You are on page 1of 41

PROP1005

PROJECT 2
Residential
Appraisal Report

Real Estate Division

ADDRESS OF The subject property is located at 12091 76 Ave, Surrey and prop
SUBJECT PROPERTY: descriptions is LOT- 37 SECTION-19 TOWNSHIP 2 PLAN NWP-
20991- NWD

PREPARED BY:

Imran Mohammed

100354790

Grader

Mark %

Letter Grade

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.1 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 1 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPORT (PROP1005, Project No. 2)

LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL INFORMATION

Property Address
12091 76 Ave

Municipality Province Postal


Code
surrey BC V3W2W4

Legal Description
Lot 37 SECTION-19 TOWNSHIP 2 PLAN NWP-20991- NWD

Prepared for:

The Jordan River Credit Union


1234 Ian Avenue
Vancouver, BC
As part of the process in completing course PROP 1005
Appraiser/Student Imran Mohammed Address
Student No. 100354790 12091 76, Ave surrey, BC

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.2 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 2 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Final Estimate of Value Date of Value Estimate


C$440,000 2020-08-01

Signature of Student Date of Signature

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.3 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 3 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

PHOTOGRAPHS OF SUBJECT

FRONT VIEW
(Showing Depth)

REAR VIEW

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.4 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 4 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790
PHOTOGRAPHS OF SUBJECT

STREET VIEW
(Showing along the street)

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.5 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 5 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Section Page Number


Photographs of Subject Property
Table of Contents
Summary of Salient Facts and Important Conclusions

Part I - Preface
Definition of the Appraisal Problem
Assumptions and Limiting Conditions
Regional and Area Analysis (optional from Project 1)
Neighbourhood Analysis and Trends (optional from Project 1)
Land Description and Analysis (optional from Project 1l)
OCP and Zoning
Description of Improvements (optional from Project 1l)
Description of Improvements: Observed Depreciation
Part II - Analysis and Conclusions
Highest and Best Use Estimate
Cost Approach - Land Value
- Cost Analysis of Improvements
- Depreciation
- Summary
Direct Comparison Approach
Reconciliation of Value Indications and Final Estimate of Value
Certification
Addenda Page No.

City/Regional Map A
Neighbourhood Map
Site/Plot Plan (optional from Project 1)
Floor Plan(s) (optional from Project 1)
Comparable Land Sales Map
Cost Summary; Cost Manual/Service Excerpts and Worksheets
Comparable Improved Sales Map
Photographs of Improved Sales
Additional Photographs of Subject (optional from Project 1)
Neighbourhood Photographs (optional from Project 1)
Transfer and Mortgage Documents for Comparables (optional)
Other Materials (list)

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.4 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 4 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

SUMMARY OF SALIENT FACTS AND IMPORTANT CONCLUSIONS

Type of single family dwelling: Single family home

Full Address of property: (Street, City, 10291 76 Avenue surrey BC V3W2W4


P.C.)
Lot 37 SECTION-19 TOWNSHIP 2 PLAN NWP-20991-
Legal Description NWD

Property Identification Number (PID)

BC Assessment information (current) Land Improvements Total

(From EValue BC website)


 Property Tax (Municipal
Website)
Tax assessed value: C$935,100

RF that means Single Family Residential Zone. 1


Zoning designation

Effective date of the appraisal: 2020-08-01

Dimensions and area of site: Dimension 7.7m X 7.7m

Dimensions and area of building(s): Area of building 1,453 sq ft

Highest and best use: Leave site and improvements as it is

Estimate of land value (as if vacant): Between the range of 144,000 – 240,000

Estimate of value by Cost Approach: 456,000

Estimate of value by Direct Comparison 4,87,000


Approach:

Final estimate of value: 440,000

1
https://cosmos.surrey.ca/external/

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.5 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 5 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790
DEFINITION OF THE APPRAISAL PROBLEM
PURPOSE of the appraisal is to estimate the Market Value of the subject property as at the effective date of
appraisal.

The INTENDED USE of the report is for the awarding of credits for completion of course PROP1005.

The INTENDED USER(s) are our client Mr Coley-Donohue and Langara College.
Present registered owner Manmeet Singh Multani

Past sales history (5 years) NONE

Encumbrances on Title

Mortgage information [ X ] No mortgage

1st held by 2nd held by

Principal Monthly Are taxes Date Interest Amortization Conditions


outstanding payments included? due rate period

1st $ $ %
nd
2 $ $ %

Rights-of-way, other encumbrances


[ X ] none [ ] (if any, describe)

Definition of property rights appraised


The Fee simple estate is "Absolute ownership unencumbered by any other interest or estate, subject only to the limitations imposed by
the governmental powers of taxation, expropriation, police power and escheat."
Appraisal of Real Estate (3rd Canadian edition)

Definition of market value


Market value is defined in the Appraisal of Real Estate (3rd Canadian edition) as: "The most probable price, as of a specified date, in
cash, or in terms equivalent to cash, or in other precisely revealed terms, for which the specified property rights should sell after
reasonable exposure in a competitive market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, with the buyer and seller each acting prudently,
knowledgeably, and for self-interest, and assuming that neither is under undue duress."

Effective date of appraisal

2020-08-01

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.6 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 6 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

ASSUMPTIONS AND LIMITING CONDITIONS

This report is subject to the following assumptions and limiting conditions.

1. Legal description is that which is recorded in the Registry or Land Title office and is assumed to be
correct.

2. Every effort has been made to verify the information received from others which is believed reliable and
correct.

3. Sketches, drawings, diagrams, photographs, etc., are included for the sole purpose of illustration and
serve to assist the reader in visualizing the property.

4. The distribution of land and building as stated in this report, apply only under the program of utilization
as identified in the report.

5.

6.

7.

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.7 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 7 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Regional and Area Analysis

Cut and Past Project 1 corrected Regional and Area into this report

The Neighborhood generally includes Single-family homes. Canada is a country with a huge amount
of pioneers from different countries in the world. Along these lines, the zone is a mix of people of
different establishments and besides local people. In spite of the way that a large number of
individuals living around there is Indian who particularly begins from the Punjab region of India.
Thusly, they have a spot with Sikh religion, and besides, there is Sikh Temple in the domain.

What's more, moreover, there are a lot of parks and play regions in the district. There is no issue of
school since it is masterminded at the corner of 39 Ave and 122 street that is just 5 min walk around
the branch of knowledge. The branch of knowledge is basically on Scott Road which is the busiest
road of Surrey. There is eminent travel organization all over town and the number of corner stores is
on the site. Furthermore, Scottsdale exchange is in like manner 10 min walk around the site and there
are number shops in the Strawberry incline. The cineplex film is also in strawberry slant and
distinctive Indian bistros, pizza shops, cafés are open in the zone

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.8 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 8 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Neighbourhood Analysis and Trends

Cut and Past Project 1 corrected Neighbourhood into this report

The subject’s neighbourhood is just


30-min drive from the Vancouver
International Airport. Also, all that's needed is 35 minutes to go to downtown. The Sky train Scott
Road station likewise open as a result of magnificent travel administration on Scott street. There is a
great deal of apartment suite units that is under development in the zone. Additionally, there are
multi-family living arrangements in the zone. In this way, these civilities influence the estimation of the
property

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.9 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 9 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Land Description and Analysis

Cut and Past Project 1 corrected Land Analysis into this report

The subject is found 120191 76 Avenue, Surrey. The property is looking towards. There is a rear
entryway route at the back which associates the house with the back garage. The subject is simply to
shut down of Scott street.

Positive highlights:

The subject property isn't arranged on Scott street as it is the busiest street so traffic clamor is
unimportant. The schools, play areas, and parks are not very close so unsettling influences won't
influence the occupants. The hydrant is simply in front of the house for fire insurance. The open bus
station is likewise a 5min stroll from the property. Likewise, the back rear entryway is extremely
helpful like for going into the house from the posterior and leaving vehicle in the back garage.
Likewise, there is free stopping out and about the front of the house. The strolling separation for strip
malls around the area isn't over 10 minutes.

Negative highlights:
The subject property has a Rancher style and no storm cellar. Additionally, it needs carport for
leaving of the vehicle in winter day off.

Upgrades:
The garage need to be constructed for assurance of vehicle in the winter season. Also, there is no
toy space for children

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.10 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 10 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790
The subject's evaluation is reasonable.
As the subject's neighborhood is found
simply close to the Scott street and 10 min
stroll from Strawberry slope court and
Scottsdale trade. The property has great
deal enhancements like parks, play areas,
school, and so on. The open bus station is
only a 5-minute stroll from the subject
property. The cineplex is at the 10-minute
walk. The malls comprise of different
Grocery stores like Walmart, Superstore,
Tropicana, and so on.; Pizza shops;
cafés and number of corner stores and
vehicle washers. As a result of all
enhancements accessible in the zone so
showcase worth would likewise be higher.

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.11 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 11 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Official Community Plan (OCP) and Zoning

Cut and Past Project 1 corrected OCP & Zoning into this report

The subject property is located at 12091 76 Ave, Surrey and prop descriptions is LOT- 37 SECTION-
19 TOWNSHIP 2 PLAN NWP-20991- NWD. According to city of Surrey this property is scheduled as
RF that means Single Family Residential Zone. 2

The property is zoned as RF which are certain building maxima, minima showed in Surrey Zoning By-
law 120003. The provisions of single-family residential property are listed in part 16.
Max floor Maximu Parking spaces
area ratio m units
Main Yard(minimum)
building
height
Front Rear Side Side
Yard yard on
flanking
street
0.70 7.7m 7.7m 1.9m 3.7m 8m 4

2
https://cosmos.surrey.ca/external/

3
https://www.surrey.ca/bylawsandcouncillibrary/BYL_Zoning_12000.pdf
Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.12 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 12 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.13 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 13 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790
DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS
DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING
Dimensions 7.7M X 7.7M Area 1,425 Type/style Single Year Built 1966
Foundation [ ] Poured concrete [ ] Concrete blocks [ ] Concrete posts [ ] Wood posts

Framing [ X ] Wood [ ] Concrete [ ] Steel [ ]

Basement [X ] Full [ ] Partial [ ] None [ ] Slab


[ ] Crawl space

Basement Finish
Exterior Walls Brick veneer Clapboard 90% Stucco Siding: Vinyl
(percentage) Wood

Stone veneer Aluminum Solid masonry Aluminum

Roof [ X ] Asphalt shingles [ ] Wood shingles or shake [ ] Slate [ ] Clay/tile


[ ] Built-up tar & gravel [ ] Gutters & down spouts [ ]

Interior Walls [ X ] Dry wall [ ] Plaster [ ] Paneling: type

Floor Coverings Above ground Carpet Tile Ceramic Hardwood 70% Linoleum
(percentage) Basement Carpet Tile Linoleum Other

Fireplaces Number: 1 Location: Living room Type: wood


[ ] Built-in range
Kitchen [ X ] Built-in dishwasher [ X ] Garburator
and oven
[ ] Exhaust fan [X ] Vent hood
Cabinets - type and material: Wood and clay Quality good

Counter material: Other features

Fixtures: Quality good

Electricity No. of amps: 74 [ ] Circuit breakers [X ] Fuses

Plumbing Pipes [ ] Copper [ ] Galvanized [ ] Mixed


Hot water tank [ ] Electricity [ ] Gas [ ] Oil Capacity:

Connections [ ] Washer [ ] Dishwasher [ ]

Drainage [ ] Plastic [ ] Galvanized [ ]

Heating [ X ] Forced air [ ] Hot Water [ ] Steam [ ]


[ ] Oil fired [ ] Gas fired [ ] Electric [ ] Humidifier

Air Conditioning [ ] Yes [ X ] No [ ] Central Swimming pool [ ] Yes Type:


NONE
Garage [ X ] Single [ ] Double [ ] Attached [ X ] Detached [ ] None
[ ] Carport [ ] Electricity [ ] Heated [ ] Interior finish

Type of construction:

Flooring: Dimensions: Area: 60M

Porch [X ] Open [ ] Screened [ ] Enclosed Size:2M X 1.5M [ ] None

Patio/Deck [ ] Concrete [ ] Wood [ ] Size: [ X ] None

Rental Equip. [ ] Water softener [ ] Hot water tank [ ] Furnace [ ] [X ] None

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.14 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 14 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS (continued)


Please identify each room with an “X”, or if more than one, indicate with a number
Room List Foyer Living Dining Kitchen Den Family Bedrooms No. Baths Laundry Other
Basement N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Room
N/A N/A N/A 0
1st Level N/A 1 1 1 N/A 3 3 2 1
2nd Level

Finished area above grade contains a total area of Rooms 158.5 Bedrooms 3 Baths2
150.5 M2
Finished basement area contains a total area of rooms bedrooms baths

Bathroom location Description of fixtures installed


Right beside the bedroom Shower, Bathtub, toilet, sink

*Comments required Good Average Fair Poor*


Energy efficiency and insulation level [ ] [X ] [ ] [ ]
Quality of construction (materials and finish) [ X] [ ] [ ] [ ]
Condition of improvements [ ] [ X] [ ] [ ]
Rooms size and layout [ ] [ ] [ X] [ ]
Plumbing – adequacy and condition [ ] [X ] [ ] [ ]
Electrical – adequacy and condition [ ] [ X] [ ] [ ]
Kitchen cabinets – adequacy and condition [ ] [ ] [X ] [ ]
Compatibility to neighbourhood [X ] [ ] [ ] [ ]
Overall livability [ ] [ X] [ ] [ ]
Appeal and marketability [ ] [X ] [ ] [ ]
Additional features

Recent modernization, renovation, and major repairs

NONE

Site improvements

[ ] Driveway [ ] Paved [ ] Gravel [ ] Concrete Area:


[ X ] Fence [ ] Wood [ ] Chain link [ ] Length: Height:
38M 93 CM
[ ] Landscaping Description
[ ] Other Describe

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.15 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 15 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS: OBSERVED DEPRECIATION

Condition of Building
Physical Depreciation - Curable

• N/A. No components on the structure have reached the end of their economic lives

Physical Depreciation - Incurable


Short-lived:

• Roofing & Exterior


Both have not been updated with the interior of the home; both are in good working order and still
serving their intended purposes.

Long-lived:
Age concept No. of years
Chronological age 58 yrs.
Effective age 43 yrs.
Economic life 60 yrs.
Remaining economic life 19 yrs.

Justification of Effective Age and Economic Life:

Eff Age: Half part interior of the home has been remodeled in 2007.. The subject property is fair
maintained in general. As a result, the effective age of 43 years is a fair and reasonable estimate.
Ec Life: Assume structure will reasonably last another 19 years before significant depreciation.

Functional Obsolescence

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.16 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 16 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

N/A

External Obsolescence

N/A

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.17 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 17 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

HIGHEST AND BEST USE ESTIMATE

Definition
Highest and best use is defined in the text Appraisal of Real Estate (3rd Canadian edition) as "the reasonably probable
and legal use of vacant land or an improved property that is physically possible, legally permissible, appropriately
supported, financially feasible, and that results in the highest value".

Analysis and support of highest and best use of the site, as if vacant
Full Discussion of all four Tests in this report

The zoning is in Rf which is single home residential zone and is not going to change in future
With the current zoning RF

if this site in question were vacant, the highest and best use would be constructing another single-family dwelling on it

Discussion of adequacy of the existing improvement(s)


Full Discussion of all four Tests in this report

The site has been constructed to be a single-family detached dwelling with total building area of 1,452 sq. ft include
garage. The site has been improved with 1 story, wood frame and concrete foundation. The current development of
the site is in fully conformed with the RF zoning and is, therefore legally permissible.

The current property has been moderate maintained. Walls and ceilings have been well kept. The hardwood floor
on main floor had been installed while vinyl for the basement. There is no indication in the neighborhood that any
major redevelopment is occurring.

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.18 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 18 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Conclusion and support of highest and best use as improved

The improvements of the subject site proved to be physically possible, legally permissible, and maximally productive.
They are also conformed to the neighborhood’s OCP. As a result, the highest and best use of the subject property is,
as improved, with single family dwelling.

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.19 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 19 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH - LAND VALUE

Data Comparison Chart


Item Subject Comparable no. 1 Comparable no. 2 Comparable no. 3
Address 12091 76 Ave 7309 123rd 12081 76th 7289 123rd
St, Surrey, BC Ave, Surrey, BC St, Surrey, BC
V3W 9J2 V3W 2T3 V3W 9J2
Legal description LOT- 37 LOT- 32 LOT- 65 LOT- 72
SECTION-19 SECTION-15 SECTION-29 SECTION-
TOWNSHIP 2 TOWNSHIP 3 TOWNSHIP 4 32TOWNSHIP 2
PLAN NWP- PLAN NWP- PLAN NWP- PLAN NWP-
20991- NWD 30991- NWD 50998- NWD 40995- NWD
Sale date 2007 4/11/2009 6/08/2016 4/03/2014

Instrument no. N/A N/A N/A N/A

Registration date N/A N/A N/A N/A

Vendor N/A N/A N/A N/A

Purchaser N/A N/A N/A N/A

Sale price 440,000 999,000 1,650,000 980,000

Right conveyed Fee simple Freehold Freehold Freehold

Financing N/A N/A N/A N/A

Conditions of sale N/A N/A N/A N/A

Expenses made N/A N/A N/A N/A


immediately after purchase

Time difference (mos) 0 4 5 6

Zoning RF RF RF RF
rd th
Location ELLIOT AND 76 AVE Arlington st and 123 ave 12081 76 street 7289 123rd street

Frontage/depth 7.7m X7.7m 15m X 8m 12.7 m X 7.5m 15 m X 7m

Lot area 493 m2 495m2 478m2 482m2

Topography No elevation or waterbed No elevation or waterbed No elevation or waterbed No elevation or waterbed

Utilities Sewage, hydro, natural Sewage, hydro, natural Sewage, hydro, natural Sewage, hydro, natural
gas gas gas gas

Interior/corner lot Interior Interior Interior Interior

Local Improvement N/A N/A N/A N/A


Charges

Easements/Rights of Way N/A N/A N/A N/A

Other comments Not listed for sale at the Traffic facing towards 123rd None None
moment ave

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.20 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 20 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.21 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 21 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH - LAND VALUE (continued)

Adjustment Chart
Item Comparable no. 1 Comparable no. 2 Comparable no. 3
Sale price 999,000 1650,000 980,000

Real property rights conveyed adjustment yes yes yes

Adjusted price 0 0 0

Financing adjustment N/A N/A N/A

Conditions of sale adjustment Arm’s length Arm’s length Arm’s length

Expenses made immediately after purchase adjustment N/A N/A N/A

Adjusted price 0 0 0

Date of sale adjustment 511 783 935

Adjusted price 998,000 168,000 967,000

Other adjustments as required:

- Zoning RF RF RF

- Location NONE NONE NONE

- Frontage/depth Similar similar similar

- Lot area 14,180 60870 63,879

- Topography good good good

- Utilities similar similar similar

- Interior/corner lot similar similar similar

- Local Improvement Charges n/a n/a n/a

- Easements/Rights of Way n/a n/a n/a

Total Other Adjustments 39,000 67,000 70,000

Final Adjusted Sale Price 1,230,000 1,679,000 1,930,000

Adjusted unit sale price / frontage OR 97,109 78,000 98,000

Adjusted unit sale price / area 2,800 3,900 3,116

For reconciliation purposes: 116,650

246,243 71,327

Total Adjustment

Total adjustment as % of Sale Price -5.68% 7.5% -4.6%

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.22 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 22 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH - LAND VALUE (continued)

Adjustment Analysis in Order: 1. Property Rights 2. Financing 3. Motivation 4. Expenses made


immediately after purchase 5. Time 6. Other

Assumptions:
1. There is no adjustment for (1) Property Rights, (2) Financing, (3) Motivation, (4) Expenses made immediately
after purchase.

2. Financing: To the best of my knowledge, no financing methods were used

3. Motivation: To the best of my knowledge, all sales were made at arm’s length and no other motivations were
evident.

4. Expenses made immediately after purchase: To the best of my knowledge, there were no expenses made
immediately after purchase.

5. Date of sale: Comparable 1, 2, 3. Adjustment has been made for 3 dates of sale.

6. Other: Adjustment has been made for Frontage and Lot area for 3 comparable.

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.23 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 23 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.24 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 24 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH - LAND VALUE (continued)

Reconciliation

Range:

Closest comparable: Comp 1 7309 76th ave with sale price of $ 999,000 with gross adjustment of -5.68%% while
Comp 2 address 12081 76th Ave with an adjustment of 7.5%. The range will be $1,650,000 – 1,890,000. However,
due to the net adjustment of Comp 3 being -4.6% compared to 2 others comparable, will go within higher range closer
to adjusted sale price of Comp 3.

Final Estimate of Site Value: $ 440,000


Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.25 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 25 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.26 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 26 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH – COST ANALYSIS OF IMPROVEMENTS


Reproduction Cost New (RCN) Estimate
Cost Manual (name): Cost to build LLC ( www.costtobuild.net) [ X ] Worksheet and excerpts attached

as Schedule ___

RCN estimate $235,139

Contractors: Name and Address RCN Estimate

$235,139

RCN conclusion and rationale:


Subtotal: 235,139 $

Extras (state source):


(not included in above RCN estimate)

Attached deck/patio $ N/A


Porches $N/A
Attached garage/car port $38.312
Basement finish $ N/A
$
$
$
Subtotal: $273,451

Total Reproduction Cost New of Building(s) $549,390

Site Improvements: (see


PROP1005.9)

Item Cost New Age/Life Depreciated Value


Landscaping $7,980 N/A/ $7,980
Fencing $786 20/40 $392
$ / $
$ / $
$ / $
$ / $
$ / $

Total Depreciated Value of Site Improvements $6,546

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.27 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 27 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH – DEPRECIATION

Age-Life Method
Item RCN Effective Age Economic Life % Dep. Accrued
Depreciation
235,139 19 years 60 years 30% 73,193
Single 38,312 19 years 60 years 30% 14,790
Garage

Total $273,451 $87,983

Description of process applied and justification of estimate:

To estimate the subject property’s replacement cost new (RCN), the cost services method is implemented in this report.
Cost To Build LLC. (A free on-line service which provides an estimate building cost summary) is used to get the RCN
estimate for the subject property. The cost summary sheet with a detailed calculation can be found in the addendum of
this report. Cost to build per square foot equal $246/square foot ($273,451 / 1,111 sq.ft = $267 / square foot).

The cost manual estimated by a local contractor is also useful in order to get the cost estimate for the subject building. In
this report, the cost manual estimate is assumed to be close to $246/square feet. As a results, Total Replacement Cost
New of Building is $273,451

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.28 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 28 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

COST APPROACH – SUMMARY

REPRODUCTION COST NEW $349,877

Less Total Depreciation $170,832

DEPRECIATED COST OF BUILDING(S) $6,746


Plus Depreciated Site Improvements $448,000
Plus Site Value $
VALUE INDICATED BY COST APPROACH $528,000

Rounded to: $530,000

Cost Approach Conclusion: Market Value = $530,000

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.29 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 29 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790
DIRECT COMPARISON APPROACH
Data Comparison Chart
Item Subject Property Comparable No. 4 Comparable No. 5 Comparable No. 6
Address 12091 76 Ave 7309 123rd 12081 76th 7289 123rd
Legal description LOT- 37 SECTION-19 LOT- 32 SECTION-15 LOT- 65 SECTION-29 LOT- 72 SECTION-
TOWNSHIP 2 PLAN TOWNSHIP 3 PLAN TOWNSHIP 4 PLAN 32TOWNSHIP 2 PLAN
Sale date N/A 4/11/2009 6/08/2016 4/03/2014
Instrument no. N/A N/A N/A N/A
Registration date N/A N/A N/A N/A
Vendor N/A N/A N/A N/A
Purchaser N/A N/A N/A N/A
Sale Price N/A 999,000 1,650,000 980,000
Rights conveyed Fee Simple Freehold Freehold Freehold
Financing N/A N/A N/A N/A
Conditions of sale N/A N/A N/A N/A
Expenses made immediately N/A N/A N/A N/A
after purchase
Time difference (mos.) 0 3 3 5
Distance from subject 0 0 1 4
(blocks)
Location
Bldg size (above grade) 493 m2 495 m2 467 m2 463 m2
Type/Quality Construction Wood frame, concrete Wood frame, concrete per Wood frame , stucco ext Wood frame , stucco ext
per
Energy efficiency Okay. asphalt shingles Okay. asphalt shingles Okay. asphalt shingles Okay. asphalt shingles
Design and appeal Clean landscape, old ext Clean landscape, old ext Clean landscape, old ext Clean landscape, old ext
Age 60 57 55 66
Condition good good good good
Room Count Ttl Bds Bth Ttl Bds Bth Ttl Bds Bth Ttl Bds Bth
6 5 2 7 4 2 8 5 2 9 4 2
Basement unfinished area
Basement/finished below
grade area
Air conditioning N/A N/A N/A N/A
Heating natural gas natural gas natural gas natural gas
Fireplace wood wood wood wood
Appliances assume standard assume standard assume standard assume standard
Lot size
Zoning
Garage/carport
Local Improvement Charges

Other comments:

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.30 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 30 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

DIRECT COMPARISON APPROACH (continued)

Item Comparable no. 4 Comparable no. 5 Comparable no. 6


Sale price 999,000 1,650,000 980,000
Real property rights conveyed adjustment N/A N/A N/A
Adjusted price 0 0 0
Financing adjustment N/A N/A N/A
Conditions of sale adjustment Assume arm’s length Assume arm’s length Assume arm’s length
Expenses made immediately after purchase adjustment N/A N/A N/A
Adjusted price 0 0 0
Date of sale adjustment (2,940) (3,490) (758)
Adjusted price 1,467,060 1,741,510 1,817,242
Other adjustments as required: similar similar
- Location

- Building size 1,305 (3,781) 2,752


- Construction similar similar similar
- Energy efficiency similar similar similar
- Design and appeal similar similar similar
- Age similar similar similar
- Condition similar similar similar
- Room count 15,360 similar 5,467
- Basement unfinished area similar similar similar
- Basement/finished below grade area 20,460 (19,360) 18,920
- Air conditioning assume standard assume standard assume standard
- Heating similar similar similar
- Fireplace similar similar similar
- Appliances similar similar similar
- Lot size similar (104,320) (291,732)
- Zoning RF RF RF
- Garage/carport 15,000 similar similar
- Local Improvement Charges 0 0 0
-

Total Other Adjustments 52,125 (127,461) (264,593)

Final Adjusted Sale Price 1,519,185 1,614,049 1,552,649

For reconciliation purposes:

Total Adjustment
55,065 130,951 319,629
Total Net Adjustment as % of Sale Price 3.7% -7.5% -17.6%
Total Gross Adjustment as % of Sale Price 3.3% 7.5% 14.5%

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.31 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 31 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Adjustment Analysis in Order: 1. Property Rights 2. Financing 3. Motivation 4. Expenses made


immediately after purchase 5. Time 6. Other

1.Property Rights: All were fee simple/freehold

2.Financing: To the best of my knowledge, no financing methods were used

3.Motivation: To the best of my knowledge, all sales were made at arm’s length and no other motivations
were evident.

4.Expenses made immediately after purchase: To the best of my knowledge, there were not expenses made
immediately after purchase.

5.Time: Based on our research through REBGV latest News Release (Real Estate Board Greater
Vancouver), single family detached in SURREY East has change -0.8% by 3 months. Comparable 1 and 2
were sold , then multiplied by 0.0020 ((3:12) x 0.008) applied. Comparable 3 sold 5 months ago, there is an
adjustment -1%, then multiplied by 0,041 ((5:12) x 0.01)

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.32 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 32 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Page of pages

DIRECT COMPARISON APPROACH (continued)

Adjustment Analysis (continued)


Other adjustments

Subject and all three comparable had suite in the lower level. No adjustments were made due to not knowing
if the owner/tenants of comparable are using the suites for rental potential and income.

Page of pages

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.33 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 33 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

DIRECT COMPARISON APPROACH (continued)

Reconciliation

Closest comparable: Comp 4 address 7289 123 RD AVE Ave with final adjusted sale price of
$498,000 with gross adjustment 4.6%.

Direct Comparison Approach Conclusion: $567,000

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.34 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 34 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

RECONCILIATION OF VALUE INDICATIONS AND FINAL ESTIMATE OF VALUE

Indicated value by Cost Approach $ 497,000

Indicated value by Direct Comparison Approach $ 523,000

The difference between the two approaches is 119,665.


Due to the highest and best use being deemed to have the existing improvement and site as is, the
market value for the subject property will be in the higher range between $450,000 to 550,000the
latter being the Direct Comparison Approach which involved sales comparable of properties that
included improvements

The Market Value, as defined, for the subject property as of 2020-08-01


(Date)
is estimated to be $523,000

The exposure time for the subject property has been estimated at 539,000 .

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.35 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 35 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.36 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 36 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

CERTIFICATION

I certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief:

 the reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity
with the requirements of the code of Professional Ethics and the Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.

 the statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct.

 the reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions,
and are my personal, unbiased professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions.

 I have no present or prospective interest in the property that is the subject of this report, and I have no personal
interest or bias with respect to the parties involved.

 my compensation is not contingent upon the reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favours the
cause of the client, the amount of the value estimate, the attainment of a stipulated result, or the occurrence of a
subsequent event.

 I have made a personal inspection of the property that is the subject of this report, located at
, on 12091 76TH Avenue, surrey, BC .

 no one provided significant professional assistance to the person signing this report.

 the final estimate of market value, as of 2020-08-01 is estimated to be:


(Date)

528,000
($ )

Signature of Student Date Signed

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.37 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 37 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790

ADDENDA

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.38 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 38 of 41
PROP1005: Project No. 2
Name: Imran Mohammed
Student Number: 100354790
PROP1005

Last

1 Braybrooks

2 Contreras Garduno

3 Dhillon

4 Dhillon

6 Garikipati

7 Hoang

8 Jain

9 Kuo

10 Moru

11 Naraghi

12 Nguyen

13 Singh

14 Singh

15 Lam

Base form Provided by UBC Sauder School of Business - BUSI 330.39 (v2.0 03_2020) Page 39 of 41

You might also like