it created more problems. have invested a lot of time, money and energy,”
Merits of quota were discussed and whether the Kodikara pointed out. However, she stressed that
system should revert to the old one, however there compromises need to be made to implement the
was much opposition to this that was reported from quota. “So the fact that some people are affected
civil society groups and even the Chairman of the in this way can’t be helped. It’s unfortunate, but
Election Commission was reported stating that that’s what a quota of this nature does,” she said
quota should stay. stressing that the quota tried to address the
“We showed at the time the bill was being women. “People will also say that a particular
prepared that the 25% women’s representation is man couldn’t get in, but some useless woman
problematic. But since everyone wanted to have who has no experience in politics got in through
the poll conducted, we were told not to worry about the list. That woman has no experience in politics
it, but to conduct the election. Now like we said, because of how the political parties have worked
there are practical issues. From the contestants in this country. People should understand this,” she
list it is mandatory that there is 10% women’s said. - Researcher and activist Chulani Kodikara
representation, but when a single party wins all interviewed in the Daily Mirror, March 2018
25%. When less than four members are elected, it is Election observers stated that the election and
not mandatory that women are appointed. There the implementation of the quota was a win for
are such instances, where meeting the mandatory democracy with more women in power, and that
25% becomes an issue.” – Mahinda Deshapriya lessons from this election must be taken into
interviewed in the Silumina, February 18 2018 consideration before the next election. However,
“We have asked the EC to implement the laws, that quota cannot be implemented for the
nobody can change the laws of the country, the Provincial Council elections as there has to be a new
people voted with the intention of implementing the delimitation report in order to do so.
quota and the government and the EC are obliged “[Prime Minister], Ranil Wickremasinghe states that
to fulfill that promise” – Minister Faizer Mustapha the government and parliament’s attention has
quoted in the Dinamina Editorial page, February 28 been drawn to the fact that the [Local Authorities]
2018 from a meeting held between the Minister and elections act will need to be amended to resolve the
“This is a dilemma that parties are facing- that wards, and appointed from the list.” – News article
certain senior popular members who may have lost in the Silumina, February 18 2018
22
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
“They (political parties) are looking at every excuse councilors and civil society activists about post-
to deprive female candidates of the opportunity election experiences and the success of the quota.
to represent Local Government bodies.” - Rosy Much of this coverage took place throughout the
In the Sinhala and Tamil media, most notably Aadivasi community. She got 1369 votes and
Lankadeepa (7 articles), Veerakesari (16 articles) ensured her seat in the Dehiattakandiya Urban
and Thinakaran (6 articles), there was a lot of Council. She says,” My community has given me
follow up on how the quota implementation was more support to win in the election and I want to
working out in local councils after the inaugural dedicate my life to the ethnic group and religion.
meetings, including specific reports from various Aadivasi people’s education and developments will
local government councils from around the country. be developed during my period. I have an idea to
Reports from these meetings included decisions contest in the Parliament election through my local
made, how women councilors expressed their views government experience.” – News article translated
and their participation in general. Tamil media also from the Veerakesari, February 2018
23
Women, quota and the press: Media coverage of the 2018 local government elections
violence against female candidates, there was candidates in particular should be viewed, especially
almost no follow up to those incidents. There was of Muslim candidates and of online hate speech.
no coverage around whether perpetrators were Such in depth analysis is not to be seen outside of
arrested, whether any cases were filed and what the such statements and interviews.
outcomes were.
organisations in general benefit hugely from While Mayor Rosy Senanayake is interviewed several
election monitoring bodies. Most of the coverage times about her views regarding quota, challenges
regarding election violence, as well as information faced by female candidates and implementation
about which laws were broken and action that of quota, there are no other female voices that are
should be taken were reiterated by these groups covered unlike in the Sinhala and Tamil newspapers.
and reported accordingly. However, the reporting There is also no reporting in the English newspapers
was more frequent in the English media compared post election about women who took office and
to the Tamil media, which means that monitoring what their experience has been like so far.
languages and Tamil media outlets must make - In the run up to the February 2018 election,
more use of independent monitoring bodies when hate speech on social media against female
reporting during election periods. candidates was a serious issue and except for a WAN
- There is very little analysis that is done by covered the seriousness of it and what that means
the newspaper reporters themselves and most of for a free and fair election.
policy makers. For example, statements from where qualifications and suitability of candidates
the Women’s Action Network (WAN) which was were discussed, majority of those interviewed spoke
published extensively in the English newspapers of the fact that the women candidates should be
24
qualified and educated and not the mother, sister or - In certain months in the lead up to the
wife of a politician. However in none of the interviews election, most weekly newspapers had very little
or articles was there a different narrative or analysis or no coverage regarding quota or women’s
discussing whether men are held to the same representation. As people tend to read more weekly
standard and about questioning the suitability of newspapers compared to daily newspapers there
men in office or male candidates, or on the topic of should be more in depth analytical articles as well as
existing nepotism that is deeply entrenched in the features in weekly newspapers. The breakdown of
Sunday Observer 1 0 1 1 4 5 2
Sunday Times 0 1 1 2 6 4 0
Sunday Lankadeepa 1 0 0 0 5 5 0
Silumina 2 0 1 2 1 2 1
Sunday Veerakesari 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Sunday Thinakaran 0 2 0 3 3 1 0
Table 2: Number of articles that appeared in the weekly newspapers in the lead up to the election
25
RECOMMENDATIONS
AND BEST PRACTICES
- The space allocated to women in the run these groups. In reporting these incidents, it is not
up to and during election campaigns is mostly with adequate to cover the incident alone. There has to
regard to election violence or coverage of the legally be statements taken from the Election Commission
mandated quota and what that means for Sri Lankan about their reaction and what course of action they
elections. The media has a responsibility to promote plan to take. Furthermore, coverage must extend
democracy and good governance and this requires to following up on key incidents and whether any
them to be more proactive than reactive. While arrests of taken place, whether cases were filed and
there is some reporting in the Sinhala and Tamil in general any outcome of the incident. This would
newspapers with female candidates about their otherwise create a landscape where women may be
plans if they are elected and their experience thus deterred in the future to contest for the elections as
far, this kind of reporting is minimum in the English they only get to know about violence against female
media. However, in all of this coverage there is not candidates and with no information about how
a lot of details that are covered – for example more those incidents were dealt with. That there was no
information about the policies, issues they intend to follow up or outcome itself is important reporting
focus on or their political directions. Interviews with that must take place, and the culture of impunity
- Extensive reporting regarding election contesting for elections, journalists must also go
violence is crucial and while it may be difficult for beyond just reporting incidents to finding ways to
media organisations to keep track of all incidents, convey the seriousness of the issue to the public.
this is where election monitoring bodies and activist For example, interviews or features with women
groups play a crucial role. Timely updates on election candidates, or women who have contested for the
violence, immediate press releases following elections about what it’s like to be a woman during
major incidents is a must and information must be a campaigning period would offer an in depth and
adequate coverage. Newspaper organisations too - It is obvious that election monitoring bodies
must be updated about information provided by and civil society organisations play a crucial role in
26
how information flows to the people. Much of the should be more robust reporting and analysis on
significant coverage and in depth analysis came the role of social media in elections, how it was used
from statements and interviews with these groups in the elections, using big data to look at broader
and it is important that any information that is being trends and usages is something that print media is
analysis or coverage and in order to ensure that - There needs to be more coverage about
citizens get accurate information in a timely way, women in office about their roles, the challenges
the work of these groups must be strengthened and they face, strategies they employ to deal with
- However it must be highlighted that all and governance. This type of coverage could
election monitoring groups are led by men and include women who have been in politics/ roles of
therefore a complete dependency on their output governance for years as well as those newly elected.
cover press briefings and statements by women - Opinions and views from men in elected
activists/ women rights organisations it is clear bodies who can be considered allies, about how
from this research that media organisations do not the increased inclusion of women in governance
actively seek them out for interviews, features or and policymaking has affected governance in
even contributions. The value of the contributions Local Authorities, how to support newly elected
by women’s organisations by way of statements and women, the experience so far in the various councils
briefings that are reproduced verbatim is significant would be a valuable addition to the coverage on
and therefore media organisations and journalists the importance of women’s representation in
them.
- Newspapers being a traditional media still balance in the way that women in governance or
cover elections in a traditional way and have not women contesting for elections is portrayed in
evolved adequately to report on new forms of threats the media. This does not only mean not depicting
and violence in an electoral system, such as the role women in sexist stereotypes but also extends to
of the internet, social media and of mobile phones. offering counter narratives about the way women
Targeted trainings around these issues and how to candidates or women’s representation is presented
report them in print, how to analyse what they see - whether through opinions of people interviewed
online during election periods is much needed. or news reporting. For example, on the topic of
- Overall reporting around use of social and nepotism, it is crucial that they raise that men
media, specifically facebook in an election and in are not held to these standards and what it is needed
campaigning in particular was non existent. There to break away from the existing political culture.
27
WOMEN AND
MEDIA COLLECTIVE