Design Journal - Criterion D

EVALUATING
D.2 - EVALUATE THE SUCCESS OF THE SOLUTION
Level 1-2 Level 3-4 Level 5-6 Level 7-8

States ​the success of Outlines​ the success Explains​ the success Critically ​evaluates
the solution. of the solution against of the solution against the success of the
the design the design solution against the
specification based specification based design specification
on relevant product on relevant product based on authentic
testing testing product testing

Grade:

DESIGN SPECIFICATION EVALUATION

Specification Did you meet the specification?

The filter will bring the It takes a long time to bring the air quality in the room
quality of the air in the to safe level, but in 15 minutes it can bring air quality
room to a safe level. near her desk to safe level.

The fan of the filter has The noise from the fan is smaller than her voice, so it
small noise while it’s won’t interrupt her classes.
working.

The filter will be small that The air filter is small enough to place under Ms. Ari’s
can fit under Ms. Ari’s desk.
desk.
 The filter will consistently The fil can consistently work
work

The appearance and shape She likes the design and size of the product.
will be designed as the
customer wants.

D.4 - EXPLAIN THE IMPACT OF THE SOLUTION

Level 1-2 Level 3-4 Level 5-6 Level 7-8

Outlines ​the impact Explains​ the impact Explains ​the impact

of the solution on the of the solution on the of the product on the
client/target audience. client/target audience, client/target audience.
with guidance.

Grade:

EXPLAINING THE IMPACT

The high aqi in the client's class has decreased by using my product. My air purifier
successfully cleans the air in the classroom during smoky season, so that it can prevent
additional problems which are health problems.

My product improves the air qualities of the client's classroom and decreases the danger of
having disease by bad air qualities.

My product met all the design brief and well constructed.