UTP/CGS/040

PAPER EVALUATION SHEET

TITLE
AUTHOR
CONFERENCE
VENUE
DATE

OBJECTIVE 1 2 3 4 5

__________________________________________________________________________
• How clear are the objectives of the
paper? _________________________________________________________________________

ORIGINALITY/SCOPE 1 2 3 4 5

• Is this an original contribution?

• Is the subject matter relevant to ________________________________________________________________________
the subject topic? ________________________________________________________________________
• Does the title of the paper reflect
its content?

METHODOLOGY 1 2 3 4 5

• Were the methods used adequate

and appropriate to yield accurate and _________________________________________________________________________
reliable data?
__________________________________________________________________________

RESULTS 1 2 3 4 5

• Is the interpretation and

conclusion sound and justified by the _________________________________________________________________________
data?
__________________________________________________________________________
• Are the tables and figures
consistent with the contents?

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS

• Is the presentation of findings,

interpretations or calculations free from __________________________________________________________________________
errors?
__________________________________________________________________________
• Is the abstract sufficiently
informative? __________________________________________________________________________
• Are the references adequate and __________________________________________________________________________
relevant?

Recommended Recommended with Corrections Rejected

Evaluated By: __________________________________ Date of Evaluation : ________________

( )
Rating: 1 – Far Below Requirements 2 – Below Requirements 3 – Meets Requirements
4 – Exceeds Requirements 5 – Far Exceeds Requirements