Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fundamentals of Launching a
Precast Concrete Segmental
Operation for Bridge
Construction Projects
Arthur M. Palmer
Lead Construction Engineer
Parsons Brinckerhoff
Seattle, Wash.
Precast concrete segmental bridge construction is This article explores the necessary facility upgrades
continuously evolving to keep pace in a competitive a precaster will need to successfully undertake
environment. As segmental bridge construction the comprehensive planning, coordination, and
increases in national popularity, a number of transformation process required to enter the
precasters will consider upgrading plant facilities segmental bridge production arena and lists sources
to handle this relatively new product. Historically, for industry technical support for this endeavor.While
general contractors have produced the majority the challenges of upgrading operations to include
of precast concrete segments for existing precast precast concrete segmental bridge components
concrete segmental bridges, and it has been the are considerable, bold innovation and careful risk
exception when a contractor has purchased segments management and system integration can establish
from a precast concrete manufacturing facility. this product line as a true precaster product.
PCI JOURNAL
A
n experienced precaster is the project within 150 miles (240 km) of Bid Document Review
best person to understand what an existing precast concrete operation, The next step is to derive an antici-
is required to run an efficient, the information presented in this arti- pated contract award date and identify
successful business in today’s competi- cle will be beneficial to the company’s project milestones to extract erection
tive construction market. The forward- future success. dates. Use this knowledge to formulate
thinking precaster may wish to consider The following list of publications will a general inventory for casting yard
expanding plant operations to include be handy reference material to start the start-up requirements, segment cast
a new and growing product line. Most segmental library; other sources will be out time frame, and maximum segment
precasters have some knowledge of listed throughout the article: storage area needed.
segmental bridge construction but may • “Deck Segmentation and Yard Carefully review contract drawings
have steered clear of segmental assem- Organization for Launched to determine segment types, quanti-
bly because of its perceived complexi- Bridges” by M. Rosignoli;1 ties, weights, anchor block configura-
ties. Upgrading a precast concrete op- • “Casting Box Girder Segments” tions, and special project requirements,
eration to handle production of bridge by Moreton and Janssen;2 including mixture proportions, curing
segments can understandably seem to • “Segmental Bridges: The Best in regimens, and testing protocol. Deter-
be a daunting task. the Business” by Barber;3 mine quantity and type of formwork
While a segmental product line is • American Association of State required, and identify the required
not the correct choice for every pre- Highway and Transportation versatility of each form to efficiently
caster, this business potential should Officials’ (AASHTO) Standard handle the project schedule. Map out a
not be dismissed without understand- Specifications for Highway preliminary casting yard layout, poten-
ing the assembly line accuracy, high Bridges and Guide Specifica- tial workforce requirements, and exist-
tolerance, and geometry control pre- tions for Design and Construc- ing (but in need of modification) and/or
cision of this next generation of pre- tion of Segmental Concrete new equipment needs.
cast concrete products. This article Bridges;4 In particular, thoroughly understand-
will explore the necessary upgrades • PCI’s Bridge Design Manual, ing the geometry control aspects of a
that an existing precaster must suc- MNL-133;5 segmental product line will ensure a
cessfully navigate, including the • “Contractor Checklist: Precast successful outcome. A healthy fear of
planning, coordination, and transfor- Yards” by Palmer;6 a costly mistake is not a bad business
mation processes. The approach taken • American Segmental Bridge perspective to maintain, and successful
here will demystify the start-up pro- Institute’s (ASBI) Construction precasters use a detailed, methodical
cess and provide the precaster with Practices Handbook for Seg- approach to daily procedures. A com-
the information necessary to make an mental Concrete Bridges;7 and prehensive review of software (provid-
educated decision. While the limita- • For additional reading, review ed by others) and monitoring survey
tions of this article preclude provid- a list compiled by the Federal instrument maintenance will keep the
ing all the answers, it is hoped that Highway Administration at project on track.
sufficient material is provided herein www.fhwa.dot.gov/bridge/eli- The theoretical casting curve will be
to allow formulation of the pertinent brary.htm. detailed by the contract drawings and
questions in a methodical evaluation interpreted by the geometry control
process. software with the approved geometry
Segmental
control data files for each bridge span.
Production—Project This span-specific data will provide the
Evaluating a New Overview necessary information to understand
Product Line— the vertical, horizontal, and superel-
Advantages for the Depending on facility location, avail- evation alignment for the bridge. The
Precaster able storage area, transportation, site ac- daily, short-line casting operation will
cess, project size, geometric complexity, be controlled by varying the position
In light of the recent Senate pas- material specifications, delivery schedule, of the match-cast segment in relation
sage of almost $400 billion in funding quality control (QC), testing/inspection to the casting form or wet-cast seg-
for U.S. transportation infrastructure regimens, reinforcing system complex- ment. Horizontal control points are
repair and rehabilitation, the use of ity, deadlines, and the client, each seg- based on the project plane coordinate
precasters in small to medium-sized mental project will have unique aspects system, using north and east surveying
segmental bridge projects will provide that must be identified by the precaster conventions. The baseline alignment
significant improvements to product during the pre-bid process. First, the pre- is established as tangent and/or curved
quality, infrastructure durability, and caster needs to be generally familiar with sections through the horizontal control
project scheduling, all important ad- the segmental construction methods and points.
vantages to project owners and con- proposed erection scheme. Then the pre- Do not limit a review to the con-
tractors. caster should review topics discussed in tract’s structural drawings, but further
If there is an upcoming segmental the following sections. identify all electrical and mechanical
May–June 2006
insufficient for the loads, overall size,
or delivery schedule for the pending
contract, the precaster must consider
upgrading facility trucking capability
or bidding the segments as freight-on-
board (FOB) plant.
Concrete Batching
Examine project concrete batching
and delivery requirements to properly
match all aspects of existing facility ca-
pacity with the specific project require-
PCI JOURNAL
side; this measurement should be close functioning properly, and local frost area relegated to the project based on
enough for a preliminary layout. Next, conditions do not have the potential to the parameters set by the contractor’s
form assembly length will be about adversely affect curing. A 12-in.-thick bid schedule. An aerial photograph
3.5 times the length of the longest seg- (305 mm) concrete floor slab in the plant showing the approximate storage area
ment—usually 10 ft (3 m). The form should be regarded as a minimal thick- (crosshatched) with estimated acreage
assembly overall height will be 3 ft to ness for segmental operations; driving is helpful.
5 ft (1 m to 1.5 m) plus the height of piles will be required to establish a
the tallest segment, with additional al- solid mechanical foundation. When a
Operational Planning
lowance for safety rails. Special limita- straddle crane will be extracting seg-
tions should be discussed with the form ments, the equipment foundations for Concrete Placement
manufacturers. the casting formwork should be iso- There are a number of choices for con-
One option for an existing precast lated from the lift crane travel lanes to crete placement in segmental production
concrete manufacturing building that is prevent adverse vibratory effects. depending on the material volume de-
too narrow in general plan is to consid- mands, project size, and expected budget
Segmental Unit Storage Capacity
er that the mandrel form can use rails (reimbursement). Options for concrete
to run outside the building. Another Figure 2 shows pier segments in placement range from a crane and con-
option is to have completed segments storage ready for shipment to the bridge crete bucket delivery to using a station-
moved along the rails to slide outside construction site. The assumed casting ary or truck-mounted concrete boom.
the building proper to be removed by schedule compared with erection de- Determining the most reasonable deliv-
crane or straddlecrane to the designat- livery dates will determine maximum ery method will depend on the number
ed plant storage areas. storage capacity requirements. Obvi- of forms, the total volume of concrete,
ously schedules change—due to ad- the needed height of forms versus clear
Casting Forms, Foundations,
verse weather or labor problems—and height to ceiling supports within the
and Layout
a significant buildup from an assumed building, and the proximity of the batch
Determine plant casting yard layout casting schedule could occur. Even plant and overall plant volume.
with an eye toward maximizing effi- environmental regulations protecting
Segment Geometry Control
cient workflow and minimizing equip- nesting birds at bridge sites have been
ment usage. Precise foundation design known to shut down construction. It A short-line casting procedure uses
for the casting formwork is crucial to is important, therefore, to consider at a stationary casting form to match cast
maintaining proper and consistent ge- what point the available storage yard succeeding segments against the previ-
ometry results in the completed seg- will be filled and whether overflow ous unit. The first segment is cast be-
ments. Review the plant site to ensure contingencies are established. tween bulkheads. Successive segments
consideration of these items: Concrete Another layout consideration pro- are cast, one at time, against the bulk-
slab thickness is adequate to support posal point is to clearly address the head on one end and the previous cast
production weights, site drainage is assumed maximum segment storage segment on the other end. A thorough
May–June 2006
Labor Requirements
PCI JOURNAL
department staff to focus the combined day following casting, a thorough seg- casting requirements of the plan and
expertise of each individual to ensure a ment review should take place. specifications. However, it is important
successful project. to remember that the manufacturer will
Post-Tensioning and Grouting
understandably design for form fabrica-
QC Manual Operations
tion ease for cost reduction, so the pre-
A concise and comprehensive QC The project specifications will de- caster must review the contract drawings
manual detailing every step of every tail the required concrete compressive from the perspective of labor analysis
process is a vital tool to underscore the strength to achieve prior to casting. To and in-house constructibility. Form
thoroughness of the precast concrete ensure a highly productive environ- needs are determined based on the tight-
plant and, moreover, to ensure the cli- ment, the concrete should be at post- est horizontal segment radius and maxi-
ent and owner’s representative that tensioning strength two to three days mum lengths of each type of segment.
every aspect of segmental production after casting. Prebagged grout mixture It is wise to analyze all of the form
has been carefully considered. If there suppliers can discuss equipment needs manufacturer proposals and make sure
is an existing QC manual, consider and technician availability for plant to look beyond the recommendations
augmenting the manual to include a training purposes. It should be noted of the lowest bidder. It’s very easy to
precast concrete segmental operation. that most project specifications reject base formwork purchase on price alone
prepackaged grout mixtures over six without considering an apples-to-ap-
Geometry Control Manual
months old. ples comparison to identify what the
A geometry control manual is typical- Specialized post-tensioning suppli- overall proposal includes and excludes.
ly provided by the contractor’s segmen- ers bidding the bridge project can dis- The initial form set up time and daily
tal engineer and will provide an excel- cuss the particular requirements of the operational costs are affected by labor
lent detailed account of daily operations, systems and can assist with employee costs and existing plant and equipment
including the geometry software pack- training. The supervisor responsible for needs to successfully transition or ac-
age procedures and hand calculation ex- grouting operations should have cur- commodate these new forms through
amples. Request a copy of a previously rent certification from the ASBI Grout- all the setup configurations. Efficient
used project manual for review and the ing Certification Training Program. form layout and plant set up are cru-
program software with some sample cial for smooth production cycles
data so the plant surveyor can become (Fig. 4). Make sure that a technical
Procurement Specifics
acquainted with program operation. representative will be at the plant for
Purchasing Segment Casting Forms form assembly. Normally, three to five
Repair Procedure Manual
Precasters forward contract drawings weeks is considered standard in the in-
Even if a repair procedure manual and specifications to segmental form- dustry. Maintain complete installation
is not mandatory for a given project, work manufacturers and discuss project overview responsibility, making sure
it is a highly recommended document requirements. The form manufacturer segmental form assembly ensures that
because it details numerous common will provide a design that satisfies the daily casting productivity is optimized.
plant repairs and lists any prior imple-
mentation approval required. Outlin-
ing a general agreement on a variety
of repair issues, materials, equipment,
and techniques will foster confidence
in the precast concrete team’s ability
to address typical industry concerns
regarding plant production, reliability,
and efficiency.
Prepour and Postpour Review
Prepour review consists of three main
inspections: raw material receiving and
inspection, reinforcement cage assem-
bly review when completed in the jigs,
Photo courtesy of Southern Forms.
May–June 2006
Review component changes necessary daily adjustment procedures that will form prepping procedures between casts
to adapt form to anchor block modifi- be necessary to maintain the correct for productivity and safety concerns.
cations in a typical span. Review and geometry control. If the forms have to
Casting Forms—Miscellaneous
approve all form shop drawings prior adapt to different segment configura-
Items
to fabrication. tions, it is critical that the components
There are several review parameters are modularized to speed operations. Three to five ton (2700 to 4500 kg)
for analyzing the casting form propos- The hydraulic jacking system (pro- winch units with a 3/8 in. (9 mm) mini-
als. Segmental form limitations must vided by the form manufacturer) can mum cable diameter are typically used
be checked for the following: scupper be ordered with 110V or three-phase to move segments along the production
placement, maximum casting lengths, wiring, depending on the voltage speci- rail system. A pulley assembly, floor
acceptable bulkhead post-tensioned fied and the voltage that works best for mounted on the opposite side of the
blockout locations, tightest radius for plant operations. You must also calcu- rails, will allow movement in both di-
form constructibility, combined upper late any anticipated costs of integration rections using one winch. Air and elec-
and lower anchor block clearances, and into the plant system. trical winches are available depending
keyway layout interference. Questions that the precaster needs to on the plant operator’s particular pref-
ask include: Is there a thickened haunch erence. Of course, for extreme econo-
Typical Segment Forms (Nonpiers)
area, wing breaks, or scuppers pen- my, a forklift could be used to move
Figure 5 shows the mandrel or core etrating the segmental wingform? How the precast concrete segments, but the
form setup for daily casting operations. does each form manufacturer handle author does not recommend this equip-
The form manufacturer will provide in- these configuration changes, and will ment for segmental operations.
struction details for either a manual or the solutions or required modifications Within each segment, post-tensioning
hydraulic internal mandrel operation. affect casting labor costs? ducts will be required. Forming blad-
Discuss each option with the produc- Discussion of the mechanics in- ders—basically a long balloonlike liner—
tion supervisor to assess the casting volved in forming the segments will at the duct locations are inflated during
cycle implications and determine cost- provide a clear picture of any necessary casting to avoid migration of concrete
effective needs. changes to complete the project. into the voids and to maintain stability.
Also part of the review of the casting As an operational approach on seg-
Pier and Expansion Forms
form proposal is to look at simplicity ments, secondary external vibrators
and ease of daily wing setup and the The size and weight of the interior can be mounted on the lower third of
pallet’s smooth hydraulic operation, pier and expansion form components the form at the outside web area. The
which cannot be overestimated, in par- are important. Whether the interior com- aesthetic quality of the finished seg-
ticular, the rigidity of the fixed bulk- ponents are manually set or machine ments is greatly enhanced with exter-
head, as any movement in the form installed will dramatically affect labor nal vibrators, and this optional measure
will delay cycling time. Determine the costs and casting cycle times. Study all could save costs on remedial patching
after segments are cured. Of course,
all plant safety walkways, stairs, and
fencing installations must meet Occu-
pational Safety and Health Adminis-
tration (OSHA), state, and local work-
place regulations. A complete safety
walk-through and inspection of work
stations at regular intervals is mandat-
ed by OSHA.
Geometry Control
For geometric control of the seg-
ments, a one-second accuracy the-
odolite is used for centerline checks
and elevation readings. A builder’s
level capable of reading to an accu-
Photo courtesy of Southern Forms.
PCI JOURNAL
Lifting Equipment Concerns Concrete Equipment
The standard choices for lifting Location, capacity, and accessories
segments at a precast concrete facil- of the concrete batch plant directly af-
ity are a straddle crane or crawler fect material quality. The quality and
crane. Both machines have accept- volume of concrete required for the
able capacity and maneuverability, bridge project will dictate the cement
but the characteristics of each ma- and aggregate storage capacity needs
chine have implications that bear on and the central concrete mixer capaci-
the entire operation. It is easier to ty. Local climate at the precast concrete
train an employee to operate a strad- manufacturing site will be the basis for
dle crane than a conventional crane. considering other items, such as an op-
In addition, the straddle crane can lift tional water chiller, ice machine, and
May–June 2006
and perimeter safety requirements. span with each anchor block separately forcement assemblies and positioning
Sufficient total tank or tank farm ca- identified. in the forms. Most piers and expansion
pacity will depend on equipment Transporting Segments joints can be pre–tied up to the tops of
usage, local temperature extremes, and the webs, accelerating the casting pro-
anticipated hours of operation minus A casting manufacturing yard built cess, which is especially important in
minimum tank pressure capacity alongside the project will probably re- match-casting operations.10
before equipment stops are crucial quire a mobile segment hauler for site
Fabricating Post-Tensioning
operational concerns. delivery. For longer distances, custom
Blockouts
lowboy trailers designed with the par-
Post-Tensioning System
ticular local, federal, and state regula- Determine quantities of post-ten-
A good source of information is tions applicable to the project will be sioning anchorage blockouts or form
Acceptance Standards for Post-Ten- required. The precaster should consult assemblies that are not provided by the
sioning Systems.9 The contractor will the proper authorities to review the in- form manufacturer. These items can be
choose a post-tensioning supplier for tended travel route, permitting process, fabricated with wood or steel depend-
project components. Review the post- and required escorts. Once the travel ing on the plant production manager’s
tensioning systems being considered route has been determined, the neces- preference. Generally, the symmetry
because unique details could add sig- sary en route bridge survey data will of post-tensioning design will utilize
nificant specialized labor and equip- need to be checked for minimum clear- a given series of similar in repetition.
ment allocation costs. The post-ten- ance heights. Making an in-house reference mark for
sioning supplier will supply the strand, each setup could speed fabrication by
Reinforcement Jigs
chucks, jaws, and certain bursting having the fabrication shop staff begin
stress reinforcement. The precaster has Reinforcing steel bar assemblies can an inventory of typical blockouts.11
to determine which raw materials are to be made of wood or steel, depending
Transverse Post Tensioning and
be included in the supplier’s bid price. on a variety of factors. The author rec-
Grouting
ommends a minimum of two jigs for
Reinforcement Fabrication
each typical casting form. Each typical The majority of transverse post-ten-
Detailed procedures are necessary segment and reinforcement jig assem- sioning and grouting operations will
if reinforcement coatings are required, bly must operate in a simple, efficient be completed at the precast concrete
especially if coating processes require manner. These jigs, however, must facility. PTI Specification for Grout-
adapting existing plant reinforcement adapt to the versatility and variability of ing of Post-Tensioning Structures is
fabrication equipment. Consider the the casting forms that are served. Prior an excellent introduction manual
different reinforcement ordering choic- to fabrication, analyze every segment to become acquainted with present
es available in the market, and order configuration requirement to ensure industry standards to eliminate steel
steel reinforcing bars by segment or by smooth transitions between the rein- corrosion. 12
Fig. 7. Casting form prepped prior to placement of the reinforcing steel cage.
10 PCI JOURNAL
Photo courtesy of Parsons Brinckerhoff.
Fig. 8. Precise reinforcement and post-tensioning layout requirements produce excellent quality.
May–June 2006 11
Bidding Process
Contractor Relations
Determine the proper scope of work
and risk assessment on each project.
Pay special attention to inclusions and
exclusions within the precast concrete
bid, especially because construction
updates during the bidding process
will complicate matters. Negotiate an
acceptable mobilization amount to
cover casting production facility setup,
equipment upgrades, and trucking op-
tions (Fig. 9), and clearly define the
12 PCI JOURNAL
elevation and layout changes between
projects. Inquire if the contractor will
check post-tensioning jacking clear-
ance at all interior anchorages, includ-
ing longitudinal and future tendons.
Managerial Assessment
After conducting a thorough review
of the precast concrete plant and equip-
ment, scrutinize the existing manage-
rial and production team expertise to
handle a segmental operation. Deter-
May–June 2006 13
Photo courtesy of Parsons Brinckerhoff.
Fig. 12. Precast segment erection using balanced cantilever construction.
14 PCI JOURNAL
May–June 2006 15
16 PCI JOURNAL