CHECK & REVISE RECORD

No.: CBD-17-E02-AR-001

Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

FLOOR PLANS

E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E02-A-1-GP-
001-0
E18066- 1. The detail index is not consistent with the
0105D-FD-17- stair section
E02-A-1-GR-
001-0

2. There are no details of the flowerbox & the

ramp

3. Please specify the area of F.F.L 327.05

Page 1 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

4. There is no drawing AI-7GN001 shown in

this drawing

5.The door number is wrong.

6.What is the function of DAS room ?

7. Why do not use raised floor in IT room? 
E18066- 1.There are no drainage pipes in AXIS X05
0105D-FD-17-
E02-A-1-R0-

Page 2 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

001-0

2. There are no F.F.L information in the

drawing
3.There are no details of the precast cover d

4.The numbers of the following two doors

shown in the following two pictures are
wrong.

Page 3 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- 1.It shows different information in the same

0105D-FD-17- area on two top roof plan drawings
E02-A-1-TR-
001-0

2. Please clarify the function of this precast

cover

Page 4 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

3. There is an error in the level information

4. There are no detailed information such as

height, location& connection details for
equipment base.
ELEVATIONS

Page 5 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- 1. Lack of detailed dimensions
0105D-FD-17-
E02-A-2-00-
001-0

2.The design depth of the elevation is not

enough. There is no detailed size. Besides,
the edges between materials are not
obvious. Moreover, there are no detail
drawings of the external wall to show the
installation and connection of the facade

E18066- 1.Same as above

0105D-FD-17-
E02-A-2-00-
002-0
SECTIONS

E18066- 1. The index is wrong

0105D-FD-17-
E02-A-3-00-
001-0

Page 6 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2. Please show the dimension and location

of the louvers `

E18066- 1. Whether waterproofing and drainage

0105D-FD-17- should be considered in this area
E02-A-5-GN-
001-0

Page 7 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2. There is no detailed section drawing to

show how to perform the exterior wall

3. Please confirm again the feasibility and

necessity of using rock wool on the floor.
We confused with this ground slab finish.
We guess rock wool is for sound
isolation, but it is a ground slab, the
noise will be absorbed by ground soil, so
the rock wool is not required in ground
slab finish.
We guess the KIP isolator is for vibration,
but the chillers vibration will transfer to
equipment foundation, and the
foundation will be split with the ground
slab, and also be absorbed by ground
soil, so the KIP isolator is not required in
ground slab finish.
We hope design consultant revalue the
function requirements and optimize the
ground slab finish design.

CEILING

E18066- 1. The height of the ceiling of this area is not

0105D-FD-17- defined .Besides, the lighting arrangement of
E02-AI-2-GR- this area is not defined

Page 8 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

001-0

2．There is no explicit node detail at this

location

3．Summary: there is no clear ceiling height

FIRE&LIFE SAFETY PLANS

E18066- According to this page of the drawing, the

0105D-FD-17- door S15 /S13 should resistant fire for three
E02-A-8-GR- hours / one hour, but in the page of E18066-
001-0 0105D-FD-17-E01-AI-8-GN-002-0 there is

no description for it.

E18066- According to this page of the drawing, the

Page 9 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

0105D-FD-17- door S13 should resistant fire for one hour,
E02-A-8-R0- but in the page of E18066-0105D-FD-17-
001-0 E01-AI-8-GN-002-0 there is no description
for it.

FURNITURE&FINISH PLANS

E18066- 1. The elevation of this area is different

0105D-FD-17- from that of the drawingE18066-0105D-
E02-AI-3-GR- FD-17-E02-A-1-GR-001-09（E18066-
001-0 0105D-FD-17-E02-A-1-GR-001-0）

2.There are no elevation information

of this area.

Page 10 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

3. There are no elevation information

of equipment base.

4.The hole is not reflected in the roof layer,

please be clear

Page 11 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- 1. There are no elevation information of the

0105D-FD-17- stairs
E02-AI-3-R0-
001-0

Page 12 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

E18066- 1. There are no elevation information of the

0105D-FD-17- stairs
E02-AI-3-TR-
001-0

Page 13 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2.TF-01 is used for floor tiles in the roof area.

There is a clear filling area in the drawing
E18066-0105D-FD-17-E02-AI-3-R0-001-0,
but the drawing is not detailed, please make
it clear

E18066- The drawing information is inconsistent with

0105D-FD-17- the electromechanical drawing
E02-AI-4-GR-
001-0
E18066- None

Page 14 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

0105D-FD-17-
E02-AI-4-R0-
001-0
E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E02-AI-4-TR-
001-0
E18066- 1.TF-01 floor tiles have no specific size
0105D-FD-17-
E02-AI-8-GN-
001-0

E18066- 1.there is no information for fixing louver

0105D-FD-17- windows.
E02-AI-8-GN- 2. there are no detailed drawings for
002-0 windows and doors.（
VERTICAL CIRCULATION DETAILS

E18066- 1. The number of steps in the detail is

0105D-FD-17- different from that in the plan
E02-A-7-GN- drawings（E18066-0105D-FD-17-E02-A-1-
001-0 GR-001-0）

Page 15 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

2. The first step is too high

3. Please specify the structural elevation of

the stair landing ,the installation location and
details of the handrails

4. There are no detailed information of the

wall such as location, thickness, finish
material

Page 16 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

5. Stair treads detail level is insufficient, lack

of size, overhang length
6. In the plan, the location of the stairs
should take the axis as the starting point
ACOUSTICS

E18066- 1.This chart does not indicate the area of

0105D-FD-17- sound insulation and the effect of sound
E02-AC-1-GR- insulation to be achieved，please indicate.
001-0
E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E02-AC-4-GR-
001-0
E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E02-AC-5-GR-
001-0
E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E03-AC-1-GR-
001-0
E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E03-AC-4-GR-

Page 17 / 18 22-Apr-20
Package No. P17 Discipline AR Reviewed by

Design
Tower No. E02 FD Total pages.
Stage

Drawing No. Comments Reply/Revised

001-0
E18066- None
0105D-FD-17-
E03-AC-5-GR-
001-0
SIGNAGE PLANS

E18066- 1.This kind of number does not specify the

0105D-FD-17- specific style, size, installation height and
E02-AG-1-GR- other details of the sign.
001-0

E18066- 1.The same as above.

0105D-FD-17-
E02-AG-1-R0-
001-0

Reviewer’s Recheck
Date

Page 18 / 18 22-Apr-20