Professor Persuasion and Persuasive Communication The term ‘persuasion’ means to force someone into something. The art of persuasion is the art of finding the best available means of moving a specific audience in a specific situation to a specific decision. Persuasive communication means, persuading others to understand what one is trying to communicate. Persuasive communication has one core purpose: get the readers to support, believe, and act in favour of presenter. Designing Persuasive Communications First, establish communications objective. Create awareness Promote image Message retention Stimulate action Designing Persuasive Communications (Contd.) Second, choose media strategy. Which Media does your target audience listen to or read? Consumer profile - specific media consumers read or watch. Audience profile - descriptions of audiences that listen to/watch specific media. Designing Persuasive Communications (Contd.) Third, decide on message strategy. Goal of the message strategy is to be persuasive relative to the communications objective. Issues to be considered: Words vs. pictures Vividness Repetition Semantics Inoculation Theory
Presenting refutational arguments to
consumers before they hear it from others makes the message appear more credible. Inoculates consumers from competitors’ ads that will be negative. Comparative Advertising Messages that directly compare a brand to a competing brand. Comparison in terms of one or more specific attributes. Most effective when they help consumers differentiate between two brands. Disadvantages: Consumers may not be able to differentiate false claims. Emotional Appeals Fear appeals Used in over 15% of TV ads Used to either encourage or discourage certain behaviors The intensity of the fear appeal is related to its effectiveness - moderate levels of fear appear to be most effective. Humor Appeals Humor Appeals Most effective when: Clearlyidentifies brand and humor does not overwhelm the product Distracts attention away from counter argument Appropriate to brand’s image
Used with existing products
Used with low-involvement products
Humor Appeals (Contd.) Most effective when: Audience is younger, better educated, upscale, professional Ads are shown in action-adventure environment rather than sitcoms (contrast effect, Gestalt) Abrasive Advertising An unpleasant ad that antagonizes listeners Agony commercials that show graphic detail upsetting to consumers Sex Appeals Effective when sex is related to the advertised product. Ineffective, if it is used just to attract attention - may interfere with message comprehension and cognitive processing. Language It’s very important to use language that fits the audience and the purpose you want to achieve. Inappropriate language uses can damage your credibility, undermine your argument, or alienate your audience The following sums up the aspects of language: 1. Levels of Formality 2. In-Group Jargon 3. Slang and idiomatic expressions 4. Deceitful language and Euphemisms 5. Biased language Levels of Formality The level of formality should be determined by the expectations of your audience and your purpose Formal (To an unknown audience Semi-formal (To a well-known individual or audience) Informal (Incorrect) Distinguish between formal and semi formal depending on purpose Group Jargon Jargon or specialized language used by small groups of like-minded individuals. Avoid using in-group jargon in general audience without explanations. Use group-specific jargon, if you want to address in-group audience. Not using the jargon when it is expected by your audience can Signal to the audience that you are not a member of that group Mean you have not mastered the group's terminology Can damage your credibility Interfere with your purpose in presentation. Slang and Idiomatic Expressions Avoid using slang or idiomatic expressions ("pull someone's leg", "spill the beans", and "something smells fishy“). These words make one sound informal, and hence, less credible. Deceitful Language & Euphemisms Avoid using any language whose purpose is deceitful i.e. seems to mislead or cheat. Euphemisms are terms that attempt to cover up that which is wrong, unethical, taboo, or harsh. Language can also be deceitful if it is overly complex or confusing. Confusing language is deliberately created and is used to downplay the truth or to evade responsibility. Stereotypes and Biased Language Avoid language that is stereotypical or biased in any way. Biased language occurs with gender, can also offend groups of people based on sexual orientation, ethnicity, interest, or race. Stereotyped Language Stereotyped language assumes a stereotype about a group of people. Non-Sexist language Non-sexist, non-biased way is both ethically sound and effective. Uses-Generic- Humankind instead of Mankind Occupation – Firefighter instead of Fireman Processes to Persuade by A Communication There are four kinds of processes that determine the extent to which a person will be persuaded by a communication. 1. Attention: One must first get the intended audience to listen to what one has to say. 2. Comprehension: The intended audience must understand the argument or message presented. 3. Acceptance: The intended audience must accept the arguments or conclusions presented in the communication; this acceptance is based on the rewards presented in the message. 4. Retention: The message must be remembered, have staying power. Variables for Persuasive Communication 1. Source: What characteristics of the speaker affect the persuasive impact? 2. Communication: What aspects of the message will have the most impact? 3. Audience: How persuadable are the individuals in the audience? 4. Audience Reactions: What aspects of the source and communication elicit counter arguing reactions in the audience? The Persuader 1. There will be more opinion change in the desired direction if the communicator has high credibility. 2. The credibility of the persuader is less of factor in opinion change later on than it is immediately after exposure. 3. A communicator's effectiveness is increased if he/she initially expresses some views that are also held by the audience 4. What an audience thinks of a persuader may directly influence their thinking about the message. 5. Communicator characteristics, irrelevant to the topic of the message, can influence acceptance of its conclusion. How To Present the Issues 1. Present one side of the argument when the audience is generally friendly. 2. Present both sides of the argument when the audience starts out disagreeing with you, 3. When opposite views are presented one after another, the one presented last will probably be more effective. 4. There will probably be more opinion change in the direction you want if you explicitly state your conclusion than if you let the audience draw their own. Audience as Individuals 1. The level of intelligence of an audience determines the effectiveness of some kinds of appeals. 2. Successful persuasion takes into account the reasons for underlying attitudes as well as the attitudes themselves. 3. Individual's personality traits affect his/her susceptibility to persuasion. 4. There are individuals who are highly persuadable and who will be easily changed by any other influencing attempt. 5. Ego-involvement with the content of the communication increases the acceptance of its conclusion Persistence of Opinion Change a) A communication from a positive source leads to more rapid decay of attitude change over time than one from a negative source. b) A complex or subtle message produces slower decay of attitude change. c) Attitude change is more persistent over time if the receiver actively participates in. 2. Repeating a communication tends to prolong its influence. 3. More of the desired opinion change may be found some time after exposure to the communication than right after exposure .