7+(

/25'
2)
7+(

5$,16 

%\%DODML1DUDVLPKDQ
VKHUORFNEDODML#\DKRRFRP!

$QDVWURORJLFDODQDO\VLVRIUDLQIDOOLQ,QGLD
VSUHDGDFURVVRQHKXQGUHG\HDUVDQG
RYHUWZRPLOOLRQVTXDUHNLORPHWHUV


'(',&$7,21

7KLVRQHLVIRUWKHORUGRIWKHUDLQV
:KRGHOLYHUVVWHUQMXVWLFHZLWKRXWIOLQFKLQJ
:KRLVEODFNDVWKHQLJKWWKDWFRYHUVDWKRXVDQGVLQV

7KLVRQHLVIRUWKHRQHZKRDWWDLQVXFFKDWYDLQ1DUDVLPKD·V1DNVKDWUD
:KRKDVKLV0RRODWULNRQDLQP\VWLF.XPEKD
:KRLVSUDLVHGE\VDJHVZKRPKHKDVKHOSHGUHQRXQFHWKHZRUOG

7KLVRQHLVIRUWKHRQHZKRVH0RRODWULNRQDIDOOVLQP\QLQWK
:KRGHVWUR\VRXUSULGHDQGOHDGVXVWRWKH'LYLQH
:KRLVERWKMXVWDQGUXWKOHVVDQGQRWMXVWUXWKOHVV


2

7$%/(2)&217(176

,1752'8&7,21 

5$,1)$//'$7$² 

'5(..$1$1$/<6,6

7+('5(..$162)0(6+$ 

7+('5(..$162)95,6+$%$  

7+('5(..$162)0,781$ 

7+('5(..$162).$7$.$ 

7+('5(..$162)6,0+$ 

7+('5(..$162).$1<$ 

7+('5(..$162)78/$ 

7+('5(..$162)95,6&+$.$  

7+('5(..$162)'+$185 

7+('5(..$162)0$.$5$ 

7+('5(..$162).80%+$ 

7+('5(..$162)0((1$ 
 
3$57,1*7+28*+76 


3

,1752'8&7,21

&KDQGUDDQG6XNUDZKRDUHERWKPRVWO\EHQHILFUXOHZDWHU6RWKLVEHJVWKH
TXHVWLRQ³ZK\LVLWWKDWZHDUHWUHDWLQJ6DQLDUJXDEO\RQHRIWKHJUHDWHVW
QDWXUDOPDOHILFVDVWKHORUGRIWKHUDLQV"

7KHUHDVRQLVVLPSOH³6DQLLVWKHUXOHURIJULHIDQGUDLQV³LQ,QGLDDVDQ\ZKHUH
HOVHLQWKHZRUOG³DUHVWURQJO\DVVRFLDWHGZLWKVRUURZ,ILWUDLQVWRRPXFK
IORRGVFDXVHGHVWUXFWLRQZKLOHWRROLWWOHUDLQLPSOLHVGURXJKW5DUHO\DUHUDLQV
MXVWULJKWVRWKHUHLVPLVHU\LQRQHIRUPRIWKHRWKHU7KHUHIRUH6DQLDVWKH
UXOHURIWKHSRUWIROLRRIJULHILVEHVWVXLWHGIRUEHLQJWKHORUGRIWKHUDLQV

)RUWKLVVWXG\,WRRNUDLQIDOOGDWDIURP,QGLDQ,QVWLWXWHRI7URSLFDO
0HWHRURORJ\,,703XQH7KHGDWDWKDWWKLVHQWLW\SRVVHVVHVRQUDLQIDOOLV
XQPDWFKHGDQG,ZDVDEOHWRILQGGHWDLOVRQWKHLU:HEVLWHWKDWFRYHUHGUDLQIDOO
GDWDDFURVVVXEGLYLVLRQVHQFRPSDVVLQJVTXDUHNLORPHWHUVRI
,QGLD$GGHGWRJHWKHUWKHWRWDOUDLQIDOODFURVV²ZDVIRXQGWREH
ZKLFKDYHUDJHGWRDURXQG$OOSHUFHQWDJHFRPSDULVRQVDUH
PDGHDJDLQVWWKLVILJXUH

7KHSDUDPHWHUV,XVHGIRUVWXG\ZHUHVLPSOH³,VWXGLHGWKHGUHNNDQRFFXSLHG
E\6DQLHYHU\\HDUIURPWRZKHQ6XU\DHQWHUHG3XVK\D3XVK\DZDV
VHOHFWHGEHFDXVHLWLVWKHILUVWQDNVKDWUDRI6DQLDQGIDOOVLQDKRXVHUXOHGE\
ZDWHU\&KDQGUD$OVR6XU\DWUDQVLWVWKLVQDNVKDWUDHYHU\\HDULQ-XO\WKH
PRQWKRIPD[LPXPUDLQV

2QFH,FRPSXWHGWKHGUHNNDQRFFXSLHGE\6DQLZLWKWKH'26SURJUDP
VZHHWHVWH[HIURPDVWURFRP,ORRNHGXSWKHGUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQVLQWKHERRN
+LQGX3UHGLFWLYH$VWURORJ\E\'U%95DPDQ2IFRXUVHDVH[SHFWHGQRWHYHU\
GUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQZDVFRQVLVWHQWEXWDORWRIWKHPZHUH

$QGQRZJHQWOHUHDGHU,VKDOOWDNH\RXUOHDYHDQGOHDYH\RXZLWKP\UHVHDUFK
QRWHV

%$/$-,1$5$6,0+$1
$35,/
%$1*$/25(


4

5$,1)$//'$7$²

 \HDU UDLQ  G GUHNNDQ
     GKDQE
     PDNUD
     PDNUE
     PDNUF
     NXPED
     NXPEF
     PHHQD
     PHHQE
     PHVKD
     PHVKE
     PHVKF
     YULVD
     YULVF
     PLWKD
     PLWKE
     PLWKF
     NDWDE
     NDWDF
     VLPKD
     VLPKE
     VLPKF
     NDQ\D
     NDQ\F
     WXODD
     WXODE


5

5$,1)$//'$7$²

 \HDU UDLQ  G GUHNNDQ
     WXODF
     YULFD
     YULFF
     GKDQD
     GKDQE
     GKDQF
     PDNUD
     PDNUF
     NXPED
     NXPEE
     NXPEF
     PHHQE
     PHHQF
     PHVKD
     PHVKF
     YULVD
     YULVE
     YULVF
     PLWKE
     PLWKF
     NDWDD
     NDWDE
     NDWDF
     VLPKE
     VLPKF


6

5$,1)$//'$7$²

 \HDU UDLQ  G GUHNNDQ
     NDQ\D
     NDQ\E
     NDQ\F
     WXODD
     WXODF
     YULFD
     YULFE
     YULFF
     GKDQD
     GKDQF
     PDNUD
     PDNUE
     PDNUF
     NXPEE
     NXPEF
     PHHQD
     PHHQE
     PHVKD
     PHVKE
     PHVKF
     YULVE
     YULVF
     PLWKD
     PLWKE
     PLWKF


7

5$,1)$//'$7$²

 \HDU UDLQ  G GUHNNDQ
     NDWDE
     NDWDF
     VLPKD
     VLPKE
     VLPKF
     NDQ\E
     NDQ\F
     WXODD
     WXODE
     WXODF
     YULFD
     YULFF
     GKDQD
     GKDQE
     GKDQF
     PDNUE
     PDNUF
     NXPED
     NXPEE
     PHHQD
     PHHQE
     PHHQF
     PHVKD
     PHVKF
     YULVD


8

'5(..$1,2)0(6+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQFODGLQZKLWHGUHVVSDUWLFXODUO\URXQGKLVZDLVWGDUNLQFRPSOH[LRQ
WHUULILFLQDSSHDUDQFHUHGGLVKH\HVDQGKROGLQJDOLIWHGD[H

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  
  

7KLVGUHNNDQLVDPDOHRQHDQGLVUXOHGE\.XMDZKRLVLQLPLFDOWR6DQL6R
QDWXUDOO\WKHILJXUHLVDOLWWOHORZWKRXJKLWKDVFURVVHGWKHPDUNWZR
WLPHV

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHD[HPDNHVLWDQ$\XGD'UHNNDQVXJJHVWLQJDZDUIRU
ZDWHU7KHUHVWRIWKHGHVFULSWLRQDOVRVXJJHVWVWKDWWKHSHUVRQFRQFHUQHGZLOO
GRDQ\WKLQJIRUWKLVSUHFLRXVFRPPRGLW\

1RWHWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHZKLWHGUHVVZKLFKQHHGVWREHFOHDQHGZLWKORWVRI
ZDWHU7KLVLQGLFDWHVWKDWWKHZHDUHUKDVWKHFDSDFLW\WRJHWZDWHUREYLRXVO\
E\EUXWHIRUFH


9

'5(..$1,,2)0(6+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$ZRPDQZHDULQJUHGFORWKIRQGRIMHZHOVDQGRUQDPHQWVVLQJOHIRRWHGZLWK
WKHIDFHRIDKRUVHDQGVXIIHULQJIURPWKLUVW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVIHPDOHGUHNNDQLVUXOHGE\6XU\D7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKLUVWPDNHVRQH
DXWRPDWLFDOO\DVVXPHWKDWWKHUHLVZDWHUVKRUWDJHEXWWKHILJXUHVZRXOGSURYH
VXFKDQDVVXPSWLRQZURQJ

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHVLQJOHIRRWPLJKWEHH[SODLQHGE\WKHIDFWWKDW6DQLZKR
UXOHVWKHIHHWDWWDLQVKLVORZHVWSRLQWRIIDOO³WKHWKGHJUHHRI0HVKD³LQ
WKLVGUHNNDQ

:KLOH6XU\DLVDELWWHUHQHP\RI6DQLKHLVDOOVDLGDQGGRQH6DQL·VIDWKHU
EHVLGHVDOVREHLQJD6DWWYLF³DOEHLWFUXHO³JUDKD7KLVPLJKWEHWKHUHDVRQZK\
UDLQIDOOLVQRWVXFKDELJSUREOHPKHUH


10

'5(..$1,,,2)0(6+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$FUXHOKHDUWHGPDQUHGLQFRORUDFWLYHZHDULQJUHGJDUPHQWVXQSULQFLSOHGDQG
DQJU\

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  
  

7KLVPDOHGUHNNDQLVUXOHGE\*XUXDQGWKRXJKVRPHSDUWVRIWKHGHVFULSWLRQ
DUHQRWSRVLWLYHDQGNHHSLQJZLWK*XUX·VEHQHYROHQWQDWXUHZHILQGWKDWUDLQIDOO
KDVEHHQPRUHRUOHVVDGHTXDWH

,QWKUHHRXWRIWKHIRXUFDVHVWKHUDLQIDOOKDVFURVVHGWKHPDUN
LQGLFDWLQJWKDW*XUX·V6DWWYLFQDWXUHKDVRYHUFRPHWKHJHQHUDOGHVFULSWLRQRI
WKHGUHNNDQ

7KHUHIHUHQFHVWRWKHFUXHOW\DQGODFNRISULQFLSOHVSHUKDSVVWHPIURPWKHIDFW
WKDWWKLVGUHNNDQ·VORUGKDVKLV0RRODWULNRQDLQ'KDQXUZKLFKLVDFUXHODQG
ILHU\UDVL


11

'5(..$1,2)95,6+$%$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$ZRPDQZLWKWRUQULQJOHWVLQFOLQHGWRHDWWKLUVW\DQGZHDULQJDSDUWO\EXUQW
JDUPHQW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XNUD6LQFH6DQLLVIULHQGO\ZLWK6XNUDRQH
H[SHFWVJRRGUDLQV+RZHYHUWKLVH[SHFWDWLRQKDVQRWEHHQERUQHRXWE\
SUDFWLFDOILQGLQJV

,QDOOWKHWKUHHFDVHVFRQVLVWHQWO\WKHUDLQIDOOLVEHORZWKHPDUNDQGLQ
RQHFDVHLWIDOOVEHORZHYHQWKHPDUNZKLOHLQDQRWKHULWKDVMXVWDERXW
FURVVHGWKHPDUN

7KHUHDVRQLVEHFDXVHWKLVLVDILHU\GUHNNDQDQGWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKLUVWDQGWR
WKHEXUQWJDUPHQWVLVLQGLFDWLYHRIWKHIDFWWKDWWKHUHLVDVHYHUHVKRUWDJHRI
ZDWHU


12

'5(..$1,,2)95,6+$%$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!



$PDQVNLOOHGLQDJULFXOWXUHEXLOGLQJKRXVHVEUHHGLQJFDWWOHPXVLFVFLHQFHDQG
DUWVSRVVHVVLQJDQHFNVLPLODUWRWKDWRIDEXOO

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\%XGKDZKRLVDOVRIULHQGO\ZLWK6DQL,QERWK
FDVHVUDLQIDOOLVZHOORYHUWKHPDUNZKLFKLVTXLWHKHDUWHQLQJHVSHFLDOO\
ZLWKUHIHUHQFHWRWKHSUHYLRXVGUHNNDQ

7KHVWURQJUDLQIDOOLVSUREDEO\EHFDXVHRIWKHUHIHUHQFHWRDJULFXOWXUHDQGWR
WKHEXOOZKLFKZDVXVHGH[WHQVLYHO\LQDQFLHQWWLPHVIRUDJULFXOWXUDOSXUSRVHV
$OVRWKLVLVDTXDGUXSHGGUHNNDQDJDLQLQGLFDWLQJDQLPDOV

7KHUHVWRIWKHGHVFULSWLRQRIWKHGUHNNDQZKLOHQRWQHFHVVDULO\LQFRQWH[W
LQGLFDWHVDOOURXQGSURVSHULW\VRPHWKLQJWKDWKDVEHHQPDGHSRVVLEOHE\
SOHQWLIXOUDLQV


13

'5(..$1,,,2)95,6+$%$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!



$PDQZLWKZKLWHWHHWKFDPHOIHHWHOHSKDQWLQHEHOO\IRQGRIVKHHSDQGGHHU
DQGDOZD\VDJLWDWHG

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDOVRDPDOHGUHNNDQOLNHWKHRQHDERYHEXWKHUHWKHFRPSDULVRQHQGV
EHFDXVH6DQLWKHQDWXUDONDUDNDIRUJULHIUXOHVLW6RLWLVQRZRQGHUWKDWWKH
UDLQIDOOLVTXLWHORZHYHQWRXFKLQJLQRQHFDVH³WKHORZHVWUHFRUGHG

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHFDPHOEULQJVWRPLQGWKHGHVHUWDQGE\DVVRFLDWLRQWKH
ORZDPRXQWRIUDLQIDOOWKDWRQHFDQH[SHFW7KHDJLWDWLRQLVSHUKDSVDOVR
EHFDXVHRIWKHODFNRIZDWHU

7KHIDFWWKDWWKLVPDQLV´IRQGµRIVKHHSDQGGHHULVFRQIXVLQJ'RHVKHOLNHWR
HDWWKHP"$QGLIVRGRHVKLVIRQGQHVVVWHPIURPWKHIDFWWKDWSRRUUDLQVKDYH
IRUFHGKLPWRPRYHDZD\IURPDJULFXOWXUHWRQRQYHJHWDULDQIRRG"


14

'5(..$1,2)0,781$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$KDQGVRPHIHPDOHVNLOOHGLQQHHGOHZRUNLVVXHOHVVDQGPHQVHV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\%XGKD:KLOHWKHGHVFULSWLRQLVWRRVKRUWIRU
RXUVDWLVIDFWLRQLWLVKHDUWHQLQJWRQRWHWKDWWKHUDLQIDOOKDVEHHQPRUHWKDQ
DYHUDJHLQERWKFDVHV

0XFKRIWKHGHVFULSWLRQVHHPVWRFHQWHUDURXQGWKHORUGRIWKHGUHNNDQ%XGKD
LVKDQGVRPHDQGWKH´LVVXHOHVVµGHVFULSWLRQILWVWKHIDFWWKDWKHLVD
KHUPDSKURGLWH

:KDWFDQRQHPDNHRIWKHVNLOOLQQHHGOHZRUN"'RHVWKHZRPDQSUDFWLFHLW
EHFDXVHVKHKDVWLPHRQKHUKDQGVVLQFHWKHUHLVQRZRUU\FDXVHGE\VKRUWDJH
RIZDWHU"


15

'5(..$1,,2)0,781$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQLQJDUGHQDUPHGIURPWRSWRWRHZLWKERZZDUOLNHDQGVSRUWLYH

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XNUD:KLOHZDWHUKDVEHHQVKRUWLQVXSSO\
RQFHLWKDVEHHQDGHTXDWHHQRXJKLQWKHRWKHUWZRLQVWDQFHVWKDQNVSHUKDSVWR
WKHIDFWWKDW6XNUDLVDEHQHILF

7KHIDFWWKDWWKLVLVDQD\XGDGUHNNDQPLJKWLQGLFDWHVRPHGDQJHUEXWWKHIDFW
WKDWKHLVLQDJDUGHQ³DSODFHIXOORIJUHHQHU\ZKLFKLQGLUHFWO\VXJJHVWVSOHQW\
RIZDWHU³LVKHDUWHQLQJ

%DVHGXSRQWKHGDWDDYDLODEOHZLWKXVRQHPLJKWVSHFXODWHWKDWWKHUHLV
VRPHWLPHVDJRQ\DQGVRPHWLPHVSURVSHULW\EHFDXVHWKHUDLQIDOOVZLQJVDOOWKH
ZD\IURPWR


16

'5(..$1,,,2)0,781$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQULFKLQMHZHOVDUPHGZLWKERZOHDUQHGDQGSHHYLVK

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

&RQVLGHULQJWKDWWKLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6DQLRQHPLJKWZDQWWRUHFKHFN
WKHGDWDDWOHDVWDFRXSOHRIWLPHV³KRZGRHV6DQLWKHNDUDNDIRUJULHIPDQDJH
WRFRQVLVWHQWO\GHOLYHUUDLQIDOORYHULQDOOWKHWKUHHFDVHV"

2QHUHDVRQPLJKWEHEHFDXVHWKHUXOHURIWKLVGUHNNDQLVUHODWHGWR.XPEDWKH
0RRODWULNRQDRI6DQL:KLOHWKLVUDVLLVFUXHODQGPDVFXOLQHLWLVDOVRDIUXLWIXO
RQHDQGVRSHUKDSVWKHUHZHUHJRRGUDLQV

+RZHYHUWKHIDFWWKDWWKLVLVDQD\XGDGUHNNDQPLJKWVXJJHVWGHVWUXFWLRQ
WKURXJKZDWHU7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHIDFWWKDWWKHPDQLVOHDUQHGPLJKWFRPH
IURPWKHIDFWWKDW%XGKDLVWKHORUGRIWKLVKRXVH


17

'5(..$1,2).$7$.$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQKROGLQJYHJHWDEOHVIORZHUVDQGIUXLWVHOHSKDQWERGLHGSLJIDFHGDQG
KRUVHQHFNHG

\HDU UDLQ 
  

(YHQZKHQRQHGRHVDQDQDO\VLVVSDQQLQJDKXQGUHG\HDUVLWLVVWLOOSRVVLEOHWR
VXIIHUIURPDODFNRIGDWDDQGWKLVSDUWLFXODULQVWDQFHVHHPVWREHDFODVVLF
FDVHLQSRLQW

8QIRUWXQDWHO\VLQFHWKHUHLVMXVWRQHHQWU\LWLVKDUGWRFRPSDUH6WLOOIRU
ZKDWLWLVZRUWKUDLQIDOOVHHPVTXLWHKLJKEHFDXVHERWKWKLVPDOHGUHNNDQDQG
WKHUDVLDUHUXOHGE\ZDWHU\&KDQGUD

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHIUXLWVIORZHUVDQGYHJHWDEOHV³ZKLFKLPSO\WKDWWKHUHLV
SOHQW\RIZDWHU³UHLQIRUFHVWKHIDFWWKDWUDLQVZHUHSOHQWLIXO7KHRWKHU
UHIHUHQFHVGRQ·WVHHPWRGLUHFWO\UHIOHFWWKHFRQWH[WRIWKLVVWXG\


18

'5(..$1,,2).$7$.$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$ZRPDQGHFRUDWHGE\IORZHUVZLWKDVQDNHLQKHUKDQGSRVVHVVLQJVWLII
GHFRUXPDQGFU\LQJORXGLQWKHIRUHVW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOH6DUSD'UHNNDQUXOHGE\.XMD7KHGHVFULSWLRQLVQRWYHU\
SRVLWLYHEXWLQWZRRXWRIWKHWKUHHFDVHVUDLQIDOOKDVEHHQTXLWHJRRGVRZH
VKRXOGVWXG\WKHGUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQFDUHIXOO\

7KLVGUHNNDQDOOVDLGDQGGRQHUHIHUVWRIORZHUVDQGLQGLUHFWO\LPSOLHVWKDW
WKHUHLVSOHQW\RIZDWHU,QWKLVFRQWH[WZKDWGRWKHVQDNHDQGWKHFU\LQJELW
UHIHUWR"

2QHSRVVLEOHRSWLRQFRXOGEHWKDWWKHZRPDQLVFU\LQJDORXGEHFDXVHRI
GHVWUXFWLRQFDXVHGE\KHDY\UDLQV&RQVLGHULQJWKDW.XMDLVDKLJKO\PDOHYROHQW
JUDKDWKLVH[SODQDWLRQSRVVLEO\ILWVWKHELOO


19

'5(..$1,,,2).$7$.$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQLQDERDWDPLGVWDQRFHDQZLWKDVHUSHQWDURXQGKLVZDLVW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

/LNHWKHRQHDERYHWKLVLVDOVRD6DUSD'UHNNDQ+RZHYHUWKLVLVUXOHGE\*XUX
DQGLVPDOH$JDLQLQWKLVFDVHWRRWKHGUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQGRHVQ·WVHHPWR
SUHVHQWDSOHDVDQWSLFWXUH

,QMXVWRQHFDVHWKHUDLQIDOOLVRQWKHORZHUVLGH3HUKDSVWKHIDFWWKDWWKLVLVD
ZDWHU\GUHNNDQIDOOLQJLQDZDWHU\UDVLUXOHGE\ZDWHU\&KDQGUDHQVXUHVWKDW
WKHUHLVSOHQW\RIZDWHU

:K\GRHVDGUHNNDQUXOHGE\EHQHILF*XUXJLYHXVOHVVHUUDLQWKDQWKHSUHYLRXV
GUHNNDQUXOHGE\PDOHILF.XMD"7KHDQVZHUSHUKDSVOLHVLQWKHIDFWWKDWERWK
UDLQVDQGGHVWUXFWLRQGXHWRZDWHUPLJKWKDYHEHHQORZHULQWKLVFDVH


20

'5(..$1,2)6,0+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$MDFNDODQGDYXOWXUHVLWWLQJRQDVDQGDOWUHHDGRJDQGDPDQFU\LQJIRUKHOSLQ
IRUHVW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHTXDGUXSHGDQGSDNVKLGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XU\D7KHGHVFULSWLRQRI
WKHGUHNNDQLVTXLWHEOHDNDQGRQHZRQGHUVKRZWKHUDLQIDOOLQHLWKHURIWKHWZR
FDVHVDERYHZDVKLJK

7KHYXOWXUHLQGLFDWHVGHDWKDQGLVUHIHUUHGWRDVWKHPRXQWRI6DQL6XU\DLV
KLJKO\LQLPLFDOWR6DQLDQGSHUKDSVWKHYXOWXUH·VUHIHUHQFHLQGLFDWHVGHDWKGXH
WRWRRPXFKUDLQ

7KLVIDFWPLJKWEHERUQHRXWE\WKHIDFWWKDWWKHPDQLVFU\LQJ7KHRQO\
DXVSLFLRXVUHIHUHQFHLVWRWKHVDQGDOWUHHEXWHYHQWKLVUDLVHVWKHTXHVWLRQ³GLG
WKHMDFNDOFOLPELWWRHVFDSHWKHULVLQJUDLQZDWHULQGXFHGIORRGV"


21

'5(..$1,,2)6,0+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQUHVHPEOLQJFHQWDXUFRYHUHGRYHUE\GHHUVNLQDQGDEODQNHWZLWKDERZLQ
KLVKDQGDQGILHUFHLQORRN

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOH$\XGD'UHNNDQUXOHGE\*XUX2QO\LQRQHRIWKHWKUHHUHFRUGHG
FDVHVLVUDLQIDOOKLJKDQGWKLVPDNHVXVZRQGHUMXVWKRZEHQHILFDJUDKD*XUXLV
LQWKHFRQWH[WRIUDLQV

7KHUHDVRQPLJKWEHEHFDXVHWKHIDFWWKDWWKLVLVDQ$\XGD'UHNNDQPD\
LQGLFDWHVWUXJJOHVRIVRPHVRUW6LQFHZHDUHGLVFXVVLQJUDLQVWRROLWWOHUDLQV
PD\FDXVHWKHSUREOHPVDQGVXIIHULQJV

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHGHHUVNLQVXJJHVWV³LIQRWDKHUPLW³WKHQDWOHDVW
VRPHERG\XVHGWRIUXJDOLW\7KLVFRXOGEHWKHLPSOLHGPHDQLQJ³OHDUQWROLYH
SDUVLPRQLRXVO\ZKHQ6DQLWUDYHUVHVWKLVGUHNNDQ


22

'5(..$1,,,2)6,0+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQUHVHPEOLQJDEHDULQIDFHDPRQNH\LQDFWLRQVZLWKORQJPRXVWDFKHV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHDQGTXDGUXSHGGUHNNDQUXOHGE\.XMD:KLOHWKHUDLQIDOOLQDOO
WKUHHFDVHVLVORZLWLVLPSRUWDQWWRUHDOL]HWKDWLQDOOWKHFDVHVWKHILJXUHLV
FRPIRUWDEO\FORVHWREHLQJDOPRVWQRUPDO

:KDWFRXOGEHWKHUHDVRQ"1RWKLQJLQWKHGUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQLQGLFDWHV
DJULFXOWXUHRUUDLQIDOO+RZHYHURQWKHSRVLWLYHVLGHWKHUHLVQRLQGLFDWLRQWKDW
WKHUHLVJRLQJWREHDQ\VFDQWLQHVVLQUDLQIDOO

3HUKDSVRQHKDVWRLQWHUSUHWWKHGUHNNDQLQWKHFRQWH[WRIWKHUHIHUHQFHWR
WKHDQLPDOVZKLFKDUHSUREDEO\KDSS\EHFDXVHRIDGHTXDWHUDLQIDOO2IFRXUVH
ZHPLJKWWKHQEHVWUHWFKLQJRXULPDJLQDWLRQWRRPXFK


23

'5(..$1,2).$1<$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$EHDXWLIXOYLUJLQKROGLQJDEDVNHWIXOORIIORZHUVOLPEVFRYHUHGRYHUE\GLUW\
JDUPHQWV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\%XGKD1RWHWKDWZKLOHLQRQHFDVHWKHUDLQIDOO
ZDVDOPRVWQRUPDOLQDQRWKHULWZDVTXLWHRIIWKHPDUNWKLVVNHZLQJWKH
DYHUDJHFRQVLGHUDEO\

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHIORZHUVZKLFKUHTXLUHZDWHUWRJURZLQGLFDWHVWKDW
UDLQIDOOPXVWEHDGHTXDWHDQGWKLVKDVEHHQERUQHRXWLQWKHILUVWLQVWDQFH
ZKHUHUDLQIDOOZDV

7KHVHFRQGFDVHSHUKDSVUHIOHFWVWKHELWDERXWWKHGLUW\JDUPHQWV³DUHWKH
ZRPDQ·VJDUPHQWVGLUW\EHFDXVHRIVFDUFLW\RIZDWHU"'RHVWKLVGUHNNDQ
LQGLFDWHZLOGIOXFWXDWLRQVRIUDLQVNHHSLQJLQPLQGWKHPXWDELOLW\RI%XGKD"


24

'5(..$1,,2).$1<$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQZLWKDGDUNKHDGDQGDSHQLQKLVKDQGZLWKDERZDQGERG\IXOORIGHQVH
KDLU

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVPDOH$\XGDGUHNNDQLVUXOHGE\6DQLDQGWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHGHQVHKDLULV
DYHU\FOHDULQGLFDWRURI6DQLZKRLVVDLGWREHKLUVXWH1RWHWKDWLQRQH
LQVWDQFHWKHUDLQIDOOZDVDOPRVWQRUPDO

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHSHQLQGLFDWHV%XGKDWKHORUGRIWKHUDVL,QWKLVFDVHRQH
ZRQGHUV³GRWKHSHQDQGWKHERZFRPELQHWRLQGLFDWHDUHYROXWLRQDU\VROGLHU
SRHWZLWKZDWHUDVWKHFDXVHIRUWKHILJKW"

:KLOH%XGKDDVDEHQHILFFDQEHH[SHFWHGQRWWRKLQGHUWKHUDLQIDOOVLWXDWLRQ
WKHIDFWWKDWWKLVLVDQD\XGDGUHNNDQPLJKWLPSO\WKDWWKHUHLVVRPHDPRXQWRI
VXIIHULQJWREHSXWXSZLWK


25

'5(..$1,,,2).$1<$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$IDLUZRPDQZLWKD\HOORZFORWKRQKHUERG\DQGH[SRVLQJKHUEUHDVWVDQGJRLQJ
WRDVDFUHGSODFH

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPLQLQHSDNVKLGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XNUDDQGWKRXJK6XNUDLVDEHQHILF
LWGRHVQ·WVHHPWRKDYHKHOSHGWKHUDLQIDOOVLWXDWLRQWRRPXFKZLWKRYHUDYHUDJH
UDLQVRFFXUULQJLQMXVWRQHFDVH

7KHUHLVQRWKLQJLQWKLVGUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQWKDWLVVXJJHVWLYHRIHLWKHUJRRG
UDLQVRUEDGUDLQV:HVKDOOLJQRUHWKHYXOJDUUHIHUHQFHLQWKLVGUHNNDQ·V
GHVFULSWLRQ³6XNUDEHLQJ6XNUDLWLVWREHH[SHFWHG

:K\ZDVWKHZRPDQJRLQJWRDVDFUHGSODFH":DVLWWRWKDQN*RGIRUJUDQWLQJ
SOHQWLIXOUDLQVRUZDVLWWRSUD\WR+LPVRWKDW+HZRXOGHQVXUHWKDWUDLQVZLOO
EHSOHQWLIXO"


26

'5(..$1,2)78/$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PHUFKDQWRUDEX\HUZLWKDPHDVXULQJSDQLQKLVKDQG

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQRZQHGE\6XNUD&RQVLVWHQWO\UDLQIDOOKDVEHHQHLWKHU
QRUPDORUKLJKSHUKDSVEHFDXVH6DQLJHQHUDOO\GRHVTXLWHZHOOLQWKHKRXVHVRI
6XNUD

:KLOH6DQLGRHVQ·WDWWDLQXFFKDWYDLQWKLVSDUWLFXODUGUHNNDQLWLVZRUWKQRWLQJ
WKDWWKHGUHNNDQPDNHVUHIHUHQFHWRWKHPHDVXULQJSDQZKLFKUHIHUVWRWKH
VLJQLWVHOI

2QHPHDQLQJRIWKLVGUHNNDQLQWKHFRQWH[WRIUDLQVFRXOGEHWKDWWKHPHDVXULQJ
SDQPLJKWEHFRQVWUXHGDVUHSUHVHQWLQJSURVSHULW\³SHRSOHEX\LQJWKLQJVLVD
VLJQRIDERRPLQJHFRQRP\


27

'5(..$1,,2)78/$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQKXQJU\DQGWKLUVW\ZLWKWKHIDFHRIDYXOWXUHDQGDWWDFKHGWRKLVZLIH
DQGFKLOGUHQ

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6DQLDQGWKLVGUHNNDQDOVRUHSUHVHQWV6DQL·V
SRLQWRIKLJKHVWULVHRUKLVSDUDPXFFKDSRLQW:K\WKHQLVUDLQIDOOORZ"7KLV
VHHPVSX]]OLQJ

7KHDQVZHULVEHFDXVHWKHGUHNNDQUHIHUVWRWKLUVW7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKH
YXOWXUHWKHYHKLFOHRI6DQLLVDOVRQRWYHU\DXVSLFLRXV5DLQIDOOLVDOVRORZ
EHFDXVH6DQLLVWKHUXOHURIJULHI

+RZHYHUVLQFH6XNUDLVWKHORUGRIWKLVKRXVHKHKDVPDQDJHGWRHQVXUHWKDW
UDLQIDOOLVQRWYHU\ORZ6RWKHUHZLOOEHVRPHVXIIHULQJEHFDXVHRI6DQLEXW
WKLVLVWHPSHUHGEHFDXVHKHLV´KDSS\µWKDWKHLVXFFKD


28

'5(..$1,,,2)78/$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQZLWKDTXLYHUDQGFODGLQFRDWPDGHRIDSUHFLRXVPHWDOIULJKWHQLQJWKH
DQLPDOVLQWKHIRUHVW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHTXDGUXSHGGUHNNDQUXOHGE\%XGKD5DLQIDOOLVRYHUDOOKLJKDQG
RQO\RQFHKDVLWIDOOHQEHORZWKHDYHUDJHLQGLFDWLQJWKDW6DQLLQWKLVGUHNNDQLV
TXLWHJRRG

:KLOHWKLVGUHNNDQLVQRWGLUHFWO\LQGLFDWLQJDQ\WKLQJWRGRZLWKZDWHUUDLQRU
YHJHWDWLRQWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHFRDWPDGHRISUHFLRXVPHWDOLQGLFDWHV
SURVSHULW\LQJHQHUDO

:KLOHWKHUHLVQRUHIHUHQFHWRZHDSRQVWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHDUPRUTXLYHUDQG
DQLPDOVVHHPWRLPSO\KXQWLQJ$JDLQWKLVFRXOGEHVHHQDVDVLJQRISURVSHULW\³
DIWHUDOOZKRZRXOGZHDUDSUHFLRXVFRDWDQGKXQWZKHQWKHUHLVIDPLQH"


29

'5(..$1,2)95,6&+$.$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$EHDXWLIXO\RXQJZRPDQTXLWHQDNHGHPHUJLQJRXWIURPDQRFHDQWRZDUGVWKH
VKRUHIHHWERXQGXSE\DVHUSHQW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOH6DUSD'UHNNDQUXOHGE\.XMDDQGFRQVLGHULQJWKDW.XMDDQG6DQL
DUHQRWWKHEHVWRIIULHQGVLWLVVXUSULVLQJWKDWWKLVGUHNNDQKROGVWKHUHFRUG
IRUWKHVHFRQGKLJKHVWUDLQIDOOILJXUHRI

2IFRXUVHZLWKUDLQIDOODVZLWKDQ\WKLQJHOVHDQH[FHVVLYHILJXUHLVQRWDOZD\V
JRRG$OVRFRQVLGHULQJWKDWWKLVLVD6DUSD'UHNNDQZHFDQEHTXLWHVXUHWKDW
WKHUDLQVZRXOGKDYHZUHFNHGDORWRIKDYRF

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHRFHDQPDNHVWKLVDZDWHU\GUHNNDQDQGLVVXJJHVWLYHLQ
WZRZD\V2QHLWLQGLFDWHVSOHQWLIXOZDWHUDQGWZRVLQFHWKHRFHDQ·VVDOWZDWHU
LVXQSDODWDEOHLWSRVVLEO\LPSOLHVWKDWWKHUDLQVDUHQRWRIPXFKKHOSWRSHRSOH


30

'5(..$1,,2)95,6&+$.$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$ZRPDQRIPDWHULDOLVWLFQDWXUHZLWKDVHUSHQWFRLOHGDURXQGKHU

\HDU UDLQ 
  

:KLOHWKLVLVDOVRDIHPDOH6DUSD'UHNNDQOLNHWKHRQHDERYH*XUXDQGQRW.XMD
UXOHVWKLVGUHNNDQDQGRQHH[SHFWVJRRGUHVXOWV%XWLQWKLVORQHLQFLGHQW
UDLQIDOOKDVEHHQDOLWWOHORZ

7KHVKRUWDJHZDVSUREDEO\EHFDXVHRIWKHUHIHUHQFHWRPDWHULDOLVPZKLFK
GRHVQ·WDOZD\VJRZHOOZLWK*XUX·VVHQVHRIVSLULWXDOLW\6LQFH6DQLLVHYHQPRUH
KHDYLO\RSSRVHGWRPDWHULDOLVPWKDW*XUXWKLVVWUHQJWKHQVWKLVDUJXPHQW

2IFRXUVHDIWHUVHHLQJWRRPXFKUDLQIDOOLQSHRSOHZRXOGKDYHEHHQTXLWH
KDSS\WRKDYHDOLWWOHOHVVUDLQ6LQFHWKLVLVDOVRD6DUSD'UHNNDQWKH\PLJKW
KDYHWRSXWXSZLWKWKHSUREOHPRIWRRPXFKUDLQIROORZHGE\WRROLWWOH


31

'5(..$1,,,2)95,6&+$.$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$OLRQZLWKDIDFHVLPLODUWRWKDWRIDWXUWOHIULJKWHQLQJZLOGDQLPDOV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHTXDGUXSHGGUHNNDQUXOHGE\&KDQGUDDQGWKHUDLQIDOOKDVEHHQ
GLVDSSRLQWLQJLQWZRRXWRIWKHWKUHHFDVHVZLWKWKHILJXUHVLQEHLQJYHU\
ORZLQGHHG

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHWXUWOHLVWKHRQO\WKLQJWKDWLQGLFDWHVWKDWWKHUHLV
DQ\WKLQJDWDOOLQWKLVGUHNNDQ·VGHVFULSWLRQWKDWLPSOLHVUDLQIDOO5DLQIDOOZKHQ
6DQLLVLQWKLVGUHNNDQLVHUUDWLFSUREDEO\EHFDXVHRI&KDQGUD·VILFNOHQHVV

7KHOLRQ1DUDVLPKDDQGWKHWXUWOH.XUPDDUHERWKDYDWDUVRI9LVKQX6DQLLV
VDLGWREHKLJKO\GHYRWHGWR1DUDVLPKDDQGKDVFRPSRVHGWKH6UL6KDQDLVFKDUD
.ULWD6UL1DUDVLPKD6WXWLLQSUDLVHRI1DUDVLPKD


32

'5(..$1,2)'+$185 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQUHVHPEOLQJDFHQWDXUVWRSSLQJLQKHUPLWDJHDQGUHOLJLRXVSODFHV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDQD\XGDGUHNNDQUXOHGE\*XUXDQGLVDOVRDTXDGUXSHGGUHNNDQ,WLV
KHDUWHQLQJWRVHHWKDWZKHQHYHU6DQLWUDYHOVWKURXJKWKLVGUHNNDQUDLQIDOOKDV
EHHQFRQVLVWHQWO\JRRG

0D\EHWKHIDFWWKDWWKHSHUVRQLVVWRSSLQJLQKHUPLWDJHV³SODFHVRIUHOLJLRQVR
GHDUWR*XUX³LVZKDWLVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKHJRRGUDLQV7KLVLVVWUHQJWKHQHGE\
WKHIDFWWKDW*XUXLVJHQHUDOO\DQH[SDQVLYHJUDKD

:KLOH6DQLWHQGVWREHUHVWULFWLYHZHKDYHWRQRWHWKDWVLQFH6DQLDQG*XUXDUH
ERWKKLJKO\UHOLJLRXVJUDKDV³QHYHUIRUJHWHYHQIRUDPRPHQWWKDW6DQLLVWKH
9DLUDJ\D.DUDND³WKLQJVVHHPWRKDYHSDQQHGRXWTXLWHZHOOLQGHHG


33

'5(..$1,,2)'+$185 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$KDQGVRPHZRPDQEULJKWDVFKDPSDNDIORZHUVLQFRPSOH[LRQPLGGOHVWDWXUH
DQGFDSWLYDWLQJORRN

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\.XMD,QDOOWKHWKUHHFDVHVUDLQIDOOKDVEHHQ
ORZWKRXJKDGPLWWHGO\LQWKHUDLQZDVDOPRVWQRUPDO6WLOOWKLVGUHNNDQ
GRHVQ·WVHHPWRRDXVSLFLRXVIRUUDLQIDOO

,URQLFDOO\WKHUHQRWPXFKWRVXJJHVWWKDWWKHUHZLOOEHDQ\SUREOHPZLWKUDLQV
,QIDFWWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHIORZHUVDFWXDOO\JLYHVXVWKHIHHOLQJWKDWWKHUH
ZLOOEHDQDEXQGDQFHRIUDLQIDOO

3UREDEO\WKHSUREOHPLVEHFDXVHWKLVGUHNNDQIDOOVLQ0HVKDWKHKRXVHZKHUH
6DQLDWWDLQVQHHFKDWYD7KLVDQGWKHIDFWWKDW6DQLDQG.XMDDUHQRWYHU\
IULHQGO\FRXOGLPSO\WKHORZUDLQIDOO


34

'5(..$1,,,2)'+$185 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQZLWKORQJKDLUDVVXPLQJDQLFHSRVWXUHDQGZHDULQJGHHUVNLQDQGVLON
FORWKHV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XU\DZKRLVLQLPLFDOWR6DQL7KLVLVDOVRDQ
$\XGD'UHNNDQDQGVRLWLVVXUSULVLQJWKDWLQWZRRXWRIWKHWKUHHFDVHVWKH
UDLQIDOOKDVEHHQTXLWHJRRG

:HSHUKDSVQHHGWRFRQVLGHUWKHIDFWWKDWWKHVLONLQGLFDWHVSURVSHULW\ZKLFK
LVSUREDEO\GXHWRJRRGUDLQV7KHGHHUVNLQFRXOGLQGLFDWHIUXJDOLW\LQWKHIDFH
RIRSXOHQFHVRPHWKLQJWKDWLVVRGHDUWR6DQL

$QRWKHUIDFWRUWREHERUQHLQPLQGLVWKDWHYHQWKRXJKWKHGUHNNDQORUGLVQRW
YHU\IULHQGO\ZLWK6DQLUDVLORUG*XUXSHUKDSVDFWVDVDPRGHUDWRUWKXV
HQVXULQJJHQHUDOKDSSLQHVV


35

'5(..$1,2)0$.$5$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQZLWKPXFKKDLUSLJERGLHGFDPHOIDFHDQGFDUU\LQJDURSHDQGDQHW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQRZQHGE\6DQLZKRLVDOVRWKHORUGRIWKHKRXVH7KH
UHIHUHQFHWRWKHKDLU\DSSHDUDQFHVHHPVWRDOVREHLQGLFDWLYHRI6DQL·VJHQHUDO
DSSHDUDQFH

:KLOHWKHDYHUDJHLVDERYHWKLVLVODUJHO\EHFDXVHRIWKHERRVWUHFHLYHG
LQ,QERWKWKHRWKHUFDVHVWKHUDLQVKDYHEHHQEHORZQRUPDODQGVRLWLV
KDUGWRUHFRPPHQGWKLVGUHNNDQDVDJUHDWRQHIRUUDLQV

7KHVKRUWIDOOLVSRVVLEO\FDXVHGEHFDXVHRI6DQL·VJHQHUDOO\UHVWULFWLYHQDWXUH
$OVRSOHDVHSD\DWWHQWLRQWRWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHFDPHOWKHVKLSRIWKHGHVHUW
ZKLFKLQGLFDWHVVFDQWLQHVVRIZDWHU


36

'5(..$1,,2)0$.$5$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$EHDXWLIXOZRPDQVNLOOHGLQDUWVH\HVOLNHORWXVSHWDOGHFNHGZLWKFRVWO\
RUQDPHQWV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPLQLQHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XNUD:KLOH6XNUDZRXOGKDYHWULHGWR
HQVXUHJRRGUDLQV6DQL·VKROGDVWKHORUGRIWKHUDVLZRXOGQRGRXEWKDYHDFWHG
OLNHDEUDNH

6WLOOWKHDYHUDJHLVFORVHWRQRUPDODQGWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHFRVWO\RUQDPHQWV
GRHVLQGLFDWHWKDWWKLVLVDGUHNNDQWKDWLVHQGRZHGWRVRPHH[WHQWDWOHDVW
ZLWKWKHDXUDRISURVSHULW\

7KHORWXVDOVRLQGLFDWHVUDLQV-XVWDVWKHSHWDOVRIWKHORWXVWKRXJKLPPHUVHG
LQZDWHUUHPDLQGU\VLPLODUO\6DQLDOVRUHPDLQVXQDIIHFWHGE\WKHTXDQWXPRI
UDLQVEHFDXVHKHLVWKH9DLUDJ\D.DUDND


37

'5(..$1,,,2)0$.$5$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQFRYHUHGRYHUE\DEODQNHWDQGDUPHGZLWKDTXLYHUDUURZVDQGERZ

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\%XGKD:KLOHLQWZRFDVHVWKHUDLQIDOOLVORZLWLV
PRUHWKDQPDGHXSIRULQWKHRWKHUWZRFDVHV³DVDUHVXOWWKHDYHUDJHLVDOPRVW
QRUPDO

1RWRQO\LVWKLVDQ$\XGD'UHNNDQWKHZHDSRQVGHVFULEHGDUHPDQ\0D\EHWKLV
LVSOD\LQJDOLPLWLQJUROHEXWVLQFHGUHNNDQORUG%XGKDLVJHQHUDOO\FODVVHGDVD
EHQHILFWKLVIDFWRUPLJKWKDYHGHOLYHUHGGHFHQWUDLQV

7KHUDLQIDOOZKLOH6DQLLVLQWKLVGUHNNDQVHHPVWRYDU\DORWDQGWKHSRVVLEOH
UHDVRQFRXOGEHEHFDXVHRIWKHPXWDELOLW\RI%XGKDZKREHFRPHVPDOHILFRU
EHQHILFGHSHQGLQJRQKLVDVVRFLDWLRQV


38

'5(..$1,2).80%+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQGLVWXUEHGLQPLQGGUXQNDUGFODGZLWKDGHHUVNLQDQGIDFHUHVHPEOLQJD
YXOWXUH

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6DQLZKRLVDOVRWKHORUGRIWKHUDVLZKLFKLVKLV
0RRODWULNRQD$VH[SHFWHGWKHUDLQIDOODYHUDJHLVORZWKRXJKLQWZRFDVHVWKH
UDLQVKDYHEHHQJRRG

$FFRUGLQJWR6DW\DFKDU\DZKRP9DUDKD0LKLUDTXRWHVOLEHUDOO\LQWKH%ULKDW
-DWDND.XPEDLVHYLOEHFDXVHWKH/DJQDGLSDWLDOVRUXOHVWKHWKKRXVHRIORVVHV
7KLVVHHPVTXLWHDSWLQWKLVLQVWDQFH

7KHYXOWXUHLVDKDUELQJHURIGHDWKDQGHYHQLQWKRVHFDVHVZKHQUDLQIDOOZDV
KLJKRQHVXVSHFWVWKDWLWZRXOGKDYHEHHQGHVWUXFWLYH0D\EHWKHPDQLV
GLVWXUEHGLQPLQGEHFDXVHRIWKLV


39

'5(..$1,,2).80%+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$IHPDOHVHDWHGLQDSDUWO\EXUQWFDUULDJHEHDULQJSRWVRQKHUKHDG

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\%XGKD6LQFHWKLVGLYLVLRQIDOOVLQWKH
PRRODWULNRQDRI6DQLLQUDVLDQGLQWKHKRXVHRI%XGKDLQWKHGUHNNDQWKLQJV
VHHPUHDVRQDEO\JRRG

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHEXUQWFDUULDJHVHHPVWRJLYHDVHPLILHU\IHHOWRWKLV
GUHNNDQ%XWEHFDXVHRIWKHJHQHUDODLURIIULHQGVKLSEHWZHHQ%XGKDDQG6DQL
QRWKLQJYHU\LQDXVSLFLRXVLVLQGLFDWHG

:KDWGRWKHSRWVRQWKHZRPDQ·VKHDGFRQWDLQ":DWHU",IVRGRHVWKLVVXJJHVW
WKDWWKHZDWHUZDVVSHQWLQH[WLQJXLVKLQJWKHFDUULDJH·VILUH"'RHVWKLVGUHNNDQ
LQGLFDWHILUHVDQGWKHXVDJHRIZDWHUWRSXWWKHPRXW"


40

'5(..$1,,,2).80%+$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQEODFNLQFRPSOH[LRQZLWKORQJKDLUDQGZDQGHULQJZLWKLURQSRWV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\6XNUD$XQLTXHWKLQJDERXWWKLVGUHNNDQLVWKDW
LWOLQNVWRJHWKHUWKHPRRODWULNRQDVRI6XNUDDQG6DQLZKRDUHERWKUDMD\RJD
NDUDNDVIRUHDFKRWKHU·VODJDQV

%XWWKLVVDLGWKHGUHNNDQGHVFULSWLRQVHHPVWRUHIOHFW6DQLH[FOXVLYHO\6DQL
UXOHVRYHUWKHFRORUEODFNLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWKORQJKDLUDQGLVDOVRFORVHO\
FRQQHFWHGZLWKLURQ

%XW6XNUD·VZLOOWRRSUHYDLOVEHFDXVHRIRZQHUVKLSRIWKHGUHNNDQDQGVRWKH
UDLQVLQWZRFDVHVKDYHEHHQILQH%XWWKLVVDLGWKHUDLQLQUDQNVDPRQJWKH
ERWWRPILYH


41

'5(..$1,2)0((1$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQHQJDJHGLQKDQGOLQJPDQ\DUWLFOHVGHFNHGZLWKRUQDPHQWVDQGVFURVVLQJ
WKHRFHDQLQDERDW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  

7KLVLVDPDOHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\*XUX&RQVLGHULQJWKDWWKHUDVLLVDZDWHU\RQH
LWLVVXUSULVLQJWKDWWKHUDLQIDOOLVVRORZ,QIDFWLWLVMXWRQFHWKDWQRUPDO
UDLQIDOOKDVEHHQH[SHULHQFHGZKHQ6DQLKDVWUDYHOHGWKURXJKWKLVGUHNNDQ

7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHRUQDPHQWVJLYHVXVDQLOOXVLRQRISURVSHULW\DQGZHDUHOHG
WRDVVXPHWKDW*XUX·VRZQHUVKLSRIERWKWKHUDVLDQGWKHGUHNNDQVKRXOGEH
JRRG8QIRUWXQDWHO\WKLVGRHVQ·WKROGWUXH

7KRXJKWKLVLVDZDWHU\GUHNNDQWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHRFHDQZKLFKLVILOOHGZLWK
VHDZDWHUDQGLVWKHUHIRUHQRWILWIRUKXPDQFRQVXPSWLRQPLJKWLQGLFDWHWKH
SRRUQDWXUHRIUDLQV


42

'5(..$1,,2)0((1$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$EHDXWLIXOZRPDQVDLOLQJLQDERDWZLWKORQJIODJVWRZDUGVWKHRWKHUFRDVW

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  
  
  

7KLVLVDIHPLQLQHGUHNNDQUXOHGE\&KDQGUD7KHDYHUDJHLVDOPRVWQRUPDODQG
LQWKUHHRXWRIWKHIRXUFDVHVWKHUDLQIDOOLVJRRG,QMXVWRQHLQVWDQFHGRHVLW
IDOOEHORZWKHPDUN

:KLOHWKLVLVDOVRDZDWHU\GUHNNDQOLNHWKHRQHEHIRUHWKHUHLVQRUHIHUHQFHWR
WKHRFHDQVRZHFDQDVVXPHWKDWWKHERDWLVWUDYHOLQJLQDULYHUZKRVHZDWHUV
FDQEHXVHGE\KXPDQVIRUTXHQFKLQJWKHLUWKLUVW

7KHIODJVLQGLFDWHYLFWRU\DQGWKHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHZRPDQLVVXJJHVWLYHRI
&KDQGUD·VIHPLQLQHQDWXUH7KHPLOGQHVVRIWKHUDVLORUG*XUXDQGGUHNNDQORUG
&KDQGUDVHHPWRKDYHRYHUFRPH6DQL·VKDUVKQHVVWKXVHQVXULQJJRRGUDLQV


43

'5(..$1,,,2)0((1$ 


G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!
G!G!
G!G!

G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!
G!G!G!G!


$PDQVWUDQGHGLQDIRUHVWQDNHGDQGDWWDFNHGE\VHUSHQWVDQGWKLHYHV

\HDU UDLQ 
  
  

7KLVPDOH6DUSD'UHNNDQZKLFKLVUXOHGE\.XMDLVWKHILQDOGUHNNDQRIWKH
]RGLDF:KLOHRQHZRXOGOLNHWRTXLWRQDSRVLWLYHDQGFKHHUIXOQRWHWKHGUHNNDQ
GHVFULSWLRQPDNHVWKLVLPSRVVLEOH

7KHUHLVDEVROXWHO\QRUHIHUHQFHWRUDLQEXWWKHUHDVRQZK\ZHKDYHUHIHUUHG
WR6DQLDVWKHORUGRIWKHUDLQVLVEHFDXVHRIKLVDELOLW\WRFDXVHVRUURZ7KLV
GUHNNDQUHIOHFWVDJRQ\LIQRWKLQJHOVH

7KLVGUHNNDQLQGLFDWHVUDLQWKDWFDXVHVDORWRIKDUGVKLSWRSHRSOH6DQLWKH
ILQDOSODQHWLQWKH9HGLFVFKHPHRIWKLQJVLVVDLGWRKDYHWKHODVWODXJKDQGKDV
PDQDJHGWRGRWKLVZLWKWKHILQDOGUHNNDQRI0HHQDDQGWKHUHIRUHWKH]RGLDF


44

3$57,1*7+28*+76

$W$VL]HGSDJHVWKLVKDVSHUKDSVEHHQDORQJGRFXPHQWDQG,WKDQN\RX
IRUWKHSDWLHQFH\RXKDYHVKRZQ

$VWURORJ\OLNHDOORWKHUVFLHQFHVKDVWREHVXVWDLQHGE\UHVHDUFKWKH
FRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQFDXVHDQGHIIHFWDQGWKHSDLQIXO³DQGXVXDOO\VORZDQG
ODERULRXV³SURFHVVRIFRUUHODWLQJUHDOLW\ZLWKWKHVWDUVDQGGLVFRYHULQJDQHZ
WKHGLFWXPDVDERYHVREHORZ

7RZKDWH[WHQWZDV,ULJKWLQDQDO\]LQJWKHVWDWXVRIUDLQIDOOXVLQJRQO\6DQLDV
P\UHIHUHQFHSRLQWDQGVWXG\LQJWKHGUHNNDQWKDWKHRFFXSLHGZKHQ6XU\D
HQWHUHG3XVK\D")UDQNO\,GRQRWNQRZ7KLVZDVMXVWDWKRXJKWWKDWVWUXFN
PH³DQGVLQFH6DQLLVWKHORUGRIP\WK,EHOLHYHG³DQGVWLOOEHOLHYH³WKDWWKLV
VWURNHRILQWXLWLRQFDPHIURP7KH&UXHO2QHDWKRXJKWWKDWLVVWUHQJWKHQHGE\
WKHIDFWWKDW6DQLDVSHFWVERWK&KDQGUDDQG6XNUDWKHNDUDNDVIRUZDWHULQP\
ELUWKFKDUW³DQG,GHFLGHGWRSXUVXHP\UHVHDUFKDQGWDNHLWWRLWVORJLFDO
FRQFOXVLRQ)RUWXQDWHO\LWLVQHYHUDZULWHU·VORWWRMXGJHKLVRZQZRUNDQGVR,
OHDYHWKLVRQHURXVWDVNWRP\UHDGHUV

,GRQRWZLVKWRVWDWHWKDWP\PHWKRGLVULJKW6WLOOOHVVHUGR,VHHNWRFODLP
WKDWWKLVLVWKHRQO\ULJKWZD\RIGRLQJLW%XWWKHQDJDLQWKHSXUSRVHRI
UHVHDUFKLVQRWDOZD\VDERXWEHLQJULJKW,WLVDERXWVSDUNLQJWKRXJKWLQRWKHUV
DQGLIP\KXPEOHHIIRUWVKDYHPDGH\RXIHHOWKDW\RXWRRVKRXOGH[SHQGWLPH
DQGHIIRUWLQWKHVHDUFKIRUWUXWKDQGUHDOLW\³ERWKZLWKLQ-\RWLVKDQGRXWVLGH
RILW³ZHOO,VKDOOWKHQIHHOWKDWP\HIIRUWVKDYHERUQHIUXLW

  

45