8^==

Sfl
S

|)

SEXTI EMPIRICI OPERA

RECENSDIT

HEEMANNUS MUTSCHMANN

YOL.

IIYPP&NEI&N YnOTYn&SE&N
LIBROS TRES
CONTINENS

LIPSIAE IN AEDIBUS B.G.TEUBNERI MCMXII

LIPSIAE: TYPIS

B. G.

TEUBNEKI

SAMUELIS SCHASS
DIS MANIBUS
S.

PBAEFATIO.
Fauci exstant scriptores e quibus studioaus veteris philosophiae plura diacere, atque si sano iudicio instructus ad lectionem eius accedat, maiorem fructum oapere possit. (Fabricius in Praef.

ad Sextum Empiricum)

ante hos quinque annos de nova Sexti Empirici editione paranda consilium iniissem, id mihi in primis proposui, ut scriptoris

Cum

memoriam quam maxime

fieri

posset

enuclearem.

rum

Recensioni igitur primum, emendationi altelocum tribui, cum ab omnibus qui ante me fuerunt

editoribus illud

animadvertissem.

munus miro quodam modo neglectum esse Quo factum est, ut viri illi egregii in
infeliciter versati

emendandis Sexti verbis haud

multos ta-

men committerent errores, cum de traditis male edocti essent. Operam igitur dedi, ut textus traditi antiquissimam formam restituerem, quem ad finem omnes qui ad notitiam
venerunt codices aut ipse contuli aut inspiciendos Quod inceptum ut felicem ad finem perducere possem, benevolentia eorum virorum factum est, qui legatum Schassianum Kiloniense administrant. Adiumentum enim lautissimum ad iter Gallicum semel, ad Italicum vel bis instituendum humanissime praebuerunt. Qua de
curavi.

meam

mecum

re omnes, quibus meae copiae usui erunt, grato animo colant memoriam Samuelis Schass liberalium artium
fautoris, cuius
I.

manibus haec

editio sacra esto.

DE RECENSIONE HYPOTYPOSEON.
"

1 Sexti codicibus quae dicenda habebam, fusius ex- ^J^j >osui in Mus. Rhen. vol. LXIV (1909) p. 244 sqq., quae Graecis

De

VI

PRAEFATIO.
1

hic paucis repetere liceat. ) Atque demonstrare hac dissertatione studui speroque me demonstravisse omnes qui exnasse.

stant Sexti libros Graecos integros ex uno archetypo maQuorum condicio ac necessitudo cum alia sit in
,

Hypotyposibus alia in ceteris scriptis Sextianis, hic de tantum dicam. Statui igitur duas eorum classes esse alteram cuius signifer est Laurentianus L (olim siglo r a me nuncupatus), alteram codicum deteriorum, quorum ingenti ex turba selegi Parisinos E et A et Berolinensem B. Sed nondum videram Monacensem M, quem ubi primum inillis
:

spexi, statim tertium testem nullo cognationis vinculo cum utraque classe coniunctum esse cognovi. Quo fortunatius nibil evenire poterat, cum nunc in locis dubiis duobus testibus contra tertium conspirantibus antiqua archetypi lectio facile eruatur. Ecce stemma librorum quibus Hypo-

typoses continentur:

Archetypu8

(=

G)

M
Codicum
ne legentium

EAB

EAB

consensum uno

in Hypotyposibus quidem quasi Menaechmos et unius patris habendos esse. Attuli autem E ut optimum huius classis, B ut vulgatae lectionis perfectissimum exemplar, A ut a Nicolao Sophiano Graeculo semidocto scri-

mentem

siglo comprendere nolui, iusto plus turbarem, scito vero eos

ptum atque inter permultas ineptas hariolationes paucas maioris pretii emendationes exhibentem. 2 ) Qui liber hac
Gaudeo quod quae de codicum necessitudine illic disassensum tulerunt Augusti Nebe, viri de Sexto optime meriti, qui (Berl. philol. Wochenschr. 1909 col. 1456) dicit: sotveit ich nachprufen kann, ist sein S. 277 fiir dos Hauptwerk des S. gegebenes Handschriftenstemma im wesenilichen zu1)

serui

treffend."
2) Idem iam cognovit Hermannus Diels qui in editione Sicde&cov quae dicuntur Doricarum in corpore Sextiano traditarum dicit (Frg. d. Vorsokr. H 1* p. 635 adn.): Seine Dialektberichtigungen scheinen nicht auf tjberlieferung, sondern auf halbgelehrter Konjektur zu beruhen."

PRAEFATIO.
similis est Parisini suppl. gr.

VH
s.

133

contuli terdum praebet, quae Ire optime excogitatatotum suo quaeque locoenim n Hypotyposibus quidem adnotavi.

toque a viro

quodam docto exaratus

XVII (D). hic in textu contaminato

Nam

Ceterorum autem catervam missam

si

credo ullum librum,

quis

feci neque quando prodierit, ad textum

constituendum vel minimo usui fore, nisi ex alio atque quem nunc tenemus archetypo fluxerit. Talium librorum, quos caeca servaverunt fata, unum esse cognovi Matritensem 30 (cf. Mus. Rhen. LXIV p. 281 2), cuius paginas nonnullas Ioannes Mewaldt, qua est erga me benevolentia, Ex quo Vesontinus ille U (cf. 1. 1. p. lucis ope depinxit. 248 et 255) descriptus esse mihi quidem videtur, ipse autem pessimae notae ac plane abiciendus est. Idem de Monacensi 493 interim a me inspecto dicendum est. Neque magnam spem mihi movent codices Norimbergensis (cf.MurrMemorabiliaNorimbergensia vol. I p. 53, Norimb. 1786), utpote qui sicut d (Escor. W, IV 16) et Londinensis (e libris Regis 16 D III, quem in illa dissertatione littera L signavi cf. 1. 1. p. 248 et 249) ab Andrea Darmario homine nefario et fraudulento ex parte scriptus sit, et

Rossicus 24
vol.

s.

XVII

(cf.

Gollob, Sitz.-Ber. d.

Wiener Akad.
solita co-

CLXIV fasc. 3 p. 72), ad mitate me revocavit. Sed quo

quos

Hugo Rabe

facilius tales libri in

stemma

nostrum redigi possent, in afferendis codicum, etiam deteriorum, lectionibus plus mihi indulsi quam hoc ad ipsum textum restituendum necessarium fuisse iure putaveris.

Haec

Quem ipsum

igitur parata sunt refingendi archetypi subsidia. olim (1.1. p. 277) initio saeculi in Occi-

XV

dentem illatum

et statim describi

coeptum

esse affirmavi.

Quae sententia
s.

stare

iam non

potest,

cum Monacensis
illic (p.

noster
conieci

281) archetypum illum Venetias primum delatum ibique, antequam evanesceret, descriptum esse, nolim hodie tanto

XIV

ex. scriptus sit.

Deinde quod

cum pondere premere, id tamen teneo communem patrem vulgatae recensionis (EAB) illa in urbe olim exstitisse et ibi iterum atque iterum descriptum esse. Et quisquis ad-

Vm
notationes

PRAEFATIO.

meas criticas attento animo perlustraverit, facile videbit hunc librum vigentibus iam litterarum antiquarum studiis ab homine erudito scriptum esse, qui interdum

levia

menda
et

sustulit,

interdum autem tradita ingenio nimis

successores eius, velut
ii

confisus corrupit,

quam audaciam

descripserunt (vide supra p. VI sq.), imitati sunt. Elucet exinde egregia Laurentiani et Monacensis fides,

qui

librorum ex archetypo iniuria temporum plus atque plus adeso descriptorum, quod docet Laurentiani condicio, qui dicdet-s ig quae vocantur uno cum Sexto traditas ac ne in deterioribus

quidem integras in

fine

lacunae quae in solo

M exstant,

non iam exhibeat, docent qui plerumque talia fide-

liter indicat (cf. e. g. p.

50, 7. 68, 14. 92, 12).

Teneo ea quoque quae illic (p. 278 sq.) de archetypi forma disserui. Duae enim lacunae in L et M p. 71, 21 et 72, 25 fenestris indicantur, quarum EAB, cum textum continuum praebeant, ne mentionem quidem faciunt. Quas inde ortas puto, quod in archetypo male habito folium unum perforatum erat, ita ut spatium inter utramque lacunam inter-

missum pro complexu unius paginae haberi

possit. Itaque sescentenae fere syllabae in singulis illius paginis exstabant, ut externa specie Laurentianum in singulis paginis vicenos sescentenos fere syllabas continentem adaequasse videatur,

ponas eum quoque ut illum binis columnis Similiter iudicandum puto de lacunis, quarum unam p. 145, 10 Otto Apelt, alteram p. 146, 7 Immanuel Bekker indicavit; spatium quod inter eas est quingentenas fere tricenas syllabas complectitur. Haec de librorum Graecorum communi archetypo. Sed iam ipsos describam: Monac. gr. 489 est codex miscellaneus in primis 58 foliis
praesertim
si

exaratum

fuisse.

M=

Sexti vnotvTtwestg continens, in charta Italica s. XIV exeunte haud ineleganter, sed festinante manu exaratus 1 ), formae quartae (29 21,5 cm).

1)

distinxi,

voL

II,

foliis forficularum, quarum quattuor genera imagines pellucent (cf. C. M. Briquet, Les filigranes Lutetiae 1907 s. v. ciseaux: Les ciseaux sont un fili-

Multis e

PRAEFATIO.

IX

=
=
B

Laur. 81, 11 omnia Sexti opera continet, fol. 345, chartaceus, formae quartae (28 20,5 cm), binas in singulis paginis exhibet columnas, scriptus a. 1465 a Thoma Prodromita. Parisinus 1964 omnia Sexti opera et diaXi^sug quae vocantur usque ad verbum noiiovxi continet, fol. 279, chartaceus, formae quartae (27x20 cm), binas in singuliB paginis exhibet columnas, s. XV ex. Parisinus 1963 omnia Sexti opera et wXi%ng usque ad

verbum

insiov continet, fol. 327, chartaceus, formae quar22 cm) a. 1534 a Nicolao Sophiano Venetiis extae (33 aratus. Berol. Phill. 1518, codicis A, quem ambitu specie fide

fere adaequat, plane gemellus, fol. 330, chartaceus, for-

mae quartae (32x23,5 cm)

Sed iam
satis sit

a. 1542 a Camillo Bartolomeo de Zanettis Brixiano Venetiis scriptus.

de

communi librorum Graecorum

arche- _ D ?

Parig.

typo. Alius autem fons exiguus quidemmanat: servata enim suppL sunt duo folia membranacea, quae finem Hypotyposeon con-

1156 (P), ubi cum aliis Mynoidae Mynae spoliis, quae ex itinere a. 1840 per Graeciam et Asiam Minorem instituto secum asportaverat, conglutinata
tinent, in Paris. suppl.

inverso

ordine exstant, signata numeris 21 et 22, e co-

20 cm) oriunda. dice, ut videtur, formae quartae (28 Scriptura est s. X. Leguntur in singulis paginis 35 versus, ipsa autem folia media in parte detrita et quinquies per-

cum implicata sine dubio libri minoris formae quasi tegmina (Schutsblatter) habita sint. Et verisimilliforata sunt,

mum duco Hypotyposes tantum in illo libro exstitisse, cum miro quodam casu factum esset, ut barbarus ille haec folia e medio quodam libro, quo omnia Sexti opera continebantur, evellens in ipsum illarum finem incideret. Et facile intellegitur Hypotyposes illis temporibus seorsum circumlatas esse, utpote e quibus optima Scepticae philograne exclusivement italien. Ils apparaissent sous une forme rudimentaire a la fin du XIIIe siecle"). Ac simillimae sunt eis, quarum formae inde a numero 3655 apud Briquetium exstant, ita ut charta illa anno 1376 vetustior vix esse possit. Qua re, sed praecipue scripturae indole commotus sum, ut hanc codicis partem, quam Hardtius (Cat. cod graec. bibl. reg. Bav. IV (1810) p. 358) s. XIV attribuit, in s. XIV ex. vel. XV. in. referam.
tres

PRAEFATIO.
*)

sophiae notitia sumi posset.

est,

quod

folia

illa

tam exiguam

Valde autem lugendum textus partem exhi-

At tamen plane pernon eandem eorum memoriam esse, quam et archetypus codicum Graecorum et Trahslatio Latina nobis servaverunt. Vides igitur iam decimo saeculo libros fuisse, quorum verba a verbis communis illorum fontis discrebeant, ita ut nihil fere novi afferant.
spici potest

parent, et sperandum est, quamquam de origine illorum foliorum neque Mynas certiores nos fecit neque aliunde quid

comperi, tamen illum codicem aut totum aut mutilatum aut gemellum eius ad notitiam nostram venturum esse. Sed
vereor,
si

cum

folia nostra totius libri quasi

specimina ha-

beam, ut magnum ex eo fructum capturi essemus.

Nam
om-

aliquid conicere licet: credo Sextianorum scriptorum nium corpus (cf. p. XXIV) multo rarius quam singulas

Hy-

potyposes

descriptum

Transiatina

servavisse, ita esse optimo iure affirmare possimus. ^ e<^ * am venmi us a ^ tertium multo uberiorem textus

genuina scriptoris verba ut Sextum haud ita male nobis traditum

melius

oneLa-fontem:

Translationem Latinam Hypotyposeon (T) dico, lat. 14700 (olim St.Victoris 32) fol. 83 132 nobis servavit. Quam e libro ab archetypo nostro diverso factam esse e variis quas praebet lectionibus elucet neque dubium esse potest, quin ex Graeco statim in Latinum sermonem conversa sit. Nam codex ille miscellaneus saeculo XIV in. (cf. 01. Baeumker, Arch. fur Gesch. d.

quam

Parisinus

Philos.

IV

p.

576) summa cum arte exaratus, membrana-

22 cm), binas in singulis pagiceus, forma maxima (34 nis columnas praebens, inter alia scripta pbilosopha in
fol.

229 sq.

continet

Vitam
(scil.

Aristotelis,

lentinumKose editorem
ex graeca utraque

(Aristot.

quae secundum VaFragm. Lips. 1886 p.442)

confusaque opera con-

vita) dedita

1) Tales libros auctoris nomine caruisse docet Translatio Latina, de qua iam verba facturus sum, docet et scholiasta ad Luciani Icaromen. c. 25 p. 108, 20 Rabe, ubi IIvqqwvsioi 'T7toTVTtm6us tantum appellantur (vide p. XIX) et locus insignis Cosmae Hierosolymitani , quem infra (p. XX) exscribam.

PRAEFATIO.

XI

flata est db interprete anonymo saeculo quidem XIII". Atque haec quidem vita in aliis quoque codicibus exstat, Translatio autem nostra, ni fallor, in hoc solo libro servata est, ubi sub titulo Pirronie informationes" latens Aristotelique perperam adscripta viros doctos diu effugit, donec a Carolo Jourdain ad lucem protracta est (Excursions philosophiques
et

historiques

d travers

le

moyen-dge,Lutetiae 1888p.221sqq?).
:

Et expressit ea totum opus omissis tantum duobus locis 26, ubi interpretem Timonis versus difficiles p. 51, 11 sane ac spinosos non intellexisse verisimile est, et p. 145, 3 160, 20. Dubitari quidem potest, utrum hanc partem futtili argumentatione et crebris iterationibus molestam quasi supervacaneam ipse interpres an is demum qui nostrum

codicem exaravit, transsiluerit. Equidem crediderim interpretem, utpote qui tanta fide singula verba vertisset, omnia quae posset reddidisse, scribam autem, qui iam in extremis quae hunc locum antecedunt paginis miro modo somniavit, ad finem operis festinavisse. Quod ei in primis animadvertendum duco, qui aliquando secunda fortuna

quam primus ad recensionem adhibere potui, eo magis praestantia eius mihi effulgebat neque dubito affirmare in omnibus eam
Graeci exemplaris instar

aliud Translationis exemplar invenerit. Quo plus in ea Translatione elaborabam,

habendam

esse.

Quis

eam

con-

fecerit, nescio, censeo autem eum, quisquis fuit, aequalem fere Guilelmi a Moerbecke fratris ex ordine praedicatorum (s. XIII) Aristotelis interpretis fuisse. Sed iam

plus non contendam, sperans

me

aliquando a viris egregiis,

qui nostris temporibus tam assidue cum in res gestas et historiam philosopham litterariamque medii aevi tum maxime in fata librorum inquirunt, melius edoctum iri. Interdum admiror illum, qui textum Graecum summa cum religione, ne dicam stupore, usque ad horrendam sermonis Latini depravationem expresserit, qui etiam in rebus minusculis,

velut verba y.ccl, av, pev, ovv diligenter reddendo, modum coniunctivum aut indicativum vel contra grammaticae Latinae praecepta tuendo semper exemplar Graecum secutus sit.

XII

PEAEFATIO.

Lacunae autem, quibus scatet codex, eiusdem generis sunt

atque in Graecis libris, homoeoteleuto aut iterato eodem verbo ortae, quales non interpreti, sed scribis culpae vertas. Hanc Translationem cum textu Graeco aestate anni VII b.
s.contuliLutetiae etprimas
illas

lectionesdedil.l.p.257sqq.

Sed cum in dies magis intellegerem non omnibus eam locis a me exhaustam esse, intercedente Hermanno Diels facile ab eorum virorum, qui Bibliotbecae Nationali Parisiensi praesunt, benevolentia impetravi, ut codicem autumno anni IX Berolinum missum per tres fere menses denuo tractare possem. Descripsi autem totam Translationem. Quam in schedis teneo apud me, omnibus viris doctis, qui
altius in

eam

facturus.

Nam

investigare voluerint, copiam earum libenter totam eam typis mandare nolui quam-

ne pretium quam erant qui, hoc ut facerem, suaderent huius voluminis immodice augeretur; attuli autem omnes
,

eius lectiones, quae a verbis librorum Graecorum vel minime discrepare videbantur. Sed ut ipse indolem eius co-

videbis,

gnoscere possis, specimen in fine huius voluminis addidi: 1 quomodo munere meo functus sim. )

Sed iam

satis sit

in Laurentiano a Petro

de recensione. Codices ipse contuli, Von der Mvihll, in Monacensi ab

Eestitui enim argumenta

menufet
tituiis

Alfredo Wolff fideliter adiutus. Restat, ut unum moneam.

et titulos,

quos omnibus in codicibus et in Translatione Latina (ubi interdum rubricatoris socordia omittuntur) traditos Bekkerus suo more plane omisit. De quibus quid
sentiam,

cum nuperrime

in

Hermae tomo XLVI (1911)

1) Iam haec scripseram, cum mihi editoris comitate suo tempore allatus est libellus nuperrime ab Hermanno Schone evulgatus (Galenus de partibus artis medicativae Progr. univ. Gryphiensis a. 1911), quo de vita ingenio scriptis Nicolai Rhegini ita edoctus sum, ut iam non dubitem, quin ille, qui s. XIV in. multa Galeni scripta ex Graeco sermone in Latinum transtulit, nostrae quoque Translationis auctor habendus sit. Qua de re propediem fusius disputaturus sum, interim velim adeas quae in ephemeride Berl. -philol. Wochenschr. 1911 col.

691 sqq. disserui.

Xm

HPEAEFATIO.
ginibus tales tituli exstant.

93 sqq. fusius explanaverim, nolo me hic ipse exscribere. enuinos eos esse puto, ita tamen ut ad externam libri speciem pertineant, cum eos in margine adpictos esse doceant vestigia nonnulla in codicibus nostris deprehensa, doceat Didymi papyrus, ubi in supremis columnarum mar-

quem interdum interrumpunt,

obtemperans. Servandos quoque, quoad

Invitus igitur eos in textum, recepi, typothetae rationibus

fieri

poterat, curavi

Bekke-^ *^*"
editione

rianae editionis paginas et versus, quos in interiore paginae margine adscripsi, eorum gratia qui Sexti locos secundum hanc editionem laudare consueverant. Fragmenta aucto-

rum, quos Sextus

exscripsit, diductis

litteris

indicavi

et

numeris syllogarum signavi, quae hodie omnium in manibus sunt. Sed hac quoque in re certos denique fines esse arbitratus perspicua tantum et ab omnibus concessa ita
adornavi,

quamquam haud

ignoro fore, qui

me non

pror-

sus mihi constitisse asseverent.

Vereor enim, ne Sextus omnia fere quae praebet, ex aliorum libris congesserit. Deinde laudavi in inferiore paginarum margine eos locos Sextianos qui nostrorum vicem gerunt: quibus praecipue nisus spero me mox ea, quae de compositione consilio vicissitudine operum Sexti Empirici dicenda habeo, ad lucem
proferre posse.

H.

DE SEXTI EMPIRICI EDITIONIBUS.

Sextus Empiricus ter Graece editus est: primum a. 1621 Genevae a Petro et Iacobo Chouet, iterum a. 1718 Lipsiae ab J. A. Fabricio, tertium a. 1842 Berolini ab Im-

manuele Bekker. Quae inter alteram et tertiam nem prodierunt editio Hypotyposeon Mundtiana
Saxonum
a.

editio-

(Halis

1796)

et editio Lipsiensis (a.

1840) Fabricium

denuo excusserunt, quam ob rem neglegendae nobis erunt. " Sed iam ante primam editionem Graecam prodiit Pa- Ste ^g a risiis a. 1562 versio Latina ab Henrico Stephano confecta, in qua multa iam textus vitia a viro praeclari ingenii

sublata

et

aduotationes

quaedam

criticae

additae

XIV
erant.

PRAEFATIO.

Quo

codice Graeco
eius

ille

usus

sit,

nescio, sed erat

inter libros

gr. 12, eius inscriptione indicatur: Ex libris Henrici Stephani Florentiis emptus anno 1555. Qui liber codicibus simillimus ea re insignis est, quod in margine eius

qui nunc

est

codex Taurinensis

quod ipsa

AB

manu altera, fortasse ab ipso Stephano adscriptae sunt, quas e libro quodam codicis L simillimo x fluxisse statim cognoscitur (cf. Mus. Rhen. LXIV p. 252 ).
variae lectiones a
v
-

et

Editores Genevenses de libro

nisi

quem

adhibuerunt, tacent,

quod conspectum quendam variarum lectionum vel coniecturarum ad marginem codicis sui repertarum editioni praemiserunt. At tamen mira res videtur, quod hic cum L,
illic

cum EAB nam ab M mox

morabiles

fecisse

deprehenditur codex

ille

fabulosus;

rem

intelleges hunc prorsus alienum esse. Quam priusquam in iudicium vocemus, locos quosdam me-

exponam,

ceterorum codicum lectionibus eas

cf.
1.

Vesontini gr. 409 utpote quae miro

(= H;

1.

p.

245

et

255) addens,

quodam modo interdum cum GenevenAdnotaverunt editores

haec verba non habebat ms. noster (om. EABH). Ugitur ccvxr} r) (licoxuir) (= L). legitur xb \isv xoi (= EABH).

sium lectione conspirent:

In editione exstant
6,

25

7tccQtt7tXr]6icc

xai (= L)
(=ABH)

8, 2 8,

iv

/JteoTtxf/ ccvxr\

viiv xi

8,6
8,

ievCsv

(= L) (=LE) (= EABH).
av

pro

i6(isv alius legit d' ol fisv

(= ABH).
14 SisX9slv
scribitur

dissX&slv
slr\

in
Xiystv

alio

(=
9,

L).

24

slr\

Xiysvv

(=

L)

alter

habet dv

(=

EABH).
10, 27 dicc&iesig 11, 18 <joa/iaroov

(= EABH) (= L)
(=
L)

legit alter ftiesig

legitur

6vo(idxav

tantutn (= L). in ms. (=

EABH).
12, 7

13.15
13, 21 18. 16 20, 7

20, 28

y.ccl vn6cpa.6[La (= EABH). (= LH*) pro Tt. fortasse 7taQa(iv6avxss (= EABH). slvcci (= EABH) scribit alter xavxa (L). zovzo (= LEB) legitur xavxtt (A; H: xovxa). scribit alter %ve$Qnog (EABH). xQvezQpog (= L) scriptum noxatg (EABH). pioxu (= L)

v.al ol vnoGcpayiLtt

ms.

nccQtt(lrJ6ttvxsg

PRAEFATIO.
Quid

XV

Equidem

est ms., quis alter? Ubi scriptum est, ubi legitur? nullo alio modo hanc quaestionem dirimi posse cen-

prout videretur, aut verba quae in textu exstabant aut notas margini adscriptas probasse, in adnotationibus autem semper lectionem repudiatam alteri" dedisse. Sed cui classi codex ipse, cui marginalia attribuenda sunt? Animadvertas velim, ubicumque ms." diserte laudatur (velut ad p. 6,25. 1 1,18.12,7), codicum EABH lectiones reddi. Accedit alia res. Omnibus locis quibus in
seo, nisi quis statuerit editores,

codice

alia atque in
eis

EABH

traduntur, editores, nisi lectio

discrepans ab

commemoratur, semper fere librorum EABH verba atque ea quidem saepe misere corrupta expresserunt, ita ut coniciam codicem classis EABH cui non
semper lectiones alterius
pictae erant, batur,
illis

ad

manum

classis (cuius signifer est L) adfuisse. Quae res eo compro-

quod saepe cum Vesontino

Genevenses

H libro pessimo vulgatae

facile perspicies:

lectionis faciunt, ut ex

hoc conspectu

Altera lectio

7,

14 xb

cpaiv6(isvov

(cum

x&v cpaivo^ivav
vnfJQ^s ceteri.

(ceteri).

EABH)
8,

33 vnfjQ^ai,] (cum H)
!

dnb cpogag (cum EABH) dnocpoQ&g ceteri. acpaloai ceteri. 25, 22 ecpcclQcc (cum H) 28, 14 d-ccXd66f] (cum H) 9aXdxxrj ceteri. uitb (cum EABH) vnb ceteri. 39, 4 dvco t) iidxco (cum ABH) dvco xdxco ceteri. 42, 3 xai (iia (cum EABH) 50, 8 fiia ceteri. Liber igitur quem Genevenses adhibuerunt vulgatam lectionem praebebat 1), deterioribus autem adnumerandus et Vesontino H similis erat. At tamen haud paucae alterius
24, 18

quippe quae in margine eius exstarent, in editionem Genevensium receptae sunt. Periisse illum codicem inter omnes libros, qui quidem mihi innotuerunt, non agnitum vix aegre feres, cum multo meliora subsidia nunc praesto sint. Quibus id quoque effectum est, ut coniecturas quas ille simul cum varia lectione in margine exhibebat a
classis lectiones,
1)

Corrigenda igitur sunt,

dixi.

quae in Mus. Rhen. LXIV

p.

282

XVI
lectionibus traditis
p.

PRAEFATIO.
nunc secernere possimus e. g. Gen. 110, 11 cov, 110, 25 6 tamquam e libro

100, 11

alrj&ig,
,

addiderunt debemus.
^oios"

quas

cum

ceteris

aequo iudicio perpendere

^*

^- Fabricio praesto erant ad Hypotyposeon recens.

sionem codex Savilianus 11

XVI

Bhedig. 45 s. XV vel XVI (V). Genevensium autem editionem sedulo adhibuit, et possidebat exemplar cui coniecturae Salmasii ad marginem adscriptae erant, nec non

(S) et Vratislaviensis

lectionesquasdamParisinorum Mediceorum Ottobonianorum, quibus raro tamen utitur. Uterque librorum quos adhibuit eidem classi cui Laurentianus adnumerandus est, ex quo V ut a me 1. 1. p. 252 demonstratum est manavit, cum Savilianus, eiusdem fere originis, ne una quidem lectione excellat. Itaque editio Fabriciana illa classe nititur, cuius exemplar nos Laurentianum habemus, cum editio Gene-

vensium vulgatam plerumque lectionem suppeditaverit, quo factum est, ut textus acutissimi editoris opera optime constitueretur, quamquam de traditis male edoctus saepe in
falsum
incidit.

Stephani quoque versionem elegantem et

copiosas notas addidit vir eruditissimus, ut vel hodie editionem illam non sine fructu consulas.
Bekker

Immanuel Bekker in Hypotyposibus nullum alium librum adhibuit, nisi quod Vratislaviensem denuo contulit. Neque omnem quam scriptor flagitabat curam ab eo adhibitam esse docet praefatio exilis quam editioni praefixit. Quid? qui ipse dicit (p. IV) inspexi alios (scil. codices), Monacenses Venetos Florentmos, quos cum viderem neque extema specie commendari ct in mendas lacunasque conspirare, non sum cunctatus de manibus deponere, nonne' facile
perspicere poterat codicum Graecorum strenuus investigator Vratislaviensem sedulo a se ipso collatum e Lauren-

tiano totum descriptum esse, Cizensem, cuius lectiones atsine dubio e Marciano 262 manasse, Monacensem denique ceteros libros fide superare? Quae res in Vratislaviensi eo magis mira est, quod codex ille in fine mutilus omnia quae inter p. 365, 6 et p. 596, 5 intercedunt non
tulit,

PRAEFATIO.
ibet,

XVII
exhibeat.

cum Laurentianus totum Sextum

Quo

fac-

est,

mes

ut saepe e Genevensium editione deteriorum lecaut meras coniecturas repeteret, cum genuina verba,

lae in

insereret.

occurrebant, tamquam spernenda adnotationibus Sed nolo viro admirabili maioraque quam Sexti

aetatis codices perscrutandos

editionem animo volventi opprobrio vertere, quod infimae ingratum sane munus

epigonis reliquerit. In emendandis autem scriptoris verbis pro eximia sermonis Graeci peritia optime versatus textum

Fabriciano multis locis meliorem reddidit, ita ut editio eius

hodie

omnium quam maxime

fere in
fieri

manibus

sit,

cuius paginas et versus.

poterat, indicare studui.

Post Bekkeri editionem Hypotyposeon textui emen- Com-

dando operam navaverunt

L.

hi:

ones cri-

Kayser, Beitrage zur Erklarung und Kritik dea S. E., Philol. IV (1849) p. 48sqq. A. Nauck, Zu S. E., Philol. IV p. 199 sqq. R. Hercher (ad p. 20, 2), Philol. IK (1854) p. 591. Franciscus Kern (adp. 51, 14sqq.), Zu Timon Phliasius, Philol. XXXV (1876) p. 373 sq. E. Pappenheim, Zum Text des S. E., Philol. XXXVI p. 415 sqq. id. in commentario ad versionem Germanicam (Lipsiae

Ucae

1881). 0. Apelt, Zu S. E., Mus. Rhen. XXXIX (1884) p. 27sqq. E. Weber, Adversaria critica in Dion. Chrysost. et Sext. Emp. in Comment. in honor. 0. Ribbeckii, Lips. 1888, p. 500 sqq.

Deinde Alfredus Holder, cum fama accepisset novam

Sexti editionem a

me

parari, certiorem

me

fecit adservari

Karlsruhiis in Bibliotbeca

Magni Ducis,

pertinentibus,

plar editionis Bekkerianae cum aliis in quibus Ludovicus Kayser olim Heidel-

cui praeest, exemschedis ad Sextum

bergensis studiorum Sextianorum fructus deposuerat. Quae statim Berolinum misit vir humanissimus , ita ut coniecturas, quae ineditae ibi latebant, excerpere possem. Sed religionis putavi esse in adnotatione mea ea tantum af-

quae seria viderentur, ommissis omnibus eis qualia philologi ludi causa et quasi prima tentamina marginibus auctorum adscribere solemus.
ferre,
Sextus Empiricus

XVIH

PRAEFATIO.

m. DE SEXTI EMPIRICI VITAE ET OPERUM

MEMORIA.
De
Sexti vita et scriptis tradita sunt haec:

Diog. Laert. IX 116: 'Hqo66xov 6s 8tr\Kov6s Usl-xog 6 EfiTtstQtKog , ov xai xd 6ixa x&v Uxsnxtx&v xai dXXa
xdXXt6xa.
7Tt,Qinbg

Sih,xov 6s 8tf)xov6s EaxoQvivog 6 Kv&rjvag, ifixai avxog. 1 Suid. s. v. ) (p. 3283 Gaisf.): Zi&og [XatQcovsvg, d8sX(

<pt8ovg HXovxaQyov, ysyovcbg Kaxd MaQxov Avxcovivov xbv KakaQa, cptXo6ocpog,~\ fiad^rjxrjg Hqo86xov xov OtXa8sXcpaiov. ffv Ss xfjg TJvqqcovsiov dycoyfjg [%al xoGovxov nQog
xtfjtfjg

x& fia6tXsi rjv, S>6xs xal 6vv8tKastv avxco]. "EyQatysv 2 ['ffthxa,] 'E7ti6KS7T,xtxd ) tXta 8iKa.
ib.

(p.

3284

Gaisf.): 2ixog y Atfivg, cptXo6ocpog.

Zxs-

nxtxd sv

(it(5Xtoig t\

Galeni Introductio
6 TtQtoxog avxrjv

s.

HvQQtavsta. Medicus c. 4 (XIV

drtb xfjg

p.

683 Kuhn):

xr)g 8s SfinstQtxfjg (scil. atQi6scog) rtQoi6xr\6s

QtXivog Kcoog,

drtoxsfivofisvog

Xoytxfjg atQi6scog,

xdg dcpOQfidg Xaft&v naQa 'HQOcpiXov, ov xai dxov6xr\g iyivsxo. ftiXovxsg 8s drtaQyat,siv savx&v xf)v atQS6tv, Tva y
7tQ6(ivxiQa xr}g
Xoytxfjg^

aQ%a6&at

avxf\g. (isxd

"Akqcovu xbv AxQayavxivov cpa6iv OtXivov syivsxo EsQarticov AXet-avdQSvg,

slxa ArtoXXcovtot 8vo, naxfjQ xs Kat viog, Avxioysig. fis& ovg Mrjv66oxog Kal 2i!-xog, o" Kai d%Qt&g ixQaxvvav avxf]v.

Anonymus Lambecii (Comment. de august. Vindob.VI [1674] p. 152) 3): 6vvs6xf]6avxo xr\v
1)

bibl. Caes.
SfirtstQtxr\v

cum cognoverunt viri docti Sextum nostrum Sexto Chaeronensi Plutarchi nepote confundi, ad quem quae cancellis saepiuntur pertinere videntur. PseudoEudocia quae in violario c. 900 (p. 650 Flach) praebet, omnia e Suida hausit, nisi quod in primo lemmate post Si-na addit xal aXXa (fortasse e Diogene sumpta), in altero iv fiiXlotg s' praebet. Sed non curamus tales Byzantinorum infimae aetatis fraudes (cf. Cohn P.-W. col. 912 sq.).
Diu
est,

a Suida

cum

Vide p. XX 2 De hoc loco et eo qui sequitur velim consulas 0. Kroehnert Canonesne poetarum scriptorum artificum per antiquitatem fuerunt (Diss. Regimont. 1897) p. 60 sq.
2)
3)
.

PRAEFATIO.
ol'Ss'

XIX

i-avSQSvg,

"Axqcov AxQayavrlvog, OvXivog Kcoog, ZsQanicov AXsZi^rog, AnoXXcoviog. Cramer Anecdot. Paris. I p. 395, 20sqq.: no6oi tialv ol

6v6Tr\6d(isvoi rr\v i(insiQixr\v laTQixrjv; ri66aQsg. ovtoi; "Axqcov 6 AxQayavrtvog' OiXtvog 6 Kcoog'
itiag 6
1

xivsg

SaQa-

AXs^avS^svg xal HsQJ-sciTag ) 6 AnoXXcoviog. Cedreni comp. hist. ed. Bekker I p. 283, 15sqq.: TqicxaidsxaTog Eih,roi xal TlvQQcovsg, 6 (isv (ir\ slvai ndvrrj yvco6rbv xal xaraXrptrbv 6 2iS,rog Soy(iuricov, iniycov xal ivi6rd(isvog' ovrog xal itQog n&6av dvrslns ri%vr\v xal l%iMxaSrjfiaixol xa\ Uvqqcovsioi aXXr\ al QS6ig 6.xr\(ir\v
f

235). ixXr\&r\6av Ss AxaSr\cpiXo6ocpcov (e Sexti Hyp.1 220

Sia xb sv xr\ AxaSr\(iia xdg SiaxQL^dg avrovg noisi6&ai. cov aQ^ag 6 TIvqqcov, dcp ov Hvqqcovsloi insxXr\&r\6av
fiaixol
cpiXo6ocpoi, rr\v dxaraXrjtpiav

dndvrcov nQcoxog siar\ydysv,

cbg

tniysLQsiv (isv sig sxdrsQa, (ir\ (isvroi dnocpuivse&ai (ir\Siv' ovSsv yaQ slvaL sXsysv ovrs vor\rbv ovrs ai6&r\rbv dXr\tyig,

dXXd Soxsiv rotg dv&Qconoig ovrcog sysvv. Agathias II 29 (p. 127 sqq. Niebuhr): Avr\Q yaQ rig vQog to yivog, OvQuviog ovofia .... r\f}ovXsxo (isv yaQ rr\v scpsxTLxrjv xaXov(iivr\v r\Xovv ifinsiQiav xard rs
TlvQQCOva xal

2irov

rdg dnoxQi6sig noLSi6d"aL xal riXog

sysiv rr\v draQa^iav rco (ir\Ssv briovv ols6&ul Xr\nrbv S6rdvai.

xu&-

Schol. in Luc. Icarom.

25

(p.

108, 15 Rabe): ovx dxQi-

(icog rr\v AxaSr\(iiav roig UvQQCovsioig r\TOi 'Ecpsxrixoig dnovifistg, Aovxiavi' dvTiSia6riXXovrai yaQ rovroig ol Axa-

Sr\(tiag, cog

avrcov s6tlv ixsivcov rcov TIvQQCovsicov dxov6ai

iv ratg

*Tnozvnco6s6t,v (=1220^

235).

sna^y^ov yovv

tovto vnb rr\g i606&svsiag rcov dvrindXcov Xoycov ovx syovrsg, onoriQco naQa6%0LSv avrovg sig 6vyxardd-s6iv. Greg. Naz.
Ss
or.

XXI 12

(vol.

35
r\

col.

1096 Migne):

dcp

oh

Si^roi xal
1)

TIvQQtovsg xal

dvri&srog yXco66a co6nsQ

Facile intellegitur hic Sexti

I.

homen

latere fortasse

cum

alio conflatum.
Sextus Empiricus

b*

XX
xi

PRAEFATIO.

voor\(ia Seivbv xai xccnorj&eg xaig ixxkr\6iaig rj(i&v eiet-

(p&ccQrj xxk.
id.

carm. II
(ir)

(ioi

1, 12, 304 (vol. 37 col. 1188 Migne): xa JSi^xov urjde IIvoQcovog nkixe'

Xov6iTC7tog EQQtiy (taxQuv 6 SxayeiQixr\g,

(irjdh Ilkccxtovog

6xiQye xr)v evykcoxxiav.

Doxographica aus Basiliusscholien von Giorgio Pasquali (Nachr. der K. Gesellsch. der Wissensch. zu Gottingen, Phil.-hist. Klasse 1910) p. 201: XXVIII: xb niunxov 6&pa y
o Sr) xakov6iv ai&iQtov xai xvxkocpoQixov, J4Qi6xoxikr)g nQ&rog ei6ryyr)6uxo' &g Si xiveg oiovxui 6 Aevxuvbg "Oxekkog, ibg xai Hil-xog iv dySoto ituQi&exo x&v Znenxix&v

(=adv. phys.H316).
Accedit locus Cosmae Hierosolymitani cognomine Philogregorii, qui in commentario ad Carmina Gregorii Nazianzeni Theologica (vol.

38

col.

555 sq. Migne)

gumenta Hypotyposeon nonnullis additis quae earum paginis vix intellecta corrasit 1 ):
tyttog olov
iiib.

descripsit are primis 6xi-

Aiyovxai xiveg YIvqqcovioi vnoxvncooeig ntQi

I

xr)g

%$qi x&v koyav x^g axityecog xai 6voua6i&v avxrjg xai

ivvoi&v xai
ccqi&v uvxr)g
ei doy(iaxiet. 6
r

imoxtnxtxog*)

ei ui Qt6iv e-/ei
ei

tpv6iokoyei

1) Vide Herm. tom. XLVI p. 106 sq. Descripsi locum ex Mignei editione adhibita nova Vaticani 1260, qui solus servavit opus, collatione a Georgio Pasquali, qua est erga me comitate, sedulo confecta. Qua nisus multa ab Angelo Mai

perperam lecta restituere potui; emendavi autem non nisi quae manifeste corrupta videbantur, lacunarum signa eis locis ponens, quibus titulos excidisse docent argumenta nostrorum librorum (vide p. 3. 63. 132). 2) Memorabilis ea de re videtur varia lectio iniaxenxixog 1 pro tfxmxds, quod apud Suidam (cf. p. XVIII ) et in codicidus EAB (cf. ad p. 5, 21) recurrit.

PRAEFATIO.
ei

XXI

dvaiQet xd cpatvofieva,

xt xb XQtxr]Qiov xr)g 6xer[>ecog

xl xb xelog

xtveg 01 6loG%eoeig XQonot xr)g inoyrig xiveg ol Sexa XQonot xoct

xtveg ol nkvxe

< <
xig xtg
xig
r)
r)
r)

>

>
ovSev
(lalXov aOucpeia

xiveg al 6xenxtxat tporvai

xt xb e%e6xtv xal

xb xaya y.cd xi xb ink%03

ovShv
xt xb
oxt

ootfoj

ndvxa dxaxdXrjnxa 1 )

navxl Xoyat Xoyog t6og avxineixai

>
r)

<
xig

intexenxtxr) bSbg \xr)v\ inl xr)v 'HQaxXetxov tpi-

ei

Xoeocpiav Siayeoei xi

r)

JrjuoxQixov

xr)g 6xetye<og
r)

ei StacpeQet xi x&)v

^AmSr^u&v

6xktytg

<> xaxd
i
r)

<

>

iaxQtxr)v ifineiQia

r\

avxr) iextv xy 6xktyet

<

>
xr)g

no&ev aQHxeov
xi xb xqixt)qiov

nqbg xovg Soyficcxtxovg

r)xr)6eo3g

Wfc

ei e6xt xqixtjqiov

dXr)&siag

xt xo vcp

ov o%
,

xi xb St

xl xb xa^^

neql dXrj&ovg xal dXri&eiag t xt xb dXrj&eg

aTtataletitraig (sic) cod.

1)

XXH

PRAEFATIO.
xi xb 6rj(isiov 1 si s6xt ) 6rjfisiov ivdstxxtxov

xig
<.
.

r)
.

anoSet^ig
.

;...>

xivsg ol 6vXXoyt6(xoi

< <
Lib. iii

>
. .

.> xi xb cpv6txbv (iSQog

xivsg al 6Qu6xtxat aQyai

xi

&sog
r)

xi xb atxtov [xat

nsQt xbv iov xs%vt]\

<.....>
xivsg ai vXtxat aQ%ai
si xaxaXrjTtxd

[si dxaxdXr\7txa

xa 6co(iaxa xd a6c6(iaxa]

xig
xig

r)
r)

xQd6tg
xivr\6tg

tisqi xfjg (isxccpXrjxtxfjg (sic) xtvr\6scog

itSQi avf)6scog
tisqI

xa\

(JLSico6scog

dcpaiQs6scog xal 7t(>o<ff>Oi<Jecog

tcsqI (isxa&s6scog TtSQt

oXov xal (iSQOvg

xat cp&OQdg

TtSQl cpv6txf)g (isxttoXf\g TtSQt ysvs6scog

<.........>
1

7tSQt XOTtOV
TtSQt
.<.

%QOVOV

xi xb ) rj&txbv (iSQog
<
si S6XtV XI xovxcov

.......,> 2

;>,

3 )

opv6st

<;

>

si l'6xiv xtg TtSQt

xbv iov xsjyr\

1)

siet xig cod.

2) 3)

xovxo cod. xovxo cod.

PRAEFATIO.
ei cbcpeXei

XXIH

xbv e%ovxa avxr\v

[neQt aot&fioif]
[xi Igxi <pv6t

dya&bv xat xaxbv (xut dyStdcpOQOv].

vnoxvnco6ecov

Ahxat
\TiQOv

fiev

at xcov UvqqcovLcov

nXoxaL'

Se xavxag cpr\6tv 6 fteiog rQr\yoQtog. JJa.Qet6dyov6t yaQ AQt6xoxeXr\v xai 'EnLxovQOV xu\ uXXovg xcov Sxcotxav,
ig
xt

av&tg KXetxofiaypv dnecpr\vuvxo 7Ceq\ dxaxuXfjnxcov ). KaQveadrjv xcd Xotncov ai r\xr\6etg xcov AxaSrjfitaxcov. ai
xat
xfjg

jv 6Y.enxtY.5iv i<pef\g' neQt xcov dvcoxdxco xqicov <ptXo6o<picov,

\g SoyfiaztKfjg, xfjg AxaSr\fitaxf\g

6xenxtxf g 2).
t

xai

tb
)6

xov cpaive6&at xbv UvQQcova neQt xr\v 6xenxixf\v xcov avxov 6co(iaxtY.coxeQOV xat intcpave6xQ0v nQ06eXr\Xvd-evat
s
),

6xiipt
bq\

rjvxtva xat Svvafxtv OQL^ovxut^), xai

x&v

6y.enxofievcov.

Kut noXvg av
r

nd&og

etr\

Xoyog xu

i<pef\g

nXdxet Xr\Qr\ftuxu StEJ-tivat, o6a xe dnoQeiv oiov xe xat 6 trj^aveiv xat iv&ov6tav xat i^E6xr\xivut ), axtva ndvxa ifytxcov 6 fteiog rQr\yoQtog Xr\Qf](iaxa dnecpf)vaxo.

Quae testimonia si attento animo perlustraveris , sine dubio haerebis in eis, quae de titulis et numeris operum Sextianorum in sensum prorsus contrarium illic dicta invenies. Ipse autem ut meam quoque de eis sententiam hie
breviter aperiam, eo moveor, quod video omnia fere quae Eug. Pappenbeim (Be Sexti Empirici Ubrorum numero et
ordine, Progr.Berol. 1874) et alii disputaverunt, quamquam nulla sint, tamen in compendiis, quibus plurimi utuntur,

pro veris atque certissimis venditari. Qui vir doctus, in Sexto Empirico ceteroquin optime versatus decem illa Zv.e nxtxd apud Diogenem et Suidam obvia pro decem notissimis

modis Scepticis (xQonotg) babenda esse non veritus

Hyp. Hyp. Hyp.
I 3. I 8. I 7, 2) cf.

1) cf.

Hyp.

I 4.

3) cf.

Hyp.

I 7.

4) cf.
5) cf.

xbv 6%enxo\ievov codd. cf Hyp. I 7 ; verbum Sv&ov6tav, cum desit apud Sextum, aut corruptum aut ab ipso Cosma per errorem receptum puto, i,e6xr\xivat fort. ad Hyp. I 68 (ixcxdvxog xf\g xaxaXr\7txtxf\g cpavxaelag) aut ad glossema aliquod referendum est.
tisqI
6) aTtogelv

ubi

et &\Lr\%ave iv

XXIV
est asserere,

PRAEFATIO.

quamquam

ipse Diogenes testatur hos

modos

omnibus Scepticis communes

modo

fuisse, sedulo enarrans quoAenesidemus, Sextus, Favorinus eos adornaverint (IX

87). Silentio autem praetermitto , quod de Suida compilatore tamquam de homine litterato abunde verba facit,

quin etiam totas paginas ingenti locorum mole implet, quibus nihil in rem probatur, cum ipsum cardinem, in quo tota quaestio vertatur, ne attinxerit quidem. Nobis autem proficiscendum est a Diogene Laertio ut
a teste antiquissimo:
verat.

Atque

facile

libros EnenxiKa nounusquisque perspiciet ex eo fluxisse

ille

igitur

decem

quae Suidas in primo lemmate exhibet, cum in altero subito

IlvQQCQveux exsurgant.

Quae

res

quomodo explicanda

sit,

iam videamus.

modum

Atque primum quidem omnes viri docti mirum in consentiunt decem illa E%enxi%a eos libros esse,

quibus Sextus dogmaticos et mathematicos, i. e. liberalium artium magistros, impugnat. Sed titulis eorum perpensis invenies undecim illos esse. Quam ob rem Fabricius disputationem quae est contra arithmeticos cum ea

quae in geometras est instituta conglutinavit. Sed cum Bekkerus codicum divisionem restituisset, vetus illa difficultas manebat, quae Eugenium Pappenheim ad infelicissimam coniecturam abduxit. Nam dubitari non potest, quin dexa numerus ad libros Sexti referendus sit. Sed
aliter instituenda erat quaestio,

quod nec

ipse nec alius

temptavit.

Quid? quod Diogenes tres vnoxvnoboeoav libros omnino non affert? Atque noverat quidem illos, cum nisi ex primo eorum quae de modis Scepticis habet repetere non posset.

Neque

Hypotyposes a posteris solas quae totius quasi Scepticae compendium suo iure appellentur, ab eo neglectas esse. Immo erant in manibus Diogenis cum reliquis Sexti operibus: omnia autem haec JZxenxixa, inter quae tres primi libri erant vnoxvnaoeig, decem voluminibus continebantur. Ipsum igitur corpus illud, quod nobis traditum est, iam
fere lectitatas (vide p. IX/X),

verisimile est ipsas

PRAEFATIO.

XXV

Diogenis temporibus exstitit, cum omnia Sexti Empirici scripta Sceptica in unum coacta essent.

rem
cile

iure quaesiveris, quo tandem modo, si ita se habere statuerimus, decem librorum numerus evasurus sit. Sed fac volumina papyracea eos fuisse, et fa-

At tamen

singulorum operum
placet

videbis recta esse, quae proposui. Adseribam autem nam librorum dicere non amplius

1 ambitum, quem veterum morem secutus ) ad

versuum, quos complectuntur, numerum computavi. E8t autem hic versus heroicus, i. e. 36 fere litterarum. Eationem, quam secundum Bekkerianae editionis paginas et versus institui, ad apicem rectam esse vix exspectabis, neque spondeo de numeris; ad ea autem quae dixi comprobanda satis, opinor, valebunt.
ordo codi-

XXVI

PRAEFATIO.

Hypotyposes seorsum circumlatas esse iam supra adnotavimus (p. X 1 ). Unde titulum IIvQQcoveicc in alterum Suidae lemma receptum esse mihi quidem verisimile videtur. Notissimum enim illud opus omnium operum Sextianorum
fuisse e testimoniis perspicitur.

Sed plura nunc didicimus.

codicis

Volumina decem cum

iu

Hypotyposes quidem primo loco ponendas esse unusquisque scriba facile videSed de quinque adv. dogmaticos et duobus adversus bat. mathematicos scriptis dubitatio essepoterat. Itaquefactum est, ut ille qui archetypum librorum nostrorum vel potius exemplar eius antiquissimum quod codicis forma exaratum erat, descripsit, duos adv. math. libros post Hypotyposes collocaret, quinque adv. dogm. adderet. Priorum autem voluminum memoriam servaverunt subscriptiones quaedam in codicibus nostris obviae: nam post librum adv.
transscriberentur,
log. I legitur si^tov

formam

ifmeiQiKOv vnofivr\ficitcov to efidofiov, post librum adv. phys. I ai^tov tcov elg Sskcc to. oySoov, post librum adv. eth. aii-tov ifineiQixov VTtOfivrjfxutcdv to Si-

xatov' tikog xtX. Quae omnia, nisi

mecum

facies,

numquam

expedire poteris. Sin autem amplius repugnaveris in sententiam ire meam, afferam locum insignem e scholiis in Basilium quae nuperrime e codice praecipue Genuensi Georgii Pasquali sollertia
,

protracta sunt (vide p. XX). Laudatur hic secundus adv. phys. liber ut octavus. Quod neque in codicum neque in

Bekkerianum ordinem quadrare primo quidem obtutu videSin tur, cum illic nonum, hic septimum locum obtineat. autem sumpseris scholiastam vel potius eius auctorem
Zi^tog iv 7]' (i. e. in septimo libro) legisse, quod perperam pro numero Vni acceperit, tota quaestio solvetur. Mos autem libros litteris secundum ordinem alphabeticum notandi a carminibus Homericis ductus apud posteros quoque
vigebat; unde nascebantur eiusmodi errores.

Quibus

e.

g.

obviam

subscriptione libri sexti Stromatum Clementis Alexandrini, aequalis Sexti Empirici, ubi adnotatur:
itur in
6 xccl r)ta.

GtQcofuxtevg extog

In septimo igitur legerat

PRAEFATIO.

XXVn

scriptor ea quae affert, ita ut eluceat in eius codice libros

eodem modo quo apud Bekkerum dispositos Sed alia quaestio inter viros doctos orta
Sexti
scripta

esse.

est:

omniane
Sextus

Sceptica

servata sint?

neque id sine magna inconipse multis locis lectores ad sua relegasset, fieri non poterat, quin de quistantia busdam scriptis tamquam deperditis hariolarentur. Quae

Nam cum

optime enodavit Pappenheimius, quem hic in omnibus

se-

quor. Adscripsi igitur singulis locis, quibus Sextus se ipse citat eos locos, ad quos respicit: in dubio tamen sum, quid

verba II 219 iv alXoig StaXe^ofie&a et II 215 neqi fiev xovxg>v nai eteav&tg Stale^ofie&a sibi velint. Incertum esse, num Sextus promissum solverit, cum Pappenheimio (p. 7) equidem credo, sed cum sciamus Sextum non semper eam

curam, quam par transeam easdem

ut cetera
verbis

erat, in scribendo adhibuisse,

quippe qui

sententias eisdem fere

repetiverit, caven-

Hyp.

II

117118

et

119120
illis

dum

obscurioribus de scriptis quibusdam deperditis vel capitibus interceptis eruere studeamus. Haud aliter de libro vel libris Tteqi tyv%rig inscripest,

ne quid ex verbis

tis

iudicandum
reliquit:

est,

de quibus Pappenheimius litem sub

dicat

iudice

cum enim Sextus

adv.

mus. 55

ovdev eGxi ipv%rj, xa&tog iv xotg Tteqi avxr)g vno(ivr](ia6tv ideiKWfiev et adv. dogm. IV 284 eiqrjxat
(ir)v

alXa

6e iteqi xovxav ccKqt@e6xEqov nav xrj rteqi xqtxrjqtov 6Ketyet xav xotg 7teqi ipv%7)g primo loco ad ea quae Hyp. 3lsqq., altero ad ea quae adv. dogm. I i. e iv xrj 7teqi xjhxrjqiov 6Hetyei passim de anima proferuntur, illum nos re-

legare persuasum habeo.

I

Quae tamen laudantur ab ipso Empirico adv. dogm. 202 Iaxqixa VTto(ivr](iaxa aetatem non tulerunt. Id eo
alio corpore

factum esse puto, quod in

tica exstabant,
ita ut,

atque scripta Scep-

Scripta

eodem modo allicerent, autem philosopha,

cum hominum curiositatem non temporum iniuria evanescerent.

in primis Hypotyposes, in schola eius propugnacula adservata

Sceptica

tamquam maxima

esse docent testimonia, quibus Sexti

nomen cum Pyrrhonis

XXVIII

PRAEFATIO.

saepe coniungitur: inde per temporum decursum miro quodam fortunae beneficio ad nostram aetatem pervenerunt.

Sed iam

in eo est, ut

hoc volumen, quod cetera

dis

adiuvantibus mox sequentur, in publicum prodeat. Restat officium sane iucundissimum gratias agendi amicis sollertissimis, qui in plagulis purgandis non solum typothetae sed meos quoque errores sustulerunt: Cbristiano Jensen Georgio Pasquali Alexandro Riistow Alfredo Wolff. In

exornanda autem editione maxime adiutus sum benigno Hermanni Diels consilio, qui inspectis scbedis meis, ut de
eis

ad amplissimum philosophorum ordinem universitatis

nostrae referret, pro eximia sua doctrina multa adnotaverit, quae in usum meum vocare potui, interdum ipsi textui

manum

admovens.

Quibus omnibus quid ipse Sextus deXI.

beat, docebit adnotatio critica.

Scr. Berolini

m. Mai.

a. h. s.

HERMANNUS MUTSCHMANN.

2EHT0Y EMIIEIPIKOY
a b r

Conspectus siglorum.
a: Codices.

= Laur. 86, 11 XV. M = Monac. 439 XIV. XV E Paris. 1964 A = Paris. 1963 XVI. XVI. B = Berol. Phill. 1518 G = consensus horum codicum. 21 et P = Paris. suppl. 1156 T = Translatio latina in Paris.
L
s. s.

s.

s.

s.

foll.

22

s.

X.
foll.

lat.

14700

83 r 132 v

s.

XIV.

in.

Gen. Fabr. Bekk.

= Petri et Jacobi Chouetorum Genevae = A. Fabricii Lipsiae 1718. = Immanuelis Bekker Berolini 1842.
J.

b: Editiones.

1621.

ITTPP&NEI&N TnOTTII&2E&N
TN EI2 TPIA TO IIP&TON.
dds ivs6tiv iv
ksqI
xfjg

z<p jiqcqtg)

t&v IIvqqovslov

V7COtV7CG)6S(OV
avcozdzco ScucpoQ&g zcbv cpiXoaocpicbv
avzfjg
tcsqI zcbv X6ycov zi)g Gnsipscog
tcsqI zcbv ovofiaaicov zig $vvoia Gxiipscog 7CSQI ZOV GHS7CZIXOV tcsqI zcov
si sl

uq%cov uvzfjg Soy^uzi^st 6 GxsnziKog UIQSGIV ^%st

si cpvGtoXoysi
l

IU
cy
iS'
It

avaiQsl zd cpatvofisva xov KQizriQiov xfjg Gxsipecog ksqI zov xsXovg avzfjg
si

tcsqI

7CsqI zcov
tcsqI zcqv
tcsq\

6Xog%sqcov zqotccov

zfjg Gnitpscog

TCSqI

Si%a zq6tccov zcbv nivzs zqotccov ZCOV SvO XQ07CCOV

l'
x'

zivsg zQOTtot (zfjgy zcbv aixtoXoytntbv cxvaxQOTcfjg 7CSQI Z&V GnSTCXVA&V cpcovcbv tcsqI xfjg *ov puXXov' (cpcovfjgy
7CSqI

xa'
x|3'

tcsqI
tcsqI

acpaoiag xov 'xdxu''

Y.ul

xov

>%

^h,sGxi

yiul

xov 'ivSixsxut*

xov

'

^iTC^x 03

correxi

Argurnentum primi secundum titulos

libri

in

codicibus misere foedatum

3 Stuvcoxdxco
addidi

G
23

15 bXoG%SQ&g L

19 xivsg XQ07COI

xcbv uixtoXoyovyiivtov ccvuxQ07cf)g

xov ovShv {l&XXov xul xov xu%u G

||

cpcovfjg

7csqI

21 tisqi xov $eGxt

"

4
xy
icsqI

nTPPNEIN
tov 'ovSsv optfoj' nsQt xov 'ndvra iaxiv doQtOTa' > xs' itsQi tov 'ituvTcc iatlv &.Y.ciTa.Xr\%Tu * > 'ov xaTaXaft^dvcaiy xff' %sq\ tov d%aTa.Xr\nTto <[xa\ %\X %sq\ tov 'navr\ (Xoyco Xoyov i'aov ttVTiy.siafrttiy xr\ naQanr)y ftaTa %sq\ tcov Gv.snTiY.8iv cpcovcov x& sl 7] av.STtTi.iir] bdog iartv in\ tt\v 'HQccxXsirsiov
xS'

tptXo-

aotpiav
X'

Xcc
Xf3'

si StatpiQsir) 4r\fioxQiTStog cctQsatg rfjg oxiipscog sl SttttpsQSt r) KvQr\va'ixf\ Tf)g axiipscog

si diatpsQsi r) IlQcoTayoQSiog Tf)g axitpstog si SitttpiQsi tcov 'AxaSr\fiicov f) axiiptg si
i\

Xy
XS'

%ard

xr\v ia.TQt%r\v ifinstQia

f)

ccvTf)

iart

rr) ov.sipsi

neQt

xr)g

dvtoxdxa dtatpoQdg xtav cptXoGotpt&v.

xi

nQdyfia r) svqeSiv inaxoXov&eiv siv.bg r) l xat dxaxaXrjtpiag bfioXoyiav r) inifiovr)v\ aQvrjGtv evQeGecog 2 fyxrjGecog. StoneQ tGoag xa\ ent xcbv xaxd tptXoGocpiav fij-| xovfievcov oi fiev evQrjxevat xb dXr)d-eg ecpaoav, oi 8 dne<pr)-l Toig r)xovGi

vavxo
3

fir)

Svvaxbv elvat

xovro

KaxaXrjcp&rjvat^

oi 8e

exi%

xa\ evQrjxevat fiev 8oxovGtv oi idiojg xaXovfievoit doyfiaxtxoi, otov oi neQt 'AQtGroreXrjv xat 'EnixovQov xa\\
^rytovGtv.

chg 8e neQt axccraXr)nrcov\ dnetpr)vavro oi neQt KXeixofiaypv %a\ KaQveddrjv %a\ dX-l 4 Xot o&ev evXoymgf 'Axadrjfiaixoi, r)xovGt 8e oi G%eTttt%oi.

xovg Eratxovg %a\ dXXot xtveg,

6o%ovGtv

ai dvoixdxca
Gxennxf).

cptXoGocpiat
TteQt

'A%a6r)fiaixr)

fiev

ovv

XQetg elvat, Soyfiartxr, xcbv aXXcov exsQotc

Xeyeiv, neQt 8e xr)g GxeTtxtxfjg dycoyr)g vnorvno) xtx&g en\ rov itaQovxog r)fietg SQOVfiev, exetvo TtQoemovxeg. ort TteQt ovSevbg r&v Xe^&rjGOfiivmv 8ia(5e(5aiovfjLe&a wc oftreog e%ovrog ndvrcag xa&dneQ Xeyofiev, dXXd xard xb vvi
aQfioGei

tpatvofievov

r)fiiv

iGxoQtx&g dnayyeXXofiev neQi exdoxov.

Argum.

dvTtxsic&at om.

3 xaTaXrjitTd G G 6 rf)g

4 xa\ ov
f)
:

axsitTixfjg cpcovf)g

TayoQSiog

rf)g oxiipscog si StcctpiQst

Textus
dicentes):

13 vnoTVTtcorixcog om. nQoasm. G

5 X6ya 11 6 TtQco scr. 6 G 13 rfjv om. B | 14 nQostnovtsg T (pre

xcct.

om.

A.

fi

nsQi xcov Xoycov

Tr\g 6xiipscog.

ETII0TTII&2E&N
xccg

Tfjg 6xsnxtxf)g ovv cptXo6ocpiag 6 fisv Xiysxat xa&oXov 5 og 6 8s siStxog, xai xa&oXov fisv iv co xbv yctQaxxf\Qa

6xitpscog ixxL&ifis&a, Xiyovxsg xig svvota avxf\g xai xlvsg ccqyal xai xivsg Xoyot, xi xs XQLxr\Qtov xai xi xiXog, xal xivsg oi XQonot xf)g inoyf\g, xai ncog naQaXafidvo(isv

6xsnxtxdg dnocpa6sig, xai xr\v StdxQt6tv

xcov itaQaxsifiivcov avxf\
fiiQog
T?Jg

xr)g

6xirpscog
co

dnb
25

tptXo6ocptcoV sldixbg Ss sv

nQog sxa6xov
fisv.

xaXovfiivrjg cpiXo6o<piag dvxtXiyoSr\

TtSQi

xov

xa&oXov

nQ&xov

aQ^dfisvoi xfjg vcpr\yr\6scog

ovofidxcov.

dnb

SiaXdficofisv Xoyov, tcov xf\g 6xsnxtxf)g dycoyf)g

TlsQi xcov 6vofia6tcov ttjj 6xsnxtxf\g.

xoivvv dycoyr\ xaXslxai
fisv

'H
5

6xsnxtxr\

xai

r\xr\xtxr\

d%b ivsQysiag xf\g xaxd xb r\xsi~v xai 6xinxs6&at , xai icpsxxLxr\ dnb xov fisxd xr\v f)xr\6iv nsQi xbv 6xsnx6(ievov yivofiivov nd&ovg, xai dnoQr\xixr\ r\xot dnb xov nsQi navxbg dnoQslv xai r\xsLv, cbg svtoi cpa6tv, r) dnb xov d(ir\%avsiv nQog 6vyxaxd%s6tv r) aQvr\6tv, xai TIvQQCovsiog dnb
xov cpaivs6&ca
r\fitv

10

xbv TlvQQCova 6co(iaxixc6xsQOv xai intxf)

cpavi6xsQ0v x&v nQo avxov nQ06sXr\Xv&ivat

8'

6xiipst.

Ti i6xt 6xiiptg.

6xsnxtxr\ Svvaittg dvxt&sxtxr\ cpat- 8 voovfiivcov xa& oiovdf)noxs xqonov, dcp' r\g iQxofxs&a Sta xr\v iv xotg dvxtxstfii15 votg nQayfia6t xai Xoyotg t606d*ivstav xb fisv nQ&lSarov sig ino%f)v, xb 8s fisxa xovxo sig dxaQal-iav. f ovv avxr\v xaXovfisv ov xaxd xb ns- 9 fisv *Svvafitv
i\

"E6xl Ss

vofiivcov xs xai

Diog. Laert. IX 69. 70.

1 TtQcotov 7 yivoLLevov

LM:
:

LM

nQcoxov

ysvociivov

EAB EAB
itQOsX.

6
||

xcov axErtxoLLsvcov Gen.

om. Gen.
XQOItCOV

11

tiqo6sX.

LM:

EAB

yiv. ndd".

10 xbv om. T 13/14 Tpo7rov MEAB

:

6
QtSQyov

nxppNEiaN
4

dnX&g xara to Svva6&at' *opcctv6fisva 8s vvv ra alG&rjxd, StonsQ dvTt8tcc6TiXXofisv Xafifidvofisv avToig tcc vorjTcc. to Ss 'xa^ oiovSfjnoTS TQonov' SvvccdXX
Tut
'

>

TtQOGttQyto&G&at

kccX

Tr)

Swdfist, tva
'

dnX&g to
xal

rijg
to.

*
;

Svvdfisoog

ovofiu, cog stQr\Kttfisv, naQaXccfi^dvoofisv , ' STtSL yCCQ TtOtaVTl&STlKT) CpatVOflivOOV T KttX VOOV flivOOV
ccvTtTt&Sfisv
tocvtcc,
r\
r\

xtXcog

cpccivofisvtt
t

voovfisva

voovfisvoig
'xa-fr

svccXXuS,

dvTtTt&ivTsg,

cpatvofisvotg r) 1'va nccGat

ai

ccvTt&iGstg
f)

sfinsQtiyoovTat,

Xiyofisv

KaQ?
tcc

oiovSf\noTS %
ts
kcci

TQonov'.

oiovSf\noTS
fir)

TQonov

cpccivofiivcov

vooi>(u.vwv',
f)

tvcc

r\T&(isv

n&g
ccXX

cpaivsTav

cpatvofisva
l

n&g

vostTat

tcc

voovfisva,

ccnX&g TavTa Xafifiavco-

10

Xoyovg naQaXafi^dvofisv ovyt ndv- 1 Tcog dnocpaGtv kcci KaTaopcc6tv, dXX^ dnX&g dvTt tov fiw/pfts- a > vovg. tG0G9 ivstav 8s Xiyofisv ttjv xara niGTtv kccX dntGTiav
fisv.

^dvTtKStfjtivovg' Ss
'

fiaypfiivoov i Xoyoov oog ntGTOTSQOv. ^snoyrf Si iGTt GxaGtg Stavoiag 8t r\v * otiis aiQOfiiv ti ovts Ti&sftsv. aTaQtt^itt' 8i sGTt il>vyjf\g
fir\8svbg
'

iGOTrjTU, oog fir\8ivu

nQOXStG&at

t&v

doyXr\6ia
ttTaQcci-itt,

Kcct yccXrjVOTrjg.

n&g

Ss

Tfj

snoyf) 6vvst6iQysTcct

iv Totg nsQt TiXovg ( 25

s'

30)

f)

vnofivf\60fisv.

TIsqI TOV

GKSmtKOV.

11

Kccl 6 TIvQQCovstog Ss cptXoGocpog Svvdfist Tr) Tr)g 6XSnTt%r)g dyooyf)g svvoia 6vvano8i8oTat' s6Tt yttQ b fiSTiyoov

TavTrjg Tf)g Svvdfisoog.

g'

TIsqI

aQy&v

Tfjg 6K,itysa>g.

12

^Qyrjv 8s Tf\g GKsnTt%f)g cctTtooSrj fiiv cpafisv slvcct rrjv sXniStt tov ttTttQttKTf\Gstv' oi yaQ fisyaXocpvsig t&v dv&Qoonoov TaQa66ofisvot Std Tf)v iv TOtg nQayfia6tv dvoofiaXiav,
Kccl

fi&XXov CvyxaTart^fG^ort, rjX&ov int ro &\tsiv, ti ts dXrj&ig s6tiv sv Toig nQttyficc6t

%Qr)

dnoQOvvTsg t/oYv ccvt&v

EAB
rs

x&v G: ro Gen. 23 post cpcctvoitsva add. f) rcp Fabr. 24 post vooviisva add. f) AB 26 f) tqoicov om. EAB!| 3 f) EAB: om. LM 30 dnocpcc6ig hccI KccTacpccetg L
21
:

MEAB:

rijL

ol

ya^MEAB:

ol fihv

11 ti&Xlov XQV

TII0TTn2EN

A.

xi tyevSog, cog c r^g intKQi6ecog xovxcov dxaQccKxr\6ov-

6v6xa6ecog
xvxi Xoyco

8e xiqg 6KenxiKf\g eaxtv

f

ttQ%r\

(icdXi6xa

xo

Xoyov

6ov dvxtKet6&at' dnb

(if\

ycco

xovxov kuxu-

Xf)yetv 8oKOV(iev eig xb

Soyfiaxifetv.

'

Ei
8e
(ir\

Soy(iccxiet 6 6Y.eitxtY.6g.
Soyfiaxi&tv xbv
6Y.eTtxtv.bv

Aeyofuv
xtveg

ov

kccx

enetvo 13
cpcc6i

to 6rj(iatv6(jtevov xov S6y(iaxog kcc&

Soyfia eivai

v.otv6xeqov xb evSoKeiv xtvt Ttoayfiaxt (xoig ycco Kaxa cpccvxa6iav Kccxi\vccyKtt6(ievotg nd&e6t 6vyKaxaxi&exat 6 6Ke7txtKog, otov ovk ccv etnot d eQ(iatv6(ievog r) tyvy6(ievog
,

oxt Sokco

(ir\

&eQ(iaive6&at
o

r)

tpvxee&at), dXXd
cpcc6i

(if\

Soyfiaxifetv

XeyO(iev

Ka&

86y(ia elvai

(iaxt xcov

Kaxa

xtvt TtQccyxdg int6xf)(iccg r\xov(ievcov dSf)Xcov

Ttvfg xf)v
,

xcov uSf)Xcov 6vyKaxaxi&exat 6 14 IIvQQCovetog). dXX' ovSe iv xco nQ0cpeQe6d at rteQt xcov dSf)Xcov

6vyKttxa%e6tv (ovSevi yuQ

xocg

6KenxtKccg cpcovd;, otov xr\v 'ovSev fiaXXov' r) xf\v ovSev ooifeo' r\ xtva xcov dXXcov rteQt cov v6xeQ0v Xeo(iev ( 187 sqq.) 8oy(iccxiet. 6 (tev yccQ 8oy(iaxicov cog vTtccQyjov xi&exat
xb TtQayfia eKeivo o Xeyexat 8oy(iaxietv, 6 8e 6KenxtKog xccg
cpcovag

'

xi&^t xavxag ov^

r)

cog

ndvxcog vnaQ%ov6ag' vnoXafi-

(iavet yccQ OTt, co6neQ

'Ttdvxa i6xi tyevSff cpcovf\ (texcc xcov aXXcov K<xi eavxr\v ipevdfj elvat Xeyet, Kcci r) 'ovSev e6xtv
bfioicog,

aXri&eg'
ccXXcov

ovxcog Kai
cpr\6t
(if\

r)

'ovSkv fiaXXov
elvcct
Kcci

(iexd

xcov

Kai

eccvxf)v

(lccXXov

Std xovxo

xoig ccXXotg eavxr\v 6v(ineQtyQucpet. xb <T ccvxb Kai ini xcov dXXcov 6xenxtK&)v cpcovcov Xeyofiev. nXrjv dXX ei 6 Soyfia- 15 xicov xi&t\6tv cog vnuQypv xovxo o Soy(iaxiet, 6 Se 6xenxt-

xdg cpcovdg ccvxov nQocpeQSxat cbg Svvdfiet vcp eavxcov neQtyQacped&at, ovk ccv iv xf\ nQocpOQu xovxcov Soy(iuxietv Xey&eir\. xb 8e (ieyt6xov, iv xr\ nQOcpOQu xcov cpcovcov xovY.bg

inser. v.ul edd.

13 dxaQUY.xfioavxsg EAB 15 i6ov om. EAB 18 post o 19 ivdoxslv L 21 6 im6xeiiTfKbg EAB Svvu33 17 ex i L: sl EABM 6 malim ngocpsQOuevog 8 xcov qpco7 fort. xovxcov (ovtogy Diels uivug Kayser v&v om. EAB

IITPP&NEI&N
to iavt& cpcctv6(isvov Xiyst
(ir\Sev
xcci

twv

to

nd&og dnayyiXXst
eh,to&ev

to eccvtov dSo^dotcog,
vcov dia(ie(}aiov(ievog.

neqi t&v

vnoxet(ii-

r[

ei

aiqeoiv e%et

Gxenttxog.

16

'0(ioiag Se cpeqope&a xai ev tw iqcoxcca&at el aTqectv eyet 6 Oxenttxog. ei (iev <^yao)> tig atqsotv elvai Xiyet

nqooxXtGtv SoyfiaOt noXXoig dxoXov&iav e%ovOt nqbg aXXr\Xd xe xai (ro) tpcctvofieva, xcci Xiyei S6y(icc

nqdyfiati dSr\Xoo ovyxcttd&eotv, cpr\GO(iev (ir) s%stvt 17 ulqeoiv. ei Si tig atqsotv elvui cpdoxst tr\v Xoyco tivi xatd to qpaivdfievov dxoXov&ov\fccv dytayr\v, ixeivov tov Xdyov tog eOxtv oq&cog Soxeiv r\v vno-

Setxvvovxog
dXX'

(xov oq&cog

(ir\

fiovov xax

dqetr\v Xa(x(5avo-

fiivov dcpeXiateqov) xai ini to eni%eiv SvvccO&at Staxeivovxog, uTqeatv cpa(iev 'syetv' dxoXov&ovfiev ydq
xivt

Xoyco

xccxd

xb cpuiv6(ievov vnoSeixvvvxi
ed-r\

r\(iiv

xb

tff\v

nqbg xu ndtqiu
xci

xcci

xovg v6(iovg

xcci

tdg dycoyug xai

oixeia nd&rj.

0
18

'
1

ei

cpvOtoXoyet
xcci

axenxtxog.
iv xto r\xeiv ei tpvGtoXo-

IIuqunXr\Gitt Se Xiyofiev evexcc yr\tiov tco oxenxtxto'

(iev

ydq

tov

fietd
xr\v

(lefialov

nstafiatog dnotpatvso&ai nsqi ttvog

Xoyittv

x&v xaxd

Soy(iaxt^o(iivcov

ov cpvOtoXoyovfiev^

evexcc

cpvotoSe xov

nuvti Xoyco Xoyov 1'oov systv dvtttt&ivat xcci tr\g dtuqal-iccg dntofis&a trjg cpvGtoXoyiag. ofttco Se xai to Xoytxbv (liqog
xcci

to rj&ixbv tr\g Xeyo(iivr\g cpiXoOotpiag insq%6(ie&cc.

16

17

(v Diog. Laert.
%%st

I 20.

Suid.

s. v.

cuQsetg.

(sectam habeat): fyst cciq. L 15 xd add. Bekk. aliquis vel seetam) 15/15* Soypaxi &8r)Xco G correxi coll. Xsyst 6vyx. om. T. 16 qpacxot (dicat) p. 5, 23/24: Soy(ia rtvl ccd. Gen. 25 nuQanlr}6ia 18 Soxslv fort. secl. 21 aiQS6tv (di)

13 yaQ add. T (sienim

12/13 aiQE6tv

MEABT

||

EABT

EAB

xai om.

EAB

TnoTTnasE&N
t

a.

si

dvatQOVOt to cpatvofisva oi oxenrtxoi.

ort
fiot

Ot 8s Xiyovrsg

avatQ0v6t ra cpatvofieva oi 19
SoxovOtv slvai r&v 7tao'
rjfiiv

Oxenrtxoi
fiivcov'
toc

dvijxoot
ycco

Xeyo-

xard cpavra6iav na&r\rtxr\v dovXr)rcog r\uag

sig 6vyxardd-e6tv ovx dvarQino(iev 9 cog xal efinQO( 17) eXiyofiev' ravra 8i i6rt rd cpatvofieva. orav 8e r\r&fiev 9 si rotovrov sort rb vnoxsifisvov bnoiov cpaivsrai, rb

ayovra

6&sv

tiev ort cpaivsrai 8t8o(isv 9 r\rov[isv 8

ov

itSQi

rov qpatvofiicpatvofiivov'

vov

dXXd

nsQt

ixstvov

Xiysrai

nsQl

rov

tovto 8s 8tacpioet rov r\reiv nsQi avrov rov cpaivofiivov. oiov cpatvsrat, (fisvy rjfitv yXvxdfeiv rb fiiXt(rovro 6vy%coQOV- 20
fisv'

yXvxa6fis&a yaQ aie&rjrix&g), si 8e xal yXvxv sOrtv o6ov ini rco Xoyco, r\rovfiev' o ovx e6rt t6 cpatvofisvov dXXd (rby nsQt rov cpatvofiivov Xeyofievov. idv 8e xai avrtxQvg

xard t&v cpatvofiivcov

SQcorcofisv Xoyovg, ovx avatQsiv jSovX6fisvot rd q>atv6fisva rovrovg ixrt&ifis&a, dXX' intSstxvvv-

rscov

rsg rr\v r&v Soyfiartxcov nQonirstav' si yaQ rotovrog iortv 6 Xoyog &6re xai rd cpatvofieva fiovov

dnaov^t

r&v bcp&aXfi&v
avrbv
nQonsrsvs6&at;
ta

rjftcov

vcpaQndfetv,
fir)

iv roig d8r\Xotg, &6re

vcpOQdo&at xaraxoXovdovvrccg avrco

%Qr\

n&g ov

nsQi rov XQtrrjQtov

rr)g 6xenrtxr\g.

"Ort 8e roig cpatvofiivotg nQ06iypfisv , 8r)Xov

dnb r&v 21

Xsyofiivcov r)fiiv nsQt rov XQtrrjQiov ri\g 6xsnrtxr)g dycoyr\g. XQtrrjQtov 8e Xiysrat 8t%&g, to ts sig niortv vnaQ^scog r\ avv-

naQ^tag Xafi^av6fisvov,nsQi ofi sv rcp dvrtQQr\rix& Xi^ofisv Xoyco (= II 14sqq.), to ts tov nQa66stv, cb nQ06iypvTsg xard rbv iov rd fisv nQa660fisv rd <?' ov 9 nsQi o% vvv Xiyo(isv.

XQtrr\Qtov roivvv cpausv slvat rr\g 6xsnrtxr\g dycoyr\g t6 cpatvofisvov, dvvdfist rr\v cpavra6iav ovrco xaXovvrsg'

22

1 dvaiQovat om. EAB 3 na&r\Ttxi]v 4 dyovrag EAB passibilem) naQ-r\Tixd EAB 13 t6 add. coll. v. 8 xal dvrttcQvg om. T
:
||

LMT

(fantasiam

10 fisv addidi 14 to cpaivofjtsvov EAB Gen. 19 avrwv L 24 ovv EAB 26/27 Xiyofisv xet28 ^a^rov^ t^qiov slvaf rpafthv slvat tcsqI rfjg <sx. EAB
ovrco Pabr. e codice Saviliano

10

IITPP&NEI&N

iv nefoei yuQ xui d^ovXr)vcp nd&eL xeifievr) ut,r)xr\r6g iativ. 6lo tvsqI (isv rov cpaiveG&aL roiov r) roiov rb vnoxei(isvov ov6eig LGcog d(itcpLGr)xr)Gei, Ttsoi 6e rov ei xolov-

31

23 rov eGxiv bnoiov cpuivexuL ^rjretrac roig cpaivo[isvoig ovv nQOGeyovxeg xara rr)v (SicoTLxr)v rr)Qr\GLv aSo^aGrcog iov(iev, enei (ir\ dvvdfiefta dveveQyr\xoL navxdnaGLV elvai. eoixs 6e avrrj r\ LcoxLxr) rrjorjGig xexQafjteQrjg eivui xai rb (iev ri eyeiv iv vcpr\yr\Gei cpvGecog, rb 6e iv dvdyxy nu&cov, rb 6e iv nuQu8oGeL v6(icov re xai i&cov, xb 24 8e iv diduGxakicc reyvcov, vcpr\yf\GeL (iev cpvGLxr) xu& r)v cpvGixcog uiG&rjrtxoi xui vorjrixoi eGfiev, nadcov 8e dvdyxrj xu&
r)v fofibg (jtev

i&cov 8e xai v6(icov TtuQuSoGet xcctf

ini TQOcpr)v r)(iag odrjyei, dityog 6" i%i n6(icc, r)v rb (iev evGe^eiv naQacog dyu&bv rb 8e aGefieiv cog cpuvXov, Xu(idvo(iev tcortxcog xeyycov 8e Si8uGxaXiu xu$ r)v ovx dveveQyrjroi eG(iev iv u
7tuQu\u(ifidvo(iev reyvutg.

mg

ruvra 8h nuvru

cpufiev

d8o-

i-uGxag.
tj3

xi xb xeXog xrjg Gxe%xtxr\g.

25

xr\g dycoyr)g Sle^eX&elv.

Tovxoig dxoXov&ovuv ei'rj xuinsQi rov riXovg rr\g Gxertxiegxl (iev ovv xsXog rb 0$ %uqlv
I

Ttdvra TtQurreraL r) Q-scoQELxaL, ccvxb 8s ovSevbg svsr) rb eGyaxov xcov OQexxcov. cpafiev 8e cc%ql vvv xiXog elvuL xov Gxennxov rr)v iv roig xccru 86S,uv draQuJ-LUv xui
xcc,

26 iv roig xurr]vuyxuGKievoig

fieTQLond&eLccv.

aQ^dfisvog yuQ

cpi-

XoGocpsiv vTtSQ xov xug cpuvxuGiug inLXQtvai xui xuTuXueiv, xivsg (iev elGlv dXrj&eig xiveg 8e rpev8eig, coGrs draQuxrf)rr)v LGoG&evr) Siacpcoviuv, r)v inixQivui insGysv' iniGypvri 6e uvxco xvyix&g nuQ27 rjxoXov&rjGev i) iv roig 6ot-uGroig dxaQuJ-Lu. (iev yuQ 6odmv xi xaXbv xy cpvGei r) xaxbv elvuL xaQaGGexuL 6iu
fjtr)

21

gul, iveneGev eig

6vvd(ievog

nuvxog' xai oxe

(ir)

ndQeGnv

avra> xd xuXu elvuL 6oxovvru,

21

2527 LM:

~
7)

III

235237

31
r)

&ncpL6r}Tr]0SL 7

(dubitabit)
avtr\

ci(icpia^ritst

2 avtr\

(iiootiTLr)

iiivtot

dslv

EAB EAB

^Lcotfnr)

6dr\ysl r)ciag

E: iv

^icotvxr)

14

avtr\ (sic) Sisi-sX&eiv LM: SieX-

AB

TI10TTn2EN
v%6
xe

A.

11
xai Stcoxet

x&v

cpv6et
cog

xax&v

votti^et ^otvrjXaxeie&at

xd dya&d,

oi'exai'

aiteq

xxr\6a(ievog

%eQt%i%xet, Sid xe xb Ttaoa Xoyov xal 6&at xai cpofiovtievog xr\v (iexa^oXr\v %dvxa %Qa66et, Xva xd dya&a avxco Soxovvxa eivat. 6 Se doQt- 28 (ir\ d%ofidXr\

%Xeio6t xaQayaig dfiixQcog enaioe-

6x&v
xi

TteQl

x&v

TtQog xr\v cpv6tv

xaX&v

r)

xax&v ovxe

cpevyet

ovxe Stcoxet 6vvxovcog' St6%eQ dxaQaxxei. o%bq ovv jteQi *A%eXXov xov ^coyQacpov Xiyexat, xovxo v%r\Q'E,e xco 6xe%xtx&.

yaQ oxt ixeivog i'%%ov yQacpcov xal xbv dcpQov xov xr) yQacpfj fiovXrj&eig ovxcog d%exvyyavev cog a%ei%eiv xal xr\v 6%oyytdv eig r]v d%i(ia66e xd d%b xov yQacpeiov yQcofiaxa %Q06Qityai xf\ eixdvi' xr\v 8e %qo<pa6l

LTtnov [ii(ir)6a6&ai

<

6atpa(iivr\v i'%%ov dcpQOV %otf\6at

(ii(ir\(ia.

xal oi 6xe%xixo\ 29
xr\v

ovv r\l%iov
dvco(iaXiav

(iev

xr\v

dxaQa^iav dvaXr)tye6&at Std xov

xe

x&v

cpatvotiivcov

Svvrj&ivxeg Se %oif\6at (ir\ avxoig olov xvytx&g r) dxaQa^ia %aQr\xoXovd-r\6ev cbg, 6xtd 6co(iaxi. ov (ir\v doyXrrxov %dvxr\ xbv 6xe%xixbv elvai vo(iio[iev, dXtf 6yXei6&ai cpa(iev v%b x&v xaxr\vayxa6(iivcoV xal yaQ Qtyovv %oxe 6(ioXoyov(iev xai dttyfjv xal xoiovxoXQO%d xiva %a6yetv. dXXd xal iv xovxotg oi (iev iSt&xat 30

xal voovfiivcov i%tXQivat, xovxo i%i6yov' i%t6yov6t Se

x&v xal ovy

6vviyovxat %eQt6xa6e6tv v%6 xe x&v %a&&v avr\xxov v%b xov xdg %eQi6xa6etg xavxag xaxdg elvat cpv6et Soxeiv' 6 8h 6xe%xtxbg xb %Qo68ol-deiv oxt e6xi xaxbv xovxcov exa6xov cog %Qog xr\v cpv6tv %eQtatQ&v
8i66aig
,

(lexQicoxeQOv
(iev xoig

xal iv xovxoig d%aXXa66et.

8td xovxo ovv iv

So,a6xoig dxaQa^iav xiXog eivai cpafiev xov 6xe%xixov, iv 8e xoig xaxr\vayxa6(iivoig (iexQto%dd"etav. xtveg 8e x&v 8oxi(icov 6xe%xtx&v jrooG&hjxav xovtotg xai

xr\v iv

xaig t,r\xr\6e6tv i%oyf)v.

ty %e^i x&v 6Xo6yeQ&v xqo%cov xr\g i%oyf\g. E%ei Se xr\v dxaQaS^iav dxoXov&eiv icpa6xo(iev xr\ %e^i 31 %dvxcov inoyfj, dxoXov&ov av ei'r\ Xiyetv oncog r\(iiv r) i%oyr\

33 i>7tr)Qfyt 27 etpluribus T 28 xal <ri> LEAB edd. 22 a (in (sic) e Vesontino 409 vel cognato aliquo libro 24 av sir\ 23 insl M: inl LEAB titulo): 6xei[)E(Dg Gen. Xiysiv MEAB: sir\ X. av L
Gen.

12

IITPP&NEI&N
9
85

nsQtyivsxat. yivsxat xoCvvv aftxr), cog dv 6Xo6%EQi6xEQOV stnot xtg, Std xr)g dvxt&iescog xcbv nQayfidxcov. avxtxi&sfisv Ss r) cpatvofisva cpatvofiivotg r) voovfisva voovfisvotg

32

r)

fisv

ivaXXd^ olov cpatvofisva fisv c 6 avxbg nvQyog noQQCo&sv

Ss

cpatvofiivotg ,
fisv

oxav Xiyco-

iyyv&sv

xsTQdycovog' ,

voovfisva

cpaivsxat 6XQoyyvXog, Ss voovfiivoig, oxav

7tQog xbv xaxa6xsvdovxa oxt s6xt itQovoia ix xr)g xdl-scog xcbv ovQavicav, dvxtxi&cbfisv xb xovg fisv dya&ovg Sv61* nQaysiv noXXdxtg xovg Ss xaxovg sv7tQaystv, xal Std

33 xovxov

6vvdycofisv xb
tog

(ir)

slvat

KQOvoiav'

voovfisva

Ss

cpaivofxivoig ,

Idva^ayoQag

Xsvxr)v xi&st, oxt r) %tcov vScoq i6xl nsnrjyog, xb Ss ftScoQ i6xl fiiXav, xa\ r) %tcov aoa fiiXatvd s6xtv. xa& 5l ixi^av Ss inivoiav dvxixi&sfisv oxs ftsv naQovxa naQov6tv, cog xd nQOSiQrjfiiva' oxs Ss naQovxa naQsXr)Xv&o6tv olov oxav xig r)fiag iQcoxr)6r) Xoyov ov Xv6ai r) fiiXXov6iv, 34 ov Svvdfis&a, cpafisv itQog avxbv ow, co6nsQ tcqo xov ysvi6&at xbv st6r)yr)6dfitsvov xr)v atQS6tv r)v fisxiQ%r), ovSinco 6 n xax avxrjv Xoyog vyir)g cov icpaivsvo, vnixstxo ftivxot thg

(xaxa6xsvdovxi}

(A 97 Diels) xcb slvat xr)v %tova dvxs-

l\

nQog

xr)v cpv6tv,

ottxcog

ivSi%sxat xal xbv dvxtxsifisvov xtb

vnb 6ov
35 xi&s6&at

iQcoxrj&ivxt
<J'

cpv6iv, firjSinco
r)fjtccg

Xoycp vnoxst6&at fisv cog nQog xr)v cpaivEO&at, &6xs ovSinco %Qr) 6vyxaxaxco Soxovvxt vvv i6%vqco slvat Xoycp. vnsQ t
r)fiiv
r)fiiv
r)

vvv

Ss xov xdg dvxt&i6stg xavxag dxQti6vsQ0v cov 6slv , xai xovg XQonovg vno&r)6ofiat St

vnons-

inoyf) 6v-

vdysxat, ovxs nsQt xov nXrj&ovg ovxs nsQt xr)g Svvdfiscog avxcbv Stafisfiatovfisvog' ivSijsxat yaQ avxovg xal 6ad-Q0vg slvat xa\ nXsiovg xcbv Xsy%r)60ftivcov.
tS'

nsQt xcbv Sixa xQoncov.

36

TlaQaSiSovxat xoivvv 6vvr)&cog

St cbv
r)

naQa
snoyr)

xotg aQ%atoxi6vvdys6&at Soxst,

QOtg 6xsnxtxotg XQonot,

27 post cpaivofisva add. r\ EAB, post voovfisvcc add. r) 8 iQcoxtjGsi, L 4 suppl. e T (construenti) coll. p. 9,31 13 vnoKsia&co EAB 15 doGen. 10 rjyriedfisvov EAB xovv EAB

AB

TII0TTII&2E&N
Sixa rbv aQid fi6v,ovg
,

A.

13
6vvcovvficog

xai

Xoyovg

xai

rvnovg

xaXov6iv.
yr)v,

i6i Se ovroi, nQcorog 6

naQa

rr\v rcov cocov it-aXXa-

SevreQog o naQcc rr\v rcov dv&Qconcov SiacpOQav, XQtxog naQa xag SiacpOQOvg rcov aie&rjrrjQicov xara6xevdg, xk-

xaQtog 8 TtaQa xag neQi6ta6ecg , nifintog 6 naQa tdg &e6eig xai xcc Sia6tr)fiata xai tovg ronovg, exrog 6 TtaQcc xccg 37 enifiit,iag, efiSofiog 6 TtaQa xdg no6orr\rag xai 6xeva6iag rcov vnoxetfiivcov , bySoog 6 dnb xov nQog ri, evvaxog 6
r) 6navLovg eyxvQr\6eig, Sixarog 6 naQa xai td e&rj xai tovg vofiovg xai xdg ftv&ixdg tdg dycoydg niexeig xai xdg Soyfiatixdg vnoXrjipeig. yjQcbfie&a Se rr\ 38 rdt-et xavxrj ftexixcbg. xovxcov Se enavaf3e($r\x6reg eidi xqo-

naQa xdg 6vveyeig

1$ dficpoiv'
5

noi xQelg, 6 dnb xov XQivovrog, 6 dnb xov xQivofiivov, 6 to fiev yaQ dnb xov XQivovxog vnoxa66ovxai

ol nQ&xoi xi66aQeg (xb yaQ xqlvov r\ coov e6xiv r) av&Qconog r) at6&r\6ig i) ev xivi neQi6xa6ei), eig Se xbv dnb rotf

XQivofiivov (dvdyovxaiy 6 efiSofiog xai 6 Sixarog, eig Se tbv i dficpolv 6vv&etov 6 nifintog xai 6 extog xai 6 bySoog xai 6 evo cog

vatog. ndhv Se ol tQeig ovtoi dvdyovtat eig tbv nQog ti, 39 elvat yevixcotatov fiev tbv nQog ti, eiSixovg Se xovg xQeig, vnoeftr\x6rag Se xovg Sixa. xavxa fjtev neQi xr)g no6oxr\vog avtcov xatd tb ni&avbv Xiyofiev' ne^i Se rr\g
Svvdftecog tdSe.

TlQ&tov

iXiyofiev eivai Xoyov

xa$

ov (naQdy

rr\v Sia-

40

36163:
171 sqq.
Aristocles

171.
(cf.

v.

cf. Diog. Laert. IX 7988. Philo de ebr. Arnim Quellenstudien zu Philo p. 59 sqq.)

apud Euseb. Praep. Ev. XIV 18, llsqq. 4078: cf. Diog. Laert. IX 7980. Philo de

ebr.

cvvcovvficog ceig

GT (figuras): ronovg edd. rgoTtovg Kayser 27 ditseig ML: Sta&i6vvcovvfiovg LEAB EAB 31 fort. 6vyxvQrJ6eig sicut p. 33, 4. 2 &ert.Ktag om. T 5 xqLvuv 6 r) iv scripsi: xal iv GT 7 add. 8 6 edofiog post 6 ev.xog iterum EAB 10 Pappenh.
23 xvnovg
:
||

M:

EAB

mg

T.

om.

EABT

EAB

11 ivvia Kayser

14 elvai

iXiyoftev

||

TtaQa add. Gen.

14

I1TPP&NEI&N
v.

wogccv x&v <oa)v ov% at avxai dnb x&v avx&v vno7t't7txov6i wavxa6iac. xovxo 8s inc\oyc6(is&a k'x xs xr)g nsQi xdg ysx&v viasig avx&v StawoQag xai ix xfjg nsQi xdg 6v6xa6stg
41 6coudxa>v naQa\\ayr)g.

%sq\

(isv

ovv xag ysviescg,

oxi

x&v
xr)g.

yivsxai <?' i tidaxog

xd #' ix 6v(in\ofoorav (isv %coQig (Jti^scog ylvsxai xai x&v (isv %coQig (li^scog ycvo(iivcov xd usv ix nvQog~M &g xd iv xalg xaiiivocg watvoitsva ^covcpta, xd

xd

w&stQOasvov &g xcovconsg, xd 8 i% otvov 6xvcnsg, xd <$' ix yr)g (cog... .y,xd <$' i* ilvog &g XQsnouivov xd 8 e ovcov dxQa%ot, xd d' ix @oq(56qov cog axco\rjxsg, xd <J' ix \a%dvo)v cog xd(tnat, xd 8 ix xaQcog xdv&aQOt
cog

v.

Tt&v

42 vcov

&g &g

ol sx

x&v iQivs&v
(xsv

(ii\t66ac

6V(i7t\oxrjg

xd

rprjvsg, xd <?' ix ^tocov 6r\no(tsix xccvqcov xai 6wr)xsg imtcov' x&v 8 xd n\si6xa, xd 8 i 8(ioioysv&v cog

dvo(ioioysv&v &g
^cooxoxsixat

r)(iiovot.

nd\tv xotvrj x&v

d'

^cocov

xd

(isv
3<

&g uvftQtonot, xd
cog ccqxxoi.

tpoxoxsixat

&g oQvc&sg, xd
TtSQi

43 8s 6aQX0X0xsixai
6sig

sixbg ovv xdg

xdg ysvs-

SiawoQag (isydXag rtoisiv dvxtna%siag, xb a6vyxQaxov xai d6vvuQuo6xov xai (ia%6(isvov 44 ixsi&sv wsQO(isvag. dWd xai r) 8tawoQu x&v xvQccoxdxcov (isq&v xov 6c6(tuxog, xai (id\c6xu x&v 7tQog xb irtcxQivscv xai TtQog xb aie&dvs^&at nswvxoxcov, (isyc6xr)v Svvuxuc Ttocsiv (xd%r\v x&v wavxa6c&v \naQa xr)v x&v ^cocov TtaQaXol yovv IxxsQc&vxsg co%qu wu6tv slvac xd r)(icv \ayr)v\.
dvottoc6xr]xag

xai

vno6wayua s%ovxsg atficoTtd. insi xd usv ch%Qovg k'%st xovg 6w&u\(iovg xd <T vwaifiovg xd 8s \evxav&lovxag xd <?' dWrjv %qocrv k'%ovxag, sixog, ol(iac, 8tdwoQOv avxoig xr)v x&v %QCO(idxcov 45 dvxi\r\tytv yiyvs6%-at. dWd xai ivaxsvc6avxsg, ini no\vv
ovv xac x&v
^cocov
xcZ slxa iyxvtyavxsg pc\ico xd yQa(i(iaxa r)\icp , %qv6osl8t) 8oxov(isv slvac xai nsQcwsQO(isva. insi ovv xai x&v cocov xtvd wv6st \a(i7tr}86va iv xoig 6w&a\(iocg k'%sc

watvofjcsva \svxd, xai oi

ic

%qovov

ttil-ecov

15 anb xwv avtSiv om.T 19 et 20 18 6voicdxcov EAB M 21 ^couqpiaBekker: animaliaparvulaT: ^coocpvtaG 23 lac. stat. Fabr. addens cbg tiug 26 oi om. M 28 tcsv 7 xai vno<eS>EAB 5/6 seclusi ut glossema ad p. 11, 14 14 Xactn. iv xolg 6cp&ct\ttov %%st LE (sic): iv xocg (pa6(ia EAB
6<p&cd(coig
X.

l%sc

AB

X.

tyet iv tocg 6<p&uXccocg

TII0TTn&2EN

A.

15

Xet,

xui <p&g XsntofiEQEg re xcci svxivr\tov dn uvt&v dnoGteXcog xui vvxtbg 606:1/, Sebvtcag ocv vofiifytfiev oti fir) te xdxeivotg ru ixrbg vnoninrst. xui ye ol bfiotcc r)fitv
yorjrsg

4&

%Qtovreg rdg &QVuXXt6ug

ore fiev

ntag noiovGtv

&oX<p <Sr\yccXxovg brs 8s fieXavag cpuiveG&ut

i& yccXxov

xcci

rovg TtaQOvrag 8td rr)v fiQuyetuv rov (ity&evrog nuQuGnonoXv 8f)nov evXoycareQov ecsrt, yv(i&v SiucpoQcov dvaQciv. xexQUfiivcov rr) OQuGst r&v cacov,(xaiyStacp6QOvg r&v vnoxetaivcov cpavracsiag uvrotg ytveG&ut. orav re nuQud-Xitpcofiev t6v ocp&aXfiov, intfir)xr\ xcci Grevu cpaiverat rcc ei'Sr} xui rd Gyf)(iuru xcci rcc fieyi&r) r&v oQur&v. eixbg ovv ori

4?

iteQ

t&v ^cacov Xo^r)v syst rr)v xoQrjv xal nQO(ir)xr), xu&dulysg ui'XovQOt xai ra iotxoru, StdcpoQU cpccvrd&rut rcc vnoxsifisvu slvcct, xai ovy ota rd nsQicpSQr} rr)v xoQrjv
oGcc
<acc elvat uvrcc vnoXufi^dvst. rd re xdtontQU nuQU StdcpoQOv xutuGxsvr)v bte fiev (itXQOtata SeixvvGt tcc ixtbg vnoxsifcsvu cog rd xotXcc, bts S inifif)xr) xai Grsvd

%ypvtu
1

48

ttjv

cag

xatoittQt^Oftivov ,
'

ta xvQrd' rtvd Ss tf)v (isv xecpuXr)v xdrco SeixvvGt rov tovg Se nbSug dvco. inei ovv xai t&v 49rd fiev i^ocp&aXfia xofitSy nQoneiteQt tr)v otyiv dyysicov

%rcoxsv

vnb xvQtbtrjtog, rd
xcci

itXdrst fisfirjxEv, slxbg

Ss xoiXbtEQu iffw, rd d' iv vntica Std rovro dXXotovG&ut rag cpccv-

xaoiag, xai fir)ts iGu rotg fieye&eGt (if)te ofiota tatg fiOQtpatg oQttv rd ccvtd xvvccg iypvccg Xeovrag dv&Qconovg nuQvonccg,
dXX'

otuv exuGtov notei

tvncaGtv

r)

Seypfievr)

rb

50tputvofievov otytg. 6 Se avrbg xai ne^i r&v ccXXcav uiG&f)Gscov Xoyog' n&g yuQ dv Xeyjfreir) bfioicog xtvetG&ut v.urd
xr)v
)

rjxav&cofiiva

rd rs oGtQccxoSsQfiu xui ru GccQXOcpavf) xai ru xai ru inrsQCOfievu rj XeXentScofiivu; n&g 6s bfioiag dvttXufi^dvsG&at xatd tr)v dxorjv td ts Grevcararov sjpvru rbv noQOV rbv dxovGrtxbv xui rd evQvtt<pr)v

xdtco

rovtco
&it'

xe%Qr)(ievcc,

r)

td tetQtycofievu tu

cotcc

xui

15
rentes)

uvxcbv om. T 21 dXoycaxsQov Gen.

olcc
:

28

olg

LEAB

1 uyydcov

(instrumentorum) atcf. Philoleg. alleg. E37(I97, 28Cohn) l/27tQOJtiitx<oxsvEAB et (ommisso r) T (jarocidunt) 7tinxcoxsv L edd. 4 ouota LE AB 5 oq&v om. 13 xd ante mxa om. EAB xcci G r) T (vety oqccv

G dgydvcov iam

ccird a Bekkero coni.

29

EAB

22 add. e T (et diffe:

aiti)v

ccvtdg L-

||

IQ
xd tyiXd

IITPP&NEI&N
rjuelg aXXcog fiev dxor\v 7iaoa@v6avxeg xa coxa, dXXatg avxolg %Q(bfie&a. xai r) 6ocpQr\Oig Se Siacpeqoi

xavxa xivovfie&a xaxd

e%ovxa.\
xr\v

onov

ye

xai

51 Se r)v dnX&g av naqd xr\v xcov o)(ov iaXXayr)v' ei ydq xcci r\uelg aXXoog xcti xov cpXeyfiaxog nXeovdoavfiev xtvovue&a iuipvyevveg
xog iv
rjfiiv,

dXXoog Ss r)v xd neqi xr\v xecpccXr\v

rjficov fieQr\

xa evc6Sr\ nXeovaOfibv aifiaxog vnoSer\xai , dnoaxQecpofievoi Soxovvxa elvai xai coOneq nXr)xxea&ai vn avxolg aXXoig xtov vo(iiovxeg, inei xai xtov fcotov xa fiev nXaSaqd xe
xai cpXey(iaxc6Sr\, xd Ss noXvaifia dcpoSoa, xa inixQaxovaav xai nXeovd&vaav e%ovxa xr\v av&r\v %oXr\v etiXoyov xai Sid touto Sidcpoqa exdaxoig r) xr\v fiiXaivav, 62 ccvx&v cpaiveO&ai xd 6ocpQr\xd. xai xd yevaxd bfioiojg xcov xai avixfiov i%6vxcov xr\v yXcoOGav x&v Se fiev xqa%etav ivvyqov OcpoSqa, eiye xai r\fieig ^rjQOxeqav iv nvqexoig xr\v yX&xxav a%6vxeg yec6Sr\ xai xaxo%Vfia r) ntxQU xd nqoaioxi
6*'

cpvOei

cpeQOfieva
xr\v

elvai

vofii&fiev,

xovxo

Se

nda%ofiev xai naqd

%vfia>v

SidcpoQOV imxqdxeiav x&v iv

iitei

rjfiiv

elvai Xeyo-

fievcov'

ovv xai xd

akc SidqpOQOv xo

ysvOxixbv aia&rj-

nXeovd^ov, Siacpoqovg dv xai xaxd xr\v yevOiv cpavxaciag x&v vnoxsiftevcov Xafi(idxr\Qiov e%ei xai Siacpoqoig %vfioig
-53 voi.

cooneq yaq r) avxr\ XQOcpr\ dvaSiSofiivrj onov fiev yivexai cpXety onov Se dQxrjqia onov Ss ooxeov onov Se vevqov xai x&v dXXoav sxaoxov, naqd xr\v SiacpoQuv x&v vnoSe%o-

fieq&v Sidcpoqov ini.Seixvvfiivr\ Svvauiv, xai coaneq xb vScoq *iv xai uovoeiSeg dvaSiSouevov eig xd SevSqa onov fiev yivexui cpXoibg onov Ss xXdSog onov Se xaqnbg xai
fiivcov avxr\v

54

r\Sr\ Ovxov xai qouc xai xcov dXXcov exaOxov, xai xa&dneq xb xov fiovaovQyov nvevfia ?v xai xb avxb ifinveofievov xco avXa onov fiev yivexai ov onov Sh ficcQv, xai r) avxr\ ineqeiaig xr\g %eiqbg ini T^g ivoag onov fiev ^aqvv cp&oyyov noiel

onov Se o^vv,

oftxcog eixbg

xai xd ixxbg vnoxeifieva Sid-

EAB
O:

15 7taQav6avxsg

MEAB:
L

(comp. script.): xavxa

rationabile est
(si

T
et

MEA.BT

et jtaga^aavxsg L 21 s iv ai 25 sftXoyov Salmasius: sKXoya 26 avx&v om. T 28 siys xal rjfvslg

quidem

coll. p. 13, 12. 14. 24. 27.

dum): nsgl
afoTjv

LEAB
:

MEAB

avx&v L

2 Xauf3dvoi L: Xaufidvsi MEABT (assumit) 10 post avxb add. nvsvua MEAB

nos): xal rj. stys xal: tj Pasquali

||

29 fort. fyovxsg 30 nagd MT (secun-

TnOTTII2EN

A.

17

nuQu xr)V StdcpOQOV xuxa6xsvr)v xcov q>OQ<x &EcoQei6&at xug (pavraGiag vnousvovTcov cocov. ivaQyioxEQOv 8h xb 55 XOIOVXOV E6Tt UU&EtV dnb tcov aiQEX&V xs xui CpEVXTCOV
xoig ^cootg.

uvqov yovv dv&Qcbnotg uhv r\8t6iov cpuivsxut, xuv&uQotg 8h xui usXi66uig 8v6uvu6iexov' xui xb sXutov xovg uhv ccvd-Qcbrtovg cbcpsXst, 6cpr)xug Sh xui usXi66ug uvaiQSi xuxuqquivousvov' xui xb ftuXdxxtov vScoq uhv drjSig i6xi ntvousvov xui cpuQuuxcoSsg, r\8i6xov

dv&Qcbnotg

xui

Ttbxiuov.

xu Sh &auvocpdyu xu Ss vXrjvouu xu Sh 6itEQuocpuyu xu Sh 6UQX0cpuyu xu 8h yuXuxxocpdya , xai xu usv 6E6r\itviu '(uLqei XQOcpr\ xu Sh veuqu, xai xu uhv cbytr) xu Sh uuysiQixcog i6xsvu6uivr). xui xotvcog xu uXXotg r]Siu
uXXotg s6xiv vsiov ntuivst
dr]Srj

8v6coSs6xccxcp r) uiv i6xi nor\cpuyu

Sh i%&v6i. 56 fioQpoQcp Xovovtui vSuti StEt8st xui hu&uqco. xcov xs cccov xce

6vsg

xs

r\8tov

xui cpsvxxd xui &avu6tua. xb yovv xco- 57

xovg OQXvyug xai 6 vo6xvauog xdg fig , di Sr) yaiQovOi xui 6uXuudvSQug i6&iov6ut, co6nsQOVV sXucpot xu iofioXu ^cou xui ui %sXtS6vsg xuv&UQtSug. oi' xs uvqxui oi 6xvlnsg dv&Qconotg uhv drjStug xui 6XQOcpovg iunotov6t xuxuntvousvot' 7} 8h uQxxog r)v UQQC06xiu xtvi xovxovg xuxuXtiucouivr\ Qcovvvxut. 7tEQtTti6rj, s%tSvu Sh 58
(ii]xsg

>

fttyovxog

uvTf)g

uovov

cpi]yov

xXdSov

xuqovtui, xu&dnsQ

xai vvxxEQig nXurdvov cpvXXov. cpsvyst 8h XQtbv uhv iXicpug, Xicov Sh uXextqvovu, xui &Quyubv xvducov iQStxouivcov xct

duXdxxtu
>

xr\xr),

nXsico

xovxcov sv6xt XiystV

xui xtyQtg tyocpov xvundvov. xai uXXu Sh uXX' tvu fir) uccXXov xov Siovsi

xog ivStuTQifistv SoxcofiEv, xotg Sh jjSiu, xb Sh r)Sv

StdcpOQOt yivovxut xotg si Sh xu uvxu xu6iut.

xu uvxu xotg

(iiv i6xtv ur\Sr)

xui

cootg

diqShg iv cpuvxu6ia. xstxut, unb xcov vnoxstuivcov cpuv-

nQuyuuxu dvouota

cpuivsxut

nuQu 59

it^v x&v
!

c6cov H~aXXayr)v, bnotov uhv r)utv &scoQStxut xb vnoxsiusvov e^ouev Xiystv, Snotov Sh i'6xt nQog xrjv cpv-

20 avd-Qwnotg om. EAB 22 xs GT: dh edd. 28 <7j>xai 29 ca L 2 MEAB 31 dh (vero) T 34 dvuQQwQav. (aut et) T 1 uovov Bekk. uovov vvrat Pasquali coll. Aelian. h. a. II 9 G cpvyov LEAB 4 dh om. T 7 svr}dss L 10 gaxav ML:
:

||

voucov

EAB

Sextus Empiricug

I.

18
Oiv icpi^Ofiev.

IITPP&NEI&N

ovde ycco intxQivetv avxoi dvvr)66fis&a xdg xdg xe i)fiexiQug xai xag r&v aXXcov fcocov, fiiq?avxa6iag oog xai avxol rr\g Stacpcoviug ovrsg xai dtd rovro xov intavxoi XQivstv Svvdfisvoi. XQtvovvrog dsr)6ofisvot fiaXXov r) 60 xal aXXcog ovrs dvanodsixrcog dvvdfis&a nQOXQiveiv rdg
rjfisrsQag

cpavxaGiag x&v

nuQa

vcov
detiv

ovxs

fux
cog

dnodsil-scog.

jtQog

roig dXoyotg fcootg ytvofiiyaQ rco fir) slvai dnor)

i'6cog,

inofivr)60fiev, uvri)
r)

Xsyofiivrj

dnoSstl-tg
ftsv
fii)
\

r]xoi cpaivofisvr} rjfiiv s6rut

ov

(paivofiivrj.

xui si

cputvofiivr),

ovSs

fisxd
r)fiiv
r)
,

nsnotd"r)6scog
instdr)

avrrjv

%QOoi6ofis&a'
xoig

si 6s cputvofiivr)
cooig r)xsixut xui

ns^i r&v cputvofiivcov

dnodst^tg

avxr) fijTTj^CETat si sexiv 61 axonov 6s xb ^rjxovfisvov dtd xov ^rjxovfiivov xuru6xevdetv intystQsiv , insi s6xai xb avxb ni6xbv xui ani6xov, onsQ

cpaivsxai %cooig ov6t, xui dXrjdrjg xu&6 i6xi cputvofiivr).

r)fiiv

dfimavov, ni6xbv
ds
r)

fisv

rj

{lovXsrut

dnoSstxvvstv , dni6rov

dnodsixvvxut. ov% s^Ofisv uqu dnodst^tv cV r)g nQOXQivovfisv xdg suvx&v cpavraeiag r&v nuQu roig dXoyotg xaXovfiivoig t,cooig yivofiivcov. si ovv dtdcpoQOi yivovrai ai
cpuvru6iui

naQu

rr\v

r&v

cocov

dfk.r)favov o*Ttv, sniystv dvdyxt)

ii-aXXayrjv, ag sntxQivai nsQi r&v ixxbg xinoxstfiivcov.

62

nsQiov6iag 6s xai 6vyxQivofisv rd dXoya xuXovftsvu dv&Qconotg xurd cpavra6iav' xai yuQ xaranut%stv r&v doyfiarixcov rsrvcpcofiivcov xai nsQiavxoXoyovvxcov ovx
coa roig

Ex

dnoSoxtfid^ofisv fisxd rovg nQuxrtxovg r&v Xoycov. oi fisv ovv rjfiirsQoi to nXfj&og r&v dXoycov fcocov dnX&g sico&a6i

63

snsi ds svQS6tXoyovvrsg oi oy~ 6vyxQivstv tc3 dv&Qconco fiartxoi dvt6ov elvai cpa6t ri)v 6vyxQt6tv, rjfieig ix noXXov rov nsQtovxog ini nXiov nai^ovrsg sni svbg coov
6rr)60fisv rbv Xoyov, olov ini xvvog, si Soxsi, xov svrsXs 6xdxov doxovvxog slvat. svQi)60fisv yaQ xai ovxco fir) Xsinofisva r)fi&v Ta cpa, ne^i cbv 6 Xoyog, cog rr\v ni6xiv

'

64 r&v

nQog

cpatvofiivcov. oxi

xoivvv ai6&r)6st 6iaq>iQSt xovxo xb fcoov

12 oi> (non) T 18 r& M: xb LEAB 21 nqooic6iis%a G producemus T: %Q06r\a6^,s&a a Gen. coniectum recepit Bekk ovv ML yovv EAB cci om. EAB 1 xd dl. $&a ovrco xa30^ 6 svgsadoyovvreg Gen. Xovfieva EAB svQeGtoXoyovvTES G 8 nai&iv Hxovrss Kayser 11 & s om. T
:
||

TII0TTn&2EN

A.

19
rf)

...
rjflCO fi&v,

01 Soyfiurtxoi

6vvofioXoyov6tv'

xui yuQ

06cpQi)-

6et
5

fif) OQCofievu uvrcp dvrtXafi^dveTut, drjQia Std ravrrjg dvtryevcov xui roig ocp&uXfioig ftarrov r)fi&v ravra oq&v xui rf) dxof) ui6&av6fUvog o^icog. ovxovv 65

fiaXXov

f)fi&v

xa

ini

rbv Xoyov

eXdcofiev.

rovrov Se

6 fiiv

i6riv ivStd-

fterog 6 Se nQOcpoQtxog. 'iScofiev ovv TtQoreQOv neQt rov ivStu&irov. ofirog roivvv xuru rovg (iaXi6ra r)fiiv dvrt!0

So^ovvrag vvv Soyfiarixovg , rovg dnb rr)g Sro&g, iv rovroig eoixe 6uXevetv, rr\ cuoeoei r&v oixeicov xal
cpvyf) r&v dXXorQicov, rrj yvco6ei r&v eig rovro 6vvretvov6&v re%v&v, rfj dvrtXrjtyet r&v xard rf)v oixeiav cpv6iv UQer&v (xaV) r&v neoi ru nd&r). 6

66

roivvv
85

xvcov., icp

evexa, ui'Qe6iv

ov rbv Xoyov eSo^e 6rf)6ai nuQuSeiyfturog itoielrui r&v oixeicov xul cpvyf)v r&v fiXufleQ&v,

ru

fiev TQOcpifia Stcoxcov, (tu6rtyog Se dvuru&eierjg vnoycoQ&v. dXXd xui reyyr)v eyet noQt6rtxf)v r&v oixeicov, rf)v ftrjQevrt, xiyv. e6rt Se ovS aQerfjg ixrog' rfjg yi roi Stxuto6vvr)g 67 dl-iuv dnoSortxf)g exu6rco, 6 xvcov rovg ov6t)g rov xur

30 fiev

Se
rfjg

oixeiovg ye xui ev notovvrug 6uivcov xui cpQOVQ&v rovg dvoixeiovg xai dStxovvrug dfivvofievog ovx e%co uv ei'r)
Sixuto6vvt)g.
ei

Se ruvrrjv e%et,
eyet,

r&v UQer&v dvraxo- 68

17

ag ov cpu6tv eyetv rovg noXXovg dv&Qconovg oi 6ocpoi. xui uXxtftov Se uvrbv ovru OQ&fiev iv ruig dfivvutg xui 6vverov, cog xui"Ofir)QOg
ifiuQTVQr)6ev , notrfiug rbv ^0Sv66iu na.6t fiev roig oixeiotg

Xov$ov6&v xui rug uXXug UQerug

dv&Qconotg dyv&ru bvru vnb fiovov Se rov "A^yov intyvto6%revru, fir)re vnb rf)g dXXoico6ecog rfjg xuru t6 6&\xu tuvSQog dnuTrj&ivrog tov xvvog, fif]re ix6rdvrog rfjg xuruXr)nrixf)g

cpuvru6iag,

r]v

fiaXXov

xaru Se rbv

XQV6tnnov

r&v dv&Qconcov ercov icpdvt). rbv fidXt6ru 6vfinoXefiovvru roig 69

III 2

dXoyotg frootg xai rfjg dotSifiov StaXexrtxfjg fieri%ei.

65
cf.

Porphyr. de abstin.
e

23 (xaYy add.
nes) coll. p. 17, 17.

(et

in

eo

28

xot L: xi

4 bvxa G: elvui T (esse) 8h 6: fiiv (quidem) T noXefiovvxa GT (qui maxime repugnat): Ttgo()%ovxa Diels
1

EAB
8

MEAB

quod

est

circa

passio-

30 yaLM: om. T:

GvfLTtoXefiovvxa scripsi:

2*

20
cpi)6i

IITPP&NEI&N

yovv ccvtov 6 nQOSiQr)fisvog dvr)Q incfidXXeiv tg> nifinTco diu nXeiovcov dvanoSeixTcp, otttv ini tqioSov iX&cov xcci tag Svo oSovg i%vev6ccg 81 cov ov 8ir)X&e xb drjQiov, rr)v tqittjv fir)S' i%vev6ccg ev&ecog
r) Tr)8e 8if)X&e 70 to ftrjQiov' ovTe Se Trjde ovre TySe' rf)Se aQcc.' uXXu xai tcov eavTov ncc%&v dvTiXr)nTixog re i6Ti xcci

0Qfir)6r) Si avTr]g. Svvdfiei yuQ tovto G&ui cpr)6cv 6 UQyaiog *rJTOi rr)Se r) Tfjde

uvtov Xoyie-

6xoXonog yccQ ccvtco xccTccnaysvTog ini Tr)v ccQ6iv tovtov oquu tt) tov noSbg TtQog Tr)v yf)v nctQccTQitysi xcci Stu r&v oSovtcov. sXxog re ei* s%et nov, inei tcc fiev QvnccQu eXxr) SveuXd-f) i6Tiv, toc Se xcc&ccqcc Qctdicog fteQaneveTcci, nQacog ccnotpa 71 tov yivofievov i%&Qcc. dXXd xcci to 'InnoxQttTeiov cpvXa66si fiaXtt xccX&g' inei yccQ noSbg ccxog dxivrj6icc, ei noTe TQavfia iv nodi 6%oir), fisTscoQi^st tovtov xcci cog oidv Te cc6xvXtov Tr)Qei. 6%Xovftev6g re' , vnb %vfi&v uvotxeicov noccv i6&iet, fleQ^ r)g ccno72 fiXv^cov to uvoixeiov vytd^eTai. ei roivvv icpdvr) to o5ov, icp ov rbv Xoyov i6Tf)6a(iev naQccSsiyfiaTog svsxcc, xcci
naQttfivftr)Tix6g'
aiQOVfisvov
rtt oixsicc

'<

noQi6Tixr)v tcov oixsicov, xcci

xai tu 6%Xr)Qa cpsvyov, ts%vy\v ts s%ov t&v sccvtov ncc&cbv dvTtXrywttxbv

'.

xcci ovx e%co UQeTf)g, iv olg xetTut f) tov ivSta&eTov Xoyov, TeXetog ccv ei'r) xcctcc tovto 6 xvcov' o&ev fioi 8oxov6i rvveg t&v xcctu cpiXo6ocpiav eavTovg 73 6e(ivvvai Tr) tov ^coov tovtov nQ06r)yoQia. nsQi 8e tov

xui nuQUfivd-rjTixov ,
TeXeiOTrjg

nQOcpOQixov tovtov yuQ

nQttTTOVTu
(ia&r)6scog

Xoyov
xtti rcov
Tr)

Tscog

fisv

ovx s6tiv uvuyxaiov

r)Tsiv'

doyfiaTixcbv svioi nccQr)Ti)6avT0 ag dvriTr)g UQSTr)g dvaXrjtySL, 8ib xui nuQcc rbv Tr)g
6iconr\v' xai aXXcog, ei

%qovov r)6xr)6av

xux? vno-

&s6iv
yov.

si'r)

cvcc

ccv&Qconog iveog, ovSeig q?i)6et ccvtov elvcci dXo8s xui tccvtcc nccQccXincofiev , fidXi6Tcc fisv OQ&fisv

11 avunoSsivLTcp Apelt coll. Plut. de soll. anim. p. 969 B (vide p. 93, 11): avaTtoSsixxcov G: per plura inmittere quinto indemonstrativo T 12 iX&cov (veniens) : iXdsiv LE AB 14 6g-

MT
:

(ir)6r]

Bekk.

6q(itj6si Gr

G 20

dveccXri&f)

16 22 r&v

otirs rjjds

T
L

31 siri xovxo xaxu xovxov EB om. L U nccou M: nsgi LEAB

yivo(iivcov
sir)

24 a aexvXov EAB xovxo xaxd xovxo A 3rj

(neque hac)

r)

rfcfs

TII0TTn2EN
. xd <3a,
cpcovdg,
izsqI

A.

21

cbg

cov 6 Xoyog, xai dv&Qconivag nQOcpSQOfisva xixxag xai aXXa xivd. iva Ss xai xovxo ia6co- 74
fif)

psv,
)

si

xai

6vvisfisv
oXcog

xdg

cpcovdg

xcov

dXoycov

xa-

ovx s6xiv dnsixbg SiaXsys6&ai (isv xavxa, Tjfiag Ss (ir) Gvvisvat" xai yao xr\g xcov aQ^dgcov cpcovf)g dxovovxsg ov 6vvis(isv dXXd fiovostSf) xavxrjv clXovfisvcov
c6cov,

vat

dxovofisv Ss xcov xvvcov aXXr\v (isv 75 oxav dfivvcovxai xtvag, aXXrjv Ss oxav coQvcovxai) xa\ dXXrjv oxav xvnxcovxat , xai SidcpOQOv indv 6uivco6tv. xai oXcog si' xig sig xovxo axsvi6stsv, svqoi
Soxovfisv.
cpcovr)v

xal

TCQOiSfiivcov

av noXXr)v naQaXXayr)v
dXXoig
cootg

naQa xovxco xs xai xotg StacpoQOig nsQt6xa6s6tv , co6xs Sid xavxa sixoxcog Xsyoix dv xai xov nQOCpOQtxov f/usxsysiv Xosi Ss fir)xs dxQttSsCa xcov 76 yov xd xaXovfisva dXoya coa.
xr)g cpcovf)g

iv

xaig

ai6&r)6scov Xsinszai xcov dv&Qconcov xavxa (if)xs Sta&ixco Xoyco, ia nsQtoveiag Ss sinsiv firjSs xco
Qiy.cp.

xco

iv-

nQOcpo-

ovx dv dni6xoxsQa r)(icov sirj xaxd xag cpavxa6iag. xai icp ixdexov Ss x&v dXoycov ^cocov i'6cog t6xdvxag xbv 77 Xoyov xavxa dnoSstxvvstv Svvaxov i6xiv. oiov yovv xig ovx dv sinot xovg OQVt&ag dy/tvoCa xs StacpsQSiv xai xco
nQOcpOQixco xsfjaffi&ai Xoyco\ oi' ys ov fiovov xd naQovra dXXd xai xd i6ofisva inC6xavxut xai xavxa xoig 6vvtsvai

Svvafiivoig
)

nQoSr\Xov6tv ,

aXXcog

xs

6r\fiaivovxsg

xai

xr)

cpcovr)

nQoayoQSvovxsg.
Ss

Tr)v

6vyxQi6iv

inotrj6u(ir)v ,

cog

inserifirjvdfirjv, ix

nsQtovxog, ixuvcog,

cog olfiai,

xai s'finQ06&sv 78 Ssi^ag [s(i-

'

nQ06&sv] oxt fir) Svvdfis&u nQOXQivsiv xdg f)(isxsQag cpavxaeCag xcov nuQa xoig dXoyoig ^rootg ytvofisvcov. nXr)v aXX si fif) i6xiv dni6x6xsQa xd dXoya cpa f)(icov n^bg xr)v
xqi6iv xcov
cpavxa6icoV)
^cocov
ifioi

naQa
S6xi

xr)v xebv

vnoxsifisvcov
xfj

yivovxai cpavra6iai naQaXXayr)v, bnoiov fisv sxa6xov xcov cpaivsxai Svvr)6o(iai Xsysiv, bnoiov Ss

xai SidcpoQoi

cpv6si Sid xd nQOSiQrjfisva iniysiv dvayxa6&r)6o(iai.

17 Ttagd tovrco
tov om.

Gen.:

L T

||

te

MT

nsgl

(in eo

quoque

et):

EAB

25 anodsfAvvsiv Gen.: 32/3 ifingoa&sv secl., fort.

MEAB: nsgl tovLEAB 24 aloycov vitodsiitvvsiv G Svvatbv om.

toitco

om.

||

iv tovtoig

2 &XX' om.

22
79

IITPP&NEI&N
Kal
6
(jtev rtQ&xog TJjg irtoif\g xQOrtog xotovxog s6xi, Se iXeyofiev elvat xbv drtb xrjg StacpoQag x&v

SevxeQOV
dv&Qcortcov'

ivtt

yaQ xa& vno&eetv

xcci

6vyfcaQr\6r\ xig rtt-

axoxeQovg dofiev xai

ccyofievr\v.

elvcci

x&v dXoycov
xr\

o6ov ini

xovg av&Qcoitovg, evQf)r)(iexeQa StacpoQa xr\v irtO'/r\v et6fcocov

Svo xoivvv
otov

elvcct

av&Qconog, tyv%r\g
QOfiev dXXrjXcov,

xcci 6coficcxog,
xccxct

Xeyofievcov i% cov 6vyxetxat 6 xccx dficpco xccvxa Stacpexcctg xe fiOQCpatg

6&fia
fiev

xal

xcctg
i

80 iSto6vyxQi6iaig.

StacpeQei

yccQ

xaxcc

fiOQCprjv
rtotet,

6&fia

Hxv&ov
cpa6iv,

'Ivdov 6coficcxog, xr\v Se rtccQaXXayr\v

xa&drteQ

x&v %v(icov irttxQaxeta. rtaQa Se xr\v Stdr) dtdcpoQog x&v yyfi&v irttXQaxetav StdcpOQOt yivovxai xcci ccl cpavxa6icct, xa&dneQ xal iv x& rtQcoxco Xoyco ( 52) rtaQe6xr\6axuvxd xoi xal iv xf\ atQe6et xal cpvyf) x&v ixxbg Statpofjtev.
cpooov
qcc rtoXXrj

xax
ot

ccvxovg i6xiv'

xccl

ccXXoig

xatf

r)(iag,

xb

aXXotg yaQ yaiQ0v6iv ^lvSoi Se StacpoQOtg ycciQetv xov

81 veiv
cbg

rtaQrjXXayfievag drtb i6xi fir\vvxtx6v.

vrtb

x&v

xaxcc

vnoxetfievcov cpccvxa6iag Xa(idSe idto6vyxQt6iag dtacpeQOfiev

iviovg xQecc 6eta nexQaicov ly&vSicov qSov rtkxxetv xat

Ae6$iov oivaQiov eig ypXeQccv neQtxQerte6&cct. r\v Se, yQavg 'Axxtxrj XQidxovxa bXxdg xcoveiov dxtvSvvcog rtQ06cpeQ0fiivrj, Av6tg Se xccl (irjxcoveiov xe66ccQug oXxdg
cpa6iV)

82 dXvrtcog iXdfifiavev. xal Ar\(iocp&v (iev 6 AXe^dvSQOv xqccrte&rtotbg iv r)Xico ytvofievog r) iv ^aXaveico iQQiyov, iv 6xta Se i&dXrtexo, A&rjvayoQag Se 6 AQyetog vtco 6xoqrticov

xai

cpaXayyicov

WvXXaetg ou<f vrtb

dXvrtcog irtXr\66exo^ oi Se xaXovfievot otpecov r) a6rtiScov Saxv6(ievot (iXdrtxov-

83 rc, oi Ss TevxvQtxat x&v Aiyvrtxicov ov fiXdrtxovxat rtQog

7989
15

cf.Diog. Laert

IX 8081. Philo de

ebr.

175 sqq.

11 xr\v 6vy%toQr)6et MLT (concedet) 17 7tagd dh MT (secundum autem) itagd LEAB 17 iTtiyiqdxeta 18 %v(t(bv om. L 20 xavxd xot G qua28 xa\ om. T propter T 21 xatd tovg av&Qmnovg Kayser 31 ivs&dXneto EAB 33 WvXXaelg G: WvXXot iam desid. a Salmasio praeb. T (psilli) add. rj 6xoQitLa>v post ocpetov

6vy%toQr\6r\
(isv

EAB:

om.

om.

||

1 TevtvQttai Fabr. avto xdtto Diels

TtvtvQltat

GT

(tintarite)

\\

itQ06vrj%6(iEvot

TIIOTTIISEN
[avco xdxco] xcov XQOXoSsiXcov. jtioav xr)g MsQorjg nccQct xov

A.

23

cdla xai Ai&toncov oi dvxi-

Aaxdnovv noxafibv oixovvxsg

axoQniovg xai
5

bcpstg xai xcc

naQanXr]ata dxtvdvvcog ia&iovatv.

xal
xal

Povcpivog 8s 6 iv XaXxidi nivcov iXXsfioQov ovxs r\(isi OVXS Olcog SXCi&aiQEXO, dXX* COg Xt XCOV awr\\TCOV JtQ06SCpSQSX0
snsaasv.

XQv6SQiiog 8h 6 'HQOcpiXstog s'C noxs nsnsQt 84 TtQoSrjvsyxaxo, xaQdiaxcog ixtvdvvsvsv. xal EtoxriQtypg 8s 6 ytiQovQybg si' noxs atXovQcov r\afrsxo xviaarjg, %oXsqc( rjXiaxsxo.
10

"AvSqcov 81 6 'AQysiog o&xcog aSttyog i\v cog xai Std xr)g dvvSQOV Atfivr\g bSsvstv avxbv ur) intr\xovvxa norov. TifisQiog 8s 6
icoQa. AQtaxoxiXrjg 8s iaxoQsi (Meteor. p.373b4) &dat6v xiva co iSoxst dv&Qconov si'6coXov itQOTjyeia&at avxov 6id navxog. xoaavxr\g ovv itaQ- 85

KaiaaQ iv axoxco

15

aXXayf)g ovarjg iv xoig dv&Qconotg xaxd xa acouaxa, i'va bXiya dnb noXXcov xcov naQa xoig Soyuartxoig xstuivcov aQxsa&cofisv sinovrsg, sixog iart xai xar avxr)v xr)v ipv%r)v Stacpiostv dXXrjXcov tot;g dv&Qconovg' xvnog yaQ xig iaxt xb acofia cog xai r) cpvatoyvcouovtxr) aocpia 8sixvvatv. xb 8s uiytaxov 8siy(ia xr)g KaTa xr\v Stdvoiav xcov dv&Qcbncov xai dnsiQOv StacpoQccg r) Stacpcovia xcov naQa xoig

xf\g r\>v%i)g)
20

noXXf)g

Soyuaxtxoig Xsyouivcov nsQi xe x&v dXXcov xai ne^i xov xiva (iev atQeia&at nQoarjxet xiva Ss ixxXivstv. Ssovxcog 86 ovv xai oi notr\xai nsQi xovxcov dnscpr)vavxo' 6 (isv yaQ
25

TlivSaQog cpr\atv (fr. 242 Boeckh, 221 Schroed.) dsXXonoScov usv xtv svcpQaivovatv tnncov
xtfiai <(t^> xai axicpavot,

iv noXvfjQvaotg d aXduotg (itoxd' xsQnsxat Ss xai xtg in ol8u dXtov

xovg
i9u

<?'

vat ftoa Stausifitov

2 dvco xdtco

duntur a

tum praeb. T (astapum): v8danr\v G edd. EAB: chrisormus T 8 xal om. T 11 notauovM
videbatur)
cf.

crocodillis)

ab Apeltio olim deletum omisit T (non le3 'Aatdnovv olim ab Herchero inven7

%vaeQuog

13 m

t&v om.

Aristot. 1. 1.: a>s Paris. 27 te add. Schroeder

suppl. 133: og

T (cui G 16

29 olSua Ptcotalg ftooibv EAB: froa atbv Gen.

dtaaticov G: pergens

EAB

G
:

28 iotd L: (iicotd M: 29* &o& LMT (navi veloci): &oa a&g Fabr. Siausicov Maas:
||

24

IITPP&NEI&N
|
s(

6 Sh noir\zr\g Xiyst ($ 228) aAilog ydg z dXXot6tv avrjo inttiQnEtat soyoig.

aXXa %ai r) tQaycoSia (Eurip. Phoen. 499)

ei itaGi

(ie6tr\

r&v totovtcov

ictC'

Xiyet

yovv

zavzbv xaXbv

l'<pv

6o<pov

afia,

ov%

r\v

av

dficpiXeKtog dv&Qconotg Qtg,

xai ndXtv (Fragm. Trag. adesp.

462 Nauck)
dvSdvstv qoz&v

Setvov ye tavtbv totg

rotg d' ex&og elvai.

(ilv

87 inei ovv
i)

r)

ai Qe6tg xal

r)

<pvyr\ iv r\Sovr\ K<xi dr\St6(ico iffrtv,

Se r\8ovr\, %ai 6 dr\8t6(ibg iv cd6&r\6et %etrat %ai cpavraGta, otav td avtd ol (iev atQ&vrat ol 8e <pevyco6iv, d%6-

Xov&ov r)(iag intXoyile6$ai ort ovSe 6(ioicog vnb t&v avt&v %tvovvrcci, inei bfioicog av td ccvzd r\Qovvzo r) i^ixXivov. si Se td (avzdy StacpoQCog Ktvet naQa zr\v StacpOQav t&v dv%Qconcov , ei6ayotz dv elxozcog %ai %azd zovzo r) ino%r)^ o ti (iev E%a6zov tpaivezai z&v vno%Et(iivcov cog itQog i%d6zr\v

10

SiacpoQuv

i6cog Xeyetv
cog

i)(i&v

Svvccfiivcov , zi

Se %6zt
15

[%azd 8vvcc(iiv\
88 tpr\va6&at. r\zot
zt6iv.

nQog rr\v tpv6iv ov% otcov te ovtcov dnoyaQ na6t totg dv&Qcanotg nt6zev60(iev r)

dXX' ei (iev ncc6tv, %ai ddvvdzotg intietQr\6o(uv %ai rd dvztnei(ieva nccQaSe%6(ie&a' ei Se zt6tv, ei7tdzco6av r)(itv t't6t %qy\ evyxatati&e^&at' 6 (iev yao UXazcovt%bg Xiet ozt nXdtcovt, 6 EntKovQetog Se 'EnmovQco , %ai ol dXXot avaXoycog, %cci ovtcog dvent%Qizcog 6za6tdovzeg av&tg r)(iag

20

89 eig zr\v ino%r\v neQt6zr\6ov6tv.

,
,

6 Se Xiycov ozt zotg nXei6totg et 6vyxcctatid e6d ttt natSaQi&Sig tt nQOoi6etai, ovSevbg Swa(ievov Ttdvzag zovg dv&Qcbnovg ineX&etv %ai SiaXoyi-

6a6&cct zi zotg 7tXei6zotg aoEtfjcet, ivde%0(i.evov zov ev zt6tv

ffryetftv,

25

^f*tg

ovk

rGjttev,

zd

(iev

TtccQ

rj^itv

6%dvta

4 vs LM:
eisdyEX

xe

EAB

EABT (quoque) 11 aixd add. Bekk. 12 15 Kaxd Svvaynv delevi 16 xolg om. M G
|)

20 EniKovQuos a Stephano restitutum praeb. T (Epicurius)

23 ngooiaexai M: tiqoet Paris. suppl. 133: 'EninovQog olexat LEAJB: infert T: nQoaiexat edd. ovSsvbg xcov dv&Qmncov

TIIOTTIIX:E&N

A.

25

... xotg

nXsioGt nQOGsivat xd Ss rjficov xoig noXXoig Gvfifiaivovxa ondvta vnaQystv, cog xovg noXXovg fisv v%b cpaXay-

yicav Saxvofisvovg fir) dXysiv, xtvdg Ss Gnavicog dXysiv, xai ini xcov dXXcov xcov sfinQOG&sv ( 81 sqq.) eiqr^ievcov iStoGvyxQtGtcov xb dvdXoyov. dvayxaiov ovv xai Std xr)v xcov

'Ensi rocoTtcov Ss

StacpoQav siGaysG&at xr)v inoyr\v. cpiXavxoi xivsg ovxsg ol Soyfiaxtxoi cpaGt 8siv

90'

savxovg nQOXQtvstv iv xr) XQtGst xcov TtQayfidxcov, intGxdfis&a fisv oxt axonog iGtiv r) d^icoGtg avxcov {fiSQog yaQ stGt xai avxoi xr)g Stacpcoviag' xal idv
xcov dXXcov dv&QCQTtcov
S

avrovg
xotg

nQOXQivovrsg ovxco
xr)g

xQivcoGt

xd

cpatvofisva,

itQtv

&Q,aG&ai

XQtGecog xb

r\xovfisvov

rr\v xq^Giv intTQsnovrsg), Oficog svbg dv&Qconov xbv Xoyov tGxdvxeg, otov xov naQ avroig ovetQonoXovfievov Gocpov, ini rr\v ino%r\v xaxavxcofiev, xbv
)

GvvaQnd^ovGtv, savcf ovv tva xat ini 91

XQixov
rbv dnb

xr)

xd^et XQonov nQ0%siQt6(is&a. xovxovS

iXiyofisv

StacpoQag xcov aiG&rjGscov. oxt Se StacpSQOvxat al atG&rjGetg nQog dXXr)Xag, nQoSr\Xov. al yovv yQacpai xr) 92 (tev otyst SoxovGtv siGoyag xai i^oyjdg s%stv, ov (ir)v xai
xr)g
xr\
>

xb fisXt rr\ fisv yXcoxxt] r)Sv cpaivsxai ini dcp&aXfioig drjSsg' dSvvarov ovv iGxtv sinsiv norSQOV r)Sv iGxtv siXtXQtvcog r) drjSsg. xai ini xov fivQOV Ofioicog' xr)v fisv yaQ oGcpQrjGtv svcpQaivst, xr)v Ss ysvGtv
dcpr\.

xai

xtvcov, xoig S

dr\dist.

xo
xco

xs

svcpOQtov insi xotg fisv ocp&aXfioig XvnrjdXXco

Gcofiaxt

95-

qov iGxt
)

Ss

navxi dXvnov,

ov%

sl^Ofiev

einsiv,

ini

noxsQOv aXvnov iGrtv siXtxQtvcog xotg GcofiaGtv oGov savxov cpvGst r) Xvnr\Qov. xo xs bft^Qtov vScoq ocp&aXfioig fisv iGnv cocpsXtfiov, aQrrjQtav Se xai nvsvfiova
xrj

<

xa&dnsQ xai xb sXatov, xaixot xr)v intcpdvstav naQrjyoQovv. xai r) daXaxxia vaQxrj xoig fisv axQOtg nQoGxs&siGa vaQxav notsi, xco S aXXco Gcofiart dXvncog naQaXQayyvst,

9099:

cf.

Diog. Laert. IX 81.

||

inl

31 avayxatcov L Sta MEAB r aXysiv om. T 6 xb grjTOVfiEvov T (quod queritur subripiunt) rd cpat10 nqo%siQ. ML (cf. p. 115, 1 e, 7 iva om. vofisva G edd.

29 ttvdg

a.):

iy%.

yofisv

EAB edd. proponimus T $' GT (autem dicimus) cf. p. 33, 5

:
||

iXiyofisv Diels:

Sh Xi-

26
Ti&STCCL.

IITPP&NEI&N
StOTtSQ

OTtOLOV

(ISV

i6TL TtQOg

X7}V CfV6lV SKCC6T0V

ov% i%0(isv Xiysiv , bnoiov Ss cpccivsTca sku6tots $i Svvcctov sinsiv. xccl aXXa Ss TtXsico tovtcov svs6tl Xsystv'
tovtcov
dXX*
Tfjg
ivtt (ir\

dtaTQi(icd(isv,

Sid Tr\v 7tQ0&s6LV [tov tqojzov]

skcc6tov

6vyyQcccpf\g
,

SKsivo Xsktsov.

t&v

cpccLvo(isvoov

ai6d r\T&v tiolklXov vitOTtlnTSLV SoKsi, olov to (if\Xov Xslov sv&Ssg yXvKv ^ccv&ov. ur\Xov ovv ttotsqov %ots TavTccg (lovccg ovToog sysL rdg TtOLOTrrrttg, r) uovoTtOLOv usv
r\uiv

S6TLV, TtaQCC Sh Tr\V SldcpOQOV KttTCC6KSVr\V

SicccpOQOv cpatvsTai,
r)

T&V

CCL6&r\T t\QLCOV

kccl

35

s%st TtoioTrjTccg, r\(iiv S' LiovoTtoiov (isv yccQ slvca TOVTO SvSiySTCCL Xoyis6&ca

nXsiovag usv t&v cpcavousvoov ov% vTto%LitTov6L TLVsg avr&v.

SK

T&V

s'(i7tQ06&sv r\(iLV SLQr\(iivcov ( 53) kccl tov vSccTog tov sig tcc SsvSqcc (icctcc dvaSiSouivrjg TQO<pf\g dvaSiSousvov xccl tov TtvsvuccTog rov [ei>] ccvXoig kccl 6vQLy%L
Kccl

TtSQL rf\g sig tcc 6co-

Toig

itaQccnXr\6ioLg

yttQ Kttl to uf\Xov

OQydvoig (su7tvso(iivovy' Svvcctccl uovosiSsg (isv slvcci, SidcpoQov Ss ftscoQsi-

6&CCL

TtCCQtt
r\

Tr\V

SLCCCpOQCCV

T&V

aied-TjTrjQLCOV TtSQL

CC

yLVSTttL

S6 ccvtov

dvTiXr\ipLg.

rtXsiovag
(ifjXoV

Sh t&v

TtOLOTrjTCOV

SJSLV TO

ItOLOTrjTttg

r\uiv SvVCC6&ttl OVTCOg STtL-

cpaivousvoov

XoyL^ous&a.
Kccl

svvor\6co(isv tlvcc sk ysvsTr\g dcpr\v usv SfOVTa o6(pQr\6iv Kccl ysv6iV) (ir\TS Ss ukovovtcc (ii\ts oq&vtcc.
VTtoXrjipsTccL (ir\TS oqcctov tl sIvccl Tr\v aQ%r\v ttK0v6T0v, dXXd uovcc skslvcc Ttt TQicc ysvrj t&v rtoiokccl r\uccg

o&Tog Toivvv
(irjTS

D7

Tr\Tcov vitttQySLV cov dvTLXa(i(5dvs6&ai Svvcctccl.

ovv

svSsysTccL

Tttg

nsvTS uovccg aie&^stg sypvTag (iovov dvTiSK

Xuilpdvse&CCL)
ttVTLXrjTtTLKoi'

T&V TtSQl TO (lf\X0V TtOLOTrjTCOV, COV S6(ISV V7tOKSi6&CCL Ss ttXXttg OLOV TS S6TL TtOLOTrjTCCg,

v7tojtL7tTOv6ag STSQOLg tti6Q"r\Tr\QioLg^ cbv rj(istg ov (iSTS6yr\T&V KCCT CCVTttg CCL6&r\KCCLISV, Sl6 OvSk dvTlXttLLfiaVOLlS&CC

98 t&v.

dXX

r\

cpv6Lg

6vvs(isTQr\6aT0,

cpr\6SL

rtg,

Tag

cci6&r\-

6sig 7tQog

Ttt ai6&r\Ttt.

Ttoia cpv6ig, Sicccpcoviag T06avTr\g

dv-

27 bnolov

28 XiysLv om. M
L:

29

t. vq.
i-xei

delevi
ovtoag

32

ttots

om. T
%%tiv
delevi

33

(lovccg fivrcog fysL

(Lovccg

M:

EAB:
8

solas vere
e

ipsum habere

(ibv

om.

EAB

(lovccg

7 iv

i(iitv. rest.

dicccpoQug

EAB

(aspiratione) coll. p. 14, 10.

10 rdg

12 to

(ifjXov

om.

EAB

TnoTTn&2EaN
,
!5

a.

27

sniKQivov

tg,

mxQa rotg oy(xartKOig ovGr\g negi rJjg vnaQ^scog Kax avxf)v\ 6 yaQ sntKQivcov avxb xovxo ei sGxt cpv6i (xsv idtooxrjg strj, dntGxog sGxat Kax avxovg, q)tX699

Nljg oq>og
jo

Ss cbv (xsQog sGrat rf)g dtacpcoviag Kai KQtv6(xsvog avxbg dXX ov KQtrf)g. nXf)v dXX (siy svsycoQSt Kai xavxag (xovag vnoKStG&at naQcc xco (if)Xco xag noioxrjxag cov dvxiXafxfidvsG&at Sokov(xsv, %ai nXsiovg rovrcov, r) ndhv (irjds xdg r](ilv vnontnrovGag , adrjXov r)(xtv eGxai bnotov sGxt
6 ds avxbg Kai eni x&v dXXcov aiG&rjx&v X6xb (xrjlov. yog. rcov aiG&rJGecov (isvrot (xr\ KaraXa(xavovG&v rd SKrog,

ovSe

ivrrjV rcov bb*r\ycovy coGxe Kai 8td

dtdvota ravra dvvarat KaraXafifidveiv, (GcpaXXovG&v xovxov xbv Xoyov r) ne^i SKxbg vnoKst(xsvcov snoyjr) GvvdysG&at 661-si. "Iva ds Kai sni (xtcig SKaGxr\g aiG&rjascog tGxdvxsg xbv 100
r)

'ov,

r)

Kai dcpiGxdfievoi xcov

eGxt cV

aiG&f^Gecov,

eyco(xev

Kaxa-

r\yetv eig xf)v enoyrjv, naQaXa(x(5dvo(xev

Kai rbv

xexaQxov

ovxog 6 naQa xdg nsQtGraGstg Kaftscov(xevog, nsQiGraGsig Xsyovrcov r)(x&v rdg StafteGetg. QSiG&ai 8 avrov cpafxev ev roo Kard cpvGiv r) naQa cpvGiv
\6nov
avxf\g.

(eyetvy, sv rco syQrjyoQSvai r) Ka&evSetv, naQa xdg r\XtKiag, naQa xb ntvetG&at r) r\Qe(xeiv, naQa xb (itGeiv r) cptXstv, naQa
xb svSsstg sivat r) KSKOQSG(xivovg, naQa xb (xs&vstv r) vf)q>stv, naQa xag nQodta&sGstg, naQa xb ftaQQStv r) dsdtsvat, [rf\ naQa xb XvnstG&at r) yatQStv. olov naQa (xsv xb Kaxa 101 cpvGtv r) naQa cpvGtv systv dv6(iota vnoninxst xd nQay(xara, snsi oi (isv cpQSvtri^ovteg Kai oi ftsocpOQOVfxsvot Sat(x6vcov aKOvstv doKOvGtv, r)(xstg 6s ov. bfioicog 6s dnocpOQag Gtv-

15

QaKog

r)

Xtftavcorov

r)

rtvog rotovrov

Kai aXXcov nXstovcov

100117: Diog. Laert. IX

:

82. Philo

de ebr. 178 sqq.

29 si Gen. T (verum etiamsi) om. G cf. p. 6, 4. 30 (iovag Bekk. nXtiovag GT (plures): ndaag Stephanus (omnes) 31 rj xal TtXeiovg Kayser 32 rdg f)(iZv om. iart om. EAB 1 suppl. e T (ductoribus 33/1 ante Xoyog inser. i](ilv M, 6L eum fallentibus) cf. p. 30, 11 5 atdvrsg Gen. Fabr. 6/7 xa11 %%ziv addidi coll. p. 24, 16. 14 r) a Bekkero raXXayfjv L del. om. T 18 anb qiOQ&g EAB 17 fteocpQOVQOv(ivot L Gen. Fabr.: odorem T
:

||

28

IITPP&NEI&N
2.

dvriXafifSdve6&at noXXdxtg Xiyov6tv y r)fi&v fir) xai to avrb v"8coq cpXeyfiaivov6t fiev ronotg intfiivcov. yv&ev e6rbv elvai 8oxei, rjfiiv 8e yXtaQov. xai rb avxb
fiev vno6cpayfia eypv6t cpaivexat xiqqov, ifioi xai xb avxb fiiXt ifiol fiev cpaiverai yXvxv, xotg 102 8e ixreQtxoig ntXQov. ei 8i xtg Xiyet oxt ^vjiirov xtvcov naQa-

atcn^avo-

ifidrtov 8e ov.

roig

21

nXoxr) dvotxeiovg cpavxa6iag ix

r&v vnoxetfiivcov notei

xotg

naQcc cpv6tv eypv6tv, Xexriov oxt inet xai

oi vyiaivovxeg yvfiovg eypv6tv dvaxexQafiivovg, Svvavxat ofixot xd ixrbg

vnoxeifieva

xotavxa ovxa

xr)

cpv6et

bnoia cpaiverai roig

3<

103 vytaivov6tv.

cpv6tv eyetv Xeyofiivotg, exeQOta cpaive6%at notetv xotg xb yaQ ixeivotg fiev xoig yyfioig fierafiXr}rtxr)v r&v vnoxetfiivcov 8t86vat dvvafitv, xovxotg 8e fif), nXa6fiaxtxov i6xtv, enei xai &6neQ oi vytaivovxeg xaxd

naQa

cpv6tv
xrjv
fiev

x&v vytatvovxcov e%ov6t, naQa cpv6tv 8h x&v V060VVXC0V) oftxco xat oi vo6ovvxeg naQa cpv6tv eypv6t xr)v x&v vytatvovxcov, xaxd cpv6tv 8e xr)v x&v
fiev

xr)v

vo6ovvxcov , &6xe xdxeivotg nQog

xi

xaxd cpv6tv eypv6t nt-

104 6xevriov.

naQa

Se xb

vnvovv

r)

iyQrjyoQivat dtdcpoQot yi-

cag xatf vnvovg cpavxa^ofie&a, ov cpavxa6fie&a iyQrjyoQOxeg , ov8e &g cpavxa^Ofiefta iyQrjyoQoxeg, xai xaxd xovg vnvovg cpavxa&fie&a, &6xe elvat

vovxat cpavxa6tat, inei

yivexat ov% dnX&g dXXd nQog rt' vnvovg r) n^bg iyQf]yoQ6tv. eixoxcog ovv xatf ftnvovg OQ&fiev xavxa d i6xtv dvvnaQxxa iv xcp iyQr\-

avxatg

r)

(ir)

elvat

10

nQog yaQ xb xatf

ov\x iv X&] xa&dnat- dvvnaQxra ovra' e6rt xatf flnvovg, &6neQ rd ftncxQ e6xtv xdv fir\ r\ xa& yaQ 105 ftnvovg. naQa 8e rdg fjXtxiag, ori 6 avrbg dr}Q roig fiev yiQov6t ipvxQog elvat 8oxei roig 8e dxfidov6tv evxQarog,
yOQivat,

15

23 xtQQOv Fabr.: xoqqov G 25 Xiyot T (dicat) rtvcov om. L 31 ftera29 rjj cpvoet G cf. p. 39, 10: cpv6st edd. 5 fyovxeg EAB 9 (rby elvat fidXXet post xvfiolg add. ci.: quare esse et non esse fit eis T 10 aitalg Apelt: avtotg G 11 iyQrjyoQ6tv <^yivtat~y Pappenheim 12 dvvitaQxtu iv tw iyQ. MLT (que sunt non existentiam in devigilando) sic iv tcp om: EAB: iv tcp iyQ. av. edd. 13 iv tco delevi: ov xal tb xad". Diels coll. p. 565,16 15 ott T (quia) edd. ht G||

TnOTTn&ZEN
i

A.

29

xb

avxb
xoig

vexat
avxr)
o

%Q(Q[i<x xoig fiev nQE6vxiQ0tg dfiavQOV q>aiSe dxfidov6t xaxaxoQig , xai qpcovn Sfioicog r)

xai

xoig fiev dfiavQa Soxei xvyydvetv xoig S iaxov6xog. nccQa xdg aiQE6eig Se xai cpvydg dvofioicog xtvovvxat 106

oi xaig r)Xtxiaig

6q>atQat 'xai
ccXXcc

StacpiQovxeg' nat6i fiev yao, ei xvyot, xqoyoi Std 6novSf)g fifftv, oi dxfid^ovxeg Se aiQOVvxat. xai aXXa oi yiqovxeg. itj mv 6vvdyexat

StdcpoQOt yivovxat cpavxa6iat vnb x&v avxcbv vnoxetxai naQu xdg StacpoQOvg r)Xtxiug. nuQu 8e xo xi- 107 vet6&ut r) rjQe(ieiv dvofiotcc cpuivexut xd nQdyfiaxa, enei
oxt
fiivcov

aneQ

e6x&xeg

oQcbfiev

xtvei6&ttt

doxovfiev.
fiev

veta xtveg
o r\8i6xcc

dxQefiovvxa y xccvxa nuQanXiovxeg nccQa 8e xb cptXeiv r) fii6eiv, oxt xqia 108 dno6xQicpovxut xtt& vneQf3oXf)v, xtveg 8e

nQ06cpiQ0vxcct.

Kock

cf.

Nauck

Mel. gr.

b&ev xai 6 MivavdQog (fr. 518 VI 120 Cobet N. L. p. 85.) ecprj

ocq>

otog Se xai xr\v biptv elvat cpaivexat; ov xotovxog yiyovev; otov &r}Qiov.

xb firjdev dStxeiv xai xaXovg rjfiag notei.

*

noXXoi (dhy xai iQcofiivag ui6yQug eyovxeg ojQutoxdxag avxug s^vat Soxov6tv. nctQa Se xb netvfjv r) xexoQi6&at, bxt xb 109
ccvxb e'Se6ficc xoig
fiev

netvG>6tv

8e xexoQe6fiivotg
5

dr\Sig.

nuQU

r]St6xov eivat Soxei^ xoig Se xb fie&vetv r) V7jgpsiv,

oxt

uneQ

vf)q>ovxeg

ccieyQU

elvcct

fie&vov6tv
6etg,

ovx at6yQu q>aivexat.

naQu

Soxovfiev, xavxa r\fiiv Se xdg nQoStcc&i- 110

bxt 6 ccvxbg olvog

q>ayov6tv b^mSrjg q>aivexcct,

nQ06eveyxccfiivotg
o

xoig fiev q>oivtxccg r) xoig Se xdqva etvat

i6yd8ag nqor)

iQefiiv&ovg

f)Svg

Soxei, xui

r)

xov (iaXaveiov

naQtt6xdg xovg rovg it,i6vxag^

Pei6d-at
r)

fiev
ei

e^co&ev ei6tovxug &eQfittivet , tpvyet 8e ev ccvxfj StaxQifiotev. nccQa Se xb q>o- 111

bxt

d-aQQeiv,

xb

ccvxb

nQccyficc

xco

fdv
xd

SetXcb

q>Of3eQOv xai Seivbv elvcct Soxei, (icog. naQtt Se xb Xvnei6&ttt

xco ftaQQaXecoxiQco
r)

Se ovSa-

yaiQetv,

oxt

avxu

17 %qco(icc coll. p. 58, 28.

sed addit

Bekk. /Spdjfic: 27 nXiovxes

:

etc. (cf. p. XI) (etiam et) fyovxts om. T Soxei om. T 14 iteoi dh rov
||

v. 34 om. T (navigantes) 1 dh quod iam Bekk. ci. addit 9 elvat 4 negl EAB 8 yivsrat

GT T

(cibus)

24 dnb Pappenh.

EAB

30

IITPP&NEI&N

rtQayfiaxa xotg (iev Xvrtov(iivotg icxiv irtay&r) xotg 8e yai-

112 QovGtv r\8ia. Toeavxr\g ovv ovGr\g dvcofiaXiag %ai rta-v oa xdg 8ia&iceig, Kai aXXoxs aXXcog iv xatg Sta&i6ect xtov vrtodv&Qconcov ytvo(iivcov, brtoiov (ikv eKaGxov x&v
Ket(iivcov

eKaGxco
ovxixt,

Ss

eGxtv
6

cpaivexat QaStov tGcog sinslv^ inei xal dveniKQtxog iextv

bnoiov
r\

dvco-

(iccXicc. yaQ intKQivcov xavxr\v r)xot ev xtct xcov 7tQoeiQr\icxl Sta(livcov Sta&icecov icxtv r) iv ovSe(ita xb itaQaitav xb (iev ovv Xiyetv oxt iv ovSefita Sta&icet xb Cvvofticet.

Xov icxw, olov ovxe vytaivet ovxs vocei, ovxs xtveixat ovxs
ovxe sv xivi rjXtnia icxiv, drtr)XXaKxai Se xal xcov aXXcov Sta&icecov, xsXicog drteficpaivet. si 8e sv.. xtvt Stafticet 113 cov KQtvei xag cpavxadag, (liQog sGxai xr\g Stacpcoviag, Kai
rjQSfisl,

dXXcog ovk eiXtKQtvr\g xcov ixxbg vrtOKetfiivcov ecxat %Qtxr\g Std xb xs&oX&G&at xatg Sta&icsGtv iv alg scxtv ovxs ovv 6
'

iyQrjyoQcog Svvaxat GvyxQivstv xag xcov Ka&svSovxcov cpavxadag xatg xcov iyQTjyOQOXcov^ ovxs 6 vytaivcov xdg xcov vocovvxcov xatg xcov vytatvovxcov'
r)(iag

xoig yccQ TtaQOVGt Kai KtvovGtv

r)

xaxd xb TtaQov Gvyxaxaxt&ifis^a (taXXov

Kai aXXcog 8e avsTtixQtxog icxtv
b
yccQ
r)

xotg

(ir\

114 7taQ0vGtv.

x&v xotovxc

cpavxadcov dvco(iaXia.

nQOKQivcov cpavxadav cpa\

xadag

v.ai

TtSQicxaCtv TtSQtGxdcscog r\xot aKQixcog Kai dvsv

r)

dnodeil-ecog xovxo Ttotei

KQivcov Kai drtoSetKvvg. dXX' ovxe

dvsv xovxcov (drttCxog yaQ sGxat), ovxs Gvv xovxotg. si yaQ 115 kqivsI xdg cpavxadag, Ttdvxcog KQtxrjQico KQtvsi. xovxo ovv xb KQtxr\Qtov rjxot dXrjd-sg slvat Xit),st r) tyevSig. dXX si
(isv ipevSig; Gst) r\xot

drttcxog scxat.

si

dvsv
(isxa

d7to8sil-scog Xii-st
a7to8sii-scog.

Se dXrj&eg slvat xovxo cpr)oxt dXr\&ig icxt xb KQtxf)si

(isv

otov,

r)

Kai

dvsv

d7to8sil-ecog,

aTttCxog scxat'
xr\v

dnoSst^tv

(isxd d7to8siscog , Ttdvxcog 8sr)cst Kai dXrj&rj dXrj&r\ elvat, inei antCxog ecxat.
si

81

16/17

tcsqI

18 21

dXXcog loxtv om. iaxl G (erit)

:

MLT
om.

EABT (circa)
(aliter)
cf.

18

xccl

SXXoxe
ebr.

19
176:

24 to 33 xulg T

25
(hiis

Philo de
yctvetxai

(ihv om. ctXXcov

EAB EAB
G
:

om.

EAB
:

29 Uxat T
v.a.1

7 ndvxcog

que sanorum sunt)

xdg

||

ccniexov

GT
sl

ycgtvei KQtxnQtco

EAB

(incredibile)

11

LMT

10 XQet
6

11

EAB

9
fierd

&7tttsxog

Bekk. ajtoSei^ecog om.

(si):

EAB

TII0TTn2EN
ovv
5

A.

31
xov
r)

Xisi

xr)v

dnbSsLJ-LV

xr)v

sig

ni6xco6iv
uvxr)v

XQixr}-

qlov Xufx(3uvofiivr)v nbxsQOV xsxQixcog

fir)

xexqlXQivccg,
r}xr)6or)

xwg; si fisv yuQ fir) XQivag, dnL6xog s6xtti, si 8s 8f Xov oxi XQixrjQia cpr\6SL xsxQixivcci, ov XQixrjQiov
t

116~-

fisv

dnbSsL&v , xaxsivrjg
XQLxr\Qiov, ivu

XQixr)QLOV.

%Qrfesi

yaQ dsi xal

tt7t6si,ig ftsfittLco&ri, xal xb xqlxtjqlov dnoSsit^scog, ivcc dXrj&sg slvai 8sL%&r)' xccl ovxs dnbSsL^ig vytr)g sivai Svvuxul fir) nQovnuQ%ovxog xQLxr\Qiov dXrj&ovg, ovxs

XQixrjQiov dkrj&sg
oftxcog

xui 117 (ir) nQonsni6xcofiivr\g xrjg dnoSsi^scog. sfininxovGLv sig xbv SLuXXrjXov xQonov xb xs XQLxr)qlov xai r) dnbSsi^ig, sv co dficpbxSQtt EVQi6xsxui unL6xa'

sxdxEQOV yaQ

xr\v

ftaxiQov
si

itioxiv
fif)xs

nsQLfiivov

bfioicog

xco

Xomcp s6xlv

avsv dnoSsi^scog (xal} XQixtjQiov fir)xs Gvv xovxoig Svvuxui xig nQOXQivuL cpavxaGiav cpuvxu6iug, dvsrtixQixoi eGovxul ai nuQu xdg SiucpoQOvg
ttTtiGxov.

ovv

diad-iosLg
i)

didcpoQOi

TtsQL

xr)g cpvGscog

yivbfisvai cpuvxu6Lui, coGxs siedysxccL xcov sxxbg vnoxsifiivcov ino%r\ xcci ogov

inl xovxco xco xQonco.

egxl Xbyog 6 nccQa xdg &i6Lg xal xd 8iu6xr\- 118 xovg xbnovg' xul yuQ nccQU xovxcov sxcc6xov rd uvxu nQttyfiuxa SLucpOQa cpuivExui, olov r) ccvxr) 6xou dnb

Ilifinxog

ucxxu xal

fisv xf g sxiQug UQ%f\g OQCofiivr) fisiovQog cpaivsxtti, dnb Ss xov fiieov 6vfifisxQog nuvxo%sv, xccl xb aixb nXotov noQQCOt

#v

fisv fiiXQov
xccl

xivovfisvov,

cpuivsxuL xccl s6xcog, syyvdsv 8h fiiycc xccl o ccvxbg nvQyog noQQCo&sv (uv cpaivsxccL

GxQoyyvXog iyyv&sv 8s xsxQuycovog. xccvxcc fisv nccQu xd Slu- 119* 6xr)fiaxa, nccQtt Ss tovg xbnovg oxi xb Xv%vlcclov cpcog iv
o TjXico
fisv dfiuvQov cpaivsxttL sv 6xbxco Ss XccfinQOV, xcci r) uvxr) xcont] svccXog fisv xsxXa6fiivr\ E%ccXog 8e sv&elcc, xai xb cobv iv fisv xf) oqvl&l dnuXbv iv diQL 8s 6xXr]Q0V, xcci

xb XvyyovQLOv iv fisv Xvyyi vyQov sv diQL Se 6xXr\Q0v,

xcci

118123
14 elg Stephanus

cf.

Diog. Laert.

1X8586. Philo de ebr. 181 sqq.

L edd. 20 xul lvu EAB * 26 xul add. 30 nsgl EABT (de): nuQu LM xul om. T beov MT (quantum): bg LEAB: ibg Gen., del. Kayser 4 LLeLovgog A: 13 XvvyovQLov et Xvvyi LM 10 ulluvqco L (vvovgog LMEB
<ttjj>>
|| ||

32
xb

IITPP&NEI&N
xoQuXtov iv &aXciTTr) fiev dnaXbv iv uioi Se 6xXr)Q0v, cpcovr) dXXoiu fiev cpuiveTut iv 6vQtyyt ytvofiivr), dXXoiu
nuQcc Se Tug ftioeig
eixcov

xai

120 Se iv uvXco, dXXoiu Se iv aioc unXcog.

oti

f) avTr) QvnTtu&fiivr) fiev Xeia cpuiveTut, no6cog Se intvevofiivr) eieoyug xui it,oyag syetv Soxei. xai oi Tocfy^Xot 8e tcov neQtSTeQwv nuQu Tug StucpoQOvg intxXioetg Stu-

121 cpOQOt cpuivovTut xutcc %Qtofiu. inei ovv nccvTu tu cpatvofieva ev Ttvt decoQetTut xui dno Ttvog Stu6Tf)fiuTog xui xutu Ttva
&i6tv, cov exu6Tov noXXf)v notei nuQuXXuyf)v ne^i Tug cpuvTu6iag, cog vne(ivf)6ufiev ( 118sqq.), dvuyxu6d r)6ofied u xui Stcc tovtov tov TQOTtov xutuvtuv eig inoyr\v. xui yu.Q 8 (iovXofievog tovtcov tcov cpuvTu6tcov nQOXQivetv Ttvug dSv, ,

122 vuTotg intyetQi]6et.

notr\6eTut
Tr\v

ei fiev yccQ

unX&g xui uvev dnoSei^ecog

ei

dnocpu6tv,

ant6Tog e6Tut'
ipevSf)

8e

dnodeiijet

\3ovXr\6eTut ^oijffacJOm,
elvut,

ei fiev

Xi^et Tr)v unoSeitltv

euvTov

neQtrQitfjet,

aXrj&r)

Se Xiycov elvat ttjv dno-

amj^hjc/fTat dn68ettv tov dXrj&f) avTr\v elvut, xdxeivr\g uXXrjv, inei xui uvTf)v dXrj&r) elvut Sei, xui fii%Qtg dSvvuTov Si e6Ttv dneiQOvg dnoSeit),eig nuQudneiQov.
Setiv

123 6Tf 6ut'

t

vetv
firjTe

fiexu dnoSei^ecog 8vvf)6eTut nQOXQicpuvTu6iuv cpuvTu6iug. ei Se fir)Te ccvev dnoSeiS,ecog fieTu dnoSeitjecog SvvuTog e6Tut Tig intXQivetv xug

ovxovv ovSe

nQoetQrjfiivug

cpuvm6iug, 6vvuyeTut r) inoyr\, onotov fiev cpuiveTut %xu6tov xutu Tr)v8e xr)v &i6tv r) xutcc t68s t6 8tu6Tr)fiu r) iv TcoSe eineiv i'6cog Svvufiivcov rjficov, bnoiov
Si i6Ttv cog n^bg Tr)v Stu tu nQoetQrjfiiva.
cpv6tv uSvvutovvtcov dnocpuive6&ut
b

124

"ExTog

i6Ti

TQonog
inei
cf.

nuQu Tug

intfityug,

xutf ov

6vvuyofiev oti,

firjSev tcov

vnoxetfievcov

%u&

euvTo

124128: 189 sqq.

Diog. Laert.

IX 8486.

Philo de ebr.

15 yivszut
ter Bekk.,
(circa)
:

at

24 xovrov xov tgonov Bekk. rovtovg rovg TQonovg GT (hos modos) 28 flovXri&riGsxui A 30 avxbv L 31 dsl MLT (oportet) Soxs rE AB 1 iertv T (est) Uxai G nsQtaxf)6ai E AB
TtuQcc
:
:

ML

cf. p. 29,

(sicut p. 26, 8) 7 xal alt.

||

21 xonco post

ttvt dubitan-

GT:

f)

edd.

22 negl

EABT

||

7 xcods

(xco

iavxb

r)fiiv

MEBAT

Tonwy dub. Bekk.

(secundum

at

cf.

p. 28, 21.

11

xa&'

se ipsum):

avtb

f)fitv

TII0TTII&2E&N
.
r)(iiv
(liyttcc

A.

33
(tiv

vnoninxst
bItiuv

dXXd

6vv

xivt,
co

bnoiov

i6xt

to

avvd-ewQeixai xdya bnoiov Se i6xt xb ixrbg vnoxeifievov eiXtKQLv&g ovx av e'ypt(iev Xeyetv. on Se ovSev rcov ixrbg xatf avxb vnoninxei aXXa ndvxcog avv rtvt, xai oxi

sx xs xov ixxbg xai xov

,

Sv-

vaxbv

naoa xovxo dXXoiov

&scoQsixaL, nQo8r\Xov, oii.ua. xb yovv 125 r)uixsQOv %Q&(icc dXXoiov usv oQuxat iv aXeeivdy aiot, dXXoiov 8e iv [t<5] tyv%Qco, xai ovx dv s%OLuev sinsiv bnoiov s6xl xfj cpv6ei xb %Qcoua r)ucov, dXX dnoiov 6vv ixa6xco

xovxcov decoQEixai. xai r) avxrj cpcovr) dXXoia (iev cpaivExat 6vv Xenxco dsQi, dXXoia 8e 6vv ncc%v(iQi, xai xd aQcbuaxa iv fiaXaveta xai r)Xico nXrjxxLXcbxsQa (iccXXov i6xtv r) iv dsQt

xaravjv%Qco ,
i

xal

xb

6co(ia

vnb vdaxog

(iev

nsQLS%6(isvov

iva 8e xal rr)g e,co&ev 126 xovcpov iextv, fiaQV. inL(uiag dno6xcousv , oi ocp&ccXuoi rjucov s%ov6lv iv iavxd ovv OQard inei (xr) avev xoig xai %trcovag xat vyQci.
rovxcov
ftecoQeixai^

vnb 8e deQog

ov

xaxaXrjcp&rj^exat

n^bg

dxQifistav'

xov yaQ (ityfiaxog dvxiXau@av6(id-a, xal 8td xovxo oi uev vno6cpay(ia eypvxsg ixxeQLXol ndvxa co%qu 6qco6lv, oi 8
ftcpaiua.

xal inel

r)

cpcovr)

r)

ccvxr)

dXXoia (iev cpaivexat iv

>

dvanenxafievoig xonoig, dXXoia 8e iv 6xevoig xal eXlxoi8s6l, xal dXXoia fiev iv xa&aQco asoi, dXXoia Ss iv xe&oXcofievcpy
sixog i6rt
vr)g'
(ir)

dvxLXa(i(5dvs6d aL
,

r)(iag

eiXiXQivcog

xr)g

cpco-

xd yaQ coxa 6xoXi6noQa i6rt xal 6xev6noQa xal

di(ito-

>

8e6lv dnocpoQf)6E6LV, cct Sr) dnb xcov nEQt xtjv XEcpaXr)v cpiQS6&at Xiyovxat xoncov, x%oXcouiva. dXXd xai iv xoig 127 vXcov vnoxi(ii(ivh,corr)Q6t xai iv xoig xr)g yv6Ecog xonotg
vojv,
(ix

ixEtvcov

dvxLXa(i(iav6(i&tt xcov ysv6xcov xai xcov

6ffqco?jTv, dXX'

ai6&r)6ELg
)

&6xe 8id xag inLfiL^iag ai EiXixQLVcog. ovx dvxtXa(ifidvovxat bnoia nQog dxQipEtav xd

ovx

ixxbg vnoxt(ivd i6xiv.

dXX' ov8s

r)

8tdvota,

insi ai b8rjyoi ccvxrjg ccie&rjasig acpdXXovxat' avxrj int(tt\iav xtvd iSiav notsixat

(idXL6xa (isv 128 i'6cog 8s xai

xcov cci6&r)-

nQog xd vnb

18 et 19 6vv T (cum) 19 iv r)(iLv edd. 4 dia(poQr\6t6tv rcadelevi: iv yLaxatyv%Qta Bekk. dub. 5 xonav glossema? 6 %vu&v Kayser productionibus T 4 al 11 sensus ductores eius fallunt T (vide p. 24,2) (cf. v. 14)
12 avzb post
||

om.EAB

Sextus Empiricus

34

IITPP&NEI&N

Gecov avayyeXXbfieva' neoi ycco exaGxov xcov xoncov iv olg %6 r\ye(iovtxbv elvai 6oxo vGtv oi doy(iaxtxoi, ^vfiovg xtvag vnoxetfiivovg &ecoQOV(Uv, etxe neol iyxecpaXov etxe iteol

xaodlav etxe neqi 6xt8r\noxe ovv fieoog xov coov xovxo xi&eG&at fiovXotxo xig. xai xaxd xovxov ovv xbv XQonov OQcofieV) 0x1 neqi xfjg cpvGecog xcov ixxbg vnoxet(ievcov ovdev
129
eineiv e^ovxeg ini^etv avayxa&fie&a. "Efto(iov xQoitov iXeyo(iev elvat xbv

naQu

xccg

noGo-

xtjxag xai GxevaGiag xcov vnoxetfievcov, Gxevaoiag Xeyovxeg xoiv&g xccg Gvv&iGetg. oxt 6e xa\ xaxa xovxov xbv xqo-

nov ineyetv dvayxa6(ie&a neqi

twv, drjkov.
cpaivexai
(ieva,

xfjg

cpvGecog

xcov itQayjia-

oiov yovv

xcc

%eG(iaxa xov xeQuxog xr)g aiybg

(iev Xevxd unXcog xal avev Gvv&iGecog &ecoQOvGvvxt&e(ievu 8e iv xfj xov xeQuxog vndQtjet (jteXuva decoQeixai. xal xov aQyxiQOv \xcc (ieQr\\ xa Qivr)(iaxa xax idiuv (iev bvxa (liXava cpaivexat, Gvv 6e xco oXco cog Xevxcc

130 vnoninxet.
OQccxat

xui xrjg TatvaQeiag Xi&ov xcc (iev (ieQr\ Xevxcc oxav Xeuv&fj, Gvv 6e xf\ 6XoG%eQet i-av&cc cpaivexat.
uXXr\Xcov iGxedaGfievat ipd(i(iot XQu%etut cpaivovGcoQOg de Gvvxe&etGut dnaXcog xtvovGt xr\v utG&rj-

xal al
xut,
cog

un

Gtv. xal 6 iXXefioQog Xenxbg (iev xal yyocb8r\g TtQOGcpeQo131 (ievog nvtyfibv intcpiQSt, XQt(jtvc66r\g 6e cov ovxixt. xal 6 olvog Gv(i(iexQog (iev ntvbfievog qcovvvGtv r)(i&g, nXeicov Se

Xa(ifiav6(ievog
Gicog

nuQuXvet xb

Gco(iu.

xai

r\

XQOcpf\

nuQunXr\-

naQcc xf\v noGoxr\xu dtdcpoQOV intSeixvvxat 6vvu(itv' noXXdxtg yovv dtcc xb noXXr\ nQOGevei&fjvut xa&aiqet xb

132 Gcofxa Std xe anetytcov xai %oXeQtxcov na&cov. xcivxav&a Xeyetv bnoiov iGxt xov xeQuxog xb

e%0(iev

ovv

Xenxbv xai

129134: cf. Diog. Laert. IX 86 (hic octavus modus). Philo de ebr. 189 sqq.

13 post e'ua6xov

inser. noisixat

EAB

M.LT (putant
(isgri

GT

esse): h%st. xal bnoiov elvat (jpartes scilicet lineatura): seclusi

:

Sox.

14 elvai Soxovatv EAB 27 xd 28 tb? om. M 29

:

Tatvageiag Gen.
tenarii lapidis

ratvaoiag

om.

1 xQt(ivmSr\g Fabr. xQt(iwSr}g G 5 xa^aiqet GT (purgaf): xa&atQei Fabr.

Taivagtag
:

EAB

Tevagaiag 3 naqanX.
:

TII0TTII&2E&N

A.

35

bnoiov xb ix noXX&v Xenxo(ieQ&v 6vyxeC(ievov, xai bnotog b ix noXX&v (iev Igxiv b [iLXQO[ieQr\g uQyvQog bnoiog Se (iiHQOfieQav 6vyxeC(ievog, xai bnoCa (iev r\ uxaQiaCu TuivaQeCa XC&og bnoCa 6e r\ ix noXX&v (ilxq&v 6vyxei(i&vr\, xai ini x&v tydufiatv xai xov eXXefioQOv xai xov oivov xai xfjg XQOcpfjg xb nQog xi, xr\v uevxoi cpv6iv x&v nQuyudxcov

%a&
i

nuQU xdg 6vv&e6eig x&v cpavxu&oXov yaQ Soxei xai xd cocpeXiuu 133 XvnrjQa ytve6&uL naQu xr\v xaxd no6oxr\xa uuexQOv avx&v x& xatf vneQXQrfiLv, xai xd (iXafieQu eivai doxovvxa iv
eavxrjv ovxexi 8id xr\v

xa6i&v dvcouuXiuv.

fioXrjv

nuQuXuufidvee&ui

uxuqlulu

ur\

Xvneiv.

uuQXVQel

8e xco Xoyco [idXi6xa xb xaxd xdg laxQixdg Svvdueig -foa)Qovuevov, iv alg r) (iev nQog dxQCfieiav uifyg x&v unX&v <paQ(idxcov cocpeXiuov noiei xb 6wxe&ev, Qonf\g Se ^Quyyivioxe naQ0Qad-eC6r]g ov uovov ovx cocpeXiuov dXXd xai XafieQcbxaxov xai Sr\Xr\xr\QLOv noXXdxig. ovxcog b xaxd 134 xdg no6oxr\xag xai 6xeva6Cag Xoyog 6vy%ei~ xr\v x&v ixxbg vnoxeiuevcov vnaQ^LV. SioneQ eixoxcog uv xai ovxog b xqoxdxrjg
.

nog

eig

ino^rjv r\uag
i6xi

neQidyoL

ur\

Svvauevovg eiXLXQLV&g
i

unocpr\vu6&ui ne^i

Tr/g cpv6ecog

"OySoog
}

XQonog b

x&v ixxbg vnoxeiuevcov. dnb xov nQog xi, xu& ov 6v- 135

vdyofiev bxi, inei ndvxa i6xi nQog xi, ne^i xov xiva i6xiv dnoXvxcog xai &g nQog xr\v cpv6iv icpei-ouev. ixelvo 8e iQr\ ( yivco6xeiv oxl ivxuv&u, &6neQ xui iv uXXoig, xco e6xi xaxaXQcbfie&u dvxi xov
xi

ndvxa

cpuCvexuC , Svvduei xovxo Xeyovxeg *nQog xovxo 8e Si%&g XeyexuL, anal- uev cog cpuCvexui.'

'

nQog xb xqlvov (xb yuQ ixxbg vnoxeCuevov xai XQLvbuevov nQog xb xqlvov cpaCvexai), xu& exeQOv 8e XQonov nQog xd Gvv&ecoQOvuevu, &g xb Set-ibv nQog xb UQL6xeQ0V. oxl Se 136

135140:

modus).

cf. Diog. Laert. Philo de ebr. 186 sqq.

LX 8788

(hic

decimus

8 Xstcx&v (tegav Stephanus: subtilibus partibus T 10 (ii13 xQvqjfjg L 19 xQ<bv [isqwv Stephanus: parvis partibus T 21 Q07Cf)g LM: xQocpfjg (ituiy (idXi6xa T (et maxime) 24 evvireL T (continet) 30 aitoXvrcog (absolute): dnX&g

EAB

GT

Gen. Fabr.

KQiveiv

EAB

7r^os

LM: naQu EAB

3*

36
ndvxcc

IITPP&NEI&N

ioxi nQog w, ineXoyvadfte&a fiev xui efMQOO&ev, olov xccxd xb xqivov, bxv Jtobg xods xb coov xcci xovde xbv uv&Qconov xui tf)v8e tr\v uia&rjOvv exaOxov cpaivexuv xai 7tQog xovdvSe neQioxuOvv, xuxd Se xd Ovv&ecoQOvfievu, oxi
TtQog
tf)v8e tr\v

Ovv&eovv xfjvde xai

137 cpaivexuv.

xai

xui xovde xbv xqotxov xai tr\v tr)v noo6xr\xu xui xr\v &iow exaoxov iSia 8e ivSiyjexuv avvdyevv oxv ndvxcc ioti
invfiv^iuv

TtQog rt, tovSe xbv xqotloV noxeQOv Svucpi^ev x&v rtQog xi xd xccxd SvacpOQUV r) o#; si fiev ov SvacpiQev, xai avxd
jtQog xv iaxiv'
xv
ei Se

SvacpiQev,

i7te\

nav
oi)

to SvaqjiQov TtQog

iaxiv

(Xiyetav

yuQ TtQog ixevvo

SvacpiQev),

nQog

xv

138 ioti xd xuxd SvacpOQuv. t&v xe ovtcov xd (iiv iaxvv dvco xdxm yivrj xuxd tovg Soyficctvxovg, xd 8 eOfaxa eX8r\, xd Se yivrj xui eXSrj' ndvxu 8e xavxd iatv TtQog tv' ndvxa uqu
iaxv TtQog
ccSrjXtt,
xv.

etv

t&v ovtcov td

fiiv

iatv

nQo8r}Xa, td

Se

avtoi cpaavv , xai arjfiaivovxa fiev xd cpavvofievu, arjfiuvvofievu Se vnb t&v cpavvofiivcov td uSrjXu' otyvg yuQ a xatavtovg (Anaxag.B21 Diels) x&v dSr)Xcov xd cpavvocog

fievu. to Se Orjfiavvov xav to arjficcvvofievov ioti TtQog tv' TtQog 139 tv uQa ioxi ndvxa. nQog xovxovg t&v bvxcov td fiiv iatvv ofioiu

td 8e dvofiovu xu\ td
tv'

fiev

vou xd Se dvvOcc'

xavxu 8i iaxv

ndvtu uqu ioxi nQog xv. xui 6 Xiycov Se fir] nQog ndvxu elvav nQog xv fieftuvov xb ndvxu elvav nQog xv' xai uvxb ydQ to ndvtu eivccv nQog tv nQog r)fiag elvav Seixwov,
140
xcci

ov xu&6Xov, 8v cov r)fivv ivccvxvovxav. nXrjv dXtf ofixco naQvOxdvxcov rjfi&v oxv ndvxcc ioxi nQog tv, SfjXov iatv Xovnov, otv bnovov eotvv exaotov t&v vnoxevfiivcov xatd tr\v eavtov cpvovv xui eiXvxQiv&g Xiyevv ov SvvrjOOfie&a, dXX
bnovov cpaivetav iv
cpvaecog
tco

nQog

tv.

<^ro^>

dxoXov&ev to ne^i

tfjg

t&v nQayfidtcov 8evv

r)fiag ini%evv.

10 xal xovSe xbv TQOitov del. Kayser: ronov pro xqo-xov Pappenheim xr\v8e xt\v 6vv&. M 15 Svdcpogov EAB 17 xe 29 Ttdvxa elvav LMT (omnia esse): Bekk.: dh GT (autem) elvuv elvav jtdvxa EAB <({atj^ elvav itdvxa Pappenheim 30 (eiy ovxeo SsLy.vv6v MLT (esse ostendit): anbdeiy.vv6v EAB 2 a> add. e T (quod sequitur) axoXov&ev LT: coni. Kayser
|| || || ||

axoXov&evv

MEAB

Sv'

r)(iag

EAB

TnoTxn&EN
, IIeqI
Geig

a.

37

Se xov xaxu xdg 6vv%Lg r) enaviovg 6vyxvQf)- 141 xQonov, 6v Evvaxov iXiyoLisv sivat xrj xdE,t, xoiavxd

xiva SlQlllev. 6 rjktog noXXco Sf)nov ixnXr\xxtxcoxsQog EGxtv u6XQ0g xo(Lf)xov' dXX* insi xbv llev rjXiov GvvEy&g oqcq(lsv, xbv Ss xo(Lf)rrjv dsxEQa 6navicog, ini llsv to5 a6xQt ixnXrj666Li&a co6xe Kal Sto6r](isittv uvxbv sivat Soxsiv,
xco r)Xico ovSaLiobg. iav ixsvxot ys ivvof)6co(isv xbv onavicog (lev cpatv6(ivov, 67tavicog Ss Svollsvov, xai t]Xiov jtdvxa (ihv dd-QOCog cpcoxi^ovxu, ndvxa Se i^aicpvrjg int6xid-

ini

Ss

s6\rcct

notovvxa,
xai
6

7toXXi)v

EKTtXrj^tv

iv

x&

Qf]60(iv.

6t6(ibg

Se

ov% ouoicog

TtQuyixaxt &eco&OQv(}Ei xovg xe 142

jtQcorov

avxov

ysvr\(LSvovg.

nsLQcoLisvovg xai xovg iv s&st xovrov yzno6r\v Ss sxnXrj^tv dv%Qcanca cpsQEt &dXu66u

TtQcorov

6cp&si6a.

dXXu xai xdXXog 6co(iuxog dv&Qconivov

itQ&rov xai i^uicpvrjg &ecoqovllevov 6vyxivi (i&XXov f)(iag q si iv E&st tov 6Qu6&ut yivotxo. xai xu (ikv 6ndvta
xifiiu slvut Soxsi,

xu Ss 6vvxQ0tpa r)(iiv xai svnoQa ovSa- 143 iuv yovv ivvorj6ca(LSv xb vScoq 6naviov, no6co av xcav xtfiicov Etvut Soxovvxcov dndvrcav rtfitcarsQOV r](iiv cpaxbv iqv6ov dnXcag ini xr)g yr)g VEirj. r) idv iv&vbirj&coLiEv
(i&g.

iQQt(L(Lvov

TtoXvv

7tccQtt7tXrj6icog

xoig Xid^otg,

xivt

So^oliev

seE^&ut xovxov

xi(itov
nccQtt

^ xaxdxXL6xov
xug

ovxcog; insi

ovv xd 144

avru 7tQuy(Laxa
6tg

oxe (lev ixnXrjxxtxd r) Soxsi, intXoyt6(i&a oxt bnoiov llev cpaivsxat xovxcov exu-

6vvytg r) 67taviovg nEQtnxcaxi(itcc, oxl Se ov xotavxa Etvat

6xov (lexu 6vvyovg nQtnxco6cog r) 6naviag i'6cog Svvr\66tiE&a XiyEtv, tytXcag Se bnoiov E6xtv excc6xov xcav ixxbg
vnoxt(ivcov ovx i6(LEv Svvaxoi cpa6xtv.

xai Std xovxov

ovv xbv XQonov nEQt avxcov

insyoLisv.

Asxaxog

i6xt XQonog, og xai LidXt6xa 6vvs'j(t

nQog xu 145

141144: cf. Diog. Laert. IX 87, deest apud Philonem. 145163: cf. Diog. Laert. LX 8384 (hic quintus modus) Philo de ebr. 193 sqq. (cf. v. Arnim, Quellenstudien zu Philo v. Al. p. 66).

xal om.

5 iXiyoiisv slvat T (dicebamus esse): alvat X&yoLtsv G 9 T 18 xccl GT: uhv Gen. Fabr. 19 si om. L 27 dh om. EAB 1 7tQos del. Kayser: pertinet ad T

38

IITPP&NEI&N

rj&Lxd, 6 TtuQU rug uycoyug xui ra s&rj xui rovg v6(iovg xai
rccg

(iv&ixug ni6rug xui rug Soyfxarixdg vnoXr)vjsig.

uycoyi)

ovv s6tlv aiqeGig fiiov r) rivog nQuyfiurog nsq\ evu r) noXXovg yivo(jLEvr), olov nsQi Aioyivrjv r) rovg
(ihv

146 Adxcovag'

vofiog Si iGriv EyyQucpog 6vv&r)xr) nuQa roig noXiTEvofiivoig, r)v 6 nuQafiaivcov xoXu^etul, s&og Sh r) 6vvr)&iu (ov diacpsQEi yuQ) noXX&v ccv&qcoitcov xoivr) TtQuyfxurog nvog nuQuSo%r), r)v 6 nuQa/3ag

ov ndvrcog xoXuetul,

olov

vdfiog

E6ri

t6

(ii)

(iol%svelv, s&og Sh rjfiiv rb (ir) Sr)(io6iu yvvuixl (iiyvv6&uL. 147 (xv&ixr) Sh iti6rig s6ri 7tQuy(idrcov dyEvf)rcov rs xai nsnXu6 (isvcov nuQuSo%r), oid s6tlv uXXu rs xui rd Tts^i

rov Kqovov
aysi.

(iv&svofiEvu' ravra yuQ noXXovg slg nl6riv Soyfiurixr) Si e6tlv vn6Xr)tyig nuQudo%r) TtQuy(turog 6V uvuXoyi6(iov r) rvvog unoSsi^ecog xqutv-

VE6&UL S0XOV6U,
148
r)

6(xoio(ieqt) (r))

sXu%i6tu

OIOV OTL UTOfJLU S6TI T&V OVTCOV 6T0iyeLa nvu uXXu. dvriri&EfiEV Se rovr)

TCOV

EXU6T0V OTE (ISV EUVTCp , OTS Sh T&V uXXcOV EXU6ZCp. olov s&og (isv e&el ovrcog' nvhg r&v Ai&ioncov 6riov6i rcc xai ^QEcpr), J)(iEi~g (5' ov' xui IHq6ul (ihv dv&o(iucpi s6&r)Ti

Sh utcqeTtoSrjQEi iQr)6$ai vo(iiov6iv svnQsnhg slvui, r)(jLSLg nig' xui oi (ihv 'ivSoi rulg yvvuii Sr)(io6ia (liyvvvruL, oi Ss 149 7tXsl6roi r&v uXXcov ul6%qov rovro sivai r)yovvrat. vofiov Ss
v6(ico

ovrcog

dvriri&EfiEv'

nuQU

(ihv

rotg

Pcofiuioig 6

rf)g

TtuzQcoug

U7to6rug ov6iug ovx u%oSiSco6i rd

Sh
roig *PoSioig
Ttdvrcog

rov

nurQog
xui
iv

%Qu,
(ihv

TtuQu

dnoSiSco6LV'

TavQOig rfjg 2xv&iug v6(iog r)v rovg 1-ivovg rjj Aqte(iiSi xaXXiEQU^&ai, %uqu Se r)(i.iv uv&QCOTtov uTtsiQTqrai TtQog 150 leqco cpovsvs6&ui. dycoyr)v Ss dycoyf), oruv rr)v Aioysvovg ^ dycoyrjv uvtltl^&liev ry to-O AQL6ri7t7tov r) ri)V r&v Aaxcovcov
rfj

r&v IruX&v.

(iv&LXf)v Ss 7ti6riv 7ti6rsL (iv&Lxf), oruv

OTtOV
7

(ISV

(XiyCOfJLEVy

TOV Aiu (JLV&EVE6&UL TtaTEQU UvSq&V

G 9 6 a coneivibus T {evfntoX.l) 8 r\ T (veT): EAB 18 t) add. T (aut) at cf. Doxogr. gr. p. 812, 4 xovto sIvcxl L: Diels 24 dXXav G: EXXf)vcov T (grecorum) 31 tov sIvul xovro M: bIvul EAB 30 xf)v (tovy EAB om. M 33 Xsycofiev add. T (dicimus) cf. p. 35, 3. 8.
f)

11 Sh bis

||

TnoTxn2EN
I

a.

39

ts ftscov t,

onov 8s xbv 'Qxsavov, Xiyovxsg (& 201)

Ss

'Slxsavov xs Oecov yivsGiv xa\ (irjxiQa Tr\&vv.

'I
'I
I

Soyfiaxixdg
yco(isv

vnoXfjtystg

dXXfjXaig

dvxixi&Sfisv,

oxav Xi- 151

xovg (isv *sv sivai GxoiysLOv dnocpaivsG&ai, xovg Ss urtsioa, %al xovg (isv dvrjXYjV xr\v ipvj^v, xovg Ss d&dvarov, xal xovg (isv nQOVoia &stbv SiOLXsiG&ac xd xad r^fiag^
1

I
1

xovg Ss dnQOvof)xtog.
olov
vofico
ftv,

xb s&og 8s xoig dXXoig dvxixi&sfisv, 152

Xiycofisv

naQa (isv HiQGaig s&og naQa 8s Pcofiaioig ditayoQSvsG&at v6(ico xovxo nQaxxsLv, xal naQ r\(iLV usv xb (sivai I (iol%svsiv dnsiQfjG&ai, naQa 8s MaGGayixaig ^iv^ dSiacpOQtag
OQQSVOfiL^iaig
yQfJGxrai ,
I

oxav

s&st,

naQaSsSoG&ai,

cog

EvSo^og
(pr.

KviStog

lGxoqsl

sv

xco

15 Brandes), xal Ttao' r)uiv usv I dnr\yOQSvG&aL (irjXQaGt (liyvvG&ai, naQa 8s xoig IliQGaig s&og I slvai. (idXiGxa ovxco ya(isi~v. xai naQ Aiyvitxiotg Ss xag I dSsXcpag yauovGiv, o naQ r)(ii~v dnsiQrjxai vouco. dycoyrj 8s 153
I TtQcoxco xf\g

nsQLoSov

I I

s&og dvxixi&sxai, oxav oi

xaig

(isv

(iiyvvcovxai TtaQjia 8r\(ioGia' xai 6 (isv Aioyivr\g dnb s^cofiiSog nsQtrjsi, I r)(isig Ss cog sico&a(isv. uv&ixr\ Ss niGxsi, [cbg] oxav Xiyco- 154
I

savxcov

noXXol av&Qconoi dvaycoQOvvxsg e yvvai^iv, 6 Ss KQaxr\g xr) In-

I Giv
I
I

ol

(iv&ot

oxi

KQOvog xaxr\G%isv avxov xa xixva,

s&ovg ovxog
Gvvrj&sia
chg

r)uLv

nQOvosiG&ai naiScov' xal Ttao' r\(itv (isv dya&ovg xal dna&sig xaxcov dfisiv xovg
Ss

&sovg,

xiXQCoGx6(isvoL

xal

cp&ovovvxsg
8s

dXXf)Xoig

vnb
bxav 155

I
I

x&v
t)(ilv

itOLr\xcov
(isv

SLGayovxai.
r\

Soy(iaxixr\

vnoXr\tySL,

I \ I

naQa &scov aixslv xd dya&d, 6 8s 'EnixovQOg Xiyr\ (ir\ sniGXQicpsG&aL r\(icov xb &slov, xal oxav 6 (isv Aq iGx Lnnog d8 vdcp oqov r\yr\xai x b yvvaixsiav d(icpLivvvG&aL Gx o Xrjv , r)(isTg
hxrog

8s

aiG'iQov

xovxo

r\ycb(is&a

slvai.

dycoyr\v

8s

dvxL- 156

3 dh om. L 11 ita6ayira.Ls LM iv addidi coll. p. 33, 19 om. EAB 16 yuiisZv T (m uxores ducere) 18 miraQ19 dnb i^co(iidog GT (ob exomide) in%ia G: Praxarchidi T usitatum, at forsitan rectum ano^dvs xf\gy i^oa(iLSog conieci coll. Aristoph. Thesmoph. 656: dits!;a>(iidiog vel d?cXfi Cgawidi Pas20 tbg om. T (quando) 23 consuetudo est T d7tsL\Tslg quali EAB 27 Xiyrj Bekk.: Xiysi GT (dicit) 28 f\yf\taL L: f)ysixaL
||

13

(ihv

||

MEABT (putat)

30 f)ya>[LS&a MEAB

f\yov(is&aL

LT (arbitramur)

40
xi^euev
nxetv
xvnxco6tv
vofico (iev y

nTPPS>NEISN
3
oxav
Std
vofiov
xcci

bvxog
ol

(ir\

i^eivat

xv-

avdocc

eXev&eoov

evyevf)
dycoyf)v

nayxQccxia6Tai

dXXijXovg

xr)v

xov

xax

avxovg
jn

(Hov, xai oxav dnetQrjfiivov xov avSqocpoveiv ol fiovofi.d%tti 3 157 dvaiQio6iv dXXf)Xovg Std xr)v avxr)v aixiav. (iv&ixrjv Se

rtaod

ni6xtv dycoyr) dvxtxi&efiev, inetSdv Xeycofiev oxv ol fiev fiv&ot xbv 'HoaxXea Xeyov6tv (i; 423) xf) 'OficpdXr]
etQtd xe ^ccivetv xcci SovXo6vvr\g dve^ee&at

xm

xccvxcc

inoir\6ev av

158 yevvaia.

aneo ovS dv fiexoicog nQor\Qr\fievog Se dycoyf) xov iov xov *HQccxXeovg r)v Soyficcxtxf) 8e vnoXfjijjet, oxccv 01 fiev d&hjxal &g
notf)6at
xtg,
r)

xr)g Sor\g dvxtnotovfievot ininovov dycoyrjv St avxrjv inavatQtovxcct, noXXoi Se xcov cptXo6ocpcov cpavpiov 159 Xov elvcct xr)v 86h,av 8oyfiaxi^co6tv. xbv Se vofiov dvxtxi&euev

dya&ov (xtvogy

xovg fteovg xai fiotyevovxag xai aQQevofit^iatg iQcofievovg, vofiog Se naQ 160 rjfiiv xcoXvr\ xavxa nQaxxetv, Soyficcxtxf) Se vnoXrjipet, oxav

(iv&ixfj ftev ni6tet, oxccv oi fiev notrrxal et6ayco6t

oi fiev ne^i XQv6tnnov (HI elvcct Xeyco6t xb (irjXQd6tv r)

161 6 Se vdfiog xavxa xcoXvr\.
Xfjipet

745 Arn.) dStdcpoQOV

d8eXcpaig (iiyvv6&at,

(iv&txfy 8e n't6xtv Soyuaxtxf) vnodvxtxi&euev, oxav oi fiev notrjxai Xeyco6t xbv Jia xaxeX2

ftovxa %vr\xaig yvvcct^i (iiyvv6&ttt, nccQtt Se xotg Soyfiaxtxoig 162 dSvvccxov xovxo etvcct vofiir\xat, xai 6 fiev notr\xr\g Xeyr\,
oxt Tjevg Std xb

nev&og xb ini SccQnr\86vt aifiaxoe66ag ipexdfiivxot cptXo60(pcov (rfy

xcci

Sag xaxiyjevev eQafe (17 459), Soyfia

dncc&eg
elvcct

xb &eiov,

oxccv(

(iv&ov dvtttQ&6iv, dvvnaQ^iag 163 xccvqov r\fiiv cpeQOvxeg. noXXd fiev ovv xai ccXXa ivf)v xa& exa6xr\v xcov nQoetQr\(ievcov dvxt&eeecov Xccfifidvetv nccQcc||

xbv xav innoaevxttvQcov nuQttSetyfia xbv innoxev)>

31 (elvai) vofico EAB oTav Bekk.: ovrcog GT (sic) v6uov (fthvy ovxog T (lege quidem existente) 38 xvnxcaetv Bekk. xv7txov6iv Gr 2 kavx&v EAB 6 gfjv post ustq. add. dubit. Bekk. nQorjgriuivog L: nQoetQi\uevog M: TtQoeiQr\uivo)g EAB: moderate discretus T 9 xtvog add. T (tamquam bonum ali14 et 17 xa>Xvr\ Bekk. quid) 11 (pavXr\v M: pravam rem T 17 fiv&txrjv doyuaxixf) 6h nicTiv vnoxcoWft GrT (prohibet) 21 Uyy Bekk.: Xiyet GT (dicit) 22 i) add. T Xfjipet EAB 23 lacunam post orav statui xbv EAB: xb M: om. L (est)
|j

||

||

TII0TTn2EN

A.

41

aoxiasL. %Xr\v iy fiara' cbg iv 6vvr6ficp Ss Xoyco xavxa iGavTYjg dvcofiaXiag %Qayfidrcov %a\ Std xovxov xov xqoiv SsLKWfiivr\g , ojtotov fisv s6xl xb v%OKsifisvov %axd )v cpv6iv ovk s%ofisv Xiysiv, b%oiov Ss cpaivsxat %Qog:
r\vSs
xr\v dycoyr\v r\ %Qog xovSs xbv vbfiov r) %Qog xoSe t&og na\ xcov dlXcav sxa6xov. %a\ Std xovxov ovv %sq\

)g

fdyxrj.

cpv6scog rcov i%xog v%o%stfiivcov nQayiidxcov s%i%siv r\fiag oftxco fisv ovv Sid xcov Si%a xqo%cov %axaXr\yofisv

ig xr\v i%oyr\v.

%SQL XCOV %SVXS XQOTtCQV. 6%s%xl%o\ 7taQaSLS6a6i XQOnovg xr)g nivrs xov68s, %qcoxov xov d%6 xr\g Siacpcoviag, %oyr\g Ssvxsqov xov sig a%siQOV iK^dXXovra, xqlxov xov dno xov
Ls'

ol Ss vscoxsqol

164"

TtQog

xl, xixaQxov xov v%o&sxlkov, TtifiTtxov xov SidXXrj%a\ b Lisv drto xr)g Siacpcoviag s6x\ %a& 6v %sq\ xov 165rtQOTS&ivxog %Qayfiaxog dvs%i%QtTOv 6xa6iv %aQa xs xco

Xov.

pico

%a\
r)v

TtaQa

xoig

cpiXooocpoig
xi

svQi6%0fisv
r)

ysysvr\fiivr\v,

6V

ov SvvdfisvoL aLQSL6d-ai
sig

a%oSo%tfidsLV xaraccTtsiQOv i%%xco6scog

Xr)yofisv

i%oyr\v.

b Ss

d%6
sig

xr)g

sig

166

s6x\v
>

TtQoxs&ivxog 7tQayfiaxog 7ti6xscog sxi^ag %Qr\sLv Xiyofisv, %d%stvo aXXr\g, %a\ fLi%Qig dnsiQov, cog fir\ iyovxcov rjfi&v %6&sv aQl-6cpsQOfisvov
6 Ss d%6 167 rf)g %axa6KSvr)g xr)v i%oyr\v d%oXovdsiv. xov TtQog xi, %a&cog %QOSiQr\Kafisv, iv co TtQog fisv xb kqivov %a\ xd 6vv&scoQOVfisva xolov r) xolov cpaivsxai xb v%o-

sv

xo

7ti6xLv

xov

(is&a

)%sifisvov,

bnoLOv Ss s6xl %Qog v%o&i6Ecog S6tiv orav sig

xr\v

cpv6tv i%iypfisv.

Ss 168-

dnsLQOv

i%fiaXX6fisvoL

oi

d%6 XLVog aQ^covxat o ov %axa6%svat,ov6LV dXX d%Xcog Ka\ ava%oSsiKxcog %axa 6vyicoQr\6LV Xafifidvsiv aS,LOVSoyfiaTL%o\
6iv.

b Ss SLaXXrjXog

XQO%og 6vvi6xaxai, oxav xo ocpsiXov

slvat
sfiaicoxL%6v

16i>

xov

r\xovfiivov %Qayfiaxog

%Qsiav

s%r\

164177
3 ovv

cf.

Diog. Laert. IX 88

89

(ol 7tSQ\'AyQi7t7tav).

EAB: om. LM:

(qui est

sic igitur

&nb rov om. T

ad

EAB

18 kqlvov

MEABT

T 7 xov LEAB: r&v M: 8 rbv post rsragrov om. aliquid) (id qiiod iudieat): kqlvslv L

42
rr\g

IITPP&NEI&N
ix rov r\xovfiivov nt6xecog'

iWa

(irjdireoov

6vvdfie-

xaxa6xevr\v d-ariqov, neol dficpoxiQcov ndv xb r\xovfievov elg xovxovg dvdyetv xovg XQonovg ev6i%exat, 6td (5oa%icov vnodeiilofiev ofixcog. 170 xb itQOxe&ev r\xot ai6r\xbv eoxiv r) vorjxov, bnoiov eT dv
Xafieiv Jtoog oxt 6e iniypfiev.

vot

xa ai6&rjrd fibva cpa6iv 6tanecpcbvr\xat' 01 fiev yaQ eivat AtjOtj, 01 6e fibva Ta vorjrd, 01 6i xiva fiev ai17,

a&rjxd, xtvd

6e

vor\rd.
r)

nbreQOv ovv intxQtrrjv elvat

dvenixQtrov;
ei

cpr\:

GovGt

xr\v

6tacpcovtav

fiev

dvenixQtrov,

Xiyofiev oxt 6ei iniyetv' neQt yaQ xcov aventxQtxcog 6tacpcovovfiivcov ov% otbv xi edxtv dnocpatve6&at. ei 6e intXQt171 rr\v, nbftev entxQt&r\6erai nvvdavbfie&a. otov rb aia&r\-

xbv [ini rovrov yaQ nQoriQOv 6rr\60fiev rbv Xbyov) nbreQOv

vnb ai^&rjTov r) vnb vor\rov; ei fiev yaQ vnb aie&rjrov, inei neQt rcov ai6d-r\rcov r\rov(iev, xai ixeivo dXXov 6er\6erat nQog nt6rtv. ei 6e xdxeivo ai6&r\rbv cctcm, ndhv
xai avxb aXXov 6er\6erat xov nt6xco6ovxog , xai xovxo fii172 XQtg dnetQOv. ei 6e vnb vor\xov entxQtve6&at 6er\6et to
catfxbjTov,

xovxo vor\rbv ov
6xcod"r\6exai;
bfioicog' ei ei

inei xai rd vor\xa 6tanecpcbvr\xat, 6er\6erat xal xQt6ecog re xai nt6xecog. nb&ev ovv ntd'
fiev vnb vorjxov, eig dnetQOv ixne6eixat vnb ai6&r\xov, inei nQog fiev xr\v nt6xtv

xov aie&rjxov naQeXr\cp&r\ vor\xbv, nQog 6e xr\v rov vor\rov 173 nt6rtv ai6&r\rbv, b 6tdXXr\Xog ei6ayerat TQonog. ei 6e xavxa cpevycov b nQo66taXeybfievog r\fiiv xaxd 6vyicoQr\6tv
xai dvano6eixxcog
xcov
ei
eijrjg,

fiev

dijtco6ete Xafifidvetv xt nQog dnbbetijtv b vno&extxbg ei6ay&r\6exat XQonog, anoQog vnaQycov. yaQ b vnoxt&ifievog nt6rbg e6rtv, r\fieig dei rb

ccvrtxeifievov vnort&ifievot ovx ei fiev dXr\&ig rt vnori&erai

i6bfie&a
b

dnt6rbreQ0t.

xai

vnort&ifievog,

vnonrov
fir)

avrb notei, xad"' vnb&e^tv avrb Xafifidvcov dXXa

fiera

26
om.
fiev

xols

ABT
T
L

om. T
.et

(constitwmus) axr\atouev G 12 bv ML: ovv EAB: om.

:

L xov om. EAB 32 ol Si tiv a 2 Xeyofisv scripsi %%oftev GT (habemus)

||

33
5

vor\td
atrjao-

7 itgoade fjcetat 13 si enim

M
T

9 xovxo 16 6 dh

&XXr\Xog

modus T

19 eiaax&^aetat 20 erit T

(introducetur)

elg &%68st,tv

TnOTTIIZEN
xaTa6KEvf\g'
si

A.

43

8s tyevdog, 6u&qu eGxui r\ vnofid&Qu tcov xui si (isv dvvst xi xo vnoTlE6&ui 174 xuTu6xsvuo(iivcov. itoog n't6Ttv, avxb xb r\TOV(isvov VTtoxi&EG&a , xai (ir)
ox> 8r\ kutu6ksvu6ei xb nQuy(iu %eq\ o% 6 uxonov EGxi xb vnori%s6%ut xb ^rjTovfisvov, Xoyog' axoitov EGxat Kui xb vnoxi&EG&ai xb snuvusr\K6g. oxi 175 8s Kui %Qog xi EGxX ndvxu xa aiG&rjTcc, 8f\Xov' E6Ti yuQ nQog Tovg aiG&avofiivovg. cpuvsQov ovv oti onsQ ccv r\(ttv

exeqov

xi

dt'

si

8s

nQOTE&rj nQuy(iu ai6d--r\x6v, eig xovg nivxE XQonovg dvdyetv xovxo svfiuQig s6xtv. 6(ioicog 8s xui nsQi xov vorjxov
sntloyi6(iE&u.
si (isv
i](itv

yuQ

XiyoiTO, 8o&r\6ETut

uvsntKQircog 8tunscpcovf\6d ui to Seiv snijstv nsQt uvtov. si 8s 176

,

EniKQi&rj6ETui

<r\

dtucpcoviu, si (isv 8tu vorjTOv, sig unstQOv

sk^uXov(isv,

si

8s

vnb ui6&r\Tov,

sig

tov 8tdXXr\Xov'
xui
(ir\

to

8vvd(isvov St uvtov sntKQivs6&ut 8tu tt\v sig unstQOv EKnTco6iv, tov vorjTOv r\6Tui &6nsQ kuI to vorjTOV tov ui6&t]T0v. Stu 177 tuvtu Ss 6 i vno&iescog Xu(ifidvtov Tt ndXtv uTonog e6tui. dXXu xal nQog xi s6xt xd vorjxd' nQog yuQ xbv vovv vor\xu
8tucpcovov(isvov,

yuQ

ui6&r)Tov ndXtv

bnotov Xiysxut, ovx ovv xul xb vor\xbv sig xovg nivxs xQonovg, StonsQ dvdyxr\ nsQt xov nQoxs&ivxog nQuy(iuxog
Xiysxat, xui si r\v
xr\

tpv6st xotovxov

uv

discpcovri&r}.

dvr)ypr]

ndvxcog r\(tug iniystv. Totovxot (iev xut

15 (isvot

of

nuQu

xotg

vscoxiQotg

nuQuStSo-

TQonot' ovg ixxi&svxut ovk SK@dXXovxsg xovg 6iKu XQonovg, dXX vnsQ xov noiKtXtoxEQOv ku\ Stu xovxcov

nivTS

6vv sxsivotg iXiyystv

tg

xr\v xcov Soy(iuxtxcov

nQoniTStuv.

Tivsg ot Svo xQonot.

IIuQuSid6u6i Ss xai 8vo TQonovg inoir)g STiQOvg' snsi 178 yuQ n&v to xuT<xXa(i{luv6(iEvov r\Tot ih, suvtov xutuXu(i-

erit

25 KuraaKEvaa^tivcov EB: xaTeoxsvua(iEva>v A 29 tarut xal om. T 4 vnb ML &%b

:

28 sermo

EAB
:

8 6

vovv vor\rd T G cf. p. 38, 30 sq. 13 i%i%stv Salmasius post Stephanum: insXQ-slv G: insfzsl&ELv T (pertransire) 14 naqu Gen.: nsgl G: a T 16 Y.ul om. EAB rovxcov T (per hos): rovro G

vn. scripsi

coll.

(qui ex supponere aliquid): i vn. 6 (ad intellectum enim intelligibilia) voovvra

||

44
fidve6&ut Soxet euvxov xt ovxe
xcov
r) iS,

IITPP&NEI&N
39
e exeoov, (vno(ii(ivrj6xovxeg oxt ovxe i% 20

a7t0Qiav

eiadyeiv

exeQOvy xuxuXu(idvexut, xui oxt Soxov6tv.

xr\v
(iev

neol ndv-- 0i

ovSev i

eavxov xuiuXu(idvexut, cpu6i, SfjXov ix xf)g yeyevrjfievrjg %uqu xotg <pv6txotg neQi xe xcbv ale&rjz&v xui xcbv vorjxcov undvxcov olfiat Stucpcoviug, r) Sr\ dvenixQtxog i6xt
(irj

SvvufJtevcov f)(icov

(if)xe

ui6&r\xco

(if)xe

vorjtco

XQtxrjQtco

25

1Qr)6&ai td xb

ndv, oneQ av
6td
Se

Xdficofiev

Stunecpcovrjfievov,

179 elvai unt6xov,

($dve6&ui

xovxo
ei

ovS' e|

6vyicoQOv6tv.

(tev

yuQ

exeQOv xt xccxaXa(ixb ov xt xuxu-

Xufifidvexui del i% exeQOv xuxuXu(idve6ftut Sef)6et, eig xbv

StdXXr\Xov r) xbv unetQOv i(idXXov6t xQonov. ei Se (iov- 30 Xotxo xtg Xaetv cog i eavxov xuxuXu(i(iuv6(jtev6v xt i ov

xuxaXafifidvexut exeQov, uvxtninxei xb (irjSev i eavxov xuxuXu(Ldve6&ut Std xd nQoetQrjfievu. xb Se (iuy6(Jtevov ncog uv

4<-

Svvutxo xaxaXtjCp&fjvui <(i))> dcp euvxov r) dcp exeQOv, dnoQovfievy xov xQtxrjQtov ttjs dXrj&eiug r) xf\g xaxaXfjtyecog (ir} cputvofievov, 6rj(ieicov Se xul Siyu dnoSei^eoog StuxQeno(dvcov, xa&dneQ iv xolg liji/s ei66(ie&u. xo6uvxu (iev ovv xul neQt
xcov xQoncov T-^g inoyfjg ini xov

nuQovxog uQxe6et XeXex&ut.

*'

xiveg XQonot xfjg x&v uixtoXoytxcov uvuxQonfjg.

180

"Sl6neQ Se xovg XQonovg <(tjJs)> inoyr^g nuQuSiSofiev, ovxco xui xQonovg ixxi&evxui xtveg, xu&' ovg iv xutg xaxd (lEQOg aixioXoyiutg StunoQOvvxeg icpt6xcb(iev xovg Soy(iuxtxovg Stu
180 sqq.: cf. Phot. Bibl.

10

212

(p.

170b 1722 Bekk.).

ex alio rememorantes quia neque ex se ipso 23 aia&r\ttw.&v alio of. p. 80, 15 dissonans 26/27 Stajts(p. slvai dntsxov T (quod omne 29 xaTula(i(}dvTatL incredibile est): d%tGxov elvat StUTtscp. 1 %axaluw$dvETat (ex quo apprehenditur aliud): ti xutusuppl. e

20

quid

neque

ex

EAB

G
||

Xa(idvEtv

T
dt'

(vel

M:

Bekk.

3 r) add. G (sed xaTaXa(idvsTai) uvtov EAB 5 8i%u LEAB: ex se ipso vel) 3/4 et dubitamus T 8 Tovg om. om. T (xal dnoSEt^Eoag?) Tf)g add. 10 invenimus T

||

TII0TTn&2EN
:6

A.

45

(idXt6xu ini xuvxutg uvxovg iiiya cpQOveiv. y.al Sr\ AivrjiSr\(iog bxxco roonovg nuQuSiSco6t xa& ovg otexat nu6uv
TtoobTov

uhtoXoyiuv ag (tox&rjQuv eXiyycov dnocpr\vu6&ut, 181 (iev elvui cpr\6t xu& ov [roonov] xb xr\g uhtoloylag yivog iv acpaviaiv dva6TQecp6(ievov ov% b(ioioyov(iir\v eyet Trjv ex t&v cpatvofiivcov ent(iuQTVQr\6tv' SevTeQOV ov noXXuY.tg evemcpoQiug ov6r\g SuiptXovg &6Te 8e xu&
ioy(iuxtxr\v
iv
J

nolvTQonag uhtoXoyr\6ut to r\TOV(ievov , XU& evu fiovov TQonov tovto Tiveg uhtoXoyov6tv' tqltov xu& ov xcqv xe- 182 xuytiivcog ytvottivcov ahiag dno8tS6a6tv ovSettiuv xd\tv
ov xcc cputvofievu Xu($6vTeg entcputvov6ug' xixuQxov xud" &g yiveTut, xui tu (ir\ cpatvotieva vo(iiov6tv cog yiveTui
xuTetXrjcpivut,

Tuyu

tiev bfioicog

xotg cputvo(iivotg

t&v dcpu-

Tuyu c?' ov% btioicog dX iStu6vTcog' ni(inTov xud-' ov ndvTeg &g 1'nog eineiv xutu Tctg iSiug 183 t&v 6TOtyeicov vnofti6etg dXX ov xutu xtvug xotvug xui OfioXoyovfiivug ecpoSovg uhtoXoyov6tv' exTOv xad" ov noXvcov
eniTekovfiivcov ,

Xdxtg tu (iev opcoqutu xuig idiuig vno&i6e6t nuQuXuttdvov6tv, xu Se dvxtninxovxu xai xr\v t6r\v eypvTU nt$uv6Tr\Tu naQuni(inov6tv' eSo(iov xu& ov noXXdxtg dno8t86u6tv 184

uhiag ov fiovov
vnod"i6e6t

Toig

(iuyo(iivug' tcov te cpaive6$ut Soxovvxcov xui rcov entr\xov(iiv(ov, ix rcov b(ioicog dnoQcov ne^i rcov bfioiag dno-

cputvofiivotg dXXu xui xaig iSiutg ov noXXdxtg ovxcov oySoov xad"

dnoQcov
qg>v

6(ioicog

notovvTut

Tug

St8u6xuXiug.

ovx dSvvaxov 8i
i\QTr\(iivovg

cpr\6t

185

xai

xaxd Ttvug
ccv

ent(iixT0vg

TQonovg,

ex

tcov

nQoetQrjfiivcov, StuninTetv eviovg ev Tuig uhtoXoyiutg.

xui oi nivTe XQonot

r\xot

uhtoXoyiug.

xdyu dnuQxoiev nQog xug yuQ 6v(icpG)vov nu6utg xuig xuxu cptXoxr\g enoyr\g

6ocpiuv utQi6e6t xui xrj 6xitpet xui xoig cpatvofiivotg uhiuv eQei xtg r\ ov. xui 6v(icpcovov (ilv i'6cog ovx iv8i%exut' xd xe yuQ cputvotieva xui xcc u8r\Xa ndvxu Siunecpcovr\xui. ei 186
8e Stdcpcovov,

dnatxrj&rj^exui xui xuvxrjg

xr\v

uixiuv,

xai

11/12

14

rgoTtov om. convenientia T

riunt)

22 voitlr\Tut EAB 28 (iam del. Kayser) 6 aituQY.oiev Kayser: cmu.QY.ov6i GT (suffi11 dtdcpcovov Bekk. Stacpavst G

Alvr\6tdr\(i.os

Fabr.

6vr\si8r\itog

G:

onisidimus

46
cpatvofiivrjv
sig
fisv

IITPP&NEI&N
cpatvofiivrjg
r)

adrjXov d8r)Xov

Xafifidvcov

anstQOv ixns6sixat, ivaXXaS, 6s aixtoXoy&v slg xbv dtdXXrjXov. t6xdfisvog di nov, 7) ooov inl xotg siQrjfiivotg Xi^st
xr)v aixlav 6vvs6xdvat, xat si6ayst xb iroog xt, avato&v xb Tiobg xr\v cpv6tv, r\ i vito9s6scog xi Xafifidvcov int6yss6xiv ovv xat dtd xovxcov iXiyystv t6cog xrjv x&v %r\6sxat.
1:

Soyfiaxtx&v iv xatg aixtoXoyiatg nQonixstav.

trf

TtSQt
ixa6xco

x&v 6XSnxtX&V
%Qcbfisvot

cpcov&v.
xs

187

'Enst

Ss

xovtcov

xai

x&v

xr)g
2(

ino%r)g XQoncov intcp&syyofisd-a cpcovdg xtvag xr)g 6xsnxtxr)g Sta%s6scog xa\ xov nso\ rifiag nd&ovg firjvvxtxdg, otov Xi-

yovxsg

*ov

fiaXXov'

*ovSsv

OQt6xiov'
st-rjg

xal

aXXag

xtvdg,
aoijra-

dxoXov&ov av strj xat nsQt xovxcov fis&a Ss dnb xfjg *ov fiaXXov.'
t&
188

StaXafisiv.

nsQt

xr)g

*ov fiaXXov'
'

cpcovfjg.
2;

Tavxrjv xoivvv oxs fisv cog scprjv nQOcpsQOfis&a, oxs 9 Ss ofixcog *ovSsv fiaXXov ov yccQ cog xtvsg vnoXafifid*ov fiaXXov' iv xatg siStxatg r)Xr)6S6t vov6i, xryv fisv naQaXafifidvofisv, xr)v Ss *ovSsv fiaXXov' iv xatg ysvtxaig, dXX'

dStacpoQcog xr)v xs *ov fiaXXov'

xat

xrjv

'ovSsv
3(

cpcovr) iXXtnr\g. yaQ oxav Xiycofisv *StnXrf, dvvdfist cpafisv *s6xia StnXf)\ xai oxav Xioxav 4 ycofisv 'nXarsta', dvvdfist Xsyofisv 'nXarsta bSog', oftxcog

fiaXXov' nQOcpSQOfis&a, xat fis&a. s6xt (isv ovv avxrj rj

vvv

cbg

nsQl

fitccg

StaXs,6-

cog

stncofisv *ov

fiaXXov,'
'

Svvdfist
,

cpafisv

'ov fiaXXov roSs

r\

189 xoSs, avco xdxco.' xtvsg fiivrot r&v 6xsnrtx&v naQaXafifidvov6tv dvrtnv6fiarogrb ov {(dvriyrov ri fiaXXov roSsr) xoSs, xb

19 tovtcov rs 12 et 16 %u[i(}dvetv EAB 15 sicdist Kayser 24 om. EAB tiov om. M 20 (ttvsgy cpcovdg ttvag EAB # om. L 32 dmlfj dvvdftst L: Svvdfist StnXfi EAB: dutatia G: Svvdfist cpaftsv om. plicem potentiam T
||

||

||

domum T

(fort.

olxia

cf.

Lys.

9)

ie&rjg

1 ettxtog vel aattxtog Pappenheim 6S6g Diels: nXatslav et nXatslav 6S6v GT (latam et viam 4 to ov Paris. Suppl. 133: tov ov G: pro interlatam)

Fabr. dnsginlatsla et nXatsla

:

TIIOTTIIZEN

A.

I
,

47

xi 7tttQaXa(idvovxg *Std xl ttaXXov xode

ccvtI cct,io(idxG)v

tv rj xb Xy6(ivov Gvvrj&eg Si i6xi xai %v6tta6iv iQr)6&ai) olov (Eur. Herc. fr. l)
9 r)

vvv dvxl ahiag),

xode;

xig xbv

Aibg 6vXXxtqov ovx olde Pqot&v;

%v6(idxcov, oiov *r)T& %ov oixu Aitov xat ^TCW&dvofiai. xivog evexa %Qr) &av(ideiv dvdQa %otr\aXXd xal xb xi dvxl xov Std (rC) %aQccXcc(idvexat xr)v.'
xcci d^,tcotta6tv ccvtI

nuQu

MevdvdQm'
xi

(fr.

900 Kock.)
iyoo xccxeXet%6(ir)v;

yaQ

Sr\Xoi Sh xb *ov (iccXXov xoSe r) xoSe' Kal %d$og r)tiixQ0v, xa& o Std xr)v i606&ivuav xcov dvxtxuttivcov %Qccyttdxcov ig aQQipiccv xccTaXf)yo(iv, t606d-ivtccv (ihv

109

xr\xa xr\v} xccxd xb cpcuv6(Jtvov r)(iiv

X^yovToov r)ti&v rjjv <7o*o%t&avov, dvxixuttva Sh

xotv&g xa
&6iv.
\% o
7)

ttuy6tiva, aQQtyiav Sh xr\v yovv *ovShv ttaXXov' cpoovr\

r)

%Qog (ii]SixQOv 6vyxaxdxdv ittcpccivr) yaQuxxf Qa 19t

t

6vyxaTa&i6Cog
tt^&u,

ovijGeojg,

r)(iug

ovy ovrcog

ccvxf)

%Qoo-

dSiacpoQCog avxr)v %uQuXa(idvottv xal xaxadvxl %v6(iaxog r) dvxl xov Xiyuv dyvoco %Qt)6Ttx&g, xivi tthv xovxcov iQr) 6vyxccxaxi96&at, xivt Sh (ir)' \6vy-

dXX'

r\xot

xaxaxi&6&at].

%q6y.uxcci

(yaQy

f)ttiv

Sr)X&6ai xb cpatvotte-

-xjli
r
'i

vov

r)(uv'

xaxd Sh

xr\v <pcovr\v Si

r)g

uvxb Sr\Xovtiv dSiacpo-

oo-Ofiev.

xdxuvo Sh %Qf) ytvdo6xuv, oxt %QOcpQ0(x.%a xr\v 'ovShv (i&XXov' cpoovr\v ov Stu@(itttov(ivot %Qt xov %dv-

i:

xcog

v%uq%uv

avxr\v

dXrj&f)

xcci

($aiav,

dXXd xaxd

xi>

<pcctv6(ivov rjtttv xui %Qt avxf\g XiyovTg.

rogatione ego: xb
(l&XXov'
:

et

||

non pro quid Jwc quam hoc T (avxiy xov locus non integer: dvxl d^twttccxog xov *o
fl

Ttvatia xb *xi (i&XXov', olov xi tt&XXov xods r) xode &vx\ xov *dtu xi' 7tva(tuxog xb 'xt tt&XXov xods r) } 11 xi add. T {propter quid) x68s Kayser 7 dvxl om. EAB 16 leoa&ivs tav Pappenheim l6oxj]xa GT 16/17 laoxrjxa xr\v add. Pappenh. 17 ntftavbv <^xori ditt&uvbv l66xr\xuy E. Weber

Bekk.

19 yovv Gen.
{licet

ovv
:

LEAB: om. M:

ostendat)

add T.

i(tcpatvst (propositum est

24 juq 23/24 avyx. om. T enim nobis) 29 fort. jrapl xavxr\g?

LAB

igitur

||

ittcpttivr)

MET

48
k

IITPP&NEI&N
Jteql

dqa6iug.
xuXeixut St-

192

Ueqi

Se Tijg dq>u6iug Xeyofiev xdSe. q>u6tg

%&g, Kotv&g xai r) uq6iv qcovr),

ISicog

ISicog, xotv&g (iev r) Sr)Xov6a fteetv ( otov r)fieQu e6ttv, ov% r)(ieQu llffui/,'

Sr\Xov6u fte6tv fiovov, xu&' o 6r\xd dnoqaxtxu ov xuXov6t q>u6etg. r) fiatvofievov

Se
r)

ovv dq>u6iu dito6xa6lg

i)

e6xi xr)g

xotv&g XeyO(ievr\g qu6ecog,

vjtoxd66e6&ai Xeyofiev xr\v xe Kaxdq>a6tv Kui xr\v dn6q>a6iv, fog eivut dq>u6iuv 7td&og r)(iexeoov St o ovxe xtd-ivau xi 193 oftxe dvuiQeiv qufiev. o&ev Sf\X6v i6xtv, oxt Kal xr\v dq>a6iav

ov% cog TtQog xr)v q>v6tv xotovxcov bvxcov TtQayfidxcov co6xe Jtdvxcag dq>a6tav Ktveiv^ dXXu Sr\Xovvxeg oxt rjfietg vvv, oxe TtQoq^eQOfue&a avxrjv, ent x&vde x&v r\TtuQuXufi^dvofiev

x&v

xovfievcov xovxo Ttejtov&afiev.

fi,r\Sev

Kaxeivo

%Qr\ (ivr\(iovevetv, oxt

dvatQetv q>a(iev x&v Kaxd xb aSr\Xov SoyfiaxtK&g Xeyofievcov' xotg yaQ Ktvov6tv rjfiag 7tu&r\xtx&g Kui dvayxa6xtK&g ayov6tv etg 6vyKuxd%e6tv etKOfiev.

xt&evat

firjSe

xu
194

neQt xov ^xd^u' Kal xov *et,e6xt' Kui xov

*ivSe%exui'.
Se

Tb
e%e6xt'
fiev

*tdyu
'

xui
9

*ov

xdyu

xui

(,

e%e6xt

Kal

"ovx

ivSifexui dvxl xov ^xdyu fiev

Kal

'ovx ivSiyexuf TtuQuXafifidvo* e6xtv xdya S ovx e6xtv\ xai e%e6xt

xui
'

elvat eE,e6xt Se (ir\ elvat\ xal ivSeyexut fiev elvat ivSiyexut Se (ir\ elvat', cog 7tuQuXu(ifidvetv r)fiag 6vvxofiiag %uqiv xb '(ir) Qetvat dvxl xov 'i^eivut fir) elvat\ xui xb ^fir)
fiev

ivSe%e6&ut* dvxt xov *ivSi%e6&ut fir) elvat\ Kai xb o$ xdya 195 dvxi *xov xdyu (ir) elvat TtdXtv Se ivxav&a ov qcovofiaypvftsv, ovSe el q>v6et xavxa Sr)Xov6tv ai qcovai, r)xov(iev, dXX
'.

dStaqoQag avxdg, &g

afixut

elTtov,

TtuQuXafifidvofiev.

oxt

fievxot

ui q>covui dq>a6iag et6i Sr)XcoxtKui, TtQoSrjXov, oifiut. > 6 yovv Xeycov *xdyu e6xtv Svvdfiet xi&r\6t Kui xb (idye6%ui

Sokovv UVX&, xb *xdyu

TteQi

fir)

elvat',

xco

(ir)

Siufie(5uiov6&at
eyet.

xov elvat avxo.

bfioicog Se

Kui eni x&v Xoitc&v

1 &Qvr\Giv

31 post Koiv&g
(sic)

inser. xs

AB
T

2/3
(neque)

6r}fiaivov
:

5 iliyofisv

(dicebamus)

otits

cvds

12 tov ddrjlov dub. Bekk. Pappenheim dubit.

22

fiovoftaxovfisv

EAB

23 tavtd

TnoTTna2EN

a.

49

II
:,

Tb

Se

^ejtiioo

y
'

eiJteiv

xlvi iQr)

x&v

7taQuXa(idvo(iev dvxl jtQOxei(iivcov jtL6xev6at

i'aa
r)(iiv

xov
r)

ovx

eyjco

196

xIvl djtL6xr)-

6ui, SrjXovvxeg oxi

jtiGxiv xai djti6xiav.

cpaivsxai xa jtQuyfiaxa

JtQog

xul

si

(tev l'6u e6xiv,

ov SiafiefiaLOv-

fie&a'
:

xb Se cpuLv6(ievov
Xsyofisv.

i)(iiv

j.

jtijtxet,

xal

r)

ejtoyr)
(ir)xe

6&ui
.,

xr)v

Sluvoluv

vog

avxcov, oxs r)(iiv vitoSe SLQrjxaL ctTtb xov iniyeXL&ivai xl (if)xe dvaiQeiv Slu
jtSQi

xr)v

L606&iveLuv xcov r]xov(iivcov.

wy TteQL xov 'ovSev oql^co'. xov "ovSev 6qlco' xavxu cpafiiv. IleQL oql&lv 197 elvaL vo(iio(iev ovyi xb djtXcog Xiyeiv xi, dXXu xb JtQayfia a8r\Xov TtQocpeQeG&aL (iexd 6vyxaxad i6ecog. oftxco yuQ ovSev oql^cov 6 6KeTtxLY.bg xdya evQed-fj6exai, ovSe avxb xb *ovdev oql^co'' ov yuQ s6xl Soyfiaxixr) vnoXrjtyig, xovxs6xiv dSf)Xco 6vyxaxu&e6Lg , dXXd cpcovr) jtd&ovg i)(iexeQ0V SrjXcooxav ovv eX%r\ 6 6xejtxixbg *ov8ev 6qlco', xovxo xixr). cpr\6iv *iyco ovxco Ttijtovftu vvv cog (irjSev xcov vnb xr)v
Se
,

r)xr]6iv xr)v8e Jtenxcoxoxcov

xovxo di
xeifiivcov
>

cpr\6L

xL&ivuL SoyfiuxLxcog i) dvuLQelv'. Xiycov xb euvxco cpaivofievov JteQL xcov jtQO(iexd

Jtejtoi&rjeecog
jtu6ye.L 8Lr\yov(ievog.

dnuyyeXxixcog, ov Soyiiuxixcog

djtocpaivofievog, dXX'

xd'

neQL xov 'jtdvxu e6xiv d6Qi6xa'.

Kai
aiQOfiiv

i)

xi

ovxe 198 UOQ16XLU Se Ttdftog Siuvoiag e6xi y xud-' ovxe xifte(iev xcov Soyfiaxixcog fyxovfiivcov,
(

xovxi6xi xcov dSr)Xcov. oxuv ovv Xiyrj 6 6xenxixbg jtdvxa ' e6xiv doQi6xU) xb (iev *e6xC Xuicfidvei dvxi xov cpaive6%aL
1

jtUQa
(ir)

avxco\ ndvxu Se Xiyet ov xu ovxa dXX' ujteQ Sie^rjX&e xcov xoig Soy(iaxixoi~g r]XOV(iivcov dSrjXcov, doQL6xa Se
jtioxLv

JtQOv%ovxa xcov dvxLxeifiivcov r) xoivcog (iuyp(iivcov xuxd djtL6xiav. xui co6jteQ 6 Xiycov *TteQLJtaxco* Svvd- 199 r)

11 o#ffEAB 14 ujtuyyeXxLxwg, ov 7 (tby uvvb xb EAB doypaxix&gT (assertive non dogmatice) ovx unayyelxixatg Gr cf. p. 45, 26/7. 22 jtQov^ovxa Gen. 7tQovnuQ%ovxa GT (preexistentia)
:

Sextus Empiricus I.

50
(jtst

IITPP.QNEI&N
(pr\6iv

'iyco

nsQtrtuxco' ,
>

ovrcog

Xiycov

'ndvru iarlv

6v66r)fiaivt *xu& rjfiag' 7) *&g nobg i(ie' r) *chg K o6a inf)Xifiol cpaivsrat , cog slvat to Xsyofisvov xotovxov &ov xcov (%aqa xoigy 8oyfiaxtxoig Zrjxovfiivcov, xotavrd

aooMSra

fiot

cpaivsrut cog (ir)8sv avrtov rov (ia%o(isvov rtQov%etv

rj

fiot

8oxeiv xard nl6nv

xe

dnt6riav.
K

neol rov itdvra i6rlv dxardXrjrtra'.

xai

200

Otirco 8e cpSQOfis&a dxardXrjrtra'' xai ydo to to 'ifioV 6vvexde%6fie&a,

orav
elvat

Xiycofisv
bfioicog

*ndvru i6riv
xai

^^^^0^
cog

i^rjyovfied-a

to

Xsyofisvov

xotovxov

Xcov

*ndvxa 06U icpco8sv6a xcov Soyfiaxtxcog r)xovfiivcov d8r)f rovro 8s i6nv ov 8tacpaiverav fioi dxardXr)rtra (t@aiov(iivov itEqi xov xd rtUQu xoig Soyfiurtxotg r)rovfisva

cpv6ecog
ort

slvat

roiavrrjg

cog

slvat

dxaxdXr)nxu,

dXXd

to savxov
(idvco

nd&og dnuyyiXXovxog , XU& 0, cprfiiv, vrtoXaficc%qi vvv ov8sv xariXafiov ixsivcov iyco 8td rrjv
l606&VEiaV'

XCOV

dvXlXEtflEVCOV cpEQOfisvu

O&EV XUt xd
slvut

Stg
fiot

nr)v
rjficov

ndvxu dnuSovxu
1

Soxsi

rtEQtXQOxcov vy

dnayysXXofiivcov.
K ,
.

nsqi xov ^dxaxaXr^rtxco xai ov xaxuXafl^dvco 201 Kai r) dxaxaXynxco 8s xui r) *ov xaxaXafifidvco' dcpi6rarat 6 cpcovr) rtd&ovg oixsiov i6ri 8r)Xcoxixr), xa&
xg
'

6xsrtnxog cog nQog xo rtUQov xov xiftsvat xt xcov %r\rovfiivcov dSrjXcov 1} dvaiQEtv, cog e6rt Sr)Xov ix rcov nQOEiQrjfisvcov r)(iiv nsqi rcov dXXcov cpcovcov.

x nsqi rov rtavri Xoyco Xoyov t6ov dvrtxst6&at.

202

"Orav Ss

Xiycofisv

'rtavxi

Xoyco

Xoyog

6og dvrixstrat
xt

',

rtavxi (isv Xiyofisv xco vcp

cpafisv

rjficov

Sts^coSsvfiivco,

Xoyov 8i
Soyfiurt-

ov% unXcog dXXd xbv xuxa6xsvdovxd

et dicit
:

24

rolg add.

T 25 7) primum T (vel quo ad me) to G 27 icugd (eorum que a dogmaticis queruntur) coll. p. 44, 21
:

r&v doyfiarixolg
xix&g Bekk.
296, 26.

ML

(sic")

rolg doyfiaTixolg

EAB

t&v

14

i'aog

32 i(iol (cpuivsraiy Kayser coll. 2 xu om. EAB rolg om. 9 17 vnolafifiuveo om. T
||

Soy(iUp. 45, 20.

EAB

TnOTTn2EN

A.

51

II y
-

xcov xai snLcpOQag

dSrjXov, xai ov ndvxcog xbv sx Xr\(i[id9 dXXd xbv 6nco6ovv xccxa6xsvdovxa. 'i'6ov Si rpaLisv xaxd nlaxtv r) dni6xiav , xd xs *dvxixsiXttL Xu.il( pdvoiisv dvxi xov (iuisxul xoLV&g, xai xb cog i(ioi cpai-

x&g, xovxiaxL

Tteoi

'

1|

vsxai

6vvsx8s%6LLS&a.

oxav ovv sinco

xovxo
cpr\(iL

^navxi Xoyco Xoyog 203 'navxi

xco

i6og dvxixsLxcci',
r}XOVLtivcp

Svvullsl

vn

sllov

:5

sxsQog Xoyog xccxa6xsvdcov xi Soy(iaxix&g, i6og ccvxco xaxd ni6xiv xai dni6xiav, dvxixsi6&aL cpaivsxai fto/', cog slvai xr)v xov Xoyov KQOcpoQav ov Soy(iaxixr\v dXX* dv&Qconsiov nd&ovg
Xoyco,

og xccxa6xsvdsi

xl

Soy(iaxLx&g,

dnayysXiccv, o s6xl Si xivsg xai oftxco

cpaLv6(tsvov
xr\v
cpcovfjv

xco

*nccvxi

nu6ypvxL. nQOcpiQOVxaL 204 Xoyco Xoyov l6ov

dvxixsL6&aL
o

dl-Lovvxsg
xi

TtaQayysXfiaxLXtog

xovxo

*navxi

Xoycp SoyfiaxLxcog

xovvxa,
I

l6ov xaxd nioxiv

dvxiXL&coLLSv',
\6
'i

Lva

xaxa6xsvdovxL Xoyov Soy(iccxix&g fijxai dni6xiav, (luypLLSvov avxco 6 (isv Xoyog uvxoig r\ TtQog xbv 6%sdnuQSLLCpdxcp
f

jtxixov,
*

%Qcovxai

Ss

dvxi

%Q06xaxxLxov ,

xco

dvxLXSL6&aL dvxi xov dvxLXL^&(isv'. naQayyiXXov6L Ss xovxo 205 xa 6xs7txLxcp, firj ncog vnb xov SoyfiaxLxov naQccxQOve&sig
dnsinrj xr\v nsQi avxov
5 xoi~g dxuQtt^iccg,

r\xr\6Lv,

xai

xr)g

cpuivo(iivr\g
xfj

av-

rjv vo(iiov6L

naQvcpi6xa6&aL

nsQi ndv-

xcov

snoyr\, xa&cog

s'(inQ06&sv vns(ivr\6u(isv ( 29),

6<paXr\ nQonsxsv6aLLSvog.

xr\

naQanr\y\x,ttxa

vnsQ x&v 6xsnxix&v

cpcov&v.

HsQi X060VXC0V dQxi6si x&v cpcov&v cog sv vnoxvnco6SL 206 Sls,sX&slv , aXXcog xs xai insi sx x&v vvv r\(iLv SLQr\(iivcov
o

Svvaxov

S6xi

Xiysiv xai nsQi

xcov

nccQaXsXsL(i(iivcov.

nsQL

na6&v yaQ x&v 6xsnxix&v

cpcov&v ixsivo %Qr\ nQOSiXr\cpi-

vai, oxl nsQi xov dXrj&sig avxug sIvccl ndvxcog ov Siafis(iaLOVLis&a , 07Tot; ys xai vcp savx&v avxdg dvaLQSLd&ai
XiyoLcsv

8vva6&UL,

6v(insQLyQacpo(iivag

ixsivoig

nsQl cov

ML:

rcov iyx%r\\idx(av 23 r\TOVLiivcp Gen. i^r\tr\LLivto 27 o r\Tovuivco EB: i^TqxovLiivco jratf^ovn om. 28/29 L'oov uvxLx. c'(vtlxsZ6&ul tov lgov EAB: i'aov om.

17/18

ML

T T

4/o avTfjs scriptas cum

EAB
illis)

8 de
:

tot

autem

14

u.nQLyQ.

GvLnteoLyQ.

T
i*

(circum-

52
Xeyovrav,

IITPPSJNEI&N
4
1

xa&aTteQ rd xa&ccQTvxd r&v cpaQtidxcov ov (ibvov rovg yyfiovg vrte^avQev xov 6co(iccrog, dXXd xcci eavxd rovg 207 %V(xovg 6vvel-dyei. cpa(iev de xai cog ov xvoicog drjlovvxeg

td rtody(Aaxa,
aXX'
itQeitei
xco

ecp*

cov

TtaQccXa(i(3dvovrav,

ri&efiev

avrdg,
2C

ddvacpOQCog xal ei fiovXovxai xaxa%Qr)6xixcog'

ovxe yaQ

6xeitxixco cpcovo(ia%eiv , aXXcog xe r\(ivv 6vveQyei ravrag xdg cpcovdg eiXvxQtv&g 6r\(iccivevv Xeye6&av, 208 dXXd itQog n xal fog TtQog rovg 6xennxovg. TtQog xovxoig xdxeivov 8ev (jvefjtvrj^&av, oxi ov neQi ndvrcov r&v TtQayttdrcov xa&6Xov cpatiev avrdg, dXXd neQi r&v d8r)Xcov xal

to

(xr\8e

r&v doy(ianx&g
cpatiev xal

r\rov(ievcov,

xal orv rb cpavvdfievov

ix

r\(ivv 25

ov%i 8vcc(ieavooTvx&g jteQi rr)g cpv6ecog dnocpavvofie&a'

vnoxev(jtevoov

r&v ixrbg yaQ rovrcov nav 6ocpv6(ia

Svva^d-ai SvarQeneTtQog cpmvr\v ive%&ev 6xenrvxr\v oiofjvat 209 6&av. inei Se rr\v evvovccv xa\ rd (leQrj xal to xQvrr\Qvov
xcci

to reXog, erv Se rovg

TQonovg

rrjg

ino%f\g icpoSev6av-

3(

reg,

xal

iteQi
rf\g

r&v 6xenrvx&v cpcov&v

6xeipeoog
efinecpccvixattev ,

einovreg,

rbv

%a-

Qaxrr\Qa
(le&tt

dxoXov&ov

r\yov-

eivat

xtti

r&v naQaxevitevoov

avfj}

cpvXo6ocpv&v rr\v

TtQog avrr\v StdxQv6vv

rr\v
c

icpexrvxr\v

evvrottoog ineX&eiv, vvcc 6acpe6reQ0v dyeoyr\v xttravor\6co(iev. aQ^cofie&a Se dnb

rr\g

HQccxXetreiov cptXo6ocpiag.

x&'
210

ort SvacpeQev
(

r)

6xenrvxr\ dyooyr\ Tfj^

HQaxXetr(eiyov cpvXo6ocpiag.
"Orv (iev ovv avrr\ SvacpeQev rf\g
r\(jLereQug dycoyf\g, tvqo-

Sr\XoV
Se ov

(iev yttQ

'HQdxXevrog ne^i noXX&v d8f)Xoov dnoinei

cpaiverccv Soyticcrvx&g,

i)(ievg d' ov%i, xa&dneQ ei'Qr\rai. rbv Avvr\6i8r\(iov eXeyov SSbv elvav ne^i (

rr\v

6xeitrixr\v dycoyr\v

irti

rr\v

HQaxXeirevov cpvXo6o-

cpiccv, Svorv TtQor\yevTttv tov rdvttvricc TteQi rb avrb VTtaQ%evv to rdvavria TteQi to ccvrb cpaiveo^ccv, xcci ol (iev OxeitTvxoi cpccive^&av Xeyov6v rd ivavricc Tte^i to avro, ov Se HQccxXeirevov ditb rovrov xcci ini rb v:tdQ%evv ccvrd (lereQyovrav,

22 xai <hg 20 aXXas Bekk.: &XX' a>$ GT (set sicut) Kayser: xaX&g GT (bene) 29 td iiioi] GT (partes): malim tdg dgxag cf. p. 3, 21. 10 6vr\6i8r\(iov G: enesidimum T cf. p. 40, 12.

TnOTTIIEN

A.

53

cpafiev TtQog xovxovg, oxi xo xa evavxta neQt xo avxo cpatve6&ut ov Soyfia 6x1 x&v 6xenxtx&v dXXd nQuyfiu ov ftovov xolg 6xenxixoig dXXd xui xoig uXXotg cptXo6ocpoig xui nu6tv dv&Qconotg vnoninxov' ovSeig yovv xoXfir\6ut uv 211
iO

eineiv

oxt

xb

fieXt

ov yXvxd&t
ntxQu^ei,

xovg vytuivovxug

r)

oxi

xovg ixxeQtxovg ov

co6xe

dnb

xotvf\g

x&v dv-

$5

$Qcbncov nQoXfjtyecog UQyovxut oi 'HQuxXeixetot, xu&dneQ xai r\fieig, t6cog Se xui ai uXXut cptXo6ocpiut. StoneQ ei fiev dno xtvog x&v 6xenxtx&g Xeyofievcov iXdfifiavov xb xdvavxiu TteQi xb avxb vnoxei6&ut, olov xov *ndvxu
e6xiv

dxuxdXr\nxu
t6cog

r)

xov 'ovSev

6o/fo'

r\
'

xtvog
inei

x&v

Tta-

Qa7tXrj6icov ,

uv 6vvf)yov
rjfiiv

o Xeyov6tv

Se aQyug

eypv6tv xui x&

jo

ov fiovov
(iicp

dXXd xui xotg dXXotg cptXo6ocpotg

xi fiaXXov xr\v rjfiexeQuv dycoexu6xr\v x&v dXXcov cptXo6ocpt&v r) xai xbv fiiov bSbv ini xr\v HQaxXeixetov cptXo6ocpiav elvat Xeyot xtg av, enetSrj ndvxeg xotvaig vXatg xeyQrjfie&a; fir)noxe Se 212

vnontnxov6ug,

yr\v

r)

f8

fiovov ov 6vveQyei nQog xr\v yv&6tv xfjg 'H^uxXetxeiov cptXo6ocpiag r\ 6xenxtxr\ dycoyr), dXXd xai dno6vveQyei, ( etye 6 6xenxtxbg ndvxa xu vnb xov HQuxXeixov Soyfiaxt-

ov

Xeybfuva StafSdXXet, ivuvxtovfievog ivuvxtovfievog Se xco xa ivavxia ne^i xb avxb vnaQyetv , xai ini navxbg Soyfiaxog xov HquxXeixov xr\v fiev Soyftaxtxr\v nQonexetuv Stu6vQcov, xb Se
fiev xf\

6fieva

cog

nQonex&g

ixnvQco6et,

*ov xuxuXufifidvco*
cog ecpr\v

xai

xb

'ovSev

oo/fco'

intcp&eyyofievog ,
'HQuxXetxeiotg.

e'fMQ06&ev' uxonov Se i6xt xb xr\v

10

oneQ

fidyexat

xoig

fiuypfievr\v

dycoyqv 6Sbv elvut Xi-

ysiv xf\g utQe6ecog ixeivr\g r\ fidyexut' dxonov uqu xb xr\v 6xenxtxr\v dycoyr\v ini xr\v HQUxXeixetov cptXo6ocpiuv bSbv
eivut Xeyetv.
X'

xivt StucpeQet

r\

6xenxtxr\ dycoyrj xf\g Ar\fio-

XQtxeiov cptXo6ocpiug.

AXXd xui
16 rovrovg
GKSTtrtxav

r)

viuv eyetv nQog

Ar\fioxQixetog cpiXo6ocpiu Xeyexut xotvco- 213 xr\v oxetptv, inei Soxei xr\ uvxr\ vXr\ r\fiiv

ML
7

EAB

avrovg EAB ad quos ita dicimus T 24 ov xaruX. Stephanus: ov% vnoXuttfidvco GT

:
: ||

(non presumo)

10 Xiyetv (nobg yva>6tvy Kayser

r\g

EAB

54

IITPP&NEI&N
i!

xexQ^&at' dnb yaq xov xoig (iev yXvxv cpaive6&cci xb fieXi xoig 8e nixQov xbv drjfioxgixov (A 134 Diels) imXoyie6&ai cpcc6i xb (ii)xe yXvxv ccvxb elvai (ifjxe

niXQov, xal

8id xovxo

emcp&eyyea&tti xr)v
8iacpoQatg fievxoi
xcci

ov

ii,aXXov'
xr\

cpcovi)v 6xenxixr)v

ov6av.
ini

iq&vxccl

'ov
2<i

(iccXXov' cpcovr) oi' xe

6xenxixoi

ol

dnb xov 4i](aoxqixoV

elvai,

ixeivoi

(iev

yccQ

xov

(ir)8exeQ0v

xaxxov6i

xr)v

cpatvr)v^ r)(ieig 8e iiti

214 ftexeQOv
(iev

xi

e6xi

x&v

xov dyvoeiv, noxeQOv dficpoxeQa r) ov&6xe xai xaxd xovxo cpaivofievoov.

r)

diacpeQopev, nQo8r)Xoxdxr) 8e yivexai

6idxQi6ig oxccv
2;,
'

Xeyrj *exer) 6e axofia xai * xevov'. *ixerf (iev yaQ Xeyei dvxi xov dXrj&eicc* xax dXr)6e vcpe6xdvat Xeycov xdg xe dxofiovg xai xb xevbv ort fteiav

6 4r](t,6xQixog

(B 9 Diels)

8ievr)vo%ev r)(i&v, ei xai dnb xr)g dvcofiaXiag voov ttQ%exai, neQixxov olfiai Xeyeiv.

x&v

cpaivofie-

Xa
215

xiw

6iacpeQei xr)g KvQr)va'ixr)g

r)

r)

6xetyig.
29 30

KvQ7)va'ixr) dyayr) i) ccvxr) idrtT?} 6xetyei, iitei6r)xdxeivr)x a nd&r) fiova cpr)6i xaxaXa(i(idve6&CU. 8iacpeQei 8e avxr)g, inei8r)ixeivr) (iev xr)v r)8ovr)v xcci xi)v Xeiav xrjg 6ccQxbg xivr)6iv xeXog elvat Xeyei, r)(ieig
6e
xr)v dxccQaijittV) r) ivavxiovxai xb xccx ixeivovg xiXog' xai yuQ %ccQ0v6r)g xr)g i)6ovr)g xcci (ir) naQ0V6r)g xccQa%dg vnofievei 6 8ittfiefiaiov(ievog xeXog elvcci xr)v r)8ovijv, &g iv

0a6i6e xivegoxi

4*

xg> Tte^i

xov xiXovg ( 25

30)

ineXoyt6d(ir)v.

elxcc r)(ieig
5

(ihv ine^pitev o6ov ini x& Xoyat ne^i x&v ixxbg vnoxeifievatVy oi 8e KvQrjvccixoi dnocpaivovxai cpv6iv ccvxd e%ei.v dxaxd-

Xrptxov.

ifl

xivv SiccyeQei xr)g IlQOXccyoQeiov dywyfjg

6xeipig.

r)

216

Kai

IlQmxayoQag (A 14

Diels) 8e (iovXexcct

xcov iQr)(idxcov elvcci (nexQOv xbv av&Qoinov,

ndvx&v (iev

30/31 xaraXa(idve6&aL Pohlenz coll. adv. dogm. I 191: xaxaXaii^dveiv GT (comprehendere) 5 neol om. T

TnOTTII2EN
9

A.

55
cog
,

)ovxcov
') <

cog

e6xcv,

x&v

de

ovk ovxcov
'
|

ovx e6xcv,
x&v
jtQuyfid-

'fiixQOv' fiev Xiycov xb XQixr\Qcov,

Tcov,
elvcci

/ )

Qr](^dxcov

6e

cog

dvvdfiec

<pa6xecv
kccc

jtdvxcov
fiev

xbv av&Qconov, x&v

eoxiv.

XQCxr\Qcov ovxcov (hg e6xcv, x&v 8e ovx

TCQuyfidxcov
xid"r\6c to: cpacvofjcevcc
xc.

ovxcov cog ovx

8cd xovxo

exa6xcp jiidva, xccl ovxcog eccdyec xb itQog xocvcoviav e%ecv itQog xovg IIvQQcoveiovg.

dcb

xccl

8oxec 217

dcacpeQec 8e av-

x&v, xuc ecobfie&a

xb

xr\v 8ca<poQav,
<pr\6cv

Soxovv

xco

TlQCOxayoQa.

iccTtXco6avxeg 6v(jcfiixQcog ovv 6 dvr\Q xr\v vXr\v

Q~ev6xr\v eivccc, Qeov6r\g 8e avxrjg

[1

6vve%&g jtQ06&i-

)6ecg dvxl
6d"f\6ecg

ujto<pOQr\6ecov yiyve6d"ac xal xdg aixe kccc dXXocov6$ai fiexaK06(iec6d-ac

218

x&v

xe (xdgy r}Xcncag kccc jtccQtt xdg dXXag kccxcx6xevag x&v 6cofidxcov. Xiyec 8e kccc xovg Xoyovg itdvto)v twv cpacvofievav v7tOKec6&cct iv xrj vXr\, cog 8vvcc6&tti xr\v fiXrjv o6ov icp iccvxrj jtdvxa elvac 06a Jtcc6c cpccivexac. xovg 8e dv&Qcojtovg dXXoxe

jtuQu

aXXcov dvxcXafifidvee&ac jtaQa xdg dcacpOQOvg ccvx&v 8cttd"i6ecg' xbv /u,ev yaQ Kaxd <pv6cv e%ovxa iKecva x&v iv xr\ v"Xr\ KaxaXu(i(5dvecv a Tofg Kaxd
<pv6cv eiov6c cpacve6&ac dvvaxac, xbv 8e JtccQa <pv6cv u xocg jtaQa <pv6cv. kccc r\8r\ jtccQtt xag 219 r\XcKcug kuc xaxd xb vitvovv r) iyQr\yoQivac ku\ xad~ exa6xov eldog xcov 8ta&i6ecov 6 ccvxbg Xoyog. yivexccc xoivvv kccx ccvxbv x&v bvxcov xQcxr\Qcov 6 uv&QcoTtog' Ttuvxu yttQ xd cpcccvofieva xocg uv&qcoTtocg kccI e6xcv, xa 8e fir\Sevc x&v dv&QcoJtcov cpacivbfieva ovSe e6xcv. OQ&fiev ovv oxc kccI TteQc xov xr\v
i

v"Xr\v

fiivcov

Qev6xr\v elvac Kal Tteoc xov xovg Xoyovg x&v cpcccvoTtdvxcov iv ccvxr} VTtoxec6&ttc doyfiuxifec, u8r\Xcov
r\ficv

ovxcov kccc

icpeKX&v.

11
(ita):

(litqov

14

diu rovro

addidi coll. p. 49, 31. tovg G

Horcv om. EAB 15 ovrcog LEABT 1G IIvqq. om. T 15 Scb 22 rdg 30 rov T (praeter natwram habentem):

56
Xy

IITPP&NEI&N
xivt
i)

lacpiocL xr)g 'Axccdrjficcixrjg cptXo6ocpiag

r)

6xitytg.
r)

220
iari

Qa6i
xr\

(livxot xtveg oxt

'Axa8r\(LaCxr\ cptXo6ocpia
ei'r)

r)

avxr)

6xityet'

dioneo dxoXov&ov av

xai

rteoi

rovrov

SteijeX&eiv. ^Axa8r\\xiat 8e yeyova6tv, cog cpa6i(v ot^) TtXeiovg p}], XQetg, (tia (iev xai aQ%aioxdxr\ r) xcov neqi nXccrcova, devreqa 8e xai (iior\ r) r&v Ttegi ^AQxeeiXaov rbv dxov6rr\v UoXi(icovog, roirr\ 8e xai via r) rcov neoi KaQvedSr\v xai KXetr6(ia%ov' evioi

TtQoert&iaet rr\v rteqi &iXcova xai riveg 8e xai 7ti(i7trr\v xaraXiyov6t rr\v 221 Tteqi [tov] *Avrio%ov. aQ%d(ievoi xoivvv dnb T-Jjg aQyaiag i'8co(iev xr\v (jtQog r)(iagy 6uxcpoQav xcov eiQr\(iivcov cpiXo6ocpicbv. rbv IlXdrcova ovv 01 (iev 8oy(iartxbv l'cpa6av elvai, ol 6e d7toQr\rtx6v, oi 8e xard (iiv rt d%OQr\rixov, xard 6i xi 8oy(iaxix6v' ev (iev yaQ xoig yv(iva6xixoig \cpa6i\ Xoyotg, ev&a 6 2coxQaxr\g et6ayexai
8e xai rerdorr\v

XaQ(iidav

nai^cov rtQog xivag r) dycovt6(ievog 7tQog 6oo?i6xdg, yv(iva6xixov xe xai aTtoQrjxtxov cpa6tv e%etv avxbv %aQaxxr\Qa, Soynartxbv 8i7 ev&a 67tov8dcov ditocpaivexai r\xoi
r\xot

222

Sicc

2coxQarovg

r)

Tifiaiov

r\

rivog xcov xotovxcov.

r)

TteQi (iev

ovv
vvv'
8e

rcov 8oy(iartxbv

avrbv elvai Xeyovxcov,

r)(iag

8oy(iarixov, xaxd 8i xt cc7t0Qr\xix6v,

xard (iiv rt 7teQi66ov av eir\ Xiyetv

8tacpOQdv.
Tteqi

avxoi yaQ 6(ioXoyov6t xr\v TtQog

ei

xov

e6xtv eiXtxQtv&g

6xe7txtxbg

TtXaxvxeQov

(iev

ev

220235

(om. fort. 228225)

p. 32.

Aenesidemo

attribuit

Natorp Mus. Rhen. 38

7 dh

cunam

5 literarum, ol suppl.
|| ||

MEAB
delevi

add. (iev

habet lapost cpaai 8 post TtXeiovg EAR 9 xbv xai (iia EAB xbv EAB r) del. Kayser 12 xr\v Fabr.: xcov G 13 xr\v (x&v^ Gen. 14 xbv

om.

||

yeybvasiv om.

EAB

||

Kayser

||

17 17/18 15 ngbg ijficcg suppl. coll. 50,26. 52,5. 19 cpccd om. T 21 25 dnoQrjxvKov Bekk. dnoQrKiaxiKbv Gr 21 yv(tvaarixov xe xai del. ut glossema Riistow 26 xai xr\v EAB quae inter nos et illos est differentia T
:
||

TII0TTII&2ESN

A.
cog iv

57
vTtoxvnco-

oig V7t0(ivr)(iu6i diuXufifidvofisv, vvv Ss

siXiyofisv

xuxd^xovgynsQi Mr)v6doxovxuiAivr}6iSr)fiov (ovxoi yuQ (idXi6xa xavxrjg rtQoi6xr)6uv xfjg 6xu6scog), oxi oxav
6 IlXdxcov drtocpuivr)xut Tteol iSecov r) neol xov Ttoovoiav eivai r) 7tsoi xov xbv ivdgexov fiiov aioexcbxeoov eXvui xov
i

(iexd

xuxicov,

Soyfiuxi&i,
xqivet xi
5

v7tdo%ov6i xovxoig 6vyxuxuxi&exui, TU&avcoxiootg 7tQ06xi&exui, iTtei txqoxuxu 7ti6xiv r) urti6xiuv, ixnicpevye xbv 6xenxicog

elxe

eixe

cog

xbv */uQaxxf)Qu'
ix
xcov

cog

yuQ xui xovxo

eiQr)fiivcov

r)fitv

e'fi7tQ06&ev

7tQoSr)Xov.

i6xiv dXXoxQiov, ei 6i xiva xai 223-

oxuv, cog cpaGt, yvfivdr)xui, ov rtQOcpiQSxui, xovxo s6xut 6xe7txixbg' 6 yuQ ns^i svbg Soyfiuxicov, tcuqu
6xS7txixcog
^
r}

dni6xiav
o

cpavxa6iav cpavxa6iag oXcog xaxd 7ti6xiv r) drtocpuivofisvogy rtSQi xivog xcov dSf)Xcov, xov Soyfiuxixov yivexai yuQuxxf)Qog, cog SrjXoi" xai 6 Tificov (Fr.
TtQOXQivcov
(r)

poet. phil. p.

200

Diels

= Vorsokr.

11

A 35)

Sid xcov iteQi

Ssvocpdvovg avxco Xeyofiivcov. iv noXXotg yuQ uvxbv irtui- 224 vi6ag [xbv evocpdvr)v\, cog xai xovg 6iXXovg avxco dvu&etvui, inoir)6ev
5

cog

avxbv oSvQOfievov xai Xiyovxa xai iycov bcpsXov nvxivov voou dvxi($oXr)6ui

SoXir) S 6Sco i,urtuxr)&r)v dfKpoxsQoftXsTtxog' 7tQS6fivysvr\g ex icov xai d(iev&r)Qi6xog dnu6r)g

6xenxo6vvr)g.
eig sv
o
l

xavxo xs Ttdv dvsXvsxo'

onnr) yuQ ifibv voov SLQv6aifii, nuv S ibv aisi

>

dvsXxbfisvov fiiav sig cpv6tv i6xa& bfioirjv. Siu xovxo yovv xai vrtdxvcpov avxbv Xiysi, xai ov xiXsiov
Ttdvxrj

uxvcpov, Si

cov cpr]6i

(Diels Vorsokr.

11

35)
\\

xaxd (yovgy Xiyofisv T (dicimus): dtaXafipdvofisv G Mr\v6Sorov Natorp: xard itsQfifjdotov GT (secundum permindotum) xatd MrjvoSotovFsibT.: xaTo^ifoooVro^Pappenheim 6 6xsrttixd EAB 7 hsqI tovtov EAB 8 olcog om. T 9 add. Pappenheim 25 dii6VQSv om. T 12 iv 13 x.

29

tisqI

||

S. del. Kayser

16

dficpotSQoflXsTttog

LM:

EAB:

aficpotSQopXirttov dubit. dubit. Bekk. ts yiQcov Nauck 18 07ir] ML: 07rov Qi6tog G
:

Bekk.

17 h'

dficpotsQo^XsTtta d>v G: iticov

ttjs

EAB

20

6(iolr\v

Bergk: dnev&rj19 tavt6 ts ML: ro:rdEAB: buoia L: i606ta& fioir\v 21 ts-

EAB

dfisv&rjQtatog

Xsiag Menagius

58

IITPP&NEI&N
Setvocpdvrjg vrtdxvcpog, bfit}Qandxr}g irti6xcbrtxr}g,
ei

xbv

an

dv&Qcbrtcov &ebv inXdaax

r)e

l6ov drtdvxr},

(dxQefir)y a6xr}&r) vosQcoxeQOv

vorffia.

vrtdxvcpov fiev yaQ xrjg de irti6xcbrtxr}v,

elrte

xbv xaxd xi dxvcpov,

bfirjQartd-

irtei xr)v

TtaQ '0(ir}QCp drtdxr\v diiavQev.

225 i8oy(idxte Se 6 Sevocpdvrjg naQcc xag x&v dXXcov dvd-Qcbrtcov 7tQoXr)vjeig *iv elvat xb rtdv, xai xbv &ebv 6vftcpvr) xoig TtaGiv, elvai 6e 6<paiQoet8r) xai drtaftr) xa\ dfiexdfiXrjxov xai Xoyixbv' o&ev xai QaStov xr)v Eevocpdvovg
TtQog
aXX*

x&v

eiQrjfievcov

IlXdxcov,

7tXr)v dXX ix diacpoQctv irttSeixvvvat. rtQodrjXov, oxi xav TteQi xivcov irtartOQrj 6 inei ev xt6i cpalvexav r) ne^i vnaQ^ecog dno-

r)fiag

cpaivofievog
7ti6xiv,

rtQayfidxcov

dSr)Xcov

r)

rtQOXQtvcov
ei

adrjXa xaxd

226

ovx dv eir} 6xertxixog. Oi Se dnb xr)g viag 'AxaSrjfiiag,

xai

dxaxdXrjnxa

elvai rtdvxa cpa6i, 6ia<peQ0v6i x&v 6xertxix&v t6cog (iev xa\ xax avxb xb Xiyeiv rtdvxa eivai dxaxdXr}7txa (Stafiefiaiovvxai

yaQ rte^i xovxov, 6 Se 6xertxixbg ivSiie6&at xai xaxaXrjtpdv)vai xiva rtQ068oxa), SiacpiQ0v6i Se r)(i&v 7tQoSr)Xcog iv xrj x&v dyaft&v xai x&v xax&v XQieei. dya&bv yaQ xi cpa6iv alvai oi AxaSr}fia'Cxoi xai xaxbv ov% cog r)fieig, dXXd fiexd xov rterteie&at oxi rti%avdv i6xi fiaXXov o Xi-

yov6iv elvai dya&bv vrtdQ%eiv r) xb ivavxiov, xai irti xov xaxov bfioicog, r)fi&v dya&ov xi r) xaxbv elvai
Xeyovxcov ovSev fiexa xov rti&avbv elvat voftieiv o cpafiev, dXX aSo^dexcog ertOfiivcov xcb ico, iva fir) aveviQyrjxot cofiev. 227 xdg xe <pavxa6iag r)(ietg fiev t6ag Xiyofiev elvai xaxa
rtiexiv
r)

drti6xiav

060V

irti xco

Xoyco,
II

ixeivoi Se
cf.

xag

fiev

adv. dogm. 226231 LXVT(1911) p. 190 sqq.

166189,

Mus. Rhen.

23 &sivo<pdvr\g Gen.: Sevo<pdvr\g G 24 si xbv Diels: ?a xbv G: x xbv Paris. Suppl. 133: ixxbg Bekk.: bg xbv Roe25 dxQSfir) add. per an' dv&Qwitoov Fabr.: dndvd-Qanov G Diels vosqwxsqov Diels: vosqoxov G 26 fisv om. L 26/27 6 inanoQei b(ir\Qandxr\g M: d(i,r\Qandxr\v L 6fLVQandxr\v EAB EAB 8 &8r\Xa (ddrjXav) Pappenheim 10 ot MET (qui autem): ov L: sl AB (deerat prima litera in archetypo) 11 12 ndvxa om. tlvav MLT (esse): ovv EAB 7tdvxa om. 13 xai om. T 14 et in T 19 dya&oov et xaxcov EAB
||

||

||

I
i
i

xnoTxn^sE^N
Se

a.

59

yccOt xdg Ss dnt&dvovg. xal x&v niXeyovat StucpoQdg'xdg uev yao ccvxb uovov ni&avdg vnaQ%etv fjyovvxai, xdg 8s nt&avdg xa\ Steo38evuevag xdg 8e nt&avdg xa\ neQtcoSevuevag xa\ dneQtandaxovg. olov iv oixca axoxeiva noo&g xetuevov a%otviov ianetQauevov nt&avf) dnX&g cpavxaaia yivexai dnb xovxov &g dnb bcpecag xa> d&QOtog ineiaeXd-ovxt' xm uevxot neQtaxonf\Oavxt dxQt&g 228 xal Ste^oSevOavxt xa neQt avxo,olov oxt ov xtveixat, oxt xb XQ&(ia xoiov ioxt, xcct x&v dXXcav exaOxov, cpaivexat 0%otviov xaxd xf\v qpavxaaiav xr\v nt&aTT.lft iti&avug slvai

&av&v

xa\ nsQtcoSsvuivrjv. r) Ss xat dnsQianccaxog cpavxaaia xotdSe iaxiv. Xeyexat 6 HQaxXfjg dnodavovaccv xr\v "AXxr\Oxtv av&tg i"At8ov dvayayeiv xat deiijat xa> ^ASuf^xco, og nt^avr^v (uev) iXdufiave cpavxaaiav xr\g ^AXxf^axtSog xa\ iteQico8evuivr\V inet uevxot rjdet oxt xe&vr^xev, neQtecnaxo avxov f) dtdvoia ditb tt/ Ovyxaxad-ioecog %a\ TtQog dntoxiav exXtvev. <(....]> nQOXQivovOtv 229 ovv oi ix xf\g viag *Axa8r\uiag xfjg uev nt&avfjg dnX&g xr\v nt&avr\v xcct neQta>8evuivr\v cpavxaaiav, ducpoxeQmv Se xovxcav xr\v ni$ccvr\v xat nsQtaSsvuivr\v xa\ dnsQionaaxov. ei Ss xa\ nsi&sa&ai xtaiv oi xe dnb xfjg 'AxaSr/uiag xai oi dnb ttjj Oxstysoig XsyovOt, xb 230 7tQoSr\log xa\ r\ xaxd xovxo SiacpoQa x&v cpiXoaocpi&v.
vr\v

yaQ nsi&sa&cct Xiysxat SiacpoQmg, xb xs ur\ dvxtxsivstv dXX anX&g snso&ai dvev acpoSQccg nQoaxXiascog xai nQOOna&siag,
cog

6 Ttaig

(lexd cciQSOscog

Xso&cct

nsi&sa&cci Xsysxat x& ncctSaytoyco' dnail Ss xb xa\ oiovet Ovuna&eiccg xccxd xb acpoSQa ovavyxaxari&so&ai xtvt, fog 6 dacoxog nei&excct xa.

SanccvnxLx&g fitovv dt^iovvxt.

SioneQ inet8r\ oi

KccQvsd8r\v

xa\

KXstxotia^ov

usxd

uev neQt nQOOxXiascog

26/27 nsQicod. Kayser 1 xccl post Sh om. T 4 os iti&ausv T (qui probabilem quidem sumebat): xccl tcl&ccvtjv G 17 xlvl: 5 cf. Mus. Rhen. 1. 1. 11 fortasse Xiyovxcci \h&ncch, et consentire alicui secundum valde. cum electione et quasi con18 moventiT 15 xb Gen.: xa> (x 17 6 om. L passione T
vijv

60

IITPP&NEI&N
xcci nt&ccvbv eivcci xi <pa6tv, etxetv dvev nQ06ncc&elag, xai xaxd

6<poSQag 71S1&E6&C11 xe
Se r)(ie tg

xaxd xb dnXcog
avxcov
xf)g

231 xovxo
xiXog

ccv

Sta<peQOi(iev.

Sta<peQO(iev

veccg 'AxaSrjfiiag'

dXXd xai iv xotg itQog xb ol fiev yaQ xax

avxrjv xo6(iet6&ttt Xeyovxeg dvS^eg xco

nt&avco nQ06%Qcov-

xat xaxd xbv (3iov, rjfietg Sh xotg v6(ioig xai xotg e&e6t xai xotg <pv6txotg nd&e6tv enottevot ($tov(iev ccdod6xcog. xai nXeico 6* av etno(iev nQog xr)v 8tdxQt6tv, ei (ir\ tjjj
6vvxo(iiag i6xoyu6[ie&tt.

232

fievxoi 'AQxe6llaog, ov xfjg (xe6r)g AxaSr\[iiccg iXiyofiev elvcct nQ06xdxr\v xai aQyr\y6v, ndvv (lot Soxet xotg HvQQcoveiotg xotvcovetv Xoyotg, chg (itav elvat 6yeSbv xr)v xccx'

avxbv dycoyr\v xai

r)

xr)v r)(iexeQav'

ovxe yaQ ne^i vndQ^ecog

avvnaQ^iag xtvbg dno<pcctv6(ievog evQi6xexat, oftxs xaxd ni6xiv r) dnt6xiav nQOXQivet xt exeqov
exeQOv, dXXd ns^i
elvcct

ndvxcov ine%et.
r)

xcci

xiXog

(ihv

6vvst6SQyE6&ut xr\v dxuQcc^iuv 233 r)(ietg i<pa6xo(jtsv. Xeyei Sh xai dya&d fihv elvat xdg xccxd fiSQog ino%dg, xccxd Sh xdg xaxd fiEQog 6vyxccxtt&eeetg.
xb
cpatvofisvov

xr)v

ino^Vy

ixxbg si
rjfitv

(ir\

Xsyot xtg,
Xiyo(isv

oxt
xcci

r)(isig

fihv xccxd

xuvxa

ov

Sius(5atcofihv

xtxStg, ixstvog Sh cog

slvttt

nQog

xr\v <pv6tv, co6xs

xai dya&bv

avxbv Xiystv

xr)v inoyr\v,

xaxbv Sh

xr\v

6vyxaxd&s6tv.

234

avxov Xsyofisvotg nt6xsvstv^ cpa6iv HvQQCovstog icpaivsxo sivui, xaxd Sh xr\v dXrj&stav Soyfiuxtxbg r)v' xai insi xcov sxaiQcov dnbnstQccv ikd(i(3av Std xr)g dnoQr)xixr)g, si svcpvcog syov6t n^bg
si Sh

Sst xai xotg nsQi

oxt xttxd (ihv xb nQoystQOv

xr\v

dvd\r\tyiv

xcov

IJXaxcovtxcov

Soyfidxcov,

S6at

ccvxbv

dnoQr\xtxbv sivut, xotg (livxot ye sv<pvs6t x&v sxuiQcov xd J IlXdxcovog nuQsyystQStv. ev&ev xui xbv AQi6xcova (Stoic fr. I 344 Arn. cf. Z 181) einetv ne^i ccvxov

20 ocpodQ&g L 22 -xsqI xov xiXovg T (de fine) 23/24 qui 3 est esse ipsam decora videntur viri T 31 elvoct doxelv 5 (sic) T, unde fortasse verbum eliciendum: liyet vel cpr\<sl

iycxbg scripsi coll. p. 243, 12.

746,26: ibv
r)(Lelg (ihv

M:

i)xoi tcXtjv

LEAB

nisi quis dicat

||

Xeyet

L
||

||

||

avxbv scripsiT secutus (unde

et

om. L 8 slvai om bonum quidem ipse dicit)

rcaxd ixiQtov

ai)xr\v

G llixl LEAB

14

kxaiQcov

MT

kxsQtov

M: sodalium T:

LEAB

(sodalium):

ixiQwv

LEAB

15

TtaQey%st-

TnOTTn&2EN
7tQ06& TJXttXCQV,

A.

61

bm&EV

IIvQQCOV, (l660g ALoScOQOg,

xf\

xb TtQO^XQ^&cct xf\ SluXekxlk^ ccl 8s avxiKQvg HXaxcovLKov.

Kccxd xbv AloScoqov,

01

8s TtEQt <%>iXcovd CpCC6LV

060V

(ISV

inl XCpSxCOLKCp 235

xy KaxaXrjnxLKfj <pavxa6ia, ttKaxaXr\%xa slvcci xcc nQayfiuxu, o6ov 8h inl xrj <pv6si xcov nQuyfidxcov uvxcov, KuxuXr\nxu. dXXu Kal 5 *Avxio%og xr\v Hxoav (isxf)yayv Eig xr\v AKu8r\fiiuv, cog
txrjQico,
Kccl

xovx6xi

e%eSelkvve

xa Hxcoma' EiQffi&ai in avxco oxi iv'AKaSr\fiicc cpi,Xo6ocpsi~ oxv itccQct HXdxcovi kelxccl xa xcov yccQ
cog

Zxcolkcov Soyfiaxcc.
dycoyr\g

nQo8r\Xov slvai xr\v

xs
xr\v

dLacpOQCcv

TtQog

xr\g 6KsnxLKf\g xsxaQxrjv kccl xr\v nifinxr\v

KttXovfiivr\v ^AKa8r\(iiav.

X8*

si

r)

kccxcc xr\v iccxQLKr\v

ifinELQta

r)

avxf) i6XL

Xfj 6KEll>El.

'Ensl
6el

8s kul

xf)

ifinELQia

xf\

Kaxd

xr\v

236 laxQLKrjv cciQi-

xr\v avxf\v

eIvul

Xiyov6L xivsg xr\v 6KEitXLKr\v <piXo6o-

tpiccv,

aKccr) ifinELQiu Ksivr\ nsQL xr\g xcov d8f)Xcov SiaEuLOvxcci, ovxs r) ccvxf) i6xi xy xaXr\tpiag 6KE1pL 0VXE UQfl6oi CCV XCO 6XE7tXLKC0 Xr\V ULQS6LV iKEtvrjV

yvco6xiov oxi, elksq

fiaXXov 8s xr\v KaXovfiivrjv (ti&oSov, cog Svvccixo ccv fisxLEVccL' avxrj yttQ fiovr\ xcov Kaxd 237 ifiol Sokel, XCOV dSf)XcOV SoKEL fir\ TtQOTtSLttXQLY.r\V CCLQE6EC0V JtEQL flV XEV6&ai, noxEQOv KuxuXr\nxd i6xiv r) dKaxdXr\7txa Xiyuv
dvaXccfjLfSdvELV.

av&cc8iccofiivr\) xoig 8e
I

cpaivofiivoLg inofiivr\

dnb xovxcov
XCOV
6K7tXL-

,}

XttflfidvE L

XO

6VflCpiQLV

SoKOVV
ca

M%cov

aKoXov&iuv. iXiyofiEv
6

Kaxd Xr\V yaQ iv xoig

kccl

fntQ06&v

( 23), oxl 8 iog

d' iv

KOLvog,

XEXQCcfiQf)g i6xiv, xb fiiv xi %cov

iv

vcpr\yr\6EL

6KnxiKog %Qf\xai, <pv6cog, xb

dvdyKrj ncc&cov, xb <5' iv 7tccQcc866L voficov xe kccI J i&cov, xb 8 iv 8Lda6KaXia XEyycov. co67tQ ovv Kccxd xr\v 238 uvdyKtjv xcov TCa&cov 6 6KE7txLKog VTtb fihv Siipovg inl

noxbv
uXXcov
eigecv

68r\yLxai,
bfioicog,

vnb 8e
ovxco
jj

kcc\

Xl(iov inl XQO<pr)v, Kal ini xi xcov xcov 6 fiE&odLKog iaxQog vnb

exinde fertur autem): iitsi $i\ L: insidtj Ss tgbg om. T cf. p. 56,1

Bekk. dubit.

T 30

insl ds

EABT

(quando

9 <xai>

iliy. edd.

16 iu-

62

IITPP&NEI&N
vnb
(Jtsv

rta&cov inl tu xutdXXrjXu b8r)ysttat,

irti tr)v

6tsyvco6scog

iavvco6tv, xatacpsvyst ttg drtb tf)g Siu tyvypg irtttstufiivov 7tvxvco6scog irti dXiuv, vrtb 8s 6v6scog ini
cog

rf)v

irtoir)v

avtf)g,
xccl

cbg

xai ot iv fiaXavsico idQ&ti

irti

JtoXXco

tr)v ixXv6(isvot ino%r)v avtov naQuyivovtat xai 8td tovto irti tbv tyv%Qbv uequ xutaott 6s xai td <pv6st dXXotQtu i%i tf)v uq6iv cpsvyov6tv.

7tSQiQQs6{isvoi

avtcov iivat xatuvuyxd&t, 7tQo8r)Xov, onov ys xui 6 xvcov 6x6Xortog uvtco xutunuysvtog ini tf)v uq6iv avtov naQayivs-

239 tai.

xai tva

(ir)

xa& sxa6tov

ttxbv tQonov

tf)g 6vyyQucpf)g,

ndvta

Xiycov ixfiaivco tbv vnotvncool(iat ta vnb tcov (is&o-

8txcov ofttco Xs yofisva vnota666&ai

Svvu6&ut

tr)

ix tcov na-

&cov dvdyxr\, tcov ts xata <pv6tv (xui tcov rtUQU <pv6tvy, rtQog tco xai tb d86%u6tov ts xai d8tucp0Q0v tf)g iQi)6scog tcov ovo-

240 (idtcov xotvbv slvai tcov dycoycov. ,u6tcog) %Qf)tai tf) 'ovdsv 6p/co'
f

cbg

yuQ 6 6%sntiY.bg (d8oxai xai

tr)

cpcovr)

*ov8sv xa(is ftodiKb g

iuXu(i(5dvco,
'

xa&dnsQ

siQrjxafisv,

otitco

xotvotr)tu Xiyst xui '^irjxsiv' xui tu naQanXr)6iu dnsQtiQycog. ofttco 8s xai tb tr)g ivSsi^scog ovofiu d8ou6tcog tcuquXu(idvst dvti tf)g dnb tcov cputvo(iivcov nu&cov tcov ts
rcov naQU <pv6tv 68r}yf)6scog ini tu xutuXXrjXu slvut Soxovvtu, cog xui ini Sityovg xui ini Xtfiov xui 241 tcov dXXcov vns(ii(ivrj6xov. o&sv olxstotr]td ttvu s%stv tf)v

xutu <pv6tv xui

dycoyr)v

tr)v

tytv, (i&XXov

xutu iuxQtxr)v t&v (isd-oStxcov rtQog tf)v 6xst&v uXXcov xutu iutQtxr\v uIqs6scov (xui cbg

rtQog 6vyxQt6tv ixsivcov, ov% unXcog), Qrjtiov ix tovtcov xui tcov nuQunXr\6icov tovtotg tsx(iutQO(isvovg.

Toeuvtu xui

rtSQi

tcov

rtUQuxst6&ui

8oxovvtcov

tr\

xutu tovg 6xsnxtxovg dycoyfj ^ts^sX&ovtsg, iv tovtotg dnuQtio(isv tov ts xu&6Xov tf)g 6xsipscog Xoyov xui tb rtQcotov tcov vrtotvrtco6scov 6vvtuy(ia.
17 ini rf)v om. EAB
ifiTtsigtav

(ad experientiam) , at

20 24

ol

EAB

23 agaiv Pappenheim: cpvatv 29 add. Steph. 31/32 suppl. e T

GT

cf. p.

66,5.

(naturam)

(inopinabiliter

5/6 eaqueconvenientiaessevidenturT 7 v7ts(ii(ivrj6xov Bekk.: v71ohl(ivt)gxov LT (memorans): v7to(ii(ivfjaxav EABM 11 rex(iaiQO(iivovg LMT (argumentantes) rsxnatQO(tivotg EAB
utitur)
:

IITPP&NEI&N TII0TTII&2E&N
TSN EIS TPIA TO AETTEPON.
Vdds svsGtiv iv
a

ta dsvtsQco t&v IIvqq(ovsC(ov

vnotv7C(b6s(ov.

$
y
S'
S'

si Svvarat ^rjTslv 6 axsitTixos nsgl r&v Xsyofiivcav itccQcc roig Soyitarfnolg nofrsv aQnriov rf)g 7iobg tous doypaTixovg fcTiTrjascog

jisqI XQlTTjQlOV sl xqlttJqiov uXrifrsiag

&m

TtSQl
tcsqI

s'

rf
fr'
l

tisqI

jisqI sl &rrt rt cpvasi ccXrj&ig 71SqI ar\(Lsiov sl &?rt rt er}(islov

7CsqI ccitodsli-stog sl lartv &7t6Ssi^tg
itSQi avXXoytaficbv jcsqI iTtaycoyfjg

TOV VCp' OV tov oV ov ' tov xa-d o aXrj&ovg xai ccXrj&siag

1

ta'

ivSsixTixov

iy' tS'
is'

>i|3' tf
ir\

l<5

TtSQl QQCOV tisqI SiaiQiascov itSQl Tf)g 6v6(tarog stg ari(iaiv6(isva SiatQiascog sl SiaiQSiTai bXov sig (iiQT\ tisqI ysvcov

i&'
x'

xa'
x/S'

xai siScov %sqI xotvcbv av(L^sPr\x6Ttov

71sqI aocptaitaTcov

a
,

el

Svvarui

r)rstv 6 6Y.STtriY.6g tzsqi r&v Xsyofisvcov naoa roig Soy(iariY.otg.

tovg SoyiiartKOvg
(isrfjk-

Knsl Ss

ri)v r)rr)6iv rr)v Ttobg

&OIISV, sxa6rov

r&v (iso&v

rf^g xuXovfisvrjg q>iXo6oqjiag

6vv-

rt frjrfiv

||

19/20 awTOficog G:

celeriter

64
xoficog

IITPP&NEI&N
80

xai vnoxvncoxtx&g icpoSev6co(iev, tcqozbqov dnoxQtvdnobg xovg dei d-QvXovvxag cog (i,r\xe r\xetv fif)xe voetv oXcog otog xe Igxiv 6 6xenxtxbg ne^i x&v 6oy2 fiaxto(ievcov naQ avxotg. cpad yccQ cog r\xot xaxaXafifisvoi

6xenxtxbg xa vnb x&v Soyuaxtx&v Xeyoueva ov xaxaXafifidvei' xai ei (iev xaxaXaufidvet, n&g r) v dnoQoir\ neQi cov xaxetXrjcpevat Xeyet; eiS'ov xaxaXaufidvet, aQa neQt cov ov xaxeiXr\cpev ovSe olSe
(lavet o

85

3 Xiyetv.
*

&6neQ yaQ
o

ur\

eiScog, ei xv^ot, xi ictxt xb

TteQtatQOVfievov r) xb Stcc Svo xQontx&v * # d ecoQr\ua, ovSe einetv xt Svvaxat ne^i avxcov, o#- 3( xcog 6 fii} ytvco6xcov exaSxov x&v Xeyofievcov naQcc xotg Soyfiaxtxotg ov Svvaxat r\xetv nQog avxovg
,

xa&

neQt cov ovx olSev. ovSafi&g aQa Svvaxat r\xeiv 6 Gxenxtxbg neQt x&v Xeyofievcov naQcc xoig Soyfiaxt4 xoig. oi Sr\ xavxa Xeyovxeg dnoxQtva6&co6av r\(itv, n&g Xeyovat vvv xb xaxaXaft^dvetv , noxeQOv xb voetv dnX&g
avev xov xai vneQ T-iJ? vnaQtjecog ixeivcov neQt cov notovfte&a xovg Xoyovg Staefiatov6ftai , r) fiexa xov voeiv xal (xby xr\v vnaQt-tv ixeivcov xtd-ivat neQt cov SiaXeyofie&a. ei uev

S'

yaQ xaxaXaufidvetv elvat XeyovGtv iv x& Xoyco xb xaxaXr\nxtxr\ cpavxaaia Ctvyxaxaxi&ecs&ai) xr)g xaxaXrjnxtxrjg cpavxasiag ov6r\g dnb vnaQiovxog^xax avxb$ xb vnaQiov ivanofiefiayfiivrjg xai ivane6cpQayt- l 6uevr\g, ota ovx dv yevotxo dnb ur\ vnaQiovxog, ovSe avxoi ovXr\6ovxat xd%a ur\ Svva6&at r\xeiv ne^i 5 ixeivcov d ur\ xaxetXr)cpa6tv ovxcog. oitov yovv oxav 6 Excot1

xbg nQog xbv 'EntxovQetov

r)

r\xr\

Xeyovxa oxt Str\Qr\xat

l

ov6ia
r\

r)

cog

oxt

r\Sovr\

&ebg ov nQOvoet x&v iv xo6fico r) dya&ov, noxeQov xaxeiXrjcpev r) ov xaxei6

||

23

qprjixl

EAB

cbgrjtot

om.

T 28 coansQ 30

einsiv.

quem-

qui ncm novit si contigerit quid est omnis triangulus habet tres angulos equales duobus rectis vel duos 29 7tQtcciQ.: xQttrJQtov Kayser trepidos theorema. nec dicere T dubit. 3 8s ABT (autem) 5 &vsv xa\ G: sine eo quod est 6 to addidi 13 ovtcog Bekk. ovxot G: ipsi intelligere et T T at cf. v. 27. Stav om. 14 ^tst EAB 15 6 om. EAB

admodum enim

||

TnOTTII2E<}N
<psv; xcci si (isv xaxeiXrjcpev ,

B.

65

atQet xr)v

2xodv'

ei S'

ov

xaxsiXrjcpsv,
xcci

vnaQyetv avxd Xiycov ccqStjv ov Svvaxai xi nQog

a
tov

Xiystv.

xa 8s naQanXi}6ia

n^bg xovq dnb x&v

aiQ6ecov dvayofiivovg Xsxxiov, oxuv xi r)xstv nsQt v Soxovvxcov xoig sxsQodol-oig avx&v i&iXco6tv. &6xe ov

vavxai nsQi xtvog tyxsiv TtQog aXXrjXovg. fiaXXov 8i, si j fir) XrjQslv, 6vy/y%r}6sxtti fisv avx&v ana6a cbg snog 6xeeiv r) 6vvxovcog 8e r)
Soyfiaxtxr],

nQ06a%d-r}6exat

txr)

cpiXo6ocpia,
oftxcog

StSouivov xov

fir)

8vvcc6&at fyxslv ne^i

7

ur)

xaxstXrjfifiivov.

yaQ nsQi xivog a8r)Xov

ayuaxog anocpaivousvog xs xcci doyuati^cov r\xot xaxtcpcog avxb dnocpaivs6&at ne^i avxov Xi^st r) (ir) xaxstXr]bg. dXX' ei fisv fir) xaxeiXrjcpcbg , aitt6tog i6xaf ei Ss xccxtXrjcptog,

rjxot

avxoxrsv xal
Xil~si

il-

savxov xal xax

i)

vnons6ov avxco xovxo

vrjg
{

xaxeiXrjtpivat
fiev

ivaQyeiav 8td xtvog eQev-

xal

r]xr]6ecog.

dXX'

si

i
ccvxtb
etr\

savxov nsQtnxcoxixcbg 8
xal xaxsiXrjCp&at xb

svaQystav Xiyot vnons6siv aSr]Xov, oftxtog dv ovSs a8r]Xov

cpatvofisvov

xax

dXXa na6iv in

i6r\g

<

xal bfioXoyovfisvov xcci fir) 8ianscpcovr\fiivov. exa6xov Se x&v dSrjXcov dvrjvvxog yiyove naQ avxotg neQt 8tacptovia' ovx uocc H- eavxov xal xax ivaQystav vnons6ov
1

avxcb xaxstXrjcp&g
si

xb ddrjXov b nsQt xr)g vnaQ^scog si'r] avxov 8ia(3s(iaiovfisv6g xs xai dnocpatvofisvog Soyfiaxtxog.
8e

av

8td xtvog SQSVvr]g,

n&g
'

otog

xe

i)v

r}xetv

Jto6

xov 9

dxQt&g avxb xccxd xr)v nQOxetfiivrjv vno&e6tv; xr)g ftev yaQ r]xr]6ecog %Qr)ov6r]g xov nQOxeQOV dxQt(i&g xttxetXricp&cct xb ftiXXov ^xete&at xcci ovxco r}xei"6&ai,
xaxaXafieiv
xr)g

8e

xaxccXrjipecog
ttvxr)g

xov

^rjxovfiivov

ndXtv

xov nQ0sr)xr}6&at

nQayfiaxog Ssofiivr]g ndvxcog ccvxo, xccxd xbv

17 xal 21 avx&v secl. Kayser xccxsiXriqiBv om. ABT 24 Gvvxovwg G: instanter T: dfioes Kayser 26 bvxcag L 29 dntaxog MEAB T (incredibilis) aiti6xov L 30 avxov L 31 avxa T (sibi): ivdgysiccv Fabr. ivigystav GT (actum) avxm G 1 (xcciy xax' iv. T (et secundum actum) at cf.
:
||

p. 594,

25

||

ivdgysiav Fabr.
Xiyst to

Xiyoizo
7 Tf

LEAB:

ivigysiav GT 1 et 6 avxco

||

Xiyoi

(dicat)

MEAB:

om.

LT
I.

10

ydt>

om.

(sibi):

avra

13

'avxrjg

om.
5

Sextus Empiricus

66

IITPP&NEI&N

8idXXr\Xov TQonov rr)g dnoQiag dSvvarov avroig yiyvsrai xa\ xb r\rsiv nsQt r&v dSr)Xcov xa\ xb Soy(tartsLv r\v xs
,

xaraXr\rpecog aqyeG^ai (3ovXcovrai xiveg, (terayovrcav r](i&v avxovg in\ xb Seiv avxb nQoer\rr\xevai tcqo xov xareiXrjcpivat, r\v xs dnb rr)g r\rr\6ecog , i%\ xb Ssiv
rr)g

dnb

it

TtQO

xov

r\reiv
(ir\xe

xareiXr\cpevat

xb

(isXXov

rjxsiG&ai,

&6xs

Sta xavxa

d8r\Xcov (if)xe i'tcov avaiQet6&ai (iev xr\v

xaxaXa(idvetv avxobg Svva6&at xi x&v dno(paive6&ai 8ia(3eatcorix&g vneQ avr&v.

rr)v
(ir)
,

&ev,

olftat,

6v(ir\6erai,

Soy(iarixr)v evQe6iXoytav avroi(pexrtxr\v Se atfayetf-iku cpi-

10 Xo6oq>iav.

ei

8e <pr\6ov6i

r\yei6&ui r\xr\6ecog nQ06r)xeiv

roiavrr\v [Xeyeiv] xardXr\tyiv vdr\6iv 8e anX&g, ovx %6xiv

dSvvarov

[iv]

kcov r\xsiv. (lai, dno xe

roig insypv6t nsQt rr\g vnaQ^scog r&v dSf\vor\6scog yaQ ovx anstQysxai 6 6xenrtx6g, ol-

r&v na&r\rtx&g vnonmrovxcov (xa\y xar ivaQavrco koycov yivo(ievr\g xa\

(ir\

yeiav

cpaivofievcov
ri\v

ndvrcog
i
'

vnaQ^iv r&v voov(iev(ov' ov yaQ (tovov ra vnaQxovra voovfisv, cbg cpu6iv, dXX r\8r\ xa\ rd dvvnaQxra. o%ev xa\ r\r&v xa\ vo&v iv rr\ 6xsnrtxr\ Stu&s6si (isvet, 6 icpexrixog' ori yuQ roig xuru cpavra6tav
ei6ayov6r\g
na&r\rixr\v vnontnrov6iv avra), 11 xarart&erat, Se8f)Xcorat. oqu 8e
r\rr\6ecog

xu&b
(ir)

cpatverai uvrco, 6vy-5

dnetQycovrai.

xa\ vvv ol Soy(iarixol ov yuQ roig dyvoelv rd nQuyicuru

r\rsiv

nQog rr)v cpv6tv 6(iokoyov6i rb avr&v dvaxokov&ov , roig d' in dxQtftsg

cog

sysi

sn nsQi
ravra
f)xr\t,r\xr\r)

oio(isvoig

yivco6xsiv'

olg

(isv

yaQ in\ nsQug

o

r\8r\

nuQS6xiv

6ig y cog vneiXr\cpu6iv, olg Se rb Si

na6a

6vv'i6rarai

12

6ig dx(ir\v vnaQyei, xb vo(iteiv cog ov% evQr\xa6iv. Ovxovv r\xr\xeov r\(iiv i6xi nsQi sxa6xov (isQovg r^g xakov(isvr\g (ptko6ocptag 6vvx6(i(og in\ rov naQOvrog. xa\ insi

16/17 (isray6vt(ov rnimv MLT (deducentibus nobis): (isxu avx&v EAB 23 i(psxvr)v L 24 Xiysiv om. T 26 iv 28 naQ"r\xi,x&g Gen. cf. del. Bekk.: xaJ Pappenheim 29 Xoycov GT xal add. T (et) p. 43,13: na&ruiaTixcog G
xovxcnv
||

(a rationibus):

Xoya Gen. e cod. Vesontino 409 vel cognato

:

EAB
9

1 ivSQyryt ixr\v aliquo libro, quod omnes editores receperunt 3 ansioyoavTai LT (prohibeantur) dnslQyovTai MEAB
r\(uv

iau

MEABT

(est

nobis)

r)(iiv

TII0TTn2EN

B.

67

Stacpcovia itsol xcov XXr) yiyovs Ttctocc xoig Soyfiaxtxoig qcov xr)g cptXo6ocpiag , xcov (isv sv, xcov Ss Svo, xcov Ss slvat Xsyovxcov, nsol r\g ovx av si'r\ 7too6r)xov nXsico vvv Sts^tivat, xr\v 86av xcov Soxovvxcov xsXstoxsQOv dvs-

6XQacp&at xard rb rbv Xoyov.

7

i'6ov

ix&ifisvot

xar

avxr\v nQ06a%0(isv

(S

no&sv aQxrsov

rr)g itQog

rovg Soy tiartxovg

r\trJ6seog.

Oi Ercotxoi roivvv xai aXXot rtvsg ro/a (isojj rr)g 13 cptXo6 ocpiag slvat Xiyov6t, Xoytxbv cpv6txbv r\&tx6v' xai aQypvrai ys rr)g 8iSa6xaXiag dnb rov Xoytxov, xairot noXXfjg xai nsQi rov noQsv aQys6&ai Ssi 6ra6scog ysysvr](iivr\g. oig dxoXovd"rj6avrsg dSoa6rcog, insi rd iv roig totoi
6 8s ns^i Soxsi rco Xoytxco (isQEt, ccqI-coXQirrjQiov Xoyog ittnEQiiyE6&at (is&a dnb rov nsQi xQtrrjQiov Xoyov xai rov Xoytxov (jtiQOvg,
(iSQS6i

Xsy6(iEva XQi6scog %Qr]st xai XQtrr\Qiov,

y
ixstvo
co

nsQi XQtrrjQiov.

nQostnovrsg, ort XQtrr\Qtov (isv Xiysrat rd rs 14 XQivs6%ai cpa6tv vnaQ^tv xai dvvnaQ^iav xai rb w
($tov(isv,

nQ06iypvrsg
XQttrjQiov

T-ijg

yuQ xov xaxd

nQOxstrai Ss r\(iiv vvv nsQi rov dXrj&siag slvat Xsyofiivov StaXafisiv' ns^i rb sxsqov 6r\(iatv6(ivov iv x& nEQi rr)g

6xit\)Ecog Xoyco (I

21

24)

Tb
rQtycog,

xQtrriQtov

roivvv nsQi oo
iStairara, o

StE^rjX&OfiEv. 6 Xoyog

i6xiv

Xiysxat 16
(itirQov

xotvcog

iSicog

KOiv&g
xai

(isv

nav

xaraXfjtpscog ,

-;;

cpv6txd otirco nQ06ayoQEvsrat XQtrfJQta, cog 0Qa6tg' iSicog Ss nav (lixQOv xaraXrjtyscog rsyytxbv cbg xavcov xai 8tafir\rr\g' iStairara Ss nav (isrQOV xaraXf)vjtcog dSf)Xov nQay(iaxog, xa& o xd
6r)(iatv6(iEvov
fitcoxtxa ov Xiysxat XQtrfJQta, (iova Se xa Xoytxd xai ansQ oi Soyttaxtxoi cpiQ0v6t nQog rf\v r?Jg dXr\&siag XQi6tv. cpattsv ovv nQorjyovfiivcog ns^i xov Xoytxov xQtxr\Qiov 16
(ihv

xad-'

rd

13 (avrdy slvat T (ipsas esse) 13/14 nXsicov av EAB Kayser 23 tonog T (locus) 24 <^tovy xoitr}Qiov edd. 29 ntQl om. T (in ratione skepseos). 3 25 vide p. XIII 5 7cqos om. M xuruXfjipsas (te%vixbvy EAB; cf. p. 197, 10.

14

tsXs ots qov

5*

68

nTPPNEISN

dXXd xal xb Xoytxbv XQtxr\Qtov Xiyotx* av 8tetevat. XQtycog, xb vcp^ ov xat xb 81 o\> xal tb xa& o, olov vcp* ov (iev av&QConog, 8t ov 8e r)xot ate&rjetg r) Stdvota, , xa& o 8e i) nQ06$oXr\ xf\g cpttvxa6iag, xa^ r]v b dv&Qconog
intfidXXet

XQivetv
(tev

17

Tavxa
(iev, TteQi

ovv &Q(ioov

ov

f)(iiv

8td xtvog xcov nQoetQrjfievcov. r\v t6cog nQoetnetv, Xva ivvor\6coi6xtv 6 Xoyog' Xotnbv 81 int xr\v clvxiQQrj-

6iv ycoQ&(iev xr\v nQog xovg Xeyovxag nQonexcog xccxetXrjcpevai xb XQixr\Qiov xr)g clXrj&eiag, dnb xrjg diacpcovlag aQ^dfievot.
8'

iji

el

vnuQ%et

xi xQtxr\Qtov uXr\&siag.

18

8iaXa6vxcov xolvvv neQt xQixrjQiov oi (iev elvat xovxo dnecpf)vavxo , cog oi Zxcotxot xaX uXXot xtveg, oi 8e
(ir)

T&v

Ssvocpdvr\g
19
r)(ielg

elvaij cog uXXot xe xa\ 6 6 KoXocpcovtog

d'

KoQiv&iog Bevtd8r\g
(B 34,4 Diels),
Xiycov

xal

ine6yp(iev,

doxog 6 int na6t xexvxxat' noteQOv e6xtv r) ovx

e6xtv.
r)

xavxrjv

ovv

xr)v 8tacpcoviav r)xot intxQtxr)v elvai cpr\6ov6tv

dveni-

xqixov' xa\ ei (iev dvenixQtxov, avxo&ev [elvai] 8co6ov6t xb 8etv ineyetv, ei 8e intxQtxf)v, xivi XQt&r\6exat Xeyetco6av,
(ir\te

20

ei

XQitr\Qiov 6(ioXoyov(ievov f)(i&v iyovtcov, e6tiv eiSotcov dXXd t,r\tovvtcov. xal dXXcog,

fifjfi'

oXcog
f)

tva

ye-

vo(ievr\ neQi

tov xQtxr\Qiov Stacpcovia intxQtd"f\, 8ei XQtxf)-

qiov

f)(iug eyetv co(ioXoyr\(ievov , 6V ov 8vvr\6o(ie&a x^iveiv avxf)v' xal tva xQtxr\Qtov 6(ioXoyov(ievov e%co(iev, 8ei nQo-

xeQOv imxQi&fjvai xr\v neQt xov xQtxr\Qiov Stacpcoviav. ofixco 8e eig xbv 8idXXr\Xov ifinintovtog tQonov xov Xoyov, dnoQog f) e^Qe6ig xov XQtxr\Qiov yivexai, (if)xe i vno&e6ecog f)(icov icovxcov avxovg XQtxr\Qtov Xapfidvetv , idv xe xQttr\ 18

~
6

adv.

dogm.

4853.

8 olov post tQix&g add. ante av&Qconog T (ut homo)

aXri&eiag
cf.

(videlicet)

15 diaqxaviag

8/9 olov transp.

(a dissonantia): sequitur in se-

21 ini6%o\iev 18 ailot xtveg xal EAB quentibus Sextus Kayser: hesitamus T: i%ia%a}(Lev Gr 23 slvat om. T 24 ixtixtKQivSTca G XQtxr\v T (iudicabilem) cf. p. 37, 33 sqq. 63, 25
:

p. 37, 6 sqq.,

quam methodum

25

(ir\S'

33

xQtxrjQiov Xapfidvetv

TIIOTTnSEN
to HQiTtjQiov

B.

xqlvelv

i&iXco6Lv
r)

Boj

ftaXXovTcov.

dXXa xai, insi

(isv

sig dnsiQLav amovg dn66sL$Lg Sshai kqi-

tt}qov

aitodsdsiyfiivov, to 6e kqlt^qlov

dno6EiS,scog xexqlTr\v 21

(iivr\g, sig

tov 6idX\rjXov ixfidXXovTai TQonov. Olofisvoi ovv Ixava Kai TavTa slvai 6siKVVvai

6oy(iaTiKcov nQoniTEiav xaTa tov hsqI to-D KQiTrjQLOv Xoyov, i'va xai noiKiXcog avrovg iXiyySLV sycofisv, ovk cxtonov 7tQ06KaQTSQr)6ai tco Tonco. ov (ir\v Exa6Trj tcov itSQi
tcov

XQitrjQLOV do^cov afiiXkrj&fjvat nQoaLQOVfis&a sidiKcog (d(ivo

ftrjTog

ycxQ

r)

dtacpcovia

xai

r)(iag

Xoyov

i(,ns6ELV

yiyovsv, xal ovTcog sig a(ii&odov dvayxaiov s6Tai), dXX^ insi to

XQLTr\QlOV
vcp

TtSQi OV r\TOV(lEV ov xai to 8l ov xai to

TQL660V

slvai

80XEL,

TO

TS

xa&

o,

sxa6tov tovtcov insX-

dxaTa\r\tyLav wvtov naQa6Tr\60(isv (tiQSL ttjv ovtco yaQ ififii&odog d(ia xai TiXsiog r)(ilv 6 Xoyog s6Tai. aQ^cbps&a 6s dnb tov vcp ov' doxsi yaQ Ttcog 6vvanoQEL-

&6vTEg iv

6&ai tovtco xai xd Xontd.

s
f

nsQL tov vcp ov.

(iol, o6ov ini Toig \syo(ia- 22 tcov 6oyfiaTLX&v, ov (iovov dxaTaXrjTtTog, dXXd Kai dvETUvorjTog slvaL. aKovo(isv yovv tov % aQa JJXaTcovi

av&QCOTtog tolvvv 8oxel

voig

vnb

ZcoKQaTovg
(ir)

(Phaedr.

p.

230a)

6iaQQf)6r)v SfioXoyovvTog

J5

si6ivai, noTEQOv av&Qconog i6Ttv r) steqov tl. naQL6Tavat te fiovXofisvoL Tr)v svvoLav avtov nQtoxov (isv 6iacpcovov6Lv, sha xai a6vvsTa Xiyov6iv. 6 (isv yaQ <drj(i6- 23 xotTog (B 165 Diels) cpr)6LV otl av&Qconog i6Tiv o ndvtsg l6(jlev. o6ov 6*' ini tovtco ov yvco6o(isd a tov av&Qconov, insi xai xvva L6(isv, Kai naQa tovto E6Tai Kai 6 kvcov av&Qconog. Tivdg te dv&Qcbnovg ovx l6(isv' 6lo ovx s6ovTaL av&QconoL. (i&XXov 6i, o6ov ini Tr\ ivvoia TavTrj, ov6sig
,

2228

~
:

adv.

dogm.

263282.
:

1 anoQov Kayser 2 nobis eicientibus T 9 sidiK&s Gen. 15 i(i(ii&.: artificialis T 19 vnb T tdixwg G: specialiter T 20 &Kova(iv L yovv rov LEAB: {a[d\ dogmaticis) &nb G 26 is\isv G i'd(isv p. 248, 26. yaQ xovto

||

70

nTPPNEIN
6
s

s6xut uv&Qconog' ei yao ixetvog (iev q>r)6t deiv vnb ndvxcov ytva>6xe6d-ut xbv uv&Qoonov, ovdevu Se uv&Qconov i'6u6t ndvxeg

24 uv&QConot^ovdeig s6xut xux uvxbv uv&Qconog. xui oxtxuvxuov 6ocpt6(isvoi Xsyo(isv, ix xf)g nQog avxbv dxoXdv&iag qjuivsxut.

dXfj&stav hnuQ^stv cprjGtv 6 avrjQ xd axofia xai xb xevov, unsQ cpr\6lv Diels) ov (tovov xoig cootg dXXd xui n&6t xotg 6vyxQi(iova
yuQ

xux

(B 125

(ia6tv vnuQ%etv, co6xs o6ov (iev ini xovxotg ovx intvorj6o(iev xr\v xov dv&Qconov tdtoxrjxu, instdr) xotvd ndvxcov i6xiv. dXX ovde uXXo xt vndxetxat nuQu xuvxu' ovx uqu
s%0(isv dt

25 gcoarv

ov xbv av&Qconov StaxQtvai xs dnb x&v dXXcov xai siXtXQtv&g vof)6ut dvvr)6o(is&u. 6 d' 'Enixov-

Qog

(fr.

310

Us.) q>r)6tv

uv&Qconov slvut xb xotovxovi

xui xaxd xovxov Ss, inei 6
i

(lOQcpcofiu (isxd

ifjt^jv^iug.

uv&Qconog dei^et i(iy>uviexut, 6 (ir) detxvvfievog ovx s6xtv av&Qconog, xal ei (iev yvvuixu 8eixvv6i xtg, 6 dvr)Q ovx s6xat uv&Qconog, ei de uvSqu, f) yvvr) uv&Qconog ovx s6xut. xd 6s avxd intjstQr\60(isv xui dnb xrjg Staq)0Qug xcbv nsQi6xu6scov ug
i'6(isv

ix

xov xsxuqxov XQonov

(cf.

xr)g

ino%r]g(\\00

117).

26

uXXot (dhy
xxtxov.
nca (I

133b2) scpu6xov uv&Qconov slvut coov Xoytxbv &vr)x6v, vov xui int6xf)(ir)g dsinsi

Aristot. Top.

78), oxt ovSsv i6xt <pov uXoyov, dXXu xai vov xai int6xr)(ir)g dsxxtxd i6xt ndvxu o6ov ini xoig vn uvx&v Xsyo27 (isvotg, ov yvco66(is&u, xi noxs Xsyov6tv. xd xs xsi(isvu iv xco

40

ovv Seixvvxut iv

xco nQtbxco xrjg

ino^g

xqo-

xux ivsQystav Xsyov6tv r) 8vvd(ist. si iveQyetuv, ovx e6xtv uv&QConog 6 (ir) int6xf)(ir)v xui iv tc5 Xoyco xeXetog cov xui iv r)6r) xeXeiuv dveiXrjcpcog uvxco xco dno&vr]6xeiv xu&e6xcog' xovxo yuQ xb iveQyeiu.
oqo3 6v(isr)xoxu rjxot
(ihv

ovv xux

Q-vr)x6v iextv.

ei

6e dvvdfiet, ovx e6xut

uv&Qconog ovxe 6

ML:

6 nagd 9 xotovrovl scr. 16 Sh 11 Uxuil 12 (ihv om. coll. p. 249,4: xotovxot G 24 dvstXrjaddidi 20 addam r&v 8oy(t,uriv.6av post uvrfov
negl

33 apud ipsum T (= nag'

EABT

aixco?) at

cf.

p. 82, 27.

(circa)

i7tivof)6utl

cpoog

Pappenheim

coll. p. 62, 27.

167,24: ansiXrjcpmg G: qui

accepit

(cf.

ad

v.

27/28)

B.

71

KTII0TTn2EN
cpcog'

Xoyov e%cov xeXstov o%xs 6 vovv xai int6xrj(ir}v dvst[xa/] xovxo 8s xov nooxsoov soxlv dxoncoxsQOv. xai xavxr\ aga a6v6xaxog nscprjvsv r) inivota xov dv&Qcbnov. 10 ycto ILX&xcov ([Plato] Def. p. 415 a), oxav dnocpaivr\xat 28
v

xbv av&QcoTtov slvat coov anxsQOv 8inovv nXaxvcortipv, int6xr\(ir\g noXtxtxr\g 8sxxtx6v , ov8s avxbg
d^tot dtafisfiatcoxiKcog xovxo ixxi&sci&at' si yctQ xai 6 av&QcoTtog sv xi ioxt xcov xar' avxbv ytvoftsvcov (isv, bvxcog 8s ov8snoxs bvxcov, dSvvaxov 8s TtSQt xcov (ir\8enoxe bvxcov Stat

pefiatcoxtxcog
dS-tco6et

xbv oqov
fisvxot

dnocpaivsad-at xax avxov, ixxi&scfdat Soxstv cog

ov8e

TLXdxcov

8ta(3e(iaiov(ievog,

dXX* coaitSQ stco&sv xaxd xb

nt&avbv

Xsycov. oxt

Ei
S

xcei 8oir\(isv

xaxd 6vyycoQr\6tv,

intvost- 29

av&Qconog, dxaxdXr\nxog evQsd-rjesxat. 6vve6xr\xe (isv y&Q ix ipvyjrjg xai 6c6(iaxog, ovxs 8s xb 6cofia KaxaXafifidvsxat x&ya ovxs r) ipvyr)' ovSs 6 av&QConog aoa.
b

6&at dvvaxat

xai oxt (isv xb 6co(ia ov xaxaXa(idvsxat, 8r)Xov ivxev&ev' 30 xd 6v(isr\x6xa xtvi sxsQa i6xtv ixeivov a> 6v(ier\xev.
o

oxav ovv

%Qco(ia
xco

r\

xt

na.QanXr\6tov
r)(itv

i)(itv

vnoninxr\,

6v(i(3e^rjxoxa

6co(iaxt eixbg

vnoninxeiv , dXX

xd ovx

avxb xb
yov6tv'
5

6c7>(ia.

xo ye

xot

6cpeiXo(iev

ovv xb

6&(ia XQtyr\ 8ta6xaxbv elvai Xi(if)xog xai xb nXdxog xai xb

xaxaX&co(iev. ei yuQ vnsntnxsv, iytvco6xo(isv dv xai xd vnaQyvQa tva Se xai xf)v negi xov 31 1QV6ia. ovSs xb 6co(ta &Qa. 6c6(iaxog d(icpt6fif)xr\6tv naQ&(iev, ndXtv 6 av&Qconog ev-

fid&og xaxaXa(i(idveiv , tva xb 6co(ia

r)(itv

xovxo

Qi6xexat
yr\v.
10

dxaxdXr\nxog
8e

Std

xb

dxaxdXrjnxov elvat
ccvxr},

xr)v ipv-

oxt

dxaxdXr\nx6g

i6xtv

8r)Xov

ivxev&ev'

xcov negi tyv%r\g StaXaftovxcov, tva xr\v noXXr)v xai dvr)vvxov

2933

adv.

dogm.

283313.
:

xiXsiov (qui rationem hdbet perfectam) 28 %a\ del. 27/28 qui accepit T Bekk. 29 anoyaivr\xat T (assignat): d^iol 31 7toXtxtxf)g: 32 &l-ioiQ: vultT 12 xo xs xoi vel xf)g xaxd Xoyovg [Plato] to (isvxot Pappenheim (corpus autem T) 14 post xaxaXd(ieo(tsv Kayser add. (oiSi ys xb aftog xaxaXa(i(3dvo(isvy, malim 15 xavxa vel xavxa ndvxa pro xovxo 19 ivxevfrsv om. EAB
%X<ov

27

M: ^cov om. EAB a

Hxeov xikstov

LT

72

riTPPNEI&N
elvat xr)v tyv%f)v ecpa6av, (fr. 63Muller), xavxr\v ovv xf)v Stacpcoviav et fiev oi Soyfuxxtxot, 8oo6ov6iv avxo&ev
fir)

fidyr)v rtaQttXlrtcOfisv, oi fiev

oog

oi rteqi xbv Me66f)vtov

AixaiaQ^ov

32 ol 8e elvat, ol Se irte6ypv.

dvenixQtxov elvat Xeh,ov6tv

xf)v xr)q ipt^Tjg dxaxaXr)tyiav , ei Se intxQtxf)v , xivi

intxqtvov6tv avxrjv eindxco6av. ai6d-f)6et fiev yag ov Svvavxat Sid xb vor\xr)v vn avx&v elvai Xiye6&at' ei Se Xeov6tv oxt Stavoia, ioovfiev ort, inel xr)g ipv%r)g xb dSrjXoxccxov i6xtv
r)

Stdvota,

cog

8etxvvov6tv oi neol

fiev xr)g

vndq^ecog

xf)g
3(

r\)V%r)g

33 ei

xf)

bfiocpcovovvxeg , neql 8e xf)g Stavoiag StacpeQOfievot, Stavoicc xf)v tyvyjr)v i&eXov6t xccxaXttfi^dvetv xai xr\v

neql avxr)g Sicccpooviccv inixoiveiv, xoo fiaXXov r\xovfiivoo xb t)Xxov r)xovfievov irttxqivetv xe xai fiefiaiovv i&eXf)-

6ov6tv, SnsQ axortov.

6exat

ov8e

xfj

Siavoicc

xoivvv irttxQt&fj- 6
uqcc.

xai

i/^t^s dxaxdXr)rtx6g i6xw.

7)

rteql xr)g

Stcccpoovia.

ovSevi

ei 6h xovxo,

o&ev ovSe 6 av&QOirtog xaxaXafioxt

>

34

dvotx r
'Iv<x

av.
Se xai

S&fiev,

xaxccXafidvexcct

av&Qoortog,

fiijrtoxe

ovx

<(av)> ivSiyptxo Sei^at, oxt vti

uvxov XQive6&at

Sei xd rtQttyfiaxtt. 6 ydq Xiycov, oxt vrt av&Qoortov Sei xqivee&at xd rtQayfiaxa, rjxot dvev drtoSei^eoog xovxo Xe^et r)
fiexd
drtobeih,eoog.

ovxe Se
elvat

fiexd

drtoSei^eoog'

Sei ydq

xf)v
i<

dnoSet^tv dXr)&f)
vrtb
vop'

xai xexQtfievrjv,

Std 8e xovxo xai

xtvog xexQtfievrjv.
0-5

inei ovv ovx e%0fiev eirteiv bfioXor)

yovfiivoog,
(^rjxovfiev

ydq

xb

XQtxi)Qtov

XQt&f)vat 8vvf)6excct avxr) xb vcp ov), ov

drt68ettg

Svv^ofie^a

xf)v dnodet^tv irttxqivetv, dtd Se xovxo ovSe xb xqtxrjQtov, 35 neqi o% 6 Xoyog, drtoSetxvvvat. ei Se dvanoSeixxoog Xei&r)-n 6exat, oxt vrtb xov dv&Qdbrtov Sei XQive6&at xd rtQdyfiaxa,

a.rti6xov
1

vcp

e6xa.t, co6xe ov% ot XQtxr)Qt6v i6xtv 6

e%Ofiev

8taefiatov6&at,
vrtb

oxt

xb

dv^Qoortog.

xivog

Se

xai

3436
ttjv

cf.

adv.

dogm. 1 314316.

21
xal om.

om.

EAB

15 negl

Xsx&rJGetai

MLT MLT

22[is6f)vtovG: messanensem T 31 xf\v post 6 dv add. Bekk. 10 xal post rovro om. T (de quo est sermo): (xb vq>' ov) negl EAB
(dicetur):

16 *Qtvs6dat

MEAB:

iXsx&fjasxat EB: iXsyxQ"r)6sxai 18 et 19 6 om. xQt9f)vat L

||

EAB

TnOTTII2EN
r)6exat, oxt xb
Sr}

B.

73
i6xtv; ov

vy
xovxo

ot)

xpmjptov
r\xovfievov

av&Qwnog

axalxoag

Xeyovxeg

nt6xev9f)6ovxat.

cd.V

ei ei

vit

dv&Q&nov,

xb

tfvvapTtacfO^tfETat.

36

vnb exeqov fcoou, n&g eneivo nabg xr)v xofoiv xov dvnov elvau xb XQixrjoiov naQaXafifidvexat; el fiev yaQ
/tcocj,

ov nt6xev&r\6exat,

el

8e fiexa xp/cecog, ndXtv exeivo

6 xivog bcpeiXet KQt&f)vai.

avxrj

ei fiev vcp eavxov, fievet dxonia (xb r\xovfievov yaQ 8ta xov r\xovfievov kqiei 8e

dXX

r\6exat)'

g* ei 8e

vnb dv&Q&nov, 6 8tdXXr\Xog ei6ayexat tqovno xtvog naQa xavxa aXXov, ndXiv exeivov xb
xb
vcp'

ixrjQtov dnatxf]6ofiev

ov,

v.a\

fie%Qtg dneiQOv.

Kai
det

xovxo

apa ov% e%Ofuv

Xeyetv,

&g vnb dv&Qconov

ive6&at xd nQayfiaxa. "E6xo3 8e xai nent6xco6d-co xb Setv vnb xov dv&Qconov 37 xa nQayfiaxa. ovkovv, inei noXXrj x&v dv&Qconcov e.6xt SKQtve6&at StacpOQa, nQoxeQOv 6av, oxt x&Se x& av&Qconco
,

ot

Set

SoyfiaxtKoi 6vftxpcovr\6dxconQ06e*/etv, el& ovxco Kai

rjficcg

avxco 6vyaaxaxi9e6d at %eXevexco6av. ei cV (Plat.Phaedr.

vit.

p.

264 d. Herodot.
e6x

Homeri ll)
SevSqea neqi avxov
fiaKQa xe&r)Xr\
Siacpcovr\6ov6tv,
r)v ycVp

dv vScoq
Sr)

xe vdr\ nai

xovxo

xb xov Xoyov

n&g
Kai 38

rjfiag

ineiyov6t nQonexcog xtvt 6vyKaxaxi&e6&at;

Xeyco6tv oxt

x& 6ocp& nt6xevxiov, eQcoxr)6ofiev avxovg, noico 6ocpco. noxeQOv x& Kaxa EntKovQOV r) x& Kaxa xovg ExcotKobg x& Kvvikco ov% e%ov6t yaQ 6vficpcovcog r\ <jco KvQr\va'tKcp r\}
;

Se dh,tco6et xtg r)fiag xr)g Jtepi toi5 6ocpov r\xr\6ecog 39 dno6xdvzag dnX&g x& 6vvexcoxeQco x&v bvxcov dndvxcov nteinetv.
ei

6xevetv, nQ&xov fiev %ai negii xov xig 6vvex&xeQog i6xt x&v dXXcov 8tacpcovr\6ov6tv , eixa Kav Softr) 6vficp&vcog dv

3942

adv.

dogm.

320326.

24 iKelvo
'

MLT
32

^qp

ov fort. del.

(illud) : instvo 7te7ti6xd>6&co

MEAB

ngbg

xr\v kqioiv
:

EAB
LT
T T
||

29 to
(cre-

-ne nt6rev6&(o

3 wbxm om. 6vynaxacptXo60(prJT(o6av xi&s6&aC scripsi coll. vv. 6. 31. p. 66, 11 : consentire &s6d-at 7 iQ(axrJ6(0fisv L 9 add. (aut cirinaico vel cunico) evfupmdatur)

1/2

EAB

||

vov$

ysyovoxmvy

11 bvxmv G: av&Qmnmv Kayser: malim addere <^xca coll. v. 14 et 18. 13 Softfi Bekk. concedaturT Sotr} G
: :

74
vu6&ut
,

IITPP&NE1&N
Xrjcpd rjvut, xig e6xt xcov

xe

ovtcov

%ui t&v yeyovo:.

ovS' ofitcog e6xat ni6xecog ovxog ul-tog. 40 inei ycco noXXr) %ui 6yeSbv unetQog e6tiv inixu6tg te %ui uve6tg %uxu 6vve6tv, cpapiev oxt xovxov xov dv&Qcbnov ov Xeyofiev elvai xcov yeyovoxcov xe %ui ovxcov 6vvexcbxeQ0v,
tcov 6vvetcotQog ,

eteQOV

6vvetcbteQov

ivSiyexut

yevfo&ai.
xcov
xe

vvv elvai

Xeyofiivco cpQOvificoxeQca

co6nQ bvxcov

ovv
%ui

xco

xcov

yeyovoxcov Stu xi)v 6vve6tv uvxov ni6tevetv d^iovfie&u, ofitco %ui xco (iet uvxbv i60(iivco 6vvexcotiQco xovxov (iuX-

Xov \xovxov\ iQr\ nt6xevetv. %ui ixelvov yevofiivov ndXtv aXXov iXntfetv yQrj 6vvetcotQOV uvxov yevfj^ee&ai, %d%ei41 vov uXXov, %ui (ii%Qtg chteiQov. %ui u8r\Xov, noxeQov note
Sto6v(icpcovr)6ov6tv dXXr)Xotg ovtoi r) Stdcpcovu Xi%ov6tv. %uv xcov yeyovoxcov xe %ui ovxcov 6vvexc6xeQog elvut neQ}
bfioXoyrj&rj

xtg, inei

ov%

e%0(iev eineiv 8tuefiutcoxt%cog, oxt

ovSeig e6xat xovxov dy%tvov6xeQog (uSr)Xov yd^), dei 8er\6ei

xrjv xov (iexd xuvxu i60(iivov 6vvexcoxiQov %q(6iv neQt42 (livetv %ui (ir\Sinoxe evyxaxaxi&e^&at xco %Qetxxovi. tva Se %ui %uxu 6vy%coQr)6tv 8co(iev, oxt ovSeig xov vnoxt&efii-

vov

6vvexov

6vvexcoxeQog

ovxe

e6xtv

ovxe

iyivexo

ovxe

e6xut, ovSe cog nt6xeveiv avxco nQ06r)%et. inei yuQ (idXt6xa oi 6vvexoi cptXov6tv iv xr) xcov nQayfidxcov %uxu6%evr) xotg 6a&Q0tg naQt6xd(ievot nQay(ia6tv vytr) %ai dXrj&r) xavxa

ei66(ie&u
Xiyet,
r](iug

8o%eiv elvat noteiv, oxav xt Xiyrj ohxog 6 dy%ivovg, ov% noxeQOV noxe, cog eyet xb nQ&yfiu cpv6et, ovxco

tyevSog avxb vnuQ%ov cog dXrj&eg naQi6tr\6t %ui r) net&et cpQoveiv cog ne^i dXr\&ovg, uxe 8r\ 6vvetcote-

r}(icov

QOg xcov dv&Qconcov undvxcov vnaQycov %ai Stu xovxo vcp' iXiyyee&ut (ir) 8vvd(ievog. ov8e xovxco xotvvv 6vy-

^uxu&rj^oiie&u cog dXrj&cog xd nQuy(iaxa %Qivovxt, 8tu xb olov xe (iev elvut uvxbv dXri&r) Xiyetv, oie^&ut $' oxt 8t vneQ(5oXr)v

dyytvoiug xu ipv8r) xcov nQuyfidxcov

cog dXrj&r)

ov-

22 GvvsTcoticico xovxov T (intelligibilior illo) xovxov 6vv. Gr 23 xovxov om. T 30 (isxu xavxa om. T 5/6 xavta elvat doxelv xal itoielv EAB 7 <pv6et T (natura): cpvascag G 8 avxm EAB 13 olov xe (lsv elvat Apelt: oi's6&at (iev GrT (propter id, quod opinamur quidem) aX-q&fi elvat Xiyetv EB &Xrj&fj elvat Xiyet A
: :
||

TnoTrn&sEN

b.

75

S.I

lofisvog naQiGxccv a (prjGt Xeyet. Std xavxa (iev ovv ovSe x& x&v undvxcov dy%tvovGxdxco Soxovvxt vnaQ%etv iv xrj xQiGei x&v TtQayfidxcav %Qr) ntGxeveiv. Ei Se qjrjGet rtg, oxt xr) x&v noXX&v Gv(Jtq>covia %Qr) 43
1

..

nQOGi%etv,
)

XH-o(iev

oxt

xovx

sGxt

(itdxatov.

tcq&xov

(isv

i
)r.

ii,

yaQ Gndvtov 1'Gcog eGxl xb uXrj^ig, xai Std xovxo ivSi%sxat eva x&v noXX&v q>Qovt(icoxeQOv elvat. elxa xai nuvxi xqixr\Qt(o nXeiovg uvxtSo^ovGt x&v xorr' avxb Gv(iq>covovvxcov' oi yuQ bnotovovv dnoXtnovxeg xqix-tjqiov exeQOv xov Gv(icpcovetG&at Soxovvxog

j
>

xaxd

noXv nXeiovg
r)

etGt

nuQu xtGtv dvxt8oE,ovGi xe uvx& xai x&v ne^i avxov Gv(icpcovovvxcov.

%ooaig 8e xovxoov,

Sta&eGeGtv

iv

oi GVfiopoovovvxeg r\xot iv StacpOQOtg etGl 44 (ita. iv StacpoQOtg (iev ovv ovSa(i&g ogov

ini x(p Xeyofievoo. n&g yuQ av xd uvxd sXsyov ne^i avrov; ei Se iv (ita, inei xai 6 elg 6 Xeycov exeQOv xt (liav e%et Std&eGtv xai ovxot ndvxeg oi Gvixcpcovovvxeg fiiav,

oGov ini xatg Sta&iGeGtv alg nQOGe%0(iev ovSe xuxd nXf)xtg. StoneQ ov %Qr) xotg noXXotg 45 itQOGe%eiv (iaXXov r) r<5 evi, nQog x& xai dxaxdXrptxov

%og evQiGxexai SiacpoQU

'

slvut,
(I

100

xaddnsQ 117)

x&v

xQiGeoov, xoov xai r)(i&v

xsxuqxco XQonco xr)g Gxitysoog xr)v xaxd nXrj&og StacpoQav dneiQcov x&v xaxd (ieQog uv&Qconcov vnuQ%6vvjte(ivr]Ga(iev,

iv xcp

dndvxcov uvx&v xdg XQiGetg (ir) Svvafievcov insX&siv xai dnocprjvaG&at, xi (iev oi nXsiovg x&v dv&Qobitcov andvxcov dnocpuivovxat, xi Se oi iXdxxovg. xai xaxd xovxo

ovv uxonog

Ei
)

d'

ovSe

ovSeva vqp xaxd Gvy%(OQr)Gtv

xaxd xb nXrj&og nQOxotGtg x&v xqivovxoov. x& nXr)&et nQOGel-ofiev, ov% e{>QrjGO(iev 46 0-5 XQt&rJGexut xu nQuyfiuxa, xuixot xoGavxa
r)

Sovxeg. StoneQ ih, undvxoov xovxoov uxaxdXrjnxov evQiGxexat xb XQtxrjQtov vq> ov XQi&rJGexat xd

nQuynaxa.

4344
yq,

~
i.

adv.

dogm.

327334.
in marg.:
ev(tq>.

18/19

dsi niGxevetv

textu, yg. vq. 7 xb om.

EAB

TtQ.
||

m. B
||

23 oi 25

3si

rttsxevstv

in

om.

24

avxeo om.

T
T

7tg6iiQt6ig

MEAB

itQoeiiQiatg

^O (xaiy xaxd

EAB

dovxsg

MEAB:

Stdovxsg

prekctio

76
47

IITPP&NEI&N
6

qicoV) inei

ZvfineQiyQacpOfiivcov SKa6rov ofurwv fjTOi fiSQOg

Sh rovrco Kai
rj

rcov

dXXcov
r)

kqittj-

nd&og
%6cog

iari tov clv&Qconov ,

il-r\g

ccxoXov&ov

fihv

r\v

iviQyr\fid ini ti rcav

TCQOiivai rco Xoyco, cog xai tzsqI ixelvcov inavcog siQr\fiivcov iv rovroig' Xva Sh (ir\Sh rr\v siStKr\v cog rcQog SKa6rov avriQQr\Qiv cpsvysiv
SoKcofiev,

oXiya

xai

jisqi

avrcov

i'E,

im-

fiirQOv Xi^ofiev.

nQoreQOv Sh neQi rov KQirr\Qiov tov St ov

naXovfiivov StaXs^ofie&a.
g'

jtept

tov Si

6\).
r\

48

HoXXr)
fis&oSov

(ihv

ovv xai aneiQog 6yeSbv

rjfieig

ne^i avrb yiyove

Sh ndXiv tov
ifi-

Stacpcovia jtaQcc toig Soyfiartxoig'

amovg avTtQOVoovfievoi cpafihv on, insi Kar ov xQivsrat rcc jtQayfiara, ovShv Sh icri rb vcp &QC07t6g ovrog e%oi av St oi) xQivstv Svvr\6srai (xa&djteQ xai avroi
6vvofioXoyov6iv)
ori ov"re
fiovrjg
r)

ai'6&rj6iv

Kai

6V

ai6%"f\6ecog

(i6vr\g

didvoiav, idv Sei'cofiev, Svvarai XQiveiv ovre 6id

avrcov, 6vvr6ficog
'

rr\g

Svavoiag ovre dt

aficporiQcov

TtQog a7ta6ag rdg

xara

fiiQog

S6ag eiQrjxafiev

na6av yaQ

49 Soxov6vv eig rag TQeig ravrag dvacpiQe6d-av 6ra6evg. apa$fie&a Sh dnb r&v ai6&r\6cov.

Ovxovv insi rivhg fihv xsvonaQsiv rag ai6&rJ6ig cpa6iv (ovShv yaQ vnoKsi6&av cov dvrvXafn3dve6d-av Soxov6vv), oi Sh Jtdvra vnoKi6&at vcp cov oiovrai xvvi6&at Xiyovfftv,

oi dh ra fihv vnoxi6&av,

rd Sh
ovrs

(ir\

vnoxei6^av, rivi

6vy%ara%r\6ofiie%a ov% s^ofisv'

Svacpcoviav
i nvxQvvovfiev
,

yaQ rf\ ai6$r\6ev rr\v inei ne^i avrfjg ^rjTovfiev, nore-

qov xevona&ei r) dXrj&cog xaraXafi\3dvev, ovre eriQco rivi, ine\ \xr\Sh e6rvv dXXo rv %Qirr\Qtov di ov %Qr\ KQiveiv Kara 50 t^v nQOKetfiivrjv \)no$e6i,v. dveniKQirov ccoa Kai aKardXr\nrov
fidvei
1'ffrat,

noreQOv xevona&ei
fir\

r\

ai'6d"r\6ig

r)

aaraXafi-

n'

co

6vvei6iQierai to

deiv

r\fiag

rr\

ai^&foei

% 47

adv. dogm. I 263. adv. dogm. I 343346. 4850

cf.

16 ngolivca T (proeedere) livai G xai om. T %lQr\fiivov 25 ovrog ^ot MLT (hic habeat utique): ovtcog Gen. Bekk. 6 HaraXufifidvEiv EAB 8 dXX' ini-Koixov L fyoi EAB
:
||

||

TnOTTII&EESN
"I I
I

B.

77

nQ06t%tLV tv rfj XQi6ti r&v nQayfidrcov, tceqI r)g ovx typLLtv tintlv, ti xui rr)v UQyr)v xuruXufi^dvti ri. akV s6rco 51
fiovrj

xaru 6vy%coQr)6LV rag ui6&r)6ELg dvriXr)nrixdg

yccQ
i

eIvul'

ovSev

r)rrov xai ofircog uni6roi EVQE%r\6ovrai 7tQog rr\v xqC6iv rcbv ixrbg vnoxsiuivcov nQuyudrcov. al yovv ai6&rj-

6SLg

vnsvavricog xivovvrat vnb rcov ixrog, olov

ors

r)

ysv6tg

usv mxQdferai, brs Ss yXvxd^srai, xal r) 0Qu6ig rb avrb %Q(buu ors usv ui(iconbv, ors Ss Xsvxbv slvat (Soxsiy. cxXX* ovSe r) 06cpQT)6ig savrfj 6v(icpcovEL' 52
to yovv llvqov 6 usv xscpaXaXyixbg drjStg slvai cpr)6iv, 6 Ss Lir) oflrcog sjcov f)Sv. xai ol d-toXrjnroL Ss xai oi cpQEviri^ovrsg
cov
rjLisig

vnb rov avrov uiXirog

uxovslv Soxov6i ovx inuxovoLisv.

nvcov
xai
rb

StaXsyoLLSvcov

uvroig,
roig
(isv

avrb vScoq

cpXsyuuivov6Lv drjShg slvai Soxsl Sl vntQoXr)v &tQuorr)rog, rolg S aXXoig %Xluq6v. notSQOv ovv na6ag rdg cpav- 53 ra6iag dXrjftug slvai qpr)6si ng, r) ru6St utv dXrj&tig, ra68s
Ss tysvSsLg,
rj

xai ipsvSsig dnu6ug, slnsiv d(if)%uvov,

(ir)-

Ssv
(isv

r)(icov

i%6vrcov XQirr)Qiov couoXoyrjuivov 9t

(isXXollev,

nQOXQivsLv
dXrj&ovg

ov xqlvovdXXa ur)Ss dnoSsi^scog svno-

rs xai xsxQiuivrjg , Siu rb lls%ql vvv to rfjg dXrj&siag XQirrJQiov, Sl ovi xai rr)v dXr)&rj dnoSsi^iv inLxoivs6&aL nQ06f]xsi. diu ravra xai 6 d^icov 54 9 roig usv xard cpv6iv e%ov6lv \iv rovroig] ni6rsvLV, roig Ss
O

Qovvrcov

frfTffG-frat

cpv6iv SiuxELuivotg ur)Suucog, dronog t6rai' ovre yuQ dvanoStixrcog rovro Xiycov nL6rtv$f)6trui , ovrt dndSel'1-lv dXri&fj xai xEXQLfiivrjv e%el Siu rd nQOELQT)(xiva. ei 55 Lvsvroi xai 6vy%coQf)6SLi rig rug usv rcov xaru cpv6iv iypv-

nuQU

rcov cpuvru6iug slvai niGrdg, rug Ss rcov

XELLiivcov

naQu

cpv6iv
r)

Slu-

dni6rovg, xui ovrcog dSvvurog svQt&fj^srui

Sia

rcov ale&rfitcov llovcov XQi6ig rcov ixrbg vnoxtL(iivcov.

f)

oqu-

51

56

decem

tropis

sumpta

(cf.

adv.

dogm.

I 845).

13 inter

sIvul et otidhv spat. 8

10
a

lit.

habet L 13 rug ale&f}-

14 f\rrov EAB: tjll&v L: om. 14 unLaroi om. osig et slvui sed lac. habet lit. vide p. VIII 14/15 xqlolv 19 Soxsl add. 15 itQuyLidrcov om. (iudicinm): Ttiativ

810

LEABT T

(esse putat) cf. p. 68, 22. cf. v. 19 26 cprJ6SL rig

69, 16 e.

22 doxovet

GT

(dicet aliquis): tpf\6siitig Gr

(putant) 1 iv

rovroLg secl.

Stepbanus

&Xr)$H) (slvaiy xal

EAB

78
6tg

IITPP&NEI&N
yovv xui
r)

cpv6tv eypv6u xbv <(crirr6v)> itvoyov bxe Sxe 8e xexQuycovov elvai Xiyet, xui r) yev6tgxu 6XQOyyvXov, avTa 6txiu ini fiev x&v xexoQe6fiivcov dr\8f), ini 8e t&v
xcfra
fiev

netvcovxcov r)8iu cpr\6iv elvut, xui

r)

dxoi) nuQunXr\6icog xf)g

uvxfjg cpcovf\g vvxxbg fiev cog evfteyi&ovg dvxtXufifidvexut, 56 r)(iSQag 8e (cogy dfiuvQccg, xal r) 06cpQr\6tg inl fiev x&v

noXX&v
elvai

8v6co8r\ inl 8e

x&v (5vQ6o8ety&v ovdaft&g xd avTa

ucpf\

8oxet,

xai

r)

uvTr)

ei6iovTcov

fiev

r)fi&v

eig

to

&eQfiuiveTut vnb Tr)g nuQu6Tu8og, il-tovTcov 8e tyv%exut. 8toneQ inel Kal xuxu cpvetv e%ov6ai al ui6d-f\6etg euvxutg fidyipvxut, xal r) Stucpcoviu i6xiv dvenixQtTog, inel
fiuXuvetov
fjurj

e%ofiev cofioXoyr\fiivov (x.QiTr\Qtovy, 61

ov xQive6%ut 6v-

vuvtui, xug uvxug dnoQiag dxoXov&etv dvdyxr\. xal uXXa 6e

nXeico fiexucpiQetv

n^bg
r)filv

xf)v

xovxov xaxa6xevf)v iv8i%exut ix

t&v

nQoeiQrjfiivcov
etr\

ovx dv
57

neQi t&v xf)g inoyf\g XQoncov. 6ioneQ dkrj&eg i6cog to xf)v aia&rjGiv fiovrjv 8vvu6&ut

xQiveiv xd ixxbg vnoxeifievu. Ovkovv inl xr\v 8tdvotuv

fiex iX&cofiev

x&

Xoyco. ol

Toivvv

nQ06iyetv iv xf\ KQi6ei t&v nQayfuxTcov nQ&Tov fiev ixetvo ovx eov6tv 8etxvvvut, oxt xuxuXr\nxov i6Ti to elvut 8tdvotuv. inel yuQ 6 fiev ToQyiag ov6ev elvut cpu6xcov ov8e 8tdvoiuv elvai cpr\6t, xtveg 8e
d^tovvxeg
xf)

6iavoia

fiovr\

xavTrjv dnocpaivovTai vnaQyeiv,

8tacpcoviav;
oiixe

n&g ovv
inei xb

intxQtvov6t xf)v

^rjtovfievov 6vvaQyuQ Stuvoiu, nu6ov6tv, ovxe aXXco xtvi' ov8ev yuQ aXXo elvai cpa6t xaxd Ti)v vn6&e6tv Tf)v vvv vnoxetfiivrjv , 8t ov KQiveTat tu nQuyfiuTu. dveniKQtTOv aqa xui dxuTuXr\nTOV Io"Tat, noTeQov e6Tt 8tdvota r) ovk e6Ttv' co 6vvet6iQyjexat xb fir)

Setv

fiovrj
xr\

xf)

8iavoia nQ06i%etv

iv

xr\

x&v nQuyfidxcov

58 xQi6et.
vota,

fjtr\8inco xaxeiXrjfifiivy.

xai

cbfioXoyr)6&co

dXXd xaxetXf)cp9co r) 8tdxb elvat xuvxr\v xad"' vno&eetv'

I

5760

adv. dogm.

348352.

Bekk.

9 suppl. coll. p. 9, 29. 28, 7. 14 <bg add. 13 mg om. T 16 \iev om. AB 20 suppl. e T (manifestum iudicium) 20721 dvvavxat G: poterunt T: Svvaxat Bekk. cf. p. 71, 18. 31 oiv om. A del. Kayser 6 mfioXoyria&co Gen. cottoXoye Lo&to G: ouo/.oysia&ca Paris. suppl. 133.
:

TnOTTnSiSEiJN
i

B.

79

xr\v dxQt^cog

ov Svvaxat XQivstv xcc JtQayfiaxa. si yccQ fir\S iavoqu, dXXu Stacpcovsi nSQi xs xf)g ov6iag avxf)g xal xov XQonov xf)g ysvs6scog xat xov xdnov sv w S6xw, ncog av Svvr\$sir\ xcov aXXcov xt dxQtficog xaxaXafidvstv; didofisvov Ss xui xov xr\v Stdvotuv xQtxixr\v slvac xcov 59 avxrjv XQtvovfisv. nQuyfidxcov } ov% svQr\6ofisv ncog xux

Uy iyco

bxi

noXXf)g

yuQ ov6r\g
r)

ixsQa

fisv scfxiv

xuxu Stdvotuv StucpoQug, instSrj roQyiov Stdvotu, xa&' r\v cpr\6i fir\Ssv
xr)g

islvat, ixsQa Ss r) *HquxXsixov, xu& r)v Xiyst ndvru slvut, ixsQa Ss r) xcov Xsyovxcov xdSs fisv slvut xdSs Sh (ir\ slvat, ncog intxQtvcofisv xr\v xcov Stavoicov StacpoQav ov% s%Ofisv, H ovSs Svvr\6ofis&a sinsiv, oxt xr\ fisv xovSs Stavoia xaxaxoXov&siv nQ06r\xst, xf) xovSs Ss ovSuficog. r\v xs yuQ Sia- 60
D

voicc xtvt

xQivstv xoXfi&fisv, xr)g Stacpcoviag fiSQSt 6vyxaxaxt&sfisvoi xb r\xovfisvov 6vvaQna6ofisv' r\v xs ixsQco xtvi, tysv^ofis&a oxt fiovrj xf) Stavoicc Ssi XQivstv xd nQayfiaxa.

Xotnbv ix xcov nsQt xov xQixr\Qiov xov vcp ov [Xs- 61 yofiivcov] Qr\&svxcov ( 22 47) Sstxvvvat 8vvr\66(nsfta,

bxt

fir)xs

xr\v

Svvdfis&u ,

bxt xs

dy%tvov6xsQav xcov dXXcov Stdvotav svqsIv dv s^Qcofisv xcov xs ysysvr\(isvcov xat ov6cov

Stavotcov dy%tvov6rsQav Stdvotav, inst uSr\X6v i6xtv, si ndXtv xavxr\g ixi^a s6xat dy%tvov6xiQu, ov Sst nQ06iystv avxr), bxi 62
xs
o

xdv vno&cbfts&a Stdvotav r\g ivxQS%s6xiQa ovx dv yivotxo, ov evyxaxa&rj^ofis&a xcp St avxf)g xQivovxt, svXafiovfisvot

fir\ tysvSr) xtva Xoyov nQOcpSQOfisvog Sia xb bh>vxdxr\g Stavoiag fisxs6ir\xivat Svvaxat r\(iug nsi&stv bxt S6xtv dXr\d"r)g.

Stavoia. (i6vr\ Sst XQivstv xa nQayfiaxa. xf) Asinsxat Xiystv bxt St d(icpoxiQcov. o 7taA.iv i6xlv dSvva- 63 xov ov (iovov yaQ ov% bSr\yov6tv ai catf-ihjGeij xr\v Stdvotav nQog xaxdXr\tytv, dXXa xai ivavxtovvxat avxfj. dfiiXst yovv ix xov xb fiiXt xoi68s (isv ntxQov rot68s Ss yXvxv cpaivs6&at
'

ovxovv ovSs

T8s\>

EAB 22 fort. ipsv6ofis&a (Xiyov.. 23 rov primum om. edd. Xsyofiivcov om. T: Xsyofiivov Bekk., idem Paris. suppl. 133 25 r&v aXXcov om. T 27 ndXtv om. T 32 &mi' uXr\&ris MEABT (quod sit vera): &Xr]frf)s
(ausi fuerimus): doyi&fisv
||

11 xul om. 19 xy Ss rovds

EAB

13

o^6r\g

i.

mg. L

(ut

etiam Bekk. dubit.)

15 Xiyovat 20 roXficoftsv

EAB

MLT

iertv

2 yuQ om.

EAB

80
6 (isv

nTPPNEISN
4r\(i6xQtxog (A 134 Diels)
(ir)xs
tcpr]

(ir)xs

yXvxv avxb
xai

slvut
ini

ntXQOV,

Ss

'HQuxXstxog d(iq>6xsQu.
ai6d"rjxoov 6
r)

r&v uXXcov oftroog dnb roov

ui6d"r)6oov re xai

ai6&ri6eoov OQ(ioo(iEvrj

avrbg Xoyog. Stdvotu StdcpoQa re

xovro Ss dXXo-

xai (iu%6(iva dnocpuivs6&ut dvuyxd^srut.

tqiov i6ri KQixrjQiov xaraXrjnrtxov. elxa xdxsivo Xsxrsov' 64 rjrot nu6utg xaig ai6&r)6s6t xai ruig ndvroov Stuvoiutg XQt-

vov6t xd nQaypaxa

r)

xi6iv.

dXt

ei

(Csv

nu6utg Xs&t

rtg,

dSvvaxa

dioo6ei xo6avxr\g (id%r)g iv xaig ui6&r)66t xui xuig Stavoiatg i(icputvo(ivr\g , uXXoog xe xai inei xr)g roQyiov

Stavoiug dnocpa6ig iext xb

(ir)

Selv

(ir)x

ai6&i]6ei

(xr)xe

neQixQanr)6exai 6 Xoyog. ei Se xt6iv, ncog xqivov6iv oxt xat6Se (iev xatg ai6&rj6e6t xui ^xffSey xat6Se Se o#, (ir) e%ovxeg XQtxr)xr) Stavoia nQ06eietv Set,
,

Siavoia nQ06e%etv

Qtov co(ioXoyr)(ievov, St ov xdg StacpOQOvg ai6&r)6etg xe xai 65 Stavoiag intXQtvov6tv; r)v Se Xeyco6tv, oxt xag ui6d"r)6etg xai xdg Stavoiag xr) Stavoia xai xaig ui6d-r)6e6t XQtvovfiev,

xt6i Se

(ir),

xb r)xov(ievov 6vvaQndov6tv'

ne^i yuQ xov ei Svvaxai xtg Sta xovxcov XQivetv rjxov(iev. 66 elxa xdxeivo Qrjxeov, oxt r)xot xaig at6&r)6E6i xdg xe ui6&r)6etg
xai xug Stavoiag XQtvov6tv, r) raig Stavoiatg rdg te at6&r)6eig xai xdg Stuvoiug, r) raig te ai6&r)6e6t xdg ut6&r)6etg xai
raig Stavoiatg xdg Stuvoiug, r) raig (ihv ui6&r)6e6t xug Siavoiag, xr) Sh Stavoia xdg ai6&r)6etg. ei (ikv ovv xaig ai6&r\6E6tv r) Stavoia d(i<poxeQa XQivstv i%eXr)6ov6tv, ovxext St aixr)

av

6&r)6ecog xai Stavoiag XQtvov6tv, dXXd St evbg xovxoov, onsQ sXoovxat' xai nuQuxoXov&r)6ov6tv avxoig ai S(inQ06&Ev
:

10 xaxaXr\nxov EAB 11 Stavoiatg T (intellectibus) StacpcoG 13 xal (ivy edd. 14 Stavoiaig MLT (inteUectibus): 1 7 tjjSs add. Bekk. xalg Stavoiatg Kayser Stacpioviatg EAB 21 xqivov(isv LMT (iudicabimus): xQtvov(tevov EAB post xpiviatg
:

vovfiev
xtcl (tev

hab. spat. 30,

||

25

lit.:

ut quibus quoque conce-

damus, quibusdam vero non T, unde

de hoc

evyxaxaxi&EGfraty
||

xovxcav

25 xQivovatv T (iudicabunt) cf. v. 30: xQtvsxe MEAB: 26 xe om. EABT L 26 r) 27 Stavoiatg om. L 26 xag ulGdrJGEig 30 xQtvovotv G: 27 aic&^GsGt om. M
exp. xQtvsxai

(per

sic fere suppleam (waxe 23 xov EAB: xovxov L: x M: 24 alGQ-rJ6sig om. EB hos): xovto G

iudicabunt

Tnorrn&2E&N
,
siQr\(iivat

b.

81
xdg
ai6&r)6stg 67

dnoQiat.

si

Ss

xaig

ai6&r)6s6t

xai

Stavoiag intxQivov6tv, instSr) (Ldypvxat xai ai6&r\6stg ai6d"r\6s6t xal Stdvotat Stavoiatg, ijvxtva dv
xr)

Stavoia. xdg

Xd(Sco6tv dnb x&v (ia%o(ieva)v aia&rj6eG)v nQog xr\v XQ't6tv x&v dXXcov ai6&r\6so)v, xb r\xov(isvov 6vvaQ%a6ov6tv' (ii-

Qog yccQ

xr)g Stacpcoviag cog

nt6xbv

r)8r\

Xrjtyovxat itQog

xr)v

x&v in i6r\g avxco r\xov(tivcov inixQt6tv. 6 8s avxbg xai 68 ini x&v Stavot&v Xoyog. ei 8s xaig (tiv ai6&ri6e6t xdg Stavoiag intxQtvovOt,
XrjXog
xrj

Stavoia

Se

evQi6xexat XQonog,

xa&

ov,

xdg ai6&r\6stg, 6 StdXtva (isv ai ai6&r)6eig

votat

intxQt&&6t, Set nQ0xsxQi6&at xag Stavoiag, Xva Ss ai Std8oxt(ia6&&6t, %Qr\ rtQoStsvxQivsiO&at xdg ai6&f)6stg. 69 inei ovv (ir)xe vnb x&v Sfioysv&v xd 6(ioysvf) XQtxr\Qtu

Svvaxat intxQiveo&at
fivr)
(if)xe

(ir)xe vnb evbg yevovg d(KpoxeQa xa vnb x&v sxsQoysv&v ivaXXd^, ov Svvr}66(ie&a

nQOXQivetv Stdvotav Stavoiag r) at6&r\6tv ai6&r)6scog. Std 8e xovxo ovSe eo(iev Std xivog xQtvoiifiev' ei yaQ (ir)xe

na6atg xaig ai6&r\6e6t xai xaig Stavoiatg XQivetv Svvr\6ofie&a, (ir)xe ei66(ie&a noiatg fiev Sei XQivetv, noiatg Se ov% so(isv St ov XQtvovfisv xd nQayfiaxa. co6xe xai
(ir),

Std

xavxa dvvnagxxov dv
'

etr\

xb XQtxr\Qtov xb St

or).

ne^i xov

xu&

o.

"ISa)(iev er)g ne^i xov XQtxr\Qiov xa& o XQivs6&ut 70 XeyovOt xd nQdyfiaxa. nQ&xov xoivvv ixeivo s6xtv eineiv

ovv

ne^i avxov, ort <(......)> dventv6r\xog i6xtv r) cpavxaeia. Xeyov6t yaQ (Stoic. r. I 484 Arn.) cpavxaeiav elvat

xvnco6tv iv r)ys(iovtx&. inei ovv

r)

ipv%r\ xai xb r)ys-

70 ~

adv.

dogm.

370379

6 6vvuQ7tdovai EAB 11 invenietur T 12 tdg 13 13 rtQodiEvxQLvela&ai EAB: nQoSiaxQtvsa&at L: itQodt. om. 15 dvva6&ai EAB 23 xad-' b xQttr\Qiov prius declarari T EAB 24 te post siTteiv add. EAB 25 iteQl avtov Ztt d om. L spatio versus (circiter 30 lit.) libero &vsTtiv6r\t6g

||

(om. a) LT (non intelligibilis) cf. p. 80,17: vor\t6g post spatium 4 fere lit. vacuum M: &TtsQtvor\t6g EAB; lacunam sic fere expleverim: oti <(ov (i6vov &xtttd\r\ittog', dXXd xaYy dvS7ttv6r\tog coll. p. 61, 19. 248,

llsqq.

||

iettv

om.

Sextus Empiricus I

82

IITPP&NEI&N

fiovinbv itvevfid iGxtv rj XsnxofiSQsGxsQov xt itvsvfiaxog, oog cpaGtv, ov Svvr\Gsxai xig xvitooGtv intvosiv iv avr& oftrs xar siGoir)v xcci it,o%f)v, cog ini r&v GcpQccyiSoov
OQ&fisv,

ovrs xard

QOtcorixf)v' ov yuQ av
Qtjfidxcov

fivf)fir\v

rf\v rsQccroXoyovfisvrjv srsxoGovxcov dvaSs^cctxo &scosrssi

oGu GvviGxrjGt xsyyv\v, iv xaig iittytvofisvatg

71 QotcoGsGt
xcci

r&v

7tQOV7toxstfisvo3v

UTtccXstcpofisvcov.

fisvrot

intvori&fivat Svvutro r) cpuvruGiu, dxccrdXrptrog sGrat' insi yaQ ndd-og iGrtv r)ysfiovtxov , rb Ss r)ySfiovtxbv ov xaxccXccfif3dvsxut, oog iSet^ccfiev, ovSs xb itd&og ccvxov xaxcc-

72 Xrjipdfis&a. slxa si
xccGicc,

xcci Soirjfisv, oxt

xccxuXttfifidvsxcci

r)

cpav-

ov Svvuxut XQivsG&ut

\xcct]

xat

ccvxr\v

rd itQayfiara'
uvxf\gy cpavaiG&rjGsoov, ai

ov yuQ

dt savxf\g iitif3dXXst xoig ixxbg xui (Si

r)

xuGiovxat

Stdvota, oog cpaGiv, dXXu dtd

x&v

Ss aiG&rjGstg xd fisv ixxbg vnoxeifievu ov xuruXufidvovGtv, fiova Se, ei ttQa, ru eccvr&v Ttd&r). xcci f) cpavxaGia ovv xov
eGrcct, oiteQ StacpeQet rov ixxbg ov yaQ xb ccvro iGrt rb fisXt xop yXvxdfeVTtoxetfievov G&ai fis xui xb drpiv&tov xo} TttxQu^eG&at, aXXd StucpeQet. 73 ei Se StacpsQSt xovxo xb nd&og xov ixxbg vnoxstfisvov , r)

Ttd&ovg t^g aiG&f^Gecog

cpavxaGta
xtvbg

sGxcct

StucpSQOVxog

ov%t xov ixxbg vnoxetfievov, uXX' sxiQOv avxov. ei ovv xccxu xccvxr\v xQtvst r)

Stdvota, cpavXcog XQivst xai ov xccxd rb VTtoxsifisvov. Sto%sq dronov iGrt rb xard xr\v cpavraGiav xd ixxbg xocve 74 G&cct Xsystv. dXX* ovSs xovxo eGxtv eiiteiv, oxt r\ tyvp]
xccxaXufifSdvet Std
xeifievcc,

x&v

cci6&r\xtx&v
itdd"r\

Tta&cov xd

ixrbg vito-

Std rb ofiotu rd

x&v

aiG&rJGecov elvcct xoic

ixrbg VTtoxstfisvotg. no&sv yuQ stGsrat r) Stdvota, si ofiota iGxt rd Ttdd"r\ rcov cciG&rjGscov xoig aiG&r\xoig, fir)xs avrr,
roig

cpvGtv

ixrbg ivrvyfdvovGa , fir)xs r&v aiG&f)6scov avrfj xr\i avxoov Sr\XovGbov dXXd xd savxcov 7td&r\, xu&aTte^

7275

adv. dogm. I 354358.

cf. p.

30
5 8

xaro: del.

Bekk. 7 dt avtfig add. e 1 13 ntnQu&G&at (.fie} Ml {per eam intelleetus apprehendif) 14 si cW dtucpigst om. EAB 17 cpavXogL 18 Uxat EAB 2( 21 tco* om. EAB aia&i\Tixa)v
del.
||

Arnim, at 6 Svvae&at L xal

271,

8.

32

iittyevofLivatg

AE

TII0TTII&2E&N
\x

B.

83
.

xcov

xqotzcov
fiev

xr\g

irto%r\g

xyvocov
iHSev, ei

2coxQaxr\v, eixbva bfioia i6xiv i\ eixcov

fiev
7td\rr\

6 75 ineXoy t6afir\v co67teQ yaq Se xovxov &ea6dfnevog ovx xco EcoxQaxet, ovxco xai r\

hdvota
$

xd
fir\

xcov

ui6&r\6ecov

enonxevov6a,

xd

XTog

3ecov

Jtd&rj

&ecoQov6u, ovSe ei ofiotd i6xi xd xtov catf-O"/)ovSe xa& xotg ixxbg vnoxetfievoig eteexat.
xr\v
xco

bfioico6tv

6iav.

dXXd
xr\v

dga Svvr\6exat xavxa xqiveiv xaxd Scofiev xaxd 6vy%coQr\6tv , TtQog

cpavxa6iav
xai

cpavxaintvoet- 76

6&at

xaxa\ufipdve6&at, ext xal int-

avxr\v xd nQayfiaxa, Sexxixr\v elvai xov XQtve6%ut xax xuixot xov Xoyov ndv xb ivavxiov vnofivr\6uvxog. ovxovv
r\xoi

7ta6r\
r\

cpuvxu6tu nt6xev6ofiev (xal xax

xivi. d\\' ei

vovfiev,

fiev nu6r\, 8f\Xov oxt

uvxr\v intxQtxai xr\ Bevtd-

cpavxa6ia nt6xev6ofievy, xatf r\v eleye na6ug xag cpavxai 6 Xoyog dn't6xovg elvut, neQixQanr\6exat eig xb fir\ elvat nu6ug xdg cpavxa6iag &6xe xai xax avxdg

Sov

xa6iag

77 itQayfiaxa. ei Se xt6tv, ncog intxut6Se (ikv xutg tpuvxu6tatg nt6xevetv TtQO6r\y.et, xut68e Se dnt6xetv; ei fiev yaQ dvev cpavxa6tag, Sco6ov6tv, oxt nuQeXxet r\ cpavxa6ia TtQog xb XQtvetv, etye

XQive6&ai

Svvu6&ut xd

XQivovftev oxt

%coQig

%ov6tv'

avxf\g XQtve6&at Svva6&at [xd] rtQuyfiaxd xtva Xeei Se fiexd cpavxa6tag, rtcbg Xrjipovxat xr\v cpavxa-

XQt6tv;

6iav, r]v 7taQu\ufi^dvov6t rtQog xr\v xcov dXXcov cpavxa6icov TtdXtv avxotg dXXr\g cpavxa6tag Ser\6et rtQog xr\v 78 r)
xr\g

XQi6tv

exeQag cpavxa6tag, xai eig xr\v ixeivr\g XQt6tv

76

~ adv.

dogm.
el

388 sqq.

30 ovdelM.:

dh
:

r)St,dvota;7taQ' uvtoigeo quod intelligitur) tb

EAB 31 eiaexat ML 7t6&ev yug ei'6exai EAB 32 r^om. EAB 33 too MT (cum LEAB 2 tovto EAB 4 4 b suppl. e
:

deleverat Bekk.): aliquas res T 12 15 tfjg (puvta6tug transp. post 14 SerJ6et EAB % itiqug cpavtu6tag T (secunde fantasie) cf. p. 77,13: t&v uXXcov

omni fantasie credemus et secundum ipsam iudicabimus aut alicui, set si omni quidem manifestum est (quiay et xeniade fantasie credemus secundum quam dicebat). cf. p. 60, 18. 275, 1. 277, 23. 6 elvat (ni6tugy nu6ag Stephanus xal om. T, fort.
(aut
(|

14 Ttwg
fir;

Bcr.

11 td

secl. (tivcc

fpuvta6iebv

G:

del.

Pappenheim
0*

84
aXXr\g,

IITPP&NEI&N

xai eig dnetQOV. dSvvaxov Se dnetQa intxqivai' dSvvaxov &Qa evqeiv, notatg fiev cpavxactatg cog XQtxr\Qtoig Sei iQfjC&ai, notatg Se ovSa(i&g. inel ovv, xdv S&(iev oxt xaxa xag cpavxaatag Sei xqtvetv xa nQay(iaxa exaxeQCo&ev neQiXQenexai 6 Xoyog, xai ix xov n&Gt ntcxevetv xai ix xov xtai (iev ntcxevetv cog xQtxrjQtoig, xtd Se dntcxeiv, cvvdyexat xb (ir\ Seiv xdg cpavxaciag nqbg xr\v xqtciv x&v nQay(id}

79

xcov cog xQtxr\Qta naQaXa(idvetv. Tavxa (iev dqxei vvv eineiv

cog

iv

vnoxvncocet xai

nqbg xb XQtxr\Qtov xa& o xQtvec&at xd nQay(iaxa iXeyexo. eiSevat Se %Qf)^ oxt ov nQOxetxat ijfiiv dnocprjvaC&at, oxt dvvnaQxxov icxt xb XQtxfjQtov \xo\ xr)g dXr\&etag (xovxo yaQ Soy(iaxtx6v)' dXX* inei oi Soypaxtxoi nt&av&g Soxovat xaxecxevaxivat, oxt eaxt xt XQtxf\Qtov dXrj&etag, r\(Jteig avxoig nt&avovg Soxovvxag elvat Xoyovg dvxe&f)xa(iev , ovxe oxt dXrj&eig eict Stae(iatov(ievoi oftxe oxt ntftavcoxeQOt

x&v ivavxicov, dXXd Sta xr\v cpatvo(ievr\v i'ar\v nt&av6xr\xa xovxcov xe x&v Xoycov xai x&v naQu xoig Soy(iaxtxoig xetfiivcov xr\v ino%r\v

Gvvdyovxeg.

80

r\ neqi dXr\&ovg xai dXrj&etag. Ei fievxoi xai Sotr\(iev xatf vno&ectv elvatxt xr\g dXr\9etag

(iev oxi,
,

XQtxfJQioV) d%Qr\Cxov evqtaxexat xai (idxatov, iav vno(ivf)acooaov ini xoig Xeyo(ievotg vnb x&v Soyfiaxt

x&v dvvnaQXxog (iiv

81
fteg.

icxtv r) dXf)&eta, dwnoGxaxov Se xbdXr\ Se ottxeog (Stoic. fr.II132 A.). Xeyexai vno(jtt(ivr\axo(iev

Siacpiqetv xr\g dXr\&etag xb dXrj&hg XQt%&g, ovala (iiv, inei xb (iev dXr\fteg icxtv (dtco(ia yaQ icxt xai Xexx6v\ r) Sl dceo(iax6v

avaxdaet Svvdfiet' ovcta

dXf)&eta c&(ia (k'cxt ydq intcxr\(ir\ ndvxoov aXrjft&v dnocpavxtxrj, r\ Se intCxf\(ir\ ncog h'%ov r)ye(iovtxbv &aneQ xai r\ neog e%ovCa %eiq nvy(if\, xb Se r\ye(io 82 vtxbv c&(ia' eaxt yaQ xax avxovg nvev(ia)' av

8183
jt&at

~ ad. dogm.
||

3842.

20

(aliquod):

GT (omnibus): n&er} edd. 27 rb secl. 29 xi MLT tb EAB aixole LT \eis): avrovg MEAB 11* <t<(>

ncog Kayser

TII0TTII2EN

B.

85

d6et
iyco

8e, inei xb (iev dXr\&eg

r\

8taXiyo(icci',

8e dXr\&eta

dnXovv xi i6xtv, olov dnb noXXcov aXr\-

yvco6ecov 6vvt6xaxat' 8vvd(iet 8e, inei r\ (iev 83 xlrj&eta int6xf)(ir\g e%exat, xb 8e dXrj&eg ov ndvxcog. \',6neQ xr\v (isv a,Xr}&eiav iv (iovco 6nov8aico cpaaiv vat, xb 8s aXrj&hg xai iv cpavXcp' iv8e%excci yccQ yv cpavXov ccXrj&eg xi sinsiv. xavxa (xsv ot doyfiaxmoi. 84 fjiietg 8e ndXtv xr\g xaxd xr\v 6vyyQCccpr\v itQoatqi6ecog 6xoytt*6(isvot itabg (tovov xb dXrj&sg vvv ro-ug Xoyovg notr\6o(is&a, htei xovxco xai r) dXr\&eta, 6v6xr\(ia

J&v

6v(i7teQtyQdcpexai

xrjg

S>v
t(ov

dXr\dcov yvco6ecog elvat Xeyo(iivr\. ndXtv

8e, inei

Xdycov oi (iev et6t xa&oXtxcoxeQOt, 8t cov avxr\v xr\v vnoSta6tv xov dXr\&ovg xtvovfiev, oi 8e eiStxot (quae exponunur adv. dogm. II 69 139), 8t cov 8eixvv(iev, oxt ovx eexiv

cpcovr)

xb

dXr\$eg

r)

iv Xexxco

r)

iv

xf\

xtvrfiet rijg 8tacog

oiug, xobg xadoXtxcoxeQovg

ix&e6&at (tovovg

nqbg xb na-

bv ttQxeiv r\yov(ie&a. &6neQ ydQ xeiypvg &S(ieXicp xaxxai xd vnsQnsifisva ndvxcc 6vyxaxa(pSQSxat, 00MB vsf%svxt xov dXrj&ovg vno6xu6et 8taxQsno(isvr\ xai ai xaxd (ief\
c,og xcov 8oy(iccxiKcov

svQS6tXoyiat 6v(insQtyQdcpovxat.

&'

si

Atacpcovittg xoivvv ov6r\g nsqi

doy(ittxtxoig,

s6xt xt cpv6st dXr\&ig. xov dXr\&ovg nccQu xoig 85

(isv

insi xtvsg

cpa6tv

slvcci

xt

dXr\ftig,

xtvsg

8s (ir\8sv slvat dXrj&eg, KQtvat, inet8r\ 6 Xiycov

dstl-scog

ovx ivSiyexat
elvai xt

xr\v

8tcc<pcoviav int-

dXr\&sg

ovxs

avsv dno-

xovxo Xiycov ni6xsv&r\6sxat 8td xr\v Stacpcoviccv' r\v xs xai dn68st%tv (5ovXr\xai cpsQStv, r)v (isv tpev8f\ xavxrjv Ivat 6vvo(ioXoyr\6r\, &nt6xog e6xat, dXr\&f\ 8e xr\v dno-

8eth,tv elvat Xiycov eig

xbv 8tdXXr\X6v xe i(intnxet Xoyov xai

II

85

adv.

dogm.

1516.

16 yvcbeecov T (a tnultis phv xb L 21 tr\v om. EAB 22 xov yvmeeas Q loyov EAB 28 fiovovg G: Xoyovg T (rationes) 32 av(nteitrcbHttOtv sed in marg. yg. evfutsQtycidcpovTat 5 producere T 6 dntaxa L sicut saepius
14 to
[ihv

MEAB:

veris cognitionibus):

86
'

IITPP&NEI&N
tivxr\v

dn66etiv aixrj&foexat (xovy ttXrj&r) ixeivrjg dXXrjv, xai (ie%otg dneioov.

:

vndoyetv , xai

aSvvaxov 6e dnetQcc

86

dno8et^at' advvaxov aga yvcovat xai oxt e6xt xi dXrfoeg. xcci (ir)v xo 'xt ', OTteg cpa6iv elvai ndvxcov yevixcoxaxov, r)xot dXrj&eg r) tyevdog i6xtv r) ovxe tpev8og ovxe dXrj&eg, r) xal
tyevdog xal aXrj&eg.
ei (iev ovv ipevdog ccvxb elvai cpf)6ov6tv, 6(ioXoyf)6ov6tv, oxt ndvxcc i6xl tyevdr). co6neo ydq, inei xb fo5ov eptyvypv i6xt, xal ndvxcc xd feoa xd xaxd

fieoog eptyvyd i6xtv, ottxcog, ei xb yevtxcoxaxov ndvxcov

c

(xo

w') tpevSog i6xt, xal ndvxcc xd xaxd (lioog e6xat ipev8f) xal co ovdev aXrj&eg. 6vvet6ayexat xb (ir)8ev elvat ipevdog'
xal ydq ccvxb xb 'ndvxcc i6xl ipevSff xal xb 'e6xt xt ipevei 8e dXrj&eg 8og' r&v ndvxcov xa&e6xcog ipevdog e6xcct. i6xt xo *xt , ndvxcc e6xat dXrj&r)' cp 6vvei6ayexat ndXtv xb
firjdev elvat

dXrj&eg, etye xal ccvxb xovxo xt

vndoypv

(Xeyco

87 8e xb (tr)6ev elvat dXrj&eg) dXrj&eg i6xtv. el 6e xai ipev66g i6xt xcil dXrj&eg xo *xt ', exa6xov xcov xaxd (lioog xcci
ipev8og e6xat xal dXrfoeg. eij ov 6vvdyexat xb (ir)8ev cpv6et elvat dXrj&eg' xb ydo cpv6tv eypv xotavxrjv co6xe dXrj&hg eivcct, ndvxcog ovx dv eir\ ipev8og. ei 6 ovxe xpev86g
i6xiv
ottxe

dXr)%eg xo *xt, bfioXoyeixat oxi

eivcct

xcci

(lioovg (if)xe ipev8r) (if)xe dXrj&f) e6xat dXrj&f). xai 6td xavxa (iev ovv d6rjXov f)(iiv e6xai, 88 ei e6xtv dXq&eg. nobg xovxotg r)xot <patv6(ievd i6xi (io-

ini

ndvxa xd Xeyofieva ovx

vov xd

dXrj&f), r) d8r)Xa fiovov, r) xcov dXrfocov xd (iev u6r)Xd i6xt, xd Se <pcctv6(ieva' ov6ev 6e xovxcov i6xiv dXr\&eg, cog 6eii-0(iev' ov8ev aoa i6xiv dXrj&eg. ei (iev ovv

(iovov i6xi xd dXrj&f), r)xot ndvxcc xd cpatvoxai ei (iev ndvxa, elvat dXrj&f) r) xtvd. neotxoenexut 6 Xoyog' cpaivexat ydq xt6t xb (ir)6ev elvat
q)ttiv6(ieva

(ieva

Xe,ov6tv

8687 8893
Ttdvrsg

~ adv. dogm. ~ adv. dogm.

14 itdvxa
%arai

II
II

3236. 1731.

8 add. Bekk.

iari

(omnia sunt)

ndvreg iatl

EAB:

M:

&>rt

ndvra L

Bekk.: ipevdig G 19 M: om. LEABT vel ri post xa^BGtcog rcov tyevdog om. T 31 ten dXri&ig om. EAB aXri&eg? cf. w.

||

18 et 27 ipevdog 20 addam (tigog 23 elvat 22 siye

1. 3. 10. p. 78, 17.

TnoTTn&2EaN
dXr)Q .rj&ig.
ei

b.

87
ov Svvaxai xig Xixovxo
xb XQLxfjQiov

8i xiva, dvemxQixcog (iev

cpaiv6(ievov elvai

xdde (iiv e6xiv dXrj&fj, xdde Se ipevSf), xQLxrjQico Se yeiv, oxl

%Qcb(ievog r\xoi
r)

Xi,ei

aSr)Xov. xai dSrjXov (iev ovSa(icog' (iova ydo vnoxeixai vvv alrj&Tj xd cpaiv6(ieva. ei Se cpaiv6(ievov , inei 89
r)xeixai,

xiva (iev cpaLvofxsvd e6xiv dXt)&fj, xiva Se tyevSfj,

Xa(ifiav6(ievov

xai

cpaivofievov nobg xr\v xqi6iv xcov ndXiv exioov Ser)6exat xoLxrjoiov cpccLvofiivov, xdxelvo aXXov, xai pixQig dneiqov. dSvvaxov Se aneiQa dSvvaxov aqa xaxaXafieiv, ei cpaiv6(ievd eoxi enixQiveiv'
cpaivofiivcov

xb

fiovov

xd dXrj&fj.
dXr)&f)

buoicog
(ihv

Se

xai

Xiycov

vov elvaL

ndvxa

ov Xiei elvai

xa dSr)Xa (io- 90 dXrjd-fj (ov yaQ

TceQLtxovg

xai xb aQxiovg elvai xovg daxiqag dXrj&eg elvai Xiei r) xb xovxovg vnaQyeLv)' ei 6i xiva, xivi xQivov(iev, oxl xd8e (iev xd d8i]Xd e6xiv dXrj&f), xd8e 8e tpevSf); cpai-

vO(iivco (iev yaQ ov8a(icog' ei Se dSf)Xco, enei r)xov(iev, xiva xcov d8f)Xcov e6xiv dXrj&f) xai xiva ipevSf), 8er)csexai xai

xovxo

xb aSr)Xov

xdxelvo aXXov,
fiovov
(iiv

d8f)Xov exiqov xov xai (liyjQig dneiqov.

Xeinexai
XiyeLv,

e6xi xdXrj&f). e6XL cpaivoueva,

r)xoL
r)

enixQLvovvxog avxo, 8ioneQ ovSk aSr)Xa oxi xcov dXrfocov xd 91

nov.

dXr)d-f),

xd Se aSrjXa' e6xi Se xai xovxo dxoyaQ ndvxa xd xe cpaivofieva xai xd dSr)Xd e6xiv xiva cpaivofieva xai xiva aSrjXa. ei (iev ovv

ndvxa, ndXiv neQLXQanf)6exai 6 Xoyog, dXrj&ovg elvaL SiSouivov xai xov (ir)Sev elvai dXr)&ig, Xe%&f)6ezai xe dXrj&eg xai xb dqxiovg elvai xovg a6xiqag xai xb neqixxovg xovxovg vnaQyeiv. ei 8i xiva xcov <paivo(iivtov xai XLva 92
xcov d8f)Xcov e6xiv dXrj&f), ncog eniXQivovfiev, oxl xcov cpaL-

vo(iivcov xdSe (iiv e6xiv dXrj&f), xdSe Se ipevSfj ; ei (iev (yaQiy Sl& cpaLVO(iivov , eig aneiQOv exdXXexai 6 Xoyog' ei Se Sl

d8f)Xov, enei xai xa adrjXa Selxai XQi6ecog, ndXiv xovxo

(xo)

9 iitoxHvraL L
tpaiv. del. v.

21 iitsl r\rov(LSv T (quia (lovov slvat): (tova LEABT (sola) 30 xs Bekk.: querimus) cf. v. 10 et p. 78,3: itir\xov(i,sv G 1 xdds fisv LEAB: xd (isv Ss GT (autem) xdSs 8s EAB: " xa M: xdSs L el (isv ydg scripsi coll. p. 74, 9: sl ydg G: si T 2 Sl' om. L 3 xb add. Gen.

10 sl Se cpcciv6(isvov om. 16 primo td Kayser 16/17 (lovov

M M

15 (tdy
(qui slvai

||

||

88

IITPP&NEI&N

dSr\Xov Std xivog xQtdr\6exat; ei (iev (yctoy Std cpatvo(iivov, 8 StdXXr\Xog evQi6xexcct XQonog, ei Se 6V d$f)Xov, 8 elg dnet93 qov ixfidXXcov. 6(ioicog Sl xcci ne^i x&v dSf)Xcov XexxioV

6 (iev yccQ dSf)Xco xtvi XQivetv ccvrd intyetQ&v eig dnetQOv ixfidXXerat, o Se cpatvofiivco r) ael cpatvdfievov nQ06Xcc(ifidvcov elg aneiQOv,
XrjXov.
r)

tyevSog
eGxiv

aQa
xcc

ini aSrjXov (iercc(5aivcov elg xbv StdXi6xi xb Xiyetv x&v dXr\&&v xcc (iev Se
dSr\Xa.
el

94 elvai cpatvofieva
fievd

ovv

(if)xe

xd

cpcctvo-

qpcctvofxevcc,

dXrfor) (if)xe xd dSrjXa ftdva, (if)xe xivd xivd 8e dSr\Xa, ovSiv icxvv dXrj&eg. el Se

(xev
(xr\-

Siv e6xiv dXrj&ig, xb Se XQtxr\Qtov Soxet nQog xr\v xqiGiv xov dXrj&ovg yQr\6t(xevetv , a%Qr\6xov xal (xdxatov i6xt xb XQtxrJQiov, xdv S&fiev ccvxw xaxd 6vyycoQr\6iv eyetv xtvd vno6xa6iv. xal etye icpexxiov ne^i xov ei e6xt xt dXrj&ig, dxoXov&ov i6xt xovg Xiyovxag cog StccXexxtxf) e6xtv int6xf)(ir\ tyevi

S&v xai dXrjd&v xal ovSexiQcov

96

nQonexeve6$ai.

'AnoQOv Se xov XQtxr\Qtov t^g dXr\&eiag cpavivxog, ovxe e neQt r&v ivaQy&v eivat Soxovvxcov, o6ov inl xoig Xeyo(iivoig vnb x&v Soy[xaxtx&v , ext olov xi i6xt 8tt6yyQie6d-ai, ovxe neQt x&v dSrjXcov inel yaQ dnb x&v ivaQy&v xavxa
'

xaxaXttfifidvetv oi Soyficcrtxoi vofiiov6tv,

idv iniyetv neQt

x&v ivccQy&v xaXovfiivcov 96 x&v d$r)Xcov dnoq>aive6&at

neQtovrog
6rr\66(A,ed a.
,

dvayxcc^cofxe&a, n&g dv neQt roXfxr\6ai(xev ; ix noXXov Se rov

xai nQog rd dSr\Xa r&v nQccyftdrcov iSicog ivxai inetSr\ rccvrcc Std 6r\fxeiov re xai dno-

Sei^ecog xaraXa(ifiave6&at xai XQccxvve^&ai Soxei, Std Qayicov vno(ivr\60(iev, oxt xcci neQt xov 6r\(ieiov xai neQt xr\g

dnoSei^ecog iniyetv
xcci

ydQ

r\

nQ06f)xet. aQ^cofxe&a Se dnb 6r\(ieiov' dn68etl-tg xcp yivet 6r\(ietov elvat Soxei.
i

neQt

6r\(ieiov.

97

nQayfjtdxcov xoivvv xaxd xovg Soy(iaxtxovg rd (iiv iext nQoSrjXcc, xd Se d8r\Xa, xai x&v dSf)Xoov

T&v

97103

~ adv. dogm.
:
||

II

141160.

4 ydo add. (cf. ad v. 1) (ihv G: ydo T (si enim) 5 dt om. L Kayser 16 xdv S&(ievM.T (et si dabimus): xccl d&\Lsv EAB: xSv doK&(iev L ccbxtp AT (ei) Kayser coll. p. 721, 9: avxb MLEB 25 conpeUuntuf T
12
fiovov

TnOTTII2E&N
xd
5

B.

89

ds TtQog xaiQOv d8r)Xa,xd xai nooSrjXa (isv slvai cpa6L xd eh, savx&v elg yv&6Lv r)(iiv iQ%6(ieva, oiov eGxi xb r)(LSQav slvai, xa&dita^ 6e adrjla, a (ir) itkcpvxsv elg
(isv

xa&dna^ ddr)Xa,xa

8s cpv6s'L aSrjXa.

a 10

r)(isxsQav niitxeiv xaxdXrjtyLv, mg xb aQxiovg elvat xovg aGxeQag, itQOg xaiQov de adrjXa cctzeq 98 xr)v cpv6iv l'%ovxa ivaQyr) %aQa xivag e^co&ev iteQi6xa6eig xaxd xaiQOv r)(tlv d8r)Xetxai, &g i(ioi vvv r) x&v 'A&rjvalcov TtoXig, cpv6ei Se ddr\Xa xa (ir) e%ovxa cpv6tv vnb xr)v r)(ji.exeQav %L%xeiv ivaQyeiav , &g oi vorjxoi TtoQoi' ohxoi yaQ ovdeitoxe ii- eavx&v cpaixr\v

vovxai, dXti ei a.Qa, 0* exeQoav xaxaXafi^dve^&aL dv vo(n,i6&elev, olov x&v idQooxcov r) xuvog itaQai*7tXr)6iov. xd (iev ovv TtQodrjXa (jLr) deie&ai 6r)(ieiov
15

99

cpa6iv' i

eavx&v yaQ avxd xaxaXa(jL^dve6d-ai. dXX^

6r)

aojf^v ddr)Xa xai xd cpv6ei ddr)Xa dia 6r)(ieicov fiev xaxaXa(if}dve6&ai, ov (ir)v 6ia x&v avx&v, dXXd xa (iev 97to6g naiQov adr)Xa 8ia x&v v7to(ivr)6xix&v, xd de 80 cpv6eL dSr)Xa did x&v svdsixxix&v. x&v ovv 6rj(ieicov 100
(ir)de

ovde xd xaftaTtah, adrjXa axe

xd
de

xr)v

xaxaXa(i(tav6(jLeva.

itQog

xaiQOv

xd uiv iexiv vTto(A,vr)6XLna xax avxovg, xd d' xai v7to(ivr)6XLxbv (ihv erjfietov xaXov6iv o

ivSetxxLxd.

6v(inaQa-

xrjQri&ev
25

tw

6rj(ieLcoxcp

oV ivaQyeiag

ducc xco vitone-

6etv, ixeivov ddr)Xov(ievov, ayei r)(iag eig VTtOfivr)6iv xov eviiTtaQaxrjQrj&evxog avxco xai vvv ivaQy&g (ir) vitOTtinxovxog, cog e%ei iiti xov xaitvov xai
xov TtVQog.
o
(ir)

ivdeixxLxbv 8e e6xi
xcb

6r)(tetov,

&g
8l

cpa6iv, 101

ivaQ6r)(ieicox& ^VfntaQaxrjQri&ev dXX ix xr)g idiag cpv6ecog xai xaxa6xevr)g 9*6r)(iaivei xb ov i6xi 6r)(ietov, &6iteQ0VV ai ne^i xb
yeiag,
80

6&(ia XLvr)6eig

6r)(ieid sl6l

xr)g tyv%r)g.

o&ev xai OQiovxai

9 Ttagd Gen. dubitanter: nsgi GT {circa) 7 altiovg EAB 9 a xaiQovg T (pertempora) cf. p. 319, 3 15 xataXa(jdvetai T (apprehenduntur) 23 ar\(ieicotm Bekk. eri(ieico t& MLT (in signo 25/26 ivagy&g LT (maniquod est): 6r\(LaivoLLsvco t& EAB 28 6r\(LELcota T (significato) ar\(isico feste): ivagyovg MEAB 29 %a\ om. L xco G
: :

90

IITPP&NEI&N

xovxo xb 6r\fieiov ofixcog ^erjfieiov i6xtv ivSeixxtxbv d^ioofia iv vytei 6vvr\fifievoo nQOXcc&rjyovfievov, ix102

xaXvnxtxbv xov
fieioov

StacpoQccg,

oog

Xr\yovxog.' Sixxrjg ovv ov6r\g xbov 6r\ecpccfiev, ov 7tobg ndcv 6r\fieiov dvxi-So
i

dXXd TCQog fiovov xb ivSetxxtxbv cog vnb xoov Soyfiaxtxobv nenXde&cct Soxovv. xb yao 6noftvr\6xtxbv nejtiaxevxai vnb xov (Hov, inel xccnvbv iSoov xig 6r\fietovxcct
Xeyofiev,

nvQ

xcct

ovXr)v &ea6dfievog XQccvficc yeyevr)6&ai Xeyet.

fiaypfie&cc

o&ev

ov fiovov ov
xop fiev

x&

(iioo

dXXcc xccl 6vvttyoovt6fie&cc,

vn
6*'

voij xoig

ccvxov nent6xevfievm ccdocc6xcog 6vyxaxaxt&efievnb xoov Soyfiaxtxoov iSioog dvanXaxxofievotg dv-

&i6xtt(ievoi.

103

Tccvxa fxev ovv rJQfio&v i6oog nQoetneiv vneQ xr)g 6a- K Xotnbv Se inl xr\v dvxiQQr\6tv q)r\veiccg xov r\xov(ievov'
%coQ&fiev,

ovx dvvnaQXXov Sei^at xb ivSetxxtxbv

dXXd
xr)v
cpcctvo(ievr\v

6t\fteiov

ndvxoog i6novSaxoxeg ,
xoov cpeQOfievoov Xoyoov

itfoc-frevctav

nQog

xe

xr)v

vnaQ&v

ccvxov xccl xr\v

dvvnaQ^iav
ttt

vnofiiftvr\6xovxeg.

ei e6xt xi 6r\fieiov

ivSeixxtxov.
ccvxixa

104

Tb

6r\fieiov xoivvv,

o6ov inl xoig Xeyofievotg neQt ccvxov

nccQa xoig Soyfiaxtxoig, dveniv6r\xov i6xiv.

yovv oi

dxQi8og neQi avxov SteiXrjcpevat Soxovvxeg, oi Sxootxoi II 221 Arn.), fiovXoftevot naQa6xf)6cct xr)v evvoiav xov (fr.

elvai d^ioofia iv vytei 6vvr\finQOxa&ijyovfievov, ixxaXvnxixbv xov Xr)yovxoc. xal xb fiev dl-ioofid cpcc6iv (fr. II 193 A.) elvcct Xexxbv wbxoxeXeg dnocpavxbv o6ov icp* eavxoo, vyieg Se 6v6r\fteiov, cpa6t 6r\fieiov

fievoo

vrjfifievov tb fir) dQ%6fievov dnb dXr\&ovg xccl Xr)yov 105 inl rpevSog. xb yaQ 6vvr\(i(ievov r\xot aQyexat dnb dXr\&ovg ( xccl olov ei i)fieQa e6xt, cpoog e6xiv'', Xf\yet inl dXri&eg,
r)

2
<

ccQyexcct
r\

dnb tpevSovg
yrj,

xal

Xr)yet
i)

int

tyevdog,
r)

olov

*ei

nexaxat

nxeQooxfj

i6xtv
II

yr)'

ccQ%exai

dnb

104106

~ adv. dogm.

245253.

ticis):

T 8 8' bnb T (a dogma10 negl AB 14 productarum rationum T 15 rememorantes T (cf. ad p. 39, 20) 16 oaov T (quantum): oau G
3 memorativum enim signum
8s

TII0TTnS2EN
Xrj&ovg xai Xf)yst ini ipsvSog, ocov
r)

B.

91
s6xlv
f)

'si

yf),

nexaxat
*ei

yfj', r)

aoysxai dnb tyevSovg

i]

xcci Xf)yet

ini dXrj&ig, olov

30

xovxcov Ss (ibvov xo dnb dXrj&ovg aQ%6(isvov xai Xf)yov ini tysvSog fiox^rjqov slvai <pcc6iv, xcc <$' dXXa vyir). nQOxa&r]yov(isvov 106
nexaxai
yr),

e6xtv

f)

yrf.

Ss Xsyov6t xb iv 6vvr)(i(iivcp aQ%o(iivcp

9i xcci

dnb dXr)&ovg

Xf)yovxt ini dXrj&sg f)yov(isvov. ixxaXvnxtxbv Ss iaxi xov Xf)yovxog, inei xb *ydXcc syst aftxrf xov *xsxvrjxsv avxrf SrjXcoxtxbv slvai Soxsl iv xovxto x& 6vvr)(i(isvco *si

ydXa
Ss

syst

ovxoi'

f)(isi~g

e6xt ^xiy Xsxxbv.

1

avxr), xsxvrjxsv atixr)'. xccvxa (isv 107 Xsyotisv nQ&xov, oxt dStjXov i6xtv, sl inei yccQ x&v Soy(iaxix&v ol (iev 'Enicpa6i
fir]

5a

xovQSioi
Ss

(fr.

259 Us.)

slvai (xt^ Xsxxbv, oi

oxav Xsyco6iv oi Excotxol slvai xt Xsxxbv, rjxot (tovrj cpa6st iq&vxccl r) xal dnoSsi^si. dXX si (isv tpa6st, dvti&r]6ov6iv avxoig oi EntxovQSLOt cpa6tv xi]v Xsyov6ctv, oxt ovx s6xt xt Xsxxbv' si Ss dnoSsi^tv naQccXr)tyovxttL , insl
sivcci,
ij

xmxoi

dtco(idxcov 6vvi6xt]xs

Xsxx&v

f)

dnoSsi^tg, ix

x&v Xsxx&v

ov Svvr]6sxttt n^bg ni6xtv xov Xsxxbv slvat nttQaXttfifittvsd&at (6 yaQ (ir) StSovg slvat Xsxxbv n&g 6vyStd xov r)xov(is- 108 ycoQrfist 6v6xr](ia Xsxx&v vndQisiv'^)
Se

6vvs6x&6a

15

vov xoivvv xb r]xov(isvov ni6xov6d-at (iovXexat 6 ix xr)g vnaQ^scog xov 6v6xf)(iaxog x&v Xsxx&v slvai xt Xsxxbv si ovv (if)xs dnX&g (if)xs St nstQcofisvog xaxa6xsvdfetv.
dnoSsil-scog ivSiysxat nccQL6xav oxt s6xt xt Xexxov, dSr)X6v s6xlv oxt s6xt xt Xexxov. bttoitog Ss xai si s6xtv d^icotta'

80

Xexxbv yuQ

i6xt
xt

xb

di-ico(itt.

(tf)noxs

Ss

xcci

si

xa&

vno- 109

&s6tv stvai

Xoig.

Qi6xsxcu, otov yovv ini xov *si f)(iSQa s6xt, cp&g s6xtv', oxs xb *ri(iiQtt s6xtv', ovSenco e6xt xb *<p&g e6xiv\ xai Xsyco

Xsxxbv So&sir], xb dico(ia dvvnccQXXov sv6vvs6xr]xbg ix Xsxx&v (ir) 6vvvnccQf6vxcov dXXf)-

107108
cf.

~ adv. dogm.
dogm.
||

109

adv.

II

II 258261. 8084. 132. 135136.

quidem)

2 xb Gen. tov G xov Gen. r6 G bng&tov tievT (primum 6 et 6'ti add. Gen. H<^6vtcovyXsxt&vKa,jser lievvlorcbocc L 24 si dies est T 19 ott G: t Bekk. dubitanter
: :

92
oxs
si

IITPP&NEI&N
8i
Xiyoo

xb

'cp&g

s6xiv'',

ovxixi

s6xi

xb

'f)(iiQa

s6xlv'. 25

fiev 6vyxsi(isva sx xivoov ddvvaxov vnaQysLv (ir) 6VVVnaQyj6vXO0V dXXf)Xotg X&V (ISQ&V avx&v, xct 6s i cov

ovv xa

6vyxstxat xb d^iootia ov 6vvvnaQySL dXXf)Xotg, ov% vnaQ^st iva 6s xal xavxa naQaXincofisv , xb vytsg 6v110 xb dioo(ia.
vr)(i(iivov

dxaxdXr\nxov evQS&foexat. 6 (iev yaQ Qikcov qprjvyieg elvai 6vvrj(i(iivov xb (nr\ aQ%6(ievov dnb dXrj&ovg xal Xf)yov iitl tyevdog, olov r)(iiQag ov6r\g xal
6lv
,

30

iitov dtaXeyofiivov xb 'ei r)(iiQa e6xtv

iyco 6iaXiyo(iai', 6 6e

di66ooQog,
(isvov

o (if]xs

ivsdiysxo

(if)xs

ivdi%sxat aQ%6- 8
xatf ov xb

dnb dXr\d-ovg

Xf\ystv inl tysvSog'

slvat 6oxsl, insl f)(ii(jlsv stQrjfiivov avvrj(i(iivov ipsv6og Qag (isv ov"6r\g i(iov 6s 6tconf)6avxog dnb dXr\&ovg aQtjd111 (isvov inl tysvdog xaxaXf)!-SL, ixsivo 6s dXrj&ig 'si ovx

S6XLV

CiflSQf)
'

X&V

OVXOOV 6X0L*{S.ia,

S6XLV

dflSQf)

x&v

bvxcov

yaQ dnb tysv6ovg dQy6(isvov xov 'ovx s6xiv xax sig dXr\%sg xaxaXf)^SL 6xoLfSLa avxbv xb 's6xlv dfiSQf) x&v bvxoov 6xoL%sia\ oi 6s xr\v 6vvaQXr\6LV siedyovxsg vyisg slvai cpaac 6vvr\(i(iivov, otav xb "dvxLXsifievov x& ivavxoo Xf)yovxi (id%r\xai xca iv
OxoLysui
dfisQf)

dsl

x&v

ovxoov

i<

r)yov(iivoo' xa& ovg xd (isv SLQr\(iiva 6vvrj(i(iiva s6xai noy&rjQa, ixsivo 6s dXtj&ig 'si i]usqcc s6xlv, rjtiiQa 112 s6xtv\ oi 6s xr\ icicpdasi XQivovxig cpa6iv oxi dXrj&ig iaxt

avx&

6vvr)(i(iivov ov xb Xf)yov iv xoo r)yov(iivoo nsQii^sxai 6vvd(iSL' xa& ovg xb 'si r)(iiQa soxiv, r)(iiQa s6xi xai nav
xb 6iacpoQOv(ievov [dl-ioo(ia] 6wr\(i(iivov i6oog tjjev6og eOxaL'

v.

113 avxb yaQ xl iv eavxop nsQLixs6&ai d(if)yavov. xavxrjv xoivvv

xf)v

6iacpooviav

imxQL%f)vaL

d(if)%avov

L6oog

slvai

66sl.
2

o%xs yaQ dvano6sixxoog nQOXQivovxig xiva x&v 6xa6soov x&v nQOSiQt](iivoov ni6xol ioofis&a ovxs (isxd dno6sit),soog. xal

yaQ

f)

dn66si]-Lg

vyif)g slvai
II

6oxsl, oxav dxoXov&fj

xrj

6iac

110

~ adv. dogm.

113117.

xsg

28 oi avvvndq^sL EAB 81 Lif) secl. Kayser 10 avvdyov12 predicta T 17 xb om. edd. dLacpoQovitevov MEAB SnpogoLisvov (eras. a) L omne quod diversificatur T 19 ]post focog add. ccv L 20 opinionum T a^icoLia del. Bekk. (cpdascDV, quod iam coni. Gen.)

||

||

TII0TTII&2E&N
t<5v

B.

93

Xr\(i(idxcov avxf)g 6v(inXoxf) xb 6v(iniQa6(ia avxf)g cog Xfjyov r)yov(iivcp, olov oftxcog *ei f)(iiQa eextv, cpcog e6xtv

i5

dXXd ur)v r)uiQa e6xtV

cpcog eoxiv'

cpcog

aoa

e6xtv.

siiteo

xai r)(iioa e6xt xai

ncog

cpcog

eoxiv''.

rftteqa e6xt, r\xov(iivov Se 114

neol xov
7tQog
(juv
jo

xQtvovuev
6

xb

f)yovuevov,
r)

StdXXrjXog

yaQ

XQi6tg

xov

Xr\yovxog evQicmexai xQonog. tva 6vvrfti(xivov dnoSetx&rj , xb 6v(ixr)v

,

dxoXov&iav

xov

,j

jtiQa6(ia xoig Xf)u(ux6t xr)g dnoSeiijecog dxoXov&ei, cog itQoeiQr)xauev' tva 8e ndXtv xovxo nt6xevd f\, Sei xb 6vvr}(i(ii-

*3

vov xai
xdXr\nxov

xr\v

dxoXov%iav intxexQi6%at' oneQ dxonov. dxa- 115 dXXd xai xb aoa xb vyteg 6vvr\uuivov.

xb (iev yao nQoxanQOxa&r\yovuevov dnoQOv e6xtv. ftrjyovuevov, cog cpa6tv, i6xl xb f)yovuevov iv xotovxco 6vvr\uuivco, o aQ%exat dnb dXrj&ovg xai ini dXr\&ig. ei 8e ixxaXvnxtxdv i6xi xov Xr)yovxog 116 Xr)yet to 6r\ueiov, r)xot nQoSrjXov iext xb Xf)yov r) dSr\Xov. ei uev ovv nQo8r\Xov, ovSe xov ixxaXvtyovxog Ser\6exat^ dXXd 6vyxaxaXr\cp&r\6exai avxcp, xai ovx e6xai avxov 6r\ueicoxov, SioneQ ovSk ixeivo xovzov 6r\(ieiov. ei 8e aSr\Xov, inei ne^i xcbv d8r\Xcov Sianecpcovr\xat dventxQixcog, noia (iiv i6xiv avxcov dXrj&f)

10

noia Se

tyevSr), xai SXcog ei e6xt

xt

avxcov dXrj&ig, aSrjXov

e6xai, ei eig dXrj&eg Xf)yet xo 6vvr\uuivov. co 6vvei6iQ%exat xai xb dSr\Xov elvai ei nQOxa&r\yeixai xb iv avxcp r)yovuevov.
15

tva

Se xai xavxa

elvai xov Xf)yovxog, eiye

naQaXinco(iev , ov Svvaxat ixxaXvnxtxbv 117 n^bg xb 6r\ueiov e6xt xb 6r\uetco-

xbv xai Sta xovro 6vyxaxaXaudvexat avxco. xa yaQ nQog xi dXXr)Xotg 6vyxaraXauf5dverat' xai co6neQ xo Sei^tov nQO
80 xat,

xov aQi6xeQov cog Seijtbv dot6xeQov xaxaXr\cp9r)vat ov SvvaovSe dvdnaXtv, xai ini xcov dXXcov xcov nQog xt naQanXr\6icog,
cog

oflxcog

ovSe

xb

6r\(ieiov

nQo xov

6r\(tetcoxov

xaxaXr\cp&f\vai Svvaxbv e6xat. ei 5' ov jroo- 118 xaxaXa(idvexai xb 6r\(ieiov xov 6r\(ietcoxov, ovSe ixxaXvnxtxbv
6r\(ietcoxov

117118 ( 119120)
26 xal rjfiiga autem quomodo) cf.
(erit)
cf. v.
:

~ adv. dogm.

II 165.

Isxtv om. T
p. 84,
||

16

13: Hsxtv G 22 a>g arfttstaxov ML crftistwxtxdv A signum ante signatum tamquam signati T om. EAB, fortasse scrib. ag <^6rftislovy 6ri(isicorov coll. v. 19.

27 %ea\ xov om. T (quesito 8 ixxaXvipavxog L 9 i-oxai T

:

ex corr.

94
ccvxov

I1TPPNEIN

Svvuxui vnd^ystv xov aua ccvxco xcci fir) fisx ccvxb xaxccXafiuvofisvov. ovxovv xui o6ov ini xoig xoivoxsqov ksxcbv exeqoSo^cov uvsntv6i\x6v S6xi xb 6r\fisiov. xcci yaQ JiQog xi xcci ixxuXvnxtxbv xov 6r\fiLcoxov , JiQog co 119 cpu6LV ttvxb slvai, xovxo slvai lsyov6LV. o&sv et fisv TtQog

25

yofiivotg

vnb

xi

S6xl xai, TtQog

xco

6r\fistcoxcb,

6vyxaxaXafidvE6d-at ndvxco

xcog

ocpsiksi rco 6r\fitcoxcb,

ttvco xcb

xui xb

xu&dnEQ xb uql6xeqov xdxco xui xd ukku <(t) nQog rt. si

6r)fisicoxov ,

Se^lco 30

6s ixxa-

kvnxtxov i6xt xov

ndvrcog
ocpsiksi,

nQ0xccxttXccudvE6&ut ccvrov
sig

ivu

7tQOE7tiyvco6&Ev

svvoiav

i)uag

120 clydyrj xov i% avxov yivco6xofiivov

Ss ivvor)6ai nQuyfiu
vai,
fir)

nQayficcxog.

uSvvuxov 8

Svvdfisvov tcqo ixsivov yvco6&r\-

ov 7tQOxaxccXafij3dvE6&at uvdyxr\v sySL' uSvvuxov uqcc imvosiv xt xai nQog xt ov xai ixxaXvnxixbv ixsivov vnuQco

ypv TtQog
i7ttvor)6ttt

vosixat.

xb

Ss

6r\fisiov

xui

TtQog

xt

cpu6iv

slvui xcci ixxuXvnxtxbv xov 6r\fisicoxov'

uSvvuxov

aQcc i6xiv

xb 6r\(isiov.
rcbv

121

xoig

Siacpcovicc ysyovs naQu Xsyovxcov slvcci xt 6r\fisiov ivSelxxlxov, xcbv Sh fir\Shv slvat 6r\fisiov ivSstxxtxbv cpu6xovxcov. 6 Xiycov ovv slvui xt 6r\fisiov iv8stxxtxbv r)xoi unlcbg

i7p6g xovxotg xuxelvo Xsxxsov.

TtQO
i)(icbVy

fihv

iQsi xcci uvuTtoSsixxcog, tptlrj <pu6si yQcbfisvog,

SsL^scog.

r\

ftsxu

uno-

ukV
r\

1 flEV

CpU6l fXOVJj

%Qrj6sxai,

U7tt6XOg E6XCCL,

sl

8h

U7toSsiE,ttt

0V\r}6Xttt ,

xb

r]XOVflSVOV

6VVaQ7tU6Sl.
i

122 insi yuQ

an6Ssttg xco ysvst 6r\fuiov eXvui kiyExut, ccficpt6r\xovfiivov xov tioxeqov s6xt xt 6r\fiiov r) OVX E6XLV,
dficpL6^f)xr]6Lg 6xul
r)

xcci

ovdaficbg, co6nEQ

xa&

TtEQi xov noxEQOv s6xtv unoSsti^ig vno&E6tv r\xov(ievov si s6xt lcbov,

r\xsixttt

&Qconog.

xca ns^i xov si s6xtv ccv&Qconog' ^coov yuQ 6 uvuxonov Ss xb fyxovusvov Stu xov in t6r\g r\r\

xovusvov
123
ccqcc

fif\xs

dnoSsi^scog Svvr\6sxui rtg SLafisfiaiovo&ai, oxt s6xt 6r\fisiov. si Ss dnXcbg (ifjts f^Etu unoSsil-Ecog otov xs i6xt nsQi xov

Si

Ectvrov unoSstxvvvat'

ovSs St

119 120~adv. dogm.

121122
rs,

II 165.

adv. dogm. II

179181.

31 xd suppl. e

(alia que sunt ad aliguid) 2 percognosciT

(fort. ijttyvcoad-fjvat cf. p. 83, 33).

admodum enim T

1 9 %eqI

xov om. T 21 ovdh Bekk.

4/5 vndq%ov om.

:

18 quem-

otixs

GT (nec)

xnoTTn&SE&N
6r)(ieiov
25

b.

95

Stafiefiaicoxixcog dnocpatveo&at , dSvvaxov e6xt neol avxov xaxaXr]nxixr)v dnocpa6tv noir)6a6&at' el Se (jtr) xafiexa

xaXattfidvexat

dxQtfieiag

xb

6r)(ieiov,

ovSe

6r)(iavxt-

xbv elvai

(ievoV xovxov xbv intXoyi6(ibv avvnaoxxov e6xat xb

*

Xex&fjeexai xivog axe Sf) (ir)Se avxb otioXoyovStd Se xovxo ovSe 6r](ieiov eaxat. o&ev xal xaxcc
6r)(ieiov

xal

80

dventvor)XOv.

"Ext
e6xl

(livxoi
6r](xeia

xdxeivo
r)

Qrjxeov.

r\xot

cpaiv6(ieva

(ibvov 124

ty*5

dSrjXa fiovov, r) xcov 6rj(ieicov xa (iev e6xi cpatvotteva, xa Se aSr)Xa. ovSev Se xovxcov e6xlv fiyteg' ovx aoa e6xt 6r](ieiov. oxi (ilv ovv dSrjXa ovx e6xi itdvxa

xa

xd

6rj(ieia,

ivtev&ev Seixvvtat.
cog

cpaivetat, nintet. xal xb 6r)(ieiov ow, ei adrjXov etr), exeoov Ser)6exai 6r\(ieiov dSf)Xov, inei (irjSev cpatv6(ievov i6tt 6r](ieiov

ol Soytiattxoi cpa6tv,

xb aSr)Xov ovx e eavxov dXXd Si exeoov vno-

xaxd

xr)v nQ0xet(ievr]v

vno&eetv, xdxeivo dXXov, xal

(le^Qtg

dneiQOv. dSvvatov Se dnetQa 6r)(ieia Xattfidvetv' dSvvaxov aQa to 6r\(ieiov xataXrjcpdfjvai aSrjXov ov. Sid Se xovxo
10 (ieiov

xal dvvnaQXXov e6tat, (xf) Svvd(ievov 6r)(jtaivetv xt xal 6r\ei Se ndvxa xd 125 elvat Std xb (ir) xataXafifidvee&at. 6r](ieia cpatvottevd iettv, inel xa\ nQog xt i6xi xb 6r](ieiov xai nQog xco
dXXf)Xotg,
6r](ietcoxco,

xd Se nQog xt 6vyxaxaXa(i(ldvexat
elvat

15
[

Xey6(ieva 6vv xoig cpatvotievotg xataXa(xav6(isva cpatvofieva e6xat' &6neQ yuQ d(ia 'hnontnxovxcov xov xe Se^tov xai xov aQt6xeQ0v ov (i&XXov

xd

6r)(ietcoxd

Setbv xov aQt6xeQ0v r) xb ao>To6v xov Sei-iov cpaive6&at Xeyexat, oftxco 6vyxaxaXa(i(iavo(Jtev(Ov xov xe 6t](ieiov xai xov 6r)ttetcoxov ov (i&XXov xb 6r](ieiov r) xb 6t]xb
(letcoxbv

0 (letcoxov,

cpaive6&at r)xeov. ei Se cpatv6(ievov i6xt xb 6t]- 126 ovSe 6r)(ietcoxbv e6xat (ir) Seotievov xov 6r)(ia-

vovvxog avxb xai ixxaXvipovxog. vov Se^tov ovSe aQt6xeQov e6xtv,

6r)(ietcoxov

o&ev S>6neQ dvatQOvtteottxcog

ovSe

6r)(ieiov

elvat

dvatQOvtcevov xov Svvaxat, co6xe dvvnaQxxov

125

~ adv. dogm.
6r}(iavTix6v

II 174.

26/27
p. 355,

22

9/10 nec signum

G: signatum T: aTtocpuvctv Kayser esse T 11 xal TtQbg om. T

coll.

96
svQicxsrat rb

IITPP&NEI&N
I

Gr\fisiov,

stnsQ

cpaivofisvcc

fiova slvat Xiyot

127 rtg xa

Xsinsrcct Xiystv, oxi r&v Grjfisicov xa fiiv crjfisia. iaxi cpcctvofisva, xa 8h a8r)Xa' xcci otixcog 8h ai dnoQiat fiix&v xe yaQ cpatvofiivcov Grjfisicov xa arjfiEicoxd vovCtv. elvai Xsyofisva cpcctvofisvcc sGxat, xcc&d nQoetQrjxccfiev , xoci
fir)

deofieva xov

crjfiavovvxog ovdh CrjfiEicoxd

crjfieia

oXcog

vtvccq-

|, o&ev ov8h ixsiva

128 xd xe
dSr\Xa
Crj(isicc

saxat,

firjShv

ar\fiaivovxa'

%Qrjovxa x&v
Grjficcivsa&ai

ixxccXvipovxcov
Xiyrjxat,
eig

avxd,

idv

fiev

vnb

dSrjXcov

dnstQOV

ixninxovxog xov Xoyov dxaxdXrjnxcc xovxo dvvnccQxxcc, cog nQOstQrjxafisv'

fiivcov,

idv

svQiaxsxat xal Std Sh vnb cpatvo-s

sCxat Cvv xoig cpaivofiivoig avx&v Crjfieioig xaxaXafifiavofLEvtt , Std 8h xovxo xat dvvnaQxxa. dSvvaxov yaQ elvai xi nQdyficc, o xal aSrjXov icxi cpvcpaivofieva
aei xccl

cpaivofievov , xd Sh Grjfisia

nsQt cov icxiv 6 Xoyog,

uSrjXa

129 nrjv

vnoxe&ivxa, cpaivdfiEva EVQi&rj xaxd xr)v nsQtXQOxov Xoyov. sl ovv firjxs ndvxcc xd Grjfisia cpcctvo-

fievd icxi firjxs ndvxcc dSrjXcc, firjxs x&v Grjfisicov xivd fiiv icxt cpcctvofisva, xivd Sh dSrjXa, xat nccQa xavxa ovShv

sCrtv,
Grjfisia.

cog

xal avxoi cpccGiv,

dvvnccQxxa

sGxcci

xd

Xsyofisvcc

130

Tavxa
o"Oat

(ihv

ovv

bXiycc

dnb noXX&v aQxicst vvv

stQfj-

nQog vnofivrjGtv xov fir) slvai Grjfisiov ivSstxrtxov' H-r)g Sh xocl xdg vnofivrjGstg xov slvai xi Grjfisiov ix^rjGofie&a, tvcc xr)v laoc&ivsiav x&v dvxixsifiivcov Xoycov naovv GrjfiaivovGi xi ccl xaxa xov Cr\rjrot QccGxr)acofisv.
fisiov

cpcoval cpEQOfisvcci

r)

ovShv

GrjficcivovCtv.

xccl

sl

fisv

xtvrjGstav rrjv flnaQ^iv xov arjfisiov; 131 si Sh Crjfiaivovai xi, ecxi arjueiov. ert rjrot dnoSetxxtxoi eiatv oi Xoyot oi xaxd xov Crjfieiov r) ovx dno$eixxixoi.
darjfioi sictv,

n&g dv

dXX

ei

fiev

ovx dnoSeixxixoi ,
ei 8h

ovx dnoSeixvvovet, xb
r)

firj

elvcct crjfieiov'

dnoSstxxtxoi , inst

dnoSet^tg

xco yi-

vst Grjfisiov icxtv, ixxaXvnxtxr)

ovGa xov 6v(insQdCfiaxog,

dogm.
:

130 oo adv. dogm. II 279. adv. 131 (v. 24 crjfielov)

II

277278.

31 aixd om.
vov

T 32
:

Xiyr\xat

videntur

5 cpuivofie-

EB

(manifesta)

13

(t,r)

14

(palvetat

xov om.

G EAB

6 vnort&ivxcc L 12 aQniaeiv 16 &vrtxet(iivcov om. T

TnOTTn&SESN
i

B.

97

67jftsiov.

o&ev

xal

xi 6r]fisiov, e6xi 6r)(iiov,

\6r](isiov'

6vvsQcoxaxaL Xoyog roLOvrog' si xai si (ii) s6ri 6r)fisiov, t6xi

6r)fisiov

xb

yc\o

(ir)

slvai

l6ti 6i]fisiov,
6r)fisiov'

Ssixvvrai.

r\xoi

e6xlv

aoa

6r)fisiov.

oV dnoSEi^scog, r) Sf) Ss 6xi 6r)fisiov r) ovx s6ri rovxco Ss x& Xoyco nuQu- 132

si ovx %6xi xi 6r)fisiov, ovx s6ri xoiovxog Xoyog. xal i 6xi 6rj(iEiov o cpa6cv oi SoyfiaxLxol 6r\6r)fisiov'

KEixat

ovx 6ri 6t]fisiov. xo yuQ 6rjfisiov nsQi ov 6 xaxa xr)v inivoiuv ccvxov xal ngog xi slvai XsyofiEXoyog, vov xal ixxaXvnxixbv xov 6r)fiELCoxov , dvvnaQxrov svql6ksxai, cog nccQE6rf)6ttfisv. r]xoi Ss s6xi 6r)fisiov f) ovx E6ri 133 rcbv cpcovcov xctl 6r)(isiov' ovx ccqcc s6n 6r)fisiov. tieqI Ss rtov vtcsq xov 6t]fisiov ccvxol ccitoxQivcc6d-co6av ol Soyfiaxixoi, noxsQov 6r)(iaivov6i xi r) ovSsv 6r)fiaivov6iv. si (isv yccQ ovSev 6r)fiaivov6LV) ov ni6xovxui xb slvai 6r)(isiov'
(ielov

sivai,

si Sh 6r)fiaivov6iv,

Ss r\v

xb

(tsiov, cog

dxoXov&r]6i avxaig xb 6r)fisicox6v. xovxo 6r)[isiov' co snsxctL rb ^firf} slvai 6r\vnsfivr)6ufisv, xard xr)v xov Xoyov nsQiXQonr\v.
slvcci xi

II

TIXr)v

dXX
fir)

oftrco eIvccl

xal nQog xb
6r)(isiov
r)

ni&uvcov xal nQog rb slvai 6i]fisiov Xoycov cpEQOfisvcov , ov fiaXXov slvai

fir)

sivai Qrjrsov.

i(}' nsQi dnoSsit-scog. QavSQOv fuv ovv ix rovrcov, oxi ovSs r) dnoSsi^Lg 6(io- 134 Xoyovfisvov xi nQayfid i6riv' si yuQ nsQi xov 6r)fisiov

iniypfisv,
j

xccl

r)

dnoSsi^ig

Ss

6t]fisi6v
xccX

xi

i6ri,

xccl

nsQi

xr)g

yuQ EVQi]60fisv rovg nsQL xov 6r](isiov Xoyovg r)Qcorr)fisvovg icpaQfio&e&at Svinsl xul nQog xl slvat, vccfisvovg xccl xaru xr)g dno8sii\scog
dnoSsil-Ecog inkysiv

dvdyxt).

ixxaXvnrixr) rov 6v[insQu6fiuxog, oig r)xoXov&si xu nQog xb 6t]fisiov i)fiiv siQr)fiivu 6%sSbv unuvxcc. si Ss 135 6sZ xul iSicog nsQi dnoSsi^scog sinsiv, 6vvr6(icog insXsvxccl

Soxsi

% 131 (inde a. v. 24 o&bv) ~adv. 134 135~adv. dogm. II 299.

dogm.

II

281282.

25 xl om. EAB 29 si om. L add.Kayser 14 dh om. AT at cf. p. 20/21 ingrediemur T

Sextus Empiricua
I.

7 xi
32",

27.

L: om. MEABT (ii) 17 xaxd xrjv rf)s L

||

98

nTPPNEISN

60fiat xbv %ol avxr)g Xoyov, TiQoteoov 6acpr)vi6at TtsiQa&eig dta ^Qayicov, xi <paaiv elvat xr\v dnoSu^tv.

"E6xtv ovv, cog cpa6iv, r) dnodttg Xoyog 8t ofioXoyovfiivcov Xrjfifidxcov xaxd 6vvaycoyr)v intcpoqc\v ixxaXvnxcov adrjXov. 6acpi6xQ0v 8h o Xiyov6iv 6xat

Sta

xovxcov.

Xoyog 6x1 6v6xr\fia ix

Xrjfi-

136 fidxcov

xai intcpOQccg' xovxov 6h Xr)fifiaxa (ihv rivat Xiyxai xd TtQog xaxa6xvr)v xov 6vfinQa6fiaxog 6vficpcovcog Xafij3av6fiva d^tcafiaxa, intcpOQa dh
[6vfi7tiQa6fia]

xo

ix
otov
>

xcov
iv

(ivov

d^icofia.

Xrjfifidxcov xaxa6Xva6xovxco xm (Xoycpy *i r)fiQa

9

6xt, cpcog 6xtv'

fihv 'cpcog

dXXa

fir\v r)fiiQa

6xiv'
i6xt,

cpcog

aQa 6xtv

xb

aQa 6xtv 6v(iniQa6(id

xa Sh Xotna

Xr)fifiuxa.

137 xcov 6h Xoycov oi fiiv u6t 6vvaxxtxoi oi dh a6vvaxxot, 6vvaxxtxoi ftiv, oxav xb 6vvr\fifiivov xb dQy6fivov fihv dnb dta xcov xov Xoyov Xrjfifidxcov 6vfinnXyfiivov, Xf)8h ig xr)v intcpOQav avxov, fiythg $, olov 6 nQOUQr\yov fiivog Xoyog 6vvaxxtx6g i6xtv, inu xrj dtd xcov Xrjfifidxcov

xov

avxov 6v(inXoxf) xavxr\

cpcog
fiivco

r)fiiQa 6xt

xai

rjfiiQa

6xt,

%6xw dxoXov&u xb
c

'cpcog 6xtv' iv

xovxco

x&

6vvr)fi-

[ei] r)fiiQa k'6xt,

(ir\

138 axxot 6h oi
xb

ofixcog %ovxg.

xai i rjfiiQa 6xt, cpcog 6xtv.' a6vvxcov Sh 6vvaxxtxcov oi fiiv

,

U6tv dXr\&ug oi 6h ovx dXrj&ug

fiovov
6vvr)(ifiivov ix
xr)g

dXrj&ug

(iiv,

oxav

(ir\

xcov

Xrjfifidxcov
r),

xai

xr)g

avxov 6vfini6xtv rjyov(itvov iv xco 6vdXrj&hg vnuQ%r\, nX^yfiivov vrjfifiivco. dXrj&hg Sh 6vfinnXyfiivov i6xi xb ndvxa jpv dXrj&r), cbg xb *r)fiiQU arri, xai ri rjfiiQa l'<Jrt, cpcog 6xtv/
6v(iniQa6fia

intcpOQ&g, cog nQOUQr)xafiv , vythg xai xb dta xcov Xrjfifidxcov

6vfinXoxr)g dXXa xai xb

139 ovx dXri&ug dh oi

firj

ovxcog ypvxg.
6xtv'
II

yaQ xotovxog
firjv

X6-

yog

*t

vv

6xt,

6x6xog

dXXa

vvS,

6xiv'

135 138~adv. dogm.

139

~ adv. dogm.

301304.

II 311.

21 temptantes T 29 7) post 8h add. Gen. Bekk. 29* csvy,om. T 30 d^imfia del. Pasquali servato v. 29* avfiXoyto suppl. e T (ut in hac ratione) cf. v. 23 et p. 88 passim 7 secl. Rtistow cp&g %cxtv bis ME 1 7 post Xoyog edd. 19 xal si v. I. om. T inser. rjfiiQag o%6ng coll. p. 356, 7. 17 aXXd
7tigaO(ia TtiqaGfia
|| ||

TII0TTn2EN
>

B.

99

6x6xog uqu s6xtv 6vvaxxixbg (isv i6xtv, insi xb 6vvrj(i(isvov xovxo vyiig i<5xiv *\et\ vv^ e6xt, xai si vvt, e6xt, 6x6xog
)

(tGxiv' 6x6x0?:) aoa e6xtv', ov ttivxot dXrj&f)g. xb yuQ r)yov' vv e6xt, xui el (isvov 6v(inenXey(ievov tyevSog i6xt, xb

vv

%6xt,

6x6xog

s6xt,'

tpevSog

eyov

iv

eavx& xb

*vv,

e6xtv'' tyevSog ydo i6xi 6v(inenXey(iivov xb eyov iv euvxcZ tyevSog. ev&ev xal dXrj&f] Xoyov elvui (pa6i xbv dt dXr\i

ft&v
Ss

Xrjn(idxa>v

x&v dXrj&cov Xoycov

dXrj&eg oi

6vvdyovxa
(jtiv

ndXtv 140 6v(i7tioa6(ia. sietv dnoSstxxtxoi, ol 8 ovx

dnoSstxxtxoi, xal dnoSstxxtxoi (thv ol Stu nQo8r)Xcov u8r\Xov xi 6vvdyovxeg , ovx dnoSstxxixoi Ss oi (ir\ xotovxot.
olov
o
(

(iev

xotovxog

Xoyog

si

rjfiega
>

s6xt,

cpcog

s6xtv'

dXXd

s6xtV cp&g uqu %6xtv ovx s6xtv dnoSetxxixog' xb ydo cp&g sivut, onsQ i6xlv uvxov 6v(jtniou6(iu,
(irjv

r)(iSQU

TtQoSrjXov i6xtv.

6 Se xotovxog *si iSqcoxeg qsov6i Std xr)g

intcpuvsiug ,

9Sid

xfjg

i6xt,
TtoQOt

vor\xot noQOi' dXXu (ir\v iSQ&xeg Q~iov6t et6tv uqu vorjxol TtoQOt' dnoSetxxtxog xb 6v(i7tiQu6(iu syjcov uSrjXov, xb 'ei6tv uqu vorjxot
eidi

intcpuveiug'

x&g
5

x&v Se uSrjXov xt 6vvay6vxcov oi (iev icpoSsvxt- 141 fiovov uyov6iv r)(iug Siu x&v Xrjfifidxcov ini xb 6V(iotov 7tiQu6(iu, oi Se icpoSsvxtx&g ctfia x.ui ixxuXvnxtx&g.
.

iqpoSsvxtx&g

(jtsv

oi
i6xtv

ix

ni6xsmg
xoiovxog

xai
*et

(jtvf)(ir\g

Soxovvxeg,

otog

xig

601

elnev
Se
6

rjQxfj^&ut ort

ovxog' nXovxr\6et ovxog, nXovxf)6st (Ssixvvttt Ss xu& vn6&s6tv xbv Aiu)

mtf)6st

ovxo6t

dsog

sini 601 oxt nXov-

ovxog'

nXovxr\6st

uqu

yuQ

to5 6v(ineQu6(iaxt

ov%

ofixcog

ovxog'' 6vyxuxuxt&i(ie&u Stu xr\v x&v Xrj(i(idxcov

dvdyxrjv

oi Ss ov 142 thg nt6xevovxeg xrj xov &sov unocpu6et. (iovov icpoSsvxtxcog uXXu xui ixxuXvnxtx&g uyov6tv r)(iug ini t6 6v(iniQu6(ia, chg 6 xotovxog *si qsov6i Stu xrjg intcpuvsiug iSQtoxsg, st6i vorjxoi noQOt. dXXd (ir)v xb nQ&7

xov'

xb

Ssvxsqov uqu'

xb

yuQ Qsiv xovg iSQ&xug ixxaII

140143

~ adv. dogm.
||

305310.

ML

19 d secl. Riistow xal si vvg EABT (et si): xal r) vv 20 add. Rustow 21 xb (siy vvT (si n. est) 7 post aot Pabr. add. Q-scov coll. p. 355, 16, ubi delendum 11 rijv om. M

100

IITPPSNEI&N
8i

Xvnxtxdv i6xt xov noQOvg slvat, Sta xb nQOStXr)cp&ai oxt 143 Std vaoxov 6cbfiaxog vyQov ov Svvaxat cpSQS6&at. r) ovv
dndSst^ig xal Xdyog slvai dcpsiXst xal 6vvay.xiy.og xal dXr)&r)g Kal aSrjXov e%cov 6vfineQa6fia [xat] iKKaXvnxdfievov vnb xr)g Svvdfiecog xtov Xr)fifidxcov , Kal Sid xovxo elvat
Xeyexat dndSet^tg Xdyog St
bfioXoyovfiivcov Xrjfifidxcov xaxd
fiev
2

6vvaycoyr)v intcpOQav ixxaXvnxcov aSrjXov. Std xovxcov ovv 6acpr\vtstv slco&a6t xr)v evvoiav xr)g dnoSefeecog.
ty

ei

%6xtv dndSet^tg.
i6xtv
r)

144
cov

"Oxt

Se

dvvTtaQxxdg

dndSetl-ig ,

dii
xcov

avxcov
neQt-

Xeyov6tv e%ofievcov iv
6vyxstxat
il-

iniXoyie6&ai Svvaxdv, ivvoia StaxQenovxa. xrj

dico(idxcov ,
(ir)

exa6xov
oiov

yovv

xd xa

Se
i|

6vv&exa
cov

Xdyog nQayfiaxa ov
3

6vve6xr\xev dXXf)Xotg xat xcov naQanXrjoxe fieQr) xov Xdyov dXXr)Xoig ov 6vvvnaQyet. yaQ Xeyofiev xb nQtoxov Xr)fifia, ovSenco vnaQyei ovxe xb exeQOv Xr)(i(ia oftxe r) intcpoQa' oxe Se xb SevxeQOV cpaftsv,

Svvaxai vnaQyetv, idv

cog

evvvndQyr), 6icov, xa Se

7tQoSr\Xov

dnb

xXivr\g

xb

fisv

nQoxsQOv

Xr)(ifia

ovxext

vnaQ%et,

i)

Se

intcpoQa9
Xr)fi-

ovSenco e6xtv'

oxe Se xr)v intcpOQav nQocpeQOfie&a, xa

ov 6vvvnaQ%et aQa dXXr)Xoig xa fJteQr) xov Xdyov' o&ev ovSe 6 Xdyog vnaQ%etv Sdet. 145 jfcooig Se xovxcov o 6vvaxxtxbg Xdyog dxaxdXr)nxdg iextv' si yaQ ovxog xQivsxat dnb xr)g xov 6vvr)(ifiivov axoXovfiaxa avxr)g ovxext vcpe6xr)xev.

&iag,

Ss xaxd xb 6vvr)fi(isvov dxoXov&ia dvsntxQixcog r) Stanscpcovr)xat xat e6xiv t6cog dxaxdXr)nxog , cog iv xco neQt 6r)fieiov Xdyco ( 110 114) vnsfivr)6a(isv, xai 6 6vv-

146 axxtxbg Xdyog dxaxdXrptxog e6xat.

cpa6tv

oi'

ys

(ir)v

StaXsxxtxoi

&6vvaxxov Xdyov yiyvs6&at rjxot naQa StaQxt)6tv r) naQa eXXettytv r) naQa xb xaxd fiox&rjQov i)Qcoxr)6&ai ff^^jtt r) xaxd naQoXxf)v. olov xaxa StaQxr)6tv
fiev,

oxav
xal

fir)

xd

Xr)fifiaxa
cbg

dxoXov&iav
xotovxog
*el

n^bg
r)fiiQait

dXXr)Xd

xe

xr)v

intcpOQav,

% 144 cf. 109. 146 150~adv. dogm.

II

429434.
(Jaqprjv/fcov

20 xal

del.

Kayaer, om.

T 24

EAB

I
>

TII0TTn2EN
cpcog

B.

101
ccyooa
TtcoXovv-

i'o*Tt,

e6xtV

dXXd

(ir)v
.

xat'

Aitov aoa JtSQiTtaxBV

Xfjfifia
r

TCUQa.

TtVQoi 6e
xr)v

iv

7tccQoXxf)v,

orav ev- 147

QiG%r]xai
yf)v,

TtaQiXxov
e6xt,

JtQog
cpcog

olov

ei

f)(iiQa

t6xtv'

xov Xoyov 6vvay(odXXd (tr)v f)(iiQcc

e6xtv, aXXa xcci Aicov TteQtTtccxet' cpcog ccoa e6xtv\ TtccQa 6e xb ev (lOi&rjQcj r]Qcoxf]6&cci 6yr](itaxi, otckv (if) y xb xov Xoyov 6vvaY.xw.6v, otov bvxcov 6vXXoyt6xtxcov, cog 6%r)(itt
(

cpcc6t,

toijtcov

ei i)fitQa

e6xt,
'ei

cpcog

e6xtV dXXd

(ir)v f)(iiQa

e6xtv'

cpcog ccqu e6xtv',

f)(iiQa

6e cpcog e6xtv' ovx

5

ttQa

f)(iiQa

e6xt, (cpcog i'o*Ttv^>" ovyi e6xtv', 6 Xoyog a6vvaxxog

0*Ttv

ovxog
r)(iiQcc

*ei

f)(iiQa

e6xt,

cpcog

e6xtv'

dXXd

(if)v

cpcog

e6xtv'

ccqcc

e6xtv\

eitel

vt](i(iivov ivxbg

xov iv

ccvxco

inayyiXXexat xb 6v- 148 r)yov(iivov elvccv xai xb Xf)yov,

ya.Q

eixoxcog

vov

r)yov(iivov
ei

7tQ06Xa(i(3ccvo(iivov

indyexat
dvaiQetxat r)v ccv xai

xai
xcci

xb
o

Xf)yov,

xai xov

to

Xf)yov.

f)yov(ievov' xov 6e

Xr)yovxog dvr}Qr](iivov yccQ r)V xb f)yov(ievov ,

xb

Xf)yovxog
r)yov(ievov'

nQo6Xcc(i(iccvo(iivov

xi&exat xai
vr](i(iivov

k r)yov(iivco
vr](i(iivov

ov6e yaQ dxoXov&etv xb f)yov(ievov, dXXd xco Xr)yovxt 6id xovxo ovv 6 (tev ex 6v- 149 xb Xf)yov fiovov. xai xov f)yov(iivov xb Xf)yov 6vvdycov 6vXXoytxb
xco

ndvxcog vntGyyeixo xb 6v-

ov

6xtxbg

eivcct

Xiyexat,

xai

6 in 6vvr](i(iivov xai

xov dvxt-

xet(xivov
5

xov

6vvdycoV
(tevov

xb dvxtxei(ievov xco r)yov(iivco Xr)yovxog 6 6e ex 6vvr](i(iivov xai xov Xf)yovxog xb f)yovcog

6vvdycov a6vvaxxog,
bvxcov
xcov

6 7tQoeiQt](iivog,

nccQO xai

dXr]9cov
bxccv
*ei
to
f)

Xr](i(idxcov

Xvyytaiov cpcoxbg bvxog

1'oxt,

tyev6og 6vvdyet, vvxxbg Xiyrjxat. xb (iev yaQ

ccvxov

f)(iiQa

cp&g

e6xt

*dXXd

(if)v

cpcog e6xt

7tQ06Xr]tytg,

6vvr](i(iivov dXrj&ig e6xtv, xcci 61 '<f](iiQa cxqcc <(i'o"Ttv)>' f)

eTtttpoQtt tyev6r)g.

xccxd nctQaXeitytv

6i e6xt

jno^ijoog Xo- 150

19 Ttagd 23 Uxiv om. T 16 et 19 socrates T 21 23 cp&g 6vXloyi6xtyc&v scr. coll. p. 91,2; 382,4: 6vXXoyt6\icov G 25 ovtos G: secundum hec T lexiv add. T cp&g alter. T
||

(lumeri): f)(iiga

Fabr.) 28 ccvatQovfiivov

sUotcog 29

26

f)iiQci

(dies): cp&g

Xf)yov

om.

EAB

(transpos.
:

iam

29

EAB

x&g

LEAB

8 Xiyexat

EAB

itQoetQr\(tivog

MT

&vr]Q7](iivov

ML:

(predicta)

10 hxtv add. T

jtQosiQr]-

(ergo dies esft

cf. p.

90, 26.

102
yog, su
(o

IITPP&NEI&N
naQaXstnexat
xt

xcov

Ttoog xr\v

6vvaycoyr\v

xov
eog

6VfinEQa6fiaxog
otovxat,
r\

yQr\6ifivovxcov'
*r\xot

olov

vytovg
Itixiv

ovxog,
6

xov Xoyov xovxov

r\

aycc&og

nXovxog
aStdcpo-

xaxbg

dStdcpoQog'

ovxe Sh xaxog i6xiv ovxs

dya&bg &Qa i6xiv\ cpavXog 6xi naQa EXXsttytv ovxog Qog' ovx e6xi o Xoyog r\xot ccya&og 6xiv 6 nXovxog r\ xaxog' 151 8s xaxog' dya&bg ccqo 6xiv' idv ovv Seitlco oxi ovSsfiia
.

StacpoQa x&v a6vvdxxcov 8taxQivs6&at Svvaxat xax avxovg dnb x&v 6vvaxxtx&v , eSeii^a oxi dxaxdXrjnxog i6xiv 6 6vv-

axxtxbg Xoyog, cog neQtxxdg elvat xdg xaxd StaXexxtxr\v (naQ^y avxoig cpsQOfiivag dnetQoXoyiag. Seixvvfit 8e ovxcog.
152

xaxd 8taQxr\6tv a6vvaxxog Xoyog iXiyExo iyvcoQi6$at (ir) eyetv dxoXov&iav xd Xr\fifiaxa avxov nQog dXinet ovv xr)g yvco6ecog xr\g Xr\Xd <^T^> xal xr)v intcpOQav. axoXov&iag xavxr\g Sei nQor\yet6&at xr\v XQ't6tv xov 6vvr\fiix

xov

t\

dvenixQtxov di i6xt xb 6vvr\u,fievov , cog ineXoyt6aur\v, (adtdxQtxogy e6xat xai 6 xaxd 8taQxr\6tv a6vvaxxog 153 Xoyog. xal yaQ 6 Xiycov xaxd 8td.Qxr\6tv a6vvaxxov eivai
(livov,

xtva
vr\v

Xoyov,
avxco

cpa6tv

fiev

itQoqjEQOfiEvog

fiovrjv

avxtxt&efii-

sc

dnoSuxvvg

cpa6tv e'S,et xr\v dvrtxetfiivr\v xr\ nQoetQr\fiivr\' Ss 8td Xoyov dxov6xat, oxt Ssi xbv Xoyov xov-

xov TtQOXEQOv 6vvaxxtxbv slvat, oxi cc6vvdQxr\xa xd Xrjfifiaxa xov

Xoyov.
xsg

&&

ovxcog
,

dnoSetxvvEtv,

g*

ov yvco66fi&a Sk
xr\

el

8ir\QX^69 at Xsyofiivov E6xtv OTtoSuxxtxog , fir\ %ovr

6vvr\fifiivov

Xoyov 6vfinXoxr\ xb xaxd xovxo ovv ovy scjofisv StaxQivstv x&v 6vvaxxtxcov xbv xaxd StaQxr\6tv fioy&riQbv slvat Xs154 yofisvov. xd Sh avxd iQOVfiEv nQog xbv Xiyovxa fioyftrfQOv
6vfinQa6[ia.

Xov&ei

XQ t6tv, Std x&v Xr\(ifidxcov xov

6vficpcovov

r\

XQtvovfiEV

dxo5

xal

152153

154

~ adv. 435437. ~ adv. dogm. dogm. 445. 444

II II
:

15 iartv <6 %Xovtogy L 18 ovv ML: &s EAB: si enim T 19 dtuxQivscsQ-ai Bekk. dtaxgivaeQ-ai G 20 6vvaxr&v L 21 25 rs add. e T (ad inadd. Kayser: proferuntur ab eis T 28 ad. add. Bekk. Stephanum secutus dtaivicem quoque) Qsatv L 7/8 Xsyofhsvov Bekk. Xoyov GT (ratio)
||

TIIOTTII&ZE&N

B.

103

I
6
i

Xbyov xiva naga xb iv cpavXco 6%r)(iaxL r\Qcnxf\6&ai' yao xaxa6xeva^cav oxi (LOr&r\Qbv xi 6yf\Lid i6xiv, ov% ' b(ioXoyov(ievov 6vvaKxiKov Xbyov Si ov dvvf\6exai 6vvdyeiv
eivt elvai

o cpr\6iv.

6vvd(ii dh dvxLQi'\xa(iv

did

xovxcov

xal nQog 155

xovg neiQco(iivovg naQ i'XXLtyiv a6vvdxxovg Xbyovg dvac SuKvvvaL. i yaQ 6 ivxXf\g <(xa^> dnr\QXL6(iivog ddiaKQixog
6xi, xai 6 iXXinf\g ddrjXog 6xai.

%ai

l'xi

6 did Xbyov
h^cov 6vvr\(i-

buxvvvai xivd iXXmf)

(livov
xf\v

fiovXb(ivog Xbyov,

(ir\

%ql6lv

cofioXoyrjLiivrjv,

dV

r\g

kqlvuv

dvvf\6xai

aKoXov&lav

xov

vn

avxov

Xyo(iivov

Xbyov,

ov

dvvr]6xaL %KQL(iivcog xal

i

dXXa Kal o %axd

Koixog
i6XLv

oxi iXXinfjg 6xiv. naQoX%f\v Xeyb(ievog elvai (io%&r)Qog dSid- 156

OQ&cog Xiyeiv

dnb x&v

dnobeiKXLKcov.

o6ov

yaQ

inl

xrj

naQoXKrj xal oi &qvXovlivol

naQa

xoig ExcoLXOig

dvanb-

dei%xoi d6vvaxxoL VQ&r)6ovxaL, cov dvaLQOV(iivcov f) na6a ovxol yaQ ei6iv ot>g cpa6iv dnoLaXxxixr\ dvaxQin^xai'
Sel^ecog (iiv
(ir)

Sefc&aL nQog xr)v eavxcov 6v6xa6iv,

dno-

SeiKxixovg Sh
Xbyovg.

vnaQiuv (didy xov xal xovg aXXovg 6vvdyiv

naQiXxov6Lv , 6xai 6acphg e%&e(iivcov
r)(i&v

oxl Sh

xovg dvanoSeUxovg xai ovxcog o cpa(iev iniXoyL^ofiivcov. IloXXovg (ihv (ow) dvanoSei%xovg bvLQonoXov6iv 157
(Stoic.
tTOfi, elg

II 232A), nivx dh xovxovg (idXL6xa iKxi&evovg oi Xomol ndvxeg dvacpiQ6d-ai Soxov6lv, nQ&xov (xbvy ix 6vvr\(i(iivov xai xov f)yov(iivov xb Xfjyov 6vvdyovxa, olov *ei r)(teQa e6XL, cp&g 6xlv' dXXd (ir\v f)(iiQa %6xlv' cpcog &Qa e6xiv\ Sevxefr.

155 156

~ adv. dogm. ~ adv. dogm.

v. 8

II

446.

II

438443.

157158

vv\ iaxiv

~ adv. dogm.

II

224226.

12 dvvdiiei xovxcov om. sed relinqu. spat. 26 28 lit. (vide p. VDI) &vxeiQi]HaLLEV T (contradiximus) cf. p. 101,32/3. xovrcov T (per has) 384, 19 &vTLQr)6d-(o L dvxeiQiJGoiiev E AB xovxo 6 14 xal add. T 15 iXlLTti]s T (defectiva scil. ratio) cf. p. 384,21: iXXeityei G hi Bekk. Stephanum secutus: oxl
||

||

||

18 avxov (iXXixovgy Pappenheim coll. v. 16 (quia) 26 Sid addidi, fort. xm (cf. T: in colligendo) 29 ovv add.e T (quidem igitur, sicut p. 93, 15. 95, 19 e. a.) 31 xbv add. Bekk.

GT

104

IITPP&NEI&N

ncci xov avxtKSt(iivov xov Xr)yovxog xb avxtKsi(isvov xov r)yov(iivov 6vvdyovrct, olov *si r\(iiQa s6xt, cp&g s6xtv' ovk k 6xt 8s gorog* 158 OVK CCQa TjflSQCC S6XIV XQIXOV XOV l| CCTCO CpaXlKOV 6V(tnXoKf\g Kai svbg x&v ix ttjj 6v(inXoKf\g xb dvxtxsCfisvov xov Xotnov 6vvdyovxa, olov ovyi rjfiiQcc s6xt xai vvl- s6xtv' r)(iiQa 8s s6xtv'ovKccQa vvt- k'6xiv\ xixccQXOv xbv i% 8tssvy(iivov %cc\ svbg x&v inssvy(iivcov xb dvxtKsifisvov xov Xotnov 6vvdyovxa,\ olov r)xot rjfiiQcc s6xtvr) vv^ s6xiv' r](iiQa 6s s6xtv' ovk ccqcc vv s6xiv nifinxov xbv sk 6 tssvy (tivov kccI xov ccvxiKSifiivov svbg x&v ins^svypcivcov xb Xotnbv 6vvdyovxa, olov 'rjxot rjftiQCc s6xtv r) vvl-

qov xbv ix 6vvr\(i(iivov

'.

k'6xtv'

ov%i 6s vv s6xtv'
(isv

ijiieoa ccqcc s6xiv'.

,

159

Ovxot

ndvxsg 6i 1.101 avxtKa yovv, tva ccnb xov nQtoxov aQ^cbfis&a,

Xoysixat
oxt

ovv si6tv oi d QvXov(isvoi dvan68siKxot, 8okov6iv &6vvaKxot slvai Kaxcc naQoXKf)v.

r\xot

6(io-

ccKoXov&st xb
iv
xco
*si

'<p&g

s6xtv

xco

'rjfiiQa

s6xtv'

rjyovfiivco
vrj(i[iivcp,

avx&
r)

f)(iiQa
ccXX'

s6xt,
(isv

cp&g

k'6xtv'

6v-

a8r\X6v s6xiv.

si

d8r\X6v

xb 6vvrj(i(iivov &g 6(ioXoyov(isvov' s6xtv oxt bvxog xov 'r)(iiQa s6xtv i% dvdyKr\g s6xat 8r\X6v KccX xb 'cp&g s6xtvj sinovxcov r)(i&v oxt r)(iiQa s6xtv, 6vv8co60(isv

iextv, ov si Ss %qo-

dysxat
c

Kai

xb cp&g s6xtv,

&g

ccqksiv

xbv xotovxov Xoyov

8s cpSQO(is&a

r)(iiQa

160 S6xt,
sni

cp&g

s6xt, cp&g aQa s6xiv', s6xtv' 6vvr\(i(xivov.

Kai na^iXKStv
6(toi(og

xb 'si r)(UQa Kai

Xf)yovxog
itlX

xov 8svxiQOV dvanoSsiKxov. r\xot yccQ ivSiysxat xov bvxog slvat xb f)yov(isvov , r) ovk ivSiysxat. (if)
si (isv
i

svSiysxat, ovk s6xat vytsg xb 6vvr\(t(tivoV si svSiysxat, a(ia tco xs$r\vat xb 'ovxi xb Xr\yov' xi( ftsxat Kai xb ovyi xb rjyovfisvov', Kai naQiXKSt ndXtv xb
8s ovk
6vvr\(i(iivov ,
xr)g

6vvsQ(oxf)6scog

xotavxr\g ytvo(iivr\g

'ovyi

159

cf.

156. adv.

dogm.

II 440.

2 ^k GvvrnnLivov T (ex coniuncto): ix xivov(tivov G 4c/ om. L 14 &ga om. L av(tnXoKv p. 94, 2 et 336, 19 19 avtm del. Kayser 22 S6rai T (erit): JcGtt G 27 avanoSsUxov (Xoyovy T (m secunda indemonstrativa ratione)

6^tj

TII0TTII&2E&N

B.

105

ovk ccqcc [oTt] r)(iiQcc e6Ttv' 6 8e ccvTog Xoyog Kcci 161 cp&g e6Ttv, 4eni xov tqitov avajtodetxTov. r\Tot yaQ nQo8r\X6v i6uv, otl ovx iv8iyeTut tcc iv rfj 6v(mXoKr\ 6vvvnuQ^ut ccXXf)Kcci ei fiev a8r\Xov, ov 8co6o(iev to unoXotg, r) u8r\Xov.
'.

cpaTtxbv Tr)g 6V(inXoKf)g' ei Se nQo8r\Xov, ccpa tco Te&r)vat to moov avaiQetTai to Xotnov, Kcci nctQeXKet to anocpccTiXeyotiev Kcci ini 162 ini tov ni(inTov avanoSeixTov. r\tot yu.Q oti iv tco Sieevy(ievco to (iev ccXr\&eg iari nQodrjXov i6Ttv, to 8e tpevSog (JteTcc (xd%r\g TeXeiccg, oneQ inuyyeXXerai to
tcc

xbv Tr)g 6v(inXoKf\g, ovk aoa vv^ e6Ttv'.

tov TETapTot;
Kcci

oflrcog

i)(i&v

eQcorcovTcov ^rjfieQa e6Ttv,

8e

nccQanXrj6icc

Stefcvyuivov , r) cc8r\Xov. nal ei (iev aSr\Xov, ov Sco60(iev to Steevy(iivov' ei Se nQo8rjXov, Te&evTog evbg ccn ccvt&v cpaveQOv i6Ttv oti to Xotnbv ovk %6Ttv, Kui ccvatQe&evTog evbg nQodrjXov oti to Xotnbv e6Ttv, cog ctQnetv 6vveQcoTuv
\

ovTcog *r)neQu e6ttv, ovk

uqu

vvl- e6Ttv', *ov%t r)(ieQu e6Ttv,

vv uqu e6Ttv\ xai nccQeXxetv to Steevy(iivov.

Se Xeyetv eve6Tt Kcci ne^i t&v auTrjyoQt- 163 xaXovfievcov 6vXXoyt6(i&v, otg (iuXi6tu %Q&vTut ot unb c to~i HeQtnuTOv. olov yovv iv tovtco tco Xoyco t6 dtKutov

HaQCcnXr)6tu

%&v

o kccXov,

6(jLoXeyetTcct
r)

to KdXbv (8) uyu&ov, to dinatov ccqcc ccya&ov' r\tot %ui nQo8r\X6v i6Ttv ort to kuXov ccyu&ov e6Ttv,

cc(Mpt6r)TetTcct

Kui

e6Ttv

cc8r\Xov.

ccXX'

ei

(xev

ccSr\X6v

i6rtv, ov 8od"rj6eTttt Kccrd Tr\v tov Xoyov 6vveQC0Tr\6tv , Kcci Sta tovto ov 6vvccet 6 6vXXoyt6(i6g' ei 8e nQodrjXov i6rtv oTt nccv oneQ ccv ij kccXov, tovto ndvrcog xcci ccycc&ov

iouv,
Tcct

tt(ia

t& Xei&rjvat
ccya&bv
^to

oti Tode rt kccXov i6tt 6vvet6ayeelvcct,

Kcci

to

uvto

cog

ScQKetv

Tr)v

TOtccvTr\v
,

6vveQcorrj6tv
Ktti

8tKcctov kccXov,

nccQeXKetv
iXeyero.

to

Toov
8e

Xr)(i(icc

to StKatov uqcc c\ycc^6v , iv cp to kuXov ccya&bv

tc5

o elvut

b(ioicog

xcci

iv

toiovtco

Xoyco

'Eco- 164
ccqcc

KQttrrjg

ccvd-Qconog,
i

nug av&Qconog
0*Tt

^oaov,

EcoKQdTr\g
ort

^wov,'

(iev

ovk

nQo8r]Xov
:

ccvTO&ev,

nuv
:

ti

33 Stt om. T 4 tc5 M to LEAB 10 rpevSog Gen. tysvShg G 12 an om. T 17/18' KaxonxQty.cov EAB 20 de add. T (bonum autem probum) 21 %Q68r\Xov MLT (manifestum) itgbg r)(icov E AB 25 ccv Bekk. iav G omne quod bonum est T 30 8h om. L
: : :

106
itSQ

nTPPNEISN
(,

dv
7)

r\

uvd-QCOJtog ,

xai

xa&oXov
ei

rovro xai fcoov fVrtv, ov% bfioXoyeiovSe co60fiev avxr)v iv xr\ 7tQ6xa6tg,
sitsxai
xco

165 6vvsQC0xr\6et.
feoov

ctv&QWTtov slvai xb xai avxbv vrtdQ%etv, xai dtd xovxo dXr\d"r\g s6xiv bfioXods
,

yovfievcog r\ *7tag ctv&QcoTtog t,cpov %Q0xa6ig, ctfia x& Xey%r\vai oxt ScoxQdxr\g av&QConog 6vvet6dyexat xai xb coov

avxbv elvat,
166 *nag

'

cbg

aQ%eiv

xr)v

xotavxr\v
ctQcc

6vveQCoxr\6tv

coxr\v

XQaxr]g av&Qconog, coxQcixi\g

fcoov,' xai nctQeXxetv

dotg IQije&ai dvvaxov itfrtv, tvcc fir) vvv svSiarQtficofisv. IIXr\v snsi 7taQsXxov6iv ovxot oi Xoyot sv oig xr)v vno-

naQanXr\6iaig ds fisdoav&Qcortog fooov' 7tQoxa6iv. xal ini xcov ccXXcov xaxrjyoQixcov Xoycov TtQcoxcov

fia&Qav
sni
xr\

xcov

6vXXoyt6ficov

oi

StccXsxxtxoi
r\

xi&svxat,
fir)

nccQoXxrj

diaxQsnsxat

na6a

StaXsxxtxr],

o6ov Svva-

Std xovxo (isvcov r\ficov StaxQtvat xovg nccQsXxovxccg xai cc6vvdxxovg Xoyovg dnb xcov 6vvccxxtxcov xaXovfisvcov 6vX-

167 Xoyi6(icov.

el

Ss ovx

aQS6xsi

xovg slvat, ovx

si6iv

Xoyovg fjtovoXrjftfiddJ-tont6x6xsQOt 'AvxtndxQov (fr.

xi6i

Stoic.111167 A.), og ovSs xovg xotovxovg Xoyovg dnoSoxtfidst. Atd xavxa fisv ovv dvsnixQtxog S6xiv b naQa xoig StaXsxxtxoig 6vvctxxixbg xaXovfisvog Xoyog. dXXd xai b dXr\&r)g Xoyog
Ttdvxcog

dvsvQsxog i6xi Std xs xd nQoeiQr\(ieva xai inei xb yaQ 6VfineQa6fia bcpeiXei sig dXrj&eg Xr\yetv.

xb

168 Xov.

elvcct Xeyofievov rjxot cpatvofievov i6xw r) aSr\xai cpcttvoftevov fisv ovSafi&g' ov yaQ dv Seoixo xov Std xcov Xr\fifidxcov ixxaXv7txs6d-ai oV iccvxov 7tQo67ti7txov

dXrjd-sg

ov% r\xxov x&v Xrjfifidxcov ccvxov cpatvofievov. si Se ciSr\Xov, insi Tts^i x&v d8r\Xtov dvsntxQixcog Stanscpcovr\xat,
xcti

xa&ttTtSQ
Xr\7txd

efiTtQo^d-sv V7tSfivr\6a(iev, StoneQ xai

dxaxdXr\7txov eexat

dxaxdxov

i6xtv,

xai

xb

6V(i7teQtt6(itt

167168
om.

~ adv. dogm.
:

II

451452.

idv G: omne utique (= dv) quod est homo T autem essentiam hominis et animal ipsum tco av&QCQTtov Bekk. tov &v&ow7tov G esse et propter hoc) elvat tb scripsi: tco slvat E: tb slvat MLAB: ttva slvat tb 25 itQOBekk. 3 aXri&rig T (vera scil. propositio) dXri&ig G

38 av Bekk.

STtstai

(si

||

||

67tt7ttov

(incidens): TtQonintov

TIIOTTnZE&N
elvai

B.

107
xovxo dxaxd-

Xeyofiivov

Xoyov.

ei

8e xai

dXrj&ig i6xt xb ayofievov r) tyevSog. dyvof)60fiev ovv, itoxeoov dXr]&f)g iextv 6 Xoyog r) tyev8f)g, xai avevoexog e6xcct 6 dXrj&rjg iva 8e xai xccvxa nccQ&fiev, 6 dta nQo8f)Xcov adrj- 169 Xoyog.
i6xtv,

ov yvcoGofte&a,

noxegov

Xov 6vvdycov avevqexog

Xrjfiudxcov

i6xiv.
r)

ei

yaq enexai
xb

xr)

8td xcov

avxov

6vunXoxfj

xai xb Xfjyov itQog xt i6xi

iTQog xi

y.ai

enouevov intcpOQtt, nQog xb f)yovfievov, xa 8e

6vyxaxaXccfi(}dvexat dXXf)Xotg, cog nuQe6xf)6ufiev , ei fiev u8r\X6v i6xt xb 6vfineQu6fia, d8r]Xu e6xat xai xd Xf)fifiaxu, ei 8e nQo8r]Xd iext xd Xrjfifiaxa, nQo8r]Xov e6xat

xal xb 6Vfi7iEQa6fia axe 6vyxaxaXttfiuv6fievov ccvxotg tiqo8f)Xotg ov6iv, cbg fit]xext ix 7tQodr)Xcov d8r\Xov 6vvdye6&ai,. Std 8e xccvxcc ov6e ixxccXvnxexcct vnb x&v Xrjfifidxcov f) 170
intcpoQa,
TtQodrjXog dn68et,tg
r)xot

d6r\Xog
fif)

xai

8eofievr]

ov6a xai (if) xaxaXafi^avofievr] , xov ixxaXvrpovxog. ei xoivvv

r)
f)

Xoyog elvat Xeyexat xccxd 6vvaycayf)v , xovxe6xt Ovvccxxtxog, 8td xtvcov bfioXoyovfievcog dXrj&cbv intcpOQav ixxaXvnxcov dSr]Xov, vnefivr)6ccfiev 8e rjfietg, oxt ovxe X6yog xtg e6xtv ovxe 6vvuxxtxbg ovxe dXrj&rjg ovxe 8td xtvcav nQo8f)Xcov uSrjXov 6vvdycov ovxe ixxuXvnxtxbg xov 6vfinEQcc6fiuxog,
ccnodEti-tg.

cpavsQov

i6ttv

oxi

dvvno6xax6g

i6xtv

f)

Kui xax
l

ixeivr]v

8e

xf)v

intfioXr\v

uventvorjxov evQf)6ofiev xf)v &n68ei,tv.

dvvnaQxxov r) xai 171 yaQ Xiycov eivat

&n68et%tv r)xot yevtxrjv xi&r]6tv dnodeitjtv r) eiStxf)v xtvcc' dXX ovxe xf)v yevtxf)v ovxe ei8txf)v dnoSet^tv xt&ivat Svvccxov, cog vnofivf)6ofiev' naQtt Se xavxccg dXXo xi voeiv

ovx

iv8i'fexcct'

devat
\6xccx6g

xf)v

dn68et^tv. i6xt 8td xd8e.

ovx uqu Svvaxai fiev ovv f)

r)xot

xtg

yevtxf) dn68ettg
Xf)fifiuxd

ag vnuQ'/pv6uv xtdvvno- 172

xtvu
xcci

eyet

xtvcc

% 172

~ adv.

dogm.

II

345 et 383384.

30 &Xr\&ovs T (rationis que dicitur esse vera): &lr}&es G Si xai G: etsi T, xccl del. Bekk. 14 6vvaxxixS>g Bekk., qui maluit xovrietL evv. eicere 8id xtvcov dfioXoyovLtivcnv T (per
el
||

||

quedam manifesta)

\\

alri&cbv iTCtqioQuv

om.

T 24

aXXo om.

108
intcpOQav
i6xtv'
r)

IITPP&NEI&N
xal ei (tev ovk e%et, ovde dnodeiiig Xf)(i(iaxd xiva e%ei xai intqpoQav xtva, inei xb dnodetKvv(ievov ovxco xui dnoSetxvvov ini (isoovg
eyet.

ovk

sl

8e

nuv
itixtv

'

ei8txr)

sGxai

dn68ettg

ovx aoa

e.6xt

xig

yevtxf)

173 dnoSet^tg. dXX' ov8e ei8txf). r\xot ydo xb ix x&v Xi)(i(id-\ xcov xai xf)g intcpOQag 6v6xr)(ia dn68eth,tv iQov6tv, r) xb 6vov&ixsoov 8e xovxcov i6xiv 6xr)(ia x&v lr)H(idxtov (tovov
dn68etig, cog naoa6xrj6co' ovx aoa s6xiv eiStxf) dn68si,tg. 174 xb (isv ovv 6v6xr)(ia xb ix x&v Xr)(i(idxcov xai xfjg int-

aSr)Xov,

cpooag ovx i6xiv dn68sttg, no&xov (isv oxt (iSQOg xt s%ov6u xovxs6xt xf)v intcpOQav, d8r)Xog s6xat, onsQ dxosi

nov'

ydq dSr)X6g iextv

r)

dn6Ssttg, avxf) Ssf)6sxat xov

dnoSsii-ovxog avxf)v (i&XXov r) sxsqcov s6xat dnodstKxtxf). 175 slxa xai insi nQog xt <pa6iv slvat xf)v dnoSst^tv xai nQog xf)v intcpoQuv, xd 8s nQog xt n^bg sxsQotg vostxat, cog avxoi cpaGtv, 1'xsqov slvat Sst xb dnoSstxvvfisvov xf)g dno-

ovv xb 6v(insQa6(id i6xt xb dnoSetKVVfievov, xai yuQ vor)d"f)6sxat r) dnoSet^tg 6vv xco 6v[ineQd6(iaxt. r)xot 6v(idXXexai xt nQog xf)v dnoSet^tv eavxov xb 6v(iSelecog'
si

ov

neQa6(ia r) ov8a(i&g' dXX' ei (iev 6v(idXXexut, eavxov e6xat ixxaXvnxtxov , ei Se ov 6v(idXXexat dXXa naQeXxet,

ovSe (ieQog

xf)g

dnoSeil-ecog e6xut, inei xdxetvrjv

xaxd na-

176 QoXxr)v iQOVfiev elvat (io%&r)Quv. dXX' ovSe xb 6v6xt)(iu x&v dv eir)' xig yaQ dv etnot xb Xr)(i(idxcov (ibvov dnoSet^tg
ovxco Xey6(ievov ei r)(ieQa e6xt, qp&g %6xtv' dXXa (if)v f)(ieQu e6xtv* \cp&g e6xtv\ r) Xoyov elvat r) Stdvotav oXcog dnaQxietv;
(

dnodet^ig
e*iet.

ovx uqu ovSe xb 6v6xr)(ia x&v Xr)(i(idxoov (iovov iextv. ovSe f) eidtxf) uqu dnodet^tg vno6xa6tv
f)

ei Se (if)xe

eidtxr)

dnodet^ig vq>e6xr)Ke

(if)xe

f)

yevtKf),

naQa
iextv

8e xavxag
f)

ovk e6xtv ivvoetv dnodet^tv, dvvno6xax6g

dnoSet^tg.

173 176rv;adv. dogm.

t)

II

385390.

28
i)

LT: om.

MEAB
ipsa)
v. 1.
?.

Kayser T (solum) cf. 20 qp. Hartv om. T G 24 tavta EAB

(uvrr\y

T (quam

6 ftjrcu T (erit) 7 aitrjv om. T|| 9 in dliis T 10 rbv L 18 [lovov 20 qp<5s 21 (tovoov G 19 uXXd (tfjv
:

del.

Fabr.

21 (iovov

(solum): (i6vav

TnOTTII2EaN
"Ext
E6xtv
j

B.

109
dnoSu^Ecog
ev- 177

ix

xovxcov

xb

dvvno6xaxov

xf)g

<

vnofUfivfoxEtv. eI yd.Q e6xiv dnoSEt^tg , rjxoi cputvo(paivofiivov i6xlv ixxuXvnxtxr\ r) uSrjXog dSf)Xov r) fjtivrj ovdsvbg Sh xovuSrjXog cputvofiivov r) cputvofjtivr) dSf)Xov'
xcov

ixxuXvnxtxr\
si (ihv

Svvuxut

intvoi6&ut'

dvsntvorrtog

aoa
178

E6rlv.

yaQ

<putvo(iivr\ cputvofiivov ixxuXvnxtxf) i6xtv,

Ufjtu

s6xut
,

xb

ixxuXvnxbfisvov

cputvdfisvov xe

xul uSr\Xov,

cpuivofiEvov (iiv, insi xotovxov slvut vnsxi&rj, uSr\Xov 6i, ETtsl SstXUt XOV EXXuXvtyOVXOg XUl OVX i EUVXOV VTtOTtl%XEl si Sh aSr\Xog dSf)Xov, avxr\ SEf)6Exui xov ixf)fitv 6ucpcog.

xaXvtyovxog avxr\v xal ovx S6xat ixxuXvitxixr) sxiocov , onsQ Stu Sh xuvxu ovSh 179 dcpi6xr\xs xf)g ivvoiug xr)g dnoSsi^scog. Svvaxat slvut dnoSst^tg' dXX' ovSh itQOuSrjXog 7tQoSf)Xov SrjXog dSf)Xov' insi yuQ TtQog xi i6xiv, xu Sh TtQog xi dXXf)Xoig 6vyxuxuXu(i(luvExui, 6vyxttxuXuji(iav6(ivov xf) 7tQoSf)Xco dnoSsi^st xb dnoSsixvv6$at Xsydfisvov nQoSr\Xov s6xai, chg

TtEQiXQinE6&ui xbv Xoyov xul

xr\v

fir\

svQi6x6d at TtQoSrjXov av,

dSf)Xov dnoSstxxtxf)v.
f)

si
(if)xs

ovv

(if)xs

cpatvo(iivr\ cputvo-

aSrjXog dSf)Xov fif)xs aSrjXog 7tQoSf)Xov (Jtf)x TtQoSrjXog dSf)Xov, naQu Sh xavxa ovShv slvat Xiyov6tv, Xsxxiov firjShv slvut xr\v dnoSstl-tv. TlQog xovxotg xdxsivo Xsxxiov. Stunscpcovr\xui nsQt xf)g 180

fiivov i6xiv

dnoSst^tg

dnoSsi^Ecog'
(irjShv

ot fihv

oXcog

slvut

xcov

elvat
i%st,

Soyfiuxtx&v' xui cpufiiv.

yuQ (iriSh slvut Xiyov6tv uvxf)v, cbg oi cpu6xovxsg, oi Sh slvut, cog oi noXXoi r)fistg Sh (ir\ fiuXXov slvut avxr\v r) (if)

aXXcog f) dnoSsi^tg Soyfiu ndvxcog nsQt- 181 nsQt nuvxbg Sh Soyfiuxog Stunscpcovf)xu6iv , 8>6xe nsQt

nu6r\g dnoSsil-Ecog dvuyxrj slvut Stacpcoviuv. si yuQ xf)g dnoSsiE,scog xov slvat xsvbv Xoyov svsxsv 6fioXoyov(iivr\g xul xb slvut xsvbv 6vvOfioXoystxut, SfjXov oxt oi d(icpt6^r\xovvxsg nsQt xov slvut xsvbv xui ns^i ttjcj dnoSsi^scog avxov

177179 180181

~ adv. dogm. ~ adv. dogm.

||

II II

391395. 327334.

om. T 3 derj&rjostai EAB 8 avyxataXawBekk. xco G 10 xgoSriXov aixi)v G: slvat T (cum non inveniatur esse non manifesti demonstrativa): 14 dicendum est ergo T nQodriXov tfjv Bekk.
31 iettv
.

alt.

avo(iiv(ov
.

EAB
.

tf\

110
dfx,cpt6r]xov6tv'
cc7iosl^ig ,

IITPP&NEI&N

%ui nsQt xcov uXXcov Soyfidxcov, cov Et6tv 6 ccvxbg Xoyog. nu,6a xoivvv ccTtodsi^ig dfi182 qpt6^r]Xtxui %cct iv Stucpcovia E6xiv. ind ovv uSr]X6g iariv

at

r)

dnoSsti-ig

Stu xr)v

Stacpcoviav rr)v

nsQt avrr)g (xd yao

Stdcpcova,
6&a.i.

xu&b
ovv

Stccnscpcovr]xcct,

dSr)Xd E6xtv),

ov%

s.6xtv

sij

uvxr)g. noovitrog
r)

dXX
%cci

i-

dnoSd^Ecog

bcpsiXst i)(itv

6vvi6xu-

ccTtodst^ig
fihv

ofioXoyovfiivr)

6V r]g %ara6xvdsrai r) dnoSEt^tg, nQOvnxog ov% 6xat {^r)xovfiv ydo

vvv eI %6xtv dnoSsti^tg oXcog), Stcccpcovovfiivr) Sh %al ddrjXog ov6a sr]6srai dnoSii),cog aXXr)g, xdxsivr) dXXrjg, %ai fiiiQtg* aTtsioov. dSvvuxov Sh unstQa dnoSsti^at' dSvvccxov dqa
183 naQu6xr)6ui 8xt s6xtv- dnoSst&tg. dXX' ovSh Std 6r)fisiov Svvaxat s%%aXvnxs6&at. r]xovfiivov ydg xov sl %6xt 6r\%ai ttTtoSsiilEcog rov 6r)fisiov Ssofiivov ngbg rr)v suvrov VTtaoijtv, 6 St dXXr]Xcov svQi6%srtti rQonog, rr)g fthv dnoSsii^Ecog 6r)fiiov Ssofiivrjg, rov Sh 6r)ftsiov ndXtv dnofistov,
Ssii-Ecog'

otceq

dronov.

Std Sh rccvra ovSh intxQtvcct Svva-

rov S6xt (xr)vy

fisv

%Qrj&t sni%Qt6tg, r)xr)6scog Sh ov6r\g %Qt xov si E6xt %Qtxr]Qtov, cog nuQs6xr]6afisv, %ccl Std xovxo dnoSsii^scog
%Qtxr)Qiov
i)

tceqI xr)g dnoSsii^Ecog Stucpcoviuv, snsi

xov %Qtxr)Qiov Ssofiivov

Qtov ,

xr)g

Sst%vvov6r)g oxt s6xt xt %Qtxr\-

o StdXXrjXog XQonog rr)g dnoQiug Er)Qi6%sxat ndXtv. 184 t ovv fir]x St dnoSEii-Ecog fir]x Std 6r]fiiov (ir)xs Std %Qtxr]Qiov E6xtv vnofivr)6at oxt e6xiv dnoSui^tg, dXX' ovS'
1-

iavxfjg nQoSrjXog 6xtv, E6rat eI 6xtv dnoSEti-tg.

cog

Std

nuQ6xr]6ufiv , dxardXrjnrov Sh xovxo %at uvvnaQ%xog

6rcct r) dnoSEil-ig' vEvorjrut fihv yaQ 6vv r& dnoSst%vvvat, dnoSst%vvvui Sh ov% uv Svvatro (ir) %araXa(jLf}uvofiivr). StonsQ ovSh dnoSst^ig s6rut.

185

Tccvrcc
ttQ%i6st

fihv

cog

sv
ot

6norvnco6si %at nQog rr)v dnoSstl-tv

Sh Soy(iaxt%oi xovvavxiov %axu6%svd^ovxig cpu6tv, 8ri r\xot dnoSst%xt%oi st6tv oi %axa xr)g dno-

XsXiy&at.

186

~ adv. dogm.
djtodsi^scos

II 465.

31 (thv ovv T (quidem igitur) 9 xr\v add. Bekk. (cf. T dissonantiam que est) 10 tntKQiaig G Stacpavla T (dissonantia)
:

14

(if)xs dt'

om.

16

nifesta): rtQodr]Xov

7tq68r\ios

(ex se ipsa

ma-

TII0TTn2EN
Ssi^scog

B.

111

ovx dnoSsLXXixoi' xa\ el fisv TjQCOxrjfisvoL XoyoL r) OVX dnoSsLXXLXoi , OV SvVCCVXCU SsLXVVVOL OXL OVX SGXLV T] ei Ss ano8eLY.XLY.oi ei6iv, avxol o^xoi xr\v vnodn68siE,Lg'
o&sv xa\ 186 T7jg dno8sis,scog ix nsQiXQonf\g siGayovGiv. toioCtov gvvsqcox&gl Xoyov' *si sGxlv dnoSsi^ig, eGxiv dnoei ovx eGxiv dnoSsL^Lg, 1'gxlv dn68ei1-ig' deLfyg' r\xoi 8e
GxaGiv
eGxLV dnoSsi^ig

dnb
yov'

Se xr\g

ovx sGxiv dn6SsLE,ig' sGxlv aga dnoSsL^ig avxr\g dvvdfiecog xa\ xovxov sqcox&Gl xbv Xo~
r)
.

'xb xolg dvxLxeifievoig enofievov ov fiovov dXrj&eg iGxLV, dXXd xa\ dvayxaiov' dvxixeixai Se xavxa dXXr)Xoig ovx sGxiv dnoSsLl-Lg", obv sxaxsQCp dxo^sGxlv dnoSsL^Lg

Xov&sl xb

elvai

dnoSei^Lv'

sGxiv

a.Qa

dnoSei^Lg

'.

svsGxl 187

fiev ovv nQog xavxa dvxiXsySLV , olov yovv, enel (ir\ vofiiokiev XLva Xoyov elvaL dnoSeixxLxov , xal xovg xaxa xr)g dnoSei^ecog Xoyovg ov ndvxcog cpafdv dnoSeLXXixovg elvai dXXa cpaive6&ai i](iiv ni&avovg' oi Sh m&avol ovx i^

ei Ss a.Qa xa\ dnoSeLxxLxoi dvdyxrjg sialv dnoSsLxxixoi. siGLV (onsQ ou SLa^s^aLOVfis&a) ndvxcog xa\ dXr\%sig. dXr\ftelg Se siGL Xoyoi Sl dXrj&cov dXrj&eg Gvvdyovxeg' ovxovv

dXrj&rjg iGxiv

avx&v

aQa dnoSeL^Lg'' (dXr\&egy aQa

ix
neQLXQonr)g.

enLcpoQa. r\v Se ye a%xr\ 'ovx eGxiv eGXL xb 'ovx eGxiv dnoSei^ig' SvvavxaL Ss oi Xoyoi, xa&dnsQ xa\ xa 188
r\

xa&aQXLxd cpaQfiaxa xaig iv x& Gcofiaxi vnoxeifievaig flXaig eavxd Gvvs^dysL, ofixco xa\ avxo\ xoig aXXoig Xoyoig xoig
5

dnoSsixxLXoig slvai XsyofisvoLg xai eavxovg GvfinsQLyQacpsiv. xovxo yaQ ovx eGXLV dneficpaivov , ine\ xa\ r\ cpcovr) avxr\ 'ovSev iGxLV dXrideg' ov fiovov x&v dXXcov exaGxov dvaii)

dXXa xa\ iavxr\v ixeivoig GvfineQLXQeneL. o xe Xoyog Svvaxai SeixvvG&aL aGvvaxxog *ei eGxiv dnoSei&g, ovxog ei ovx eGxiv dnoSeL^ig, sgxlv dnoSei^ig' sgxlv dnoSeL^ig' sGxlv aorc', xa\ Sia nXsiovcov r\xoi Se 1'gxlv r) ovx sgxlv'
Qei,
fisv,

&g
186 187 188

Ss

nQog xb naQOv aQxovvxcog Sia xovSs xov iniII II

II

~ adv. dogm. ~ adv. dogm. ~ adv. dogm.

466469. 473478.
480.

MLEB: xa&dneg AT

11 &Xri&hg add Gen.

12 xa&dneQ xal scripsi: xal xa&dnsQ 16 rovro dk T {hoc autem)

112
189 %etQr)(iaxog.
aitoSei^ig ,
ei

IITPP&NEI&N
II

xb 6vvrj(i(ievov xovxo vytig 9 eoxiv dndSei^ig , Set xb dvxtKeiuevov

i6xi

'ei

e6xi

xov

i:
2

Xrjyovxog, xovxeGxi xb *ovk eGxiv drtdSei^tg' , (id'' xovxo ydq iaxi xov 6vvr](i(iiye6%ai xcp 'e6xiv dnoSei^ig' vov xb r)yov(ievov. dSvvaxov 8i i6xi xax' avxovg 6vvr](i-

avxcp

(livov vyieg elvai ix (iayp(tivcov a^tcoKidxcov 6vve6xcog.

(iev

xb

yaQ

6vvr](i(iivov

inayyiXXexai

ovxog

xov

iv

avxcp
3

r)yov(ievov elvai xal xb Xrjyov, xd Sh (ia%d(ieva xovvavxiov, ovxog xov exioov avxcov bitoiov8r]7toxe aSvvaxov eXvai xb

Xotnbv vTtaQyetv.
ei %6xtv

ovxog aoa vytovg xovSe xov 6vvr](i(iivov > dndSei^ig, e6xtv d7tdSeih ig ov Svvaxav vyveg elvav
)

xovxo (xby 6vvr}(i[iivov

190 Set^tg.'
itdXiv
(?'

*ei

ovk e6xtv aTtdSev^tg^ e6xtv

r)(icov

aitd-

i<

vyveg elvai xdSe xb 6vvr]n(iivov ei ovk e6xvv a7td8ev\vg, e6xvv aTtdSev^vg', Svvaxav 6vvv7tdQyevv xb *ei e6xiv dndSev^vg xco 'ovk e6xvv aTtdSev^vg'. ei Se Svvaxav avxco 6vvv7taQyetv,

av 6vyycoQOvvxcov (

Katf

V7t6&e6t,v

ov

(idyexav
3

avxcp.

iv

aooc

xco

*el

e6xvv

dndSev^vg^

e6xtv

aTtdSevt-tg

6vvr](i(iivco

ov

(idyexav

xb

dvxiKeivievov

191 e6xav

xov iv avTco Xr)yovxog xco iv avxco r)yov(iivco, co6xe ovk iKeivov Kaxd vyveg TtdXiv xovxo xb 6vvr](i(iivov cog vyvovg xv&evvivov, (irj (iayo(iivov 81 xov 6vyycoQr]6vv
,

%6xvv andSev^vg' xco e6xvv aTtdSev^vg'. ovSe xb Sie( evy(iivov vyveg e6xav xb r]xoi e6xtv dndSev^vg r) ovk e6xvv l xb yaQ vyvhg Sve^evyvvivov inayyiXXexav ev xcov dndSev^vg
'

*ovk

iv avxcp vyieg elvav, xb Se Xovnbv

ipevSr)

xa Xontd tyevSog r) r) evneQ vyvig i6xt xb Svefcvyfiivov, TtdXvv cpavXov evQi6Kexat xb 'ei ovk e6xiv a7td8ei\ig, e6xiv ovkovv aTtdSei^ig' 6vvrj(i(iivov , fx (laxofiivcov 6vve6xcog.
(iexa (idyr]g.
r)

192

a6v(icpcovd xi i6xv Kal dXXr)Xcov avaiQextKa xa iv xco Xdyco xco 7tQoeiQr](iivco Xf)(i(iaxa' StoTteQ ovk e6xtv vyirjg 6 Xdyog. dXX ovSe oxt aKoXov&et xi xolg avxiKet(iivoig Svvavxai SetKvvvaty (ir] eypvxeg KQtxrjQtov aKoXov&iag, cog ineXo$

yi6d(te&a.

26 to-uto Si T (hoc autem) cf. v. 16 1 t6 add. Gen. 9 tovto MLT: t6 vnb 10 tii] (ia(hoc coniunctum T) 20 post xi T add. tam aliquid %oitivov Se secl. Kayser 21 dlrj&siag T (veritatis) (mg Tt?)

EAB

TII0TTIIS2E&N
Tuvxu
sl6lv ot

B.

113
si

Se

sk

7tEQiov6iug Xiyofisv.

yuQ itt&avol

fiiv

vtieq xf]q dnoSEL^Ecog Xoyoi (s6xco6av yd^), ni&aval Ss Kal ai TtQog xr)v uTtoSsi^LV XsyofiEvaL i7tifELQr\6Eig, E7ti%Eiv dvdyKrj kul TtEQL xf)g dTtoSsi^scog, firj ficcXXov slvat
r)

firj

sivai Xiyovxag.
iS

F'Sel^lv xal Aio

TtSQi

usqI 6vXXoyi6(i&v. x&v &QvXov(iivcov 6vXXoyi6ficov

i6cog 193

TtSQixxov e6xlv SiE^LivaL, xovxo fisv 6vfiTtSQiXQE7tofiivcov avx&v xrj vnccQi-Ei xf}g a7todslscog (SfjXov yccQ ori SKsivrjg fir)

ov6r\g ovSs dnoSsiKXLKog Xoyog y&Quv sysi), xovxo Ss Kal SvvdSlu xcov EfiTtQoe&sv r)fitv XsXsyfiivcov fisi

dvxsiQrjxoxatv

r)(i&v (146 sqq.) rtQog uvxovg, oxe tieqI xfjg TtaQoXKfjg SiaXsyofisvoi fii&odov xiva iXiyofiEv Si r)g svSiysxai SsLxvvvai, oxi Ttdvxsg oi ccTtoSsiKXLKol Xoyoi x&v xs 2xcoikcov xai xcov
JlsQi7taxr\XLKCov cc6vvaKT0i

xvyydvov6LV ovxsg. i| irtifiixQOV 194 Ss ov ysiQov L6cog Kai iSicc rtEQi avx&v SluXuelv, irtsl fidXi6xa irt avxoig fiiya cpQovov6iv. noXXu fisv ovv s6xi
xb

XiysLv

dvvrto6xaxov

avx&v

v7tofiLfivrj6KOvxag'

cog

iv

V7toxv7tco6si Ss
Xi^co

aQKst

xfjSs xf) fis&6Sco jftfjQ&tn

Kaxd avx&v.
xovxcov

Ss

xai

vvv

rtSQL

x&v

dvaTtoSsiKXcov'

yaQ

dvaiQovfiivcov xai ot Xoirtol 6vfi7tuvxsg Xoyot SuxxQirtovxai,

xr\v drtoSsi^iv
C

xov 6vvdysiv drt avx&v sypvxsg. 7tQoxa6ig xoivvv attxrj *rtug av&Qcortog
'

coov'

iK 195

ix yuQ xov 2coirtaycoyiK&g ftsfiaiovxai XQdxrjv av&QcoTtov ovxa Kal &ov sIvul, Kai UXdxcova hfioicog Kai Aicovu Kai eku6xov x&v xuxu uiQog, Svvaxbv
fiiQog

x&v xaxd

slvai

Soksl Slu($e(}ulov6&ui xul oxl rtug uv&Qcortog &6v E6xLv, &g el xuv sv xi x&v kuxu fiiQog ivavxiovfisvov cpaivolxo xoig dXXoig, ovx s6xlv vyLr\g r) xu&oXov 7tQoxu6ig,
olov yovv,
xlvel,
1}

irtsl

xu

fikv

7tXsi6xa

x&v

^cocov xr\v xdxoo

yivvv

fiovog Se 6 KQOKoSsiXog xr\v uvco, ovk s6xlv dXrj&rig ( 7tccv &ov xrjv kuxco yivvv xlvsl 7tQoxu6Lg. oxuv ovv 196

27 a%6u%Lv G: airrjv
,32 Xeyofiivcov

(contradicentibus nobis) 5 licet T (gveaxi?) 8 Xiyco T (dico) 10 Ixovreg om. r}(ilv L sed spat. 8 lit. rel. 12/13 ffwxptmjv EAB: ccoxpar^ Sextus Empiricus I. $
fjfimv

MA

33

MEABT

(non magis ipsam

esse

quam)
:

ML

114
Xiyco6i

IITPP&NEI&N
'nag

dv&Qconog o5ov, 2coxQaxr\g <?' dv&Qconog, toov\ ix xr\g xa&oXov nQOxa6ecog xrjg 'nag av&QtoTCog cpov' xr\v xaxd (ieQog nQ0xa6iv 6vvdyeiv j3ot>r
ScoxQaxr\g
ccqcc

X6(ievoi,

xr\v

2coxQaxr\g

aQa fwov',
xccxd

r)

Sr) (ie(iaicoxixr\ rJJg

:

xad^oXixfjg

nQOxa6ecog
elg

i6xi

xbv

inaycoyixbv XQonov,
xr\v

cog V7te(ivrf6a(iev ,

xbv SidXXr\Xov i(ininxov6i Aoyov,

fiev

xa&oXixr)v %Qoxa6iv 6V exa6xr\g xcov xccxd [ieQog(

xr\g

197 ix

xov

xa&oXixr)g 6vXXoyi6xix&g. nccQccnXr\6icog Se xal ini xoiovxov Xoyov 'coxQaxr\g dv&Qconog , ovSeig Se dv-

&QC07tog
xr)v
(ihv

xexQunovg,
'ovSeig

2coxQdxr\g aQa ovx i6xi xexQanovg av&Qconog xexQanovg' nQoxcc6iv ix x&v

xaxd

x&v

fieQog enaycoyixcog (iovX6(ievoi (ie(ittiovv, exa6xr\v Se xttxd [ieQog ix xr)g 'ovSeig dv&Qconog xexQdnovg' 6vXxrj

Xoyi&6&ai deXovxeg,
198 nlnxov6iv.
nccQtt
xcci

xaxd xbv SidXXr\Xov dnoQicc neQixai

bfioicog

Se

icpoSevxeov

xovg Xomovg x&v

xoig UeQinccxrYxixoig

xovg xoiovxovg
ro
xe

*ei rjfieQu e6xi,

dXXd Xeyofievcov dvanoSeixxcov. cp&g e6xiv*' xo xe yaQ

cog <pa6i,
i

'ei rjfieQa e6xi,

cp&g e6xi

6vvccxxvx6v e6xiv,
(iexd

xov
(ie-

'cpcog

1'ort',

'cpcog e6xt
r

xov
cpcog

'r)(iiQa e6xi e6xt,v

.

(iaicoxixov
ccv
(ir)

i6xi

xov

ei

r\[ieQa

e6xi,

ov yuQ

vyieg ivo(ii6&rj xb
'.

nQoeiQrjfievov

199

nQOxeQov xe%ecoQr\xo ei ovv Sei nQoxaxeiXr\cpevai, oxi r\(iiQccg e6xiv ov6r\g ndvxcog e6xi xcci cp&g, eig xb evv&eivcci xb *sl r\[ieQa e6xC 6vvr\(i(ievov , Sid Se xov 6vvr\(i(ievov xove6xt, cpcog
xco
'rjfieQtt

6vvr\(i(ievov elvai, el r 6vvvndQyov dei xb cpcog e6xi

xov

6vvdyexcci

xb

oxi

r)(ieQag

ov6r\g

cpcog

e6xiv,

xr\v

(tev

6vvvnaQ^iv xov r\(ieQav elvcct xcci xov cpcog eXvai 6vvdyovxog xov 'ei i)(ieQcc e6xi, cpcog e6xC 6vvr\(i(ievov o6ov ini
xco nQOxeifiivco dvanodeixxco, xb de 6vvr\(i(ievov xf\g 6vvxdvxccv&cc 6 SucXvnaQJ-ecog xcov nQoeiQr\(ievcov (ie(icuov6r\g,

26 tqo7Cov T (modum) 27 lacunam indic. Bekker, quam recte sic fere explendam censet (ligog <^i7tay<oyixcog (tefiacovvT5, avvdyovtsg de kxa6xr\v xcov xatd (ligog): (ligog 4x tf)g
tr\v

8h xatd (tigog Paris. Suppl. 133 ex coniectura (cf. Mus. Rhen. LXIV p. 253). 1 post SidXX. add. T tQonov (modum) 4 ts om. T 6 ts 6: 8s T (autem) 9 ts^smgrito ML ts&sdoQotto EAB 11 to primum om. L 13 oti del. Bekk. %6tiv Pasquali slvai G: om. T 17 t&v 7tQosiQr\(iivcov G: tovtcov T (eorum)
:

||

TnOTTII2EN
XQonog
xf)g

B.

115

Xr)Xog

Xoyov.

unoQiug uvux^inet xr\v vno6xu6tv xov r ini xov xotovxov Xoyov ei r)fiiQa 200 e6xtv' ovyi Se cpcog e6xtv' ovx uqu r)(iiQU e6xtv i'6xt, cpcog 1% (lev yao xov fif) avev cpcoxbg r)(iiQuv ftecoQeicj&at. vyteg
bftoicog

Se xui

'.

uv elvai vofit6&eir) xb ei r)(tiQu e6xt, cpcog e6xt 6vvr)fiuivov, cog etye xatf vno&e6tv r)(iiQu fiev cpaveit) noxi, cpcog Se fif), tyevSog av Xey&eir) xb 6vvr}fifiivov eivut' o6ov Se ini xco nQoeiQrjuivco dvanodeixxco xb fir) etvut r)fiiQuv cpcoxbg
xat,
ftf)

co6ze

bvxog Std xov 'et r)ftiQU <rw, exdxeQov avxcov nQog xf)v

cpcog

e.6xt

6vvdye-

euvxov

xov xb exeQOv fieuicog eiXrjcp&ai, l'va ni6xbv yivrjxai xaxa xbv StdXXr)Xov XQonov. dXXd xal ix 201 xov fir) Svvu6&ut uXXr Xotg 6vvvnuQyetv xtvd, olov r)fiiXQrfeei
t

fieuito6tv St avxov

Qav, ei xvypt, xal vvxxa, xb xe unocpuxtxbv xr\g 6v(tnXoxf\g, xb *ov% r)fiiQa e6xt xal vi) lo"w', xul xb Stefevyftivov, xb
rjfiiQa e6xtv r) vv% e6xtv\ vytf) vo(iiotxo av elvai. dXXd xb (firjy 6vvvnuQyetv uvxu (ie(5uiov6\rui vo(tiov6t Std xe xov dnocpaxixov Tijg 6vftnXoxf)g xai xov Ste&vyftivov, Xiyovxeg *ovyi r)(iiQtt e6xt xal vv e6xtv' dXXd fir)v vh
*r\xot
?

e6xtv'

ovx
uXXd

iiQa
fir)v

r\fiiQa

e6xtv'

vv

e6xtv'

Sh

vv e6xtv'

r)fiiQa

XoytZou-e&u, bxt ei (tev vov xal xov xf)g 6v(tnXoxr\g dnocpaxtxov %Qrjo(iev xov nQoxaxetXrjcpivat, bxt xd iv avxotg neQte%6fieva dS-tcbfiaxd
l6xtv
\dyeiv

r\xot r)(tiQu e6xtv r) vb$ y ovx UQa r)(ieQa e6xtv , r) ^ovyl dqa e6xtv\ b%ev f)(ieig ndXtv ent- 202 nQog xr\v fieaito6tv xov Stefcvyfii-

e6xtv

,m

u6vvvnuQxxu, xb Se a6vvvnaQxxa xavxa eivat 6vv-

Soxov6t Std xe xov Steevyfiivov xal xov xf\g 6v(inXoxf)g unocpaxtxov, b St uXXf)Xcov ei6uyexai xQonog, fir)
Svvufiivcov r)ficov fif)xe xoig nQoetQrjfiivotg XQontxoig ntexevetv dvev xov xb a6vvvnaQxxov xcov iv uvxoig neQteyp(tevcov d^itofidxcov xuxaXa(3etv, fif)xe xb u6vvvnaQxxov avxcov

Stuf3eutov6&at

nQo T^g

xcov

6vXXoyt6ficov

Stu xcov

23
1

tg)

GT

Gen.
\exiv

25 xb Gen.: cug eiys G: quodsi vere (fort. dXX' eiye) 28 %Qr)&i (in eo quod) (indiget): %Qf)ov G: %Qr)eiv 1 aXXu add. Gen. 4 f\xot 5 rjfieQa aiixd om. fif)

j|

om.

EABT

(i\ v

itQog

EAB

TtQog

uiv

MLT

(si

ad

cer-

ificationem quidem)

8*

116

IITPP&NEI&N

203 XQontxcov GvvsQcoxr\Oscog. StonsQ ovx sypvxsg, no&sv ccqi-6(is&a xr]g niaxscog Std xb naXtvSQOfiov , Xsijofisv (ir\xs xbv xqixov (ir\xs xbv xs.xa.Qxov (irjxs xbv ni(inxov xcov avanoSsixxcov ooov ini xovxotg

vnoGxaOtv

systv.

ToOavxa

(isv

xai nsQc GvXXoytGficov inl xov naQovxog

ts'

aQY.iasi XsXiy&at.

204

nsQi inaycoyrjg. EvnaQaixrjxov Ss slvai vo(iico xai xbv nsQi inaycoyr\g XQonov. insl yaQ dnb xcov xaxd (iSQOg ntOxovG&at j3ovXovxat St avxf\g xb xa&oXov, r\xot ndvxa imovxsg xa
xaxd
sGxat
(iSQog touto notr\GovGtv
r)

r)

xcvd. dXX' si (isv xtvd, dfisfiaiog

inaycoyr), ivSsypuivov xov svavxtovG&at xco xa&6Xov xtva xcov naQalstnofiivcov xaxd (ilQog iv xr\ inaycoyr)' si Ss

ndvxa, dSvvaxa
(JtiQog

(noyb^r^GovGtv

xa\

dnsQtOQtaxcov.

wod'

dnstQcov ovxcov xcov ottxcog sxaxs qco&s v ,

xaxd
oifxai,

Ov(ialvst OaXsvsa&at xr\v inaycoyr\v.

tg

nsQt oqcov.

205

8r\ xsyvoXoyta (iiya cpQOvovOtv ot doyfiaxtxot, r]v xco Xoytxco (liQSt xr)g xaXovfiivrjg cptXoOocpiag iyxaxaXiyovOtv. cpSQS ovv xai ns^X oqcov
xrj

^AXXd xai int

nsQt oqcov

oXiya ini xov naQovxog I7p6? noXXd xotvvv

xtxcov Soxovvxcov,

si'nco(isv.

yjQr\6t(isvstv

Svoxa

xovg oQOvg xcbv Soyfiadvcoxdxco xscpdXata (jx) nsQiXrjnrtxd

206 ndotjg XiyovOtv dvayxatbxr\xog avxcov tGcog svQf)ostg'

cog

r) yaQ nQog xaxdXr\tptv r) cog nQog StSaOxaXtav iv naot naQaSstxvvovGt xovg OQOvg dvayxaiovg. idv ovv vno-

(ivr\Oco(isv, oxt

nQog ovSixsQOv xovxcov

%Qr\ot(isvovOt, nsQtxQs-

tyofisv,

ol(ic4i,

naOav

xr\v

ysysvr\(tivr\v

nsQt

avxcov
si

naQa
6
(isv

207 Tofg

Soyfiaxtxotg fiaxaionoviav. sv&icog dyvocov xb Sqioxov ovy otog xs ioxt xb

ow,
(ir\

xov

avxco OQiaaO&at, 6 Ss oqov xb OQtOxbv

ytvcoGxcov,
xaxsiXr\cpsv

sld^

ytvcoax6(isvov OQt6(isvog ovx ix

dXX

ini

nQOxaxstXr\(i-

((teiv
(et
r\g

18 7taXlvdQO(iov T (propter retrocedentiam): naXtvSgofis tv G comp. script.) 23/24 xal xbv xf\g l%aycoyf\$ tqotcov T inductionis modum) 4 d add. T (que) 5 post nd6r\g add.
8 %Qr}6i(ievovoi

Gen.

LT

(utiles sunt): %Qr}6i(iev6ov6t

MEAB

TII0TTn2E&N
fiivco xovxco

B.

117

xbv oqov inrfvvxe&eixev , nobg xaxdXrjtptv x&v xui yuQ inei itoayfidxcov 6 OQog ovx e6xtv dvuyxulog. ndvxu fiev OQi&G&ai deXovxeg xu&dnu^ ovdev OQiciofie&a 8id xr\v (elgy uneiQOV exnxco6iv, xivu Se xaxaXafifidveci&ai
xui

8i%u

xcov

oqcov

xaxdXr\ipiv
i

xovg

ofioXoyovvxeg ovx dvuyxaiovg TtQog OQOvg dnocpuivofiev , xu&' ov xqotcov xd

rjficov

fir)

OQia&evxa xuxeXrjcp&n , Svvufievcov

oqcov

ndvxa

%coQig

xcov

xuxuXafifidvetv ,

r)

xu&dnu'!-

ovSev

oQiaSfie&a 208

xr\v eig unetQOv exnxco6tv\ r) ovx dvayxaiovg xovg OQOvg dnocpuvovfiev. 8id Se xuvxu ovSe nQog 8tSu6xuXiuv uvxovg e^QOifiev dv dvayxaiovg' cog yuQ 6 nQ&xog xb rcQayfia yvovg tyvco xovxo %co^ig oqov, xaxd xb nuQunXr)6u>v xal 6 8t8a6x6fievog uvxb Svvuxut %coQtg oqov 8i8a-

[8iu

%%r)vac.

ext

dnb

xcov

6qi6xcov

OQOvg, xai Qie%ovxdg

)

cpa6i (io%d"r\QOvg oQOvg xi xcov fir) %qo6ovxcov

r)

inixQivov6t xovg 209 elvac xovg nexoig

8Qi6xoig,

SioneQ oxav efnrj xig xbv uv&qconov elvai coov Xoytxbv d&dvaxov r) ^coov Xoytxbv ftvrjxbv yQafifiaxtxoV) bnov fiev firjSevbg bvxog.dvr\xoi

nu6iv

xi6iv.

&QC07COV d&avdxov, bnov 8e xivcov fir) yQUfifiuxtxcov bvxcov, cpa6i fio%&r)Qbv elvut xbv oqov. xd%a Se xai 210 6 dvenixQixoi ei6iv ol oqoi Sid xr)v uneiQiuv xcov xaxa fiei cov inixQive6&ui 6cpeiXov6tV elxa ovx dv xaxuQog,
Xr\nxixoi xe xal Stduxxixoi xovxcov elev i^ cov inixQivovxai
vcov.

s
)-

8rjXovoxi nQoeneyvco6fievcov, etye &Qa, xal nQoxuxeiXrjfifiencog Se ovx dv ei'r\ yeXoiov xb Xeyeiv cog ol oqoi

%Qr\6ifievov6i

nQog xuxdXrjtytv

r)

8i8a6xaXiav

r)

6acpr)veiav

bXcog, a6ucpeiav r)(ttv

Tvu

xt

inet6xvxXovvxeg xo6uvxr\v\ olov yovv, 211 xul nui^cofiev, el' xig nuQU xov fiovXdfievog nv&ednr\vxr\xui uvxco
icpeXxofievog
,

6&ui
xai

ei

uv&Qconog inl Xnnov 6%ov\xevog

iQcoxr\6tv

xvva
16

xr\v

ovxco

noir\6uixo

co

(diffinemw): oQi&ne&a L 17 eig 19 xafr' ov rQonov G: utioqov EAB quemadmodum enim T 22 secl. Bekk. 27 iuxqIvov6i MEA.BT 84 Sh T (fortassis autem et): \ievd (iudicant): iniKQtvovei L T (a quibus ut v. 2): icp' G 6 %Qr\2/3 Y.axulr]Tttol EAB 3 9 obviavit T cf. ad p. 105, 8. cifievcovet
6Qia6(ied-a

MEABT
\\

add.

(in infinitum)

MEAB

118
<5ov Xoytxbv &vr\x6v,
xr\xo 601 coov

nTPPNEIN
vov xai
int6xf)fir\g
,

Sexxtxov, unf)v-

yeXu6xtxbv nXuxvcovvypv int6xf)(ir\g noXtxtxf\g Sexxtxov, fraoo %vr\xco yQefiexi6xixcp xu 6cpatQc6fiaxu i<pr\-

doanog, icpeXxofievov opov xexQunovv vXaxxtxovf ncog ovk

ovxco yvcoQifiov nQuyfiuei'rj xaxuyeXu6xog, eig acpu6iuv xog ifxfiaXcov xbv uv&Qoonov Stcc xovg oQOvg; ovxovv uyjQr\212 6xov elvai xbv oqov oeov ini xovxotg Xexxeov, t'r' ovv

av

Xoyog elvai Xiyotxo Stcc fiQayeiag vnofivr\6ecog eig evvotuv r\(xccg aycov xcov vnoxexuyfievcov xutg cpcovutg nQayfxdxcov, cog Sf)X6v ye (ov yao;) ix xcov fxtxQco nQ06&ev r\fitv eiQr\fxivcov etxe Xoyog 6 xb xi r\v elvat
,

SrjXcov, etxe o fiovXexui xig.

xal yccQ xi i6xiv 6 OQog ovX6-

fxevot jtuQi6xav eig ccvf)vvxov ifininxov6t Stucpcoviuv, r]v Stcc

xr\v

nQ0uiQe6iv r^g yQucpf\g nuQir\fxt vvv, etye xul Soxei StuxQenetv xovg OQOvg (o6u iv xovxotg ne^l xov u%Qr\6xov elvut xbv oqov iXeyofxevy. To6uvxu fiev xul neQi oqcov chtofiot

yjQr\

vvv XeXey&at.
t'

neQt dtuiQeeecog.

213

'Enei Se xtveg xfov Soyfxuxtxcov xr\v StuXexxixr\v

elvui cpu6vv ini6xr)fir\v 6vXXoyt6xixr\v inuycoytxr\v 0Qt6xtxr\v <(StatQexixf)v),SieXe%d"r\fiev Se rjfxetg r\Sr\, fxexcc
xovg neQt xov XQtxrjQiov xui xov 6r\fxeiov xui xf\g anoSei^ecog Xoyovg, neQi xe 6vXXoyt6fxcov xai inaycoyf\g xui ne^i oqcov, ovx

uxonov r\yovfie&u elvut xui ne^i SiutQe6ecog Quyeu StuXufietv. yive6&ut xoivvv xr\v StuiQeeiv cpu6t xexQuycog' bvofia eig 6r\(iutv6fievu StutQet6&ut r) bXov r\ yccQ eig fieQr\ r) yevog eig ei'Sr\ r\ eldog eig xcc xu& exa6xov. bxt Se ovSevbg xovxcov e6xtv int6xf)(xr\ StaiQextxf),
quSiov
t6cog ineX&etv.
6cr]vxr]xai

495,28: dbviavit T (cf. ad v. 9) 15 fors. &<sd<psiav 16 ov17 XsKtiov om. T 18 creditur T 20 tbg 21 sIq. om. T xovv 20 ov ML ovdh E AB 24 si'ys scripsi (licet videatur T) s l G 24*
p.

11/12

coni.

Bekk.:

ccjtr)vtr\Ksv

Kayser

coll.

suppl. T secutus (destruere diffinitiones quantum in hiis inutilem 25 oqcov MEAB: 8qov L 28 esse diffinitionem dicimus. Tot) 29 dtaiQSTtxrjv T (divisivam) om. G 3 dii7taycoytxr\v om. T
:

vidunt

TII0TTn2E&N

B.

119

TteQi xrig ovofiarog slg 6r\(iatv6(ieva StatQe6ecog. Ev&ecog ovv xug i7ti6xf)(iug xcov cpv6et cpa6iv ei- 214 at, xcov fre6et Se ovSuficbg, xai eixoxcog. f) (iev yuQ
i7tt6tf)(ir\ (ie(5ui6v xi
)

xai dfieruTtrcorov TtQuyfia elvai d-e\et, xcc Se &e6et QuSiuv eyet xui evfiexuTtxcoxov xr\v (iexa($o\f)v, xalg ivaWuyuig xcov &e6ecov, av ei6iv icp' f)(iiv, exeQOtovfieva.

inei
yccQ

ovv xa ovofiaxa &e6et

ccv

6r\(iuivet

xui ov cpv6et (jtdvreg

6r\(iatv6(ieva,

6vvie6av itdvxa

xcc

vnb

xcov cpcovcov

b(ioicog"E\\r\veg xe xai ($aQ(5aQ0t, itQog xcc xai icp f)(iiv elvut xd 6r\(iutv6(ievu olg av (iovlcofxe&a 6v6[iu6tv (xut) exeQOig
del Sr\\ovv xe xai 6r\(iaivetv), Ttcog ccv
xtxf\v

Svvaxbv

etrj

StatQer)

6v6(taxog

eig

6r\(iatv6(teva iiti6xr\\ir\v elvat;

itcog

e7ti6xf)(ir)

6rj(iaiv6vxcov xe xai 6r\(iatvO(ievcov,

r)

cog

oiovxai xtveg,

Sta\exxtxf) Svvatx*
TteQi

ccv

VTtuQyetv;

td"'

oXov xai (ieQOvg.

IleQi Se oXov xai fiiQovg dta\e6(ie&a (iev xui iv xotg 215

cpv6txoig

Sr)

\eyo(ievotg(=JIl98sqq.),i7tiSexov7taQ6v-

xog TteQi xr)g \eyo(ievr\g 8tatQe6ecog xov o\ov eig xd (UQr\ avxov xdde \exxeov. oxav \eyr\ xtg StutQei6&ui xf)v SexdSu eig fiovdSa xai Svo xai XQia xai xe66uQu, ov StatQeixat eig xavxa r)
J5

Sexdg. a[ia

yaQ

xco

xb TtQcorov

avrfjg ccQ&fjvat (ieQog,

Sco(iev,
J

tva

xard

6vy%coQr\6iv ovxert vTtoxetrut

xf)v

vvv
f)

rovro

otov

rr)v

(iovdSa,

Sexdg,
f)

d\\

ivvea xai
\ot7tcov

TtuQu
JO

SexdSu.

ovv xcov

ucpcciQEGig

oXcog exegov xt xe xai 216

StaiQe6tg ovx aTtb

SexdSog yivexat d\\ UTto xtvcov a\\cov, exu6rr\v dcpatQe6tv ereQotov(ievcov. rdycc ovv ovx ivSeyerat rb b\ov StutQsiv eig rd \ey6(ieva elvat avf-jjg

xa&

rov

(ieQr\.

xai yuQ ei StatQStrat rb

xco

o\ov eig

(JteQr\,

cptXei

iinteQteyee&at TtQO xr\g StatQe6ecog, ov otov yovv, tvu i%i xf\g SexdSog 6xf\o8 7teQte%exut Se t6cog.
(ieQr\

ru

o\co

6co(iev

7td\tv xbv \6yov,

rijg

elvat xu ivviu' StuiQeirut

yuQ

SexdSog fieQog cpu6i 7tdvxcog K d\\d xui eig lv xui ivvea.

15 xal add. T

(et

unum

ut

v. 26): (itav

G
v.

semper diversis) 31 elvat om. T

cf. v.

(enim): ovv

23 fiovdSa T (in 22 3 ydg T

(quod

6 igitur T): yovv Bekk.

120
xd 6xx&
ofiotcog'

IITPP&NEI&N
Siaiqeixai ydq eig oxxco xai Svo.
"

xai xd

e%xd
xai

6(ioicog
ev.

xai
ei

217 Svo xai

xai nevxe xai xi66aqa xai xqia xai ovv xavxa %dvxa iv xy SexdSi %eqiiyexai

(iex avxr)g %evxexai%evxr)xovxa yivexai, ev xolg Sixa %eqiiyexai %evxexav%evxr]xovxa' o%eq axoitov. ovxovv ovxe %eqdyexai iv xf) SexdSi xd Xey6(ieva avxfjg elvai (liqr)) ovxe i) Sexdg elg exeiva diatqeiG&ai, Svvaxai

avvxi&ifieva

218

chg

bXov

eig

fiiqrj^

(irjSe

bXcog iv avxrj

d ecoqeixac.
,

xd 8e

avxd d%avxr\6exai xai i%i x&v

(liye&og,
ei xvyoi,

(teye&cov, oxav xo 8exd%r)yy

xig.

Siaiqeiv i&iXoi
eig (liqt).

ovx ivSiyexai ovv

idcog Siaiqeiv

ovSe bXov

x
219

Ovxovv

6 %eqi

%eqi yev&v xai eiS&v. x&v yev&v xai x&v eiS&v v%oXei%exai

Xoyog, %eqi ov %Xaxvxeqov (iev iv dXXotg SiaXeS-6(ie&a iv 6vvx6(ico Se vvv xavxa Xio(iev. ei (ihv (cf. p. XXVII), cog
ivvorjfiaxa elvat xd yivrj xai xd el'Sr) Xiyov6tv, at xaxd xov 7)ye(iovixov xai xr)g cpavxa6iag i%iyetqr)6etg avxovg Staxqi%ov6iv' ei 8e iStav v%o6xa6tv avxoig d%oXei%ov6tv, xl %qbg

220 xovxo iqov6tv;

yivrj 9 r)xot xo6avxd i6xiv o6a xd ev i6xi xoivbv %dvxcov x&v eiS&v avxov Xeyofiivcov ei'8r), i) elvat\el8og r]yovv\ yivog. ei fiev ovv xo6avxdi6xt xd yivrj o6a xd ei'8r) avx&v^ ovxix^ dv eir) xotvbv yivog, o eig avxd StatK qed"f)6exat. ei Se kv elvai Xiyotxo iv %&6t xoig ei'Se6tv avxov 2 oXov avxov exa6xov el8og avxov (nexiyet r) (iiyivog, r\xot qovg avxov. dXV bXov (ihv ov8a(i&g' d(ir\yavov ydq iextv ev xi v%dqypv Kiv^} aXXco xai dXXco xaxd xavxb %eqiiye6$at ovxcog cog bXov iv exa6xco d-ecoqeie&at x&v iv olg elvai Xiyeei 8e (liqovg, %q&xov (iev ovx dxoXov&r)6ei xco etSet 3' xai. xb yivog %av, cog v%oXa(ifidvov6iv , ovSk 6 av&qco%og eerat coov dXXd (tiqog froou, olov ov6ia 9 otixe Se e(Ltyvypg ovxe 221 ai6$r)Xixr). elxa fiivxoi xai r\xoi xavxov Xiyoixo dv (iex- e6yr)xivai %dvxa xd ei'Sr) fiiqovg xov yivovg avx&v, r\ exiqov
ei e6xi

xd

10 slvai om. T cf. ad p. 107, 31. 15 dnoXelnerat EAB , 23 om. T del. Bekk. 25 airov del. Kayser 26 yivog ML: xb yivos EAB 28 iv add. T xard rairb MEABT (secundum 1 xal om. T avxb L idetri): xar
||

TnOTTII2EN
xai
ixeQOv.

B.

121

dXXd xavxov fisv ovx ivSiysxat Std xa tcqoSs dXXov xai dXXov, ovxs ofioia dXXr)Xotg e6xat xa etSt) xaxd yivog, oneQ ov nQo68iS,ovxat, anetQov xe eGxai yivog exa6xov elg dnetQa xefivdfievov (ov fiovov xa el'6rj ccXXa xal xa xa& e'xa6xov, iv otg xal avxotg fiexd xcov siScov avxov dscoQStxat' ov yaQ fiovov av&Qconog dXXd
eiQTjfiiva.

el

xai <pov o Aicov elvai Xiysxat).

ei Se

xavxa axona, ovSe

xaxa
xog.
firjxe

fieQog
el Se

fiexi6yr)xe
fir)xe

xov yivovg avxcov evbg ovoXov fiexi6yr\xev exadxov elSog xov yivovg 222
el'8r)
K

xa

fieQOvg avxov, ncog

xotg ei'8e6tv

ovx av sypt Xonoir\6eig, dl xalg ixelvcov avxcov dvenixQixoig Stacpcoviaig xaxd xdg 6xsnxtxdg icpoSovg nsQtxQanr)6ovxat. UQog Ss xovxoig xdxelvo Xexxiov. xd stSr) xota 3} 223 xold i6xtv' xovxcov xd yivrj r\xot xal xoia xal xoia, r\ xoia
fiev

av Xiyotxo iv elvat yevog iv na6t avxov, co6xe xai eig avxcc 8taiQet6&at', xdya xtg Xiyeiv fir) ovyi dvanXa66cov xtvdg eiSco-

xoia

xtvcov
dXrj&r)

xd

Se ov, r) fiiv i6xt

tysvSfj,

ovxe

xola

ovxs xoia.

oiov

inel

xcov
fiev

6c6fiaxa

xd Ss a6co(iaxa, xai

xd

xai svta fiev Xevxd, el xvypt, svta Se fiiXava, xai svta fisv fiiyi6xa svia Ss 6fiiXQ0xaxa, xai xd aXXa bfioicog, xo xi Xoyov svexsv, o <pa6tv slvai xtvsg ysvtxcoxaxov, r) ndvxa s6xat rj xd sxsQa r) ovSiv. dXX si fisv 224 ovSiv i6xiv oXcog xb xi, ovSs xb ysvog, ni^ag syst r) r)ei Se ndvxa sivat Qrj&sir), nQog xco dSvvaxov slvat xr\6tg.
i6xt

xd 8s

xb Xsydfisvov, xai Ttov siScov xai xcov xa& sxa6xov iv otg Ssr)6st ndvxa slvat. cog yaQ, insi xb coov, cog cpa6iv, ov6ia i6xiv sfityvyog ai^&rjxtxi), sxa6xov xcov siScov
avToi) xai ov6ia slvat Xiysxat xai sfityvyjog xai ai6&r)Xtxr), ysvog xai 6&)fid i6xt xai a6cofiaxov xai tysvSsg xai dXr)&eg xai fiiXav, ei xvfpt, xai Xevxbv xai 6fitXQOxaxov
ottxcog si xb

xai (iiyt6xov xai xdXXa ndvxa, s'xa6xov xcov siS&v xai xcov

xa&

sxa6xov ndvxa t6xat' onsQ ov ftscoQStxat. tysvSog ovv xai xovxo. si Ss xd sxsQa fiova i6xi, xovxcov xb ys- 225
9 Xiysrat om. T ydg 25 %%ot AB (tiiw?)

aivd

(et

ipsa)

8 aira>v

28

derjosi 8s

19/20 r&v tivco' G: quorundam T 26 rm MET (cum eo quod) rb LAB

:

(eorum considerantur)

8 ov

(pportet autem)

122

IITPP&NEI&N
i

vog xcov Xotncov ovx e6xat yivog, olov ei 6co(ia xb xi, xcov d6co(idxcov, xai ei Xoytxbv xb coov, xcov dXoycov, cog (nr)xe a6cb(iax6v xi elvai coov (ifjxe dXoyov, xal ini xcov aXXcov bfioicog' oneq dxonov. ovxovv ovxe xal xotov xal xoiov
xb yivog, ovxe xoiov (iev xolov Se ov, ovxe (irjv ovxe xotov ovxe xotov Svvaxat elvat [yevog]' el Se xovxo, ovSe e6xtv ei Se Xeyot xig oxi Svvd(iet ndvxa i6xi oXcog xb yivog. xb yivog, Xi^Ofiev, cog xb Svvd(iet xi ov 8el xi xal iveqyeia elvat,

olov ov

Svvaxai

xtg

yqa(i(iaxtxbg
ei

eXvat ei

(ir\

xal

iveqyeia.
xco(iev

xa\ xb yivog

ovv

8vvd(iei

ndvxa

i6xiv, iqco-

avxovg xi i6xtv iveqyeia, xal oftxco (ievov6tv ai xdvavxia (iev ydq ndvxa iveqyeia elvai ov 226 Svvaxat. dXX ovSe xd (iev xal iveqyeia xd 8e Svvd(iei
avxai
ditoqicct.

iveqyeia, 8vvd(iei 81 &6cb(iaxov. oiov xe i6xiv iveqyeia vno6xr\vat, xb Se 6co(ia eveqyeia <^ov)> dSvvaxov i6xiv &6c6(iaxov yeve6&ai xax iviqyetav, co6xe ei Xoyov ydqtv 6co(id (xt) e6xtv iveqyeict,
6co(ia
(iev

(ibvov, olov Svvdtiet ydq

i6xiv o

ovx i6xtv a6cb(iaxov Svvdfiet, xal xb dvdnaXtv. ovxovv ovx ivSe%exat xb yevog xa (iev iveqyeia eXvat xd Se Svvdei Se ovSev oXcog i6xlv (iet (iovov. iveqyeia, ovSe vcpe6xr\xev. ovxovv ovSiv e6xt xb yevog, o Statqetv eig xa ei'Sri Xi227 yov6tv.
6
ext

avxog
*

i6ttv *AXiE,avSqog
9

xal tovxo &ea6a6d at a^tov. co6neq ydq, inei xai Tldqtg, ovx ivSiyexat xb
,

(iev

AXil-avSqog neqtnaxet'
tpevSog, ofixcog
>

neqtnaxei
'

dXrj&eg elvat, xb Se Ildqtg ei xb avxo e6xt xb av&qconov

r\

elvat &ecovt xai Aicovt, eig 6vvxatv d^tcofiaxog dyo(ievr\

nqo6rjyoqia r] dXrj&eg r} ipevSog in d(icpoxeqcov ov &ecoqetxai Se xovxo' xov (iev ydq notr)6ei xb d%ico(ia. r Aicovog xad"Yi(iivov &ecovog Se neqtnaxovvxog xb av&qco-

dv%qconog

nog neqtnaxet'
6 xal xolov

icp'

ov

(iev Xey6(ievov dXrj&ig iextv,

icp

ov

8 yivog del. Bekk. 9 Xiyot 11 sl (t,r\ xal T (nisi et 16 ivegyeia 15 td Si actu): (ir[ tig 6: ftrj tig oav Gen. 19 ti om. T 18 ov add. e T (corpus autem quod est actu) add. (fortasse excidit exemplum) 25 6 avtbg T (idem): avtbg G 27 tb av&econov T (hominem esse), coni. Pappenheim: tm
alt.

G:

est

EABT

(dicat): Xiyoito

M:

Xiyet

dv&Qdoneo

TIIOTTII&ZE&N
ipevSog.
jtocf

B.

123
r)

ovk

uqu

xotvr)
i)

i6xtv

dficpoxiQcov

uv&qcoISlcc

nQ06j)yoQiu. ov8e

uvxr) dfitpotv,

dXX

ei

uqu,

eKCCXEQOV.

xa
ei

UccQccitXipia
(IrjKOXcov.

neQi xotv&v 6Vfifie(5r)x6xcov. 8e Xiyexat xai neQi x&v xotv&v

*ev

6vfi(3e-

228

yuQ

Sicovt

xb

oq&v,

xui xb uvxb 6vfi(}ir)xe /Hcavi xe xui euv xa^ vno^eGiv cp&aQrj fiev Aicov,

&icov 8e neQtrj xui oqu, r\xot xr)v oqu6iv xov ecp&uQfiivov Jicovog ucp&uqxov fiivetv eQ0v6iv, oneQ dnefitpuivet, <^r]y xr)v avxr)v oqu6iv icp&uQ&ut xe xai fir) icp&ccQ&ai Xih,ov6tv,

ovk uqu r) &icovog 0Qu6tg i) uvxr) i6xi xrj xai yccQ ei xuvxbv dicovog, dXX' ei uqu, i6ia enaxiQOV. Aicovi xe xai Qicovi xb dvanveiv, ovx ivSiye6Vfiir)xe xai xr)v iv Qicovi dvunvor)v etvut, xr)v iv dicovi 6e fir)
oneQ uxonov'
elvut'

ivSiyexat 6e
r)

xov

fiev

cp&uQivxog xov

6e

neQtovxog'

ovx uqu

uvxr) i6xiv.

IleQi fiev

ovv xovxcov eni xo6ovxov vvv

ccQxi6ei

6vv-

xoficog XeXiy&ut.
xj3'

ne^i 6ocpi6(idxcov.

6e t6cog xai xco ne^i x&v 6ocpi6fmxcov im- 229 6uc ^Quyicov, inei xai eig xr)v xovxcov 8tuXv6tv 6xrj6at Xoyco dvayxaiav elvai Xiyov6t xr)v 6 iaXexxixr)v oi 6efivvvovxeg

Ovx axonov

*uvxr)v.

ei yuQ x&v xe dXrj&cbv xai tpevS&v Xoycov, i6xiv utixr) 8tuyvco6xtKr), ipevSeig Se Xoyot cpueiv, xui xu 60<pi6(iuxu, xui xovxcov ccv ei'r) StuKQixixr)

Xvfiutvofiivcov xr)v dXrj&etuv cputvofiivutg nt&uvoo&ev cog (5or)9ovvxeg ot 8tuXexxtxoi 6aXevovxt xcp xr\6tv.
jSico

xui xr)v evvotuv xui xug StucpOQug Kui xug intXv6etg

6ocpt6fiuxcov fiexu 6novSr)g r)(iug neiQcbvxui

8r)

x&v

8t8u6xetv,

Xiyovxeg 6ocpt6fia elvat Xoyov nt&uvbv xai 8edoXtevfiivov co6xe nQ06Si,u6&ut xr)v intcpoQuv r\xot tyev8r)
i)

chfiotcofiivrjv

tyev8et

r)

u8r)Xov

r)

uXXcog dnQ06-

1 ovSe T (nec): xal 8h icovt: Bekk. dubit.

||

to L: om. M(T?)

20

cpaciv

om.

EAB

7 r) add. T 12 xt\v </xr> iv (autem): xal EAB 17 rco EAB: 18 Xoyov T (instare rationem) xr\v om. L 23/24 tk> (3ito Gen.: xbv iov G: adiu-

MLT

||

vantes concussam vitam

(faJse):

24

ipevdfi

ML

Sr)

om.

28

tpEvdsl

EABT

124

iitpp&nei&n

230 8exxov, olov tyev8r} (iev cog ini

f

(xovxov) xov 6ocpiov8eig 8i8co6t Kaxr}yoQr}(ia nteiv xaxr\-^ yoQr}(ia 6e ioxi xb atytv&tov nteiv ovdelg aQa 8i8co6tv dtytv&tov nteiv', ext 8e ofiotov ipevdei (hg ini xovxov "o (ir)xe ive8i%exo (jbrjxe iv8i%exat, xovxo ovx eaxiv dxonov' ovxe 8e ive8i%exo ovxe iv8i%exati xb b iaxQog, xa&b iaxQog ffrt, cpovevet' (ovx ccQa 231 dxonbv io~xi xb 6 iaxQog, xa&b iaxQog iaxi, cpovevet/. ext 8e d8r\Xov ofixcog ov%i xai rjQooxrjxd xt 6e nQ&xov, xai
Gficcxog e%et
'

'

ov%i ol aGxeQeg aQxiot eidiv' r\Qcoxr\xa 6i xi 6e nQiool aQa aGTBQEg aQXiot eietv*. ext Se anQoQ6eKXOv aXXcog, cbg ot Xeyb(ievot 6oXotxiovxeg Xbyot, olov 'o fiXeneig, eaxtv' ftXinetg 8e cpQevtxtxbv eoxtv &Qa cpQevtxtKov'. *o bQag,e6xtv' bQag 8e cpXey(latvovxa xbnov' eGxtv &Qa cpXey(iatvovxa xbnov'. 232 elxa (livxot xai xccg intXvGetg avxcov \oqccv r\xot\ naQtdxav int%etQov6t, Xiyovxeg ini (iev xov nQooxov 60cptGfiaxog, oxt dXXo Sta xcov Xr\(i(tdxoov 6vyxe%coQr\xat xai dXXo inevrjvexxat. 6vyKe%ooQr\xat yccQ xb ntveO&at xaxr\yoQr\(ia xai elvat xaxr\yoQr\(ia xb (ir) dtyiv&tov ntvetv, ovx avxb xb cciptv&tov. 8tb 8iov intcpiQetv 'ovdeig oa nivet xb aiptv&tov ntvetv\ oneQ i6xiv ccXrj&eg, inevr\veKxat *ov8sig &Qa ccipiv&tov ntvet', oneQ icsxi rpev8og, ov 6vvayb(ievov iK 233 xcov GvyKe%coQt](iivcov Xr\(iudxoov. ini Se xov 8evxeQOv, oxt 8oKet (iev ini tyevSog dndyetv chg notetv xovg dventGxdxovg bxvetv avxoo 6vyKaxaxifte6&at,\

xoV

'

ovx aQa dxonbv i6xt xb 6 xa&b iaxQog i6xt, cpovevet\ ovSev y&Q iaxQog, dijtooua dxonbv iextv, di-tooua 8i i6xt xb '6 iaxQog, xa&b iaxQog i6xt, cpovevet\ 6tb ovSe xovxo axonov.
6vvdyet Se dXrj&ig, xb
29* notelv 29 xovxov add. T (sicut in hoc sophismate) 31 ht de Gen.: inl dh G: om. T (similis autem false) 22* suppl. Bekk. coll. v 1 8s om. L 2 6 EAB: om. ML 5 slatv om. M 4 r)Qmxr\xa 20/1 2* fri Sb ut p. 111,31 hxt Ss ut p. 111,31 (aliter autem inaccep5 oi LT: sl EAB

EAB

||

tabiles T)

9* oq&v

rjxoi

om.

TII0TTn&2EN
r\

B.

125

8s int xb aSr\Xov dnaycoyf), cpa6tv, oxt ix xov yk- 234 (ir\Ssvbg ycco tiqor\Qcoxrj(isvov xaxd xr)v vno&s6tv xb dnocpaxtxbv xf)g

vovg xa>v (isxantnxovxcov i6xtv.

sv(inXoxf)g dXr\&sg yivsxat, tysvSovg Tfjg 6V(inXonaQa xb ifinsnXsx&at tysvSog t6 ^rjQcoxr\xd xi 6s nQ&xov' iv avxf). (isxa Ss xb iQcaxrj&f)vai xb dnocpaxtxbv rfjg 6v (inXoxf)g, xr)g nQ06Xr\tyscog f ccXrj&ovg ysvo(isvr\g r\Qcoxrjxa 8s xi 6s nQcaxov', 8 ta xb iJQaxrje&ai tiqo xfjg JtQ06Xf)tyscog xb dnocpaxtxbv
nf\g ov6r\g

6v(inXoxf)g r) xov dnocpaxtxov ttjj 6v(inXoxf)g itQoxa6ig yivsxai ipsvdrjg xov iv tc5 6v(insnXsy(isvco tysvSovg ysvofisvov dXrj&ovg' cbg (ir\8snoxs Svvaff^cft 6vva%&f\vai xb 6V(insQa6(ia (if) 6vvvnaQ%ovxog xov dnocpaxtxov T^g 6v(inXoxf)g xf) nQ06Xf)tyet. xovg Ss xsXsvxaiovg, cpa6tv svtot, xovg 60X01- 235 xtovxag Xoyovg, dxoncog indys6&at naQa xr\v 6vvxf)g

H&stav.(xat (idxcov

ovv xivsg StaXsxxtxoi cpa6v nsQt 6ocpidXXot aXXa Xsyov6tv)' xavxa 8s xag (isv x&v yccQ slxaioxiQCOv dxoag i'6cog Svvaxat yaQyaXi&iv, nsQixxd Ss iext xal (idxr\v avxotg nsnovr\(isva. xal xovxo Svvaxbv (isv t6cog xaX dnb xcov r\Sr\ XsXsyfisvcov r\(itv Sqccv' vns(tvr\Totavxa
(tsv
(ir)

6a(isv yaQ, oxt

Svvaxat xb dXrj&hg xal xb fysvSog xaxa

xovg StaXsxxtxovg xaxaXafifidvsefrat, novxiXcog xe dXXcog xal x& xd fiaQXVQia xf)g 6vXXoyt6xixf)g Svvd(iecog avxcov, xfjv dnoSst^tv xal xovg dvanoSeixxovg StaxQsns6&at Xoyovg. sig Ss xbv nQOxsi(nsvov xonov iSicog xal aXXa (isv noXXa 236
Xsystv svs6xtv, atg Ss
(iev

iv
r)

6vvx6(ico

6ocpt6(iaxa

iStcog

StaXsxxtxf)

vvv xoSs Xsxxsov. o6a 8vva6&at Soxet St-

eXeyyetv, xovxcov r\ 8tdXv6ig dyjQr\6xog i6xtv' o6cov Se r\ StdXv6tg iQr\6t(ievet , xavxa 6 (iev StaXexxtxbg ovx ccv StaXv-

24

EAB

inaycoyr) Gen.

28 8h om. L

29

xr)g nQ06Xr)rpscog

om.

29*

Bekk.: ngol. G: assumpticmem T ut v. 29 6 5 rovg evvrjd-. corrupta esse putat Pappenh., qui avxobg vel aliud desiderat 5 Ivtot MEABT (quidam): $v&a L 5 a iitdys6&at T 9 oIxsioteqcov L 14 Sv7 xtveg om. T (induct): iitdystv G vd(iEcog om. L

ysvoy,ivr\g

ML:

yivo(iivr\g

EAB

30

nQ06Xr\ipscog

126
6eiev,

IITPP&NE1&N
ii

oi

Se

iv

exu6rr\

re%vr\

rr\v

inl

r&v

237 nuQuxoXov%rr\6iv

ev&ecog yovv, i6yr\xoreg. Sevxeqov fivr\6&&fiev nuQuSeiyfiurog, eQcoxrj&evxog [iuxqco] xoiovrov 6ocpi6(iurog \axa rug vo6ovg iv ruig nuQqxfiuig rf\v re noixiXr\v Siuiruv xul rbv olvov Soxifiu6reov' ini
tijg nQcorr\g

nQuyfiurcov ivu evbg r)

2!

nu6r\g Se rvnco6ecog vo6ov nQO

rcog

yiverai

SicltqIxov

xf\v

nuQaxfifj' uvuyxuiov re noLxiXr\v Siaixuv

6
fiev

uqu

diarqirov nuvnQO rrjg nQcorr\g

xui rbv

olvov

cog

rb

SiuXexxixbg ovSev uv eineiv 238 eypt itQog SluXvGlv xov Xoyov, xaixoi %Qr\6ifir\v ov6av, 6 Se iaxQog 6iulv6erui rb 6ocpL6fku, eiScog on nuQuxfir\ Xeyerui Siycbg,
r\

noXv nuQqXu(i(tuveLv'

3<

re

rov oXov vo6f)fiarog xai

r\

xu6ecog fieQixfjg unb xf\g axfif\g Qonr\ nQog xui nQO (iev xr\g nQcoxrjg SiuxQixov cog xb
nuQuxfirj r\ rr)g iniru6ecog rffc fteQLxfjg, rf\v Siuvtuv ovx iv ruvrr\ SoxLfiu^ofiev clXX^ iv

exu6xr\g inixb xQei66ov,

noXv yivsxum
Se
rr\

noixiXr\v

nuQuxfifj

rov oXov vo6f)iiarog. o&ev xui StrjQr^&uL Xeei ru Xf\(ifiuru rov Xoyov, ereQug fiev nuQaxfifjg iv rco nooreQco
Xfjfifiuri

Xufifiuvo(ievr\g ,

rovre6n

rf\g

rov

oXov

nu-

&ovg, ereQug Se iv rco SevreQco, rovre6ri rf\g fieQLxfjg. 239 nuXiv re ini rivog nvQe66ovrog xuru nvnvco6tv inirerufieru ivavriu rcov iQtorr\&evrog rov roiovrov Xoyov ivavricov icifjLuru iertv' ivavriov Se rf\ vnoxeL(ievr\ nvQco6ei to tyvyjQov' xarqXXrjXov uqu rf\ vnoxeLfievr\ nvQCovr\v
(

ic

240 6ei rb tyvyQOv' 6 iiev SLuXexrixbg r\6vyu6eL, 6 Se iuTQog, eiScog rivu f*,ev i6riv nQor\yovfievcog nQ06eyf\ nu&r\, xivu
Se
6vfinxcoKiuxu

xovxcov,

i^ei

fir\

inl

xcov

6vfinxcofiuxcov
15

nQoxonreiv rbv Xoyov {ufieXei yovv nQog rf\v iniyv6iv rov tpvyQOv nXeiova yive6&ui 6Vfifiuiveiv rf\v nvQC06iv) aXtf
nQ06eycov nu&cov, xal rr\v fiev 6reyvco6iv elvai nQ06e%fj, f\ng ov xr\v nvxvco6iv uXXu xbv yuXu6xtxbv xqoinl
rcov

nov

rf\g

inifieXeiug

ccnairei,

rb

Sh

rf\g

inuxoXovd-ov6r\g

23 Iuxqco secl., fort. leg. xov toiovtov ao114,9 aut iatQiKOv 6ocpi6fiaTog 26 ante primum 27/28 ante primam paroxisim tertiane T 1 ante primam quidem tertiane T 4 xal om. T 9 rov roiovrov Xoyov ML: xov Xoyov tov xoiovxov EAB: huiusmodi ratione T
21 inl om.
(pi6fiurog coll. p. tertiane T

TnoTTn&2EaN
ificcGiag

b.

127
(irjSe

ov

TVQorjyovfiivcog

dXXi]Xov
iiGfiaGi

elvut

Soxovv

uvxf).

nQOGe%ig, odev xal oftxcog (iev

rr\v

xo
xoig 241

ini

xoig

%Qr)Giu,cog

dnutrovGt

StdXvGtv

ovdev

StuXexxtxog, eQcoxf)Gug 6e r)(idg xotovxovg vvg *et ov%\ xui xuXd xi^uxu e%etg xal xi^axa tg, xi^axa ^tg* ov%i 6e xuXd xi^uxu e%etg xat axa e%etg' xi^uxu uqu e%etg.' *ei xtvelxai xt, r)xot 242 (o eGxt xonco xtvetrat^ ev co ovx eGrtv' ovre 6e r) co eGrtv ((livet ydo) y ovre [de] iv co (ir) eGrtv (n&g
Xiyetv 6

dv eveQyotr) rt ev ixeivco, ev co (irjde rr\v aQ%r)v rtv() ovx uou xtvetrai rt.' 'rjxot xb ov yivexat r) 243 to (ir) ov. xo (iev ovv ov ov yivexat (eGxt yuQ)' d\X* ov8e xo (nr\ 6v' (to (iev yaQ ytv6(ievov nuG%et rt, to 8e (ir) ov ov nuG%et)' ovSev uqu yiverat.' *f) 244
q

%tcav vdcoQ iGri nenr)yog' (liXuv 6e to vScoq eGriv. (liXatva ccqu iGriv r) %tcov.' xai rotovrovg rtvdg d&QoiGag tt&Xovg Gvvdyet xdg ocpQvg, xai nQO%etQierut rf)v StaXe-

ndvv Ge(iv&g ent%etQei xaraGxevd&iv r)(iiv 6V dnodei^ecov GvXXoytGrtx&v, ort yiverai w, xai ort xtveirai n, xai ort r) %tcov eGrt Xevxf), xai oxt xi^axa ovx e%0(iev,
xxtxf)v, xai

xairot ye aQXOvvxog tGcog xov xr\v evuQyetuv uvxoig dvrtxt&ivat nQog xo ftQuveG&at xr\v dta^eutcoxixr\v ftiGtv avr&v dtd rf)g ex r&v <patvo(iivcov tGoG&evovg avrcav dvrt-

xurd rfjg xurd tov

raOTa rot xai iQcorrj&eig cptXoGocpog (rtg^ tov Xoyov Gicon&v neQtendxr\Gev , xai ot fiiov uv&Qconot ne^dg xe xai dtunovxiovg GxiXXovrut noQeiug xuruGxevdfyvGi re va-Og xai oixiug xui nutdonoiovvrat r&v xard rrjg xtvr\Gecog xai yeviGeag dfieXovv(lUQrvQrjGecog.

xtvr)Gecog

20(6tiy nQ06s%ig
xetv auT^ Pappenheiin

gans autem nos):

del. E.
siTtsQ

f)(ilv

Weber
:

20/21 zb (ipv%Qbv to> xax. elvat do23 iQcoxrjaeig EAB f)(tag T (interroGr 24/25 et 25/26 xal xiQuva fyetg
||

28

(isvei

Kayser

||

iv

aixcp iaxtvy E.

Weber

coll. p.

pivet yaQ (iv atixcp, Ss om. 137,26

||

5 ivaQysiav Fabr.
alt.

iviQysiav G: ad manifestam
olg
:

avx&v

EAB

phil.) cf. p. 136, 25.

e9ivr\g

M eis T 8 xtg add. T (quidam ad cpd. rubr. in L add. in mrg. 6 dvxi9 xara om. T (rationem motus) 12 xara G:<JeT
uvxov L
avxcov
:
||

128

IITPP&NEI&N

246 xeg Xoycov. cpeQexat 8e xat *HgocpiXov xov iaxQov %aolev (xt) dnofivr\fiovevfia' 6vve%q6vi6e yccq ovxog 4to8coQcp, og ivanetQoxaXcov xf\ StaXexxtxf) Xoyovg 8te!~i\et aocpiGxixovg xaxd xe dXXcov noXXcov xa\ xi\g xtvr\6ecog. cog ovv ixflaXcov noxe cofiov 6 JioScoQog r\xe fteQanev&rfiofievog cog xbv

HQOCpiXov,
iv
(o

r\v

xonco

iyccQievxi6axo ixelvog itQog avxbv Xeycov *r\xoi 6 cofiog cbv ixnenxcoxev , r) iv cp ovx f\v'

ovx aQa ixnenxcoxev\ xovg xotovxovg Xoyovg, &bquxr\v Se i iaxQtxf\g aQ[i6ov6av uvxcp 7tQ06ccyeiv 246 netav. ciQxei yao, olfiut, xb ifineiQCog xe xa\ dSou6xcog
ovxs 8e iv
cog
cp r\v

ovxe iv

cp

ovx

r)v'

xbv 6ocpt6xr\v XtnuQeiv iuv

fiev

xuxd xag xoivdg

xr\Qr\6etg

xe

xal

nQoXfjipeig fitovv
xr\g

neQt

xcov ix doyfiuxtxrjg TteQieQyiag

xa\ (idXi6xu e%co

tcoxt-

xf\g XQeiag Xeyofievcov iniypvxug.

ei ovv o6u fiev ev%Qr\6xcog dv intXv&eirj, xavxa ovx av StaXv6utxo r) StuXexxtxf), 06a

Se

intXve6&ut
r)

6oir\

xtg

ccv

t6cog

vn

avxfjg

6ocpi6fiaxa,

6tdXv6tg u%Qr\6x6g i6xtv, a%Qr\6x6g i6xt xaxd iniXv6tv xcov 6ocpt6(idxcov r) 8taXexxtxf). xr\v 247 fc a \ &jt avxcov 8e xcov nuQu xotg StaXexxtxotg Xeyoxovxcov
fievcov

OQficofievog

TteQtxxa

dv 6vvx6ficog vnoftvr\6ete oftxcog xtg elvat xd neQt xcov 6ocpt6fidxcov TtaQ uvxoig 8f\ xe-

yyoXoyovfieva. int xr\v xe%vr\v xr\v 8taXexxixf)v cpu6tv coQfirjxevat oi 8iaXexxtxo\ ov% unX&g vneQ xov yvcovat

xi ix xivog evvdyexut,

ccXXd nQor\yovfievcog

vneQ

xov 8t dnoSetxxtxcov Xoycov xd dXr\&f\ xu\ xd ipevSf) 'xQivetv ini6xa6&ai' Xeyov6t yovv elvat xr\v diaXexxtxr\v int6xf)fir\v dXrj&cov xa\ ipevS&v xa\ ovSexi248 qcov. inet xoivvv avxoi cpa6tv dXr\&f\ Xoyov elvat xbv
dXrj&cov Xr\fifidxcov dXrj&eg 6vvdyovxa 6vfineocc6fia, afia x& iQcoxr\d-f\vut Xoyov il>ev8og eypvxa xb 6vfiTtigaaua ei60fie&a oxt ipev8f)g i6xtv xa\ ov evyxaxa&^Ofie^a
8t

15 ivanetQoxuXav Bekk.: 14 xt add. T (gratum quid) 16 xard G: de T iv dneiQoxdXco G: in dyalectica inexpertus T 18 ad i%uQ. L habet in mrg. evtQaiteXi6axo, i-axoipev Xiycov T
||

(dicens):

26 Xeyofiivcov om. T 31 Se MEAB: om LT dicunt enim T 8 xbv L:

Xiyco

19

cbv

om. T 24 tovv T (vivere): lov Gr 29 xaxd GT (secundum) fort. %qos 6 Xiyovat yovv Bekk.: Xiyovotv ovv G:
:

xcbv

MEAB

TnOTTII2EN
xtxbv x<b.

B.

129

dvdyxrj yccQ xai avxbv xbv Xoyov r\xot (ir\ elvai 6vvxa Xf)uuaxa eyetv dXr\%f\. xal xovxo Sf\Xov ix 249 r) (ir\8e

x&vSe.
ttJ

ei

r\xot dxoXov&et xb iv xco Xoycp tpevSeg 6vuniQa6(ia Sid'x&v Xrjuudxcov avxov 6vunXoxf\ r) ovx dxoXov&et. dXV (iev ovx dxoXovftet, ovSe 6vvaxxixbg Xoyog s6xat' Xiyov6t

ycco

(Stoic.

fr.

II

oxav axoXov&rj
1

239A.) 6vvaxxixbv yive6&at Xoyov, xf\ Std x&v Xr\(i(idxcov avxov 6v(i-

nXoxfj xb iv avxco 6v(iniQa6(ia.

ei Se dxoXov&et, dvdyxrj xat xf\v Sid x&v Xr\(i(idx<ov 6v(inXoxr\v elvai ipevSf) xaxd xdg

avx&v
det
'

ixelvcov xe%voXoyiag" cpa6i

yaQ oxt xb ipevSog ipevoxt Se 6

(ir\

(jtev

dxoXov&et, dXr\&et Se ovSaficog.

250

6vvaxxtxbg r) (ir\ xog idxtv, 8f)Xov ix x&v e'(inQ06&ev eiQt\uivcov.

iQCoxrj&ivxog

dXr\&r\g Xoyog xaxd avxovg ovSe dnoSetxxiei

xoivvv

Xoyov, iv

to

avxo&ev ytvco6xo(iev, oxt

rpevSog i6xt xb 6v(iniQa6ua, ovx E6xtv dXr\$r\g ovSe 6vvaxxteyjetv

xbg 6 Xoyog, ix xov 6vuneQa6(ia

xad r\6oued a
, ,

avxco,

xdv

(if\

ytvco6xcouev
oxt

ipevSig, ov 6vyxana^d xi xb dnai6xt xd

xr\Xbv eyet.
~
:!
I

&6neQ yaQ ovS

xdv
(if\

dXrj&fj

vnb x&v
t6(iev

ipr\<ponatxx&v ytvoueva
a7Caxco6tv,

^vyxaxaxt&ifie&a,

dXX

oxt

'*

ytvco6xcouev oncog dnax&6tv, oftxcog ovSe " xotg ipevSi6t uiv, nt&avotg Se elvat Soxov6t Xoyotg net&6(M&a, xdv (ir\ ytvco6xcouev oncog naQaXoyi&vxat. r) inet 251

ov uovov ini ipevSog dndyetv xb 6o<pt6ud <pa6tv, dXXd xal inl dXXag dxoniag,xotvoxeQOV ovxco 6vveQcoxr\xiov. 6 iQcoxcofievog Xoyog r\xot ini xt
r)

dnQoeSexxov r)uag dyet ini xt xotovxov cog %Qf)vat avxb nQoeSeie^&at. dXX' ei uev xb SevxeQOVf ovx dxoncog avx& evyxaxad-rj^o^ie&a' ei Se ini
1
i

'

dnQo6Sexxov, ov% r)uag xrj dxonia 8ef\6et 6vyxaxaxi&e6&at nQonex&g Std xr\v ntdav6xr\xa, dXX ixeivovg dcpi6xa6&at xov Xoyov xov xotg dxonotg dvayxd^ovxog 6vyxaxaxi&e6&ai , etye ur\ XrjQetv natSaQicoS&g, dlXd xdXr\&r\
xt
^rjxetv,
cog

vnt6fyovvxat, nQor\Qr\vxat.

co6neQ yaQ ei bSbg 252

15 avtov om. T 22 r) tir\ G: ur)ts T (nec) 27 tisqI T 31 uhv MLT (quidem): ur\ EAB 32 r) iitsl G: qtwd autem T (insi8r\ ds?) 1 ditdysiv xb 6ocptaud cpaatv dXXd xal scripsi sec. T (in falsum deducit sophisma dicunt quidem etiam): andysiv tolg 6o<piauaatv dXXd xal G
(circa)

Sextus Empiricus

I.

130
eXr\

IITPP&NEI&N

ini xtva XQrjfivbv cpeQ0V6a^ ovx m&ovfiev avxovg eig xbv XQrjfivbv Std xb 6S6v xiva elvat cpeQ0v6av in avxov, dXX dcpt6xd(ie&a xrjg bSov Std xbv XQrjfivoVj ovxco xai ei

Xoyog
ovyl
ovxcog

etr\

ini
dxonco

xt

bfioXoyovfievcog

dxonov

f)fiag

dndyav,

xo}

253 dno6xr\6ofie%a
f)fitv

evyxaxa&rjeofie&a Sta xbv Xoyov, dXV xov Xoyov Sta xr\v dxoniav. oxav ovv

6vveQcoxaxat Xoyog^ %&& exa6xr\v itobxaGiv elxa xov oXov Gvveomxrj&evxog Xoyov xa (f)(itvy icpeo(iev, Soxovvxa indl-ofiev. xai elye ol rceol xbv

Xqv6m%ov

Soyfiaxtxoi (fr. II 275 A.) iv xr) 6vveQ0)xr\6et xov 6fOQixov itQOiovxog xov Xoyov cpa6i Setv i'6x a6&at xai ine%etv, tva (ir\ ixne6co6tv eig dxoniav, noXv Sf)nov fi&XXov av f)fitv aQfioov ei'r\ 6xenxixotg ov6tv^ vnonxevov6tv dxoniav, (xr\ nQoninxstv xaxd xdg 6vvsQcoxr\6stg x&v Xrjftfidxcov, dXX ineyetv xatf exa6xov ecog xfjg bXrjg 254 6vveQcoxr)6eojg xov Xoyov. xai f)(ietg fiev dSo^a6xcog dnb xf\g
(3ta>xixf\g xr\Qr\6ecog OQficofievot

xovg anaxrjXovg

oftxcog ixxli-

vofiev Xoyovg,

oi Soyfiaxtxoi Se dSvvdxcog e%ov6t StaxQtvai

xb
etye

6ocpt6fia
yjQr\

xxtxov

dnb xov Seovxag Soxovvxog iQC0xa6&at Xoyov, Soyfiaxtx&g avxovg intxQtvat, xai oxt 6vvai6xt xb 6yf\fia xov Xoyov %a\ oxt xa Xf)fi(iaxd

255 i6xtv dXrj&fj r) ov% oftxcog e%ei' vnefivr^afiev yaQ SfinQO6&sv, oxt ovxe xovg 6vvaxxtxovg Xoyovg Svvavxat xaxaXafidvetv ovxe dXrj&eg elvai xt xQivetv otoi xe atft,
(ifjxe xQtxr\Qiov (if)xe dnoSet^iv bfioXoyovfievcog s%ovxsg, cag ix x&v Xeyofisvcov vn avx&v ixsivcov vnsfivr 6a(isv. naQt eXxst ovv o6ov inl xovxotg f) d-QvXovfiivrj naQa xotg Sta-

Xsxxtxotg nsQi

256

x&v 6ocpt6fidxcov xeyyoXoyia. IlttQanXf)6ta Se xal ini xf\g 8ta6xoXf)g

si

x&v

dficptfioXt&v

Xeyofiev. yaQ f) dfiqjtfioXia Xetg i6xi Svo r) nXeiat 6r\fiaivov6a xai ai Xs^stg 6rjfiaivov6t ftsesi, 06ag (isv

ev xtvi 1Qf)6tfi6v i6xtv dficptfioXiag StaXvse&at, xovxe6xt xdg

17 ovrcog
add.

GT
:

(sic):

ovrog rtg Rustow: ovrog?

:

18

r)filv

22 xal inixetv om. T 24 ngo(que videntur nobis) 6 r) T (duo aut niTirstv Bekk. itQ06nlitruv G coneedere T plura): xai G: f) xal coniecerat Pappenheim coll. Diog. Laert. VII 62.

I
&g ini tavtrjg

TII0TTII&2E&N
:>

B.

131

ixdatrjv tiyvtjv iyyeyv(ivaa(iivot 6taXvaovtcct, tr)v ifiJtetQiav eypvteg avtoi tr)g vii avt&v nertotri(iivr]g ftettxrjg yQr)aecog t&v 6vo(idtcov ruxta t&v arjfiaivofiivav , 6 6e 6taXexttxbg ov6cc(i&g, olov 257
tr)g dficpt^oXiccg "iv taig jtaQax(iaig tr)v > Slavtav xai tbv olvov 6oxt(iaatiov jtotxiXryv r)6r) 6e xai xata. tbv fiiov ccyQt xal tovj rtaidag oq&uev 6tccateXXo.

t&v i(uteiQt&v , tavtag oi xad

(tivovg ducpLpoXlag , cov r) SiaatoXr) yQrjatuevetv avtoig Soxei. ei yovv tig 6(icovv(iovg oixitag eycov xeXsvot rtaidiov
xXrj&rjvai avt& tbv Mdvrjv, ei tvyot (tovto yccQ tovvoua toig oixitaig eatco xotvov)^ Jtevaetat 6 naig noiov. xal ei
i

rtXeiovag

'syyeov
rtoiov.

ixot

xai diacpoQOvg tig otvovg eycov Xiyot t& rtaiSico tov oivov rtteiv', bfioicog 6 rtaig jtevaetat
r)

ovtcog

iv

eiadyet. eiatv d(i<ptoXiat^ dXX' iv 6oy(iattxaig oir)aeat xeivtat xai eiaiv tacog ayjQr\atot rtQog tb d6o^datcog fitovv, ne^i Tccurag idicog 6 6taXexttxbg sycov dvuyxaa&r)astat xai

6taatoXr)v

ixdatoig iurtetQia tov yQr\ai(iov tr)v 258 6aat (livtot (ir) s'v ttvt t&v fitcottx&v

ifirteiQt&v

iv

avtaig

buoicog

irtiysiv

xatd

tdg

axsrtttxug
r)

icp66ovg,

xu&b
\

rtQayfiaatv

d6r)Xotg xai

dxataXrpttotg

xai dvvno-

atdtotg Xacog eiai avve^evyiiivat. dXXd jts^i (isv tovtcov 259 xai eiaav&tg 6taXel;6(ie&a (cf. p. XXVII)' ei 6i ttg 6oyfiatixbg rtQog tt tovtcov dvttXiyetv irttyetQoir], XQatvvei tbv

axenttxbv Xoyov, ix

tr)g

exatiQco&ev irttyetQr)aecog xai

Jte^i

tr)q

dveittxQttov 6ta<pcoviug
1

tr)v

t&v

r)tov(iivcov

irtoyr)v

xai avtbg fiefiut&v. Toaavta xai Jttol d(i<ptoXt&v eirtovteg avtov rtov JteQtyQd<po(iev xcci t6 6evteQOv t&v vjtotvjtcoaecov avvtayixa.

om.

10 ?^ovrfs 14 8s om. T 17 jtatSicov M 20 oivovg xig EAB XiyoL T (dicaf) Xiysi

:
||

18

sl

xv%ot

31 xpa-

xvvsl Bekk.

xqccxvv st

GrT (confirmat)

1 avxov

nov suspecta

Pappenheimio

nTPPNEIN TII0TTII2E&N
TN EI2 TPIA TO TPITON.
Tdde BVB6TVV iv
a
Jtegl

tC3 XqCxG) tCOV IIvQQCDVELiOV V7tOtV%C06B(OV.

' itegl cq%(qv y tisq\ ftsov

cY
s'

xov cpvaixov pigovg $Qaaxixwv

ksqI alxiov
si'

iari x\ xivbg alxiov

g' tieqI ccq%&v vXlxwv sl xaxaXr\Jtxd xa awpaxa

&
t/3'

r\

7Csq\

xqdaswg

jieqI xivr\6scog

i tieqI xr\g \i,sxa$axixr\g xivr\6swg ta' tisq\ av^rjaswg xa\ (letwaewg

JteQl 71sqI

ty
id'
ie'

dcpatQiaewg xa\ 7tQoa&iaewg (lexa&iasag 7tSQ\ oXov xa\ fiiQOvg

itEQl cpvaixf)g (LEXaoXr)g

tg'

xsqI ysviaswg xa\ cpQ-OQ&g

tieq\ (lovfjg

i%

7tEQ\ XOTtOV Vf\ i%' %eq\ %q6vov

7tSQ\ aQld"(lOV

xa' tisq\ xov r\&txov (liQOvg x$' xl iaxi cpvast dya&ov xa\ xaxbv xa\ aSidcpOQOv
si haxi xx xovxwv cpvasi xS' xl iaxiv r) Xsyo(iivr\ xi%vr\ tieq\ fliov xs' si %axi xi%vr\ tceq\ fiiov x? si yivsxai iv dv&Qwnoig f\ 71q\ xbv fiiov xi%vr\ xf si Sidaxxr) iaxiv i\ 7tsQ\ xbv filov xi%vr\

xy

5 et 6 inverso ordine leguntur in

26

i/j

xnoTTnasESiN
xtj'

r.

133

si

%axi xi SlSucx^llsvov

x&'
X'

si laxtv 6

SiSdav.cov xal 6 iiav&dvcov

si $6xl xig LLa&rjascog xgdnog Xa' si cbcpsXsl r) 7tsol xbv (iiov xi%vr\

X$ Slu

xl

axsnxLxbg

ivioxs

tbv fyovxa avxrjv aLivSoovg xalg ni&av6xr\aLV

iqcoxuv irtLxi\8svsL Xoyovg.

Heql llev (ovvy xov Xoyixov Liiqovg xr\g Xsyofiivrjg cpiXoCocpiag cog iv vnoxvnco6EL xoiavxu ccQXOVVxoag Xiyotxo av'
a'

7tEol

xov cpv6ixov fiioovg.

8s xbv uvxbv XQonov xr)g 6vyyQucpr)g xul xb cpv6ixbv sxu6xov xcov XsyOLiivcov fiioog avTrjg imovtsg ov nobg avxolg xuxcc xonov ccvxsqovllev, uXXcc xu xa&oXixcbxEQa xt-

Kuxa

velv

ini^siQrieoLLEv,

olg

6vLLnQiyQcccpexai

xul

xu

Xoina.

aQ^ojLLE&a 8h

anb xov nQL UQypv Xoyov.

fi

nQL O.Q1&V 8qu6XLxS)V.

nuQcc xoig nXsiexoig 6v(incpo)vrixai xcbv ccq%cqv xug llev vXixug eXvul, xug 81 8Qu6xLXccg, ccnb x&v 8qu6xlx&v xr\v ccQirjv xov Xoyov noLr}6oLLE&a' xuvxag yuQ xul xvqlco-

Kal inu8r\

TEQug x&v vXix&v cpu6iv eIvul.

nsQL &sov.

Ovxovv
ccnEcpr)vuvxo,

insl &sbv slvai 8qu6xlxc6xuxov alxiov oi nXsiovg 2 nQoxsQOv nsqi &sov 6xonr\6coLLv , ixivo nqosLIII

1 2

~ adv. dogm. 412. ~ adv. dogm.

XiyoLLSv
xi

III 49.

'5 ovv add.

om. B 32 xig om. B 34 xovg m&avovg B | (quidem igitur) 6 xoiavxa Gr: xavxa T (hec): xoaavxa Gen. 9 ab eis T (nuo' uvxoigT) tonov L: xbv tonov MEAB: localiterT, fort. xata (tootoj') xbv xoitov cf.ip 391,16. 11 ccgiimLis&a MEABT (incipiamus): aQ^OLis&a L 392,15. 11 a et 15 a tituli inverso ordine exstant in L 13 Sga6ti~ xug EAB: SgaexrjQiovg ML

30

||

134

IITPP&NEI&N

novxeg, bxi t& (iev ico xaTccxoXov&ovvTeg d8oijd6Tcog cpafiev elvai fteovg xai 6efio(iev &eovg xai noovoelv avxovg cpafiev,
jtobg 8e ttjv nQoneTeiav

t&v 8oy(iaTix&v

Tccde Xeyofiev.

ivvoovfievcov r](i,iv nQayfiaTcov Tag ov6iag imvoeiv dXXd xai ocpeiXofiev, olov el 6co(iccTa Igtiv r) dao)uav<x.

T&v

ov yuQ av xig innov ivvof)6ai dvvano (ir) ovyi eiSog tov innov (tcc&cov. to t ivvoovfievov inei ovv t&v 8oy(iccTix&v oi (iev 3 ivvoei6&ai nov ocpeiXei.
xd
el8r\'

itQOTeQOV

t6

6&(id cpa6iv elvcct, tov fteov, ol 8e a6co(iaT0v , xcci 01 pev dv&QconoeiSf), ol Se ov, xai oi (iev iv Tonco, oi Se ov, xcci t&v iv Tonco oi (iev ivTog xo6(iov, oi Se ixxog, n&g 8vvrj60(xe&a

evvoiav &eov Xa(i(ldveiv

(if)xe

ov6iav e%ovTeg ccvtov

6(io-

Xoyov(ievr\v (ir\Te el8og (if)xe Tonov iv ro eir); 7rooToov yaQ ixeivoi b(ioXoyr\6aTco6dv T xcci 6v(icpcovr)6dTco6av, oti TOio68e

i6Tiv

-frfoj,

Ta

rjfitv

avTov
fteov

vnoTvnco6a(ievoi
Xcc(idveiv.

ofiTcog

d%iovxco6av

r)(iag

evvouxv

ig

o6ov 8e

dveniKQiTcog Stacpcovov6iv, xl vof)60(iev r)(ieig SfioXoyov4 (livcog naQ ccvt&v ovx ejip(iev. dXX cccp&aQTov ti, cpcc6t, xcci uay.dotov ivvof)6ag, rbv debv elvai tovto v6(iie. tovto
8i iexiv evrjd-eg' &6neQ (yaQ) 6 (ir) eiScog xbv Aicova ovSe tu 6v(i^erjX0Ta ccvtco cog Aicovi SvvaTai voeiv, ofiTcog inei ovx i6(iev Tr\v ov6iav tov fteov, ovSe rd 6v(ifie(ir)5 xoTa avTco (icc&eiv T xai ivvofj6ai 8vvr)66(ie&a. ^ootg
8e tovtcov einaTco6av
rjfiiv,

xi

i6Ti

xb (iccxaQiov, noTeQOV

to iveQyovv xaTtt aofTjjv xai nQOvoovfievov t&v vcp eccvrb reTayfiivcov, r) to dveveQyrjTov xcci (ir)Te ccvto nQay(iccTa ejpv (irjTe exeQco naQe%ov' xai yaQ xai ne^i tovtov 8iacpcovr)6avTeg
(ittxaQiov, 8id 8e

dvemxQiTcog dvevvorjTov tovto xai tov &eov.

inivofJTai
o

r)(iiv

nenoir\xa6i

to

"Iva

8e

xai

&eog, ineyeiv

dvdyxrj

ne^i

19 providere
coll. p. 109, cilicui (fort.

ipsos nobis

14

||

ts: igitur

pro alicubi
(hoc):

slvai

2 &h om.

EAB
qui)

T 24 sldcoXonoieiadai Kayser T 25 nov ML: xov EAB: mtelligi cf. 26 xbv fteov p. 134, 15) T
Kayser 6 ydg add. T 16/17 nsgl xov koxsqov G: de

4 avx&v

5 touto

EABT

xovxov L: om.

(ijtivori&hvy

(quemadmodum enim
hoc prius utrum

TII0TTII&2E&N

T.

135

xov noxeQOv iattv r\ ovx eaxtv, oaov ini xoig Soyfiaxtxotg. xb yccQ eivat xbv ftebv nQoSrjXov fiev ovx iaxtv. ei yccQ
:

ii-

eccvxov nQoaintnxev, avvecpcovr\aav

av oi Soyfiaxtxoi,

xig

iaxt

xai noSanbg xai

nov'

r\

nenoir\xev
1-ecog

avxbv

dSrjXov

4\fitv

dvenixQttog Se Stacpcovia eivat Soxetv xal dnoSei7

ovv (dnoSetxvvcovy oxi eaxt &eog, r\xot Std nQoSr\Xov xovxo dnoSeixvvatv r\ Si d8r\Xov. Std nQOSr\Xov (iev ovv ovSaficog* ei yccQ r\v nQoSr\Xov xb anoSebfievov.
6 fiev

Setxvvov
xtb

oxt eaxt &eog, inei xb dnoSetxvvofievov nQog dnoSetxvvvxt voeirat, Stb xai avyxataXafifidvetat avtoo, xa&cog xai naQeatr\aafxev , nQoSr\Xov eaxai xai xb eivat

&eov,

8r\Xoo ovxt.
i

avyxaxaXaftav6fievov xco dnoSetxvvvti avxb ovx iaxt Se nQo8r\Xov, &>g vnefivr\aafiev'

nQOovSe

dnoSeixvvxat uoa 8td nQo8r\Xov. dXX' ovSe Si' dSr\Xov. 8 xb yaQ aSrjXov xb dnoSetxxtxbv xov eivat deov, dnoSeitlecog %Qrjov, ei fiev Std nQoSrjXov Xeyotxo dnoSeixvva&at, ovxitt
aSr\Xov

dnoSetxxtxbv

eaxat dXXd nQoSr\Xov [xb eivat fteov]. ovx &Qa xb avxov dSr\Xov Std nQoSrjXov dnoSeixvvxat.
eig

dXt ovSe 6V dSr\Xov'

Xeycov,
,

aixovvxcov

rjficbv

dei

dnetQov yaQ ixneaeixat 6 xovxo dn6Set*iv xov cpeQOfievov

d8r\Xov nQog dnoSeicltv xov nQoexxetfievov. ovx &Qa i exeQOv Svvaxat dnoSeixvva9ut xb eivat &eov. ei Se fir\te 9

iavxov iaxt nQo8r\Xov firjxe i eteQOv dnoSsixvvxat , dxaxdXrpttov eaxat ei eaxt fteog. "Ext xai xovxo Xextiov. 6 Xiycov elvat %ebv r\zot nQOvoeiv avxbv x&v iv xoauco q>r\aiv r\ ov nQOvoetv, xai ei
fiev nQovoetv, r\xot ndvxcov r\ xtvcov. (Epic. fr. 374 Us.J dXX' ei fiev ndvxcov nQOWoet, ovx r\v dv ovxe xaxbv xt ovxe xaxia iv xoo xoafioo' xaxiag Se ndvxa fieaxd

eivat Xeyovatv'
19
add.

ovx aQa ndvxcov nQovoeiv Xe%d"^:

ML:
heim

22 nQoiitnttev G: incideret T 7tQ06i-jtntzev Bekk. 25 &7to8eixvv6fi,svov (qui enim demonstrat) cf. v. 24 29 post TtgodnXov add. Pappena7todeixvv(LEvov tb slvat freov, quod fors. e p. 121,1 huc transponen-

EAB

dum

censet
:

1 del.

Pappenheim

existentis)

Ttgo-neifiivov

5 7tQosxxsiftivov GT (preedd. llsqq. Epicuri fragm. agnovit

Pasquali

13 8i G: ydg

(enitn)

136
10 6exat
6

IITPPNEIN
,

xtvcov nQOvoet, Std xi x&vSe (ihv Ttoovoet, x&vSe 8e ov; r)xot ycco %cc\ (lovXexcct %cc\ Svvaxat ndvxcov itoovoelv , r) (iovXexcct
freog. ei Se
(lev,

ov Svvaxat 8e, r) Svvaxat (iev, ov (iovXexcct Se, r) oftxe fiovXexcct ovxe Svvaxcct. dXX' ei (iev %cc\ ov r)(iovXexo %a\ rjdvvccxo, ndvxcov av nQOvvoet' Se ndvxcov Siu xcc TtQoeiQrjfieva' ovx uqu itQOVoet xcci (iovXexat xcct Svvaxcct ndvxcov nQOVoeiv. ei 8e ovXexcct (tev, ov Svvaxat 8e y ccG&evicxeQog e6xt xf)g ccixiag St r)v ov Svvccxat nqovoeiv cov ov nQO11 voet' e6xt Se nccQcc xr\v &eov inivotav x6 aa&eveexeqov elvai xtvog ccvxov. ei Se Svvccxcct (iev ndvxcov' TtQOVoetv, ov (iovXexcu Se, (id6%ccvog ccv elvat vofit6&eir}. ei Se ovxe (iovXexat ovxe Svvaxcct, xcct jSaffxavog Igxi xcct d6&evr)g, oneQ Xeyetv neQt fteov a6e(iovvxcov iaxiv. ovn uqu nQovoei x&v iv %o6(ico 6
&eog.
ei Se ovSevbg jtQovotccv noteixcct ovSe e.6xtv ccvxov eQyov ovSe dnoxeXeGficc, 0$% e"t-et xtg eineiv, no&ev %axaXa(i(idvexcct oxt eOtt fteog, eiye (ir)xe ih, eccvxov cpaivexat (ir)xe 6V dnoxccxccXcc(i(idvexcct.

xeXe6(idxcov xtv&v 12 d%ccxdXr\nx6v iaxtv

xcct

Std

xavxcc

uqu
J

^Ofie&a, oxt

i'6cog

i% Se xovxcov intXoyta6eeiv dvayxdfrvxcct oi Sitt(ie(itticoxix&g

ei

e6xt

&eog.

Xeyovxeg

eivcct

fteov'

ndvxcav

(iev

y&Q

ccvxbv

nQOvoeiv

Xeyovxeg xax&v aixtov xbv ftebv elvcct cpf)6ov6tv, xtv&v 8e a\ (irjSevbg nQovoeiv avxbv Xeyovxeg r)xot (idenavov xbv r)
ftebv
r)

a6&evfj

Xeyetv

dvayxae&f^eovxcci,

xccvxcc

Se e6xtv

d6eovvxcov nQo8f)Xcog.
8'

neQt

ccixiov.
entfetQr\6to6tv
r)(iiv

13

"Iva

Se

(ir)

xat

r)(iccg

^Xaecprjfieiv

ot

8oy(iaxtxo\

St

dnoQiav xov nQay(iaxiK&g

dvxtXeyetv,

T (jprovidet semper) 29 ovdhv (apprehenditur) naTocXafifidvei G 1 &6^eiv ML: d6eeig EAB: impii T 6vo[idovzai T {ap7 &vayv.a6(oaiv T (compellant) pellantur)
14 dsl post 7tQovosl add.
%axa\u(L(ldvTtti

30

||

xnoTTn&SE&N
K01V0ZBQ0V
TtlQl

r.

137

XOV ivSQyr\XLXOV
nsLQa&lvxsg
xr\

ttixioV

xsqov int6xf\6uL

Stan0Qr\60USV, 7tQOxov aixiov inivoicc. oGov

xcov Soyuaxixcov ovS'

usv ovv

iitl

xoig Xsyousvoig

vnb

dv

nQog xco diacpcovovg xui dXXoxoxovg ivvoiag xov aixiov (anodiSoGdaCy exi xul xr)v vno6xu6tv avxov nsnotf)xa6tv dvsvQSXov Sid xr\v nsQL avxb ol usv yccQ 6coua, oi Ss a6couaxov xb aixiov 14 Stacpcoviav. tlvai cpa6LV. So^ul 6* av atxiov sXvai xotvoxsQOV xccx o ivsQyovv yivsxai xb unoxsXs6ua, olov ccvxovg Sl cog 6 r\Xiog r) r) xov r\Xiov &SQu6xr\g xov %sl6&ccl xbv xr\QOv
ivvor)6cci xig

xb alxiov

Svvcctxo, siys

r)
i

xr)g

xu6tv,

^v6scog xov xijqov. xccl yuQ iv xovxco Siunscpcovr)ol usv nQ06r\yOQicov cclxlov slvai xb cclxlov

<pu6xovxsg, olov xr)g pUtw?, oi Ss Xttxr\yOQr\udxcov, olov xov isZeftai. 816, xuftdnsQ slnov, xolvoxsqov ccv
ei'r\

xb aXxiov xovxo Si

o ivsQyovv

yivsxai xb dnoxsXs6ua.

xovxcov Ss xcov aixicov oi usv nXsiovg r)yovvxai xd usv 15 6vvsxxixd slvcci, xd Ss 6vvaixia, xd Ss 6vveQyd, xal GvvsxxLxd usv vnuQ%SLV cov nuQOvxcov nuQS6xi xb dnoxsXs6uu xal uIqousvcov ulqsxul xal usiovusvav

uslovxul
*i'6r\v
>

ttixiov slvtti cpa6i

s%va.i

yaQ xr\v nsQi%s6iv xr)g 6xQuyydXr\g xov nviyuov), 6vvuixiov Ss o xr\v si6cpsQSxai Svvauiv sxsqcq 6vvccixico nQog xb xb dnoxsXseua (ovxco <(yoro^> sxcc6xov tcov
(o-CJtw

*iXxovxcov

xb uqoxqov fiocav atxiov slvai cpcc6L xov aQOXQOv), 6vvsQybv Ss o ($Qa%si~av si6cpsQSxai Svvccuiv xal nQog xb usxd Qcc6xcovr\g vnuQ%siv xb dnoxsXs6ua, olov oxav Svoiv fiuQog ixi ficc6xu6vxcov uoXig XQixog xig nQo6sX&cov 6vysvlol usvxoi xccl naQovxa usXXovxovcpi6r\ xovxo. xcov cclxlcc scpa6ccv slvdcl, cog xd nQOXuxuQXXLxd, oiov
xr)g 6Xxf)g
5

16-

inLxsxuusvr\v r)Xico6iv nvQSXov. XLvsg nuQr\xr)6ttvxo, instSr) xb cctxtov nQog xl vndQypv

xr)v

Ss xavxcc
xccl

nQog

13 add. T (de causa 9 xotvcog Pappenheim dubit. 14 tcsqI avrov Kayser 20 to atxtov assignant) cf. p. 123, 23. 29 aixtov T (causam): atxtog Gr Gen. xb dyystov GT (vas) 30 yap add. T (sic enim) cf. v. 28 30 avvaixtov Kayser, at cf. v. 29 1 rt et xtg om. T
:

138

IITPP&NEI&N
otq atxtov.

t6 dnoxsXs6fta oV ov Svvaxat nQor)ysi6&at avroi/

iv Ss
xrj

nsqi avxcov SianoQi)6st xdtdSs Xsyofiev.

s'

si'

i6xt xi xtvbg atxtov.

17

Ili&avdv i6xtv slvai xb alxiov'

n&g yao av

avr)6tg

ysvotxo, fisico6tg, ysvs6tg, cp&ood, xa&dXov xivr\6tg, xcov cpv6txcov xs xai ipv%txcov dnoxsXs6fidxcov sxa6xov, r) xov navxbg xo6fiov Stoixr)6tg, xd dXXa ndvxa, si (ir) xaxd xtva
aixiav; xai ydo si fir)8sv xovxcov cog nobg xi)v cpv6tv vndofsiy Xs!-0(isv oxt Std xtva aixiav ndvxcog cpaivsxat rjfiiv

*8

xotavxa, bnoia ovx S6xiv.

cog

dXXd xai ndvxa ix ndvxcov xai

sxvysv av

r\v

ftvcov, si xvfpt,

otov Innot fisv ix o%6r)g aixiag. fir) ysvvr)9r)6ovxat, iXscpavxsg 8s ix fiVQfif)xcov'

xai iv

fisv

xai %tovsg
si
(Jtr)

xatg Aiyvnxiatg @rj(iatg ofioot noxs ih,ai6tot dv iyivovxo, xd 8s vdxta Ofifiocov ov fisxsiisv,

aixia xtg i)v,

6V

r]v

xd

fisv

vdxtd i6xt 8v6ysifnsQa,

19 avifir)qd Ss xa nobg xr)v sco. xai nsotxosnsxat Ss 6 Xsycov si fisv ydo dnXcog xai dvsv xtvbg fir\8sv aixtov sivat' aixiag xovxd cpr)6t Xsystv , dnt6xog s6xat' si Ss 8td xtvu
<aixiav, flovXdfisvog dvatQSiv xb atxtov xi&r)6tv, aixiav 8t r]v ovx S6xtv atxtov.

dnoStSd^&co
xb

Atd xavxa
20
oxt

fisv

ovv

nt&avdv i6xiv

slvat

atxtov

Ss

xai xb

S6xt, cpavsobv noXXcov ini xov naqdvxog nobg xrrv xovxov vndfivr)6iv. olov yovv dSvvaxdv i6xt xb aXxtov ivvor)6at noiv xb dno-

Xsystv (ir) slvai xtvdg xt atxtov nt&avdv s6xat Xdyovg rjficov ix&Sfisvcov dXiyovg dnb

1719

~ adv. dogm.

III

200204.

18 %iovsg (Jog ixv%ev\ 17 o(l(Iqoi (xaxd xvt.r\v^y EAB ^t Sft^Qmv (inel (texi%ei) EAB iyivovxo Bekk.: iyivovxo G22 cpr\6st Kayser 19 ioxt om. L Xiyetv G: elvat T (esse) 23 xi&r\6i GT (ponit): &r]eet Kayser dnoStdovg Kayser: dnofort. locus sic reficiendus xb aixtov, (at4idco6t yovv Bekk. 23 drtodtSoefrco xtov xiy xi&r}6tv dnoStSovg cf. p. 433, 13sqq. 25 elvat 24 aixtov causam causam T 25 6*1 ovv om.
||
|| ||

27

iext

om.M

26

xt

om.

EABT

TII0TTn&2EN
riXs6ua to-utoi; xaraXa^eiv cog ydq yvooQi^ouev, ort aXndv S6rt

r.

139

dnoriXe6ua ccvrov' rore dnoreXi6 fiarog, orav ixeivo oog dnoriXe6fia xaraXccufidveouev. dXX' ovde rb dno- 21 riXeOfia rov airiov oog dnoriXs6ua awoi; xuruXufieiv 6vvdue&a, eav ur\ xuraXdoofxev to aXrtov tov dnoreXi6(LUtoj cog airiov avrov' rbre ydq xai oTt dnoriXe6fid isriv avrov ytvco6xetv 6oxovfiev, orav to aXnov avrov cog aXriov avrov xaraXdfieofiev. ei ovv, Xva fiev ivvor\6oofisv to uXttov, 22 6ei nqosntyv&vat rb dnotiXe6fia, Xva 6e to dnotiXe6ua yv&Toi;

uev, (cog) scprjv, 6si TtooETttGTCHTihM to aXttov, 6 6tdXXr\Xog tr\g dnoqiag rqonog dficpco 6sixvv6tv dvsntv6r\tu, ftr\ts tov airiov cog airiov fir)rs tov dnorsXi6fiarog cog dnors-

Xi6fiarog intvosi6&ut

6eofiivov

rr\g

naqd

sxarioov 6vvafUvov' darioov ni6reeog, ov%

ydq

e^ofiev

avr&v dnb

avt&v aQ^Ofie&a tf\g ivvoiag. 6t6neg ov6e dnoqpaive6&ai ^vvrjeofied-a, ort e6tt rt rtvbg aXrtov. Xva 6e xai 23 ivvot6&at 6vva6&at to alrtov 6vy%eoQr\6r\ rtg, dxardXrjnrov dv slvai vout6&sir\ 6td rr\v 6tacpooviav. oi usv ydq
rivog

*q>a6tv

(slvut ri rtvbg aXrtov, ot 6s

<(ti)>

(ir\

elvut, oi 6* eni6yov.

og ydq cpr\6tvy elvat

(ir\6efitccg

rtvbg aXrtov, r\rot

dnX&g xui dnb

oQucouevog airiag svXoyov rovrb <pr\6t Xiyetv, r) 6td rtvag airiag ini rr\v 6vyxard%e6tv rccvrr\v iivat Xist. xai si uev dnX&g, ovx s6rat nt6r6rsqog to-O Xiyovrog dnX&g
ur\6sv slvat ur\6svbg aXrtov'
ei 6s airiag
XiE,st

6t

ocg eivcct

(riy rtvbg uXrtov voui^st, to r\rovusvov 6td tov r\rovuivov nuQt6ruv iniystQr\6sf r\rovvrcov yuq r\u&v, eX S6rt
ri
i

nvbg

aXrtov

uXrtov, avrbg oog airiag ov6r\g tov elvat aXrtov elvut cprysiv. xui uXXeog, insi nsqi rr\g vnuQ^eoog 24
6er\6et

tov airiov r\rovusv,

TOt/

ndvroog ccvrbv xai

rr\g

airiag

elvui rt aXrtov airiav

naqa6ysiv, xdxsivr\g dXXr\v, xai

8 add.

5 avrov prius om.

(ut dixi)

16*

17

add.

(hii quidem igitur esse aliquid alicuius causam. hii non esse. hii vero destiterunt qui dicit igitur) 17' tt

autem
add.

18 Xiyeiv om. T 21 8k MLT: xal EAB: ds xai Gen. 22 * add. Bekk. vo(iiet Bekk.: vofiifrt GT (estimet) 24 tov slvat T (essentie cause), Stephanus: to slvat G
||

140

IITPP&NEI&N
/;

(ts%qig dnsiqov. dSvvarov Ss dneiqovg airiag naqa6yetv' dSvvarov dqa Sta^eatcortxcog dnocpr\vat, ort icri r\ nvog 25 aXnov. nqbg rovrotg r)rot ov xal vcpe6rcog r)Sr\ aXrtov rb aXnov notet rb dnoreXe6(ia, r) (tr\ ov aXriov. xal (tr\ ov Ss '6v, Set avrb nqoreqov vno6rf\vai (iev ovSaticog' ei xa\ nqoyevie&at aXrtov, sl$ ovrcog indystv rb dnoriXs6(ia,i onsq vn avrov dnorsXsie&at Xiysrat ovrog r)Sr\ airiov. dXX*

inet nqog ri i6r\ rb airiov xat nqbg rb dnoriXe6(ia, 6acpeg ort (ir\ Svvarat rovrov oag aXriov nqovno6rf\vat' ovSe ov dqa

26 aXrtov rb aXnov dnoreXelv Svvarat to od Se

e6nv

aXrtov.

ei

rf (ir)re (ir\ 8v aXrtov dnoreXet rt (tf)re ov, ovSe dnoreXel 6tb ovSe aXrtov e6rat' avev ydq tov dnoreXetv rt rb aXnov ov Svvarat cog aXrtov voet6&at. o&ev xdxetvo Xsyov6i rtvsg'
to aXrtov
r\rot 6vvvcpi6ra6&at Sst tco anorsXs6(iart r) nqovcpi6ra6&at rovrov i) (slvaty (tsra to yivs6$at (anoreXe6(ia). to (tev ovv Xiyetv, ort to alrtov eig vno6ra6tv ayerat fiera rr\v yive6tv rov anoreXe6(iarog avrov (ir\ xa\ yeXotov r\.

27 voet6&at

ovSe nqovcpi6ra6&at Svvarat rovrov' nqbg avrb yccq Xiyerat, rcc Se nqog rt cpa6tv avroi t xa&b nqog dXX ovSe xi ieriv, 6vvvndq%etv xa\ 6vvvost6&at aXXrjXotg.
dXX*

6vvvcpi6ra6&at'
ytv6(isvov
ei

ei

vnb bvrog

ydq dnorsXs6rtxbv avrov i6rtv, to Se r\Sr\ yivs6&at %qf), nqorsqov Set to

sltf

atnov ysvs6&at aXrtov ,

ovrcog notstv to dnorsXs6(ia.

ovv to atrtov (tf)re nqovcpi6rarat rov dnorsXs6 (tar og avrov (ir)rs 6vvvcpi6rarat rovrm, dXX ovSe <to dnorsXs6(iay nqb avrov yivsrat, (if)nore ovSe vno6ra6ecog oXcog (tere%ei.
Se Xecog ort xai Sia rovrcov r\ inivota rov airiov ndXtv neqtrqenerat. ei ydq to aXrtov cog (iev nqog rt ov Svvarat rov dnoreXe6(iarog avrov nqoentvor\ftr\vai , tva Se Ssl avrb nqocog aXrtov rov dnoreXe6(iarog avrov vor\&r\
,

28 6acpeg

2628

~ adv. dogm.
e

III

232236.

10 suppl.
yetv

differre

T (aut esse postquam fiat effectus) T 20 add. T (sed neque effectus est

11

14-

ante eam),

coniecerat Kayser

TII0TTn2EN
/oetc&ai

T.

141

tov dnoteXiCfiatog

LVor\&f\vai ti ixeivov ov nQoenLVOrj&fjvaL vvatov ictiv imvor]d-7)vai tb aitiov.

avtov, dSvvatov Se noo[] ov Svvarai,

'Ex tovtcov ovv Xombv iniXoyiZofie&a, oti (ety m&a- 29 fiiv eIclv ol Xoyoi xatf ovg vnefivfjCafiev cbg %Qr\ Xiyetv tiov elvai, ni&avoi Se Kai ol naQiCtdvteg, oti firj itQOGel

aitiov eXval ti dnocpaiveC&aL , xai rovrcov nQOXQiveiv

wg

ovx ivSiyerai,

fif\re

Cr\(ietov
r)ficov

fir\re

XQitrJQiov
cog

fifjre

dnoSei^LV
to-O

bfioXoyovfiivcog

iyovrcov ,

efMQOC&ev

iniyeiv dvdyxr\ xal ne^i tr)g vnocrdcecog airiov, (ir\ fiaXXov elvai r) (ir\ elvai ti ahiov Xiyovrag oCov ini tolg XEyofiivoig vnb rcov Soyfiarixcov.
naQECrf\Cafiev ,

?'
JTfol
fjiev

7tEQl
trjg

vXlX&V

CiQ%C0V.

SQacrixfjg roCavra vvv aQxicei 30 Se xal ne^i tcov vXtxcov xaXovfiivcov XeXiypai' avvtoficog ccq%cov Xexteov. oti toivvv avtai eiciv dxatdXrjntot, QaSiov

ovv

CvviSetv ix
rotg

T?jg

TteQL

Soyfiaxixoig.

avtcov yeyevr\fiivr\g Siacpcoviag naQa &eQexvSr\g fiev yaQ 6 EvQiog yfjv

eine rf\v ndvrcov elvai aQyfjv, &aXf]g Se 6 MiXf\Ciog v"ScoQ^Ava%ifiavSQOg Se 6 dxovCtr\g tovtov tb dnetqov, 'AvaJ-ifiivrjg Se xal Aioyivr\g 6 'AnoXXcovidtrjg

diQa,"InnaCog Se

Meranovrtvog nvQ, Sevocpdvr\g

Se 6 KoXocpcovtog yf\v xai MScoq, OivoniSrjg Se 6 ( *Xtog nvQ xai diga, "Inncov Se 6 Pr\ytvog nvQ xai v"Scoq, 'OvofidxQitog Se iv rotg 'OQcpixotg nvQ xai

CScoQ xai yf\v, oi Se neQi rbv^EfineSoxXia xai rovg 31

Diels).

3032

~ adv. dogm.
Bekk.
(quod
.
. .

III

359364 (cf. Doxogr. p. 248 sqq.

27

xl del.
||

om.

MT

el

(aixlagy T xovg T (qui

MLEB

29 lontbv 28 taoay icxlv Gen. insL Bekk.: om. Gr 5 SQa6XLxf\g 9 ydg om. EAB 16 xal (de agenti causa) autem circa empedoclem et stoicos) A: ngbg xovg

si):

cf. p.

462,

3.

142
Sxcotxovg nvQ
Xoyovfiivrjg
ccioa

IITPP&NEI&N
vScoq yf)v

nsQi yctQ xfjg xsqcctonaQtt xt6tv v"Xr)g, r)v ovSe ccvxoi xaxccXccfidvetv Stafiefiatovvxai, xl Sei xai Xiyetv; ol Ss tvsqi

dnoiov

AQt6xoxiXr)v xbv
32 xvxXocpoQr)xtxbv

TIsQtnaxr)xtxbv

nvQ diqa vScoq

6

6&fia,

/drjfibxQtxog

yfjv xb Ss xcci 'Eni-

xovQog dxofiovg, Avcc^ayoQag Ss

iXa%i6xa
xcci

KXao(iivtog

HQaxXsiSr)g Ss b Hovxtxbg xai A6xXr)ntdSr)g b Bt&vvbg dvaQfiovgi oyxovg, ot Ss tzsqI Hv&ayoQav xovg dQt&fiovg, ot Ss (icc&rffiaxtxoi xd niQaxcc x&v Gaadrcov 2xquxcov 33 Ss b cpv6txbg xdg notoxrjxag. xoGavxr\g xoivvv xai ext itXsiovog Stcccpcoviag yeyevrjfiivrjg jvsqI x&v vXtx&v aQ%&v
dfiEQf)

bfiotOfiSQsiag, AibdcoQog Ss b intxXrj&sig c

ecofiaxa,

KQovog

nccQ

6xu6e6t xaX xatg dXXcctg

ccvxoig, r\xot na6cctg 6vyxaxa&r)66ue&a xalg xetuivatg xi6iv. dXXdnd6ccig fiev ov Svvaxbv' r)
Svvr)66fi>eQ a xal
,

xoig nSQt A6xXr)ntdSr)v 6xot%sicc Xiyov6i xai notd, xai xolg nsQi 4r)fi6xQtxov, axofiai xavxa slvcct cpa6xov6i xai anota, xai xoig nsQi 'Ava^ayoQav, na6ccv ai6&r}xr)v notoxrjxa nsQi xccig
6vyxaxaxi&s6d-ai ,

ov yaQ Sr)nov

&Qav6xa slvai xd

34 bfiotOfiSQsiaig
XQivovfisv

ttXXcov nQOXQivovfisv, rjxoi

r)

dnoXsinov6iv. sl Si xtvcc 6xa6tv x&v dnX&g xai dvsv dnoSei^ecog nQO-

fisxd dnoSsi^scog.

6vv&r}66fis&a'
Sst^tv slvat.
XQtxrjQico

avsv uev ovv dnoSsi^scog ov dnodXrj&rjg Ss ovx av So&sir) fir) ov%i xsxQiaivt)
sl Ss fisxd dnoSsH),scog, dXrj&rj Ssi xr)v

dXrj&si,

dXr)&sg Ss XQtxr)Qtov slvat Ssixvvxai

6V

35 dnoSsi^scog xsxQifiivrjg. sl xoivvv, tva usv r) dnoSet^tg r) nQOXQivoved xivcc 6xa6tv ttXr)&r)g slvai Sst^f) ? Ssi xb xqixr)Qtov avrf)g dnoSeSeiy&at, tva Se xb XQtrfjQtov dnoSet^d-fj,
Sei rr)v dnoSetl-iv avxov nQ0xexQi6&cct, b StdXXrjXog evQi6xerat XQonog, og ovx ea6et nQofiaivetv xbv Xoyov, xfjg fiev dnoSei^ecog dei XQtrrjQiov Seofiivrjg dnoSeSetyfiivov, xov 36 XQtxrjQiov Se dnoSefl-ecog xexQtfiivrjg. et Se dei xb XQtxr)Qtov

rola

30 aXXatg ML: SXccig EAB: et aliis etiam T GT {talia) 3 nsgi G: iv T (in) 6 ov

e.

1 noid Gen.:
7

dnoSsi^scag

G: manifestum est qui (i. Bekk. dubit. 11 &Xr}&i)g

EABT

quial)

7 avynarccQ-riodfis^a

(vera): dXr}9-sg

ML

TII0TTn&2EN IV
urr}OLco

143

xqivetv
xtg,
eig

xcci

xr\v

vXotxo
Uxtg

dnetqov

anoSet^tv dnoSet%et dnoSetxvvvui ei xoivvv (if)xe ix^Xrj&f^eexat.

xaig neqi
(if)xe

dec&cu

Avvaxov
dxaxccXr\ipiav'

6xotyeitov Gzdaeai Svvdfie&a 6vyxaxaxixivl xovxtov, ineyetv nqo6f)xet neqi avxtov. fisv ovv t6tog e6xl xcci Std xovxcov (ibvcov
xf\v

37

vnofit(ivr\6xetv

xtov

6xotyeicov

xcci

xtov <hXtxtov dqytov

Xva

Se

xcci

dficptXacpe6xeqov

xovg Soyfiaxt-

xovg iXeyyetv eytofiev , evdiaxqitycofiev evfifiexqtog xco xbnto. xai inei noXXai xcci 6yeSbv unetqoi xtveg eioiv ai neqi
6xotyeitov

S6at,

6xr\v Xeyeiv eiStxtog

xfjg

6vyyqacpfjg f
r)v

fiev nqbg exdvvv naqaixrjaofie&a Std xbv yaqaxxfjqa Svvdfiet Se nqbg na6ag dvxeqovfiev. inei

xa&cog vnefivfjeafiev, x6

ydq

av

xig

e'inr\
r)

neqi 6xoiyeicov 6xa6iv y

ini

r)xot ini 6co(iaxa

xaxeve%&r\6exai
fivrj6ai,
I

a6t6fiaxa, bxt dxaxdXr\nxa (tev i6xi

dqxeiv f)yov(ie&a finoxa 6cbuaxa, axaxaXrynxa

6acpeg
e6xat,
bxt

Se xa ccecofiaxa' Std yccq xovxov exotyeid iextv dxccxdXr\nxcc.

xai xd

'

ei xaxccXr\nxcc

xd 6tbfiaxa.

Ucofia xoivvv Xeyov6tv elvcci xiveg o olov xe not- 3& eiv r) na6yeiv. o6ov Se ini xccvxr\ xr\ inivoicc axaxdXrjnxov
>

i6xt

xovxo.

xb

fiev

ydq

ccXxiov

dxaxdXr\nxbv i6xt, xa&cog

vnefivf\6afiev' (ir) eyovxeg Ss eineiv ei s6xt xt aixtov, ovSe ei e6xt xt na6ypv eineiv Svvdfie&a' xb ydq ndoyov ndvxcog

vnb aixiov
o

nu6yet. xcn xov nd6yovxog,

6&fia.

Std

dxaxaXf)nxov Se ovxog xai xov ccixiov xccvxcc dxccxdXr\nxov e6xat xcci xb

xtveg

Se

6xaxbv
37 38 39

fiexd

6&(ia elvat Xiyov6i dvxtxvniag. 6r\fieiov

III 365. III 366. III 367.

xb
fiev

tqtyfj

ydq

cpcc6tv

Stao&

39>

~ adv. dogm. ~ adv. dogm.

cf.

adv.

dogm.

adv. math. III

1920.

17 dnoSsil-st

MLT

(demonstratione):

dnoSsi^scog

EAB r

tmde editorum error Sl' ccnoSsiscog 18 ixlr\&f]esxaL olim tentatum a Nauckio T (eicietur): ift&X- G vide ad p. 132,28. 23 xal om. T 24 ivSiargiipcofisv GT (retardemus) ivStargi29 av Bekk. idv G: quamcumque si quis T tyoftsv edd.
:

2 iaxtv

(sunt): farat

11

(isv

om.

||

cpaetv

om.

144
(ii(jog

IITPP&NEI&N
i

dnXaxig, intcpdvetuv Se (if)xog (iexu nXdxovg' oxuv de avxr) xal (id&og nQ06Xdftr) xui dvxtxvniuv, 6&(ia elvut, %sql
0% vvv iaxiv
40
rjfitv

ov&iv,

yQU(i(ir)v 6e (if)xog

6 Xoyog,

6vve6xoog ex xe (if)xovg xal

evfiaorjg (tivxoi

nXdxovg xal fid&ovg xa\ dvxtxvniag.

xal 6 JtQog xovxovg Xoyog. xb yuQ 6&(iu r\xoi ovdev nuQa xuvxu elvut Xiov6tv r) exeQov xi nuQu xf)v 6vviXev6tv x&v TtQoeiQrjfiivav. xal eJ-co&ev (iev xov (if)xovg xe xal xov nXdxovg xa\ xov (id&ovg xal xr)g dvxtxvniag ovSev av etr\ xb

xuvxd i6xt xb tfcofta, idv Sei^r) wg, oxt avvnuQxxd i6xtv, dvatQoirj dv xal xb 6&(iu' xd yuQ oXu 6vvuvutQeixui xotg euvx&v n&6i (liosQiv. notxiXeog (iev ovv e6xt xuvxu iXiyyeiv' xb 6e vvv aQxi6et Xiyetv, oxt ei e6xt xd
6eo(iW
el

6e

41 ni^axu^ r)xot yQU(i(iai et6iv rj intcpdvetat r\ 6co(iaxa. el (iev ovv intcpdvetdv xtvu rj yQa(i(ir)v slvat Xiyot xtg^ xui xoov 7tQoetQr](xivoov exu6xov r)xot xuxu idiuv vq>s6xdvut dvvu6&ut
Xeypr\6exut
r)

(idvov ns^i xotg Xeyofiivotg

euvxr)v (iev
i'6eog

6co(iu6t

decoQeir)

6&ut.

dXXa

xu&

vnuQyov6uv
eftrj&eg.

r)xot yQU(i(ir)v

intcpdvetuv bvetQonoXetv
(iu6t

ei de

&eooQei6&ut Xiyotxo fiovov xui (if) s6xdvut xovxeov exu6xov 9 nQcoxov (iev uvxo&ev So&rjeexat xb xa 6oo(iuxa (i%Qf)v yao, olfiat, xavxu (ir) avxoov yeyovivut
'
1

neQt xotg 600xufr euvxb vcp-

nQOxeQov vnb6xa6iv xaO euvxu i6yr)xivut, xui ofixeo 6vveX-42 ftovxu nenotr)xivut xu 6cb(iaxu), elxu ovde iv xoig xaXovxcci xovxo dtd nXetovcov (iiv (tivotg 6co(iu6iv vcpi6xr\xev.

vvv xu ix xf)g dcpf)g dnoyuQ unxexut dXXf)Xeov xu nuQuxt&i(ievu 6co(iuxu, xoig niQu6tv afarwv, olov xuig intcpuveiutg, tyavet al ovv intcpdvetut oXut (iev 6t bXcov dXXf)Xuig dXXf)Xeov. ov% evoo&rjeovxut xuxu xr)v dcpf)v^ inei 6vyyy6ig e6xat r) ucpr) xai 6 %coQt6(ibg xeov dnxo(iiveov 8tu6nu6(iog' oneQ ov
i6xtv vnoiiifivrj^xeiV) aQxi6et 6e

QOV(isva Xiyetv.

ei

adv. dogm. III 368. adv. math. III 83. 40 adv. dogm. III 434. 4144

28

et

17 xuvxaT (adhec) 24^7*tvG:dz'/ferreT(atcf.adp.l25,ll) 30 et 1 29, 13 negl G iv T (in) cf. p. 127, 3 31 (ifj om. EAB
:

TII0TTn2EN
coQEtxat.
si

T.

145
r)

8h dXXotg

<^|uiv)>

(iqe6iv

sntcpdvtta ccnxs- 43
inicpavsiccg,

xat

xf\g

xov

nccQaxt&sfiivov

avxfj

6c6(iccxog

uXXotg 8h 6vvf)vcoxut x& 6c6(iaxt ov i6xt niQccg, (pvx s6xat

*d(5a&f)g, diacpOQcov xcov ccvxfjg (ieqcov voov(iivcov xaxd fidb&og, xov (isv xov nccQaxt&sfiivov dnxofiivov, xov 8h xaO"

nsQt
j

ov i6xi niQag^. ovx uqu ov8h Svvaxai xtg (ifjKog xal nXdxog 6(ioicog Sh xal Svo intdfiaftig, o&sv ovSh intcpdvstav. xa&' vn6&s6tv nuQaxt&Efiivcov dXXf)Xatg xaxd xu cpavstcov 7tiQuxa avxcov sig a Xf)yov6t, xaxd xb Xsy6(isvov avxcov xovxi6xt xuxd yQafifidg, ai yQa(i(iat avxat, (ifjxog slvai, oV cov aTCxs6&ut Xiyovxat dXXf]Xcov ai intcpdvstcct, ov%
o

6vvf)vcoxat

xco

6c6(iaxt

6c6(iaxt

&coQrj6ai

svco&rj6ovxut (isv dXXf]Xatg (6vy%vdstsv yuQ dv)' si Sh sxd6xr\ avxcov dXXotg (ihv (iiQs6t xotg xaxd nXdxog dnxsxat Sh 6vvf]vcoxat xf\g naQaxt&S(iivr\g ccvxf\ yQU(i(if\g, dXXotg
xfj

intcpavEta
si

r)g

i6xt ni^ag,
(if)x

ovx s6xut dnXaxf)g, o&sv ovSh

s6xtv
r)

yQU(i(if).

8h

yQu(i(ir\
r)

iv

6c6(iaxt

(if)xs

int-

cpdvsta, ovSh
t

(if]xog

nXdxog
Xiyot
si

fid&og E6xat iv

6(6(iaxi.

si Si
r)

xtg

6c6(iaxa

nQog avxbv dnoxQt6tg.

Ssr\6st xovxo sig cov sxd6xr\ 6co(jlu

xd ni^uxu, 6vvxo(iog s6xat 44 yaQ xb (ifjxog 6co(icc i6xiv, xag XQsTg avxov (iSQis6&at Stct6xu6tg, ov6a ndXtv ccvxrj 8tutQE&f]6EXttt sig Stccslvat

dXXag XQEtg, al s6ovxat 6c6(iuxu, xat ixstvat sig b(ioicog, xai xovxo (ii%Qtg dnstQov, cog dnstQo^iyEdsg onsQ dxonov' yivse&at xb 6co(ia sig dnstQa (isqi^6(ievov
6xa6stg

dXXag

'

ovSh

oSh

6c6(iaxa ttQtt sWtv ai 6c6(iuxd u6t (if)x (nf)xs

nQOStQr\(iivat
yQttfifiat
r\

8ia6xd6sig.

si

intcpdvEtat,

ovSh

slvcct vo(it6&f)6ovxat.

^AxaxdXnnxog

Si

s6xt

xcci

r)

dvxtxvnia.

avxr\

yaQ 45

45 46~adv. dogm.

III

259261.

10 (ihv add. T (quidem) suppl. verbotenus e T (terminus non erit sine profunditate differentibus eius partibus intellectis secundum profunditatem hac quidem cui opponitur tangenti hac autem secundum (quody coniungitur corpori cuius 25 6m(iaxcc LT: <scb(iatog MEAB est terminus. Non ergo) Xiyot xd nigaxa MEABT (si autem aliquis est corpora esse 32 6cb(iaxa om. T dicat terminos): xd TtsQata Xiyot L
||

12 a-c

Sextus Empiricus

I.

10

146
i7tEQ

iitppnei&n
xuTuXu(*pdvTui)
otov
xi
io~Ti

ucpf)

xuxuXa(t.fidvoixo

uv.

iuv ovv
eoxcci

dei^co^ev,

bxt uxuxdXrftxog

iortv

r)

dcpf),

6cccpeg

bxt

ov%
8\

xuxuXu(i$dvs6%ut
r)

xf)v

uvTtTvniuv.

bxt

intXoyt6(jiE&u. xu ccTtTOfievu ccXXrjXcov rjTot (ieqe6iv uXXfjXcov utctetui r) oXu bXcov. oXu (isv ovv bXcov ovSu(i&g' vco&f)6Tat yuQ ov"tco xal
ccXX ovSh (ieqe6i (uq&V xu yuQ nqbg xu bXu (lEQrj i6xiv, cog 8e itQog oXa. xuvtu ovv tcc oXa, ^Jiy i6Ttv eteqcov 46 fieQrj, bXa (ihv bXcov ov% utyETut Std tcc rtQOiQr\(iivu, uXX' ovSe (ieQe6t (ieq&v' xut yuQ tcc tovtcov (iEQr\ &>g rtQog xu iuvx&v (JteQrj bXu ovtu ovte bXu bXcov utyexut oftxe (ieqe6i (ieq&v. et Se (ir)xe xuxu bXoxr\xu (if)r xuxcc ueoij ytvo-

dxaTuXrftrog

i6Ttv

ucpf),

Stu xovxcov

ovi utyExut
(iQr\

uXXf)Xcov.
fiev

uvx&v &g xd fieQrj iavx&v

(itevrjv

cccprjv

Std
yccQ

Se

xovxo xut

xuxuXufi^dvofiEv, uxuxdXrptxog e6xut r) ucpr). dvxtxvitiu. b&ev xat xb 6&(iw el r)

tcuqcc
xccg

ovSiv i6xt xovxo

i8eu(iev

XQEtg 8iu6xa6etg

xal

xr\v
2

uvxtxvrtiuv ,

8e

dxuxdXrjrtxov

xovxcov

exu6xov,

xut xb 6cb(iu 6xut uxuxdXrjTtTOv.

Ovtco

(iev

ovv, o6ov

irtt xr\

ivvoiu xov 6cb(iuxog, dxu-

47 xdXr\nxov iativ. ei e6xt xt 6&(iu' Xexxeov Se xat xovxo eig xb rtQoxei(ievov. x&v bvxcov xu (iev cpu6tv elvut catfahjTa,

xd Se vor\xd, xut xd
8h
xutg

(iev xf)

Stuvoiu xuxuXafi^dvEe&at, xd

ut6&f)6E6tv , xut xug (isv ut6df)6tg urtXortu&Etg eIvui, xf)v 8h Stdvotuv drtb xf)g x&v ai6&r)X&v xuxuXfjtyEcog e6ti xt inl xr\v xaxdXr\tytv x&v vor\x&v ikvat. ei ovv
6&(tu, r\Tot

ut6&r\x6v i6xtv

r)

vorjxov.

xal ut6&r\xbv

(iev
3

evvu&Qotffibv (if)xovg xut fid&ovg xul rtXuTOvg xuX uvxtxvniug xul iQ03(taxog xut aXXcov xtv&v xaxuXu(ifidvs6ftai SoxEt, 6vv otg ftEcoQEtxut' ui Sh ui6&f\6tg
48 urtXortu&Etg Elvut Xiyovxut rtuq' uvxoig.

<(.
. .

ovx i6xtv'

xuTa yaQ

/> ei 8e vor\xbv

4748

~ adv. dogm.

III

437439.

12 & add. Bekk. 14 xal 16 (isgcov om. T 17 karai om. T 18 non soliditas T 26 dnXoitu&sig Stephanus: ditlonu&siag GT (simplices passiones) cf. v. 33 et p. 146, 7 33 excidit totum enuntiatum, quod ex simpliciter passibiles T p. 146. 7 sic fere expleverim (mats rovxcov ndvtcov 6v(i(ivrj(i6vsvatv fystv ov 8vvr)aovtaty, plura excidisse putat Pasquali
||

TnoTTnasESN
x&v
ov

r.

147
xf)

slvut Xiysrut to 6&(iu, Ssi xt ndvxcog vndqyttv iv

rtquyfidxcov
tti6&r\x6v,

cpvesi

dcp

r)

x&v

6cofidxcov vorjxcov

ovxcov s6xut v6r\6tg. ovSsv Ss s6xt rtuqd xb 6&(ia xai xb &6c6fiaxov, cov xb fisv d.6cbfiaxov avxo&sv vor\xov iart, xb Ss 6cbfia ovx afc&rjxov, cog vnsfivr)6ct(isv. fir) 'ovxog ovv iv xr\ cpv6st xcbv nqayfidrcov afa&rjxov xivog dcp' o&
r)

si

v6r\6ig s6xai xov 6cbfiaxog, ovSs vot)xbv s6xai xb Ss firjxs afc&rjxov i6xi (if)rs vor\rov, nuqu Ss

6&ua. xuvxa

ovSsv s6xt, Xsxriov o6ov ini xco Xoyco fir\Ssv slvat xb 6&fia. Stcc xuvxu ovv Tjfisig dvrtrt&ivrsg rovg xard rov 6cbfiaxog 49
Xoyovg r& cpatvs6&at \Soxsiv\ vndqyov xb 6&(iu, 6vvdy0fisv xr\v rtsql xov 6cbfictxog inoyjqv.
Tr\ Ss xov 6cbfiaxog dxaraXrjipta 6vvsi6aysxai xcti xb al ydq 6rsqr\6stg r&v dxardXr\nrov slvai xb tt6cbfiarov. s^scov voovvrat 6rsqr\6stg, olov 6qu6scog rvcpXorrjg xai dxor\g
xcocporrjg

xal

irtl

r&v aXXcov

rtctqartXr]6lcog.
r

Stortsq

iva

6riqr\6iv xaruXdficofisv, Ssl rrjv s%tv r)(iag rtqoxccrstXrjcpsvaty r}g Xsysrca 6riqr\6tg slvat r) 6rsqr\6tg' dvsvvor\rog ydq rig
cbv xr\g 6qu6scog

ovx
rb

ccv

Svvatro Xiystv, ort oqcc6tv oSs ovx

slvat.
si

s%st,

ortsq

i6ri

rvcpXbv

ovv
(ir\

6rsqr\6tg 6c6(ia- 50
xttraXccfifiavo-

rog

i6ri

fisvcov

a6c6fiarov, x&v Ss s%scov aSvvaxov xdg 6xsqr\6stg avx&v

xb

xttxaXtt(i@dvs6frat,

xai SsSstxxai oxt xb 6&[ia dxaxdXrjrtxov i6xtv, dxardXrjrtrov S6xui xui xb tt6cbfiuxov. xui yuq r\xot aie&rjrov i6xiv r) vorjtoV. stxs Ss

ai6d rjx6v i6xtv, dxaxdXrjrtxov i6xt Std xr)v Stacpo^cocov xui x&v dv&qcbncov xai xcov ai6%"f\6scov xai rcbv rtsqi6rd6scov xai rtaqd rdg inifii^iag xai rd Xotrtd rcov nqosiqrjfisvcov r)fiiv iv roig rtsqi rcbv Sixa rqortcov
,

quv x&v

'

(I

36

163)'

stxs

vor\xov,
y

fir)

cci6&r\xcov xaxaXf)ipscog, dcp

r\g

ccvxo&sv xr\g rcbv oqficbfisvoi roig vorjxoig intStSo(isvr\g

(idXXstv Soxovfisv,

ovSs

r)

rcov vorjxcov

avxo&sv

xccxdXr\ipig

do&rjesrui, Stortsq ovSs r) rov u6co(idrov. o rscpdexcov xara- 51 Xttfifidvstv to u6c6(iurov r\rot cci6&r)6st rovro rtuqu6rr)6st

3 bvxcav om.
p.

476,4:
6

(ir}Ss

%slv del.

32

ydq

T secutus (quod T (qui enim)

6 dcp' ov om. T 9 10 ((itvy ovv T (quidem

videtur existens)

tiT}dhv

scr.

coll.

igitur)

11 So-

31 So-kovgiv
10*

EAB

148

IITPP&NEI&N
'.

instSr\

xaxaXaft^dvstv r) Std Xoyov. xal tti6&r\6st fisv ovSccfKog, al fisv al6&r}Gsig xaxd insQSt6tv xcct vvtv dvxtXafifidvs6$at Soxov6t xav atO^rcSv, olov r\ 0Qa6tg, idv xs

ylvr\xai xcovov, idv xs xaxd eiScoXcov dnointxQiestg, idv xs (xccx^y dxxivcov r) %Qcoftdxcov dyto%v6stg, xccX r) dxor) <Jf, r\v xs 6 %s%Xr\yfisvog dr\Q, r\v xe

xaxd svxa6tv

xotescg xs

xcct

xd
xo

fioQtcc

xf\g

tpcovf\g

cpsQr\xcci

tcsqX

xa

wxa
qivX

xccX

nXr)xxr\
cpcovf)g

dxov6xtxbv

ditSQyds6$at.

&6xs dXXd xcci ai

nvsvfia

xr\v
oSficcX

dvriXr\tytv
xr\

xrjg

xaX

oi %VfioX
1

av xr\ yXcorrr\ %Q06Ttiitrov6tv , xccX xa xr\v dcpr\v xtvovvra 62 ofioicog xf\ dcpy. xa Ss a6cofiaxa i%SQSt6tv xotavxr\v v%Ofievetv ov% otd xs i6xtv, co6xs ovx dv Svvatxo xf\ ul6&r\6et (xavxdy
xaxaXafifidvs6&at.

dXX ovSe Std koyov.

fog oi

si fisv

yaQ ksxxdv

Sxcotxoi cpa6iv (fr. II 166 A.), 6 Xiycov Std koyov xaxccXafifidvs6ftcct xa a6c6ftaxa xb r\xov(isvov 6vvccQ%dst. ^rrrovvxtov yuQ r)fi&v, si Svva6

i6xtv

Xoyog xal d6wfiaxog,

xai xt u6c6(iaxov xaxakafifldvse&at, ccvxbg d6c6(iaxov xt ka/Scbv ditkcog Sta xovxov xr\v xaxdkrjtytv xtov u6cofidxcov %ot-

st6%at %sXst.
53
ttjs

xaixot avxbg 6 koyog^ st%SQ u6(6fiux6g i6xt,

i6xl ftoiQug. %ag ovv ditoSsi^st Ttg, oxt 7Cq6xsqov xovxo xb a6c6ftttxov xttxakafifidvsxat {cpr\fit Ss xbv koyov); si fisv yaQ 6V akkov u6cofidrov, xdxsivov r\-

tcov

r\xovfisvcov

xr\60fisv

xr\v

d%6Sst,tv xr\g

xccxttkrjipscog,

xal fis%Qtg ditsi-

%sqX xr\g xaxaStd rivog ovv Ssi^Ofisv^ oxt xaraXr)tyecog 6cofidrcov' kctfifidvsrttt rb 6&fia t6 sig d%6Ssiiv xf)g xaxaXr)tyscog xov u6(Ofidxov Xoyov Xafi($ccv6fisvov ; ei fisv Std 6c6fiarog, sig

qov'

si

8s

Std

6(6fiaxog,

r\xstxat

xal

x&v

ttitstQOv

ix(iakk6fixra'

si

Ss

oV

a6cofidrov,

sig

rbv Stdk-

4 lvra6tv Kayser coll. Diog. Laert. VII 157. Doxogr. 4 Diels lv6ra<stv GT (instantiam) yivr\xat Bekk. yi7 xd pr vr\rai Gr 5 suppl. T (sive secundutn fluxus radiorum) 10 xal om. L tcsqI L: itgbg MEABT (ad) 9 xal oi %vttol om. T 10 av xfi Bekk.: avxfj G 12 add. T (sensuhec appre 15 xuxalattfidvee&at T (apprehendi) Xaft^dveed-at G hendt) 16 ydg G: dh T (autem) 17 xi &6. MEABT (aliquid incorporeum): xt a6. xtL 20 ditoSei^et T (demonstrabit) ixidsi^et G 23 post xal add. EAB xovxo 28 iftfiaXX. AB (eicimur T) vide ad p. 127, 18
p. 406,
:

\\

#!

|[

TnoTTn&nEN
XrjXov

r.

149

usvovrog ovv oiircog dxurutqotiov ixninrousv. Xf)nrov rov Xoyov, sinsQ d6c6(iur6g iariv, ovx uv Svvuiro ng Xiysiv 6V avrov xutuXulluvs6&ul rb a6couurov. si Ss 54
6coud ionv
nscpc6vr\ruL,

Xoyog,

insi

xui

7tsol
r)

rcov
ot>,

6coudrcov

dia-

Xsyoc rr)v to6V Ssi^iv inifiivrjv 8ifjs6&ui,ii,r\s slvui voLiis6&ai) nuQo xui 6 HXdrcov (Theaet.
p.

norsQOv xuruXaudvsruL 6vvs%rj qv6lv uvtcov, cog urjSs

Slu rr)v

152E) yivousvu usv, bvra Ss ovSinors xuXel

r)

rcc

ecouara, unoQto ncog inixQL&rJ6STUL

Siucpcoviu,
uf)rs
6c6(iarL uf)rs

nsQi rov a6coudrov

ruvrrjv
oqcov

d6coudrco

im-

XQLVS6&UL 8vva(isvr\v Sid rdg ulxqco TtooOxtev siQrjuivug droniug. ovxovv ovSe Xoyco Svvurov i6ri xutuXuuuvslv rcc cc6c6(iuru. si 8s uf)rs ui6d-f]6SL vnoninrsL uf)rs Slu Xoyov 55

xutuXuu^uvetul, ovd* ccv bXcog XUTuXaLL^dvOLTO. Ei roivvv (ir\rs nsQL rr)g vnuQtjscog rov 6c6uurog uf)re
d6coudrcov olov rs i6ri 8iuPsuic66u6tyuL, xui nsQi rcov 6roLjsicov i6riv icpsxrsov, rdycc 8s xui ns^i rcov usrd tcc 6toLyeiu, siys rovrcov rd usv 6c6uuru, rd Ss a6couara, Kui ns^i ducporsQcov r)noQr\ruL. nXr)v dXXd rcov re

nsQi rcov

8qu6tlxcov aQ%cov xui rcov vXix&v Siu ruvru icpsxr&v ov6cov dnoQog i6TLv 6 ns^i aQy&v Xoyog.
r\

nsQi KQu6scog.

xui ruvru nuQuXinrj rig, n&g uqu xui yive- 56 6&ai cpu6i rd 6vyxQi(iuru ix r&v nQcorcov 6tol%elcov, uf)rs &i,scog xui ucpr)g vnuQxov6rjg uf)rs xQu6scog r) ui^scog oXcog;

"Iva Ss

ori usv

yaQ ovSsv i6riv

46), bre ns^i rr)g vno6ru6scog rov 6c6uurog 8isXsy6ur\v' bri Ss ovSs 6 TQonog rr)g XQa6scog o6ov ini rolg Xsyousvoig vn avrcov Svvarog i6ri, Slu (}qu%scov ini6rr\6co.

suvr\6u (45

f)

ucpf),

ulxqco

nQo6&sv vn-

noXXd usv yuQ XsysruL ns^i xQu6scog, xui 6fsSbv dvf)vvroi nsQi rov nQOXEiusvov 6xsuuca6g si6i nuQu rolg Soyuuri2 xoSs Apelt coll. Plat. Tim. 49 de qnocnm consentire videtnr T (ut neque eam que est hoc possit demonstrationem 5 aecoudtov scripsi: ocbfiatog GT (de coraccipere): roxs G 9 corpora T 12 faruL Bekk. dubitanter 15 dubitanpore) dum est T 21 (xuY} ulxqco Gen.
:

150

IITPP&NEI&N

xotg 6ta6stg' o&sv sv&icog &(ia tr\ dvsTttXQitco dtacpcovicc xai to dxatd\r\7ttov tov 6xi(i(icctog 6vvdyott av. r\(iEig
b*E

vvv
did

ti)v Ttobg ti)v

sxcc6tov

avt&v
i

dvtiQQr\6tv

7taQccttr\6d(iE\i!-Etv

voi

tcqo&eGiv

tr)g

6vyyQacpf)g ,

tdSs

ini

tov naQovtog
57

ttTtoyjQcovtcog

bitoXa(idvofiv.
,

xtQvdfisva ov6iag xcci 7toiotr)tcov 6vyxsi6$at ovv tdg (isv ov6iag avtcov (iiyvv6Q at cpr\6st ttg, tag 6s 7toi6tr\tag (jtr\6a(x&g , rj tdg (Jtsv 7tot6tr\rag dva(iiyvv6%at, (ir\xitt 6s tdg ov6tag, r) (ir\&itEQOv dvafiiyvvcpa6iv.
r\tot

Td

6&at

ftatiQco,

)}

dficpotSQa SV0V6&CCI d\\r)\otg.

d\\
,

si (isv

ovts ai Ttot6tr\tsg ovts ai ov6iat dvafiiyvvvtat d\\r)\otgf dvs7ttv6r\tog E6tat r\ XQ&6tg' n&g yaQ (iia ai6% r\6tg dnb

t&v
58 t&v

ntQvafjtivcov

yivE6&at

6v(i(lr\6tai,

stys

xatd

(ir\dsv

7tQOStQr\(iivcov

(liyvvtat

d\Xr)\otg

td

xtQvd(isva;

ei

de ai (iev 7tot6tr\tsg dn\&g 7taQaxsi6&at Xsy&EtEv d\\r)\atg, ai ds ov6iat (iiyvv6&at , xai ovtcog dtonov dv str\ tb \syofievov'

ov

yaQ

xe%coQi6(i,ivcov

t&v
d\\
,

7tototr)tcov
cog
(itccg

t&v
ditb

sv

tatg

XQtt66tv

dvtt\a(itflav6(i&tt,

t&v

si ds tdg (iev ai6&ttv6(ied a. 7tot6tr\tttg (iiyvv6&at Xiyot rtg, tdg 8e ov6iag (ir\Scc(i&g, advvata Xist' r\ yaQ t&v 7tototr)tcov \37t66tcc6tg sv taig

xtQVttfiivcov

a7totsXov(iivr\g

ov6tatg E6tiv, StonsQ ysXoiov dv

tr\tsg

str\

ycoQt6&si6tti
ttTtotot

t&v ov6t&v
cci

[xcct]

\iystv, cog ai (isv noioiSia (liyvvvtai Ttov

XsiTtstcct

59 d\\r)\atg,

6s

ov6icct %coQig VTtoXsiTtovtcct.

Xiystv, ott xcci ai 7tot6tr\tsg t&v xtQvafiivcov xai cci ov6iat %coQ0V6t t d\\r)\cov xai (ityvvfisvcct tr\v XQ&6tv aTtots-

o t&v 7tQOEiQr\(iivcov i6tiv dtOTtcotSQOV ddvvatog yuQ 6ttv r) totavtr) XQ&6tg. otov yovv idv dixcc xotvXaig fidatog xcovsiov %v\ov xotv\r\ (it%d-y, nccvti tco vScctt 6vvavaxiQva6&at dv \iyotto tb xcovEtov' t yovv xai tt

\ov6tv.

fiQayytatov (liQog tov fiiyfiatog \d(iot ttg, s \)Qr\6Ei %E7t\r\60 Qcofiivov ccvtb tf)g tov xcovsiov dvvdfiscog. si ds 7tt(iiyvvtat tb xcovstov Ttavti (liQEt tov ftdcctog xcci TtttQEXtsivstcci
,

avtm o\ov

o\co

xatd

ts tr\v

t&v ov6t&v xai t&v

7tototr)tcov

14 (dtacpoQdsy Xeystv
T, del. Kayser
||

alicui

cf.

ad

(differentias dicere) 22 tot p. 119, 25

15 xal om.

AB

r.

151
xqo.6 tg yivr\xat, xd

xa& IxnoTTii2EaNdnav
f)
J
'

tbv

dV

dXXf)Xcov 6io6ov, tv

ovxcog

(lioog xbv i'6ov TtaQexxetvotteva dXXf)Xotg ini%et xonov , 610 xa\ i6a dXXf)Xotg i6xiv, t6r\ e6xat 7) xoxvXr\ xov xcoveiov xatg 8ixa xoxvXatg xov fidaxog, cog etxo6t xoxvXag ocpeiXetv slvat xb (ityfia r) 8vo (tovag, o6ov int

vno&i6et xov XQonov xfjg XQa6ecog' xat xoxvXrjg xf\8s xrj ndXtv vdaxog xalg e'ixo6t xoxvXatg o6ov in\ xco Xoyco ttjs
;

VTto&i6scog eneu^Xr\&ei6r\g xe66aQaxovxa xoxvXwv ocpeiXet xb uixQOv elvat r) ndXtv 8vo uovcov, inei8f) xa\ xr\v xoxv-

xoxvXag ivSiiexat voeiv, 06atg naQexxeivexat, xoxvXag uiav, f) 6vvsh,t6ovvxat. 6vvaxbv 61 uiav xoxvXr\v ineu(5dXXovxa xa\ ouoicog 6vXXoyi6(isvov 6vvdystv, oxi al etxo6tv oQtouevat xov
Xr\v

eXxo6t

xa\ xag eXxo6t 8e ovxco xaxd

uiyuaxog xoxvXat 8t6uvQtai nov xa\ TtQog 6cpeiXov6tv stvat o6ov int xf) vno&i6et xov XQonov xr]g XQa6scog, at 8e avxat xat 6vo uovat' otcsq dneucpa6ecog vneQoXr\v ovx dnoXiXotTtsv.

ovxovv
ei 6e

axoTtog

e6xi

xu\

avxr\

r)

vn6d-e6tg

xf)g

XQu6ecog.

ovxe x&v ov6tcov uovcov

notoxf)xcov

(ityvvfiivcov dXXr)- 62

Xatg

ovxe

xcov

uovcov

ovxe

ducpoxiQcov

ovxs

ov&exiQOv 8vvaxat ytve6&at XQa6tg, naQa 6e xavxa ov8sv olov xi i6xiv intvostv, dvsntvor\xog 6 XQonog xr)g xe XQa6ecog xa\ oXcog r^g (Jtt^ecog i6xiv. 8t6nsQ si (if)xe xaxd
%iE,tv

naQaxt%iusva aXXf)Xotg xd xaXovusva 6xot%sta

(if)xe

6vyxQt(idxcov avaxtQvoofieva r) utyvvueva 7totr\xtxd xcov elvat Svvaxai, dventv6r\xog i6xtv r) xaxa xovg 8oyuaxtxovg cpv6toXoyia xat o6ov int xovxco xco Xoyco.

&' TtEQl xtvfj6ecog.

IlQbg 6e xotg 7tQoetQr\(iivotg f)v i7ti6xf\6at xco neQt xcov 63 xtvr\6ecov Xoyco, xat cog d6vvaxog av elvat vo(it6&eir\ r) xaxd
Ttdvxcog yaQ xaxd xtva tovg 6oy(iaxtxovg cpv6toXoyia. xivr\6tv xcov xe 6xotyeicov xa\ xf)g 6Qa6ttxf)g dQif\g otpsiXst yivs6&at xa 6vyxQi(iaxa. idv ovv vno(ivf)6co(isv, oxt (ir\6ev

4 avve^i6ovvxat Gen. 6vvetGovrat GT (coe1 ocpeiXr] L T 6 xtgvmitsvat Kayser coll. v. 17 7 Ttov 6: 14 (alloy intvosiv T (aliud in8 Ttgo&iast EAB dSvvarov tellegere) 21 xal om. Stephanua: fort. xai ovrag'?
:

quatur) (quoque)

\\

AB

152

IITPP&NEI&N
*3A
21

eldog xtvrj6ecog OfioXoyetxat, 6acphg s6rat oxi xai Stdofiivcov xatf vno&e6tv r&v nQoeiQrjfiivcov dndvrcov fidrrjv 6 xa-

Xovfievog <pv6txbg Xoyog rotg doyfiarixotg dtel-obdevrai.

t

itsol rfjg fierafiarixrjg xtvrj6ecog.

64

<X>a6i

xoivvv 01

doxovvreg ivrsXiereQOv

tvsqi xi"2|

vrj6scog StstXrjcpivut (Aristot. Cat. p. 15 a 13)

etdrj

xontxrjv f/texdu6tv, <pv6txr)vii fiexafioXrjv, uvrj6tv, fieioo6tv, yivs6tv, cp&OQUv. s rjfietg ovv exu6xcp x&v nQoetQrjfiivcov eid&v xr)g xtvrj6ecog xax idiuv eni6rrj60fiev, dnb rrjg rontxrjg (ierufiu6ecog ccqd(tsvot. s6rtv ovv avxrj xaxd xovg doyfiaxtxovg xa& r]v
xavxrjg

vnuQ%etv,

xdnov sx xdnov fisriQ^srut xb xtvovfisvov rjron: bXorrjru r) xaxd fiiQog, (xud" y oXov fisv cbg ini r&v nsQtnurovvrcov, xaxd 'fiiQog de oog ini rrjg TteQt xivxQco xtvovfiivrjg 6cpuiQug' oXrjg yuQ uvrrjg fievov6rjg iv x& avxco rbncp xa fiiQrj xovg rbnovg*

xa&

65 dfieifiet. XQetg di, olfiat, ysybvu6tv ai dvcoxdxco nsQt xtvrj6 fihv yuQ fiiog xai xtveg r&v cptXo6ocpcov 6ecog 6xa6etg. elvut xivrj6tv vnoXu(i(idvov6iv , fir) elvat 8e TIuQfisvidrjg re xal MiXt66og xai aXXot nvig, firj fiaXXov dh slvat r) slvat ecpa6av oi 6xenr txoi' o6ov fihv yuQ ini rotg (ir) cpatvofiivotg doxetv elvat xivrj6tv, o6ov Se eni rcp qptXoebcpco
1

Xbyco

firj

vnaQietv.

rjfieig

ovv ix&ifievot
rrjv
r)

rrjv

r&v

re elvat xivrj6tv vnoXufifiuvbvrcov

xai r&v

dvriQQrj6tv firjdhv elvat

xivYj6tv

dnocpatvofiivcov , idv teofffovij , fir) ficcXXov elvat

firj

dtacpcoviav svQi6xcofiev elvat xivrj6tv Xiyetv

66 dvayxae&rj^ofie&a 06OV ini roig Xeyofiivotg.

dQ^cbfis&u 8h

dnb r&v vnuQyetv avxrjv

64 65 66

Xeybvxcov.

~ adv. ~ adv. ~ adv.

dogm. IV 3741. dogm. IV 4549. dogm. IV 6768.

G:
G-

1 (isviQXErat scripsi coll. p. 139, 11. 484,24: TtSQtsQXSTat

2 add. T (seeundum totum) 6 cf. p. 485,19 9 slvat T (esse): v.ivr\6iv (livoig om. T dQ^mfts&a T (incipiamus)
transit
)|

(iiog Qt
:

(vita)

15 oaov

dQJ-oiis&a

Xsyo-

Biag

TII0TTn2EN

T.

15&

fir)

Ovxoi 8r) xf) ivaqyeia fidXt6xa ineqeiSovxat' ei ydq e6xt, cpaci. xivr\6tg, ncog fiev dnb dvaxoX&v ini

SvCficcg 6 fjXtog cpiqexat, ncog 8e xctg xov exovg cbqag

)

f)fiag 6vveyyt6fiovg avxov ajtoCxdceig ytyvofiivag; r) ncog vr\eg dnb Xtfiivcov ava^&etcai xaxaiqovGiv ini Xt-

notet,

naqd rovg nqbg

f)ficov

xai xag dcp

fiivag aXXovg ndfinoXv xcov nqoxiqcov clcpeGxcoxag; xiva 8e xqonov 6 xf\v xivr\6tv dvatqcov nqoeiGt, xf)g *oixiag xai av&tg dvaGxqicpei; xavxa 8f\ xeXicog 5 dvavxiqqr\xa elvai. 8tb xai xobv xvvtxcov xig iqcoxrj&elg <^t6v)> y.axd xr)g xtvf\6ea>g Xbyov ovdev dnexqivaxo,dviexr\ 8e xai if3dSi6ev, eqyat xpci Std xr)g ivaqyeiag nuqt6xdg, oxt vnuqxxf) icxiv f) xivr\6tg. Ovxot fiev ovv o-Ctoo 8v6conetv intyeiqov6t xovg xfjg
,o

evavxiag
xtvfjeecog

avxotg

6xu6ecog

bvxag'

oi 8e

xf\v

vnaq^tv
xotovxotg.

xf)g

67

dvatqovvxeg
exiqov,

Xoyotg

intyetqov6t

ei

r) vcp exiqov. dXX xb ydq Xeybfievov vcp' exiqov xtvet6&ut r\xot dvatxicog xtvr\&r\6exut r) xuxd xiva aixiav. dvatxicog fiev ovSiv cpaCt yive6&at" ei 8h xuxd xtva aixiav

xtveixai xt, r\xot vcp

ei fiev vcp'

eavxov xtveixut
^>.

xtveixut,
5

f)

aixia,
eig

xud

'

r)v xtveixut, xtvrjxtxr)

avxov

yevf)-

dnetqov ixninxet xaxd xf\v fitxqco nqo6d-ev aXXcog xe xai ei xb xtvovv iveqyet, 68 eiqrjfiivrjv intoXf\v. xb 8e iveqyovv xtveixat, xdxeivo 8er\6exat xtvovvxog exiqov,
6exat, o&ev

xai xb Sevxeqov xqixov,

xai

ftiyjqtg

aneiqov,

cog

dvaqypv

ovx dqa nav xb xivr\6tv' oneq uxonov. 10 xtvovfievov vcp' exiqov xtvsixat. dXX' ov8e vcp' savxov. inei
yivs6$ut
xr\v

Kyaqy nav xb xtvovv

r\xot

nqooi&ovv xtvei

r)

ini6noSfievov

adv. dogm. IV 7076. 67 69 adv. dogm. 68 dXX' oiSh

~
G

IV 8384.

17

24 secundum quem autem modum T 25 it>Tt T (sunt) factas) 26 addidi coll. p. 115, 8. 490, 3. 1 lacu6 &vxi6&ivris in mrg. nam quam statui eic fere expleverim (ovx iaxat -nivriaigy, sed 9 xivr\plura excidisse monet forsitan v. 6 intf3oXfjv 6 aXXcog 6tv hunc in locum transferri iubet Pasquali irigov alt.
||

Sr\

MEAB

8h

LT (autem)

21 (avxovy ytyvo(iivagT(eius

||

(db alio): havxov

3 uhv (ovvy Bekk.

11 ydg add. Gen.

J.54
r)

IITPP&NEI&N
iv&Xtfiov, 8er\6et xb iavxb xtvovv xocxd xivct dXX' ei (tkv iavxb xtveiv. rtQoetQr\(Uvcov XQoncov
r)

dvco&ovv

69

xcov

7tQOco6xtxcog iavxb xtvei, e6xcct if-oitia&ev iavxov, ei 8h int6na6xtxcog , e'(itnQ06&ev , ei 8e dvco6xtxcog, vnoxdxco, e i 8e iv&Xtrtxtxcog, indvco. ddvvaxov 8e avxb xt iavxov
irtdvco

eivat

r)

e'(JtrtQ06&ev

r)

vrtoxdxco
ei

r)

6711603'

dSvvaxov
eocvxov
xi

aQa
70
xr\v

vcp xtveixat

eavxov
(if)xe

xt

xtvei^&at.

8e

(ir)xe
xi.

vcp
ei

vcp

ixeQOv,

ov8e xtveixai

8i xtg inl
2

oQ(ir}v
xf\g

xal xr\v
TteQt

TtQoaiQe6tv xaxacpevyot,
icp
r\(iiv

avxbv
xog

xov

vrtO(ivr\6xiov 8tacpcoviag, xal oxt avenixQir)(icov

av"xr\

xa&i6xr\xev , XQtxr\Qtov
evQrjxoxcov.

xf\g

dXr\&eiag dyjQt

vvv ov%
71
xoTtco

"Ext xdxeivo Xexxiov.

ei

xivelxai

xt, r\xot

iv
co

co

e6xi
2

xivelxai

r)

iv

co

ovx eexiv. ovxe 8e iv

e.6xtv'

(livei yaQ iv ccvxco, etrteQ iv avxcp e6xtv' ovxe iv co (ir\ e6xiv' ortov yaQ xi (ir\ e6xtv, ixei ov6e 6q&6ai xi ov8e rta&eiv 8vvaxat. ovx ccQa xivtlxal xt.

ovxog
rtoXXcov

6e 8e

Xoyog e6xt
dvxtQQf)6ecov

(if\v

4io8coqov xov Kqovov,

,

xexvjr\xev

cov

xag

7tXr\xxtxcoxi-

2i
31

Qag 8td
72
xf\g

xbv

XQOrtov
r\(iiv

xfjg

6vyyQacpf\g

ix&rj^ofie&a

(iexd

xiveg, cpa6tv e6xt xonco xtvei6$at' xdg ' yovv TteQi xolg xevxQOig neQt8tvov [livccg 6cpaiQag iv 13 xco ccvxco (ievov6ccg xonco xtvei6%at. rtQog ovg (lexcccpiQew %Qr\ xbv Xoyov icp' exa6xov xcov (jteQcov xf\g 6cpatQag, xa\ vrtO(it(ivi\6xovxag, oxt o6ov irtt xco Xoyco (ir\8e xaxd (ieQr\ xtvei<patvo(iivr\g
irtixQi6ecog.
co
'

ovv

oxt

Svvaxai xi iv

73

6vvdyetv oxt (ir\8e iv cb e6xt xortco xtveixai xt. xb 8e ccvxb xal rtQog xovg Xiyovxag, oxt xb xtvovfjtevov 8vetv e%exat xortcov, xov xe iv co e6xt xcct xov eig ov cpiQexat. rtev6o(ite&a yuQ ccvx&v, rtoxe cpi^exat xb xtvovxcct
,

rtotr\6o(iev

71 72 73

~ adv. dogm. IV 87. ~ adv. dogm. IV 93. 103104. ~ adv. dogm. IV 94. 105107.

12 y.ivovv T (quod se movet): ayvm&ovv ML: di&oiv EAB 13 xQoncov T (modorum): xgonov Gr 26 otixe T (neque): oftxs 6h G 2 <^xai^> (isxacpsQstv T (et circumferre)! duo tenet loca T

TII0TTn&2EN

I\

155

iv

xco

itQcoxco

xortco

s6xtv

r)

oxe sv xco Ssvxsqco.

aXX

oxs

Sev(isv iv xcp TiQcbxcQ xoTtco s6xtv , ov (nexeQyexcct eig xbv xsqoV ext yctQ iv xco %qcoxco s6xiv' oxs Se ovx s6xiv iv

ov (isxiQxsxai d% avxov. %Qog xco xat 6vvccQ%d- 74 s6&ai xb r}XOV[isvov' iv co yaQ (ir) S6xiv, ovSs ivsQyslv iv avxco Svvaxat' ov yaQ Sr)%ov cpSQS6&ai sig xiva xoitov 75 6vyycoQr\6t xtg ixuvo d%Xcog o (ir) StSco6t xtvet6&at. xtveg (tevxot xdxetvo cpa6tv' xd%og Xeyexcct 8t%cog, 6 (iev iv
xovxco,

cog i(iov r) oixitt, 6 Se %Qog axo/jSftav, Xdyov %ccqiv 6 jteQtxexvitcoxcog (iov xr)v intcpaovetav xov 6co(iccxog dfjQ. Xeyexcct ovv iv xd%co xtvei6$at xb Ktvovfievov ovx iv xco %Qog aKQtftetav dXX iv tw Kccxtt itXdxog. %Qog ovg ev6xtv v%oStatQOvvxag xbv cbg

%Xdxet, olov

iv nXdxet xdnov Xeyetv^ oxt xovxov iv co (iev e6xt KVQtcog xb Ktvet6&at Xeydfievov tfcoua. cog iv xco %Qog dKQtfietccv ccvxov %d%co, iv co Se ovk liffTtv, cog iv xotg Xontotg (ieQe6t xov xaxd
TtXdxog xd%ov eixcc 6vvdyovxccg, oxt (ir)xe iv co k'6xt xoitcp Ktvei6&cci xt Svvccxat (irjxe iv co (ir) s6xtv, i%tXoyie6&at, oxt (irjde
'

iv xco Kaxd TtXdxog Kaxa%Qr)6xtKcog Xeyofisvco xditco Ktvst6&cct xt dvvaxat' 6v6xaxtKtt yaQ i6xtv avxov xd xe iv cp s6xt
o
|

TtQog dKQtfistav kccI iv co %Qog dKQt(5stav ov&sxsqco xivefc&ttt xt Svvcc^&at SeSetxxat.

ovk s6xtv,

cov iv

'EQcoxrjxeov Se xdxetvov xbv Xdyov. ei xtveixai xt, r]xot 76 xccrd xb TtQoxeQov (rtQoxeQOvy xtvetxai r) Kccxd u&qovv

(ieQi6xbv

Svvaxai
cTTTjua,

ovxe Se xaxd xb TtQOxeQov %QO%eQOv Ktvet6%at^ ovxe Kccxd xb a&QOvv (ieQt6xbv Stdcog Seil-0(iev' ovSs Ktvelxcci xt ccqoc. oxt (ikv ovv
6td6xrj(icc'

xt

Kccxd
i

xb

TtQOxeQOV

7tQoxeQOV

ovk
sig

ivSsysxai

xt

xtvsfc&at,

si (isv SfjXov. 6c6(iaxa xcd ot xoTtot xcct

avxd&sv

yaQ

anstQov

oi yjQovot otg

xs(ivovxat xd xtvst6&cct Xeyexcct

adv. 75 76~adv.

dogm. IV 95. 108110. dogm. IV 139141.

14 iv <p 15 Svvaxcct secl. Kayser 23 xb xvQtag xiv. Kayser 33 %qox. add. T (prius primo) 3 a>? dio(isv om. T

156
toc

IITPP&NEI&N
*3

6c6(iara f
xi iv

ov

yvr\6rat

xtvr\6tg,

dSvvdrov
,

ovxog xov

nq&xov
77 xai
xb

dndqotg ^q^&fjvat,
l

dcp

o<b

nqcoxov xtvr\6i

xaxaXf)yt xtvovfiivcov 6(ioicog xb nq&xov d(iqhg xov xonov xco nqcoxco iccvrov d(iqt (iXolov iqyjerat yqovco, ndvrcc xd xivov(ivcc 6xtv ieorccyjq^ 6 rccyvrarog tnnog xa\ r) yXcovr\' onq xov nqoxiqov
d(iqhg

xtvi6&at Xy6(ivov.

Sh

tfg

xa

nqotqr\(iivcc 9 xcct

xcc6xov xcov

i6xlv

dronc6xqov.
r)

ovx aqcc

xaru

to

nqorqov nqorqov
(iqt6rov Std-

yivrat

xivr\6tg.

dXX' ovSh xccrd to

d&qovv

78

rcov cpcctvofiivcov, tog cpcc6tv, fiaqrvqt6&at ra ttSr\Xcc %qf) 9 imi, Xva ng dvv6r\ 6raStaiov Su nqoxeqov avxov dvv6at xo nq&xov xov Sta6xr\(ia,
6rr\(ia. ei

ydq dno

exaSiov (liqog
oftxco
xcci

xcci

nccv xo

xo Sevxeqov Sevxeqov xcci xd dXXcc Ofioicog, xtvov(ievov xccxd xo nqoxeqov nqoxeqov

xtvt6&at

nqo6f)xet, xtvovfievov Xiyotxo ndvxa xa 6&at Xiyexat, iv n&6tv dfitt

xcci ei

insi

xoi

(iiqr\

d&qocog xov xonov iv

xotg

ei

Sttivat
co

xo

xtvei-

xo (ihv ipvyqov

ir\

nouixat xr\v xivr\6tv, r) Xvx6v co6X xcct %qcoetv xd ivxvyydvovxcc Svva6&cu, x6

ccvxov^ xov St ov fiiqog, xo Sh fteqfiov xo (iiv, t xvyot, fiiXccv, xo Sh

(iiq6tv

e6xat

( .

xtvov(ivov 6xat &eq(iov x tt(icc xcci ipv%qov xca (xiXav 79 xa\ Xevxov' oneq dxonov. elxa xcci no6ov d&qocog Stiet6i xonov xo xtvov(ivov, eindxco6av. el (xhv ydq doqt6xov

xovxov
6r\g
r\(itv

elvcct cpr\6ov6tv y

xr\g

ro (ihv ydq nqog dxqifieiav int%etqeiv oqi^etv tov ronov, o-S nXiov Std6rr\(ia ovSh xard to dxaqtatov Svvr\6erat SteX&etv to xivovfievov d&qocog,'

yr\g d&qocog' xo fiiye&og xov xonov.

ei

nqo6Siovxa xt xtvei6&ui Std ndSh xovxo cpevyov6tv, 6qi6urco6uv

nqog
elvat^

rco

dnoxXr\qcortx6v xa\ nqonerhg

rf\v

r)

xcct

tg

dqyr\&ev

dnoqiav

ifininret'

yeXoiov i6cog ndvrcc ydq

77 78

~ adv. dogm. IV 154. ~ adv. dogm. IV 124126.

EAB
11
&[t,eget

10 xccQ-' lixaozov malim ^(iiQst.y dfiegei

25
xvjrot

19 6ta8iov LT

jcara

AB Par. suppl. 133: xv%r\ MLE: contingit T om. EAB 2 t& MEABT (eum eo quod): tb L

(stadii) si

^&fieQety coni. Kayser, craSiaiov

:

MEAB
33

,
5
.0

TIIOTTnX!E&N

V.

157

sxaexov avxcov Sfioicog xaxd neQti6oxccyr\, stys coQt6fiivovg xonovg xag fiexccd6etg xcov xtvrfiecov noteixat. ei 8e cpf\6ov6tv, oxi (iixqov ftiv, ov Ttobg dxQifietav Se usq- 80 lC0Qt6fliv0V XOTtOV d&QOCOg XtVeiXttt XO XtVOVfieVOV, svs6xai
eexcct
r\fiiv

xccxd xr\v 6coQtxtxr\v

dnoQiav dsl
notovfiivcov

xco

vnoxe&ivxt
si

fis-

yi&et dxaQtaiov nQ06xt&ivat ttiye&og xonov.

6xr\6ovxai

fisv

yaQ

nov

xotccvxr\v

r\(icov

6vveQcoxr\6tv,

ndXtv
vtjv

sig

xbv dxQtr\ neQtOQt6fibv xui xr\v xsQaxsiav ixei-

Se nQ06r\6ovxcct xr\v naQavr\6iv, si ifi7ts6ovvxai' dvayxa60fiev avxovg 6vy^coQsiv d&Qocog xt 8vva6&ai xtvr\drjvai Std xov fieyi&ovg xr\g yr)g dna6r\g. co6xe ovSe (xaxdy

15

a&QOvv
ei

(iSQi6xbv Stdexrjfia xtveixat xd xtvei6&at Xeybfieva.

fiSQi6xbv xbnov fir\xe xaxd xb 81 xtvsixai xi, ovSs xtvsixai xi. itQoxsQOv (jtQoxeQovy Tccvxa fisv ovv xal sxt nXeico xovxcov cpa6iv ot xr\v Se fir\xe xovg r)fieig fiexa($ttXLxr\v xivr\6iv dvaiQOvvxeg.

8s

ft/r\xs

xaxd

u&qovv

10

Xoyovg xovxovg ftr\xe xb cputvbfievov , co xaxaxoXov&ovvxeg ei6ayov6t xr\v vno6xu6tv rfjg xtvr\6ecog, Svvdfievot SiaXQinetv, o6ov inl xr\ dvxt&ieet xcov xe cpatvofiivcov xal xcov Xbycov, infyofiev neQt xov noxeQOv s6xt xivr\6ig r) ovx s6xtv.

iu

nsQt
avxco

ttv,r\6scog

xul

ftstco6scog.

Tco
25

8s

%Qc6fisvot

Xoyt6fico
r\

xal

nsQt

av%r\6scog 82

xs
xr)v

xal nsQi

fieico6ecog

iniypfiev'

yuQ

ivuQyeta

Soxei

vno6xa6tv
r)

8oxov6tv.
eig ftiye&og

eiedyetv, r\v ol Xoyoi 8taxQineiv ftiueut yovv' xb ccv^dfievov ov xal vcpe6xcog

avxcov

intStSovut nQ06r)xet, cog eiye sxiQco nQo6&i6scog ysvofiivr\g sxsqov r\vt),r\xivui xtg Xiyot, ipsv6sxat. insi xoi80 vvv r\ ov6ia ovSinoxs s6xr\xsv, dXX dsi Qsi xs xcci hioa
dvQ"
fft

sxiQag
xr\v

insi6%Qivsxcct,

xb

r\vt-r\xivcct

Xsyofuvov
dXXr\v
ei,

ovx
xr\v

nQoxiQav
dXX'

ov6iav
oXr\v

xai

fiezu

xavxr\g

nQ06xe%ei6u.v

exiQav.

&6neQ

ovv

Xoyov 83

6 (xuTdy

(iixqov

(poffoiffovrai?) 14 alio (iv ^pco?)

Kayser 8 eaTrjgtxrjv L 12 producent T xaxd add. Gen. 17 Jtpdr. add. Gen. 28 in 29 yevoftivr}g Bekk.: yivoftivr\g G

158
4

IITPP&NEI&N
XQvnf)yeog ovxog Sexunr\yy exeoov dyaycov xvg-

yuQW, vXov

rjv^rjxivuv xb xqlitr\fy Xiyov, tpev6exuv Svu xo oXov sxsqov slvai xovxo ixeivov, cOtco xul inv nuvxbg xov uvS-s6&uv
vXrjg dnoQQeov6r}g xul exiqag nQ06xi&exuv xb nQ06xi&e6&uv Xeyofievov, ovk uv avt,r\6iv xig evnov xb xovovxov elvuv, dXX* ij oXov 84 sxsqoC(o6iv. 6 Se avxbg xul nsQV xr)g (ievdo6ecog Xoyog'

Xeyofiivov,

xf)g

TtQOxioag

inev6vov6r\g,

si

yaQ (ir) vcpe6xoog oXoog ndbg av (levteube&uv Xiyovxo; %Qog Se xovxovg, ev r\ (iev (ieioo6vg yivsxav xaxd dcpaiQS6VV, 7) Se av"l-r}6vg xaxu nQ06&e6vv, ovSev Si l6xvv o%xe acpaiQS6vg ovxe 7tQo6&e6vg, ovxovv ovSs r) (isioo6vg ovSe
xb
r)

av!-r)6vg s6xv xv.

vfi

nsQv dcpuvQe6ecog xuv nQ06&i6eoog.

85
ev

"Oxv Se ovSiv i6xvv dcpaiQe6vg, ivxev&ev envXoyifrvxuv. cccpavQevxai xv dnd xvvog, r)xov xb i6ov dnb xov v6ov cccpavr)

Qevxav

xb

(ievov

xov

(ieiovog.

dnb xov iXu66ovog r) xb e'Xu66ov dnb xaxd ovSiva Se xoov XQonoov xovxoov dcpaioog

Qe6vg

yivexav,

nuQa6xf)60(iev'

dSvvuxog
xb

uqu i6xvv

r)
r)

dcpaiqe6vg.

oxv Se

xux ovSivu xcov nQoevQrj(iivoov XQonoov

,

dcpaiqeevg

yivexav

Sf)Xov

ivxev&ev.

dcpavQOVfievov
2

dno xvvog i(n,neQviye6&av yQr) nqb xr)g dcpavQi6eoog xa. 86 dcp* od dcpavQevxav. ovxe Se xb l'6ov iv xop v6oo neQiiyexav, ovov xd ? iv xovg ?' (ievov yaQ elvav Sev xb neQviypv
xi

xov

neQveyoviivov

xul

xb

dq?

oh

dcpavQevxai

nuvxeXovg uQ6ecog r) ovov xu *e!87 (ivy xovg nevxe' dnsficpuivev yuQ. Svu Se xovxo ovSe xb l eXu66ov iv xco (teifrvv. ev yuQ iv xovg el- neQviyexuv xu
xf)g

xov dcpavQOVfiivov, vva (iexd xv' xovxoo yuQ Svucpiqevv Soxev

dcpaiQe6vg'

xr)v

dq>uiQS6vv vnoXeinr\xui

ovxe xb

(ievXov

iv

xco

(ivxQOxiQop,

2.

nivxe

cog

iv nXeio6vv

6%e&f)6exav

iXu66ova, xal iv xovg nivxe neqvxu xi66uQU xuv iv xovg xixxuQ6v xu xqiu xul

8588

~ adv. dogm.
:

III

297307.

1 ixegov dyaydov xvg G: aliud aliucl differens aliquid T: aXXdaawv e. g. Apelt 23 bno\L%i\xuv G: corr. Bekk. 24 xovxm scr. xovxo G hoc T 26 iv add. T (in quinque) 29 xsxQ&6t G
:

TnoTTn2EN

r.

159
sl-st

,iv
)

xotg

xqigI xd

Svo
xQict

xcci

sv xovxotg
sv, cbv
l

xb sv.

ovv

rcc

'f

nivrs ri66ccQcc

dvo

6vvrs&ivroov yivsrut 6

nsvrsxccidsxa ttQt&(i6g, og iv rco didofiivov rov rb sXcc66ov sv

'

si-

nsQti%s6&at 6vvdysxccc

a'0(ioicog Ss xcci
fiivco

(isifovt nsQti%s6&ai. iv rco nsvrsxcciSsxcc roo sv roo ? i(insQts%orop

XQtaxovxccxuinivxs ccQi&iibg nsQti%sxcct xcci xarcc vnoa6tv uTCsiQOi. ccronov Ss t6 Xiystv aTtsiQOvg aQi&fiovg uroTtov uqu xcci t6 Xiystv, i(iTCSQii%s6&uc roo ?2j ccQi&fiip
6
' >

Ori SV TCO (tsi^OVt

c\(puiQov(isvov
&cpttiQSt6&at

7lSQli%SXUl

XO

s'Xu660V.

St

OVV

%Q1}
acjp'

xb

8$

dno rtvog
iv
rG>

fiiXXst,

nsQti%s6&at ovrs Ss to i6ov iv

(itxQoriQoo

sv

ixsivoo
fo*co

ov

tco

nsQtiysrat,

ovrs
roo

to

(isi~ov

ovrs

to

(itxQorsQOv sv

(isi^ovt,

ovSs cccputQsixut
si cccpaiQStrut

xt cctco rtvog. rt
cctco

Kui
(liQog
cctco

(ir)v
r)

rtvog,
r)

r)

oXov
cctco

cctco

oXov
r)

cccputQStxut
cctco

(tiQOg

cctco

(li^ovg

oXov

(jtiQOvg

oXov. oXov

(isv

ovv cccpatQSt6&ui Xiystv

rjxot 89>

>

oXov r) cctco (li^ovg ccTCS(icpatvst nQoSr)Xcog. Xsinsrat Xiystv to (tiQog cc<patQSt6&ut r)rot cctco oXov r) catb (iiotov yovv, ivcc ini UQtd-^imv Qovg' otcsq S6xiv ccxonov.
Sr)

6rrj6co(isv

rbv Xoyov xov

cccpatQSt6&at
cctco

6acpovg svsxu, s6xoo

Xsyi6d-oo
(iovdg.

Ssxdg,

xai

ccnb

ravrrjg

uvxrj

(tovccg

ovxs
ccTtb

oXr\g

xr)g

SsxdSog
fiiQOvg

tt<pttiQsi6&at
rr)g

ovv r) Svvaxut

ovxs
)

rov XstrtO(iivov
cog

rr)g

svvsdSog,

nuQu6rr)6oo'

ovxovv

SsxdSog, rovri6xt ovSs ucputQStrut.

yuQ r) (tovctg unb oXrjg cccputQStrut Tfjg SsxdSog, insi r) 90 dsxug ovxs sxsqov ri i6rt nuQcc rug dixu (tovddag ovrs ng r&v (tovddcov &XX' r) 6vviXsv6tg nu6&v r&v fiovddcov, dnb
si

sxu6rt]g
oXr\g

fiovddog

dcputQSt6&at

ocpsiXst

r)

(iovdg,

l'vu

dnb
(io-

acputQfjrui rf)g

dsxddog.

(idXt6ru

(isv

ovv unb

vdSog ovdsv dvvurut a<puiQSt6&ut' uStuiQsrot yuQ st6tv ul fiovdSsg, xui dtu rovro ovx ttcpcctQS&r)6sxui r) fiovug dnb
xr)g

Ssxddog ovxcog.

si

6s xui
rr}v

oir\

rtg

unb
sE,st

sxu6rr)g
(iiQr\
n)

r&v 91
(io-

(lovddcov

ucptttQSt6&ttt

(tovdda, dixu

88 (inde a xal

(irjv)

93 ~ adv.
28
Soir\

dogm. IH 308320.

3 (xaiy
14
Sri scr.:

u71siqoi

(et infinitt)

10 xal

rtvog om. MEAB

Scbr)

Sh

GT

(autem)

Bekk.:

160

IITPP&NEI&N
,

dXXd xat i%e\ vdg, Sixa Se e%ov6a (iiQr\ Sexdg e6xcct. Sixa ereqa (legtj dnoXiXetnxcct, cup cov dq>r\Qr\xtti xa xr\g fiovdSog Xeyo(iivr\g Sixu (iiQr\, e6xat xa Sixa etxo6t. dxonov Se Xiyetv xb %v Sexcc elvai xai xa Sixa e'ixo6t xa\ xb
ccSiuloexov xccxd

92 dnb oXr\g

dnb
(ihv

xr)g

yccQ

avxovg StutQei6&ut. ccxonov uqu xb Xiyetv SexdSog dcpaioelGd^at xr\v (iovuSu. aXX' ovSe xf)g vnoXetno(iivr\g ivvedSog aqxxtQeixat r) fiovdg' xb ofi xi dq> uqatQeixat ov (tivet bX6xXr\Q0v, r) Se
>

ivveug (iexd
(xivet.
xcci

xrjv

dXXcog,

dqcciQe6tv ixeivr\g xr)g (tovdSog bX6xXr\Qog inet r) evveug ovSiv e6xt nuQu xug

7]

ivvia (tovddug, ei (ihv dnb oXr\g uvxr)g Xeyotxo aq>atQei6&ttt (iovdg, ivvedSog dqaiQe6tg e6xat, ei Se anb (liqovg xcov ivvia, ei (iev anb xcov bxxco, xd avxd uxoitu axoXov&r\6ei,
ei

93

dnb xr)g i6ydxr\g (lovdSog,* StaiQexrjv elvat q>r\6ov6t (iovdSa, oneQ dxonov. ovxovv ovSe dnb xr)g ivvedSog uyutQeixat i) (iovdg. ei Se (if)xe dnb oXr\g xr\g SexdSog
Se
xr\v

dcpuiQeixut
r)

dnb oXov (if)xe dnb (liqovg ccvxfjg, ovSe fieQog (UQOvg aqpcctQet^&ai Svvaxcct. ei ovv (if)xe oXov anb oXov xt cccpcctQeixai (if)xe (liQog anb oXov (if)xe bXov unb
(liQOvg
(ir)xe

(liqog

dnb

(liqovg,

ovSe

dqaiQeixai
>

xt

dno

xivog.

94

'AXXu

xcci

r)

7tQ06&e6tg xcov dSvvdxcov

elvcct itaQ

avxoig
eavxco

vneiXr\nxut.

xb
r)

yuQ
xco

itQ06xi&i(ievov ,

q>a6iv,

r\xot

nQovnoxet(iivcp r\ xco il- d[iq>oiv 6vve6xcoxt" xovxcov Se ovSiv i6xtv vytig' ovxovv ovSe 7tQ06-

nQ06xi&exat

xi&excci xt xtvi.

otov yovv

e6xco

&og,
iavxf)

xat
(ikv

TtQO^xt&e^&o)

xoxvXrj.

r\x&

xt xexQccxoxvXtaiov 7tXf\xivt 7tQ06xi&exat'

yaQ ov Svvaxcct,
xov

inet

xb

(iev

7tQo6xt&i(ievov

exeQov

i6xt

7tQ06xi&exttt,
ii-

95

i6xtv.

dXX* ovSe
Ttcog

xco

u(iq>oiv,

ovSev Se eavxov exeQov xov xexQuxoxvXtaiov xai

xoxvXr\
et

xf)g xoxvXrjg'

ydq

ccv

7tQ06xe&eir\ xt xca (ir\Se7tco bvxt;

xf)

xui aXXcog, ei t<5 xexQaxoxvXtaia) xai

(liyvvxat

9496

cf.

adv. dogm.

IH 321325
32
&r.

326327.
om.

30 SsxugT
1 dividetur

(decas):

fiovugG

33

six.

EABT

24

hocvv$>

EAB

TIIOTTII&EE&N
xoxvXrj
7)

T.
eGxat

161
TtXr)&og

TtQOGxt&etiivr) ,

eaxoxvXiai~ov
xr)g

anb xov xexQaxoxvXtaiov xal

xoxvXr\g xai xf)g TtQOGtt-

ei 6e (lovco xco &e(iivr]g xoxvXr\g. xexQaxoxvXtaico TtQOGxiftexat r) KoxvXrj, inet xb TtaQextetv6(iev6v xivi 1'gov iGxtv

96

ixeivco
xvXrj

co

TtaQexxeivexat ,

xa xexQaxoxvXtaico
xb

TtXr)det

r)

xocog

TtaQexxetvotiivrj

8ntXaGtdGei

xetgaxoxvXtaiov

yiveG&ai xb itav 7tXr)&og oxxco xoxvXcov' oiteQ ov decoQeixat.

ei

ovv

(ir)te

eavxco

TtQOGti&exat

xb

TtQoGxid-eG&at
xco

Xeyo-

fievov
xcov,

(ir)xe

xco

itQovitoxeifiivcp

(ir)xe

aficpotv

xov-

TtaQa 8e xavta ovdev eGxtv, ov8e TtQoGxi&exat ovdev ovdevi.

ty
Tr\

neQt (lexa&iGecog.
97

TtQOG&iGecog xal xr)g acpatQiaecog xal xr)g zoTtixrjg xtvr)Gecog vitoGxuGet GvfiTteQiyQdcpexat xal 7] (iexd&eGtg (atixr] yccQ drto xtvog (tiv iGxtv dcpaiQeGtg xtvi 8e
8e
xr)g

TtQoG&eGtg (ieta^axixcog)y

neQt oXov xa\ (liQOvg. Kat xb oXov 8e xai xb (xeQog. xaxd (iev yaQ GvvitcY

98

XevGtv xa\ KQoG&eGtv xcov fieQcov xb oXov yiyveG&at 8oxei~f xax acpaiQeGtv 8i xtvog r) xtvcov itaveG&ut xov oXov elvat. xal dXXcog 8i, ei eGxt xt oXov, r)xot exeQov iGxt rtaQa xd
fiiQrj

(iev

avxov r) avxd xd (liQrj avxov <(to)> oXov iGtiv. exeQOv ovv xcov (leQ&v ov8ev cpaivexat xb oXov elvat' d(ii-

99

yovv dvatQOVfiivcov x&v (leQcov ov6ev vTtoXeiTtexat^ EVa ei 6e avxd %xeQov xt jtaQa ravra XoytGco(ie&a xb bXov. xd (liQrj xb oXov iGxiv^ ovoita eGxat (tovov xb oXov xat
Xet
r

nQOGrjyoQta xevf), VTtoGtuGtv 6e i6iav ov% e%et, xa&diteQ ov8e StuGxaGlg iGxi xt jtaoa xd 6teGxcoxa ov6e 66xcoGtg itaQa xd 6e6oxco(iiva. ovx uqu eGxt xt oXov. dXX' ov6e 100

98101
32 iertv

~ adv. dogm.
(esf):

III

338349.

Zorut

13

15 tb add. Bekk.; inter uvxov et oXov spat. unius lit. 17 &vuiqov(l4vcov T (ablatis partibus) quodiam Bekkerrestituit:
\aiQov(iiv(Bv

SXov^

LEABT
458,
3.

(totum):

Uov

M M

LE:

alQ0(iivcav
I.

MAB

cf. p.

22 ioxut
11

EAB

Sextug Empiricua

162
.
t

IITPPNEIN
i

yaQ e6xt (JteQr), r)xot xov bXov xavxd i6xt (xeQi) (iSQr &XXr)Xcov r) eavxov exa6xov. ovxe 8e xov oXov , inei r) xi naod xa (iSQr) (xai dXXcog xd (isqt) ovxcog (ir)8e s6xt s6xat (leor) savxcov, iitel sxa6xov xcov (isq&v 6v(inXr)Qcoxtxbv elvat Xeysxat xov oAot;), ovxe dXXr)Xcov, inei xb (isQog
ei

i(ineQisis6&at Soxet iv ixeivco o^

i6xt

i6xt

(iSQog,

xai

dxonbv

Xsyetv

xr)v

%eiQa,

ei xvjpt,

iv

xca

101

exa6xov savxov (iSQog s6xaf ei ovv (ir)xe Qioyr\v e6xat xi eavxov (ietov xai eXaxxov. xov bXov (if]xe eavx&v (ir)xe dXXf)Xcov (ieQr) i6xi xa Xeyoei Se (irjdevog i6xi (ieva elvai (teQrj, ovSevog i6xt (ieQr]. ovSe e6xt peQr)' xa yaQ itQog xi dXXr)Xotg 6vv-i fiiQrj,
ccXX'

ovSs

noSi nsQteis6&ai. Sta yccQ xr)v %e-

avatQetxat. Tavxa (ikv ovv aXXcog eiQrj6d-co xaxa naQex@a6tv, instSr) anal- oAov xai (ieQOvg ine(ivf)6&r)(iev.
te Tte^i <pv6ixr\g (aexa^oXf^g. Avv7to6xaxov 8e elvat Xeyov6i xiveg xai xr)v xaXovfievrjv

102

cpv6txr)v (iexaoXr)v, Xoyotg int%etQOvvxeg xotovxotg. ei (iexai6xt xb (lexafidXXov r) a6co(iaxov' exdfidXXet xt, rjxot 6to(id

103

xsgov Se xovxcov f)noQr)xat' dnoQog aQa e6xat xai 6 ne^i ei (iexadXXet xt, xaxd xtvag iveQxrjg (iexa@oXrjg Xoyog. StaxQenexat )> yeiag aixiov xai na6jov (iexa(5dXXet. <(

yaQ
104
(ir)

r)

eypv vnb

xov aixiov vno6xa6ig' co xb na6yov 6V(ineQixQsnexat oxov nd&rj. ovSe fiexafidXXet xt aoa. ei
xt,
rjxot

(lexafidXXet
(iev

xb

ov

ovv
xb

(ir)

6v dvvno6xax6v
co6xe

(lexafidXXet i6xt xai

r)

xb

(if)

ov.

xb
xt ei
r)

ovxe

na6yetv

ovxe
Se

Sqccv

Svvaxat,

ovSe

fiexafioXrjv

intSi'/sxai.

ov

(lexafidXXet,

r\xot

xaftb

bv i6xt

(texafidXXet

104105

cf.

adv.

dogm.

III

267268.

25 Ttegl AB 145, 1 %& yag 160, 20 om. T (vide p. XI) 2 7taQixaoiv L: 7tagi(i^a6iv M: %aqix%actv EAB 10 lacunam quam statuit Apelt sic fere explet <^o dSvva^ovy, melius fort. (0718Q ddvvarovy Pasquali, at malim ^xara (xsv ovv rivag 12 ivsQysiag akiov ov (is%adXXsty coll. p. 148, 8. 155, 13.
ante
el

inser. 8

TnoTTnssESN
t&b
(ir)

r.

163
bv
Se
e6xtv ,

ov e6xtv.
ovSe
ycco

xcc&b (iev

xafidXXet'

ovv ovx bv e6xiv'

(ir)

ov

(ie-

105

ei

na&b

bv e6xt

uexafidXXet, exeoov i6xt xov axoitov Se xb Xeyetv t6xat. ovSe xb ov (lexafidXXet. aga
(if)xe

ov elvat,

xovxeaxiv

ovk

ov

xb ov ovk ov yivee&cu' ovx ei Se (if)xe xb ov fiexafidXXet Se ovSev e6xt, Xeinexat Xeyetv xb 106 xai xavxd cpaei xtveg.

xb

(if)

ov, Tcaod xavxa

(iexa(5dXXet.
ext

bxt

ovSev

(texafidXXov ev xivi %qovco (lexafidXXetv bcpeiXet' ovxe Se ev xco 7taQco%r)KOxt yjQovco (lexafidXXet xi ovxe ev xco (ieiXovxt, dlV ovS' ev xco eve6xcoxt, cog 8eio(iev' ovk aQa
(lexafidXXei
xi.

ev

[itv

ovv

xco

7taQeXr)Xv&6xi

r)

(liXXovxt

XQOvco
xev,
)

ovSev

dSvvaxov

(lexafidXXet' xovxcov Se e6xt Sqccv xi r\

yaQ
iv
xcl

ov&exeQog eve6xr\xco
(ir)

%a6yetv ev

bvxi

v.al

eve6xr)x6xt %qovco.
yjQovog
t6cog

dXX*
[ihv

ovSe

ive6xcoxi.

yaQ 107
8e
8e

ive6xcog

xai dvvnaQxxog i6xtv,

d(xeQf)g

tva

touto

vvv

VTteQ&co^ie&a ,

e6xiv'
t

dSvvaxov

6e6xiv <^V> diieQei %q6vco vofiifeiv xbv 6iSr Q0v,

Tfy? 6nXr]Qoxr]xog eig

ei xvypt, ditb

(laXaxoxrjxa (lexaftdXXetv tJtcov

aXXcov

fiexa^oX&v
cpaivovxai
5

eKa6xr)v
yQr)etv.

yive6&at'
ei

naQaxa6ecog
iv
xco

yaQ

avxat

ovv

(if)xe

^oovco

(lexafidXXei

xi

(if)xe

ev

xco

(liXXovxi

7taQeXr}Xv&6xt iv xa> ((i>f)te

ive6xcoxt, ovShy fiexafidXXeiv xi Q~r\xiov. TtQog xovxoig, ei 108 i6xi xig (texafioXf), r)xot( g dnXona&eig et6iv,r) 8e )> ai6&rJ6ei
(lexafioXr)

6V(i(ivt)(i6vev6tv

eyetv

SoKei xov xe e ov tiexa-

xai eig o (texafidXXetv Xeyexat' ei 8e vor(tf) e6xtv, ene\ %eo\ xr)g vnaQ^ecog xcov vor)xcov dveitixQtxog yeyove itaQa xoig naXatoig Siacpcovia, xa&dneQ r)8r) TtoXXdxtg vne(ivr)6a(iev, ov8ev e%0(iev Xeyetv ov8e neQt xr)g vitaQ^ecog
fidXXei
xr)g (iexaoXf)g.

106107
$6x1

cf.

144145. (ad 107

cf.

adv.

dogm.

III

271 sqq.)

19

G: iGtat edd.
:

1 iv add. Bekk.

&axoxr)Tcc
:

EB

itaXxaY.6Tr\xa

||

dite^f\

(sic)

ufjxs

2 ualovde add.

6 (lETapdXXsiv Fabr. qui ov scripsit, quod correxit Pasquali Fabr. usTa(ldXXst Gr 1 Ttg EAB ti ML lacunam quam statuit sic fere explendam censet Bekker fjTot (al6&rjTf) Igtiv r\ vor\Tf). xai al6d-r]Tf) uhv ovx 6tiv ai (ihv ydgy aie&rjestg
:
||

11*

164
ts'

IITPP&NEI&N
Tteql yvi6scog
(ilv

xai cp&OQdg.
i\

109
xf\

ZJvfiTtEQiroijieTcd

ovv xai

yivs6ig xai
rf\

r)

cp&OQa

%Q06&e6ei xai

rf\

a<paiQe6ei xai

cpv6iY.f\

(israfioXf]' A

ovxe yevoixo av xi ovxe cpd-aQsirj, olov %(QQlg yccQ rovrcov yovv chtb xfjg SsxdSog cp&ELQO(iivr\g , cog cpa6iv, ivvsdda

yivs6&ai 6v(i(5aivEL xaxd dcpaiQE6LV (tovdSog, xal rr)v SexdSa dnb xrjg ivvsdSog cp&LQO(iivr\g xara nQ66d"E6iv xfjg (tovdSog, xai xbv lov dnb xov yaXxov cp&siQOfiivov xara

&6XE UVaiQOVflEVOOV XCOV nQOSLQr\(livCOV XLvf)6EC0V dvaiQEfc&ai xai rr\v yivs6iv xai xr\v cp&OQav i6cog 110 dvdyxrj. ovSsv Ss r\rrov xivsg xdxslva cpa6iv. si iysvvr)Q"r\ EcoxQarr\g, (r\xoi} brs ovx r\v EcoxQaxr\g iysvsxo 2JcoxQarr\g,
HEXa(5oXfjv.
r\v r\Sr\ ysysXiyovto, ysysvr\(iivog' si Ss oxs ovx xal ovx r\v. r\v, afia xal r\v 2coxQaxr\g r\v (isv xco ysxal si dni&avs 111 yovivai, ovx r\v Ss xaxd xr\v vn6ds6iv.
r)

oxs r\v

r\Sr\

2coxQttxr\g.

dXX'

si

(isv

oxs

vf\6&at,

8lg

ccv

ei'r\

2coxQarr\g, r\xoi oxs st,r\ dni&avev r\ oxs dni&avev. xal oxs (isv s%r\, ovx dni&avsv, insi 6 avxbg av xal sr\ xal ixs&vf)xsi' dXX* ovSe oxs dni&avev, inei Slg dv ei'r\ xe&vr\xcog.

ovx aQa dni&ave coxQarr\g.

icp

xovxov Se xbv Xoyov

rj

1.

cp&siQse&ai, yo(iivcov i6xdvxa dvaiQSiv xr\v yivs6iv xal xr\v cp&OQav. 112 svioi Ss xal oCFcn 6vvsQcorco6iv. si yivsxai ri, r\xoi xb ov

olov xi i6xiv

sxa6xov xcov yivsd&ai

Xs-

ovxs Se xb (ir) ov yiverai' rco yaQ yivsxai r\ xb (ir\ ov. bvri ovSev 6v(Lefir\xivai Svvarai, &6xe ovSe xb yi(ir\
ve6&ai.
dXX*
i6xi

ovSe

xb
r\

bv.

ei

xa&b bv
ijtsl

yivexai

xa&b
ei

yaQ yivexai xb ov, ovx bv i6xiv. xa&b

Se

r\xoi

(iev

ovv ovx bv i6xtv, ov yivexaL.

s'6xai

xa&b bv

i6xi yivsxai,

xb yivbfisvov exeQOv i exi^ov cpa6L yive6&ai, exsqov 1 xov bvxog xb yiv6(isvov, otcsq i6xiv ovx bv. xb

113 aQa yivofisvov ovx

ov E6xai,

ZnsQ

ansficpaivEi.

si

ovv

% 109 ~ adv. dogm. IV 323. 269. IV 346. 111 ~ adv. dogm.

III

112o*adv.

dogm. IV 326327. 113 114~adv. dogm. IV 344345.

23 28

ysvfj&r\

L 24

6 gcoxq.

post iysw.

EAB

||

r\xoL

add. Bekk.

tiTtbfreoiv.

(ofix

aga iyivsto 2coxQarr}gy E. Weber

xnoTTn&sE&N
(irjxe

r.

165

xaxa xd
5 rjroi

ov yivexat (if)xe xo bv, ovSe yivexai xi. el yccQ Se ovSe cpdeiQexai. cp&eiqexai xt, to 6v cp&eigexat rj xb (ir) ov. xb (iev ovv ovx ov ov
xb
(tr)

ccvxd

cp&eigexaf Tta6%etv yao

xb bv.
(tivov.
r)xot
xcci

xi

Set

ycco (livov iv xco ei (iev (livov iv xco

xb cp&etQOttevov. dXX' ovSe ov eivut cp&eiQexat rj (irj

d(ia xal ov xcci ovx bv i-rtel yccQ o ov i6xtv, dXXd xcc&b bv i6xtv, xa&b

ov eivut, e6xat xb ccvxb ov cp&eiqexat xa&b (ir) 114

(itev

icpdaQ&at Xiyexat,

exeQOv eGxat xov bvxog

xcct

Std xovxo ovx bv,

xu&b

Se (ii-

vov

iv

xco

elvttt

8e xb Xeyetv xb fievov iv xco elvat

15

cp&eiQecj&ut Xeyexat, ov eaxat. avxb elvut xcci ov xal ovx bv'

cpd-eiqexat

uxoitov

ovx

ccqcc

xb bv.
eig xb

ei
(ir)

Se ov

fiivov iv

xco

elvat xb

"ov

cp&eiQexcct,

dXX

elvat 7teQii6xccxcct
(ir)

tiqcoxov,

eld-'

ofixcog

cp&eiQexat,

ovxixt xb bv, uXXcc xb

elvat
vTte(tvi)6a(iev.

ov

cp&eiQexut'
(iijxe

oiteQ

dSvvaxov
(if)xe

ei

ovv
50

xb ov cp&eiQexat

xb

(tr)

6v, TtuQcc Se xavxa

xcov xtvf)-

ovSev e6xtv, ovSe cp9eiQexai xt. Tccvxa (ilv ovv cog iv VTtoxvnco6et xal

Tteqt

6ecov ccQxiset XeXeyd-cct, olg emxat xb dvvituQxxov eivut xul dvejttvorjxov xr\v xccxd xovg Soy(iaxtxovg cpvcftoXoyiav.
t'

TteQt (iovr]g.

'ErtOfievcog
r)noQr\6ccv
55 tcccv

Se xal TteQt xr\g cog TtQog xr\v cpv6tv (tovr)g 115 xtveg Xiyovxeg, oxt xb xtvovttevov ov (tevet,

Se 6co(icc dtuQxtog xtvetxat xuxu xug xcov doyftaxtxcov #* VTtoXr)ipetg, Qev6fi\v eivat Xeyovxcov xr)v ov6iav xat aei tttcpOQr)6etg xe xat TtQO^&edetg itotov (livrjv, cbg xbv
(ihv

nXdxcova

(cf.

54)

(irjde

bvxcc Xiyetv

xcc

6co(iuxu
v

ccXXu ytvofievcc (taXXov

5

xccXetv, xbv de

'HQaxXetxo

b^eitt Ttoxatiov
fiXrjg
(liveiv

Qv6et xr)v evxtvr\6iuv xr)g r)(iexiQag aTtetxd^eiv. ovdev uqu 6co(iu (tevet.xo ye (tr\v Xeyotievov 116
awv/e^&cci Soxet vrtb xcov
cf.

TteQt ccvxo

xb Se 6vveyp-

116

adv.

dogm. IV 246.

2 a(paigi6eis in mrg. L (cf. p. 146, 15), quod probat Kayser coll. p. 146, 15; at malim aitocpoQ^asis cf. p. 49,19.

166
fisvov nu6ysi' vne(ivf)6ufiev'

IITPP&NEI&N
ovSsv Ss s6xi nu6yov, insi ftr\8s uixiov, cbg ovSs fiivsi xi aqcc. iQcoxco6t Se xiveg %u\ xovl<

xb fiivov nu6ysv, xb Ss nu6ypv %ivslxut' xb aoa fiivsiv Xsyofisvov %ivsixai' el Ss %ivslrut, ov fiivei. 117 i% Se xovrcov cpaveoov e6uv, oxi ovSe xb u6cb(iuxov ivSiyexat fiivsiv. ei yuQ rb fiivov nu6ysi, xb Ss nu6ysiv 6co-

xov xbv Xoyov.

(idxcov

i6xiv iSiov,

sinsQ uqu,

%u\ ovyi u6cofidxcov , ovSev

fiivsiv,

Ss

u,6co fiarov

ovxs

nu6ysiv
%eo\

Svvarai ovrs

ovSsv

v.

uqu
118

fiivsi.

To6uvxa
6X0V X&V
voslxai,

fiev

%a\

fiovrjg

7tQ0SlQ7](lSVC0V

OVK UVSV

siQ^d-co. ins\ Ss s%aXOTtOV i) yQQVOV ini-

in\ rrjv neQt rovrcov 6%etyiv' iuv yuQ ravra SeiE,rj ng dvvno6rara, dvvno6rarov e6xui %u\ Sid xuvru i%eivcov e%u6xov. uQ^cofis&u Ss dnb xov xbnov.
fiexixeov
Iff

TtSQl XOTtOV.
Stycog,

119

Tonog xoivvv Xsyexui

%cog, %axuyQr}6xi%cog
Xig, KVQtcog
fiui

%vQicog

fiev

[chg] 6 iv

nXdxsi,

%u\ %axayQrj6xicog ifiov r) nboti

Se 6 TtQog d%Qifieiuv %uriycov, vcp

^rjrovfisv

neQiiyp25

nQog

d%Qifisiuv.

ovv nsQt rov xbnov (rov}

(isv
(isv

nQog

d%Q(,siav.

xovxov Ss ol

s&eGav, ol Ss dvsiXov,

120 oi Se ins6yov nsQi uvxov. cov ol

xsg in\ xr\v ivuQyeiuv %axacpevyov6iv.

vnuQyeiv uvxbv cpu6K0vxlg yuQ uv, cpu6i,

Xi^ete

sivai xbnov oqcov xd fiiQrj xov xbnov, fir\ olov xd Ssl-td xu uqi6xsqu, xu uvco xu kuxco, efinQO-' 6&ev bnl6co, %a\ uXXoxs dXXuyov yiyvbfievog, Xs- 30 ncov xe, oxi sv&u 6 vcprjyrjxrjg 6 ifibg S isXiysxo, ivxav&a iyco vvv S taXiyo (iai, xbnov xs Sid%ovcpcov cpv6si %u\ cpoQOv %uxuXufi(5dvcov rcov

120121

~ adv.

dogm. IV 712

(cf.

Aristot.

Metaph.

p.

983 a 26sqq. Phys. 208 b llsqq.)

(i

23 mg del. Bekk. 24/25 7ieQii%o(iui MEAB: 7ttQii%o L 25 TiQog &xq. secl. Kayser rov addidi xoitov secl. Bekk. 26 tovxcov EAB 28 uv om. MA 29 Xi&ie Kayser: li&i G 29/30 fort. (rd) ifMQ.^tdy^Tt.l 33 KutaXapovtwv M (slvui} tcav Kayser
||
||

||

TII0TTn2E&N
v cpv6et (iaQecov,
ext xal

V.

167
dxovcov 121

xcov aQ^aicov

eyovxcov
eivat

yuQ nQ&xu %dog iyevexo'. eivut uq <pu6t %dog xbv xonov dnb xov %coQr)xt%bv avxbv
*r)xot fihv

iv avxcl yivofievcov. etye fir)v e6xt xi cpa6iv, e6xt xal 6 xonog' dvev yuQ xovxov a ovk av ei'r) xb 6cofiu. xal ei e6xt xb vcp ov xai xb e6xi %al xb iv co, o%eQ i6xlv 6 xonog' xb 8e ij 0-5,
xcov
5

6cofxu,

St

xb uqu SevxeQOv iv aficpool 8e avaiQOvvxeg xbv xonov ovxe xa fieQrj 122 xeQOig. xov xonov 8i86a6iv eivai' fir)8ev yuQ elvai xbv xonov naQU xd xovxov (iSQr) xu\ xbv 6vvdyeiv netQcofievov, oxi

xqcoxov iv exaxeQco'

15

xonog ix xov xa (ieqt) avxov cog ovxa \afii3dveiv , xb t)xov(ievov 6V eavxov xaxa6xevdetv fiov\e6&ai. bfioicog 8e XrjQeiv xal xovg ev xtvv xonco yive6&ai xi r) yeyovevat cpa6xovxug, oXcog (ir) 8i8o(ievov xov xonov. 6vvuQnd^etv 8e avxovg xal xr)v xov 6c6(iaxog vnuQ^tv fir) 8i8o(iivr)V ov xal xb vcp ov 8eixvv6&ai dvvnaQxxa avxo&ev xal xb
e6xtv 6
i',

nuQunlrfiicog

eivai XQixr)v xcov

xd
20

eig

fir) d^toiQecov 123 xal ovxco 8taxQov6fievot cpilo6ocpiav. xaxu6xevr)v cpSQOfieva xov eivai xonov, r\8r) xal

xco

xonco.

xov xe

*H6io8ov

xaxd

notxtkcoxeQOV xuxu6xevdov6iv, oxi dvvnuQxxog i6xt, xatg ififiQi&eexeQaig eivut 8oxov6utg xcov Soyfiaxtxcov 6xa6e6i

neQi xov xonov nQ06%Qc6fievoi, rjj xe xcov Sxcotxcov xal xcov IIcQinaxrjxixcov, xbv XQonov xovxov.

xr)

Oi Excotxoi
85

(Stoic.

fr.

II

505

A.) cpa6i xevbv fiev 124

,

eivai xb otov xe vnb ovxog xaxe%e6d at

Se,
r)

fir)

ti&fievov
6xr)fia

8td6xr)(ia

eQrjfiov

6c6(iaxog,

xuxe%68tdr)

dxu&exxovfievov
122123

vnb

6c6fiuxog,

xonov 8e

124

~ adv. IV 1319. ~ adv. dogm. dogm. IV 3

4.

1 axovoa
del.

5 lexat edd.

8 fort. 7/8 dwyoTEQOtg EAB: uiupovEQCov ML Kayser (ovte uvtov tov xoitov oiSts^ add. post xoitov 16 to <^to^ i Bekk. dub. avvnuQXTu EAB: uvvnuQXTOv ML 17 te G: dh 21 ifiQL&atEQais G cf. p. 65,11. 15. 18. 20. 27 et Gen. 22 rfj alt. om. L saepius: ifi^Qt^EGtuxutg Bekk.
||

7 iv ixuxiqco et lv aiupoTiQoig

168
Stdaxr\(ita
xco

nTPPSNEI&N

vnb ovxog xaxe%6(ievov xui itaa6(iexaxe%ovxt avxov, vvv 8v xaXovvxeg xb atofia, icboav Se Stdaxr)(ia xaxd (iev xt xaxe%6(ievov vnb acbfiaxog xata Se ti dxu&exxovfievov,^ ivicov %coQav einovxcov elvai tbv xonov xov (ieydXov acb(iuxog, cog iv (ieye&et tr)v StucpOQuv eivut 125 tov te xonov xal xf)g %cbqag. Xeyexat ovv, oxt inetSr) Sidvov

6tr)(ia

vnb
xal

acbfiaxog

xaxe%6(ievov cpaaiv elvai

xbv xonov, d

ncog
(ifjxog

Xeyovatv

avxbv
7)

elvai

Sidaxrj(iu;
7}

noreqov
ftovov

t6
r)

xov acbfiuxog

to
ei

nXdxog
(iev

to

(id&og

yuQ fiiuv Stdaxaatv, ovx i%tadexat 6 T07tog xco ov xonog iaxiv, nobg xco xal fieoog xov neqie%o(ievov to 7teoie%ov elvut, navtdnaaiv dnefi126 cpaivei. ei Se al tqevg Staaxdaetg, inel ovxe xevbv vnotdg
XQeig
Staaxdaetg',

xeitai iv t<5 Xeyofievco xonco oftxe dXXo a&fia Stdaxuatv s%ov, (i6vov Se tb iv tonco Xeyofievov eivat atofia ov 6vvkatr\xev ix xtov Staaxdaecov (eaxt ydo tovto (ifjxog xai

nXdtog xui (id&og xal dvxtxvrtia,

r)

Sr)

av(i(5sf}r}XEvut Xe-

yeTai xuig Staaxdasat talg rtoosiQrjtievaig) , auTo to atofiu saxut suvxov xortog, xal to avtb rtSQte%ov xal neoie%6(ie-

ovx &Qa eaxt rtg Stdaxuaig tonov vov, oneg dtonov. 127 vnoxeifievov. Std Se totJto ovde eaxt xt 6 xortog. iqcoxaxat cVe xal ovxog 6 Xoyog. inei StrtXai al Staaxdaetg ov
decoQOvvxat xa#' exuaxov xcov iv xortco elvat Xeyofievcov, dXX %v (irjxog xal ^v nXuTog xui %v (Id&og, rtOTeQOv (iovov

tov acbfiatog eiatv ai dtaatdaetg avtat r) fiovov tov tonov r) d(icpoteQcov ; dXX' ei (iev (tovov xov TOJtov, ov% e%et tb atofia tStov (if)xog ovSe nXdtog ovSe (lu&og ov&ev, cbate
128 ovSe acb(ia eaxat xb acowu, oneQ dxonov. ei Se dficpoxiQcov, irtei xb xevbv ovSefiiav vrtoaxaatv e%et rtaQa xdg Staaxdaetg, ei ai Staaxdaeig ai xov xevov vnoxetvxat iv xco acbfiaxt

21

avaxaxtxai ovaat avxov xov acbfiaxog, xd xov xevov avaxattxa xai xov acbfjtaxog eatat avaxaxtxd. neqi pev
xr)g

yuQ

vrtUQ^ecog xfjg

dvxixvrtiag ovx eaxt Stafisfiatcbau-

0$ G: 8 Pappenh.

9 (i6vov Pappenh. et Apelt coll. 11 r) drj L

p. 62, 1. 574, 13: (tivov

TII0TTn2E&N
6&C at,

V.

169

50
!
i

s'(inQ06&sv vns (ivr)6a (isv ( 45sq.)* Sta6xa6scov cpatvofiivcov xaxd xb Xsy6(isvov (lovcov 6co(ia, airtSQ sicJi xov xsvov xcci ai avxcci xcp xsvco, xsvbv S6xat to 6cb(ia' oitsQ dxonov. si 8s fiovov xov 6co(iax6g si6iv al Stcc-

xa&dnsQ
8s
xcov

si
/ jM

6xu6stg, ovSs(iia l'6xai Sia6xa6tg xonov, StonsQ ovSs o xonog. xotvvv xax ovSiva xcbv nQOStQr\(iivcov XQoncov svqi6hsxai xonov 8ia6xa6tg, ovSs s6xiv 8 xonog. JtQog xovxotg 129
Xiysxat, oxt oxs snst6t xco xsvco xb 6co(ia xal yivsxai xonog, vnotiivst xb xsvbv r) vno%coQsi r) cp&siQSxai. dXX si (isv vnotiivst, xb ccvxb s6xat xai jtXfJQsg xai xsvoV si Ss
VTtoycoQSi

r\xot

5
j

xtvovfisvov (isxafiaxixcog r) cp&siQSxat (isxafidXXov, 65)(ia s6xai xb xsvov' 6co(iaxog yaQ iStd s6xl xavxa xd nd&rj. axojtov 8s xb avxb Xiystv xsvbv xcci nXrjQsg, r)

10

uxonov aoa xb Xsysiv otov xs 6co(iaxog xarao^s-frijva'. xcci ysvs6&at xonov. 8id 8s xavxa xcci xb xsvbv dvvno6xaxov svq(6xs- 130 xat, siys (ir) Svvaxov s6xtv ccvxb xarao^CtHjvat vnb 6co(iaoxi
6cb(id

s6xi

xb

xsvov.

slvat

xb

xsvbv vnb

xog xai ysvs6&ac xonov'

xs

sXiysxo

yuQ xsvbv slvai o otov

6v(iitSQiXQSTtsxai

vnb
xai

6co(iaxog
r)

xaxa6%s&rjvat.
sixs

8s

xov-

15

yaQ 6 (liyag xonog S6xi %coqu, xco xonco, sixs r) xccxd (isv xi vnb 6co6v(i7tSQiyQacpsxai (taxog xaxs%0(iivr}, xccxd Si xv xsvr\ Sta6xcc6tg, d(i<poxoig
%coqcc'

xsQOig 6vvavaiQsixai. Taura (isv ovv xai sxt nXsico nQog xr\v 6xu6tv xcov Hxcotx&v 131 nsQi xov xonov Xsysxcci' oi Ss HsQinaxr\xixoi (cf. Aristot.

Phys. 212 a 6) cpa6iv slvai

i%ovTog, xu&b nsQts%si,

xonov xb nsQccg xov nsQicog i(iov xonov slvai xr\v

xr\v

snicpdvsiav xov
S(nco 6couccti.

deoog

nsQixsxvnco(isvr\v

xco

dXX sinsQ xovxo s6xw 8 xonog, xb avxb xai

s6tcci.

s6xai xai ovx

15

oxs yttQ (liXXsi sv rvvi xonco yivse&at

(irj

to 6cb(ia, xad"b (isv ovSsv Svvccxai ysvi6d"cci iv xco

129 adv. dogm. IV 2123. 131 cf. adv. dogm. IV 30

vnuQ-

1 ante Ttgbs lac. exst. in Q 5 xLvov(tsvov Bekk.: xsvovfisvov G10 $td-~ 12 x6nov bis EAB: om.

tcsqI

xsvov
slvoci

ML
Gen:

i.

mrg.
ieri

170
ypvn,

IITPP&NEI&N

8el rtQOVrtaQyEiv rbv rortov, Tvu ovrcog iv uvrcpyivrjrt to 6&fiu, kuI 8ia rovro i6xui 6 xonog noiv iv avxco ysveG&u, to iv tgo ro7t(o 6co(ia. kcc&o de rtQirvrtov(iivr)g ttjj rov rtEQL-

iypvrog irticpuvEiug
vrto6xr)vcci 6 xoTtog

rtQiyo(iivcp UTtoxsXurui, ov dvvuxui nob xov iv uvxco yevia&ca xb 6co(iu, xul

tc5

Siu xovxo ovk E6xui xoxs.

rt
Kcci
(ir)

elvui'

uxoTtov 8\ xb uvxb XiySLv Kui elvul ovx uqu i6ri rortog rb Ttiqug rov rtEQi-

132 iypvxog, xu&b

6 xortog, r)xoi TtEQtiyEL. Ttqbg xovxoig, eX i6xi ovv ovk (iev yevvtjxog i6xiv r) uyivviqrog. uyivvr\xog 6tiv' TteqixvTtovfievog yuo, cpu6iv, tco iv avtco 6co(iati
UTtoreXelrui.
r)toi
cUA,'

ovde yevvrjrog'
i6ri to
6co(jlu,

ore iv ronco

cb r]dr\

133 ovxe

Xiyetai eivut to iv ronco, r) 8\ oxe iv uvtco i6nv (J6ti

6

ei yuq i6xi yevvrjtog, rore yiverui 6 tonog iv ore ovx, i6nv iv avxco.

yuq

rjdrj

tov iv uvtco

6cofi,arog ronog) ovre ore ovk i6xiv iv uvxco, eiye neqirvnovxu.1 (tiv, cog cpa6iv, rco rtQLyp(iivco to rtEQiiyov Kui

ovrco yivErui rortog, rco 8\ fii] iv uvxco bvxv ovdev 8vvaxui rteQixvrtco&rjvai. ei 8\ [ifjxe oxe iv xortco iexi xb 6cb(icc, oxe ovx i6xiv iv uvxco, yivexui 6 rortog, nuQcc 6e (if)x tuvtcc ov6ev k'6nv irtivouv, ov8\ yvvr)tog i6xiv 6 xortog.
ei

6e

(irjtE

134 kolvoxeqov

yevvrjxog i6xi (if)te dyivvrjxog, ov8e e6xlv. 61 Kui xuvxtt SvvttXtti Xiy6d ui. el i6xi
,

b
i

rortog, r]tot 6co(id i6ttv

urtOQetrui, cog 6 rortog Qog.

EKutEQOv S\ rovrcov u6co(iutov' Kcci 6 tbrtog V7te(ivf)6u(iev' uqu i6riv urtor)

urtOQog
Kcci

rtQog xco 6co(iaxi voeixat, ov e6xi tortog' 6i i6xiv 6 Tteqi rf)g vnuQ^ecog tov 6co(iuxog Xoyog' 6 rteqi rov rortov ccqcc. 6 rortog Kcc6rov ui6iog (iev
i6xtv,
(ir)

ovk
135

yiv6&UL

6e XEyojiEVog

c\vvrto6XttXog evQi6Kxai

yvi6Ecog

"Eve6xi

vrtaQ%ov6r)g. 6e Kixi aXXcc

nXdco Xiyuv.
irtuKxiov,
oxi

uXti

Tvu

(jLr)

xbv

Xoyov

(ir\Kvvco(kv ,
(ikv

ekelvo

8v6torti r) ivttQyetu. 8i6rtQ ov&erEQco 7tQ06rL&i(i&a o6ov irti rotg XEyo(iivoig vrtb rcov 8oy(iarLKcov , clXX* irtiyo(iev neQi xov xortov.

ivrQ7tov6L

ol

Xoyoi,

rovg 6e Kui

6KrtxLxovg

28
XoyoL?

tS>

om. edd,

10

rc5

xoitco

24

fort.

ovtol oi

TnoTTn&ZEN
l&
TtE

r.

171

Ql XQOVOV.
kccI

Tb
^r\x{)6sc'

8h

ccvrb

na6yo(isv
(isv

sv
xoig

Tr)

jtsgl

xov

%q6vov 136
Soxsi

060 v
6

yccQ

sni
8s

cpaivo(isvoig
jieqi

xi

slvai

yoovog,

ogov

sni

xoig

fisvoig

dvvno6xaxog
8t,a6xr)(ia

cpaivsxai.

ol Se

(isv

xr\g

xov
ol

%qovov yccQ oXov Kivf)6ecog

avxr\v
xr\v

avxov Xeyoslval cpa6iv

(oAov

Xsyco

xbv

ko6(iov),

8s

xivr)6iv

iccQid-fibv

xov K06ftov, AQi6xoxsXr)g Ss, r) cbg xivsg UXdxcov, xov sv %ivr\6si tcqoxsqov xai v6xe-

jpov, Sxqccxcov Se, f) cog xivsg l4ot(>TOTX^g, (ietqov 137 xt,vf)6scog xal (iovf)g, EnixovQog (p. 126, 12 Us.) Adxcov cpr)6i, 6v(inTco(ia 6 xa&cog 8s, drj(ir}TQiog 6v(i7tTco(iccTcov, TtaQ sno (isv o v r)(iSQat,g te xai vvt^i xal cooaig xai nd&eet, xai ana&siaig xai Kivr\6sKai fiovaig. kut oveiav te ol (isv 66b(ia wvtov 138 i 61 scpa6av eivai, cog ol ne^i tov Aivr)6i6rj(iov (ur)8ev
i

yccQ

avTov 6uccpQEiv tov ovTog Kai tov tiqcotov 6co(xaT0g), ol 6s cc6co(iaTOV. i\toi ovv 7tcc6ai al 6xa6Eig avTai si6t,v aXridsig, r) nd6at, tysvdsig, r) Tivsg (ihv dXr)d sig, Tivsg
,

8e

ipev8eig'

ovxe

8e

nd6ai

aXr\%sig

vnaQyeiv

SvvavTai

\\

((idyovTai yccQ al nXei6Tai) ovte nd6ai tpev8sig slvai 8od"r)6ovTai vnb tcov 8oy(iaTixcov. xai dXXcog' si So&sir} ipEv- 139

8og
to

(iev

slvat,

to

6cb(ia
,

elvai tov %qovov,

ipEvSog 8e Kai
r)

(f

OTt a6co(iaTog e6Tiv

dvvTtaQ^ia' ovxs qov.

naQa yaQ
Tivsg
(isv

avTO&ev do&rjaexai xavxa ovSev elvai

si6iv

xov yQovov Svvaxai sxsSh

ipEvSsig

dXr)9sig,

Tiveg

SvvaTov KaTaXafisiv 8id te Tr)v i6o6&svrj Siacpcoviav xai ttjv dnoQiav ttjv xaxd (rby KQiTr)Qiov ts xai Tr)v cxtcoSeiIiv. &6ts 8icc TauTa ovSsv %0(iev tteoI j;oovou 8iaat,co6a- 140 6&ac. sha, snsi ovk avsv xivr)6Ecog r) Kai (tovfjg

136137

~ adv. dogm. IV 170.

17

176. 181 (ubi singulis

placitis continuo additur

88 138

~ adv. dosrm. IV 216.

Bekk.
:

&vriQQr]Oig). 219. 228.

31
Gen. et

8)>ov et o>lov

corr.

14 to om. L

2 (iovf)g %q6vov et %q6vov G 11 fort. y&Q c^&kXrjlaigy ? 18 t6 addidi t^v tert. om. EAB
:

(tovrjg

MLEB
||

172
6

IITPP&NEI&N
vcps6xdvui Soxsi, xr\g xivr\6scog dvuLQOV(iivr\g, xui xr\g (iovr\g, dvuiQStxui 6 %Qovog. ovSsv Ss
cpaai xiveg

iqovoq

bfioicog Ss

r\xxov xai rdde

xuxu xov

yjQovov.

ei

iaxl <(w}>

141 iQOvog^

nsnsQu6xav r\ dnsiQog e6xiv. dXX' ei (ikv neniQU6xut, dno xivog iqqvov rjQt-axo xai el'g xiva iqovov Siu Se xovxo r\v noxe %Qovog, oxe ovx r\v %Q6vog Xrfeei' xov UQ^ua&ut avxov), xui s6xut noxs %Qovog oxs ovx (jtQO
r\xoi

S6xut

%Qovog

142 xoivvv
xb (iiv

ov ((isxd xb Xr)t),ai avxov)' onsQ dxonov. ei Ss nsnsQu6xut b jjQovog. unstQog i6xtv, insi xi uvxov Xsysxut nuQcp%r\x6gy xb Se ive6xcog, xb Se
6 nttQcoyr\xcog r\xot ei6lv
r\

(ieXXov, b (liXXcov xui

ovx

ei6iv.

dXX

ei

ovx

to"/v,

fiovov

xov ive6xcoxog vnoXetnofievov,

og i6xiv dxuQtutog, neneQu6(jtevog e6xut 6 iQovog xui dxoXov&r\6ov6tv al d.Qir)&ev dnoQiuf ei Se b nc(Qcop\xcog s6xt J xai 6 fieXXcov s6xtv, ivs6xcog s6xat sxdxsQog uvxcov. dxoTtov

Sh xb

Xsystv ivs6xcoxu xbv

nuQcpjr\%6xu xui xbv (isX6

Xovxu %qovov"
Sh
(ir)xs

ovxovv ovSs dnstQog i6xiv

(if\xs

uneiQog

nsnsQa6(isvog,

ovSs

ei %Qovog. s6xtv oXcog

143 iQovog.
i6xiv
r\

xui yuQ
eig

ei s6xtv 6 %Qovog, r\xot (iSQt6xog d(iSQt6xog (iev ovv ovx i6xiv d(iiQt6xog' StatQStxbv ivs6xcoxu xui sig xbv naQcoyr\x6xa xai si'g xs

nQog xovxotg,

dXX ovSe (iSQi6rog. xbv (LsXXovxa, cog uvxoi cpu6tv. sxu6xov yuQ xcov (jlsqi6xcov xaxufiexQetxui vno xivog euvxov exu6xov fieQog xov (jtexQOVfievov ytvofievov fieQOvg, xu&
6 Ss cog oxuv SukxvXco nr)%vv (isxqco(isv. ov Svvuxcct xuxu(isxqsi6&ui vno xivog suvxov (is%QOVog QOvg. si yuQ 6 ivs6xcog Xoyov %uqiv xuxafisxQSt xbv nuQcoxbv nuQcpyr\x6xa xui Std xovxo yr\ttsvov, s6xut xuxd xui ini xov (isXXovxog bfioicog (isXXcov. xui nuQcpyrjxcog ,

xov fiexQOvvxog,

(tsXXcov

nuQcpyr\xcbg,

xai

xuxu(isxQoir\ xovg uXXovg , ivs6xcog s6xui xui xui b naQcpir\xcog nuQunXr\6icog (isXXcov s6xui ovxovv ovSs (j,SQi6xog ive6xc6g' oneQ dns(icpuivsi.
si

141142 rv adv. dogm. IV 189192. 143~adv. dogm. IV 193195.

xi

23

addidi

coll. p.

155,

9.

2 <<?>

^trrat

EAB

TIIOTTnEN
iv.

I\

173
ovSh eGtiv.

si

Sh

(irjTS

dfiiQtGTog
TQtfiEQr)g

fir)TE

(isQtGTog,

re

%QOvog Xiysxat

sivut,

xa\
cov

to

fihv 7taQCp%r)-

144

6 (ihv 7tuQCpir\xcog xut 6 fiiXXcov ovx siciv ei yuQ sict vvv o te TtaQcoyr)xcog xa\ 6 fiiXXcov %QOvog, EGtut ivsGtcog sxaTEQog avrcov. sGTtv 6 ivsCTcog %QOvog, si yuQ aXti ovSh 6 ivsGTcog'
xcog, to
r\TOi

Sh ivsGTcbg, to dk fiiXXcov.

iCTtv'

dfiiQtCTog dfiiQtCTog iCTtv r) fiSQtarog. iv yaQ tco ivsCTcoxt %q6vco XiysTat

fihv
tcc

ovv ovx
fiSTu^dXcoCte
(ieqi-

XovTa [iSTafidXXsiv, ovShv Sh iv dfiSQsi %q6vco ftETa^dXXsi,

3

olov 6 aiSr)Qog sig fiuXuxoTrrrtt r) tcov dXXcov sxccCtov. ovx iCTiv dfiiQiCTog 6 ivsGTcog jQOvog. dXX ovSh
CTog'
rr)v

145

sig

ivsCTcoTug

fihv

yuQ ovx dv
xoCfico

fiSQia&sir)

iitsl

Stu

o^stav
xal

qvCiv

t&v iv

dvETtivorjTcog

ivsGTcog

sig
:f

7tttQCoyr)xoTa fiETadXXstv XiyETat'

dX ovS

sig

nuQcpto

%rjxoTa
fiiv ti

fiiXXovTa'

sCTut

yuQ

oftTcog

dvvTtuQXTog,

bv. (irjxiTi ov Eycav fiiQog euvtov, to 8h fir\8inco o&sv ovSh riXog tov 7taQcoyr\fiivov xal dQ%r) tov fiiXXov- 146 TOg slvut SvvccTcct 8 ivsCTcog, inst xal ECTat xa\ ovx sarat.
i

sarut fihv [ovv]

cog

ivsGTcog,

ovx eGtul Sh inst

fiSQiGtog
iCTtv.
si

fir\

sgtiv
firJTE

uvtov tu

(JtSQr).

ovxovv ovSh

Sh

dfiEQtCTog icxtv o ivsGTcog (itjte fiSQtCTog, ovSh sGTtv. fir) ovTog Sh tov ivsCTtoTog firjdh tov 7taQcp%r)(iivov firjSh tov
fiiXXovtog, ovSi
)

icri Tt %Qovog' to yuQ e dvvTtuQXTCov GVVSGTCOg UVVTtUQXTOV iGTtv. AiySTat xutu tov %qovov xdxstvog 6 Xoyog. si sgti 147 IQOVog, r\xot ysvr)tog icrt xa\ cp&uQTog r) dyivrrxog xcct acp&aQTog. dysvrjTog fihv ovv xut ucp&UQrog ovx iCTtv,
sXys

uvtqv to
fiiXXstv

fihv

to Sh

cp&uQTog.

ovSh ysvr)Tog xat 148 tu yaQ ytvofisva sx Ttvog ovTog yiyvsG&at Sst
xa\

7tuQCp'ir)xivut XiysTut dXX* fir)8i7tco slvat.

xu\

firjXSTt

slvat,

144145

146

~ adv. IV 197199. ~ adv. dogm. dogin. IV 200202.

M

147 148~adv. dogm. IV 203205.

32 avsTtivorjrcog Kayser: txitEQtvorJTcog G 31 ivE6Tcoxa (xociy ovxwg 5 ovv del. Bekk. coll. p. 146, 27; fort. yuq 9 ?<srai M rt om. L ccwTcdQxrcov Kayser: ccwndQXTOv 6
fort.
|| ||

174
%ai

IITPP&NEI&N
i

xd cp&etQOfieva

ei'g

xt

ov

cp&eioeG&al

%axd xag x&v

vov cpdeioexat,

ei ovv eig xbv 7taQcop]fiov% ov cp&eiQexat, %ai ei i% xov fieXXovxog yivexat, e' ov% ovxog yivexat' ov&exeQog yaQ avx&v e6xtv. axonov 8e xo Xeyetv xi i% ov% ovxog yive6&at xb fir] ov cp&eiQe6&at. ov% ixQa yevr\xbg %al cp&aQr) eig

8oyfiaxt%&v

avx&v

V7to&e6etg.

eig

xog

i6xtv

6 %Qovog.

ei

8e

fif)xe

dyivrjxog

%ai acp&aQxog

l6xi, fjLtjxe

yeviqxbg %al cp&aQXog, ovde oXcog e6xiv.

149

JJQog xovxotg, inei Ttav xb ytvofievov iv %qovcq yiyve-

6&at 8o%et, ei yivexai 6 %QOvog, iv %qovcq yivexai. r)xot ovv avxbg iv eavxco yivexai r) txeQog iv exeQco. dXX' ei
fiev

avxbg iv eavxcc,
yccQ

xb

inei

xb

iv

co

xi

yiyvexai
6

avxb %ai e6xat %ai ov% e6xat. xov iv avxco ytyvofievov

3

bcpeiXet
fiev

7tQ0V7taQ%etv,

yivexai,
co6xe
ei

ovdenco

e.6xtv,

ytyvofievog iv eavxco %QOVog, ei ei 6e iv eavxco yivexat, r)8r]

dXX*

150 e6xtv.
exeQog.

ovde yivexai iv eavxco.

%ai
ei

ov8'

iv

exeQco
fieXXcov
i.

yaQ 6 ive6xcog iv
iv

xco fieXXovxt

yiyvexai,

e6xat

iveexcog,

xco

naQcoyr]%6xt, naQcop]%cog.
iqovcqv.
co6xe

xd

8e

avxd Xe%xiov %ai ne^i x&v dXXcov

ovde exeQOg iQOvog iv exeQco yivexai iqovcq. ei 8e firjxe avxbg iv eavxco yivexai fir]xe exeQog iv exeQco, ov8e yevr\xog i6xiv o iQOvog. idei%vvxo Si, oxt ovSe dyivr]xog i6xiv.
fif)xe

ovv yevrjxbg

cov

fir)xe

dyivrjxog
yevrjxbv

ovS'
r)

oXcog

e6xtv'

e%a6xov
7iQ06r)%ei.

yaQ x&v

ovxcov

r)xot

dyivt]xov

elvat

151

% TteQi dQl&flOV. Enei 8e 6 %Qovog So%et fir] dvev aQt&fiov d ecoQet6d at, ov% dv eir\ dxonov %ai ne^i aQi&fiov (JQayia Siel-eX&etv. o6ov fiev yaQ ini xrj 6vvr]&eia %ai d8o!-d6xcog aQt&fietv xi cpafiev %ai aQt&fibv elvai xt d%ovofiev' 6e x&v r) %ai xbv %axd xovxov %e%ivr]%e Xoyov. 8oyfiaxt%&v TteQteQyia
,

149150

~ adv.
:

dogm. IV 206211.

29 a^ro Bekk.
alt.

cb

G 32

Gen.

\lr\de

ovSe Stephanus:

otite

7 firjxe

I
;

TIIOTTm22EN

V.

175

uvxi%u yovv ol dnb xov Uv&uyoQOV %ui 6xotf^sZu xov 152 KOGfiov xovg UQt&(iovg slvut Xsyov6tv. cpu6t yovv, ort
xcc

cputvottsvu
eGxi

s'%

rivog 6vvs6xr\%sv, unXcc 8e

slvut

8sZ

xcc

6xotysZu'
(iev
j

u8r\Xu

uqu
cog

EGxl

xa 6xotyeiu.

6co(iuxu,
cbg

fiuxu,

6%r](iaxa

ol uxfiol %ui iSeut

8e u8r\Xoov xcc %ul ol by%ot, xu 8h uGcoxcov

%ui

uQt&(ioi.

cbv

xd

6vve6xcbxu e'% xe tir\(iev 6cS(iuxu %ovg %u\ nXdxovg %al fid&ovg xul dvxtxvniug r) %ul (SccQOvg (cf. Epic. 276 Us.). ov (iovov agu uSr\Xu,
&6xt 6vv&exu,

dXXu %ul a,6co(iaxd s6xt xd 6xotysZa. dXXd %ul xcbv u6co- 153 s%u6xov int&ecoQov(ievov eyet xbv uql&(h,6v' r) (idxcov yuQ ev s6xtv r) Svo r) nXsico. Sl cbv 6vvdysxut , oxi xu
6roiyeZu rcbv bvrcov ei6lv ol uSr\XoL %ul u6co(iuxot %al nccxe 6iv ent&ecoQOV(ievoi uQt&(ioi. %ul ov% unXcbg, &XX r\ fiovug %al i\ %axd sjti6vv&E6iv xr\g fiovdSog yivo(isvr\

?o

doQi6xog dvdg, r\g %uxu (isxov6iuv ul %uxu (iSQog ylyvovxui SvdSsg SvdSsg. 1% xovxcov yuQ %ul xovg uXXovg ytve- 154

xovg eni&ecoQOVtievovg xoZg aQL&(ir\xoZg, xbv %o6(iov %uxu6%evde6&UL Xeyov6iv. xb (iev yuQ 57 6r\(ieZov xbv tr\g (jtovdSog sneysiv Xbyov , xr\v Se yQU(i(ir\v xbv xf]g Svddog (8vo yuQ 6r\(isicov (isxu^v &ecoqsZ6&ul xuvSs smcpdvsiuv xbv rf\g xQiddog (qv6lv yuQ slvut xr\v), xr\v
%al
5

6&uc UQi&(iovg,

cpuGi xr\g yQU(i(ir\g sig nXdxog %si(isvov), xb Ss 6co(iu xbv

sn
xr\g

uXXo

6r\(isZov

xsxQuSog'

i% nXuyiov enuvu6xu6iv

yuQ yiyve6&ui
%ul
oftxco

xf\g

xd xs

6co(iuxu

sntcpavsiag sni xi 6r\(xsiov vnsQ%st(ievov. %ul oXov xbv %o6(iov uvstdcoXo- 155

10

notov6tv, ovxtvu %ul dtot%sZ6&ai cpcc6t %uru uQ(iovt%ovg Xoyovg, xbv rs Std xe66uqcov, og E6xtv snirQtrog, cbg syst nQog ru *s% xu 6%xco, %ul xbv 8tu nsvxs, og s6xtv r\(itoXtog, cbg syjet nQog xu 11), xu svvsu, xul xbv dtu nu6cov, og l6xt
8tnXu6tog,
&>g

s%st

nQog xu ^| xu 6co8s%u.

xuvxd xt ovv 156

153 cf. adv. dogm. 1 104. adv. dogm. I 99100 adv. math. 154 155ooadv. dogm. I 9697 IV 283.

IV 45.

15 Toti IIv&. Bekk. r&v TIvQ'. G 19 ul &xo\loi Pappenheim coll. p. 527, 7 23 &ga ML: ydg EAB 29 uoQiaxog Fabr. &Qi6tog G: om. Stephanus 30 dvdSsg alt. om. M 5 tqiuSos EAB
:

176

IITPP&NEI&N

6vetQonoXov6tv, xal oxi ereoov xt idxlv 6 aQt&fibg naocc xd ccoi&tiiixcc xaxa6xevdov6t, Xeyovxeg oxt ei xb fwov xaxd xbv eavxov Xoyov i6xiv, ei xvyot, ev, xb cpvxov,inei (ir) ioxt
coov,

ovx

eoxai,

eV

l'axi

8e xai (xoyqpvxbv ev' ovx ccga xb

coov, <(cbg coov)>, v (TTtv, dXXd xaxd xi exeqov int&ecoQOVjievov e^oo&ev avxoo, ofi (nexeyet exa6xov xai yivexat 8t avxb ev. kccI ei xd ccQi&(ir}xd e6xiv 6 aQi&fiog, inet8r) ccvccQt&firjxol xai (56eg, ei xvypt, xai mnot, xai j3og xai tnnoi eGxai 6 ccQi&fjLog, xcci Xevxbg avd-Qconoi aQi&iibg xai (teXag xcd yeven)xT]g , ei xvyptev xotovxot

&Qoonot ei6tv ol

2<

157 ovres ol

xd

xavxa 8i iGxtv dxona' ovx (iexQOV(ievot. eGxiv 6 ccQi&fiog, &XX' idlav vnoGxaGiv ccQid-nrjxa
r)v

aQa
eyev
ae

naQa xavxa, xa&

eGxt 6xot%etov.
Otixoog
xcc

xai int&eooQetxat xotg ccQt&firjxotg xai

ovv ixeivoov 6vvayay6vxoov , oxt ccQt&fibg ofix TtaQet6r)Xev r) xaxd xov &Qtd (iov &noQta. Xeyexat y&Q, oxt ei e6xtv ccQt&tiog, rjxot avxcc xcc ccQt&iirjxd iGxtv 6 ccQt&fibg r) exeQov xi naQa xavxa fijco8-fv' o-UTf 8e avxcc xd aQt&firjxd i6xtv 6 ccQt&fiog, cog
i6xt
,

ccQt&nrjxd,

30

158

ot IIv&ayoQtxoi, ovxe exeQov xi naQa xuvxcc, ovdev aQa 0*uv 6 aQt&(iog. oxt 8e vno(ivr]6o(iev' ovSev e^co&ev i6xt naQu xd dQt&firixa 6 dQt&pog, naQa-

ccnedet^av
oog

is~

6xr]60(iev

ini xr)g

fiovdSog xbv Xoyov

ei

6xr\6avxeg
eavxr)v

ev6r)(iov
r)

8tScc6xaXiag evexev.
r\g
(licc

yaQ e6xt
r)

xt

xa&

fiovdg,
5

(lexeypv exa6xov xoov (lexeyovxoov avxr)g yivexat ev, r)xot

e6xat

ccvxr)

r)

(tovdg

xo6avxat
iexiv,
avxfjg

o6a

xd (lexeypvxa
oXrjg
r)

ccvxr)g

i6xtv.

dXX' ei (iev

(ita

noxeQOV

avxr)g

(lexiyet

exa6xov x&v

fiexeyeiv

Xeyo(iivcov

avxr)g\
elg

ei (iev yaQ ncc6av eyet xr)v (iovdda, av&QConog , ovxext e6xat (iovdg r}g (le&etjet 6

fieQovg ei xvyot, 6
etg

tnnog

10

adv. 156 158162

dogm, ~ adv. dogm. IV 293298.

IV 285287.

adv. math.

IV 1113.

17 lac, quam stat. Gen. explevi: 16 xb add. Rustow xardxbv kavxov %6yov Gen. xa&b a>6v iartv Bekk. 20 ol del. Kayser 21 6 EAB: om. ML 22 &gt&(t,bs om. M (fors. recte) 23 ovxeg scr. Sexti variandi studium tv^ois' Gen. xv%oioav G 29 si om. respiciens coll. p. 102,3. 160,12: xvy%dvovxes G EAB 6 ttvxr) Gen. ccvxij G
:
: :

||

TII0TTn2EN
6
eig

T.

177
Xiyofxev eivai ev,

xvcov

r\

tcov dXXcov sxa6xov

xa\ noXX&v vnoxe&ivxcov yvfxvcov dv&Qconcov , evbg 159 Je 6'vtoj [fiaxLOv xa\ xovxo evbg d(icpia6a(xivov , yufivol iwvoCcfn/ of Aowtot xal ycoqlg ifxaxiov. el Se fiioovg avxr\g
X)67teQ
u.exi"/ei

exaoxov, nqcoxov (xev

eh,ei

eE,ei

fiioog

xi

r\

(xovdg,

xa\
elxa

a%eioa ye
&>g

fiiori,

eig

SiaiQetxai'

oiteo

dxonov.
Sid

xb

fiioog

xr\g

SexdSog,
xT\g
t

oiov

7]

Svdg, ovx e6xi Sexdg,

e6xai
(xovdg,

otixcog

ovSe

xb

(tioog

(xovdSog

Se

xovxo ovSe
fiovdg
r\g

(xe&ii-ei xi
(xexiy^eiv

xf g (xovdSog. co6xe ovx e6xi (xia r\ Xiyexai xd xaxd fiioog. el Se todoi&fioi 160

Tofg aQi&firjXotg, ecp' cov Xiyexai xb ev, al fiovdSeg ei6lv, wv xaxd (xexoyr\v exaoxov xcov xaxa (liQog Xiyexai ev,

dneiQoi

i6ovxav

ai (xexe%6(ievai

(xovdSeg.
r\

xal avxai r\xoi

(xexiyov6iv enavaefir\xviag (lovddog

(lOvdScov i6aQi&(icov

avxatg (xa\ Sid xovxo ei6i (xovdSeg) r\ ov (xexiyov6iV) dXXd ycoQig xivog (iexoyr\g f^ovdSeg ei6iv. (...)> ei (xev yaQ ycoQig 161 (xexoy T\g uovdSeg elvai Svvavxai avxai, Svvr\6exai xa\ xcov
ai6&r\xcov
ei

exa6xov %coQig (lovdSog

r\

(xexoyr\g

"v

elvai,

xa\

avxoftev neQixQinexai
(xovdg.

xa&

eavxr)v frecoQefc&ai Xeyo(iivr\

Se

dnb

(xexoyr\g

xdxetvai

(tovdSeg
iSiag.
r)

ei6iv,

r\xoi
(xev

(iiag (xexiyov6i na6ai r\ (iia exa6xr\ ncc6ai (iiag, r\xoi xaxd (liQog exa6xr\

xa\

ei

oXr\g

Xeyfor\6exai

xa\ (xivov6iv al aQ%r\&ev dxoniai' ti Se exa6xr\ 162 xa\ exeivcov xcov (xovdScov exa6xr\ (tovdSa eni&eooHSiag, Qei~6&ai Set, xa\ xatg eni&ecoQOV(xivaig exeivaig dXXag, xa\
(xexiyeiv,
(ii%Qi>g

dneiQOV.

ei

ovv

i'va

xaxaXd@co(xev,

oxi

eioi xiveg

xa&

eavxdg (xovdSeg, cov xaxa (xexoyr\v exa6xov xcov ovxcov e6x\v ev, Set xaxeiXr\cpivat dneiodxig dneiQovg vor\xdg (xovdSag, dSvvaxov Se xaxaXafietv dneiQaxig dnei^ovg (xovd-

Sag vor\xdg, dSvvaxov

xiveg
vor\xa\
(xexoxrjv

uqcc

e6x\v

dnocpr\va6&ai, oxt
bvxcov
ev.

ei6i
l

(xovdSeg
iSiag

xa\

exa6xov xcov
yivofxevov

e6x\v

ev

xaxd

(xovdSog

dxonov

aQa 163

xb Xiyeiv, oxi xo6avxai ei6iv ai (xovdSeg o6a xa (xexiyovxa

EAB

15 (xigog xi ML: xi (ligos (isvovaiv scr. (livovaiv G 26 excidit 8neQ 18 (xovdSos Stephanus: dexddog G dSvvccxov vel simile quid ydg G: ovv Bekk. dubit. 2 kxdaxr\ Bekk. i%a6xr\v G

14

||

Sextus Empiricua

I.

12

178
ccvxcbv.

IITPP&NEI&N
si
(irjts

Ss

(if)xs

(iia
y

sGxlv

f)

xu&

iavxrjv

Xsyo(iivr\

(tovug

to6uvtul o6u ru

s6nv

oXcog fiovug xud-

ccqi&iicov

sxaGrog

xu&

avrfjg iauv, ovSs iavrrjv. bfioicog Ss ovSe rcbv uXXcov iavrbv t6ruL' iQf)6&ai yuQ svs6uv
(istsiovtcc

ini Tcdvrcov rcbv ccqi&(icov rco Xoyco uXX' ini rr)g fiovddog rjQCOTr](iivcp.

nuQuSeLy(iuTLxcbg
si
(if)re
(if)rs

i6uv
d~(irjra

6
6

ccQi&nog,

cog

vns(ivf)6u(isv ,

vvv xa&' iavrov avra ra uql-

aQi&nog iariv, cog ot dnb IIv&ayoQOv nuQSarrj6av, naQu Ss ravra ovSsv e6ri, Xsxreov (t,r\8s sivai
cIqi&(i6v.

164
oi

Ilcbg Ss xai

k%co&ev
ors

ri

yivs6&ai cpu6iv sx rf)g fiovdSog rf)v SvdSa Soxovvrsg slvai rbv uql&(iov nuQu rd uql6vvri&S(isv fiovdSu stsqu (iovuSl, f)roi ralg (iovu6lv k'co&ev, dcpuLoeirui xi r) ovrs dcpaiQsiruL. dXX' cute TtQoeri&srai

&(ir]rd;

yccQ

itQ06Ti&STui

avrcbv, r) ovrs TCQ06riderai (ti) ovrs dcpuLQSLTUL, ovx t6rai Svdg. ovtc yuQ %coQig dXXf)Xcov ov6ul ai fiovdSeg el%ov rf)v SvdSa snL&ecoQOV^svrjv avraig xard xbv 1'Siov avzcbv
si (isv

dn

165 Xoyov, ovts vvv ri avraig ti-oo&sv nQ06yiyovsv, co6tcsq ovSh &6rs ovx t6rai Svug r\ d(pr)Qr\Tui xard rrjv Vn6&s6iv.
rfjg (tovdSog TtQog rr\v fiovdSa, (irjrs dcpaiQsoscog TtQo6&s6scog 's%co&sv TLvog ycvofisvrjg. si Ss dcpuiQS6ig yivsrai, ov fiovov ovx s6tul Svdg, dXXd xui (isicod-f)-. 6ovrai ccl (xovdSsg. si Ss nQ06ri&srtti avraig ei-to&ev r\
(irjrs

6vv&s6Lg

slvai

Svdg, iva ix rcbv (lOvdScov ysvrjrai Svdg, rd Svo Soxovvra riaauQa s6rui' vnoxsiraL yuQ (tovug xai irsQu (io-

vdg, alg nQO^Ti&Sfisvrjg e$co\?sv SvdSog 6 rs66aQa uqi166 &(tbg aTtorsXoLTO av. 6 Sk avrbg Xoyog xai sni rcbv aXXcav\

xaru 6vv&s6lv dTtorsXsi~6&aL Xsyo(isvcov. si xaru dcpaiQS6LV (Lf)rs xard TCQoo&saLv (if)rs dvsv dcpuLQiascog xai TtQ06&i6scog yiyvovrcu oi 6vv&stol Xsy6(isaQid-(icbv

rcbv

ovv

(ir)rs

voi
16tlv

slvai
r)

dQL&fioi

ix

rcbv

ysvs6ig

rov

xax

inava^s^rjxoTcov , d6v6Tur6g iSiav xa\ TtuQu xu uQL&(i)]xd

(e Platonis

164 165~adv. math. IV 2122

sumpta
)
:

PhaedonO'

96

sqq.

27 xl add. Bekk. 29 SvdSu Kayser fiovdSa G 30 m6nsQ Bekk. coaxs G lO&cTcovLEABiaOTwrM llsrapaBekk. tcsqIG
:
:

TII0TTn2EN
elvut

I\

179

6tv

Xeyofievov uQid-fiov: oxt 6e ovSe dyevrrtoi tvy/dvovbvxeg oi xutu 6vv&e6tv aQi&fioi, 6r\Xov6tv avxoi 6vvxi&e6&ai xe avxovg xui yiyve6&ut cpu6xovxeg ix x&v inuva(5efirjx6xcov ,

otov xi\g xe (iovd6og

xal 6vd6og
i6iuv
6

xr\g

doql-

6xov.
8e

ovxovv
xax

ov%
idlav
xr\v

vcpe6xr\xe

xux

firjxe

UQt&fibg

&ea)Qeixut

el 167 aQi9(i6g. iv xoig fir)xe xt

aQi&firjXoig

eyet

vno6xu6tv, ov8e e6xt

UQt&fibg

o6ov ini xaig nsQteqyiutg xaig vnb x&v 8oy(iuxtx&v et6evr\vey(ievutg. xo6avxa fiev xai jisqI xov cpv6txov xaXovfiivov
xr)g cptXo6ocpiag fieQOvg

UQXOvvxcog &g iv vnoxvnco6et XeXex&co.

xr)g q>tXo6ocpiug.
xr\v

xa
xe
i

JtSQt

xov Tj&txov fieQOvg

AeinexutSe xb rj&txov, oneq Soxeineqi

xuX&v xai xux&v xui dStucpoQcov xuxuyiyve6&ut.

8tdxQi6tv x&v 168 tva

ovv xecpuXutco8&g xai neqi xovxov dtaXdficofAev, neqi xr)g vnuQ^ecog x&v xe dyuft&v xai xax&v xai ddtucpoQcov t,r\xr\6cofieVj xr\v evvotuv exu6xov JtQoex&efievoi.
x/3

Jteqi dyaft&v xai xax&v xai d8 tucpoQcov. Oaeiv ovv oi Zxcotxoi (Stoic. fr. III 75 A) dya&bv 169 elvat dxpeXetuv r) ov% exeqov acpeXeiug, wcpeXetav 3 fiev Xeyovxeg xr\v aQexr\v xai xr\v 6nov8uiuv nqaatv, ov% exeQOv 8e oicpeXeiag xbv 6nov8aiov uv&qconov xai xbv cpiXov. r) fiev yuQ dqexr) ncog e%ov r)ye(iovtxbv xa&e6xr\xvia xai r) 6nov8aia nQu'E,tg iveqyetd xtg ov6a xax dqexrjv avxtxQvg e6xtv dxpeXeta, 6 8e >i6novduiog uv&Qconog xai 6 cpiXog ov% exeqog ibcpeXeiag. (ieQog (iev ydq xov 6nov6aiov i6xiv cocpe- 170 Xetu, xb r\yefiovtxbv uvxov vnuQ%ov6u' xu 6e oXu ovxe xd avxu xoig (ieQe6tv elvai Xeyov6tv (o-u yuQ 5 i6xiv o uv&Qconog ^eiq), ovxe ixequ nuQu xu * uvev yuQ x&v fieQ&v vcpe6xr\xev). 6t6(ieQr\ (ovx neq o&i exeQu x&v fieQ&v tu oXu Xeyov6tv. o&ev

168~adv. dogm. V
169171

~ adv. dogm. V 2227.

incipit

2.

20 inde a xoguvxu denuo

dgxovvxcog
i|

(cf.

(sufficienter)
^i]xr)6cofisv

aQKovvra

de)

26/27

LEABT

ad p. 145, 1) 21 25 (jtai) nsgl T (et

r\xr\60fisv

(queramus):

12*

180

iitpp&nei&n
c&g

xbv 67tov8aiov oXov bvxa

TtQog xb r)ye(iovLKov iavxov, ortEQ e<pcc6av cbqpiXeiav, ov% exsoov cocpeXeiag elvai Xiyov6iv. evxev&ev aal XQiy^&g xb aya&ov cpa6L

Xiye6&ai. xa& eva (iev yaQ XQOTtov q:aGlv elvai 10 ccya&bv xb vcp ov e6xiv mcpeXeiG&ai) o Sr) ScQyiKcoxaxov e6xi Kcci ccQexr)^ Kud exeQov 8e xatf o 6v(iftaivei &cpeXeL6&ai, cog i) ccQexr) Ktti ai kux ccQexr)v 7tQai),eig, kuxcc XQixov 8e xqotiov xb olov xe cocpeXeiv, xovxo 8e Kcci u,Qexr)v elvai Kcci <^xr)vy xccxcc ccQexrjvi* tcquI-lv xui xbv 67tov8uiov xcci xbv cpiXov, &eovg xe 15 xai 67tov8aiovg Sai(iovag, a>g xb (ihv SevxeQOv 6t](iuiv6(ievov xov ccyu&ov ifiTteQLXrjTtxixbv elvui xov TtQcoxov 6rj(iuLvo(iivov, xb Se XQixov xov Sevxi^ov 172 xai xov TtQcoxov. xiveg 8i cpu6iv (Stoic. fr. III 73 elvai xb 81 eccvxb uLQexov, uXXoi 8eW\ Arn.) ccyu&bv
171
,J

xb 6vXXa(ifiavov TtQog ev8uL(ioviuv r) xb 6v(i7tXr\qcoxixov' ev8ui(ioviu 8i i6xiv, cog oi Zxmxoi cpu6iv,

20

evQoia
173
xtti.

(5iov.
(iiv

Toiavxu
eixe

xiva

eig

xr)v

Se xb

cocpeXovv eixe xb

evvoiav xov ccyu&ov Xiye8l euvxb aiQexbv elxe xb

xig elvat Xiyoi, ovyi
xi xcov
25

xi e6XL

6v(ier(x6xcov avxcb Xiyei. OTteQ e6xi (idxaiov. r\xoi yccQ (iovco x& ccycc&<b 6v(ii@r}xe xu 7tQoeLQrj(iivu ?} xui exiQOig. dXX* ei (iev xui exiQoig, ovx e6xi yttQaKxr]Qi6xixcc xov aycc&ov xolvoTtoiovfievu'
ei

6vveQyovv TtQog evSaiiiovittv ccya&ov xb ccytt&bv 7tuQi6xr\6LV , dXXd

8e

(i6vco

xco

dya&w,

ovx

ivSiyexoci

r)(iag
30

174 dnb xovxcov voeiv xb dya&ov' cog yaQ 6 dvevvorjxog ltctcov ovxe xb %Qe(iexieiv xi e6xiv olSev, ovxe Sid xovxov Svvccxai eig evvoiav

iX&eiv

(iexiovxi evxvypi, ovxco

Lmtov^ (xuiy 6

ei
dicc

(irj

xb

(ir)

TtQOxeQOv LTtnco %QeeiSivai xb aya%bv

30. adv. dogm. 172 173 174~adv. dogm.

a

V35 39.

10 reputari T 14 xr\v add. Kayser 15 tcq&^iv EAB: ML 19 b 6vXXa(idvov G: collectivum T: 6vXlcc^iav6fievov Bekk. dub. coll. p. 551,25: 6V(iaXX6[isvov Kayser coll. 22 xtveg p. 97, 13. 163, 1: fort. 6vveQyovv coll. v. 24 lyov6i T (quidam dicunt) 24 quod cooperatur T 28/29 habentia communitatem cum aliis T 33 ovxa xal T (ita et); ovrcog G
TtQ&^Lg

TnoTTn&SESN
'

r.

181

^rjr&v xi i6xiv dya&ov, ov Svvaxai yiva6xeiv xo iSicog avxco xai fiovco vnuQyov, Tva 6V ocurov t6 dya&bv avxb vor)6ai Svvrj&r). rtooteoov yaQ Sei fia&eiv xr)v avxov xov

dya&ov
i

cpv6iv,

el&

ovxco

6vveivai

oxi

cocpsXei

xai

oxi

avxb aiQerov e6xt xai bxi evSai(ioviag noir\xixov. bxi Se 175 xd nQoeiQr\(ieva 6v(i(le(Sr\x6xa ovk eaxiv ixavd (ir]vv6ai xr)v
di

inivoiav xai xr\v cpv6iv xov dya&ov, Sr\Xov6iv 1'oyco ol SoyfiaxiKoi. cbg (iev yccQ cocpeXei xb ccya&bv xai oxi atQexov e6xi, naQo xai dya&bv eiQijxai xb oiovel ccya6xov (Plat.
o

412 C), xai oxi evSaifioviag e6xi noir\nx6v, ndvreg 6vyycoQOv6iv eQcoxcofievoi Se, xi e6xiv co raxira 6V(ie^r\xev, eig a6nei6rov i(ininxov6i noXepov, oi (iev ccQexr)v Xeyovreg, oi Se r)Sovr)v, oi Se dXvniav, oi Se dXXo xi.
Cratyl.
'

i'6cog

xaixoi ei ix
5

r&v nQoeiQrjfievcov oqcov iSeixvvxo xi i6xi xb aya&bv avxo, ovk av i6xa6iaov fog dyvoov(ievr\g xr)g xov-

xov q?v6ecog. Ovxco (iev ovv SiacpeQOvxai Jttol xr)g ivvoiag xov dya- 176 &ov oi Soxificoxaroi Soxovvxeg elvai r&v Soyfiarixcov' ofioicog Se Sirjvexd-^av xai ne^i rov xaxov, Xeyovreg (Stoic. fr.
(0

III

77 Arn.) xaxbv elvai

rb

(lXd(ir}v

r)
,

ajStfg, oi Se

6V eavxb cpevxrov

oi Se xb

ov% ereQOv (iXdxaxoSai-

fioviag noir\rtxov. oV cov ovyi xr)v ov6iav xov xaxov, dXXd xiva r&v 6V(i(5e(ir)x6xcov i'6cog avxco a>a6xovxeg eig xr)v
7tQoeiQr)(ievr)v i(ininrov6iv

dnoQiav.
177

25

Tb Se dSidcpoQOV cpa6i (Stoic. fr.DI 122 Arn.) Xeye6&ai (iev XQi%&g, xa& eva (iev xqouov ztQog o (ir]xe
yivexai, olov i6xi xb d^xiovg xovg a6xeQag r} xdg ini xr\g xecpaXfjg xqI%ag' xcO' exeQOv Se %Qog o bQ(ir) (tev rj dcpOQfii) yivexai, ov (taXXov Se TtQog xoSe r] xoSe, oiov ini Sveiv xexQaSQa%(icov dnaQaXXdxxcov, otv
eivac
adv. 175 adv. 176 177~adv.

$*0Q(ir) (ir)xe dcpoQ(ir)

~ ~

dogm. dogm. dogm.

V 4244 V 40. V 5961.

:

(ex Aenesidemo)

9 dyaatbv Fabr. coll. p. 553,4 (idem Plato): dycoybv GT 12 ac7teiatov Fabr. aniatov GT (incredibile) 15/16 (woii) tovtov T (ipsius eius) 19 (ol (ievy Xiy. Pappenheim
(agogon)

182

IITPP&NEI&N
i6.

Siy to ersQOv avr&v

ytverat
ju.fiAA.ov

cclqeiG&cci'

oQfir)

(iev

yap29<
30

rtobg rb cttoeiG&aL rb ereqov avrcov, ov Se nobg roSe r) roSe' xccra rqtrov Se tqo(ir)re

nov

dStdcpoQOv elvai rb (ir)re ngbg evSat%obg xaxoSatfiovtav 6v(iaXX6(ievov,i63 cog vyietav nXovrov' co ycco eGriv bre (iev ev, bre Se xaxcog ^pijcraa-frai, rovro dStdcpOQOV elvat cpa6tv, "jteql ov (idXi6ra iv rotg rj&txotg StaXacifidveiv XicpaGiv

(ioviav

178 yov6iv. rtva (livrot xai tceqi ravrrjg rr)g ivvotag Sei cpQOveiv, 8r)Xov ix rcov eiQr}(iivcov r)(iiv nsgt re dya&cov xai xaxcov.

Ovrco
rrj

(isv

ivvota

ovv 6acpig i6rtv, ort ovx ini6rr\6av r)(iag rcov nQoeiQrjfiivcov exa6rov' ovSev Se dnetxbg
10

nenov&a6tv iv dvv7to6rdTotg rdya nQay(ia6t 6cpaXX6(ievot. ort yaQ ovSev rfj cpv6et e6rlv dya&bv r\ xaxbv r\ dStdcpopov, ivrev&iv riveg intXoyi^ovrat.

179

xy el e.6rt Tt cpv6st dya&bv xai xaxbv xal dStdcpoQOV. Tb TtvQ cpv6ei dXsaivov na6t cpatverai dXeavrtxov, xat r) %tcov cpv6et ipv%ov6a na6t cpatverai ipvxrtxr), xal ndvra rd
cpv6et

xtvovvra

6(iotcog Ttdvrag xtvet

rovg xard cpv15

6tv, cog cpa6iv, e%ovrag. ovSev 8e rcov Xeyo(iivcov dyadwv 7tdvrag xivel cog dya&ov, cog vno(ivi)60(iev' ovx&qu e6n cpv6et

dya&ov.

ort

Se

ovSev

rcov

Xeyofiivtov

dya&cov

ndvrag

180 6(ioicog xtvei, 8r)Xov, cpa6iv. iva yag rovg iStcorag nagco(tev, cov oi (iev eve^iav 6co(iarog dya&bv elvat vo(iiov6tv,
oi Se rb Xayvevetv , ol Se rb dSrjcpayeiv , oi Se oivocpXvyiav, 20 ot Se to %Qr)6&at xvftotg, oi Se nXeove^iav, oi Se xai %etQco^0a. rtvd rovrcov, avrcov rcov cpt Xo6ocpcov rtveg (iev rgia

yivr\

cpa6iv elvat (Div. Aristot. 1[5])'

dya&&v, cog oi JleQtnarr\rtxoi tovtwv yaQ rd itev elvat negi

25

181 xai rd

tpvirjv a>g rag aQerdg, rd Se negi 6co(ia cog vyietav iotxora, rd 8e ixrbg cog cptXovg, nXovrov,
179

~ adv.

180181

dogm. ~ adv. dogm. V 4447.

6971.

73.

add.

1 6vXXa(i(3av6nevov ? cf. p. 558,21 EAB: fort. iartv T (manifestum est)

6 xal post df)Xov 20 a8Sr\qiayuv Gr

TIIOTTn&SEN
tcc

V.

183

xr\g Exoag XQtyiveiav 96 Arn.) elvat dyud^&v' xovxcov yccQ xd (iev elvat neQt tyv%r\v &>g xdg aQexdg, xd 8e ixxbg cog xbv GnovScciov xal <tov)> cpiXov, xd 8e ovxe neQt ipvxrjv o%xe ixxog, olov xbv GnovSuiov cog nQog eavxov' xd (livxot neQt G&(ia [r\ ixxog\, a cpuGtv oi ix xov UeQtndxov aya&d elvat, ov cpaGiv uyuftd. evtoi 8e xr\v r)8o-

nuQunXr)Gtcc.
Kal
ccvxoi

oi 8e

dnb

(iev

cpccGtv

(III

vr\v r\GnaGavxo

cog

dyadov, xtveg
coGxe

6e

dvxtxQvg elvai
si

cpuGtv,

xai xiva

xaxbv avxr\v x&v ix cptXo-

Gocpiag dvucp&iy^ccGd-ut *(iuveir\v (laXXov r\ r\G&eir\v.' xoivvv xd (ilv cpvGet xtvovvra ndvxug Sfioicog xtvei, ini 182 6e xoig Xeyo(iivotg dya&oig ov ndvxeg 6(ioicog xtvovfie&a,
ovSiv
icxt
cpvGet

xal yaQ ovxe naGatg xaig dya&ov. GxuGeGt ntGxevetv ivSiyexcct 8td xr\v (idyriv 7tQoexxet(iivatg ovxe xtvi. 6 yuQ Xiycov, oxt xr\8e (iev ntGxevxiov xf) GxaGei, xr\8e Se ov8u(i&g, ivavxtovpivovg xovg nccQtt x&v dvxt8o^ovvxcov Xoyovg ccvxcp eycov, (liQog yivexat (xr\gy 8tacpcoviag, xal xov XQtvovvxog ccvxbg 8er\Gexut 8td xovxo (iexd x&v uXXcov,

dXX

ov% exiQovg XQivei.

(irjxe

ovv XQtxrjQiov ovxog

Std

6(io-

xr\v Xoyov(iivov (if)xe dvenixQtxov xai neQt xovxcov 8tcccpcoviav, eig xr\v ino"/r\v xaxavxr\Get, xcct 8td xovxo ov% e$et 8iae^aiovGd-ui, xi iGxt xb cpvGet uyu&ov. UTto8ei,ecog

"Ext xuxeivo XiyovGi xtveg, oxt uyu&ov icxtv r\xot 183 xb utQeiG&ui ccvxb r\ ixeivo o aiQOVfie&a. xb (ikv ovv aiQetG&at ovx eGxtv uyu&bv xccxd xbv l'8tov Xoyov' ov yuQ dv iG7tev8o(iev xvyjeiv ixeivov o cctQovfie&a, tvu (ir\ ixneGco(iev xov ext ccvrb cctQeiG&at, otov ei dyu&bv r\v xb dvxtnoietG&at noTOv, ovx av iGnev8o(iev noxov xvyeiv' dnoXavGavxeg yaQ xovxov xr\g uvTtitoir\Gecog avxov uitaXXaxxoxut inl xov rtetvr\v bfioicog xat int xov iQ&v xal (te&u. x&v uXXcov. ovx ttQa xb uiQeiG&ut 8t ccvxb atQexov ioxtv,
el
(ir)

ye

xccl

6yXr\Qov'

xcct

yaQ

itetv&v GnevSet (iexu-

183184

~ adv. dogm. V 7984.

30

28 xbv addidi
8
rfjSe

LEAB:

xf\

r)

rf\g

ixrbg vel r) del. Apelt 24 eiye add. Bekk.

3 ind L
(if\

184

IITPPNEIN

M
ix

Gjuv xqocpr)g, oncog dnaXXayr\ xfjg 184 6ecog, xai 6 iqcov ofioicog xai 6 Sttpcov. xdv iaxt xb dya&ov. xovxo ydq r\xot
r\

xov netvr)v oyXr\-\ dXX' ovSe xb aiqe'e%coftiv

iaxiv

r (icov
t

neqi rjfiag. dXX ei fiev e^co&ev r\ficov, r\xot notet neqi r)(iag a6xeiav xivr\6tv xai dnoSexxbv xaxa6xr\fia xai dya6xbv ndftog, r\ ovSaficog r\fi&g Siaxid-t\6tv. xai el fiev ovx
ecfxiv rjfitv

nqbg
6xr\fia

xb

dya6xov, ovxe dya&bv e6xat ovxe indl-exat aloeiG&at avxb ovxe oXcog aiqexbv eGxai.
neqi
r)fiag

r)fidg
ei

Sh

yivexai

xi

dnb

xov

ixxbg

nqo6r\veg

xaxd-

xal d,6(ievtGxbv nd&og, ovyi St eavxb aiqexbv eGxat xb ixxog, dXXd Std xr)v neqi r\(iag in avxco ytvofxe185 vrjv Std&eGtv' coGxe ov Svvaxat xb St avxb aiqexbv ixxbg
eivat.

dXX
ei fiev

ovSe neql
r\

r\fiag.

r\xot

ydq neqt 6&fia eivat

r)

Xeyexat

fiovov

neqi rpvyr)v

(i6vr\v

neql

dficpoxeqa.
rjficov'
;

dXX

neqt Gcbfia fiovov, ixcpevt,exat xr)v yv&Gtv

rpvyf\g

ydq at yvcoGetg eivat Xeyovxat, xb Se Gcofia dXoyov elvai cpaGtv oGov icp' eavxco. ei Se xai fieyqt xr)g rpvyr\g
xrj

Staxeivetv Xeyotxo,

xr)g ipvyf)g dvxtXrjipet

xal xco xavxrjg

dyaGxco nd&et Soxoirj dv aiqexbv elvat' xb yaq xqtvofievov cog aiqexbv xr) Stavoia xqivexat xaxd avxovg xai ovx 186 dXoyco
iGxiv.
Gcofiaxt. Xeinexat Xiyetv, oxt

neqi rpvyr\v fi6vr\v xb dyal

&6v iGxtv. xaixovxo Sei^

r)

ydq

tpvyr)

xdya

xai vndqyet, oGov icp' ahg ineXoyt6dfir\v iv xco neqi xqtxr\qiov Xoyco (II 31 33). ncog <?' dv &aqqoir\ xtg iv ixeivco xt yive6&at Xiyetv, 187 o fir) xaxaXafifidvei', tva Se xai xavxa naqaXeincofiev, ncog dqa xai Xiyov6tv iv xr\ rpvyr) xb dya&bv yive6&at; ei yovv

XiyovGtv dSvvaxov xai dvvnaqxxog iGxtv' ei Se otg XeyovGtv ov xaxaXafifidvexat , xacov oi doyfiaxtxoi
fiev

Enixovqog iv

r)Sovr)

xrjv rpvyr]v, inei xai ndvxa,

xi&exat xb xeXog xai cpr\6t eij dxoficov 6vve6xdvat,

185 186~adv. dogm.

fort. (xf\s

V87 89.

1 yivexai aagxbgy xivr\(Siv coll. p. 48, 32. 3 avxm MAB avxb LET (ad ipsum) 6 r) 9 kavrco T (in hsqI dfLcpoxsQa del. Kayser coll. p. 166, 7/8.

29
:

(fit)

iyyivexai

se)\

kavxb

19

itaQaleiitcofiev

ML:

naQaXinoftsv

EAB

TII0TTII&2E&N

T.

185

ncog iv dxoficov 6coqco Svvaxbv r)Sovf)v yiyve6&at %ai 6vynaxd&etiiv r) kqi6iv xov xoSe fiev aiQexbv elvat nai dya&ov,
25

xoSe 8e cpevKxbv Kai xanov, dfif)yavov eineiv.

k8' xl

l6xiv

r)

Xeyofiivr] xiyvt] Tteol iov.

5a

HdXtv ol ZxcotKoi (Stoic. fr. II 96 Arn.) neol tyv%r)v 188 dya&d cpa6tv elvat xi%vag xtvdg, xccg aqexdg' xi%vr\v 8e elvai cpa6t (Stoic. fr. I 73 Arn.) 6v6xr\fia in
KaxaXf)tyecov

6vyyeyv(iva6fiivcov, xdg Se KaxaXf)ipetg yiyve6&ai Tteoi xb rjyefiovtKov. ncog ovv ev xco avxovg vnaQyovxt, nvevfiaxt %ax 9*r)ye[ioviKcp,
80

ivano&e^tg yivexat
cog

KaxaXrjipecov

Kai
xe

a&oorffibg
ivvof)6at,
avxf\g

xo6ovxcov
ttjj

yevi6&at

vofiivrjg

xvnco6ecog

xiyyryv, ov% dei xf)v

olov

intyt-

nab

dnaXetcpov6r\g,

66xai

inei yyxdv xe i6xi xb nvevfia Kai i% oXov Kivefc&ai XiyeKa& eKa6xr\v xvnco6tv. xb ydg xf)v HXdxcovog dvei- 189 8coXonoir]6tv Xiyetv intSeKxtKf)v eivat Svva^&atxov dya&ov,
cpy\fii

8e

xf)v

kq&6iv

xf)g dotd-fiovg, xiXeov Xr]Q&8ig i6xtv. o&ev ovSe ne^i vjvyr\v eivat Svvaxat xb dya&ov. ei Se fif)xe xb atQefc&at avxb dya&ov 190 i6xi, fif)xe iKxbg vnoKetxat xb St avxb atQexov, fif)xe ne^i
6cofid

ov6iag Kai

xfjg dfieoi6xov %ai ft,eot6xf)g ftaxioov cpv6ecog Kai xavxov, r) xovg

i6xt

fif)xe

ne^i tyvyjy,

cog ineXoyt6a\xr\v ,

ovS' oXcog

e6xt xt cpv6et
10

dya&ov.

Atd Se xa nQoetQrjfiiva ovSe KaKov xt e6xt cpv6et. xa yaQ exiQOtg SoKovvxa elvat KaKa, xavxu exeQOt Sicokov6tv cog dya&d, oiov d^iXyetav dStKiav cptXaQyvQiav aKQa6iav, xa
iotKoxa.

o&ev

ei

xa

fiev

cpv6et

ndvxag

bfioicog
bfjtoicog

15

nicpvKe Ktveiv, xa 8e Xeydfieva elvat Kaxd ov ndvxag Ktvet, ovSiv i6xt cpv6et KaKov.
'Ofioicog

8e ovS' dStdcpoQov i6xi xt <pv6et Std xf)v ne^i 191

L 26 rivdg, xdg dgsrdg G: algsrdg T (artes 1/2 dveiStoloitoiriGiv G: ymaginum ydeas simula2 itt8exri,Y.y]v LT (susceptibilem) iTttdsiiiriKr)v tionem T MEAB 4 r) om. L 8 firjSs Bekk. dubit. 16 ovS' dStdq>OQOv
23
fjSovr)

eligibiles)

T
xf\

{nec indijferens): ov Sidcpogov

||

rt

ML: om. AB

in ras.,

[|

Ttsgl

om.

(aliquid):

186
x&v dStacpoQcov

nrpp&NEiaN
166 Stacpcoviav.

nQor\y(iiva ovxs drtOrtQOr\y(iiva, n QOr\y(iiva (isv xdw* lxavr\v d^iav e%ovxa cog vyistav nXovxov, ano- 20 nQorjyfiiva Ss xa (ir\ ixavr\v e%ovxa d^iav cog neviav
192 xo

ExcotKOt yovv xa (iev (Stoic. fr. III 122 Arn.) x&v dStacpoQcov <pa6i ovxs TCQorjyfiiva elvat, xd Se drtOrtQor\y(iiva, xa Se
otov
ol
(iev

vo6ov, fir)xe Se rtQor\y(iiva (if)xe drtortQor\y(iiva cog ixxeivai r\ 6vyxd(iipai xbv SdxxvXov. Tiveg Se ovSev x&v dStacpoQcov <pv6et rtQor\y(iivov r\ ano2i * nQor\y\iivov eivat UyovGtv' exa6xov yccQ x&v aStacpOQcov naQcc xccg StacpoQovg neQtGxdaetg oxe (iev rtQor\y(iivov cpaive6&at, bxe Se dnonQor\y(ievov. ei yovv, cpaeiv, oi (iev nXovGtoi irttfiovXevotvxo vnb
25

xvqccvvov ol Se nivr\xeg stQiqvsvotvxo, nag dv sXotro eivat nivrjg (iccXXov r) nXov6iog, cog dno193 rtQor\y(jtivov yive6d-ai xbv nXovxov. &6xs irtei sxa6tov x&v Xsyo(iivcov dStacpOQCov oi (csv dya&bv elvai <pa6tv, oi Se
xaxov, anavxeg 8
el'ye

30

av

Sfioicog

dStdcpOQOv avxb iv6(itov eivai,

dStdcpoQov r\v cpv6ei, ovSiv e6xt <pv6st dStdcpoQov. Ovxcog xai et xtg <pv6st atQSxr\v eivat Xiyot xr\v dv- 16 7 S^eiav Std xb xovg Xiovxag <pv6tx&g xoXfiav xai dvS^ie6&at Soxeiv Kai xavQOvg, ei xvyot, Kai dv&Qcbrtovg xtvdg
irti

Kai dXexxQvovag, Xiyo(xsv, oxt o6ov

xovxco Kai

r\

SetXia
5

<pv6si atQSX&v i6xtv, irtei sXacpoi Kai Xayco Kai dXXa Kai oi rtXet6xot Ss rtXeiova coa cpv6tx&g irt avxr\v OQ(ia.

x&v

x&v

dv&Qchrtcov

SetXoi ftecoQovvxai'
eig

6rtavicog

(isv

yaQ

xtg

vrteQ rtaxQiSog eavxbv irtiScoKev

r)

ftdvaxov fiXaxsv6a(isvog

dXXcog &SQ(i6v xt rvcpco&sig l'So$i xtg StartQaxxe6dat, 6 Se rtXet6xog o(itXog x&v dv&Qconcav ndvxa xa xotavxa iK- 10
adv. dogm. 191 192 adv. dogm. 99. 193

6266.

om. AB 2 v.a\ T (quod leones naturaliter audavidentur fortiter agere) i%\ xb G, unde Gen. 6q(i&v 3 doxsiv MEAB: doxsi L 5 Xayco pro Toif/av coniecerunt scr.: Xaychg MLE pr. 8 Xaycool AB et E in ras., unde edd. Xax. post 10 tcov ccv&qcqtccov transponi iubet Apelt: lasciviens

33

i6ti
et

ces

sunt

quidem

vel

9 tvcpco&slg

MEABT

(elatus): tvcpXco&slg

TnoTTnssESN
xXivet.

r.

187

o&ev xai ol 'EntxovQetot (Epicurea p. 274, 194 25 Us.) 8etxvvvat vofiiov6t cpv6et atQexr\v elvat xr\v r)8ovf]v' xa yaq cod cpaoiv dfia xco yevia&ai,
d8ta6XQ0cpa bvxa, oQfiav fiev ini xr\v r\8ovr\v, ixxXivetv 8e dXyr\86vag. xui nQog xovxovg 8e i6xt Xiyetv, 195 ort xb notr\rtxbv xaxov ovx av ei'r\ cpv6et aya&ov' r) Si ye r\8ovr\ xaxav e6xi notr\rtxr)' nu6r\ yuQ r\Sovf\ nuQunenrjyev dXyr\8cov, r\ e6xi xax avrovg (Epicurea p. 276, 23 Us.) cpv6et xuxov. olov yovv r\8erut 6 fii&v6og ificpoQOVfievog
otvov xal o ya6tQtfiaQyog rQocpf\g, xa\ 6 Xdyvog acpQo6t6ioig

dXXd xavxa xa\ nevlag xal vo6cov afiixQCog iQcofievog' i6rl notr\rtxd, aneQ dXyetvd i6xi xal xaxd, cog cpa6iv. ovx
a.Qa

cpv6et

to

notr\xtxbv

dya&ov i6xtv r\ r\8ovr). nuQunXr\6icog Se xui 196 dya&ov ovx i6xt cpv6et xaxov, r\8ovdg 8e

dXyr\86veg' xal yuQ int6rr)fiag dvaXafifidvonovovvreg, xal nXovrov xai iQcofiivr\g ovrcog iyxQarr)g yiveral rtg, xai vyietuv neQtnotov6tv at dXyr\86veg. ovx
(Jtev

dnoreXov6tv

ccqu
r\v
r)

novog cpv6ei xaxov.

r)8ovr\,
cog

xui yuQ ei cpv6et dya&bv fiev

oQc&fiev Se

cpavXov Se 6 novog, ndvxeg

iXiyofiev'

exetvro ne^l uvxcov,

cptXo6ocpcov xbv fiev
r\8ovr\g

dv ouoicog noXXovg

8txcov

novov xal xr\v xuQxeQiuv atQOVfiivovg, xaxacpQOvovvxug. bfioicog 8' dv neQtXQe- 197 inotvro xai ot rbv ivuQerov iov cpv6et dyad-bv elvat Xeyovreg, ix tou rtvag rcov 6ocpav rbv (ie& f)Sovf\g atQefc&at /Stov, cog ix tJjj nao avrotg ixeivotg Stacpcoviug to qpv6et rt rotov r) rotov elvat StarQene^&at.
xf\g

Se

Ovx dronov
teoov
int6xf,6at

dv

i'6cog

ei't\

n^bg xovxotg xai

eiStxco- 198

vnoXr)tye6t xatg ne^i atcfypcov xai ovx aiC^ocov, d\}e6ficov xe xai ov xotovxcov xai
^Qccyicov

Std

xatg

voucov xai i&oov xai

rf\g eig

&eovg ev6e(5eiag xai

(ir\

rf\g

rovg xarotypfiivovg o6torr\rog xai xav iotxorcov'

)

ns^i xai yaQ

ovrco ne^i rcov nQaxricov

r)

noXXr\v evQr\60fiev dvcofia-

194196
Iveext

~ adv.
(inest)

dogm.

9698.

14 a

20

23 dya&ov (inmoderatis) edd. 28 r\ AB: om.

MLT
L

dfiitQiog

MLE

(boni):

8 i&cov

GT

Nauck: diiirgotg GT dya&bv EAB: ayu&cov

(consuetudinibus): decov

Kayser

9 xaxr\%ovfiivovg

188
199 Xiav.

IITPP&NEI&N

olov yovv nuQ* r)(iiv (isv ul6%qov, fiuXXov Ss Kui nuQUVOfiov vsv6(ll6xul xb xr\q uQQEvoiu^iug, tcuqu rsQciuvoig
Si, cog q>u6iv, ov% ai6%Q0V, dXK cog i'v xi x&v 6vvr)&cov. XsysxuL Ss Kal rtuQu Qrjfiaioig xb rtuXuibv ovk ui6%Qov xovxo tlvav S6E,ui, Kui xbv MrjQiovrjv xbv Kqt)xu ovxco KEKXr)6&ui I
cpu6L
rtQog
Sl
s(Lcpu6iv

UuxqokXov Slutivqov yiXiav

xov Kqt)x&v s&ovg, Kui xr\v AyiXXicog sig xovxo dvdyov6i xivsg.

200 Kui xi &uv(iu6xov , ortov ys Kui oi drtb xr)g Kvvi%r)g cpiXo6ocpiug Kai oi rtSQi xbv Kixisu Zrjveova Kui KXsdv&rjv
Kai

XQv6inrtov (fr. Stoic. xovxo slvui cpu6iv; v.ui xb

I,

256 Arn.) dSidcpoQOv

yvvuivX (iiyvv6&uL, Kuixoi rtUQ r)(iiv ui6%QQV slvui Sokovv, rtuQU xi6i x&v IvS&v ovk ui6%Qov slvai vofii^sxai' (liyvvvxui yovv dSiacpOQag 8r)(io6ia, KU&drtSQ Kai rtSQi xov cpilo6ocpov KQuxi)xog
8r\(io6iu

201 uKr)Kou(isv.
(ilv

dXXu Kui xb xdg yvvuixug sxuiqsiv rtUQ^ f)(iiv % ui6iQov E6xi Kui Ertovsi8i6xov , rtUQa 8s rtoXXoig x&v Aiyvrtxicov svxXsig' cpu6i yovv, oxl ui rtXsi6xoig 6vvlov6ul
Kui ko6(iov syov6i rtSQi6cpvQiov 6vvd"r](iu xov rtUQ uvxuig rtUQ sviotg Ss uvx&v ui koqul tiqo x&v 6s(ivoXoyr)(iuxog.
,

yd(icov

xr)v

tcqoiku

eS,

Kui

xovg SxcoiKOvg

sxuiQr)6scog 6vvdyov6ui yapovvxai. (Stoic. fr. III, 755 Arn.) 8s 6q&(isv

202 xb s
rtUQ

ovk uxortov slvui Xiyovxug xb sxuiQcc 6vvolkslv r) sxuiQag SQyu6iug Sia^rjv. dXXd Kui xb E6xiy&uL
r)(iiv

(isv

203 Aiyvnxicov
iXXofiiu

Kui

ui6%Qov Kui uxlliov sIvul Sokel, rtoXXoi Ss n 2uQ(iax&v 6xiov6i xu ysvvcofisvu. xo te

rtUQ i6xi

r)(iiv (jlsv ui6%Qov E6xi, sysLv xovg uQQSvug rtUQ ivioig Ss xcov uq^uqcov, co6rtSQ Kui SvQOig, svysvsiug xivsg Ss irtixsivovxsg xb 6vvQr)(iu xr)g 6vv&r)(jLu.

svysvsiug, Kui xug (jivag

drt

x&v naiScov XLXQco6Kovxsg KQUovg

o

uvx&v uQyvQiovg
rtOLr)6ELS

r)

204 ovx dv

Kui rtoSrjQr) xig uqqtjv ivxav&a <^av)> d(icpis6aixo i6&r)xu, KuixoL rtUQu
xig,

%Qv6ovg drtUQX&6Lv, a6rtSQ ovSs dv&ofiucpr)

xov
rtUQ
r)(iLV

tiuq

r)(iiv

HiQ6aig

svrtQsns6xdxov

ui6%Q0v

xovxov

12 rsQ(iavolg GT (apud germanos): KaQ(iavolg Fabricius 19 Kvriia Bekk.: KLzxiia G: citiensem T 23 yovv 35, 8 ML: ovv EAB 7 cc-x' Gen. om. G: in eis 28 nul om. T dependent T 9 dcv add. Bekk. 10 xov vel tovxov secl. Pasquali
cf. p.
:

TII0TTn&2EN
Soxovvrog
tvodvvco
sivcci.

r.

189
xco
xr\g

xcci

TtccQcc

Aiovv6ico ds
xcci

EtxsXiccg

xoiccvxr\g

i6&rjxog HXdxcovi
6
fikv

cpiXo6ocpoig TtQ06v'f&i6r\g sintov (Eurip. Bacch. 836)

AQt6ximtcp TOtg TJXdxcov dnsnifi^axo,

ovx dv

Svvccifir\v

%r\Xvv ivSvvai 6xoXr\v

aoorjv nscpvxcog,
6 Ss 'AoicitntTtog nQ06r\xccxo, cpr\6ag (Bacch.

317)

xcd yaQ iv \Sax'fsvfia6iv

ov6
)

r\

ys 6cocpQoav ov Stacp&UQr\6xai.

6ocpcov cb fiv ovx al6%o6v, w Sh ai6%Q0v iSoKEi tovto sivat. ads6[iov xs i6xi nccQ rjfiiv {irjTEQa r\ 205 dSsXcprjv iSiav yccfisiv' IlEQ6ai Si, xcci (idXi6Ta ccvtcov ol

ovxco

xai xcov

6ocpiav a6xiv Soxovvrsg, ot

xcci
I

Mdyoi,

yccfiov6i

Tag

fir\TiQag,

AiyvitTioi rdg dSEXcpag dyovTai TtQog ydfiov, xa\ cog

7jvg "HQr\v itQ06ssnts xu6tyvr\Tr\v ttXoypv te. o KiTisvg Zr\vcov (Stoic. fr. I, 256 Arn.) cpr\6l uTonov sivttt to {ioqiov Tr\g fir\TQog tco eccvxa.1

6 noir\Tr\g cpr\6iv {II 356),

dXXa
(ir\

tov
'

Qog tov 6co(iaTog

(fr.

'tccv

xaftuTtEQ ovSs dXXo ti (iiccvTfjg ttj ItiQi TQityai cpavXov EiTtoi Ttg slvai. xccl 6 XQv6tnnog Ss iv rr\ noX iTsia
fiooico

TQiipcct,

ix Tr)g ix tov
5

745 Arn.) SoyfiaTisi tov te nuTEQcc &vyaTQbg natSonotsie&cci xai Tr\v (ir\TEQcc ncciSbg xcci tov dSsXcpbv ix rr\g dSsXcprjg. HXdTtov (Resp. IV 423 E sqq.) Se xal xa&oXtxcoTEQov
Stoic.

III,

xoivccg slvcci
xt
fr.

xdg yvvatxag Ssiv dnscprjvccTO. xd 206 ai6iQ0VQystv inuQUTOv ov nuQ r\fiiv 6 Zr\vcov (Stoic. I, 255 Arn.) ovx dnoSoxifid^sf xai dXXovg Ss cog
xco

dya&co xivt tovtco ^ofjoMftu

xcci

xaxcZ

nvv&avofis&a. dXXd 207

rjfiiv

xb

dvfrQconsicov

ci&E6fiov, Jtao' oXoig xai xi Ssi xovg o i6xtv.

yV6\rai 6aQXcov itccQ 1'&ve6iv Ss PttQfittQOig

fiaQfiuQovg

(iev

Xiystv,

dSuccpoQov bnov xcci 6

,

TvSsvg xbv iyxicpaXov xov noXsfiiov XiyExai cpaysiv

xai

23 ccaxovvtsg SoxstvL 11 (ovxcoy xai T (sic et) cf. v. 20. 27 Kittsvg Bekk Kittisvg G 28/29 tw savtov ftOQtcp MLT 2 doxt(suo membro confricare): tcov avtov (loqicov EAB fidgsi Kayser 6 aTtioatov EAB 7 aXXoig EAB 8 tovtcp om. T
:

190
cc

IITPP&NEI&N

ol dnb Tr)g Sx o g (Stoic. fr. I, 254 III, 748 Arn.) ovk to-1nov slvcci cpa6t xb 6uQKug xtvd io&lsiv aXXcov xs
\

208

dv &Qconcov
ftcofibv

Kcci

suvxov;
Ttfitv
'

&sov itaQ

xo xs dv&Qconsicp fituivsiv atfiaxt fisv xoig noXXotg uds6fiov, AuKcovsg

ij

OQ&coCiug 'AQTSfiidog fxaax^ovxat xov noXXrjv atfictTOg ini xov ficoftov xr g &sov ysvs6d-ai qv6lv. dXXd ku\ xcj. Kqovco &vov6tv uv&Qconov xtvsg, KU&dnsQ Kcci ZIkv&ui xrj AQxifit8t xovg i-svovg' r)fisig 8s %Qaivs6&at tu isqu 8oKOVfisv dv&Qcbnov cpovco.
coftov
xf)g

8s

ini xov

ittKQcog VTtSQ

209 xovg ys
xi6iv

r)fiiv voftog, kuqu 8i firjv (ioi%ovg koXu^si naQ d^LucpOQov i6xt xulg xcov sxsqcov yvvut^i fiiyvv^&ui'

21

kuI

cptXo6ocpcov

6s

xtvig

cpu6tv

d6tdcpoQov
xovg

slvcct

xb
xs

210

dXXoxQtu yvvutKt fiiyvv6&ut.

vnb
xcov
ncciScov

TtuxsQug

intfisXsiug

d,tov6&ut

ksXsvsi nccQ

rjfiiv
21

oi 2kv&ui 6s vnsQ xu s^rjKOvxu sxr\ ysvofiivovg kuI xi &av{ia6x6v , siys 6 fisv uvxovg a7to6cpuxxov6tv. KQovog xrj uQnrj xu alSoicc s'S,ixsfjts xov nccxQog, 6 6s Zsvg
vofiog'

Kqovov kuxsxuqxuqco6sv , 7) 8s 'A&rjvu fjtsxu "HQug Ho6st6covog xbv nuxi^u 8s6fisvstv ins%siQrj6sv\ dXXd 211 kuI xovg suvtov nccidccg 6 KQovog dvatQStv sxqivsv, kuI
ku\
6 26Xcov

xbv

si

A&rjvuiotg xbv
8s to

TtSQt

xcov

aKQUcov vofiov s&sto

7tttt8tt

Ktt&
TtccQ

0V CpOVSVStV
rjfiiv

SKU6TC0

TOV

SO.VTOV

iniTQStysv
*|

xovg nai8ccg cpovsvstv dnayoQSvov6tv oi oi' xs Pcofitticov voftot. vofio&ixat xovg nui8ug vno%stQiovg kuI 8ovXovg tcov TtttTiQtov ksXsvov6iv slvcct, kccI Tr)g ov6iag

t&v
scog

Ttaidcov

fir)

kvqisvsiv Tovg 7tai8ag dXXd xovg naxiQag,

J

7tui8sg xvyco6t Kuxa xovg aQyvQcosxigotg 8s cog xvQavvtxbv xovxo iK^i^XrjTcct. vr)xovg' 7tccQ' 212 vofiog te i6Tt Tovg dvSQOcpovovg KoXdfa&ut' oi fiovo-

uv iXsv&SQiag oi

cpovsvovxsg TtoXXuKtg kuI xtfir)g xvy%dvov6tv. xb xvnxstv iXsv&iQOvg oi vofiot KcoXvov6tv' oi d&Xr)xat 8s xvnxovxsg iXsv&iQOvg ccv^Qccg, noXXttKtg (8s)> kccI
fid%at

8s

dXXd

kccI

i(

213 dvatQOVvxsg,

xifi&v

kccI

6xscpdvcov

d^tovvxat.

voftog

xs

18 GKV&ccg L 20 et 24 fort. (6) nag' rjfiiv v. 21 htaiT (amicorum) 22 xod 23 tiiyvvG&ut om. EABT 5/6 secundum mancipia T 8 fort. dXXr]Xovg pro itolldKtg scrib. cf. p. 35,32. 36,2. 10 Sh add. T (autem et)
qcov

TII0TTII&2E&N

T.

191

nuQ r)(tiv xeXevei (tia 6vvoixeiv exu6xov, Oquxcov Se xal ranovXcov (Aifivcov Se e&vog xovxo) noXXuig exu6xog
15

6vvoixei. xd xe Xr]6xeveiv nuQ i)(iiv (iev nuQuvO(tov xal 214 dSixov G*u, naoa Se noXXoig rcov fiaofiaQcov ovx dronov. cpu6t Se, ori xai evxleeg xovxo ol KiXixeg ivoca^ov elvui,

xal xovg iv Xt]6XEiu xeXevxr\6avxag xi(if)g uS,iovg elvui xui 6 Ne6rcoQ Se nuQa rco noir}ri), (ierd xo cpiXoq>oovrfia6%ca xovg neol xbv Tr]Xe(iu%ov, cpr]6i rtobg avxovg
cog

Soxeiv.

20

(y 72) r) (tuipiSicog dXdXrje&e old xe Xr]i6xf]Qeg;

xb Xr]6reveiv, ovx uv ovrcog uvrovg Sid rb vnonreveiv, (irj uQa roiovroi xicpiXocpQOvr]6d(ievog dXXd xui <to)> xXenxeiv nuQ r)(iiv (iev uSixov 215 veg ekv.

xuixoi ei uxonov

r)v

25

xal naQdvofiov e6xiv' ot Se xul xXenri6ruxov elvui %ebv Xeyovreg rbv Eq(it)v ovx uSixov xovxo vo(ii^E6% ui noiov6iv
,

so

(nCog yuQ uv &ebg el'r] xuxogy). cpa6i Se xiveg, oxi xal oi Adxcoveg xovg xXetpavxag eKoXa^ov ov Siu xb xexXocpevui, dXXu Sid xb necpcoQa6&ui. dXXd xul 6 SetXbg xul 6 (jiipa6nig 216 Sib xul r] xr)v u6nCdvr)Q xoXdferai nuQu noXXoig v6(ico'

Su

xa>

naiSi

inl

noXeiiov

it,i6vxi

SiSoveu Adxaiva *6v

xuvxuv'
.

172 Etpr],

'rexvov, i} r) ^AQ^iXo^og Si, co6neQ 6e(ivvv6(ievog r)(iiv inl x& xr)v u6niSu Qitpug cpvyeiv, iv xoig noif)(iu6i neQt eavxov cpr]6iv (fr. 58 B.)

xuvxuv

inl

u6niSi
5

(iev HaXcov xig dydXXerui, r)v naQu ftdfivco evxog d(ic6(ir]xov xdXXinov ovx e&eXcov,

uvxbg
ul Se

d' i^ecpvyov

&uvdxov

xeXog.

i%wXevov xd aQQeva xcov vn av- 217 xcov yevvcofievcov vneQ xov (irjSev dvS^eiov avrd noir)6ut Svvu6&ut, neQi n6Xe(iov Se e6jov avrui, xov ivuvxiov
A(ia6veg
xal

23 post
quid
coll.

Thuc.

cpiXocpQovr\6diisvog fort. inser. wvsidioe vel simile I 5, 2 did to vnoitxevEiv G: sed propter id
||

quidevi suspicabatur T 24 xb add. coll. p. 170, 5. 9. 13. 171, 14 28 xXeipavTag post xXtTtTEiv Gen. inser. (ihv 25 dsbv om. MEAB: xXiitTug L 5 fvrog Brunck: ivrbg G: interius T xdXXinov T (dimist): xdXXmtv G 7 vit' avrebv T (ab eis); itsgl avxdg G: nag' avratg Bekk. 1) hcrov G: habebant seT: sl%ov vel iaxoXafrv Bekk. dub. at cf.p. 177, 13.

||

||

192

IITPP&NE[N
172
1]

ovxco KQivu6u 7} 218 &eog, eiye cpv6et cpuvXov rjv xb (ir) ccvdQeiov elvai. ovxco zal xcc neQi xcov 8tKuicov Kui adiKCOV Kal xov kuxu xi]v

naq r)(iiv KuXcog efetv vevo(it6(iivov. Kui &e&v nQ06iexut xovg &t)Xv8Qiug, ovk ccv

(ir)xr)Q

8e xoov 10

ccvdQeiav kccXov noXXr)v ccvcoftuXiuv e%et. Kal xu %eQi ev6efieiug 8e Kui ftecov (fteQuneiugy nenXrjQcoxat noXXr)g Siacpcoviug.
eivut, xtveg 8e

15

A ovx Xiov Kal OeodcoQOV Kal KQixiav xbv A&rjvuiov.

xobv elvat fteovg dnoa)t)vu(iivcov oi (lev xovg

fteovg yccQ 01 (iev noXloi cpa6iv etvut, w6neQ ol neql tuyoQuv xov Mf)Y.ai

nuxQiovg

vo(ii-

ov6t tffouj, oi 8e xovg iv xaig doyfiauxatg aiQe6e6tv

nXcc66o(ievovg,

dvu-w&
20

cogAQt6xoxiXr)g (cf.fr. 26 Rose) (iev Sc6coelnev elvat xbv &ebv Kui ni^ag xov ovquvov, fiuxov SxcotKOt (Stoic. fr. I 159 et II 103 Arn.) 8e nvev(ia dtfjKov Kui 8tu xcov ei8e%&&v, EniKOVQOg (p. 355, 7

Us.) 8e c\v&Qcon6(ioQ<pov, Eevocpavr\g (cf. A33 Diels) 219 8e 6cpatQav dna&r). Kui oi (iev nQovoeiv x&v Ka& r](iug,zi*
oi 8e
(ir)

nQOvoeiv' xb yuQ (jlukuqiov Kai

'EniKovQog

(p. 71,3 Us.) cpr)6t (ir)xe k'%etv (ir)xe exeQotg nuQi%etv. o&ev Kal x&v kuxu xbv fiiov oi (iev evu cpu6tv elvut &eov, oi 8e noXXovg kuI dtacpo-

ucp&uQxov 6 uvxb nQuyfiuxu

25

Qovg xuig
ifininxetv,

(lOQcpuig, cog kuI eig

xug xcov Aiyvnxicov vnoXr)tyetg

173

KvvonQ06oonovg kuI ieQuKOfioQCpovg xui 6ag Kui 220 KQOKodeiXovg Kui xi yuQ ov%i vo(it6vxoov xovg fteovg. b&ev
xui xu negii &v6t&v Kui xr)g ne^i xovg fteovg &Qrj6Keiug Xcog noXXr)v ccvcofiuXiuv eyef a yccQ ev xi6tv ieQOtg (yoiti^exuty Kuixot ei cpv6et xb o6tov o6tu, xccvxcc iv exiQotg dvo6ta.

ovk ccv xovxo ivo(ii6&r). otov yovv ovk ccv &v6eti xtg, HQUKXei 8e Kui 2uQuni6i yptQov A6KXr)ntcp &vov6tv. nQofiuxov "I6t8t ftveiv u&eefiov, xf)
Kui xb dvo6tov t\v,
xcov fteoov (ir)XQi (xevxot Xeyofievr)

221 xut.

<^.

.y

x& Kqovco &vov6tv uv&Qconov ,

Kui fteoig uXXotg KuXXteQeixoig nXeiexotg

10

15 &SQa7tei.ag vel &Qr)Gxetag add. e T (de credulitate au21 tbv ftebv tem atque pietate deorum) cf. p. 173, 3. 174, 10. 4 add. T 1 iintintetv T (incidere): innintetv G elvat AB 6 xovto om. T: tt (in quibusdam sacris putantur sancta) totovtov Kayser 10 excidit ztveg dh vel nomen proprium
cf. p.

170, 17

TII0TTII2EN
a6s(}eg sivat

T.

193

vofii&xcct. ailovQOv iv AXs^avSQsta tg5 "Qoea &vov6t, xai OixtSt 6iXcpr\v' o nctQ* r)fitv ovx dv notr\6sti tnnov xco Ho6stScbvt xaXXtSQ0v6tv' AnoXXcavt 8i, xtg.
iE,aiQSt(og
(itSt

tco

ftvstv

sv6s(lig,

AtSvfiaico, xb c5ov dnsypig. aXX' ovx ^A6xXr\ntcp.

Xiystv eycov
ei fiivzot xi r\v

alyag
xcci

AqxiuXXa Ss 222

xovxotg ofiota nafinXr^&f)

6toycc^6fievog.

icb, xr)g 6vvxofiiag o6tov cpv6st ftvfia xui dvo-

Otov,

nuQu nu6tv av

bfioicog ivofiifezo.

UaQunXr\6ta Ss zovzotg S6ztv svqsXv xa\ xa sv xf) xuzu zr\v Siatzav xcov dv&Qcbncov &Qr\6xeia neqi xovg ftsovg, IovSuXog fiev yuQ i\ iSQSvg Aiyvnxiog daxxov av dno&d- 223
voi
yoiQetov cpdyot, Aifivg Se nQOiSccxeiov ysveue&ai xcov d&eefioxdxcov etvcct SoxeX, Evqcov 8i xtvsg nsQtxqicog iy&vg xs sv xt6t fisv tSQOtg 6xsQug, dXXot Ss isQsicov. &i(iig i6d-istv, iv uXXotg Ss a6s(iig. Aiyvnxicov xs xcov
r)

eocpcbv

slvat

vevo(it6fiivcov

ot

(ilv

xecpaXr\v coov

cpuyeXv

dvisQov slvut vo(iiov6tv, oi Se co(ionXdxr\v, oi Se noSa, oi ds dXXo xt. XQOfifivov Se ovx dv xtg %Q06sviyxutxo 224
xcbv xu&tsQOVfiivcov to3

ovSe iSQSvg
av.
tr\Svo6fiov,

xr)g

xuxu Tlr\Xov6iov Kcc6ico Ati, &6nsQ xaxd Ai(5vr\v 'AcpQoSizrjg 6%6qSov ysv6atzo
fisv

dniypvzat Ss sv (otgy
sv
olg

8s

6sXivov.
xcov

tSQoXg svtot

(tiv&rjg,

iv olg Sk

Ss
r)

ftazzov
xvdptovg.

dv zdg
aXXcc

xscpaXdg

cpccysXv

cpa6t

nccxiQcov

naQ

sxiqotg zccvzcc
r)fistg
r

dStdcpoQU.
>

xvvsicov

xe

yevtfacfftat

So- 225
'

xovfisv

dvisQOV slvat,

Squxcov

8s

svtot

xvvocpaysXv

i6zoQovvxut. i 6cog Se xal naQ "EXXr\6t xovzo r\v 6vvr\$sg StonsQ xut JtoxXr\g dnb xdiv xaxd xovg *A6xXr\nitt8ag 8q(icofisvog

xt6l

xcov
xtvsg

na6y6vxcov 6xvXdxsta 8iSo6&at

Ss xai dv&Qcbncov 6aQxag, cog scpr\v, jroro' r\(itv slvat vevofit-

xeXsvst xqia.
\

dStacpoQcog i6diov6tv, o%sq dvisQOv

n

26 voititottivcov T (legit fors. Isquxcov interpres) 28 xq6(ivov L 30 6xoq6Sov edd. et A 31 olg add. 3 xs ML: Sh Bekk.: abstinentur autem in sacris quidam T EAB: om. T
cipitres

12 6tlcpr\v GT (silfen) 11 &Q<p Fabr.: ygco G: yro T 8uspectum 16 ^co MT (dimito): iv w LEAB 17 6to%ut6fisvog Bekk.: 7taQu6Toxut6(isvog G: brevitatem considerans T 24 an'

EAB

Sextu Empiricus

I.

13

194
226
Gxoci.

IITPP&NEI&N
%ccixoi

eiye

r\v

cpvGSL

xu

xr)g

%Qr\G%eiug

%u\

xcov

d&eG[itov , nccQU

tvccGlv

uv
ol

bicoicog ivo[iiexo.
xr\g

HaQanXr\6Ltt Sh eGxi Xeyeiv xui nsgl

xoifoycevovg
oGLQxr\xog.
[ihv

slg

xovg %uTtSQiGxsi-

yaQ

SXoxlrjQcog

arco&avovxug yr) %uXvtcxovGlv , aGefieg eivai vopifrvxeg r\Xicp dewvvetv ccvxovg' AiyvTtxioi Sh xcc evxeQa e^eXovxeg xuQiyevovGiv uvxovg %cc\ Gvv euvxoig vTteQ yf\g 227 syovGiv. Ai&iontov Sh ol ly&vocpccyoi eig xccg Xi[ivag ifiXavxeg

rovj

vrtb xcov fiuXXovGiv ccvxovg, iydvtov ^Qto&rjGOfisvovg' Sh *Tq%ccvo\ Sh %vg\v ccvxovg ixxi&evxat (5oquv, 'ivStov evioi yvipiv. TQcoyXoSvxag Se cpaGiv ini xiva yetoXocpov uyeiv xbv djto&uvovxu , elxu SeG[ievGavxccg avxov xr)v %ecpaXr\v JtQog xovg itoSccg Xi&oig dXXeiv (iexu yeXcoxog, t#' oxccv uvxbv xolg aXXo(ievoig dnuXXuGGeG&ai. icoGcoGiv

228 xiveg Sh ^uq^uqol xovg (ihv vrtSQ ef}KOvxa exr\ yeyovoxag ftvGuvxsg eG&iovGiv, xovg Sh iv vedxr\xi dno&uvovxccg yr\

XQvnxovGiv.
ot
[ihv

evioi

Sh

%cciovGL

dvaXufiovxeg

avxtov

xd

xovg xexeXevxr\%6xag' cov oGxea %r\8evovGtv , oi Sh

TleQGag Se
vixQto
cpccGiv
kcc\

dcpQOvxiGxcog %uxccXeinovGiv

iQQi(i(ievtt.

&vuGKoXo7tieLV

xovg

dno&avovxug
GvveiXeiv.

xccQLyeveiv,

el&

ottxco

xeXcc(itoGL

ccXXoi

Sh oGov
kccl

nev&og in\

229 xolg xeXevxr\GaGLV vno[isvovGLv

&dvccxov 6Q&[iev. Sh ccvxbv oi [ihv Seivbv %a\ cpsvKxov elvai vo(iiov6iv , oi Sh ov xoiovxov. 6 yovv EvQiniSr\g tpr\6\v (fr. 638Nauck).

xbv

S olSev ei xb r)v [isv eGxi %ux9ccvslv, xb %ax$ttvsZv Ss r\v %dxco vo[ii^sxai; xul 6 'Eni%ovQog (p. 61, 6. 71, 6 Us.) Se <pr\Giv '6 Q-dxig

vccxog
Sh

ovSev nQog

rjfiag'

xb

6&r\xei, xb Sh dvuL6&r\xovv
kcc\ cog

yuQ SiaXv&ev dvaiovSev TtQog r)[iag.' cpaGL

etTteQ GvvsGxr\%a[isv s% tyv%r\g %a\ GcbfiuSh d-dvuxog SidXvGig eGxi ipv%r\g na\ Gto(iuxog, xog, oxe [ihv r\[ietg iGfiev, ov% 'eGxiv 6 ftdvaxog (ov yuQ SiaXvofied-a^), oxe Sh 6 ftdvuxog eGxiv, ov% iGfiev rjfietg' xco yttQ [ir\%sxL xr)v GvGxaGiv slvai xr\g
6

10/11 ea que putantur religiosa 12 Si (rovxoigy T (proxima autem 20 yvipiois L KccroixovLiivovs L

et

que putantur illicitaT

\\

hiis)

laxt

om.

EABT

TII0TTn2EN
y\>vyr)g

T.

195
i6(isv.
6 Ss 230

xai xov 6c6(iccxog ovds

(cf.

rjfisig

HQuxXstxog

B 88

Diels) <pi\6tv, oxi

t,r\v

xb drto&avsiv xal iv xca

r)fiag

xai xb r)v xai S6xi xai iv xco

xs&vdvaf oxs fisv yuQ 'fjf^sig cofisv, xdg tyvydg r)ficov xs&vdvat xai iv r)fiiv xs&dcp&ui, oxs 6s r)fisig
drto&vr\6xofisv, xdg ipvydg dvafitovv xai
r\v.

svtot

6s xai (isXxtov sivai xb drto&avsiv xov r\v r)fiug vrtoXafidvov6tv. 6 yovv EvQtrtidr\g <pr}6iv (fr. 449 Nauck)

ydo r)fiag 6vXXoyov rtotovfiivovg xbv cpvvxa &Qr\vsiv, sig 06 SQysxai xaKa, xbv 6 av ftccvovxa xcci xccxcov itsrtavfiivov
i%Qr\v
ccTtb

yttiQOVxag svcpr\fiovvxccg ixrtifirtstv doficov. 8s xr)g avxf\g vrtoXr)tyscog xai xccvxcc siQr\xca' (Theogn. 231
aQyr)v fisv fir) cpvvat irtiy&oviot6tv &qi6xov, i6tSsiv avydg o^sog r)sXiov,

4^so)

firjd'

epvvxcc <f ortcog coxi6xa rtvXccg

AtSao

rtSQr\6ut

xcci

xai xsi6&cu rtoXXr)v yaiav icps66ufisvov. xd nsQi KXsofitv ds xai Bixcova i'6fisv, d cpr\6tv 6
xco rts^i xr)g

Hqo-

doxog iv

^AQysiag IsQsiug Xoyco (131).

i6xoQOvvxai 8s xai qccxcov svtot rtSQixa%s6&svxsg xbv 232 ysvvrftsvxtt &Qr\vsiv. ovds 6 &dvaxog ovv xcov cpv6st Sstvcov slvat vofiifyixo dv, co6rtSQ ovSs xb r\v xcov <pv6st xaXcov.

ovds xcov rtQosiQi]fiivcov xt i6xi (it6xd Ss rtdvxa xai rtQog xt.

cpv6st

xoiov

r)

xoiov, vo-

Tbv
xr)v
fisv

ccvxbv

Ss

XQonov

xr)g

iniysiQr\6scog

fisxcccpSQStv

233

S6rt xcci icp' sxa6xov xcov dXXcov,

fir)

i$s&Sfie&a vvv Std

fii)

6vvxofiiav
strtsiv

cov Xoyov.

si

Ss xai rtSQi xtvcov

avxo&sv
cbg

dvcofiaXiccv ,
r)(iiv

Xsxxsov,
rtSQt

bxt

sv

syoxt6tv

s&vs6tv dyvoovfiivotg
dtacpcoviav.

ivSiysxcct xcci

xovxcov sivat

ovv

si

(ir)

xb rts^i 234 iytyvco6xoftsv , si xvypt,

xcov

xov
xb

xdg

dSsXcpdg

yafisiv

Aiyvrtxicov

s&og,

ovx av
slvat

OQ&cog
fif)

Sts(5s(5aiovfis&a

SfioXoyovfisvov

rtaQtt

ncx6tv

dsiv ddsXcpdg yafisiv, oftxcog ovde rtSQi xcov rtQCcyfidxcov ixsivcov, iv otg ovy vnonin,xov6tv r)fiiv dvcofiaXittt, Sta-

icJiSelv

MEAB

17 ydg om. L 20 gaudentes et benedicentes T 28 ftrjd' Gen. nec aspicere T ft,r\ Ss ISsstv G r)tXiov L r)sXioto
:

||

7 tovtcov

(de hiis): uvtcov Gr

13*

196
SL3atov6&ai %Q06r)xst
yp(n,svov,
(ir\

IITPP&NEI&N
(ir\

slvat dtaq>coviav iv avxotg, ivde

xa&d%SQ

sq>r\v,

xov naQa xi6iv s&vsai xcov

r\(itv

ytvco6xo(iivcov xr\v %sqI avxoov slvai 8taq>coviav.

235

xoivvv 6%s%xtxbg xr\v xo6avxr\v dvco(iaXiav x&v %Qay(idxcov oocov insysi (isv ksqI xov q>v6st xi dyaftbv r)

%Qaxxsov slvat, xdv xovxco xr\g doy(iaxtxr]g sitsxai 6s ddoa6xcog xfj fitcoacpt6xd(isvog %QO%sxsiag , xtxfj xr\Qf\6st, xai 8ta xovxo iv (isv xotg doa6xoi~g d%ai)

xaxbv

oXcog

&r\g

(isvst, (isv

iv

ds

xotg

xaxr\vayxa6(isvotg
al6&r\xtxbg

(isxQio-ita&st'
(ir\

236

cog

yaQ
8i,

av&QCOTtog
oxt

%a6yst,
i6xt

%qo6(is-

8odo3v

xovxo

%a6yst

xaxdv

q>v6si,

XQto%a&st. xb yaQ %Q06dodstv xi xoiovxo %siq6v i6xt xai avxov xov %a6ystv, &g ivioxs xovg (isv xs[ivo(isvovg ^ aXXo xi xotovxo %a6yovxag q>SQStv, xovg 6s %aQS6x&xag dtd xr\v %sqI xov ytvo(isvov doijav 237 6 (isvxot ys v%o&i(isvog xo cpv6st
oXcog
cog

cpavXov Xst%oipvystv.

xt

dya&bv

r)

xaxbv

r)

%Qaxxsov i) (if) %Qaxxsov xal yaQ %aQovxcov avxco xovxcov a

slvat

xaQa66sxat %otxiXcog.

vo(iist q?v6si xaxa slvat %oivr\Xaxst6d-at Soxst, xal x&v cpatvo(isvcov dya&&v avxcb ytvofisvog iy%Qaxr\g v%6 xs xov xvcpov xal xov %sqI
xr\v

iv

xotg

d%ooXr\v avxcov q>6\3ov, [xal] svXaftovfisvog avx& q>v6st xaxotg vo(ito(iivotg %aQ

(ir\

%dXtv

yivr\xat,

238 xaQayatg ovyi xatg xvyov6atg %SQt%i%xsf xovg yaQ dva%6Xr\xa slvat xd dya&a Xiyovxag iqjsS-Ofisv ix xfjg d%oQucg xf\g xaxa xr\v dtacpcoviav. o&sv i^tXoyt^ofis&a, oxt si xb xaxov %otr\xtxbv xaxov i6xt xai qpsvxxov, r) 8s %s%oid-r\6tg xov xdSs (isv slvat q>v6st dya&d, xdds Ss xaxd xaQa-

xaxov i6xt xai q>sv%xbv xb v^oxi&so&at xai %s%otftivat qjavXov xi r) dya&bv cog %Qog xr\v q>v6tv slvat. Tavza (isv ovv i%i xov %aQovxog aQxst XsXsy&at %SQi
yag %otst,

dya&&v

xai xaxcov xai ddtaqjoQCOV'

235237

2527, adv. dogm.

158161.

18 post itQaxxiov Gen. inser. r\ (t,r\ %eaxxiov 19 Ss om. T 27 Xtnoipv%slv EB 33 xal om. T cf. p. 8, 23sqq. 3 desistere

compeUemus

TIIOTTn&EEN
XS
Sl

T.

197

S6XI XS%Vr\ TCSQl fiiov.

Xr\

/dr\Xov ds ix xcov TtgostQrjfisvcov, oxt ovds xsyyr\ xig dv 239 si yaQ s6xt rotavrr\ xsyvrj, nsoi xr\v itSQi xbv fiiov.

dya&cov xai xcov xaxcov xai t&v ddtacpOQCOV dtb xovxcov dvvnuQxxcov ovxcov dvvnuQxxog s6xi xai r) yst' xsqi xbv iov xsyyr\. xai dXXcog, insi (ir\ Ofiocpcovcog (itav htoXsinov6t itdvxsg ol doyfiuxtxoi xsyyr\v nsoi |S/ov, dXX
JsgoqIcxv xcov xs

xXXot
zco

dXXr\v
xr\g

vnoxidsvxat, vnoninxov6t
dtucpcoviug Xoyco, ov

xr\

Stacpcovtu

xai

dnb

r\Qcoxr\6u

iv xoig %sq\

vdya&ov XsXsyfisvotg r\(iiv ( 169 sqq.). si (isvxot 240 Kai (jtiav sivat ndvrsg Xsyotsv xa-6"' vn6&s6tv xr\v nsQi xbv 3iov xsyyry , olov xr\v doiSifiov cpQovr\6tv, r\xtg ovsiqoTtoXsixat fisv naQU Sxcotxoig, (iccXXov Ss nXrjxxtxcoriQu
xcov

dXXcov

slvat

naQaxoXov&r\6ov6tv.

Soxsi, xai ovxcog ovdsv r\xxov droniat insi yuQ cpQ0vr\6ig s6xtv aQSxr), xr\v 8s
(ir\

aQsxr\v fiovog stysv 6 oocpog, ot Excotxoi

sov6t. xr\v nsQi xbv fiiov xsyyr\v.
jcat'

ovxsg 6ocpoi ovy

(ir\

oXcog xs, insi

dvvarat 241

avxovg vno6xf\vat xiyyr\, ovds nsQi xbv iov s6xut xsyyr\ xtg o6ov icp' otg Xsyov6tv. otov yovv xsyvrjv slvai cpu6t (Stoic. fr. I 73 Arn.) 6v6xr\(iu ix xuxaXrjipscov,

xuxdXr\iptv 6s xuxuXr\nxtxr\ cpuvxu6iu 6vyxaxdfts6tv.

dvsvQSXog

ds

S6xtv

r\

xaxaXr\nxixr\

cpavxa6ia'

ovxs

ydo nu6u cpuvxu6iu xaxaXr\nxixr\ idxtv, ovxs noia xig s6xtv dnb x&v cpavxa6tcov r) xaxaXr\nxixr\ cpavxa6ia intyvca6%r\vat dvvaxat,
insi
(ir)xs

nu6r\ cpavxa6ia

dvvdfis&a xQivstv
xoiavxr\,
%QX\-

junXcog, xig (iiv s6xt xaraXr\nrixr), xtg Ss ov ^ovxig xs xaxaXr\nxtxr\g cpavxa6iag sig xr\v

iniyvco6tv xov

noia

xig i6rtv r) xuxuXr\nxtxr\ cpavxa6ia sig dnstQOV sxfiaXX6(is&u, sig iniyvco6tv r^g Xu(i(5uvo(isvr\g cog xaxaXr\nxtxrjg

cpavxa6tag xuxuXr\nxtxr\v cpavxu6iav aXXr\v aixovfuvot. xavxd 242

239~adv. dogm. V 173177. 240242 adv. dogm. V 180183.

13 9ov 6
om.

se habet

(cf.

ad 172,9)

28 ix 4

xaxaXTjx}>scov

%axaXa(t,\3avottivr\q

EAB

18 x&ya&ov Bekk.: dya2 xs Bekk.: iyxux. G: om. T

198
xoi kccI

IITPP&NEI&N
ol SxcolkoI (Stoic.
fr.

II

97 Arn.) iv

xf) xf)g

kuxu-

Xr\7txiKf)g cpuvxu6iug ivvoiag a7toSo6SL ovy vyicog cpioovxat,' KaxaXr\7tx LKr\v (ilv yuQ cpavxa6iav Xiyovxsg xr\v uTtb

vnuQyovxog
o

yLvo(iivr\v, vnuQyov Ss sivui Xiyovxsg olov xs %ivslv KuxaXr\7txiKr\v cpavxu6iav, sig xbv

StdXXr\Xov i(i7ti7txov6i xr)g UTtoqiug xqonov. sl xoivvv, ivu fisv TtSQL xbv iov r) xig xiyyr\, Ssl Ttooxsoov slvuv xiyyry,

iva

Se

V7t06xfj

xiyyr\,

KuxdXrjrpLv

7tQ0vcpe6xdvuL,

lvu

Se

V7t06xf)

%uxdXr\ipig,

%uxuXr\7txi%f)
r)

cpuvxu6iu

6vy%axd%s6Lv
cpuvxu6iu,

KaxsiXfjcp&ai, uvevQSxog Si S6xiv

KuxuXr\7txL%r\

dvsvQSxog s6xw r\ TtSQi xbv /3/ov xiyyr\. 243 "Exi %u%sivo Xiysxui. 7tu6u xiyyr\ i% xcov
xf\g

iSicog

v% uv-

&7to6i-do(iivcov

SQycov

Si s6xiv iSiov SQyov xf\g SQyov slvui xuvxrjg Xiyr\

xcov lSlcoxcov,

KuxuXu(i@dve6&ui SoKei, ovSev %sq\ xbv fliov xiyyr\g' o yuQ ccv

xig,

olov xb xi(iuv yovsig,

xovxo kolvov svQi6%sxui kuI xb %uQu&r)%ug unoSi-

Sovul, xu uXXu %dvxu. ov% uqu s6xl xig %sq\ xbv fiiov xiyyr\. ovxs ycx.Q i% xov u%b cpQOvi(ir\g Stu&iescog cpuivs-

244

6&ui y lv 6 (ievdv xi vitb xov cpQOvi(iov r) %ovov(ievov (cog cpu6i XLvsg) e%Lyvco66(ie&u, oxi rrjg cpQovr\6ecog SQyov i6xiv. uvxr\ yuQ r) cpQOvi(ir\ SLud*6ig d%uxdXr\%x6g
l6xi, (if)xe i uvxfjg uTtXcog %ul uvxo&ev cputvofiivrj (if)xs i% xcov SQycov avxfjg' %olvu yuQ s6xl xuvxu %u\ xcov lSlcoxcov. xb xs Xiysiv, oxl xco Sio(iuXi6(ico xcov %Qde,ecov kuxu-

Xu(i(idvo(isv xbv s%ovxu xr\v %sq\ xbv ftiov xsyvr\v,

VTtSQcp&syyOfiivcov s6xl xr\v uv&QcoTtcov cpv6iv %u\ svyofiivcov

(i&XXov

136 sq.) r) xdXrj&f) Xsyovxcov' (o xoiog yuQ voog i6xlv STtLyd-ovicov dv&QcoTtcov olov i% r\uuQ uyr\6L %uxr\Q uvSqcov xs &ecov

xs.

243 244

~ adv. dogm.V 188 189.197 199. 207209.

G
:

15 KatsLlf)cp&aL: ysysvf)a&uL Kayser coll. p. 580, 32. 19 av 21 malim 7tuQu%utu%r)%ag coll. p. 584, 28. (utique): idv 23 ohSs Pappenh. dubit. 24 ylvollsvov GrT (factum) Xsyofievov Stephanus coll. p. 185, 18; at hic yLvoiisvov pro locutione

Gen.

TCQatvoLisvov usurpatur, xs GT (quoque)

:

quae differt a verbo 7toLot>[isvov 28 t&v om. L 31 tf\v Bekk. ta>v

\\

ti

xnoTTnasE^N

r.

199

vexat

Aeinexai Xiyeiv, oxi i% i%etvcov (riovy eQycov %axaXa(if$d- 245 Tteol xbv iov rv/yr\, aiteo r\ dvayQacpov6iv iv raig

fiifiXoig' cov rtoXXcov %ai 7taQa7tXr\6icov aXXfjkoig bvrcov bXiya ix&^GOfiat TtaoaSeiyfiaxog 'faoiv. oiov yovv 6 aiQe6ucQ%r\g avxcov Zf)vcov (Frgm. Stoic. I 250 Arn.) iv xatg SiaxQi\3aig <pr\6t %eQi TtaiScov dycoyfjg dXXa re 3(ioia xai xdSe *Sia-

(ir\Qietv (irjSev (iccXXov (ir\Se r\66ov %aiSt%d r) (ir) 7tatSt%d, (ir\Se &f)Xea r) aQQeva' ov yaQ ScacpioEi iv TtatS t%oig r) (ir) 7tatSt%oig, ovSe &r\Xeiatg i) &QQe6tv, dXXd xavrd itQenei xe %ai itQeitovxa iGriv'.

neQi Se rf\g eig rovg yoveig oGioxrjxog 6 avxbg dvr\Q cpr\6tv 246 eig xd neQt rr\v 'loxa6xr]v %ai xbv OiSinoSa, ort ov% r\v

^Seivbv XQipeiv rr)v

(ir\riQa

a6&evov6av exeQOv

xi fieQog

i)

xaig %eQ6iv cocpiXet, (ihQij XQitpag evcpQatvev, b8vvco(ihvr\v 7tav6ag, %ai TtaiSag i% xf\g (irjXQog yevvaiovg iitoir\6ev, ai6%Q0v;' xovxoig Se b(ioyvco(iovei %ai b XQv6t7t7tog' iv yovv xf\ *7toXixeicc cpr\6i (1117 45 Arn.^) *8o%ei Sh (iot %ai xavxa ovrto Ste^dyetv, Ka&diteQ %ai vvv ov %a%cog itaQa noXXoig el'&t6xat, &6re %ai rr)v (ir\reQa i% rov vlov texvo7toiei6&ai %ai rbv TtareQa i% rf)g \rvyarQog %ai rbv %ai (6vveyp)g %ai 247 b(iO(ir\XQiov i% xf\g b(io(ir\rQiag
>
.

256 Arn.). *%ai el (iev xov 6c6(iaxog XQityag ovSev at6iQov' ei Se exeQa
(I

to^>

j](iiv iitei6ayet' cpr\6i

roig avroig 6vvrdy(iaGiv av&QCOTtocpayeiv yovv (l254Arn.) '%ai idv rcov frav-

iv

hrcov dno%07tf\ rt (ieQog %Qog rQOcpr\v %Qf)6i(iov, (if)re %aroQvrreiv avrb (if)re dXXcog Qinretv, dvaXi6%etv Se airo, bncog i% rcov r\(xexiQtov ereQOV (ieQog

yhvr\rat\

iv Se roig Jtcot rov

%a&f)%ovrog

7teQt

rf\g

rcav 248

245249

~ adv. dogm. V 190196.

8/9
%ccl

3 add. Bekk.
SiacpigtL iv

(differt *'):

$tup,r]Qifeiv Gen. 11 iaxi

Siau,sQi^etv
r\

(aik)

xal om. edd. 23 suppl. e T

22
(et

xbv

6(io(irjtQi.ov

23

(ir\

edd.

10 19*
om.

d(ionr}XQias
itQbg

om.

continu(uym etiam)

25

%Qr\6i(i,ov

200

IITPP&NEI&N
752 Arn.) drtoyevopivcov
*

yovicov xuqpf\g Q~r\x&g cpr\6tv (III

Se

xaig,

x&v yovicov xucpuig %Qr\6xiov xaig drtXov6xd-i\ xov 6c6(iaxog, xa&dneQ 6vv%cov r) s cbg dv

odovxcov r) XQt%&v, ovSev ovxog Ttobg rjfi&g, xui ovSe eni6xqocpr)g r\ noXvcoQiug rtQ06Seo(iivcov r\(i&vii xotavxrjg xivdg. Stb xai %Qi\6i(icov (iev ovxcov x&v
XQecov XQOCpri iQr\6ovxat avxotg, xa&d-neQ xai x&v iSicov fieQcov, otov noSbg dnoxonivxog, ini^aXXe %Qr)6%ai avxco xui xoig nuQunXr\6iotg' d%Qeicov Se ovxcov r\ xuxoQv^uvxeg eu6ov6tv, rj xuxuxuv-

6avxeg
tyavxeg
249

xr\v

xicpQav dcpr\6ov6tv, r) fiuxQOxeQOv q~LovSe(iiav avxcov ent6XQ0cpr\v notr\6ovxat

i)

xa&dneQ ovv%og

xoiavxa (iev nXei6xu o6u dneQ ovx dv xoX(ir\6eiav StunQuxxeGofru, etye (ir\ naQa KvxXcoiptv r) Aut6XQvyo6t noXtxevotvxo. n ei Se xovxcov (iev dveviQyrjxoi navxdnu6iv et6tv, a Se rtQuxrot^rov.'

Xiyov6tv ol cptXo6ocpot'

xov6i, xotvd xai x&v iStcox&v e6xtv, ovSev XStov EQyov e6xi x&v eyetv vrtOrtxevo(iivcov xr\v ne^i xbv iov xiyyr\v. ei ovv

al

(iev

xaXafifidvee&ai)
jS/ov

xiyyut ndvxcog 6cpeiXov6tv ix x&v iSicov eqytav xaovSev Se tStov eQyov oq&xui xr\g nzoi xbv n
xiyyr\g,

Xeyo(iivr\g

ovSe

8iafiefiaiov6Qai

neQi

ov xaxaXa(i($dvexat avxr\. StoneQ avxr)g Svvuxai xtg, oxt l6xiv

vnaQXXr).

x<s

ei

yivexai ev dv&Qconotg
xiivr\.
ei

r\

ne^i xbv iov

ne^i

250

Kai
xiyyr))

(irjv

yivexai
ei (iev

iv

r\xot

cpv6et eyyivexat avxoig

dv&gcortoig r\ Stu 17
r\xot

xbv

fiiov

(iu&r\6eag

xai

sc

St8a6xaXiag.
rtot

dXX'

q>v6et,

xafto

eiotv av&Qco-

dv avxoig r\ ne^i xbv fttov xiyyr\, r) xa&b xa&b (iev ovv oK>x eietv dv&Qconot, xa&6 ei Se ovSa(i&g' ovSe yaQ ovx ei6tv dv&Qcortot. ei6tv av&Qcortoi, nu6tv dv&Qcbrtotg vrtr\Qb,ev dv r) cpQ0vr\6tg,
eyyivotxo

ovx

ctatv dv&Qconoi.

35

1 ovSe

GT

(nec):

ovSev edd.
(ivfJLiay

G: expedit 18 v7taQn.rr\

T 5 MEAB:

4 inipaXXe Bekk.: iniaXe

ide.

<rd

Dyroff

coll. p.

vituQxrtxi}

25

vitf\Q%ev

583,28 Kayser

TII0TTn2E&N
&g ndvxag
cpavXovg 8e
SLGlV

T.

201

elvat

cpQOvifiovg xe xai ivaQexovg xai Gocpovg.

nXei6xovg Xiyov6tv. ovxovv ov8e xa&6 251 CCV avXOtg f) TtSQL xbv jStov ovSs cpvasi aQa. xai aXXcog, insi8f) (Stoic. fr. I 73 xsyyr\. so Arn.) xr\v xs%vr\v 6v6xr\(ia ix xaxaXfjipecov elvai o&fiovXovxat Gvyysyv^vaG^svcov, Sta netQag xe xivog xai

xovg

CCV&QCOTtOl

VTCCCQ^SISV

fia&rJGscog i(icpaivov6t fidXXov dvaXa(ifidvs6&at xdg xs dXXag xsyyag xa\ ravrrjv ne^i rjg 6 Xoyog.

el
1

StSaxrf) iGriv
8tSa6xaXia

r)

iteQi

xbv fliov

xiyyr\.

Ix%
ovSe
f)

dvaXa(i(ldverat. 252 va yccQ VTtoGxaGiv eyr\ ravra, Sei rQia nQOco(ioXoyf\6&at) xb

(ia&r\6et

'AXX

ovSe

xai

StSa6x6(ievov TtQccyfia, xbv StSa6xovra xai xbv fiav&dvovxa, xbv XQOTtov rf)g fia&rJGecog. ovSev Se xovxcov vcps6xr\xev'

StSa6xaXia

ctQa.

xr\
5

ei

eGxi ri St8a6x6(ievov.

Olov yovv xb St8a6x6(isvov f)xot aXrj&sg icxiv f) ipsv- 253 6og' xai si (isv tpsvSog, ovx av 8iSa6xotxo' dvvnaQXxov yaQ cpaGiv slvai xb ipsvSog, dvvitaQxxcov 6e ovx av eir\
6i8aGxaXia.
dXX'

ovS'

ei

dXr\&eg

elvai

Xiyotxo'

oxt

yaQ

dvvTtaQXXov i6rt rb dXrj&eg, vne(ivf\6a(iev iv xoig ne^i

io

xQixr\Qiov

ei ovv [if)xe xb ipevSog (if)xe (II 80 sqq.). xb aXr\&sg St8a6xsxat, naQa Ss xavxa 8i8axrbv ovSsv iouv (pv yaQ Sr\ rovrcov dStSdxrcov bvrcov rovg dnoQOvg (tovovg StSa6xetv i^ei rtg), ovSev 8t8aGxerai. ro re 8i8aGx6(ievov 254

7tQay(ia r\rot <patv6(ievov i6rtv

r)

dSr\Xov.

dXX

ei (ihv cpat-

u*v6(isvov i6rtv, ovx s6rat 8t8a6xaXiag 8s6(isvoV rcc si 8e d8r\Xov, 15 v6(isva nd6tv btioicag cpaivsrat.

yccQ cpatiitet
xct

d8r\Xa 8td rf)v dvenixQtrov ns^i ttvrcbv 8tacpcoviav dxardXrptrd i6xtv 9 &g noXXdxtg vnsfivf^eccfiev, ovx eoxcct
253 254

~ adv. V 232. ~ adv. dogm. V 227228. dogm.

:

-slo&at 30 ix xax. Bekk. iyxax. G 1 7tQOco(ioXoyfja&at 12 &7tOQOV\iivovg L: -0(LoXoysi6d-at EAB 8 Xiyotto om. L SlS. coni. Gen.: ambiguitates T
:

202
8ida%x6v'
o

iitpp&nei&n
181

Sa6%eiv
255
(if)xe

r)

%uxuXu(ifidvei xig, -Jtbog av xovxo Sl(luv&dveLV SvvaLXo; ei Se (ir)xe xb cpaivofievov

yuQ

(ir)

exi xb Sl- 20 xb cc8t]Xov dtduoxexai, ovSev Si8u6%exuL. Su6%6(ievov r\xoi 6oo(id e6xiv r) u6oo(xuxov, endxeoov 8e avxoov r\xoi cpuLvoiievov r) d8r)Xov(ievov <(oi/)> ov Svvuxui

Sidd6ne6&ui %axd xbv luxqoo 7tQ06&ev r)(ilv eiQi](iivov Xoyov. 256 ovx uqu Si8a6%exai xi. itQog xovxoig rjtot xb ov SiSu6xexuL xb (ir) ov. xb (iev ovv (if) ov ov 8i8d6xexui' ei yuQ Sir)
Su6%exui xb
Si8u6xuXiuL, %ul vndQ^ei' 257 xb
(ir)

25

bv, enel xoov dXr)&6ov 8oxov6lv eivui al bv. dXrj&eg e6xai xb (ir) dXrj&eg Se ov
cpu6iv
e6xi

aXrj&eg yuQ elvui %a\ dvxi%eixai xlvl. uxortov Si

(ir)

vTtdQ^ei
vituQieiv
30

Xiyeiv

dXX ovSe ovx uqu SiSu6nexui xb (ir) ov. xb bv. ei yuQ St,Su6%exai xb bv, r]xoi xu&b ov e6xi SiSu6xexuL r) %ux uXXo xl. dXX* ei (iiv, %u&6 (e6xi) bv, 16x1 SlSuxxov, xoov bvxoov e6xui, Siu 8e xovxo ovSe 81xlvoov

bv

8u%xov' xug yuQ 8i8u6%uXiug ex %ul dSiSd%xoov yivee&ui 7tQ06f)xei.

258 bv e6xi Si8u%xov e6xLV.
xal
(ir)v

6(ioXoyov(iivoov 182

ovx

ccqu xb

ov xu&b
xi.

ovSe %ux*

ccXXo

xb

ov i6xiv, (ir) yuQ ov ov% eyei ccXXo xi 6v(ifie@r)%bg uvxop 6o6xe ei xb ov %a&b bv e6xiv ov Sida6%exai, ovSe %ax ccXXo
xi

Si8ay%r]6exai'

exetvo

yaQ

xi

itoxe

e6xi

6v(ifier\xbg
el'rj

uvxoo, bv i6xiv.

%al uXXoog, etxe cpaivbfievov

xb

ov

Xe,ov6L 818^6x^6^01, elxe uSr)Xov, xutg eiQT](iivaig drtOQiuig VTtOTtiitxov dSiSaxxov e6xui. ei Se (if)xe xb ov Si8u6%exui
(if)ve

xb

(ir)

bv, ovSiv e6xi xb 8iSa6%6(ievov.

6

10

%&' ei e6xiv 6 8 i8u6%oov %ul

259
6

(lavQ-dvoov.
xe

(lav&dvoov
255

Ev(iTteQLXQiitexaL (ikv oi)8ev 8e rxxxov %ul ,

ovv

xovxoo

SiSa6%oov

%ul

%uxu iSiav dnoQOvvxaL.

~ adv.

256 258~adv. dogm. V 219223.

259265

dogm.

224231.

~ adv.

dogm.

234238.
est doci-

bile)

22 supplevi 32 add. T (secundum quod est ens, 4 ccXXo om. T 8 inde ab aSrjXov incipit P
r)

10*

el

ioxLV rig SlS.

LLavft.

TnOTTII2EN
r\xot

T.

203

yaq 6
6

xbv axeyyov
15

xeyvixr\g xbv o dxeyvog r)

(iev

uxeyyov.

StSa6xet r) 6 uxeyvog xbv xeyyixr\v r) 6 xeyvixr\g xbv ovv xeyyixr\g xbv xeyvixr\v ov StSu6xet'
xeyyixr\v

ov&exeQog yuQ avxcov, xu&6 eGxv xeyvixrjg , Seixut (lu&r)6ecog. dXX ovSe 6 uxeyvog xbv dxeyvov, &6neQ ovSe xvcpXbv
ovSe 6 uxeyvog xbv xeyvixr\v' 6Sr\yeiv Svvuxut xvcpXog. yeXoiov yuQ. Xeinexut Xiyetv oxt 6 xeyyixr\g xbv axeyyov' 260 20 o xai avxb xcov dSvvdxcov iaxiv. oXcag yuQ vnoaxfjvut

dSvvuxov etvut Xiyexut, inei (ii\xe uvxocpvcog xig xui u(iu xcp yevea&ai xeyyixr\g vcpt6xd(ievog Xinexat (ir)xe
xeyyixrjv

25

yivexai xig xeyyixr\g. r\xot yuQ *ev &ecoQr\(iu xuxdXr iptg Svvuxut %otf\6ut xbv dxeyvov xeyvixry dXX ei (iev xuxdXrjiptg (iiu xbv uxeyyov xeyyi- 261 r) ovSu(icog. xr\v dneQydfexut, nQcoxov (ihv eveaxui Xiyetv, oxt ovx etixi
i

dxeyyov
(iia

xai

gv6xi\jxu
l

ix

'

xuxuXrjtyecov
elxu

r\

xiyvrj

yuQ

(ir\Sev

bXcog

eiScog, ei ev &ecoQi\(ia

Xiyotxo
80 (iuxu

elvat.

SiSaypeir\ xeyyr\g, xeyyixr\g dv ovxco xul iuv Xiyrj xtg, cog 6 xtvu ftecoQr)-

xui nQ06Se6(ievog evbg ext xul Stu xovxo cbv dxeyvog, uv xb 'ev ixeivo nQ06Xdr\, xeyyixr\g 5 dxeyyov dnoxeXeixut ix xuxuXr)ipecog (Jttag, dnoxXr\Qcoxixbv Xit-et. inl yuQ xcov xuxu (liQog ovx uv Svvutxo Sei^ui 262
xiyyr\g
dvetXr\cpcog

i83xivu
,

uxeyyov

(iev

ext,

xeyyixry

Se i6o(ievov,

iuv ev

xt

d^ecoQTjfiu

nQ06Xd($r\'

ov yuQ
xiyyr\g
,

d ecoQi\(idxcov
&(it\6u(ievog
5

exd6xr\g

Sf)nov xr\v ini6xuxui xtg,

&ecoQi\(iaxu,
xfjg

xtov iE,aQi&(itr\6tv

&6xe

dnaQtXeinexat

xu

iyvco6(iivu
xcov

no6u
xiyyrjg

%Qog
einetv

xbv

%Xr\Qi\

d ecoQr\(idxcov
evbg

eyetv.

ovxovv

&ecoQi\(iuxog

yvco6tg

ov

UQt&fibv notei

xbv dxeyyov xeyvixr\v. ei Se xovxo i6xtv dXrjxrig, inel (ir\ 263 ndvxa d&QOcog xu &ecoQr\(iuxu xcov xeyycov dvuXu(i($dvet
xig,
10

dXX* etneQ uQa, xuxu

ev

exu6xov, ivu xtg xai xovxo

&ecoQi\(iu

jca#' vnod-e6tv StSco, 6

Xufifidvetv

Xey6(ievog

xaxu *ev ovx dv

T^g tiyyr\g dvuyivotxo'

vnefit-

xeyyixr\g

17 &6%zq <yae>
tur): cpaivBTut
TaXr\xpecov

P 18 26 iviexat
iyvco6(iiva

P: om.

G
:

GT

(inerit)

21 tiystui ^veGTtv P

GT (dici-

Paris suppl. 133: SyxaT

27 ixxa33 29 Xiyoi Gen.

SvvatTO om.

(tw) P

204
(ivr\Gxo\isv yuQ,

IITPP&NEI&N
i83
oxt

ov Svvaxat
xsyyixrjv.

&scoQr\ficcxog

xbv

dxsyyov

notf\Gat

ovSs
Std

sE,

ivbg yv&Gtg dxsyyov xoivvv

15

ylvsxai xig xsyyixr\g.

coGxs

xcct

xavxa cpaivsxat dvv-

noGxaxog slvai 6 xsyvixrjg. Std Ss xovxo xcct 6 StSuGxcov. 264 dXX' ovSs 6 fiav&dvstv Xsyofisvog, dxsyyog cov, Svvaxat
xd
xs
xf\g
xccl

oGov

xsyyr\g &scoQr\fiaxa , r\g iGxtv dxsyyog, fiav&dvstv cog yaQ 6 ix ysvsxf\g nrjQog^ slg xccxaXafiftdvstv. sGxl nr\Qog, ovx av Xd@ot yQcofidxcov dvxiXr\xptv, ovSs

6 ix ysvsx fjg xcocpbg bfioicog cpcovrjg,

xccxaXdfiot

ovxcog ovSs 6 dxsyyog 20

av xd xr)g xsyvr\g &scoQrj[taxa r\g sGxiv dxsyyog. xal yaQ dv ottxcog 6 avxbg sl'r\ xsyylxr\g xs xcct dxsyvog x&v avxcov, dxsyyog fisv insi ovxcog vnoxstxat, xsyylxr\g
25

Ss insi %axdXr\tyw syst xtov xr\g xiyyr\g \rscoQr\fidxcov. 265 coGxs ovSs 6 xsyvlxr\g xbv dxsyvov StSuGxst. si Ss fir\xs 6 xsyyixr\g xbv xsyyixr\v StSuGxst fif\xs 8 dxsyyog xbv dxsyyov
(ir\xs

TtttQa

Ss xavxa

axsyyog xbv xsyyixry \ir\xs 6 xsyyixr\g xbv dxsyyov, ovSsv sGxtv, ovxs 6 StSaGxcov sgxiv ovxs

6 StSaGxofisvog.
X'

si

Mr\

ovxog Ss

sGxt xtg [iad"f\Gscog XQonog. fif\xs xov fiav&dvovxog fif\xs xov

SiSd-

30

266 Gxovxog xcci 6 XQonog xf\g StSaGxccXiag nccQsXxst. OvSsv Ss r\xxov xcd (ovxogy Std xovxcov dnoQStxai. 6 yuQ XQonog xr\g SiSaGxaXiccg r\xot ivuQysicc yivsxat r) Xoyco' ovxs Ss ivccQ-

ovSs 0I184 yivsxai ovxs Xoyco, xa&dnsQ naQuGxr\Gofisv' XQonog uqcc Tijg (iadr\Gscbg iGxtv svnoQog. ivuQysicc fisv ovv ov yivsxav StSaGxaXia, insl xcov Sstxvvfisvcov iGxlv r) xb Sh Sstxvvfisvov naGiv iGxi cpcctvofisvov' xb ivuQysiu. Ss cpatvofisvov , r\ cpaivsxcct, n&Giv iGxt Xr\nxov' xb Ss 5
ysicc

266269

~ adv. dogm. V 239243.

M

19 &v Xdfiot P: dvaldot GT (non assumeret) ig GP et EA.B om. L 29 a tit. exst. in L et P; in sectio nova incipit v. 31 O&Shv xrX. praefixo titulo: d Vort, 32 ovzog addidi, xard ISiav Riistow coll. lia&rjcscog tQoitog 33 ivagysLa utrobique Fabr.: ivsQysia GPT (actu) p. 182,12
18

24

rf\s

TII0TTn2EN
...
xotvcog
7tcc6t

I\

205

Saxxov

e6xtv.

Xr)nxbv xai

dSiSaxxov'
(ir)v
r)

ycco rjxoi 6r)(iaivet

xi

ovx ccqcc xt evaqyeia 81ovSe Xoyco 8i8a.6y.tTai xi. ovxog 267 ovSev 6r)(iaivsi. dXXd (ir/Sev (iev
xi

6r)[iaivcov ovSe
10 xt,

6xat xivbg
6r)(iaivet
(ir)

r)xot

cpv6et

ei 8e 6r)(iaivei 8tSa6xaXtx6g. ftieei. xal cpv6ei (iev ov r)

6r)(iaivet

Std

xb

ndvxag ndvxcov

dxovovxag 6vvtivat,
&e6et 268
drv
eh,

olov "EXXrjvag

fiaQfidqcov xal fiaQaQovg 'EXXf)voov.

8e ei 6r](iaivet, SfjXov cog ol (iev nQoxaxetXrjcpoxeg

xa&
ovx

ai
15

Xi^etg

ei6t

xxay(iivat

dvxtXfjtpovxat

xovxcov,

avxcbv 8tSa6x6(ivot arceQ r)yv6ovv, dXXd dva(it(ivr)6x6(ievot xal dvaveovfievot xavxa dnsQ r]Se6av, oi Se %Qr)ovxeg xf)g
x&rv dyvoovfiivcov
(iad-r)6ecog

xal

(ir)

siSoxeg,

xa&

&>v ei6iv

20

StoneQ 269 Svvatxo av. xai xf)g vno6xf)vat yaQ b 8i8a6%cov xaxdXr)iptv x&v &ecoQr)(idxcov xr)g 8t8a6xoai Xi^etg
xexay(iivat,

ovSevbg

dvxiXr]tptv

'e%ov6tv.

ovSe 6 XQOTtog
(tivrjg

(ia&f)6ec0g

xiyyrjg

i(inoteiv

ocpeiXet

xa>

(tav&dvovxt, Xva ovxcog

yivr)xat.

ixeivog

xb

6v6xi](ia

xovxcov
cog

xaxaXafidrv xeyyixr\g

ev xotg e'(inQ06&ev vne(ivf)6a(iev ( 264)' ovxovv ovSe 6 XQonog rfjj StSa6xaXiag

ovSev 8i i6xt xaxdXrjiptg,
25

vq>e6xdvat Svvaxat. ei 8e (xf)xe xb 8tSa6x6(ievov e6xt (if)xe 6 Si8a6xcov xa\ 6 fiav&dvcov (if)xe 6 XQonog T-Jjg (ia&f)6ecog, oftxe (id&r)6tg e6xtv ovxe StSa6xaXia.

iteQt (ia&f)6eag 270 eve6xt 8e dnoQiv otixco xai ini xf)g Xs80 yo(iivt]g TtSQt iov elvat xi'/yr]g. otov yovv xb (iev 8tSa6xo(ievov nqay(ia, xovxi6xt xr]v q>Qovr)6iv, dvvno6xaxov iSei(iev

Tavxa

ovv xotvoxeQOv intx%siQr]xat

xai

StSa6xaXiag'

h,a(iev ev xotg k'(inQ06d-V ( 240)" dvvno6xaxog 8i e6xt 185 xai 6 8t8a6xcov xat (lav&dvcov. r)xot yaQ 6 q>Qovt(iog

xbv aqjQOva
5

xbv tpQovt(iov StSd^et xr\v nsqi xbv iov xiyyry r) 6 dcpQoov 6 dcpQtov xbv cpQOvt(iov r) 6 cpQOVtfiog xbv r) dcpQOva' ovSelg 8e xovxarv ovSiva 8tSa6xet' ovx aQa StSd6xexat
r)

neQt xbv fiiov slvat XeyO(tivr)

xiyyr).

xai neqi (iv 271

270272

~ adv. dogm. Y 243247.

GT
9 ovSsig

(ihv

add. P: om.

EAB

27

(td&Tjeig

<tis>

30

Ttsgl

<rov^> Gen.

10 xi alt. om. 6 slvai om. L

206
xcov dXXcov

iitpp&nei&n

si 8s 6 l'6cog nEQixxbv xui Xiystv' cpQOvtfiog xbv 8t8a6xst xr)v cpQ0vr)6tv, r) 8e cpQ0vr)6tg ent6xf)(ir) cccpQOva

e6xiv dya&cov xai xaxcov xui ov&exiQcov,

cpQ0vr)6tv dyvotav xcov xai ov&exsQcov, ayvoiav Se
(ir)

acpQcov

dya&cov xui xaxovxcov e%cx.v ndvxcog 8t8u6xovxog avxbv xov cpQovitcov xa ccyaQ-d xai xuxd xui ov&exeQa dxov6exut (tovov xcov Xeyofiivcov, ov yvco6exut 8e xuvxu. ei yuQ dvxtXu(idvotxo uvxcov ev dcpQ06vvr\ xue%cov xr\v
ey^et

xcov

10

d e6xcog
,

e6xut xui

r)

272 xa\ ov&exeQ(ov &ecoQr)xtxf).

r)

dcpQ06vvr) xcov xe dyu&cov xal xaxcov ovyi 8i ye xovxcov xaxd avxovg

15

dcpQ06vvrj &ecoQY)xtxr)
6

xade6xr)%ev, enei

cpQOvticog.

uqu
(ir)

dcpQtov
r)

ovx

dcpQcov e6xut dvxtXu(iL3dverut xcov vnb xov

6

qpQOvifiov Xeyofiivcov
6ecog

Xoyov.

nQuxxociivcov xuxu xbv xfjg cpQOvr)dvxtXu(iL3uv6(ievog 8e ovx dv 8t8u6KOtxo

20

vn uvxov,
8vvuxui
(if)xe

8tu Xoyov (ir)xe evuQyeiu fif)xe 8tdu6xe6&ut, xu&d nQoetQf)xa(iev. nXr)v dXX'' el 8lu (ia&r)6ecog xal 8t8u6xuXiug eyyivexui xivi r) itSQi
Xeyofievr)
xiyyr)
(if)xe

uXXcog xe xal enei

xbv

fiiov

cpv6et,

dvevQExog E6xtv

r)

nuQU xotg cptXo6ocpotg &QvXov(iivr) xiyyr) TteQt xbv fiiov. 273 Et (livxot xui 8oir) xtg ex noXXov xov neQtovxog iyyi- 25
vs6&ui
xtvt
xf)v

6viQ07toXov(iivr)v

xiyyr)v

TtEQt

xbv iov,

lSXu^equ xul xuQuyf)g uixiu cpuvr)6exut (iccXXov xoig eypv6tv

uvxr)v
r)

cocpiXttiog.

Xa'

ei chcpsXei

r)

neQi xbv fiiov xi%vr) xbv ey^ovxa

uvxf)v.
tva
7tuQu8iy(iuxog

Avxixu yovv,
noXXcov
SL7tco(isv,

cocpsXEtv

dv

evexev oXiyu dnb xbv 6ocpbv r) nsQi^* 8oxoir)

30

rbv

ftiov

xiyyr\

nQog

xb

xuXbv

iyxodxEtuv uvxco nuQsypicivr) iv xaig xai iv xaig dnb xov xaxov OQLiuig

273 277~adv. dogm. V 210215.

rj

14 xul ante
21
obliterati

om.

p. 594, 4: tfjg ^T}tr)as(og

18/19 rfjg q)Qovr^ascog (questionis): x-qaascog Gr (in

Gen.
:

scr.

coll.

vv. 18

sunt):

ita&rjascog

tfjg

23

GT

XsyoLtivt] xs%vi\

MLP:

xiryt) Xsy.

EAB

Bekk. 31 xaXbv P: xaxbv

(La&fjasojg

(malum)

TnoTTn2EaN
acpOQfiaig.

r.

207

86

6 ovv Xey6(ievog xax avrovg iyxQurf)g 6ocpbg 274 xurd xovxo Xiyerut iyxQurf)g, xa&oGov iv ovSe(itd yif)rot verat OQfifj xy TtQog xb xuxbv xui dcpoQfif) xfj dnb zov
r)

etye (iev cpuvlug OQficcg xui dcpoQfidg, dXlu xaru (isv xb (if) 275 neQtexQUTet Se uvrcbv tco \6ycp. iv cpuvXutg XQi6e6tv ovx av e'ir] iyxQurf)g' ov yivsa&ut xai cog ovx uv etnot xig xbv yccQ XQurf)6et ov ovx iyet.

dyu&ov,

%a&o6ov

evvovypv iyxQurf) itQog dcpQoSi6tu xai xbv xuxo6TO(iuiovvru HQog iSe6(idrcov dn6Xav6tv (pvd' oXcog yuQ int^f)rr]6tg
10

ylvexai rcov toiovtcov, tva xai iyxQurcbg xaxel-avu6zcb6t xf)g inir]rr)6ecog), xco avxco TQonco ovSe rbv 60cpbv iyxQarf) Qrjreov Stu rb (if) cpve6&ut iv uvrcb nd&og o&

avxoig

el Se xard rovro dtco6ov6tv avrbv vtcuq- 276 syxQuxf) xu&o6ov yiverut (iev iv cpuvXatg XQt6e6tv, nsQtyiverat Se avrcov tco Xoyco, nQcbrov (*ev Sco6ov6tv, ort 15 ovShv cocpiXr]6ev avrbv i) cpQovi]6tg, dx(if)v iv ruQuyutg

i6rui iyxQurrjg.
ystv

ovru xui ftorj&etug Se6(ievov,

eiru xui

xuxoSut(iovi6rsQog

r&v

ei (iev yuQ 6q(iu ini cpuvXcov Xeyo(iivcov evQt6xerut. rt, TtdvTcog ruQu66srut, ei Se neQtXQurei tco Adyco, 6vvi%et iv suvrco to xuxov, xui Stu rovro fiuXXov ruQu66srat rov 20

cpuvXov ixeivov
raQu66eTat,
ei

TUQuyf\g. vf\6et 6 6ocpog'

rovro nu6ypvrog' ei (isv yuQ 6q(iu, 277 rvyydvet rcbv int&vfit&v, nuverui rfjg ov roivvv iyKQurf)g yiverut o6ov ini rf) cpQO(ir]xirt

Se

r)

etnsQ yivsrut, ndvrcov dv&Qconcov isri

25

xaxoSat(iovi6rurog, StonsQ ovx cbcpiXetav, dXXd ruQU%f)v uvrcp ort Se 6 vo(ii(ieyi6rr]v f) ns^i rbv fiiov nuQi6ys riyvrj.
cov

uvxf)g inesystv rf)v nsQi rbv (liov reyvr]v xui St yvcoxsvut, rivu ri i6nv dyu&u cog nQog t^v cpvatv xui rivu cpuvXu, ruQu66erut 6cp6$Qu xui rcov dyu&cbv uvrcb naQov-

tcov xai
30

r&v

xuxcbv, iv roig
ori ei (if]re
f)

Xexriov

ow,

acWgpoocov

vno6ru6tg

vne(ivf)6a(iev. dyadcbv re xui xuxcbv xui 278 6(ioXoyeirut, f) re ne^i xbv iov
rcov

snnQoe&ev

32 aocpng om. T, sed exstat quoque p. 587, 17. 3 cpuvXcov L 6 ov om. P: f)g A 9 tcov xotovxcov GT (talium): tovxcov P sicut p. 587,25. 17 18 20 21 r) pro d P sicut G f) p. 588, 1. 2. 4. 5. 21 tr)g ora. L 24 Siottsq P: mats G: quod T 28
tuQ. dcpodQu

GT

(turbatur valde): ocpodQu tuQuxtetut

208

IITPP&NEI&N TII0TTn2&N

V.
186

riyyr} xdyu fisv xai dvvno6xax6g i6xtv , si Ss xa\ vcps6xdvai So&slt] xa& ^Tto&sGiv , ovSefiiav cbcpiXetccv xoig syov<Siv

avxrjv naqiyst,

rovvavriov Ss xaqayag avroig ifinoieiz8j

oi Soyfiartxot

(tsyfoxag, fidxrjv cocpqvco6&at Soxoiev ccv

xdv
cog
5 1

x&
279
sv

Xsyofiivco rj&txco fiiqet

xyg xaXovfiivr\g cptXo6ocpiag.

6vfifiirqcog

To6avxa
i

xai

neqi xov rj&txov xonov

,

evrav&a neqtyqdcpofiev xoci xo xqirov 6vvrccyfia xui xb nav rcov Uvqqcovsicov vnorvbnorvnco6et
Ste!-eX&6vrsg

KC06SC0V 6novSa6fia, sxsivo inetnovreg'

X
280

Si^d xi 6 6xenrtxbg eviore dfivSqovg xalg nt&av6rr}6tv eqcorccv entrrjSevet Xoyovg.

6xenrtxbg Std xb cptXdv&qconog slvai xr\v rcov Soyfiaxtxcov oi'rj6iv xs xai nqonixetav xaxd Svvafiiv taG&ai Xoyco fSovXexcct. xa&dneq ovv oi xcov 6cofiaxtxcov na&cov iaxqoi Std- 10
cpoqa xccxd (liys&og eyov6t ^orj&rjfiaxa,
xcci xoig fiev

6cpoSqcog

nenov&o^t xa 6cpoSqd xovxcov nqo6ayov6t, xoig Se xovcpcog xa

xovcpoxeqa, xai 6 6xenxixbg ofixcog Siacpoqovg iqcoxa [xcu] 281 xaxd i6yyv Xoyovg, %ai xoig fiev ififiqt&i^i xai evxovcog dva6xsvdsiv Svvttfiivotg xb xrjg oir\6ecog xcov Soyficcxtxwv nd-

15

&og ini

xcov

6cpoSqa

xr\

nqonsxsia

xsxaxcofiivcov

yqfjrat,

voig Ss xovcpoxiqoig ini xcov emnoXutov xui eviurov iypvxcov xb xfjg oir)6ecog nd&og xai vnb xovcpoxiqcov nt&avoxrjxcov

dva6xevde6&ai

fiqt&etg xaig

ntftavoxrySiv ,

Svvafiivcov. Stoneq bxe fiev ifibxe Se xai dfiuvqoxiqovg cput- 20

vofiivovg ovx bxvei Xoyovg 6vveqcoxuv b dnb xf)g axeipscog bqficofievog, inirrjSsg, cog dqxovvrag avxco noXXdxtg nqbg
to dvvstv to nqoxeifievov.

11 post fiiys&oQ desin. Bekk. 16 acpoSgu scr. cum

sitate):

13 xul sup.
et

lin.

M,

del.

(vehementi presumptuo-

6(p6doa edd.

Specimen Translationis
In fine codices (excepto

latinae.

209

M) addunt:

1 IIvqqcov fiiya ^avfia 7tcpa6fivov cog TtXiov ovdiv, rcov dXXiov e'xqov %Qr)fid ftafifiaXiov.

i fihv VTtQcptdX(og

tt

ivavrlov iX&ifiEv irXrjg, 6vfi7tdvrcov y 6ocpcov cpv o6ov r\6&a rdXag' Sh %hv l8fio6vvr\g rrjg avdQOfiirjg xar^yvcoxcog,

xar

rd 7tQcori6ra cpiQig rav

6ocpir]g xariyvcog.

Specimen Translationis
(III
i.i

latinae.
editionis.)

3036.

p.

141143 huiusce

De

Nunc faciat dici agenti quidem igitur causa tot compendiose autem et de principiis que materialia vocantur dicendum est quod enim ipsa sunt inconprehensibilia facile est

considerare ex dissonantia facta de hiis

a dogmaticis pherecides quidem igitur syrus terram dixit &

omnium thales autem millesius aquam anaximander autem auditor ipsius infinitum anaximenes 9 r Y 2 autem et diogenes apolloniates aerem ypasinus autem metapontinus ignem exenophanes autem colophonius terram et aquam oenopides autem chius ignemetaerem-ypporeginus ignem et aquam onoma certus autem in orficis ignem et aquam et terram qui autem circa empedoclem
esse principium

'
|

io

et stoicos

aquam terram] quidem

quid oportet et

ignem aere<m)> aquam terram de materia [aere a quibusdam sine qualitate monstruosa dicta [a]quam nec ipsi apprehendere affirmant
dicere qui vero circa aristotelem

is

pery-

pateticum ignem aerem aquam terram circulariter motum corpus democritus autem et epicurus attoma anaxagoras autem clazomenius similium partes diodorus autem
cui cognomen- saturnius minima et indivisibilia corpora 20 eractides autem ponticus et asclepiades bithinensis ine

quales magnitudines pictagorici autem numeros mathematici autem terminos corporum st<V^>ato autem phisicus qualitates tanta igitur et ad huc pluri dissonantia facta

SextuB Empiricus

I.

14

210

Specimen Translationis
eis

latinae.

de materialibus principiis ab
positis

dissensionibus et

aliis

aut omnibus concedemus etiam aut quibusdam set

omnibus quidem non est possibile Non enim poterimus et hiis qui sunt circa asclepiadem concedere frangibilia 5 esse elementa dicentibus et talia ex hiis qui circa democritum attoma ipsa esse dicentibus et non qualificata ex que circa anax<^ag^>oram omnem sensibilem qualitatem in omiomeriis relinquentibus si autem aliquam opinionem ab aliis proponemus autfem] simpliciter et sine demonstratione preferamus aut cum demonstratione sine quidem igitur demonstratione manifestum est quia veram oportet demonstrationem esse vera aute<^m)> non utique dabitur non iudicata iudicio vero verum autem iudicium esse ostenditur per demonstrationem iudicatam. Si quid<em)> ut demonstrationem quidem que prefert aliquam opinionem vera esse demonstretur oportet iudicium ipsius demonstratum esse ut autem iudicium demonstretur oportet demonstrationem eius preferre qui per se invicem invenitur modus qui non dimittet procedere rationem demonstratione quidem semper iudicio indigente demonstrato Si autem semper iudicio autem demonstratione iudicata iudicium iudicio iudicare et demonstrationem demonstratione demoostrare voluerit aliquis in infinitum eicietur Si enim neque omnibus de elementis opinionibus possumus concedere neque alicui harum desistere convenit de hiis.
hiis

10

'^''

15

20

25

concedimus

24 epimonibus T

SINDIN& DEPT.

FEB 1

1959

PLEASE

DO NOT REMOVE
FROM
THIS

CARDS OR

SLIPS

POCKET

UNIVERSITY

OF TORONTO

LIBRARY

PA 4410 S5A15 T.l

Sextus Empiricus Opera.