You are on page 1of 33

Page 1

.
. .

,
,


1
. , 1915 .


*
- , , , ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , ,

,


1914 .
,
,
2
1915 . 26-,

,
,

* 15. 04. 2017


1 , 10 ( ,
), . 1995, ., . 7, 177
2 , () , 2014, N 2 (46),
224-243
Page 2

, , ,

1.

,
, ,
, ,
,
3
1915 .
300

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
,




, ,
,
, ,
4 ,
,
.
- ,
5
.
,
, ,

,
,

6
, .
, 7
- , 10-12
, 4-5
30 8,

3 , , ., , . 8, 349-391
4 , 402
5
6 , 404
7
8
Page 3

9
1915 . ,
, . ,

, , ,
, 10
29-
.
-
- ,
-
- ,
(, ), () (100
)
( )11

, ,
, ,
,
,
,
, ,
,
- ,



,
,
-
. -
- 12
13 , ,
, ,
,

,
, 7

200- ,

9 , 409
10 , 397
11 , 401
12 , 405
13 , 407
Page 4

14,


7
,
.
, , 15


, ,-
,-
,


,
16

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
,
,
.


, -

1914-1918 . 100
-
18-
,
,
17
, ,

, .
, ,
, ,
,

,
, ,
, ,
,
,
,
, 18 (
14 , 402
15 , 403
16 , 7, 578
17 , 441
18 , 7, 440
Page 5

- ..) , ,
, ,
, , ,
,

,

, ,
,

,
,

,
,
.

, 19 ( - . . )
1915 .
,


1915 . 18-
300
19- 20
.
-
,
, , , , ...
- , , ,

, 21


,
22,-
. - (-)

, ,
.
,

19 , 441
20 - 1852-1942 -
21 . , 4000- , , (1908 -
1918), , 4, 752 (. , )
22 -, , 1914-1915 ., ., 1917, 476
Page 6


,
,
. 27-,
, ,
1915 . 23-
,


.

, ,
, ,
23

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
1915 . 26-

, 24,
25,
,
, ,
, 26
,
, ,
.
,

- ,
, ,

,
, ,
.
, ,

, 27
,
14-, (
,
23-, ),

,
23 , , 1915, 22, N 162
24 , , . 7, 177
25 , 176
26 , 194
27 , 178-177
Page 7

2.
, ,

1915 . . ,

,
, , .

29-

, ,

, , , -
,
. , ,
.. 28
,
, ,
, ,
. - 29
,
30, -
30-
. , ,
, , --
-
-
-
- ,

-
.. - , - - -
, - ,
, - ,
31
32 ,
28 , . 8, 405-406
29 , 405
30
31
32 (20.12.1872, . . -1945, )
, , , ,
( , 1914 .
Page 8



.
- , , ,
,- -
, , ,
. ,
,
-
,
, .
33

, . .

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
, , ,

,
,
- 34
,

35
, ,


. -
, , - , - -
- 36 ,
, ,
,
,
- , 37

, ,

1915 . ),
140
1912 . ,

33 , ( ), . , 504 ,
, ,
, ,


34 , 136
35 , 584
36 , , . 8, 409
37 , 411
Page 9


.
-
- -
- 38
, 500
.
. , ,
39, - 8- 14-,
500
40


2000 ,
405-
200
, 41,


, , , , , ,
, , , -
45 785 42
,


, , ,
,
,

.
,
, , 43

, , , , ,
,

. ,
,
,
38 , 406
39 , 10, 228
40 , 229
41 , 72
42 , , . 8, 407
43 , , ., 2009, ., 125
, ` .

Page 10

44



1918 . 12-, .
, .
, , .
,
, 45

3.
,
, , ,
,


-

() , 2 (58), -, 2017

1915 . 7 -
. , . , ,
,

,
46

, .
350 2000 ,

,
, , , ,
,
,
47 ,
, ,
,
,

,


,
.
. ,
, , , , -

44
45 , , . 2, 73
46 ,, 60
47
Page 11

, .
-
48
49


,
, .
, - -
50
, , ,



,
, ,
, 51

, -,


,
1915 . 6-

. .
,
52
5-
. . . ,
,

53
. ,
.
,
54

, ,
,

48 , , . 8, 408
49
50
51
52 , , N 1674 (491)
53 , , .32
54
Page 12



,


. .
, - 55
(
), , , , ,

, , ,
-
,
, , 30-

() , 2 (58), -, 2017

,
. .
. ,
,
56 ,
,
200- 20-30 ,
57
,

,


,
1915 5-
.

. ,

.
.
, , ,
58

55 , , . 8, 408
56 , , . 32
57 , , . 7, 178
58 , , N 1897 (175, 3- .)
Page 13

4.
1915 .


,- ,-
- , 20
, ,
- -
,
, 59

.
- ,
,
, 200-
( ), ,
,

,
4 - ()60
,

.
,
,

61 1915 . 30-

.
-
,
, , , ,

62 ,
500 ,

, ,

59 ` (1879,
-29. 01. 1919 ), 1905-
1915 . ,
1916
-1917 , 1917


60 , , . 8, 406-407
Page 14



, 63
,



,



64 30-
,
. 30/7- /
1915- . ,

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
, , 65
1915 30
.
. . . . ,


, 66
- ,
(), 5 500
3000
800

,
, ,

1915 . ,

,


,


,
63
64 ,
( , , N 1728 )
,
,

65 , , N 1728
66 , , 1915, 9, 14, N 178,182
Page 15

,

,
, ,
,

,
1915 . 9-
.
.. . , . , . . ,

67

. , . , . 5
14-,
,
,
.
3 6 ,
, ,
. . .
, .
. 68

, 31- ,
,-
,- ,
.

, ,

, ,
, 4-5 69


, ,
70

67 , , 1915, N 178, 9, 3
68 , N 182, 14, 3
69 , 7273
70
,
,

Page 16



71
,

, ,
. , ,
, ,
72
,


(
) , ,
.
,

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
. ,
, ,
73

74 , ,

. . ,
75

,
.
,
,
,
,
,
, ,
, ,
,

, ,
, -
71

, .
, .
, ( , , 124)
72 , , 124
73
74 , ,
, (, ,
. 7, 178) , .
, , , (, 686)
75 , 686
Page 17

76
,
, ,
,
. 1.
2, 3, 4,
5, 6. 7, ,
- 20 , 10.77

1915 . 8- .
, ,
, ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
, ,
78
. ,
, ,

, ,
,
, , 79
.

- ,
. -
, ,

( )
80
.
, ,
, ,
81

, .
, - , -
- , , ,
, -
- - ,

76 , , . 7, 178
77 , , 32
78 , , . 10, 228
79 , . 7, 180
80 , , 32
81 , , 32
Page 18

82 ,


,
. ,
83
,
, 84

,
, , ,
,

. , ,
85

. - , 86

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
,
,

, . ()
- 87,
. , ,,
88
, 28-
7000 , 3000-


,
-
- , , - .
, - , - 89

, ,
,
. , , 90

,
, , ,

. ,
82 , , . 8, 408-409
83 , 409
84 , 846
85 , , . 8, 409
86 , 408
87 , 409
88
89
90
Page 19

, ,
,
, , , ,
,
,
, , ,

,


, ,
,
,
, , ,
,

() ,
,

, ,

,
, .
23- (1915 . - . .) 70 ,
, 24-

- 91
, ,
, ,
.
-

-
. ,
, , ,
, , , ,
, ,
92 ,


. ,
,
93

91 , , 8, 410
92 , , 1930, 13, N 83, 3
93 , 1939, 15, N 12, 2
Page 20

, .


,
, . , ,
, , , 50 94

5.

,
,
,

,

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
. , , ,
,
, ,
, ,
, , 95

, ,


, ,

-, ,
. ,
,

,
. , ,
,
,

, ,
, ,
, ,
96


,
. , , , ,
, .
94 , , . 32
95 , 136
96 , 684
Page 21

-
, .-
, 97

6.
1915-1918 .
, ,
,

, ,
.
, , ,

, ,
, ,
, , ,
, ,
,

- , ,

- ,
, ,
98
,
,
5 -,
99

97
98 , , , ., 1986,
73 , ,
, .
, ,
( )
99 , , , 15
,
,
,

. , ,
,
. - ,
, ,
( ,
, , ., 1986, 74)
Page 22

7.



,

,



, ,
, 19-
100 .
- 101
,- ,-

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
, ,
(
, )
` ,
,
, ,
102
,
,

103

8.

(
- ), , ,

,
, ,

, -
, , ,
,
,
,
1915 .
.

100 , , . 8, 410
101
102 , , 126
103 , , 1982, N 1, 39 , 137
Page 23



, .


. ,
,
104
, .

-

, ,
, ,
105 ,
,

,


, ,
, , ,

,
,
, ,
,

106



,
,
,
` ,

107

104 , , , ., 2013, 26
105 ., , ., 1966, 153
106 ., . , , ., 1939, 15,
N 12, 2 , . 1, ., 2002, 192
107 1915 . ,


,
, , .,1958, 206

Page 24

9.


29-
125 , 43
, ` ,
` 108
- 29-
1
-
,
` 1-
109
`


() , 2 (58), -, 2017
, , ,


1915 2/15-

, ,
,
,


.

.

. , ,
,
.


110
2- ,
- ,

,
168 ,

,

108 , 71
109 , , 32
110 , , N 1352 (152 3- .)
Page 25

,
350
1915 . 1-

.
350 ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
, , 111
31-
. ,

... , ,
112
1-,
.
7-
600 ,
700
25 000 113
1915 . 7-

. 7 . ...
( ) ,
7 ,
,
99
( )114
1915 . 8-

, 18 ,

.
,
, ,
115 . ,


,
, ,

111 , , 1915, 1, , N 137
112 , 72
113 , , . 10, 230
114 , , . 32
115 , , 1915, N 215
Page 26


- .... 116

,
, ,
, ,
,
, ,
,

, , ,
, 117

. , ,
, ,

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
, ,
118
15
,
46-
,
, ,
, ,
119
,
1915 . 10- .
120
1915 .
, ,
40 ,

.,

,

,
1915 . 1-

. . - ,
. ,-

, ,
116 , , . 8, 410-411
117 , , 129
118
119 , 130
120 , , . 10, 232
Page 27


, 121
1916 . ,
. 122
, ,
123
,
1916 . 1- .
,
, , , ,
, ,
, () ,
, - 124
, ,

. , ,

, , , ,
,
, , ,
, ,
-
, ,
, ,
, , ,
, , , 125

N 1
1915
4- ,

.
.
,
, 500 300- , 100-
, 100- ,
N 1
, N 2 ,

,
,
121 , 152
122 , , . 10, 240
123 , 232
124 , 245
125
Page 28


126

,
- ,
127

,
, , ,

, 128
, ,
. ,
,

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
, , ,
, ,

, ,
, 129

10.
1915-
, ,
1915 . 30-,

-


,

,
,


, ,

126 , , N 1125
127 1915 . 4-
128
. .
,
, , . ,
, , -
, ,
(, , . 7, 178)

,
129 , , . 7, 178-179
Page 29

, ,
,
, 1915
. ,
,

, ,

, ,

,
, ,

- , ,
130:


1916 . ,

,

(
, ) .
, ,
`
,
131

, 1916 .
28- .
, - ,
-


, , 132
,
,
.

.
.
-

130 , 1, 280
131 , , , 1933, 21
132 , 1916, N 46, 28
Page 30

..



133


1918 .

,


,


.
,

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
.

, , ,


134


1920 .

( 1919 . )
,
135
,
()
()136
,



1920 . ,
, 10 000
, 10 000 .` ,
10 000 . 137
,
` ,
-
133 , 1, 284
134 , . 2, 62
135 , 1920, N 48, 29
136 , 1920, N 88, 21
137 , , 1920, N 55
Page 31


,

, ,
-
,
,

, ,

.
- ,
.
, ,
138
,
, ,
- -,
,




,
, ,
-,
,

,
,

Summary

HOVHANNES TUMANYAN IN THE MAELSTROM OF THE GENOCIDE

Susanna G. Hovhannisyan

Key words Hovhannes Tumanyan, Echmiadzin, refugees,


orphans, genocide, diaries, drafts, records, children, Nvard, Sate-
nik Ohanjanyan, Western Armenia, Van, Alashkert, Erzrum, Mush,
Berkri, Tiramerik, Abaga, Khndzorken, Bitlis, Datvan, Panchi,
Manazkert.

The article introduces a few episodes of Tumanyans activities in Echmi-


adzin during the period of the Armenian Genocide, particularly August-Sep-

138 , , . 10, 253


Page 32

tember of 1915. Tumanyans diaries kept many testimonies about the life of


orphans and refugees sheltered in Echmiadzin during that period.
Heroism of a teacher Hakob Jrbashyan and Arpiar Safrastyan to save 300
children of a bording school of Varag is represented, the incidents, which took
place while migrating to Igdir from Shatakh, Archesh, Van, Alashkert, Erzrum,
Mush and other regions of Western Armenia, as well as description of massacre
which took place in Gortsot, Tiramerik, Abagha, Berkri, Khndzorken, Bitlis,
Mush, Datavan, Panchi and other places are represented. There are also facts
about material losses of the Armenian people in Manazkert and Western villag-
es: statistical data about the refugees who had become victims of epidemic
during a month in Echmiadzin, which are expressed in Tumanyans telegrams
sent to the Armenian National Bureau.
18 out of 100 articles of literary-critical, political-public nature written by
the poet during the period from 1914 to 1918 remained unfinished and in draft
condition which often remind records. Today these drafts have also value of

() , 2 (58), -, 2017
ratification: they express testimonies and thoughts of the poet as a witness of
Genocide. The author emphasized horrors of Genocide and created an image of
human-beast.
The poets orphan-protecting activities started in Echmiadzin which contin-
ued until the end of his life. In February of 1920 by the initiative of Haskel /
High Commissioner Colonel of Allies (appointed in summer of 1919) / Armenian
Orphans and Refugees Subscription Committee was formed and Tumanyan was
elected as chairman.
Tumanyans selfless bravery and multi-layer devoted activities carried out
during Genocide period are considered to be a striking example of humanity
and patriotism in the history of all nations.

, , -
, , , , , , , -
, , , -
, , , , , , , -
, , , , , ,

.
, , - 1915 .
.
, .
,
Page 33

- ,
,
, , , , ,
,
, , , ,
, , , , .

, ,
.
, .
-
- , 1914-1918 .,
:
. ,
,
. ,
-.

, .
1920 .

(
1919 .)
, .


.

You might also like