Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By:
October, 2018
ABSTRACT
This study was concerned with the challenges beginning teachers faced when they enter the
field of education. Through the use of phenomenological approach, beginning teacher personal
reflection of experiences were recorded and analyzed to discern particular experiences that
In this qualitative study, the experiences of purposely chosen beginning teachers and
experienced teachers during their beginning years in teaching were analyzed. The research
method of interpretive phenomenology was used to analyze teacher reflections for the purpose of
obtaining a better understanding of the experiences beginning teachers deem as most challenging
and these challenges include differentiation of instruction, classroom management, and the
unexpected expectations required of the teaching profession. These three primary themes are
further analyzed and interpreted in the presentation of data. The researchers concluded that
beginning teachers nowadays were challenged especially when handling different students with
different behaviors and mental capacities. Diversity of learners is one of the most prevalent
classroom.
Moreover, teachers need to be supported as they transition into their roles as beginning
and, most of all preparing teachers for unrealized expectations they will encounter when entering
the classrooms.
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First and foremost, we are very blessed and thankful to our Almighty God for giving us
This research study could not have been possible without the support and guidance of these
following people.
To our teacher in Practical Research I, Ms. Anrose R. Cueco, thank you so much for guiding
us through this study, for widening our perspectives in life, for believing that we can accomplish
this task, and for letting us discover how difficult and sometimes cruel this life is. It is such a big
To the teachers who were part of this study, thank you for sharing your experiences,
knowledge and wisdom to us, and without you, this study would not be successful. We are so
glad and thankful that you gave your precious time to us despite of your busy schedules.
To our families and friends who supported and guided us from the very start and providing
our needs to achieve and complete this, thank you very much. To God be the glory!
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Abstract ………………………………………………………………. ii
Introduction ……………………………………………………………….. 1
Findings ……………………………………………………… 18
Conclusion ……………………………………………………… 20
Recommendation ……………………………………………... 21
Bibliography …………………………………………………….... 22
Appendices ……………………………………………………………… 25
By:
VILLAFLORES COLLEGE
iii
CHAPTER I
Introduction
The field of education, especially the role of classroom teacher, brings with a host of
challenges that are unknown to other professions. The majority of teachers enter the field
knowing that the pay they will receive is subpar to many other professions; but for their own
personal reasons, individuals continue to choose teaching as a life profession. Perhaps the lure
of offering support to young learners is the overarching appeal; however, the difficulties faced in
providing support to diverse learners, a lack of adequate training in classroom management, and
in dealing with the unrealized expectations the teaching profession holds often lead to a desire to
While much research has been conducted into the reasons why teachers leave the field of
education, there is less research based on the challenging experiences of beginning teachers told
through reflection. This study will provide insight and shed into the challenges beginning
teachers feel they have dealt with: diverse learners, managing classroom behavioral challenges,
for beginning teachers to teach effectively, they need to acquire skills or knowledge in three
general areas. The areas are knowledge of learners, subject matter, and teaching content with an
positive environment.
In this qualitative study, the research method of interpretive phenomenology was used to
analyze teacher reflections for the purpose of obtaining a better understanding of the experiences
beginning teachers deem as most challenging and if these challenges include differentiation of
instructions, classroom management, and the unrealized expectations required of the teaching
Problem Statement
Teachers in their beginning years are more likely felt difficulties in teaching because of the
different challenges that they faced. There is a plethora of reasons beginning teachers choose to
leave their professions. A lack of preparedness, inadequate support from administration, poor
working conditions, and the inability to obtain autonomy in the choices they make in their
Balls, et al., (2011) stated that too often teachers are ill prepared for the challenges that await
them when they enter the classroom. The authors listed three key challenges new teachers face
due to unpreparedness: teacher expectations, the inability to differentiate instruction for diverse
The findings of this study will redound to the benefit of society considering that teachers
play an important role in the society today. When beginning teachers enter the field of education
and confront the realities that await them as classroom teachers, there is a sense of
disillusionment with the many requirements associated with their career of choice. Thus, for the
beginning teachers to be successful in providing the needs of diverse learners, they should
receive training and be prepared sufficiently to meet the needs of these learners prior to entering
the classroom. This research is also addressed to the administrators to have their support and
guidance with regard to the problems and challenges that beginning teachers encountered. It is
hope that the results of this study lend themselves directly to future research. For the researches,
the study will help them uncover critical areas in the educational process that many researchers
DEFINITION OF TERMS
Classroom management – means a set of behaviors and activities by which the teacher
organizes and maintains classroom conditions that bring about effective and efficient
instructions.
Differentiation – means a way of thinking about and approaching the planning and
in important ways.
Expectations – in this study, the term expectations will primarily address the assumed
High positioned teachers – teachers having long experience of teaching and promoted into
higher positions.
Reflection – is a meditative and experiential form of viewing oneself in the process of learning.
Reflective practice – is the capacity with which one reflects on an action or experience which
Research Design
Phenomenological approach is used to describe the true and unique events and
perspectives of beginning teachers as they occur in everyday life (Welman & Kruger,1999).
Groenewald (2004) stated that phenomenology is based on the perspective and experiences of
people as they are lived. Phenomenological approach is a qualitative research method that is
study attempts to set aside biases and preconceived assumptions about human experiences,
feelings, and responses to a particular situation. It allows the researcher to delve into the
perceptions, perspectives, understandings, and feelings of those people who have actually
typically conducted through the use of in-depth interviews of small samples of participants.
Research Locale
The study was done at Villaflores College Tanjay City, where five of the participants are
teaching. The other beginning teacher is from Banawe High School – Pamplona District a public
school, and the other one is from Casa Marie Learning Institute Tanjay City. The other two
participants are both Principals of an Elementary School of Pamplona District, and also one of
Research Respondents
There are a total of ten participants of this study and nine of them are remained
confidential. Five of them are beginning teachers, two are Elementary Principals, one is a
Supervisor, and the last two are both professors of Villaflores College having a long term
experience in this profession. One of the beginning teachers is Mr. Romulo Jabas, 22-year old, a
and graduated as Com Laude. He is currently residing at Brgy. Sta. Agueda, Pamplona, Negros
Oriental and presently teaching at Casa Marie Learning Institute, Tanjay City.
Research Instruments
In this study, in-depth interview was conducted and with the aid of mobile phone or audio
recorder, the answers of the participants were recorded. The interview protocols were given and
The data collection was done on the month of September, year 2018. The participants
were purposely chosen to have the interview about their respective experiences during their
beginning years of teaching. After the choosing of participants, the distribution of participants’
consent was done. Those participants who chose to answer the questions written, was given an
ample time to answer it. And three of them were interviewed face to face with the help of audio
recorder to record their respective answers. Semi-structured interview was typically conducted
with a series of open-ended questions which are designed for the participants of the study.
iii
analysis of the reflections of experiences beginning teachers viewed as most challenging in their
first years of teaching. More specifically, this research examined personal self-reflections that
provided insight as to the level of preparedness beginning teachers feel when they enter the
classroom to differentiate instruction, manage classrooms effectively, and deal with job-related
expectations. The participants were asked to describe in detail their experience with these three
challenges. Through personal reflection by participants, the researchers gained a clear, logical,
The three major themes are highlighted in this study to gain pieces of information about the
difficulties and challenges that beginning teachers mostly faced, namely, differentiation of
professionals with regard to the study were further analyzed by the researchers. According to
Headden (2014), teaching force has changed considerably in the past 20 – 30 years. “The
challenge of training for the classroom must be commensurate with the challenge of effectively
RELATED LITERATURE
This research focuses on three areas that have been present in much of the corresponding
literature examining challenges beginning teachers face, namely, the preparedness beginning
teachers feel they have to differentiate instruction for all learners, the challenges that beginning
teachers face when trying to manage a classroom effectively, and the expectations beginning
When beginning teachers enter the classroom for the first time, they encounter numerous
challenges. The most prevalent of these challenges is transitioning from the role of student
teacher into that of a professional educator, planning and delivering instruction to a group of
diverse learners. Learning to teach effectively requires beginning teachers to transition from
apprentice to that of a crafted and well-versed educator. A large part of this new responsibility
includes creating a classroom management system and planning instruction that is differentiated,
challenging, and meets local and state standards. In their few years of placement, beginning
teachers are required to “sink or swim”, according to NCTAF (1996). Beginning teachers are
often assigned the most challenging classes, students with special needs (Bransford, et al., 2000).
iii
The definition of teacher has changed dramatically in the last century. A sage on stage form
of the instruction is viewed as inequitable, and the antiquated system of one size fits all in public
education is not beneficial to the majority of students. According to Tomlinson and Allan
(2000), addressing the complexity of academic diverse classrooms is one of the greatest
challenges in education today. Tomlinson and Allan contended, however, the reality is that
many students will receive instruction in the same manner as if they were essentially identical in
learning styles, readiness skills, proficiency levels, and behaviors. Tomlinson (2003) contended
that in order to meet the needs of a mixed-ability classroom of diverse learners, many adaptations
Classroom Management
Of the many challenges beginning teachers face, one of the most prevalent is managing a
classroom and engaging students effectively. Most teachers struggle from time to time is to keep
a classroom of students engaged. For beginning teachers, however, the struggle can be seen
especially daunting. “We are the authors of what happens in the classroom. Students follow our
lead and behave in ways that we unconsciously allow” (Smith, 2004). Smith 2004 contended
that the key of effective classroom management is to be conscious of student actions and
behaviors and of the actions that teachers present to the class, to develop and follow procedures
According to Smith (2004), a teacher’s job is ongoing and often feels as if it is never ending.
Smith described teacher’s responsibilities as “infinite” (Smith, 2004). Smith stated further that
the single most stressful part of teaching is the unrealistic expectations that teachers have. In
Weinstein’s (1988) research on preservice teacher’s expectations regarding their first year of
teaching, she described the teachers as that beginning teacher as having “unrealistic optimism”
and a “reality shock”. Weinstein added that beginning teachers have “unrealistic expectations
about the difficulty of teaching in general and about their own ability to deal successfully with
The first few years in a classroom are critical for beginning teacher’s survival. Smith
(2004), award winning teachers education consultant, and international presenter, stated, “Being
a new teacher is like trying to fly an airplane while building it” and added that unrealistic
expectations beginning teachers place on them are perhaps the single largest source of stress.
The transition from being a student teacher to that of a classroom teacher brings with it many
CHAPTER III
This study presents the analysis and interpretation of data with regard to the lived
experiences of five beginning teachers and five experienced teachers during their beginning
years in profession. This research focuses on three areas or themes that most beginning teachers
faced during their first years in teaching, namely, the differentiation of instruction, classroom
management, and beginning teacher expectations. These three highlighted themes further
Differentiation of Instruction
All participants in this study said that differentiation of instruction is very challenging for
beginning teachers because of the diversity of learners, the behaviors of students nowadays are
quite difficult to handle due to different characteristics of students and different mental
capacities, and students vary in different ways that the teacher should consider of.
Classrooms today offer an abundance of technology – based instruction and learning, yet more
diversity and inclusion of diverse learners than perhaps ever before. Differentiation is varying
instructional methods and processes in such a way that all learners are accommodated
(Tomlinson, 2014). A teacher in a differentiated classroom does not classify herself as someone
who “already differentiates instruction.” Rather that teacher is fully aware that every hour of
teaching, every day in the classroom can reveal one more way to make the classroom a match for
According to Howard Gardner, one of the biggest mistakes made throughout the centuries of
educating children is in the assumption that all children are of same or equal intelligence – this
fallacy has led educators to teach their students the same curriculum in much the same manner.
“A teacher who differentiates robustly creates environments and processes that make room for
Classroom Management
Eight of the participants said that it is very difficult to manage a classroom especially for a
beginning teacher. (Greenberg et al., 2014) stated that beginning teachers are often
overwhelmed and frequently feel defeated as they are challenged to deliver engaging instruction
Yes, it is difficult because it is not easy to handle a classroom especially in having a great
number of students and diversity of learners exist. Different teaching flavors will be
applied in a class of students. (Teacher – Participant 1)
Definitely difficult because you are dealing with students with different backgrounds, and
different attitudes and behavior. Also, some are dealing with issues that they can only vent
out in school. (Teacher – Participant 3)
Managing a classroom? Yes, it is a bit difficult for beginners like me. It is not easy to
handle diverse students with diverse personalities and cultured backgrounds. (Teacher –
Participant 5)
Yes it is very difficult to manage a classroom especially when your students came from
different families whose backgrounds are undesirable coming from areas where
civilization is not yet developed. Especially when you are teaching in lower sections,
where the voice of expression is being abused. (Teacher – Participant 9)
There is difficulty in managing a classroom. But the difficulty is not a possibility; meaning
in dealing with students in a classroom it is always filled with difficulty but to a committed
and dedicated teacher, these difficulties around can be translated into challenges again.
(Teacher – Participant 10)
Of the many challenges beginning teachers face, one of the most prevalent is managing a
classroom and engaging students effectively. Most teachers struggle from time to time to keep a
classroom of students engaged. (Smith, 2004) said that for beginning teachers, however, the
struggle can be seen especially daunting. “We are the authors of what happens in the classroom.
Students follow our lead and behave in ways that we unconsciously allow.”
All participants in this study expected for an enormous amount of paper works. Several
adjustments will be made and it is expected that there are a lot of paper works to do in the
beginning. There are moments where unexpected events or things happen that can be a reason
for the paper works to stagnate them and an enormous paper works will be waiting on the table.
Paper works were expected in the field of teaching. As a teacher, you expect an enormous
paper works; lesson planning, making test questions, making instructional materials,
charting, checking and recording of students’ outputs, etc. (Abrea, 2018).
According to Smith (2004), a teacher’s job is ongoing and often feels as if it is never ending.
He described teacher’s responsibilities as “infinite”. He further stated that the single most
Nowadays, if you are in a private school there will be less paper works, but if you are
public school teacher to be particular, there are vast opportunities for you to dwell on
iii
paper works. And that is one of the reasons why I’m still around at the private school
because my teaching skills, the time that I have to spend with my students doing the job,
teaching them the right things in life may be less because you have to spend more time
working on the paper works and I usually hate doing paper works. (Teacher – Participant
10)
In Weinstein’s (1988) research on preservice teacher’s expectations regarding their first year
of teaching, she described the teachers as that beginning teacher as having “unrealistic optimism”
and a “reality shock”. Weinstein added that beginning teachers have “unrealistic expectations
about the difficulty of teaching in general and about their own ability to deal successfully with
Through this study, the researchers would like to have a deeper understanding of the
expectations. Most of the participants found these three challenges a difficult one especially for
beginning teachers. (Smith, 2004) said that the first few years in a classroom are critical for
beginning teacher’s survival. “Being a new teacher is like trying to fly an airplane while
building it.”
When beginning teachers enter the classroom for the first time, they encounter numerous
the diversity of learners. Managing a classroom today is quite different from yesteryears because
FINDINGS
Based on the data gathered in this study, the following findings were drawn up:
instruction were, they have experienced difficulties and being challenged because of the trends
nowadays in handling diverse learners who belong to millennial era who are sometimes under-
focused during the formative years in college and student teaching experiences, you are meeting
the different characteristics of students and different mental capacities, especially that you are
dealing heterogeneous type of students, and there are times when students do not pay attention
and find the discussion very hard to understand. Sometimes it comes to a point where you do
not know how you will teach first or if you should continue to the next topic or lesson knowing
that there are students which can be referred to as slow learners who will be left behind. So as a
teacher, you need to think for more or different classroom instructions that will help each diverse
management be characterized?
Beginning teachers mostly felt being challenged with regard to classroom management
because you are dealing with students with different backgrounds and different attitudes and
behavior. Also, some are dealing with issues that they can only vent out in school. Most
participants said that it is very difficult to manage a classroom especially in having a great
number of students and diversity of learners exist. Different teaching flavors will be applied in a
class of students. One of the participants said that there is difficulty in managing a classroom.
But the difficulty is not a possibility; meaning in dealing with students in a classroom it is always
filled with difficulty but to a committed and dedicated teacher, these difficulties around can be
All of the participants were expecting for an enormous amount of paper works as a part of
the profession. Paper works were expected in the field of teaching. As a teacher, you expect an
enormous paper works; lesson planning, making test questions, making instructional materials,
charting, checking and recording of students’ outputs, etc. As a teacher, you will have to
prepare everything, you will have to prepare your classroom; you will have to prepare your
lesson plan, your syllabi, and for beginning teachers, there are so many papers to prepare.
Teaching profession is more on paper works. As a number of students increases, expect more
The researchers concluded that most of the beginning teachers have experienced difficulties
and being challenged with regard to differentiation of instruction, classroom management, and
job – related expectations when they enter the field of education. Beginning teachers nowadays
were challenged especially when handling different students with different behaviors and mental
capacities. It is truly hard to teach effectively when your students are not focused on your class
because of some reasons that affect them and especially showing undesirable attitudes.
Diversity of learners is one of the most prevalent reasons why teachers experienced difficulties in
RECOMMENDATION
It is further the belief of the researchers that teachers need firsthand experience of the
challenges they might encounter far in advance of their first year in the classroom. The
preservice teacher should be required to enroll in behavior management courses in which a vast
array of classroom behaviors one might encounter are highlighted and viable solutions are
offered in managing the unwanted behaviors. Moreover, teachers need to be supported as they
transition into their roles as beginning teachers in differentiation of instruction for diverse
learners; managing a classroom effectively; and, most of all preparing teachers for unrealized
If beginning teachers are adequately prepared, the possibility and likelihood of retention is
greater. Teacher efficacy, as well as a teacher’s view of the occupation of teaching is strongly
influenced by a sense of preparedness (Darling – Hammond et al., 2005). In order to prepare our
beginning teachers for the challenges that await them as classroom teachers, a paradigm shift in
policies at both the college level and in the preservice years that affect their overall wellbeing is
Balls, John, Eury, Anton & King, John. (2011). Rethink, rebuild, rebound: A framework for for
Bransford, John D., Brown, Ann L. & Cocking, Rodney R. (2000). How people learn: Brain,
Dack, Harrold & Tomlinson, Carol (2015). Inviting All Students to Learn. Educational
Darling – Hammond, Louis & Baratz – Snowden, John. (2005). A good teacher in every
classroom: Preparing the highly qualified teachers our children deserve. San
Greenberg, James, Putman, Harry & Wals.h, Klein (2014). Training our future teachers:
Headden, Sid (2014). Beginners in the classroom: What the changing demographics of teaching
mean for schools, students, and society. Standford, CA: Carnegie Foundation for the
Advancement of Teaching.
National Commission on Teaching and America’s Future. (1996). What matters most: Teaching
Putman, Harry, Greenberg, James & Walsh Klein. (2014). Training our future teachers: Easy A’s
and what’s behind them. Washington, DC: National Council of the mid – western
Smith, Rick (2004). Conscious classroom management: Unlocking the secrets of great teaching.
Tomlinson, Carol Ann (2003). Deciding to teach them all. Educational Leadership, 61 (2), 6-11.
Tomlinson, Carol Ann (2014). Differentiated classroom: Responding to the needs of all learners.
https://books.google.com.ph/books/about/LeadershipforDifferentiatingSchoolsC.html?=5
6hzQeSsMMC&redir esc=y
Weinstein, Carol S. (1988). Preservice Teachers’ expectations about the first year of teaching.
Welman, James & Kruger, Sky. (1999). Research methodology for the business and
APPENDICES
RESEARCH TOOL
Interview Questionnaire
characterized?
3. How can beginning teachers’ experiences with regard to unrealized expectations of the
works?
iii
RESEARCH CORRESPONDENCE
The purpose of this research study is to explore the lived experiences of Secondary Beginning
Teachers. I understand that the research is being carried out in partial fulfillment of the major
I also understand that all the information I provide will be confidential and my name will be
Signed:
Date:
RESEARCHERS’ CURRICULUM VITAE
PERSONAL DATA
Age : 17
Negros Oriental
Negros Oriental
Nationality : Filipino
EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND
Age : 17
Nationality : Filipino
EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND