Professional Documents
Culture Documents
-'
~1ATHEMATICAL PUZZLES FOR THE SECONDARY MATHE~1ATICS
AND EVALUATION
of
In Partial Fulfillment
By
Randall R. Baumback
\
November,\ 1980
Copyright @ 1980
By Randall R. Baumback
ii
ABSTRACT
iii
according to four criteria: (1) clarity and under-
concept.
iv
Y..)._THEl1ATICAL ?GZZI.ES FOR THE SECONDARY :1J:._THE:1ATICS
3y
?,andall ?. 3a.umbac;·:
APPROVED: DATE:
Lk'.2. 7:
>
1'180
~e~:f::(/(~ 9 ///0
/
v
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ABSTRACT . . . . iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS vi
LIST OF TABLES . xv
Chapter
1. INTRODUCTION 1
ASSUMPTIONS 3
2. METHOD OF STUDY 15
Motivational Value. . . 17
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
INSTRUMENTATION . . . . . . . . . 18
CONCEPTS COVERED . . . 20
ARITHMETIC PUZZLES . . . 24
2. A Tennis Tournament. . .. 25
6. Squares. 26
9. Thirty Flasks. . . .. 28
viii
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
ALGEBRA PUZZLES . . . . . 42
ix
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
39. Is 4 = 8? 47
GEOMETRY PUZZLES . . . 61
49. Toe-Tac-Tic . 62
51. A Paradox . 63
x
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
75. Watches 89
xi
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
77. Two Horses and a Fly . . 89
78. Draining a Water Tank 90
79. The Physicist and the Escalator 90
80. Average Speed 90
8l. The Confused Teller 91
84. Scales . . 92
xii
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
xiii
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Chapter Page
4. RESULTS . . . . 130
SUMMARY . . . . . . . . 140
RECOMMENDATIONS . 141
BIBLIOGRAPHY . . . . . . 142
APPENDICES
xiv
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
xv
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1
2
Inaccessibility of Appropriate
Puz £IeLT"terature- ----
The pleasure and stimulation found in grappling
purpose.
ASSUMPTIONS
in efficient learning.
saying:
age may create a taste for mental work and leave their
S
Lynn Arthur Steen, "What's in a Game?," Science
News, CXII (March, 1978), 204-206.
6
G. Polya, How to Solve It (Princeton: Princeton
University Press, 1973), p. v.
7
Liebnitz, and Euler found many new ideas and even fields
today.
subj ects, ~'lhi t.e makes this same point. He uniquely argues
matics. fl18
t
'
lme. ,,24
METHOD OF STUDY
15
16
presented in Chapter 3.
DISCUSSION OF CRITERIA
of those available.
be used.
for evaluation.
Motivational Value
difficult to generate.
Illustration of a Mathe-
matical Concept
in the collection.
DESCRIPTION OF POPULATION
INSTRUMENTATION
fair, or poor.
MATHE~mTICAL PUZZLES
puzzles.
CONCEPTS COVERED
20
21
Arithmetic
1. Adding integers
2. One to one correspondence
3. Deductive reasoning--doubling a number
4. Squaring a number
5. Addition of fractions with like denominators
6. Addition of fractions with unlike denominators
7. Multiplication of fractions
8. Deductive reasoning--distance = rate x time
9. Deductive reasoning--classifying information
10. Average of numbers--deductive reasoning
11. Discovering patterns
12. Divisibility by 8 and 9
13. Powers of 2
14. Deductive reasoning--one to one correspondence
15. Sets of numbers--subsets of numbers
16. Deductive reasoning--whole number subtraction
and multiplication
17. One to one correspondence
18. Deductive reasoning--adding integers
19. Binary numeration
20. Deductive reasoning--addition of whole numbers
21. Whole number addition with regrouping--
deductive reasoning
22. Diameter of a circle
Algebra
Puzzle No.
Algebra
Geometry
Puzzle No.
Geometry
Intermediate
Algebra
Puzzle No.
Advanced
Mathematics
ARITH~£TIC PUZZLES
each day but slips back two feet at night. How many days
5. The Bookworm
,---- (21)
The two volumes of Gibbon's "Decline and Fall of
6. Squares (10)
• • • • •
• • • ••
• • • • •
• ••••
never taking your pencil off the paper. You may not
city?
That's all the digits in all the numbers, not all the
numbers themselves.
29
fowls are replaced here by blanks, for they have faded and
are now illegible. What are the two faded digits, and what
was the price of one turkey? (Assume each turkey cost the
same.)
adjacent squares?
way:
31
17 days left
7 days left
2 days left
0 days left
hotel. There were 11 men who went into the hotel at the
settling the argument, said "I'll tell you what I'll do.
I will put two men in room 201 with the understanding that
I will come back and get one of them a few minutes later."
The the clerk went back to get the extra man he had left
The hotel clerk said there was only one room available.
The room cost $30, and each man paid $10. After the men
had left for their room, the clerk decided that he had
the cost to each man was $9. Now 3 x 9 = $27 and the $2
1 3 5 7 2 3 6 7 4 5 6 7
9 11 13 15 10 11 14 15 12 13 14 15
17 19 21 23 18 19 22 23 20 21 22 23
25 27 29 31 26 27 30 31 28 29 30 31
8 9 10 11 16 17 18 19
12 13 14 15 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31 28 29 30 31
Card 4 Card 5
roll three standard dice and add the top faces. The
S EVE N
+ N I N E
RIG H T
decoded?
35
the inch, how far does the needle travel while the
record is playing?
Solutions to Arithmetic
Puzzles
1.
number of the day on which the snail reaches the top of the
well, so n = 28 days.
2.
3.
4.
62 = 36
52 = 25
2
4 = 16
2
3 = 9
2
2 = 4
2
1 = 1
--
204
5.
6.
START
1/ 5 13
" Lt , 11.
I'"
J 7 11 15
a \0
2S Cf 21 " 17
2'1 2.'2. 20 18
'....t7 ~~ let
/ -
END
7.
·1
Since
4
cake weighs 43 pounds, an entire cake
weighs 4 x i = 3 pounds.
8.
9•
10.
wear no shoes and the other half will wear two sandals.
This works out at one shoe per person for the "remainders."
11.
999,999,999 and 0;
999,999,998 and 1;
12.
13.
3
The pile is 2 °(.01) > 10 million inches
14.
• •••
• •••
..• ....
·•••••
•.:.
••
.•.•. •.• '
it can't be done.
40
15.
16.
17.
18.
actually pay $27 for the room but $25. If the problem
$25 + $3 + $2 = $30.
$27 to get $25 plus the $5 hotel clerk rebate equals $30.
19.
iirst card are all those numbers whose last digit in the
appears.
Example:
16 8 4 2 1
24 = 1 1 0 0 0 (base 2)
20.
total is the sum of the three top faces plus the previous
21.
22.
ALGEBRA PUZZLES
name off the top and add your name to the bottom of the
list. Next, you send the new letter with your name at the
43
26.
--~ ...
A Bottle and
~----- ...
a Cork (10)
'_._~.
$1.00 more than the cork. How much does each cost?
what he had left plus half an egg. The farmer went home
happy since he sold all his eggs, yet he had not broken a
single egg. How many eggs were in the basket when the
hill, back down the hill, and home without stopping. They
and girls living in the town, how much did Mr. Anthrope
give away?
3 ;:)
C'
. More or Less? (4)
equally spaced around the ball, how far is the tape from
and the tape? Could you crawl between them? Could you
did he own?
Let a = b
2
a = ab
a 2 _b 2 = ab-b-
?
39. Is 4 =: 8? (19)
4 = 8 (adding 6)
and that .
i dollar = 25 cents
so . . .
~ dollar = 5 cents
What is the error?
Le Havre for New York and another ship leaves New York for
answer graphically?"
The last one will be the original selected card. How does
if there were 472 tiles along one side and 296 along the
other?
every mile that he runs. Prove that he will need only one
quart!
50
solutions to Algebra
Puzzles
23.
2
x2 must be such that: 1800 s x S 1899 since
24.
25.
1 1
2" of 5 = 2
2"
1 _.- 3 1
3" of 10 3"
Thus, if 2 1 3 3"
1 :::; x
2" = 3, then
1 1
2 3
2" 3"
-3- -" -x-
5
2" x = 10
5x :::; 20
26.
2x + 1.00 = 1.10
2x = .10
27.
implies:
2 (n-l) = n+l
2n-2 = n+l
n = 3
n+l = 4
28.
1\
Let x = the weight of the brick
1
2" x = half of the brick's weight
1
x = 2" x + 6
2x = x + 12
x = 12
29.
5x + 60 -- lOa
5x = 40
x = 8
x+6 = 14
x+12 = 20
x+18 = 26
x+24 = 32
.08x .05(26-x) = 0
8x - 130 + 5x = 0
l3x = 130
:. x = 10 correct problems
31.
280 = 5x
56 = x
54
1
2 =
-x 28 study mathematics
~x -- 8 study chemistry
7
56 students in all
32.
1 1
2x + 2" e.ggs;
1 1 1 1 1
-(x-(-x
2 2
+ 1:.)
2
) + 2" = :rx + "4 eggs;
1 1 1 1 1 1
-(x- (-x
2 2 + 1:.
2
+ -x
4
+ 1:.)
4
) + 2" = -x
8
+ 8" eggs.
1 7
-x - -
8 8
= 0
x - 7 = 0
33.
we get:
55
d d
4" + 4"
:::: time walking on level road;
h
3' = t.ime walking uphill;
h :::: time walking downhill;
6"
thus,
~ + ~ + h + ~ = 2 hours or,
436 4
3d + 4h + 2h + 3d :::: 24 or,
d + h = 4 and,
34.
(.6) (10)b + 6g = x
6b + 6g = x
6(b+g) = x
6(2,240) :::: x
35.
36.
C = c + 10 = 2nr + 10 = 2n(r + b)
2n (r + b) = 2nr + 10
2nb = 10
5
b = feet
57
both tapes are away from each sphere exactly the same
distance--~
1T
feet.
37.
y = number of chickens
thus,
x + y = 35 and,
4x + 26 = 78
solving simultaneously yields:
x = 4 and y = 31
38.
39.
4 - 6 = -8 + 6
-4 + 6 =8 - 6
Note, a
2
=b 2 does not imply o =N
58
40.
units of measure.
41.
42.
PEAk
•\ UPHILl.. :
-_-0
.- '- ., DOWNHilL:
\.
I ·---e__,
~_ _--L ....x..;::~~ llME
-e,
The above graph clearly shows that the mountain
43.
deck. Note that the 44th card from the top is the 9th
44.
A EHE .-
45.
GEOMETRY PUZZLES
that each new cigar must not touch any of the previously
row loses. Can the player with the first move avoid being
beaten?
J J
II ~
,
J J
8 I I
~ , .. J
~
~
~
~
~~
,l 13
(3 J
II
r
J
I
~
s
Can you determine where the ~extra" square unit has come
from?
64
the triangle?
66
shack by a chain 60 feet long. She can not get under the
shack but can graze anywhere else she can reach on her
can graze?
59. .
Koch's Triangles (27)
S~P3
n-th figure.
7
The isosceles right triangle shown above has a
rope from his tool box enabled him to form the corners and
a'
It'
A room is 16 feet long, 12 feet wide, and 8 feet
right wall and 2 feet from the front wall f sees a fly
sleeping on the left wall, 2 feet from the front wall and
reach the fly. Can you find it, and calculate its length?
and the baggage man could not take any article whose
by which the fly can walk to the honey, and exactly how
_.--~
ruler?
72
T E
Solutions to Geometrv
+
Puzzles
46.
\ I' }
\ I , I
\
\ I
I \
\ I
I (b)
, I \ I
\ I \ J
\ I \ I
\1- ,I
48.
flat end over the center of the table. From then on, he
the table.
49.
50.
- - - - - -- - - ,',
- ."./ 8'
, I
0........... ' I
/
/
B ..:;.. .;a./
c..
theorem.
51.
.........
r--... .
~
---. ~
......... -...
.~ . .·.L..
.,-.- '---
~
~ ....
'" .......
When the four pieces are put together to make
pieces. )
52.
Therefore, GF = 2".
76
53.
the circle.
54.
AD = /2""
6
(tACD:
AE =
/6"" DE = (L.ADE: 30° - 60° - 90°)
IS '
77
EF = 312 -16"
9
(6BEF : 30 0 - 60 0 -- 90 0 )
12
DF = 3 - .4714 (DE + EF)
55.
56.
A
1 2
Area (semicircle AC) = -TIr
6
= 31 TIr
2
Area (semicircle AD)
1 2
Area (semicircle AB) = -TIr
2
1 2 2
= 61 ITr
1 2
Area (region 1) = 2"TIr -ITr
3
78
1 2
Area .- -TIr
6
1 2
- -TIr
3
Both sections have the same area.
57.
in radius from the north, through the east and the south
to t h ewes.
t T h e area 0 '
f th 1S reglon 3 TI 60 2 sq. f t.
. .1S 4
58.
59.
A.)
side becomes four sides. Thus, with each step the number
Hence, S
n
= 3 x 4(n-l), where S
n
:: the number of sides
where P
n
= the perimeter on the nth
step.
81
60.
units.
61.
2
x = 2
x = 12 - 1.414 inches
82
62.
between the first two segments separates the rope into two
3
lengths and 4" t. Stretching the knotted rope out,
63.
C.E"ILIN6-
1'2.' 5
LEFT
WAll
,
'I' :
t
FRONT
WALL
F
cut open along the edge joining the north wall and
west wall, and the ceiling can be laid out flat. The
64.
l~
1 yard on a side.
2 2 2
(i) x = 1 + 1
x = 12
2 2
( ii) Y = 1 + (12)2
Y = 13 > 1. 73
84
65.
66.
67.
b
h~
68.
2
The surface area of a sphere = 4nr . The
4 3
volume of a sphere = 3nr . However, both 4r 2 and
4 3 must
-r lie between 1,000 and 9,999. Thus,
3
2
1,000 s 4r s 9,999 implies 15 < r < 50;
3
1,000 s 4r s 9,999 implies 9 < r < 20.
Therefore, r lies between 16 and 19 inclusive. But for
4 3
3r to be an integer, r must be divisible by 3.
Therefore, r = 18, area = 1,296n, and volume = 7,776n .
69.
70.
T ~
71.
A"
asked.
"I would tell you the sum of their ages but that
same time. When will they show the same time again? When
The long one can burn 3 } hours; the short one, 5 hours.
miles per hour, starts from the nose of the Pinto, when the
travel?
90
hour. What was his average speed for the round trip?
91
0 0 6 D 00
J I [ l
/\ /\
( l) (it)
LL
11---_/\
__1
DOD o[
7\
OU) ( tV)
y
"i I - - - - r - - - _
3
Z
I
1
1 +
1
1 + 1
I + 1 + e t c.
equation
X + 5 4x - 40
x - 7
- 5 = 13 - x
(x+5) - 5(x-7) 4x - 40
x - x = 13 - x
or
4x - 40 4x - 40
7 - x = 13 - x
wrong?
95
x - 2v =- Yi x = -y + 2v
multiply:
2 _ 2vx _- 2
X Y - 2 vY
2
add v :
2 2 2
v , or (x-v) = (y-v)
x - v = Y - v
x =Y
~ =If, and
= and
1 = -1 .
1 1
3 log (2) > 2 log (2) , or
1 > 1
8" 4'
97
solutions to Intermediate
Algebra Puzzles
72.
x, y, and z:
x Y.. -z x + y + z
1 1 36 38
1 2 18 21
1 3 12 16
1 4 9 14
1 6 6 13*
2 2 9 13*
2 3 6 11
3 3 4 10
9.
98
73.
This problem requires that we make a preliminary
estimate of the unknown.
(i) A volume of 99 pages needs: 9 + 2(90) = 189
digits;
(ii) a volume of 999 pages needs: 9 + 2(90) +
74.
Let x = depth now (!3 finished)
70 - x = height above now (since 5'10" = 70" )
x = 42
75.
The watches will show the same time again when the
gain of mine plus the lag of Janice's equals 12 hours
(43,200 seconds). In x hours my watch will be x
99
3
seconds fast, and Janice's watch will be 2" x seconds
slow. Then:
3
x + 2" x = 43,200
76.
77.
r------»«~--J
5 1I'\i.. 5 P\ t.
fly is 10 miles.
78.
x x x
15 + 30 + 45 = 1
6x + 3x + 2x = 90
llx = 90
2
x = 8 11 minutes - 8 minutes 11 seconds.
79.
s - 20 = 20 rand,
s - 32 = 16 r.
80.
2x = 48
- - - - = 480 x miles an hour.
x x 10 £
65"+4"0
81.
Then,
199d + 932
c = 98
102
82.
83.
;;)
( ...... 6 = Y + . 25
x - 2
Substituting (i) into (ii), yields
6 6
(iii)
x - 2 = x
+ .25
(5x-40) (5x+30) = 0
x = 8, -6
84.
85.
If t-+.---t
(OJ I )
--~~-~X
86.
or,
2
x - x - 2 = 0 then,
(x - 2) (x+l) = 0 thus,
x = 2 or -1.
/2 + /2 + IT + ... = 2.
87.
As a decimal:
1
x = 1 + -
x
2
x = x + 1
2
x - x - 1 = 0
1 + 11 + 4 - 1. 618
x = 2
106
88.
;1+ g-8 x +2 _. x
2
x - g-x - 2 =;1
8
g-x - 2=;1
1
x - 18 = 9;1
2
x 36x + 324 = 31 (~)
2
2x - 153x + 648 = 0
(2x-9) (x-72) = 0
x = 72 bees.
89.
90.
2
The wrong square root of (y-v) was used.
x - v = - (y-v) ;
x + y = 2v.
numbers had been used, you would have seen the fallacy.
91.
92.
r-
ya
iff la, are real numbers.
93.
transfer the entire tower from one peg to either of the two
109
game?
mathematical induction:
true.
a2 = a3 = . = ak ~ a k +l · Therefore, al = a2 = ... =
a
k
= a k + l , and P(k+l) is true. It follows that P(n)
is true for all natural numbers n, i.e., any set of n
How many moves will it take to get all glasses in the down
position?
must be equilateral.
c.
A -.L.._ _ --aB
1
2
by x. Then PC = 3 - x and PA = PB = (x +36)2. There-
1 1
ds _ 2-
fore, S = 3 - x + 2(x 2 +36)2 and dx - -1 + 2x(x +36)-2 .
ds
Setting dx = 0, we find x = 2/3 > 3, ·and thus P lies
1---+--.. -+--t-----,-
1-+--1I---I--f-"--
mathematician:
114
M
M A M
M A T A M
M A T H T A M
M A T H E H T A M
M A T H E M E H T A M
M A T H E M A M E H T A 1-1
M A T H E M A T A M E H T A M
M A T H E M A T I T A M E H T A M
M A T H E M A T I C I T A M E H T A M
H A T H E ]\1 A T I C I C I T A M E H T A M
M A T H E M A T I C I A I C I T A M E H T A M
M A T H E M A T I C I A N A I C I T A M E H T A H
one of the first five rows. With the deadline for sub-
of magnitude?
right envelopes?
likely is it that among them any two people will share the
at Tic-Tac-Toe?
next man. "Ugly old boy isn't he?" Assuming that one of
times out of four, and the other tells it four times out
hit its target one out of four times, and four such
94.
of leaves.
95.
1 cube is unpainted.
118
1 8 8 0 0 0
2 27 8 12 6 1
3 64 8 24 24 8
4 125 8 36 54 27
96.
1 1 = 21 - 1
2
2 3 = 2 - 1
3 7 = 23 - 1
4
4 15 = 2 1
97.
a
2 = a2· But we can not conclude that a
l = a
2
since
119
for to
98.
99.
s;:-- x
l\
(1) wx = wI
of pounds, thus,
(2) w2 x =w
Solving (1) for x and substituting in (2) yields the
correct weight
100.
O ~8
- !.2 + 1 !. +
you \,vil1 end up with a geometric series: 1
4" - 8
1
16- . . . = 1
1 = 1
1 = 3"
2
1 - (- - )
2
1 +
2"
L BOY = L AOB - L BOe + L COD - L DOE + L FOE -
I I I
= L AOB - 2" L AOB + 4" L AOB - "8 L AOB +
1
16 L AOB -
1 1 1 1
= L AOB (1 - 2" + 4" - "8 + 16 - ... )
1
=L AOB ( 1)
1 + 2"
= L AOB (~)
L BOY = tL AOB
122
101.
2
The equation a2 + b + c2 = ab + bc + ca is
equivalent to (a-b)2 + (b-c) 2 + (c-a)2 = o. Hence,
102.
At any given instant the four bugs form the
corners of a square which shrinks and rotates as the bugs
move closer together. The path of each pursuer will,
therefore, at all times be perpendicular to the path of
103.
Let x = the number of my house. The sum of the
.
num b ers I ess th an mlne =I + 2 + 3 + ..• + (x-I) = (x-l)x
2
The sum of the numbers greater than mine =
2(x;1)X + x = x2 = n(n;l) Since the sum of the first
2 n(n+l) 2
a 2 . b2 2a·b
x - -"2- x :::
-2- va+1b n
2 2 2·1
1 ::: 1 1 = 1'1 -2- l~l 1
2 2 8·9 1j
6 = 36 6 =: 4·9 -2- 2 --;;.3 8
104.
Examine for endpoint maxima and minima. If
P = D, then S = PC + PA + PB -- 3 + 6 + 6 = 15. If
P = C, then S = PC + PA + PB = 0 + 3/5 + 3/5 = 6/5 < 15.
Hence, the desired point P on CD is the endpoint C.
105.
This is a combination problem:
lor
2! (10-2)! = 45
handshakes.
106.
a time:
6!
3! (6-3) = 20
107.
(i) 3! 3!
3C 2 + 3C 1 = 2!!! + 2111 = 3 + 3 = 6 different
possibilities from 3 flavors using double scoops.
108.
The numbers of different arrangements, or permu-
n!
The rectangle is 6 blocks long by 4 blocks wide,
a!bT
is lor routes.
6!4! = 210
109.
8,191 paths.
110.
Ill.
112.
the first man can see two sides, then the second man can
113.
birthday:
114.
9!
Of the 9 C 3 -- 3!6! = 84 possibilities, only the
115.
A B Answers Probability
3 4 12
5" = 20
Truthful rrruthful Same
4"
3 1 3
Truthful Lie Different
"4 5" = 20
1 4 4
Lie Truthful Different
4" 5" = 20
1 1 1
5" = 20
Lie Lie Same
"4
Given the fact that the two men made the same response,
12
20 12
12 1 = 13
20+20
116.
81 175
1 - 256 = 256 .
117.
( ~.l) + (~.9) 1 9 28
2 2 19 = 2 + 38 = 38 = .737 = 73.7%
128
PUZZLE SOURCES
Books
Other
RESULTS
evaluation.
130
131
Excellent = 3
Good = 2
Fair = 1
Poor = 0
13-15 Excellent
8-12 Good
3-7 Fair
0-2 Poor
the sum of the values of the four criteria per puzzle, and
51-60 Excellent
31-50 Good
11-30 Fair
0-10 Poor
132
Criterion
Puzzle
No. I II III IV Overall
1 15 15 13 14 57
2 11 13 12 9 45
3 14 14 13 14 55
4 13 11 12 13 49
5 12 13 12 7 44
6 10 11 12 9 42
7 13 13 13 14 53
8 15 15 15 15 60
9 13 13 13 10 49
10 15 14 14 12 55
11 13 9 12 15 49
12 12 8 10 12 42
13 15 8 13 11 47
14 11 12 12 10 45
15 14 14 14 11 53
16 12 13 13 12 50
17 13 14 13 12 52
18 14 13 14 13 54
19 13 13 15 14 55
20 12 14 13 12 51
21 15 15 15 15 60
22 13 14 12 12 49
23 14 14 13 14 55
24 13 14 14 15 56
25 14 15 15 15 59
KEY:
Criterion Summarized Ratings Scale
I Clarity and under- Criterion I Overall
standability.
I I Time factor practicality. Excellent 13-15 51-60
~T~
.J.~J. Motivational value. Good 8-12 31-50
IV Illustration of a Fair 3-7 11-30
mathematical concept. Poor 0-2 0-10
133
,]~ABLE 2 (Continued)
(~riterion
-----
Puzzle
No. I II III .0_ _IV
_ _ _·_. Overall
26 14 14 13 14 55
27 11 15 14 15 55
28 14 14 13 14 55
29 15 13 14 14 56
30 15 14 14 14 57
31 10 13 11 14 48
32 14 13 13 15 55
33 15 12 13 15 55
34 14 10 12 13 49
35 8 10 9 12 39
36 12 13 14 15 54
37 13 14 14 14 55
38 14 14 15 15 58
39 12 14 15 14 55
40 14 14 15 14 57
41 12 9 11 11 43
42 11 11 8 8 38
43 10 8 9 13 40
44 12 10 9 10 41
45 12 12 10 6 40
46 13 13 14 14 54
47 12 11 10 11 44
48 9 8 9 10 36
49 13 10 12 11 46
50 14 14 14 14 56
KEY:
Criterion Summarized Ratings Scale
Clarity and under-
I Criterion IOverall
standabi1ity.
II Time factor practicality. Excellent 13-15 51-60
III Motivational value. Good 8-12 31-50
IV Illustration of a Fair 3-7 11-30
mathematical concept. Poor 0-2 0-10
134
TABLE 2 (Continued)
Criterion
Puzzle
No. I II III IV Overall
51 12 13 14 13 52
52 15 14 14 15 58
53 13 12 14 14 53
54 12 8 10 12 42
55 14 14 13 14 55
56 12 10 12 14 48
57 14 14 14 15 57
58 14 10 14 1.3 51
59 13 9 11 12 45
60 13 12 14 12 51
61 15 15 14 15 59
62 10 11 10 12 43
63 14 14 15 15 58
64 13 14 15 15 57
65 13 13 13 14 53
66 13 12 12 11 48
67 11 12 14 14 51
68 15 11 13 15 54
69 11 9 11 9 40
70 14 11 9 14 48
71 13 10 13 13 49
72 14 13 13 12 52
73 15 13 12 13 53
74 13 15 14 15 57
75 13 11 14 15 53
KEY:
Criterion Summarized Ratings Scale
I Clarity and under- Criterion IOverall
standabi1ity.
II Time factor practicality. Excellent 13-15 51-60
III Motivational value. Good 8-12 31-50
IV Illustration of a Fair 3-7 11-30
mathematical concept. Poor 0-2 0-10
135
TABLE 2 (Cont;inued)
Criterion
Puzzle
No. I II III IV Overall
--------
76 13 12 14 14 53
77 14 13 13 12 52
78 15 15 14 15 59
79 11 13 12 15 51
80 13 12 11 14 50
81 13 8 10 10 41
82 15 14 14 15 58
83 15 15 15 15 60
84 11 12 14 15 52
85 13 8 12 14 47
86 14 12 13 15 54
87 14 12 11 14 51
88 14 15 15 15 59
89 14 14 14 13 55
90 10 10 11 14 45
91 14 14 14 14 56
92 15 14 14 14 57
93 15 14 14 15 58
94 13 11 11 14 49
95 12 12 14 13 51
96 12 11 14 12 49
97 12 12 11 12 47
98 13 12 14 12 51
99 11 13 12 12 48
100 14 14 12 14 54
KEY:
Criterion Summarized Ratings Scale
I Clarity and under- Criterion I Overall
standability.
II Time factor practicality. Excellent 13-15 51-60
III Motivational value. Good 8-12 31-50
IV Illustration of a Fair 3-7 11-30
mathematical concept. Poor 0-2 0-10
136
TJl.BLE 2 (Continued)
106 13 15 13 15 56
107 15 15 15 15 60
108 13 13 13 14 53
109 12 11 12 13 48
110 14 13 13 15 55
111 14 14 12 12 52
112 15 15 15 15 60
113 13 10 11 10 44
114 14 13 14 14 55
115 13 13 13 15 54
116 15 13 14 15 57
117 12 13 14 13 52
KEY:
criteria.
138
I 83 34 0 0 117
II 68 49 0 0 117
III 75 42 0 0 117
IV 79 36 2 .-0 117
Overall 74 43 0 0 117
KEY:
Criterion
RECOMl'{ENDATI ON S
ANALYSIS OF EVALUATIONS
139
140
and they are: 25, 29, 30, 38, 40, 50, 52, 57, 61, 63,
needed.
SUMMARY
matics teachers.
141
RECO~1ENDATIONS
study:
142
143
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
Journals
other Sources
DATA SHEET
148
149
COVER LETTER
Dear Colleague:
Thank you,
~~ r:?uu'~lekJ
Randy Baumback
150
DATA SHEET
NAME
7
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
151
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
APPENDIX II
152
153
PUZZLE 1 PUZZLE 2
II II I
III III I
--- f - - -
IV IV :
PUZZLE 3 PUZZLE 4
PUZZLE 5 PUZZLE 6
PUZZLE 1 PUZZLE 2
PUZZLE 3 PUZZLE 4
PUZZLE 5 PUZZLE 6
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 7 PUZZLE 8
I 3 I 2 I I 5 :
II 3 i 2 II 5 I
III 3 I 2 III 5 I
IV 4 I 1 IV 5 !
PUZZLE 9 PUZZLE 10
PUZZLE 11 PUZZLE 12
PUZZLE 13 PUZZLE 14
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 15 PUZZLE 16
PUZZLE 17 PUZZLE 18
PUZZLE 19 PUZZLE 20
PUZZLE 21 PUZZLE 22
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 23 PUZZLE 24
Criterion Ratin~
----E--G F P
I 4 1 I 3 2 --
II 4 1 .. _.- II "4 ---
I
III '3- 1--2 III 4 1
IV ~- 1 IV 5
PUZZLE 25 PUZZLE 26
"
PUZZLE 27 PUZZLE 28
PUZZLE 29 PUZZLE 30
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 31 PUZZLE 32
PUZZLE 33 PUZZLE 34
PUZZLE 35 PUZZLE 36
PUZZLE 37 PUZZLE 38
KEY:
criterion Rating
PUZZLE 39 PUZZLE 40
II 4 1 II 4 1
III 5 III 5
IV 4 1 IV 4 1
PUZZLE 41 PUZZLE 42
PUZZLE 43 PUZZLE 44
PUZZLE 45 PUZZLE 46
I
II
III
IV
E G
! 3 I :l I 1 I
I,3 I 1 I 1
i 2
I
1 I 2
I
121 2
F P
1
I
II
III
IV
E G
I~I ~I
EfJ i I
FI
F P
: •
KEY:
criterion Rating
PUZZLE 47 PUZZLE 48
PUZZLE 49 PUZZLE 50
PUZZLE 53 PUZZLE 54
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 55 PUZZLE 56
PUZZLE 57 PUZZLE 58
IV I 5 IV 3 2
PUZZLE 59 PUZZLE 60
PUZZLE 61 PUZZLE 62
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 63 PUZZLE 64
PUZZLE 65 PUZZLE 66
PUZZLE 67 PUZZLE 68
PUZZLE 69 PUZZLE 70
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 71 PUZZLE 72
2 III T 2
IV 3 2 IV 2 3
PUZZLE 73 PUZZLE 74
PUZZLE 75 PUZZLE 76
PUZZLE 77 PUZZLE 78
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 79 PUZZLE 80
PUZZLE 81 PUZZLE 82
PUZZLE 83 PUZZLE 84
PUZZLE 85 PUZZLE 86
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 87 PUZZLE 88
PUZZLE 89 PUZZLE 90
PUZZLE 91 PUZZLE 92
PUZZLE 93 PUZZLE 94
KEY:
Criterion Rating
PUZZLE 95 PUZZLE 96
PUZZLE 97 PUZZLE 98
KEY:
Criterion Rating
tIhl_~B
I 4 1 I
II 3 2 II
2"
III
IV
3
3 "2
III
IV EtHf3
PUZZLE 105 PUZZLE 106
Criterion
---~--,
Rating Criterion
E G F P -
E G
I 2 3 I 4 1
II 2 2 1 II 3 2
III 3 1 1 III 3 2
IV 3 2 IV 5
KEY:
criterion Rating
II 4 1 II 5
III 2 3 III 5
IV 3 1 1 IV 5
PUZZLE 117
Criterion Ratin9:
E G F P
I 2 3 I
II 3 21
III 4 11
IV 3 21
KEY:
Criterion Rating
I Clarity and understandability. E Excellent
II Time factor practicality. G Good
III Motivational value. F Fair
IV Illustration of a mathematical P Poor
concept.