MAHARASHTRA STATE ROAD DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION - MUMBAI-

PUNE EXPRESSWAY PROJECT

REVIEW COMMENT SHEET (RCS)
Submission of Method Statement for Ventilation Shaft tunnel excavation
(NEC-MPEW-2020-21-009) date 11.05.2020

Document number Document title Design Stage

GLJV-A3000-CON-CIV-TVS-RCS-0044 Review and Comments on Submission of Method Statement for Ventilation Shaft tunnel excavation NA
(NEC-MPEW-2020-21-009) date 11.05.2020

STATUS
Revision R0 GLJV REVIEWERS GLJV APPROVER
Closed / Not Closed

Enter the latest revision being reviewed R0 Not Closed Gagan Sharma Noel P. Mundo

REVIEW CODE SIGNATURES SIGNATURE

REVIEW CODES:
R: REJECTED
R&R: REVIEW AND RESUBMIT
NOWC: NON OBJECTION WITH COMMENTS R&R
NO: NON OBJECTION

NOTE: no construction allowed for R and RR review codes

Date 5/26/2020 5/26/2020

DESIGN STAGE:
Design Stage 1 (DS1): To fix the design criteria and other preliminary design inputs before heading to detailed design
Design Stage 2 (DS2): Preliminary design for each discipline
Design Stage 3 (DS3): Detailed design with interfaces and interdisciplinary checks resolved
Design Stage 4 (DS4): Issued for Construction

GLJV-A3000-CON-CIV-TVS-RCS-0044 1 05/26/2020
 MAHARASHTRA STATE ROAD DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION - MUMBAI-PUNE EXPRESSWAY
PROJECT
REVIEW COMMENT SHEET (RCS)
Submission of Method Statement for Ventilation Shaft tunnel excavation (NEC-MPEW-2020-21-009)
date 11.05.2020

DRS No: Submission Date:

GLJV-A3000-CON-CIV-TVS-RCS-0044 MS 5/11/2020
Comments Sent by Letter No. Revision Comments Issued On:
SO-P1-0327 R0 5/22/2020
COMMENTS OVERALL STATUS:
CLOSED NOT CLOSED
Section/
Doc.
No. Page/ Part GLJV COMMENTS By NAVAYUGA RESPONSE By Status
Rev.
No.
Method Statement for Ventilation Shaft tunnel excavation
This MS is valid only when the Design is approved from AE and corresponding
1 General R0 GLJV Open
details and recommendations incorporated.
   Please ensure the excavated surface shall be mapped and temporary
2 Geology support shall be installed without any delay for safety concern and mapping R0 GLJV Open
report shall be submitted to AE for review ASAP.s.

Please provide the complete sequence for Vertical shaft excavation including
procedure of muck removal from the shaft with EOT , taking into consideration
3 Scope R0 GLJV Open
of the safety of worker who shall be loading the EOT bucket.How to make safe
arrangements to lift them after the bucket loading is completed.

MS for
Ventilation Please provide the maximum unsupported safe depth of each rount of
4 R0 GLJV Open
shaft tunnel excavation, No further excavation shall be carried out beyond the safer depth.
excavation
MS for
Before supporting the newly excavated portion, scalling must be done
Ventilation
5 properly so that no loose blocks should be left behind.Please specify the the R0 GLJV
shaft tunnel
method of scaling .
excavation

Please explain the scheme for the Dewatering during the construction. A
6 Dewatering drawing/ sketch shall me attached with the details and details of standby R0 GLJV
dewatering arrangement shall be included.

After every Blast, What shall be metod of surveying and Profile sections , this
would help in locating the exact location where the under cut/overbreak
7 Survey .Please ensure to attach Drawings of ventilation tunnel and Vertical shaft R0 GLJV
including cross-sectional details,along with primary and complete support
details.
MS for
Ventilation The method statement approval is subject to the design approval and closer of
8 R0 GLJV Open
shaft tunnel the above comments.
excavation
EOT
The EOT crane should cover all the aspects and design as per IS codes , IS
9 Specification R0 GLJV
3177(1999) and IS 807 (2006)
s
Please provide the Blasting pattern in case of any change in Pattern of
Blasting
10 Blast.The no. of holes for drilling and loading will be done strictly as per R0 GLJV
pattern
Blasting pattern in order to have the minimum overbreak ,

Muck
11 Muck disposal plan from vertical shaft to dumping yard with equipment detail. R0 GLJV
Disposal

Please ensure the submission of the drawing/sketch of the shaft including detail of
R0 GLJV
shotcrete thickness, size and length of bolts, EOT details, etc.

Electrical / Provide method of ventilation and all electrical and lightning during
12 R0 GLJV
lightings construction operation in Vertical shaft.

*The Authority Engineer team is available for any clarification you need in the content of these observation.

GLJV-A3000-CON-CIV-TVS-RCS-0044 2 05/26/2020