Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geological Complexity
Principal Consultant
Photo: Ed Medley
Terraphase Engineering, Oakland, CA
Matrix
Blocks, inclusions, lenses, etc
Matrix
Matrix
Simple way
to describe
complexity
Courtesy of Prof.
R.E. Goodman
Intact fragmented
6
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
..and > 1000 geological words/terms for
fragmented rocks and complex mixtures
Laznicka, 1988
7
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
So: the main reason for the word bimrocks
8
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Bimrocks (and bimsoils)
Think of Rock/Soil mixtures
Term “bimrocks” intended to focus engineer/geopractitioner on
working with geological complexity regardless of countless
geological terms and variety of geological causes
Bimrocks definition (Medley, 1994) : block-in-matrix rocks - mixtures
of rocks composed of geotechnically significant blocks within a
bonded matrix of finer texture (melanges, fault rocks, weathered
rocks, etc.)
Geotechnical significance means that there is mechanical contrast between
blocks and matrix, and the geometry and proportion of the blocks influence
the properties of a rock/soil mass underlying a slope, at the scales of
engineering interest (centimeters to hundreds of meters) i.e.: scale matters!
Bimsoils are analogous to bimrocks but with little or no bond between
blocks and matrix (debris flow deposits, glacial tills, colluvium, etc. )
- depends on scale of interest
9
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
A bimsoil: coarse alluvium (BUT: scale matters!)
Road cut Hwy 1
near Carmel, CA
E. Medley, 1990
HARD cobbles
and boulders:
troublesome to
work with?
Depends on
excavation
method
Scale matters! This is a bimsoil at lab scale; possibly for a scraper (but not
a D-10 bulldozer); possibly for micro-tunnel (and maybe a TBM)
11
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Weathered rock: Bimsoil?
residual HW Soils diagram
corestone (a block)
(http://echo2.epfl.ch/VICAIRE/mod/3/chapt/picture -
s_fig1_7.jpg).jpg
residual
saprolite
Residual soil not likely a bimsoil; but highly to moderately rock could be
a bimrock/bimsoil (depends on state of matrix)
soil
13
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
The complexity of a “simple” rock/soil mixture
14
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Complex poly-lithologic geologic mixture
15
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Volcanic rock masses can be complex too
Clinker
forms at
cooling
surfaces
bottom clinker
a’a
clinker
26
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Significance of Fault Zones
Geotechnical Relevant
Characterization of Brittle Faults
Geotechnically Relevant
Characterization of Brittle Faults
The significant geotechnical feature is a substantial heterogeneity,
reflected by the occurrence of more or less undeformed competent
blocks which are typically surrounded by a fine-grained matrix
consisting of gouge and highly fractured rocks. The matrix appears
to be flowing around the blocks in an anastomosing pattern
Cowan,
1985
29
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Mapping of slopes (Bolu Tunnel, Turkey)
Typical Melange Showing Diverse Elongate Blocks
and Irregular Foliated Matrix (S-M-C-Cataclasites)
Area of photo
Serpentinite blocks
sheared
serpentinite
32
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Fault Structures
block
sheared
rock
Quartzitic Sandstone,
Devonian
Graphitic Shale,
Carboniferous
37
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges (mélanges)- the most intractable of bimrocks
melanges: geological mixtures with poly-lithologic blocks ranging in size from
sand to mountains
Gwna Melange, Tryn-y-moel, Lleyn Peninsula, Wales Franciscan Complex melange, Caspar
Headland, near Mendocino, California
38
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Melanges are common (and ignored!)
Medley, 1994
40
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Franciscan Complex near San Francisco, California
41
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
)UDQFLVFDQ& RP SOH[LQ6DQ)UDQFLVFR
$OFDWUD]7HUUDQH
FUXVWDO
EORFNRI´EURNHQ
IRUP DWLRQµOLNHP pODQJH
JUD\Z DFNH VDQGVWRQHV
DQGVKDOHV
)W3RLQW+XQWHUV3RLQW6KHDU
=RQH DP HODQJHRIVKHDUHG
VKDOHDQGVHUSHQWLQLWH ZLWK
VDQGVWRQHVDQGH[RWLFEORFNV
&LW\&ROOHJH6KHDU=RQHLV
P HODQJHRIVKHDUHGVKDOH 0 DULQ+HDGODQGV7HUUDQH
ZLWKVDQGVWRQHV FKHUWV
FUXVWDOEORFNODUJHO\RI
JUHHQVWRQHV DQGH[RWLF HURVLRQUHVLVWDQWP DVVHVRI
EORFNV FKHUWDQGJUHHQVWRQH
http://www.nps.gov/goga/forteachers/images/graywack
Graywacke outcrops at Baker Beach, Presidio, San Francisco e2-copy.jpg
http://www.nps.gov/goga/forteachers/images/graywacke-outcrop1.jpg
http://www.nps.gov/prsf/naturescience/images/serpent1_2.jpg Baker Beach landslides in Serpentinite
ttps://encrypted‐
tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSLlad8a3K1pA7zGIk2giaaZrYhh_bkJBFRK4A7wQUwxFC4fAce
6HUSHQWLQLWH
&$6WDWH5RFNIRUP HGE\0 [
URFNVFUDSHGIURP EDVHRIVXEGXFWHGRFHDQLF
SODWH0 [DWKLJK3
ORZ7
ZLWKZDWHU
Weaker sheared matrix
But: weaker “ sheared matrix” is
big block of strong graywacke actually a mix of hard blocks in
sheared shale
tortuous shear
48
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Typical Melange Showing Diverse Elongate Blocks
and Irregular Foliated Matrix (S-M-C-Cataclasites)
Slope debris
Sandstone
Marble / Shale
Tectonic Melange
(Photo C)
51
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Matrix and blocks in core
Prof R E Goodman
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
53
BUT: melanges are even more complex : there are many
different kinds, and many geology arguments
Laznicka, 1988
Cowan, 1985
54
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Definition of melange (from Geological Dictionary)
57
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Summarizing: bimrocks have strong blocks, weak matrix
Sheared
serpentinite
melange
58
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Summarizing: block-in-matrix fabric is common
Bimrocks include: melanges, fault rocks, weathered rocks, etc.
59
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Start by looking at blocks (look at matrix later!)
“ Diameter“
dmod
chord
“Diameter”
Boredcore
Outcropped block
62
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Drilling through a block: chords and diameters
Diameter
Cowan, 1985
65
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
a Franciscan Complex melange: blocks at many scales
66
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Measuring block
sizes
“size” = dmod
(and size
distributions)
in 2-dimensions
Outcrop scale of
interest
A
A< 1 m2
Medley, 1994
67
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Histogram of block sizes
Medley, 1994
68
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Log Histogram of block sizes
Medley, 1994
69
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Block measurements at many scales
Medley, 1994
70
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Histograms at several scales
Distributions look similar….
“Censoring” of data
due to undercounting-
blocks too small to
see at this scale but
will be counted when
scale zooms in
smaller
Medley, 1994
71
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Log Histograms at several scales
Medley, 1994
72
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Normalization by √A
Medley, 1994
73
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Add Franciscan Complex blocks in Marin County
A Regional map
scale of interest
A~1000 km2
74
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Log Histogram at km scale
75
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Compare Log histograms at different
scales
76
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Scale-independent block size distributions of
Franciscan melanges
Block/matrix
threshold:
0.05√A
Low
frequency
because too
small to
count
accurately
(“censored
data” Kalendar et al, 2014, after
Medley, 1994
Plotted as a Log-Histogram
77
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Another reason to select the 5%
block/matrix threshold
Number
of blocks
95% of number
of blocks are
smaller than
Volume 0.05dmax but
represent
< 1% of total
volume of
blocks
0.05dmax
dmod/dmax
78
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Blocks in Franciscan Complex melange
(and many other bimrocks)
• Blocks range in size between mountains and sand and will always be
present, even if you cannot see them
• Block size distributions are scale independent and fractal (power law) - they
look much the same
• Blocks will always be found: Characterization must take blocks into account
79
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
AND: findings from studies of “model”
bimrocks at outcrop and laboratory scale
ARE
relevant for in-situ bimrock masses!!!
81
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Use these guidelines at any scale of
interest
• smallest blocks are:
0.05Lc or 0.05 A or 0.05dmax
82
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
When is a block not a block? Depends on scale of interest
For a large area, A: use
Lc= A (100m)
Smallest block = 5 m
100 m Largest block = 75 m
At scale of trench
Lc~ 2 m (trench width)
Smallest block = 0.1 m
Largest block =1.5 m
pipeline trench R. of W.
100 m
20m At scale of width of
Right. of Way (for day to
day progress)
1 m block Lc= 20 m (ROW width)
Smallest block = 1 m
Largest block =15 m
For construction
estimates of whole
trench use Area of
trench (45 m)
Smallest block = 2.2 m
Largest block = 33 m
83
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
From the chaos of geological
complexity and geological words we
can focus on a few simple ORDERLY
concepts
85
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
BIG CONCLUSION 1: Remember this
picture!!!
Matrix
Blocks, inclusions, lenses, etc
Matrix
Matrix
91
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
“ At the scale of engineering interest, a chaotic rock mass composed of
competent blocks of various size and lithology, embedded within a weaker,
usually argillaceous matrix” (Medley, 1994)
Road cut
Dam site
Tunnel Slope
Plotted as a Log-Histogram
Medley, 1994
93
Copyright © All rights reserved - Dr. Edmund Medley, Sept. 2017
Formation of Clay Minerals
Quartzitic Sandstone,
Devonian
Graphitic Shale,
Carboniferous
Extensional shears
4 cm base
Graphitic Phyllite
Marble block
with calcite filled
extension
fractures
embedded in
graphitic phyllite
and foliated
quartzite