You are on page 1of 100

2.

Geological Complexity

Geotechnical and Geological Engineering with


Melanges, Fault Rocks and Other Bimrocks

Dr. Edmund Medley, PE, CEG, D.GE, F.ASCE


Geological Engineer

Principal Consultant
Photo: Ed Medley
Terraphase Engineering, Oakland, CA

Departamento de Ingenieria Civil


Grupo de Investigation en Geotechnica
Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Medellín

Aula Máxima Facultad de Minas


Sept 18 - 22 2017

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 1


BIG CONCLUSION 1: Remember this
picture!!!

Matrix
Blocks, inclusions, lenses, etc

Scale: 1:?????? Matrix

Actual Distribution of Blocks Medley, 2000


2
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
BIG CONCLUSION 2: Remember this
picture as well!!!

Matrix

Matrix

Apparent Distribution of Blocks


Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 Willis, 20003
Geotechnical Engineering = From Rock to Soil

Simple way
to describe
complexity

Courtesy of Prof.
R.E. Goodman

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


4
“Rock”: simple word, complex concept!
“simple” geology but
challenging rock
engineering

Intact fragmented

“complex” geology and


REALLY challenging rock
engineering
Laznicka, 1988
5
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
An early (1986) Geotechnical
Classification of Complexity

From Medley, 1994

6
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
..and > 1000 geological words/terms for
fragmented rocks and complex mixtures

Laznicka, 1988
7
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
So: the main reason for the word bimrocks

Term “bimrocks” created intended to focus engineer/geopractitioner


on working with geological complexity regardless of countless
geological terms and variety of geological causes

i.e.: reduce the complexity of geologic WORDS and geologic origins to


a simple word/simple concept suitable for engineers

8
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Bimrocks (and bimsoils)
Think of Rock/Soil mixtures
Term “bimrocks” intended to focus engineer/geopractitioner on
working with geological complexity regardless of countless
geological terms and variety of geological causes
Bimrocks definition (Medley, 1994) : block-in-matrix rocks - mixtures
of rocks composed of geotechnically significant blocks within a
bonded matrix of finer texture (melanges, fault rocks, weathered
rocks, etc.)
Geotechnical significance means that there is mechanical contrast between
blocks and matrix, and the geometry and proportion of the blocks influence
the properties of a rock/soil mass underlying a slope, at the scales of
engineering interest (centimeters to hundreds of meters) i.e.: scale matters!
Bimsoils are analogous to bimrocks but with little or no bond between
blocks and matrix (debris flow deposits, glacial tills, colluvium, etc. )
- depends on scale of interest

9
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
A bimsoil: coarse alluvium (BUT: scale matters!)
Road cut Hwy 1
near Carmel, CA
E. Medley, 1990

HARD cobbles
and boulders:
troublesome to
work with?
Depends on
excavation
method

Scale matters! This is a bimsoil at lab scale; possibly for a scraper (but not
a D-10 bulldozer); possibly for micro-tunnel (and maybe a TBM)

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 10


Glacial till: rock/soil mixture

Corestones, block, boulder


soil

Glacial till in Michigan Virginia Tech Univ website

11
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Weathered rock: Bimsoil?
residual HW Soils diagram
corestone (a block)
(http://echo2.epfl.ch/VICAIRE/mod/3/chapt/picture -
s_fig1_7.jpg).jpg

residual

saprolite

Highly to completely weathered basalt


rock in Hawaii

Residual soil not likely a bimsoil; but highly to moderately rock could be
a bimrock/bimsoil (depends on state of matrix)

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


12
Decomposed Granite

Corestones, blocks, boulders

soil

Mixture of weaker soil and strong blocks (decomposed granite


at Hwy 50, California)

13
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
The complexity of a “simple” rock/soil mixture

turbidite sequence - interbedded sandstones and shales


(Devil’s Slide, Pacifica, California) photo: Ed Medley

14
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Complex poly-lithologic geologic mixture

mega-breccia, Death Valley, California

15
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Volcanic rock masses can be complex too

Pahoe’hoe lava Volcanoes National Park, Hawaii

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


16
Background: Basalt Lava Flows

Website of Dan Stora, France


Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
17
Background: Detail of Basalt Lava

Clinker
forms at
cooling
surfaces

Website of Dan Stora, France


Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
18
Formation of clinker

top a’a clinker

a’a rock core

bottom clinker

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


19
Pa’hoe’hoe (ropey lava)

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


20
Volcanoes National Park, Hawaii
a’a lava

Volcanoes National Park, Hawaii


Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
21
a’a lava

a’a
clinker

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


22
Successive flows are irregular

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


23
Volcanoes National Park, Hawaii; Aug 7, 2002
Sequences of rock/clinker/cavities

Volcanoes National Park, Hawaii

Blocks of massive a’a basalt


within irregular non-uniform
sequences of massive a’a, a’a
clinker, paho’hoe flows and
pahoe’hoe lava tubes and
cavities
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
24
Fault Rocks and Shear Rocks
http://www.newcastle.edu.au/department/gl/ro/str/st4.htm

Fault zones and


Shear zones may
have blocks
millimeters to 100s
of meters wide:

Riedmueller et al, 2001

block size distributions


tend to be scale-
independent
5m, 5km,..
5m, 5km,.. Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 25
This is a one line title slide

26
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Significance of Fault Zones

Geotechnical Relevant
Characterization of Brittle Faults

 Faults are elongated complex zones of deformation,


ranging from decimeters to kilometers in magnitude

 A significant internal structure of shear and extensional fractures


has developed, reflecting the geometry of the strain field
and, consequently, the orientation of the principal stresses

 The brittle deformation, such as particle size reduction by


crushing of grains and reorientation of grains by shearing,
generates the characteristic fine-grained gouge

 Low-temperature solution transfer contributes substantially


to the alteration of fault rocks, in particular gouge, through
transformation and neoformation of clay minerals

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


27
Significance of Fault Zones

Geotechnically Relevant
Characterization of Brittle Faults
 The significant geotechnical feature is a substantial heterogeneity,
reflected by the occurrence of more or less undeformed competent
blocks which are typically surrounded by a fine-grained matrix
consisting of gouge and highly fractured rocks. The matrix appears
to be flowing around the blocks in an anastomosing pattern

 The mainly lozenge shaped blocks exhibit a fractal distribution of


dimensions, ranging from the microscale to hundreds of meters in
length. Fault structures are scale independent

 A considerable heterogeneity of the stress field may exist.


Variations in the stress field might be an important cause of
segmentary fault zone formation

 Groundwater conditions are also highly variable. Water pressures


and flow directions may change dramatically across fault zones.
A fault zone acts as aquifer, aquitard and aquiclude
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
28
Block orientation in bimrocks

Cowan,
1985

29
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Mapping of slopes (Bolu Tunnel, Turkey)
Typical Melange Showing Diverse Elongate Blocks
and Irregular Foliated Matrix (S-M-C-Cataclasites)

Area of photo

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


30
Fault Structures

FINE - GRAINED LOZENGE - SHAPED


INTENSELY SHEARED BLOCKS OF NO
GOUGE DEFORMATION

Fault Zone Model, Blocks Show Fractal Dimensions,


from the Micro – to the Megascale (SCALE INDEPENDENCE)
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
31
Sheared Serpentinite

Serpentinite blocks

sheared
serpentinite

Sheared Serpentinite, Franciscan Complex, Oakland.,


California; 2015 photo: E. Medley

32
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Fault Structures

Blocks (phacoids) of quarzite


embedded in
graphite phyllite

Tunnel Steinhaus, Austria, Tunnel Face

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


33
Faulted and Sheared Rock

block

sheared
rock

Mixture of sheared rock and intact blocks at a Quarry


within San Andreas Fault zone – not your typical soil slope
34
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Fault Structures

Foliated soft matrix showing Lenticular stiff block showing


ductile and brittle compressional extension fractures
deformation features

Quartzitic Sandstone,
Devonian

Graphitic Shale,
Carboniferous

Formation of Melange in an Foreland Basin Overthrust Setting,


Main Tunnel, Mae Kuang Irrigation Project, N – Thailand
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
35
Melanges

Franciscan Complex melange, Mendocino California photo: Ed


Medley 36
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges and Similar Bimrocks
• Bimrocks: block-in-matrix rocks
“mixtures of rocks composed of geotechnically significant
blocks within a bonded matrix of finer texture”

• Melanges: (French mélange) : UNCHILE* mixtures of


competent blocks composed of sedimentary/ metamorphic
blocks in weaker matrix of sheared shale or serpentinite

• Melanges are the most difficult bimrocks..

• Similar Bimrocks: Saprolites, Breccias, Fault Zones, Lahars,


Tillites, etc.

*CHILE: CONTINUOUS HOMOGENEOUS ISOTROPIC LINEARLY ELASTIC

37
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges (mélanges)- the most intractable of bimrocks
melanges: geological mixtures with poly-lithologic blocks ranging in size from
sand to mountains

Gwna Melange, Tryn-y-moel, Lleyn Peninsula, Wales Franciscan Complex melange, Caspar
Headland, near Mendocino, California

38
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges are common (and ignored!)

Verizon ad San Francisco International Airport, Oct 2007

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, 39


Sept. 2017
Global distribution of melanges (> 70 countries)

Medley, 1994
40
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Franciscan Complex near San Francisco, California

From Medley, 1994; after


Ellen and Wentworth,1995

41
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[LQ6DQ)UDQFLVFR
$OFDWUD]7HUUDQH
FUXVWDO
EORFNRI´EURNHQ
IRUP DWLRQµ OLNHP pODQJH 
JUD\Z DFNH VDQGVWRQHV
DQGVKDOHV

)W3RLQW+XQWHUV3RLQW6KHDU
=RQH DP HODQJHRIVKHDUHG
VKDOHDQGVHUSHQWLQLWH ZLWK
VDQGVWRQHVDQGH[RWLFEORFNV

&LW\&ROOHJH6KHDU=RQHLV
P HODQJHRIVKHDUHGVKDOH 0 DULQ+HDGODQGV7HUUDQH 
ZLWKVDQGVWRQHV FKHUWV
 FUXVWDOEORFNODUJHO\RI
JUHHQVWRQHV DQGH[RWLF HURVLRQUHVLVWDQWP DVVHVRI
EORFNV FKHUWDQGJUHHQVWRQH

Source: GDR, Transbay


Transit Center, Arup
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 42
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[* UD\Z DFNHORZ 0 [6DQGVWRQH

Graywacke hand sample

http://www.nps.gov/goga/forteachers/images/graywack
Graywacke outcrops at Baker Beach, Presidio, San Francisco e2-copy.jpg

http://www.nps.gov/goga/forteachers/images/graywacke-outcrop1.jpg

7\SLFDO)UDQFLVFDQ&RP SOH[JUD\ZDFNHYHU\KDUG RIWHQJUHHQLVKFRORU


GLUW\VDQGVWRQH

GHSRVLWHGFORVHWRVRXUFH
P DQ\IUDJP HQWVRIYROFDQLFURFNV

6: : &"6RXUFHRIP XFKRI6)FRQFUHWHDJJUHJDWH
6: : &" P HDQV6R: KDW": KR&DUHV": K\GRHVWKLV
LQIRUP DWLRQP DWWHU WRP HDVDQHQJLQHHU "" Copyright © All rights reserved ‐ Dr. 
Edmund Medley, Sept.  2017 43
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[* UHHQVWRQH 0 [EDVDOW
greenstone at Shell Beach
(http://geology.about.com/od/geology/ca/ig/CA
shellbeach/shellbchgreenstone.htm)

7\SLFDO)UDQFLVFDQ&RP SOH[JUHHQVWRQHLQ0 DULQ+HDGODQGV7HUUDQH


HJ
7ZLQ3HDNVDUHD 
YHU\KDUG
FKDUDFWHULVWLFJUHHQFRORU

6: : &"&DQEHYHU\KDUGDQGHQFRXQWHUHGXQH[SHFWHGO\
Copyright © All rights reserved ‐ Dr. 
44
Edmund Medley, Sept.  2017
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[& KHUWDVVRFLDWHGZ LWKJUHHQVWRQH
Marin Headlands: E
Medley 2005

7\SLFDO)UDQFLVFDQ&RP SOH[FKHUWLQ0 DULQ+HDGODQGV7HUUDQH  HJ


7ZLQ
3HDNV YHU\KDUGLQWHQVHO\IUDFWXUHG
EUHDNVLQWRSULVP DWLFEORFNV
6: : & UDYHOVRQVORSHVXQGHVLUDEOHLQFRQFUHWH
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept.
2017 45
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[6HUSHQWLQLWH0 [P DILFXOWUDP DILF

http://www.nps.gov/prsf/naturescience/images/serpent1_2.jpg Baker Beach landslides in Serpentinite 
ttps://encrypted‐
tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSLlad8a3K1pA7zGIk2giaaZrYhh_bkJBFRK4A7wQUwxFC4fAce

6HUSHQWLQLWH
&$6WDWH5RFNIRUP HGE\0 [
URFNVFUDSHGIURP EDVHRIVXEGXFWHGRFHDQLF
SODWH0 [DWKLJK3
ORZ7
ZLWKZDWHU

6: ": &"&DQEHYHU\WURXEOHVRP HIRU


http://0.tqn.com/d/geology/1/0/f/A/1/taffyboulder.jpg
HQJLQHHUV
DQGP D\KRVWDVEHVWRVP LQHUDOV
Copyright © All rights reserved ‐ Dr. 
46
Edmund Medley, Sept.  2017
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[P pODQJH P HODQJH
Mendocino; E Medley ~1992

Weaker sheared matrix  

But: weaker “ sheared matrix” is 
big block of strong graywacke  actually a mix of hard blocks in 
sheared shale   

7\SLFDO)UDQFLVFDQ&RP SOH[P HODQJH DWHFWRQLFP L[WXUHRIKDUGEORFNVRIURFN P RVWO\


JUD\ZDFNH LQVKHDUHGVKDOHP DWUL[ 
6: : & VKHDUHG
´IROLDWHG
P DWUL[FDQEHYHU\ZHDN YHU\WURXEOHVRP H
EORFNVFDQEH
YHU\KDUGDQGYDULDEOHOLWKRORJ\VWUHQJWKVL]H
'LIILFXOWWRFKDUDFWHUL]HFKDRV
Copyright © All rights reserved ‐ Dr. 
Read the mixture: Medley, mélange, Wales, Berkeley, etc..
http://edmedley.com/blog/2009/02/07/on-first-encountering-melange/ Edmund Medley, Sept.  2017 47
$)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[P HODQJHRXWFURSVFDOH

tortuous shear

48
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Typical Melange Showing Diverse Elongate Blocks
and Irregular Foliated Matrix (S-M-C-Cataclasites)

Slope debris

Sandstone

Marble / Shale
Tectonic Melange
(Photo C)

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


49
Typical Melange Showing Diverse Elongate Blocks
and Irregular Foliated Matrix (S-M-C-Cataclasites)

Melanges look like fault rocks


Bolu Tunnel, Turkey

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


50
weak block/matrix contacts
Gwna Melange
Lleyn Peninsula,
N. Wales
photo: E . Medley

51
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Matrix and blocks in core

matrix-rich core - sheared


shale: (aka argille scagliose)

Intercept of block and core (not the


“diameter!)

Scott Dam melange (California) photos: Prof . R Goodman

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 52


Simple model for origin of melanges

Prof R E Goodman
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
53
BUT: melanges are even more complex : there are many
different kinds, and many geology arguments

Laznicka, 1988
Cowan, 1985

54
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Definition of melange (from Geological Dictionary)

“ A body of rock mappable at a scale of 1:24.000 or smaller and


characterized both by lack of internal continuty of contacts or strata
and by the inclusion of fragments and blocks of all sizes, both exotic and
native, embedded in a fragmanted matrix or finer-grained material”

In engineering sense and considering the scale of most engineering


works (larger than 1:24,000) This definition is not satisfactory

Prof.Dr. Reşat Ulusay, Turkey, 2004

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. 55


Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges in Turkey

Prof.Dr. Reşat Ulusay, Turkey, 2004

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. 56


Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges in Turkey: the Geological Engineering Experience of
Prof.Dr. Reşat Ulusay, Hattecepe Univ. Turkey (2004)

• Melanges have been recognized by geologists as significiant components


of orogenic belts for decades, yet the engineering community has been
slow to appreciate their importance

• In many engineering projects, melanges are still treated as stratified


units, or occasionally mistaken for soil with boulders

• Whether a melange is of tectonic or sedimentary origin is unimportant


for engineering purposes

• In contrast, the grade of metamorphism of the matrix can be


important, because significiant recrystallization of the matrix
strengthens it and reduces block-matrix strength contrast

• Serious errors have been by engineers made because of


mischaracterization of melanges

57
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Summarizing: bimrocks have strong blocks, weak matrix

Sheared
serpentinite

melange

Weathered rocks Major fault zones

58
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Summarizing: block-in-matrix fabric is common
Bimrocks include: melanges, fault rocks, weathered rocks, etc.

Bimsoils, analogous to bimrocks but without bonded matrix (debris


flow deposits, glacial tills, colluvium, etc. - depends on scale of
interest

Bimrocks/bimsoils often have severe spatial variability and


mechanical/lithological heterogeneity- depends on scale of interest!

SO WHAT? Mischaracterizations of bimrocks co$t - so important to


Contractors, Owners and Lawyers

Geopractitioners must consider blocks (lithology, shape, SIZE etc..)

59
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Start by looking at blocks (look at matrix later!)

Soon-to-be Dr. Julien


Waeber, Geological Engineer

Concretions in Panoche Fm, Livermore, CA: photo E Medley, 2006

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


60
Some elements of CHARACTERIZATION
(much more in another Lecture)
•Block/matrix discrimination
•Matrix lithology
•block size
Prof. Dimitrios Zekkos
•block shape
•block lithology
•block orientation
•block size distribution
•block discontinuities
•Etc… Photo: Julien Waeber, 2006

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


61
Q: : KDWLVEORFNVL]H""$ 5DUHO\WKH´GLDP HWHU”

G round surface maximum


observed
Boring
dimension

“ Diameter“

dmod

chord

“Diameter”
Boredcore

Buried block exploredby a boring

Outcropped block

62
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Drilling through a block: chords and diameters

Diameter

Only rarely will a drilled


chord be the same as the
diameter: so when drilling
bimrocks be very careful
when you use the words:
“block diameter”
chord

After Russ and Dehuff (2000),


“Practical Stereology”
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
63
the importance of scale
independence in our
work with bimrocks

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


64
Scale independence

Cowan, 1985
65
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
a Franciscan Complex melange: blocks at many scales

Caspar Headlands Mendocino area, CA E Medley

Huge blocks, big blocks, small


blocks, tiny blocks – all depends
on your scale of interest

66
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Measuring block
sizes
“size” = dmod
(and size
distributions)
in 2-dimensions

Outcrop scale of
interest
A
A< 1 m2

Medley, 1994
67
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Histogram of block sizes

Medley, 1994

68
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Log Histogram of block sizes

“fractal dimension” in 2D:


D=1.2 (add 1 to get fractal
dimension in 3D)

Medley, 1994

69
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Block measurements at many scales

Medley, 1994

70
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Histograms at several scales
Distributions look similar….

“Censoring” of data
due to undercounting-
blocks too small to
see at this scale but
will be counted when
scale zooms in
smaller

Medley, 1994

71
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Log Histograms at several scales

Medley, 1994

72
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Normalization by √A

Medley, 1994

73
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Add Franciscan Complex blocks in Marin County

A Regional map
scale of interest
A~1000 km2

From Medley, 1994; after


Ellen and Wentworth,1995

74
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Log Histogram at km scale

75
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Compare Log histograms at different
scales

76
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Scale-independent block size distributions of
Franciscan melanges
Block/matrix
threshold:
0.05√A

dmax= size of largest


block: 0.75√A

Low
frequency
because too
small to
count
accurately
(“censored
data” Kalendar et al, 2014, after
Medley, 1994
Plotted as a Log-Histogram
77
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Another reason to select the 5%
block/matrix threshold

Number
of blocks
95% of number
of blocks are
smaller than
Volume 0.05dmax but
represent
< 1% of total
volume of
blocks

0.05dmax

dmod/dmax
78
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Blocks in Franciscan Complex melange
(and many other bimrocks)
• Blocks range in size between mountains and sand and will always be
present, even if you cannot see them

• Block size distributions are scale independent and fractal (power law) - they
look much the same

• regardless of scale – one or two large blocks, and increasing numbers of


smaller blocks

• Largest reasonable block is:


0.75A aka dmax

• Block/matrix threshold is 0.05A

• Blocks will always be found: Characterization must take blocks into account

79
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
AND: findings from studies of “model”
bimrocks at outcrop and laboratory scale
ARE
relevant for in-situ bimrock masses!!!

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


REG
80
SO: if blocks will be found at all scales:
What is Block and What is matrix?
Scale matters!

Need a characteristic dimension (Lc) to scale the


bimrock mass to the scale of engineering interest (like
having coin, penknife, Significant Other/Graduate Student
in field photos))

Lc is lab specimen diameter, height of slope, width of


footing, thickness of expected failure zone, √A, etc.

81
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Use these guidelines at any scale of
interest
• smallest blocks are:
0.05Lc or 0.05 A or 0.05dmax

•largest block is:


0.75Lc or 0.75 A or 0.75dmax
(Medley and Lindquist, 1995)

82
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
When is a block not a block? Depends on scale of interest
For a large area, A: use
Lc= A (100m)
Smallest block = 5 m
100 m Largest block = 75 m

At scale of trench
Lc~ 2 m (trench width)
Smallest block = 0.1 m
Largest block =1.5 m

pipeline trench R. of W.
100 m
20m At scale of width of
Right. of Way (for day to
day progress)
1 m block Lc= 20 m (ROW width)
Smallest block = 1 m
Largest block =15 m

For construction
estimates of whole
trench use  Area of
trench (45 m)
Smallest block = 2.2 m
Largest block = 33 m
83
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
From the chaos of geological
complexity and geological words we
can focus on a few simple ORDERLY
concepts

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


84
So: the block-in-matrix fabric is common
Summarizing so far:

Lessons learned from studying engineering problems in melanges


applies to geotechnical problems for all geologically complex
mixtures

Bimrocks include: melanges, fault rocks, weathered rocks, etc.

Bimsoils, analogous to bimrocks but without bonded matrix (debris


flow deposits, glacial tills, colluvium, etc. - depends on scale of
interest

Bimrocks/bimsoils often have severe spatial variability and


mechanical/lithological heterogeneity- depends on scale of interest!

SO WHAT? Mischaracterizations of bimrocks co$t - so important to


Contractors, Owners and Attorneys

Geopractitioners must consider blocks (lithology, shape, SIZE etc..)

85
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
BIG CONCLUSION 1: Remember this
picture!!!

Matrix
Blocks, inclusions, lenses, etc

Scale: 1:?????? Matrix

Actual Distribution of Blocks Medley, 2000


86
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
BIG CONCLUSION 2: Remember this
picture as well!!!

Matrix

Matrix

Apparent Distribution of Blocks


Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017 Willis, 200087
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
88
EXTRAS

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


89
Weathered Rocks
•Rock weathers into soil, saprolite and corestones above intact bedrock

Corestones, ledges, wedges,


blocks, boulders, cobbles,
etc… of rock surrounded by
soil

Enchanted Learning website

University of Florida website

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


90
bimrocks are “miserable materials”

V. Marinos, P. Marinos , . Hoek,


“The geological strength index:
applications and limitations”,
Bull Eng Geol Environ (2005) 64:
55–65 DOI 10.1007/s10064-004-
0270-5
Courtesy: www.Rocsciece .com

91
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
“ At the scale of engineering interest, a chaotic rock mass composed of
competent blocks of various size and lithology, embedded within a weaker,
usually argillaceous matrix” (Medley, 1994)

Road cut

Dam site

Prof.Dr. Reşat Ulusay, Turkey, 2004

Tunnel Slope

Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017


92
Scale-independent block size distributions of
Franciscan melanges

Plotted as a Log-Histogram
Medley, 1994
93
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Formation of Clay Minerals

Sample 1: Smectite 92%


Illite 8%

Sample 1a: Smectite 87%


Illite 13%

Sample 2a: Smectite 77%


Mixed Layer
3%
Kaolinite 17%
Illite 3%

Sample 2b: Sample 40%


Kaolinite 50%
Illite 10%

Fault Zone in Gneiss („Zentralgneis“)


HPP MALTA – Göß Tunnel, Km 4,615
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
94
Fault Structures

Foliated soft matrix showing Lenticular stiff block showing


ductile and brittle compressional extension fractures
deformation features

Quartzitic Sandstone,
Devonian

Graphitic Shale,
Carboniferous

Formation of Melange in an Foreland Basin Overthrust Setting,


Main Tunnel, Mae Kuang Irrigation Project, N – Thailand
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
95
Fault Structures

Extension fractures Blocks of serpentinite

Extensional shears

4 cm base

Typical Structure of Ophiolitic Melange in Mesoscale


Egnatia Motorway, N-Greece
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
96
Fault Structures

Blocks of Serpentinite in an Ophiolitic Tectonic Melange


Egnatia Motorway, N- Greece
97
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Fault Structures

Foliated quartzite Blocks of dolomite marble

Graphitic Phyllite

Tectonic Melange in an Alpine Thrust Setting


Semmering Motorway, Tunnel Steinhaus, Austria
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
98
Fault Structures

Marble block
with calcite filled
extension
fractures
embedded in
graphitic phyllite
and foliated
quartzite

Tectonic Melange in an Alpine Thrust Setting


Semmering Motorway, Tunnel Steinhaus, Austria
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
99
Fault Classification (Classical References)

• Brekke T.L & T. R. Howard (1973):


Functional classification of gouge material from seams and
faults in relation to stability problems in underground
openings. U.S.Bureau of Mines Contr. H0220022, pp.195.

• Zhang Xian-Gong, Han Wen-Feng & Nie De-Yin (1986):


Engineering geological classification of fault rocks. 5th Intern.
IAEG Congr. Buenos Aires, 479 - 486.

Engineering Geological Classification of Fault Rocks


100
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017

You might also like