Name of Evaluator: _Michael Jefferson___ Name of Authur: _Puimay Ho_

Peer Evaluation of Final Paper Rough Draft

Use the following criteria to evaluate your classmates rough draft. Make sure to offer as many comments as possible.
Purpose 1. Is the purpose of the paper clear? 2. Is the authors position on the topic clear? Comment: Score: Score: No - Somewhat - Yes 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5

Data Collection 3. Have data been used to explore or argue a position on the topic? 4. Is the meaning drawn from the data clear? 5. Is enough information given to make the data understandable without becoming the sole purpose of the paper? Comment:

Score: Score:

1 1

2 2

3 3

4 4

5 5

Score:

Literature 6. Has psychological theory and research been used? 7. Have psychological terms and theory been used to support the papers purpose? 8. Has more than one perspective or explanation been discussed? Comment:

Score:

Score: Score:

1 1

2 2

3 3

4 4

5 5

Format 9. Has APA format been utilized? (Is there a reference list? Does each fact that is not commonly known have a reference?) 10. Is the style of the paper appropriate? (Have quotes been kept to a minimum? Have terms been defined? Is the discussion in everyday language? Does each paragraph discuss a single issue?) Comment:

Score:

Score:

Grade you think the paper as is deserves:

____A____