Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Trainer
MTA 1
Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer –
ASEAN Master Trainer
MTA 1
Trainee Manual
Project Base
William Angliss Institute of TAFE
555 La Trobe Street
Melbourne 3000 Victoria
Telephone: (03) 9606 2111
Facsimile: (03) 9670 1330
Acknowledgements
Project Director: Wayne Crosbie
Project Manager Jim Irwin
Chief Writer: Alan Hickman
Subject Writer: Alan Hickman
Editor: Jim Irwin
DTP/Production: Daniel Chee, Mai Vu, Kaly Quach
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) was established on 8 August 1967. The Member
States of the Association are Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar,
Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Viet Nam.
The ASEAN Secretariat is based in Jakarta, Indonesia.
General Information on ASEAN appears online at the ASEAN Website: www.asean.org.
All text is produced by William Angliss Institute of TAFE for the ASEAN Project on “Training of ASEAN
Master Trainers and Master Assessors for Front Office, Food and Beverage Services and Food
Production Divisions”.
This publication is supported by the Australian Government’s aid program through the ASEAN-Australia
Development Cooperation Program Phase II (AADCP II).
Copyright: Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) 2014.
All rights reserved.
Disclaimer
Every effort has been made to ensure that this publication is free from errors or omissions. However, you
should conduct your own enquiries and seek professional advice before relying on any fact, statement or
matter contained in this book. The ASEAN Secretariat and William Angliss Institute of TAFE are not
responsible for any injury, loss or damage as a result of material included or omitted from this course.
Information in this module is current at the time of publication. Time of publication is indicated in the date
stamp at the bottom of each page.
Some images appearing in this resource have been purchased from stock photography suppliers
Shutterstock and iStockphoto and other third party copyright owners and as such are non-transferable and
non-exclusive. Clip arts, font images and illustrations used are from the Microsoft Office Clip Art and
Media Library. Some images have been provided by and are the property of William Angliss Institute.
Additional images have been sourced from Flickr and SXC and are used under Creative Commons
licence: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/deed.en
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Introduction to trainee manual
Travel Agencies
Tour Operations.
All of these Competency Standards are available for you to look at. In fact you will find a
summary of each one at the beginning of each Trainee Manual under the heading ‘Unit
Descriptor’. The Unit Descriptor describes the content of the Unit you will be studying in the
Trainee Manual and provides a table of contents which are divided up into ‘Elements’ and
‘Performance Criteria”. An Element is a description of one aspect of what has to be achieved
in the workplace. The ‘Performance Criteria’ below each Element details the level of
performance that needs to be demonstrated to be declared competent.
There are other components of the Competency Standard:
Unit Title: statement about what is to be done in the workplace
Unit Number: unique number identifying the particular competency
Nominal hours: number of classroom or practical hours usually needed to complete the
competency. We call them ‘nominal’ hours because they can vary e.g. sometimes it will
take an individual less time to complete a Unit of competency because he/she has prior
knowledge or work experience in that area.
The final heading you will see before you start reading the Trainee Manual is the
‘Assessment Matrix’. Competency based assessment requires trainees to be assessed in at
least 2 – 3 different ways, one of which must be practical. This section outlines three ways
assessment can be carried out and includes work projects, written questions and oral
questions. The matrix is designed to show you which Performance Criteria will be assessed
and how they will be assessed. Your trainer and/or assessor may also use other assessment
methods including ‘Observation Checklist’ and ‘Third Party Statement’. An observation
checklist is a way of recording how you perform at work and a third party statement is a
statement by a supervisor or employer about the degree of competence they believe you
have achieved. This can be based on observing your workplace performance, inspecting
your work or gaining feedback from fellow workers.
Your trainer and/or assessor may use other methods to assess you such as:
Journals
Oral presentations
Role plays
Log books
Group projects
Practical demonstrations.
Remember your trainer is there to help you succeed and become competent. Please feel
free to ask him or her for more explanation of what you have just read and of what is
expected from you and best wishes for your future studies and future career in tourism and
hospitality.
© ASEAN 2014
2 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Unit descriptor
Unit descriptor
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
This Unit deals with the skills and knowledge required to Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master
Trainer in a range of settings within the hotel, travel and tour industries workplace context.
Unit Code:
MTA 1
Nominal Hours:
105
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 3
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Unit descriptor
© ASEAN 2014
4 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Assessment matrix
Assessment matrix
Showing mapping of Performance Criteria against Work Projects, Written
Questions and Oral Questions
The Assessment Matrix indicates three of the most common assessment activities your
Assessor may use to assess your understanding of the content of this manual and your
performance - Work Projects, Written Questions and Oral Questions. It also indicates
where you can find the subject content related to these assessment activities in the
Trainee Manual (i.e. under which Element or Performance Criteria). As explained in the
Introduction, however, the assessors are free to choose which assessment activities are
most suitable to best capture evidence of competency as they deem appropriate for
individual students.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 5
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Assessment matrix
3.1 Explain pre-requisites for eligibility to become 3.1 31, 32, 33 18, 19
an ASEAN toolbox trainer and Master Trainer
3.2 Define roles and responsibilities of an ASEAN 3.1 34, 35, 36 20, 21
toolbox trainer and Master Trainer
3.3 Explain nature of relationship between ASEAN 3.1 37, 38, 39 22
toolbox trainers and assessors
© ASEAN 2014
6 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Glossary
Glossary
Term Explanation
AM Assessor Manual
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 7
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Glossary
Term Explanation
MA Master Assessor
MT Master Trainer
TG Trainer Guide
TM Trainee Manual
© ASEAN 2014
8 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Element 1:
Identify operational context
1.1 Explain background to the ASEAN-Australia
Development Cooperation Program Phase I
Introduction
The program for training of Master Trainer and Master Assessor follows on from a series of
earlier related projects.
This section discusses the history and development of ASEAN vocational training in the
Hotel and Tourism industries by providing a context to the initiative and presenting some
basic information about William Angliss Institute.
Background
Rationale
There is increasing awareness globally of the key role played by tourism as a driver of
economic development and change and of its contribution to poverty alleviation while at the
same time supporting natural conservation and heritage.
The tourism sector was initially identified as one of the eleven priority sectors targeted for
ASEAN integration by 2015.
The ASEAN region, by providing a safe and secure environment for tourists through
consistent quality service, free movement of labour and enhanced connectivity between all
member states has the potential to contribute positively to increased global tourism demand.
Over the last ten years, along with this growing awareness, has come an equal
understanding of a number of impediments to tourism growth in the ASEAN region:
This initiative was established in support of the Vientiane Action Plan (VAP) and the Mutual
Recognition Arrangement (MRA) which aims to strengthen Human Resource Development
activities through the development of a Common ASEAN Tourism Curriculum (CATC).
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 9
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
The Australian Government aid agency ‘AusAID’ who funded the project through the
ASEAN-Australia Development Cooperation Program (AADCP1)
The ten ASEAN Member States – Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos PDR,
Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Viet Nam
The ASEAN Secretariat based in Jakarta, Indonesia.
General overview of process
Tourism focus
The importance of the progress made by these initiatives can be seen from the fact that a
key Element of the ASEAN Tourism Strategic Plan (2011-2015) is to build on work already
done in the development of the Common ASEAN Tourism Curriculum (CATC).
Produced a Qualifications Framework – see section 1.2, 2.1 and 2.3 for details
Wrote Competency Standards – for Units within the Qualifications Framework (see
section 2.2 for a complete list of these Units)
Developed Packaging Rules – to guide the way Qualifications are created to reflect the
needs of individual students, industry and/or training providers: see section 2.4 for
details.
The development process
The process of developing the Qualifications Framework and writing the Competency
Standards was characterised by:
© ASEAN 2014
10 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
The funding for the current and previous ASEAN Tourism Projects has been provided by the
Australian government agency, AusAID, to the ASEAN Secretariat via the ASEAN-Australia
Development Cooperation Program.
Angliss Consulting, the commercial arm of William Angliss institute has been a key partner
with the ASEAN Secretariat in the design and implementation of several related projects up
to date, including the development so far of 144 training ‘Toolboxes’ in the industry divisions
of housekeeping, front office, food and beverage services, food production and core and
English language competencies. The pilot project to train the first batch of 58 Master
Trainers and Master Assessors (Core/Housekeeping competencies) was led by a project
team from Angliss Consulting in November/December 2012.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 11
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Subsequent action
In addition to curriculum, Toolbox and Master Trainer and Assessor training additional
related projects were undertaken by Angliss Consulting:
2. Feasibility Study for the Establishment of a Regional Secretariat for ASEAN Tourism
Professionals. This involved conducting a feasibility study to assess the need for the
establishment of a Secretariat and to determine whether the use of a Secretariat is the best
option to support and respond to the challenges inherent in the implementation of the Mutual
Recognition Arrangement (MRA) on Tourism Professionals.
© ASEAN 2014
12 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
CATC
CATC stands for Common ASEAN Tourism Curriculum.
It is the common curriculum for ASEAN Tourism Professionals as mutually agreed by the
ASEAN Tourism Ministers following recommendation by the ASEAN National Tourism
Organisation.
The CATC Project, led by a Project Team from William Angliss Institute, was undertaken
between April 2006 and April 2008.
RQFSRS
RQFSRS stands for Regional Qualifications Framework and Skills Recognition System and
it is the overriding educational framework for the ASEAN region.
The RQFSRS comprises 52 qualifications from Certificate II to Advanced Diploma Level,
spread across the six identified Labour Divisions.
Qualifications can be selected be users (according to mandatory Packaging Rules) to suit
individual need from the 242 Units for which Competency Standards were developed and
Toolboxes produced.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 13
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
ACCSTP
ACCSTP stands for ASEAN Common Competency Standards for Tourism Professionals.
The ACCSTP are:
‘Blueprints’ which support the implementation of competency-based common ASEAN
tourism programs
Minimum requirements of competency standards in hotel and travel services which aim
to upgrade tourism services.
Together they provide Trainers and Assessors with the necessary guidance on the skills,
knowledge, and attitudes required for the participants to perform the tasks identified for the
six Labour Divisions at the defined standard for industry.
Developing the 242 Competency Standards of the ACCSTP has enabled stakeholders in the
ASEAN member states to implement tourism training programs which contain the minimum
standards required for participants to undertake a job effectively in the industry.
MRA
MRA stands for Mutual Recognition Arrangement. The MRA is a critical element of the
Project as it underpins the aim of creating a system where there is genuine portability of
credentials between all ASEAN Member States.
The intention of this MRA (the MRA on Tourism Professionals) is to:
Ensure a standard and high-quality level of training and assessment for all students who
undertake training within the CATC/RQFSRS regardless of which country the training
and assessment occurs in
Ensure all Qualifications gained under the RQFSRS are recognised by all ASEAN
Member States regardless of the country which issues the Qualification
© ASEAN 2014
14 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 15
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
RPL
RPL stands for Recognition of Prior Learning.
RPL is the process that gives current industry professionals who do not have a formal
qualification, the opportunity to benchmark their skills and experience against the standards
set out in each Competency Standard.
This process is a learning and assessment pathway which encompasses:
Recognition of Current Competencies (RCC)
Skills auditing
Gap analysis and training
Credit transfer.
RPL acknowledges skills and knowledge can be acquired in a variety of ways other than via
formal training and gives applicants for RPL a chance to have their skills and knowledge
formally accepted and acknowledged regardless of how they were obtained.
Successful application for RPL will give a person ‘advanced standing’ towards Qualifications
they are seeking to attain.
© ASEAN 2014
16 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Regional Secretariat
A follow-on activity from the MRA is the intention to establish a Regional Secretariat to
manage and monitor the facilitation of tourism professionals within the region.
The system to support the MRA will be comprehensive and involves a range of stakeholders
with a full-time professional staff dedicated for the work.
The Regional Secretariat will serve as the responsible institution to oversee the
comprehensive system and activities under the MRA at regional level, including the ASEAN
Tourism Professional Registration System (ATPRS), and also to support the work of the
ASEAN Tourism Professional Monitoring Committee (ATPMC).
Competency
The following is contained in the Trainer Guide for all Toolboxes:
“Competency refers to the ability to perform particular tasks and duties to the standard of
performance expected in the workplace.
Competency requires the application of specified
knowledge, skills and attitudes relevant to effective
participation, consistently over time and in the
workplace environment.
The essential skills and knowledge are either
identified separately or combined.
Knowledge identifies what a person needs to know
to perform the work in an informed and effective manner.
Skills describe the application of knowledge to situations where understanding is
converted into a workplace outcome.
Attitude describes the founding reasons behind the need for certain knowledge or why
skills are performed in a specified manner.
Competency covers all aspects of workplace performance and involves:
Performing individual tasks
Managing a range of different tasks
Responding to contingencies or breakdowns
Dealing with the responsibilities of the workplace
Working with others.”
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 17
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
18 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
In relation to CBA:
It is a process of systematically collecting evidence and making a judgement of a person
performance against the prescribed competency standard
It seeks evidence/proof of trainee competency, in relation to the endorsed Industry
Competency Standards against which they are being assessed.
This evidence may be obtained by:
Observing their work – in the workplace or in a simulated setting
Obtaining reports of their competence from supervisors, co-workers and customers
Sighting samples of work they have done.
To be assessed as Competent a candidate must demonstrate they are able to:
Perform at an acceptable level of skill
Organise the required tasks
Respond and react appropriately when things go wrong
Fulfil a role in the scheme of things at work
Transfer skills and knowledge to new situations.
Principles of CBA
CBA operates under the following principles:
Fairness – assessment:
Must be equitable to all groups of learners
Procedure and criteria must be made clear to all
learners before
Must be mutually developed
Must be able to be challenged.
Reasonable Adjustment – this requires:
Measures or actions taken to provide a student with a disability the same educational
opportunities as everyone else.
Reasonable adjustments must be appropriate for the person and must not create
undue hardship.
Reliability – meaning assessment:
Must be consistent
Techniques must be consistent in the results they give
Must be regularly reviewed to ensure all assessors are making decisions in a
consistent manner.
Flexibility - assessment:
Must provide for the recognition of knowledge and skills regardless of how they have
been acquired
Must be made accessible to learners through a variety of delivery modes.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 19
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Validity - assessment:
Must assess the range of skills and knowledge needed to demonstrate competency
Be based on evidence drawn from a number of occasions.
Evidence rules
Evidence/proof which is captured and used as the basis for
making the ‘Pass Competent’/’Not Yet Competent’ decision
must conform to the following rules – it must be:
Valid – that is, the evidence must:
Assess only the Elements and Performance Criteria of
the competency
Reflect only the skills knowledge and context of the
competency
Reflect demonstration and application of the standard
Reflect the Qualification level being assessed.
Sufficient – that is, the evidence must:
Be enough to enable the ‘Pass Competent’/’Not Yet Competent’ decision to be made
Be demonstrated over a period of time
Cover all aspects of the competency.
Authentic – that is, the evidence must:
Be the trainee’s own work
Be able to be verified as genuine.
Current – that is, the evidence must:
Reflect candidate ability at this point in time
Demonstrate current skills and knowledge used in the workplace
Reflect skills and knowledge which comply with current standards.
Overview of CBT and CBA
Occupational/job analysis forms the basis of a competency
The focus of training is on the performance of the competency
Trainees have access to the competency statements and the level of
achievement/assessment required
Assessment methods are appropriate
The results are reported as competencies achieved
Detailed records are maintained.
© ASEAN 2014
20 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
General acknowledgement
It is acknowledged all participants in this course are professionals with extensive and
relevant industry skills and experience combined with suitable professional vocational
training certification.
The purpose of this section is not to teach or re-train participants but to remind them of the
key principles which need to be applied.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 21
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
22 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 23
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Barriers to learning
All training/learning situations may be impacted by barriers to learning.
Common barriers which need to be taken into account include:
The Trainer:
Trainer attitude is critical – they must be:
– Positive
– Approachable
– Supportive
– Open
– Honest
– Unbiased and unprejudiced.
Trainers must be properly prepared:
– Preparation for training is like an iceberg – people only see the third above the
waterline, the other two thirds are below the water line
© ASEAN 2014
24 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
– Lack of adequate planning and preparation by the Trainer is one of the biggest
barriers to student learning.
The training environment:
The training room must be appropriate for what is being delivered
The place must be appropriately equipped
Lighting must be adequate for safety
Temperature must be comfortable
Distractions must be eliminated or minimised
Layout of the training room must be suitable for the type of training to be conducted.
The individual trainee:
Must have the necessary language and literacy skills – see below – required
numeracy skills
Must be ready, willing and motivated to learn
Needs to attend when required.
English language as a barrier in the ASEAN context
In relation to the ASEAN Toolboxes there is a need to maintain awareness of all the points
listed below:
The entire CATC is delivered in English
English is a foreign language for most participants
Currently there is no mechanism to determine English language levels of students or
Trainers
Currently there are no entry level guidelines for English language to be able to undertake
delivery or participation in training
English language content may be challenging for many trainees
English language content and delivery in English may be challenging for some Trainers
Trainers may not be experienced in modern teaching methodology
Inherent risks raised by an English language barrier may include:
Learners are not competent in skills areas due
to low level English language proficiency
Trainers are unable to deliver units effectively
Learners with mixed English language abilities
in classes can be extremely challenging for
Trainers and potentially frustrating or a
‘paralysing’ experience
Not meeting desired outcomes of the
curriculum.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 25
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Training as a system
It is possible and useful to view training as a process comprising the following sequential
steps or stages:
Identify training needs – which can embrace skills, knowledge and attitude
Determine entry level of learners – to identify what they already know including
implementation of RPL
Specify learning outcomes and objectives on the basis of the above
Determine content of the training and the sequence in which it will be delivered
Select appropriate training strategies to deliver identified training
Deliver training
Assess learner achievement and progress
Evaluate trainer performance and training delivery and resources.
© ASEAN 2014
26 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 27
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Administration
People to be informed
Safety issues
Specific support requirements of the learners
Other organisational requirements.
© ASEAN 2014
28 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Details of references – for students to use to follow along and obtain additional
information.
Role of assessment
Assessment used must be Competency Based Assessment and is applied in order to
generate evidence, information, proof or data to enable the ‘Pass Competent’/’Not Yet
Competent’ decision to be made.
Competency Based Assessment is a process of systematically collecting evidence and
making a judgement of a person performance against the prescribed Competency Standard.
Assessment must:
Incorporate reference to and use of RPL where appropriate
Embrace and reflect requirements listed in the Competency Standard in relation to:
Critical aspects of assessment
Context of assessment
Be appropriate to the nature of the content/Competency Standard
Ensure students/candidates are advised about all relevant assessment details and have
ready access to information regarding their assessment and how, when and where it will
be conducted and assessed
Assess only what candidates have been told they will be assessed on
Conform to what candidates have been told about their assessment – regarding, for
example, when and where it will occur, how long they have to complete it,
materials/resources which will be supplied, what they will be expected to do or
demonstrate
Align with the principles of CBA – refer back to section 1.3 for details
Comply with Evidence Rules – see section 1.3 for full information.
Content
‘Content’ refers to the information provided within the training to enable competency in
relation to the requirements of the Competency Standard.
Indicative content is provided in every Competency Standard under the ‘Unit Variables’
heading.
All Trainee Manuals prepared for ASEAN Toolboxes have addressed the required content
for each Competency Standard.
When delivering training:
Trainers must deliver the content identified in the Competency Standard – this is a non-
negotiable, mandatory requirement
Trainers may deliver additional ‘content’ to any Competency Standard but nothing can be
removed to compensate for adding extra content.
Extra content may be added to ‘contextualise’ training for:
Individual employers – by adding (for example) workplace references, workplace
policies and procedures; workplace terminology
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 29
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Training methods
Training methods refers to the delivery strategies Trainers use to conduct training.
Training methods should:
Be suitable for and accommodate the content (nature, type and complexity) being
delivered
Reflect the learning styles or preferences of the learners
Vary throughout the training – to introduce variety and interest
Always:
Ensure and emphasise safety
Support Competency Based principles
Reflect the assessment which candidates will be required to undertake.
Take into account the practicalities of the training environment – such as:
Equipment and resources available
Budget
Available time.
Training resources
‘Training resources refers to the materials used to deliver training in accordance with the
delivery methods which have been selected.
More information is provided in section 4.1.
Toolbox resources
For every Unit the Toolbox provides the following resources to support the Trainer and
Assessor and to facilitate training and assessment:
Trainee Manual
Trainer Guide
Assessor Manual
PowerPoint presentation.
Reference to resources in the Toolboxes
Trainers can gain insight into resources required by referring to:
‘Recommended training equipment’ listed towards the rear of the Trainer Guide
‘Resource implications’ as specified in the Competency Standard.
© ASEAN 2014
30 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Training delivery
‘Training delivery’ refers to the actual conduct of the planned training to the identified
students.
Training delivery:
Should align with the planning which has preceded it – with reference to training/learning
plans and programs, budgets, scheduling
Should (nonetheless) be flexible enough to accommodate unforeseen issues
Should accommodate/reflect the identified learning styles and preferences of students
Must address identified need – as determined by the training provider (this may be as a
result of TNAs which have been conducted or may require the complete delivery of a
Competency Standard regardless of any prior experience held by students)
May be provided:
By one Trainer operating on their own – for the entire Unit or qualification
By a range of ‘subject experts’
In a team teaching context – where two Trainers work together in the same class or
with the same group at the same time
Using Guest Speakers
May occur:
in a formal classroom situation
In a simulated industry setting
In a workplace
In a blended scenario – where some training
occurs in a classroom and some takes place in a
workplace.
Will often be customised by Training Providers to accommodate the needs of specific
organisations in the industry they serve – this customisation may require:
Delivery outside of normal hours – to accommodate the demand on employees in the
workplace and their availability for training
Training at the host employer’s workplace
Training sessions which are longer or shorter than ‘normal’
Inclusion of nominated content
Training of students on certain equipment.
Effective Trainers will need to apply a range of skills when delivering training – such as:
Interpersonal skills – to establish and maintain a rapport with students and create a
positive and supportive learning environment
Communication skills – to convey content, ask questions, receive and provide
feedback, read body language, provide advice
Class management skills – to control students, resolve issues, manage time and use
of resources, negotiate solutions.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 31
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Work Projects
It is a requirement of this Unit you complete Work Projects as advised by your Trainer. You
must submit documentation, suitable evidence or other relevant proof of completion of the
project to your Trainer by the agreed date.
1.1 Prepare and present a 15 minute verbal presentation which identifies the context for
the Master Trainer program.
© ASEAN 2014
32 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
Summary
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 33
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify operational context
© ASEAN 2014
34 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Element 2:
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
2.1 Name Labour Divisions to which ASEAN
toolboxes apply
Introduction
The Project to develop Toolboxes was tightly focussed on identified industry need deemed
important to all ASEAN Member States.
This very brief section names the Labour Divisions to which the ASEAN Toolboxes apply.
Labour Divisions
Project development and consultation was based on a suite of Competency Standards that
were provided to the project as the building blocks for the final product.
Competency Standards were provided for:
Hotel Services – Restaurant Services
Hotel Services – Front Office and Housekeeping
Travel – Travel and Tour Services.
The proposed Curriculum Framework was required to be structured across six Labour
Divisions:
Food Production
Food and Beverage Service
Front Office
Housekeeping
Tour Operation
Travel Agencies.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 35
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
36 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Front Office
This Labour Division addresses competencies relating to:
Product knowledge
Workplace health and safety
First aid
Customer relations and service
Communication skills
Bookings and reservations management
Night audit
Business and staff management
English language.
Housekeeping
This Labour Division addresses competencies relating to:
Product knowledge
Workplace health and safety
First aid
Customer relations and service
Communication skills
Room preparation, service and cleaning
Valet
Laundry
Security
Business and staff management
English language.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 37
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Tour Operation
This Labour Division addresses competencies relating to:
Product knowledge
Workplace health and safety
First aid
Customer relations and service
Communication skills
Bookings/reservations and information
management
Tour guiding and conducting tours
Driving and vehicle maintenance and repairs
Camping and on-tour catering
Security and risk management
Sensitivity and respect for local cultures
Business and staff management
English language.
Travel Agencies
This Labour Division addresses competencies relating to:
Product knowledge
Workplace health and safety
First aid
Customer relations and service
Communication skills
Processing bookings/reservations
Billing and settlement plans
Information management
Domestic and international ticketing
Marketing and sales
Business and staff management
English language.
© ASEAN 2014
38 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
List of Units
A total of 242 Toolboxes (plus one for Master Trainer and one for Master Assessor, and one
for National Trainer and one for National Assessor [see 3.1]) have been developed.
The list below shows:
Names of each Unit
The Labour Divisions to which each Unit applies:
FP = Food Production
FB = Food and Beverage Services
FO = Front Office
HK = Housekeeping
TA = Travel Agencies
TO = Tour Operation.
The list (and all resources) can be accessed through waseantourism.com: click on
‘Approved Toolboxes’. Username = guest, Password = guest1.
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
1. Access and retrieve computer-based data X X X X X X
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 39
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
11. Perform clerical procedures X X X X X X
© ASEAN 2014
40 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
38. Apply catering control principles and procedures X
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 41
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
63. Provide a link between kitchen and service area X
© ASEAN 2014
42 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
87. Audit financial procedures X X X X X X
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 43
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
111. Start conversations and develop good relations X X X X
with guests
112. Communicate in English on a telephone X X X X
© ASEAN 2014
44 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
137. Provide valet services to guests X
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 45
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
160. Create promotional display stand X
© ASEAN 2014
46 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
183. Carry out vehicle maintenance or minor repairs X
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 47
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
206. Develop, implement and evaluate regional tourism X X
plans
207. Develop, implement and evaluate sponsorship X X
plans
208. Develop, manage and evaluate local marketing X X
strategies
209. Develop/monitor ecologically sustainable tourism X X
operations
210. Implement event management systems and X X
procedures
211. Plan and implement sales activities X X X X
© ASEAN 2014
48 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
UNIT NAME FP FB FO HK TA TO
229. Plan and promote training courses X X
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 49
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Clusters
Clusters form the basis of determining which Competency Standards can be used when
applying the Packaging Rules (see section 2.4) to create a qualification which meets the
needs of the individual student and aligns with the requirements of the Qualifications
Framework.
Each of the 242 Units has been allocated into one or more Clusters within three Competency
Standards Menus.
Where a Competency Standard has more than one Unit Number this means it has been
listed in more than one Cluster.
At the time of writing the following Clusters apply (see waseantourism.com under CATC
documentation, A1 Final Report):
Travel Services Competency Standards Menu
Cluster 1 Common Core Competencies
D2.TCC.CL1.01 Work effectively with customers and colleagues
D2.TCC.CL1.02 Work in a socially diverse environment
D2.TCC.CL1.03 Implement occupational safety and health procedures
D2.TCC.CL1.04 Follow safety and security procedures
D2.TCC.CL1.05 Communicate effectively on the telephone
D2.TCC.CL1.06 Manage and resolve conflict situations
D2.TCC.CL1.07 Develop and update tourism industry knowledge
D2.TCC.CL1.08 Promote products and services to customers
D2.TCC.CL1.09 Perform clerical procedures
D2.TCC.CL1.10 Access and retrieve computer-based data
D2.TCC.CL1.11 Speak English at a basic operational level
D2.TCC.CL1.12 Process financial transactions
D2.TCC.CL1.13 Use common business tools and technology
D2.TCC.CL1.14 Perform child protection duties relevant to the tourism industry
D2.TCC.CL1.15 Perform basic First Aid procedures
D2.TCC.CL1.16 Develop protective environments for children in tourism destinations
© ASEAN 2014
50 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 51
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
52 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 53
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
54 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 55
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
56 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 57
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
58 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 59
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
60 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 61
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Reading
D1.LAN.CL10.08 Read and interpret basic instructions, directions and/or diagrams
D1.LAN.CL10.09 Read general information texts or media
Writing
D1.LAN.CL10.10 Write a short message in English
D1.LAN.CL10.11 Prepare a business letter in advanced English
Hotel Services (Front Office and Housekeeping) Competency Standards Menu
Cluster 1 Common Core Competencies
D1.HOT.CL1.01 Work effectively with customers
and colleagues
D1.HOT.CL1.02 Work in a socially diverse
environment
D1.HOT.CL1.03 Implement occupational health
and safety procedures
D1.HOT.CL1.04 Comply with workplace hygiene
procedures
D1.HOT.CL1.05 Perform clerical procedures
D1.HOT.CL1.06 Access and retrieve computer-based data
D1.LAN.CL1.01 Speak English at a basic operational level
D1.HOT.CL1.07 Communicate effectively on the telephone
D1.HOT.CL1.08 Maintain hospitality industry knowledge
D1.HOT.CL1.09 Develop and update tourism industry knowledge
D1.HOT.CL1.10 Promote products and services to customers
D1.HOT.CL1.11 Manage and resolve conflict situations
D1.HOT.CL1.12 Perform basic First Aid procedures
D1.HOT.CL1.13 Perform child protection duties relevant to the tourism industry
D1.HOT.CL1.14 Develop protective environments for children in tourism destinations
Cluster 2 Hotel Front Office
D1.HFO.CL2.01 Receive and process reservations
D1.HFO.CL2.02 Operate a computerised reservation
system
D1.HFO.CL2.03 Provide accommodation services
D1.HFO.CL2.04 Maintain guests’ financial records
D1.HFO.CL2.05 Process a financial sale transaction
D1.HFO.CL2.06 Conduct a night audit
© ASEAN 2014
62 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 63
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
64 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 65
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Overview of qualifications
The following table provides an overview of the qualifications currently provided for under the
Framework matched against Labour Divisions – please note these qualifications were
correct at the time of writing but are subject to change as the Project is implemented:
Food Production 2 3 3 1 1 10
Front Office 1 1 1 1 1 5
Housekeeping 1 1 1 1 1 5
Tour Operation 2 3 4 2 1 12
Travel Agencies 3 3 3 1 1 11
Total 52
© ASEAN 2014
66 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Qualification names
This presents the approved and endorsed titles for each of the qualifications which have
been provided for:
Food and beverage service qualifications:
Advanced Diploma of Food and Beverage Service (Management)
Diploma of Food and Beverage Service (Supervision and Administration)
Certificate IV in Food and Beverage Service
(Waiting)
Certificate IV in Food and Beverage Service
(Supervision)
Certificate IV in Food and Beverage Service
(Beverages)
Certificate III in Food and Beverage Service
(Waiting)
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 67
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
68 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 69
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
70 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Students are free to select the Functional competencies they want to comprise their
qualification – providing:
They are within the nominated Clusters
Training providers are willing and able to deliver them.
In-keeping with CBT principles qualifications are not time-based – a legitimate
qualification of the same type may be of different ‘lengths’ depending on:
Individual students and/or their needs or preferences for studying
Delivery methods and timetables of training providers.
It is possible each qualification of the same type will consist of different
Units/competencies – to reflect:
Individual need/preferences and proposed work career path
Industry/employer need
Local need/demand.
Packaging Rules
A selection of Packaging Rules is provided below to illustrate what they look like, what they
contain and how they ‘grow’ as the qualification level increases.
The full suite of Packaging Rules can be found at waseantourism.com under CATC
documentation, A1 Final Report.
Note: the Packaging Rules provided below were correct at the time of writing but are always
subject to change by Authorities.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 71
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies, ten (10) competencies from the
Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with at least four (8) from
the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Food and Beverage Service
Financial Administration
And
At least two (2) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
72 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies eighteen (18) competencies from
the Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with at least twelve
(12) from the following Clusters:
Food and Beverage Service
Financial Administration
And
At least three (3) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
Human Resource Development
Management and Leadership
And
At least three (3) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 73
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies eighteen (18) competencies from
the Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with at least eleven
(11) from the following Clusters:
Food and Beverage Service
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
Financial Administration
And
At least four (4) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Human Resource Development
Management and Leadership
General Administration
And
At least three (3) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
74 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twenty-four (24) competencies from the
Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with at least eight (8) from
the following Clusters:
Food and Beverage Service
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
And
At least twelve (12) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Financial Administration
Human Resource Development
Management and Leadership
General Administration
And
At least four (4) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 75
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twenty-nine (29) competencies from the
Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with at least eleven (11) from
the following Clusters:
Food and Beverage Service
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
And
At least thirteen (13) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Financial Administration
Human Resource Development
Management and Leadership
General Administration
And
At least five (5) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
76 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twelve (12) competencies from the
Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with at least ten (10) from
the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Commercial Cookery
And
At least one (1) competency from the Cluster:
Management and Leadership
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 77
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twenty-three (23) competencies from
the Hotel Services (Restaurant Services) Competency Standards Menu with eleven (11) from the
following Clusters:
Commercial Cookery
Commercial Catering
Patisserie
And
At least ten (10) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Financial Administration
Human Resource Development
Management and Leadership
General Administration
And
At least two (2) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
78 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies ten (10) competencies from the
Hotel Services (Front Office and Housekeeping) Competency Standards Menu with at least
eight (8) from the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Hotel Front Office
Security Services
And
At least one (2) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 79
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twenty-eight (28) competencies from
the Hotel Services (Front Office and Housekeeping) Competency Standards Menu with at least
seven (7) from the Cluster:
Hotel Front Office
Financial Administration
And
At least fifteen (15) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
General Administration
Human Resource Development
Resource Management
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
Security Services
And
At least five (5) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
80 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies fourteen (14) competencies from
the Hotel Services (Front Office and Housekeeping) Competency Standards Menu with at
least eight (8) from the following Clusters:
Housekeeping
Security Services
And
At least three (3) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
General Administration
And
At least two (2) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 81
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twenty-four (24) competencies from
the Hotel Services (Front Office and Housekeeping) Competency Standards Menu with at least
twelve (12) from the following Clusters:
Housekeeping
General Administration
And
At least seven (7) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Customer Service, sales and Marketing
Security Services
Human Resource Development
Resource Management
Financial Administration
And
At least four (4) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
82 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies fourteen (14) competencies from the
Travel Services Competency Standards Menu with at least ten (10) from the Cluster:
Tour Guide Services
And
At least two (2) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
Tour Operations
Travel Agency – Ticketing
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 83
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies eighteen (18) competencies from the
Travel Services Competency Standards Menu
with at least fourteen (14) from the Cluster:
Tour Guide Services
And
At least two (2) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
Tour Operations
Travel Agency – Ticketing
General Administration
Resource Management
And
At least one (1) competency from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
84 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies fourteen (14) competencies from the
Travel Services Competency Standards Menu with at least nine (9) from the Cluster:
Travel Agency – Ticketing
And
At least four (4) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
Common Core Competencies
Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
General Administration
Tour Operations
Financial Administration
Human Resource Development
Resource Management
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 85
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Functional Competencies
In addition to the above Core and Generic Competencies twenty-eight (28) competencies from
the Travel Services Competency Standards Menu
with at least seven (7) from the Cluster:
Financial Administration
And
At least thirteen (13) competencies from one or more of the following Clusters:
General Administration
Human Resource Development
Travel Agency - Ticketing
Tour Operations
Tour Guide Services
And
At least three (3) competencies from the following Cluster:
Resource Management – two (2) of which must be:
o D2.TRM.CL9.05 Lead and manage people
o D2.TRM.CL9.16 Monitor work operations
And
At least three (3) competencies from the Cluster:
English Language Proficiency
In all cases selection of Functional Competencies must reflect the intended Job Title, local
industry requirements and the Certificate level.
© ASEAN 2014
86 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Competency
Competency is a combination of the skill, knowledge and attitude required to perform a task
or job to the standard expected in the workplace.
If a person can do a job to the required standard they are deemed to be ‘competent’.
By an individual enterprise
By an industry
By government.
Endorsed Competency Standards form the basis which underpins all Competency Based
Training and Assessment – that is, all activities undertaken by the Trainer and Assessor
must refer back to and relate directly to the relevant Competency Standard.
Competency Based Training and Assessment are processes that focus on the transfer and
validation of the competency standard.
Job design
Job descriptions
Performance appraisal
Selection criteria
Career path development
Identification of training needs
Development of training programs
Certification
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 87
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
The above activities in combination aim to increase customer satisfaction through better
employee performance.
About the Competency Standards which have been created
The ASEAN Competency Standards:
Are written in a format which has been endorsed by representatives from all ASEAN
Member States
Have been reviewed by, revised as necessary, and endorsed by all ASEAN Member
States
Provide the basis for the delivery and assessment of all Units under the Qualifications
Framework
Contain information and detail to help users (students, employers training providers)
select Units under Packaging Rules to create a qualification
Are all presented using the same structure
Can be located at the document repository at waseantourism.com.
Elements of Competency Standards
All Competency Standards comprise:
Unit Title
Unit Number
Nominal Hours
Unit Descriptor
Elements
Performance Criteria
Unit Variables
Assessment Guide
Linkages to other Units
Critical Aspects of Assessment
Context of Assessment
Resource Implications
Assessment Methods
Key Competencies for the Unit.
© ASEAN 2014
88 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Unit Title
The Unit Title is the name of the competency.
It is written in such a way it indicates the general content of the competency.
The titles for all Units begin with a verb to reflect the nature of competency based training.
It is a statement about what is to be done in workplace.
There is no standard length for Unit titles – they may be short or long: length of the title
bears no relationship to complexity of the Unit or Nominal Hours for the Unit.
Unit Number
Every Unit has an identifying number.
Where a Unit is allocated to more than one Labour Division it will have more than one Unit
Number which will change to reflect its location in the various Clusters (see section 2.4)
Each Unit Title comprises four parts:
1. D1 refers to all the Units in the Hotel Services classifications
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 89
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
3. The CL number refers to the Cluster Number the Unit is listed under. Every Cluster has a
number under each individual Competency Standards Menu.
4. The final two-digit number indicates the position of the Unit within the Cluster.
Nominal Hours
This figure represents indicative time required to deliver and assess the Unit.
It is not mandatory: CBT is not time-based.
A Unit may be delivered in less time than shown as the Nominal Hours, or in more time.
Primary uses of the Nominal Hours figure are:
As the basis for allocating funding – which may be based, for example, on the number of
face-to-face or ‘contact’ hours per Unit
To assist with rostering of staff
To enable scheduling/time-tabling of classes.
The time for each Unit was calculated based on:
Amount of content
Complexity of the Unit
Time allocated to similar Units under other vocational training Frameworks
Advice of experienced trainers and assessors who have delivered and assessed similar
Units.
© ASEAN 2014
90 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Unit Descriptor
This section provides a brief description Unit giving insight into context and content.
This section of the Competency Standard is often used by training providers to describe
Units they offer in:
Media advertisements they create to promote their courses
Internal Student Handbooks or other internal course promotional materials/brochures.
Elements
All Competency Standards comprise a number of
Elements.
There is no fixed, set or ‘required’ number of Elements
per Unit.
There is always more than one and three to five is a
common range.
They identify and describe:
The key tasks or activities which make up the Competency
The major building blocks of the Competency
A sequential approach to the required tasks.
Performance Criteria
All Elements comprise a number of Performance Criteria.
There is no fixed, set or ‘required’ number of Performance Criteria per Element.
There is always more than one and five to eight is a common range.
They are sub-sets of an Element and prescribe action needed for competency in the
Element.
Parts of the Performance Criteria may be written in italics meaning this part is addressed
under the Unit Variables section (see below) of the Competency Standard.
Unit Variables
This section of the Competency Standard:
Provides advice to interpret the scope and context of the Unit of competence, allowing
for differences between enterprises and workplaces
Relates to the Unit as a whole and facilitates holistic assessment
Identifies the Labour Division/s to which the Unit applies
Gives detail of and presents key points relating to italicised parts of Performance Criteria
which the Trainer should cover when training delivery takes place.
Assessment Guide
This aspect of the Competency Standard lists the skills and knowledge which must be
assessed as part of this Unit.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 91
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
92 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
94 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 95
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Assessors can use the Matrix to reference content which can be used as suitable evidence.
Glossary of terms
Next follows a list of acronyms, words and/or phrases relevant to the topic of the Manual with
a corresponding definition/interpretation.
Notes/training content
This is the heart of the Trainee Manual.
It contains:
Sequential presentation of every Element and
Performance Criteria listed in the Competency
Standard for the Unit
Coverage of Unit Variables as identified in the
Competency Standard
Information which has been reviewed, revised as
necessary, and endorsed by industry professionals from the ASEAN Member States
References to websites which provide additional information
A Summary of content at the end of each Element.
Trainers should feel free to:
Add supplementary information as they see fit/deem necessary
Contextualise the content to reflect host country, local, organisational or other needs
Use the PowerPoint presentation provided as part of the Toolbox to deliver the Unit
leaving students to use the Trainee Manual as a reference source.
Work Projects
At the end of each Element there are Work Projects.
These:
Are suggested/optional assessment items for the Element – they are not mandatory and
Trainers/Assessors can elect:
Not to use them
To use only some of them
To re-word or change them in any way deemed appropriate
To use them as non-assessable exercises or in-class activities – rather than as
formal assessment activities to capture evidence on which the Pass Competent/Not
Yet Competent decision will be made.
The allocation of Work Projects to Performance criteria is shown in the Assessment Matrix at
the start of the Trainee Manual.
Presentation of Written Work
This section presents suggestions for students regarding how they might address
preparation and submission of written work required for assessment purposes.
© ASEAN 2014
96 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
The information provided is the same in every Trainee manual and covers:
Introduction – highlighting need for preparation and professionalism
Style – giving important advice on the focus of activities relating to work to be submitted
Presenting Written Work – giving generic advice in relation to:
Types of written which may be required
Format
Use of a Cover Sheet
Need to retain a copy of all written work submitted
Need to use inclusive language.
Recommended Reading
This section lists additional reading and references relating to the Unit.
Students (and/or Trainers) may elect to use these to obtain additional
information or follow-up on topics of interest.
The list:
Can provide guidance to Training Providers in relation to
establishing a Library/Learning Resource Centre
Is not a list of books the student or Training Provider must
buy
Aims to provide materials which are relatively current – the general aim when the list was
produced was to include references which were no longer than 10 years old but in
several cases older references have been included where they are recognised as
‘industry standards’ or there were no other references available.
Trainee Evaluation Sheet
Every Trainee Manual contains this document and it is the same across all Units.
The Trainee Evaluation Sheet should be:
Completed by the Trainee when they have competed the Unit – students are not under a
legal obligation to complete and submit these Sheets but they should be encouraged to
do so, and should be encouraged to be honest in their responses.
Removed from the Trainee Manual and handed to the Trainer – or the Trainer may elect
to photocopy these Sheets and hand them out to students to save them having to
damage their Trainee Manual.
These sheets:
Provide important feedback to Trainers
Should be used as a critical Element of the Trainer’s evaluation of their delivery.
Trainee Self-Assessment Checklist
This is a list which may be used by students to indicate to their Trainer and/or Assessor their
readiness to be assessed.
There is no compulsion for students or Trainers or Assessors to use this Checklist – it is
optional and to be used at the discretion of all parties and/or if required.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 97
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
98 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 99
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
The sequence of the information in the slides follows the sequence of content in the
Trainee Manual
Trainers can add extra slides if they want to include additional content
A Summary is provided at the end of each Element.
There is no set number of slides per presentation – the number of slides provided varies with
the content, nature and complexity of the Competency Standard and the approach taken by
the Subject Writer to preparing the slides.
Classroom Activities
PowerPoint slides contain ‘Classroom Activities’.
These are suggestions for activities which the
Trainer may use to enhance and optimise learning.
They are not compulsory.
See more information on these in section 4.2.
© ASEAN 2014
100 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 101
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
102 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Assessing competency
Regional Qualifications Framework and Skills Recognition System
Recognition of Prior Learning
Code of Practice for Assessors
Instructions and Checklists for Assessors
Instructions for recording competency
Instructions for different assessment methods.
Competency Standard
The endorsed Competency Standard for the Unit is provided in full so Assessors have ready
access to the source document which must be used as the basis for assessment with
reference to:
Content covered by the Unit
Assessment Guide
Critical Aspects of Assessment.
Oral Questions
These are questions which Assessors may use as part of their evidence gathering to
determine the Pass Competent or Not Yet Competent decision.
There is at least one Oral Question for every Performance Criteria.
The allocation of Oral Questions to Performance Criteria is shown in the Assessment Matrix
at the start of the Trainee Manual.
Oral Questions are not mandatory – Assessors may choose to:
Use all of them – as presented, in their entirety
Use none of them
Use some of them – to capture additional evidence
where required on certain Performance Criteria
Develop their own series of Oral Questions
Use them as non-assessable exercises or in-class
activities – rather than as formal assessment activities
to capture evidence on which the Pass Competent/Not
Yet Competent decision will be made
Convert Oral Questions to Written Questions.
Space is provided for assessors to:
Enter student name
Enter assessor name
Enter location where assessment was done
Record answers provided by trainee – in short-hand form
Record the Pass Competent/Not Yet Competent decision for each question.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 103
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Model answers are not provided for Oral Questions as most answers will depend on the
experience of the candidates and the examples they provide in response to the questions
asked.
A section titled ‘Specifications for Oral Question Assessment’ is contained at the start every
Assessor Manual.
Written Questions
This is a set of questions designed to be distributed to students for them to answer in writing
and submit for marking.
Assessors may use these as part of their evidence gathering to determine the Pass
Competent or Not Yet Competent decision.
There is at least one Written Question for every Performance
Criteria.
The allocation of Written Questions to Performance Criteria is
shown in the Assessment Matrix at the start of the Trainee
Manual.
Written Questions are not mandatory – Assessors may
choose to:
Use all of them – as presented, in their entirety
Use none of them
Use some of them – to capture additional evidence where required on certain
Performance Criteria
Develop their own series of Written Questions
Use them as the basis for a non-assessable exercise or in-class activity – rather than as
formal assessment to capture evidence on which the Pass Competent/Not Yet
Competent decision will be made
Convert Written Questions to Oral Questions.
A section titled ‘Specifications for Written Question Assessment’ is contained at the start
every Assessor Manual.
Answers to Written Questions
This section provides model answers for the Written Questions provided in the Assessor
Manual.
Assessors:
May use these to assist them mark the responses to Written Questions provided by
students
Must use common sense when using/referring to them – the answers provided are
indicative only and discretion must be used to determine the acceptability of an answer
which has been provided.
© ASEAN 2014
104 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Observation Checklist
The Observation Checklist is provided for Assessors (only) to record observations of actual
candidate performance of the required competencies for the Unit as described by the
Competency Standard.
The document is used to capture evidence of practical competency which is used to help
make the Pass Competent/Not Yet Competent decision.
In relation to this document:
Name of student and Assessor must be entered
Location/venue where observation occurred must be entered
Dates on which observations occurred must be entered – multiple observations are
required to ensure consistency of competency
The Elements and Performance Criteria for the Competency Standard are reproduced
on the form to facilitate and focus the observation
Space is provided to assist in recording evidence
Space is provided to enable feedback
Space is provided for both Assessor and student to sign the document:
The Assessor signs to authenticate the observations
The student signs to acknowledge they have received the feedback as a result of the
observations.
A section titled ‘Specifications for Observation Checklist’ is contained at the start every
Assessor Manual.
Third Party Statement
This form is provided for distribution to a designated and appropriate person in a workplace
who will use the document to provide evidence which can be used by an Assessor as part of
the evidence they use to make the Pass Competent/Not Yet Competent decision.
An ‘appropriate person’ could be a supervisor, manager, business owner or other suitable
senior/experienced person in the workplace.
The ‘appropriate person’ must:
Agree to provide the required information
Have the requirements of completing the Third Party Statement explained to them
Be supported by the Assessor in their efforts and with any questions or difficulties they
may have.
Space exists on the Third Party Statement to:
Enter student name and name of authorised/approved Third Party
Contact number for the Third Party – to facilitate contact by the Assessor if there is a
query or of follow-up information is required
Indicate the relationship between the candidate the Third party competing the Statement
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 105
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Room for them to indicate their opinion (‘Yes’, ‘No’, ‘Not Sure’) regarding the competency
of the candidate for the Elements and Performance Criteria – in many cases
Performance Criteria have been combined in this document to make it easier and quicker
for workplace Third Party personnel to compete the form
Space for the Third Party to provide more detailed/written feedback regarding candidate
performance – if the Third Party wishes to do so
Space for the Third Party to sign to authenticate the document/their contributions.
A section titled ‘Specifications for Third Party Statement’ is contained at the start every
Assessor Manual.
Competency Recording Sheet
The final document in the assessor manual is the Competency Recording Sheet.
One Competency Recording Sheet needs to be prepared by the
Assessor for every candidate for every Unit.
This document:
Is provided in the same format for all Competencies
Provides a central location for the evidence captured during
assessments to be recorded
Is the main reference point for making the final Pass
Competent/Not yet Competent decision
Contains room to enter:
Student and Assessor name
Dates assessment commenced and was completed
Follow-up action required by student in the event they initially failed to achieve
competency
Observations made by the Assessor about the candidate and/or the assessment
process – if deemed necessary/appropriate
Indication of the types of assessment used to capture evidence on a Performance
Criteria-by- Performance Criteria basis
Signatures (with dates) of:
– Assessor – to authenticate the document
– Candidate – to verify their assessment has been given to and explained to them.
A section titled ‘Instructions for Recording Competency’ is contained at the start every
Assessor Manual.
© ASEAN 2014
106 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Work Projects
It is a requirement of this Unit you complete Work Projects as advised by your Trainer. You
must submit documentation, suitable evidence or other relevant proof of completion of the
project to your Trainer by the agreed date.
Identifies the Labour Divisions to which the CATC applies and gives an overview of
the nature of the competencies provided for under each Labour Division
Explains how a new Trainer can identify/access the names of all the competency
standards under the CATC giving an several example of titles of competency
standards which exist
Provides an overview of the qualifications which exist under the Framework
explaining the structure of the Framework as well as names of each qualification
level
Describes the role of Packaging Rules using knowledge of these Packaging Rules
to describe the requirements for creating a qualification under the Framework.
2.2. Select one competency standard under the ASEAN Qualifications Framework/CATC
and for that unit/toolbox:
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 107
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Identify ASEAN toolbox components
Summary
Identify ASEAN Toolbox components
© ASEAN 2014
108 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
Element 3:
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
3.1 Explain pre-requisites for eligibility to become
an ASEAN toolbox trainer and Master Trainer
Introduction
In order to maintain the integrity and rigour of the training there are non-negotiable
requirements which apply to the becoming a Trainer and a Master Trainer for ASEAN
Toolboxes.
This section discusses there pre-requisite requirements.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 109
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
110 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 111
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
112 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 113
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
114 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
Suitable to train vocational trainees but not yet other Trainers and/or Assessors
Level 4: (0 – 14) Not Yet Competent Trainer and/or Assessor:
Unsuitable to perform the role of Master Trainer and/or Assessor either due to certain
character faults or lack of knowledge, ability, aptitude, attitude or communicative ability (in
English and/or native language) or requires more intensive study and vocational experience
in order to be able to train other trainees or other Trainers/Assessors.
Interpretation of Ratings
Based on the scoring system above Master Trainers or Assessors will be graded into four
levels on completion of this Unit:
Category (a) = Outstanding Master Trainer or Assessor: Master Trainers or Assessors who
have the ability to train Trainers or Assessors nationally and in other AMS
Category (b) = Competent Master Trainer or Assessor: are competent to train Master
Trainers or Assessors nationally but not yet multi-nationally
Category (c) = Competent Trainer or Assessor: they have many of the skills and abilities of
national Master Trainers/Assessors but need more development in English, CBT/CBA
understanding or in developing training or assessment
programs
Category (d) = Not Yet Competent Trainer or Assessor:
they are unsuitable to perform the role of Master Trainer
and/or Assessor either due to some personal
characteristics or lack of knowledge, ability, aptitude,
attitude or communicative ability in English and/or mother
language.
Grading tool
The following (subject to change/development as deemed appropriate) will be used to guide
rating of participants:
Degree of competency
Competency Scoring system
1= low 5= high
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 115
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
Degree of competency
Competency Scoring system
1= low 5= high
© ASEAN 2014
116 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 117
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
118 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
Work Projects
It is a requirement of this Unit you complete Work Projects as advised by your Trainer. You
must submit documentation, suitable evidence or other relevant proof of completion of the
project to your Trainer by the agreed date.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 119
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
Summary
Characterise role of ASEAN trainers
© ASEAN 2014
120 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Element 4:
Implement training of an ASEAN
Competency Standard
4.1 Plan and prepare for delivery of an ASEAN
Competency Standard
Introduction
Implementation of training of ASEAN Competency Standards is a three-stage process which
involves:
Planning and preparing the training – covered in this section
Conducting the training – covered in section 4.2
Evaluating training delivery – covered in section 4.3
This section emphasises the importance of proper preparation identifying and discussing
and describing actions which need to be addressed.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 121
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Sufficient and professional planning and preparation for training gives the Trainer full
knowledge about and immense confidence in relation to:
What they are going to deliver
What they are going to do
What they are going to say
How they are going to do things
How long things will take
What resources and materials they will need
How training will be assessed.
© ASEAN 2014
122 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 123
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
124 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 125
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
126 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 127
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
128 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Group discussion
This is a conversation between trainees around a set topic or issue
Learners discuss and record the group’s thoughts and answers to questions asked
Group may have a recorder and a spokesperson
Good for increasing understanding of content and concepts
Trainer needs to take care to ensure the activity involves all trainees and is not
dominated by some or excludes others.
Questioning
Questions may be:
Asked by the Trainer – a good Trainer asks more
questions than their learners
Asked by learners – of the Trainer and of each other
Oral or written
Planned and structured to probe understanding of identified issues and content
Used for clarification, understanding and assessment.
Techniques in effective questioning:
Ask the correct question
Ask the question correctly:
Put the question to the whole group
Pause
Nominate someone to answer
Pause
Respond warmly and encouragingly, or
Redirect the question.
Use a mix of question types:
‘Open’ questions:
– Assess understanding
– Allow trainees to give opinions
– Start with “how,” what,” “why”.
‘Closed’ questions:
– Require only one word or very short answers
– Used to check direct knowledge.
‘Target’ questions – to elicit information about past experiences
‘Probe’ questions – to probe for and seek more information on the topic
‘Hypothetical’ questions – to:
– Deal with ‘made-up’ situations
– Assist in case study work.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 129
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
130 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 131
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
132 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Learner profiles
‘Learner profile’ refers to the overall composition of individual learners which will impact
training delivery – it embraces:
Age and gender of student
Language skills of the person
Experience and ability of the trainee
Individual preferences for learning
Special needs.
Ways to identify learner profiles
The following options exist:
Undertake pre-entry testing – related specifically to the ASEAN Competency Standards
to be undertaken by the individual.
The pre-entry testing (assessment or evaluation) can address:
Theory
Practical
Meet with and interview individual learners as part of SOP and talk to them, asking
relevant questions to elicit information which will create the required profile
Talk to workplace supervisors where learners are employed to obtain input from them
Include questions on enrolment forms for applicants to present details of their personal
requirements and issues
Apply TNA – see immediately below.
Impact of TNAs
In some cases, such as certain workplace situations, there will be a need to refine training
delivery to address and reflect the specific needs of individual workers as identified through
a Training Needs Analysis. In these cases:
The training gap forms the basis of the training to be delivered
There is no need or requirement to deliver other parts of the Competency Standard or
training program
RPL may be sought by/granted to participants for certain Elements or Performance
criteria or Competency Standards.
This Unit takes the approach Trainers will be required to deliver all the content of a
Competency Standard as presented under the Qualifications Framework/RQFSRS.
This is commonly the case where Trainers are employed to deliver vocational training
through a private provider to those wishing to enter/learn about the industry.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 133
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
134 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 135
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
OSH info for Ergonomics of chair and desk, check lighting and temperature suitable for computer use.
participants
© ASEAN 2014
136 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Learning/training program
A Learning/training program is:
A series of individual training sessions
A sequence of training events.
The document will contain headings/sections as follows to help direct the thinking of the
Trainer as they plan and prepare for delivery:
Delivery schedule – identifying number of training sessions/events
Content – giving overview of what till be covered in
each session
Delivery method/s to be used – attention should be
paid to:
Varying strategies used to introduce interest and
diversity into training
Ensuring they are relevant to and support learning
of the content
Making sure resources exist to underpin/allow the selected delivery method to be
used
Assessment linkages – indicating activities to be used: may/will require liaison with
Assessor
Resources available/to be used – listing resources, training materials and references
which can/will be used as part of the delivery.
Sample Learning/training program
The document below is presented as an example/model of a learning/training program.
It is indicative/representative only and can be amended as required to suit individual/Training
Provider/Trainer need.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 137
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
Session 1 Introduction to all units: Theory: Complete Front office Front Office Reception
position and duties work notes for 2011 available
SITTTSL007A – Receive and Process Whiteboard
sheet from MyWai Hospitality
Reservations
Power point Portal under lecture notes
SITHACS001A – Providing Accommodation
Reception Services Worksheet activity Text book page
71 – 72
Issue Text Book DVD
Session 3 Introduction to Opera PMS system and Practical: Role Play Week 8 & 10 Text Book page 30 – 44
Angliss Hotel [rates, market segment and Manual Reservation Week 8 case study and page 48 – 53
product knowledge] Reception notes available
Electronic Reservation
Reservations & office procedures. Record from Hospitality Portal
Theory: under lecture notes page
© ASEAN 2014
138 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
reservation details manually Whiteboard 61 – 64
O.H.P
Written conventions [hotel jargon & etiquette,
Power point
grammar &spelling]
Work Sheet
Receive & process reservation requests,
procedure and handling reservation
problems. Allotments and Group
Reservations.
Angliss Hotel features & rates summary
sheet for use in practical assessment
Session 4 Electronic Reservations, guest profile, Practical: Role Play Week 8 & 9 Text Book page 55 – 62
and page 64 – 65
special requests, availability & guest history. Telephone reservations. Case Study
How to enter a
Confirming details Data input to Opera reservation into Opera
Role play: Taking a reservation. Confirmation letter notes available from
MyWai Hospitality Portal
Entering reservation into Opera [credit card Theory: under lecture notes
payment]
Whiteboard Power point
Work Sheet
Session.5 Product knowledge and marketing Hotel Practical: Role Play Week 8 & 9 Text Book page 58 – 61
and page 63 – 64
features. Oral confirmation of details Data input to Opera Case Study
Guaranteed vs. non Guaranteed, financial Information to other
status of the Reservation departments
Definitions; room rates, rack rate, costing Guest Requests
room rates
DVD
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 139
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
Session 6 Manage reservation problems Practical: Role Play Week 8 & 9 Text Book
© ASEAN 2014
140 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
Session 8 Case study competition date Student, one on one with Assessment
teacher Students each attend a
Practical Assessment
specified time
Student to take a manual reservation over Same day debrief
the phone and then input the information
accurately into Opera and print a
confirmation letter. Demonstrate message
file /storage
Session 9 Observation in the workplace
Trainee to take a minimum 4 reservations
including transcribing email reservations
Session 10 Reception/ Cashier theory Reception Theory: Role Play Text Book page 155 –
White board Work place observation 173
Roles of reception staff
How to check in notes on
Power point
Pre-guest arrival activities Hospitality portal on
mywai
Preparation for registration; guest vouchers,
arrival & Departure lists, Room Status
Session 11 Registration steps: confirmation of details, Practical: Role Play Text Book page 155 –
173
DOD & MOP, policies and procedures, Role Play Work place observation
Rooming Guest, key & room location Activity sheet 1 How to check in notes on
Guest registration Hospitality portal
Practical Credit card Check in
Account creation
Financial process, pre authorization
Theory:
Role plays with pre set scenarios
White board
Registration Card storage, Credit Card Guest
Power point
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 141
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
Quiz
Session 12 Reservation problems. Monitoring Arrival Practical: Role Play Text Book page 169 –
173
Offering other services, marketing Role Play Work place observation
hotel/resort services and in house Activity sheet 2 How to post notes on
businesses Guest Account & check Hospitality Portal
out
Reception problems ; overbooking, room not
available etc Theory:
© ASEAN 2014
142 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
Session 13 Company charge check-in Practical: Role Play Text Book page 168 –199
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 143
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery Schedule
Delivery Content Delivery Method Assessment Linkage Resources
Schedule Note; text book page
numbers on the bottom
of text book pages
Session 14 Demonstration of Practical procedure Text Book page 200 –
204
Front Office reports
Express check out.
Reception/ Cashier. Role-play for guest
check in and checkout. Opera exercises.
Session 15 Revision Practical: Role Play Revision checkout
questions in text book
Practical activities Student one on one with Workplace observation
page 161, 174, 190, 200
the teacher
Student to Check guest in, generate a guest & 206
account, check guest out and process
documents
Corrections ,split screens and ‘mistake’
window
Session 16 Case study questions cover terminology Practical: Role Play
© ASEAN 2014
144 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 145
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
How did you involve the learner in Pre-interview to establish prior skills so activities are established to meet individual needs taking into account the
the selection and development of selection the trainees.
these activities?
What provisions have you made for Practice sessions with role play scenarios and mentored shifts at the front desk.
the learner to practice their skills or
apply their knowledge?
What feedback model are you going Both verbal and a written feedback form.
use to provide constructive feedback
to the learner?
How will you find out whether your Through observation and supervisors report
learners’ needs are being met?
At what key points in the learning Session 7and 15 as they prepare for assessment
relationship are you going to check
whether your learners’ needs are
being met?
© ASEAN 2014
146 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Session plan
Key points about a session plan:
May be known as a ‘lesson plan’
A detailed description of each delivery session as identified in the training program
showing
Each session shown in the learning/training program should have a session plan
prepared for it
Is a planning document developed by the Trainer, for
the Trainer – the learners do not see them : the Trainer
should develop whatever they want which suits their
personal needs and teaching style best
There are templates which can be used to develop
these plans but the layout and content of these plans is
at the discretion of the Trainer.
Trainers should feel free to put whatever they want in these plans as they are only for
their personal use/reference.
Sample session plans
The document below is presented examples/models of session plans for two different
sessions taken from the Learning/training program above.
They are indicative/representative only and can be amended as required to suit individual/
Trainer need.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 147
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
148 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Telephone
In person at the front
desk
Mail
Email
Fax
Same chain referrals
CRS p.31
GDS p. 32
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 149
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Number of rooms
Number of guests
Ask questions and match the Guest needs to Room type(s) required
Sample conversation page.33 – 32:
Detailed Availability
Room Status
Room Rack.
Manual Booking System page 33
Computerized System page 33
Slide 51 – 53
Alternatives if not available Refer to page 35 Reasons booking not made Text Book
Customer, Price too high. Desired features not available. Minimum stay requirements not page34 – 35
suitable. Doesn’t want to be added to waitlist.
Venue
No rooms at all available. No waitlist or waitlist full. Allotment is full.
Already overbooked for requested date.
Recap Overbooking from week 2
© ASEAN 2014
150 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 151
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
152 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 153
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 155
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
156 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Scheduling of training
‘Scheduling of training’ refers to time-tabling the delivery of training.
It is different to but will obviously reflect the ‘Delivery Schedule’ in the Learning/Training
Program document.
Scheduling of training of ASEAN Toolbox training:
Refers to the dates and times of delivery of content as identified in the planning
documents (Learning/Training Plan and Training Program) – the duration of the
scheduling must ensure the required content of the training can be delivered within the
scheduled time.
Remember, however:
CBT is not time-based
Training Providers may not allow the time indicated as Nominal Hours in the
Competency Standard/s.
Gives starting and finishing times of
sessions/classes – also (usually gives a venue for
the training as ability to deliver training is often
dependent on having access to certain
resources/rooms, equipment)
May be conducted any time on any day – late at
night, early in the morning, on weekends, public
holidays, weekdays
Will wholly or in part be determined (or influenced) by:
Availability of resources, training spaces/rooms/venues
When learners can attend
Learner preferences for attending – preferences of whoever is paying for the training
to be provided/delivered
Public holidays, staff holidays, religious occasions and festivals
Levels of trade – where learners are also employees: employers are reluctant to
release staff for training during busy times.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 157
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Essential standards
It is vital to ensure in all of the above situations the resources/materials:
Reflect individual student need – learning style/preference and/or requirement for extra
content
Address identified individual client/workplace need – to provide organisation-specific
information
Are current, comprehensive and accurate
Respond to special needs of different student groups
Cover the specifics of the Competency Standard/s being delivered
Can be created within the allowable budget
Wherever possible, can be re-used in other sessions and/or by other Trainers.
Advice by item
Resources which may need to be prepared will reflect the planning which has gone into the
training/session plan and could raise a demand to prepare:
Chalk boards or white boards – in readiness for class/session use. This may require:
Obtaining and positioning boards
Cleaning them
Writing up (and covering) material
Obtaining chalk and/or markers
Obtaining dusters and/or cleaning materials.
Overhead projectors and acetate/overhead sheets –
which may require:
Obtaining and positioning projector and screen
Obtaining spare globe and testing projector
Focussing projector to suit acetate sheets and position of projector
Preparing acetate sheets
Developing a stand-by plan in case OHP does not work
Practising with the OHP.
Also note:
Use of OHPs allows use of colour
Acetate sheets featuring ‘fold out’ disclosures can be produced to enhance display
Choose from permanent or non-permanent marker pens
Frames can be bought or made to protect acetate sheets – these are a good idea if the
plan is to use one/several sheets regularly as the frames stop them curling up
It is possible to photocopy onto acetate sheets and then project these images – be sure
to use the correct type of OHP/acetate sheet or there may be damage to the photocopier
Trainers may hand draw their own OH sheets, or computer-generate them and then
photocopy them onto an acetate sheet
© ASEAN 2014
158 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
They are very handy as Trainers can prepare acetate sheets at home/in advance and
then screen them in class
Ensure print is large enough for learners to read
Do not try to fit too much on the one OH/acetate sheet – this is probably the most
common fault with overheads, especially where people photocopy a page of text from a
book/manual onto an overhead sheet.
Actual examples/samples:
These are very effective as training tools – try to use ‘the real thing’ whenever possible
Make sure everything is known about it (whatever ‘it’ happens to be) – names of parts,
how things work and fit together, what buttons are used for, what is written in all sections
of a form/document
If ‘it’ is a document there is a need to find out what all the parts, headings and
abbreviations mean, who fills in what, what goes where, where the document comes
from and where it goes to next in the sequence of things
Try to get supporting ‘exploded diagrams’ of equipment, plant and machinery where
appropriate – manufacturers and suppliers may be able to help here.
Projects and exercises – keys are:
Can be used as in-class reinforcement and drill
Develop them to progress from simple exercises to complex ones
Make sure all questions/exercises have already been worked through and the Trainer
has sample answer/s together with details of the working out for each
Must be relevant and not just a time-filler
Use known company terms, rates, names, abbreviations, policies, SOPs wherever
possible to give projects, practices and exercises relevance and realism
Use actual workplace documents, price lists, schedules, itineraries, menus, tickets,
forms, reports and similar as the basis for what is produced
Consider whether group or individual work on these is best – both have a place, but
beware the trainee who is prepared to let the
others do the work while he takes the credit
Exercises are useful to fill in otherwise idle time
when Trainer is spending time with one trainee
and others have nothing to do – having some
sort of bank of exercises constantly available for
trainees to work on is a good thing to have and
obviously a consideration when
planning/preparing for sessions.
Videos/DVDs – considerations are:
Consider commercially produced ones (there are some really good ones but there are
some really bad ones) or make them in-house
Know how to use the VCR/DVD player in the training room – and check to see it is
actually working
Position monitor/screen so everyone can see and have volume pre-set to what is
required
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 159
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Cue video/DVD before class arrives to either the real start of the film or the particular part
of the DVD to be shown – it is OK to only show part of a video/DVD and not all of it
Ensure video/DVD has been pre-viewed so it can be properly introduced and to check it
genuinely is relevant and applicable
Consider preparing and distributing a question sheet to guide viewers through it/focus
their attention on what is being screened.
Demonstration – in addition to what has already been provided and/or to reinforce it:
Make sure all the necessary items are available for the proposed demonstration –
ingredients, bits of equipment, tools, safety items
Check the equipment works and is safe
Consider providing a written set of instructions to supplement the demonstration.
Handouts:
Are useful when Trainers need to be sure trainees go away with certain information
The Trainee Manual are mass versions of handouts
Computers have made this a very popular medium – as they facilitate initial production
and allow easy updating and ease of printing
Consider using ‘skeletal’ handouts – where learners fill in the missing parts/names
Keep the language appropriate to the knowledge level and language capability of the
learner
Be on guard for literacy problems that may impede things
Up-date handouts as the need dictates and/or on a regular basis.
Guest speakers – points to note are:
These can be extremely useful – they provide a new and knowledgeable face for the
trainees to listen to, and a new and different ‘learning resource’
Trainees are likely to learn more from Guest Speakers than from Trainers as learners
may ascribe more credibility to the Guest Speaker
Be aware they can be an absolute disaster – there are some very, very knowledgeable,
experienced and competent people who simply go to pieces when asked to be a guest
speaker: they can sometimes:
Wander all over the place in terms of what they say/present
Get flustered and lose focus
Lack credibility by virtue of their lack of presentation skills
Simply ‘freeze’ in front of an audience/class.
They can be in-house or from anywhere outside – as a Trainer never be afraid of using a
guest speaker because they are a valuable and legitimate training technique.
Many Trainers will not use them because they feel they are handing over their authority
to someone else, or that by getting someone else to do the training, they themselves are
failing to do their job.
Guest speakers do not just ‘happen’ – Trainers have to arrange them and:
Notify date, time and where to attend
© ASEAN 2014
160 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 161
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
If delivering training in a new venue/unfamiliar site try to visit the site beforehand to:
Determine what equipment and facilities are there and what will need to be provided
Ascertain physical location of things
Get a feel for the area – to help visualisation of the actual delivery.
Never assume even the basics will be there, or be operational, in a different/someone else’s
environment.
Following plans
Reasons to follow the plans
The plans which were prepared for the training must be
followed for the reasons given below – doing so means:
The Trainer will have confidence in the presentation and
delivery – because they have planned and prepared and
know what they will be doing, what they are going to say
and where and when things are going to take place
The trainer can arrive at the training venue early and set up
the area in advance for the training – and this will:
Instil even more confidence in the Trainer
Prove to the learners their training is important and effort has been put into it
Demonstrate to the learners the Trainer is ready and prepared
Allow the session to start on time.
The learners will benefit because the Trainer is more self-assured, confident and aware
of what is happening – learners will sense the belied the Trainer has in themselves and
in the people they are training and this positive energy is contagious
The Unit will be delivered:
On time – by the planned/required completion date/within the allocated hours
Within budget – the preparation undertaken will have ensured all resources,
materials and consumables fit within the allocation of funds for the Unit.
All necessary content will be covered – this may address:
Requirements as listed in the Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
162 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
They must always take whatever action is needed before the next session to effectively
address and resolve the situation. Solving these matters cannot be left to the Stage
3/Evaluation phase.
Depending on the issues the following may provide a suitable response – often a
combination of responses is required:
Spend extra time out-of-class with students – to catch up on missed content and help
with understanding of certain topics or provide more one-on-one training or give an
opportunity for additional supervised practice
Schedule another training session – this can require cooperation and goodwill from all
involved (and time provided free-of-charge by the Trainer) but is often a very effective
way of bringing plans back on track.
Generally speaking Training Providers are loathe to pay for extra time for Trainers to
deliver make-up, remedial or catch-up classes. Employers are likewise commonly
reluctant to release employees for additional hours during their paid working time.
Adjust subsequent plans – which may (for
example) entail:
Altering original delivery technique to a
more time-effective method – such as:
– Replacing demonstration and practice
with lecture
– Not using a Guest Speaker – (which
traditionally occupies a deal of time) and
delivering the content they would have covered using handouts or ‘chalk and talk’
– Getting rid of the excursion – and using that time to catch up on what needs to be
covered
– Limiting non-essential delivery methods – which may allow reducing time
allocated for discussions, in-class research or group work.
Eliminating or reducing non-essential content listed in the session plans as being
planned for delivery – content can often be classified as:
– ‘Must know’ content – which MUST be delivered regardless of any factors or
constraints
– ‘Should know’ content – which it is important for learners to be aware of
– ‘Nice to know’ content – which can be presented if time allows: it is this area of
content which may be able to be removed from the plans.
© ASEAN 2014
164 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 165
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Spend a few minutes (with new/first-time learners only) explaining CBT and CBA – as
described under ‘Introduction to the Trainee Manual’
Provide an overview of the contents of the Unit as presented under ‘Unit Descriptor. In
the TM
Explain how learners can use the Assessment Matrix to help them reference content
when studying and preparing for assessments
Take time to explain the terms, phrases and acronyms as presented in the Glossary
Highlight the ‘Recommended Reading’ section which learners can elect to use if they
want extra information from various sources.
On-going use of the TM
The Trainee Manual can be used by the Trainer when conducting training in the following
ways:
As a sole reference when conducting the training – that is the Trainer may choose not to
use the PowerPoints which are provided and deliver training using the TM as the central
source and reference point – this approach may be suitable where facilities for using
PPTs do not exist and/or in circumstances where the Trainer has decided ‘chalk and talk’
delivery is appropriate
To support the use of the Toolbox PPTs – this approach can be used where:
The Trainer uses the PPTs as the primary method of delivery of content, screening
the slides as provided
The Trainer makes in-class reference to pages of the TM which learners can refer to
in- or out-of-class to gain additional information.
It can be reserved for private individual study for learners and not used at all during
classes – while Trainer delivers the training using the PPTs
To explain assessment requirements in relation to the Work Projects listed in the TM –
ensuring the information provided to the learners has been discussed with and agreed to
and approved by the Assessor.
When training delivery for the Unit has been completed the Trainer should encourage
learners to complete and return the ‘Trainee evaluation sheets’ which are situated at the rear
of each TM – Trainer may choose to photocopy these pages and distribute them as
handouts rather than have students tear them out of their own TMs.
© ASEAN 2014
166 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 167
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Screen the selected slides in the order determined in the planning stage – standard
practice would be to:
Show the slides as provided in the Toolbox starting at Slide 1 and moving though
each consecutive slide until the end of the session is reached
Screen new slides which have been created to supplement those provided in the
Toolbox (where applicable)
Verbally explain the points shown on the slides – which can be done by:
– Referring to personal industry experience
– Using the material provided in the Presenter’s view of the slides
– Referring learners to nominated pages of the TM
– Taking the points on the slides as the basis for class discussion.
Use of Classroom Activities listed in PPTs
Trainer can choose to:
Use the Activities as presented – adapting and or interpreting them as best suits
particular needs
Ignore Activities as they see fit – it some cases the Activities provided for may not be
able to be accommodated due to availability of resources, personnel or time
Add extra Activities – to reflect additional content which has been added, or to provide
extra practice or learning opportunities for students
Replace or substitute Activities – with a different Activity which is more appropriate for
the student cohort, local requirements or industry need
Change or modify Activities – again to better suit the needs of the situation or class
Re-locate position of Activities – and use suggested Activities in a different position when
presenting the training.
Classroom Activities commonly include but are not restricted to:
Discussions
Guest Speakers
Handouts
Demonstrations
Practical Work
Role plays
Group work
Internet Research
Excursions.
© ASEAN 2014
168 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 169
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Never use them unless they are 100% on the mark for the training and are current and in
good condition.
Using demonstration
In addition to what has already been provided and/or to reinforce it:
When doing a demo, the accepted sequence/method is:
I do it normal, I do it slow, you do it with me – then off you go!
Using handouts
Perhaps consider having trainees read sections of the handouts (or Trainee Manual) out
– but this can be fraught with problems though if trainees are easily embarrassed about
their reading skills
Beware many will just want to go/leave as soon as they get the handout – they may feel
they have what they need and will not learn anything else, or there will not be anything
else to learn over and above the handout
Up-date handouts as the need dictates and/or on a regular basis.
Using Guest speakers
NEVER walk out and leave the guest speaker on their own – it is rude, plus it means the
Trainer will not know what was covered or what was said
Remember the Trainer will often learn a lot from guest speakers too
Be prepared to ask questions of the guest speaker – sometimes trainees are reluctant to
ask them so it is up to the Trainer to do so: this often means asking questions to which
the answers are already known and asking them more as a prompt to the speaker than
anything else
Send all guest speakers a “Thank You” letter after the session, perhaps even a small gift
– especially if you want them back.
© ASEAN 2014
170 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Setting and advising boundaries for the group – in terms of what is acceptable and what
is unacceptable in relation to participation, language, behaviour, commitment,
submission of work
Expressing expectations for the group – in terms of their attendance, engagement,
outcomes, results
Providing relevant motivation to learning – at the outset of training programs and
individual sessions
Integrating known workplace demands, protocols, requirements, terms, SOPs, methods
and/or equipment, plant, materials, ingredients and/or utensils into training
delivery/content
Engaging with and working with learners – before, during and after training sessions
Developing rapport and good working relationships – with the group
Monitoring group participation and interaction – with:
Each other
Training content
Training methods and activities.
Intervening as required when sub-optimal conditions/circumstances are identified –
which may require:
Altering planned delivery, activities, timing or other factors
Talking to, warning, or separating learners who are creating disruption for others or
who are causing a problem for training delivery
Modifying the training conditions or environment.
Controlling the delivery of the session – so that:
Identified content is covered
Training finishes on time
Learners feel safe, respected, challenged and engaged.
Learner support
There is a strong link between ‘facilitation skills; (above) and ‘learner support’ described here
– in many cases there is a blurring of boundaries which may distinguish these concepts.
Learner support differs from facilitation as it is
targeted at an individual learner (or group/sub-set
of learners) rather than something undertaken to
support the entire group of learners, as a whole.
Examples of activities which can provide learner
support therefore could be:
Determining individual leaner characteristics,
styles and preferences – and responding to
them/including them as part of training delivery
Preparing individual learning plans for certain learners – who have been identified as
having special needs or a particular need for extra attention
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 171
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Monitoring of delivery
Monitoring of actual training delivery must include a combination of all of the following on a
regular and ongoing basis:
Checking timing/pacing of delivery against session plan – in order to:
Finish session on time
Cover content identified for the session.
Observing the learning environment – to:
Maintain safety
Keep it conducive to learning.
Watching interpersonal relationships between
learners – so action can be taken as
appropriate/required to:
Defuse problems
Facilitate positive connections.
Controlling the process – by:
Managing access to resources
Administering/supervising activities and practice
Directing and limiting actions.
Determining learning of individuals – through:
Observation
Questioning
Testing.
Assessing suitability of:
Training resources used
Teaching methods employed.
© ASEAN 2014
172 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
174 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Context of evaluation
In relation to evaluation of training delivery the following are important:
Evaluation is not assessment – assessment refers to CBA, while evaluation (in this
context) refers to an analysis and review of the training and related practices of the
Trainer.
Evaluation means reflecting on what has happened with a view to Continuous
Improvement.
All Trainers should evaluate their training – without exception: even very experienced
Trainers and Master Trainers.
Evaluation is an integral part of all training.
Payment for delivering training always includes a component
for not only ‘planning and preparation’ but also for
evaluation.
Evaluation can occur after each session – or at the end of a
program, or both.
Evaluation needs to be based on objective feedback to the
best extent possible – this feedback should come from:
Current students/trainees
Past students/trainees
All stakeholders.
Feedback can be:
Verbal – comments made by and complaints/compliments received from students
Written – such as the Trainee Evaluation Sheet at the back of each TM: see also
below
Visual – through observing actions, body language and reactions of students to
training practice.
Trainers must be pro-active in seeking feedback about all aspects of their performance –
they must:
‘Ask for it’
Actively seek it out.
The results/findings of evaluations are one of the main ways Trainers can continue to
refine and improve their training practice
Outcomes/findings must serve as the basis for future action – for example:
Negative findings must be addressed and rectified
Positive outcomes need to be repeated and extended into other areas.
There will be times when evaluations result in findings which are not particularly flattering
or ‘nice to hear’ and in these cases it is vital to:
Ensure legitimate criticism is listened to and acted on
Never victimise anyone who has contributed legitimate negative comments
Strive never to repeat actions which gave rise to that feedback.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 175
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
176 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Conducive to learning?
If not, it may be possible to:
– Make the location quieter
– Adjust lighting and/or heating/air conditioning
– Restrict access by others to the training area.
Reflective of industry/workplace needs?
If not, there may be a need to:
– Change plant, equipment and utensils to better reflect what is used in the
workplace
– Alter practices and procedures taught to reflect workplace need
– Move to more relevant training location
– Re-locate to workplace/on-the-job training.
Able to support the training required strategies and/or preferred student learning
preferences?
If not it may be possible to:
– Change training methods
– Obtain necessary infrastructure.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 177
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
178 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Evaluation of content
Things change and training needs to keep pace.
The intention is to ensure content/competencies remain in-line with industry requirements.
Is training content still acceptable to the situation, the trainees, their managers, and the
industry – is it in-line with Best Practice and does it align with current legislation?
To evaluate content the following can be useful:
Undertake regular analysis of content – at least every three years is considered a
standard
Use of a representative cross-section of industry personnel and businesses as the
reference point for determining relevancy, currency, legitimacy and other applicable
factors
Liaise with industry (individual employers, employer
groups, peak industry bodies, government agencies)
on an on-going basis to stay in touch with
current/changing practice – for example through
bodies such as:
‘Industry Reference Groups’
‘Industry Advisory Boards’.
Conduct practical comparisons (say, every three years) between ASEAN Competency
Standards and:
Vocational curriculum documentation from other countries which use CBT
Actual ASEAN workplace protocols (policies, practices and procedures; equipment,
systems and technology used).
Methods of evaluation
The total evaluation process will embrace both the 'process' of the training itself (the nuts
and bolts of the actual training process) as well as the 'product' of the training (the results of
the training).
The sources of information which will form the basis for the evaluation, and the techniques
used to capture it, will vary depending on the aim of the evaluation.
In addition to what has been identified above the following provide valid and valuable
sources of relevant feedback for the purposes of evaluating training delivery.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 179
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
180 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Observation Checklist
This can be used by a ‘trusted friend’, colleague or another Trainer to provide feedback on
listed aspects of the training.
Observer Checklist
Trainer: Date:
Observer: Session:
Preparation and set-up Y N Comments
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 181
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Delivery
Throughout the training session did the trainer manage the learning environment by:
Speaking clearly using plain English, no slang or
unnecessary jargon?
Use questions effectively and appropriately?
Listen actively and respond appropriately?
Give clear, specific feedback?
Support the learner throughout the session, identifying and
responding to needs where appropriate?
Monitor learning throughout the session and modify the
plan where appropriate to ensure effective learning?
Monitor OH&S issues to ensure safety throughout the
session?
In general
© ASEAN 2014
182 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Name:
ASEAN Competency
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 183
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
184 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Work Projects
It is a requirement of this Unit you complete Work Projects as advised by your Trainer. You
must submit documentation, suitable evidence or other relevant proof of completion of the
project to your Trainer by the agreed date.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 185
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
Summary
Implement training of an ASEAN Competency Standard
© ASEAN 2014
186 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Presentation of written work
2. Style
Students should write in a style that is simple and concise. Short
sentences and paragraphs are easier to read and understand. It helps to
write a plan and at least one draft of the written work so that the final
product will be well organised. The points presented will then follow a
logical sequence and be relevant. Students should frequently refer to the
question asked, to keep ‘on track’. Teachers recognise and are critical of
work that does not answer the question, or is ‘padded’ with irrelevant
material. In summary, remember to:
Plan ahead
Be clear and concise
Answer the question
Proofread the final draft.
Format
All written work should be presented on A4 paper, single-sided with a left-hand margin. If
work is word-processed, one-and-a-half or double spacing should be used. Handwritten
work must be legible and should also be well spaced to allow for ease of reading. New
paragraphs should not be indented but should be separated by a space. Pages must be
numbered. If headings are also to be numbered, students should use a logical and
sequential system of numbering.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 187
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Presentation of written work
Cover Sheet
All written work should be submitted with a cover sheet stapled to the front that contains:
The student’s name and student number
The name of the class/Unit
The due date of the work
The title of the work
The teacher’s name
A signed declaration that the work does not involve plagiarism.
Keeping a Copy
Students must keep a copy of the written work in case it is lost. This rarely happens but it
can be disastrous if a copy has not been kept.
Inclusive language
This means language that includes every section of the population. For instance, if a
student were to write ‘A nurse is responsible for the patients in her care at all times’ it
would be implying that all nurses are female and would be excluding male nurses.
Examples of appropriate language are shown on the right:
Mankind Humankind
Host/hostess Host
© ASEAN 2014
188 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Recommended reading
Recommended reading
NCVER PUBLICATIONS
The following are available from the National Centre for Vocational Education Research at
NCVER, All publications, 2014,
http://www.ncver.edu.au/wps/portal/vetdataportal/pubs/menu/search/!ut/p/a1/04_Sj9CPykssy
0xPLMnMz0vMAfGjzOI9DY2cPTxMDLwszB3NDDzNTQ1DDQIMDAxCTYEKIoEKAjzczYyc
QAo8fA0MPP2Cg9x8XYONDQzMiNNvgAM4GhDSH64fBVaCywVm5lAFuMzwNSVgAsgPY
AV4HFmQGxphkOmZDgCzBoES/dl5/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/?hitstart=682&term=all
th
viewed 27 of May, 2014
See also www.ncver.edu.au/.
(1) Competency Based Training
In this eclectic collection of papers, 13 essayists and four high-profile discussants consider
the complexity of the tertiary education system and its underlying structures.
VET and the diffusion and implementation of innovation in the mining, solar energy
and computer games sectors 30 Aug 2011
This report examines the linkages between innovation and skills development in vocational
education and training (VET) across three industry sectors: mining, solar energy and
computer gaming.
Using a case study approach, the research finds that each of the industry sectors differs in
their relationship between innovation and the education and training system. However, the
formal VET system is seen as being very important in teaching the underlying skills and
knowledge of a vocation.
In contrast, informal on-the-job learning imparts the actual skills for innovation, but based on
what was learnt formally. The VET system is seen as being slow in responding to new skills
needs; however, whether this represents a bad thing is debatable.
This report looks at whether vocational education and training (VET) is equipped to meet the
changing needs of the modern workplace.
This paper was presented by Robin Shreeve at the NCVER Research on Toast seminar in
March 2009.
It briefly compares the vocational education and training (VET) sector in Australia with its
equivalent in England, which is known as the skills or further education sector.
The paper then outlines two key aspects of the English VET sector which might be of use to
Australia: using course completion rates as a key performance measure at all levels of the
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 189
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Recommended reading
VET sector; and using vocational 'foundation degrees' as a way for students to articulate
between the VET and higher education sectors
Competence and competency-based training: What the literature says 12 Jun 2009
This paper is a review of literature on employer engagement with vocational education and
training (VET).
The main conclusion is that the major form of engagement is through the competency-based
training system, which is manifested through training packages. Another way employers are
encouraged to engage with VET is through competition amongst training providers. This
provides employers with greater responsiveness and choice.
Getting the knowledge-skills mix right in high-level vocational education and training
qualifications 12 Feb 2009
This paper aims to contribute to the discussion on the quality and accessibility of
underpinning knowledge in competency-based training. It uses the Vocational Graduate
Certificate and the Vocational Graduate Diploma in Education Design in a Queensland TAFE
institute to examine how the 'traditional' knowledge and theory associated with higher-level
qualifications can be accommodated within the framework of competency-based training and
assessment.
The paper raises some interesting, and provocative, questions about the status and value of
these qualifications by comparison with their university counterparts.
Creating place: Design education as vocational education and training 16 Sep 2008
Design is an increasingly important component of our world-at-work. This project reveals the
views of design educators working within vocational education and training (VET).
Research participants called for a review of design education teaching methods in the VET
context, with a particular focus on promoting innovation and creativity in diploma level
programs.
© ASEAN 2014
190 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Recommended reading
Australia needs highly skilled workers to sustain a healthy economy. Current employment-
based training models have limitations in meeting the demands for highly skilled labour
supply.
The research explored current and emerging models of employment-based training to
propose more effective models at higher VET qualifications that can maintain a balance
between institution and work-based learning.
(2) Competency Based Assessment
A stocktake of issues and activities in vocational education and training in schools through
the perspectives of the published literature and policy documentation between 1997 and
2003 is the subject of this report.
It identifies progress made and concludes that vocational programs in schools are meeting
expectations and have achieved a legitimate place in the school curriculum, but that several
implementation issues remain
Assessing generic skills in a selection of training packages is the focus of this report. Based
on case studies, the authors also examine how these skills are understood by trainers and
learners. The report contains a comprehensive literature review of assessment of generic
skills.
The use and potential of online assessment is investigated in this report. It identifies: *the
principles of quality assessment *assessment practices that can be supported with online
technologies *methods and tools that work *factors that influence choice and design on
online assessment methods.
The report is published in two volumes. Volume 1 is the main report and volume 2 contains
the appendices and is available in PDF format only.
Graded assessment in Australian vocational education and training has developed a range
of practices.
This study examines the current practice for graded assessment and identifies policy issues
that need to be addressed. Areas studied include validity, reliability and consistency,
associated costs, and cross-sectoral concerns.
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 191
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Recommended reading
This study considers the status of validity in the context of the assessment of VET in
Australia.
The project has involved reviewing the literature, reporting the outcomes of case studies,
presenting the key findings and developing a diagnostic tool to guide assessors.
The changing role of staff development for teachers and trainers in vocational
education and training 5 Jul 2001
This report analyses the changing parameters of staff development that are emerging from
the changing environment of VET in Australia.
It illuminates the changed structure of the VET workforce and the differentiation of the roles
of practitioners across different types of registered training organisations and it identifies the
implications of such changes for the future design of staff development.
Not just falling over the line? A snapshot of competency-based assessment 11 Jun
1999
This report explores whether competency-based assessment is meeting the needs of its
users. The researchers found that a number of issues were raised by those consulted in the
project.
These included grading (the need to bridge the gap between competence and excellence),
the quality of Competency Standards and their treatment of underpinning knowledge, who
are appropriate assessors, and what resources are needed to support assessment. The
report puts forward strategies to improve competency-based assessment. These strategies
are directed at policy-makers, ITABs and registered training organisations.
Assessing in VET: Issues of reliability and validity - Review of research 11 Jun 1999
This review of research reviews both the Australian discussion papers on reliability and
validity of competency-based assessment as well as international empirical research in this
field.
The review discusses two types of competency-based assessment - paper-based objective
testing techniques and performance assessments as well as the implications for validity and
reliability of each type of assessment. The review includes guidelines for establishing
procedures to enhance reliability and validity.
Deals with the pros and cons of 'grading', that is, assessing and reporting levels of
performance in competency-based VET
Existing policies and practices are examined in the light of current practices. A must for all
those involved in competence-based assessment.
A collection of papers for a wide audience within the VET sector who are tackling the issue
of assessment and RPL in the workplace.
Includes: research in competency-based assessment (CBA); assessment of knowledge,
attitudes and values; peer; self- assessment; and needs of special workers
© ASEAN 2014
192 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Recommended reading
OTHER RESOURCES
http://lrrpublic.cli.det.nsw.edu.au/lrrSecure/Sites/Web/13289/resources/competency_based.h
tm - Containing lists and links of useful publications and websites
http://www.dhs.vic.gov.au/funded-agency-channel/management-toolkit/workforce/education-
and-training/types/competency-based-training-and-assessment - What is Competency
Based Training? What is a Unit of competency? What is Competency Based Assessment?
http://www.training.qld.gov.au/resources/employers/pdf/competency-based-guide.pdf -
Competency Based Training and assessment: A guide for employers, apprentices and
trainees
http://www.education.vic.gov.au/training/employers/apprentices/pages/competencyfaq.aspx -
Competency Based Completion: FAQs
http://www.avetra.org.au/abstracts_and_papers_2000/rb_full.pdf - Abstracts and papers on
CBT and CBA
Rothwell, W.J., & Graber, J.M., 2010, Competency-Based Training Basics, ASTD Press,
Alexandria, VA
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 193
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Recommended reading
© ASEAN 2014
194 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Trainee evaluation sheet
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 195
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Trainee evaluation sheet
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
© ASEAN 2014
196 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Trainee self-assessment checklist
Yes No*
© ASEAN 2014
Trainee Manual 197
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer
Trainee self-assessment checklist
Yes No*
Statement by Trainee:
I believe I am ready to be assessed on the following as indicated above:
Note:
For all boxes where a No* is ticked, please provide details of the extra steps or work you
need to do to become ready for assessment.
© ASEAN 2014
198 Trainee Manual
Train the Trainer – ASEAN Master Trainer