Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The O2 and CO2 concentrations were The preparation of films with 30% GA and
determined with a gas chromatograph drying for 12 h resulted in a smooth, brittle
(Varian model 3400CX, USA) with material, without flexibility, with an opaque
Chrompack capillary column type poraplot appearance and with whitish spots. A
Q, with thermal conductivity detector (TCD) second set of tests, based on three levels of
and flame ionization detector (FID). GA (10, 20 and 30%) and two of
Temperatures of 80, 150 and 170 C were temperature (60 and 90 C) showed that
used in the column, injector and detectors, there was solidification from 20%, although
respectively. The column operated at a with higher concentration of GA it was
gauge pressure of 158.5 kPa. difficult to manipulate the mixture and
incorporated air that was not eliminated
The quantification of O2 was assisted with during the rest. Also, it was determined that
calibration standards (Praxair de Mxico the times required to obtain a suitable
S.A. de C.V.) in balances of (2.01% O2 - solution at 60 and 90 C were 60 and 30
97.99% N2) and (4.98% O2 - 4.98% CO2 - min, respectively, however, it was found
90.04% N2). For the CO2, a typical curve that if the condition of 90 C was applied in
was constructed, with containers of 7 ml a sustained manner it could cause
capacity and the combination of air with caramelization. In all cases, opaque
CO2 (99.8%), to make mixtures of 0.03, materials of brittle consistency were
2.79, 5.54, 8.29, 10.48, 12.18 and 14.75%. obtained. The opacity was not a desirable
In all cases, samples were injected into the characteristic due to the eventual alteration
chromatograph with glass syringes for gases of the appearance of the horticultural
(Hamilton) in aliquots of 100 ml. product to be coated; In addition, a brittle
consistency does not allow the stability of GA required greater effort to deform the
the polymer on the product. films and therefore became more rigid and
less extensible (Table 1). However, the
In parallel, tests were carried out with CMC, factors of CMC and GL produced an opposite
which formed completely translucent effect, obtaining more extensible films with
materials. In order to preserve the the increase of concentration of these
emulsifying potential of the GA and obtain compounds. The values found were of the
the transparency characteristics of the CMC, same order of magnitude as those reported
mixtures of both compounds were made. by Chick and Ustunol (1998) for different
When preparing a solution with 30% GA and films made with proteins. These authors
0.5% CMC, heating at 90 C and determined slightly higher values with
subsequent mixing for 30 min, a translucent casein films, although the difference could
material with a slight yellow tone was be due to the use of a probe displacement
obtained, without whitish spots, smooth, speed of 50.8 cm min-1 in the stretch,
bright and of brittle consistency. Finally, the which was greater than that used in the
consistency was improved with the choice of present work.
glycerol as a plasticizer, so with 30% GA,
0.5% CMC, 15% GL, heating at 90 C, When a product is packaged, control is
subsequent mixing for 30 min, emptying sought over the exchange of gases with the
and resting for 24 h, He obtained a surrounding medium and protection against
translucent and flexible material. mechanical stress during transportation,
packing and storage (Debeaufort et al.,
According to Sothornvit and Krochta (2000), 2000). The phenomenon of friction or
the addition of glycerol to a formulation friction between fruits or against the walls of
reduces the intermolecular force along the the container, by effects of vibration during
polymer chain and this results in an increase the packaging or transport, is a factor that
in flexibility. accelerates the deterioration of a fruit.
Zamora-Magdaleno et al. (1999) evaluated
Stage of characterization of the film
that the problem of friction in avocado fruits
can occur naturally, even before harvest
Transmission of light. The films presented
and that it is a function of the type of
average light transmission of 81%, which
management, so that the passage of the
denotes a high degree of transparency, but
product through the packer can cause
there was no significant difference between
between 7 and 62% of it can not be
formulations (Table 1). In the stage of
marketed, since fruits with higher symptoms
evolutionary design it was found that the
of friction at the end of the process show
addition of CMC caused the coating to cease
higher rates of softening, so they suggested
to be opaque and acquire a transparent
the need to apply treatments to delay said
appearance and the data in Table 1 suggest
loss of firmness and provide protection
that it is sufficient to add 0.25% of CMC in
against of additional mechanical stress. In
the formulation to achieve this
fact, by inducing a modified atmosphere at
characteristic. Currently there are no
the tissue level with the use of a cover, a
quantitative reports on the degree of
delay in the loss of firmness of the product
transparency of other materials, which
is achieved, as demonstrated by Del-Valle et
prevents a comparison, however, the values
al. (2005) with the application of a coating
obtained in this work suggest that the
based on cactus mucilage on strawberry
application of GA-CMC-GL coatings can be
fruits, which translates into greater capacity
done without altering the visual
to maintain integrity against impacts and
characteristics of the horticultural products.
friction. In the same sense, the application
Secant module of elasticity. The results of a coating helps in a situation of friction,
showed that increasing the concentration of that does not act on the pericarp of the fruit
and decreases the damage. Amarante et al.
(2001), achieved within a packing unit the FIGURE 1: Effects of the interaction between
decrease of the problem of discoloration components of the formulations used in the
caused by the friction between pear fruits preparation of the coatings. Boxes A, D and
with the use of a coating prepared with G explain the GAxCMC interaction, B, E and
carnauba wax. H interaction GAxGL and C, F and I
interaction GLxCMC. Equal capital letters
To comply with a mechanical protection indicate non-significant difference between
objective, the coating must have a certain lines for the corresponding condition on the
capacity for deformation, such that when abscissa axis. Equal lowercase letters
exposed to an effort, the outermost layers indicate non-significant difference to the
deform and leave intact those more internal interior of each line (Tukey, 0.05) The bars
that contact the epidermis of the product. represent standard error (n = 3)
Similar to the phenomenon of fluid flow in a
pipeline (Bird et al., 1960). The statistical
analysis reported that the mechanical
strength of the coating depends on a Permeability to O2 and CO2. Table 1
significant interaction between the shows the values of permeability to O2 (O2)
components of the formula (Table 1). The and CO2 (CO2) obtained. No significant
evaluation of this interaction confirmed that difference was found between the levels of
the highest resistance is obtained with the evaluated factors; however, a significant
higher GA content, but can be modulated in interaction between them was found, which
a wide range with the addition of CMC and indicated that the effect caused by any of
GL in the ranges from 0.25 to 0.5% and the components (GA, CMC or GL) depends
from 5 to 10%, respectively (Figures 1A, 1B on the presence of the others.
and 1C). This fact indicates that it is
For O2, the effect of changing concentration
convenient to select a high concentration of
of CMC with GA at 20% was different from
GA and depending on the needs of the
that caused with GA at 30% (Figure 1). With
product, the appropriate level of CMC and
GA at 20% there was a non-significant
GL should be selected, in order to obtain an
increase when the CMC increased from 0.25
adequate coating resistance. However, other
to 0.50%, but when varying from 0.50 to
aspects must be considered, which in a
0.75% the permeability to O2 was
combined way aim to improve the selection.
significantly reduced. In contrast, with GA at
30%, it did not change when the CMC
changed from 0.25 to 0.50% and the value
exhibited was lower (P0.05) than with GA
at 20%. However, the passage from 0.50 to
0.75% generated an increase in the
exchange capacity of O2, to the extent that
the condition with 30% of GA the coating
became more permeable than with 20% of
the rubber (Figure 1D). The interaction
between GA and GL caused a reverse
situation (Figure 1E). With GA at 20%, the
increase in GL caused an increase in
permeability to O2 and with GA at 30% the
opposite effect was had. In this case, with
GL at low concentration the coating was
more permeable the higher the
concentration of GA; however, with high
concentrations of GL the highest
permeability was obtained with lower
GA. On the other hand, the evaluation of nogelatine-sorbitol films (O2: 2.593 x 10-
the interaction between GL and CMC (Figure 16, CO2: 1.12x10-15; M s-1 m-2 Pa-
1F) showed that with low concentration of 1), (starch-hydroxyprolyl) -gelatin-glycerol
GL (5%) the behavior was similar to the GA (O2: 4.8 x 10-15, CO2: 2.24 x 10-14),
case at 30% when the amount of CMC was (starch-hydroxyprolyl) -gelatin -sorbitol
increased, but with higher concentrations of (O2: 1.28 x 10-14, CO2: 7.04 x 10-14) and
GL, the increase in CMC caused a behavior (starch-hydroxyprolyl) -gelatin-sucrose (O2:
of the type shown for GA at 20% (Figure 4.48 x 10-15, CO2: 1.60 x 10-
1D). 14). Jangchud and Chinnan (1999) reported
that peanut concentrate films exhibit O2
In the case of CO2, the result of the permeability of 3.68 x 10-18 mol m s-1
interactions was a reverse behavior to that m-2 Pa-1, while McHugh and Krochta
described for the O2 permeability. With GA (1994) found that the transmission of this
at 20% the increase in CMC caused a gas in protein materials isolated from whey
reduction in the CO2 exchange capacity, but and glycerol occurs between 6.85 x 10-18
with GA at 30% an increase was induced and 2.81 x 10-18 mol m s-1 m-2 Pa-1,
(Figure 1G). With GA at 20% the increase in which is also lowerto the one found in the
GL caused a reduction in CO2 permeability, present work. The comparison with plastic
but with GA at 30% the result was also an materials confirms the greater permeation
increase (Figure 1H). Finally, in the GL-CMC capacity of GA-CMC-GL films, since
interaction, it was found that with a low Cameron et al. (1995) pointed out that the
concentration of GL (5%) the increase in values, in mol m s-1 m-2 Pa-1, for low
CMC caused the reduction of CO2, but when density polyethylene are 2.7 x 10-15 for O2
GL was set at 10 and 15%, the increase in and 9.9 x 10-15 for CO2; in the case of
CMC caused the increase in said polypropylene they reported 9.0 x 10-16 for
permeability or remained constant, O2 and 5.8 x 10-15 for CO2 and in polyvinyl
respectively (Figure 1I). chloride 1.9 x 10-17 for O2 and 6.5 x 10-17
for CO2.
The permeation process consists of a
combined phenomenon of the solution of Valle-Guadarrama et al. (2005), reported
the gas in the polymer and the transport that the minimum O2 permeance that
through it by diffusion (Kester and should exhibit a coating to preserve 'Hass'
Fennema, 1986).The presence of preclimatory fruits was 1,963 x 10-10 mol
interactions indicates that changing the s-1 m-2 Pa-1. If the permeability is
proportion of the components of the divided by the thickness of the membrane,
formulations altered these mechanisms, but the permeance is obtained (Banks et al.,
a more detailed explanation will require that 1995). The materials of GA-CMC-GL of the
in later works the structural change of the present work had average values of
formed polymer be explored. thickness and permeance equal to 262 m
and 7.69 x 10-10 mol s-1 m-2 Pa-1,
On average, the materials were more respectively. This indicates that such
permeable to O2 (20.15 x 10-14 3.87 x materials could be used as coatings for the
10-14 mol m s-1 m-2 Pa-1) than to 'Hass' avocado fruits in the manner
CO2 (7.56 x 10-14 1.83 x 10-14 mol m indicated. It is also applicable to lettuce,
s-1 m-2 Pa-1). since Cameron et al. (1995) suggested that
this product could be handled in a modified
Likewise, the comparison with other
atmosphere if a polyethylene film with a
materials allows the classification of high
permeance of 1.08 x 10-10 mol s-1 m-2
permeability to O2 and CO2 to coatings of
Pa-1 is used.
GA-CMC-GL, because Arvanitoyannis et
al.(1998) reported lower permeability values Coating selection
(mol m s-1 m-2 Pa-1) in chitosa-
When a coating is applied on a product, the CONCLUSIONS
gas exchange capacity of the product with
its immediate environment is reduced. As An edible film based on gum arabic (GA),
the O2 intake required for the respiration carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) and glycerol
and the discharge of the CO2 generated in it (GL) was developed. The combination of GA
occur at a lower speed, a reduction of the in proportion of 30%, CMC in a range of
O2 concentration and an increase in CO2 0.25 to 0.50% and GL in a range of 5 to
inside the product itself is caused. After a 10%, presented an adequate potential for
certain time, the rates of O2 consumption use in fruit conservation by modified
and CO2 production are equalized with the atmosphere systems. The change of
exchange rates through the shell-coating set concentrations in GA, CMC and GL allows to
and constant concentrations are reached, regulate the permeabilities to O2 and CO2,
which is called a steady-state state modify their mechanical properties and
(Cameron et al. , nineteen ninety five). It is obtain light transmission capacity greater
essential to avoid O2 and CO2 being than 80%.
installed at a lower or higher level,
respectively, than the tolerance limits of the LITERATURE CITED
product, so when selecting a coating,
priority must be given to this criterion and AMARANTE, C.; BANKS, N. H. 2001.
this involves defining the adequate values of Postharvest physiology and quality of coated
fruits and vegetables. Horticultural Reviews
permeability to O2 and CO2 thereof.
26: 161237
The results of the present work show that it
is feasible to control the gas permeability of AMARANTE, C.; BANKS, N. H.; GANESH, S.
2001. Effects of coating concentration,
the GA-CMC-GL coating, through the
ripening stage, water status and fruit
concentrations of these components. If the temperature on pear susceptibility to friction
variables of light transmission and discolouration. Postharvest Biology and
mechanical resistance are considered, it is Technology 21(3): 283290
convenient to choose a formulation based
on 30% GA and modulate the permeability ARVANITOYANNIS, I. S.; NAKAYAMA, A.;
to O2 and CO2 by fixing the concentrations AIBA, S. I. 1998. Chitosan and gelatin
of CMC and GL in the ranges of 0.25 to 0.5 based edible films: state diagrams,
mechanical and permeation properties.
and 5 to 10%, respectively, based on the
Carbohydrate Polymers 37(4): 371382
behavior shown in Figure 1.
It must additionally be considered that the AYRANCI, E.; TUNC, S. 2001. The effect of
fatty acid content on water vapour and
formulated material presents characteristics
carbon dioxide transmissions of cellulose
of a hydrocolloid. In fact, it was observed base edible films. Food Chemistry 72(2):
that the presence of high relative humidity 231236
induced longer solidification times and sticky
tactile appearance in already formed BANKS, N. H.; NICHOLSON, S. E. 2000.
materials, which is attributed to the Internal atmosphere composition and skin
hygroscopic properties of CMC and GL. It is permeance to gases of pepper fruit.
suggested, therefore, to explore the Postharvest Biology and Technology 18(1):
3341.
hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (BHL)
management in later works, although this
BANKS, N. H.; CLELAND, D. J.; CAMERON,
could affect the gaseous exchange capacity
A. C.; BEAUDRY, R. M.; KADER, A. A. 1995.
of the film, as shown by Ayranci and Tunc Proposal for rationalized system of units for
(2001), who evaluated the effect of the postharvest research in gas exchange.
incorporation of fatty acids to control BHL in HortScience 30(6): 11291131
a methylcellulose material and observed
that the gas exchange capacity decreased.
BIRD, R. B.; STEWART, W. E.; LIGHTFOOT, GIRARD, M.; TURGEON, S. L.; PAQUIN, P.
E. N. 1960. Transport Phenomena. John 2002. Emulsifying properties of whey
Wiley & Sons Inc. New York, USA. 780 p proteincarboximethylcellulose complexes.
Journal of Food Science 67(1): 13119
BOSQUEZ, E.; VERNON, E. J.; PREZ, L.;
GUERRERO, I. 2000. Pelculas y cubiertas JANGCHUD, A.; CHINNAN, M. S. 1999.
comestibles para la conservacin en fresco Peanut protein film as affected by drying
de frutas y hortalizas. Industria Alimentaria temperature and pH of film forming
22: 1436 solution. Journal of Food Science 64(1):
153157
CAMERON, A. C.; TALASILA, P. CH.; JOLES,
D. W. 1995. Predicting film permeability KADER, A. A. 2002. Modified atmosphere
needs for modifiedatmosphere packaging during transport and storage, pp. 135
of lightly processed fruits and vegetables. 144. In: Postharvest Technology of
HortScience 30(1): 2534 Horticultural Crops. KADER, A.A. (ed.).
University of California, Davis, California,
CHANAMAI, R.; MCCLEMENTS, D. J. 2001. USA
Depletion flocculation of beverage emulsions
by gum arabic and modified starch. Journal KESTER, J. J.; FENNEMA O. 1986. Edible
of Food Science 66(3): 457463 films and coatings. Food Technology 40(1):
4759.
CHICK, J.; USTUNOL, Z. 1998. Mechanical
and barrier properties of lactic acid and MANGONON, P. L. 1999. The principles of
rennet precipitated caseinbased edible material selection for engineering design.
films. Journal of Food Science 63(6): 1024 PrenticeHall Inc. New Jersey, USA. 824 p
1027