Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TEACHeXCELS Module 6 PDF
TEACHeXCELS Module 6 PDF
MODULE 6
Second Edition
Second Edition
SEAMEO INNOTECH
Copyright © by SEAMEO INNOTECH
All rights reserved. Published 2010.
Printed in the Philippines
ISBN 978–971–0487–30–1
www.seameo-innotech.org
www.innotech.org
Contents
What Is This Module About? ............................................................................... 1
What Will You Learn? ........................................................................................... 2
Flow of Instruction ................................................................................................ 4
What Do You Already Know? ............................................................................. 5
Feedback ................................................................................................................. 7
How Do You Rate Yourself? ................................................................................. 8
After studying this module, you should have enhanced your competencies
on facilitating the teaching-learning process and how you can effectively
share these with the teachers that you lead. You will develop skills that,
when transferred to your teachers, will help them deliver instruction more
effectively. You are expected to be able to do the following after completing
the lessons in this module:
This module is composed of three lessons that will familiarize you with
strategies and techniques that can enhance the teaching-learning process,
namely:
The lessons covered in this module will provide you with the essential
knowledge and skills that will help your teachers enhance your school’s
teaching-learning activities.
Each lesson can be completed in about two hours. The whole module can,
therefore, be completed in about six hours if you really take time to sit
down and work on it. It may, however, take you about a week to work on
the lessons on a part-time basis. Make sure you work diligently on the said
activities and tests to find out how much you have learned.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
a. Visual
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
b. Auditory
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
d. Tactile
___________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
6. Can you tell between effective and ineffective praise? Write E on the
spaces beside the praise statements that are effective, and I for ineffective
praise statements.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Feedback
Check your answers by comparing them with those in the Key to Correction
on pages 110-112. Some of your answers may not be expressed in exactly
the same way, but as long as the thoughts they express are similar, mark
your answers as correct.
The perfect score is 17 points. If you got 15 or more correct answers, you
are already very familiar with the contents of this module. However, you
may still need to study this module to refresh your memory and learn new
concepts. If you got a score of 14 or lower, the more you should study this
module carefully in order to acquire the knowledge, skills, and values
that will make you an effective instructional leader, especially in terms of
facilitating the teaching-learning process.
1. Discuss the
role of teaching
philosophy
in facilitating
the teaching-
learning
process.
2. Write your
statement
of teaching
philosophy.
3. Describe the
characteristics
of facilitative
teaching.
4. Analyze your
teaching style.
5. Explain the
different
teaching styles
to teachers.
6. Guide teachers
in interpreting
their teaching
styles.
7. Explain the
different
learning styles
and factors that
affect learning.
8. Explain
motivation in
the context of
teaching and
learning.
9. Demonstrate
effective
teaching
strategies to
teachers.
10. Train teachers
in formulating
enabling and
challenging
questions.
11. Promote active
learning and
reflecting
thinking.
12. Implement
facilitative
teaching and
learning in your
school.
Let’s Read
Read the two scenarios below carefully.
Teacher A
Mr. Kamulwat is a third-grade teacher in a primary school. He has been
teaching for five years. He loves teaching and considers it his vocation.
He believes that students have their own unique abilities that he can
help develop by giving them opportunities to learn and practice their
skills. He feels that his students have as much to teach him as he them
so he encourages his students to ask questions and plan activities that
will enable them to apply new lessons to practical situations. He gives
his students opportunities to work in groups and come up with projects
that further explore their new skills.
Feedback
Compare your answers with those in the Key to Correction on page 112. If
your answers are similar to mine, that’s great! If you have other answers,
share and discuss them with your co-learners and Flexible Learning Tutor.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
2. Why are the two teachers’ teaching beliefs and attitudes different?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Teachers’ beliefs and attitudes are different from one another’s because they
are unique individuals who have different experiences. These experiences,
whether acquired from their training as teachers or when they were still
students, form the foundation of their teaching attitudes and activities. For
a school head like you, helping teachers examine and reflect on their beliefs
and attitudes about teaching-learning is an important step toward making
them more effective providers of instruction.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
The activity shows you that teachers teach differently using different
techniques and approaches because they have different teaching
philosophies. A teaching philosophy is a set of beliefs that a teacher values
as well as uses as a guide in instructional activities. It encompasses the
teacher’s beliefs about students, learning, teaching, and his/her role as an
educator.
Purposes
Components
Before you can help your teachers determine their teaching philosophy, it
would be best if you yourself could undergo the experience of defining your
own teaching philosophy and writing your own philosophy statement. Are
you ready to do that now? Then, proceed to the next activity.
Format
10 Steps to Completion
2. Jot down what you know about your students and how they
learn.
What school factors affect the way you teach? What were some
critical moments or experiences for you as a teacher? How do you
know that a teaching activity or a course has been successful?
Consider how these issues are connected.
Use these ten (10) steps to help guide you in preparing your own teaching
philosophy statement. Write your teaching philosophy statement on a
separate piece of paper or in your learning journal. Share your teaching
philosophy statement with your co-learners and Flexible Learning Tutor
for feedback.
Call the teachers to a meeting. Discuss with them what you learned about
teaching philosophy. Encourage them to ask questions, and then ask them
to prepare their own statements of teaching philosophy. Provide them with
a copy of the format and the 10 Steps to Completion.
Provide positive feedback and encouragement and ask the other teachers
to do the same. Ask all the teachers to include their statements of teaching
philosophy in their teaching dossier. A teaching dossier is a five- to eight-page
document with appropriate appendices. It is an opportunity to document
and present teaching achievements both for self-assessment and for review
and interpretation by others who make personnel decisions (SEAMEO
INNOTECH, 2010).
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
It is well known that learners differ from one another. They come from
diverse cultural backgrounds and they have a wide range of learning
needs. Some may have challenging physical, mental, and social problems.
Others may not be strongly motivated to learn. Learners also tend to vary
significantly in the degree to which they are willing to engage in self-directed
learning by comparison with learning under close teacher guidance. They
also differ in how much they prefer to learn using a hands-on approach as
opposed to learning through listening and reading. Correspondingly, some
teachers may not possess the facilitation skills needed to deal with learners
of diverse learning styles and preferences.
This scenario calls for the intervention of a school head like you. As an
instructional leader, your guidance to your teachers on good teaching for
diverse students is crucial. Good teaching is now understood to involve a
process of facilitating learning rather than being the simple transmission of
knowledge from the teacher to the learner.
What comes to your mind when you hear the phrase “facilitative teaching”?
What roles should teachers take as facilitative teachers? Write your answers
on the space below:
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Let’s Read
Roles and Behaviors of Facilitative Teachers
The teachers in your school play a crucial role in facilitating the teaching-
learning process. The box below describes their tasks as facilitative teachers
(Smith & Blake, 2005).
Teacher Behaviors:
• Listens actively
Teacher Behaviors:
Teacher Behaviors:
Teacher Behaviors:
Teacher Behaviors:
Content Knowledge
Pedagogy Knowledge
Teacher Behaviors:
Are there teachers in your school who already demonstrate the qualities and
behaviors of facilitative teachers? If there are, have you been supporting
them? What can you do to nurture their facilitative teaching skills? Write
a brief reflection about this in the space provided.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
13. Validate the good things that are happening in their classrooms as
part of best practices.
As a leader of change, you have to keep in mind that there will always
be resistant teachers who will cause you to reflect and to question your
actions in the process. Regardless of whether the teachers are completely
on board with new initiatives or not, you, as school head, must continue to
work toward engaging individual teachers in an effort to improve student
learning. Building upon positive working relationships to address various
aspects of teaching-learning will enable you to work your way through.
You will also be able to model facilitative teaching and foster respect and
understanding if you appreciate not only their teaching philosophies, but
also the resulting teaching styles.
Teaching Styles
Do you know your teachers’ teaching styles? Before you go and find out
theirs, let us first see what your own teaching style is.
This assessment will help you determine your teaching style. Answer
the following questions by placing a check mark (p) on the space before
the letter that corresponds to your answer. You are allowed to choose
only one answer for each question.
a. teacher-made tests
c. performance-based criteria
b. role-playing
c. peer-tutoring
d. brainstorming
a. lectures
b. demonstrations
c. films/videos
d. class discussion/brainstorming
Count the number of times you checked each letter and write the frequency
counts on the table below. Each letter corresponds to a teaching style. A
is for the formal authority teaching style, B is for the demonstrator or
personal model teaching style, C for facilitator teaching style, and D for
the delegator teaching style.
If you have the most number of check marks on A, you have a formal
authority teaching style. Review the A items in the checklist. What does it
mean to have a formal authority teaching style? Write your answer on the
space below.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Are your check marks mostly on C? Then, your teaching style is that of a
facilitator. Read the C items in the checklist again. Any idea about what a
facilitator teaching style is? Write your answer below.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Did you score highest on D? Then, you are a delegator in terms of teaching
style. Review the D items in the checklist. What is the delegator teaching
style?
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Are there letters where you have an equally high score? If yes, then you are
adapting a mix in some elements of other styles. Is it possible for a teacher
to be using two or more teaching styles? Read on to find out.
Formal Authority
Facilitator
This type of teaching style works best for students who are comfortable
with independent learning and who can actively participate and collaborate
with other students.
Delegator
Teachers who have a delegator teaching style tend to place much control
and responsibility for learning on individuals or groups of students.
This type of teacher, who is also a “Guide on the side,” will often give students a
choice in designing and implementing their own complex learning projects
and will act in a consultative role.
Given the four teaching style categories, is it possible for a teacher to be using
two or more teaching styles? The answer is YES. Such a teacher is called the
“All-Round Flexible and Adaptable Teacher”. Mohanna, Chambers, & Wall
(2008) describe this teacher as one who “can use lots of different skills, can
teach both peers and juniors, and is very aware of the whole environment
in relation to teaching and the learners.”
The all-round flexible and adaptable teacher is an effective teacher who can
adapt to any of the four teaching styles depending on the subject matter
and other variables. This implies that as an instructional leader, you need
to help your teachers learn and appreciate the different teaching styles and
adopt two or more for their teaching repertoire. But before you can do this,
you will need to assist them in finding out their own teaching styles.
What are your teachers’ teaching styles? Write the number of teachers
falling under the specific teaching styles on the space provided. Classify
teachers with two or more teaching styles as the all-round flexible and
adaptable teacher.
Let’s Read
Although not all your teachers may be the all-around flexible and adaptable
teacher type, you can help them meet the needs of all the students in any
class by asking them to include several, if not all, of the following techniques
(Engineering, 2009).
• Do not fill every minute of class time lecturing and writing on the
board. Provide intervals - however brief - for students to think
about what they have been told.
• Assign some drill exercises but do not overdo them. Also provide
some open-ended problems and exercises that call for analysis
and synthesis.
Wow! This module has just walked you through important knowledge, skills,
and values that you can share with your teachers on how to state a teaching
philosophy, conduct facilitative teaching, and evaluate their teaching styles.
Your understanding of these important inputs in the teaching-learning
process will come in handy when you study the succeeding lessons that
focus on effective teaching-learning and communication in teaching.
Part 1.
Read the following critical incident then answer the questions that follow.
Critical Incident
The class was discussing a short story on friendship and social skills.
Earlier, the teacher announced that the objective of the discussion was for
the students to come up with general conclusions on social skills. Seated
in chairs arranged as a letter “U”, the students contributed ideas without
being called upon. As they spoke, the teacher wrote their comments on
the board. She did not speak but simply focused on getting the essence
of the contributions noted down. After about ten minutes, she said to
the class, “Where are we? We need to think about this exchange and see
if we can draw some general conclusions out of it. Please review the
notes I have made on the board.” After several minutes of silence, she
said, “Does anybody see any connections between these comments?”
As the students ventured comments, she drew lines and circles, added
numbers, occasionally revising and sometimes erasing. Students were
1. How would you describe the teacher’s role in the class activity
presented?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
3. What do you think was the general atmosphere in the class during the
discussion?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Answer the following questions using the spaces provided for each.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Feedback
Compare your answers with those in the Key to Correction on pages 113–117.
If your answers are similar to mine, that’s great! If not, review those where
you made mistakes, then revise them before proceeding to the next lesson.
Do you want to know more about how an instructional leader like you can
guide teachers in improving the teaching-learning process? Read on if you
do.
Critical Incident
Mr. Kamulwat is worried about a student named Kim. Kim showed
promise as a learner. However, she did not do well in class activities
that did not involve pictures or stories conveying vivid images. She did
poorly in math and science, but when asked to draw pictures, she did
the task gladly. Whenever she asked questions, she tried to relate a new
concept to something she had seen before. Mr. Kamulwat recognized
that Kim seemed to have a different way of learning. So he tried his best
to provide Kim with opportunities to draw and relate new learnings
with images. He noticed that this strategy seemed to work. However, he
also noticed that this approach did not work well for his other student,
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
2. If you are to describe Thuy’s learning style, how would you do so?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Students like Kim and Thuy differ in terms of capacity to learn. Aside from
this or maybe because of it, they also differ in terms of how they learn.
This well-accepted fact has enormous implications for classroom teaching.
Since students learn differently, they should also be taught in ways that
best support their unique ways of learning.
What are learning styles? According to Kolb and Kolb (2005), learning style
describes individual differences in approaches to or ways of learning. A
person’s learning style is a biologically and developmentally imposed set
of personal characteristics that make the same teaching method effective for
some and ineffective for others. What works for Kim will not necessarily
work for Thuy. Like signatures or thumbprints, each learner has a personal
learning style. And if you accept the concept of having different learning
styles, then you must also accept that different approaches to teaching help
students develop their skills because they have unique strengths.
There are many ways to classify learning styles. One of the most popular is
classifying them based on a learner’s sensory preference. The most familiar
concept of learning style involves sensory preferences and how these affect
learning. These preferences lead to different learning styles, which are:
• Visual
• Auditory
• Kinesthetic
• Tactile
In the simplest sense, visual learners best acquire new information by sight.
Kim is a visual learner. She prefers the show-and-tell approach. She wants
demonstrations and assignments rather than mere topic discussions. Visual
learners often ignore verbal directions or find them uninteresting. Hence,
teachers like Mr. Kamulwat must provide opportunities for translating
learning into visual images to help this type of students learn well.
Kinesthetic learners like Thuy prefer activities that involve their whole
bodies. Learners like him prefer dramatizations, pantomimes, and fieldtrips.
They may often be restless in class. Role-playing and interactive games are
good strategies to help them learn.
Let’s Read
Aside from learning styles based on the different sensory preferences,
learning styles may also be based on other individual preferences. Students
can also be classified based on their individual preferences for:
• Sound levels
• Lighting
• Temperature levels
• Seating arrangements
• Mobility
• Group sizes
• Time preferences
Let’s Read
Myths and Facts About Learning
You learned from the foregoing readings, discussions, and activities that
the concept of a ‘learning style’ is used to describe the preferred way, or
process, that a student uses to identify and integrate information. In other
words, the way a student seems to learn most often or most effectively is
called his or her learning style. It should be noted, however, that while
individuals vary in their preferred ways of learning, most people learn best
by actively working with new concepts and ideas, solving problems, asking
In light of this understanding of learning styles, let us find out how well
you can identify commonly held flawed beliefs or myths about learning
against facts. In the list below, write F on the blank if the statement is a fact
about learning. Write M if the statement is a myth about learning.
______ The person who does the most listening does the most learning.
______ The more “serious” the learning is, the more we will remember.
______ The only person who should be the “sage on the stage” is the expert in the
field.
If you wrote M in all the statements, you are correct. Below are flawed
beliefs or myths about learning and their corresponding facts (WGBH
Educational Foundation, 2006).
• Myth: The person who does the most listening does the most
learning.
Fact: The person doing the most talking, moving, or writing is doing
the most learning.
• Myth: The more “serious” the learning is, the more we will
remember.
Fact: Not only do we learn best and remember more when we enjoy
success at an appropriately challenging experience, but we also
become more willing to seek out other challenging experiences.
• Myth: The only person who should be the “sage on the stage” is the
expert in the field.
Instructions:
To find out what learning style you prefer, encircle the numbers
corresponding to statements you agree with.
6. I can always tell directions like north and south no matter where I
am.
8. When I talk, I like to say things like “I hear you,” “That sounds
good,” or “That rings a bell.”
12. When others are talking, I usually create images in my mind of what
they are saying.
14. It’s easy for me to talk for long periods of time on the phone with
friends.
18. I usually say things like “I feel I need to get a hand on it” or “Get a
grip.”
20. When I recall an experience, I mostly hear sounds and talk to myself
about it.
21. When I recall an experience, I remember mostly how I felt about it.
24. I prefer to act things out rather than write a report on them.
Get your total score using the following guide to determine your learning
style.
Visual statements: 2, 3, 6, 7, 12, 17, 19, 23, 25, 30, 31, and 33
Auditory statements: 1, 4, 8, 11, 14, 15, 16, 20, 22, 27, 32, and 34
Kinesthetic statements: 5, 9, 10, 13, 18, 21, 24, 26, 28, 29, 35, and 36
Your percentage score for each style indicates your relative preferred
learning style/s. Compare your scores for each column. What is/are your
predominant learning style/s based on the test? Some people have very
strong preferences, even to the extent that they have little or no preference
in one or two of the styles. Other people have more evenly–balanced
preferences, with no particularly strong style. The point is simply to try to
understand as much as you can about yourself and your strengths (your
preferred style or styles), and then make best use of learning methods
which suit your strengths (your preferred style or styles).
Now that you know how to determine your learning style, it’s time to
introduce the self-test to your teachers. Afterwards, they can ask their
students to accomplish the same instrument. The more the teachers
understand their students’ learning styles, the better they can adapt their
instructions to accommodate as much learning preferences as possible. The
better students know the way they learn best, the greater their chances of
performing well in school.
What is your role as school head in this regard? Your responsibility is that
of guiding your teachers in preparing lesson plans using teaching styles
and techniques that would cover as many learning styles as possible.
Remember the teaching techniques that will benefit all learners covered on
pages 35-36? Ask them to use those and see what difference they make.
Plato, one of the great Greek philosophers, was Aristotle’s teacher, who
in turn, was Alexander the Great’s teacher. A great teacher, Plato, used
didactics or discussions as his primary form of teaching. He acknowledged
very early on that motivation was the key to learning and teaching. Do you
agree with him?
There was once a young duck who was born with only one leg. All
the ducks in the pond laughed at him because of his peculiar state.
Nevertheless, he never gave up trying to learn how to swim with only
one leg. He started by learning how to float. Next, he found a way to
use his wing to compensate for his lack of one leg. In spite of many
failed attempts, he was able to swim in the end. He also helped other
young ducks swim and this made him very happy. The other ducks
were amazed at what he was able to accomplish. One of the older ducks
said, “Young duck, I am impressed by your nice wing and how you were
able to use it to balance and swim.” The young duck replied, “Thank
you, sir, but I wish you could also see the determination behind it.”
• Emphatic leadership
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
This saying means that a teacher can provide the “light of knowledge” in two
ways — by being a provider of information or by acting as a guide, helping
his/her students through the processes of discovery and exploration. This
is especially true in primary schools because studies have shown that early
experiences can be so powerful that they can determine how a person turns
out in the future.
The list below shows concepts that are associated with either internal or
external motivation. On the space before each number, write I if the concept
is associated with internal motivation, E if the concept is associated with
external motivation.
Compare your answers with those in the Key to Correction on page 117.
Let’s Study
Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation for Learning
Motivation is defined as the process that initiates, directs, and sustains goal-
oriented behaviors. Sometimes, these processes are nurtured by drives and
needs within ourselves and the outside forces that direct them (Shalaway,
2005).
The probable downside, however, includes the possibility that the learner
might concentrate on the appearance of achievement to the detriment of
“deep” learning (Atherton, 2010). Some authors also contend that extrinsic
motivators sometimes discourage creativity, the desire to learn, and
commitment to good values (Shalaway, 2005). For example, Jere Brophy,
an educational researcher, said,“The improper use of praise, an extrinsic
motivator, can undermine a student’s desire to learn. Simply saying, ‘You
did a great job!’ may be interpreted in many ways. In this case, the student
who receives the praise may say, ‘Why are you saying that? Is it because I
was doing a poor job before?’” But still, it is important to praise children
for a job well done. This helps them to feel good about themselves and be
willing to continue to try harder. Challenge your teachers to find something
to praise children for each day.
Your teachers praising children publicly is also a good practice. It has the
benefit of inspiring other students to follow the example. Students may
act embarrassed, but the more your teachers point out the positive things
students do, the more students will work to receive your praise. Public
praise is also an excellent way to keep students behave appropriately. For
children who commit misdemeanours in your class, try to catch them in
moments when they are doing good things and focus on praising them. This
will help them shape up faster than being compared to their classmates.
_________1. I noticed how you took time to show the new student around
the school. I am sure she appreciated the help.
_________5. I can see that you enjoy math. You have worked on these
problems for over half an hour!
_________7. I’m glad to see you are working so hard on your spelling!
If you answered all eight questions correctly, you already know very well
how to provide effective praise and you can easily train your teachers
on this skill. If you missed one or more items, you need to re-study the
discussion on how to provide effective praise.
Aside from giving rewards, teachers’ expectations can also influence student
motivation and achievement. Students often reflect and even magnify their
teachers’ expectations. If teachers do not expect much from their students,
chances are, the students will be less motivated to learn.
Let’s Read
Teacher Expectations and Student Behaviors
Teachers should make a habit of expecting just a little more from their
students each day. Pick a subject, an assignment and push students a
little more. It is important that these expectations are not portrayed in an
angry, frustrated or impatient tone. Expectations should be conveyed with
patience, confidence, and gentleness.
Teachers need to spend some time teaching students simple social skills
that help them understand how to make a friend, how to be good friends,
how to walk away from a fight, and other basic social skills. When speaking
with students about how a situation was handled, the teacher should
convey the expectation that next time, the students will act and react more
positively. Teachers need to reward students for small actions that show
they, the students, are meeting expectations (Wagaman, 2009).
To learn more about motivating and effective teaching strategies that you
can train your teachers to apply, read on.
What effective teaching strategies can your teachers use to further improve
the teaching-learning process? Here are some of them:
• Experiential Learning
• Direct Instruction
• Social Learning
• Problem-based Learning
• Constructivist Instruction
• Multiple Intelligences
Which among these strategies are your teachers using in their classes?
Are there other strategies and approaches that they are already effectively
applying? Share and discuss these other teaching strategies with your
Flexible Learning Tutor and co-learners.
Let’s Read
• Develop their skills in stages. “You may find it difficult now but
it will become easier with practice and as you exert more effort.
Sooner or later, you will master the lesson and will find it much
easier.”
• What to learn
• How to learn
A good way that you can impart to your teachers in motivating their
students is to create a thinking atmosphere inside the classroom. Think of
eight possible ways to achieve this. Write down your answers in the spaces
provided below.
1. ______________________________________________________________
2. ______________________________________________________________
3. ______________________________________________________________
4. ______________________________________________________________
5. ______________________________________________________________
6. ______________________________________________________________
7. ______________________________________________________________
8. ______________________________________________________________
2. Start early.
According to Kellough (1994), there are so many activities that teachers can
do to facilitate the teaching-learning process. Basic behaviors that teachers
can manifest to make students learn include:
• Model behaviors.
• Use silence.
• Question intelligently.
Let’s Remember
In this lesson, you learned that:
o Visual
o Auditory
o Kinesthetic
o Tactile
o Sound levels
o Lighting
o Temperature levels
o Mobility
o Group sizes
o Time preferences
o Biological differences
o Imaginative
o Analytic
o Common sense
o Dynamic
o Myth 2: The person who does the most listening does the
most learning.
o Myth 5: The more “serious” the learning is, the more we will
remember.
o What to learn
o How to learn
o How well they need to learn and why
Let’s see how much you have learned from this lesson. Try to answer the
questions below.
Part 1
1. Match each student learning style with the most appropriate learning
strategy by connecting each correct pair with a line.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
b. The person who does the most listening does the most learning.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
d. The more “serious” the learning is, the more we will remember.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
h. Is general or global.
Part 2
Read the critical incident below and answer the questions that follow.
Critical Incident
The clock ticks to 2:40 p.m. and the bell rings. With a weary smile, Ms.
Choong waves goodbye to her grade two pupils as they scurry out of
the classroom. Feeling a sense of relief, she goes back into the classroom.
Sighing, she looks at the pile of spelling test papers on her desk, starts
going through them, and finds that most of the words in the test papers
were misspelled. She had been so sure that her pupils would be able to
spell most of the words because she saw them listening well and looking
at the flashcards when she taught them the words. Apparently, it was
not so. At least, not for everyone. Ms. Choong sets aside the papers,
too disheartened to review them. Her eyes feel teary as she reflects on
her day. She had caught Adi, Mazlan, and Ros secretly drawing each
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
2. What results does she get from adapting the teaching style?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Ways to Overcome
Challenges
the Challenges
If you got all the 30 answers correct, that’s great! This means that you have
already learned so much from Lesson 2. You may now proceed to Lesson
3. If you missed 5 items or less, you still did well, but review the parts of
the lesson that you missed in order to appreciate the concepts better. If you
got 6 or more incorrect answers, study this lesson carefully one more time.
Reviewing the contents may help you understand the lesson much better.
Concentrate on the parts that you missed. Revise your answers after your
review. After doing so, you may then proceed to Lesson 3.
Part of good teaching is the ability to ask questions that trigger the use
of information stored in the mind of the student. Facilitative teachers ask
enabling questions that promote further learning and the use of higher
order thinking skills.
_______________________________________________________________
2. What did the merchants and courtiers do when they came upon the
roadway?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
What do you think about the questions you have just answered? Respond
to the following questions with a Yes or a No.
1. Did the questions encourage you to think about the story? __________
2. Did they challenge you to extract the moral of the story? __________
3. Did the questions lead you to appreciate the story based on how they
were asked? __________
The answers to all the questions above should be No. They were all recall
questions. As such, they failed to encourage you to analyze and appreciate
the moral of the story. They are what almost 90 percent of teachers ask
their students every day. It is about time you learn how to transform recall
questions into enabling ones or questions that enhance learning and the
use of higher-order thinking skills.
Through the years, educators have recognized the value of good questioning
as an essential educational tool. Questions have many significant purposes
in education. Questions can encourage critical thinking, promote reasoning
skills, determine the amount of information absorbed by students, and
stimulate interest. Asking the “right” questions can stimulate higher
order thinking skills which develop creativity and insight among students
(Shalaway, 2005). Do you know what higher order thinking skills are? They
represent the higher levels of cognitive functioning. Higher order thinking
skill questions are not merely fact-recall or comprehension questions. They
encourage learners to analyze and explore further applications of acquired
knowledge. You may learn more about higher order thinking skills in the
TEACHeXCELS module, Manage the Integration of Multiple Intelligences
and Higher Order Thinking Skills.
Many teachers today still ask questions that only encourage recall of
information (Shalaway, 2005). These questions focus on the lowest level
of cognitive functioning. Put simply, they only challenge students to
regurgitate or repeat information and not actively process them. Asking
good questions is essential in enhancing the teaching-learning process.
As school head, you are expected to guide your teachers in learning how
to ask more enabling rather than just recall questions. Teachers need to
develop their skills in asking “good” questions and, in the process, help
their students become better thinkers. Study the strategies given below.
1. Yes, but why? Teachers need to ask their students why they
think their answers are correct rather than just accept them as
true. If a student answers that “Photosynthesis is the process of
food/energy production in plants,” don’t just say, “That’s right!”
Instead, ask him/her, “Yes, but why can’t plants produce food the way
humans do?” This will encourage better information processing
and not just recalling as well as develop the student’s ability
to think.
2. What’s the use? Teachers need to ask questions that encourage the use
of information. Ask questions like, “Why do you need to know the different
ways of food production by various organisms?” In this way you present
to your students an opportunity to remember facts more easily and
promote appreciation for the topic by highlighting its relevance.
• Modify. “If plants were to produce food only through the use of moonlight
instead of sunlight, what do you think would happen?”
• Substitute. “What do you think would happen if all plants were blue
instead of green?”
• Magnify. “If bees that help pollinate flowers were as big as cats, would
they still be able to do their job?”
• Reverse. “If fruits appeared before flowers, how would this affect the
pollination cycle?”
• Combine. “How different would the world be if there were only one kind
of plant?”
4. Can you prove it? Ask for proofs for answers. This requires learners to
formulate answers and support them. “How can you prove that sunlight is
essential for photosynthesis in plants?”
5. Right, wrong, or neither? Avoid questions that have only one correct
answer. Encourage creative thinking by asking questions that have
answers that require students to defend them. Ask questions like,“How
important is knowing about agriculture in human history?”
6. All of the above? Ask questions that have more than one correct answer
like, “What plants can be used as medicine? Why?”
Feedback
Compare your answers with mine in the Key to Correction on page 122.
How did you find the activity above? Did it stimulate your interest in the
topic? Did it make you think more analytically and creatively? Did you find
this activity fun? Imagine what it would be like for your teachers and their
students!
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
2. What did the merchants and courtiers do when they came upon the
roadway?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Do you think your questions would now make the students think more? Why?
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
Compare your answers with mine in the Key to Correction on page 123.
Now that you are already more familiar with the kinds of questions to ask
to strengthen learning among students, you will learn next how to ask
these questions. Below are some tips for asking questions that can further
enhance the teaching-learning process.
On the other hand, questions should not only come from the teacher.
Students should also be encouraged to direct their own questions not
only to the teacher, but also to each other. Many students are afraid to
ask questions for fear of ridicule. Make sure that the classroom is an
environment that is safe for such an activity. Show respect to your students
for them to also respect you. In other words, teach by example.
Think-Pair-Share
Sample situation:
Games
Student Debates
Student Dialogues
This strategy may be used for review or for the actual exam. This technique
helps students actively process material, gives them a better understanding
of the difficulties in writing reliable and valid examination questions, helps
them review material, and gives them practice for the exam.
Mini-Research Projects
A teacher can have the students conduct a research study on a topic from
the class. The teacher can guide them on collecting data during class time
through observing some situations or giving out short surveys. The teacher
can also guide students on doing outside-of-class data gathering. Either
way, students will, afterwards, present their research in a class research
symposium similar to the conduct of professional meetings. The teacher
may invite other faculty and students as guests.
The teacher may ask students to do three steps: collate raw data about
certain topics, analyze them, and draw up a conclusion. The teacher can
review the students’ data analysis and provide feedback so the students
are guided on how to utilize raw data.
Case Studies
The teacher may bring to class case studies for students to read. Students
can discuss and analyze the case as well as apply concepts, data, and theory
to the class. They can work individually or in groups or do this as a think-
pair-share activity. The teacher may consider combining this with a brief
in-class writing assignment.
The teacher can have students make journal or log entries periodically (on
paper or computer, in or outside of class). He/She may also require a brief
critical reflection or analysis of each entry. The teacher should be aware of
ethical issues involved in asking students to record and analyze personal
events or issues.
Newsletter
Concept Map
What does the statement above mean to you? Do you agree with it?
The statement above means that students who are actively involved in the
learning process learn better. In active learning, students are provided with
opportunities to learn through application and practice, which enhance the
learning process and guarantee comprehension.
Let’s Read
Reflective Teaching: Thinking About Teaching
Toward Professional Growth
There is a saying that goes, “The better you are at thinking and talking
about teaching, the better you are in the classroom.” Do you agree
with this? Teachers should be encouraged to stop and think about the
way they teach every now and then. As school head, you should help
them reflect on their skills as educators. Systematic reflection on one’s
teaching skills is not easy. It needs time and effort. Reflective teaching is
thinking about one’s skills as a teacher and constantly findings ways to
improve them.
The following are some tips on journal-keeping that you can share with
your teachers (Shalaway, 1999).
• Keep track of how much you have been focusing on each aspect of
teaching.
What do you think of the journal entry above? Was it easy to understand?
Were you able to relate to the teacher who noted her insights about the way
she teaches and the way her students respond to her in class? How would
your teachers like it as a sample for writing simple journal entries?
Some teachers may want to keep track of their progress but have little time
for writing. They may write shorter journal entries similar to those shown
below.
August 8, 2009
August 9, 2009
This module has just walked you through your role as the first resource on
facilitative and reflective teaching for the teachers. With the knowledge,
skills, and values you have gained on leading teachers in facilitating the
teaching-learning process in your school, you can now look forward to
improved student performance and enhanced teacher competencies.
Let’s Remember
In this lesson, you learned that:
n Adapt
n Modify
n Substitute
n Magnify
n Minify
n Rearrange
n Reverse
n Combine
o Alike or different?
o Think-Pair-Share
o Collaborative learning groups
o Games
o Student debates
o Student-to-Student dialogues
o Student-generated exam questions
o Mini-research proposals or projects
o Using raw data
o Analysis of case studies
o Keeping journals or logs
o Writing and producing newsletters
o Concept mapping
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
a. What is photosynthesis?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Feedback
Compare your answers with those in the Key to Correction on pages 123–
124. If your answers are similar to mine, that’s great! If not, review the
parts of the lesson you made mistakes in; then, revise your answers before
proceeding to the final part of the module.
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
a. Teacher-centered
b. Democratic
c. Student-focused
a. _____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
b. _____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
c. _____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
d. _____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
8. What do you think would happen if a teacher did not practice reflective
teaching?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
11. What do you think are the key elements of active learning?
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________
Feedback
Compare your answers with those in the Key to Correction on pages 124–
127. Some of your answers may not be worded exactly as mine, but so long
as they express the same thought, you may give yourself a point.
If you answered all the questions correctly, that’s great! That means you
have learned much from this module. If not, review the parts of the module
that you made mistakes in. Revise your wrong answers after your review.
For a final check, may I invite you to return to the Self-Rating Competency
Checklist on pages 8-9. Review the list of competencies and place another
set of check marks (p) on the “Post” column that best describes your level
of mastery of each competency now that you have completed the module.
Compare your competency level before and after studying the module and
reflect on how much you have learned. Write your insights on the space
below.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
The final activity for this module requires you to complete the following
module assignment. Please follow the Module Assignment Guidelines
detailed below.
2. Present to them what you have learned from this module regarding how
they can improve the teaching-learning process.
3. Divide them into groups, then have each group come up with a lesson
plan that integrates enabling questions and active learning strategies
into the teaching process.
4. Discuss their lesson plans with them and ask them to implement these
for one week. Explain to them that you will be visiting their classes in
which they will apply the respective lesson plans.
You may also ask your teachers to start their own journals where they
can record their reflections or learnings from you as their school head/
supervisor. Their journals should document how they applied their
learnings to improve student performance.
a. What worked and what did not work when your teachers
implemented their respective lesson plans?
b. What feedback did you provide to your teachers? Give examples.
c. What other support did you extend to your teachers on their use of
enabling questions and active learning strategies?
a. Visual
Viewing students’ photo and art exhibit
Constructing maps
b. Auditory
Listening to stories
Singing about a topic
c. Kinesthetic
Role playing
Playing games that involve physical activities
d. Tactile
Performing experiments
Preparing a diorama or dish garden
5. What might happen if teachers failed to provide students with choices in terms
of learning activities?
Students tend to lose interest and motivation faster if they are not
given choices in terms of activities. Different students are interested in
different things. Thus, the challenge for teachers is to provide varied
activities that will tap the interests of their different learners.
I a. Good job!
Part 1
1. How would you describe the teacher’s role in the class activity presented?
The students’ role was that of active participants and “resource persons”
in the class discussion. They were the main players in the activity.
3. What do you think was the general atmosphere in the class during the discussion?
a. Provides a meaningful context for learning where lessons are framed by the
context of the students’ life situations.
The topic of the short story was on friendship and social skills. This
is an important topic for students as it forms part of their day-to-day
activities at home and at school.
The teacher drew out responses from the students and provided
questions and prompts that encouraged the students to exchange ideas
and discuss with one another. The process also enabled the students to
exercise critical thinking skills.
d. Recognizes that the prior learning and life experiences of learners are valuable
foundations for constructing new knowledge and skill sets.
Part 2
Delegator – Teachers who have this teaching style tend to place much
control and responsibility for learning on individuals or groups of
students. Students are often asked to work independently or in groups
and must be able to maintain motivation and focus for complex
projects.
You can help your teachers meet their students’ needs and deliver
effective instruction by sharing with them teaching techniques that can
benefit all learners. The teachers should be encouraged to include as
many techniques as are doable in their situation and continue adapting
more until they are able to apply all the techniques. These teaching
techniques include:
• Do not fill every minute of class time lecturing and writing on the
board. Provide intervals - however brief - for students to think about
what they have been told.
• Assign some drill exercises but do not overdo them. Also provide
some open-ended problems and exercises that call for analysis and
synthesis.
E 1. I noticed how you took time to show the new student around the school. I am
sure she appreciated the help.
The correct answer is E, effective, because the statement specifies the
praiseworthy aspects of the student’s behavior.
E 5. I can see that you enjoy math. You have worked on these problems for over
half an hour!
The correct answer is E, effective, because the statement attributes
student success to effort and ability.
How Much Have You Learned From This Lesson? pages 77–81
Part 1
1. Visual: b and f
Auditory: a and g
Kinesthetic: c and d
Tactile: e
d. The more “serious” the learning is, the more we will remember.
This is a myth because studies have shown that while some learners
prefer a serious learning atmosphere, others thrive well in a learning
situation where there is sense of humor and fun.
h. General or global.
Part 2
Many of Mrs. Choong’s pupils are not performing well in spelling tasks
and some become uninterested in the class. Some activities, like the
science experiment, become too difficult for her because she tries to do
them all her own. She becomes weary and her health suffers because she
does most of the doing and talking in class.
3. How would you describe the pupils’ motivation for classroom learning?
4. In the table below, write the challenges encountered by your teacher, Ms.
Choong, and how you, as her instructional leader, would help her overcome the
challenges.
Ways to Overcome
Challenges
the Challenges
Many of Ms. The school head may train Ms. Choong on the use
Choong’s of facilitative teaching skills and techniques that can
pupils are not benefit all learners no matter what their learning
performing styles are. Instead of just using flash cards and
well in spelling direct teaching to the pupils (which benefit only
tasks. visual learners), Ms. Choong could provide concrete
materials like actual objects or pictures of the words
being spelled, or create opportunities for students to
do something active besides reading the flash cards
and writing notes, such as acting out the words or
spelling the words with their bodies or by forming the
words using beads or other things that they like.
Pupils’ lack of The school head may train Ms. Choong on applying
interest in the teaching techniques that heighten the motivation of
topic being students to learn. This includes relating the topic to
discussed. situations that are fun, familiar, and significant to
the pupils. For example, instead of directly teaching
the pupils about flags, Ms. Choong may group the
students into three teams and ask the teams to create
their own flags that would symbolize their respective
teams. This will definitely be a fun starting point for
rich pupil-centered discussions about flags, leading
to their discussion of the national flag as guided by
Ms. Choong. The school head can also train her on
exploring the multiple intelligences of the students
by asking them to draw or create the national flag
using available materials or to act out the history of
the flag.
Possible answers to the question, “What do you think would happen if humans
produced food through photosynthesis?”
7. Having lunch breaks would mean going out to get doses of sunlight.
You may have thought of other creative ideas. Share and discuss them with
your co-learners and Flexible Learning Tutor.
1. If you were the king, would you have done the same thing? Why?
3. How similar or different would the story be if the merchants and the
courtiers were also carrying the same load on their backs?
4. Make analogies between the elements of the story and your life.
5. Explain the statement, “The peasant learned what many did not
understand.”
You may have thought of other interesting enabling questions. Share and
discuss them with your co-learners and Flexible Learning Tutor.
How Much Have You Learned From This Lesson? pages 101–102
c. What do you think would happen if the third letter of the English
alphabet were removed?
d. What do you think would happen if the light bulb had not been
invented?
You may have thought of other interesting questions. Share and discuss
them with your Flexible Learning Tutor.
How Much Have You Learned From This Module?, pages 104–107
1. What are the strengths of facilitative teaching? Its challenges? Explain your
answers.
a. Teacher-centered
b. Democratic
c. Student-focused
5. Enumerate the four learning styles based on learners’ sensory preferences. Give
a brief description of each one.
You may have thought of other interesting questions. Share and discuss
them with your Flexible Learning Tutor.
8. What do you think would happen if a teacher did not practice reflective
teaching?
12. What are the roles of a school head in promoting teachers’ skills in facilitating
the teaching-learning process?
Facilitate - means to make a certain task easy or easier to carry out and
accomplish
Gatling gun approach - refers to asking one question after another in rapid
sequence
Optimize - means to get the most out of something or using its full
potential
Bloom, B., Engelhart, M., Furst, E., Hill, W., and Krathwohl, D. R. (1956).
Taxonomy of Educational Objectives Book 1: Cognitive Domain. New York:
David McKay Company, Inc.
Cashman, K. (2008). Leadership from the Inside Out: Becoming a Leader for Life.
California: Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc.
Mohanna, K., Chambers, R., & Wall, D. (2008). Your Teaching Style: A Practical
Guide to Understanding, Developing and Improving. United Kingdom:
Radcliffe Publishing.
Ramsey, R. (1997). 501 Tips for Teachers: Kid-Tested Ideas, Strategies, and
Inspirations. Chicago, Illinois: Contemporary Books.
Shalaway, L. (2005). Learning to Teach: not just for Beginners The Essential
Guide for All Teachers, 3rd Edition. New York: Scholastic Professional
Series.
Shalaway, L. (1999). Learning to Teach: Not just for Beginners The Essential
Guide for All Teachers, 3rd Edition. New York: Scholastic Professional
Series.
Stein, J., Steeves, L., and Mitsuhashi, C. (2001). Teaching Styles. Online
Teaching: Have You Got What It Takes? Retrieved from http://members.
shaw.ca/mdde615/tchstyles.htm
Constructivism
[Adapted from Constructivism in Teaching and Learning
Project COMPETE Module (SEAMEO INNOTECH, 2002)]
We can not fully understand, much less appreciate, constructivism and its
implications on improving our pedagogy if we don’t have a glimpse of its
historical context and antecedent. In the 18th century, an Italian philosopher
by the name of Giambattista Vico held that humans can only clearly
understand what they themselves have constructed. To know, according to
Vico, means to know how to make. Implied from his view is that whatever
it is that we succeed in learning is nothing more or less than the ideas we
construct for ourselves.
• Organize students.
Modelling
• Write legibly.
• Demonstrate competence.
Accepting
Clarifying
Using Silence
Questioning
Lesson Planning
• Is able to multitask
• Is approachable
2. Constructivist teachers use raw data and primary sources, along with
manipulative, interactive, and physical materials.
For example, students can read historical accounts of the effects of the
social policies of the early 1960s on the economic and educational profile
of the Muslim population in the Philippines. Or, students can be taught to
read the census reports and allowed to generate their own inferences about
social policies. The former relies on the authority of a stranger, the latter on
the ingenuity of the individual student. Lists of figures and pages of charts
are probably not the first images evoked when the terms “hands–on” or
“manipulative” are heard. But the census data can tell a loud story if the
right pages and lists are highlighted in the context of a good question.
The words we hear and use in our everyday lives affect our way of thinking
and, ultimately, our actions. When one teacher asks students to select a
story’s main idea from a list of four possibilities on a multiple-choice test,
and another teacher asks students to analyze the relationships among three
of the story’s characters or predict how the story might have proceeded
had certain events in the story not occurred, the tasks being required are
different. Analyzing, interpreting, predicting, and synthesizing are mental
activities that require students to make connections, delve deeply into texts
and contexts, and create new understandings.
In a 3rd grade classroom, a teacher read a story to her students about three
children who got lost in a forest. The teacher related that after struggling
mightily, yet unsuccessfully, to find their way, one of the three children, a
brave and daring youngster, volunteered to go off alone in search of help
while the two waited in a clearing. At this point, the teacher stopped and
asked the students to predict how the story was likely to end and to support
their answer. Majority of the students predicted that all three would be
rescued. Their reason? They pointed out the competence of the child who
went off in search of help. The students used information and impressions
gathered from the text to predict how the story was likely to end. Framing
Although some teachers may not have much latitude regarding content, all
generally have a good deal of autonomy in determining the ways in which
the content is taught. For example, a certain elementary science curriculum
called for students to begin learning about the “scientific method” and to
conduct some rudimentary experiments using this method: ask a question
(develop a hypothesis), figure out a way to answer the question (set up an
experiment), tell what happens (record your observations), and answer the
question (support or refute the initial hypothesis). One 5th grade teacher
asked her students, in preparation for this assignment, to talk about their
favorite things at home. One student, Jade, spoke about her cat. A classmate,
Eric, discussed his house plants. Capitalizing on their responses, the teacher
asked Jade and Eric to think of questions each had about the cat and the
plants. Jade wanted to know if her cat would like other cat foods as much
as he liked the brand he normally ate. Eric wanted to know how plants
grow. Through the teacher’s mediation, Jade organized an experiment to
answer her question about cat food. She arranged four different brands
of cat food in four different bowls and placed them on the floor. When the
cat entered the room, she observed which bowl he went to initially and
from which bowl he ate. Jade changed the positions of the bowls and tried
the experiment again. Ultimately, she concluded that her cat preferred one
brand over the others.
The students’ thinking drove these experiments, and the teacher’s mediation
framed the processes that followed. The curriculum content—exploration
of the scientific method—was addressed faithfully in a different manner for
each student.
When teachers share their ideas and theories before students have an
opportunity to develop their own, students’ questioning of their own
theories is essentially eliminated. Students assume that teachers know more
than they do. Consequently, most students stop thinking about a concept or
theory once they hear “the correct answer” from the teacher.
Two weeks later, while this same class grappled with another seemingly
simple problem—how to redraw silhouettes in half the original size—one
student, after much consideration of the question, declared: “Now we’re
trying to figure out what ‘half’ really means. I still want to know: What is a
battery!” In each of these sessions, the students addressed their questions
and statements to one another. The teacher clarified the questions they
raised of one another and demanded accuracy of word choice, but the
communication currents were between and among the students and led to
deeper understandings of the topics at hand.
Students of all ages develop and refine ideas about phenomena and then
hold tenaciously onto these ideas as eternal truths. Even in the face of
“authoritative” intervention and “hard” data that challenge their views,
students typically adhere staunchly to their original notions. Through
experiences that might engender contradictions, the frameworks for these
notions weaken, causing students to rethink their perspectives and form
new understandings. Consider the following example:
After a moment’s thought, the student said, “I guess they wouldn’t have
changed that much.”
The teacher then asked, “Would anything else have changed? How about
Germany’s quest to rule Europe?”
The student replied, “I can’t think of anything that would have changed,
except that maybe the Archduke would still be alive.”
“Then,” continued the teacher, “what was it that made this event the cause
of the war?”
The student, now quite enmeshed in thought, said, “I guess that maybe
it [the war] could have happened anyway. But, the killing of Austria’s
Archduke gave the Germans an excuse to begin their plan to conquer all
of Europe. When Russia and France jumped in to help Serbia, the Germans
declared war on them, too. But, I think I see what you mean. It was probably
going to happen anyway. It just happened sooner.”
Note that this elaborate explanation didn’t come from the teacher. It came
from the student. Note also that the student said, “I think I see what you
mean,” as if the meaning came from the teacher. But it did not. The meaning
was constructed by the student who was ready and able to understand a
different point of view. When the student revealed his original perspective,
the teacher was presented with the opportunity to intervene; but the
contradiction was constructed by the student.
In every classroom, there are students who, for a variety of reasons, are
not prepared to respond to questions or other stimuli immediately. They
process the world in different ways. Classroom environments that require
immediate responses prevent these students from thinking through issues
and concepts thoroughly, forcing them, in effect, to become spectators as
their quicker classmates react. They learn over time that there’s no point in
mentally engaging in teacher-posed questions because the questions will
have been answered before they could develop hypotheses.
Another reason students need wait time is that the questions posed by
teachers are not always the questions heard by the students. The “Gatling
gun approach” to asking and answering questions does not provide an
opportunity for the teacher to sense the manner in which most of the
students have understood the questions.
The teacher said: “Now you know what the problem is. Just don’t forget that
the wind is fast, too.” And the teacher moved on to students with whom he
had not yet interacted that day.