Operarecognovitb01platuoft PDF

SCRIPTORUM CLASSICORUM
BIBLIOTHECA OXONIENSIS
OXONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO
LONDINI ET NOVI EBORACI
APUD HENRICUM FROWDE
PLATONIS OPERA
RECOGNOVIT
BREVIQVE ADNOTATIONE CRITICA IXSTRVXIT
lOANNES BURNET
IN VNIVERSITATE ANDREANA LITTERARVM GRAECARVM PROFESSOR
COLLEGII MERTONENSIS OLIM SOCIVS
TOMVS I
TETRALOGIAS I-II CONTINENS
,;':
\
OXONII
E TYPOGRAPHEO CLARENDONIANO
OXONII
Excudebat Horatius Hart
Typographus academicus
A.
/"
PRAEFATIO
Ceteris libris Platonicis cum tum fide
antiquitate
excellerc iam pridem constat inter omnes codicem
Clarkianum sive Bodleianum (Bekkeri (, Schanzii B)
anno DCCCXCV exaratum, et Parisinum 1807 (Bek-
keri A) eiusdem fere aetatis. his post egregiam
viri doctissimi M. Schanz in librorum stirpibus in-
dagandis collocatam operam tertius accassit Venetus

bibliothecae Marcianae Append. Class. 4, cod. i
(Bekkeri t, Schanzii T). cum autem alia sit ratio
tetralogiarum I-VII, alia reliquarum, de illis tantum
hoc loco dicendum est. scilicet sermones Platonici,
iam antiquitus in tetralogias dispositi, duo volumina
explevisse videntur, cuius rei vestigium servant verba
TcAo? Tov T:p(aTov ^LJSXCov in Marciano aliisque quibus-
dam libris ad calcem Menexeni adscripta. eundem
ordinem secuta sunt apographa vetustissima ut non
mirum sit in tanto librorum interitu Parisini prius,
alterum Clarkiani volumen periisse.
Prioris igitur voluminis imaginem refert Clarkianus,
sed ne hanc quidem integram, cum casu aliquo factum
sit ut tetralogiam VII non exhibeat ; Marcianus,
qui Civitatem et Timaeum continet, sed posteriora
a recentioribus librariis postea addita, habet a prima
manu tetralogias I-VII et ex octava Clitophontem et
Civitatis libros i-iii, 389 d. his igitur fundamentis
nititur prioris voluminis memoria; quod enim iam
PRAEFATIO
senserat M. Wohlrab, duas omnino codicum familias
esse, id M. Schanz, qui antea cum Cobeto nil fere de-
terioribtis ut aiebat tribuerat, libello plus viginti abhinc

annos edito^ tam certis indiciis comprobavit, ut nullus
iam locus dubitandi relictus sit. licet enim quibusdam,
velut ipsi M, Wohlrab, non probaverit reh*quos libros
a Clarkiano et Marciano totos pendere, at nemo nunc
negabit his hbris Platonis memoriam ita contineri ut
ceteris omnibus paene sine damno carere possemus.

sed de hac re in commentariolo critico mox edendo
fusius disputare constitui hoc tantum nunc dico,
;
Schanzium meo iudicio verum vidisse rectissimeque

farraginis librorum a Bekkero et Stallbaumio con-
gestae iacturam fecissc.
Priorem igitur in tetralogiis I-VI familiam ducit
Clarkianus, Marcianus alteram. et Clarkiani quidem
ab omnibus conceditur summam esse auctoritatem,
Marcianum diu neglectum in lucem rursus protraxit
M. Schanz, quae res non mediocriter Platonis me-
moriae profuit. licet enim Clarkiani ea sit indoles ut
singula quaeque fidelius repraesentet, quippe cuius
menda eiusmodi fere sint ut recta via ad verum ducant,
at saepius omittendo peccat et lacunis hiat, quae nunc
nullo negotio e Marciano sarciii possunt, cum antea
ad apographa nuUius fere auctoritatis, praesertim
Venetum 184 (Bekkeii H, Schanzii E) in Bessarionis
usum exaratum, confugiendum esset. adde quod
passim in Clarkiano intempestive corrigentium mani-
bus prisca scriptura periit et ex eius apographis
Tubingensi (Stallbaumii %, Schanzii C) et Veneto 185
'
Uber den Platocodex der Markusbibliothek in Venedig, Append.
Ciass. 4, Nr. i. Leipzig, 1877.
PRAEFATIO .<^
(Bekkeri IT, Schanzii D) repetenda est. quae cum ita

sint, si Clarkianus solus suppeteret, Platonem habere-
mus sed mancum et mutilum et passim sollertis critici
indigentem, quae tamen res propterea fugit parum dih*-

gentem lectorem quia textus vulgatus, ex apographo
quodam Marciani descriptus, telam quandam suggerit
cui editores Clarkianas lectiones intexere possint.
Marcianum, alterius familiae ducem, scripsit Hbrarius
paulo eruditior qui perraro omittendo peccat nec fere

ea scribit quae nullo pacto intellegi possint. correc-
tiones et varias lectiones ipse in margine passim ad-
scripsit. recte plerumque decurrit oratio ut nusquam
fere haereas. quae omnia ne Hbrario adscribenda esse
putemus suo arbitrio corrigenti interpolanti idcirco
prohibemur, quod non semel sinceram et antiquam
lectionem hic Hber solus servavit. cuius rei unum
exemplum apponere iuvat nobiHssimum locum Phae-
donis 77 e. hic Socrates vulgo credebatur dixisse
'A\Aa XPTJ avrQ) eTraSetz; e/cao-TTjs rjfxipas fcoj av kîaa-r^jai
(id est, ut videtur, kâcn^Ti), quae etiam in prioris

famiHae libris sic scripta invenies. primus verum
vidit Heindorf, eâraarjTe rescribere iubens. evolve
nunc Marcianum. in textu scriptum videbis eâTrat-
o-jjre, cum primo aspectu ante oculos habere
librarius
âTTaTTâ-r]T sibi sit sed, cum in margine
visus ;
Clarkianum iUud ^tdo-7;rai adscriptum sit, hanc sci-

Hcet correctionem rettulit textus vulgatus. priscam
scripturam in uno Vindobonensi T invenies, cum alia
Marciani apographa eêrdo-Tjre, fêuTrdo-jjrat vel similia
exhibeant. videsne Schanzium recte statuisse alterius
familiae memoriam Marciano totam contineri ?
Ouae cum ita sint, satis apparet Marcianum ex
PRAEFATIO
optimae notae exemplari descriptum esse, quod non
sine causa suspiceris ipsum Parisini deperditum volu-
men fuisse. sed de hac re cum ad Civitatem perve-
nerimus occasio erit dicendi ; nunc satis sit cognovisse
praeter spem novum et idoneum testem Schanzium

protulisse. hoc tamen cavendum ne plus iusto Mar-
ciano tribuamus ; nam in singulis verbis conformandis
apparet eius testimonium minus valere. notandum
imprimis saepius immutatum esse verborum ordinem,
ut fit inter scribendum sententiae magis quam
dum
litterulis animum intendimus, quod ipsa signa transpo-
sitionis a prima manu passim addita testantur. quare
in iis et eiusmodi rebus boni critici est Clarkiani
testimonio stare, cum praesertim in scribendi ratione
propius ad sinceram Atticorum normam accedat.
Sunt praeterea codices interpolati permuUi qui,
quanquam priori familiae si summam rem spectas
adnumerandi sunt, identidem lecliones alteri proprias
exhibent. horum instar est omnium codex Vindobo-
nensis 54, suppl. phil. Gr. 7 (Stallbaumii Vind. 1,
Schanzii W), qui ita cuni Clarkiano consentit ut scrip-

turas Marcianas passim admisceat. quin etiam haud
raro lectiones servavit quae, tametsi vetustatis notam
gerunt, neutri familiae referre possis. huic libro simil-
limus fuit quem secutus est vetus Armenius interpres
Euthyphronis, Critonis, Apologiae, cuius lectiones
Conybeare noster^ qui tamen
publici iuris fecit F. C.
Vindobonensi nondum bene cognito, eo adductus est ut
apographi foede interpolati Vaticani 225 (Bekkeri A)
partes susciperet. at si quid video huiusmodi res est.
extitit olim Platonis recensio a nostra diversa, cuius
' American Joitrnttl of Philology, vol. xii. pp. 193 sqq.
PRAEFATIO .^r
vestigia etiam apud Eusebium, Stobaeum aliosque

scriptores deprehendas, unde non ita pauca in codices
istos defluxerunt. quod si verum est, ut prorsus
Schanzio assentiendum tertiam famih"am, quod non-
nuHis placuit, hodie non extare iudicanti, nec multum
consensui Marciani et Vindobonensis tribuenti, ita
quotquot hic praebet singulares lectiones diligentis-

sime erunt perpendendae, praesertim sicubi versio
Armeniaca accesserit.
Superest ut de fide fragmentorum Phaedonis a viro
clarissimo Flinders Petrie nuper repertorum pauca
dicamus, quae intra centum annos post Platonem
mortuum in Aegypto papyro exarata esse videntur.
quorum meo quidem iudicio praecipuus est usus quod
non sinunt plus iusto Clarkiano tribuere, cum non
semel cum altera familia conspirent. sed tanta incuria
scripta sunt, tot manifestis erroribus scatent, ut vel
inde colligas quantum praestent codices ex
nostri
optimis exemplaribus descripti apographis quae iam
tum vili pretio in usum Htteratorum plebis prostabant.
Lex est huius editionis ut, quantum fieri potest,
sermo Platonicus, nisi in rebus quae ad scribendi
rationem pertinent, talis servetur qualis in communi
duarum famiHarum tamen
fonte extiterit, adhibito
Vindobonensi quando antiquiorem
et affinibus eius si
lectionem servasse videantur. non erat nostrum

virorum doctorum coniecturas nec nostras in textum
recipere praeter eas quae tam certae et firmatae
essent ut de iis vix dubitari possit. quam rationem
in verbis scribendis secutus sim facile intellegent
harum rerum periti, ceteri non curabunt.
Codicem Clarkianum, cum Oxonii essem, multis
PRAEFATIO
locis inspexi, nondum editum
Politicum a Schanzio
vehementer doleo Clarkianum
ipse accurate contuli.
phototypice expressum non prius inter manus fuisse
quam plagulas plerasque correxissem. mihi primo
contigit Marcianas lectiones in Phaedone et Politico
divulgare, cum hic a Schanzio nondum editus sit, ille
cditus quidem sed nondum adhibito Marciano. quod

ut facere possim, acceptum refero bibliothecario
Veneto, Comiti Soranzo, qui intercedente T. W. Allen
hos dialogos meum in usum phototypice exprimen-
dos curavit. in rehquis dialogis codicum notitiam
plerumque a Schanzio Wohlrabio mutuatus sum,
et
in Sophista praesto nitidissima Ottonis Apelt
fuit
editio. sicubi autem de Vindobonensi (W) non mihi

constaret, in eius locum successere affines, praesertim
Vindobonensis 109 (Bekkcri 4>).
lOANNES BURNET.
Scribebam Andreapoli Scotoriim
S. Salvatoris et D. Lconardi
e coUegio
mense Novembri m.dccc.xcix.
De codice Vindobonensi (W) a viro doctissimo

losepho Kral mcliora edoctus, vidi, in Phaedone prae-
sertim, longius a Schanzianis rationibus discedendum
esse. nunc igitur habes huius dialogi textum ad trium
codicum BTW auctoritatem retractatum.
lOANNES BURNET.
mense Novembri m.cm.v.
/^l
DIALOGORVM ORDO
TOMVS I
TeTRALOGIA I ED. STEPH.

EVTHYPHRO I- PP- 2-l6
Apologia Socratis . . . . I. pp. 17-42
Crito I. pp. 43-54
Phaedo I- PP- 57-118
Tetralogia II
Cratylvs I- PP- 383-440
Theaetetvs I- PP- 142-210
Sophista I- PP' 216-268
Politicvs . . . . . . II. pp. 257-311
TOMVS II
Tetralogia III
Parmenides III. pp. 126-166
Philebvs . . . . . . II. pp. 11-67
Symposivm III. pp. 172-223
Phaedrvs lll. pp. 227-279
Tetralogia IV
Alcibiades I II. pp. 103-135
Alcibiades II II. pp. 138-151
HlPPARCHVS II. pp. 225-232
Amatores I- PP- 132-139
DIALOGORVM ORDO
TOMVS III
Tetralogia V
Theages I. pp. 121-131
Charmides II. pp. 153-176
Laches II. pp. 178-201
Lvsis II. pp. 203-223
Tetralogia VI
Evthydemvs I. pp. 271-307
Protagoras . I. pp. 309-362
GORGIAS I. pp. 447-527
Meno . II. pp. 70-100
Tetralogia VII
HlPPIAS MAIOR III. pp. 281-304
HlPPIAS MINOR I. pp. 363-376
lo . I. pp. 530-542
Menexenvs . II. pp. 234-249
TOMVS IV
Tetralogia VIII
Clitopho III. pp. 406-410
Respvblica . II. pp. 327-621
Timaevs III. pp. 17-105
Critias . III. pp. I06-I2I
DIALOGORVM ORDO
4^
TOMVS V X"'^
Tetralogia IX
MlNOS . II. pp. 313-321
Leges . II. pp. 624-969
Epinomis n. pp. 973-992

Epistvlae III. pp. 309-363
M & VI
J<
Definitiones III. pp. 4II-4I6
NOeEYOMENOI
De Ivsto pp. 372-375
De Virtvte pp. 376-379
Demodocvs pp. 380-386
SlSYPHVS pp- 387-391
Ervxias pp. 392-406
axiochvs pp. 364-372
SIGLA
B= cod. Bodleianus, MS. E. D. Clarke 39 = Bekkeri Qt
T = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. i = Bekkeri t
W = cod. Vindobonensis 54, suppl. phil. Gr. 7 = Stallbaumii

Vind. I
C= cod. Crusianus siue Tubingensis = Stallbaumii X

D = cod. Venetus 185 = Bekkeri n
G = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. 54 = Bekkeri A
V = cod. Vindobonensis 109 = Bekkeri *
Arm. = Versio Armeniaca
Ars. = Papyrus Arsinoitica a Flinders
Petrie reperta
Berol. = Papyrus Berolinensis 9782 (ed.

Diels et Schubart 1905)
Recentiores manus librorum BTW litteris btw significantur
Codicis W lediofies cutn T consentientes commevioravi, lec-

tiones cum B consentientes silentio fere praeterii
ET0T*PI1N
If T
ET0Y4)PX2N SXIKPATHS ^

p.2
ET0. Ti vea>Tpov, S "SooKpaTes, yeyovev, otl cv Tas h a
AuKeto) KaraAtTTcby 8tarpt/3as ivOdbe vvv 8tarpt/3et9 Trept ttjv
Tov âcrtAecos crroai'; ov ydp ttov Kal croi ye biKr] tls ovcra
TvyxdveL Ttpbs tov âcrikia utcnrep ^fxoL
2X2. Ovrot brj 'AOrjvaLoC ye, S EvOvcppaiV, bLKr]v avTr]V 5
KaAoSo-iy dXka ypa(f)r]v.

ET0. Tt ^rjs; ypacprjv o-e rts, &>? eotKe, yiypairraL' ov b
ydp KLv6 y KaTayv(iiC!-op.aL, cbs cru ^Tepov.
Sil. Ov ydp ovv.
ET0. 'AAAa cre aAAos;
212. ndyu ye. 5
ET0. Tts owros;

212. Ovb^ avTOi irdvv tl yLyvuxrKO), a> Yivdv(f)po)V, tov
dvbpa, v4os ydp tls ptoL cf)aLveTaL Kal dyvcas' ovofxaôvcrL
fjLevTOL avTov, o)? iy(o]xaL, MeArjror. ecrrt be tuiv brjfxoDV
YlLTOevs, et rtzâ rco exêts ITtrêâ MeÂrjroy olov TeTavoTpL^â 10
Kat ov Trdvv evyeveLOV, eTiiypvTiOV be.

ET0. OvK evvoG), S) ScoK/aares' dAAa 8?; rtW ypacf>rjv
(re yeypaiTTaL; C
2X2. "Hyrtiâ; ovk dyevvrj, efJLOLye boKeX' to ydp veov
B T as 5 Ev6v(ppaiv constanter B T, plerumque

Was
7t om.
W
:
: S) Evdv<ppov B^ b 2 crv B (Ty T-e T

: 2 ws t/j.oiye t
PLATO, VOL. I. i, X
ac nAATXlNOS
ovra ToaovTov TTpayjxa eyvaiKsvaL ov (âvkov icrTiv. eKelvos
yap, u)s (f)r](nv, olbe Tiva Tpoirov ol vioi 8ta<^êipovrai koX
6 riVes ot biacpOeipovTes avTovs. Kal Kivhvvevei o-o(})6s tls
eTvai, Kal ttjv i[xi]V ap.a6iav KaTLbcov o)? bLa(f)6e[povTos Toiis
rj\LKL(OTas avTov, ^pêTaL KarqyoprjcrcDV p.ov axnrep irpos

}xr]Tepa irpos ti]V ttoKlv. Kal (ftaLveTaC p.0L t5)V ttoXltlkcov
d p.6vos ap\e(TdaL 6p6(as' 6p6S>s yap (cttl t&v v4(t)v iTpojTov
i7TLiJLX.ri6rjvaL ottcoj icrovTaL otl apL(TTOL, wo-Trep yecopybv

aya6ov tG)v vecov ^vtG)V elKos TrpwTov eTTLp.e\r]6rjvaL, p.eTa
8e TOVTO K(iL t5)V aKkcav. kcll brj kol MeÂrjros to-cos TTpG)TOV
3 /xey rjixas eKKa6aLpL tovs tG)V viu)V tcls ^Xda-Tas 8ta0êt-

povTas, c5s (f)r](rLV CTretra p.Ta tovto brjXov otl tGv TTpea--
^VTcpcav iTLp.ekr}6ls TrkeLa-Tcav Kal pi.eyi(rTcx)V dya6G)V alTLOs

Tjj irdkeL yeinjo-erat, u>s ye t6 et/co? o-u/i/S^rat eK TOLavTvis
5 dpxv^ dpâ]xiv(a.
ET0. BovkoLjxr^v dv, 6) ^(OKpaTes, dAA' 6ppu)b(o fxr] tov-

vavTLOv yevrjTaL' drex^^cSs ydp fxoL boKel d(f)' kcTTLas apxea-6aL
KaKovpydv ti]v mkLV, eTTLêLpG^v dbLKelv ai. KaC p.oL keye,
tC koll TTOLovvTa ae (f)r]a-L bLa(f)6eCpeLV tovs veovs;
b 212. AroTra, a> 6avp.da-Le, w? ovro) y aKoxxraL. (f)r]a-l ydp
fxe TTOLr]Ti]v elvaL 6eG)V, Ka\ u)S KaLvovs iToiovvTa 6eovs tovs
8' dpxaCovs ov vo^xCôvTa eypa\fraTO tovto)V avrGiV eveKa,
u>s (f)r](TLV.
5 ET0. Mavddvot), S ScoKpares* ort S?) av t6 baLp.6vLov

^rjs (TavT<2 eKdcTTOTe yCyveadaL. co? ovv KaivoTOfxovvTds
aov TTepl TCL 6eLa yeypaiTTaL TavTr]v Tr]v ypa(^r]V, KaX d)?
bLaâkwv br] ep^^TaL els t6 bLKaaT-qpiov, eibcos otl evbLd-
fioka Ta TOLavTa 7Tp6s tovs TTokkovs. Kal e]xov ydp tol,
C OTOV TL keyo) ev Trj eKKkr]a-Ca TTepl tG)V 6eCo)V, TTpokeyo)v
avTols Ta p.ekkovTa, KaTayekGiaLV ws p.aLvopevov KaCTOL
C 7 wartrtp T W ois B e8 irphs om. al. Cobet a2 aij BT

W
:
yp. : Tf ois W b2 jTonjTî' (hai /ue T b8 SiaâKilDv (sic)

BTw : Sia^dWcay W t : iv &\\<f SiafidWwy B^
ET0T4>Pf2N 3^
ovbev OTL ovK akriOes eipjjKa <av Trpoe^LTTOv, aAA' o/icos (p6o-
vovaiv yjfXLV Tracn toij tolovtols. aX.)C ovbev avT(x>v XPV

<f)povTLC(LV, aXX' oiMoa-e Uvai. 5
2X2. '12 (pCXe Kv6v({)p(ov, akXa to jjiev KaTayiXacrOrjvaL

X(rois ovbev Trpayp.a. 'AdrjvaLOLS ydp tol, o)? e//ot So/cei,
ov (r(j)6bpa /xeAet av TLva beLvbv ot(avTaL elvai, fxri fxcvToi
bLbaa-KaXLKov ttjs avrov cro(f)Las' ov 8' av /cai aWovs otcov-
rai TTOLelv tolovtovs, 6vp.ovvTaL, eir' ovv (f)66v<^ w? (tv Ae'yet?, d

eire 81' aAAo ri.
ET0. Tovrov ovv Trepi o7ra>? Trore TTpbs e/ie (XOVctlv, ov

irdvv TTL6viJ.(a TreLpadrjvaL.
212. 'la-dis yap av fxfv 8oKer? (nrdvLov creaxrrbv 7rape'xety 5
Kot StSacTKety ovk k6iX.kLV Tr]v creavTOV cro^piav' eyo) 8e

(poôvfxaL p.r] vTrb ^Lkca>6p(i)T:Las boKU) avTols OTLTiep eyo)
fKKexyixev(t)S iravTl avbpl keyeLV, ov p.6vov avev fXLcrdov, dkka
Kal TTpocTTLêls av rjbe(i)S et rt? /xou eê'Aet aKOvetr. et
fxev ovv, 6 wvbrj ekeyov, fxekkoLev p.ov KaTayekdv wo-Trep 10
av (f)rjs a-axrrov, oi/bev hv eir/ dr]bes TTaiôvTas kcu yekS)VTas e

ev T(2 bLKaaTr}pi(o bLayayelv et 8e o-7rov8ao-oz/rat, tovt' ijbri
OTrri d7ro/3?;o-erai dbrikov TTki]v vp.LV tols fxdvTea-LV.
ET0. 'AAA' to-cos ovbev earaL, S) ^(oKpaTes, irpdyixa, dAAa

(Tv re Kara vovv dyo)VLfi tt]V biKr^v, olp.aL be Kal efxe Tr]v 5
efxrjv.
2f2. "EoTtr be br] croi, o) Yiv6v(ppo)v, rty t/ 8tKj/;
(f)vyeLS avTr]v 7/ StwKet?;

ET0. AiwKO).
212. Tizâ; 10
ET0. Oi' bL(oKO)v av boK(a ixaive(r6ai. 4
2X2. Tt be; 'ueTop.ev^v TLva StwKets; -
ET0. noAAoi5 ye bel TTeTecr6aL, os ye Tt^yxdiêi wv ev

fxdka irpea-^VTqs.
d. 7 oTi vapex'^ W d9 iOeKfi T 4d4\oi Bt 6 2 Sidyeiv

W
:
P*"-
pr. (TirovSd^TotTai B" T W Arm. : (xirovSdôvras B S' 3 7
5? BT : ye naX S(l W
4a nAATilNOS
5 2f2. Tt? ovTos;
'
ET0. 'O ifibs Trarrip.

2X2. *0 (Tos, u) ^\ti<tt;
ET0. Udvv fjLv ovv.
212. "EoTiy 5e r^ to iyK\r][xa Koi tCvos t} hCKr];
lo ET0. ôvov, a> SwKpares.

2X2. 'HpaKAei?. ?] ttov, o> Fiv6v(f)pcdv, dyvoeXTai vtto tcSv
rroAAwy ottt/ 'TroTe dp^cSs fX^'* ^^ y^P olixaC ye tot; eTrtTU-
b x^^^^^ [dp^&is] avTO TrpdâL dAAa Trdppco ttou 7/8rj ao^pCas
ekavvovTos.
ET0. Uoppoi fxevTOL vrf ACa, S) '2(0KpaTs.
2X2. 'Eo-Tiy 8e br] tS>v olKfCcov tls 6 TeOveois vtto tov
5 aôv iraTpos; rj brj\a br]; ov ydp dv ttov virip ye dAAo-

Tpiou iiTc^rjcrOa (f)6vov avT(S.
ET0. reAoiov, a> 2&)KpaTes, OTt otei ti bLa(f>piv etre
dAAoTptos etre ot/cetos 6 reîêcos, dAA' ov tovto ijlovov belv
(j^vXdTTfLV, elre ev bC^r] ^ktlvv 6 KTeCvas etTe pir], Kal ei
lo jJLiV v StKT/, edv, et be yJ], eTre^teWt, kdvnep 6 KTeCvas crvv-
C ecTTLOs (TOL KaX 6]ioTpdTTôs if' tcToi' ydp To ixCa(Tp.a yCyveTaL

idv (Tvvrjs tcd toiovt(o (TvveLb(os Kal /x?; d(f)0(TLOLS (TeavTov Te
Kol eKelvov Trj bC^r] eTTe^L(av. eTret 6 ye diTodavoiV 7TekaTr]s

TLS 7/y ejuds, Kal ws eyeu>pyovp.ev ev Trj Nd^co, e^7/Teuei^
5 ejcet Trap' 17/xtz/. 7rapoty7/o-as ovv Kal SpyLCTOels Tcoy otKeTwy
Tivt tS>v rjfxeTepcov diTO(T(pdTTeL avTov. 6 ovv iTaTr^p crvvbr]-
aas Tovs TTobas koll Tas xelpas avrov, KaTa(Ba\d>v els Td(f>pov
TLvd, TTefXTTeL bevpo dvbpa 7Tev<T6]xevov tov e^r]yr]Tov otl XP^^V
d, TTOteti'. ev be tovt<^ T(S XP^^V "^^^ bebefxevov o>kLy(i>peL T

Kal 7//xe'Aet cos dvbpo<f>6vov Kal ovbev dv iTpdyp.a el kcll dtro-
ddvoL, oTTep ovv KOL eTTaOev vtto ydp At/xou xat pCyovs Kal
S, 12 4iriTvxoyTos B iTriTvxouTos eluai TW b i opdSis seclusi

W
:
V)^7) BT : om. b5 irov inrep ye oKXoTplov T irov ye virfp:
aWoTpiou B : iroTe vwfp aWoTpiov ye W C 8 xp^'^V pr. B Suidas :

XP^B^TW
;
ET0T(I>Pi2N 4d
tG>v b(Tfj.(i>v aT:o6vr](TKi. Trplv tov ayyekov Trapa tov ^r]yrj-
Tov acjiLKecrdat.. TavTa bi] ovv Kal ayavaKTel o re TraTr^p Ka\ 5
ol akXoL otKetoi, ort eyoii vnep tov avbpo(f)6vov ra) TxaTpl
(povov (TTeêpxojxai ovtc aTTOKTeCvavTt, fos (f)a(riv e/cctroi,
oiir' et ort fxikiaTa aTT^KTtvv, avbpo(f)6vov ye oirros tov

aT7o6av6vTos, ov belv (f^povTtCftv VTckp tov toiovtov av6crtov
yap eTvat t6 vov TraTpX (f>6vov 7re^te'rat Ka/cws etSoVes, 6
o) '2(i>KpaTes, To Oeiov ws exî tov ocrtov re Trepi xat tov
avocTLOv.
212. Si 8e bi] 77/00? Atos, o Kv6v(f>p())v, ovTco^rl aKptû>s

otet eTTL(TTa(rdat irepl tS)v 6eio)v ottj] exet, Kat rcSr octloov re 5
Kot avo(Tt(Dv, &crT TOVTO)v ovTd) 7Tpax6evT(ov ci)S (Tv Ae'yets,
ov (})0j3ri btKaC6pLvos rw iTaTpl ottcos /xt/ av <tv av6crtov
TTpayp.a Tvyxavr]s TTpa.TTcov

ET0. Ovbev yap av fxov ocpeXos etr;, St ScuKpare?, ovbi
ro) hv btacpepot F.v6v(f>pot)v t^v ttoWQv av6p(07T(t)v, et fxi] to. 5
rotairra Trcxi^ra aKpt(3(as elbetr]v.
212. 'Ap' ovv fJLOt, o) 6avp.acrte ^v6v^po)v, Kpa.Tt(TT6v ecrri
IxaOrfTj] (T(a yeve(T6at, Kal irpo Trjs ypa(f)rjs ttjs Trpos Me'Ar;roy
avra TavTa TTpoKaXeicr6at avT6v, keyovTa ort eycoye Kal iv 5
rcp ep.TTpo(T6ev xporcp to. 6eia Trept TroAAoC kTTOLov]xr]v eibevat,
Kal vvv TTtbr] fxe eKclvos avToa^bt(x(ovT(i (pr](rt Ka\ KatvoTO-
fxovvTa Trepi rwv 6to)v iâfxapTavetv, fxadr]Ti]S br] yeyova aos
"Kai ei fxev, o) Me'Arjre," (f)atr]v av, " F>vdv(f)pova ojuoAoyety
(T0(f)6v etvat Tct rotavTa, [Ka\] 6p6(iis vofxtêtv Ka\ ejue rjyov b
Kai fxr] btKdôv et 8e fxrj, eKetrcj) rctJ StSao-KoAci) Acix^ btKrfv
irpoTepov rf kfxoi, o)s tovs TrpecrjBvTepovs bta(f)6eipovTt ejue re
Kai t6v avTov 7rare'pa, (fxk fxkv btb(x(TKOVTt, eKeivov b\ vovde-
TovvTi T Ka\ KoX.(xCojrrt" Kat av fxrf fxot Trei^r^Tat fxrfbe a(pir] 5
d 5 ravTo] ravrri B^ d 7 (ve^fpxofiai BT : f^fpxo/xai W

69 &v T om. B : fiov Heusde : ôj BT a 7 (prjat B : om. T
b I Kai seclusi Ka). ifif T Wb Arm. : tê B t> 4-5 SiSa.(rKovri
. . . vovdfTovvTi . . . Ko\d(ovTi] SiSdffKOVTa . . . vovdfTovvra . . . KoXdôvra
BT b 5 T B : om. T
;
5b nAATX2NOS
TTJs Si/cr/s T) avT (jxov ypa(\)r]Tai (re, avTO. TavTa kiynv kv rw
biKacTTripLio h npovKaX.ovp.r^v avTov;
ET0. Nat p.a ACa, co 'Eu>KpaTs, d apa e/ie Tnx^tpria-et,
C ypd(pe<T6ai., evpoLp.' av, o)? o1p.ai, ottt] (raOpos kcrTiv, Kal ttoXv
&v qp.tv TrpoTepov Trept iKeCvov Aoyos eyeveTO iv t<2 bt,Kaa-Tr]pL(a
7j rrepl e/jtoi).
2f2. Kat iy(a tol, ui ^tAe eTalpe, Tawa yLyv(oa-K()v

5 ixadr}Ti]s iTL6vp.5> yevecrât cros, elbois ort KataWos ttov tls
Kal 6 Me\r]Tos ovtos ae p.ev ovbe boKel opav, e/xe be ovtcos
oêdis [cLTexvois] kol pctbCcos KaTelbev <3(TTe a(rej3eLas eypd-
\lraTO. vvv ovv TTpbs Alos Xeye /xot 6 vvvbr] crac^ws elbevat
bLL(rxvpLôv, TTolov TL To ev(reês (pfjs elvaL koX to dcreês
d KOLL TTepX cf>6vov KOL TTepl t5>v a\X(t>v; rj ov Tavrov ecTTLV ev
TTdcrt] TTpdêL to oo-lov avTO avTca, /cat to dvocrLov av tov piev
ocTLOv TTavTOS evavTLOV, avTO be avT(o op.oiov Kal eôv fxCav
TLva Ibeav KaTo. ttjv dvoaLOTr^Ta irdv oTLiTep dv fxeXXr]
5 dvoa-LOV etyat;
ET0. YldvTCiis brJTTov, S ScoKparey.
SO. Ae'ye brj, tl (fifjs elvaL to oo-lov Kal tl to dvocrLov
ET0. Aeyo) tolvvv otl to [xev oo-lov eaTLV oiTep eyoi vvv
ttolG), rcf) dbLKOvvTL rj TTepl (f)6vovs 7] iTepl iepciv KXoTrds ?/ rt
10 oAAo rwy tolovt(ov eâp.apTdvovTi eiTe^LevaL, edvTe TTaTrjp
C oiv TvyxdvT] edvTe p.r]Tr]p edvTe aAAoy 6o-rtcrow, to be /xt)
eTTe^LevaL dv6(TL0V eiTeC, 2 ^(aKpaTes, 6eaa-aL ws [xeya croL ep5>
TeKiir]pLov Tov v6]xov OTL ourcos exet o Kai aAAots 7/8r/ etTroi',
OTLTavTa dpdS)sdveLr] ovto) yLyv6]xeva p.r] eTTLTpeireLV t(S dae-

6 ôvvTL ixr]b' dv oo-tlo-ovv Tvyxdvr] lov. avTol ydp ol dvdpioTTOL
Txryxdvova-k vo]xCQovTes tov Ata tG)V de&v apLo-Tov Kal bLKatd-
t)8 in^ T: fie B C2 fyeVeTo B: ytfotro B' T W Arm.

C 7 aTexfSis T : om. B C 8 vdv 5^ B : vvu T (sed Cg Si/
supra Ti) d4 avoffiirriTa Tw : 6aî6Tr]Ta B /xi] dertSTriTa Arm.
W Arm.
:
d7 Kol ri rh B^' T (ex emend.) : kuI rh B 63 rov voiui/u.ov

Baumann : an TolvvSfiov ? Schanz 64-5 oti . . . rvyx^-^V ^^ secl.
Rassow: Stj . . . yLyv^niva secl. Schanz
;
ET0TPI2N 6a
TaTOV, KOL TOVTOV ojuoAoyoCcTi Tov avTov TTaTepa brja-ai otl 6
Tovs V(l9 KaTinvV ovK kv Si/ci/, KCLKdvov y av TOV aVTOV
iraTipa ktixIv bi Tpa Toiavra' ifxol 8e xaXeTTaCvovatv
OTL T<S TTaTpl iTT^pxofj.ai abLKovvTi, Kot ovT(os avTol avToXs
Ta IvavTia Xiyova-i TrepC re tc^v Oecov Kal iTepl ifxov. 5
212. 'Apa ye, a> KvOvcf^poov, tovt^ ea-Tiv [ov] ovveKa r7/y
ypa(f)i]v (f)vya}, ori to. TotavTa (Treibav tls TTepl tQv deoiv
*~*
îyi], bvaîpGis ttuis aTroSexojuat; 810 h], ws lot/ce, (f^rja-ft
rt? jue eâp.apTav.tv. vvv ovv et Ka\ o"ot TavTa avvboKei r<S
ev elboTi 77epi T&v TOiovT(jL)V, avdyKr] bi], &>? eot/ce, Kat tj^xlv b
(rvyx(>ip(^v. tC yap Kal </)ô-o/xey, ot ye /cat aiirot o/xoAo-
yovp.V Trept avTcov fxr^bcv dbivat; aWd p.01 etTre Trpo?
^tAtou, (Ti; d)S aXr]d(as r]yf) TavTa ovtcos yeyovivai;

ET0. Kat eri ye tovtojv 6av]xaa-L(0Tpa, S) 2(d/cpares, & 5
ot TToAAot ovK Lo-aa-LV.
2X2. Kat TToXejxov apa rjyr] (tv etrat roJ oz-Tt er rots êots
TTpbs aX\rj\ovs, Kal X.^pas ye Setiâs /cat /îcixas '^ctt aAAa
TOiavTa TToAAa, ota keyeTaC re vtto r<Sy iTOLrjTcav, Kal vtto twv
ayad6)v ypa(f)U)V Td re aAAa Upd rjfx^Lv KaTaTTiiToCKLkTaL, /cat C
hr] /cai rot? jueyoAot? rTara^Tyyaiot? 6 tt4tt\os /xeorros rdjy
rotOT;ra)y TTOLKLkfxdTcov dvdyeTaL els Tr]v dKpoTToXLv; Taxrra
dXrjOi] (f)(atxev etvaL, S) Kv6v(f)p(DV
ET0. M^ fxovov ye, a 2ci)Kpares, aAA' OTrep cprt lttov, 5

Kat aAAa oôt eycb ttoAAci, edvirep (3ov\r], Trept rwy 9eC(i)V
bLr]yr](Top.aL, a (rv aKOvu^v ev ot8' ort eKTrAayô^?/.

2X2. OwK ay OavfxdQaLfLL. dAAa raCra /xe'y ftot ets ovOls
eTTt cr)(oA^? bLr]yr]a~i]- vvvl 8e OTrep aprt cre rfpdfirfv 7retp<5
aa(f)4crTpov etTretr. ou ycxp /i.e, S eratpe, ro TTpoTepov d

lKaz;<us' e8i8aâs kpiaTTja-avTa to oaLov otl ttot dr], dWd fxoL
a6 ouj/e/ca Schanz : ov ovveKa B T (sed ? in marg T) a 8 Sih T

Cse(3 a supra versum) : 5i' & B Eusebius b 2 ai ovtoI T Arm. :
ouTol B Eusebius b6 supra iroWol add. \onr T b 8 fx^pa^ 7^
B Eusebius x^P*: T bg ^fyerai t B Eusebius: Xtyerai
T W Arm. e5 /xoVov B W : fj.6ya B* T W^ Eusebius c6 0eiai']
eeai;' Arm. Eusebius C9 <TxoKr)v W
6d nAATONOS
fiTres oTi TOVTO Tvyxdvei. oaiov ov o crv vvv Troteis, ôvov
(TTe^Lcbv T<a iraTpL
5 ET0. Kat aXrjOrj ye (\eyov, S 2w/cparey.

212. "la-ois. dAAa yap, S) F,vdv(f)pa)V, Kal aXXa TroAXa
(f^rjs etvai 0(ria.
ET0. Kal yap tcTTiv.
211. Mejui^Tjo-at ovv ori ov roCro o-ot SteKeXeuo/xr/i', ey rt

lo 77 hvo /xe 8t8aât rcSv ttoAAo)!' octlwv, oAA' iKcXvo avTo to
etSos J Trai^ra ra oo-ta oo-td (o-tlv; t^ricrda ykp irov fXLq i8e'a
e rd re avoa-La avocTLa etvat Kat ra ocTia oa-La' rj ov p.vrniov(.vLs;
ET0. "Eycsiye.
212. Taurr;y toCvvv jue avrrjv bCbaôv TrjV Ihiav tCs iroTi
ioTLV, tva et? (KcCvrjv dTro/SAeVcoy Kat XP^/^fôs avrrj irapa-
5 beCyixaTL, o ixev hv tolovtov ^ &v hv rj (tv rj dAAos rts

TTpcLTTr] (})S> oa-Lov etrai, 6 8' Sy /x^ rotoCror, /x^ <^cS.
ET0. 'AAA' (l ovTco ôvkcL, S) 2a)Kpares, Kat ovrto orot
(ppdau).
212. 'AAAd fjLrjv jSovXofxaC ye.

10 ET0. "Eo-rt ToCvvv t6 jxev rots êots 7r/)oo-^tAe? oaLOV, t6
7 S^ ix-q TTpoa(f)LX.S avoa-Lov.
212. nayKdAa)s,d>Eii^v^pcoy, koX (as ^yco e^riTovv airoKpCva-

aOaC cre, ovrco vSv aTreKpCvo). et ix^vtol aXri6G)s, tovto ovtkd
olba, aXXa av brjXov otl eTreK^tSdêts cas eo-rty aXridrj b. Ae'yets.
5 ET0. Yldvv pikv ovv.
212. fpepe 817, iiTLaKeyf/âixeda tC Xeyoixev. ro /xey êo-

(f)i\S re Kat êo^tA^s avOpcoTTOs oaLos, t6 8e OeoixLaes kol 6
d0[XLaris avoaLos' ov ravroy 8' earCv, dAAd rd evavTL(i)TaTOV,
t6 oaLOV rw avoaC(^' ovx ovtcds;

10 ET0. Ovrco /Aey ow.
212. Kai eS ye (f)aCvTai elprjadaL;
b ET0. AoKO), S) 2c)Kpares. [etprjrat yd/).]
d3 <ri; om. pr.W d 7 3<no post d 8 effTii' transp. B a3 aXriBws

B : iis a.\ri9ws T a 7 koI 0o</)iA))j W : Kcd d 6fO(pi\i]s BT bi eJ"-
priTai yip secl. Naber

;
ET0T4)Pf2N 7b
Sli. OvKovv Kal OTi (TTaa-LdiCovcriv ol OeoC, S Y.vdv(f)pa)V,
Kol bLa(f)poVTai dAArjAots Koi ^xOpa ecrrti' kv avTols TTpbs

dAATjAous, Kal tovto ctprjTai.;
ET0. Etprjrai ydp. 5

212. "Exdpav 8e Kal opyas, o) apLO-Te, ri Trept tlvcov
hLa(l)opa TTOiet; <58e 8e o-KOTrwjuei'. ap' ay et bLa(f)epoLp.0a
iyco re cat ot> Trept dpL6p.ov oiroTepa TrAeto), 17 Trept rovrcoy

bLa(f)opa e)(6povs hv rj pids ttolol Kal opyLêcrQaL dXkr\X.0LS,
7] eTrl X.oyL(rp.bv iXOovTes irepL ye tSiv tolovtoov Ta^y dv 10

ditaXXayelp.ev C
ET0. Udw ye.
2X2. Oi/coCi' Kat Trept tov pieCCovos Kal ikdTTovos et
hLa(f)poLp.9a, e77t ro [xeTpelv eAôWej raxî 'navcraLp.&' av

Tr]s bLa(f)opds; 5
ET0. *Eo-ri raura.
2X2. Kat eTTt ye ro la-Tdvai \66vts, ojs iy(Sp,aL, irept
rou fiapvTepov re xat Kov(f>OTpov bLaKpL6Lp.v dv;

ET0. Ilcos yap ov;
2X2. ITept rtyos 8e brj bievex^devTes Ka\ ttI Twa KpicrLV 10
ov bvvdpevoL d(pLK(r6aL kydpoi ye hv dAATjAots etp.ey /cat
dpyLCoLpieda; lctcos ov irpoxeLpov croL kaTLV, dAA' e/xoC Xeyov-

Tos (TKOTTeL et rd8e eo-rt t6 re bUaLov Kal Tb dbLKov Kal d
fcaAoi' /cai alcrxpbv Kal dyadbv Kal Ka^dv. dpa ov TavTa
eaTar^TTepl <3y SierexêWey Kat ov bvvdp.voL ttI LKavrjv
KpCa-LV avTMV kkdelv kydpol dXkrjkoLS yLyv6p.da, orav yL-
yvdpLeda, Kal eyo) koI ot) /cai ot dAAot dv6p(DTT0L Trdyres; 5
ET0. AAA' ea-TLV avrr] rj bLa(f)opd, S) 2ojKpares, Kat
Trepl TOVT(DV.
2i2. Tt 8e ot êot, S Y,vdv(f)p(i)v; ovk etTrep rt Staê-

povTttL, 8t' avTa TavTa bLa(f>poLVT dv;
\) 2 Si
B:
Ev6v(pp(i)v post b3 a\\-fi\ois T C 4 fnrpelv T Arm. : W
/xfTpiov /xeTpoy al. C lo iirl Tiro] îrt rtva Schanz C ii ye
B : T T ^/ifi/ B : eirt/xev T d. 4 exdpol B T e-xQpoi ye : W
d9 5i' oiTct Toi/Ta T : 5to ToiiTa B : 5jo toCto toSto W
7d nAATXlNOS
lo ET0. rToAA^ avdyKt].
6 211. Kat T&v d^&v apa, S yevvalc F,v6v(f)p(t)V, aXXoi
aWa hUaia rjyovvrat Kara tov aov koyov, Kal Kaka Kal
al(r)(^pa Kal ayada Kal KaKo.' ov yap av ttov ka-Taaiaôv
aAArjAois et p.i] Trept TOVTOiv bnîpovTO' ^ yd.p;
5 ET0. 'OpOm Aeyeis.
2X2. OvKovv airep KoXa rjyovvTaL ^Kacrroi Kal ayaOa Kal
hLKaia, Tavra koX (fîXova^Lv, to. 8e kvavTia tovt(ov p.iaov(TLv;
ET0. Y16.VV ye.
20. Tavra 8e ye, ws o-u <^^9, ot /Aef StKota rjyovvTai,

8 ot 8e abiKa, Trept & xal ap.(f)ia-^r]T0VVTS a-TaatdôvaC re Kat
TToAe/xoCcrti' dAAi/Aots* Spa ovx. oi/ra);
ET0. Ovrco.
2X2. Tailr' dpa, ws (oikcv, pa^reXTai re iTTo rwy êwy
5 Kat (piXeLTai, Kal 6eop.Larj re Kat 60(f)L\rj TavT^ hv eXr].
ET0. "EotKev.
212. Kat oo-ta dpa Kal dyocrta tcl avTO. hv ctr], u) F^vdv-
(f)p(DV, TOVT(o ro) Ao'ya).

ET0. Kti^Swevet.
10 2X2. OvK dpa o r]p6pt.r]v dTTeKpLVCo, S) 6avfJ.da-L. ov ydp
TOVTO ye r]p(i)TO)v, o ruyxdzêt TavTov ov oaLOV re Kai dvo-
(TLOv o 8' dv 6eo(f)L\S 17 Kat êopLLcres kaTLV, ws eoLKev.
b &a-T, u) F,vdv(ppcov, (Tv vvv TTOtets Tov TTaTepa KoAd-
ô)v, ovbev 6av]xacrTov et tovto bp5>v t<S ]xkv Att Trpoo-^tAes
TTOtet?, r(p 8e Kpdyo) Kat rw Ovpav<^ exÔpov, Kal rw /xev
H0atcrr(i) (f^Ckov, Trj 8e "Hpa \6p6v, Ka\ et rt? dAAos rwy
5 6eS)v eTepos kTepdo bLa(f)epTai Trept avTOv, Kal eKeCvoLS Kard
rd avrd.
ET0. 'AAA' o"L]xai, u) 2o)Kpare?, Trept ye rovrou rwy
êwi' ovbeva erepov eTep(^ bLa(f)epeo-6aL, u>s ov bel bLKr]v
bLbdvaL eKelvov os dv dbLKcos TLvd diroKTeLvr].
e 9 (pi^s B T î^Tjj
: W a4 re W : om. B T a 11 &] ^ al.
Schanz b 6 Ta alri B : toutci T : Tawra auTa W b7 tovtou
BT : Toircev T^ W
EY0Y4>PilN 8b
2X2. Tt 8e; av6p(aTTu>v, Si F>v6v(f)pa>Vf Tjbr} tlvos rjKOVcras lo
aiJL(f)L(r^r]TovvTOS &)S tov dSiKtos a-noKTeCvavTa 7] aXXo abiKcos c
TiOLOvirra otlovv ov Sei bLKrjv bLbovaL;
EY0. Ovbev ixev ovv TravovTaL TavTa ap.<\)L(T^riTovvT(S

Kcu a\Xo6L Kou, iv tols bLKaarrjpLOLS' abLK0vvTS yap Trayx-
iroAAa, 'navTa ttolov^tl Kal k^yov(TL (f)evyovTS ti]v bLK-qv. 5

2X2. ^H Kal 6p.oXoyov(TLv, cb Kvdv(f)p(t)v, abLKelv, Kal
6p.oX.oyovvTS op.(os ov belv <f)a(rl (r(f)as bibovaL bLKtjv;
EY0. Ovbafxois tovto ye.
2X2. OvK apa Trav ye ttolovctl Kal KeyovcrL' tovto yap
oTfxaL ov To\p.(a(TL XeyeLV ovb' ap.(f)L(T^riTeLV, U)S ovyX eiTrep 10
abLKOV(TL ye boTeov bLKr\v, dAA' 0Lp.aL ov (f>aa-LV abLKLV 17 d

yap;
EY0. 'AAtj^^ Aeyeis.
2X2. OvK apa eKelvo ye apL(f)La-l3r]Tov(rLV, wy ov tov
abLKOVVTa beZ bLbovaL bLKr]v, dX)C eKelvo tcrcos aix(f)La-j3r]T0V- 5
a-LV, t6 TLS i(TTLV 6 abLKoiv Kal TL bpU)V Kal TTOTe.

EY0. 'AXr]di] XeyeLS.
2X2. OvKovv avTCL ye Tavra Ka\ ol 6eo\ TTeTTOvdaaLV,
eLTTep cTTaa-LdCovcTL TTep\ t(ov bLKaCcov fcat dSiKcoy tos 6 aos

Aoyoy, Ka\ ol p.ev (f)acrLV dX.X.iqkovs dbLKelv, ol be ov (f)aa-Lv; 10
eTTe\ eKelvo ye br]TTOV, o) 6avp.d(rLe, ovbe\s ovTe 6e(i)V ovTe
dv6p(i>iT0)V ToXp.q Xeyeiv, o)? ov rw ye dbiKOVVTL boTeov bLKr]v. e
EY0. Nai, TOVTO iiev dXr]6es XeyeLS, S 2wKpares, t6 ye
Ke(f>dXaLov.
2X2. 'AAA eKaarov ye olp.aL, S Kv6v(pp(i)v, tS>v TTpa-

)(6evr(j)V dfx(f)La-l3r]T0va-LV oi dp.(f)Lcr^r]TovvTes, Ka\ dv6p(s)TT0L 5
Kol 6eoL, eLirep dp.(f>Lcrl3r]Tova-LV 6eoL' TTpdêoiS tlvos TTepi
bLa(f)ep6ixevoL oi p.ev bLKaCcos (f>aa-\v avTr]v TreTrpaydaL, oi be

dbLK(t)S' Sp' ov\ ovTO);
e 7 ou ûv B- T Arm. ovSev B W C 10 etirep a5iKov<rt B t virep-

: :
aîKoiin T d4 eKeTvo T W Arm. Stobaeus eKelvoi B CI5 Se? :
B- Arm. om. T (in B W plurima ciesunt)

: d8 outo B TavTo, :
B- T d 9 irepl B re irepl T 6 2 -ye T om. B post a\r]des W

: : :
e 4 fKatTTOv T W eKia-Toiv B :
8e nAAT12N0S
ET0. UAvv ye.
9 2X2. "Wl vvv, S)

(f)[\ V!,v6v(j)pa)V, bLbaôv kol ejue, 'iva
(ro(f)u>Tpos yevoîxaL, tC (tol TeKfxripLov iaTLV ws TrdvTcs deol

TjyovvTaL iKLVov abLKcos TeOvdvaL, 6? hv OriTevcov dvbpo(p6-
vos yevofxevos, (rvvbedels vtto tov bea-noTov tov dirodavovTOS,
5 (f)6d(rr) TeX-evT-qa-as 5ta tol bea-[xa Trplv tov avvbria-avTa Trapa
tQv e^riyriT&v itepX avrov imdea-daL tC \pri TTOLelv, Kal virep
Tov TOLOVTOV 8?) opdcos ex^L eire^LevaL Kal eTTLa-KT^TTTea-6aL
(})6vov Tov vbv Ti^ TTaTpC; X6l, iTepl tovtcdv ireLpS) tC ixol
b a-a(})es evbeCâaOaL o)s iTavTos ixdWov TrdvTes deol iiyovvTaL
6pQS)S eyeLV TavTrjv Tr^v iTpd^LV' Kav ixol iKav&s evbeC^ji,
eyKcoixLd^cov ae eirl (ro(})Ca ovbeiTOTe iTavaoixaL.

ET0. 'AAA.' Xa-ois ovk okCyov epyov earCv, S) ^(oKpaTes,
5 eTTel Trdvv ye (ra^ws lxoi//6 av eTTLbelâC (tol.
212. Mavddvd)' OTL ctol boKU) t5)V bLKaa-T&v bvaixade-

a-Tepos etvaL, eiTel eKeCvoLS ye evbeC^ri brikov 6tl w? dbLKd re
ea-TLV KCLL ol deo\ aTravTes Ta roiaCra ixLaovaLV.
ET0. Hdvv ye aa(f)(os, o) 2a)Kpare?, edvirep aKovcaaC ye
lo ixov XeyovTos.
C 212. 'AXA' aKovaovTaL. edvnep ev boK^s keyeLV. Tobe bi

(Tov evev6ria-a dp-a XeyovTOS Ka\ TTpos eixavTov ctkottG)' " Et
OTL ixdX.LaTd [xe Ev6v(f)poi)V bLbdêLev ws ol 6eol aTravTes tov
roLOVTOv 6dvaTov riyovvTaL dbLKOv elvaL, tC ixdXkov eyoi)
5 ixeixddriKa iTap' Fiv6v(f)povos tC ttot earlv to oaLdv re Kal to

dv6a-Lov; 6eoixtaes ixev ydp tovto to epyov, ws eoLKev, eXri
dv. akkd ydp ov tovtco e(f)dvri dpTL b^pLajxeva to oaLOV

Kal ixri' TO ydp deofXLaes ov Ka\ 6eo(f)LXes e(f)dvri," uiaTe
TOVTOV piev d(f)CrinC ae, o) Ev6v(f>po)V ei jBovXeL, TTdvTes avTO
d r]yeCa6(x)V 6eo\ dbLKOv Ka\ TTdvTes ixLaovvTO)v, dXX.' dpa tovto

o vvv eTTavop6ovixe6a ev r<S Xdyco w? 6 ixev dv TTdvTes ol
ai vvvB: ToivvuT a^ 7ri(rK67rT(j-9ai pr, B ba /cSyB^TW

Arm. :Kai B b 8 TrdvTes T c 2 ivev6r](Ta B (vorjaa : W :
exofiai T c8 T^ yap i<pavr) secl. Kleist

. . . C9 ixlv T: om.
B ei W
b /ca2 j T
: d a & vvv iiravopdovfneda B Arm. vvv W :
ivavopQovixeQa T : vvv iiravopdtifji,eda al.

ET0TcI>PaN 9d
Oeol \it<TS)CTLv avocTLov k(TTLV, 8' av (pLkGicrLV, ocriov o b av
ol ixkv (pLXiaaiv ol b fXKrSicrLV, ovbirepa t/ aixcpoTepa ap' ovtco
jSovXeL IJfUV O)pL(T0aL VVV TTepl TOV 6(TL0V KoX TOV aV0(TL0V; 5
ET0. Tt yap KcoAvet, S 2wKpares;

2X2. Ovh\v e/jie ye, oj Kvdv(f)p(av, aXXa crv hr) to aov (tko-
TTCL, el tovto VTTodepevos ovtco pa(TTa fxe SiSaêts o vTricT^ôv.
ET0. 'AAA' lyojye <f)aLr}V av tovto (TvaL to octlov o hv e
irdvTes ol deol (pLkwcrLV, Kal to (vavTLOV, o ^v tt(xvtS Oeol
IXL(TWCrLV, aVOCTLOV.
2X2. OVKOVV iTTLCTKOTTWpLeV aV TOVTO, S) Yiv6v(pp(v, el
KoAcos XiyeTaL, 7] ecjfxev Kal ovtoi) i]pS)V re avTS)v aTTobexco- 5

jxeOa Kal tS)v akXcov, eav piovov (pfj
tls tl exft^ ovtci)
(TvyxopovvTes eyeLv; 7/ aKeTTTiov tl XeyeL 6 keycov;

ET0. ^KeTTTeov olp.aL p.evTOL iyooye tovto vvvl KakS)S
XeyecrdaL.
212. Tax^', b)ya6e, êkTLOv elcropLeda. evv6r]CTov yap to io
roioySe* apa t6 octlov otl octlov ecTTLV ^tAetrat vtto tS)V
6eS)V, 1] oTL (^tAetrat o(tl6v e(TTLv;
ET0. O^K ot8' ort Ae'yets, &> Sw/cparey.
2X2. 'AAA' eycb 7reLpd(TopiaL (Taê^rrepov <{)pd(Tai. keyo- 5

fxev TL (pepopevov Kal (pepov Kal dy6pevov Kal dyov Kal
6p(apevov Kal 6pS)V koX iTdvTa tol TOLavTa fxavddveLS ort
irepa dkkrjkcov earl Kal 77 eTepa;
ET0. "Eyojye p-OL boKS) p.avddvetv.
2X2. OvKOVv Kal (()ikovixev6v tC ecrTLV Ka\ tovtov eTepov 10
To (f)tkovv;
ET0. Tl(as ydp ov;
2X2. Ae'ye b^ p.ot, iT^Tepov to (pepofxevov btoTt (pepeTat b
<l)ep6pev6v e(TTLV, rj bC dkko tl;
ET0. OvK, dkkd btd TOVTO.

2X2. Kai To dy6p.evov br] 8tori ayerat, Kat to dpcafxevov
810V1 oparat; 5
e2 01 B : om. T W
lob '
nAATI2N0S
ET0. Uavvye..
212. OvK apa btoTL opcaixevov yi lcmv, 8ia tovto opaxai,
aAAa to ivavTiov 8toVt opaTai, bia tovto 6p(ofXvov ovbe
8ioTt ay6p.(v6v (TTLV, bia tovto ayerai, oAAa 8tort ay^Tai,
10 ta TOVTO ayopievov ovbe 8to'rt (f)ep6iJLV0V (êperat, dAAa
8tori 0e/)erai (f)p6p.vov. apa KaTabrjkov, w F,v6v(f)po}v, o
C ôvXofxai \iyciv; ôvKop.ai 8e T6b, otl et tl yCyveTai r/ ri
TrdoTêi, ovx ori yiyv6p.v6v eo-rt ytyyerai, dAA' ort ytyyerai
yiyv6p.v6v (TTLV' ovb^ OTL TT(X(rxôv eo-rt Trdoêt, *dAA' ort
Trdaêt Trdorôi' (ttlv' t] ov avyxcapeXs ovTOi;
5 ET0. "Eycoye.
212. OvKovv Kal To îXovyLevov rj yLyv6fXv6v rt eo-rty rj
TTaa-xov TL vtt6 tov;

ET0. ndvv ye.
212. Kat TOVTO apa ovrtos exft axnrep to. irpoTepa' ov^
lO Ort (f)LX.0VfXv6v ka-TLV (()LXLTaL VTTO 5)V (})LXLTaL, dAA' ori
(/)tAetrai (^tAov/xeroy;
ET0. 'Avdy/cr/.
d 2i2. Tt 8^ ovv kiyojxev Trepi tov octlov, a> Fiv9v(f)pci)v;
aXko TL (^tAetrat vtto dewv TTa.VTO)v, ojs 6 (rbs Adyos;

ET0. Nat'.
212. 'Apa 8td TovTo, otl oo-l^v icTTLV, 7] 8t' dAAo rt;
6 ET0. OvK, dAAd 8td tovto.
212. Atdrt apa 6(rL6v kcTTLV (f)LkLTaL, dAA' ovx_ otl
îAetrat, 8td tovto o^tlqv (ttlv;
ET0. 'EoiKez;.
212. 'AAAd ixV br} 8tdrt ye (f)L\XTaL vtto Bedv (f)L\ov-
To ixv6v eoTt jcat êo^tAes <(rd êo(^tAej)>.
ET0. ricS? yd/3 ou;
212. Oi/c dpa rd êoc^tAes ocrtdy icTTLV, S) F,v6v(f>pot)v, ovbe

TO 6(TL0V 60(f)L\S, 0)9 OV XiyLS, oAA' TpOV TOVTO TOVTOV.
Ci
BT
ij Ti 7ra<rxJ
Arm.
B :
d 10
tj tt ti irdffxei tiT
eeo(pi\(s add.
d2 &\\o tj W : dA\'
2t tJ Bast

ET0TPi2N ioe
ET0. n&is 8r/, a> ^(tiKpares; e

2X2. "Ort 6fj.okoyovfX(v t6 fxkv oo-lov 8ta tovto ^tAeto-ât,
ort oo-ioV k(TTiv, dAA' ov 8to'rt (pL\eLTai octlov etzâf ?/ ydp;
ET0. Nat.
212. To 8e ye Oeocf^LXks otl ^tXetrat 1^770 êwi', avrw 5
TOVTio rw (pLkeLcrdaL d0(f)LX.s LvaL, dAA' ov)( ort êoc^tAe'?,
8td roi5ro (f)L\L(r6aL.
ET0. 'AArj^^ Aeyet?.

212. 'AAA' ei ye tovtov 7]V, S (/)t'^ F.v6v(pp(ov, t6
6eo(f)LX.S Kal rd oo-lov, et /u.ey 8td rd do-toi' etiât e</)tAetro rd 10
ocrioy, Kai dtd rd 0eo(^tAes etyat ^^tAetro d:; rd êoc/^tAe'?, et 11
de dtd rd (pLXdadai vtto 6ewv t6 êo</)tAe? êoc^tAes 7/y, Kat

rd do-toy dr dtd rd (})L\la-6aL oo-lov rjv vvv de dpas ori
kvavTUtis \Tov, 0)9 TraiTdTrao-ty kTiput ovt dAAr/Acor. t6
fjLev ydp, otl (^tAetrat, eo^rty otoy (pLKeicrâL' t6 8' dri eo^riy 5
OIOV (pLkLCr6aL, dtd TOVTO (pLk^LTaL. KCLL KLvbvVVLS, S) Kvdv-

^po)V, p(i)T(i)p.vos rd do-toy otl ttot (rTLV, TTfv ixV ovcriav
fxoL avTov ov (3ovk(r6aL brjkwa-aL, 770.609 bi tl Trepi avTOV

kyLV, OTL TT^TTOV^^ TOVTO t6 OaLOV, (PLkL(r6aL VTT^ TT(ivT(i)V
6G)V OTL 8e ov, ovttco etTres. et ovv (tol (pikov, p.r\ fxc aiTO- b
Kpv\}/ri akka TrdAty etTre e^ o^PXV^ "^^ ttot ov t6 o(rLov etre
(^tAetrat vtt6 dS>v etre drtS^ Trdoêt' ov yap Trept tovtov

bLOi(r6p.6a dAA' etTre TTpo6vp.(i)s tl kaTLV to re daioy Kai
rd avocTLOv; 5
ET0. 'AAA', Z) 2wKpare?, ovk \(t) y(t)y ottcos o-ot etTTO)
o voG)' TTpLpx(TaL ydp 770)5 rfpXv det d h.v TTpo6(opLda Kal

OVK eê'Aet ixVlv ottov dy lbpv(r(6pi6a avTo.
212. Tod r]p.TpOV TTpoyOVOV, Z) EiV6v(f)p(i)V, 0LKV LVai
AatddAou rd VTrd a-ov ky6p.va. koll ei fxkv avTa iyo) eAeyoy c
Kat TL6fXriV, tO-O)? dv fX TT(rK(t)TrTS iiS dpa KoX kfXoX KaTCL
65 dvTif) B^TW Arm. : alrSiv B ag ipiXflTai T b? riiuv

oel B : a(\ riy.lv T : r\filv Arm. KpodwfieOa Tb : vpoOvfxdixfOa B
C2 atrfiTKanrTes W
II c nAAT12N02
Tr]v KLvov (Tvyyiveiav to. v toIs Xoyois epya aTTobi.bp6.(rKei
Kal ovK (O^kd iXVeLV ottov av tis avra drj' vvv be cral yap
5 ai VTTo6e<Tis da-iv. aKkov hr\ tlvos Sei o-jcw/xjaaros" ov yap
edeXova-L aol p.iveLV, ias kol avT<3 aoL hoKet.
ET0. EjLtot 8e 8oKet a^yjebov ri tov avTov a-KU>p.p.aTOS, ut
"ûiKpaTis, beXaOaL tcl ky6p.(va' to yap TTCpLLevaL avTols

TOVTO Kal p.r] p.eveLV iv tS) avTut ovk iyca elpLL 6 ivTLdeCs,
d dAA.a av jjlol boK^ls 6 AaiSaAo?, eTret (fJLov ye iveKa fj.Vv
hv TavTa ovTMS.
2X2. KLvbvvevui apa, co kTalpe, (kclvov tov avbpos bcLvo-
Tepos yeyovivaL ti]V T^yj^r^v ToaovTf^, o(r(a 6 juev tcl avTov
5 fjiova iiTOLeL ov ]xivovTa, eyo) 8e iTpos Tols l]xavTov, iis eoLKC,
Kal TCL dAAorpta. *cat brJTa tovto ]iol ttjs re^VTj? iaTl
Koy^lroTaTOV, otl aKoiv L]u cro(f)6s' ej3ovX6]j.rjV yap av fxoL
Tovs Xoyovs ]J.VLV Kal aKLvr]T(tiS ibpva-daL p.a\kov rj iTpbs Trj
e AatSdAou cro(j)Lq tcl Tai^rdAou \pif]]xaTa yevecrdaL. kcu. tov-

Tbjv ]iev abrjv e7ret8r/ 8e ]xol boKels av Tpv(f)av, avTos croL
av^xTTpoOv^xrâo^xaL [8etât] ottojs av ]xe 8t8dr/s TTepl tov

6a-[ov. Kal ]xr] TTpoaTroKap.ris' Ibe yap el ovk avayKal6v aoi
5 8oKet 8tKatoy etzâi TTav to oaLov.
ET0. "E^xoLye.
2i2. 'Ap' ovv Kal ttclv to bCKaiov oaLov; r] to p.ev oaLov
12 TTCLV bLKaLov, TO be bLKaLov ov TTav ocTLOv, aWa To p.ev avTOV
oaLOV, To be tl Kal akko;
ET0. Ovx. eTTO]xaL, Z> ^caKpaTes, toIs keyo]xevoLS.
SH. Kal ]xr]V ve(iiTep6s ye ]xov et ovk ekaTTOv r] oa-(D
6 cro(f)(aTepos' akk\ o keyu), Tpvcf^qs vtto iTkovTOV Trjs aocfiLas.
akk\ S ]xaKa.pLe, ovvTeLve aavT^v Kal yap ovbe X'"^^'''^^

KaTavor]aaL o keyoo. keyco yap br] to evavTLOv r] 6 7T0Lr]Tr]s
eTT0Lr]aev 6 TTOLrâas
C 7 supra 8 add. -yf B' c 8 ra B^ T W : rdSf B avTo7s TW :
TovTots B 6 2 0-1/ rpv(pav B cruvTpvtpav T 63 56i|ai BT;

W
:
om. a4 (Karrou T W : iKoLTrovi B a6 ouSeJ ovSfv Naber

:
ET0T*PX2N X2a
Zfjva b^ Tov [6'] ipâvTa Ka\ o? Tahf. navT i^vTivaev
ovK eêAci veiKeiv tva yap bios vda Kal albds. b
eyo) ovv TOVTia bia(f)poixaL T(o Trotrjrf/. etTro) crot ottt/;
ET0. Udvv ye.

2X2. Ov boKeX fioi eXvai " Xva bios vOa Kal albws '
TToXXol ydp y.01 boKOVcri Ka\ voaovs Ka\ irevCas Ka\ aXXa 5
TTokXa ToiavTa bebtOTes bebUvai. [xiv, atSetcrât be ixrjbev
TavTa h 6e8tao-ti'' ov Ka\ o"ot SoKet;
ET0. Udvv ye.
S12. 'AAA' tva ye albias kvOa Ka\ bios elvai' eirei ecrriy
ooTts albovp.ev6s rt Trpayfxa Ka\ al(r)(yv6pLevos ov T7e(f)6^riTaL lo
re Ka\ biboLKev a/xa 8o'ây TTovqpias; C

ET0. AeboLKe jxev ovv.
2i2. OvK ap' opQGis XL KiyiLV " tva yap bios v6a Kal
atSws," oAA' tVa fxev aibojs v6a Ka\ b4os, ov jxcvtol tva ye
beos TtavTayov aib(as' em Trkeov yap oi/xat beos aibovs. 5
fxopLov yap aibias beovs uxnrep dpLOfxov irepLTT^v, uxrre ov\
tvairep dpLdp.os v6a Ka\ Treptrroi', tva 8e irepLTTov ivOa Kal
dpL6p.6s. eTTT/ ydp ttov vvv ye;
ET0. lidvv ye.
2X2. To TOLOVTov TOLVVV Ka\ Ki Xiydiv rip(tiT(i}V apa tva lo
biKaLov v6a Ka\ octlov ; rf tva jxev octlov v6a Ka\ biKaLov, d
tiâ 8e biKaLov ov TravTayov o^tlov p.6pLov yap tov bLKaCov ^^
To ocTLOv ; ovT(a ^(3/xey r] aAAcos o"ot 8oKet;
ET0. OvK, dAA' ovT(a. (paCvr] ydp fxoL 6p6S>s XiyeLV.
212. Opa 8^ To ixeTCL tovto. eZ yap fxepos t6 octlov tov 5
8tKatOU, 8et 8^ r}p.ds, WS 0LKV, ^VpLV t6 TTolov fXpOS h.v
tr] Tov bLKaCov t6 octlov. et fxev ovv (tv \x rip(aTas tl t&v
VVvb-q, oloV TTOLOV fxipOS CrT\v dpL6p.0V t6 dpTLOV Ka\ TLS u>v
ag OepâuTu B
cTTtpâvTa.
:
yp. : T B W
êâvTa Stobaeus Apostolius
schol. ap. Cram. Anecd. Par. I, p. 399 : 0' epâuTa B^ b i edt\ei W
viiKily scripsi : iOeKfis eiireiv BT
(veiKfffiv schol, T) ideXeiv elneTv : W
corr. B^ : eOeXeiv etKetv schol. ap. Cram. 1. c. c6 alSws Seovs B t
alSovs Seos T
PLATO, VOL. I. 2
;
jard nAATQNOS
Tvyxo.Vi ovTos 6 apidjxos, d-Kov hv ori os h.v firj crKakr)vbs
lo T) aW' i(ro(rKX.ris' r) ov boKel croi.;
ET0. "Efj.oi.ye.
e 2X2. netpo) 87) Kal <rv ifik o{)to) bibdât t6 ttoIov fxcpos
Tov biKaCov oaiov icTTLV, tva Kal MeATjro) Aeyco/iey p,r]Ki6^
7]p.as abiKeiv pLrjbe do-e/3etas yp6.(f)crdai, d)? LKavQs ?/8rj TTaph

(Tov /uejui.a^rjKo'ras r6. re evo-e/3^ koi ocrta Kat ra /xtj.
5 ET0. ToOro toCvvv epLoiyc 8ojcet, w 2w/cpares, ro nipos

Tov biKaCov etvai evo-e/3e's re Kat o(riov, to Trept r^y rci)i' êwi'
dfpaTTcCav, t6 8e Trept rî^ t&v avdpiiiTOiiV t6 Xolttov eirai

Tov biKaCov ju,e'pos.
2X2. Kat KoK&s yi pjoiy co Fiv9v(f)p(ov, (\>aCvr\ Xeyeiv, aX\a

13 (rp.iKpov TLVos Ti ivberis dixr Tr)v yap depaTreCav oinrti)
(TvvCr\ixi rjvTLva dvoix(x(is. ov ydp ttov Aeyets ye, oXaCirep /cat
at Trept to. dXka OepaTrelaC etcrty, TOLavTrjv Kal Trept êovs

\eyop,V ydp irov olov (f)apLV tTnrovs ov 'jras CTrtWarai
5 depaireveLV dAAa 6 tTTTrtKos' ^ ydp
ET0. ndw ye.
212. 'H ydp TTOV LTniLKri Xttikhv OepaTTfCa.
ET0. Nat'.
2i2. Ov8e' ye Kvvas ttcls lirCa-TaTai OcpaTrcveiv dWa 6

10 KW?7yeriKo's.
ET0. OiJrco.
2X2. *H ydp 7T0V Kwr)yTLKri kvv&v depaireCa.

b ET0. Nat'.
2X2. 'H 8e ye /ôrjAartKT) /Sowy.

ET0. Udvv ye.
2X2. 'H 86 8^ d^TLOTrjs re Kal V(r^La Oeuiv, cb FivOv-
5 ^p(t)v; ovTCt) Aeyets;

ET0. "Eycoye.
2X2. OvKoSv OepaTTeCa ye Trao-a TavTov bLaTTpdTTCTat;
olov TOLovbe' tt' dya6<2 tlvC eo-ri Kat a)</)eAta rov OepaTTevo-
b2 76 T : om. B b8 ô-ti B : (rrot T

ET0T4>P12N iab
liivov, cocnrep opas brj otl ol ittttoi vtto ttjs l7nTtK7]S depa-
Titvojxevoi oxêAourrat Kal jSekTLOvs yiyvovTaL' 7} ov boKOvaL lo
(tol;
ET0. "EfioLye.
2X2. Kat ol Kvves yi ttov vtto Trjs KwrjyeTLKrjs, Kal ol
ôes VTTO Trjs fiorjkaTLKrjs, Kal raWa TTavra uiaavTcas' r/ em c

^kajir] otet tov 6paTTevop.ivov Trjv depaiTeCav etrat;
ET0. Ma At" ovK eyojye.
2X2. 'AAA' eTr' wêAta;
ET0. nw? 8' ov; 5
2X2. 'H ovv Kal fj oa-Lorris OepaiTeCa oxxra de&v a)0eAta

re' eoTt 6eoi)V Kal êX.TL0vs tovs 6eovs Trotet; Kat crv tovto
(rvyxoi}pi](raLS av, &)S eTretSay tl 6(tlov ttoltjs, (BekTLdi tlvo.
Tu>v 6e&v aTTepya^r];

ET0. Ma At" ovk eycoye. lo
2X2. Ovbe yap eyco, S F.v6v(pp(i)v, olixaC (re tovto keyeLV

TToAAoC Kat Se'co aAAa tovtov br] eveKa Kal avr]p6ixr]v
rCva TTOTe keyoLS rqv depaireCav tS)V 6eG)V, ovy^ r]yovp.ev6s cre d
TOLavTr]v keyetv.
ET0. Kat dp^ws ye, S) Sw/cpares' ov yap TotavTqv keyo).
2X2. Etey' dAAa rts brj de&v 6epaTTeCa eirj av 17 6(rto'rr/?;
ET0. "HvTTep, S) 2ci)Kpares, ot SouAot tovs bea-mTas 5

êpaTrewoucrti'.
2X2. Mav6<xv(i)' VTrqpeTLKi] tls av, o)S eoLKev, etrj êots.

ET0. Ylavv piev ovv.
2X2. "Exots hv ovv elTTelv t] laTpols VTsr]peTLKr] els tCvos

ipyov aTTepyacrCav rvyxaveL ovaa VTrr/pertKTj; ovk els vyLeCas 10
oiei;
ET0. "Eycoye.
2X2. Tt 8e r] vavTrr^yols VTTr^peTLKrj ; els tCvos epyov e
CLTTepyacrCav VTTr]peTLKr] eaTLv;
ET0. AÂoi; ort, S) 2c)Kpares, etj TrAotou.
dI Xtyois B : Kfyeis T W d5 Tfjvvfp T W : îrep B d9 &//

TW : om. B
2*
136 nAATONOS
2f2. Kat 17 01/C080/X01S yi ttov ds oi/cta?;
5 ET0. Nai'.
212. EtTre bri, S apia-TV rj be Oeois VTrr^peTiKri ei? tlvos

^pyov aTrepyaa-Lav VTrrjpeTLKri h.v eirj; 8Âoy yap otl (tv
olo-da, iTTibi]TTp t6l ye êta /caAAtora (^17? dbevai avOpcairoiV.
ET0. Kat a\ri6rj ye X4y(i>, S ScoKpares.

10 212. EtTT^ 8?/ Trpo? Ato? tC Trore eo-rtv cKelvo to TrAyKa-
\ov epyov o ol 6eo\ aTrepydCovTaL fjfXLv vwrjpiTaLs xp(i>}XivoL;
ET0. noA.Aa koll KoXa, w ^(oKpaTes,
14 212. Kat yap ol crTpaTrjyoL, o ^tAe" dAA ofxois to K(f)a-
\aLov avT&v pcibLcos hv (lttols, otl VLKr]v iv rw 7roAe'/i(i)
aiT(pyd(ovTaL' rj ov;
ET0. U(os 8' o{>;
6 212. IToAAa 8e y\ otpLaL, Kal Kaka koI ol y(opyo[- aAA'

^ ojjicos TO K(pa.XaLov avT&v k(rTLV ttjs aiTepyaa-Las rj K ttjs
yfjs Tpocf)-/},
ET0. UAvv ye.

212. Ti 8e bri; rwy TroAAwy koi KaXS>v h ol 6ol aTTcpyd-
10 ôvrat rt t6 K(})d\aL6v o-tl Trjs kpyacrias;
ET0. Kai oAtyoy o-oi TTpoTcpov etiTov, S 2&)Kpares, ort
b TrAetWos pyov eo-rtv aKpL^&s TTdvTa TavTa o)? \l pLa6lv
Tobe fXVTOL aoi anrAajs Aeyo), ort iav fxev KxapL(rixva tls
TTL(rTriTaL TOLS 60LS \yLV TC Kal TTpdTTLV Vx6lXV0S T
Kal 6v(av, TavT (ttl tcl oo"ta, Kat o^wêt tcl TOLavTa tovs re
5 t8tOU9 OtKOU? Kat TCL KOLVCL T&V Tt6\(j}V' TCL 8' VaVTLa tG)V
K\apLa-ixV(X)V da-^ri, h 87/ KOt dvaTpTTL aiTavTa KaL
dmWvaLV.
212. 'H TToAv ju.ot 8ta /3paxvrepa)v, S> F.v6v(f)p(>)v, et
e/3ovAou, etTres av to K(pdkaLov S>v rjpdTu^v' oAAa yap ov

C 7Tp66vix6s ix et 8t8aat 8Âo? et. Kat yap vvv eTretS?) eTr
avT(a rjo-â dTTTpdiTov, et diTeKpCvo), LKavuis hv ijb-q iTapa
e 8 KdWKTra T W Arm. : KdWta-ra. 76 B a2 ante avraiu add.

T^j awepyaa-ias Schanz a 10 fpyacrias B : cnrtpya(rias T W Arm,
b I x*' ^T :
6X<" W ' *^ ^ jKOf ais B : "(ffas T
ETGY^PHN 14C
(Tov njy oa-LOTrjTa (fxefxaO-qKr}. vvv 8e avayKr] yap tov fpoovTa

rw (p(op.4v(o aKoX.ovdlv otttj ^v CKelvos vitayrf, tC brj av
keyets t6 oaiov elvai Kal r)]V ocrioTrjTa; ovyjL CTrioTTj/iTyy 5
Tiva Tov 6vLV re Kal ev\a-dai;

ET0. "Eyoyye.
211. OvKovv t6 6v(iv bcopelcrOaC cm toXs Oeols, t6 8'
(vxecrOaL alTelv tovs Oeovs;

ET0. Kat pidka, d) ôoKpaTes. 10
2X2. 'E7ri(rr^/xrj apa airqa-ecDS Kal boirecos Ofois oa-iorrjs d
av etr} ck tovtov tov koyov.
ET0. ndru Kak&s, ui ScoKpares, (rvviiKas o (lttov.
212. 'ETTt^r/utTjr^s ydp (lp.L, oj (îXe, t^s (rrjs a-o(f)Las Kal
irpoaiyu) tov vovv avTi], (Sore ov yap.aX Trecretrai ort av 5
ei7n;s. dkkd ]xol keôv tls avrr] rj VTrripea-La eo-rt rots êots;
atreii' re (j)f]s avTOvs Kal 8t8oVat eKetVoiy;

ET0. "Eycoye.
2X2. 'Ap' ovi' 011 ro ye 6p6(Ds atrety ay eirj wi/ Sedfteâ
TTop' iKuvuiV, TavTa avTOvs alTelv; 10

ET0. 'AAAa rt';
2X2. Kat av t6 8i8oVat opdoos, <Sy e/cetrot rvyx^droucrti' e

beoixevoL irap rjfxStv, Tavra eKcCvoLS av dvTLboopeladaL; ov
ydp TTov TeyvLKOv y hv dr] boiipo^jiopelv bibovTa ro) raCra wy
o^8ey Setrat.
ET0. ÂXr]6r] Xe'yeiy, u) 2(0Kpare5. 5
2X2. 'E/iiTTopiKT) dpa tls dv etr;, S) Evdv(])p(t)V, Te\vr] rj
ocTLorqs deoLs Kal dv^pdrtoLS Trap' dAAr/Acoi'.
ET0. 'E/xTTopiKTj, ei ovrtos rjbLov <tol ovoixdêLV.
2X2. 'AAA' ovbev rjbLov epoLye, ei /xt) rvyxdret dA?7ês ov.

<j)pd(rov be fxoi, tls rj bi^êkCa tols 6eoLS Txr/xdveL ovcra 0770 10
tS)v b(apo)v S)V TTap r]]i5)V kafx^dvovcTLv; a fxev ydp biôacn
c3 5tl 5); BT fpwvra Bt : ipaiToivTa T W Arm. c 4 epw-

yueVif) BT : pofj.(vei> W : (p<uTctiiJ.iv<f Arm. d5 post xcMi add.
TTore in marg. T dg 76 T : om. B Arm. (iacunam indicat W)
e9 Tiryx**'*' ^T : Tvyx**'"* ^
;
isa nAATaNOS
a Travrl drjXov ovbkv yap rjixiv kcmv ayaObv ori hv nr}
(KelvoL bHaiv. h be Trap rifj.&v kaiiâvovcTLV, tC cixfxXovvTaL; rj
TocrovTOV avT&v TrkeoveKTavfiev KaTo, rqv (imopiav, &(TTe^ TravTa

Ta ayaOa Trap avT(av Xap,âvop.V, (Kclvot 8e irap' rip.(av ovbev;
5 ET0. 'AAA' otet, S> 2a)/cpares, tovs deovs ox^cAeto-ât
aTro TOVTOiV h irap' rjpiciv Xafx^dvovcrtv
2X2. 'AAAa rt brjTroT hv etTj TavTa, S) ^vOv^pctiv, to. Trap
r)p.S)v b&pa Tols 6(oXs;
ET0. Tt 8' olet aAAo rj Tip.ri re xai yepa KaC, oTrep eyui
lo aprt eXeyov, xP'S';
b 2X2. K()(âpia-pLevov apa ((ttCv, S Fiv6v(f)p(i)V, t6 oaiov,
dAA' ovyl a)0e'At/ixoy ovb\ (f)C\ov rots êots;
ET0. Ot/xat eyo)ye iravTo^v ye /j.dAto-ra (f)CX.ov.
2X2. ToSro ap' ((ttIv av, u)s eoLKc, t6 o(tiov, to tois

5 êots (f)C\ov.
I . ET0. MdAto-rd ye.
212. 0aujLido-?7 ovv TavTa Kiyoiv edi o-ot ol Adyoi (f)aCvcov-
rat p.r] piivovTes dAAd âbCCovTes, Kal e/xe atrtdo-r/ tov

AaCbakov fiabC(pvTas avTovs ttouIv, avTOS u)V ttoXv ye
lo TxviK(i)Tepos Tov AatbdXov Kat kvkAo) TrepttovTa ttolwv; t/
oiiK ai(r6avr} otl 6 Adyos fjp.tv TTepL\6o)V TTaXLV els TavTov
C i^Ket; ixefjivrjcraL yap ttov otl ev rai TcpodQev t6 re octlov Kat

t6 6eo(f)tXes ov TavT^v rjiJ.LV e(p(xvr] dAA' eTepa aXX-qXo)V' r]
ov [xep.vr]a-aL;
ET0. 'Eywye.
5 212. NSy ovv ovK evvoels otl t6 roty êois ^CXov (f>rjs
ocrtov etvat; tovto 8' dAAo rt 17 deo(f>LXes yCyveTat; rj ov;

ET0. U6.VV ye.
212. OvKovv rj apTL ov KaX&s b)ixoXoyovp.ev, r] et t6t
KaAws, vvv ovK 6p6G)s Tt6ep.eda.
a
I icrriv rip.tv T a 9 yfpa B T ^wpa yp. tpya : W W
bg AalSa\ov^ yp. Si5d(Tica\ov ye om, T W b 10 irtpt^vTa B
:
Kfpiidvras T (sed s supra versum) Arm. c i iroSa-Ofv T ifxnpo(r6(v :
B C 3 011 B oiiSe T: c 8 6/io\oyovfJi.fv pr. B T

ET0TPi2N 15C
ET0. 'EoiKfv, xo
2X2. 'E^ o.pxrjs apa rjpuv TraAiv <rKTrriov tC kari, to

ocnov, 0)? kyoi irpXv h.v p.d6(o kKOiV eivai. ovk aTrobdktdcra).
dAAa p.ri fte dTifJida-rjs dAAa TTairrl TpoTTta TTpocrayMV tov d
vovv OTL p.dXLcrTa vvv ctTre ttjv dXrjd^Lav oXcrda ydp elirep
tls aAAoy dvdp<aTT(t)V, kol ovk d(f>T4os ct loa-TTep 6 YIpuiTfvs

TTplv dv (LTTjjs. et ydp p; rjdrjaOa aacficos t6 re oaLOV Kal t6
dvoaLOV, ovK eoTLv ottojs dv Trore (TTfxeLprjaas VTTtp dvbpds 5
drjTOs dvbpa npeajBvTriv TraTipa dLOiKad^LV <f)6vov, dkka Koi
Toiis deovs dv ibfLaas TTapaKLvbvveveLV fj.ri ovk opdSis avrd
TTOL-qaoLS, Kal tovs dvdpcoTTOvs ricTxvvdrjS' vvv be ev oi8a ort
aa(f)cos oUl (ibcvai t6 re oaLov Kal pLrj. eiTre ovv, S) ^4\TLaT e
YiVdv(f)p(i)V, Kou. p.1] dTTOKpv\}/r) OTL avTO rjyrj,
ET0. Eis avî? Toiwv, Z) 2w/cpares' vvv ydp Krireubu)
TTOL, Kai /xoi oopa diTLfvaL.

20. Ola TTOLds, S) eratpe. d7r' eATTtSoy fxe KaTaâko)v 5
fxfydkrjs diTipxi] rjv etxor, ws "jrapa aov ]xa6!j)V Ta re oaLa

KOLL ]xr] KoX TTJs TTpos M4kr]Tov ypa(f)r]s dTTakkdôfxai, erSet^d-
]xvos iKeCvco OTL ao(f)ds 7/877 Trap' Evdvcppovos to. dda yiyova l6
fcat ort ovKiTL vtt' dyvoLas avrooêStd^co ovbi KaLvoTOfxG)
TTepl avTa, Kal br] Kal tov dkkov ^Cov [ori] d]XLVOV /Stco-
aoL]xr]v.
C I r rf iiTTiv Zciov T d. i irpoaax^v scripsi : vpo<r(xo>v B :
irpoax^*' T 64 iroi] wov pr. T a3 ori secl. Schanz

f^
AnOAOriA 20KPATOY2 t. i
p. 17
"Otl }X(v v/xei?, S avbps ÂOtjvolol, TreiTovOaTe vTrb twv a

^\x5>v Karqyopcov, ovk oida* eyo) 8' ow Kat airos vtt' avTuiv
okCyov ifxavTov kTtiXa66p.r]v, ovtoh TnOavQts ekeyov. KaiToi,
akr]dis ye &)S tTTOS etTreiy oi^der elprjKacrLV. p.akLcrTa be

avTS)V ev (davnacra tS)V "nokkwv &v l-^^vaavTo, tovto er o) 5
^kcyov a)S xpri^^vpias tvka^^XcrdaL /x^ vir' kp.ov eâTraT-qOrJTe
U)s beivov ovTOs keycLV. to yap /x^ alarxvvdrjvaL otl avTLKa b

vtt' e/xou eêAeyx^^foyrai (py(o, iTreLbav /i7j8' OTrooorioCy
(fiaLVoofiaL bcLVOs keycLV, tovto fxoi cboêv avT&v avaLcryyv-

TOTttTOV LVaL, t /J.?/ apa bcLvbv KakoVCTLV OVTOL k4yLV Tbv
Takr]9ri kiyovTa^jd piev yap tovto kiyovcriv, 6p.okoyoLr]v av 5
^yooye ov KaTO. tovtovs elvaL pi^TOip. ovtol pikv ovv, u>crTrep
eyo) k4yu), rj tl rj ovbev akriOes (IpiqKaa-LV, vfxels b4 fxov clkov-

o-ecrê TTacrav Tr]v akr^dcLav ov fxivTOL p.a ACa, ui avbpes
'AOrivaloL, KKakXLTrr]pLVovs ye koyovs, uxnrep ol tovtcov,
prifxacrL re Kal ovofxaa-LV ovbe K^KOcrfxrffxivovs, aAA' aKov- C

crecrde eiKjj keyofxeva toIs (ttltvxovctlv dvofxaaLV Trto-revco
yap bUaLa (tvaL a Ae'ya) Ka\ /iTjSets vfx&v TTpocTboKr^cTaTut

aAAo)?* ov8e yap av brjirov TtpîTOL, o) avbpes, T?}8e tt)
7/AtKta wcnrep fxLpaKL(a TrkaTTOVTL koyovs eis vfLas ela-LtvaL. 5
Koix ixiVTOi Kul TTaw, S) CLvbpes 'AdrjvaloL, tovto vfxu)v beofxaL
a 2 iyi) 5 ow B : tT-co-y o5;/ T a3 i/xavrhv T a 6 Xf ^''

B xp^"" (îc) T b4 ovtoi B ai>Tol T b6 fj.fv oZv B T ixtv
W
: : :
y oiiv B^ : fiiv yip Arm. b? {Jt^B: oui^W (scd ov erasum

et ^ s. V. W; : om. T

17 c nAATX2N02
Koi TTapCeixai,' eav 8ia Tutv avr&v Xoycov aKOvrjrc jjlov airo-
XoyovfJêvov bC &VTTp dioOa Xiynv koX kv ayopq em toov
TpaTTe^cov, tva vpiSiV ttoWoI aKTjKoacn, KaX aXkodi, /XTjre
d 6av[xdCiv p.r]Te Oopvêtv tovtov (VKa. Ixei yap ovtuxtL

vvv eyo) iTputTov cttI biKaa-Tripiov aval3ifir]Ka, (tt} yeyovias
k^hop.r]KOVTa' a.TXV(os ovv êvoos exw Trjs ivOdbe Aeêtos.
&a-TTep ovv dv, et rai ovti êvos eTvy\avov &v, a-vveyiyvat-
5 a-KeTe 8?/7rou dv p.oi el ev iKîvr] Trj (p(t)vfj re Kal rai TpoTTio
l8 (\eyov iv olaTtep eTe6pdp.p.r]v, Kal br] Kal vvv tovto V]X(3iV
bioixat bUaLOV, &s yk p.oi 8okS, tov jxev TpoiTOV rrjs Aeêo)?
iav- t(ra)s ixev ydp \eLp(ov, lo-o)? be l3e\TC(ov av eirj aiiTO
be TOVTo aKOTTCtv Kal TOVTid Tov vovv TTpo^rexeLV, el biKaLa
5 Aeyo) ?/ ]xry bLKaaTOV p.ev yap avrq dperr], pr]TOpos 8e

Takr]6ri XeyeLV.
YlpSiTov ixev ovv biKaLos ei/xi dTTo\oyrja-aa-6aL, S) dvbpes

Â6r]vaL0L, TTpos Ta Trpwrd pLOV yjrevbfj KaTr]yopr]]Xva Kal rovs
TTp(i)T0Vs KaTrjyopovs, eiTeLTa 8e TTpos Ta vaTepov Kal tovs

b vcTTepovs. (p.ov ydp ttoXXol Kar-qyopoL yeyovaaL trpos vpids
Kal TrdkaL iToXXd 7)817 ^'''1 '^"' ovbev d\r]6is XeyovTes^^ôts

eyoi ]xdKkov (f)ol3ov]j.aL r] tovs dpi(f)l "Avvtov, KaiiTep ovTas
Kal TOVTOvs beLVOvs' dAA' eKeXvoL beLvoTepoL, o) dvbpes, 0%
6 vp.S)v Tovs TToXXovs eK 7Taib(i)V iTapaka^xjBdvovTes TTeL66v
re KOL Karriyopovv epiov [p.dXX.ov] ovbev dXr]des, cos eo-rtv rts
^coKpdrqs ao(f)ds dvqp, Ta re p.eTe.(Dpa ^povTLarqs /cat Ta

VTTO yrjs TTavTa dve^qrqKMS Kal tov iJTTU) Xoyov Kpeirru)
C TTOL&v. ovTOL, S) dvbpes 'A6qvaL0i, <ôl) ravrqv Tr]v (f)r]pLr]v
KaTacTKebda-avTes, ol betvoi elcrLV ]xov Karqyopof ol ydp

aKOvovTes r^yovvraL tovs ravTa ^qTOVvras ovbe 6eovs vo]xiêLV.
eTTCLTa elcTLV ovtol 01 KarqyopoL TroAAot Kai ttoXvv x^povov
e8 îrl TW Hipp. Min. 368 b koI ^wl B : 09 KoKKoi B ol :
KoKKol T .d 3 f^ho^7\Kovra B schol. ad Hermogenem irAtiw :
i^ôfxr)KovTa T a 9 varfpov T vffrepa B W : b 2 /cai ante

ovZiv secl. Schanz b 6 fiaKKov B om. T b 7 (hfovriarijs
:
secl. Bamberg t 8 irdvra T &Travra B: C i oi add. Heindorf

C3 oLKovovTfs B- T W : aKoiffavns B 04 ^5j XP^''"" ^
AnOAOriA 212KPATOT2 i8c
7/677 KaTrjyoprjKOTes, ert b^ koI iv Tavnj tt/ rjXtKLa Xeyoirres 5
Trpos v[xas iv 77 av ixaXLcrTa eirioTeware, 7rat8e? 6vt(.s (viol
Vfxoiv Kal ixip6.Kia, drexJ^ci)? ep7j/x7jy KaTr^yopovvTcs aTroAo-

yovfxevov ovbevos. ^ 6 8e TrdvToov aXoycoTaTov, otl ovhe to.
ovopLaTa OLOv re avTcov eibevaL Kal eiTretr, TrAT/v ei ri? d

KcoixiaboTTOLos Tvyxd-Vd- oiv. 6(T0L 8e Ôovdi Kal bLajSokfi
XpcojxfvoL vfjMs dvTTeL6ov ot 8e Kot aiToi TreTTeto-Txeroi
dWovs TTeCdovTes ovrot Travres aTTopcoTaTOL eiaLV ovbe ycp

dvajSL^da-aaOaL oXov r' eo-rtv avTcav ivTavOol ovb^ (KeyâL 5
ovbeva, dAA' dvdyKrj dTfX^^s ooaiTep aKLafxaxf^v dTTo\oyav-

fXv6v re Kat eAe^yxety fxrjbevbs dTTOKpLvop.vov.\*' d^Loia-aTe
ovv Kal Vfxds, (3o-7rep iyo) Xiyoi, bLrrovs fxov tovs Karrjydpovs
yeyovevaL, ere'/x)vy piev tovs dpTL Karrjyoprfo-avTas, (Tepovs 8e
Tovs TroAai ovs eyo) Ae'ya), Kat oir]6r]Te beiv TTpos Klvovs e
TTpu>T6v /xe aTroAoyT/o-ao-âf Kat ydp v/xeiy iKeCvcov TTp6Tpov
^KovcraTC KaTTiyopovvTOiV Kal iTokv ixdXXov rj Tcavbe tcov
vcTTepov,
Etey aTroAoyT/reoy 877, S dvbpes Â^rfvaloL, Kal iTTLX^Lpri-
Tov v[xcov eêAe'o-ât Trjv Sia/SoAT/y rjv v/xet? iv TroAAw XP^^^ ^9

eoêre TavTr]v iv ovTuts oAtyo) xpdvco. jSovXoCixriv ixev ovv
av TovTo ovTcos yeviadaL, et rt dfXfLvov Kal vixZv kol ip.oC,
Kal Trkiov tC /xe irotT/o-at dTroAoyoT^/xeroy ot/xai 8e avro

XaAeTroy etyai, Kat ov Trdw /xe Aai^^diêt 010'^ ioTLv. o/xcos 5
TOVTo ix(v tro) OTTT/ rw 0eo) (^tXov, roi 8e iô^/îfa) TTeLo-Tôv Kal
dvoKoyriTiov.
'Avakdôiixev ovv i^ dpxrjs tCs r] KarqyopCa ioTLV i^ rjs
7/ ipiri bLajSoXri yiyovev, ^ bri koX TTiarevoiv MiXrjTos /xe iypd- b

^lraTO Trjv ypacfrriv TavTrjv. eiey rt 877 Ae^yovre? 8te'âAAoy
ot Sta/SdAAoyres; coaiTfp ovv KaTrjyopoov ttjv dvTu>noa-Cav

Sei dvayv&vai avr&v " 'S.ooKpdTris dSiKei Kai TTfpLipydîTaL
Ct^tG>v rd re vtto y^s koi ovpdvLa Ka\ tov T/rro) Adyov KpeCTTca 5
c 7 vnu>v TW Arm. : 5' vti.Siv B d i ei /x^ ns W Arm.

d4 irai/Tes BT W : iroi/roiv Arm. d5 ivravQl T a2 ex""* T
a 3 ovTuaiv pr. T a 5 Ojua;? B : 8yus 5e T b i 77 5?; B : ^Stj
T b5 ouâvta B : ra iirovpavia T
19 c nAATaNOS
C TTOLOiV Kol aWoVS TaVTCL TaVTa bLbdcTKMV. TOLaVTrj TLS eCTTLV'
TavTa yap koopaTe Kal avTol iv tt) ^ ApLcrTOCpdvovs /ca)//,(j>8ta,
Eco/cpartj TLva CKet Treptêpoju.eiôi', (pda-KOVTa re depojSaT^lv
Kal aXkr]V TroAA^y (f)kvapLav (pkvapovvTa, av eyo) ovbev ovt
S ixeya ovt p.LKpbv Tt^pi 7rato). koI ov>( ws drt/xaC<"i' kiyo)
Tr]v TOLavTrjv k'nL(TTr\p.r]v, et ri? rrept t5>v tolovtcov (rocpos
ka-TLv p.r) TTcos eyo) vtto MekrjTov TO(ravTas bLKas 4>^vyoLpLL

dkXa yap eptot rourcoi^, o) dvbpes 'AOrjvawL, ovbev pLeT(TTLV,
d p.dpTVpas be av vp.wv tovs Trokkovs 7rape'xo/xat, Kat d^t(3
v/xas dkkrjkovs bLbda-KLV re Kai (f)pd^(LV, oaoi p.ov TrcoTTore

aKrjKoaTe bLakeyop.evov TroAAot 8e vfxoiv ol tolovtol el(TLV
(f)pd(Te ovv dAAÂots et TTcaiTOTe t] jXLKpbv r/ p.ya ijkov(t4
5 rts vpLoiv e/xoC Trept t&v tolovtoi)V bLakeyopievov, Kal iK
TOVTOV yv(i)a-e(T6e otl TOLavT eaTl Kal Takka Trept epiov h ol

iTokkol keyovcTLV.
'AAAa yap ovTe tovtoov ovbev eaTLV, oiibe y et riyos
aKr^KoaTe 0)s eyo) iTaLbeveLV eTTtxetpo) dv6 pcLiTovs Kal \pr]p.aTa

e TTpdTTop.aL, ovbe TOVTO dkr]6es. eTrel koX tovto ye p.0L boKel
Kakbv etvaL, et tls olos t etr/ TraLbeveLV dv6p(0TT0vs oâ-Trep
TopyCas re 6 Aeoi^rtiôs Kat IlpoStKos 6 Ketos Kai iTTTrtas 6
'HAetos. TOVTO)v ydp eKacTTOS, oo dvbpes, otos r ecrTLv lo)V
5 ets eKdcTTriv tG)V TTokeoiv tovs veovs ots eêcTTL tS)V eavTutv
TTOkLTCOV TTpOLKa CTVVeLVaL O) d^ j3ovko)VTaL TOVTOVS TTeLÔVCTL
20 rds eKeLVOov o-vvovcrLas aTTokLiTovTas crcf)LaLV crvveLvaL XPV'

/xara bLbovTas Kal ydpLV TrpocreLbevaL. * eTret Kai dkkos dvrjp
ea-TL ndptos evOdbe aocf^bs bv eyo) paôp.r^v eTTLbrjp.ovvTa'
eTVXOV yap TTpoaek6o)v dvbpl bs TeTekeKe xPWCLTa cro^to-rats
C I ra, avra. Tavra Bw : toCto T : to oiiTa W C7 /u^ ttojs BT :
ix-fj-iro) W et Arm. (ut vicJetur) : kot' b

yUT^ (pevyot/ut T : B
(pvyot/xt
P8 iuo\ TOVTOiv B : jxoi rSiv roiovrajv T d. I S' oii 1 : Se avrovs B :
5' Schanz
avToov da e/j.ov B: v/ii.aiv T d6 tovtov T:
rovTuiv B ToAAa B^T Arm. iroWa B W : 62 (Luirep . . .
aa irpoa-fiSevai c{. Theag. 1270 63 ts B om. : T a^ TTAe/c

B : TTeA.'/cei T
AnOAOriA SilKPATOTS 2oa
7rA.eta) rj aviXTTavTCS ol aAAoi, KaXXtq to) 'Ittttovlkov' tovtov 5
ovv avr]p6ixriv koTov yap avT^ bvo vel "'X2 KaAAia," rjy
8' " et /xey <tov to) êt TrwAa) ^ fxocrxoD kyevia-Oriv,

eyw,
fXxop.V &v avToiv (TnardTrjv Aaêiv Kal pLLcrdcitXTacrdai 6?
IjLieAAei' avrco KaAci) Te Kayaô) TrotTjo-eu' T^y irpoariKova-av b
dpeTTjr, 7]y 8' &r ouTO? ^ twv ittttikwv tls r] Twy yecopyt/cwy*
iwv 8' eTretS^ avdpc^Trui ((ttov, TLvq ovtolv kv V(^ exet?

iTTLaraTriv Aa/3ety; Tts tt)? TotavTTj? dpeTijs, ttjs dvdpcoTTLvris
T KOL TToXtTLKfjs, (TTLOTqixMV kaTLV, oXjxaL ydp cr iarK(pdai 5

8ia Ti}V TO)V vecov KTr\crLV. ia-TLV Tts," ec^ryy eyw, " r/ oii;"
8' 6s. 8' "
"ndin; ye," 77 "Tt?," ^r eyw, kol 7ro8a7rd?, Kat
7rdo-ou 8t8do-Kei;" "EuTjros," e^^r/, "S 2&)KpaTes, ndptos,
"nivTe firoiy." koi eyo) Toy ^vrjvov p.aKdpLcra et ws dkrjdSiS
l)(oi Tavrqv ttjv T\vr]v Ka\ ovto^s iixfxekds 8t8do-Ket. eycb C

yovv Ka\ avTos eKak\vv6[xriv Te Kai rij3pvv6[xr]v dv ei r]TTLcrTdixr]v
TavTa' dAA' ou ydp iiTLcrTaiiaL, 2 di^^pe? 'A^r/vatot.
'TTToAdôt &z; ovv tls vixo)v ta-diS' " 'AAA', SwKpaTey,

To o-oy Ti eoTt TTpdyixa; irdêy at bLajBoXaL croL avTaL yy6- 5
vacTLv; ov ydp bi]TTOV a-ov ye ovbev t&v dkkoiv TTepLTT^Tepov

TrpayixaTevoixivov TTLTa TOcravTr] (f>r]ixr] T Kal Adyos yyovV,
et ix-q TL TTpaTTs dkkolov 17 ot TToAAot. ' Ae'ye ovv rnuv n
ia-TW, Lva ft^ rjixels irepl aov avTooê8td{a)]uei'." Tavri /i,Ot d
8oKer 8tKata Aeyeiy 6 kdyoiv, Kayo) vixlv 7retpdo-o/itai aTro-
8etat Tt ttot' eorty tovto b e/xoi TTTTOLr]KV t6 t 6vop,a
Kal Tr]V bLaôk^qv. dKOVT 877. Kal la-oos p-ev bdôi TLalv
vpS)V TTaL^LV' ev ixVTOL XcrT, TTacrav vpXv Ti]V dkr]0Lav 5
epci). eyo) ydp, dvbpes 'A^rjiâtot, 8t' ovbv dAA' 77 8td

(Toîav TLva tovto t6 6vop.a ayz]Ka. TToiav 8r) aro(f)iav
TavTr]v; r]iTp eoriy icro)? dvdpcoiTivr] (ro(pia' tw ofTt ydp

Kti;8vreva) Tavrqv etyat crocpds. 1 ovTot 8e t^x' dy, ovs dpTt
a6 oSf BT : yap W bi Ka\(i re /cai dyaPo) B : Ka\w KayaOw T

C I fxo'' BTW :
X" ^^- 5i5a(r/cet B Arm. : 5(5a(7/coi TW 7^-7'
oii> ex emend. T : iyu) oSv B pr. T C3 5 B : cm. T c8 i
/xTj , , . 01 voWoi secl, Cobet
20 e nAATHNOS
e (Xeyov, ixcCCoi TLva rj Kar avOpitHTOV (To<îav (ro(f>ol ftev, rj
ovK Ix^ '^ Aeyo); ov yap br] (ydiyc avrqv ^TriVTajaat, oAA'
ooTis (f)r}(rl \j/vbTaC re Kal TtI bcalSoXrj rrj e/UT/ A.eyet. Kat
/xot, 0) avbpes 'AOrjvawi, fxr] dopvj3r](n]T(, pirjb' iav bo^d) rt
5 vfuv iMya Aeyeiy ov yap ijjibv epo) ror Xoyoi' ov h,v ^^yoo>
aAA' eis a^Loyjyecav vpuv tov keyovTa avo[a-(o. Trjs yap
ffiT/s', et 817 rts ea-Tiv a-o(f)La Kal ota, fxApTvpa vfuv "napiôixaL
Tov diov Tov iv AeA(/)ots.*j XaLp(f)(avTa yap lo-re ttov. ovtos
21 efxos re eratpoj ^v e/c zê'ou jcai vfxciv t(o TrATjêt eratpos re
Kal (rvve(f)vy ttjv (f)vyr}v TavTrjv koI jxeO' vix&v Kar?;Aê.
Kat lo^re br] olos tjv X.aLp(f)(av, o)s (r(f)obp6s e(/)' ort opp.ri(rLV.
Kal 877 TTore Kat ets AeAôvs \6oi)V kT6kp.riae tovto p.avTv-
5 aaaOaL Ka^, oTrep Xeyct), ixr] dopv^LT, u) avbpes ypeTO yap
bi] et rts e]xov eirj (ro(f>(aTpos. avelXev ovv rj nu^ta ]xr]biva
(ro(f)(aTpov elvaL. Kal tovtu^v 7re'pt 6 abeX(f)bs v]xiv avTov

ovTocn fxapTvpiqa-eL, eTretS^ eKetvos rereAevrTjKey./
b ^K\f/aa-de bi] <!)v 'iveKa TavTa Ae'yco* ]ieXX(i) yap v]xas 8t8a-
êty oOev ]xol 77 bLajSoXr] yeyovev. TavTa yap eyoo aKova-as
evedv]xov]xr]v ovTcocri' " Tt TTore Aeyei 6 6e6s, Kal ri TTOTe

alvirreTaL; eyo) yap br] ovre fxeya ovtc a-]XLKpbv avvoLba
5 epi.avT(^ a-o(f)bs &v Ti ovv Trore Ae'yet (f^dcrKcov e/ie a-o(f)(a-
TaTOV etrat; ov yap brîTov \pêvbeTai ye* ov yap 6ep.LS
avT(o." Kal TTokvv fxev y^p^vov r^mpovv Ti Trore Aeyef

eTreira /xoyts ttixvv eTrt ^Tjrrjcrty avTOV TOLavrqv tlvo, eTpaiTO-
fxr]v. r]k6ov etTi TLva T&v boKovvT(t)v a-o(f)U)V elvaL, iws

C evTavda eliTep ttov ekey^(t)V Tb jxavTelov Kal a7TO(f)av(Jiv rw
\pr](rp.^ 6tl"Ovto(tl epov a-o(f)(iTep6s eaTL, crv 8' epe e(f)riada."
bLaa-KOTT&v ovv TOVTOV dv6]xaTL yap ovbev beo]xaL keyeLV,
^V be TLS tS)V TTOkLTLK&V TTpOS OV eyO) a-KOTT&V TOLOVTOV TL
62 Ti B : oTi T
/i?75' iav Heusde 64 /UTjSe h.v B firiSiv &j/ T : :
67 (l St) (om. koI o'la) Arm.

Ti fTTiv, ffocpias a 1 t fraipos^
eraTpSs T6 Schanz fraTpSs t( secl. Cobet fToipSs ts Kal secl.
W
:
Liidwig a 5 Qopvfi(~Tf 6opv$rJTf T 6opvê't(r6t B

: b i S^ :
TArm, ^SeB-W C 3 oiTOcrl t /*oi/ B : oStJs 76 /uou f C^TOiovTovi

T. T
:
AnOAOriA 2i2KPATOTS 21C
(iradov, o) &vbpS 'A^Tjyaioi, Koi StaA.eyo/xeros avT(^ ^boê 5
fxot, ovTOS 6 avrjp boKelv fjiev elvai (ro(f>bs aXXois re ttoAAoi?
av6p(iOTTOts Kal juoAto-Ta kavTU), (TvaL 8' ov' KaireLTa CTreipw-
^r]v avTco ba.KVVvaL otl oIolto jjikv (IvaL (ro(f)6s, eir/ 8 ov.
evTevdev ovv tovtco re aTTr]y66iJLr\v kcu TTokXols r<Sy TTap6vT(ov d

77/309 kp.aVT0V 8' OW 07710)1' kXoy L(6\Xr]V OTL TOVTOV pL(V TOV
avdpôTTOv eyo) a-o(j)(i)Tep6s dfXL' KLvbvveveL y.ev yap r]p.SiV
ovSeVepos ovbev koXov KayaOov ilbivaL, dAA.' ovtos /xey
oierai tl eibevaL ovk eiSws, eyo) 8e, uxriTep ovv ovk olba, 5
ov8e oio/xatA eotxa yovv tovtov ye afXLKpca tlvl avTto TovT<a

(TO(^(i>Tpos (TvaL, OTL CL /x^ oi8a ovbc oLOfxaL (IbivaL. evTevdev
eTr' aAAoi' rja tuiv eKetVou boKovvTcov (ro(p(i)T4p(i)V etvaL Kai
]xoL TavTOL TavTa e8ofe, Kat kvTavda KaKLV(a Kal aAAots e

TToAAots aTTr]yB6]xr]v.
Mera ravr' ovv r]br] itpe^rjs fia, al(r6av6fXvos fxev [Kal]
kvTTOVfxevos Kal 8e8ta)S ort aTTr]y6av6]xr]v, ojxcos 8e avayKalov

e8oKet etvat to tov 6eov iTepl TrkiLcrTOv TToteto-âf ' tre'oi' 5
OVV, (TKOTTOVVTL TOV \pr](TpOV TL X4yL, eTTl CLTTaVTaS TOVS TL
boKOvvTas ilbivaL. Kal vr] tov Kvva, o) avbpes 'Adr^valoL 22

8et yap TTpos ii/xas roATj^^ Xiy^LV 17
]xr]v (yoi TTad6v tl
TOLOVTOV 01 fxev /xaAto-ra evôKt/xowres ibo^dv fxoL oXCyov
belv Tov TTXiLcrTov vbeels etrat ^rjroiJyrt KaTo. tov 6i6v,
aAAoi 8e boKOVvres (pavX^Tepoi TTLLKa-TpoL elvaL avbpes 5
TTpOS TO (f)pOVLfX(aS 1x^1^'. Sei 8^ VfXLV TTfV kfxrfv TTXdvrfV
7TLbLâL axTTTep tt6vovs tlvcls TTOVOVjrros tva fxoL Kal. dv-

eXeyKTOS r] fxavTeCa yevoLTO. fXTa ydp tovs ttoXltlkovs r]a
eTTi rovs 7T0Lr]Tds tovs re tcov Tpay(>bt(av Kal tovs, tS)V
bL6vpdfx(3(iov Ka\ Tovs ctAAou?, <uy (VTav6a eir' avTO(f)(i)p(d b

KaTaXr]\l/6]Xvos cfxavTOV dfxa6i(TTepov CKeCvâv ovTa. ^ dva-
XapLJSdvcav ovv avTwv to, TTOLrffxaTa d fxoL e8oKet fxdXLO-Ta
TTcnpayfxaTevcrdaL avTols, bLr]p(j)TU)v hv avTOVs tC XiyoLfv,
C5 Ko.\ 5ia\fy6/x(vos avr^ secl. Schanz d6 76 BT : om. W

e3 Kal secl. Cobet e 5 heov ovv B : Irtov oly iSSKei iivai Arm.
Koi ifvai T a7 ixoi Koi BT W : û^ uoi Arm. al.
.
22b nAATXlNOS
6 ir' ^jua rt Koi iiavOdvoifXL irap' avr&v,/ alcryyvoiiai ovv
viilv ilirelv, 0) avbpes, TdXrjOfj- o/xo)? be p-qreov. w? cttos
yap eiTrew oAtyou avr&v aTravTes ol TxapovTes hv /3eArtoy
(\eyov irepl S>v avTol iTreTTOtriKea-av. eyv(ov ovv av Kal
TTepl tS>v TTOtrjrdiy ev 6\(y(a tovto, otl ov o-o(j)Ca ttolouv
C h TTOLoXev, dKkd (f^vaeL tlvI Kal evOovcrLaôvTes c3o-7re/) ot
OeopidvTeLS Kal ol xPV^H-^ôC' Kal ydp ovtol keyovcTL p.ev
TToAAa Kat KoAa, icraorii' 8e ovbev &v XeyovcTL. tolovtov

' rt |u,ot e(f)dvr}a-av Trddos Kal ol TrotJjrat ireTTOvdoTes, koX
5 dp.a ficrOoixrjv avTOiV 8ta r^y TToiricrLV oloixevcav Kal raAAa

cro(f)(iiTdT(i)V elvaL dv6 pdiTToav h ovk ^crav. aTn/a ovv Kal
evTevOev rw avroi oto'jueros iTepLyeyovevaL uyrTep kcu T(av
1T0X.LTLK(aV.
TeAeuroii' ovv eiTL tovs xeipoTexyas â* epiavT^ yap

d (Tvvfihri ovhev eTTto-rajLteyo) ws tovtovs bi y ^bri
eiros etTretv,
OTL evpi^croLixL TToAAa *cat KaAa eiTLcrTaixevovs. Ka\ tovtov

ixev ovK e\frev(r6r]v, dAA' riiTLcrTavTO h eyo) ovk riiTLCTTdp.riv
Kai ixov TavTTi ao^fxaTepoL îa-av. dAA', 2 dvbpes 'AdrivatoL,

6 TavTOV ixoL eboâv e\eLV dixdpTrnxa OTTep Ka\ ol TTOLriToX koX
ol dyado\ brnxLovpyoi Sta to ttiv Teyvriv KakSiS eêpyd-
êcrdaL eKaaTos riîov Ka\ Takka Ta ixeyLcrTa cro(p(aTaTos
LvaL Kal avTU)V avrr] r} TTkr]ixp.ekeLa eKeivriv r?)y (ro(f)iav
e diTOKpvTTTeLV utaTe p-e ep.avTov dvepodTav viTep tov \priap.ov

TTOTepa beâiixriv dv ovtoi)s ooa-iTep ex") ^êtv, ixrJTe tl a-o(f)bs
ci)V Triv eKeiv(t)v o-ocfiiav ixriTe djxadris rfiv d[xa6iav, ^ d/x-
(fôTepa h eKeZvoL eyovcnv eêLV. aTTeKpLvdpLriv ovv eixavT^

6 Kat rw XPI^H-^ ort /xot Avo-treAot ojo-Trep ex^ exetr.
'Ek TavTria-\ bri ttjs eêTda-eu^s, o) dvbpes Â6r]vaioL,
23 TToAAat ixev aTTeydeLai jxol yeyovaa-L Koi otat x^^^'^^^^'''^'-
b 8 avT om. B b tovto B T TovT(f> W Arm. c6

W Arm.9
: ^ffav
TW
:
B T yp. W : iJKovffav c 7 t$ ovt^ B^ : Th avrh B : t^

avT(ji avToiv al. Schanz d. i Se 7'] 8' eS Cobet e i airoKpviTTeiv
W : airoKpinrTfL B : aTreKpvKTiv T Arm. a5(rT yue e/xavThv B : Siffre
fif Ka\ avThv T : Sctt' ifj.e e/navThv Heindorf e 5 \vfftTfXe7 W
e6 Tavrrjffl Sr; BT : TavTrjs fjSy] W t i^fTciffioiis T VV : 6|cos B
: a
AnOAOriA 2f2KPATOT2 23
Koi j3apvTaTai., &(tt TToXKas 8ta/3oAay aTr' avrStv yiyovivai,

ovofj.a 8e tovto Xiycr6ai, (TO(\>oi eiyof oXovTai yap fie
kKacTTOTi 01 TTap6vTs TavTa avTov elvaL (ro(j)ov h av akXov

eêXeyô). to 8e KLvbvveveL, S) avbpS, rai ovtl 6 ^coy 6
(ro(f)6s LvaL, Kal iv t(o xprjcrp.^ TOVT(p tovto keyLV, otl tj
avdpoiTTLirr] (TO(f)La dXtyou tlvos a^Ca (cttIv /cai ovb^vos. kol
<\)aLVTaL '^TOVTOV kiyiLV Tov ScoKparr;, 'Kpo(rK\pr\(r6aL 8e

rw ejLtw ovopaTL, kpk Ttapab^Lypa TTOLovpevos, S)cnTp av b
êt^ eiTTOt ort " Ovros vpG>v, o) av6p(x)TT0L, (ro^fxaTaTos icTTLV,
OOTtS &CnTp '2(i)Kp(XTT}S yVO)KV OTL OvbeVOS a^LOS icTTL TTJ
aX.r]6Lq iTpos a-o(})Lav." TavT^ ovv eyo) piiv tl Kal vvv

7TpLL0i)v Cv^^ '^^'' ip^vvci KaTo. Tov dcov Kal TO)V aoToiv Kal 5
êvo)v av TLva olo)p.aL (ro(p6v HvaL' Kal iiTeLbdv jxol /x^

boKi], ro) 6eQ> ôrjd&v kvb^LKwpaL otl ovk ((ttl cro(f)6s. Kal
VTTO TavTrjs Trjs dcrôAtay ovt tl t&v ttjs TroAecoy TTpaâC
fioL aôki] yiyovev a^LOV k6yov ovre tc^v oIklo)v, dAA' iv

TTvCq pvpCq elpl 8ta rrjv tov 6eov XaTp^Cav. C
ri/jos 8e TOVTOLs OL vioL p.0L iTTaKoXovdovvTcs OtS /Ltd-
Xtcra oôAt/ icTTLV, ol T(av TrAovo-iajrdrcoi' avT^paroL,

yaCpovcTLV aKovovTis i^TaCo\xivo)V t&v av6p(a7TO)v, Kal avTol
TTokka.KLS ipi pLpovvTaL, etra eTrixeipoucrti' dAAoDj eêrdêti'* 5
KaiTLTa oXpaL vpC(TKOVcrL TTokkr^v a(p6ovCav OLop.ivo)v p.iv
(IbivaL TL a.v6p(aTT0)v, etSdrcoy 8e oAtya 17 ovbiv. ijfTvdv

ovv OL vtt' avTO)v i^TaC6pV0L ipol opyCCovTai, ov^ avrots,
Kai Ae'yovo-ty ws ôoKpdrqs tCs icTTL pLapcjTaTos Kal 8ta- d
<f)6CpL TOVS vioVS' Kal ilTLbdv TLS aVTOVS ipO)Tq OTL TTOLOiV
Kal OTL bLbdcTKoov, iyova-L p.V ovbV etTretr dAA' dyvoovcrLV,
as \fyf (Tdai'] \eyofj.ai Schanz as HvSpes B : &vSpe5 'AOrjvaToi T

a 8 TovTov] tovt' ov F. A. Wolf bI ifjie Bt i^k Se T b2 et
W
:
add. Stephanus b 4 tj T : ex*" Ti b b5 fTjTw Bt

ivi^riTw T b6 ^fvaiv B : T
04 4^(Taô/xfvwv B :
tcHv êvaiv
i^f\fyXOfjifvci)v T C 7 av6pci>ir(i)V B : tuv avOpunaiv T d\lya B :
^ 6\iya T C 8 oiix avTols T oAA' ovx at'To7s B : oAA.' oiiK avTo7s
W W
:
ex emend, d i ia-Ti tis Arm. ds oAA' ayvoova-iv

secl. Cobet oAA' afx(piyvoov<Tiv Schanz
:
PLATO, VOL. I. 3
:
23d nAAT12N02
Xva be )ur) boKQartv aTTopelv, ra Kara TrdvTcov tS)V (pikocro-
5 <f>ovvT(t)v TTp6\Lpa TavTtt kiyovcnv, oti " to, )u,frea)pa Kal
Ta VTTo yrjs " Kal " Oeovs /xj) vofxCêiv " Kal " tov '^ttco
\6yov KpeiTTOii TTOLiXv." TCL ycLp dXrjOij oXofxat ovk av

kdikoLiV keycLV, otl KardSrjXot yCyvovTaL TTpo(nTOLOv[xcvoL
piev cibivaL, etSorcs 8e ovbev. cLTe ovv otjuai 0tAo'rtju.ot
e ovTS Kal a-(f)obpol kol TTokkoi, Kal (TvVTTa}xivois /cat ttl-
6av(as kcyovTcs iTepl ip.ov, kp.TT(TTkrfKaa-LV vjx&v tcl S^ra koI

TTakaL Kal a-(f)obpws bLa/BdkkovTes. (k tovtcov Kal MeArjros
juot eTTedcTO Kal "Avvtos Kal Avkcov, M^krjTos fxkv VTTep t&v
5 TTOtrjrd)!' ayOdp-ivos, "Avvtos 8e viT^p t&v brjfXLovpy&v Kal
24 T&V TTOkLTLK&V, AvKUiV 8e VTTp tQ)V prjTOpUiV &(JT, 01Tp
dpxopLevos eyo) ckeyov, davp.dCoLp^ av et otos r' etrjz; eyo)
vix&v TavTrjv Trjv bLa/iok-qv iêkicrOaL iv ovrcos oAtyw XP^^^V

ovToi TTokkrjv yeyovvlav. TavT (o-tlv vfXLV, S dvbpcs 'A^rj-
5 vatot, TakrjOr], Kal vfxds ovtc fxiya ovt fXLKpbv dTTOKpxr^d-
fxivos eyo) Aeyco ov8' v7roo-retXdju.eyo?. KaLTOL oTba axebbv
OTL avTols TovTOLS dTTexddvofxaL, b Kal TiKfxrfpLov OTL dkrjOrj
kiyot) Kal OTL avTrj (cttIv rf bLajBokrf rj cfxrf Kal tcl aLTLa
b TavTd ka-TLV. kcll edvTe vvv idvT av^ts ^rfTrfa-r]T TavTa,
ovT(i)s evp^trere.
riepi juev ovv S)V ol npS^Toi fxov KarqyopoL KaTrfyopovv
avTrf io-TU) LKavTf aTTokoyCa TTpbs vfxds' TTpbs 8e M4krfTov

5 Tbv dyaObv kcll ^LkoirokLV, ws 0rj(rt, Kat tovs va-Tepovs
fXTd TavTa TTeLpdcrofxaL dTTokoyrforaa-OaL. avOLS ydp brf,
&a-TTep iTipcjiv T0VT(av ovTutv KaTrfyopoiv, kd^difx^v av Trfv

TOVTdiv dvT())fxoaiav. exft 8e 7ra)s w8c* "ScoKpdrrf (prforlv
d7 voif7v Bt : iroif? T d9 efSeVoj ri Cobet et sic Artn.

ei (Ti/i/TeTa/ifVws] ^vvTfray/xfVCifs BTW 63 ird\ai Kol TW: iraAoi
Kal vvv b <r<t>oSpa B^ 65 Kal rwv iroKtTiKSiv secl. Cobet sed
legit Laertius a 2 iyi) apx^/JLfvos T a 7 avTo7s to^tois Arm.
To7s avTo7s BT to7s avTo7s tovtois Schanz oArjfl^ B
TaA?;?} T
WTW
: :
b4 f(TT(t) Arm. : VtIv B airo\oyia B : ^ aTo\oyia T

bS itya&hv T: aya96v t6 B b6 aTro\oyii<Ta(TOai T: ^TroAo-
yf7<T6ai Bt b7 tovtoov fTfp<av T b8 5^ irSis ; w5e Herwerden
AnOAOriA SHKPATOTS 24^
^tKcty Tovs T v4ovs bLa(f)6eipovTa Kal Oeovs ovs rj TroAts
ito/Aiêt 01 voixiCovTa, Tpa be SatjuoVta Kaivd. to pikv bi] c

(/Kk-qfXa TOLOVTOV icTTLV TOVTOV bc TOV y KX.r] fXaTOS ^v
iKaCTTOV ^Td(rWIX(V.
<l>rjo-t yap brj tovs viovs dbiKilv fx( bLacpOeipovTa. eyo) bi
yc, 0) dvbpes 'A^Tjyatot, dbLKelv <j)r]ixL MikrjTov, otl (nrovbf] 5

XaptevTtffTai, paStcos ets dy&va Ka^toras dvOpia-novs, irepl
TTpayfxdTdiv TTpocnTOLOvfxevos a-7T0vbdCLV Kal K-^becrdaL Stv ovbiv

Tovro) TrajTrore ifxekrfcrev ws 8e rouro ovrco? exet, TTeLpdaoixaL
KOLvpXv eTTtSetât. KaL fxoi bevpo, S) MeÂrjre, eiTre'* aXAo rt 17
irept TrAeto-rou ttoljj ottcos cbs îKTL(TT0L ol v(oTpoL icrovTaL; ^

"Eycoye. '
"Iî brj vvv etTre rovrots, rts avTOvs êArtous Trotet;
STjAof yap ort otcâ, fxiXov ye o-ot. tov fxev yap 8ta-
<f)6LpovTa iêvpdiv, ws (^77?, eju,e', eto-dyets rouroto-t Kai KaTrj- 5
yopds' Tov b\ br] êArtovy TTOLOvvTa l6l etTre /cat fxr^wcrov
aVTols TLS kcTTLV 'OpqS, S) MeXr]T, OTL (TLyqS Kal OVK
ex^ts eiTreti'; KaLTOL ovk alcr^pov ctol boKcl etrat Kot iKavov
TiKfxrjpLov ov br] eyo) Aeyo), ort o-ot ovbev fxcfxikqKtv; oAA'
eiTre', u)ya6i, tls avrovs dfxeLVOVs Trotet; 10
01 VOfXOL.
AAX' ov tovto kpu)TS), o) ^4kTLcrTe, aAAa rts dvdpcoTTOS, e
oo-rts TTp&Tov Kal avTo tovto ot8e, rovs vofxovs;
OvTOL, 0) SwKpares, ot bLKaa-Tai.
n3s A^yeis, S ]VIe'A?jre; otde rovs ye'ovs TraiSevety oiot

Ti ilcTL Ka\ /3eArtovs Trotouo-ti'; 5
MdAto-ra.
no'repoy aTrain-es, 17 oX fxkv avrQv, ol 8' ov;
"A^Trarres.
b9 aSiKuy B= T W oSiKf? B C5 B om. T e6

W t Arm. c
:
7 irpotriroiovnevoi T :
"ye
irpoa-irotovfifvovs
:
B c8
erywi/as
iriiiroTc
Toi}T(i> T dI irXelcTTov T iroWod
: B d3 Wi B t : rtrflt
T ds Toirrojo-l] <is TouToi/fft Cobet e4 Bt ovSe T
e5 iriwoCtni/ B irote7y B* T
: W 67 airavTfs B : &v
o'/5e
iro/Ts
:
T
8*
346 nAATilNOS
Ev ye vrj rrjv "Hpav Aeyeis koX TroWrjv a(f)6ov(av t&v
lo oi>(f)(X.ovvTOiv. Ti 6e 87/; ol 8e aKpoarai /SeArious ttoioCo-ii;
25 ri ov;
Kai ovTOi.
T^ 8e, 01 l3ov\xrraC;
Kal 01 [3ovX.VTaC.
5 'AA\' apa, S MeAT/re, /u.^ 01 ev r^ kKKkqcrCa, ol kKKkr\-

(TiaaraC, bia^fÔeCpova-i, tovs vcoiTepovs; rf KaKdvoL (BcXtCovs
TTOiovcnv S.TTavTCs;
KaKdvoi.
HdvTes apa, ws ôlkcv, 'AdrjvaXoL KaXovs Kayadovs
10 TTOLOvo-L TrXrjv kp.ov, kyo) 8e p.6vos 8ia<^êip(U. ovrco Ae'yeij;
Y16.VV (r(f)6bpa TavTa Xiyca.

YloWriv ye /xou KaTeyvooKas bvcTTVxCav. KaC [lOL 0.1:6-
KpLVaL' ?7 KOX TTepl LTTTTOVS OVT(a CTOL boKL XLV; ol pikv
b /3eAriouy irotowres avrovs iTavT^s av6p(OTT0L itvaL, ets bi

TLs 6 bLa(f)ddp(tiv; 7) TovvavTCov tovtov ttclv ets ixiv tls 6
/3eArtous oto's r' cov ttollv rj TTavv okCyoL, ol lttttlkoC,. oi 8e

TToAAoi eavTrep crvv&crL kol \pS)VTaL lttttols, bLacf)6Cpov(TLv;
5 ovx ovrcos ex6i, S> MeAijre, koX Trepi Xtttto)v KoiX tG)V aAAcoy
aTT6vT(t)V Côdv; TTavTcas St/ttou, kavTC (tv Kal "Avvtos ov

(f)r]T 6vT (f)r]T' TToAA^ yap av tls evbaLfxovCa eirj Trepi
rovs viovs et ets ixev [x6vos airrovs bLa^fÔeCpeL, ot 8' aAAot

c b)(f)kov(rLV. akka yap, S) Me'Ai/re, LKavcas eTTLbeLKvvcrai
OTL ovbTT(aTTOT (f)p6vTL(ras t5)v V(t)V, Kal cra(f)S)s aTT0(f)aC-
VLS Triv (raxjTov aixik^Lav, otl ovb^v (toi /xe/xeAr/Key Trept c5y
^ e/xe eiorayets.
5 "Eri 8e rjiJLLV etTre', S) iTpbs Aios MeAr/re, 7rorepo'y eo-rty
oIklv ap.LV0V kv TTokCTaLS XPWôî^ V TTOvripols; S) Tav, cltt^-
KpLvaL' ovb\v yap tol xakeTTOv epo^TOi. ovx ol pikv TTOvrjpol
e 10 oi 8e T : olSe ol B a5 01 iKKArjffiaffrai secl. Hirschig

a 12 amxâ' T sed 5v<r in marg. b i Trdyres B avavrfs T
W Arm.
:
b6ouBt:/t))T 02 airo(j)aivri <ra<p6is c7 irovrjpol

KaK^v ri B Trovrjpol
: aei koxSv ri T : irovTjpol KaKhv dt ti W
B
AnOAOriA 212KPATOT2 35C

6'
KaKov Ti ipydCojrraL tovs det iyyx/rdTco avTav ovTas, ol
ayadol dyaOov tl;
Yldvv ye. 10
'^(TTiv ovv ooTts ôvXiTai VTTO rwy crvvovTiav ^KdTnea-dai d

fxdWov rj dxpekdcrdaL; diroKpCvov, S) dyaOi' Ka\ ydp 6 voixos
Kekevet. dTTOKpCv(rdaL. eo"^' oorts jSovXeTaL ^kdiTTecTdaL;

Ov hriTa.
îpe 877, TTOTepov e/xe etcrayet? bevpo ws bLacpdeCpovTa tovs 5
veovs KOL TTOirqpoTepovs TTOLOvvTa (KovTa 7] aKovTa;

'ExoWa eyooye.
Tt biJTa, 0) MikrjTe; too-ovtov (tv e/xou (ro<â)repos et rtj-
XtKOi^rou OVTOS rrjXtKocrSe (av, ooa-Te crv pikv eyvoiKas otl ol

/jtey KaKol KaKov tl epydCovTaL dei rovs fxdA.io-ra TrXrja-Cov 10
eavT&v, OL 8e dyadol dyaOov, cyd) 8e 8^ ets ToaovTov dfxa- e

6ta? TjKO) tSo-re Kat tovt dyvoS>, ort edy rtra \xoy6r]pov
TTOtT/o-co rcSi' avvovTcov, Ktvbvveva-oi KaKOV tl Aa/3eti' i^Tr avTov,
(uore rouro ^ro^ rocrouroi; KaKov eKwv TrotS, d)s ^t/s av;
TavTa eyctf o-oi ou TreCdop.aL, S) Me^Xr/re, ot/xat 8e ov8e dAAoy 5
dvdp(aTTO)V ovbiva' dAA' rj ov 8ta(^êipco, 77 ei 8ta<^0etpa),
^Kcoi', wcrre ot; ye Kar' dpL(f)6Tepa yj/evbr}. et 8e aKcoy 8ta- 26

</)0etpa), rcSy tolovtôv [Kal dKova-Ccov] diJ.apTr}fxdTu>v ov bevpo
v6p.os eicrdyeiv earCv, dXka IbCq Xaj36vTa 8t8do-Kety Kat vov-
êrety 8^\oy ydp ort edy fxddui, TTavaojxai o ye dKooy 'jroiS.
av 8e oryyeveVât fxiv fxoL Kal 8t8dât (f)vyS Ka\ ovk 5
rjdekri^ras, bevpo be eladyeLs, ol vdfxos eaTlv elcrdyeLV tovs
Kokdaeoos beoixevovs dkk' ov \xa6ricr eois-
'AAAd ydp, o) avbpes 'A^T/yatot, tovto fxev rjbr) brjkov

ovyo) ekeyov, otl MeA7/r&) tovto)v ovt fi-eya ovTe [XLKpov b
'jrctfTTore efxekrjaev. ofxo)s be brf keye rjfxlv, tt&s fJ-e cfiffs
d 2 airoKpivov B T aTroKpivai : B' W d. 6 ytovs T : vfUTfpovs B

d 8 5^To B yp. t irore T : S-fi d.g crv B : fv T ei aryaOov ri
TArm. e 3 uir' T dir' : 64 Tbom. BTW e6 el om.
Stephanus Siacpdupw bis scripsit Naber a 2 koI oKovaiwv secl.
Cobet a 4 3] o5 Schanz a 8 ijSr] Stj\ov Sr}\ov b Stjôv W
W
: :
ijSri icTTLV T b I ovyw T : & iyii b toiJtw;' B ; tout^ TW

:
a6b nAATHNOS
bia(f)6CpLV, S) MeXrjTe, tovs vôiTipovs; r} hrjKov hr) oti
KaTO, Ti]v ypacf^rjv rjv kypa^co deovs bibda-KOVTa ju.?/ vojxCCav
5 ots rj TToAts vojxCCî, Tpa 8e 8ai/xwta KaLvd; ov Tavra
Aeyets ort bibda-Kcov biaÔiCpui;
Tldvv ixev ovv cr<p6bpa TavTa Xiyco.
Hpbs avT(av toCvvv, S> MeArjre, tovtcdv t&v dedv &v vvv
6 Aoyos <ttCv, etTre Irt a-atpecTTepov Kal e/xot Kat rots dv-
C bpda-iv TOVTOia^C. kyu) yap ov bvvafxai ixaOeiv iroTepov Aeyets

bibda-Keiv /ixe vop.Cîv eivaC Tivas Oeovs Kat avTos dpa vop.CQii
eTvai Oeovs Kal ovk eiiu to Tiapdirav dOeos ovbe TavTi] dbiKGi
ov p.evTOL ova-irep ye r] 7ro'Ats dAAa eTepovs, Kal tovt* ea-Tiv
5 o /ixot eyKokeis, ort eTepovs, r/ 7rarr({7ra(rt jue (pr]S ovTe
avTov vojxCêLV Oeovs tovs re aAAovs TavTa bLbda-KeLV.
Tayra keyca, cl)s ro TtapdiTav ov vopuCêLS 6eovs.
d 'il 6av]xd(TLe MeÂjjre, tiâ rt Tama KeyeLs; ovbe r]kiov
ovbe cre\r]vr]v dpa vojxCô) $eovs elvaL, u>a-'7Tep ol aAAoi dv-
dpOiTTOL;
Ma At', a> dvbpes StKacrrat, eTrei tov fxev rjkLOV \C6ov

6 (pr]a\v eXvaL, Tr]v be a-eXr]vr]v yrjv.
'Avaâyopov otet Karqyopelv, S) (f)C\e Me'ATjre; Kat ovtoi)
KaTa(f)poveLS rwv6e Kat otei avTOVs aTteCpovs ypaiXjxdTcav elvaL

&(TTe ovK elbevaL otl tcl Âvaâyopov ^L^kCa tov >.kaô]xe-
vCov yenei tovto)V t5>v koyo^v; koX br] Kat ot iêôi Tama Trap
10 ejuou ]xav6dvova-LV, h eêa-TLv evCoTe el Trdvv iTokkov bpaxp-VS
e eK Trjs opxrârpas iTpLa]xevoLS ôi)KpdTOVs KaTayekdv, edv

TTpoa-TTOLrjTaL eavTov elvaL, dkk(t)s re Kat ovto)s aTOiTa ovTa;
dkX\ 0) TTpbs Alos, ovTooaC aoL boK(a; ovbeva vo]xCô) debv
elvaL;
6 Ov fxevTOL ]xd ACa ovb^ oTrcoo-rtow.
b3 SrjXou 5i] Sti B : SrjKovort T C r ro7s avSpdfftv secl. Cobet

C I T0VT0t(rl B^ T W : tovtois B di 'Iva Bt : om. T d6 'Afafa-
y6pov secl. Schanz d7 avrovs B aiirhs T e i irpiafjLfvois B^
W
:
irptd/xfvoi BT 63 vofj.iâi B vofjii^dv T ws vo/iiCt Arm. :

W
: :
VOfJiiCoiV
AnOAOriA SriKPATOTS 26
"ATncTTos y t, S MeATjre, /cat ravTa /xerroi, o)? e/xot
SoKeis, o-aurw. l\i.oi yap SoKet ovtoo-l, S) avbpes ÂOrjvaloL,

Trdvv elvat vj3pi(rT7]s Kal aKoXaaTOs, Kal aTxvu>s ttjv ypa-
(f)r]V Tavrqv v^pei tivX koX dKoX.a<Ti.a koX veorqTt ypdâaOai.
(OLKev yap uxttt^p atvLyfxa o-vvtl6Vtl StaTretpco/AeVo) "'Apa 27
yywo-erat ôjKpdrqs 6 ao(f)6s brj e/xoC xapLevTLCoiJi.evov Kal
kvavTL ipLavTUf KiyovTOS, rj kâTtarriau) avTov koX tovs oK-
\ovs Tovs aKovovTas; " ovtos yap e/xoi âLv^TaL tcl ivavTLa
KiyiLv avTos kavT^ iv t?] ypa(pfi uxnrep hv et etTTOf " 'AStKet 5
^0)KpdTr]s Oeovs ov vo}xl(iU)V, akkd Oeovs vofXLCoov.^' Katrot

TOVTO ecTTL TTaiôrros.
^vv7TL(rK\lra(rd bi], S dvbpS, rj jxol (jyaCv^TaL TavTa

X.yLV crv 6e TjfxXv diioKpLvaL, u) Me'A7jre. v/xets 8e, oTrep
KaT dpxds vfxds TraprjTri^rdixriv, p.ixvr](Td jxol fxr] dopvfS^lv b

av V ro) etojôrt Tpoino tovs Ao'yov? TrotcS/xat.
*'EoTti^ ooTis dv6p(i)i:(t)V, S) MeArjre, dv6p(aTTLa [xkv vofxi^^L

TTpdyfxaT etrat, dv6p(i)TT0vs 8e ov vofxiC^L; diTOKpLvicrdo), S)
dvbpS, Kal fxr] aAAa Kot aAAa 6opvj3LT(o' cr&' oo-tls Xttttovs 5
fXV ov vofXL(L, LTTTTLKa b TTpdyfxaTa; rf avkrfTas fiV ov

vofxCC^t etrat, avA7/rtKa 5e TTpdyfxaTa; ovk ô-tlv, S) dpLcrT
dvbpQv et p.r] (tv ôvkL diT0KpLV(T6aL, eyo) o-ot Aeyco Kat

rots aAAots rouroto-i. dAAa to tt\ TOVTdi ye diTOKpLvaL'
(tB^ octtls baLfxovLa fxv vofxiC^L TTpdyfxaT etyat, baifxovas 8e c
ov vofxiC^L;
OVK (TTLV.
'X2s (i)vr](Tas OTL fxoyLS dTTKpiv(i) VTTO TOVTO)v\ dvayKa(p-

fXVos. ovKovv baLfxovLa fXV (pifs fx Ka\ vofxiC^LV Ka\ bLbd- 5
oTKeti', etr' ovv KaLva eire xraAatti, ctAA' ovv baifxovLa ye

vofii((t) KaTa tov (tov koyov, Ka\ TavTa kol bLu^fLocro) V tt/
dvTLypa(f)fj. et 8e baLfxovLa vofxiCo), kol baifxovas brjTTOV
e 7 yap B : /xfv yap T a i post (TwriQivTi add. f) T : Ka\ Arm.

a2 5^ Bt : om. T a4 ovrois Arm. (recte fortasse) et mox xiyuv
as fi B^TW: om. B a8 5^ Bt: 5e' T ôi Bt: iôl T
b8 atroKpivtaQai BT : a.iroKpivacrdai W t b9 t6 B t t^ T
: C 7 rfl
*
Bt : om. T
27C nAATI2N02
jroAA,^ avdyKr] vofxiCîv ixi ^cttiv' ov\ ovro)? ex^' ^X^' ^T
lo tCOtjixi ydp cr dixokoyovvTa, (iTCtbri ovk aTTOKpLVjj. tovs 8e
d baCp.ovas ov)(l 7/roi deovs ye TjyovfxcOa r) 6e5>v "naihas; (Pfjs
q ov;
Hdvv y,
OvKovv ftiTep baLpLovas rjyovjxai, wj av ^j]?, ei /jtey êot
5 Tivis cio-ty 01 baLixoves, tovt hv flrj o eyco (f^rjjXL o-e alvLT-
TeaOai Kal yapLiVTLCia-daL, Oeovs ovx^ rjyovixevov (jxxvaL jxe
deovs av r}yL<TdaL ttoXlv, eircLbrJTiep ye baiixovas rjyovixaL'
(l 8' av 01 baLfxoves OiStv TraiSes eio-tv iôôt rtiês r; ex vvp.-
(f)&v rj Ik tlvoov aXXcov Stv bri kol keyovTaL, tls hv dvdpta-
lo TTcoi' 6(5>v ixev TratSas rjyolTO etrat, 6iovs 8e /x?/; bixoioas ydp
e &v aroTToy etTj axnTep hv el rts tTnrcoi' /aer TratSas rjyoLTO
[^] Kttt oytoi;, Toi/s fnxLovovs, lttttovs 8e Kot ovovs ixri rjyolTO
fivaL. dXk\ 2 Me'Arjre, ovk ^cttlv OTTcas crv ravra ovxl

diTOTTiLpdiixiVOs r]pi,(iiV iypd\l/(o TTiv ypa(f)riv TavTriv ri diTopSiV
5 ort eyKaAots e/xot dArjês dbUrnxa' oTTcdS 8e (rv TLva iTd6oiS

hv Kttl (TixLKpov vovv i\ovTa dv6p(aTTa>v, o)? [ov tov avTov]
i(JTW KoX baLixovLa KoX êta riydcrâL, Koi av tov ovtov ixrJTC
28 baCixovas ixt^tc 6(0vs ixt^T ijpoias, ovbeixCa ixriâvri ((ttlv.
'AAAa ydp, u) dvbpes 'A^rjiâtot, b>s ixkv eyo) ovk d8tKc3

Kara rrjy MeAr/rou ypa(f)riv, ov iToWrjs ixol 8oKet etyai dTro-
Aoyias, dAAa iKava Kal TavTa' 8e Kai iv toIs cp.TTpo(r6V
6 eAeyoy, ort iroAA^ fioi dTTx6ei.a yiyovev Kal TTpbs tto\X.ovs,
ev to-re ort dArjêj eo^rty. Kai tovt (ttlv o kixk alpel, edv-
Trep atp^, ov MeArjros ov8e "Aruros dAA' rj t&v TToXXCiv 8ta-
/3oAr/ re Kat (})66vos. h. 8r/ Kat aAAouy TroAAovs Kat dyadovs
d1 7fôvfi.t6a B fiyovfjL(6a elvai T d6 /le T : ^/ue B d9 &>'

W
;
B' W t : om. BT e i &<rirf p &i/ T : So-Trfp B ez fi secl.

Forster tous T]fxi6vovs secl. Baumlein sed legit Arrianus e3 <ri)
B' T W : oi B TaOra secl. Schanz e6 i/oCc T W : -y' oZv

vovv B ou ToC oiToO B :ov rov avTov avSphs : secl. Rieckher T
a6 a\r)94s B: oA.7j6^s T oipf? T: alp^fiafi B a8 koI
HlKKovs iro?0>.ovs Kal coni. Schanz et sic Arm. : voWovs koI &\\ovs
al BT
AnOAOriA 2X2KPATOT2 28b
avbpas ripr]KV, oXjxai. 8e Kal alprja-CL' ovb^v bc beivbv [J.r} iv b
e/xot (TTrj.
"la-ojs av ovv etTTOt tls' " Etr' ovk al(r)(yin), S) StoKpares,

ToiovTov eTrtTTjSeu/iAa einrqbeva-as e ov Kivbvveveis vvvl cltto-
davelv;" eyo) 8e TovTca av bUaiov Xoyov dz^Tet7rot/ii,t, ort "Ov 5
KaX&s Ae'yet?, oi avOpcDTre, et otet belv Kivbvvov VTtqkoyi^^crOai

Tov Crjv rj TiOvavai avbpa otov ti koI a-pnKpbv o<êAo's ka-Tiv,
dAA' ovK iKeivo p.6vov a-Ko-neiv oTav TTpaTTrj, iroTepov biKaia rj
abiKa TTpaTTet, Kal avbpbs ayaOov epya rj KaKov, (pavXoL

yap hv TO) ye a-Q) Aoyo) eiei' t&v r}fj.i,6(ov ocrot ey TpoCq C
TeTeAeuTTjKao-ty ot Te dAAoi Kal 6 tijs 0eTt8os vos, os
ToaovTOV Tov KLvbvvov KaTcf)p6vricrv irapa to ala\p6v tl
VTTOjLtetyat (ScrTe, eTreiSr) etTrei' r} pirJTrjp avrw iipodvp.ovp.iv^^
"FiKTOpa aTtoKTUvai, d^bs ovcra, ovTuta-C ttcos, a>s eyo) ot/uat* 5

">Q Trat, et TLp.(t)pricrLS IlaT/soKAa) to) kTaCpui Tbv (f)6vov
Kal "FiKTopa aTTOKTVis, avTos aTToOavri avrCKa yap Toi,'
<\)ria-C,
'
ixeO^ "ExTopa ttoV/io? eTOt/xos
'
6 8e touto aKOVcras
Tov pikv davcLTOv Kal Tov Kivbvvov o)\Ly(apr}a-, ttoXv 8e /xdA-
Aor SetVas Tb Cvv Ka^bs oov Kal Toty <îAots fx^ Tipixopelv, d
'
AvTCKa,^ (j)ria-C,
'
TedvaCrjv, bCKrjV eTrtêts tw abLKOvvTL,
Lva jxrj evOdbc jxivo) KaTayikacTTOS Trapa vr]va\ Kopo)vC(riv
axdos apovprjs.^ fxrj avTov oiei (j^povTCa-ai OavaTOV koX
"
KLvbvvov; 5
OvTco yap exet, a> avbpis 'A^Tjiâtot, Tq akrjOiicL' ov av tls

kavTov tA^ riYqa-api.Vos jBdkTLo-TOV etvaL 17 vtt' apyovTOS
Taydr}, kvTavOa 8et, w? kp.ol boKel, jxivovTa KLvbvveveLV,
fxrjbev VT:okoyL^6p.ivov p-rjTe ddvaTov pLrjTe dAAo ixrjbev irpb tov
aLa-)(j30v. eyo) ovv beLva av eCqv eLpyacrp.ivos, o) avbpes 10
A^Tjratoi, et oTe pAv fxe ol apxovTcs iTaTTOv, ovs v/uets etAeo-ê e
b I otpîrei Tb alfyfifffiv B b^ &>/ T Eus. Stob. : 8' &' B t
W
:
b5 ou Bt : om. T b 8 iroTtpov T : irdTfpa B 05 oinu^ri

B : ouTwy T c6 5 tto? B^TW Arm. : om. B c8toCt'T:
TaJJro B d2 îK-qv B : ttjj' Si/ctjv T d3 Kopuvifftv T : Kopwvriiffiy
B : iTtiffiov Homerus 2 104 d7 ^^ ante Tiyriffd.ixivos add. B
a8e nAATilNOS
apxLV [xov, Koi ev IloreiSata Koi kv 'AiJ,(f)i,7r6k(L kol em
Ar]\L(o, t6t fxkv ov iKcivoL ^TaTTov iixevov &(nTp /cai aAAos
TLS Kal iKLvbvvevov aTToOavelv, tov be deov t(xttovtos, ws eyoi
5 (^qdr]v re Kal vTreXajBov, (^tAocroôui^ra fxe belv Cw '^'^^ eieTci^
CovTa ejxavTov Ka\ rovs aAAovs, evTavda be (polBrjdels rj BdvaTov

29 ?/ aAA' oriow TTpayfxa Xlttolixl rrjv Ta^LV. beLv6v Thv etrj, Kal
us akrjdtas t6t av [xe Si/catcos eto-txyot rts ets 8t/cacrr7/ptor,
ort oi) voixlCô deovs etvaL aireLOSiv tt} fxavTeCq koI bebiMS
ddvaTov Kal ol^jxevos o-ocôs etyat ovk &v. to ydp tol
5 OavaTOV bebLevaL, S avbpes, ovbev aAAo ecrriy rj SoKeii' (ro(f)6v
elvaL p,r] ovTa' boKelv yap elbevaL eoTLV h ovk o^tbev. o7be
fxev yap ov8ets tov OavaTov ovb^ ei TvyxaveL roi avOpcoTTio
TTdvTUiV fxeyL^TTov ov T&v dyadSiv, bebiacrL 8' ws ev ei8ores

b ori ixeyLCTTOv t5)V KaK&v ecm. KaLTOi tt&s ovk dixaOCa eo-rij/
avrr] -q eTTOveCbL^TTOS, rj tov ote^rOaL elbevaL h. ovk oXbev; eyih

8', co az^Spes, rovro) /cat evTavOa to-cos bLa(f)ep(t) t&v TroAAwr
dv6p(aTT(t)v, Kal ei 877 ro) (ro(f)(aTep6s tov (fâCriv eTvaL, tovt(a
5 av, OTL ovK eibojs LKav&s iTepl tS)v evÂLbov ovto) Ka\ otoixaL
ovK eibevaL' t6 be dbLKelv Ka\ diTeLdeXv roi j3e\.TCovL Ka\ Oeca
Ka\ dv6p(i)TT(ii, OTL KaK^v Kol ai(r)(j)6v e(rTLV oXba. TTp6 ovv tS)V
KaKS>v S)V olba otl KaKa ea-TLV, h ixr] oXba et Kat dya$d ovTa
TvyxdveL ovbeiroTe (fto^ricroixaL ovbe (jêvôfxaL' uxrTe ovf et
c fxe vvv v/xets d(f)CeTe 'Awroj dTrto-rT/o-arres, 6s e(f)r] 77 r^r
dpxrfv ov belv eixe bevpo ia-eX.6elv ?/, eiTeLbr] ei(rrj\dov, ovx
ol6v T elvaL t6 p.r] diTOKTeLvaC /xe, keyodv 7Tp6s vjuas cos et
bLa(f)evôCixr]v rjbr] [dv] vp.(av ol veXs eTTLTr]bevovTes a "Ea^Kpd-
5 rTjs bLbd(rKeL TTavTes TTavTaTTaa-L bLa(f)6apr](rovTaL, et ixol
7Tp6s TavTa eiTrotre* "îl ScoKpares, vvv ixev Âvvt(o ov Trei-
e 5 Suv ^'] Sia^TJv Stobaeus a i Kliroifnt B : Kdiroini T

T&i' B fj.evr' i.v T tiuStobaeus a6 ovk'] /u^ in marg. T
W
: :
b I Kairoi Eusebius koI rovro B T : Stobaeus /co! Arm. : b2 avrri

T)om. Arm. bs rovrtf secl. Schanz b^ rovrcf B^TW :
rovro B b 8 e/ *co2 Stobaeus Eusebius Theodoretus : ei BT

c 4 &j/ secl. Cobet c 6 Knd^tnQa Baumann
c
AnOAOriA 2X2KPATOYS 29
a-oêOa dAA' a(pifj.V o-e, 1tI TOVTio /xeWot, e0' wre \ir\KiTi
iv TavTT} TTj ^qTrj(rL 8iarpi/3eiy fxrj8e <f)LX.o(ro(p'LV' iav 8e

oAwj eri rovro TTpaTTOov, aTroOavrj
" et ovv /Lie, OTrep Lttov, d
em rovrots a(})L0LT, clttoljx^ hv vpXv otl "'Eyco i^/xas', w avbp^î
ÂOr^valoL, do-Trdô/Liat /xer xai (f)L\&, Treioô/xai 8e fxaXXov t(o
deu> rj vpXv, Ka\ coocrTTep av kp.TTvi(x> koX oXos re cb, ov p.ri
TTavaitip.aL ^Lkocro^Siv Ka\ vixlv iTapaKeXevoixevos re Kat 5
vbLKVvp.Vos OT(o &v det fVTvyx(iV(o Vfxatv, Ae'ya)y otaTrep
etcoâ, ort "H apLCTTC avhp5>v, 'A^r/yatos wy, TroAecos' r%

fxeyto-rr/s Kai vhoKLp.o)Tan]S ets (rocf^Cav Ka\ i(r)(yv, xprifX(XT(tiV
fiey ovK ato^wT/ eTrt/xeAov/xeros ottcos o-oi ôrai ws TrAetora,

icai b6^r]s Ka\ rt/x7/y, (^poi^T/o-ecos 8e Kat aXrjOeCas Ka\ Trjs e
"^XV^ OTTcos ws (BeXrCa-Trj ea-TaL ovk eTrt/xeAr) ov8e (fipovTC-
êts; ' Kat edi' rts v/ici)!' aix(f>L(r^riTricrr] Ka\ (f)fi
eiTHX(.KLcrOaL,
ovK evOvs a(f)r\a-(D avTov ov8' aTret/it, dAA' (prjcrofxaL avTOV Ka\
eêrdcro) Kai kkiyô), Ka\ kav fxoL /xr/ 8oKr/ KeKTrja-OaL apeTi]V, 5
(f>avaL bi, oviLbLG) otl to. irXeCarTov d^ta Trept eAaxtVrou Trot- 30
-etrat, rd 8e (pavkoTepa -Trept TrAetoro?. TavTa Ka\ v(j)Tp(a
Ka\ '7rpeo-/3irre'p&) 0T(a av ivTvyx^^JL^ 7rotr/o-co, Kat êVo) Kot

doTto, /xdAAoy 8e rots dorrois, oo-w fxov iyyxrripd) a-T yVL.
TavTa yap KeAevet 6 êd?, eu to-re, Kot eyco OLOfxaL ovbiv tto) 5
vpLLV pllCov ayaOov yeviaOaL kv Tr] TrdAet r/ Tr]v ]xr]v ro) êw
VTTr]p(rCav. ovbev yap akXo Trpdrrcoy eyco TTpLpxofxaL rf
TTeCOoOV Vp.S)V Ka\ V(DTpOVS KcCl TTp(T^VTpOVS fXr]T (T(i)fXaT(i)V
eTTLfxekelaOaL fxr\T xpr]fxdT(jov iTpoTepov /xr/8e ovto) a-(f>6bpa b

b>s Trjs yf/vxrjs ottcos s apCoTr] eaTaL, kyo)V otl '
Ovk K
Xpy^fxa-To^v dpTr] yCyvTaL, dAA' e^ dpTris XPW^"^^ '^"' "^^
dAAa dyaOd rot? dvOpcoTTOLS aTravTa kol ibCq. Ka\ 8r///,oo-ia.'
d2 T W om. B 03 a.ix(pi(Tfir)Ti)<Tri T d/i</)i(r/37jTf B

W (sed
: :
a I voiilTai B : iroi-ricreTai T a4 fiov B : fioi T supra T w)

v i
b I /urj5e] jUTj 5 B et (ut videtur) Stobaeus : /u^Te &\\ov Tivhs

Tb b2 oTi T W Arm. Stobaeus om. B : b 3 apeT^
B : 7] dpT^ T Stobaeus to xP^Mttâ Stobaeus b4 airavTa
om. Stobaeus
3ob nAATi2N02
5 ei fJikv ovv Tavra kiyoiv bta(p6e[pco tovs v4ovs, TavT av eiTj
Âa/3ep(i' et 8e' tls fxi (f)ri<nv aXXa kiyciv rj ravra, ovbev

Aeyet. irpbs ravra," <f)aCr]V av, " S avbpcs 'Adrjvaloi., rj
TTcCOea-de 'Arvro) rj fxri, koL ?/ a(pUT fxe ?/ fxri, ws efxov ovk

C ^v aWa,
TTOLrfcravTos ov8' ei fxeXXca TroXXaKLS TeOvavaL."
M^ ôpu/Seire, w avbpes ÂdrjvaLoi, dAA' p.p.eLvaTe fioL
oXs eberfOrfv vfiS>v, firf 6opvj3LV e^' ols av Xeyb) dAA' aKoveLV'
KoiX ydp, b>s eyo) oijaat, dwyo-etrê aKovovre?. juÂAa) yap ovv
5 arra v/u,ry epety Kat aAAa e(^' ois tcrcos ôrja-ea-ê' dAAa
fjirfbafx&s 'TTOtetre roCro. ev yap to-re, edr /lAe aTTOKTeCvrfTe
TOLOVTov ovTa oXov eyo) Aeyco, ovk ifjik fxeC^ca ^kdêTe rj
vfxas avTovs' e/xe fxev yap ovbev av l3\d\}/eLev oiJre Me'Arjros
ovTe "AvvTos ovbe yap hv bvvaLTo ov yap otofxaL 6efXLTov

d etiât dfxeCvovL dvbpl vtto yeCpovos /SAd-Trreo-ât. aTroKretVete
fxevTOLV X(T(as rj eêXda-eLev rj dTLfxdxreLev dAAd TavTa ovtos
fxev lcruis oterat /cat dAAoy rt? ttov fxeydXa KaKd, eyo) 8' ovk
oXofxat, dXKd ttoXv fxaXXov TTOLelv h ovToal vvv Trotet, avbpa

5 dStKcos eTTtxetpety dTTOKTeLvvvaL. vvv ovv, w dvbpes Â6rf-
valoL, TToKKov beca eyco VTrep epi,avTov d77oAoyeto"ât, oSs ris
dv ototro, dAAd vTrep vpi&v, fxrf tl eâfxdprrfTe iTepX rqv tov
e 6eov boa-LV vfxlv efxov KaTa\\rr]^L(rdfxevoL. edv ydp fxe diTO-
KTeCvrjTe, ov pîbCoos dXXov tolovtov evprf^reTe, dTe\vG>s ei
Kat yeXoLOTepov eliTelv iTpocrKeCfxevov Trf iToXeL vtto tov 6eov
uxTTTep LTTTTCo /xeydAo) fxev Kal yevvaC(o, vtto fxeye6ovs be V(i)6e-

5 aTep<a Ka\ beofiev<o eyeCpea6aL vtto fxvoyiTos tlvos, olov bri
fxoL boKei 6 debs e/xe r?/ TrdAet Trpoa-TedriKevaL tolovtov TLva,
os vfxds eyeCpoiV kol iTeC^cov Kal 6veLbCC(ov eva eKaaTOV

31 ovbev TTavofxaL TrfV rffxepav dkrfv TTavTaxov TTpo(rKadC(u)V.
b 7 &v^pes T om. B : b 8 /xe T om. B i^ /*^ T ^ yu?) d<^(eT B : :
e I TTOiiîrovTos Cobet iroffitrovTos B T

: e 2 S T om. B 04 ody :
om. W 05 ipe7v itxiv T e 6 yue T iixf B cQ tiv $\a.rp(iev :
B ^Kdêi T
: C 9 Svvaivro Stobaeus et corr. pr. T d i airoKrtvfi
fif T d 2 aTifidffftfv Stobaeus aTtfidcTeiev B T d 4 ovTO(rl vvv
:
T oStoj vvvX
: B d 7 ti B om. T toC Beov T
: b twv W W :
Ofuv B e I /tte T ifii B :64 vwQporeptf T

AnOAOriA SHKPATOTS 31 a
TOLOVTOi ovv aAAos ov paStcos vixtv yevria-^raL, oi avbpes,

dAA' eav ixov v/xets 8'
e//ot TTiiOricrOi, (P^LcrecrOi to-co? rdx'
ai' a\66\x(VOL, axnrcp ol vvcrTdCovT(S iyLp6p.V0L, Kpov(ravTS
&v fxc, ttl66ixVol Âvvtu), pabL(os hv dTTOKTLvaLT, etra tov 5
XoLTTov ^LOv KadevbovTfs StareAotre dv, et fx-q TLva dXXov 6

êos vpLLV iTTLiTip.\p^Lev Kr]b6[XVos vp.5>v. OTL 8' eyo) Tvyxdvco
oliv TOLovTos olos VTTo Tov diov TTf 7ro'Aet SeSoVât, (v6ivb
hv KaTavo-qcraLTi- ov ydp dr^pcoTriro) eotKe to e/xe t&v h
fxev ijxavTOV TTdvTOiv rnxXr\KvaL koX dv\(TdaL TOiv olkMV
dfXXovp.4v(tiV TO(ravTa t/Stj errj, t6 8e vp.Tpov iTpdTTCLV diC,
t8ta e/cdoTO) iTpo(TL6vTa &(nTp TTaTepa r/ dbeXcfiov 7Tpa-j3v-
repov TTL6ovTa iTTLfx^XilcrâL dp^Trjs. Kal et /xeV rt diro 5
TOVTOiV d-niXavov Ka\ fXLcr6ov Xafx^dvoiV TavTa iTapiKf-

Xevdfxrjv, eTx^^ ^^ '"'^^ Xo'yoy zn;y 8e 6pdT brj Kal axrrol
OTL ol KavffyopoL rdAAa iTdvTa dvaL^rxvirroiS ovT(a Karq-
yopovvTS tovt6 y ovx otot re iyivovTo d7TavaL(r)(yvTi](raL
Trapacrx6fXV0L fxdprvpa, ws eyco Trore rtra 17 iiTpa^dfxrjv c
IXL(r6bv rf T/rT/cra. LKavbv ydp, ot/xat, eyo) TTap\ofxaL tov
fxdpTvpa ws dXr]6rj Ae'yco, rT/i TTVLav.
"Icrco? dv ovv b6^LV aTOTTOv etrat, ort brf eycb t8ta /xei'
raCra a~vp.(3ovXvo) Trepttcbi' Kat TroAuTrpay/xoiâ), 8rj/xocrta 8e 5
ov roA/xcS dvaâivoiv ets ro 7rA7/0os ro VfXTpov avfxfiov-

XVLV rrf it6Xl. tovtov 8e oltl^v icTTLV o vfx^ls ifxov
TToXXdKLS aKTjKoâre TroAAaxou Ae'yoi;ros, ort fxoL 6l6v tl Kal

baLfx6vLov yLyvTaL [^corT/], o 8^ /cat ey r^ ypa^^ff CTrtKco- d
/xa)8(3v Me'Ar/ros iypd^j/aTO. e/ioi 8e roCr' ecrrti' eK 7rat8os
dp$dfXVov, ôivrf tls yLyvop.vr}, -q OTav ye^rr/rat, dei d^ro-
TpTTL fX TOVTO dv fxiXXoi 7TpdTTLV, TTpOTp7TL bk OVTTOT.
TOVT^ (rTLV 6 fXOL ivaVTlOVTai TCL TToXlTLKO. TTpdTTiV, Kal 5
a5 &f post âSiais om. T a 6 $iov B yp. t XP^"'^'' "^

6 Ofhf T b 2 trdvTwv T awdvroiv B :b 5 ixtv ri
^M'"*'
fj.ivrol
:
W :
Tt B n
T (sed ixtvri fuisse videtur in T) b 7 efxo^ B : flx^" ^
b 8 ouTois avaiax^vrws T b 9 re B om. T C 2 ^y'"' o^^' T
W
:
t5)i/ B T om.
: C 5 troKvirpayfiovwv T d. i (pwvi) secl.
Forster d 4 toCto B rovrou T :
3id nAATilNOS
TrayKaAo)? ye fxoi boKel ivavTLOvcrdaL' ev yap lore, S) avbpcs
Â6r]valoi, il iyoi TraAai eTrexeCp-qaa irpaTTiiv Ta iroKiTiKa
TTpaypLaTa, TraXat av aTToXcakr] koI ovt av vpLas oxjêATjKr;
6 ovbfv ovT hv iixavTov. Kat /lot p.r} axêo"ê XeyovTL Takqdrj'

ov yap iariv 0(rTi.s av6pu>Tro)V cru)6r\aiTai ovre vpXv ovT
aXXoi TrXridei, ovbevl yvrjo-ms kvavTi,ovp.Vos koX btaKcaXvoov
TToXAa abiKa Kal Ttapavop.a ev Trj TroAei yiyv(r6aL, dXA'
32 avayKCLLOV ((ttl tov t& ovtl p.ayovp.Vov VTvep tov bLKaCov,
Kal et /ie'AAet oAiyoi' \p6vov crco6ri<ra-6aL, tStcorevety dAAa
fjLr] brifj.oa-LVLV.
MeydAa 8' eycaye vp.lv T(Kp.rfpLa Trapeôfxat tovtcov, ov

5 Ao'yoi;s dAA' 6 v/xets TLp.aT, epya. aKovaaTf b-q piOL tcl
avp.^^r]K6Ta, Lva dbrJTc otl ovb' h,v kv\ vt:lk(x6olixi Trapa

TO btKaLov 8eio-as 6dvaTov, /i^* vttlk(ov bk dAAd kclv cltto-
\oCp.r]v. kpSi 8e vp.lv cf)opTLKa fxev kol 8t/cart/cd, a\r]6r] 8e'.
eyo) y<xp, S) avbpes 'A6r]vaL0L, d\\r]v pikv dpxh^ ovbepiCav

b TTCiTTOTe Tfpâ (V Trj TToAet, J3ovKvaa bi' *cat tv\V rjfx&v
f] cj)v\r] ['Arrtoxts] irpvTav^vovaa 6t vixls tovs biâ

aTpaTr]yovs tovs ovk dvXo]XVovs tovs k Trjs vavixaxCas
ôvXvaaa6 d6p6ovs KpCvLV, iTapavofxcos, o)S V tm vaTp(^
5 XP^^V TTaaLV vfxlv bo^V. t6t iyo) [x6vos t&v TrpvTavôov
r]vavTL<a6r]v vfxlv ixrjbcv 7T0Llv Tiapa tovs vdfxovs nal kvavTCa
\}rr](f)Ladixr]V' Kal ToC\X(x)v ovtoov vbLKvvvaL /xe Kat dTrdyety

tS>V pr]T6p(i)V, Kol V]x5)V KXv6vT(DV KCLL j30(aVT())V, ]XTd TOV
C v6]X0V KOX TOV bLKaCoV (a]Xr]V IxdXkoV ]X 8ety bLaKLvbvVVLV
r] /xe^' vpioiv yVa6aL fxr] 8tKata l3ovXvopi.V(t)V, cjôjSr^êvTa
baixbv 7/ ddvaTOV. Kal TavTa ]XV ^v tl br]p.OKpaTOV]Xvr]s
rrjs TrdAecos' e7ret8^ 8^ oAtyapxici kyiv^TO, o\ TpLdKOVTa av
d7 TtaXai secl. Cobet e 3 ovZevX irX-fidti T a i rhv B : om. T

a5 not ra. : T
/loj; ret e/xol B /j.ov rct
: W a7 SiKaiov B t : Stov T
aWa Ktiv scripsi : afia Kal afxa hv B : afia Kal T oAAi Ka\ &fi tiv
: W
a9 ivSpis : T
om. B b 2 î/A)j B^ Tw : /SouA^ B
'Avrtoxh
secl. Hirschig b4 ejSouAei/iroo-ee T Arm. : ffiovXtaOf B vapa-
v6fius Bt : napav6fj.ct!V T b6 vfuv T W Arm. : om. B koI
ivavria iiiiri<\>t<Tafxriv secl. Hermann
;
AnOAOriA 2i2KPATOY2 32C
fjLTaTTfx\l/dfjiVo( fi TiifXTTTOv avTov (Is TTfv 66\ov TTpoo-eTaâv 5
ayayelv ex SaAa/iiyoj Aeorra tov 'âkafxCviov 'iva aTtoOavoi,
oXa br] Kal aAAois Klvoi, iroAAois TToAAa Trpoa-eTaTTOV, (3ov-

\6p.V0L d)? TrkiCa-Tovs avaTrXrja-aL alTL(av. t6t fxivTOi iyoi
ov Aoyo) dAA' py<a av VhLâp.r]v otl e/xot OavaTov \iv d
/xeAei, L p.r\ aypoLK^T^pov rjv IttIv, ovS' oriow, tov 8e fir]bV
dbLKOv fx.778' dv6a-Lov ipydCâOaL, tovtov 8e to Trdv /lieAei.
jLie yap KCvr] rj dpxn ovk kî-nkq^^v, ovrcos ia^vpd ovaa,

{Sorre aSiKoi; tl kpyda-aadaL, dAA' eTretS^ e/c t^s ôAou 5
^r]k6ofXV, ol fxv TTTapS wi)(ôvTo eis âkafxlva Kal rjyayov
AiovTa, eyo) 8e <jd)(6p.r]v aTTuiiV olKah. koX Xauis dv 8ta

rairra aTriâvov, ei y.r] rj dpxr] 6id raxecoi; KaTkv6r]. Kal
TOVTbiV VfXLV âOVTaL TTOkkol fxdpTVpS. C
'Ap' ow dv fX ota6 Toa-db ^rrf bLayVa6aL et eirparroi'
rd 8?]ju,o'o-ta, Kat iTpdTToiv d^Cuts dvbpbs dya6ov ôr]6ovv

TOLS bLKaCoLS KoX U)aTTp \pr] TOVTO 7Tpl TTk^CaTOV 7T0L0VfXr]V
iroAAoi; ye 8et, S) avbpS 'A6r]vaXoL' ovb yap dv dAAos 5
dvdpcaiTOiV ovb^Cs. dAA' eyo) 8td ttovtos tov ^Cov br]fxoaCa 33

re ei ttov tl iirpaâ tolovtos (f)avovfxaL, Kal IbCa 6 avTos
ovTos, ov8eri TTcaTTOTe avy\(aprjaas ovbev iTapd to bCKaLOV
ovT dAAo) ovT TovTcov ovbvl 01/9 8^ 6ta/3dAAoi^res fX
(f>aa-LV fxovs p.a6r]Tds eiyat. eyo) 8e 8t8do-KaAos fxv ovb^vos 5
jTWTTor' yv6fLr]V' et 8e rts fxov keyovTOS Kal rd cfxavTOV

TTpdTTOVTOS TTL6vfxol dKOVLV, eire v(aTpos etre TTpâ-^VT^pos,
ovbVL TTWTTore (^66vr](Ta, ovb xpr]fxaTa fXv kafXJSdvodv 8taAe-
yofxaL fii] kapijSdvoiV 8e ov, dkA ofXoCoiS Kal iTkovaCâ Kal b
TTvr]TL TTap\oi ipLavTov cpoiTav, Kal idv tls ôvkr]Tai
diTOKpLv6fXVos dKOVLV &v dv Ae'yco. Kat TOVTOiv kyoi etre
rts \prr](TT0S yCyvTaL eire fxrf, ovk dv bLKaCcos rrjy alTLav

VTT\OLfXL, (av fxrjT^ VTTâypfxrfv fxr]bv\ fxr]bV TTtoTTore fxddrjfxa 5
fXTjre e8i8aâ' et 8e' rts </)rjo-t Trap' fxov TTOiiTOTi tl fxad^lv 7/
dI fiiu eavarov T e I Ifuv] i/xuv Hermann e5 St7

B^TWt Si] B a4 5i) T: 01 Bt a6 /uou B: iôv T
a 7 iiridvfxol T : (vi0vjj.(7 B : (nfdvfj.d Cobet b6 tj B : ^ T
33b nAAT12N02
aK0V(Tai. i8ia ori fxt] Kal oi aAAoi TrdvTes, ev tore otl ovk
aXrjdrj A.eyct.
'AAAa bia tC b-q ttotc ixct e/xoC yaCpova-i nzês TroAuy

C xpovov bi,aTpCj3ovTs; aKtjKoaTe, w 6.vbpes Âdrivalot,, Traa-av
vfuv Tr}V a\i]9Lav iyco elirov' otl aKovovTcs \aLpov(Tiv

e^TaCoiJ.4vOLS Tols olop.VOLS pikv LVaL (rO(f)OLS, OVCTL 6' ov.
((TTL yap ovK arjbes. p.ol be tovto, ws eyco (f)r]p.L, wpooTe-
6 raxrat vtto tov Oeov Trpcirrety (cat ex /uavretcoy Kat ef kvvnvmv
Kcu TtavTX TpoTTOi (DTTe/) rts TTore Kat aAA?; êta p.olpa avOpdirio
Kal OTLOvv TTpocriTaê iTpdTTeLV. TavTa, o) dvbpes 'A^rjraiot,

Kat d\r]6fj koTLV koX ev4X.yKTa. et ydp br] eycoye t&v ve(i>v
d Tovs fjikv bLa(})9Lp(ii Tovs be bL(f)9apKa, XPV^ briTTOV, etre

rtJês avT&v TTpecr^vTepoL yevopLcvoL eyvooa-av otl vioLS ovctlv
avTOLS eyo) KaKov iTâiTOTe tl avvejBovkevara, vvvl avTOvs
dvaj3aLV0VTas epiov KaTr^yopeiv koX TLpo^pela-âL' ei 8^ /u^
5 aurot ijêXov, t5>v olKfmv TLvds t&v eKetvcor, iTaTepas kcu
dbekôvs Kat aAAous tovs iTpocrqKovTas, etTrep vtt' kp.ov rt
KaKov (TTeTTOvêarav avratv ol oIkclol, vvv pi,fj.vr]a-9aL [Kal
rt/Acopetorât]. Trciz^rcoj 8e TTapeLa-LV avT&v TroAAot evTav9oL
ovs ey&) 6p(a, ttp&tov p.ev Kptrcoy ovToai, epos r]X.LKL(aTr]s
e Kat br]p,6Tr]s, Kptro/3ouAou Tovbe tTanfip, eireLTa Avcravias 6

2^7/rrtos, Ala-)(îvov Tovbe TTaTr^p, tl 8' ÂvTi(f)OiV 6 Kr](f)L-
CTLevs ovTOcri, 'ETrtyerous iTaTr^p, aAAot Toivvv ovtol &v ol
dSeAôt V TavTT] Trj 8tarpt/3^ yeyovaa-LV, NtKcJo-rparos'
5 0eoôrt8ou, dSeAôs QeoboTOV Kat 6 fxev &6boTOs TT-

kVTr]KV, coare ovk av Klv6s ye avTov KaTaber^êir] Kai
riapciAtos obe, 6 Ar]pLob6Kov, ov ^y Qedyqs dbeXcf^ds' obe 8e
34 'AbeipLavTos, 6 'AptVrcoro?, ov dSeAôs ovToal IIAcircoi', Kal
b 7 ot T W : om. B e 6 &\\ri] &\\<i) Arm. eeia fj.oipq. T

C 9 &v5pes T : om. B C 8 fvf^(\(yKTa T eywT-e B : ^yci T
vinv B : vfttiTfpaiv T d7 auTwi' om. T /col rin<tipu(Td<u om. T
e I ToCSe B : tovtov T e2 tTi S' T Arm. : stj B e 5 eeo-
CoTiSov W cf. CIA ii. 2, no. 944 : 0(o(wTiSov B : 6 6(o(rSoTiSov T : re
6 (oTiSov Arm. e 7 Uapd\ios Kirchner cf. CIA ii. 660 irdpaôs
W
:
T : vdpaSos B Arm.

AnOAOriA 2I2KPATOT2 34a
Aiai^roSoopo?, ov 'A7roAAo'5a)pos obe ab(\(j)6s. Kal aWovs

TToXXovs eyo) ex^ ^/^'^ dTrelv, &v TLva ixpV^ /liaAioTa ixev iv
rw (avTov Koyu) TTapaaxea-OaL MeArjroy ixapriipa' ei 8e rore
(TrekadiTO, vvv Trapacrxâ-Ou) eyo) Trapaxcopoi Kat A.eyer(o 5
L TL lx.et rotoCroy. dAAa tovtov ttclv TOVvavTLOV evprjcreTc,
o) avbpes, TrdvTas e/xot jSo-qOelv kTOLfjLOVs rw bLa(p6eLpovTL, tu>
KaKCL pyaô\iiv(^ tovs olKiLovs avTuiv, uts (pacTL MeArjros kol

"
Xwtos. avTol /xey yap ol bL(l)dappLVOL tclx o.v Xoyoi b
exotey j3orjdovvTS' ol 8e abLd(j)6apT0L, irpecrlivTepoL rjbr]
dvbpes, ol TOVTcov Trpoa-rJKOVTes, TLva aXkov exovarL Xoyov

l3or}6ovvTs e/xot dAA' rj tov 6p66v re xat bUaLov, otl
(TvvLcraa-L MeATjrw ixkv \f/evbofXV(^, ipol be dkr}6evovTL; 5
Eiej' br], S) dvbpes' h pikv eyo) exotp.' ay dTToAoyetcrâi,,
(Tx^bdv ia-Ti TavTa Kal dXXa to-o)? TOLavTa. Taxo. 8' ai^ rt?
VfxSiv dyavaKTria-LV dvapvr^crdels kavrov, et 6 /u.er Kat eAarrto c

TOVTov): Tov dyS)Vos dyOiva dy()VLC6\xvos br]6r\ re Kai
tKeVeucre roi;? StKaoras jLtera TTokk&v baKpv(ov, iraLbLa re
avTOV dva^Lâcrdpevos tva otl \xdkLaTa ikerjêir], Kal dkkovs
tS)v OLKLOiv Kou (pLkcdv TTokkovs, eycb 8e ovbev dpa tovt(ov 5
TTOtTycTco, Kat TavTa KLvbvvevcav, u>s dv bdâLfXL, tov ea^xo-Tov

KLvbvvov. Tox dv ovv tls TavTa vvor]aras av6abcrTpov
dv TTp6s p aôCr] Kal dpyto-êt5 avrots TorjTOLS êiro dv /xer
opyrjs Tr]V y\rrj(pov. et 8rj rts V]xG)V oiVcos exet oîk d^tai d
pkv yap eyojye, ovv et 8' eTTtetK?) dv poL 80K&) Trpo? roi3roi'
keyeLV keycov otl " 'Ep.ot, 2) dpLa-T, el^rlv pev ttov tlvs Kal
otKetof Kat ydp tovto avTo to tov 'Op.r/pou, ovb eyo) '
d^ro
bpvds ovb^ dTTO TreVprjs ' TT(f>VKa dAA' ef dvdp(OTT(i)V, u)(rT 5
Kat otKetot jttot elcTL Kal vet? ye, co dvbpes 'A^rjvatot, rpet?, ety
juey fxeLpaKLOv rjbrj, bvo be TTaLbCa' dAA' op,o)s ovbeva avTcav
a2 S5 B : 6 T a 3 eyio B yojy' T a 4 Tapexe(r0ai T

:
b3 \6yov 1'x'""''' 'I' ^4 B &!/ T b 5 ûviaaai T b

'''''' :
^wiaai B aXrjQiiovri B dAT/flr) Xfyovri

: T 2 iSfridri B t -)p.
SeScTjTai T 05 <pi\aiv B (pi\ovs T : c6iJsBt:^T C7 rax

&y oSv scripsi : rax' oS' B Tax foi/;'
: T d6 -ê T om. B :
PLATO, VOL. I, 4
34d nAATflNOS
bivpo ava/SilSacrdiJLevos berjo-ofxat vixCiv aTTO-^rjcpia-aa-dau* tC
8?/ ovv ovbiv TovTutv TTOiô-u); OVK avOabiCojJievos, S) avbpes
C Adr]vaioi, ovb' v/xas dn/xa^coi', dAA' d p.ev Oappakio^s (ycb
IX'*^ T^pos davaTov ?; /x?/, akkos koyos, Trpbs 8' ovv boâv kolI
ifjiol Kal vpuv Kal okrj Trj TToket ov p.oi boKel Kakbv elvai [X
TovTcov ovbev TTOieiv Kal TrjkiKovbe ovtu Kal tovto Tovvop.a

5 exovTa, etr' ovv akrjdes etr' ovv "êvbos, dAA' ovv beboyp-dvov
35 ye kaTi rw ^(HKpdTri biacîpeiv t&v TTokkQv av6pu)TToov. el
ovv vp.GiV ol boKovvTcs bia(pepeiv ctre troîa eire dvbpeCa

cire dkkr] ijTiVLOvv dpeTi] TOiovTOi eaovTai, ala"^bv hv etr)-
oiova-!Tp iyu) TrokkdKis kutpaKd Tivas OTav Kpivu)VTat, bo-

* 6 KovvTas fJ-iv Tt etvat, 6aviJ.data b^ (pyaôp.evovs, ws betvov
Tt olopievovs TTetarea-dat et aTTodavovvTat, u>a-!Tep dâvdTcav
eaofxevoov hv v/jiets avTovs p.r] diTOKTeivrjTe' ot epLol boKovatv
ala-\vvr]v Trj iroket TreptdiTTetv, cSor' dv Ttva Kal tS>v êvuiv
b VTTokaêtv ort ot btacpepovTes 'A6r}vatu>v els dpeT-qv, ovs
avTol eavTutv ev re rats dpxats koI rats dAAat? rt/xats
TTpoKpivovatv, ovTot yvvatKUJV ovbev bta(f)epova-tv. TavTa ydp,

0} dvbpes 'Adrjvaloi, ovTe u/ias j(p^ Troieti' rovs boKovvTas
* 5 Kat OTTrjovv rt etiât, ovr', av rjp.is 7T0t&p.ev, vp.ds eTrt-
TpeiTetv, dkka tovto avTo evbetKVvaât, ort ttoAv p.dkkov

KaTaxf/ricf^tela-ê tov Tct eketvd TavTa bpdp.aTa eladyovTos Kal
KaTayekaaTov Trjv TToktv ttolovvtos rj tov r]a~vyj.av dyovTos.
Xcopts be Trjs bo^rjs, u) dvbpes, ovbe btKatov p.ot boKet
C etvat 8eto-âi tov biKaaTov ovbe beoptevov diTOcfêvyetv, dAAd

bibda-Ketv mi iretêtv. ov yap cttI tovt(o Kd6r]Tat 6 btKa-
aTTfjs, eirl T(p KaToyapiêcrât rd btKata, dkk' eTTt rw Kptvetv
TavTa' Ka\ dp.(li]X0Kev ov yapieia-6at ols dv boKfj avT(o, dAAd

5 biKd(reiV KaTo. Toiis v6p.ovs. ovkovv xpV ovre rjpas iîêtv
d9 5); oHv B t : 5)> T : oZi/ W e i 6appa\fos T a i ti>>
2<(cpaTi7 scripsi: t^ 'XtuKpa.rd B: Toy 'XcuKpa.Tr) Tb: t^ 2aicpaTr;

al. Sia<pfpeiv scripsi : Sta^pfpeiv tivI BT W b4 r]iJ.as Arm.
b5 oTr-povv Ti Heindorf Stt? : ti ovv BT : bTiovv Arm. b9 Soku
flvaiinoiT C2 TOUT^ B t : tovtoT C4 post ;âpierCT0ai add.
To 5iaia T
AnOAOriA 211KPAT0T2 35 c
VfMS (TTLopKclv ov6' v/ua? 6[(e(rdat' ovberepoL yap av i]\iGiv
cvo-e/Soier. p.y) ovv aîovTe fxe, w avbpes 'A^rjvaloi, TOLavra

bflv Trpbs vfxas Tipa.TTei.v h fir)T rjyovfxaL KaXa elvaL ixrjTe
biKaLa \xr]Te ocrta, aXXois re fxevTot inj ACa TrdvTcos Kal aa-e- d
/Setas (pevyovTa VTtb MeXriTov tovtovl. <Ta(P&s yap av, et
TTeCdoLfXL vfjus Kal TM belcrdaL ^La(oLfxr]v ofxcafxoKOTas, deovs
av bLbAa-KOLfXL fxrf rp/ela-âL vfxas elvaL, Kal aTexv(as aiToXo-

yovfxevos KaTrfyopoLrjv av ifxavTov ojs deovs ov vofXLCo^. oAAa 5
TToWov bel ovTuis exeLV vofXL(oct re yap, S) avbpes 'AdrfvaXoL,

b)S ovbels TU)V efxGiV KaTrfyopcov, Kal vfxZv eTTLTpeTTO) Kal tS> 6e^
KplvaL TTepl efxov oirrf fxeXXeL efxoC re apLo-Ta etvaL koj. vfxlv.
To fxev fxrf ayavaKTelv, w avbpes 'AdrfvaToL, eTTi TovT(a e

TU) yeyovoTL, otl fxov KaTe\frr}(f)C(Taa6e, aXka re fxoL ttoXXcl 36
(TD/ix/SaAAerat, Kal ovk avekiTL^TTov fxoL yeyovev Tb yeyovbs
TOVTO, aXXa ttoXv fxaXXov 6avfxdC(i> eKaTepav t(ov \}/r](f)(ov
Tbv yeyovoTa dpL6fx6v. ov yap (Lofxrfv eyo)ye ovto) iTap
bXCyov ea-e(r6aL dXXa TTapd ttoXv' vvv be, ws eoLKev, et 5
TpLaKovTa fxovat fxeTeiTecrov tS)v y\rr]^(DV, diTeTTe^pevyr] dv.
MeATjroy fxev ovv, ws efxoX boKU), koX vvv diTOTTe^pevya, Kal

ov fxovov diTOTTeêvya, dXXd iTavTl bifXov tovto ye, otl el fxr]
dvejSr] "Awtos Kal Avk(i)v Karqyop-qcrovTes e]xov, Kdv S)(j)Xe
\LXCas bpaxfxds, ov fxeToXaôDV Tb TTefxiTTOv fxepos tQv b

^r](f)oov.
Ti/xarat 8' ovv fxoL 6 dvifp davaTov. elev eyo) be brf
tCvos vfXLV dvTLTLfxrfaofxaL, 0) dvbpes 'Adr^valoL; r] brjXov otl
TTfs d^Cas; tC ovv; tC d^Los elfXL TTa6elv rf d~0Tel(TaL, otl 5
fxa6o)V ev rw ^C(o ov\ r]av\Cav ^yov, dXX' dfxeXrfaas uiVTTep
ol TToXXoC, yj)r]fxaTL(Tp.ov re koi olKOVofxCas kol o-TpaTrfyLOiv
C 6 T]fj.o!>v B : v/ncOr T d. i /xfvroi vt] Aia iravTois B vdvTcos vi/

:
Aia ufvToi T : vt) Aia TavTcus secl, Stallbaum irdvTus secl. Schanz
:
d.6 Sei B t : Suv T Sfoi Cobet

: a 6 TpiaKovra B yp. t rp\s T : ;
,TpJ t ag avaR^ pr. T b^ avTiTi/jLr;a-wfx.ai Hirschig &vSpts

om. W ^ Bt om. T : b 6 fiadwv} iradwv Hermann
b7 iroWol oij Schanz et sic Arm.
4*
36b nAATX2N02
Kat hr]iir]yopmv koX twv aXkcav apxpiV KOii (rvv(oixo(n(av Ka\
OTacrecoy t&v kv r^ TroAet ytyyo/xeycor, rjyr]aaiJ.evos iîavTov
C Tfc) ovTL f'JTi.LK(rTepov etvai rj ojcrre eis TavT iovTa (r(o(e(Tdai,
(VTavOa IMV oi/K rja ol e\6(bv fJir]T vjxlv fjLi]T ejuavrw ffxeX.-
\ov fJi.r]bV oêAos etzât, eiTt 8e t6 i8ta Ka(TTov [loiv] evepye-

rety Trjv fieyiarrjv evepyea-Cav, ots eyco (l>r]fxi, kvTavda f]a,
S eTrixftpwy ^KacrTov Vfi5)v TreCOetv ju,?; TrpoTepov fir]T t&v

kavTov fjLrfbevbs iirifxeXeia-Qai irplv kavTov eTTt/xeATjêtrj orrcos
0)5 )3eArto-ros Kat (f)povtp.(aTaTos i(rotTO, /x7/re roiy r^s tto-
Aecos, irplv avTrjs Trjs 7ro'Aec)?, t&v re aAAcoy ovrco KaTct tov
d avTov TpoTTov iinfxeXeta-Oat rt ovv etjut a^tos TraOetv rotoC-

ros wy; ayaOov Tt, ut avhpes ^ hOrfvatot, et 6et ye Kara r?)y
dftaj' rf) akqOeia. TtfxaaOat' Kal TavTct ye ayaOov tolovtov

ort av TTpeTTOt efxoi. rt oSy iTpeTTet avhpX Trevr^Tt evepyeTr]
5 beofxev(a ayetv axoXrfV em Ty vp.eTepa TTapaKeXeva-et; ovk

eaO^ OTt [}xaXXov], S avbpes ÂOrfvatot, TTpeiret ovrcos o)? tov
TotovTov avbpa ev TTpvraveioi (rtTetaOat, ttoXv ye fxaXXov rj
ei rts vp.S)V iTTTrco rj arvvcopibt rj C^vyet veviKrjKev 'OAujuTria-

(Ttv 6 pLev yap vfxas TTOtet evbaifxovas boKelv elvai, eyo) be
e etyat, Kat 6 ju,ey Tpo(f)r]s ovbev betTai, iyia b^ beofxat. el
ovv 8et jLie KaTo, t6 biKatov Trjs aîas ri/xacrât, tovtov

37 Ttfx5>fxat, ev iTpvTaveiâ o-trrjcrecos.
"Icrco? ovv vp.lv Kal ravrt Xeyo)V 7TapaTTXr](rt(t)S boK(a Xeyetv

&(nTep TTepl tov oXktov Kal Trjs dz^rtjSoAj/creo)?, dTrauâStô'-
êvos' t6 be ovk ecrrtr, S) avbfies 'AOr]vaXot, TotovTov aXXct
5 roto'y8e jxaXXov. jTeiTet^rp.at eycb eKiov elvat fxrfbeva abtKetv

&vOp(a7TO)V, aXXa vpias tovto ov TTeiOo)' oXiyov yap x.p6vov
aXXrfXots bteLXeyp.e6a. e-nei, b)s eyw/xat, et r]V vpuv vopos,
axTTTep Kal aXXots avOpdTTOts, TTepl OavaTOV fxr] p.iav rjp.epav
b povov
, Kpivetv aXXa TToXXds, eTTei(TOr]Te av vvv 6' ov pabtov
ci l6vTaT oj/ra B C3 jou' secl. Schanz (vepyfrwv Arm.

C 4 ivTovOa -â
:
secl. Hermann d2 et 5e ye . . . rifMaaOf B W :
fl S-fi (sed corr. 56? pr. man.) ye . . . riâffde T : c . . . rtfiaa-dai Arm.

d6 fiaWov secl. Mudge : ovtocs secl. Adara a4 &vSpis T : om. B
b
AnOAOriA 2nKPAT0T2 37
^v XPoVo) oA.tyft> fieydXas 8ia/3oXa? aTToXv(rdai.. TTCTTeLorî-
vos bri eyo) ix-qhiva ahiKîV iroXkGV beco ifJiavTov ye abLKrj(retv
Kal Kar ifxavTOV kpdv avTOS &>? a^to's djxC tov KaKov Kal
TifiJjcreo-âi tolovtov tlvos kfiavT^. tC beCcras; rj fxr] Trddai 5
TovTO ov MiXrfTOS y.01 TLfxaTaL, 6 (prjfxi ovk flbivaL ovt ei
dyaObv ovt ei KaKov (ttlv; dvTl tovtov br] Aco/xat <5i^ ev

otbd TL KaKUiV ovT(i)v TOVTOv TLixrjcrdfxevos; TTOTepov bea-fxov;
Kal tC fxe Sei ^fjv kv becrfL^nTrjpidi, bovXevovTa r^ det KaOL- c

OTafxivr) dpxr\, Tot? evbeKa; dXka xprifi.dT(x>v kol bebecrOat
((t)S dv kKTeC(T(i>; dXXd TavTOV fxoC i(TTLV oirep vvvbrj eXeyov

ov ydp (rTL fxoL ^(jprffxaTa oiroOev eKTeCcrd), dXXd brf (pvyijs
TLfxrfcr(DfxaL; Xcrois ydp dv fxoL tovtov TtfxrjcratTe. TtoXXr] 5
fxevrdv fxe ^tXo\lrv\Ca exot, a> avbpes 'AOrjvalot, ei ovtu>s
dXoytcTTos et/jtt toore fiir} bvvaa-6aL XoyCêcrdaL otl r/xets fxev

6VTS TToXlTaC fXOV 0V)(^ oloC T eyV(r6 VyKLV Tas ifLas
8tarpt/3as Kat tovs Ao'yoi;s, dXX' ifxlv âpvTepaL yeydvaaiv d
Kal 7rL(f)dov(oTpaL, SaT frjretre avTS>v vvvl aToAAay^raf
oAAot 8e dpa avrds olo-ov^tl pcibCctis; ttoAAou ye dei, <Jb dvbpes
'AdrjvaloL. KoXbs ovv dv fLOL 6 /3ios etrj ^X66vtl rrjAiKwSe
dvdp(i)T!(ii dXXrjv e^ aAArjs 7ro'Aeco? dp.LôfXV(^ koX eêXavvo- 5
fLV(o ^rjv. v ydp olb' otl ottol dv eXdo), XiycvTOS efxov
dKpoda-ovraL ol vOL (oa-Trep ivddbe' Kav fxkv tovtovs dir-

eXavvd), ovToC fx carrol eêASo-t 7TC6ovtS tovs Trpecr^vTepovs'
kdv b fxr] diTeXavvca, ol tovtcdv TTaTepes 8e Kat ot/cetot 6t' e
aVTOVS TOVTOVS.
"la-cos ovv dv Tts iTTOL' " 2tywi> Se kol r]avyj.av dycov, u)
^(i)KpaTS, ov^ oto? T ^X6u)V " tovtI

crr] rjfxlv Cw> 8r/
eoTt 7TavT(i)v yaXTT(aTaTov TTelaaC Ttvas vfxcav. kdvTe ydp 5
bS B
8); :
5' T b6 oS] & in marg. B' b8 oJU n Baumann :
oTS' oTi BT rovTou] rov Meiser c 5 rtfiria-cofiai B rifirj<rofxai
TW
:
rovrov B rovro T : C 6 5 &v5pe5 'AQr^valoi T om. B :
ds &vZpis om. B ds viMws'] voXiv Cobet koXiv 7r6\fws al.

:
d6 Cvv] yriv rrpo 71 j Cobet d 8 fjLsT f w* B : aiirol] al Schanz

e I Si Kal B : Te koI T 64 ol6s Bt : oTs T

37 e nAATXlNOS
Aeyo) oTt rw 6e(o aTTi9(iv tovt (ttIv koL 8ta tovt ahvva-
38 Tov iâ-vyjiav 6.yLV, ov TTfCa-ea-dd \xol w? dpaivevojxevcf eaxr'
av Aeyco ori Koi rvyxdvd, ixeyio-Tov dyaOov ov dvdpdiTio

TOVTO, kKdarqs rjpL^pai irepl dpeT^? tovs Aoyous TTOUia-Oai
Kal tu>v akK(ov irept (5y v/xeis e/iou dKovTe bi,aX.eyop,Vov Kal
6 epLavTov Kal aAAows eêrciôiTO?, 6 8e dveêTaa-Tos /3io? ou

/3ia)ro? dvdp(07T(a, TavTa 8' eri ^rroy Treiaea-Oi p.01. XiyovTi.
To. 8e e\ei /xei' ovrco?, ws eyw ^jj/xi, oj avSpe?, ttl6i.v 8e ou
pqhLov. KoX eyo) a/xa ov/c i6iap.aL ep.avT0V d^Lovv KaKov

b ovSevo'?. et /iev yap T/y /xoi \prip.aTa, (TLpirjadprjv dv XPV-
fxdTcov oa-a l/xeAAoy KTLcreLV, ovbev yap hv ejBXdjBrjv' vvv
be ov ydp eaTLV, ei p.r] apa oaov dv eyo) bvvaLp.r\v eKTeXaaL,
ToaovTOV ôvKeade jxol TLjxfjaaL. to-co? 8' dv bvvaLfxrjv eK-
5 retcrat vixlv ttov fxvdv dpyvpiov ToaovTOV ovv TLpG)p.aL.
riAcircov 8e o8e, S az^Spes 'A^r/yatot, Kat Kptrcoy Kai
Kptro]3ovAo? xat 'ATroAAo^Scopos KeXevovaC jxe TpLaKovTa p.vS>v
TL\xr]aaadaL, avTol 8' eyyvda-6aL' TLp.(op.aL ovv ToaovTOv,

yyvr]Tal 8e vpiLV eaovTat tov dpyvpiov ovtol d^Loxpeô.
C Ov TToWov y eveKa -yjpovov, u> dvbpes ÂdrjvaloL, ovopa

eêre xat alTLav vtto tQv ôvKop.ev(ov ti]v ttoXlv XoLhopelv
0)9 'EcoKpdrr] dTreKTOvare, avbpa ao(p6v ^r]aova-L ydp 8r;
ao(f)bv elvaL, et Kat /xr/ eljXL, ol ôvK6p.evoL vp.lv oveLbiCetv

5 et yovv Trepte/xetyare oAtyoi \p6vov, diTO tov avTop.aTov av
Vjxlv TovTo eyeveTO' opaTe ydp br] Tr]V rjXiKiav otl Troppo)
i]br] earl tov jBiov 6avdTov be eyyvs. Ae'yco 8e tovto ov
d TTpds TrdvTas v/xas, dAAa Trpos tovs ep.ov KaTa\}rr](f)Laa-
fxevovs 6dvaTov. Xeyio 8e Afot ro'8e Trpos tovs avTovs

TovTovs. La(os fxe 0Lea6e, a> drSpes 'A^rjratot, dTTopia X6y(ov
a I iOLVT o5 B : (oj' TavTo T a2 6' B : om. T a6 5' tj1

8t' Tt BT a8 âSio T ouo B : & T b5 T
irov : om. B
niav ixvav Arm. C3 post 877 add. ûe TW C5 yovv T : oi/v B
c6 post i-fivtTo add. ijxe Te6vdi.ai T 5); B t : ty T da Kal
roSe B t om. T : d3 'Aflijj-ojoi T : om. B

AnOAOriA 2OKPAT0TS sSd
kakoiK^vai TotovTcov ols av vjua? eTTeicra, el (ofjirjv belv
airavTa TTOieiv Kal Xiyeiv woTe aTTO(f)vyelv ttjv bU-qv. 5
TToAAou ye Sei. dAA' aTTopia ixkv eaXoiKa, ov fxevToi koyatv,

dAAa ToKiJLrjs Kal avaLcryyvTias koX tov iiT] eOikeiv keyeiv
Trpo? vjjMS TOLavTa oV av v[xlv ixev rjbLara rjv aKoveiv
6pr]vovvT6s T /Ltou Kal dbvpofjLivov Kal akka ttolovvtos Kal
kiyovTos TToAAa kol ava^La (jxov, ojs eyw <^^H'it> oXa br] Kai e
eWLa-0 VfxeLS tS>v akkoiv aKOveLV. aXk^ ovt t6t (ar]6r^v
beiv evcKa tov KLvbvvov TrpaâL ovbev avekerjdepov, ovt vvv

]xoi fxeTafxekd ovTOiS aTTokoyrô-afxevca, aXka TTokv ixakkov
alpovfxaL w6e a7Tokoyr]a-dp.evos Te6vdvaL r] eKeCvcos Cw- ovTe 5
yap ev bUr] ovt ev TTokefXio ovt efxe ovt^ dkX.ov oibeva bel
TOVTO fxr]yavda6aL, ottcos diTocfierjêTaL TTav ttolQv 6dvaTov. 39
Kal ydp ev rats fxdâLS TTokkdKLS brjkov yiyveTaL otl t6 ye
d~o6aveLV av tls eK(f)vyoL Kal oiTka dipels Kal eip' Ueretay

Tpairdfxevos twv bLO0K6vTO)V' Kal dkkaL fxrfyavaX TTokkaC elaLV
ev eKda-ToLS rots KLvbvvoLS &aTe bLacjtevyeLV ddvaTov, edv tls 5
Tokfia TTav TTOLelv Kal keyeLV. dkkd ju?/ ov tovt f] xakeTTOv,

0) dvbpes, ddvaTov eKcfrvye^LV, dXka TTokv 'xâkeTTooTepov TTOvr]-
piav 6dTTov ydp 6avdTov 6ei. Kal vvv eyo) piev aTe (Bpabvs b
ojv Kal TTpea-^vTr]s vtto tov ^pabvTepov kdXoiV, ol 8' epo\
KarqyopoL are beLVoX Kot oêt? ovTes viro tov 6dTTOVos, r?;s
KaKLas. KoX vvv eyoi fxev diTeLfXL v(f>' vfxGiv 6avdT0v bLKv^v
6(f)k(ov, ovTOL 8' VTTO rfjs dXr]6eLas oxÂTjKoVes fxo^^ripiav 5

xat dbLKiav. koll iyd re T<a TLfxrffxaTL efxfxevoi KaX ovtol.
TavTa fxev ttov la-ois ovtu)S Kal e^beL a\êlv, Kal oi/iat avTa
fxeTpiois eyeLV.
To 8e br] fxeTa tovto eTTL^Vfxia VfXLV \pr](rp.<abrja-aL, oj /cara- C

\frr](f)Lardfxevoi fxov kol ydp elpL ?/8r; evTav6a ev o) fidkLcrTa
d. 7 1X7)1 h Arm. om. B : d8 ofo . . . ji^ktt h.v T fjLfv T :
om. B d 9 re B om. : T 65 diroAo^r/cranei/oy T W : diro-

\o-fy\(T6ixivos B a I ixj^xa-vritTaffOai Stobaeus a 3 ir] piov
&v Arm. al. vrrtK^pvyot Stobaeus a 7 5 &vSpfi 'Ad7)va7ot Tb
b2 5' i/xot B : 5 fiov T b 4 viv B : vvv Srj T v(p' W t : acp' BT
b6 iyti Te Heindorf : tyorye BT b 7 fxev oZv * * irov T
39C nAATX2N02
avOpcoTTOt )(pr]crij,(obov(nv, orav /xeAAcoo-iz; aTToOavîcrOau (f^rjixl
ydp, oii avbpes ot e/xe a-neKTOvaT^, TiiJi.oi)p(av vpXv rjêLV v6vs

5 jJL^Ta Tov ip-bv QavaTov ttoXv \a\eTTcoTepav vrj Ata rj otav
e/i.e aTT^KTOvaTv vvv yap tovto dpyacrde olopLevot p.\v a-KaX-
\a^crdat tov hthovat ^keyyov tov (3tov, to be vpXv ttoXv

kvavTtov aTTO^r](TTat, ws eyw ^r//it. TrAetous (crovTat vp.as
d ol ikiyxovTes, ots vvv eyo) Karetxor, vp.Xs 8e ovk rjcrOd-
veo-0' Kal )(aAe7ra)re/)oi ia-ovTat ocr(o vecorepot ucrtv, KaX
v/xets p.aKKov dyavaKTri^reTc. el yap ote^rde aTTOKTeivovTes
dvdp(aTT0vs eTTtcr)(r\(Tetv tov ovethtC^tv Ttvd vpXv ort ovk
5 opSSis ^re, ov KokGis btavoeta-Oc ov ydp e(r9' avTrj rj aTraA-
Aayr/ ovTe iTdvv bvvaTrj ovTe KoXri, dAA' eKetvt] koi /coAAtcrrT/
Kal pcicrTr], /at/ tovs akkovs KoXovetv oAA' eavTov irapaa-Kevd-
êtv oTTcos earai wy /SeÂrwrroy. ravTa fjtev ovv vpXv rots
KaTa\}/r](}}tcraiJ.evots iiavTevcrdpLevos dTTaXkdTTO]xat.
e Tots 8e dTTO\l/r](pta-ap.evots rjbeoos av btaXexdetr]v VTTep tov
yeyovoTos TovTovt iTpdyjxaTos, ev w oi apxpvTes da-ôXiav
dyovcrt koI ovttco pxop.at ot ekdovTa ]xe bel TeOvdvat, dXkd
p-ot, u) avbpes, TTapap.eivaTe ToaovTov \p6vov ovbev ydp
5 KooAuet btap.v9okoyr]a-at iTpbs dkkrjkovs ecos eêaTtv. vpuv
40 ydp u)s <f)ikots ovatv eiTtbetât e9ek(o to vvvi pot a-vp.ê^r]-
Kos t[ TTOTe voeu epLol ydp, S dvbpes btKaaTai v]j.ds ydp
btKaards Kak&v 6p9(os dv Kakoir]v 6av]j.dcrt6v rt yeyovev,
rj ydp el(o9vtd fxot ]xavTtKr] [r] tov batpLOviov] ev ]J.ev rw
5 Trpda-Qev yjp6v(o TTavTt iTdvv TTVKvr] del '^v Kal Trdvv CTrt
crixtKpols evavTtovixevr], et rt [xekkot]xt ]xr] 6pd(os Trpdêtv,

vvvl be crv]xl3e^r]Ke p.ot diTep opaTe Ka\ avToi, ravrt d ye br]
olri6eir] dv Tts /cat voixiêTat ecryjoLTa KaK&v etvat' e]xol be

b ovTe e^tovTt ea)6ev otKo9ev r]vavTt(o9r] to tov 9eov crr]ixetov,
04 o7 jue airoKrevuri T C 6 aireKrfivare T fXpya<r6t T

W
:
flpydffaaOe B oionfvoi filv Hermann : olunevoi fj,e B : olofxtvoi ^'T

d I i\tyôvT(s Schanz d5 ou KaKais T : ovk opBccs B yp. t
aa ri TTor' ivvott T 8-4 ^ toO Saifioviou secl. Schleiermacher
a8 Kal vofjLiêrai secl. Schanz
: b
AnOAOriA 212KPATOYS 40
ovre rjvLKa a.VJ3aivov ivravdol (ttI t6 btKaoTi^jpLov, ovre Iv

TM Aoyft) ovbaixov fiiWoirrC tl epeXv. KaiToi kv ctAAots Aoyois
TToXkaxov bri jue eTreoê KiyovTa ixeTa^v' vvv be ovbafxov
Trept Tavrqv ti]v irpaî.v ovt iv epyco ovbevl ovt iv Xoyca 5
qvavTLiaTaC fioL. tC ovv aXTtov itvaL v-noXap.âvcti; iyoi
vp.LV ipca- KLvbvvVL yap p.oL to (Tvp.^(.^y]KO's TOVTo ayaOov

yeyovivat, kol ovk ead' ottcos '^pL^ls 6pd(as VTroKap.âvopLtv,
ocroL oiopLeda KaKOV etmt to TiOvavaL. p.iya fxoL TeKpLi^pLov C
TOVTov yeyovev ov yap âO' ottcos' ovk rivavTtoodr] av p.0L to
ei(i)dbs (rrip.eXov, et jUTy rt p.Wov eyo) ayaOov TTpdêLV.
'Evvoi](r(t)pLv 8e xat Trjbe ws ttoAA^ eA77ts eoTtz; dyadov

avTO (tvaL. bvoLV ydp OaTepov ((ttlv t6 reOvdvaL' rj ydp 5
otoi' pLr]bv etvaL p.r]b atcrOr^crLV p.rjbiJLLav /xrjSeros ex^'^ ^
Tdv(aTa, ri Kard Td XeyopLeva p.TaôXr\ tls TvyxdvL
ovcra Ka\ nTOLKr]crLS t^ "^X^ '^^'^ tottov tov ivOevbe ets
oAAoy TOTTov. Ka\ etTe bi] pLrjbepLLa alo-6r](TCs ka-TLV dAA'
olov VTTVOS kiTLbdv TLS Ka6 evb(iiV,yLr]b^ ovap /x?]8ez; opa, 6av- d
p.da-Lov Kepbos dv etT/ 6 âraTos-i eyo) ydp dv otfxaL, et Ttâ
iKXf^dpLevov 8e'ot Tavrrjv Tr]v vvKTa iv rj ovtcd Karibapdev
ojo-Te p.r]b ovap ibeiv, koX tos aAAas vvKTas Te Kot f]p.4pas
rds Tov ^LOV Tov kavTov dvTLiTapa6ivTa Tavrr] ttJ iÛKTt 8e'ot 5
(TK\l/dp.vov etTreiy TTOcras dp^Lvov koX ijbiov rjp-ipas koX

vvKTas Tavrrjs Trjs wkt6s ^(3CooKev ev tS> kavrov /3tw, oijuat
dv jU7/ OTt LbL(OTT]v TLvd, dXXd t6v p-eyav (BacrLXia vapLdp.r]-
Tovs dv vplv avT6v ravras Trpos tols aAAay r}p.pas Ka\ e
vvKras ei ovv tolovtov 6 ddvaros icTTLV, Kpbos iycoy
Ae'ya)* Kai ydp ovbev TrXeCutv 6 iTas xpoiôs (()aCvTaL ovT(a
bi] etvaL r] p.Ca vv^. et 8' av otov dTTobr]]xrjcraC iaTiv 6
Odvaros v6vb ets dXXov tottov, koI dXr]6r] ka-TLV rd 5
bs ovâiiov B : ovieA T rt B-TW : om. B b^ Tavrriv T :
avTTjp B b6 rii'avTi{i>rai B : i)vavTilo0r] T c 2 toitou B :
toCto T c 8 ntToiKiffis Cobet c9 Sri T : om. B d. 2 6 Bt

om. T yap &>'] yap 5r; Schanz d.6 drroffas T e i avrov
om, Ann. 6 2 eâjê B t e-yw : T 64 et 0'] jt' Stobaeus
4oe nAATXlNOS
kcyofxeva, o)? apa Ki d(n irdvTes ol TeOveQres, tl fxelCov
ayadov tovtov eirj av, S avhpes biKaaTat; el ydp tls
41 d(f)LK6p.evos els "AtSou, diTaXXayels tovtcov). tQiv âa-KovTcav

bLKaa-T&v etvat, evpTâ-ei. tovs o)? d\r]9ois StKaoras, otirep
Kal XeyovTai eKei biKdêiv, Mivcos re koi 'PaSa/^jiayî;? Kot
AtaKO? Kat TpMrroAejLios Kat aAAot oo-ot tG>v rjfXLdeMV StKatot
5 eyevovTO ev tQ> eavT&v /Stw, dpa (pavkr] dv etrj rj dTTobr]p.La;
7] av 'Opêt (TvyyeiêVât Kat Movorato) Kat 'Ho-toSw Kat

'OpLrjpio em ttoo-c^ av Tis Se'atr' dv vpQv; eycb fjiev ydp
TToAAaKts e6ek(i) TeOvdvaL et TavT ecrTLV dkrfOrj. eirel
b ep-OLye koX avro) 6av}iaa-Tr] av eiT/ rj bLaTpL^rj avTo^L, OTTOTe

. evTvxoLpLL riaAa/iJjSet Kot Aiavrt rw Tekapcivos Kal et rts
aAAos T(ov TraAatwy 8ta kplctlv dbLKOv Te6vr]Kev, dvTLTcapa-

fidXXovTi TCL ep.avTov Trddr] Trpbs tcl iKeCvaiV ws' eyo) olpaL,
5 ovK dv dr]bes etr] Kat 8r) to peytcrTOV, tovs eKet eêrciôyra

Kat epevvSiVTa uxnTep tovs evTav6a Stayetv, rts avTwv aoôs
eoTLV Kou. TLS oterot p.ev, ecrTLV 8' ov. eiTL ttoVw 8' dv tls,
o) dvbpes bLKacnaL, beâLTO eêTdaaL tov eiTL TpoCav dyayovTa

C Tr]V TTokXr]v aTpaTLav rj 'Obvaa-ea 7] ^LOVcfôv 7] dkXovs
pLVpLOVs dv TLS etTTOt KOt dvbpas KaX yvvoLKas, dts eKei
8taAe'ye(rât Kat o-wetyat Kat eêrdêtv dixr])(avov dv etrj
evbatpovLas; TrdvTcos ov brjirov tovtov ye eveKa ol eKei
6 dnoKTeLVOvaL' Ta re ydp dkka evbaLpovea-TepoC ela-LV oi eKtt
T&v ev6dbe, Kal rjbr] tov koLTTOv xpovov dddvaTOL elaLV, et-nep
ye Ta keyopueva dkr]6fj.
'AAAa Kat XPV' ^ dvbpes btKacrTaL, evekTTibas elvaL

v]j.ds
TTpos Tov ddvaTov, Kal ev tl tovto bLavoelcrdaL dkr]6es, otl

d ovK eo-TLV dvbpl dyad(o KaKov ovbev ovTe ^&vtl ovTe Tekev-
TrjaavTi, ovbe d/iieAetrat 117:0 6euiv rd tovtov TrpdypaTa'
e6 T daiv
flffi Traz^Tfy : B
o7roi'Tf rB T &>' om. T a I rov-
Tuvl T rovrwv B
: a2 T b om. B
"djy a 8 iOf'\a> T 6f\Q, B
: :
bi &w6Te {re) Schanz bs orj5s B Arm. aj?5);s T /fai 5)? B : :
Koi Sr) Ka\ T b6 ris T rls tiv B

: h'] Sav (i. e. 5t/ tiv) Schanz
sublata distinctione post oi( b8 ayaycvraT : &yr.'raJi 2 Sia-
\fy firQai f 6? T C 5 a.Tr3KTfvov(n T C 7 post aA.7j67) add.
iariv W T W
AnOAOriA 2ilKPAT0Y2 4id
ovb^ To. eixa vvv airo tov avTOfiaTov y4yovev, aXXd yoi
hijXov ((TTi TOVTo, OTL ?/8j] TedvcLvat Kal a.TTrjXX.dxdo.t rtpa-
yixaTMv l3eXTiov rjv fxoi. bta tovto Ka\ 6/xe ovbaiJLOV a7TTpe\j/ev 5
t6 ariixetov, Kal eycoye Tots KaTa\lfri(pt(rafxevois fxov Kal Tois
KaTTjyopots ov irdvv xa^^raiVa). KatTOt ov TavTrj rfj htavoict
KaTexj/rjcptCovTo fxov Kal Karrjyopovv, dXX' olcfxevot (BXaTTTetv
TOVTo avTols d^tov ixepL(f)a-6at. T0(r6vbe fxevTot avT&v e

beopiaf Tovs vets fxov, (Tretbav rjjBricrco^ri, TifX(opr]a-a(r6e, cb
dvbpes, TavTct TavTa Xvttovvts diTep iyoi) vfxds iXvTTovv, eav

vp.lv boKdcrtv rj \pr]f).dT(i)V i] dXXov tov TrpoTepov (irt-
pieXelcrdat rj dpeTrjs, Kal idv boKuia-i rt etvat fxrfbev ovTes, 5
dvtbiC(T avTols u>o-7Tp fyo) vfxu', oTt ovK eiTifxeXovvTat S)v
beX, Ka\ oXovTai Tt etvat ovTes ovbevbs d^tot. koI edv

TavTa TTotrJTe, biâta iTeTTOvdoiS eypa diTievat, efxol fxev
d~o6avovfxev(), vfxXv be (Btoiaofxevots' oTTOTepot be r]p.u)v
epxpvTat eTTt dixetvov iTpdyixa, dbrjXov ttovtI irXr^v el
tS 6eu). 5
d5 TovTo B rai/Tt T d8 p\d.TTeiy ti T et Arm. (ut videtur)

W
:
e I fXiVTOi alTwv S(OfJ.ai B' T : Sfo^tot fxivTot auTcoy B 63 Ku-

TovvTo.^ T W a 4 ttAV 1 B W : itK7]v *) B- T W^
^^
KPITXIN
2f2KPATH2 KPIT12N St. I

P-43
212. Tt rqvLKabe a(pLâL, S KpiTiav; rj ov iTp^ TL icrTiv; a
KP. Havv fikv ovv.
212. riTjvi/ca p.d\i(rTa;
KP. 'Opdpos âOvs.

212. @avp.dôi OTTcas ÔiX.rjae crot 6 tov becrfKOTrjpLov 5
(})v\a^ VTTaKOVcraL.
KP. ^vvrjO-qs ijbr] p.OL kcrTLV, a> 2wKpares, 8ta ro 'JtoA-
XaKLs 8vpo <f)OLTav, KaC tl kol iixpyiTrjTaL v-n ipLov.
212. "ApTL 8e rJKLs 77 TroAat;

KP. 'ETrtetKws TroAat. 10
2X2. Etra tt&s ovk v6vs eTnjyetpas fxe, dAAa o-iy^ iTapa- b
Kd^Tjcrat;
KP. Ov /j,a roy Ata, S 2&)Kpar?, ov8' dy avTos rÔekov

V Tocra^vTt] re aypVTTvCa Kal Kvttt] eirai, dA.Aa Kai o"q) -n^dAai
0ai;/xd^co alcr6av6p.vos &)? rjbecos KaOevbeLS' Kal eTTLTrjbes <re 5
ovK fjyiLpov Lva ws rfbLora dtdyrys. Kai TToAAdKts /u.ei' 8^ o-e
Kai TTpoTepov kv iTavTL rw /3t({) r]vbaLp.6vLcra tov TpdiTOV, ttoXv

be fiakLcrTa ev Trj vvv TTapecrrcacrr] crvp.ôpa, <t)S pqbi(x)S avrt]v
Kal TTpaXOS cf)4pLS.
a 5 i]df\ricre B : ^9e\e T b l irws B d>s T b4 aypvirvia

W
:
TC b 8 ywl W
43 b nAATXlNOS
10 Sf2. Kal yap av, Zi KpLTOiv, 7rA?]ju/xeAes etr} ayavaKTelv
Tr]\i,K0VT0V ovTa et 8a 7/617 TekevTav.
C KP. Kai aXXoL, 00 SwKpares', rr/XiKoCroi ev TOLavTaLS
(Tvixcpopals oXiaKovTaL, dAA' ovh\v avrovs kinkviTai t] f]\LK[a
To fxr] ovxL ayavaKTelv Tr] Trapova-r] TV)(r].
2i2. Eo-rt raiira. ak\a tl bi] ovto) Trpo) a(f)lâL;
5 KP. AyyekCav, w ScoKpares, (fêpuiv \akeTrr]v, ov a-oi, ws

]xo\ (f)aiveTaL, dAA' e)i(.ot xat rot? o-ots e-TrtrJjSetots Traa-LV Kal
Xa\Ttr]V Kal âpeiav, rjv eyw, ws e/uot Soko), ey rots (3apv-
Tar av eveyKaL]XL.
212. Tiva TavTr]v; rj to ttXolov d<^tKrat ck Aj/Aou, ov 8et
d a(f)LKO]xevov TeOvavaL /xe;
KP. Ovrot br] a^plKTaL, aXXa boKLV ]xev ]xol ijêL Tr]]xe-
pov c S)V airayyeWova-LV rJKovTes tlvcs airb ôvviov Kal

KaTakLTTOVTes eKet avTO. brjkov ovv eK tovtcov [t&v ayyi-
5 kuiv] OTL rj^CL Tr]pi,epov, kolI avayKr] br] ets avpLov ecTTaL, w
2a)Kpares, tov îov cre reAevrdr.
2i2. 'AAA', o KpiT(ov, Tvx]! o.ya6fi, ei TavTj] rots êois
(f)ikov, TavTij ecTTU)- ov ]XVtol dL]xaL ijêLV avTO Tr]]xepov.

44 KP. no^êy tovto TK]xaipr];
212.'Eyw o-ot epw. rf/ ydp ttov vaTepaict 8et /xe aTro-
6vr\a-KeLV ?/ ?] dy eA^r/ to Trkolov,
KP. $ao-t ye rot br] ol tovtcjov KvpLOL.
5 2X2. Ov Toivvv Trjs kTtLovar^s r]]xepas oX]xaL avro rjêLV
akka Trjs eTepas. TeK]xaipo]xaL be eK tlvos evvnviov o e(o-
paKa okiyov TrpoTepov TavTr]s Trjs vvktos' kol KLvbvveveLS ev

KaLpS> tlvl ovk eyelpai jxe.
KP. 'Hy 8^ br] Ti to evvirvLOv;

10 212. 'E8o'Ket rts ]xol yvvr] Trpocrekôvcra Kakr] Ka\ eveLbr]s,
b kevKo, t/xdrta e\ov(ra, KaAeVat ]xe Kal elirelv " '12 ^dKpaTes,
C2 aurouj B : avTols T C5 post x"^*"'^'' add. koI $ape7av B

C7 âpvraT B t : fiapvraTois T (ut videtur) SoKer!/ . . da
{}|f .
Buttmann : SoKeîu . . . TJletc B : SoK(7 . . . Tfi^tiv B'TW d^ rwv

ayyiXwv B T et marg. W : secl. Hirschig : rS>v ayytXiuv W
KPITX2N 44t)
7//>iart K(V TpLTaTca ^dirjv ipt^coXov lkolo"
KP. "Atottov to ivvTTVLOv, 0) ^(aKpaTes.

212. 'Evapyes {xev ovv, oos ye /xoi boKel, co Kptrcoy.
KP. Atav ye, wy ioLKev. /. aXX.\ S> baLp.6vLe ûtKpaTes, 5

TL Kal vvv ifxol ttlOov Kal (raidriTL' wy ejuoi, eav crv a-no-
6avi]s, ov ixLa (Tvp.ôpa kcrTLV, oKKa xoipls p.ev tov iaTepij-

(rdaL TOLOVTOV eTtLTTqheiov dlov eyco ovheva /x?/ Trore evpi](r(i>,
eTL he Kal TroAAot? bo^co, ot ejue Kal (re /x?/ aa^pios t(ra(rLV,
0)? otos T &v (re o-wêty ei ijOeXov avaXL(rKeLV xpi]pLaTa, c
d/xeAT/o-ai. Katrot rts hv al(r)(j.(iiv eir/ TavTrjs boâ ?/ SoKeiy
\pr]p.aTa Trepi jrAetoyos Troteto-ât ?/ (fyCkovs; ov yap Tretaoy-
rat ot iroAAot o)? ot) avTos ovk r]dekr]aas aTTLevaL evdevhe
r}p.Q>v TTpo6v[j.ovixev(ov. \
5
212. 'AAAa rt rjfxiv, w p.aKapLe KpLTOiV, ovt(o tijs t5>v
TToXKGiv h6^r]s iiekeL; ol yap eTTLeLKe^TTaTot, b)V ixakkov u^lov
(f)povTLêLV, i]yr](TOVTaL avTct ovto) TTe7Tpa\daL uxnrep &v

vpa\6r].
KP. 'AAA' bpas br] otl avayKr], > 2a)Kpares, fcat r7/s Toiv d
TroAAcSi' bo^rjs fxekeLV. avTo. he br]ka tcl TTap6vTa vvvl otl otot
T el(rlv ol TTokkol ov to, ajXLKpoTaTa t5>v KaKSiv eêpyaCecrdai

akka Tci ]xeyL(rTa o-)(êh6v, eav tls ev avTols 8ta/3e/3A7//xe-
vos f].
5
212. Et yap w(f)ekov, S) KptTcov, otot r' eti-at ot iroAAot
Ta ]xeyL(rTa KaKO. epy6ê(r6aL, tva oloC r' rj(rav Kal aya6a tol
fxeyLCTTa, Ka\ KaAais av etyev. vvv he ovheTepa oloC re* oilre
yap ({)p6vL]xov ovtc a(f)pova Swarot TTOi.rj^rai, 7rotoS(ri he tovto

OTL av TV\(M)(rL. 10
KP. Taura fxev hr] ovt(j)S eyeTd)' Tahe be, u) 2a)Kpare?, e
b3 B oiy &TOTrov T Proclus

&Toirov : b 4 ye fj.01 B e/xol T :
b6 Burges Treleov B T
Tridov : b 7 oii /ito T ov5(/xia B tov :
Sallier aov : BT
bg 5e secl. Schanz c i ws secl. Cobet
d.2 5^\a] StjXo? Cornarius d^ crxf^^y fa. fieyKTTa T d? (pyd-
Cfcrdat B e^fpya(((r6ai T
: Kal B T aS Kal W ra jueîo-TO : W
ayada. W: Tay aOa to (leyicrTa Cobet
44 6 nAATiiNOS
eiTre /AOt. apa ye ixi] efxov TTpo^rjOri Kal tuiv aXXcov eTnTr]-
Setcor /U77, iav (tv ivdevbe eî\6ris, ol a~vKO(f)dvTat Tjfxlv
irpdyp.aTa TTape^Mo-LV ws cre IvOivhe KKXe\}/aa-LV, Kal dvay-

5 Kaa-QG>p.iv ?/ Ka\ Ttda-av Tr]v ovaCav djtojiakilv r] a-v\vd
\pr]]iaTa, r] Ka\ aKko tl irpbs tovtols TraOelv; ei ydp tl
45 TOLOVTOV (jiofirj, ia(Tov avTO \aLpeLV' r]]ieLS ydp ttov hLKaLoC
ia-fjiev adaavTes ae KLvbvveveLV tovtov tov KLvbvvov Ka\ idv

berj Iri tovtov ^x^lCo^. oAA.' f]xo\ TTeCOov Ka\ [xr] dWctiS ttoUl,
2X2. Kal TavTa TTpo]xr]OovixaL, S) KpLTcov, Ka\ dWa
5 TToWd.
KP. M^re tolvvv ravTa (j)OJ3ov Ka\ yap ovbe ttoXv
TapyvpLov kcTTLV o OeXova-L kaj36vTS TLves auia-ai ae Ka\ e^-
ayayelv ivOevbe. eiTeLTa ov\ opas tovtovs tovs a-VK0(f)dvTas
w? evreAeis, Ka\ ovbev dv biot k-n avTovs ttoXKov dpyvpiov;
b (To\ he VTrdpxeL ]x\v Ta i]xd \pr][i.aTa, ws eyo) oT^xaL, iKavd'
eTretra Kai et rt e]xov Kr]h6]xevos ovk otet belv dvaXicTKeLV
Td]xd, êvoL ovTOL evOdhe eT0L]X0L dvaXia-KeLV els he koI

KeKO^XLKev eTr' avTo tovto dpyvpLov LKavdv, ^L]X]xias 6 Qr]-
5 /3atos, eTOL]xos he Ka\ Ke^r]S Ka\ aAAoi TroAAot TTavv.
S)(JTe, OTTep Xeyo), /U7/re TavTa ôôvp.evos diTOKd]xrjs aavTov

a-daâL, ]xr]Te, o eXeyes ev rw hLKaaTr]pi(o, hvcrxêpes croL
yeveaOci) otl ovk dv exoLS eêXOcov otl xP^^ aavTU)' ttoX-

C Xaxov ]xev ydp Ka\ dXXoae ottol dv d(f)iKr) dyairrâovai cre'
edv he ôvXr] els &eTTaXiav levaL, ela\v e/xot exet êvoL ot
o-e Trept ttoAAou TTOLr]crovTaL Ka\ da-^dXeLdv aoL TTapeôvTaL,

&aTe ae pir]heva Xvnelv t&v KaTa SeTTaXiav.
6 "'Ert he, S) 2(o/cpares, ovhe hiKatov ]xol hoKeXs eiTLX^î-pîv
TTpdyp.a, aavTov TTpohovvaL, kôv crcoOrjvaL, Ka\ TOLavTa (nrev-

heLS TTep^ aavTov yeveaOaL diTep dv kol ol exOpoi aov airevaaLev
re Ka\ eaiTevaav ae hLa^pOelpaL j3ovX6]xevoL. TTpds he tovtols
62 ju^ BT om. W e 6 tovtois Tb : tovtovs B a6 fi-fiTe B :
W
:
ju)? TW bs ovToi] Toi Schanz koI BT : om. b6 î^re

B t : ynT/ T (Tcoffat (ravrSv TW C i fiAAoo-eJ &K\odi Schanz
c6 (T-mvSetv Stephanus
KPIXaN 45 c
Koi Tovs vet? Tovi (raxrrov liJLOLye boKels 7rpo8i8oVai, ovs aot
^6v Kal iK6pe\j/aL Kal eK7rat8euo-at 01x^707/ KaroAtTrwy, kol d
ro (rbv jJiepos otl hv TV)(^M<rL tovto TrpaôvaLV TevôvTaL be,
0)9 To (Ikos, tolovtcov olcLTTep (tuidev yLyvi(T6ai (V ratv
6p(f)avLai9 iTpL Tovs 6p<f)avovs. 7} yap ov xph TtoLiicrâL
TraiSay 77 0T;y8iaraAai7ra>peri' Kat Tp4(povTa Kal TraLbevovTa, crv 5
8e' fxot 8oKety tcl pqdvixoTaTa atpeio-ât. xprj be, airep av avijp
aya66s Kal avbpcLos eAotro, TavTa aipeto-ât, (f)6.(rKovT(i ye br]
apfTrjs 8ta -navT^s tov ^lov ^Trt/xeAeto-âf ws lywye Kot

VTTep a-ov Kal VTTep r}p.S)V tS)V (t5)v (TTLTribeLcov ai(r\vvop.aL ixrj e
80^77 aTray to TTpayfxa t6 Trept o-e avavbpCcL tlvl Trj r)p.eTepa.
TTeTTpa\6aL, Kui r} elcrobos ttjs bLKrjs ets t6 bLKa^rr-qpLov ws

eto-Âêy kôv p.r] elcreXddv, Kal avros 6 ayojv Trjs bUrjs
b)s iyeveTO, Kal t6 reAeuratby 8^ tovtl, &(nTep KaTayeXâs 5
TTjS TTpa^0)S, KaKLCL TLvX KoiX OVavbpLCL TTJ r]p.eTip(l bLaTTe(f)(V-
yivaL r]]xas boKeiv, ovTLvis o-e ovyj. icrcocrapLev ovbe crv (ravTov, 46
olov re 6v Kal bvvaTbv ef rt Kat fXLKpov rjjiSiv oêAoy rjv.
TavTa ovv, S) '2(i>KpaTes, opa ixr] ap.a r&i KaK^ Ka\ aicrxpa yj
(TOL re Kot rjiXLV. oXKa jSovkevov -/jtaAAoy 8c ov8e fiov-

\eve(rdaL eTi u>pa dAAa l3e(3ovXevcrdaL- /iia 8e /SovAtj* rrjs 5
yap eTTLovcrrjs vvkt6s TravTa TavTa 8et TTeTTpa^âL, ei 8' ert
TTepLnevoviiev, abvvaTov Ka\ ovKeTL olov re. dAAa Trarri

TpoTTc^, w ScijKpare?, TTeCôv iiol kcCl nrjbaixi^s oAAtoy Trotet.
2X2. 'H (j^tAe Kptrtoi', rj iTpodvp.La (tov ttoKKov aîa ei b

IxeTa TLVos opdoTrjTos etr;- et 8e fxr'], o(r(a ixeLô)V TO(rovT(a
XaX.eTT(i)Te pa, (TK0TTeLcr6aL ovv \pr] rnxas etre TavTa iTpaKTeov

eire /utj- wj eyco ov vvv TTpiaTov aWa Ka\ det tolovtos olos
Tu)V eixS)V ixrjbevL aAAw TTeidea-âL rj rw Xoyia os av ixol 5
Xoyiôixevca j3e\TLcrTos (paLvrjTaL. tovs brj Ao'yov? ovs ev roi
daSfBTrrtW d^ xph B :
XPV" (sic) T 64 tlo-riXeev
B : flaT}\0fi
a I ouxl B ou/c T
Tb toutI T 617^00 tovtI B
65 5i/ 5); wourt : : W
: a 4 ovSf om. T a 6 5' 'ti B 5 T :
b 4 oi vvv irpSiTov herma Socratis C I G iii, 843. no. 61 15 ov fxovov :
vZv B T Eusebius b6 5tj T Eusebius 5 B W :
PLATO, VOL. I. 5
46b nAATilNOS
(IxTTijoaOiv ^Kcyov ov bvvafiai vvv <K/3aA<u^, <77(i57j fioi
ijbf f) TV)(7} yeyovfv, aX.\a a^fbov ri ofjLOtoi (âivovraC fxoL,
C Kal T0V9 avTovs Ttpea-^fvut KaX TifxSi ova-jTfp Kai irpoTfpov

<av iav fxr} /SeArito (x^MfjLfv Kfyeiv iv rw napovTL, ev ladi
5ti ov nrj aoi avy\<apria-ui, ov6' hv irXfua tHv vvv Ttapov-
Toiv 7} tG>v TToXKSiv hvvafiLS a>a-iT(p Traidas ^fia? fioppio-
5 \vTTr]Tai, 5eo-/xovs Kal dav6.T0vs (TTtiT(fnTova-a Kal x/w?M^^<Ji'

a<})aipsa-( ts. irwy ovv hv fKrpuoTaTa a-KOTToCfi(0a avTa; d
TTpGiTov jx(v TovTov Tov \6yov iva\di3otfx(v, ov av \iy(is
TT^pl T(av bo^v, TTOT^pov KoXuts (\(y(TO îcdoTorc r] ov,
d ort Tais fx(v b(t tQv 6oa>r TTpo<r(\(tv tov vovv, Tats
b^ ov* Tf irplv fx(v ifx^ b(iv dTTo6irrf(TK(tv Ka\<as (\(y(To,
vvv bi KaTdbrjôs dpa (y(V(To ori aAAws (V(Ka \6yov
(\(y(TO, ^v b^ Ttaibut Koi <f)\vapta q>s d\r)du)s; iTTtOvfxo)
5 8' eycoy' (TTLcrKe\f/aaât, oi KpLTcav, KOtvfi fi(Ta aov d ri
fxot dAAotorepo? <f>av(LTat, (7T(tbrf X'^ ^ ^ avros,

u)b(
Kai id<rofx(v xaCpetv rj TT(t<r6fx(6a avrw. (\(y(To b4 ttws,

b)S iyiofxat, (Kd<TTOT <ab( vno rcSr olofX(V(>)V t\ \4y(a>,
<oa-TTp vvvbrf (yu) (\(yov, ori twv bo^Qv hs ol dv6po)iTot
e So^dôuorir 8eoi rds fx\v irfpl ttoWov irotd^rât, rds 8e fxrf.
TOVTO irpbs 6(S>v, S> KptToov, ov boK(t KaXcis aot \(y(a-6at;

<rv ydp, oaa y( Tdv6p<aTT(ta, iKTos (t tov fx(W(tv aTTO-
47 6vr'](TK(tv avptov, koX ovk av ar^ TtapaKpovot rf Trapovaa avfx-
<f>opj,' (TKoVet bif ov\ iKavHi boK(t aot \(yT6at ort ov
irdo-? \prf Tas b6âs tS)V dv6p(i>TT<i)V Ttfxav dAAd rds fx(v,
rds 8' ov, ovbk iTdvTcov dWa tQv fxiv, tS>v 8' ov; tC <f>rfs;
5 TavTa ovyjL KoAcis Aeyerai;

KP. KaAb)s.
Sil. OvKovv rds ftcv xptf<rra.s rifxav, rds hk TTovtfpiks fxrf;
KV. Nat.
C8 w*pV rhv irtpl Eiisebius d3 taraSjjAov B yp. t : Kol <8jXoj T

do âiVfrai B' d 7 iiaiMv B t : iaaaifity T a wapaKpovOiB'
i
Cobet as tHw BT: rii rwy W Eusebius a^ ovSi ... 8'

oC T W Eusebius : om. B
KPITHN 47 a
212. Xprjaral b^ ovx al tS)v <l>povi}JMV, TTOvr]pal 8e al lo
Twv acppovoiv;
KP. Uuis 8' 0;
S12. êpe 877, irws au m ToiavTa (kiy^To; yvpivaConevos
^jrqp Kal tovto TtpaTTOiv TroTepov TravTos avbpbs (TraLVia Ka\ b
\lr6y(o Kal bo^ tov vovv Tipocr^xî, r\ kvbs p.6vov Klvov bs
av TvyxcLvrj iaTpbs 1] TraLboTpLJSrjs wr;
KP. 'Eyos ix6vov.
SX2. OvKovv (f)ol3La-6aL XPV '^5 "^^yovs Kal aaTraCâ-daL 5
Tovs (TraLVovs tovs tov kvbs eKeCvov oAAa /xtj tovs t&v
TToAAwi'.
KP. AÂa 877.
2X2. Taurr/ 6.pa avria irpaKTeov kol yvp.vaaTiov Koi.
ebeoTôv ye Kal TtoTiov, // av tm kv\ boKr\, rw eTTLaraTrf Kal 10
iTTatovTL, fjLoXXov rj f/ avp.Tiaa-L tols aAAois.
KP. "EoTi raCra.

2X2. Eify. aTret^T/o-as 8e rw Irt Kat drt/xao-as avTov Tr]v C
b6âv KoX Tovs (TTaLvovs, TLfjiria-as be Toiis twv TToXXoiv [X6-
yovs] Kal [xrjbev iTTax^vTOiv, apa ovbev KaKov TTeCa-fTaL;

KP. YIws yap ov;
2X2. Ti 8' loTi To KaKov tovto, koX ttol TeCveL, Kal els 5
ri Toiv TOV aTTL60VVT0S;
KP. Arjkov OTL eis to aS)p.a' tovto yap bL6XXva-L.

212. KaAwy Aeyets. ovkovv kol ToXXa, S) Kptrtor, ovtms,
tva fir] TTavTa bLLoofxev, Kal brj Kal Trepl T(av bLKaCo^v Kal
abCKbov Kal aicrxpSiV kol KoXoiv Kal ayadoiv koX KaKoov, iTepl 10
&v vvv r] /SouAj/ rjfXLV eaTLv, TT^Tcpov Tfj Ta>v iroAAwv 80^7/
oet Tjixas TTea6aL Ka\ (f)of3ela-6aL avT-qv rj tt/ tov kv6s, et rts d
eo-rtr eTratcoi, bv 8et koX aicjyyveadaL koll (f)oêLa6aL fxaXXov
r] (rvp.TTavTas tovs akXovs; w et ]xr] aKoXov^rjaojxev, 8ta-
b2 irpo(T*'xt rhv vovv pr. T b i r 7* T : j B C2 \6-yovs

B : om. T Eusebius C5 Eusebius om. T
tJ B C 7 ZioWvti
W
:
B (ut videtur) c 11 ^ ôvX^ post tffriv transp. T

5*
:
47 d nAATIiNOS
(f)dpovixv fKflvo Kal \(tifir](r6[X6a, o T<a êv biKaCto ^4\tiov
5 (y(yvTo tu> 8e abCKto ctTrwAAuro. t/ ovbV iari tovto;
KP. Oi/iat yu)y, S) SwKpares.
212. 4>epe 8r;, eai' to imo tov vyuivov fiV îkTiov
yiyv6fXVov, vrto tov vocrcobovs b^ bia(pdi.p6fXVov dioA(ra>/i
TTl66fiVOI. fXr] TTf TUtV TTdi6vT(DV b6^T}, Upa ÛHTOV Tjfxlv koTtV
e bi(f)6apfLVov avTov; ori 8c ttov tovto (rwfxa' rj ov\C;
KP. NaC.
2X2. 'Ap' ovv ^kjdtov ifpuv iariv fxTa fxo\6rfpov Ka\
bi(f)dapfiVov (r(ap.aTos;
5 KP. OvbafX(as.
212. 'AAAa fXT ^k^Cvov Sip ijfxlv ^lo)Tov bi(l)6apfXVov,
S) To abiKov fxv Aco/3arai, t6 bi bCKaiov 6vCvr](riv; ^ (f)av\6-
Tpov r]yovfXda eivat tov (rdfiaTO^ Klvo, otl ttot coti tQv
48 r]fXTp(DV, TTpl o 1] T ddi/cia Kal ff biKaioa^vr] iarCv;
KP. Ovbafx&s.
212. 'AAAa TifLKaTcpov;
KP. noAu ye.
5 212. OvK &pa, o) /3e'ArioTe, tt6vv fjfxXv ovrca (f)povTiaTov
tC Ipovaiv ol TToAAol fffxas, dAA' ori 6 iiraKav irepi tS)V
biKaCot)v Kol abCKo)V, 6 ely Koi avn] f] &Xr]6ia. toore iTpQTov
fxkv Tavrr] ovk opdds eioTjy^, eioTjyovfieros r^s rv ttoAAui/

8o'^Tjs Seir T/fias (f)poirrCîv Trept r<Sv 8iKaia)y koi KoAuii; Ka\
10 dya^cSv koi rwr vavTCu)V. " 'AAAa fxv brf," (paCt] y av

rts, " oTo^ re l(nv fffms ol TroAAoi diroKreiwroi."
b KP. AÂa br] koI TavTa^ âCrf yap av, S) 2wKpares.

aXrjdi] A^yeis.
212. 'AAA', S) 6avfx6a-t, ovT6i re o Ao'yos ov bi\r]\v6a-

fxv Kfxoiye boKl Irt o/ioios eivai koi ir/xJrepov *cai rwde 6^
e I toCto TiB
T : toCtoe7^B:^cx*T:5 supra versum
W : h a6 t/ B in 1 oAA* St B T oAAo ti Euscbius
Eusebius : :
6 om. T a II T' B :t' >' T b âitj -fap & secl. Schanz i
b 4 iri ifioios B Priscianus a.y6fAOtos T ca2 rp6rfpo Priscianus

:
T9 Kal itpiTtpov B w cai itpirtpoi T

: t^ xpirtpo 5i T om. B
: W :
KPIT12N 48b
av (TKOTTei et ert fxeva i)\xiv ^ ov, oTt, ov to ^rjv TTfpl TrXet- 5
(jTov TTOi.r]Tov oXXa To ev îjv.
KP. 'AAAa fxevei.
212. To 8e eu nal KaXats Koi bLKaim otl tuvtov kaTLV,
yL(V(L 1] ov ixiveL;
KP. MeWt. lo
2X2. OvKOVV iK TtiiV 6fXOkoyOVfXV(t)V TOVTO (TKiTniOV,
TTOTepov bUaLov e/xe kvdivb^ TT^LpaaOaL k^LevaL fxi] a(f)LevT(i)V
'AdrjvaLoov rf ov hLKaLov Kal iav jxev (f)aLvr]TaL bCKaLov, C

TTeLpdfxeda, d b pLrj, i&pLev. hs 6e oo Aeyets tcls (rKdyjfeLS
TTfpL re ava\(o(r(t)s xpr]fxa.T(x)v Ka\ bo^s Kal TratScor Tpo^f^rjs,
fxrf 0)5 aXrfdcos TavTa, S) Kptrcor, (TKefXfxaTa r] tG)V paStcos
aiTOKTiLvvvTdiv Ka\ ava^ni(TKOfXV())v y av, et otot r' ifcrav, 5
ovb^vL ^vv V(h, TOVTOdv T&v TToXXcov. iffXLV b\ (TTeLbi] 6 \6yos

ovT(i)s aipeL, /ix?) ovbev a\Xo aKciTTiov fj
r) oTrep vvvbi] iXeyo-
fXV, TTOTepov bUaLa iTpaôfXiv Ka\ \pr]fLaTa reAowres tovtols

TOLs (fxk ivdevbc kâôv(TLv Ka\ \apLTas, koX avTo\ âyovTis d
re Ka\ kâyofxevoL, rj rf; dArjêta abLKrfaofxev TravTa TavTa
TTOLovvTS' K^v (f)aLV(afX0a abLKa avTo. epyaôfxevoL, fxi] ov
ber] vTToXoyCC^^TdaL ovt' et aTTodvrj(rKLV 8et iTapafxevovTas Ka\
r](rv\Cav ayovTas, oijTe aXXo otlovv TTCKryjeLV TTpo tov abLKtiv. 5
KP. KaAws fxiv fxoL boKiis XeycLV, S) 'E,(i)KpaTes, opa e

rt bpCifxev.
212. SfcoTrcSjaer, o) ayaOc, KOLvfj, Ka\ ei iTp ^xfi? di^ri-

XiyeLV (fxov XeyovTos, avTCXeyc KaC (tol TTeCa-ofxaL' et de fxrf, e
Traucrai r^jbr], o) fxaKapLe, ttoXXcikls fxoL X4y(t)V tov ovtov
Xoyov, b)s xph ivOivbe aKOVTôv ' A6r]vaC(i)v ejue a7TLvaL' i)s
iyu) iTp\ TToXXov TTOLOvfxaL TTeCcras cre TaijTa TrpaTTeLv, aXXa

fxif CLKOvTos. opa be brj Trjs crKe'\/Aecos Ti]V apxijv eav croL 5
lKavG)s X4yr]TaL, Ka\ TTLpQ) aTTOKpCvea^daL to po)T(t)fXvov r\ 49

av fxaXLora otr].
c 3 XPVt^^''''^^ avakdatus T c8 TeKovvTts BT marg. W :
rpiTTovTts W64 Ttiaas Buttmann : Truffai B : TCfiaat (sic) T

49 a nAATIlNOS
KP. *AAAa Treipao-ofxai.
212. Ovbfvl TpoTTO) <f>aiJiev kKOirras dibucriTôv elvai, ^

5 TLvl fjikv abiKTjTiov TpoTTia Tivl 6e ov; 7j ovdafjL(o9 t6 ye
abiKelv ovTf ayaOov ovtc koXov, ojs TroAAoKis fifjLLV Koi ev
ro) (piTTpoa-dev XP^^'^ i)p.o\oyri6r] ; [oTrep Koi apri (Keyero]
rj iraa-at fjplv e/cetrai ai -npocrOev opioKoyiai iv Tala-be roij
oA.tyais fjpepais (KKexypAvaL daiv, koX woAai, Zt KpiTcov,

lo 6.pa rq^LKoibe [yepovTfs] &.vbp(s Trpo? oAAÂous a-novbfj bia-
b Aeyo/xerot iXdOopfv ^/btas avTovs iraibuiv ovbiv bLa(f>(povT(s;

1] TTavTos pJaKXov ovtcos ^xêL &a-iT(p t6t eAeyero f]p.LV'
efre (f)aa-lv ol ttoAAoi eire /it), koI efre 6et f]p3.s (tl Toivbc
XaX(TT(oT(pa TTaaêLV e?re cai ttpaoT^pa, opuos t6 ye dStxeu'
5 rw dStKouvrt Kal KaKov kol ala-xpov Tvyx^vf*- ov irairri
Tp6iT<a; (fâpikv rf ov;

KP. fPapîv.
212. Ovbapoos &pa bd &bucflv.
KP. Ov bfJTa.
lo 212. Ovbk abLKovp(vov &pa drraduceu', oj? ol ttoAAoI

oiowai, ^TTetS^ y( ovbapMS bel dJbucdv.
C KP. Ou <f>aiv(TaL.
212. T^ bk brj; KaKovpydv bd, a> Kplruiv, ^ o&;

KP. Ov 8et br]iTov, a> 2wKpares.
212. Ti 8e'; di^tKajcoupyety KaKuts irdoxorra, $ ol
5 TToAAot <f>aa-LV, biKaLov r] ov biKaLov;

KP. Ovbap&s.
212. To ydp ttov KaKias iroLdv iafdpdtiTow rov i&LKdv
0Vb(V bLa<f>(p(L.
KP. 'AAt;^^ Aeyeiy.

lo 212. Oure apa &irrabLK(iv Sei ovt KaxQs iroulv ovbh'a
avdpTT(t)V, ov8' hv 6tiovv TrdtrxT/ vtt* avTdv. koI 5pa, <o
d KpircDr, TavTa Kadopo\oyS)v, oitu)S pi] Trapa boâv i/ioAoyfiy
a6 o6t Ka\hy otrrt oyaBiv W

Eusebius a 7 iw*p . . . ixiytra
secl. Burges a
10 -ffpovrtt secl. Jacobs ba iKtytro iifup
B Eusebitis : iiuuv tKtytro T d i KaOofioKoyiv B Eusebius Sto-
baeus : ifioKoyii T
KPlTi2N 49 d
oioa yap otl oXiyots Tial TavTa Kal boKel Kal 8ogei. ol^
ovp ovTO) bdboKTai Kai oh jJ-ri, tovtols ovk eaTL kolvt] /SotiA?/,
oAAa avdyKri tovtov? ak)\.T^K(i)v KaTa^Ppovelv 6pu)VTas akXrj-

kdiv TCi liovXevp-aTa. a-KOireL 8?) ovv Ka\ av v [j.a\a itgt- 5
pov KOLVitiveLS Kal a~vvdoKL aoL Kal ap\(idp.(6a (VTevdev

(iovkevoixevoL, ws ovbeiroTe 6p6G)S exovTos ovTe tov abLKelv
ovT Tov civTabLKeLV ovTe KttK&s Trda-xovTa aiivvea-6ai clvtl-
bpG)VTa KaK&s, 17 a(f)LaTacraL kcu ov kolv(i)Vls rrjs apxfjs;
efwl fxev yap Kal TraAat ovt(o Kal vvv eTL boKel, (ro\ be el e
> TTt] akkrj beboKTaL, keye Ka\ bCbaaKe. ei 6' ejxfxeveLS tols
TTp6a-6e, t6 fxeTa roCro aKOve.
KP. 'AAA' epifxevo) Te Ka\ crvvboKeL fxoL' akka keye.
2il. Aeyio bi] av t6 fxeTO. tovto, fxakkov 8' cpcoroi* 5
TTOTepov a av tls ofxokoyrfcrrf rw biKaLa ovTa TTOLrjTeov r;
eâTrarT/reov;
KP. rioirjreoy.
212. 'Ek tovt(i)v 87/ &6peL. dLTTLOvTes ev6ivbe rffxels fxrf
TTeCcravTes Trfv iTokLV TTOTepov KaK&s TLvas TTOLOvfxev, Ka\ 5

Tavra ovs rfKLara bei, 77 ov; Ka\ efxfxevofxev ols oi^fxokoyif-
(Tafxev biKaCoLS ov^tlv rf ov;
KP. OvK eyo), a> 2a>/cpares, aTTOKpCva(r6aL Trpos 6 epa^Tas'
ov yap ivvoS). 5
SH. 'AAA' cSSe (TKoVei. ei pLekkov(nv rjfxlv kvdevbe elre

aiTobLbpdaKeLV, eW ottoos bel ovofxacraL tovto, ek66vTes 01
vofxoL Ka\ t6 kolvov rffs TrdAeco? eTriorayre? epoivTo- " EiTre'
fioi, 0) "EdKpaTes, tC ev y<S exfts Troteti'; aAAo rt rf roj^ro)
rw epyw w eTTtxeipets bLavofj tovs re vopovs rjfxas d.TToke(raL b

Kat (TVfXTTaaav TTfv TTokLV To cr6v fxepos; rf boKeZ ctol olov re
ert eKeCvrfv Trfv TTokLV eTvaL Ka\ fxrf d.vaTeTpd(f)6aL, (v rj hv
al yevofxevaL 8tKat fxrfbev L(r-)(y(i)(rLV dkka V7t6 ibLioTcov CLKvpoC
re yCyvdiVTaL koX bLa(})6eCp(ovTai;" tC ^povfiev, u) KpCTo^v, 5
d4 oAA-^\a!j' Ttt T To aW-fjXwv B : d 5 5r) ovv B: ovy Sri T

d8 avTiSpwyras T b 3 ai' T W om. B b 4 l(rxvu(Ttv B T W
:
bj "îiyvwvTat Sia(p6(ipw./r at T
. . . yiyuo^/rat Sia(p9fipovTai B W
: . . .
5ob nAATllNOS
irpoi Tavra koI &XXa Toiavra; TToXXa yap &v rts ^X"*
&\X(OS T Kal pr\Tlt>p, flTTflv VTTfp TOVTOV TOV VOfWV illToWv-
fxevov 6s Tas biKas tos bi,Ka(rd(C(ras TTpoardTTei Kvplas elvai.
C fi ipovfxev TTpos avTovs 5ti " 'H8^k(i yap Tjfias ij ttoKis koX
ovK opdQs TTjv biKrfv iKpivv; " TavTa rj tC ipovfxev;
KP. Tavra vrj ACa, Si ^(aKpaTfs.
21. T^ oHv hf (l7r(t>a-iv ol vofxov *"i2 SwKpaTes, 17
5 kolL TavTa ufxoXoyrfTo rffuv t Kal aroC, ^ ipLfifvdv Tals

bCKais als ^v rj ttoAis SiKti^T/;" d ovv avT(av davfJMôififv
XfydvTOiv, 10-0)5 hv fliroifv ori '"i2 ^(aKpaTfs, firj Oavfxa^f
To. \(y6fx(va AAA' hiTOKpCvov, lirfvbr] Kal euDdas Xpr\(T6ai
Tw ipoiTav Tc Kal aiTOKpCv(rdat,. <t>^pf 7^9 "^^ iyKakS>v
d fffxZv KOX Tff TTOkfl ilTIXflpfls rjfxas ilTToWvvai; OV ITpiiTOV
fxiv a-f iy(vvrf(rafX(V rffxds, Kal 81' r)fxa>v lAa/3e Trfv fxrfTfpa
aov 6 TTaTTfp Kal i(}>vTV(r4v (re; (}>pdaov ovv, tovtois rffxdv
Tols VOfXOlS Tols TTCpl TOVS yafXOVS fiffJ-^fyrj Tt 0)5 ov KaXbis
5 ^xov(riv;" " Ov fxifx(\>ofxai," (fâCrjv &v. "'AAAa Tots irepi
TTfV Tov yevofxivov Tpo(f>rfv Te xai TratSetW iv fj
Koi av
iiTaibevdrfs ; rf ov KaAcds iTpo^TiTaTTov rffX(ov ol iirl Tovna
TfTayfxfvoi vofxoi, TTapayyikXovTfs Toi TraTpt t^ <ro) ai iv
e fxovcTLKr] Koi yvfxva^rriKff TTaibcvfiv;" " KaAws," <}>aCrfv &v.
"Eicy. ^7ret87; 8^ iyivov Te Kot i^(Tp(!L(f>rfs Kal iiTatb(v6rfs,
Hxois hv (liTdv TTpS>TOV fxkv o)S ovyjL rffX(T(pos â-Oa Kal (Kyovos
Ka\ 8oi3Aos, avTos Te Kat ol <roi Tipoyovoi.; koI d Tovd^ ovto)S
5 eêt, S/)' i^ to-ov oUi dvai <roi t6 8iKatov Kai rffilv, kol &tt
&v ffpids (r( iiTV)((ip5>fx(v iTOidv, koX (rol TavTa &VTnToidv
oiet 8Katoi; etvat; fj irpos fxkv &pa <roi tov TtaTipa ovk e
frrov rfv to bCKatov Kal irpos b^^riTOTrfv, d <rot o)i' iTvyxav(V,
U>(TT( &TT(p TtAcTXOIS TOVTa KoX ixVTlTTOldv, OVT( KaKO)S aKOV-
b 8 S/km Tctj T b W : om. B c i ifilK*i\ iXiKu Hein<lorf

C 5 iuufffTv Stephanus : iuixiyfiv B : ift.nfvfiv T da fKafif TW :
iXanBavtv B <i 4 tojj vofiots secl. Slallbaum cl 7 Vl rovr^ T

ex tTil TovTO : iitl toCtois B <i 8 v6fiot sccl. Stallbaum e i koI
B : Kol fvT e 8 Sfaw^Triv W
rhv StairiTrjv B T ^se<l rhv punctis
:
notatum in T)
KPITI2N 5ia
ovTa hvTikiydV ovtc Tvirroêvov avTiTVTrrîv ovtc aXka 5^

TOMVTa TroXka' Trpbs be ttjv iraTpiba &pa Kal tovs yo/u,oi;s
eêWai o-ot, uxTTe, eAv o-e iTnxtpciixv rjfxels aTtokXxivai
bUaiov r]yovp.(voL (TvaL, Kal av 8e 17/xa? tovs vopovs Kal
Trfv TtaTpCba KaO^ oaov bvvaa-ai 6771X^^7'^^'^ avTaTroXkvvai, 5
Kal (f)ria-eLS TavTa iroLSiV biKaLa TrpaTT^LV, 6 rr/ akrjOeLa Trjs
apfTrjs (TrLix(k6fXVos; rj ovtoos ei a-oipos (oore kekrjdcv (re
OTL firjTpos re Kal iraTpbs Kal tS>v akkoov npoyovinv aTTavTcov

TLp.LtiiTep6v kaTLV TTaTpls Kal a-p.v6Tpov /cat ayLUiTepov
Kol iv p.L(pvL poLpa KoX TTapcL dôls Kal Trap' avOpUtlTOLS b
roi? vovv exowo-i, Kai a^îaOaL 8et Kat puakXov vttlklv Kal
6oiTTVLV TTaTpLba âkfTTaLVOVO-aV ?/ TTaTipa, KOL rj TTl6LV ?/
iroteri' h hv KeAein/, Kai Trao-xety idv tl TTpoaTaTTrj iTadfZv

r)arv\Lav ayovTa, edjrre TVTTTiadat, idvT bdaâL, earre et? 5
TTokffxov dyr) Tpoi6r]a-6p.Vov 7/ dTTo6avovp.VOV, iTOLrfTfov
TavTa, Kal t6 bUaLov ovtms eêt, Kat oi^xi vttlktov ovbf
dva\cop7]Tiov ovh\ keLiTTfov ttjv Ta^LV, dkka Kal iv 7roAe'/x(j)
Kai V bLKacrrrjpLia Ka\ TTavToyov TTOLrjTôv a av Kck^vrj 7/
TTokLS Kal r} TTaTpLS, 7/ 7Tl6lv avTrjV rj to biKaLov 7re'0i;Ke* C

/3tdêo-0ai 8^ ovx. oaLov ovt p.r\Tpa ovt TTaTpa, irokv 8e
TovT<ov TL rJTTov Tr]V TTaTpiba;" Ti cf)r]a-ofXV iTpos TavTa, 00
KpiTcov; dkr]6r] kiy^LV tovs vdfxovs 7/ ov;

KP. "E/xotye SoKet. 5
**
212. SKOTret Toivvv, S) ^(aKpaTs," (f)alv dv Xacas ol
v6fxoi, " et f]p.LS ravTa dkr]6i] kyofXv, otl ov 8tKaia rjfxds

e7rt)(etpets bpdv h vvv iTTix^Lpcls. ^/xeiy ydp o-e yvvrf(ravTs,
K6p\j/avTs, TTaLbva-avTs, p.Tab6vTs aTTavTcov 0)V otoi r'
r]fXV Kakiov (rol Kal Tols dkkoLS iTda-LV TTokiraLS, o/xcos 7rpo- d
ayopvofXv rw iôvaiav iT^TTOLrfKivai 'A6r]vaiQ)v tSi l3ovkofXV(o,
&s e|'(TTajl farai Schanz a^ Se] 7 al. Schanz a^ Vti

T : fariv -^ B : om. Stobaeus b^ iroT/>o] iroTepo /cal firiTfpa
Stobaeus fi ireiddv secl. Schanz b 4 &] ^ Stobaeus
b6 irot-nTfa W Stobaeus b9 & &c vel &v Stobaeus
jf c i kcU
B : Tt Ka\ T tj Kal irfiQfiv Stobaeus ^ rh om. Stobaeus
5id nAATXlNOS
(ircibav 6oKifia<r9ff koI tbri ra iv rrj noKa -npayfxaTa koi
7//xa? rovs vofjiovs, w hv fJirj ap4(rK0ifjifv fjfjifli, (^dvai. Kajioirra
? To. avTov aTTUvai ottoi hv ôvkrfTai. koX ov6eiy i]fj.5iv TQiv
vofJMiv kfXTTohiav iamv ou8' 6.TTayopevei, idwf tis ôvkrfTai

vfxutv cis aTtoiKiav Uvai, el /bt?/ api<TKoifKv rffids t( Kal ?/
TToAis, iavTf ixfToi,Klv aWo(r4 ttoi (\&<av, uvai ^Kela-f oiroi
e &v ôvkrfTai, (\ovTa to. avTov. bs 8' hv Vfx<av TmpafjLfCvrf,
opStv ov TpoTTov fffxeis Tas re bUas biKaCojxfv koI roAAa tt}v
.^ TTokiv btoiKovfXfv, rjbrf (pafjiev tovtov îxoXoyr]K(vat (py<a fffxuf
h hv fjfxdi K(\(V(afx(v TroLrj<r(iv ravTO, Kal rbv fxr) TT(i.66fx(vov
5 Tptxff <f)afx(v abiKdv, ori re yfvvrjToXs ov<riv fffxXv ov tt(1-
6(Tai, Koi OTL Tpo<f>(v<TL, Kttl OTi 6fjM\oyi^<ras fffxlv TT(L<rrdat
ovT iT(C$(Tai ovT Tr(Cd(i fifJMS, (l fxff KoAws rt iroiovfx^v,
52 TTpoTtd(VT(i)v fffxCiiV Kal ovK dypio)? imTaTTovTcov iroKtv h av

K(K(v<afX(v, dAAa (<f)t(VTUiv bvotv 6aT(pa, rf TT(t6(tv fffxas fj
TTOtdv, TovT<iiV ovbiT(pa TTOKt. TavTats b^ <fiafx(v Koi <r(, w

^<aKpaT(s, Tais alTtais iv(^T6ai, (i7T(p TTotrf(r(i.s h (TTivods,
5 Kal ov\ f]Kt<TTa 'A6rfvat(iiV <t(, oAA' kv toIs /xaAi(7Ta." d ovv
eya> diTOtfxf " Aia tC 8^;" i<r<iis &v fxov btKaCoiS KaâTiToivTo
X.(yovT(S oTi iv Tots /xdAtcrra \\6rfvaC(iiV iy<ii avToXs bifxoKo-

yrfKOis Tvyx(iV(ti Tar/rqv Tf]v ofxoXoytav. <fiat(v yap hv ori
b "'li "SiâKpaT^s, /xeydAa f]fxtv TovToiV TfKfxrfpta (<mv, ort o-oi
xai fffxds r]p(<TK0fX(v KaX 7/ 7ro'Aty ov yap av TTorc T<av dAAtor

'Adr]vaC(iiv aTT(iVT(tiV bta<f)(p6vT(iiS iv avri] imbrjfxds d fxrf <roi
bta(f)(p6vT(iiS fjp(a-K(V, Kat ovt ^tti 6((iiptav tt^Lttot (k tt]s

5 TrdAecos i^f]kd(s [, ori fxfj aiTa^ ds '\crd]x6v,] ovt( akko<r(
ovbafx6<T(, d fxT) TTOi aTpaT(V(r6fX(vos, ovt( &Wr]v StiTobrjfxCav
(TTOtr](r(ii "TrwTTore &a^(p 61 dAAot &.vdp(iiiTOi, ov6' (iTidvfxCa a(

dAAj/s TrdAfojy ovb( oAAcoz' vofxoiv (kajS^v (ib(vai, akka 17/xctf
ds. 6 col$ov\vru
. . . : om. B B'TW
d8 -01 B'TW: om, B
a6 M. Schmidt
6jLo\oyri<ras] ifida-as fifui> rtianrdai W : ijfj.!^ wtl$fir$at
B H fi^p xtlOfaOau Tb ^ fi^v -rtivtffOai Buttmann
: : a 3 om. B
b 3 (1 /u^ ^p*<rKtv secl.
Cobet b 5 Srt ^j^ . . . 'I<r0/Lu$f add. T
et in marg. om. Bw sed legit Athenaeus
: W b6 iwoiiiati
iwoSrinltw T b 7 iWoi B : om. T
;
KPITI2N 52 c
(Toi LKavol ^fiV Kol T} TjixfTepa TToS.is' GVTOi (Tcpobpa T/f/as c

ripov Kal &/ioAoyis Kad' rjfms iroXiTevafcrOat, tcl re aAAa Kal
TTaiba^ V avrr^ ^TTOiTjfra), &>? apa-Kova~qs aoL ttjs TToXecos. eTL
Toivvv V avTTj TTJ 8tK7/ i^rjv aoL (f)vyrjs Tiprjo-aaOaL et fjSov-
\ov, Kal OTTcp vvv oKova-rjs rfjs TroAecos (TTLXd-pfts, TOTe 5
kKovarjs TTOLi](raL. oa; St rore pLev (KaKXonTTLôv oj? ovk aya-

vaKTGiV t 8eoi TedvavaL ae, aXXa rjpov, oos ecf^rjaOa, iTpo rrjs
(f>vyrjs OdvaTov vvv be ovt eKeivovs tovs Xoyovs ai(rxvvr],
ovTe r}pGiV t&v v6fji(nv ivTpeiTr], eTTLxeLpGiv hLa^pOelpaL, Trpar-
rei? re airep hv SouAoy 6 (fâvkoTaTos TTpaêLev, aTTohLhpaa-KeLV d

eiTLyeLpGiv Trapa Tas a~vv6riKas re Kal tcls dfioXoyias koO' hs
i]pLV (Tvvedov TToAtreveo-âi. iTpwTov pev ovv ripXv tovt avro
aiTOKpLvaL, ei aXr]dr] kdyofxev (fxKTKOVTes ae copioXoyqKevaL
TToKiTeva-ea-daL KaO^ rjfms fpy^ oAA' ov Aoyw, rf gvk dAtj^T/." 5
rt (f)u)fxev rrpos TavTa, S) KpiTcov; oAAo rt rj ofiokoyGtfiev
KP. ÂvdyKT], S) ^coKpaTes.

2i2. " "AAAo ri ovv," hv (JHuev, " t) crvvBrfKas Tas Trpbs
ffpias avTovs Kal opokoyias TTapaâiveLS, ovx vtto av(iyKr]s e
6ju,oAoy7/o-as ovde a-iTarqOeLS ovbe eV oAtyo) XP*''^*^ avayKaa-dels
fiovXevaaadaL, dAA' ev eTe^rtv e^bop.r]KovTa, ev dts e^v croi
aiTLevaL, ei fxr] rfpeaKOfiev rjfxeis P-r]be Stxatat ecfjaivovTO (roi
ai ofxoKoyiaL etmt. av be ovTe AoKebaipova TTpor,pov ovTe 5
KprfTTfv, hs bir] eKaaroTe (f^rjs evvopelcrOaL, cnrre aXXrfv ovbe-
fxiav T(ov *EAA7jyt8<oy TroAecor ovhe tG)v âpâpLK&v, oKXa 53

eAdrrco k^ avrrjs aTTebr]fxr]a-as r] oi xîaXoi re Kat TV(f)XoL Kal
oi oAAot ovdTrqpoi' ovto) ctol bLacfêpovToos t5)V aXXoiV ÂOrf-
vaioov TfpecrKev rj ttoXls re Kai r]p.eLS ot vopoL hf]Xov otl' Tivt
yap hv ttoXls dpecrKOL dvev vopxav; vvv he bi] ovk eppevels 5
rots (i)fxoXoyr]pLevoLS ; eav fjpuv ye ireiOr], S) ^coKpaTes' Kai

ov KaTayeXaaTos ye ear] eK Tijs TToXeo^s eêXddv.
C2 iroKiTfvfffffeai
B T
B : voKiTeveffBou T W d i 6 T Eusebius om. B :
ds /iev : otn. Eusebius d^ woKiTevafa-dai T -rroKiTeveadai B

:
e 5 5 B Tf T : a I oCTt tuv fiap0xpu)i> T a 7 ye T re B

(sed ex emend.) W :
53a nAATi2N02
" ^KOTTd yap brj, ravTa TTapaâs Ka\ fâyuapravuiv ri
TovTcov Ti ayadov ipyaa-jj aavTov rj tovs TTt,Tr]beiovs tovs

b a-avTov. OTL piev yap Kivbvv(vaova-C yi crov o\ CTTiT^Sfiot koi
avrol (f>evyiv Kal aTpr]di]vai. t^s iToX.ecDS rj rrfv ova-Cav

d.TToK4a-ai, a-)(êb6v Ti brjKov avrbs be iTpSiTov fiv iav ds
Tiov (yyvTaTo. Tiva TToKnav ^KOrjs, rf 0rj/3a^(E r] Mfyapdbe
5 (vvopLovvTai yap i.ix(f>6Tpai TToKefxios ij^fis, S) SwK/xxres, tt/
TOVTCOV TToKlTfCq, Kttl âOlTTfp KTTjboVTai TUiV avT&v tt6K(cov
V7Tol3K4\froirraC cre bia(f)6opia rjyovpifvoi tS)V v6pL(iiV, Kal ê-

/3aoo-eis tois btKaaTals ttjv b6âv, doore boKflv 6p6S>s r?;r
C bCKr]v bLK6.(raL' ootls yap v^jxaiv bLa(f>6opevs eoTiv (T^6bpa
TTOv b6^LV ^v vecov y Kal avorjTctiV av^pixHTOiV bLa(pdop(vs
(TvaL. TT^Tepov ovv (f)v^r] Tas re ivvop.ovp.ivas 7roA.ets KaX
Tuiv avbpSiV Tovs Kocrp.LO)TdTovs; Kal tovto ttolovvtl apa a^L6v
5 a-oL Cw ô-TaL; r] TrATjo-tao-ei? tovtols Kal dvaL(rxyvTr](r(LS
biaKey^pievos rtVay Koyovs, S ^(OKpaTes; t] ova-TTfp iv6db(,
a)s r] dpiTT] Kal fj bLKaLoa-vvr] ttK(C(ttov d^LOV tols dv6p^TT0LS
Ka\ To. v6iiL]xa KOL ol v6]xol; Ka\ ovk ol(L aa)(r]]xov [hv]
d (f)av(Xa-daL oUadaC y( XPV- oAA'

to tov ^coKpdTovs irpdyjxa;
(K ]x(v TovTOiV tG)V T^TTitiv diTapds, rj^ds b( (LS Q(TTaKCav
TTapd Tovs îvovs tovs KpCToivos; (K(l yap br] TrAeio-nj aTa^Ca
Ka\ dKoKaaCa, /cat la-ois av rjbions aov dKovoL(v &)S y(KoCoiS
5 iK Tov b(a-]xoiTqpCov d7T(bCbpa(rK(s a-K(vi]v t( TLva tt(pl6(]X(vos,

rj bL(fid(pav KafioiV */ oAAa ola 8^ (l(a6aa-LV (va-K(vdC(a-6aL ot
dTTobLbpdrrKovT(s, /cat to (txvp-O- t6 cravTov ]X(TaKKdâs' ori
b( yipoiv dvr]p, (rp.LKpov xpdvov roi /3ta) Kolttov ovtos ws to
e et/co'?, (T6K]xr]a-as ovToi yKLO-xpois iTTL^vixdv Cv^> v6pL0vs tovs
p.(yCa-Tovs TTapajHds, ovb(\s os (pd; laois, dv ixt] Tiva Kvirfjs'
(L b( fxrj, dKovai], a> Sw/c/xirfy, TroAAa Kai dra^ta aavTov.
a 8 ilaixaprCiv T C 5 iffn aoi ^f T c 8 &i' 6 om. T :
Eusebius da rîruv B Eusebius 7r6\fO)v T d^ rovs Kpi- :
ruvos B Eusebius rov Kplruvos T : d 7 >itTaA\o|os T Eusebius :
KaraWdâs B e I oStu yKKrxpHs T (in marg.) Eusebius W :
oStcos aiaxpSis B W
yp, oBt< y aiffxpais in marg. t
:
KPITflN 536
VTTpxoiJ.V09 brj jSicoo")] TrdvTas avOpwTrovi koX hovkevdiv

ri TtoiGiV r} (vcoxovixfvos iv frraAia, tScTTrep cm belirvov 5
aTTobfbrifxrjKCtis eis erraAiay; Aoyoi 8e iKdvoi, ol irepl
biKaioaijvris re Kat rrjs oAAr/s ap(ri]s ttov r]p.lv taovTai; aAAa 54

8^ tG)V iraiboiv VKa ôvKn ^rjv, Iva avrovs eK6p4\j/ris Kal
TTaibevcrris ; ri 8e; ets erraAiay avrovs ayayoiv 6p4\j/i.s re
Kal TTaibV(ri.s, ^Vovs TroiT/o-as, tva Ka\ tovto aTTokava-u>a-Lv;
r) TovTO fj.V ov, avTov 8e Tp<f)6jXV0L a-ov ^CdVTOs y3e'Arioy 5
6p\lfovTaL Kal TratSevo-orrai [xr] avvovTos aov avTols, ol yap

e7rtr7/8etot ot o"ot iTTLjxeXrjaovTaL avTu>v; iroTepov iav eis
erraAtay 0-77087/ /xtjo-t/s, eTri/xeA^/o-oyrai, av 8e eis "AtSou

aTTobr]ixi]a-r]s, ov)(l TTLp.kr]a-ovTaL; etTrep ye' ri 6<pXos avTG>v
(OTLV tG)V aoL (jiaa-KOVTCov 7TLTr]bL0i}V eimt, ouadaC ye XP"!- ^)
" 'AAA', o) 2(riK/)ares, Tretô^/xero? ^/xty rots o-ois TpoiêvaL

}xr]T Traiây Trept TrAetoro? Trotov prjT^ t6 ^rjv ]xrJT oAAo
fxrjbev TTpo Tov bLKaiov, tva ets "Atôu iXdwv ex>/? TTavTa
Tavra a7roAoy7/o-ao-âi roiy exei apxova-LV ovt yop ivddbe 5
o-oi (paLVTaL TavTa TTpdrrovTL d]XLvov eirat oii8e bLKaioT^pov

ovbe 6aL(i)Tpov, ovb oAAfa) tS)V a^v ovbevC, ovt e/ceto-e
a.(f)LKop.V(a dfXLvov eorai. dAAa vvv fxv -^bLKrjfxevos oTret,
av 07717/ s, ovx v(f)' r]fxG)V tG)V v6fxo)V dWd vtt' dv^pcoiTcov' C

dv 8e ^k6i]s ovTo)s alaxpcos dvTabLKriaas re koi dvTLKa-
Kovpyrfo-as, Tas (ravTov 6/xoAoytas re koi (rvv6r]Kas Tas irpos
r]fxds TTapa^ds Kal KaKa pya(rdfXVos tovtovs ois rJKLaTa
e8et, o-airroi' re koi (pCkovs kol iTaTpiba Kal rjpds, r]fXLS re' 5
o-ot xaAeTrarou/iey ^wirri, Kai eKet 01 f]pi.TpoL a8eA<|)0t ot iv
"Aibov vdfxoL ovK vixvo)s (Tc VTTobcôvTaL, ei8orey ort KOt
rifjd.s TTXipria-as dTToXiaaL t6 a6v fxepos. dkXd fxt] cr
TTiar] KpiTOiv ttollv d Ae'yet fxdkkov r] 7//xets." d

TaiSra, o) (f)Lk cratpe Kptrcor, eu lo-^t ori eyo) SoKoi
e4 viTfpx^fifVos B Eusebius iirtxdl^fvoi T Kavras a.vdpciirovi

W
:
PtdiTfi T a 4 Tovro BT : tovto crov a 7 iav B : (av

fify T b 4 irph secl. Cobet ToCra irdyTa T Eusebius b7 ovSk
6<TiuTfpoy T Eusebius oi/Te 6(nciTfpoy B
:
54d nAATIlNOS KP1T12N
aKovdv, ojaiTep oi KopvâvriSiVTCi ratv aiKSiv boKovtnv
6,KOV(iv, KoL iv iiiol avrr] f] tjx^ tovtmp Tb>v koycav ôfx^d
6 Kol TTOiei fXT] bvva(r6aL Tutv aXkuiV &.koviv aXKa Xa-di, wra yf
Tu vvv ifJ.ol boKovvra, (hv kfypî Ttapa TavTa, pjXTtfv ipfU.
opuas fiivToi (t Ti olei TiKiov TToaja-fiv, X.ey(.
KP. 'AAA', a> Sw/cpaTfs, ovk cx^ Aeyeir.
e 211. "Ea Toivvv, 2 KpiTcor, Ka\ TTpaTTuifKV Tavrrf, ivfibrj
ravTif 6 6e6s wftrfyelTai.
d6 ^0;- BT : idfTt^Wt: ws iav W >5 s. v.)

W
ÂIAXIN
EXEKPATH2 *AIAi2N St. I

P.57
EX. AvTos, a> âLb(DV, TrapyVov StoKpdrei (Keivrj rf} a
T)fi4pq ^ t6 câpp.aKOV iiri^v kv roi bea-ncoTrjpLta, ij akkov tov
iJKOva-as;
<1>AIA. AvTos, w 'E)(eK/)are?.
EX. Ti ovv bri (oTiv aTTa (iTrev 6 avi]p irpo tov 6ava- 5
Tov; Kal 7j-&)s tTfXevTa; rjhiois yap.av eycb aKOva-aLfU, Kal
ycp ovTc [tS)V TToAirwz'] ^XeLao-Ciov ovbels Trdvv tl TTL\ai)pLa^L
Tb, vvv ÂOrjvaC^, ovt tls ^Vos a(f>lKTaL \p6vov a-uxvov

(Keldev ooTLS av -tjiJLLv o-a<p4s tl dyyetAat olos t ^v Trept b
TovTUiV, Tikriv ye br] otl (f)dpfJLaKov TTLOiV dTToOdvoL' rSiV 8e
dAAcoi; order eiêy (f>pdîv.
ÂIA. Ovbe TCL Trept Trjs 81x779 dpa fTTvdecrOe ov Tpoirov 58

(y(V(To;
EX. Nat, TavTa piev rjp.LV tjyyeLke tls, Kal (6avp.dôpv
ye ort TrdAat y(vop.(vr]s avrfjs itoWSt voTepov (fiaLVfTai
aTTodavdov. tl ovv rjv tovto, a> 'PaLboiv; 5
4>AIA. Tvxr] tls avri^, S) 'Exef/actres, crvvcjBr]' (tvx^v

yap rf/ TrpoTepaLq ttjs 81x77? ^7 irpvpiva (crT(}j.p(vr] tov tt\olov
o ei? Afjkov Â6r]vaLOL T:(p.TTOWLV.
a2 tirifv To (pa.pu.aKov W SL 6 iyu B om. T a 7 Twy iroKi-

W
:
tHv secl. V. Bainberg : ^\iafflwv secl. Schaefer b i a.irayy(7\ai

^v B : ?j T a 5 oZv B : om. T a8 ittfi.irovffiv BT : irifnrovaiv
Kar' Iros B'
58a nAATi2N02
EX. TovTo b hr] tC iariv;
10 AIA. ToCt' loTi To TiXoXov, ois (\>a<rw ÂOrjvaloi, iv ^
&ri(rvs TtoTe ds Kpi^rjv tovs " hh iTrra " iKfCvovs ^X^to
^
b 6.ytiiv Kal iauxri re Ka\ avroi icrcadr]. rw ovv AttoWiovi
rjvâjrro uts A^yerat t6t, el (roidfuv, kK<i.(rTov (tov9 daopCav
aTT&îiv eh Arj\ov' rjv br) afl Kal vvv cri i^ ^KtCvov Kar
iviavTov tS> êu) Trc/xTrouo-ir. iTTfi.bav ovv ap^divrai rfjs
5 detapCai, vofios icrrlv avrois iv rw \p6v<a Tovrto Kadapevftv

TTjv Tr6\iv Kal brjfxocrCa pLrjbeva aTTOKT(ivvvai., irplv av (h
6'
ArjKov T a(f>CKr]Tai to ttKoiov Ka\ iTaXa> bfvpo' tovto
ivCoTf iv TTo AA<S xP^ro) yCyvrraL, otov Tv\(ii(Tiv &vim)i Atto-
C Aa/3o'yres avrovs. ^' ^*""* '^^ OaopCas iiTeibav 6
apx^
ifpevs Tov 'ATrdAAcovos otcx/^t; tt^v iTpvpvav tov ttKoCov
TOVTo 8' (Tvxev, uxriTep kiyui, Trj irpoTepaCti r^s bCKr\s yfyo-
vos. bia Tavra' K(u ttoAvj xpovos iyevero rw ScoKpcirei iv
5 roi be(rp.(M>rqpC(o 6 fxera^v Tijs bCKr]s re Ka\ tov Oav6.Tov./

EX. T^ b\ br\ To. TTep\ avTov rhv ddvarov, a> âCbdiv; tC
Tfv Ta keyOivTa koX TTpa\6evTa, Ka\ rCves oi napayev6p.evot.
tS>v iiTLTr]beC(jiV t^ drbpC; 7/ ovk elu>v oi ap\oirres iTapelvai,
dAA' ^prjfxos irekevTa <f>C\(i>v;
d AIA. OvbafxS>9, dAAa TTaprj^rdv Tives, Ka\ ttoWoC ye.
EX. Tavra br^ TTairra TTpo6vfxri6r}Ti i>s (ra<^'(rraro rjfxu/
aTTayyelXai, el /xtj tCs a-ot i.(rxo\Ca rvyxavei ov(ra.

4>AIA. 'AAAa (rxoAdô) ye koI ireipa^rofxai. Vfuv birf-yrf-
5 (ra(rdai.' Ka\ yap to fxefxvii(r6ai ^(oKpArovs Ka\ avTov Af yoiTa

Ka\ aAAou aKovovTa efxoiye 6.e\ ttomtôv rjbKrrov.
EX. 'AAAa p.rfv, S> âCbcov, Koi tovs aKOV(rofxevovs ye

TOLOVTOvs erepovs ex(i-S' dAAo iTeipS> s h.v bvinj aKpilie-
oTora bieê\6elv Trdrro.
e <1>AIA. Ka\ fxrfv eyu>ye davfx<i(na eiTadov TTapayev6p.evos.

ovT yap ws 6avaT(o Trap^vTa fxe avbpos iiTiTrfbeCov e\eos
a II iroT OijcTfi/j W b7 T B om. T c6 t( ^r BT: rtra

W
:
i|v B'W d4 7 B: T T d8 irtf>out BT: irc^povs

d9 5ic{(A07*' B : iit\ef7t> T
AIAX2N 58 e
(lajief (vbaifxcov ydp iioi avi]p ((paivero, S> 'ExeKparej, Kal

Tov TpoTTov Kol t5)v Xoyuiv, b)s dSedJs' Koi yevvaCois ercAevra,
uxrre px>i Klvov itapiaTaa-Oai pLj]V ets "Athov lovTa avev 5
OeCas jxoLpas Uvai, aXXa Kal KL(T acpiKopievov (v npa^^LV .
yctTrep TLs Trw-jrore Ka\ aXKos. 8ta 8^ TavTa ovh\v Trdvv [xoi 59
eX.Lvbv ilcrqeL, o)? eiKos av boêLev elvat TtapovTL irivdeL,
ovTe av TjbovT] o)? ev (f)L\oa-o(f)La r]p.5)V ovtojv uia-Trep el<))6ep.ev

Kai yap ol \6yoL tolovtoC TLves rja-av dAA.' aTexv&s
aTOTTov tC p.oL TTados Trapi]v KaC tls dridr]s KpdaLS diTO Te ttjs 5
r]bovrjs avyKeKpapLevT] opiov Kal diro Trjs Xvirqs, ev6vp.ovpev(o
OTi avrCKa eKelvos e/xeAAe TeXevTav. Kal TrdvTes ot TrapovTes

a\eb6v TL ovTo) bLeKeCp.e6a, TOTe fxev yekS)VTes, evCoTe be
baKpvoirres, els be r]p.G)V koX bLa<pep6vT(i)s, ' AiroW^bcopos

dta^â ydp ttov tov dvbpa koX tov Tpd-nov avTov. b
EX. riojs' ydp ov;
AIA. 'EKeiro'? re toCwv TTavTaTTaa-LV ovrcos eL\ev, Kal
avTos iy(i)y ^TeTapdyixrjv Kal ol oAAot.
EX. "EiTvxov be, S) âCbo^v, TCves TTapayevopLevoL; 5
AIA. Ovt6s Te brj 6 'A7roAAo8a)/3os TOiv eTTLyot)pC(t)v
Traprjv Kal KpiTO/SouAoy Kal 6 iraTqp avrov kcu eTL 'EpjjLoye-

vr]s Kal *FiTTLyevr]s Kal Alay^Cvrjs Kal 'AvTLcrdevr^s' r]V be Kal
Krqa-LTTTTOS 6 Ilatartei/S' Kat Meveêvos Kal dAAoi TLves tS)V
eiTL\(j)pC(i)v. YlXdT(DV be olp.aL r](rdevet, 10
EX. EevoL be TLves iTaprja-av;

4>AIA. Nat, 2tju/itas re ye 6 07j/3atoy Kat Kej3r]s Kal c
4>ai8cdi;87/s Kat Meyapo'êy EvKAei8?7S re Kai Tep^^Ccov.
EX. Ti 8e; 'AptoTtTTTros Kat KAeo/x/3poro? iTapeyevovTo;
4>AIA. Ov br]Ta' ev AlyCvr] ydp eXeyovTo elvat.
e 3 av^p B d : avijp T
W64
ray \iywv B' T W : rov \6yov Bt
e 5 &(Tre fioi B r : wffr' e/xo(7 irapitTTaaOat fKtivoy W et transp.
signis fecit T a 6 airh B om. T a 8 r6rf T drt B t^
: : : W
b 7 KpirofiovAos T 6 KpiroôvKos B
b 1 1 5 om. pr. T
:
c i re B T om.
ai/rov B T avrov Kpirwv B'
c 2 <paiîi)v^r)s B* T
: W
: W
âtSoictST;; B W :
PLATO, VOL. I. 6
59 c nAATliNOS
5 EX. 'AAAos 8e rts napfjv;
4>AIA. SxeSor n oi/xai tovtovs itapayevia-OaL.
EX. T^ ovv hrf; rtvfs (f^rjs rj(rav oi Ao'yoi;
ÂIA. 'Eyw o-oi (^ CLpxT]^ irdvTa TTdpacrop.ai. biT]yTi<ra-

d a-Oai,. ^1 ya/) brf koI ras Tipoa-Qfv fffjJpas elddf/xev tf)oiTav
Kal iyoii Kal oi cfAAot Trapa tov 2a)KpdT7j, OTÂAeyd/ierot
eu>6V eh to hiKaarrqpiov iv w Kai 17 hUr] (yivtTO' TtX.râiov
yap r^jv tov bearpiMTrjpiov. TtfpupAvop.v ovv kKaoTOTi lcos

5 ^voiyOelr] to hea-fxooTripiov, hiaTp((iovT9 fJ-fT^ dAAr/Actiz^, av((a-
yeTo yap ov Trpwi' eTretSr; 8e dfotx^ctr/, (iarjfKV Trapa tov

2)a)Kpdrr; xat to, jtoAXo birfft^pevofjiaf /ler' avrou. Kai brf Kal
t6t TTpioaCTfpov a~vv(X(yrjfj.(V' Trf yap TrpoTepaCa [rffi^pq]
e eTretS^ e^r/Aô/xey iK tov heapicarqpCov ka-nepa^, ^TwOofKda

OTt t6 irkolov iK Arf\ov a<î.ypAvov (Irf. TraprfyyfCKafKV ovv
dAAr/Aoi? i^Kety ws irpiâCTaTa (h t6 (luiOos. Kal rfKOfKV Ka\
Tfpiv (^(Xdcov 6 Ovpotipos, 6aTT(p (iu>6(i. inraKovdV, (2tt(V irept-
5 p.^v(iv Kot ftr/ TrpoT^pov irapUvai ^toy hv avros KeAevoT/*
" Avovo-t ydp," i(f>rf, "01 (vh(Ka ScdK/jdrr/ Kai irapayy^Wovaiv
OTTcos av rf/8e tjj yffUpq reAeuro." ov ttoAw 8' ovv xpovov
(TTKTyoov TfK(v Kai iK(\(V(v Tfpias (iaUvai,. (iai6vT(S ovv
60 KaT(Xafj.(3dvop.(v t6v p.(v SojKpdrr/ apri \()\.vpJvov, Trfv b(
"EavdCinTrfv ytyvoja-Kets ydp (^jôvadv re r^ 7rat8ioy avrov
Ka\ '7TapaKa6rfp.(VT]v. ws ovv etêv ffpMS ff aavdCTTTTrf, dvrfv-
(f)rfprfa( re /cat TOLavT drra eiTrer, ola 8r/ (i(a6acriv ai
6 ywatKes, ori "'X2 2(>K/)ares, varaTov brf <re Trpoa^povaî vvv
01 ^TTtr^Seiot Kat 00 rovrous." Kat d ^cDKpdrT/s /3Ae\/âs eis

rov KpCTcova, " '12 Kpirwr," e^r/, " dTrayeTU) rts avrr/r
otKafiej,"
Kal iK(Cvr]v p.(v dirrfyov rtres roir rou Kpira)ros fioQadv

b re Kat KOTTTopAvrfV' 6 8e 2a)K/)dT7/s dfaKaîCd/ifiôs eis t-^v
d 5 IwK^tro B T : iv*(fiyyirro W d6 tl<nftifi,tv B : ^tfKv T

d8 ^;up^ secl. Hermann 64 8<^(P BT: Sffni B'W Tttpt-
fitytiv B ficinivtiv T 67 TAfwrqi T : Tt\tvrfi<nff B 69 ît'-
W
:
Acufi/ BT: iKtKtvafv B* /(ri<(^fj BT: tl(ftX96vrts B'W

a7 avTV B: toiJttjv T W bi /i BT et s. v. W: ^1 BWt
4>AIAX2N 60 b
KkCvrjv <Tvv^KaiJ.\{/ re to (TKeKos koI c^^TpL\{f Trj X^V' '^"'
TpLjScov dfxa, 'Hs aTOTTOV, cf)ri, S) dvhpes, eoiK rt eZrat
TovTO b Kakov(nv ol dvOpcoTTOi rjhv' o>s OavfxaaCcos 7t(pvK
npbs t6 boKovv (vavTtov eii/at, to Xvirrjpov, to dp.a pkv 5 \

avTOii fj.r) 'êAety TrapayLyvecrdai tw dv6p(aTT(^, kdv hi rty
hi(i)Kr] To Tpov Kal XapilSdvrf, crxf^dv rt az/ay/caêo-ât dei

kapLJSdveiv Kal t6 Tepov, &(n:p K jutaj Kopv(f>T]S r)pipiV(i>
bv 0VT. Kai fxoi hoKl, ^rj, 1 Vvdr](rV avTa AtfrcoTTOs, c

fjLvOov dv (TVvOcLvat o)S 6 d^ds l3ovkdpLvos avTa btakkdâi
7TokpiovvTa, 7rLbr] ovK ibvvaTO, (rvvr]\(/V ets tovtov avTols
Tas Kopv(f)ds, Kal 8ta TaCra w dv t6 Tpov irapayivrfTai

TraK0k0v9l V(TTpOV Ka\ t6 TpOV. U)(nTp OVV Kal aVT^ fXOL 5
OLKV TTLbr] vtt6 tov bâfxov rjv v tSi (TKkL t6 dkyLvdv,

i]KLV br] (f>aLVTaL TraKokovdovv t6 rjbv.
*0 ovv Ke^rjs VTTokalBcov, N?/ t6v ACa, a> SajKpare?,

(f>r], v y TTOLr](ras dvafxvrfo-as fx. TT^pl ydp tol t&v
TTOLr^fxdTOiV (t)V TTTTOLr]Kas VTivas Tovs Tov Ai(r(aiTOV kdyovs d
KOL t6 et? t6v 'AttoAAo) Trpootjutoy Kat aAAot tlvs jue rjbrf
rjpovTO, aTap Kal F.vr]vos 7Tpwr]v, otl ttot bLavorjO^LS, e7ret8?)
bVpO r]kdS, TTOLrf(Tas avrd, TTpOT^pOV OvbcV TT(0TT0T TTOLTf^TaS.
et ovv tC (tol jae'Aet tov \lv ejue EvTjyo) aTTOKpLvaa-OaL oTav 5
fx avdLS pa)Ta eu ot8a ydp otl pr](TTaL eiTre Tt XPV

kyLV.
Aeye tolvvv, (f)r], avTui, S) KÎSr^s, TakrjOr], otl ovk
KLV(0 PovkdpLVOS Ovbc TOLS TTOirffXa^TLV ttVTOV dvTLTyj)OS
etyai TTOLr](ra TavTa f]br] ydp ws ov pqbLov eiry dAA' e
WTTVL(t)V TLvCi)V aTTOTT^LpdfX^VOS TL kiyOl, KCJU d(f>0(TLOVfXVOS
(l TTokkdKLS Tavrrfv Tr]v fxovcTLKrfv fxoL CTTLTdrroL Trotety.
b 2 i^fTptyfie B fTpiipe T : b 3 ôiKt tj B T toiKev Stob. : W

bs Tb BT W Ty BH Stob. : b? dei T Stob. om. B b8 : i)ix-
/xfvoo T Stob. (Tvvr]fj.ix4vci)

: B 03 auToTs B avTuv T Stob. :
C 5 avT6 W C 6 (TKe\fi B T Stob. (r/ceAet irp^Ttpov B" : a\- W

yeivhv B dA.7rj' T Stob.
: C 9 tv ye ireToiTj/coy d 5 airoKpi- W
vacrdai B aTroKpiveardai T
: d 6 (pcora B T eprjTai B^T- xph W
W
:
B T xpri m* ^^ W
: e i ou T otj ou B e 2 \fyoi ref. T
: :
\fy(iv B \4yfi pr. T b

: e 3 i B el &pa B'^ T W :
6*
6oe nAATilNOS
ijv yap bi] aTTa rotaSe' TroWdKLs /ioi (f)OLrQv t6 avrb kv-
5 virvLov (V Tw TTap\66vTL I^Lb}, SlWot (v oAAt/ o^j/eL (paivo-
ixevov, Ta avTa be keyov, " 'i2 2/c/)aTes," I^t/, " nov(rLKr]v
TToifi Kal ipy6.(ov" Kal eyui ev ye tio rrp6<rdev xp6v<a o-nip
tirpaTTov TovTO VTTX.ap.âvov avT6 jxol itapaKikfvea-Oai T
6l KOL TILKKVLV, ^<nrp ol TOLS dOV(rL bLaK\v6fJLV0L, Kal
e/xoi ovrco to kvvirvLov oiTp eirpaTTov tovto TriKeAeueir,
lJLOV(rLKr]V iroLLV, uts (f)LXo(ro(t)Las fjikv ova-qi fieyL^rrqs ]iov(tl-
Krjs, ]XOV b TOVTO TTpaTTOVTOS. VVV 8' 1TLbT] i] T bUr]
5 yVTO Kal fj Tov dov eo/JTJJ bLK(o\v p. aiToOviYrKeLV, ibo^
Xprjvai, fl &pa iroAAa/ciy (xol irpo^rraTTOL to iiwiTVLov ravTrjv
Tr]v br]fx(abr] /xouo-ikt/v ttollv, /i?/ aTrei^^crai avTia dAAa
TT0LLV' a(r(\>ak(TTpov yap eivai /i?/ aiTLivaL iTplv a(l)0(rL(a-
b (ra(rdaL TTOLrjcravTa 7roi7//>iaTa [kol] TTL66p.Vov T<a ivvTTv((a.
ovToo 8?/ TTpoiTov fxv ls Tov 6ov kiToir^^Ta OV r]V f] TTapov<Ta

OvcrCa' HTa bi rov 66v, ivvoiq<ras otl tov TTOLr]Tr]V 8e'oi,
iTrep /xe'AAoi 7roi7/r^s eirai, iroLLV ixv6ovs oAA' ov k6yovs,

5 Kal avTos ovk t) /ivôAoyixos, 8ia Tavra br] ots TTpoyeCpovs
etyov fxvOovs koll r]TTL<TTafxr]v tovs Ai(r<aTTOv, T0VT<av iiTOLr]<Ta
oXs irp<oTois kvTvxov. TavTa ovv, 2) Ki^r]s, Euj/vo) </)/)aê,
kclI ipp<ji<rdaL KaC, ^lv <r<ji)<f)povr], e/x^ SiuKeir i)s Td\L<rTa,

C aTTlfXL b, i)S OLK, Tr]fXpOV' K\VOV<TL yCLp 'A^T/VaiO'..
Kai 6 ^LpLfxCas, Olov iTapaKeKevr], e</>7/, tovto, S) 2-
KpaTS, Evj/yo); TroAAa yap rjbr] ivTTvxr]Ka T<a avbpC*
(r\bov ovv i^ <x)V kyu) r](rdr]fxaL ovS' OTTwaTtoCv o-ot kK(i)V
5 eiiât ireô-erai.
T^ 8e'; t/ 8' os, ov <j)LX6a-o(f)os Kvr^vos;

"E/xoiye 8oKer, e</)T/ 6 ^LpifxCas.
'EêA)/o-et toCvvv Kal Kvrfvos Kal ttcls 5t<o dûoj rovrou
Toi TTpayfxaTos fXT<rTLV. ov fXVToi la-<i)s /Siao-erat avT6v
a8 thai BT : Tkoi iv6fti(o B* W irp\y BT : wpirtpov -Kp^v tip

B'W bI (col BTw : om. W et punct. not. l letieSfifyov
BTW sed cx I T b 5 8J) B om. T : b 6 <tal ifriaTilnriy
fivdovs B* T W Tovrty T rovrovs B
: b 8 wt rixi^TTa B om. :
T C 4 <Toi B : &' <roi T C 9 fiivroi B T Olymp. fiiyroi >c :
B'W
4>AIAI2N 6ic
ov yap <f)a(ri, Oiixvrov ivai. Kat afxa kiyaiV ravra KaOrJKc lo

ra (TKkr] em rrjv yijv, Kal KaOcônevos ovrm 7)877 ra AoiTra d
blk(yTO.
'HpfTo ovv avTov 6 Kc/Stjs* Hm tovto Aeyets, S>
Sw/cpares, to p.r] O^jxitov etrai kavrov /Stci^fcrât, IdiXnv 8
ai^ rcri aTroOvrjfTKOVTi. tov (pi.\6a-o(pov fTrecrOaL; 5
Tt 8e, w Ke/3Tjs; ovk aKrjKoaTe (jv re Kai Si/ifAias Trepi

rci)y rotovrwy 4>tAo\a<) oT^yyeyorore?;
OvSeV ye cra(f>S, Si ^(oKpaTes.
'AAAo fir}v Kal iy(i> $ aKofis irepl avroiv Aeyco* a p.ev
ovv Tvy\Av(i> aKrjKO(i>s (f)d6vOs ovbels Xeyeiv. Kal yap lo^cos 10
Kai p.(xXL(rTa TTjoeTret /êAAorra eKcto-e a.TTobrjp.dv bLaaKOTTelv e

re Kai jLtrôAoyeiy "Trepi r^s aTTobrjfXLas Trjs Ki, TToCav Tiva
avTTjv owfxfda eiyat* ri yap av tls kcu ttoloI oAAo kv roi
yie'xpt iÂtov 8uo-/u(Sv xp6v(o;

Kara ri 8^ oili' TTore ov âa-i BfpLLTov eirai avrov kavTov 5
a7roKTLvvvaL, S) "EcoKpaTfs; rjbr] yap eycoyc, oTrep iwvbri av

Tjpov, Kal <l>tAoA(iov r^Kova-a, ore Trap' rîxîv 8t7/raro, rjbrj be
Kal aXX(tiv Ttv&v, b>s ov beoi tovto Trotetv" cra</)es 8e xe/3t
avroii; ovSevos Trcri-Trore ov8ei' aK>]Koa.
'AAAa TTpodvp.iLcrOaL XPV> ^4>V' to-X^ y^P "^ '^"^ clkov- 62

o-ats. fo-cos fxivTOL Oavfxaarov aoL </)aretrat et tovto ix6vov
T(av a\k(t)V aTtdvTcov aTrXovv ôtlv, Kal ovbiiroTe TvyxaveL rw
av6p(air(f, waTZfp Kal roAAa, eaTiM ore Kal ols (3e\TL0V \ovy
TedvdvaL rj ^v oXs 8e ^(Xtlov TedvdvaL, davfxaaTbv Xaoos 5
crot (f)aLVTaL et roiôt? roiy dvOpcoTTOLS fxr] oaLOV avTOVS
kairrovs ev Trotetr, aAAa aAAoy 8et TTepLfxevew evepyeTr]v.
Kal o Ke^rfs ripefxa iiTLyekdaas, 'Irrco Zev?, e^Tj, Tfi
avTov (})o>vri eiTrcBy.
d I (TKeXrj B Olymp. : <r/f Arj air^ ttjj kKIvtjs W et marg. T d8 <ra-

Aes T W : ffapws B B T 5rj vvy e 6 pvv 5?; : W 81 i aKovffais
B ccKoviraio T
: a 3 Tcf avdpdiâcf B T twv avBpdnrwv : t a 4 î/
add. ci. Heindorf a 6 haiov B T Zffi6v iffriv B^ : W a 8 jttco
s. V. WOlymp. frTt B jttjw b (ttjw T cjttjw
: : : W ^tvj BT
W
: :
feC
6ab nAATi2N02
b Kat yap tiv hoêKv, I</)t/ 6 SwKpdTTj?, ovrui y tirat
oAoyoi;' ou [tAvToi dAA' tcr<us y' ^x** '""'^ A.o'yoi'. 6 /licv oSy
Iv aTToppriTois Xeyonevos TtepX avrciv Aoyos, ws ev tivi,
(Ppovpa e(rp.ev ol avOpMTroL Kal ov bel hi] kavrov ck ravTTjs

5 Avety ov8' d7ro8t8p(i(r/cu;, p,eyas t4 tCs p.oi. (âivtTai. Ka\ ov
pabtos bLibelv ov fteVrot dAAa Tobe ye p.oi 8oKct, S) K4^r]s,
(v Aeyco-ât, to deovs elvai. r}p.S)V tovs TnpLe\ovpUvovs Kal
TjpLas Tovs ovOpdTTovs kv tQv KTTj/xdrcDV rois deols elvaL. ?/
o-ot OV b0K(L OVTOiS;

lo "E/xotye, (j^rja-lv 6 K^/3t/s.
C OvKOW, ^ 8' 09, Kai (Tv av t&v cravTOv KTrip.dT(ii)v ct
rt avro kavTo aTTOKTeLirvoL, p.r] (rqpirivavTos (tov otl (3ovK(l
avTo TedvdvaL, xaXeTraCvoLs av avr^ KaC, i rtra \ols

TLpLdipCav, TLp.cnpoXo ov;
5 Ildvv y , (f)r].
"lo-tos ToCvvv Tavrri ovk &Xoyov p.r] "nporepov avrov

diTOKTeLvvvaL betv, iTplv "(dv} dvdyKqv TUfO, 6tos eT:LiTep.^ri,
&(niep Kol Ti]v vvv rjpLLV iTapovcrav, i
'AAA' eiKo'?, l</)r/ 6 Ke/3r/s, Tovfo ye (fâCveraL. o pjiv'

lo rot vvvb^ ikeyes, to tovs (^LKoa-o^îovs pqbCcos hv kdekeLV
d aTTodvfj^rKeLV, (olkcv tovto, w ^(aKpaTes, dTOTTca, eiTrep o
vwbi] kKiyop.ev evKoyais ^x^l, to deov Te eii/ai tov ^Trt/xe-
Xovp.evov r]]xS>v Ka\ i]p.ds (kcCvov KT>]p,aTa eTvat. to ydp p.i]
dyavaKT^v tovs (\>povLp.oiTdTovs K Tavrris Trjs depaiTeCas
5 dTridrras, ev ^ eTrtoraroCo-ti; avr&v otiTep dpLcrToC el(TLV TSiV
ovTOiv eTTL^rrdTaL, deoC, ovk Ix^^ Adyof ov ydp ttov avros ye

avrou oierat dp.eLvov eiTip.eKrj(re(rdaL eKevdepos yev6p.evos.
dAA' dvoriTOS pCev dv6p(tiTTos Td\ dv olr]6eCr] Tavra, (ftevKTeov
e eTvaL diTo tov be^nroTov, Kal ovk dv Aoyiôtro drt ov bel diTo
ye Tov dyadov (fievyeLV dAA' drt /xdAtora Trapap.eveLV, bio
ba<y' B T om. : W
b 4 post itriitv add. vitn-ts B' b 10 <prf
B f(pri T
ffiif : W
c i Kr-nixirbiv B om. T c 7 &i' add. Heindorf
:
W
Sebj B d dfhs B' T
: Olymp. W
c8 irapovffay fi/xty d 2 fx
B'T W ^x*' B
: d6 TToi; B Olymp. ir<w T d 7 4irifi.t\-/ifftffeai
:
B Olymp. iirifi(\ua0ai T
:
*AIA12N 626
aXoyicrT(t>s av (fxvyof 6 be vovv )((ov TTi6vij.oI ttov av del
ilvai TTapa roi avrov /3eArtori. KaiToi. ovro)?,. w 2()/cparey,
TovvavTiov eirai eiKOs i] b vvvbi] iXeyeTO' tovs fjiev yap 5

(l)povLiJi.ovs ayavaKTtiv aitoOvri^rKOVTas TrpeTrei, tovs 6e acfypovas
Xa(pLV.
'A/covcras oili' 6 ScoKparTj? ricrOijvaC re /xoi eboê ti] tov
Ke/37jros TrpaypaTeiq, Kal e7ri/3Ae'A//'as eij i7/u,as, 'Aei roi, 63
1^17, o Ke'/3rjy Ao'yov9 rtras avepeuvq, Kal ov Trdvv evê'a>s
eê'Aet Treiêcrât ort av rts etTn;.
Kat 6 ^Lix[xCas, 'AAAa /xT/y, e(^r/, o) 2wKpares, rCy ye /101
8oKet rt Kat avT^ XeyeLV Ke'/37;s' ri yap hv fiovX.6fxevoL 5
avbpes (ro(f)ol ws dXr]d(as bea-TTOTas d[j.LV0vs axrrSiv (f)vyoLev
Kal p(ibL(DS diTaXkdTTOLVTO avToi>v; KaC fxoL boKel Ke'/3r/s ets
(re TeCveLV tov Koyov, otl ovro) p(ibCcos 0e'pets Kal r]]xds
dTTokeCiraiV Ka\ dpxovTas dyaOovs, w? avTos o/xoAoyei?, deovs.

ACâLa, (j)r], Ae'yere' otjxaL ydp vjxds kiy^LV otl xpi] p.e b
irpos TavTa dTToXoyqa-aa-daL uxnrep iv bLKaaTr]pC(a.
Tldiw piev ovv, ((f)r] 6 2t/ix/utas.
4>e'pe bi], 7]
8' os, TTLpa6(o TTL6av(oTepov TTpos vfxds dTToXo'
yiqa-aa-6aL ^ TTpos tovs biKaa-Tas. eyo) ydp, e(pr], S) ^Lp.fxCa 5
re Kai Ke/^r/s, ei /xey /x^ w/ixrji; rjêLV TTpQtTov fxkv Trapd

6eovs aAAous ao(f)ovs re Kat dya6ovs, eiTeLTa [Kal] Trap'
dv6p(0TT0vs TeTeXevTrfKOTas dp.eCvovs r<Sv ev6dbe, r]bCKOvv

dv ovK dyavaKT&v rw 6avdT(0' vvv be ev to-re ort 7ra/>'
dvbpas re eXiTCô) d(f)Cêo-6aL dya6ovs Kat tovto fxev ovk dv C

TTavv bLLcr\vpLcraCp.r]V to fxevTOL TTapd êovs beaTTOTas Trdvv
dya6ovs rjêLV, ev lo-re ort etTrep rt aAAo t(ov tolovtov

bLLcr)(vpLcraCfxr]v dv Kal tovto. â-Te 8ta Tavra ovx o/xotcos
dyavaKT(a, dXX' eveXiTCs elfXL elvaC tl tols TeTeXev-rfKoa-L KaC, 5
65 (iKhs ehai T sed add. sign. transp. &z 6 om. pr. T

1 4 "ye /jioi SoKf7 tj B : -ye SoKfT ri /xoi T : re fMi SoKf? ti W 8. 9 airo-
Kfliraiv B" T W : aTro\nra>u B b 2 trpos ravra B om. T b 4 irphs
W
:
vuas KiQavdnfpov T b7 Ka\ -rrap' B t : tto/j' T Stob. b 9 OTt

om. Stob. C2 t6 T (in ras.) Stob. : Sti B 04 dii(Txvpia-aifj.riv
B Stob. : lax^P^^raifjiTjv T sed 5i s. v.
63C nAATi2N02
uxnrfp ye koL TiaXai Xeycrai, TroA.u a^dvov tois aya6o7s r)
ToTs KaKOLS.
Tt ovv, ^(f)r) 6 Si/xfxâ?, S) Sw/cparey; avTos tyjjiv ttjv
bi,dvoi.av TavTT}v Iv v& ex^'^ cntUvai, rj kclv rjfilv fX(TaboCr)s;
d Koivov yap hr) l/xoiye boKî Kal fjixiv (Ivat, ayadbv touto, koI
ap.a (Toi fj aTToXoyCa (TTai, iav &Tr(p Acycis rjfxas TrfioT/s.
AAAa TTi,pacrop.ai, (\>r\. TTptaTov 8e Kpircora Tovbf

a-K\}/oofX6a t[ iCTTtv o ôvK(r6aC fxoi boKei -jrdXai, tlmlv.
5 Ti be, S> 2(0K/3are9, I<^t; 6 Kptrcor, aAAo ye fj TrdAai
fxoi A^yet 6 /xe'AAa)i; o-oi Swo-eiv ro (ÂpfxaKov ori XP/ ""O'
^p6.((LV 0)9 eAdx^^Ta 8taA^yeo-0ai; <^r/o-i ya/) deppLaCvf^rdai
fmXXov biaXeyofxevovs, belv be ovbev tolovtov 7rpo(T(f)fpLV
e rw (f)apfX(iK(a- ei 8e /xt/, eviore drayKaêo-âi Kat 8is Kat rpis

TTtreti; TOVS TL TOLOVTOV TTOLOVVTaS.
Kat 6 2a)Kpcir7/s, 'Ea, e</)7j, âCp^LV avTOV dAAa fxovov
To (avTov TTapa(rKva^(T(i) u)S Kal bls bd^rcov, (av 8e 6e'7/,
5 Kai TpCs.
AAAa o-xe8oi/ /xe'v rt t/St/, I^t/ 6 Kptrcof dAA({ /xoi TroAai
TrpAyfLaTa 7rap\L.
Ea avTov, ^(f)r]. dAA' vfXLV bff tols 8tKao-rats ftovKopiaL
ifbrf Tov Xoyov diTobovvaL, &s fxoL (f)aCvTaL (Ik6to)s dvffp roi
lo ojrn fv (f)L\o(ro(f)Ca bLaTpC^f/as tov jSCov 6appLV fxdWcov
64 dTTo6avL(r6aL /cai eveATriy eimt eKet fxeyL(rTa oio-eo-ât dyaâ
eTretSdi' reAetm/o-T/. ttS)S dr ovv bif tov6^ ourcos eôt, S
^LfXfxCa re Kat Kf/irfs, eyo) JTfLpda-ofxaL (f>pda-aL.
KLvbvvevov(rL ydp o(roL Tvyxdvov(rLV 6p65)S dTndfXfvoL

5 (f)L\o(ro(f>Cas kekrfdevaL tovs dAAovs ort ovbev dXXo avTol
^TTLTrjbevov(TLV 7/ dTTo6vfi(rK(LV re Kat reî^dfat. d ovv tovto
dXr}64s, aTOTTOv bi^TTOv dv fCrj TTpoOvfxeia-daL fxev iv TravTl Tut
c8 avrhi BT : it^Ttpov avrh^ B'W ?x<"i' BT ovrus ?x*"' B'W

W W
:
dz ^ T :ovrwi r] : om. B ttnai : ^(ttIi/ BT (Js 8 B^T:

8' W: Bom. d6 prius croi BT: om. W dv <t>pd(fiy B^TW:
(ppovri^fiv B d 8 fiaWov BT : fiaWov Toi/r B' W e6 fitv
Ti T /xfvroi B
: iraAai irpa.ynaTa B : irpdyfiara ircUai T 69 ffS?;
: om, T e 10 dappdv T : dappu B
;
*AIAi2N 64a
/S^fc) firjhfv 6XKo rj TovTo, iJKovros 8e 8j/ avrov ayavaKTfiv
t TTdkai ttpovdvyi.ovvTO re kcu eTreTTjScuor.
Kat 6 '2Lii}iCas yiXdaas, N?; ror Aia, I^tj, S ^(oKpares,
ov Ttdw ye ju.e vvvbr] yfXaa-eLovra eTToCr]a-as yfkaa-at. oTp.ai b

yap &v Tovs TToXkavs avrb tovto aKovaavTas boKelv ev iravv
ilpr]a-Qai cis tovs (f)LXoa-o(f)OVVTas Kal (rvp.(i)dvai av tovs pifv
TTop' r^fXLV dv6p(aTT0VS Kal Trdvv ort rw ozrri ol (pikocro-
<povvT(s davaTuxri, Kal a(f)ds y ov XiXr]daaiv oTt aQioC (iai,v 5
Tovro TTdaêLV.
Kal dXrjdrj y av Xkyoiiv, S) '2,ip.p.ia, irXrjv ye tov a-(f)ds
firi XeXrjOevat.. X4Xr]6(v ydp avTovs >j re 6avaTG)ai koX f]

dîoi
(laiv 6avdTov Kal oXov 6avdTov ol ws dXr]6^s (f>LX6cro(poL.
L7T(Dfj.ev ydp, ((f>r], iTpbs r)p.ds avrovs, \aLpiLV iiTTOVTiS (K(l- C

vois' riyovp.e6d tl Tbv 6dvaTov elvaL;
Udw ye, (f)r] VTToXa^MV 6 2t/xfiias.
'Apa p.1] dXXo TL 7] Tr]V ri/s "^XV^ ^"^^ '"^^ o-w/xaros
a7raAAay7/r; Kat eirat tovto to T6vdvaL, x<>pt? f^^v diTO Tqs 5
"^vxrjs diTaXXayev avTb Ka6^ avrb rb a-u>ixa yeyovivaL, x^^pi-^
8e Tr]v yfrv)(r]v [aTro] tov a(i)p.aTos d-naXXayiLaav avTr]v Ka6

avTr]v fivai; dpa fxr] dXXo tl ^ 6 6dvaT0s rj tovto;
OvK, dXXa TovTO, i(f>r].
"SiKeyf/aL brj, (ayaQe, edv dpa Kal aol (rwboKr] diTep (fxoL' lo
CK ydp TovT(t)v fxdXXov oXfxai. r]fxds et(readaL iTepl &v o-ko- d

TTOVixev. (f)aLVCTaL aoL (f)LXoa6(f)ov dvbpbs etvai eaiTOvbaKkvaL
TTepl Tas r]bovds KaXovfxivas Tas rotdo-Se, oXov aLTLO)v [re]
Kat TToroiy;
"HKtfrra, S SwKpare?, e</)r/ 6 "^LfXfXLas. 5
Ti be Tas TU)v d(f)pobLaL(t)v
Ovbapiios.
a9 >B et s. V. t : & T b3 &' B T Olymp. ttu Sh B' W

W W
:
Td 7 -y' BT : t' toD B T : rovs b 9 Kal olov Qavdrov B

lambl. Olymp. : om. T
lambl. Olymp. om. B C5 rb TW :
C 7 aith B om. T lambl.

: cQ ii 6 davaros ^ T ^ * Bavaros ^ B :
W
:
^ & Bdvaros ^ C 10 airtp B T orrep Kal B^ d 3 airiwv re

W
:
W T airwv B
: sed i s. v. W airuv re lambl. d 5 ^kktto B : :
?IKl(TTd 7 B^ T W
64 d nAATaNOS
Ti 6e TCLS oAAas Tas Trepi t6 (nofxa Ofpa-mias; hoKil crot
(VTLfxovs Tiyela-Oai 6 toloxjtos; olov lixaTLCDV bLa(f>fp6vT0iiv

10 KT7]<Tis Kal virobr}p.dT(ov Koi Tovs aXkovs KakXcoTTLo-piovs
Tovs irepl t6 crcoixa TroTepov TLp.av hoKei <roL fj aTLpL<x^(LV,
e Kad^ ocrov pLrf TroXX-q dvdyKTf p.iTt\(LV avTSiv;
ÂTLixdC^LV ifXOLy^ boKL, f(f)r], ye wy oAt/ôJs (f)L\6-

a-o(f)os.
OvKovv oKcos boKfl (Toi, i(f)7], f} Tov TOLovTov TTpay-

5 ixaTfCa ov irepL t6 crcopLa CLvaL, dAAa KaO' ocrov hvvaTai.
d(f)e(rTdvai avTov, Trpos bk tt]v '^vxiqv T(Tpd(f)daL;
'E/xotye.
A/)' OVV TrpOiTOV IXV fV ToXs TOLOVTOLS br]\6s i(TTLV 6
65 (f)LX.6(ro(f)os aTTokvâv otl ixdkLora ri]v ^XV^ ^^^ ttjs tov
(T(j)p.aTos KOLV(t)vias btacfxpdvTOis Tav dWatv avdp(OTT<i)v;
âLVCTaL.
Kal boKei yi ttov, & "ZLixpLLa, tols -TroAAoty avdpdi-noLs
5 w pLr]bV fibi) Tu>v TOLovT<t)v ixr]be /Merexei avTwv ovk d^Lov
flvaL (rjv, dAA' iyyvs tl TeCviw tov TeOvdvaL 6 pLr]bev <ppov-
TLôiiV tG)v fibovdv CLL 8ta Tov crdixaTds elcnv.
ndvv p.v ovv dXr]dfj Ae'yets.
Ti be bf] TTfpl avTf]v Tf]v ttjs (f)povf](r(as KTf](rLv; tto-
10 Tcpov ipLTT^biov t6 (Tatixa fj ov, idv tls avro iv Tfj ^jjrTjo-ei
b KOivo)v6v (rvixTrapa\aixl3dvr] ; oTov t6 rotoV8e Ae'y(o' apa ^xei

d\7]6Ldv TLva 6\ffLS re Kai aKof] tols dvdpâiroLs, fj Td ye
TOLavTa Kal ol 'TrotJ/rat ^fxlv det 0pi;Aoi;o-ti;, ori ovr aKovoixiv
aKpijies ovbfv ovtc opcipLev; KaLTOL et aurat tuv TtepX t6
5 (TcS/Lta ala-dfj(r(t)v ixf] aK/Jt/Seiy eio-t:; /xr;8e o-aêts, a\o\7]
at ye dAAaf Trao-ai ydp ttov tovt(dv (pav\6T(pai d(rLV. f]
(TOL ov boKof}(rLv;
Tldvv ixev ovv, ^(f)ri.
j
no're ovv, i) 8' os, f]

"^XV '''V^ d\7]dCas ^Trrerat; orav
dg Sta<pfp6fTuv
8 4 yf nov TW: 7
B'TW : kuI Sia<pfp6vT{av B dii o-oj 5o(c? W
S-fiirov B as /i<tx C lambl. fifTfXftv BTW
:
b 3 fifuv afl U del : ijnlv T lambl. Olymp.

*AIA12N 65b
fikv yap fXTa tov (T(o[j.aTos iTTixcipfj ri crKOTTilv, bi]kov otl io
t6t iâTTaTaTai vtt' avTov.

ÂXrjdij Aeyet?. ^
'Ap' ovv ovK iv ro) koyLCârdaL diTep ttov aXkoQi Kora-
hriKov avTrj yiyvTai ri tu)v ovT(av;
NaC.
Aoyiêrat b4 yi ttov t6t KaAAiora, OTav avTijv tovto^v 5
p.rib(v TTapakvTrf], ixrfTi aKor) p.r]T 6\lns }xr]Te aXyr^boiV p-rjb^
ris r]bovr], aA.A' ori /laAto-ra avrr] Kad^ avrqv yCyvr]TaL ioiaa
XaCpLV To (TWjxa, Kal Kad* ocrov bvvaTai ]xr] KOLVoiiVovaa
avT(a pLr]b^ aTTTOfxivr] opiyqTaL tov ovtos.

*'EoTi TavTa. lo
OvKOVv Kal kvTavOa r] tov (f)LXo(T6(f)ov '^v\r] ixaXLcn-a
aTLfxaCfL To aS)]xa Ka\ (\>ivyiL aTT avTov, C^ret 8e ainrr] Ka6^ d

avTrjV yCyv(rdaL;
âCvTaL.
Tt b bi] TOL TOLab, S) ^LfXfxCa; (\>a]xiv tl trat bCKaLov
avTo 7/ ovbiv; 5
âfxkv fxivTOL vr] ACa.

Kai av KaX6v yi tl Ka\ aya66v;
n&is 8' ov;
"Wbr] ovv Tr&JTTore rt tG>v TOLoijTdiv rots d(f)daX]xols etSes;
Ovbapois, rj 8' os. lo
'AAA' oAAtj rtft ai(rdr]crL tS>v 8ta tov (T(aixaTos i(\)r]ô)
avT&v; kiy(x) b\ TTcpl iTavT(i>v, otov ixyi6ovs iTipL, vyLiCas,
i(r)(yos, Kal t&v aAAcoi' kvl Aoyo) aTravTCDV Trjs ov(rCas o

TvyxavfL iKacTTov ov apa Sta tov (T(a]xaTos avTG>v to e
akr]6i(TTaTov 6(i)pelTaL, rj <38e ex^'* ^^ ^^ /jtaAiora i^/xoiiy
Kai aKpLJBioTaTa iTapacTKivacTr^TaL avTo iKacTTov bLavor]6rjvaL

Trept ov o-K07ret, ovtos av kyyvTaTa lot tov yvS>vaL iKacrrov;
Hdvv ]x\v ovv. 5
C5 ToVe B'TW
lambl. rovro t B firiStv tovtwv avrijv W
W
:
C6 lambl.
/U7)5 B /ii^re T : d 6 fnfVToi B toj T Olymp. : W
d 7 a5 Heindorf e Ficino oy T om. B d 9 ^Stj B^ T
: ri 5^ B
: W :
e I ra\riQ<TTaToy avrwv T Olymp.

:
656 nAATIlNOS
Ap' ovv (Kflvos &y TovTo iroiTjtrfifi/ KaQap^taTa o&fii
oTL /xoAiora avrrj Trj biavoCq toi ^^' ^KaaTov, firJTe tiv
oxlfiv TrapaTLOcfJifVos V t& biavoda-dai, fXJjrc [Tiva] aXXrjv
66 ala-6r)(nv ((f)(\K(iiV fj.r\h(ixlav' fi.eTa Tov Aoyi<rpioC, aXJC avTrj

KaO^ avTr]v (IkiKpivei Trj biavoCq yjnayifvos avre Kaff avTcr elXt,-
KpLVfs (Kacrrov iinxd-pol OrfptveLV tQ>v ovT(tiv, d-TroAAayeis

oTi /xdAtara 6(^daXp.S>v rc Koix &T(aif Kal coy ciros eliTflv a^p,-
5 TtaVTOS TOV adfXaTOS, i>S Tap6.TT0VT0S KoX OVK &VT0S Ti]V

"^vxriv KTrjcracrdaL dAT/êidr Te kol <f)p6vr]a-LV oTav Kowoivj];
ap ovx ovt6s ((ttlv, a> "ELfXfxCa, CLTTfp tls [Kal] dAAos 6
TV^6]JLV0S TOV OVTOSf
TTT(p(\>v5>s, i(f)r] 6 Si/Xfiia?, 9 aXr]dr} XeycLS, co
JO '2(OKpaTS.
b OvKovv avdyKr], (<f)r], ^K TrdvTâv tovTOii/ 'jrapC(fTa&6aL
boâv TOLavbf tlvo, toTs yvr](rCo)S (f)iXoa6(f)OLS, wore xat Trpos
dAA7/Aoi;s rotaCra arra Xiydv, otl " KLvbvvda tol &a-TT(p
aTpams [tls] ^K(f)(p(Lv rjfias [/xerd tov Xoyov (v tt/ CKfi/êt],
5 ort, 60) s hv t6 (T5>p.a (xojkv Kal a~v]n:((f)vp]X(vr] r/ r]]iS>v ff
yfrvxT] ]X(Ta TOLovTov KaKov, ov p.rj ttot^ KTr]a(j>]i(6a LKavu>s

ov (TrLdv]iov]j.(v (f)afi(v b( tovto eifai t6 dXr]d(s. fxvpCas
fxkv yap rffuv da-xoXCas irapix^L t6 aS>]xa 8td tr]v dvayKaCav
C TpO(f)rjV' (LtL b(, &V TLV(S v6&0L TTpoaTfâdXTLV, ifJiTTobCôvaiv
Tjfiuiv Tr]v Tov ovTos 6r]pav. ipcjToiv b( Kal iTTi6v]XL(0V Kal
<f)6^())v Kal (ib(aX(i>v TTavTobaitoiv Kal (f)XvapCas kfxirCfXTTXrfaiv

rjfMS TToAA^s, &aT( to X(y6fX(vov i>s dXrfdws rui ovtl vtt
5 avTov ovb( (f)povr]a-aL r]]XLV iyyCyv(TaL ovb(iTOT( ovb(v. kol
yap TToX(fxovs kol ordo-eiy xat fidxas ovhkv aXko Trap^x^L i]
t6 aoifxa Kal ai tovtov iiTL^vfxCaL. buL yap Tr]V T(ov XPV-
fxdT<t)v KTijaLV JTdvT(s OL irdAe/xot yCyvovTaL, tcl bi XPVI^'''^
e6 iro^<ri(i')
Tiv* scripsi : rriv
B'TW:
BTW
01^077 B
e8
67 ^^,t BT: jx^fiwoTt
B om. T lambl. Olymp.
rivii :
W
a 7 oMs B t oSratj T : tal B om. T lambl.
: b 3 irTa B t
om, T b4 Ti B : om. T lambl. Olymp, iKtptptiv vfias B T
lambl. OIj'mp fipias iKpiptiv
: ftfri, . . W
<r*t*i^*j secl. Christ .
post b 5 1'xft'M*' traiisp. ci, Schleiermacher b 6 toioi^tou B

lambl. toC roiovrov B'T
: Olymp. W
ca S^ B lanibl, Olymp. i
T T c8 oj BT
lambl. Olymp. f)fuv ol ^''W :
4>AIA12N 66d
ovayKaCofJLfda KTaa-Oai bia ro a-Qfxa, bov\vovTi Trj tovtov d
OipaTtiCa' Ka\ (k tovtov airxokCav ayofxfv <f>iJ\.o(ro<pCas Trepc
bia TrdvTa ravra. to 6' icryaTov TrdvTOiv ori, iav riy
j]p.LV Kal (txoAt) y.ivy]Tai d^n avTov koI TpairdipiiOa iTpos to

a-KOTTeTv ri, er Tals ^Tjnô-eo-iy av TTOJfTaxov TTapaTTLTnov 5
Oopvôv T:apixi KaX Tapayj]V KaX (KirkrjTTeL, ojo-re /u.^
bvva&6aL vtt' avrov Kadopdv TaXrjOii. dkXd rw ovtl tjijllv
bibsLKTaL oTL, ci pAXkopAv irore Ka6apm tl eta-ca-dai,
aTTaXXaKTiov avTov Kal avTy Trj V^^Xf/ 6(aT4ov avrd Ta C

TTpdypaTa' kol TOTe, ws 4olkv, rjfjLLV lorai ov eTTLdvfJLOvp.v
T Kai (papL(V fpaaral eirai, ^poyTyo-fws, firfibdv TfX^VTrj'

aôififv, ws Aoyos a-rnxaCviL, ^Staîv be ov. d ydp p.r] otov
T pLTd Tov a-<a]jLaTos [JLr]bv Ka6ap(as yvQ>vaL, bvolv 6dTpov, 5
7/ ovbaixov icTTLV KTTja-acrdai to eibivaL r] reAeimjo-ao-ii'* t6t

ydp avTT] Kad' avrqv rf ^l/vxr] (CTTaL x'"^'? ''"O'^ a-dfxaTos, 6?
TTpoTcpov 8' ov. Kal (V w dv C^fJLev, ovTUis, u)s eoLKev,
iyyvTdTca icr6]jL6a tov elbivai, idv otl //oAto-ra pLr^bfv
OfJLLkQpLev tm adipaTL fJLTjbe KOLVCoviapLfv, OTL jxi] TTaa-a dvdyKr],
fxr^bi dvaTTL]XTT\(apL(6a Trjs tovtov cf^va-euis, aAAa KadapevapLev 5
aTr' avrot;, ioiis hv 6 debs avTos aTToXvar] f]]xds' Kal ovro) [xev
Ka6apol diTaWaTTdfxevoL Trjs tov crcafxaTos dcf)pocrvvr]s, a)S to
eiKos pccra tolovtcov re ia-6]xe6a Ka\ yvo)a-6]X6a bC r]]xa)V
avTu>v TTav to eiAtJcptres, tovto 8' eo-rir X(r(t)s to dkqdis' b

]xi] Ka6ap(a ydp Kadapov i(f)dTTTa-6aL fxi] ov 6e]XLTov
f]."
ToiavTa olpaL, a> ^L]X]xCa, dvayKalov flvaL iTpds dAAr/Aouy
XiyfLV re Kal So^dêiy Trdrras tovs dp6S)S (îAo/xaêiy. r] ov
boKfl croL ovT(i)s; 5
riai^rd? ye ftaAAoi', w SwK/aarey.
OvKovv, i(f)r] 6 2a>KpdrTjs, ei Tavra dXr]6r], w eratpe,
TToAA^ eAms d(f)LKopLiv(o oT iyo) TTopevofxaL, eKei LKav^Hs,
d. 6 irapexi B lambl. : Tape|et T 63 tppovfjfffais^ <pp6vr](rts lambl.

a I ^ ^vxv f(rrai BT
^vx^ B'^ : (<rrat r) W Plut. lambl. a 6 avrhs
B*TW Plut. lambl. Olymp. om. B : a8 re om. lambl. Olymp.
b 4 T B om. T : b 8 (ku iKayus B : iKavws (Ke7 T Olymp. W
67b nAATilNOS
(infp Ttov &XK061, KTqaaardai tovto ov fvcKa r) iroXXr}
10 TTpayfxareCa fjpLiv iv tw TTapeXdovTi ^C<a yiyovfv, wore 17 ye

C aiTobr^pCa fj vvv poi irpoa-TeTaypAvr) p,Ta ayaOrjs iXTrCboi
yCyvTai koI aA.A<i) avbpl 6s rjyelTaC ol TiapearKivaa-dai Trjv
i, bi(i.voi,av uxnrep KCKadapixevrjv,

Udvv pev ovv, ^(prj 6 "îpLfxCas.
6 K6.dap(ri.s be elvai h.pa ov tovto (rvp.âCvei, orrep "niXai
iv ro) Aoyo) Aeyerat, to \(x>pCêw ori pAXi(TTa ai:o tov

(TiapLaTos Trjv \jrv)(r}^ Kal edC(rai avn]v KaO^ avTr]v iravTa-
ypdev K Tov (r(ap.aTos (TvvayeCpecrdaC re koI adpoCCe(fOai,
Kal oIkcIv KaTO, to bvvaTov Kal iv roi iwv TrapovTi Kal iv r<5
d eireiTa pLovrjv Kad^ avn^v, eKXvopAvr}v (ocnTep [^k] bea-pSiv tK
Tov (r(apaTos;
Tldvv pev ovv, e(f)r].
OvKovv TodTo ye ddvaTos dvofidCeTai, Xvais Ka\ X(>ipt,crp6s
5 ^XV^ ""'^ (^^pMTos;
HavTdiraa-C ye, i^ 8' Ss.
Avftr be ye avTrjv, u>s (f)api,V, npoOvpovvTai. deX /xclXiOTa

Kai povoi 01 (f)iXoa-o(f>ovirrs dpd&s, koX to p.eX^Tr]pa avro
TOVTO ia-Ttv tG)V (f>LXoa6(f)(iiV, Xvcris Kal yôopiapbs '^X^S
10 aTTo (T(i)jxaTos' r] ov;
âCveTai.
OvKovv, Snep iv dpxji eXeyov, yeAoibr hv elr] dvbpa
e TTapaa-KevdCovd^ eatrrbv iv rw /3i<i) ort iyyvrdtd) ovTa tov
TeOvdvai orjTU) ^rjv, K&nei6' {Jkovtos airr^ tovtov dyavaKTeiv;
reAoioy TTois 8' ov;
TS> ovTi &pa, i(f)r], Zi îppCa, 01 opdoos (f)iXo(ro(f)ovvTes
S laTToOvpg-Keiv ixeXeTOia-if Kal ro Te6vdvai rJKiaTa avToi s

y&v6p(an(iiv ôêpov. iK T(avbe bi (TKonei. el yap iia-
C I /xoi B : ifiol B' T W

C a irapt<rKtvd<rOeu B T ircLpMKfvi-
W
:
aaaBai prius ix T lambl. Protr.

d i om. B alterum iK : W :
BT W lambl. Protr. : om. lambl. v. Pyth. d^ Bivaro^ tovt6

7 W d 5 if/vxv^ B' T lambl. Stob. W
om. B d 9 ^vxrjJ :
B'TW lambl. Trjs ^pvxv^ B

: 63 yf\oTov scripsi oi ytKoTop :
BTW Socrati tribuentes in Ars. spatium septem littcrarum

:
:
4>AIAI2N 67e
)3/3A.rjrrat fxev Traiâxfj Tft) (T(afJi.aTL, avrrjv 8e KaO^ avTTjV
fTTidvixovcn TTjv yl/vxvv fX^'-^' tovtov 6e yLyvofxivov [ei]
<pol3oivTo Kol ayavaKToXev, ov 770AA.7) av aXoyCa ett], et ixrf
aa-fxevoL (KeLcre totev, ol acf)LKOfxevoLS e\TTLS eoTLV ov bLO. (3lov 68

"ijpiav Tvx^lv ijpoiv 8e (ppovqa-eotis w re bicêfiXrfVTo, tovtov y.
aTTr)XX.(ix6aL crvvovTos airroLs; rj avdpuiTrLVOiV fxev TraiStKwy 1
Kat yvvaLKU)v Kal v4()v aiToOavovTcov ttoXXoI bi] eKovTfs

'qdeXrfo-av is "AtSou fxcTeXdelv, vtto Tavrrjs ayofXfvoL Trjs 5
fXiTLbos, Tijs Tov o^êadaL re eKet &v 7T(6vfxovv Kal avveae-
adaL' (f^povj aeoos be apa tls t(o ovtl epQ>v, /cai Xa(3u}v a(p6bpa
TTfV avTrjv TavTTfv eXTTLba, fxrfbafxov aXXodL ejrrevêa-dai avTji j
a^Loos Xoyov rf ev "Aibov, ayavaKTrjcreL re aiTodvfi^rKoov Kql /b

ovx d(rfxevos eTcTLV avTocre; oUcrdaL ye XP^> ô.v ro) orri ye
ff,
S eratpe, (f)LX6a-o(f)os' (r(f)6bpa yap avT(o raSra Soêi,
fxrfbafiov aXXo6L Ka6apm evTevêcrdaL cf)povifcyeL aX)C rf eKet.
et be TovTO ovTO)s exet, OTrep aprt eXeyov, ov TToXXrf av 5
dAoyta etr; et (f>olBoLTo tov OavaTov 6 tolovtos;

IToAA^ fxevTOL vrf ACa, 97
8' o?.
OvKovv LKavov aoL TeKfxrjpLov, e(f)r], tovto avbpos, ov

hv Ibrfs ayavaKTOvvTa fxeXXovra aTTo6aveLcr6aL, ort ovk cip'
TjV (f)LX6a-o(pos aXXd tls (f)LXoa(iofxaTos; 6 avTos be ttov C

ovros TT^yxaiêt wv Kal (f>tXoxpvpiaTos Kal ^tAoVtjuos, 7/rot ra
tTepa rovrcoy r/ dfx(f)6Tpa.
Yldw, i(f>r], eêt ovtcos u)S Xeyeis.

'Ap' ovv, e(f)r], S) 2t)u./xta, ov koi rf ovofxaCofxeirrf dvbpeCa 5
rots ovToo bLaKeLpLcvoLS fxdXL^rra iTpo(rrfKeL;
YldvTOis brfTTOv, ecftrj.
e 8 X*"' BT
et yp. ehai W ej B
: om. W 3,4 kuI : T
0)1/ , 7) fUfKa Ars.
TraiScov 5^ om, Ars. a 5 fieTeXduv B^ T :
dKOfTvBWt a6 T C: T( B (in ras.)TW h 2 elaiv B t W
olfffi T ye fi B Ars. om. T : W
b 3 S6^(i B So^tii/ : T
b 4 . . dauov oAXoOt Oapais (ppovrjffd (v : yp. &\\o6i SvvaThv flvai
KaOapms in marg. B (L e. fi.i)'Safxov &Wodi SvvaTov elvai KaSapcos <ppovi)ffei
ivTvxf^tv) b 5 a\oyia kv Ars. b 8 i(j>r] TeKfiripiov Ars. avSphs
et fj.e\\ovTa a.Trodave7ff6at om. ut vid. Ars. C2 . . yxavei <pi\o . *
Ars. C 4 Trdvv B T Stob. ira.vv y : W
68 c nAATftNOS
OvKovv KoL 7} (r(i)(f)po(ruirr}, 771; koI oi ttoXXoI ovofxdCov^ri
(r(a(f>po(rv2rr]v, t6 TTfpl tcls iiTLOvfMias /x^ TTTorj(r0ai oAA'
10 dKiy(apo)s ^xf ty Kal Koa-ixCuiS, Sp' ov tovtois ixovots Trpoo-T/Ket,
TOLS /xaAiora tov odfxaTos okLyoipova-iv re kcll kv (f>L\ocro(pL(i
^SxTLv;
d 'AvdyKT], ((pt],
Ei yap ideKeis, ?}
8' os, ivvoTJcraL Tqv ye tu)V aXKoiV
avbpfCav T KOL a-(o(f)po(rvin]v, 8oêi o-oi elvai aroiros.
H(as brj, S) ScoKpaTfs;

5 Oio-â, 7}
8' os, OTL Tov OavaTov rjyovvTaL tt(xvtS ol oAAoi
T&V ]Xy&k(DV KaKOiV;
Kal /xdA', lc^rj.
OvKOW (f)6l3<a ]xeL(pv(DV KaK&v VTToixivovcriv avT(DV ol
avbpcloi Tov ddvaTov, otov xmofxevoixrLv;

10 "Eorrt TavTa.
^ Tw 8e8i^rai 6.pa Kal bêi &vbpeLoC eio"i irdirres Trkr]v oi
î\6(ro(f)Oi' KaCTOL a\oy6v ye 8lei Tiva Kal SeiAâ hfbpclov

fivai.
e Uavv fxkv ovv,

I
Tt 8^ 01 K6a-]XL0L avTQ)v; ov Tavrbv tovto iTeTTOvdacriv

aKo\aa-C(i tlvI a-(a(f>pov4s (la-Lv; Kairoi (f)ayuiv ye dSvvaroy
eiyai, dAA' o/icoy avrotj a~v]xâCvL Tovna 8]xolov t6 tt(x6os
5 t6 TTfpl TavTr]v Tr]V ivr]dr\ a-oi)(f)po(rvvr]V' (f)oôv]XVOL yap
Tpo)v r]hovS)V a-Tpr]6r]vaL Kal eTTiû/uowres' iKfCvo^v, aX.\o)v
diT\ovTaL vtt' dK\o)v KpaTov]XVOL. KaCroL Kcx\ova-C ye aKo-
69 Aao-iW t6 vtt6 tG)V rjbovoiv dpyeadaL, dAA' o/xtos avfxj3aCvL
avTOLS KpaTovyAvoLS v(f) r]bov(av KpaTLV dAAcof ffbovoiv.
C8 ^ B Tlambl. Stob. : om. W

c ro fidyof Ars. d i f(p-n
W W
om. Ars. d a i0f\us B T lambl. Stob. idtK^fftn 7* T
:
lambl. Stob. t B : d nfydXwv yp.

6 B T lambl. Olymp. Stob. :
fifyiffTwy B'TW KaKuy Bt lambl. Olymp. Kojcuy fhai : B'TW
Ars. Stob. dg
virofxfyuffiy] uiroMM* Ars. dia ii\oyoy

B Ars. lambl. Stob. : &rowoy B'TW

63 (âaxppoyyovffiv Ars.
? B lambl. Stob. : 7 irov B" T W
64 rovro Ars. ifioioy B
ambl. Stob. Sfwiov flvai B* T
: W
e 5 rb irfpl ratrrr)v] roi fw avrr\v
Ars. f{ii)Br)] ivSpairoSuir] Ars. e6 arfpT]0rjvai irtpuv ifSovuv
Ars. e 7 Kparovnfvot vx' iXXcD' W
&\Ka)v] fKfivaiy Ars.
a I ry om. Ars. iA\' Sfms ffvfifialy*i] ffvfifiaiytt S oiy Ars.
:
AIAnN ega
TovTo 8' ofxoiov la-Tiv w vvvbr] iXfy^TO, rw Tpoirov Tiva 84'
aKo\a(rCav avTOVs (rea-axppovCa-dai,.

'Eoi/ce yap. 5
'ii p.aKapii ^tlxjjLLa, /xtj yap ovx avrrj ?/ ^ dp^?) Trpos',
apTT}v aXXayri, rjbovas Trpoy TySoyas Kal kviras Trpbs Xviras

Kal (poôv TTpbs (popov KaTaXXaTTecrdaL, [/cat] p.î((^ Trpbs
eA-arro) axnrep vop.\.a-p.aTa, dAA' 7/ e/cetro p.6vov to v6iJ.iaiJ.a
6p66v, clvtI ov 8et TrdvTa Tairra KaTaWaTTeaOaL, (f)p6vT}aLS,
[fcat TovTov p.ev TtavTa] Kal p.Ta tovtov [b)vovp.va re Kat

7rt7rpao-Ko'jbtem] tS> ovtl ri Ka\ dvbpeia Kal ao}(f)poavvri Kal
biKaLoavvr] Kal avkki]j3briv dkr]dris dp^Tr], [xeTCL (ppovriaeoi?,
Kal TTpoayLyvofJLevoov Kal d7ToyLyvop.4viov kol r]bov(jiv Kal
(f)6j3(ov Kal tG)V aAAcoy TrdvTfDV tG)V tolovt(i)V \(idpL^6p.iva
8e (f)povr]a(*)s [Kal] dAAarro'ftera dyrt dAAr/Acoy /xr) o-Kta-
ypa(f)La rts 17 r] TOLavTr] dperi] /cat tS> ovtl dvbpaTTobcobr^s re

Kai ovbev vyLes ovb' d\r]d^s ex>?j t6 8' d\r]des rw wrt ^
KadapaLS tls t&v tolovtwv TTavToov Kal r/ ao)(f)poavvr] Kal
1] bLKaioavvT] Kal dvbpeCa, Kal avTi] r/ (f)p6vr]aLS pr] ko- i
$ap]x6s Tis T/. Kat Kty8wci;ouo-t KOt ot rd? reAerds ^/jtty
ovrot KaTaaTrjaavTis ov (pavKoC TLves etrat, dAAd roJ oyrt

jraAat alvCTTeaOaL otl bs av d]xvr]Tos Ka\ aTikeaTos ets 5
At8ot; d<|)tKr/rat kv ôpfidpca KcCaeTaL, 6 8e KeKa6app.vos
re Koi rereAecrjue'ros CKelae d(f)LK6p.vos /xerd êcSi' oLK-qaeL.
elalv ydp 8r/, [cos] (paaLV ol iTepl rds reAerds, " vap6r]KO(f)6poL
]iev TTokkoC, /SaKXOt 8e' re TTavpoL'" ovtol 8' eto-ti' Kard Tr]v d
ffxr^v b6âv ovk dAAot 17 01 TreîAoo-o^r/Ko^res dp^ws. oiv 8t/
Kot eycu KaTa ye rd bvvaTov ovbev dirikLTTOv iv rw /3i<j),
a 6 7ap B Ars. Olymp. T ^^]pB:^T

Stob. a^ aWayij
om.
W
:
lambl. : oAAa B:T

a8 /cal om. lambl. Stob. a 9 oAX'
p W: aWr; B T a lo a.v0' Srov iroj/TaT lambl, Stob. W
arrarro B :
bi,2 inclusa seclusi

B^TW lambl. Stob. om. B
SiKaioa-vy-n Kal auxppoavvT) b 6 fcoi W
oAAtjW B^TW lambl. Stob.
: :
6.\\(t>v B b8 u^jej TW lambl. Stob. vyils fhai B exv ^^

W lambl.
:
Stob. :
^x* ' yp. exo"'''^ W KdBapffts ^V/ C2 oj^SpfJO
TW
:
B : ^ dj^Sptio 03 KivSwevovffi B -yp. W

lambl. Olymp. kivSv- :
vfvwffi. B- T \V c 4 Tivfs B- T W om. B lambl. Stob. C 7 tc

W
:
om. c8 s B Clem. Stob. om. T lambl. ds 7^ B

eyayye T W 7 B om. T W :
;
PLATO, VOL. I. 7
egd OAATfiNOS
aXXa TravTL Tpotti^ TrpovOvjxridr^v y(vi(rdai' il 6' opdHi
5 npovBvp.ridr]V KaC Ti r}vv(Tap.(v, kKeiac ikdovTfs t6 aacpi^
ela-ofxeda, hv Oebs ide\r], okCyov va-Tepov, ci)s (p.o\ hoKil.
TavT ovv iyo), ((f>ri, o 2)i/iA/iia re Koi Kd^rjs, 6.-iToX.oyov[iai,
ats (Ik6to)s vpias T diroXeCira^v Kal tovs ivddde becriroTas ov

e yaXiitSis (f)ep(o ov8' ayavaKTut, rjyovpLfvos /caKct oibev T/TToy
rj (vdabe bea-iTOTais re ayadols ivTevêcrOai Kal kTaCpois'
\toZs 8^ 'TroAAois dirioTtay "napeye^^' <t ti ovv vp.lv Tndavd-
Tepos et/ixi ev Trj d.TTo\oyC(i rj toIs ÂdrjvaCcov biKaarais, ev
5 &v ex^t.
EIttovtos br) tov ScuKparouy TavTa, viTokajBiov 6 Kij3r]s
^(f>r]' 'X2 '2(iiKpaTes, to. p.V aKX.a epxtiye boKei KaK5>s keyea-Oai,
fjo To. be rrepl Trjs "^vxfjs TToKkrjv coTia-TCav iTapeyei toIs avOpdrTois
prj, eiTeibav aTTaWayTJ tov acapLaTos, ovbap.ov crt t/, oAA' eKeCvrj
TTJ i]pepqbLa(f)9eCpr}TaC Te Kal aTToKX.vrjTai. fi

av 6 avOpoiTTOsaTTO-
dvTqaKr], evdvs aiT(t\X.aTTOfxevr] tov crdnxaTos, koI eKâCvova-a
5 S)a-TTep TTvevfxa 7/ KaiTvbs biaa-Kebaa-Qela-a oixr/rai bi.aTTTop.evr]
Kal ovbev (TL ovbafxov p. eTTeC, eliTep cirj ttov avrr] Kaff
avTi]v a-vvr]dpoi(rp.evr] Kal aTTr]XXayp.evr] tovtu)V tCov KaKU)V
&v (TV vvvbr] bt.r]Xdes, iToXXr] h) elr] eXiTls Kal KaXrj, u)
b ^(OKpaTes, ft)? oAtj^^ eaTLv h (tv Xeyeis' aXXa tovto bi]
ta-o)s ovK 6XCyr]s TTapap.vdCas beiTai koX iriWccDS, u>s eari re
v/^DX) aTToOavovTos Tov av6p(t>TTov KaC Tiva bvva\xiv eyjii Ka\
(f)p6vr](nv.
5 'AAr/^j/, e^r], Xeyeis, 6 ^(OKparrjs, o) Kej3r]s' oAAo tC bi]
TT0iS)p.ev; r] iTepX avTu>v tovt(i)V ôvXei buxp.v6oXoyG)pev, eiTe

eiKbs ovT(i)s ^xeiv eiTe p.r];
d8 diroXtiVwi' TW : axo\nruv^ 6 2 iralpois B^TW: trfpois B

e 3 To7s . . Kopix.fi secl. Ast e 7 fnoiyt SoKfi B t Stob. SoKti :
t;xoiyf T W aa iri fl
BT
1 itrri Stob.
Stob. om.
a 3 Sia<pdtlpfTai Stob.
W awoey^ffKTi B'
ieK6\Kvrai Stob. 6 : :
aTro9v^(TKfi B hicoeavri B' (marg.) TW Slob. as oXxrtrai . . . rf
B' W vvv
:
secl Schanz olxfrai Stob. a 8 rvy Si) : tiv B : vvv

T
.
Stob. Air!y tiiiT ba taws BTW Stob. : <ra<pis s.v. W

b 3 i^xh T : fi ^vxh B Stob. W
<l)AIAi2N 7ob
*Eya) yovv, l^rj o Ke^rjs, rjbidis av aKOVcranii rjvTLva

boâv X^'^ '"'^P'
avTStv.
OvKovv y av otfiai, ?]
8' bs 6 ^(iiKp6.Tr]s, clTrdv Tiva vvv lo
aKov<ravTa, ovb' ei KtojuwSoTroios et?;, ws dSoAeo^w Kal ov c

TTept TTpoa-rjKovTOiV Tovs Xoyovs TTOiovjiau d ovv 8oKei, XP^J
StaoTKOTreto^ât. "^
'2,K\jra)ixe6a 8e avro rrjSe tttj, etr' apa kv "AiSoi; eio-tr al
ylrvyaX TcXevTrârAvToov tG>v avOptoTTcav etre Kat ov. TraAatos 5
[xkv ovv iOTTi Tis Koyos ov fxepLVTqixcOa, &>s eto-ty (vdivbs

aîKoixevai e/cei, KOt ttoXim ye bevpo a<f)LKVovvTai. Kal yC-
yvovTai K T&v TdvU>TOiV' Ka\ et Tovd' ovTws exet, ttoXlv
yiyvea-daL (k twv aTToOavovTOiv tovs ôiVTas, oAAo rt t/ etey
av ai \/n;xii rjjxSiv eKei," ov yap av ttov ttoXiv eyiyvovTo fxr} d

oSo-at, Kai TovTO iKavov TeKpLi^pLov Tov TavT^ eXvaL, et rw
orri (fyavepov yCyvoLTO otl ovbafx66ev a\ko6V yiyvovTaL o\
^SiVTes r) K T&v Te6va>T(t)V' et be fxr] eort tovto, ak\ov av
Tov beoL \6yov. 5
Hdw pikv ovv, e</)Tj 6 Ke'/3Tjy.
M^ TOLVvv KaT av6p(LTT(t)v, rj 8' os, o^Koiret p.6vov tovto,

el /3ouXet paov fxaêlv, aXka Kal Kara C"^^ TravTOiv kol
<PvtS>v, Ka\ (TvWrj^briv ocraiTep exei yivecrw iTepl TTOVTOiV
Lb(jip.ev ap' ovT(ii(rL yiyveTaL TrdvTa, ovk a\ko6ev rj eK rwy e
(vavTLOiV TCL evavTia, oaoLS TvyxaveL ov tolovtov tl, olov t6
KaAw rw aio^poi evavTiov ttov Kal biâLov dSiKw, koi aAAa
br} fxvpia ovTOis exet. tovto ovv (TKe-^dixeda, apa avayKalov
o(rois ((ttl tl ivavTiov, ixribap.66ev akXodev avro yCyv(T6ai 5
r) eK Tov avTU) ivavTiov. olov oTav ixelC6v tl yiyvrfTai,
avdyKrj ttov e^ ekarrovos ovtos TTp^Tepov iiTeLTa ixelôv
yiyva-6aL; t
\> 8 i-yayyt oZv B : 4ywyovv T : tywy' oZv W^ C I Ku/itfiSoTroihs pr.

T (,ut vid.) W : KwfitfiSLoiroihs B t C4 Si B : om. T c6 \6yos
B: 6 \6yos ovtos B^TW Olymp. :\6yos ovros Stob. d r oi
i^vxol rifi.wv B Tjfiwv al fpvxal T W Stob. d 3 ylyvotTo B T :
W
:
yivoiTo W Stob. d8 piov B Stob. f>aSiov T

: e r '[Swfj.ev
Olymp. Stob, : flSwfj-fv BT W oStws W vdvTa B W
Olymp. Stob. an-avra T 64 tovto BW oZv Stob. om.
: T
W
:
e 5 (<m Ti B T Stob. : iffnv e 6 iavr^ W '
7*
7oe riAATilNOS
Nai'.
lo OvKovv KCLV ikaTTov ytyvr]Tai, K ixeCCovos ovtos npoTfpov

'ji vcTTepov ikaTTOv yivri<TiTai; l
"Ecrrty ovro), I^tj.
Kal p.r]v e iayypoTipov ye to acrOiViOTipov Ka\ Ik ^pa^
bvTpOV TO 6aTTov;
5 Hdvv y.
Ti 8e; av ri x^^P^^ yCyvrjTai, ovk e^ ap.iCvovoi, Ka\ hv
SiKaiorepoy, e^ d8tKcore'pou;
ridis yap ov;
'iKaj^QJS ovi;, ^<f>ri, liyop.V tovto, otl TrdvTa ovTOi yCyveTai,
10 e^ ivavTCuiV to. kvavTCa npdyp.aTa;

Yldvv ye.
Tt 8' av; icrTL rt Ka\ TOLovbe ev avTols, olov pieraî/
dp.(j)OTp(av TrdvTMV T<av (vavTCuiv bvolv ovtolv bvo yev^creLS,
8' av TOV (Tfpov
b aTTO fjikv Tov Tpov eTTi t6 Tpov, aTTO
TToAty eTTl t6 Tp0V' p.CCoVOS p.V TTpdypiaTOS Kai iXdTTOVOS
p.Ta^v av^ricris Kat (f)dC(rLS, Ka\ KaXovp.V ovTCii t6 p.V av^d-
V(rdaL, t6 8e (f>dCvLv;
5 Na^, (\)r].
OvKovv Ka\ bLaKpCv(r6ai Ka\ (rvyKpCvcrdai, Ka\ yfrvyjeaâL
Ka\ 6pp.aCv(T6aL, Ka\ TtdvTa ovT(ii, kcLv et p.r] ')(jp(!ip.6a toIs
6v6pa(TLV kvLayov, dXX.' py<o yovv TtavTaxov ourcoy xeu'

dvayKOLOv, yCyv(r6aC re avra e^ dWr^koiV yiv(rCv re eivot
10 KaTpov LS dXXr]ka;
Yldvv pikv ovv, Tj 8' os.
C Tt ovv; ^(l>r], T(D (rjv ((ttC tl evavTCov, eoa-mp rui
iypr]yopvaL t6 Ka6vbLv;
HdvV ]JLV OVV, I^TJ.
Tt';
aa oStu) i<py) B ^<^7j : oZrw T W Stob. a^ 7 T Olymp. Stob. :
om. B a 7 ^{ B T : oixc ^{ Wt Stob. a 12 tan ti B T (ffriv

:
tn B' iffn W h z ^(v ^ : yap T : fxiv ykp B" W

Olymp.
W
:
b 10 fKarfpov T : i^ iKartpou B b 11 ftfv oZv B : yt TW

;
4>AIAX2N 71 c
To TeOvdvaL, <f)r}. 5
OvKovv ^ aXkrjKcov re yiyvTaL Tavra, eiTrep kvavTia

koTiv, KoX ai yevearfLS elcrlv avTolv fxeTa^v bvo bvolv ovtolv;
Tl(os yap ov;
Trjv fJiiv TOLVVV kTpav ovQoyLav &v vvvhy] fkcyov eyco
(TOL, i^rj, ipS), 6 2a)Kpan79, kol avrijv Kal tcls yevea-eLS' ot) 10
bi fxoL TTjv (Tepav. Aeyto 6e t6 fiev KaOevbeLV, to be eypr\-
yopevaL, Kal eK tov KadevbiLV to iyprjyopevaL yiyveadaL Ka\
K Tov eyprjyopevaL to KadevbeLV, Kal Tas yereVeis avTolv d
Trjv ixev KaTabapddvfLv elvaL, Trfv 6' dvfyeCpfa-OaL. l/caz^ws
(TOL, e(pr], rj ov;

UdvV fJiV ovv.
Aeye brj fxoL Kal (rv, e(f)r], ovrco irepl C^rjs Kal 6avdT0v. 5
ovK kvavTLov fxev (pr\s rw îfv to TeOvdvaL eXvaL;
Êycoye.
TCyvecrOaL b\ e^ oAA^Xcoy;
Nai'.
'E^ ovv Tov ^GiVTos tC to yLyvofnevov; 10

To TedvrjKos, e(f)r}.
Ti be, ^ S' os, eK tov TeOve&TOs

'AvayKaXov, e<^rj, ojuoAoyery ori to ^wv.
'Ek T(av Te6ve<aT(i)v dpa, S) KejBrfs, Ta ôivTd re Kal ol
^cSi^res yCyvovTaL; 15
Iâîêrai, e(f>r\. e
Eto-iy dpa, e(pr], a\ xj/vxal rffiGiV ev "AiSou.
*'EoiKey.
OvKOVv Ktti roii' yeve(TeoLV toIv irepX TavTa rj y eTepa

(ra(f)r]s ova-a TvyxdveL; t6 yap diTo6vri(rKeLV (ra(f>es b^îrov, 5
7/ ov;
Udvv fjiev ovv, e(f>r],
Y\S)s ovv, 7]
8' 6s, TTOLrfcrofiev ; ovk dvTaTTobôcropLev Tr]v
C 7 avrailv B Stob. : axnwv T C 11 ^ypyiyoptvai ... 12 KaOivSdv

B*T W Stob om. B : d avrwv Stob.
i d 5 fioi Kal av B koI
B^ T W Stob. W
:
ai ^Loi e 2 d(riy &pa T Stob. &pa u(rlv B

:
71 e nAATfiNOS
(vavrCav yivi<Ti.v, aXKa Tavrp x^^V "Tâi r} <l>v<ns; r} avayiaj
lo aiTobovvai to> airoOvjjcrKiiv ivavrCav Tiva yiv(.(Tw;
Tiva ravrqv;
To avafiua(rKi(rdau
OvKovv, 7)
8' os, ctTrep lori to hvafti<a(rK((rdat, ^k t<Sv
72 Tdv(aT(iiv av (irj yiv(ns cis toiis ^wvras avnj, t6 aya-
îwo-Keo-âi;
ndru ye.
'OfjLoXoyeiTat &pa rjfuv Kat Tavrrf tovs C&VTas ck T(av
5 T6ve(aT(av ycyovevat ovbev rjTTOv rj tovs TfdvedTas (k twv

^(ovToov, TovTov 8e oirros 'tKavov ttov fboKet TCKfiTJptov dvat
oTt avayKatov ras tQv TcdveoiTaiV \l/vxo.s (IvaC ttov, odev bri
TrdXtv ytyv(r6at.
AOKCX flOt, (f)ri, S) ^(i^KpaTS, K T<JiV u>iJ.o\oyr)n4iHAV
'
10 avayKatov ovtcos \tv.

'15^ ToCwv ovToos, t^r), Si Ki^tfs, oti ov8' abCKoos ii\io-
XoyqKap.V, 0)5 p.ol boKt. 1 yap /xt) dei drTa7ro8i8otrj to.
b Tpa Tots Tpots ytyv6pva, o)(nrpt kvkX^^ irepttovTa, a\X

v6t<i TLS tT) r) yiv(r ts k tov Tpov jxovov eis t6 KaTav-
TtKpv Kal pT} dvaK(xpTrrot TrdXtv eiri t6 Tpov pirjb^ Kap.Trr]v
TTOtotTo, oZ(Td^ oTt TtdvTa TkVTiirra t6 avT6 (rxfipa h.v (rypCi)
5 Ka\ t6 avTo Trd6os av "nddot koX TtavcratTO ytyv6p.va;

XlSis Ae'yeis; l<^?7.
Ov8ei' yaX^Ttov, 7]
8' oy, ewoôâi & Xtyoi' dAA' otoi' ei
t6 KaTabap6dvtv pV eir;, t6 8' dvyCp(r6at /xt; drTairoîSotr;
ytyv6pvov e*c tov Ka6vbovTos, ol(r6^ oTt TXVTu>VTa iravT^
C (J^^y Xrjpov t6v 'ErSvfittora d7ro8etêtev koI ovbap.ov av

(fiaCvotTO bta t6 Kal TaAAa Trdvra TavTov ^KetVw ireTTOvdivat,
Ka6evbtv. Khv el ovyKpCvotTo pv TrdvTa, btaKpCvotTo 8e
a4 ipa fifuir BTipa Stob, a 6 ^SJkci

: iifuv W B Stob. : om. T
a II ofjrais B : om. TW
IJ4 koio7to'B: xoiOiT b^ iworiffat
B T W ivvoiiffaffiv B
: b 9 xikvr' h Bekker : xiina BT W
C3 îaKplvoiTol: Sicucpiwoiro^BW
*AIAX2N 72 c
p/, raxv av to tov 'Avaâyopov yeyovos (tt], " 'Ojuou TrdvTa

XprjfxaTa." bxravTcos 8e, oi <îAe Ke/3rjy, Kal fi aitodvria-KOi, 5
p.v Trdvra ocra tov ^rjv pLeTaXdfSoL, eTreibri be dTToOdvoi,
pivoi fv TovTco ro) a-)(riixaTi. to. T(6ve(ii>Ta Kal p.!] TrdXLv
dva^L<aa-KOLTO, ap ov ttoAAt) dvdyKrj TeAeurwyra irdvTa

TeOvdvaL Kal fxrjbev (fjv; ei ydp eK fjiev TUiV dXXcov Ta d
^(avTa yiyvoLTO, To. 8e ^covTa 6vr]a-K0L, rts p.r]yavi] {j.i] ov)(l
irdvTa KaTavakw6j]vaL els to TfdvdvaL;

Ovb jJLLa fxoL boKfl, <pr] 6 Kc/Stjs, a> Sw/cpare?, dAAa p.0L
boKels TiavTdTtaaLV dXr]6i] \4yiLV. 5

"YaOtlv ydp, (f)r], a> Ke^rjs, ws ifxol Sofcei, Trayroy /xaAAoy
ovTOi, KOL rjfxelis avTo. Tavra ovk ea7raraj/xero6 6p.okoyov[Xv,
dAA' eo-rt rw orrt Kat to dva^Liaa-KecrâL kcll e/c tQiv T6v(a-
T(av Tovs C^VTas yiyvea-daL Kal rds rwy T6v(aT()V i//-uxd?
eiyat [xai rats ]x4v ye dya6aLS &ix(LV0V elvaL, rat? 8e KaKats e

KaKLOv].
Kal fx-qv, e(f)r] 6 Ke'^7js VTroX.a^(ov, Kal Kar eKelvdv ye

Tov Xoyov, o) ^(oKpaTes, et dX.r]6T]s eoTLV, bv (tv et(i)6as
6a]xd XeyeLV, otl fjfxlv rj ixd6r](rLS ovk dAAo ri ?) dvd]xvr]crLS 5

TvyxdveL ovaa, Kal KaTa tovtov dvdyKr] ttou rjfMS ev iTpoTepio
tlvl XPo'^<? ]xefxa6r]KevaL a vvv dva]XL]xvr](rK6]xe6a. tovto be
dbvvaTov, el ]xr] -^v ttov r]p.LV rj "^vxt] irplv ev r<38e rw dv- 73
6p(t)7TLV(o etSei yevecr6aL' cucTTe kcxl TavTi] d6dvaTov r] ^vxv
TL eoLKev elvai.
'AAAd, &> Ke^rjs, e(f)r] 6 2t///xtas V7toX.al3(ov, Trotai tovt(ov

al diTobeLêLs; xnrofxvria-ov \xe' ov ydp (r(f)6bpa ev rw jrapdvTL 5
]xe]xvr]]xaL.
Ei;t ]xev Adyo), e^r] 6 Kej3r]s, KaAAtcrra), ort ep(i)T(o]xevoL

OL av6p(OTT0L, edv tls koA&js ep(OTa, avTol XeyovcTLV iTdvTa i]
eêL' KaLTOL ei ]xi] ervyyavev avToZs iiTLaT-qfxr] evovcra Kal
C 5 KalT W: om. B d2 oiixi T b ovx : : W

wov B d7 avra B :
To aiira TW e 1-2 koI . . . KaKiov secl. Stallbaum yt B: om.

T Olymp. e 6 tovtov B : tovto T a i rifiiv B : rinaiv T W
a2^BT:T<^W ^ ('"X^
"""* ioiKti' B (ut vid.) W : t ioiKev j] ^vxh
T b Olymp.
'
73a nAATfiNOS
lo opOos \6yos, ovK hv oloL t r)crav tovto Troirja-ai. iirnTa
b k6.v Tts fTrl To. bi.ayp6fifMiTa ayrf rj &XXo ti tS>v tolovtuiv,
kvTavOa (ra(f)e(rTaTa Karrjyopel oti tovto ourco? x^'*
EZ 8e fiT] Tavrp ye, e<^7/, Trei^r/, aj lifxixia, 6 ^CDKpdrqs,
(rK\{/aL hv Tjjbi iTrf (tol (TKOTTOVf/.^vca (rvvbo^ri. dTrioTeis yup

5 br] 770)? 17 KaXovp.ivri fxdOrf^rLS av6fxvr](TLS ((ttlv;
'AirLo-Toi fiiv \(tol\ iy(oy(, rj b' bs 6 2i///:xias, ov, ovto h\
ToCro, e077, biofxaL Traddv Trepl ov 6 \6yos, dvafxvrfo-drjvaL.
Kal a^(b6v ye e wy Ke'/3rjs e7rexeiprjo-e kiy^LV ifbrf fxip.vr]fxaL
Kal TreidofxaL' ovb\v fxivrhv rfTTov dKovoLp.L vvv tttj av (tt-
10 exetpT/o-as kiyav.
C Tt;8' iyoiiyc, 7/ 8' os. o/xoAoyo{S//ey yap biîTOV, ci ris rt
dvafxvr](rd-q(r(TaL, belv avTov tovto iTp6Tp6v Trore iiTL(rTa(r0aL.
Ildvv y , e^r/.
A/)' ovv KOLL To8e 6/xoAoyov/iei', oTai (TTL^rnjpLT] TTapa-
5 yiyvrfTaL TpîTi^ tolovt(o, dvdfxvricnv (IvaL; Ae'ya) 6e TiVa

TpdiTov; ToV8e. ^dr t^s ti ^Tfpov rj lba)v fj dKovcras i} riva
aXkrfv aX(rdr](rLV kaôiv fxr] pl6vov iKflvo yvS>, dkXd Koi
(Tpov ivvor](rr] ov fxr] rj avrr] (iTLcrr^pir] dXk' akkr], dpa
ov)(l TOVTo bLKaiios k^yofxev oti dvcfxjnj^rdrj, ov rrfv ewoiar
d lAa/3ei';
rici)? Ae'yeiy;
Olov TCL Toid8e* dAA?7 Trou km(rrrifxr] dvdp(aiTov koll kvpas.

Yi&s ydp ov;
5 OvKovv OL(rda otl ol ipaarai, orav Xbui(rLV kvpav ^ ifxdTLOv
1/ dAAo TL ols TCL TTaibLKCL avT&v eicoê xP^<^^t> TTdcr\ov(TL
TovTo' (yvctxrdv Te ttjv kvpav kcll iv Trj biavoM ikaôv to
a 10 voiTJaât Hirschig : iroi-fiirftv B : irott7v T W b4 <rot T W : <roi

ttv B (sed tiv punct. not.) b6 aot B om. TW b^ iraet7v
W
:
Heindorf fiaetTv BT b9 jxtvr' &>/ B' W îv &v BT ir^

W
: :
<ri/ BT : (r{> irjj B^ C r t^5' B : ri Si T c 6 rivSt B ":
Tovrov T trtpov T ; wp^rtpov B Olymp. ^ (post ertpov) B Olymp. :
Tj T 09 \tyofjifv TW: iXiyontv B d6 &\\o Ti B : rj

&\\oT
;
*AIAX2N 73 d
eiSo? Tov 7rai5o? ov ^]v ?; Kvpa; tovto ê ecrTiv ava^vrja-ts'
&(nTp ye Kal '2ip.p.Lav tis Ihuiv TroAXaKis KcjSrjTOS avepLVijadr],

Ka\ aWa ttov p.vpia TOtavT av ^tr]. lo
MvpCa p.VTOL vr] Ata, I^t/ 6 2i/ijuiias.
OvKow, ^ 8' os, ro rotoSroy avapivrja-Cs tls eort; ftaAto-ra e

pLVTot oTav Tts TovTo TTaOr] TTfpl eKetva h vtto yjtovov Kal tov
fxj) iTTt(rKOTTtv 7/8jj (TTeXi^r](rTo;
Hdvv pikv ovv, <f>r].
Tt 8e'; 7] 8' os* eo-rty Ittitov ycypafxpiivov tboirra Kal 5
Kvpav yypappvr]v av6p(aiTOV avaixvr](rdfjvat, Kal ^tjXfxtav

IbovTa yeypapLjxevov Ke'/3r;ros ava]xvr](r6rjvat;
Xlaiw ye.
OvKovv Ka\ ^tfxixCav ibovTa yeypap.ix4vov avrov îfXfxCov
avaixvr](rdr]vat; 10
"EoTt ixivTot, ((f)r]. 74

'Ap' ovv ov KaTo, TTCLVTa ravTa (rvfxfiaCvet ti]v avd[xvr](rtv
(tvai fxkv d(f)^ 6fxoC(ov, (Tvat 8e Kat aTro dvofxoCuiv;
2vfxj3aCvet.
I
'AAA' oTav ye ciTro t&v ofxoCuiV dvafxifxvrj(rKr]TaC tCs rt, ap 5
ovK dvayKalov Tobe TTpocnTd(r)(iv, (vvoelv eire rt eAXetTrei

TovTO KaTCL Tr]V opotoTr^Ta etre /lit) (KeCvov ov dvfxvi](rdr]
'AvdyKr], i(^r].
^KOTrei 8rj,^ 8' o?, et TavTa ourco? exet. (pafx^v ttov tl

etrai lo-oi', ov ^vkov Ae'yaj ^tÂci) ov8e XCdov XCd(o ovb' aAAo 10
rwy TOLovToav ovbiv, dXkd iTapd TavTa TTavTa Tp6v Tt, airrb
To Xcrov (})wpiV ri eirai rf fxrfbiv;
<P(!opev fxdvTot vr] At", (f)rj 6 1,tfxfxCas, 6avfxa(rT6is ye. b

^H Kat eTTtoTa/jieâ avTo o icrTtv;
Tldvv ye, 8' o?.
rf
no'êy X.a(36vTes avTov Tr]v (TTKrrrjfxrfv; dp' ovk e cov
vvvbrf Ikiyofxev, r] ^vXa r) X.l6ovs 77 oAAa aTTa lb6vTs 5
dp 76 B'TW : om. B eg avrov B: aZ rov T a 10 &\\o

B T &\\o T B'
: W a 1 1 ravra rrd.vTaB Travra ravra T W
W
:
a 12 t5 B^ T : Tf B b i nfvroi B : rolvvv T b 2 iariv BT

iarLv Xffov W : X<tov in marg. B^ T^"
:
74b nAATXlNOS
L(Ta, (K TOVTOiv (KeXvo iv(vor](ra[XV, (repov ov tovtmv; rf
ov\ erepov aoi (f)aCveTaL; (tkoitcl bk kol Trjbc. ap' ov XlOoi
fjicv ta-oi Kal ^vKa kvCore Tavra ovTa to) p.(.v la-a âCvtTaL,
T(o ov;
lo T\6.vv /uey ow.
C TC hi; avra tcl l<ra iarLV ot( avLO-d <roi (f>6.vri, 17 ^ lcrorrjs
avLcroTrjs;
OvbeiKaTTOTe ye, on 2<aKpares.

Ov TOVTov 6.pa ecTTLV, ?J
8' os, TavTo. re to. Xa-a kol avrb
5 To lcrov,
Ovhap.Sis p.0L <\>aLveTaL, ^caKpaTes.

'AAAa /xT/y e/c tovtojv y , e^rj, T&v ta-ctiv, eTepcav ovtmv
^KeCvov Tov ta-ov, op.(os avTov rqv eTTLOTrifj.riv evvev6r]K6.s t
Kal et\r](f)as;'
10 'AAjyêorrara, e^Tj, Aeyeis.

OvKOVV r] 6fX0i.0V OVTOS TOVTOLS 1] a.VO}XOLOV;
Tlavv ye.
AiacfiepeL be ye, r/ 8' os, ovbev ecos ^v aWo Iboiiv aTrb
d TavTTjs Trjs o\jreoos &.KX0 evvor](Tr]s, etre o]j.olov etre av6]ioLov,

avayKOLOV, ^(f)rj, airrb avaixvrâ-LV yeyovevaL.
Vlavv {xev ovv.

Tt bi; i] b' os' ^ Trdaôfxev tl tolovtov irepl tcl ev toXs
5 ^vKoLS T Kal ols vvvbr] k\eyo]xev toXs tn-oLs; apa (âiveTai

qfx^LV ovToos taa eTvai wa-Trep avTo to b ea-TLV, // evbel tl
eKeivov toj tolovtov elvaL olov rb tcrov, r] ovbev;
Kal TToKv ye, e(f>r], evbeL.
OvKovv 6pi.oKoyov]xev, oTav tls tl Iboov evvoi]a~r] otl /3ov-
10 KeTcu ]xev tovto o vvv eyoj opoi eimt olov aXKo tl toov ovTOiv,
e i^Mi b^ Kal ov bvvaTaL tolovtov eirai [lo-ov] olor eKelvo, dAA.'
b6 B Jfffo ri ttra T b 8-9 rw t^ B yp. W rSTt . . roTf

T W yp. B
: . . . : .
C 13 &/ B : yap &' B' T W d I afifioiov tfre Sfxotov T

d 4 5e ; B Si r6S' T
: d 5 roh W : iv ro7s BT d6 tJ. ft W :
tJ pr. B (ut vid.): h T : om. B in ras. ^crrtv B W :iariv Xaov T b

T T W : Ty B d 7 T^] rov Heindorf e i iaov secl. Mudge
oAA' ffTxi/l oAA' a.\K6 iariv in marg. B^
*AIAX2N 746
((m.v (âvkoTepov, avayKoiov ttov tov tovto Ivvoovvra Tvyjdv
TrpoeiSora iKilvo w ^rjcrw; avTo TTpo(rioi.Kivai p.iv, ivbaTp<i)s
be ^xeiv;
'AvdyKrj. 5
Tt ovv; To TOLOVTOV TTTr6v6aixev Kal rjiJiels rf ov Trept re
To. Xcra Ka\ avrb to i(rov;J
IlavTdTtacrL y.__f
'AvayKalov apa Tjfms Trpoei.bevai. to Xcrov irpb Klvov tov
XPOVOV 0T Tb TTpSiTOV lh6vTS TO. X<Ta Vvori(rap.V otl 75
afiYTai. [jikv irdvTa Tairra ^tvai oXov Tb Xcrov, \i.
vb(rTp(as.
"EoTi TaOra.
'AAAa ixi]v Kal T6b 6p.oXoyovpLV, p.r] akkoO^v airrb v- 5
vVor]Kvai, jxrjbc bvvaTbv tivat ivvorjcraL dAA' rj K tov Ib^Xv
1] a\\ra(r6aL 17 K tlvos akkrjs tQ>v ala-6ri(T(ov' Tavrbv b
TTavTa TavTa Xeyo).
TavTbv yap ioTLV, w Sw/cpare?, Trpos ye 6 /3oi;Aerat
SfjXoiorat 6 X6yos. 10
'AAAa p.v 87) K ye T5iv al(rdj]cr(tiv 8et ivvoij^raL otl
irdvTa tcl V Tals al(rd-q(r(rLV Klvov T opiy^TaL tov 6 b
eoTty Xcrov, koX avTov vba-Tpd kcrTLV 7/ ttws Xyop.v;
Oi/TCO?.
Ylpb Tov apa apâcrdaL rjpM.s opav Kal dKovLV Ka\ raAAa
ato-âveo-ât tv\lv eSet ttov etATjcôras TTL(rTrjiJ.r]v avTov 5
Tov X(rov OTL (TTLV, L iX\Xo]XV To. K T(av alcr6r]cr(iiv lcra
KL(r dvOL<TLV, OTL '!Tpo6vp.LTaL fJJV irdvTa TOLaVT LVaL (KOV

KLVO, OTLV bc avTov (f)av\6Tpa.
'ArayKjj k Ta>v 7TpoLp7]pi.V(ov, S) ^(aKpaTfS.

OVKOVV yv6p.V0L V6VS (iOpa>IXV T Kal riKOVOp.V KClLTaS 10
fiAAas aia^d-qcT^LS X\o}Xv;
Yldw ye.
TW:
e2 Ti;x*'V BT : rv^xa'*'' B" W e6 t2> Tb : om. B ^ B'
om. B ag ôp in marg. T aii 7 TW: om B
D T B
I T : 7 W rov B : Tovd' T b4 rov &pa B : yap rov T
prius /co} B : ^ T b 7 ToiaCT' B : Tck TOtaCTo T
75C nAATX2N02
C E8ei be y(, â/xeV, irpo totIjtu)P ttiv tov lcrov iTrurrrifirjv
el\r}<f>(vai;
âC.
IIplv yfvia-Oai. &pa, <as ioiKfv, iof&yKr] rnuv avniv elKrf-
5 (îvai.
"Eoifcer.
OvKovv fl pkv Kaôirres avTrjv irpb tov yeviaOaL \oifT(s

ky(v6p.(da, ^mard.fifda Kal TrpXv yevia-Oai koI evOvs yevo-
fifvot ov fiovov To lcrov Ka\ to pielCov Kal t6 eKarrov oKKa
10 Kai a-vjiTTavTa to. TOiavra; ov yap Trepl tov laôv vvv 6 Koyos
i]iuv imKKov ri rj Kal Trepl avrov tov koKov Kal avrov tov
d ayaOov Kal btKaiov Kal ocrCov Kai, oirep Kiyco, TTfpl aTrdmoiv
oh Tna-(f)payi(6iJLda t6 " avT6 6 lori " koI kv Tais ^puiTri-
a-eaiv ipMToivTes Kal ev Tais aTroKpla-ea-iv dLiTOKpiv6p.fvoi.
&aT( avayKoiov rfp.lv TovTUiv TiavTUiv Tas iTnaTiffias 7rp6 tov
5 yeveaOai. dKr](f)^vai.
'Eo-ri TavTa.
Kal el p.(v ye Kafi6vT(s 4K(ioTore fxrf ^TnKeKTâ-fieda,
(IboTas ael yCyveadai Kal Stel bia ^Cov db4vai' t6 yap
(lb4vai TOVT Hcmv, Ka^6vTa tov kTnarrffxrfv ^xî.v Kal fiif
lo aTToKoi)KKvai,' fj ov tovto Kr]6r]v Keyofxev, Si 2i/x/iia, iin-

anfffxrfs i.iroôKr^v;
e YlAvTU)S br]T:ov, lc^tj, S '2,<S)KpaT(s.
Ei 8^ y( dtpLai, Ka^6vT(s irpiv yeveaOat yiyv6fX(voi dTro)-
Kiaap.(v, varepov b( raiy ala-6i]a-(a-t, \p<ap.(voi iT(pl avra

iK(Cvas avaKafxfiavop.(v Tas iiTiaTrfixas &s 7tot( Koi iTplv
5 (lxop(v, ap' ovx 6 KaKovfx(v p.avd6.v(iv olK(iav h.v kTTi.<rrr]p.r]v
avaKap.l3dv(iv drj; tovto b4 ttov &vap.ip.vr]aK(a-6a{, K(yovT(s

6p6S)s h.v Kiyot.p.(v;
Yl6w y(.
C I rovTiDV B T roxnov B'

: C 11 ^ T om. B W
d a t8 ainh :
scripsi : toCto BTW rh lambl.

: d^ ^/uiv B rifiiv *lyai B'T : W
irivruiv B : 'airivroiv B' T W
d 7 /i^ iKi<Trort B' T d 8 d- W
i6ra^ B W t tli6rfi T b #tal Af l T ital B W
d 10 i S<m/u.o
:
W
:
om. T e I itivriDi B T xavrfXwi B' 63 avrii B T : raira

W
;
e5&vT:om. B e6 tr T : ii' f rij B

4>AIA12N 76a
Avvarov yap 8^ tovto ye icfidjrr], ala-dofx^vov tl r) ibovTa 7^
rj tj Tiva aWrjv aL(T6r\cnv XaôvTa ^Tepov ti 0.1:0
aKovcravTa
TOVTOv (vvofiaraL b eTreAeArjoro, o) tovto eTrATjcrtaêy avojxoLOV
01/ 17 0) op.OLOv' (oore, OTrep kiyco, bvoXv daTepa, iJtol eTTi-
(rTdjXivoL ye avTo. yey6vap.ev Kal iTTLo-Tdp.eOa 8ta /3iou Trayrey, 5
1] varepov, ovs (f)aixev ixavOdveLV, ovbev dAA' 7/ dvap.Lp.VT]-
(TKOVTaL ouroi, KOL Tj p.d6r]crLS dvdp.in](rLS ^v urj,
Kal p.d\a bi] ovro)? exft, 2wKparey.

rioVepoy ovv aipf], 2 2,Lp,p.La; kTrLarap.ivovs rjpMS yeyo-
vevai, r] dvap.Lp.vr\(rKcr6aL voTfpov S>v TrpoTfpov TrLcmr]p.r]v b
eiArjfôVes ^p.ev;
OvK eâ), 2) ScoKpares, ey r^ irapovTL kkia-6aL.

Ti 8e; roSe e^f is eAeo-âi, koX tt^ o-oi Soxei 'Trepl avrov;
dvrjp eTTioTa/xeyos Trept (Sy eTTiorarat exot hv bovvaL koyov 5
rj ov;
IIoAA^ dvdyKT], (f)r], S) 2(ricpares.
'H Kat boKovaC aoL irdvTes exety StSoVat Aoyoy Trepi tov-
T(t)V &v vvvbr] kkiyo]xev;
BovkoLp.r}v pLevTav, (f)r] 6 2t/xjutas* dAAa ttoAu fxdkkov 10
(f)o(3ovp.aL ]xr] avpLov Tr]VLKdb ovk^tl r] dv6p(i)Tto)v ovbiLs

d^L(t)s oXos re tovto TTOLfjaaL.
OvK apa boKovaC aoL iirCaTaaâC ye, (pr], S) 'S,L]xp.Ca, C
Trdrre? avTd;
Ovba]x5is,
* AvapLLp.vf]aKovTaL apa a -noTe p.a6ov;
ÂvdyKT]. 5
rioVe kaôvaaL ai yfruxal r]]xG)V Tr]V fTnaTrJixrjv avTotv; ov

ydp br] d(f)' ov y &v6p(aTT0L yy6vap.v,
Ov brJTa.
ripoVepoi; apa,
fiaC. 10
a I atl<r6av6fitv6v W a4 Qdrepov B" T W ; tvl (Ttpa B b4 r6Se

W : om. BT C4 S Trore B : irore i T C 6 airruv B : om. T
76 c nAATIiNOS
llaav &pa, S ^LfXfxCa, al ^vxal Kal iTpoTcpov, mplv
(tvai ev av6p<aTT0v (tbei, x^Pi-^ a-(ap.dT(av, Kal (f^povrjaLV
(txov.
Et fxr] apa ap.a yiyvopLevoi kap.âvop.(v, S ItaKpaTf^,
15 TavTa^ Tas încrTripMr ovtos yap AeiTTCTai Iri 6 xpovos.
d Ya.V, Zi kToipc aTT6\Kvp.(V b^ avras (v ttol<o 6XK<a \p6v(o;
ov yap 87) (\ovTes ye avTas yLyv6p.(0a, wy &pTL bip.o\oyr)-
(rap.(v 1] iv tovt(d aiT^kkvpLev iv îTfp Kal \apLpdvofjLv ; rj
Ixeis oAXoj; Tiva elTTfLV xp6vov; 1
5 OvbapL&s, ui SwKpaTes, &Wa Kkadov ipMVTov ovbiv (1-
TT(jiV._\
*Ap' o5y ovT<as ^x** ^^^ W*^> ^ ^LHfiCa; d fikv t<mv

b. Opvkovfifv aeC, Kakov t4 tl koi &ya6bv Kal TTaa-a r) TOLavTr)
ovaCa, Kal (ttI Tavrqv tcl ^k tu)V ala-d^crfoiiv TrdvTa dva-
e 4)pop.fv, VTTapxova-av irp^Tipov dvivpCcrKOVTfs ^fxer^pav
ovaav, Kal TavTa (KfCvr) diTLKdCofJL(V, dvayKalov, ovTCiiS toa-TT(p
Kal TavTa (otlv, ovToas Kal ttjv rjfX(T(pav \j/vxi]v dvai Kal
npXv yeyovivai rffULS' d b\ fir\ iari Tavra, aWais hv 6 \6yos
5 OUTOJ (lpr}fX(Vos (irj; dp 0VT<iiS i\fi; Ka\ lcrrf dvdyKrf TavTa
T (IvaL Kal Tcis rjfx^T^pas \lrvxas iTplv Kal 17/xas yeyov^vaL,
Koi (l fxrf TavTa, ovbi Tdb(;
'TiT(pcfivois, S ^<aKpaT(S, (<f)rf 6 ^LpLfiCas, boKd fxOL f]
avTif dvdyKrf dvaL, Kal ds Ka\6v ye KaTa<fi(vy(L 6 \6yos ds

77 To ofxoCois dvaL nffv tc yfrvxrfv rffx&v TTplv y(V((rdat rffxds Kal
Tqv oiicrCav rfv crv vvv \4y(Ls. ov yap Ix^ lywye ovbiv
ovTdi fxoL ivapy(s ov 0)5 TovTo, t6 TTdi^Ta TCL TotaCr' cimi ojy
oloy T /xfiAioTa, KaAov T Kal dyadbv Kal ToAAa TTdm-a h
S ov wvbrf i\(y(S' Kal l/itoiyc boKd LKavws dTTob(b(LKTaL.
TC bi brf K4^r]TL; i<prf 6 ôiKpdrqs' bd yap Kal K4^r]Ta

TTeC^^LV.
'lKava>s, l</)Tj 6 ^LfxfxCas, uis (yaiyt oTfxaL' koCtoi KapT(p<o-
eii Tfiip iw Vf c 14 ifia W: om. BT c 15 S om. W

d3 ^.' ^Ttp B : ^wtp T di (<t>v Vfuy ?x' W^ d8 t. B T W :
om. B e8 i (rit>Kpa-Tn W a^ irivra BT: -arra B'W

as ifutl iUKti B:
il<t>ri
1/10*7 ^^^: ixol 7 W

raro? avdptairuiv koTiv Trpos t6 aTna-Teiv Tols Aoyoi?. aXK
oi/xai ovK evbem tovto TreTreicrâi avTov, ori Ttplv yevia-Oai
fjpLas 'qv 7}p.GiV T} \j/vxTri' el ix.ivTOi koX iireLbav a.TToOavuip.ev b
eri ârrai, ovbe avria p.0L hoKii, (f)r], <Jb ^(aKpaTcs, aTroSeSei-
Xât, dAA' ert fvea-TrjKev o wi^St/ Ke/Sjjs lAeye, ro rcSy
TToAAwy, OTTO)? fi^ a/xa d-TTOî^^ô-Korros roC av6pu)TT0v bia-

aKebdvvvTaL rj yf^vxrj Kal avTrj tov etvai, tovto Tekos j]. ri 5
yap KO)KvL yCyveaOaL pikv avTi]V Kal awCaTaaOaL a^xodev
TTodev Kal LvaL TTplv Kal (is av$p(oTTLov a-G)]xa a(f>LKea-6ai,
fTTLbav 8e a.(f)LKr]TaL Kal dTraAAdrrrjrai rovrou, t6t Kal avTr]V

TeXevTav Kal bLa(f)6eLpadaL;
Ev Aeyets, e^rj, S 2t/i)uia, 6 Ke'/3rjs. (âiveTaL yap c
&(nTp r]]XLa~v diTobebe^LxdaL ov 6et, ori Trplv yeveadaL r]]ms
r]v r]p.G)V r]
^XV> ^^^ ^^ TTpoaaTrobeiâL otl Kal eTreibav
dTTo6dv(i)piV ovbev rJTTOv ea-TaL 7] Trplv yvia6aL, et ixdkkeL

Tekos r] dTTobeL^LS eêty. 5
'A7ro8e'8etKrat ]iv, (f>r], oj ^Lpp-ia re Kat Kej3r]s, 6

ScoK/jdr?/?, Kat vvv, el 'ê'Aere o-vi^êtzât tovtov re tov
koyov els TavTov KaX ov Trpo tovtov oi)]xoX.oyr]a-aixv, to
yiyvea6aL TTav to ôjv eK tov Te6veS>Tos. et ydp earLV pev
f] yfrvxT] Kal TTpoTepov, dvdyKr] be avTr\ ets to (rjv lovaj] re d
Kai yLyvo]xevr] ]ir]bajx6dev dkkodev ^ eK davaTov Kal tov
Te6vdvaL yiyveadaL, tt&s ovk dvdyKr] avT-qv Kal eTretddy
dTTo6dvr] etmt, e-TretS^ ye bei av6LS avTrjv yiyveadaL; diro-
'8e8eiKrai ]xkv ovv oiTcp Aeyere Kai vvv. o/itos 8e ]xol boKeXs 5
(Tv re Kai ^L]X]xias rjbews dv Kal tovtov bLa7Tpay]xaTe1jcraa6ai

Tov \6yov eTL /xdAAoy, Kai bebLevaL t6 tS>v TTaibcov, ]xf] ws
dXr]d&s 6 dveixos avrf^v eKâivovaav eK tov (Tco^xaTos 8ia-
a9 (ttI' . . . airi<rT(7v in marg. T to7s in ras T b 2 $0Kf7

om. pr. W S> (TwKpaTfs f<pri T b^ a/j.a B'TW: om. B Sia-
iTKeSavvvTat Matthiae b 6 aixddfv Bekker &\\o0(v B T c 3 5et W
W
:
B S(7v T2t. B Htid T {d s. v.) 05 'e^dv T ^x^^v B

W
: : :
C 9 fievB: om. T dz koI B Te Kal 4kT d 3 avTiiv T b

W
: :
B (ut
auTT? vid.) 6.4 7 B Se T sed punct. not.
:
ai/Tiiv
avdisW ds X'7T Par. 181 1: AtysToi BTW
77e OAATIINOS
e <f)vcrd, Koi hiaa-Kebdvwcnv, cIAAojs re kol orav tvxJ] tis firf Iv
irqvejxia dAA,' (v fXyd\(o tcvI TTVCVfj.aTi dirodvria-KUiv.
Kal o KcjSrjs e7rtycA.a<ray, *I2s SfSioro)!', Ic^tj, ^<iKpaTs,

TTiipd dvaTT(ideLV' fjJdWov be pLt] ws rjficav bebLOTojv, dW'
5 lo-ojs 6V6 ris Kat er thjlIv Trals oaris to. Toi.avTa (fôjSelTai.
TovTov ovv TTCipcS nfTaTTcCddv ft^ bebifvai rbv OdvaTov &<nrp
TCL p.OpiXo\VKLa.
'AAAa XPV> *^^ ^ ScoKpdrrjs, eTrddeiy avroi Kdorr/s rjfiipas
i(tiS hv iêTTaa~r]T(.
78 YloOev ovv, i(f)ri, S) Swxpares, t&v tolovtcov dyaOov kiK^bov

\ri\lr6fj.e0a, TreiS?) (tv, <f>r], ijpids aTroAeiTreiy;
rioAAT/ p.ev 7/ 'EAAds, e^r;, S) Ke'/3rjs, ey 7/ VLa-[ ttov
dyadoL dvbpes, TroAAd 8^ Kal rd rwy âp^dpojv yivr], o-&s
5 Trdvra? )(p7/ bLfpevvdcrOaL ^r]Tovirras tolovtov i-n^^bov, p.r]Ti
-)(jir]ixdTO)V <f)LboiJ.evovs p.r]T Trdvo)v, ws ovk ea-TLV ets ori
dv (VKaLpoTepov dvaXCa-KOLTe \prr]]xaTa, Cw^^^ ê xM '^^*-
avTovs /ier' dAAÂwv to-cos' ydp hv ov8e pabCo)s evpotre

]xdWov vp,S)v bvva]xevovs tovto Trotetr.
10 'AAAd raCra /xey 87/, e07j, VTrdpêt, 6 Ke'/3r/y oêv bi

b dTTeXCiTOfXfv ^TTav^\do)]X(v, ei o"ot fibo]XV(o kcnCv.
'AAAd /xT/i; ribopievio ye* Trois ydp ov /xe'AAet;
KaA&is, e^r/, Ae'yets.

OvKow roto'v8e rt, r/ 8' 09 <5 2a)Kpdr7/s, 8et ^/id? dvepâ-dai
5 eavrovs, rw Troto) riyt dpa TTpoai^KfL tovto to irdOos Trdfrxetv,

ro 8taa-/ce8dwvo-ât, Kat VTrep tov ttoCov tlvos bfbLcvaL /xr/
TrdOr] avTo, Kal rw Tro^w rtrt (ôv)' Kal /xerd tovto av

7rLa-K\f/aar6aL iroTfpov [r/] >//"vX'/ ((ttlv, kol (k tovtv
dappelv rj 8e8ie'vat VTrep ttjs r]]XTfpas \frvxrjs;
10 'AXrjdrj, i<f}r], Ae'yet9.
C 'Ap' ovv rai /iey (rvvTiOivTL re Kat <TvvdfT<a ovTi (^vcrei
e6 irtipS) fi(Tair(l9(iv W : wtipdfifBa TfiBtty BT eg i^firacrrfTf

Vind. 21 T'^ : ^fairao-TjT* T: W
^{fTrofffjjTa B : W iîarrqrai. yp. et in
marg. t a i iyofloii' pr. T a 7fvKaip^Ttpov T
2iv : ava^yxaK^Trpo;'
B W 7p. T a 10 inrip^fi r</)rj B' T W b oiTfAfiVoMfK T W I
b4 avf ptffBat T Olytnp. W ipftrBai : B b 6 ri T W Olymp. toC B :
b7 oC add. Heindorf b8 ^ B om, T

: W
4)AIA12N 78C
TTpocrriKd TovTO Trda-xetv, biaipeOijvai. TavTr) fjTrep ovveTeOr]'
d 8e Ti Tvyxdvei. ov cktvvO^tov, TOVTta [x6v(o T^pooriML jn?/
nda-yjeLV Tama, eL-mp tw aAAw;

Ao/cei p.01, e(f)r}, ovtoos ^X^tv, 6 Ke^rjy. 6
OvKovv aTTep det Kara TavTO. koI waavTcos ex^'' TavTa
\xdk{.<TTa elKos (Tvai to. davvOeTa, to. be dkXoT dkkcas Kal
p.r]hiT!OT KaTO. Tavrd, ravTa 8e (rvvOtTa;
"Ejuotye 80/cet ovrojyî
"loop-ev brj, (f)r], eTTt TavTO. e^' OTrep iv tw epi.TTpo(r6ev 10
koyd). avTi} r) ovaria rjs koyov biboixev tov etvai Kal epto- d
rwi^res Kat diroKpLvopLcvoL, TroTepov 6)(ravT(jiis det eêt KaTo.
TavTCL ri dkkoT dAAcos; avTO t6 taov, avTo to Kakov, avTO^

Ka(TTOv 6 eoTiy, to ov, ^ iroTe ixTal3oki]v Kal rjVTLVovv
evbex^Tai; rj del avTwv eKacTTOv o (cttl, [xovoeLbes ov avTO 5
KaO' avTo, b)aavT(t}S KaTO. TavTa exet Kat ovbeiTOTe ovbaixfj
ovbapiOis dkkoCdiCTLV ovbefxCav vb\eTaL;
'il(ravT(os, e^Tj, dvdyKrj, 6 Ke^/STj?, KaTo. TavTo. ex^LV, Si
ScriKpaTes.
Tt 8e TU)V TTokkQv KakG)V, olov dvOpÔTTCOV 1] XlTITOiV r] 10
LfxaTL(i)V rj dkkcov oiVTLVuivovv TOLOVToov, r] Lcroiv [r/ KaAwi;] ?; e

apa KaTa Tavra exî V Trav
iravToov tohv Klvols ofxcovvfxctiv;
TovvavTLov eKeCvoLs ovtc avTa avroXs ovt dAATjAots ofSeTroTe

oi)S eTTOs etTretv ovbafxws KaTO. Tavra;
OvToos av, (f>r] 6 Ke'/3Tj?, Tavra' ovbeTTOTe b)a-avT<x>s exft. 5
OvKOVv TOVToov juey Kav aT/âio Khv tboLS kolv rat? dAAais 79
ala-dt]crea-LV atcrdoLO, tcov be KaTO, TavTa exdyTcoy ovk eo-Tty
0T<a TTOT dv dkkco e7rtAd/3oto 7/ tw tt]s Starotas koyLo-fxQ,
dAA' eoTLV aLbrj tcl TOLavTa Kal ovx opaTa;
C4 ravra B C7 ra] & Heindorf

(sed punct. not.) : rh,avTaT
C 8 5 BT : 5e flvai B^ W
Karh ravra B' T Kara ra
t d2
W
:
avrii Karavra B
: d. 10 Ka\wy secl. Classen e i ^^ ante
fcraii/ om. T fj koXwv seclusi e 3 ovn B T Koi oijre B : ' W
ovhiVitiwoTf B^W 64 ravrd B ravra ea-riv 6 5 o5 : B"TW
T b om. B ravra B^ T om. B
: a^ di5^1 aiSes, aiSrj constanter
:
pr. T Ars. atiSfs, det5^ B

: opard B bparai, T (sed ex emend.) : W
PLATO, VOL. 1. 8
:
79a nAATIlNOS
6 TlavTdTracnv, f(pr}, aXTjdrj Xeyeis.
Qutfjiev ovv jiovkii, ((ftt], bvo etbrj rCiV ovtcov, to ^v

SpaTov, To 8e dcbis;
&<DIXV, t<^r\.
Kat To fxkv dibis dci Kara ravra iXP^ '"o ^^ opaTov

lo nrjbe-JTOTe KaTo. Tairrd;
Kal TOVTO, (f)r], 6S>iiiv.
b <^cpe 8^, ri b' os, dkko ri fjn&v avT&v t6 fxkv a^&fxd iori,
To be yjfvxTi;
Ovbev aAAo, c^tj.
norep&) ovv ofxoiOTepov rw etSei (f>afXV hv itvai kui

5 (Tvyyivia-Tepov to crai/xa;
riavri, ^?7, TovTo ye SÂov, ort rw 6paT<a.

Ti 8e ^ V^^X^ 6paT6v jj dt8e's;
O^x V7r' dv9p(inTcov ye, ai SwKparfs, e^Jj.
'AAAa /x?)y ^juet? ye ra 6paTa Kal to. fxrj tt} t&v dvOpâTtoiv
lo (f)va-i i\yop.V t) aAAr/ rivi oiet;
Tr/ rcov dvOpui-nutv.
Ti oSv Tre/)! "^vxris Kiyofxiv; dpaTov rf dopaTov flvai;
Ovx dpaTov.
'Ai8es &pa;
15 Na^.
'OfxoioTfpov apa yfrvxtf (rdtfxaTos kariv r^ diSei, to h\ ri
6/)ara).
C X\d(ra dvdyKTf, S) 2(0K/)ares.
OvKovv Kai Tobf TrdAai kXiyofxev, oti rf >\fv\rj, orav fxh'
Tu> (Tw/jtari TTpoa^pifTai els t6 aKOTrelv rt 7; 6ta tov 6pdv rj
bia Tov dKovetv if

61' dWrfs tivos alaOrfaectiS roiTO ydp
5 iaTiv t6 8td Tov (rdifxaTos, rd 8t* alaOrfanas aKoiTflv rt
a6 /8ouA B T Stob. i /SouAt B^: W

b^ ô^JvTStob. <p<ufji*v :
B Eus. b 9 fih" T W
Eus. Stob. om. B b 10 iKiyotitv B- T
: W
(ante ipifffi) Eus, Stob. Ktyonfv B : b la Xtyontv B T Eus. Stob.
i\iyoix(v B' W t ^ kipaTov B Eus. Stob. om. T C 2 At- :
70^' B T W Eus Stob. xiyofitv Theodoretus : C 5 al<r9iitrtws

B^T W Stob. al<TH<rto,y B
:
<J)AIAf2N 79 c
t6t /xey ekKerai vtto tov (ru)ij.aTos ds to. ovbiiroTe KaTo.
TavTO. iypvTa, Koi avTq TrXavaTaL Kal TapdTTeTat Kai ciAiyytS

tSo-Trep fXfOvovcra, aT TotovTcov (f}aTTTOiXVi];
Uavv ye.
"Orai' be ye avTr) KaO^ avnjv (Tkott^, Kia- oXxeTai els d

TO Kadapov T Kal det ov Kal dOdvaTov Kal bâavTOis ^xov,
Koi &)S (rvyy(v-i]s ovcra avTov dei joier' (KeCvov re yCyveTat,
oTavTTcp avTri Kad* avrqv yevqTat Kal e^r] avrrj, Kal TreTravTaC
T Tov irkdvov Kal irepl ^Ketva del /cara TavTo. iicravToos e)(ei, 5
aTC TotovTcav kâTrroixivr]' KaX tovto avTrjs to TrdOrip.a <^po'-
vr](Tts KeKkr]Tatji
UavTaTTafrtv, (f)ri, koXZ^ Ka\ dXi]6ri Aeyei?, ^(OKpaTcs^

nore'p<i) ovv av (rot boKei tS> et8et Kat (k tG>v TTpocrOev Kal eK
T&v vvv XeyopLV(tiv "^XV ofxotoTepov etrat Kai (rvyyevi(rTpov ; e
Ilas dv /xot SoKet, ?]
8' os, a-vyx(opr](rat, S ^(aKpaTcs, ex
TavTr]s Trjs fxedobov, Kal 6 bvcrfxadio-TaTos, ort oAo) Kat
7raz;rt opiotoTepov i(rTL "yj/vxv T<f dei bxravTOis exoi^rt fxdXXov
V T^ M^- 5
Ti 8e ro a-Qfxa;
Tw Tp(a.
Opa bi] Ka\ Trjbe ort eTretSai' ey rai avrS So-t "^vx^ Kal
(Tw/ia, rw /ley 8ovA.ei;ety Kat dpx^^rdat 7/ (^vats Tipoa-TdTTet, 80
rrj 8e dpx^tv Kal bearTTOêtv Kal KaTct TavTa av iTOTepov aot
SoKei opLotov T(o 0eto) etrat Kat TTOTepov ro) 6vr]T^; 7/ ov
8oKet o-ot ro /xey êtoi' otoy dpxftv re Kat ^ye/xorevety TTe(f)v-
Kevat, To 8e dvr^Tov dpx(r6aC re. Kai ôvAeveti'; 5

'E/xoiye.
nore'pa) ow ^ ^^X^ ioiKfv;
AijXa brj, o) ^(oKpaTes, ort 77 /xey "^vxv ''w êto), ro 8e
(Toifxa rw dvrjT^.
c6 T(fTf BT Eus. tJ) B Stob. gT : d 3 t6 in ras. B

: W
d 4 7*Vtjtoi B T Eus. Stob. yiyvriTou B^ d 5 T6 B T 7
: t W W
W
:
d 8 oATje^ B T Stob. a\rj0ciy B^ : dg itp6(Tefv B^T Eus. W

Stob. ^/xwpoffdfv B
: e 2 yuoj B t/xoiT-s B^ T W Eus. Stob. : e 8 St;
B T Eus. Olymp. 5 Stob. W
a 2 tjj ex t^ T koto touto
W
:
B'^ T kotouto B
:
8*
8oa nAATilNOS
lo S/coTrei 8?;, I^tj, w Ke/^Tjs, d ^k 'navTOiv tQ>v (Iprjnevôv
b Tabe Tjfuv (rvfJLlSatvei., tS> fjikv 6(C<a Kal a6avdT(o Kal vot]T(o
Kal fjLovocLbel Kal dbi.aXvT<a Kal dfl wcravra)? KaTO. TavTa
iXpvTi kavT(^ ofxoLOTaTov (Ivai ^v\r], r<S be dvdpa)TTiv(D Kal
6vr]T(a Kal TToKveibel Kot dvoi]T<^ koI SioAutw Kal p.r]biTOT
5 KaTO, TavTO. eôyrt kavTU) ofjLoioTaTov av etvai (rS)]xa, lyo]iev
Ti irapd TavTa oAAo Xeyeiv, w 0iAe KelSrjs, rj ovx ovTOis exct;
OvK XOfX.V.
Tt OVV; TOVTOiV OVT(tiS \6vT(iiV dp' OV)(l (rdfUlTl fJLfV
Taxv biaXvea-6aL Trpoa-qKfi, \}fvxf] bi av t6 "napdiTav dbia-

lo Aurci) elvai. rj iyyvs tl tovtov;
C n(S? ydp ov;
'Ewoeis ovv, e<^7j, ^7ret8ay diroddvr] 6 dvdpoiiros, t6 /xey
6paT6v avTov, t6 crGifxa, koX iv opaT^ KeCfievov, h br] vKp6v
KaX.ovfjiev, w T7poa-r]KeL btaXvecrdaL Kal btaTrLTrreLV koI 8ta-
5 TTVela-6aL, ovk ev6vs TovTOiv ovbev Tre-novdev, dAA' eTTtetKoJs
avxyov iiTLfxeveL \p6vov, edv fxev tls kol yapLevTons eyutv to

(rSifxa Te\evTr']a-rj Ka\ ev TOLavTrj u)p<i, kol Trdvv fxd\a. avfx-
TTea-ov ydp t6 a-oifxa kol TapL\ev6ev, wa-jrep oi ev AlyvTrT<a
TapL\evdevTes, okiyov o\ov fxeveL dfxrjâvov oa-ov \p6vov
d ivLa bi y^^pf] Tov a-dfxaTos, Kal dv oraTTrj, oard re koI vevpa
Kal Ta TOLavTa irdvTa, ofxois ws eTro? etTrcii' dddvaTa cortv
V ovjj
I^t.
5 *H 8e yjfvxn d.pa, t6 dt8e's, t6 els tolovtov tottov tTepov
olxpp.evov yevvalov koll Ka6ap6v kol dtbij, els "Atôu ots
d\r]duis, TTapd t6v dya66v Kal (fipdvLfxov 6e6v, 61, dv 6e6s
b2 B Eus. Stob. Kal Karii T

Karii : b 4 i.vo^ffr^ Ktd ToAvctSct
T W Eus. Stob. b 6 jf Schanz ^ B ^ ij T Eus. Stob.
: : W ^ : :
marg. t^ du
: marg. b ca 4irftSiiy B: Sri iwtiSiii/ B' T Eus. Stob. W
C3 avTov rb B Eus. avrov T Stob. : C4 koI SiawyfTtrOai TWb
Eus. Stob. om. B
: c 7 &p<f T b Eus. Stob. W V*'p^ B :
d 5 'irfpov r6irov Ars. d 6 rhv ytvvalov Ars. d 7 rhv kyaShv

Ofhv (^Koi <t>p6yifi.oy) Ars. (ut vid.) ofS^ Ars. (ut vid.)
4>AIAi2N 8od
64\r], avrUa Kal rf] e/XT/ \l/vxfl Itov, avTi] 8e 8?/ yjfxlv ?/
TOiavTT] Kal ovTco TT<pVKvla aTTaXXaTTOixivrj tov adjxaTos

(vdvs bLaTT(f)V(rriTai Kal aiToXcoXev, ws (paa-LV ol ttoAAoI io
avOpcoTTOi; ttoXXov ye bd, o) îAe Ke/3rjs re /cat '2ifx]ita, e

ctAAa TToAAo) ixaXXov cS8' exet* ear //ev KaOapa aTTaXkaTTr]Tai,
^rjbev Tov a-(6fiaTos (rvve(()4\K0V(ra, aT ovbev KOiV(jL>vov(ra
avT<a iv tw ySio) kKov(ra eTvai, aXka (f)vyov(ra avTO Kai

o-vvr]6poia-]xevr] airrr] ds avTr]V, aT /xeAeroiora det tovto 5
To 8e ovbev aWo iarlv 7] 6p6m (l)iXo(TO(f)ova-a Kal rw ovti

Tidvavai /xeAerwcra pcibim' r] ov tovt av etTj /leAeV?; gl
davaTov;
HavTaTTaa-i ye.
OvKOVv ovT(j) fxkv )(ôva-a eh t6 ofxoiov avTfj to dt8e?
aTT(.pxTai, To 6el6v re Kot adavaTov Kal (ppovifxov, oX 5
a(f)iK0fXvr] VTTa.p\i avTr] ivbaifxovi elvai, iTXavrfs Kal avoias
Ka\ <ô'/3a)y Kat aypmv kp(aTO)V Ka\ tS)V aXXcDV KaKS)V t5)V
av6p(i)TTi(j)V aTTrfXkayfxivrf, cocnTfp be Ae'yerat KaTo. t5)V fxe-
fxvr]fXV())v, b)s aXrjdS)S tov XoiTTov yjp^vov fxeTO, 6(av bidyovaa;
ovToo (f)u>fXV, S) Ke(3r]s, r] aXX(as; 10
OvTco vr] Aia, e(f)r] 6 Ke'/3?7S.
'Eaj 8e ye oTfxai fxefxiaafxivr] Ka\ aKddapTOS tov ad^fxaTos b

aTraAAdrrTjrat, aT t^ crdfxaTi dei (Tvvov(ra koa. tovto depa-
TTevovaa /cat ipSxra koI yor]Tevop.evr] vtt^ avTov viro re tQv
TTi6vfXiG)V KCLi TjbovS^v, cucrre fxrfbev aXXo boKeiV eivai dXrfdes
dAA' 7j To (TcofxaToeibes, ov rts hv a\f/aiTo Ka\ iboi kol ttlol 5
Kat (f)dyoi Ka\ TTpos rd dcf^pohLcna xprjaaLTo, to 8e rot?
ofXfxaaL a-KOTcibes Ka\ dtSe'?, vorfTov 8e Kat ^tAocro^ta atpero'z',
d8 fleAft Ars. : i6i\ri BT W Eus. Stob.

e 5 avr^ eis eavriiv
(airiiv) B T W Eus. Stob. rh Ars.
: om. rovro B
B e6 : TW
Eus. Stob. ai âS/oij BTWArs.
Eus. Stob. secl. Hirschig :
a8 avdponrflwu B T (sed et ex i) avdpwwivwv C Ars, W ag 6ewv

:
B' T Ars. Eus. Stob. rwv Oewv B : b i olfjiat] 01 Ars.

b 3 yor)TevoiJ.(vq pr. T Ars. yfyoT)TfVfA.ivri B t Eus. Stob. ujr' avrov
om. Ars. Tf om. Ars.

:
b 4 r^Soywv Kal iwiBvfiiwv b 5 oAA'] W

iiA\o Ars. &v ris Ars. ^0701 Kal vloi b 7 <ropla Ars. W
;
8ib nAAT12N02
TovTO be eldKTixevri /^to-eiy re koI Tp^fxdv Kai (fxvydv, ovtco
C 5?/ ex.^^vcrav oUl 'ylfvxrjv avTrjv Kad* avTrjv eiAiKpu^ airoA-
Aaêcrât;
Ov8' oTroxrnoSr, <j)r].
'AAAa [/cai] bi.ikr}fxfx4vriv ye oijtxai vtto roO <ra;/xaroei8o{)s,
5 o avr?; 7/ 6/xiAta re jcat o-wov(rta roC adfxaTos 8ta ro aei

o"wetiâi Kai 8ia tijv ttoWi]v /xeAeVî' iveTToCrja-e aijfxcfiVTOv
Yldvv yj\
'Eju,/3pt0es 8e ye, S) (f^Cke, tovto oUa-6ai XPV îvaL Kal
fiapv Kal yecSSes Kat opaTov o bij kol ixova-a 7; ToiavTr}
10 V^^X^ l3apvvTaL re Kat cAKerai TroAti' ets rov opaTov tottov

(f)6lB(o Tov cLLbovs re Kat "AtSou, u>a-TTp Ae'yerat, Trept ra
d ixvi]fxaT(x re Kat roi/s raôus Kv\Lvbovfxevr], irepL h bi] Kal
b)(f)9r] ttTTa yf/vxfi^v (TKLoeLbrj (âvTaa-fxaTa, oXa Trapeôi^rat ai
TOLavTaL \f/vxal eiSajAa, ai fxi] KadapS)^ aTToXvdila-aL dAAa

Tov opaTov fxcTexovaaL, 8to Kat 6p5)VTai.
5 EiKo's ye, Z) ^(i)KpaTs.
EtKos p.ivTOL, o) K^fBtfS' Kal ov tl ye tus tu>v aya6Q)V

avTCLs ilvaL, dXXa Tas t5)V (f)avXa)v, a% irepl tcl roiaSra
diâyKaôyrat TrXavda-6aL bUr^v TLVOva-aL Trjs irpOTepas Tpo-
(f>r]S KaKT/s ovar]s. Kal fJ-^XP'- 7^ tovtov irkavStvTaL, ecas dv Trj
e Tov avv(TTaKo\ov6ovvT09, Tov (ru)fxaTOLbovs, Ittl6vpll(l ttoKlv
evbedSia-LV ets a-5>fxa' evbovvTaL be, (Za-Trep (Ikos, eis TOLavra

ijdv] OTToV ttTT dv Kal /xe/xeAerrjKutat rvxoarLV Iv roi /Sto).
Ta Trota 8?/ TavTa Ae'yets, u> 'E(oKpaT(s;
5 Otoi' Tovs pev yaa-TpLpapyias re Kat v/Spets Kai (\)Lko-no(TLas
fXifxekeTrfKOTas Kal /x?; bLTfvkalSripievovs ds Ta t^v ovcdv yevrj
82 Kat t(ov tolovtcov dr^pCcov cIkos ivbvecrOaL. 1] ovk oUl;

n.dvv fxkv ovv etKos Ae'yeis.
C 4 KcdB om. B' T Ars. Stob.

: SifiXrnx/xfvn pr. B c 5 re
om. W 8 8 yj rovro {& <plK(') ? Ars. oUaOal 7 09 5^) W
Kol B T Stob. 5^ : da W x""' ôv Ars. et mox w to(^
. . . . . . . . .
adivtt ds i/f<Jra)y Ars. 5 Swtporty] ^<^)7 Ars. d^ outAi

Ars. Toi/Toj B T
: Stob. W d 8 Tpo<pris B Stob rpv<pris T
W
:
e a Tojoi/To BT
Stob. Tv XvKOiv re Kal lepaKMV Kal iKTLvoiV
y4viT 1] TToX av aAAo(re (paixev ras TOiavTas levai; 5
'A/xeAet, I^tj 6 Ke/3rj?, ets ra roiaura.

OvKOur, 77
8' os, 8Âa 8?) Ka\ raAAa 7^ ar exaa-ra toi
/cara ra? avTiov opoLOTrjTas rijs jiieAerTj?;
AtjAov 877, e^Jj* 7r(Ss 8' ov;

OvKOVV evhaipovearaTOi, e(f>r], Kal tovtcov elal koI els 10
êkTKTTOv TOTTOV lovTes oi Tr]v brip.oTLKr]v KOL iroAtriKT/y
apeTi]v efTLTeTr^bevKOTes, r]v bi] KaXovcn auicppoavvriv re Kat b

StKatooTJfrji', e^ edovs re Kat jueAe'r>js yeyovvlav dvev </)tAo-
aôcf^Las re Kai vov;

rTf/ 8^ oSrot evbaLfxovearaToi;
"Ort Tovrouy etKo's eoriy eis tolovtov TTdkiv a(f)LKvela-daL 5
TroAtriKoy Kat i]p.epov yevos, 17 ttov jixeAtrrwz/ ?) acf)i]KS)v rj
[xvpixr]KU)V, Kal els tovtov ye ttoXlv to avOpcoTTCVOv yevos,

Kal yiyvea-Qai e^ avTUiV dvbpas ixeTpCovs.
EtKOS.
Eis 8e ye 6eQ)V yevos p.i] (f)LX.oao(f)r]a-avTL Kal TTavTek(^s 10
KaOapi^ aiTLOVTi ov dejxis acf^LKve^LaOai aXk rj ro) (f^Lkopadel. c

ctAAa TovTcov eveKa, w eratpe ^LpfxCa re Kat Ke73?7?, ot
opO&s (f)Lk6ao(fiOL aTTeyovTaL t&v KaTo. to au)pa eiTLQvp.L(av
aiTacrciv Kal KapTepovai Kal ov TTapabiboaaLV avraXs eavTovs,

ov TL oiKO(f)dopLav Te Ka\ TTevCav (f)oj3ovfxevoL, uâTrep ol 5
TToAAoi Kat (f)LkoxpripaTOL' ovbe av aTLpCav fe Kal abo^Cav

po\6r]pCas 8e8to're?, coaiTep ot (f)Ckap\oC re Kat (pLkoTLpoi,
eTreira aTreyovTaL avT^v.
Ov yap av iTpe-noL, e(f)r], w 'EcaKpaTes, 6 Ke'/37j?.
Ov fxevTOL p.a ACa, 7] 8' os. TOLydpTOL tovtols pev d
a3 76 om. Wa 4 re om. as Uvai B-T: thai B W

a 7 ^ BT W Eus.
^ Stob. oT recc. : eKoo-To B : Stob. fKaa-TTj W :
T Eus. a ir koX B Eus. re Kal T Stob. b^ ort B-T

: Eus, W
Stob. 3t oii B
: iariv om. Ars. a(piKf(r6at Ars. b 6 ôl
T Eus. Stob. re koI B :{T)î.4)rfpov Ars. (ut vid.) b^ /col
T 7): W
^ coJ B vv Eus. Stob.
: C i aK\' B &\K<f B=T lambl. : W
Stob. C 3 <îAocro<ôi T Ars. lambl. (pi\o(To<povvres B airexovrai :
T W Ars. lambl. exovrai. B c 4 n-oo-a;/

: C 5 odri B' T : W W
ox/x). lambl. : ori B
.
8ad nAATf2N02
uTracriv, d) Kefdrjs, (KflvoL ots tl /xcAei rrjs kaxrr<av ^v\r}9
aWa [XT] (TuiiJiaTi TrAarTorre? C^(tl, yaCp^Lv Lit6vts, ov
KaTa TavTci iropevovTaL avrols ws ovk eiboa-LV oin] iEp\ovTai,
5 avToX h\ rjyovixevoL ov hiiv kvavTLa Trj (f)L\ocro(f)Lq. irpaTTfLV

Kal TT/ ^KeCvrjs Xvcrei re Kal KaOapfx^ TavTr] br] Tpeiroirrai
iKLvr] kiToixevoL, eKLvr] v(f)r]y(LTai.
f]
riws, S) ^(lOKpaTfs;
Eyo) epia, (({)r]. yLyv(aa-KOVcrL ydp, ?]
6' os, ol (f)L\ofxa6(LS
e ort 7rapa\aôv(ra avT<av Tr]v yf/v)(r]V 7] (f)L\o(ro(f>La dT\V(as

biab(b[x4vr]v (V rw (r(6]xaTL Kal iTpocrK(Kokkr]]X(vr]V, dvayKa-
Co]X(vr]v b( too-Trep 8ia fLpy]xov 8ia tovtov o-KOTreLo-OaL tcl
ovTa dXAa fxr] avTr]v bC avTrjs, Kal (v Tid^nj d]xa6Lq kv\lv-

5 bov[x4vr]v, KUL Tov (Ipyixov Tr]v SeiyoVrjra KaTLbovaa otl bC
(TTLOvfxias ((TTLV, &)? hv jxdkLcrTa avTos 6 bebffxevos crvWr^TrTcop
83 eiTj Tov bebiadaL, OTrep ovv \(yo), yiyvîxrKOva-LV ol (f)L\oixa-
6(Ls OTL ovTo) TTapa\a(3ova-a 7] (f)L\o(TO(f)La \ov(rav avTwv

Tr]V \f/vxr]V "qp^jxa TTapa]xv6(LTaL Ka\ \vciv ^TTLXfLpeX, ivbeiKVV-
fxevr] OTL dndTr^s fxev /u.eo-rT; r] 8ia t&v d]X]xdT(t)V (rKi\f/LS,
5 diTUTr^s 8e 17 8ta Tcav u)T(t)V Kal tS)V d\X(i)v aLa-6r](reo)V,
TTeLôva-a be ck tovto)V fxcv dvayjiapdv, oaov fxrf dvdyKrf

avToHs xprja-6aL, avTr]V 8e els avTi]v (rvWdyeaâL kol
d6poLCfa-6aL TTapaK($vofX(vr], TTLaTevfLv 8e p.r]b(v\ dWia dAA'
b 7] avT-qv avTff, otl dv vor](rr] avTr] Ka6^ avTr]V avTo Ka6^
avTO tQ)V 6vt(i)v otl 8' dv bC dWcov aKOTTf] iv dAAois ov
dAAo, fxr]b(v r]y(la-6ai d\r]6es' (IvaL 6e to fxkv tolovtov
ala-6r]T6v re Kal opaTdv, 6 6e avTr] dpq vorjTov re Ka\ di8e's.
5 TavTr] ovv rf/ Avcrei ovk oiofxevr] buv evavTLOva-daL rf tov uts
d a 5 B ^<^7j 5 : B' T W d3 adixaTi aipiaTa B' T

B : W
d 4 TTopcuaovTai Ars. d6 koI t^ KaOapfjLif Ars. 5); Ars. om. :
BT d7 iKfivri om. Ars. d8 irij] TrcSy xiyfis fipri Ars.

d 9 (<pri om. Ars. e i ^ BT : om. W e a SfStnfvriv W
a I Tov Ars. (coniecerat Heindorf) : ry B T W
Ars. as &tii:v
BT lambl. okowvW :cal] ^ Ars. a6 airoxtoptTv V/ &'] av-
To7s om
Ars. a8 aA\' ct mox outV om. Ars. b i 'oti hv]
Srav Ars. et mox aiiro Kad' ujt^ ti ût vid.) h a hv om. Ars.
b 4 Tc om. Ars. t 6p^\ <^ . irpo<rex Ars.
. . b 5 oiv^ 8 b
. . .
:
AIAX2N 83b
aXri$m ($iXo(t6(\)OV v//ûx^ ovrco? direxerai tS>v r]hovQ)V re

KoX (TnOvixiStv Kal \vttu>v [xat (fioôiv] KaO' o(tov bvvarai,
Xoyiôixivr] ori, eTreiSai/ rt? o-(f)6bpa r]a-6f] rj (fôjSrjOy [rj
kvTrrjdr]] r] 7ti6v]xr](rr], ovh^v ToaovTov KaKov eiradev a^n
avTG)V S)V av ris oh^deCr], olov r] voar](ras r) ti, avak(t)(ras C

hia Tas iTndv]j.ias, dAA' o "navTo^v ]xiyi(rT6v re KaKwv Kal
^(ryaTov etrrt, tovto 7rd(rxet Kai ov Aoytêrat avTO,
Ti rovro, ai SojKparej; Ic^tj 6 Ke^rjs.
"Ort \/ax^ TravTos av6p(li)TTOV avayKa^^TaL a]xa re r](r6r]vat. 5
a-(f)6bpa T] XvTTr^^rjvai eTrt rw /cat ^yeto-ât Trept o dy ]xaX.iaTa

TOVTO TTa^rxr], tovto kvapyi(TTaT6v re etrat xai aXr]64(rTaTov,
o^x o{/r&)9 exoy raiJra 8e /xdAto-ra <(rd)> opara' t] ov;
Hdvv ye.
OvKouy ey rovro) rw Trdêt ju,dAtoTa KaraSeirat V^^x^ ^tto d

o-wjuaros;
riw? brj;
"Ori eKdoTT; ^8oi^ at Xvirt] ^(rirep rjXov exouo-a i:po(rr]XoZ

avrqv TTpbs rd (rS)]xa Kal iTpo^rTTepova Kal Trotet o-w/xaroeiST/, 5
boâôv(rav Tavra aXr]6r] (IvaL aTrep av Kal to (rQ)]xa

(f)fj.
(K yap Tov op.oboêlv roi (rca^xaTL Kal rois avrots "xaLp^LV

avayKa^TaL oTp.aL 6]x6TpoTr6s re xat 6]x6Tpo(f)os yCyveaâL
Kal ota ]xr]b7T0T ets "Atdou Ka6apG)s d(f>LK4(r6aL, dXXd det
Tov (r(opLaT09 dvaTrXia k^Livai, wore Tayy ttoXlv ttltttlv eis lo
dAAo (rQ)]xa /cat uxriTep (rTTLpo]x4vr] (]X(f)ve(rdaL, Kal e/c roT^rojy e
d]xoLpos elvaL rrjs tov 6(lov re Kat Kadapov Ka\ ]xovoeLbovs
avvova-Las.
b7 XinrcSi' Kol 4-iridv/xicov W Kol (pSâiv B et in marg. T : om. T

Ars. lambl. b8 ns] tis tj Ars. i) Kvnrierj T post ô-0j) B^ : W
(sed /cal pro ^ W)
Ars. lambl. om. B C i wv B T
: ws lambl. W :
Tis olrjdfiji tiu Ars. C 2 KaKwv T lambl. : KaKhv B 03 Vrt om. W

c6 (r<|)(^5pa ^ AuTrijfl^vat Ars. lambl. ^ Ai/TrjjeTJroi (xtpoSpa B et marg.
:
T om. T
: h] ov Ars. C 7 toDto . aKrjdeffTaTovl fidXta^Ta 8
. .
{S^) ehat TovTO Ars. C 8 to add. Heindorf d i virh B T lambl.

vwh Tov B^ W d 6 Kal om. Ars. d8 dfi^Tpotpos Ka\ dfidTpoiTos
B^ W
Ars. dg Ka6apSis fls atSov Ars. W
/jtrjSeiroTf post oiSov
Ars. d 10 di-ojrAeo toC (rwfJtaTos T Ars. lambl. W
I
:
836 nAATX2N02
*AKr}d(rTaTa, i^r], kiyns, 6 Ke/3jjs, o) ^(aKpaTCS.
5 TovTcov Toivvv evcKa, Si Ke/Sr/s, ol 8iKaC(ii9 (f)iX.ona6e'is
Ko^rfXLOL eio"i Kol avbpdoi, ovx. ^^ ol TroAAot fVCKd. <f>a(riv'

* \ y
7/ (TV OLi;
84 Oi) bijra eydiye.

Ov yap' dAA.' ovro) Aoytoratr' av yffvxv o.vbpb9 (f)L\o(r6(f)OV,
Kal ovK hv oirjdcLT] Tr]v jikv (f)LXo(ro(f)Lav xprjvaL avTrjv kv(LV,

Xvovarjs be eKfCvrjs,' avrrjv irapabLbovai rais rjbovaXs Kal
5 \vTTaLS avTr]v TraAty av eyKaTabelv Kal avrjvvTov tpyov TipaT-
TLV YlrjviXoTTTjs TLVCL (vavTL(t)s icTTOv y,TayiLpLôp.ivr]s, aXka
yaX.rjvr]V tovt(dv TTapaaKcvdCov^ra, (:T:op.ivr] tG> Aoyio-/ji<3 Kai
ael iv TOVT(o ov(ra, to aXrjOes Kal rd Bdov /cai to aboâaTOV
b 9((jo]j,ivr] Kal vtt' Klvov Tp((f)op.evrj, ^rjv re oterat ovrco
belv (t)S OLV Cf}>

iô,'- (TrLbav TeXevTrjaj], eis t6 (rvyyeves
Kal LS t6 tolovtov a(f)LKO]iivr] aTrrjKXdxdaL tG)V avdpcnTTLVOiV
KaK(i)V. (K br] Trjs TOLavTr]s Tpo(f)r]s ovbiv beLv6v /ij/ (f)ofir]6fi,
[TavTa 8' eTrtrjjSevcrao-a,] S) ^L]X]JLLa re Kai Ke'/3Tj9, otto)? /xt)

5
8tao-7rao-êtcra ev Tfj aTTaWayi) tov ar(ap,aTOS vtt6 tG)V av-
]i())V bLa(f)va-r]6Lcra Kal bLaiTTopAvr] oXyr^TaL /cai ovbev ^tl
ovbafxov f].
C 2'y'7 ovv kyiveTO ravra eZTroVros tov 2a)Kparous ctti
TTokvv yj)6vov, Ka\ avT6s re iTp6s rw ipr]]x4vio k6y(a r]V 6

ScoK/sdrrj?, b)s ibeXv ((paiveTO, kol r]p.G)V ol TrAeio-rof KffBr^s
be Kal 2t/i/xta? (r]XLKp6v Trpoj akkr^ko) SteAeyeV^jji;. Kat o
5 2a)KpdrT/5 ibtov avTO) rjpcTO, Tt; (f)r], vp.LV to. k)(6ivTa ]xu>v
pr] boKL ivbeo)s keyea-âL; TroAAas yap bi] (TL exei vTToyf/Las
Kol avTLkaâs, ei ye 8r; rt? avTO. /ie'AAet LKavcjs bLe^Levai. et
fxkv ovv TL oAAo (rKOTreio-ôr, ovbev Ae'ya)* ei 8e ri irepi
655 KcjStjs om. Ars. e6 tol BT t* koJ: B'W

<paffiv
om. Ars. &s airiiv Ars. : iavritv BT lambl. a^ aurij

Ars. aslambl.oS BT
om. : W 4yKaTaS(7v] iiri in marg. B'
a6 BT
/ifToxfipiC"/"*''"?* Ars. W lambl. ;uTax<ipC''M<"?' vulg.
:
a8 tJ) alterum et tertium om. Ars. b i oXtrai oZtws h(7v B lambl.

oUrai Sftv oijTm T Ars. ovtus oUrat St7v : b 4 5^ B' T W W
lambl. Se B b 5 5] 7' ci. Stephaiius inclusa secl. Ast :
W
:
c 6 AeVta-Oo B T AeA.'xeoi B' : t c 8 5e ti B 54 T :

AIAX2N 84 c
TovT(ov aTTOpîTOV, fxr)b(V aTTOKvri(rr]T Kal avTol elTTCiv Kal

btekddv, 4 777/ vfuv (âiviTai îknov (avy \e\6rivai, Ka\ d
av Ka\ efxk crvfXTTapakaîLV, ei n fifiAAoi' oUa-9e /uer' fjuoi!
viropy]a-i,v.
Kal 6 2tju,/xias e</)7j' Kat /otTjy, SwKpare?, TdA?j^?/ o"oi
p(a. Tr(x\ai yap rjpL&v l/cdrepos cmopGiv tov eTepov TrpooideX 5
Ka\ KcAeivei kpicrOai hia to (TnOvixeLV fxev aKovcrai, oKvelv 8e
dxôv Ttapiyîv, fx^q <roi arfbcs rf bia ti]V Trapova-av crvfx(\)opav.

Kai Off aKOVcras Ayikaakv re qpep.a Kai cftrja-tv BaâC,
0) îfXfxCa' 7/ TTOv xaXcTTCas av tovs aWovs av6p(ii)TT0vs ttcC-
(ratfxi 0)5 ov crvfX(f)opav rfyovfxai Tr]v TTapovaav Tv\r]v, OTe e

ye jU7j8' vfxas hvvafxat. iTeCdeiv, aXka ô/êio-ê //.?) bva-KoXd-
Tepov TL vvv bL(XKeLfxai 7/ ev rw TTp6a-6ev jSCcd' KaC, o)? eoLKc,
TO)V KVKVUiV boKQt (f)avX6TpOS VfXLV eimi TlfV fxavTLK-qv, 0%

e7TLbav ata-dcovTaL otl 8et avTovs aiTodavelv, abovTes Ka\ ev 5
rw TTp6cr6ev y^p6v(^, T^Te br] TrAeto-ra /cat KdAAto-ra aSoDo-t, 85

yey7/ôVes ort fxekXovcrL iTapa tov 6eov aTTievaL ovTrep eto-t
6epd7TovTes. ol b^ av6p(tiTT0L 8td to avToHv beos tov davaTov

Ka\ tS)V kvkvoov KaTa\}revbovTaL, KaC câcrLV avTovs dprfvovvTas
Tov 6<xvaTov VTTO X.VTTr]s eâbeLV, Ka\ ov XoyCôvTaL 6tl ovbev 5
opveov abeL oTav TTetvi] 7/ /5ty(S 7/ rtiâ dAATji' KviTr]v kviTrJTaL,
ovbe avTT] rj re dr^boiv Ka\ xekLboov Ka\ 6 eTToyj/, a 8?/ âo-t

8td Av7r7jy 6pr]vovvTa qbeLV. dAA' ovt TavTa fxoi cf)aCveTaL
kvTTOvfxeva qbeLV ovTe ol kvkvol, dAA' aTe oifxaL tov Âirdk- b

k(i)Vos ovTes, fxavTLKoC Te eio-t Kat TrpoetSoVes rd ev AtSou
_dya6d qbova-L Ka\ TepiTOVTai eKeCvqv Tr]V rjfxepav bLaêp6vT(t)s
1] ev rw efXTTpoadev \p6v(o. eyu) be Ka\ avTos rfyovfxaL

6fx6bovk6s re etyat twv kvkv(dv Ka\ lepbs tov avTov 6eov, 5
Kat ov \eLpov eKeCv(i)v TifV fxavTLKrfv exei^ Trapd tov beaTT^Tov,
C 9 TovToiv B TouTu T : d. I Si(\0e7i> BT StfêKOeTv B- W t
W
:
tiu add. ci. Heindorf e3 rt om. Stob. a i KdWiaTa (conie-

cerat Blomfield) : fi.a.\iiTTa B T Stob. et s. v. W a 6 ^170? B T W
a 7 6 om. W b3 Koi B re Ka\ T
: W b4 fiyovfjLai Tb Stob. :
irov oI/j.ai B (ut vid.) W b 5 Te T W Stob. 7 B : b6 x^ô"'

Hermann
85b nAATi2N0S
ovbe hv<r6vfWTpov avrcov tov ftiov aitdKk&TTfcrOai.. aKXa
TovTov y VKa \eyeLv re XPV '^^'- (p(>^Tav oti av ôvX-qa-de,
lo)? hv 'AdrjvaCodv kSxTiv avbpes erSeKa.
{
lo Kakois, ^(f)r], Aeyeis, 6 'Sifj.fJLLas' Kal iyu> re coi pu> o

C CLTTOpw, Kal av obe, ovk aTTob\Tai to. dp-qfieva. e/j.ot
f]
yap SoKei, S> ScoKpares, Trepl T(av tolovtu>v lo-cos &criTp Kal
<rol To fj.v a-a(f)s etSeVai iv t(o vvv ^L<a ^ abvvaTov dvai

7] 7rayxciAe7ro'i; tl, to fxivTOL av tol Xeyopieva Trepl avrwv fxrf
6 ov)(l TTavTl TpoTTio Ky\LV Kal fXT} TTpoacfjLaTaaOat TTplv av

TTavTaxfj a-KOTT&v dTretTjTj tls, tt&w fJMhdaKov etrai avbpos'
belv yap Trept avTo. V yi tl TovTcjiv bLaiTpdâcrdaL, ff fiaOeiv
oTTTf \L 7] vpLV 7/, et TOVTa abvvaTov, Tov yovv ê'A-
TtoToy T<av dvdpMTTLVOiv koyoov kaj36vTa Kal 8uo-eêAeyKTo-
d TaTOV, TtI TOVTOV 6)(^0VfiV0V U>(nTp eTTl OêStaS KLvbvVVOVTa
bLaTTkV(raL tov ^lov, et fxrf tls bvvaLTo d(r(f)aX(rTpov Kal
aKLvbvvoTepov em l3J3aLOTpov oxrjfJLaTos, [rf] \6yov dLOV
Tiv6s, bLaiTopv6rfvaL. Kal brf Kal vvv y(oy ovk ^TTaLa-)(yv-
5 drfcrofJiaL epia-doL, TTLbrf koll a-v Tavra Ae'yets, ov8' ifxav-

Tov aiTtdo-o/iat ev vaTp(a \p6v(a otl vvv ovk eliTOV a fxoL
8oKet. p.o\ ydp, cb '2(j!>KpaTS, TTLbrf Kal TTpbs ifxavTov

Kal TTpbs T6vb (TKOITU) TO. LprffXVa, OV TTdvV (paLV^TaL LKavSiS
lo elprja-daL.
e Kat 6 ônKpdrrfs, "la-âs ydp, (f>rf, u> TaLp, d\rf6rf aoL

(f>aLVTaL' dAAd Ae'ye otttj 8^ ovx LKavois.
Tavrrf e/xotye, 17
8' 6s, i] brf Kal Trept dpfiovias dv tls Kal
Xvpas T Ka\ \opb6i)V tov ovtov tovtov kdyov eiTrot, o)s ?/
5 p.V apfxovCa dopaTov koX d(r(afiaT0V Kal TTdyKoXdv tl kol

86 êtdy eo-Tir v Trj r}pfio(rixvrf Xvpci, avTrj 8' rj \vpa kol
b 9 es &i/ T W : fws B b 10 4yu> rt T W : iywyt B t c i i/xoi

yap T b ^ftoiyf B (ut vid.) W C4 fxtvrot aS ri B rh t>.ivroiT ra
W
: : :
rh Se roiavra ex emend. C5 oiixl BT:ouW C8^c/Bt:

{ T C 9 \6yov W Sv(Tf\(yKr6rarov W d 3 ^ secl.
Heindorf d6 o fxoi Sok(7 BT : fi /xo iS6K(i B' W ^3^8^
W : IJSt/ BT 4 \6yov rovrov W 65 a6parov T : k6par6v
Tl B
*AIAi2N 86a
al \opbal (T(i)p.ara re Ka\ a-(afJ.aTOibr] kol (TvvdeTa Kal

y(obr} eoTt Kol tov 6vr]Tov a-vyyevi}. CTreiday ovv 17 KaTa^r\
Tis Trjv kvpav ri 8tare/xr/ Kat btapprj^r] Ta^ xopbds, et ris
bu(rxvpiCo(.TO rw avT(o Aoyw uiaTiep av, ws avdyKri (tl etvaL 5

TTjV apiJi.ovCav iKeCvrjv Kal fir} airokookevaL ovbffxCa yap
liriyjxvr) h.v (tr] rrjy jjikv kvpav TL etmi bipp(t)yvL(av tS^v
yopbG>v KoX Tas xopbas î/T/roetSet? ova-as, Tr]v 8e ap]iovCav

a.TrokoL)k4vaL Tr]v tov deCov re KOt ddavdTOV opio^f^vrj re Kal b
a~vyyvr], TrpoTepav tov 6vr]Tov dTTokofXvr]v dkka (âCr]
dvdyKr] TL ttov elvaL avT-qv Tr]v apfxovCav, Ka\ irpOTepov tcl
^vka Kal TCLs xopbds KaTacrairq^rccrâL TrpCv tl eKeCvrjv
TTaOetv Kat ydp ovv, S 2(o/cpare?, oi/iat eyo^ye Ka\ avTov 5
(Te TovTO kvTdv]xr]cr6aL, otl tolovtov tl fidkLcrTa VTtokajj.-

^dvofiev Tr]V ^/o^x^y eirat, ^(mep ivTeTafxevov tov crdfxaTos
rifxGiV KotX a~vve\opLevov inrd êpfxov Ka\ \}/vxpov Ka\ $r]pov
Ka\ vypov Ka\ tolovt(dv tlvwv, KpdaLV etrat Kat dpfxovCav
avT&v TOVToav Tr]v yfrvxqv rffx&v, eiretSay ravTa KakSts kcll C
fxeTpCoJs Kpadfj Ttpds dkkr]ka et ovv rvyxdveL r] "^vxj] oxxra
apfxovCa TLS, bfjkov otl, orav x^^^^^V '"o (rGfxa rjfxQv
dfxerpois rf eirtra^T/ 17776 voaoiv Ka\ dkko)V KaKwv, Tr]v fxev

'^vxrfv dvdyKr] ev6vs virdpxeL aTroAcoA.eVat, KaCirep ovcrav 5
êtoraTTjy, wcrTrep Kat at aAAat dpfxovCaL aX r' ev rots
(f)d6yyois Ka\ ev tols tG)V br]fxLovpy5)v epyoLS TrdcrL, rd be
keC\j/ava tov crd^fxoTOs eKdaTov irokvv xP^vov TrapafxeveLV,
eo)? dv r] KaraKavdr] rj KaTaa-aTrfj
opa ovv Trpds tovtov tov d
Aoyov rt (^-qcrofxev, edv tls d^Lol KpdcrLV ovcrav rqv yp^vxv^^
tQ)v ev ro) acofxaTL ev rw Kakovfxev(a 6avdT(a irpdTrfv diTok-

kvadaL.
ALa^ke\j/as ovv 6 ^(jOKpdrr^s, caaiTep rd TTokkd etwêt, 5
a2 ffiiftaTa B acifia T ffvvOfra B ffvvBiTo. re T a4 koX

W
: :
B : ^ T &'] h.v secl. Bekker b i <5/xo<pii^ Ka\ ^v/jicpvr}
b3 avdyKri Baiter b 4 koI B t : kuI B' T W C i ixerpiiios
Kol Ka\wsW C3 r\nS>v B om. T: C4 iiri.TaQ^ T W : viroTaO^

B W marg.
et viro s. V. in t 05 avdyKij BT W a.viyKi)v t virap-
W
:
Xfiv B T W C T 7 eV : ot fV B d i KUTaKoud^] Karad^ pr.

d5 SiafiAf^l^d/xevos in marg. B*
86d nAATi2N02
Kol fjLCLbida-as, Auaia fxevToi, ((f)r], Aeyei o Si/x/iia?. d
ovv Tis vfJi.<av evTTopcoTepos ipLOV, tC ovk aiTKpCvaTo; Kal yap
ov (âvkois ioLKiv aTrTOfxevu) tov \6yov. boKfl fxevTOi. /xoi
Xpfjvai TTpb TTJs diTOKpCcreays (ti. iTpoTepov Kcj^rjTOS dKOVirai

e tC av obe iyKoXei t& Aoyo), iva yjpovov iyyfvopLcvov /3ov-
kV(r(ap.6a tC ipovpiev, îTdTa [8e] dKov(ravTas rj <Tvy)(jDp(lv
avTois idv tl loKuxn TTpocrqbiLV, iav b^ firi, ovrcoy rfbr)
imipbLKiLV Tov koyov. dkk^ dye, ^ b* os, S K4fir]s, Acye,

5 tC ^v t6 crc av dpdrrov [dTTLcrrCav Trapi^^êL].
Aeyo) 8^, ^ 8' 6s 6 Kc/Stj?. ifxol yap (paCvcTaL Iri iv

Tw avTS> 6 koyos dvaL, KaC, OTTfp iv tols Trpo^rOiv ikiyofxfv,
87 TavTov (yKkrffxa eyjeLV. otl piev yap ^v 7)pL&v r}

"^xh 'ôt
TTplv (Is Tobe To elbos ikddv, ovk dvaTCOffxaL fxr] ov)(l TTavv
XapLVT(tis KaC, cl fxrj iiTaxOes i(rTLV (Ittlv, Trdvv LKavias
dirob(beLxdaL' ws be Kal diTodavovToov rffxSiv (tl ttov (ttlv,
5 ov fxoi boKCL Trjbe. ats fxkv ovk lcrxvpoTepov Ka\ irokv-

XpovLbiTepov ylrvxj]' (T(t>fxaTos, ov (rvyx^^pS) Trj ^LfifxCov dvTL-
kr]\l/L' boK(L ydp fxoL TTacrL tovtols TTavv TTokv bLa<f>ipeLV. tC
odv, av (j)aCr] 6 koyos, (tl dTriorer?, iireLbr] opas diToOavovTOS
Tov dvOpdmv t6 ye d^rOeve^TTepov Tl ov; to be iTokv-
b XP^^''^'^^?^^ ^^ boKiL (TOL dvayKalov etvaL TL o-w^co-âi iv

T0VT(ji Tfc) xpdv<a; iTpos 8j) tovto To8e iiTC(rK\}/aL, et tl keyoi'
flK^vos ydp TLVos, b)S ioLKfv, /cdyo) u)cnTep "SiLfXfxCas beofxaL.
ifxol yap boKel 6fxoC(t)S keye^rOaL Tavra axriTep dv tls TTfpl

5 dv6p(6iTov v(f)dvTov 7Tpe(rl3vTov diroOavdvTos kiyoL tovtov
t6v koyov, otl ovk dTrdkoi^kev 6 avdpo)iTos dAA' eori ttov
<r<as, TCKfxrfpLOv 8e TTapixo^To doLfxaTLov h rffxiTeCxeTo avTos
v<f>r]vdfXVos Sti i^rrl <r5)V Ka\ ovk dTroAtoAei', Ka\ et tls
C d-nL(TToCr] avTw, dvepcoTôrf TT^repov TTokvxpovL(i)Tep6v icrTL
6.6 l S.iuLn.ias Xfya W ^B om. T

: e 2 8i B : om. TW
e4 oAAcf 7 BT W e 5 rb BT al.W : ft o.TrKyriai' vapfXfi secl.
Hermann e 7 ^fjiirpoaOfv W a a iivaTi6f/jLat W Olymp. AvTt-
W
:
rietnai BT a4 ro-Tiv B= T r<rTOJ B

: a8 irrfiii, B : iirfiS-f,
ve B^ T W b 7 (Tus Forster fawj B T : W c i iKnrToii,

Heindorf : &viffTuv BT W
4>AIAi2N 87C
To yV09 ovBpoiTTOv 17 ifxariou kv xpîa. re ovtos koX (j)opov-
fievov, aTtoKpivaixivov hr\ [rtiôs] otl itokv to tov avdputiTov,

otoLTo aTTobebeLxdaL otl iravTbs apa p.aWov 6 ye av9pu>TTos
0-0)? kcTTLV, e7ret8r/ t6 ye oXLyoxpovLcoTepov ovk aTToXcoXev. 5
70 8' oTfxaL, S) St/x/xia, ovx ovrco? exei" (tkott^l yap Kal av

a keyco. iras [yap] av vTToXafioi otl evrjOes XiyeL 6 tovto
X(yu>v 6 yap {/(pdvTrjs ovtos ttoXXcl KaTaTpCâs TOLavTa
t/xdrta Kat v(f)r}vdpLevos Klvu>v fxev vaTepos aTToXioXev ttoX-
\u>v ovTcov, Tov be reAevratou ot/xat TrpoTepos, Kal ovbev rt d
pLk\0V TOVTOV (VeKa dvOpOJTTOS kcTTLV IpaTLOV (f)av\6Tpov
ovb' dcrdevecrTepov. tijv avTi]v be TavTrjv oXp.aL elKdva
beâLT av "^vyi] TTpos (TU)p.a, Kai tls Xeycov avTa TavTa Trept
avTwv fxeTpL dv p.0L (paivoLTO keyeLV, ws ?/ iikv ^V)(r] 5

TToXvxp^vLov eo-rt, to 8e crwpa d^rdevea-Tepov Ka\ oAtyo-
XpovLCdTepov dWa yap av (()air] KdcrTr]V tG)V ^j/vx^v TToWd
adfxaTa KaTaTpi^cLV, dXkoos re Kav TTokkd eTr] (Blu). et ydp
peoL To a-G)p.a Ka\ aTTokkvoLTo eri ^cavTos tov dvdp(i>7T0V,
dAA' ^7 ^vxi] det to KaTaTpLJ36fXvov dvv^paivoL, dvayKalov e

fxevTCLV etr/, 6tt6t d-nokkvoLTO rj
"^xq, to reAerraioy v(f)aa-pia
Tvx^lv avTrfv ex^'^^'^^ '^'^'- tovtov fxdvov iTpoTepav diTok-

kva-daL, dTTokop.ivr]s 8e Trjs "^vxv^ t6t ijbrf rr/y <pv(rLV Trjs
dadeveias iiTLbeLKVvoL to awfia kol raxv aarTev bLoixoLTO. 5

coo-re TOVTia T<a Adyo) ovttu) d^Lov TTLareua-avTa Oappeiv b)S
iiTeLbdv aTToOdvoofxev TL ttov ifpcov 7/ yj/vxh eaTLV. et ydp 88
rts KOi TTkeov tl rw keyovTL r] a (tv keyeLs cvyxwpôêter,

bovs avT(a fxrf fxdvov ev rw iTplv Kal yeveadai rnxds XP^^*{^
etiâi rjpoiv rds yf/vxds, dkkd fxrfbev KcokveLV Kal eTretSdy
dTTo6dvu)fxev evicov eTL etmt Kat eaeaOaL Ka\ TroAAaKts yevi]- 5
o-eo-ât Kat dtToOavelcrOaL avOLS ovtu) ydp avTO (f^vaeL
C3 OLWOKpivoixivov T S^^ om. W Tivos seclusi C 7 yap

B: om. TW cg vcntpos BT et or s. v. W: vffTtpov 13- VV
d3 TauTijc B^ T W : om. B d5 avTuiv B* TW : twv avTuv B
fxiv f^vxh B : y^vxh f^fy T W
d 8 k&j/ B* TW : Koi t B jSi^ T :
/8jc(J77W B a I ^ '|"'X^ ^/ucDv T W a 4 Tas ^l/vxas B : t^V

^vxîv T W
88a nAATX2N0S
i<r)(ypov (Lvai, uxrTe 7roA.AaKts yiyvoy.ivT]v y^v)(j]v avT\tv
' bovs 8e TavTa eKelvo fxrjKeTi, (Tvy\u>pol, fxr] ov irovelv
avTTfV V Tals 7roA.A.ats yev4(r(nv Kal TeX.evToj(rdv ye ev
lo Ttvi. tG>v davdT(X)V TTavTdira^rLV dirokXv^rdaL, tovtov be Tov
b ddvaTOV Kal TavTrjv ttjv bidkva-LV tov (rwfiaros fj Trj
"^X^
(\>epeL okedpov p.r]beva (fâCr] elbevaL dbvvaTov yap elvai,
6t(oovv ala-9e(r0aL T]p,S>v ei be tovto ourcos exet, ovbevl

irpoa^rjKeL ddvaTov OappovvTi fxr] ovk dvor]T(i)s Oappelv, 69 &y
5 /xr/ e)(r] diTobelâL otl ea-TL ^vxv TravTdTTacnv dddvaTov re

Kai dvdkeOpov ei be [xt], dvdyKrjv elvaL del tov iiekkovTa
diroOaveLcrdai bebtevai virep rrjs avrov yjrvxv^ M^ ^v rfj vvv
Tov a-(ajiaTos bLaêvêL TravTd-nacrLV dirokr^TaL.
C UdvTes ovv dKovcravTes einovTOiv airrQv dr]bu>s bLeTedr]-
fiev, ws vaTepov ekeyojxev irpbs oAAÂods, ort virb tov

e]XT:poadev koyov (r(p6bpa TreTreLa-p.evovs rj]xds TraAtr eboKovv
dvarapdâL Kal eis dTrtoriay KaTajâkelv ov ]x6vov rots
5 TTpoeLpr^^xevoLS kdyoLS, dkka Kal eis to. vcrTepov ]xekkovTa

pr]6r]a-ea-6aL, ]xr] ovbevbs d^LOL eT]xev /c/otrat r/ Kat tcl TTpd-
y]xaTa avTa diTLcrTa 77.
[
EX. N^ Tovs 6eovs, S> 4>at8ajy, (rvyyv(ji>]xr]v ye Ix^ vûv.

Ka\ yap avrdv vvv dKOva-avTa (rov tolovtov tl keyeLV
]X
d 77/309 e^xavTov eTTepx^TaL' " Tlvl ovv eTL TTLaTevao^xev k6y<a;

b)S ydp a(\>6bpa iTL6avbs b>v, bv 6 StoKparTjs ekeye kdyov,
vvv eis diTLaTLav KaTaTTeiTTâKev." 6av]xaa-Tu>s ydp ]xov 6
kdyos ovTos dvTLka]x(3dveTaL Kal vvv Kal det, Tb dp^xoviav
6 rtva T]]xG>v eXvaL T-qv \lfvxvi^> '('î- w(r7re/o VTTe]xvr]aev ]xe pr]6els
OTL Kal avTU) ]xoL TavTa TTpovbeboKTO. Kal TTdvv beofxai

TTdkLV u>aTTep e^ dpxv^ dkkov TLvbs koyov os fxe TTeiaet &)$
Tov dTTo6av6vTos ov (TvvaTTodvr]aKeL rj '^vxil- keye ovv TTpbs
a7 riiv ^vxh" W fl- 8 fivK^Ti iK(7vo T br ^ T W :
r B b3 aiadftrOai T : al<r6a.vta6ai B b4 TrpocriiKfiv Stephanus

b6 ivdyKTiv BW t iLvdyKri T c 3 iraAij' T ird\at B : C 5 vffTtpov
W
:
W sed a supra ov C6 iXrifiiv T W ^fifv B : 07 avrk B^ T :
om. B ^j tlfrj Heindorf d i Kianvdofj.iv B irt<TTtva-ufifv T :

AIAi2N 88d
Atos Tnj 6 2a>Kpar7jj jxeTijXde tov Xoyov; koI iroTepov

KCLKelvos, ooaiTep vp.as (/)/;s, (vbr]X6s ri iy^veTo a\66pievos rj e
ov, aXka TTpaois ij3oi]9i. T(d k6y<^; [r;] koi LKavSis ijSo-^d-qaev
rj evbeois; iravTa rjpuv SieAê o)S bvvaa-ai aKpiîa-TaTa.
AIA. Kai p.r\v, S) 'Eê/cpare?, TTo\ka.Kts 6avfxd(ras
^(liKpaTrj ov TTWTTore ixaWov r)yaa-6r]v 7/ roVe TTapayevdp.evos, 5
t6 fxv ovv exeiy ort Ae'yot eKeii'? lo-oos ovbev aTOTrov aWa 9
eycaye ixdXi(7Ta edavfxacra avTOV irpwTov p.\v tovto, ois rjbioos
Kal vpL(V(is Kal dyafxev(tis tQv veavCaKâv tov \6yov dir-
ebiâTo, eTretra i]p.Qv o)S oêcos fjcrdiTo 6 VeTroVê/xey vtto

T(ov k6y(jov, eTretra &>s ev 7//ias IdaaTo Kal wa-irfp TreêvyoVas 5
Kot r]TTr]ixivovs dvKa\4a-aT0 Kal TrpovTpexj/ev Trpbs t6 Trap-

iTTea-dai re jcai o-i;o-/co7rety t6v \6yov.
EX. H&s bi];
4>AIA. 'Eycb epcS. (tvxov ydp kv be^ta avTov Ka6^-

fxevos Trapd T-qv KXivrfv eTrt \ay.aL0]Xov tlv6s, 6 8e em ttoAi b
v\jn]XoTepov rj eyw. KaTayj/riaas ovv fxov Tr]v K((f)aXr]V Kal
avfXTTLeaas Tas em roi av\ivL TpL\as etwêt ydp, 6tt6t
TvxpL, TTaCêtv fxov eis Tas rptx.as Avpioi' brf, e<^Tj, lo-cos, a>
'âCbcov, Tas KaXds TavTas KOfxas aTTOKfpr]. 5

EoiKei', ^v 8' iy(t>, S) ScoKparey.
OiIk, av ye e/xot TTC6r].
'AAAa ri; 171' 8' eyc.
TrffKpov, (f)r], Kayo) Tas (fxds Ka\ av TavTas, edvnep ye

?/ju,ti' o Aoyo? TeXevTrfarj Kal p.r] bvv(i>]X(6a avTdv dva^Loo- 10
aaa6aL. koX yu)y^ dv, ei av ir]v KaC /ute 8ia(/)evyoi 6 C
Aoyos, iVopKOV dv iTOLrâaCfxrfV cocrTrep 'Apyetot, fu] iTpoTepov
KOfxrfacLV, irpXv dv VLKrfaoi dvafxayofxevos t6v ^LfXfxCov re Kat
Ke/3rjros X6yov.
e I Ti B om. T 62 ^ B T om. al. Heindorf 65 Tore

W i)
: : :
B- T : B
iroT a 9 Kad-fi/j.(vos 4v 5f |io airou T W b l iroAi/
B : iroAAy T b b5 Toirras B^ T W B
om. b7 76 Vot BT
W b 10
:
TW W
:
iîoiyt ^vvuixida B^ : Svvdij.ida B c i Sia^pvyoi T

C 3 avafjLax^fifvos in marg. T
PLATO, VOL. I. 9
89 c nAATONOi:
5 AAA', ^v 8' (yco, irpos bvo Aeyerai ow8' 6 'HpanXfjs olos
T (Tvai.
'AAAa Kal (fxe, ((f^rj, tov ^lokfoiv TrapaKoXd,, etos rt
(f)Cis ((TTIV,
napaKaAa) Toivvv, (<^r]V, ov\ ws 'HpoKA^?, oAA' ws

lo loAecos Tov 'Hpa/cA^.
OvSej^ StotVet, I^tj. aAAa TipCiiTOV ivka^r]6G>p.iv tl Tiados
jUTJ TTadctip.iV.
o TTOLOv; r]v o eyo).
d M^ yv<aij.6a, ?}
8' os, /Lito-oAoyoi, uxnTfp ol îurav&poiTToi,
yi.yv6p.evoi' o)? ovk icrTiv, ec^r/, ort av rt? fielôv tovtov
KaKov TTadoi. rj \6yovs /xto-rj(ra?. yCyveTai be k tov ovtov
Tp^TTOv p.i(Tokoyia re koX p.i(rav6p(aiTCa. i\ re yap p,L(rav-
5 6pcaiTLa vbvTaL k tov (r(f)6bpa tlv\ Trto-reCo-ai avv re^x^^Tjs,
Kat r)yi](raa-6aL TTavTaTTaa-i ye aXr]6r] elvaL koll vyirj Kal

TTLCTTOV TOV av6piaiT0V, TTLTa oXiyOV V<rTpOV VpLV TOVTOV
TTOVrjpoV T Kal aTTLCTTOV, KCLL aV^LS TpOV Kal OTOV TOVTO
iToAAaKts iTa.6r] tls koll vtto tovtiov jxdkLGTTa ovs av f]yqa-aLTo
e ot/cetdr(irous re Kai kTaLpoTOLTOvs, reAeurwi' S^ dajua TTpoa-.
Kpov(ov fXKrel re Travra? Kat i^yetrat ovbevos ovbev vyiks
etvat t6 TTapdiTav. f] ovk r]a-6r](raL (rv tto) tovto yLyv6p.Vov;
Tldvv ye, r]v 8' eyw.
OvKouv, 8' 05, aL(r-)(jp6v, Ka\ br^kov otl avV T\vr]s Tr]S
5 1]
TTepl Tdv6p^TTLa 6 TOLOVTOS xpfj(r6aL TTxeipL rots dv6p(ii-

TTOLs; et ydp ttov fiera Texy^s expfJTo, c5o"7rep eêt ovrou?
90 av f]yr]craTo, tovs fjiev xprjcrrovs kol TTOvr]povs a-(f>6bpa
okiyovs etyat eKarepovs, tovs 8e pera^v TTkeiarovs.

Ylois keyeLs; e(f>r]v eyut.
"Q.aTTep, 7;
8' 09, Trept tS)V a-(f)6bpa a-p.LKp5)V kou. pLeydXiav
C5 oii5' S TipaK\7Ji Xfyerai B'' T W 09 roiuvv ^<f)-i\v B' W : roivv

icpT] B : i<priv roivvv T ws B : us 6 T Cir ((pri B om. T
:
d6 7f B' T W : Te B e3 o-i/ irw] (tv B et in marg. yp. W : oCir

TW oStco Stob. e6 ^jrx**/'*' Stob. 4-irtxeipt'i BT W i.v6pw-
W
: :
noi% B'T : av9poi)irfiois B a i rjyiâaro B Stob. : rjy/itrairo I b

a3 </>7ji' B : rjj' 5' TW
4)AIAi2N goa
oTei Tt (nTavL(i>Tpov etrat rj (T(f)6bpa ixiyav rj crôhpa crfxiKpov 5
(êvpelv avOpoiiTOV rj Kvva rj aXKo oriovv; rj av raxvv rj
^pabiiv ^ aicrxpbv rj K(xXbv rj Xcvkov rj p.4Kava; r] ovy).
r](T6r](Tai ort T:avT(jdV t&v toiovtoov to. p.\v aKpa tG>v kcrxaTOiV
(nrdvLa Kal oXiya, tcl b( pLeTa^v a(p6ova Kal TToAAa;
Yl(xvv ye, ^v 8' eyw. 10
OvKovv otet, ec/)?], ei TTovrjpCas ayoov TrpoTcdfCt], Ttavv av b

oAiyous Kal ivTav6a tovs T:p(oTovs (jâvrjvaL;
EiKO? ye, ?]y 8' eyw.

EtKo? ydp, e^J?. dAAa Tavrt] fxev ov^ opiOLOi ol Aoyot
Tots dv6p(i>7roLS, dXKa (tov vvvbr] TrpodyovTos eyob e(p<nT6p.r]v, 5
dAA' KeCvr],
f],
eTretSdy rty TTL^rTev^rr] Adyw Ttrt dArjêi
etvat avV ttjs Trept toi;? Adyovs T)(yr]s, KairetTa dAtyor
varepov avT^ b6^r] ^j/evbrjs eirat, evCore [xev cov, ivCoT 8'
ovK wv, Kal av6is (Tepos Kal eTepo?* Kat fxdAtora br] ot
Tre/Ji Tovs dfTtAoytKOV? Adyov? bLaTpC\(ravTs oXa-6' otl TeAev- c

TwvTes OLovTaL aocfxoTaTOL yeyovevai Kal KaTavevor]KevaL
\x6voL OTL ovTe tS>v TTpayfxdT(ov ovbevos ovbev vyiks ovbe
êâiov ovTe tS>v Adycoi;, dAAd TrdvTa to. ovTa aTexvuts uicnTep
iv EiiptTTft) dv(3i KaTO) orpi^peTai. koX xpovov ovbdva ev 5

ovbevl /xeVet.
Hdvv jxkv ovv, e(f)r]v eyco, d\r]6r] Xeyas.
Oi/Kovv, oi âCboiV, (f>r], oLKTpbv dv eCr] to TTdôs, et
ovTOS br] TLVos dXr]6ovs Kal (BeâCov X6yov Kal bvvaTov

KaTavoijaaL, eTTCLTa 8td Tb TTapayCyvecrdaL tolovtols rt(rt d
Adyot?, roty avrots TOTe fxev boKovcrLV dXr]dicriv etvaL, TOTe
be fxr], pL-q eavTdv tls atrtwro fxrfbe ti]v eavTOV dTeyvCav,
dAAd reAeurcoi' 8td rd dAyeir da-fxevos eirt tovs Xdyovs d<^'
a 7 KoXhv alcrxpitv TW oux' T W : ovk B a 10 76 B

fl
W
:
om. W b 3 7e : 5 BT b 4 ot BT : om. W b5 avOpw-

Kois B: avOpcoTTOis etVt'' TW i<pfa-Tr6fj.T}v T: t(pe<Tiroijj.i)v BW
b6 ^ secl. Madvig b7varfpov oXiyov T b 8 So|ej W W
C 2 Kal T W : T Kol B C 4 oijTf tuv \6ywv^^ ovifv twv vvtuv in
marg. B- ra B^ W : om. B T C 5 Ka.TCD T /cai /caTc B W :
C 7 t<prj B T : om. B" W C 9 S^ B 76 T : W

d i toioktojo-I
Tio-l T : TOiouToio-1 B t d 2 a\r)d((nv B a\7i6rj \fyfiv T
:
ds M^
alterum ora. pr. T tis om. W
9*

9od nAATi2N02
5 kavTov Ti]v alTtav ^nâaaLTO Ka\ i}hr] tov Xotirbv ^Cov fiKr&v
re Kol koibopSiv tovs \6yovs StareAoi, Tiav 6e ovTUiv Tijs
akrÔeCas re Kal cTrtoT^/Ar/s (rr(pr]d(Cr}.

Nr/ Tov ACa, rjv 8' cyw, olKTpov hrjTa.
YlpSiTov p.\v ToCvvv, ((f)r], tovto (v\a^r]6<afiV, Kal fir)
e TTapCoip.(V ets Tr]v yj/vxh^ ws Toiv koyoav KLvbvvevei ovbkv

aKXa
vyies eivai, ttoXv fxaWov otl Tjfxw ovira) vytS>s <ixo]iiv,
aXKa avbpKTTiov koI TTpo6vp.r]Teov vyiCas x^'^' '^^' /^^^ ^^
Kol rots aAAot? Kat tov Tretra /3tot) iravTos (VKa, c/xot 8e
91 avTov ^VKa tov 6avdTov, ws Ktvbvvevu) eycoye ev r<S "napovTi
Trept avroi; rovrou ov (fîkoao^fxiis exeir dAA' uxnrep ol iTavv

aTraCbevToi (^tAoyiKcos. xat yap eKelvoL oTav Trept rov d/ix-
(f)tcrl3r]T(o(TLV, OTTT] fjiev \L TTfpl oiv hv 6 Aoyos T] ov (f>pOVTC-

5 ôixrtr, oTTOiis be h avrol (6evTo TovTa 8o'êt rois Trapouo-tr,
TOVTO TTpo6vp.OVVTaL. Kal kydi flOL boKoi CV tS> TTapOVTL
TO(rovTov fiovov iKeCvoiV bLoCa-etv ov yap otto)? rot? TTapova-tv
a iyCt) Ae'ya) 8o'et dArj^^ etrat TTpo6vfxr](rofiaL, ei fir] dr]
TTapepyov, dAA ottcos avroi ejuoi ort /xdAtoTa 8o'êt ovtojs

b exetv. Aoytô/xat ydp, w <^tAe cratpe diacrai ins TrAeo-
veKTLKMS et fi\v Tvy\dvL d\r]6r} ovTa a Ae'ya), Ka\S>s brf
exet t6 7TeL(r6rivat' ei be firfbev eart reAevrT/o-arri, dAA' ovv

TOVTov ye ror ^povov avrov tov iTpo tov 6avdTov T}Ttov Tots
5 TTapova-LV dr}br}s ita-ofiaL obvpofievos, r) 8e drotd fiOL avTrf ov
o-w8iareAet KaKov ydp av 7/y dAA' oAtyov va-Tepov diTo-
Aeirat. f TTapea-Keva(rfLvos 87/, e0>/, w ^tfLfiCa re /cai KcjBrfs,
ovTOio-l epxofxat (ttI tov Xoyov vfxets fiivTOL, av e/xot jrei-
C 6r](r6, (TfiLKpov (fipovrCcravTfs ôiKpdTovs, Tijs 8e dkr^êCas

TTokv fidXXov, edv fiiv tl vfiiv boKSi dXr]6es XeyfLv, (rvvofxo-
Xoyrfa-aT, el b^ ftrj, Trarrt Xuyco drrtretrere, [evAa/Sov/xerot]
d6 Tohi \6yovs B'TW: om. B dg fvKa0rieunfv BT: tv\*-

firiTfov B' W (sed 6a/xtv S. v.) a3 îAovf {xaii B t <pi\ovtiK(riv T
:
d^(î(r)3TjT'^<ra)<rj>' r W a8-9 8<J|tT: 8J|j; B a8 irpo6u^^cro>(ai T:

vpoOvfXTidiiaofxai B b i a>r BT : Sxrirtp W b4 7 B' T W
W
:
5* B b5 &voia B' T : Swôio B b7 8^ B : ;u*i/ 5J) Tb

ca \eytiv iATjfleV T C3 fv\afiovfxfvoi B' T W : om. B
:
*AIAi2N 91C
0770)9 fXT} cyo) imb irpo6vfji.ias &fia ffJLavrov re Ka\ vjmls fâ- .
7rar7/(ra?, uxnrep jLieAirra to Ktvrpov iyKaTakntMV ol\rf<Top.ai. 5

'AAA' hiov, i(f>rj. npCoTov /xe VTTop.vria-aT a kkiy^Ti, kav
fMT] (f)aCva)[j.ai p.ep.vr]p.ivos. '2ip.p.Cas fJ.v ydp, ws (yiofxaL,
dTTio-ret re cai (pojSîTaL /xt; 17 yjrvxv o/xajs Kat dcLOTtpov Ka\
KaXXtov ov Tov (TfipaTos TrpoaTToXXvrfTaL iv appovias etSet d
ov(Ta' Ke^rjs bi poi l8oe tovto fikv ipol crvyxfaipilv,
T!oXvxpovL(aTep6v ye eimt \frvxrfv (rdpLaTos, aXXa Tobe

abrfXov TTavTL, fj.rf iroAAa 8r/ crd^fiaTa koX TToXXaKis /cara-
TpLâ(Ta r} "^v^^rf to reXeuratoy (rStfxa KaTaXLTTOvaâ vvv 5
avTrf diToXXvrfTai, KaX rf avTo tovto ddvaTos, \ffvxrjs oXe-

dpos, 7ret awfid ye dei aTToXXvfjLevov ovbev TravtTaL. dpa
dX)C rf TavT (ttLv, oa ^LfJLfiCa re Kai Ke/Sr/y, h 8et rffjids
(TTLCTKOiTela-OaL;
2vv(tifioXoyeCTr]v brf TavT elvai dpû). e

YioTfpov ovv, (f)rf, TrdvTas tovs efnrpoaOe Xoyovs ovk
diTobexêade, rf tovs fxev, Tcivs 8' ov;
Tovs fi.ev, (f)dTr]v, tovs 8' 01!.
Ti ovv, 77 8' os, TTepl eKeCvov tov Xoyov Xeyere er o) 5
e(f)ap.ev ttjv p.ddr]aiv dvdpivrjatv elvai, Kal tovtov ovt(i)S
e\ovTos dvayKaC(as X^'^ dAAo^t TTpoTefMv rfpCjv elvat TrfV
TTpXv ev rw a(apaTL evbe&fjvaL;

yfrvxrjv, 92
'Eyo) pev, e(f>r] 6 Ke^rjs, Kal TOTe 6avfi.aaTCis ws eiTeCaOrjv
utt' avTov Kal vvv epp.ev(o o)? ovbevl X6y(o.

Kal firfv, e<f)r] 6 ^LppCas, Kal avTos ovt(os ex*^ '^'^' Trdvv
dv davpidCoLfiL ei fjxti iTepC ye tovtov dXXo iTOTe tl bdêLev. 5

Kat d 2a)/c/)drr/s, 'AAAd dvdyKr] aoL, e(f>r], S) êve Qr^jBale,
dXXa boâi, edvnep fxeCvrj 'fjbe f] oir/o-ts, rd dpfxovCav fxev eXvai
(TvvdeTOV TTpidyfxa, y^vyrfv be dpfxovCav TLvd e/c tS)V KaTa to
C 7 ykp B : T
i>s ^ycpfiai om.
om. 4yiffjLai s. v. d i Ka\- W : w
XicTTOv W vvv ante rh rfXfvralov transp. T
d5 d 8 Se? e
5ij T 64 (<parnv T b Stob. <paTT)v B 65 KtytTe T Stob. :
: W
X'7Tat B W 6 7 &X\oei T &\\o ri B Stob. &.\\oel nov : : W
a 3 îi/xfvw W
a 5 &\\o T b &\\a B Stob. TroTe tj scripsi
: W
iroTf Ti T Stob. voTf B : W
a 7 i\Ao] &\\o Stob. Sofot T
Slob. ^sed 5o{oj (v pr. T) 5o|a<rai B : W
gsa nAATriNOS
rrwjua (VTTa[i(V(tiV crvyKdaOaL- ov ydp ttov airobf^rf y
b (ravTov XiyovTos ws irpoTfpov ijv app.ovia (TvyKft,fiivr], Ttplv
K(lva (IvaL e ojv ^6ci avrijv aDVTfdijvai,. rj dirofic^;
OvbafxuiS, ((t>r], oi ^(aKpaTes.
Alcrddvrf ovv, ?]
8' os, ori TavTa (tol (rvp.âivi Xeyeiv,
5 oTav (f)f}S fJLv ivaL TTiv yfrvxriv itpLV KoX eis avOpdirov eT8o's
T Kal aQip.a a^LKea-6aL, ftmt 8e avTrjv avyKLy,vrfv (k t5>v
ovb^TTUi ovTUiv; ov yap 8?) app.ovia yi (tol tolovtov Icttlv
<p d-TretKaêt?, dAAa TtpoTepov Kal fj Xvpa Kal al xppdal Kal
C ol (fidoyyoL 4tl drdp/iooTot oirey yiyvoirraL, TfXexrralov 8e

TrdvTcoy avviaraTaL rj apfxovia kol irpGiTov aiioWvTaL. ovtos
ovv roi 6 Xoyos exeti^w ttojj oT^rao-erat;
OvSa/icSs, ((prj 6 2t/i/itas.
5 Kat piriv, ?/
8' os, Trpeîret ye eiTrep r^ dAAb> Aoyo) owwSoi
eiyat /cat rw irept app.ovias.
ripe^Tret ydp, ec^r; 6 Si/x/xias.

Ovros Toivvv, (f)ri, aol ov a~w<0b6s' aXX* opa "norepov
alpr] tS)V koydiv, tijv pidOrjcrLV dvdp.vr](rLV eZeat tj yjfV)(r]V
lo app.oviav;
rioAi /xaAAoi', ^<^?7, Klvov, S 2wKpares. o8e /xey yap
d /jiot ykyovV dvev d7ro8eteais /xerd etKoros rtros Kat euTrpe-
jretas, oêr Kai rots iroAAots 8oKet dvdpdi-noLS' eyo) 8e rois
8td TUiV (iKOTOiv rds dOT8etêts TTOLOvp.ivoLS Ao'yots OT;roi8a
ovcTLv dXa^pcTLv, Kai dv rts avrovs />i?/ ^vAdrr?jrai, tv p.aXa
5 eâ7rar<So-t, Kat ey y(iiixTpiq, Kal tv rots dAAots a7rao-tr.
d .8e Trept r?js dvaixvr](T(iiS kol ixadi](re<tis Adyos 8t' viroOia-eoiS
dîas diTobiâcTdaL fLpr]TaL. fpprÔr] ydp ttov ot/rojs r]fX(iiV
(TvaL 7] v//ûxîl '^"^ ^^^ o-(S/xa d(j>LKa-daL, (HxTTTfp avTrjs

""P'''
ka-TLV rf ovaia (XPvaa Tr]v iiT<iijn>iiiav Tr]v tov " o eortr."
b I (ravTod B'^TW Stob. : avrod B b4 8ti B T Stob. 2ti : ou W

b6 Tt BTW: 7* B: om. Stob. b8 ^ B^TW Stob. : h B
C 3 ^vvdtTtTai B'^ T W
^wtafrai B ^vyaivfatrai Stob.
: C 8 ffoX
:
ov Bn"'W Stob otov B : C9 (.uxV B'^T Stob. ^vxh B W :
c 1 1 f((>n iKfivo B {iKflvov B-) vov 1(^7/ T Stob. :d 7 v)ro5- W

{afftfoi W
scd d supra u d 8 auTî] aurjj Mudge
(I>AIAi2N 926
eyc!) 8 TavTr]v, ws k}xavTov ttC6(o, Uayais re Kal opOSis diro- e

bebfyixai.. avdyKt] ovv fxoi, m eotKe, hta TavTa fXT/re ifxavTov
jitr;re aWov d-nobexâ-OaL XeyovTos o)? ^vxi] (ttiv apixovCa.

Ti 8e, ^ 8' o?, S I^Lp.p.ia, Tf}be; boKel o-ol dpfxovCa ?; aAAr/
TLVL a~uvdcrL TrpoariKeiv dXXcas ttcos X^'^ ^? '^^ ^^ CKCtra 93

^XV ^^ ^^ ^^ o-vyKerjTaL;
Ovbafxois.
Ovbe piifv TTOLfLV TL, u)S iylfxaL, ovbi tl rrdoêty oAAo
ira/)' a dv kKiiva r/ Trotr/ */
"nda-xrf; ^vv(f)rf. 5
OvK dpa rjyela-OaC ye TTpoa~^KL dpfxovCav tovtcov e &v dv

a-vvT6rj, dAA' eTreo-âi. SweSoVet.
rioAAou d/3a Set IvavTCa ye dpfxovCa KLvrf6r]vaL dv rj
(f)d4yâa-6aL 7/ rt dAAo ivavTLcodffvaL rots avrT/? fxepea-LV.

rToAAou fxivTOL, ((f)r].
10
Tt 8e'; ovx ovtcos dpfxovCa 7T(f>VKev etrat e/cdo-r?] dpfxovCa
ot)S dv dpfioa6fj;
Ov fxav6dv(t), e^rj.
*H ovxt, 17
8' os, dv fxkv fxdWov dpfxoa-6f] Kal eTTt TrXeov,
eiTrep evSe^f Tat roCro yCyvecrdai, fxakXov re dr dpfxovCa eir/ Kat b

TrAetcor, et 8' ^rroV re Kat kii ikaTTOv, rJTTâv re Kat eAdrrcoi';
Udvv ye.
'H ow ecrrt tovto irept yfrvxrfv, MaTe Kai Kard ro afXLKpo-
Tarov fidWov (Tcpav ere'pa9 ^vxijs eTrt TrAeoy Kat /xdAAoi' 5
r/ eTr' cXaTTOV Kal rJTTov avTo tovto iXvaL, ^vxvv;

Ovb' 6tt(i)o-tlovv, (f)r].
e'pe 8r7, ec^r/, Trpo? Atdy XiytTaL ^vxv V fxev vovv re

exf ti' Kttt dpeTrfv Kal eimt dya6r], 77 8e dvoLav re Kai fxox^rfpCav
Kal eTvaL KaKrj; kol TavTa dXr]du)S keyeraL; C
'AAtJ^WS fXeVTOL.
a I &' fKtlva B Stob. : iK(7va &i/ T a a { BT : ra ^{ W

a 8 &v Stob. om. B T : W 14 ^ om. Heusde
a b &v
i BStob.
W
:
om. T b 2 fiTTCtiv BT Stob. ?ittov al. b 4 ^ Tb ^ B^ et

:
W BW
:
s. V. : ' b5 ixaWov secl. Heusde 'f/vxh'' Stob.

b 6 eV(l) B T Stob. om. W : b 8 ecbrf B Stob. : om. T re
B Stob, om. ; TW
;
93C nAATHNOS
TCiv ow 6ffUv(i)V yjrvxvv apfxovCav (Tvai tl tis <f)rj<r(i
Tavra ovTa fivai (v Tais ylrv\ais, Trjv rc ap(TJ]v koX Tr]v

5 KaKiav; iroTfpov apfxovCav av Tuva aKkrjv. Kal avapp.o(TTiav
Ka\ TTjv jxfv f]pp.6(rdai, tyjv ayadriv, koI cxeiv (v avrrj
hpfiovlq ov<rp &\X.t}v apfxovlav, Trfv bi avdpnooTOV ovnjv T

eivai. Kal ovk cx^"' ^^ avTrj aXXrjv;
OvK X'^ ^y<^y> f^? o Stju/ita;, (Imlv brjKov 6' oti
lo TOLavT &TT hv Acyot 6 (Kelvo VTrodefxevos.
d 'AA\a TTpocaixoKoyrjTaL, ^(fyri, fxribfv fiaWov fxrjb^ ^ttov
(Tepav Tpas ^vxh^^ '^'^XV^ (Ivaf tovto 8' cfTTt t6 ofxo-
Xoyrffxa, fxr]b(v fiaKKov fxrjb^ iirl TtKiov fxrjb' rJTTOv p.rjb* ("n
(KaTTov (T(pav (T(pas apfxoviav apfxovias (tvai, ?; yap;
5 Ylavv y(.
Trjv b( y( pir]b(V piaKKov firfb^ tjttov apfxoviav ovaav fxrfT^
fxaKkov fxrfT( rJTTOV rfpfxoa-Qav (cttlv ovTois;
"EoTtv.
'H b( fxrfT( fxaKKov fxrfT( rJTTOv r}pfio(rfX(vrf KoTtv OTi TtXiov
lo rf (KaTTOv appiovias /leTexci, if to l(rov;
To ro-oi'.
OvKovv 'yj/vxv (iTdbrf ovb(v fxaKKov ovS' tJttov aKKrf
e aAAr;? avTo tovto, ^vxVy ^cTiv, ovb( bif fxaKKov ovb( rfVTov
ifpfxocrrai;
OvTOi.
Toi5to 8 y( TtcnovOvla ovh(v irKôv avapnoarias ovbe
5 apfxovias ft(T(xoi av;
Ov yap ovv.
TouTO 8' av TTCiTovdvla Sp' &v Ti itK(ov KaKias rj &pTr}s
fKT^xot (T(pa ^T^pas, (Itt^p rf pikv KaKia &vapfxo<TTia, rj b(

ap(Tri apfxovia dr};
C 3 Btfifvwv B riOttiivttv T b Stob.

: C 5 it6rtpov B irirtpa T :
Stob. 08 Tiva B Stob. nva. ai T : KaX^v in marg. B*

iXATji']
C 9 iyuyt, <pfi<Tlv Stob. 6 B' T W : i B d 4 apfioviai secl.
Schmidt d 6-7 ^^t6 . . . )u^t Stallbaum : fxriii . . . /uTjSt BT W
Stob. d9^T:TjW:/B Stob. d 12 iittil)i om. Stob.
6 I ovhh"] ohhiv Bekker
;
4>AIAf2N 93e
OvSev TrX.iov. lo
MaAA.oy 5e ye ttov, w îfxixCa, Kara tov opdov \6yov 94
KaKMS ovbfîa ^XV /t*e^f^ft> (tirep app.ovLa ioTiv apfxovia
yap hrfiTov TravTeX&s avrb tovto ovo-a, appiovCa, avapp.o(rTl.as
ovTTOT av /ixeracrxot.
Ov p.4vTot. 5
Ov8e ye brjirov ^/ûx^ ov(ra TravTekcas "^vxrj, KaKias.
IT<3? yap l/c ye Toiv TTpoeLprjpievoov
'Ejc tovtov apa tov Xoyov r}p.LV iTao-ai y\rvxoX jTavTOiV

((ocov 6p.o[(DS ayaOal ^crovTat, (tirep o/ioicos \}/vxo.i- TT<f)VKa(rLV
avTo TovTo, \frvxo-C, elvaL. 10
"Ejuoiye boKel, ((f^rj, a> ^(oKpaTes.

'H Kal KaXS)S boK^X, 7]
8' os, ovtco X^yecrOaL, Kal TTa^rxftv
hv TavTa 6 Ao'yos ei opOi] f] VTToOea-Ls rjv, t6 ^jrvxv^ apfxovLav b
CLvaL;
Ov8' OTTCOOTloSl', ^<t^V'
Tt 8e; 7/
8' oj* Toii' ey av6p(i>TT(o TTavTcav (r0* otl aXXo
Aeyets apx^LV r/ yj/vxv^ o.XX(os re Kat (ppovLfxov; 5
OvK iyoay^.
YloTepov (Tvyx<J^povcrav rot? xara ro o-co/xa Traêo-ii' 7/ Kat

h'avTLov\xivr\v ; Aeyco 8e ro roiorSe, otov KavfxaTos ivovros
Kal bL\j/OVS (TTL TOVVaVTLOV cXKfLV, t6 fXr) 7TLVLV, Kal TTCLVrfS
VOV(rr]s (TTL t6 fxrf (t6Ulv, kol aXXa fxvpia ttov opSifxtv 10
ivavTLovfxevrfv Trfv yf/vxv^ toIs KaTO. t6 a-G>p.a' rf ov; C

Ylavv fxkv ovv.
OvKovv av b)pioXoyrf(rafXV V tols TTpo^rdev fxrfTTOT av
avTrfv, apfxoviav ye ovcrav, kvavTLa abcLv ols eiTLTiLVOLTo
ag iûxoi secl. ci. Heindorf a 10 rovro TW Stob. rovro :
ri> Bt (Jvai l-i/xai Stob. b i tiv Stob. om. B T ^ T : W W

Stob. :om. B b 7 -irddeaiv B T iraOrifj.acriv W Stob. :
^ koI
B^T W Stob. om. B : b8 ivavnovtievTiv T (^sed add. in marg.
Kadfifiacriv) W
Stob. ivavriovn(vr]v irad-fifj.acri B rh BT Stob :
W
:
om. oTov T W Stob. a>s ti B axrel et us Kavfiaros in marg. b

:
W
:
b 9 ri B T rov: b 10 irov fivpia Stob. C 3 npâOev B T

Stob. : (fiirpoadfv W
ftiiitor' h.v avr)]v B^ T fXTiirorf ravrriv W :
B Stob.
:
94 c nAATilNOS
5 Koi x,o-\^To Kal 'âWotro Kal aWo otiovv 1:0.609 Traa-xôi
(Kflva ^ (av Tvy\dvoi, ov(ra, a\\' (Tfeadai, ckciVois Kal ovttot

av 7]yfj.ovev(Lv;
Q,lxo\oyq(ra[j.V, (f)r]' ttws yap ov;

Ti ovv; vvv ov Ttav Tovvavriov tjij.lv <f)aCvTaL ^pyaôfxetn),
10 r]yfxovvov(r(x re fKeCvoiv TrdvTaiv i^ wy <^j;o-i ris avrrjv

d LvaL, Kal ivavTLovfievT] oAiyov iravra 8ia TravTos tov ^lov
Kal Seo-TTOôvcra Trarras Tpoirovs, tcl ]j.v \CL\TT(i>Tepov Ko\(i-
Covaa KOL ]XT a\yrib6vcov, tcl T KaTO. Tr]V yvp.va(TTLKr]v kol

Tr]v laTpLKrjv, to. 8e TTpCLOTepov, Ka\ to. fxv aTTL\ova-a, to, be
5 iôvêroucra, raiy eiTLOvfXLaLS Kal opyals Kal <f)6fioLS i)S aWrj

ov(Ta a\\(o TTpdyfxaTL hLa\yo]Xvr]; oX^v ttov Kai "O/xTjpos v
'Obva-(rL(i TTTTOLr]Kv, ov \yL Tov ÔhvcTcria'
arrjdos be TrA^fas Kpabirfv rjviiTaiTe ixvO(o'

e r^rXaî br], Kpabir]- /cai Kvvnpov &\ko ttot T\r\s.
ap OLL avTov TavTa TroLrjaaL bLavoov]Xvov ws apfxovias

avrrjs ovcrrjs Kal otas ayeadaL vtto rwy roi5 adifxaTos iTadr]-
IxaTOiv, dAA' ov\ oXas ayLV re TavTa Ka\ beaTTO^^LV, kcu
5 ova-r]s avTrjs ttoAu dioTpov tlvos TTpayfxaTos rj Kad^
apfxoviav;
Nr] Aia, S) ^<aKpaTs, fxoiy boKL.
OvK &pa, 0) apLare, f]]XLV ovbafxr) KaXaJs \L yf/V)(i]v
95 apfxoviav tlvcl cf)dvaL eimi* ovt yap dv, ws 0lkV, 'Ofxrfpâ
OiCta TTOirfTr] 6f/.o\oyOLfXV 0VT aVTol TffXLV aVTOLS.

"E^êi ovT(i)s, (f)r].
Ecer 8^, ^ b^ os 6 liCOKpdTrfs, to. fxkv 'Apfiovias fjfXLV- rj/s
5 &r]l3dLKfjs iXed ttcos, <s)S 0LK, fxcTpitas yyovV' Ti 8e 87; rd

Kdbfxov, (f)r], a) Kc^rjs, irws iAao"o'/xeâ kol TivL \6y(a;
2i; fioi SoKets, (f)r] 6 KejSrjs, ^VprjaLV' tovtovI yovv
C5 jl/iKKoiro pr. T (ut vid.)

Stob. : ircUXoiro B T c 6 niyxdyoi W
T : rvyxdffi B Stob. vvy B T Stob.
C9 om d i ifaTtov
: W
fifvri B' T W
Stob. ivavTtov/J-turjv B
: d 3 t B T Stob. 8 : W
e 3 iraOrindTwy B^ T W
Stob. iraOciv B : 65 npdyfiaTos B om. T :
Stob. e 7 ^^Loiyt B Stob. ^fiol T :a 3 rxt T Siob. W

?X*'' Bt ft 7 rovrovl B : roirov T
<l>AIAi2N 95a
Tov koyov Tov TTpbs Tijv apjxovLav 6avpLa(rTCiS p-oi etTres o)s
Trapa boâv. ]Siju/u,tot; yap X^yovTos ot rjTTOpei, Travv kOav-
p.aCov ei ri cêi Tis xprjcraa-Qat. rw Xoydi avTov' Tiavv ovv b

/xoi aToiro)? ibo^fv evOvs rt]v TrpwrTjy ((pobov ov biâa-dai
Tov aov Xoyov. TavTO. bi] ovk av âD/xacrat//t Kat tov tov
KdbpLov Xoyov et TrddoL.
^Q-yadi, e<^rj 6 Sco/cparrjs, /xt; /xeya \eyf. /x>/ tls rjiXLV 5
l3aaKavLa Treptrpex//^?/ rov Ao'yoi' roi/ p.^XkovTa ea-â-OaL.
dAAa 8?/ raCra /xer rw êw //.eAô-et, 7//iers 5e '0/x7jpt/cai?

eyyifs iovTes Tretpw/xeâ ei a/aa rt Ae'yets. eo-ri 8e 8r/ rb
K(f>dXaLOV S)V ^r]T(LS' d^tots eTrtSetx^T/rat 17/xwy rr/i; yjrvxqv
dv(iiki6p6v re Kai d6dvaTOV ovaav, et (pLX6a-o(j)os dvr]p /xe'A- c
Atov dTToâvetcât, dappcov re Kat rjyovixevos diro6avo)v eKei
eu TTpd^cLV bLa(pep6vT(t)s i] et ei' dAAo) /3ta> jBlovs ereAevra,
/x^ dvorjrdv re koi rjXC^Lov 6dppos 6appi]a-L. Tb 8e dTro-

(paCvcLV ori lo-xvpdi; rt eo-rty ^ '^vxr] Kal êoetSes Kai Tjy ert 5
7rpo'repoy, Trpiy ^/xdy dv6p(l)Trovs yeveadaL, ovbev k(oXvlv
(f)f]s irdvTa TavTa ixrjvvcLV d6avaa-Lav pikv . /xr/, dri 8e TroAu-

XpdvLov re eorii' yj^vxi] Kal ^v irov irpoTepov dp.rjyavov oaov
Xpdvov Kal rj8et re Kat e-npoTTev TroAAd aTTa' dAAd ydp
ov8e'i' rt ]mXkov r/y d6dvaTov, dXXa kcll avrb rd et? dv- d
dpcoTtov (rS)]ia iXêlv dp^r] t/v avrrj 6X46pov, cSo-Trep voVos'
Kat TaXaLTT(apovp.evr] re 8r/ tovtov Tbv ^Cov ôjr/ Kat reAeurcoord

ye (V rw KaXov]xev(a 6avdT<a dTToXXvoLTo. bLa(f)peLV 8e 8r/
(f)f]s ovbev eire aTra^ ei? o-oi/xa epxerat etre TroAAaKts, Trpd? 5
ye rd tKaaTov r)]i(av (f)0J3La-6aL' TTpoanjKeL ydp (fôfieladaL,
et /x^ di^dr/ros etr/, rai /xr/ et8dri /xr/ê eyovTL X6yov bLb6vaL
d)S d^drardi' eo-rt. rotaCr' aTTa kaTLV, olpiaL, S) Ke(3r]s, a e
a9 3t] i ri ci. Forster b i xp^ffac^* B :

xP^f^'" T ow T
W
:
fj.ev oSc B b 5 f]fi7v ^/^1/ BT b6 ecrea-eai BT ^tyeadai

W
: :
B^ t c3 61 B : om. T c 5 ^v BT gr ^j/ B^ W c 7 <^^s

W
:
&1' in marg. b iro\vxpovi(iTfp6v c 8 oaov xpovov B : om. T

d4 5io<^fp6j al. Heindorf d.6 irpoo-riKf/ Baiter ei toioCt'
axTa B : roiavra T
:
956 nAATIlNOS
keyeis' Koi (êTTLTrjbes 'jtoX\6.ki,s avdKaiiâvo), Xva }xri rt
bia(f)vyr} rjixas, c? re ri [BovKei, TrpoarOfjs rj a(f)eKr]s.
Kal 6 KejBris, 'AAX' ovbkv ^yayye iv ry irapovTi., (<pr],
5 oilre a<\>(K(iv ovt^ Trpoa-deivai Seo/nai* l(rri 8e TavTa a

Aeyco.
*0 ovv ^(aKpdrqs <rvxy6v \p6vov ^T:i,a-yMV Ka\ irpbs (avrov
Ti <rKe\f/aiJ.evos, Ov <f)avKov Trpd.yfxa, ((f)r], S) Kf/3/jy, ^rjTeis'
o$t)s yap bel iiepX yfve^reo^s Kal (f)6opas Tqv aiTiav bia-
g6 7Tpayp.aTfV(ra(rdai,. cyo) ovv (tol bUip.L Trepi avToiv, iav
l3ov\r], TaLvr]TaL tov hv Aeyo), Trpbs rrjv Treiâ) Trepi <av brj Acyeis
XPWV'
5 'AAAa fj,i]v, (f)r] 6 Ke^r^s, ôvXoixaC ye.
'Akoi>6 tolvvv &)? ipovvTos. yo) ydp, (f)r], S) Ke^rjs,
veos o)V 6av]xa<TTG)S ws iTT(6v[xr](ra TavTr]s rrjs (ro^pCas r]v
br] Ka\ov(rL TTepX <f)vcr(DS loro/aiar* VTrep^âros ydp fxoL
(boKCL ftvaL, (ib4vai ras airias kKa^fTov, bia rC yiyvcTaL
lo (Kaa-Tov Kcu 8ta ri dTroAXurai Kai 8ta ri ecrri. *cai TroAAoKts

b (fxavTbv a.v(i) Karo) ixeTdfBaWov (tkottS^v TTpciTov to. rotdSe*
"'Ap' eTreiSdr to depfxbv /cai to yjrvxpbv crrfiTfbova tlvo.
Xd^r], u>s TLVfs eAeyor, t6t br] tcl âia (TvvTp4(f)TaL; Kal
TT^Tipov Tb alfxd koTLV <p (f)povovfxev, r] 6 dr]p r] Tb irvp; r]
5 TovT(i)V fXV ovbcv, 6 8' (yKe(f)aX6s eoTtr 6 rdy aicô-ets
7Tapex(t)V Tov aKOveLV kcll bpdv koX 6(T($paLV(crdaL, (k tovtu)v
b^ yCyvoLTO fxvrffxr] Kal b6â, iK 8e fxvrffxr^s Kal b6^r]s Aa-
j3ova-r]s rd ^pffxelv, Kard TavTa yCyvfa-dai (TTLarrjfxrfv; Kal
av TovTu)V rds (f)dopds a-KOTT&v, Ka\ tcl 7re/)i rbv ovpav6v
e 3 Sia(pvyr) W
iia(pfvyoi B T
: e 9 8? B T Stob. 8}j : W
a 3 (pavfîTai T 5^ \(y(ii Baumann hv Atyjjj B \tyns T Stob. : :
a5-6 fiovKofiat Ki8r?J .om..B add. in marg. B' a

:
5 > B'^ t W
W
.
T T a 8 virtp4)<t>avos B T {virfp<ppci>v schol.) viefpii<p<wov Eus. :
Stob. ag flUvai B^TW

Eus. Stob. om. B alrias : BW
Eus. Stob. et in marg. yp. T: iirropias T bi irpuTov B'TW
Eus. Stob. om. B : b 2 /cai tJ> \(/vxp^v T Eus. Stob. kuI i^vxphv :
B W secl. Schanz
: (cal t^ vyphv Sprengel
: b 8 Kari rairra B \V
Eus. Stob. : Koi ravra T Karh ravrit Heindorf :
*AIAX2N 96C
re Koi Tr]V yijv 770.67], reXeurwi' ovrois ejxavTia ^boâ irpos C
TavTTjv TTjv a-K^yîv a(Pvr]s (Ivai. ws ovbev y^prjixa. TiKixr]-
piov 8e' (TOi e/3(S LKavov eyoi yap a KaX irpoTepov aa^pats
r]iTL(TTdp.r]v, S)S ye p.avT(D Kal toIs aXXoLs iboKOVv, t6t

VTTo TarjTrjs Trjs (TKe\//ê(os ovtu) acfiobpa eTV(f)k(odr]v, oxrre 5
diTepLadov Kal Tavra a irpo tov (opi.r]v etSeVai, TTcpl dWuiv re

iroAAwy Kal 8ia tl dvOpoiTios av^dveTaL. tovto ydp u>ixr]v
npo Tov TTavTl brjXov etvaL, otl 8ia t6 kcrOULV Kal TTLveLV
TTLbdv ydp K t5)V aLTLdiV Tals pikv aap^l adpKes TTpoa- d
yivoiVTai, toZs be octtoIs dora, koX ovt(o jcara tov avrdv
Koyov Kal tols dWoLS Ta avT&v oiKcia eKaorois Trpoa-yivr^Tai,
TOTe br] Tov oKiyov oyKOV ovTa vaTfpov ttoXvv y^yovivaL,

KOLL ovTUi yCyvicrdaL tov (jp.LKpov dvOpoaiTov fxiyav, ovtcos 5
t6t (jd]xr]V' ov boKQ aoL /xerptft)s;
"E/xoiye, (prj 6 K4j3r]s.
^KexlraL br] Kal ra8e ert. u)jxr]v ydp LKavu)s pi.0L boKiv,
6tt6t tls (paLVOLTO dvOpooTTos TTapaaTds p.iyas a-fXLKp^ fxcCCoDV
LvaL avTj] Tfj Ke^paXrj, kol lttttos lttttov kol TL ye tovto)v e
evapyearepa, Ta beKa fxoL ebdKci tS)V oktu) irKiova etvai bid
t6 bvo avTols TTpoaelvaL, Kal t6 bCiTrjxv tov irqxvaCov /xeiôy
eirat 8ta t6 r]]xCaeL avTov viTepiyeLV.
Nw 8e 8^, e<^rj 6 Ke'/3rjs, ri o-oi 8oKet Trept avTOiv; 5
Yloppu) TTov, e^T/, vr] ACa e/xe etvat tov oXeadaL Trept
TOVTOiv Tov Tr]V ahCav eibevaL, 09 ye ovk diTobixopaL epiavTov

ovbe 0)? e7ret8ay evC tls TTpoadi] ev, rj t6 kv & TTpoaeTedr]
bvo yeyovev, (r] t6 iTpoaTedevy, 17 t6 TrpoaTedev Kal oi Trpoa-
eTedr] 8ta Tr]v TrpocrdeaLV tov eTepov rw eTepca bvo eyeveTO' 97
dav^xdQa ydp et oTe ]xev e^dTepov avT&v x.(opls dXX.r]\oiv
?/y, ev dpa eKaTepov r]v KaX ovk rjarqv T^Te bvo, eiTel 8'
C B^T W Eus. Stob.

I Tf : om. B 05 virh ravrrjs BT : wr' av-
rrjsW Eus. c6 aireinaOov Koi ravra B^ (in marg.) TW Eus.
Stob. : B
aTroT' e/xadov C 8 t5 B rov T : d. i Kpo<jy4v(ovrai
B^ T W Kpoayfvvoivrai B
: d 8 yap B yap : iyo) T : yap tycoyt b
ig TrapacTTas &vdpa>irus^ 6 1 aur^] ayroO W^ttenbach 'lirtrov
B : Tb
Xiririf e3 tJ> BT : tJ) Ta W Kpoailvai B' T W :
irpoadflvai. B 64 i^fxia-d B^ T W : ti^ktv B 67 rov Wt:

rov B T eg % rh irpoanQiv add. Wy ttenbach
97 nAATilNOS
(TTXrj(rCa(rav aAX?/Aois, avrr] apa alrCa avTois (yevero tov bvo
5 yevfcrOai, fj (rvvobos tov iiXrâiov dAATjAwi^ Tedrjvai. ovb4
ye fa)s fdv tls ^v Siao-xtVr/, bvvajxai, In ircCdea-dai ws avTTj
av ahCa yeyovev, rj o-)(tVts, tov bvo yeyovevav ivavTCa yap
b yCyveTai t/ roVe atria tov bvo yCyve(r9at. t6t /xev yap ori
rwi^^yero TrXrjcrCov dAAÂcoy koI TrpcxreTCdeTO (Tepov Tep(D,
vvv b' oTi aTT(xyeTaL *cai xoipCCeTai eTfpov d0' (Tepov. ovbi
ye bi oTi ev yCyveTai ws eTrCaTap.ai, eri TTeCOo) epuvrov,
5 ow8' dAAo ovSey eri Aoyo) 8i' ort yCyvcTai 17 d7ro'AAvrai 7/
loTi, Kara roCroy tov Tpoirov ttjs p.e66bov, aXka rty' oAAoi'
TpoTTOv avTos eiKT/ (\>vp(a, TOVTOV bi ovbap.?] irpoa-Cffxai.
'AAA' dKovo-as /xeV Trore e/c î^kCov Tiv6s, ws ec^r/, 'Ava^-

C ay6pov dvayiyvdixTKOVTos, kolL XiyovTos ws apa roCs ôTtr 6
bLaK0(rp.G>v re Kai Trdrrcoi' atrios, TavTj] bi] Trj alTLCL r^jadrjv re
Kai ^boê fJiOL Tp^TTOV TLva eS \eLV TO Tov vovv (LvaL TTairrcov
alTLov, Kal r]yr](rdp.r]v, ei Tovd' ovtcds Ix^'' '"^*' 7^ ^^^'^
5 Koa-piovvTa iTdvTa Koafxeiv koX (Kaarov TLdivaL TavTT] oiTr]
hv iSiKTLo-Ta XJ]' et ovv tls ôvKolto ti]v ahCav evpflv

irepl (Kda-Tov oirr] yCyveraL 7/ dTroAAvrat 7/ eort, tovto biiv
TTfpL avTov evpelv, ottt] fieKTL(rTov avrio icrrLV r] etrai r]
d dAAo orioCv irdo-xetv 7/ Troteti'' (k 8e br] tov \6yov tovtov

ovbev dAAo crKOTrety Tspo(rr]KiLV dv6p(aTT(a koi Trepi avrov [eKet-
vov] Kal Tpepi T&v dWiov dAA' f] to dpL^rrov Kal t6 ê\TL(rTov.
dvayKaiov b^ eizât tov avTov tovtov koll to yeZpov eiSerat*
5 Tr]v avTr]V ydp elvaL TTLa-Tr]fxr]v iTfpl avTGiV. TavTa 8j;
XoyL^dfxevos d(r]XVos r]vpr]KvaL w]xr]v bLbda-Kakov rrjs ahCas

TTepX tG)V ovTitiV Kard vovv ifxavTui, tov 'Xvaâydpav, KaC
]X0L ^pdaeLV TTpGiTov jxev TrdTfpov r] yrj -TrAaretd ecrrii' rj
e cTTpoyyvkr], eiretSr; 8e (f)pda-Lv, e7reK8t7jyô-eo-0ai ri]v ahCav
a4 aiiTols alria T rov 5uo W : 5i/o B : 5uorv T a6 6ix^(rri W

a 7 a6 om. T bi^W:^BT fifv om. W ba tJ> TArjffiof
et mox T^ ?T*poj' W b3 W b5 ^-1 îyv B : cV

6\ly(f T ^ ^fî/tTat W 6<f'
C2 5Jj B Eus. : ^5rj
T
T
W
t B
Eus. : om. T 07 oir; t) Eus. C8 ai/rif B' Eus. : air-
ruv B da irpo<T'fiKfii' BTW: irpoffîiKn Bw iKtivov B : om.

TW Eus. d3 Tj' B' TW Eus. : om. B d8 iffriv om. W
e I iiifKlnrrn<r<^<rû. W (et mox e 4, b 3)
*A1AX2N 97(
Koi T-qv avayKr}v, Xiyovra to afiLVOV Ka\ otl avTrjV aixdvov

rjv TOLavTTjv eTvar Kal i v fjLi(T(o (fâLrj (TvaL avTrjv, ttck-
6trjy7jcr60"âi ws afieLvov rfv avTrjv kv fxiaio (TvaL' Kal et /uot
TavTa aTT0(f)aLV0L, Trapeo-KeuacrjUTjy i>s ovkTL TToOecrofXfvos 98

airias aWo (Tbos. Kal bi] Kal Trfpi rjXCov ovTdi Trapea-Kev-
dafxr}v uiaavT(i>s 7Tva-6fXVOS, Kal a-fXrfvrfs Kal tS)V aAAcoy
aO-Tp(tiV, TOLXOVS T TlipL TTpOS oAATjAtt KOt TpOTlSiV KciX t5)V
aWdiV TTaOrffxdToiV, Trrj ttotc TavT dfXfLvov ((ttlv (EKacrTov 5
Kat TTOLCLV Kal TrdcrxeLV h TrdcrxeL. ov ydp dv ttotc avTov
^fxrfv, (f)d(rKOVTd ye vtto vov avTa KeKoa-fxrjcrdaL, dXXrjv tlvo.
avTols OLTLav (TTeveyKclv rj otl êXTLcrTov avTa ovtoos e\eLV
(otIv &a-iTp ex^'' î^daTia ovv avTwv d7ro5t8oVra Tifv OLTLav b
Kai Kotz^ Tracri to kKd(TT(D jSeXTLaTov ^prfv koX to kolvov
TTaa-LV 7TKbLr]yrfcrcr6aL dyaOov Kot ovk dv dTTebofxrfv ttoAAov
Tas (XiTLbas, dXXd iTdvv a-TTOvbr} XajBoov Tas (3lI3Xovs o)?
Td\LaTa oXos t rf dveyCyvoiaKov, Xv' ws Td^LaTa dbeCrjv to 5
(SiXTLaTov Kal to ^(ipov.

'Atto brf davfxaaTrfs (XiTCbos, S (TaTpe, uixofxrfv (fxpdfxevos,
(TTfLbrf TTpoLoiV KoX dvayLyvdaKOiV opG) dvbpa t fx\v via
ovbev xp(ofXvov ovbi TLvas airiay (TTaLTL(ap.vov (Is to

bLaKoafxelv Ta iTpdyfxaTa, depas b Ka\ aldipas Kot i!8ara c
aiTL(afXvov Kal dXXa TToXXd Kal aroTra. Kai fxoL iboêv
dfLOLOTaTOV TTeTTOvOivaL WaTTp dv L TLS XdyOiV OTL ^(OKpdTrfS
ndvTa oaa TTpdTTi V(o TTpdTTL, KaiTeLTa TTLyLprffaas XiyeLV
Tas ahCas KdaTO)v S)v Trpcirrco, Ae'yoi iTpGiTov fxv otl 8ia 5
TavTa vvv v6db Kd6rffxaL, otl avyKeLTaC fxov to a^fxa e
ocrrGiV koll Vvpo)v, Kal Ta fxkv oaTa kaTLV crrepea Kat
bLa(f)vds exet x^P'-^ ^"^^ dXX-^Xoiv, rd 8e vvpa ola ttl-
TCva6aL kcu dvCa6ai, iTepLafXTTeyovTa Ta oaTa fXTd tS)V d

aapKQ)V KCLL bepfxaTos o avvixî' avTd' alo)povp.vo)v ovv tQv
oaTOiv v Tals avToiv avfxjSoXals x<^^<^^^ci Kat avvTeCvovTa
a r a.iro<pa'iuoi Tb : airo^paivoiro B jro/je<r/cva<ra/x7ji' W (et mox)

iro0(7OjUvos T Eus. : viroBtfjievoi B et yp. T vTrodr]a6jxevos W a8 al-
W
:
Tiav auTois B- W ^(Atiov b I avTwv B Eus. avrhv T

W
:
hf S> fTaipf eAiriSos TW Eus. C 3 AeÔi pr.

98d nAAXnNOS
To, vevpa KdixTTT(rda[ ttov iroid olov t euâi f/if vvv ra
5 fX\Tj, Kal bia Tavrrfv ttjv ahiav <rvyKa}i(j>di\s ^vOdbe /ca-
dTjnaL' Kal av irfpl tov biaKfyfa-dat vp.lv (Tepas rotairras

airiay Aeyoi, <f)(tivds re Kal depas Kal aKoas Kal oAAa fivpia
e Toiavra alTi<ap,Vos, d/xeATjo-as Tas ws dXrjO&s airiay Xeydv,
OTl, 1TLbl] 'AdriVaCoi.S bo^ îkTLOV LVaL p.ov KaTa\jrr]'
(f)La-a(rdai, bLO. TavTa br] Kal e/uoi ^\tlov av beboKTaL ivOdbe

Kadrja-daL, Kal bLKaiOTcpov iTapap.V0VTa vtt)(lv Tr]v bCKrjV
5 rjv &v K\va-(i)a-LV' eTrei vr] tov Kvva, wy iyZ)pMi, TroAai hv
99 raCra tcl Vvpa Kal tol da-Ta rj TTpl Mcyapa r/ Boicorow? t]V,
VTTO b6^r]s (\)p6p.va Tov ^\tl<ttov, l fJLr] bLKaL6Tp0V (ip.r]v
Kal KaWtov cirai TTpb tov <f)vyLV re Kal dTTobLbpda-KLV

vTTeêtv TTJ tt6\L bLKTjv T]VTLv' CLV TaTTT]. oAA' airia p.V
5 TOL TOLavTa Ka\LV \Lav aTOTTov et 6^ ri? Ae'yoi ori &Vv

Tov TCL TOLavTa ^x^''^ '^^'- dcrrd Kal Vvpa Kal oaa dWa ^x^
ovK hv ol6s T rj TTOLeXv TCL b^âvTtt p.0L, d\T]6rj hv Ae'yof us
p.VTOL 8ta Tavra ttolS) h ttolS), Ka\ Tavra v<a TTpdrrâv, oAA* oi
b TTJ Tov ^\TLaTov aLpa-L, ttoAAtj hv Kal pLaKpd p(idvp.La elr]
Tov \6yov. To ydp p.T] 8ieAe'orâi olov t eirai ori ÂAo p.iv
TL iaTL t6 atTLOv rw wrt, 5AAo 8e eKeiro dvV ov to alTLov

ovK dv TTOT etrj airtov 6 brj p.0L (fâCvovTaL \frr]\a(P<avTS ol
5 TroAAoi &(nTp kv <tk6tl, dWoTpC<a 6v6p.aTL 7Tpo<rxp<i!iii.voi,
0)? arrtoy avrb TTpoaayopVLV. bto br] Ka\ 6 p.v ris bCvT]v
7TpLTLd\s TT] yfj VTTO TOV OVpaVOV p.VLV br] TTOLL Tr]V yijv,
6 be &a-T[p Ka/)8o7ro) TrAareta jSddpov tov depa VTrepet^Set*
C TTjv b^ Tov 0)9 oldv T ^\TLaTa avTa Tdr]vaL bvvap.LV oi/r<a
vvv KLadaL, TavTr]v ovre ^t^tovo-lv ovt TLva otorrai 8ai-

p.ovCav iaxvv exfu' dAAa f]yovvTai tovtov ArAajrra &v
TTore la-xvp6Tpov kol d6avaT<aTpov Ka\ /xaAAoy aTrorra
d4 iroi; om. W
ei ws om. pr. T 65 KfXtvuxnv T ai tca)
T W Eus. T KoJ B : a6 &\\a 8<ro a 7 a\ridij tiy \iyoi om. T W
a8 iro(ai & B^T W Eus. itoiaiy & B irpiTTUv Heindorf: irpaTTtt
:
BTW Eus. bi &I' T W^ Eus. om. B (post p<f0v/xia recc.) :
b3 4<rTi Tt T iKfTyo BT Simpl. Stob. tKflvo t B' Wt b 5 aKdrif

W
:
dvSnaTi T Simpl. Stob. 6fi/xaTi BW b8 aipa BT :
Simpl. Eus. Stob. itpa KaTot W : c j8Ati(tto oi-tA T Simpl. Eus. i
Stob. aiiTh. fif\Ti(TTa B" W

: fii\TiaTov airra B : C 3 &v tot*
StAoi^to T W Eus. Stob.
4>AIA12N 99C
(Tvvl\ovTa (êvpeiv, kol o)? akrjdcos to ayaOov Kal biov 5
(Tvvbelv Kal (rvviyjeiv ovbev oXovTai. iyoD [xkv ovv tt/j
ToiavTr]s alTias oTrrj TtOTe eê6 âdrjTrjs otovovv ijhta-T hv

yevoCfxrjv eTreiS^ 8e ravrrjs ia-Tpi]6r}V Kal ovt avTos evpelv
ovTe TTap' akkov ixaOelv olos re iyevofxrjv, tov bcvTepov
TTkovv cTTt Ti]v Ttjs alTLas ^^rT;(Tii' 7| Tre-TTpay/xdreujuai jSovkeL d
(Tot, e(j)r], ^TribeL^LV TroiT/o-co/xai, Si Ke/3rjs;
'TTTp(pv(iis juey ow, ec^r/, ws ôvkoixaL.

'E5oê TOLVVV p.0L, 7/
8' os, /xera raCra, eTreiSr) amLprjKr]
TOL ovTa a-KOTr&v, bfiv vka^r]6r]vai jut) Trdôi/xi oTrep ol roy 5
rjkLov CKkeLTTOVTa 6e(t)povvTs Kal (TKOTtovp.(.voL Trda-xova-Lv'

bLa(f>dLpovTaL ydp ttov ivLOL tcl 6p.p.aTa, kdv /xt) Iv vbaTL ?/
TLVL TOLOVTIO aKOTTMVTaL Tr]V (iKOVa aVTOV. TOLOVTOV TL Kal 6

eyo) bLVoi]dr]v, Kal ibeLaa //^ Trai^rdTrao-i rqv \j/vxw TV(})k(a-
6eCr]v (3keTr())v Trpbs rd Trpdy/jiara ro6s 6pLp.aaL Ka\ eKdo-Tj]
tQ>v alcrdr]a-u>v eTTLx^LpStv aTrreo-ât avTwv. (boê bi/] p.0L
XprjvaL ets tovs Ao'yovs KaTa(f)vy6irra iv (KeCvoLS cKOTrety 5
T&v 6vT(x)V Tr]v dkr]deLav. Lacos p.V ovv <2 eijcdâ) TpoTtov
Tiva ovK OLKV ov ydp Trdvv (rvy$t)pG) tov kv [rots] Ao'yots lOO
(TKOTTOVfXiVov Ta ovTa kv elKoa-L /xdAXov a-KoireXv x] tov kv
[rois] epyoLS. dAA' ovv br] TavTrj ye o)p]xr](ra, Ka\ viTOêpi.evos
kKd(rTOT koyov ov av KpCvu) (ppwixeviaTaTov eiyat, h pikv

dv ]X0L boKrj rovro) a~vfx(f)(ji)veLV TCdr]p.L &)S dkrjdrj ovTa, Kal
TTpL ahCas KOL TTep\ tS)V dkX(t)v diTdvToov [6vto)v], a 8' hv
fXT], o)s ovK dkr]6r]. ôvkofxaL 8e' o-ot cra($ia-Tepov etTreiy
h. keyot)' oXfxaL ydp ae vvv ov p.av6dveLV.

Ov p.d Tov ACa, e(f)ri 6 Ke^rfs, ov (r(f>6bpa.
'AAA', ?/
8' os, w8e keyo), ovbev KaLvdv, dAA' diTep det b
C7 roiainijs B Stob. : canrjs T di T b Stob. ^ B

17 W : :
b d2 voi^ficrccfiai recc. : iroffiffo/iai BT W

Stob. d 3 ovv
f)i/
om. W d4 air(ip{\K7) T (rj ex ei) : airetpT)Kii Stob. : aireipTjKO

BWt d6 e/cAtiroVTa T irciffxoiKnj' B* T W Stob. om. B :
d7 tvioi BT
Stob. hiort B^ W t e 1 ^ iv rivi T e6 ^ Tb :
W
:
is B W Stob.
t a I To?s B W : om. T Stob. a.2 iv om.
as Tors B Stob. om. : TW a4 &' B-TW Stob. om. : B
a6 ovTuv B W : om. T Stob. : ruv ovrwv vulg.
PLATO, VOL. I. 10
;
loob nAATi2N02
re aWoT Koi (v rui TrapfXrjXvOoTL X6y<a ovbev Ttiiravfxai
Xeyctiv. (pxofiai [yap] br] (T:iyiip5>v croi iTtihdâa-Oai ttjs
ahias to dbos o TreTrpay/xtirevyiat, Kal Tfii ttoXiv ctt' eKelva
5 Ta nokvdpvkr]Ta Ka\ apyonai om iKdvoov, v7ro64ixvos (IvaC

Ti Kokov avTo Kad' avTo koI &yadbv Kal fiiya Kal roAAa
Tra/rra* h ct fxoL bibm re /cai o-vyxfopfis (ivat TavTa, eATri^co

(TOI, (K TOVTMV T1]V alTiaV iTnbiiîlV Ka\ aV(Vp7}a-lV 0)9
addvaTov [t]] '^vyj].

C 'AAAa p.r]v, e07j 6 Kij3r]s, ois bibovTos troi ovk av
(f>$dvoLs TTfpaCvoov.
S/coTTei 8?;, ((f)r], to. î]s fKcCvots idv croi crvvboKr] (So-Trep
]xoC. (f)aCveTai, ydp fxoi, el tC Icttiv akko Kakov irk-qv avTO
5 To Kakov, ovbe bC ev dkko Kakbv irat rj bioTi p.eT\i
fKeCvov Tov Kakov' xat Trarra 8^ ovro)? Aeyco. rf) roifiSe
I
^- a^râ a-vyxoipets
^vyxoipoi, (f)r].
Ov ToCvvv, ^ 8' os, eTi ]xav6dvo) ovbe bvvafxai tcls dkkas

lo ahCas Tas cro0ay TavTas yLyv(oa-KLV' dAA' idv tCs fxoi keyr]
d 8t' OTL Kakov ioTLV oTLOvv, t) yj)Q>p.a evav6es eyov rj a-xrjfxa
7/ oAAo ortow tHv tolovtcov, to, fxev dkka xaCpeLV 6w,

TapdTT0]xaL yap iv rots aAAots jrda-L tovto b^ dTrAuy Kai
drexycos Kal Xa-o)s vrj6o)S ex^ '"'"P' (p-o.vT(^, otl ovk akko tl
5 'JToiet avTb Kakbv ?/ ?/ eKeCvov tov Kakov cire Trapoixrâ^^cire

KOLV(vCa eire oirr/ bi] Ka\ oTrcos "it:poayevofxevr]' ov ydp'eTL
TOVTo bLLaxvpCCojxaL, dAA' ort rw KaAa> Trdrra rd xaAd
[ytyrerat] KaAd. tovto ydp ]xol 8oKet da-(f)akeaTaTov eirai
Kai ifxavT^ dTT0KpCvaa6aL Ka\ dAAco, /cat tovtov exopLevos
e r^yovfxaL ovk av Trore Trecreti', dAA' dcrâAes eiyai koi ifxo\
Kai oTâovv dAAci) d7roKpCvaa6aL otl rw KczAfa) rd KaAd

[ytyrerat] KaAd* t/ ou Kai aol boKei;
2 T B' T
b W
/cai B :b 3 îp B om. T h 8 <toi B trt T : :
T^f B T r-fiv ts: W b 9 ^ om. pr. T 04,5 ir\^v Ka\6f . . .
B-iTWôm. B di ^ (bis) B: i>gTj B^TW d4fMW

d 6 Kpoffyevofi4vr{] irpocraryopfvo/xfvrj Wyttenbach d 7 irivTo T b W :
om. B d8 yiyvfrai Tb: om. dg ayroKpivfaOat T BW

3 7i7vT04 T et (post koAo) om. B W :
4>AIAi2N looe
AoKei.
Kai fJLye6ei apa ra /xcyaAa /xcyaAa Kal tcl jueiXa) juet(w, 5
/cai (TfxiKpoTr^TL To. eAdrra) eAaTTco;

Nai.
Ovbi (Tv ap' av diroSexoto et tls TLva (paCr] fTepov hepov
rfj K(f)akfj [XLCa) elvaL, Kal tov (kaTTo) tw avri^ TOVT(a
(X(XTT(i), dAAd bLap.apTvpoLO av otl (tv pikv ovbiv dAAo Aeyets lOi
Tj OTL t6 fXfLCov TTav (Tepov kTfpov ovbevl dAAo) /xetôV ea-TLV

rj fxeyedeL, Kal 8id tovto pielCov, 8td to p.eyeQos, to be
eXarrov ovbevl dAAw ekaTTov t] a-jXLKpoTriTi, KOt 8td tovto

ekaTTov, 8td Tr]V a-jXLKpoTrjTa, (ôôvp.evos oTfxaL fxr] tls (tol 5
evavTLOS koyos aTiavT-qcrr], eav rf] Kecfyakf] pLeCCovd TLva cfifjs
eTvaL Kal eAdrro), iTpuiTov fxev rw avT^ to fxelCov ju.etôr eti-at
Kat To ekaTTov ekaTTov, eireLTa Tfj Kecpakf] o-pLKpa ov(rr] tov
fxeCCâ /xeiCo elvai, kol tovto br] Tepas eTvaL, rd afXLKp^ tlvl b
fieyav tlvo, eHvaL' 77 ovk av (fôjBolo TavTa;
Kat o Kel3r]s yekaaas, "Eywye, e^rj.
OvKOVv, 77
8' os, To, beKa twv oKTui bvolv irAeta) etiâi, Kai
8td TavTr]v Tr]V alTMV vireplidkkeLV, (f)o(3oXo av keyeiv, dAAd 5
fxr] TTkr]deL Kal 8td rd TrkfjOos; Kal To 8t777])(w tov Trr^-xyaLov
rffXLO-eL pLelCov etrat dAA' ov fxeyeOei; 6 avTos ydp ttov (f)6j3os.
Udvv y , e(f)r].
î be; ev\ evos irpoa-TeOevTos Tr]V irpocrOecrLV alTiav elvaL
Tov bvo yevea-OaL 7) bLaa-)(^L(rdevTOS Tr]V (r\ia-LV ovk evAajSoto C

av keyeLv; Kal peya av /80(0779 ort ovk o7a-9a aAAcos tto)?
eKaa-Tov yLyvofxevov rf p.eTaa-\bv Trjs Ibias ovcrias eKacrTov

ov av fxeTdayr], koll ev tovtols ovk exeis dkkrjv tlvcl ahiav
Tov bvo yeveadaL dkk' rf Tr]V Trjs 8m8os ju,erd(rxeo"ti', Kat 5
8ety TorjTov fxeTaa^êlv tcl fLekkovTa bvo ecrearOaL, koll p.ovdbos

o av p.ekkr] ev ecrecrdaL, rds 8e o-xtcret? TavTas kcu. TipocrOecreLS
Ka\ TCLS dkkas tcls rotai/ra? Kop\f/eias eior^s av âipeLV, Trape\s
e 6 IxiTTw alterum in marg. t e 8 &pa &v T W : &pa B

a2 To BT : W
ro fiiv a 4 eAoTTov ânte fi) om. T b2 dvai
B : flSfvai T 02 /xiya B- T W : ft.fya.\a B olffda T
W
:
ol6fi,(0a B : oiunfOa W 04 ixfTaffxxi T et 7; s. v. W : fifra.(rxoi B

10*
loic nAATiiNOS
aiTOKpivacrOai rot? creavTov a-o^pcaTipoi^' (tv 8e ScStci)? av, to
d Xiyofxivov, Tr}v aavTov (TKiav Kal rrjv aimpiav, fy6y.ivo'i
fKfivov Tov a(r(f)a\ovs Trjs viroOi (nois, ovTOis aifOKpivaio av.
fl 8e TLS avTijs Ttjs VTTode^recos ex^^^^' X^^P^*-^ ewrjs av Kal
ovK aiTOKpLvaio eois av to. a^n eKîvrjs 6ppLr]6^vTa (TKeyj/aLO
5 ft (roL dAA7/Aoi? (TvpL({)U)veL r} bia^fxavei' enretbr] be eKeCmjs

avTrjs beoi (re 8t8o'yat Ao'yor, ^(ravTUis ^v btboLrjs, aWrfv av
VTTodecnv VTrodp.evos rJTLS tS>v avcadev êX.TL(rTr] (fâCvoiTo,
e ca)s 7ri TL LKavbv ekdoLS, &fJLa be ovk av (f)vpoLO uxnrep ol

CLVTLXoyLKOL TTepL 76 Trjs apxrjs bLaKey6p.evos Kal tS)V e^
eKeCvrjs o)pp.r]p.evo)V, el-nep ôvkoLo tl to)V 6vto)v evpelv;
eKeCvoLS ixev yap lo-coy ovbe ets Trepl tovtov \6yos ovbe
5 (f)povTis' iKavoi yap vtto (ro(f)Las ofjLOv iravTa KVKGnrres ofxoos
bvvaa-QaL avTol avTols ape^rKeLV av b\ eXiTep eX tS)V (f)L\oa6(f)0)v,
I02 otfiat av ci)s eyo) \eyo) ttolols.j
^ A\r]6eaTaTa, e(f>r], \eyeLS, o re '^Lfj.p.Las aixa xat 6 Ke/3rjj.

EX. N^ Ata, u) âlbo^v, etKo'ra)s ye' 6av]iaaTS)S yap
fxoL boKeX o)? evapyS)S roi Kai afXLKpov vovv e\ovTi, elitelv
5 eKetiôs TavTa.
4>AIA. Ylavv fxev ovv, w ÊêKpaTes, Kal iraai tols

irapovaLv eboêv.
EX. Kai yap rffxZv toZs aTTovaL, vvv be aKovovaiv. aX\a
TLva brf Tfv To, fxeTCL TavTa \ex6evTa;
10 4>AIA. '12? fiev eyo) oTpiaL, eTTel avT(o ravTa avve\o)pr]6r],
b Kai o)/ioAoyetro elvaC rt eKaarov tS)v elbSiV koll tovto)v

roAAa fxeToXafxâvovTa avT&v tovto^v Tr]v eTCOiWfxCav Xa-êiv,
TO br] fxeTo. TavTQ. r]p(j)Ta, Et h], 7]

8' os, TavTa ovto)s \eyeLS,
Sp' ov\, OTav ^LfXfxCav 'Eo)Kp(XTovs ^f]S fxeCCoi elvaL, ^PaCbo)vos
5 8^ eAdrru), Aeyet? t6t^ elvaL ev rw 2t/x/jtta afX(f)6Tpa, Kal
fxeyedos Kal afXLKp^rqTa;
09 (TâvTov B^TW : iavrov B d i (ravrov B'TW: iavrov B

d.2 aTTOKpivoto pr. T W d3 (<poiro Madvig d6 au B 5' T :
e 3 dp/j.aiij.ffcav pr. T 64 ovSk fh B : ovSds T Wb 65 S/xws

B^ T W : Sn-a.s B b 5 t6t' B : rSrf W ravT
: T
4>AIAi2N i02b
"Eywye.
'AAAa 8' os, o/uoXoyeis t6 tov ^tixfxCav v-n^pixîv
y6.p, ?}
ôoKpoLTOvs ovx ^s ToXs pi]p.a(Ti Aeyerat ovt(x> Kai to akrÔts
^)(IV. OV ydp TTOV TTiCf^VKivai ^LjXjxiaV VTtpi)(jeLV TOVTdi, TIO C

îlxfiCav klvai, aXXa T(a fxeyidet b Tvyxdvei ^yuiV' ovb^ av
iSojKparou? VTTpXLV OTL îoKpdrqs 6 ^coKpdTTjs ea-TLV, dkk
OTL apLLKpoTriTa iyjEL 6 ^coKpdTTjs TTpbs To eK^LVOV p.ye6os;
'AAtj^t'/. 5
Ovb4 ye av vtto âibcovos VTTepexeadaL t5> otl âibcov

6 'i>aib(i)V ecTTiv, dAA.' otl jidyeOos l;(et 6 fpaibcov TTpbs Tr]V
2t/x/xiou (rixLKpoTrfTa;
*EoTt TavTa.
OvTcos dpa 6 ^Lpifxias eTTOJWfiiav e)(et (TfXLKpos re Kat lo
fxiyas dvaL, iv /xeVo cov dfxcfôTepcov, tov fikv T(o fxiyiOn

VTceply^Lv Ti]v apLLKpoTrfTa VT:i\uiV, rw 8e Tb fxeyedos Trjs d
(TfXLKpoTrfTos TTap\u}v VTTpe)(ov. Kat dfxa ]uei8tao-a?, Eot/ca,
e^rj, Kat (rvyypa(f)LKu>s epetr, dAA' ovv eêt ye' ttov u)S Ae'ya).
^vve(pr].
xXiyut br] Tovb^ veKOt, /3ouAo/xews 8o'ât o-ot OTrep (fxoi. 5
ejLioi yap (f)aivTaL oi/ f/iovov avTo to fxeyedos ovbeiTOT eê'Aety /
ttjLia fxya Kal a-p.LKpbv eirat, dAAd /cai Tb v rffuv fxiyedos {
ovb^TTOTe TTpo(rb4x((^6aL to (rfxLKpbv ovb^ eddkeLV viTp\(rdai^

dAAd bvoXv to tTipov, rj (f)(vyLV /cai vjTKxu)pLV oTav avT(a
irpoair] to ivavTiov, to (TfXLKpov, i] TTpoaeXOovTos Kivov e
dTroAcoAe^yaf vTTOfiivov 8e xat b^dpLvov Tr]v afXLKpoTrjTa
OVK dkLV LVai TpOV 1] OTTp r]V. UXTTT^p yU) b^dfXVOS
KOL V1T0fXivaS T1]V (TflLKpOTrjTa, Kal TL U)V Oa-TTp Lfxi, OVTOS

6 avTbs (TfXLKpos lp.L' KZvo b\ ov TT6kfxr]KV p.ya OV 5
(TfXLKpbv elvaL' ws 8' avToos /cat Tb a-fXLKpbv to iv ifpuv ovk

idik^L TTOTe fxiya yiyv(r6aL ovb etmt, ov8' dAAo ovbV tu>v
C 6 T9> B T rovrtf : W d. i T
virfX'^'' W
uirfpexw' B t
: r^
Se ex rh 5e T et mox om. rh ds T b 8
5tj W
d 6 ovSi-
W
:
iroT\e) BW: oljirorf T e I irpocriri Tb: irpocrfirj B: irpoffjjei

e4 Sxrvfp W 65 fKf^vo B'- T W fKelvos B
: ou B' T W :
om. B e 6 axravrus T e 7 yfvftrdcu W

oy5 B T oCre :
B'Wt
io2e nAATX2N0S
ivavTioiv, Ti ov oTTfp T]v, aixa TovvavTiov yCyvfo-daC tc
103 Kal elvai., dXA' iJtol aiTipxfTai 7) airoKkirrai kv Tovrui to)
Tra6rip.aTi.
YlavTaTiacrLV, I^tj 6 Ke/Srjj, ovro) <f)aCvTaC fwi.
KaC Tis etTTe T(av irapovTiav aKova-as ootis 8' ijy, ov

5 (rac^ws p.ip.vr\p.ai ripos êoiii;, ovk y Tots Trpoa-dfV rjfxZv
Aoyois avTo to (vavTCov tS)V vvv\ kyop.ivu)V wfxoXoydTO, (k

Tov (kdrTovos t6 fxfiôv yCyvea-dai, Kal ^k tov fxeCôvos t6
ikaTTov, KoL aTex^tiis auTTj etmi rf yevfais Tots fravriot?,
fK T(av (vavTUtiv; vvv bc /xoi 8oKt keyeaOai otl tovto ovk
10 dv TTOTe yivoLTo.
Kai 6 2(0KpaTTj? TTapaâkuiV Ty]v K(f)akr]V Kal aKova-as,
b 'Av8ptK(Ss, (f)ri, aTTefivrffLovevKas, ov fxevTOL (vvofls t6

bLa(f)pov Tov Te vvv keyofLfvov Kal tov t6t. totc fLfv
yap (keycTO K tov ivajrrCov iTpdyfiaTOS t6 IvovtCov irpdyfxa
yCyv(rdaL, vvv be, 5tl avTO t6 (vavrCov avro) evavTCov oiiK
5 dv TTOTC yeVOLTO, OVTC TQ (V 1]fUV OVT t6 (V Trj <f)V(rL.
t6t fuv ydp, S) (f)Ck, TTpl t5>v -)(6vT(t)v Ta ivavTCa fAeyo-

fiv, ^TTOvofxdôvTes avTa Trj KCvo)v iT<t)WfXLa, iwv 8e Trepi
KCv(i)V aVTbiV (OV v6vT(i)V XL T7/r TT(DVVfxCaV TO. OVOfXaÔ-
C \xva' avTCL 8' Klva OVK dv TTOT (f)afiV eêAj/o-ai yV(rw

dAAÂcoi' hiâa-daL. Kat $.fxa ^k\f/as TTp6s t6v Ke^rfTa
etTrer, 'Apa fxi] ttov, o) Ke'/3r/s, e</)/, Kat crc tl TovT(av
iTdpa^V ojv o8e etTrei';
5 O118' av, (pri 6 Ke'/3j/s, ovt(os exw koCtol ovtl keyoi

b)S OV TToAAd fX TapdTTL.
^vvo)fxokoyr]KafXv dpa, rj 8' os, diTk^s tovto, /ixj/8c'7roTC
ivavTCov avT(a t6 ivavTCov (T(rdaL.
navrdTrao-u;, ^^t/.
e 8 ?T< Si' TW : aXrwv B et yp. W a 5 i)n7v W vixiv BT

a II irapa.\aâ>v W b^ iroTt om. T 02 irpds B :
:
*/s B-TW
03 r<J>rj 5 Kt/Siji T W 05 oW oZ W t : A 5' aJ B T et yp. W
ko/toi otfTi B' : Kol roiovr6 t BT W 08 ifftvQat ante kaxn^ T
4>AIAI2N 103C
"Eti 8tj /xoi Kal Tobe (TKt^lrai, eîj, ct apa (Tvvofxo\oyq(rLS. 10
dfpixov TL KoAeis Ktti \lfvxpov;

"Eyoiye.
'Ap' oTrep îwa Kai Trvp;
Ma At" oiiK eyojye. d
'AAA' hepov n Trvpos ro Oeppiov Kal Tp6v tl xlovos to
y}/vxp6v;
Nai.
'AAAa ro'8f y' oi/xai SoKei o-oi, oiiSe-Trore x''^'^" 7 ov(rav 5
beâfxevqv to deppiov, uxnrep kv tols iipocrOev ikyop.V,
iTL ((TeadaL oirep rjv, xi-ova Kal depp-ov, aXXa irpoa-L^vTOS
Tov 6epp.ov rj VT:iKyoipr\(rLV airr^ rj aTToKdcrdaL.
Havv ye.
Kal To irup ye av Trpoo-iorros tov \j/vxpov avTca r] 10
viT$LevaL rj aTTokeLO-OaL, ov fxivTOL Trore ToXp.r](TeLV beâ-

p.V0v rtjv y\rvxp6Tr]Ta TL elvaL oTrep rjv, TTvp Kal \j/vxp6v.
'Akr]drj, e(j)r], Aeyei?. 6

'EaTLV &pa, ^ 8' 6s, TrepX evLa t&v TOLOvToav, SiaT [xi]
fx6vov avTo To elbos a^LovadaL tov avTov dv6pLaTOS els tov

ocl xfovov, dAAa Kal aAAo tl b Ioti piev ovk eKelvo, ex^L
be TTjv eKiLVOv p.op(f)r]v dei, OTavTTcp 77. Iri be iv Tiabe 5
Xaois iaTaL aa(f)aTpov o Aeyw to yap TrepLTTov aei ttov
bel TovTov Tov 6v6]xaTos Tvyx^viLV oTTep vvv keyofxev r] ov;
Hcivv ye.
Âpa p.6vov tG)V ovTOiv tovto yap epojrco 7; Kat aAAo
TL o eaTL piev ovx oirep to TrepirroV, 6p.(jos be bel avTo 104
/xera rov eavTov 6v6pLaTOs Kal tovto KoXelv ael bLo. to ovtco
TT^PvKivaL uiaT Tov TTepLTTov p.r]beTTOT aTToXeiTTeadaL; Aeyoj

8e avro elvaL oXov kcu r] TpLas TTeiTOvde Kal akka TTokka.
o-KoVet be TTepl Ti]s TpLabos. apa ov boKel aoL tSi re avTr]S 5
C 13 X'<^''* B : ^tiiv T d. 5 yiiva y' W : xôjâ BT d6 irpo-

(TdevT : ffxirpo<xQtv B d. 8 auT^j TW : avTh B dp-ir iravv . . .
airo\f7ffdat om. T d 1 1 To\fxr,fffiv B^ T W : roKfiiicrmv B

e 5 T^5 T : rola^t B
i04a nAATilNOS
ovofxaTL ad irpoa-ayofxVTea (tvai Kal tw tov TreptTTov, ovtos
0V\ OTTp TTJS Tpidbos; dAA.' d/Xa>9 0ijT<DS Ttii^VKi Kai fi
Tpias Kal 7] TTffjLTTTas Kal 6 i]p.i<rvs tov apLdfjiov aiTas, warc

b OVK OiV OTTfp t6 TTepiTTOV ai\ iKaOTOS aVTUtV eOTt TTipLTTOS'
Kal av To. bvo Kal [to.] Tirrapa Kal &TTas 6 T(pos av aTiyps
Tov api6p.ov ovK o)v o7Tp To &.pTiov ofxcas e/caoTos avT&v
apTLos iOTLV aL' o-vyxcopds 7] ov;
5 U&s yap ovk; ^<f>r}.
*0 ToLvvv, <j>r], iBovXonaL hr]\&<raL, 6.$pi. <ttlv h\
Tohf, OTL ^paCveTaL ov p.6vov KLva TCL ivavTLa aWrjXa ov

bexpp-fva, akka ml o<ra ovk ovt dAAÂots ivavTla ^xcl ad
TavavTLa, ovbe TavTa loi*ce bexop-evoLs (KeCvrfv ttjv Ibeav fj
lo hv Tr\ kv avTols oxxrrf ivavTLa 7/, dAA' eTTLOv<rr]s avrrjs i]tol
C dTToAAvfxera 17 vTTeKyonpovvTa. r] ov <f>r]<rofj.v tcl Tpla Kal

aiToXetcrdaL rrpoTepov Kal aXXo otlovv TTi<r<rdaL, TtpXv vtto-
fielvaL hi TpCa ovTa apTLa yevicrOaL;

YlAvv fi\v ovv, <f)r] 6 KejSrjs.
5 Ovb^ firfv, 7}
8' 09, vavTL0V yk Icttl bvas TpLabL.
Ov yap ovv.
OvK apa fiovov tcl etbr] tcl vavTLa ovx VTTOfiVi ciTLovTa
a\Xr]\a, aWa Kal dAA' drra tcl ivavTLa ovx vTTop.VL
ilTLOVTa.
10 'A\r]6<rTaTa, <f>r], Aeyct?.

BovAei ovv, 77
8' os, av oloi t S>fiV, 6pL<r<afi6a OTTOia
TavTr], S> Ke'/3j79, T(xb etr] av, h otl av KaTa<rxr],
fxrj fxovov CLvayKaCeL Tr]v avTov ibeav avTo L(rxLV, aWa Ka\
ivavTiov avT^ aeC tivos;
a 7 o57r*p Heindorf oSrwi T : ovTta irws B t ba ri om. T

b 4 M om. T b8 itl xi T b 10 avTols recc.
W
: avTrj
W
B T \V
C 2 TW
Trplv irp]y B C 5 ovBi B T : oi Stj B etj, s. v.
c 8 To om. T
: t)
ci I ^ 8' 5j1 ^c^Tj W d 1 4 B' W om. B T

:
d 2 avayKd(tt B'TW avaryKd(fiy B avrh BT : avTo7s W f<rxy

oiry W
:
T W : o-x*''' B d3 avTtf afl rtfos B : itl rifos : 5?

avT<f Ttyos T
*AIAI2N 104 d
ITwy Xeyfis;
"Ho-Trep apTi iXiyofKV. oTcrda yap briTrov oti ah.v tj rOiV 5
TpiSiV Ihia KaTacryr\, avayKT] avTO^Cs ov p.6vov Tpia-lv elvai,
&\ka Kol TTepiTTols.

Udvv y.
'Em To ToiovTov 8r/, âjLier, rj ivavTua i8ea lKeivr\ r^
p.op(f>r] rj av tovto aTTepyd^rjTai. ovbi-TTOT av ikdoi. ^
Ov ydp.
Eipya^cro 8e ye r] TrepiTTri;
Nai.
'Eyairria 8e TavTj]
'
r] tov dpTiov;
Nai. 15
'Etti to. Tpia dpa rj tov dpTiov ibea ovhiTtOTe viî" ^

Ov brJTa.
"Apoipa bi] Tov dpTiov ra rpia.

Apoipa.
ÂvdpTLOs dpa r] rptas. 5
Nai.
O Toivvv ikeyov 6pi(ra(r6aL, ttom ovk ivavTia tlvI ovTa
ofKas ov bex^Tai avro, to kvavTiov oXov vvv r] rptas roi
dpTiid ovK ov(Ta kvavTia ovbev tl pLaWov avTo 8e'xerai, to
yap evavriov del avTca eTTKêpei, Kal fj bvds T(o irepiTT^ Kal to
To TTvp rw \l/v)(j)(^ Kal dWa TTdp.TroWa dAX' opa brj ei 105
ovTdis opiQ], pi] povov t6 kvavTiov To (vavTiov ju,?/ 8e'xeo-0ai,
aAAa Kal e/ceiro 6 dv eTTKpepr] rt kvavTiov eKeivu, e(/)' ort

dv avTo tr], avTO t6 TTL(f)pov Ti]V Tov eiTL^pfpopdvov vav-
TLOTT^Ta p.r]bi'noTe beâcrdai. 7TdX.LV be dvapL]xvr](TKov' ov 5
ydp yelpov TroAAaKts dKoi;eii'. Ta ttvt Tr]v tov dpTiov
ov 8eferat, ovbe Ta b^Ka Tr]V tov ireptrroC, t6 StTiAdo-ioi;.
TovTO fxev ovv Kal avT6 dAAo) <(ouk)> kvavTiov, opcos 8e r7jy
d9 MB: iiTfl T drof,W:^BT e-j Splffaffeat BT

W W
:
dptffaffdat Sflv 6 lo out^ afl T a2 yu^ Sfxefâ tJ

iyauriov T (add. sign. transp.) a3 Stj BT : oVy B'^ W a^ t-p
T :
^ B : (XriW a s SfêffOat Madvig a8 oyToTW: outi^ B
et i^s. V. W oiiK add. Kohler
:
J05b nAATXlNOS
b Tov TTfpiTTOv ov be^fTai,' ov8e 8r) to TjfJLioKiov ovhe TaWa
TO, TOiavTa, To r]iJLi.(rv, tt]v tov o\ov, Kal TpiTr]\i6piov av
Kai TtavTa to. ToiavTa, eLTTfp cttt/ re Kal crwboKfl aoL ovTUiS.
Ylavv (T(f>6bpa Kal (rvvboKfi, I07j, Kal iirofxai.
5 riaAiv brj fxot, ^<f)r], i^ o.px^]i Aeye. koI /xt; /xot 6 av

ipcoTbi aTTOKpCvov, oAAa ixLfJLOvp.(vos ipA. kiyoi br] Ttap rjv
t6 TTpGiTov ^Keyov a-n^Kpia-w, Tr]v aa-(pa\r] ^KeLvrjv, ck tS)V

vvv Aeyo/xevcov SAAtjv opSiv aa-(f)(x\Lav. ct yap ipoL6 /le
o) h.v tC (V Tw (T(j)p.aTL yyvr]TaL Oepfxbv eo-rai, ov Trjv
C aa-(f)a\rj aoL epd) aTT^KpLcrLV (KfCvrjv Trjv apiadr], ori w av

OepixoTr]^, dAAa KOfxyf/oTepav ^k t&v vvv, oti u) hv irvp' ovbe
&v epj] (1) hv (rdfxaTL tC iyyevrfTac roo-Tjo-ei, ovk epw ori
w hv v6a-os, dAA' o) hv TwpcT^s' ov8' o) &y aptdfxia tC
5 yy4vr]Tai inpLTTos eorai, ovk ^/)oi) w dy 7repiTTo'rr;?, dAA'

fa) dy /loms, Ka\ raAAa ovrcos. dAA' opa d rjbr] iKavQs
oX(T&' oTi ôvKofxaL.
'AAAd Tti.w LKovSis, e0jj.
ÂiTOKpCvov br], ^ 8' 6s, w hv tC yyiirr]Tat croifxaTi C^v
lo eorai;
*I2i dy yjfvx^, e^jj.
d Ov/coyy dei tovto ourcos e;(ei;
rici)? ydp ovxC; Tj 8' o?.
^'UX'? ^pa oTL hv avTrf KaTda-xr], det i^fcet ^tt' iKflvo

(f)epov(ra ^co^y;
5 "H/cet fxivTot, i(f)r].
YloTfpov 8' eo-rt rt ^corj kvavrtov f] ovb^v;

'EoTtr, e<^rj.
Ti;
b r om. B
8i> T hs fioi ftiiT
: h tv tpunS B ^ &i> ipvrSi W :
T : ipanw airiKpiiriv yp
^v h.v b 6 aAAek B W iAAo iAXy T W :
iAA' &\\vv yp.W 5); B^ T S^ B W

b 7 ^k B T dAA" %i/ ^k
W
: :
b 8 6p<ev T b 6pa> B bg^T^fcBWet mox

: tv ri^
secl. ci. Stephanus t(rrtv sed oi s. v. W
03 ^ tiv] fc &i' B W
W
:
^ Si T tI om, voarjtrfi C 5 tyyfvriTai B' T om. B

. . . W :
C4(?T:ftB'W C5 irtpiTrhv pr. T c 9 ^ T Stob. & B :
(et mox c 11) c II t<pji B Stob. i<fni Kffrcu T ds ^vxh T : :
f) ypuxh B Stob.
;
*AIAIiN 105 d
Qa.vaT09.
OvKovv ^vxri To ivavTLOV <p avTi} cTncfêpeL ad ov ju?/ 10
TTore b^^rjTai, cos 6/c tQv TrpocrOev coftoAoyTjrat;
Kai pidka a(p6bpa, ((f)r] 6 Kfj3r]s.
Ti ovv; To b\6ixevov fjLr] tijv tov dpTLOV Ibâv tC vvvbi}

b)VO]idCoiJ.ev
ÂvdpTLOv, <\)r]. 15
To b\ bUaLov [xi] bx6pLvov Kal hv fxovcrLKov /i?/ Sexrjrai;

"Ap.ovcrov, <}>r], t6 8e a6iKoy. e
Eier* 6 8' av ddvarov fxi] Sextjrat rt KaXoviJ.v;
^ AddvaTov, ((t>r].
OvKovv '^XV ov 8e)(erai ^dyaror;
0{>. 5
'A^dyaror apa ^x^*
'A^draroy,
Etey, l(^r]' roSro fxey 8^ d7ro8e8etxât âi/xei^; 77 Trois 8oKeT;
Kat /xdAa ye iKai^ws, 2 2ci)Kpares.
Ti o^v, 7]
8' os, S) Ke'/3rjs; et rw dvapTL<a dvayKOLov i]V 10
dv(i}k4dp<a LvaL, dAAo ri rd rpta t/ dv(ake6pa dv rjv; 106

riais ydp ov;
OvKow et Kat To ddepp-ov dvayKOLOv rjv dv(t)Xedpov elvaL,
6tt6t rts eTTt x^-ova depiibv eTrdyot, viTeî]L dv f]
x^-^^ ov(ra
crds Kal aTr]KTos; ov yap dv drKaXiTd ye, ovb^ av vtto- 5
fxivovcra e8e'âro dv Tr]V depfJidrqTa.
Wkrjdi], (f)r], Aeyei?.
*X2s 8' avT(i)s 0Lp.aL Kav et rd d\}/VKT0V dvdkeOpov tji',
OTrdre eTrt to irvp y^vxp6v tl eTrrjet, ovTror' di^ dTTt^rîvvvTO
ovb^ dTrcoAAirro, dAAd (yG>v dv dTTckdov ^x^'''^-

^'^
d 10 i^x^ B Stob. : ^ frx)? T W d 13 rC/ 5^ B^ T W Stob. :
vuySJ) ravra B d 14 wvofjidônfv B et in marg. T : wfio\oyr](Tafiev

T ovofjLaôfxev W Stob. e4 i|'vx'? T W Stob. : ^ '/'wx^ B
:
e 6 ûx^ T Stob. ^ '^"X^ B W e 10 avapTitf> Bt Stob. apri(f T

a r i^ B et post n
:
t Stob. : oin. T a3 &$(pfj.ov t : dtpfxhv

:
BT W
Stob. a4 iirdyoi TW : (irdyd. Stob. : firaydyoi B oScra (Twi
Ktti] fifvovffa Stob. a8 ij 5' aDVoiy T VV Stob. : uffavrws B
4;|(i;cT0' BTW : \f/vxphv Stob. : S4'ux/"'*' Wyttenbach
io6a nAATi2N02
b OvKovv Koi oiSe, (<f>r], avdyKri iTfpl tov dOavdrov el-ndv;

(l fxkv t6 dOdvaTov kuI dv(aK(6p6v ((Ttiv, dhvvarov V^X?)
oTov 6dvaTos tt' avrijv it], dTToWvaâi' ddvaTov fxev yap
brj K TUiV TTpofiprqpAvuiV ov be^fTai ov6' lorai T6vr]Kvla,
5 axnrfp ra TpCa ovk lorai, t(f>ap.iv, dpTiov, ovbe y av to
ittpiTTOV, ovb\ br] TTvp \\rv\p6v, ovbi ye ff ev tw Twpi 6(p-
/moTTjs. " 'AAAa tC KcoAvet," (f)aCr] dv tis, " dpriov pikv t6
7TPltt6v fxr] yCyv((T6ai (tti^vtos tov dpTCov, axriTfp w/ioAdyr/-
C Tat, dTTo\ofX(vov be avTov dvr (KfCvov dpriov yeyovevai;"

r^ TavTa kiyovTL ovk dv ^xpifjLcv bLafia)^(ra(r6aL otl ovk
dTrdWvTaL' t6 ydp dvdpTCOv oIk dvcaKfdpov ((TTLV' (TTfl d
TOVTO U)IX0\6yr]T0 Tffllv, pCLbCuiS dv bLfXax6fX(da OTL TT\-
5 66vTos Tov dprCov t6 tt(pltt6v kol tol TpCa oixfTai diTLdvTa'

Ka\ TTcpl iTvp6s Ka\ 6(pfxov KOL TSiv dXK(i)v ovTOis dv 8ie/xaxo'-
fxfda. q ov;
Tldw fxv o5r.
OvKOVV Ka\ VVV TTp\ TOV d6avdT0V, L fX(V r]fxZv 6fxoXoy(LTaL

lo Ka\ dv(a\(6pov (IvaL, yfrvxr] dv (lt] irp^s tw d6dvaT0S (IvaL
d Ka\ dv(i)k(6pos' (l b( fxr], dXKov dv b(OL Xdyov^
'AAA.' ovb(v b(L, ((f)r], TovTov y( (V(Ka- oôAtj ydp av
TL oAAo (f)6opdv fxrf b(\0LT0, (l t6 y( d^ddvarov dCbLov dv
(f)6opdv b(^(TaL.
5 *0 b( y( 6(6s oTpLttL, ((f)r] 6 'EcoKpdrr^s, Ka\ avrd t6 ttjs
Ccorjs (Ibos Ka\ d tl oAAo dddvardv ^(ttlv, iTapd TTdvTiav dv

6fxo\oyr]6(Crf fxrfbiiroT^ dTT6Xkv(r6aL.
ITapa TTavTiDV fxivTOL vr] AC\ ((f)r], dv6p<aiT(t)V t( ye kol

(TL fxJdXXov, i)s iyZfxaL, irapd 6(5)V.
e ' 'OTTOTe br] t6 dddvarov Ka\ dbLd(f)6op6v ((ttlv, dXXo
bI om. T Stob.
flirf7v B : b 6 irOp B rh wvp T Stob. :
C I B T airoKXv/xfVOv
i,iro\ofifvov Stob. : C 2 iiafiaxfffaaOat W
T W
SiafjLdxfirOai B Stob.
: C 4 wfioK^yriTO B i)fio\oyfiro T Stob. :
c8 Ko.vv fJLfv oiv Bt om. T C9 9avirov pr. T Stob.

: rifi7v
om. W cio TAlAi2N io6e
TL '^vxrj ?/, ei a6dvaTos Tvy)(avi ov(ra, kol aviaKcdpoi

av (iT];
IToAA^ avdyKTf].
'ETTtoiTos dpa Oavdrov eirl tov &v6p(t)7rov to pikv 6vr]T6v, 5
ws 4oLKv, avTov aTro^VT^cr Kii., to 8' dddvaTov crSiv Kal

dbLd(f)dopov otx^TaL aTiLov, v-niKyuiprqa-av rai 6avdT(^.
<t>atVerai.
riai^ros p.d\kov &pa, I<^tj, Oi Kc/Stjs, '^vyj] dddvaTov Ka\

dvooXedpov, Kal rw orrt tcrovTaL fjpoiv ai \j/vxal Iv "AtSoii. 107
OvKovv eyooye, S) ^(aKpaTes, ^(jir], ex^ Trapd TavTa aAAo
rt \4yeLV ovbi Ttr] dTiL^rr^Zv tols Aoyots. dAA' et brj tl
2t///:xtas obe ?/ rts aAAo? Iêt Aeyety, v Ix^' I^V KaTacrLyi]-

(raL' ois ovK oTba els ovTLvd tls dWov Kaipov dva/SdWoLTO 5
?/ Tov vvv Ttapovra, Tre pl twv tolovt(i)v fiov\6pLVos ?/ rt
ftety 7/ dKOV(raL.
'AAAa pr]v, ^ b* os 6 '2,Lix[xCas, ovb^ avTos exw ert ott?/
dirtoTci) K ye t&v Aeyo/xefcoy vtto pAvTOL tov /xeyeôus 7re/)i
dv OL KoyoL dcTLV, Kal Tr]v dv6p(aTtLvr]v dcrdeveLav dTLpdôov, b

dvayKaôpaL d~L(rTLav en exeii' Tra/)' ipi.avT(a irepl tSiv
elpi]p4v(i)V.
Ov p.6vov y, e(/)?/, o) ^LppCa, 6 2(DKpdTr]s, dAAa raCrd

re eS Ae'yets Kat rds ye vTTOêVets rds TTpcoTas, Kal et 5
TTto-rat v/Atv eio-iv, o/xa>s e7rto-Ke7rre'at cra^picTTepov' kol kdv

avTas lKav(i)S 8te'A?/re, ws eyw/xai, dKoAou07/o-ere roi Ao'yo>,
Ka^' oo-oy Svmroy /xdAto-r' dv6p(l)TT(^ (TraKokovdrja-aL' kclv
TOVTO avTO a-a(f)S y4vr]TaL, ovblv ^?/7ô-cre TTepaiTipoo.

ÂXr]6r], ((f)r], Ae'yeis. 10
'AAAd rdbe y , e^?/, S) dvbp(.s, hlKaLov bLavor]6r]vaL, otl, c

etTrep r) '^vyr] dddvaTos, eTrt/xeAetas 8?/ 8etrat oi^x. VTre/j roi)
6 2 iûx^ BT Stob. ^ i//ux^ W : ^ B : post ri Stob. : om. T

as ov5( irrj BT ovSfn W a^ 356 B'TW : om. B a^ ts
W
:
B T Tiy &'W ava^dKoiro (în marg. avo/cpovoiTo) a6 ij t

W
:
BT i^Toi W a8 Tj T : om. B h i ouk arifid(a>v in marg.

W
:
B' b5 7 B= T om. B b6 iviaKtirria Seager b 7 5'-

ATjTf B- W SifATjToj B
:
eAtjTa T (e s. v. t) a.Ko\ovdii(riTt B,- W :
b 8 k&v B W t
: :
aKo\ovei)<T(rai BT (t s. v. t) : T
/cai C i toSc
7' B : T
roif W : r6 y' Stob. C 2 aedvaros BT lambl. Stob.
addvar6i iariv WW
I07C nAATQNOS
\p6vov TovTov ixovov (V u) KoXovixfv To Cv^t oXk* irnkp tov
TravTos, Ka\ 6 Kivbvvos vvv hr] koX hoîuv hv beivbs (ivai.,
5 ei Tis avTijs d/xA?/o-et. i p.ev yap ^v 6 ddvaTos tov irairrbs
airaXKayri, epp.aiov h.v r\v toIs KaKois aTToOavovai, tov T

(TcapiaTos fi/x' dTTTjAAdxâi Kal Trji avrStv KaKias fi(Ta tt/s
\j/vxfis' vvv 8' C7rei8?/ dOdvaTos (f)a[vTai ovaa, ovbpi.ia av

d (tr] avTrj dAA?j aTTOcfivyr] KaK^v ovb^ cruiTrjpia Trkrjv tov ojs
^\TC(rTT}v T Kal (f>poviixu}TdTr]v yevecrdai. ovbev ydp aWo

exovcra cts "Atbov fj yjfvxi] (p\Tai. Tr\r]v Trjs Traibdas T Kal
Tpo(\>fis, h br] Kcu pAyiaTa XeyeTai. oxfxKelv ?/ /SAaTrrfii; tov

5 TfKevTrj^ravTa v6vs (v dp\r] Trjs (Kd^re 'nopeias. keyfTai,
8e ovTOis, i)S dpa TX.VTrj(ravTa Ka(TTOv 6 (Kd(rTov baCpiOiV,
ocTTrep ^wi^Ta eiA?;^^' ovtos dyav iTn\i.peX eiy brj Tira
TOTTov, ol bL Tovs (TvWeyevTas btabtKa(rapvovs cis "AtSov
e TiopV(r6aL p.Td r}yp6vos KCvov u) br] TTpocrreTaKTat tovs
v6vb KL(r TTopva-aL' TV)(6irras bc e/cci wr 8?; rvx^lv
Kal p.CvavTas ov xph XP^^^^ dAAos bvpo ttoXlv yyepLwv
KO]xC^t V 7roAA.ats XP^^^^ '^'^' iiaKpals TTepidbots. aTL b
&pa T] TTopeCa ovx w? o Ato-;(vAou T?/Ae(ôs Aeyct* ^fcctros
Io8 fjLV ydp diTXrjv oXp6v (j)r](rLV is "AtSov ^pLV, r] 8' ovt
aTTXrj ovT ]xCa (f)aCvTaC ]xol ctrat. ov8e ydp dv r]yp6v(jjv
(bf ov ydp TTOV tls dv bLafxdpToi ovbap6(r /xtds obov
ov(rr]s. vvv 8e eotxc (rxC(rts T Kai Tptobovs TroAAds )(eti;*
5 dTrd tQv 6va-LU)V T KOL VOpiCpoOV TU)V v6db TKp.atp6pLVOS
Aeyco. ^ ptkv ovv Kocrp.Ca t Kal (f)p6vLpos '^Tf^Tai T ^XV

Kai ovK dyvoL Ta TrapdvTa' }] 8' TTL6vp.r]TLK(os tov (r(Lp.aTOS
xovcra, oiTp v to) p.TTpo(rdV eiTror, Trepl Klvo ito\vv
C5 ifitX^fitrft B T lambl. Stob. : i/xtX^fftttv B' c6 &y B t W

lambl. om. T Stob.
: KaKOit] kokws Stob. d^ ixiyiffra Kiyfrai
B: Xtyfrai fifyttrra TW
lambl. Stob. d^ Scrtrfp ovros] uxrwtp . . .
. .. oSrws Stob. e a ivdfySt B Stob. ivBdSt T iropfvcrai B

:
Stob. : iroptvtadai T iKtl Siv T fKtivaiy 5>v B :iKtlvoiv Stob. S^ :
Stob. 5*r B T
: W
a a ouSi] ovitv Stob. &j. B Stob. om. T :
sed add. post ihtt a 3 ou B T Stob. ovii B^ itafuiprot B :

: W
audproi T W
Stob. a^ rpi65ovs 01j'mp. Proclus wtptSSovs : BTW
Stob. as Bvfftwv T Stob. W
dcriwv B et yp. : a6 olv Wt
B*TW Stob. om. B: a8 tfjnrpoadtv B Stob. irp6<rdtv T :
:
*AIA12N io8b
\p6vOV 1TT0r]flVr} Kol TTCpl TOV OpaTOV TOTTOV, TToWa b

avTiT(iva(Ta Ka\ TroXka TraOova-a, îa Ka\ p.6yLS vtto tov
TTpoa-TfTayixivov baifxovos otxeTat ayop.4vr}. acf)iKop.4in]v be
odnrep ai akXai, rqv fxev aKadapTOv Kai n iTcnoiriKvlav
TOLovTov, 7/ (f)6v(i}v abLKcov rjp.piivriv ?/ aAA.' aTTa TotavTa 5
cipyaapifvrjv, a tovtcov ab(X(f)a re Ka\ abeX<pu)V \j/vxiov (pya '
Tvyyjwî ovTa, Tai/rrjv fXV aTras (f)(vyL T kol VTTeKTpiireTai

Ka\ ovT crvvip.TTopos ovT rjyefxuiV eêAei yiyvecrOaL, ovtt)
8e TTXavaTai iv TTaari yo\xivr] aTTOpi(i eoos av br] TLves C
Xporoi yiviavTai, Stv (\66vT(t)V v-n avdyKr]s <f)ep(Tai els TrfV
avTr) TTpiiTova-av OLKrjaLV rj be KaOapQs re Ka\ fxeTpiuJs tov
l3iov bL^K6ova-a, Ka\ avvjXTT6p(iov Ka\ i]ye\x6v()v 6iG)V
Tvyovira, !^Kr](riv tov avTfj kKaa-Trj t6itov iTpoa-rfKovTa. ila\v 5
8e TToAAot Ka\ 6av]xaaTo\ ti]s yr\s t6ttol, koI avrt] ovt ota
ovTe oar] Soâêrai vtto tu>v Trept yrjs lo)66t(ov XiyeLV, ws
e-yo) VTTo' rtfos Wireto-ftai.
Kai 6 ^Lixjxias, YlQ^s TavTa, ((f)r], Ae'yeis, u) 2&j/cpares; d
Trept yap tol yrjs Ka\ avTos ttoWo. br] aKrjKoa, ov fxdvrot
TQLVTa h (T Tretêf r]be(t)s ovv av d/cowat/ixt.
'AAAa fxivTOt, S) ^tppiia, ovx rj TkavKOV T^xvr] yi fxot
boKî etrat 8t7jy7/o-acrât a y' eaTiv o)S fxivTot dkr]6r], 5

XaAeTTwrepoi' fxot <âtyerai r] KaTo. Tr]v rAauKOu rixjrqv, Ka\
OLfxa fxev eyo) to-cos ovb^ av ol6s re eirjr, dpa 8e', et Kat
riTTtaTafxrfv, 6 (3ios fxot boKet 6 eô's, co '2ifXfiia, T(o fxr]Kit
Tov k6yov ovK eâpKelv. rqv fxevTot tbeav rrjs yrjs otav
7re'7retT/xai etrai, KOt tovs t6ttovs avTrjs ovbiv /xe KcoAvet e
Ae'yetr.
'AAA', e</)rj 6 'Stfxfxias, Ka\ Tavra dpKft.
b I iroA\o] &\\a Stob. b2 /jl6\is T Stob. b4 oTirfp Cobet

b7 vTTfKTpfiTfTai] vTTOKpvirTeTai Stob. C4 Beciu B* T
Stob. : W
offwv B c5
fKa.(TTr] T
C 8 tivos B T W : 5e tivos Stob. (fort.
8^ Tivos) yris B Stob. t^s 77)? B' T
d. 2 d : 3 oSv &' B tiv olv T :
olv Stob. d 4 ovx ^ B T Stob. ovxi v Eus. W

ovx^t Heindorf : :
Tfxyv y( M"' B T Eus. Stob. <y fioi t(x*'V d 5 o 7' T Eus. W

W
:
W
:
a 7 S T Stob.
: 86 7' B :d 7 ovS' B T Eus. Stob. ovk :
Koi j Eus. d 9 iâpKflv T Eus. Stob. iâpKf'i B W :

io8e nAATXlNOS
ne7rei(r/xat tolvvv, t) 8' os, ^yu> <)$ TtpQtTov /x/y, eZ (<mv
5 cr /netro) to) ovpavut TrepKfxpi^s ovaa, ixrjbev avrrj bdv /xf/re
109 aepos TTpos to ixrj irfa-flv fxrjTe oAAtjj &va.yKr]s yLr}bep.Cas
T0iavTr]s, aXka iKavr]V (Tvai avrrjv laêiv Trjv 6fj.oi6Tr]Ta
Tov ovpavov avTov lairrw itavTr} Koi ttjs yrjs avrijs tt]v
ia-oppoTTLOV' la-oppoTTOv yap irpayp.a oixoLov Tivos iv pUarô
5 Tedev ovx êt [xaWov ov8' rjrrov ovbaixoac K\idr]vai,
ojxoCois b' Xov aKki,vs /xerei. TrpSiTov ]xkv tolvvv, tj 8' os,
TOVTo TTeireLa-ixai.
Kal opOios y, e(f)r] 6 ^LixixCas.

"Eti tolwv, (f)r], TTdixixeyd n eirat avro, koI rjpMS oIklv
b Tovs p^XP'- 'Hpa/cAeiW a-Tr]X.S>v aTTO 4>do-i8os iv a-p.LKp^

TLVL p.op[(a, &(nTep 7Tpl reA/xa ixvpixr]Kas 7/ fiaTpdyovs iTfpl
Ti]V OdXaTTav OLKovvTas, KaX dAAous dAAoî ttoXXovs iv

TToAAoio-t roiovTOiy roVots oiKelv. (IvaL yap TTajrraxfj TTfpl
5 Ti]v yrjv TToXka xotAa Kat TrarroSa^rd koI tcls ibeas Kal tcl
IxeyeOr], ets d a-vvppvr]KvaL t6 re vb(ap Kal rrjv o/i^jÂTjy

KOt Tov depa' avrqv be Tr]v yfjv Kadapav iv KaOapM KfLadaL
T(a ovpav^ (V wTTep ^crri rd aa-rpa, ov br] aidepa dyo/xdêii'
C Tovs TToAAous T(av TTepX Ta TouxvTa i(o66T(av Ae'yetv ov brj
VTToa-Tddp.r]v TavTa (Ivai Kal (Tvppelv dei ety rd KOtAa Trjs
yr]S. rjixds ovv oiKovvTas ev tols kolKols avrrjs XekrjOevaL

Kal oi(r6at dv(a (ttI rrjs yrjs oIkiv, &<nTp av ei rt? v
5 /xeo-fa) r<S TTv6ixvi tov TreAdyovy otKa>r 010 trd re eTri Trjs
daXdTTTis oiKLV Kal 8td tov vbaTos opiav tov rjKLOv Kal rd
dAAa da-Tpa ttjv 6dXaTT(xv riyoLTo ovpavov etvat, 8id 8e
d ^pabvTriTd T Ka\ dadeveLav pLribTT(aiTOT ttI rd aKpa Trjs
6aXdTTr]s d(f)LyiXVos /Ar/8e (apaKa)s ei?/, iKbvs Kal dvaKrj\f/as

K Trjs 6a\dTTris eis rbv iv6db t6ttov, oar(a Ka6ap(aTpos
Kttt KaAAtaif rvyxdrei u)V tov iTapd o-<^tVt, ixr]bk dAAou
e4 y^ Stob.
*/] e 5 rov ovpavov Stob. a3 auT^j B t Stob. :
outV T Eus. a6 fifvd B T roiwv T W 8i; W : Eus. : om.

B Stob. B Eus. Stob. om. T (add. in marg.)
^ 8' kj : W b4 toA-
Ko7(Ti T iroWoh B Eus. Stob.
: c 4 tî B T Eus. ; om. Stob.
d 1 ov^fniuiroTt W
d 4 KoAXiW pr. T
:
*AIAI2N logd
aKTjKoo)? etTj Tov koopaKOTOS. TavTov brj tovto kol rjfjLas 5

TTTT0vd4vai,' olKOvvTas yap V TivL KOtAo> TT]s yyjs oucrdai
TT6.v(ii avrfis oIkcIv, Kal tov aipa ovpavbv KaXeiv, &)? bia
TovTov ovpavov ovTos TCL 6.(TTpa \o>povvTa' To 5e a.vaL Tav-
TQV, VK aa-Ocveias Kal fSpabvTTJTos ovx otovs re elvaL Tjfxas e
bLQe\6eLV ctt' eayaTov tov aipa' eireL, et tls avTOv k'n cLKpa
eKOoL 7/ TTrrjvbs yevojxevos avdTTTOLTo, KaTLbelv (avy dvaKV-
yj/avTa, a>a-np ivddbe oi K Trjs ôAarTTjs ixOves dvaKV-
TTTOVTiS 6pG>aL TO. kvddbe, OVTU)S dv TLVa Ka\ Ta KL KttTLbcLV, 5
Koi (l r) (pva-LS LKavr] etr] dvaayia-daL dccopova-a, yvSivaL hv
OTL KLv6s kaTLV 6 dkr)6<as ovpavos Kal t6 dXr]6Lv6v (pws
Kal rj u)S dXr]6ws yrj. rjbe pikv yap r} yrj Kal ol \l6ol Kal IIO
diTas 6 TOTTos 6 cvddbe bL(f)6apfxeva (o-tIv Kal KaTajSf^poi-
fxva, uio-TTep tcl iv tt) 6aXdTTr] vtt6 Trjs dXfjirfs, Kal ovt
(jiveTaL a^LOV Xoyov ovbkv v tt) 6akdTTr], ovt TekeLOv wy
TTos Ittlv ovb^v icTTL, (Trfpayy^s b Kal dfifios Kal TTr]X6s 5
dfxrixavos Kal fiopôpoi eiaiv, ottov av Kal [17] yrj
ff,
Kal
TTp6s To. TTap* rjfiLV KdXXr] KpLveaOaL ovb^ OTTOicrTLovv d^La,
KLva b av tG)V TTap' rjp.lv ttoXv dv tl ttXôv (f)avLr] bia-
(fiipeiv 1 yap brj Kai fiv6ov XyLV koXov, a^LOV dKOvaaL, S b
^LfifiLa, ota TvyxavL to, ttl Trjs yrjs vtt6 tw ovpavSt ovTa.
AXXd fxifv, (f>r] 6 ^LfXfiias, (o ^(t)KpaTS, rjfxels y tovtov
Tov fxvOov r]b0}s dv dKovcraLfXV.
AyTaL Toivvv, (})r], S> eratpe, TTpaTov fXV tyat TOLavTrf 5
i] yrj avTr] ibelv, et tls dvoidcv de^TO, ojaTTep al bu)bKdcrKV-
TOL a-(f)aLpaL, TTOLKiXr], >(p(>/xao-ii; bLLXr]fxp.vr], S)V Kal Ta
v6ab LvaL xp(ofxaTa coaTTep beiyfxaTa, ols bi] ol ypa^firjs
e 2 &Kpa B T Eus. Stob. &Kpou

: W
e 3 &!/ Stephanus 5?) Eus
W
:
om. BT W Stob. e 6 dvaerxfVeaj t &v avaaxeaOai T Stob,

:
avexeo-eot B Eus. et W s. v. W
e 7 aK-nOivhy B^ T Eus. Stob.
a\7ieu>s B a 1 7}5 B T W
Eus. Stob. ^5rj B a 4 ovSkv
:
post \6yov T Eus. ante B utrobique WStob. a6

: Sîov :
Kai
om. Stob. om. : a 8 noKv T W Eus. Stob. noWov B
fi recc. t
W
:
b 5^ T
I (e 5?) B Ka\6v B^ T W Eus.
Eus. Stob. 5*? : Stob.
om. B B T Eus. i|(oj/ B^ W b2 Stob.
om. oi &îov : ttjs
Stob. b6 B^ T W Eus. Vs B 6? Tis T Eus. Stob. OeipTo
B^ W
:
Stob. hv B
: e((fiTo : et(fTo avTiiv
PLATO, VOL. I. H
iioc riAATiiNOS
C Karaxp^vTat. ^xei Sk tTaa-av ttjv yi\v ^k toiovtohv (ivai, Kal
TToXv (TL (K X.aiXTTpOT^pOiV Kttl KaOapOiTe pUiV 7} TOVTOiV TrjV
fikv yap aXovpyrj ctrat [/caij davixacTrfv t6 koAAoj, ttjv bk

Xpva-oeibrj, TrjV be oa-rj Acu/c^ yviôv r] xi^^vos \VKOT(pav,
5 Kol ^K Tu>v aWuiv xpuifxdTUiV avyKdixdvrjv dxraura)?, fcat rt
rrkeiovuiv Kai KaXkiovuiv r] oa-a ffp.els kuipaKafxev, Koi yap

avTCL TavTa to. KolXa avTrJ9, vbaTos re *cai aepos c/cTrAea
d om-a, xpiofxaTos ri etSos Trapexecrâi a-Ti\/3ovTa iv tji tS)V
aXkuiv \puip.dTUiv TToiKLX.Cq, cjare ev tl avrrjs eTbos avvexes
ttolklKov (fiavTdCea-daL. iv 8e Tavrt] ova~r] TOLavTj] ava
Xoyov TCL (f)v6p.eva (fivea-daL, bevbpa re /cat avdj] koI tovs
5 KapTtovs' KoX av to. opr] uicravTUiS Kal tovs \l6ovs ^X^"' ^^"
Tov avrbv \6yov rt]V re ketOTrjTa koI Tr]v bui<f>dveLav Kal to.
XpiofxaTa KaWCui- (Hv kcu to. evOdbe AtîSta eXvaL TavTa tcl
dya-nâfxeva fxdpLa, (rdpbLd re Koi Ida-nLbas Kai (Tfxapdybovs

e xat iravra to. TOLavra' e/cei 8e ovbev otl ov tolovtov etrai Kai
eri TovTUiv /coAAtco. to 8' atrtoy tovtov etrai ori eKeiroi ot
Aiôt el(ri KaOapoi /cat ov KaTebr^bea-fxevoL ovbe bLe(fidap]xevoL
uicntep ol ivddbe vtto a~qTTeb6vos Kai &\p.r]s vtto tu>v bevpo
5 (Tvveppvr^KOTUiV, h Kai Atôts Kai yf]
Kai toXs dWoLS Côls re
Kai (fiVTOLs ata-xr] re Kai voaovs TTapexd-. ti]v be yijv airnjv
KeKoa-fxr^crdaL tovtols re aTrao-t Kai ert xpv(T(a re kclI dpyvp(o Kai

III rot? aAAots av tols tolovtols. eK(f)avr] yap avTO. TT(f)VKevaL,
ovTa TroAAa TrA^êt Kat fLeydXa Kai iTavTaxov Tfjs yi]S, u>aTe
avTrfv Ibelv etrai Oeafxa evba^x6vuiv deaTuiv. {Sa 8' eir'
avrr] eXvaL d\ka re TroAAa Kat dv6p(aTTovs, tovs fxev ev

5 fxeaoyaCci olKOvvTas, tovs 8e Trepi tov depa uiaiTep rffxels
B T 05 W B'TW
M03B
Koi Stob. : om. Eus. iyKftfiftnjv fr
C 7 iKx\fa BT W Eus. Stob. : ffiirXfa al. d i irop
fXftrOat B^TW Eus. : irapfxfrat B Stob. d^ &ydri BT Eus. Stob.
&\<ni B''W d6*** Tî/ T \ft6Tr]ra T {Tf\ft6TTira B
Stob.) e I 8r ou B T: dnovv Eus. (et mox
ovk fhat^ : bVi jjl^ B*W
h fiii Stob. e 3 f iffl Ka0apo\ B : KaOapoi flaiv T W Eus. Stob
65 & s. V. T : om. Stob. AfOoiy] rols in marg. B' 67 fiTorri
B Eus. Stob. : itaatv T Eus. Stob. /tal B

t /tol T s a av :
raxov TW : itoWaxov B Eus. Stob. a 3 Ofaruv om. Stob,

a4 awTp B : avriiy T W
auT^j Stob. :
*AIAQN III a
Tre/oi TTjV OaKaTTOv, tovs 6' V y^crois hs irepippdv tov aipa

irpbs Trj ^Tretpo) oixras' nal evl Xoyca, oirep rjiuv to vhoop tc
Koi fj OaXaTTa eort TTpos ttjv fjfxeTipav XPîay, tovto Ki
Tov aipa, h 8e f}p.iv aqp, (KeCvois tov aiOepa. tcls 8e wpas b

avTois Kpacnv exetv TOLavrrjv axTTe (Keivovs av6(rovs eTvai. Kal
Xpovov T 0]V TToXv TTkeioi T&v v6dbe, Kal 6\j/ei Kal aKofi Kal
<f)povq(ri Kal Tracri Tois ToiovTOis f}p.5>v aêcrrayai Trj avTri
cnToa-Tacrei rjirep drjp re vbaTos d(f)eaTr]Kev Kal al6r]p depos 5
npos KadapoTT^Ta. Kal br] Kal 6e&v aX(rq re Kal iepa avTols
eivai, iv ots rw ovTi oiKTjras 6eovs elvai, Kal <\>r]p.as re Ka\
fiavTeCas koI al(r6r](reis t5>v 6eS)v koI ToiavTas crvvovcrias
yiyvecr6ai avTols Trpbs avTovs' Kal tov ye rjXiov Kal (reXrjvqv C
Koi a^TTpa 6pd(r6ai vit' avT&v ola Tvyxdvei ovTa, Kal rqv
d\Xr]v evbaipLoviav tovtoov dKoXovôv etvai.
Kal okr]v fjiev br] rryv yrjv ovTUi Tre^jJVKevai Kal to. Tvepl
rr]V yfjv tottovs b' ev avTr] elvai Kara ra eyKotXa avTrjs 5
KVK\(a TtepX oXr]v 'noKkovs, tovs piev (SadvTepovs Kat dva-

TTeTrraiJ.evovs jxdXXov fj ev ^ fjpLels olKovp.ev, tovs be fta6v-
repovs ovTas to yd(rim avrovs ekaTTov exeiv tov "nap f]p.iv
TOTTOV, ecrrt 8' ov? Kai ^pa^vTepovs roi j3d6ei tov ev6dbe d
etyat Kai 'TrAarvrepous. tovtovs be Trdvras vtto yfjv eis
d\Xr]kovs a-vvTeTpf](rdai re iToXXaxr] Kal KaTa (TTevoTepa koX

evpvTepa Kal bteôbovs e\eiv, f]
ttoXv piev vboip pelv e^
dXkf]k(iiV eis dXkqkovs &cr'TTep eis KpaTrjpas, Kal devdctiv 5
TT0Tap.5>v dfiriyava yieye6r] vtto Tf]V yf]V Kal 6ep]xS)V vbaToiv
KoX ^lfvy^pSiV, TTokv be TTOp KOi TTvpos p.eyaXovs TTOTajxovs,

TToXXovs be vypov TrrjAou /cat Ka6ap(aTepov koI (3opôp(t)be-
(TTepov, u>a-iTep ev 2tKeAta ot TTpb tov pvaKos TrqXov peovTes e
TTora/xot Kat avrbs 6 pva^' wv bf] kcCl eKdcTTovs tovs tottovs
a7 re om. Stob. b 2 outo?s T Stob. avTris B 1)6 &KaT\ :
B Stob. fh-t] T et ut vid. Timaeus

: ca dpaaOai : OeupfâOai BT
B*W C3 TovroDv B Stob. : om. T d o6s
i B Stob. oS :
pr. T ds Kal KaTa B T W

Ka\ addubitavit Heindorf: koJ tcI
:
Stob. d 5 /cai T Stob. W

e'| in ras. B d 8 Se B T Stob.
: :
T B' WKttOetpuStarfpou in marg. B^ Bi iv B Stob. 01 ivT :
11*
iiie riAATilNOS
TrXrjpovcrOai, (as hv e/caorots tvxjj kKdaroTe rj Trepippoi] yiyvo-
fjLvr], Tavra bi itAvTa Kivdv avoi Kal KaTO) uxmfp aldpav
yfy ecrri 6e apa avrr] f] al(apa bia (f)v(riv

5 TLva evov(rav V rr;
TOMvbe TLvd. (V Ti Tuiv \a(TyLdT(j)v TTJs yfjs &\k(tis re
112 fJ-fyLarov Tvyxdvd 6v Kal biafxiTfpcs TerprjpAvov bi oKrjs Trjs

yrjs, TovTo oirfp "Opirjpos eiTre, Aeyojr avro
TrjKe iMLk\ fi\i. ftd6i(TT0v vtto \6ov6s ioTi îpedpov
b Kal aWodi Kal (Ketvos Kal oAAot ttoAAoI tZv iroLrjToiv Tdp-
5 Tapov KiKkrjKacTLV. eis ydp tovto to yd^rp.a (rvpp4ov(ri re
iravTCs ol TroTafiol Kal ^k tovtov TrdXiv kKpiovtrLv yCyvovTai
b^ ^Ka(rToi TOLOVToi 8i' otas Sy Kal ttjs yfjs p(o(riv. fj 8e
b aZrta eortr tov iKpdv re erreCêv koI da-pflv irorra ra
pevpMTa, OTL nv6fx4va ovk eêt ovbe ^da-LV to vypov tovto.
al(t)peLTaL bfj Kal KVfxaCveL dvo) Kal KdTCi), Kal 6 df]p koI t6
TTvevfxa To "Trepi avro Tavrbv Trotet* (rvveTTTai ydp avrw Kal
5 oTav eiy t6 eTr' eKetra ttjs yfjs 6ppir](rri Ka\ orav eis t6 (irl
Tdbe, Kal coa-Trep t&v dvaTTveovTOiv aet fKirvel re Kai dvaTryei

peov t6 TTvevfxa, ovrco xai e/cet a-vvaLcopovfxevov T(o vyp(o t6
'TTvevfxa bfLVovs TLvas dvefxovs Kal dfxrfxdvovs irapeyeTaL KaX
C ela-L6v K(XL i^Lov. drav re ovv vTT0)(0)pr]a"p t6 vboip els tov
TOTTOV t6v bff fcdra) KoXovfxevov, tols Kar (Kelva tcl pevfxara
[8ta] Trjs yfjs eto-pet re xat Trkrfpol avrd wcnTep oi eTrar-
rAoyvres* oTav re av eKeWev fxev diTokCTTrf, bevpo b\ opfxffa-r],
5 Ta iv6db TrkrfpoL addis, tol b^ 7TXr]poi)6evTa pd bia tS)V

6xfTS)v Ka\ 8ta Trjs yfjs, kox els tovs tottovs eKaara d(f)LKVov-
fxfva, els ovs iKaorot? iSoirotTjrat, âAd7~ras re Ka\ \Cfxvas

Ka\ TTOTafxovs KoX Kprfvas Troiet* evTev6ev bi TroAty bvofxeva
d Kara Trjs yfjs, rd piev fxaKporepovs tottovs TTepLeK66vTa koX
TTkeCovs, rd 8e eXdrrovs Ka\ ^paxyrepovs, TrdAtr eis rdy
e 3 dr Stob. 5/ B T : a 5 t B T Stob. om. : W b4 avrh

Heindorf: oirbv Stob.BT C i oiy Stob. BT : ovy dpnvaay
B^ W 3 5ick B T om. Stob. : C 4 diroA*iir; W C 6 koI
810 om. W C 7 iKciarois T Stob. tKcurTovs B : aiSoirolriTai
Stob :65oiroifrTO B T jSotto^jtoi: (sed d s. v.) W d2 AottwW
PpaxvTfpovs B Stob. : fipaSvrfpous T
4)AIAnN n2d
Taprapov e/xj3aAAet, tcl fjiev ttoX.v KaTcaTipoo (rj)
fj
^tttjv-
rAeiro, to, 8e oXiyov TrdvTa 8e vTTOKdTO) da-pcl ttjs eKporjs,

Kal Irta fifv KaTOVTLKpv (rf) y [ela-pei] iêirea-ev, iVLa t\ 5
KaTa To avTo }xipos' ea-TL be h TravTdiraa-LV kvk\(o Tre/aieA-
OovTa, 7} d-na^ rj Kal TrkeovdKLS T:epLeKL\divTa Trepl Trjv yfjv
Coa-nep ol ocpeLS, els to bvvaTov KdTo) KadevTa TidXLV e/x/3aAAei.
bvvaTov 8e eorrtv kKaTepcoae p.expi' tov ixeaov KaOLevai, Trepa e
b' ov' dvavTcs ydp dp.(poTipoLS tols pevjxaa-L t6 kKaTepcodev
yiyveTai fxepos.
Ta fxev ovv brj dXXa TToAAa re Kat /xeyaAa Kat TravTobaTra
pevfxaTd ea-TL' TvyxdveL 8' dpa ovTa ev tovtols tols ttoWoIs 5
TeTTap' aTTa pevfxaTa, Stv to fxev fxeyLo-Tov koX e^coTdTco peov
TTepl kvkAo) 6 KaXovfxevos 'HKeavos ea-TLV, tovtov be KaTav-
TLKpv Kol evavTLOiS peoov 'Aêpcov, os 81' epiffxoiv re TOTtoiV
pei dXku)V Ka\ br] koX imo yrjv peoov els ti]v X.Lfxvriv d(f)LKveLTaL 113
Trjv 'Axepova-Ldba, ov al twv TeTeXevrrfKOTcov ypvxol tG)V
iroXKSov d(f)LKVovvTai KaC TLvas eifxapp.evovs \p6vovs fxeivacraL,
al fxev fxaKpoTepovs, al be ^pa\vTepovs, itdXLV eKTtefx-novTai
els Tas tQ)V C^^ yeveaeis. rpiTOS be Trora/xo? tovtcov /cara 5
fxea-ov Kj3dXXeL, Kal eyyvs Trjs eKôkfjs eKTTtTrrei ets tottov

fxeyav iTvpl iroAAo) Koofxevov, Kal XCfxirqv Trotet fxei^co Trjs
TTap' fffxXv daXdTTrfs, Côvaav vbaTos Kal tttjAoC- evTevdev be

Xt>pet kvkAo) doXepos Kal TTrfXâbrjs, TTepLeXLTTOfxevos be rrj b
y?} aAAocre' re d^fîKvelTai Kal Trap' ecryaTa TTfs ' Ayepov(TLdbos
Xifxvrjs, ov o-vp.fxeiyvvfxevos rw vbaTL' TrepteAtxêt? be TroAAoKts
VTTo yyjs efx(3dXXeL KaTcoTepoo tov TapTdfMV' ovtos b' eaTlv
ov eTTovofxdCovaiv TIvpL(f)Xeye6ovTa, ov Kal ol pvaKes diTO-
5
d3^J^]^BT:^W d5^^]^BTW eiVpe? om. Stob.

e2 ya.p afx<t>oTepois T Stob. yap irphs ajxcpoTipois Bt irpos yap aix<pO'
W
:
W
:
ripois B- : 70^ irphs afxcpoTfpa in marg. (error ortus e v. 1.

irp6ffavTes) 65 Tvyxdyeiy W e6 Stto B : om. T Stob. uvtu :
in marg. B' 67 irfpl KVK\Cf) T : itfpiKVKKif B : toi Tr(p\ KVK\cf> Stob.

e 8 evavTiais T Stob. : ivavTios B a 2 oS] of Schanz a 5 tovtuv
BT Eus. Stob. 5io tovtwv : W a 7 /xeyo T bi tt) 77) BT W
Stob. om. Theodoretus (habet
: Eus )
b5 eirovo/xdôvcn T W Eus.
Stob. tTi ovofidôvffiv B
:
113 b nAATI2N02
(riTaa-fxaTa ava^^vcrSxnv oirr) hv rvyaxri ttjs yrji. tovtov bi
au KaTavTkKpv 6 TeTapros iKTTCiTTei eis tottov TrpStTov bdvov
T Koi dypiov, ws XeyfTai, ^piapa 8' iypvra 6\ov olov 6
C Kvavos, ov hr) kirovopAôva-L ^Tvyiov, koX ttjv kCpvrjv ^v
TToiel 6 TTOTapbs fpfidW(ov, ^Tvya' 6 8' (pTrecru^v (VTavOa
Kal bdvas bvvapeis Xaô)!' ev tu> vbaTL, bvs KaTO. r^y yrjs,
TrepieXiTTopevos X^P^^ evavTCos tw Tlvpi.(f)\eye6ovTi. Kal
5 aiTavTa ev ttj 'A\epov(ridbi \Cpvrj e^ evavTCas' kcli ovbe to

TovTov vbcnp ovbevX peCyvvTttL, dkka Kal ovtos kvkAo) iTepLeX.-
doiiv ep^dWei els tov Tdprapov ivavTCos tw HvpLcf^XeyedoirrL'

ovopa be TOVT(o ^(ttCv, ws oi TroiTjrai keyova-LV, KoiKVTos.
d TovTcov be ovt(i)s iTe^fiVKOTaiv, eTreLbdv d(f>CK(i>VTaL ol TeTe-

KevTTjKOTes els tov tottov oX 6 baCpxav eKacrrov KopCêL,
iTpG>T0v pev bLebLKdaravTO 6t t koX&s Koi oo-uos /Suio-ayrcs
Kal 01 fXTj. Kal ot piev dv b6â>a-L pea-cos êj3L(OKevaL, iTopev-
5 OevTes eTTL tov AyjipovTa, dva0dvTes h

' bri avTols dx^/ictTa
ecTTLV, eiTX TOVTdiV d(f)LKVovvTaL els Tr]v \Cpvr]v, kcll eKel
oiKova-C T Kal KadaLpopevoL Ty Te dbLKrjpdToiv bibovTes
bCKas drToXvovTaL, eX tCs tl ribCKr]Kev, t5)v tc evepyecrLSiV
KaTa 5' dv
e TLpds cfiepovTaL ti]V d^Cav l/caoros' oX Sd^coo-iy
dvLdTOis ^X^"' ^'^ ''^ peyedrf twv dâprqpdTOiv, rj iepo-
avXCas TToAAas Kai peyd\as ^ (fidvovs dbCKovs Kai iTapavopovs

TToAAous eêLpyaa-pevoL rj dWa oaa TOLavTa rvyxdveL ovra,
5 TovTovs b\ f] 'jTpoa-r]Kov(ra poXpa pCiTTei els tqv TdpTapov,

oOev ovTTOTe ^KjSaCvova-LV. o\ 8' dv Idaipa pev peyd\a be
boôicrLV r]papTr]KevaL dpaprtjpaTa, olov iTpbs iTaTepa r] prj-
114 Tepa v-n opyijs ^CaLov ti tTpdâvTes, kolL peTape\ov avTOLS

Tov dWov (3Cov ^Luta-LV, t] dvbpocfiovoL toiovt<i) TLvi oAAo)
TpoTTâ yevciiVTaL, tovtovs b^ ipTrea-elv pev eis tov TdpTapov
b6 8? B T Stob. iwov Eus. : b 7 aJ B T Eus. Stob. alrrov B W :
c ^v al.Theodoretus
I om. Eus. Stob,
: BTW
04 ivayrltas Stob.
C7 ivayrlvs W
Stob. ea f] Eus. Stob. BTW
om. B :
4 rvyxiyei rotavra W
a 3 ravrovs B Stob. : rovrots T Eus.

AIAX2N 114 a
avdyKr}, fnT(r6vTas be avTovs Kal kviavTov iKel yevo^^vovs

eK/3dAAei to Kv\ia, tovs ixkv avbpocpovovs KaTo. tov Ka)/cirroV, 5
Tovs 8e TraTpakoLas Kal p.r]TpaXoCas KaTo. tov Tlvpi(f)\y-

iOovTa' TTiihav 8e (pepopievoL yivu>VTai KaTo. ti]V Xip.vr]v ti]v
'AxfpoucrtdSa, kvTavOa (SoSxri re Kal KaXovcnv, ol ix\v ovs

diTKT(Lvav, ol 8e ovs v^pLcrav, KaXecravTes S' i/cerevoucri
Kal hiovTaL idcrai crâs eK^rjvaL ei? Tr]V XLp.vr]v Kal biâcrOaL, b
Kal iav iifv t:L(T(i>(tlv, eKâLVOvcri re kcu kqyovcn tcov
KaK&v, et be p.r], (pipovTaL avOLS ets tov TdpTapov Ka\
iKiWev TrdkLV eis roi^s iroTap.ovs, Kal TavTa Trdo-xoyres ov

TTpoTepov iravovTaL Trplv av 7reL(rooa-LV ovs r]bLKr]aav avTr] yap 5
r] bLKr] VTTO TU)V bLKaaTcov avToXs kTayOr]. o\ be bi] av boôocrL
bLa(f)p6vToos TTpbs t6 daCois ^L&vaL, ovtoC 1(tlv ol T&vbe juei'
Toiv TOTToov tG)V V Tr\ yrj ikevOepovjxevoC re xat aTToWaTTO-

fievoi uxTTTep be(T[xoiTr]pCo)v, dvo) be els Tr]v KaOapdv OLKr](rLV C
d(f)LKvovp.evoL Kal eiri yf]S otKt^d/ievoi. tovto)v be avriav ol
(f)LKocro(pC(i LKavats KaOr^pdpLevoL dvev re (rco/Ltdrcoy ôio-t to
TTapdiTav els tov eiTeLTa \p6vov, kol els olK-qa-eLS ctl tovto)V
koXKCovs d({)LKV0VVTaL, as ovTe pabLov brjXuxraL ovTe 6 ^(pdvos 5
LKavos ev r<3 7Tap6vTL. dkXd tovtoov br] eveKa xp^/ u)V 5teArjAv-
Oaixev, o) ^LpixCa, Trav iTOLelv wcrTe dpeTrjs Kal (f)povr]cr eo)s ev
rw /3tft) pLeTa(ryjiLV' Kakov yap to dOkov Kal t] ekiTLS peydkr].
To p.ev ovv TavTa bLLayypCcracrOaL ovto)S eêiv (j? eycb d

bLekrjkvOa, ov TTpe-neL vovv eôvTL dvbpC' otl [xevToi 7] Tavr
ea-TLV rj rotavr' aTTa iTepX Tas ylrvxds rj]xu)v kcll rds otKr/o-ets,
eireCiTep dOdva^dv ye 7; ^vxi] (f)aCveTaL ova-a, tovto /cat
TTpeireLV ]xol 80/cet Kal d^Lov KLvbvvevcraL OLOfxev(a ovtms 5

exetj^ Kakbs ydp 6 KCvbvvos Kai xpi] rd rotavra coa-irep
eTT(ibeLV eavTu, 8to bi] eyooye kolI TrdAat [xr]Kvvo) tov ]xvOov.
a 5 Kvpia B T Eus. êt/jua Stob. b3 iKfiaivovcri B' W Eus.

W
: :
airoâivouai B T Stob. b5 riSiK-fiKatrtv b7 fiiSivai BTW

Eus. Stob. : îwvai irpoffKeKKrjcrdat Clem. : fiiSivai irpoKeKpiffdai Theo-
doretus c2 a<piK6/xevoi W îrJ rrjs yfis Euseb. Stob. oIk
W
. . .
(6ntvot T 03 ffa>na.Ta)v] Kafxdraiv Eus. C 4 KaWiovi rovTuv

d I ravra B- T W Stob. : TomuTO B Suffxvplêffdoii VV d5 fioi
B Stob. ifiol T :
ii4d nAATi2N02
dAXa TovTutv brj evKa Oappdv XPV "^^P^ ^^ kavTov V^X^
e avbpa ooTts iv t(o ^C<o tcls fxkv oAAas fjbovas tos irfpl t6
<TG>p.a Kol Tovs KocTfxovs etacre yaipdv, a)S aXkoTpiovs re
WTtis, Kat TrAeoy daTcpov rjyrjadpievos aTrepya^fa-Oai, tcls be
TTfpl t6 ij.av6dviv io-novbaai tc koL Koa-fxricras Tr]v ^XW
5 ovK dAAor/)t(i) dAAa rw avrrjs Koa-ixio, a-o)(f)poaijvr] re KOt
115 biKaioaijvr] Kal dvbpeia koX ekevOepCa Kal dkrjOeCa, ovTia
ireptfxevet. Tr}V ets "AtSou iropiCav [ws TTopevaoixevos otov rj
eiixapfxevr] KaATj]. v/xets fxkv ovv, e^rj, S) îfxfxCa re Kal

KejSrfs Kal ot aAAoi, els avOis ev tivl yjjovtsi (KaaTOi iTopcu-
5 a-ea-Oc e/xe be vvv rfbr) Kakel, (f)aCr] dv dvrfp TpayiKos, rf
elfxapfxivrf, koX a)(b6v tC fxoi &pa TpaTria-Oai irpos t6 kovrpov

boKei ydp brf êArtoy eiyai Aouo-d/jtevoy iTielv t6 (f)dpfxaKov
Kal firf TTpdyp.aTa tois yvvai^l Trapiyeiv veKp6v koveiv.
b Tavra brf eiiTovTos avTov 6 KpCTCDV, Elev, e(f)rf, u)
2a)/c/)ares* rt be tovtois ^ e/xoi eTTioTeÂAets ^ Trepl tQv

TTaCbcov rj irepX dAAou tov, ort dv ctol iTOLOvvTes rfpLets ev
^dpLTL fxdkLora TTOLotfxev;
5 "AiTep del keyu), e<f)rf, S K/atrtov, ovbev KaLVOTepov ort
vfxoiv avTutv eTTLp.ekovp.evoL vfLels koX efxoX kcll rots epoXs

KOLL VfXLV avTols ev ydpLTL TTOLrfaeTe aTT dv TTOLrJTe, Kav fxif
vvv ofxokoyrfarfTe' edv be vfxStv [fiev] avTQv d/xeA^re xat

fxrf '6ekr]T ojo-Trep KaT txvr] Kard rd vvv re elprffxeva
10 K(iL rd ev rw efxiTpocrêv xpdvoi ^rjv, ovbe edv TroAAd ofxoko-

C yrfarfTe ev T<a TrapovTL kcll a-(f>6bpa, ovbev Trkeov TroiT/o-ere.
Taura fxev toCvvv TTpo6vp.rfa6fi.e6a, e(f)rf, ovTCt) TTOLelv
OdiTTcofxev be ae TCva TpdiTov;

"OTrcos dv, e<f)rf, fiovkrfade, edvTTep ye kd^rfTe fxe Ka\
5 fxrf eK(f)vy(o v/xSs. FeAdo-as 6e dfxa ffcrvxfj Kal iTpds ffpMs
aTTO^keyf/as eTrrev Ov TTeCdo), S) dvbpes, Kptrajm, o)S
d8 ainov ^vxv^
rrjs W
e 2 t6 om. W a 7 8J> BT :
fjSrj B^ W 2 iiTKTTfWfis Coisl. îrireAAtiJ T : (-KiTtKKft B

W
: :
iirnfKKri B' W b 4 7roi(Dja<' B^ W b 5 t<pr) Ktyu

b6 Kal To7s i/xoTs om. T b 8 fjiiv B om. T : W e 2 irpoBvfiri-
aofjLtOa T W
irpo6ixvTi)9r)a6nt9a B
: C 3 flairrai^tv B : OaôfjLtv TW
at Tiva B rlva <re T
: c 4 /ic B : om. T c6 Jl T : ?^7j 2>
B=W: om. B
*AIAi2N 115 c
eyci) ijui ovTOS SwKparTj?, 6 vvvl biaXeyofxevos Kal 8ta-

TaTToov (KaaTov T(i>v Xiyo\xV(tiV, dAA' oierai /xe kKiivov ilvai
ov o\f/eTaL okiyov va-Tipov vKp6v, Kal (pcoTo. 8r/ ttws jue d
ddTTTj]. OTt b iyoi 'TroA.ai TTokvv Xoyov TreTTOirj/xat, a)s,
(Trei.bav ttCco to (f^dpjxaKov, ovktl vp.LV 7rapap.vS), dAA'

otx^ô-oyjtat d-Trtcbi' eis p.aKdp(ov 8^ TLvas vbaLp.ovLas, TavTd
p.0L hoKS) avT^ dWciis Aeyeiy, 7rapap.v6ovp,Vos dpa p.ev 5
vp.ds, dpa 8' p.avr6v. eyyvri^racrde ovv /xe Trpbs KptVcoya,

e(^rj, TTjv evavTLav yyvr]V t] r^v ovtos irpbs tovs 8t/caoTas
riyyvaTo. ovtos p.ev ydp ^ p.r]v 'napap.VLV' vp.LS Se 77 p.r]V
jur) Trapapcv^LV kyyvrâracrd^ e7ret8ay aTToOdvoi, akkd ol\r]-
(T(r6aL aTTLdvTa, Xva Kptrcoy pqov (p^prj, Kal p.r] op&v p.ov to e
(TQtpa 77 Kaopevov rj KaTopvTT6p.vov dyavaKTr] VTTp p.ov
ti)S bLvd 7Td(rxovTos, /xrj8e Aeyrj iv rfj ra^rj o)? rj TTpoTL^^Tat.
HcoK/adrr/ r] K(f)pL rj KaTopvTTL. v ydp l(t6l, r] 8' os, S)
dpL(TT KpLT(t)V, t6 jXrj KoXciS kyLV OV p.6vOV cls aVTO TOVTO 5
'7Tkr]p.p.kS, dkkd Kal Ka^dv tl ejuTTOtet rats xf/vxaLS. dkXd

dappLV re yj)r] koll (pdvaL Tovp.bv (r(ap.a 6d7TTLV, Kal 6dTTTLV
ovTcos oTTU)S av o-oL (pCkov r] Kal p.dkL(rTa r^yfj v6ixLp.ov eiyat. Ii6
Tairr' Îttmv Klvos ixV dvicTTaTO ets 0LKr][xd tl ws kovcro-
p.VOS, Kal 6 KpLT(ji)V LTTTO aVTS>, r]p.ds 8' KkV TTpLp.VLV.
TTpL]XVOfXV OVV TTpOS 7]p.ds aVTOVS hLaky6p.V0L TTpl tS)V
lpr]]XV(i)v Kal dvacrKoiTovvTS, tot 8' av Trept Trjs crvp.(f)opds 5
8te^toz;res ocrr] r^plv y^yowla Lr], aT^xvws r]yov]XVOL &cnTp
TTaTpbs crTpr]6VTs bLd^LV dp(f)avol rbv eTreira jSiov. e7ret8^

8e kov(TaTo Kal r]Vx6r] iTap^ avrbv Ta TTatbia 8j;o ydp avT^ b
VLS crpLKpol qaav, eis 8e piyas Kai at oi/cetat yvvoLK^s
d(f)LK0VT0 eKetrai, ivavTLov tov KpLTCovos 8taAexêts re Kat
eTTto-retAas aTTa eôvkcTO, rds pikv yvvalKas kol rd TTaibia
C 7 ovTos
W
B
ovros : STW d a edvrr) B : 0iirrei T W : ed^f/fi
fecit {}p s. y.) d8 rryyvaro BT et -yp. W : i)yyvii(raro WW
d9 oZv post fyyvfiffaa-ei add. t e i paov T f^dStov B e 3 Seivit :
irdaxovTos B t Sftva Stto (TxSvtos T

: e 7 OaTrTeiv Kal om. pr. T
b 3 fKelvai ivavriov T W
ivavriov iKeTvai B {iKeivais fecit B
:
)
iiSb nAATi2N02
5 airUvai Ki\evarev, airos bi rJKe Trap' rjims. koI fjv 7/8rj
iyyvs ri\(ov bv(rixciv' xpovov yap irokvv biiTpiyjffv ivhov.

ikOcov 8' (KaOiêro kf\ovp.ivoi koX ov noXXa ^rra pitTa
TavTa biekex^drj, Kal rJKev 6 T(ov evbcKa vmiperqs koL oras
C Trap' avTov, '12 SwKpares, ^^r;, ov KaTayvda-ofxai ye aov
oirep akKuiv KaTayiyvoia-KU), oti p.oi xaXcnaivova-i, Koi KaTa-
p&VTai iireibav avTols iTapayy(ik(o TriveLV to (fxi.pp.aKov
avayKaôvTOiv t&v ap\6vT0)v. o-f b\ eyo) Koi &X\(as

5 <Eyvu>Ka iv XP^^V yevvaioTaTOv kcu TTptioTaTov
TovTca T(a
Kal &pi(rTov &vbpa ovTa tcov TrwTrore bevpo aî/co/xeVcoi;, Kal

Stj Kol vvv v oib' oti. ovk epLol xaAeTraiyeis, yiyvda-Keis yap
Tovs ahiovs, ak\a e/ceiroiy. vvv ovv, 6la6a yap h -qKdov
d ayyiWoiv, x^^P^ ''^ ''"* iTeipfa ws pqaTa (îpuv to. avayKaia.
Kai &p.a baKpva-as yiTa(TTpe^6p.evos aTTrjd.
Kai 6 2(o*cpdT7js aval3\i\f/as TTpos avT6v, Kal crv, (f>r},
Xaipc, Koi ^fifis Tavra iToiriaop.v. Kal Sipxx Ttpos rjpLas,
5 '12ff doTeioy, ^(f>rj, 6 &v6poi)TTos' Kal iTapa tTavTa p.oi tov

Xpovov iTpocrr\eL Ka\ bieKeycTO ivioTe Kal ^v avbpGtv Kâros,
kolI vvv ws yevvaiois p. airobaKpvei. dAA' aye brj, Si
KpiTOiv, TTi6(ap.6a avrai, Kal iveyKdTO) tis t6 <f)<xpp.aKov, ei

TTpL1TTaL' fl 8e p.T^, Tpi.\f/dTO) 6 av6pO)1TOS.
e Kai 6 KpiTcov, 'AAA' otfxat., e(f)r], eyooye, S ^(aKpaTfS, Irt
rjKtov elvai eTrt toXs op(riv Kal ovtto) bebvKevai. Kal apa
iyo) olba Kal dAAovs irdw Q\f/ TrivovTas, iiTeibav TTapayytKî)
avTols, biLTTvricravTds re icai TtwvTas eu fidAo, Kal avyyevo-
5 fxivovs y Iviovs Siv hv Tvx^txriv itl6vixovvtS. dAAd fxrjbev
iiTeiyov (tl yap eyxôpet.

Kai 6 '2o)KpdTr]s, EikoVcos ye, ^r/, o) KpiTO)v, Klvol T
Tavra ttolov^tlv, ots aii Ae'yeis oiorrai yap KpbaivLV Tavra
TT0L^(ravTS Kal cycoye Tavra lk6to)s ov Troa/o-co* ovbiv yap
b7 SrTa B* T om. B W : C i ^f T om.W : B 03 irapay'

ytlKv T irapayytWw B
: c 8 ovy T om. B : & B t om. T
:
d I fiaffTa B' T W
iip;<rTo B : e 5 &i/ T om. W : B 09 tU^rots
TaCTo T
*AIAX2N 117 a
otfxaL Kepbavdp oXiyov vcrTepov iniiiV aXXo ye rj yeAcora 117

6(f)XricrLV irap ifxavTU), yAtxojuieyos tov Cv^ iôl (f)(Lb6pLVos ov-
bevos TL evovTos. aAA' Wl, e(j)r}, TreCdov Kal fir] aXkcas ttoUl.
Kal 6 KpLT(t)v aKova-as evevcre tw 7rai8t irXrj^rLov kcTT&TL.
Ka\ 6 Ttals iêXOoiv Kal avyvov xp6vov bLaTpL\f/as rJKev ay(av 5
Tov ix4\XovTa b(ocrLV t6 (pdpixaKov, kv kvKlkl (f)ipovTa TeTpLfj,-
[l4vov. Ibobv b 6 2a)/cparrjs tov avOpuiTTOV, Eier, e(^Tj, &>
jSeXTLcrTf, (Tv yap tovtoov kTTLa-Tr]p.(DV, tl xPV "ôLelv;
Ovbev aXko, (f)r], rj TTLovTa iTepLLevaL, ecos av aov j36.pos
iv Tols a-KcKecrL yivrjraL, eireLTa KaraKeto-âi* Kal oijT(t)s avrb b

TT0LT]crL. Kot afxa wpeê Tr]v KvAt/ca tw ScoKpaTet.
Kat 6? \a^d)V Kal fxaka lAecos, S) 'Exe^KpaTes, ovbev
Tpia-as ovbe bLa^pOeCpas ovtc tov \p(apt.aTos ovt tov iTpo(r-
(aiTOV, dAX' coo-7re/) etcoêt Tavprjbov VTTol3\eyf/as iTpbs tov 5
avdp(j)iTOV, Tt Ae'yet?, e</)7j, Trept Toi;8e tov TT(I)p.aTos irpos to
dTToaTTela-aC tlvl; eêcTTLV r) ov;
ToaovTov, (f>r], S) ^(i)KpaTS, TpCôixev oaov oldixeda
piTpLov elvai TTietr.
Mavddvo), 77
8' os' dAA.' evyecrOaC yi ttov tols deoXs eêcTTC C
Te Kat XP^' "^W p-eToCKrjcTLv Trjv ivdevbe eKeto-e evTvxfj yevi-
cjQaL' h. 8t) Kat eyco evyo\iaC Te KUt ykvoLTO TavTrj. Kal ajx
flTTO)v Tavra iiTLcrxîxevos Kal p.d\a ev\po)s Kal evKo'Acos

e^TTLv. Kal rjpL&v ol TToAAoi Tecos pLV eTrtetKw? otot re 5
?](ray KaT\LV to /lit) baKpveLV, <o? 8e et8ojLiei' TTtfoi^rd re Kat

TreTTcoKCjra, ovktl, dAA' e/uiou ye /3ta Kat avrov dcnaKTX X(i)pL
To. baKpva, (oa-T yKa\v\frdixVOS dTTK\aov efxavTov ov

yap brj eKelvov ye, dAAd Trjv ejxavTov Tv\riv, otov dvbpbs
TaCpov a-TpriixVos etrjv. 6 8e Kpircoi' eri iTpdTepos ejxov, d
e7ret87j ov^ ol6s t t\v KaTyj.LV rd 8dKpiia, âv(TTr\,
KTToKK6b(t)pos 8e Kat kv rw \xTTpoaQV xpdvio ovbev TTavTO

baKpv(t)v, Kal br] Kal t6t dva^pvyjjcrdpuevos KXdcov Kal
B, i KepSav(7u B' : KepSaiyfiv BT viwy B' t : iroiwv BT : aviiav W

aa irfiBov T W irieov B a6 Sjlxreiv B-T VV Si56vai B a8 rt
W
:
W
:
B T fitre ri
: b4
post Sta^pdeipas add. oi/re rvv (Tu>/j.aTos
C3 afia \fyccv W C 7 76 îa Ka\ avTov B avTOv $ia Ka\ T re Kol: :
avTov pia W a(TTaKT(e\ BT: dffTaAo/CTi yp. Ka\ aPaaTOKil W:

Ka\ /3i^ W d I trpoTfpov pr. W ifiov B : fj,ov T
ii7d HAATiiNOS 4>AIAI2N
5 &yavaKT(ii>v ovbeva ovriva ov KaTeKXaac tQv i:ap6vT0iv ttXriv
ye avTov ôiKpdTovs.
'Ekcivos 8e, Ota, I^tj, iroi.elTf, S Bavixda-ioL. iyu) [Mcirroi
ov\ iJKKTTa TOVTov iViKa Tas yvvalKas a.Tri-n^p.yâ, tva /x?/
e TOiavTa TrArj/xjueXotey /cai yap aKriKoa oti, iv eviprfnif} \pr}
TeXevTav. oAA' r]a-v\iav t &yT Kal KapTepelTe.

Kal ^/xeis aKovcravTes fia-^vv6rjpi4v re Kal kiria-yjip.fv tov
baKpveiv. 6 bi irepLeXBiav, ^ttciStj ol âpvvâ-daL I^tj to.
5 a-KeXrj, KaTfKkivri vtttlos ovrco yap iK^Kevev 6 avOpuiTTOs

Kai apa câTjro/xevos avTov ovtos 6 bovs ro (âppaKov,
bLaXLTioiV xpovov eTreo-KOTrei tovs Trobas Kal to. o-kIAtj,
K^TTCtra a-(f)6bpa Trieo-as avTov tov 7ro'8a 7/pero ei aio-âwiro,

llo o 8' ouK l^ry. Kat /txera roCro av^ts ras Kin//xas* Kai cTrartobi'
OVTUiS rjp.LV eTTcbciKVVTO OTL \ffVX0LT6 T KOt TTrjyVVTO. Kal
avTos r]TTTT0 Kal ctTrey ort, eiretSay ir/jos r7/ Kapbia yivrjTaL
avTM, t6t olxTâ-fTaL.
6 "Hbr) ovv a-x(b6v tl avTov rjv tcl Trepl t6 rjTpov y^vyop^va,
KoX KKa\v^dp(vos eveKeKaAvTrro yap eiTrev o 8?/ reAev-
ratoy ^(pOeyâTo -'X2 Kpfrcoy, e^rj, ru 'Ao-KAr/Trtoi d<êtAo/ier
aXiKTpv6va' dAAa d7ro'8ore Kat prj apeKiâ-rjTe.
'AAAa raura, l0?j, eorrat, 6 KpiTUiv dAA' o/)a cl ri oAAo

lo Alyets.
Taura epopivov avrov ovbev (tl aTTfKpivaTo, dAA' okiyov
Xp6vov StoAtTrcoi' eKtrj/^T/ re Kai 6 avOpcDTTos (^(KaXv\l/(v
avTOV, Kal 6s ra d/x/xara Harrjcnv IboiV b^ 6 KpiTOiv o-we'Aa/3e
ro a-T^pa kolI tovs 6<f>6(xXpovs.
15 "Hê ^ reAeirTT/, a> 'Exlf/Kires, roi; (Taipov rjp.LV iyfVfTO,
avbp6s, ti)s rjpels <f>aLp.V av, tS>v t6t &v iireLpa^rjpev apiarov
Kal aAAcos (^povLpoiTaTov ks ^m'' c^rors B' W irriyyuTO BT W

a8 Sia/xfK-ficrriTf W &g ravra f<rrcu ll<pri T a 14 Kcd B : rt
KalT
^3>
>
KPATTA02
EPMOrENHS KPATTA02 2X2KPATH2 St. I

P. 383
EPM. BovKei ovv koi ScoK/sarei rwSe avaKOi.voi)(ra>[j.6a a
Tov \6yov;
KP. El (TOl 80K6t.
EPM. KparvXos (f)r](rlv oSe, SwKpare?, 6v6iJt.aTos
opOoT-qra eimt efcacrra) rwy ovtoov <pv(reL iT(f)VKvXav, Kal ov 5

TovTo cTvat ovo[xa o av Tives (TvvOiixevoi Kakelv Kak&crc, ttjs
avTuiv (f)(ovr]S [Moptov eTn(f)dcyy6fXVoi, aXXa 6p66Tr}T6. TLva tG)V
6vopiaT(i)V 7Te(f)VKvaL Kat "EAAtjo-i Kal l3ap(3apoLS tijV avT-qv b

aTrao-iy. epojrw ovv avTov kyo) avrw KparTÂo? Tr\ aXrj6Lq
ei
ovofia [((ttIv rj ov]- 6 8e ojitoAoyet. " Tt 8e ^coKparei;"

((f)r]v. " 2a)Kpdrrjs," rj 8' os. " Ovkovv Ka\ toIs aWoLS
av^pôTTOLS TTacrtv, oTrep KaXovpiev ovop.a eKaaTov, tovt6 5
icTTtv kKaa-T(jC) 6vop.a;" 6 8e, " Ovkovv ctol ye," tj
8' o?,
" ovofjia 'Epfxoyevrjs, ovb hv TravTes KaXwa-LV avdpatTroL."
KaL fX0V p(x)TU)VTOS Kal 'Kpo6vp.OVp.ivOV ilhivaL OTL TTore
Aeyei, oiJre aTro(ra(f)t ovbev tp(i)vevTaC re Trpos ê, TTpocr- 384
TTOtovp.v6s Tt avTos V avT(a biavotcr6at &>? etSo)? Trept
avTov, o et /3or;Aotro a-a(f)(as etTretv, TrotTjo-etei' av Kal e/xe
6/:>toAoyetv Kai Ae'yety aTrep avro? Ae'yet. et ovv 77?/ exety
a I a.vaKoiv<ii(TU)ij.iv T b 2 ouT(p T : owt^; tt^t fpov B b3 Vt2j'

^ oC B : om. T b 4 f<pTjv T : (<{>riv iyci B
384 a nAATX2N02
5 (TvixâKd^v TTjV KpaTvX.ov fxavrdav, TjbôiS av aKov(raifii.'
fiaWov be avT(o croi ottt) 80x61 [cxf^^] iTfpl 6vop.dTOiV

6p96Tr]Tos TL av rjbiov Trv9oip.r}v, eX (roi /SouAo/xeVo) [ecTTiV].
2X2. '12 TTal 'iTrTTovUov 'Epp,6y(V(s, TToAaia irapoip.Ca oti
b X'*^^'"'"
'"" '^ciXa (CTTiv oirr) cx^* fiaêiv koI brj koI to Trepl
TU)V 6vop.aT(av ov (rpnKpov Tvy\dv(i, 6v iid9r]p.a, el fxev ovv
eyo) 7]br] tJktjko'?; Trapa YIpobiKov Tr]V Tt(VTr]KovTdbpayjxov eTTi-
bd^LV, r]V aKOvaavTi VTrdpyii itepX tovto TrciTaiSevcrâi, cSs
6 (\>r](TLV (Kelvos, ovbev hv K(a\v(v (re avTLKa /xaAa eibevai

Tr]V aAr/êtav Ttepl ^vopidTOiv 6p96Tr]Tos' vvv be ovk aKi^Koa,
C dAAa Tr]V hpayjxLaiav. ovkovv olba it^ ttot to d\r]9S
4Xl TTfpl tS>V TOLOVTOiV (rvCr]TLV fXfirrOL T0L]x6s (l]XL KOL

(rol Kal K/aaruAo) KOLvf]. otl be ov <f>r](rL troi 'Ep^xoyevr]
ovoptxi LvaL Trj d\r]9L(i, uxrTrep vnoTTTevoi 'avTov (rKcaiTTCLV
5 oferat ydp X^rois cre \pr]]xdT(iiv (\>l(]X(vov /cn/crecos aTro-
Tuyxcivetr e/cci<rroTe. dAA', o wvbr] (Keyov, (IbivaL fxkv
TCL ToiavTa xaXfiTdv, to kolvov b\ KaTa9(VTas XPV

et j (TKOTTiLV
eiTe 0)9 crv Ae'yei? cxet (tTf cLy KparuAos.
EPM. Kai ]xr]V (y(tiy(, Si "^dKparfs, ttoAAciki? br] Kal
10 TOVTO) 6taAexêis Kal oAAots ttoAAois, ov bvva]xaL TreL^rdr^vaL

d ois aAAr/ tis 6p96Tr]s 6v6]xaTos r] crvv9r]Kr] kcu 6]xo\oyLa.
ifxol yap boKL OTL av tls Tcp ^^Tai ovo]xa, tovto eirat t6
6p96v KOL hv av9Ls ye (repov fxeTa^rJTai, Klvo ^ pj]KTi
kczAt/, ovbev rJTTOv rb v^rrepov 6p9(os Xlv tov iTpoTepov,

5 &(rTTp TOLS OLKTaLS 7]]XLS ]XTaTLd]X9a [ovbV rjTTOV TOVT
eTvaL 6p9bv rb /LteTaTeêr toO TTp^repov Ket/xe'rou]' ov ydp

(pv(rL eKczo-To) TT(f>VKvaL ovopâ ovbev ovbVL, dAAa vofxio
KOL eêi Twv cîcrdrTcoi' t Kal KokovvTOiv. el be ttt] dAAr/
e ^xfi- (TOLfxos eycoyc Kai fxav9dvLV Kal dKOVLV ov fxdvov iTapd
KpaTvKov, dAAd Kat 7ra/)' dAAou otovovv.
a6 ^x*"' O'"- T * 7 opO^rriTos'] op66rrii Schanz t<rriv om. T

\) 5 iKtiKvf T : iK(i>\v(Tfv B C 3 ou <pi)<yti B C 4 (TKOirtlv marg. T
C6 fKaKTTOTf om. T da flvai] tlvai toi T Kal tlvai Heindorf
:
<i5-6 oi/Sfv . . . Kfififvov om. T d8 idicrdvTwv] fifdi<rTavr<uv al.

;
KPATTA02 385 a
212. "lo-o)? fxevToi. tI Aeyei?, o) Êpfxoyeves' <rKe\lfutfJie6a 385

8e. o av (f)fis Ka\fj us Kaa-Tov, tovO^ kKda-T(a ovofjia;
EPM. "E/xotye goKci.

2X2. Kal eav iStwrrjs KaA.?) xal
'
eav 7ro'Ais;
EPM. 4>77/ii. 5
212. Tt ow; eav iyco KaXta otlovv t&v ovTOiV, otov
o vvv KaXovfJiV avdpoiTiov, kav kyoa tovto tTiTTOV irpoa--
ayopeva), o 8e vvv lttttov, av6po)TTOV, eaTai brjpLoa-Lq /xey
ovofxa av^poiTTos T(o avT<a, Ibiq be lttitos; Kal IbCq pikv av

dvdpo)7Tos, brjfxoa-Cq 6e 117770?; ovro) Aeyeis; 10
EPM. "EpiOLye 80/ca. b

2X2. epe brf fioi Tobe d-ni' KaXcLS ti dkrfdij XeyeLV /cai
\f/vbr]
EPM. 'Eycoye.
212. OvKovv drj dv Xoyos dkrf^-qs, 6 8e \{/vb^s; 5
EPM. Udvv ye.
212. 'Ap' ovv ovTos bs dv Ta oirra k^yrj o)s ioTLV, dXrjd-qs'

os 8' dv ws ovK ea-TLV, êvbrjs;
EPM. Nai.
2X2. "'EoTty dpa tovto, \6y<a Aeyeir tcl ovTa re Kat /ztj; 10
EPM. ndvv ye.
2X2. 'O Aoyos 8' iarlv 6 dkrjdrfs iTOTcpov fikv oAoy dXrj^^qs, C
TCL fxopLa 8' avTOv ovK dXrfOrj;
EPM. OvK, dAAa Kal Ta fxopLa.
2X2. TloTepov 8e Ta fjiev fxeydKa fxopLa d\r]6i], Ta 8e

a-fxLKpa ov' rf TTavTa; 5
EPM. ndrra, oi/xat eyoiye.
2X2. "Eo-riy ovv otl Ae'yeis Ao'you afXLKpoTepov fxopLov

oAAo r/ ovopia;
EPM. OdK, dAAd tovto afXLKpoTarov.
2X2. Kai TOVTO [ovofxa] dpa to tov dXqdovs koyov XiycTaL; 10
ast&v, <p^s, /caA.f) Hirschig : t hv ^^s Ka\eiT t : eiiv 0y Ka\(7v B : ft &i/
<f>rj KoXetv Schanz tovt' i^rrly eKd.<Tr<f) B b 2 tj] ra T C i S\os

/jifv B 09 rovTO TG : tJ> B c 10 ^yo/xa B T suprascr. G
: :om. al.
385 c nAATaNOS
EPM. Na^.
2f2. 'AArjês ye, ws /^tJs.
EPM. Nai.
20. To 8c Tou \f/vbovs fxopLov ov \l/vbos;
15 EPM. ^rjixL
SX2. "'Ecrrty apa ovoiia y}fvbos koI aXrjOks X^yeiv, iXirep
KoH \6yov;
d EPM. n&s yap ov;
212. *0 hv apa cKacTTOS <f)rj ro) ovopu tlvat,, tovto icmv
eKdoTCi) 6vop.a;
EPM. Nar.
5 2X2. 'H KoX oTToaa av <f)fj
tls eKdoTw 6v6p.aTa ilvai,
Toaavra eorai koX t6t dir^Tav (f)rj;
EPM. Ov yap ^X''^ ^y<>>y(f 2) ^w/c/jare?, 6v6pMT09 aXXr}v

6p66Tr]Ta 7] TavTrjv, ipLol fxev Tpov 2vai koX^lv eKdoTO)
6vop.a, o kyci) idcpirjv, (toI 8e Tpov, o av av. ovto) 8e Kal
e Tals TT6\a-LV opCi ibCq [eKdorais] erioi? ttI tols avrols

KLp.va 6v6p.aTa, kol "EAAt/o-i Trapa roi/s dAAou? "EXA.Tjvas,
Kat "EAArjo-t rrapd âplBapovs.
212. <J>e'pe 8r/ TSco/iev, ai 'Epjixdyeve?, iT^T^pov Kal to. ovTa
5 ovrco? ^X^'^ '^'' <t>(^CvTaL, IbCq avTdv ^ ova-Ca eimt eKdora),
Hp(iiTay6pas eAeyey Xeytoi' " irdirro)!' xpr]p.aT(t}v
(joa-np
"
386 p-irpov eirat avdpcoTTOv o)? dpa ota pikv av p,ol cfâCvrjTaL
TCL irpdyixaTa [etvat], rotarrra iikv cotlv p.oC' oXa 8' av
(ToC, TOLavTa 8e a-oC rj \lv Soxet o-ot avrd avTQtv TLva
(3J3aL6Tr]Ta ttjs ovaCas;
5 EPM. 'H^rj 'TTore ya)y, S) 2a)K/)ares, atTopG^v koX V-

TavOa ^^r]Vydr]v ets direp Tlp(DTay6pas \4ycL' ov TTavv tl
p.VTOL flOL b0KL OVrO)? X^LV.
6.5 riscp^T dg aZ Hirschig : &v BT ei raTs wS-

\f(Tiv fort. secludendum (Kiffrais seclusi : iKd<rTais ivlois om, T
63 Trapa om. B aa (Tvai om. T a^ Toiavra S( aoi T:
ToiaSf B : Toiavra 5' o5 (xoi W (cf. Theaet. 152 a) SoKci <Tot aiTo]
toKfls oi oTTa T
KPATTA02 386 a
2X2. Ti^ be; es robe rjbr) e^/jiêx^???, ojcTTe /u-t) TTdvv aoL
boKLV cTvaC TLVa avdp(i)TTov TTovripov; D

EPM. Ov ixa Tov ACa, aX\a TToXXaKLS br] avrb TreirovOa,
uxTTe fioi boK^lv TTavv TTOvrjpovs (LvaC TLvas av6p(aiTovs, Kal
IxdXa crvxvovs.
212. TiSe'; lidw xP^^^^ôIovttm <roi. iboiav eLvailavOpo)- 5
ttol];
EPM. Kal p.dXa oXCyoL.

212. "Eboâv 8' ovv;
EPM. 'Ejuotye.
212. YiS>s ovv TovTo TCdea-aL; ap' wSe* Tovs /xey Trdw 10
Xpr](TTOvs Trdwv (f)povCp.ovs, tovs be TTavv TTOvr^povs Travv
a(f)povas;
EPM. "E/ioiye boKel ovto)S. C
212. Olov re ovv [eaTLv], ei IlpooTayopas d\ri6rj eAeyei'
KOi eoTiy awTT/ ^ dA7]êta, ro oXa av Soktj eKaoro) roiaSra

Kal elvaL, tovs pkv rjixGiv (ppovCpMVS eivai, tovs bi d(f)povas;
EPM. Ov brJTa. 5
212. Kat rairra ye, wj fyîxaL, (rol Trdvv boKH, (ppovrj-

o-eo)? ov(rr]s koI dcppo^rvvrjs fiTj Trdin; bvvaTov dvaL Hpo)-
Tayopav dXr]6r] X^yeiv ovbev yap dv ttov rr/ dXr]6eC(i
erepos tov kTepov (f)povLfX(aTepos etr/, eiTrep a av kKacTTio
boKf] kKd(rT(o dX.r]dr] tcrrai. d

EPM. *'EoTt Tairra.
212. 'AAXa /x^y ou8^ Kor' ^v6vbriix6v ye ot/xat o-ot 8oKet
Trdo-i Trdyra 6}xoC(ds etyat d/ta Kai det* ovbe yap dv ovTâs
elev OL ixev xp^CTot, ot 8e iTovrjpoC, et o/jtotcoj aiTa^rL Kal det 5
dpTrj T Kal KaKCa etrj.
EPM. 'XXr]6r] Aeyets.
212. OvKoiJy et /xr^re 7rdo"t Trdi^ra eo^rty 6]xoC(i)S ap.a Kal
deC, fxr]T Kd(rT(o ibC(i KacrTOV \t5)V ovtcov eoriv], SÂoi' 8?;
b2 aiiTJ) T : ravTh B b 5 &j/9pwrroi om. T C2 iffriv om. T

04 Zyou om. G C9 & &v] 6 â*' T d.9 twv ovtwv iiTTiv om, T
PLATO, VOL. I. 12
386e nAATilNOS
e vTi avTo. avTUiV ovaCav iyovra Tiva fiiâiov ka-Ti to. TTpa-
yfiaTa, ov irpos fjpias ovb v(f>' Tip.Q>v k\K6p.iva avoi kox kolt^x)
Tw TjfxfTepu (âvTacTnaTL, akkh. KaG' avra Ttpos tijv airrQv

ovcriav e)(ôvTa rfirep TT4(f>VK(v.
5 EPM. AoK(i /uot, a 2a)/c/>ares, ovto).
2X2. YloTfpov ovv avTo. ixev av clt] ovro) TT^PvKOTa, ai hk

TTpd^fis avTOiv ov KaTO. Tov avTQV TpoTTOv; 17 ov Kol avrai
(V TL clbos tS)v ovTOiv (l(riv, ai TTpdêLs;
EPM. ndio ye Kal avTau
387 212. Kara t^j; avT&v apa ^v^tlv kol ai Trpdêis TrpaT-
TovTaL, ov KaTCL TTjv f]pL(Tpav boâv. olov edv tl ciTLxeLpT]-
(rO)p.V 7]p.LS tG)V OVTOOV TepiVLV, TTOTfpOV f]]XLV Tp.J]TOV
[eoTty] (KacTTov ti>s av f]]xeLS ôvk(i>p.t6a Ka\ w av fiovKr]d(opL(V,
5 7] eav ixV KaTo. tt]v (j>v(rLV ôv\r]6G>p.v (Ka(TTov Te]xv(LV tov

Tepiveiv T Kal TpLV(r6aL kol w TreÛKe, re/xoC/LieV re Kal
TTXioV TL f]]xlv i(TTaL K(XL OpdQs TTpd^0pLV TOVTO, idv 8e TTapo
(^vcTLV, âp.apTr](r6pi6d re kol ovbiv TTpdôfxfv;
b EPM. "Ejuotye 8oKet ovto).

2X2. OvKovv Kal iav Kdetv rt TTiXfi-PWOip.fv, ov /cara
TTacrav bdâv 8et Kdeii;, dA.Aa Kord rqv dp6r]v; avrr] 8' eo-rij;
T] TT(t)VK(L Ka(TTOV Kd(T6aL T Kal Kd^tV Kttt ^ TT(f>VKL;
5 EPM. 'EoTt ravTa.

2X2. OvKovv Kal roAAa ovT(a;
EPM. Udvv ye.
212. 'Ap' ovv ov Kal to Ae^yeti pCa tls t&v iTpdêcov
(TTLV;
10 EPM. Nai'.
2X2. ndrepoy ovv 17 dv rw boKf\ \ktOV etrat, TavTj]
C \yo)v 6p6(j)s Ae'et, r] idv pkv rj TT(pVK rd iTpdy]xaTa \yLV

T KoX \y(rdaL koi (5, TavTjj Kal TovT<a Ae'yT/, iTîov re' ri
ea riitS,i] vfias ivra d 63 oAAcl] ak\it. KoX T 64 fivwfp pr. B

(ut videtur) 65 ouru] oCtois fx"*' ^ b6 tiv fXri] atl ^ T sed
ccrr. in marg. 7, 9 alnai (bis) Heindorf: ahraX BT a^ tVrli/
om. T rHv
: ovrcov G b4 i-Kt<pvKu (.bis) BT : xt^puKfv (.bis) Hermann
KPATTAOS 387C
TTOLrja-ci Kol (pel' av be iir], âfj.apTri<rTaC re Kal ovbev

TiOLrjcrei;
EPM. Ovrco p.01 hoK^Z 0)? A.eye6?. 5

21i. OvKovv rov Xiyeiv p.6piov to ovoixadeiv bLOVopid-
(ovres ydp ttov kiyovcTL tovs koyovs.
EPM. Udvv yf.
212. OvKOVV KoX TO 6vopA^LV Hpaîs [tLs\ eCTTLV, lTTep
Kal To \4yeLV Trpa^LS tls ^v TT^pl tcl iTpdyp.aTa; 10
EPM. Nai.
212. Al b\ TTpdêLS icfydvrjcrav rjpilv ov TTpbi ^/u,ay ov(raL, d
dAX' avT&v TLva IbCav (pvcTLV eyovcraL;
EPM. "Eo-ri TavTa.

2X2. OvKOvv Kal ovofxacTTeov [(cttIv] rj iTecfiVKe to, irpd-
yfxaTa 6vo[j.dêLV re Kal 6vopLd^(rdaL Kal w, dAA' otix ') av 5
ripLels l3ovXr}6(ap.ev, (LiTep tl tols epLTrpocrdev /xe'AAei opLoXoyov-
p.vov (IvaL; Kal ovTOi pikv av TrXiov tl TTOLoZp.f.v koll 6vop.d-

CoLpifV, aAAcos 8e ov;
EPM. îâiVerat p.01.
2X2. <J>ejoe 87/, 6 e8et Tip.VLV, tbeL rw, cf)afi4v, TepLveLv; 10

EPM. Nai.
2f2. Kai o e8ei KepKLêLV, e8et rw KepKLêLv; koX ebeL e
Tpvndv, ebeL t(o TpviTav;
EPM. Udvv ye.
2i2. Kat 6 e8et 8^ 6vopLdCeLV, e8et ro) wojadêty;
EPM. "Eo-rt raOra. 388
2X2. Ti 8e rjv e/cetyo o) eSei Tpvndv;
EPM. TpvTTavov.
2X2. T( 8e w KepKCêLv;
EPM. Kep/ct'?. 5
2X2. Tt 8e <S djô/ixdêty;
EPM. "Oyojila.
C 6 Kol Siofo/xaôrrtj T : ovofid(ovTfs B C9 rfj om. B d4 4(TtIv

om. T d5 ovofxa^ftv re /coi om. B d 10 & ora. B
12*
;
388 a T1AATX1N02
211. Ev X.eyLS. opyavov apa tC ((ttl /cat to ovopLa.
EPM. Udvv ye.
lo 2jiL. Lt ow eyoi epoLfxr^v 1 (. 7)v opyavov t) KcpKLs;
ov;( w KfpKLôfjicv;
EPM. Nai.
Ij 2X2. KepKiCovTes be tl bpiopiev; ov ttjv KpoKrjv koI tovs
OTqpLovas (rvyK)(yp.vovs bLaKpCvop-ev
EPM. Nar.
212. OvKovv Kal irepX TpvTrdvov êts ovro)? etTrety fcai
5 Trept rcSv oKXoiv;

EPM. naw ye.
2X2. "Exets 8^ koI Trepi 6v6p.aTos ovTois Ittlv; dpydv<^

ovTL TO) ovoixaTL 6vop.dôvTes TL TioLovp.ev;
EPM. OvK X(o keyeLV.
lo 2X2. 'Ap' ov hLhd(TKop.ev tl akXi]Xovs koX to. iTpdyp.aTa
bLaKpCvofxev fj
e^^L;
EPM. lidw ye.
2X2. "OvofjLa apa hLhacTKaXLKov tC ea-TLV opyavov /cal
C hLaKpLTLKov Trjs oixrCas axnrep KepKLS v(^d(Tp.aTos.

EPM. Nat.
2X2. *T(f)avTLK6v he ye 17 Kep^Cs;
EPM. ncS? 8' ou/
5 2X2. 'T(f)avTLKbs pi.ev apa KepKChL koX&s xPW^t^''' fo^ws

8' eoTii/ v(f)avTLK(as' 8t8a(rKaA.tKos 8e 6v6p.aTL, KaXws 8' eorl
8t8ao-KaAiK(S9.
EPM. Nat.
2X2. Tu tCvos ovv py(^ 6 v(f)din~r}s KoXuts XPW^^'- otov
10 Trj KepKChL xp^rat;
EPM. Tw roC TeKTovos.
2X2. rias 8e TeKTcov rj 6 Tr]V Texyrjv ^x^^
EPM. *0 rqv Texvr]V.
b4 ToC ante Tpvirdvov add. b8 G iroior/uci' B b 10 ou Stepha-

nus : B T sed y punctis notatum in B
oiv 05 xp^hcfcat] K(x(yfi(rfTou T
C6 dy6/xaTi ^koAws), koAws al.
KPATTA02 388 d
212. To) Tivos Se epyw 6 TpvTrriTr}? ko^.ws xprjcreTai oTav d

ro) TpVTTavia xp^ratj
EPM. T<3 roC xoAKecos.
211. *Ap' ow Tras x^'^^'^^ V ^ "^V^ Tiyvr]v e-ôov;
EPM. 'O rqv Txvr]v. 5
212. Elfv. ro) 8e rtws epyw 6 8tSacr/caA.iKos XP^*'"^^'^^
oraj; Tca ovopaTL xprJTai.;
EPAI. Ovb TotT extt).
212. Ovbe TovTo y exeis fxzCiV, tCs TTapabCboio-LV t)puv

Ta ovopaTa ols \pu)p.da; lo
EPM. Ov bfJTa.
212. 'Ap' ov)(l 6 vopos boKiX ctol [eoâij 6 irapabLbovs

avTo.;
EPM. 'EoiKei;.
212. NojuoêVou apa epyo) xpô-f^-ai o SiSao-KaXiKos oray e

ovopaTL xprJTaL;
EPM. AoKet poL.
212. Noju,oê'r?js 8e' o-oi 8oKet Tras etrat di^^p ^ 6 r);v
Tixvrjv excoi;; 5
EPM. 'O r?;i; T^xvrjv,
212. OvK apa TravTos dvSpos', ai *Ep/uioyeyes, ovopa diaOaL
ovopaTovpyov' ovtos 8' Ig-tCv,
[eoTii'] dA.A.d rtiôs qhs OikV, 389
6 vopx)deTr]s, os brj tS)V brjpiovpy^v cnTavLiaTaTos Iv avdp(o-
7T0LS yCyveTaL.
EPM. "EotKey.
211. "IOl bi'], e7rtcrKei//at "Trot jSX^Ttoov 6 vopo6iTr]s to. 5
ovopaTa TCOeTaL' (k tS>v ipTrpocrdev 8e avda-K\}/aL. ttol
^k^TTOiv 6 T(KT(t)V Ti]v KepKt8a TTotet; ap' ov Trpbs tolovtov

TL o eTre^vKet KepKC^dv;
EPM. ndvv ye.
d. I Stoj' xpvfcit om. T

. . . d 5 ^ riiv rix^Vv om. B d 8 oiiS*]
ov Heindorf dp tovto 7'] toOt' T d 12 6 vo/xosl oi^dôTor T :
d vo/jLoOeTTis Schanz dvat om. T a i (iTriv om. T a 2 eV
om. T a 8 TrpvK(i B Tre^v/ce al. Stallbaum :
;
389b nAATX2N02
b 2X2. T^ bi; hv KaTayfj avTta rj Kep/cis iroiovvri, Trorepov
n6J\.w TTOiT/crei &XXr]v Trpbs t^v KaTeayvTav /3Ac7ra>r, tj irpbi

iKclvo To ci8oy Trphs oiTfp Kal rjv KaTeaêv k-noUi;
EPM. ITpos (Kfivo, ifxoi.y( boKeX.
5 212. OvKovv (Kilvo fiiKatoVar' hv avTo b loriy KfpKts

KoXioâiniv
EPM. "E/xoiyc SoKei.
2X2.OvKow kTTiihav hir\ XeTTTfa) i/xari<i) ?/ 7ra)(f t t/ Xiroi
rj ^pew ^ oTTotwovy Tiri KfpKiba iToi.elv, iTda-as p(v bei t6

lo TT/s KepKtSos Ix^'^ ciSo?, ota 8' CKOOTa) KaAAto-Trj iir<f)VK(i,
C Tavrrjv d7ro8i8oVat t^v (f)va-i,v ds t6 tpyov (Kaa-rov;

EPM. Nat'.
2X2. Kai TTfpl T&v aXXoov br] dpydvcov 6 airr^s Tpoiros'

To (f>vaiL kKda-T(a 7re<^vKoy opyavov iêvpovTa bel aTTobovvai
5 ets eKetyo e^ ov hv ttoi^ [t6 ipyov], ov^ olov av avT6s
jSovKrjdi], dAA' oroy TT(f)VK(i. t6 (j)va-L yap iKaoTfc), s ioiK,
TpvTTOvov TT(f)VK6s eis t6v (ribr]pov Sci iTTLaraxrdai TiOivai.
EPM. Udw ye.
2X2. Kai T7jr <f)va-i KcpKCba kKdarca TT(f)VKVLav fls $vkov.

lo EPM. 'EoTTt ToCTa.
d 2X2. ^vo-ei yap ^v kKd(rT(o clbcL v(f)da-ixaT0S, <as IolkV,
kKda-Tr) KpKLS, Kal rSAXa ovto}S,
EPM. Nai'.
2X2. 'Ap' ovv, u) /3e'Art<rre, Kat t6 Ik<zoto) (f)va-i 7re</>VKoy
5 ovop.a t6v vop.odTr\v ^Kflvov eZs tovs (f)66yyovs Kal ras

truAAa/3aj 6et eTTLaraa-daL TLdivaL, koX jSXfiTovTa iTpos ainro
KLVO 6 (CTTLV OVOp.a, TTdvTa TO. 6v6p.aTa TTOLflv T KaX
TLdeadaL, d /ie'AAei KvpLOS ctmi 6voixdT(i)V dirr^s; eZ 8^ fx)
eZs Tas avTas avXKaâs tKOCTTos 6 vopLodfTr^s TiOriaLV, ovb(V

e 8et TovTo d(îx(f)LyyvoLV ovbf yap etj t6v avT6v aLbr^pov
b I ^ om. pr. T b 5-7 oiKovv . So(ft om. . . B b 9 8*] 8^ T

b 10 nf<pvKf Stallbaum 04 rh om. G 05 ri fpyov om. T
C6 TrifpvKs Stallbaum C 7 8* ?! 6J) T d7 iyoixa] oviiiora B
e I a,n<piyvouv Pcipers : iryvouv BT oySi] ov T uxrrhv om. T
KPATYAOS 3896
aTTas xaXKevi Ti6r\(nv, rov avTov fvcKa TroiSiv to avTo

opyavov dAA.' o/xcos, lcos ^v ti]v avT7]v Ibeav aTToStdw, edvTe
V aAAo) o-Lh]pu), opuos 6p6(as Ixei t6 opyavov, kdvTi kvOdhe 39
kdvT V j3apl3dpots tls iTOLfj. ^ yop>
EPM. Udw ye.
2i2. OvKOvv ovT(os d^LdxTfis Ka\ Tov voixoOiTrjv TOV T
v9db Kal Tov kv rois jSapjSdpoLS, lcos hv to tov ovoiJLaTos 5
etSos aTTobLbS) to Trpoa-rJKov e/cdoT(j) v oTTOtaLaovv crv^kafials,

ovbcv X^^P^ vop.o6eTr]v elvai tov kv6dbe 77 tov ottovovv dAAoî;
EPM. Udvv ye.
212. Tts ovv 6 yvcocrofxevos et t6 TTpo(rriKov etbos KepKtbos b
iv 6iTOL(ôvv $v\(o KiTaL; 6 TTOLricras, 6 TtKTOiV, 7/ 6 xpr]-
(TopLevos [6] v(f)dvTr]s;
EPM. EtKo? fj.V fj.dWov, S) 2coKpare9, t6v xfilô\xvov.

2X2. Tts ovv 6 rw tov XvpotTOLov py(o xpTl^^diJievos ; ap 5
ovx ovTos os (TT((TTaLTO CLV kpyaô]xiv(a KdKkLo-Ta iiTLa-TaTilv
Kal dpya(rix4vov yvoii] cir' (v (tpya^TTai eire /X7j;
EPxM. Udvv ye.

2X2. Tts;
EPM. 'O KL6apL(rTr]S. 10
2X2. Tts 8e 6 roi roS yauTT^jyoC;

EPM. Kv^pvr]Tr]s. C
2X2. Tt? 8e rtS roS voixodeTov epyo) cTTL^rTarqcreLe r dr
KaAAtcrra Kai eipyacrpevov KpiveLC Kal v6db Kal V tols
jiap^dpoLS ; ap' ovx ocnTp xp^cerat;
EPM. Nat. 5
2X2. 'Ap' ovv ovx 6 ipooTav TTicrTdyiVos ovtos kcTTLv;
EPM. Udw ye.
2X2. *0 8e avTos Kal aTTOKpivicrOai;

EPM. Nai.
6 3 hv om. B âvTf . . . ar o.aojj secl. Schanz a r ^y

(jrip avrif iavTf iv') &\Kif Ast a
5 toIs om. G b3 i om. B
vcîj/TT/y secl. Naber b6 iviaraiTo &v (pya(o/x(v<f> T W: (iria-raTai
T^ avepyaô/xfytf) B
390 c rrAATilNOS
10 212. Tov b^ IpuiTav koX d.TTOKpivea-Oai ^Triora/xerov aXXo
Ti av KoXfls 7] biaXeKTiKov;
EPM. OvK, aWa TovTo.
d 212. TfKTOvos p.\v apa epyov ôrty Troifja-ai TrrjbaXLov (in-
aTaTovirros KvfiepvriTov, fl /xÂAei Ka\bv flvak to 7r7j8<iAtov.
EPM. aiWrai.
2X2. No/xoêVou 8e ye, u)S lot/cey, ovofia, (TnardTriv i^xoV'

5 Tos hiaX(KTLKov &vbpa, ei /xÂAei KaAois' 6v6p.aTa d-qaea-Oai.
EPM. "EoTTt TavTa.
2X2. Ktvbvv(VL apa, a> 'Ep/xoyere?, Trat ov (âCAoi', s
a~v oUi, ^ ToC dvo/i.aTos dia-Ls, ovbi (f)av\(i>v avbpStv ovd^
rGiV iiTLTVXîrroiV. Kal KpaTv\os aXrjdi] Acyet \(yu}V (f)vafi
e Ta ovofxaTa eti/at rots TTpa.yp.aaL, kol ov TtavTa brip.uyvpyov

6vopL(iToov eTvaL, a\\a jxovov iKdvov tov 6.T:oft\(TiovTa els t6
Tjj (j)vaL ovofjLa ov eKa(rT(a Kal bvvaixfvov avTov to elbos
TLdevaL ets re to. ypap.p.aTa Kal tcls avWafias.
5 EPM. OvK w 2wK/)aTes, ottcos xPV T^pbs & Ae'yets
exft),
391 ivavTLOvadaL. lo-tos pevTOL ov pabLov fariv ovtcos kâL(^vr]s
TTeLaOrjvaL, a\\a boK& p.0L <S8e hv pJaWov iTLOladaL (tol, et
/xot Se^êtas rjvTLva (f)j]s etyat ttjv (f)vaL opOoTrjTa 6v6p.aTos.
2X2. 'Eyo) p.(v, d) p.aKapLi 'EppoyfVfs, ovbep.Lav Ae'ya),
5 Â' ^TreAaôu ye wy oAiyoy TTpoTcpov eAeyor, ort ovk

(IbeCriv aWa aKÔLp.r]V peTO. aov. vvv be aKOTTOvp.ivoLS
T)p.LV, (p.oC re Kat o-ot, ToaovTOV p.ev ijbr] (f)aCv(TaL TTapa to.
TTpOTfpa, (f)va(L T( TLva ^pdorqTa exoy eiyai to ovopa kcll ov

b iravTbs avbpbs (iTCa^TaadaL [koAojs] amb iTpayp.aTi OTiôvv
6(adaL' rj ov;
EPM. Uaw ye.
2X2. OvKovv To p.(Ta tovto xprj ^rjreti', eiTre/) (iTLOvpids
5 (IbivaL, rJTLS ttot av iaTLV avTOV f] 6p66Tr]s.
e 3 rb] r6 re T a2 oAAck . . . iriOtaBai T (i : om. B Schanz

iriOfffOai ffoi scripsi auctore Schanz : riOfffOai fff pr. T : irfidfffdai fft pr,
G : irfiffOrivai ffot Cobet a3 /uo(] fx^ Schanz a 5 yr Siv dKiyoi^
B : o\iyov yap T b I koAwj om. T b5 a2 B if T
:
KPATTA02 39ib
EPM. 'AAXa fxriv eTriû/xw ye etSeVat.

211. SKoVei Toivvv.
EPM. riws oS:^ XP^ (TKOTTelv;
211. ÔpdoTarq jjLev Trjs o-Ke'\//êa)?, kTOipe, fJLTa tQv

eTTicrTaiJ.4vu)V, yj)rip.aTa eKeivoLS TeXovvTa Kal x.aptTas KaTa- lo
Ti.d4iJ.evov. eicrl 8e ovroi ot aocpta-TaL, olcnrep koX 6 abeXcjios

(Tov KaAAtas TroAAa reAeVas -)(pi^[j.aTa a-o(f)bs SoKet etzât. c
eTret^T) 8e ovk iyKpaTTjs et tu)V Trarpwcoy, AtTrapetr XP^/ ''"^'^
ab(X(f)6v Kal bel(r6aL airrov btbdât o-e rTJi' opOoTTjTa Trepi

r<Sy TOLOVTOiv rjv epLadev iTapa YIpdiTayopov.
EPM. "AroTTos fj.evTav etrj piov, u) "Ed^KpaTes, r] berjcrLS, 5

ci TTjv [xkv 'AAj/êtay ttjv ITpcorayopoD oAws oti/c d7ro8e'xo/jtai,
ra 8^ rrj TOLavTr] akr]dL(i prfOivTa ayaTT(oriv ws tov a^La.
2X2. 'AAA' et p.r} av o-e Tavra apicTKeL, Trap' 'Op.r}pov xpi]
jxavdaveLV koI iTapa tG)V akX(t)v TTOLr]T(av. d

EPM. Kat rt kiyeL, u) Saj/cpares, "O/i.Tjpos Trept dvopLaToov,
Kal TTOv;
2X2. rioAAaxov* fxiyLCTTa 8e /cai KoAAto-ra kv oXs bLopCCeL
iirl Tols avTols a re ot avOpooTTOL ovofxaTa Kakov(rL Kal ot 5
êot. T] ovK otet avTov fxeya tl Kal 6av]xda-Lov keyeLV iv

TovTOLS Trept dvopLaTdLtv dpôrriTos; brjkov yap br] otl ot ye
êot avTCL KoXova-LV irpos 6p66Tr]Ta diTep ecTTL (pvcreL 6v6]xaTa'

r] a-v ovK oll; C
EPM. Ei! otSa fxev ovv eycoye, etTrep KoAoCo-tr, ort 6p6u)s
Kakova-LV. dkkd iTola TavTa Ae'yets;
SX2. OvK oLcr6a OTL Trepi tov 7TOTa]xov tov ev rrj Tpota,
os efxovofxd\eL rw 'HtâtVra), *' ov p,dvdov," (f)r]crL,
" KaAe'ouo-t 5
;"
0eot, dvbpes be ^Kdfxavbpov
EPxM. "Eywye.
212. Tt ovv bi]; ovk otet rotTO aefxvdv tl eTvaL yvwvai, 39*
OTTTj Trore 6p65)S e\eL eKelvov tov iTOTap.ov s,dv6ov KaXelv
c 5 Stoitos] fort, &TOTrov (om. mox fj dfrjffis cum al.) e^Tj] ftriv al.
Cobet (om. mox yuou ,..}) StTjffis)
;
392a ITAATIINOS
fmWov rj 'S.K&iiavhpov; (.1 6^ ôvkfi, TTfpl Ttji opvidos rjv
\4yei OTL
5 x.aXKCba KiKXri(TKovcn. deoC, 6.vbpS 8e KVfiivbiv,
<f)av\ov rjyfj to fjiddrjixa o(r<a opOoTepov la-Tt KoXela-dai xoXkIs

KvpiCvbtbos T(o avT<a dpv(<a; rj ttjv BaTCadv re Kal MvpCvrjv,
b Kol aXXa TToXXa Kal tovtov tov TroirjroD Kal aWuiv; aXka
TavTa pev ta-oiis /ixe^ôi) fortr 17 Kar ip,i koI ae i^fvpdv
6 8e ^Kapdvbpios re Kal 6 Âa-Tvdva^ dvdpoiTnvdiTepov 8ia-
a-K4\j/aadai, ws fpol boKi, Kal paov, d (^r]aiv ovopaTa dvai
5 TO) Tov "EKTopos vfZ, tCv^ ttotc Aeyei ttjv opdoTtjTa avTOiv.
olaOa ydp Sjjttou raura Ta cttt/ Iv ots (veaTiv h eyo)
Ae'ya).
EPM. ndw ye.

2X2. TloTepov ovv oiet "Opr^pov opOoTfpov rjydaOai, T(av
10 6vopdT(jiiV KCLaOai. rw TraiSt, tov " 'AarudvaKTa " fj tov
" ^Kapdvbptov"
C EPM. OvK exo) kiyeiv.
2Ii. *X28e br] aKOTrei. tl rt? ipoiTo ae iroTfpov oiet
opOoTepov KoAety tcl ovopaTa tovs (f>povLpLOJTepovs r] tovs

d(f>povaTpovs;
5 EPM. ArjXov br] ori tovs (f)povLpi(t)T4povs, (paCrfv &v.

212. YloTepov ovv ai yvvalKes iv rats TroAecrtv (f>povi-
/uwrepat o-ot 8oKo5o-ir eiiâi rj 01 dvbpes, o)? to oKov (lttclv

yivos;
EPM. 01 dvbpes.
10 212.OvKow oio-â ort "OjLtJjpos ro TratStoj; ro rou "E/cropos
d VTTo TQiV Tpdoiv (firjalv KaXeladaL 'AoTudvaxra, 2Ka/xdv8ptor

8e SÂoi' ort vtto tS>v yvvaLKutv, eTreiS?; ol ye dvbpes avTov
'AaTvdvaKTa (KdXovv;
EPM. 'EoiK^ ye.
b2 ^^^3 ^M* T B b3 <rK<inavSp6i BT b4 ^ôy] piSiov T

d. a "yc]T B T d. 3 iKiKovvl iKaXovft.r^v B
;
KPATTAOS 392 d
20,. OvKovv Koi "Oju.Tjpoj Tovi Tp&as o-o^corepous i^yetro 5
Tj Tas yvvaLKas avTUiv;

EPM. Ol\iai lyojye.
212. Tov " A(TTvdvaKTa" apa opdoTepov wero KdaOat

^ r<S
Traibl f] Tov " ^Kap.dvbpLov"

EPM. <t>aivTai. 10
212. 2K077aj/xei; 87) 8ia rt Trore. ^ avros jyjuiy fcaAAio-ra
v(f)r}YlTai. To 8iort; (prjcrlv ydp

otos ydp (T<pLV ipvTO tt6\iv Kal reixêa pLaKpa. e
8ia raCra 87/, ws ioLKev, opOSiS exet Kak^LV tov tov acoTyjpos
vov \(TTvdvaKTa tovtov

^
eo-wêr 6 iTarrjp aiiTov, (os 0tjo-ii;
"O/xrjpos.
EPM. JJaiyerai juot. 5
212. Ti 8rj TTore; ov ydp ttco ov8' avTos iycnye ixavddvoii'
S) ÊppLoyeves, (tv 8e p.avddveLs;

EPM. Ma At" ovK 4y(oy.
2X2. 'AAA.' apa, oiyadi, Kal rw "EKropt avTos idcTO to 393
^vofxa "O/iTjpos;
EPM. Tt877;
212. "Ort fiot 8oKet /cat roiSro TrapaTrAr/crtoV rt etyat T(a
ÂoTvdvaKTL, Kal eoLKev 'EAATjyiKots raOra [tcl 6v6fj.aTa]. 5

6 yap " dva^" Kal 6 " KT(op" o-xe8oV rt tovtov o-rnxaLveL,
/3ao-tAtKa diJi^poTepa etmt ra 6v6p.aTa' ov ydp dv tls "dva^"

1], Kal " exrcop " 87/7701 eo-rti; tovtov bfjXov ydp ort KpaTel
re avrou Kai KCKTriTaL Kal eêt ai^ro. 7/ ovSeV o-ot 8oKa) b
Ae'yety, oAAa kav6dv(a Kal kp.avTov ol6p.ev6s tlvos &(nTp
Lxvovs ((fidTTTCcrdaL n/y '0/x7/pou 80'^7/s Trept ()i;o/x(zrcoy
opd^rqTOs;
EPM. Ma At" ov (tv ye, s e/*oi SoKeis, dAAa icrcos tov 5
ec^cxTrrr/.
d5 Ko2] o5 Kal G 6 6-8x1... (yt>ryf post d lo <pa'ivtTai transp.

Hermann e 7 (ri/ Se] ovSe B a 5 ri ovJjuaTa seclusi dvo/iaTa T :
a 7 $a(Ti\iKh. . . . ove^/ioTo secl. Stallbaum

)
393b riAATllNOS
2)12. AUaiov yi roi ivTiv, ws l\uoi <f)aCvTai, tov kfoirros
(Kyovov \4ovTa KaKelv Kal tov iTT-nov ^Kyovov iTnrov. ov n
Xeyu) cav ui<ntep Tepa9 yivr]Tai k^ Xiniov a\ko tl t) iTTTroy,
C oAA' ov hv fi
Tov yevovs eKyovov rrfv <f>v(ri.v, tovto keyu)'
iav /3ooj iKyovov (f)v<Tei lttttos irapa (f)V(Ti.v TfKj] fxoaryov, ov
TToiXov KXrjTeov oXKa y.6(rôv' ovV av e^ avdpdiTOv oTjxai
[xri To av0p(aTTOV (Kyovov yevrjTai, [dAA' 6 av] t6 (Kyovov

5 avdpcoTTos /cArjreos* Kal to, bdvbpa o-atJrtoy Kot raXAa ^Trarra'
r] ov (TvvboKet;
EPM. ^VVb0Kl.
211. KaAo)? Aeyeis* (f^vkaTTf ydp fxe p.r\ TTr\ TrapaKpov^ruip.aC
(T, KaTo, yap tov ovtov Xoyov kclv k fiaaLXecos yCyvrjTaC tl
d (Kyovov, âaLXei/s KXrjreos' d be iv repais (n;AAa/3ats rf ev

krepaLS t6 avT6 crrjpLaCveL, ovbev iTpayp.a' ovb" ei TTpocTKeLTaC
TL ypdp.fj.a 77 a(^rfpr]TaL, ovbev ovbe tovto, eu)s hv eyKpaTTfS rj fj
ovaCa Tov TTpdypLaTos br]Xovp.evr] ev r^ ovoixaTi.
5 EPM. Tlu)S TovTo XeyeLs;

212. Ovbev ttolkCXov, oAA' &(ntfp t5)V (rTOL\eC(i)v ol^rOa
OTL dvofxaTa Xiyop.ev dAA' ovk avrd rd o-roixcia, TrXrjv
TeTTdp(t)v, Tov E Kal tov T Kal tov O kol tov 12* rois 8'
e dAAot? (f)(t)vr]e(rC re kol a(f)(avoLS ola-da otl iTepLTLdevTes aXXa
ypdfxfxaTa Xeyofxev, ovofxaTa TTOLovvTes' dAA' ccos av avTOv
br]Xovfxevr]v Tr]v bvvafXLV evTLd&fxev, opOds eyeL eKelvo to
ovofxa KoXeLV 6 avrd rffXLV Sj/Awo-ci. oXov t6" jBrJTa"' opds
5 drt Tov T^ra Kat tov Tav Kal tov aX(f)a TTpoa-Te6evT(v ovbev
eXvTTr]aev, coo^re /u,^ ovyjL ri]v eKeCvov tov aTOL)(eCov (f)vaLV
brjX&aaL oAo) roi ovofxaTi ov ^/SovAcro 6 vofxoOeTrfS' ovtu)S
TfiTLaTr^dr] K(iXG)s OeaOaL tols ypdfxfxaai tcl ovofxaTa.
EPM. 'AAtj^j^ fxoL boKels XeyeLv.
394 îl. OvKOVv Kal TTepl j3aaLXe(DS 6 avrdy Adyos; lorat
c I iA\'oZtivBT dAA* ttv al. : c a fi6(rxoy secl. Ast

i> c 4 dA\'
6 iav B: iAAo tav T: secl. Peipers (cf. C C5 raAAo TW: i
iroWa. B &iravra BT : vdvTa W d3 ^ T : ovS' B : ouS' tl al.

fi I irfpiTiOfVTfs] Kpoaridivrts Naber e4 koAc?*' tt T : Kaxflvo B
KPATTA02 394 a
ydp TTore k âcriXioiS âcnXevs, Kal e^ aya6ov ayados, Kal

CK KoXov KoXos, Kal TakXa TtdvTa ovtcos, e kKd(TTov y4vovs
^Tepov TOLOVTOV Kyovov, kav p.i] repas yLyvrjTat' KA.rjreoy 8?;
TavTCL dvofJLaTa. TroiKiA.Aeiy 8e eêo-rt rais (rvkkaâls, uxttc 5
boâL av TU) ibLcoTLKws iôvTL Tpa elvaL dXXi]X(t)V tcl avTo.
ovTa' uxTTTep Tjiuv TOL tS)V laTpSiV (pdppLttKa xpcajxaaLV KaL
o^ryLaXs i:T:oLKLkp.iva aXka (f>aCv(Tai tcl avTa ovTa, rw 8e' ye

laTpGi, cLTe ri]V bvvap.LV twv âpp.dK(i)V a-KOTrovp.ev(a, tcl avTO, b
âiviTaL, KOL ovK iKirXriTTiTaL vtto tG>v irpocrovTUiV. ovra)
8e to-o)? Ka\ 6 eTTio-ra/ixeiôs irepl ovopATUiv Ti]V bvvajxiv avTiav
o-KOTrei, KaL ovk eK7rA7;rrerat ei tl irpocrKeLTaL ypa]x]ia tj
p.eTdKeLTaL 17 d(pj]pr]TaL, tj Kal kv dkkoLS navTdTiaa-LV ypdp.- 5

p.acrLV kcTTLV 7] Tov ovopiaTOS bvvafXLS. &(nrp o wvbr]
ik4yop.V, "ÂoTvdva^" re Kal ""E/crajp " ovbev tS)V avT(av
ypa]x]xdT(i)V exet ttXtji' tov Tav, dkk^ ofxcos tovtov crrj]xaLVL. C
Kat " ÂpxeTTokCs " ye rwy fxev ypap.]xdT(idV tl eTrt/cotycoyet;
8r;A.or 8e ojuoos to avTO' /cat aAAa TroAAa iaTLV cl ovbev akk

fj âa-Lkia a-r]p.aLveL' Kal dkXa ye av crTpaTrjyov, olov '"Ayts"
icat "Ylokdpiapxos " koi "Evirokefxos ". Kal tarptKa ye iTcpa, 5
"'IarpoKA7/s" Kat "'AKeo-t/Li/3poros"* Kat eTepa av ta-ois crvxva

evpot/xer rats /xev a-vkXajBals Kal roty ypdp.p.aa-L bLacfidivovvra,
TJ} 8e bvvdfxeL Tavrbv (fideyyofxeva. (jiaLveTaL ourcos r] ov;
EPM. Udw p.v ovv. d

2f2. Tois /xey 8^ Kara ^vcty yLyvofxivoLs tcl avTO.
drroboTeov 6v6p.aTa.
EPM. nciw ye.
212. Tt 8e rots Trapa (pvaLV, o\ av iv repaTOS et8et 5
yertoz/rat; otoi' oTav e^ dvbpbs dyaOov Kal deoaejBovs

do"e/3^s yivr]TaL, dp ov\ cocrTrep ey rots e/zTrpoo-êr, Kay
?7r7ro? /3oos eKyovov TKr], ov tov tk6vtos bijirov e8et r?/i'
(TTdiWfxiav Ixe"', oAAa tov yivovs ov etiy;
EPM. Udvv ye. 10
a 7 Kol T : ^ B b2 irpoffiSvrwv B c2 Koij^wcer G

"
394 6 riAATIiNOS
e 211. Kal To) iK Tov (V(T(fiovs &pa yVOfjUv(a aa-ffid to
Tov yevovs ovofxa airohoTiov,
EPM. "Ea-Ti TavTa.
2X2. Ou " @6(f)iXov," 0)9 (oiKV, ovhe " Minjo-iêor
5 ovbe TUiV TOLovT(i)v ovb4v' oAA' ori TavavTia tovtois (rrjfiaCvei,
edvTiep TTJs opdoTTfTOS Tvyxavi] to. ovoixaTa.

EPM. YlavTos ye fJLaWov, a 2(0Kpare9.
2i2. "Q.^nrep ye Kal 6 " 'Opco-TTjj," u) 'EppLoyeves, kiv-
bvveveL dpdS>s (X^''^> ^'^^ '"'^ ''^X^ eOfTo avTia to ovofxa eire
lo Kal TTOirfTrjs Tis, to 6r]pi(abs Trjs ^vo-ecos /cal t6 &.ypu)V avrov
Kal t6 dpiv6v ivb(LKiwfj.(vos ro) droyiari.
395 EPM. aiVerai ovtcos, S> 2wKpares.

212. "'EoiKei' bi ye Kai rw rrar/ai avrou KaTo. <f>v(riv to
ovofia ilvaL.
EPM. 4>aiWai.
5 212. KtvSwevet yap tolovtos tls cimt 6 "ÂyafXffxvoov,"
oXos h b6^Lv avro) StaTroveio-âi Kat KapTepelv t\os emri-
êis rots b6â(TL bC dpTrfv. (rrffxelov 8e avrov ^ ^j^ TpoLa
fxovrj Tov irdOovs re Kai KaprepCas. otl ovv dya(TT6s Kora
b Trfv TTLfxovrfv ovTos 6 dvrfp iv(rrffxa[vL t6 ovofxa 6 '"Aya-
fxfxv(i)v. L(rois 06 Kai Arpevs opoâs Xl. o re
yap ro{! XpvarLTnrov avrai (f>6vos Kal b, Trpos t6v veorrjy
&)S a);Lta SteTrparrero, Trdzn-a raCra ^rj/utwSrj Kat dTrjpa Tip^s
5 dperjjv. ^ ovj/ roC dvo'ju.aroy eTToiWfxCa (TfXLKp6v TrapaKXivd

Kal 7rLKKd\vTrTaL, &a-T fXTf irdaL brfXovv ti]v (f)vaLV tov
dvbpds' TOLS 8' eTraiovo-i irepi dro/xdrcor iKai^ws StjXoi o
)3ouAerai d '"Arpevs." Kal yap Kara ro Areip^s Kal
C KaTO. t6 &Tp(TTOV KOL KaTCL t6 dTrfp6v TTavTaxff 6p6S>s
avria t6 ovofxa Ketrat. 8oKet 8e' fxoL koll rw rieAoTri
t6 ovofxa ipip.Tp(i)s KeladaL' a-rffxaCvL yap tovto to
6 9 'vxp B a6 4 Hermann : &i/ BT iiriPth T a8 irofloui

scripsi : irK-fiOovs BT Koprfpla al. b^ dT7j/)i] ixfipck B
b8 ttTtipir B : At7Jpj T C i lirpfcrTov'] &Tpfirrot> G Ca avr^B:
BVT^ W sed ^ supra ^ : ainh T 5ok< tov MvpriAoi (ôVo) ovt)kv olov re yevea-QaL TTpovor]6rjvaL
ovbe Trpdihilv rwy TToppu) tS)V eis to Trav yevos, oVr/s aiiTo
bva-TVXLas iveTTLjXTrkri, t6 eyyvs p.6vov opSiv Kal t6 iTapa- d
XPVH-^
TovTO 8' ecrrt " TreXas " rjvUa jTpoeOvixeXTO kajBdv
navTl TpoTTOi t6v ttjs 'liTTTobaneLas ydiJ.ov. rw 8e TavTaX(a
KOL TTas av rjyria-aLTO Tovvoixa 6p6S>s Kal KaTo. (pvaLV Te6r]vaL
d d\ri6rj tcl Trept avT6v Xeyoixeva. 5
EPM. Ta TTOta TavTa;

212. "A re ttoiv ^tl ^GtVTL bv(TTV\riiJiaTa eyeveTO TToXkd
Kal beLvd, SiV koX Tekos 17 Trarpts avTov okri dveTpdiTeTO,
Kal TekevTr](ravTL kv "Atdou ^ vTTep rr/s Kecfxxkrjs tov kCôv

TakavTeCa 6avixaa-Tr} u)s aviiôivos roi 6v6ixaTL' Kal dTex,V(iis e
eoLKev, <oa-TTep dv ei rt? ôvkdixevos rakdvTaTov dro/u.acrat
dTTOKpvTTT6p.evos oiô/iao-ete Kat etTTOt dvT eKeivov "TavTokov,

tolovt6v tl kcu. rovro) t6 ovopi.a eoLKev eKTTopicraL rj tvx"! Trjs
(f)rifxris. (paCveTaL be Ka\ rw Trarpt avTOv keyopievco ro) Att 5
TTayKdkcas t6 ovop.a Keto-âf eo-ri be ov p(xbLov KaTavorjaaL. 396

dTexv(as ydp ecrTLV olov koyos t6 tov Aios dvofxa, biekovTes
6e avT6 bLxf} ol fxev t2> eTep(o ixepeL, ol be rw eTep(a xp(i>pLe6a
01 [xev ydp " Z^m," ot be " Ata
" KaAoCo-ty avvTLêixeva
8' ets ev Sr/Aoi Tr]v (f)va-LV tov 6eov, 6 br] iTpoa-qKeLV (\>aixev 5
6v6p.aTL oto) re eTvaL d7Tepyd(ea-6aL. ov ydp eaTLV rjpuv Kal

TOLS dkkoLS TTaa-LV oaTLS ecTTXv OLTLOS fxdkkov Tov Cv^ V
dpxoiv re Kat j3aaLkevs t&v TTavTUiV. a-vpLJBaLveL ovv 6p6(as
ovoixdêcrdaL ovtos 6 de6s elvaL, 8t' 6v Cv^ del iTdcrL rot? b
C4 S|jo' . . . iiruvvixias secl. Herinann C8 o1ov\ o1<(i BT

C9 auTi] avT(f BT d5 avrhu] avrwv T ei Ta\avr(la
Spalding ravraXfia B T
: davfjiaaT^ iis (Tvixtpwvois T : davfiaaToiis
ws ffvfxipdivos B 64 Tovrcp] tovto T as 5f ante avrh om. T
b I Si tv] Sih B
396 b nAATilNOS
CSxTLV vnapyeL' hiiikqitrai h\ hiya, axnTfp keyco, ^v ov rh
ovofxa, T(j) " Ad " KoX T<a " Z-qvC." tovtov be Kpovov vov
vfipKTTLKov jxev av ris 8oeiev eTvai, aKOVcravTi kâi^vr]s,
5 (vkoyov hk fieyaKrjs TLvbs bLavoias ^Kyovov cimi tov Aia'
Kopov yap arifxaivei ov iralba, aWa to KaOapov avrov koX
aKrjpaTOV tov vov. ((tti 8e ovtos Ovpavov vos, cbs Aoyos*
f) be av cs t6 avui 6y\ns koAcSs !>(*' tovto to 6vop.a KoXeia-dai,
C " ovpavia," opQiaa to, arco, o6(v 8r) Kai (paa-iv, a> 'Epp.6-
yeres, tov KaOapov vovv irapayiyvea-dai oi ixcTfctipoXoyoi,

Kal TO) ovpavQ opdois t6 6vofxa KetcrOaL' cl 8' ffJLffxvrffJLrfv ttjv
'Ha-Lobov yiVioXoyiav, Tivas iTL tovs avMTfpM iTpoyovovs

5 \e'yei tovtcov, ovk av (Travofxrfv bLe^LOiV &)S opOois avTols tcl
ovofxaTa KetTai, ecos aTTTreLpd0r]v Trjs ao(f>Las Tavrrfal Ti
TTOLr]aL, et apa airepeL rf ov, fj ^fxol âi(j)vr]s vvv ovrcoo-i
d TTpOa-TTTTT(aKV apTL OVK OlS' 6tt60V.
EPM. Kai fikv b-q, S) 2wKpaTes, aTX^^^ 7^ ôi SoKeis

waTTcp OL v6ova-LoivTS âi(f)vrfs x/"70'M<{^Seti'.
2i2. Kai aLTL&fxai ye, S) 'Epfx6yVS, fxaXLcrTa avnfv aTTo

5 Ev0V(f)pOVOS TOV UpoaTToXTioV TTpoaTTTTT(t)KVaL fXOL' (t)0V
yap TToWa avT^ avvi] Kal tTapelyov Ta S)Ta, KLvbvvVL ovv

v6ovaL(av ov fx6vov tcl S)Ta fxov fXTT\fjaaL Trjs baLfxovias
a-o(f)ias, aXXa Kal ttjs "^XV^ îTLXr](f)0aL. boKL ovv fxoL
e XPV^^'- ovT(oal rjfias iTOLrjcraL' t6 fxkv TTffxepov etyat XPV-

aaa0aL awfj Kai tcl Aotira TTcpl tQ)V 6vofxaT(i)V TTLaK\f/aa0aL,
avpLov b, hv Kal VfXLV avvboKfj, aTTobLOTTOfxiTr]a6fX6a t

avTr]V KOL Ka6apovfX6a ^vp6vTs oaTLS tcl ToiavTa Seiros
397 Ka0aipLV, eiTe T(av iepeov tls lt tG>v a-o<pLaTG)V.

EPM. 'AXA.' ky(i) fxkv avyx(>pQ>' Traw yap hv rfbitas tol
TTiK0L1Ta TTpl TOiV 6vOfXaT(t)V aKOVaaLfXL.
2X2. 'AAAa XF'] ovT<a ttollv. it60V ctvv ôvAei api(a-
6 fxfda bLaaKOTTOvirres, iTLbrf7Tp els tvttov tlvcl fx^^rfKafXV,
Ca fttTtwpo\6ya> B 03 ovpav*^ T c6 Tourj<rl ri\ tovttis

tt Ti B aa hy om. T
,
KPATTAOS 397 a
tva eibatixev et apa ijfjuv TnfiapTvpri(rei avTO. ra 6v6fj.aTa p.r\
TTavv airb tov avrojuarou oirra)? Ka<TTa KfXaOaL, akk iX^îv
Tiva opOoTrjTa; to. piev ovv t&v fjpuxiiv koI avOpcoTTOiv Xeyo- b
pLfva 6v6p.aza ifro)? av rjixas iâTTaTrjaeiev TToAAa fxiv yap
avTwv KLTai KaTo. TTpoyovoiV (TTcovvpiCas, ovbev TTpOarJKOV
ivCoi9, oJa-TTep KaT apyas iX.4yop.ev, ttoWo. 8e uta-TTep evx6-
fievoi TiOevTai, olov " KvTvxCbrjv " /cai " ôiaiav " Ka\ 5
"0eo'(/)tAov" Ka\ aXka TTokka.. to. p.\v ovv TOiavTa 8oKet p.oi
Xpifvai cav ei/cos 8e /u,aAtcrra rjnas evpelv to. 6p6S)S Kifj.eva

TTepl To. det ovTa /cat 7T(f)VK6Ta. ia-TTOvbdaOai yap evTavOa
pa.KiaTa TrpeVet Tr]v Oeaiv tu>v ^vojjiaToyv taois 8' eiîa avT&v C
Kat VTTo OeiOTepas hvvdfxeois rj ttjs T(av dv6p(oTT0)v eTedr].
EPM. AoKets juoi KaXS>s keyeiv, o) 2ci;Kpares.
2X2. 'Ap' ovv ov biKaiov aTTo tG)v 6eG)V dp\ea6ai, aKoiTov-

fievovi Trf) TTOTe avTo tovto to ovofia ol " 6eoi " 6p6(iis 5
eK\ri6rfaav;
EPM. EiKos ye.
212. ToiorSe TOivvv eyooye VTTOTTTevo)' (f)aivovTai poi oi
TTpG)TOi T(av dv6p(aTTO)v t5)v TTepl Tr]v 'EAAciSa tovtovs fx6vovs

[tovs 6eovs] rjyeXadai ovaTTep vvv TToAAot toiv (3ap^dpo)v, d
ijKiOv Kal aeXrjvriv Kal yrjv Kal daTpa Kal ovpavov aTe ovv
avTO. opwvTes TTdvra dei toVra bp6fx(^ kox 6eovTa, diTO TavTrfs
TTJs (f)vaeo)s TTJs Tov 6elv "6eovs" avTovs eirovofxdaai' v^rre-

pov be KaTavoovvTes tovs dAAous iTdvTas yjbr] TovT(a r<3 6v6- 5
/lari irpoaayopeveiv. loiKe' ri 6 Ae'ycD tS> akrfdel r] ovbev;

EPM. Yldvv fxev ovv eoiKev.
2X2. Ti ovv h.v fxeTo. tovto aKOTTolfiev;
EPM. AÂoy brf ori [baCfxovds re Kai ijpoâs Kal dvdp(6-
TTOvs] baCpLovas. e
b3 ivufvfMlas] d/i,(i)vvixlas B b5 fvrvxidi^V>' B b7 XP^*'<"1

Xaipfiv al. C I vpfTTti] TTspl G dI Tovs 6eovs seclusi Ofovs :
Eusebius et Cpost Theodoretus

if-yflaBai) d^ yp. Ka\ iiriKa\(<raiW
d6 T<f a\Ti6(7 T : t^ aKrtOtla B d9 ^ SrjKov al. Heindorf Schanz
Socrati tribuentes Saifj.ovds re . . . av6pun:ovs seclusi
PLATO, VOU I. 13
397 e riAATXlNOS
212. Kai 0)? a\ri6<as, oi 'Epfioyeves, tC av Trore vool t6
ovofxa ol " balfxoves"; a-Kexjrai. av tC croi boôi (IttIV.
EPM. Aiye p.6vov.
5 212. Oicrâ ovv nVas cf>r]alv 'Ha-iobos (tvaL tovs bai-

[xovas;
EPM. OvK ivvo(o.
2i2. Ovbe OTL xpva-ovv yivos to iipGtTov (prja-LV yiviaOaL

T<av av9pu)Tr(iiv;
lo EPM. OrSa roSro ye.
2X2. Aeyet toLvvv iiepX avTov
AvTap eTreiS^ tovto yivos KaTO. /ioip' iKdXxr^cv,
39 01 ixev baLpioves ayvol vTioyfiovLOL KokiovTaL,
kad\oL, aXe^LKaKOL, (f)v\aKs 6vrjT(av avdpdmdiv.
EPM. Ti' olv b^;

212. "Otl oTpLaL (yo) kiy^LV avTov to xpvaovv yivos ovk
5 CK ^(jiva-ov TT((pvKbs dAA' ayaOov re kcu koXov. TKp.ripLOV
be fxoL eaTLV otl Kal r]pi.as (f>rj(riv aLbrjpovv clvaL yevos.

EPM. "AXrjefj Aeyeis.
2X2. OvKovv Kal tQv vvv otcL ^v cfxivaL avrbv e? tls
b ayaOos ia-TLV K(lvov tov xP^^ôv yivovs elvaL;

EPM. EiKos ye.
2X2. 01 8' ayadoX aXKo tl r) (ppovLjjLOL;
EPM. ^pOVLfJiOL.
5 2X2. Tovto tolvvv iravTbs ixaWov X4yL, wj inol boKel,
Tovs baLp.ovas' otl (jypovLpLOL Kal baîxoves â-av,"baiixovas"

avTovs (ov6p.aacv Kal ev ye rfj 6.p\aLq Trj r]p.Tip(i (jxnvfj
avTo (Tvp.âLveL Tb ovofxa. Ae'yet ovv KaX&s Kal ovtos Kal

oAAoi "TToiTjrat ttoAAoi oo-ot Aeyouo-iv ws, e7rei8dr ris ayaObs
lo (ov reAeurô-Tj, [xeydXrjv ixoZpav koll TLfxrjv ex.L Kal yCyvcTaL
C baCix(av KaTCL ttjv rfjs (f>povr\(reois iiroiVvixCav. Tavrp ovv

TCOejxaL KOL iyui [tov baripi.ova] TTavT avbpa os av ayadbs rj,
b I yfvovs'] yivos B b8 crvn&aivfi] (mnalvti G C a rhv

Sa^/wya secl. Hermann
KPATTA02 398 c
batnovtov (Tvai. aal ((avra Kal TeXevrrja-avra, Kal 6p6&s

" baLixova " KoXelcrOat.
EPM. Kai cy&) jjlol boKO), S ^(oKpares, tovtov Trdvv ctol 5
(TV[ji\ln}c})09 elvat. 6 be bi] " ijpois" tC av etTj;
2X2. TovTO be ov iTavv xaXeTrbv kvvorjcraL. crjiLKpbv
yap iraprJKTaL avTutv to ovojxa, brjXovv rqv (k tov epo^TOs

yivtcTLv.
EPM. rio)? XiyeLs; 10
21i. OvK otcrda otl ^jjLLdeoL ol rjpoics;

EPxM. TloZv;
21i. YIavTS brjTTOv ycyovacTLV ipacrOevTos r] deov OjrqTrjs d
r/ dvr]Tov Oeas. (hv ovv o-kotttjs Kal tovto KaTO. Tr]V 'Atti/ctji;
Tr]v TrakaLav cfxtiirqv, fjLaXXov ctcrr]' br]\co(reL ydp (tol oti
napa to tov epcoTO? ovop.a, oOev yeyovaaLV ol rjpoies, afXLKpbv

TTapr^yp.ivov e<TTtv "f 6v6p.aTos "^ ydpLV. kcll rjTOL tovto Aeyet 5
Tovs rjpoias, rj otl ao(pol rja-av kol prjTopes [kol] beLvol Kal
bLoXeKTLKOL, epojTCLV LKavol ovTes' Tb yap " eXpeiv " XeyeLV
ecTTLV. oirep ovv dpTL Xeyop.ev, ev ttj 'ATTt/cfj ^corf) Xeyo-
[xevoL OL rjpcoes pr]Topes Tives koa. epo)Tr]TLKol o-viiâLvovcrLV, e
&crTe pifTopoiv kol (TO<pLcrTG)V yevos yiyveTaL Tb rjpcoLKbv
<f)vX.ov. dXXa ov tovto yaXeTTOv ecTTLV evvorjcraL, dXXa

p.dXXov Tb t5)v dv6p(tiTro)v, bta tC iroTe " dvdpo)TTOt " Ka-
XovvTat' (ri) av exets elireLv; 5
EPM. n66ev, u)ya6e, exiD; oib^ eX tl oX6s t hv eXr]v
fvpelv, ov (TvvTeCv(j) 8ta Tb r]yelcrdaL (Te pLakXov evpr^creLV 7/
efiavTov.
2X2.T^ Tov F.v6v(f)povos eTtLiivoCa. TiLcrTeveLS, ws eoiKas. 399
EPM. Af/Xa b-f].
2X2. Ôp6S)s ye av TTLo-TevociV' <U9 Kai vvv ye fxoi
C5 iyti] 67a>7 T di tpaaOevros f) Oeov ej^TjTijs fj Ovtitov 6eas]
(paffBtvres fj 6to\ 6vt)ttjs fi BvtitoI deas BTG d5 ovo/xaTos] aTOfxaTos

Peipers d6 Ka\ ante Seivo\ B: ras. ante Sivo\ T dv ipanav
(/cal flpeji') H. Schmidt d8 Aeyo/uei'] e\fyofj,fv T ei fp<t>Ti\-
TiKolJ ip{M>TiKo\ T e 5 ^ add. Heindorf
13*

399 a nAATf2N02
(f)aivo[xai Ko/x'^ci)S cvvevorjKevai, Kal KLvbvvevcra), âv fxrj
6 (vKaj3u>ixai, Irt Trjfxepov (ro(f)u>Tpos tov biovTos yfvicrOai.

(TKOTTei bq o A.eya). TTptaTov ixev yap to Toiovbe bei (vvorjiTai
irepl 6vopia.T(jiiv, oti noK.ka.Kis eiTe}xfiaXXoixev ypap.pMTa, to.
8' eâipovixev, irap' b ôvkoixeOa ovoixaôvTf^, koI Tas

" Ait "
o^vrriTaî )Liera/3aAAo/iey. otoi; (f)CKos tovto tva
b clvtI prjpLaTos ovoixaripXv yivr]Tai, t6 re (Tepov avT^dev IQTa
^(CKopiv Kol clvtI oêiay r^s /xeVT/s (rvKKaj3TJs âpeiav
i(f)9ey^dix(9a. clKKmv be TovvavTLov eixâXkoixev ypafxixaTa,
TCL be âpvrepa (^6^vTepay (f)9eyy6ixeda.
S, EPM. "kKr]9^ KeyeLs.
2f2. TovTMV ToCvvv ^v Kal To TU)V av6p(o7r(t)V ovoixa
7reTT0v9ev, o)? ep.ol boKeX. eK yap prjixaTOS ovoixa yeyovev,
evbs ypdpLiLaTos tov a\(pa e$aLpe9evTOS koI jBapvTepas Trjs
TeKevTTJs yevoixevr]s.
10 EPM. n&)j KeyeLs;
C 22. ^Q.be. (rrnxaCveL tovto Tb ovoixa 6 " &v6p(i)Tros " ort
TCL ixev aKKa 6ripCa 5)V opa ovb^sv eiTL^rKOTTel ovbe aroAoyiêrai
ov8e dvadpel, 6 b\ avdpu^TTos ap.a ecjpaKev tovto 8' ecrrt
[to] "oTTcoTre
" Kat dva9peX koX KoyCêTaL tovto b oiToiiTev.
5 ivTevdev bq ixovov t5)v 9ripCcav 6p9^s 6 dv6po)TTOs " avdpo)-

TTOs" (ji)VopLd(r9ri, dva9p(av h. 07ra)7re.
EPM. Tt ovv To ixeTo. tovto; epcoixaC (re b ^8e'a)s dv
TTv9oCixriv;
212. Yldvv ye.

d EPM. "ilcTTTep TOLVVV fxoL boKeX TovTOLS e^s elvaC tl
yjprjixa. " \jrvxr]V

" ydp ttov Kai " (r&ixa " xaAoC/xer tov
dv9p(i)TT0V.
212. Y[S)s ydp ov;

5 EPM. rietpw/xeâ 8?/ kol TavTa 8teAety coa-TTep Ta
ep.TTpoa-9ev.
b4 olvTfpa add. Buttmann b6 rovTtov] rovro T b8 ypifi-

fiaTos om. G C4 rh om. al. Eusebius C5 iii] SiSi}B d2 aroina]
aoifxd Ti T
KPATTAOS 399 d
211. ^vxv^ Aeyets (TncTKiâaOat ws dKOTOos tovtov tov

ovofxaTOS Tvyyavii, eTretr' av to (T&fjLa;
EPxM. Nai.
2X2. 'i2? juev Toivvv (k tov Trapaxpw'^ Xiyeiv, oXjxai ti lo
ToiovToy voiiv Tovs Ti]v \frvxrjv 6vop.a<TavTas, ojs tovto opa,
oTav TTaprj to) a-wfjLaTL, oltlov ia-TL tov Cv^ avT^, tijv tov
avaTTVLV hvvap.Lv irap^xov Kal ava\j/vxov, apa be (KkeL- e
TTOVTOS TOV aVa\l/VXOVTOS TO (T(OpLa CLTToXXvTaL T KttL TeK(VTa'
odev 8r; pioL boKOvaLV avTO "yj/vxw" /caAecrat. et 8e jSovXei
^X^ Vpp.a- boKut y<xp p.0L tl KoBopav TTLOavooTepov tovtov
TOLS djuî F.v6v(f)pova. tovtov p.\v yap, ws (po\ hoKil, 400
KaTa(ppovâ-aLV av Kal ifyqcraLVTO (fôpTLKov etrat* Tobe 8e
(TKOTTeL iav apa Kal aol apiai].
EPM. Aeye p.6vov.
212. Trjy (f>vaLV iravTos tov a(ap.aT09, waTe Ka\ C^v Ka\ 5
TTepLiivai, TL aoL 8oKet ^x^'^ "^^ '^'^' ox^ti' aAAo ?/ '^vxvi

EPM. Ovbêv aXXo.
212. Tt be; Ka\ t-i]v tcov aXXodv aTTavTcov (pvaLV ov
TTLaT(V(LS 'Avaây6p(i vovv Ka\ yf/vxhj^ etiât rtjv bLaKoap.ovaav
Ka\ <ixo'^'ô.v> 10
EPM. "Eycoye.
2i2. KoAois apa av to 6vo\xa tovto exot T17 bvvap.eL b
TavTTj r) (f)vaLV oxî ât ex^' " (pvaexv^" (TTOvop.dCfi.v.
eêaTL be Ka\ " xj/vx^^v

" Kop.\j/ev6p.evov XeyeLV.
EPM. ndvv ]xev ovv, kcll boKeZ ye p.0L tovto eKeCvov

TexviKîiTepov eXvai, 5
212. Kat yap eaTLV yeXoiov p.evTOL (paiveTai o)? dXrjdois
6vop.aC6p.evov ws eTedrj.
EPM. 'AAAa 8^ to p.eTa tovto ttoos (f)&p.ev exeti^;
2X2.To aSip.a Xeyets;

EPM. Nat. 10
2X2. rioXAax^ poi boKel tovt6 ye* av p.ev Ka\ ap.LKp6v
TLS TTapaKXivr], Ka\ Trdvv. xai yap aT]p.d TLves (f)aaLV avTo c
400C nAAT12N02
elvaL 77)9 ^vxrjs, 0)9 T6aiJ.fj.vr]s fv T<a vvv TtapovTi' kcu
hiOTi av TOVTi^ (nrjiJLaivet h hv (rr}iJ.aCvr} fj ^/o^x?;. Kal TavTri

" crrjfxa " 6p9(os KaXelcrOai. boKOVcri /leWoi /i06 /iaAioTa
6 Oicrdat, 01 aiJ.(pl 'Opcf^sa tovto to ovopia, &)? bUrjv bibovcrqs
Trjs"^^XV^ ^^ ^V (veKa btboicnv, tovtov 8e 7rept/3oXov e\tv,
tva o-w^Tjrat, becrpLOiTriptov etKova' (Ivat ovv Trjs y}/vxT}S
tovto, uicnT^p avTO 6vop.a^Tat, eco? hv fKTficrr) to. dejlêiXd/xeva,
[to] " 0-wjixa," Kat ovbev betv TTapdyctv ovb^ V ypdp.}ia.

d EPM. TavTa p.ev p.ot 8oKet tKavSis, Zi ^(oKpaTcs, dprja-Oai'
TtepX b\ Ttiiv diSiV T&v 6vofj.dT(iiv, diov Kai Trept tov " Atos
vvvbr] lAeye?, exoijuey av ttov /cara tov avTov TpcriTov
^TTt(rK4\}fa(r9at KaTct Ttva ttotc 6p66Tr)Ta avT(av to. 6v6fiaTa
6 Keirat;
212. Nai pia Aia rjixets ye, Si 'Ep/idyeves, et-rrep ye vovv
i\otixv, va /ixey roi^ KdAAto-roi; TpoTTov, ort Tre/st 9tSiV ovb\v
t(rpLV, ovT 7re/>t avTuiV ovtc irept tuiv 6vopi,dT(iiv, aTTa Trore
eai;rous KaAoOo-iv 8Âoy yap dri eKeXvoC ye Tdkr]drj KaXovat.
e 8evrepo9 8' av TpoiTos dpdoTriTOS, uxriTep (V rats euxats

voiios ecrrtv rnxiv evxeor9at, olTtvis re Kat 6it69(V xaipovcrtv
6vo}xa^6p.VOt, TavTa koX r}p.ds avTovs KaXetv, iis aAAo ixr}b(V
401 etSdraj' KaXS>s yap br} îxotye boKet vevofxiadat. eJ ovv

ôvKh, crKOTT&ixev (io(riTp TTpoftTTovres Tots 6eoXs ort TTept
avT&v ovbev jyjuets (rKe^ôfxeâ ov yap d^tovixev oloi t hv

eiyat o-K07rety ctAAa Trept t&v dv9p(0TT(tiV, ijv ttotI rtva boâv
5 expvTes iriêvTO avTOts Ta dvopiaTa' tovto yap dveixi(rr}Tov.

EPM. 'AAAd ixot 8oKets, Si ScoKparey, ixeTpicns Ae'yeiv,
Kat ovT(a TTOtw/xey.
b 212. "AAAo ri ovv d(\i '^Y.crrias dpxjiiixeda KaTa tov voixov;

EPM. AiKatov yovv.
c 3 <rr)/j.rfvr) T c 4 /xoi om. Stobaeus C 6 Si] 8^ Heindorf

C 8 Tovro, wcrirep avrh B T tovto avr6, Sxrirtp Stobaeus
: C 9 t6 om.
Stobaeus oiiS' iv scripsi oiiSiy B :ovSi T d 7 fxof^f ^d.
:
Basileensis altera, Schanz & i el fiovKfi olv T fiovKti oiv Jordan :
a4 IJf iroTf Tiva, BT : ^vTivii iroTf vulg.

KPATTA02 40ib
SI2. Ti ovv av TLS âir] biavoovixevov tov 6vo^(ravTa
'Eariav dvoixdcrai,; ^
EPM. Ov fxa Tov Aia ovbe tovto ot)/at pabLov (tvai. 5
]Sn. Kivbvvevovcn yovv, diyaOe 'EpiJLoyeves, ol TrpQiTOL tcl
ovopiaTa TLOeixevoi ov (pavXoi elvaL dkXa fxeTeoipokoyoi *cai
dbok4a\aL TLves.
EPM. Tibrj;
212. KaTa(})aiveTaC fxoi fj Oicns tG>v ovofxaTOiV roiovrwy 10
TLVwv dvOpwiroiv, Kal kdv tls to. êvLKo. 6v6p.aTa dvacrKOTTi], C

ov\ rJTTov dvvpi(rKTaL eKacTTOv /3ovAera6. oTov Kai iv
TOVTio r]p.eXs " ovcriav " KoXovfxev, elalv 01 " ecrcriav
KoXovcnv, CK 8' av " bicriav." np5>TOV [xev ovv KaTo. to

Tpov ovojxa TOVTuyv 7/ TcHv TTpayfxaTojv ovcria " Ecrrta 5
KdKeLcrBaL eêi Xoyov, Kal ori ye av rifxels t6 ttjs ovcrias
IxfTexpv " lo-rii^ " (})ap.ev, Kal Kara tovto 6p6G>s av koXoIto
"'Eo-rta"* eoiKafxev yap Kal rjpLels to TraXaLov " eircriav"
Kdkelv Tr]v ovcriav. (tl be Kal KaTO. tcls dvcrias dv tls
evvor]cras r^yqcraLTO ovtoo voelv Tavra tovs TL6ep.evovs' to d
ydp irpb irdvTOiv 6eS>v r?) 'Eorta ttpôtt] Trpo^veLV elKos eêi-
vovs otTives Tr]V TtdvTOJV ovcriav " eaaiav " eiroovoixaaav.

oaoL 8' av " coaiav," crêbov tl av ovtol ko^' 'HpaKXetroi^
dv riyolvTO Ta ovTa levaL re Trofra Kal fxeveLV ovbev to 5
ovv aLTLOv Kal To dpxriybv avT&v eTvaL to d)6ovv, o6ev

br] KoXois e\eLV avTo " oiaiav " o)voixda6aL. koll Tavra
fxev bi] TavTr] ws Trapa ixrjbev elboTcov elpr]a6o}' ixeTa 8' e
*Eo"riav biKaiov 'Peav Kal Kpovov einaKeylracrâL. KaiTOL
To ye Tov Kpovov ovofxa {jbri bLr]K6oixev. LaoiS ixevroL
ovbev Xtyo).
EPM. Ti 8^, 0) '2(itKpaTes; ^
212. ^Q,yade, evvev6r]Kd tl crixrjvos aroc))ias.
EPM. ITotoi^ 8// TovTo;
b6 yofv om. G C I avOpwTTwv] avdpdnrwv (luat B 03 (criav B

C 7 %<rri.v scripsi : (ffri Badham : icrriav B : tffriav T d2 irpodveiy^
dvuv G d3 (Tcria;' scripsi : iariav B : k<rriav T
4o2a nAATX2N02
402 212. FfXolov [x(v 7T(4ru ciircu', oîxcu fjJvToi Tiva TndavorriTa
EPM. Tiva Tavrqv;

212. Tov *lip6.K\(LT6v fxot. boKta KaOopav TraXaC arra
5 (ro<f>h \4yovTa, aTxv(iis to, ^ttI Kpovov koI 'Pcas, h, koI
"Oixripos ikeyev.
EPM. riws TovTO \4ycis;
212. A4yi TTov 'HpdKAciros oti " T:6.VTa xâpil kolL ovhtv
fi4v(i" Kal TTOTafiov porj aTTftfcdi^coy to. ovTa Aeyf i &)S " bls
10 ^s Toy avTov TTOTajxbv ovK av ^/uâ^Tjj."
EPM. 'Eo-ri raCra.
b 2i2. Ti ovv; boKei (toi. oXKoioT^pov 'Hpa/cAeiroi; vodlv 6
TLOifxevos TOLS tS>v akkoiv OeSiv TrpoyovoLS " 'Peaj; " re Kal
" Kpovov ; apa oUl aiTo tov avTOfxaTov avTov afx^fiOTepoii
pevfxaTaiV dvofxaTa OicrdaL; wcrTTep av "Ofxripos " ^Q.Kav6v rc
5 $6iv yiV((TLV " (pricTLv " koll fxrfTepa Tridvv" olixaL 8e Ka\
Ho-ô8oj. kiyiL bi ttov koll Ôp(f)cvs otl
^Q.Keav6s TTpStTos KoXklppoos îpi^ y6ixoLO,

C os pa KaaLyvrfTTiv bfxoixriTopa TrÔvv oirvLfV.
TaVT^ OVV (TKOTtei OTl Koi okk-qkOLS a~vp.(f)(tiVl Kol TTphs TO, TOV
'HpaKkeCTOv Trdvra reirei.
EPM. (paCvri TL fxoL kiyiLV, a> 2(oK/3ares' Tb fxivTOL rTjs
5 Ttj^vos ovk kvvoG) ovofxa tC ôvkiTaL.

212. 'AAAa pJriv tovto ye okCyov avrb kiyn otl iTriyrjs
ovoixa iTTLKiKpvfXfxivov k(TTCv. Tb yap bLaTT(afXvov Kal

d TO rfdovfxcvov TTriyris iiTfCKaa-pA (aTLV iK bi TOVTOiV 6fx-
(PoT(p(ov T(av 6vofx6T(ov rf
" Tifdvs " To ovoixa (TvyKdTaL.
EPM. ToiSro fx(v, Si 2a)Kpare?, K0fx\^6v.
212. T^ 8' ov fxikk(L; dAAa tC Tb fx(Ta tovto; Tbv fx(v
5 ACa (LTTOpLV.
a I fxiy om. T a 4 raAari wdXcu B iraktu T b 4 ^tvfiiroty

:
om. T b 5 (priffiy B ((>ria\ B'

: om. T W
b 7 KaWip6ovs B
: :
KaWipp6ovs T C 6irvtey T &irv(y B

I C 2 &\Aois B
: C 4 (paivti
Ti T :ôdvtTu B d 4 /iÂAtij fitKJitt B T
KPATTAOS 402d
EPM. Na^.
2X2. Tovs abekcfyovs br} avrov X4y(oixV, tov re rioo-eiSa)
Koi Tov YlkovTiova Ka\ to iTepov ovofjia 6 dyo/xaôuo-iy
avTov.
EPM. Udvv ye. lo
2X2. To ijikv Toiwv tov IIoa-eLb&vos fioL cfiaLveTai wvo-

IMda-dai [tov TTpatTOv 6vofj.d(ravTos]y otl avTov âbi^pvTa e
eTria-yjev fi ttjs âAdrTT/s (pva-Ls Kal ovk^tl etaa-ev iTpoeXdeXv,
dAA' wo-7rep bea-p.os tu)v iTobciv avT(o eyeveTO. tov ovv
dpyovTa r?/? bvvdpLediS TavTrjs Oeov (avopLaa-ev "Uo^reLbaiva,
b)S " TTOCTLbecriJ.ov " oyra* to be e eyKeLTaL tcrôs evTrpeTreCas S
eveKa. Tdâ be ovk av tovto XeyoL, dAA' dvTL tov crlyixa
bvo kd^ba To TTpa)Tov ekeyeTO, ws ttoWcl eiboTOS tov 4^3

deov. Lcruis be diTO tov creieLV " 6 a-eCoiiv " b)v6p.aa-TaL'
TTpdcrKeLTaL be to TTel Kal t6 bekTa. t6 be UkovTOiVos,

TovTO ixev /cara ttjv tov TrkovTOV b6aLV, otl e/c ttjs yrjs
KdTOiOev dvCeTaL 6 iTkovTos, eTr(ovop.da6r]- 6 be " ALbrjs," ol 5
TToAAot ixev ixoL boKova-LV vTTokap.^dveLV t6 aLbes TTpoa-eLprja-Oac
ro) 6v6ixaTL tovt(o, Kal (f)o(3ovpLevoL t6 ovop.a " Y\kovT(ava "

KoAoCo-iv avTov.
EPM. 2ot 8e Trw? âCveTaL, S) 2w/cpares; b
2X2. noAAaxTj ep.0Lye boKovcTLV dvOpoiiTOL bLr]ixapTr]KevaL
TTepl TOVTOV Tov 9eov Trjs bvvdp.e(t}S Kal (fyoêlaQaL avTov ovk
d^Lov (ôvy. OTL Te ydp, eTTeLbdv aTTa^ tls fjix&v aTToOdvri,
del eKel eaTLV, (f)oôvvTaL, Kal otl fi yfrvxr] yvixvf} tov 5
a-(s)p.aTos TTap' eKelvov diTepxeTaL, Kal tovto TTe^f^d^rjVTaL'
Ta 8' eixol boKeL irdvTa es tovtov tl avvTeCveiv, Kal fj dpx.^

Tov 6eov Kal t6 ovoixa.
EPM. nws bi];
2X2. 'Eya> o-ot epw d ye ixol cfâCveTaL. eiTre ydp C
e I ToC . . . ovofidaayros secl. Schanz : {nrh tov . . . ovoixaaavTos al.
a6 aihfs scripsi (cf. 404 b 2) : detSes BT b2 &v6pconoi BT : ol

&vdpwvoi G \) \ 6v add. Baiter b 5-6 <pofifnai . . . irf<p6-
firjTai T
403C ITAATIINOS
1X01, 8fcr/jios ^(po) oTiaovv oJo-re fX(Vi.v ottovovv, 7r6Tpos
la-yyporepos ^(ttiv, &vdyKr) rj iTndvfJLia;
EPM. rioXv bta(})pL, 0} SwKpares, fj Tn6vp.ia.
6 212. Oiet ovv Tov "Aibrfv ovk av TroAAoi/s K(f)(vyt.v, tl
ixr] To) l<rxypoTdT(a 8eo-/j,o) I8ei tovs iK(T(r lovras;

EPiM. Af]\a brj.
2f2. 'E7ri0v/u,ra apa Tiyl avrotJs, wy lotKe, Sei, ctTrtp t^

fj.y[a-T(o 8eor/i^ Sei, xal ovk avdyKri.
lo EPM. 4>aiveTai.
212. OvKoCy Tndvp.iai. av noKKal ^lcrtv;
EPM. NaL
d 212. Trj fJLyi(rTr} &pa ^TnOvfxlcL tQv ^TnOvfXLOiV Sei avTOVs,
eiTrep jLteAAet rcS fXyLa-T<a 8e(7/ia) KaTe^xetr.
EPM. Nar.'
2X2. "EcTTti' ow Tty /xet^coi' kinOvfxLa rf oTav tls to) otîô)!;
5 otTjTai 8t' Klvov (r(r6aL dfxîvcov dvrfp;
EPM. Ma Ai" ov8' OTrai^TTLOvv, a 'S,(OKpaTS.
2X2. Ata TavTa apa (^Sifx^v, S) 'Epfx6yVS, ovbeva bvpo

eêAô-at aTreAêty tcSi' Kl6v, ovbc avTas tos ^^Lprjvas,
e aAAa KaTaKKr}\rja-daL Kivas T Kal tovs aAAous TrdrTas'
ovTO) K(xXovs TLvas, o? ioLKV, liriaTaTaL \6yovs Ae'yetv
6 "At^rjs, Kal â-TLV, &s y Ik tov \6yov tovtov, 6 debs

[ovTos] T\Os ao(f)LaTr]s T Kal fXyas evepyeVjjs tS>v TTap"
5 avTU), os ye Kot Tots ev^d8e Too-airra dyaOd dvirfaLV ovto)

"
TToAAa avT^ Ta TreptdiTa ^Kei ioTLV, kol tov " Yl\ovT(t)va
diTO TOVTov â)(^ To ovofxa. Kal to av fxif eê'Aetj; oT^yeirai
Tots dvdpdi-noLS iypvaL tc adpiaTa, d\\a t6t avyyiyva-daL,

404 e7ret8ar r] '^vyrf Ka6apa 77 TTdirruiv t&v irepi t6 (rStfxa KaK&v
KOt TTL6vp.Lu>v, ov (f)L\oa6(f)OV boKL aoi eimi Kai v ivT6vfxr]-
fxivov OTL ovTO) fxkv &v KaT\oL avTOvs 8T;o-as TTJ Trepi dpTr]v
kTTL6vfxi(i, iôvTas bk TTfv Tov adfxaTos TTToirfaLV KOL fxaviav
d2 (iiTfp] fJiTfp 7 G d5 HffftrOai] (crrai T e a Kfytiv

\6yovs G 64 oZtos om. T aa <î\o^6ôv fvTfOvfxri/jLtyov
. . .
Heusde : <pi\6<rQ<l>oy . . . ivrfOv;xi\it.iifoy B T aoi SoKf T 1

;
KPATTA02 404 a
ovb^ av 6 Kpovos bvvaiTO 6 Trarqp crvyKaTi\eLV avT^ kv rois' 5
hio-p.ols STjcras ToZs avTOv XeyopMvois

EPM. Kivbvvvei,s tI Aeyetv, S> 2coK/)ares'.
2i2. Kal To ye ovofxa 6 ""AiSrjs," S) 'Epptoyeves, ttoX.Xov b

bel aTTO Tov aibovs fTTMVofjidcrdai, aWa ttoXv fjMkkov airo
Tov irdvTa to. Koka ilbivai, aTTO tovtov vtto tov vopLoOirov
""AiSt;? " (KkrjOrj.

EPM. Eiei'* rt 8e ArjfxrjTpd re Kal "Hpav Kal 'ATroAAo) 5
KOi W6rjvdv Kal "HcfâKrTov Kal "Apnt] koX tovs dkXovs 6eovs,
TTcas Xeyojiev;
2X2. Arjfxrirqp fxev (fâCveTaL KaTa Tijv boaiv Trjs eboybrjs
bibova-a ws fxrfTrfp
" ArjfirjTrjp" KeKX?]cr0ai, "Hpa be epaTrf
TLS, axnrep ovv Kal Aeyerat 6 Zevs avTijs epaaOels e\eiv. C
Xa-MS be fxeTeoipoXoycav 6 vofioOeTrfs tov depa ""Hpav"
d)v6p.a(rev eTTLKpvTTTOfxevos, OeXs ti]V dp\i]v eTrl TeXevTijv
yvoirfs 8' dv, et TToXXdKis Xeyots to Trfs "Hpas ovofxa.
" êppe(f)aTTa " 8e'' TToXAot fxev toKal tovto (polBovvTai 5
ovofxa Kal tov " 'AiroAAaj," vtto aTretptas, ws eotKev, ovo-

fxdTOiv opOoTrjTOS. Kal ydp pLeTajBdXXovTes (TKOtTOvvTaL ri]V
" ep(re(f)6vr]v," Kal beivbv avTots (f)atveTat' t6 b^ fxrjvveL
(ro(f)7]v elvat rqv deov. aTe ydp (f)epop.ev(t)v tu>v TrpaypdTcov d

t6 e(f)aT6fxevov Kal eiTa^fi&v fcai bvvdfxevov eTTaKoXovOelv
(ro(f>ia hv eLTj. " <t>epeTTa(pa " ovv 8ia rrfv cro(f>(av Kal Trfv
eTTa(f)i]v Tov (êpofxevov r] 6e6s dv 6p6&s koXoIto, rf
tolovt6v tl 8t' OTTep KOL (rvvecTTLV avTfj 6 "ALb-qs a-0(p6s 5

(ov, bioTL TOLavTq e^TTtv vvv be avTrjs eKKXCvovcrL t6 6vop.a
evcTTOfxtav TTepl TTXetovos iToiovfxevot Trjs dXrj6eias, ojare
" êppe(f)aTTav " airrijv KoXelv. TavTOV be kcll TTepl tov
Att6XX(i), oTTep Xeyoo, ttoAAoi 7re<ô^rji;rai irepi t6 ovofxa tov e
6eov, U)S TL beLv6v fxrfvvovTOS' 77 ovk ^(r6r](raL;
EPM. Hdw fxev ovv, Kal dXr]6r] Xeyets.
b2 diSois re vera B T (cf. Phaed. 79 a 4"; aeiBots vulg.

: b3 (al)
fJSfVa Hermann bq Atj/uwijp om. B ei tpaffOfls ^xuv
liber Bessarionis^ 6 potrOtis x** ^T di 0t6v] Oedv T
404e nAATflNOS
Sf2. To 6e y ((TTiv, i)S f/xot do/cei, KaAAi(rra KcCfievov
5 TTpos T^y bvvayi.iv tov dtov.
EPM. n&)s 877;
212. 'Eyo) TTetpao-o/Liai (f)p6.<rai o yi fioi (})aCvTai' ov yap

405 tcTTLV OTL &v [jmWov ovofM rjpfj.o(rv kv ov TTTapa-i bvV(ifJL(n
rat? Tov deov, c3o-re Tracr&v i(f)dTTT(cr6aL kol brjXovv Tpoirov
TLVa fXOVCTLKIfV TC Kal p.aVTLK1]V KOL laTpLKIfV Ka\ TO^LKTjV.
EPM. Aeye 8^' &tottov ydp tC p.0L A^yeis to ovofia

5 ilvai.
212. EvapjLioo"roy fikv ovv, aTe pLOV(riKov ovroi tov Ofov.
TTpwTOV pikv yap fi KdOapaLS kol ol Ka6app.o\ koX KaTO. ttjv

laTpLKTjv Kal KaTCL TTjV fxavTLKijv Kal ai tols larpiKois
b (f)apij.dK0LS Kal al tols fiavTLKols iTfpLdeLd^reLS re Kai to,
\ovTpa TCL kv TOLS TOLovTOLs Kal ai TTfpLppdva-eLS, TTdvTa ev

TL Tavra bvvaLT dv, KaOapov 7Tap4\fLV tov dvdpooTTOv Kai
KaTCL t6 aG)p.a Ka\ KaTo. ti}v xf/vxifv rj ov;
5 EPM. Hdvv pLV ovv.
212. OvKOW 6 Kadatpuiv debs Ka\ 6 dTro\ov(i>v re Kai

&.'JToX.v(av tQv tolovtoov KaKdv ovtos hv etrj;
EPM. riajû fjLev ovv.

2i2. Kara pikv toCvvv ras aTroAvo-ets re koi dTroXovtrcty,
^
C 0)9 larpo? o)V tS)V tolovt(v, " XttoXoxxdv" hv 6pd(os koXolto'
KaTCL be T7]v p.avTLKr]v koll to d\r]des re Kai to dTT\ovv
TavTov ydp iarLV uxnTep ovv oi crraAot KoXovaLV avTOV,
opdoTaT av koXoIto' " "AttAow" ydp âai TTdvTiS rroXoi
5 TovTov Tov deov. 8ta 8e to de\ [3o\&v iyKpaTifs ctrat to^lktj
" 'Aet/3aAAa)v" (ttCv. KaTa 8e ti]V fiovcrLKr]V bd ii7roAa/3etv
[3)cnTp Tov aKoôvdov re Kai Tr]v aKOtrtr] ort t6 d\(f)a (rqpLaCvd

TToAAaxou t6 opLOV, Ka\ ivTav6a ti]V 6p.ov 7T6\r]a-LV Koi
7Tp\ Tov ovpavov, oiis bi] "ttoAovs" KaAoCcrtr, Kai [rr/v] ire/ai
a I fip/xo<Tfv tv tv TW
ripnoarfifvov B et in marg.
: b i wfpi- W
6tKv<TfisT iTfpidf^ ois fhB
: b a TaCra ? T B b T 6 a.nte iwoKvaiv T
C I airoKvwy ^ airoKovwv Heindorf C4 "AirKovv Boeckh airAci' B : :
airAoV T c 7 SxTirtp . Hxoniv secl. Ast

, . c 9 t^v del. t
KPATYA02 405d
Ti]v V TTJ w8t) apiiovCav, i) h-j] (rvfJKfxovta KaXeirai, otl TavTa d

TTavTa, &s âaiv ol kojxôI irepl fxovaLKi^v Kal aarpovofiLav,
apfxovLa TLVL TTokel ap.a TrdvTa' (TTLo-TaTel be ovto9 6 debs
Trj app.ovLa opiOTTokc^v avra TidvTa Kai KaTO. Oeovs Kal Kar
dvdpUlTTOVS' U>a-TTp OVV TOV 6fXOK\vdoV KOl 6p.6K0LTLV 5
" aKoKovdov " Ka\ " clkoltlv " lKaXeaap.ev, p.eTajiak6vTes
dvT\ Tov " 6p.o-" " a-," ovTU) Kal " 'ATroAAtom" iKoXea-apev
"
os ^v 'OfioTToXcdv," (Tepov kd(3ba epjBakovTes, otl 6p.u>- e
i'Vfxov eyCyveTO ro) ôkeTi^ 6i'6fxaTL. oirep Kal vvv vrro-

TTTevovTes TLves 8ta to /xt/ 6p6ws a-KOTTeiaOaL nfv bvvafXLV
Tov ovofxaTOS (popovvraL avTo ws a-rjfxalvov (f^dopdv TLva' to
be [iTokv], u>a-7Tep apTi ekeyeTo, iTaaoov ecpaiTTdfxevov Ketrat 406
T(av Tov $eov bvvdfxe(t)V, aTTkov, del (3dkkovTOS, diTo-
kovovTos, 6pLOTTokovvTos. Tcis be "Movaas" re Kal
okcos Tifv fxovaLKifv aTTo Tov p.(aa6aL, w? eoLKev, Ka\ Tifs
0fTjfae(i>s Te Ka\ (f)Lkoao(})Las to ovofxa tovto eiTUiVOfxaaev. 5
Aj/ro) be aTTO ttjs TrpqoTrfTos ttjs 6eov, KaTo. t6 edekrjfxova

etvaL S)v dv tls berfTai. tau^s be o)? 01 êvoL KakovaLV'
TToAXot ydp " Arfdu) " Kakovatv eoLKev ovv TTpos to fxif
"
Tpa)(y Tov r]6ovs dAA' rjfxepov re KOt Aetoi' " Atjô)
KeKkrfa6aL vtto toov tovto KakovvToov. ""ApTefXLs" be {8ta} b

TO dpTep.es (paiveTaL Ka\ to Koafxtov, 8ta TrfV Trjs TTapdevCas
eTTi6vfXLav tacos be dpeTffS XaTopa Trfv 6e6v eKakeaev 6
KoXeaas, Td\a 8' dv Ka\ cos tov dpoTOV pLLarfadarfs tov
dvbpos ev yvvaLKL' rf 8ta roi^rcoi; rt 77 8ta Trarra TavTa to 5
ovofxa TovTO 6 Ti6efxevos ^6eT0 rf; de^.

EPM. Tt be 6 " ALowaos " re Kat ^ " 'A(/)po8irTj ";
2X2. MeydAa, 00 -Trat 'Ittttovlkov, epooTqs. dkka eaTl

ydp Ka\ aTTovbaCoiS elprfp.evos 6 TpoiTOS t5)V ovofxdTUiV tovtols
d 3 icoKeX] iroA.?TOt Ast d 4 oura] Tauro Ast d7 avTl

Tov dfjLO &A(pa Hermann avrl tov &\<pa B
: ayrl tov o d : T e i (fi-
â\6uT(s G ififidWovTes B T
: a i troKv om. al. : nov Hermann
8.3 dfj.oiroKovvTos om. B a6 0(\i]fjLova T: e\ffifi.ova Orion (ut
videtur) a^ Aenjei Heindorf b i 5aadd. Stephanus baT^
om. G
4o6c nAATftNOS
C Tols deols Kol TratStK^Ss. tov fiev ovv (nTovbaiov &Wov^
Tivas p(OTa, Tov bk TratbiKbv ovbkv KUiKvei bKkddv <f)i\o-
7raC(rixovs yap koI re yap Alovvctos eirj hv

oi deoC. o
6 bi.bovs Tov oTvov " AiSoiwo-os " (V TTai.bia KaKovp.ivos,
8', oTi oli^rOai. vovv
5 oiros (X^'-^ Troiei T(av Tn.vovToiv rovs
7to\kovs ovK expvTas, " olovovs " biKaioTaT h.v KoXovfxevos.
Trepl bi Â(f)pobCTr]s ovk aîov *Ho-to'8a) avTikiyeiv, aXKa
d (Tvyxdipeiv OTL bia ttjv ^^/c) tov i.<l)pov y4v(riv "Â(}>pobCTr)"
iKkriOr].
EPM. 'AXA.a /xT/y ov8' 'A^rjms 'A^Tjmto'? y iLv, w 2(tf-
Kpares, eTriKricrrj, ovb^ 'Hâtcrrou re Kal "ApeoiS.
5 212. Ov8e etKos ye.

EPiM. Ov ydp.
2X2. OvKovv To fxkv (repov ovofia avrrjs ov \a\eTTov
eiTTety 8t' 6 /cetrat.
EPM. To TTotoi;;
10 2i2. " naAAd8a " ttov avrrjv KoXou/xcy.
EPM. nois yap ov;

212. Toilro fxkv ToCwv cnTh ttjs iv tols 5tt\ols 6pxw^<^^
e rjyovixcvoL TcdrjvaL 6p6(iis av, w? eyw/xat, fjyoCfxeda' t6 yap
7T0V ^ avTov 7/ ri a\Ao p.eT(opC^LV f/ dTTo Trjs yrjs i) (V rat?
"iTdWeiv" re Kal " 7raAAe(r0at " /cal 'ât
407 X^P'^'^ <5/)Xii^
6px(^<J'do.L Ka\ovixv.
EPM. ndyu /iey ovv.
212. " OoAAdSa " /iev toCwv Tavrr].
5 EPM. Kai dpôjj ye. dA.Aa 8?/ t6 hcpov ttHs Ae'yets;

2X2. T6 Trjs Âdrjvds;
EPM. Nat.
212. TovTO ifx/SpLOecrTepov, S (/)tAe. ioCKaa-i brj /cat ol
7raA.atoi ttjv 'AOrjvdv vofxCêLV &a-'nep oX vvv TTepl "Ofxrjpov
b Seivoi. Kol ydp tovtcov ol 7roAA.oi e^yovfxevoi tov TrowjrTjy
c 6 KoXovnevos^ KoKo^To Hermann di iK add. Hermann

a9 dfiiipov T
;
KPATYAOS 407 b
4>acrL TTjv ^K6r\vav avrbv vovv re Kal bLavotav TTCTTOLrjKevaL,

Kal 6 TO. ovofxara t:olS>v eoLK tolovtov tl irepl avTrJ9 8ia-
voda-daL, tl 8e /ietôyo)? Xeyoiv Oeov v6r](TLV oicnrepel \eyeL
OTL " a dfovoa " (ttIv avrrj, rw ak(f)a êvLKUis civtI tov rjra 5
\pr](rafjiVos Kal t6 iwra Kal t6 (rlyiia a(f)X(av. tcrcos 8e

ovbe TavTrj, dAA' o)S to. dela voov(rrjs avTrjs bLa(f)p6vT(os t5)V
akk(i)v " Qeovoriv " eKaAecrei;. ovbev be d7re'xei Kal Tr}v kv
ro) 7/êi v6ri(rLV o)s ov(rav Tr]v 6e6v TavTrfv " ^Vl6ov6riv " p.\v
ôvkecrdaL TrpocreLTTeLV itapayayoiv 8e 17 avT6s rj TLves v(TTepov C
eTTt To KoXkLOV 0)9 ôvTO, " 'A9r]V(xav " eKaAecrar.
EPM. Tt 8e br} t6v "HcfâLaTOV, Trfj keycLs;
2i2. 'H t6v yevvalov t6v " (f>deos ta-Topa " epcoras; '
EPM. 'Eotxa. 5
212. OvKovv ovTos pikv TTavTl brjkos " 4>at(rros " o)v, t6
Tjra 7[pocrekKV(Tap.evos
EPM. Ktz^Swevet, eav ixrj ir-q ctol, U)S eoLKev, ^tl akkr] b6^r].
212. 'AAA' lya /Lt^ bo^rj, t6v "Apr] ep(i>Ta.
EPM. 'Epwroi. lo
212. OvKOvv, et p.\v ôvkeL, KaTO, t6 appev re Kai KaTO. d *
t6 dvbpelov ""Apr^s" dv etr]' et 8' av KaTCL t6 (TKkr]p6v re
Kat dpieTd(TTpo(pov, o bi] " dppaTov " KaA.etrai, Kat TavTrj dv

TTavTaxf] TTok(]XLKU> 6((a TTpeiTOL " "Apr] " KoAeto-ât.
EPM. Ildvv p.ev ovv. 5
212. 'Ek jxev ovv t5)V 6e5)V 7Tp6s 6eG)v dTTakkay(a]Xv, o)S
eyo) 8e'8otKa Trept avToiv bLakeyecr6aL' iTepl be dkkôv (fivy

TLVcov jBovkeL 7Tp6l3cLkke p.0L, " o(f>pa i8r/at otot " F.v6v(ppovos
tf rf
tTTTTOt.
EPM. 'AAAa iroijjo-o) TavTa, eTL ye ev ep6p.ev6s cre Trepl e

*Ep/jto{5, eiretS^ ]xe Ka\ ov (f>r](rLV Kparukos 'Ep]xoyevri eXvaL.
'neLp(i>]xe6a ovv t6v " 'Epixijv " (TKeyfraa-6aL tl koX voel t6
ovojxa, tva Kal elbiafxev et rt obe Ae'yet.
bsôm.G h5a.0fov6aB\ittmann:T}6(op6riB:r)dov6r)T TyJroT

b7 ouSej ou T C 2 a.d7]vaav T adrivav B :d. 4 TrpeVet T d6 oZv
om. r d7 wi/ rivaiv\ rivwv B : 1; tivuv T 64 'Iva. koI] Iva T
407e nAATaNOS
5 2f2. 'AA\a iJii]v TOVTO ye (oiKe TTpl koyov Tt etvaL 6
"
'Epixrj^," Kol t6 kp\xr)via iivai Ka\ to &.yy(\ov koI to
408 KkoTTLKov T Kol To aTTaTi^kbv (V Aoyoi? Ka\ t6 ayopaa-TLKQV,
TTfpl \6yov bvvafj.LV ((ttlv Traa-a avTTj fj npayp.aTeLa- OTrep
ovv Kal iv TOLi Trpoa-dev i\4yopLV, t6 " dpeLV " Ao'yoi; XP^^^
"
ea-TL, t6 be, oTov Kal "Oixrjpos TTokX.axov Aeyet, " (fxriaâTO
6 (f)r]aLV, TOVTO 8e fxrixavrja-aa-OaL iaTLV. $ aix(poTp(DV ovv

TovTdiv t6v t6 KiyeLV t kuI tov \6yov fxrjcrdixevoif r^ bi
\yLV bl] (TTLV LpLV TOVTOV TOV êOV 0)CnTpl ^TTLtAtTÎ
b rifxlv 6 V0iX0dTr]S' "'ii avOpbiTTOl, OS t6 lpLV fXrfO-aTO,
StKaio)? hv KaAoiTO vvv 8e rjfxcls,

vtt6 vfxS>v EipipLrfs"'
ws ol6fX0a, KaAAcoTTiôires t6 ovofia " 'Epfxrjv " Ka\ovfXv.
[Kal if ye 'Ipts aTro tov LpLV 0LKV KK\r]fXvr], otl
5 ayy\os -qv.]
EPM. Nr] t6v Ata, v apa fxoL 8oKet KpaTv\o9 \yLV t6

fx^ fiLr] etyat 'F,pfxoyvr]' ovkovv Vfxr]xav6s ye' et/xt Aoyou.
212. Kat t6 ye t6v Flaya tov 'Eppiov clvat v6v bL(pvfj
e;(et t6 lk6s, co eratpe.
c EPM. Um br];
212. Oto-â ori 6 Ao'yos to ttclv a~r]p.a[vL kol kvk\i Ka\
TToAet det, Kat eo-rt 8t7rAou5, a\r]dr]s re KOt xlfevbrjs.
EPM. Udw ye.
5 212. OvKovv t6 fxV oATjê? avTov Aetor Kat êtoi; koi

uvoi oIkovv v rois 0eot?, t6 8e \l/vbos Karo) V tols TroAAots
T&v avBp(i>iT(tiv KaX Tpayy koll TpaytK^v ivTavOa yap TrAcioToi

Ot fXvdoL T Ka\ TCL \j/vbr] (TTLV, 1Tp\ t6v TpayLK^V ^LOV,
EPM. Uavv ye.
10 212. ÔpdSiS ap' (hvy 6 iTav fxr]vv(X)V Kot dei TroAcii'
d " riay aZTro'Aoy " eir/, 8t<î;^s 'Epfxov v6s, to. fxkv av(o0V
Aeto?, TOL 8e KdT(a0v Tpaxys Ka\ rpayoeiS^s. Kat eo-rtv
7/rot Ao'yos r; Ao'yov d8eA<ôs 6 Yldv, eiirep 'Epfxov v6s
a6 5i om. T rh . . . &"] tXpnv secl. Cornarius b^ #tal

. .bs ^K secl.
. Heindorf b6 rb] rhy Schanz b8 uhr\
vihv B hvT : c 10 &!> add. Stallbaum
KPATTA02 4o8d
fO-TLV abX(f)Q> 8^ OiKi.vaL abekipbv ovbev 6av\ia(TT6v. dXA'

oTrep eyo) eK^yov, 2> \iaKapie, cmakXayiayLev ex tG)V deoiv. 5
EPM. Tu>v ye tolovt(j)v, u) Sco/cpares', d j3ov\l. irepl
Tciiy rotwySe 8e 7-1 o-e KcoAvet 8ieA.êty, otoy Âtou re xal

(TeXi^vris Kal a^TTpcov Kal yfjs kol alOipos Kal aepos Kal TTvpos
Kal vbaTos Kal cop&v Kal fVLavTov; e
2f2. '2vxva fxev fxoL irpocrTiXTTeLS, ojxcos 8e', etTrep o-ot
KiyapL(TpLivov i(TTaL, ideXct).

EPM. Kai fxi]v x^P^-V'
SH. Tt brj ovv TTpS^TOV ôvkeL; 7/ axnrep etTre? tov 5
iJKlov 8te'A^to)u,er;
EPM. Udw yc.

2X2. "EoiKe rotiwi' Kard8TjA.oy ycvopLcvov av ixaXkov
T<L AcoptKw ris ovofxaTL XP'?^^ " dAtor " yap Kakov(TLV ol
et
409
AiopLTfs
"oAtoy" ovv et?} fiev dy Kard rd dAtêiy ets
TavTov Tovs av9p(aTTovs TTLbav drareiAr/, etJ/ 8' av Kal roi irepl
Tifv yfjv det etAety tcor, koLKOL 8' dr Kai ort TiOLKCWcL mv tcl
yLyvopieva eK r7/y y^s* rd 8e TroiKiAAeti' Kot atoAetv TavTov. 5
EPM. Tt 8e rj
" (Tekrivrf ";
2X2. ToCro 8e rd ovop.a âirerai tov Âvaâyopav irte^êw'.
EPM. Tt^Tj;
2X2. 'EotKe 8rjAowrt irakaLOTepov o CKelvos veioaTL ekeyev,
OTL rj (Tekrjvr] 0.1:0 tov rjkCov \eL to (f)C)s. b
EPM. n<Ss bri;
2X2. Td fxev ttov " crikas " Kat rd " ^S)s " TavTov.
EPM. Nai.
2X2. Ne'oir 8e ttoi; Kai evov det (Ttl Trepi rr/y crek-qvrjv 5
TOVTO t6 </>&)?, etTrep akridrj ol ÂvaôyopeLOL keyov^TLV kvkAo)
yap TTov det avTi]v TTepLLcbv veov dei e7rt/3dAAet, evov bk
V1Tap\L TO Tov TTpoTepov firjvos,
EPM. Udw ye.
d. 7 Tir TOJwj^Se 5e] tj' TojwvSe B : t' Toiovrw' 5e T : Se ruv toiovtuv G

KoiKvd o-e T aa &J' om. B a^ tl\e7v T eoiwe G
a9 ST)A.ot;;'Tt Heusde : Sri\ovv rt BT b5 evov T
PLATO, VOL. I. J4
409 b nAATHNOS
lo 2f2. " êXavaCav" bi ye KaXovakv avnjv ttoXXoC,
EPM, rrain; ye,

Sfi. "On 8e (riKa^ viov xai (ivov t\eL aeC, " êKaevo-
C veodei.a " fxev Si/caiorar' av [rwr] dyo^rtav KaA.oiro, (ruyKe-
KpoTr]ixevov he " ScAaraia " KeKkrjTai..

EPM, AL6vpafi(3u>bes ye tovtto Tovvofxa, S 1,(oKpaTes.
aWa Tov jxrjva Kal to. aa-Tpa Trais \eyeis;

5 212. *0 /xev " fxels
" diro rou fxeiova-dai. etTj &r " fieCrjs"
5' **
dp6G)S KeKkr]p.evoSf tol fiorpa " (oiKe tt/s aa-TpaTrfjs
eiTaiVVixCav e^êiv. fj be " dcrTpaTrfi" ori ra oiTia dva-
a-Tpe(\>ei, " dvaarpuiTir] " dv ctr;, vw 5 " darpain]
" KaA-
AtriTrio-êro-a KeK\j]Tac.
lo EPM. Tr 8^ ro TTvp Kal to vbcap;

d 212. To "TTvp" dTTopG)' Koi Kivbvvevei rJTOi 7} Tov KvOv-
(}>pov6s fxe ]xov(ra cTTiAeAotTreVat, r] tovto n TrayxdAf Tror elvai.
a-Keyf/aL ovv rjv eWdyfa p.r]yavr]V Ittl TrdvTa tcl TOLavra h dv
UTTopci.
5 EPM. Ttm brj;
2X2. 'Eyci^ rot ^pw. dTroKptrat ydp iioi' Ix*"'^ ^" eliTeiv
TTvp KaTa tCvu TpoTTOv KoAftrat;

EPM. Ma At" ovK eyuiye,
212. 2Kei/rat br] o eyo) vTTOTrrevui TrepX avrov. ivvoH yap
e ort TroAAa ot "EAArjres ovofxaTa oAAojs re Kai ot vtto tols
l3apj3dpoLS olKOvvTes iTapd tQv jiap^dpuiV eLKr](â(TLV.
EPM. T^ olv br];
212. Ei rts C'?'"^' ravTa KaTa Tr]v 'EAAr/ytKrjr (f)(tivr]V w?

5 elKoTOis Kftrat, dAAa /X7/ Kar' eKeCvr]v e^ rjs t6 ovofxa rvyxdveL
ov, oXa-Oa OTL diTopoi &v.
EPM. EtKoVtos ye.

410 212. "Opa rotrw koi tovto t6 ovofxa t6 " irvp " ]xr] tl
âplSapLKov rj. tovto yap ovt pqbLov npoa^d^âL ecrrij'
b 12 KolT T ffol T atXatvovtoifia Heindorf atKatvvtoana B

: :
Watvvtoitia T
(Tf C i rwv seclusi koXoIto riiv dvofidraiv pr. F
C3 7] 8^ 7f T cio Tf KcdT 67 ioiKirtts B
KPATTAOS 410 a
ÊXXrjviKr} (fxavrj, (f)avpoi t da-lv ovrcos avrb KakovvTS

4>pvyes (TfxiKpov tl TrapaKkivovTes' Kal to ye " vb(ap " Kal
TCLs " Kvvas " Kal akXa TroAAd. 5
EPM. "EoTi TavTa.

212. Ov Toiwv 8et raOra 7rpoo-/3idêa-0at, eTret tyoi y av
TIS dTTelv TTpl aVTtiiV. TO p.\v OVV TTVp Kal TO vbuip TaVTT]
aTTU)dovp.aL' 6 8e 8/; ai]p apd ye, S) 'EpjJLoyeves, otl atp(L b
To. d-Tro TTJs yrjs, " di]p " KeKkrjTaL; r) otl dtt pet; 77 ort
TTViVfxa e^ avTov yiyveTaL peovTos; ol ydp TroLr^Tai irov rd

TTvevp.aTa " dr]Tas " KaAoCo-ti;* to-a)s ovv Xiy^L, coo-Trep dv et
etTTOt TiVivp.aToppovv, " dr^Toppovv" [oOev bi] jSovXcTaL avTov 5
ovTOiS etTTety, ort ka-TLV dr]p\ Tov h\ alOepa Trjbe irr] vtto-
Xa^x^dvoi, OTL det êt Trepi tov dipa p4o>v " dcLder^p" bLKaioos
dv KaXolTO. yrj 8e [MdXXov a-r]]xaiveL o jSovXeTaL idv tls
" yalav" 6vo]xdarr]' yaXa ydp yVvr]T(Lpa dv etr/ dpdG>s c

KKXr]]xivr], u>s (^râ^LV "O/xrjpos" to ydp " yeydaaLV " yeyev-
vrjaOaL Ae'yet. etei'' rt ovv rj]xXv 7]^ to /xerd tovto;

EPM. îlpaL, S) ^coKpaTes, Kal (VLavTos Kal (tos.
212. At ]XV br] (apai 'Arrt/cto-ri b)S to TTaXaLOV pr]T(0V, 5
eiTrep jBovXeL t6 (Ikos dbivaL' HOPAI ydp eto-t 8td rd
opi^cLV xeL]X(avds re Kat êp?; Kai iTvevpiaTa Kal tovs KapiTovs
Tovs eK r^s yrjs' opiôvaaL 8e biKaicas dv " opaL " KaAoti^ro.
eytairrds 8e Kai iTOS KLvbvvtv^L iv tl eTvai. to ydp rd d
(f)v6]xeva Kal rd yLyv6]Xva iv ]xipL eKaaTov nrpodyov ets
<f)S)S KaX avTo kv avT(o êTdQ)v, tovto, c5o-7rep (V toIs

TTpoadev To Tov Alos dvo]xa bi\a birjprj^x^vov oi ]XV Zrjva,
oi 8e Ata Kat evTavda ot ]xev " evLavTov,"
eKaAoDz^, ovroj 5
ort iv kavTS), oi 8e " Tos," otl erdêt* 6 8e oAos Adyo?
eoTti; rd " iv kavTSi eTaôv " tovto TTpoaayop(V(adaL ev dv
bi\a, u>aT bvo 6v6]xaTa yeyovevai, " ivLavTdv " re Kai

Tos, e^ ivos Xoyov. e
b I 5^ G : om. B T b5 oOfv . b 6 aip secl. Heindorf

. .
b7 pfuv secl. Schanz C2 ytyfvriadai T: an yfyevvriVTai]

C8 wpaiT d.4 ffjiirpoffdfv G d. 7 Tovro {Se) Stallbaum
14*
;
4ioe nAATI2N02
EPM. 'AXAa brJTa, oj ^(aKpares, ttoXv linSiSajs.
212. Hoppo) ijbr] o^fxai (f)aivofxai (TO(f)ias (Kavveiv.
EPM. ndvv nv ovv.

5 2i2. Taxa [xakXov (f)-q(Tis.
411 EPM. 'AAAa /xcra touto t6 cTSos cycaye rjbccoi h.v
6ea(TaLfxr]v ravra to, Kaka dvofxaTa rCvi ttot^ opOoTrjTi

Ketrat, ra Trepl r^y apenjv, olov " (f)p6vr](rCs " re Kot
" o-vrco-is " Kal " bLKai.ocrvvr] " koI rSAAa tcl TOLavTa iravTa.
5 2X2. 'Eyeipeis /leV, a> (Talpf, ov (f>av\ov yivos dvofxaTiov'

o(X(ji)9 be e7rei8r/7rep r^y Aeoyr^v ivb^bvKa, ovk a-nobHkLaTiov
dAA* ^7rto"Ke7rre'or, o)? ôlkc, (f>p6vr](rLV Kal (rvv((rLV Kal
yv(afxr]v Kal TTL(rrqjxr]v /cai raAAa 8^ h (f^rjs irdjrra Tavra to,
b KaAa dvofxaTa.
EPM. Tldvv jxev ovv ov bel T]]xa9 TrpoaTTOOTrjvaL.
212. Kai ]xr]v, vrj tov Kvva, boKU) yk jxol ov KaKois

txavTev(rdaL, o Kal vvvbi] (vev6r](ra, otl ol Traw TraAatot
6 6.vdp(i)TT0i ol TLOefxevoL TCL 6v6[xaTa TravTos fxdkkov, uxTTTep

Kal tS)V VVV OL TToWol tS)V (TO(f)S)V VTTO TOV TTVKvd TTfpL-
(rTpe(f)e(T6aL ^rjTovvrcs oiTrj exei Ta ovTa ciKLyyLoi^rLV, fca^reira
ovrots (f)aCvTaL iTpL(f)p(r6aL Ta TTpdyfxaTa Kal Trdrrws

C (f)ep(TdaL. aJrtwrrat 8?/ ov to vbov to iTapa (T(f)C(TLV TTa6oi
oCtlov eirat TavTr]^ Trj^ b6^r]s, oAAa avra Ta iTpdyfxaTa

ovTo) TT(f)VKevaL, ovbev avToiv jxovLfxov etmi ov8c jSfjSaLov,
dXXa pelv kol (f)ip(r6aL Kal fxfcTTa eimt 7rd<r7js (f>opds kol
5 ycfcVcajs dei. Acyo) 8?) ivvor](Tas iTpos iTdirra rd wvbij

dvdfxara.
EPM. riais 8^ TovTo, 0) 2<oKparcs;
212. Ov KaTv6rt(Tas l(to)s rd dpri \y6fXva otl Trairrd-
TTatTLV O)? (f>pOfXVOLS T KOL pOV(TL Kal yLyVOfXVOL% TOIS

10 7Tpdyfxa(TL tol ovdfxaTa cTriKetrat,
EPM. Ov TTdw V6vfxr]6r]V,
63 <J5rj otfiai B
(paivo/xai : fjSr] (paiyofiai W; 8i oljxcu T 65 ^f,(r(is B
i(pi)(T(is T b 7 oma afl tiKiYyiiîri T C 5 5^ T : S^ B
G
KPATTA02 4"d
211. Kal ni]V TTpS)Tov ixev tovto o irpCiTov eiTro/xei^ d

TTavTaTTacnv ws k-nl toiovtiov eortr.
EPM. To TTolov;
212. *H " (pp6vr](ns"' (popasydp eo-rt Ka\ pov vorjcrLS.
ctrj 8'av Kal ovr](TCV v-noXaêiv (popas' oAA' ovv irept ye 5
To (f)pa-daC ea-TLV. d be (Sovkei., 7] " yyw/177 " TTavTaTraa-Lv

br)XoL yovrjs (XKe^LV Ka\ v(li>p.ri(TLV' to yap " vuiiMV
"
KOL To " o-KOTTeiy " TavTov. et 8e /3ovAei, avro 17 " vorja-is
Tou veoy eoTtv eo-is, t6 8e ve'a etyat tcl ovra aijpLaLvei
yLyv6p.va det etvaf tovtov ovv ((pUadaL "^fvxw P-Vvv^'- ^

Tr]v
To ovopLa 6 diJ.Vos rrjv " veêaLV." ov yap " v6r]a-LS " to

apxalov eKaAetTO, dAA' drrt tov T/ra et eSet XeycLV bvo,
" vo(rLV." " (r(i)(f)poa-vvr]" 8e cr(>)Tr]pLa ov vvvbi] la-Ki]x-
liÔa, (f)povr]a-0)s. Kal jxqv rj ye emo-TTj/iTj ]xr]vveL ws 412

({)po]xivoLS Tols TTpayfxaa-LV eiTOixivr^s Trjs ^j/vxn^ rrjs l^Cas
X6yov, Kal ovT aTTokLTTOfXvr]s ovT TTpo6Ova-r]S' 8to brj
ixl3akkovTas 8et t6 et " TT'La-Tr]]xr]v " avrijv ovoixaC^LV.

" (rvva-LS " 8' av ovto) }XV b6^LV av u>a-7Tp a-vkkoyL(T- 5
ixos eirat, oTav 8e crvvLvaL kiyr], TavTov iTavTaTTaaLV rai
TTLcrTaa6aL avixâiveL ky6p.vov a-vp.TTopVcr6aL yap Aeyei

Tr]V ylrvxh^ "^^^^ TTpayp.aa-L t6 " avvLvaL." akka p.r]V 7/ ye b
" (ro(f)La
" (f)opas (f)dTTTa-6aL crr]ixaLVL. aKOTcobicrTepov 8e
rovro Kat êvLKcoT^pov dkka 8et K T(i)V ttoltitG^v dvap.Lixvr]-
a-Ka-6aL otl otov av TvxcoaLV tG)V

TTokXaxov kiyovaLV Trept
dpxoixV(i)v Taxv TTpdUvaL

" kavdr] " (paaiv. AaKO)VLKbo 8e 5
dz^Spt tS)V vboKLixo)V Kal ovoixa r]v "'2ovs"' rqv yap Taxâv
6pixr]V 01 AaKeSat/xoytot rovro KokovaLV. TavTr]s ovv Trjs
(fiopds TTa(f)r]v ar][xaLVL r] ao(f>La, o)? (f>poixV(t)V TOJv ovto)v.
Kal ixr]v To ye " dya66v," tovto Trjs (f)va0)s TTaarjS rw c

dyaaT(D /3ovAerat t6 ovop.a e-rrtKeto-ât. e77et8T/ yap TTopV-
erat tcl ovTa, vl ixkv dp avTols Taxos, ivL 8e /3pa8i;rr/s.
e4 voffcriv G : veoecnv BT a4 iK$a.\KovrfS al. 5? om. G

fir(i(TTi\ixi)v Heindorf: îrKrr^yUTji' BT : iritTT^j/nT;' a6 \fyr}rat
Heindorf b5 AaKwviKif . . . b 7 KaXoviriv secl. Heindorf
412 c riAATilNOS
icTTiv ovv ov TTav To Ta)(y aWa tI avrov iyaaTov. tov
6 Ooov bt] TO) ayacTTia avTt] 7] iiTOiivvixCa koTiv, " TayaOov"
" AiKaLoa-vvri " 8e, otl fjikv iirl tt) tov bcKalov (Tvvead
TOVTO KiLTai To ovofxa, pabtov cTvixliaXfLV' avTo bf. to "bCKaLov"
XakciTov. Kal yap 87) Kal eoi/ce y^XP*- M^^ '''O^ o/uoAoyeto-âi
d napa iToXXSiV, iireLTa be ap.(f)La-j3riTiLa-6aL. oa-OL yap riyovvTat
To TTav elvaL iv iTopfCa, to fjiv ttoKv avTov VTToXap.âvova-LV
TOLovTov TL cLvaL oLov ovbev oAAo 7] xiopelv, 8ia be tovtov
TTavTos (LvaC TL bif^Lov, 8t' ov TTdvTa TCL yLyvojxeva yCyvea-daL'

5 cTvaL be Taxîoror tovto Kal X.TTT6TaTov. ov yap hv bvva-
adaL aAAco? 8ia tov ovtos UvaL iTavTos, ci fxr} XfiTTOTaTov
T ^v u>a-T avTO ixrjbev oreyeLV, kol Tax^Lo-Tov u>a-T XPW^^'-
&a"!Tep fOT&aL tols oAAois. CTrel 8' ovv iiTLTpoiTeveL tcl
e aAAa TTdirra bLaCov, tovto t6 ovoixa eKX^dr] 6pd<as "bCKaLov,"

(va-ToixCas eveKa ttiv tov KdinTa bvvaixiv iTpoa-Xa^^v. ixiy^pL
fxkv ovv kvTavOa, h wvbri iXeyoixcv, Trapa iroXXoiV OfxoXo-

413 yeLTaL tovto (TvaL to bCKaLov iyo) 8e, w 'Epix6yevS, aT
AiTrapTJs wv iT^pX avTov, TavTa ixev iTavTa bLaTTfTTvaixaL (v
CLTTOpprJTOLS, OTL TOVTO ioTL TO bCKaLOV Kal TO aLTLOV 8l' O
yap yCyviTaL, tovt iaTL to oCtlov

xai " Aia " KaXiiv i<^ri
5 TLS ToxTTo 6p6S)<5 yLV 8ia TavTa. iiTfLbav 8' ripifxa avrovs
iTTavpuiT<a dKOva-as Tavra fxribcv rJTTov " Ti ovv ttot taTLV,
S) dpLaT, bCKaLov, l TOVTO ovToos fX^'>" ôkQ T ijbri
IxaKpoT^pa Tov iTpoa-riKOVTOS ipuiTdv Kal viTp Ta iaKaixixiva

b aAAeo-âi. iKav&s ydp fxi (\>aaL TTTrva-6aL [aKT/KoeWij Kal
iTTL\Lpova-LV, l3ovX6ixvoL aTTOTTLixTTXdvaL /16, ÂAos aAAa Tjbri
XyLV, KOL ovKTL avixcfxjiiVOva-LV. 6 ixV yap tCs (ftrjaLV tovto
eTvaL bCKaLov, tov ijXLov tovtov ydp fxovov biaLdvTa Koi

5 KdoVTa iTTLTpOTTVLV Ta OVTa. iTTLbdv OVV T<i) Xiyoi aVTO
C4 Tov 0OOV Baiter (coll. 4223) : toCto o5 BT da ^y iroptia

liber Bessarionis : (viropla B : fvwopla. T d6 6vtos B T (cf. 41 7 c) :
l6vTos al. d.7 /i7)5^ B d8 icrTQis T a^ ylyvtToi

^Tt) Stallbaum Aia Hermann : /5io BT a^ t^ SlKaiov G
a8 iffKf/jifitva B bI OKfiKOfvat del. Schanz : col iucriKof vai vulg.
KPATYA02 4i3b
a(rixVos w? KaXov tl aKr\Kom, KarayeXa {xov ovtos aKovcras

Koi (poora d ovbev bUaiov otfxai etvai ev tois avdpooTTois CTret-
bav 6 T/'Aios bm]. knrapovvTos ovv p.ov otl av cKetro? Aeyei c

avTo, To TTvp (f>r]a-LV' tovto be ov pabLov ea-TLV cibevaL. 6 b
ovK avTo t6 irvp (j)r]a-LV, aXJCavrb t6 Oepp-ov t6 ev ro) TTvpl (vov.
6 8e TOVToav jjikv TrdvTCtiV KaTayekav (prjcrLV, eLvaL 8e to bLKaLov
6 XiyeL 'Avaâyopas, vovv (TvaL tovto' avTOKpaTopa yap 5
avT6v ovTa Kal ovbevl p.epLeLyixevov TrdvTa <f)r](rlv avrov koct-
pelv To. TTpdyfxaTa 8ta ttcivtoov lovTa. ivTavOa bi] eyw, S </)L\e,
TToAi; ev TTkeiovL diTopLCL eijxl rj TrpXv kiTL\eLpricraL p.av6dveLV
TTepX Tov biKaiov otl ttot ecjTLV, dAA' ovv oviTep evcKa ecTKo- d
TTovp.ev, t6 ye ovopa tovto cpaLveTaL avT(a 8ta raDra KelcrdaL.
EPM. 4>atV?/ fxot, S '2i(aKpaTes, ravrra \xev aKrjKoevaL tov
Kal ovK avToaxebLdêLV.
212. Tt 8e ToAAa; 5
EPM. Ov TTdw.
212. 'AKoue Stj" Xcrois yap av cre Kat tcl eTriXonra eâTrar?/-
o-at/xt ajs ovK aKrjKooos Xeyco. jxeTCL yap bLKaLoa-vvqv tl fjpLLV
keCeTaL; dvbpeCav o7p.aL ov-ttco bLi]k6opev. d8tKta p.ev yap

SÂoj; ort eo-rii' ovtos epLTTobLafxa tov bLaXovTos, dvbpeCa be e
crrjpaCveL o)s ev /^dx?/ eTTOvopa(opevr]s tt/? dvbpeCas P-dxV^
8' etrat ev T(o ovtl, eXiTep pel, ovk dkko tl t/ tt/i' evavTLav
poriv eav ovv tls eêkr] t6 8e'Ara tov ovopaTos tt/s dvbpeCas,
avTO p.r]vveL t6 epyov t6 6vop.a r]
" dvpeCa." brjkov ovv otl 5
ov TTaa-r] porj rj evavTCa poi] dvbpeCa eaTCv, dkka Trj Trapd

TO biKaLov peovar]' ov ydp av eirqveZTO rj dvbpeCa. Kal t6 4H
" appev '
Kat 6 " dvi]p '
eTrt irapaTTkrjaCio tlvl tovt(o ecTTi,
Trj dv(o pofj. "yvvi]" be yovr] p.0L (f)aCveTaL (BovkeadaL

etmi. t6 be " drjkv" diT^ Trjs 6r]kj]s tl (f>aCveTaL eiToovo-
p.dcr6aL' rj be " 6r]kr] " dpd ye, S) 'F,pp.6yevS, ort Tedr]kevaL 5
TTotet a^cTTTep Ta dpbojxeva;
b6 ovTos 6 a.Kov<ras T ei Swjj B ei ovtos BT: tii^Ttiis
liber Bessarionis e 5 dvpeia T : aySpeia B

414 a riAATiiNOS
EPM. "EoiK^v ye, a> 2coKpares.
212. Kai firjv avTo ye to " ôXAeiv " rrjv av^v fxoi boKti
aireiKdCeiv tt]v rwv veuiv, ort rax^cia Kal âi(f)vib(a yCyveTai.
b olovTTep ovv fJ.efJLiixr]Tat, T(o 6v6[xaTi, avvapfi6(ras aTTO tov

Oelv Kal &Wecrdai to ovop.a. dA.A' ov yap CTrKrKOTrets pe
uicnrep eKTos bpofxov (f>ep6fj.evov eTreibav keiov emAd^co/iiaf
eTiikoma he Tjp.lv eri a~v)(va tQv boKovvT(t)v aTTovbaiuiV etvai,.
5 . EPM. 'AAtj^^ keyets.

212. *X2y y ea-TLV ^v Kal " Teyvrjv " IbeXv ori Trore
ôvkeTai elvai.
EPM. Udw /x^y ovv.
212. OvKovv tovt6 ye eîv vov (Trip.aivei, to p.ev Tav

C a(f>ek6vTi, epl3ak6vTi, be ov pieTa^v tov xt 'fcit iôv vv Kal (jov
vv Kaiy Tov -^Ta;
EPM. Kal pidka ye ykia")(poos, S 2wK/jarcy.
212. '12 p.aKdpLe, ovk oTcrd^ oti. to. Trpwra dv6p.aTa reOevra
5 KaraKe'xa)OTai 7/817 '^'^^ "^^^ Povkop.ev(tiv rpaywSeiv avTa,
TTepLTtdevTOiiv ypdppaTa Kal eâipovvTOiV evcrTop.ias eveKa Kal
TtavTa^T] (rTpe(f)6vTCi)V, Kat vtto Kakk(ji)7Tta-p.ov Kat vtto yjpovov.
eiTeX ev rw " KaroTrrpo) " ov boKel [o-oi] dToiTov elvat to ^/x/3e-
fikrjaOat t6 pQ; dkka TotavTa oi/xai TroioSo-ir 01 ttjs pev
d dATjêias ovbev (^povTiôvTes, ro b\ (rTopLa TTkaTTOVTes, coor'
eTTep[3dkkovTes TroAAa em rd TTpG)Ta ovdpaTa reAevrcSrres
TrotoCo-iv p.riK av evaavveXvat ori Trore /3ouAerai
dvOp(i!>TT(ov
"
To ovop.a' &(nrep Koi ttjv ^(f)iyya dvTl " (fîKos " " a-(f)iyya
5 KoAovoîy, Kal dkXa TroAAd.
EPM. Taura pev ea-Ttv ovT(t)S, S) 2coK/5are?.
2X2. Et 8' av tls edcrei Kai evTtOevat koI eâipeiv &tt'

av jSovkrjTai Tts els tcl ovdpaTa, TroAAj; evrropia earai Kai
TTav av TTavTi tls ovopa TTpdyparL TTpoaappoaeLev.
b4 iiriKoiira . . . crux"^ scrip&i \oiiri : avxv^ . . . irel BT (fVl om.

al. : ^ffT vulg.) Ci ToC vC cal add. Stephanus c8 ^tl] iird
KolG (Toiom. B d3 HvdpuirovB d^ rb tfiô/ta sccl. Schanz
<f>iKds al. cum Hesiodo : ff<f>iyyhs B : <fnyhs T
KPATTA02 414 e
EPM. 'A\rj6ij Xiyeis. e

212. ÂXrjOij fxivTOi. aXXa rb jxhpiov oXixai hd <jiv\dmt.v
Kal t6 eiKos' (re tov crocpov (TncrTaTqv,
EPM. BovXoLiJLrjv av.
212. Kat iyat (tol <rvixj3ovXo[jiai, a> 'Epfi6yV9. aXXa fxi] 5
Xiav, S) baifxovLe, aKpiôXoyov, 4^5
" fxrj }x atToyviuxrrjs /Aereos.**
ipyo}xai yap cttI tt/v Kopv(f)r]V <av etpr]Ka, kireLbav fxeTa
T^xvrfv ixrfxavrjv TTL(TKe-û)ixe6a. " fxrixavr]

" ydp {xol boKel
Tov avcLV iirl ttoXu <rr]fxeLov cimi* to yap " fxifKos" ttoos 5
To TToXv <rrifxaLVL' ef dfX(f)0LV ovv tovtolv avyKLTaL,

" fxrfKovs " re Kal tov " dvLV," to ovofxa rj
" fxrfyavrf."
dXX', OTrep wvbrf (xttov, liil rifv Kopv(f)r]v bei tG)V ilprffxiva^v
X6LV' " dpeTTf " yap Kal " KaKLa" otl jBovXeTaL Ta ovofxaTa
^rfTTfTia. TO fXV OVV TpOV OVTTOO Ka6op<0, t6 6' Tp0V b
So/cei [xoL KaTabrfXov eimi. <rvfx<f)(i)VL ydp rot? pLTTpo<r6v
TTd<rLV. dT ydp 16vt(dv t<j)V TrpayfxaTcov, TTav t6 KaKois
I6v " KaKLa" dv eiJj" tovto 8e OTav kv V^xf/ V> "^^ KaK&s
UvaL ttI Ta TTpdyfxaTa, fxdXLCTTa rffv tov oXov ciToovvfXLav 5
exet Trjs KaKLas. t6 Se KaK&s Uvai otl ttot <ttlv, boKL
fxoL brfXovv Kal v Trj " 8etAta," o ovtto) bLr]X6ofXV dXX'
vTTp^rffXV, biov avT6 fXTd Tr]v dvbpLav <rKyl/a<r6aL' c
boKovfXv 8e juot kol dXXa TToXXd vTTp^J3r]KvaL. rj 8' ovv
8eiAta Trjs \lfvy^rjs (rr]fxaLVL bcrfx6v ^XvaL i<r)(yp6v t6 ydp
" XCav" i<rxvs tls <rTLV. b(rfx6s ovv 6 Aiai' kox 6 fiyL(rTos
TTJs ^XV^ V SetXia dv Lrf w(nTp ye Kal rf diTOpLa KaKov, 5
Kat TTaV, 0)S OLKV, OTL dv fX7Toboi)V f/ tS) UvaL KoX 7TOpV(r6aL.
TOVT ovv <f)aLVTaL t6 KaKcos leVai brfXovv, t6 i(TxofJi.vo)s re

Kat fnTobLôfXvot)s TTopV(rdaL, 6 8^ '^XV oTav ^xjlt KaKLa
fX<rTi] yLyvTaL. et 8' e77t rotoj;rots 57 " KOKta " <rTlv
85 Tra-s] irpby RT 88 j/vj^Stj] S); vi)i' BT C5 /(o/C(5vB C6 77]

flVj B levaih: elvaiHT C "] Xcrxofâi SxTTeB c8 (KiroSiôfXfvws
B T, sed yu supra T 5?;] 5' ^ B c/cia TG : KOKia B : KOKiai vulg.
415 c IlAATllNOS
10 Tovvofia, Tovvavriov tovtov t)
" &pTr)" hv cir;, aTfixaivov "npSt-
d Tov fikv evTropiav, lirctra 8^ \e\vfjievriv tijv porjv Trjs ayaOijs
^XV^ firat aet, (oore t6 d<r;(rcos Kat to aKOi\vT(iiS

del pov eTrojvvfxiav (.Ikrfi^fv, wy (oi.k(, tovto Tovvofxa, ô^
opOSiS fJ.V (\t " a(i.p(iTr]v " KoXelv, [la-a>s be alp(Tr]v \ey(i,
5 U)S ov(rrfs Tavrtfs Trjs (^((os aipcrtordrTjs,] avyKiKporrfTai 8e
KoX KaXfXTai " apeTrj." Kal lcruis /xf av <^^(rfts TrAdTTftv
eyo) be ciTrep 6 ffjLTrpoa-dev (Tttov opOSrs X^'' " iio,Kio.t"
(l>r\fii, V
e Kat TovTO To ovofia Ti]V " apeTTfv " dpdHs Ixci'
416 EPM. To 8^ " KaKov," bi ov TroAAa Toiv Hfi-npoadev

eiprfKas, Ti hv vooZ Tovvofxa;
212. 'Aroirdy rt vi] Aia (fioiye boKel koI xaXenrbv <TVfi-
ISaXeiv. ^Trdyo) ovv koI TOVT(f kKeivrfv Tr]v firfyjxvrfv.
5 EPM. riotai; Tavrrjv;
212. Ti]v Tov jSapâpLKov ri koI tovto (frdvak ftvai.

EPM. Kat eoi,K(i.s ye opBws XeyovTt,. dAA' ci Sokci, raGra
fxev (Gifiev, to 8e " koXov " koX [roj " aiayjiov " Trei.pSip.eda
Ibelv 17?] evKoyuis x^^*
10 212. To fiikv Toivvv " ala")(pbv " Kat br] Kard8?jAdr ôi
b (âiviTaL h voeZ' Kat tovto yap rois IpiTTpoaOev 6fxo\oy(lTat.
t6 yap (piiTobiCov Kal iayov Trjs porjs to. ovTa koi.boplv /iot
(fiaiveTai 8td iTavTbs 6 rd 6v6fxaTa Tideis, Kal vvv roi dcl

lo-xoyrt Tbv povv tovto rb ovopM eOeTO (ro) " dfio-xo-
5 povv " vvv be avyKpoTTfcravTes " alay(jibv " KaA.ouatr.
EPM. Tt 8^ rd " KaAoV ";
212. ToCro yakeTT(!iTpov KaTavor]aai. Kairot Acyci ye
avT6' apfxovici piovov Kal /XT/Ket tov ov irapTjKTai.
EPM. USis bi];
10 212. Trjs btavoias ris eoiKer (iToivvfxia (Ivai. tovto rb

ovofxa.
d3 8rT
it\] h add. Heindorf d^ t(rus. d.$ oipfratrdiTiis . .
seclusi ds fffwi] A/{*a)y T a8 koi] t koJ T rh om. G

h^ rh add. Heindorf b 7 A*7i 7- B T Kfyovtri 7 G Ar/w, : :
tXyt Schanz b 8 post avr6 distinxi rov ou B : r6 TG

KPATTA02 4i6b
EPM. n&is Xeyeis,-

212. 4>epe, tC oUl crv etrat t6 alTLOV Kkr]6rjvaL kKd(TT(f c
T(av ovTOiv; ap ovk iKelvo t6 tcl ovoixaTa Oefxevov;
EPM. ndlTCOS TTOV.
212. OvKovv bLCLVOLa hv etr] tovto tjtol 6eS)V i] avdpcoTroiV
1] dp.(p6Tpa; 5
EPxM. Nat.
212. OvKovv t6 KaXicrav to. itpdyixaTa koX t6 koXovv
TavToy iCTTLV TOVTO, bLdvoLa;
EPM. 4>aii;erai.
212. OvKovv Kal o(ra p.ev av vovs re Kai 8idyota epyd- lo
cn]TaL, Tamd Icttl tcl e-Tratyerd, a 8e ]xr], \jr(KTa;
EPM. Udvv ye.

212. To ovv laTpLKov laTpLKCL (pyd(eTaL Kal t6 tKtovlk6v d
reKToytKd; tj irws Ae'yets;
EPM. OvT(os eyoiye.
212. Kat t6 koXovv dpa KoXd;
EPM. Aei ye rot. 5
212. 'Eo-rt bi ye tovto, c5s (f)afxev, dtdrota;

EPM. ndyu ye.
212. 'Op^w? dpa (f)poinj(roos avrrj ^ eTTOivvpLia eo-riy
ro " KaXoi' " T^y rd TOLaxrra diTepyaôixivr^s, a 8r) KaAd

(f)dcrKOVTes eiyat do-7ra{o/xeâ. lo
EPM. cJjatVerai.
212. Tt ovi' ert i^fxlv XotTroy rwy rotovroji';

EPM. TaCra rd Trept ro dya66v re Kai KaAoV, o-v/x-
(pepovTd re Kat ADO-treAowra Kat (t)<ê'Atju,a Kat Kepbakia Kal 4^7

TavavTLa TOVTOiv.
212. OvKoui' ro /xer " (Tvp.(ppov " ?)8?j ttou Kay o^ evpots
eK rojy TTp6Tpov eTTL(TK0TTS)V' Tr]s ycLp eTrto-TT/jUTjs d8eAô'y
c 5 afj.((>oTepwv T c 7 KaKovv Badham : KoXbv BT c ir &

Heindorf: to B T d.4 /coAoi)' scripsi
/coAJ^j/BT d.9 to
om. T e I 7]ix7v Tt T as Kor] /col B a^ irpoTcpaiv B
(TKOTrwv T
417 a nAATX2N02
5 Ti (f>aiveTai. ovbev yap &\Xo brjXoX ^ Tr]V &,fia <ôpav rrjs
"^XV^ fjtcTa tHv npayp.aTUiv, koL to. vtto tov toiovtov TtpaT-
Toftcra " (rvfJi(f>epovTa " t xat " (rup.<\)opa " *ceKA^(r0at OTio
Tov (rvpLTTfpi(j)p((r6ai eoiKe, t6 be ye " KepbaXeov " Sltto tov

b Kpbovs. " Kepbos " be vv clvtI tov bekTa aTTobibovTi i$ to
ovop.a brjXol o ôvkeTai' to yap ayadbv Kar &Wov TpoiTov
ovop.6.^n. OTi yap KepdvvvTai, is TTavTa Sie^toV, Tavrqv
avTov Trjv bvvapnv CTToro/xa^cov e6(T0 TOvvop.a' 8eA.TO <(8')
5 (v6fls clvtI tov vv " Kfpbos " e(f)6eyâT0.
EPM. " Avo-tTfAow " 8e ti 8t);
212. EoLKev, Si 'Epftoyeves, ov)(l Ka6aiT(p ol K&.irrjXQL
airrSt \pS)VTai, eav to av6.\(p.a dirokvr], ov Tavrq keyeiv

C /xoi boKei To " AvcrtTeAow," dAA' OTt Td)(^t(rTOV 6v tov ovtos
X(TTa(T6aL ovK efi to. iTpdypiaTa, ovbe Tekos kaôv(rav Tr]v
ôpdv Tov (f)epa-daL aTrjva[ Te /cat TTav(ra(r6ai, dAA' dei

Auei avTTJs dv ti (TTixeipfj Tekos iyyCyve(r6ai, Kal 7rape'x<t
5 aiTava-Tov Kal d6dvaTov avrriv, TavTrj p.oL boKei eTTL^r]p,LaaL.
To dya6ov kva-LTekovv to ydp Trjs (f)opds kvov to T^kos
" kva-LTekovv " xaAeVat. " d>(f)4kLfxov " be êvLKov Tovvo\xa,
<j) xat Op.r]pos TTokkayov Ke\pr]TaL, tw " d<f)ekXeLV " ItrTt
b\ TOVTO Tov avêLV Kal fiTOkeLV eTrcoyu/uia.
d EPM. Ta be br] tovto)V ivavTia irciis Ix^' VH-^^>

212. "Oo-a ijiev diT6(f)r]a-LV avTQv, a>s yi /xoi SoKei, ov6ei'
8et Tama bLe^Levai.
EPM. riota TavTa;

"
5 2f2. " ' Aavpi(f)opov " Kal " dvaxpekes " Kai " dAro-iTeAey
Kat aKepoes.
EPM. 'Akr]6r] keyeLS.
2i2. 'AAAa " J3kal3ep6v " ye /cai " ^TjftioiSes."
EPM. Nat'.
10 212. Kai To p.ev ye " j3kal3ep6v" t6 j3kdTTTov t6v
a8 foiKt TW : om. B b4 5' acld. Bekker c 7 KoXtffot secl.

Schanz c8 ii<f>t\t'ivT C9 irotcii'] irA/oc irotcii' Orelli : "Wiai-
ytty vel irtWa irotcti' Heindorf
KPATTAOS 417 e
povv etvat Xeyer to 8e " /3Aairroy " av crr^fxaivei jBovXo- e

fXvov aiTTei.v to 8e " S.TTTeLV " Kal heiv TavTov eort, rovro
be TiavTaxov yîyî. to ôvkoixevov ovv aTrrety povv
opOoTaTa p.V av " (BovX.aTrrepovv"
eXrj KoXkcaTncrOiv 8e
KaAeio-ât juot âtrerai " jSXajBepov." 5
EPM. riotKtXa ye a-oi, &> 2wKpare?, K(3aLVi, to. 6v6p.aTa.
KoX yap vvv p.01. eboâs uxnrep tov ttjs 'A^rymay v6\xov
TTpoavXtov (rTop.avXri(Tai, tovto to 6vop.a TTpoenrMV t6
" âvkaimpovv." 418
20. OvK eyw, S *Ep/xoyeves, atrto?, dAA' ot 6ip.ivoi
To ovop.a.
EPM. ÂXr]6rj Aeyet?* dXAa 5^ to "^Tj/bitwSe?" rt &y eiT/;
2X2. Tt 8' hv etrj irore " ^rj/xiwSe?"; ddaa-ai, S> 'Epjixo- 5
yere?, o)? eycb a\r]6rj Ae'yco Xeycov ort TTpoan-tdivTes ypap.p.aTa

Kttt eâipovvTes a-(f)6bpa dAAotoCo-t rds roiy dvojLidrcoy Stayota?,
ovro)? wo-re crp.iKpa tt<xvv TTapaa-Tpe(f)ovTs kvioTe TavavTia

TTOieiv ar}'fXaiveiv. olov Kal kv rw " hiovTL " kvev6r]a-a yap b
avro Kat avep.vrj(T6r]v dprt dTrd roOSe 6 l/ueAAdy o-oi epety dri
^ ju.ei' vea (f)a)vr] rjfxlv rj KaXr] avrql Kal Tovvavriov Trept-

(Tpeyf/e p.r]vveiv to " 8e'or " Kat to " ^?7juta)8es," a(f)aviôvaa
oTi voi, 7] 8e TraAatd aix(f)6Tpov Sr/Aoi d jSovAerai Tovvoixa. 5
EPM. n<Ss Aeyets;
2X2. Eyw oôt epw. oto-â drt ot TraAatot ot rjfxeTepoi
TU) lti)Ta Kal tS> 5e'Ara ev ]xa\a k\pG)VTo, koX ov\ rJKia^Ta
ai yumtKes, atTrep ixakLcrTa ri]v apyaiav (f)(ovr]v aioCovai. c
vvv de dyri fxev tov t(3ra 7) et ^ r/ra ixeTaaTpe(f)Ova-iv, avTi
8e ro5 8e'Ara ^^ra, ws d^ fxeyaXoTTpeirea-Tepa ovra.

EPM. nw? di/;
2X2. Oioi/ ot ixev apxai^TaToi, " Ifxepav " ttjv rjfxepav 5

eKoAow, ot de " kfiepav," ol 8e vvv " r]fx4pav."
EPM. 'Eo-rt TavTa.
e 7 'Aflrjjâs T a 2 77e B b3 awrrjl scripsi : aSriii B :
OUTIJ T 05 '|Upo;'] ffjiipav ? lannaris c6 e/iepo;'] vtjTfpov

knepav Heindorf e Proclo
4i8c nAAT12N02
2f2. OtarOa ovv ori fxovov tovtoov brjXol to apxaiov
oro/uta rqv biavoiav tov dffxevov; ori yap aa-iiivois rots
d av9pu)Trois nalifieLpova-iv k tov aKOTovs to (^<Ss iyiyviTO,
ravTT) b)v6piaa-av " IfjJpav."
EPM. aiWai.
212. Nvv bi ye TeTpay(ahy]p.ivov ov8' av KaTavorja-an ori
5 (BovXeTat r)
" rjpLepa." KatTOL TLves oXovTai, a>s hr\ t) rjfxipa
rjjxepa Troiei, 8ia rawa b^vofxdadai airrjv ovTais.

EPM. AoKft fxoi.
2i2. Kat t6 ye " (vybv " oio-â ori " bvoybv " ot TraAatol
iK6.\ovv.
lo EPM. Udvv ye.
212. Kat Tb ixiv ye " C^ybv " ov8ey 817X01, to 8e rotr
e Suoiy eveKa ttjs biaeuis is ttjv dycoyrfv firuivdfxaaTai
" bvoybv " StKatoos* vvv 8e " Cvy6v." koI dWa irdixiToXXa
OVTCOS ^X^'"
EPM. âiveTai.
5 212. Kara TavTO. toivvv TTp&Tov pikv to " biov " ovrco
Xeyoixevov TovvavTiov arjixaivet irda-t toZs irepX Tb dyadbv
ovoixaatv dyadov yap ibia ovaa Tb biov (patveTai bea-fxbs
etvat Kat KcoAu/xa (f)opds, wa-Trep dbeXcfibv ov tov /3Aa/3epo{;.

EPM. Kat fxaXa, d) 2wKpares, ovto) âivtTat.
10 212. 'AAA' ovK idv rw dpxo-i<a ovdfxaTt XPV' ^ ttoXv
419 fxdXXov etKo? eo-riy opd&s Keicrdat rj Tb vvv, oAA' o/ioAoyj/o-et

rots TTpdaOev dyaOots, idv dvT\ tov ei rb i&Ta dTrobtbios,
u)aTTep Tb TraXatov btibv ydp av arjixaivet, dAA' ov biov,
Tdyaddv, oirep koX ovroi ovk evavTtovrai avTos
brj eiratvet.
5 -avrai 6 Ta ov^fxaTa Ttdi\xevos, dXXd " 8e'oy

" Koi " cixpiXiixov "
Kat " Au(rtreAoyv " Kat " KepbaAiov " Kat " dyaObv " KOt
" avix(f)epov " Kat " evitopov " Tb avTb (f)aiveTat, eTepots
C 8 TOt^Tft)!'] toPto B d 2 Tjfiepav pr. BT d8 Svayhv

Schneider ex Et. Mag. e 8 Sv om. B e 10 îi/ . . .
xpv) ^"
.
xp^ T
. . a3 Suhv Heindorf Sthv : T : Sidiov B al om. T
a4 S^ B : ael TW

KPATTA02 419
ovoixacri crrwxcuvov to btaKoa-fjLOvv Kal lov TTavTOxov eyKeKco-

fxtaa-ixcvov, to be l<txov koI bovv yj/c/oixevov. koI brj Kal b
To " (rjfxtoibes" eav KaTO. r}]V apxaiav ^cofTjy aTroSw? avTl
Tov Cw^ biXra, (fâvfiTai (toi Kiia-Qai to 6vo\xa CTrl ru)
bovvTi To lov, eTTOvojxacrOev " brjixtwbes."
EPxM. Tt 8e 8t/ " rjbovi]

" Kal " XvTrq " Kal " iTridvixCa " 5
fcai To, TOLavra, S) ScufcpaTes;
212. Ov TTaw xakeTra /loi âtrerat, &j 'Ep/iK^yfyey. rj
T yap " rjbovr]," rj Ttpbs Tr]v ovr]crLV loiKe retVorcra Trpa^ts
TOVTo eêty to ovoixa

to 8e'Ara 8e iyKeLTat, u>(rT " fjbovi]
"
drri " r]ovi]s " KoAetrat ij re

" A.V7nj " aTTO r^s StaXvo-eojs c
rou (TcaixaTOS ioLKev eTToovoixdaOaL rjv kv tovto^ tCo Traêt
kclI 17 ye " d^'ta
tcxf t ro (rStixa. " to eixTTobCCov tov Uvai.
^ 8e " akyr]b(ov " êvLKov tl (paiveTai ptoL dTTO tov dXycLVOv
oivoixaa-ixivov. obvvr]" 8e dTTO ttjs ivbva-ecas Trjs Xvttt^s

*' 5
KeKXy]ixevr\ eoLKcv. " dxdribihv " 6e Kai Trairt br]\ov diTeL-
t6 ovoixa rw 7^? (popds jSdpeL. "
Kaa-ixevov X^P^ " ^^ ''"??
8taxuo-et Kat eviTopLa tt]s porjs ttjs ^XV^ eotKe KCKXrnxivr].

" Tp\j/ts" be aTTO TOV TepiTVOV- TO be " TfpTTVOv" dTTO Trjs d
8ta rrjs "^XV^ e/jx/êcos iTVor\ dTretKaa-Oev KeKXr]Tat, ev btKri
dv " epiTVOvv " KoXovixevov, xpovov be " TepTTVov

'
ixev vtto
irapriyixevov. " eixjypocrvvr] " be ovbev TTpoabelTaL tov Stort
pr]drjvaL' TravTL ydp brjXov otl

diTb tov ev toIs 7Tpdyp.acrL 5
ti]v yjrvxw a-vixêpecrOai tovto eXaê Tb ovoixa, " evcf)epo-
(rvvr]v" t6 ye biKaLOV opicos be avTb KoXovixev " ev^ppoa-virqv."
ov8' " eTTLOvixia" x^^^^^v ttJ ydp 7tI Tbv Ovixbv lovarr]
bvvdpLeL brjXov otl tovto eKX-qOr] Tb 6voixa. " Ovixbs " 8e dTTo e
TTJs Ova-eois KCLL êVecos Trfs yfrvxvs exoL dv tovto Tb ovoixa-
dXXa p.i]V " tpiepos " ye rw /xdAtcrra eXKovTL Tr]v \fwxr]V pw
a 8 ihv Bekker : tiv BT b3 (paivtrai B C i Tjovns]

fiivriais T : 6vr)tns G C 2 eirci)vofj.a(rdrjvai (sic) B $/j/ . . . C3 atcfi.a
secl. Baiter ^r] ^ Stallbaum c6 KfK\r)fjLfvri Heindorf : KtK\riij.vrj
BT (et mox C 8) d 2 epxpfais^ Ttprf/fais T (16 eixpepoavvriv
Bekker : iv<f>po<rvvr)v B : i<pepucrvvri T
" :
4aoa nAATilNOS
420 (TTUiVOiJ.aa-Or]' otl yap UfXvos pd Kal ((fnefxevos tojv
TrpayixaTOiv, Kal ovro) 8^ eTrKTTra a-(j)6bpa ttjv "^xh^ ^'^ ''^''
ecTLV TTJs pofjs, aTTo TavTTji ovv 7r<io-Tj9 TTJs bvvdp.fcos

" tfjiepos " KX.i]9r]. Koi pJqv " ttoOos " av KoXdTai (rr}p.aiV(ov
5 ov Tov TrapovTos elvai [ipif pov re Kal pdjfxaTos] aWa tov

akXodC TTOV OVTOS Kal aTTOVTOS, oOiV " TTodos" eTTOiVO-
Ixa^TTai, o? t6t, oTav Trapi] ov riy ((Ûto, " i/xepos
fKaXeiTO' aTroyvop.Vov be 6 avTos ovtos " tt60os " eKA.^^Tj.
" p(os" 8e, OTi eicrpd (^(oOev Kol ovk oiKiia ((ttXv fj porj
b avTT] T(S ex"'^'"^ "^^' CTreio-a/croy 8ia t(ov dixp.aT(ov, bia

TavTa aiTO tov (rpelv " (rpos" t6 ye iTaX.aibv exaAeiro
rw yap ov clvtI tov Si expw/xeâ vvv 8' " ipois " KeKkrjTai.
bia Tr]v Tov Si avTL tov ov /leraAAayî;. aXXa tC ert (ru
6 Ae'yeis oti. (rKoiT&fxev;
EPM. " Aoâ" Kal to. ToiavTa 7rf) o-ot (âCveTai;

2X2. " A6â" brj iJtol Trj 8iwêt eTTcov^fxacrTai, rjv rj
"^Xn bidKovcra t6 elbevai ottt/ exei to. irpixyfxaTa Tropeuerat,

7] Trj aTTo Tov t6ôv /SoAr/. ôtxe 8e tovtio fmkkov. 7/
C yovv " oi7jo"is rouro) (TVfKJioivei. " oTcnv " yap Trjs \f/v)(T]s
ttI TTav TTpayfxa, ol6v eo-rty ^Ka^TTOV twv ovTOiv, brfkovcrr]

TTpocreoi.Kev, uxnTep ye Kat rj
" ôvkrj " ttco? Tr]v ôkr]v, Kal
To " ôvke^rdai " to k(\)Ce(Tdai (rr]fxaCvei, K(ii (ro} " fiovkev-
'
5 ccrdaL TTO.VTa Taxrra b6^rj kTTOfxev' aTTa âCvfTaL Trjs
ôkrjs aiTeLKa(rfxaTa, uxTiTep av Kal TovvavTCov rj

" aôvkCa "
aTVxCa boKCL eimi, ois ov l3aX6vTos ovbe rvxpvTos ov r'
l/3aAAe Kal o e/SovAero Kat Trepi ov eôvAevero Kat ov e^fiCcTO.
d EPM. Tavra tjbr] fxoL boKels, w ^dKpaTes, iTVKv6Tfpa

(TTayeLV.
as 1/j.fpov . . . fifvfiaToi secl. Ast ag ^(rpti B b^ <ri
(vel o5) Heindorf : BT

oif b 7 8^ iJTOi^l Si JJtoj BT : 5^ toi Schanz
b8 T^ B : ToC T b 9 tout^ T: toGto B c i olffiy ybip t in marg.
oXfffiv 7'efcp B
f(rBS tlffivyhpT: oXaiv' iffusyiipV^
: caxSvT: tJ) B
03 Hermann vphs BT
irws C4 t^ add. Heindorf
: c6 /SoA^j T:
$ov\rjsB C7 Pa\6vTns Ti t: /SoWorros T tux^^^ôj B T: Tiry- W
Xdyoyros W
ov t'] o5t' B o5 T C 8 ifiaWe] *âA.AeTO B T i B: oC T
:
KPATTA02 42od
2i2. TeAo? yap TJbri 6eG>. " avayKr]v " 8' ovv Irt ôv-
Ao/xai hiaTT^pavai, ori tovtol^ k^s eoTi, Kal t6 " eKOva-iov"
To pL^v ovv " kKov(ri.ov," t6 etKov Kal fxrj avTiTVTTOvv akX\ 5
uxnrep AeycD, ilKov tw Iovti bebr]k(oiJiivov av eirj rovro)
rw ovoiJLaTi, roi /cara r^y ôvkt]<nv yi.yvoii.ivdi' t6 h\ " av-

ayKoiov " /cat avTiTvnov, Trapa ttjv ôvKrja-LV ov, t6 TTcpl tt]v
apLapTiav av eirj Kal ap.a6iav, aTTÛaa-Tai h\ ti] KaTO. to.
ayKT] TTopeia, ort bva-iTopa Kot Tpayia koX X6.(na ovTa Xa^d e
Tov UvaL. ivTv6V oSi' icrtos iKXr]6r] " avayKalov," rrj 8ta
rou ayKovs aTT^LKacrdev iTopL(t. ecos 8e TTdpea-TLV 17 p(!>p.r], fxr]
dvLa>p.v avT-qv dWa /cat crv ]J.r] dvCeL, dWa epcora.
EPM. 'Epooro) 87) TCL p.iyL(rTa Kal to. KaAAto-ra, Tr]V re 421
aXr]6uav KaL to yevoos Kat ro ov k^l avTo

TovTo Trept cSy yw 6 AcJyoj ^/>iry caTLV, " 6vop.a, 8t ort to
6vop.a exet.
2i2. Matecrât ovv KaAety rt; 5
EPM. "Eycoye, to ye ^r]TLV.
212. "Eot/ce rotwi' e/c Ao'you ow/xari ovyKKpoTr]ixiv(o,

kiyovTOS OTL TovT <TTLV 6v, ov TvyxdvL ^-qTr^pLa (6v/, [^6]
" 6vo]xa." /ixaAAoy 8e hv avT6 yvoirjs V & kiyo]iv t6 " ovo-
pLaa-Tov"' ivTavda ydp ora^ws Aeyet tovto eirat ov ov 10
p.dcr]j.a kcTTLV. r] 8' " dkrjdeLa," Kal tovto rots aAAots eotKe b
[o-vyKeKpor^crâi]' r] yap 6La tov 6vtos (popa olk iTpoa--
CLpfja-6aL TOVT(a tS> pr]]iaTL, rf) " dkr]6L(i," o)? êta oilo-a dkr].
t6 <^8e)> " êvbos " TovvavTLOv r^ (popa' iTdkLV yap av Aot8o-

povfxevov i]KL t6 laryoixfvov Kal t6 dvayKa^6]Xvov rjcrvxdC^LV, 5
aTretKacrrat 8e rot? Kaêvbova-L' t6 \j/L 8e TTpoa-yv6]Xvov

iTTLKpVTTTL Tr]V ÔvkrjCTLV TOV 6v6]xaT0s. t6 8e " ov " Kal 1)
" ovcTLa" 6]xokoyZ rw dAr;0et, t6 i&Ta dTToka^6v' 16 v ydp
d 3 6(5) T deu> B Oeip vulg. deu Adam

: : d 8 o.vTnvTovv B
:
dg ri &yK7\ b: avdyKtjv BT aa /cal t6 Sj' TW om. B SL^ wv :
BT: 6 vel o5 al. a6 -ye om. T a8 o;/ addidi, tJ seclusi

a 10 tv ov fj.aL(Tfjia effrlv Heusde {ixdafjia Buttmann) 6v6/j.a(r/j.d : iarTiv BT
b 2 (TvyKfKpoTTiffOai secl. Hermann b 4 5 om. B T
PLATO, VOL. I. 15
4aic nAATilNOS
C (rrjfxaLvei, koI to " ovk ov " av, (Ss Tive^ koX 6vo\xaâv(Ti.v
aVTO, OVK lOV.
EPM. TavTa [liv ixoc boKcls, Si Eco/c/aares, avbpfuas Trdw

bi.aKKpoTr]Kevai' et be tCs (re ipoiTO tovto to " Ibv " koX
6 To " p4ov " Kal t6 " bovv," Tiva tyii opdoTrjTa raura Ta
ovojxaTa
212. " Ti hv avT^ hiroKpivaiy.iOa; " Aeyeis; ?} ydip;
EPM. Yldvv ixv ovv.

212. *Ey pLv TOLvvv dpTi TTOV (TropKrdiJ.eda uxTTe boKelv
lo tI kiyeiv dTT0Kpi,v6pLV0L.
EPM. To TToXov TovTo;
212. ^dvaL, b hv p.r} yLyvcoa-KCiifxev, âpâpiK^v tl tovt

d iTvaL. elr} fxkv ovv tcrois dv tl tt) akr]deLa koX tolovtov
avT&v, etrj 8e kclv vtto TraXaLOTrfTos tcl Trpcora t&v ovo/xaroii;
dvevpeTa eXvaL' 8ta ydp t6 TTavTa)(i] (rTpe(f)ea-6aL Ta 6v6fxaTa,

ovbev davp.a(TT6v [dv\ ei rj TTakaLa (f)(tivr] Tr/aos Trjv iwvl
5 âpfiapLKrjs ]xr]bev bLa(f)epL.
EPM. Kat ovbev ye d-jTo TpoTTOv keyecs.

212. Aeyo) yap ovv elK^Ta, ov [x4vtol jxol boKel irpo-
(f)d(reLS dyoiv be^êcrOaL, dkka TTpodvfxr^Teov Tavra bLaaKe-
âcrdaL. ev6vp.r]6G)pi.ev be, el tls dei, bC S)V dv keyrjTaL t6
C ovofxa, eKelva dvepr^creTaL Ta prffxaTa, kclL av6LS av bC &v
h.v Ta prjfi.aTa ke)(6r\, eKelva Trevo-erai, Kal tovto p.i] TTavcreTaL
TTOL(av, dp* ovK dvdyKTf TekevTo^VTa direLTTeLV t6v diTOKpLvd-

fievov;
6 EPM. "EfxoLye boKel.

423 212. riore ovv dTTeLTTcov 6 diTayopevoiV bLKaCods iTavoLTO
&v; Sp' ovK eiTeLbdv eri' eKeivoLs yivr]TaL roiy ovdfxaaLV, h.
acTTTepel (TTOLXfia t5)v dXX(DV Icttl koX k6yo)v koX ovofxdrcov;
e 2 ovK I6v BT (et sic Boeoti) : ovk\ 6y Bekker C 4 crtTG:

om. B c la T om. T d i o5i/ om. T ds 6.i>fvp(Ta]
avfpfvuTiTa al. d4 &/ seclusi ti ^] fjj BT d5 Sia-
(ptpfiv BT d6 \4yfis TW: <p(p(is B d8 TaOro] avTi, T
e I ivfp-fi<rfTai Bekker : ipiifffTot B : &i/ 4pîTfT(u T 63 Thv^ Th B
KPATTA02 422a
Tavra yap ttov ovKeVt bUaLov (j)avrjvat e^ aXXcuv ovoixaTcxtv
avyicdfjifva, av ovtcos ex^. olov vvvbi] t6 " ayaOov " 5
(f)aixV K Tov ayao-Tov Kal (k tov 6oov (rvyKela-Oai, to
bi " dobv " l(T(i)s (ôx\xV av k^ eTepcov, eKelva be i^ aWoov

dAA.' idv TTore ye Xaô)\xV o ovkti K tlvoov kT^pcov b
(TvyKeLTaL 6vop.dTOi}v, bLKaCcos hv (jialfjLev eirl aroLxeLio t
tjbrj cTvaL Kal ovk^tl tovto tjijms bilv eis aAAa 6v6[xaTa
dva(f)pLV.
EPM. "EjxoLye boKfXs 6p6(as XeyeLV. 5
212. 'Ap' ovv Kal vvv d y epooTqs Ta 6v6p.aTa (rTOLêla

ovTa TvyxdveL, Kal beX avT&v aXX<o tlvl Tpoixoi rjbrj ti]v
6p66Tr]Ta T7LcrK\l/acr6aL iJTLS kaTLv;

EPM. EtKos ye.
212. EiKos briTa, Z) 'F.pfx6yVS' irdvTa yovv (jâCveTaL ra lo
efXTTpoa-êv ets TavTa dvXr]Xv64vaL. ei 8e tovto ovtcos ^X^'' C

U)S ]XOL b0KL yLV, bVpO av a~VVTrL(rK\l/aL ]XT ]XOV ]Xr]
TL napaXr]p-qa-oo Aeyooy otav 8et Tr]V tG)V TrpcoTcov ovofxdToov

6p66Tr]Ta etrat.
EPM. Ae'ye fxovov, 0)s ocrov ye bvvdiXcos irap' ]xol kcrTLV 5
awiTL(rK\jrofxaL.
212. "Ort [XV TOLWV fxCa yk tls tj opdoTqs Trairros
6v6paTos Kal TrpooTOV Kal vcTTdTOV, Kal ovbev bLa(ppL rw

ovofxa etyat ovbev avToiv, otfxaL Kal aol awboK^X.
EPM. ndw ye. lo
2X2. 'AAAa fxrjv 5)V ye wv^biiy bLXr]Xv6afXv t5)v d

ovofxdToov Tj 6p66Tr]s TOLavTTf TLS ôvXTO LvaL, ota br]Xovv
olov Ka(TT6v ea-TL tS)v ovtcov.
EPM. Ucos ydp ov;
212. ToCro fXV dpa ovbev tJttov /cat rd TrpStTa 6et XLV 5
Kat ra vaT^pa, etTiep 6v6fxaTa (rTaL.

EPM. Udw ye.
a 5 &/ scripsi (& &/ Heindorf) &v B T b i 7 om. T

: b 6 fi
y fpwrSs fort. scribendum Schanz ayp^rais B & ipotT^s (sed yp.
: :
aypdnais) T d i 5t) add. Heindorf

422d nAATX2N0S
22. 'A\Xa to. /lc^v Ha-Tepa, m ioiKc, bia tG>v TrpoTfpiov
olA T rjv TOVTO &Ttpya^(rdat.

lo EPM. <Paiv(Tai.
212. Eiey to, 8e 8t/ Trp&Ta, oTs ovtt(o (Tfpa viroKdTai,
TtVL TpoTTô KaTO, To bvvaTov oTt /xoAioTa (f>avpa r]iuv
e TTotT/o-et Ta ovTa, etTrep /xe\Aei dvofxaTa etvat; aiioKptvat 8e

/xot ro8e* et (f)(ovT]v p.i] etxo/xev /xr/Se yXoirTay, iôvk6fxc6a
8e 877X0VI' oAAÂot? ra irpayfiara, ap' ovic &y, &(ntep vvv

ot eveoi, eTrexetpoC/xev &y cn]p.atviv rais x^P*''^ '^^' K((pa\fj
5 Kat rw aAAo) o-w/jiari;
EPM. ricS? yap ay aAAcos, > 2i(aKpaTs;

423 212. Et /ie'r y' ot/xat to av(t> Kal to kov(()ov iôvXofxeda
b7]\ovv, fipojjLev av TTpbs tov ovpavov Tr]v x^^P^' /xi/xov/xewt
avTTjv Tr]V (f)V(rtv tov TTpdyp.aTOS' (l 8e Tct xaro) Kai to.
âpea, TTpbs rr/y yfjv. Kal et Xttttov diovTa ij rt ÂAo Tav

5 C<{^coy ôv\6pi(da br]\ovv, dtcrda ort a)S 6p.ot6TaT hv ra
^jxcTcpa avT(av (rti)p.aTa koX (r)(f]p.aTa iTtotovixev (Keivots.
EPM. ÂvdyKT] fxot boKei ws Ae'yfts exetj;.
22. Ouro) yap av oTfxat bi]X(t)[xd tov [(T(ap.aTos] iyiyvero,
b ixi\xri(Tap.hov, o)? eotKe, tov (T(o]xaTos eKelvo 6 e/3ovAero
8/)A(S(rat.
EPM. Nat.
212. 'E7ret8r/ 8e (j)(i)vi] re Kat yAwrrT/ Ka\ (rrdfxaTt /3ovAo-
5 /xeâ br]kovv, ap^ ov t6t kKdarov 8Âa)/xa r]]xtv ecrrat ro

diro TOVT(OV ytyv6]XVov, OTav ]xi]xr]ixa yeirqTai 8ia TOVT(av
TTp\ OTtovv;
EPM. 'AmyKT/ ]X0t b0Kt.
2i2. 'Ovofx &p' ia-Tiv, o)? eoiKe, ]xipi.r]fxa <f)Oi)vj] eKeivov
10 S /xt/xetrat, Kal dro/idêi 6 [xtfxovfxevos Trj (fxavf] b av

fXtfxifTat.
EPM. AoKet fxoi.
e6 iWws secl. Schanz 0,3 rh ante c<{t G: om. BT

a8 Tov Heindorf: rov BT ffufjLaros secl. Schanz bi (li-
fxriffafifvovs B b9 <l><yî iKuvo T b 10 6 &!] Jroi' Heindorf

KPATTA02 423 c
212. Ma Ai" dAA' ovk (iiot tto) SoKei KaAws kiyecrOai, C

cb fratpe.
EPM. Tigj/;
2X2. Tov? ra Trpoâra fn.iiov[xivovs tovtovs Kal tovs
akeKTpvovas Kal tol akX.a Câ avayKaÔLpLfd' av 6pi.okoyuv 5
ovopia^^Lv ravTa aiTep p.i}xovvTai,
EPM. 'AXr]6ri ky is.
212. KaAo)? ovv exêti^ Sokci (tol;
EPM. OvK îxoLye. a\ka tls av, S) 2wK/)ares, p.Lp.r]<TLs
ir] To ovofxa; lo
212. Ilp&TOV jxev, Ot)S e/xoi SoKei, ovk kav KaBaiiep r?)
[lova-LKr] iJ.LiJi.oviJ.e6a to. TTpdypiaTa ovtco p.Lp.(iip.e6a, KaLTOL d

ôjyrj ye koX totc ixL]j.ovp.e6a' eTreira oiik kav airep r] pov-
(TLKr] pLp.LTaL Ka\ rjpds pLp(ap.e6a, ov [XOL boKOV]xev 6vo]xd(rHV.
Xeyo) 8e' rot tovto' ^(ttl toZs 7Tpdyp.aaL (j)(x>vr] Kal a)(rjp.a
eKcio-rw, Kai yj)5)]xd ye ttoAAois; 5
EPM. Udw ye.
2X2. "EoiKe TOLWV ovk idv tls TavTa pL]xr]TaL, ovbe Trepi
TavTas Tas p,Lp.r]a-LS r} T^yvr] r] ovopaa-TLKr] elvaL. avTaL

pikv ydp etcTLV rj p.V pLOvaLKi], r) 8e ypa(pLKr]' ?] ydp;
EPM. Nau 10
2<i2. 1 1 oe 057 rooe; ov KaL ovcrLa ookl (tol eLvai eKaoTO), e
uxTirep K(u x/><S/xa Kat h wvbr] kX(.yo]xev; TrpoiTOV avT(a rai
\p(x)p.aTL KoX rr} (f)(i)vri ovk ecTTLV ova-Ca tls KaTep(i> avTwv
Kal TOLS aAAois Trao-ii' oaa ijficorai rai^rrjs' Trjs 7Tpocrpr]a-(i)s,
Tov elvaL; 5
EPM. *'Efiotye 8oKet.
2X2. Ttoiiy; et rts ai^ro roSro /ixt/xeto-ât dvratro eKao-roi,

Tr]v ovcTLav, ypdp,paa-L re Kat avkXajSals, ap ovk hv brjkol
(.KaaTOV o eaTLv; 7/ 01!;
EPM. Ildw p.\v ovv. 424
e I aJOC ovK yp. T ; ovk &\\' B : oijK aAA' T irw] oijvoi T d. i fii-
fj.ovfjifda^ ft.ilic!>/j.e0a B d3 fjnfLriTai BT d4 5e tqi G : 5 rt BT :
5' T< Baiter d8 ^ ante ovofxaaTLKr) om. B e i roSf] rdre B

424 a ITAATnNOS
2i2. Kal tC hv <f)aCr]s rov tovto hvvay^vov, uKnrep tovs
TTpoTipov^ Tov p.\v p.ov(TLKov 4(f)-q<rda, Tov bi [TLva] ypa(f>i,ii6v.
TovTov b TCva;
5 EPM. TovTO tp.oiy( boKfl, ui 2w/cpares, oirfp ToAai
CrjTovixev, ovtos hv etvai 6 dro/xaoTiKos.
1,0,. Et 6.pa TOVTO aXT]Oh, yjbr] lotKey ^Trio-xeTrrcoi' irfpl
(KfCvmv Tciv 6voiM(XTcov (av ai} ijpov, irepl " poijs " re Kai rou
" Uvai " Kol " o-)(o-ea)?," d roty yp6.p.pLaai kcu tols (rvWaâls
b Tov ovTos iTTL\ap.(3dv(TaL avT&v uxttc aTTop.Lp.fZadaL ttjv
ovcrCav, eire Ka\ ov;
EPM. Y\6.w iJLV ovv.

2f2. epc br] Lb(tifj.V TTOTepov &pa TavTa p.6va koTL T<av
5 TTp(aT(iiv 6vop.aT(iiV r/ Kal aXKa TToXXd,

EPM. Ot/iat cy(ay Kal aXXa.
2i2. E^Kos ydp. dXXa tCs hv etrj 6 TpdiTos rfjs SiaipcVews
oOev &p\TaL fj,ipLl(r6aL 6 fiLfxovp,vos ; Spa ovk Itt^Ctt^p
(TvXXaÔLS T KoX ypdpfxa^TLV fj p.Cfxr](rLS Tvyydv^L ovcra rffs
lo ov(rCas, 6p06TaT6v eo-rt 8teAe'o-ât to. o-rotxeta TTpaTOv, &(nTp
C ot ^TTtxetpouyrej rots pvOfxols tS>v (rroLyÛiiV iTpaiTov ras

bvvdfXLS 8tet\oyro, TTLTa t&v (rvXXaôiv, Kal ovt(os tfbrj
epxovTaL ttI tovs pvOfxovs (rK\lr6fiV0L, iTp^T^pov f ov;

EPM. Nat'.
5 2i2. *Ap' ovv Kal fffxas ovTca 5et iTpojTOV fxev TO. (fxavrf^VTa
SteXeVât, iTLTa tu>v Tp(i)V Kara etSrj rct re a(f)U)va koI
&(f)0oyya' ovT<aa-l ydp ircrv X^yov^riv oi beivol irepi rourcoi'

Kat TOL av (f>(i)vrjVTa fx^v ov, ov fxivToi ye a(f)0oyya; koI
avTdv tS)V (f)(i)vr]VT(t)V o(ra bLd(f>opa ei8r; ix.L oAAt/Acov; koI
d ^7ret5ay Tavra bLX(ap0a [tcl ovTa] v irdvTa av ols 8et 6v6-

fxara TTL0LvaL, l ô-tlv ets h d.va(f>pTai irdrra uxriT^p to.
rrotxeta, e^ aiy eo-rty i5eti' avrd re Kat ci ^v airroLS eveoTii'
a3 Tiva om. B a6 i(-t)ToZnfv BT a7 wt toiKtv T

b I SxTTf om. B : S(rT . . . ov<riav secl. Schanz c 8 oi^ om. T
C 9 avTwv T(ii'l aiiTwv B o? tuv al.
: Schanz d I TaDra] xetKTa B
Tci ovTa secl. Beck o5 oh Badham : aidis BT
KPATTA02 424 d
(ihrj Kara tov avTov TpoTrov axnrep iv toZs cTTOiêioiî' TavTa

navTa Kokm biadeaaraixV0V9 kma-TacrOai eTTKfêpav eKaaTov 5
KaTa TTjv oixoLOTrjTa, fdvTf V evl be-p emcfêpeiv, kdvTe
(TvyKepavvvvTa TTokXa [kvC], wairep ol (ooypdcfôL j3ovX6p.VOL
d<f)oiioLovv evLOTe p.ev ocrTpeov p.6vov eTTrjveyKav, evioTe he
OTLOvv dXko Ta>v (f)app.dK(jL)v, ecTTL he oTe TroXXa crvyKepd- e
cravTes, olov oTav dvhpeLKeXov aKevd((ocTLV rj dXXo tl tG)V
T0L0VT(av o)S hv oi/xai boKrj eKdcrrq rj elKoov bel^rdaL eKdcTTOV
(fâppidKov ovT(t) 8?) Kal rjfxeLS tcl (TTOL^^êla eTrl to, 'npdyp.aTa
eTtoLcrop.ev, koll ev eTtl ev, ov dv hoKr\ helv, /cal (rvfXTroXXa, 5
TTOLOvvTes o 8t) crvXka(3as KoXovcnv, Kal crvXXa(3ds av ctvvtl-
OevTes, e^ S)V Td re oiôftara koX Ta p7]}xaTa crvvTLOevTaL' kcil 425
TTdXLV eK tG)V dvop.dT(j)v koX prjixdTo^v jxeya {jbr] tl Kal KaXbv
Kal dXov cn}<rTri(ro\xev, axnTep eKel to Côv Trj ypa(f)LKrj,
evTavOa tov Xoyov rfj dyojuao-riKf) r] prjTopLKr] rj iJTLS ea-Tlv
7] Texyrj. [xdXXov be ovx rjfxels, dXXa Xeycnv e^ve)(6riv, 5
crvveOecrav p.ev ydp ovT(t)s r\TTep crvyKeLTaL ol iroAaior rjixds
be 8et, etiTep TexvLK&s eTrL(rTricr6p.eda a-KOTTeladaL avTa TrdvTa,

ovTd) bLeXofxevovs, etre KaTa TpdiTOV Td re iTp&Ta 6v6p.aTa b.
Ketrat Kat Ta vaTepa etre [xrj, ovto) OedcrdaL' dXkoos be
crvveLpeLV p-r} <f)avXov rj Kal ov Kad^ 6b6v, S ^tAe 'F,p[x6yves.
EPM. "lo-cos vi) At", S) ScoKpares.

212. Tt ovv; (tv Trto-revet? cravTio oXos t dv eTvai TavTa 5
ovrco bLeXea-daL; eyu> fxev ydp ov.
EPM. rioAAoi; dpa beu eyooye.
2i2. 'Ecio-o/xey ovv, rj (BovXeL ovt(i)S ottcos dv bvv(t)p.e6a,
KOLL dv crp.LKp6v TL ovtS^v oXol t o)p.ev KaTLbelv, e'7TL\eLpS)pi.ev,
TTpoeLTT^vTes, uicnTep dXiyov irp^Tepov rots Oeols, otl ovbev c

etSore? Trjs dXrjdeLas to, t&v dvdp(aiT(t)v b6yp.aTa iTepl avTa>v
eLKaCop.ev, ovrco 8e Kat vvv av elTTOVTes [rjixlv] avTOLS ico/xer,
d 5 e/cocTToj'] Ka9' fKacTTov T d7 evi om. T 65 SeTvl

ISfTv B <ri^;uiroA.A.a] (rvfi0o\a T 66 &] & Heindorf a i ctvvtI-
dfTui al. a6 îrep] ftwfp BT b2 Koi supra ifTe add. T
c 3 ^n7v seclusi
425C nAATX2N02
ori ei jiev tl xP^^ [e8ei] avra buXicrdaL eire aWov ovtivovv
5 etre T}ixas, ovt(os e8ei avTO. biaipela-Oai, vvv 8e to kiyonivov
KaTO. bvvafxiv 8e7;(rei t}iw.s irepl avr&v TTpaypxiTevfa-daL; boKfl
Tavra, r] ttws Ae'yei9;
EPM. Udw p.V ovv a-(f)6bpa l/ioiye boKfi.
d 212. reAoia p.ev oi/Liat (fâvela-Oat, o} 'F,pp.6y(V9, ypap.p.aa^L
Koix o-iAAa/3ats ra TTpdyp.aTa p.p.nir]p.(.va KaTdbr]ka yLyvo-

\iva' op.(os 8e dvdyKr]. ov yap exo/xey rovTov îXrLOV fls
OTL f'navv4yKu>p.v Trepl dXrjdfLas t&v irpwrcov dro/xdrcaj;,
5 el fjLT] apa <(/3oyÂei, wa-TTfp oi rpaywSoTTotot eTretSdj; ri
diTop&a-LV iTil rds iJLr])(avas KaTa(f>vyova-L deovs alpovTfs,

KOL T^pieTs ovTUiS eiTrdyres aTraAAayaiyiev, ori rd itpStTa
ovopiaTa OL dcol eOecrav Kal 8td TavTa opdQs eêt. dpa

e Kal f]fuv KpdTLOTOS ovTOS T&v koytov; rj iKelvos, otl Trapa
fiapl3dp(ov TLvSiV avTO. irapeLki^cfâfMev, elcrl be r]fiu)v dp\aL6-

TpoL fidpjSapoL; 7/ drt vtto TraAatoTT/ros dbvvaTov avTo.
426 TTL(TKyffacrdaL, a>a-7Tp Kal tcl jiapâpLKd; avTaL ydp hv
TTaaraL KbvaLS etey Kal fxd\a K0fj.yf/al rai /xtj ^deXovTL \6yov
8i8dmt TTpX t5>v TTpcjTitiv ovofxdTUiv i)s opOQs Ketrai. KaLTOL
dr<i) rtj Tp6TT(o TCiV TTp(OT(ov ovofxaTcov TTfv opdoTTfTa fxrf ot8ei',
5 dZvvaT^v TTOV t&v ye vaTepuiv ei8eVat, h e^ iKeCvoiV dvdyKrj

brfkovaOai &v tls irepi fxrfbev oiSev dAAd 8Âoi; ort tov
(fidaKovTa iTp\ avTSiV TeyvLKov eimt Trept tS>v TTpdTcnv
b dyojudrcoi' fxdAto-rd re Kat Ka6ap(0TaTa bel ^x^''^ d7ro8etâi,
7/ v eibivaL otl rd ye vaTpa rjbr] </)Avap7jo-et. rf aol dAAtos
8oKet;
EPM. Ov8' dTrcooTtow, co ^fdKpares, dAAcos.
5 2X2. *Â fxV TOLWV iyut rja-OrffxaL TTcpl tS>v TTptaTUiV 6vo-
fxaTUiv Trdw fxoL boKel vlipLo-TLKa elvaL Kal yeAoia. tovtq)v

ovv aoL fXTab(oau}, dv ôvkrf (tv 8' dv tl exT/s /3e'Aridy
iroêy AaySeii', TTLpda-6aL Kal ifxol |iera8t8oVai.
c 4 xp5' Ast : xpv<^'''^f BT Hti. del. Ast d5 $ov\ti

Hermann : ScrBT: Sâl. az fio-8i;o-s B b^ i\Kws S>
3(iKpar*s G
KPATTAOS 426 b
EPM. noiTjo-o) Tavra. aXXa dappQiv Xeye.

212. ripairor fxev tolvvv to pu) e/xotye (âiv^Tai uxnrep c
opyavov tlvai, TraoTjs r^s Kti;ryo-e(09, ^y oii8' etTTo/xei; 8t ort
eêt roim) Tovvop.a' akXa yap hriXov ort eo-is ôvXiTai,
eimf ov yap 7]ra ixP^H-^^'^ aXXa et ro TiaXaiov. rj 8e
apx^ airo tov " kUlv" êviKov 8e Tovvop.a tovto 8' eo-rtz; 5
teVat. et ovv rts to TraXaLov avTrjs evpoL ovona eis ti]V

r]ix(Tpav (f)(Dvi]v (rvp.âLV0V, " eo-ts " hv 6p6a)S /caAotro* vvv
8e airo' re rou êytKou rou Kteiy Jcat oTro ttjs tov Tjra [xeTa-
ôXrjs Kal TTJs tov vv hdicreois " KLvr}(Tis " KeKXrjTaL, eSet
8e " KLLvri(TLV
" KdXdadaL [rj eto-tr]. ^ 8e a-T(X(rLS aT:6(f)aa-LS d
"
roS Uvai ôvX^TaL (TvaL, 8ta 8e tov KaXXo)TTL(Tixbv " a-Taa-LS
bivoixaaTaL. to 8e ovv pQ to (rTOL\LOV, uxnrep Aeyo),
KdXov eboêv opyavov etyat Trjs Ktnjo-ecos rw ra 6v6p.aTa

TLdeixivca irpos t6 a(f)oixoLovv t^ ôpq, iroXXaxov yovv XPV'^^'- 5
avT(a eis avrrjv TTpa)TOV fxev (V avTU) tS) " pdv " Kat " poTj
8ta TOVTOV Tov ypdpLfxaTos rr/y (popav y.Lp.dTaL, etra kv rai

" Tp6fX(a," etra iv rw " Tpix<eLV," tl 8e ei; rois rototo-8e e
prnxacTLV oXov " KpoveLV," " Opaveiv," " (peUeLV," " dpviTTeLV,"
" Kpp.aTLîLV," " pvp-jSelv," TtavTa raOra to ttoXv aTretKaCet
8ia Tov pca. ((a^pay yap oi/xat rqv yXwTTav kv rovro) rJKLaTa
yAvovcrav, p.a.XLa-Ta 8e creLOfxevrjv 8to (âirerat ji/ot rovro) 5
Trpos TavTa KaTaKexpricrOaL. rw 8e av twra Trpoj to. AeTrra

TrdvTa, h 8?) /laXto-ra 8ta Trdrrcoi; lot av. 8ta raOra ro
" Uvai" Kal t6 " lecrOaL" bLO. tov i&ira aTTopLLpLeLTaL, uto-TTfp 427
ye 8ta rou <êt Kat tov \/Aet Kai roC o-ty/ia Kai rou ^Tjra, ort
TTvev}xaT(i)hr\ tcl ypdfxpiaTa, TTdvTa to. TOLavTa p.p.Lp.r]TaL
avTols 6vopM^(t)V, otov t6 " y\rv\p6v " koll t6 " îov '
koi to
" aeUcrOaL " Kat oAcos crHcr]x6v. kcll OTav ttov t6 (pvaSihes 5
C2 oii 5j6iiroî' Naber e3 effis scripsi : Teo-js B : Uais T (et

mox C 7) c6 jeVat B C9 ^Sei ... 6.3 aivofiaffTai secl. Hein-
dorf Ast Schanz d i ^ lo-ii/ seclusi da jeVoj B d6 eV om. T
ei Tpaxe' B T
Tp'x'] 64 Heindorf oj B T
eojpo : e6 irphs
toDto] Kol vphs Tavra T a I Xeffdat Schanz UveffOai : B : Uffdai T
oTo/iJ/ijoÔot al. Heindorf a 5 fftffixdf Heindorf
"
4a7a nAATXlNOS
fJiifirJTai, TTavTa\ov kvTavda wy to ttoXi/ to. Toiavra ypdfifiaTa
în(f)epLv (f)a[vTai 6 to, SvofxaTa TiOepifvos. ttjs 8' av tov
heKTa (rvixT:ii(Tf(i>s KoiX tov Tav kox dTrepeifrccos ttjs yXdiiTTris
b TT]v hvvap.iv xPW^-H-ov (âiviTai qyq^Ta^rOai, Trpbs ttjv p.ip.ri(Ti,v
Tov " bea-pLov " koI ttjs " ardcrfQis." oti bi oKKrddvci pA\icrTa
^v r<S kdl3ba f) yXSiTTa KaTibcav, d(f)op.oi,5iv uiv6p.aa-e rd re
" Aeia " KoX avTo to " 6Ki.(rddviv " koI to " KLirapbv " Kal
5 To " KoXXHbes " Kal rSXAa irdvTa to, TOiavra. ^ be 6ki(r6a-
voxxTTfs yXcaTTqs dvTLKap^dvTaL rj tov ydp.pa bvvap.LS,
Tfjs
t6 " yXicryjiov " dTTep.Lprf(TaTO k(iI " yXvKv " kox " yXoLiabis."
C Tov 8' av vv To 610-0) al(rd6p,vos ttjs (fiaivrjs, t6 " ivbov
Kal TCL " (VTOS " (iivdpacrev, o)? d(\)op.oLSiv rots ypdppa(rL tol
(pya. t6 8' av aX(f)a rai " p,ydX(a " direbcDKf, Kal rui
" pLriKeL " t6 T/ra, ori p-eydXa tcl ypdppara. ds 8c t6
5 " yoyyvXov " tov ov bedpievos a7}p.Lov, tovto TTXfLO-Tov avT^
els t6 ovopa kveKepaaev. koX raA\a ouro) (âiveraL 7rpocr/3t-
^dêLV Kal KaTCL ypdp.p.aTa kol KaTO. avXXal3as (Kda-Tio rSiV
dvTCtiv a-r]p.fL6v re Kal ovop.a iroLoiv 6 vop.o6(Tr]s, ^k bi tovtcov
TCL XoLTTo. ybr] avTOLs TovTOLS (TvvTLdevaL aTropLLpovpfvos. avrr]
d p.0L (fiaivfTai, Si 'Epp6yVs, (3ovXcr6aL eiyat // twv dro/xdrtor

6p66Tr]s, l p,r] TL dXXo KparvXos obe Aeyet.
EPM. Kal p,rjv, Zi Swfcparey, iroAAd yi poi iroAAdKis
TrpdypaTa Trapeêi KpaTvXos, wo-Trep /car' dp)(as eXeyov,
5 (f)da-K(iiv pV elvai 6p66Tr]Ta 6vop.dTOiiv, rJTLs 8' fcrrii' ovbev
(ra(fiS Xiyoiv, (a(rT fxe p.r] bvva(r6aL clbevaL iroTepov kKoiV rj
aK(tiv ovTdis d(ra(f)(iis Kda-T0T TTpl avrSiV XiyeL. vvv ovv

e jnot, u) KparvXe, evavTiov ^MKpdrovs el-ne TTOTepov dpa-Ki
croL
fj
Aeyei ScoKpcin/y itfpl 6vop.dT(iiv, f]
/x^'* "^V ^^V
KdXXLOV XiyeLv; Kat el ^xeLS, Acye, tva i]TOL pddr]s Trapa
^(tiKpdTovs 1] bLbd^yjs fjpas dp.(f)OTpovs.
5 KP. T^ 8^, S) 'Epp6yV(s; boKL crot pa8iov eirai ovro)
a 7 OifjLtvoi T ba S^ om. T C 6 iv iKtpaatv B : ivtKtpaxrt T

09 ffSij] elSij BT d6 itiTtpov^j t, irp6rfpov B
KPATTA02 427 e
Taxv âdelv re Kal bibaâi, otlovv Trpayixa, /xt; ort too-ovtov,

6 8^ boKH ev Tois [/LieyioTots] fxiyiarov elvai;
EPM. Ma At", oriK e/ixotye. oAAa ro rou *Ho-to'8ou 428
KoAws /xoi âtyerat eyjîv, to et Kat ris a^jiiKpov iirl a-pLLKpS)
KaTaOeCr}, irpovpyov iXvai. et oi)y Kat ap.iKp6v rt oto'? r' et
Tikiov TTOLrjaaL, /nr) cnroKap.ve aAA' VpyTeL Kal 'S.coKpa.Tr]
Tovbe 8tKato? 8' et Kat e/xe'. 5

2X2. Kat fxev br] eycoye Kal avTos, S> KparvAe, ovbev av '
layypLa-a(.p.r]v 5)V eiprjKa, rj be /xot ((paCveTO fxeO^ '^F.pp.oyevovs
eirea-Keyl/dp.rjv, waTe tovtov ye eveKa Oappwv Xeye, ei tl
cxets êXrLov, a>s efxov evbeôp.evov. et pievTOL exets rt oo b

KaAAioy TovTcov XeyeLV, ovk av 6avp.a.^0Lp.L' SoKeis ydp p.0L
avTos re eaKe(f)daL tcl TOLavTa Kal iiap' dXkcov pLep.a6r]KevaL.

iav ovv keyr]s ri KoAAtoi', eva tS)V fxa6r]T0iV irepl 6p66Tr]TOS
ovofxdTCjiV Kal ep.e ypdcpov. 5
KP. 'AAAa fxev brj, o 2ajKpare?, UiaTtep av Ae'yets,
]xe]xeXr]Kev re' piot Trept avTwv Kal to-cos av ae TTOLrâaLfxrjv
]xa6r]rt]v. (ôôvfxaL fxevTOL firj tovtov Ttav TovvavTLov p, c

ort fioL TTcos eirepx^TaL XeyeLV Trpbs (re t6 tov 'A\LXXe(t)S,
eKelvos ev Atrats Trpos roi^ Aiarra Ae'yet. (îjo-i 8e
Aiai' Atoyeiês TeAa/utcriyte, Koipave XaSiv,

irdvTa TL fxoL KaTO. 6vfxov eeicroi fxvdr]aaa6aL. 5
Kat efxol (Tv, w ^caKpaTes, eTTtetKoi)? (f)aLvr] KaTO. vovv XPV-

(rp(^beLV, etre irap' F.v6v(f)povos eTTLTTVovs yevdfxevos, eLTe Kal
dXXr] TLS MoSo-a TroAai o-e ivova-a eAeAijêt.

2)12. 'f2ya0e KparvAe, 6avfxdC(>i kol avTos TraAai Tr]v d
efxavTov (ro(f)Lav Kal aTTLaTw. boKel ovv fxoL xprjvaL etiava-
aKe\f/aa6aL tC Kal Xey(a. t6 yap eâiTaTda6aL avTov i<^'
avTov TrdvToov ^''^^'^^'''aTOV' oTav yap fxrfbe afXLKp6v diTO-

(TTaTff dAA' det Trap^ 6 eâTrarT/o-coy, iTois ov beLvov; 8et br], 5
e6 /i^l ^ B 67 fieyiarois om. liber Bessarionis az <r/i<(cp$]

fffxiKpov B c 2 vpbs (ri Kfyav G C5 ififfao Cobet C 7 'ir<-
yvovs B
4a8d nAATi2N02
0)9 loiKf, Oafxa fiTa(rTp^(f)a-6ai. ^ttI to. Trpodprififva, Kal
TTipaa-6ai, t6 iKcCvov tov TTOiriTov, /SXîrcij/ " &fia Ttpocrao)
Kcu OTtia-aôi." Kal 8t; Kal jrvvl rjfxels rScu/xcy tC rjfuv elprfTai.
e dv6p.aTos, âfiiv, 6p66Tr]s (o-tIv avrr], r/ris ivbeCêTai, olov
(o-TL t6 TTpayfia' tovto <^G>p.(V iKavSis elpijadai.;
KP. 'E/xoi fx(v boKcl Trdvv a-^6hpa, u) 2(oKparey.

211. Aibaa-KaXCas &.pa iV(Ka to. 6v6iiaTa Aeyerot;
5 KP. H6w ye.
212. OvKovv (f}S>ixV Kal Tavrqv T\vr]v eimi Kal btf-
fxiovpyovs avTTJs;
KP. UdLW ye.
211. TCvas;
429 KP. Ova-TTep av Kar apxas fXeyfs, tovs vop.o6iTas.
211. T\6TpOV OVV KOil TaVTtfV (f)Qp.V TTfV TiXVrjV (V TOIS
avdp(aTTOis lyyCyviadai wcnre/) Kat tols aAAas t/ /z?/; ôvkopLai
b\ Xiyiiv To Toi6vb. C^ypa(f)Oi daCv ttov oi /xer xeCpovs,
5 ol be afXfCvovs;
KP. ndw y.
212. OvKovv oi /xfi; dfxeCvovs to. avT&v ipya KakXCu)
irapeyovTat., to. â, 01 8e (f)av\6Tpa; koI olKob^fxoi. ojo-avrcos
oi fxkv KoXkCovs Tas ouias kpydôvTai, oi b\ alcryjiovs;
,0 KP. Nai'.
b 211. 'Ap' ovv kclI vofxo6iTa\. oi fxkv kolKKCu) tol [tpyoL^
avTMV TTapiyovTai, oi b\ alayj.(i);
KP. Oy fioi boKii TovTO Iri.

211. OvK dpa boKovaC (roi vofxoi oi fxkv /SeXrôuy, 01 8^
5 (âvAoVepot firai;
KP. Ov 87/ra.
211. Ovbi brf ovofxa, b)S ôiKe, boKcl aoL K(L(r6ai to piiv
\(Lpov, t6 be dfXLvov;
KP. Ov bifTa.
10 211. ndrra dpa tcl dvofxaTa 6p65)S KelTaL;
d8 vuj/l] yvy T 2 Kol ante toDto add. B bi fpya seclusi

KPATTA02 429 b
KP. "Oa-a y ovofiaTd eariv.
212. Ti ovv; o Kal dpTi ikeyeTO, ÊpfxoyeveL Tw8e TroTepov

fjLrjbe ovop.a tovto KelaOaL (pQtfxev, d p.r} tl avTia 'Epp-ov C
yVar(os TTpoa-^KeL, rj Kela-QaL fXV, ov p.4vT0L dp6(a9 ye;
KP. Ovbe Kcla-daL (p.0Lye hoKO., S) SajKpares, aKKd boKelv

KiLO-QaL, (IvaL be hepov tovto Tovvojxa, ovirep Kal rj (pvaLS
[ri t6 ovopi.a brjXovcra]. 5
SX2. HoTepov ovbe \j/evbTaL oTav rty (f)fj

'Epjuoyein;
avTov etvaL; fx-q ydp ovbe tovto av fi,

to tovtov (pavaL
'Epfxoydvr] eTvaL, el fxr] eaTLv;
KP. ritoy Aeyets;
212. 'Apa OTL \f/vbr] XeyeLV to TTapdiTav ovk ea-TLV, dpa d

TOVTO (Toi bvvaTaL 6 Aoyos; a-uxvol ydp tlvS ol XeyovTes,
S (f)LX. KpaTvXe, Kal vvv Kal TraAat.

KP. 11(3? ydp dv, 0) 2wKpare?, XeyoiV yk rts Tomo
o \iyeL, fxr] to ov XeyoL; i] ov tovto eaTLV to xjfevbrj XeyeLV, 5
t6 fxr] Ta ovTa KeyeLv;

212. Kofx\l/6Tpo9 ju.ey 6 Ao'yos 17 Kar ]x Kal KaTa
Tr]v ix-i]v rjXLKLav, S) eratpe. o/^cos fxevTOL etire fxoL roo-oi^Se*
TTOTepov XeyeLV fxev ov boKel croL etrai ^l/evbrj, (f>dvai be; C

KP. Ov fxoL boKel ovbe (f>dvaL.
212. Ovbe etTrety ovbe ttpo(TLTTlv; oXov et rty aTTavTTjcras
a-oL tt\ êvias, Xaôfxevos Trjs x^'pos etTTOt* "Xaipe, o) ^V

'Adr]val, v '!2fxLKpLO}vos 'Epfxoyeves," ovtos X^LV dv 5
TavTa rf cfiaCr] dv TavTa 77 etTTOt dv ravra 77 TTpoa-eCiTOL av

ovTO) (re fXV ov, 'Êpfxoyevrf 8e Tovbe; r] ovbeva;
KP. 'Ejuoi fxkv boKL, u> 2a)Kpare?, aAAco? dv ovtos TavTa
cfÔeyâcrOai.
212. 'AAA' dyawffTov Kal tovto. iTOTepov ydp dXrfOij dv 430

c^deyâLTO Tavra 6 cf^dey^dfxevos rf \ffvbrj; r] t6 fxev tl
avTCjiv dXr]6S, t6 be \ffvbos; kol ydp dv Kal tovto iâpKOL.
C I TovTo secl. Schanz C5 tj . . . Sr]\ov(Ta secl. Schanz

e 4 |ef las] JeVr/j Cobet a 2 toCto om. T a3 iâpKoiri T

43oa nAATIlNOS
KP. ô<f)iv ty(tiy hv (\>alr\v tov toloxjtov, fjATr^v avrov
5 kavTov KivovvTa, (ocrirep hv ef tis X'^'^^^ KLVT)<ri Kpovcras.
2X2. <l>e/)e 8^, idv iTr\ biakXa-)(dG>}i(v, o) KparvKc ap'

ovK aAAo p.ev tiv (fjaitjs t6 ovofia eimi, &Kko bi (Kelvo ov
TO OVOpA (<TTLV;
KP. 'Eywye.
lo 212. OvKovv KoX To ovofm ofioXoyfls fiLiJ,r)ijA rt eivat tov
b TTpdyp.aTos;
KP. YldvTOiv p.dXL(rTa.
212. OvKovv Kal TCL C^ypacp-qfjiaTa TpoiTov tlvcl oAAoi'

Xe'yety p.Lp.rip.aTa eirai irpaypATUJV tlvu>v;
6 KP. NaC.
2i2. 4>e'pe 8^ t(r<os yap ^yo) ov p.av6dv<a arra ttot'
i<TTLV h. k4yLS, <rv 8e rd^ hv 6p6(as XeyoLS lort 8ia-

reijuai xai Trpo^reveyKdv Tavra dp.<p6Tcpa to. p.Lfxrip.aTa, Td
re ^(tiypa<f)rip.aTa KaKelva tcl 6v6fxaTa, tols T:pdyfia<rLV aJv
lo fJLLp.r]fjLaTd (TTLV, Tf ov;
C KP. "Eo-rir.
212. YlpQTOv fiev brf o-KOTret T^be. ap' dv tls Trfv fxkv
Tov dvhpos LK6va tS> dvbpl diToboLr], ttjv 8e t^s yuvatKos rfj
yvvaLKL, Kal rSAAa ovTUis;
5 KP. Hdw fxev ovv.
212. OvKovv KOL TovvavTCov T^v fxkv Tov &vhpbs Tjj yvvoiKC,
TTfv 6e TTJs yvvaLKos rw dvbpC;

KP. 'EoTi icai raOra.
2X2. 'Ap' ovv avraL al bLavofial dfL<f)6TpaL 6p6aC, rf ff
lo fTipa;
KP. 'H kT^pa.
212. *H &v kKdcrT(f oTfiaL to TrpoaiJKdv re Kat ro ofioLOV
d7ro8t8a).
KP. "E/xotye 8oKet.

d 2X2. "Iva ToCwv ju7/ fiayd)fii6a kv rots Xo'yois ky<S) re Kal
a5 Tij] Ti B b8 T({ post fjufx-fiixara om. B

KPATYA02 430ci
<ri <îXoi ovT9, CLTTobeâC fxov o Xiyoi. ttjv ToiavTr]v yap,

S) kTaip^, KoXSi iyuiye hiavojxr]V eTr' afX(f)OTpots ^xkv toIs
fxifJLrifxaa-LV, tols T C^Jôts Kal tols ovoixaaiv, opdrjv, eTTt 6e

Tois 6v6[xaa-t irpos tm 6p6r]v /cai aXrjdrj' ti]v 8' (Tepav, Tr]v 5
Tov avojxoCov b6cn,v re Kal imcfiopdv, ovk 6p6rjv, Kal \l/vbrj
OTav iiT^ 6v6p.aa-Lv r].
KP. 'AAA' oTToos pJ], d) 2w/cpar?, kv fxv toIs Quiypa<pr]-

fxaa-LV ff
TovTo, to fxi] opdojs bLavefxeLV, (ttl be toIs 6v6fxaa-LV e
ov, dAA' dvayKalov 17 dei 6p6cis.
2X2. Ylcas Aeyeis; tl tovto iKeCvov bLa(f)4pL; Sp' ovk
eoTt TTpoa-eXdovTa dvbpi rw etTreiy ort " Tovrt eo-rt aov
ypdfxfxa," kol 8etât avT(^, dv fxkv Tv\ri, Klvov etKoVa, dv 5
8e Tvxj], yvvaiKos; to 8e Seiâi kiyoi ds rrfv t&v 6<^6aXfxG)V
aXa-6ria-LV KaTaa-Trja-aL.
KP. Udvv ye.
2i2. Ti 8e; TrdX.LV avT^ tovtio iTpoa-fXdovTa etTreti/ ort

"Toirri kaTLV aov ovofxa" ; eaTL bi ttov Kal to ovofxa fxifxrffxa 10
u>aTTp To ^(j}ypd(pr]fia. tovto bi] Ae'yco* dp' ovk dv etr; avT^
eiTrety ori " Toirrt eori aov ovofxa," Kal juerd tovto ets Tr]v 431
Ti]s dKorjs av atadrâtv KaTaaTrjaaL, hv fxev TV)(y], t6 ^Keivov
fXLfxr]fxa, elTTOVTa otl dvqp, dv 8e tvxJ], t6 tov 6r]keos tov
dvdpoiiTivov yevovs, eliTovTa otl yvvr]; ov 80/cet crot tovto
oXov T elvaL koX yiyvea6aL evioTe; 5
KP. 'E6e\.(a aoL,ai^(aKpaTes, avyxodpv^âi- nal ecrrtt) ovTtiis.
212. KaA<Ss ye crv ttolwv, co <pi\e, el eori tovto ovTdiS'

ovbev ydp bet vvv Trdvv btafxdyea6at Trept avTov. et 8' ovv
eaTt TotavTT] tls bLavofxr] Kal evTavda, t6 fxev eTepov tovtcov b
dXr]6eveiv fiovkofxeda Kakelv, t6 8' eTepov êvbeadai. ei 8e
TOVTo ovTOiis e\et, Kal eaTi fxrj 6p6(as btavefxetv rd 6v6fxaTa
fxrfbe diTobtbovat rd 7Tpocn]KOVTa eKdoTC), dAA' evioTe rd fxrj
TTpoarfKOVTa, eir] dv Kal prffxaTa Taxrrdv tovto iTOLetv. ei be 5
d3 iyci) KoAdJ 76 T d5 t^] tJ B e 10 5e om. B a8 ov-

5ej/] ovSk B
43ib nAATflNOS
prjfji.aTa koX dvofiaTa tcmv ovto) Tidivai, hf&yKr) Koi Xoyow
C Aoyoi y6.p ttov, ws eyw/xai, rj TOVTUiV (rvv9((TLS eortv t; Troiis
Acyets, Si KpaTvKc;
KP. OvTOi' KaXias ydp p.0L boKeis X4yeiv.
2i2. OvKovv (l ypap.p.a<nv av to. irpGiTa dv6p.aTa htteiKiL-
5 C(^p.V, li(TTLV oocnrep iv tols (oiypa(firi}xa(TLV koll iravTa to.
TTpocrriKOVTa xpdfxaTa re Kal (r)(ripiaTa aTTobovvaL, Kal p.r]
TrdvTa av, oAA.' ivLa (XKeLTreLV, evLa be Kal "npocmdivaL, kox

TrAeift) KoX p.LC(ii' 7/ OVK (.(TTLV;
KP. "E^TTLV,
lo 212. OvKovv 6 piev a7ro8t8ovs Trdirra Kaka tcl ypdpLfxaTa
T Kal TCLS elKOvas d7ro8t8coo-tr, 6 8e t/ Trpoortêi? rj d(ât-
pwy ypdpLfiaTa pikv Kal et/cofas epydêrai Kat ovtos, dAAd

TTOVTfpds;
d KP. Nai'.
2i2. T^ 8^ 6 bia t&p (rvWaôiv tc kol ypaixfxdToiV rqv

oiKTLav TGtv TTpayfxdTCtiv dirofXLfxovfxevos ; apa ov /card tov
avTOV Xoyov, av p.V TtdvTa diTob^^ to. TTpo(rrfKOVTa, KaXrf
5 ff elKUiV 4araL tovto b* eoriv ovofxa edr 8^ a-fXLKpa
lAAeÛT/ 17 TTpooTi^T} IvLOTC, dKoiV fxkv yivrfo-eTaL, KoXr] 8e
o^; uxTTC To. pikv KoX&s dpyacTfiiva larat t5>v 6vofxdT(tiV, rd

8e KaK(jis;
KP. '10-0)9.
e 212. "lo-o)? dpa lorai 6 jxkv dyados brffXLOvpybs ovofxdTcov,

6 8e KaKds;
KP. Nai'.
212. OvKovp ToruT(a 6 " vofxoOiTrfs " ^v ovofxa.
6 KP. Nat'.
212. 'lo-coy dpa vif At" eorat, &a-7Tp iv rais oAAats
re'xyats, Kat vofxodcTrfs 6 fx(V dyaOos, 6 bk kokos, idvirfp

TCL (fXTTpo(rd(V fKelva ofxoXoyrfdfj rffxTv.
KP. "EoTi TavTa. dAA' opas, Si 2&)Kpares, orar raCra
b 6 Mnara] ovk iy6fMira T 676 ante KO/ioflfTTji T

KPATTA02 431 e
ra ypafifxaTa, t6 T aX<f)a Kal to î]Ta Koi fKaarov rG>v lo
o-roiyjeiiav , rois 6v6âa-i.v airoStSoS/xey rfj ypafJLixaTLKfj r^xvr},
idv Ti d(f)\(i)iJ.v 7] iTpo(TdQ)p.iv 7} fxeTa6u>p.V Ti, (pv) 438

ysypainal fxev TjfiXv to ovofxa, ov fxevToi opQSis, dKXa to
TTapaTrav ovb yiypainaL, dAA' v6vs Tepov icTTLV kav tl
TovT(t}V Trd^rj.
2i2. M?/ yap ov KaAco? (TKOTrcU/xey ovro) crKOTTOvvres, a> 5
KpaTvXc.
KP. U&s bri;
212. "lo-cos ocra 4k rivos dpidfxov dvayKOLOv Lvai 7/ fxr)
LvaL "ndcTypL hv tovto o (Tu Xeyeis, uxnrfp Kal avra

To. beKa rj ootls (Bovkei. d\Xos dpLdfxos, edv dcpeXrjs tl Tf lo
TTpoa-6fjs, Tpos v6vs yiyow rov h\ ttolov tlvos Kal b

(rvfXTTaaTfs (Ikovos jut) ovx o,VTri (_^fi) 77 opôTrjs, dXka to
(vavTLov ovbe to irapdTTav birj iTdvTa dirobovvaL olov kcTTLV
d) eiKaCet, eJ fxekXeL eiKoji' eiyat. o-KoireL 6e el rt Aeyo).
ap' dv bvo TTpdyfxaTa etr] rotaSe, otoi' Kparvkos Kal Kpa- 5

tt;Aou etKwr, et tls 6U)V fxr] fxovov ro crov \pG)p.a kox
(T)(7//xa dTTLKdcrLV u)(nTp ol ^coypd(})OL, oAAa Kal rd ivrbs
Trdvra TOLavTa 77ot7/a-etei' otaTre/p rd (rd, koX fxaXaKOTrfTas
Ka\ 6pfx6Tr]Tas rds avTas diToboLr], Kal KLvrja-LV Kal \}rv)(r]v C
Kat (f)p6vr]a-LV otaTT^p rj iTapa crol fv6Lr] avrols, Kal evl Aoyw
TTai^ra aTrep av )(êLs, roLavTa eTepa Karao"r?/cretei' TTKrfaLOV
(Tov; TT^Tepov KpaTvXos dv Kal eiKcbv KpaTvkov ror' etr] rd
roLovrov, 7/ bvo Kparvkoi; 5
KP. Avo epLOLye boKOvaLV, o) ^(oKpares, KparvKoL.
212. Opqs ovv, 0) 0iAe, ori dWrjv xpr] etKoros 6pd6Tr]Ta
^T/rety Kai S>v vvvbr] eXiyofxev, koI ovk dvayKaCeLv, edv tl
dTTjj 7/ TTpo(rf], fxr]KTt avrrjv etKoya etvat; ?/ ovk alcrddvr] d
oaov (vbeovaLV al etKoVej ra avTa eêLV eKetfots u)V etKoVes
fla-iv;
e 10 eKcurrov] ^v fKacrrov T ai oy add. Bekker ba ^ add.

Heindorf b^ (vavTioy^ tv avrlf o/ pr. T b^ i^ scripsi :
t BT c8 caJ . . eAfyofiev secl.

. Schanz TjjTisT
PLATO, VOL. 1. 16
432d nAATQNOS
KP. "Eywyf.
5 2i2. reAoia yovv, a> KparvKf, vTrh rSiV ovofjidToiV irddoi
av KLva &v ovoixaTd ioTiv To. ovofiaTa, d TrdvTa TravTaxfj

avTots ofxomdeCr). btTTa yap av ttov itdvTa yevoiTo, Kal
ovK h.v iyoi avT(ov dirfiv (pvbds) ovbeTfpov cmoTfpov cori

To fikv avTo, To b\ ovofia,
10 KP. "kky]dr) Xcyety.
S12. Qappwv Toiwv, 5 y(vvau, ia kolI ovofxa to fikv ev

e Keio-âi, to be firf, Ka\ pJr) dvdyKaê Tidvr (XeiJ^ tcl ypafi-
fxaTa, Xva KOftLbff ff

tolovtov oloviTep ov ovofid ioTLV, dAA
ea Kal t6 fxrf TTpooiJKOV ypdfxfxa ^TrL(f)epLV. d 6^ ypdfxfxa,
Ka\ 6vop.a ev Adyo)* ei 8e ovofxa, Ka\ Xoyov ev \6y(o fxj]
5 TtpoarfKOVTa Tols irpdyfxaa-LV eiTLcêpecrOaL, koL fxtfbtv rfTTOv

ovofxdCeardaL to iTpdyfxa Kal XeyeaOaL, ojs hv 6 tvttos (V^
Tov TrpdyfxaTos TTepl ov &v 6 Ao'yo? jf,
(na-iTep iv tol9
433 Ta>v (TTOLXiiciV 6if6fxaa-iv, el ix4fxvrfaai b, wvbrf iyoi koI
'EfôyevTfs eAeyo/uer.
KP. 'AAAa fxifxvTffxai.
212. KoAws roLVW. STav yap tovto ivff, k^v fxrj vdvTO
5 Ta TTpoa-vfKovTa exV' ^'^f''"' y^ '"^ TTpdyfxa, /caAwy oTav
TTdvTO, KaKws be orav oXCya' XeyeadaL 8' ovv, a> fxaKapLf,
(Gifxev, tva fxrf 6(f>\(iifkev &a~iTep ol iv Alyivrf vvKTUip Trepi-
loyre? dê obov, Ka\ fffxeLi (tt\ tcl TrpdypxiTa b6^(t}fuv av
b r^ dXrfOeCci ovtio ttcos eXrfXvOevat 6\f/taLTepov tov beovTos,
rf Cv'''^'-
''^^ aAATji; 6v6fxaTos opd^rrfTa, Ka\ fxi] 6/oioAo'yei
brfX(ji)p.a avXXaâh Ka\ ypdfXfxaaL iTpdyfxaTos 6vofxa etvaL.
el yap ravTa dfX(p6Tpa epels, ovx oXos t ccn; avfX(f>oivelv
6 (Tam^.
KP. 'AAAa fxoL boKeLS ye, 2 SwKpare?, fierpitos Xeyeiv,
Ka\ ouro) TLdefxat.

212. 'E7rei8^ toCwv raCra Tffxlv (TvvboKeL, fxeTO, raGra
d 8 ?x<"s vel ?x< Ttj Heindorf ovStU addidi e6 Jcbj] iii B

as \f\f^(rai al. a? tya] &T a8 6<j/i 6dov] suspicor a<|/r/to5
vel fort. iylnoilov scribendum esse nS Heindorf: oi-rp BT

KPATTA02 433 b
rabi (TKOiT&ixev' d fieAAei <f)afikv Ka\&s KeXcrdaL to ovofJia,
ra TTpoa-qKovra 8ei avro ypdixfiara (X^îv; o
KP. Nat'.
212. ripoo-T^Ket 8e ra o/xoia rois TTpdyfxaa-iv; C

KP. naru ye.
212. Ta /xey apa /caXws KeCpieva ovrai Keirat' ei 8e /0177
Tt KoAw? ere^^rj, to fikv av Tro\v lo-cos eK Trpoa-riKovTcov eir/
ypaix[j.aT(t)V Kal ofxoLoiv, (tirep ecrrat (Ikwv, exot 8' ay rt 5
Kat ov TTpoarJKov, 8t' o ovk Sy Ka\ov etrj oiSe KaAw?

(IpyacTfxivov to 6vop.a. ovto) (f)aixkv rj aAAco?;
KP. OvSey 8et oTfxai. btafidxffrOai, Si 2ajKpares' eTret ovk
dpea-Kei yi jue ro (pdvai. 6vo\xa pikv etiât, ju,?/ fxivTOi KoXcas
ye Keicrât. 10
212. HoTepov TOVTO ovk dpicTKH cre, to elvai to 6vo\xa d

hr\k(j)ixa Tov npdyp.aros;
KP. "Ejuotye.
212. 'AAAa to itvai r&v ovofxdTOiV to, p.V Ik irpoTepwv
a-vyKLfxeva, Ta 8e irp&Ta, ov KaAws aot doKet KiyeaOaL; 5
KP. "E/xotye.
2i2. 'AAAa tcl irpQtTa ei fxiXXeL brfXcafnard tlvcdv yCyve-
crOaL, exets rtiâ KoXkCti) TpoTTOv tov 8r]Acoju.ara avra yevicrOaL

dXXov 7) avrd iroLrjaaL ort /xciAto-ra TOLavTa ota eKeLva h. 8et e
6r/Aow avrci; r\ o8e /xaAAoi; cre dpiaKeL 6 Tpoiios ov 'Ep-
\xoyivr\s XiyeL kol oAAoi ttoAAoi, ro crvvdr\\xaTa etiât ra
ovofLaTa Kal br\\ovv rot? a-ovdefxivoL^ TrpoeLbocrL 8e ra
TTpdyfiaTa, Kal eirat Tavrqv 6p66Tr\Ta 6v6\xaT0s, avv6r\Kr\v, 5
bLacf)ipLV 8e oiiSey eciyre rt? crvv6rJTaL u>(n:ep vvv avy-

Ketrat, earre Kai TOvvavTCov eirt /xey w rw afLLKpov, fxeya
KoAetv, eTTi 8e w /xeya, a-fXLKpov; TTOTepos cre 6 TpoiTOS
dpia-KiL;
bg ToSe] 5e b 10 airb] aurw (sic) T

T e8 /ioxfrOoj T
d3 ffi.ol T
ye Bekker
: (fjii d 5 ou AfoAws t ouk &W(as B (in T :
plurima desunt) e i & om, T ea ^] ^ T: koj ^ B 7 ^]

o B T (sed ex emend, B) e 8 ^ /**7] " M*? T
16*
;
434a nAAT12N02
434 KP. "OAw Ka\ travTl bia^fyepei,, S "S.titKpares, to 6fioL(anaTi
br]\ovv OTL av rty br]\oi &Wa fir} tw (iri.Tvx6vTi.
SH. KaA(Ss Xeyety. ovkovv eiTrep ea-Tai, to ovofxa ofjioiov
ro) irpdyixaTi., dvayKalov ir(f)VKvaL to. o-roixcia ofxoLa roiy
5 TtpdyfiacTLV, ^^ &v tcl Trp&Ta 6v6p.aTd tls avvOrja-eL; t58e

8^ keyoi' Spd Tror' &v tls a-vviOrjKev & vvvbr] eXeyofiev
^(oypd(pr]iJ.a opiOLov ro) T(av ovt(ov, el p.i] (pv(TeL viTrjp\e
b (f)appLaKLa op.oLa ovTa, e^ (av avvTLOeTaL to, C<^ypa(f)0VfJLva,
fKCLVOLS h p.Lfj.elTaL T) ypa(f)LKri' r] dbvvaTov;

KP. 'A8waror.
212. OvKovv u)aavT(t)9 Kal ovofxaTa ovk dv Trore o/xota
5 yevoLTO ovbevi, et fxi] VTrdpêL (Kelva irpoiTov 6fj.0L6Tr]Td TLva

iyovTa, e^ 5)V avvTiOeTaL to. ovofiaTa, (KeivoLS ^v i(rTL to.
6v6p,aTa fiLfxrffiaTa; ecrTi be, e^ aJr avvdeTeov, aTOL\La;

KP. Nai.
2X2. "Wbr) Toivvv Kal av KOLvdvr] tov Xoyov ovirep apTi
C *Epp.oyvr]s. <f)ep, koXo^s (tol boKovfLev XeyeLV otl to /5(3 rt]
ôpa Kal KLVqaeL Kal (TKkr\p6Tr]TL TipocreoLKev, rj ov KokQs;

KP. KaA.a)s ifLOLye.
212. To be Aa/38a rw Xeto) /cat fj.a\aK(D Kal ols wvbrj
5 keyofj.ev;
KP. Nar.
212. Oto-â ovv oTL eirl rw avT(a r;/iet? fiev (fâfiev
**
a-KXr]p6Tr]s," 'EpeTpLrjs be " crKXr]poTi]p"
KP. Udw ye.

lo 212. YloTepov ovv t6 r pu) kcil to (rlyfia eoLKev dp.^6Tepa
Tto) avT(^, KOL brfkoL eKeivoLs re to avro Te\evT5>vTos tov
pS) Ka\ Tffuv Tov a-lyfxa, rf rois eTepoLS r]fj.S>v ov brfkoX;
d KP. AtjXoi p.ev ovv dfJ.(f)OTepoLS.
212. n^Tepov 1] ofxoLa rvyydveL ovTa t6 pS) koX t6 avyfxa,
^ V H-V!
a6 Apo Sir^r' &v BT C] Ttji auT^] r6 avrh T C 8 ffK\ff

poriip B : sine accentu T : aKXvpiriip al. d a jcol] t Koi B
KPATTA02' 434 d
KP. ^Ht o/xota.
2X2. 'H ovv ofJLOtd la-TL TravTaxfj; 5
KP. Hpos ye to trro)? (popav brjXovv.

2X2. 'H Kal To Ad/38a kyKdp.^vov; ov to havTiov brjKoi ~
(TKkrjpOTrjTOS;
KP. "Icra)? yap ovk 6p6a>s iyKîTai, S 2a)/cpaTes" uxnrep

Kal h wvbr) av Trpos Êpixoyevr] eXeyes (âip&v re Kat lo
ivTtOds ypdfiixaTa ov bioL, Kal 6p6G>s kboKHS l/xotye. Kai
vvv i(ra)S avTL tov Ka^ba pS> 8et keyecv.
211. Ev kiyets. Tt ovv; vvv ws kiyop.(V, ovbev p.av6d- e

vopLV dkXrikuiv, CTreibdv tis " a-Kkr]p6v," ovbe oTcrOa crv
(j)fi
vvv oTi eyo) kiycn;

KP. "Eyo^ye, bid ye to e6os, 2 (plkTaTe.
212. "Eôs be keycov otet Tt bid(j)opov keyeiv (rvv6r]Kr]s; 5
^ dAAo Tt kiyeis to e6os r] ori eyw, oTav tovto (f)6eyy(i:.pLaL,
btavoovpiai eKelvo, av be yiyvcaaKeis otl (Kelvo bLavoovpiaL;
ov TOVTO keyeLs;
KP. Nat. 435
2X2. OvKovv et ytyvwo-Kets e/xou (\>6eyyopiivov, SÂwjLta
o-ot ytyjêrat Trap e/xou;
KP. Nat'.
212. 'Atto tov dvop.oLov ye r] o bLavoovp.evos ^ê'yyojwat, 5
etTrep to kdjSba dvopiOLov eo-Tt tt] ^ (fyrjs (tv (rKkr]p6Tr]TL' ei

8e TOVTO ovTMS e)(et, Tt dAAo rj avTos aavT^ (rvve6ov KaC -
aoL yiyveTaL r] 6p66Tr\s Tov 6v6p.aTos (rvv6riKr], eireLbr] ye

8r;Aot Kat Ta o]xoLa Kal to. dvdpoLa ypdpLpaTa, 6ovs Te fcai
(rvv6i]Kr]s Tv^dvTa; et b' otl pt.dkL(TTa /xt/ eo-Tt t6 e6os 10

(rvv6r]Kr], ovk av Kak&s TL exot keyeLV rqv 6p.OL6Tr]Ta b
br]ka)pa elvaL, dkka to 6os' exetiô ydp, ws eotKe, Kat
opoLio Kal dvopoL(D br]kot. e7ret8^ 8e Tavra crvyx(^povp.ev,

w KpaTvke Tr]V ydp (rLyr]V (tov (rvy\(apr](TLV 6r]a-(a dva-
yKatdv TiOV Kal avv6i]Kr]v tl Kal 6os avp.^dkka6aL Trpos 5
ds ^ ovySfiOiaom.B a6 ai>6fioi6v]S/xoiovB \3 5 avnfia\(adaiT

435b nAATIlNOS
8Â.a)(ny c5y bLavoovixcvoL XiyofXfV ^Trei, S /SeArioTe, ci
'^Âeis ^TT^ Toy apLdixbv iKOelv, iToOev oUl e^fLV ovofjLara
ojxoLa kvl eKdtoTfa) tu)V apLOfxCiv ^TreveyKeLV, iav /xj; ^fis n

C Tr}V crr]V opLoKoyCav Kot crvv6r]Kr]V Kvpos ^X^*-^
'"'^" 6vopi.aTU}V
opOorqTos irepL; ipi.ol pikv ovv Kal avT<a apea-KCL fxev KaTo, t6
bvvaTov opuOLa eii/at tcl 6v6p.aTa toIs iTpdyfj.aa-LV' a\\a /i^
ws 6Xr]6(as, t6 tov 'KppLoyivovs, yKL(Tyj>a fj

r) oAkt) avrr] rrjs
S opiOLorqTOS, ovayKOLOV he r] xat Toi (fyopTLKca Tovrta Tipo^T-
\pri<r6aL, t^ a~vv6r]Kr], eJs ovopidTcov 6p66Tr]Ta. ^Trei lcrcos
KaTd ye t6 SwaToi' kcIAAio-t' &i' A^yoiTO otoi' rj Traa-LV rj
&S irXiCaTots byuolois XiyrjTai, tovto 6' iarl TtpocrfiKovcnv,

d aXayLo-Ta h\ TovvavTLOV. Tobe be piOL Iti eiTr^ /iCTa Tavra,
TLva r]p.LV bvvap.LV ^x^l tcl ovopaTa Kal tl <\>S>iiiV avra Kak6v
aTTpyd(a-6aL;
KP. ALbda-KCLV ifxoLye Sokci, a> ScoKpaTf?, Kai tovto Trdw
5 aiTXovv LvaL, 6y hv tcl 6v6p,aTa ^TTLarqTaL, TTLa-Taa-6ai Kal

TCL iTpdyp.aTa.
212. "la-cos ydp, o) KpaTvAe, t6 TotoVSe Aeyets, &)S îTfLbdv
TLs ei8r) t6 ovop.a ol6v co-tlv eo-Tt 8e oloviTfp t6 TTpayp.a

e ftcreTOi brf koI t6 'npayp.a, ^TreiTrep op.oLov TvyxdvfL 6v tu
6v6p.aTL, T^xyq be fiia ap' iarlv ?; avTq iTdvTcov T(av oAAt;-
Aots ofxomv. KaTO. tovto 8j; \xol SoKets Ae'yety s os h.v Ta
6v6p.aTa dbi] eto-eTai Kat tcl iTpdyp.aTa.
5 KP. 'A\r]dicrTaTa Ae'yet?.
212. "Exe bq, Lb(i)pv TLS ttot hv etr] 6 Tpdrros mrros Trjs
StSao-KaAtay Ta>v ovTu>v 6v oo Ae'yeis vvv, Kal iTOTfpov eori
p.iv Ka\ aAAos, ovtos p.4vT0L /SeATitoi;, rf ovb' (.(ttlv oAAos
7] OVTOS. TTOTip(i>S 0LL;
436 KP. OuTtos eycoye, ov iTdvv Ti ftvai &\kov, tovtov b^ koX
pLovov Kal ^(Ktlcttov.

2X2. rio^Tepoj; 8^ Kat evpea-iv tQv ovtcov ttjv avTrjV Tavnjv
b6 \.4ywfxtyT c8 6ftotots Heindorf : Sfiolm TiT ds M-

crratrdai om. pr. T a3 fSptiriy'} aSpfaiy T
;
KPATTA02 436 a
(ivai, Tov ra ovoixaTa evpovTa Kal eKelva T]vpr]Kivai &v ((ttl
To. ovofjLaTa' 17 Ct''^^^ /*^^ '^^'' ^vpiaKiW Tpov belv Tpo-nov, 5
p.av6aveiv 8e tovtov;
KP. YlavTOiV ixaXLO-Ta Kal Cv"^^^ '^^'- (vpC<TKiv tov avTov
TpOTTOV TOVTOV KaTCL TaVTCL,

2i2. 4>ep 8^ hvorja-oifxev, S) KpaTvXe, et Ti? ^tjtcSi' tcl
i:payp.aTa aKokovdol tols dvopiacrL, ctkott&v oXov ^KacrTov b

/SovXerai elvaL, ap ivvods otl ov o-fjiLKpbs KLvbvvoi kcrTLV
kâTTaTqOrjvaL;
KP. U&s;
2f2. AT/Aor oTi 6 BipLcvos Trpwro? tcl Sv6p.aTa, ota T^yeiro 5
(ivai ra TrpdyixaTa, TOiavTa iTLd^TO Koi tol ovofxaTa, u>s
<\>ap.ev. Yi ydp;
KP. Nai.
20. Ei ovv KLvos pLT] opdZs rjyeTro, lêro he ota ^yetro,
ri otei TjpMs Tovs dKoX.ov6ovvTas avT(a Treio-eo-âi; aAAo rt 7; 10
eâTrarTj ^^ o-e<râi
KP. 'AAAa fxr] ovxovro)? X^' ^ ^(oKpaTcs, dXk' dvayKOLOV
7] (IboTa TL6(T6aL Tov TL64pLvov TCL 6v6\xaTa' ei 8e p.r], OTrep c

jToAat eyo) (Xeyov, ovb' av ovojxaTa eiTj. fxiyL(rTov bi aoi
4a-T(ii TeKfxiqpLov otl ovk ea-âArai r?]? oArjêtas 6 riêjueros'
01 yap ay Trore ovrco <rvfX(f)cova ^v avTca aTravTa. rj ovk

Vv6LS avTos Xiyciiv ws Trarra KaTO. tovtov kcll kiu TavTov 5
eyCyvfTO tcl 6v6p.aTa;

212. 'AAAa tovto fxiv, ayaOi KparvAe, ovbiv icrTLV diTO-
X6yr}ixa. et ydp to TrpSiTov cr^paXfls 6 TL6i\xvos TaXXa ybrj
TTpds TOVT e/3tdêro Kat avrai a-vpL^fxoveLV rjvdyKaCfV, ovbfv d

aTOTTOv, uiaTTep twv bLaypapLjxaTdiv evLOTe tov TTp(t>Tov (rpLLKpov
Kal oStjAou \lf(vbovs yevojxivov, Ta AotTra 7rd/i77oAAa ijbr] ovTa
e7ro'p.era o/xoAoyety oAAvjAots'. 8et br] Trepi ttjs dpxrjs TTavTos
TTpdyixaTos Trai^ri dr8pt tov ttoXvv Xdyov eirai cat Tr]v iroXXr^v 5
a-Ki\f/LV eire 6pd<as etre fxr] vTTO^/cetraf Kivr]s 8e eêrao-êtoTjs
bI &KoAoi;6ct T b 12 exj7 B 05 Kari TavThv] kut' avTh B om. T

:
436d nAATHNOS
iKavcis, To, \oLTTa <f)aCv(T6ai ^Kiivrf kiioyiiva. ov jxevToi aXXa
e davfidôi^' av ei /cat to. 6v6fj.aTa a-vixcfjaivd avTO. avTols.
TrdtXiv yap 67rtcr/cev//^w/jte0a h. to TrpoTepov bi.T]K6ofjL(v. ws
TOV TTaVTOS ioVTOS T Kol (fxpopAvOV KOX piovT^s (f)ap.(V
a-ri}xaiveiv i]p.lv ti]V ova-iav to. 6v6p.aTa. akKo tl ovtu} (tol
5 8oKet br]\ovv;
437 KP. ndvv a-(f)6bpa, Kat 6p6cii ye (rT]p.aivL,
212. ^KOTr(o]Xv bi] i^ avTtav avaKafi6vT(s irpSiTov [xev
TOVTO TO ovojxa, Ti]V " TTL(rTi]ixr]v," d)s d]x(f)iô\6v [co-Ttl,
Kol ]xdKkov 0LK (rr]]xaivovTL otl to-Trja-LV t]]xQ)v ^tti tois
5 Trpdyixaa-i Tr]v ^XV^ V on a~vp.TTpL(f)pTcu, koI 6p66Tp6v

k(TTLV &(nTp vvv avTov Tr]v dp)(r]V Xiy^LV fxdWov r] e/ix/3a\-
XovTas To et " TTL(TTr]fxr]v," dXKa ttjv ifxlBoKi^v TT0Lr]a-acr6ai
dvTl Ttjs V T(S et V T(S l&Ta. iTTLTa TO " îjBaLOV," OTL
/3a(rea)S tlv6s koTLV koll (TTtxcrea)? ixi]xr]]xa oAX' ov (f)opds.
b TTLTa f]
" L(rropia" avTo ttov ariixaivL otl X(rTr]rrL tov
povv. Kal To"TTiaTov" ia-Tav TravTaTTa^rL (rr]fxaivL. TTLTa
b fj " ]xvr\p.r]" TTavTi ttov ]xr]vvL otl fxovrj ia-TLV V Trj yfrvxfl
dAA' ov (popd. et 8e fBovK^L, f] " dfxapria" /cai f] " av]X(f)Opa,'
5 et Kara to 6vop.d tls dKoKov6r]aL, <f)avLTaL Tavrov r^
" (rvv(rL " TavTr] /cat " TTLa~n]fxr] " Kal Tols aAAots ira^n
TOts Trept TCL OTTOvbaLa ovdfxaaLV. TL tolwv f] " dfxa6ia
Ka\ f]
" aKoKaa-ia " TTapairKrâ-ia tovtols (f)aivTai' fj fxkv
ycip Tov dpia êoi ôVtos iTopeia (f)aivTaL, " dfxa6ia,"

C f]
f]
8' " dKoKaaia" TTavTaTTaaLV dKoKov6ia toIs Trpdyfxaa-L
(f)aivTaL. Kal ovtcds, h vofxiô]XV tt\ tols KaKiaTOLS 6v6-
fxara ^lvaL, ofxoLOTaT dv (f)aivoLTO tols ttl tols /coAAtWots.
5 olfxaL be /cat aAAa ttoÂA' dv tls vpoL ei iTpayp.aTevoLTo,
i^ S>v oir]6ir] dv av iTaKLV tov to. ovofxaTa tl6]xvov
ovx). idvra ovSe (f)p6fXva oKKd fXVOVT(X TO. iTpdyfxaTa
a-qfxaiviv.
aa fxiv'] fiiv 8)/ pr. T a^ ô-ti om. T a6 iKPiWoyraT B

a7 iirfi(rT-fjfj.r}v Heindorf: iiri<rTiini}v BT: Ki(Tri,n.r)v al. dAAcb . . .
a 8 iwTo secl. Ast

;
KPATTAOS 437d
KP. 'AA.A.', S '^(OKpare^, opas otl to, TToXka eKeiVcos d

(cn][iai.vV.
212. Ti ovv TovTO, > KparvAe; uxritep xjrqcfôvs hiapiOpL-r]-
(Toixeda To. dvofxaTa, Kal kv rovro) eo-rat rj opOoTrjs; oTTOTepa
av TrAetoi (fyaivrjTaL to, ovopiaTa (rf]y.aivovTa, Tama hi] tcTTai. 5
roATj^^;
KP. OvKovv (Ikos ye.
2X2. OvS' oTrcooTtow, S </)tXe. Kot rairra /xey ye avrou
eao-co/ixey, eir(weX.d(i)ixv 8e TroAii' oêy 8eu/oo ixTi^r]p.ev. 43^

aprt yap er rot? TTpocrQev, et p.ep.vr](raL, tov TL6t]XVov to.
6v6p.aTa avayKaZov (^r]cr6a itvai elhoTa TiOeaOaL ots iTiOiTO.

TTOTCpOV OVV (TL (TOL boKL OVTOOS r] OV;
KP. ''Ert. 5
2X2. 'H Kat Tov to. Trpwra TL64fxevov etSora (Pf]s rtêo-âi;
KP. EtSoVa.
2X2. 'Ek ttolcov ovv ovofKiT^tiV r/ ]x]xadr]KOi}S i] r]vpr]K(os ^v
To. TTpayp.aTa, etTrep rd ye TTp^Ta [xt^ttoo (.k.ito, fxade^LV 5' av b
(f>aixv To. TTpdyixaTa Kal evpcLV abvvaTov etyat oAAcos 17 ra
oiô^/xara ]xa66vTas rj avTovs kêvp6vTas dta ((ttl;
KP. AoKet? rt p.0L XiyeLV, S 2(oKpares.

2X2. Ttra oSy tp6ttov (fiQfxev ovtovs etSoray 6icr6aL ?; 5
vo]xo6Tas elvaL, frplv Kal otlovv ovofxa KeLcrâi re Kai
K(ivovs etSeVat, etirep /x^ eort tcl TTpayfxaTa fxaêlv dAA' 7/
eK roiJy 6vofxa.T(t)V
KP. Ot/xat /xey eyo) roy akr]6(TTaTov koyov Trept tovtol>v c

etiât, 2) 2o5Kpares', /xet^ca rtrd hvvafXLV elvaL ?/ av6pu>TTiav
d I e/cetVous] (Kfivtj) B a I post ia(T<tifx(v add. d in marg. man,

rec. TaSe Se fin<TKf\pufj.(dcL, d tîxlv Kal T7J5e 6/1x0X076?$ elfrf jcal ofc
(pipf, Tovs To ov6fj.aTa fv Ta7s ir6\e<n TiQejXfvovs eKdcTTore, ev Tt TaTi
'^Wr]viKa7s Ka\ âp0apiKa7s, ovk apTius &fj.oKoyovfj.ev vofioOeTas elvai Ka\
T^v Texvvv TT)V TOVTO ivvaixevT)v vofJ.oQeTiKr]V ; KP. Tlavv ye. ICi. Aeye
S-fi. ol irpuTOi vofxoBiTai to. irpwTa 6i/6fiaTa ttoTepov ytyvclxTKovTes to
irpiyfxaTa, ois eTidevTO. eTidevTo f) ayvoovvTes; KP. Olfiai fxev iyti. S>
'S.diKpaTes, yiyvticTKOVTes. 211. Ou ydp ttou (1. irou\ & eToipe KpaTv\e,
ayvoovvTes ye. KP. 06 fxoi SoKel. mox add. eadem manus k Troiaiv
Se ut significet a i iiraveKdfnfiey . a 7 ei56ra omittenda esse
. .
438 c nAATHNOS
rqv dfjxevrjv tcl Trp&Ta ovofxaTa rols "npdyfiaaiv, w(tt(
hvayKoiov elvai. avra 6p6ios Ix***^*
5 2X2. Etra oUi kvavTia av ^rtêro avros avrl^ 6 OeCs, lov
haifjMV Tts 7/ 6(6s; rj ovhiv croL iboKovjxev apTi Kiyuv;

KP. 'AAAci p.1] ovK rjv tovtmv to. (Tcpa ovopxiTa.
212. Ilorepa, w apLCTTe, to. ttI tt]V a-Taa-iv 6.yovTa 7/ to,
^ttI ttjv (f)opa.v; ov ya.p ttov KaTO. rb apTi Kiydiv 'nX.rj6n,
lo Kpidrj(T(Tai.
d KP. Ourot 8^ hiKaiov ye, w 2<)K/)ares.
2f2. Ôvop.aT(iiv ovv (rTaa-ia^rdin-oiiv, koI rc5v fikv âa-KOVTOiV

âura etvai tcl opLOta Trj aXrfdfiî, Ta>v 8' ka\jT<x, Tivi Iri 8ia-
KpLVovp.v, r) kiil Ti \66vTs; ov ykp Tiov i.Ta 6v6p.aTd yc
5 (Tepa d\X.a TovTOiv ov yap ea-TLV, dXXd bijKov otl oAA' dTTa
CrfTrfTâ irX.rfv 6vop.dT(jov, h rffxiv ifX(f)avLL dvfv 6vofLdT<ov
OTT^TCpa TOVTdiv ecTrt TdXrfdij, bciâvTa bffXov otl Trfv dX-qdcLav
tS>v ovtcov.
e KP. AoKei flLOL OVT(l).
2X2. "Ea-TLV dpa, ws ioLK(v, S) KparvKe, bvvaTov fxaêlv

avev ovoftdTcov ra ovTa, tTrep TavTa ovrcos ^x^**
KP. atVerai.
5 2X2. Ata rtvo? aAAou ovv ^tl irpoaboKas dv raCra

fmdcLv; dpa bC aAAou tov rj ovirep flKos re fcat bLKaLOTaTov,
8t' dX\rf\(i)v ye, ei ttt/ avyyevrj iaTLV, Kal avTa 8t' avTcav;
t6 ydp TTov (Tfpov eKiv(x)V koX aAAoiov tTepov dv tl Kal
dAAotoy aifffxaivoL dAA' ovk kKtiva*
lo KP. ÂXrf6rf fxoL (paivrf X4y(LV.
439 2X2. 'Exe brf iTpbs Al6s' Ta bi 6v6fxaTa ov TroAAaKis

fxivTOL i)fxoXoyrf<Tafxev Ta KoXSts Keifxcva ioLKOTa (Tvai iK(ivots
wv 6v6fxaTa Keirat, Kat eirai tlKdvas T&v TrpayfxdTOiv;
KP. Nat.
C$ 6 6eh iiipi: 6 Bit<rwv BT C^^vBT:^ ^'ulg. c9 <popav'\

ffvfKpopdv T iroii] irei> T di odroi Heindorf: ovtih BT
ds &\Aa] ixTa Heusde d6 iixâyift] ifi^vTi tlT 65 TaCro]
avrh al. e 7 yt] rt Heindorf e 8 i^Xolov Heusde : iXKo ttvhT
KPATTA02 439 a
212. Et OVV i<TTL ixkv OTL /xaAtcTTa bt 6vOIJ,dTCdV to, TTpd- 5
yfjLaTa p.av6dvei.Vy(.(TTi. 8e koa. bC avToiv, TtOTepa av etrj KaWioyv

Kol cra(f>(rT4pa ri fidOricris; K ttjs eiKoVoy pLav6dvLV avn^v
re avri]v ei KaAwj eiKaorat, Kai ttjv akr\6eiav tJs riv (Ikcov,
7] eK TTJs dXr^deCas avTi]V re avr)]v koI ti]V eiKoVa avrqs et b

TTpe-noirrcos eipyacTTaL;
KP. 'Ek TTJs dkr]6e(as pioi 8oKet dvdyKr] etmi.

212. "OvTLva p.ev toCwv Tpoirov 8et p.av6dveLv rj (vpCcrKeLV
TOL ovTa, /xeiôv ?(ra)s ecrriy eyvcoKevaL q KaT e/xe Kai o-e'* 5
dya7n;roy 8e Kat tovto 6fio\oyrj<Taa6aL, otl ovk e^ 6vo[xdT(av

"^
dAAa TroAv /xdAAoy aiyrd e avTUiV kcll fjiadriTeov Kal {Tjrrjreôy
/ eK TWV ^VOpATOiV.
KP. ^âtrerat, S 2a)Kpare?.
2X2. 'Ert ToCwv Tohe crKey\Kop.e6a, oTrcoy jn^ ^/xds rd lo
TroAAd ravra 6v6p.aTa es TavTov TeCvovra eâTrara, et roi c

di^rt p.ev oi 6e[JLV0L avTO. bLavor]6evTS ye edevTO a)s lovtcov
di:dvT(av dei Kai peovTOiv (f>aCvovTaL yap efxoLye koX avT<a

ovT(o bLavor]6r]vcu t6 8', d ervyev, ov\ ovt(x>s cx^* ^^'
ovrot avrot re uxnrep eis rtra bCvr]v ejuTreo-oVres KVKcSi^rat 5
Kat ^jods ecêAKo/xeroi TTpocrep.^dXXovcrLV. (rKe^jraL ydp, u)
6av]xa(TLe KparT/Ae, o eycoye TroAAaKts 6vLp(aTT0i. TroTepov

(pu>iJLiv TL (IvaL avTO KoXbv Kal dya6bv Kal ev (KacrTOV tS>v
ovTOiv ovTO), r] fx^; d
KP, "E/xoiye doKet, o> 2(oKpare?, [eiyai].
'
212. Avrd ToCwv eKetro crK\j/(i)p.e6a, fxrj et TrpoaoiTTOv rC
fCTTLV KoXbv 7/ rt T&v T0L0VT0)v, Kttt SoKet TavTa TrdvTa pelv
aXX avTO, ^(a]xev, Tb Kakbv ov tolovtov deC kcTTLV olov^V
(OTLV;
I
KP. 'ArdyKT/.
a 6 avruy Baiter a 8 ^ ante fiKoiv add. T b5 /jluCuv B

C I ^foiroTa, el Wyttenbach fâiraTaTat Kal B
: : iâiraTa Kal T
C2 7eAst: rt BT C3 oiptiS Heindorf: ovtoI BT 65 ifiire-
(TovTis b t : fKTTfffSvTfs BT c 7 fyaryf^ iyu T d2 flvai om. B
d4 Kol . . . (ifiv secl. Schanz
439d nAATHNOS
212. Âp* ovv olov re Tipoa-mriiv avTo 6p6S>'5, il di
v7T^p)(êTai, TTpcaTov fjiev otl (Kelvo ^cttiv, CTreira ort toiovtov,
lo 1] avAyKr] &p.a r}p.G>v XeyovTOiV akko avTO evdvs yiyveadat

Kal VTT$UvaL Kal IJ.riKiTL 0VT(OS (X^'-^>
KP. 'AvdyKt}.
e 212. Ylu)S ovv hv cir/ tI K(lvo b fxrjbenoTf oxravTOJS

6;(ct; et ydp "Trore ct>(ravT(ns fo-xet, ev y iKiivi^ roi yjiovi^
hr]kov OTL ovh\v iJ.TaâiveL' ci 8e del bxravrais ^xtL Kal t6

avTo kcTTL, ttS)S av tovto ye /LtcraôAAot fi klvolto, /ixrjSey
5 c^LcrTapLevov ttjs avTOV ibias;
KP. Ovbaix&s.
2i2. 'AAAa p.r]v ov8' av yvocxrOeirj ye vn ovhevos. dfjLa
440 y^P O.V eiTLovTos Tov yv(i)(roixevov oAAo xai dAAotor yiyvoLTo,
u>(TT ovK dv yvoxrdeir] eTL oiroZov yi tl ecTTLV rj ircSs i\ov'
yvSxTLS be br\TTOv ovbefxia yLyvtacTKeL o yiyviacrKei. ixribaficas
^XOV.
6 KP. "Eo-rti; u>s XiyeLs.
212. 'AAA' ovbe yvGxTLV eXvaL cfidvaL elKos, o) KparvXe, el
IxeTaiTiiTTeL TrdvTa xPÎP-^t^ '^'^'-

M^^^^ p.eveL. el ixev ydp
avTo TOVTO, ri yvoicrLS, tov yvSxTLS elvaL /xt) /xcraTrtTrrct, /meVot
re dv dci rj yvSxTLS koll cit/ yvSxTis. el be kcll avTo to elbos

b ixeTairiiTTeL ttjs yvdcTeoos, dp.a t dv ixeTaiTiiTTOL els dAAo
elbos yv(a(Teo)s Kal ovk dv elri yvSxTLS' ct be dci /icra77t7rrci,
det ovK dv etri yvSxTLS, koX ck tovtov tov \6yov ovre to
yvoxTîxevov ovTe t6 yvoxrdrjcroixevov av elr]. et 8e eo-rt /xcr
5 dei t6 yLyvSicTKov, ecTTL be t6 yLyvo}CTK6p.evov, ecTTL he t6
KaX6v, ecTTL be t6 dyaddv, eort he kv eKacrrov tS)V ovtcov,
ov ixoL cf)aiveTaL TavTa 6p.oLa ovTa, h iwv 17/xets Xeyoixev, poi)
C ovbev ovbe (f)opa. Tavr ovv TTdrepov iTOTe ovtods ex<i V
iKeivctis u)s OL TTepl 'HpaKKeLTdv Te Xeyova-LV Ka\ dAAot
iroAA.ot, /xt) ov pdhLov rj iTTLcrKe\f/acrdaL, ovhi Trdw vovv
exovTos dvdpcaiTov liTLTpiyfravTa 6v6ixacTLv avror cat Trfv avTOV
a8 nfrarrixToi B ex cmend : jutTair/wrji' T C2 t om. T

KPATTA02 440C
\frvx}]V depairevîv, TreTrtoreuKora eKetyots Koi tols 6(fj.V0is 5
avTo., hu(T)(ypiî(r6aL (5s tl eiboTa, Kat avTov re Kal tuiv ovtuiv

KaTayLyvaiaKeLV wy ovbev vytes ovbevos, aXXa irairra c5(r7rep
Kepafj.La pet, Kal aTx,v(is axnrep ol KaTapp<a voaovvTes

av6poi>TTOL oilrcoy oUadaL Kal tcl iTpayp.aTa bLaKelcrdaL, vtto d
pevfJiaTOS re kol KaTappov navTa [Ta\ xpvP-o.Ta \(r6aL. lo-cos
jLtei^ ovv brf, S> KpaTvke, ovtojs ex^^' '^'^^ 8e Kal ov. (tko-
TTeLcrdaL ovv \pr} avbpeLOis re Kal (v, Kal p.r} /5a8ta)S aTToSe'-
X(r6aL ert yap veos et /cat r]\LKLav exeis (rK\j/(xp.Vov 8e', 5
iav evprjs, ju.era8t8oyat Kat epoL

KP. 'AAAa TrotTjcroo raCrra. ev puivTOL Xcrdi, d) 2coKpares,
Ort Ovb\ VVvl a(rKTTTO)S ^X^> ^XKa p.OL (TK0TT0Vp.iv(O Ka\
TTpaypaTa ^xovtl ttoKv ixaX\ov iKeCvois (paLV^TaL eêty o)S e
'HpcxKAetros Ae'yet.
212. Ets aS^ts TOLVVV /ii.e, o) kTalpe, StSciêts, eiretSav
T/Kr/s* vvv 8e, axTTTep TTape^rKeva^raL, TTopevov eis aypov
TTpoiTip.yû 8e cre Kai 'Epp.oyvr]s o8e. 5
KP. Tairr' taTaL, d) 2wKpares, dAAa Kat cru iTCLpca (tl
ivvouv TavTa ijbrj.
e6 Tf] 7 T da ra om. T d8 Koi ante Trpo-yyuoTa

secL Naber
j^
\!(
w^
0EAITHTO2
ETKAEIAH2 TEINfmN St. I

p. 142
ET. "ApTi, 0} TepyffCiav, tj TrdAai i^ aypov; a

TEP. 'ETTtetKO)? TiaXai. koll cr ye e(7;rovi' Kar ayopav
Kttt k6avp.a(pv ori ov^ 010? '"'
^ (vp^lv,
ET. Ov ya/) 77 Kara TroAtr,
TEP. Uov ixrjv; 5
ET. Ets XLp,va KaTaâivutv 0eatr^Tft> v4tv\ov êpo-

êiô) efc Koptyôu aTTO roiS (rrparo7re'8ou 'A^Tyraê.
TEP. Z&)i;rt ^ rereAevrrjKort;

ET. Z&vTi. Kot p.d\a /xoAiS' xaXeirois /xei yap exet Kat b
VTTo TpavfxaToov TLvGiv, iwXkov fJLTiv avTov alp^X t6 ycyovbs
voarrjfjia kv rw (rTpaTevp.aTL,
TEP. M&v bva-VTpia;

7)
ET. Nat. 5
TEP. Olov dvbpa Ae'yets iv KLvbvv(o etz/ai.
ET. KaAoi; re fcat dyadov, co Tepyf/Ccov, eTret roi xai rCy
i]K0v6v TLVodV p.dKa yKooiXLa^6vTU)V avTov Trepl ttjv p.d\r]v.
TEP. Kat ovbiv y aTOTTOV, dAAa ttoAi 6avp.aa-T6Tepov ei
}xri TOiovTos ^v, drdp tt&s ovk avTOv Meyapot KaTeKvev; C
bI /ji6yis W b7 Tf] 7 al. b8 vtpl rV f^XVy avrSy pr. T

(sed corr. T) b9 owSeV] ovSt W
I4ac IIAATnNOS
ET. 'HTTetyero oiJcaSe* ^Trel tyioy kh^6fn]v kou crvv-
efôvKevov, dW' ovk ijdeKev. Kal 87/ra TrpoTTiJ.\j/as avrov,

CLTnuiV "nakLV avefJLvrjcrOrjv Kal lOavixaa-a 'S.ooKpa.Tovs o? piav-
5 TiK&s aWa re br] eiTre Kai Trepl rovrou. boKfl ydp fxoi
6\Cyov TTpb Tov OavaTov ivTVX^^v avrai pt,LpaKi(o ovti, Kal

(rvyyv6pi.(v6s re Kal SioAexêtj TTaw dyatrdijvai, avrov ti]V
(})V(nv. Kai fjioL \66vtl ÂOrjvaCe tovs re \6yovs ovs 8t-

d eAe'x^?7 avrw 8iJ]yT/(raro Kat /xaAa dîovs dKOrjs, etTre' re ori
Ttdcra dvdyKTj (trj tovtov eAAo^yt/xov yivicrdaL, eiinp eZs
TjkLKiav \6oL.
TEP. Kat d\r]6i] ye, w? olkv, eiTrer. drap rtres Tjfrai'
5 01 Ao'yot; exots dv bLrjyrjo-acrOaL;

ET. Ou /ixa Tov Aia, ovkovv ovTOi ye aTro (rT6fj.aT0S'
143 dAA' eypaxj/dixr^v fJiV t6t v6vs otKad' ckdoiv viTOfivijfxaTa,

va-Tpov 8e Kara o-xoA^y dvafj.Lfxvr](rK6p.V0s ypa(}>ov, kol
6(rdKLs Â6rfva^ d(pLKOLfxr]v, eiravrfpcaTcov tov ScoKpdrTj 6 fxrj
fXp.v^p.rfv, Kal bvpo eA^cbv Tnfvop6ovfxrfV' a>aT poL a-\b6v
5 ri TTas 6 Ao'yo9 yiypaiTTaL.
TEP. 'AAij^^' rfKovird &ov kox irp^repov, Kol fxivroi, del
fxiWuiV K\va-LV eTTtSetât bLaTTpL(pa bevpo. dWd tl
K(o\vL vvv rffxds bL\6Lv; TTdvTcos y(t)y Kal dvaTTavaaadaL

8e'o/xat o)S e dypov rJKcav.
b ET. 'AAAd fxV br] Kal avTos p-XP^ 'EptroC eaiTT/rov

TTpovTTfxylfa, u>a-T ovK dv drfbois dvaTTavoifxrfv. dAA' luifxev,
Kal ffixLV dfxa dvairavofxivoLS 6 ttols dvayv(oa-TaL.

TEP. 'Op6u>s Aeyets.
5 ET. To fXV br] ^L^\iov, S) Tpîo)V, rourt* eypayl/dfxrfv
be br] ovTcoal tov \6yov, ovk e/xoi ScoKpdrT; bLr]yovfXVOV wy

StTjyeiro, dAAd StaAeyo^/xei/oy ots (f>r] bLaXexîjvai. H^r} bi
tQ) t yii)fXTpr] &ob(j)p(a kcll rw eotr^rcj). tva ovv V rj)
ai om. B a4 iiri\vopOovfjii\v BT: iirriv</ip6ovnr\v vulg.

a6
ixfv
aXrje^l a\\' {{5tj Heindorf a8 iravTCBS ; ^7 5t Kal W
bI fjikv om. W ipivov W : iptlvov B : ^ptv ou T
0EAITHTO2 143 c
ypac^T] 1X1] -napiypicv TTpayixara al /u,eraî/ tu>v X6yu>v hir\yr}(ris C

Tiepl avTov T oTTOTe Aeyoi 6 ScoKparjjs, olov " Kal iyoD (f)r]v" rj
" Kal eyci) 17701;," rj av Trepl tov aTTOKpLvoixivov oti " crvvefpr}
7]
" ovx wixokoyei," tovtohv evKa ws avTov avTols 8taAeyo-
fxevov ^ypayfra, ^Xo)V Ta TOtavTa. 5
TEP. Kal ovbiv ye aTTO TpoiTOv, w Ei/KXetSrj.
ET. 'AAAa, TTai, Xa/3e t6 îfikiov Ka\ kiye.
2X2KPATHS 0EOAX2PO2 0EAITHTOS

212. Ei jxev tS>v iv Kvprjvr] fxaKXov Kr]h6]xr]v, S 0eo- d
Scope, To. eKei av (T koX irepl CKeCvcav am^pdoTcov, ei rtyes
avToOi TTepl ye(t)]XTpLav ij Tiva akXr]v (f)L\o(ro({)Cav dal tG)V
V(DV e7ri/xe'Aetai' Trotov/xevof vvv 8e r]TT0v yap Klvovs rj
Tov(Tb <|)tA(S, Kai pMkXov iTTLOvpLW (Ibevai TLves rjpxv tu>v 5
v4(ov (TTLboôL yevicrOai eTTtetKets. raiSra bi] avT6s re o-KOTToi
Kad^ ocrov bvvaixai, Kal tovs aXkovs epoctTU) oXs av opG) tovs
veovs eOekovTas o-vyyCyvecrOaL. crol 8?/ ovk okCyLCTTOL TrArjo-ta-
ôvo-t, Kat bLKaCo)S' a^Los yap Ta re aAAa Kat yeco/îerptas e

VKa. et br] ovv tlvl ivTVX,S d^to) Ao'you, r]b0)s av
TTv9oLfXr]V.
0EO. Kat jx-qv, o) ScoKpare?, ejmo^ re eiTrety Kat a-ol
aKov(TaL TTaiw a^LOV otw vfXLV tQv TTokLT&v ]XLpaKL(a ivTerv- 5

XrjKa. Kat et jxev rjv koAo?, k(poôvp.r]v av a^6bpa kiyeLV,
1X1] KaC T(a b6ô) kv kiTL6vp.C(L avTov elvaL. vvv be Kat [x-q
[xoL ayOov -ovk eaTL KaAo?, iTpo(TeoLKe 8e crot Tr]v re aL]x6-

rqTa Ka\ to eô) t&v 6[xixaT0)V' r]TTOV be ?/ crv TavT eyei.
abe5)S br] keyo). ev yap Xo-Ol otl &v br] TTcoTTore evervxov 144
Kat TTaiw TTokkols TTeiTkrj^rCaKa ovbeva tto) i](r66ixr]v ovto)
6avfxao-T(as ev TTe^f^vK^Ta. t6 yap evp.a6rj ovTa ws akk(o
XakeTTOv TTpaov av elvaL bLaêp6vT0)s, kclI eTTt tovtols
C 3 axiTOv W : axnov B T d. 2 avripiruv] &' iipcirtcv B d. 8 crvy-

ytvfcrdaiW S^] 5e W a2 iroAAors] iroA.A.orj 5^ W &3 (d
om. W a4 aS om. T
PLATO, VOL. I. 17
:
144 a TlAATi2N0S
5 avbpeLOv Trap' 6vti.vovv, iyca piev ovt hv wo/xTjy yivicrdax
ovTC 6pS> yiyvoixevov itAA' oi re oêis cSo-Trep ovros koI
ayx^Cvoi. Kal p.vr\p.ov(s o)? To. TToXka kox Trpos Tas opyas
o^vppoTToC dcri, Kal arrorres êpoyrat axrirep to, avepim-
b rio-ra TrAoia, Kal p.aviK(aTtpoi. r) ^vhpîoTepoL (pvovTai, ot t(
av [x^pi.d4(TTpoL voiOpoC TTOiS aTTavTuxn TTpos Tcis ixa6ri<ris
Kal ki]6r]s yepiovTes. 6 8e ovro) Aeico? re Kal airraCaroiS

Kal avva-CpxtiS (py^Tai fw. Tas ixa6ricr(is re koX ^jjTTj<rets
5 jXiTo. TTokXrjs TTpaorqTos, olov ikaCov pivp.a a\l/0(f>r]Tl piovTos,

u)(TT 6avp.a.(raL to TrjkiKOVTOv ovTa ovtojs Tavra biaiTpdT-
T(r6ai.
212. Ev dyye'AAei9. rivos 8^ koI (ctti. tu)V iroXiTQtv;

0E). 'Ax^Koa p.\v Tovvofxa, ixvrjp.ovVU) be ov. aXKa
C ydp iari r&vbe Tciv irpocnovTOiV 6 V rw fxeVo)" aprt yap (v
tS> I^co bpojxoi rjXeCcfôvTO kToipoC re rtres ovroi avroC xai
avTos, vvv bi fxoi boKovcnv dK(L\}/dixcvoL bevpo UvaL. dWa
o-KoVet el yLyv(t>a-KLS avTov.
5 212. riyv&jo-Ko)* 6 Tov ôvvlQs Y!,v(ppovCov ^cttCv, Ka\

irdvv ye, cb (^tAe, dvbpos olov Kal (tv tovtov bLrjyfj, Koi
aAAcof vboKCixov, kol /xeVroi Kai ovaCav p.dka TTokXr\v
KaT^kLTiev. t6 b' 6voy.a ovk otSa tov fxcLpaKCov.

d 0EO. 0eatr7jros, oj 2(0K/)ares, t6 ye ovofxa' ti]V yAvroi
ovaCav boKovaC fxoL eirCTpoTToC TLves bL(f)6apKvaL. dAA' ofxots
Kal TTpos TTfV tG)V ^rffxdToiV ikevdfpLOTrjTa davfiaaTOS, oi
'2i(aKpaTes.
5 212. rewtKoi' Ae'yets tov avbpa. KaC fxoL Ke'Aeve airrov
iv6db TTapaKadCCââL.
0EO. "Eo-rat TavTa. QeaCTrfTf, bevpo Trapa ^(OKpdTrf.
212. Yldvv fxv ovv, o) 0ea^rjre, tva Kayo) ifxavTov
dvaaKi-ôifxaL ttolov tl ^x.oi to irpoaoiTTov' <f>r]a\v yap 0eo-
a6 yiyv6fi(yov T ut videtur : yiyyofx^yovs B Berol. b a inrotyToiiri B

& vdvTuv T b 3 T* om. W b5 W
0101] oloyfl b 8 fixtyyf^tTs
T Berol. catrorpoiB: fxfpolT c^ytom. W 0^ fvSoKi/xor
B d3 Kolj (5 W d 7 rffTot T : f<rT. B
0EAITHTO2 144 e
boipos ^Xî-v /jie (Tol ofiOLov. aTap ci vS>v (x6vtoi.v (KaTepov e

kvpav ((p-q avras r]pp.6a-dai op-oms, -n^T^pov ivOvs av
CTTto-revoju.ey 17 iirea-Ke^j/dixed' av ei /xouo-tKos obv Xiyî;
0EAI. 'E7reo-Ke\/âju,e^' av.
SH. OvKovv ToiovTov pikv vp6vTs kTm06\j.id^ av, dixov(rov 5
8e', riTn.a-Tovp.ev;
0EAI. 'AAtj^j/.
212. Nuj/ 8e' y', otjuat, et rt /xe'A.et 77/xty tt)s TUiv Trpoo-wircov
6}xoi6Tr]Tos, a-KTTTov il ypa({)LKbs ctiV Aeyet 7/ ov. 145

0EAI. AoKet fxoL.
212.'H ovv ôoypacjiLKos 0eo'8a)po?;
0EAI. Ovx, oaov yi /xe et8e'vai.
212. 'Ap' oiiSe yeuijxeTpLK^s; '
5
0EAI. ndvrcos 87/7rov, S 2a)Kpares.

212. 'H Kai do-rpovo/itKos Kat Aoyto-rtKOS re Kat pLOva-LKbs
Kal oaa TraiSetas Ixerai;
0EAI. 'E/xotye SoKei.
2X2. Et /xey dpa rjfms tov o-w/xaro'? rt ojxolovs (f)ricrlv 10
etrai iTraLvcav Ttr\ 7/ y\riy<x)V, ov Trdvv avT^ dîov tov vovv

Ttpo^xix^Lv.
0EAI. "lo-tos ov.
2X2. Ti 8' ei Trorepov Trjv Klrv\r}V ktraLvoZ irpbs dpeTr]v b

re Kat (ro(f)Lav; dp' ovk d^Lov tQ fxkv aKovaavTL irpodvfxtL-
adaL dvaa-K4\}raa-6aL Tov iTraiveddvTa, rw 8e Trpodvfxuis kavTbv

(TTLbeLKVVVaL;
0EAI. Yldiw jxkv ovv, S> 2ajKpare?. 5

212. "Hpa TOiwv, o) 0tAe eatrT/re, o-ot pikv kTTibeiKvvvaL,
eftoi 8e o-KOTreto-ât* o)S eS lo-^t ort 0eo'8ajpos' TroAAovs 87)
-n^pos /xc (Traivicras îvovs re Kai da-TOVs ovbiva Traj iirpvea-ev
ojs o-e rvz;877.
0EAI. Ev ay e)(Ot, S) 2a)Kpares' dAA' opa /at) Trat^wy 10
eAeyer. c
a9 lyuoryc] ^yuoi T a lo ^ffl' 6fiolovs T a 11 S^to' ouTy W

17*
;
145 c nAATilNOS
212. Oii)( 0VT09 6 rpoTtos eoScopov aWa [xtj avabvov
Ta u)ixoXoyr]yi.iva (rKr]TTT6iJ.vos TTaiôvTa kiy^LV Tovhe, tva /X7/
/cat avayKaaOfj jjLapTvpeLV TTavTOiis yap ovbcls iTruTKjiyj/iT
5 avTut dAAa dappiav ip.p.(.v t?] 6p.o\oyia.

0EAI. 'AAAa yj)i] Tavra iTOLfZv, d (ro\ SoKet.
2X2. Aeye br] /xor pLav6ave(.s ttov irapa, &od(apov

yecoixeTpCas CLTTa;
0EAI. "Eycoye.
d 212. Kai Twy TTcpl ^crTpovoixiav re kcll apfxovias Kal
koyLcTfxovs
0EAI. UpoBvixovixaC ye biq.
2X2. Kai yap eyco, S) Trai, Tra/ad re rovrou jcat Trap'
5 dAAcoi; ovs &i' omp.aC tl tovtoi)V eTraieir. dAA' o/xco? rd

/xey dAAa exco Trept avrd fier/9ic)s, fXLKpov b4 ri &TTop& o
p.eTa crov re /cat roirSe (rKCTTTiov. KaC px>L Ae'ye' ap' ou rd
p.av9a.vLV IcttIv to (rocfxaTcpov yCyvicrdaL irept 6 fxavOdvcL

rts;
10 0EAI. ricD? ydp oii;
2X2. ô(f)Ca be y oTpiaL cro(j)ol ol (ro(f)oC.
0EAI. Nai.
e 2X2. Touro 8^ fxiov Siaêpei ri ^mor^/xjjs;
0EAI. Td TTOLOv;
2X2. 'H cro(f)ia. 1] ov\ dTrep ^TTio-r^/xores raCra Kat

0-0(^01;
6 0EAI. Tt/xy/y;
2X2. Tavrdi; apa ^Tnarrjfxr] Kal (ro(f)ia;
0EAI. Naf.
2X2. ToOr' avrd Toiwv eoriy 6 hTTopCa koX ov hvvafxai
Xaêiv LKavds TTap' ^fxavTut, kiTLcrTr^fxr] otl Trore rvyxciiêi 6v.
146 ap ovv hr] exo/xev \4yeLV avro; Ti câr^; ris av r]fx5)V
TTpS)Tos clttol; 6 8e afxapT(av, kol oy hv det afxapTdvij,
C4 Kol om. W tiri(ncfiif/(T' Schanz : 4irt<npfi}f/(i BT d r apfio-

viav W d4 W T6 Berol. : 7* BT d6 5 t] ' fri Hcindorf
d 11 -y' om. W
0EAITHTO2 I46a
KaOebdrai, câ-nep (pacrlv ol TratSes ol o-cf)aipiCovT9, ovos' os

8' av TiepiyivriTai avapiapTrjTos, l3aaL\ev(reL i]p.G>v Ka\ eTriraêt
OTi av l3ov\r]Tai. aTTOKpLvea-Oai. tl aLyaTe; ov tl ttov, cb 5
Qeoboope, eyo) vTTb (/)iAoAoyta9 aypoLKLQ)p.aL, iipoQvp.ovp.evos

i]pLas noLyja-aL biaXeyea-OaL Kal (^Ckovs re Kal TTpoa-rjyopovs
aAA7;Aots yiyvecrOaL;
EO. "HKtcrra p.iv, S 2co Kpares, to tolovtov av etr] b
aypoLKov, aXXa t&v fxeLpaKmv tl KcAeue aoL aTTOKpiveaOaL'
eyo) pLev yap ai]6r]s ttJs TOLavTr]s bLaXeKTOV, kcll ovb^ av

o-vveOiêcrdaL i]\LKiav eyu). Tolabe 8e TrpiiTOL re av tovto
Ka\ TTokv TTkiov (TTLbLbouv T(o yap ovTL rj veorqs ets ttclv 5
eTrt8oo-ty exet. oAA', coaTTep ypôo, /i.^ acpiecro tov QeaLTi^TOV
dAA' ipcoTa.
211. 'AKovets bi], oj eatrTjre, a Ae'yet Qeobcapos, w
aTreiêti', wy eyo) otjnat, oiJre av eêAô-ei?, ovre ê'/jits Trept C
To. TOLavra avbp\ o-oc^cS eTrtrarroi^rt v(i>Tpov cnTeLOeLV.
dAA' eS Kat yevvaiios elTri' Ti aoL 8oKet etiât kTTLaTi]p.rj;

0EA1. 'AAAa xpi], S) ^coKpaTes, e7ret8?y7rep vpL(LS KeAevere.
TTdvTdiS ydp, dv TL Ka\ apidpTai, (TTavopdcLaeTe. 5
212. ndn p.v ovv, dv7Tp ye otot re S}fxv.
0EAI. AoKet Toiwv [xol Ka\ a iTapa 0eob(iopov dv tls

fxaOoL eiTLaTrj]xaL etrat, yecafxeTpia re Kat as wvbi] av biViXdes,
Kol av aKVTOTop.LKr] re Kat at twv aAAcoy br]pLovpyQv TeyyaL, d
7rdo-at re Kat eKao-rTj tovt(dv, ovk oAAo rt ?/ eTTLaTi]]xr] etrai.
212. rewatws ye Kat (f>L\ob(Lp(jL>s, Sj (fiike, ev atrr/êts
TToAAd 8i8a)s Kat irotKtAa dvrt aTrAoC.

0EAI. noJs rt roSro Ae'yeis, a> 2wKpares; 5
212. "lo-cos fxev ovbev b fxevTOL olfxaL, (f)pda-(o. oTav
Xeyr^s a-KVTi.Ki]V, /xt/ rt oAAo (f^pdêis 1] eTnarqjxrjv VTTobrijxdT(t)v
epyacrias;
0EAI. Ovbev.
a 5 3tj] tv W airoKpirmrOai W a 7 ^^3s] u/iSr T b r ^V

om. T b 2 Tl Tiva W b4 t om. W c i aveidfiv W
W
:
OTA&er' al. : airKrTflv BT d7 /ujj &\\o ti

146 e nAAT12N02
e 212. Ti 6' orav TCKTOviK-qv; fi-q n aWo ^ eTricm^nrjv r?)?
T(av ^vXCvMV (TKev&v ipya<rCas;

0EAI. Ovbe Tovro.
2X2. OvKovv V aix(f)OLV, ov fKaTcpa iiTKTTrjfir], tovto
5 bpiîis;
0EAI. Nai.
212.To hi y ^poorr^div, S) QeairqTe, ov tovto rjv, Tivcov
f} ^TTi.aTrifxr], ovb^ oTTocrai, TLvh' ov yap h.pi6p.ri(Tai avrai
ôvk6p.Vot rip6p.6a a\\a yvSivai eiTLanîxrfv avrb otl ttot
10 icTTiv. rj ovbkv Aeyco;
0EAI. riciw pikv ovv 6p6u>s.
147 2X2. 2K\/âi 8^ KOL Tobe. e? tls ^/1x09 rcSi/ (pavXoav rt
Kat TTpox^îpoov epoLTO, olov iTepl TrqXov otl ttot ia-Tiv, ci
aTTOKpLvaip.eda avT^ TrqXbs 6 tS)V xwrpeoor koX irqkbs 6 t^v

lTTV0TT\a6GiV K(iL TTrjXbs 6 tQv TTXivOovpyGiV, ovK hv yeAoioi
6 eijuer;
0EAI. "lo-ws.
2X2. ITpwroi' /ueV ye ttov ol6p.voL a~vvLvaL k ttjs r]p.(Tpas

aTTOKpi(T(os Tbv fpuiTOiVTa, OTav LTT(ip.(V TTr]\6s, etre 6 Ta>v
b KopoTTXaddv TTpoa-devTes eire aXXoiiv oiVTivoivovv br]p,LovpyGiV.
I rj oiei rts ri (rvvirja-iv tlvos 6vop.a, b p.r] oiSev rt ioTLv;
0EAI. OvSa/xws.
2X2. Oii8' apa kiTL(rTr]p.r]v VTTobr]]x6iT(tiV avvirâ-LV 6 irTL-
5 (TTr]pLr]v ]ir] etSws.

0EAI. Ov y6p.
2X2. ^KvrtK^y a/)a ov crvvirâ-Lv os &y fTTLorrîir^v i.yvor],
ovb4 Ttva &XXr]v T4\vr]v.

0EAI. 'Eo-rir ovTOiis.
lo 2X2. reAota a.pa f] aiT^KpL^ris tw ^pcorqOevTi TTLan^p.r] Ti

ea-TLV, OTav aTTOKpivrjTat Ti\vr]s TLvbs 6vop.a. TLvbs yap
C iTTt(Trqp.r]v aTTOKpivTai ov TOVT (poiirq^fis.
6 7 T^ 5 yt tpasTi^Bfv W Berol. -.
rh 5' iwtpwTrjBfv BT a4 lirvo-
TrAafloivB: /fopoir\adci)v T W in marg. TKiydouKKwy lierol. a> 5 ^jucv
T W ba Ti BT : gri W Berol. c i oij 6 W
0EAITHTO2 I47C
0EAI. "EoiKev.
2X2. "ETreira ye ttov e^bv (pavkois koI /3paxea)? aTTOKpC-
vacrOai. TrepUpx^TO.i airipavTov obov. oXov koI iv t^ tov
Trqkov ipoiTrjcrei (f)avk6v ttov koI aTckovv elTTelv otl yrj vypS> 5
<f)vpadel(ra TrrjXos av eti], t6 8' otov av xâCpiLV.

0EAI. 'PaStoi', Si ^(aKpares, vvv ye ovT(a (paCveTaL' aTap
KLvbvvVLS ipdiTav olov Kal avTOLS rjixiv vayxos eicnjkde
bLakeyofjievoLS, epoC re Kal rw a(a 6fX(ovvfJL(a TOVT(a 2a)Kparei. d
212.To TTolov bi], S) eaiTTjre;
0EAI. Hepl bvvdpLeoiV tl i]p.LV 0eo8a)/)oy ohe eypa(f), Trjs
re TpCiTobos Trepi kol TTevTeirobos [a7TO(f)aCv(i)v] otl p.riKeL ov
(rvp.pLTpoL rfj JToSiaia, Kal ovtco KaTO. p.Lav eKdcTTrjv TTpoaLpov- 5
p.evos pê\pL tt;? e7rraKat8eKa7ro8os* kv 8e TavTrf tto)? eve^rxeTO.

rjpuv ovv el(rrjk94 tl tolovtov, eiTeiby] aiTeLpoL to TTkrjdos al
bvvd]ieLS e(f)aLV0VT0, TTeLpadrjvaL crvkkajSelv els ev, oto^ jracras
TavTas TTpo(Tayopevcrop.ev tols bvvd\ieLs. e

2X2.'H Kat r]vpeTe tl tolovtov;
0EAI. "Eftotye boKovpiev' crKOTTeL be Ka\ crv.
2X2. Aeye.
0EAI. Tbv dpLOjxbv TTdvTa bC^CL 8teXa/3oftey tov p.ev 5
bvvap.evov lcrov l(rdKLS yCyveaOai rw TeTpay(i!>v(o to cxTy/xa

aTretKao-ai^res TeTpdyo)v6v re kcCl icrdiTkevpov TrpocreCTTop.ev.
2X2. Kal eS ye.

0EAI. Tbv ToCvvv p.eTa^v tovtov, o)V Kal tcl TpCa Kal
TCL irevTe koX Tras os dhvvaTOS lctos icrdKLS yevecrdai, dAX' 17 14
TrkeCoov ekarrovdKLS r) eA.arrcov 7rA.eomKt? ytyrerat, p-eCQav
be KCLL ekdTTO)V de\ TTkevpa avTbv TTepLkapi^dveL, rw TTpop.i]KeL
av (rxrjp.aTL aTTeLKdaajrres TTpop.r]Kr] dpL6p.bv eKOLke(rap.ev.
2X2. KaA\to-ra. aAAa rt Tb p.eTa tovto; 5
0EAI. Oo-ai p.ev ypap.fxal tov icr^Trkevpov koI eTTCTrebov

dpLdp.bv TeTpayo)vCCov(rL, p.rJKos o)pLcrd]xe6a, o(rai be rbv erepo-
d4
C 4 a-KfpaTov Berol.
a^ro^paivwv om. T
C 5 7^ om. pr. B d3 fypa\f/e W
e i wpotrfpov/xfv Cobet e 5 rhv /xfv B
corr. Berol. : rh fifv
W
T pr. Berol. : koI rhv fitv W a i yiyvfadai
a3 ir\fvpav pr. T
I48b nAATilNOS
5'
b /XT/Krj, bvvd[JiLS, o)? /x^Kci fxkv OV (TVIHliTpOVi ^Kitvais, TOIS
iinTTibois h bvvairrai. Kol TTfpl tcl (TTfpfa 6X\o TOiovrov.
\ 2X2. "AptcrTa y avdpiaTTcov, S Tralbes' axTTe /xoi boKel 6
QeoboDpos ovK evoxos tois ylrevbop.apTvpiois i<Tt<TQaL.
5 0EAI. Ka\ fx-qv, o EwKpaTe?, o ye ^pcoTas irept fTri-
(TTr\p.r]s ovK ^v bvvaipLrjv aTTOKpivacTdaL (ocrTrep Trept toC

/xTjKous Te Kox T^s Swa/xeco?. KatToi ot; ye /xoi Sokcis toioCtw
Ti ^r]TiLV' uiaTC TTaXiv av (âivtTaL \}/evbr}S 6 &(6b(i}pos.
C 2X2. Ti bi; et o-e Tr/aos bpoixov iiTaLVCiV pLr^bevl ovto)

8/30/xiKc5 e^Tj Twi' ve'a)y lvTiTV\r]Kivai, (LTa biadeoiv tov
aK[j.(xCovTOS Kal TayJ.(TTov rjTrridrjs, Tjttov tl av oUl aXr]6rj
Tovb^ TTaLvea-aL;
5 0EAI. OvK lycoye.
212. 'AXAa Tr]v eTTLcrTT^fxr^v, SxTtTfp wvbr] iyu} ^kcyov,

(TfiLKpov TL oiei etvat (êvpelv Kal ov T<av TTavTr] aKpaiv;
0EAI. Nr) Tov Ai" iycoye Koi /xdAa ye t&v aKpoTaTOiv.

2X2. Qdpp^L Toivvv TTfpl crauT&) Kai ti oiou 0eo'8copoy
d X^yety, TTpodvfx^qOr^TL 8e iravTi tp6tt(o t&v tc aXkoiv iTepL Kal
kTTL(TTrip.r]s \aj3LV \6yov tC iroTe Tvyxdvd ov.
0EAI. Y\podv]xLas fxev VKa, S 2coKpaTes, <f)avlTaL.

2X2. "Wl br] KaX&is yap apTL v(f)r]yr]a-w TTeLpd /xt/xow-
5 pLVOs TTjv TTepL T&v Suyd/iecoy diro^Kpio-tv, axriTep Tavras

TToWas ov<Tas kvl etSet TrepteÂa/Ses, ovtcd Kat tcls TToWas
emcrrqfxas (vl \6y(o Trpoo-etTretr.
e 0EAI. 'AAA.' ev to-^t, aj 2coKpaTes, TroAAciKt? 8?/ avro

Trexeii/aTjo-a (TKe\pâa-6aL, aKovcav tos Trapa (tov aTTO(f)epopLvas
ipoarqcreLS. akka yap ovt ovtos bvva]xaL Treifrat ]xavTov cos
iKaiâis Tt Ae'ya) ovt' ciAAov aKov(raL keyovTOS ovtoos (os a-v 6ta-
5 KeAevr/, ov fxev 8r/ av ovb' aiTaWayrjvaL tov /xe'Aety.
2X2. 'X^Stiêts ydp, a> (pike Qeain]T, 8ta to fxt] Kevos

dAA' iyKvpLCiiV etvaL.
b 7 T Kol TW Berol. : Kai B Cr fpTj oStu ipo/xiK^ T

C 7 liKpmv T : HiKpiBwv B 65 toO B T BeroK : rov rov W fitXtiv
B Berol. et ^p. W : niKKttv T : uptrv W
0EAITHTOS 148 e
0EAI. OvK olba, o) I,a>KpaTr o ii4vtol -neTTOvda Aeyco.
212. Eira, S) KaTayiXa(rT, ovk aKrjKoas w? eyw ct/ui vbs 149
IxaCas jjidXa y^vvaias re koI ^koa-vpas, âivapiT-qs;

0EAI. "Hbr] TOVTo ye rjKovcra.
20. 'Apa Koi OTL kitLTTihivoi Ti]V avTTiv Txvr]v CLKriKoas;
0EAI. Ovbaixm. 5
212.' 'AAA' eS lo-^' otl- fjii] \xivTOL jjlov KaTd-nris Trpbs tovs
akXovs. Xkr]da ydp, S) kTOLpe, Tavrqv exa)y Tr]V rexJ^y

01 8e', aT ovK eiSores, tovto iikv ov k4yov(TL Trepi ip.ov, ori
8e droTrwraro'? ci/xt Kat 770tcS rovs avOpatTiovs aiiopeLV. 7/ /cat
roiSro aKTjKoas; 10
0EAI. "Eyo^ye. b
2X2. EtTTo) oSi' (Tot ro oltlov;
0EAI. Yldw fxkv ovv.
212. 'Evv6r](rov 8r) ro irept ras /xatas a-n-az/ o)? exet, Kot
paoy p.a9ricrrj /3ovAo/xat. oto-â yap ttov ws ovbepi.La avTwv 5
ert avr^ Kv'L(TKop.ivr\ re Kat TLKTOVcra akkas patei/erat, dAA'

at 7/877 dSiîârot tlkt^lv.
0EA1. Wdvv pikv ovv.
212. Atrtay 6e' ye rovrou (f>a(rlv (TvaL rqv "Aprefxtr, ort

aAoxos oSo-a rTJy Aoxetai; etArjxf oreptcât? ju,ey ovv dpa 10
owK eScoKe p.aLVa6aL, otl rj dvdpcoTTLvr] (f)vaLs d(rdevaTpa 7; c

Aa/3ety Tixjrqv *5y Sy ^ aTretpoy rats 8e 8t' rjkLKLav dTOKOLS
7:pocrTa^ TLpi&cra Trjv avTrjs 6p.0L6Tr]Ta.

0EAI. EiKos.
212. OitKoCy Kol ro'8e etKo's re Kai dvayKawv, Tas 5
Kvovcras kol p.r] yLyv(a(rK(r6aL ixdkkov vtto tQiv ixaLwv rj roii'
aAAcov;
0EAI. Udw ye.
212. Kat ixr]v Kal bLbova-aC ye al p.atat (f)apixdKLa Ka\
TTdbovaaL bvvavTaL yLpLV re ras o^blvas Kal p.ak6aK(o- d
a8 ffiov B W : /xov T Berol. C 2 aroirois pr. B C 5 re]

7e W C9 (papfiMCia W : (pap/xaKeia BT
; ;
i49d nAATilNOS
Hpas &v ôvkbiVTai ttouZv, Ka\ tCkthv re hi] tols bvaro-
Kovaas, Ka\ kav fviov ort ho^rf aiJ.j3\Ca-K(,v, &ix^kCa-Kov(riv
0EAI. 'EoTi TavTa.
5 212. 'Ap' ovv Iri Kal Tobc avTiav ria-O-qaai, ori koi
TTpofxvria-TptaC da-i. Seirorarai, u>s naa-aoôi ovaai TTfpl tov
yvS)vai TtoCav xpi] ttoC(o avbpl avvovaav d)s apCarovi iralbas
tCktclv;
0EAI. Ov Ttavv TOVTO oTba.
lo 212. 'AA.A' laO' oTi eTTi tovt(^ fxiiôv <\>povovaiv 7] eirt
e Tfi 6ix(f)aXr]Top.C(i. ivvoet yap' tT]? avTijs rj oXAtjs oiei
Texyrjs eiyai OepaireCav re kcll a-v-yKOfxibrjv t5v e/c yr]s
KapirQv Kol av to yiyv(a(TK(LV eis iroCav yrjv ttolov (pxjrov

re Kal aTripfxa KaTa^\r]Tôv
5 0EAI. OvK, dAAa Trjs avTrjs.
211. Eiy yvvaLKa b4, S) (f)C\e, 6.XXr]v fxkv olei tov

TOiovTov, a\\r]v 8e avyKOixLbrjs;
0EAI. OvKovv cIkos ye.
150 2X2.Ov ydtp. dAAa 8td Tr]v abLKov re /cat aTX^(^^
(n>vay(oyi]v avbpos Kal yvvaLKOs, f] br] TTpoayuiyCa ovopia,
(pevyovai Kal ttjv TTpofxvqarLKi^v dre aepival ovaaL al /ixatai,
(f>ol3ovpivaL ]xr] ets iKfCvr^v Tr]v ahCav 8td TavTr]v e/iTreVcoo-ti^'
6 iTTfl Tals ye ovtohs fxaCaLS fxovais ttov iTpocrrjKCL kcu Trpofxvrj-
craaOaL dpdCis.
0EAI. 4>atVeTat.
212.Td fxev ToCwv tG)V ixaLutv too-ovtov, eXaTTov be
tov ifxov bpdfxaTos. ov yap TTpoafoTL yvvaL^lv ivCoTf fxkv
b etStoAa tCktLv, (otl b' otc aXrfOLvd, tovto bk fxi] pabtov
eirat Stayrcoyat. (l yap iTpoarjv, fxiyL^tTOV re Kai KaAAioTov
ipyov ^v hv rats fxaCats to KpCveiv to a\r]6is re Kat fxrf rf
ovK otet;
5 0EAI. "Eycoye.
d a 5^] KedW d3 yfov iv] v6fxtnov Schanz d5 ^ti oin. W

d 10 M] ifftt T : oJa9' W b i iLKnOivi] Kieiva T
0EAITHTO2 150 b
212. Tf/ 8e y e/x^ t^X^ ''^^ /uatevo-eco? ra /iey aAAa

VTrapxî o(ra (Kfivais, bia<f)peL 8e Tfai re avbpas aWa fj.i]
yvvaLKas p.aLV(r6aL Kal T<a tcls yfrv)(as avTG>v TLKTovaas

(TTLaKOTTLV dAAtt /LA7/ TCL a-U)p.aTa. p.iyL(TTOV 8e TOVT (VI
Trj 17/xerepa TiyvT], âa-avL^^LV bvvaTov etvaL TravTl TpoTno C

TTOTepOV Lb(ii\0V Kttl \l/vboS aTTOTLKTiL TOV VOV T} bLCLVOLa
77 yovLfxov re Ka\ akr]6is. 7ret Tobe ye Kol e/xot vTrapyei

oirep Tals fJLaCaLS' ayovos (Ip-L ao(f)Las, Kal oTrep rjbrj ttoAAoi
jjLOL o)VLbL(rav, 0)? Tovs p.ev aXX.ovs (pcoTci, avTos be ovbev 5
aTTO(f)aLvop.aL Trept ovbevbs 8ta ro fjirjbev exêtr ao(f)6v, aXrjOes
6vLbLôv(rLV. ro 8e airtoy roi^roi ro'8e* iiaL(ve(r6aL jue o
êos drayKaêt, yevvav be dTreKOjAvrrer. ei/xt 5?/ ovv avTos

pikv ov TTavv TL ao(f>6s, ovbi tl fjLOL eaTLV vprip.a tolovtov d
yeyovos ri]s e/x^? '^'^XV^ iKyovov ol 8' e/:xot o-Dyytyiô^/xerot
ro fxev TTpS)TOV âivovTaL Vlol /xer Kat iTdvv d/xaêts, iTavTes
be TTpo'Lova-r]S tt]s crvvovaLas, oX^nrep av o 6e6s iTapeLKr],
davpLaarov o(rov e7ri8i8oyres, ws avrot? re Kat rots dAAots 5
boKovcTL' Kal TOVTO ivapyes otl TTap ep.ov ovbev iTCoTTOTe
]xa66vTes, dAA' avrot Trap' avratv TroAAa Kat KaAd evp6vTes

re Kai TeKovTes. ttjs fievTOL fiaLeias 6e6s re Kai eyo)
avTLos. '^wbe be brjkov iroAAot ijbr] tovto ayvoija-avTes Kal
eavTovs alTLaa-ajxevoL, ejxov be KaTa(f)povi]cravTes, rj avTol rj
vtt' akXcjiV TTeLcr6evTes aTTf]\6ov TTp(oaiTfpov tov beovTos,

aTTeX.66vTes be rd re AotTrd eî]p.jiX(x)a-av bLo. irovr^pav
avvovcriav Kal tcl vtt" epov p.aLev6evTa KaKcos Tpe(f>ovTes 5
dTrwAeo-ay, \f/evbij Kal elbcoXa irepl TTXeiovos iTOLr]crap.evoL
Tov aXr}6ovs, TeXevT&vTes 8' avrots re Kai rots dAAot?

eboâv afxadeTs etrat. o)V ets yeyovev 'ApicretST/s 6 Avo^t- 151
fxdxôv Kal dAAoi jrdn TroAAot* ovs, oTav irdAty eX6(DcrL
be^fxevoL ttjs efirjs crvvov<rias kcu, âvfxacrra bp^vTes, evioLS
C 4 -KoWoi] KoWoi KoWd.Kis W c6 airo<patuofxai W Berol.

TW
:
aTroKpivo/xai BT d i itdvv rt Berol. irdvu ris B d^ ^vioi

W
:
T : (vi &Tt B d8 Ka\ TiKiyrfs W Berol. : /fOTexorres BT

62 1^ ai>To2 ^ W : ^ avTol BT a i o/xa&ets eSoâi' W
151 a nAATi2N02
fjLfV To yt.yv6fj.v6v fioi baLfioviov i-TTOKcoXwei crvvflvai, evCois
5 bi iq, Kal TToXiv ovtoi, eTrtStSoacn. Trdo-xouo-t 6e br] oi c/xoi
crvyyiyv6fivoi koX tovto tovtov tois TLKTOvcrais' dibivovcn

yap Kal cnropias (p.-nip.TikavTai vvKTas re /cat fjpLepas ttoAu
fiaWov 7] ^Kiivai' TavTrjv 6e rqv uiblva iyeipeiv re xai
b aTTOTTavciv fj e/x7/ T\vr) bvvaTai,. Kal ovtoi fxev 6j; ovtws.
iviois be, w eatrrjre, o"t av p/ b6ôiai ttms eyKvpioves
ftot
etmt, yvovs otl ovbev e/xou 6eoi;Tat, Trdw ev/xevw? Trpop.vSip.ai.
Kai, cTvv êw eiTrety, 'ndw LKavSts TOTrdô) ots tiv crvyyevo-
5 [liVOL ovaLVTO' a)V ttoXKovs }xkv br) eîbu)Ka Y\pobiK<a, ttoKkovs
b^k dAAot? cTocôls re Kai êo-Treo-tots avbpdcTL. Tairra b-q
croL, S) &pL(rT, veKa Tovbe epJiKVva' vttoittvo) cre, waiTfp

Kal avTos ofei, wbiveLV tl KvovvTa ^vbov, iTpocrcfîpov ovv
C TTpos fxe b)s TTpos fxaias vov Kal avTov fxaLevTLK^v, Kal h av
epcoToi TTpodvfxov 6tto)S ol6s T et ovT(i)S aTTOKpivacrOaL' Kal
av 6.pa <rK0TT0Vfxev6s tl S)V hv Xeyr]s Tjyrfa-a^fxaL et6a)Aoj;
Kat fxrf dXrfOes, etra vTTeâLpu>fxaL Kal dTTo/SdAAo), fxrf dypiaLve

5 u)cnTep al ttpu)tot6kol iTepl to. 7rat6ta. ttoAAoi yap r^jbrf,
S) davfxdcTLe, TTp6s fxe ovto) bLeTeOrfcrav, tSore dTe\v<as baKveLV

eTOLfxoL elvaL, iiTeLbdv TLva kfjpov avT&v dcpaipQfxai, Kal ovk
otovTai fxe evvoia tovto TroLelv, iT6ppo) ovTes tov elbevaL otl
d ov6eis 0eos bijcrvovs dvdpca-noLS, ovb' eyo) bvcrvoici tolovtov
ovbev bp&, dAAd fJuoL yj/evbds tc crvyôjpfjcTai kol dkrfdes
dcf)avicrai ovbafx&s defXLS. TrdAty brf ovv e^ dp\ffs, o)
QeaiTrfTe, 5ti ttot kcrrlv eiTLCTTrffxrf, TTeLpca keyeiv o)S 6' ov\
5 ordff T ei, fxrfbeTTOT eLTTrfs. eav ydp 6ebs edekjf Kal dvbpi(rf,
oios T ea-rf.
0EAI. 'AAAa fxivToi, S 2wKpaTes, ctov ye ovto) irapa-

KekevofxevQV alcT\pov fxrf ov TTavTL TpoiTOi TTpodvfxeLcrdai ori
a 5 ovToi T : aiiro\ B a8 Ktivai T : iKtivai B ba ivioa

Berol. ivloTt B T
: (vioi : W noi om. W b^ trvv om. pr. B
b6 i\Koit~\ iXKovs BT b^ ujroirTtvuv B b8 Kvovra B
C I ixaias] fiaias rt Ka\ W C 4 a-rofidWu T uiro)3iXai B dirojBaAw
W
: :
05 ^St)] 5)j Plutarchus 07 air iiv om. T c8 /ue

Plutarchus : om. B T W Berol.
0EAITHTO2 tsie
TLS ex^ft Xiyiv. SoKet ouv ijlol 6 kincrTaiievos tl alaOaveaQai e

TOVTO -ni(TTaTai, Kal uis ye vvvl (âiv^Tai, ovk akko tC
icrTLv TTL(TTi]iJ.r] 7] atadrjCTLi,
2X2. ES ye Kal yevvaims, S Trai* \pr] yap ovtcos aTTOipaL-
v6fXVov keyeiv. aXka <êpe 8?) avTo Koivf} <rK\}r(i)p.e6a, 5
yovLiiov r\ avefXLalov Tvyxo,VL ov. aL(r9r](rLS, (f)r]s, ktiL^TTrîxr];
0EAI. Nai. ,
2X2. KLvhvvevHS fx4vT0L koyov ov (f)avkov (lpr]KevaL Trepl
k-nLCTTrîxqs, akk ov ikeyi koI YIpooTayopas. Tpoirov be TLva 152

akkov Lpr]Ke to. avTO. TavTa. (fyrjal ydp ttov " TTavT(i)V
Xpr^pdTOtiV fiiTpov " avOpojTTOv etvai, " tG>v fiev ovToyv ws iOTL,
Toiv be pi] ovTcov ws ovk ecrTLV." aviyvcoKas yap ttov;

0EAI. 'Ayeyz^co/ca Kal TTokkaKLS. 5
2X2. OvKovv ovTCd TTois kiyei, w5 ota p.\v eKaa-Ta epol

(f)aivTaL TOLavTa pikv co-tlv epoi, ola 8e aoi, TOLavTa be av
aoi' av9po)7Tos be crv re Kaydo;
0EAI. Ae'yet yap ovv ovto).
2X2. EtKo? pivTOL (Tocôv avbpa ju^ kr^pelv TTaKokov6-q - b

cro)p.ev ovv avTO). ap' ovk evioTe iTveovTOS avepov tov avTov
6 fiev r]fiS>v pLy^, 8' ov; kcu 6 fxev rjpefxa, 6 be a(f)6bpa;

0EAI. Kat ptaAa.
2X2. IloVepoi' ovv Tore aiTo e<^' eauroS to irvevpa 5
yjfV)(j)bv 77 ov yfrvxpbv (f)r]aofxev; rf iTeLa6fxe9a t5 ripftJTayo/aa
OTt Tw pev pLywvTL \}/v\p6v, Tw 8e fxrj ov;

0EAI. "EoLKev.
2X2. OvKcvv Kal cf)aiveTaL ovto) eKaTep(o;
'
0EAI. Nat. 10
2X2. To 8e' ye " (paCveTai " ala9avea9ai eaTLv;

0EAI. "Eo-Tty yap.
2X2. <t>ayTa(rta apa koX aXa9r]aLS Tavrbv ev Te êppols C
Kai Trao-t TOts TOtovTOts. ota yap aia9dveTaL eKaaros,
TOLavTa eK(xaT<i) Kal KLvbvveveL etvaL.
bs favTov W Berol. : (avrh BT b 11 alcrddyfTat Berol.

.
igac nAATIiNOS
0EAI. "EoiKev.
5 2X2. At(r6ri(ri,s apa tov ovtos acl kariv KoX 6.\l/evbS w?
fTTKTTrjfxr] ova-a.
0EAI. 4>aiWat.
212. 'Ap' ovv TTpos XapCT(t)V 7:d<r(ro(f)6s tis ^v 6 Upoii-
Tayopas, Kal tovto rjpLLV ijikv rjviâTO tw 7roA.Aa) (rvp(f)eTS>,
lo Tols 8e p.a6r]Tals iv cnTopprJTif ttjv ak-q6ciav cAeyer;
d 0EAI. n&)s 6^, % ^(siKpaT(s, TOVTO \4yis; y-'

212. 'Eyo) epo) Kal p.aX' ov (})avkov \6yov, o)? fipa ev
lAv avTo Ka6' avTo ovbev (rTt,Vj ovb' av ti TrpoareCTroLS
dp6(j)S ovb' OTTOLOvovv TL, oAA.' iav OiS IJ-iya irpoa-ayopevris,
5 Kal criJLLKpov (fâveXTaL, Kal iav âpv, Kovcpov, crvinravTa re

ovTias, 0)9 jurjoews oiro? evos p-r]Te tlvos p.r]Te ottolovovv^ tjt
(K 8e br] (f)opas re koll KLvii^recDS Kal Kpdcnoos iTpbs aAAijAa
yCyveTaL iTavTa b. brj (fâp-ev eXvaL, ovk 6p6S)S Trpocrayo-
e pevovres' (cttl piev yap ovbeiroT ovbev, dei be yiyveTaL.

Kol TTepl TOVTOv TT(xvTes kîjs oi 0-0001 7rA?V Tiapp-evLbov
(rvp.(f)epe(r6(t)v, YIpcaTay^pas re Kal 'HpaKkeLTOs Kal 'EpLiTe-
boKkfjs, Kal T(av TTOLr]T(ov ol CLKpoi Trjs TTOiTjo-eo)? eKarepas,
5 KcrijixwStas ixev 'EiTLxapiiOs, Tpaycobias be "OpLripos, (05^
elTTcav
'Q.Keav6v re deSv yevecTLV kol iir]Tepa Tr]6vv
TTavTa eLprjKcv eKyova porjs re kol KLvrja-eoiS' ^ ov boKet

TovTo Ae'yeiv;ji*^ ds^
10 0EAI. "EixoLye.
153 2X2. Tis ovv hv eTL TTp6s ye Toaovrov aTpaTîTebov Kal

arpaTriybv "Op.r^pov bvvaLTo ap.(f)La^r]Trjaas ixr] ov KaTa-
yikaaros yevea6aL;
0EAI. Ov pabLov, w 2a)Kpare?.
d 4 post wpoffctyoptviis add. ri Stobaeus d 5 ^0 om. post T

fiapv add. Ti Stobaeus e 2 i^rjs ol Stob. T
^{aiViOi B Eus.
: W :
4âl(Ttot 01 Berol. e 3 avjji^ptpiffOw B (ut videtur) ffvft.<t>tpfffOov

TW
:
Berol. Eus. : ffvfKpfpovra Stobaeus e 5 iy add. Heindorf

aa ftii oiW Stobaeus : /ij) BT
0EAITHTO2 I53 Xoya)'^^*^T

a-qfjLeXa iKavd, otl to jixcy eirat SoKouy Kat to yiyvtcrdai.
KLinjcns 7rape'xet, ro 8el/u,?) etyatlKat d77o'AAi)o-ât^ô-u)(ta* ro
yap depixov re Kai inJp, o br} Kal rSAAa yevva Kal iiTLTpo-
Trevet, avro yeymrat eK (f)Opas Kal TpC^j/eoiS' tovto) 8e

KLvijcreLS. rj ov^ avrai yev(rLS TTvpos; ô
0EAI. Avrat /xey ovv. t>
2i2. Kat /X7/J/ t6 ye rwi' Oj^coy ye^ros eK rwy avTQv

TOVTUiV (f)VTaL.
0EAI. nws 8' oi);
2X2. Tt 8e'; tj tG)V <roL)p.dT(iov e^tj ov)( vtto Tj^rvxias ixev 5
Kai dpyias 8toAAurai, vtto yvfxvacrioov 8e Kal Kti^rjo-eo)? eiri
TToXv o-(riêrat;
0EAI. Nat'.
212. 'H 8' V Trj \}rvxrj e^ts ovx vtto /xa^Tjo-ecos /xev Kai
/bieA.e'rr]s, Kti^Tjo-ecor ovt(dv, KTCLTai re pLa6r]p.aTa koX a-u)êTaL lo
Kai yiyveTaL iSeXTiâVx vtto 8' ri(rvxio.s, diJ.\eTr](rias re Kat
dp.a6iasov&r]s, ovt tl pLavddvH d re ay /xd^T; iTLKav6dvTaL; C
0EAI. Kai /udAa.
2X2. T6 /xey dpa dyadbv Kivrj(ns Ka^d re ^/^vx^/y Kai
Kara o-co/xa, ro oe TovvavTLOv; "^
0EAI. 'EotKey. 5
2X2. *Ert oSy o"ot Ae'ya) vr]Vp.ias re Kat yaATjiâ? Kal

oara TOLavra, otl al jxev r](TvyJ.aL arjTTovcTL koX diToWvaaL,
rd 8' Tpa o-(riêt; Kat eTTt tovtols tov KoKo(^Q>va, [dvayKd^()i\
TTpoa-^Ll3d^(i) TTjv xpvarjv a-eLpdv cb? ovh\v akXo r/ tov rjXLOv
"Op.rjpos kcycL, Kal 8r;Aot ort eco? pikv dv r} 7repi0opd r] d
KLVovp.ivr] KOLL 6 7/Atos, irdyra eo-rt Kai frcoêrat rd kv deols
a6 ioKovv secl. Schanz ag tovto) B^WBerol. toSto BT

W
:
Stobaeus a lo Kivfâîs B /ctVrjtris T Kivr)<ns Stobaeus

W r)
: :
b 2 ye tJ> pr. B b 6 air6K\inai Kivâews Stobaeus KLvfiffeaiv :
BT eiri 7roA.i/l ois f-n-i iroAi; T (sed a>s supra versum) eirl rh iro\v B :
Stobaeus b lo Kivrtffewv ohffwv Stobaeus KivT\ffeoiv ovtoiv Buttmann:
C 8 avayKdCa) secl. Cobet C g irpofffii&a^w Cobet irpoPt $a^cov B

W
:
Stobaeus Trpofffiifidûv T
; Berol. d 2 Ta om. Stobaeus
153 d nAATHNOS
T Kai av6p(aTToi.s, cZ be crTair] tovto axnrfp bed{v, TrdvTa
XP?/xar' av hiatpdapilr] koX yivovr hv to Xiy6p.evov &.vui^^^>,>f*
5 Karco Trarra;
0EAI. 'AAA.' c/xotye hoKii, w 2w/cpares, Tavra br]Kovv
212. T7rqA.a/3e roiin;i', w apioTC, ovTooa-i' /cara ra

ofXfxaTa TTpStTov, o 8;; KaAei? yjywixa kevKov, \xi] etrai avro
lo (Tepov TL lô) rc3y o-wy ofMixdTcav fir]S' ^v roiy ofjLfiaa-i fir]be
e riy' avr(S xutpav aTTora^T/s' 7/8r/ ya/) &v 6^7/ re bîTov kv

raêt Kat [x4vov Kal ovk &v ^y yevecret, yiyvoi,TO.
0EAI. 'AXXa irc3s;
212. 'ETTw/^teâ rw 5/3rt Aoyw, /iT/Ser avro KaG' avrb tv

5 ov TidevTes' KoX fiixLV ovTui fxikav re koL KevKov Kal otlovv
aKX.0 xp&ixa ck rijs TTpocrfioKrjs t&v oixixdTcav iTpos Tr]V
TTpo(Tr]Kov<Tav (popav (ârctrai yeyevrîxevov, Kal 6 8^ (KacTTOv
154 tmt (f)ap.V XP<2/>ta oiJre t6 iTpocr^dXKov ovt t6 irpo^Tâk-

k6p.Vov ((TTai, dX\a fxcTa^ tl kKdcrrca tbLov yeyovds' ^
crv bLL(TxvpL(raLo hv u)S olov crol (f)aLVTaL (KacrTov xpiafxa,
TOLOVTOV Kal Kvvl Ka\ OTioouv C^(a;
5 0EAI. Ma At" ovK eyuiye.
212. Tt 8e; aA\(p dv9p(aTT(D ap' ofxoiov Kal (rol (f>aLVTaL
OTLovv; ^x^^s^ TovTo L(rxyp(as, 1] ttoXv /xaAAoi' ort ovbe (tol
avT(o TavT6v 8ta t6 fxrjbeTTOTf ofxqLois avT6v (reaxrr^ ^X^^*'

0EAI. ToOro fxdWov fxoL boKeX rj iKelvo. ^
b 22. OiiKovv el fxiv S> TTapafxeTpovfxeda f; ov 6â7rro'/xcâ

p.4ya rj XevKov r] depp6v yv, ovk &v Trorc aAAw Trpo(nT(r6v
aAAo dv iyey6v(L, avT6 ye fxrjbev /xera/SoAAov ei be av to

TTapafieTpovfxevov rf f(f)aTTT6fxevov eKacrrov ^v tovtchv, o^k
5 h.v av aAAou 7rpoo-cA0orros 7/ ri TraôWos avro fxrfbev iTa66v
d.3 Ztdtv T SoOtV B Stobaeus

: d 4 to ivo) Kirw Stobaeus
d.8 Kara TW ko2 B
: tl Kara B'
: e i 5^xoi/ Schanz Hv irov : BT
e 2 Kol ttivov Stobaeus Kfl/xtvoi pr. B (sed corr. koI titvoi) : Ktlfitvov T
:
a8 avrhv] atavrhv W
b I ^J ft Comaiius ba HWtfi T: &Wo B
b 4 ^] ^ t6 WStobaeus
0EAITHTO2 i54b
akXo av (yiveTo. eirel vvv ye, w (/)tAe, davfJiaa-Td re Kal
yekoTa ewxepws tto)? d.vayKa(6iJ,e6a kiyav, ws (âirj av

ripcorayopa? re /cat Tray 6 ra aiira KCv<a kTnxîpS^v Xeyeiy,
0EAI. n&is 8^ Kal TTota Aeyets;

212. ^fxtKpbv kajBe -napdbeiyiJ.a, Kal TrdvTa eio-rj ^ /Bov- c
Xofxat. do-rpayoAouy ydp -n-ou e^, dy /xey TeTTapas avTois
TTpoa-eviyKrjs, Trkeiovs (f)apLv elvai t5>v TeTrdpcov /cat ^jitto-
Aious, edy b^ baibeKa, ekdTTOvs koI i]p.ia-eis, Ka\ ovbe dveKTOv
dkKias keyeiv' rj ai) dve^rj; 6
0EAI. OvK 4y(tiy.
212. Ti ovv; dv ae YlpooTayopas epr]Tai ?/ rts dA.Xos'

"'12 0eatrTjre, eo-^' o-Trcos rt /xetôr ?) irkiov yiyveTai dkkm
7] av^dev;" tC dTTOKpLvfj;
0EAI. 'Edr fxev, u) 2coKpare?, rd hoKovv Trpos ti]V vvv io
kpwrqa-iv d7roKptycop,ai, ori ovk eaTiv edr 8e Trpds ti]V d

TxpoTi.pav, (j)vkdTT(ov /u.^ evavTia eiTToo, ori eaTiv.
212. ES ye z^t) rr/v "Hpay, co 0tAe, KOt Oeioos. aTap, ojs
OLKV, edv dTTOKpCvri OTL (o-TLV, EiiptTTtSetoV rt ovfxîfaeTaL'
r] fxkv yap ykStTTa dvikeyKTOS rifxlv eo-rat, 57 be <f>pr}V ovk 5
dvekeyKTOS.
0EAI. 'AAtj^^.
212. OvKovv et /ixey Setrot Kat coôt eyo) re Kat av
TjjLter, Trdrra rd roii; (ppeviav e^r^raKOTes, 7)817 dy rd AotTTov
eK TTepLOvaCas dkki]ku>v dTTOTretp&jju.eyot, cruyeA^dvres ao(f)i- e
o-rtKci)? et? fJ^dxrjV TOLavrqv, dkkifkoiv tovs koyovs tols Adyots
eKpovofxev vvv be aTe t8t(Srai TvpS^Tov ôvkrjo-ofxeOa dea-
aaaOaL avTa Trpbs avrd tC ttot eaTlv h bLavoovfxeOa, TioTepov

r]fdv dAA7/Aoty avfX(f)(avek rj ovb* oTTOiirTiovv. 5
0EAI. ndyu fxev ovv lycoye roirr' dv (ôvkoCfirfv.
212. Kat pifv eyw. oTe 8' oxJrcos exêt, dAAo rt rj rjpepLa,
d)? Trdm; TTokkr^v axokrfv dyovres, TrdAty eTTavaa-Ke^ôfxeda,

ov bvaKokaCvovTes dkkd roi d^frt rffxds avTovs eêTdôvTes, 155
d5 ivf^fXtyKros W 67 iyw'] l^yaiyi B (sed ex emend.) W

PLATO, VOL. 1. 18
155 a nAATilNOS
uTTa TTOT ecTTL TavTtt To, (l)d(r[xaTa ev fjfxiv; S>v TrputTov
(TncTKOTrovvTis (f)ri(ro[iV, <l)s eyo) oTfiai, ixr)b4TroT fir}bev &v
Helôv fxr)be ekaTTOv yV(rat fiTjre oyKio nrJTf apiOy.^, ccos
5 Xaôv eLT] avTo kavTSt. ov^ ovtcds;
0EA1. Nai.
212. AevTepov be ye, u> fxrjTe ttpo^ttiBoIto jxrfTe aâipoT.TO,
TOVTO fx-qTe avâvecrOai iTOTe fxi}Te (pdCveiv, ael be laov
etvai..
10 0EAI. Kofxibrj fxev ovv.
b 2C2. 'Ap' ovv ov Kal TpiTov, o fxrf irpoTepov ^v, v(rTepov

ak\a TovTo etvai avev tov yeveaOai. kolI yiyve(r6aL abvvaTOv;
0EA[. AoKel ye brf.
212. Tavra 8?;, olofxaL, ofxoXoyrffxaTa TpCa fxdxfTai avTO.

5 avTols ev Trj rffxeTepcL "yfrvxfj, oTav tcl Trepl tu>v dcrTpayakoiV
Xey(op.ev, rf oTav (f^&fxev c/xe TrfkLKOvbe ovTa, fxrfTe av^rfdevTa
fxrfTe TovvavrCov TradovTa, ev evLavT(a crov rou veov vvv fxev
fxeCôo eTvaL, v(rTepov be eXaTTco, fxrjbev tov efxov oyKov

C dâipedevTO<i dXkd (tov av^devTos. eifxl ydp bif vaTepov
o irpoTepov ovk 17, ov yevofxevos' dvev ydp tov yCyve^rOaL
yevecrOaL dbvvaTOV, fxrjbev be dirokkvs tov oyKOV ovk dv
TTore eyLyv6p.rfv ekdTTOiV. kcu. dkka bif fxvpCa eTiX fxvpCoLS
?i ovrcos ^x^* ^XTTep kcxl raCra TrapabeôfxeQa. tTrrf ydp nov,
(i> &eaCTrfTe' 8oKet9 yovv fxoL ovk dTreipos T(av tolovto>v
etvaL.
0EAI. Kai vTf Tovi Oeovs ye, 00 2cdAcpares, vTrep^pvm

(t)S 6avfxaCoi tC ttot ecrT\ TavTa, k(xl evCoTe o>s dXr]dS>s
10 j3keTTo>v els avTa a-KOTobLVLoi.
d 212. Qeobcopos ydp, u (f)Cke, (}>aCveTai ov KaKois TOTTdêiv

TTepl Tifs (f)V(re(iiS (rov. fxdka ydp (f>Lkocr6(f)ov tovto to
a2 (}>d(rfiaTa] (pavTdffiJLaT W
a 4 /iij8J] fi-fiTt a 7 (J] ft W W
bI aAAcl ScTTfpov Stcphanus (at schol. 6 np6K\os rb TtapfKKtiv aWa
K4yti) b 3 5^ T W
Sok f7 B b 4 5^] 76 8^ b 7 iviavrif 1 W
W
:
ifjiavrtfi al. C5 eVej Heindorf: flirf BT

c6 yovvl yhp oiv
c8 yt secl. Schanz c9 uiy post virtp(pvui om. T d i 70^] 7^p
S8 W
0EAITHTOS i55d
Tra6o9, To davfxdCfLV ov yap aXXr} apxn (f>iÔ(ro(f)Las i]
avTT}, Kal eoLKeV 6 rrjv 'Iptv &avfjLavTOS iKyovov (f)^(ras ov

KaKU)S yeveaXoyeiv. aXXa iroTepov p.av6dvLS rjbrj bt o 5
TavTa TOLavT' (ttiv k^ S>v Tov HpooTayopav (f)apLV X.iy(LV,
q ovTioi;
0EAI. OVTTO) fXOL ZokS).

2)12. XdpLV ovv fxoL da-rj edv croL dvbpos, ixdXXov be
avbpS)v dvopMOT&v rrjs biavoias rrjv dXr}6eLav diroKSKpvfiixivrjv lo
(Tvv^pVVT^cr(jt)paL avT&v; e
0EAI. Tlo)s yap ovk eta-opai, Kal Ttdw yc 'noXXrfv;
2X2. "Adp^L br\ TTepLCTKOTTav fxrj TLS T&v dpLVriTcov TraKovrf.
clcrlv be ovTOL ol ovbev dXXo oi6pvoL eivat rf ov dv bvvuivTaL

d~pl^ Tolv yjepolv Xa^(Tdai, TTpd^^LS be Kal yereVet? Kal Tidv 5
To doparov ovk dTrobx6pVOL o)S v ova-ias fxipei.

0EAI. Kal pV byf, S) "EôKpaTes, aKXrfpovs ye Aeyets Kal
dirrLTVTrovs dv6p(aTT0vs. ^56

212. Kl(rlv ydp, 0) TTal, fxdX' ev a/xoutrof aAAot 8e ttoXv
Kop.y\r6TpoL, &v pXX(t) croL to. fxvarrfpLa Xey^LV. dpxt] bi,
e^ rjs Kol a wvb-i] iXeyopev TTavra i]pTr]TaL, rjbe avr&v, o)S
t6 irdv KLvr](rLS r]V kcu dXXo TTapd tovto ovbiv, rijs 8e KLvr]- 5
cr(t)s bvo eXbrj, nXr]6L pev dTTLpov kKdrepov, bvvapLV 6e to
fXV TTOtety \ov, To 8e Trao-xêty. K 6e rrjs tovto)v opLXCas

T Kol TpL\l/0)s TTpos dXXrfXa yLyvTaL Kyova TTXr]6i piev
dTTLpa, bibvpa 8e', ro pV alo-6riT6v, to be alcrdrfcrLS, dei o

avvKTTLTTT0V(ra Kal yvvo)pv>] ju,era tov alcr^rjTov. ai p.V
ovv aio-^ô-ety Ta roid8e rjplv xov(nv 6v6fxaTa, oT//-ets re koX

dKocu Kcu 6a(})pr]a-LS kol v/fvfets re Kai Kava-LS Kal rfbovai
ye 5^ Kat XxnraL xat TTL6vp.iaL kcu c})6[3ol KKXr]pvaL Kal 5
dAAat, diTcpavTOL fxkv al dvoowpoL, Tra/xTrArjêis 8e at o)Vo-
d6 toOto] to W Xfynv <pafi4v W e i avrSsv^, avTcav W

64 oj ol6/Jifvoi] oi
. . . oXofiai B . . a 2 SaAoi Se scripsi &Woi
. :
5 B T a\\' oTSe Schleiermacher

: iroAi;] iroAAol T a 4 e| ^s]
|7Jy B T a 5 î' secl. Schanz b 2 ffvvfKirlirToviTaj (rvvfKTiK-
Tov(Ta Ast b 4 /cavo-eis] 6ep/j.dvfffis in marg t pr. : W
18*
156 b nAATXlNOS
liaafxtvaL' to b av alaO-qrov yevos TovTOiV kKdaTais 6yu6'
C yovov, d\f/ea-L ixcv yjitafxaTa fTavTobaTrals TTairrobaTri,, d,Koais
b^ ii(ravTU)s (ôivai, koX rais ÂAais alaOricricn to. 6.\Ka

al(r6r]Ta arvyyfvij yiyvoî^va. tI bi] ovv rjfuv ôvk^Tai ovtos
6 fxvOos, S) eatTTjre, iTpbs to. iTpoTcpa; apa ivvoels;
5 0EAI. Ov TTavv, w 2)(WK/)ares.
2X2. 'AAA' aOpei iav ttms aTroTeKea-Qrj. /3ovAerai yap

br] KiyfiV o)? Tavra TT^.VTa fxev a>aTT(p keyofxev KLVfiTai,
T(i\os b^ Kal l3pabvTr]s Vi Trj Kiv^crci avrcoy. oa-ov fxev
ovv fipabv, V roi avrai koL Tipbs Ta Tr\r]ai.(i.(ovTa TTfv
d Ktvrja-LV La)(êL Ka\ ovTâ bif yevvd., to. be yVV(6pi.eva ovtco

Sj; OoLTTdi iaTLV. (f)pTaL yap Kal iv (ôpa aurwr rf KLvrjaLS
TTe^pvKev. eTTeLbav ovv ofxfxa kol &\X.o ti t5>v Tovr<i) crvfx-
fxeTpoiv TT\riaL(xaav yevvrfat] ti]V \evK6Tr]T(x re Kal alaOrjaLV
5 avTfj avfX(f)VT0V, h ovk av ttot eyeveTO eKaTepov eKeivuiV
TTpbs aWo i\d6vT0S, t6t br] fXTa^v (f)epofxev(i)V Trjs fxev
e 6\j/(t)S TTpbs T(aV 6(\)6cL\fXti)V, Ttjs b^ \eVK6rqT0S TTpbs TOV

avvaTTOTLKTOVTOs To ^(^poifxa, 6 fxev 6(f)6a\pibs apa o\//-ea)S
efXTT\(i)s eyeveTO kol opq br] t^tc Kal eyeveTO ov tl o^ls

aX\! 6(f)da\fxbs bp5)V, Tb be avyyevvrjaav Tb xpiafxa \evK6TrjTos
5 TTpLeTT\r]a6r] Kal eyeveTo ov \evK6rqs av aWa \Vk6v, eiTe
^v\ov eire \C6os efre OTâovv avvifirf )(j}rjfxa xpoDa^rjvaL r<j)
TOLOVT(^ \p(ifxaTL. Kcu rSAAa br) o^to), aK\r]pbv Kal 6epfxbv
Kal TTavTa, Tbv avTuv TpîTov vTTo\qTTTeov , avTb fxev Ka6^

157 avTb fxrfbev elvaL, b br] Kal t6t eAe'yo/xer, iv 8e ttJ irpbs
a.\\q\a 6fXL\Lq iTavTa yCyveaâi kol TTavTola aiTb Trjs
KLvrjaeo)s, eiTel Kal Tb ttolovv elvaC tl Kal Tb iTaaxov avToiv

^ttI evbs vorjaaL, ws (f)aaLV, ovk elvai iTayL(i)S. ovt yap
6 TTOLOvv eaTL TL TTplv hv T(o TTaayovTL avv\6r], ovTC TTdaxpv
}}"] Kacrraiy 6/j.6\oyov

T
Sairory xp^^l^f^ra
W: fKiffTrjs &fi.6yovov BT
078^ om. fiiv om. TW
C r Torro-
d i post
W
lacunam indicat Schanz
oi>To 5);
W
d^ koX] t kclL toiJt^] W
ToiovTuv e 6 6T<fovv Campbell Stou olv B T &tiovv al.
: :
Xp^MK 3I. Heindorf: x/''i'M<( BT: secl. Campbell o'x^M<* Schanz :
a 3 avTa!v'\ al Schanz a 5 t om. T &v] aZ B

0EAITHTOS I57a
'Trplv hv Tw TroLovvri' t6 re tlvl (rvveXdov koI TtOLovv aAAo)

av TTpo(nre(r6v 7rd(7)(ov avecpavr]. &(tt e aTravTOiv tovt(ov,
6iTp e^ 6.p)(fjs eXeyofjiev, ovbev etvaL ev avTO KaO^ avTO, aXXa.
rivi det yLyvfcrdaL, ro 8' iXvai iravraypdtv eâLpereov, ovx b
OTL rjpieXs TToXXa Kal aprL i]vayKaap.e6a vtto (TvvqOeias koX
aveTrLarrfixocrvvqs yjtrjcrQaL avrSt. rb 8' ov 5et, &)? 6 Twy
<ro(^G>v koyos, ovn ri (TVY)(u>pa,v ovre tov ovt (p.ov ovrc
Tobe ovT eKfiro ovre aXXo ovbev ovop.a otl av [(rrrj, aXXa 5
Kara (f)V(rLV (f^deyyea-OaL yLyvojxeva Kal TTOLOiJixeva Kal aiToX-
Xvp.va Ka\ aXXoLovp.(va- wy iav rC tls a-Tr](n] t(o Adyo),

(veXeyKTos 6 rovro ttol&v. bel 8e Kal Kara \xipos ovrco
Xiy^LV KCLL 7Tpl TToXX(ii)V aOpoLaOivTOiV, & br] a6poi(T]xaTL
&v6p(iiTT6v T ridevraL Kal Xidov Kal iKaarov Ci!^6v re Kal c

(tbos. ravra 817, w eaiVrjTe, ap' rjbia ^doKcl a-oL cTvaL, Kal
yevoLO hv avr&v ws apa-K6vT(ov;
0EAI. OvK oTba y(oye, u) 'EôKpares' Kal yap ovbe irepi
aov bvvapaL KaravorjaaL Trdrepa boKovvra aoL Aeyeis avra r/ 5
(fxov aTTOTTeLpa.
2X2. Ov fxvrjfxoveveLs, Sj (piXc, otl eyoj p-ev ovr oTba ovre

TTOLOvfxaL tG)V roLovT(j)v ovbev i]x6v, dAA' el]xl avrwv ayovos,
(Tt 8e [xaLevo]xaL Kal rovrov eveKa e7ra8co Te kol TTaparidrjpL
kKa(TT(DV tS)V ao(f)&v aTToyevaaaâL, eojs hv ets ^S)S ro aov d
b6yp.a crvveâyayu)' eâ^êWo? 8e r^r 7)877 a-Ke\j/o]xaL (lt
avep.Lalov eXre y6vL]xov ava^pavrâ-eraL. aXXa 6appG)V kol
Kaprp5)V ev kcxl avbpeia^s atTOKpivov h. h.v <f)aivr]rai croL irepl
Zv av ep(DTG>. ^5
0EAI. 'EpwTa 8^
211. Aeye tolwv ttoXlv et o-ot apecrKeL rb ]xr] tl eXvaL akXa
yiyve(r6aL dei ayadbv /cai KaXbv xat iTdvra a apTL bLr]]xev.
a7 a5" h,v W 0iV<pd.vr\] h.v i<pavT) T b4

tov oIjt' (fj.ov]
toCto Schanz : ffov oGt i/xov Hirschig b8 KaTo] /coTi T
koI
C ICv^"
om. T
'''* 'f^ eKoffrov elSos Schanz c 2 ffot 5oKe7 W
e 3 is
d I aTToyfvfffdai T d 8 ayadhv Kal Ka\hv secl. Ast
Si^fifv BT et in marg. W : hii]Kdonfv W
i57d nAATI2N02
0EAI. 'AAA.' e/uotye, TretS^ a-ov aKovco ovtu) Sieîovro?,
^x^"' ôyov koX vnoXrjirriov

10 davfxacTLOis (âivirai. o)j ffirep
buXi]\vdai.
e 212. Mrj ToCwv &,TTo\CiT<iifXV 5(rov ikkeiirov avrov. Aei-
TTfrai, 6e iwirvCMV re tt^/ji Kai voo-mv tG>v re iAAcor Kal
fiavCas, ocra re irapaKovdv 77 irapopav y ri aAAo Tiapai.crdd-
veadai Ae'yerat. oto-â yap ttou ort er Trao-t rovrots
5 6fw\oyovp.4vMS ikeyxeadai SoKet &y 5/3ri bLi^jxev koyov,
158 0)? Trayros nakkov fjfXLV \//êy8ets ato-^Tjo-ets ev avrots yLyvo-
fievas, Kal TTokkov bel tcl <paLv6p.va eicdo-ra) Tama koa. ^lvai,
aXka Trav TovvavTCov ovbev 5>v <})aCvTaL dvai.

0EAI. ' Akr]Oi(rTaTa Aeyets, w SwKpares.
5 212. Tts br) ovv, S) TTal, keLTTeraL Ao'yos rw ti]v aX(r6r]<TLV
fTTL(TTr]ixr]v TL9]xev(o Kal To. (})aLv6fXva KdaT(o TavTa Kal

(IvaL TovTio u> (jiaCvfTaL;
0EAI. 'Eyoj fxiv, S) 2(tfcpares, okvQ diTelv otl ovk exo)

rt keycti, 8tort jxol wvbr] eTTeTTkr^âs (Itt6vtl avT6. eTrei ws
b dkrjdQs ye ovk hv bvvaCp.r]v dfx^pLo- ^r]Tr](TaL ws ot [xaLv6fXvot
r] [61] 6vLp(aTT0VTS ov ^vbfj bo^dCov^TLV, oTav oi fXV dcol

avT<av oLcovTaL etrat, ot 8e TrrqvoC re Kai ws Trero/ierot iv t<o
VTTV<0 bLavo&VTaL.
6 2X2. 'Ap' ovv ovbe t6 T0L6vb d]X(^La-^r]Tr]\xa ivvofls TTCpl
avTOiv, fxdkLo-Ta 8e Trept tov ovap re Kot vjTap;
0EAI. To TTOLOv;
2f2. *0 TroAA^Kts o-e oi/xat dKr^Koivat ipcoTiovTcov, tC av

rts xôi TKjxi]pLov aTToSetât, et rts ipoLTO vvv ovtcos V rai
10 TTapdvTL Tt6tP0V Kadvbop.V KOLL TTdvTa h bLaVOOVfXda 6vL-

C p(i>TTOfXv, rf ypr]y6pafx4v re koI vnap dAAj;Aots 8taAeyo'/ie0a.
0EAI. Kai firfv, a 2wKpares, diTop^v ye oro) \pi]
^7rt8etât TKfxr]pC<o' Trdrra ydp uxriTep dvTCa-Tpo(f>a rd avrd
e I i,vo\fiirttfiev W 6 2 ruv re] re rwv Stobaeus a i fiaWovl

/jia\Kov tiv Stobaeus a a 8?] 5?' Heindorf a 3 &y Th;
t)v B Stobaeus hs om. T
ol bg ^x"' otn. T C2 ^pj^
TW :
xp^^V ?CPh B : xp^wv Hultsch C 3 to avra] ravTa W
0EAITHTO2 158C
TrapaKokovdKX. a re yap wvl bteiXeyjxeOa ovbev KcaXvei Kal

(V rw ^TTJ^w boKW ak\i]koL$ biakdyea-dai' Kal orav br] ovap 5
ovetpara SoKw/zex^ btrjyeladai, aTOTTOs rj 6p.o(,6Tr)s tovtcov

iK^CvOLS.
212. 'Opas ovv ort t6 ye ap.(f)La-^r]Trja-aL ov xakeTr6v, 6t

Kal tt6tp6v ia-Tiv virap r] ovap apL(f)La-l3r]TeLTai, Kal 87/ laov d
ovTos Tov \p6vov ov Kadevbofxev oi eypr]y6paiJLv, ev e/care/jw
btajj.dxTaL r]]xGiV r]
"^XV ''O' ^^^ irap^VTa b6yixaTa TravTos
jxakkov etvai akr]6r], âTe laov ]xkv xp6vov Tabe (pafxkv
ovTa (TvaL, taov 8e eKelva, Kal ofxoLcos <^' eKaTepoLS 5
bLL(TxypL^6ixe6a.
0EAI. YlavTA-nacrL ]x\v ovv.
2i2. OvKovv KCLL TTepl v6(r(av re kcu fxavL&v 6 avTOS k6yos,
TTkr^v Tov xp6vov OTL ovx} Laos;
0EAI. 'OpO&s. 10
2X2. Ti ovv; irkifOeL xpovov Kal oAtyorr/ri to akrjOes

6pLa-6r](r(TaL;
0EAI. reAoioy pLevTav eirj TToXAax^. C

2X2. 'AAAa ri aAAo exêts aa^pes evbeCâcrâL OTTola TOVTOiV
T5iV boâa]x6.Tcov akr]dfj;
0EAI. Ov poL boKW.

2X2. 'E/xoij TOLwv aKove ola TTepl avT^v av keyoLev ol to. 5
det boKovm-a 6pL^6p.evoL rw 8oKot'i'rt eTrat dkr]6r]. keyovaL
be, 0)9 eyo) oi/xat, ovt(os epcorojyres* '*'X2 0eatr?7re, 6 dv
eTepov r] TTavTdiTa^TLV, p.r] TTrj TLva bvvapLV Tr]v avTr]v eêi
rw eTep<a; Kal fxr] viTokdôofxev Tfj p.ev TavTov e7vaL o
epoiT&jxev Trj be eTepov, dAA' oAcos eTepov." 10
0EAI. 'ASwaroy toCwv tovt^v tl exî-v r] ev bvvdpeL f] 159

ev aAAci) 6ro)oi;y, otov rj KopLbfj eTepov.
2X2. 'A/a' ovv ov /cat dvdpoLov dvayKaiov to tolovtov

6p.okoyeLv;
C4 rufi] yvvSii Cobet c6 ovfipaTa &TTa Heindorf cQ t6

yf TOTe 76 W dg oux^] ovk W ei /j.tyT^yl /ifv iiv "W
e8 efj; tV 5' aiiTijv W a2 Srav] ori tu' Dobree : t tiv Hirschig
;
i59a nAATi2NOS
5 0EAI. 'EjLtoiye SoKei.
212. EZ &pa Ti o-v/x/Sa^ret SfxoMv r^ yiyvf<r6ai rf h>6\ioiov,

etre kavr^ etre ciAAw, 6fj.oiovfivov yikv ravTov (f)ri(rofiV
yiyvca-dai, avofxoi,oviJt.(vov 8e (repov;

0EAI. 'Avay/cTj.
10 212. OvKovv TTpocrOev iXiyofXfv o)i TroWa p.ev eiTj rct
TToiovvra Kal ^Tretpa, wo-awrajs 8e' ye ra Trao-^ôvra;

0EAI. Nar.
212. Kat /xTjy ort ye aWo a\\(a (Tvixp.iiyvvpLVov koX
a\\(a ov TavTCi ctAX' (Tfpa yivvrj^rei;
b 0EAI. YldLW p.V ovv.
212. Ae'yftj/jiey 8^ ejLie' re Kat o-e xai rSAAa 7)87; fcara
rbv avTov \6yov, ^(aKpdrq vyiaivovTa kolL ^(tiKpart] av

acrOevovvTa. TT^Tfpov ofJLOiov tovt iK(iv(o r] av6fiou)V
5 (f)rf(rofiev
0EAI. 'Apa Tov ^.(rOevovirra "SMKpdTTf, 5\ov tovto \4yeis

oAo) Keiv(a, roi vyiaivovTi 2(0Kp(iret;
2i2. KdAAto-ra V7r4\aj3s' avTo tovto X^yo).
0EAI. Âv6fxoiov brjiTOV.
10 2X2. Kat Tpov apa ovtcos u)(nTfp 6,v6fji,oLov;
0EAI. 'ArayKTj.
C 2X2. Kal Kadevboirra 87/ xat iT6vTa h. wvhif birf\Oofxev,
wo-avrcos ^r\(Tei.s;
0EAI. "Eycoye.
2X2. "Ejcao-roj; 87) t5)V ire^pvK^Ta^v ri irotety, aXAo rt, oTav
5 fxev \dprf vytaivovTa 2a)K/3dr7/, b)s er^/)(t) /xot xpifcreTai,
oTav 8e do-êroSrra, ws eTip(^;

EAI. Ti 8' ou /iAAet;
2X2. Kai (Tfpa 87/ e^' (KaTepov yevvrfcrofxev eyo5 re 6
7rdo-xa)v Kat (Kelvo t6 ttoiovv;
10 0EAI. T^ fxrfv;
a 10 irp6(T6tv\ iv Tols irpocrQtv W C i Ka0vSoirr? B lo/j/SJ^
Heindorf : vvv BT ca ^^(rcisj ^cofitv T

;
0EAITHTO2 I59C
2X2. "Orav br] olvov TtCvu) vyiaivuiV, i]bvs [xol <f)aCvTaL
Kol ykvKvs;
0EAI. NaC.
2X2. 'EyeVyrja-e yap br} eK tS>v ttpo(aiJ.oXoyr}[xeva>v t6 re
Tioiovv Kal To TTd<T)(ôv yXvKvrqTO. re Kal ata-drjcnv, ap.a d
<f)p6fj.va dp.(f)6Tepa, Kal rj p.V atcr6r](ns Trpos tov Trda-)(ôvTos
ovcra al(T6avo\xivr]v Tr]V ykuiTTav aTrr^pydcraTO, r) be yXvKVTr]s
Ttpos Tov oivov TTepl avTov <()poiJ.4vrj yXvKvv tov oXvov Tfi
vyiaLVOvcrr] ykcoTTrj eTToCrjaev Kal (IvaL Kal (paCvea-dat. 5

0EAI. Yldw jxev ovv tcl TTpdTepa r]]uv ovtoos b)pio\6yt]TO.
2X2. "Oray be d(T6evovvTa, aXXo tl TTpS)TOv piev Trj dXr]6(C(i
ov Tov avTov ikaêv; dvo]xoC(f ydp br] TTpo(rrj\6V.
0EAI. Nai'.
2X2. "Erepa br] av eyevirqcrdTr^v o re toiovtos 2a)Kpdrrj5 e

Kal r] Tov OLVOV 7ro(ris, TTepl p.V Tr]V y\Q)TTav aL(r6r]crLV
TTLKpOTr^TOS, TTfpl b( TOV OLVOV yLyVOp.Vr]V KOL (f)pO]X.eVr]V
TTLKp6Tr]Ta, KCLL TOV ]XV OV TTLKp6rr]Ta dXkd TTLKpdv, (fxk 8e

OVK aXcr6r]crLV dAA' alcr6av6]xevov 5
0EA1. KopLLbrj /xef ovv.
2X2. OvKOVv eyw t ovbev dWo Trore yevi^crofxaL ovt(i)s
alcr6av6]XVos' tov ydp dkXov dkXrj aL(r6r]aLS, Ka\ dXXoXov

Kal dXXov Troiet tov ala6av6]XVov' ovt (Kelvo to ttolovv epte 160
IxTjTTOT dAAu) avve\6ov TavTov yevvrjaav tolovtov yivr]TaL'
drro ydp dAAou dAAo yevvrjaav dkkoXov yevrjaeTaL.
0EAI. "Eo-rt TavTa.
2X2. Ovbe ]xr]v eycaye efxavT<o tolovtos, eKelvd re eauro) 5
roioirror yei^Tjo-erai.
0EAI. Ov ydp ovv.
2X2. 'AvdyKr] bi ye ifxe re tlvos yCyveadaL, oTav ala6av6-

fxevos yCyv(t)fxaL' ala6av6p.evov ydp, fxrfbevbs 8e aiadavdfxevov,
dbvvoTOV yCyvea6aL' Klv6 re rtrt yCyva6aL, oTav ykvKv rf b
C II Stoi'] 8x0 fifv W C 12 Koi] t) W d 7 &Wo Ti] &x\o

Tt ^ W a I &\\ov rhv
. . &\\ov
, W : . . . t6 B : &\\o . . . rov T
a8 T om. B a 9 aladavofifvos yap B'
i6ob nAATilNOS
TnKpov 7/ n TOLovTov yCyvTjTaL' y\vKv ydp, iJ.i]bevl 8e yXvKV
abvvaTOv yfvea-Oat,.
0EAI. TlavTdTTacri ixev ovv.
5 2X2. AciTrcTai brj oi/xai rjfxLV dXAÂois, (It â-fxev, (Tvai,
flTC yiyvofxeOa, yCyveadaL, CTretTrep rjix&v f} avdyKT] ti]v ovcriav

(TvvhiX fxev, (TvvbeL be ovbevl t&v aAAcov ov8' av ijpXv avrots.
dAAÂois bi] XfLTreTttL arvvbeben-OaL. toare eiTe n? elvai tl
dvoixdêL, TLVL elvai rj tlvos tj TTpos tl pr]Teov avT&, eiT
lo yCyveaOaL' avTo be e(pi' avTov tl ?/ 6v ?/ yLyvofxevov ovtc
C avro) XeKTeov ovt akXov KeyovTos aTTobeKTeov, <Ls o Aoyoj
ov bieKr]kvdafxev a-r^fxaivei.
0EAI. TlavTdTTaa-L fxev ovv, S SwKpoTe?.

2i2. OvKovv oTe br] t6 efxe ttolovv efxoi ea^TLV Kal ovk
5 iiAAa), eyoi Kal aia-9dvofxai avTov, aAAos 8' ov;
0EAI. Hias yap ov;
212. ÂXr]di]s dpa efxol tj ^fxi] aladrfa-LS Trjs yap ^fxfjs
ovaîas dei ea-TLV Kal eyoi KpLTr]s KaTo, tov YlpiDTayopav

T&v Te ovTcov efxoL a)s caTi, Kal tG)V fxif ovTOiv ws ovk eaTLV.
lo 0EAI. "EoLKev.
d 212. HSts hv ovv dxffevbrfs ci)V Kal fxrf TTTaiuiv Tr\ bLavoiq
TTepl TCL ovTa Tf yLyvofxeva ovk eiTLOTrffXdiv hv elrfv (HvTTep
ala-dr]Ti]s;
0EAI, Ovbafxijs oTTcas ov.

5 212. YlayKdKMS dpa croi eXprfTai otl eTTLo-Tiffxr} ovk aAAo
Tt eaTLV f] ata^dr]a-LS, koi els TavTov avfnrdTTTOiKev, KaTa fxkv
"Ofxrfpov Kcu 'HpaKAeiTov koX TTav t6 tolovtov <f)vKov oXov

pevfxaTa KLvelaSaL tcl iTdvTa, KaTo. be UpooTayopav t6v
a-0(f)(aTaTov irdvTOdV \prffxdTO)v dvdpo)TTOV fxeTpov elvaL, KaTa
e be &eaiTr]Tov tovto^v ovto)s eyovToov aLa-dr]aLV eTTLa-Ti']fxr]v
yiyvecrdaL. r] ydp, o) Qeairr^Te; (\)G)fxev tovto crov fxev
etvai olov veoyev^s TTaibiov, ^fxov b^ fxaievfxa; ff TraJs \eyeis;
b5 8^] 5^ W b lo yiyvftrBai, {yiyvfireai) Frei C i oCr

. . . i.woSfKTfoy om. pr. B d. i oSy tw T d4 oif] olv B
e a TovTO oSt<d (pSiixfv W
0EAITHTOS i6oe
0EAI. OvTUiS avdyKr}, S) 2coKpares.

2X2. Toiko iiev hri, ws 0(.kv, ixokis Trore kyevvr](Tay.ev, 5
3r4 hr\ irore Tvyyavei ov. ixeTa 8e tov tokov tcl aiJt.(f)Lbp6iJ.ta
avTov 0)? akrjOuis iv kvkAo) 7rpt,dpeKT0v tu> Aoyw, o-KOTrou-

piivovs jotr/ Aa^T/ rjims ovk d^LOV ov Tpo(f)i]s to yLyv6p.Vov,
dAAa dz/e/xiaioy re Kat êvbos. r/ oo; otet TrdvTcos belv t6 ye 161
(Tov Tpi(pLV Kol /x?) dTTOTtdevaL, rj Kal dvi^ri ekeyxpixevov
6pS)V, KOL oii a-(f)6bpa )(aXTravLS idv tls (tov o)? TrpoiTOTOKOV
avTO v(f)aLpfj;
0EO. 'Av^TaL, 0) "EâKpaT^s, QcaCrqTos' ovSaftwy ydp 5

SvcTKoAos. dAAa Trpbs 6(ov ctTre ^ av ov\ ovt(i)S \l;
211. 4>tAoAoyos y' et dTxvS>s Kal xprja-Tds, S) 0eo'8cape,
ori /Lte otet k6y(t)V tlvcl etiât OvkaKov Kat pqbL(i)s eêAwra
epety ws ovk aS e^êi ovro) raura* to 8e yLyv6iXvov ovk b
ei^yoet?, ori ovSets rcoy Aoycoy iêpxeTai 'nap' ifxov dAA' det
Trapa tov ejuot TrpocrbLaXeyop.evov, eyo) 8e o{i8ey TTL(rTa}xaL
irkiov irA7)y l3paxos, ocrov \6yov itap Tpov ao(f)Ov XajBcLV
Kal dTTobiâcrOaL //erptco?. Kat vvv tovto Trapd Tovbe ireLpd- 5
a-ofxaL, ov tl avTos eiTrety.
0EO. Si; KciAAtoi', 2> 2c)Kpare9, Ae'yets* Kat Trotet oiJrcos'.
211. Oto-^' ovv, S) Qedbiope, Oavpidô) tov kTaipov (rov

Ilp(i)Tay6pov;
0EO. To TTOtoi;; C
211. Ta ixV aAAa [xot irdvv ^Seco? eiprjKei', ws to boKovv
eKcio-rcj) roCrro KOi crTLV' ttjv 8' dp)(rjv tov Xdyov Tdavp.aKa,
OTL ovK etTrev dp\6fXvos rrjs 'AATjêtas ort " TldvTcov XP''1~
lxdT(t)V fXTpov ecrrty vs" rj
" KvvoK(f)aXos" 7/ rt dAAo droTTc)- 5
Tepov tG)V x6vt(i)v aXcr6r\crLV, tva /jteyaAo77pe7rd)s Kat 'Trdyu
KaTa(f)pojrr]TiKu>s ijpâTo fjfxtv Kiy^LV, vbLKvvp.V0S utl rjp.'LS
{XV avTov coo-Trep 6ov 6avixdCo[xV eTri (To^pia., 6 8' dpa

Tvyyavv u)V eis (f^povrjaLV ovbev (S^Xtloov âTpdôv yvpCvov, d
e5 îMfyis W a 6 ^ scripsi ^ B ^ : W : elT ovx ora. T
W
:
a8 fj.e] /loi Stallbaum b i o5 ex*] X* 5 ' b6 oih-i T :
Stj B C 5 a.r(nr(t)Ta.Tov W d i fiaTp.xxov secl. Valclcenaer

;
i6id nAATXlNOS
fir} ori 5\Aou tov &v0p(a7r(av. rj ttws XiyoifjLev, S) Qeohcape;
(l yap br] ^KtioTa) aXriOes tcrrai h hv 8i' alcrdricriOiS hoâ(r\,
Kox p.riT To &Xkov t:6.6os oAAo? ^(Ktiov biaKpivd, p.riT Tr]v
5 boâv KvpiutTcpos eorat (TnaKeyj/aa-dai (Tfpos ti]V (Tfpov

6p9r} r) ^(vhr]s, dAA' o TToXkaKis (IprjTai,, avTos to, avTov
(KaoTOs p.6vos boôLO-d., Tavra b( rravTa 6p6a Kal a\r]drj, tL
brj TTOT(, S) (Taip(, YlpoiTayopas p.(v (ro<p6s, (u<tt( kolI aXk(DV

e bibacTKaXos aîova-Oai biKaCôs p.(Ta p.(yaKoov fxicrOiav, rjpds
b( afxad(a-T(poi t koI (\>oiTr]T(ov rfpXv i]V irap^ (K(ivov, ix(Tp(o
ovTi avT(a (Kd(TT(o TTJs avTov (ro(f>Las; raCra iiQs fJir] (f>5)]x(v
br]pLovp.(vov Xiydv tov Y\po)Tay6pav; to b( 8) e/xov t( Koi
5 vqs (jJ.rjs T(yvr]s rqs ]iaL(VTiKr]s (TtyS) ocrov y(K(oTa dÂio-Ka-

vojJL(v, oijLtai be Kal a-vinracra f] tov biaXeycadai TTpaypMTda.
To yap (TnaKOTrdv Kal (iriyjapdv iXiyyjeiv tcls dKKi]\(ov
âvTaaias t( /cat boâs, 6p6ds (KdaTOv ovaas, ov fxaKpa
162 IJ.(V Kal bLooXvyLos (^Xvapia, d dXr]di]s f] 'AATjêta Tlpa)-
Taydpov dAAa ft?j iraiôuo-a (k tov dbvTOv rfjs î^kov
((f>6(yâT0^
0EO. *i2 2a>KpaTes, (f)ikos dinjp, wair^p av vvvbi] (ltt(s.
5 ovK dv ovv b(âi]ir]v bC (]xov dfxokoyovvTOS (kiyyââL

Tlp(OTay6pav, ovb^ av aol irapd bdâv dvTLT(iv(LV, tov ovv
&(aiTr]Tov irdkLV AayS^' TrdiTcos Kai wvbr] fxdJC iixfX(kois aoL
i(f>aiv(TO viTaKov(LV.
b 212. 'Apa Kdv ds AaK(baifxova ^k6(av, coScope, iTpbs
Tas TTakaiaTpas d^tots hv dAAovs 6((a]X(vos yvfxvovs, iviovs
(f>avkovs, avTos fxr] dvT(TTLb(LKvvvaL to (Tbos TTapaiTobvdfx^vos
0EO. 'AAAd rt fxi]V boKds, (LTT(p IX(kk0L(V ]X0L (TTLTp(\f/(LV
5 Kal TTda(a6ai; a>aTT(p vvv oifiai Vjxds iTda^LV lpL( fxkv (dv
6(da6aL fcat fxi] (kK(LV TTpds to yvp.vdaLOV aKkr]pdv ybr] ovTa,
tS) b( bi] v((t)T^p(o T( K(u vypoT(p(o dvTL TTpoaTTdkaiav.
da Xfyofity vulg. d4 Stcucpiyti] Stcutplyji B (ex cmend.) T

d.'] fjL^vosB: fi6vov T d8 ffiffT* B: itfjT B2 f/vriftTvVf 7 ^tj-
Yfipfxj^TW: om. B ai/uîôm.W a 2 /3u/3Aoi B T a^ ai^p
Bekkcr cwiip BT : wvSh tlirts] tlwts vvv W b6 6fii<Ta<r0at T
0EAITHTO2 i62b
212. 'A\A' el ovrm, 2> Qeoboope, crol (\)iKov, ovb^ efxol
kyOpov, (f)a(TLV ol T:apoip.LaQ)p.iVOL. TrakLV hr] ovv kTU tov C

(rofjyov QeairqTOv hiov. Aeye 8?;, S eatrr/re, irpSiTOv
fiV h irvvbri hLriKOofxev, apa ov crv OavfJLa^fLS et iâC^vrjs

oirrcos ava(pavri<Tr} jjLrjbev xeCpcov els (ro(f)Lav otovovv av6p(aTT(i)V
1] Kal 6iG)v; r} rJTTov tl oiet to HpcoTayopeLov fiiTpov cts 5

deovs ri ets av6p(aTT0VS KeyecrâL;
0EAI. Ma At" ovK ^yooy^' koll OTrep ye p(OTas, TtAvv

davpMôi). rjVLKa yap 8t7J/xey ov Tpoirov keyoLev to boKovv
eKaoTO) rovro Kat etiât rai SoKoSyrt, Trdvv p.0L ev ecâtrero d
\4yea6aL' vvv 8e TovvavTLov Td)(a fteraTreVrcoKey.
2f2. Ne'o9 yap et, S) (f^Cke Trar ttjs ovv brjjxrjyopCas oêcos
v~aKoveLS Kal TreCdrf. Trpos yap ravra epet UpcoTayopas ij tls
dkkos VTtep avTov' "'12 yeyiâtot 7rat8e's re Kat y4povTs, 5
br]ij.i]yop(LT crvyKa6^6p.VOL, 6eovs re et? t6 fiiaov dyovTes,

ovs eyco eK re roC Kiy^LV kcu tov ypd(f)LV irepl avTOJV ws e
eto-ti^ 7/ &)s ovK elcTLv, iâLpS), Kal a ol TroAAot dv d-nobi^ôLVTo
aKovovTcS, XeyeTe TavTa, &)s beLvbv et fxrjbev 6toto-et ets ao(f)Cav
eKacTTOs T(av dv^pôTToov l3o(rK-qp.aTOS otovovv dirobeL^LV be

Kal dvj.yKr]v ovb^ rjVTLVOvv Ae'yere dAAa rw etKort \prjcr6e, 5
w et edikoL Qeobcapos t] aAAos rt? t&v yeo^fxeTp&v \p(i)p.VOS
yeco/j.erpetv, aîos ov8' eiôs fxovov dv etr/. o-KOTretre owy (tv
re Kai 0eo'8copo? et dTtobeêcrde TTLâvokoyCci re Kat eiKoo-t

-Trept rrjAtKovrcov keyofxevovs koyovs." 163
0EAI. 'AAA' ov bCKaiov, S) 2coKpares, ovtc av ovt dv
rifxels (f)aXfxev.
212. "AAAt; byf (TKeTneov, u)S iokKiv, q)S o re cros Kat 6

0eo8ci)poi> Ao'yoy. 5
0EAI. ndw fxev ovv dkkr].
C I <ppotniaC6/ji(voi W C2 S:^] o5)/ W C3 W (Ti; dau/ua^(is :
(Tvvdav/jia.^fis BT C4 oSrcijy (âicpvrjs W d om. W^ i /cal

d2 Taxoj Toxi' T d5 uTTf p] rrepi W d 6 &yovT(s T W :
\fyovTfS B e I ToD 7po<J)(v] ypd<peiv W e6 W

êAot
e 7 fos schol. : ovStvhs
oii5' BT e 8 iridavoôyia] irtdavo\oyiais B
a I Tri\tKovTuv] Toirrav B a5 0e6Scepos B A^Jt-os post a 4 ahs T
i63a TIAATflNOS
2f2. Tfjbc br] (TKOTTuiixev (l &pa ((ttIv (itKrTrip.r] re Ka\
ai(r9r](ns Tavrbv tj eTepov. fls yap tovto ttov Tras 6 koyos
ijpXv (TfLVfv, Kal TovTov X&piv To, 'HoXka Koi &TOTra TavTa
lo iKivrj^Tafxev. ov yap;
0EAI. YlavTaitacn p.ev ovv.
b 212. 'H ovv 6p.o\oyr)crop.(v, h. t5 opav ala6av6p.i6a t]
rw aKovLV, TTavTa Tavra afxa kolL ^TTiVrao-âi; olov tG>v

âpj3apcov irplv p.a6(lv Tr]V (fxavr^v TroTepov ov (^r](rop.iv
aKovdV OTav (pdeyycovTat, ^ d/covetj; rc Kal ^TTLaTa^rdai

5 h Xtyova-L; Koi av ypdpLfxaTa fxr] iTna-TafifVOL, ^X.TTOVT(s
ds avTCL TTOTcpov ovx opav rj li:L(rTa(r6aL (LVfp 6p&]x(v
bLLcrxvpiov[X6a;
0EAI. Avro ye, S ^(oKpaTes, tovto avT&v, oiTfp op&fxdv
re Kal aKOvofXfV, (TTLa-Ta(r6aL (f^rfcrofXfv t5>v fxev yap t6
lo (r)(r]]xa kol t6 xpw/xa 6pav re kol (TTL^rTacrdaL, tu)v be rifv
C d^vTr]Ta KOL jSapvTr^Ta aKoveLV t( &fxa Kal flbevaL' h b^ ot rc
ypafxp.aTL(TTa\ TTepl avTu>v Kal oi (pp.r]vrjs bLba(rKova-LV, ovt
aiadavea-âL rw opav r] aKovfLV ovt (TTLaTaa-6aL.

212. 'Apio-rd y, S &aLTr]T, kol ovk 6^l6v aoL iTpos
5 TavTa api(pLafir]TrjaaL, tva Kal avâvrf. dAA' opa 8j) kox
T6b( akko TTpOaLOV, K(IL aK^TTtL TTfj avTo bL(iia6p.6a,
0EAI. T^ TToXov bri;
d 2X2. To TOL^vbc el tls ^poiTO' "Âpa bvvarov otov tls

(TTLarr^podv yivoLTo ttotc, (tl (\ovTa fxvrffxrfv avTov tovtov
KOLL a(a^6fXvov, t6t ot( fxepLvrfTaL fxrf iiTLaTaaâL avro tovto
o fxepvrfTaL; " paKpokoyd be, ws colk(, l3ovk6p.(vos (piadaL

5 (i p.ad(iiv TLS TL p(fxvr]fx(vos fxi] oTb(.
0EAI. Kal TTOiS, o) ^(aKpaT(s; repas yap hv dr] 6 k(y(LS.

212. M?; ovv (yoi Ar/pw; o-xoVei 8e'. Spa to 6pav ovk
aia6dv(a6aL Ae'yets kol Tr]v o^^lv ala6r]aLv;
a 7 T^5 T Wt/ 8i B
: a 8 ^ trtpof'] irSrtpov B roxnS]
rovrSy B a 9 I^Tftvfv] rflvti W
03 irdTtpov] rrp6rtpov T
b 10 Kol] rt Kol T Kal rh XP^M" O""- ^^ *"?] ""'' ^ ^
da tri ix'"^"'] iiftX"'^'* ^ ^^ Kol om.W
0EA1THTO2 i63d
0EAI. "Eycoye.
212. OvKovv 6 ibcav Ti eTTLOTrificov (KeCvov yiyov^v o (Ibev e
Kara tov apTi Xoyov;
0EAI. Nai'.
212. Ti bi; [JLVT^firjv ov Xeyeiy fxivTOi. tl;
0EAI. Nat. 5
212. UoTcpov ovbevbs 17 tivos;
0EAI. TCVOS brjTTOV.
212. OvKovv <5y (fxaOe Kal ojv rjo-OeTo, Toi,ovToiv[ Tivoiv;
0EAI. Ti fxriv;
2i2. *0 8t; eT5e tls, /xefijn/rat ttou ei^tore; 10
0EAI. Me/xJ^rjrai.
212. 'H Kal iJ.v(ras; rj tovto bpd(ras iir^XdOeTo;
0EAI. 'AAAa beivov, w 2<)Kpares, tovto ye (f)dvai.
2i2. Aet ye fteVrot, et o-wo-o/jtei' roy TrpocrO^ Xoyov et 164
8e /x^, oixerat.
0EAI. Kat eyco, y^ roy Ata, vTroTrrevco, ov p.r]V iKavG>s
ye oTwow* dAA' etTre tttJ.
2X2. TTjSe* 6 fi\v op&v kiri.crvqp.cav, <l>ap.iv, tovtov yiyovev 5

ovTrep 6pS>v' 6\f/ts ydp Kal atcrdricn,s Kal eiTL(TTrifjLr] TavTov
b)p.o\6yr]Tai.
0EAI. Udw ye.

212. 'O be. ye bpSiV fcat eTTKTTrifKov yeyovoos ov (opa, edv
p.V(Tr\, fj.p.vrjTai, p.iv, ov\ opa 8e avTo. ^ ydp; 10
0EAI. Nat'.
2/12. 1 o oe ye ov)( opa ovk eTrtcrarat tcmv, enrfp D

Kai To " opa " " eTTto-rarai."
0EAI. 'AAtj^^.
212. ^vfJLJSaLveL dpa, ov tls TTL(rTriiJ.ct)v eyiveTO, ctl fiefxvrf-
fievov avTov p.i) enLCTTacrOaL, eiTeLbrf ov\ opd' o Tepas ((pafiev 5

dv eti/at et yiyvoLTO.
a I <Tti(Toij.fv Dissen : erdxToifjifv BT b 1-2 fcmv . . . (TrlffraTat

om. pr. B b5 auTbi/ yui) T W : aiirb' ^ ut videtur pr. B : ainh
fiil Hirschig ta/ ftpafxfv W
i64b nAATiiNOS
0EAI. 'AA.)j êo-rara Xeyeis.
212. T(av d.bvvdT(tiV hrj tl (rvfMl3aCvi.v (f>aCvcTaL (av tis
(TTKTTri^rjv Kal at(T6r]aLV tovtov (j)fi
elvaL.
lo 0EAI. 'EoLKev.
212. "AXXo apa kKaxipov âTiov.
0EAI. KLvhvVVL.
C 2f2. Tt ovv biJT hv etTj kTrL(TTriyLr\; iTakLV k^ ^pxTJi, ws
(OLKev, KeKTfov. KaCTOL TL TTOTe fx4KX.ofXv, S) eaiTTjre, bpav;
0EAI. TCvos Trepi;
2X2. âLvofjLeOd /xoi dkeKTpvovos dyevvovs bCKrjv irplv
5 vevLKrjKevaL dTT07tr]bi](ravTS d-no tov \6yov ab^LV.

0EAI. nw? br];
2X2. 'AyTiAoyiKO)? ioCKapLev Trpoy tols tHv 6vop.dT(ov

opLoXoyCas dvofj.oKoyr](TdixVOL Kal TOLOVT(a tlvI 7TpLy(v6fj.fV0L
Tov koyov dyaTtdv, koll ov (f)d(rKOVTS dy(jiiVL(rTal d\ka <îAo'-
d (To(\)OL iXvaL kavddvofxiv TavTO. iKiCvoLs TOLS beLvols dvbpd(TLV
TTOLOVVTfS.
0EAI. OvTT(t> fxavddvoo ottco? Ae'yfis.
2X2. 'AAA' eyo) TTfipd^TOfxaL br]kcia-aL Trepi airrciv 6 ye

5 br] voS). r]p6fx(6a ydp br] el fxad(ov Kal fxefxvrffxevos tCs tl
fxr] kiTCcTTaTaL, kou tov lb6vTa Ka\ p.v(TavTa fxffxirqfxevov
op&VTa be ov dTTobeCâvTes, ovk etSoVa diTfbeCâfxev Kal
dfxa fxffxvrffxivov tovto 8' eiyat dbiivaTov. Kal ovto) br]
fxvdos diT(i!)keTO 6 Ilp(i)Tay6pLos, Kal 6 aos dfxa 6 tt/j
lo 7TL(TT-qfxr]s Kal aic^T/cecos oti Taurov eoTii;.

e 0EAI. 4>aiVeTai.
2X2. Oii Tt dv, OLfxai, S) <f>Ck, LTTp ye 6 TTarqp tov (ri^
pov fxv6ov eCn, dkkd iTokkd dv yfxvvc vvv 8e 6p(f>av6v avrbv
fifxeLS TTpoTTrfkaKCôfxev. Kal ydp ovb^ oi (ttCtpottol, ois Ylpa)-
5 Taydpas KaTekLiTev, l3or]6eZv f6ekov(TLV, S)V Qe6b(i}pos els o8e.
oAAa br] avTol KLvbvvV(rofxev tov bLKaCov evfK avTia jBorjdeLV.
O r iiri(rTrini) fx^ B (scd fxij punctis notatum) d4 iri\u(rai

T W : an-Aw<rai B 63 toAA^ om. T es th om. T
0EAITHTOS i64e
0EO. 0 yap eyw, a> SwKpares, aWa iJLaXXov KaXXCas

6 '^lTTTTOViKOV TO)V kKtlVOV eTTLTpOTTOS' ^/XetS 8e TTCO? daTTOV 165
ex t6)v \lnXa>v Xoyoiv Trpoy rTJy yeu>}x^Tpiav aTTevV(raiJ.V.
X^P'-^ yf P-^VTOL (To\ ^0p,V (CLV aVT(0 ÔTJ^tJ?.

212. KaAws Aeyets, a> Qeobcope. crKe\j/aL ovv ttjv y
kp^]V ô/]0Lav. tS>v yap apTL bsLvoTepa av rts 6fxoX.oyi]- 5
(Teiey /ut) Trpocreyj^v rots prip,acrL tov vovv, ij t6 7to\.v
WLcrij.e6a cfxxvaL re Kat aiiapviicrOaL. cro\ Aeyco ott?/, ^

0eatr?;r<o.
0EO. Et? t6 kolvov pikv ovv, aTTOKpivicrOoi 8e 6 i/ewrepos*

(rcf)aX\s yap rJTTov acr)(r]povrjcreL. b
S12. Aeyo) 8?/ ro SetroVaror ip(aTr]p.a, (.(ttl 8e ot/xat
rotw8e rt* "'A/sa oto'i' re t6v avTov ei8o'ra rt roCro 6 otêy

fxi] etoeyat;
0EO. Tt 8j/ ovv aTTOKpLVOvpLcOa, o 0eatrrjre; 5
0EAI. 'A8vmroy 770U, otjuat eycoye.
2X2. OvK, ei ro opay ye iTTio-Ta^rdaL ^Tycrets. rt yap

XPV^Jl acf)VKT(o po)Tr]]xaTL, to Keyopevov kv (ppean crvcrxp-
fxevos, oTav ipâTa avKTT\r]KTos avr]p, KaraA.a/3a)y rf) X^V^
o-ou roy erepov 6(l)0aKp.6v, ei opay ro i/xdrtoi^ r<S KaTeLkrjp.- c
/ie'y<);
0EAI. Ov (f)r]cro) otfxai tovt(o ye, rai pivTOL kripo).

2X2. Oi/fcoCy opa? re Kat 011^ opas apta tovtov;
0EAI. Oilro) ye ttcos. 5
212. Ou8ey eyco, ^7/o-et, tovto ovt T(xtto) ovt rip6pLr]v
t6 6iro)s, dAA et o eTricrTacraL, tovto Ka\ ovk iiTLcrTa^raL.
vvv 8e 6 ovx opas 6p5)V cfâivr]. o)poXoyi]Kd)s 8e Tvyxaveis

t6 opav eTTtcrracrâi Kat t6 pi] opav /jt?/ imcrTacrOaL. i^
ovv TovTO)V koyiôv rt oôt (rvp.i3aivL. 10
0EAI. AAAa XoyiCppaL otl Tavavria ots vTTeOipLrfv. d
b7
a3 aol
7 om. W
om. B a6 wpo^rcrxoov al.
W b
b 2 SduoTtpot/ W
6ri(rets] <t>ria-eis 8 (n/frxoufiôj B" T
<Tvvex6n.(vos
c8 & om. W
B 03 fifVTOi'] /xevTot y W C 7 et & T W : efr' B
:
PLATO, VOL. I. 19
i65d nAATONOS
212. "lo-co? 8e y', u) davfi6.(riy TrXeto) h.v Toiavr leiraOes
et TLS are iTpoa-rjputTa el iTL(TTa(r9ai eori jxev o^v, ((ttl be
a/ix/3Av, Kal eyyvdev fxkv i-niaTacrdaL, TToppwOev bt /x?), koI

5 (r(f)6bpa KOL -qpijxa to avTO, Kal a.Wa [xvpLa, h (Wo)(â>v av
TreXracrriKos avrjp p.L(r6o(l)6pos iv koyoLi (p6ixV09, t}vCk
TTL(rTr]p.riv Kal ataO-q^riv TavTov iOov, i[x(3aX.(ov hv ds to

aKoveLV Kal 6(r(f)paLVa-9aL Kal tcls TOLavTas alcr^ri^rwi, y]X.iyyiV
e av eTrexcoy koll ovk avLeli iTplv 9avpAaas rqv iTokvApaTov
(ro(f)Lav (rvvTTobL(r9r}9 vtt' avTOv, ov bri o-e \Lp(i)(rdfXv6s re
Koi (Tvvbri^rai rjbr] av t6t eKvTpov yj)r]pAT(t)V oa-(ov a-oC re
KaKeCvio ib6KL. TLV ovv bi] 6 Ylp(Tay6pas, (fâCr^s hv tacos,
5 Ao'yoi^ eirCKovpov toIs avTOv epet; aAAo ri TTLp(i)[X9a kiyiLv;
0EAI. Wavv ]x\v ovv.

SO. TaSra rc 6j; Travra oa-a rjfxeli ^Tra/xwoyres avr^
l66 keyofxev, Kal 6fx6(re oXjxaL x.(t)pr]a-eTaL KaTa(f)pov(ov r]]xG)V koX
kiy(i)V' " OSros br] 6 Sco/cparTjs 6 xprjaros, ^TTCid^ avrai
iraLbCov TL ep(j)Tr]9ev ebeLaev el ol6v re tov avTov to avTO

]xe]xvr]cr9aL a]xa kcu ]xr] elbevaL^ kcil beZcrav dTTe(\)r](Tev 8ta to
5 ]xr] bvvacr9aL TTpoopdv, yekcoTa br] tov e]xe ev rots k6yOLS

diTebeLêv. to be, S) pq.9v]x6TaTe ^(oKpaTes, rrjS' eêf OTav
TL tG)V efxQv bC ip(i>Tqa-e(i)s crKOTrfjs, eav fiev 6 epu)Tr]9eLS
oXdiTep dv eyoi) diTOKpLvaCjxr^v diTOKpLvd^xevos a-(f)dkkr]TaL, eyu)
b ekeyxofxaL, el be dkkoLa, airrbs 6 p(t)Tr]9eCs. avrCKa yap

boKels TLvd aoL crvyxoyp^qa-eaâL ]xv^jxr]v iTapelvaC rco (av
TTa9e, tolovt6v tl ova-av irciôy otor OTe eTTaa-\e, fxrfKeTL
TTdcrxovTL; iTokkov ye bel. r] av dTTOKvr]creLv ofxokoyelv oldv
5 r' etyat eZ8e'rai Kal fxr] elbevaL tov avTov t6 avT6; 7/ edvTTep
TOVTO beCa-r], bâaeLV Trore tov ovtov elvai tov dvofLOLovfxevov
tQ) TTplv dvofxoLOvcr9aL ovtl; fxdkXov be tov elvaC TLva

dA.A' ovî Tovs, Kol TovTovs yLyvofxevovs diTeCpovs, edviTep
d2 8 y, S]^ iyioB d3 5i] Si col W d5 iv\oxS>v BT

h.v] 6.V Tis W e 3 T*] 7 B 6 7 3o-o] 8<ro 7' W a8 ftv
om. T iTroKpiv6fi(vos T cr<pa.\r]Tai W b^ 0^01' Srf T: olov rt

B : oUv r St" W b5 j5Voi post flvai om. T b 8 koI om. T
0EAITHTO2 i66c
avofioCoicris yiyvrjTai, cl bi] ovofJidTcov ye 8e?Jcret ^rjpevcrei? c

SievXajSetcrâi aWi]Xoiiv; dAA',- S) ixaKdpi," (f)i]crL,
" yevvato-
Tp(os eTr' avTo (XOuiv b Xeyco, ei bvvacrat., ^4keyôv ws ov)(l
tStai ala-Orja-eis eKaoro) 7]p(av yCyvovTai, 77 o)? tSwoy yiyvo-

jxivoov ovbev rt av jmlXXov to (paLVOfxevov p6v(o KiV(a 5
yCyvoLTQ, 7] et etzât 8et ozô/zaêty, ei// coTrep (f)aCveTaL' vs Se

87) Kat KvvoK(f)d\ovs key(t)V ov [Jiovov avTOS irqveXs, dXka Kal
Tovs aKovovTas tovto bpdv ety tcl crvyypdjipiaTd p.ov dva-
TTfCdeLS, ov KoXSis TTOL&v. kyoi) ydp (f)r]pL [xev tyjv dXijOeLav d
exeii' 0)? ylypa(pa' pLeTpov yap (Kaa-Tov r^pGtv etyat t(j)v re
6vT(j)V Kal ]xr], ]xvpCov p.evTOL bLa(p4peLV (Tepov kTepov avTio
TOvTco, OTL rw jxkv dXXa ecrTL re Kat (f>aCvTaL, rw 8e aAAa.
Kat ao(f)Cav koX aô^f^bv dvbpa ttoXXov 8e'a) to jxi] (f)dvaL etrat, 5
oAA' avTov TOVTOV Kal Xeyco aro(f)6v, os dv tlvl r]]xoiV,
(1) cf)aCvTaL Kal eaTL Ka/ca, [XTa^dXXo)V TXOLr^crr] dyaOa (paC-
Vcr6aC re Kal elvdL. tov 8e Ao'yoi^ av ]xr] rw pr]]xaTC fxov
bCo)K, dAA' c58e ert cracpia-Tepov jxd6e tC Aeyco. otoi' ydp ev e

rots TTp6cr6ev eAeyero dva]xvi]a-6r]TL, otl T(o piev dcr6evovvTL
TTLKpd cf)aCveTaL a eadCeL Kal eaTL, rw be vyLaCvovTL TavavTCa
ecm Kal (fâCveTOL. crocf)(oTpov pev ovv tovt(ov ovbeTepov bel
TTOLrjcraL ovbe ydp bvvaTdv ovbe KaTr^yoprjTeov b)S 6 fxev 167
Ka]xvo)v dpa6i]s oTb ToiavTa bo^dêL, 6 be vymCvoiv crocpos
OTL dAAota, ]xeTal3Xr]Teov 8' eTTt 6dTepa' dfxeCvoiV yap r] eTepa
e^LS. ovTO) be Kal ev Trj TfatSeta aTro ere'pas eêcos eTTt Tr]V
d]xeCvo) ]xeTa^Xr]Tov dXX' 6 [xev laTpbs ipappdKOLS ]XTa- 5
âXXeL, be a-ocf)La-Ti]S XdyoLS. etTel ov tC ye xfrevbf] bo^dôvTd
tCs TLva va-Tepov dXr]67] etToCrâe bo^dêLV ovTe ydp ra fxi]
ojrra bvvaTbv bo^daaL, ovt dXXa Trap' a dv TTda-)(r], Tavra

be del dXr]6rj. dXX' oXpaL iTOvr^pds ^vxrjs eêt do^ciôi^ra b
e I avo/jLoiooa-isl avoîoiais B 04 tKacncf T C6
oirep W : marg. b
ft in C
T\fxS>v
7 outJ) (Tvovih T Photius c8

ftrep]
e/s]
irphs
d6
Cobet e Photio
isT d7
d2 yeypa<pa] typa^pa
W
W d. 5 ri>] t^ T
fcs] om. 62 rrp6(r0ev'] fnirpoaeev T
a6
bI
oS] oirre T
(f
a 8 irop' & iiv W
vapa hv B : irapa h.v : T
TovTjpSj] TTotrup^ Aldina 5o|aô;/ro] So^d(ovTas B
19*
i67b nAATi2N02
(Tvyyevrj kavTiji XP^"''^ (TroC-qare bo^da-ai, (Tfpa roiavTa, h 877
TLves To. (f)avTd(rfj.aTa vtto dimpias dXrjOT] KaXovcnv, eya)

6e ^cArico piev to. CTfpa t5)v (Tepoiv, dXr^decTTfpa be ovhiv,
5 KOi rovs (ro(f)Ov^, S) (j)Lke ^(aKpaTes, ttoKX.ov b((o jSaTpdxovs
kiyiLV, dXXa KaTa p.v (r(i)p.aTa laTpovs Aeyo), KaTO. be (f)rjTa
y(t)pyovs. (f^TjpX yap Kal tovtovs tols (})Vtols dvrl Trovr^pQv

C al(rdrj(T(jiv, OTav ri avT(av dcrdev?], xpr](TTas Kal vyLeivds
al(r6r](T(is t /cot dXrÔds kp.i:oLiLV, tovs be ye (Tocjôvs re Koi
dyaOovs prjTopas tols itoke^TL to. xprâ-Ta dvTl to)v TTOvr^p&v
diKOta boKLV eTvaL Troieiv. cirei old y dv kKd(TTr\ TTokeL bUaLa
5 Kal KoAo boKrj, roSra koi eivot avTij, (t)s hv avTO. vopLL^ri' oAA'
6 (TO(})bs dvTl TTOVrjp&V OVTOOV aVTOLS (Kd(TT(OV XP^JCTâ (TTOLTJ^TeV
(LvaL Kal boKe^LV. KaTo. b^ tov avTov koyov koll 6 (TO(j)L(TTr]S
Tovs TTaLbevofxevovs ovrco bvvdpievos iTaLbayooyeLV (T0(f)6s t

d Kal d^Los TTokk(av xprjixdTOiV tols TTaLbevOd^TLV. Kal ovtu)
(TO(f)(OTpoL T ttcTtv (TepoL (Tepojv Kot ovbels \f/vbrj bo^d^L,
Koi croi, edvT ôvkrj idvTC fjLrj, dvcKTeov ovtl fxeTpio' o-w^frai
ydp iv TOVTOLS 6 koyos ovtos. w (tv el pL(v exfLS e^ dpxrj^
5 dp.(f>L(TJ3r}TLV, dfX(f)Lcrl3i]TL k6y(o dvTLbL^(k9(ov' el bi bi
po)Trf(T0)v ôvkeL, 8t' epu)Trf(TeoiV' ovb^ ydp tovto (f)evKTeov,

dkkd TTavTo^v iJ.dkL(rTa bLooKTeov tS> vovv ^xovtl. Trotft
e fxevTOL ovTO)(TL' p.r] dbLKeL ev rai epo)Tdv. Ka\ ydp 770AA7)

oAoyta dpeTrjs (f)d(TKOVTa eTTLp.ekeL(T6aL firfbev oAA' j/ dSiKoGyra
ev koyoLS bLaTekelv. dbLKelv 8' ecTTlv ev t(o roiot/ro), oTav
TLS fxjf x^P'-'^ Mf^ ^^ dyo)VL0p.evos Tas 8tarpt/3as Trotjjrat,
5 xj^pls be bLakey6fj.evos, Kal ev piev tS> Trai^?/ re Kot (T(f)dkXri

Kad^ 6(Tov dv bvvrfTaL, ev be rw SiaAeyto-ât o"7rov8d^7; re koi
iTTavopdoL Tov TTpoabLakey6pLevov, eKeZva fi6va avT(o ivbeLKVV-
168 p-(vos rd (T(f)dkp.aTa, b. avTos V(f)' eavTov Kot twv TTpoTepoi)V
(tvvov(tlS)V TTapeKeKpovaTo. dv fiev ydp ovto) iroLfls, eavTovs
b2 iavrrii'] out^j al. xpvcr^ W b6 ipvrii] rck ûrck W

C2 dAi7fle7s] a\rid(ias Schleiermaclier C4 tlvai secl. Schanz
oTa y'] Htt' Cobet C 7 Kal post thcu om. W d4 ^y tovtois
post oZros W e4 ois om. W
0EAITHTO2 i68 a
alTLdcrovTaL ol TTpoa-hiaTpiôvTis croi TfJ9 avTwv Tapaxrjs Kal

aiTopCas a\k' ov (re, Kal cre p.ev bicaôvTat Kal 0tA?j(roi;o"iy,
avTovs be fj.ta"q(T0va-i. Kal (f>evôvTai. a(j)' kavT&v ets (piXo-- 5
aoîav, tv aAXot yv6p.V0L airdKkaySxTL tS>v 0% TtpoTepov
7]a-av' eav b^ TavavTia TovT(av bpqs &a-7rep ol TroAAot,
TavavTLa av}x^r](TeTaL aoL Ka\ tovs (rvvovTas avTl (pLXoa6(f)(ov
p.taovvTas TOVTO t6 7rpayp.a aTTOcfâveXs iiTfLbav irpealSvTepoL b

yevcovTaL. iav ovv ep,oL iret^rj, 6 Kal irpoTepov ippTÔr], ov
bva-pivu>s ovbe fiaxTjrtKws dAA' lAew tt] Starota o-vyKaêis
u)s oAtj^w? aKe\f/r] tl TTOTe kiyop.ev, KLvelaOaL re aTTOcfyaLvo-
fievoL TCL irdvTa, t6 re boKovv (Kda-Tid tovto Kal eivaL tSiwrrj 5
re Kal WAei. Kat ex TovT(t)v TTLaKe\f/r] etre tovtov etre Kat
aAAo kiTLaTr]fxr] Ka\ ata6r](TLS, dkk' ov)(^ &cnTep upTL eK a-vvt]-
Oeias pr]iidT(av re Kai ovofxdTcov, a ot woAAot ottt/ av TV\o)aLV c

ekKovTes aTTopCas dkkrjkoLs TravTobaTTas TTape\ovaL." TaiTa,
u) &e6b(X)pe, tS> eTaCpô aov els ôr^deLav TTpoar]p^d]jLr]v Kar^
e]ir]v bvvapLLV a-pLLKpa diro afiLKpSiV' el 6' avTos e^r], jxeya-
keL^Tepov h.v tols avTov eôr]6r]aev. 5
0EO. riaiêt?, oj ^wKpares' Trdvv ydp veavLKMS rw dvbp\
êôr]6r]Kas.
2X2. Ei! Ae'yet?, S) eTalpe. KaC ]xol etTre'* evev6r]ads ttov
keyovTos dpTL tov YlpoiTayopov koX oveLbCCovTOS r]]uv otl
TTpos TTaLbCov Tovs Aoyovj TTOLOvfxevoi T(a tov TTatbbs <f)6l3(p d
dy(i)VLôC]xe6a els tcl eavTov, Ka\ yapLevTLafx^v Ttva diTO-
Kaku>v, d7T0(rejxvvv(i>v be t6 TrdvTcov fxeTpov, aTTOvbdaaL r]ixds
bLeKekevaaTO irept tov avTOv kdyov;
0EO. UQs ydp ovK evev6r]aa, a ôoKpaTes; 5
212. Tt ovv; KekeveLs 7TeCdea6aL avT^;
0EO. 2<ô8pa ye.
2Ji2. Opay ovv otl Tdbe TrdvTa irkrfv (rov TTatbCa eaTCv.
ct ovv TTeLao^xeâ T(a dvbpC, ifxe Ka\ ae 8et epooTwvTds re Kai
&5 avTovs Sf m(T7i<Tov(ri om. pr. B b 6 Toirroij'] tcDv T C3irpo(7-

7]p^d/xriv] 7rpo(T7]pKi(Td.ix7]v Schneider : irpocr7]pKe(Ta fj.ev Coraes C5 ifioT]-
6ri<Tav B d 1 post iroiovij.evoi add. 0 B d2 uyoovtô/xeOa B
;
i68e TlAATi2N02
e aTtoKpivoixivovs dAAÂoi? (n:ovh6i<rai avrov iiepL rhv Xoyov,
Xva fxri TovTo ye Ix?? fyKoXelv, coj TraiôvTcs irpbs iJLip6,Kia
Steo-fctx/â/jte^' avTov tov k6yov.
0EO. Ti 8' ; ov TTokKdv rot 0eairjjros pieydXovs TrdJycovas
5 (\6vT(ov aixeivov &v iiraKoXovdria-eK Aoyo) Siepewco/ieVa)
212. 'AAA' ov ri a-ov ye, oj 0eo'8aj/3e, apLdvov. /x?/ ovi/
otou e/xe /x^v r<j) o-ai eTaCpia rereAeuTT/KC)ri SetJ/ Travrt Tp6iT(a
169 (jrap.vvew, ae 8e /D/Sev^. dAA' iî, o) apto-re, oAtyov eiriaTtov,

p-ixpi TOVTov avTOv ecos Sy etSw/xev eire a/>a o-e 8et biaypap,-
pATOiV irept n^Tpov etrat, etre -Trcivrey 6p.oiois (toX iKavoX
kavTols et9 re aarpovoiiiav kox roAAa wr 8// o-w irepi atrtai;
5 cxets bi.a(ppi.v.
0EO. Ov pahiov, oi 2(^Kpares, oôt irapaKadripevov /x?/
^tôyat Aoyor, dAA' eyu) d/)rt TTapXripr}a-a (f)aa-Ku)V cre eTTi-
Tpexf/eiv ixoi pi] aTTobveaOat, Kal ov)(l avayKdaav KaOdirep

AaKebaip.6v(,or av 8e' /xot 8oKets Trpbs tov ^Kipôva ixaXXov
b TeiveLV. AaKebaip.6vLoi, ixev yap arrUvai 7/ d7ro8ve(rât
KeAei/oixrt, av 8e Kar 'Ayratoy rt /xot /xdAAor 8oKets rd

bpap.a bpav tov yap T:poatX66vTa ovk avir]s Trplv (avy
avayKaarjs aTTobvaas iv tois X6yois npoaiTaXaiaai.
5 2X2. ' ApiaTa ye, w @e6b(npe, Tr]v v6aov /xou dTTJjKao-as'
la~)(yptK(aTpos /xeWoi ^yd) iKiivoiV. ixvpioi yap i)bri /xoi
'H/)aKAe'es re Kat 07/o-e'es errDxdi^Te? KapTepol Trpbs to Ae'yeiy
/xdA' eS avyKK6(f>aaiv, dAA' eyo) ovb4v rt paXXov a(f)iaTap.ai.'
C ovrco ris Ipcos 8etrd9 ^r8e'8uKe tt)? Trepl raiJra yvp-vaaias.
1X1] ovv p.r]b\ av (f)doviiar]s TrpoaavaTpt\f/6ixvos aavT6v re

d/xa Kat e/xe cJfTô-at.
0EO. Ov8ev Iri drrtAe'ya), dAA' dye otttj 'ê'Aeis* jrdrrcos
5 Tr]V Tre/Jt raCra lp.apixvriv rjv {dr) o-y ^TrtKAcio-T/s êi dfa-
e 2 toCtJ yt W to tovt6 yt B toi t<{ 7 T 63 outoC] aJ toD

Tbf B: T
a? toCtov
:
a4
:
rt'] 7 T a8 oirx] ouAt W

ba /xaWov om. W bs &i' add. Heindorf b^ ivrvyx^-
yovTfi B KpaTfpol TW C4 iA\' i^t T: iAAi Atyt B C5 i
add. w
EAITIIT02 i69C
TXrjvai eXeyxo/xeroy. ov jxivTOL -Trepairepo) ye &v TTpoTiOeaai
olos T ^(TO\iai Trapao-^êiy eixavTov aot.
212. 'AAA' dpKet Kal fie'xpi TOVTOiV. Kai /xoi TTaw rj/pet
To TOLovhe, \xr] ttov TraLhiKov tl kdOcoixev elbos tG>v Xoycov
noLovy.VOL, Kai rt? TrdkLV iîxlv avTo oveibLcry]. d

0EO. 'AAAa 87) TTeipdcroiJLaC ye Ka6^ oaov dv bvv(i)[j.ai.
212. ToSe TOLVvv Trp&Tov TrdXiv dvTLkajSaifxeOa ovTTep to
TTpoTepov, Kal tb(x)p.ev 6p6u)S 7/ ovk op6(as ehv(TyepaLVop.ev
eiTLTHxSiVTes rw Ao'y(o ori avTapKrj eKacrTOV eis (f^povqcnv 5
eotei, KOt rjjXLV cn)ve)(bipricrev 6 UpcoTayopas iTepi re tov

dp.eivovos koX yeipovos hLacpepeLV TLvds, ovs hr] koX eivai
(ro(f)ovs, ov)(î;
0EO. Nat.
2X2. Et piev Toiwv avTos TTapoov w/jtoAoyet dAAa jui?; 7/jLiets 10
l3or]dovvTes irrrep avTOv (Tvve\(opri(rapiev, ovbev dv iTakLV eheL e

eiTavakaôvTas jSeâiovcrOaL' vvv be Td\ dv tls rnxds aKvpovs
TLdeir] Trjs v~ep eKeivov Ofxokoyias. 8to KaAAto'fcos exet
(racf)ea-Tepov TTepl tovtov ovtov bLO[xokoyr](Ta(r6aL' ov yap tl
cr]XLKpbv TTapakkaTTeL ovtcos e\ov 7/ dkkois. 5
0EO. Ae'yets dXr]6r\.
212. Mt/ Toiwv bC dkKoiV dAA' ex rou eKeivov koyov o>s
8ta (3pa)(yTdT(av kdô)]xev tt]v 6]xokoyiav. 170

0EO. nw?;
2X2. Ovrojcrt* ro hoKovv eKda-T(o tovto Ka\ eHvai c})r]ai
TTOV o) boKei;
0EO. *r/o-t yap ovv. 5
2X2. OvKovv, o) YlpcoTayopa, Kal 7;/xets dvdp(0TT0v, pidkkov
he TTdvTOi)v dvdpcoTTcov hoâs keyofxev, Kal cpapiev ovheva

ovTLva ov Ta p.ev avTov rjyela6aL tcov dkkojv ao(P(OTepov, to.
he dkkovs eavTov, Kal ev ye rots peyiaTOLS KLvhvvoLS, oto.v

ev aTpaTeiaLS 77 ro'o-ot? 7/ ev 6aXdTTr] )(eLp.dQiovTaL, (oaiTep 10
C 8 vav v-irripeiTO B d 2 5^] Zii T d 4 tihwu.(v B 64 ov-

rov] aZ Schanz 67 i.Waiv, &\\ov W a8 ov] oiv T: ov. ovW
a 10 voaois] iv v6(rois W
Si<rv(p] iis T
i7oa nAATflNOS
77/305 Oeovs fxfiy Tovs iv eKaoToij apyovras, (Tu>Trjpa9 a<^5iv
b TTpocrboKcivTas, oiiK &}J\.<a T<a bi.a(f)(povTas rj Tut elbevai' Koi

TravTa ttov fxeoTa TavdpwTTiva ^rjTovvTOiv bibaaK^Xovs re koX
&p)(pvTas (avTuiv re Kal tu>v 6.\.\o}v C^cov rcoy re ipyaa-to^v,
olojxivMV T av iKavav fikv bLbda-Kfiv, iKav&v be ap\(i,v
5 (Tvai.. Kal iv tovtols aTTacri t( aWo (f)i](rop.V rj avTovs tovs
avOpdiTovs rjydcrdai. a-o(})Cav koI dp.adiav ilvai irapa a-(f)icnv;
0EO. Ovbev &\ko.

2X2. OvKovv Ti]v ixfv a-o(f)Cav dXrjdrj biAvoiav rjyovirrai,
TTjv be dfxaOiav "^(vbfj boâv;
C 0EO. T[ ixriv;
212. Tt ovv, 0) YlpoiTayopa, xprjcrofxeda rw X6y<a; ttotc-
pov dkrjdfj (f)&ix(v del tovs dvOpdiTovs bo^dî.v, i] TOTe [Xfv

d\r]dfj, TOT^ 8e yfrevbf]; i^ d]x(f)0T4p(i)v ydp ttov avfxl3aivi fxri
5 det d\r]df] dAA' dfX(f)6Tpa avTOvs bo^d^(i.v. CKoVei ydp, a>
&e6bu>pe, el i6e\oL av rts t&v dp.(f)l Tlpu)Tay6pav t] (tv
avTos biafxd)(iCTdat &>? ovbets rjyelTOti ^repos Tpov dfxadfj

re etrai Kat \fr(vbf] 8o^dêty.
0EO. 'AAA' diTta-Tov, S Swxparey.
d 212. Kat firjv (Is tovt6 ye dvdyKrjs 6 \6yos J/Ket 6
TTavTOiv \pr]fidTO)V fxirpov dvdputTTOV \iyu)V.
0EO. Uu>s by;
211. "Oray av Kplvas ri irapa (ravro) 7rpo'j fie dTTO(f)aCvr]
5 TTepC Ttvos bdâv, a-ol fXv br] tovto Kard roi' (KfCvov \6yov
dArjês eo-ro), fjfxîv be br] rois aAAots Trepi Tf]s a~f]S KpC(r(ois
TT^Tepov ovK (o-Ttv KptTats yevea-Qat, i] det cre KpCvoficv
dXrfdf] bo^dCdv; i] fxvpCot (Kaa-TOTi croi fidxovTat dvTtbo^d-

CoifTS, ffyovfxevot \frvbf] KpCvftv re fcai oteo-âi;
e 0EO. Nt) tov Aia, o) ^(oKpaTes, fx(i\a fxvpCot bf]Ta,
(f)r]crlv "Ofxrfpos, ot y4 fxot rd ef dvdpcairoiv TrpdyfutTa

TTap)(pV(TtV.
C2 2) npajrayipa B' T : t$ TlpayraySpaB C 3, 4 r^Tt . . . rSrt

W : TTori . . irori BT C5arom. W cSTtom. W
d7 alfl ffiB: ai iel T
0EAITHTO2 lyoe
211. Ti ovv; ôvXei Aeyco/xei; o)S crv totc (ravTU) /xer

akrjdrj bo^dCets, Tols 8e fxvpiOLS -^(vbri; 5
0EO. "EoiKfv K ye tov \6yov dvdyKr\ etvai.

2X2. Ti 8e atTO) ITpcorayopa; ap' oii)(i dyayKr;, et /xer
/UTj8e avros wero [xeTpov etmt dvOpoiTrov fxrjbe oi ttoAAoi,
axnrep ov8e otoiTai, pLrjbevl br] elvai TavTTfV ri]v dXrÔdav
rjv eKelvos eypa^êv; et 8e avTos p.\v oiTo, t6 8e T:\rjdos p.r] VJi

(TvvoUTai, otcrO' otl Trp&Tov fxev oo-o) -TrAetous ots fxr] So/cei rf
ols boK(i, TOcrovT(^ fxdWov ovK ((TTLV r] eaTLV.

0EO. 'Aydy/crj, etTrep ye Kad' kKd(rTr]v boâv ecrrat xat
OVK (rrai. 5
2X2. "ETretrd ye roirr' eêt KOfiôTaTov CKetvos fjikv irepl
Trjs avTov otT/o-ecos Tr]V tGiv dvTLboâôvTOiV oXr\(rLV, f] exet-
vov rfyovvTaL ylrevbea-daL, ony^copet ttov dkrjdr] etiât ofioXoyStv

rd wra 8o^dêtz; aTravTas.
0EO. Yldvv fiev ovv. lo
212. OvKovv TTfv avTov hv -êvbr] (rvyxcopot, et Tr]v t&v b
rjyovfXV(t)v avTov xj/evbea-OaL ofJLoXoyel dXrfdrj etmt;
0EO. 'AvdyKrf.
212. Ot 8e' y' dAAot o{i oT^yxto/sowty eaurots yj/fvbc^rOaL;
0EO. Ov ydp ovv. 5
212. O b4 y au d/xoAoyet Kat TavTrfv dXrjOfj Tr]v boâv

e coy yypa(f)v.
0EO. atWat.
212. 'E^ aTrdrrcoi^ dpa aTrb YlpcDTayopov dpâfxevodv
dfJL(f)i(r^r]Tr](rTaL, /xaAAoy 8e vtto ye eKeCvov ofxoXoyqa-eTaL, lo
dray rw TdvavTia XeyovTL a~vy)(U)pr] dXr^dfj avTov bo^dêLV,

t6t KaL 6 TJpcoTaydpas avTos oaiyxcopTjcrerat /xr/re Kvva /xTjre C
rdy e^TTtrvxdi^ra avdpooTTov fiTpov eimt fxrfbe Trepi ej^ds ov dv
fxr] fxddr]. ovx ovT(t)s;
0e6. Oi^rcos.
e 9 5^ om.W a2 ^
b 8 âiyeraiTW: om. B
oTs SoKel om. pr. B b4 eavroTs] favrohs
^
W
b 11 t^) om.W ffvyxf^PV '
<rvyxopp7iSv T
I7IC ITAATXINOS
5 2f2. OvKovv cTTfiS^ aiM(f)i.(rftr]TlTai, irno ndvTojv, ovbevl
hv ftt] 7} npo)Tay6pov 'AA^^cta oKrÔrjs, ovt rirl &W<a ovr*
avro) iKiv(a.
0EO. "Ayar, aj Swfcparey, T(iv kralpov p.ov KaTadeofxev.
212. 'AXAd roi, oi {îAe, &br}\ov fl #cal Tiapad(.op.v to
lo opOov. (Ikos ye apa (Kelvov Trpe^r^vTfpov ovTa (ro(f)(i!)Tpov
d rjp.(ov elvaL' Kal d avTiKa ivTevOev avaKv\\rei,e fiXP^ '''^^
avx^vos, TToAAa hv epie re eêyâs XrjpovvTa, &)S ro elKos,

Kal (Te opLoKoyovvTa, KaTabvs &v oX\olto diTOTpe\oiV. dAA'
fjpiLV dvdyKT] oTfxai -xfrjadai fjfxlv avTols diToloL TLves iarfxev,
5 Kal TCL boKOvvTa del raura \eyeLV. Kal brJTa kol vvv oAAo
TL (\>Gip.ev 6p.o\oyeXv hv tovt6 ye ovtlvovv, to elvaL (ro(^(LTepov
^Tepov eTepov, elvaL be koll dp.adea-Tepov;

0EO. 'E/xot yovv boKel.
212. 'H Kcu, TavTT] dv /idAiara XcrTacrOaL tov \6yov, tj
e ffiieLS vireypdâpiev (BorjOovvTes Ilpajrayopa, ws tcl piev
TToAAa fi
boKL, TavTjf Kal ÔTLV e/cdoTo), depfxd, ^r\pd,
y\vKea, rrdvTa oaa tov tvttov tovtov ei be irov ev tlo-l
(rvyôiprfcreTaL bâêpeLV dWov aWov, itepX to. vyieLva Koi

6 vocrdibr] de\f](raL dv (f)dvaL fxf] irdv yvvaLov kol TTaLbiov, Kal
6r]pLOV be, LKavov eTvaL Ida-OaL avTo yLyvGxrKov eauroi to
vyLeLvdv, dX\d evTavOa bf] dX\ov oAAou bia^êpeLV, eX-nep
'
TTOV;
0EO. 'E/xoiye boKel ovtu)s.

172 212. OvKovv KOLL TTepX TroAtriKwi;, KoAa fxev kol alcrxpa
Kal 8t/cata Kat aStKa Kat o(ria Kat ]xfj, oXa dv eKd^rrt] it6\ls
oirjdel^ra OffTaL v6]XL]xa avTrj, Tafrra Kal elvaL rf] d\r]6eL(i
eKd(rTr], kol ev tovtols fxev ovbev (rocfxaTepov ovTe ZSkottjv

6 ^Stcorou ovT tt6\lv TrcJAcajs elvaL' ev be tu> (rvp.(\>epovTa
kavTT] f] ]xf] (rvp.(f)epovTa Tide(r6aL, evTavd\ eliTep ttov, av

6/xoAoy7j(ret crv]xôv\6v re av]xôv\ov bLa(f)epeLV Kal irdAecos
C I o y( ipa B 7 Sp' T : : yiip W d6 rh B : rov T

d9 Jio^Tacrdai j ImOcu Badham a7 ffvfxfiovKov] avfifiovKou al W
:
0EAITHTO2 lyâ
boâv kripav kripas Trpbs aXr\6eLav, koL ovk av Trdvv ToXp.i']-
<rie (f)fj(TaL, h av diJTaL TToAts ovp.cf)povTa olrjOelaa avTrj, b

TtavTos ixaXkov TavTa Kal crvvoia-iiv' dAA' eKci ov X4yoi, kv
rots StKaiois Kal dStxots Kat 6o"toty Kat avoaioL^, kdiKovaLV
la-^^vpL^â-OaL ws ovk ea-Ti. (f)va-L avTcav oiibev ova-iav kavTov
iXpv, aXka To kolvi] hoâv tovto yiyv^TaL aXrjOes t6t, otov 5
hoî^ KOLL oa-QV av boKij yj)6vov. Kat oo-ot ye av p.i] TTavTaTraaL
Tov Tlpo)Tay6pov X6yov XiyaxrLV, a)bi Trco? Trfv a-0(f)iav ayovaL.

X6yos be r][xas, S) 0co'8a)/)e, tK Aoyou p.iiô)v k^ kXaTTOvos
KaTaXapL(3avL, C
0EO. OvKovv a-xpXrjv ayo}Xv, S) 'S.uiKpaTes;
211. âLv6fxe6a. Kal TroAAaKt? jxev ye bi], o) baLix6vLe,
Kal oAAore KaTevorâa, aTap Kal vvv, ws etKorcos' ot kv rat?

(f)LXoa-o(f>iaLS ttoXvv \p6vov bLaTpiyfravTes eis to. hLKaaTiqpia 5
toVre? yeAotot cfâivovTaL prjTopes.

0EO. Yl&s bi] ovv XeyeLs;
212. KLvbvvevovaLV ol iv bLKacrrqpioLS Kal toIs tolovtols
eK veo)v KvXLvbovp.evoL Trpbs tovs ev (f)LXo<TO(f)ia Kal Ti}
TOLabe 8tarpt/37/ T9pap.p.evovs o)? olKeTaL Trpbs kXevdepovs d.
Te6pd(f)daL.
0EO. Uf] h];

212. ^Ht rot? fxev tovto b av etTres det Trdpea-TL, (rxoX-q,
Kal Tovs Xoyovs ev elprjvr] eTri a^ôXijs TrotoSrrat* &a-'jTep 5
ijp.els vvvl TpiTov ijbr] X6yov eK Aoyou ]xeTaXap.^dvop.ev,
ovTO) KOLKeLVOL, eav avTOvs 6 eireXdwv tov TTpoKeLfxevov fxaXXov
Ka6diTep rjfxas dpeai]' Kal 8ta p.aKpS)v r] ^payeo^v p.eXeL
ovbev XeyeLv, av jxdvov TvyutaL tov) ovtos' ol be ev daôXici
re deX Xeyovai KaTeireiyeL yap vbo)p peov Kat ovk eyxoopel Q
TTepX ov dv eTTL6vixr]ao)crL tovs Xoyovs -Troteto-ât, dAA' dvdy-
a8 ToK/xTia-Tis
W
T b 3 Kal oSt/cots W
om. B T
: eOtKova-i
SiL(TxvpiCf<^Sat b 4 favTov] (p' avrov Badham b 6 &;/
Schanz : 5ij BT b 7 Xeywfftu B T Xtyovcrtv al.
: &yov(Tt BT
&yxov(Ttv V^ : Xeyovcrt Badham C9 KaX] koX f j* W d.2 re-
6p(x<p0ai W : riTpd^dat BT 62 irotri^TatTdai W
lyae nAAT12N02
KTjv \a}v 6 avTLbi.Kos i(f)4(rTT]Kv Kol vTToypacf^rjv irapava-
yiyv(TKo\xivT]v wv ^ktos ov prjTôv [fjv &jrrcofW(rOiv KaXov(ruf]'
5 oi 8e Aoyoi ad irepl 6fxobov\ov Trpos 8eor7ron;i; Ka9i']fj.vov,
Iv Xdpi TLVa bLKTJV i\OVTa, KoX ol d.y<iiVS OvbiTTOTe TTJJ/
aAAft)s dAA' dei ttjv irepi avrou, iroAAîKt? 8^ Kat irepi Va>x^^s
173 bp6p.0S' UXTT^ (^ aTrdvTCOV TOVTUiV eVTOVOL Kal bpLp.LS
ylyvovTaL, iTTLcrTapLfvoL tov bf^rTTOTrjv Aoyw rc ^wTreCoâi Kal

^py(o vTTeXddv, (Tp,LKpo\ b^k koX ovk opdol tols \/a;x<is. tÎ'
yap av^rjv Kal to ev9v re koI to k\(v9ipLov f] iK vi(nv bov-

5 Aeta d</)r/p7jrat, avayKdôv(Ta TTpaTTeLV (TKo\Ld, /jieyaAovs
Kty8wovs KOL (fiojBovs TL aTTaAats \/Avxats îrt/JdAAouo-a, o^s
ov bvvdfxevoL fjieTa tov StKatov Kat aATjôGs VTTO(f)epeLv, ev9vs
eiri ro \f/evb6s re Kat ro dAAjjAovs dvraStKcii' TpeiT6fj.evoL
b TToAAa KdfXTTTOVTaL Kal ooiyKAwrrat, wo-^' vytes ovêy cxorres

r^s Stayotas ets dvbpas ^k fieLpaKLOiv rcAeuroio-i, beLvoi re
Kat (To(f)OL yeyovdTes, i)S otorrat. Kot ovroi piev br] tolovtol,
S) &e6boi)pe' Tovs be tov fffxerepov \opov mTepov ôv\eL

5 SteAôVrcs f] edo-avres TrdAtv CTrt roi; \6yov TpeiT(opie9a, tva
fxf] KaC, o wvbf] i\4yofiev, \Lav ito\v ri] i\ev9epl(i Kat

fxeTa\i]\freL T(av \6y(DV KaTa)(j)(opLe9a;
0EO. M7j8a/ixci)s, S SwKpares, dAAa 8teAôvrcs. tt(!lw
C yap 5 TOVTO etprfKas, otl ov\ 17/btcts ot iv T<a roLtabe \opev-

ovTes tG)V \6yu)v VTrrfpeTaL, cOOC ol \6yoL f]fxeTepoL uxnTep
olK^TaL, Kal eKaoTos avToiv iTepLfxevei dTT0Te\e(T9i]vaL otclv
fffxlv boKrf' ovT yap bLKaarffs ovre êarffs uxnrep irowjrais

5 kTTLTLp.r]a-(j)V Te KoX dp^lDV eTTL(TTaTeX TTap' f]fXLV.
212. Aeycofxev 8?j, ws eoLKev, eiTel aol ye boKel, TrepX t&v

Kopv(f)aL(t)V' TL yctp &v Tis Tovs ye (f)av$i)s 8tarpi/3orTas ev
(f)L\oa-o(f)Lq Acyot; ovroi 8e' irov ^k vecDV TTpG^Tov fxev eis
d dyopav ovk to-ao-i Tifv 6b6v, ovbe ottov bLKaa-Ti']pLov tj /3ov-
e 4 ^K . . . ((o\oi"(n' secl. Abresch e 6 Tiva] t^>v T a3vwx-

0e7v Cobet e Themistio :
xaf^"^'"''*'" ^^ 0,4 rb i\tv6fpiov Themis-
tius : rh iXfvdtpov BT : 4\tv6tpov W Ca rifJLtrtpoi W : ol fi/xt-
rtpoi BT C 7 ôvAoux W
EAITHTOS i73d
k(VTi]pt.ov 7/ TL Koivov aXXo Trjs TToAetos avvihpLov vofxovs

be Kal y\ry]($i(TîaTa Xiy6p.iva 17 yypap.}xiva ovTe opSxriv ovTe
aKovovai' a-novhaX he Iraiptwv e7r' ap^s koI avvohoi /cat hiiTiva
KoX avv avkrjTpiai KO)p.oL, ovbe ovap TTpaTT^LV TrpoaCaTaTaL 5
avTols. v be rj KaKws tls y4yovv kv TTokeL, ij tl Tca
KaKov eaTLv ex Trpoyovcov yeyovbs 7/ Trpbs avhpQtv 1] yvvaL-

KU)v, piaWov avTbv kekridev 77 oi tt/s OakdTTrjs key6p.evoi
Xoes. Kat TavTa TravT ovb^ otl ovk olbev, olbev ovbe yap e
avTwv aTTe\eTaL tov evboKLp.dv \apLV, dkka tS> ovtl to aS>p.a
fx6vov ev TTi TTokeL Ketrat avTov Kal eTTLbr]p.el, rj be bLavoLa,
TavTa TTOMTa 7iyr]aafxivr] afiiKpa Kal ovbev, dTip.aaaaa ttov-

Ta)(r\ TTeTeTaL KaTo. IlLvbapov " ras re yds xnrevepOe " Kat 5
rd err LTTeba yeoifxeTpovaa, " ovpavov 6' v-jrep " da-rpoi;o/u.o{}ora,
Kai Trdaav TTavTr^ (f)vaLV epevvunxevr] TOiv ovTOiv eKaoTov okov, 174
eh Ta>v eyyvs ovbev avTi]V crvyKaOLelaa.
0EO. YIG)S TovTo keyeLs, S) SwKparfs;
212. "Q.a7Tep Kal QcLkfjv daTpovop.ovvTa, S) &e6b(ope, Kal
dvu) iBkeTTOVTa, TTea6vTa els (j)peap, parra rt? eixp.ekr]S KaL 5
XapUaaa depaiTaLVLS dTToaKwxjraL keyeTaL w? Ta p.ev ev
ovpav^ TTpodvfxolTo elbevai, Ta 8' efxiTpoadev avTov Kal iTapd

TTobas kavOdvoL avTdv. TOVTbv be dpKel aKwppa eiTL TTavTas
baoL ev (^.koao(pLa 8iayovcri. rw ydp ovtl Tbv tolovtov b
6 fxev TTkrfaiov /cai 6 yeiTO)v kekrfdev, ov fxovov otl iTpaTTeL,
dkk' okiyov Kal el dvOpoîTds eaTLV rj tl dkko dpefxfxa' Ti be
TTOT eaTLV dv6po)TTos Kal Ti Ti] TOLavTr] (pTjaeL TTpoar]KeL
bLaôpov tG)V akkoDV TTOLelv ?) iTda^êLV, (rjrtt re kcll TTpdypar 5
eêL bLepevv(op.evos. fxavOdveLS ydp ttov, o) Qe6bo)pe' 7/ ov;

0EO. "Eycoye* Kat dkrÔrj keyeLS.
2X2. Totyciprot, S) (j)ike, t8ta re crvyyLyvofxevos 6 tolovtos
d6 TiJ W : Tt BT iv Tp ir^\ei W t^] tJ) W e I olSei/,

olSev] ol5v h (ISey B 64 koI iis o-j5ev ariijidcracra Schanz e Theo-
doreto e 5 TreTtrai B- W lambhchus : (pfperat BT ras re Campbell
e Clemente tS re B Tct t T
: : e6 fl' vwep scripsi : re virep BT
aI hiepevvwfxevq Theodoretus Tci)'] a>' B a 2 (nryKade'Lcra T
a8 dp(C jj Tj/ce* Badham : &p' iJKti Schanz b7 koI om. B
174 c nAATI2N0S
C Ka(rT(o Koi brjixoa-Ca, oiT(p dpxo/xfws fXcyov, orav (v
hiKaarqpiâ ij ttov &KKo9i &vayKa(r6r] Trepl T(av Ttapa irdSaj
Kou, Twv (V 6(f)6a\fxol9 hiaXiyecrât, yeK(OTa Tiape\ei ov
jxovov Qp(iTTais aXKa Kal tS> aXkio ox\(o, (h (f^peaTa, re
5 Kal Tra(rav airopiav e/iTriTiTcoj; vtto aTTftpiast Kal 7; do^Tj-
p.o(rvvri beivi], boâv d/3eAre/)tas TTap(yop.ivr]' ev re yap
rats Aoi8o/9iai9 tStoi' 1^^' ovbev ovbdva Xoibopdv, ar ovk
elbuis KaKov ovbev ovbevos ck tov pif] /xe/MeAcTT^Kcrat* d.TTopiov
d ovv yeAoto? (f)aivTai. ev re rois (Traivois kou rats rwy

dAAcoy /xeyaAav)(tats ov Ttpo(nToir]T(os akka roi orrt yeAoii;
iivbr]kos ytyvoixfvos kr^pdbr^s 8oKet eivai^ rvpavvov re ydp
ri â(rtkia iyKoopuaCofxevov, eva tS>v vop^coiVi olov crv^(x)Tr]V
5 7/ TTOt]X(va 7/ rtm ôvKokov, r^yelrat aKovetv evbatfxovtCo-

p.(vov TTokv /SSdAAoyra* SixTKoAwrepoi' 8e (Kcivcov Côv Kal
cTTtjSovkoTepov TToipaivetv re jcat /38dAAety vofxiâ avTOVs,
aypotKov 8e Kat dTratSeuroy vtto a(rxokias ovb^v rJTTov tu>v
e vopiioiv Tov TOtovTOV avayKatov yiyv(r6at, (rrfKov iv dpet t6
reixos Trept/Se/SATj/xeVoi/. yrjs be oTav pLvpia iTkidpa 7/ eri
TrAetcD aKovcrr] <2s ris &pa KCKrqfxevos davfxacTTa iTkr]6(t
Ke^KTTjrai, TravcrfxtKpa boK(t ctKovftv eiy dTrao-ar cico^ws r^v
5 y7/y j3keTTtv. to. 8e 8^ yeVrj vfxvovvTUiV, ws yevvaios Tts

kiTTa TTaTTTTOvs TTkov^riovs exoiv aiTo^prjvat, TTavTaiTacrtv
afxf3kv Kal eTTt crfxiKpov 6p(ovT(ov ^yetrai t6v tiTaivov, vtt6
175 aTratSevo-tas ov bvvafxevoov ets t6 iTav det /SAeVety ov8^ Aoyt-

fe<r0at ort TT(iinT(ov Koi irpoyovdiv /xuptdSes ^Kaorw yeyovacrtv
avapi6fxr]T0t, kv aXs TTkovcrtot Kat Trrcoxoi Kat /SacrtAT/s Kai
8o{iAot âplâpoi re Kat "EAAtjvcs TroAAaKiy fxvpioi yeyovacriv
5 droJoSv dAA' eTri iTevTe Kal eiKoo-t KaroAdyw TTpoyovoav
(refxwvofxevcov Kal avaêp6vT(ov ets 'HpaKAe'a rov Âfxcftt-
Tpv(ovos droTra avrai KaTa(f>aiveTat rfjs crfxtKpokoyias, drt
b 8e o d7r' ^ AfxcfitTpvoovos els t6 6.V(o irevTeKaieiKOcrTos roiou-
ros T/y ota (Tvveâtvev avrio tvxt], Kal 6 iTevTrfKo^rTos i-rr
d4 f^Ktf/tta^îcra' Madvig lacunam staluit Cobet

: ba ola . . . tvxjj B
EAITHTOS i75b
avTOv, yeA.a ov bvvafievcov XoyCCfo-daC re Kal yavvorqTa

avoriTOV "^yjis omaXKaTT^LV. fv aTiacn hi] tovtois 6 tolov-
Tos VTTO Tu>v TToXkwv KaTayekaTat, tcl fxev viTpr](f)dvo)s 5
^(0)1', o)? boKel, Ta 8' iv 7T0(rlv dyvoSiV re koX kv kKdaTOLS

diTopSiV.
0EO. YlavTaTTaa-L tcl yLyv6p.va Aeyeis, S SlcoKpare?.
212. "Oray be ye TLva avTOS, S (f>C\, kXKixrj] dvco, Kal
eOekrâ-rj tls avT(^ kK^rjvaL ck tov " Tt eyo) o"e dbLKw rj av C

e/xe'"; ets a-Ke\lrLV avTijs bLKaLO(Tvvr]s re Kat dStKta?, rt re
(KaTepov avTOLV Kal tC t&v iTdvToov r] dWiqXoiv bLa(ppTOv,
?) K Tov "'H /3a(riAei)s evbaCfioiv," " KeKrqjjLdvos t av
XpvcrCov," (BaaLkeCas Trepi Kat dvOpooTTCvrjs oXcos (vbaLfxovCas 5
Kai ddkLOTTjTOS eTTt (rKiy\rLv, TToCoi re' rtve ka-Tov kcll TCva
TpoTTOv dvOpdiTTOV (pvaeL Trpo(rriKt to flkv Krqcraa-OaL avTolv,
fb 8e dTTO<pvyLV Trept tovto)v diTdvTOiv oTav av Se'?/ Aoyoy
bibovaL Tov afXLKpbv (Kelvov rr;y \j/vxr]v Kal bpnivv kol d
StKaiîKov, TraAty av tcl dvTCa-Tpocpa dTTobCboio-LV ^lkLyyLSiV
re aTTo v\lrr]Xov Kpep.acrd\s kcll ^kiiToov juere^copo? avoidev
VTTO dr^deCas dbr]fxovS>v re Kat diropSiV kcll âTTapCôiv yikoiTa
QpciTTaLS p.ev ov 7rape'xêt ovb' dkkca diTaLbevTco ovbevC, ov 5
ydp aiaddvovTaL, tols 8' kvavTCois rj ois dvbpaiToboLS Tpa-
(fi^la-L TTacTLV. oilros br] kKaT^pov TpoiTOs, Si Qeoboipe, 6
ju.ev r<3 ovTL kv ekevOepCci re Kat o-yokr] T6pap.pLVov, ov e
br] (pLk6ao(\)Ov KaA.ets, w dvfJ.ar]T0v vr]9eL boKcXv Kal
ovbivl etyat OTav ets 8ovAtKa kfXTT^crr] bLaKovr]p.aTa, oXov
crTpoi]xaT6bea]xov ]xr] TTLa-Tap.vov ovaKevdcraadaL p.r]b 6\}fOV
r]bvvaL r/ doiTTas k6yovs' 6 b' av Ta ]XV TOLavra TrdvTa 5

bvva[XVov TopSis re Kot oîois bLaKovLV, dvajSdkkâdaL 8e
b 3 ivvafxfvcf T Svvdiu.fvov Heindorf

W
:
W
b 8 rb yiyv6fj.fvov W
b 9 7 om. &VW T om. B c a ovttjs
: al ttjs B T W :
C 4 ^ scripsi ti B T : KKT-p/j.ijv fort. scribendum t' ai xoAv al.

lamblichus e 7 Krria-aadai] KT-fia-fo-dat B T e 8 tovtwv
air6.vTwv'\ TravToiv rovTwv T d 4 âTTopiCoiv e Themistio Pierson :
Pap$api(wv B T d 6 Tpa<p(7ffiv diraffiy B 63 ouSevJ] ovSfy

Cobet 6555* oSJ ou5 o5 B T

175 6 nAATilNOS
ovK TTt.aTafj.vov ^TTiZi^La (XevOepidis ovbi y apfJuovCav Aoycop
176 kaôvTOs opO^s vixinja-ai dedv re Kal avbpciv evdakfxovoiV
îov [dA.T7^^].
0EO. Ei TtavTas, a> 2w/cpar69, TreCOoi.s h Aeyets uxnrfp

ifie, TrAeicov Sv dprjvr] Kal KaKO. eAdtTTO) Kar avOpdirovs (ti].
5 S2. 'AAA' ovT aTToKiaOaL to. KaKo. bvvaTov, d) 0eo8copc

VTrevavTLOv ydp tl rai aya9(o ael etiât avdyKT) ovt^ iv
deoXs avTo. Ibpva-OaL, ti]V b^ dvrjTrjv (f)va-iv Kal Tovbe tov
TOTTOV TrepLTToXfL $ avdyKr]s. 8to fcat TreLpaa-daL xph ^vOivbe
b cKeto-e <pevyLV otl Tdxi-o^Ta. (jivyr] be 6/uotoxris Oe^ /cara
To bvvaTov 6p.0L0iaLS b\ bLKaLOV Kal oa-LOV iXTa (ppovriaêMS
yevea-OaL. dkXa ydp, S) dpLo-Te, ov iidvv tl pabLov Treio-ai
b>s dpa ovx wj^ ^vcKa oi ttoWoC <f)aa-L belv iToviipCav fxkv
5 <f>vyLV, dpTr]V be bL<aKiv, tovtcov X"^P"' '"^

M*^ eirtrTj-
bevTcov, To 8' ov, Xva br] iir] KaKos koa. Iva dyaOos boKr\
eivaf Tavra p.V ydp ia-TLV 6 X.y6]XVos ypaatv vOXos, o>s
ifxol <f)aCveTaL' t6 be d\r]Oes &be \iy<oixev. Oe6s ovbafxri

C ovbafxais dbLKos, dAA' o)? olov re bLKaLOTaTos, Kal ovk ô-tlv
avTu ofxoLOTepov ovbev i] os dv r^fxGiV av yeirqraL otl Si/cato-
TaTos. TTepl TOVTO KOL f] i)S dXr]OQs beLVOTT^s dvbp6s Kol

ovbevCa re *cat dvavbpCa. 17 fxev yap tovtov yvHaLS a-o<\>Ca
5 KOL dpeTi] dXr]OLvr], f] be dyvoLa d[xaOCa Kal Ka^Ca ivapy/]S'

al b' dkkaL beLvorqTes re 8oKoCo-at Kal <To<pCaL Iv pev
TTokLTLKaLS bvvaorTeCaLS yLyvofxevaL (f)opTLKaC, iv be Te)(vaLs
d ^dvavcroL. ro) ovv dbLKovvTL Kal dvoa-La keyovTL r] TTpdTTOVTi
fxaKp<ji dpLo-T e\eL t6 fxi] a-vyxâpelv beLVta vtto iTavovpyCas

eivat* dydAAorrai ydp roi dret8et Kal olovTaL dKoveLV otl
ov krjpoC elcTL, yi]S dAAcos dxOr], dAA' dvbpes otovs bel

5 iv TTokeL Tovs a(t)Or]aofxevovs. keKTôv ovv TdkrfOes, ori
Toa-ovTi)} fxdkkov elaLV otot ovk otovTaL, otl ov)(l otorraf
e 7 ^\(vOepici>s Athenacus : i\ev6fpws BT y' om. W a i iy-

SpwvlafdpanrcevB.]. aa iA.r/0^ om. Athenaeus ti om. b^ B
b 6 5^ om. B 5i Eusebius
: b 7 fiky om. B 03 tovto lamblichus
Theodoretus Stobaeus : tovtov BT c6 /cal om. T <To<plai] <To<pod B
0EAITHTO2 i76d
ayvoov(TL yap ^r)fjLiav dSiKiaj, h bd ijKto-Ta ayvoiXv. ov ydp

fo-TLvrjv boKova-iv, TrArjya^re Kal ddvaToi, 5>v evCoT jrdaôva-i.v
ovbev dbLKovvTCS, dXXa ^v dbvvaTOV kK<\>vytiv. 6

0EO. Tiva bi} XiyeLs;
212. YlapabLyiJidT(tiV, o) (pike, kv r&i ovri kar(aTU>v, tov
fxev 6eiov evSat/Lioveo-rdrou, tov be d6eov d6XL(iiTdTov, ovx

opQiVTiS OTL ovT(i)S \L, T/TTo i/At^tdrrjrds re Kai Trjs eo-^^drT/S' 5
dvoias Xav6dvova-L rw fxev 6p.OLOvp.evoL 8td rds dbiKOvs 177

irpd^Li, T(o be dvop.oLovp.evoL. ov br\ tlvovctl biKrjv ^&irrey
Tov eLKOTa îov & opLOLOvvTaL' iav 8' eiiroip.ev otl, dv p.i]
diraAAaycSo-i tt/s beivorrjTOS, kol reXevrrjo-ayra? avTovs

eKelvos pev 6 t5>v KaKStv Ka6apos roTros ov beêTaL, iv6dbe 5
8e TT]v avTols opLOLorqTa Trjs bLaycoyrjs del eôvaL, KaKol

KaKOLS a-vv6vTS, ravTa br] Kal itavTdiraa-LV ws detiôt Kat
Trayoupyot dvor\T(v tlv&v dKovaovTai,
0EO. Kai pAka brj, S) 2)(dKpares.
212. OtSd roi, S kTaxpe. %v p.ivToi tl avTols avp,- b
ê^riKev oTav Ibia Koyov birj bovvai re Kat beâcrdaL
TTeffi &v \l/eyov(rL, kol eêXrjcrôa-LV dvbpLKcos ttoXvv \p6vov
VTrop.Lvai Kal p.rj dvdvbpcos (f)vyLV, t6t drd-jrcos, S) baLp.6vL,
TkevT(avTS ovK dpicTKOvcrLV avToX avToXs iiepX u>v XeyovcrL, 5

Kat r} pr]TopLKr} eKeivrj tt(x>s dirop.apaiveraL, u>aTe Traiboov
p.r]bev boKelv bLa<f)epeLV. Trept pev ovv tovtôv, eTretSr) ko^

TTapepya rvyxdveL Xey6p.eva, dirocrTSipev et 8e p.ri, TTkeico
del eiTLppeovTa KaTaxcoaeL r)p.(ov tov e^ dp^îjs kdyov eTrt C

be TCL ep.TTpoa-dev L(op.ev, et Kat o-ot 8oKet.
0EO. 'Ejitot p.ev To. TOLavTa, S) ^(oKpaTes, ovk drjbecrTepa

dKoveLV pci(o ydp rqkLK^be ovtl eTTaKokov6eLV. et p.evT0L
boKel, ttoXlv eTTavi(op.v. 5
2X2. OvKovv evTavdd ttov 77/Jtey tov kdyov, ev w (f)ap.V
Tovs Trjv (f)pop.evrjv ovcriav keyovTas, Ka\ to del boKovv
e3 ovTi] iravrl W b2 ot' &;/ W Srt &' BT b4 <j>vyt7v

W ; (pevydv BT b7 odv om. W
:
PLATO, VOL. I. 20
I77C nAATHNOS
(KaoTO) TovTO Koi (IvaL TovT<a ut boKii, (V fjikv Tols aAAots
(deKetv bua-xypCCcorOai Koi ovx iJKLaTa TtepX to. bUaLa, ws
d TTavTos (jmWov & hv OfjTaL TTokLS boâirra avrfj, raOra koI
itTTL bUaLa Trj OefJLevr], (uxnTfp hv KtrjTaL' TTfpl bi Tayada
ovbeva avbpeLov l^' ovtms eivai wore ToXfjiav 8ia/iaxc<rôi otl
Kal a av o>(î\Lp.a olrjdeLcra ttoKls (ovTrj OiJTaL, Kal ((ttl Toaov-
5 Tov \p6vov oaov av KtrjTaL wêAi/xa, -ttAî; et tls t6 lovoiia

\eyoL' TovTO bi ttov o-KoSfi/x' hv (trj Tcpos h k4yofjLV. ^ ovyi;
0EO. Wavv y.
e 212. M^ yap AeyeVo) to ovofxa, aWa to iTpayfjLa to
dvofiaôixevov detiipeCTO).
0EO. Mr) yap.
212. 'AAA' o div TovTO ovofJLaCr), tovtov bi^TTOV <7T0)(<iêrat
5 vofiod(TOVfivr\, KaX irairas tovs vofxovs, Kad^ ocrov oUTai re

Kai 8warai, ojs oxêAi/xwrarous kavTT] rt^craf rj iTpbs aAAo
ri l3XTT0v<ra vofxodeTfXTaL;
178 0EO. Ovbay^Qis.

212. 'H ovv KoX TvyyaviL ckl, 1] TToAAa Kai bLafjiapTavfL
kKaa-TT];
0EO. OTfxaL eyuiye koX afiapTavfLV.

5 2X2. 'Ert rotwi' ivOevbe av fJuaWov iTas tls 6p.o\oyifa-L(v
TavTCL TavTa, d iTepl TTavTos tls tov dbovs fp<or<f)i7 (V <i)
Kat t6 ti>î\Lfxov Tvyyav^L ov (aTL b( ttov Kal iT(p\ tov

fxiWovTa yjjovov. OTav yap vofxo6(T(ofi(6a, (Ls (aofX(Vovs
0)(f)(\LfXOVS TOVS VOfXOVS TL6(fX(6a (LS t6v (TT(LTa \p6vOV'

10 TovTo b( " fxiWov " dp6<as h.v \(yoLfx(v.
b 0EO. Uavv y(.

212. "Wl brf, ovTUjaX ^pcorw/xey ripcorayo^pai; ?/ oAXor
rtva Tiav ^KetVo) to. avTO. \(y6vT(i)V' " YldjrroiV fx(Tpov
C 9 ri om. B d2 TTJ Otfi^yri] riO(fj.ivri T riiyadiL] ri.^yor

Bov B d6 {) W: om. BT 613 Xfyirt . . . fi^ yip
om. T e I T^ dvofxa(6nfvoy W : t ivofia(6fifyov B e a Bfu-
pflrw'] dfupf7ro pr. W : 6fa>pf7rai B a a iroXXi] tal *-o\Ai T
a3 iKdanj W : tKiffry BT a 10 fxiWov W : fioWov BT
0EAITHTOS i78b
avdpuiTros eoTiv" ods (âri, 2 YlpoiTayopa, XevKwv âpioiv

Kov(po)v, ovbevos otov ov tG>v tolovtoiv excoy yap avTcav 5
To KpiTTjpiov kv avT^, ola Trdo-xei ToiavTa oio/xews, akr]6ri

re oterai avToi kcli ovTa. gv\ ovtu>;
0EO. Ovro).
212. 'H Kal T<av pLeXXovTOdV eaeardai, <pri(rop.ev, w Hpo)-
Tayopa, eêi t6 Kpirqpiov (v avT(o, Kal ola av olrjdfi eo"eo-âi, c
TavTa Kal yCyvfTai, KU'(a rw olrjdevTL; olov 6(pp.a' ap
OTav TLS olr}6ri tStw-njs avTov TwpiTov Xri\lre(r6aL Kal crcr6aL
Tavrqv Tijv êppLorqTa, Kal Tpos, laTpos 8e', avT0Lr}6fj, KaTCi
Ti]v TTOT^pov boâv (p&pLV t6 p.eXXov aTTO^ri^rccrdaL, rj KaTct. 5
T7]v aiJi(f)OT4poiV, Ka\ rw piv laTpco ov 6pp6s ovbe 7wptTT0)V
yvi](rTaL, kavTSt 8e ap.(p6Tpa;
0EO. reAotoi^ p.(.VTav etrj.
2X2. 'AAA' ot/xai TTepi otrou yXvKvrqTOS Kal ava-TrjporqTOS

fjieXXovcrqs ea-cr6ai, rj tov yeoipyov boâ aXX' ovx, V '^^^ ^
KLâpLO-TOV KvpCa.
0EO. Tt pirjv;
2X2. Ov8' av av TTfpl avapixocTTOv re xai evapfxocTTov
(o-ofievov TraLboTpi^rjs h,v îXTLOv 8o^d(reiey fwvcTLKOv, 6 Kal 5
eireLTa avT(o rw TraLboTpL^r] 8dêt evapfj.o(TTOv elvaL.
0EO. Ovbap.G)s.
2X2. OvKovv KoX Tov fxeXXovTos k(rTLacre(T6aL fxr] fxayeL-
pLKov ovTos, (rKevaôfXvr]s doCvqs, aKvpoTepa 7/ KpCcrLS Trjs
Tov oxj/OTTOLOv TTepl Tijs aop.vr]s i]bovrjS. TTepl p-ev yap tov 10
ijbr] ovTOS kK<x(rT(a fjbeos t/ yeyordros fxrfbev tto) roi Xdyo) e
8ia/xa)(<ri/jte0a, dAAa Trept tov peXXovTos eK(xaT(o Kal boêLv
Kal ecrecr6aL iroTepov avrds avTut apLaTOS KpLTi]S, 7] (tv, oi
TlpoiTayopa, t6 ye Trepi X6yovs TTL6av6v eKaoro) r]fx5tv
eaofxevov ds bLKaa-TrjpLov j3eXTL0v av 7Tpoboâ(raLS r) tG>v 5
lbLo)TQ>v ooTLcrovv;
b4 XivKwv (^n^Xivwv'^ Cornarius C 2 TovTa] roiavra Heindorf

C3 om. T
(cal tiffcrOai d 5 & om. T e 4 t<{ 7 W
tot B T :
20*
178 e nAATX2N02
0EO. Kat fxaXa, a> 'SwKpares, tovto ye (r(f)6bpa vtT'
Krxyelro TrdvTUiv bia(f>epei.v avTos.

212. Ntj ACa, Si {xekc ^ ovbeCs y hv avrai SteAcyero
179 8i8oi/s TTo\v apyvpiov, il fXT] tovs avvovTas i-nuO^v ort koX
To ixikkov (aecrOaC re Kai 8oêti; ovt( ixdvTis ovt( ris fiAAos
ajxeivov KpCvcuv Sv i] avTos [avroi].
0EO. 'AATjêWra.
5 2f2. OvKovv Kal al vopx)6i(rCai koX to o>(f)^\ifxov Trepl
ro jxeKkov ^(ttC, koi Tras hv 6p.oX.oyol vop.o6eTovp,evr]v

ttoXlv TTokkaKLs dvdyKr]v etvai tov u>(f)ekLp.oiTdTov diro-
Tvyydveiv;
0EO. MaAa ye.
10 2f2. Merpto)? dpa rjpXv TTpbs tov StSao-KoAoV (tov dpr]-
b o-erat ort dvdyKr] avrui o/xoAoyeir (ro(f)(t)Tp6v re ÂAoi'
aAAou etvat Kat tov p.ev toiovtov fXfTpov flvai, ipol 8e rcS
aiêTrto-rrz/jtoyt /ur/Se OTrcoo-rtoui; dvdyKr]v elvai p.4Tp(o yCyv(r6ai,

oiS apTi /xe rjvdyKaCev 6 virfp (KeCvov kdyos, efr' e/3ouAo/iT;j;
5 etre /xr/, tolovtov etrai.

0EO. 'EKetyr/ /iot SoKet, u) ^MKpaTcs, /xaAiora oAiVKe-
o-âi 6 Aoyos, aAio-Ko/xeros Kai TavTrj, fj
ras rwv aAAa>y
8oâj KvpCas Trotei, aurai 8e i(f)dvr]a-av tovs CKeCvov kdyovs
ovbafxf] dkr]OiLs rjyovpevaL.
C 2X2. IloAAaxrj, S) 0eo'8a)pe, koI aAAr/ Sr ro' ye rotoirroi'
oAotr/ /A^ Trd(j-av -navTos oArj^r/ So^ây etyai* we/rt 8e to

napov CKaoTo) Trdôs, e^ b)V al al(r6^(r(LS Kal al KaTo. Tavras
6o'at yCyvovTaL, xakcirdTepov kkdv ws ovk dAr/êty. l(r(t)s
5 Se ovbev keyo)' dyoAojrot ydp, d irvxov, flcrCv, koll ol
(f)d(rK0VTS avrds evapyels re etmt xai iTTL(m]pLas Td\a dv

ovTa kiyoLiV, KaX QfaCTrjTOS obe ovk aTTo aKOTTov (IprjKev
d ala6rj(TLV koX iTL(rTr]p.r]v tovtov 6ep.ivos. TTpo^rLTiov ovv eyyV'

Tepu), ot)S 6 VTTfp Ylpo^Tayopov Ao'yos ^7re'rarre, Kai (TKCJTTeov
ar fiii] irpHeindorf: 8^ Campbell aa 6Ty secl. Schleier-

machcr a7iydyicn T C l woWaxv] ôWaxV "^" Stobaeus
C2 iravTii] iravTws Stobaeus
OEAITHTOS I79d
"njv îpo}xivr)v ravrqv ovcrLav hiaKpovovra etrf vyiks etre
traOpov (f)9yy(Taf /xax^ S' ovv Trepl avnjs ov cjâvkr] ovb*
oAiyois yiyovev. 5
0EO. rioWoS Kal 8et (fiavXrj eiyat, aXXa Trepl fxkv -njv
^ldivCav Kal Tnbib(0(n Trd^xTTokv. 01 yap tov 'HpaKAetVou

eratpot xoprjyovcri tovtov tov koyov p.(xXa ippoifXivcDS.
2X2. To) rot, 0) (îAe Qeobcope, fxaXXov crKmTiov koX e^
apxfji, uxTTTfp avTol vTroTeivovTaL. e
0EO. HayraTTao-t [xev ovv. Ka\ ydp, a> "EâKpaTes, Trept
TOVTOiV t5)V 'HpaKAeiretcoi; 7/, uxmep crv Xe'yets, *0/x7jpeta>y
Kat ert irakaLOTepuiv, avTol^ fXV rois Trept Tr]V "Ecêo-or, oo-oi
7rpo(nTOLOvvTaL e/ixTreipot, ovbev fxakkov olov re StaAex^rjrat 5
rf rots ol(TTpS)crLV. aTexvG)^ yap KaTO. tcl crvyypdfxpLaTa
(f)epovTaL, t6 8' eTrtp.eiyat eTTt Aoyw Kat epooTijfxaTL Kal r)(TvxC<>>i
iv fxepeL aTTOKpLvacrdaL kcu kpicrQaL tjttov avTols evL rj t6 180

fXTjbev fxakkov be v7rep/3aAAet t6 ovb^ ovbev Trpos t6 fxrjbe
(TfXLKpov ivelvaL rot? dvbpdcTLV rjcrvxLas. dAA' dv TLvd tl

(prj, axnrep eK cfâpeTpas pr\fxaTLcrKLa aivLyfxaT(abrf dvaa-jTbivTes
aTTOTOêvovcrL, Kav tovtov Cv^V^ koyov kafBeLV tl eiprfKev, 5
ere'p(i> TTeTrkif^r] KaLvws fxeT(avofxa(Tfxev(a. Trepavels be ovbeiTOTe
ovbev TTpos ovbeva avT&v ovbe ye eKetvoi a^rot Trpos dAA^-
Aovs, dAA' ei! Trdin; </)uAdrrouo-t t6 fxrfbev êâiov edv eXvaL
fxrfT ev Ao'yw p.rfT ev rats airrQv r/n^xai? rfyovfxevoi, ws efxoX b
SoKet, aiTO (TTd(TLfX0V elvaL' TOVTd^ be TTdvV 1TokefXOV(TLV, KoX
KaB' o(TOV bvvavraL TTavToyodev eK^dkXofvcTLV.
20. "lcruis, oi Qeobcope, Toiis dvbpas fxaxofxevovs eôpaKas,
elprfvevovcTLV be ov crvyyeyovas' ov ydp ctoX eTalpoC eicrLV. 5
oAA' otfiaL TCL TOLavTa toIs fxaOrfTals tTrt oôAtJs (f^pdôvcTLV,
ov? av ôvkcovTaL ofxoiovs avTols Trotrô-at.
0EO. Hotots fxadrfTOLS, S) baLfxovLe; ovbe yiyveTaL tG)V

TOiovTOiv eTepos eTepov fxadrfnljs, dAA' ax/TOfxaToi dva^vovTaL c
A^hiaKpovovTaTW: hcovovTa^ AT irdfiiro\vy B dg

t^ rot
B Eusebius : rovro ut videtur T fjLoWov] fid\a T om. T
Koi
e4 Kol] T Kol W a 2-3 /loXAoj' . Tjavxias secl.
. . Schmidt
i8oc nAATilNOS
6tt69V hv Tvx[i cfcaoTos avr&v IvOovcrtAcras, Kai rov trepov
6 (Tepos ovbev i^yftrai clbevai. irapa /x^r ovv tovtoiv, oitfp
fia ipQv, ovK av ttot Adtôis \6yov ovt K6vTQiv ovTt

5 aKovTCiiV' avTovs 8e 8et Trapakaji6vTas a>a-iT(p TTpojBKrip.a
iTna-KOTTeicrOai.
2i2. Kat p.(Tpi(ai ye Xeyetj. to be 8?; TTp6^kr]p.a aXXo

Ti TTap(i\r}(f>ap.v iTapa p.ev tS>v apâCoiv p.(Ta TTOiijaeuiS
d iTiKpvTTTop.V(iiV Tovs TToAAjovs, (Ls Tj yiveais tQv aAAojy
TTdvTdiv '12Kearos re fcai Trjdvs pcvfxaTa (ovtol) Tvy\avi koX
ovbev iOTriKe, iTapa 5e TUiV voTipdiV 5re aocfxtiTepaiV ava-
(fiavbov aiTobLKwp.iv(iiV, Iva kolI ol a-KxrroTîxot avTGiV ti]V
5 (TO(fiCav fj.a9(iia-iv aKovaavTes Kal TTava-oiVTai Ât^tcos ol6p.(voL
Ta ixev e^rrdvaL, tcl be KWiLcrdai tS>v ovTOiv, ixaO^vTcs bf. otl

TTavTa KLViLTaL TLixQo-LV avTovs ', oXCyov be ^TreAaô/XTjv, ui
0eo'Scope, ort aAAot av TovavTCa tovtols aTT((\>rivavTo,
e toTov aKLvr]Tov reXida r^ iravTl ovoix eirait
fcat oAAa ocra Me'Ato-o-ot re Kal VlapixcvCdai ivavTiovixevoi

iracn rotJrois Stto^vptôyrat, ots er re ircm-a ôrt kol (Trr]Kev
avTO (V avTut ovk ^x^^ x^^P^^ ^^ V f u^f t'""'- tovtols ovv, aj
5 (TOLpe, TTaa-L rC \pr]a-6pda; Kara aixLKpov yap iTpoLovres
AeATjâ/xey aixcfiorepaiv eis rb ix(rov ireirrco/cores, Kat hv fxri
l8l TTij aixvv6ixV0L bLa(fivy(tiixV, bLKrjv b(a(rop.V (orrTrep oi v raty

TraAatoTpats 5ta ypaixprjs iTaCôvres, orav vtt d/x0ore'pa)i;
\r](fi6irrS eA/ccorrat ets ravavrCa. Sofcet ovv ixoi rovs krdpovs

TTp6rpov aKTTT0v, e0' ovcnrep ot)pixi]crajXV, rovs piovras, /cal
5 kav p.V TL (fiaCvdivraL keyovres, aw\ôpLV /xer' avTQi>v jjixas
avTovs, Tovs re'povs eKcfivyew Tret/Ktffierot* eai' 8e oi tov

okov (TTacrLoirat aXr)6(rrpa kdyeiv boKQai, (f>V^6ix6a Ttap
C3 oirtp â B C 7 8i 8^
ipSiv'] SirepiTji iitpaiv \s\c) Eusebius W :
^fSJj BT (12 6i>Ta addxdi d6 fjuiSSvTa Si om. T e i cê

hoc versu vide Diels ad Parmenidem 8. 38 a 7 iro/ aWovs 4t'
aZ rwv Schleiermacher irop* avTovi iir' a^jrwv raiv
: : iir' ovtwv tSi' W
irop' auravs B ra>v vap' aiirovs iw' airruv T
:
0EAITHTO2 i8ib
avTOVs an av tQ>v to. aKlvr\Ta KivovvTCdv. onKôTcpoi 8' av b

(fyavuKTi fxrjbfv fxerpiov \iyovTiS, yeXoiot eaoixeOa T]yovp.Voi
ijfxas ixev tI Xeyeiv (pavXovs ovTas, irap.TTaXaiovs 8e Ka\
TTa(rcr6(f)ovs avhpas aTTobeboKLpLaKOTfS. opa ovv, cb Qeobaype,
1 Xv(TLT(\l eis roo-oCroy TrpoUvai Kivbvvov. 5
0EO. Ovbev fxev ovv aveKTOv, o SwKpares, fxr] ov

bLacrKi\l/a(r6aL tl keyovcrLV kKarepoL t&v avhpS>v.
2X2. "^KeTtTeov av eXrj crov ye ovTOi 'npodv\xov\xevov. boKel
ovv fxoL apxri elvai Trjs (TKe^lreois KLvâ-ecos TtepL, ttoIov tl c

TTOTe apa XeyovTes âo-i tcl TiavTa KLvelcrOaL. ôvkofxaL be
KeyeLV to TOLOvbe' noTepov ev tl elbos avTrjs Xeyov(TLV i),
co(nrep ep-ol (PaCveTaL, bvo; jxrj jxevTOL fxovov efxol boKeLTO),
aWa avfxfxeTe)(je Kal crv, Xva KOLvfj iTacrxbifxev av tl Ka\ berj. 5
KaC fxoi keye' apa KLveLaOaL KaXels oTav tl ^dipav ck \(i>pa<i
fxeTa^6Xkr\ r\ koX ev to) avT^ (rTpi(})r\TaL;
0EO. '"Eya^ye.
SI2. ToCto fxev toCvvv %v ecTTO) eTbos. oTav be r\ fxev ev
rw avT^, yr\pdcrKr\ be, rf fxekav eK kevKOV i\ (rKkr\pbv ck d

fxakaKOv yCyvr\TaL, ?/ Ttâ akkrjv akkoCoocrLV okkoL&TaL, apa
ovK a^LOV eTepov eXbos <f)dvaL KLvr\a-ea)s;
0EO. ["EfxoLye ôKei] dvayKalov fxev ovv.

2X2. Avo bi\ keyo) tovto) etbeL KLVi\a-eo)9, dXXoCaxriv, ti\v 5
de (})opdv.
0EO. 'Op6o)S ye keyoov.
2X2. ToSto toCvvv ovto) bLekofxevoi bLakeydfxeOa 7/877 Toiy
TCL TrdvTa ({)da-Kova-LV Kivela-âL kol epwTcofxev YloTepov Tray
(f)aTe dpL(f)OTepo)9 KLvelaâL, (f)ep6fxev6v re Kat dkXoLOVfxevov, e
7/ To fxev TL dfX(f)OTepo)S, to 8' eTepo)s;
0EO. 'AAAa /Lta Ai' eyo)ye ovk eô) elTTelv oLfxaL 8 av
(f)dvaL dfx(f)OTepo)s.
b I To] Kal To T b 2 TiyovfjLfBa B b6 avfKT6v\ avf reoy

Madvig c2 <f>a(Ti om. T d4 tfxoiye SoKe7 om. Stobaeus
avayKaiov fi.fu oiv vulgo Socrati tribuunt ; Theodoro iam tribuit B
CI5 Wtj Kiv(\(rfa>s tovtu T d.6 <popdv W : irfpi<popdv BT Stobaeus
i8ie nAATIiNOS
5 Sf2. E^ bi y firj, o) kToipe, Kivovfxfva re avrois Kal
kcrrSiTa (f)avLTat, Kal ovbev fmWov 6p6a>s fci (lirelv crrt
KiveXTai To. ndvTa rj otl (m]KV.

0EO. 'AkqeicTTaTa \4yLs.
212. OVKOVV ^TTfLbr] KLVfLO-daL aVTO. bd, TO be IIT] KLVLa-6aL
l8a H-V ^velvaL ixrjbevC, TrdvTa brj Tta^rav KCirqa-iv &l KtveiTaL.
0EO. 'AvAyKTi.
212. 2x01761 brj fWL rJ8e air&v ttjs depjJMTrjTos rj X.evK6-
TrjTos rj OTovovv yev(rLV ov\ ovrco ttcos i\yop.v (f)a.vai
5 avTovs, (f)^p(r6aL ^Ka^TTov tovt()v &iJLa al(r6ria-L fieTa^v tov

TTOLOvirros t Kal TrdcrxovTOS, Kal to /x^y Trda-xov aladrfTLKOV
aAA.' ovK aX(T6r](TLV [^ri] ylyveadaL, to be ttolovv ttolov tl
dAA' oi) TTOLorqTa; Xa-(as ovv rj "TTOLorqs" aixa dXKoKOTOv T
(f)aLVTaL ovojxa Kal ov p.av6dvLS a6p6ov ky6p.vov' xaro
b fJi-epr] ovv aKOV. t6 yap ttolovv ovt 6pp.6Tr]s ovt kevKorqs,
êpjxov b\ Ka\ KevKov yCyveTai, Kal raAAa ovtco' ]xi]xvr](Tai
ydp TTOV iv TOLS TTp6a6V otl ovtoos iX^yofxev, ^v jxr^bhf avTO

Kad* avTo eXvaL, ]xr]b^ av to ttolovv r] Trd^ryov, dAA' ^^ d.p.(f>o-
5 Tepcov TTpbs &Wr]\a (rvyyLyvo]XVMV rds al(T6r]a-LS Kal to.
ala-6r]Ta diTOTLKTOVTa tol fxev ttoC drra yiyv(T6aL, to. b\

ala-6av6]Xva.
0EO. Meixvr^fxaL' ttcjs 8' ov;
C 212.Td ]XV TOLVvv dAAa yaipeu} ^da-(o]XV, efre dAAtos
etre ovt(os Keyova-LV ov 8' VKa \yo]XV, tovto ]x6vov
<pvXdTToi)]Xv, epcorcSiTes* Ktreirai Kal pel, c3j (PaT, tcl
TTdvTa; ^ ydp;
6 0EO. Nai.
212. OvKovv dix(f)0T^pas hs 8teiAd/xeâ Kuniafis, (f)p6]Xvd
re Ka\ dWoLov]Xva;
0EO. Tlm 8' ov; eiTrep ye 8^ reAe'a)s Kuô-erat.
e5 tthrois W : iavrots BT a i ivf7yai W ; ii/ flyai BT

a6 alffOvTiKhu] alffOrtrhy B T al(T6av6fitvov Hcindorf a^ fr om.
W
:
(suspicor e correctione lectionis alaOriThv ortum esse) Tot6t> Ti

W : iroiovvri B : voiovv, tj T b3 iv^ Kal iv B
0EAITHTOS i82C
Sfl. Ei fxev TOivvv ((f>peTO fiovov, qWotovTO be ixrj,
LxoixV av TTOv ciTreiy ota aTTa pei to. (pepofxeva' r/ Trws lo
0EO. OvTOiS.
2X2. 'EttciS^ be ovbe tovto ^xevei, to XevKov peXv to piov, d
oXka fXTaâXX.i, wore Kal avTov tovtov elvat porjv, ttjs
XevKorqTos, Kal /iera/SoA.Tji' eU aXXrjv xpoav, tva fxr] aXw

TavTT] fxdvov, apd ttotc olov re n TTpoa-enrelv xpwixa, utaTe
Kal opduis TTpoa-ayopViv; 5

0EO. Kat Tis fxrwavri, S 'S.dliKpaTes; rj aWo ye rt TOiv
TOLOVTwv, etiTep ael keyovTos VTTeîp\eTaL are hr] piov;
2X2. Ti he Ttepl aio-^j/o-eo)? epovfxev oTTOiaaovv, olov Trjs
Tov opav rf aKoveLv; fxevcLV ttot ev avTSt rw opav rj aKoveiv; e
0EO. OvKOvv bel ye, eXiTep TTavTa /cizêirat.
2X2. Ovre apa Spav TTpoarprjTeov tl fxaXkov r] p.r] opav,

ovbe TLV akkqv aLadrjo-LV fxakkov r] fxr], iravTOiV ye Trdi^rcos
KLVOVfxivoiV. 5
0EO. Ov yap ovv.
2X2. Kat fxrfv alcrOrfo-ls ye ciTLirrqfxr], ws e(f)afxev ey<a re
Koi 0ea^r77ro?.
0EO. 'Hy TavTa.
2X2. Ovbev apa eTTLan^fxrfv fxaXkov r] fx-q eTTLon/ffxrfv 10
aTTKpLvdfxe6a ep(OTu>fxevoL otl iarlv fTTLo-Trffxr],
0EO. 'Eotxare. 183

2X2. KaAoy hv rffxiv avfxâivoL to eiTavopdcofxa Trjs diTO-
KpLcrecDS, TTpoOvfxqdeTcTLV aTTobelâL otl TrdvTa KLveiTaL, tva br]
KLvr] T] diTOKpLa-LS opOr] (pavfj. To b\ bis eOLKev, e(f)dvr], el
TTavTa KLveLTaL, iTdcra aTTOKpLCTLS, iTepl otov dv tls diTOKpLvr^TaL, 5

ofxoLcos 6p6i] etvaL, ovtod t e\eLV (j)dvaL Kal fxr] ovT(a, ei be
ôvkeL, yLyvea-6aL, Xva jxr] (TTrfaoiifxev avTovs rw koyui.

0EO. 'Op6S)S keyeLs.
C 11 \eya)fi(v B d I toGto] r^re T d 2 toiJtoi;] toC T

64 ouSeJ oCre Dissen eg ^v ravra om. T a? avroi/s (sic)
B : a<jrovs T : avrovs Schanz
.
l83'a nAATHNOS
2f2. T]\riv ye, o) oScope, otl " ovro) " re ^Tttov koI
lo ovx ovTO). oet oe ovoe tovto (to) ovto) Aeydv ovde
b yap hv ^TL klvoIto (to) " ourco " ovb' av " fxr) ovTOi "
ovbe yap tovto KLvrja-Ls aWd tlv &kKr\v (f)wvr]v 6(Teov tols
Tov Xoyov TOVTOV \4yova-LV, &)S vvv ye irpos Trjv avTutv vtto-
Oea-LV ovK exowt prjfMaTa, d pLrj &pa to "ovb^ ovrtos" ix6Xia-Ta
5 [8' ovTOis] &v avTOLS appLOTTOL, 6.TTLpov Xeyojxevov.
0EO. OlKeLOTArr] yovv bL(!iX.KTOs avrr] avTols.

2X2. OVKOVV, 0) Q(6b(>}p, TOV T (TOV (TaCpov aTTTjA.-
XayfxeOa, Kal ovttu} (rvyyoipovp.iV avTw irdvT avbpa iTa.VTo)V
C XP'?M<^'^ pLCTpov cTvaL, hv fxrj (f)p6vLfx6s tls 17* CTrtony/xrjv

T aLorOrja-LV ov avyx(opr]a6pL(6a KaTa ye rtjv tov iTdirra
KLvdadai ixidobov, [rj] d ixrj [tl] TTcas oAAws QeaiTrjTOS obf
\4yei.
6 0EO. "ApLo-T (LprjKas, 00 2)wKpaTcs* tovto)v yap Trepav-

6iVT0)V Kal ifxi ebcL aTTr]\X.d\daL aoL dTTOKpLv6fx(vov KaTo. Tas
(Tvv^rJKas, iireibr} t6 iTfpl tov YIpcoTay6pov \6yov TeKos (rÔLr].
0EAI. M^ TTpLV y av, o Qf^bcope, ^^MKpdrqs re /cai a-v
d Tovs (f)da-K0VTas av to TTav cordrai 8tcA07/re, a>o-7rcp u/ari
TTpovdf^rde.
0EO. Neo9 &v, o) QfaCrqTe, tovs TTpea^vTipovs dbLKelv

bLbda-KLS 6/ioAoytas TTapaâivovTas; dWa TTapaaKevdôv
5 6tto)S t5)V iiTLXoLTTCov ô)KpdTi b(aa-is \6yov.
0EAI. ÊdvTTep ye jBovKrfTaL. rjbLO-Ta fxevTav iJKova-a
TTcpl &v Aeyo).
0EO. " 'iTTirias Ls iTebiov " TTpoKaki] 2coKpdr7j eis Aoyouj
TTpoKakovfXdVOS' epo)Ta ovv kcu dKova~r].
10 212. 'AAAd fxoL boK&, o) 0eo8cope, Trepi ye (av KeAeuet
e QeaLTrfTOs ov TTL(rea-daL avTM.
0EO. Tt bi] ovv ov TTiLaeadaL;
a ro-b I rh (bis) &dd. Schleiermacher b 4 ovrais W : Sirwj BT

b5 oStwj (e correctione lectionis ou5' iiras ortum) om.
8' W b6 7*
oiv B: olvT b8 of/jr T oiTta B W 03 ^ om.
: W n del.
Schanz (glossettia fuit IJ t) c6 ftet scripsi : Sf 7 BT
EAITHTOr 1836
Sf2. MeAi(r(ror fxev koI tovs aXXovs, ot ev eoros \4yovcn

t6 TTav, al(rxvv6^V09 ixr] ({)opTLK&s (TK0iT(h\x(V, T]TTOV alfryy-
ro/jtai 77 va ovTa UapiJ.vibriv. napfxevibr^s 8e /Ltoi (paLveTai, 5

t6 tov 'OpLrjpov, " albolos re juot " eirat a/xa " bcLvos re."
(Tvp.TTpocr^p.eLâ yap br] r(S drdpi Trdru reoy Tiavv TTp(a(3rjTr],
KaC jxoL i(j)<xvr] ^ddos tl ^x^^tv TTavTdiTacn yevvalov. (f)ol3ovixaL 184

ovv ixr] ovT To. keyofxeva (rvvLcoixev, tl T bLavooiifXfvos eiTre
TToXv TrXiov XeLTTdfxeda, Kal t6 ]x4yL(rTov, ov eveKa 6 Xoyos
(op]xr]TaL, iTTL(rTr]]xr]s Trept rt Tror' kaTW, a(TKTTT0V yivr]TaL
VTTO T&V iTTeL(TK(ti]Xa(6vT(jOV XoyOdV, (L TLS aVTOLS TTiL^T^TaL' 5
aXXbis re Acat ov vvv (y(Lpo[xev TTXr^deL a]xr]xavov, etre rts kv
TTap4py<a (rK^\}rTaL, ava^C av TTaOoL, etre LKavSis, ]xr]KVv6ixvos
t6 rijs eTTto-rTj/xTjs a(f)avLl. 8et 8e ovbeTepa, aXXa QeaLTr^Tov

S)v Kvel TTfpl e7TL(rTr]ixr]s TTiLpaaOai r^fxas Trj /lateuriK^ '"^X^ ^
OLTToXva-aL.
0EO. 'AAAa XPV> ^^ boKel, ovrco Trotetr.

211. Ert TOLVVV, 0) &aLTr]T, Toa-6vbe Trepi t&v flpr]-
]xiv(i)V iTTL(TKe\l/aL. aX(r6r](rLV yap br] iTTLaTr]]xr]v aTTCKpLVco' 5
V yap;
0EAI. Nat.
2X2. Et ovv TLS oê c58' epcorwrj* "T(o rd AeuKa Kai fxeXava
opq avdp(i)TT0s Kal rw rd 6^4a /cat /3a/>e'a dfcovei; " etTTOts av
ot/iat ""OfxixaaL re koX 0)crLV." ^
^^^ \o
0EAI. "Eycoye.
"^1. Td b\ (.v\ep\s TMV dvojxaTcov re fcai prîxaTcov Kal c
fxr] 81 d/cptêtay ^Ta^6ixVov to. piev ttoXXcl ovk ayevvts,
aXXa ixaXXov rd tovtov kvavTLOV aveXevdepov, (o-tl b\ otc
avayKalov, oXov koX vvv avayKi] e7riA.a/3e'(r0at ttjs aTTOKpLo-ecds
r]v aiTOKpLvr], 17 ovk opd^q. (tk6tt(l yap' aTT^KpLo-Ls TTOTepa 5

opdoTepa, (h 6pS)iLiv TOVTO etrat 6(f>6aXixovs, t] bC ov opwixev,
Kal (h CLKovoixev o)Ta, 7/ 81' ov aKOVoixev;
e4 ffKovcifjKyl (TKdiirroDfifp Cornarius bi wv] tiu B Vktti^/itjs

irtpt W b9 Kai Ttt ôpea W
i84C nAATilNOS
0EAI. Ai' <5y (Kaara ala-davofjLfOa, l/xotye So/cei, u>
^(oKpaTcs, fxaWov t) oXs,
d 2X2. Advbv ydp ttov, <J) Trai, ei TToXAa^ riiê? fr ^/xty

u)(nTp (V bovpeCoLS ittttois aio-^Tjo-cis (yKa6r\VTat., aXka fxri
(Is fxCav TLva Ibdav, ut yjrvxv^ ftre otl bd KaX(Lv, na.VTa

TavTa avvTiiviL, r\ 8ia TovTOiv olov 6py6.v(av ala-OavofMeOa
5 oaa aiadr}T(i,.
EAI. 'AAA(i fJiOL boKei owto) fJLaWov rj ^KfLVcos.
2X2. To{58e roi evcKa avTd aoL 8taKpiô{5/iai, ei rtri rjpLoiv
avT&v ro) avT(D 8ia p.ev 6(f)daXfJi6iV ((pLKvovpLfda AeuKwy re

e Koi ixckdvcov, bLOL be t&v aXXcov fTepoiv av TivoiV' kol eêts
p(OT(afXvos TrdvTa tcl rotaura cts to aCip.a dva(f)(pLv; lo-cos
b^ jSekTLOV (Te XeyeLV avTO. aTtOKpLVOfxevov fxaWov rj ifxe
VTTcp aov TToXvirpaypLOveLV. Kai fxoL Aeye* Oepfxa Kal a-KXrjpa

5 Kat Kov(})a Kal yXvKea bC SiV aiaOdvrj, apa ov tov adfxaTos
(KacTTa TLdrfs; rj dXXov tlvos;
0EAI. Ovbevbs dXXov.
2i2. 'H Kat eêATjo-ets ofxoXoyeXv h bC eTepas bvvdfX(as
185 alaOdvrf, dbvvaTOV etvat 81' dXkrfs Taw aicrOiaÔaL, olov a
bC aKorjs, bC o\}/OiiS, rf h bC 6\}/e(tis, bC CLKorjs;
0EAI. ricSs ydp ovk idfXrfaai;

2X2. Et ri dpa TTepl dfxôTepoiv Starof), ovk hv b^d ye
5 Tov (Tepov 6pydvov, ovf av 8ia roiJ (Tepov TTCpl dfxcfiOTdpoiV
ala-OdvoL dv.
0EAI. Ov ydp ovv.
212. riept brf (ficovrjs Kal iTepl xpoas TTp&TOv fxev avTO
TOVTO TTCpl dp.(}iOT(pC0V 7/ bLaVofj, OTL dfX(}iOTp(ii kcTTOV;
lo 0EAI. "Eycoye.
2X2. OvKovv Kal otl kKaTepov kKaTepov fxkv (Tepov, eairro)
be TavTov;
b 0EAI. Tifxrfv;
d 3 8ti] i T d 4 opydvtfi pr. B (ut videtur) d7 rovif]

Tov 5e Bekker d 8 i<piKvov/xf6a] SuKvovfi6a T 64 (t/p^ T
0, l ravr'] ravrtis T : rovrwy vulg. &9 ^ om. W
0EAITHTO2 i85b
212. Kat OTL afX(f)OTp(a bvo, e/cdrepoj; 8e ey;
0EAI. Kat rorTo.

212. OvKOuy Kol eire avofJioCoi etre ojjLoCdo aXXriKoiv,
bvvarbs ci (Tn(rKi\lfacrdai; 5
0EAI. "lo-o)?.
212. Tairra 8^ Trdvra 8ta rtVo? Trept avroti; biavori; ovTe

yap 81' aKOT^s ovt 8t' o\(/(os olov re ro kolvov XapL^dveLV
TTcpl avT&v. TL bc Kal Tobc TeKjxripLOV "Trepi ov keyopLev' et
yap bvvaTov etr/ a[ji.(f)OTep(i) (TK4\lra(T6aL ap' ((ttov a\p.vp(t) r/ ov, 10

oto-^' ort eêts eiTrety w iirLa-K4\l/r], Ka\ tovto ovt 6\j/ls ovt^ c
CLKor} (f)aLVTai, aXXd tl dAAo.
0EAI. Tt 8' ov /jte'AAet, 17 ye 8ta rr/s y\(oTTr]$ bvvafXLs;
2X2. KaAws Ae'yets. rj 8e 8t/ 8id rtvos bvvap.Ls t6 t eTrt
Trdo-t KOLVov KOLL To e-JTt TovTOLS St/Aoi oôi, fa) ro " eoTty " 5
eTTOiôjLidêt? /cat to " ovk eoTt " Kot h vvvbii rjpooTQiJiev
irept avTiov; tovtols 7rdo"t Troia dTro^&jo-et? 6pyava bC (av
alcr6dvTaL r}p.Q)v to aicr6av6p.(vov (Kaara;

0EAI. OvaCav Ae'yets xat to /i^ etrat, Kat 6p.0L6Tr]Ta
Ka\ dvo[xoL6Tr]Ta, Ka\ t6 tovtov re Kot [to\ Tepov, tl 8e 10

(V re Kat tov aXkov dpL6p.ov Trept avrcov. brjXov 8e ort d.
Kat dpTLov re Kai irepLTTbv (pooT&s, Ka\ raAAa ocra tov-

TOLS eTTCTaL, 8id tCvos TTore Toiv tov crcoixaTos rf/ ^jrvxi)
ala-6av6p.e6a.
212. ^Tiripev, S) QeaCTr]T, dKoAouêts, Kat eortf d epcorcii 5
avrd TavTa.
0EAI. 'AAAd ixa ACa, S) ^WKpares", eycoye ouk dv
expLfXL etTrety, TrAr/y y' ort /xot boKL ti]v dpx^fv ovb^ eirat
rotorroy oii8ey rourots' opyavov tbLOV (Zcnrep (KeCvoLS, dAA'
avrri bi avrfjs rj ^/n;^^ tcl KOLvd fxoL (f)aCvTaL Trept irdvTCDV e
eTrto-KOTreti'.
2X2. KaAos ydp et, w 0eatTT/re, Kat ovx> ^^s^ eAeye
b6 YircDy ircos W b ro a.fx<poTepa) revera B W : ifKpoTfpus T

e6 Kol &W: & BT rip'jyToi>/j.ef irpwTCfi TW: /xev B C lO t6
om. W d.9 opyauoy iSiov} opyavtSiov B i airavTW W
iSse nAATONOS
Qeobiopos, at(T)(fi6s' 6 yap koAo)? ktyaiv Ka\6s . re Kal
5 ayad6s. iTpbs 8e tw KaA.a> ev (TroCr]a(i.s fif fid\a av\vov \6yov
cnraXXaâs, el (fiatvcTaC croi ra fj.ev avTT} 8i' avTTJs rj yfwxr]
(7n(TK0TT(iv, TCL 8 8ta rcSi' tov crdfxaTos bvvapLi(av. tovto yap
^jv h Kal avT(a poi eSoKei, kôv\6fXTi)v 6e Koi ao\ h6âi.,
l86 0EAI. 'AAAa pr\v (ftaCveTai ye.
212. YIoTp(ov ovv Tid-qs Ti]V ovcriav, tovto yap fx6iKiara

6771 TfavTuiV TTapeVerai.
0EAI. 'Eyo) fikv S>v avTTf rj yirvxv âd^ avTr]V kiropiyeTai.
5 212. 'H Kai To ofxotov Kal to av6fxoi,ov Kal t6 Tairrov Kal

(Tpov;
0EAI. Nai'.
212. Ti 8e; KaA.w Koi ala-xpbv koI ayaObv Kai KaKov;

0EAI. Kal TovTcov fxoi 8oKet kv roty fxakicrTa Tcpbs
jo aAArjAa o-KOTreio-âi Tr]v ova-iav, avaXoyiCppivr] ev kavTf] to.
b yeyov^Ta Kal to. Tiap6vTa irpbs to. fiiiWovTa.

212. "Exf 8^* aAAo ri roi! fxev a-KXr]pov Tr]V aKkqpoTr^Ta
hia Tr]s iTTa(jir]s alcrdr](rTai, Kal tov fiaXaKOV Tr]v pLakaKorr^Ta
tixravTois;
5 0EAI. Nat.
212. Tr]v 8e ye ovaiav kcu oti kaTbv Kai Tr]V kvavTi&rqTa
TTpbs dAAT/Aco Kat ti]V ovaiav av Trjs ^vavTi^rqTOs avTr] f]
v/^DX^ e7raz;toSo-a Kat crvfiliaXXovcra Trpbs aAAr/Aa Kpivnv

Tretparai rîxiv.
10 0EAI. Ylavv fxkv ovv.
212. OvKovv TCL fxkv v6vs yV0fXV0is TTapeoTi, (f)va-(i
C ato^^ciiêa-ât ovdpdiTTOis re Kai 6r]piois, ocra 8ia tov o-wjuaros
Tia^rffxaTa eTTi Tr]v V"^X^/^ retyet* to. 8e 77e/Jt rovrooj; ava-
XoyicrfxaTa Trp^s re ovcriav kcu (oêAetai' fxoyis koI iv XP'^^'^

bta TToX.kS)V TTpayfxaT(t)V Kal TTatbeias TTapayiyv(Tat ols av koI
5 TTapayiyvrjTat;
0EAI. narrcxTrao-t fxkv ovv.
e7 iirt(rKOirov(Ta W a5 Koi rh irtpoy W b9 Ttipao-flo* T

EAITHT02 l86c
212. Olov T ovv aXrjO^Las TV)(êlv, w fJ-rjbe ovcrias;
0EAI. 'AUvaTov.
212. Ov b\ aki]6iias ris aTvxri<Tii, TroTe tovtov (TTicmfiiJLCov
iCTTaL; lO
0EAI. Kai TiGiS av, SwKpaTes; d

212. 'Ey /xey a/oa tocs Ttadrifxaa-iv ovk evi, kTna-Trnxri,
(V 8e Tw Trepi (KeCviov OT;AAoyio-/jia)* o{/o-tas yap /cat dAr;-
deCas kvTavda \xiv, wy eoi/ce, 6uraToy aâcrOai, e/cet 8e

aSwaToy. 5
0EAI. <J>aiyeTat.
212. 'H ovv TavTov kK^lvo Te ai tovto KaAets, ToaavTas
bta(})opas (xovTc;
0EAI. OvKovv bri bCKaiov ye.

212. Tt ovv 8t) eKiCvio aTTobCbais ovoyLa, rw opai; aKoveti' lo
6(T(\)paCvi(Tdai \lrv\(rdaL 6(pfj.aCv(rdaL;
0EAI. Ato-âzêo-ât iyioyv tC yap aXKo; e

212. ^vpiirav &p' avTo KaAeis aCcr6r](TLv;
0EAI. 'ArayKij.
212. ^'lî ye, (f)ap.iv, ov fj,T(rTLV dAjjêtas a\lra(T6aL' ovbe
yap oixrCas. 5
0EAI. Ov yap ovv.

212. Ovb^ ap' k'nL(TTr]p.r]s.
0EAI. Ov yap.
212. OvK ap^ av etT/ Trore', o) 0eatTTjTe, atcrOr^^TCs re /cat
kTtLCTTr^p.r] TavTov. lo
0EAI. Ov (f)aCvTaL, o) ^(oKpaTs. Kal /xaAiard ye t-w
KaTa(f)av(TTaTov y^yovev dAAo w atcr^T/o-ecos TTLCTTr]]jur].
212. 'AAA' ov Tt ]xkv bi] TovTov ye veKa r]p^6p.da bta- 187

Aeyc^/xeyoi, tra evpa)/x.ey rt TroT' ov/c eor' kTTL^rrqixr], dAAd ri
iCTTLv. op.(t)S 8e TocrotrroV ye iTpoê^r^Kajxev, w(tt ]xi] ^T/rety
avTi]V v al(rd/](TL to TTapaTtav dAA' er KCv(o tw 6v6]xaTL,
07 ^] o5 Heindorf 09 o5 Se T : ouSe B sed rasura supra v

d 6-7 (paiverai % oC; ToiiTtJv, B d. 7 tovto] Taiirh T : TO^Tii' B
d9 5),] &v5J?T
iSya nAATXlNOS
5 oTi TTOT exei rj
^XV> ^tov avrrf KaS* axrn\v TrpaynaTfvrjrai,
TTCpl TO. OVTa.
0EAI. 'AAAa prjv tovto ye KoXeiTat, o} Sw/cpaTf?, ws

lyîiai, boâ^HV.
212. 'OpdS)s yap oUi, S <^tXe. Kal opa brj vvv ttoXiv i^
b apxrjs, TrdvTa to. iTpoa-dfv iâkdyjfas, cf ri pJaWov Ka6opq<i,
iiTeibr} kvTavOa TTpoeKrjXvOas, koi Xeye avOis tC ttot ka-TU>
fTTLO-Tripr].
0EAI. Aoâv pV iTaa-av Itt(iv, w ScoKpare?, dbvvaTov,
5 (TTi,br} Kal \l/vbris iari boâ' KLvbvvevei bc fj dXr]6i]s boâ

iTTia-Tijpr] eTvat, KaC /xoi tovto dTT0KKpCa-6(o. iav yap /m^
(f)avfi TTpoXova-iv cSo-Trep to vvv, 5.\Xo tl iTLpaa6p6a \eyeLV.

212. OvTM pivTOL XPV> ^ ea^TT/Tc, Aeyeiv TTpo6vpMs
pjdXKov, 7) ws To 7TpS)Tov (i)KVLS diTOKpCvcaâL. iav yap
C ovTOi bpcapev, bvoLV 6dTpa, ^ (vprjaopcv i(f) o ipyopeOa, t/
r]TT0V olr]a6pe6a ilbivai 6 pr]bapr\ lapev KaCTOi ovk ^v dt]

pepTTTos ptadbs 6 tolovtos. Kal 8t/ Kal vvv tC (j>fis; bvolv
ovTOLV IbdaLV b6^r]s, tov pev dX.r]dLvov, \j/evbovs 8e tov eTepov,
6 Tr]V dXr]6i] b6âv lTTLaTr]pr]v opC^r];
0EAI. "Eyoiye* tovto yap av vvv poL (paCveTaL.

212. 'Ap' ovv T d^Lov TTepl b6^s dvaXajBelv TrdXLV
0EAI. To TTolov 8t/ keyeis;
d 212. @pdTTL pe TTCiiS vvv T Kal ÂAoTe br] TToXXaKLS,
&aT iv diTopCcL ttoAAt/ iTpos ipxLVTOv K<xi TTpos aXXov yeyo-

vevaL, ovK iypvTa elTTew tC ttot i^rrl tovto t6 TTados irap'
7]p.LV Kaix rCva TpdiTov iyyLyv6pevov,
5 0EAI. To TTOLov 8t/;
212. To bo^dCeuf tlvo. êvbrj. o-kottS br] Ka\ vvv hi
bLardQav, iT^Tcpov ida^capev avTO t/ iiTLaKe\{f(>pe6a aAXov
TpdiTov r] okCyov iTp^Tepov.
0EAI. Ti p.r]v, o) 2<oKpares, eXiTep ye kox ottt/tiow âi-
bsôm. W c4 ZSfoJi' BT W : f/5o' vulg. c6 fioi

yDv W d7 idffonfi/ . . . i-KiaKfr\i6nfea T d 9 birpTiovv scripsi
(coll. Apol. 35 b) : &iniyovv B : 0*77 yov W : jjrpowy T
0EAITHTOS i87d
vcrai helv; apri yap ov KaKois ye (tv Kal eoScopos eAeyere lo
o-;(oA^s Trepi, b>s ovbev V tols roioio-Se /careTretyei.
212. 'Op6o)s v'!Tp.vr$ras' Xcrois yap ovk a~6 Kaipov 7rd\LV e

axTTTep Lxvos ixeTekOelv. KpiLTTOv yap irov a-p.LKpbv v i] ttoX.v
fj.ri LKavois Trepavai.

0EAI. Ti fMTiv;
212. riws ovv; tC brj Kal \4yofiev; yfrevbrj (f)aixev kKacTTOTi 5

LvaL boâv, KaC Tiva rjfxiav bo^dêiv yjrevbrj, tov 8' av dXr]67],
o)? (pva-L ovToos kypvTdiv;

0EAI. âp.\v yap br].
212. OvKovv Tobe y (r6^ rjpuv Trepi TrdvTa Kal Ka6' i88
KaaTov, TjTOL eibevaL r] ju^ elbevaL; p.av6dveLV ydp koll
TTLkav6dvecr6aL iJ.Ta^v tovt(dv ws ovTa yaipeLV Aeyco kv roi
TTapovTL' vvv yap r][XLV Trpos koyov iaTLV ovbev.

0EAI. 'AAAa [xriv, a> 2ci)/cpares, aAAo y ovbev keLireTaL 5
Trept eKaa-Tov T:ki]v elbevaL r] fxr] elbevaL.
212. OvKovv Tjbr] dvdyKT] tov bo^dQiVTa bo^dêLV rj dv tl
olbev 7] fxr] oTbev;

0EAI. 'AiâyKTj.
2.12. Kai ixr]v etOora ye jxr] eioeiâi to avro rj fxr] (LboTa lo
elbevaL dbvvaTOV. b
0EAI. USis 8' oii;
212. 'Ap' ovv 6 To. \j/evbrj bo^d^div, h otbe, Tavra oierat

ov TavTa eTvaL dXXa eTcpa drra &v oXbe, koX dfx($6Tepa etScos
dyjôet av dp(f)6Tpa; 5
0EAI. 'AAA' dbvvaTov, S) 2criKpare?.
212. 'AAA' dpa, b. fxr] olbev, r^yelTaL avra elvaL erepa
drra Siv fxri otSe, Kai tovt ecrrt r<S /UT^re QeaLTr\Tov p.riT
^coKpdTr] eiSoVt eis Tr]v bLdvoLav kajBelv u)S 6 2coKp(ir7/s
êairrjros rj [6] 0eatrTjros 2cok/3CXT7;s; io

0EAI. Kat TTws az^; C
e5 Til eri W a I toCtJ 7' ^(TtIj' W a3 Ae^so] Xiyofjifv W

b 4 f Ij/oi] flSfvai W b 5 a5 W
om. : BT b9 jS^^to W
b 10 6 om. T
PLATO, VOL. I. 21
i88c nAATX2N02
2f2. 'AAA' ov ixTjV, d ye tis oTbev, oUraC tiov h /x^ oTb(v
avra elvai, ovb^ av a /x^ otbev, h olbev.

0EAI. Tepa? yap corat.
5 Si2. riajy ovv hv iTi \lrvbrj bo^da-eiev; iKTOs yap TOVTuiv

abvvaTov ttov bo^dCîv, ^TretTrep Trdvr rj la-fxfv ri ovk ta-fxfv,
iv 8e TovTois ovbafxov (fâCveTai bvvaTov \f/vbrj bo^d<rai.

0EAI. 'AAr/êWara.
212. Ap' ovv ov TavTr) <rKCTTT(ov o CrjTovixiv, Kara to
d elbevai Kal ix-q elbevai. iovTas, dXXd Kara to ctrat Kai ixij;
0EAI. nws Aeyeis;

212. Mt) aTrAoi5i' fi
oti 6 to. fxri ovra irfpl otovovv bo^dCuiv
ovK â-ff' 0)5 ov \lrcvbrj bo^dad, k^v OTTcaaovv oAAo)? tcl ttjs
5 biavoLas ^XV'
0EAI. EtKoy y' av, S) 2,(aKpaTs.
212. Yla)S ovv;

S) QeaCrqTe, idv tls ^/xas
tI ipovixev,
dvaKpCinf " AvvaTov bc oTtoovv o A^yerat, Kai rts dv6pit>TTU)V

t6 ixt] ov Soâcret, eire Trept tQ>v ovTOiv tov efre avro KaO^
lo avTo;" Kal 7//xets 8j/, ws olkV, Trpos TavTa (f)i]aoiXV'
" Otov
e ye /a^ dA)/^?/ otr/rat ol6p,vos'" r] Tri^s (povixev;
0EAI. OvTos.
2X2.'H ow /cat oAAo^t ttov to tolovtov kaTLv;
0EAI. To Trotor;
5 212. Ei ri? 6pq /xe'v ri, 6p& b\ ovbev.
0EAI. Kat TTcSs;
212. 'AAAa ixr]v eZ ev y^ ri opa, rwr ovT(av tl opq. rj <ri
otei TTOTe To kv kv toIs ixr] ovaLV etzâi;
0EAI. OvK iyioyc.

lo 212. 'O dpa v yk tl 6pa>v 6v tl 6pq,
0EAI. *I>aircrat.
e3 & oJStv om. B C 5 &v] iv Tii B C6 ireJyr' ^}] irdt^ri B :
Trivra T : irdvra f) W C 9 b ^rirovfifv'^ ^Cvrovfitv B d. i cli/ai]

tj5*VaBT deyi^ciDW d8 5i] Si; Heindorf A^Tt
Buttmann d 10 8^] 5 W e i diAvdTJ /i^ T e 5 r tij]
^ ris Heindorf e 8 tJ iv] iyT-.rhivVf e 10 6y] iy B
0EAITHTO2 iSga
SI2. Kat 6 apa tl aKOV(ov fv yi tl aKova Kal ov âxovet]. 189

0EAI. Nai.
212. Kat 6 a-nroixevos bri tov kvos yk tov aTrrerat Kai
orTos, et7r6/3 eiô?;
0EAI. Kat TOVTO. 5
2i2. 'O 8e 8^ loiaC<s>v ovx ^v yk tc boidCu;

0EAI. 'AvdyKT}.
2X2. 'O 8' v TL ho^dCoyv ovk ov tl;
0EAI. 2iryxwp&).
212. 'O dpa fxi] ov bo^dCoiV ovbfv So^dêi. 10
0EAI. Ov (âtzêrai.
212. 'AXAa p.i]v ye /UTjStr bo^dCcav t6 TTapdirav ovbk

bo^dCeL.
0EAI. AriX.ov, o)? olkV.
212. OvK dpa olov Te t6 ixt] ov bo^dCî-v, ovre Trepi tQv b

OVTOJV OVT aVTO Kad^ aVTO.
0EAI. Ov (\)aLVTaL.
212. "AA-Ao Tt ap' eo-Ti t6 xlrevbrj 8odêty tov tcl fxr] ovTa
bo^dCfLV. 5
0EAI. "AAAo eotKey.
212. OiIt' dp' ovTws ovT ws oXCyov irpoTepov (a-KOTTOVfxfv,
\//ev87js eoTi 8da kv ripXv.

0EAI. Ov ydp ovv 817.
212. 'AAA' dpa wSe yLyvofxevov tovto Trpocrayopevoixev ; 10
0EAI. ndJy;
212. 'AAAo8o^tay Tii^d ovarav yf/evbT] âjuey etyat boâv,
oTav Tts <(ti^ twv ovtoov dAAo ail Twy ovtwv dvTaWa^dixevos C
tt) bLavoCa (^fj etiât. out<o ydp oy juey det 8o^dêt, (Tepov
8e di^d' iTkpov, k<u dfxapTdvwv ov la^KomL bLKaCcos dv KoAotTo
yl/vbrj bo^dCav.
a I iv] ov Ti W aKovfi seclusi a3 6] 6 t1 W toi;] ttow B

a4 ovTos] 6vTos airrerai vulg. a6 ye W : om. BT o6t
Ib 7
&p' Heusde ov yap BT hg olv^ ov B b 10 post wSe add.
W
:
avrh C i ti om. BT
21*
iSgc nAAT12N02
5 0EAI. OpOoTaTOL fxoL vvv boKfls (lpr]Kvai. oTav ykp
rts avTl Kakov al(r)(j)6v 17 avTi, al(r\pov Kakbv bo^dî], TOTe
&)S dXrjdias 8o^d^fi \l/vbi].
212. AÂos 1, S) eatrT/re, KaTa(^povS)V p,ov Kal ov

bebL(os.
10 0EAI. Ti ixdKKTTa;
212. OvK av oi/xat o-oi boKot tov d\r]6Qs \j/evbovs dvTi-
d \aê(r0aL, ipofxfvos fl oTov re Ta\v jSpabeoos rj koxxôv
âpedis rj dWo tl evavTLOV ixr] KaTo. rqv avTov (f)V(TLV dWa
KaTCL Tr]v Tov evavTLov yCyvecrdaL eavrcp ivavTLcos. tovto
fxkv ovv, tva fxr] fxdrqv Oapp-qcrps, d(^Lr]]XL. dpda-Kei b4, (os
5 (f^fis, To TCL yfrevbrj bo^dêLV dWobo^dv eivat;
0EAI. "E/xotyc.
2i2. 'EoTtr &pa KaTa Tr]v a~r]v boâv (Tepov ri ws irfpov

Kal jxr] u)s KLVo Trj bLavoLci TiOicrOaL,
0EAI. "Eo-rt ]x4vT0L.

e 2X2. "Orai' ovv tovO^ t] bidivoiA tov bpq, ov koL dvdyKr]
avTr]v rjTOL dfx^ôT^pa r] to eTcpov bLavoeXa-daL;
0EAI. ÂvdyKr] ]XV ovv 7/rot fi/xa ye r] ev ixipeL.
212. KdAAtora. to b\ bLavoiLo-dai 2lp Srrfp eyo) KaAeis;
6 0EAI. Tt KaAwi';
212. Adyoi" ov aM] Ttphs avrqv rj yf/vxr] bL^(p\Tai Trcpl
&v hv (TKOTTfi. u)s ye ]xr] clbds ctol drrocfâLVOfxaL. tovto ydp

/xot ZySdAAerat bLavoovpLivr] ovk dAAo rt 7/ 8taAe'yeo-0at, avn/
190 kavTr]v (pa)TU)(Ta koll dnoKpLVOfxivr], koX (f)d(rKova-a Ka\ ov
<f)da-Kova-a. oTav bk dpia-acra, efre ^pabvTcpov eire xai
o^VTepov f-nqâa-a, to avro r]br] (f^fj kol fxr] bLord^r], boâv
TavTrjv TL6e]X(v avTrjs. u>a-T (yu^ye t6 bo^d^fLV \4yLV Ka\(a
5 Kai Tr]v boâv \6yov iLpr]]xivov, ov fxivTou TTp6s dWov ovbi
(Pu)Vj], dAAd o-tyTJ Trpos avTov crv 8e ri;
0EAI. Kdyi.
d7 post tnpov alterum add. ti T 63 fi/ia] oAAek T a4 t9-

fktda Badham
:
0EAITHTO2 igoa
2f2. "Orav apa tls t6 Tepov eTepov bo^dCri, kcI (p-qaCv,
cb? eOLK, TO TepOV iTpOV itvai TTpOS kaVTOV,

0EAI. Ti fjL-qv; b
212. ^ Ava\j.iixvr\(TKov hj] d TTWTtOT etTTfs Trpos a-eavTov oti
'navTos pmXXov t6 tol Ka\bv al(T\p6v ((ttlv t] to abLKOv

bUaLOV. rf Kai, to tt^jlvtoov K(f)(x\aLov, (tkottcl ci ttot CTre-
\Lpr](ras (reavTov Treiêir o)? TravTos /xaAAoy t6 eTepov eTepov 5
ecTTLV, rj TTav tovvovtlov ovh^ kv VTTVca TrcoTTore iToXfxricras
(LTTLV TTp6s (TCaVTOV 0)? TTaVT(iTTa(rLV Upa TO. TTepLTTCL apTLa

k(TTLV 1} TL aXKo TOLOVTOV.
0EAI. 'AXrjOi] Aeya?.
212. "AAAoy 8e TLva oUl vyLaCvovTa r] pLaLvojxevov ToXfj.rj(TaL C
(TTTOvbri TTp6s kaxjT^v diT^lv avaTTeCOovTa avT6v cjs avdyKT] t6v
j3ovv LTTTtov elvaL r] tcl bvo ev;
0EAI. Ma Af ovK eyojye.
212. OvKovv ei t6 KeyeLV Trp^s eavT6v bo^dC^LV ^(ttlv, 5
ovbels dpL(p6Tpd ye Ae'ycov Kal Soâ^coi' [Kal] i(f)aTTT6p.ivos
d]J.(f)olv Trj "^XV (^TÔL dv Kal bo^d(rLv ois t6 eTepov Tep6v

icTTLV. kaTeov 8e koX (to\ t6 prjfia [Trept tov erepou]' Ae'yco
ydp avT6 TTjSe, p.r]b4va bo^dC^LV o)? ro al(rxp6v Kak6v rj aAAo d
ri rciii; tolovtcov.
0EAI. 'AAA', o) 2()/<pares, ecS re Kat /xot 8oKet ct)? Ae'yet?.
212. 'A/xcâ) iJLiv dpa bo^dôvTa dbvvaTov t6 ye erepov

fTepov bo^dCiLV. 5
0EAI. "EotKei;.
212. 'AAAa fj.r]v t6 Tp6v ye ]i6vov bo^dCoiV, to 8e Tpov

fj.r]ba]j,fi , ovb4iTOT bo^daeL t6 eTepov Tpov eiiâi.
0EAI. 'AAtj^^ Ae'yets* dvayKdCoLTO ydp dv (pdTTTcrdaL

Kal ov fj.r] 8o^dêi. lo
b 2 fatnhv W et mox b4 fiiroT' T

koI post
: fr' B c6
Soâ^wy om. T C 8 Se Kal] 5' post pTJfia
etrToi Campbell
adci. B îrJ ricv iv fJLfpa, iireiSij rh ^Jjjuo erf pov Ttf fTfpcj) KaTo. I)rifj.a TavrSv
fffTiv haec tuentur Badham Schanz al. omisso prjfj.a priore et mox
:
vfpl Tov fTfpov iv Ty fifpfi Archer Hind

: d.4 ro yt Heindorf
ToTe B T<J * T
:
igod nAATilNOS
212. OvT* ap afX(j)6Tpa ovtc to trepov bo^dCovTi kyyuipii
e dWohoêiv. ot' d riy opietrai hoâv etvai xj/fvbrj t6
(Tepoboîv, ovbev av kiyoi' ovt yap TavTr) ovTf. KaTO, to,
TTpoTepa (ftaCveTai \j/(vbr]s iv fjiuv ovca boâ.
0EAI. OVK OLKV.
5 212. 'AAAa fiiVTOi, 0} QeaCrrjTe, ei tovto p.r] (f)airr}a-(Tai

ov, TToWd dvayKaa-6r]a-6p.da dp.oXoy{i,v kox aTOTia.
0EAI. Ta TToXa bri;
212. OvK ip(a croi irplv dv Travraxr] TreipaOoi (tkott&v.
al(r)(yvoi]xr]v ydp dv vTrep r]]x5>v, Iv w dTTopovfxev, dvayKaô-
191 ijl4v(v 6p.o\oy{iv oXa Aeyoo. dAA' tdv ivpoiiiiv Ka\ ikevdfpoi
yev(ap.da, t6t ijbt] iTfpl tQv dWcov (povfjiev ots TTa^ryovTCDV
avTa eKTos tov yeXoCov ccrrcires* edv be TTavTr] dTTopr]a-(ji]iev,
TaTTeiv(ti9dvTs oijuai rJi Aoyw iTapeôfiev ws vavTiiavTes

5 TTaTelv re koX xpr](rdai ort dv ôvkr]TaL. i] ovv eri iT^pov
TOfd evpCa-KOi tov ^r]Tr]]xaTOS rjjxlv, aKOve.
0EAI. Aeye fx^vov.
212. Ov ({)r](roi f]jxds opOois ofxokoyrja-ai, r]vCKa w/xoAoy?;-
a-a]xev d rts oTdey, dbvvaTov bo^d(Tat d p.i] olbev eTvai. avTa
b Kat yj/eva-diivaf dAAa tttj bwaTov.
0EAI. 'Apa Ae'yets o xai eyo) rcJre V7r<tf7rrev(ra, f]vCK
avTo e^pafxev Tot,ovTov etvai ori IvCot' iyoi ytyvioa-Kcov

2a>Kparr;, mppcoOev be 6pa>v dAAoy ov ov yLyvda-KO), to-qOjjv
5 etyat 2c)KpdrTj ov oTba; yCyveTat ydp bi] ev rai TOLOVT(a

olov KeyeLs.
2f2. OvKOvv dTreo-nyjuey avroiS, ort d la-fxev eiToCeL f]]xds
eiSoVas ]xi] elbevat;

0EA1. Yldvv ]xev ovv.
10 212. P.Ij; ydp ovTO) TL6a>]xev, dAA' c58e* tcrcos ttj] f]]XLV
C o-yyâ)p^<Terat, tcrcos 6e dj^treyet. dAAd ydp ev tolovt(d

e\6]xeda, ev St dvdyKTf TToirra ]xeTa(TTpe(f)OVTa koyov âa-avl-
d 1 1 ri] Ty W a 3 avri] avrwc W : aurol Ast : avrS. ovtoI Hcin-

(Jorf b 10 Kol ante Xcrais add. T c i ^kt^ roiowy T C a ^f
^] y^ B /ictrr^ Tpi<povTa. T
0EAITHTO2 igic
êir. (TKOTrei ovv et t\ k4y(o. apa eoTiy fxi} (Ibora tl
irpoTepov v(TTpov pLa0Lv;

0EAI. "Eo-ri pivTOL. 5
212. OvKovv Ka\ avOis Tpov Kal Tpov;

0EAI. Ti' 8' ov;
211. 0es 877 /Ltot koyov VKa V raiy ^vxo.'^^ rjfjLS>v evbv
KrfpLVov Kpiayiov, rai p.V /xei^r, ra) 8' ^karrov, Ka\ rw
juei' Ka6ap(OTpov Krjpov, rai 8e KOTTpcabâr^pov, Ka\ crKkr]- 10
poTepov, ivLOLs 8e vypoTpov, ^cttl 8' oiy /xerptws \ovtos. d

0EAI. Tt^rj/xt.
212. A&pov Toivvv avrb (f)Qp.v eirai rTjs roiy Mouo-wy
p.r]Tpbs Mvr}po(rvvr}s, Ka\ ei? roOro ori az' j3ovXr]6u)pV p-vrf-
pLOVV(raL b)V av tbcdpev ?/ aK0V(r(iipLV rj avTo\ VVor]a(i)p.V, 5

VTtixpvTas airrb rats al(T6r](T(TL kol kvvoiaLS, aiTOTVTrov(rdai,
U)cnrp baKTv\L(ov crr^p^Za ivarjpaLVopivovs' Ka\ o p.V av
Kpayfj, pvr]pLovVLV T Ka\ TTL(rTaa-6aL ecos av ivr] Tb
Lb(j)Xov avTov' b 8' hv âXL<f)6r] r] fxr] olov re yvr]TaL
Kpayr]vai, T:Lkkr]a-6aL T Ka\ p.i] TtL(TTaa6aL. e
0EAI. Eo-rcri ovT(i)s.
2X2. 'O TOLVvv 7r LcrTdpLvos p,v avrd, (tkottcov 8e rt wz'

opa 1] aKovL, a6pL ei apa roiwSe TpoiTâ \}/vbr] av bo^dcrai.
0EAI. riota) bi] tlvl; 5
2X2. A otSei', otrjêt? etyat tot pv h ot8e, tot 8e

a pr]. TavTa yap V tols 7Tp6a6V ov Kakios u)]xokoyi]cra]XV
6pokoyovvTs dbvvaTa.
0EAI. Nw 8e tto)s Xe'yeis;
2X2. Aet cS8e kycr6aL Trept avTdv e^ dpxpjs 8toptô- 192

pVovs OTL o ]iV TLS olb^v, crxo)V avTov pvr^p^lov V rf/
^vxrj, alcrddvTaL 8e avrb fxr], olr]6r]vaL Tp6v tl 5)V oibV,

XovTa Ka\ KLV0V tvttov, alcr6av6pVov 8e pi^, dbvvaTov.
C rO Kol (TK\T]pOTfpOV OITl. W d 5 &J/ OtTl. T tliai/J.(V B aKOVW-

ufv BT d.6 uwfxovTe W : vvfxovTfs vulg. dg & 5' &j' bW :
oTav B oT&i/ 5^ T
: a2 crxtiiv BT ex'^" ^ ^ 3 ante oirjdTjvai
W
:
add. TovTO B t] Tt rvai W tt 1 alaOavofifos

igaa IIAATIINOS
5 Koi 6 ye oTbev av, olrjdrjvai. (Tvai, 6 /x^ otSe î-qb* cx^' avrov
a-(f)paylba' Kal o fxr} oTbev, o ^rj olbev av' koi o ît] oldev,
o oTbe' Kal b ala-OavcTaC ye, iTepov n &v aio-ôrcTat
olr]6r]vaL eTvai' Kal b ala-dav(TaL, (av tl fxr] aladaveTai' koL
b 1X1] ala-daviTai, &v [xr] ala-6dvTaL' Kal 6 fxr] ala-divfraL,
b)V ala-ddveTaL. Kal (tl ye av Kal b oi8e Kal aladdveTaL Kal
eXft To a-r]]XiL0V KaTa Tr]v atadrâLV, olr]6rjvaL av iTp6v rt
&v oTbe Kal aladdveTaL Koi I[x.L av Kal iKeCvov to ar]]xeLOV
5 KaTO. Tr]V aLadrâ-LV, dhvvaT<i)Tepov tl iKLV(av, tl olov re.

Kcu b ot8e Kat [6] ala-6dveTaL eyoiv to jxvr^fxe^Lov 6p6^s, b
oTbev 0Lr]6r]vaL dbvvaTov kol b otSe cai aicr^cifcrat (xov
C KaTCL TavTa, 6 ala-ddveTaL' Kal b av ]xr] otSe ixr]be ala6dv(TaL,
b [xr] oTbe [xr^be aia6dvTaL' Kal 6 fxr] oi8e /xr;8e ala6d-
rerai, o [xr] oTbc Kal 6 [xr] oTbc [xr]be ala6dvTaL, 6 [xr]
ala-6dvTaL' TrdvTa TavTa VTTepjidXkeL dbvva[XL(i tov (v

5 avrots ^l/evbrj TLva bo^dcraL. AetTrerat br] kv toIs TOLolabe,
LTTp TTOV dXXo^L, TO TOLOVTOV yVa6aL.
0EAI. 'Ei' rtVt br']; iav apa i^ avT<av tl [xdWov [xdda>'
vvv [Xv yap ovx ^Tto[xaL.
212. 'Ev ois oT^V, olr]6r]vaL avTO. Tp aTTa etvat Siv
lo otSe KOL ala6dvTaL' rj (av /xj) otSei', aLa6dvTaL bi' t/ S)v
d ot8e Kai atcrâyerat, S>v oTbev av Ka\ ala6dvTaL.

0EAI. Nw TTOXV irXioV dTTkL(f)6r]V 7/ t6t.
212. îlbe br] dvdiTaKLV aKOV. iyu) ibu)S &6b(opov Kal
V [iavT(o [X[xvrj[xevos ol6s cotl, Kal &aLTr]Tov KaTa Tairrd,
5 aXXo TL VLOT fXV 6/3(3 aVTOVS, VLOT be OV, Kal dTTTO[XaL JTOT
avTav, TOT 8' ov, Kal aKovo) r) Tiva aXXr]v aLa6r]aLV aia6dvo-
[xaL, TOT 8' aXadrâLV [xev ovbefiLav exo Trepl V[xS)V, [L[xvr\[xaL
be vpjds ovbev rjrrov kol TTLaTa[xaL avTos v [xavT(^;
\) 1 Siv alffddvfrai B koI . \i z Zv al(r6dv(Tai om. B b2 ical

W
. .
6 j/ BT b3 ante ^x*' ^^'^' B i' T (sed utrumque

W
: :
punctis notatum) aSJ aiirh b6 ft secl. Bonitz rh

fivrifiuov . . . b7 ^x'"' o"i- BT: add. B'T marg.in 03 ft m^ o^**
Kol . . . fiij alaOdvfTai om. B C 10 &v] & Ast ds iror
secl. Schanz d8 î/ W : om. pr. BT
0EAITHTOS 1926
EAI. riari; juey ovv. e

212. TovTO TOLVVV Trpa>Tov fjLaOc (av ôvkofMai SrjAwcrat,
oTi lo-Tt fikv a oTbe fj.r] ala-daveaOai,, (tti.v 8e aia-Odvecrdat.
0EAI. 'A\i]dij.
2Ii. OvKovv Kal h ju^ oiSe, TroAAaKt? ji-iey lo-Tt ju7j8e 5
aia-Odvea-Oat, TToWaKts be aia-Odvea-Qai ixovov;

0EAI. "Eo-Ti jcai Tovro.
212. 'I8e St) ^dv TL fjiuXkov vvv kiria-nri. "âyKpdTr]?
et yi,yv(aa-KL &6b(opov Kal QeaLTrjTov, opa 8e firfhiTepov, 193

pjSe aAAr/ ata-drfaLS avTS> Trdpea-TL Trept avT&v, ovk dv ttotc
(V eavT(a bo^dcrLV ws 6 0eatTT;To's eort &e6bu)pos. Xeyoi
TL Tf] ovbev;
0EAI. Nat, dXr}ef} ye. 5
212. ToiJto ixV tolvvv iKeCvoiv irp&Tov ^v Zv ekeyov.

0EAI. 'Hv ydp.
212. Aevrepov tolvvv, otl tov ixev yLyvcoa-Kâv vp.u>v, tov
be p.1] yLyv(aa-K(av, aia-davojxevos be p,r]beTepov, ovk dv iroTe
av oir]6eLr]v ov oXba eZvaL ov [xr] oTba, 10

0EAI. 'Op^ws.
212. TpLTOv be, fxr]beTepov ytyvâcrK^tiv fxrjbe ai(rdav6- b
fxevos ovK av oir^deCrjv bv ]xr] olba eTepdv tlv eTvaL &v [xr]
oTba. Kal TttAAa tcl TrpoTepa TrdvO' e^rjs vdpLLê irdXLV

dKr]KoevaL, ev ols ovbe-noT eyM TrepX (tov Ka\ &eob(apov tcl
\lfevbr] bo^dao}, ovTe yLyvâcTKUiV ovTe dyvoa>v dp.(\)(a, ovTe 5

tov ixev, Tov 8' ov yLyv(iicrK(av /cai Trept aia6-qa-e(ov KaTa
TavTd, ei dpa eirr].
0EAI. "E-TTo/xat.
212. AetTTeTai tolvvv tcl ypêvbr] bo^dcrac ev Tw8e, oTav

yLyv(oa-K(jiV ae Kal &e6boipov, Kal eôiv ev eKeLV(o tw Kr]piv(o 10
oiCTTTep baKTvkioiv a-(f)Q>v dp.<polv tcl ariixela, bLo. p.aKpov kcil C
e3 8x1 W : d)S pr. BT ecrriv Se . ..65 yUTjSe alcrOdyecrOai om. B

a I fl ytyvwffKei W : îriyiyvuxTKei BT iirtl yiyvtiiffKn Ast b6 Ka\
W
:
om. b9 ra] rb Wagner b lo Kr\pi(f W C i dyu</)o?;']
axnoiv B
I93C nAATilNOS
fxi) iKavias opcav a\i(û) TipoOvixrfOG), to olKilov kKarepov (rrj-
fiilov aiiohovi Trj olKcCa oyj/i., ip.pLJ3d(ras Trpocrapfw^rai eis t6
kavTTJs ix^^^' '^^** yivr]Tai drayvwpto-t?, eira TovTOiv iiro-
5 TVx^MV Kal uxriTfp ol fp.itaKiv {mohovixfvoi TrapaWdâi

Tipocrâkui ri\v (KaTcpov oîv irpbs t6 &\X6Tpu)v (rqfjiduv,
fj Kal oTa To. kv rots KaTOTrrpoLs Trjs o\j/e(iiS TTdOr], bfîa eh

d dpL(rTpa fXTappfov(rr]s, tovt^v TraOcov hLap.dpT(a' t6t bi}
(TVfiâLveL fj (Tepobo^La kol t6 xjfevbrj bo^dCfLV.

0EAI. "EoiKe ydp, S) SwKpares. Oavfxa^riMs wy Aeyeis
t6 TrfS bd^rfs Trddos.
5 212. 'Eri TOLWV Kal oTav dfL(ÔTipovs yLyv(o(rK(iiv t6v

fXv Trpos ro) ytyi^wo-Kcti' ato-ûi^cofiat, tov be fxrf, ti]v be
yvGxTLV Tov Tpov jLi?/ KaTOL TTjv al(r6rj(rLV (X'^' ^ ^^ ''*'''
irpoa-Oev ovro)? eXeyov Kal fxov rore ovk ffxdvdavis.

0EAI. Ov ydp ovv.
lo 2i2. Toirro fxrfv tXeyov, otl yLyvcHxrKUiv t6v (Tfpov kol
e al(r9av6fXVos, kol ti]V yvGxTLV KaTO. Tr]v aL(rdr](rLV avrov (X'^^'
ovbeiTOTe otô-erat ctrai avT6v (Tfpov TLva ov yLyv(t>(rKL re

Kat ato-ârerat Kat rr/i; yrwo-ti' av kox kKiivov l^^t KaTO. ri]V
al(r9x](TLv. r]V yap tovto;

5 0EAI. Nai.
212. rTapeAeiTrero be yi ttov t6 vvv Xey^fxevov, (v w 8;/
(f)aixV Tr]v y}/vbrj boâv yLyv(T9aL t6 dp.(f)U) yLyv(o(rKovT.i
194 Kat dp.(f)(t) 6pG)VTa y TLva dWrfv aL(r9r](rLv xorra dfx^fôlv rJj
<rr]fXL(t) fxrf cara TTfV avTov al(rdr](rLV kKdTepov Ix*"' ^^

olov To^6Tr]v (f)avXov UvTa irapaWdâL tov (tkottov Ka\
a.fxapTLV, 8r) Kai \ffiôs dpa (i)v6fxa(TTai.
.s 0EAI. EIk6t(os ye.

212. Kat oTov toiwv rw fxev Trapfj aX(r6r]a-is tQv (rrjficuDV,
C 5 irapaWii^ W C 7 8*|iai th api(rrtpiiy Ast d r fitrwpt-

d8
povar}s Buttmann d6
ry] rh B al<rO<iyoncu B nov]
/10 W d 10 {6) yiyvuiTKuv Hcimôrf rbi'] rb W eahv]
Sy T a I Tw (TTj/ieiw al. Heusde : t^ <rrifi(l(f T : rh ai\nt7ov B
aa rxjjB
0EAITHTO2 igâ
T(3 be firi, t6 bc ti]s aTrovcrrjs al(rd-q(r(os rf] Trapot^CTj irpocr-
apfMocTT], TiavTr] TavTt] xjrevb^Tai 7; Siojôia. Kal kvl \6y(a,
irepl S>v p\v ]xi] olbi rt? p-qb^ (irfjadeTO TrwTTore, oiiK ((ttlv,
&)s eoLK(v, ovT xj/evbe^rdaL gvtc \j/vb7]s boâ, ci rt vvv ^jLieis b

vyies \4yo]Ji(v TTepl be 5iv La]xev re koX aladavoixeda, iv avrols
TOVTOLS (rTp(f)TaL Kal kkLTTTaL T] boâ yf/evbr]^ Kal a.\r]67]S
yLyvo]Xvr], KaTavTLKpv ]x\v kcll KaTO. to evOv tcl oLKela crvv-
ayova-a aTTOTVTT(ap.aTa Kal tvttovs a\r]67]s, eis TrkdyLa 8e Kal 5
CTKOkLa \lrVb7]S.
0EAI. OvKovv KoX&s, S) ScoKpares, Aeyerat;

2X2. "Eri ToCwv Kal Tdbe aKov(ras fxakXov avro epeis. to C
p.v yap raATjê? So^dêti; icaAoV, to be -êvbecrdaL alcryjiov.
0EAI. U5)s 8' ov;

2Ii. TaOra Toiwv (fâcrlv ivdivbe yCyv(rdat. otov fxkv
6 Kr]p6s Tov kv tt) yjrvxrj âdvs re Kat tto\vs kcil Aetos kcil 5
/xerptcos upyaapevos 7], tcl l6vTa 8ta tS)v aicrdt']creci)V, ivo-rj-
paLv6pva eis tovto t6 Trjs ylrvxfjs " Keap," 6 <f)r] "Op.r^pos

aivLTT6p.vos Tr]v Tov KTfpov 6/xoto'r7]ra, t6t fxev Kal tovtols
Ka6apa ra a-qpela fyyLyv6fXva Kal LKavas tov (3a6(rvs \ovTa d
TTo\.v)(^p6vLa re yiyveTaL koll eicrXv ol tolovtol iTpiaTOv fxev
evpa6LS, iTLTa fxv7]fxovs, etra ov iTapaXKaTTOfvcrL tcov aicrd^]-

a-(i)v Ta a-ripeZa akka boâ.(pvaLV akrjdrj. (racf)?] yap koX iv
vpvyjj)pL(i ovTa Ta)^v bLavfxov(rLV em tcl avTcov eKacrra 5
CKfxayela, a 67) ovTa /caAetrat, /cat (ro(pol br] ovtol KakovvraL.
7] OV bOKL (TOL;
0EAT. "TTTpcf)vQs fXV OVV.
2X2. *Oray tolwv kdaLov tov t6 Keap fj,

6 br] kirqveaev e
6 TTaaao(f)os TTOLqrqs, tj OTav KOTrpoibes Kal p.7] Ka6apov tov
KTjpov, 7] vypov a(f)6bpa r] aKkr]p6v,S>v fXv vypov evfxadeZs
fxv, TTLkrfafxovS 8e yiyvovTai, utv 8e aKkr]p6v, TavavTia.
ag /iTjSf 4irt(9tro ^w-pcrdfTO pr B ut videtur (corr. b) /ttrjSe ^<tO(to T :
b 5 Tinrov<ra T W
C 6 wpya(T/j.fvoi Suidas, Timaeus (ipyafffxfvos B T :
07 /c^/) Ast d5 Siavfîouert'] SjajSajVoixrij' ex emend. B ei too

ri j toCto Tb B e a irourcro^s schol. iroj^Ta ao<phs B T :
194 e nAATilNOS
5 ol 86 br] X.6.<nov koL rpaxy At^c58es ri ij yfJ9 rj Koirpov (rvfi-
}xi.ylcn]9 p.TT\(av x.o}rrs a(ra(fi7} ra (Kixayda Xaypvcriv.
a(ra(pTJ be Kal oi ra aKXr]pd' ^ddos yap ovk tvi. da-a(f)rj
195 bk Kal ol ra vypd' xmb ydp tov avyxfla-daL raxv yiyvfrat

diJLvbpd. eav bi Trpos iracri tovtois îr' dWrjkoiV aviXTTcma)-
Kora rj vtto aTcvoxoipCas, (dv tov afiiKpov fi
t6 \lrvxdpiov,
CTi daa(f)daTepa CKeivcov. TtdvTes ovv ovtoi, yiyvovTai oloi
5 bo^d^dv êvbfj. Stov ydp tl 6pS>aLV 17 aKovuiaLV rj îrirow-
aLV, (Kaara dirovffJifLV Ta^y eKdaTOLS ov bvvdfXfvoL ^paêLS

re LaL Kal dXkoTpLovofiovvTes TTapop&aL t Kal TTapaKovovaL
KOL TTapavoovaL TrActtrra, Kai KoXovvTaL av ovroi iy\f(.vafivoi
T brf tG>v ovT(iv Kal a/xaêis.
b 0EAI. 'OpOoTaTa dvdp^TTdiv kiycLS, ui ScoKparcs.
212. ^StfXiv apa iv rffuv \}/evbLS boâs tivai;
0EAI. ^(pobpa y.
212. Kat dXrjdiXs brf;
5 0EAI. Kai aATjêts.
2i2. 'llbrf ovv olofXcOa LKav&s 0i)fj.o\oyrja9aL otl TTavTos

{/.aAAor eaTov dfx^fiOTepa TovTui Tui boâ;
0EAI. 'TiTep^fivSiS fxev ovv.
2i2. AfLVov re, ui QeaiTrfTc, ws dXr]$&s KLvbvvevei Kal

10 drfbes LvaL dvifp dbokfaxffs.
0EAI. Tl b4; TTpOS TL TOVT LTTS;
C 212. Trjv ifxavTov bvafxadLav bvayjepdvas xat a)s dXr]6GiS

dbo\(a\Lav. t( ydp dv tls oAAo ^ciro ovofxa, otov avoo
Karo) Tovs \6yovs cAkt/ ris vtto vdideCas ov bvvdfxevos
TTCLaOifvaL, kol fj
bvaaTTdWaKTos d<^' tKdaTov Koyov;
5 0EAI. 2v bf br] TL bvaxfpaLV(Ls;
212. Ov
bvaêpaLvoo fxovov dXKd kox biboLKa otl diTOKpL-
vovfxaL dv TLS ^prfTaC fxv "'12 2&)Kparcs, T]vpr]Kas br] yfffvbrj
boâv, OTL ovT iv Tals aladrfaeaCv ioTi Trpbs dAAÂas oirr'
a 2 aW^Xoij W a6 eKacTTo] fKcurrot BT a7 rt om. W

b9Tt]7*T c8 gTjTW: om. B
0EA1THTOS I95d
h' rai? Stavotat? dAA' iv ry <rvva\}/i atcr^T/crecos iTpbs d

Stciiôtay; " ^rjo-co be eycb ot/xat KaAAcoTrtô^/ueiô? cos rt
rjvprjKOTiov yjfMwv Kdkov.
0EAI. "E/iotye Soxet, S ScuK/oare?, ovk alayjpov uvai to

VVV aTT0bbtyiJ.V0V. 5
212,. " OvKovv," (f^rjo-L,

" Aeyets ort av tov avOpooTTov
ov biavoovfjieda p.6vov, 6pSip.^v 8' ov, Xttttov ovk av irore
oirfdeCrjixev elvai, ov av ovTe 6p5)p.ev ovt a.TTT6[xe6a, btavoov-
"
fjLeda be pl6vov Kal aAA' ovbkv al(Tdav6iJ.e6a TTepl avTov;
TavTa oip.aL (^r\(TU) Aeyetr. lo
0EAI. Kat (5p^ws ye.

Sf2. " Tt ovvT (firja-L,
" TCL evbeKa h pir]bev aAAo rj 8ta- e
voelTaC rt?, aAAo ri ex tovtov tov \6yov ovk av Trore oirjOeLri
6(o5eKa eiiâi a p.6vov av bLavoelTat; " i^t ovv bi], cry
aTTOKpCvov.
0EAI. 'AAA' aTTOKpLvovfxai otl 6pG>v fikv av tls rj i(f)a7TT6- 5
ixevos oirjOeCr] to. evbeKa b(obKa etrat, h ij.vtol kv r?) taz;oia
cxet, ovK av ttot iTepl avTSiv TavTa bo^d(reLv ovtcos.
212. Tt ovv; otei rtra TrcoTrore avTov ev avTSt iTeirre Kat

eTrrcx, Ae'yco 8e ftr) av6p(oiTovs eiTTa Kal irevTe TTpoêiievov 196
cTKOTrety jutjS' aAAo tolovtov, dAA' avTo. TreWe Kat eTrrcx, a
(âp.ev (Kel p.vrjp.ela ev T(d eKp.ayeC(o elvaL Kal ^lrevbrj ev avTOLS
ovK etrat So^cicrat, ravra avTo. ei ris avdpdiToov 7/877 TrcoTrore
ea-Ke\lfaTo Xeyoyv iTpbs airrbv Ka\ epoorav 7rc)cra Tror' c^ttCv, 5

Kat 6 fxev TLS etirey oir]6els evbeKa avTo. e7vaL, 6 be b(abeKa,
1] TTavTes Xeyova-C re Kot oioz^rat bdbeKa avTo. etrat;
0EAI. Ov pLCL Tbv Ata, dAAa TroAAoi 87; Kat evbeKa' eav b
8e' ye ev irXeLovL apLîxS) tls crKOTTfJTaL, ixaXXov a-(f)dXXeTaL.
OLixaL ydp cre TTepl iravTbs [ixdXXov] dpLdpLov XeyeLV.
212. Op6Ss yap otef Kat ev6vixov ixi] tl T^Te yCyveTai
d.6 (J)^(r4 al. ai rhv] avrhu ex emend. D: avrbv rhv Heindorf

d8 î/ au] > vvv T e I <pi)(r't\ <p^s B : (p-fifffi Stephanus a 2 avrii']
ainh. ra Heindorf a3 <pafj.ev\ f<pa/JLev Ast b 3 naWov om. W
W W
:
post api0fMv T b4 fiii] 5^ t<(t : iroTeBT

; ;
I96b nAATftNOS
5 5AAo 7/ avTa ra b<abKa to. iv ry iKfiayeC<f HvbcKa ol-
T]6rjvai.
0EAI. 'Eoi/ce ye.
2i2. OvKoui' (Is Tovs TipoiTovs TcoXiv drTjKf i Ao'yous; 6 yap

TOVTO TTaddv, o oTbev, ^Tfpov avTo oteTat, dvai <av av oibev,
lo h i(âp.(v abvvaTov, Ka\ T0VT(a avT^ 'qvayK^.CoiJ.ev p.r] cTvai
C yjrevbrj boâv, tva fii] tcl avra 6 avTos avayKaCoiTo (Ibois /x^
(Ibivai 6.]xa,
0EAI. "AkrjeicrraTa.
2i. OvKow aAA' oTLOvv 6^1 ai:o<\)a(viW to to. \}rvbrj
5 Soâêii' r] btavoCas Trpbs aX(Tdr](TW -napaXKaYqv. d yap

TOVT r]v, ovK av iroTe iv avTols toXs biavor]fxa(riv i\lfevb6]j.e6a.
vvv be rjToi ovk Ioti êvbifs boâ, r] a Tis olbev, olov tc /xtj
elbivai. Kal tovtoov iroTepa alprj;

0EAI. "AiTopov atpecnv TrpoTidr]s, Si ^(aKpaTes.
d 212. 'AAAa fjJvToi apL(f>6Tepd ye Kivbvvevei 6 \6yos ovk
ed(retv. o/xo)? be iravTa yap To\]ir]Teov tl ei k-nLxei.pri-
a-aL]xev dvaKryyvTeXv
0EAI. US>s;
5 212. 'EêAT/o-avrej elTreZv ttolov tC ttot' ôtI to k-nCcrracrdai.
0EAI. Kai tC tovto dvaCayyvrov
212. 'EotKas ovK kvvoeZv otl itds r]iuv e^ dpxfjs 6 Aoyos
^r]Tr](TLS yeyovev C7rt<m//X77s ws ovk elb6(TL tC ttot c^ttCv.
0EAI. Êvvoca p.ev ovv.

lo 2i2. "ETreir' ovk dvaLbes boKei /x^ elbdTas eiTLa-Tr]]ir]v
dTTo<paCve(T6aL t6 eiTCcTTa^TdaL ol6v e(TTLv; dAAa ydp, w

e 0eaiTT7re, TrdtAai ia-piev dyaTrAea) tov Kadapcas btake-
]xr]
yecrOai. fxvpLdKis ydp elpr]Kapi.ev to " yLyv<a<TKopLev " Kai

" ov yLyv<aa-K0]xev," Kal " eiTLaTdp.e6a " fcat " ovk eTTLcrra-
ixe6a," u>s ri (TvvLeirres dkktjKcov iv w Irt iTTL(TTrjpr]v dyvoov-

5 p-ev el b^ ôvkei, Ka\ vvv ev rw iTapdvTL Keyjir^p.ed' av t<^
b8 iiv4tKfi] kvriKf W fort. &v tJkoi Campbell C 4 rh^ rov T

W
:
ri om. c 7 5($(o] ^ 5<{(o B c 8 ir^Ttpa W : -KOTtpav BT

;
0EAITI1TO2 igSe
" ayvoelv " T Koi " (rvvUvai," w? TTpoarJKOV avTols xpricrQai
(iTTep (TTep6p.e6a TnaTri[j.rjs.
0EAI. 'AAAa Tiva Tpoirov StoAe^, 2 SwKpares, TovT(av

aTTexopievos
2X2. Ovbeva ^v ye os ei/xi, d p.ivToi 7] avTikoyiKos' oXos 197
avi]p (l Kal vvv Traprjv, TovTOiv t h.v ((pt} aTT^xeadai Kal
rjfjuv (r(f)6bp^ hv h eyo) Aeyco (TTCTTXrjTTev. iTTetbr] ovv k(Tp.ev
(f)avkoL, l3ovXeL ToXp.r]cr(ji eiTreti' ol6v eort to kiTL^rTaaOaL;

(palveTaL ydp fj.01 iTpovpyov tl hv yevicrdaL. 5
0EAI. ToA/xa tolvvv vrj Aia. tovtcov be /ix?) aiT(\op.iv(ii
croL ea-TaL ttoAAt) crvyyvdipr].
212. 'AKT/Koas ovv o vvv Kiyov(TLV to iTTL(TTa(rdaL;

0EAI. *I(rcos' ov p.4vT0L (V ye tS iTap6vTL iJ.vr]p.ovev(t).
212. ^F,TTL(Trqp.r]s ttov ^lv (pa(T\v avTo etrat. b

0EAI. 'AAtj^t^
2X2. 'HjLiets TOLVvv (rp.LKpov p.Tad(ap.6a /cat t7Tco//ei'
iTTL(TTr]pur]s KTrjrrLV.
0EAI. Tt ovv br] (^T/creis tovto iKeCvov bia^fêpeLv; 5

2X2. "lcTitis IJ.V ovbiv o 8' ovv boKel aKovcras (rvvboKLixaê.
0EAI. 'EavTTep ye oto's r' S.
2X2. Ov TOLVVV p.OL TOVTOV (f)aLVeTaL t5> KKTrj(T6aL t6

)(LV. otov ip.aTLov TTpLafj.ev^s TLS Kal iyKpaTi]s (ov /xt) ôpdv,
exety ^.'kv ovk av avTov avT6, KKTrj(TdaC ye fj.r]V âLp.V. 10
0EAI. 'Op6m ye.
2X2. "Opa br] KOL eiTKTTrjiJ.riv et bvvaTov ovTca KeKTrjfievov c
Hrj ^x^LV, oAA' wcnrep ei tls opvL6as dypLas, Trepto-re/aas 7/
TL aAAo, 6r]pev(Tas olkol KaTacrKevacrdiievos TTepLcrTepeiova
Tp4(f)0L, TpOTTOV p.\v [yOLp^ dv TTOV TLVa (f)allXeV aVTOV aVTCLS

aei \LV, OTL brj KKTr]TaL. 17 ydp; 5
a 3 &] aKovtuv & W b5 S^ odv W b8 tJ) KfKTTJ(r0ai r^ T

b 9 (l ante Ifxdrwv adcl. vulg. et mox <popot <popwv b : <ôpw B :
(popijj T W </)oper Campbell b 10 yf /x^v W

7 5^ B 7 T
W
: : : :
5f 7 vulg. b II /coj opOcDs 7 T C2 ^ ante veptffrfpas add.

C 4 7ip om. W
;
197 c nAATX2N0S
0EAI. Nat.
212. TpoTTOv 8e y aWov ovb(fx(av ^x^'^ &Wa biuvafiiv
fxev avTio Trepl avras irapay^yovivai, kiTdhri kv oIkC(o iTfpL-
/3o'A(j) VTToxftpCovs iiTOLT](raTo, XajSdv nal cr\(lv iireLbav
d ôvKrjraL, $rjpev(raixV(o rjv hv aet eêA?/, Kal ttoXiv &<f)L(vai,
KOL TOVTO iêlvaL TTOLCLV OTTOaaKlS OLV boKT] aVT^.

0EAI. "Ecrrt TavTa.
212. IlaAiv brj, axnrep ev tols TTpoa-Oev Kr\piv6v Ti kv Taty
5 y^fVjâL^ KaTecrKevaôixev ovk 018' ort 7rAdo-)txa, vvv av ev kKaoTr)
"^vxfl TTOLrja-MiMfV TrpL<TTep<av6. Twa TTavTobaiT&v opvCdoiv,

TCLs pikv Kar dyeAa? ovcras xoipXs t5>v a.XXoiv, tcls be Kar
oXCyas, ivCas be fxovas 8ta TTaa-Stv 07n/ hv tt^x^ci TTiTopAvas-
e 0EAI. rieTrotô-^co 8^. dAAa rt TovvTtvOev
22. YlaLbCcnv fikv ovto^v (f)dvaL XPV ^^vaL tovto to ayyelov
Kivov, avTL 8e t5>v opvCdoiv kTTLcrTrffxas vorjcraL' r)V 8' hv
CTTLCTTrjfxrjv KTTfo-dfxevos KaOeCp^ eis tov iTipCôkov, (f)dvaL
5 avTov fxefxaOrfKevaL rj rfvprfKevaL to TTpayfxa ov ^v avrq rf
eTTtOT^/btr;, kol to kiTCaTaardaL tovt elvaL.
0EAI. 'Eo-ro).
198 212. To ToCvvv ttoKlv rjv hf ôvkrfTaL T&v eTTLOTrffxCiV
OrfpeveLV Ka\ Xa(36vTa taxeLV Kal avdLS cKpLevaL aK^TTCL tCvojv
belTai ovofxaTOiv, eire rwv avTcav (av to ttp&tov otc (ktclto

efre kTepoiV. pLa9rfa~p 8' evOevbe a-a(f)4arepov tC Acyco.
6 dpLOfxrfTLKifv fxev yap \4yeis rexvrfv;

0EAI. Nar.
212. TavTtfv brf vTT6kaj3e drfpav kTTLcrnffxGiV d.pTCov re Ka\
TTepLTTOV TTaVTOS.
0EAI. 'TiToXafx^dvu).
10 212. TavTrf brf olfxaL rfj Tex^V 0-vt6s t viToxfi^pi-ovs Tas
b eTTLa-rrjfxas tS)V dpLdfxoiv Ixei Kai dAA<t) Trapaî^coo-u; 6
TrapaStôvs.
Cg (TXfîf^ ^X**' T ^4 ToTs] Ty W 6 2 xph tlvai] xpVfai W

a4 iydfvSt] iyTfvOty B &5 fiiv om, W bI 4\A.v TW :
i\\o pr. B
0EAITHTO2 igSb
0EAI. NaL
212. Kat KaXovfxiv ye TrapabLbovTa fxev bLbda-Keiv, Trapa-
KapiâvQVTa h\ p.av6dviv, ^ypvTa h\ hi] rw KeKTTJadaL iv ro) 5
TrepLo-TepeQvi eKeiroj iTTLOTacrdaL.
0EAI. ndvv pikv ovv.
212. Tw 8c brj ivTcvdev yjbrj Trpoa-ayes tov vovv. dpLdp.ri-
TLKos yap cov Tfk^cos aAAo tl irdvTas dpL6p.ovs eTTLaTaTaL;

TzdvTcov ydp dpL6p.SiV ila-Lv avTU) kv t?] "^vxf] e7TLcrTfip.ai. lo
0EAI. Tt p.rjv;
212. 'H ovv 6 TOLOVTOs dpL6p.oZ dv TTore rt 7/ avTos irpcs c
avTov avrd i] d\ko tl t&v e^co oaa xî dpi6fj.6v;
0EAI. Uu)s ydp ov;

212. To 8e dpL^p-elv ye ovk d\ko tl 6r]crop.iv tov
crK0TTela6aL TToaos Tis dpL6p.bs Tvyx_dvi cov. 5
0EAI. OvTcos,
212. *0 dpa (TTiCTTaTai, VKOTTOvfievos cfâCveTaL u)S ovk
clbcos, ov b)poXoyr]Kap.(v diTavTa dpLdp.ov eibevaL. dKOvas
ydp TTov Tas TOLavTas dpLcpLcr^r]Tria-Ls.
0EAI. "Eycoye. lo
212. OvKovv r]pHS diTLKdCovT(s Trj Tcov TTepLaTepcov KTr]Cri d
re Kal 6r]pa. epovp.V ori Strrr) ?)i' r] 6r]pa, r] iikv Trplv KTr]cr6ai
Tov KeKTrjadaL eveKa, r] be KKTrjp.ev(o tov KaêZv Kal e\eLV

ev Tals xepcrlv a TraAai iKeKTrjTO. ovtcos be Kal oiv TraAat
eTTicrTrJiJiai rjcrav avTco iJ.a66vTi Kal TjTriVraro ax/Td, TraAty eo-rt 5
KaTap.av6dveLv TavTa TavTa dvakap.j3dvovTa Tr]v eTTLcrTr\p.r]v
eKdcrTov Kal La-)(pvTa, r]V eKeKTTjTO p.ev TrdAat, TTp6)(eipov 5'

ovK eX)(e T?] biavoLCL;
0EAI.''AArja?/.'
212. ToCro bi] dpTL r]pcoT(ov, ottcos xPV 'ô^S' 6v6p.acri e
b5 8 S^] B 5)? b 8 ry 5e rwBe B t^ TW : b9 : M-

(TTaffai B b
lo eiriffTTJfiat tvr^ ^^XV ^^ C i ^ oSj/] ri cZv Badham
C 2 auT^] ivrhs Cornarius C 5 '6iroff6s T c 8 &'] Sv T
d 3 x*''] ffX^^v Naber d 4 oStoii] ivrws T d 5 fiaOovri
Kal W ixad6vTi B T
: âQwv t Badham
:
PLATO, VOL. I. 22
198 e nAATXlNOS
XpwixVov Xiyeiv ircpl avrGiV, otov &pi6fX'q(r(ov tt] 6 a.pi.6pLr}-
TiKos 7] Ti avayvaxroixfvos 6 ypapLpiaTiKOs, a>s iTnardpLfvos

&pa iv TO) Toi,ovT(o TroAty lp;(CTai p.a6r](T6p.ivos Trap* kavrov
5 h eTTLo-TaTat;
0EAI. 'AAA' &T0TT0V, S) Stu/cpaTfs.
2i2. 'AAA.' b. ovK iTTicrTaTai ^w/ixey avTov avayv(i)(re(T6ai

199 'cat api6p.r]a-iv, SeSojKoVes avrw TravTa p.iv ypd[j.fxaTa iidvTa
8e dpidixbv eTtCa-Taadai;
0EAI. 'AAAa Kal tovt^ dXoyov.
211. Boi/Aet ovv \(y(tip.ev oti. tu>v fxev ovoixdTOiV ovbev
5 rjpuv fxeXeL, oirrj tls x.aipeL ekKOiv to eTTLa-Taa6aL Kal pav6dveLV,
eiTeLbi] b^ 0ipL(Tdp.e6a eTepov p.ev tl to KeKTrja-6aL tijv ^ttl-
aTr\p.r]v, eTepov be to exeLV, h fxev tls eKrqTat p.r] KeKTrjaâL

dbvvaTov (f)ap.ev eimt, uiaTe ovbeiTOTe avfxâLveL 6 tls olbev fxi]
elbevaL, êvbrj fxevTOL boâv oXov t elvaL TTepl avrov kaêlv;

b fxr] ydp ^xeLV Tr]V iTTLOTrifxrfv tovtov olov T, oAA' kTepav dvT
eKeLvrfs, OTav 6r]pev(iiv TLvd ttov ttot eTTLaT-qpLr]v bLaireTop.evayv
dv6^ eTepas erepav dpapTuiV \d(3r], t6t dpa Ta evbeKa bd-

beKa (fy]6r] e7vaL, Tr]V tG>v evbeKa eTTLaTrip.r]v dvrX TTfs tQ>v
5 bdibeKa X.al3u>v Tr]v ev eax^(o olov (f)dTTav dvTL TTepiaTepds.

0EAI. "Exet ydp ovv \6yov.
212. "OTay bi ye rjv iTTLX^LpeX Xaêiv Aa/3?/, d\j/evbelv Te
Kal Ta ovTa bo^dêiv Tdre, Kal ovt(d br] elvaL d\r]dr] t Kal
C ^lrevbrj bdâv, Kal Stv ev tols TTp6a6ev ebvaxepaCvopev ovbev

efXTTobobv yCyvea6ai; tacos ovv pot avfx({)r]aeLS' r] ttCjjs
TTOLrjaeLs;
0EAI. OvT(os.
5 Kal ydp tov fxev h eirCaTavTaL /x?/ eTTCaTaa6aL
2X2.
dTTr]\\dyfxe6a- h ydp KeKTr]pe6a pi] KeKTr]a6aL ovbapov erL
(TVfxâCveL, ovTe \}/eva6elaC tlvos ovt fxr]. beLvdrepov fxevTOL
TTd6os aWo TTapa(f)aCvea6aC poL boKeL
e7 om. W b2 irov vor' W : OTr" aurov B T 1) 3 r^re

W :
ft
SreBT C 5 Mararcu D C 8 &KKo\ SAAo rt W itapa-

<paivf(Td<u] tpaivfo-Oat W : vapffxpaiyftrOai al.
0EAITHTO2 199 c
EAI. To TTolov;
2X2. Ei f] tG)v iTTLcn-qfiQv /ieToAAay^ -^(vbijs yevq<r(TaL lo
TTOT boâ.
0EAI. Um hri;
211. TIpojTov /xey t6 tlvos (XpvTa eTTtcmîx-qv tovto avTo d

ayvoelv, /xt) ayv(ofj.oa-vvr] ak\a Tfj kavTOv (TTL(m]p.r}' TT(LTa
(Tfpov av TOVTo bo^dCeLV, to 8' eTcpov tovto, ttcos ov ttoAA?/

aAoyta, iTTLOTrjp.r^s TTapayevoiJ.evr]s yvwvaL pikv ttjv xfrvxtiv
p.r]hiv, ayvorja-aL be iravTa; (k yap tovtov tov Aoyov KcoAvei 5

ovbiv Ka\ ayvoLav TTapayevofxdvrjv yvcHvaL tl 7roi?/o-at Kal
TV(^X6Tr]Ta Ibdv, iLTTip KOL iTTLa~rq]xr] ayvoTJa-aC ttotc TLva
TT0L1]a-L.
0EAI. "lacos yap, w 2coKpares, ov KaXws tg.s opvidas e

(Tl6]j.V (TTLCTTripas fx^vov tl6VT(s, c8ei b Kal dvdTLcrTr]-
]xoavvas TLêvaL opov crvvbLaTreTOfxevas (V Trj \j/vxrj, kol
Tov 6r]pvovTa tot pikv TTL(rTr]pi.r]V Xap^dvovTa, rore 8'
dvTTLarr]]xocrvvr]v tov avTov TTcpL \l/vbr] ]XV bo^dCcLV r?/ 5

dvTTLcrTrj]xoa~vvr], dkr]6r] 8e rr/ TTLarr]]xr].
21i. Ov pa.bL6v ye, d) 0eatr7]re, //.?/ e atiêty cre' 6 ]XVtol

etTres TraAty eiTLa-Kexj/aL. e(rra> ]xev yap ws Ae'yets' 6 8e 8t/ r7/y
dv7TL(rTr]]xoa-vvr]v \a^(tiv -êvbij fXV, (f)ris, bo^dcreL. 7/ ydp; 200

0EAI. Nai.
212. Ov St/ttou /cat ^yr/o-erat ye \}/vbr] bo^dCeiv.
0EAI. Ows yczp;
212. 'AAA' dXr]di] ye, /cat oj? etocos 8iaKetVerat Trept o)V 5
e\//êuo-rat.
0EAI. Ti/xr/i;;
212. 'E7rto-r>//x7/v dpa ohjaeTaL re^7/peuKcos exety dAA' ovk

dvTTLaTi]]xoaijvi]V.
0EAI. AÂoy. 10
212. OVKOVV ]XaKpdv 7TpL\66vTS TTCzAtl' eTTt TTJV TTpcaTr^V
6 2 novov iviffT-fifias W 65 So|aê B e8 ij] i W

a8 TfOrjpoKws W
22*
;
200 a nAATi2N02
TTapfo-fKV aiTopiav. 6 yap (KcyKTiKoi eKetro? y\a(ras <f>ri(Ti'
b " YloTepov," S) îXTicTToi, " apL(f)OTpas ris dbcos, iiri.cm^fXTjv
T Kal 6.veTTL(rTrjfxo(Tvvr]v, rjv olhev, kTipav avrrjv oXeraL rtva
iivai wv o*b(v; r/ ovbeTepav airrolv dbcos, rjv p.r] oTbe, 8oâ^ct
(Tepav S)V ovK oXbev; rf rrjv ixev etSco?, ti]v 8' ov, rjv otocr,
5 r\v fxr] olbev; rj fjv fir] olbev, rjv olbev ^yetrat; fj iroA.tv av
IXOL epelTe oti rcov ^Tn(rTrip.G>v koI aveiii(rTr]]io(TvvCi)V el^rlv
av eTTKTTijnai, as 6 KeKTrjfxevos ev eTepois TicrX yeAoiot?

C iTepi(TTepeCi(nv r] KrjpCvois 7rXao-/xao-t KadeCpâs, eoxriTep av
KKTrJTaL eTrCcTTaTaL, koX iav p.r] "npoyeCpovs ^XV ^^ '''V '^^XV!
Kal ovT(ji) bi] avayKa(r6r](Te(T6e cts TavTov TreptTpexêiV /xupidjciy
ovbev TcXeov TTOLovvTes; " ri iTpbs raura, S) eairr/re, aTTOKpL-

5 vov]xe6a;
0EAI. 'AAAa ]xa AC\ o) Sw/cpares, ey(i>ye ovk ^x^ rt
Xpr] keyeLV.
212. A/)' ovv fjpLLV, S) TraX, KaAw? 6 \6yos eTrtTrAr/rret
Kat ivbeCKWTaL otl ovk opdcis ^l/evbTJ boâv irpoTepav ^r]Tov]xev
d eiTL(TTr]]xr]s, eKeCvj]v a(f)evTes; t6 8' eo-rtv abvvaTov yvGtvaL

TTplv av TLS eTTi(TT-qp.r]v LKavois Ad/3T/ rt TTor' e^rrCv.
0EAI. 'Aj/dyKT/, tt 2wKpares, ev rw TTapovTi wy Ac'yeis
oreo-ât.
5 212. Tt ovv TLS epel TrdAtj; e^ cipxrjs eTTL(TTr]]xr]v; ov ydp

TTou CLTTepovfxev ye tto);
0EA1. "HKto^ra, edvTTep ]xr] crv ye aTTayopevijs.

2i2. Ae'ye br], tC hv avTo ]xdkL(TTa eliTovTes ^kiot' av
i]]XLV avTOLS evavTL(t)6el]xev
e 0EAI. "OjTep (irexeLpovfxev, S) "SidKpaTes, Iv rai TTp6(r9eV'
ov yap ^x^ eycoye dAAo ovbev.

212. To TTOLov;
b I iifiaT-iifa\v\ i-Ki<rTj\no<Tvirnv W b3 auToi'] avriiv B T om. : W :
C 9 npoTfpav fTtpav B ] d 5 yap irou W : yip trw B T y4 : irai
Schanz d6 y4 ira] 7 irou W oni. Schanz d^ &irayopfv<rTts

W
:
T sed corr. T : airayopfVfn pr. B d8 5^j 5 W airh} ain^

iu>] tiv avrh B
0EAITHTO2 2ooe
0EAI. Tr}V aXrjOrj boâv fTn(TTr\ixr]V elvai. avafxdfyrr^Tov
yi iTov k(TTiv To ho^dêiv u\r]6fj, Kal to. vtt' airrov yiyvoix^va 5
TrdvTa Kdka Ka\ dyaOa ytyveTai.

212. 'O Tov TTOTaixbv Ka6r]yovixevos, S eairrjre, (f>r} dpa
beCêiv avTo- Kal tovto edv iovTes epevvu^fxev, t^x dv
epLTTobLOV yev6piVov avTo (f)r]veLev to 0]tovixvov, ixevovaL 201
8e brjKov ovbev.
0EAI. 'Op^ws Aeyeis* dAA' i(ofxev ye Kal aKOiToofxev.
212. OvKovv TovTO ye ^paxeias a-K4\f/eo)S' Ti\vr] ydp

croL oXr] crr]fxaLveL fxr] elvaL eiTL(TTr]p.r]V avTO, 5
0EAI. Ilws bri; Kal tls avrq;

212. 'H T(av }xeyL(JT(jiV ei? (ro(f)Lav, ovs br] KaXovcTLV
pr]Topds T Kal bLKavLKOvs. ovTOL ydp.TTOV Tf] kavTwv Texvj]

TTeCdov^TLV ov bLbdcTKovTes dAAa bo^dC^LV TTOLovvTes h av
ôvKuivTaLt r] crv oUl beLVOvs tivas ovto} bLbaa-KdXovs elvaL, 10
u>a-Te ols fxr] TTapeyivovTo tlvcs aTTOCTTepovixevois \pr]]xaTa b

7/ TL dXko ^LaôfxevoLS, tovtols bvvaadaL iTpos vb(i>p crfXLKpbv
bibdâL iKavbis rwy yevop.evitiV Tr]v d\r]6eLav;
0EAI. Ovbajxws eyctiye olfxaL, dAAa Tretcrat fxev.

212. T6 TTelaai 8' ov)(l bo^daai keyeLS TTOLrfaaL; 5
0EAI. Tifxrfv;
212. OvKovv oTav bLKaioos TTeLa6S)aLV biKaaTal iTepl &v
IbdvTL fxdvov eaTLV elbevaL, dAAws 8e fxi], ravTa TOTe e^
aKorjs KpivovTes, dXr]6i] boâv XajBovTes, dvev eTTL(rTr]fxr]s C
iKpLvav, 6p6a TTeLa6evTes, etiTep ev ebiKaaav;
0EAI. Hai^rdTrao-t fxev ovv.
212. OvK dv, S) (f)iXe, et ye ravTbv r]v bdâ re dXr]di]s
fKal bLKaaTr]pLaf Kal eTTLaTr]p.r], 6p6d ttot dv bLKaaTrjs 5

aKpos iboâC^v dvev e7rtcrr?/jurjy vvv be eoLKev dXXo tl
eKdrepov elvaL.
e 5 ye] ydp W a 3 ê] t W &1 V om. B b i of?l

*{ Naber b2 tovtovs T b8 iSovTi] etSou ti B : dSoTi W
SA\aisl iiAAy Ast C5 Kol SiKaffTrtpia' Ka\ SiKaa^rfiptov T: secl.
Heindorf : Kara SiKaffT-^pia Jowett Koi StKoaTripia Madvig
:
aoic nAATi2N02
0EAI. "O ye eyci, o) ^(aKpares, (Ittovtos tov aKov(ra9
^Tr\\rj(riJ.r}V, vvv 8' IvvoSi' 8e Tr]V fXfv ix(Ta \6yov
^<f)r}
d aKrjOr} b6$av (TnoTrîxrjv cTvai, rrjv 8e a\oyov (ktos (TTicrT^-
fxrjs' Kal S)v fxkv fxr] coTi \6yos, ovk eTrio-rjjra elvai,, ovTcoal
Kal 6vofxd^(i}v, h 8'
^x^' ^TTioTTjra.
212. 'H Ka\6i9 Aeyet?. tcl be 6t/ îrKrrj/ra raOra Kat ^^
6 tttJ 8iT/pei, Aeye, ci fipa xara ravra otJ re Kayo) aKT/fcoa/ier.
0EAI. 'AA\' ouK ol8a eZ eêipj/o-a>* Ae^yovros fxarrav
kTepov, o)? ly^fxaL, aKo\ov6r](raiix 6.v.
2i2. "AKoue 8^ ovap dvri oiêtparos. ^yo) ya/) av ^8o'kow

e aKove.a> TivQv oti to. pikv irpGiTa olovnipd (JTOiyjua, i^ (Hv
re (rvyKeCixeda Kal raAAa, Aoyoy ovk ^x^'*

TjpLels avf^ y^P
KaO* avTo (KacTTov 6vop.a.a-ai fx^vov eiT/, TTpo(T(LTTiiv 8e ou8ey
aAAo 8waroV, ovd^ cos eorti', ovff u>s ovk icrTLV ybr] yap
202 av ovtTLOv rj fxr] oixxiav avr^ TipocrTLde^rOai, bdv 8e ovbev
TTpo(r(f)epiM, etire/) avTo (Kflvo ]x6vov rts e/jei. eTrei ov8^

ro aiTo ov6e to (Keivo ovbe to fKaarov ovbc to
" ix6vov " ov8^ " TOVTO " Trpo(roia-Tov ou8' 5AAa TroAAa
5 TOLavra' Tavra /xer yap iKpLTpiyovTa iTaa-i iTpoaiîipe^TdaL,
Tpa ovTa eKeCvuiV ols TTpoariOiTaL, bdv 8e', eiTre/) 7]V
bvvaTov avTo \iyea-0aL Kal (^x^v olklov avTov \6yov, avev

T&v a\\(t)v aiTavTutv \iye(T6aL. vvv b\ kbvvaTov itvai
b ortoCv tS)V TTp(i)T(t)V pr]6r]vaL Adytp' ov yap eu.'ai avro) oAA'
7/ dro/xdêo-âi pu6vov dvopia yap p.6vov (X(iv to. 8e ex

TOVT(t)v r^jbr] (TvyKeifxcva, utaTrep avTO. TTiiTêKTai, ovto) kol
TO. 6v6]xaTa avT(j)V avfXTTâKivTa \6yov yeyovivaL' 6vop.aT(DV
5 yap (TvpiTT\oKr]v eiyat Adyou ovaiav. ovto) 8t/ ri ]xkv
o-roiXfMi Âoya Kai ayvoicrra eivat, aladr]Ta bi' Tas 8e

av\Xaâs yrtoo-rds re Kot /jTjras Kai dAT/êt 6d^7/ ôâords.
oray /xey ovv avev \6yov Ti]V a\r]6rj boâv tlv6s tls Ad/3T/,
d2 &v] (f
B d3 ^/oyuaô) B & 8* T : oAA* B d7 iucoKov-
94)(Tain' 6.V Schanz : aKo\oi,^<Taiixr\v BT : kKo\ov9ii(fatfjn al. a i ^t7v]
8(1 T a 4 toDto] t^ ToiTo Heindorf t^ rb Buttmann : b i oin^]
tiinh Bonitz b2 fxfty] ^x* ^
0EAITHTO2 202c
avTov avro, yv/vwcTKeiv 8'

akri6Vi.v fjikv tijv ylnrxjjv Trepl c
ov' Tov yap jlit) hvvap.evov bovvaC re Kal beâaOaL \6yov
av(Tna-Tr]p.ova etvai. Trept tovtov TTpoa-XaôvTa bk Xoyov
hvvaTov re TavTa "navTa yeyovevai Kal reAetcos Trpbs e7ri(rr7/-
fxrjv X(i-v. ovrcoy ot) t6 (jwttviov rj aAAcos aK-qKoas; 5

0EAI. OvTco fjikv ovv TravTaTTaa-u'.
2X2. 'Apeo-Kei ovv o-e Kal TiOeaai Tavrr], hoâv 6Xr]dr\
fXTa \6yov (TnoT-qiJLrjv eivai;
0EAI. Ko[xibf] ixev ovv.
2X2. 'Ap', u) eatrr/re, in;y ovrco r7/8e r?) r]pApa elXr]<paix(v d

6 TroAat fcat ttoAAoi T(ov a-o<f)Qv ^T/roi^rrej Trpti' ivpelv
KaTeyr]paaav;
0EAI. 'E/xot yow 8o/cet, a> ScoKpares, KaAw? Xiyecrdai
TO vvv pr]6iv. 6
212. Kat eiKoj ye avro rouro ovro)? t\eiv' rts yap ai;
Kai cri e7rt(rr7//x7/ eiT/ x.'^P'S rou Ao'yoi; re Kat opdi]^ h6^r]s;
^v fxivTOi tC fX t5>v prj6(VT(ov aTTapea-Kei.
0EAI. To Trotoi' 87/;
2X2. *0 Kai 8oKet Kiya6ai KOfxxf/oTaTa, o)S tcl fxkv 10

OTotxeta ayycoora, t6 8e T<av avWaâv yivos yvu)a~r6v. e
0EAI. OvKoCi' 6p6Gi^;
2X2. 'IoTe'oy 8^' a>aiT(p yap ofxrjpovs e)(0/xei; tov \6yov
ra irapabeLyfxaTa oXs xpiofxcvos etire Ttavra Tavra.
0EAI. noia 87/; 5
2X2. Ta rwr y/)a/xju.arcoi'OTOixetcx re Kat o-uAAa/3cis. 7/ oiei
aAAoo-e' irot ^XiitovTa TavTa eiTreti' t6v et7ro'yra h. Xiyofxfv;

0EAI. OvK, dAA' 1? TavTa.
2X2. Bao-art^co/xer 8j/ avTo. avaXafxjidvojrres, fxaXXov 8e 203
fjfJMS avTovs, ovT(DS rj ovx ovrcos ypdfxfxaTa lfxd6ofxev. <êpe
TTpQiTOV' ap' ai fiev avXXajSal X6yov e)(0ucrt, to. 8e crrot^êia
aXoya;
0EAI. "lacos. 5
05 ffi/] ffoi B d6 avTh] o5 Heindorf

203 a TIAATilNOS
212. Yldvv jxev ovv Kal e/xot (paiveTaL. û>KpaTovs yovv
et Tis (poiTo TTjv TTpwTTjv cTuAAa/Sr/i' ovt(0(tC' " îl eaiTTjre,
Aeye rt eori ZQ "; tC aTTOKpivT);

0EAI. "Ort alyp.a koX w.
10 212. OvKovv TovTov ^x^'^ Aoyoy t^s (rvWa^fjs;
0EAI. ''Eycoye.
b 212. "IOl bri, ovTdis t7re Kai tov tov alyfxa Koyov.
0EAI. Ka^ 770)? Tou (TTOLêCov Tts epet o^Totxeta; Kat
yap 8?/, o) ScoKpaTes, to' Te (TLypi,a t(ov dcfxjovaiv ((ttl, \/ô'(ôs"
Tts fjiovov, olov (rvpLTT0V(Tr]s Tiji yAwTTTjs' Tov 8' av /jrjTa
5 oiJTe (fxavrf ovtc \lf6(pos, ovbe tS>v TT\eC(TT(ov o-Totxetcoi'. cwo-Te
Trdvv ev exet t6 Xeye^TdaL avTO. dkoya, wv ye Ta h'apyi(TTaTa

avra tci eTTTa (f)(iivr]v ixovov exfi> Koyov 8e ovS' oi^Ttiôw.
212. TouTt juey apa, oi kTalpe, KaT(apd(t)Ka[XV Trept
eTTtoTr/ju.rj?.
lo 0EAI. <t>aLv6p.da.
C 212. Tt 8e'; To p.1] yv(i)(TTov etvat t6 (rroLxelov dAAa

T^y (rv\\aî]v Sp' opO&s aTToSeSety/xeâ;
0EAI. EtKos ye.
211. <l>e'pe 8r], Tr/y o-uAAa/Sr/y TtoTepov Xeyo]iev tcl d/i(/)o'-
5 repa orTotxeia, Kat edr TrAetco

f]
r) Siô, rd irdvTa, r/ /;itay
Ttvd i8e'ay yeyoi^wtay crvvTedevTOiv avTOiv;

0EAI. Td SLTravTa efxoLye hoKov]xev.
211. "Opa bi] eTTt hvoXv, aLyp.a Kal S). dp.^6Tepd ((ttlv
7] TTp(aTr] (TvkkajSi] tov (jxov ovopiaTOS. dkko tl 6 yLyviocTKoov
lo avrr]v tcl d\x^6Tepa yLyv(a(TKeL;
d 0EAI. Tt ixrjv;
Td (Tlyjxa Ka\
2X2. to o) dpa yLyvdxTKeL.
0EAI. Nai.
2i2. Tt 8'; (KaTepov dp' dyvocL kol ovbeTepov et8cbs
5 d]X(p6Tepa yLyv(o(TKeL;
b6 fx*' T^ *^ ^ ^7 """* ^""''^ ^"^- ^" ^^*^ ^'^"^- *""'* '" marg.
C2 ano5(Sfyfj.(6a, al. C4 Kfywjj.ei' B
0EAITHTO2 203d
0EAI. 'AAAa beivov kol akoyov, S) ^(oKpares.

2X2. 'AAAa fxivTOL t ye avdyKrj kKarepov yLyvwa-Keiv,
etTrep afxcfiOTepd tls yv(oa-(TaL, TrpoyLyvcoa-KeLV tcl a-TOL\a.a
diraa-a dvdyKr] rw fxekkovTL irore yvdxreaOaL a-vkkajSi^v,
Koi ovTois rjfXLV 6 Kakos koyos aTrobebpaKUiS otxô'^''"'' '
0EAI. Kat fxdka ye iâL(f)vr]s. ^

'2il. Ow yap Kaku>s avTov (pvkdrroiJLev. XPV^ 7^9 ^^^^
rrjv avkka^r]v TLdea-OaL pLi] Ta a-TOLxela dAA' i^ eKeCvoav ev
TL yeyovbs etSo?, i8ear fxtW avTO avTOv e\ov, eTepov 8e
Toiv aroLyemv. 5
0EAI. Wdvv p.\v ovv KOL Tdya y av [xdkXov ovt(i)S i)
\eLV(os exoL.
SX2. ^KeTTTeov Kal ov TipoboTeov ovrcos dvdvbpuis [xeyav
re Kai (refxvov koyov.
0EAI. Ov ydp ovv. Jo
212. 'ExeVco bi] ojs' vvv (fâjxev, /xia t8e'a e^ eKacrrcoy tu)V 204
a-vvapfxoTTOVTcov aTOLxeLcov yLyvofxevr] fj a-vkka^rj, o/xotcos'
V re ypdixp.aa-L /cat ev rots aAAots aTracrt,

0EAI. Udvv fxev ovv.
211. OvKovv fxiprj avTrjs ov 8et etyat. 5

0EAI. Tt hri;
212. "Ori ov av rj ]xipr], to okov dvdyKr] Ta TrdvTa fxepr]
(TvaL. 1] Kal t6 okov ex toov ]xep5>v Ae'yets yeyovbi ev tl

elbos eTepov tS)V TrdvToov p.ep(i)v;
0EAI. "Eycoye. jo
212.To be bi] 'ndv KaX Tb okov TTOTepov TavTov KoAei? */
eTepov eKdTepov; b
0EAI. "Exô p.ev ovbev a-a(f)es, otl be KekeveLS Trpo^v/xcof
diTOKpLvaadaL, TrapaKLvbvvevcov keyu) otl eTepov.

212. *H jxev TrpodvfxCa, u) êatrr/re, opOi]' el be /cat 7/
diroKpLa-LS, (TKeTrreov, 5
d 10 ouTCDsl ovTos B a I
X*' <"''(> Mac]vig : tffroi 5^ aut fxiav
IStav . . . yiyvofjLfyr)v Heindorf ws] us Kal T aii TovThv]
ainhv T
ao4b nAATXiNOS
0EAI. Aei ye bjj.
212. OvKovv bi,a(f)4poL hp rb okov rov Ttavros, ws 6 vvv

\6yos;
0EAI. NaL
lo 2X2. T^ 8e 8^; ra TTavra Kal rb irav ^crO^ otl 8ia(^'pei;
oiov eTTLbav \eyu}ixV ev, bvo, rpia, TiTTapa, mvTe, c^, koI
C iav bls TpLa r) Tpls bvo rj TeTTapA re Kal bvo 77 rpta Kal bvo
Kal ev, TTOTfpov kv Ttaa-L tovtols to avTo ^ erepov Keyofiev;
0EAI. T^ avTo.
212. 'Ap' aXXo TL rj e^;
5 0EAI. Ovbev.
212. OvKovv e(f)' eKdarrjs kiêcos Trdvra t^ elp-qKapiev;
0EAI. Nai.
212. riai' 8' ovb^kv kiyop-ev to. irdvTa \eyoirres;
0EAI. 'AvdyKTj.
10 212. 'H a\Ko TL r] tcl e^;
0EAI. Ovbev.
d 212. Tavrov apa iv ye toIs ocra e^ dpL$p.ov ka-TL t6 re
Ttdv TTpoa-ayopevoixev kol to. aTravTa;
0EAI. aLveTaL.
212. *î28e bi] TiepX avTS>v keyoip.ev. <5 rov iiXedpov

5 dpLdpos Ka\ To TrXedpov TavTov t/ ydp;
0EAI. Nai.
212. Kai 6 rou oraStou 87) ojo-avro)?.
0EA1. Nat.
212. Kat pLr]v Ka\ 6 tov cnpaTOTtebov ye koX to a-TpaTd-
10 7re8oi', Kat Trarra ra TOLavra ojLtotcoy; 6 ydp dpLdpios Jras
b6 7f 5:^ W : BT
Sf 7 5^ b 10 8ti] 8t* c i t om. W W
rpia] rpia t W C a t^ avrh om. C3 t^ auTiJ W W:
T^ avrdv B : rax)r6v T
C 6 irtfjo-a irdyra tA B T W
up^-:
#ta/tti/ T c8 irav olim Campbell ird\iy BT: itoAjv roi' nunc :
Campbell tA iriô] t^ itov Schleiermacher rh irai' auTA Wohlrab :
C lo ^ om. T d4 vfpl] ri irfp\ W

dg Kal fi^v koIJ koJ
/uJ)!' T 7] Te W
d 1 1 rb iro;' 6f Heindorf
0EAITHTO2 204d
0EAI. Nai.
212. 'O 8e Kd(rT(i)v dpi^juof jxcjv aWo tl i] ixipr\ ka-Tiv; e
0EAI. OvUv.
2i2. "Ocra apa 1^^' /^fV*?' ^*^ ixepiav av eiri;
0EAI. âiviTai.
2X2. Ta 8e yc Trdyra /xepr; to Trav (Ivat o)p.ok6yr\Tai., 5
etTrep Kat 6 Tras dptdfxos t6 Trdy ecrrat.
0EAL 0/ra)s.
212. To oAoy dp' oiiK eo-rtz; k fxep&v. rrdy yd/) hv eir;
rd TrdiTa dy /xepTj.
0EAI. OvK eocKev. lo

212. Mepos 8' eo-^' orou dAAou eo-riy oTrep eo-rtv rj tov
oKov;
0EAI. Tou 'Trai^rd? ye.
2X2. ÂvbpiKQs ye, w eatrr/re, ixdxj]. to Traz; 8e ov^ 205
orai' pLTjbev aTrf], avTO tovto Trdi' ^cttiv;
0EAI. 'Ai;'dyKrj.
2X2. "OAoy 8e ou TavTov tovto e<rrat, o dr p.r]haix?]
IxTjbev dTTooTaTi]; ov 8' dv dTtoaTaTfj, ovTe okov ovt Trdi', 5

d]xa yevofxevov ex tov avTov rd avrd;
0EAI. AoKet fxoL vvv ovbev 8ta0e'petv Trdz; re Kat okov.
2X2. OwKoCy (\eyojXV drt o5 dz; /xe'/)?7 r/, rd oAoi' re KUi
Trdi; rd Trdirra fxepr] eorat;
0EAI. ndvv ye. 10

2X2. ndAty br], oTrep dpTi kTTeyjeipovv, ovk, etTre/) r]
arvXXa^r] fxrj to, OTOtêid ka-Tiv, dvdyKt] avTr]V ]xr] o)s fxepr] b
exeir kavTrjs rd o-rot^êta, r/ TavTov ov(rav avTols ofxoicas
.(KeivoLs yv(t)(rrr]v etzât;

0EAI. OvToos.
2X2. OvKovv TOVTO tva fxi] yivr]Tai, Tpov avT(av avTi]v 5
eê/xeâ;
e 5 dfioKoyurai B a 5 hv^ tiv /xii T a7 koI] al rh W

a8 Kol] <coi ri W a9 ecTTaiJ eVrjj/ W
205b nAAT12N02
0EAI. Nal.
2)12. Ti 8'; fl /ir; ra (TTOLxela avXXaîjs fifpr] lcrTiv,
^XW ciAA' aTTa tlttilv h ixepri p.iv ((ttl crvWajSrjs, ov

lo fJiivTOL crTOLX^â y (KfLvrjs;
0EAI. Ovbapicos. fl yap, o ^(oKpares, jxopL S.TT avTrjs

(rvy\(t}poLr}v, yeKoLov ttov tcl (TTOLêLa a(f)ivTa eir' ciAAa
UvaL.
C 2i2. UavTdLTracn brj, S) 0aLTr)T, Kora tov vvv koyov
/uta TLS Ibea ap.ipL(TT0s (rvXXa^r] av dr].
0EAI. "EoLKev.
2i2. MifjLvrjcraL ovv, Si (f>L\, ori oKCyov iv ro) Trpoa-Ofv
5 aTT(bex6iJ.(da rjyovpLfvoL ev Aeyeo-ât otl rwy irpwrcoi' ovk

eirj Aoyos e^ wy raAAa o-vyKeirai, 8iort avTo Kad^ airrb
iKacTTOv elr] acrvvOeTov, kol ovbe to " elvaL " irepi ovtov
opOSis 6X01 irpo^rcpepovTa elTrelv, ovbe " roirro," ws repa
Kat dAAoVpta Aeyoju,ei;a, Kai avrrj brj i] atrta aAoyoV rc Kat
lo &.yv(ticrTov avTo ttoloI;
0EAI. Mepivr]iJi.aL.
d 212. ^H ovv fiAAr; rts rj avTr] rj airta tov /xoroftSc? rc

Kat a]xepL(rTov avTo elvaL; iyco ]XV yap ov^ opo) dAAr/y.
0EAI. Ov yap ovv bi] cjâtfcrat.
212. OvKovv els tovtov l/AireTrrcoKcv r; o-vAAa/3^ cioos
5 eKeivbd, etirep fJ.epr] re /lir/ exei xai /wta eorii; ^dâ;

0EAI. rTai^rciTrao-t ]ikv ovv.
2X2. Et ]i\v &.pa TToAAa o-rotxcta r/ orAAa/S^ loTir Kai

oAoi' rt, /xeprj 8' avrr/? raCra, 6/j.ota)S at re oT;AAa/3ai yrto-
o-rat Kat /5r/rai Kai ra arotxeta, CTretTrep ra Trai^ra /xe'pr/ rw

lo oAo) ravrof i(f)Avr].
e 0EAI. Kai /iciAa.
2i2. Et 8e' ye ey re Kai d/xepe's, o/xotcos /xer ooiAAa/Sr/,
bg x*' CTi. B b II f/ ydp om. T M<^/' &TTa aiiTTJs W :
fiSpta ravrris BT c8 toCtoj Tb touto Heindorf : rh t6 Buttmann

C9 Tf] Tt T c lo iroir W d I i^ secl. Bonitz toC] tJ>
Bonitz Tt W in ras. B : Ti T ds t] yt Naber
0EAITHTOS 2056
bxravTOiiS be (TTOLX<elov akoyov re koX ayvcoarov' tj yap

avTT] airia 7rot7j(rei atra rotaih-a.
0EAI. OvK exo) aAAcos eliTelv. 5
2i2. Touro jjikv apa pi] aiTobxixe9a, 09 av keyrj crvAAa-

/3tjv M^^ yvMOTov Kal prqTov, a^TOiyelov 8e TovvavTiov.
0EAI. Mt; yap, tiTrep rw Xoyio Treidopeda.

2X2. Tt 8' av; TovvavTiov keyovTOS ap' ov pxLkkov av 206
cfuohiâLO k^ oiv avTos crvvoi.a-0a cravT& kv Trj T(av ypap.imT(av
fxadiâei;
0EAI. To irolov;
212. *i2s ovh\v akko p.av6av(av bieTekeaas 7; to, aTOixela 5

V re rTj o^jrei biayiyvcacrKetv Treipw/Lievos Kat ev Trj ctKofj avTo
Kad^ avTo (.KaaTov, tva prj rj decrts cre TapctTToi. keyop.h'(av
re Kat ypacfyopivuiv.
0EAI. WkrjdeaTaTa Xe'yet9.
212. 'Ey 8e KtQaptaTov reAe'(os pi.ep.a6r]Kivat p.(t>v akko rt 10
i]v 1] To roi (j)d6yy(a kK(i(rT(o hvvaadat liraKokcfvdetv, TToias b

Xopbrjs et?7* a 8rj o-rotxeia Tras ay o/iAoAoyj/crete [xova-tKrjs
kiyeadat;
0EAL Ov8ey &kXo.
212. Î2y p,ey ap' avroi e/oi7retpot ecrixev o-rotxetwy Kat 5
avkka(3Qv, et 8et aTro rovrcoy TeKpatpeadat Kat et? ra aAAa,
TToAv ro rdii; o-rot)(etcoy yivos ivapyea-Tepav re Ti/y yva>aiv
ex^cty (f)i]aopi.V Kal Kvpt(OTpav Tr]S crvkXa(3ris Trpo? ro kajBeXv

reAe'cos eKaaTov p.(idr]fxa, Kat idv rts <^7/ cn;AAa/3r/y /xez; yyo)-
oToi;, ayvoiCTTOV h\ irecf^VK^vai arotxdov, kKovTa rj aKovTa lo
Tratêtj' f^yqaoped^ avTov.
0EAI. Kojxtbi] fxev ovv.
212. 'AAAa 8^ tovtov fxev ti. Kav akXat âretey oTro- c

8etet?, ojs ]xol 8oKet" to 8e TrpoKetjxevov pr/ ItitkaddipeOa
8t' avra tSetr, ort 8r/ Trore Kat key^Tat t6 p.Ta ho^r]^
e6 toiJto] Toirrow Heindorf e 7 î/oxrTo;' W iyvoxTTov pr. BT

W
:
a6 T om. B
: T bi tJ om. B b2 & 5^] oAA.' B
i}
C I iri Ktw om, T

206c nAATI2N02
a\r]6ovs Xoyov iipocryfvoîvov ti]v TeKeoiTdTrjv 7ri(TT^/x7jv
5 ycyovdvai.
0EAI. OvKovv )(j)r] opav.
212. 4>pe 8^, tC TTore /SovAerat tov \6yov Tjp.LV (rrjpiaC-
vcLv; TpL&v yap ev tC /xot boKel keydv.

0EAI. TCvcov bri;
d 212. To p.v TTpSiTov iCr) hv To Tr}v avTov bidvoLav (p,-
(f)avi] TToieiv buL (fxavrjs /xcra pr]p.6.TUiv re kox 6vopMTU)v,

(a<nTp ds KaToirrpov t/ vbcop Tr]v b6âv (KTV7rovp.(vov ds
TTjv bia Tov (TT6p.aTos por]v. rj ov boK^l crot to toiovtov
5 Aoyos (TvaL;
0EAI. EpLOLye. t6v yovv avTo bpdvTa Xiyuv <â]xiv.
212. OVKOVV aV TOVTO y TTCLS TT0LLV bvvaTOS dcLTTOV T]
(TypXaCTepov, To ivbeCâ^rdaL tC boKfl iTfpl cKOo-rot; avTi^,

6 p.r] ev(bs r/ Kocxfibs a-n apyrjs' kol ovrois ofroi tl opdbv
e 8oâôuo-t, TTavTfs avTb p.Ta K6yov âvovvTaL exovTfs, kol
ovbap.ov ^TL opdr] b6â x^^pis ^JTKrr^/iT/y yejnjo-erat.
0EAI. 'AArj^^.
212. M?; ToCvvv pabCdis KaTayLyv(a(TKaip.(v Tb ixrjbev flprj-
5 K(vaL Tbv a'!TO(})r]vdp.vov iTTL(Trr]p.r]v b vvv (TKOTTOvp.V. lo-u)?
yap 6 Keyoiv ov tovto lAeyev, dAAa Tb (pciirqOevTa tl

Ka(TTov bvva^bv elvaL Tr]v aTT^KpLCTLV 8ia roii; o^roi^êuiuy
207 aTroSowai rw fpop.V(a.
0EAI. Olov tC Aeyeis, w ^wKpare?;

20. Otoy Kat 'Ho-toSos Trept ap.d^r]s Ae'yet Tb " (KaTov
8e re bovpad^ apA^r]s." h iyui piev ovk hv bvvaCp.r]V (lttlv,
5 OLfxaL b( ovbe crv' dAA' dyaiTQp.^v hv epcorr/êWe? ort eoTiy

&p.aâ, et exot/xey e^Trety Tpo\oC, dôiv, VTT(pT(pCa, dvTvy(s,
(vy6v.
C 7 Thv xSyovl rh \6yos Stallbaum d 4 ffT6fi.aroi'\ ffwnaros W

d6 yovf oiv B TW : d 7 a5 : om. W BT d 9 ^ Koxpbs
dir'&pxvi secl. Cobet Arpuvos in marg. T e i <pavovvTat ntrbi \6-
W
:
yov T 6 5 Tov awo<pr]vaft.fvov Heindorf e6 tI\ tI iffriv

as kyairwfJLfv MT avfpwrr]dtvTfsii a6 virfprfpiaK.uhn : vrtp-
Ttjpla B : vnfprr,pia T
0EAITHTOS 207a
0EAI. riain; fikv ovv.
212. 'O hi ye to-coj ololt h.v r)fJ.a9, Sxnrep ^v to (tov

oro}xa fp<x)Tr]dVTas Ka\ aTioKpLvopiivovs KaTo. a-vXXafii]v, 'o
yiXoLOVs (LvaL, 6p6u)S p-ev hoâCovTas Kal XiyovTas a Ae- b

yop.ev, olop.vovs 8e ypaiJ.p.aTLKovs itvai Kal ^Xîv t( Kai
XiyeLV ypafxpaTLKCos tov tov eatTTjrou 6v6p.aTos Xoyov to

6' ovK tlvaL iTTLarTri[j.6v(t)S ovbev XiyeLV, Ttplv av 8ta t5)V
(TTOLyjeLOiV p.Ta TTJs aXrjdovs bo^rjs (Ka(TTov TTepaLvrj tls, 5
OTTfp Kal iv Tols TTpoaOe TTov kppr\dr],
0EAI. Êppi]6ri yap.
212. OvTO) TOLWV Kal TTepl apa$r]S ^/txa? p.V 6p6r]V ex^LV
boâv, Tov 8e 8ia tGiv kKaTov (KLV(t)v bvv(ip.(vov bLeXddv
avTrjs Tr]V ovaiav, iTpo^rXajS^VTa tovto, X6yov re TTpo(reLXr]- C
^cVai Tr) aXr]dd b6^ Kal uvtI boâ^TTLKOV t^x^lk^v re Kal
kiTLcrTqpova TTepl a.p.a^r]s ovaLas yeyovevaL, 8ia aTOLxîft^v t6
oXov TTfpdvavTa.
0EAI. OvKovv ev boKel aoL, S) ScoKpare?; 5
2X2. Et aoL, S) eratpe, goKet, Kat aTTobixV "V ^' rrot-
Xetou bLeôbov TTfpl KaaTov X6yov ilvai, Tr]v 8e KaTo.
(rvXXa(3as *; Kat KaTO. pLelCov eTL aXoyLav, tovto poL Ae'ye,

ti;' avro eTnaKoirwixev. d
0EAI. 'AAAa iravv d-TroSe^xo/xai.
212. riorepoy rjyovfjLWos iTTLan]p.ova etrat ovtlvovv
OTOvovv, OTav To avTo tot\ fxkv Tov avTov boKf] avT^ elvai,
TOT be tTipov, r] Ka\ oTav rov avTov Tore fiv cTepov, tot^ 5
8e (Tpov bo^dCj];
0EAI. Ua A" ovK eycoye.
2X2. Eira dixvr]p.ovtLS iv tj] tG)V ypaix]xdTO)v fxadriad
KUT dpxas aavT6v re Kat tovs dXXovs bpG)VTas avTa;
0EA1. ''Apa Ae'yets r?J? avTr]s (rvXXa^rjs tot ]x(V ere- lo
pov, Tori 8e iTepov i]yov]xivovs ypdixp.a, Ka\ to ovto tot e
ba T6 om. W b6 irp^frOfv ou B bg ihv] rh Turicenses

W d 4 totJ
Twv] rhv T Sii] 5tck rov T d3 flv:ii] flvai koI
r6Tf W : ire BT oury] avrh B
;
207 e nAATI2N02
fxkv ds Ti]v TrpocnjKovcrav, totc bi ds a\\r)v TLOeVTas
(TvXkajiriv;
212. Tavra Xeyw.
5 0EAI. Ma AC ov toCvvv aixvr]fxovbi, ovhe yk ttco
rjyov/xai ^TTCoTaarOai tovs ovtco? \ovTas.
212. Ti ovv; otov tv roi toiovt(^ KacpQ " &aCTr]Tov "

ypd(f)(ov Tis dijTa Kal (1 olrjTaC re bdv yp(i(f)ei.v Kal ypd\lrr},
208 xal av " eoScopoy " (T:L\êipS)v ypd(îv Tav koI ei olrjTaC
T beXv ypd(l)eLV Kal ypd\j/r], ap^ (TrCa-Ta^rdaL (fii^croixfv ovtov
Tr\v TTp(aTr]v tS)V vfxcTepoov 6vo]xdT(>)V (Tv\Xafir]v;
0EAI. 'AAA.' dpTL wixoXoyrj^rafxev tov ovt(ds eyovTa

6 ixri-n(a dhivaL.
212. KcoAvet ovv tl koX irepX rr]V hevripav a-vWa(3r]v koI
TpLTr]v Kal TTdpTr]V ovrcos x^'^ '^^^ avrov;
0EAI. Ovbev ye.

'Ap' ovv t6t Tr]V 8ia (TTOLxeCov bieôbov eyjxtv
2X2.
lo ypa\}/L " 0aCTr]Tov " /xera opdrjs b6^r]s, otov eîjs ypd(})r];
0EAI. Arj\ov brj.
b 212. OvKovv TL dveTTLCTriixoiV &V, 6pda b\ bo^d^(t)V, c2y
(^âixev;
0EAI. Nai.
2i2. Ao'yoy ye exu^v ixeTo. 6p6r}s b6^r]s. tt/i; yap 8ta
5 roO crrotxfiow 6bbv extoy ^ypa(f)V, fjv br] \6yov i)ixo\oyq-
(Taixev.
0EAI. 'AAtj^^.
. 212. 'Ecrrii' apa, a> eraLpe, ixeTa \6yov 6p6r] b6â, rjv
ovTT(t) beL eTTL(TTr\p.r]v KoKelv.

lo 0EAI. Ktj;8wevet.
212. "Ovap br], ws toLKev, e7T\ovTr]o-aixev olrjdevTes exeiy
Tbv d\r]dea-TaTov eTTL^TT-qixris \6yov. rj ixrJTTO) KaTr]yopQ)p.ev
C icrco? ydp ov tovt6 tls avTov optetrat, dAAa to ôlttov
e8 otriral] oUrai BT et mox a r rt ora. W a 2 Te]

Ti W b I 8 om. W b5 typatl>ty W b8 &pa tffriv W
b9 Ka\t7 B
0EAITHTO2 2o8c
fwo? T(ji>v Tp<MV, SiV iv yk n iâ\i.iv Xoyov $rj(r(r6ai tov

(^ncnriixrjv optCoixevov boâv elvai 6p6i]v fxiTa koyov.
0EAI. Ôpdias VT:k\xvri(Tas' ert yap ev Xolttov. to plkv
yap r]v biavoCas kv (fxjovfj dxnrep (ibooXov, t6 8' aprt X^x^^v 5
bia (TTOLxeCov obbs (Trt t6 okov t6 8e bij TpLTov tC Xkyeis;
212. Oirep av ol TToWol eLTToiev, t6 ^xclv tl crrip.elov
(LTTelv (ri T^v aTravTOiv bLa(f)(pL t6 epcoTrjdkv.

0EAI. Olov TLva TLvos X^'^ l^^'' ôyov elTTLV;
212. Olov, 1 ôvXiL, rjkLOV Trepi Ikov^v oXp.aL uol eXvaL d
aTTobeâcrdaL, otl t6 kaixirpoTaTov ecrri toiv /cara t6v ovpav6v
LOirrojv Trepl yqv.
0EAI. Yiavv pikv ovv.
2i2. Aaê bij ov x.P'^ (tpriTai. (ttl 8e oiTep apTL 5
keyopLv, b)s apa Tip bLa(f)opav kKaa-Tov av Aa/x/3ar7/y rj rwy
akkoyv bLa(f)4p(L, koyov, a>s (paaL TLves, kri\l/ri' e(i)s 8' av
KOLVOV TLVOS 60(17777/, (KLV(t)V TTepL (70L iCTTaL 6 koyOS b)V CLV
ri KOLVOTTIS T?.
0EAI. Mavddvo)' KaC p.0L boKel KakS)s ^Xî-v koyov t6 e

TOLOVTOV KakeXv.
22. "Os 8' av p.T 6p6iis bo^rjs Trepi otovovv tS)v ovtcov
Tj]v bLacpopav tQv akk(DV TTpocrkdjBr], avTOV kiTLcrTriiJ.o)V yeyovobs
tcTTaL ov TTpoTepov ^v boâ(rTr]s. 5
0EAI. (Paixev ye p/y ovrco.
212. Nw brJTa, o) QeaCTrjTe, TTavTaTTacrLV eyoiye, eTreLbi]
kyyvs axnTep (TKLaypafpriixaTos yiyova tov keyoixivov, crvvCriixL
ovb\ crixLKpov cos 8e dêKrn/foj TT6ppo)6ev, ecpaCveTO tC ixot,
kiyecr6aL. lo
0EAI. riws tC tovto;
2i2. ^pacTd), eav olos re yeVco/Ltat. 6p6i]v eyody^ ex'^^ 209
e2 <paixtv W
d 3 Trepi yriv I6vr<i)v W
d. 4 vavv fjiev oZv
. . . \6yov
209 aa om. TW: d^ iiaKptpfi BD om. T W:
d8 (Kfivuv] fKfivov^W <ro] ferojs &v] W
64 &\\<a)v'\ ^W
ovTtav W 6 5 o5] ovKfp W
e 6 /t-^j'] vvv e 7 iravTd- W
iracriv tywyf W
iravTavaffi yt iyii T
: 69 aiptiar^KT) Schanz :
aipfcrT-fiKTi T acptirr-fjKti
: a I Hyuyt W t-yo) T W :
rLATO, VOL. I. 23

209 a riAATllNOS
boâv TTfpl (Tov, (av ixV TTpoa-Xdfio) rbv <r6v koyov, yiyvuxTKiti
hri (re, d 8^ /xtj, Soâ^ca piovov.
0EAI. NaC.
5 212. Aoyos be yf ^v fj Trjs <rijs buKpopoTryros kpp.r]Viia.
0EAI. Ow-tos.
2Ii. ^WvLk ovv (boâôv p.6vov, aWo ti w tS)V 5AAa>r
bLa(f)epeLS, tovtidv ovbevos r]Trr6fxr]v Trj biavoCci;
0EAI. OVK ioiKf.

lo 2i2. Twy Koirci>v ti apa bifvoovpirjv, S)V ovb\v <tv imWov
/ Tts ÂAos ^xei.
b 0EAI. 'AvciyKTj.
2i2. 4>epe 8^ Trpo? Aio's' tt&s ttotc V t&) toiovto) ae

fAaAAoy iboâôv rj aXXov ovtlvovv; d(s ydp /xe buxvooviJ.vov
0)5 lo-Tiy ouTos 0atTr;Tos, os &v f\

T av6p(t)TT0s Kal (xrj
5 plva Kal 6(f)6aXp.ovs Kal a-Tîxa Kal ovto) 8t) kv (Kacrrov tS^v
p.(kQ)v. avTt] ovv rj btdvota ((rd^ oti iiaX.kov iroiriard /le
QeaLTTiTov rj Qi6bopov biavo(lcr6ai, rj tS)v \(yoiUv(t)V

^v(tS)v tov licryaTov;
0EAI. Ti yap;
lo 212. 'AAA' (av br] iir] p.6vov tov (\ovTa plva Kal 6(f)6a\-
C tiovs biavori6a), dXXa Kal tov (riix6v T( Kal (^6(f)da\iwv, fjLrj
Ti a^k av imWov bo^dao) 17 îiaxrrbv rj oaoL toiovtol;

0EAI. Oubiv.
212. 'AAA' ov Ttp6T(p6v ye, ot/iai, ^tatTTjTos (v i[xoL
5 bo$aa-6ria-(TaL, Trplv hv f] (ti/xo^ttjs avTT; t&v akXojv a-Lixori]-
T(DV dv eyo) ((apaKa bLd(f)op6v tl ixvrnxdov T:ap îxol (va-r]ixr]-
vaixdvr] KaTddr]TaL Kat TaAAa ovtco (^ ojv ci <rv rj /xe, Kat
iav avpLov dTrom/crco, dvaixvTâ-(i Kal Troif]a-(i dpda bo$d((LV

TT(pl a-ov.
10 0EAI. ' AXr]6iaTaTa.
a2 hac voce redit B

yjyi/citrxo) in a9 foucc] ôr/f B b7 t4
\ey6tJLfvov Cornarius C i /ui^ ri\ nfirt W C 7 T o-u l| ^ W
(sed {5 postea additum) 7 ov ^yui : B : ttafi ifj.^ T C8 avafi.v^<rfti
. . iroi-fifffts T
0EAITHTO2 aogd
2X2. riept Tr}v bLa(f)op6Tr}Ta apa Kol rj opdr) boâ av cirj d

eKaoTou TTepu
0EAI. âtyerai yf.
211. To ovv TTpoa-Xaêlv Koyov Trj opdfj bo^rj tl av Iti
etrj; ei /ler yap Trpocrbo^dcraL kiy^L fj
bLa(f>epeL tl tS>v 5
aXXdiv, TTavv yeXoia yCyveTaL fj eTriraîy.
0EAI. Um;
212. ^lv 6p6r}v boâv ^\op.V fj
t&v aAA<oy bLa(f)epL,
TOVTOiv Trpocrkaêlv KeAevei r]p.as opOrjv b6âv ?) t(^v dXXoiv
bLa(p4pL. Kal otrrcos rj p,V (rKVTaXrjs rj VTrepov 7/ otov 8?/ 10
Ae'yerai TrepLTpoTTrj iTpos Tavrqv Trfv fTTLTaîV ovbev hv XiyoL, e

TV(f)Xov 8e 7rapaKe'Aet;(ns &v fcaAotro StKatorepoi^* t6 ydp,
a )(0[XV, Tavra TTpo^rkaêlv KeAevetr, tjâ p.d6(oixv a
bo^dCojxev, Trdw yevvams olkv i(rKOT(t)p.V(o.
0EAI. Etire bi] tl vvvbrj u)s kp5>v (ttv6ov; 5

212. Et To Xdyov, S) iTaX, irpocrXafif.w yv&vaL KeAerêt,
dAAa fxr} bo^d^rai tijv bLa(j)op6Tr]Ta, rjbv XpripL av etrj tov

KaXXC^rTov t5)V TrepX eTito-rTy/iTjs Aoyov. to ydp yvCovai
(TTLcrTripi.rjv ttov XajSdv ((ttlv' ^ ydp; 210
0EAI. Na^.
2X2. OuKow fp(i)Tr]dLS, w? eotKe, ri eoTLV iTTL^rnJixr],
aTTOKpLViLTaL OTL boâ dp6l] pLTa TTLCrTrip.riS bLa(f)0p6Tr}T0S.
X6yov ydp iTp^^rXr^yf/Ls tovt^ hv etrj Kar' Klvov. 5

0EAI. 'EotKev.
2X2. Kat TTavTdTTacrC ye evrjdes, ^Tjrovirrooy r]p.&v fTTLcrrr]-
]xr]V, bdâv (f)dvaL 6p6r]V etvai jxeT iiTLcrTrjfxr]? eire 8ta<ôpo-
rTjro? etre otovovv. ovtc dpa at(r6r](rLs, S) &eaCTr]T, ovtc

b6â dXrj6r]S ovt /xer' dXr]6ovs b6^r]s Ao'yos Trpoo-ytyw/uei/os b
eTTia-rrj/xTj dv eirj.
0EAI. OVK OLKV.
d6 dirc^Tolij B d.9 fi/jLcis KeXfVft T d 10 (TKtndXr]s ^] (TKv-

rd\rj (TTj T e 2 5] Sf Kol W 64 5o|aâ)yU;' T 65 t tVe
5t) T et in marg. W ti yf Srj B y 7 5); B^ W ws fTtpov vvfOov

W
: :
Badham e8 Vto-T^/uT/v T bi fifra 5o{r;j aKridovs

23*
2iob nAATilNOS EAITHTOS
2fl. *.H ovv cri Kvovfxev rt koX dibCvofxev, u) ff)i\(, irfpl
5 CTricrr^/jtTjs, ^ iTdirra CKTeTOKaixfv;
0EAI. Kal val jxa Af cycoye ttXcCo) fj 8<ra (i)(pv iv
ilxavT^ 8ta tre etprjKa.
212. OvKovv TavTa ixkv iidvTa rj /xaiorrtK^ rjixlv Tiyvrf

dveixiaZd (prja-t, yy(vrj(r6ai, Kal ovk 5ta Tpo(f)rjs;
lo 0EAI. nairrdTraai. pikv ovv.

212. 'Eav Toivvv dXXcav fxcTa Tavra eyKVfxcav ^TriXfipT/s
C yCyvea-dai, co QealTrjTe, (dvTe yiyvrf, ^(Ktlovmv tai) i:X.ripr]s
hih Trjv vvv kîTacriv, idirre Kevos ^s, rJTTOv â-j] jSapvs roi?
avvova-i. Kal fjpiepdiTepoi a(a(f)p6v<jDi ovk olofxcvos fibevai &
fxrf oXaOa. Toaovrov yap fxovov 77 (pir] Texyr] bvvaTai, "nXiov
5 8e ovhiv, ovbi rt oiSa oiv ot aAAoi, oo-ot fxeydKoi Kal 6av-
fxdaLoi &vbps (laC re fcat yeyovaaiv Trjv bk fxaieCav Tavrrfv
eyctf T Kal fj fxrfTrjp k d(ov (Kdôfxev, t/ fxkv T(av yvvaiK&v,

d eyo) Toiv V(t)v re Kat yevvaC(i)v Kal oaoi KaXoC. vvv fxev
ovv dnravTrfTeov fxoi ets Trfv tov /Sao-tAecos oroar ^Trt rrfv
MeATjrou ypa(f)j}v ijv fxe yiypaTrrai.' ccoêv 8e, S eoScope,

8eSpo TTciAti' dTravT(ap.v.
b8 irctjra] orrain-a T bg (âtrj W koI om. T b II Tolfvy]

oiy Toivvv B c3 iTvvov(ii\ oIkti B
-!^
ai
20$I2TH2
0EOAOPO2 SflKPATHS St. I

EAEATH2 HENOS 0EAITHTO2 P* ^^^
0EO. Kara ti]v xOe^ oixoXoyiav, o) 2(u/c/3ares, rJKOfxev a

avToC T KO(T}iiois KoX Tovhe TLva êvov ayofjLev, t6 ^xkv
yevos $ 'EAeas, (Taipov be t&v aiM(f)l Ylap]ievihr]v /cat
7.rivu)va [kTaipu>v\ fxdXa he avhpa (f)iX6(roôv.
211. 'A/)' ovv, S) eoSojpe, ov îvov aWd Ttva 6(ov 5

dy(i)V KaTa tov 'Op.r\pov \6yov kikriOas; os (f)r}(rLV dXXovs
T deovs TOLS dvOptaTTOis omaoL ixiTi)(0V(TLV aihovs hLKaias, b
Kal hr] Kal tov îvLov ov\ i]KL(rTa debv (Tvvoitahov yLyv6-
p.(Vov vfipets T Kal evvopiias tcov dvdpdiTcov KaOopdv. t^x
ovv dv Kal (Toi tls ovtos tS>v KpeLTTovo^v <tvvt:olto, (pavkovs
rjfxds ovTas (v tols koyoLS i7ro\}/6ixv6s re Kal ekiyôov, debs 5
biV TLS ikeyKTLKOS.

0EO. OVX OVTOS 6 TpOTiOS, W ^(jOKpaTS, TOV ^VOV,
dXXd ]XTpL(aTpos t5)V 776/31 Tas epLhas i^nrovhaKdTcov. Kai
]X0L hoKL debs fxv dvi]p ovhap.u>s 2vaL, d^Los fxrjv iTdvTas
ydp iyii) tovs (pLkoa6(f)ovs tolovtovs Trpoa-ayopevu). C
21i. Kai Kaku>S y, OD (f)ik. TOVTO }XVT0L KLvhvVVL TO
a 2 riva] rhv W a 3 ruv W : rhv BT napiJ.veiSriv B ut solet

a4 tToipo' secl. Fischer &6 &KKovs'\ aW-fiXovs B b 4 oStj W
b 9 avTjp Bekker avijp B T
: 2 koI om. B 7] yap W
2i6c nAATHNOS
yeVos ov ttoXv tl paov ws Ittos il-mw ^lvaL hiaKpivnv t) to
Tov dcov' Ttavv yap avbpe^ ovtol TtavToloi <f>avTa^6fjL(voi 8ia
5 Ti]V T(av aXXoiv ayvoiav " kincrTpux^GxTL iroAj/as, oi [ii]
TrAaoTui? dAA' ovTOiS (l>Lk6cro(\)oi, KaOopwvTfs v\j/69ev tov

TcSi/ k6.T(i> îov, Kox Tols ix\v hoKova-LV fivai Tov \ir]hivos
[ri/uiiot], roi? 8' 5^toi rou Trayros* Ka\ tot^ y.(v TroAiriJcoi
d (f)avTaCovTaL, tot 5 a-(x^L(rrai, TOTe 8' Iotij; ot? 8o'ây
Trapdo-xoivr' hv a)s 7rai'rd7rao-u' Ixo^^tcs pxivlkQ>s. tov p.iVTOL

îvov Tjfxa' Tjhiois hv Trvv6avoip.riv, ei (f>i\ov avT^, Ti Tavd
21'j OL "Trepl Tov iKL t6ttov riyovvTo Kal (IvoiiaCov.
0EO. Td iroia hri;
2f2. '2o(f)La-Triv, ttoXltlkov, ^L\6a-o(f>ov.
0EO. Ti 8e jixdAto-ra Kal to tto16v tl iTfpl avrS^v Sta-
5 TToprjdels epia-QaL hi(vor]dr\s;
212. To'8e' TTOTfpov ^v iTavTa TavTa (v6p.L(ov rj hvo, ?/
KaOaTTip To. 6v6p.aTa Tpia, Tpia kol tcl yivr\ hLaLpovjxivoL
KaS' %v ovop.a \yivos\ eKdoTO) TTpoa-rjiTTOv;

0EO. 'AAA' ov8ei5, ws iy^fxai, (f>d6vos auro) 8teA5eti'
10 avrd* t/ Trw?, a> ê^ve, Ae'ya>/uer;
b HE. OvT(i>9, S> 0eo'8a>pe. (f)96vos p-tv yap ov8ets ov8e

yoKiTTov eiTretv ort ye rpt" rfyovvTO' Kad^ cKaarov p.r]v hiopi-
aaa-dai a-a(f)m tl ttot Iotiv, ov afXLKpov ovh\ pahLov epyov.
0EO. Kat ]xev 8jj jcard Tvxr]v ye, u) 2w/c/?ares, Ao'ya>v
5 e7reAd/3oi; TTapairkrjaioov S>v kol Trplv r)p.as hevp' eAêtr
Sie/ja^rwvres avTov (Tvyxavojx^v, 6 8e ravrd dTTcp Trpos o-e
vvv Kal t6t ea-K-qTTTeTO TTpbs r)ixas' ^Trct Sta/cTjKoei/at ye
<f)r]aLV LKavais Kal ovk a\xvr]}xoviLV.
C 212. M^ Toivw, o> ^4v, fjixwv nriv ye iTp^Tr]v alTr](rdvTo>v
yapLV dTTapvr]dLS y^vrj, Tocrdvhf. 8' rnilv ir^Tepov

(f>pdC(.
C3 -iroXv B T et s. V. W : rtivv pr.W C 4 rov etov] tS>v Bfuv Cobet

<>'^<^<ô</>'> secl. Cobet
itvSpa Bekker : ivSpts BT C5 0/m^
C8 Tifxtot secl. Madvig : g|io et mox tojs 5 tov vavTSs Cobet

a6 ToDra Tra^Ta W a7 rck 7k>7 T : ^fV B 8 yjvos secl.
W
Schleiermacher : êVf j Stephanus vl Cobet : a 10 Kfjofifv
b5 wi' Kctl f)fAf7s irplv Cobet koI rmfts irplv Schanz
:
20ct)I2TH2 217 c
fXoiiOas ijhiov avTos eirl (ravTov fxaKp^ X6y<a 8ieieVai Xcycoy
TOVTO o av kvhiiâadai rw j3ov\r^9f]S, 17 8t' epcorrjo-ecoi', olov
iTOT Kal YlapfxevLbrj xpw/j,eVa) /cat 8tef toVrt Aoyous TrayKaAovs 5
TTapeyevoix-qv eyo) Jêôs wi;, iKeivov îaka br} TOTe oirros
npea-fivTov;
HE. T(3 /xeV, S ^(aKpaT9, oXvttms re KOt evr^vioos Trpoa- d
biaXeyofxivc^ paov ovtco, to Trpos aXkov et 8e /xtj, to Kad
avTov.
2i2. "Eêo-rt Toivvv tu>v 'KapovTiav ov av jBovXrfdfjs (k-
Keâa-dai, TrdvTes yap rmaKOvaovTai o-ot TrpauiS' a-vfj.l3ov\ia 5
ixyjv ipoi xpwMevos rwy re'a)y rtra alprfar], QeaiTr]Tov Tovbe,
7) Kal TUiV dXkiiiv ei rts rot /cara vovv.
HE. 'i2 Sw/cpare?, atScdS rts ^' exci to vvv TTpG>Tov avy-
yevojievov vp.LV fir] KaTo. o-fXLKpov eiros irpos etros Trotetcrât
TTfv a-vvovcriav, aAA' eKTeivavTa dTTop.r]KvveLV Xoyov avxvov e

KaT kfxavTOV, etre Kat Trpos eTepov, oXov eTrtSet^ti; ttolov-
fxevov rw yap ovtl to vvv pr]devovx oaov wSe epcoTr^dev

eKTtiaeLev av airrb eTvai tls, dkka Tvy^dveL koyov nap.fxrfKovs
ov. To be av ao\ fxr] \apiêa6aL Ka\ Tolabe, akk(as re /cat 5
aov keâvTos u)S eiTre?, dêvcv tl KaTa(j)aiveTai fxoL ko.l
dypLov. eTTet QeaiTrfTov ye tov iTpoabiakeyopevov eTvaL 218

be\opaL TTavTdiTaaLv e^ wv avTOs re iTpoTepov bLeikeyfxaL Ka\
av To. vvv fxoL bLaKekevr].
0EAI. Apa Toivvv, u) êve, ovTOi Ka\ KaOdirep et-e

Sco/cpcirTjs TTaaLV KeyapLafxevos ear]. 5
HE. KLvbvveveL Trpbs fxev TavTa ovbev eTL keKTeov elvaL,
eatrrjre* Trpos be ae 7/817 '"^ ]J-(Ta tovto, cb? eoLKe, yiyvoLTo

av 6 koyos. dv 8' dpa tl rw jLi7//cet iTovSiV dyQrj, fxrf e/xe
airtacrâi TovTOiv, dkkd Tovabe tovs aovs eTaipovs.
C 4 otwv W C 5 Ka\ secludendum putat Schanz d 8 rb vvv

T W : rhv vovvB e 2 oToy Ast '6aov B T e 5 re] 8e T
W a3
:
66 (liras 5iaKf\evr)] TrapaKeKfvi) W a 4 8pa Badham :
Hpa B : apa T W a6 flvai \eKTfov W a7 5 eatTijTe Schanz

a8 ^jj ifif TW : /x^/it Cobet : ^rj /Ae B
:
2i8b nAAT12N02
b 0EAI. AAA' oifxaL fitv br] vvv ovtws ovk dire/jeu/* av o
apa Ti ToiovTov yiyvr^Tai, Kal Tovhi irapaXrj^j/oiJifda SoiKpdrT],
TOV ÛiKpaTOVS pifV 6p.(i>VV\X0V, (p.OV 8c r]\l.KI.(OTT]V Koi (Tvy-

yvpivaa-Triv, w avvbiaTTovelv p.iT e/iou to. TioXka ovk arjdes.
5 HE. Ev Aeyeiy, Kal ravTa ixev IbCq ôvXfva-rj Tipdiovros
Tov Xoyov Koivrj bc fXT ifJLOv a-OL avaKiineov ap\ofuvia
TTpSiTOV, 0)5 p.oX (f}aLVTaL, VVV aHO TOV (rO(f)LarOV, ^rjTOVVTL
C Kal (p.(l)avLCovTL \6y(o tl ttot Ioti. vvv yap brj av re Kayui

TOVTOV TiepL TOVVOjXa fJLOVOV ^)(ÔfJLV KOLVT}, TO bf tpyOV ((f)'
oj Ka\ovp.v kKaTepos to.^ hv i8ia jrap' rfp.LV avrols (\OLfJL(v
b(L b( ad TTavTos iT(pL To TTpayfj.a avTo pJaWov 6ta Xoycov rf
5 Tovvofia fxovov crvvdifxoKoyifadaL )(0)pLS koyov. to b( (pvkov

O VVV (TTLV00Vfi(V OlT^LV OV TTAvTtaV pqOTOV Ovkka^dv TL
TTOT (CTTLV, 6 (To^toTJjs' oaa 8' av tG)v pL(yak(ov bd 8ia-

TTovdadaL KakSiS, TT(p\ tS)V tolovt(i)V b(boKTaL TTaa-LV Kal TrdAai
d t6 TTpoT^pov (V a-fXLKpols Kal pqoaLv avra bdv p.(k(Tav, TTplv
(V avTOLS TOLS fX(yL(rTOLS. vvv ovv, S) &(aLTrfT(, eycoyc kol

vCdv ovT(t) a~vpLJ3ovk(vo), xakcTTOv Kai bvcrdi]p(VTOv r]yr]aap.(V0LS
(IvaL To Tov (ro(l)LaTov yivos iTpoT^pov (V dAAo) pqovL t)]v
5 fi(9obov avTOV TTpofX(k(Tav, d fxr] av tto6(v (VTT(TrT(pav

IXis cZiretr dAA?;!^ obov.
0EAI. 'AAA' ovK Ixft).
HE. BovAei bfjTa iT(pL tlvos t5>v cfiavkoov fX(TL6vT(s
TT(Lpa6(iipL(v 7Tapdb(LypLa avro dicr6aL tov fxdCpvos;
e 0EAI. Nai.
HE. Ti br]Ta TTpoTa$aLfX(0' hv (vyv(ocrrov fikv Kal a-fXL-
Kpov, k6yov b( fxr]b(vos Ikarrova i^\ov t5)V fx(L(pv(iiv; olov

aaTrakL(VTrfS' ap' ov iTaaC re yvcapLfxov Kal anTOvbrjs ov tto.vv
5 TL ttoAAtjs Ttros (Tra^Lov;
0EAI. Ovrcos.
b 3 ervin\\iKi<iTri!/ T b4 tci iroWi )u*t' ifiov W C i t* W

om. BT C 3 avroii Vf^" W C 5 avvofio\(rfi,aatTOai B avvo- :
fio\oyft(rBai W C7 6 (rotpKrr^fis secl. Cobct c8 rwy toioiJtciiv]

TouToii' Stobaeus di irpli/] rply &k W d8 S^Ta] 5^ W
20I2TH2 i2i9a
EE. MiOobov fxrjv avTov ckTTCC^ Kal koyov ovk av7nTri- 219
Seioy rjixiv Ix^"^ irpos o jBovkofJieda.
0EAI. KaAo)? av exoi.
HE. 4>e/3e b^, Tfjb^ apybnx^da avTov. Kai fioL keyc
TTOTfpov o)s Te^viTTiv avTov 7/ Tiva aTi^vov, aKkr]v h\ 5
bvvafxtv i)(pvTa 6r](rop.ev;

0EAI. "HKto-ra ye aT)(yov.
HE. 'AAAa firjv t&v ye t)(vu)v TracrZv a\bbv (tbr] bvo.
0EAI. Hw?;
HE. TfoopyCa fxev Kal ocrr] Trept to dvrjTov Trav crQfia 10
OepaTreCa, to re a3 Trepi ro crvvOeTov KciX 'nXacrTov, o br]
a-Kcvos oavofiaKafxev, rj re fxifxrfTiKr], avfj.TTavTa Tavra btKaLOTaT b

av evl TTpoa-ayopevoLT av ovofxaTi,.
0EAI. Hcis Kal tCvl;

HE. Ylav oTTep hv fxrf TrpoTtpov tls ov vaTepov ei? ovaCav
ayr], tov fxev ayovTa TTOLelv, t6 6e ayofxevov TTOLelaOaC ttov 5
<f)ap.V.
0EAI. 'Op6(os.
HE. Ta 8e ye rw8r/ (h^ bt,r]k6ofXv airavTa eixci' eis
TovTO Tr]v avTG>v bvvafXLV.
0EAI. Eixe yap ovv. 10
HE. YlotrfTLKrfv ToCvvv avTCL avyK(f)a\aLcaadfxcvoi irpoa-

eiTTco/xer.
0EAI. 'Eo-ro). C
HE. To 8j/ fxa6r]fiaTLKov av fxeTo. tovto etbos oXov Ka\
To Tr]s yvoopCaatis t6 re xP^/^ctTto^riKoy Kal dyoovLaTLKov Kal
6r]pevTLK6v, eTretdr; brjfXLovpyeZ fxkv ovbev tovtu)V, to. bl ovTa
KOL yeyov^ra tcl fiev xîpoCrai Aoyois Kat TrpdêaL, to. be rois 5
yjeLpovp.evoLS ovk kiTLTpeTTeL, fxdkLaT dv ttov 8ia TavTa avv-
diTavTa Ta fxeprf Teyvr] rts KrqTLKr] Aexêica dv bLaTTpexf/eLev.
a3 KoKwsl Ka\ws Toiwv Vi/ a6 &fi(rofi.(v'\ (fyficrofjifi' 'W a 7 7

oin. B b I SiKai6raT' h.v] SiKaidraTa W
Stobaeus b 4 ov]
ivW b8&om. BTW e 2 SJ)] Se Heindorf c 7 &v
Sia7'piif'Cic>' T : dirptifetei' Stobaeus
aigc nAATX2N02
0EAI. Nar Trpîroi yap &v.
d EE. KrqTiKrjs bj] Koi TroLrjTLKrjs (TViXTTaaiav ovcrSiV TuiV
TC)(yS>v v TTOTipa Tr]v acnTa\LVTtKr}v, S) eaiTTjTf, Tid5>\xv;

0EAI. 'Ev KTr]TLKfj TTOV bfjXoV.
EE. KrTjTiK^s 8e ap' ov bvo ei87j; to ixkv kKovTcov TTpoi

5 eKOVTas p.iTafi\r]TLKov ov 8ia re hoipeS>v /cat ixLaduKreoiV Kal
ayopacTiuiv, to 8e Xolttov, Kar ^pya ^ KaTa Aoyous xe^-P^^'
rj
fxcvov (rv[XTTav, xeLpciiTLKov hv iir];
0EAI. iJatVerat yovv k twv elprijxevcov.

EE. Tt 8e'; Tr]v xêtpcortK^v ap' ov bLxrj TfxrjTiOv;
10 0EAI. nf);
e EE. To fxkv ava(\)avbov oKov ayo)VL(TTLKov devTas, to 8e
Kpvcjâlov avTrji ttclv OrjpevTLKOv.
0EAI. Nat'.
EE. Tr]V bi ye }xr]v dr]pVTLKr]v akoyov to /xtj ov Tp.vLV
5 bL^.
0EAI. Aeye oTrrj.
EE. To }XV a^yov yivovs bL^Xofxivovs, to 8' ix\jru)(ôv.
0EAI. Ti jxrjv; eiTrep ^(ttov ye ap.(f)(ii.

220 SE. ITws 8e ovK iarov; Kal Sei ye 7//ixas ro /lev
rciiy a\j/v)(OiV, av(ovv]xov ov TT\r]V Kar VLa Trjs KoXvfx-
l3r]TLKf]i cLTTa ptpr] KOL TOLavT aXXa ^pa\a, \aLpLV

(CLcraL, t6 8e', t&v kfxy^yoiv CôiV ov(rav Oripav, iTpo(TnTLV
5 ^(iio0r]pLKriv.
0EAI. "Ea-Toi.
EE. ZioodripLKrji 8e Sp' ov bLiTXovv et8o? hv Ae'yotro ey
8tK7/, To ixV Treôu ye^yous, TToAAots eiêo-t Kot diô/xao-t
bLjipriixivov, TTCôOripLKOv, To 8' Tpov VV(rTLK0v ^wov ttSi'
lo IvvypodripLKov;
0EAI. naw ye.
C 8 /a( secl. Cobet d. 5 ayopiafoiv koX fiiadaxrfuv T e i Btvrat

Stobaeus: 6* /tos W : eivrts BIl e^Sfom. W ou om. W
aa ii/ Heindorf iav : BT Wom. Stobaei cod.
: A as toioCt'] t4
toioDt' W
204>I2TH2 22ob
HE. NeuoTi/cou /xtji; t6 /xey TTTtjvov (f)vXov 6pa>fXv, to 8e b

ivvbpov;
0EAI. ncSs 8' ot;;
HE. Kai Tov TTTrjvov )u,r)y yerous wao-a TjfXLV 7] Oripa
Xiyerai ttov riy opvLdevriKri. 5
0EAI. Aeyerat yap ovv.

HE. ToS 8e ivvbpov o-)(êhov to otjvoXov akLevTLKrj.
0EAI. Nat'.
HE. Tt 8e; Tavrr^v av ti]V 6r\pav ap' ovk av Kara
p.iyL(TTa p-ipr) hvo hLiXoLp.v; lo
0EAI. Kara Troia;

HE. Ka0' h. To piev epK(rLV avToOev Trotetrai ttjv Oripav,
To 8e TrA.Tjy^.
0EAI. n&)s Ae'yets, Kat Trrj hLaLpovfJievos kKaTepov;

HE. To juey, ori Trav ocrov av evcKa K(a\vcr(os (tpyrj tl C
TrpLe\ov, epKos etKo? oro/xaêti/.
0EAI. ITaru /xey ovv.
HE. Kvprovs 8?) Kat hCKTva Kal /Spoxovs Kal TTopKovs Kal
Ta TOLavTa fxwv aAAo ri Trkrjv epKrj \pr] TTpocrayopeveLv; 5
0EAI. Ovhev.
HE. ToiSro pkv apa kpKoOripLKOv rr/s aypas to fxipos
(f)1](rop.V 7/ ri TOLOVTOV.
0EAI. Nat.
HE. To 8e ayKL(rTpoLS kol TpLohova-L TrXrjyr} yLyv6p.Vov 10
iTepov \xkv K(Lvov, Trkr]KTLKr]v 8e rtra difpav rjpias irpo^r- d

etTretr eî Aoyo) vvv xpewr" 7) rt ris av, u) 0eatT7jre, eiTTOt
KaAAiov;
0EAI. 'A/xeA<3/xer rou dyo^/iaros* d/3Ket yap Kal tovto.
HE. Ttjs roifw 7rAr/KrtKJ/s to fxkv vvKTepLvov oXp.aL 5
b I 6pwfj.ev post ewSpoi/ transp. W b 9 aS T W

Stobaeus tiv B :
caTa] icaTo Ta Stobaeus 10 SifKoifiev Stobaei cod. A Stf\oi-

b
W
:
BT
fX7]v b 12 Ti>] To avT66(v al. avrSdi B T aiiToTv
W
: :
Baumann C4 5^] 5 W c6 ovSiv &\KoW da 5

Stobaeus : om. B T (Xiroi ante totV^Te transp. W
22od nAATilNOS
TTpos TTvpos (fiu>s yiyvofiivov VTt' avToiv T(DV irepl Trjv O-qpav
7rvpVTLKr]v prjdrjvai a~vfMj3l3r]KV.
0EAI. ndvv ye.

HE. To 5e ye ixe6r]pi(pi.v6v, u>s ix^^^^ *^ aKpois ay-
lo Kia-Tpa Kal Twy TpiohovTutv, irav ayKLO-TpcxmKOV.
e 0EAI. Aeyerai yap ovv.
HE. Tov Toivvv ayKLo-TpevTLKov ttjs TrXrjKTLKrjs to jxfv
&V(i>9V (is t6 Kcira) yLyvopievov 8ta ro tols Tpiobova-iv ovrco
fiaAi<TTa xprjaOaL TpiobovTLa tls olfiaL Ke/cAr/Tat.
5 0EAI. 4>ao-t yow TLves.

HE. To 8e ye XoiTroy eoriv ^v (tl ixovov <ws eiTreti^ elbos.
0EAI. To TTotoy;
HE. To Trjs evavTLas TavTrj TrXriyrjs, ayKLo-Tpta t yiyvo-
pLVov Kal tS>v lydvtiiv ov\ fj
tls hv rvxj] tov (T(Lp.aTos, Sicritep
221 TOt? rpto8ou(rtv, aXka irepX Tr]v K(f)a\r]v Kal to aTo^xa tov
6r]pev9ivTOS K(iaTOT, Kal k(xto}9V els tovvcwtlov dvoi
pdjSboLS Kal KakdfxoLs dvaa^(aixV0V' ov tC (prjcroixev, a>
QeaLTr]T, belv Tovvofxa key(r9aL;

5 0EAI. AoKcD piiv, dnep dpTL i:povdiixe9a beiv kêvpeZv,
TOVT aVTO vvv dTTOTT\ea-9ai.
HE. Nw dpa Trjs daTta\LX)TLKT}s TtipL crv re Kayct)
b (rvv(i)}XoXoyr]Kap^V ov ]x6vov Tovvofxa, dWd Kat tov \6yov

Trept avTo Tovpyov L\r](f>afXV LKavcis. a-vixTrd(rr]s ydp Txvr]s
To fxev rjfXLo-v fxepos kttjtikoi; t/v, KTr]TLKov be xf'/">TtKoV,
Xet/jojrtKou be 9r]pVTLK6v, tov 8e ^TjpeurtKou ^wo^jjptKoV,
5 ^(ao9r]pLKOv 8e ivvypo9r]pLK6v, evvypo9r]pLKOV be to KdT(a9ev
Tfirjfxa o\ov aAteurtKoi', aAteurtK^s 8e TrATjKTtKoi', ttAtjk-
TtK^s 8e dyKLCTTpevTLKdv tovtov be to irepl Tr]v KaT(t)9ev
C dvo) Tr\r]yi]v dvaainnfxevr^v, drr' avrrjs tt/s irpdêcos dcpo-
d.8 7] fifv olv W ^ 6 4 Tjs ol/uai B Stobaeus : olyuai th T

e 7 tJ) irolov T W : om. B e 8 rainris W 9 j^ B
tis] ^tis
a2 flijpf uojôs W a3 KaXo'|uois] T*po^cT(' HerocJianus a^SuKw
;ttV B Stobaeus : 8oKa)/ii/TW a^ (tu Heindorf : oSffuBT t*]
yc W b5 fwSpoBripiKhv ivv5po6r)piKov T b7 rovrov^ rovro T
:
204>I2TH2 22IC
fjLomOev Tovvoixa, rj vvv a(nraXLiVTLKi] ^-qT-qOelcra eTrCKX-qv
yeyovev.
0EAI. TlavTdTTaa-L juey ovv tovto ye iKavcios bebrjXMTai.
HE. 4>epe bi], KaTCL tovto to napdbiLy]ia Ka\ tov ao({)L(rT7]V 5
TTLX(LpS)IXV (Vpelv OTL TTOT ioTLV,

0EAI. KojuiSt; p.\v ovv.
HE. Kal p.i]v eKiLVo y r]V to î^Trjjxa irpSiTov, TTOTfpov
ibL(aTr]v 7/ TLva T)(vr]v i\ovTa O^tôv itvai tov aaTiakievrqv.

0EAI. NaC. lo
HE. Kal vvv br] tovtov iStcorTjv 6r](ro]iV, a> &aCTr]T, r] d

TTavTdTTacTLV 0)9 dXqOSis (ro(f)L(JTqv;
0EAI. Ovba]j.(a9 IbLooTqv' fxavOdvoi yap o keyeLS, o)?
TravTos bel tolovtos eTvai t6 ye dvo]Ma tovto ^xcov.

HE. 'AAAa TLva t^xvtjv ovtov r]]M.v tyovTa, ws toLKi, 5
6(t4ov.
0EAI. TCva TTOT ovv bi] Tavrqv;
HE. 'Ap' S) TTpos 6iG>v -qyvor^Kaixev Tavbpbs tov dvbpa
ovTa (Tvyyevrj;
0EAI. TCva Tov; 10
HE. Tov d(nTakL(VTr]v tov (ro(pL(rTov.
0EAI. n^; f
HE. 0rjpeirra tlvc KaTa(f>aCva-6ov d[X(p(a fxOL.
0EAI. Ttros 6r]pas aTepos; tov ]xkv ydp iT^pov (LTTOfxev. e
HE. Atxâ TTov vvvbi] bLcCKofxev Tr]v dypav TTaa-av, vevarL-
KOV jXfpOVS, TO be TTeCoV T]XVOVTS.
0EAI. Nat.
HE. Kat To ]XV bLr]Kdo]xev, dcrov TrepL ra vevoTLKa tcov 5
Vvbpu)V' To 6e TT^6v idaap.ev dcrxLorov, ctTToWes ort
TTokveLbes etrj.
C8 ^fiTtjfj.a] QtfToifxtvov W d 4 iravrhs

e 9 Texvr]y Tiva W
Se TotoCros Winckelmann : toiovtos B Trdvrais 5et TOJoiiToi' T
iravTOiis Sel
W
:
d.5 xorTtt ^ftn' auTJj' d8

ip^l ap' ovv V^ 10 toD Heindorf d
TovTov B T d 13 KaTacpaivitrQoKrav pr. W
e 2 vvv i^ T :
vvv B airacrav W vfvcTTiKhv /xipos Madvig e 3 irfôd Tt-

fivovTfs T W : irtQty Tf fivovTOS B 67 tfTj] fXr\v B
aaaa IlAATilNOS
222 0EAI. Udvv ye.
HE. Mexpt /xey toCvvv ivravOa 6 o-o^ktt^s Kal [6]
do-77aAteur?)s afxa aTTo ttjs kttjtik^s T^yirqs TTOpevio-dov.
0EAI. 'EotKaroi' yovv.

5 HE. 'EKTpiTTea-Oov 8e ye diro T^y CiaoOrjpLKrjs, 6 pifv (irl
6d\aTTdv TTov Kal TioTap.ovs koX kCfxvas, ra iv tovtois Câ

drjpeva-oiMCVOs.
0EAI. TC p.riv;
EE. *0 b4 ye eirl [ttjv] yv^ '^**^ Trora/xouy (T^povs av
lo rira?, TrAourou Kal reoTTjros olov \iix<avas d^66vovs, tov
TovTOLS 6pip.p.aTa xiip(ii(T6p.ivos.
b 0EAI. U5>s Aeyeis;

HE. T^s TreC^s ^T/pas yCyvea-dov biuo ixiyCara TLvk
pLpL.
0EAI. notoy KdTpov;

5 HE. To pikv tS>v i]pApu>v, to 8e tS^v dypCoiV.
0EAI. Eir' eoTt rts drjpa tS>v rjixepMv;
HE. EtTrep ye eo-rii' dv6p(i}7ros r]p.pov (wov. 6s 8e otttj
XaCpfLS, etre jurjSer rtêts 'qpifpov, etre aAAo p.V r]p.p6v tl,
Tov 8e &v6p()iTT0v dypLov, efre qp.epov fikv Ae'yet? au ror

10 dvdpoiTTov, dv6p(aiT(i)v 8e ixr]hep.Cav rjyfj 6r\pav TOVTOiV oiTdTip
dv riyr] (f)C\ov eiprja-daC a-oL, tovto rnxlv hLopLaov.
C 0EAI. 'AAA' Tjixds re rjixcpov, S $ve, riyovixaL Côv,

6r]pav re dv6p(aiT(i}v cTvaL Ae'ya).
HE. Atrrr/v toCvvv Ka\ T-qv r]pLpodr]pLKr]v etTrco/xey.
0EAI. Kara ri kiyovTes;

5 HE. T^v ixkv \r](TTLKr]v Ka\ dvbpaTTobLOTLKr^v kol rvpav-
az Tolvvv] odv W Kol] re koX B 6 om. W as 5e 7

TW 5' 7^ ^ a9 5 7] W
5" t^j' om. W a 10 olov
:
Xeiixwvas iipdivovs secl. Cobet b2 yiyvtcrdcD B ^j^vfVffaii' W

W W
:
bs kypiuv transp. \>6 rwv rifjLepaiv 0^pa

om. W
. . . ijnipuDV
b7 7e] T6 T Heindorf
avdpoDiros coni. Ji; T :
b8 Ttfleis Cobet &\\o Ccbet

6^^ tA\ol b 10 ^Trtfrep' &r]
om. W
^)
STtvtp iiv Badham dirorfpov Cobet

: b 1 1 dprjadai ffoi
Si6piffov T W SiopiffTtov B et Ttov s.v.
: W
c i 5 |<V< ?ifjiepov W
20*I2TH2 222C
viicqv KoL (rvfXTTaa-av rqv TToXefJLLKT^v, kv TrdvTa, îaiov 6-qpav,
opKrdixevoi.
0EAI. KaAw?.
HE. Tr}V bi ye biKavLKrjv Kal brjfxrjyopiKrjv Kal itpocT-
op.iKr]Ti.Kr\v, kv av to (tvvoXov, TriQavovpyiKriv Tiva p.iav lo
T\vr]v TTpocreLTTOin-es. d
0EAI. 'Op6S>s.
HE. T?/s 8^ TTL6avovpyLKrjs Sirra Xeycofxev yivr].
0EAI. UoLa;
HE. To fxkv hipov ibCq, to 8e brffxoa-Lq yLyvofXfVOV. 5
0EAT. TLyv(T6ov yap ovv ftbos (KdTepov.

HE. OvKovv av Trjs ibLo6r]piXjTLKfjs to piev fXL(r6apvrfTLK6v
iiTTLV, To 8e b(iipo(f)OpLK6v;
0EAI. Ov fxav6dv(o.
HE. Trj t5>v ipdvTOJV 6rfpq tov vovv, o)? eoiKas, ouTrco 10
TTpocrecryjes.
0EAI. ToC Trept;

HE. "Ort rois d-qpevêlcri buipa TTpocrciTLbLbdaa-LV. e
0EAI. 'AArjêVraTa XiyeLS.
HE. ToCto fxev TOLVVV ipcdTLKrjs T(\vr]s eoTO) eiSos'.
0EAI. ndvv ye.
HE. Tou 8e' ye fXLa-6apvr]TLKov to pikv iTpoa-ofXLkovv bia 5
XapiTos jcai TTavTdiTaaL 81' rfbovfjs rb 8e'Aeap iTiTTOLrfp.ivov /cai
Tov p.Lcr6ov irpaTTdp.evov Tpo(f)i]v kavT(^ fx6vov KokaKLKrfv, (as
eyujuat, TTdvTes (f)aLp.ev hv (rf) rfbvvTLKTfv TLva TixyW ^^vaL. 223

0EAI. YlSis yap ov;
HE. To 8e e7rayyeAAo'/jiei'oi' /xev o)? dpeTrjs evcKa tcls
ofXLkLas TTOLovp.tvov, fXLcrQov 8e v6pLLa-fxa iTpaTT^p.evov, apa ov

TovTo To yevos kTp(a iTpoaeLTTfLV d^Lov 6v6p.aTL; 5
C 10 fv aS rh W
tvavro B: fv avrh : T d7 fj.t(r6apvfvriK6y
BTW: correxit Heindorf (et mox infra) d8 ia-Tiv] ri iffTiv T
d 10 rhv vovv post irpoirtVxes transp. W 6 I irphs eri Sccpa SiSSaaiv W
e3 elSos cTTw T ; ô-to) W e 7 fj.ovov'^ n6vr}v T Ko\aKLKi)v secl.
Schanz a i ^ add. Heindorf a5 yeVos] yeôv^y B
223 a rrAATiiNOS
0EAI. rTais yap ov;
EE. TiVi br] TOVT<a; TTipoi \iyiiv.
0EAI. ArjX.ov br]' tov yap (To(\)i(rrr]v fxoi boKovfxev
avr]vpr]Kvai.. tovt' ovv (yooyc ciTrcoy to TrpocrriKOv ovo]i av
lo T]yov]iai KoXciv avTov.
b HE. Kara 8r/ tov vvv, S 0ea[Tr]T, Xoyov, i)S (olkv,
7/ TXVr]S olKL(OTLKr]S, (xêipCOTtK^s), [KTr]TlKrjS,] dr]pVTLKfjs,

((oo9r]pCas, [ireCodr^pias,] x^p^raCas, [r]]Xpo6r]pLKT]s^ avdpoo-
TTodrjpCas, {TTL6avo9i]pCas), lhLo6r\pCas, [p.L(T6apvLKr]s,] vo]XL(r-
5 ]iaTOTT(iiKLKr]s, boÔTtaLbevTLKrjs, v(ov 'TrAovcriajr Kal ivboûiv

yLyvojxevr] 6rjpa irpo^rpr^Tcov, ws 6 vvv koyos r]]xlv (rv]xjiaCvL,
(rO(f)L(TTLKrj.
0EAI. riayrdtTrao-i ]Xv ovv.

C HE. "Ert be Kal Trjbe tbooixev ov ydp tl (\>av\r]s ixiToypv
(rTL Tiyjfr]s to vvv 0]tov]X(vov, akk' ev ]xd\a ttoikiXtjs. Kal
yap ovv iv tols iipocr^^v ilpr^pAvoLS (f)(XVTa(r]xa Tra/aexerat fi^
tovto vvv avTo rjixeXs (f)a]XV dAA' Tpov etvaC tl yivos.

5 0EAI. nf) 87/;
HE. To r^s KTr]TLKr]s rexv7/s ^fjrAow rjv (Ibos irov, to
]Xv dripdrrLKov fxepos Xov, To 8e dAAaKrtKOf.
0EAI. 'Hy yap ovv.
HE. T^y ToCvvv dAAaKTiK^s bvo ^Cbr] kiy(i)]Xv, to ]XV
lo b(apr]TLK6v, To b\ Tpov dyopacTTLKov;
0EAI. Y.lpr](r6u).
HE. Kai p.r]v av (prj^rofx^v dyopa<mKr]V bLxfj T]xv(r6aL.
d 0EAI. nf/;
HE. Trjv ]XV tS)V avTovpywv avTOTTooXLKrjv bLaLpovixvr]V,
Tr]v be Ta dAAorpta pya ]XTaâ\ko]Xvr]v ]XTa^\r]TLKi]v.
0EAI. Udvv ye.
ba Aldina
x*'P<*''''"f^* a.dA. Ija-^ kttitik^s, vtôBriplas, r}fitpo-
6TipiKrji secl. Schleiermacher b^ ni6avo6ripias add. Heindorf
fj.iffdapviKr}s secl. Schleiermacher c i iSonfifv W flSunty B T
W W
:
HfTexo" C 4 rjfxeTs aiiTh W 07 ^X"" f-*poi iA\o-

KTiKhv {o') Heindorf c 10 fTtpov om. W C 12 aS <p4)<T0fi.(v
T W :&!/ (pijffaifxfv B d 2 Siaipovfxfvoi al. 8)j flprftt.fvr\v Stcphanus
:
204>I2TH2 223d
SE. Tt 8e; Trjs /xera/3A7jTiK^s ovx ^ /jtei' fcara ttoAii; 5
aAAay?;, rxeSoi' avri^s rJixL(TV yApos ov, KaTTrjKLKq -npocrayo-

peverai;
0EAI. Nai.
SE. To hi ye e aAArjy eis aXkr]v TTokLV bLaXkdrTOV
d>vf} Kal TTpdaeL kiiTTopLKri; Jo
0EAI. Tt' 8' ov;

SE. T^s 8' (ixTTOpLKrji ap' ovk fi(r6-qp.c6a otl to p.V oo-ois e
t6 (TS>p.a Tpe(pTaL Kai \priTaL, to 8e oo-ots 7/ "^XV' ttcoXovv
8ia voiXLCTfjLaTos oAAdrrerat;

0EAI. Yla)s TovTo Ae'yets;
SE. To TTept rqv ylfvx^v to-cos dyvoovp.v, ^Trei t6 ye 5

Tp6v TTOV (TVvUp.(V.
0EAI. Nat.
SE. Mov(TLKriv re tolvvv (TVvdTTacTav Kiy(ixV, ex 7ro'Aea)s 224
eKaoTore eZy TToKof tvdev pikv d)vr]d(L(Tav, ere'pa)o-e 8e dyo-
IxAvrjv [xat TTLTTpa(TKop.ivriv\ Ka\ ypa(pLKr\v Kal 6avp.aT0iT0LLKi]V
Kal TToKkd hepa Trjs \j/vxrjs, Ta p.iv TrapapvdCas, Ta 8e xat

criTOvbrjs X^P'-^ dxdevTa Kal TTOikovp.iva, tov dyovTa /cat 5
TTcoAowra prjbev rJTTov Trjs tS)V cTLTmv Kal ttotS>v Tr/oao-ecos
p.TTopov 6p6u)s dv ky6p.evov Trapacrxety.

0EAI. 'AArjêorara Ae'yets.
SE. OvKovv Kal Tov p.a6rip.aTa crvv(avovp.Vov iT^kLV re b

K 7ro'Aeco9 vopLcrp.aTos dp.Lj3ovTa tovtov TTpoaepels 6vop.a;
0EAI. 2(ô8pa ye.
SE. Trjs br] xl/vx^P-TTopLKrjs TavTrjS Sp' ov to pev iiTL-
^CLKTLKr] 8tKato'rara keyoLT dv, to 8e yeAotw ]xev ovx r]TTov 5
Tov TTp6adev, dpoos be p.a6r]p.dT(av ovaav TTpd(TLV avTr]v
dbek(f)^ TLVL Ti]s TTpdêois 6v6]xaTL TTpoa-eLTTelv dvayKT];
d6 Koi irnXlKTi BT (corr. b t) : Kair-nXfvriK-n W d9 SioAXcitto']

SioAciT rov W : SiaWarrofHfvaiv BT BiaKKarro/xfvov vulg. 6 2 Kal
W
:
Xprjrai Heindorf Kexprirai BT a i Kfyofjitv avvdiraffav a3 Kal

W W
:
KiTrpacrKOfjifVTjv seclusi QavfjLaroiron)riK)}V a 7 iroptx*' T :
trKapxfiy Badham b5 ye\oi(f> Heindorf : ytKolov BT

PLATO, VOL. I. 24
224b nAATi2N02
0EAI. Tla.vv /xey ovv.
HE. TavTT]s Toivvv r^s ixadrjnaTOTTOiXLKrjs t6 fxfv Trtpl
C Ta tS>v akkoov t(\vS>v fxa6r\y.aTa (Tcpoi, t6 bk irepl t6 ttjs
apeTTJs aA.A(j) Trpoa-pTjTeov.
0EAI. ricSy yap oij;
s,E. Tex^ÔTTcoAiKw p,r]v t6 ye tTcpl raAAa &v apfxoTTOi'
5 TO b\ irepl TavTa crv TTpo6v(xi]6r}TL XeyfLV ovofxa.

0EAI. Kai TL Tis hv 6.W0 ovofxa (Itt(}v ovk hv TTkrjfx-
fX\oLr] TTXr]v t6 vvv 0]tovix(vov avro elvaL t6 (T0(\)L(mK6v

yivos;
aE. Ovh\v aAAo. X6l br] vvv (rvvaydyoofxev avT6 Ae-
10 yovTS (as to Trjs KTr]TLKr]s, fXTali\r]TLKrjs, ayopa^rTLKrjs,
d ifXTTopLKtjs, \lru)(êfXTTopLKr]s TTfpl \6yovs Kal ]xa6rj\xaTa apeT^s
TTooXr^TLKOv bevTfpov ave(f)(ivr] (ro(f)L(rTLKr].
0EAI. MaAa ye.

EE. TpLTov 8e y' oljxaC cre, Khv (Xtls avrov KadLbpvfxevos
5 iv TToAei, TCL fxkv OiVOVfXCVOS, TCL bi Ka\ TKTaLv6fX(V0S aVTOS
fxa6r]fxaTa Trept to. avTo. TavTa Kal tt(i}\Qv, k tovtov t6 (rjv
TTpovTdâTO, Ka\eLV ovbfv d\\o tt\i]V oiTep vvvbr].
0EAI. Ti 8' ov jxeWoo;
e HE. Kal t6 KTr]TLKfjs dpa fXTa^\r]TLK6v, dyopaa-TLKov,
Ka7Tr]\LK0V eire avT0TTu>\LK6v, dp.(f)OTepoiiS, ornrep dv rj Trept
ra rotaSra fi.a6r]p.aTOTTOd\LK6v yivos, det rri Tr/aocrepers, ws

(f)aCvr], ao(f)L(rTLK6v.
5 0EAI. ÂvdyKT]' tS> ydp \6y(o Sei o-vyaKoAovêiv.

HE. "Ert br] (TKOTTG^fLev ei riyi rotwSe TTpo(r4oLKV dpa t6
VVV fL(TabL(t)K6f).tV0V yivos.
225 0EAI. Iloia) b-n;
HE. Trjs KTTjTLKrjs dyo)VL(rTLKrj tl fxipos fffuv r]v.
C I rb] rcfi "W e 6 (liriiv 6vofia W Cg Xdi vvv BT

(sed 5^ supra versum T) %ei S^ : W C 10 yuTa/8\7/Tif^y] /iSTo-
fi\riTiKhv BT d 1 4fivopiKrjs^ 4fnropiKov BT ^pvxffi-rôptKov W
ed ris supra versum 65 \6y<i)] AoytKCf B aa fifpos t ^v
rifuv W
20*I2TH2 225a
0EAI. ^Hv yap ovv.

HE. OvK a-no Tpo-nov toCvvv eo-ri hiaip^lv avrrjv bCxo-
0EAI. Kad^ OTToXa Aeye. 5
HE. To jjL^v afXLXXT]TLKov avTTJ^ TiOivTas, to h\ fjiax>]TiK6v.

0EAI. 'Eo-rii;.
HE. Trjs TOLvvv fxa)(r]TLKr]i rw p.ev awfjLaTL irpos (r(6fj.aTa
yLyvofxivi^ a-x^hbv etKos Kal irpiTTOV ovofxa XeyeLV tl tolovtov
TLdifxivoVS oXoV ^LaCTTLKOV. 1
0EAI. Nai.
HE. Tw 8e XoyoLS Trpbs Xoyovs tl ris, S) 0airTjre, aAAo
eiTn/ irXrfv apL^La^rfTrfTLKOv; b
'EAI. OvUv.
HE. To 8e' ye Trepl ras afX(f)L(rl3r}Trf(rLS QiTiov hLTTov.
0EAI. nf,;
HE. Ka^' 6(rov p.\v yap yCyvfTaL fxrfKâi re irpbs (vavTLa 5
fXTjKT] X6y(av Kal irepl [Ta] bUaLa Kal a8t/ca hrffxoaria., bLKavLK^v.
0EAI. Nai'.
HE. To 8' ev tSiots av Kal KaTaK(K(pfxaTL(Tp.ivov epooTrf-
o-eo-t TTpbs aTTOKpia-^LS fxu^v (iOio-fx^da KaXelv aXXo TiXifV
avTLXoyLK^v; 10
0EAI. Ovbh.
HE. ToC 6e di^rtAoytfcoC Tb fxV 6(rov TTepl tcl a-vfx^6XaLa
afX(j)La-^T]TLTaL fxev, dKrj 8e Kai aTixycos Trepi avTo irpaT- c

rerat, TavTa deTôv pLV elbos, eTretTrep avrb bLeyvcoKev ojs
Tpov 6v 6 X6yos, aTap 7roovvp.Las ovQ^ virb tS>v (fXTTpocrdev
tTV\v ovTe vvv v(f)^ r]fxS)V tv\lv a^Lov.

0EAI. ÂXrfdT]- KaTCL a-fXLKpa yap Xiav Ka\ TravTobaTra 5
StTjpTjrat.
HE. To be ye iVTeyyov, Kcd irepi bLKaioov avrwv kcu

abiK(i)v Kal Trept tu)v aXXoov oAco? atx(f)La-j3rfTovv, ap ovk
(pLaTLKov av XfycLV dOicrfxeOa;
as o5v om. W bi afji<f>i(TPrrrriTiK6v] afi<pi(r$ririK6v BTW

W
b 3 SiTTby OeTfov W b 5 yap om. W b6 ra om. T
C 2 ToCra B T tovto : al. C9 a5 om. W
24*
;
225 c OAATXINOS
lo 0EAI. riajs yap ov;
d HE. Tov ixi]v epiaTiKov to fuv Xpr]îaTO(\i0opi.K6v, to 8e
yj>r]p.aTL(rTLKOv ov TvyyaveL.
0EAI. riavraTraa-i ye.
HE. Ti]v iTTcovviJiCav Toivvv f\v kKaTcpov hii KaXiw
5 avrCiv TTiLpadSni^v (ItkIv.
0EAI. OvKovv XPV-
HE. Ao/co) p.i]v To ye bC f]bovr]V Trji nepl Tavra bLaTpL^rji
a/xeA^s t&v oIkL(ov yLyv6]iivov, iTepl 8^ Tr]v Ki^Lv tois
TToWols tG^v aKov6vT(i)v ov ]Md* f]bovr]s aKov6pLvov KaKfXa-OaL
10 Kara yv(a]JLr]v Tr]v i]if]v ov\ Tpov abo\(r\LKOv.
0EAI. Aeycrai yap ovv ovro) ttcos.
e HE. TovrOl TOLVVV TOVVaVTLOV, airb TUiV IbLUiTLK&V ipCbdiV
\pr]p.aTL^6]XVov, iv ro) /xc/aei crv Treipo) vvv elTTdv.
0EAI. Kal (rCy tls. hv av eliTibv ^Ttpov ovk iândpToi

'JT\r]V ye tov davixaa-Tov iraKLV Iklvov f]KLV av vvv TtTapTov
5 Tov ]XTabL(iiK6]Xvov v(f)^ f}]xS>v cro(\>LaTr]v
226 HE. Ovb\v dAA' f] To \pr]]xaTLaTLKov yivos, o)? olk(v,

pi,a-TLKf]S OV T)(Vr]S, Trjs aVTL\oyLKf]S, Tfjs apL(f>La-j3riTr]TLKf]S,
Trjs ]xaxr]TLKf]s, Tfjs ayoiVLa-TLKTjs, Tr]S KTr]TLKfjS icrTLV, oiS
6 Aoyos av ]X]xr]vvK vvv, 6 (ro^toTT^s,

5 0EAI. Ko]XLbf] pi^v ovv.
HE. 'Op3s ovv (1)9 akr]6fj Aeycrai to ttolklKov ttvaL toxjto
TO 6r]pCoV KOL TO Ky6p.V0V OV Tfj T4p(l Kr]TTT6v;
0EAI. OuKow a]x(f)OLV XP"^'

b HE. Xpf] yap ovv, Kal KaTa bvva]xCv ye ovrco ttoltjtcov,
T0L6vb TL ]XTa6ovTas Ixiôs avTov. KaC pLOL Aye' rair
OLKTLKCiV 6vO]xdTUiV KaKovp,V ttTTa TTOV;

0EAI. Kal TToKKa' &Tap TTOLa bf] t&v ttoAAcSv TTVvddvr];
d5 auTwi'] airrhv B d7 fiiiv'] fiiv Heindorf ri yt] riSt B T

W W W
:
tJ 5 d8 i.fjif\us d 10 r^y] r-fiv 7' e 3 t/ add.

Heindorf iâfiapri.voi W 65 rhv om. B aa ifKpnrPri-
riKJJi BT W a3 KrrirrirtKrji B a6 Tb Oriploy rovro W
a 7 Tp irip^f] OoTfpif Cobet \fiirr6y W : \riirrfov BT
S0*I2TH2 226b
HE. Ta Toidbe, otov bi,-q$dv re kiyo[iV koX hiaTrav Kal 5
(BpoLTTeiv Kal ibtaKpiveiv.f
0EAI. TC firiv!
HE. Kai TTpos ye rovrots eri âivdv, KaTayeiv, KepKtCetv,
Kal fxvpCa (V rats reîâts aAAa TDtaura ivovTa iTnardixeOa.
^
^ ydp;
0EAI. To TTotoy avT&v Trept /3ovArjêts b-qXoia-aL Trapa- C
beiyp.aTa Trpodels Tavra KaTO. TtdvToov ijpov;
HE. Atat/aeriKa itov Ta X)(^divTa eiprjTai avimavTa.
0EAI. Nat.
HE. Kara tov ifxbv Toivvv koyov o)? Trepi Tavra fiiav 5
ov(ray kv aTracri Teyvrfv kvo^ dv6p.aT0i d^L(aa-ofXv avrifv,

0EAI. TtVa TTpoa-(t.iT6vTs;
HE. At.aKpLTiKrjv.
0EAI. 'EOTCO.
HE. 2\-07rei brj TavTrfs av bvo av irr] bvvdifieOa KartSety 10
61877.
0EAI. Taxeiay ws e/xot a-Ke\l/LV e-Trirdrret?.

HE. Kai fv ye rat? elprjfiivaLs bLaKpia-ea-L
ju.T/i' to fiev d
\eXpov aTTo (SekTiovos diToxoopiC^Lv ifv, to 8' 6p.0L0v dcf)'
ofxoiov.
0EAI. SxêSoy ovrto vvv Xexdev <paivTaL.

HE. T^s fikv Toivvv ovofxa ovk eyja ky6p.V0V Trjs 8e 5
KaraAetTTOvcTTjs /xey rb îXrLov bLaKpiaeo^s, t6 be x^^lpov
dTTOjSaXXovaris X^*
0EAI. Aeye ri'.
HE. Dao-a ^ rotavTTj StdKpto-t?, wj eyo) avvvooi, Aeyerat

Trapa irdvToov KaOapfxds tls. ^
0EAI. Ae'yerat yap ovv.
b5 5(7;0erj' BT : in marg. T sed 77 priore eraso (^Siaa-fiOetv

îrjff-rfieiv
voluit) re BT : W
post Xtyofxev add. Siaa-fideiv
ti b 6 5(o- W
KpjVe!'] Stappivf7v Orelli diaKivt7v Campbell
: suspicor Siaaridfiv fuisse
:
vel avoKiveTv b 8 |o/i'6(' Kal Kardytiv fcol KfpKiêiv d. 4 ovro) W

T W olv r B
: d 6 KOToAtdroucTjj W
/caToAjwoutTTjj B T
;
226 e TIAATGNOS
e EE. OvKovv t6 ye KaOapTiKov elbos av bntkovv Sv iras
hv ibot;
0EAI. Na^, Kora aôXriv ye la-coi' ov fiijv iyoiye

Ka6opG> vvv.
5 HE. Kai iJ.7]v tA yc Trepl to. acafxaTa TToWa eldri KaOdp-

o-ecoi' vl TTcpiKaêlv oiôiJLaTi. TTpoaifKiL.
0EAI. Hola Koi tCvi;

HE. Ta T Twv ^ûiv, o(ra ivTos cwpLaTaiv xmo yvfjivaa--
'
227 TiKTJs laTpiKrjs re opdojs biaKpivoixeva KadaipeTai Kal Trepi
Td,KT69, elTTflv /xev (fiavKa, oaa âXavevnKT} TTapf^fTaf Kal
T<av ay^yjMV a(op,6,T0tiV, u>v yvacfxvriKr] Kal (rvp.TTa(Ta >coo-/xtj-
riKT) Tr]v iiTLneKaav TTapi)(op.ivri KaTo. (rpLLKpa iToWa Kal

5 yeAota boKovvTa 6v6p.aTa t(T\^v.
0EAI. MdAa ye.
HE. YlavTaTTacTL fikv ovv, a> eafrrjre. aXka yap rr)
TQiV \6y(iiv ix(d6b<o OTToyyioTiK^y rj <f)appiaKOTTO(rLas ovbev

iJTTov ovbe TL iJLaWov Tvyx6v(L pAkov ei to fuv (rfiLKpa, to
10 8e /jteydAa rjp.as oxêAei KaOalpov. tov KTria-acrdaL yap
b evKa vovv TTaaStv Tex,v&v t6 avyyeves kol to /x^ or^yyeves
Kararoeii' TTiLpuipAvYi TLfia TTpos tovto e laov irdaas, Kal
OaTepa twv (Tpoiv /card ti]v 6iJ.OL6Tr]Ta ovb\v fjyfLTaL yeAoid-
Tpa, a-pLv6TpOV bi TL TOV 8td OrpaTT/yifCT/S V (fidfLpLOTLKTis
5 briKovvTa dr]ptrrLKi]V ovbcv vv6ixlkv, oAA' ws to ttoKv
\avv6Tepov. Kal bi] Kal vvv, OTTtp ypov, tl iTpo(rpovix(v ovofxa
avixTTacras bvvapieLS oaaL (rQixa eire (fx^vxov etre a\frvxov
C etA^x^^^ KadaCpfLV, ovbfv avrf] 8totVei ttoioV ri Aexêr
(VTTpeiTeaTaTov etmt Sdêt* ix6vov ex4T(ti \(tipls rcSv Trjs
'^v\rjs Kaddpaeoiv iTavTa avvb7J(rav oaa oAAo rt KaOaCpd.
ea tSot] ftSoi T : (rvviSoi W e^ vai secl. Cobet 5 7

W om.
: BT e8-a2 Scrois . . . <pav\a Badham : 8<tois . . . (fiavKois
Schanz a i KaOaipfTat T W : KadatptTrai B irtpl Td#tT($j]
irtpiraKThs B : toi irplto ^Krhs & T a3 fo<r/i7n'"f^] <r/iiirr"f^
Badham a8 <papfMiKoiroilas Ast b^ 8* ti W : t tj BT

f) (pdftpKTTtKTJs om. B b6 8^ Kol om. T c i tl\iix<""^ ^ *
tiK^tipaai BT
W
204>I2TH2 227 c
Tov yap TTcpl TTjV bLavotav KaOapiwv aTro Tutv akXiav eirt-
K(\ipr]KV a(f>opL(ra(r6ai to. vvv, et ye oTrep fiovK^TaL 5
p.avd(xvopLV,
0EAI. 'AAAa p.fxd6r]Ka, Kal (Tvyx<^p<^ 8vo fj.lv dhr)
Kad(ip(T(x)s, ^v 8e to Trept ti]V '^j/vxvv eiSos eirat, roC Trepl
To au^fxa x.(apls ov.
HE. YldvToiv KakkLcrTa. Kai p.oL t6 jJL^Ta tovto eTTaKove 10
TTcipdoiJLfvos av To kfxdcv Stx?? TeV^ftr. d

0EAI. Ka^' OTTOi' hv iKpr^yf] "niipdaoixai (toi (tvv-
Tp.VLV.
HE. Uovrjpiav iT^pov dpeTrjs iv '^V)qJ kiyop.iv tl;
0EAI. YlGis yap ov; 5
HE. Kat p.r]v Ka6ap}x6s y r]v to XeiVeti' iikv 6dTpov,

(KJ3dkkLV 8e o(rov av f]
irov tl (f)kavpov,
0EAI. Ûv ydp ovv.

HE. Kat i/o^x^? dpa, Kad^ oaov av evpicrK(OfXV KaKias
d(f)aipe(Tiv TLva, Ka6apixbv avTov keyovTes kv fx^keL (f)d(y- 10
ô'/xeâ.
0EAI. Kat pidka ye.

HE. Avo pikv eibri KaKias Trept ^v^V^ prjTiov.
0EAI. nota;
HE. To ixkv oXov vocrov kv crdpiaTL, t6 8' otoi' atcrxos 228
iyyLyv6p.evov.
0EAI. OvK (jxadov.
HE. No(roy lorcos Kai (rrdcrLV ov TavTov vev6[XLKas;
0EAI. OvS' av 77/309 TovTo x<*) Ti xpr] /i.e diroKpi- 5
rao-ât.
HE. Y\6TpOV dkXo TL (TTd(TLV TfyOVfXiVOS rj T1]V TOV (fivcreL
(rvyyevovs e/c rtros bLa(f)6opds bia(f)opdv;
C 4 rhv] tJ W C 10 iirdjtove irfipti/ieros] iiraKo\oiOft irdpaififvtp Bad-

ham da Ka0o)ro< &;/ B : (caCoiroi &v T : /ca0' ^jroia;' d4 opeT-^j]
S/)' T^J B d6 7' W: om. Bl' AsiVeii/ Heindorf : KaTa\eiirtiv
Olympiodorus : Kittui/ BT d 13 fifv BT W Stobaeus : yUTjy Heindorf
a5 tJ] oTi W a8 Sia^pdufias Sia(j>opiv Galenus : Sia^popas Sia<pdopay
BT Stobaeus
228a nAATI2N02
0EAI. Ovbev.
10 EE. 'AAA.' ot<rxos îAAo n TrA^r ro t-^j ifKrplas TravTa\ov
bv(ribis ivbv yivos;
b 0EAI. Ov8a/x<Ss îAAo.

HE. T^ 8^; iv ylrvxfj boâs kTiiOvjiCais kou dvfxbv rfbovals
Kal Xoyov XvTrais Kal iiavTa aAATjAois ravra tG>v <f>Kavp(as

f)(^6vT(ov ovK r)<r6rifji6a btacfxpofKva;
5 0EAI. Kat (r(f)6bpa ye.
HE. ^vyyevTJ ye /ut;v f^ avdyKris crvp.TTavTa yiyoviv,
0EAI. YlG>s yap ov;
HE. Hrdo-iy 5/>a Kal vocrov Trjs ^XV^ TTovrjpiav X4yovTfs
dpdQ>s fpodpLev.
10 0EAI. 'OpdoTaTa fxkv ovv.
C HE. Ti 8'/ o(r (avy KLvrjareoiis fiiTacrxpvTa Ka\ o-kottov
Tiva difxeva Treipdpieva tovtov Tvyxdveiv Kad' c Kcio-rT/i; opfxijv
Trapa^fyopa avTov yiyvrfTai KaX d-noTvy\avr], TroTfpov avrd

<f>rfcrop.v VTTo (Tvp.fXTpias Trjs irpbs ctAA?jAa ^ tovvovtCov
5 VTTo dfkiTpias avrd TTdcrxft-v;
0EAI. AÂoy ws imo dfxirpias.

HE. 'AAAa fxrfv ^vxrfv ye fo-/xey &K0va-av TTaa-av irar
dyvoovcrav.
0EAI. ^(f>6bpa ye.
lo HE. To' y fxr\v dyvodv ^cmv ^tt' Â^êtay 6pp.(ofLfvr]s
d ifvxv^, TTapacf)6pov crvvicTiois yiyvopuivrfs, ovbiv dXXo ttXijv
TTapacf>pocrvvrf.
0EAI. ndvv fxev ovv.

HE. ^vxvi' dpa dv6r]Tov alcrxpdv Kal dfXfTpov deriov.
5 0EAI. "EoLKfv.
HE. "EoTi 8?/ bvo TavTa, ci)S cf>aiverai, KaK&v iv avrfj
a 1 1 4vhv Schleiermacher tv hv Stobaeus fv 6v t: iv B T

W
: :
b2 i/zux^]T^ ^xp C I &i/ add. Cobet c a O^fifvov Stobaeus

irtipu/xfva om. B add. T Galenus Stobaeus irfipufi.(Oa
: : Kaff] W
Kol Kaff Stobaeus c 3 yifvfrai Galenus Stobaeus al. oto-
Tiryx<i''* B Galenus Stobaeus al.
:
20*I2THS 228d
yh-T], TQ likv TToirqpCa KoXovixfvov inrb t&v iroXk&v, roVos

avrijs (ra(p(TraTa ov.
0EAI. Nai.
HE. To 8e ye ayvoiav fikv KdXova-i, KaKiav 8e avTO iv lo
oyioXoydv.
V^Xf/ H-^vov yiyv6\xivov ovk kQiXovcnv
0EAI. Ko/xt8^ a-vyxfnp-qTiov, o wvbr} XiâvTOS W^^-
yv6r]ara aov, to bvo elvai. yivr) KaKLas h ^XV> '^"' beikCav
yL(v Ka\ aKoXafrCav Kal ahiKCav a-vfjLTTavTa r)yr}Tov v6(tov iv

fipuv, t6 be Trjs TToXkrjs Kal TTavTobairris ayvoCas iTdOos
alaôs Oeriov. 5
HE. OvKovv ev ye o-<ujuart iTfpl bvo iTadrifiaTe tovtco bvo
riyva tiv\ eyeviaOriv;
0EAI. Tire tovtoo;
HE. riept pLev al(T-)(os yvfxvaariKq, TTcpl be v6(tov laTpiKrj. 229
0EAI. i>aCvea6ov.
HE. OvKovv Kal TTepl jjikv v^piv koX abiKCav koX beikCav
fj KoXaoTiKr] TT4(pVKe Te\vG>v iiaXia-Ta brj iTaa-5>v TTpoa~t]Kovaa
ACkj]. 5
0EAI. To yovv et/co's, i>s diTeiv KaTO, Tr]V dvOpooiTCvr^v
b6âv.
HE. Tt 8e; Trept crvixTTacrav dyvoiav ixQ>v dkkrjv Ttva r]
St8ao-KaA.tK7)i; dpdoTcpov etTTot tis dv;

0EAI. OvbenCav. 10
HE. <Pepe br]' btbaaKaXiKrjs be dpa ev p6vov yevos b

(paTeov [etratj f] iTkeCa), bvo be Tive avTrjs eTvaL fxeyCaTOi;
CTK^TTei.
0EAI. Skotto).
HE. Kat ]xoL boKOVfxev rfjbe dv ttt; TdxLora evpelv. 5
0EAI. Ufi;
Bi %v vvv 5^ B
^ 8)j vvv Stobaeus i)fi<peyv6r)(Tas ovT 63 v6(rov^
W
:
'6(Tov T e6 ye (T<a/j.aTi Stobaeus tv ye ry crdiixaTi

iv : eV ffwfxari :
76 BT ravrii} Stobaeus a 2 <paiveTai Stobaeus a 4 5^

T Stobaeus 5' ^ B ante fxaKKXTa transp.
: : W
a 5 A/kt? Cobet
5//C7J B T Stobaeus b a flvai. om. Stobaeus
;
aagb nAATQNOS
HE. T^y ayvoiav ibovTcs et ttj/ Kara yAcrov avr^s ro/i<ijjr
cxci Tiva. hnrkri yap avrri yiyvoy.ivr] hrfkov oti Kal ti]v
bi.ba(TKa\iKy]v bvo avayKa^d. fxopia i\itv, %v e(f>' hl [yevd]
10 TOiv avrrjs tKarepo).
0EAI. Tt ovv; KaTaâv4s titj (toi t6 vvv ^r]Tovp.ivov

C HE. 'Ayroias yovv p-fya tC fxoi boK(a Kal \a\(TTbv a(^(ji-
pi(rpi4vov bpav ciSo?, Trao-t Tois aAAois avT7^s avTLoradpiov
puipicnv.
0EAI. noiov 8^';

5 HE. To /xr/ KaretSoVa Ti boK(iv elbfvai' bC ov Kivbwevfi
TTavTa o(ra btavoCc} ar(âhX6pi.6a yCyvicrdai, TTacnv.
0EAI. 'AkyfBri.
HE. Kat br] Ka\ TovT(a ye oi/xat piovdi Ttjs ayvoCas
ap.a9Cav Tovvofxa irpo^rprÔrjvat.
10 0EAI. Yldvv ye.
HE. Tt bi br] T(S Trjs StSao-KaAtK^s &pa iiipn to) tovto
aTiakkaTTovTi kcKTeov;
d 0EAI. Ot/xat p.v [ovv], w êve, to p^v akko br]piovp-
yiKas bLbacTKakCas, tovto be (vddbe ye TraiSciai' 8i' fjpo^v
KCKkTJcrdai.
HE. Kai yap a-xebov, w 0eaiT7jTe, iv TTacriv "^kkqcriv.
5 dAAa yap rjplv Irt Kai tovto (TKeiTTfov, Sp' oltohov ybr] co-ti
TTav 7/ Tiiâ Xov bLaCpecTLv d^Cav iiT(iiVvp.Cas.
0EAI. OVKOVV \pr] (TKOITeLV.

HE. AoKet ToCvvv px>i koX tovto cTt 777/ oîêo-ât.
0EAI. KaTa Ti;
b7 avrfjs W
oSttj Stobaeus
: abTjjt B T : b 9 ^^'i om. Sto-
bacus c I yovu W
5' oii> B T : t' oSc Stobaei cod. L
: i<popi(6-
/it^/oi/ Stobaeus C2 avrbi> avTt(TTa0f/.ovv Stobacus c6 diavoia
BT 81' ayvolas Stobaeus
: c8 /idvy] fjLopitf Badham C9 i/ua-
Oiai' WStobaeus anadia B T
: c 1 1 t^ ante Tiji om. Stobaeus
d I o5i' om. W
Stobacus ij]fi.iovpyiK^ Stobaeus da 81'] v<t>'
W Stobaeus ds ante rjnlv add. î/ BW: om. T Stobaeus
Ka\ rovTo tiri(rKcirTfov Stobaeus ap' &TOfxov ^{aTOjuov Stobaei W :
cod. L ti &TO;uoj' BT
: ô-tii' tjSri Stobaeus d6 f^*' Sto- ^
baeus d8 (cal] kot^ Hermann
20I2TH2 229 6
HE. T^s h rots \6yois btba<rKa\i,KTJs rj ixev TpayyTipa e

rtj (otKev obbs eirai, to 8' eTepov avrijs p.6piov Xa^Tepov.
0EAI. To TTOLov bi] TovTcov iKaTepov K4yop.ev;
HE. To pikv apxatoTrpeTres ri TraTptov, w irpos rovs iêis
IxaktdT ixp5>VT6 T Kal ert ttoAAoI xpSiVTat to. vvv, oTav 5
avTots iap.apTavoo(Ti rt, ra juei x.A.e7ratVorre9, ra 8e p.ak6a- 230

Ku}Tp(os TTapapLvdovfxevof t6 8' ovy (Tvp.-nav avTo opOoTaTa
ctTTOi rts ai' i/ouêrTjrt/c?/!'.
0EAI. "Ecrrti' ovrcos.

HE. To b4 ye, etâo-t rtiês av X6yov kavTots bovTes 5
^yô-ao-âi Traa-av aKova-tov ap.adiav elvat, Kal p.adeiv ovbev

7T0T av edeketv tov olofxevov elvat a-o(})bv tovto^v Stv ototTo
Trept betvbs etvat, ftera 8e TroWov mvov Tb vov$eTrjTtKbv

elbos TTJs iratbeias a-pttKpbv avvTetv.
0EAI. ÔpOcos ye vop.iC,ovTes. lo
HE. Tw rot TavTr]s Trjs bo^rjs (Trl eKôXrjv aXX(o Tpîrio b

(rre'AAorrat.
0EAI. Tti^t bri;

HE. Aiepcoraio-ti; wy hv oXr]Tai rts rt Tre^pt Xeyetv Xeyoiv
\iy]bev' eW aTe 'nXavoip.ev(xiv tcls b6âs pabiois eêraôvo-i, 5
Kat auvdyovTes bi] Tots X6yots eis tovtov Ttdea(rt irap
aXXr]Xas, TtOevTes be eTTtbetKvvova-iV avras avrats afxa irepl

tQv avTU)v irpbs to, avTo. KaTo. TavTo. evavTias. ol b opoivTes
eavTols fJtev \aXeTraivov(Jt, Trpbs be tovs aAAous r]p.epovvTaL,
Kal T0VT(a bi] ro) Tpoirâ Toiv irepX avTovs pLeyaXoiv Kal ctkAtj- c
poiv boôiv diraXXaTTovTat Traaoiv [re] d-TraAAaywy aKoveti^ re
r]biaTr]v Kal rw Trao-xôrrt êjBat^TaTa ytyvopevrjv. vop.iôvTes
ydp, S TTat </)iAe, ot KadaipovTes avTovs, wo-Trep ot Trept Ta

(T(ai]xaTa laTpol vevo]xiKaa-t fxi] irp^Tepov dv Trjs Trpoa-(f)epoixevr]s 5
ea /x<$pioi/ auTTjs W Stobaeus 63 A.'-yo/xev W Stobaeus : Aeâj/uei'

BT 64
rh /xfu om. Stobaeus ai rt om. T & ^ iis
ante ftôuri add. vulg. : om. Stobaeus BT a6 ovSav iror' ii.y T :
ovSe r' &/ Stobaei cod. L b i ry toi B Stobaeus koI yap roi T :
b 6 <Twdyov<rt et mox tls ravrSv re Stobaeus b 7 avrais^ avrais

T W avro7s B
: c a t om. Stobaeus
230C nAATflNOS
Tpo(f)rii ^TroXavdv hvvaa-dai a-G>y.a, itpXv h.v ra kp.i:ohC(pvTa
ivTos Tts K^6Xri, Tavrhv kcu iTfpl ylfvxrjs bifvoridrja-av iKflvoi,,
fJLr} TTpOTfpov airnjv eêiv tG>v Trpoa-cfxpoijJvcav piadrjpATcov

d ovrja-iv, TTplv hv ikcyxuiv tls tov i\(yxopLvov ds ala-)(yvr}v
KaTaaTrjaas, ras rois p.a6r\p.aa-iv ifiTTobCovs boâs i^\(iv,

Kadapov aTT0(f)rjvr] Kal Tavra r]yovp.Vov &TTp oTbev (Ibevai
fxova, TrAeio) 8e p,rj.
5 0EAI. BeXTCarr] yovv Kal a(t)(f)pov(rT<irq T(av lêojy avTTj.

HE. Aia Tavra brj TTavTa r]p.lv, Z) &eaLTr]T, Ka\ tov
i\y\ov \KTov u)S apa p.yCcrTr] Kal /cvptojrdrTj tu>v KaOap-
aecov (oTi, Kal tov avekeyKTov av vop.taTov, hv Ka\ Tvyxdvr]
e /3acnXevs 6 p.^yas &v, to, /leyiora aKddapTov ovTa, diTaCbfVTov
T Kal alaxpbv yeyovevai TavTa h KaOapooTaTov Kal KdWtaTov
^TTpeTTe Tov ovT(DS icroixevov evbaCfxova elvai,.
0EAI. UavTdTTaa-L fjLev ovv,
5 HE. T^ be; tovs TavTr] xpcofxevovs rr) Tcxvr} nVas

231 (f^rja-ofxfv; eyo) fxev ydp (fôôvfxat o"0(/)i<rras (f>dvai,'.
0EAI. TCbri;
HE. M^ ixelCov avTOLS TTpoadTTTcoixev yepas.
0EAI. 'AAAa ixr]v TTpoaioLKi ye roiovroj rii^t tcl vvv
5 lpr]ixeva.
HE. Kai yap kvvI \vkos, dypi(OTaTov rnxepoDTdTô. tov

be do-(f)a\f] beL iTdvTo)V ixd^Lora Trepl Tas 6/xoton;ras dei
TTOLL(rdaL Trjv (f)v\aKr]v 6\Ladr]p6TaTOV yap t6 yevos. opLcos
bi â-TU)- ov yap iTepL aixLKpiav opo)V Tr]v dix(PLaj3r']Tria-LV oio/xat
b yvr]a(rdaL t6t ottotov Ikov&s (f)v\dTT<D(ra),

0EAI. OvKovv t6 yc (Ik^s.
HE. "Earo) brj bLaKpLTLKrjs T^xvr]s KadaprLKr], KadapTLKijs
bi To iTepl yffv\r}v /xepos d(f)0)pCa9(t), tovtov be btbaaKa^LKr],
c6 tiy om. W C 7 ivT6s Stobaeus iv avr^ BT d8 rhv

:
B Stobaeus rh T e i &!/ T Stobaeus 6v B &i fiivom.W

:
W W
:
a3 npotrdirTODfxfv'] irpoffanToixtv B vpoffdyafitv : a 4 7 om. :
BT a 6 iiypiwTfpov B &-] atl om. Stobaeus a 9 fffToi

scripsi iffTwaav B T
: {ffTwv Schanz
: b i ipv\6,Trwntv Schanz
\)a t6 7] t6t( W
204>I2TH2 23ib
8t8a<T/<aAiK7/? 8e TraibevTLKrj' Trjs be TraibevTLKrjs 6 irepl tijv 5
fxaTaiov boôa-ocpLav yLyvoiu.evos lAeyxos iv rw vvv Aoyo)

irapa^pav&TL fxrjbev aX)C rnuv etvaL XeyidOoi Tikriv r) yevL
yevvaia a-ocpLaTLKrj,
0EAI. Aeyia-Ooi yAv amopGt 8e eyoiye rjbrj 8ta t6 TroAAa
TTe(f)dvdaL, TL XPV Trore ws aXrjdrj XeyovTa Ka\ bLLa^vpLQop.evov C

elirelv ovTctis elvai tov aô^pLarqv.
HE. Et/coVo)? ye aij aTTopSiv. aXkd tol KaKeZvov rjyela-daL
\pr] vvv rjbr) a-(f)6bpa ditopeiv oTTrj ttotc eTL bLabva-eTaL tov
\6yov 6p6i] ydp rj TTapoLp.La, to Tas dTrda-as /xt) pabLov elvaL 5
bLa(f)evyeLv. vvv ovv Kal /xaAtara eTTLOeTeov avT^.

0EAI. KaAo)9 XeyeLS.
HE. UpcaTov 87) cTTdvTes olov eâvaTTveva-oifjiev, /cai TTpos
j/jxas avTovs bLaXoyia-(op.eda dp.a dvaTTav6p.evoi, (pepe, oTTâa d

ijpuv 6 (ro(})ia-Tr}S TTe(j)avTaL. boKoi piev ydp, t6 iTpoiTov
rjvpeOr] vecov Kal TTkova-mv ep.p.L(r6os drjpex/rqs.
0EAI. Nat.
HE. To 8e ye bevTepov efxiTopos tls iTepl Ta Trjs '^XV^ 5
p.a6rip.aTa.
0EAI. Udvv ye.

HE. TptToy 8e dpa ov iTepl avTa TavTa KdTTrjkos dve(f)dvr];
0EA1. Nat, Kai TeTaprdv ye avTOTT(akr]s TTepi Ta p.a6rip.aTa
fjpuv (^'^vy. 10
HE. 'Opô)? ep.vr]p.6veva-as. iTep.TTTOV 8' eyo) TTeLpda-op.aL
pvrjpoveveiv Tfjs ydp dyooviaTiKrjs iTepl kdyovs ^v rts ddkrjTrjS, e

Ti]v epiCTTiKrjV Tex^rjv d(f)a)pia-p,evos.
0EAI. ^Hv ydp ovv.

HE. To ye p.r]v eKTOv dp.(f)i(T^r]Tr](Tipov p.ev, opicos 8'
edep.ev avT^ (rvyx(pw(''-^'^^^ boô)V ep.7Tobiu)v p.a6r]p,aaiv iTepl 5
yf/vxv^ K0.6apTr]v avTov elvai.
d.2 -yop W : yap &v BT : yap S-fj Schanz ds Kal secl. Cobet
d5 5e om. T d8 avTo, W: touto BT avp6.vq dvai W
d 10 ffv add. Heindorf e i yap ayuvKTTiKrjs T W TrapayuvKTTiKrjs B
W
:
e 5 naO^fiaai T : fjiaQr\(nv B
231 e TIAATXiNOS
0EAI. YlavT(!LTra<ri ijikv ovv.
232 HE. 'Ap' ovv hvoels, orav e-TrKTTTj/xcoy tis ttoW&v (\>ai-
VTt]Tai, fiias 8e rexrrjs 6v6iJ.aTL Trpoa-ayopevrjTai,, t6 (f>a.vTaa-na

TOVTO o)? OVK (a9^ vyUs, aWa hrjXov uts 6 Trda-)(ûiv avTO Trpos
Tiva T\V7)v ov hvvaTai, KaTihelv (K(lvo avTrjs eis o i:avTa ra
5 p.adr\p,aTa raCra /3Ae'7rci, 810 koI iroAAots oro/jtao-u' dr^' kvoi

Tov ^xovTa avTo. Trpoa-ayopevei;
0EAI. Kivhvvevei tovto TavTrj irrf fiaXiara TTi^vKivai.
b EE. Mj) Toiwv ri\if.ls ye avro ^v r?) ^T/rô-ei 8t' dpyiav
Ttdayaniiv, dAA' diôAd^wjLicr (^v^ ifpSiTov t&v Trepl rov
a-o(f)i.a-Tr]v lpr]p.V(ov. kv ydp tC /xoi /buiAioTa Karc^dvr]
avTov fxr]vvov.
5 0EAI. To TToroy;
HE. 'ArriAoytKoy avrw itâfiiv iivai ttov.
0EAI. Nar.
HE. Ti 8'; ov Kal raiy &W(tiV avTOV tovtov bihda-Ka\ov
yCyviadai;
10 0EAI. Ti p.r]v;
HE. '2>K0TxSmiV hr], irepl tCvos &pa KaC (f)a(riv oi toiovtol
itokIv dvTLkoyLKovs. 7} hi a-Ki\}fLS r)p.lv i^ dpxv^ Ioto) T^8e'
C irr]. (f>(pi, "TTfpl tS)v 6(C(ov, 6(r d^pavrj rois TroAAois, ap'
tKarous "TTOioCo-i roih-o hpdv;
0EAI. A^yerai yovv hr] Trepi avTOiV TavTa.
HE. T^ 8' ocra (f)av(pd yijs T Kal ovpavov kuI tG)V TTepl
5 Ta TOLavTa;
0EAI. TCydp;
HE. 'AAAa ixr]v tv ye rais IhCaLS ovvovaCaLS, ottotciv
yerô-ecos re Kat ovaCas iT^pL Acara iTdvTcov k(.yr]TaC tl,
(rvvLapuiv b)s avToC re di^reiTreti; 8eivoi tovs re dAAovs ori

10 TTOtouo-ty oTrep avrot hvvaTOvs;
aa <pivr<uTtJM\ (fxicrfia W br rp om. W ba tv add.

Heindorf irpierov] irp&Tiv ri al. b^ KaTf^pivrj /xdXiffra^W
b4 avrhv'] avrh T C3 yoiii' W : olv BT C8 oiiffias] oIkIos T
C9 Stjvoi] Svvarol W 8t secl. Cobet
;
204)I2TH2 232C
EAI. TlavTdTTaa-C ye.

HE. Ti 8'au TTpl voixcav Kal avinravTOiV t(ov iroXLTiK&v, d
ap' ovx VTTL(r)(vovvTaL TroLeiv aix(pL<Tl3r]Tr]TLK0vs
0EAI. Ovbds yap av avTols b)S iiros dTrdv 8tcAeyro

fXr] TOVTO \mL(T\vovp.ivoLS.
HE. Ta ye jmtjv Trepl Tra^r&v t Kal KaTo. p.Lav kKa<TT7]v 5
Tiyi>r]v, h. hiL TTpbs (KacrTov avrov tov hr]p.Lovpyov avTCLTTdv,

bebr]pioa-L(oixiva ttov KaTaêfiXrjTaL yeypaixfxiva tS> j3ovXofiV(a
jxadelv.
0EAI. Ta Ilpcorayopeia p.0L (paivy Trepi t TToXr^s kol
T&v aXkcov TC)(vS)V eipr]KvaL. e

HE. Kal TToXXStv ye, ai ]iaKapL, hepcov. aTap br] to
TTJs dvTLXoyLKrjs Tiyvr]s dp' ovk Iv K(f)aXaL(f iTepL TTavTOiV

TTpos d]X(pLa^r]Tr](rLV LKavr] tls bvva]XLS (olk (7vai;
0EAI. âLveraL yovv 8t) crxebbv ovbev VTToXLireLV. 6
HE. 2v br] TTpbs BeSiv, o) TTal, bvvaTov rfyfj tovto; Ta\a

ydp dv vixels ]xev o^Tcpov ol veoL iTpds avTo (3X47tolt, r)]xels
5e dix(3XvTpov.
0EAI. To TTolov, KOLL TTpbs TL ]xdXL(rTa XeyeLs; ov ydp 233
TTOV KaTavoSi Tb vvv kpoiT(ii]xevov.
HE. Et TTavTa eTTLCTTaaOaL TLva dvdpu>TTOiv ecrrt bvvaTov.

EAI. MaKciptoi' fxevTdv r}p.S>v, 2 îve, r]v to yevos.
HE. riws ovv av ttotc tls iTpos ye Tbv eiTL(TTd]xevov avrbs 5
dvTTL(m]ixcov o)V bvvaLT dv vyLes tl Xeyojv dvTeLTTUv;
0EAI. OvbafxSs.
HE. Tt -TTor' ovv dv etrj to ttjs (TocpLarLKrjs Swa/necos
Oavfxa;
EAI. ToC br] 7TpL; 10
HE. Kad^ OVTLVa TpOTTOV TT0T bvvaTol TOLS VOLS boÔV b
TTapaa^KevdC^LV us elal TTavTa TTavToiv avTol a-o(})(aTaTOL,
d. I Tup om. W d. 2 a.fj.(pi(T^r)TiKo{is T d 3 ois eiros elirfiv

avTois W d6 avThu] ahTh B d 7 itov T W:
om. B 64 irpbj] /cal
irphs B e 5 5)) W om. B T
: e 6 5?/ B T Stobaeus 5^ :
Si) W a 2 TTov\ vu Stobaeus a 8 rii om. T

233b nAATilNOS
bfj\ov yap m tl ixrJTC avT^Keyov 6p6m p-^^re (k^lvols ((\>ai-
vovTo, (f>atv6fjivoi re d pjjbev av fiaWov ib^Kovv bia ttjv

5 aix<pi,(rj3r]Tri(rLv eTvat (f)p6vLfji0L, t6 (tov bj] tovto, (r)(ô\r] ttot
av avTols tls xPW^to^ bLbovs ijdckev hv TOVTOiv avriav fxa&qrtjs
yiyvicrOaL.
0EAI. SxoXt) fifVT&v.
HE. Nvv 8e y (6iXov(nv;
lo 0EAI. Kat fi6\a.
C HE. AoKovcTL yap otfiai irpbs ravra iTncrTrjfjLovcos ^X^'"
avTol irpos airep avTLKeyovaLV.
0EAI. riais yap ov;
HE. ApuxTL b( y TovTo TTpos &iTavTa, (jiafxiv;
5 0EAI. Nai.
HE. UdvTa 6.pa (ro(f>ol tols fia^rfTals (paCvovTaL.
0EAI. Ti/xjjr;
HE. OvK ovTs yc abvvaTov yap tovto ye ^(f)avrf,
0EAI. n<Ss yap ovk abvvaTov;
lo HE. AoâcTTLKrfV apa tlvcl irepX irdvToov iiTL^Trqfirfv 6
(ro(f)L(TTi]s rjfXLv dAA' ovk aXrf6(Lav (x^^ dvam^fâvTaL.
d 0EAI. navTdTra(TL fiev ovv, Kal KLvbvv(V(L ye t6 vvv
Lpr]fL(vov 6p66TaTa ir^pX avToiv (lpr](r6aL.
HE. Adfi(ofx(v TOLWV (Ta(f>icrT(p6v tl iTapdb(Lyfxa TTepl

TOVT(aV.
5 0EAI. To TToXov brf;
HE. To8e. KaC fxoi Tr(Lpo Ttpo(Ti\(i>v tov vovv v fxdXa

dTT0KpLva(r6aL.
0EA1. To TTOLov;
HE. Ef TLS <f)aLr] fxr] XeyeLV fxrfb* &VTLk(yLV, dWa ttol(lv
lo Kal bpdv fXLq Tiyvrf (rvvdiTavTa (7TL(rTa(rdaL TTpdyfxaTa

e 0EAI. Y\G)s TTdvTa (ltt^s;
HE. Trfv dpyrjv tov pr]6ivTos crv y fjfXLV (v6vs dyvo(Xs'
TCL ydp (TufxTTOvTa, 0)5 HoLKas, ov fxavddv(LS.
b4 /xTfiiy TW : fii) /iTjSi' B o5 om. W b5 rh <rJ>v] rSffoy BT W

20cJ)I2THS 2336
0EAI. Ov yap ovv.
HE. Aeyco tolvvv (re koI e/i,e rajy TrdvTuiV koI Trpos ijiuv 5
Takka ^(Sa koi bevbpa.
0EAI. ria)? Aeyets;

EE. Ei rts e/xe Kai (re Kal raAAa ûra wayra T:oir\(TLV
(fyaCrj
0EAI. Ttra 8^ Kiyoiv ttjv TTOirja-iv; ov yap brj yccopyov 234
ye epets rtva* xai yap Côiv avrov eiTres 7toi.riTi]v.
SE. 't^r^fxC, Kal TTpos ye âAtirrT;? koI yrjs Kal ovpavov koX
deoiv Kal T&v aAAcoy (Tvp.TTavTu>v Ka\ toCvvv Ka\ Ta^ ttoit^-
cras avTGiv eKaara Tiavv afxtKpov vojxCay.aTos airobCboTai. 5

0EAI. naiSiai; Ae'ycts rtya.
EE. Tt 8e'; ti]v tov XiyovTOS ort iT&VTa otSe Kat TavTa
Tpov av bibdêuv okCyov koX kv 6Aty() xpovd), [X(av ov
TTaLbiaV VOp.L(TTOV;
0EiVI. Y[dvT()iS TTOV. 10

EE. riatSta? 8e exfts / rt TiîK(!>Tipov ^ Kai yapii(rrepov b
etSos 7/ To p.Lp.r]TLK6v;
0EAI. Ovbafj.(os' TTdp.TTokv yap eiprjKas etSoy eis kv

TrdvTa (TvXXalicbv Ka\ crxêbbv TTOLKLkcoTaTov.
EE. OvKovv Tov y v7TLaxyovp.vov bvvaTov etvaL [xlS. 5
Tixvrj TTdvTa TTOLelv yLyv(d(rKop.V ttov tovto, otl fxLfxi^fxaTa

KaL 6fX(avvfxa to^v ovtcov drTepyaôfxevos Trj ypa(pLKi] Ti\vi]
hvvaros e(TTaL tovs dvoifTovs rS>v v^div TTaCboov, iToppoiOev to.
yeypafxpAva k-TTLbeLKvvs, kavddveLV 0)s OTLirep av ôvkrfOi]

bpdv, TovTo LKavdjTaros cov diTOTckdv py(a. 10
0EAI. riais yap ov; C
EE. Tt 5e brj; Trept tovs \6yovs Sp' ov iTpocrboKGifxev
etvaC TLva dKX.r]V T)(vr]v, rf av bvvaTov (ovy [av] Tvy\dvt
e4 odv] ov W e8 iroi-fiireit/ W : voirjffiv BT a 2 70^] yip

877 (cal W a3 Koi yrjs W
om. B T
: a4 Kal roiwv] Kairoi eZ
Badham a 7 r^v] rh Schanz bi ^ bis om. W b6 rovro]
rovrov al. C 3 rfxyv" Ttva &\\7]v W ^ ad scripsi ^ ou B rj
: :
ovT %i>a(i(]i(ii aSseclusi ruyx''''*' Heindorf rvyxavfivBT

:
PLATO, VOL. I, 25
;
234 c nAATX2N0S
TOVi ViOVi KoX TL TTOppui TUiV TTpayp.a.TOiV TljS 6Xr]0(Cas
5 aêoTwras bia tG>v iotojv toIs X.6yois yor}T(Vi.v, bi.KVvvTas
eiScoAa keyopieva Trepl -navTdiV, axrre ttouIv aXrjOjj boKelv Af-

yeadai Kal tov XiyovTa 81) (ro(f)U)TaTov TtdvTODV aTravT ilvai.;
d 0EAI. T( yap ovK ^v eiJj aXXr) ris TOtavTrj t4x^V>

EE. Tovi TToXXovi ovv, oj catVrjre, T<av t6t aKovovTaov
ap^ ovK avdyKrj yj}6vov re CTreAôrro? avrois Uaiôv Ka\
TTpoXovcrrjs Âi/ciay roiy re ov(n TTpoa-iTLiTTovTas lyyvQiv koX
5 8ia TTaOr^pLaTcov avayKaCop.Vovs kvapySts e(f)diTTa9ai. Tdv
6vTU)V, pi.Ta^dk\LV Tas t6t yVoiJ.vas b6â9, u)(tt a-ixtKpa
ixev (f)aLVa-dai ra fxcydXa, jâAeira b^ to, p(ibia, Kal Ttdjrra
e TTdvTr} dvaTTpd(f)6aL to, iv rots Ao'yois (fâvTda-fxaTa vtto T(av
v rais TTpd$aLv ^pyuiv TrapayvopLvoi)v

0EAI. '12s yovv iixol rijAiKoiSe ovri KpLvai. dtyLai, 8e
KoX e/ie t5)V tl mppojOev d(f)aTr}K6T0)v etyai.
5 HE. Totyapovv r]piLs o"e oXbe TrdvTes TTeLpaadixeOa Kal
vvv TtLp(!)p.Oa (wy lyyvTaTa 6.VV tS>v TTaOrjixxTo^v TrpocrdyeLV.
TTp\ 8' ovv Tov a-o(f)LaTov ro8e /xoi Ae'ye* iT^Tepov ijbr] tovto
235 (ra(f>S, OTL tS)v yoriTOiV Io-tl tls, HLp.rjTr]S o)V tojv 6vto)V, tj
Stcrraô/xey ert p.!] Trept 6(ro)VTTp dvTLkeyetv hoKel bvvaTos

eiyat, Trept to(tovto)v koX tcls TTL(TTr]ixas d\r]6o)s )(o)v
TvyxdvL;
5 0EAI. Kal 'TTOis &v, S) êve; dAAa <rxeb6v ijbri <ra<^cs
K To)V lpr]ixvo)V, OTL TO)V Trjs 7rai8tas ixTx6vto)V ea-TL rts

t pLpS)v t ets.
HE. T6r]Ta ixV br] Ka\ ixLixr]Tr]v apa Oereov avT6v TLva.
0EAI. riws ydp ov OeTeov;
10 EE. "Aye 8?;, vvv r]ixTpov epyov ijbr] tov Orjpa /XTjKe^r'
b dyctrat* o-xc8oy ydp avrbv 7repiciA^</)afxci' (v d/x<î/3AT;crrpiKo>
C 7 airavTwv W d I roiavrr] ris &K\r\ W <i a 3 om. B

<i4 Tors Tf oZiTi om. pr. T 63 Kplvat secl. Ast : Kpivtiv W
e6 irip(tf/u(0o del. Schanz a^ rvyxivri Heindorf &'] yutpwi']
fivpiwv Apelt fh W : tU BT (hospiti tribuunt ut sit ds yîtr)
a8 avT6v T W : om. B a 10 vvv'^ vvv yap W
20*I2TH2 235b
Tivi T(av (V rot? XoyoLS Trept to. Toiavra opydvuiv, cScrre
ovKT K(f>ev^Tai Tobe ye.

0EAI. To TToXov;
HE. To fjif] ov Tov yivovs ivai tov tu)V OavixaTOTiOiSiv 5
TLS 1?.
0EAI. Kd/jtoi TovTo ye ovTUi jrepl avTov (rvvboKd.
HE. AeSoKrat toCvvv otl TaxLora bLaLpeXv ttjv etScoAo-
TTOLLKijv Txvr}v, Kal KaTa^CLVTas ets avTijv, iav [j.V 7;/xas' eii^vs
6 (ro(f>i(TTr}s VTTOjj.Lvr], crvXXaîLV avTov KaTO. tcl imcTTaXp.iva 10

v-no Tov âcTLXLKov \6yov, Ka.KLV<a TiapahovTas aTTO(pi]vaL c
Ti]v dypav idv 8' dpa Kora /ixeprj rTjs /it/XTjrtK7/s SvTjrat 777/,
oT;yaKoAo vêti; avrw Statpouirras det ttjv V7robexop.4vr}v avTov

pLOLpav, cocnTp dv krjcfiOi]. ndvTcos ovt ovtos ovt dXXo
yevos ovbV jxri itot K(pvydv TTv^r]TaL Tr]V tS)V odrco 5
bvvap.V(jiiV fXTLvat Ka6' Kaa-Td re Kat eirt Trcii^ra ^6obov.

0EAI. Aeyet? eu, Kal TavTa TavTj] TTOLr^Teov.
HE. Kara br] tov TTapeXrjXvdoTa TpoTTOv Ti]S StatpeVecoj
fyoiye fioi Kal vvv cfiaLVOixai bvo Kadopdv elbr] Trjs p.Lp.r]TLKrjs' d
Tr]v be Cr]TovfXvr]v Ibiav, iv 6TTOTp(o tto^' rjjxXv ovcra TvyxdvL,
KaTap.adLV ovbeirco p.0L boKco vvv bvvaTos etvat.
0EAI. 2i/ b' dAA' etTre iTpSiTov kol bUXe fjfxlv tlv rcJb
bvo Aeyet?. 5
HE. Mtav fxV TrjV etKacrriKî; opcov iv avTrj Txyi]v.
(rTL 8' avrq fxdXL^rra OTTorav KaTa Tas tov TTapabLyp.aTos

(rvpLfXTpLas TLS V /X7/Ket Kai TrAdret Kat jiddL, Ka\ iTpos
TovTOLS TL yj}(i)fxaTa aTTobLbovs Ta TTpocrifKovTa KdaTOLS, TTfV e

roi; fLLfxr]pLaTos yV(TLV dTTpydQf]TaL. .
0EAI. Tt8'; ou Trdrresot /xt/xo7;/xeyoirt roiJr' eTTtXfipoi^frt
8pdy;
b 3 ovKtT WovK: iri B ovk T b4 rb W : om. BT b5 tov

W
:
tSiv T TovTwy B b8 5f Sfi/cTotW SeSeiKTaj BT C 2 KaTo]

KaTo,
:
Th Heindorf d. 2 Trore odaa W7]fjuv

:
d 3 vvv Sokw W fxoi

d4 Koi Sif\e irpwTov W d. 6 opu W e i kKaaTois W Stobaeus :
eKa.(rTais BT
25*
;
2356 nAATI2N02
5 HE. OvKovv oaoi. ye tQv ixc/akoiv tcov ti vkaTTov<Tiv
epyoiv T] ypa(\>ov(TLv. ct yap atTohLhoZiv Trjv tu>v KaX^v

a\r]6i.vr]v (TVfJLpifTpiav, otcr^' ori a-fxiKpoTepa fiev tov biovTOi
236 To. av(o, /xf t^co 8e to. /carco (\>aivoiT av 8ia t6 tol jxkv "noppoidiv,
TCL 8' kyyvQiv {xpi' r)p(iv 6pa(rdai.
0EAI. Yldvv pikv ovv.

HE. 'Ap' ovv ov xaCpeiv t6 dArjêj (dcravTes ol brjixLovpyo).
5 vvv ov Tas ov(ras (rvjxixfTpLas dAAa tcls boôvaas elvat Kakas

TOLS ctSwXots ivaTTfpydôvTai;
0EAI. na:;rd7rao-i ye.
SE. To fxv dpa iTfpov ov bUaLov, (Ikos ye ov, tlKova
KaX.(Lv;
10 0EAI. Nat'.
b SE. Kai Trjs ye /xt/xTjriK^j ro cTrt rovro) fxepos /cXr/rcoi'
oTrep LTTOfXv v rw TTpoa-dev, flKaarua^vj
0EAI. KArjreW.
SE. Tt 8e; ro (f)aLv6fXvov fxev 8ta TTJy ovk ck KaAoO
5 6eav eoLKvaL t(d KaAw, bvvafXLV be et tls Ad/3ot tol rr/At/caCra
tKai^cis opai', /XTjS' eiKos oi (l>rfcrLv eotKeVat, rt KoXovfXiv; ap

OVK, CTretTrep (fâCvcTaL fxiv, olk 8e ov, (f)dvTaa-fia;
0EAI. Tt jLtTji;;
SE. OvKOW 7rd/A7roAu Kot Kara rr/y âypa^pCav tovto t6

C fxipos ecrrt Kat Kora crvfXTTaa-av fXLfxrfTLKrjv;
0EAI. nws 8' ov;

SE. TT/y 8t; (pdvTaa-fxa dAA' ovk eiKoVa d-nipyaôfxivrfv
Texyrfv dp' ov (jiavTaaTiKrjv 6p66TaT dv irpoaayopevoi.fxev
5 0EAI. noAv ye.
SE. TovToii TOLVVV TOi bvo (k^yov ilbrf Trjs (iboiXoTTOlLKrjS,
eiKao-rtKT/y Kat (jyavTaa-TLKifV.
e 6 aAii/] KciXeoi' Badham a 3 irdw ixtv oZy T Stobaeus :SoKfl

fxoi -irdvv /xfv olv W om. B a 5 vvv] ol vvv Hcindorf a 7 xav-
W
:
Toirao-j 7 : ireti/u /ui' olv BT a 8 tJ) /lif i/ 4pa] ip' oiv rh

/ufvW fWs 7 o/] tixao-TtKrfi/W (lK6vaom.\W bôiucfic]
ToO Stobaei cod. A îc al. b6 ^] S W C i ri)v ^vfnracrav
T Stobaeus C3
:
(ôvTao-juo W : <pavTd<rfiara BT C 5 -Kdw yt W

2012THS 236 c
0EAI. 'Op(9(Ss.
HE. *0 be ye /cat tot^ riix(()eyv6ovv, <(eiv TroTepa tov
(To<l)L(rT-t]v dTov, ovb vvv 770) bvvufxaL 6e(i(Ta(rdai cra(f)U)s, lo
dAA' ovT(DS 6av\xa(TTos avr]p Kot KartSety irayxaAeTros, cTret d

Kai rw /ioAa ev Kat Kop,\lfa)S eis aTiopov eiSos 8ie/3wr/(ra(râi
KaTaTTe^fêvyev.
0EAI. "EotKer.
HE. 'Ap' ow awo ytyrcotrKO)!' crvix(f)ris, ?/ (re otoi' pvV^? 5
rts -yTTO rou Xo'you <Tvveidi(Tp.ivov (Tvv^Tiea-TxacraTO xpos to
raî/ (rvpi(f)fjaat;
0EAI. n&is Kai 7rpo9 rt tovto dprjKas;

HE. "Orrcos, S) fxaK(xpL, ecrjuev ey TrarraTracri \a\T:fj
crKi\f/L. t6 yap (paivecrdaL tovto Kal to boKelv, etrat 8e e
p.y], Kal To XeyeLV [xev ctTTa, aXr]dT] be fxi], TrdvTa Tai'T<x eort
[xecTTa dTTopCas del ev roi Trpocrdev Xp6v(o kol vvv. ottco? ydp
eiTToVra \pi] xj/evbrj KeyeLV i] bo^dêLV ovtcds elvaL, koX tovto
(pOey^dfxevov evavTLokoyCq ixrj (Tvve\ecr6aL, TTavrdTiaa-LV, a 5
0eatr77re, \akeT:6v. 237

0EAI. Tt87j;
HE. Tero'A/>iTjKei; 6 X6yos ovtos vTiodecTOaL to /x?/ ov
eXvaL' yf/evbos yap ovk dv dWoos eyCyveTO ov. YlapixevCbr]^
b^ 6 fieyas, S) Tral, Tratcrty rjp.LV ov(tlv dpx6]xev6s re Kat 8ta 5

re'A.ous tovto aTrefxapTvpaTO, Tre^T/ re c58e cKcio-rore XeycDV Kal
[xeTd fxeTpoDV
Ov ydp plT] TTore tovto bafxfj, (f)r](rCv, etvai fxr] eo'rra*
oAAa (Tv Tr](rb^ d^f)' obov bL^r]jxevos etpye vdvjfxa.
C9 t<{t'1 toCt' T iv ac3d. Bessarionis liber irorepa B:

Trdrepa TW C lo Bedcraffdai] PeâitiaaffBai W (an dfdffacrOai
jSe^Soicoy ?) di Oav/xacrrws B avT}p Bekker auijp B T d6 crvv-
W
:
eTTfcrirdcraro W^ yvv iinairdcraro BT d8 t/ oti B T 63 fjLeara

W W
: :
T W : om. B a 4 iyiyvtro'^
W
yl-yvoi.ro a 5 t^jxiv niv BT
W
:
Te (col Heindorf ye koI : : Se /col BT a6

toDtoI toCt'
ir*^^] Toifei T a
8 rovro Saufj Simplicius toCt' ovSa/^y B T toSt'
W
: ;
ou SafiTJ (6vra Aristoteles Met. 1089 a, 4 Svra BT a9 Si^ti-

W
:
I.UVOS BT (sed St(ri(rios infra 258 d)

:
237 1> nAATX2N02

b Trap iKLVOv T ovv fJLapTvpdTai, Kal fxdXKTTd ye 8j) TrdvTcov
6 Aoyos avTos hv STjXworeie fiiTpia âa-avLorOeCs. tovto ovv

avTo TTpuiTov dcaa-dixeOa, ei /xtj tC o-oi 8iaê'pei.
0EAI. To jLtei^ ipLov oirrf j3ovAet TLOecro, tov 8e Ao'yoy
5 r/ /3e'AricrTa 6te'êiori o-kott&ij; airos re Wi /ca/;x^ /cara TavTr]v
r?)y 68oy aye.

HE. 'AAAa x/>^;
S/aay raCra. /cat /xot Ae'ye* to fxrjbaiiojs
6v ToXp.(ap.dv TTov cfÔeyyeaÔaL;

0EAI. riws yap ov;
lo HE. M?) rotyw eptSos ere/ca /xrjSe TraiStas, dAA' ei a-jTovb?j
C 8e'oi o-urwj/o-arrd riva cLTTOKpCvaa-daL tS>v OLKpoaTiov, ttol \pii

TOVVOfX iTTL(f)pLV TOVTO, TO /X?) OV TL boKOVpifV CLV eiS rt
KOL ttI TTolov avTov T KaTaxpwaaOaL Kal r^ TTvvdavoixcvca

beLKVvvai;
5 0EAI. XaAeTToy -Ijpov #cat a-)(bbv eiTreiy oio) yc ifiol
TTavTdiTaa-LV ^Tropor.
HE. 'AAA' ovv TovTo ye SÂor, ort t^v ovtcov ert ^rt)
t6 /xr) oy ovK oto-reor.
0EAI. ns yap ay;
lo HE. OvKovv iTretirep ovk îri r6 ov, ov8' ^ttI to tI êpoiv
dp9S>s dv rts (f)poi.
0EAI. nS,s brj;

d HE. Kat TOVTO Tj^lLLV TTOV <f)aVp6v, 0)S KOL TO " tI" TOVTO
{prjp.a] eTr' ovtl Xyop.V KdaTOT' p.6vov yap avTo Xiy^LV,
&a-TTp yvp.vov kol dTTr]pr]pLOi}pLVov dTTo tS)V ovtoov airdvTcav,
i,bvvaTov ?/ ydp;
5 0EAI. ÂbvvaTov.
HE. Âpa Tr\b a-KOTT^v (rvp.(f)r]i ws hfdyKt] tov ri \4yoirra
V yi Ti kyLv;
b2 avThs W : ovros BT b8 <p0(yâ(Teat W b lo a\\' *l

W
airovSp Bekker : iXArjj irov 5^ B a\\ij ffirovS^ T :
: iw' ti fficovSrii
2 Ti] StiTW C7 t< add. corr. Par. 1808 c 10 <pfpa.v]
<j>fpov W dI Tovro Schanz tovto ^rjfia T : rov ^fxaTOS B
W
:
^5/ua d2 yiip oiD. T

20I2TH2 237d
0EAI. Ovrm.
SE. *Evos yap hi] t6 ye "ri" tpijaeLS a-qixelov etvai, to
be " Tive " hvoZv, to 8e

**
rires " TToXkoiv. lo
0EAI. riaJs yap ov;

SE. Tov 8e 8^ /xr) rt XeyovTa avayKaiOTaTOv, ws eotKe, e
7rai'rd77ao-t fxr]bev Xeyeiv.
0EAI. 'ArayKatoraror /ixei' ovv.
SE. 'Ap' oSy ov8e roCro (rvyx<opr]Tiov, t6 tov toiovtov
Aeyety jueV [rt], Ae'yetv p.ivToi fxrjbev, aAA' oiJ8e Ae^yetr 5
(f>aTOV, os y av eTrtxetpjj /x?) oy (^Qiyyea-Qai;

0EAI. Te'Aos yovv av aTTopCas 6 \6yos <X^*'
SE. M7/7r(o jue'y' ei777/s* ert ydp, S) p.aKapi, ecm, Kal 238
TavTo. ye roii' aiToptu>v tj jJieyiaTr] Kal TrpdoTr]. Trept yap
avTi]V avTov ti]V apyr]V cvaa Tvyxavû
0EAI. ITaJs (\>r\s; kiyc Kal fj.r]bV cnroKvrj^rqs.
SE. T<a peV OVTL TTOV TTpoayivOLT aV TLTiOV OVT(i)V Tp0V. 5
0EAI. ritSs ya/) ov;
SE. Mt) oi^rt 8e rt rwy ovtcov apa. ttot Ttpoa-yLyvea-OaL
(j)r]aop.ev bvvaTov etrat;
0EAI. Kai TTuts;
SE. ÂpL0p.6v br] t6v avfiTTavTa t5)v ovTOiV TLdepev. 10
0EAI. EtTrep ye xat dAAo rt OeTeov ws or. b
SE. Mt) tolvvv ftrjS' eTTLX^LpQpLev apLOpov fxrJTe Trkrjflos
p.r]T V TTpos ro /i?; oz; 7Tpoa(f)ipLV.
0EAI. OvKovv av opOcos ye, a)s ioLKev, kiTLyeLpoLpev, u)s

(f)riaLV 6 Adyoj. 5
SE. riais' ovv av 7/ 8ta ro5 aT6p.aT0S (f)6iyâLT0 av tls r]
KOL Ty bLavoLCL t6 Trapa.TTav XijSoL tol pi] ovTa 7/ to p.r] ov

XCDpls apLOpLOv;
dg 76 om. W e^ rhv rb B 65 /ueV om. B ri secl.

Schleiermacher e6 y] 5' W: om. T iv] fj.r)5fv W
W
/j.r]
e 7 &y] Stj xo* ^ AtJyoj T a r ert] (ttj T a 2 7

delendum susp. Heindorf a 7 ovti Se tP &' 5e ti B : outi. 5e T
TTOTs om. B a 7 <tyi)aofi(v irpoayiyyeffdai W b 3 J tJ> ev
W : Tb i,' T
238 b nAAT12N0S
0EAI. Aye Trfj;
lo HE. M^ ovra /xey iirdhav XeycofKV, Zpa ov T:\rj6os
C iTi\ipovixiv hpidp.ov TTpoa-Tidevat;
0EAI. Tl ixi]v;
HE. M^ 6v be, S,pa ov to ^v av;
0EAI. âcftea-TaTa, ye.
5 s,E. Kai p.T]v ovT biKaiov ye oiJre opdov <})afi(v ov
eTTLx^Lpetv fxr] ovtl TTpoa-appt.oTTeLV.
0EAI. Aeyeis akr]6iaTaTa.
HE. Swroeis ow ws ovTi (f)6iyâa-0aL bvvaTov 6p6<as
ovT dTTLV ovT hiavoy]67]vaL To fiT] ov avTO Kad^ avTo, ÂA'
lo loTiy ahLavor^Tov re kol apprjTov Kal a(f)deyKTov Kal aXoyov;
0EAI. YlavTaTTaa-L jj-ev ovv.
d HE. Ap' ovv i\}/eva-aiJ.r]v apTL Xcycov Tr]v fXyLa-Tr]v aiTopLav
epiLV avTov iTepL, t6 8e ert /ieiX<u tlvcl XiyHV aXXr]v iyopav;
0EAI. Tiva hr];
HE. '12 6av]xaaL, ovk î^roety avToli roiy Aexêtcriv ori
5 Kal Tov iXeyôvTa els aiTopiav KadioTrja-L t6 fxr] 6v ovtcos,

ware, oiTOTav avTo eTrtxetprj rts eAe^yxety, ivavria avT6v
avT(a TTepL eKetvo avayK(iC(o-6aL XeyeLv;
0EAI. Ilaiy (t^ps; etTre ert (Ta(f>i(mpov.
EE. Ovhiv 8et To aa(f)e(rTpov iv ifxol (TKOTTfiv. iyo) fikv
e yap VTTo6ifXVOS 0VT v6s OVT T&V TToXXCiv t6 /xj/ ov bflv
/xere'xety, apTL re Kal vvv ovto)S (V avTo elprfKa' t6 /xt/ ov
yap <^7j/x/. avvLrjs rot.
0EAI. Nai.
5 HE. Kai fi.r]v av Kal (TfXLKp6v ifxiTpocrdev 6.(^6 iyKTov re
avT6 Kcu apprfTov kcll aXoyov e^T/y etrat. avviiTr];
0EAI. 2uW7ro/xat. ttS)s yap ov;
C I ipi6fxov iirixftpovixtv T C 5 iv T W om. B da r^ S^

W
:
: T<J5e BT sed rov in marg. T : rf 5i in marg. al. : r6 Si (t/ 5i)

. . . txoîfv hospiti primus tribuit Winckelmann ds riva 5^;
Winckelmann: t/ 56; B: rtSal; T hospiti tribuentes d^ avTots]
iv avTois W d 7 abrif T : oury W avrh B 67 (wtVoÔi.
W
:
Kws yap oC; T : ^vvivo^jiai woiy B

:
204>I2TH2 2380
HE. OvKovv t6 ye cimi itpoa-a-nTeiv TTdpaixivos ivavTia

Tols TTpocrOiv eXfyov; 239
0EAI. âivri.
HE. Ti 8e; tovto irpocrdTrTcov ov^ w? ^rt SteAeyojur/y;
0EAI. Nai'.
HE. Kal ixrjv dXoyov ye XiycDV Kal dppr]Tov Kal a(f)6yKT0V 5
ws ye TT/oos ty roy koyov iTTOcovpirjv.
0EAI. ncSy 6' oi;

HE. Jâ/xey 8e ye beXv, iiirep opdc^s rt? Aeêt, jUTjTe ws
ey /iJ/re ws TToAAa btopL^fLV avTo, ixrjbe to TrapaTrav avTO -
KaXdv v6s ydp ei8ei /cai Kara Tavrrjv dv TrjV Trp6apr](rLV 10
Trpocrayopevotro.
0EAI. IlayraTrao-t ye.
HE. Tov iiev TOLVvv e/xe ye rt rts dv XiyoL; koX ydp b
TraAat /cat ra wy r]TTr]ixevov dv evpoL Trept roy tov ixr] ovtos
eAeyxoi'. cSo-re iv e/xotye Ae^yoz^rt, KaddiTep eliTov, /x?)
<TKOTTSip.V Ti]v opOokoyiav TTepl To /ir/ oi', dAA' eta br] vvv
iv aol (TKexj/coixeOa. 5
0EAI. U(os </)7/s;
HE. "Wl rjpuv v Kal ycwaCcos, aTC veos U)V, otl ixdkL^TTa
bvva(raL (TvvTeivas TTeLpd6r]TL, ixrjTe ov(riav p.r]Te to ev ixriTe
TTkrjdos dpL6p.ov TTpoa-TLêls rw /x^ wri, KaTa to 6p6ov

(f)6eyâ(r6ai tl Trept avTov. 10
0EAI. HoAA^ ixevTdv /xe Kai dTOTTos exot iTpo6vp.ia c
TTJs eTTtxei/oâ-ecos, et (re rotaC^' opojy Traoôvra avros
eTTixetpotr/y.
HE. 'AAA' et Sofcet, o-e p.v Kal e/xe yaipeLV ecopLev etos
8' ay rti'! bvvaixevio bpdv tovto VTvy\dv(X)p.ev, p-expi- tovtov 5
aI T
e\(yov \6yov BW a 3 vpoffdirrwv] wpotrdycav T ej/l]
W
:
Iv T : Heindorf
6</ &;/ as-yeTW^TtB a8 rts] ri
a 10 fvhs yap eifSet B ev rt âp tlfSet T fvhs yap (Sti
: iv evhs yap: W :
fiSft Winckelmann ev ri yap ^Stj Heindorf

: b i iix4 re ri ris B
W
:
e/iE y( tri ris T : yue trt ri ris b4 elo Bessarionis liber

a BT b8 rb om. W hg rh opdhv'] rhv opdhv \6yov T
C 2 opwv roiavra W
239 c nAATi2N02
kcyo)fXv b>s TTavTos fxaXXov iravovpyws cts SiTtopov 6 cro<f)i(rTi]s
TOTTOV KaTahihvKiv.
0EAI. Kat /idAa 8^ (paCvcTai.
\\
HE. Toiyapovv et Ttva <f)ri(rofXv avTov exfti' <f)avTa(mKi]v
v\ d Tixytfv, paottos ^k ravT-qs rijs XP^ los ^^^ Koycov avTt.Xap.fta-

v6p.vos r]p.G)v ils TovvavTiov aTToaTpi\j/i tovs Xoyovs, oTav
eiScoA.oTrotoy avTov KaX.Qp.v, avp(i)Tcav tC Trore to Trapa-nav
lh(i)\ov \4yofxev. (TKOitiiv ovv, o) QeaiT-qTe, \pi] Ti rtj rw
5 ViavLa irpbs to ip(i)T(ip.vov aTTOKpaxlTai.
0EAI. AÂoy ori (f>i]a-op.iv t6. re Iv toZs vha(n KaX

KaTOTTTpois eiSojAa, ^ri Kai to. yeypappeva Kal to. TiTVTT(t)p.iva
KaX TaXXa ocra ttov TotavT^ (r6^ (Tepa.

C HE. fiâvepos, o) QâirqTC, et cro(pia-Ti]v ov\ kcopaKdcis.
0EAI. TCbri;
HE. Aoêi (Tot jxviv TTavT&TTaai.v ovK exetv 6pp.aTa.
T]
0EAI. UG)s;
5 HE. Ti]v aiT^Kpicnv oTav ovto)s avT<a bih^s iav ev KaT6-
TTTpois T] TTXa(Tp,a(Ti Ae'y7/s rt, /carayeAdo-era^ (tov tG)V X6yo)V,
OTav 0)s ftXeiTOVTt X4yr]s avTSt, TTpoa-TTOiovp.Vos ovre KaToiTTpa

240 oiJre vhaTa yLyvcaa-KUV ovTi rh irapaTTav 6\ffiv, to b' ck tQv
X6y(i)V (po)Tr\(Tu arc pMVOV.
0EAI. notor;
HE. To 8ta Tr6vT(t)v tovto)v h ?roAAa flTToiv "q^Caxras kv\
5 TTpoa-eiTTetv 6v6p.aTi (fÔcyâpevos (tho)Xov eiri Trao-tr o)S ev
6v. Ae'ye ovv Kal apvvov pr]b(v VTTo\o)p(av tov avhpa.
0EAI. Tt br]Ta, 0) êv, eiScoAoy hv (fâlfxfv eivat irXyjv
ye To TTpbs TaXr]6tvbv a(f)0)p.oto)pvov tTcpov TotovTov;
HE. "Erepoy b\ Ae'yets TotovTov aXx]6tv6v, rj ttI tCvl to

b TOtovTov etTres;
C6 iravovpyoi B d. i p^peios to);' A.iJyeB' W

T :
XP*'"* rbi/ XcJyov B :
Xf iSy Tov \6xov Madvig d a airo(TTp(\f/(t corr. T aiT0Tpf\f/fi B T VV

W W
:
d 3 rrore om. T d 4 xp^t ^ OfaiTffTf W

d 7 Itj om. :
Tj (5^) xal Heindorf ei tl, Si d(aiTr)T( W

65 a' secl.
Heindorf 4av : Kfyris
. . t.secl. Cobet e 7 Stoi/ oury del. . . .
Cobet /3AirofTt] /3AeVwj' ti T a a \6y<iiy] ipyaiu W

204>I2TH2 240b
0EAI. Ovbaixcas akqOivov ye, oAA' koLKos y-iv.

HE. Âpa To aXr]6ivov 6vto)S ov kiyoiv;
0EAI. Oin-coy.
HE. Ti 6e; to aXrjOivbv ap' ivavTiov aXr]6ovs;
/lit/
5
0EAI. Tl ixriv;
HE, OvK ovToos [ovk] ov apa Aeyets to ioLKOSy (LiTfp avTO
ye p.-!] a\r]6iv6v epets.
0EAI. 'AAA' eo-rt ye fj.r]V TTOiS.
HE. OvKovv aXr]d(iis ye, </)r/s. 10
0EAI. Ov yap ovv TrXrjv y elKiov ovTOis.
HE. OvK ov apa [ovk] ovtoos ioTlv ovTcas rjv Xiyoiiiv
iLKova;
0EAI. KirSvyevet TOLavrqv tlvo. 'neTikiy6aL avixTT\oKi]v c
To ixrf ov Tw ovTL, Kal pioAa cltottov.
HE. Tlcas yap ovk aTOTtov; opqs yovv otl Kal vvv 8ia
T7/9 eTTaAAaêcios TavTr]s 6 nokvKicâXos (TO(f)LaTr]s rjvayKaKiv
i]IJ.as To ixri ov ov)(^ CKOVTas o/xoAoycii' ciyai ttoos 5
0EAI. *0p<3 Kat /uaAa.
HE. Tt 8e 6t]; n/i^ Txvr]v avTov TLva a(f)opL(ravTs rniiv
avTols aviJi(paiveXv oXoi re (aoiieâ;
0EAI. n?/ Kat To TTolov TL (f>oPovp.vos ovT(o Ae'yet?;
HE. "Oray Trept t6 (fxxvTaa-ixa avT6v aTraTav (f)Qixev Kal d

Tr]v T^xyriv LvaC TLva aTTaTr]TLKr]V avTOv, t6t TroVepoi' \f/evbr]
bo^dC^LV Ti]V yf/rr)(r]v rjp.oov (f)r]crop.v vtto Tr]S iKCLVOV Tiyvrjs,

7/ rt 77ot' ipovpi^v;
0EAI. Tovro* Tt yap av aAAo etTrai/uei;; 5

HE. ^ciiSt/s 8' av boâ icTTai TavavTLa rot? ovo-i boâ-
Covcra, 7/ TTcas;
b7 ovTCDS W : uvTuv B : om. T iv T : ovKbv B : ouk hv W

bg ira)s Hermann : irws; BT praecedentia hospiti tribuentes^
b 10 oijKovvV^: ovKovv T ovKbv B : -ye 07Js (sic) T: "y' %(pi)v BW
b II ovTwy] ovTos rec. t (et mox) b 12 ovk Jv] ovKhv B : ovkovv T
ovK secl. Badham C 3 iâs 70D1' T W Stobaeus : om. B C 4 eV-
o\A.a|f ctfs] iira.\êa)S Stobaeus C7 axjôpiôvres W Stobaeus
d I tpdvTaarna T Stobaeus <l>d<rixa : B d2 vorfpa W
24od nAATi2N0S
0EAI. OvTOiS' TavavTLa.
HE. Aeyeis &pa Ta fxri ovTa bo^d(îv rriv yjrfvbr] boâv;
lo 0EA1. 'AvdyKij.
e HE. HoTepov pLT} elvai. to. fxr] Sirra ho^d(ov(rav, 7; ttcos
ftvai Ta iJLr}bap.&s ovTa;

0EAI. Yilvai irois to. fxr} ovTa Sei ye, eiTrep yj/eva-eTai
TTOT^ Tis Ti Kol KaTCL ^payy.
5 HE. Ti V; ov Kol fxrjbafjL&s eirai to. Trarrcoy ovra
bo^dC^Tai;
0EAI. NaC.
HE. Kat TovTO br} îvbos;
0EAI. Kai Tovro.
10 HE. Kai Aoyos oTfxaL \}rvbris ovT<a /cara ravra vo}XL<T6rf-
241 o-erat ra re ovTa Xiyiav fxrf elvaL Kal tcl fxr} ovTa eTvaL.
0EAI. Ylcas yap &v dXkoys tolovtos yivoLTo;
HE. 2)(e8ov ovbafxSiS' dXKd TavTa 6 cro<^L(TTr}s ov <pr}(TtL.
r} TLS fxrfyjoLvr} avy)(^(t)piv TLva TOiv cv <ppovovvT(tiv, otov

5 \a(l)6eyKTa koX dpptfTa Kal dKoya Kal dbLav6r}Ta] iTpocr-
bL(ti}xo\oyrffxiva
f}
Ta Trpd tovtoov ofxokoyr^dejrra; fxavddvofxev,
o) QeaLTrfTf, h Ae'yei;
0EAI. n&)s ydp ov fxav6dv6fXv ori TavavTLa <f)-qcr(L
Ae'yeiv rffjMS toTs vvvbrf, ^cvbrj To\fxi}<ravTas eltrflv ws loriy

b iv boâLS re kol Kard Xoyovs; rw ydp fxrf ovtl to dv TTpo<r-
diTTeLv r}p.ds TToWdKLS dvayKdC<r6aL, bLOfxoXoytfcrafxevovs
vvvbr} TovTo eTvai TrdvTiav dbvvaT<aTaTov.
HE. Ôp6G)s aTTefxvrffxoveva-as. dXk^ dpabr}[ôv\evia6aL\

5 TL XPV bpdv TOV (TO<\)L(TTOV TTpL' TaS ydp dvTLkr}\l/LS Kal
d 8 ovTies Stobaeus om. B T : d 9 SoâCtiv to /j.^ tiuTa fiij W :
ivTa SoîCeiv Stobaeus e i irws'] irus Ktyfis Stobaeus e 3 5t?

ye] Kfff Stobaeus Sii yt Heindorf
: 64 ti om. T e 10 TavTo.
Stobaeus ToOTa toCto B toCto T toutci toCto
W
: : : a a SAX&jy W
Stobaeus: 6.\\os BT0,^ ov om. W

4 ^ om. W
as &<pdfyKTa . &Siav6ijTa secl. Madvig
. . wpohiwnoKoyriixfva T
a 7 \ey(i\ \eyeis B T a 8 A^7*ii' <prifflv W
b 3 tovto W :
irov TovTo BT b4 o/>o] &pa al. fiovKfvfadai seclusi ffov- :
\fV(Ta(T6fu T
; :
20*I2TH2 24ib
OLTTopias, (CLV avTov 8tepeuycSju,ey iv Trj t5)v -êvhovpydv koI

yoriTtiiv Tiyjrq TiOivTe^, opas <ws evTTOpoL Kai TroAAai.
0EAI. Kai )u,aAa.
SE. MLKpbv fxepos TOLWV avTcav bikqXv6apt.V, ova-Qiv
WS iTTOS (iiTiiv aTTpdirr(ov. C

0EAI. ÂbvvaTov y dv, wj eoiKV, eiTj tov (TO(f)La-Ti}v
kXelv, el TavTa ovtcds e\eL,

HE. Ti ovv; ovT(j)S dTToarrâ-opieOa vvv fxaXOaKLa-OevTes
0EAI. OvKovv eycoye (f)r]ixL be^LV, ei Kal KaTO. a-p.LKp6v 5
oXoL T e-nLKajiecrdaL TTrj Tdvbpos ea-p.ev.
SE. "Eêts ovv a~vyyv(ap.r\v Ka\ KaBdiTep vvv eXires dya-
irqa-eLS edv TTrj Kal KaTo. I3pa)(y TTapadTTacrwp.eOa ovt(ds
Lcr^pov Xoyov;
0EAI. Uuts yap ovx e^w; lo
HE. To8e TOLWV eTL pidXXov TTapaLTovfiaC cre. d

0EAI. To TTOLOv;
HE. Mrj /Lte oroy TraTpakoLav VTToXdjirjs yiyvecrOaL TLva.
0EAI. Tibri;
HE. Toy Tov TTaTpos Ylap[xevibov Xoyov dvayKalov rjp.lv 5
d}ivvopLevoLS ia-Tai âa-aviêLV, Kal îdêa-OaL t6 re /u.r/ 6v o)S
ecTTL KaTd TL Kal To ov av TrdXLV o)s ovk eaTL TTrj.
0EAI. IâtVerai to tolovtov 8taju,axere'oy ev rots Ao'yots.

HE. ri(os ydp ov (f)aLveTaL Kal to Xey6p.evov 67) tovto tv-
(f)X^ ; TOVT(av ydp p.r\T eXeyxdevToov p.r]Te 6pLoXoyr]6evT(DV crxoXf] 6
TTore TLS ol6s re ecrrat Trept X6y(i)v yêvbS>v Xeycov r/ b6^r]s,
eire elb(oX(j)v etre elKovo^v etre p.LpLr]p.dT(t)v eire (f)avTaa-p.dT(t)V
avTdtv, r] Kal iTepl Teyvwv tS)v oa-aL Trept ravrd eto-t, p.r] KaTa-
yeXaa-Tos etvaL Td <(y') evavTia dvayKaC,6}xevos airr^ XeyeLV. 5
b6 yo-fjrwv Kol i^fvSovpyaiy riOfvreT rix^V ^ ^ 7 eviropoi] &iropoi

Heusde C2 -y' Sj^scripsi : yap B T Sp' W yap tiva.\. : r&p Camp-
W om. B T
: :
bell fet mox toiK, Uv eXri) C 4 ovrws C 7 e?7rs

W
:
i/C/ C8 irjj] itt; ti Badham d8 rb . . . \6yois secl.

Hermann îafiaxnreov TW:om. B er i\fyxOfvrwv T;
/Lcir)T6
/jiTirfKex^fyTaiv B /i-fire Xix^^vrwv W 65 ra.y ivavria scripsi

W
:
ra fjifv avTi B : ra tvavria T

:
241 e riAATiiNOS
0EA1. 'AkrjeearaTa.
242 EE. Aia Tavra îevToi ToXixrjTôv iTnTiBea-dai t& Tta-
TpLK(o Aoyo) vvv, 7] To TTapa-nav iaTcov, el tovto tis elpya.
bpav oKVos.
0EAI. 'AAA' ^/xa? tovto ye pirjbev /irjSa/iiTj ^"^P^h
5 HE. TpiTOV ToCvVV iTL (T( (TIXLKpOV TL TTapaLTl](rOIXaL.
0EAI. Aeye p.6vov.

HE. EiTTW Ttov vvvhi) X-eyoov &>? Trpbs tov Trepl Tavr
iX^yyov aL re dTreipj/KO)? eyo) Tvyx6.i^<ii Kal bij Kal to. vvv.
0EAI. EiTres.
10 HE. 4>o/3o{i/xat brj to. ilpr\p.iva, ixi] Trore 8ta Tavra (tol
fxavLKos elvaL 80^(0 Trapa 7ro8a /Aera/SaAcor ep.avTov avco Kal
b KaTU). arjv yap br]

X^P'^ eA.e'yxeiy tov Xoyov TTL9ricr6iJ.0a,
kavirep eAeyxw/xer.
0EAI. ils TOLVVv pLOLy /XTj8a/x7j b6^0iiv fjirjbev TrKrîi-
fxcKelv, hv im tov iXiyyov tovtov koX rqv aiT^bei^LV trjs,
5 6appu>v Wl tovtov ye VKa.

HE. <t>epe brj, TLva apyjiv tls hv 6.pâLT0 TTapaKLvbvvcv-
TiKov Aoyou; boKia fxev yap Trjvb^ Si iraL, Tr]V obbv drayfcaio-
TaTrjv rjpLLV eivai TpeiTecrdaL.
0EAI. Uoiav br];

jo HE. Ta boKovvTa vvv ivapy&s ^X^'-^ kTTL(rKiy\ra(T6aL
TTpSi-
C Tov fXT] TTT] TiTapayp.ivoL ]xkv w/xey Trept Tavra, /5ata;s 8'
dAA?jAoi5 6ixokoyS)]xiv u)S evKpLV&s xovtS.

0EAI. Ae'ye (Ta(f)icrTpov b Ae'yei9.
HE. EuKo'Aa)9 fxoL boKcX Tlap]XVLbris r]fxZv bLeLXex^^'- '^^'-
5 TTCLS OCTTLS TTCOTTOTC (TTL KpL(TLV Uip]Xr](T TOV TO. OVTtt bLOpicTaadaL
TT6(Ta Te KoiX TTOLO. (TTLV.
0EAI. Urj;
j
HE. Mv96v TLva e/caoTos (âLveTat fxoL SiT/yeio-âi TraLorlv
\ 0)? ouo-iv ^fXLV, 6 ]XV ois TpLa Ta ovTa, TToAe/iei b\ dAAÂot?
a2 vvv om. T a7 itov vwh^l vvviii irov B C i /xtvSiixevW

fxfvwfjLfv BT 8' om. T c 4 Soku /moi W C 5 Sans} HaTis
rjfx7v Eusebius
20I2TH2 242d
VLOT avrSiV arra Trr\, Tore h\ Koi (^tXa yiyvofJLCva yd^xovs d

T Kal t6kov9 Kal Tpo(f)as Toiv Ky6v(t)V TTap\(Tai.' bvo 8e
(Tepos etTTCoy, vypov Kal ^rjpbv ri Oeppibv Kal \lfvxp6v, avvoL-
KiCî T avTO. Kol K8i8coo-f To bc Tiap rjpLLV 'EAeari/coy (dvos,
cnrb s.evo(l)dvovs re Kal tl Trp^crdev ap^diievov, b)S kvbs ovtos 5
Toiv TrdLVToov KoXovixevoiv ovTOi heêpx^TaL rois p.v6oLs. 'Ict8e?
8e Kat ^LKekaC TLves v(TTpov MoCo-at a-vvev6r\(rav otl (rvp.-

TTkeKfLV a(r(pa\(rTaTov aiJ.(l)6T(pa Kal XeyeLv a>s ro ov iToXXd e
re Kal ev ((ttlv, exOpq. he Ka\ (pLXCa cmvexeTaL. bLa(f)p6p.evov
yap det crtijLKêperat, (f)a(rlv ai (rvvTOVoorepaL T(av MoDcraiy
ai 8e fxaXaK(aTepaL to [xkv dei rairra ovrcos exeiy ôAao-ai^,

ey ftepet be tot fxev ev elvaL (f)a(rL Tb ttclv Kal (piXov v-n 5
\\(f)pobLTr]s, TOTe be TroAAa *cat iioKep.Lov avTb avT(^ 8td retKo'? 243
rt. TavTa be irdvTa ei piev aXrjdois tls rj /u?) tovto)v elprjKe,
XaAeTToy Kai TTX.r] fXfxeX.es ovro) pi.eydXa KAetrots Kat TroAatoty
dvhpd(TLV eTTLTLfxdv eKelvo be dveTTL(f)9ovov dTTO(f)rfvaadaL

0EAI. To TTolov; 5
HE. "Ort AtW TO)V TToXX&v r]fx5)V viTepLbdvTes o)XLydiprfa-av
ovbev yap (^povTLcravTes eir' eTTaKoXov6ovp.ev avTols XeyovaLV

etre diToXeLiT^p.eda, TiepaLVOv^n. to (r(f)eTepov avr&v eKa<TTOL. b
0EAI. Uo)s XeyeLs;
HE. "Oray rts avTotv (f)6ey$rfTaL Xeyo)V cLy ecrrty 77
yeyovev rf yiyveraL TroAAd rf ^v rf bvo, Kal Oepfxbv av ylrvxp^^
(TvyKepavvvp.evov, oXXo^l TTrj StaKptcret? Kat (rvyKpL(TLS vtto- 5
tl6ls, tovto)v, o) 0eatT7jre, eKdaTOTe (tv tl iTpbs êwv

(TvvCrfs OTL Xeyov(TLv; eyco p.V yap 6t fiev rjv vecoTepos,
T0Vt6 T Tb VVV aTTOpOVfXeVOV OTTOTe TLS eLTTOL, TO fXlf ov,
d r &TTa iTT?] 070117; B Ko2 om. T

B Eusebius d 3 KaY] re
W
:
KolW \f/vxphv Kal 6fpp.6v W

d 4 T]iMv al. Eusebius rifj.wv B T :
d6 Tovs fj.v0ovs Theodoretus d 7 <nK\ai B Simplicius ffiK(\iKal :
T W Eusebius ^wfv6ri(Tay T Eusebius Simplicius ^vvvevo-fiKaa-iv B :
W
(IJ.tr\(Keiv e I aa-(t>a\f(TT(pov Eusebius 65 Iv T Eusebius W
Simplicius 01* B a i 5e] 5 koI T ovt^ avrh B a 2 iro^TO
ravra W
:
S( b 8 t secl. Cobet: ye Hermann tJ) TW:
om. B rb fjiii 6v secl. Cobet

243b nAATONOS
aKpil3ois ^jxrjv (rvvUvai. vvv h\ opas ir' (rp.v avrov Ttfpi
lo Trjs aTTopCas.
c 0EAI. 'Op&.
HE. T(ix Toivvv lo-ft)? ovx tjttov KaTo. t6 6v TavTov
TovTo Trddos d\r](f)6Ts Iv "^xfl '^^P'- /^^^ tovto evnoptiv
ttj
(f)afj.v Kal ixav9dvLV oiioTav Tis avTo (\>6y^Tai, ir^pl be

5 6aTp0V OV, TTpbs dpi(f)6Tpa OfXoCoiS \0VTS.
0EAI. "{(Tois.
HE. Kal TTpl tS>v dW(i)v brj tQ)v 7rpotpr]pLV(iiv fjixiv
TavTov TOVTo lprj(r6(D.
0EAI. Udw ye.
lo HE. Tmv p,V Toivvv TToWciv 7re/)t Ka\ fiera tovto (rK\}/6-
d fX6\ hv bo^ri, 7Tpl bi TOV pLyL(TTOV T KoX dpXrfyOV TTpcltTOV
VVV (TKiTTTioV.
0EAI. Tivos br] \iyLs; rj brjXov otl to 6v (^rjs TTpG)Tov
b^Xv bLpvvri(racr6aL tl tto6^ ol KiyovTcs avTO brjkovv
5 rjyovvTaL;
HE. Kara 7ro8a ye, S aLTr]T, vWA.aê?. Ae^yco yap
brj TavTr] b^lv TT0LL(T6aL Tr]v p.6obov r]]xds, oXov avTS)V
TTapOVTOilV dva7TVvdaV0fXV0VS c58e' " ^p, otto^tol d^pfxov
Kal \lfvxpbv rj tlv bvo tolovto) Ta TTavT etrai 0are, tl ttot
e dpa TovT eTr' dpi(f)OLV (p6yy(rd, XiyovT^s d]x^(t> Ka\ KdTpov
LVaL; TL TO LVaL TOVTO VTTOkd^(i)pLV Vp.S)V ; TT^T^pOV TpLTOV

TTapd Ta bvo KLva, Kat rpta Tb iTav dkkd fxr] bvo tl Kad
v/xas TL6(a[Xv; ov ydp ttov toIv ye bvoLV /caAourres ddTpov
5 ov dix(f)6Tpa o/xotcos eiyai \yT' (rx^bbv ydp dv d[x(f)0Tp(DS

V, a\K ov bvo LTr]v.
0EAI. 'Akr]6r] Aeyeis.

HE. "'AAA' dpd ye Ta &ix^(i) ôvkâ-Qi KaAetr ov;"
h lo T^y secl. Cobet C 4 StroTav'] iirSre B di irpirov vZv

TW: irpdiTov 5ij B: irpwTov vvv al. irpuTov Sii Schanz d^ 5*7 W
d6 irSSa T (ex emend.) W: iroWi
:
B pr. T d? 5ij om. W

eI <pd(yyf(T6at B e a toDto] Toirro B 65 Xe7T6] KtytTai B
e6 (XT-nv W : ei rV B T e 8 -yt W : om. BT
;
20cI)I2THS 2436
0EAI. "10-0)5.
HE. " 'AAA', 0) îAoi," <f)r}(TOfX(V, *' Kav ovto) tcl bvo 244
A.eyotr' av (ra(p(TTaTa V."
0EAI. 'OpôVara (tprjKas.
HE. " 'EireiSr/ toCvw T^jueis- 'qTToprJKaiJ.ev, ^/xeiy avra
^ju.ii' (p.(âvC^T. LKavGis, tC ttot (3ov\(rde o-rip.aCvLV oiroTav 5
ov (f)dyYr](r6. bijXov yap ws viJ.is fJikv TavTa TraAat

yiyv<a(rKT, ^juet? be irpo tov p-ev <L6fji.6a, vvv 8' qiroprf'
KapifV. bibda-Kere ovv irpSiTov tovt avTO rjfxas, Xva fxr]
hoâQx>fj.V fxav6avi.v fi\v to. keyofjieva irap vfxSiV, to 8e

TOTôv yCyvrfTai nav tovvovtCov" ravTa hrf XiyovTfS re b
Kal a^tovvTS TTapa re rovTOiV KoX rtapa rSiV aAAooy ocroi
TrAeioy kvos \eyova-L ro Ttav euât, fJLUv, oj "Tral, rl "nXrffx-
fi^Krfcrofxev
0EAr. "HKiOTa ye. 5
HE. Tt 8e; Trapa rSiV ev ro ttclv keyovTdiV ap ov

TTeva-TiOV (Is hvvap.LV rC Trore Ae'yoi;crt ro 6v;
0EAI. Um yap ov;

HE. To8e ToCvvv aTTOKpLvicrdoyv. ""Ev ttov (})aT fxovov
etyai;"
" 't>afXV yap^^ ^rf(Tova-iv> ?] yap; lo
0EAI. Nar.
HE. " Tt hk; ov Kokdrk tl;^^
0EAI. Nat'.
HE. " rioVepoy oTrep er, eTri rw avTw :rpoo*xp/w.eroi Suou' C
ovofxacTLV, rf tt&s;"
0EAI. Tts ovv avTots rf fxera tovt, m êVe, aiTOKpLcrLs;
HE. AifXov, S QeaCrrjTe, otl r<S ravrTjy rifv VTTodecrLV
vodep.ev(o TTpos rb vvv epoi)Tri6ev Kal TTpbs aAAo 8e 6rioi;i' 5
ov TTavTOiv pacTTOv aTT0KpCva(r6aL.

0EAI. licos;
a 1-2 Khu xiyoiro if B koI keyere tv T (sed 01 supra-

W
. . . : . . .
scripto) Kav
: . . . Keyir' tiv W a 7 umfda B a9 S6âjij.ev
hg airoKpivfcrdwffav BT W b ta KaAerre] KaAuTai B Simplicius
C I T9) auT^] tJ ai/Th W C 4 t$ T W : tJ B
PLATO, VOL. I. 26
J
244 C IlAATiiNOS
SE. To re bvo dvofxaTa 6[xoXoylv ^lvai /nrjScy Oiîevov
TrA^v ty KarayeAacrroV irou.
10 0EAI. nws 8' oi!/
SE. Kat ro irapATtav ye aiioh^yjea-OaC tov XiyovTos (Ls

d |(rr' ovofxa rt, Aoyov ovk &i; Ix^'
0EAI. nTj;
SE. Tiîs re Tovvo[xa tov TTpdyfxaTos HTcpov bvo Aeyct
TOu riye.
5 0EAI. Na^.
SE. Kai fxrjv hv Tavrov ye avr&i ri^^ Tovvoiia, q firjhevbs
ovofxa avayKa(rdr\(TiTaL XeycLv, el 8e rtroy avrb (^Tjo-ei,
o-vjMjSTjcrerat ro ovofxa ovojxaTos ovofxa fxovov, oAAou bi

ovbevos ov.
lO 0EAI. OVTCOS.
SE. Kai To iv ye, eiô? ovofxa ov koX tov dvofxaTos av
ro (V ov.
0EAI. 'Ayay/crj.
SE. Ti 8e'; t6 oXov (Tepov tov ovtos (vos t/ tovtov
15 ^Ô-OUCl TOVTio;
e 0EAI. Tlois yap ov cjiTâ-ova-C re koi (f)aa-lv;
SE. Et Toivvv okov kcrTiv, o3o-7rep Kai riap/xevtSTjs Ae'yei,
ndrroêv iVKVKKov <T(f>aLpr}s ivdkiyKiov oyK<a,

fXiaa-oOiv Zo-oTraAe? TrdvTrf' t6 yap ovt ri /xetôy
5 ovre rt âioTepov TreAevat xpeov ôrt Tr\ rj Trj,
ToiovTov ye ov t6 6v fxeo-ov re Kai iayaTa exet> raDra 8e

llyov Traa-a dvdyKrj fxiprf 4)(êiv' rf Trws;
0EAI. OvT(as.
c8 Tf] 8^ pr. T c ri rov Hermann : rov BT di ovk ttv
Hxov T W Simplicius Kavtxov B oiik &>/ txoi al.

?;ôu : d 3 Xtyfi
W
:
Sw d II ovofxa 1)v Apelt iv tv /jlSvov B 'bv fi6vov T oco/ia

: : :
ii' ^({yo;/ Zeller roO] toDto T oS tJ Schleiermacher out^ :
BTW d 15 <pi]ffovcn Tovrtf Simplicius TW

Qiâovffi rovro B :
e 3 ffipalpns Simphcius ff<palpas B T sed Tjt suprascr. T

: 65 irfAei/ot]
ireAov W ; v(\ffj.ev vel rf\46(iv Cobet XP*'^" W e 6 ^x*'
#X<' al. e 7 ^x'"' T ^ Simplicius : ?x'"' ^ iraffav T
20cI>I2TH2 a45a
SE. 'AAXa [JLriv t6 ye fxeix^pKTijAvov TraOos juey tov kvos 245

<eXii.v kiii Tols fjip(n itacnv ovb\v anoKdikvî, Kal Tavrri 8^
TTav T ov Kal okov h> {tvai,
0EAI. Ti 8' 01!;

SE. To 8 'KtTiovQos TavTa ap ovk ahvvaTov avro ye to 5
ly avTo ilvai;
0EAI. Uti>s;
SE. 'A/Afpes hriTiov hii TrayreXws t6 ye akqOGis iv xara
Tov opOov X6yov (Iprjcrdai,
0EAI. Afi yap ovv. 10
SE. To 8^ ye roiom-oy e/c iroXAcSy fiepQv ov ov crvp.- b

<f)(t)vri(TL tS) [oA(ri] Xoyo).
0EAI. Markyco.
SE. rioTepoy 8?) TrdOos exoi' ro 01; roC kvbs ovtcos ev re
(CTTaL Kal okov, Tj TTavTaTTacrL ixr] Xeycoixev okov ilvaL to ov; 5
0EAI. XaXeTrTjv 7Tpo^(l3kr]Kas atpecTLV.
SE. 'AX?7ê'oTara ixevTOL Xe'yei9. TTeiTovOos re yap ro
oy ^y etyai 770)? ov Tavrov ov rw ei'! (pav^lTaL, Kal TTkdova
bi] Ta TTavTa kvos earai.
0EAI. Nai. 10
SE. Kat iJLi]v eav ye ro oy 17 ju^ oXoy 8ia ro TT^TTovOevaL c
'"*' ^^ KLV0v TTados, r] 8e avro ro okov, ei^Sees to ov kavTov
(rvnl3aLVL.
0EAI. Uavv ye.
SE. Kai KaTCL tovtov br] tov k6yov kavTOV crTp6p.V0V 5
ovK ov eorai to ov.
0EA1. Ovtoos.
SE. Kal ei'o's ye av TrXeio) ra Trai^ra yiyyerai, roC re
oyros Kai rou okov x(x>pls IbCav CKaTepov (f)V(rLV etXrj<ô'roy.
0EAI. Nat. 10
SE. M^ ovTos 8e ye ro TTapaiTav tov okov, TavTd re
a 2 oTratrivW b2 oA,yB om. Simplicii E F

: : post \6yip
add. T Simplicii D h5 6v Schleiermacher o\ov : BT Simplicius
b8 ipcweTTat Simplicius : <(>aivfTcu B T irAfWa] it\fov h, B
26*
245 d nAATilNOS
d ravra VTTap^^^L t<3 ovti, koI irpos rai /xt/ ilvai jxrjb^ av yevecrdai
TTore 6v.
0EAI. TCbri;
HE. To yv6p.vov ael yeyovev oKov uxrre oi/re ovcriav
5 ovre yivicnv ws ovo-oy Set TTpocrayopeveiv [t6 ^v fj] Tb oKov
iv Tols ov(Ti 1X7] Tidivra.
0EAI. YlavTairaa-LV (olkc TavO^ ovTUis (X^'-^'
HE. Kal fjLriv ovb^ oTTOcrovovv rt 8et to ixij oXov eivai'
irocTov Ti yap 6v, oitocrov hv ?|, ToaovTov okov avayKoiov

lo avTo elvai.
0EAI. Ko/xi8^ ye.

HE. Kat Toivvv aXKa fxvpia aTrep&vTovs airopias (Kaa-Tov
e etAr/</)o? (paveiTai rw ro or etre 8vo rtre etre kv p.6vov etrai
A.'yoi;ri.
0EAI. At/Aoi o-xeSoy Kat ra vvv v7TO(f>aivovTa' avv-

aTiTeTai yap tTepov ef aAAou, fxeiCon Kal yaXf.-KuiTipav (f)ipov
5 Trepi TCiV (jXTTpoa-Oev dei prjdevTUiv 7T\dvr]v.
HE. Tovs fxev Toivvv biaKpiôkoyovixivovi 6vto9 t TTepi

Kal ixrj, TTavTas [xev ov bKkrjXvOaixfv, oixcas oe iKovois e)(e'ra)'
Tovs be aAAcoy Xiyojrras av OeaTeov, tv iK irdvTOiv lOco/xei;
246 ort t6 6v tov /x7/ oi;roj ovbev evTtopwTepov elrTelv ori 77or
ea-TLV.
0EAI. OvKovv TTopevea-OaL xpi] Kal ^Ttl tovtovs.

HE. Kat ix7]v eoLKe ye ev avTols oXov yLyavToixayia rt?
5 etzât 8ta tt/v dp(f)Laj3i]Tria-LV Trepl ti]s ova-ias TTpos dAA?/Aoi;s.

0EAI. Uuis;
HE. Ot ixev els yfjv i$ ovpavov kcll tov dopdTOv Trdrra
IAkouo-i, rats yepoLV dTexvSis ireTpas Kal bpvs "TreptAa/i-
^dvovres. Ta>v yap tolovtv kâiTTopLevoi. TrdvT<av biia-)(ypC-
dI vphs T^] vphs ri B d 5 yivtffiv ws] ytvofifvrfv oCrt Sim- W

plicius rh iv ^ secl. Bekker d 10 avrh Simplicius om. B T W
W
:
d la &\\as fivpias al. e i rb T om. B W 63 viro<paivovra vvv

:
e6 Tt om. W 67 iravras Eusebius iravv : e8 a? Xf- BT

ryovras W l^wfitv Eusebius tl^wfitv B
: dSwnfv T : a 8 irfxvois
^wy) Hermann
W
204>I2TH2 246a
ôvTai, TovTO (IvaL [xovov o 7âp\ei TTpocrjSoXi^v Kal Tra(f)i]v lo
TLva, TavTov a-Qixa Kal ova-Cav opLôfxevoL, T<av be aXXoiv el b
TLS <(rt^ (f)r](rL /jit) croopLa exov etvaL, KaTa(j)povovvTS to
napa-nav Kal ovbev idiXovTes a\\o aKovLV.
0EAI. 'H betvoiis etprjKas &vbpas' ijbr] yap Kal eyo)
TovTuiv crvxvols TTpoa-iTvyov. 5
HE. ToLyapovv o\ TTpos avTovs api(f>L(r(3r]TovvTS fxaka

evXa^&s avuidev i^ aopaTov TTodev aixvvovTaL, vor]Ta aTTa
Kal aa-wpLaTa (tbr] ^La0]xevoL Tr]V ak.r]6Lvr]v ovcriav iXvaL'
To. be iKLV(DV (r(o]xaTa Kal Tr]v Kyo]xivr]v vtt' avToiv okr^deLav
KaTCL (TixLKpa bLaOpavovTes ev toIs \6yoLS yV(ruf ovt ovcTLas C
(f>epofXvr]v tlvcl TTpocrayopevovcTLV. iv ixi(r(o be iTfpl TavTa
aTTkiTos aix(f)OTep(av fX(x)(r] tls, S) QeaLTJjTe, det (rvv4(rTr]K(v.
0EAI. 'AAtj^^.
HE. Tlap' ap.ôw tolvvv toXv yevoXv xara fxipos ka^caixev 5
Koyov V7Tp r]s TiOevTaL ttjs ovaCas.

0EAI. H(as ovv br] kr]\f/6fx6a;
HE. Hapa p-ev twv iv eXbe^TLV aiirqv TLdffxevcov paov,
r]fLp(j)TepoL yap' TTapa be t(ov els (rS)p.a TTOLVTa ekK^vTcov

îq yaXeTT^Tepov, L(rcos be Kal (rêbov abvvaTov. oAA' o)bi d
fxoL belv boKeX TTepl avT&v bpav.
0EAI. U(os;
HE. MaAicrra fxev, et ttt] bvvaTov i]V, epy(d /3eAriovs
avTOVs TTOLeXv el be tovto fxr) iyyoipeZ, Ao'ya) TTOLoifxev, 5
VTTOTLdefxevoL vofXLfX(oTepov avTovs rj vvv idekovTas av aTTOKpi-
va(rdai. to yap ofxoXoyqdev TTapa /SeArtovcov ttov KvpLdrepov
77 t6 irapa )(eLp6v(DV r]p.eLS be ov tovto)v (ppovTiôfxev, dAAa
Tokrfdes ^TjroCfxey.
0EAI. 'OpôVaTa. e
HE. KeXeve brj tovs êArtou? yeyovoTas aTTOKpivacrdaC
o"oi, Kal To ke\dev iTap avrwv a(f)epfxr]veve.
b2 Ti add. al. : om. BT (^^(retB Eusebius: <pi\(ri T b^ 70^]

Ze pr. W b5 irpoa-fTvxov B pr. T Eusebius inpifTvxov W corr. T al.
W
:
c8 T0/*e'i'>' cwT^f d.2 SoKfi Setj' 63 {(pfpfj.-fjViveW

;
346 e nAATI2N02
0EAt. Tavr' ecrTau
5 EE. AeyovTOiv brj Ovtjtov Côv el (f)a(ri,v itvat ri.
0EAI. Um 8' ov;
HE. TovTo 8e ov (rai/xa (y^\fvyov ofwXoyowrtv
0EAI. ndvv ye.
HE. TidiVTfs T(. T<av ovTcov y{w)(i]v;
247 0EAI. Nai.
HE. Tt 8c; ^jrvxn^ ov ttji/ /uei/ diKatW, T?/y 8^ ^SiKor
(fâcriv (tvai,, Kal ttjv ij.\v (f)p6viixov, ttjv Sc a(f)pova;
0EAI. TifiT/i;;
5 HE. 'A\A' ou 8tKai00T;i;7j? eêt Ka2 iTapova-iq ToiavTr]v
avT&v kK6.<TTr}v yiyvfcrdai, koi Twy (vavTicav ttjv ivavrCav;
0EAI. Nat, Kai TavTa (rvfjL(f)a<rtv.
HE. 'AAAa jxrfv t6 ye bvvaTov t(o irapayCyve^rdai Kai

'
aTroyiyv(r6ai. TravTCtiS eTvai tl <f)r](rov(TLv,
lo 0EAI. âa-l [xev ovv.

b HE. Ovcrris ovv bi.KaL0(rvvr]s Kal (f^povri^recos Kal t^s
aAAr/s apfTrjs Kal tS)v ivavTi(i)v, Kal br] Kal i/o^x^s iv fj
TavTa iyyiyviTat, iT^Tfpov opaTov Ka\ aitTov elvai <f)a(ri tl
avTS)V T) TtavTa a6paTa;

5 0EAI. 'S.îbov ovbiv TovToov y( 6paT6v.
HE. T^ b T&v ToiovT(i)v; fJL&v a-&ixa ti Xe^yovo-tr toêti;;
0EAI. Toirro ovKTt KaTO, TavTo. aTTOKpivovTai Trav, aWa
Tr}v /xey ^vxi]v avTr]v boKelv a-(f)i(rL (r<ji[x6. tl KfKTrjadaL,
(f>p6vr]<rLV b^ Kal T&v &X.X(>)V (Ka^rrov (av r]p(i)Tr]Kas, ala^v-

C vovTaL To ToXfxav r] fxr^bev tG)v ovt(dv avra ofxoXoydv rj
TtavT (LvaL a-cojxaTa 8tio^vptêo-0at.
HE. â<f)<as yap f]fxXv, a 0eatTT/Te, êXTiovs yy6vaa-LV

avbpes' cTTet tovtcov ov8' hv (v cTraio-xwêtei' ot ye avT<av
5 ariraprroi t kol avT^ydoviS, akXa btaTiivoLVT av Ttav o /xt/
a3 T a5 irapouct^] <ppov4i<r((i>s Campbell a 8 t^]

T^ B
<l>povln.r\v
T tJ W a9 T om. W b3 ti tpavXv W b
7 to avrh W :
TaCTO B T
:
b9 (Kaffrov'^ (Ka<TTa W C3 2 dtalrr)rt rjfxlv W

c 4 ivSpfs Bekker : &vSp(s BT oW hv tv] ovSkv itv W ivfrai-
204>I2TH2 347C
bvvaTol rais X^P^''- n^fiTrieX'^*^

eto-ir, d>s apa rovro ovbev ro
irapaTiav kcrriv.
0EAI. SxfSoy ola biavoovvrai ksycLS.
HE. IlaAti' roivvv avepojrcopev avrovs' i yap ri koX
(Tp.iKpov dfXov(n rav ovroiv avyyjap^lv a(r(op.arov, iâpKeX, d
rb yap i-ni re rovrois ap.a KaX tt' kKîvois 6(ra \l crutpa
(rvp(f)VS yeyovos, ds o /3Ae7royre? ap(f)6rpa (Ivai X^yovcn,

rovro avrols p-qrdov. rd\ ovv to-ojs av aTTopol^v ei 8^
rt roiovrov TTCTTovOaa-i, o-KoVei, nporei.vopevoyv rjpwv, ap 5
idiXoiev av hi\(T6ai koI djxoXoyeLV roLovb^ etvaL ro ov.

0EAI. To Troioy 6^; Xiye, kol rdyji clcrdixeOa.
HE. Aeyco br} rb Kal oiTOLavovv [rira] KeKrrjpievov bvvap.LV
etr' ts ro TTOLtiv irepov orLOvv TTe(f)VKbs etr' els rb TTaOeTv e
Kat (TpLKporarov vnb rov (f)avXordrov, Kav et povov 6ts aTra^,
TTav rovro ovrois etraf riOepiaL yap opov [opi^^Lv] ra ovra v

ff
b)S (rrLV ovK aXXo rt ttXi]V bvvap.LS.
0EAI. 'AAX' iTTeiiTep avroi ye ovk <^yov(TLV kv ro) iTapovrL 5
rovrov (SeXrLov Xiy^LV, bixovraL rovro.

HE. KaA(Ss* to-tos yap av ds vorepov T]p.LV re cat rovroLS
frcpov hv (Paveir]. TTpbs pikv ovv rovrovs rovro rjp.lv kvravOa 248
p.evero> (TvvopoXoyr]6iv.
0EAI. MeWt.
HE. ripos br\ rofvs kripovs icd/xey, rovs riav eiScSi; (f)iXovs'
(Tv b r]]uv kcCl ra Trapa rovTO)v d(f)ppi]vev. 5

0EAI. Tairr' ea-raL.
HE. reyeo-ii', ti]v 8e ovaiav yo^pis ttov bLeXopevoL Aeyere;

V yap;
0EAI. Nat.
HE. Kai (r(ap.ari, /xey rjpds yevecrd 8t' aia-6r](Tcos kol- 10
vo^VfLV, bLCL XoyL(rp.ov be ^vxrj TTpbs ri]V ovrcos ovcriav,
6.4 5^] 5e Heindorf d.5 ti/j.ccv om. B d8 riva om. B

e I flr (is W : d rts B T 63 6pi^ftv secl. Ast dpi(^fiv ra ovra.
:
secl. Badham e 7 &/] Z)j Schanz a 3 ixfvfl Schanz a 4 5^]

5e W a u 5e KoyiafjLOv W
;
248a nAAT12N0S
qv dei Kara TavTo. bxravTtas ^xav (paT^, yiviaiv hi aXXoTi
fiAAcos.
b 0EAI. âfikv yap ovv.

HE. To 8e hi] Koivuivelv, w TrivTaiV &piOTOL, tL tov&' vfxai
^TT api<f>OLV Aeyetv (^w/xey; ap' ov ro vvvbtj Tiap f]p,Qv pr]Qtv;
0EAI. To 770101';
5 HE. Y\adrj]j.a itovqp.a rj Ik Swd/xews tlvos a-no tS>v irpos
&Wr]\a (rvvLovTcov yLyv6jj.evov. rax^' ovv, u QeaiTTjTe, avrStv
Tr]v irpos TavTa h-noKpLa-LV crv pikv ov KaTaKOveLs, iyco bk ta-oos
bLCL (TvvqOeLav.
0EAI. TtV ovv br] \4yova-L koyov;
C HE. Ov (rvyx(*>pov(TLV rjp.LV rb vvvbr] pr]6\v Tipos tovs
yr]yV(LS ov^rias mpL.
0EAI. To TTOtoy;
SE. 'iKavbv (depev opov ttov tS>v 6vT(t>v, oTav ro) TTaprj
5 Tj Tov TTao-xetj; rj bpav Kal irpos to apLLKpoTaTov bvvapLs;

0EAI. Nat.
HE. 17/30? br] TavTa robe kiyovaLV, otl yevicreL p.tv
/bteVeoTt Tov irAaxuv /cat Troteu' bvvapôis, Trpbs Se oixriav

TOVToov ovbcTipov Tr]v bvvapLV appomLV (j>aa-iv.
lo 0EAI. OvKovv \4yova-i tl;
HE. Hpbs o ye AeKre'oy fjplv otl 8eo'/xeâ Trap' avTutv
d ^ri TTvdf.aÔaL (ra(f>ia-Tepov et TTpoa-opokoyovaL Trjv pev ^j/vxh^
yLyvda-KfLV, Trjv 8' Qvaiav yLyv(S>aKi(r6aL.
0EAI. <l>ao-i pr]v tovto ye.
HE. Tt bi; Tb yLyvdaKfLV rj to yLyv(aaK(cr6aL (f)aT
5 TToirjpa rj TTd6os rj ap(f>6T(pov; rj rb pkv TT<x6r]pa, to bi

66,Tpov; 7] TTavT6.TTaa-iv ovbirepov ou8ere'/)ou tovto^v p.Ta-
Kapâvuv
0EAI. AfjXov 0)5 ovbiTfpov ovbfTfpov TavavTia yap hv
TOLS ipiTpoa6V Xiyouv,
b3 (pSijxfv \iy(iv T C 7 tJ5] t($5 yt W 8t] St* W

d5 j^ tJ ijifv . . . d6 Odrfpov om. T d8 St)\o . . . Kiyoity
primus Theaeteto tribuit Heindorf
.
20*I2;TH2 248d
HE. Mavddvoi' Tobe ye, o)s t6 yLyv(acrKLV etiTep ((TTaL lo
votelv Tt, t6 yLyvcoo-KOjxevov avayKalov av (rviJ.(3aLVL Traoêir. e

TTJV OVCTLaV bl] KaTCL TOV XoyOV TOVTOV yLyVU>(TK0IXV1]V V7r6 T7/y
yvcacrecos, Kad' ocrov yLyvuxTKeTaL, KaTci toctovtov KLvelcrdaL 8ta
t6 Trao-xeii', o brj (f)afXV ovk hv yev4(rdaL irepl t6 rjpefiovv.

0EAI. "OpeuJs. 5
HE. Ti 8e TTp6s Alos; &)? aXi]dQ)s KLvqaLV Kal C(î]v Kal
yjfv^^rjv Kal (t)p6vr]a-LV 17 /5a8ta)s TrLa-dr]cr6pLeda rai iravTeX.&s
ovTL p.1] TrapelvaL, pir]be 0]V avro pLr^be (ppovelv, aXXa aep-vov 249
KOL dyLov, vovv ovK ex'^^' dKLvr]Tov ecTT^s etmi;
0EAI. ALv6v fxevTav, a> êve, X6yov (Tvyyu)poXp.ev.
HE. 'AAAa vovv p.ev ex^'^' C^V^ ^^ H-V <p^p-^v;
0EAI. Kal TTco?; 5
HE. 'AAAa TavTa piev dp.(j)6Tpa kv6vT avTta Xeyopiev, ov
prjv iv "^vxfi y (f)7](ropv avT6 eêLV avTd;
0EAI. Kat TtV dv Tpov exot Tpdirov;
HE. 'AAAa 8^Ta vovv fj^v Kal Cî]v Kal yj/vxqv (ex^Li'),
aKLvrjTov p.VT0L t6 'napditav p.\j/vxov ov eaTdvaL; 'o
0EAI. IlayTa epoLye dXoya Tavr eTvaL (f)aLVTaL. b

HE. Kat t6 KLVovpLVOV 87) Kat KLvrja-LV (rvyx(^pf}Tov cus
ovTa.
0EAI. Dws 8' ov;
HE. ^vp.âLVL 8' ovv, S) QeaLTrjTe, dKLvqTcov T ovtcdv 5
vovv pir]bvl TTepl p.r]bv6s eTvaL p.r]bap.ov.
0EAI. Kop.Lbrj p.V ovv,

HE. Kai pir]v edv av (\)p6p.va kcu KLvovp.va TidvT eXvau
rvyx<p^p-^v, Kal tovt(o tu Aoyo) Tavroi' tovto k t&v 6vto)v
iâLpr]crop.V 10
0EAI. U5)s;
d 10 rh Se ye T Se BtJ> e 3 Sti] Kara. W

64 Tipejxovv']
W
:
jlpefieTv B a6
ivov T'auT<(5 4v6vTa aiirifi Simplicius
: fvhv :
TauT^) B : ev t>v Tairry T

x4ywp.ev T
a 7 76 IB Simplicius : re T
&g Ix*'" add. Schleiermacher bi fixoiye &Koya'\ ye\o7a
efxol
Simplicius b 5 5' ovv^ yovv W Simphcius ovraiv] ovrwv rwv
6vruv Heindorf : ovrwv Ttdvrttiv Badham
249 b nAATIlNOS
HE. T6 Kara Tavrb. Kal ixravTais Ka\ Trepl r^ avTb boKcl
C o"ot x^pi-^ (TTda-eoos yfvfcrdai ttot &v;
0EAI. OvbafjL&s.
HE. Ti 8'; &vv TovToiv vovv Kadop&s orra T] ycvofxfvov
hv Kal oTTovovv;
6 0EAI. "H/ciora.
HE. Kai /lA^y Ttpos ye roOror Trawl Aoyo) p.a\Tiov, 6s
&!> kTna-Trjpriv ri <})p6vr]<nv rj vovv a(})aviC(ov la-xvpCCrjTai, ixipi
TIVOS OTTrjOVV.
0Ea'i. 2(ô8pa yf.
10 HE. To) 8^ (f)LXoa6(f)(o Ka\ Tarha /jtoAicrTa TipOiVTi Tracra,
o)? (OLKev, avdyKrj bia Tavra ju7;re twi' ^r t; Kal to, ToAAa
d ibr] Xey6vT(ji)v to Trav Iottjkos aTTobixea-Oai, tG)v re av
navTaxfi to 6v klvovvtoov prjb^ t6 irapairav aKovfLV, dAAa
KaTCL Tjjv tS)v TtaLboiv VXW> ^^^ aKLvrjTa Kal K(KLvrjp.iva, to
ov T Kal t6 irav a-vvap(f)6Tpa XeyeLV.
5 0EAI. 'AAr/êo-TaTa.
HE. Ti ovv; ap ovk TrieiKdis 7/8rj <paLv6p.6a ircpietATj-
(pivaL T<3 Aoyw t6 6v;

0EAI. Il6vv IMV ovv.
HE. Ba/3at t/xeW Ar 5pa,t S 06aiTrjTe, c5s /xoi 8oKoC/xer
lo vvv avTov yvdcreadaL TT^pL Trjv d.TTopCav Trjs aKf-êcas.
e 0EAI. Ylais av Kal t[ tovt eipr/Kas;

HE. 'X2 p.aKapL, ovk (vvods otl vvv ka-p.fv kv ayvo[q
Trj 'n-AetoTT/ Trepl avTov, (f)aLv6p.9a 8e' tl XeyeLV rfpXv
avTOLs;
5 0EAI. 'E/xoi yovv ottt} 8' av AeA^â/xei/ ovtcos ex''^^^^>
ov TTavv (TVv[r]p.L.
HE. SKoVet 8^ (Ta(f>eaTpov el to, vvv (TVVOiJLoXoyovirres
C I itot'] t<{t' B C4 twTW: alB c ii ru,y TW rh B :
d I rwv T W
rhv B: d 3 Sffa KtKivrjfifva secl. Schanz
. .
d 9 fwVT &j' Spa

.
d 4 X7e'] XtV* B d 6 o5j'] 8i? oiv "W

B T ;u^ \lav ddppti Apelt fort. fntvfTtov &pa
: : e^ ra vvv] ravra
yvy T ToSra: W
tu B :
20I2TH2 25oa
bLKaCcos hv eTTefKarqOeXfJiev aTrep avTol Tore qpoiTtiifxev Tovs 250

kiyovTas (Tvai to Trav Ofpfxov Kal \j/vxpov.
0EAI. Hola; VTTop.vria-ov jue.
HE. Ylavv fxkv ovv Kal Ti^Lpacrop.ai ye hpav tovto
ipoiTiiv cre KaOaTtip e/ceirous t6t, Xva 6.p.a ti Kal 5
Trpoico/iei^.
0EAI. 'Op^ws.
EE. Eiev 8^, Ktmia-iv Kal orao-iy Sp' ovk kvavTmTaTa
Ae'yets dAA7/Aois;
0EAI. Ila)? yap oi!; 10
HE. Kat eiyat ye

/liTJi' 6/xotco? (^t)? a.p.(f)6Tpa avTa Kal
eKaTipov;
0EAI. (t>r)ixl yap ovv. b
HE. 'Apa KiveladaL kiycav ap.^6Tepa koX kKaTepov, oTav
eirai (rvyxMpfjs;
0EAI. Ovbafxm.
HE. ÂXX' ((TTavaL a-rj[xaCvLS keycov avTaa[X(p6Tpa(LvaL; 5
0EAI. Kat 770)5;
HE. TpLTov apa tl irapa ravra to ov kv Trj "^vxf] TLOeCs,
ojs vtt' kKeivov ti]v re arda-LV Kal ri]v KCvrja-LV jrepiexofxeVrji',
o-uAAa/Sojy Kat d7rt8a>y avToiv Trpbs Trjv Tijs ova^Cas KOLVojvCav,
ovTcas LvaL TTpoaeLTTas ap.({)6Tpa; 10
0EAI. KLvbvvvop.v o)s a\ridu)s TpLTov cLTTopiavTeveadaC c
rt t6 ov, oTav KCvrja^LV Kal cttcktlv etvaL \4y(op.V.
HE. OvK apa KCvrjaLS Kal (rraaLS eo"rt (rvvafx(f)6Tpov t6
ov dAA' eTcpov 8tj rt tovtodv.
0EAI. 'EotKer. 5
HE. Kard TTjv avTov (f^vaLV apa t6 $v ovt earrjKCV ovre
Ktyetrat.
0EAI. 2xe8oV.
a I îrepwTtidfTfifv] ipanrÔfl-qfJiep T W a 1 1 avra] ravra W

b2 Ae-ya/] \4yo/ji(v W b8 r-fiv re Kivi\aiv Kol t))v arTacrtv W
b9 auTw'] avrhv B C i Kii/Si/iêuwêv T C 4 Tovraiv^
rovro W
250C nAATX2N02
HE. Vlol 87) x/") Tr}v bi,dvoLav tri Tpe-JTeiv rbv ôvXofxfvov
10 Ivapyi^ TL irepl avTov Trap' kavria ISeâtaxraa-dai;
0EAI. Uoiydp;
HE. OTpiai. p.v ovbajxoa-e ^tl pabiov. d yAp ri fxr}
d KivelTai, TT&s ovx (arqKev; fj to p.r]hayxas karos ttws ovk

av KivetTai.; to bi 6v r]p.iv vvv Iktos tovtcov hp.(^0Tipu}V
avaTT(f)avTai.. ?j bvvaTov ovv tovto;
0EAI. YldvTcov \xkv ovv dbvvaTcaTaTov.
5 HE. To'8e Toivvv ixvTja-dijvat bLKaLov iirl tovtols.
0EAI. To TTOLOv;
HE. "Otl tov fxr} ovTos kp<t)Trj6ivT(s Tovvop.a ^0' otl
TTOT^ bel <\>ip(LV, TTdoT} a~vv((r)(6fx6a aTTopia. ixip.vr]a-aL;
0EAI. ria)? yap ov;

e HE. Mwy ovv kv kkdTTOvC tlvl vvv i(rfxv diTopL^^ TTepl
t6 ov;
0EAI. 'Efiol fxiv, S) ^4v, el bvvaThv Itt(lv, iv tt\lovl
(f)aLv6p.(da.
5 HE. Touro fXV TOLVvv ivTav6a KiCado) bLrfTTOprffxivov
iiTeLbr] 8e i^ laov t6 re 6v koX to fxr] Sv aTTopCas êreiATj-

(paTov, vvv iXiTLi ifbr] Ka^diTep hv avTciv 6dT(pov eire
dfxvbpdTcpov eire (ra^piarepov dva<âCvr]TaL, koX 6dTepov ovrcoj

251 dva(})aCva-6aL' Kal idv av fxrfbiTepov IbcLV bvv(aixcda, tgv
yovv \6yov oTrr/Trep ^v oloC re S)fXv evTrpeirôTara bL(i)(r6fxe6a
ovT(i)s dfx(f)6Lv dfxa.
0EAI. KaKm.
5 HE. Ae'ya)jLiey 8^ /ca^' ovTLvd irore Tpd-nov ttoXXols 6v6fxan-L
TavTov TovTo (KdoTOTe TTpoa-ayopevofxev.
0EAI. Olov br] tC; iTapdbcLyfLa fliri.
H E. Aiyofxfv dvdpcoTTOV bifiTov xroAX' UTTa iirovofxdCovTes,

Ta re yj)(apLaTa iTTL(f)ipovTs avT(o Kal Ta o^Tjjuara Kal fxyi6r]
C9 5); om. T d8 mtvtx^t'-*^'''' W ovvfix^fitOa Heindorf

e 7 KaOitrtp &!/ T : W
Kadtrfpav B a i ivaipcwtTiTdai Heindorf :
hv kva<paivfa6ai Hirschig aa Stua6fJLtOa] Stoia6/jLf6a Wagner

a9 T<k ante fttyÔr) add. W suprascr. T
;
20I2TH2 25ia
Koi KUKLas Koi dptras, iv ots iracTL Kal erepois fivpCoLS ov fxovov lo
&v0p(t)'nov avTov eTvaC (f)afXV, aWa Kal ayaOov koX irepa b

aTretpa, Kal raAAa br} KaTo. tov avTov Xoyov ovtcos %v iKacTTOv
VTToOeixevoL TTaX.LV avTo TToAAa koX iroAAots dvofxacrL \iyopîv.
0EAI. 'AArj^T/ Aeyeis.

HE. "Odev ye oXp.aL toIs re vioLS koa. tcov yepovTcov roi? 5
6ylfLp.a6i(TL doCvrjv Trap(rKvdKap.v' v6vs yap avTLkaî(T6aL

TTavTL TTpox^Lpov o)? abvvaTov Ta re TroAAa ^v koX to v
TToAAa etvaL, Kal brjTrov yaCpovcTLV ovk eu)VTs ayadov KeyeLv
avdpojov, aXXa t6 [xkv dya6ov dya66v, tov b\ dv6pcoov C
dv6p(t)-ov. ivTvyxdveis ydp, S eaiTTjre, coy eyw/xat,
<roAAdKts Ta TOLama kcmovbaKoa-LV, kvCoT^ lipea-^VTipoLS
dvdp(i)TTOLs, Kal vTio TtevCas TTJs Trept (f)p6vr](rLv Krqcreoos Ta
TOLauTa Ti6avfW.K6a-L, koX brf tl koX 7Td(rcro(f)ov olop.ivoLS 5
TovTO avTO dvr\vpr]KvaL.
0EAI. Yldvv p.v ovv.
HE. "Iva ToCvvv TTpos diTavTas rjfuv 6 \6yos rj tovs
TT(i)OT TTcpt oxxrCas KoX OTLOvv bLoXexîvTas, CrT(0 Kal TTpbs d
TOVTOvs Kal TTpos Tovs dWovs, ocrot? p.7TpO(r6V bLLkyp.6a,
TO, vvv uis V p(OTq(rL kx6r]cr6fxva.
0EAI. Ta TTota Stj;
H E. HoTcpov p.r\T rqv ovcrCav KLvricreL Kal crTd(TL irpocT- 5
aTTT(op.v ixr]T oAAo dXX(a fxtjb^v fxr]bVL, dAA' o)? dfXLKTa ovTa
KaL dbvvaTov fLTaXap.^dvLv dXkr]k(i)v ovtcos avTa kv toZs Trap'
rffxlv koyoLS TL6G)fXv; r] iTdvTa ets TavTov (Tvvaydy(OfXv ws

bvvaTa TTLKOLV(i)VLV okkrfkOLS ; ^ TCL fXV, Ta b^ firj; TOVTOOV,
o) Q)aCTr]T, tC ttot dv avTovs TTpoaLpL(T6aL (f)T^(rop.v 6
b 3 iroAAa om. Simplicius b 57 TW Simplicius: re B b 6 irapf-

(TKivicrafjLfv W a.vTi\a^((rBaC\ d AojSfcrOai Simplicius C i t^]
rhv Simplicius rhv Se] roSe (s\c) B rh Sk W C3 ra
W
:
roiavra itoAAokis iviore om. Simplicius c4 Kr^fiffews secl.

Badham c6 oiiTi om. W
Simplicius c8 A070J] 6fj.6-
6
\oyos in marg.
BT
T d 7 aSvvara T d 8 ^vvaydywfifv : W
^vvaycofitv e i ainovs vpoaipe7(Tdai\ Trpoaipela^dai rovrovs T
(pTjffOfjLev W : <fyiiffaifj.ev BT
351 e T1AATX2N0S
0EAI. 'Eyo) jjikv vTrkp avrwy ovh\v tyj^ Trpos Tavra
aTiOK.pivacrOai,
HE. Ti ovv ov KaO^ kv &TTOKptv6ixVos icf)' kKdarov tol
5 a-vpLâLvovTa eo-Kex/ô);
0EAI. KaAws \4yas.

HE. Kai Tid(ap,v ye avTovs Aeyeiy, cl ôvXei., npSiTov
Hrjbcvl fxrjbev p.rih(yiLav hvvap.LV (X(t,v KOLvuivLas eis pr]bev.
ovKOvv KLvr]a-is t Kal (rrdoris ovbapirj p.(6^T0V ova-ias;
252 0EAI. Ov yap ovv.
HE. Tt 8^; eCTTat TtoTepov avr&v ovaCas p.r] TTpoaKoi-
voivovv;
0EAI. OvK ea-Tai.
5 HE. Taxv br] TavTrj ye ttj avvop.o\oyia TrivTa av6.aTaTa
yiyovev, ws ôlkV, 3.pa re tu>v to Trav klvovvtoov Ka\ Ttav
0)5 tv ia-T6.VT(av Kal ocrot Kar ctbrj to. ovTa KaTO. TavTo,
wo-avrcos iyovTa itvai âaiv dei' irdvTes yap ovtol to ye
eivai Trpoar^TTTOva-LV, ol ixev dvToos KLVCLO-Oai kiyovTS, ol 8e
10 OVTUiS koTrjKOT (IvaL.
0EAI. KopLbfj /xey ovv.

b HE. Kai prjv Kal oaoL tot^ ixkv avvTiOiaaL to. TiAvTa,
TOTi 8e 8iatpoucrtv, eire ets ^v koX e^ eros airupa etre eis
TTfpas Ixorra 0T0t)(eta dtaipov/xezôt Kat ex rovrcoy o-wrt-
divT^s, opoicos pikv edy ei' /iepet roirro rt^wo-t yLyvopevov,
5 d/Ltoio)? 8e Kot edi; det, fcard Trdvra rairra Ae'yot' dr ov8e'v,
eiirep p.ribep.ia lo-rt avppet^LS,

0EAI. 'Opôi?.
HE. "Ert Toivvv hv airrol tt6vt<jov KaTayeXaaroTaTa
fXTioLv Tov Xoyov OL prjbev <avTS KOLvoovia TraOrjpaTos
10 TpOV 66Tp0V TTpoaayOpVLV.
c 0EAI. USis;
e 4 t/ olv ...65 iiTKîu) hospiti tribuit Badham et mox Theaeteto

KaKSis \(yeis & 2 TrpoffKoivuvovy W : irpoffKoivajvflv BT a 6 t*]
T^ Campbell a 8 -ye] t -ye W b8 avrol^ avTtiv W b9 /itT
(oi'] fjKrloi/Mfv BT W
20*I2TH2 252 c
SE. Tw re "cirai" ttov Trept Trai^ra ayayKaôz^rat

Xprjo-daL Koi rai "x^pt?" ""' Tw " T<av akXoiv" Kal rw
" Kad' avTo" Kal juupioiy erepoiy, wy aKpaTîs ovtS
(tpyeadai Kal ju^ (TvvaTTTHV kv rois Aoyots o^^k aAAcoy 5
beovTaL t5>v efeAeyôWcoy, dAAa ro X.y6ixvov otKodfv
TOV TToXip.lOV KOl (vaVTL(i)(r6lXV0V X^^'''^^> kvTOS VTTOffiOey-
y6ixvov uxnrcp tov aTOTTov EvpvKkea TTpL(f)4povTs det
TTopevoi^rat.
0EAI. KopLLbfj Xe'yetj 6p.0L6v re Kat akrjOes. d

HE. Ti b', av TTOLVTa akXrikoLs eco/xei' bvvay.Lv \Lv
TTLKOLV0L>VLas;
0EAI. Touro fxkv oio'? re Kayo) 8taA.vety.

HE. U&s; 5
0EAI. "Ori KLvrjCTLS re avr?; TTavTaTTacrLV loratr' Si; jcal
ordcrt? av -TrdAty avTq klvolto, etTrep TTLyLyvoL(T9r]v tt'
akkrjkoLV.
HE. 'AAAd //^y roCro' ye' ttou raiy fJL^yLOTaLS avayKaLS
abvvaTov, KLvr\(TLV re t(TTa(r6aL kcCl (tt(X(tlv KLVL(r6aL; 10
0EAI. riaJs ydp ov;
HE. Td TpLTov bi] [x6vov koLmv.
0EAI. Nai.
HE. Kai [xrjv V ye rt TOVToyv avayKaZov, rj iTavTa rj e
fxrjbev r) rd [xkv kdik^LV, tcl 8e jix,^ (rvfXfXLyvvcr6aL.
0EAI. Ylois yap ov;

HE. Kat fxifv T(x ye bvo abvvaTov rjvpidrj.
0EAI. Nat. 5
HE. nds apa 6 l3ovk6fXVos opdc^s aTT0KpLVcr6aL t6 koLiTov
T&V TpL&V 6r](TL.
0EAI. KofLLbr] fXV ovv.

HE. "Ore br] tcl fxkv kQ^k^L tovto bpav, tcl 8' ov, cr)(b6v
C 3 rwv &\\wv^ &\\wv T &\\-{i\aiv Campbell

: c 6 eleAfy-
X^vTtav T C 7 4vavTia>dri(T6fj.tvov W
d. 3 ^TrtKoivaivias T W :
4Trl Koivccvias B iiriKoivoovfTv Schanz

: d 6 re] -ye B T e 4 tu W
pe^Tj. yoi Heindorf fvpfQijvai B T
: eupedîât. : val W
253 a nAAT12N02
253 otov Ta ypajx\iaTa it(T70v66t av etr]. koI yap iKfivoiV Ta
pikv avapp.ocrTL ttov Trpos a\XT}\a, to, 8e (rvvappLOTTd.
0EAI. Um 6' ov;

HE. Ta 8e y (f>o)VT]VTa bia(f)(p6vT(09 tG)v aXkoiv olov
5 h(rp.os hia TrdvTUJV K\(i)pr]Kv, ajore avV Tivos avTdv

abvvaTOv appLOTTeiv Kal tCjv aAAcoi' iTepov kTp(a.
0EAI. Kat fjuxXa ye.

HE. Ylas ovv olhev oTTola oiroCois bvvaTa Koiviaviiv, t]
T)(vr]s bel to) jxiXXovTL bpav iKav(as avTo;

10 0EAI. Texirqs.
HE. HoCas;
0EAI. T^s ypapi]xaTLK7]S.
b HE. Ti be; irepl tovs t5)v 6î(t)v kcll (3ape(>)v (f)66yyovs
ap" owx. ovTcos; 6 fxev tovs (rvyKepavvvixevovs re Kal //,?;
T\vr]v \u)V yLyv(a(TKeLV ixov(tlk6s, o 6e ixr] crwieis ap.ov(ros;

0EAI. Ovroj?.
5 HE. Kat KaTo. tG)v aXX(t)v 8r) Teyv5)v koX aTe}(yL5)v
TOLavra evpr]ao]xev erepa.

0EAI. US)s 8' ov;
HE. Tt 8'; eTret^T/ Kai tcl yevr] TTpbs aXXr]\a KaTo. TavTo.
/xetêcos exety b)]xo\oyr]Ka]xev , ap^ ov /xer' eTrt(rrj//xj/s rtros

10 dray/catoi; 8ta TcSy Aoycor iTopevecrâL tov 6p6S)s piWovTa
beiêLV TTola ttolols (rv]X(f)(i)veX tmv yev5)V KciX iTOLa aWr]\a
C ov 8e'xerat; Kat 8r; Kai 8ta Trarrcoy e2 crvvi\ovT arr' avr'
eo-rtr, wo-re (Tv]X}xeLyvv(T6aL bvvaTo. elvaL, koX ttoXlv kv Tals
bLaLpe(TecrLV, el 8t' o\(i)v eTepa ttjs 8tatpeVea)s airia;
0EAI. ITais yap ovK eTTLcrrr]]xr]s 8et, Kai o-ê8oV ye Xcru^s
5 r^? ]xeyL(rTr]s;
HE. TtV ovi' aS [vvv] TTpo(Tepov]xev, u) QeaLTrjre, TavTr]v;
a2 (TUf ap^fJrTti] apfjiSTTfi T a8 iTToral (Jiro7a Kal W SvvaTo]

Swarai W corr. T a9 outo'] avTd T W b 5 dTx'ci' T
b8 ravTi] Ta TotoDTa B b9 ^^ O'"- ^
""^ "^*' ^
W W
^x**'
b 1 1 iro?o om. C I 5^ /col] 8); <Tvy4xovT' Stt' oCt' Wagner :
(TvvixovTa toCt' BTW C 7 Tlf'] t/ Stephanus vvv om. T

204>I2TH2 253 c
77 vpbs Alos (kd6ofjLv eis ti]v tQv kX^vOiputv e/xTrecroyTes
eTn(TTÎJ.r]v, Koi KLvbvvevoixv fTjroSrrf s tov <ro<pL(TTrjV Trporcpov

avr]vpr]KvaL tov (f)i\6cro(f)Ov;
0EAI. US>s KiyeLs; 10
HE. To KaTCL yivr] hLaLpilaOaL koX ixr]Te TavTov eiSos d

(Tpov )]yri(raa6aL p.r]Te cTCpov ov tovtov p.G)V ov rrjs SioAeK-
TLKrjs (pr^croixev e7TL(rTr]p.ris etrai;
0EAI. Nai, (})r](rop.V.
HE. OvKovv 6 ye tovto hvvaros bpav fxCav Ibeav 8ta 5
TToXk&v, kvos kKaarov KeLfjLevov x<i)pLs, lidvTr] hLaT(^Ta]x^vr]v
Ik(xvS)S hLaL(r6dveTaL, koI TtoXXas kTepas akkqX^DV vtto fXLas

(^(tidev TTepLeôp.evas, Kal fiLav av bC o\(t)V ttoW&v kv kv\
(Tvvr]fXfXvr]v, Kal TToXkas x^P'-^ iTdvTr] bL(j)pL(rfx4vas' tovto 8'
(.(TTLV, r] re KOLV(i)VLV eKacTTa bvvaTai Kal oirr] fxrf, bLaKpLVf.LV e
KaTCL yeVOS TTL(TTa(T6aL.
0EAI. YlavTdTTacTL fxev ovv.

HE. 'AAAa fxrjv t6 ye bLakeKTLKov ovk oAAo) Sw-
o-eis, o)s ky^fxaL, ttXi]V tG> Ka6apS)S re koll bLKaLods (f)LXo- 5
(T0(f)0VVTL.
0EAI. Tl(as yap av aAAo) 80177 tls;

HE. Toy pLV 877 (f)LK6ao(f)ov ev TOLOVT(a tlvI totto) Kal vvv
Ka\ eiTeLTa dvtvprfaofxev eav ^r]TG)fxev, ibeLV fxkv yaXeTTov
evapycos Ka\ tovtov, (Tepov fxrfv Tpo-nov ij re tov (TO(f)LcrTov 254
XaX.eTTOTr^s rj re tovtov.
0EAI. Ua,s;
HE. 'O fxev aTTobLbpda-Kov els Tr]V tov fxr] ovtos aKOTeL-
vdrqTa, TpL(3f] TTpoaaiTT^fxevos airrffs, 8ia to aKOTeLvov tov 5
roTTou KaTavorjaaL )(aAe7ro's' ^ ydp;

0EAI. "EoiKei;.
HE. O 8e ye (f)L\6ao(f)os, Trj tov ovtos aet 8ta XoyLafxav
TTpoaKeLfxevos Ibea, 8ta t6 KapiTTpbv av Trjs
x^P*^^ ovbafxo^s
dI Tavrhv (t>v) Hermann d8 oKwv] liWaiv Proclus iv'] tv

Apelt e 8 rby] rbW a 3 vws T VV : om. B
PLATO, VOL. I. 27
254 a nAATiiNOS
lo (VTTeTrjs 6((>0TJvai' tcl yap tt/s rwy ttoWS^v "^vxrjs ofinara
b Kaprepelv Trpbs t6 OeXov a<\>op(avTa abvvaTa.

0EAI. Kai TavTa (Ikos ov\ tjttov fKfCvuiv ovro)? e\Lv.
HE. OvKovv Tiepl fxev tovtov Kal Ta)(â iTncrK(\l/6ixe0a
(ra(f)aTpov, hv cri ôuAojui^voi? rjixlv fi'

iTepl 8e tov (To<piaTov
5 TTOV brjkov o)S ovK aveTeov TTplv hv iKartSs avTov Oea(r(i>p.eOa.
0EAI. KaAw? 17769.
HE. "Ot ovv hr) To. fji.v rjpuv tG)v yevS>v u>p.ok6yr]TaL
K0iv(jive1v eOeKeiv dA.A7/Aois, to. he /ut/, Ka\ tcl ixev Itt' 6\iyov,
To. 8' fTTi TToAAa, To. be Kal 8ia TraiTcoy ovbev k(i>Kvlv toIs
C Trao-t KKOiV(t>vriKvai, to bri p.Ta tovto avveTTL^nTdjxeOa T<a

Aoyo) Trjbe (TKoiTOVVTes, fi^ irept iTavTcov tmv ibu>v, tva p.r)
TapaTT(i>p.Oa iv TroAAots, dAAa TTpo\6p.voL tQv pLeyiaTcov

\yopAv(t>v arra, iTp&Tov p.V TTola Ka(TTa icTTiv, iireiTa
5 KOLVcovCas oAAt/Acoi' ttc^s Ix^' bvvdpLecos, tva t6 t Sv koi

/at) 6v ei ju?/ Trdo-T/ o-a0r/yeia bvv(xp.0a Xaêlv, dAA' ow
Ao'you ye ivbeels //.T/8ei' yiyvd^peOa TTepl avTG>v, KaO' oaov
6 TpoTTos evbex^STaL ttjs vvv (rK\(/e(i>s, eav apa rjpiLV ttt/
d TTapeLKCiOr] to p.r\ ov XeyovaLV u>s e(TTLV 6vt(i>s fxrj ov aO(aoLS

CLTTaWaTTeLV.
0EAI. OvKovv XPV'
HE. Meyiora p.r]v Ta>v yevG>v h. wvbr] bif]p.V t6 re ov
5 avTo Kal ordo-t? Kai KLvr](TLS
0EAI. noAv ye.

HE. Kat p.r]v T(a ye bvo (pap.ev avroiv d.pLeLKT<a iTpbs
dAAÂo).
0EAI. I,(t>6bpa ye.
lo HE. To 8e' ye 6v p.LKTov a.}x(poiv' k(TTov yap ap.<p<t> Ttov.
0EAI. U5>s b' oi;

HE. Tpia br] yCyveTaL TavTa,
0EAI. Ti/xT/r;
a lo (v-Ktrî W : iijrTy BT C5 ica) ^^ 1>v om. W d i âpft-

Kadri Boeckh : irapfiK<uj6^ BT d4 Tt] 7 B d5 Koi . . . (col]
Kai 7) . . . /cal ^ W
S04>I2TH2 254d
HE. OvKOVV aVTUiV Ka(TTOV Tolv IXeV bvolv Tp6v kcTTLV,

a.VTO 8' kavT(^ TavTov. 15
0EAI. OvTm. e
HE. Tt TTOT av vvv oilrcos elpriKaixfV t6 re TavTov Ka\
Oarcpov; iroTepa bvo ydvr] Tive avTca, tG>v p.\v rptwy aXKu>,
(Tvp.p.iiyvvp.iv(x) p.r\v (KeCvoLS e^ av6.yKr]s aeC, Kal irepl TreVre
dAA' 01) irepl TpLcov ws ovt(ov avT&v (TKdTTiov, rj t6 re TavTov 5
TovTo Ka\ daTepov b)s iKLV(t)v TL 7:poa-ayopevovTS XavOavoyL^v 255
T}p.as avTovs;
0EAI. "lo-cos.
HE. 'AAA' ov Tt, p.r]v KLVr](ris ye Ka\ a-TdcrLS ovd' T(pov
OVT TaVT6v (TTL, 5
0EAI. Um;
HE. "OTLirep av KOLvfj Trpoo-eiWcofiey KLvr]aLV Kat crTdaLv,
TOVTO OvbTpOV aVToXv ol6v T LVai.

0EAI. TCbr];
HE. KCvr^cTLS T arr]a-TaL kol o-racris av KLvr]6r]arTaL' lo
Trept yap dp,(})6Tpa 6dTpov oiTOTepovovv yLyv6p.vov avToXv

dvayKd(rL juera/3aXAety av 6dTpov eirt TovvavTLOv Trjs avTov
(f)VO-(t)S, dT ]JLTaa-)(OV TOV kvavTLOV, b
0EAI. Ko/xi8t/ ye.
HE. Mere^xeroi; ]ir]v a/xô) TavTov koll 6aTpov.
0EAI. Nat'.
HE. M^ TOLVvv Ae'ya))uey KLvrja-Cv y LvaL TavTov rj
5
6dTpov, ]xr]b^ av arda-LV.
0EAI. Mrj yap.
HE. 'AAA.' apa to ov Ka\ to TavTov ws V tl bLavor]Tov
Tjfuv;
0EAI. "la-cos. 10
HE. 'AAA' et To ov Ka\ to tovtov nrjbiv bid(f)opov arjfJLaC-
e2 a5] & B (tpriKev W e 3 auTc^l oifroO (sic) B avrov Csic) T

W
:
ti\AcD] T 64 ^vfJifJiiyvvfj.evoiv B a 12 a5] ouTa

l>5 7'] Tf
&\\(f>
W b8 Tb alterum om, W b 11 Sid(popov W :
Sia<l>6pov T : Sta<{>epov B
27*
255 b nAATaNOS
VTov, KLvrjo-LV ov TrdXiv Kol (TTCKnv afj.(f>6T(pa eirai Aeyoyrej
C afX(f)6T(pa ovTOiS avTo. tuvtov o>s ovTa TTpo(repodiJ.(v.
0EAI. 'AAAa iJir]v tovt6 ye abvvaTov.

HE. ÂbvvaTov apa Tavrov KciX to ov iv eivai.
0EAI. 2xe6oV.
5 HE. TiTapTov hr] Trpbs tois rpKrlv eiSeo-ii; t6 Tairrov
Tid5>ixv;
0EAI. Tldvv yikv ovv.

HE. Tt 8e'; to daTepov apa rjpXv Xcktcov Trîxirrov; r]
TovTo KoX To ov b)s hv OLTTa 6v6p.aTa e<^' kvl y4vL bLavoel-

lo ofât 8et;
0EAI. Tdx ^v.

HE. 'AAA' ot/xat o-e (Tvyyjx>peLV tu>v ovT(av to. /xei; avTOL
Kad" avTd, Ta 8e itpos aXka dei XiyfcrdaL.

0EAI. T^ 8' ov;
d HE. T6 8e' y' ^Tcpov det Ttpbs (Tepov ydp; rj
0EAI. Owra)?.
HE. OvK dv, ei ye t6 oi; Kai t6 daTfpov /xj/ Trd/xTroAi;
bie(f)peTr]V' dAA' eiTre/) OdTfpov dp.(poLv /xeTeixe Toty ei8otv
5 uxriTep to ov, r]v dv TTOTe tl Kal Totv kTepa>v eTepov ov irpos
^Tepov vvv 8e aTexvfiiS r]]XLv oTLtrep av eTepov f],

<rvfxêl3r]Kev
^^ dvdyKr]s eTepov tovto oixep ecrrXv elvai.
0EAI. Ae'yets KaOdirep exfi.

HE. YlefXTTTov br] Tr]v darepov (f)V(rLV keKTeov ev TOtj
e eiSeo-ti' oiUo-av, ev ols TrpoaLpovfxeOa.
0EAI. Nat'.
HE. Kat 8ta irdvTu^v ye avn^v avrSjv <f)r](rop.ev eTvai
bLe\r]X.v9vLav ev eKa^TTOv yap eTepov elvaL twv dKXcov ov

5 8ta Tr]v avTOv (f)V(TLV, dAAa 6ta t6 ixeTeêLV Trjs Ibeas rijs
doTepov.
0EAI. Ko/xi8r/ ]xev ovv.
C5 WeffiBT: eWeo-ii' elSoy W c8 3po om. W C 13 iK\a

TW:A.ArjAaB di 5* 7'] 8 7 W : 8' BT d7 ^Tt>w]
ixfpov T rovrci\ rovr aiirh W
204>I2;TH2 2556
HE. *I28e 8^ Aey<o/xey cttI rwy TreVre xa^' ev avaXafx-

^&VOVTiS.
0EAI. nw?; lo
HE. YlpGiTov ixkv KLV7](nv, 0)9 eoTi jrarrdTraaiz; Tpov

crrao-eo)?. 17 ttws Xeyo/ier;
0EAI. Ovrcos.
ati. Uv (TTacns ap crTi.v.
0EAI. Ovbapiws. 15
HE. "Eo-ri 8e' ye 86a ro fiere')(ety roC ovtos. 256
0EAI. ''Eo-rti;.
HE. ASîs gj) TrdXty ^ KLvrja-Li ^repov TavTov (ttlv.
0EAI. 2xe8o'y.
HE. Ov TavTov 6.pa (cttlv. 5
0EAI. Ov yap ovv.
HE. 'AAXa fjirjv avT-q y r\v TavTov 8ia to juere'xeiy av
TT&VT aVTOV.
0EAI. Kat p.aXa.
HE. Tî KLvricTLv hy] TavTov r' ewai Kai /xr) TavTov 6p.oKo- 10
yrjTeov Kal ov bvaêpavTeov. ov yap oTav ei7ra>//ey avTi]v
TavTov KoX 1X1] TavTov, o/xoto)? (LprjKaixfv, aXA' OTTOTav fxev

TavTov, 8ta r7jv [x46e^LV TaiiTOv Trpos eavTrjv ovTOi Ae^yo/xey, b
ora^' 8e pt?/ TavTOV, 8ta rTjy KOLVuiviav av OaT^pov, hC r]v
aTToyu>pLôp.h'r] TavTov yiyov^v ovk ^khvo dA.A' tTepov, uicrT^
opOcas av Xey^TaL TrakLV ov tovtov.

0EAI. Yiavv (XV ovv. 5
HE. OvKovv Khv 1 nr] ixcTekdixlBav^v avTr] KLvr]crLS a-Ta-
crecos, ovhev av aToirov ^]v oTacTLixov avrqv TrpocrayopeveLv;
0EAI. ÔpOoTaTd ye, etTrep tcov y^vcav avyxuiprja-oixfda
TCL fxev dAArjAots kOik^Lv jxeCyirvadaL, rd 8e /x^.
e 12 \tyofifv W
Xeywfiey B T
: a 3 ((tti ravTov a 7 i/Vrjl W
favr^ (auTTJ Schanz) Madvig oS tttj Heindorf a 8 trdvT outou]
W
:
irov TavTov Madvig a 10 t'] t6 B T ri b i Atyoêv

: W :
Xtyufifv B pr. T b6 out);] oS ^ Ast oiit)/ ri Stallbaum o5 : :
Schanz b 7 post irpoaayoptvtiv lacunam statuit Heindorf

;
256 c nAATIiNOS
C HE. Kat iMTjv (ttC ye ti]V tovtov irpoTfpov aTrobdîv
7] rCiV vvv a(f>i.K6[Jida, \^yxpvTs W9 tort KaTo, (Pvcnv
TaVTTf.
0EAI. Um yap od;

5 HE. Aey(tifX(v 8?) TTdKiv' rj KCvqcrCs (cmv (Ttpov tov
(Tepov, KaOoLTrep TavTov Te ^v aWo Kal Trjs (TTdcrecos
0EAI. 'AvayKaiov.
HE. Ovx ^Tpov 6.p iarC ini nal (Tepov Kara tov vvvbrf
Koyov.
10 0EAI. 'AAtj^^.
HE. Ti ovv hr] To fiCTa tovto; 5p' av t&v pi^v TpiCiv
Tpov avTrjv (})ri(roixV elvai., tov bi TT(ipTov [j.r) ^S)p.v,
d 6p.oXoyr\cravTs avTa elvai TrivTc, Trepi oov Kal iv ols
'npovdep.eda crKOTtiv;
0EAI. Kat TiSis; abvvaTov yap (Tvy\(p^^v fAoTrco tov
api6p.ov Tov vvvbr] (f)avVTOS.
5 HE. 'ASeciis S.pa Tifv KCvrja-Lv Tpov eiyai tov ovxos

bLa[xa)(6fj,voL kiycofxev;
0EAI. 'ASeeoraTa ixev ovv.

HE. OvKovv bif (ra(})S>s rj KCvrf(ris 6vT(as ovk ov eoTi Kat
ov, eTTetTrep tov ovtos /J.ere'xet;
lo 0EAI. â(f)(TTaT6. yc.
HE. "Eo-rti' apa e^ avayKrfs t6 firf ov ttC re KLvrfa-(i)S
etyat Kat KaTo. TravTa to, yivrf KaTO. TravTa yap ff darepov
e (^vcTLS iTepov aTTpyaCofXvrf tov ovtos Kaa-Tov ovk 6v irotet,
Kai aiufXTTavTa brf KaTO. TavTO. ovt(j)s ovk ovTa opdcis povfXV,
Kal TrdkLV, oTi /iere'xet tov ovtos, elvaC re Kat ovra.
0EAI. KiySwevet.
5 HE. riept Ka(TTov apa t5)V elbStv jroXi fxiv koTL to 6v,
a,TTLpov be TrA^êt to fxif 6v,
0EAI. "EoiKer.
C5^TW:iB cii aJHeindorf: ou BT d6 \4yofitvB

6 3 Tf secl. Schanz
20I2TH2 257 a
HE. OvKovv Kol To ov avTo T&v aXX.u>v Tpov etvaL 257

\KTOV.
0EAI. 'AvdyKT].
EE. Kal To ov ap r)\xZv, oa-airlp ecrrt Ta aXKa, KaTa
TocravTa ovk ioTLV eKcXva yap ovk ov (v fxkv avTO iaTLv, 5
airepavTa 8f tov api6p.ov TaXka ovk earTtv av.

0EAI. 2))(f8oy ovTcos.
HE. OvKOvv brj Kal TavTa ov hva-yepavTiov, ^TreiTrep exei
KoivcovCav dAATjAot? rj tu>v yev^v <pvaLS. el be tls TavTa

fxi] a-vyyoipeZ, Treto-as T]fxSiV Tovi efXTrpoaOev Koyovs ovtoo 10
TTeLOeTOi To. fxeTO. TavTa.

0EAI. AtKatorara etprjKas.
HE. "Ibcoixev br] Kal Tobe. b
0EAI. To TTOLov;
HE. 'OTTOTav To ixr] ov Xeycafxev, s eoLKev, ovk evavTiov \
'
TL keyofxev tov ovtos oAA' eTepov fxovov.

0EAI. llQ>s; 5
HE. Otoi' oTav eLTTCoixev tl ixr] fxeya, t6t jxaKKov tl croi
(paLvofieOa to afXLKpbv r] to taov br]\ovv rcS prjfxaTL;
0EAI. Kai TTcos;
HE. OvK ap', evavTLOV OTav aTTOcfâaLS XeyrfTaL arjfxoLveLV,
avyxu)pr]a6fxeda, ToaovTov be fx6vov, otl tcov aWotiv tI pirfvveL 10

To fxrf Kal TO ov iTpoTLOefxeva t5>v eiTL^VTOiV dvop.aTOiv, fmWov C
be T(av TTpayp.dTOiv TTepl &tt av KerfTaL to. iTTL(f)6eyy6fxeva
varepov Tffs aTTOcfidaeois 6v6p.aTa.
0EAI. YlavTdiTaaL fiev ovv.

HE. To8e be bLavor]6a>]xev, el Kal aol avvboKeX. s
0EAI. To TTolov;
HE. 'H 6aTepov poL (f>vaLS (PaCveTaL KaTaKeKepfxaTia6aL
Ka6dTTep eTTLaTr]p.r].
a4 tiv ip^l ovap B a, 1 1 jUfTo Tavra] jueToCra B b i tdw/^fv

W (sed suprascripto et) : (lSa)fj.ev B etSw/ji.fi/ T b 10 a-vyxwprr
W
:
(TOfjLev ca tA ivipdfYy^Hfva] & iiri(l>dfyy6y.fda Heindorf

C 7 ipiffis fxoi W
257 c nAATGNOS
0EAI. Um;
10 HE. MCa fxiv k(TTi irou kcu iKfCvr], to 8' kirC t<j) yiyvo-
fxcvov }jApos avrijs (Kaarov a(f)opL(r0v fTrcorv/xiar t<r\cL Twa
d iaxn-rjs IbCav btb TroAAat Tiyyai, t ilcrX kiyoyi^vai. kui
CTrio-T^jutai.
0EAI. riaru /ufy ovv,
HE. OvKovv Koi Ta Trjs OaTepov (î/cco)? fjLopta fxias
5 ovcrris TavTov TtiirovOi tovto.

0EAI. Ttix' av dAA' oirr\ hri Xy(ap.(v;
HE. 'Eo-Tt tS) KoAb) Ti 6aTpov fiopiov avTLTtdefj.Vov;
0EAI. 'EoTir.
HE. ToCt' ouy avoovvfxov (povfjifv yj tlv^ ^xor iiToiWfJiCav;
10 0EAI. "Exôy 6 yap KaXbv kKa(TT0T <\>Qyy6fx(da,
fjirf
TOVTO OVK aAAoU TtlÔy tTp6v kcTTW Tf TTJ^ TOV KoXoV <f>V(TDS.
HE. "101 wv T^be fioi k4y(.

e 0EAI. T6 -nolov;
HE. "AAAo Ti Twv ovTOiV Tivbs kvbs yivovs a(f)opicr6(v
Koi TrpOS Tl tG)V OVTOiV av TldkLV aVTLT(6(V OVTOO (TVp.^(^r]K(V
(waL To fxr\ Kak6v;
5 0EAI. OVTCO?.
HE. 'Oi^Tos bif irpbs ov avTL0rLS, wy (olk, (IvaC tls
(TVfxâCv(L t6 fxr) Kak6v.
0EAI. 'Op06TaTa.
HE. T^ ovv; KaTo. tovtov Tbv k6yov apa fxakkov fxkv rb
lo Kakbv rffXLV ôri tS>v ovroiv, rfrrov b( to fxrf Kakov;
0EAI. Ovb(v.
258 HE. 'O/xoicos apa to fxrf fx(ya Koi to fx(ya avrb <u'ai
AfKTôy;
C 10 ^Kflyv^ iKtivri BT t^! rh B Toirry C :T(rxi Tiri W 1 1
iirwvvtJiiav "W d i âirr^j secl. Heindorf: outou Baumann t4

tlffi W : T((r T ri(Tiv B
: d 6 a\K' Sin? 5^) i\K6 xij T W :
i\Ao B
irfl ea ^vbs om. B ytvovs] yp. fitpovs in marg. T
fitpovs W (an iv6s yi rivos ?) 63 (vfiPfPvKf

BT: W
^''' Stephanus
^vf^0f$riK(vai BT e6 >K D: ftj/ 6 iiyri0t<riv B: 4
iyr/Oto-ty W tij Apelt : ti BT : om. W
; ;
20*I2TH2 258a
0EAI. 'O/aoitos.
HE. OvKovv Kal To fXT] bUaiov tw SiKatw Kara Tavra
6cTov Trpbs To \xr\h^v n fxaXXov ilvat OaTepov 6aT(pov; 5
0EAI. Tt ixi]v;
HE. Kai TcAAa 8?) TavTrj X.ôfj.V, iTTfLirep rj 6aTipov
(f>v(ns e(f)avr] tG)V 6vt(ov ovcra, iKLvr]s 8e ov^rrjs avdyKr] brj
Kal To. ixopLa avTrjs ixr]bv6s rJTTOv ovTa TL^dvai.

0EAI. HQs yap ov; lo
HE. OVKOVV, U>S OLKV, rj Trjs 6aTpOV fXOptOV (f)VCr((tiS
Kal Trjs Tov ovTos TTpbs oAArjAa avTLK(ipiV(tiV avTidecTLS ovh\v b

riTTOv, f.1 64fXLS flTrelv, airrov tov ovtos ova-Ca eaTLV, ovk ivav-
TLOV KLV(o (TqfxaLVOvaa aWa to(Tovtov fxovov, eTfpov Klvov.
0EAI. â(f)4aTaTa ye.
HE. TlV OVV aVTtfV TTpO(rLTT(t)fXV 5
0EAI. ArjXov otl to fxrj ov, b bLO. tov cro^pKTTrfV e^T/rou/xev,
aVTO kcTTL TOVTO.

HE. IToTepor ovv, uxnrep etTres, ((ttlv ovbevos t&v aAAcoy
oxxrCas iWeLTTOfxevov, Kal bel 6appovvTa ijbrj kiyeiv otl t6
fxrj ov ê/3aift)? eort Trjv avTov (f^vcTLV eôv, cocnTep t6 fxeya lo
r]V fxeya Kal t6 kclXov ^v koXov kol t6 fxrj fxeya (jxrj fxeya^ Kal C
t6 fxr] KaX6v (^fxi] koAoV)', ovto) be Ka\ t6 fxr] ov KaTO. tovtov
r]V Te Ka\ ecTTL fxr] ov, evdpL6p.ov tS)v iroXk&v ovtcov elbos ev;
1} TLva eTL irp6s avro, 2 ^catTTjTe, diTLcrTLav eyofxev;
0EAI. OvbefxCav. 5
HE. Oto-^' ovv OTL YlapfxevLbrf fxaKpoTepcos ttjs diToppri^reios
rfTtLaTrfKap.ev
0EAI. Ti 87/;
HE. IlAetoi; t/ 'Keiros aTreiTre o-KOTretr, rjfxels els t6
Trp6(r6ev eTt ^T/TT/o-azrres dTrebeCâfxev airrca. lo
a8 iipdirri'] (painj B b2 ohffia^ oZffa Simplicius b8 Sffirep]

tirtp W b9 Madvig 5! T
ovfflas^, ovffla 5^ B C i fii)W :
fieya et mox Ka\6v add. Boeckh

f/.i} C4 txoiJ.evTV^: om. B C 7 îri-
ffThKafi.fv'^ a<p(ffTT]Kafi.tv Cornarius C 10 tri ^y\r-f,ffavTis] iitiCir^-lf
ffavrts Simplicius
258 c nAATiiNOS
0EAI. m^;
d HE. "Ori 6 /xey ttov <l>r](riv
Ov yap fjirj ttot tovto ba^fj, clvat firf iSvra,
&X\a av TTJab^ a<\> obov Si^^crios eipye vorjfia.
0EAT. Aiyi yap ovv ovrws.

5 HE. 'H/iei9 8e ye ov fiovov to. /xt) ovTa ws eariy dire-
bdâfi^v, aXka KaL to tlhos o Tvy\avi, ov tov /x^ ovtos
aTr(f)rivdp.da' Trfv yap daripov (\>v(tiv airobîâvTes ovcrdv
e T Kol KaTaKKpp.aTL(rp.vr\v Itu TrdvTa tcl ovTa irpbs aAAj;Aa,
t6 TTpbs To ov Ka(TTov pLOpiov avTTJs dvTiTi6p.vov iTokpLrj-
crap.V eiTreiy ws avro rouro' icrTiv ovtcos to /xt) ov.
0EAI. Kal navTdiTa^rC ye, w êVe, dkr]6(rTaTd p.oi
5 b0K0Vp.V ipr]KVai.
HE. M?/ Toivvv r]p.ds e?7r7; ris ori Tovvavriov tov ovtos
TO fir] OV dTT0(f)aLv6lJ.V0l. T0\fJL(afiV \yLV OiS i(rTLV. fffLTs
ydp TTpL pLv ivavTiov Tivbs avT^ yaipLV TrdAai keyofiev,

259 eir' ^(TTLV elre fxr'], \6yov xpv r] Kal iTavTdTTa^rLV aKoyov
o b^ vvv lpr]KafiV LvaL Tb fir] ov, rf TTL(rdTOi tls ds ov
KoX&s k4yofXV eAeyây, r] fiXpLiTp hv dbvvaT^, X.ktov
Kal Kiv(a Ka6diTp r]p.LS Xyop.V, otl crvp.fiLywTai re
5 dAAr/Aois rd yivr] koll t6 re ov koX 6dTpov 8id TrdvTMV koX

bC dA\r]Ko}v bLXr]Xv66T Tb fjiV Tpov fx^Ta^r-j^bv tov ovtos
(TTL p.V 8ld TaVTTfV Tr]V fl6^LV, OV ft.r]V Klv6 y OV
flT(TyV dAA' TpOV, ^TpOV b TOV OVTOS OV (rTL aa(f)(TTaTa
b e^ dvdyKrfs etfai fir] ov rd 8e 6v av 6aTpov /xereiAj</)os
Tpov T(av d\\(t)v dv eiTj yvm>, Tpov 8' iKeivcov aTTdvTiav
6v ovK (rTLV Ka(TTOv avT&v ovb (rvfiTTavTa Ta dAAa iT\r]v
airrd, (ocrre rd 6v dvap.(f)Lcrfir]Tr]T(os av fxvpia iiTl fxvpiois ovk
da rovTO Sa/xv Simpliciiis tovt' ovSanfj

: 46yTa Aristoteles BT :
6in-a BT da hic re vera

Si^rjo-ios (sed cf. 3373) BTds oij
fffTiv To /u^ Syra B Simplicius 6 2 tKaffTov Simplicius: iKdarov
BT a
4 Tf B Simplicius : oin. T a6 in\ii\vd6Tt Simplicius :
Si(\ri\v06Ta B T
20<I)I2TH2 259b
l(rri, Kal TaXXa 8t) KaO^ iKacTTov ovtco Kal (rv}i.iTaVTa itoXkay?] 5
}i^v (CTTi, TToWaxi] 8' ovK eoTtr.

0EAI. 'Ak-qdi].
HE. Kal TavraLS 8t; Tals evavTLuxrecrLV eire dTTicrret rt?,
(TKeTTTeOV aVTU> Kol \KTOV j34kTl6v Tt tS)V VVV fipr}fXVWV'
etre cos rt xakeTTov KaTavVor]KO)s \aip(î tot\ fxkv eTri daTipa C
TOTk 8' eTTt daTipa tovs koyovs ^Xku>v, ovk a^ta TroAAr}?
(TirouS^s eoTTOvSaKey, wy ot z;{5i/ Aoyot (f)a(rL tovto p.v yap
ovT TL Kop.\\rov ovT xakcTTOv (vpLV, kKilvo 8' rjhT] Kttt xaXeiTov
ap.a Kal Kakov. 5
0EAI. To TTotor;
HE. *0 Kat TTpocrOev eXprjTaL, to TavTa (xcravTa &)?
t Suiâra t rots keyojxevoLS olov t elvaL Ka6' CKaa-Tov

kkeyyovTa kiTaKokovdeLV, otov t rts eTepov ov ttj] TavTov
etrat 0fj Kat otov TavTov ov eTepov, eKcCvr] Kal KaT^ (Kctvo d
o (^rjcrt rovrtov 7TTTOv64vaL TTOTepov. t6 8e TavTov (Tepov
aiT0(paLVLV djLiTj ye ttt] Kal t6 66.T(pov tovtov Ka\ t6 fieya
(TfJiLKpov Kal t6 op.oLov cLVopiOLOv, Kttl xaCpdV ovTO) TavavTLa
det TTpo(f)epovTa ev rots Ao'yots, ovt rts eAey)(os ovtos 5
akr]6Lv6s apTL re Tcav ovtcov tlv6s ((fâTTTOfievov bfjkos
veoyevrjs u)V.
0EAI. Ko/xt8f/ fxev ovv.

HE. Kal ydp, d)ya6i, t6 ye TTav aiTo Trarros eTTtxetpety
aTTO)(Oi)pL^(LV dAAcos re ovk ifxjxekes Kal bi] Kal TTavTo.TTacnv e
afxovcrov tlv6s Kal a(f)Lkoa6(f)ov.
0EAI. Ti' 8?j;
HE. TeAecordrTj tt6vt(i)v k6y(ov ecrnv a(f)avLcrLS t6 8ta-
kveLV eKacTTov dTro iTavTMV' 8id ydp rrji; dAATjAtoy T(ji)v elhoiv 5
(TVfXTTkoK-qv 6 k6yos yiyovev rffxlv.
b 9 (TKfTrTtov] JirttTKfirrfov T C 4 ^Stj /cal] fjSr] C 8 Swara] W

SvvaruTaTa Schanz av-fivvra Badham
: SvvaThv /uaAjiTTO Campbell
: :
an S(ov avra ? Apelt d. 2 rovraiv T tovto B W

d 5 Tpo<T<p4-
:
povra W ris om. W

64 wpavKrls iari 65 oAAÂco'] W
aAAÂ.o(s Baumann
259 6 nAATX2N0S
0EAI. 'Akrêrj.
260 HE. 2*co7r6i Toivvv &)? ^v Kaipl^ wvtn] TOis roiov-
rots hieiiayojxida kolI TTpo(rr]vayKdôfXv iav tnpov krepio
lXCyvv(rdai.
0EAI. Upos br^ tC;

5 SE. Upbs t6 tov Xoyov ^jmv tS>v ovTUiV V rt yevwv
(Ivai. TovTov yap crTeprjOevTis, to fxkv p.iyi<TTov, (f)iAo(TO(f>Cas
av (TTepriOelixev' Iri 8' iv ro) itapovTi hii, koyov Tjixas
bi,op.o\oyrj(ra(rdat, tC ttot lo-riy, d be d(prfp46r]ix(v avTO fxrfb^
etyai to TrapaTiav, ovbev h.v ^tl ttov \4yeiv oloC r rjixfv.
b d(f)r]pi0r]p.ev 8' dv, el (rvvexapWO-fJ^^v fxrfbefxCav clvai fxd^LV

fxrfbevl TTpbs firfbev.
0EAI. Ôp9(as TovTO yv Koyov be bCori vvv biOfxoKoyrfTeov

ovK efxaQov.
5 SE. 'AAX' XcroiS Tf]V kTiofxevos pa(TT dv fxddois.
0EAI. nfj;
HE. To fxev br] fxr] ov rjfxiv ev rt rcSi; dXkoov yivos ov
dve(j>dvr], Kara Trarra to, ovtu bie(nrapfxevov.
0EAI. Oyra)s.
10 SE. Ovkovv to fxeTO, tovto crKeTniov ei 8o'^t; r /cat A.o'y(j>
fxeCyvvTai.
0EAI. Tt brf,
C HE. M^ fxeiyvvp.Vov fxkv airrov tovtois dvayKalov d\r]6rj
TrdvT eTvai, fxeiyvvfiivov be boâ re êvbrfs yiyveTat. Koi

Xoyos' Tb yhp Ta fxrf ovTa bo^dêiv rj Xiyeiv, tovt ((tti ttov
To \lfevbos ev btavoCa t Kal XoyoLS yLyvofxevov,
5 0EAI. OvT(tis.
SE. 'Orros 8e ye \l/evbovs eoriy dTTdrrf.
0EAI. Nat'.
SE. Kai fLr]v dTTdrr]s ov(rr]s dboiX(av t( Kal elKOVOivijbr}
Kal <f)avTaaCas irdvTa dvdyKr] fxecrrd etvaL.
a4 Sj) ri] ri i-fi^W as rhv Wom : BT a8 avrhl av

rh W nv^'] fiv^ky B b 3 6tio\oyT]Tfov W b 7 6' om. T
b8 4<pd>rn W
2012THS 260 c
0EAI. riais yap ov; 10
HE. Tov be y <ro^tn-T7)y ^(pa[MV V tovt(o ttov ro) TOTTio
KaTairecfievyivai fiiv, (âpvov be yeyovevai. t6 TTapa-nav /xt;8' d

etmt \(/vbos' to yap jxi] ov ovt biavodZaOai Ttva ovTe Kiytu"
ova-ias yap ovb\v ovbafxri t6 /x^ ov /xerex^"'.
0EAI. "Hv TavTa.

EE. Nvv bi ye tovto fxev (f)dvr] fiTi\ov tov ovtos, 5
woTC Tavrq fiev to-a)s ovk av ixdxoiTo Irt' Taxo. b' av (âir)
TOiV ilbSiV To. p.ev /xerexety tov /xtj ovtos, to. 8' ov, Kal
Koyov bi} Kal boâv etmt riov ov /xerexoWcoz', ooo-re tj^v
flbâXoTTOUKifV Kal (ftavTaoTLK-qv, kv r\ (f)aiJ.(v avTov etvat,
biap.dxoiT av TrdAty o)S TiavTdiTaaLV ovk ((ttlv, C7ret8?) boâ e

KOL Ao'yos ov KOLVoovL Tov 1X1] ovTos' "îvbos yop t6 TTapdirav
ovK etyat ravTTjs /x^ (rvvL(rTap.ivr]s Trfs KOLVcovias. bLo. TavT
ovv Xoyov TTpQiTov Ka\ boâv kcll âvTacriav bLepevvriTeov
OTL TTOT iaTLV, LVa (f)av4vT(DV Kal Tr]V K0LV0)VLaV aVTWV T(0 5
]xr] ovTL KaTibcopLev, KaTLbovTes 8e t6 yfrevbos ov d7Tobei^(i)fX(v, 261
aTTobeiâvTes be t6v a-o(f)L(rTr]v et? avT6 ivbr]<Jo)]xev, iiiTep
ivoyps ia-TLV, r] Kal diTokv^ravTes iv dk\(o yivei ^rjrw/xer.

0EAI. KofXLbfj bi ye, S) îve, ioLKcv dkqOes eTvaL t6
TTepl t6v (ro(f)LaTr]v Kar dpxds kexOiv, otl bvcrO-qpevTov etr/ 5
t6 yivos. (f>aLVTaL yap ovv TTpojSXrjfxaToov yifxeLV, Zv
7rei8ay rt TTpofSdXrj, tovto TipoTepov dvayKalov Sta/xdxeo-âi
TTplv eir' avT6v kKeivov d(f)LKia-OaL. vvv yap fxoyLs fxev t6
fxr] ov &)S ovK eaTL iTpojiXrjdev bLeiTepd^rafxev, eTepov 8e
TTpoj3il3\r]TaL, Ka\ bel br] yf/evbos o)S eort Ka\ Trept koyov Ka\ b
Trept boâv aTroSetât, Ka\ p.eTa tovto tcroos eTepov, Ka\ er'
dAAo /xer' eKeiiô" Kai iripas, o)S eoiKer, ovbev (fâvrjaeTai
TTore.
HE. Qappelv, o) 0eatrTjre, xpi] t6v Ka\ afXLKpov tl bvvd- 5
fxevov ets t6 iTpoa-Oev det irpolivaL. Ti ydp y dOvfxuiv iv
C 1 1 5e 76 W : Se BT d9 aitrhr] avruv B e 2 ykp rh

T W T^ yap B a2 ainh W avrhy BT a4 5e om. T W
W
: :
a 7 TOVTO] TOVTlf
;
26ib nAATiiNOS
TOVTOLS hpa(THV hv (V aAAots, rj fxrjbiv ev ^KeCvois avvTiov
7) Kal irdkiv cis TOVTna-Ofv a7ru)(r6iCs; (Txokfj ttov, t6 KaTo,
C Trjv TTapoLnCav Xiy6p.ivov, 6 ye tolovtos av ttotc eXoL ttoXlv,
vvv 8' CTTcC, b)yad4, tovto o Aeycts 8ta7rc7repain-at, t6 tol
iliyKTTOV T]llLV TL\0S fjpTJlX^VOV hv fLT], TO. 8' oAAtt 7/8t; p(l(i)
KOL (rp.LKp6Tpa.
5 0EAI. KaAws ctTre?.
EE, Aoyoj; 8^ irpCiTov jcat h6âv, KaBAiTip epprfOt] vvvbr],

Xa^cajxev, tva kvapyioT^pov a'7ToXoyL(r(i)p.e6a iT^Tepov avTb)V
aTrrerat to p,r] 6v r] TTavTdiTaa-LV aXri6r] ixiv kaTLV a]i(\)6Tipa
TavTa, \lrvbos 8e ovbeiTOTi ovbiTepov.
lo 0EAI. 'Op6S)s.
d HE. êpe b-q, Ka66,7Tp TTepl Toiv elbStv KalTavypapi.fi(!LT(ji)v
(Xeyofxfv, ircpX t5)V dvofidroi^v iTdXLV ci)(ravT(ji)S kiTL(TKfy\r(j)]xi6a.
(paCveTai yap ttt/ ravTr] t6 vvv ^rjTovixcvov.

0EAI. T6 TTOtov ovv br] TTepl tS)V ovofxaToov vTTaKOV^rreov
5 HE. Etre 'jrayra dAAÂois (rvvapfx6TTL eire fxrfb^v, tre
Ta fxev eêAei, tcl 8e pLrf.
0EAI. AÂoy tovt6 ye, ort tcl fxkv id^XcL, to. 8' ov.
HE. T6 roiovê A^yeis t^rcos, otl tol fxev i(f)^s Xfy^fxeva

e Kal br]XovvT6. tl crvvapfx6TTL, to. b\ rTj o-vrexeta fir]b\v
(rrjfxaCvovTa dvapfxoaTd.
0EAI. Ylois tC tovt (LTTas;
HE. "OiTfp ^rf6r]v VTToXa(36vTa cre Trpo^rop.oXoyelv. eort
5 ydp rfpLLV ttov t5)v Tr\ (fôovr) TTepl ti]v ovcrCav bi]Xa)fxdT(DV
8i7t6v yivos.
0EAI. U&s;
262 HE. T6 fxv 6v6fi.aTa, t6 8e prffxaTa KXrfdiv,
0EAI. EiTre kKdTcpov.
b7 avinw B
Ci 6.V iroTf B &v iroO' om. T
: W
e 6 0 5o'{oi' :
irpwTOV W C 7 aitoXoyiau)ti.t9a Heindorf airoXoyqawtJifda B T

d 3 (paivtTai B T Stobaeus (pavfTrai
:
d I itfpi B Stobaeus îrl T :
W
:
Heindorf d 5 ûvapn^TTd ^vvap/JtdTTfiy B T : d 8 taws

B Stobaeus ws T :
204>I2THS 262a
HE. To fxlv 771 TOLS '7Tpdî(ri.v ov 6Âco/xa /a^jua tiov
Xiyojxev.
0EAI. Nat. 5
HE. To 8e y' ctt' avrois rois eKciras TrpaTTOVO-i a-q^.lov

r^s (f)(i}vijs (TTLTeOev ovoiia.
0EAI. Kojat8f) /ixev ovy.

HE. OvKovv k^ ovojxdTcov fiev fxovcov crvvexbis Aeyo-
^xivdiv ovK <i(TTi TtOTi \6yos, ovb' uv prjixdTcov Xdipls dvop/XTOiv lO
KeydivToiv.
0EAI. Taur' ovk p.adov.
HE. ArjXov yap wy Ttpos Tp6v tl ^XeiTOdV apTi (Tvvoiixo- b
Aoyeis' eTrei tovt avTo (j3ov\6p.r]v etTreu', ort crvvex^s cS8e
Aeyo^/ueya raCra ovk (ttl Aoyos.
0EAI. nws;
HE. OXov "/3a8tCet" " Tp4x(L" " KadevbeL," Kal 5
raAAa oo-a Trpaêts (rrjpaLveL pr]fxaTa, k^v irdvTa tls e(f)eî]S
avT etTTT/, Aoyoy oii8e'i' rt juaAAor aiTepydêTai.
0EAI. n&)? ydp;

HE. OvKOW Kat TTaAty OTav keyrjTaL "keoov" "eAaôs"
"tTTTros," o(Ta re 6v6p.aTa tQv tcls TrpdêLS av TrpaTT6vT(ov lo
u)vopA(T6r], Ka\ KaTo. Tavrr^v br] Tr]v (TvvexeLav ovbeCs tto) C
(TvvecTTr] X6yos' ovbep.Lav yap ovTe ovtcos ovt eKeCvojs
TTpa^LV ov8' aTTpa^Lav ovbe ova-Cav ovtos ovbe ]xr] ovtos
Sr/Aoi Ta <f)u)vr]devTa, irplv dv tls rots 6v6fxa(TL to. p-qpaTa
KepdcTT]. T^Te 8' rjpfxocrev re Kat Aoyo? eyeveTO evdvs 5
rj iTp(OTr] (TU/xTrAoKr/, crxebov tS)v X6yo)v 6 iTp5)T6s re Kai
crpLKp^TaTos.
0EAI. n<Ss ap S)be Xeyeis;
a4XeySfievov Stobaeus a 6 auToTs Torj (Ktlvas B Stobaeus :

aiiTors Tors iKtivdye W
(sed ye ex o-e factuml auTOjy iKf7va T a5 :
W
:
To7s ^KeTva Heindorf a 9 fxovov b i luj/ccyuoAcPyeis T Sto-

baeus ^vvo/no\oyt7s B
: b 2 eirel toOt'] TretT' offr' T b 9 orav
TW: om.B (sedKoyprojtajb) b 10 Te]T SAAa W Ci wvofjLaaQrf
T Stobaeus bvoixa<T6^ B dvofiaarl W C 6vtos post ovcriav B
W Stobaeus3
: :
Stobaeus fii/Tttfs T
: c 6 ts cai : ct /col T : /col B
a62c nAATilNOS
SE. "Orav (Xirr) ti?* " &v6p(OTTOS fJ.av06.veL," \6yov
lo (Ivai (f)7js TovTov e^dxLCTTOv T Koi irpo^Tov;
d 0EAI. 'Eyojye.
SE. AtjAoi yap 7/87; iroi; t6t Trepl twv ovtcov t] yiyvo-
fiivuiv rj yeyovoTcav rj [XW6vT(av, Kal ovk ow/xaêi fwvov
aXXd Ti TTfpaivd, av}xi:XK(i>v to. prip.aTa tois ov^fxacru bio
5 Aeyetv t^ avTov dXA' ov ii6vov ovofidâv eiirofiev, Ka\ brj Koi

tS> TrXeyfiaTt TOVT<a to ovofia ((f^dey^dfifda X6yov.
'
0EAI. 'OpeS>s.
SE. OvTO) 8^ KaOditep to. TrpdyfiaTa to, fikv dAATJAotj
ijpflL0TTV, TO. 8' OV, Kal TTepl TO. TTJS (f)Ciivi]S av (TTffKla Ta fikv
e (n)\ apfWTTCL, To. 8e apfx^TTOVTa avT&v k6yov aTnfpydcraTO.
0EAI. navTaTrao-i p.V ovv.
SE. 'Eti hi] (TfxiKpov To8e.
0EAI. To 710101';
6 SE. Ao^yov dvayKaZov, OTavTnp r], Twbs itvai \6yov, fxif
8e Ttiôs d8 waToy.
0EAI. OvT(as.
SE. OvKovv KOL ttol6v TLva avTov ttvai bil;
0EAI. Uu,s 8' ov;
10 SE. IIpo(rex(>ifiev br] tov vovv rffXLV avrols.
0EAI. Aft yovv.
SE. Acô) TOLVVV (TOL X6yov (rvvOeis iTpdyfia Trpdêi
8t' 6v6fxaTos kcu pr]\xaTos' otov 8' hv 6 \6yos (tv fxoL

fj,
(f)pd^LV.
263 0EAI. TauT' eo-Tat KaTa bvvap.Lv.

SE. " 0ea^T7;Tos fcd^r/Tat." fx5)V p.i] fxaKpos o \6yos;
da t<{t] tJ> W d4 vtpalvd T W

Stobaeus : ittpcdvfi koL B :
Kol irtpaivti Hermann ds t W
Stobaeus t< icoi :Jfiro- BT
Stobaeus cfirot/uci/ BT ko2 5^) kqI B Stobaeus ica2 5^ T
f>.fv
W
: :
d6 iirecpOfy^dfieda Stobaeus d 8 tA irpiyixara KaJdaicfp ri
fx\v W Stobaeus
T B d9 : ix\v apfiSrTtt W e i Ac^T-of T Sto-
baeus om. B : 63 5^ om. T eBStitlvatVJ e la irpayfia]
W
irpdyfiaTa 614 W <(>pd^ aa /tt' /i^ B : /tjj T, scd fiiy
suprascripto et /xii eraso

204>I2THS 263a
0EAI. OvK, akka fierptos.

HE. Soy pyov bi] (jipdCîv Trepi ov r' ecrrt Ka\ otov.
0EAI. Arjkov oTi TTepl ifxov re koI e/xo?. 5
HE. Tt 8e 08' av;

0EAI. noto?;
HE. "0eatrijros, (^ vvv lyco bLaXeyofiai, Trererai."
0EAI. Kai TovTov ov8' ay cts aAAcos etTroi Trkijv ipLOV
T Kal irepl ifwv. 10
HE. riotoi' 8e' ye rtm (f)aixev avayKoiov eKaarov etyat

rdJr Ao'ycoy.
0EAI. Nat. b
HE. Tovrcoi; 8?) 7roto'y Ttm Ijccirepoy (/)areoy eimt;
0EAI. Tbv piev yjrevbTJ ttov, tov be dkrjOfj.
HE. Aeyet be avT&v 6 fxkv dXrjOrfs to. ovTa ws eoriv
irept crou. 5
0EAI. ri fxriv;
HE. *0 8e bi] \}revbr]s eTepa tSiv ovTOiv.
0EAI. Nat.
HE. Ta JU7J oW apa ws ovra Ae'yei.
0EAI. ^x^bov. 10
H E. "Ozrrcoi' 8e' ye ovra eTepa irept croi!. iroXAa fiev yap

e(âp.ev ovTa Trepi eKaarov elvai iiov, TtoKKa b\ ovk ovTa.
0EAI. Ko/xt8fj jxkv ovv.
HE. *0y varepov hr] Koyov etprjKa Trept o-ou, T:pG>Tov ]xev, C
e^ c5y b)pi(Tdp.da tC ttot ecm Acjyos, dvayKatOTaTov avrov
va T&v (3paxyTdT(ov etvat.
0EAI. NwS?) yovv Tavrq (Tvv(afio\oyri(raiJLV,
HE. 'ETretra 8e' ye rti;o's. 6
0EAI. Ovrcos.
HE. Et 8e fxi] icTTiv crds, ovk aAAou ye ovbevos
a 10 T] t' (Ivai B b4 odiTwv] axn^ B b 11 6vruv Cor

narius: ovtws BT b 12 oj/ra i<pa]uv W C5 Se -ye B Afê T
W
:
c 7 76 T : T B
PLATO, voi, I. 28
:
263 c TIAATiiNOS
0EAI. nS>s ydp;
EE. MrjSeyos (be) ye Siv ovb* hv \6yos ctri t6 TrapaTtav
lo aTr(l)rivafXV yap ort t&v abvv6.T0)v ^v \6yov 6vTa firjbcvos
(IvaL \6yov.
0EAI. 'OpôVara.
d HE. Tlepl br] a-ov keyofxeva, Âeyo^/ifya^ /ucrrot O^Tfpa
to)S To. avTo. KoX fjLrj ovra d)? ovTa, TravTaTTaa-iv [ws] ôlkcv fj
ToiavTr) (TvvOio^Ls ^K T pr]fx6T0)v yiyvoixivr) koX 6vofx6,TO)V

ovTu)9 T Kal a)\.r]6u>s y(.yvadai k6yos y}/vbi^s.
5 0EAI. 'AATjêWara fXV ovv.

EE. Ti be brj; 8tayoia re Kal b6â Kal (f)ai^Taa-[a, fx&v
ovK ijbr} brjXov ort Tavra ye ^vbr} re Kai aXrfdfj itavff fjfxtav
V rais ^vxais yyiyvTai.;

0EAI. US>s;
lo EE. '^126' Xa-ri pqov, hv irpQTOv A({/3r;s avra tC Tror tariv
e Kat rt bLa(f)pov(raf KacrTa ak\i]\(i)V.
0EAI. ACbov fxovov.

EE. OvKovv bLavoLa fxev Kal \6yos TavT6v TT\r]V 6 fuv
Vt6s TTJs ylrv)(r]S TTpbs avTr]v StaAoyos avv (fxavfjs yLyv6fXVos
5 TOVT avTo fffXLV kircavofxacrdr], Stavota;
0EAI. Uavv fXV ovv.
EE. To 8e y' d.ii KLvr]s pVfxa 8ta tov ar^fxaTos I6v
fXTa ^96yyov KK\r]TaL \6yos;
0EAI. 'AAt;^^.
lo EE. Kai p.f]v iv \6yoLS ye av XafXV v6v
0EAI. To Troior;
EE. âa-LV T Koi 6.Tr6(f)aa-LV.
0EAI. "la-fxev.
C9 8 add. Heindorf e lo i7rtip7it>d/xriv T di Xtyîatva

add. Badham d a &>; om. W ily roiavTTi avvBtffd ^rindTwv W
d7 7 Stobaeus y*^ T rck yfvri B
: d lo auTo W Stobaeus
W Stobaeus
:
om. BT ei Sta^fpovd' Schanz 65 îrad/oâtrfl/ :
iiraivoixaaBai B : iiraivoixdffOai T 6 7 8*7'] 5' Stobaeus e 10 7

al Stobaeus : yt avrh W : 011x6 BT tfffitv B T oh : fiiv Stobaeus
ivbv Stobaeus : tf B T
20*I2TH2 264 a
HE. "Otov ovv tovto ev ylrvxfj KaTo. bi.a.voi.av iyyCyvr)Tat 264

bo^s X^'^ ^'''* T^poo-fCTrps avro;
fj.Ta (TLyrjs, irkriv
0EAI. Kat ttQs;

HE. Tt 8' oTav 1X1] Ka6^ avro aXXa bC ala-6ria-a>s Trapfj
TLVl, TO TOIOVTOV aV 170.605 OLp oXoV T dp6SiS elTTilv iTCpOV 5
Ti TrXrjv (f)avTaorLav;
0EAI. Ovbiv.
HE. OvKovv eTreiirep Xoyos a\r]6r}s rjv Kal \}/evb-qs, tov-
TCitv 8' ((pdirq bLdvota iikv avrrjs Trpos kavrr^v yjrvxv^ btdkoyos,
boâ be btavotas aTroreAevTTjcri?, " (patvcTat" 8e o k^yofxev b
(Tvixfxeiîs ala-6ri(r(i)s Kal bo^rjs, ctvdyKrj br] Kot TovTCtiV rai
koyca crvyyev&v ovT(av \}/vbr] [rej avT&v ivta Kot kvioTi dvat.
0EAI. UG,s b' ov;
HE. KaTavoeXs ovv oTt TrpoTepov r]vpi6r] \l/vbr]s boâ 5
Kal \6yos r] /cara ttjv TrpocrboKtav rjv ôj3i]6r]ixv dprt, [xrj
TtavTd-nacrtv dvr]vvTov tpyov iiTtâkkot]X6a 0]tovvtS avTo;
0EAI. KaTavoa.
HE. M^ Toiwv ]xr]V ets to. XoiTra d6vfxoiixV. (iretbr]
yap TTCcfiavTat Tavra, tS)V c]XTrpocr6ev dvaixvr]cr66i]xev KaT c

eiSrj btatpicreoiv.
0EAI. OotW 877;

HE. AttX6[X6a Trjs elbdiXoTTOLiKrjs etbr] bvo, rrjv fxev
(LKaoTLKriv, Tr]v 8e (pavTacrTLK-qv. 5
0EAI. Nai.
HE. Kai Tov (ro(f)t(rn]V fiiTOfxiv b)S d-nopotfxev ets OTtoTepav
drja-ofxev.
0EAI. "Uv Tavra.

HE. Kat Tov6' r]fxG)v aTTopovfxevatv ^tl fxetôiv KaTeyy^r] 10
(TKOTobuvia, (pavivTos tov kdyov tov TTcta-tv dfX(pLafir]TovvTos
a4 2to'] Stobaeus
h-av 5<{|a koO' airh Stobaeus Kad' a'jri)v B T
oAXoj oAA.' i^ W a 5 Sp' om. Stobaeus a 8 6 ante \6yos
:
W
a 9 ^vxvs'] rrjs ypvxv^ W
b r <f>aivf(T0ai Stobaeus b 2 ry KSyc/il
riav Xoycev Stobaeus b 3 re secl. Heindorf -ye Schanz :b 5 irpo-
repovl irpairfpoy T Stobaeus C 10 fx(i(w B
28*
264 c nAATXlNOS
0)5 ovT eiKojv ovT (tb(t)Kov ovT <\)avTaa}x etrj to TrapaTtav
d ovbev bia t6 /xrjSa/xcS? fjLrjbeTTOTe fjir}bafiov êvbos (tvai.
0EAI. Acyeis akrjOy].
HE. Nvv be y' iTreibrj iti^âvTai, ykv Aoyos, "ne^pavTai
8' ovcra boâ xj/cvbrfs, kyxj^pî bi] ixipiriixaTa tS>v ovTuyv (Ivai.
5 Kal Tiyvnv k TavTrjs yiyvea-Oai r^s biaOia-em airarqTiKriv.
0EAI. 'Eyxcopei.
EE. Kat /urjy ort y' tjv 6 <ro(f)iaTris TovT(av iroTfpov,
bi.coiJ.o\oyriixevov rjnlv iv ro is irpoadev tjv.
0EAI. Nat.
lo HE. IlaAti' Toivvv kiriyeLp&ixev, ayJiôvTes bi)(r] to
e TtpoTeOev yevos, TTopeveadai /cara rovrt Se^ta aei p-epos tov
TixriOevTos, \6pt,vot Trjs tov aocjiLOTOv KOiv(ovias, ecos ^v

aiiTov To. KOLva TrdvTa TrepteAoinres, Ti]v oLKeiav Xltt6vts
265 (fivaLV TTLbi^(j)iXV /u.aAt(rra ixev ijixlv avTols, 7TLTa Kal

TOLS yyvT(XTa) yevet r^s TOLavrris p.d6bov Tre^pvKoaLV.
0EAI. 'Opem.
HE. OvKOVV t6t HV rip\6lXda TTOLr^TLKriV Ka\ KTrjTLKTJV
5 T\vr]v btaLpovixevoL;
0EAI. Nai.
HE. Kat rTjs Krrjrt/c^s iv 6r]pVTLKf] Kal ay^Dvia koX
iixTTopLKr] Kai TLaLV V TOLOVTOLS etbeaLV i(f)avT(x^6* fipLiv;
0EAI. riavv ixv ovv.

10 HE. Nw be y i-neLbri ixLixr]TL\a] TTpLikri(f)v avTov Teyvr],
br]Xov <us avTr]V Tr]v TTOLrjTLKqv bixa Statpereoi' Ttp(t)Tr]v.
b 7? ydp TTOv ixiixrjaLS TToir]ais rts iaTLV, ctStoAcoi' ixivTOL,
<paixV, dAA' ovK avrS^v K(xaT(i)V' 7} yap;

0EAI. riayraTrao-t ixev ovv.
HE. rioirjrtK^s 8^ irp&Tov bv 4<rT(i) piepr].
5 0EAI. noi(o;
HE. To ixv delov, t6 8' b.v6p(aTTLVov.
d4 lêwStry T 5); om. W d? 8t 7*] 8r' W 63 o/kcioi']

fSioi' olKflav T a I tiTfiTo] ?TiTa 5i T B,1 iv aywvia W
a8 ^j/ ifitropiK^ T W b I fSoiAo' T b 4 ^<rT Suo Stobaeus
2;0I2TH2 265b
0EAI. OvTTcd ixcix6.6r]Ka,

HE. rioirjTiKTyy, t7rep fxii.vrifi6a to. Kar apxas kexêvra,
Traa-av (f)afjLV elvat bvvafxtv rJTis hv ahCa yCyvrjTat Tots fxi]
irpoTfpov ova-tv varepov yCyvio-dat. lo
0EAI. MefjLvriiJieda.
HE. ZS>a bri TrdvTa 6vr\Ta Ka\ brj Kal <pvTa, oa-a t ItA C
yrjs ^K a-TT(pp.aT(tiv Kat pt^Siv (pvetat Kal oaa
ev yfj ayj/vxâ
(rvvCaraTat (T(t>ft.aTa TrjKTo. Kat arqKTa, pS)V aXkov Ttvos rj
60v brjpi.tovpyovvTOS (priaofxev vcrrepov yCyveadat irpoTepov

ovK ovTa; ri rw twv TTokXS^v boyfxaTt Kal pripâTt yjp(>nx(.vot 5
0EAI. noi<j) rw;

HE. Tryv (pvatv avTct yevvav ctTTo Ttvos alrCas avTOfxdTrfs
Kal avv btavoCas ûovcrj}?, 17 juera Ao'you re Kal irTtaTrnxris
êCas aTTo deov ytyvofxivris;

0EAI. 'Eyoj fuv ta-oos bta Tr]v rjKtKCav TToXXaKts ap(f)6- d
Tcpa fxeTabo^dCd)' vvv fxifv ^XiiToov ets o-e koll virokafxâvoiv
oUa-6aC o-e Kard ye debv avTct yCyva-6at, ravTr] Kal avTos
vevofitKa.-
HE. KaXws ye, 5) QeaCTrfTe. Ka\ et fxev ye' o-e rjyovfxeda 5
Tav cts Tov eTretr' <(ay)> xpovov akkois ttcos boâôvToov etvat,
vvv av rw koyio juera Tretôus dvayKaCas iTT^xetpovfxev iTOteXv
Ofxokoyelv iTretbi] b4 arov KaTapLavOdvco rrfv (f^vatv, ort Kal
avev tS)v iTap r]fxS)V k6y(DV avrr] iTpâetcrtv e^' OLTTep vvv e
ekKeadat (f)^s, idao)- \p6vos yap Ik iTeptTTov yCyvotr dv.
dkka 6r]aoL> to. pLev (f)vaet k^yofxeva iTOtetadat deCî riyvr],
TOL 8' eK TovTo)v vtt' dv6p(<07TO)v avvtardfxeva dvdpooTTCvrf,
Kal KaTct TOVTOV br] tov kdyov bvo TTOtrfTtKrjs yevr], t6 fxev 5
dv6p(i>7Ttvov etvat, to 8e êtoy.
b 1 1 fiffiddTfKa Stobaeus c i 5^ koI Stobaeus om. B T W :
C 2 tK yrjs 4v yp Stobaeus c 3 ti/cto koI &TiKTa B C 5 t^ twv]

Twv Stobaeus Koi pr}fj.aTi om. Stobaeus c 6 iroicfi T(f Hermann :
icoicf T<p B T woirjTiau Stobaeus noi(f!; EE.

: : T<j5 vulg. d2 fii]!/
b: /xr} BT: fj.ev Stobaeus ds 7 om. W Stobaeus d^ 76
om. Stobaeus d6 &;/addidi 5o|a<r({^T()v Baumann ei auT)}
W : avTTi B avrri T
: : out^ Stobaeus airep] & Stobaeus
265 e nAATilNOS
0EAI. 'Op0&s.
EE. TefMve brf bvoiv ovaaiv bCxa kKaripav aZOis.
0EAI. nws/
266 HE. OloV TOT^ fxkv KUTa 'n\6.T0S Tip.VOiV TT]V 7T0lT]TlKriV
TTaaav, vvv bi av xara fxrJKos.
0EAI. Tcr/xrjo-ao).
EE. Terrapa p.r]v avrrjs ovtcd tcl 'navTa p.pT] yiyviTai,
6 bvo fikv Ta TTpbs r]p.&v, avdp(aTri.a, bvo 8' av to. Trpbs Oidv,
Oiia.
0EAI. Nar.
EE. Ta bi y us kT^pm av bir]pr]pAva, pApos pifv ev
a<p' kKUTepas Trjs p.pibos avTOiroi.rjTLKov, toj 8* vTrokoLiTOi
10 (Txêbbv pAkLCTT hv XeyoLadr^v e^8a)Ao7rouK(o' koI KaTo. raura

8^ 7Td\LV T] TTOLr]TLKr] bL)(r] bLaLpcLTai.
b 0EAI. Aeye ottt] kKaT^pa avdLs.

SE. 'H/xeis p.iv ttov koX ToXKa ôJa koi e^ Stv tcl
TTecjiVKOT ia-TLV, TTvp Kal vbcop Kal TCL TovTMV db\(f)A, deov
yevvrjixaTa TTavTa X(rp.ev avra diTLpyaa-ij.eva iKaara' rj ttoSs;
5 0EAI. OvTios.
EE. Tovrtoy 8e ye eKaorwy et8a)Aa dAA.' ovk avTo,
TTapiiTeTaL, baLfxovL(i Kal raura /u.Tj^âznJ yeyovoTa.

0EAI. noia;
EE. Td re ev roi? vttvols kol oaa fieO^ r]fx4pav (pavrdcT-
10 /xara avTo^vrf KeycTaL, crKLd fxev orav iv T(o TTvpl aKOTos
C iyyCyvrfTaL, bLTTkovv 8e rfVLK dv (f)(as oixetoV re Kal oAAoVpioy

Trepi Ta \ap.TTpd kol Aeia eis ev a~vv\d6v Trjs efxiTpocrOev
eldidvLas oi//ê(os evavTiav ala6rf(TLV TTapiyov etbos diTepyd-

(rfTaL.
5 0EAI. Avo ydp ovv eoTi TavTa Oeias (pya. TTOLrfceuiS,
avTo re Kal to iTapaKoX.ov6ovv eiScoAoy eKaoTO).
e 8 avdii] avToiis T sed On in marg. a 4 rck Tavra T irovTa ; W :
Ta B a8 a5] Suo B ag o5 rb KOifjnK^v TW

a 10 /uo-
Aktto rotn. tiv^ B b 1 3jrj;] Siroi B T biroi': W
iKarfpa B
W
b 9 <pd.(r/JiaT' C I V"< ôm. &i') T C 3 Tapavx^y T
;
20*I2TH2 266C
EE. Ti 8e Ti]v rjixerepav Tiyyr]v; ap* ovk airn^v fj.v
oIkiov olKoboixi.Kr\ <pri(rofjLv TTOtelv, ypa(f)LKf] be tlv' kTipav,
oXov ovap av6p(t>Tnvov ^ypriyopocnv a.TTi.pya(Tp.i^vr]v
0EAI. Ylavv ]ikv ovv. d

HE. OvKovv KoX Ta\A.a ovto) KaTO, bvo Snra ^pyct
Tr]S r]p.Tpas av Trotr/riKT/j Trpdêcos, t6 fxev avTO, (âfiiv,

[avTovpyiKi]], To 8e etScoAoi' [ctSojAoTrottK?/].
0EAI. Nuy fxaXXov îxadov, Kal TiOrifxi bvo 8txrJ TTOtT/rtK^s 5

ei8ef deCav pikv Kal dvdp(oTTLvrjv jcara OaTepov T]XT]]xa, KaTo. be
OaTcpov To pikv avT(av ov, to be ojxoLcofxdToov tlvQv yivvr]]xa.
SE. T^s Toivvv lb(i>\ovpyLKr]s dvafxvqcrO&fxa} ort to fxkv
eiKacTTLKOv, t6 be (f)avTacrTLK6v efxeWev etfai yivos, ct t6
\ffvbos ovTUiS ov \{/vbos Kal Twv ovTOiV iV TL (paviCr] 7T({)vk6s, e
0EAI. "Uv ydp ovv.
SE. OvKovv ((f^dvrj re Kat 8ta raura br] KaTapL6]xr]cro]XV
avTui vvv dvajx(f)L(r(3riD]T(os ei8r/ bvo;
0EAI. Nai'. 5
SE. To TOLVVV (fâvTacTTLKOv avdLS bLopCQiafxev bixa. 267
0EAI. Ufi;
SE. To ]x\v bC 6pydv(i)v yLyvofxevov, t6 6e airrov
TrapiyovTos kavT^v opyavov tov ttolovvtos t6 (f)dvTa(T]xa.
0EAI. Uo)s (f)iis; 5
SE. "Oray otfiat t6 (r6v (ryji^xd tls rw kavTOV yjxoixevos
(r(j)]xaTL TTpocropLOLOV 7; (fxovrjv (fxovr] (paLV(r6aL iTOLrj, ]XL]xr]crLS
TovTo Tr]s (f>avTa(rTLKr]s /xdAio-ra KeKAr/rai ttov.
0EAI. Nai'.
SE. Mt/xrjrtKoi' 8r/ tovto avTrjs irpocreLTTovTes dTTOveLjxco- 10
ix6a- To b aAAo Trdv d(f)0)]Xv ]xaXaKLcr6VTs Kal TtapivT^s
Tp(a (rvvayaylv re ets v Kal iTpiTTOVcrav iTa)W]xiav b
d77o8owai TLv* avT(o.
d2 jcaTo] Kcd To B d4 avTovpyLK-fi et mox elSaiKowottKTi secl.

Apelt d6 6eiav . .. avdpcinrivriv Heindorf: Oda . . . avdpiciriyr}
B : 6(ia . . . avBpaixivri T 64 outw] outî B T a 10 aTToveifj.w-
fjifda W : avovei/x6fifda BT
267 b nAATflNOS
0EAI. Nfz/c/xô-ô), t6 bk fJL(6L(rd(a.
HE. Kai fxr]v Koi TovTo Irt bnrKovv, S) (aCrrjTf, &îov
5 fjyeLa-dai.' bi h 8c, (TKOTrct.
0EAI. Acyc.
HE. TcDy y.i}ioviJ.iva)V ol fxkv elboTfs t fiifjLovvTat toCto
TrpdTTovcnv, ol d' ovk eiboTes. KaiToi Tiva /xei^co biaCpfaiv
hyvuxrCas re koL yvdcrecos OiâojXfv;
lo 0EAI. OvbifiCav.
HE. OvKovv t6 yc apri KeyO^v dboTcov ^v p.Cp.r]fxa; to
yap (Tov (TXVH-^ '^^'- ^^ yi,yv(a(TK(ov &v tls /ixi/x7jo"aiTO.
C 0EAI. nws b' ov;

HE. Ti 8e bLKaLO(rvvqs t6 (rxrjfJLa kol SA.tjs (rvWi^^brfv
&pTrjs; ap ovk ayvoovvTis pAv, bo^(3.(ovTs b4 trt], <r<f>6bpa
eTTLxeLpovcTLV TToWol t6 boKOVv (r<f>C(rLV TovTo Q)s ivov airroLs

5 irpoOvp.iL^rOaL (fâCvfcrOaL ttoiciv, ori /xaAiora (pyoLS rc Kal
XoyOLS p.LpLOVp.VOL;
0EAI. Kal Trdw ye ttoX.XoC.

HE. M(av ovv irdvTes aTTOTvryxdvowri tov boK(lv (Tvai
bCKttLOL pLrjbapLois ovTfs; rj tovtov irav tovvclvtCov;
lo 0EAI. nai;.
d HE. Mt/x7jr^y brf tovtov ye fTcpov iK^Cvov XiKriov oXfiai,
t6v dyvoovvTa tov yiyv<a(rK0VT0S>

0EAI. Nar.
HE. no'^cy ovv ovofJM kKaT4p<a tls avTwv A7/\|^crai
5 TTpiiTov; rf brjKov brj xaAcTToi' ov, 8iort Tijs tcjv yfvdv Kar
(Lbr] 8tatpe'o"ecos TraAata rts, (i>s cotKcr, dpyCa tols p.TTpo(rd(v
KOL d(rvvvovs iraprjv, cSotc /xr/8' CTrtxciperv pLrjbfva Statpeio-âf
Kad6 bif tQv ovofxdTcov dvdyKrj /xt; aôbpa evTTopdv. ofuas

bi, Khv d ToXfxrfpoTepov dprja-OaL, bLayv<aa-t}s (V(Ka rifv
e /x^y /xcra bo^rfs fxCfxrf(rLV boôfXLfxrfTLKrfv irpoatCTTaifxev, Tifv 8e
/xer' kiTKrTTfpLrfs LcrropLKrfv TLva fxCfxrfcrtv.
b4 Kol alterum om. W C3 i6ânti W Trf\ 8^ W

d6 d.pyla Madvig ahia B T : d8 KaQh^ Kaff 6lW
204>I2TH2 267e
0EAI. "EoTO).
HE. QaT^p(o Toiwv xfxqaTeov 6 yap (ro(f)icrTr}S ovk iv
Toi? elboaiv ^v dAA' iv Tols pLL[xoviJ.ivoi,s bi]. 5
0EAI. Kal fjiaXa.

HE. Tbv 8oo/j,tfi?jr^y brj crKOTrtopicOa coa-Trep (r[br}pov,
(LT vyLi]s tre bLTrXoriv cr' c)(^(ov tlvo. ioTLV kv amQ).

0EAI. ^KOTlSifliV.
HE. "Eêi TOLVvv Kal îaXa (Tv\vriv. 6 \xkv yap (viÔrjs lo
avT(siv koTLV, ol6p.(VOs dbivaL TavTa a bo^dêL' t6 be 268

daTipov crxrjixa 6ta Tr]v ev rots Aoyot? KvXLvbrja-LV exet
TToXX-qv vTtoy\tiav koX (f)6(3ov a>s ayvoel TavTa h Trpbs tovs
aWovs 0)9 elbojs ecrxrj/xdricrrai.
0EAI. Uavv pLV ovv iOTLV kKttTcpov yivos S)V fXprjKas. 5

HE. OvKovv Tov [xkv aTTX.ovv fJiLiJ.r]Triv TLva, tov be
elpojVLKOv ixL]j.r]Tr]v Orjaojxev;
0EAI. EiKos yovv.

HE. Tovrou 8' av to yivos kv bvo ^5)\xev; i]
0EAI. "Opa (Tv. lo
HE. SkottcI), fcat [xoL Strro) KaTa(f)aiva-66v tlvc tov b

fxei' br]fxocriq re Kat [laKpols Adyots Trpbs ttAt/^tj bvvaTov
lp(avVa6aL KadopGj, tov b\ Ibiq re xat ^payeaL Adyots
avayKa.ôvTa tov TTpocrbLa\ey6[XVOV evavTLoXoyelv avrov
avT(a. 5
0EAI. Aeyets 6p66TaTa.

HE. TiW ovv aTTOcfiaLvâfxeOa tov [xaKpoXoyiaTepov flvai;
mTfpa TToX.LTLKbv br][xokoyLK6v; 1]
0EAI. Ar][xoKoyLK6v.
HE. Tt bc Tov (Tepov ipov[Xv; cro(^bv ao(f)LaTLK6v; 1] lo
0EAI. Td pl4v ttov ao(f)bv abvvaTov, iTTeiiTep ovk 6t8dra

avrbv de[xev /xt/xrjr?/? 8' o)V tov ao(f)ov brjXov otl TTapu)- C
e8 f t' om. T a5 iKartpov yivos Apelt (Karfpov * yivov

:
{eKaTfpovs yfvovs Vat) B : iKarepov yevovs T eKdrepov yevos Madvig

W
:
b I 5jtt(1>] ^mhv T b 7 Tiyo] Ti b 1 1 ri Stephanus :

Tbj^BT
268c nAATQNOS 20*I2TH2
irvfjLiov avrou ri X^x/rerai, Koi a\ebov ijbr] ii(fia6r)Ka ori
TovTov bel TTpoa-enrflv aXrjdtos avrov CKiTvov rbv TtavTaTtaxru;
ovTOiS a-o(f>i(rrriv.
5 HE. OvKovv avvbiâ-otiev avrov, KadaTTfp ifiirpoa-dev,
Tovvofia (ru/xirAeârrcs avo T\.evrrjs ear* dLpxjqv;
0EAI. riavv p.V ovv.
HE. To brj TTJs ivajrruyjTOiokoyiKrjs (IpôvLKOv fjUpovs

T^s boâariKrjs /xi/irTTtKoy, tov (jâvTaariKov yevovs cltto ttjs
d fHbciyXoTrouKrjs ov 6(lov dAX' av^poiiriKov Trjs TTOiiqaecos
iufxopuTfjJvov V \6yois t6 6avpMTOTTOUKbv p.6piov, " TOVTrjS
TTJs yeveas t Kal atfiaTos " bs av <pfj Tbv ovtojs a-cxfjuTTTfv
ttvai, TaXrfdicfraTa, ws loiKiv, kpii,
5 0EAI. Y\avTa~aaî fikv ovv.
C 3 rhr] rhVf C 8 ri SchleJennacher : rhp B T da 0av

fuervwouKhp : W
$aufieurroirotriKhi' B dwaiiairromushp T
:
^
<^
nOAITIKOS
20KPATH2 GEOAnPOS SEN02

212KPATH2 O NEIITEP02
212. 'H TToXXriv xapiv o^peiXcti (rot r^s QeairqTov yvuipi- a

(rtojs, Zi 0eo8cope, ojua /cai Tr,s tov îvov.
0EO. Tdxa 8e [ye], da 2()Kpare?, o^tA.7ô-ets Tavrr]?
TpLTikacrCav' TTibav tov re TroAtriKW aiiepyatruiVTai croi
Koi Tov ^tAoVoôr. 5
212. Eiev ovro) roirro, cb ^tAe 0eo'8a)pe, ^ri(Top.^v
aKTjKooTes etiâi roO 77ept Aoyio-/xovs Kai to. yewfierptKa

Kparicrroi;;
0EO. n&)s, S 2(riKpaTes; b

212. Twi; avbpav eKaarov devTOS ttjs Xa-qs d^tas, o% Trj
Ttftj) TrAe'oy dAA^/Ao);' acfxaTaa-iv i] Kard r?jy avakoyiav ri]v
TTJs vpLTepas re'xi^?.
0EO. Ew ye y?) rdv T]]i4Tepov 6i.6v, S '2(i)KpaTs, rbv 5

'Afxfjuiiva, Kal biKaiois, Kai Trdiw fxiv ovv [ivrnxovLKUts eTre'-
TiKri^ds ixoL To TTepl tovs koyLa]iGvs apMprqfia. Kal ae piev

dvTl TOVTUiv ets aJî? jieTeLfXL' av 8' t][uv, w ê'iê, fjL-qbaixois
dT:oKd]xi]s xapLôfxevos, dAA' ($r]s, etre rdi' TroAtrtKoi' dvbpa

TipoTipov eire tov (^LK6ao(\)Ov TrpoaLprf, -jrpoeAd/xeros 8te'êAê. C
as 76 om. B: supra versum T a? toO] rot T b2 devTOS

Heindorf : eeVres BT b^ aWi\wv om. B
357 c nAAXaNOS
HE. TavT, S) edScope, trot.rfriov' iTrfCirep &Tra^ yt
(yK(xeipTJKafX(v, [koI] ovk &'jrocrTaTeov irplv hv avr&v Trpos
TO TcAos ^Kda)fj.v. d.Xka yap nepl cain^rou Tovbc ri
5 XPV V"^ M;
0EO. Tov Ttipi;
HE. îavaixaxxTUip.fv avrov p.(Ta\a^6vT(^ avTov tov

(rvyyvp.va<TTi]v Tovhe '2i0iKpaTr\; rj ttws <rvp.l3ov\V(i,s;
0EO. KaOdiTfp fiTrey, p.(TaKdp.âvv viui yap ovt pqov
lo otcreTOV irdvTa ttovov dvaiTavopiivci).
d 2i2. Kal fiTjy KirSwcucTov, oi êve, apicfxa tto6(v (p.ol
avyy(V(iav ^xd-v TLvd. tov fxiv y( ovv viMds KaTo. ttjv tov
TTpocrdoTTOv (f)vcnv ofxoLOv e/xoi (f)aLV(crdaL (f>aT(, tov 8' r)p.LV r)
258 KkT]crLS 6p.<avvp.os ov(ra Kal 7} iTp6(rpr](TLS TTapiyjETai TLva

olK(L6Tr]Ta. b(l br] rovs ye (rvyy(V(ls ^pJds d(\ TTpoOvp.(j)s
8ta \6y(i)v dvayvti)pL^(LV. catTi/ra) p.(V ovv avrds t( (tvv-
cfteiâx^^^ ^'^ \6yo)v Kal vvv dKrJKoa dTTOKpLVop.(vov, 2co-

6 Kpdrovs b( ovb(T(pa' bd b( (TK(yâcrdaL koll tovtov. (p.OL
p.(v ovv (ts avdLS, a-ol b( vvv dTTOKpLvicrdd)^^

HÊ. Tavr' (arai. u) Sw/c/oarc?, d/covcis brj SwKpdrovs;
NE. 212. Nai'.
HE. Svyxcopcis ovv ols A.eyct/
10 NE. 2i2. Udw pLv ovv.
b HE. Ov ra cra k(i)\v(lv (f)aiv(TaL, bd b( ta-ois (tl tjttov
rajiia SiaKcoAveii'. dAAa 8?; /xera tov (ro(f)L(TTi]v dvayKalov, cls

ip.0L âtrcrai, TToAmKov [roi' ar8pa] Sta^Tjrciv y&iy KaiîAcyc
tt6t(pov tS)v (TTLa-Tr]fx6v(t)v TLv^ 1JIUV Kal TovTOV d(Tov, t] Trws;
5 NE. 2i2. OiJrcos.
HE. Tas c7rt(rT7//xas dpa îaAjjTrrcor, w^nrep rjVLKa tov

TTp^T^pOV ((TK01T0Vp.(V;
NE. 212. Tcxx' dv.
C3Kolom.B aa-ye^TfBT a 4 iiroKpifa^/^ôv B b i rw-

A?v T b3 KoXiTiKhv rhv &vhpa B T (seci rhv ante iroAiTHfb' supra-
scr. t) : rb' iroKniKhv rhv HvSpa al. rhv livSpa seclusi rhv woKniKhv
: :
HvSpa Yulg.
nOAITIKOS 258b
SE. Ov fxev bi] Kara ravTov ye, aj '2(tiKpaTes, (f)aCv(TaC
jxOL Tixrjâ. 10
NE. 212. Ti ixriv;
SE. Kar' aXXo. C
NE. EX2. "EoiKev ye.
SE. T^y oi5y voX.LTi.Kriv aTpaiiov irfj ns ayeupTjcrei;
bei yap avTriv avevpeXv, Kal xoopls acfêkovTa^ aito tS)V
aWiov ibeav avTrj p.iav iiri.crcppaytcraa-OaL, Kal rais aAAai? 5

(KTpoTTaXs ly aAAo etSos kTitaTnirivaixivovi Traaas Tas
(TTLaTtipLas <t)? ovaas bvo etbri bLavoriOrjvai ttiv \frv)(riv rnxQv
xotTjcrat.
NE. 212. Tour' i]br] a-bv olixaL to epyov, S) êVe, dAA'

ovK kixov yiyveTaL, 10
SE. Aet ye ixriv, co SwKpares, avTo etmt Kai coV, oTav d

ep.(f)avs riplv yevriTaL.
NE. 212. KaAws etTres.
SE. 'Ap' ovi' ovK apLOixriTLKri /xey Kat rtre? TpaL TavTri
avyyeveis Tiyvai yf/LKal tG)V TTpdêuiv et(n, t6 8e yi^wrat 5

Tiapea-ypvTO fiovov;
NE. 2X2. "EoTty ovrco?.
SE. At oe ye Trepl TeKTovLK-qv av Kal avixTraa-av x^'-'
pqvpyiav Oio-nep iv rats TTpdêaLV kvova-av avix(f)VT0V ttiv
e~LcrTrip.riv KKTriVTaL, Kal crvvaTTOTeXovarL to. yLyvoixeva vtt e

avTwv (TcoixaTa TrpoTepov ovk ovTa.
NE. 212. Tt ix-qv;
SE. Tcwrry TOLWv crt>jot7rao"ag eTTtcrTj/xay bLaipei, rqv fxev

TTpaKTLKriv TTpog-eLTrcov^ Trip.3e ixovov yvaiaTiKqv.
NE. 212. 'EoTO) crot Tavd' w? jLtta? kitLCTTqixris r^y oAr;?

etS?/ 8vo.
SE. IloVepoi; ovv tov ttoXltlkov KaX âcTLXea Koi
bea-TTOTTiv Kal cr' OLKov6p.ov 6rja-op.v o)? kv irdvTa TavTa
b9 KOTtt] /col T c3 oiêupîrei] &j/ 6^/>^(rp B : &j/ *ip^(rei pr. T

c6 oiroo-oj T (sed a postea additum)
258 e nAkTI2N02
lo TTpoa-ayopevovTes, 7/ TocravTas Tfxyas avras eivai (f)<i^cv
oa-aiTep 6v6p.aTa ipp-qdri; imWov b4 /iot bevpo tiiov.

NE. 2f2. U^;
259 EE. Tr/Se. 1 Tw Tis TcSi; brfiwarievovroiv larpStv Xkovo^
(rvp.ôvX.veiv lbLu>Tevu)V avTos, Sp' ovk i,vayKaiov avTo)
TTpoa-ayopevecrOai Tovvofxa ttjs t^xvtjs Tavrbv oirep u> crr/i-
/SovAcvei;
5 NE. 2i2. Nai.
EE. Ti 8'; ooTi? jBaa-LXevovTL x<^po? aySpi Tra/saiiêry
8eivos IbKoTTjs wv avros, ap' ov <^7/o-o/iei' Ix^"^ avTov ttjv

e'nLa-Tr\p.r]v rjv ebeL tov ap^ôvTa axrrbv KeKTrja-daL;
NE. 212. (t>7/o-o/Aei;.

b EE. 'AAAa /xî; 17 ye ^rjdivov /3ao-tXe'a)s /3ao-iA.i(C77;
NE. 2X2. Nai'.
EE. TavTr]V be 6 KeKTrjfxevos ovk, avTe apyjav avTe
iStwTT/j u)v Tvyx&VT^, TT&VTUiS KaT^, yc rfiv Texyrjv avrrjv
5 /3ao-iAiKo9 6p66is TTpoa-pr^d-qa-eTaL;
NE. 2i2. AUaLov yovv.

HE. Kal fir]v oIkovohos ye Kal beoTrorqs TavTov.
NE. 2f2. Ti p.riv;
EE. Ti be; ixeydXrjs (^XW^ olKria-e<as fj a-fiiKpas av
10 TToXeois oyKos fx&v n irpbs dpxvv bLoCa-eTov;
NE. 2i2. Ovbev.
C EE. OvKovv, o vvvbr} bLea-KOTTOVfxeOa, (âvepbv u>s ^ttl-
aT-qp.r] /xia Trepi TravT' ô-ti TavTa' TavTr]v b^ ehe âcrLXLkrjv

eiTe TToAiTiK^y eiTe olKovop^LKrjv tls ovopidêL, fxr]bkv airr^
bLa(f)ep(ipie6a.
5 NE. 212. Tt ydp;

EE. 'AAAa pLrjv Tdbe ye br]\ov, m /Sao-tAevy Stto? X^P""'
icai (TVfxiravTL tw o-w/xaTt (TfXLKp^ aTTa els t6 KaTe^xctv ti]v
dpxh^ bvvaTaL iTpbs Tr]v Trjs ^XV^ crvvemv Kal pcLfxrfv.
a 3 ravrhv 8ir*p] ravr6virtp T b5 7rpo<Tpy\6ii<T(rat BT sed

suprascr. <Kyoptv t : KpoaayoptvO-fâtTai al. b 10 xi om. T
;
nOAITIKOS 259 c
NE. 2f2. ArjXov,

HE. T^9 6^ yvitia-TiKrjs jxaXXov rj ttjs xeLpoTexvtKrj? koI lol
okcos TrpaKTLKrjs /3ovAet tov /3a(rtAea olKeioTepov etvai; d X

m (f}U)[jLev 1
NE. Ti /xTji;;
HE. Tr]V apa TTokiTLKrjv Kal TroXtTtKov Kal (3a(Tt\tKr]v Kal

âa-tXtKov eis tovtov ws ev iTavTa raCra (rvvdi](rofXv
NE. 212. AÂoj;. 5
HE. OvKovv TTopevotfjted' av ^]S, d ixeTct TavTa ttjv
yv(ji(TTtKr]V btoptôi]ie6a;
NE. 20. Uavv ye.

HE. ripoVexe 8^) tw rouy h.v apa kv avTi] riva bia(f)vr]v
KaTavor]cr(i)fXv. 10
NE. 212. ^paê TToiav.
HE. Toiai^Se. KoytcrTtKr] ttov Tts r]]uv ^v Ti\VT]. e

NE. 2f2. Nat'.
HE. TSiv yv(i)crTtK(av ye ol]iat TTavTaiTacrt Te)(ySiv.
NE. 2X2. UG>s 8' ov;

HE. rvovoT^ 8j) AoytoTiKTj Tr]v ev Tots aptdiJLols bta^popav 5
fx&v Tt TTkeov epyov b(acroiJiev r] to. yv(i>cr6evTa Kplvat;

NE. 2X2. Tt nr]v;
HE. Kai yap ap\tTiKT(t)v ye ttcls ovk avTos epyaTtKos
dAA' kpyaTwv ap-)(jj)v.
NE. 212. Nai'. 10

HE. IlapexoVfiôs ye' ttov yvSxrtv dAA' ov yetpovpyiav.
NE. 212. OvT(j)s.
HE. AiKatcos 8^ ]ieTe\etv av XiyotTO rfjs yvo^crTtKrjs 260

(TTt(rTr]]ji.r]s.
NE. 212. ndyu ye.
HE. TovTO) 8e ye otftat TrpooT/Ket KpivavTi ju^ re'Ao9
d 3 /cal ante iroXiTWcbi' om. pr. T koI ante fia<n\iKhv om. pr. T
d 4 irdvTa TavTa T (sed add. signis transpositionis) d 9 5ta(î^j']
Sia0vy^v B T sed -y erasum in T e i ^v~\ ^ pr. T 65 S^]
5e B e6 /(p?yoi] Kpivonfv pr. T sed ^fv erasum et at suprascriptum
a 4 TOirry] TovTO T
26oa nAATHNOS
6 exei-v /UTjS' aTTrjXXdxOai., KaOdirep 6 Xoyia-rqs SnrriXXaKTO,
7Tpo(TTdTTLV 8e (KdcTTOLS TOiv ipyaTiJV To y Trp6a-(f)opov (as
&v direpydcTdiVTai to TTpo(rTayOiv.
NE. 212. 'OpeS>s.
EE. OvKovv yv(t)(TTiKaX fxkv aX re ToiavTai crvpiTra^rai Koi
lo oTToVai (TvveTTOVTai rf) KoyLaTiKrj, KpCa-ei b^ Kal iTTtrdêi
b bLa({)pTOV dWriKoLV tovt(o ro) ycVrj;
NE. 2a. (PaLvea-dov.

HE. 'Ap' ovv a-vpLTrdcrqs Trjs yvoicrrLKrjs (l rh fxkv ^ttl-
TaKTLKOV IXpOS, TO b^ KpLTLKOV btaLpOVpLeVOL TTpO(rLTTOLfXV,
5 ip.ix\(as av <f)alixV bL-ppfjadaL;
NE. 2i2. Kara ye r^y fixrjv boâv.

HE. 'AA.Aa /x?;y rois ye Koir>) ri TrpdrroiHriy oyaTnjroy
6}X0V0LV.
NE. 2X2. nws 8' ov;

lo HE. Tovrou tolvvv p.i\pL'nep h.v ovtoX Koiv<t)v&fiV, kaTeov
Td ye rwy aA\a)y bo^da-fxaTa âLpeLV.

NE. 212. Ti fxrfv;
C HE. 4>e'/)e 8^, tovtolv tolv TiyvaLV tjixlv tov /3a<nXiKoy

iv TTOTepci OeTcov; ap' kv r^ KpLTLKTJ, KaOdiTep tlvo, Oearriv,
7] fxaXkov TT]S (TTLTaKTLKrjs 6)s ovTa avTov Texyris Oiicrofxev,
bea-TToCovTd ye;
5 NE. 212. Yl(as yap ov fi.dWov;

HE. Trfv TTLTaKTLKr}v 8j) Tixyrfv ttoKlv av eir} OeaTeov
L TTrj bLa-TriKv. KaC fxoL boKel Tjjbd TTr}, KaOdiTep t} t5)V
KaiTrfKtav T\vri Trjs Tutv avTOTT(t)\u)V 8ici>pio-rai Texirqs, Kal

d To âcTLXLKov yivos olkV diTo Tov Tu)V KripvK(i)v yivovs
d(f)(t)pLadaL,
NE. 212. n&)?;

HE. Y\(t)\ridVTa TTov TTpoTcpov pya oAAorpia Trapa-
5 bexpfxevoL bevTepov ircoA.ouo-i -TraAiv oi (caTnjAoi.
b4 irpoatiirontv T: irpotrtiwufifv al. CI rairaiv rcuv BT

C3 aiirhv^ avrov T C 8 avroKwXwv B : avroir(i\i)v T
1
nOAITIKOS 26od
NE. 2fl. Hdvv jjikv ovv.
SE. OvKovv Kol To K-qpvKLKov ({)v\ov kTrtTayOivT aXKo-

Tpia vorjjxaTa itapaheyoii^vov avTo bevTepov eTTtrarTet ttoXlv
fTepoL^.
NE. 212. 'AA.rjê(rrara. lo
SE. TCovv; iis TavTov fXLôiJiV âa-LXLKrjv kpixrjvevTLKrj,
KeXeu(rrtK7/, pLavTLKrj, Kr^pvKLKrj, Kal TToAAat? cTepaLS tovtcov e

re^xiâty avyyevea-LV, at a-vp.TTaaaL t6 y litLTaTT(.LV \ova-Lv;
rj j3ov\L, KaOaTTcp i]Ka(piJ.v wvhri, /cat Tovvopia TTapeLKda-(o-
fxev, eiretS^ Kat oêSoz; dvu)wp.ov ov Tvyydv^L to tQv avT-

7TLTaKT(ov yivos, Kol TavTji TavTa bLX(ofxe6a, to fxev' rajy 5
âaLXidiv yevos els ttjv avTCTTLTaKTLKrjv OevTes, tov 5e aAAou

TTairrbs a/xeATjo-arre?, ovojxa eTepov avToXs TrapayoopricravTes
OeaOaL TLvd; tov yap dpyovTos iveKa rjfxlv rj ixidobos ^v
dAA.' ov)(\ Tov evavTLov. 261
NE. 20. Yidw fxev ovv.
SE. OvKOVV TTLbr] TOVTO fXTpL(iiS d(îaTrfKV d'n kKLV(tiV,
dXXoTpLOTrfTL bLopL(rdev TTpos olKeLOTrfTa, tovto avTO TroAty av
hLaLpelv dvayKalov, et rtya TOfxrjv tl exojuey viTeLKovaav ev 5
TovTia;
NE. 212. Udvv ye.
SE. Kai fxrjv (paLvofxeOa eyeLV dAA' eTTaKo\ov6(av avv-
TfXV.
NE. 212. Ufi; 10

SE. ndrras ottoo-ous dv dpyovTas hLavor]6Sifxev eiTLTdêL
TTpoaxpcop-^vovs dp' ovx evprjaofxev yV(T(as tlvos eveKa b

TTpOCTTdTTOVTaS ;
NE. 2X2. U&s 8' ov;
SE. Kat fxrfv Ta ye yLyvofxeva -ndvTa hixa bLoXaêlv ov
TTavTdTTacTL xaXeTTov. 5
NE. 2a. Ufi;
d7 4TriTax6iv raWSTpta BT d1 /xiôfifv T : /j.iâ)iu.ev B

e 3 ^l B 6 4 avTeiriTdKToov B a lo jrTj om. pr. T
b2 jrpoffTa.TTOvres T b 4 ye] re B T
PLATO, VOL, I. 29
a6ib nAATHNOS
HE. Ta fjiev &\frv\a avr&v ia-ri ttov avfnr6vTa>v, ra 5'
Hfixlfvxa.
NE. 212. Nar.

lo EE. TovToi,s Se ye avrols to tov yviaoTiKOv fUpos
^TriraKTUov 6v, (Ittp ôvk6p.i6a TifxviLV, Tffwvfiev.
NE. 212. KoTa tI;
EE. To fxfv ^TTi Tals tQ>v a\lrvxo)v yevâ-fciv avrov t6,t-
C Toirres, tu 8' iirl ^rats^ TtSi; ifi\{rvxov' koX Ttav ovTOis ijbr]
buuprjo-iTai, bL\a.
NE. 212. navTdiraa-i ye.

EE. To fiev Toivvv avT(av TTapaXiiroifKV, to V 6.va\6û)-
5 fJLV, avaX.aj36vTS 8^ pLepiadipeda els bvo t6 avp.T:av.

NE. 212. Aiyns 8' avToiy avaXrfTrriov ilvai Ti6T(pov;
EE. IldtrTajS' TTOV t6 TTfpl To. ^(ia (TTiTaKTLK^v. oii yap
brf t6 ye Trjs /3a(riAiK^s iTTLorrfprfs kari iTOTf tS)V 6.y^v\uiv
(TTLOTaTOVV, oloV ipXI-TfKTOVlK^V, &\ka yfVVaLOTfpOV, iv TOIS
d ^<pois Kal TTCpL avTCL Tavra ttjv bvvafuv del KfKTrffJuivov.
'
NE. 212. 'OpOcis.
EE. Trfv yt firfv t&v C^^^ yiveaLV cal Tpo<f>rfV r^r pJv
TLS hv tboL pLOVOTpO<f)iaV OVaaV, TTfV b^ KOLVJfV TU)V (V TOLS
5 dycAats dpfppdTOiv iiTLpi4\(Lav.
NE. 212. 'Op6&s.
EE. 'AAA,' ov prfv t6v ye ttoXitikoj; evprjaofiv lbL0Tp6(f>ov,
waiTep ôrfXATrfv ij TLva iTTTroKo/xor, dAA' iinTo^popîa t koI

ôvôp^ta fjJaKkov TTpoaeoLK^Ta.
Jo NE. 212. atycTa^ ye 8^ prfdiv vvv.
e EE. IToVepoi^ ovi' T^s (iooTpo<f>Las r^r rdij; <ry/u.'7rdAAa>i'
KOti/î; Tpo^rfv d,y\aLOTpo(f>iav rj K0LV0Tpo<f>LKrfv TLva 6vo-

fidCofJLCv;
NE. 212. 'Oir^Tfpov hv iv r^ Adyy avfiâivr].

5 EE. KoAws ye, aj 2wKpaTy k&v 8ta</)vAd^T;s rd /iJ)
b lo fiipovs vulg. b 13 T<{(r(rorry B T C t toTs aL om. B T :
d 4 Koiyiir'] KoiKJj B d 7 liiorp6<pov D tSi6rpoirot> B T

: 6 i T^^r]
TQT B ea iyofid(o/xfy B T 6yofti(a>fi,ty al.
:
nOAITIKOS 26ie
(rrovSaêiy eiri rois ovoixacnv, TTkovcnoiTcpoi ei? to yrjpas

ava(âvrj(rr} (ppovrjo-eois. vvv b^ tovto \iiv, KaOdiTep dia-
KeKevrj, TTOiriTiov' ti]v 8e dyekaioTpo(pLKr]V ap' kvvoi<i Trfj
Tis bCbviJiov dTTO(l)rivas to ^r]Tovp.evov iv bL7T\a(TL0i.(ri to. vvv 262

iv Toiy r]p.i(T(rLV ets tot^ TTOtTjtrci ^retcrâi;
NE. 212. Y[podv]xr](Top.aL. KaC ]xol boKel t&v jxev dvOpdTTOov
erepa rt? etrai, rwy 8' av OrjpCojv uAAtj Tpo(pr].
EE. HavTaTTacrL ye TTpodv]i6TaTa koll dvbpeioTaTa bi- 5
ripr]craL' /x^ ]xivT0L tovto ye ets aS^ts xara bvvaijt.LV iTdcrytiiiiev,
NE. 21i. To TTOLov;

HE. M^ (TfjiLKpbv ]x6piov V TTpo9 fxeydka Kal ttoXXo.
d(})aLp(ji]XV, ]xr]b etSoi? x.<^pts* oAAa ro ]xepos d]xa elbos b

e\eTOi. KaKkL(rTov ]xev ydp diTO t&v dkkcov eiiOvs 8tax<wptêtz;
ro (r]TOV]xevov, hv opO&s exjlt KaOdtTep okCyov (tv irpdTepov
olr]6els eyeLV Tr]v biaCpe^TLV eTTecnTevcras tov koyov, ibcov e7r'
dvOpooTTOvs TTOpev6]xevov' dkkd ydp, S> (f)Cke, keTTTovpyew ovk 5
d(r(pakes, bia fxea-oiv be dacjiaXia-Tepov levaL Te]xvovTas, Ka\
]xdkkov Ibeais dv tls tt po(rTvy\dvoi. tovto be bLaêpeL to

Trdv TTpos Tas ^Tjr^crets. C
NE. 2X2. n&)?, S êve, Xeyets Tomo;
HE. ITetpareW ert cracpea-Tepov ^paêty evvoCa, r^s cr-^?
(f)vcre(as, d> ^(aKpaTes. ev Tca ]xev ovv TTape(TTr]K6TL Ta vvv

8r;Xa)(rat ]xr]bev evbeoos dbvvaTov eiTLyeLprjTeov be tl Ka\ 5
a-]XLKp5t TTkeov avTO TTpoayayelv els to TTpdaOev cra(pr]veCas

eveKa.
NE. 2f2. noioy ovv br] ^pdêis bLaLpovfxevovs rjfxds ovk
6p6S)s dpTL bpdv;
HE. TotoVSe, 0101 et rt? Tdv6p(o7TLVov eTTiyeLpY]cras bCya 10
8teA.eo-0at yevos Staipot Kadd-nep ol TTokko^ t&v evddbe bia- d

ve]xova-L, to ]xev ÊkXrjVLKov ws kv diTO TTdvTonv d(})aLpovvTes
Xwpts, avp.TTacrL be rots aAAots yevecTLV, diTeCpoLS oScri Kat
e6 fls tJ] Ka\ eh Athenaeus a 1 SiirXaa 101(71] SiirXoffjots ^ B T

b4 otTjOels] oi-{i07]s B c 6 vpoffayaryui' T irp6<r6i T C 8 5);
om. T d3 ffi;' irS<ri B
29*
362 d nAATX2N02
afJifCKTOti KoX &(rvfi(f>(avoL9 Trpbi 6X\r)Xa, ^dpfBapov /xiA KXrj^rei
5 TrpocTfLTTovTes avTo hia TavTrjv tt]v fiCav KKjjaiv Kal yevos

^v airrb etvai iTpocrboK&a-iv' tj Tbv apidpLov ris av voixiôi.
KaT ilhTf) bvo biaipeiv fjLvpi,dba dTTOTffxvofxevoi diTb TTdvToov,

e 0)5 kv elbos dTT0\(opl^<av, koI roi \onT<a br] Trarri Oefxevos tv
ovofxa 8ia Tifv K\rj(rLV av Kal tovt dîol yevos ^KeCvov Xdtpls
^TCpov kv yCyv(rdaL. KoAAioi; 8e ttov Kal fjidWov KaT elbr}
Kal bCxO. bLatpOLT &V, d TOV fl^V dpLOfJibv dpTL(0 Ka\ TTpiTT<a
5 ris TffxvoL, To b^ av tG>v dvdp(aTTOiv yevos dppevL Kal 0Âct,

Au8oi/s 8^ r/ ^pvyai r) TLvas eTepovs TTpbs diTavTas TdTT(x>v
dTTOcryJiôL t6t, ffVLKa diTopol yivos &fJM Kal fxipos evpCa-Ketv
263 kKaTepov tS>v (ry^LO-QivTiav.
NE. 2X2. ÔpdoTaTa' dX\d ydp tovto avTo, Z> îve, trS^s
dv TLS yevos kol fxepos kvapyicmpov yvoCr\, s ov tovtov
icTTOV dAA' Tpov dX\ri\oLv;
5 HE. 'X2 /3e\rto-re dvbpo^v, ov (f>av\ov TTpoardTTfis, 2o5-
Kpares. Tffxds fx^v Kal vvv fxaKpoTepav tov bôvros dTTo

Tov TTpoTeOivTos \6yov iTTT\avrffxeda, av b^ Irt tt\ov rffxds
K\(VLS TT\avrf6rfvaL. vvv fxkv ovv, (jjaiTfp e^Kos, iiTavCo^fxev
b TTctAty ravTa bi ds avOLs KaTa axo\rfv KoddiTep IxvevovTes

fXiTLfxev. ov fxifv dX\d tovt6 ye av TTavTdiTaaLV (pv\aâL, fxrj
TTOTe TTap kfxov bd^rfs avTo ivapyQs bL(pLafxivov dKTfKoevai,
NE. 2X2. To TToZov;
5 SE. Et8os re Kat fxipos iTepov dWi]\(i>v etmt.

NE. 212. Ti fxifv;
S E. *X2s et8oy fxev oTav '/ tov, kol fxipos avTo dvayKalov
etyat rov iTpdyfxaTOs oTovmp dv etSos \eyTfTaL' fiipos b\
etSos ovbffxCa dvdyKrf. ravrr/ fxe ^ 'KetVr/ fjidWov, S> 2wK/?arcs,

10 ael (f>ddL \4yeLV.
NE. 2X2. TaCr' eorai.
ds
avrb secl. Stallbaum d6 ^] ^ / Heindorf 63 tv
yiyufffBai Stallbaum tyyiyvfirOat B T
: a 6 îaitpirfpav T
a 7 TDO TtffeVroj T b I Ixvtvontv D b 7 Stoi'] Srt ir
Schleiermacher b 9 dSos] *Xiovs B T 4) Ktirti B
nOAITIKOS 263C
HE. ^pd(Tov bri y.01 To [xera tovto. C

NE. 2X2. UoXov;
HE. To Trjs aTTOTTXavri(r0L)S oirodev rjixas bevp' ijyayev.
oi/xai pikv yap /uaAtora, oOcv epcorrjêis (tv Tr]v ayeXaLorpo-
(f)Cav oTTrj Statpereoy eiTrej /xaAa irpoOvfjiMS bv etrai {mojz; 5
yevr], t6 piev avdpdiTiLVOv, tT^pov h\ t5)V ak\(ov crvfnidvTOiv

drjpmv V.
NE. 2X2. 'Akr]6rj.
HE. Kat l/xotye 8^ tot e<j)dvr]s jJiepos a(f)aip(av rjye'Lcr6aL
KaraAtTretv to Xolttov av irdvTwv yevos ev, otl TTOLcn Tavrbv 10

eTToyo/ixaêti; ia-ês 6vopi.a, drjpCa KoXea-as. "
NE. 212. 'Hi; Kai TavTa ovtoos.
HE. To be ye, S irdvTdiV avbpeLOTaTe, Td\ av, et ttov
(pp6vLp.6v earC n Côv erepov, oTov boKel to twv yepdvcov,

q TL TOLOVTOV &XKo, h KaTct TavTO. lcrois bLOvofxdêL Ka6dTTep 5
Kat crv, yepdvovs piev ^v yevos dvTLTL6ev toXs aAAois C*ôls

Kal creiJLVvvov avTo eavTo, tcl be dkXa p.eTa t5>v dv^pioTroiv
(TvXXafBov els TavTO ovbev dXXo ttXi^v tadjs ^rjpCa TTpoaeCTTOi.

iTeLpa6G>p.ev ovv r)p.eis êvXaj3eXa-6aL iTdv6^ OTTOcra TOLavTa. e
NE. 2X2. n<Ss;
HE. M^ TTav To T&v C4^v yevos hLaLpoviievoi, tva rjTTOV
avTO. iTdayu)}xev.
'
NE. 2X2. 0^8ey yap bel. 5

HE. Kat ydp ovv Kal TOTe rnxapTavero ravrr].
NE. 2X2. Ti bri;
HE. T^j yrcooTiK^s ocrov eTTLraKTiKov rjixZv fxepos 7]V ttou
rov C(ooTpo(f)LKov yevovs, dyeXaCoiv ixrjv C^^cov.

' ^ ydp;
NE. 2X2. Nai. 10
HE. ALrfpr^ro roCvvv rjbr] Kal rdre avixiTav ro Côv rut 264
Ttâo-fa) KOt dypC(^. tcl p-ev ydp e\ovTa rL6aaevea6aL (f)vaLV
ijixepa TTpoaeCpr]TaL, ra be ixr] eôvra dypLa.
c9 T<$T*1 tovt' B d3 5 7! Xeye B d5 & secl. Heindorf

Stofo/ictêi BT : ZiovofiAôt t 69 /xVl '?*' ^
a64a nAATX2N0S
NE. 2f2. Ka\S>s.
5 HE. *Hi; 8e ye d-qpevonfv ^TnaTTJixr^v, iv tols fjnepots ^v

T Koi ioTiv, ^ttI Tols AycAatoty iirfv ^T/rr/Tca Op^fjLfxaaiv.
NE. Sfl. NaL

HE. M^ ToCwv biaip<tifxe0a &(mp t6t vpbs &TravTa
6.TTOJ3K4'âvTes, fitfb^ trniva-avTis, tva hr) Tayy yv<afjLda
b TTpos Tj} ttoAiti/ct). TTeTToCrfKe yap T/fxfis Kal vvv tTadelv t6

KaTo. TTiv irapoifjiCav TtdOos.
NE. 212. notor;

HE. Ovx rja-vxovs ev biatpovvTas rjWKevai ^pabvTpov.
5 NE. 212. Kai KakQs ye, îv, iTeTioCrjKe.
HE. TauT* loTa>. TTaXi.v S' ovv i$ o.p\r]s ttjv koivo-
Tpo(})tKj]v TreipdfjLcOa btaipelv ia-cos yap Kat tovto o ai;
TTpoOvfi^ btaT[paiv6fivos 6 \6yos avrds aot KdWiov firfvva-cu
KaC pot (f)paC.
10 NE. 212. notoy brf;

HE. To8e, l TUfOiV iToXXdKis dpa btaKrfKoas' ov yap brf
C TTpoaTv\ris y avTos olS' oti yiyovas Tats v tw NetXo)

Tiâo-ftais tG>v lydvoiv koX tQv V rais /Sao-iAiKais \Cpvats.
iv pLv yap Kppffvats Td\ h.v ?o-a)y lr]S r]a6rfp.vos.
NE. 212. riaru fikv ovv koX Tavra T^diapat KaK^lva

5 TTOWWV dKTfKOa.
HE. Kai prfv )(r]vo(3(tiTCas y Kal ypavo(3<t}TCas, l Kal
fir} TTiT\dvr]aat Trept TCt cTraAiKa ireSta, WTrvo-at yow

Kat TrtoTeveis eiiât.
NE. 212. Ti prfv;
d HE. Tou8' VKd Tot iTavTa qpârrfaa raura, fiioVt
Trjs Tu>v dy\aCoiV Tpo(})r]s eort fikv Iwbpov, lori bk kox

^rfpoâTtKdv.
NE. 212. "EoTt ydp ovv.
5 HE. 'Ap' ovv Kcti aot avvboKî Tavrrf biv btxdC^tv tijv
b 3 xo7oy om. pr. T b 6 8' oly'] Ci B in ras. b ix r^St tl

(sic) B tJ 5^ pi. T
: ds Sixiitiv] 8/x f^xK*^" * '" marg.
nOAITIKOS 264d
KOLVOTpo(f)iKriv eTrioTT^/xrjy, t^' c/caTepo) tovtchv to \xipos
avTTJs TTiVpL0VTa9 kKoxepov, To jxkv Tpov vypoTpo(()t,Kbv

ovopiaCovTas, to b' iTcpov ^poTpo(j)i.K6v;
NE. 2X2. 'E/xotye.
HE. Kal p.i]v KoX To IBaaiKiKov ovTais ov ^rjnljcroixev lo
oTTOTepas ecTT-i ttjs TexvrjS' h^X.ov [8?)] yap TravTi. e
NE. 2X2. n&)9 8' ov;
HE. Has pikv bi] t6 ye ^poTpo(f)iKov tt/s dyeAaiorpo^îa?
SieAoiT' Sv (j)v\ov.
NE. 2X2. ncSs; 5

HE. Tw TTTrjv!^ T Koi TTe^cS 8iopi(ra/Aeyoy.
NE. 2X2. 'AXTjêWaTa.

HE. Ti 8e'; to TroAiTtKoy ?} Trepi to Tre^bv ^TjTTjTeor; ^
otiK otei Kat Toy a^f^poviaraTov &>? cTros eiTreti' So^dfetr
ouTcos; lo
NE. 2X2. "Eycoye.
HE. Trjv 8e TT^CovofxiK-qv, KaOaTi^p apTL Tov apL6y.6v, 8et
TpLvofxevr]v bLâ cnTocpaLveLV.
NE. 2X2. Ar^/Aor.
HE. Kat p.i]v i(j)' 6 ye )Lte'poy uipfir]Kev ^fXLV 6 \6y05, eTr' 265
eKetvo 8vo Tizê KaOopav 0800 TTap.iva âCveTaL, Tr]v fxkv
6aTT(i), TTpos fxiya fxipos (TfXLKpbv bLaLpovfXvr]v, Ti]v 8e, oTtep
kv TO) 7rpo'o-êy kkiyopiev otl 8et fxecroTOfXLV ws jadAtoTa, toCt'

exovo-ay /iÂAor, fxaKpoT^pav ye /i7/i^. eêoTiv o5y oiTOTepav 5
av j3ov\r]6&fXV, Tavrqv TTopv6r]vaL.
NE. 2X2. Ti ê; afX(poTpas abvvaTov;

H E. A/xa y , cb davfxacrri' v fXpL ye /:x7/i' brjXov otl
bvvaT^v,
NE. 2X2. 'Ey /xepet tolwv y(i)y afX(f)OTpas alpovfxaL. b
HE. PaStoi', fiTeLbr] to koLTTOv (ipayv' KaT apxas fxi]v
Kal p.(Tov(rLV afxa Trjs TTopeCas xakeTTov av t^v ijfxlv to iTpâ--
ei Sijseclusi: post ^ctp transp. al. e8 ^ ire/)2 Heindorf : warirfp

BT e 12 ipri rhv Ast : &pTioy B T b2 fJLrjv] fi.ev oiv T
265b nAATilNOS
TayfjLa. vvv 8', iTTdbi] boKcT Tavrp, ttjv ixaKpoTepav TTpOTfpov
5 tii)pLV' viakifTTfpoi yap ovTes paov avTr}v TTopivaoixeda, tijv
b^ bt] biaipea-LV opa.
NE. I,iL Aeye.

EE. Ta ireâ rnxiv tQv rjpUpwv, oa-aiTep dyeXata, bir\prip.iva
(otX (f)va-L bCxo-
10 NE. 212. TCvl;
EE. Ty T&v /x^y Trjv yivea-iv 6.K(p<tiv cirat, tG)V be
Kpaa-(f)6pov.
C NE. 2i2. 4>au;crai.

EE. T^y br] iTfCov^fJi-i-i^v bieXdiV AiroSoy cKaTcpo) tw /xepci
Xoyo) -xjxifxevos. hv yap ovopidCeLV avTO, ôvX.r]6r\s, lorai o-oi
TTfpLTT^TlXfypAvOV pM.XXoV TOV bdoVTOS.
5 NE. 212. riwy owi' XP^ keyciv;

HE. *i28e* T^s ircôiô/xiK^S' ^Trio-TTj/xTjy 8^xa 8tatpeêfo-rj5
To p.6pLOV daTfpov eTTi Tw Kepaa-(})6p<f pL^peL t(o ttjs ayeXrjs
eTrtTCTaxât, to 8e iTepov IttX toj t^s dxe/xiToi;.
d NE. 2X2. TauT' Io-tco Tavrr] Aex^cWa* jrdrTcoy yap tKaro)?
8e87/\a)Tat.
SE. Kai prjv 6 ye /3ao-tXev? ^/uiy av KaTa<pavr]S otl

Ko\oj3bv 6.yekr]v tlvo. KepdTcav ro/xevei.
5 NE. 212. ITais yap ov 8^Xos;
EE. TavTrjv toCvvv KaTadpavaavTes to yLyvoficvov avroJ
ireLpdpieOa dTrobovvai.
NE. 212. Udw ye.
EE. UdTepov ovv /3ovAet toJ o^torw re kol t^ KaXovfx^v<a
lo /xwruxt 8taipetr avT7/y t) tt) KOLVoyovCq. Te Kot i^toyorta;

p.avddvLS ydp ttov.
NE. 2X2. T6 Trotor;

e E E. "Oti to pikv T<av tTnT<av Kal 6v<i)v TTe<f)VKev i^ dXA.i]Aa)y
yfvvdv.
b4 vpoTfpay BT C 7 Ktpo(p6p<f> B d 4 nya iytAij' T

Kcptircttv] iLKfpiroi T d. 6 ytyv6fi.(vov Cornarius : KivovfKvov BT
d 10 Tp] xjj B
nOAITIKOS 265 6
NE. S12. Nai.

HE. To bi ye Aoiirov Iri r^y Aetas ayiXr]s r&v rj[xep(av
afxiyes yivei Trpos aAArjAa. 5

NE. 2X2. na>s 6' oij;
HE. Ti 8'; 6 ttoXltlkos S.p' e7rt/u.eA.etay exftz' (f)aCvTaL

TTOTCpa KOLVoyevovs ^vcreajs ?/ rtvo? tStoyeyoCs;
NE. 212. ArjXov otl rijs ap.iLKTov.
HE. TavTTjy 8^ 8et Kadair^p tol eixTTpoa-div, ws iocKev, 10

^//as 8t)(a 8tacrre'AAeti'.
NE. 2X2. Aet yap oSi;.
HE. Kal p.7\v t6 ye C^ôv, ocrov rjpicpov kol ayeXalov, 266
(T\bov irXrfV y^voZv hvolv irav rjbrj KaTaKKpixdTL(TTaL. t6
yap tS>v KvvQiv ovk kiid^Lov KaTapLOfx^lv yivos &)s kv dyiXaioLS
dpep.p.a(TLV.
NE. 2X2. Ov ydp ovv. dXXd tlvl brj ro) bvo bLaLpovpiev; 5
HE. Q.LTTep KOL bLKaiov ye QeaLTrjTov re /cat o-e bLavip.LV,
eTretS^ Kai y(op.TpLas dTTT^crdov.
NE. 2X2. Toi;

HE. Ttj 8ta/xe'rp(i) 8^7rou Kai TToAty rfj r^s 8ta/ieV/30u
Sta/xeVpo). 10
NE. 2X2. ncSs et77es;
HE. H (f)V(TLS, Tjv To yevos rjpSiv tS)V dvOpdiTToov KeKTr]- b

rat, /iwy aAAco? ttcos ets Trfv TTopeCav TTi(f)VKv rj KadaTTfp r]
bLapLfTpos r) bvvdixL bCTTovs;

NE. 2X2. OvK dXX(os.
HE. Kai fir}v 7] ye tov Xolttov yevovs TrdXLV ecrri KaTa 5
bvvap.Lv av Tr]s ^/xerepa? bvvdp.OiS bLdp.tTpos, eiTrep 8voty ye'
COfrt TToboT.V b\s 7T(f)VKvla.
NE. 2^X2. Tl(as 8' oi^k ecrrt; xat br] Kal (r)(êbbv o /3oi;Aet
br]Xovv p.av6dv(a.
HE. ripos 8r) rovrots cTepov av tl Tav TTpbs yiX(DTa 10
e 4 A.etoy] /xtSs T a6 îrep] &<TV(p t a 7 Kol BT :
om. al.
; ;
266 c nAATQNOS
C (vboKtfj.r)(rdvT(ov av, S) I!.<aKpaTS, apa Kadopu^yiiv rjpXv yeyovos
kv Tols hiripr]yi,ivois
NE. 2X2. To TToHov;
HE. TdvdpciiTivov r}p.Siv dpLa yevos (rvv(iKri\os kox

5 (Tvvhibpap.r]KOi yivi r^ t5)V ovTOiV yevvai,OTdT(f Kal &p.a
vyepi(TTdT(^.
NE. 2i2. Kaôpo) koL fidX' droTrcos (rvixâtvov.
HE. T^ 8'; ovK tlKos tJorara d(f)LKvei(rdai to. jBpabvTaTa;
NE. 2X2. Nai, tovto yc.
lo HE. To'6c b ovK vvoovpLV, b>s Iri y\ouiTpos 6 âcri-
kvs (f)aCvTou fiera rrjs ayeXris (rvvhiad(av Ka\ oijvbpofJM
d iii:opVfxvos rw tG>v avbpStv av irpos tov evx^pv /3wi; dpi(TTa
yyvpLvaa-p.V(a
NE. 2X2. narraTrao-i /xey ovv.

HE. NCr ydp, 0) 2wKpares, iKlv6 i(m KaTa(f)av^s fJidWov
5 t6 pr]6V TOT V Trj TTpl TOV (TO(\)l(rTi]V (r]Tr](TU
NE. 2X2. T6 TToiov;
HE. "Ori Tjj rotaSe nd6b(o tG)V Aoycor ovre (Tp.voTpov

fidWov fj.kr](TV 7] firf, tov re afj.LKp6Tpov ovbv rfTCfiaK
irpo Tov pllCovos, dei 8e xa^' avTr]v iTepaCvei Td\r]6(TTaTov.
lo NE. 2X2. "EoiKej/.

HE. OvKow /xerd tovto, tva p.ri fj. <})6r]S ^ptonjo-os Tr]v
e ^pa\VTpav obov rJTLS t6t ^v ^ttI tov tov l3a(TLk4(i)S opov,
avros o-oi TTp6Tpov k6(D;
NE. 2X2. 2(/)o8/)a ye.
HE. Ae'yco 8j/ Seir t6t v6vs to Tre^pv t(o 8iiro5i TTpbs
5 ro TTpdiTovv yevos Starei/iai, Kari8o'yra 8e Tdv6p(i)TTLVov tl

fx6v(f r^ TTTT/vo) oT^retAT/xos TTfv bCiToba dykr]v irdAir rai
yffLk^ KOL r<j) TTTpO(f)VL TflVLV, TfXr]6L(Tr]S 8e av7T/s fcai
rdr' ?/8r/ r^s dv6po)iTOVOfXLKr]s br]k(t)6C(Tr]s Tcxvqs, (f)povTa

Tov TrokLTiKov kclI jSaorLkLKov olov rfvCo\ov ls avrqv Iv^rrq-
C4 i)fuv al. C 7 /loAa rb ttcbi B T C io t<{8 8i] t<{8 7- B :
rh 8* 7 Stallbaum
fort. d 1 1 toOto tvci] rovroiv 4 B fit ^dps
Stephanus e Ficino /*' ^Ôr/y B nffjL<pei)s T
: e 5 Ti om. B T
:
;
nOAITIK02 266e
a-avTa, TrapaZovvai ras rrjs TroAecoy rjvCas o>s otKetas kol lo

avT(i Tavrqs ovotjs ttjs iTnoTtjfirjs.
NE. 2X2. KaA.a)y /cai Kadairfpel XP^^^ d7re8a)/ca? fxoL tov 267
Ao'yor, irpocrOels T-i]V iKTpoTn]v olov tokov Kal avaTtkripcaa-as
avTov.
HE. $epe 5?/ Kal o-vyeipcofxer e7rai;eXôVres eTri ttjv apx>]V
p.expi- TTJs TeXevTrjs tov Xoyov tov ovopiaTOS Tr}s tov ttoX.i.ti.kov 5
Texvrjs.
NE. 212. Udw pikv ovv.
HE. Trjs yvitiO-TLKrjs toCvvv kT:L(TTr\p.r]s j]]ilv r]v Kar dpxas

fXepOS eTTLTaKTLKOV TOVTOV bc dTTLKa(rdeV TO p.6pL0V aVTfTTL-
TaKTLKOV ppt]6r]. Û>OTpO(f)LKr] 8e TrdkLV aVTeTTLTaKTLKrjS ov t6 b
cnLKpoTaTOV t5>v yevSiV dTrecrxCC^TO' Kal ^worpoc^tK^s elbos
dyeXaLOTpo^LKov, dye\aioTpo(f>LKOv 8' av TTeCovofXLKOv tov b^
TTeCovofXLKOv p.dKL(TTa diTeTefjLveTO Tex^r] ri^s dKepaTov (pv^recos
OpeiTTLKr]. TavTr]s 8' av to fxepos ovk ekarrov TpLirkovv 5
(TVfjLTTXeKeLV dvayKOLOV, dv els ev tls avTO ovofia crvvayayelv

povkr]dfj, yevecrecos d/xetKrou vofxevTLKifv eTTLcrTrffirfv Ttpocr-
ayopevoiv. to 8' dTro tovtov Tfxrffia, eTri TTOLfxvr] 8i7ro8i fxepos C

dvdpinTtovofXLKOv eri kei<f)6ev fxovov, tovt avro (mv rjbr] t6
CrjTr]6ev, dfxa /Sao-iXiKoi' TavT^v Kkr]6ev kclL TTokLTLKov.
NE. 2X2. riarrdTrao-t fxev ovv.
HE. 'Apd y', w 2()Kpares, dkr]d&s rjfXLV tovto KaddiTep 5
a-v vvv eLpr]Kas ovtcos eo-rt xat TreTrpayfxevov

NE. 2X2. To TTotoi' 87/;
HE. To TTavTaTTaaLV LKavSis elpijadaL t6 7Tp0Te6ev; rj
TOVT avT6 Kal fxdkLaTa r] ^VTrfaLS eAAetTret, t6 tov koyov

eiprjadaL fxev ttujs, ov fxr]v TravTaTTaaL ye Teke(iiS diTeLpydadaL; d
NE. 2X2. Uuis etTres;
HE. 'Eyo) vS)V TTeLpdaofxdi tovt avT6 6 bLavoovfxai vvv

eTL fxdkkov brjk&aaL.
a I airoSfSuKas T a9 avreiriraHTOP BT b5 rpnr\ov al.

Stallbaum b6 ^wiyeiv T b7 a,u.iKrov Boeckh : fiiKrov BT
yofi.fVTtKijv Heindorf : yOjueuTt/c^s BT Ca iri] tvi B
;
266 c nAATllNOS
C vboKi^r](rdvTCt>v av, o) ^(0KpaTS, apa KoJdoplafxev tjp.LV yeyovos
^v Tois bi.T}pr]p.4vot,s;
NE. 212. To TToXov;
HE. TavOpcoTTLVov r]p.S>v fi/xa yivos crvviiKriyos koL

5 <rvvh(.hpap.riKos yivn. t^ tS>v ovTOiV yVvaioT6,T<f koI &pxL
(vxfpcardTio.
NE. 212. KaOopd Koi fidX* AroTrtos avp.âLvov.
EE. Ti 6'; ovK i/cos voTara a(f)LKVfL<r6ai to. ^pahvraTa;
NE. 212. Nai, tovto ye.
lo EE. To6e 8c ovk vvoovp.(v, <as tl yckoLdTfpos 6 fia<rL-
\VS <l>a(vTv Koi <rvvbpopia
d TTTT0pVpV0S T<a TOiV dvbpS>V av TTpOS TOV fVXfpi] ^CoV <!ipL<TTa
yyv]xva(rpLV(p
NE. 2X2. narraTrao-i jxkv ovv.

EE. NCr ydp, oi> 2wjcpaTes, iKclvo ((ttl KaTa(f)av(s paXXov
5 t6 pr]6\v TOT kv Tjj TTfpl Tov (ro<f)LaTr]v ^rjnjcriL.
NE. 212. To mlov;

EE. "Otl Trj TOLqbe p.66b(a tS>v X6yo>v ovt (repivoT^pov
p.a\Xov ]iikr]a-v t) p.rj, t6v T (rpLLKp^Tcpov ovbfv rjTCp.aK
TTpO TOV p.iCoVOS, dL 6c Ka6^ avri]V TTpaCvL TdXr]d(TTaTOV.

lo NE. 212. "EoiKci/.
EE. OvKovv fJLTa TOVTO, tva fiT] p. 6r\s pu>n'](Tas n}v
e l3paxvTpav obbv rJTLs t6t ^v ^ttI tov tov /3ao'iA.â>9 opov,
aVT6s aOL 1Tp6TpOV \do>;
NE. 212. l(f>6bpa ye.
EE. Acyo) 8?; bciv t6t v6vs to ttQ>v tw SittoSi TTpOS
5 TO TTpdlT0VV yV0S SiarCl/iai, KaTlbdvTa b^ Tdv6pTTLV0V TL

pj6v<^ ry TTTqv^ avvLKr]\os ttjv bCiToba dyiktfv ttolXlv tw
yffLX^ KiXL TO) TTTpO<f>VL Tp.VLV, Tp.r]6L<Tr]S b avnjs KUL
t6t Tjbr] njs dv6po>iTovopLLKfjs br]Ko>6Ca-qs T\vr]s, (f>povTa
Tov ttoKltlkov koX ^cktlXlkov olov r]vCo\ov is ovr^y Iv^rrf]-
C4 ^^r' al.C 7 îoAa rh rus B T C lo t<<5 8i] r6St yt B :
fort. tJ7 StaUbaum

5f' d 1 1 toDto Iva] rovroiy ft B fit <p9^s
Stephanus e Ficino /*' (<l>9ris B fitfk<p6^s T
: 65 t6 om.
: BT
nOAlTIKOS 266e
cravTa, TrapaZovvai ras Trjs TroAecoy rjvias u>s olKias Ka\ lo
avT(a TavTTjs ovotjs ttjs Trio-nj/iTj?.

NE. 2X2. Ka\a)s Kal KadaTrepel XP^ôs aTTibcoKas fiOL tov 267
Xoyov, Trpoa-Oels ttjv eKTpoiniv olov tokov koa. avaTTkr]p(a(ras
avTov.
HE. epe 8?; Kal crvveCponiev kiraveXOovTes eirl rqv a.px>]v
iie\pi tTjs TcAevTT/s tov koyov tov ovojxaTos Trjs tov 'noXt.TLKOv 5
Texi^y.
NE. 2f2. Udw fjLev ovv.
HE. Trjs yvuxTTLKrjs tolvvv eirLcrTrjp.rjs fjfjuv r]v KaT apyas
fxepos eiTLTaKTLKov TOVTov 8e aTreLKaarOev to fxopLOV avTiiTL-
TaKTLKov epprfdr]. ^woTpoîKTj 8e iTdkLV avTeiTLTaKTLKr]s ov t6 b
apLLKpoTaTov tS>v yevuiv d-necryJ.QeTO' kol ((aoTpocf^LKrjs elbos
dykaLOTpo(f)LK6v, dykaLOTpo<})LKov 8' av iTeôvoiJLLKov' tov 8^

TTeCovoixLKov ]xdkL(rTa diTeTefxveTO Teyvr) Trjs dKepaTOV (f)vae(os
OpeTTTLKr]. TavTrjs 8' av to fxepos ovk ekarrov TpLTTkovv 5
(TVfXTTkeKeLV dvayKalov, dv els ev tls avTO ovofxa (Tvvayayelv

ôvkr]6f], yeveaeo)S dfxeUTOV vofxeVTLKr]v eTTLcrT-qfxrfv TTpocr-
ayopevujv. t6 8' aTTo tovtov Tfxrffxa, eiTl iTOLfxvrf hiTTohL fxepos C

dvdpoiiTovofXLK^v eTL keL(f)dev fxovov, tovt avTO ecTTLV ifbrf to
^r]Tr]6ev, afxa /Sao-iAtKor TavT^v Kkr]6ev Kal TTokLTLKOv.
NE. 212. Ilai^TaTraa-i p.ev ovv.
HE. Âpd y 0) 2wKpaTe?, dkr]6cjs
, rjpuv tovto KaddiTep 5
(Tv vvv etprfKas ovtcos e(rTl Kal TTeTTpayfxevov;
NE. 212. To TTOLov 8?;;

HE. To Trar^TaTrao-iy LKavSts elp7]cr6aL t6 TTporedev; rj
TOVT avT6 KoX fxdki(TTa rj ^qTr](TLS eAAetTret, t6 tov koyov

elpr](r6aL fxev Troj?, ov fxi]v TravTdTTacTL ye Tekeo)S diTeLpydcrâL; d
NE. 212. U(os eiTres;
HE. 'Eyo) rwy Tretpdo-o/uat tovt avTo 6 8taroo{5/Aai vvv

eTL fxdkXov brfk&craL.
a I airoSfSocKas T a9 avrciriraKTOV BT b5 rpnr\ov al.

Stallbaum b6 ^vpdyeiv T b7 a,u.iKrov Boeckh : (iiKrov BT
vofifvriKijv Heindorf : vo/xutik^s BT Ca fri] tvi B
a67d nAATilNOS
5 NE. 212. Aeyois &v.
HE. OvKOVV T<aV VOflVTlKS)V rjfuv TToWQv âVil(T(aV
apTL TfyvGiv ixCa Tt,s ^v fj TroAiriK^ Kal juas tivos dyeArjs
CTTi/xeAfta;
NE. 2Xi. NaC.

10 HE. Tavrqv bi ye SKwpiêy 6 Koyos ovx tTTTTOiv etvai. Tpo<f)bv
ovb' aKX(ov 6r}pC(i>v, dAA' avBpdTTHiV KoivoTpo(îKi]v (TTicrTrjnrjv.
NE. 212. OiJrco?.
e HE. To brj T&v vopuiuiv iTavT^tiV bi.<i.(f)opov Ka\ to tQv

â(TikioiV 6(a(T(i)p.ida.
NE. 212. To 170101;;
HE. Ef rts T(av aAAooy ro), T^yirqs &AAt;s ovop.a ixoiv,
5 Koivr\ TTJs dyeArjs (TVVTpo(pos (TvaC (f^rjai Kal TTpo^TTTOulrai.

NE. 212. USis <^j7s;
HE. OIoi' 01 ijXTTopoL Kal y(apyol Kal (riTovpyol TTdvTfs,
Kal TTpbs TovTOLS yvp.va(TTal Kal Tb tS>v laTpQv yivos, oTcrd^

OTL TOLS TTfpl TO. av6p(07nva VOp.(V(TLV, OVS TTOkLTLKOVS kKoXi-
268 (Tapicv, TTavTCLTTacrL rw Aoyo) 8ia/xdxoirr' &v ovtol crvp.TTavT(s,
b>s (T(f>LS TTjs Tpo(f>r}s iTTLp.(\ovvTaL ttjs avdpoiTrCvrjs, ov yuovov

aykaCo>v avdp(i>TTo>v akka koX ttjs tS>v ap)(0VT0>v avTS>v;
NE. 2i2. OvKovv 6pdS>s hv kiyoLcv;
5 HE. "lo-cos. Kal TOVTO fikv k'JTL(TKe^6y.i6a, robi bi l(rpifv,
OTL /SouKoAo) ye ovbels ap.(pLcr^r]Tria-iL iTfpl tovto>v ovbv6s,

dAA' airrbs Tijs dye'Ar/y Tpo(f>bs 6 (3ov(f>op^6s, airrbs iaTp6s,
aVTOS oloV Wfl(f>VTrjS KOi TTepl TOVS tQv yLyVOfUv(i>V TOKOVS
b Kai Aoêây p.6vos ^TrioTTy/iojy ttjs naLVTLKfjs. tl toCiwv
TratScds fcat /xovo"ifc^s ^0' o(tov avrov tcl 6pp.\j.aTa <f>vcrL
IJLTLkr}(f>V, OVK 6\koS KpCTTO>V TTapajlvd^LCrâL KOL KTjkStV

7TpavVLV, P.t6. T dpy&.VO>V KoX \f/LkS) rw (TT6p.aTL T1]V TTJS
5 aVTOV TToCp.Vr]S apL(TTa p.Ta\LpL^6p.VOS ]WV(TLK1]V. Kal bl] KOL
T&v &kko>v Tripi voyA(ji>v 6 avrbs Tpoiros. ^ yo.p;
4 T^ G : Tft T : rb B 65 (uvTpocfoj T wpotrxoiflrcu T

a4 \4yoifitu B a6 ofKpivfiTiTu T : iîpt^rfiriTUTcu vulg. b4 t]
yt vulg.
; ;
nOAITIKOS 268b
NE. 2f2. 'OpôVara.

HE. Ylcas ovv rjfXLV 6 X6yo9 6p66s (fâvelraL Ka\ d/cepato?
6 Trept Tov /3a(rtAea)9, orai' avrbv voixea Kal Tpoôv ayikqs C

av9pu>TTLvris 6uip.V jxovov kKKpivovT^s ixvpLuiv aX\.(i>v ap.(pLcr-
^r]TOVVTu>v
NE. 2X2. OvhaixZs.
HE. OvKOvv 6p65iS oXiyov îXTrpoa-dev e(f)o(3ridr]fXV vtto- 5
TTTeva-avTes ixrj XeyovTcs p.iv tl Tvy\avonxev cryj]p.a âcrLXLKov,
ov ixi]V aTTeLpyaaixevoL ye elp.ev tto) 5t aKpijSeias tov ttoXl-
TLKov, ecos av tovs iTepLKe^p.ivovs avTSt Kal Trjs crvvvop.rjs

avTCd avTLTTOLOVfxivovs TTepLekovTes Kal \(tipia-avTes air eKeivoov
Ka6apbv ]x6vov avrbv aTTO(pr]V(ap.ev lo
NE. 2X2. "Op66TaTa fxev ovv. d

HE. Touro Toivvv, u> '2(aKpaTS, r][XLV iTOLr^Teov, el ]xi]
fxek\oixev eiTl rai reAet Karato^Syai Tbv \6yov.

NE. 212. 'AAAa ]xr]v ovbapL&s tovt6 ye bpaareov.
HE. ITaAti' Toivvv e^ cAAtjs apxi]S beX Ka6^ eTepav obbv 5
7TOpev6i]vai TLva.
NE. 2X2. notW bri;
HE. '2xebbv TTaLbLCLV eyKepacrafxevovs' avxv(o yap fxepeL

bel fxeydXov p.v6ov TTpo^rxpifo-acrâL, Kal to Xolttov br], Ka6aTTep
ev Tols 7Tp6cr6ev, fxepos ael fxepovs a(f)aLpovfxevovs ît' aKpov 6
a(pLKveLO-6aL to Qr]Tovp.evov. ovkovv XPV*
NE. 2X2. ITain; fxev ovv.
HE. 'AAAa 8^ rw fxv6(o fxov Traw Trp^crex^ tov vovv,
KaâiTep ol iTalbes' TrdvTcos ov TroAAa eKcpevyeLs TratStas 5
hr].
NE. 2X2. Aeyots av.
HE. ^Hv Toivvv Kal eTL ecrTaL twv TraAat Xey6evTU)v

TToAAd re dAAa kcll 8?/ /cat to iTepl n]v 'Arpe'a>s re Kat
b8 T sed in marg. yp. ajcptPiis

aKfpatos C2 Ow/te] (pwfiev \ailg.
C7 B rjfj.ev T
ilix4v\ elfiev : c8 ffvvofirjs B d.3 fj.e\\ofj.ev
Ast fj.e\\oifiev B T
: d 9 5t)] Ssi B 65 iraiStasCampbell :
iratSias (sic) B T itaidias Stephanus ircwSeôs al.

: : e 9 5^ /col om. B
268 e nAAT12N02
lo Qvea-Tov X^x^^^^^^ ^/"^ (fâa-fxa. dK^Koay ydp ttov koI
aTTO^vr]iJ.ovevei.s 6 (ftatn yevecrdai t6t(,
NE. 2i2. To TTepl ttjs \pvcnjs d.pvbs Xcroiis (rqfjielov
(f^pdCfLS.
269 HE. Ovbapibis, aXXa to irepl ttjs /xera/SoX^s bvcrecos T
Kal avaTo\rjs ff\iov Kal T(av aWcov acTTpaiV, ois &pa o6ev /xev
8'
avaTeWeL vvv els tovtov TOTe tov tottov ibveTo, aveTeWe
eK Tov ivavTiov, t6t be brj pi.apTvpr\<Tas &pa 6 6ebs 'Arpci
5 p.eTeâXev avTo kin to vvv (ryfipLa.
NE. 2i2. Aeyerai yap ovv br] kolL tovto.

EE. Kai p.r]v av Ka\ tt^v ye âa-ikeCav ^v T^pê Kp6vos
TToW&v aKr]K6ap.ev.
b NE. 2X2. UKeicTTiov piev ovv.
HE. T^ 8e'; to tovs ep.TTpoa-6ev (pvea-dai yqyeveis koI pir}
e^ aX\rik(t>v yevvaardai,;
NE. 2i2. Kat tovto kv T<av TrdXou. kexdevToiv.
5 HE. TaSra Toiwv lori p.ev (rvp.iTavTa ^k Tavrov Tt&dovs,

KoX TTpbs TovTois ^Tepa p.vpia Ka\ TovTOiv Iri 6avp.aaT6Tepa,
bi.a be )(j)6vov TTkrjôs to. piev avT5>v aTTea-^rjKe, to. be biea-iTap-
peva eipT/rai x^P''^ eKaa-Ta dtT oAAÂcoi'. h V kariv TTacn
C TOVToi,s airioy to iraôs ov8ei? elprjKev, vvv be brf keKTeov
els yap rfjv tov âaikeoiis dTrdbet^LV iTpeyfreL pr]6iv.
NE. 212. KdAAior' eliTes, Ka\ keye p.r]bev ikkeiiTOiv.

HE. Âkovols dv. To yap TTav ro'8e tot^ pev avrbs o
5 6ebs (Tvp.TTobrjyei TTopev6p.evov koX (JvyKVKkel, Tore be dvrJKev,
oTav al TTepioboi tov iTpoarr]KOVTos avT(a fx^Tpov elkr](f>aia-iv
rjbr] xpdvov, Tb be TroAtv avT^pxiTov els TdvavTia iTepidyeTai,

d ((ôv ov KoX (f)p6vr]a-iv elkr]xbs iK tov crvvappoaavTos avrb
Kar dpxds. tovto bi avr^ Tb dvdiTaki.v ievai 8ta ro8' i^
avdyKr]s e]j.(f)VTov yiyove.
NE. 2i2. Aia ro iroioi; 8^;
a 7 l>i'] B 7j b 3 Aa\Âdi''J i.U,\wv pr. T 03 i\Ku-ro B

C4 îp] yb.p 5^ Demetrius Phalereus C5 iroptv6(i.tvos Eusebius
IvyKVKKol Eusebius d i ti\i\^s Eusebius
^^ nOAITIK02 26gd
HE. To KaTa TavTo. Ka\ ctxraTtJTOiS
^X^^^ ^^^ '^'^' TavTov 5
cTvaL TOLS iravTOiv êiorarois TTpoa~qKi fMovois, crdtixaTOS
8e (f)vcn,s ov TavTrjs Trjs Tdêuis. ov 8e ovpavov koX

KoapLov Tr(avofJiaKap.v, TroAAwy ixkv Kal \xaKapiu)V iiapa
Tov yevvqa-avTOS p.Ti\r]<pv, aTap ovv bi] K(K0iV(s)vr]Ki ye
fcat a(op.aTos' 66ev avT(a p.eTal3okfjs ap.oip(^ yiyveaOai hia e
TTavTos ahvvaTov, KaTO. bvvapiiv ye /XTJy ort p.aki(rTa kv rS
avT(a KaTo. TavTO. p.iav (fiopav KLveiTar 810 rqv avaKVKkr]cnv
(tkr^xêv, oTi a-[XLKpoTdTr]v r^s avTov KLvrjaeu>s TtapdWa^LV.
avTO 8e eairro aTp4(f)LV del (jêbbv ovhevl bvvaTov 7rX.r]v rai 5

rwv KLVov[xev(/}V av irdvToiv r]yov[XV(a' KLve^LV be rouro) tot
pev dXkdis, avdLS be evavTioos ov 6e]XLS. (k TrdvTOiV bi]
TovTOiV Tov KoapLov ]xr]T avTov \pr] (f)dvaL aTp(f)LV kavTov

dei, pr]T av okov del imo 60v aTpe(f)eadaL Sirrds kol ivavTias
TTepLayooyds, ]xr]T av bvo tlv 6(0) (f>povovvT kavrols ivavTia 270
aTp(f)LV avTOV, dAA' OTrep dpTL ipprjdr] Kal povov koLTTov,
TOT ixV VTT^ dkkr]s (rv]X7robr]yla6aL deias ahias, t6
Cv^
TtdXLV t:lkt(j)]XVov kcll ka]x^dvovTa d6avaaiav cirLaKevaaTrjv
TTapa Tov br]p.Lovpyov, tot 8' OTav dvedf], 8t' kavTOV av- 5
rdy lezâi, /card Kaipov d(f)6VTa tolovtov, (oaT dvdiraXLV
TtopVa6aL TroA.Ads' TtepLoboiv fxvpLdbas 8td bi] to fxiyLaTov
ov kolL iaoppoTTOiTaTov kirX ]XLKpoTdTov âlvov TTobbs UvaL.
NE. 211. 4>atWrat yovv brj koX fxdXa et/corcos Lpr]a6aL b
TTdvd' 6aa SteArjAuâs.
HE. AoyLad]XVOL br] (n)vvor]aoi]XV to irddos K tcjv vvv
kx6VT(t)V, O TTdvTOiV (f)afXV etvttL TO)V daVfXaaTOJV aLTLOV.
ecrrt ydp ovv 87) tovt avTo. 5
NE. 212. Td TTolov;
HE. To rrjy tov TTavTos (f)0pav tot fXV e^' d vvv

KUKAetrat (pepeadaL, tot 8' eTrt TdvavTia.
d6 flvai] (lyai itivrws Theodoretus d 7 &' 5e] Ka\ 5^? hv Theo-

doretus d8 ^t-ev] fiev ovv B d 9 yevvii(TavTos] ireTroi-qK^ros
Theodoretus e4 Sti] tj B 65 t^] t^ B a 5 kavrov
Eusebius tavrhv : BT ovtov'] eavTij/ B a 7 StJ Stallbaum :
Se BT bI Ka\ punctis notatum T

270 b nAATi2N0S
NE. 2i2. Um brj;
lo EE. Tavrrjv iijv fMCTaôXrjv rjyiZcrdai hil t5>v TttpX Thv

C ovpavbv yiyvopivoiv TpoiiCiV TiaaSiv iyai p,(.yi<TTr\v koL
TiXi(siTaTr]V TpoTTriv,
NE. 212. 'Eoi/ce yoCi'.

HE. Meyôra? Toiwv kox fXTal3o\as xpr} vop,iîv yi-
5 yvea-Oai totc rot? erros 7//xry oiKovaLV avTov.
NE. 212. Kat roiJro (Ikos.
HE. Mera/3oAas 8^ /ueyoAay Kal Trokkas Kal TravToias

avp.(f>popievas ap' ovk io-/xey Trjv T(av C<mi)V (})va-LV otl xaKe-
7r? dye'xerai;
10 NE. 2X2. U&s 8' ov;
HE. (Jiôpai Toiwv l^ &v6,yKr]s t6t itiyLaraL a-viifiai-
vovcTL Tuiv re aAAcoy C<â)i', koX br\ koll to tmv avOpcaTTOiV

d yivos oXiyov tl TrepLKeiTr^TaL' irepX 8e tovtovs SAAa re
Tra^Tj/xara iroAAa icai 6avp.aa-Ta koX KaLva a-vp.-nitrT^L, piiyLa--
Tov 8e ro8e Kat a-vvTT6pvov rfj roC irain-os avLKi^L t6t,

OTav fj TTJs vvv KaOeaTrjKvias ivavTia yiyvrjTaL Tpoirfi.
5 NE. 2X2. T6 Troioy;
HE. *Hv rjkLKiav ^Kamov eixe rSiV C^cjv, avrr] TrpQiTov

fikv iaTT] TrdvTOiV, Kal CTTavaaTO Trav oaov ^v dvr]Tov k-nX to
ypaLTpOV ibLV TT0pX)6p.V0V, fJLTa(3(!l\XoV b^ TTOXlV ilTL
e TovvavTiov oXov V(aTpov Kol aTTaX(aTpov i(f>VTO' Kal T(av
TTp(r^vTp(siv oX AeuKai Tpiês ip.\aivovTo, tuiv 8' av

fjikv
yVL(avT(tiv ai Trapeiai Aeaiyo/xerat TroAty eirt r^v irapeA-

ôi5o"av ojpav ^Kaa-Tov KaOiaraaav, Tdv 8e 7//3(orraji; to.
5 cr(op.aTa XaLv6fiva koll apLKp6Tpa KaO^ fjpepav kol vvKTa

KdaTr]v yLyv6fXva ttoXlv ets Tr]V tov Voyvovs 7rot86s (^xktlv
aTrr/et, Ka^d re ti]v ylrvyrfv /cat /cara r6 aSifia d(jiopoLovpiva'
To 8' errcuêi' rjbrj p.apaLv6p.va KOfjLLbfj to irdfiTTav ^(fia-
b9 8^] Schleiermacher
8' otf c i rpiitKV B c 2 t* Aio-
riiri\v T C 7 8J] 8/ yt Eusebius d 7 ^(Tttj] itrri B e 4 8i]
Tf vulg. e 5 (rfUKp6rfpa T #taO' iK(i(rri]v rjnfpav Kol vvKra T afi* :
flixfpav iKd(miv cal 'WTa signis transpositionis effecit t e 7 t om. T

nOAITIKOS 27oe
VLêro. t5>v 8' av jBtaiuis Tk(VTa)VT(t)V iv rw t6t XP^^^

To Tov vcKpov <T5)}xa To. avTCL TavTa iraa-xov naOi^p.aTa hia lo
Taxpvs ahr]kov kv oXLyais ^juepats hi^(^6eipT0. 271
NE. 211. reVeo-ts 8e 5t; ti? t6t ijv, m êVe, (4^^! i^c-^
Tiva Tp^TTOV (^ aXXrjXoiiv iyevvoiVTo;

HE. ArjXov, 0} SwK/jares, ori ro joiei' e^ aXXi^Xcov ovk T/y
ev r7/ t6t (Pv(Ti, yvv(op.Vov, t6 be yqyeves etvaC Trore 5
yivos Xexdev tovt rjv to fcar' kKeivov tov xpovov eK yrjs

irdXiv ava(rTpe(f)6p.evov, aTteyLvr]p.oveveTo he vtto t^v rjiieTe-
poiv Trpoy^voiV tG)V Trpwrcor, 01 reA.evr()o-rj p.ev Trj TrpoTepcL
TTepL(j)opa Tov e^rjs xp6vov eyeLTovovv, Trj(rbe be kut apxas b

e(f>vovTO' TOVT(x)V yap ovtol KrjpvKes eyevovd^ rjpiLV tG>v X^yoov,
o\ vvv VTTO TToXXu)v ovK 6p6a)S aTTLo-TOvvTaL. To ycLp evTevdev

o7p.ai xph (TvvvoeLV. eTT6p.evov yap eaTi rai tovs TTpea^vTas
771 Tr]v Tov TraiSos leVat (pixTLV, e/c T(av TeTeXevTrjK^Toov 5
av, KeLpev(t)V he ev yr\, it(xXlv efcei (TvvL(rTap.evovs kol ava-
j3Loo(TKopevovs, eTTe(r6aL Trj TpOTTrj (TvvavaKVKXovpLevr}s eU

TavavTLa Trjs yevecreoos, Kal yrjyevels hrj KaTo. tovtov tov
X6yov e^ avayKrjs (f)Vop.evovs, ovro)? exety Tovvop.a Kal tov C

A.oyoy, ocrovs iir] debs avTu^v eis aXXrjv p-olpav eK^pLLcrev.
NE. 2X2. Kop-Lhf] fxev ovv tovt6 ye e-rTeTaL tols cp.-
TTpocr6ev. aXXa hrj tov ^lov ov eirt Tr]s Kp6vov cf)fjs etvaL
hvvap.ea)s, iT^Tepov ev eKeivaLS ^v rats rpoTrats rj ev Tala-he; 5
Tr]v p.ev yap tG)v acTTpoov re Kat ?/Atou /xera/3oATjy hrjXov (as
ev eKaTepaLs (Tvp.TTLiTTeL rats rpoTrats yiyvea-âL.

HE. KaAcos T(o X6y<a crvp.'napr]KoXovdr]Kas. o 8' rjpov
nepl Tov TTavTa avT6p.aTa yiyvecdaL rots avdpcoTTOLS, r]KL(TTa d

Ti]s vvv eo-ri Kadea-Tr]Kvias (popas, oAA' ^v Kal tovto rrjs
ep.TTpoadev. t6t yap avTrjs TTpdTov Tr\s KVKXr]a-e(os r]px^v
e 10 ffufMa om. B 8ia t4\ovs T (in marg. yp. Sih rdxovs t)
a 2 SfSii Tj] 5 5' ^Tty B 56 tis Eusebius

: a 7 axefivrifiovfvc ro
5 B b 4 eirifxevov Stallbaum fxîJ-fvov B T : b7 firfffdai om. B
c I \6yov] Tp6irov Eusebius c2 fK6ffnT)(rf ex eW/ii<r fecit t
c 5 hvvafjLfus T sed in marg. hwaffrfias t

PLATO, VOL. I. 80
271 d nAATflNOS
^TTt/nfXov/bieros oAtjs 6 deos, &s 8' av Kora tottovs Tavrov tovto,
5 VTTO deHv apxovTUiv ttolvt rjv to, tov Koa-fwv fJ^pr] SiciAtj/x-
fxeva' Ka\ 8t/ Kal to. ^(aa jcara yivr] koI ay(Ka9 olov vofjLTJi ddot
bii\r}<f)a-av baCpLOves, airrdpKrfs (Is TrdvTa iKaaros ccdoTOis
e uiv oX^ avTos (Vp,ev, ware ovr &ypt.ov rjv ovbev ovre iWrj-
\(iiv iboiibai, tt6K([j.6i t ovk evijv ovbe a-Taa-is to TTapd-nav'
dXka 6^ oaa Trjs TOiavrrfs eori KaTaKoa-fxria-fcoi Tro/ifra,
[jLvpia hv elrj keyetv. t6 8' ovv tQ)V dvOputiTOJV \e)(dev

5 avTopidTOV Trepi (3iov bia t6 Toi.6vb cipj/rat. ^cos iv(fj,ev
avTovs avTbs eTrtoraroii', KaOdiTcp vvv dvdpuiiToi, ^ôv ov

Tpov OeioTepov, oAAa yevrj (fiavXoTfpa avT^v vofievovaf
vifJiovTos be ^Keivov TroAiretat re ovk ifo-av ovb^ KTTfaeis
272 yvvaiKQv Kal TTaiboiV eK yifs yap dve^maKovTO Trdrrcy,
ovbev yiefivrffievoi Tutv TTpdadev dXKd Ta fxev roiaCra diTTJv
TTdvTa, KapTTOvs bi d(f)d6vovs el\ov dird rc bevbpaiv koI

TToWrjs v\rfs dAArj?, ov\ vtt6 yempyias (fivofxevovs, dAA'
5 avTOfxdTrjs dvabibova-rfs Trjs yrjs. yvfjivol bi Kal dorpcorot
dvpav\ovvTes rd TroAAd evefiovTO' rd ydp tiov oipGiv ovtols
akvTTOv eKeKpaTO, fxaKaKas be cvvds ctxoi; dva(f)Vofxevrfs eK
b y^s TTdas d(fi96vov. t6v 8t; fiiov, w S&jjcparc?, aKodcis fxev
t6v TUiV cTri Kpdvov T6vbe 8' bv \6yos CTrt Atds ctyat, tov
vvvi, TTapuiV avrbs rfadrfa-ai' Kplvai 8' avTolv t6v evbaifjLOV-
ecTTepov dp dv Sdratd Te xat c^cA^crctas;
5 NE. 212. OvbafX(0S.
HE. BovAct brJTa ey(a croi Tp6iTov rtrd biaKpivo;
NE. 212. ridw fxev ovv.
HE. Kl fxev Toivvv ot Tp6îfxoi tov Kp6vov, iTapovcrrfs
avTols ovTOi TToAA^s <rxo\rfs Kat ûvdftccoj Trpos to fxrf fxovov
10 dvOpuiTTOis dAAd xat Qrfpiois 8td \6yitiV bvvaadax (rvyyiyve-
C o"ât, Karcx/)ci)yro toijtois (Tvp^Traaiv CTri (fn\oao(fiiav, /xcro
rc drfputiv Kal pieT d\\rf\(iiv 6fXL\ovvTes, koi Twvdavdfxevoi
3.4 Aj 8* a5 scripsi : u>s vvv BT: an wo-airrws 5' aZ ?CampbeIl
ds irivr Stallbaum
fiv : iri,vn;i BT 67 irtpuv al. Apelt
a 3 SfvSpwv] Spvuv vulg. ba tv] ws BT : tv its al.
nOAITIKOS 272 c
Trapa Trao-rjs ^vo-ecos ei tlvo. tls ibiav hvvayiiv txpvcra fjadcTo
Ti hi.6.(\>opov tQ>v aXkMV eis avvayvpfxbv (jtpovTâ-euis, iVKpiTov
OTL T(av vvv oi t6t ixvpiio TTpbs evbaifxoviav bi((j)pov' ei b 5
e/j.TTt/xTrAafxcroi (tCtcdv abrjv Kal ttot&v biektyovTO itpos (xXki]-
Xovs Koi To. 6r]pia [p.v6ovs] oXa 6?) koI to, vvv TTepl avT&v
kiyovTai, Ka\ tovto, ws ye KaTO. r)]v ]xi]v boâv aTT0(j)riva(r6at, d
Kal ixdX^ (VKpiTov. op.(as 8' ovv TavTa juey a(f)u>ixev, eu>s av
TjpXv pLr]vvTris tls iKavbs (}>avfj, Trorepcos ol TOTe Tas (ttl-
6v]XLas etxov Trepi re eTTLaTr]p.(ov Kal Tr]S twv XoyoDV xPft"S'

ov 8' (VKa Tbv p.v6ov TiyeLpafxev, tovto kfKTeov, tva Tb 5
fxeTCL TovTo eis to Trpo^rêv TTepaCvoiiixev. eireiS^ yap TTavToav
TOVTUiv yj)6vos kTeXe(i)6r] koX ixTaj3o\r]V e8ei yCyve(r6aL kol

br] Kal Tb yr]LVov i]bri ttclv avi]kodTO yevos, Tra^ras kKacrrqs e
TTJs -^XV^ ''"^^ yvi(Tis aiTobebo^KvCas, otra r^v e/caorr; TTpocr-
Ta-)(6\v TOcravTa eis yr]V cnTepfxaTa TT(rova-r]s, t6t br] tov

iravTbs 6 piev KVêpvqTTjs, olov TrqbaXCoov otaKos a(f)eixevos,
eis Tr]v avTov TTepLooTTr]V aTTearr], Tbv be bi] Koaixov iraXLV 5
aveaTpe(pev elpapixevr] re Kal a-vix(f)VTOS eiTL6vp.Ca. iravTes
ovv oi KttTa Tovs t6ttovs (TVvapyovTes rai p.eyCaT(o baCixovL
6eoC, yv6vTes rjbr] Tb ytyvîxevov, a(f)Ceaav av to. ixepr] tov

Koaixov rfjs avTS)V eiTLixeXeCas' b be ixeTaa-Tpe(f)6pLevos Kal 273
a-vixl3a\\o)V, apxrjs re Kal TeXevTrjs evavrCav 6pp.i]v 6pp.r]6eCs,
(reiapJbv ttoXvv ev eavT& ttolwv aXXr]v av (f)6opav C^^

TTovToCoov aTTr]pyaaaTo. ixeTo. be rairra TTpoeX66vTos iKavov
Xp6vov, 6opvl3o)v re Kal Tapaxvî vb^ iTav6p.evos kol twv 5
aeKrixQv yaXrivrjs eTTLXa^îxevos ets re Tbv eiood^Ta bp6ixov

Tbv eavTOv KaTaKOcr]xovixevos T/e6, eTTLp.eXeLav Ka\ KpaTos eôov
airrbs tu)V ev avTSt re Ka\ eavTOV, ti]V tov br]ixLovpyov Kal b
naTpbs aTTOixvr]ixovev(i)v bLbaxjiv eis bvvaixLV. Kar apxas
C 7 HV0OVS seclusi auctore Wohlrab d i &syfG: &cTTt T : Za-Te B

ea eKatrTj?] (KdarTiv B irpoaraxOiv roaavra al. Eusebius : irpoff-
raxOfvros avra BT as favrifi] avrcji T a^ vpo * (\6ovros

T vpofffXdovros B
: a5 dopvfiov T Eusebius a 6 an omit-
tendum re ? Campbell
30*
a73b nAATGNOS
IXV ovv SiKpilBda-Tepov dTrcrcAet, T(k(x;TS>v be ap.f3\vT(pov
TovTOiv be avT(a rh o'ft)/j,aToei8es t^s (ruyKpdo-fo)? alTUiv, to
5 r^y iraAai irorc (f>v(rcuis oijvTpo<f)ov, otl ttoAA^s 171; \i(t(\ov
aTa^Las irplv cts 701 i/w K6<Tp.ov a<^LK((rdai. Trapa p.(v yap
Tov a~vv6evT0i travTa KoXa KeKrqTaL' irapa bk ttjs ^pLTTpocrOev
C e^(tii, oaa xâXeTra Kal abLKa ev ovpavSt yCyvfTaL, TavTa i^

(KfLvrjs avTos TC (\L Kal Tols ((ooLS (vaTrepyd^fTaL. fj.Ta
piev ovv Tov KvjSepvriTov tcl ^wa rpicûiv iv avrta <Tp.LKpa p.v
<f)\avpa, /AeydAa 8e (v4tlkt(V dyada' yuipL^6p.(vos b( (K(lvov

6 Tov (yyvraTa \p6vov dd ti)<s d<f>(a-((tis KdAAiora TrdvTa
bLayd, TTpoLoirros b^ tov xpovov Kal Atj^tjs iyyLyvop.(vr]s iv
avT(^ plclWov Kal bvva(rT(V(L to ti]9 TraAaid? dvapfjioaTLas

d Trdôs, reAevroiiTos b( (âv6(L tov \p6vov kolI ap.LKpa pikv
Tdya6d, TTokXrjv bi Tr]v t5>v (vavTuov Kpda-LV iir^yK^paviw-
IJ.(vo9 (ttI bLa(f)6opds KLvbvvov avTov re d^LKvdTaL koX t(ov
(V avT(^. bLo bi] Kal tot ybr] 6(os d Koapr]aas avr^v, Ka6o-
6 p5>v iv d-KopiaLS ovTa, Kr]b6]i(vos tva fxr] x^Lîaadds vtto

Tapaxv^ SioAvêi? ets tov Trjs dvoixoLdTr^Tos aTT(Lpov ovTa
e t6ttov bvr], TTakLV ((f)(bpos avTov tS)V TTrjbakLdiv yLyv6]i(vos,
Ta voarjaavTa Kal \v6(VTa iv Tfj Ka6^ kavTov TTpoT(pcL Trepi-
08(1) aTpiâs, Koap-d re Kai iiTavop6(av dddvaTOV ovtov Koi
dyr']poiv dTT(pyd((TaL. tovto ]i(v ovv re'Ao? aTTavTtiiv (Xpr]TaL'
5 To 8' eTTt Tr]v tov fiaaLkioiS d-ndbeL^Lv LKavov (k tov TTp6a6(v

diTTOfiivoLS Tov k6yov' aTp((f)6(VTos ydp av tov K6a]j.ov tt/v
eTTi Tr]v vvv y(V(aLV obov to Trjs 7/AiKtas av TrdAiy XaraTo

Kal KaLva TavavTLa dire8i8ou rots t6t(. rd ]i(V ydp inro
a]iLKp6Tr]T0s okLyov beovTa i](pavLa-6ai t5)V (tôiv r]v^dv(To,

10 rd 8' (K yrjs v(oy(vr] adofxaTa TToAid <f>vvTa TrdAir dTro^rTj-
(TKOVTa (Is yr]V /caTi/et. koX raAAd re TTavTa p.(T(âXk(,
\) 4 (TcojuarociScs] awfia rh <T5os B b5 ixiroxov vulg. b7 tritrra]

irivTa Tck B KfKTijrai B Simplicius Theodoretus : K(K\ijTai pr. T
C5 a(pf(rea)s] (ptKTfwi B et in marg. t d6
StoAu^fU BT : SioAutfp t
e I Tiiiroy] ir^vrov Stallbaum yfv^f/ifvos Eusebius e a tA sccl.

Heusde e 10 iroAia] iroAiai B : woAAo T (corr. in marg. t)
nOAITIKOS 274 a
CLTroixLfxoviJieva /cat ovvaKoXovdovvTa tQ> tov TtavTos TradrifxaTi, 274

Kal br) Kol To trji kin/o-ecoy Kal yevvrja-^cas Kal Tpo(f>rjs ixiiirnxa
o-yyeiTrero roi? Trao-iv VTf' avayKrjs' ov yap i^fjv er' kv yi] hC

iTepiov a-vvLCTTdvTuiv (jiveaOaL Côv, aWa KaOa-nep rw koo-jxco
TTpoa-eTdTaKTO avTOKpaTopa ftvaL ttjs avTov iropeiay, ovT(a brj 5
KaTO. TavTO. Kal roi? ixipecrLV avTols 8t' avTuiv, Kad^ ocrov olov
T 7]V, ({)VLv re Kal yevvav Kal Tpe(f)LV TTpocr(T(XTTTO inrb rrjs

ofxoLas ayoiyrjs. ov be VKa 6 koyos &pixr]K Tras, ctt' avrt^ b
vvv icrixev ijbr]. Trepl ixev yap twv aAXcoy OripCcav TToXXa av
Kal piaKpa bieêXdeLV yCyvoLTo^ (^ &v iKacrTa Ka\ bC as atrta?
lxTaî^Xr]KV Trept 6e dvdp(i>Tr(av ^payvTepa kcu ixdXXov
7Tpo(rr]KovTa. Trjs ydp tov KeKrrnxevov Kal veixovTos r]ixds 5
baCixovos dTTpr]ix(odVTes eTrt/xeAetas, twv ttoXXwv av dripCcov,
oaa xaXeTTa Tas (pvaeLS rjv, dTTaypLcoOevTôv, avTol 6e dad^-

VCLS dvdpoiTTOL KCLL d(f)vXaKTOL yeyovoTes bLripiTaôvTO vtt'
avTciv, Kal er' a/x^>(ayot Kat arexi'ot Kora tovs 7Tp(0T0vs C

Tô-ai; xP^ôv^f ^T^ T^? M^^ avTOixaTrjs Tpo^f^rjs eTrtXeAotTTVta?,
TTopLêadai 8e ovk iTTLo-TaixevoL ttco 8ta to ixrjbîxCav avTOVS

Xp(Lav TTpoTepov dvayKd^LV. ex roi^rcoi' TTavTUiv ev jueyd-
Aat? diTopiaLS rjaav. odev br] to. TrdAat Ae^êWa Trapd 5
6eo)V b(opa rjixlv 8e8(oprjrat yixer' dvayKaCas bLbaxrj^ nal Trat-
bevaeuis, TTvp fxev TTapa Ylpop.r]6(i)S, T\yaL 8e Trap' *H0at-

(TTov KoX Tr]S (TvvTyvov, cnTpixaTa 8e av kcu. (f)VTd iTap' d
dXXcov Kal TTav^' OTToa-a tov dv6p(OTTLVov ^Cov crvyKaT-
0-KVaKV K TOVTCOV yyOVV, 7TLbr] TO pi.V K dG)V, OTTp
ppri6r] vvvbrj, Trjs eTri/xeAetay TTXlttv dv6p(0TT0vs, bi kavTu^v
T bL Tr]V T bLayoyTjV Kal Tr]V TTLIXXLaV aVTOVS aVT5)V 5
\LV KaddiTep oXos 6 Koaixos, O) a-VIXIXLp.OVIXVOL Kal a-VVTT6-
IXVOL TOV det XpOVOV VVV IXV OVT(OS, TOT bf KLVa)S (S)pi.V
re Ka\ (pv6p,6a. kcxl to ixV br] tov ixv6ov re'Aos )(T(o, e

XPVaLixov 8e avTov TTOLrjadixeda TTpbs Tb KartSetr oaov rjixdp-
0,4 Cifov] Cv^^v B b 7 ?iv] 7j B 035 om. B iro)] tl

wv B d2 &KK(tiv Stephanus e Ficino : a\\i,\wv BT d5 re
rSei] 8* 15 B
274 6 TIAAT12N02
Toptev aiTO(f)r]vanvoi tov fiaa-tXiKov re nal iroAiriKoi; iv ry
Trp6<T& Aoyo).
5 NE. 212. Ilais ovv *cai iroa-ov hfj.dprtjtJ.a <f>f}s (Ivai yeyovbi
fjljuv;
HE. Tt7 fjiev ^payvTepov, Ty bi piAka ycvvaiov Kal TroAAoi

/xeiôv fcat Ttkiov rj t6t.
NE. îl. nws;
lO HE. "On pLV kpU)T(i)p.fV0l TOV ^K TJJS VVV 'KipKÔpaS KoX
ycv4a-(o9 /SacriAea Kal ttoKitlkov tov k ttjs ivavTCas 7repio'6ov
275 TTOLpLVa TTJS t6t avOpCOTTLVrjS CiyeAT/S CLTTOp.eV, KoX TaVTa dOV
avT\ OvrjTov, Tavrt] p.V TTap.iTo\v TTapr]V\6r]p^v' otl bi
<ry/x7r(i(rrjs Trjs TToAfcos &pyovTa avTov aTT(f)^vap.V, ovTLva
8e TpoTTOV ov bLLiTop,V, TOVTr] 8c av t6 pLV \)(dv oArjês,
5 ov p.r]V okov ye ovb\ a-a(f)S ipprjdr], 6io koll ^pa\VTpov t]
Kar KLVO r)p.apTr]Kap,V.
NE. 212. 'AAt;^^.

HE. Aet TOLWV TOV Tp6lT0V, &)S OLK, bLOpL(TaVTaS TTJS
apxrjs TTJs iroÂecos ouro) reA^ws tov TTokLTLKov i]p.iv Lprj(rdou
lo TTpoaboKav.
NE. 212. KaAta)?.
b HE. Aia TavTa p.r]v Kal tov p.vdov TTapedifnOa, Xva iv-
Seiâtro Trepi ttjs dyeAaiorpoîas /bt^ ws ir<ivTS avTrjs
pi6vov
apL(f)La-(3r]T0va-L ro) ^r]Tov]JLV(o to, vvv, akka KaKLvov avTov

vapy(TTpov XhoL]XV, ov TTpo(rr]KL p.6vov Kora To TTap6bLypa
6 '7T0Lp.V(l)V re KoI ÔVK6k0)V TTJS 6.vdp(i)TTLVr]S iTTLp.kLaV \OVTa
Tpo(f)r]s TOVTOV novov aÛtidrjvoL tov TTpoaprj]xaTos.
NE. 212. 'Op6C)s.
HE. Oi/Ltat b4 y, S) 2(dK/>ares, tovto p.V Iri p.lCov r]
t6 t6 tov 6lov tovs 6'

C KaTCL /3ao-iAe'a eivai a-)(r]]jLa vop.(t)s,
v6<xb VVV OVTaS TTokLTLKOVS TOLS apXPfJ.VOLS OpLOLOVS T
e 7 ij,d\a] fiaWa (sic) T {fiaWov voluit) a r ^^1' . a 4 ravrn . .
8f oin. pr. T
sed add. in marg. (ubi, pro rpiitov ov Sttiroufv, rp6iroix*v)
bs Tijs] rhv BT iiriixfKfiai B b^ opOus om. B b8 8i(
7'] '' ^7**7* T /lii' Ti om. B

nOAITIKOS 275C
ftrat /xaAXoy Trokv ras (\>v(TIS Ka\ TrapaTrXrja-iaLTepov iraibeCas
fi(Ti\r](l)evai, Kal Tpo(f>r]s.
NE. SI2. UdvTcas ttov. 5
HE. ZTjTTjreot ye p.i]v ovb^v hv ftrjcrav ovd^ ^ttov ovt
fjjakkov, 10' ovTOis ctr' ejceircos Treff^vKacnv.
NE. 2X2. rTws yap ov;

HE. Tfjb 87/ TraAir i'rrav\9uyp.V. rjv yap ^(f)afXV avT-
eTTiTaKTiKrjv fxev eivai T\vr]V kin C*ôis, ov p.r]v Ibia yc aXXa 10
Koivfj Tr]v iiTLfxiXfLav \ov(rav, k(h "npo^reCTTop.ev br] roVe evdvs d

dyXaiOTpo(f)iK-qv fjLp.vr](rai. ydp;
NE. 2X2. Nai.
HE. TavTr]s ToCwv in] bir]fLapTdvofiV. tov ydp ttoXitikov
ovbafxov (rvv\dfiofX(v ovf o)vofxdaapiv,d\X.' fjfxds ekaOev Kara 5
Ti]v dvofxacrCav K(f)vy<av.
NE. 2X2. nwj;

HE. ToC Tas dyiXas cKaoras' Tp(f)iv rots fxkv aXA.ois
TTov Tidcn fiLTcrTt vofXV(n, T<a TroXtrtKw 8e ov fXTov irrfVy-
Kafxev Tovvofxa, biov t&v kolvS>v cireveyKeLV tl (rvfnra^Ttv. e
NE. 2X2. 'A\r]6r] Aeyets, eiTrep Tvyxav ye dv.
HE. riws 8' ovK ^]V To ye depaireveLv ttov TTaaL kolvov,
p.r]bV bLopLaOeC^rqs Tpo^prjs pr]b tlvos dX\r]s iTpaypaTeCas;
dAA' 7/ rtiâ dyekaLOKOfXLKrfv r] OepaTtevTLKr^v rj KaC TLva 5

TnfXX.r]Ti,iO)V avrrfv ovofxdcraa-LV ws KaTa iTdvTu^v e^rjv irept-
KaAvTrretv Kal tov ttoXltlkov dp.a rots aAAot?, eirei87/ 8ety
TOVT crr]fxaLVV Xoyos.

NE. 2X2. 'OpOSiS. dAA' r] fxeTa toivto btaCp(TLS av rCva 276
TpOTTov iyCyver dv;
HE. Kara TavTa KaO' direp ifxirpoaOev bLr^povfxeOa Tr]v
dy\aioTpo(f)iKr]V Tre^bis re Kat aTrrô-t, Kat dfxetKrots re Kai
C6 (T}Ti]Tfov BT C 9 T^5e Stephanus ri Se B : T e<|>ayuev]

â/x^v T c 10 rexvv^ om. B d i Ix'""''" ^ Tdre] tiJtc
76 T d 4 Toirrrjj] TaiJrp Ast 5iri/xaprdvofJ.ev T 6 1 Se'oi'
T<iv] AeoVTtov B : Bfoi/ri rSiv vulg. 63 ê^ Te B irov] iroKv B

e5 oAA.' ^j 6.\K7\ B : &KK-nv T e 6 Karo Travruiv] Ka.\ airdvrwv B
e 7 Se?!' om. B a 2 iyyiyver' B
276a nAAT12N02
S aKfpdTOLS, TOIS aVTols &V TTOV TOVTOIS biaipOVfJLVOl Kal TTIV
ayiKaioKOfiLKTjv Tr]v t vvv Kal Tifv iiTl Kpovov âiriXeCav
7repteiATj(ôre? ^v îxev 6p.oiois (V tw X.6y<ji.
NE. 212. 4>aiverai" 0?ra) 8e av tC to /xera tovto.

EE. AjjA.oi' ori kexOivTos ovto) tov Trjs ay(\aLOKOixtKrjs
b ovojxaTOS OVK av ttot eyeveO^ rjfXLV t6 rtvas aii(f)La-l3r]TeLV
s ov8' ^TTijueAcia ro TTapaiTav ka-TLV, &(nT(p t6t biKaCois

r]p.(f)a-j3r]Tri6ri fxrjbeixCav eTvaL Te)(vr]v iv r]p.LV a^Cav tovtov tov
OpeTTTLKOV TTpoa-pr]]XaTOS, (l 8' OVV TLS ftJJ, TToAAots Tip6T(pov
5 avTrjs Kal fxaWov TTpoa-qKeLV ?/ rtvt t&v âa-tXiaiv.
NE. 212. 'Op(9a)?.
HE. 'ETTtjLteAeta 8^ ye av6putiTCvr]s avp.TTaa-rjs KOLV(avCas

ovbspiCa hv idekrâeLev kripa fxaWov xai iTpoTepa ttjs âcri-
C XLKrjs (f)dvaL /cat /cara TTdirrcav dv6p(aTT(i)V dpxrjs elvai T4\vr].
NE. 2i2. AeyeLs opdm.

HE. Mera Taxrra be ye, S) ^(aKpaTcs, ap ivvoov[xev otl
TTpbs avT^ 8; rw reAei avxyov aJ/ bLrjjxapTdveTo;
5 NE. 212. To TTotoi;;
HE. To'8e, 0)5 ap' et Kot ^teiôrj^rj/xey 5ri fxdXLara Trjs
StTroSos ayeA.T7s etyat rtiâ dpeiTTLKr^v t^xvtjv, ovb^v tl
fjMkkov r]fxds e8et /3ao-tAt/c7)i; avTi]v evdvs Kal TTokLTLKrfv o)s
dTTOTTe\a-fxevr]v TTpocrayopeveLV.
lo NE. 212. Ti fxrjv;
HE. YlpSiTOV fxev, h keyofxev, Tovvofxa fxeTaa-Kevtii-
d prja-aa-daL, TTpbs Tr]V eiTLfxeKeLav [xdWov TTpoaayaydvTas rf
Tr]v Tpo(f)r]v, eneLTa Tavrqv TefxveLV ov yap o-fxtjcpas dv eôt

TfXrjO-eLS TL.
NE. 212. nota?;

5 HE. '^Ht re Tbv 6eLov dv ttov 8ietAo'/xe0a vofxea xo^pt^s 'ô'
Tbv dvdptaiTLVOV liTLp.eXrfTr^v.
a6, ag ieYtXaiovofiiKîv, -^s al. bs fj] f B b^ yt om. B

b8 vpoTfpa Stallbaum trpaoTfpa B irpaoTipa T
: : C i Tfxyv*' ^
C3 Sf 7] Ktyf B C II 6 Atyo^t'] ^Xtyofxfv B : t> 4\tyofifvT (sed i>
supra versum) d i irpoffayary6vTas B T Stobaeus : itrarYaryovras vulg.
nOAITIKOS 276 d
NE. la. 'Op6<os.

HE. Avîs bi ye rrjv aiTOVffxrjdda-av iinficXrjTLKriv bCxa
reixvdv avayKoiov ^v.

NE. 2X2. Tlvl; 10
HE. T5 jSiaib) T Kai kKovaCco.
NE. 2X2. Tt' 817;

HE. Kai TavTTi Ttov to TrpoTepov ap.apTavovTis (vrjOecTTepa e
rou biovTOs eh TavTov âaiXia koX Tvpavvov a-vv46fJL(v,
avopLOLOTaTovs ovras avTovs re Kal tov Trjs apxrjs kKUTepov

TpOTTOV.
NE. 2X2. 'AXrj6rj. 5

HE. Nvv 8e ye TrdAti; kiravopOovp.evoi, Ka6d7T(p (Ittov,
Tr}v dv6pu)TT(.vr]v iTTiixe\r]TLKr]v bCâ bLaLp(aiJ,6a, rw jSLaCca re

Kal eKoutrio);
NE. 2X2. ITdyv p.ev ovv.
HE. Kal Trjv fjiev yk ttov twv jBLaCcov rvpavvLK-qv, Trjv 10

be eKova-Lov kol kKovarCoov hLiToboiv dyiXaLOKop.LKr]v C4^^
TTpo(rLTT6vT(s iToXLTLKr]V, Tov ^yovTa av Ti)(vr]v TavTrjv Kal
e7TL]j.eX(Lav ovtws ovTa (BaaLXea Kal ttoXltlkov dTT0<paLV(^]X6a;
NE. 2X2. Kal KLvbvv(VL ye, S) i4v, reAecos &v 7}[jllv ovtoos 277
exeti r] Trept tov ttoXltlkov diTobeL^LS.
HE. KaAw? dv, u> 2(0Kpares, r]pLLV exoi. Sei 8e jxr] aol
lx6v(o TavTa, dXXa Kd\xo\ fxcTa aov Koivrj (TVvboKfXv. vvv 8e
Kard ye rr]v ]xr]v cvttco (f)aCvTaL TeXeov 6 (Sa^rLXevs r]]XLV 5
(T)(r]]xa t)(jELV, dXXd Ka^diTep dvbpLavTOTTOLol TTapd KaLpov
evCoT (TTTevbovTes iTXeCco Kal fXCC(a tov beovros (Kaara tS>v
(pycov kTTe]xâXX6]xevoL fipabvvov(TL, kol vvv r]]xeLS, tva br] b
TTpos rw Ta^v Kal pLyaXoTTpeTTu>s br]X(xicraL]xev to Trjs e/x-
TTpocrdev afxdprqfxa bLe^dbov, rai â^riXeL vofxCcravTes TrpeiTeLv
fxeydXa TTapabeCyfxaTa TTOLelcrdaL, OavfxacrTov oyKOV dpdp.evoi

Tov fxvdov, fxeCôvL Tov beovTos r]vayKdcr6r]fxev avTov fxepeL 5
e 6 5e] 56 B e i r a.ye\aioKo/j.iKiiv T (sed k ex v) a 2 rwv

iroXniKQov T a4 /cd/uol] Kol fxo\ B as iix))v^ ffi^v S6âv a).
a 7 T^ epyti> Badham b2 Taxi] Tax vulg. b 5 ;u/fo/< ] /JieTôv T
tj
277 b nAATHNOS
Trpo(r)(j)ri(ra<r6ai' Sio ixaKporepav tt^v diroSeiîr ireTroirJKaiKV
Kal TTdvTois Tw /xvdb) rcAos ovK eTTidffKv, dAA' dTexiôSj 6
C Aoyos rjpXv uxnrep C*ôv Tr}v eûiOev p.ev Tr(piypa(t)i]v HoLKtv
I/cara)s )(êiv, Tr]v b^ olov toIs (âpp.6.K0LS koX tt) (rvyKpa^ni
T(av yjpo}p.'j.T(iiv ivdpyeiav ovk airi.kr}<p4vai tto). ypa(j)ijs be
Kal o-u/xTrdo-r/s yjeipovpyias \f$i Kal Adyw br}\ovv nav Côv

5 (jLaKXov TTpTTi Tols 8wa/xcVots iTTi(Tdai' Toii 8' aAAoty 8id
\i.povpyi.(av.
NE. 212. To{}to /xev opOSiS' ottj} bi jjpuv oviTd) <f)fjs iKavoiS
flprj(TdaL briKoi)(rov.
d HE. XaAfTToy, 2 8at/xoVie, /x^ TTapabfCyfj.acrL yjxLp.fvov

LKavS)S kvbiLKVVcrOaL tl tQv /xetC/jVo)!'. KLvbvveueL yap rjpoiv
^KacTTos oXov ovap flb(i)S aiTavTa Trdvr av ttoKlv &<nTp viTap
dyvoLV.
5 NE. 212. ria)? Tovr' eiTres;
HE. Kai /idA' dTOiTu^s ioLKd ye iv t^ TrapovTL KLvr^cras
To TTcpl TT/s eirto-r^/xTjs 'jrdôff iv rjpXv.
NE. 2X2. Tt' bri;
H E. IlapaScty/itaTos, u) \mKdpLi, av /iot kcu to -noLpdbeLyp.a

10 OVTO bf.br]KV.
e NE. 212. Ti ovv; Acyt /xr/Scv ^/xou ye VKa diroKvStv.

HE. AefCTcoy ^-TretS^ kcll <rv ye cTot/xoy dKoAouêtf.
Toiis ydp TTOu TratSas L<rp.V, OTav dpTL ypappMTa)v }XTTLpoL
yCyvcovTaL
5 NE. 2X2. T6 TToior;
HE. "OTt Twi' o-Totxctcoy Ka(rTov v TOLS ^paxyrdTaLs
Ka\ pd(rTaLS tS)V <rvWaj3u)V iKavo^s bLaL<r6dvoirraL, kol Td\r}6T}
^pdêLV TTcpt CKcrra SvvaTOi yCyvovTaL.
278 NE. 212. ncSs ydp ov;
C 3 ivipyttav B d 2 ivitlâffdai Stobaeus d 3 SiTavTa] f xflurra

Stobaeus Tdvr' om. B d 6 /ioAa rh ircJy B /uaAa arSirus T :
loixa 7 1' tKaarov iv rats rh i^T\i (sic !) Ppaxvrdrais yt iv ry irap6m

I
|
K.r.X. T (cf. e6) irapi6vri B Kiv^(Taf\ KiVT$Tai. T d 10 8<8(7}Kt T

e I 7 om. B ea oi yt^ (sic) T : (ri/ al.
nOAlTIKOS 278 a
HE. TavTo. bi ye ravra kv aXKai^ a.ix<l)iyvoovvTS Traki.v
boîj T \lfvbovTaL Kal \6y<o.
NE. 2X2. Hdw /xei' ovv.

HE. 'Ap' ovv ovx <38e paa-Tov Kal KoXXia-Tov iTrdyei.v 5
avTovs 771 TCL /u.T/TTO) yiyvctia-Koixeva;
NE. 212. nws;

HE. 'AvdycLV TipSiTov (tt' eKflva ev ols TavTO, TavTa
6p6<as (boâôv, avayayovTas be Tidivai Tiapa to, p.rjiro}
yi,yvo}a-K6p.va, Kal Trapa^dXXovTas ivbeLKvvvai ti]v avTi]V b

6p.oi.6Tr]Ta KoX ($vaiv iv afxcfiOTipais ovaav Tals a^vpTTXoKaXs,
fxexpi-TTep av Tiaai tois dyvoovp.ivoLS to. boâ(6p.eva dkr]6(as
napaTL^tpeva beL^di], bLx64vTa 8e, TTapabeiypaTa ovto) yLy-
v6p.eva, TTOL-qa-r] t5>v o-tolxcloov eKaaTov TTavTutv iv TTdaaLS 5
TOLS avkkaâls to p.(v eTepov ws tG)V aAAtor eTepov ov, to
be TavTov ojs tovtov dei Kara TaiTo. kavT^ TTpoa-ayop(.Vf.a6aL. C

NE. 2X2. YioLVTdTTaaL pkv ovv.
HE. OvKovv TovTo p.tv LKavds a-vvLXrj(f)apV, otl TTopa-
bLyp.aT6s y ecrri rore yivtcrLS, ott^tov 6v tovtov iv Tepu>

bieaTTaa-pivâ boâ^6p.evov 6p6G)s kcll (rvva)(6ev Trepl eKdTepov 5
0)s avvdp(f)o) fXLav dXr]6rj bdâv dTroreAfj;

NE. 2X2. fpaCveTaL.
HE. Qav]xd^0LpiV av ovv ei tovtov tovto rjpQv rj

"^XV
(f)va-eL TTepl to. t&v TrdvToov o-rotxêta iTeTTOvdvla tot fxev vtt' d
dXrjdeLas iTepl ev eKacrTov ev tl^l a-vvLaTaTaL, Tore be TTepl
diTavTa ev eTipoLs av (f>ipeTaL, Kal to. p.ev avTG)V dfxfj yi TTrj
tG)V avyKpdaeo)v 6pdG)s bo^dêL, peTaTL6ifxeva 8' els tcls rwi'
TTpayp.dTO)v paKpds Kal pr] paStovs a~vXXal3as TavTa raCra 5
TTaXLv dyvoel;
NE. 2X2. Kai 6avfxaaT6v ye ovbiv.
as yîivôvTiT a7 $ a8 a.vay(7vT
Jij' B ag dya-
yovTas B b2 oStro' ovinv B
ex oiffi T
b 4 Setx^f'] Setx^*'? B
:
ovTu>\ TovTuv T b 5 eKaffTov Ko.vTwv^ iravTwv eKaaTov B

C 5 eKciTfpov] eTepov Cornarius C 6 uisl xal B d 2 cc ri<ri]
eV Tj B d 3 irdvTa T
278d nAATXlNOS
HE. Tlu>s ydp, S) (f)L\(, bvvaiTo &v tis 6.p-)(pncvos cmo
e 8o'^s ylfivhovs iirl rt rrjs i\Tjdeias koI ynKpov fjJpos dîKo-
ixfvos Krqa-aa-Oai ^povqcriv;
NE. 212. ^\(b6v ovbafxois.

EE. OvKovv TavTa cl TavTjj Tre^VKev, ovbfV br] tTkrfnfif-
5 XoXfifv hv iyd re Kal (tv itpGiTov pikv înxapria-avTfs oKov

-napahdyp.aTos Ibdv ttjv <j>vaiv iv ap.iKp(o KaTO, fxepos &W<a
TTapabeiyfnaTL, juera be ravra fi.eK\ovTS, ciri to tov âaikiuis
fLtyiaTov ov TavTov ciBos d-n eKaTTovoov (pepovTes iToOev, bid
Tiapabdyfj.aTos kTtiXdpiiv av Ti]v tG>v KaTa ttoKlv OepaTreiav
lo Tiyyr) yvcopl^cLV, tva virap dvT ovdpaTos rffiiv yCyvrfTOi;
NE. 212. Yldvv fiev ovv dp6S>s.
279 HE. YldXiv hr] Tov efnrpoadc Xoyov dvaXrfiTTeov, ois
eiTfLbif tS> /3ao-iAtK&) yeVet tijs TTfpl Tas tt6Kls eTrt/xcA.6tay

dfx^La^rfTovaL fwpioL, bd brf TTavTas dTToyuipi^^LV tovtovs
Kol fxovov iKdvov XeiiTLV Ktti TTpos TOVTO brf TTapabiiyfxaTos
5 (f)afi.v belv tlvos rjfi.LV.
NE. 2i2. Kai fidXa.

EE. T^ brJTa irapdbiLyfid tls &v, i\ov rifv avTrfv TToAtriKrj
TTpayfiaTiiav, afXLKpoTaTov TrapaOifxevos LKavGis dv evpoL to

b ^rfTOVfXivov ; ôvkiL iTpos Alos, u) ^MKpaTfs, (i fxrf tl iTpo-
\Lpov ^Tcpov Hyofxiv, dAA' ovv Trfv ye v(f)avTLKrfv irpocAw/xeâ;

Kat TavTrfv, el boKel, fnr] TTaaav; dTTOxprjafL ydp ta()s ?/ TTfpl
Ta eK TU)V fpiu)V v(pdafxaTa' Taya ydp dv rffxtv Koix tovto to
5 pifpo<r avrfjs fLaprvprfafLf iTpoaLpfdfv h /SovXofXfOa.
NE. 22. Tt ydp ov;

EE. Tt brJTa ov, KaddiTfp iv tols HfnrpoaOc TifivovTfs
fxiprf fxepdv tKacnov birfpovfXfda, koI vvv TTepl v(f)ain-LKi]v
C Tairrov tovt^ ibpdaafxfv, Kal KaTa bvvafXLV otl /x(iAto-ra 6ta
d. 8 yap] &p^ Stallbaum e4 tl rainri'] iir' avrri B ouitv 8i;]
ouSfVa ^ B 5 T om. T e6 -irapaStiytiaros] irpayfiaTos Schleicr-

macher e 9 aS tî'1 ovtV B ft 4 Atiwtiv B : Af'iirf ii' T a 5 ijnty
rtyosT a 7 ^X"'' T iroAiTiKp Ast itoAitik^' B T
: a8 irpay-
fiaTflay] wapaSfiyfiaTtiay B b a irtpo om. T sed add. in marg.
nOAITIKOS 279C
ftpaxôiv TOxy tt6.vt Itt^XOovt^s irakLV ijkdoiJ.v iirl t6 vvv
XPWLixov;
NE. 212. U&s Xeyets;
HE. AvTr]v ri]v bLôbov a-noKpLcrLV croL -noLiâ-oixaL. 5
NE. 2X2. KaAAio-r' d-nes.
SE. "EoTi TOLWV TiavTa rjyXv OTTocra br}^LOvpyoviJ.v Kal
KTUi}j.ida, To. iikv (VKa Tov TfOLeLV TL, TCL be Tov iJ.r] 7racr)(fii;
afxvvTripLa' Kal tS)V aixvvTripLOiV tcl ixev aXe^LcpdpixaKa Kal

deXa Kal avdpa)TTLva, tcl bk Trpo^KrnxaTa' tS>v be Trpo^KrifxdTOiiV d
TCL /xey TTpbs tov TToXfixov OTrkLcrixaTa, to. 8e (f)pdyixaTa' Kal
Tcav (f)payixdT(ov tcl p-ev TrapaTTeTdcrixaTa, to. be iTpbs \Lixu)vas
Kal KavixaTa aXe^TiipLa' T(av 8e ak^TripL(DV tcl ixev (tt^-
yda-ixaTa, to. be CKeTTdcrixaTa' Kal tG)V (TKeiTaa-ixaTcov VTToiTe- 5
TacrixaTa /xer aAAa, TrepLKakvixixaTa be eTcpa' TTcpLKaXvixixdTMV

be TCL ixev Skocrxta-Ta, avvdeTa bk erepa' Tcav be avvOiTOiV
TO. ixev TprjTa, to. bk dvv Tpriaeâs ovvbeTd' Kal tu)V aTpr]- e
T(av To, ixkv vvpLva (})VtS)V K yrjs, tcl be TpL\Lva' T(av 6e
TpLyJ.vo)V TCL ixev vbaai Kal yrj KokkrjTd, tcl b^ avTO, avTols
avvbeTd. TOVTOLaL br] Tols e/c rcSy eaurois (rvvbovixevo)v
cpyaaOilaLV dixvvTr]pL0LS Kal aKTTdaixaaL to fxev ovoixa lixaTLa 5
KCLkaaiXV T-qV be tS)V LIXaTLO)V IxdkLaTa 7TLIXkoVp.Vr]V

T\vr]v, &aTTp t6t Tr]V Trjs TToAecos TTokLTLKi]v eiTTOjuer, 280
ovrco Kal vvv TavTrjV TrpoaeCTTCoixev diT' avTov tov irpdyixaTos
llxaTLOvpyLKr]v; (pG)ixv de Ka\ v(})avTLKriv, oaov eTrt tj] tS)V
LixaTLO)v kpyaaLO. ixeyLaTOV rjv [xopLOV, ixr]bV bLa(f)pLV Trki^v
ovoixaTL TavTr]s Trjs i/xartovpyt/cTjs, KaddiTep KOKet roVe ti]v 5
[3aaLkLKr]V Trjs TTokLTLKrjs;

NE. 212. 'O/30o'rarci ye.
SE. To ixTa TovTO br] crvkkoyLacoixeda otl Tr]v t/xartcoi'
V(pavTLKr]V ovTO) prÔetadv tls Td^ av LKav&s elprjaOai b6^LV, b
C4 A67is] AeytTe B d^ a\f îr-fpia BT

(et mox oKfî-
TTiplcov) 64 TOVTOicrl T eavTo7s avvSov/xfvwv^ avTwv (avruiv B)
(xvvdovnfvois BT a3 IfxaTovpyiKiiV T (êt mox ifjiaTovpyiK^^s) :
i/j.ai>Tovpyt)cfiv al.
28ob nAATilNOS
1X7] bvva[Xvo^ (Tvvvoflv uTi T&v nfv iyy^^ avvfpytav ovjro)
Sici/Jto-rai, TToKKGiV h\ (T(poiV (rvyyevu>v aTTfyifpLaOr),

NE. 2X2. YloioiV, il-ni, crvyyv(av;
5 SE. Ovx ((TTTov Tols \(x6ci(riv, fcs (âlvrf -noKiv ovv
toiKiv i-rTaviTiov ap\6p.(vov h.TTo rtXftn^s. il yap (tvv-
voels TT]V oiKeioVT/Ta, Tr}V p(v ht.(T(p.op.(V a-n avr^s vvvhri,
TTjv T(av a-Tp(t)pAT(t)V avvd(cnv Tre/)i/3oA7j )(uipi(ovT(9 xai

vttoôXtj.
10 NE.'2f2. Mavedv(o.
C EE. Kal pLT}v TTjv iK T&v XCv(av koX (TirapTaiV koX tTavTOiV
oTToa-a (f>vT(av apTL V(vpa cara \6yov (lTTop(v, hr]p.iovpyiav
TTaaav &(f)ei\op(V' rqv t( av "JtiAt/tiactjv dc/xopioâ/xeda Kal
Tr]V TprjCTd Ka\ pa(f)r] yjxapAvr^v (rvv6((nv, r]S rj irAeioTTj
5 0-CyTOTOfllK?J.
NE. 2i2. Ilaru fiev ovv.

SE. Kat Toiwv rqv t&v 6Xoa-)(î(rTo)v (rK(TTa(rp.A.TO)v 0epa-
TTdav bepfxaTOvpyLKr^v Kal tcls tS>v aTeyaa-fiaTiov, otrat Te iv
oiacoSo/xikt) Kol oKr] TeKTOVLKfj Kot (V aAAais T^xyais p(vpATO)v
d aT(KTiKat yiyvovTai, avpiTa.a-as a.(f)(i\op.(v, 0(rai t( iT(p\ Tas
KXoTTas Kcu. Tas fiiq TTpd^dS 8iaca>Ain-tKa <lpya TTapiyovTai,
Ti\vai. (f)paypdTa)V, iT(pi T( y(V(a-LV iTTL6r]paTOVpyias ovaaL
Koi Tas tS)v 6vpo)ixdTO)V Tnjêi?, yop(f>o)TLKrjs diTov^prê^XaaL
5 ]x6pLa Texyrjs' Tr]v Te ottXottollkt^v d7T(T(fx6fX(6a, fxeydXr^s Kal
TTavToias Trjs TTpo^Xr^fxaTovpyLKrjs Tpfjpa ovaav bvva]xeo)S'
e Kal bi] Kal Tr]V [xayevTLKi]v Tr]V iTepl tcl dXe^L(f)dpixaKa Kar
dpxas evdvs bL0)pLa-dp,e6a a-vixiTaaav, Kal \eKoiiTapLev, o>s
boâLjxev dv, avn]v Tr]v ^TjTTjêio-ar dpvvTLKi]v xeLpdvo^v, ipeov

TTpo^\7]paTos epyaa-TLKrjv, ovoixa bi v(f)airni^v \(x6ela-av.
5 NE. 212. 'EoiKe ydp ovv.
SE. 'AAA' ovK loTi TTo) Te'Acor, a> irai, rovro \e\eyix4vov.
O I \iyeiv B irdyTuy] iravra B C 3 xo\iriK)\y T C4 Tp^<ri"|
rp rpiiati B d i t om.D : BT da Aoiri?] -XocAt BT

d' 3 olaai] iaai pr. T d5 iitXovoiitrut^ T 63 ipiov T e 6 ]
voi; vulg.
nOAITIKOS 280 e
6 yap h apx^ Trj^ tS>v i/xariwr ipyaa-Cas aTrro/Aeyos rovvavriov
V(pfj bpav (paCverai,. 281

NE. 2X2. Uios;
HE. To ixev TTJs v(f)rjs avfJLTTXoKTq ris l^rri ttov.
NE. 2X2. Nai.
HE. To bi ye tS)V a-vv(a-T(aT(t)V koI (Tvp.iT'niKrjixiv(i)V 5
hiakvTiKi].
NE. 2X2. To TTolov 877;

HE. To Tris Tov âivovTOS t^xvtjs ipyov. r] ttjv âvTi.Kr]V
ToXfxri(Top,V V(\>avTiKT]v KaX Tov ^(xvTrjv &)S ovTa v(f)airrr]v
KoXeiv; 10
NE. 2X2. OvbajxCis.

HE. Kat p.r]v Tr]V ye av arqixovos kpyaa-TiKr]V koI KpoKrjs
1 TLS v<pavTi.Kr]v TtpocrayopevtL, 'napaboôv re /cai y\fivbos
6vo]xa Xeyei. b
NE. 2X2. US>s yap ov;
HE. Tt bi; Kva(f)evTLKr]V a^p.Tracrav /cat Tr]v aKea^TLKr]v
TtoTipa p.r]b]xiav iTrL]XkeLav /iTjde TLva OepaTreiav ia-drJTos

6&]XV, T] KaX TOVTas Ttda-as S>s V(pavTLKas kiôfxev; 5
NE. 2X2. Ovbap.cis.
HE. 'AAAa fxr]V Trjs ye OepaTTîas ap.<pL(T^r]Tr]aovaLV
avTai (TVfxiTacrai, koX r^s ycvicrecds ttjs tG>v IfxaTicdV Trj Trjs
v(pavTLKr]s bvvd]XL, fxiyLOTOV piev joiepos eKeivrf bLbovcraL,
fxeydka be Kal a-cpiaLV airrals dTTovip.ovcraL. 10

NE. 2X2. Udw ye. C
HE. Ylpos Toiwv TOVTaLS (tl ras tS>v epyaXeiuiv br]-
fXLovpyovs rexiây, 8t' c5y dTroreAeirai ra Trjs vcprjs epya,

boKeiv XPV "^^ y^ (TVvaLTias etvai TTpocnTOLrâ-aa-OaL TTavTos
v(pd(TfxaTos. 5
NE. 2X2. 'OpOoTaTa.
HE. YloTepov ovv rffuv 6 TTepX Tr\s vâvTLKrjs Xoyos, ov
TTpoeiXofxeOa fxipovs, LKavG>s ecrTai buapLcrfxivos, idv dp' avrqv
a I v<p^ ras. trium litterarum T sed add. v<t>^ in marg. e 4 7] t BT

aSic nAATilNOS
tS>v iiTifxeXciCiv OTTocrcu Trepi ti}V ipeav iardfJTa, (h W/f
d KaWCoTqv Ka\ inyicrrqv TTa(r&v Ti$oifKV' rj Xiyoifiev fxkv av
TL aKrjdei, ov fxijv (ra(f)i9 ye ovb( Tikiov, Trplv hv Kal Tavras
avTTJs TTaaas TrepieAco/xei';
NE. 212. 'OpeS>s.

5 HE. OvKovv ixfTa Tavra TTOir]Teov o Xeyoixev, Xv ((f)e^f]i
i]}xi,v 6 \6yos ir];
NE. 212. Um 8' ov;

HE. ripâTov ixv Toiwv bvo Tex^vas ov(ras Trepl irdvTa
TO, hp(ji]Xva 6a(r(a]X6a.
lo NE. 212. TiW;

HE. Tr]v ]XV yevicreois ovcrav (rvvaiTiov,TT]V favTT]v airiav.
NE. 212. n&)s;
e HE. "Oo-ai ]Xv To TTpay]xa avTo /xtj hr]]xiovpyov(n, raiy
8e hr]]xiovpyov(rais opyava TTapacrK(V(iCov(ri.v, ojv fxr] irapa-

yVO]xiv(i)v ovK &.v TTOTe ipya(r6(irj t6 iTpocrT(Tay]x(vov kKAcrTr]
T(av TeyvQtv, TavTas ]xkv (rvvcuTiovs, tcls b( avTo rb TTpiay]xa
5 aTT(pyaô]X(vas ahias.
NE. 212. 'Exei yovv \6yov.
HE. Mera tovto 8r/ Tas ]x(v TT(pi t( aTpa.KTovs cai
K(pKibas KoX OTTOcra oKka opyava rqs TT(p\ to. api(f>i(a-]xaTa
y(V((r((as KoiV(av(i, irdo-ay (TvvaiTiovs etTrca/xer, ras bi avra

lo 6(paiT(vov(ras Kal br]pn,ovpyov(ras ahias;
NE. 212. 'Opd6TaTa.
282 HE. Tciv alTioiv brj TT\vvTiin]v pi^v Koi aK((mKr]V Kal
TTCKTav Tr]V 7T(pl TavTa 6(paTT(VTiKr]V, TToKkrjs ov(rr]S rrjs
K0(r]xr]Ti.Kr]s, TovvTav6a avTrjs /xo/stor (Ikos /ioAto-ra iT(pi-
ka]xfiav(LV 6vo]x(xCovTas ttov Tfj Ti\vp r^ Kvac^^vriKf].
5 NE. 212. Kakm.

HE. Kai pi.r]v âvTiKrj ye Kal rT/oriKj/ koX Trarra av
Ta 7T(pl Tr]v TToir](nv avrj/r tt/s ((rdrJTOs rjs k(yo]x(v
C 9 tU TJ)!'] fls yriv B fla\ al.

: d 2 &' . . . irpi/Xftî'] al . . .
irtptfKwfxtv BT : al . . . wtptfKointf Hermann a^ 0' Ttjj ircbTjj T

a6 âvTtKi) . . . i>i}(rTiKit Stephanus : (wriK^*' , . . vii(rTiKi)v BT 7] t B
I
;
nOAITIKOS 282a
êp?;, fj.Ca t(s eori Ti\vr] tS)V vtto TtdvTMV X.yoiJLva)V,
1] TaXaa-LovpyiK-q,
NE. 212. riais' yap ov; lo
HE. Trjs br] ToXaa-iovpyLKrjs bvo Tp.r]p.aTd iaTOV, Kal b
TovTOLV kKaTepov apM bvolv TTecj^vKaTov T^xyaLV piipri.
NE. 212. no)?;

HE. To p-iv âvTLKov Ka\ to ttjs KepKiariKrjs rliJ.iarv xat
oa-a TCL avyKL[j.va aTr' aW^qXcov d^LaTqaL, ttclv tovto ws kv 5
<ppd^LV ttJs t ToXaa-LovpyLas avrfjs (o-tl ttov, Kal p.yd\a tlv
KaTOL TTdvTa rjfXLV Tjo-Trjv T^yva, fj avyKpLTLKrj re kol bLaKpLTLKr'].
NE. 2X2. Nai'.
HE. Trjs TOLWV bLaKpLTLKrjs rj T âvTLKi] Kal TCL iwvbr]

pr]dVTa diravTd ka-TLV rj ydp kv ipCoLs re Kal aT^]j.oa-L 8ta- C
KpLTLKrj, KpKLbL ]j.V aAAoy TpoTTov yLyvo]Xvr], Xpa\ Se Tpov,
a)(^V oaa dpTLUiS 6v6p.aTa kppr^dr].
NE. 2X2. Yldvv iikv ovv.
HE. Av6ls br] ttoXlv a-vyKpLTLKrjs nopLOv dfxa Kal ToXa- 5
aLovpyCas v avTf] yLyv6fj.vov X.d^(i)fj.V' oaa 8e r^s StaKpi-

TtK^S rjv OVToOl, fJ.6LMfXV aVfXTTaVTa, bixa Tp.VOVTS TTfV
TaXaa-Lovpyiav bLaKpLTLK(a re cat avyKpiTiKto Tfxi^fxaTi,
NE. 2X2. ALr]pr]a6J.

HE. To ovyKpLTLKov TOLWV av aot, kox ToXaaLOvpyLKov lo
apia fxopLov, (o 2(tfKpares, bLaipT0v, eiirep Ikov&s fiiXXofxcv d
T7]v TTpopprf^^laav v(f)avTLKr]V aLpr](riv.
NE. 2X2. OvKovv XP'^-

HE. Xp^ fxV ovv KOL \y(afXV ye avTrjs to pikv eirai
aTpeTTTLKOV, TO 8e aVfXTTk^KTLKOV, 5
NE. 2X2. 'Ap' ovv fxav6dv(i); boKLS ydp fxoL to Tre/ai Tr]v
Tov (TT-qfxovos pyaaiav \yLV aTpTTTLK6v.

HE. Ov fxovov y, dWd Kal Kp6Kr]S' r] yVa-LV daTpo(f)6v
TLva avTTJs vpr]crofXv
C7 nfBiwfift/ ^vel fifBaîfv) Hermann : nfriufifv BT dg rivx

6,<Trpo<f>ov T (sed add. signis transpositionis)
PLATO, VOL. I. 8X
282d nAATilNOS
lo NE. 212. Ov8a/xa)j.
e HE. AiopKTat bi] Kal tovtoi,v (KdTepov l<r<ai yap 6

biopLa-fjLos ^yKaipos &v aoi yivoiro.
NE. Sii. nT-j;
EE. T^bc tQv TTfpl âvTiinjv 4py(ov firiKvvOfv Tt koX
5 ayov TrAaros \eyofiev etvai KdTaypLO, n;
NE. 212. Nai'.
HE. TovTov 8t; t6 piev aTpaKTto re a-Tpa(t>(v koX arfpfov
vrjixa yv6p.vov arrjpx^va ixkv (f>ddi to vrjpia, ttjv be aTrevdv-
vovaav avTo Txyr]v dvai (rTr]\iovovr]TLKriv.

lo NE. 212. 'Opem.
HE. "Oo-a 8e' ye av ti]V piev a-vaTpo(Pi]v x,avvr]v \ap.^(iv(i,
Tr] bk Tov aTqp.ovo9 fjUTrX^êt iTpos ti]V Trjs yvd\j/(t>9 oKKTfv

e/xfxerpcos Tr]V paXaKOTr^Ta la-)(^fi, Tavr apa KpoKrjv piev ra
vr]6ivTa, Tr]v b\ T:iTTaypAvr]v avTois tlvcu T4\vrjv rrjv
283 KpOKOVr]TlKr]V (^G)llV.
NE. 212. 'OpOoTaTa.

HE. Kai p.r]v t6 ye r^y v(j)avTiKr]9 p.^pos h TTpov$-
fifOa, TiavTi irov briXov ijbr]. to ydp crvyKpiTiKr]S r^s
5 iv TaXaaurvpyCq pMpiov ^rav vdv7r\oKC(i Kp6Kr]s koX ot^-
liovos ditpydQf]TaL TT\ypa, t6 jxkv TrA.ex^fv (rvfMTTav iadrjTa
ipdv, Tr]V 6' eTTi TovT(a Tiyvrjv ov(rav TTpo(rayopvopLV
v(\>avTLKr]V.
NE. 2(2. 'Opôrara.

b HE. Eiev ri 8^ TTore ovv ovk evffvs dTTKpLvdp.da wAeK-
rtjc^y eirat KpdKTjs koX aTrjpMvos v(l>avTLKrjv, dAAa TTpLi^\6opLV
iv kvk\(o TTdpTroWa 8toptô/xeroi pLdrrjv;

NE. 212. OuKow pL0Ly, a> êVe, /xott/v ov8ei' rwr
B pq0VT(i>v e8oe prjdrjvaL,
HE. Kat davpxKrrdv ye ovbiv dWa Td\ av, a> paKdpL,

b6î. TTpos br] t6 v6ar]pa t6 tolovtov, dv dpa TroAAciKis
e I iit\ 8i T & îopiffnhi] 88' dfutrfihs T 64 ftrtKvr94r t] ftriKvr-

OfyTfsB e8 <^<{ft] (âo-i vulg. eg avrh] avrkB ffTfinoyrrrt-
K^T e 14 T^v] TivcbCampbell : om. al. bi olr ovk'] ovKovy ovk B
nOAITIKOS 283b
varepov cTTir] Oavnaa-Tov yap ovbev Koyov aKOVcrov Tiva
npoarjKovTa Trepl TravTcov TUiV tolovtwv prjdrjvai.. C
NE. 2X2, A4y p.6vov.
SE. YlpGiTOV Toiwv lbo)p.V Tracrav Trjv re VTTpô\r}v Kal
Trjv ekX.L\}/i.v, tva /cara koyov eTrairw/jtei; Kal \j/4yo)p.ev to.
piaKpoTepa Tov beoirros eKaoTore ky6pt.eva Kal TavavTia Trepl 5

ray roia<r8e StarpiySa?.
NE. 2X2. OvKovv XPV-
SE. riept 8^ TovTdiv avTOiv 6 \6yos rjixiv oi/xai yiyv6fXvos
6p6(as hv yiyvoiTo,
NE. 2i2. TiW; 10
SE. M^/cou? re jrepi Kat fipayyTr]TOS kol iracrris VTrepoxr]^
T Kal kkeCêa)S' rj ydp ttov fXTpr]TLKr] Trcpt TravT iarl d
Tavra.
NE. 212. Nat.
SE. AteAco/xei' tolwv avTr]v bvo p-epr]' Sei ya/) 8?/ irpos
o vvi' a-TrevbopLev. 5
NE. 2X2. Aeyois &y rqv bLaCpea-LV oirr].
SE. TTjSe* To ixev KaTO. ti]v irpos akkr]ka p.yi6ovs koX

a-p.LKp6Tr]Tos KOLVoyvCav, to be [to] KaTO. Trjv rtjs yereVecos
avayKaCav ovcrCav.
NE. 2X2. U&s key(Ls; 10

SE. Ap' ov KaTCL cj^vaiv SoKei cot t6 iieLôv pLr]bv6s
(Tepov bcLV fxelôv keycLV 77 tov ikarrovos, kol TovkarTOv av
Tov pLeCCovos ekaTTov, akkov 8e fxr]b(v6s;
NE. 2X2. 'E/xotye.
SE. Tt 8e'; t6 Tr]v tov fxeTpCov cf)va-LV vTTp(3akkov Kal
vTrepl3akk6pLevov xrn avTijs 4v k6yoLs etre xai ev epyoLs ap'
ovK av keôfxev coy ovtcos yLyv6fxevov, ev & Kal bLacf)epova-L 5
fxdkLa-Ta r]fxu)v ot re KaKol Kal [01] ayadoC;
NE. 2X2. *airerat.
_ c 3 (ISwfKv BT c6 Toa<7-5T roiavras T d i ^ BT (sic) :
5? al. d8 T^ om. B d 12 o5] cwtI (sic) B e6 oiom. T

31*
aSae nAATHNOS
HE, AiTTay apa ravra? ova-Cas Kal Kpiaw tov p.(y6Xov
KOX TOV (TfXlKpOV d(TOV, iAA' ovx ws ^(f)ap.(V apTi TTpbs
10 aA.A.TjAa piovov bflv, aAA' uxnrfp vvv elprjTai. piaWov ttjv piv
TTpbs aAAjjAa XcKTfov, tt^v 8' av iTpos to p.iTpiov ov 8e
VKa, p.aOilv ap h.v l3ovKo[p.eda;
NE. 2X2. Ti ixriv;
284 HE. El Trpos fJirjb^v ^Tfpov ttjv tov p.(L(pvos etio-ci ns
<\)V(riv t] Trpbs TovKaTTOV, ovk etrraL Trcfrk irpos t6 ncTpiov
NE. 212. OuTwy.

5 HE. OvKovv ras rexyas re avras Kal Tapya avT<av (rvfi-
TravTa bio\ovp.V TOVTia ro) \6y<a, Kal brf Koi rqv ^r]Tavp.ivrjv
vvv TToAirtKTJi; Ka\ ttjv prfdflcrav v(f)avTiKr]v a(f>avioviJ.(v;
&TTa(raL yap ai ToiavraC ttov t6 tov fiiTpCov irXiov kolI
fkaTTOv ov^ 0)9 ovK ov dAA* ws ov yaXeiTov iTfpl Tas TTp(iî.s
b 'TTapa(f>vX.dTTov(ri, Kal tovtco br] ro) Tp6iT<a t6 fxiTpov (T(ôv(Tai

TTavTa ayaOa koI Koka 6.7Tpya(ovTat.
NE. 2X2. Tt fxrjv;
HE. OvKovv hv rf]V iroXiTiKqv i(f>avCa-(t>p.v, aiTopos r]]xiv
5 r] fXfTa TovTo (crTai. ^rjrqcrLS Trjs jSacriAiK^s fTTKrrqfxrfs;

NE. 212. Kai fxdka.
HE. ITorepoy ovv, KaOaiT^p kv Tta (ro(f>i.(rTfj npo(rr]vayK&-
crafxiv iXvaL t6 fxr] ov, iiTd.br] KaTo, tovto bi.(f>\ryev f]pMS
6 \6yos, ovrco Kal vvv t6 irXeov av Kal ^KaTTov fxtTprfTa

10 TTpo^ravayKacrriov yCyvecrOaL fxrf npos oAArjAa fx6vov dWa Kai
C Trpoy TTfv Tov fxerpCov yev(riv; ov yap brf bvvar^v yc ovrc
TroAiriKor ovt aAAoi' riiâ rcSr TT(p\ ras TTpd^ds kiTKrTrffxova
dvafx(f>L(rfir]rqT(i>s yeyovevaL tovtov fxrf (rvvofxoXoyrfdivTOs.
NE. 212. OvKOW Ka\ vvv otl juciAio-ra x/"? raurov

5 TTOLiLV.
HE. riAeoi', a> 2coKparc?, eri tovto t6 (pyov 7/ \eLVO

a6 iioKovfity Bekker : Si(\ov/ift> BT vvy îrTovixitn^v T
b T fxirpov^ fiirptov T b8 toCto] toOto' BT O i yt post
KoKiTiKiv add. T ca twv] rhv B
nOAITIKOS 284C
KaiToi KaKeCvov ye fxejjLvrnxeOa t6 fj.rJKOs 6(rov Tjy dAA'

VTTOTidea-dai fjiev t6 Totovbe Trepl avTuiv Kal ixdka hiKaiov.
NE. 2i2. T6 -noiov;
HE. "ils -noT^ Se^cret tov vvv XexÔ^VTOS Trpos ttjv Trepl d
avT6 TaKpijSes aTTobeL^LV. otl 8e Trp6s tcl vvv KoAois Kal
iKavQ^s bcLKiwTaL, boKel juoi ôrjd^LV fjLeyaXoiTpeTr&s rjp.lv ovtos
6 Xoyos, 0)? dpa rjyrjTdov 6p.oLcos Tas Tiyvas 7rd<ras eirat,
fxilôv re a/ita /cat iXarrov \xiTpiLa-6ai. jxr] TTp6s oAArjAa p.6vov 5
dAAa fcai Trpos T-j/y roi) pLfTpCov yivecrLV. tovtov re yap ovtos
iKilva i(TTL, KdKeivdJV ova&v iaTtr Kal tovto, jxr] be ovtos
TTOTCpOV TOVTMV OvbTpOV aVT&V (TTaL TTOtL
NE. 212. Torro p.\v dpOSts' dXkd tl br] t6 jieTd tovto; C

HE. Arjkov OTL bLaLpolp.ev dv rqv jxeTprfTLKrjV, KaddiTep
fpprjdt], TavTrf bCxo. TifxvovTis, kv fxkv Ttdevres avTrjs fxdpLov
(rvp.TTd(ras t^xvo.s OTrocrai t6v dpL$fx6v Kal fxrfKr) koX ^dOrf
KoX TTkdTrf Kal TaxrJTtfTas iTpos TovvavTLov fXTpov(rLv, t6 8e 5
iTepov, OTToaai Trpos t6 fXiTpiov Kal t6 TrpiiTOV koa. tov Kaip6v

Kal t6 beov Kal irdvO' oiTOcra eis t6 fxcaov diTii^KLcrOr] tG>v
iaxdTcov.
NE. 2X2. Kat jue'ya ye (KdTepov Tfxrjfxa etTre?, Kat ttoAv
bLaîpov dXkrfkoLV. 10
HE. O ydp ivLOTC, 0) '^(aKpaTes, oldfxcvoL br] tl ao<p6v
(f)pdC(i.v TToAAoi T&v KOfxûtv keyovfTiv, ? opa fxcTprfTLKr] 285

TTept TTarr' eo-rt Ta yLyvofxeva, tovt avTd t6 vvv Aexêr ov
TvyxavcL. fXTpr]ae(as fxev ydp brf TLva TpoiTov TTavO^ oTToaa
ivTexJô- fXTLkr](f)V' hd 8e t6 fxrf Kar etbrf crvviLOLcrdai
aKOTTiLV bLaLpovfxevovs Tavrrd re ToaovTov bLa(f)povTa (rvfx- 5
âAAovo-tv evOvs eis tovt^v ojuota vop.L(ravTS, Kal TovvavTLOv
av TOVTOV bpacTLV Tpa ov Kard fxipr] bLaLpovvTes, biov, OTav
fxkv TTfv tS>v TTokkSiV TLS TTpoTfpov aL(rdrfTaL KOLVoiviav, fxr] b
d2 Srt] Tt Cornarius ds ZelKvvTai] teiKvvaQai Cornarius

d4 flvai] flvai Ka\ al. d5 re] Tt B T d 7 tKflva <rT]
(Kiivai (iai Madvig tovto] ravTa BT 65 TaxwT^Tos] iraxv-
TfjTas B
B85b nAAT12N02
Trpoa(f)[(rTa(rdai iTplv hv iv avrf/ ras 5iaôpa$ JjSt/ jra<ra?
onoaanrep iv etSeo-t ccj>rai, tcls bi av TravTobaTras avofjioio-
TrjTas, OTav ev TT\r)6((riv 6(\>6G>(nv, p.i] hvvaTov cirat bvariiynov-
5 fxevov iTavi(T6ai Trpiv hv (ruy.TtavTa to. olKtia (vtos p,uis
6fJLOi.6TrjTos ^pâs yivovs Ttvbs ov(TCa TTepi^dXrjTat. Tavra

p.V OVV IkOV&S TTfpl T TOVTdiV Kol TTepl t5>V iW(L\ffe(tiV Kal
VTTpôk(av (Iprjarôt)' <f)v\6.TTCi>nV 6e p.6vov ort hvo yivr)

C iT(p\ avTo. (^vprjTat Trjs fxcrpTjrtK^s, Kot & (pafiev avr (Ivai
p.(p.v(iip.(6a.
NE. 2X2. Mcfivr]a-6ix(da.

HE. Mcra rouroi; bi] tov \6yov irfpov iTpoah(^(x)p(6a
5 TT(p\ avT(av re tQv ^rjTovpivaiV Ka\ TT(p\ v6(n]s ttjs (v toIs
roioio-Se Ao'yois huiTpijBrjs.
NE. 212. To TToiov;

SE. Ei rts avipoiTO rjfjLas Tr]V iTept ypdppLara (rwova-Cav
T(av p.avdav6vT(ji)v, oiT^Tav tls Stlovv ovop.a (pooTrjdfj tCv(ov
lo eo-ri ypapfiaT(t)v, tt6t(pov avT^ t6t( <f)6ip(v yCyv((r6ai Tr]v

d CrfTrja-tv (vbs (V(Ka paKXov tov TTpo^kr]6(VTos rf tov Trepi
iT6irra to. iTpoâ\X6ft(va ypafiiJMTu<(i)T(p(o yCyv((rdai;
NE. 212. AfjKov ort tov iT(p\ aTTavTa.
SE. Tt 8' av vvv rffiiv rj irepi tov tto\itikov ^rjrqa-is;
.) (V(Ka avTov tovtov TTpofi4j3\r]TaL fiaWov rj tov irepl irciz^ra
8iaAeKrtKa)r^/30is yCyv(a-6aL;
NE. 2X2. Kai tovto hr]\ov ort tou iT(p\ -jrarra.
SE. 'H TToi; Tov TTjs v(f)ain-tKrjs ye Ao'yov avTrjs ravrr/s
^v(Ka 6r]p(v(LV ovh(\s hv i6(\ricr(i(v vovv (X(i)v dAA' olpai
lo rovs irAeto-rovs AeÂjjêv ort rois fxkv tQv 6vt(i)V paSicos
e KaTafJLa6(LV ala-6r]TaC Tiv(s ofxotorT/res TT((f)VKa(rtv, hs ovbiv
XaAeTrof hr]\ovv, otov ovtcjv tls /QovAt/^t) roi Ao'yoi' airovi^rt
jrept Tov p.r] fjL(Ta iTpayfjLaTcov aWa x^P'-^ Ao'yov paduos

ivb(C^(Tdai' TOLS 8' aZ fteyforois ouo-t xai rt/ita>r(irots
ba fKp (sic) T b6 dixoiS-niTOi scd in marg. oUftSTrtros T

irfptpiKKrirai B e i a/(r0^ra/ Cornarius : alcr^Tuccd BT 63 p^-
ilois Heusde e Ficino
nOAITIKOS a86a
ovK ecTTiv eXboiiXov oibiv Trpo? tovs avOpunrovs elpyaafxevov 286

evapyois, ov bei-xdevTos rqv tov TTVvOavofj.evov ^')(i]v 6
(iov\6fj.V09 aTioTikr]pG)(Tai, irpbs tG>v aladrjcreuiv Tiva Trpoaap-
pLOTTcov, LKav&s TrXrjpcoa-et. btb bei p.\Tav koyov (KacrTov

bvvaTbv elvai bovvai, Kal beâadat' to. yap aa-(ap.aTa, KaWKTTa 5
ovTa Kal p.iyt<TTa, Koyâ p.6vov aAAw b\ ovbivX (ra^S>s betKvv-

Tat, TOVTcov be VKa TiavT eort tcl vvv KeyopL^va. paoiv
8' v TOis i\dTToa-tv T] /MeAerTj TiavTbs Trept [xaKkov r] irepl b
Ta fiei^ft).
NE. 212. KoAAkTt' 17769.
HE. ^Q.v ToCvvv xaptv airavO^ r][uv TavT epp-qdr] Trepl
T0VT(OV, lX.Vr](TdS>lXV. 5
NE. 212. Tiv(iiv;
HE. TavTr]s re ov\ rJKta-Ta avTrjs eveKa ttjs Suoêpeta?

rjv irepl Tr]v p.aKpokoytav Tr]V Trept Tr]v v(f)airrtKr]V a-TreSeâ-
fxeOa bva"x(p(os, Kal tt]V irepl Tr]v tov iravTbs dvetkt^tv Kal
Tr]V Tov ao(j)ta-TOv TTtpt Trjs tov /x?/ ovtos ovcrias, evvoovvTes 10
o)? eoê p.r]Kos Trkeov, KOt eirt rovrots br] Trdatv kiTT:Kr]âp.V
r]iuv avTols, bei(TavTes jxr] irepiepya dpta Ka\ fxaKpd keyotfxev. C
Lv ovv els avOts fxr^bev irda-xo^fxev TotovTov, tovtcov eveKa
TrdvTcov Ta irpoa-Oe V(ov elprjcrdat (pddt.
NE. 212. TavT ecrTat. Xeye e^rjs fxovov.
HE.
Aeyco Toiwv otl xPV br] ixefxvr^fxevovs ep.e Kal ae 5
T(ov vvv eipr][xev(ov t6v re \j/6yov eKdaTOTe Kal e-naLvov
TToteta-OaL ^paxvrqTos dfxa Kat [xrjKovs S>v dv aet Trepi
\ey(o[xev, [xr] TTpbs oAAT/Aa Ta [xr]Kr] KpivovTes dX\d /cara to

Tr]s [xeTpr[TLKr]S [xepos 6 t6t c})a[XV belv [xefxvija-Oat, iTpbs d
Tb TTpeTTOV.
NE. 212. 'Op<9(Ss.
HE. Ov Toivvv ovbe irpbs tovto TrdvTa. ovt ydp irpbs
a2 o5] ou B a3 Trpoffapn^TTwv ex n-poffap/j.oTTOvTwv T b6 rt-

votv] Tinuv B hS ijv irspl] fjvirfp Hermann i)v post v<pavTtKriv
transp. Heindorf hg t})v toC] toC BT 03 vdyraiv] iravTa
Ast Ta wpoffde om. B d2 t5] Tovrh T
i>86d nAATXlNOS
5 TTiv rjbovTjV /X7JK0V? apixoTTovTo? ovbev TTpoa-beria-ofxcOa, ttAt/i'
(l irapfpyov tv t6 re av Trpbs ttjv tov TTpo^KrfdfifTOi ^T/TTjo-ti',
ws hv pacTTa koX Ta.\L(rTa vpoi.fj.(v, bevTfpov dAA' ov TrpG^TOv

6 Aoyos ayaTtav TrapayyeAAei, ttoAu be p.aKL(TTa Kal Trp<aTov
Tr]v p.i66bov avTr]v TLfMV tov Kar ct8r/ bvvaTov ctrai bLaLpdv,
e Kat 8t) Kai Aoyov, avTe Ttapifx^qKrjs K\deli tov d.Kova-avTa
evpeTLKotTepov aTre/aya^r/rai, roirroy o-7rovba.((LV Kal roi nrjKfL
jxrjbev ayavaKTdv, Slvt av ^payvTfpos, iio-avTOiS' ^tl b* av
Ttpbs rovrois tov TrepX Tas roiao-8e a-vvova-Las yjffyovTa Koyuiv
6 firJKr] Kal Tas (v kwkAo) 7repto'8oT;s ovk aTTobexofJievov, otl \prf

Tov TOLOVTOV fJLT} [TTaw] Ta)(y /jItj8' v6vs ovtoo fi(6LevaL "^lâvTa
287 fxovov 0)5 fiaKpa tol \e)(dVTa, aXXa Kal TTpoa-aTTO(f)alv(LV
oUa-6aL bdv a>s ^paxvTepa hv yevofxeva tovs avvovTas

aiTripydCfTO 8taAeKriKa)re'pous Kal Trjs tHv 6vt(i>v Ao'ya) 8t;A<o-
<rea)s vpTLK(ji)Tpovs, TUiv b\ aXkoiV KaX irpos oAA' SiTTa

5 \lf6y(DV KOL iTTaCvoov fxrfbev (f>povTLC(LV fxrjbe to TTapdirav
CLKovHV boKflv tG)V tolovtcov X6y(DV. KaX tovtcov fjLV &\ls,
et Kat o-ot TavTrf a-vvboKel' iTpbs bi brf rbv TToAtrtKor
b L(t)fiV tt(!lX.lv, Trjs TTpopprfdiiajfs v(feavTLKi]s avTtf (PepovT(s rb
7rap(i.bLyfia.
NE. 2)X2. KoAd)? ciire?, koi noL&fKv h Ae'yet?.

HE. OvKovv aTTo ye rcSr TroAAoii' 6 /3ao-tAei;s oaai
5 a-vvvofjLOL, fid.X\ov 8^ 0776 Trao-oir tcov nepl Tas ayeXas
StaKexwptoraf AotTrat 8e', (Pafxev, ai KaTO. ttoKlv avTrfv rcir
re (TvvaLTLiov Kal t(^v aLTL(i)V, hs iTpdjTas cltt' AAAÂa>r

6tatpere'oi'.
NE. 2X2. 'Opôis.

10 HE. Oio-^' ovv ori xaXfTTbv avTas refxeiv 8ixa; to 8'
C airior, d)S ot/xat, iTpoXovaLV ov\ Tjttov eaTaL KaTa^lâvfs.
NE. 2f2. OVKOW XPV bpaV OVT(t)S.

SE. Kara fiiXr) toCwv avTas olov Upclov Staipco/xeâ,
d 5 ovSiv] oiiSfvl T d 6 Zj / /n^ T e i ixovffoyra (sic' T

e 4 rhy^ ruy T e 6 irdfv seclusi xavraxv (sic) : B {faxv f"'t a t4
' i
]
T^ xp6(r6tv ravra rhT b i oury] ouTi T b lO T>i?i' avrh.s vulg.

:
nOAITIKOS 287C
îretSTJ bixo. abvvaTovfiev. Sei yap eis tw kyyvTaTa oti

/xaA.i(rTa Tefxvdv aptOfxbv aei. 5
NE. 2X2. Ilws ovv TTOLwp.ev to. vvv;
HE. "Ho-Trep ep.TTpoa-dev, oTrocrai iTapeiyovTo opyava Trepi
Ti]v v(f)avTiK-qv, irda-as brjTTOv t6t( hCdepLev ws a-vvai.TCovs.

NE. 2X2. Nai.
EE. Kat rw 87; TOVTOV pkv tovto, In 8^ p.akXov rj toO^ 10
^/xiy TTOir]Tov. oa-ai yap apnKpbv ^ P^^yo. ti br]p.Lovpyova-i d

/cara tt6\i.v opyavov, 6eTOV aTraa-as TavTas a)s ovaas avvai-
TLOvs. avev yap tovtmv ovk av ttot yivoLTO tt6Xls ovbe ttoKl-
TLKrj, TovfoiV 8' av â^riXLKrjS ipyov t^x^V^ ovbiv ttov drja-op.V.
NE. 2X2. Ov yAp. 5
HE. Kai pLV br] X^f''''01' TTL-)(ipOVp.V bpCLV dTTOXOpL-
ôirtes TOVTO diTb t&v aAAcoi; Tb yivos' otl yap ovv tS)V ovTOiV
ia-TLV 0)9 v6s yk tlvos opyavov eliTovTa boKelv lpi]KvaL
TL TTLOavov. ofMOis b Tpov av tG>v V TToAet KrqpAToiv e
ciTrcofiei; roSe.
NE. 2X2. To -Troior;
HE. 'X2j ovK a-TL TavTr]v Tr]v bvvafXLV Xov. ov yap TtI
yVa-Ois aLTLa TTrjywTaL, Kaddirep opyavov, dAA.' VKa tov 5
br]fXL0Vpyr]9VT0S a-oorrfpLas.
NE. 2X2. To TTolov;
HE. ToSto o br] ir]poLS Kal vypots kol kfLiTVpoLS kol
diTvpoLS TTairrobaTTbv etbos ipyaadev dyyelov [o bi]] fiLa K\.r]a-L
7Tpoa-(pdyy6fX9a, Kal fxdXa ye a-vxi^bv elbos Kal Trj ^r]TovfXvr] 10
ye, ats oi/xat, TTpoa-riKov ovbV dTxyG>s iTTLarrtfxrf. 288

NE. 2X2. Ilws ydp ov;
HE. ToVTOOV br] TpLTOV TpOV clboS KTr]fxdTOt)V TTdfXTToXv
KaT0TTT0v Trcfoi' *cat wbpov Kal TTokvTT\avS Kal diTXaves
C 4 Sti om. pr. T C 8 S-îrov] 5 irov B irov T d 6 ;âAirb']

:
XaKtirhv fifv T sed fifv punctis notatum d 8 fo^riv is Campbell

ojs iartv B cts iariv T
: fffriv Hermann
: e i o5 t&jj'] avruv B
e 5 alriai VTjyvvvrai B T 6 8 (col (ftirvpois koI cnrvpois om. B
69^5^ secl. Hermann &2 oV secl. Schleiermacher
a88a nAATfiNOS
5 Kal TLfXLov Kal &.TIIJLOV, ^v b 6vo\ia <ixov, 8ion "nav tvfKii
TLVos ^(f)4bpas la-TL, 6aK09 6.(C Ttvi yiyv6ix(vov.
NE. 2X2. To TTOLOv;
EE. "Ox^M** clvt6 ttov \(yofiv, ov itaw itoAitikt/s
ipyov, dAAa imKKov ttoAu TiKTOVLKrji koX KfpaixLKiji Kal

lo X"^'^*"^'"'^'^^'
NE. 2X2. Mavedvu).
b EE. T^ 8^ T^TapTov; ap' tTfpov elvaL TovTUiv Xktov,
iv (S To, TrAcioTd i<rTL T(av TToAai pr]$VT(DV, ((rOrji re ot;/x-
TTacra Kal tG>v ottKoov t6 ttoKv kol Tetx^ TTavra B' ocra yrjLva
TTpLl3Krip.aTa Kal KCdLva, Kal fxvpCa Tpa; TTpojBoKrjs be

5 tvcKa (TvpLTTdvTMV avT&v (lpya<rp.ev(tiv SifcaioTaT' hv okov
TTpoarayopivoLTo iTp6^kr]p.a, koll TroAAo) fxaAAor Ti)(vris ol-
KobopiLKrjs tpyov Kal v(f)airrLKr]S to TTKelcTTOv vop.CôLT av
opdoTepov ri ttoAitik^s.
NE. 2X2. Yldvv jxev ovv.
C SE. YlifXTTTOV be ap' hv i6e\oLfXV Tb Tre pl tov KocrpLOV
Kal ypa(f>LKr]v 6eZvaL kol o(ra TavTr] iTpo(r\p(!)]x(va koX px}V(TLKi\

]XLpLr]p.aTa TeAeiTat, 'npos tcls ybovas pLovov f]fx(iiv dircipya-
(rpLva, bLKaCcos 8' hv dvojxaTL TTpL\r](f>6VTa kvC;
5 NE. 2X2. noiw;

SE. WaCyvL^v ttov tl AcyeTat.
NE. 2X2. T^ p.r]v;
SE. Toirro toCvvv tovtols (V ovo]xa ^Tract iTpeêi iTpoq--
ayopiv6iv' ov yap (nrovbfjs ovb^v avT&v xdpiv, dAAa iraiSias
10 e.VKa TTdvTa bpcLTaL.
d NE. 2X2. Kai tovto (rxfbov n fxav6dv(a.

SE. To b^ TTd(TLV TOrVTOLS (TcifXaTa TTapiXOV, l^ <aV KCU
h< ots br]fXLovpyov(rLV oTroo-at t&v TexvHv vvv elprji^TaL,
TTavTobairbv elbos ttoW&v iTfpoiV TiyvSiV (Kyovov ov, ap

5 oux '^t^Tov 6r](ropLv;
a8 xiyofjLf oxi] \tyofXfyov pr. B ba iirOri ri<rrf B l>3 ^']

8' BT C4 ivinara B C6 irov r] ti 5J> T d i ti
scripsi : ^ti B : om. T d4 jf om. T
:
nOAITIKOS 288d
NE. SX2. To TTolov bi] Aeyet?;

HE. Xpvaov T Kol apyvpov koI TravO^ oiroa-a fxeroA-
Xeverai Kal oaa bpvoTopnKr} Kai Kovpa (Tvp.TTa(ja Tepivovaa
Trapeyjei. rc/croyiKT/ koX nkeKTiKr\' koa. ti Âoto-rtKTj (f)VT<Jov
T Kol ^fx^x^^ hipfxaTa (Tu>ixaT(av itepiaLpoxxra (rKVTOTOixLKi], e

Kal 0(rat Trepl to. roiairra ctcrii' Tiyyai, koX (f)kX.<av koI ^v^kuiv
Ka\ 8eo-jU(Sy (pya(rTi,Kal Trapicrôv brjfxiovpyelv <rvv6eTa ck /xt)
(TvvTidefXfvcov etbr] yev&v. v be avTo iTpo^rayopevofxev irav

To Trp(OToy(ves av6p(oTTOLS KTrjfxa kol a(ruv6f.T0V Kal â^rLkiKifS 5
fTTL(TTr]fxr]s ovbafX(as epyov ov.
NE. 212. KoAcSs.
HE. Trjv br] TTJs Tpo(f)r]S kttj^tlv, Kal ocra t? to (TwpLa
(TvyKaTafxeLyvvfxeva kavT<jiv fxep^^TL fxepr] a(afxaT0s ets t6
dcpaiTfv^raL TLva bvvafXLV elkrfxê, kcKTiov l3bofxov ovofxd- 289
(ravTas avTo (rvfXTrav rjfx&v etyai rpoôv, et fxrf tl Kakkiov
4xpfXV akX.0 64(r6aL' ye^tipyLKrj 8e xat 6r]pVTLKr] Kal yvfxva-
(TTLKfi Kal laTpLKfi Kttl ixayLpLKrj TTaV VTT0Tl6VTS 6p66TpOV

aiTob(a(ropLV rf Tff TToAtrtKT/. 5
NE. 211. nd)? yap ov;
HE. 2xf8oy tolvvv ocra exerat /crr/o-eco?, irkr^v Toiv
fjfxepcov C^ôiV, kv TOVTOLS kiTTa oXfxaL yivecTLV elpfjcrâL.
(TKOTTjEL bi' rfv yhp 8t*catorara fxev av T^dkv Kar apxcis t6

TTpcoToyeves etSo?, fxeTO. 8e tovto opyavov, ayyelov, oxrffxa, b
TTp6pkr]fxa, TTaCyvLov, ^pepfxa. (a) iTapak^LTTOfxev 8e', et
rt fxr] fxiya kekrfêv, eis rt rovr coi; bvvar^v apfxoTTeLv,

oXov ff Tov vofXL(rfxaTos lb4a Kal (r^^payibdiv koll iTavTos
XapaKTrjpos. yivos re yap V avTols TavTa ovbev exet 5
fXya (Tvvvofxov, akXa to, fxev ei? K6(rpov, to. be et? 6p-
yava ^l(i fxiv, ofxcos 8e TTdvToas kkK^fxeva (rvfx^fxavrjaei.
To, 8e TTcpl ('^(Jiiv KTrja-LV t&v rjfxipuiv, irkrfv bovkdiv, f]
d 6 T^ om. B e I ffKvroTomK-l} secl. Stallbaum e 2 PvfiXav B

kvkXwv D pi$\av T: e4 irpocrayopfvwfxfv al. Stallbaum e 8 rpo-
<pvs] <Trpo<piKrjs B b 2 & add. Madvig vapa\(iiro/ji(vov pr. T
bs Tovrwv] rovTtov fifja nl. : rovrwv /Ji6yis ci. St&Uhaum b8 ^^t-
ptov^ ri/jifTfpwp B
289 c IlAATiiNOS
C TTpoTepov dycXaiOT/aoîK^ bi.aixepia-6elaa nivr ctAj<îita
ava<f)avtTai.
NE. 2X2. ndvv ix^v ovv,
EE. To be brj bovKoiv kuI ii&vTuiV VTrqpcTOiv X.onr6v, (v
5 ol? TTov Kal fjiavTvop.ai. tovs Ttepl avTo to TrAey/xa apL(f)i<T^r]-
TOvvTas T(o /3a<nAe? Karacâvcis yVT^(r(rdai, Kaddnfp tols

{xpdvTais t6t tovs itepX to vrjdeiv re k<u âivuv koX ocra
aAAa (Ittoplv. oi bi oAAoi Trdires, ws (rvvaLTi.oi K(xd4vTs,
ap.a TOis epyois Tols vvvbr] pr}del(nv diÂojrrai Kal aTnyoipi-
d (r9rj(rav aTTO /Sao-iAiKjJy re Kal TToAtrtK^s TtpdêoiS.

NE. 212. 'Eot/cao-t your.
EE. "I^t brf aKe\j/(jip.da tovs AotTTOuy Trpoo-eAôWcs

kyyvdiv, Xva avTOvs (lbS>p.(v j3eftat6Tpov.
5 NE. 212. OvKovv XPV'
EE. Tov? fikv br] /xeytWous vwrfpiTas, y kvdivbf Ibdv,
TovvavTiov i)(pvTas vpicrKop.v ols VTTO)irTev(TapL(v ^7rtr^8er/xa
Kai Trdôy.
NE. 212. Tivas!
lo SE. Tous d)vr)Tovs re Koi T<f rpoTKf TOVT<f KrrjTOvs' ois
e &vapL(})i,(r(3r]TriT(i)s 8ovAous l^*'/***' fi'"'"!'; rJKiara âa-tXiKrjs
flTaTTOI.OVIXVOVS TX^''l^'
NE. 212. nd)9 8' ov;

EE. Ti b4; tQv ikevOepoiv 5o-ot rots wvbr] pr\6Z(rLv ils
5 VTTr]pTLKr]v (K6vTes avTovs Tdrrov^TL, Td re y(Dpyias Kal tcl
tS)v &XK(t)v T\vS)v fpya 8taKo/iiôrres Itt' dAAÂous koI

dvLO-OVVTfS, OL fJLV KaT dyopds, ol 8c 7t6KlV iK Tt6\0)S
dX.\dTTOVTS KaTo. ddXaTTav Kal ttc^^, rd/xto-/xd re Trpoj rd
dAAa Kal avTo iTpbs avTo 8ia/xet/3orres, ots dpyvpapLotôvs re
290 Kai ipLTrdpovs Kal vavKki^povs Kal KairqKovs iTTO)vop.dKap.(v,

p,S)V Trjs TToKLTLKrjs dpL(t)Lcrj3r]Tr](rova-i tl;
NE. 212. Tdx' ^v lao)s r^y yc tS)V ifnTopevTLK&v.
C I itdtrr''} irdvras T Ca ivacpcwtlrou'] livatpalvfTai B d4 tSet-

fxfv Ast d7 into-wTtiaofttv ^.sic) T e 5 an S/xnptaia ? Campbell
ra BD : tJlsT
nOAITIKOS 290 a
HE. 'AA.A' ov ij.-i]v ovs ye opoifjLev [xktOcotovs Kal ^^ray
Traa-Lv iTOLfxoTaTa VTn]p(T0VVTas, \xri TTore (3acrLki,K^s ixeTa- 5
TroLov[j.ivovs (vpuiixev.
NE. 212. U(os yap;

HE. Ti 8e apa tovs to. roiaSe Sta/corowras tjixlv kKaoTOTe;
NE. 20. Ta TToia eiTTfs kol TLvas;
HE. ^^v To KTipvKLKov fdvos, oo-oL T TTepl ypap.p.aTa b
a-o(f)ol yiyvovTaL iroKkaKLS VTnipfrâavTes, Kal ttoAA' aTTa
Tpa TTpl TCLS apXaS bLaTTOVda-daC TLVCS TpOL TTavbeLVOL,
TL TovTovs av Aefofifi';
NE. 2X2. "OTTep eiTres vvv, vTrqpeTas, aXX* ovk avTovs ev 5
rai? TToAeo-iy apxovTas.

HE. 'AAAa ov \xt]v 0L\xaL ye (vvttvlov iboi>v lttov TavTi]
TTTf] (f)aviqa-a-daL tovs bLa<f)p6vT0is afx<\>La-^r]TOvvTas ttjs ttoAi-
TLKTJs. KaLTOL a-(f)6bpa ye oltottov av eimi 8o'eie to C^reii'

TOVTOVS V VTTT]pTLKfi p.OLpa TLvL C
NE. 2X2. KoixLbrj ixkv ovv.
HE. "Ert 8^ TTpoa-ixeC^coixcv kyyvTepov eTTi roi? {x-qTTU)
(3l3aa-avLa-ixVovs. eio"t be ot re Trept ixavTLKr]v (Xovt^s

TLVos iTTLOTrjixris bLaK^vov ixopLov kpixr]veuTaX ydp ttov 5
voixLôvTaL TTapa êwy dvOpfaiTOLS.
NE. 2X2. Nai.

HE. Kai ixT]v KoX To T&v Lpi(i)v av yivos, u)s t6 vdixLpLov
(f)r]a-L, TTapd p.ev rnxStv bcopeds êots 8ta dva-L(av cTTLcrTrjix^v

ioTL KaTd vovv KLvoLS b(j)pLa-daL, TTapd be Klv(dv t]ixlv eu- d
Xais KTrj<nv dyad&v aiTrja-aadaL' TavTa 8"e bLaKdvov Tix^r^s
eoTt TTOV ix6pLa dix(f>6Tpa.
NE. 2X2. 4>atverat yovv.
HE. "Hbr] TOLJWV ixoL boKOvixev ol6v yi tlvos txvovs e(^' 5
o TTopevîxeOa iTpoadTTTea-OaL. t6 ydp br] t5)V Upduov axrjixa
Kal t6 tu>v ixdvT(i)V V ixdXa (f)povr]p.aTos iTk-qpovTaL Kal
a5 (Tot/jiSTaTa] fToinofS T : kToifjLOvs vulg. b2 ir6\\' J^TTa]

iroWa T6 B bp T^] Tov B C 4 Te om. B d. 5 ye Tiyos
T : yfiTovos B et in marg. yp. T
29od nAATGNOS
boâv (rffxvi^v XafxfiavH hia to fxeyeOos Tdv iyxfiprjji&TOiV,
a>OT Trepl fxiv AtyvTTTov ov8' Ifeort /3ao-i\ca x^P'-^ iepaTLKfjs
e apyeiv, aAA' eav apa Kal tvxJ] TtpoTfpov e^ oAAou yevovs
îa(Tap.evos, vaTepov avayKalov ds tovto ioreAeTo-âi avTov
To yivos' (Ti be Kal Tutv 'F.WrjV(i}v TToWaxov rais p.yL(TTais
ap\aXs Ta jxeyia-Ta tS>v irepl to. TOiavTa 6vp.aTa evpoi. tis
5 h.v TTpoa-TaTTopieva 6vLV. Koi bt] Kal Ttap' vp.iv ovy^ rjKiara
brjXov o Aeyco' to) yap AaxoVri âo-tAft (})a(nv Trjbe Ta
aep-voTaTa KoiX p.aKL(TTa irdiTpLa T(Sr ap\aLoiV 6v(tl5)V airo-
beboa-âL.
NE. 2X2. Kal ttclvv ye.
291 SE. TovTovs T TOLWV Tovs Kkr\p(jiTovs âaiXeas &ixa

Koi Upeas, Kal vTTrjpcTas avT&v Kai TLva tTepov 7ra/xiroAw
oxAoy (TKeTTTeov, os apTL KaTabrjXos vvv i]pxv yiyovev
aTT0y0i>pL(T6ivTOiV TUIV ep.TTpo(T6(v.
5 NE. 2X2. Ttvas 8' avrovs xal Xeytis;

SE. Kat p.aXa TLvas cltottovs.
NE. 2i2. Tt 8^;
SE. Udix^pvXov TL yivos avT&v, uts ye 5.pTi (TKOTTOvp.evi^
(jyaLveTaL. ttoAAoi fxkv yap Aeovo-i tS>v dvbputv eigao-i Kai Kev-
b TOVpOLS KOLL TOLOVTOLdLV eTepOLS, TTdfXTToWoL bc XaTVpOLS Kai

Tots da-devea-L kol TTokvTpoTTOLS ^rjpioLS' Ta\v bi fxcTokkdT-
TovaL Tds Te Ibeas Kal Trfv bvvap.LV els oAAtjAovs. /cai fxevToi
fiOL vvv, u> '2(aKpaTes, dpTL boKU> KaTavevorjKevaL tovs dvbpas.
5 NE. 212. Aeyots dv eoLKas ydp dTOTTov tl Ka6opdv.

SE. Nat- To ydp dTOTTov e^ dyvoCas Trao-t a-vfxjSaLvei,
Kal ydp brf Kal vvv avTos Toirr' eTTadov eâL^pvrjs rifx(peyv6r]aa
C KaTiSajy tov TTepl Ta Tutv TTokeuiv TrpdypiaTa xopov.

NE. 212. noioi;;
SE. Tor TTdvToiv TUiV a-o(pL(TTUiV fieyLaTOV yorfTa kol
dg Upcorucris B: laTpiKrjs al. 64 an Ovfiirwv ? Campbell

as vvv supra versum T as 8' om. B a8 5j yt] &(Trt B
&prt] aprlus T b2 ij.tr a\\d(r(rov(xi T b 7 koI 7^ . . . vvv
0111. pr. B C3 ao<(>i(rruv} <to<(>wv B
nOAITIKOS 29i(
ravrrj? ttjs rix^V^ ^fJ.TieipOTarov' ov cmo tu)V ovtcos ovtuiv

7coXltlku>v Kat âcriXiKS^v Kaiircp TrayxaXeTTov ovTa acâipiiv 5
a(f)aipTov, el fxeXXopLev ibelv kvapyuts to CrjTovfjLevov.

NE. 2X2. 'AAAa p.r}v tovto ye ovk avTôv.
HE. OvKovv bri KaT(i ye ttjv e/u,^y. KaC pLOL (f)pd^ Tobe.
NE. 212. To TTOLov;
EE. 'Ap' ov ixovapyJ,a toiv TroXiriKwy Tjfuv dpyjav eort /xia; d.
NE. 212. Na^.

HE. Kai juera yiovap\Lav ctTTot ris ar oXjj.aL ttjv vtto tcov
oXiydiv bvvacTTeLav.
NE. 212. nwj 8' ov; 5
HE. TpLTov 8e cryrjpxL TrokLTeCas ovx rj tov TiXridovs dpxji>
brjpLOKpaTCa TOvvop.a KkrjOelcra;
NE. 212. Kat Trdw ye.

HE. Tpeis 8' ovorat fzaiy ov irevTe TpoTTOV tlvcl yCyvovTaL,
bv' e^ kavTa>v oAAa Trpos avrals ovopiaTa rtKrouo-at; 10

NE. 212. noia bri;
HE. ITpos t6 jSCaLov ircw Kal e/cowtoy aTroo-KOTroCrres e

iwv Kal irevCav k<u ttXovtov kol vojxov Kal dvopiCav iv avrals
yLyv6p.eva bLTrXrjv CKaTepav tolv bvocv bLaLpovvTcs ixovapxCav
jxev TTpocrayopevovcrLV o)? bvo TTapXop.vr]v etbri bvolv ovoixacn,
TvpavvCbL, t6 be âcrLkLKr\. 5
NE. 212. Tt ixriv;
HE. Triv be vtt' dkCyoiv ye eKdaroTe KpaTriOeta-av ttoKlv

dpLcrTOKparCci koX 6X.LyapxCq.
NE. 212. Kat iTdw ye.
HE. AripLOKparCas ye {xriv, edvr ovv /3taicos edvre eKOva-Cuis 10
T&v TCLS ovcrCas kxdvTOiV t6 ttXtjOos dpxjl, Kal edirre tovs 293
vdfxovs dKpLJB&s (})vXdTT0V kdvre ixri, jrdzrrcos rovvoixa oiêXs
avrfjs eldiOe ixeTaXXdrTeLV.
NE. 212. 'AAjj^.
C 4 6vT<ioy\ 6 rSov B C5 ir<ry;^tt\eiro'] x**^*"'^*' ^ ^^ ^^

om. B 6 5 (rh /*i') rvpavviSi Cornarius e8 apiffTOKparia,
/coi l>\iyapxi<i vulg. a i ou<r/os] Qvalas B
agaa nAAT12N0S
5 HE. Tt ovv; ol6ixi6a. riva tovtmv r&Jy ttoX.itmv opOijv
flVaL TOVTOLS TOLS OpOLS 6pL(r6L<TaV, kvl KOL okLyOLS KOL
TToXX.ols, Kal TrAovra) Kal TTevia, kol roi ^Laic^ koI kKovaiui, kol
fxeTCL ypanfxaTCtiV Kal avev v6p.a)V crvp.âivova-av yiyv^crdaL;

NE. 2X2. Ti yap 8r) /cat KcaXvfL;
b HE. 2K07ret 87/ (ra(f)crTpov rfj8e kmfxevos.

NE. 212. Ufj;
HE. To) priOivTL Kara TT/awras TTOTepov fp.fXvovfxev 17
8ta<^cov^(ro/:iev;
5 NE. 2X2. To) 8?) TToto) keyeLs;

HE. Ttji; âcrLkLKrjv ap)(i]v t5)V (TTLcrTrjfxtav elvai TLva
(f)afXV, olfxaL.
NE. 212. Nat'.
HE. Kai TovToov ye ovx, airacroiv, dAAa KpLTLKrjv hrfTTOV
10 TLva Kal eTTLo-TaTLKrfv k tS>v aXX(ov 7Tpoik6fxeda.

NE. 2X2. Nai.
HE. KCLK TTJS iTTKrTaTiKtjs T^r fx^v 1t' o^vxôls epyoLS,
C Tr\V 8' ^TTl ^()01S' Kai KaTO, TOVTOV bt} TOV Tp6lT0V fXepiÔVTfS
bevp^ det TTpoeKrfkvdafxev, eiTLO-Ti^fxrfs ovk eTTL\avdav6fxevoL, to
8' i^rts ov\ LKavGis tto) bvvdfxevoi 8taK/)t/3co(racrâi.
NE. 2X2. Aeyeis opdQs.
6 HE. ToCr' avTo Toiwv ap^ evvoovfxev, ort tov opov
ovK 6X.iyovs ovhe ttoXXovs, ovhe to eKova-Lov ovhe to
aKova-LOv, ovh\ iTeviav ovbe TrX.ovTov yiyveadaL Trepl avTu>v
Xpedv, aXXd TLva eTTLaTrffxrfv, eLiTep aKoXovOrfaofxev tols
TTpâdev;
d NE. 2X2. 'AA.Aa fxrfv tovt6 ye dbvvaTov fxif TTOLelv.
HE. 'E^ dvdyKrjs brf vvv tovto ovtoo aKeiTTeov, ev rtVt

TTOTe TOVTO)V eTTLaTrjfirf avfxjBaiveL yiyveaOaL iTepX dvdp(0TT(i)V
dp\rjs, aêbbv x^^^'"^'""?* '^"^ fieyiarqs KTrfaaadaL.

Trjs
5 8er ydp IbeLV avrrfv, tva deaadfxeOa TLvas dâLpeTeov dTTo
ag Kui\vfiv D b6 Pa<TiX^v T riva] t< B C3 tJtisI

^v Tis B : IjrTis T iro^] Triwj BT : vou vulg. C 5 ainh om. T
C9 iixirpoadfv T
nOAITIKOS 292d
Tov (f^povC^wv fiacn.\iais, ot TrpocnroLovvTai /iej elvaL TroAiTiKot
Ka\ TTeCOovcn Trokkovs, eio-t 8e ovbafx&s.

NE. 212. Aet yap 8?/ Trotety roCro, d)s 6 Ao'yos rjpXv
TTpoeCprfKev.
HE. Mwy ovv boKeX TrX.rj66s ye ey 7ro'Aet Tavrrjv ti]V e

eTTtoTrj/XTji; Suyarov etvat KTr\(racr6ai;
NE. 212. Kat ttws;

EE. 'AAA' apa kv îKiavbpca 7ro'Aet SvyaTOf eKaTo'y Ttmy
t/ Kat Trei^TT/ Koi^ra avTî' iKavSis KTrjo-aa-âi; 5
NE. 212. 'Pao-TTj ixevTav ovtm y eiT/ TracrSiV twv t^x-

V(av' ta-jxev yap otl )(tAtcoi> avbpa>v aKpoi TrerTevTai toctovtoi
Trpos Tovs V Tols oAAoi? "EAAijo-ty ovk av yivoivTo itot,
fxr] tl brf jSacriATjs ye. 8ei yap 8?) tov ye Tr}V /3ao-tAtK?;r
iyovTa iTTLa-Tyjixrjv, av t apxjj Kal eav p.r\, KaTO. tov e/x- lo
TTpoa-6e Xoyov o/xoos /Sao-tAtKoy Trpocrayopeva-6at.. 293

HE. KaA&i? aTTp.vrip.6vV(ras. kiT^p.^vov 8e ot/xat tovto)
Tr;y ix\v dp6r]V ap\r]v TTCpl iva Tiva Ka\ bvo koX iTavTa.TTaa-LV
oKCyovs 8et ^rjTelv, oTav 6p6i] yCyvrjTaL,
NE. 212. Ti p.r]v; 5
HE. TovTou? 6e ye, edvTe (k^vtcov avT aK^vTcav &px(o-
CTLV, avT KaTO. ypapLp.aTa edvTe avev ypap.]xdT(i>v, KaX
kav ttXovtovvt(s rj ttv6ixVol, voixLcrTeov, u>cnTp vvv r]yov-
]X6a, KaTO. Txvr\v ^vtlvovv apxqv dpypvTas, tovs laTpovs
8e oi^x. ViîCTa vevofxCKafxev, eai^re eKdvTas edvTe aKovTas b
îxds loivTaL, TîxvovTcs rj KdovTcs rj TLva oAAt/v dXyribdva
TTpoa-diTTOVTes, KOL av KaTCL ypdixp.aTa r/ xcopls ypaixixdTuiv,
Kal fCLV TTevr^T^s ovTes r] ttXovo-lol, TTdvTcas ovbev rJTTOv
laTpovs (f)apLV, (oa-TTp av (TTLo-TaTOvvTes Texyri, Ka6aCpovTS 5

etre aAAco? lcrxyaCvovTS etre Kai av^dvovTiS, av p-dvov e7r
dya6(^ T(a t&v acaixdTcav, /3eATta) TrotowTes eK x.etpwcoy,

crw^cocrii; ot êpaTTfVOVTGS iKacTTOL tcl 6epaTTiv6p.eva' TavTji c
e I ra{ni\v\ abrîv B a4 oXiyov B ^tiv Stephanus a7 Karit

B : Kara rkT b4 ouSei'] ouSe B b6 al om, B
PLATO, VOL. I. 32
293 c nAATflNOS
Orjcroixev, w? oi/xai, koL ovk aAAr/, tovtov opov opdov etvat
pLovov laTpiKijs Kol &.KKr]s fj(rTivo(rovv a.p)(T]s
NE. 212. Kop.ibfi fi^v ovv,

5 EE. 'AvayKoiov 8?) Kal iroXirfiwy, y ôiKc, Tavrqv 6p&r]v
bia(f)ep6vT(t)S eivai koI p.6vr}v iroX.iTeCav, iv ^ Tis ^v ivpi(TKOL
Tovs ap)(ovTas oXr^dQs fTTtoTTj/ioras koI ov boKovvTas p.6vov,
kavTf. KaTo. v6povs iavTe avev v6pL(iiv ap$oa-i,, Kal (k6vt(v rj
d aK6vT(av, Kot 'nv6p,Voi t/ TrkoxrrovvTes, TOVTOiV inroX.oyiaTeov
ovbiv ovbaix(as elvai Kar ovbenCav opd^rrjTa.

NE. 212. KaX(os.
HE. Kat edvTi ye aTTOKTdvvvTfs Ttvas ri xat e/c/3a\A.oi'rfs
5 KadaCpaxnv (tt dyaO^ rqv TrdKiv, fire Kai aTTOtKtas otoi'
a-prjvri /jteAtrrwy eKiTep.TTOVTes ttoi crpLKpoTepav TTOLôa-iv, ?/
rtyas eTTeia-ayoiMevoC tto6(v aAAous ^^(nOfv TroXtras irotowrcs

avTiiv av^(aa-LV, ((aa-iTep dv iTTLa-Trip.ri /cat rw St/cato) TTpocr-
XP(apLevoL (TiaôvTes (k x^Cpovos /3eArta> 'jrotcSa-t /cara bvvap.iv,
e TavTTiv t6t Kal KaTO, Tovs TOLOVTOvs opovs fjpiv p6vriv opdriv
TTokLTeCav LvaL prjTeov oaas 8' oAAas \4yopev, ov yvriaCas

ov8' ovrco? ovcras AeKrôy, dAAa ppLprip.vas Tavrriv, hs piv
b)S vv6povs \yoixv, ^TTL TCL KaAAto), Tas bi dAAas eTri to.
5 atcr^^tom [/xe/:>ii/J.^crât].
NE. 2X2. Ta p.V dXXa, o) êVe, fiTpC(i)s loiKev elprja-daL'
TO 8e Kat avV v6p(i)V beZv dp\LV \aXiT(i)Tpov dKOVLV ppridri.
HE. MLKp6v y i($6ris /xe p6pVos, 2 2c)Kpares. e/xeA-
294 Aof ydp o-e StepcorTjo-eti/ raCra n6Tpov dTTobexii TtdvTa, rj tl
Kal bvaxpaCvLs tS)V Xx6VT(i)v vvv 8' ijbri (âvpov ort

TOVTO ÔvXria-6p6a TO TTp\ Trjs t5)V dvV v6[Mt)V dpx6vT(Ji)V
6p66TriTos 8teA0ety rnids.

5 NE. 2i2. US)s ydp ov;
C 2 Q^ffonfv] <t>i,ffofxtv T C5 wokiTti&t''] woXiTflcw B C6 810-

iptpivrws 6p6i)v T dI Kal\ ^ T d8 fteffwtp^ &ffwfp B
e 2 yvriffias] yvrjfflus T e3 &r fiiv i>s Stallbaum ^4i ftiv Heindorf :
aiTfifvus B : afffxfvus T 64 ^tI tAJ ^xetra B 5 fitfufxriffdax secl.

Stallbaum
nOAlTIK02 294 a
HE. TpoTTOV Tcva yAvTOi hrikov otl ttjs /SacrtXiK^s eoTiy

7] VOjJLodeTLKri' t6 8' apLCTTOV OV TOVS VOfJLOVS ((TtIv ia-)(VLV
dAA' avbpa tov [xeTa (})povri(T(os âa-LkLKov. olad^ oitr);
NE. 2X2. ntj hr) \4yLs;

HE. "Ort voixos ovK av ttotc bvvaLTO t6 re apLo-TOV Ka\ 10
To bLKaLOTaTov aKpLJScis 7ra(rLv ap.a TrepLXaôuv to pikTLcrTov b
iTTLTCLTTCLV' al yap avoixoLorqTfs Tcav re avOpcaiToov Kal t&v
TTpdêcov Kal to jxrjbeiTOTe fxrjbfv ws eiTOs eiTreiy r](Tvyiav
ay(LV TcHv avOpcDTTLvoiv ovbev (Jo(rLV aTrXovv kv ovb^vl TTepl

aTTavTOiv KOL eTTt TtdvTa Tov xpovov d7TO({)aLV(T6aL Texyrjv 5
ovb' rjVTLvovv. Tavra bi] a-vyyu>povp.iv ttov;

NE. 2X2. Tt ixriv;
HE. Tbv 8e ye vopiov 6pS>ixV (rxb6v kir' avT6 tovto

(TVVTLvovTa, &(nTp TLVo, dvOpojTTOv avOdbr] Kal dixaOrj Kal C
ixr]bva ixr]bV kStVTa Trotety TTapa Tr^v kavTov Td^LV, ixr]b^
eirepoiTav fxrjbcva, /xr;6' dv tl viov dpa t(o a-vixâLvrj îXrLov

Trapd t6v Xoyov ov avT^s TTTa^V.
NE. 2X2. Âkr]6ri' TTOtet ydp aT^xyias Ka6d7Tp tpr]Kas 5
vvv 6 voixos rjiuv eKacrrotS'.
HE. OvKovv dbvvaTOV v e^êty tt/sos tcl fxr]bTTOT aTrXa tt
ro 8ta Trarros yLyv6fXvov aiTkovv;

NE. 2X1. KLvbvvVL.
HE. Ata rt brf ttot ovv dvayKoXov vop.o6TXv, iTLbriTTp 10
ovK 6p66TaTov 6 v6ix osj_ dvvpTov TovTov Trjv olTLav. 6.
NE. 2X2."lrnt5;
HE. OvKovv Kcu TTap* vp.LV l(TL TLVs otat Kat V oAAats
TToAeo-tv ddp6o)V dv6p(i)7TO}v do"/c7;o-ets, etre Trpos bpdpov eire
irpos dWo TL, (f)LXovLKLas VKa; 5
NE. 2X2. Kat TTdvv ye TroAAat.

HE. 4>epe vvv dvaXd^(i)p.v TTdX.Lv fxviqp.r] Tas Toiv Txvrf
yvp.va(6vT0iv e-TTirdêis v tols TOLavTaLS dpxo.ls.
a6 (jLiVToi rivh. T b i afxa vacriv T b2 îriTaTTtj B re

om. T b 3 t6] tov B T d>s dirfTv iroj T c2 /iijSeVa om. T"
C3 Tijj (TvfxfiaivTi] rb ffvfiâv ^ B , d4 adp6ov B : aOpoov T
32*
294 d nAATI2N0S
NE. 212. To TTolov;
10 HE. "Ori kcjTTOvpyeiv ovk kyyuipiiv rjyovvrai KaO^ va
^KaCTTOV, T(0 (T^fXaTL TO TTpOcrTJKOV efcdoTO) Trpoa-TaTTOvTes,
e akXa TtayyTepov oXovrai bdv a)S CTri to "nokv koX ctt^ ttoA-
Xovs Tr]v Tov \v<Ti,TXovvTos Tols autp.ao-L TlOKLa-Oai Ta^LV.
NE. 2X2. KaAcS?.
HE. Aio 8?; ye koi 10-0115 ttovovs vvv 8t8ovres aOpooLS
5 a/Att jLtei' ôpp.Qi(TLv, ap.a he kol KaTairavova-L bpofxov kol

TrdXrjs Kal irdvTUiv tG>v Kara to. au>p.aTa Tr6v<ov.
NE. 2X2. "Eo-ri TavTa.
HE. Kal Tov vop.o6Tr]v tolvvv riyoi[xcda, tov rato-ii;
dyiXaLS kTtLa-TaTrfo-ovTa tov hLKaiov TrepL kol tG>v irpbs dAArj-
295 Aovs a-vixôXamv, p,r] Trod' LKavov yevqa-earOaL TTaa-LV ddpooLS

irpofrTdTTovTa dKpLJ3(as kvl KdaT(o to TTpoaTJKOv d7ro5i5oVai.
NE. 2X2. To yovv (Ikos.
HE. 'AAAa To TOLs TToAAot? ye ot/iat Kat ws tTrt t6 ttoAu

5 Kat TTcos ovToxrl TraxvTepoos eKdaTOLS tov v6p.ov OrjaeL, Kal iv
ypdixixaaLV dirobLbovs Kal kv dypafXfxdTOLS, iraTpLOLS b\ (OeaL
voixoOcTwv.
NE. 2X2. 'OpeS>s.
HE. 'OpOws ixdvTOL. TTw? ydp dv tls LKavbs yevoLT' dv
b "Jrore, a> '2(0KpaTs, c3o-re 5ia (3lov dei TTapaKadrjixevos iKaoTO)

81' aKpLêCas TTpoaTdTTeLV Tb TTpoarJKOv; eTret tovt' dv bvvaTos
S>v, b>s 0Lp.aL, tS>v Tr]V âo-tAtKTJi; oo-rio-ow ovt(i>s e-Trto-n/jiiTji'
lXri(f)6T(i>v aôKi] ttot dv kavTw OelT fpLTTobCaixaTa ypd(pipv

5 Tovs AexêVra? tovtovs vdixovs.
NE. 2X2. 'Ek rwv vvv yovv, S> êve, eipjj/xeVcov.
HE. MdAAoy 8e' ye, S> /3e'ArtoTe, iK tS>v ix?0\.6vT(t>v
pr]9riaadai.
NE. 2X2. Tti^toy 8j/;
10 HE. Tcii; rotwrSe. et7rco/iey ydp br] tTpos ye fip.ds avTovs
65 5^Kol]8^T e6 Tck om. B e8 raT^riv^ ratTtv B ar /it?-
Tfl'B a 5 &^<retv B T a 9 &i' om. B b i df i Stit fiiov T

b a îTf i] îrl B b 4 avTw OfJT' B b 10 (fro/u*' B
; ;
nOAITIKOS 295C
laTpbv /xeXAoyra rj kuC riva yvixvacTTiKov aTTobruielv koI C

aiTa-a'6aL tS>v dipaTTevo^j.ivoiV a-vyvov, 0)9 oXoito, yj)6vov,
jxi] fivrjfxovevaeiM oirjOevTa To, irpoa-TaÔivTa tovs yvp-va-

Cofx^vovs rj Tovs KafxvovTas, VTToyuvrijj.aTa ypa(îv hv kOiknv
avToZs, r] TT&s; 5
NE. 2X2. OvTm.
HE. Ti 8' ei TTapa boâv kXaTTOi -^fjpovov cnTobrifXTâ-as
fkdoi Trdktv; ap ovk hv Trap' exewa to. ypapLfxaTa Tokixrjaeiev

akk' VTToOeaOaL, a~vpLJ3ai.v6irr(ov dkkoov /SeAnwcoy roi? xd/i-
vovaL bid TTvevixaTa rj tl Kal dkko TTapd Ti]V ekmba T(dv k d
Alos erepojs TTOis t&V eloiOoTaiv yevojxeva, KapTepQv b' dv
rjyoiTo beZv /ht/ eKâCvcLV Tapxald Trort vopiodeTrjdcvTa
fx-qTi avTov TTpoaTaTTOVTa dkka [xtjtc tov KafxvovTa Tepa
TokfXbiVTa Trapd Ta ypaîvTa bpdv, &>? Tavra ovTa laTpLKd 5
Kal vyLfLvd, ra 8e erepwS' yLyvdfxeva voacabr] re Kal ovk

evTe)(va' 7/ Tray t6 tolovtov 4v ye eTTLcmjixr] crvix(3alvov Kal
dkr]$(L Tiyvr] TTepl diravTa TTavTdTTaaL yikcos dv 6 /xe'ytcrro? e

yCyvoLTO TU)V tolovtwv voixoOeTrifxaTCov
NE. 212. rTayrdTrao-t pikv ovv.
HE. Tw 8e Ta bUaLa br] Kal dbLKa kol Kokd /cat ala)(j}d
Kol dyadd Kal KaKd ypd^f/avTL Kal dypa<f)a vofioOeTrjaavTL 5

rats T&v dvdpdiTcov dyikaLS, OTToaaL KaTd irokLV Iv kKdcrTaLS
vofxevovTaL /cara tovs tQ>v ypa\l/dvT(av vofxovs, dv 6 fxeTa

TexvrfS ypd\pâs ij tls Tpos ofxoLOS d(f)LKr]TaL, /xt) eêVro) 8?/
Trapa Tavra eTepa TTpoa-TdTTCLV ; 7] Kal tovto t6 dTTopprjfxa 296

ovbev rJTTOv dv Klvov Trj dkriOeCci yekolov (f>aLVOLTo;
NE. 2i2. Ti ixr]v;
HE. Oio-^' ovv eTTt rw T0L0VT(a koyov t6v Trapd tQv

TTokkutv keyoixevov 5
NE. 2i2. OvK kvvo^ vvv y ovT(as.
HE. Kai ixi]v evTTpeTrqs. (f)aa-L ydp brj beXv, et ris
C I riva om. B C3 om. B yii); ixvnfj.ovfvfLvT C] S' et']
ial f j T : 5^) B 09 inroTiOfffdai T d4 aA.Ao T e 4 t^

5ej To, 5e Tcf T Stj om. T : post 5e transp. Bekker a i diro/Mj/ia B
;
296 a IlAATilNOS
yiyv(a(TKi. Ttapa tovs t&v ^fJLirpocr0ev ^(XtCovs vofiovs, vofio-
OcTelv T7)i; kavTov ttoAii; ^Kacrrov laCa-avTa, fiAAtoj hk fi^.
lo NE. 212. Ti ovv; ovk opQGis;
b HE. "la-m. hv 8' ovv pJf] iTfCOojv rts îA^-qTai to /3\-
Tiov, aTTOKpivai, tC Tovvofw. TTJs ^Cas ârat; pLT] fiivToi. ttu),
Trepl dk tS)v ^fjLTTpoa-Ocv iTpoTfpov.
NE. SX2. Ylolov 8t; Aeycty;

5 HE. "Av TLS apa p.T] ireCOaiV tov laTpevofKvov, ix^mv hi
opOuiS TTfv Ti\vr]v, TTapa to. yeypapfiiva t6 (3e\TLov avayKACr]
bpav TTaiba 7/ TLva avbpa rj Kal yvvaiKa, tC Tovvofia Tijs
/3ta? eoTat ravrrjs; Sp' ov nav fmWov rj to iTapa ri]v Ti\-

vr]v X^yofievov afidpTr]fj.a to voaSibes; Kal TTovTa opOQs
C (iTTelv ea-TL iTpoTepov ro pLaa-divTL jrepi to tolovtov ttXi]v
OTL voa^dbr] Kal arex^ci TriTTOvdev vtto TUiV /SLaa-afJxvoiV laTpStv;

NE. S12. "Akr]6i(rTaTa XiyiLs.
HE. Tt b\ fjfj.lv br] Tb TTapa Tr]v iToXLTLKrfV Ti\vr]v afi6.p-
S TTifia \ey6fxev6v ia-TLv; ap* ov to aiayjpov KaX [roj KaKov

KOL abLKov;
NE. 2t. riai^rairacri ye.
H E. TcDy 87) ^Laa-OivTinv iTapa to. yfypafifieva Ka\ 7r<irpia

bpav fTfpa 8tKatorepa Kai afieCvo) Ka\ /coAAtco rciii' efnTpoadev,
d <\>ip(, Tov tS)V TOLovT<t>v av \^6yov iTepL ttjs TOLavTrfs ^Cas,
ap\ et /xcAAet fxr] KaTayfXaa-r^TaTos civat iTdvTojv, TTavT
avT(^ /xaAAor XeKTeov (K(xa-TOT TT\r]V (as aL(r)(j)a Kal a8tKa
Koi KaKo. TTfiTovdaa-LV OL ^LaadivTis VTth t5)V ^Laa-afj.V(t)V
5 NE. 2i2. 'AA7jêVrara Ae'yei?.
HE. 'AAA' apa iav fxiv ttXovo-los 6 j3Laa-dfj.(vos 77, 8tKaia,
h.v 8' apa TT(vr]s, dbLKa to. ^Laadfirra iarCv; r] Kav TTfCaas
Kav p.1] TTcCaas tls, TTXova-Los 7/ rrevr^s, 7/ KaTO. ypdfifjxiTa tj
e Trapa ypdp^fiaTa, bpd [fX7/ aijfi<f)opa rj] (rvfj.(f)opa, tovtov 8ct

Kal TTfpl TavTa tov opov flvax tov yt iXr]div(aTaTov opOrji
bi Tij fiii irfldw T \i6 rh otn. B C4 v/juyl *i nh ^

05 0x1 rh] ovrv B rh om. B da ip' 1] ip ij U e 1 nii
rvnfopa ^ del. Comarius Su] 8^ T
nOAITIKOS S96e
Tr6\a>s bioLKi^crecos, ov 6 aro^pos koI ayados avrjp hLOLKrjo-ei
To Ttav apxo^jAvuiv ; uxnrep 6 KvlSepvrjTrjs t6 t^s rccb? Kal
vavTuv dei (rvp.(l>ipov TTapacpvkaTTajv, ov ypan[j.aTa Ttdels 207
aXKa Tr]v Tyvriv v6p.ov 'Kap\6p.evos, a-i^^n. tovs a-vvvavTas,
OVTCi) Kal KaTO, TOV aVTOV Tp^TTOV TOVTOV TTapa tG>v ovtoos
ap\LV bvvap.vcov opd-i] yiyvoiT av TToXiTfCa, Tr]v Trjs T^xvrjs
puip.r]v Tbiv v6[X(ov TTap^xop.ivfov KpciTTd); Kol "navTa Trot.ovcri 5

Tols iJ.(f)pocnv apyovcriv ovk eaTiv apapTr\p.a, pixpnrep av
v p.ya (f)vXaTT(i}(ri., t6 pLTa vov Kal T^xvrjs biKat^TaTOV ael b
bLavep.ovTs Tols iv Tfj TToAei a^êiv Te avTovs oloi t ojo-lv
Kal afxeivovs k yLp6v(ov aTTOT^Xelv KaTo. t6 bvvaT^v;

NE. 2X2. OvK aT aVTLTTLV TTOpd y o. vvv ipr]Tai.
EE. Kal p.r]v TTpos KLva oib avTLppr\TOV. 5
NE. 212. Ta Trota ltts;
HE. *12y ovK av ttot TTXrjOos ovb^ o}VTLV(t)vovv Tr]V tol-
avrqv Xa^6v iiLcrTr]pLr]v oX6v t h.v yivoLTO p.Ta. vov bLOLKLV
tt6Xlv, aXXa 7Tp\ arpLLKp6v TL Kal oXiyov Kal t6 V (rTL ^r]- c
Tr]Tov Tr]v [xiav Kivr]v TToXLTeiav ti]v dpdr]v, tos 8' aAAas
pLixi]ixaTa 6T0V, &cnTp Ka\ oXiyov iTp^Tepov epp-qdrj, tcls fxev
Tt\ to. KaXXiova, Tas 8' tt\ to. alo-yid) fxLpovpvas TavTr]v.
NE. 211. riciis Ti TOVT ipr]Kas; ovb ycp apTL brjdV 5
KaTpa60V t6 TTp\ T&V [XL]Xr]]XCLT(t)V.
HE. Kai ixr]v ov (})avX6v ye, av KLVâas tls tovtov t6v

Xoyov avTov KaTaâXi] koX fxrj bLX6o)V ivbei^Tat t6 vvv
yiyv6p.vov aixapTr]p.a TTp\ avT6. d
NE. 2X2. noioi; h];
H E. ToiwSf TL Set ye ^TjTeiy, ov iTaw crvirqdes ovbe pcibLov
IbeXv 6p(i)s p.i]v TTeLpd^fxedaXaêlv avT6. (j)p yap' 6p6fjs qfxlv
p6vr]s ova-r]s TaljTrjs Trjs TroAtTetas rjv lpr]KaixV, olad' otl tos 5
aAAas 8et Tots Tavrqs crvyypappacrL y^pcofxivas ovto) (rioêadat,
bpdaas t6 vvv TTaLVovfXV0v, KaLTTp ovK 6p66TaTov ov;
63 5i04K^ffa>s om. B a^ rfxvijvB Ci rt] re pr. T C2 5'
om. B 05 SrjOfy] (irjdii' Badham C8 vvp B : pvvl T

agyd nAATi2N02
NE. 212. To TTolov;
e HE. To TTapa tovs vohovs ixrjbfv yLrjhiva ToXyuav ttouZv
t5>v kv TTj TTO Aei, Tov ToXixdirra be davari^ ^rjixiovrdai Kal
iraa-i tois ^{r;(arois. xai toCt' tcrTiv dpOoTara Kal koAAio-t'
Xov 0)5 SevTcpor, îreiSay to TrpSiTov Tts pieTaOrj t6 wvlif
5 ptjdev S> b^ TpoTTu ycyovos ia-Ti. tovto 6 8^ bcvTepov icfîjaa-
fJLV, biaTtepavtap.tQa. ^ ydp;

NE. 212. riarv /ici' ovv.
HE. Ets bj) Tas ilKovas ^TiavionKV 7raA.tr, at? drayKaioy
dTreiKa^ftr dei Tovi âcnXiKovs apyovTas.
lo NE. 212. nora?;

HE. Tor yerrator KvftepiniTrjv /cai tov (Tipcov TToXkoiv
avTa^Lov laTpov. KaTCb(op.V yap 8jJ ti o^^/xo iv TovToi.i
avTOLS TrAao-d/xeroi.
NE. 212. noior Tt;
2g8 HE. TotoVSe* olor d tt6.vts irfpl avrGtv bi,avo7]6in(v

OTL SetroVara vtt avTiov Trdo-ô/ier. ov /xer ydp dr e^cA^-
aroXTLV rilxS>V TOVTOiV KaTpOL (TioCcLV, d/iOtCOS bi] aiaÔVCTLV, ov
8' hv \(i)â<rdaL ôvXridSta^LV, Xoi^QvTat thvovtS icat k6,ovtS
5 Koi TTpoaTaTTOVTs avaXdixaTa <f)pLV iTap kavTovs oXov

(j)6povs, u>v aiiLKpa iikv ts tov KdpLvovTa Kal ovbkv clvoXl-
(TKOVa-LV, TOLS 8' oAAoiS aVTOt T Kal ol olK^TaL xpwvTCU* Kv
Tov KaixvovTOs Xpripi.aTa iiLa-Qov Xaii(3(xvovTS aTTOKTivvaa-LV.
ot T av Kv^^pviiTaL nvpia Tpa TOLairra ipydôvTaL, KaTa-
XLTT0VTS T K TLVos TTLôvXijs v Tals dvayoiyaLS epj;/xovf,
5 Kat (r<pdXiJ.aTa 7tolovvtS v tols TreAdyeo-tr eK/3dAAoi;o-ir ets

TTjV OdXarrav, Kal Tpa KaKOvpyov<TLV. et bi] Tavra bui-
V0ri6VTS fiovXV<TallX6a TTp\ avT&V l3ovXl]V TLVa, TOVTCOV
C tS>V T\vG)V IXT]KTL TTLTpTTLV &pXLV aVTOKpOTOpL IX7]bTp(X
lxr]T ovv bovX(i)V fX7]T iXv6p(i)V, (rvXXâL 8' ^KKAijo-iav
7)ixQv avTQv, 7] aijixTTavTa tov bijixov 7] tovs ttXov^tlovs ixovov,
b3 coTa\(ir<(iê j BT O i /utjSfTtpa B
nOAITIKOS 298C
fêlvaL 8e /cai lbio)Tu>v Koi tu)V aXXoiV hriy.iovpyQ)V Trepi Te
ttXov Kal 776/31 vocTOiv yv(ofJLr]V ^jxâKiadai KaO^ otl \pr} 5

Tols (pappidKOLS ^pMS Kal Tols laTpLKOLS opydvoLS TTpOS TOVS
KafxvovTas xprja-daL, Kal brj Kal toTs ttXolols re avTols Kal
TOLS vavTLKOLS opydvoLS els TTjv tG>v irXoLoyv xp(.Lav Kal irepl d
TOVS KLvbvVOVS TOVS T TTpOS OVTOV TOV TtXoVV dvpLO)V Kal
daXdTTrjs irepL Kal iTpos tcls tols Xrja-Tals ivTcvêLS, Kal iav
vavpia\eLV dpa berj ttov fxaKpols ttXolols TTpos (Tepa TOLavTa'
TCL 8e ro) TTX-q6(L boâvTa Trept tovto)v, eire tlvo)v laTpo)v Kal 5
KVêpvrjTav cir' 6XXo)V iSitorair (rvp.j3ovXv6vTO)V, ypd\j/avTas
v KvpfiecTL TLCTL KciL cmjAats, TCL b\ KciL dypa(f)a TTaTpLa 6p.h'ovs e

1^77, KaTCL TavTa rjbr] TrdvTa tov (TTeLTa yj)6vov vavTLXXecr6aL
Koi TCLs T&v Kafiv6vTO)v depaTTeias iTOLiLcrâL.
NE. 2X2. Yiop.LbT] ye etpriKas aTOTTa.
HE. Kar' IvLavTov bi ye dp\ovTas Ka^LoracrOaL tov 5

ttXt/ôvs, etre ck t&v ttXovctmv eire ck tov b-^jjLov TTavT^s,
os av KXr}povpLVOs Xayydvr]' tovs b\ Karaa-TdvTas dp\ovTas

dp)(jELV KaTCL TCL ypdpLfJLaTa KvjScpviavTas tcls vavs Kal tovs
KdfxvovTas lo)fx4vovs.
NE. 2X2. TaCr' Irt x^^^'^^'''^^"" 10
HE. 06(3 8^ Kai To fxeTCL TavTa kirdfxevov. CTretSar yap
br] Tav dpx6vTO)v Kd(rTOLS 6 ivLaxrrbs ^4X6r], bafcreL biKa-
CTT-qpLa Ka^LcravTas dvbp&v, t] twv iTXovcrLo^v K irpo/cptVews rf
(TVfXTTavTos av Tov brjpLov tovs XaxdvTas, et? tovtovs eicdyeiv 299

roiiy dpâvTas Kal v6vvlv, Karqyopelv be tov ôvX6fxvov
b)S ov KaTCL To. ypdfXfxaTa tov kvLavTov kKvîpvrfcn Tas vavs
ovbe KaTa tcl TraAata tcjv iTpoydvoov e6r]' TavTo. 8e TavTa
Kol iTpl T&v Tovs KdfxvovTas lo)fxivo)v (j)V 8' h.v KaTa\l/r](f)La-6rj 5
TLfxdv OTL XPV TTCl6LV OVTWV TLVaS r] aTTOTLVeLV.
NE. 2X2. OiiKovv o y e64Xo)v Kal eKO)v kv tols tolovtols
apx^LV 8iKato'rar' hv otlovv irdaxoL Kal diTOTLVOL. b
e5 avfiPa\4(r6at B ^v/j.$a\\f(T6ai T
: d 2 irpbj ] wepl B d4 Sejj]
Seri' B 613 KadiffayrasD. Ko-li(rayrasB: KadiardvrasT ai oS]
axnov B
299b nAATilNOS
EE. Kat ToCwv Iri Sojcrei di<r6ai vSfiov ^ttI TTacn tov-
rois, av ris KvjSepvrjTtKrjV Kal to vavTiKov 77 t6 vyinvov Ka\

laTpiKTJ^ akqOnav iTfpl irvfvp.aTa re Kal depfm kcu \ffvxpa
5 Cv^^^ (f)a[vr}Tai, irapa to. ypdfxp.aTa Kal ao<f>iC6fievo9 otiovv

TTfpl Ta Toiavra, irptaTov fjiiv firjTe laTpiKov avThv fn^re
KV^pvr]TiKov ovofidCîv iAA^ fierecopoAoyoj/, ^bo\i(ryr]v Ti.vh
(ro(f>i(rTr\v, eW ws bi,a(f)dftpovTa a\kovi veooTfpovs Kal ava-
C TTfCdovTa k-mTidâOai KV^cpvrjTiKrj Kal laTpLKrj p.r} KaTo. v6p.ov9,
dA.A' avTOKp&Topas &pxiv tS>v irAotcoy Kal tu>v vo(tovvt(ov,

ypayf/dfxevov eto-ayfty tov ôv\6p.vov oXs efeorti' eh brf n
diKao-TT/ptoi^* hv bi TTapa tovs vofiavs koL to. y(ypafip.4va
5 b6^r) TTeiOîv eire viovi eire iTpecr^vTa^, koKACîv roty ^(tx^-

rot?. ovh^kv yap beiv T(av vofKov elvai ao(f)(iiT(pov ovbtva
yap ayvoetv t6 re laTpiKov Kot to vyieivov ovb^k to KvjBepvrj-
TiKov K(u vavTLKov i^flvaL yap ro) /ôuAoêro) fxavdavfLV
d yypafifLva kol Trdtrpta (Orf Kfififva. rairra 87/ Trept re Tav-
ra? ras mcrTrip.as el yiyvoLTO ovTôi o)? XiyofKV, o> ^(aKpaTes,

KOL (TTpaTTfyLKrjs Kal a-vfnT(i(rr]s fjO-TLVoa-ovv OrjfyevTLKrjs kol
ypa(f>LKfjs rf avft.TTa(rr]s fiipos otlovv fiLfxrfTLKrjS K(ii TCKTOVLKrjs
5 Kot crvv6Xr]s oiTOLaa-ovv a-Kevovpyias r] Kal y((i>pyiai Kal Trji
TTepl TCL (fivTa aw6\r]s re^xr?]?, t) kol TLva LTTTTO(f>op(Biav av

KaTCL a~uyyp6.fXfxaTa Oeaa-aifxeda yLyvofx4vr]v ff a-vy.iTaaav
ayeXaLOKOfXLKrjV r) fxavTLKrfV */ TTav otl p.epos bLaKOVLKi)
e iTpLikr](f)V, Tf Trerretay ^ <rvp.TTaa-av apLdfxr]TLKi]V \f/L\r]v
cfre MiTebov etr* iv ^6.6fa-LV elr h Tdxe^riv ova-av ttov,

TTept ^Trai^ra ratrra ovro) iTpaTT^p.fva Ti ttot h.v (f>aveir], Karb.
crvyyp6p.fxaTa yLyv6fXva Kal /it; KaTO, rixv^^l

5 NE. 212. Ar]\ov oTL Ttaaal re oX TXVO.i TrarreAo)? av
aiT^koLVTO fffiTv, Kai ov8' h ovOls yivoLVT &v TTore 8ta t6v
aTTOKO)KvovTa tovtov C^reiy vofxov wore 6 /3ios, u>v koI vvv
b 4 iryfvfjiaTJi] irvfvfii B b 6 fiit^ om. B b 7 ovofiiCv B

d4 ôm. T &T10VV fifpos'^ d6 T^s anteTtxT>s B ea Tetx**''!
Tixfffif al. 64 /coTi] KaTh t^ T 65 t om. B e6 ovSi tis
aStfis y4voivT' iv T oiiSfls oJtfr yfvoiT av B
: 67 jSioi &r] $iii<rwv B
nOAITIKOS 299 6
XO.X.eTT69, et? Tov xpovov (kÎvov a.(3Ca)Tos yiyvoiT av to

TrapaTrav.
HE. Ti Se Tobe; d KaTo. (rvyypdfj.fjLaTa pL^v avayKa.(oL- 300

fiey (KaoTov yCyv<r6aL t&v (lpr\ixivu>v koX rois (Tvyypdp.iia-
(Tiv fipiS)V imcJTaTetv tov xeipoTovriOivTa rf kayovra k Tvyris,

ovTos he ixrjbev (f)povTiôov tS>v ypap.p.dT(jdv rj K^pbovs eveKev
TLvos r] xdpi-Tos IbCas Trapa Tavr kTtvyjeipoZ bpav cTcpa, [xr]bV 5
yLyv(acrK(ov, apa ov tov KaKOV tov TrpoadfV /uetôi' h^ Ti.
TOVTO yCyvoLTO KaKOv;

NE. Sn. 'AArjêaTaTa [ye].
HE. ITapa yap oTfxaL tovs vofxovs tovs ex Treipas 7ro\X?;s b
KiLiiivovs KaC TLV(ov (rvpij3ovku>v iKacrTa \apLivT(as (Tvp.ôv-
XiVcrdvT(iiv Ka\ TTL(rdvTcov 6e(r6aL t6 Trkfidos, 6 iiapa TavTa
ToXp.&v bpdv, dp.apTrip.aTos dp.dfrrr\p.a itoXKaTrXdcrLov ditepya-
^6pLVos, dvaTpiTTOL Ttd(rav av Trpd^LV ert /xet^bVcoy tcov 5
(rvyypap.p.dT(av.
NE. 2X2. Um
8' ov jueXAet;
HE. Aia raura 8?/ rois Trept otovovv v6p.ovs koX crvy- C
ypdp.p.aTa TLêpAvoLs bevTepos ttXovs to irapa TavTa /XT^re
fva jUT/re ttXtj6os jur/Sei' p.r]biTT0T eay 8pay /X7j8' oriow.

NE. 212. 'Op^cS?.
HE. OvKovv p.Lp.rip.aTa pikv dv eKaoTcoy TavTa etrj Trjs 5
aA.7j0etas, tcl iTapa tuiv ilboTiav ety bvvap.LV etzât yeypap.-
fiiva;
NE. 2X2. nc3y 8' ov;
HE. Kat p.i]v t6v ye etSora (f)afxv, tov ovtcos ttoXltl-
k6v, et fxep.vrip.i6a, Trotr/o-eiv rfj Ti)(vr\ TToXkd et? rr]v avrov 10
TTpd^Lv T(av ypap.pMT(av ovbkv (f)povTCôvTa, diroTav dXX' avT&

^cXtCco b6^r] Trapd ra yeypafxfxiva v(j)^ avTov Kal ^TreoToAjMeVa d
aTTOVcrCv tl(tlv.
NE. 2X2. "E^pap-fv ydp.
a 3 iiri(rraTf7v Tifiuv T a4 i^pay/j.a.TWv T evfK^v BT

* 5 îrX*'P* T 7 (coKfi;'] /ca/coV rt B && ye om. B
b3 Kfi(Ta,VT(i>v'\ ^vfiirdcrdvTwv T C i S)j om. B 8t' o5y B
300 d nAATi2N02
HE. OvKOVV avr)p ootktovv els i] TTXrjdos onovv, oh av
5 vofxoL K(Lfj.(vot, Tvy)(av(t)(n, Trapa Tavra ori ^v eTTt,\etrpT](TUi(ri
TTOieiv <ws I34Xtu)v hepov ov, ravrov hpSicn KaTo. bvvafiLV

onep 6 oXrjdLvbs iKelvos;
NE. 212. HdLvv pikv ovv.
HE. 'Ap' ovv el piev hve-nLcrrqp.oves ovtc^ to tolovtov
10 bpStev, p.Lp.eL(TdaL fxkv ^v iTTLxeLpoUv t6 a\r]d4s, plhiolvt av
e p.ivTOL TTayKaKdiS' el 8' tvTeyyoL, tovto ovk ôtlv (tl iXLyirip.a
dAA' avTo To aX.r]64(rTaTov iKelvo;

NE. 212. TidvTOiis irov.
HE. Kai fXTjv inTtpoadi ye inio\oyr)p.ivov rjpHv KelTai
S fXTfbev Trkrjdos fxrff -ffVTLVovv bvvaTov etvaL kafielv Teyvrfv.

NE. 212. Ketrat yap ovv>
HE. OvKovv el fxkv icrrL âcnXLKrf tls rexyrff to rdv
ttKovo-lcov TrXrjdos Kal 6 (rvfxiTas hfjfxos ovk av ttotc Xa/3ot
TTfV TTokLTLKIfV TaVrtfV (TTL(TTr\fXr]V.

lo NE. 212. n<Ss yap &v;
HE. Aei 8^ ras roLavTas ye &)? loifce iroAireias, eZ fxe\-
301 Aovo-i KakSis rtfv aXrfdLinfv (KeivrfV rifv tov kvbs fxeTa Te\vr]s
&PXOVTOS TToXLTeLav ds hvvafxw fXLfxrf(r(a-6ai, fxrfheiTore kci-
fx^voiiv avTOLS tG)V vofxoiv fxrfhev TTOLeiv iTapa tcl yeypafxfuiva

KoX TT&TpLa i6rf.
5 NE. 2X2. Kd\\L(TT etprfKas.

HE. "Orar &pa oi it\ov(tlol ravrrfv fXLfxStvraL, t6t(
apLcrroKpaTLav KoXovfiev rrfv TOLavrrfv iTokLreLav OTTorav Sk
tG)V vofxoov fxrf (\)povr'LC((TLV, 6KLyap\Lav.
NE. 2X2. KLvhvveveL.
10 HE. Kai fxrfv ottotov av6LS eXs &PXV '^**'"" vofxovs, fXLfxov-
b fxevos rbv eiTL^Trrjfxova, fia(TL\ia Ka\ovfxev, ov hLopiCovres
d.5 iTav iirixtipSxTi B d6 fi^KrtcrTov B 6y om. B d.g Th

om. B e I irayKdKus scripsi : iravKaKas (sic) B : iray. KOKai-s
T ?Tt filnrffia'] iiriTinrjna T 64 ffxirpoffdtv T 65 \a-
Pftv SuKOTbf tlvai T 6 oJr] vvt/ ^ aa /iifi^(ra(r6(u B
a3 Tî v6fi<f> B
nOAITIKOS 30ib
ovofjLaTi. Tov ixT tTrioT^jUTj s 7] bo^rjs KaTa vofxovs ixovap"

Xovvra.
NE. SH. KtvbvvevoiJ.V,
HE. OvKovv KOLV Tis cLpa ki: KTTTiimv ovrois OiV ets apyr^, 5
TravTdis t6 ye ovojxa TavTov âuik^vs Ka\ ovh\v Tpov
TTpoa-prjO-qa-eTai.' bi h 87; to, Trerre ovofxaTa tG>v vvv Ae-
yofxevcov ttoX.itl&v kv fxovov yeyovev.
NE. 212. "Eotxe yovv.
HE. Ti 8' OTav [xrjTC KaTO. vofxovs fxriTe KaTa iOrf TrpaTTrf 10
TLS ets apxoiiv, TTpoa-TTOLrJTaL be uâ-TTcp 6 (TTLo-Tiffxuiv &)s apa C

TTapa TCL yfypafLfxeva t6 ye j34kTLa-Tov TTOLrjTeov, 7/ 8e ris
7TL0vfiLa Kal ayvoLa tovtov tov fxifxr\p.aTos rjyovfxivrf, fxG>v
ov t6t tov tolovtov Kaa-TOv Tvpavvov KkrfTiov;
NE. Sil. Tt p.riv; 5
HE. Ovrto 87) Tvpavv6s re y^yove, <pafXV, Kal j3a(riA.ei/s
Kai oAtyapxîa xat apta-TOKpaTLa Kal brffioKpaTLa, bvaxepavdv-

Tcov Tcjv avdpu>TT(ov Tov va KLVov fx6vap\ov, Ka\ aTTLarrf-
a-dvTOiv fLrfbeva Tifs TotavTrjs dpxffs d^Lov av yevicrdaL Trore,
ajtrre ideXeiv Kal bvvaTov elvaL fxcT dpeTTJs Kal iiTLanffxris d.
dpxovra to. bUaLa Kal oaLa bLavfXLV 6p6S>s TTda-Lv, \o}j3d-

o-daL 8e KOL dTTOKTLvvvaL Kal KaKovv ov dv (3ov\r]dri Kda-TOT
fffxoiv' TTl yv6fxv6v y dv OLOV \yofXV dyaTTaa-daC re dv

Kal oIkIv bLaKV^pvS>vTa vbaLfx6vo)s opOrfV dK/aijSw? fx6vov 5
TroAtreiay.
NE.
HE.
mNw ncSs
8e'
8'
ye
ov;
oiroVe ovk Ioti yLyv6fXvos, w? 877
(f)afXv, V Tals iT^Xea-i âcrtAevs oXos V afx-qvea-LV fx(f)VTai, e

t6 re <r&fxa v6vs Kal Trfv "^vxvv bLa(f)po}V ets, 8et 8^
o-vv\66vTas avyypdfLfxaTa ypd(f)LV, o)S 0lkV, fLTa60VTas
To. TTfS dXrfêcTTdrqs TroAtretas ix^*
NE. 2X2. KLvbvvVL. 5
b 5 ovKovv om. B b 7 5t' &] 8ck BT e2 t6 ye] r^St T

C6 Te om. B ds aTroKTlviwcrOatT d4 Kiyci>iJ.ivB d.8 dvoTf]
5t T e I ofoy] olov (sic) B
3oie nAATllNOS
HE. Qav^dCofxev brJTa, o) îOKparcs, Iv rals ToiavTais
7:o\iTLais ocra avixfiaCvei yiyvta^dai KaKo. koX oaa avii^ri-
(TCTai, TOt.avTr]<i tt/? Kpr\i:iho<i VTT0KLfJL(vr]S avrals, 7T/y KaTO,
yp6.p.fiaTa Kal idrj /xj; fXfTa Trtor^/xrjs T:paTTOva~qs Tas
302 TTpdêts, (^y ^Tipa Tipoayjiiiip.ivri TtavTX KaTdhr]Kos wy Ttdvr
av 8ioAeo-cte to. Tavrrf yiyv6p.tva; r] ^Kflvo rjiJ.lv davnaariov
p.aXkov, ws ia-yypov ri ttoAis oti (f)va-i; Trao";(oi;o-ai yap
hrj TOLavTa ai TroAeis vvv xpdvov dTrepavTov, opuas Iriai
5 Tives avTUiv fjLovLfxoi re eio-i kol ovk dvaTpeirovTaL- iroAAat

fujv vioT Kal KaOdirep TrAota KaraSwftevai 8to'AAwTat /cal
8toAcuAao-t Kttt eTt StoAoCvrat 8ta Tr\v TUiV KvfiepvrjTiav Kal

vavToiv fioxdrfpiav tQv iTepl to. fxiyLo-Ta fxeyiaTrfv dyvoLav
b ilkrfcfiOTaiv, ot Trept tcl TroAiTt/ca kot' ow8cy ytyrwo-icorTes
TfyovvTaL KaTCL irdvTa a-a<f>4a-TaTa iiaaGiv ^TrtoTTj/xoii' TavTrfv
i\rf(f)vaL.
NE. 212. 'AXrfdôTaTa,

5 S E. Tiy ovv brf t&v ovk 6p6S>v TtokLTiLSiV tovtujv rfKLora
XaAeTr^ a-vCyj^, iraa-Qv xoXcttS^v ovaGtv, /cai Tts fiapvTdTrj;
8et Ti KaTtSety rffxds, KaiiTfp irpos ye to vvv irpoTidev fffxlv
irdpepyov keyofxevov; ov fxrjv oAA' ets ye t6 oKov laois

airavd^ Irefca tov tolovtov irdvTes bpHftev X^P"'*
10 NE. 212. Aei- irws 8' ov;
C EE. Trfv avTTfv Toivvv (f>d6L TpLoiv ovaSiv \aXf.Tu\v 8ta-
(fxpovTOis yiyvfadaL Kal paarrfv.

NE. 212. n<Ss (firfs;
SE. OvK dkkois, TTkrfv fxovapyJ.av (firjfxl Kol dKiyoav dpyrjv
5 Kai TroAAoir, eivat Tpet? TOVTas rjfXLV Aeyo/xeVas tov vvv

iiTLKXVfJ^4vov \6yov KaT dp\ds.
NE. 212. 'Ho-av ydp ovv.
SE. TavTas Toivvv 8txa TfxvovTS fxiav e/ccio-TT/y ef
a I jf add. Stephanus e Ficino oh Schleiermacher irfpa T

:
a 2 Tcb TouTp] Tiir' ouT^ Badham an t^ irw' avrf Campbell : 4k(7-

vov B a6 iro) ante KaBdirfp om. T a^ 8ia)A<$Aa(ri B
b9 Jjrovff*] ir{'fi' B C i Sia^fp6vrwi ifxa Kol ^^(rrTii' ylyytaBat T
nOAITIK02 302 c
TroioSjLtey, rqv opdrjv x.(t)p\s anoKpCvavTis rovTUiv kfibo-

10
iiriv.
NE.
EE. 'Ek
m USis;
p^kv TTJs iMovapxCas jSaa-iXLKrjV Kal TvpavviKrjv, d
(K 8' av tS>v p.1] TTokXoiV Trjv T iV(i)wpx)V <pap.ev [eirai]
apicTTOKpaTCav koX oKLyap^Cav e*c 8' av tS)V TroXXQiv t6t

fxkv airXrjv eirovondCovTfS (TCdep.V brjjjLOKpaTCav, vvv 8' av
Kal TavTt^v rip.iv 6t4ov eort bLTrXrjv. 5
NE. 212. Huts bri; Kal tCvl biatpovvTes TavTrjv;
HE. OvbV bia<f)4povTi tS)v dKk(DV, ovb^ ei Tovvofxa 7/8r/
bLTrKovv icTTi. Tavrqs' dWd t6 ye Kara v6p.ovs dpyjeiv Ka\ e

Ttapavop.ois ecrri /cat TavTij koX tois dXXais.
NE. 212. *E<m yap ovr.

HE. Tore /xev toCvvv Tr]v opOrjV ^r]Tov(TL tovto to TfJLrjp.a
ovK Tjy xprfCTLpLOV, o)S kv toIs TTpocrdev d7re8etâ/iey eTretSr; 5
8e i^cCXoixev KCvr]v, rds 8' aAA.ay eêjuey dmyKatas', er

ravrais 8^ ro Trapdvofj.ov Kal ivvoixov e/cdcrTTjy Sixo^ÔMfi
TOVT(t)V.
NE. 2X2. "'EoiKer tovtou vvv prjddirros tov \6yov.

HE. Moz/apxtct ToCvvv feuxêto-a /xei' er ypdiipaaLV dya- 10
0ots, ovs v6p.ovs Ae'yo/xey, dpCcrTr] iracrCiv tG)V e^* dvopLos be

âXiirr] Kal jSapvTdrr] (TVvoiKrjcrai.
NE. 212. KtrSweuei. 303
HE. Trjv 8e ye tS^v /x^ TroAAwj', oocnrep evbs Kot ttAt/ôus
TO oAiyoi; pLiO-ov, 0VT(DS r}yr](r(6ixda pLecrr]v eir' d]x<p6Tpa'
Tr]v 8' aS ToS TrArjôus Kard TrdvTa dcrOfvr] Kal pLr]bev fxr]T
dyaObv ]xr]T KaKov [xeya bvvap.vr]v oi)S Trpbs rds dAAas 8td 5
rd rds dpxds iv TavTrj biavevfixfjcrdaL Kard aixLKpd et? iroA-
Aows. 810 ylyovi Trao-wy ixkv voixCp.(DV tS)V T:okLTL5)v ovaQv

Tovroiv \LpC(rTr], TTapav6ixo)V 8e ovaQv (Tvix-nacrG^v ^X.TCa-Tr]'
KCLL dKo\dcrT(i)v ixv TTacrGiv ova^v iv brjixoKpaTCq vlkA 0]v, b
C 11 trus oZv T d. 2 tlvcu, om. T e i ye^ re B e 2 irapa-

yo/xfly T b i viKar} B : viKav T
303b nAATXlNOS
KOa-fxuav b ovardv i]Kiara iv Tavrp (3ioiTov, kv rf) 7r/)(ur7
8^ 7roA.v TTp&Tov T Kal &pi.aTov, ttKijv TTJs (fibofjLTjs' TTaa-Civ

yap ^KfCvrjv ye iKKpiTcov, olov deov i^ avdpoiiroiv, iK tu>v
5 8,XX(t)V TToKl.TlOiV.
NE. 2i2. <t>aLVTai. Tavd^ ovt(o (TV}iâiviv re Ka\ yC-

yvio-dai, KoX iroiTjreoi' T^Trep A,cyei?.
HE. OvKovv hr] KoX roi/s Kowiavovs tovtcov Toiv rroA.treiwy
C TTaa-oiv iTKriv ttjs eTTta-rqnovos d.<f)aLpTôv tuy ovk ovTas

TToXiTLKOvs aWa araa-LaaTLKOvs, Kal elbcaXcov p.eyLaTOiV TTpo-
a-T&Tas ovTas kol avTovs (TvaL tolovtovs, fieyLfTTovs 8e ovTas
IXLfxrjTas Kal yorjTas jLteytorouy yCyvcaOaL tS>v <ro(f)LaT&v
5 a-o^pLards.
NE. 2X2. KLvbvvcvei tovto fls tovs ttoX.ltlkovs Aeyo-

fjiivovs TTpL(rTpd(f>6aL t6 prjfxa SpdoTaTa.
HE. Erev TOVTO fxkv dT^xyois rffj.lv uxttt^p bpdfia, KaOd-
Trep kpprfOr) vvvbrf KevTavpLKov opda-daL koa. 'LarvpLKov TLva
d îao-oi;, hv brf yuipiaTiov diTb TToX.LTiKfjs ftrf Tixyrfs' vvv V
0VT(n TTdvv fioyLS kyoipCa-Qr].
NE. 2X2. a>aii;erai.

EE. TovTov 8e y Tpov tl yaK^TTtiiTepov Aeiirerai ry
5 <rvyyvis re ojliou t LvaL pMXkov roi /3ao-iAiKM ycVei Kal
bva-KaTaft.adrfT6Tpov' KaC fxoL <f)aLv6fXda tols tov yjwaôv
KaOaCpOVa-L ITdOos OfXOLOV 1TTT0v6VaL,
NE. 2X2. UQ)s;
HE. Trfv TTov Ka\ \C6ovs Kal ttSXX* &TTa erepa diTOKpC-
10 j;ouo-i Ka\ Klvol ttp^tov ol brffXLOvpyoC* fXTa b^ Tavra
e AetTrerat a-vp.fXfXLyixva to. a-vyyevrj tov xpvcrov TCfXLa Ka\
TTVp^ fxdvov d(f)aLpTd, âAKOs >cat apyvpos, ia-TL 8' ot koI
dbdfxas, (&) fXTa fBaa-dvcov Tals k\frrfa-a-L fxoyLS d<f)aLp6VTa
b4 iyKpiTfov B b6 rovff B (rvfipalvtiy re koI yiyvtarBai,

Kol scripsi : ffvfnfiaivtiv t koI B : ylyvtffOai t co1 Ivfifiaivtiv, koX T
C 7 iTfpitffTptipOai BT C8 om. al.
&ffirtp ipafia d i 8' om. B
d4 Ty] Tb B ds t' ante tlvai om. B d lo irparov]
Kpirtpov B ravra BT : toCto vulg. 6 3 4 add. Stephanus
e Ficino
;
nOAITIKOS 303.
Tov Xiyoixevov aKrjpaTov \pv(rov etacrev rjjxas ibeXv avrov

p.6vov (f>*
kavTov. 5
NE. 212. Aeyerat yap ovv 8r; raSra ovto) yCyvecrdai.
HE. Kara tov avTov toCvvv Xoyov eoiKe koX vvv tjixlv
ra ixev (Tepa Kal OTTocra aXXoTpia Kal to. pi] (f)LXa TroXLTiKrjs
e7rioTJjju,rj9 a-K0Ke\(api(r6ai, AetTreo-ât 8e tcl TLjXLa /cat crvy-
yevrj. tovtcov 8' eo-rt ttov crTparriyLa kol bLKacrTiKr] Kal ocrrj 10
âcTiXLKrj KOLV())vov(ra prjTopeCa TreCOovcTa to hiKaLov crvvhLa- 3^4

KVêpva TCLS kv Tals TToXecrt Trpaêts* b. hr\ tlvl TpoTTio pacrTa
TLS aTtoixepLôiV Setêt yvpvov xat p.6vov leKuvov KaO' avTov

Tov ^rjrov/jteyoy v(^' y^pSiv;
NE. 212. dJqXov oTL TovTO Trrj hpav TTeLpariov. 5
EE. Iletpa? p.ev tolvvv eveKa (jâvepbs eaTaL' 8ta 8e

IxovcTLKrjs avTov ey\eLpr]Teov br]X&(raL. Kai poL Xeye.
NE. 212. To TTOLov;
HE. MovcrLKrjs eo-rt ttov tls rfp.lv p.adr](rLS, kol oXoos t5)V b
Trept xeLpoTexyias eTTLcrTr{\x(ii)V
NE. 2X2. "'Eo-rty.

HE. Tt 8e; to 8' av tovto)v rjVTLvovv etre 8et p.av6dveLV
riixas etre jur/, iTOTepa <f)ri(ropev ^7TLcrTr]ixr]V av xal Tavrqv 5
etiât rtya irept cun-a TavTa, rj tt&s;
NE. 212. OvTcas, ftvai <f)r](roixev.
HE. OvKovv kTepav 6poXoyr](roixev eKeivcov elvai TavTr\v;
NE. 212. Nat'.
HE. IloVepa 8e avTdv ovhefxiav apyeLv helv aXXr]v aXXr]s, 10
r/ eKeivas TavTr]s, r] TavTrjv helv eTTLTpoTrevova-av apxeLV C

(rvixTTa(rG)V tS)V aXXoov;
NE. 2X2. TavTrjv eKeivcov,
HE. (Trjv} el 8et p.avddveLv r/ /xr) Trjs fxavâvopevrjs Kal
8t8ao-/covo-rjs dpa (tv ye dTTO(paivr] helv r]]XLV dp\eLv; 5
NE. 212. 20o8pa ye.
e6 Stj revera B om. T : e 10 Sotj] Str' ^ B a? avr^^v]

avrh B b 4 S^ rSS' o3; Ast b 10 dA\ijy] a\A' 7) ye B
e I iirnpfirovffav B C4 om. (c/ tV BT . . . fx)] Socrati tribuentes)
PLATO, VOL. I. 33
304C riAATnNOS
SE. Kal Ti]V (l 6et TT^COeiv upa t/ p/ rijs bvvafiivr)^
TTeCOetv;
NE. 2fi. nws 8' ov;

lo SE. Etei;' rtvt to TTeKrTLKov ovv cnTobaxrofKV ^tti,-
d (TTriiJir) ttXi]9ovs re Kai oxA.ou dia fivdoXoyCas aWa ixr] 8ia

8t8ax^s;
NE. 212. avp6v ot/xat xat tovto prjTopiKt] boreov ov.
SE. To 8' etre 8ta 7ret(?ow eire naX 8td rtyos /3tas 8*1
5 TTp&TTiiv TTpos TLvas 6ti.ovv t] Kal t6 TTapaTTav {i](rv\Cav)

e\6iy, TOVT^ av ttoCo. TTpo(r6i]a-opLv iTTL(rnl]pir];
NE. 2i2. Trj ttJs TretcrriK^s ap\ovcn] Ka\ AeKriKT;?.

SE. Eir/ 8' av ovK 6Xkr] tls, wy ot/xat, 7rAj;r ^ roC
TroXtriKou 8wa/it?.
10 NE. 2X2. KaAAtor' (tpr^Kas.
SE. Kat rovro /iei' eotKe raxu KeyuipCcrQai iroAtrtK^j ro
e pr^TopLKov, ws eTfpov et8os oy, vTTr]peTovv jxijv TavTi].
NE. 212. Nar.

SE. Tt 8e TTe/ai r^j rota(r8' aJ5 8wd/xea)s bLavor]Tov;
NE. 212. notas; .
5 SE. T^9 0)? TToXfixr^Teov eKoo-rots ots Si; ir/JoeAw/ieâ

77oXe/xeti>, e?re aur^y aTexô^ ^^Ct^ (vt(x^'ov ipovixev;
NE. 2i2. Kat TTo^s hv aTfxôv bLavorjddpifv, ijv ye f]
(TTpaTr^yiKr] kcCl iTa.(Ta f] TToAe/xtK?) Trpa^LS TTpaTTfL;
SE. T^v 8e etre iToK(pir]Tov eire 8td </tAtas d7raAAaKre'or

lo otav re Kai imcrTrJnova bLaj3ov\V(ra(rdaL, Tavrqs (T^pav
VTToXdLJBcopiev r] Tf]V avTijv TavTj];
NE. 2i2. Tois TTpocrOev avayKalov (.TTop.ivoLcnv (Tepav.
305 SE. OvKovv 6.p\ov(rav rai/rr/s avrf^v aTTO(âvovp.(6a,
eiTrep roi? l/xTrpoo-êV ye vTTo\r]\j/6pL(da ofioCois;

NE. 2X2. 7//xr.
SE. TCv' OVV TTOT( KOL ^TTLXdp^qO-OfKV OVT(a b(LrfjS KOl
d4 Ka2 om. T d$ r^ffvxô-v add. Hermann d^ XtK-

Toc^s B d8 oiiK &I' T 69 iirf prius om. B a i Ta.u-
Tr}v aiiT^s T
;
nOATTIKOS 305 a
/xeyoAT/j Ti\vr]i <TV}nta.(Tr]s rrjs iroXfiiiKrjs bea-TroTiv aiTOcfâC-
5
V(r9ai. TTki]v ye 8j) ti]v ovtms oxxrav âcnki.Krjv
NE. 2i2. Ovb]jiiav aXkqv.
HE. OvK apa TToXiTiKr^v 6r]a-o]iiv, VTTr]piTi.Kr]V ye ova-av,
Tr]v T(av (TTpaTrjySiv kTn(rTr]]ir]v,
NE. 212. OvK eiKos. 10

HE. "Idi hr], Koi TT]v tS>v ht.Kaa-T5>v tG)V opd&s biKaôvTcov b
6aa-(ajj,0a bvva]xiv.
NE. 212. Ylavv ]ikv ovv.
HE. Ap ovv kiiX Tikiov tl bvvaTai tov Trept to. (rvp.-
ôXaia TTiivO^ OTroVa /cetrai v6]Xi]xa Trapa vo]xo64tov /SatriXecos 5

TTapakaôvcra, KpCveiv cls CKetva (TKOTTovcra to. re biKaia
TaydiVT iivai KoX abiKa, ttjv airrrjs ibCav aperr^v Trapeyo^xivr]
Tov ]xr]d' VTTO Tivcav bdpoov ]xi]d' vtto (fôjScov ]xr]Ti oCktoov ]xr]d'
VTTo Tivos akkr]s \dpas pi.r]be (îkCas fjTrqdeio-a iTapa Tr]v c

Tov vo]xodiTov T<xîv idikdv hv TaKkrjk(av yKkr]]xaTa
biaipelv;
NE. 212. OvK, akka a-xÊbov oaov dprjKas TavTr]s eorl
TTJs bvvdpi(as tpyov. 5
HE. Kat Tr]v TStv biKaaTutv apa p(o]xr]v avevpC^TKOfxev ov
âaikiKrjv ovaav akka v6]X(ov <\>vkaKa kcu vTrqpiTiv CKeCvr^s.
NE. 2a. "EotKev ye.

HE. To'8e 8^ KaTavorjTôv lb6vTi (rvvaiTa<ras Tas eTTto-r^-
]xas at ipr]VTai, oti 7roA.iriKJj ye avrStv ovbefxCa av((})(xvr]. 10
Ti]v yap 6vT(as ovcrav (BacnkiKrjv oiiK avTr]v bel TTpcLTTetv dAA' d
ap)(jeiv Toov bvvap.V(ov ttp<xttiv, yiyvdcTKovcrav Tr]v ap-)(r]v
re Kai 6p]xr]v Tutv p.yCaTOiv iv rats -TT^kea-iv (yKaipCas re

ire'pt /cat aKaipCas, ras b' a.kXas tcl TTpoarraydivTa bpav.
NE. 2X2. 'Opdois. 5
HE. Ata TavTa apa as ]xev aprt biekrjkvdapiev, ovt iXA^-
a8 -ye pKJSt vvy]periKrjv T : post iro\niK-r]v B b8 ^^re] /xifi''
(sic") B 07 v6fj.ov (sic) B C9 rJSe B Stobaeus : r6

ye T lS6vTe B iiri<rri)it.as a\ elpTji^Tot] dprifjifvas iTriffr-fjfias T
e 10 -ye] Tjs T diêêiyi;] ^<f ayTj T di je?] o<el B
83*
305 d nAATi2N02
Xu)v ovd* avTUiV &p\ov<Tai, Trepl hi Tiva IbCav avrrjs ov<ra
(Kda-Tr] Ttpaîv, KaTO. T7\v ioioTryra riav iipdîtav Tovvofia
StKatcos lKr)(f)V Ibiov.
e NE. 2i2. Etâo-t yovv.

EE. Tj)v 8e Tracraiy re tovtmv &pxov<rav Kal tG>v vopMV
Koi (Tvp.T:dvTUiv TUiv KaTO. 'nokiv kiinxi\ov\ievr]v koi TtdvTa
(Tvvv(f)aivov(Tav opOoTaTa, tov koivov tt} KA7/cr(t ireptAa-
5 j36vTS Trjv hvvap.iv avTijs, TTpo(rayopvoi,piev btKaioTaT dv,
b)S 0I.K, TToXl.TlKrjv.
NE. 212. riaj/rdTrao-t p.v ovv.
HE. OvKovv bi] Koi KaTo. To T7/S v(f>avTiKr]9 Trapdbeiyfia
fiov\oLfj.d^ av (TTfieAddv avTy]v vvv, 6t( Kal -ndvTa tcl yivr]
10 TOL KaTo. TrdKi.v brjXa i^p.lv yeyove;

NE. 2i2. Kat (rôbpa yi.
306 HE. T^v 8j) (3a(rLktKi]V (Tvp.TrkoKrjV, w? I01K6, Xe*cTeoy
iroia re' eort Kai rtVt rpoVo) o-v/xTrAe^Kouo-a Troioi' f^fiiv
V(f)a(rna diroStScoo-tr.
NE. 212. Ar]kov.
5 HE. 'h x"^*'"'^^ (.vbiLâaOai. Trpayp.a dvayKaiov ipa

yiyovev, w? (fâCveTai.
NE. 212. Ildirrooi ye /xt/v prjTeov.
HE. T6 yap dper7/s ]x4pos dpfTrjs elSet bi,d<popov elvaC
TLva TpoTTOv Tois Trepl Ao'yoi;s dix(f)i(r^r]Tr]TiKols Ka\ /xdA'
10 Vttl6tov TTpbs Tcis Tciv TTokkiav boâSo

NE. 212. OvK ip.adov.
HE. 'AAA' a)8e TrdAtv. dvbpeCav yap olixaC <t ^yeio-ât
b /xe'/)os ^v dper7/s 17/xti; elfat.
NE. 212. ndi-u ye.

HE. Kat /x^v (r<M)<f)po(rvvr]v ye dvbpfCas pi^v trcpov, tv b*
OVV KOL TOVTO fWpiOV rjs KdKflvO
5 NE. 212. Nai.
d 7 riya tSlav^ rriv atdtav B ea aira(rci)>' T 67 wavTdwatri}

irivv T e8 Kol om. B 69 avr^v ]
avrn B a a rlvi]
roi<f B a9 a/xfiff firjTiKoTs T : ifi<piffPrjTiKols B
nOAITIKOS 306 b
HE. TovTcov bri Tript 6avfJi,aar6v riva Xoyov cnrotpaCvâ-Oau

T0\}Xr]Ti0V.
NE. 212. Uolov;

HE. *X2s iaTov Kora 8?; Tiva TpoTTOV ev pidXa Ttpos oAA?/-
Aa? i\6pav koX aracnv ivavTtav i\ovT(. iv iroWols t5)V 10
ovTcav.
NE. 211. US)s \iyLs;

HE. OvK (liodoTa koyov ovbap.&s' Trdvra yap ovv 8?/
oAAt/Aois rd ye Trjs dpeTjjs popta Xiy^Tai itov (p[Xca. C

NE. Sa. Nai.
HE. ^KOTT&ixfV brj TTpo(r<r)(6vTS Tov vovv ev ju,aAa TroVe-
pov ovT(x>s airkovv eori tovto, 1) TravTos pdXXov avT&v Ix^'
bLa(popav Tols crvyyivtcrLV S tl; 5
NE. 212. Nai, Aeyois hv tttj crKiTniov.

HE. 'Ey Tois crupitacTL xpi] ^Tjretv oo-a KaAa /xey Ae^yoju.ey,
ij 8vo 8e avra Ti6ep.ev ivavria dXXr]X(x)v ubr].
NE. 2X2. Ae'y' eri (ra(})4crTpov.
HE. 'O^VTrjTa Kal Taxos, etre Kara (T(tip.aTa etr' er 10
ylfvyaLS eire Kara cfxovijs (Popdv, etre avTu>v tovtiov etre ey d

etSwAots 6vT(ov, OTrda-a ixovaiKri nniovixivri kcu (tl ypa(f>LKri
fXLixriixaTa Trap^xeTaL, tovt(ov tlvos eTraiv^Tris etre avTos

TTOiiTOTe yiyovas etre aAAov iTapdtv iiraLvovvTos fja6r]aaL;
'
NE. 212. Ti' ixriv; 5

HE. 'H Kai ixvr]}xr]v exfts ovTLva rpoTToy avro bpdaLv ev
eKdaTOLS TovT(av;
NE. 212. OvbapL&s.
HE. 'Ap' ovi' 8waro? avTo ^lv yevoinrjv, S>aTTep koX
bLavoovixaL, Sta Aoycor evbeiâa6ai (tol; 10
NE. 212. Tt S' oij; e

HE. 'PaStoi/ eotKas 7]yla6aL to tolovtov aK0iT(aix6a 8'
ow avro er rots VTT^vavTioLS yeveaL. tu)V yap 87/ iTpdêoiV
b 10 ^x^po. Campbell xoiTe] ^x*''"'"' ^^ ''3 i''poar(XovT(s B

C 4 X**] *X<"' corr. t C5 es ti Campbell : ia-Ti T : ia-Tiv B : iffri
Tt Heindorf 63 an ^y toTs inrfvavTiais yfyfatai Campbell
3o6e nAATI2N02
cv 7roAA.ars Koi TroAAaKis kKaa-TOTe rdxos Koi (r<f>obp6TrjTa
5 Kal 6^VTt]Ta biavoria-ecas T Koi o-cjixaTos, (Tt, bk Kal (fxiiviji,
oTav dyacrdSniev, \(yoixv avTO iTraLVovvTes fiia xpdfxevoi

TTpoa-pricrei, tt) TrjS dvbpeCas.
NE. 212.' U(os;
HE. 'Oû Kal dvbpelov TrpwTov ttov (f)ap.(v, Kal Ta\v Koi
lo dvbpLKov, Kal (T(f>obpov ixravTcos' Kal irdirrôs (TTL(f>povTes
Tovvop.a o Aeyco kolvov Ttdcrais Tois (ftvcncrL Tavrais ^Trairov-

p.ev avTas.
NE. 212. Nar.

307 HE. Ti be; fb TTJs ripfixaCas av yevecrfois etbos Sp' ov
TToAAa/ci? 7r>]VKapiv ev TroAAarj Twy irpdîoiv;
~
NE. 2X2. Kat crôbpa ye.
HE. Mwi' ovv ov TdvavTCa XiyovTes ^ Trepi ^KfCvâv
5 Touro (fideyyopfda;
NE. 2X2. nS>s;
HE. *Qs rjo-vxald ttov (f>aix(V (KdcrroTe Kal <r(a(ppoviKd,
TTepC T bidvoiav TipaTTOixeva dyao-devTcs Kal KaTo, Tas
npdêis av ^pabia Ka\ ixaXaKd, /cat Iti Ttfpi (fxavas yiryvo-.
10 fxeva Aeta Ka\ fiapea, Ka\ ird^rav pvOp.i.Kr]v KCvricrLv kcu oKriv
b ixovcrav kv Kaip<a ^pabvTiJTi 'jTpo<r\p(i>ix(.vriv, ov to Tijs
dvbpeCas ciAAa to ttjs Koa-p,idTriTos ovoixa iTTufîpojxev avrois

] (TuiXTTaa-iv.
NE. 2f2. 'AATjêWaTa.

5 HE. Kal fxriv ottotov av ye dpL(f>6Tpa yCyvr^Tai Tav9^
i]ixiv OLKaipa, ixTa(3d\kovTs ^KOTepa avT(av êyoixev tt\
TdvavTCa irdXiv diTOvefxovTes toIs. ovoixaciv.
NE. 212. n<Ss; .

.
HE. Ô^vTfpa fxev avTa yiyvdfxeva tov Katpov Ka\ ddiTco
e 5 8ick foiifftws T e 6 XtyofKV om. B e 9 irpwT^y

om. B a. I fiptfilas B aa imiVfyKafi.ty B foK-
Ao?j B a4 ov om. pr. T a8 irpaTT6fi.fva\ irpi.Tro-
fifv T b5 aj y*] o5t B b6 tjcaipa Stephanus e Ficino :
ijctoaia BT
nOAITIKOS 307 b
Koi (TKkqpoTfpa âiv6p.iva [KaX\ v^picrTiKa Kal ixaviKa Ae- 10
yovTes, To. be (3apvTpa Kal ^pabvTepa Kal pLokaKOJTepa beiXa C

Kal iBXaKLKO.' Kal a-x^bbv ws t6 ttoXv TavTa re Kal Ti]v
a-di^pova (j)V(riv Kal ttjv avbpdav ttjv Totv evavTmv, olov

TToXfiJ.Lav 6taAa)(owas aTaaLv Ibia?, cvt aXXi^kaLS p.iyvv-
p.ivas i(f)(vpLa-Kop.v v Tals Trepl tcl TOLavTa TrpcxêcrLV, TL re 5
Tovs kv TOLs ^vxals avTCLS LcrxpvTas 8ta(/)e/)0)ueVovs dAATjAois
6\l/6fxeda iav ixTabL(i>Koop.ev.
NE. 212. Uov brj keycLs;

EE. 'Ey Trao-i re br} tovtols ois vvv eLTropiev, ws ciko's .
T kv tTepoLS TTokkoLS. KaTCL yop otpaL ti]v avTU)v eKarepoLS d

a~vyyevLav tcl p.ev iTraLvovvTes ois oiKeia atpeTepa, tcl be
tS)V bLa(})6p(tiv yîyovTes ws dAAoVpia, TroAAî; els exdpav
akkrjkoLS Kal Ttokkiav TrepL KaOCcTTavTaL.
NE. 212. KLvbvvevovaLv, 5
EE. ITaidta tolvvv avTrj yk tls rj bLa(f)opa tovt(x)V eori
tG)v elbGiV' TTfpl be tcl p.eyLaTa v6aos crvixâLveL TraaGiV
\OL(TTri yCyvecrOaL rais 7ro'Aeo-ii'.
NE. 212. ITepi br] iTola (^r\s;
SE. ITept 6kr]v, u)S ye etKo'?, Tr]v tov ^tjv iTapa^rKerxqv. e

ot fxev yap br] bLa(})p6vT(i)s ovTes K6cr]XL0L tov r]crv\ov det
^LOv (TOLfxoL Cv^'> avTOL Kad^ avTovs pi6voL TCL a-(f)eTpa avT&v
TTpaTTOVTes, OLKOL T av TTpOS aTTaVTas 0VT0)S OfXLkoVVTeS, Kal
TTpbs TCLS e^codev 7ro'Aeis b)(ravT(i)s Tol]xol iravTa 6vtS 5
Tp^TTOv TLVCL ayLV lpr]vr]V' KdX 8ta Tov epooTa br] tovtov .
aKaLp6Tpov ovTa r]
XPV' oTav h ôvkovTaL TrpaTTooaLV,
ikaOov avTOL re aTTokepLOos tcrxovTS Kal tovs V0vs oacrav-
T(i)S bLaTLdVTS, OVTS T dei tS)V TTlTLdp.VO)V, ^ WV

ovK v TTokkols TcrLv avTOL Kal TTalbes Kal avpiTacra r] 10
b 10 Koi ante vBpKTriKk add. B T e i papvrepa Ka\ om. B

C2 TowTa] avTo. B C4 voKefxlav Campbell iroAe^/os : BT
C 8 TTov 5t/] (TTrovSrii (t add. rec.) B cnrovS^ T :d i Te] ye T
d 2 ff^perepa^ ecf erepa B T d 6 vaiSeia B T ye tis] an y' eri ?
Campbell ea rjffvxiov T 63 ^Jiô secl. Valckenaer 64 oS
om. B 7 XP^" Isic) T fiovXtvrai BT
3o8a nAATilNOS
308 TToXis avT (\(v6(p(tiv TToAAdiKis (\adov avrovs yfvo/ierot
bov\oi,.
NE. 2X2. XaXeTTov elircs koI beivov TrdOos.

SE. Ti 8' ol TTpos Trjv hvhpiiav fwXKov piirovTis; ap
5 ovK ei:\ TToKffxov dci Ttva Tas avroiV crvvTfCvovTfs iToKfis
8ia Tr]v Tov TOLOVTov fiiov (r(f)obpoTpav tov bfovTos (ttlOv-
fxiav eis t\6pav iToXkois Ka\ bvvaToXs KaTaardvTfs i} iTi.yiiTav
fitwAeo-ay t) bovkas av kox VTToyfipiovs Tols (\6pois viTidio-av

Tas avriov TTaTpibas;
b NE. 212. "EoTt Kat ravra.
SE. ricSs ovv /xt) (jiâixfv kv tovtois afj.(f)6Tpa Tavra to.
yivr) TToXkr]v TTpos fiAArjAa dct xat Tr\v fj.(yiaTr)v Xa-)((iv
lx,6pav Ka\ (TTdcnv;

5 NE. 212. OvbafiSiS 0)? ov (f)i]a-ofi(V.
SE. OvKovv oTT(p (TT(a-KOTTovfX(v KaT &pxas avrfvp^Kafx(v,
5ti fxopia h.p(Tr]S ov (TfXLKpa dAA?/Aots bLa(f)(p((r6ov (f)va-(L Kat
8^ Kat Tovs lcôvTas bpaTOV to avrb tovto;

NE. 212. KLvbvv(V(Tov.
10 SE. To'8e Toivvv av kaôifxiv.
NE. 212. To TTOLov;
C SE. EI Tis TTov TOiv crvv6(TLKQv (TTLOTrffxCiV TTpayfxa
OTLOvv tG)V avTTJs ^pyoiv, K^v (l To (f)av\6TaTov, ^Kovaa (k
fxo)(6r]pS)V KOLL XPV^^^ TLVUiv (rvvi(m](TLV, 7/ Trao-a (TTLarrifxr]
TTavTayov to. fx(V fxo\6r]pa ds bvvafXLV aiTOJSdXK^L, tcl b(

5 e7rtT7/8cta Kai [to] xprfOTa eAa/Scr, (k tovtcdv b^ Ka\ ofxoioiv
Ka\ avofxoioiv 6vto)V, TTdvTa ds kv avTO. (rvvdLyova-a, fxiav
TLva bvvap.LV Ka\ Ibiav brffXLovpyd.
NE. 212. Ti p.r]v;
d SE. Ov8' 6.pa KaTCL f] (f)VcrLV aXrjdciS ovaa rjfXLV tto\ltlki]
fxrj TTore iK xprjaTQv Kai KaKQv dv6p(aTT0)v kKov(ra eivai

ruoTô-Tjrai mKLV TLvd, dAA' cv8?jAor ori 7rat8id ttpQtov
a7 Karaffrdvrfsl an KaraffT^^ffavTas ? Campbell ba rcb om. B

b 3 &AXj\a </ B b6 iaKoirovfifv T b8 SpoTov] 8pa rhv T C 5 ri
om. B d2 ju^ iroTt] fxfiSrwoTf T d 3 Tif o ir6Kiv T
nOAITIKOS 3o8d
âcravuX, fxeTO, be ti]V âcravov av Tois hvvaîvois Traibeveiv

Kal vTrqpeTelv TTpos tovt avTO Trapabdoa-ei, TTpoaTaTTov(Ta 5
Ka\ kTncTTaTovaa avTi), Kadanep vâvTiKr] tois t âCvovcri
Kal Tols TaWa TrpoTTapacTKiva^pvcnv ocra Trpbs ti]v TrXi^LV
avTijs (TvpiTTapaKokovOovcTa npoa-TaTTei Kal (.TncTTaTU, toi-
avTa kKaa-Tois ivbeLKVva-a to. ipya aTTOTeXelv ota av eTrtT?/- e
bLa rjyfJTaL iTpbs Tr]v avTJJs etvaL (tv]j.tt\ok7]v,
NE. 2X2. Yldvv fjikv ovv.

HE. TavTov br] ]xol tovO^ rj /3a(rtAiK7/ (fyaiviTaL iTaaL
TOLS KaTO. v6]xov TTaLbevTals Kal Tpo({)(vaLV, Tr]v rfjs eTricrTaTi- 5
Krjs avTT] bvvafJLiv )(ôvcra, ovk iiTLTpdyj/fLV acTKdv otl fxr] tls
TTpbs Tr]v avTTJs ovyKpacTLV aTTepyaôfXivos rjOos tl ttp^ttov

aTTOTeXd, TavTa 6e pLOva TTapaK^kevecrOaL TTaLbeveLV Kal
Tovs fxv fxrf bvvafxevovs kolv(i)V(lv r^jdovs avbpcLOV Kal (rdi-
(fipovos oa-a Te aAAa eo-Tt TetiôrTa TTpbs dpfTrjv, aXA' els 10

aêoTr^Ta Kal vfipLv Kal abLKLav VTrb KaKr]s ^m (pva-fcos 3^9
a7T(66ovfx4vovs, OavaTOLs tc iKâXkiL Ka\ (jivyaLS Ka\ Tals
fxeyLCTTaLS Kokdôva-a aTLjxLaLS.
NE. 2f2. AeyeTaL yovv ttcos ovtcos.

HE. Tovs be iv dfxaOia. tc av /cat TaireLVOTrfTL ttoAAtj 5
KvkLvbovfxevovs et? to bovkLKbv viroQevyvvaL yivos.

NE. 2f2. 'OpôVaTa.
HE. Tovs koLTTOvs TOLWV, 6(T(tiv al (pvaeLS tt\ to yev-
vaLOV LKava\ TTaLbeCas TvyxdvovaaL KadicTTaadaL kcu beâcrOaL b

fxeTCL Texyrjs ovpfxeL^LV TTpbs dkkrjkas, tovtcov Tas fxev 7t\
Tr]v dvbpeiav fxdkkov (TvvTeivova-as, oXov crTrfpLovocpves vofxi-

aaa' avTcav eHvaL Tb aTepebv
^ ^]6os, tcls be C7rt Tb Koafxiov
TTiovL Te Ka\ fxakaK^ Ka\ KaTa Tifv elKova KpoK(i>beL bLavrjfxoTL 5
TTpo(r)(j)(i)fxevas, evavTLa be TeLvovaas dXk-qkaLS, TTeLpaTai
TOLOvbe TLvd TpOTTOV a~vvbeXv Ka\ crvfXTTkeKeLV.
NE. 2X2. notoi; br]-,
e I oiroTe\6< T 4 ^ om. B (sed toW^ e6 iiriTpcKfiv T

aa airceOovfifvovs Stallbaum airwdovfjieya
: BT b^ vofj.l(ras BT
h5 SiavîLiaTi Cornarius Siavd-fifiaTi B T
:
309 c riAATilNOS
c HE. rTpairoy fjiev xara rb avyyevei t6 <ieiyj;? 6v Trjs
"^VXV^ avrijv \iipos OeCoi (rvvapnoa-aîvr) bea-fiQ, fi(Ta bk t6

6(iov t6 C<ôyevis avToov av9i9 avOpaiTTLVOis.
NE. 212. Tlcos TovT (TiTfs av;
5 EE. Tr}v TU)V KoXoiV Kal biKaCoiV Trepi Kal ^ya65>v koX
tS)V tovtols (vavTioov ovtms ovaav oXrfdTJ boâv fieTa ^(âi-
(oo-ecos, oiroTav kv [7019] \j/vxals eyyCyvrfTai, 6eCav (prjiu (v
baipLOvCia yCyv(rdaL yeVei.
NE. 2X2. TIpiTTft yovv ouroi.
d HE. Tov brj TTokiTtKov Kal Tov ayad6v vo\io6iTr]v ap

l(rp.V oTi Ttpoa-rfKd fiovov bvvaT^v flvai, tt) ttjs /SaoriAiK^s
fxova-r} TovTO avT6 kp.T:oitiv Tois 6p6u)S /xraAa/3oi)o-t 7rai6câs,
ots i\iyofiV vvvb-q;

5 NE. 212. To yovv (Ikos.
HE. *0s 6' av bpav y(, S 2wKparey, abvvaTrj t6 toiov-
Tov, fjLrjbiiioTe rois vvv ^jjrou/iirots 6v6fui<Tw avT6v "npocr-
ayopevcopiev.
NE. 212. 'OpdoTaTa.

10 HE. Ti ovv; avbpeCa ylfv\rf Kafiâvofxivrf TTfs TOiavrrfs
e akrjêCas ap' ovx rfjxepovTai, Kal tS>v biKaCoiV fx^Xiara ovrco
Koivoovelv ^v i^fXrja-eiev, fxi] /xcraAa/3ouaa 6e aTTOKXivd
fxaXXov TTp6s 6r)pi(3)br] Tiva (^vaiv;
NE. 212. Um b' ov;
5 HE. Ti 8e t6 Trjs KocrfxCas (Pva-euis; ap ov tovtohv fxev
fXTa\a^6v tQv boûiv ovTdiS aSx^pov Koi (^povifxov, &s ye Iv

TToAtreia, yCyveTai, fxi] KOLVcovifaav b^ (Hv keyofxev iiToveC-
bia-TOV Tiva (vrfOeCas SixatoVara \afxj36.v(i. (firjfxrjv;
NE. 212. riari; fxev ovv.

10 HE. OvKOW a~vfXTTXoKr]V Kal ba-fx6v tovtov roij fxev
KaKOis TTp^s (r(f)as avrovs Kal toIs ayadols TTp6s T(yvs KaKovs
c 7 ra7i otn. B Stobaeus d

6 7-*] t T 62 ixoic\iyf7
scripsi airoKKivfi
: BT e6 fifra\a$6vr(i>v Soâiv B tf>p6vifxoy]
K6<Tfxiov T e 10 Sf(r/xhv^ (vvSf<riJ.ov T rovrov] an rotovrov ?
Campbell
nOAITIKOS 3096
fir]hiiTOT novtfxov <f)&[XV yiyv<r6ai, jjnjbi Twa f'jn(rTr}(j.r)v
aVTQ> (TTTOvbr] TTpOS TOVS TOIOVTOVS civ )(^fnj(r6aC TTOTe;
NE. Sil'. n&is ydp;

EE. Tois 8' (vyevicn yVOfiVoi,s re e^ ".pxrjs rjOio-i 310
OpecfyOdcrC re /cara (f)V(rLV piovois bta vopLoov iiJL(pv(r6ai, Kat
TTi TOVTOts 8r) TovT (tvat Tiyvr] (f)6.pixaKOV, Kat Ka^direp

("tTTOfjLev TOVTOV ^(toTepov elvat tov (rvvbea-pLOv dpeTrjs fxepQv
(f)V(r(os dvofxoCuiv kolL eirt to. iVavTta (fKpofxivcov.
NE. 212. 'AXr]ei(rtaTa.
EE. Tovs fxrjv XotTTOvs, ovTas dvdpooTTCvovs h(r[xovsi
vTTapxovTos TOVTOv Tov 6eCov (ryj^hov ovhtv yaXiTTQV ovre

ivvoeiv ovre h'vor](ravTa dTTOTeKeiv.
NE. 212. IIcDs hr], Ka\ riras; b
EE. Tovs tS>v (TTtyafxt&v Kat iraCbâv Kotvonvqaeoiv Ka\
tQ>v TTpl TOLS IbCas eKôVeis Kal ydjxovs. ol yap 7T0XX.0I Tct
Trept TavTa ovk 6p6Qs avvbovvTat TTpos Trjv Ta>v iTaCboov

yivvr](rtv. 5
NE. 2i2. Ti Stj;
EE. Ta ixv ttXovtov Kal bvvdixeoov iv toIs TotovTots

bt(ay[xaTa tC KaC Tts dv o)? aîa Xoyov a-TTOvbdôt ix[x(f>6]xevos;
NE. 212. Ovbiv.
EE. MaAAov bi ye bCKatov tQv Trept tcl yivr] TTOtovjxivoov 10
iTTtfxiXetav tovtoov iTipt kiyetv, eC rt }xr] KaTct TpoiTOv iTpdT- C
roucrti'.
NE. 212. EtKos yap ovv.

EE. ITparrouo-i fxev brj ovb^ i^ kvbs dpdov Koyov, Tr]v iv
T(o TTapaxprJixa btcoKOVTes pacrTdovrjv Ka\ tS tovs fxev iTpocr- 5
ofxoCovs avTOLS da-7Tdâ-6at, tovs b' dvopLoCovs fxr] crTipyetv,

TTkelaTov Trj bvcr^^êpeCa fxipos dirovifxovTes.
e 12 (pw/xfv ylyveffOai fiSvifiov T a i yevofjievois y | dpx^s

B : 7 ^l o-PX^^ ytvofjLfvois T a3 tovtois^ rovrovs B /cal
om. B a4 toCto" T dftiraTov B a^ <j>vffea>s^ (pvfffi Ste-
phanus a 9 o(jTe ivvoitv otn. B b8 ZitiyfxaTi sed in marg. 5J T
C 4 jJLfV 5^] fJL)]V T
3I0C nAATiiNOS
NE. 2(1. Um;
HE. 01 fiip TTOv Koa-fiioi rb cr^hcpov avT&v ^doi (r)-
10 Tovai, Kol KaTa hvvafj.i.v ya/iowt tc iTapa tovtojV kuX tcls
d (Kbiboix4vas Trap' avrSiv cts tovtov^ kKTiiintovcri. TraKiv' iy

8' avro)? To Trepl ttjv hvhpiiav y4vos bpa, ttjv airrov fxiTa-
hiQiKov (f)V(nv, beov TroicTi' afj.(f)6T(pa to. yevq TovTUiv Tovvav-
tCov &7rav.
5 NE. 212. n&i?, Kai 8ia t[;
HE. AtoVt -nicfiVKfv avbpda re er woXXats yevicncnv
fi/iciKTo? yvv<jiyAvr] a-(o(f)povi, (f)V(Ti jcara fxcr ipx^^ aK/xaêtr
p(ap.ri, reAevr&io-a 6e (âvdiZv TravTdira^fi fiavCais.
NE. 212. EJko?.
10 HE. 'H 8e albovs ye av Xtay TrXi^/yrjs V^^X'/ '^"^ "'
e Kipa(TTOs T6kp.r]s avbpeCas, eirl bk yeveas TToWas ovtco yevvr]-
6cL(ra, voi)6(rTpa (f)V(r6ai tov Kaipov Kal dTrorcXcurwo-a 6f/
T:avT(iTra(nv avaiTr]pov(rdai.
NE. 212. Kai TOVT^ (Ikos ovtco (rviiâCvdv.
5 HE. Tovrouy br] tovs b(rp.ovs (\eyov oti xaXfTTov

ovbev a-vvbflv VTrapâvTOS tov iTfpl to. KaXa Kd,yada ixCav
Ixeiv ap.(^6Tpa to. y^vrj b6âv. tovto yap kv Kal oKov

(otI /Sao-iAi/c^s (rvvv(f)a.v(r()S ^pyov, /iTjSeTrorc iav CKfiCara-
<r6ai (r(li(f>pova i.Trb t&v &vbpCoiv 7/07/, avyKpKCCovTa bk
lo Ofjiobo^Cais Kal Tt/iais Kai drt/xiais Kat 8o'ats Kal 6fir]piCi>v
Kb6cra-i,v fis dAA7/\ouj, Actoy xai t6 Ky6fivov evrJTpiov

311 v(fiaa-fia a-vvdyovTa i^ avrStv, Tas kv Tois iroÂeaiv iipyas
det Koivrf tovtois kiTiTpeTTfW.
NE.'2I2. n<3?;
HE. Ou fi\v h,v kvhs &p\ovTos XP*^ avfiâCvr), tov
TavTa hp.(fi6Tpa i^ôvTa alpoifxVOV iTTi.ard.Trjv' ov 8* Si'
5
TTX.L6v(tiV, TOVT(tiV fJipOS KaTpUiV aVfJLfiiyVVVTa. TO, fJLV
yap a(ii(fip6v(tiv 6.p\6irroiv 1)6^] a(f)6bpa pkv cvAa/3^ Kal Stxata
C 10 T] T Kal B d I rovTovt] ToiovTovs T d

10 ytl
Tf B e I 5i om. e6 ^vy5t7v irripôyTOS T
: (vwwipâtrros B
e8 (n;vv^ciy(r(ws] (rw^xMrtvs B e i o koI kriitiais om. B
nOAITIKOS 3"a
Kal (ToiTrjpia, hpnivrr^Tos h\ KaC tlvos ira//orrjro? oêtas Kal
TTpaKTlKiji (vhHTaL.
NE. 2X2. AoKet yovv brj Kal raSe. lo
HE. Ta 8' avbpeld ye av Trpos fxev t6 hiKaiov koX evXa- b

êy iKeCvoiv iTriSeeVrepa, ro 8e ey rai? irpdêa-i lTap.ov
StaêpoVrcos icrxet. Trai^ra 8e Kak5>s yiyvea-Qai to. Trepl Tas

77o'Aets tSta xai hrjp.oa-ia tovtolv ju,t/ 'napayevop.ivoLv diJLffôlv
dbvvaTov. 5
NE. 2X2. Ylois ydp ov;
HE. ToCro 8?) re'Aos v^da-p.aTos evQvTrXoKLa avp.T^KaKkv
yiyvea-OaL (p&fxev rrokLTLKrjs Trpafecos to tG>v dvbpeio^v Kal
a-M(f)p6v(i)V dvdp(aTr(tiv rjdos, diroTav bpovoicL koX (pLkiq. kolvov
avvayayova-a avT&v tov îov r} /SacrtAtK?) T\vri, TrdvToov c
p.eyaXoTrpcjria-TaTOv v^pacrpidToov Kal dpLo-Tov diroTekecracra
[cScrr' etiât kolvov^ tovs t dXkovs iv rats TTokecrL TrdvTas
bovkovs Kal ikevdepovs dp.T[ia-yova-a, arvvi\r\ TOVTOi rw irAe'-
yp.aTL, Kal Kad^ oaov evbaipiovL Trpoa-^KeL yiyvecrOai. irokeL 5

TovTov p.rjbap.rj pLrjbev eAAetTTOvo-a dpxj} re Kat eTrtcrrarr/.
NE. 212. KctAAto-ra av tov âcTLkLKov dTTeT^kearas dvbpa
rjpLLv, 00 e'ye, Kat tov irokLTLKOv.
bI tA 8' om. T b2 Irafxhv Ast : rh ixkv BT b7 trv/t-
ir\oej/] ffviiitXeKdv B : ^vfxirKiKiv T b8 <^cD/iei'] <pafj.V B

C3 S)(tt' eliôi Koiv6v secl. Ast Sctt'] Ss 7'Campbell C4 0,0-
</)i(rxoi'<'' B
V
,l>
OXONII
Exciidebat Horatius Hart
Typographus academiais
o
BlNDlâG LiU i 1343
PA Plato
4279 Opera
A2 t. 1
1905
t.l
PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE

CARDS OR SLIPS FROM THIS POCKET
UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO LIBRARY

Operarecognovitb01platuoft PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Operarecognovitb01platuoft PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

SCRIPTORUM CLASSICORUM

TETRALOGIAS I-II CONTINENS

dagandis collocatam operam tertius accassit Venetus

terioribtis ut aiebat tribuerat, libello plus viginti abhinc

ceteris omnibus paene sine damno carere possemus.

Schanzium meo iudicio verum vidisse rectissimeque

(Bekkeri IT, Schanzii D) repetenda est. quae cum ita

indigentem, quae tamen res propterea fugit parum dih*-

paulo eruditior qui perraro omittendo peccat nec fere

(id est, ut videtur, k^acn^Ti), quae etiam in prioris

Clarkianum iUud ^tdo-7;rai adscriptum sit, hanc sci-

praeter spem novum et idoneum testem Schanzium

Schanzii W), qui ita cuni Clarkiano consentit ut scrip-

vestigia etiam apud Eusebium, Stobaeum aliosque

quotquot hic praebet singulares lectiones diligentis-

lectionem servasse videantur. non erat nostrum

cditus quidem sed nondum adhibito Marciano. quod

editio. sicubi autem de Vindobonensi (W) non mihi

De codice Vindobonensi (W) a viro doctissimo

TeTRALOGIA I ED. STEPH.

Leges . II. pp. 624-969

Epinomis n. pp. 973-992

Definitiones III. pp. 4II-4I6

B= cod. Bodleianus, MS. E. D. Clarke 39 = Bekkeri Qt

T = cod. Venetus Append. Class. 4, cod. i = Bekkeri t

W = cod. Vindobonensis 54, suppl. phil. Gr. 7 = Stallbaumii

C= cod. Crusianus siue Tubingensis = Stallbaumii X

Berol. = Papyrus Berolinensis 9782 (ed.

Recentiores manus librorum BTW litteris btw significantur

Codicis W lediofies cutn T consentientes commevioravi, lec-

TvyxdveL Ttpbs tov ^acrikia utcnrep ^fxoL

2X2. Ovrot brj 'AOrjvaLoC ye, S EvOvcppaiV, bLKr]v avTr]V 5

KaAoSo-iy dXka ypa(f)r]v.

ET0. Tts owros;

fjLevTOL avTov, o)? iy(o]xaL, MeArjror. ecrrt be tuiv brjfxoDV

YlLTOevs, et rtzâ rco exêts ITtrêâ MeÂrjroy olov TeTavoTpL^â 10

Kat ov Trdvv evyeveLOV, eTiiypvTiOV be.

B T as 5 Ev6v(ppaiv constanter B T, plerumque

: S) Evdv<ppov B^ b 2 crv B (Ty T-e T

rj\LKL(OTas avTov, ^p^eTaL KarqyoprjcrcDV p.ov axnrep irpos

d p.6vos ap\e(TdaL 6p6(as' 6p6S>s yap (cttl t&v v4(t)v iTpojTov

i7TLiJLX.ri6rjvaL ottcoj icrovTaL otl apL(TTOL, wo-Trep yecopybv

3 /xey rjixas eKKa6aLpL tovs tG)V viu)V tcls ^Xda-Tas 8ta0^et-

^VTcpcav iTLp.ekr}6ls TrkeLa-Tcav Kal pi.eyi(rTcx)V dya6G)V alTLOs

ET0. BovkoLjxr^v dv, 6) ^(OKpaTes, dAA' 6ppu)b(o fxr] tov-

5 ET0. Mavddvot), S ScoKpares* ort S?) av t6 baLp.6vLov

C OTOV TL keyo) ev Trj eKKkr]a-Ca TTepl tG)V 6eCo)V, TTpokeyo)v

avTols Ta p.ekkovTa, KaTayekGiaLV ws p.aLvopevov KaCTOL

C 7 wartrtp T W ois B e8 irphs om. al. Cobet a2 aij BT

yp. : Tf ois W b2 jTonjT^i' (hai /ue T b8 Sia^aKilDv (sic)

vovaiv yjfXLV Tracn toij tolovtols. aX.)C ovbev avT(x>v XPV

2X2. '12 (pCXe Kv6v({)p(ov, akXa to jjiev KaTayiXacrOrjvaL

ov (r(j)6bpa /xeAet av TLva beLvbv ot(avTaL elvai, fxri fxcvToi

bLbaa-KaXLKov ttjs avrov cro(f)Las' ov 8' av /cai aWovs otcov-

rai TTOLelv tolovtovs, 6vp.ovvTaL, eir' ovv (f)66v<^ w? (tv Ae'yet?, d

ET0. Tovrov ovv Trepi o7ra>? Trore TTpbs e/ie (XOVctlv, ov

212. 'la-dis yap av fxfv 8oKer? (nrdvLov creaxrrbv 7rape'xety 5

Kot StSacTKety ovk k6iX.kLV Tr]v creavTOV cro^piav' eyo) 8e

fxev ovv, 6 wvbrj ekeyov, fxekkoLev p.ov KaTayekdv wo-Trep 10

av (f)rjs a-axrrov, oi/bev hv eir/ dr]bes TTai^ovTas kcu yekS)VTas e

OTrri d7ro/3?;o-erai dbrikov TTki]v vp.LV tols fxdvTea-LV.

ET0. 'AAA' to-cos ovbev earaL, S) ^(oKpaTes, irpdyixa, dAAa

2f2. "EoTtr be br] croi, o) Yiv6v(ppo)v, rty t/ 8tKj/;