Augmentation and Rehabilitation of UWSS for JHALAWAR Town

Observations of PDMC

Sr. Referen Details Observation Compliances

No. ce Of Observations
1 DPR- The water The total demand for design DPR has been revised as per Ex E
Jhalawar balance years – intermediate and PHED.
WS calculations are ultimate stage, and how this
not clear demand will be met from
different sources and
adequacy of transmission
system to be given in the
report.
3.10. Though this Please check the statement Updated in Revised DPR
SERVICE service delivery
ADEQUA is much high…
CY &
KEY
ISSUES

3.11. The distribution In ADB funded, RUIDP Considered in DPR -AMRUT

DISTRIB system has not project whether Distribution
UTION been updated, system was laid?
SYSTEM designed and
augmented
symmetrically
after first
execution.
8.2. Some of the Which zones are to be Already clarified in schematic Dia
SOURCE zones shall be considered to be supplied and updated in revised report also.
OF fed from Chhapi from each source may be
WATER Water Supply given.
SUPPLY Project and the
remaining zones
shall get water
from the Pipa Ji
Ki Deh.
Whether scheme for bulk The bulk water system is not sanct
The existing water supply system for but the reservation of water in the
sources of water 2045 demand is already reservoir is sanctioned. the sanctio
supply would be sanctioned? reservoir would be needed beyond
sufficient up till year 2026 so that it can be constru
the year 2031 To justify laying of and commissioned before the year
only. distribution system and Bulk water system is developed in
Beyond this year construction of OHSRs for modular way, especially when it is
bulk water ultimate demand, the source brought from different sources.
supply is assurance shall be The distribution system is designe
Sr. Referen Details Observation Compliances
No. ce Of Observations
proposed to be ascertained. Years Horizon as digging along th
augmented from and right of way is always a proble
Rajgarh Dam
where
reservation of 10
MCM water
exists for
Jhalawar Town
2 Annexure Estimate for The Rate per ML is shown in For complete WT P, we are adopti
CE 03 Construction Of (Rs.) it should be in Rs. In of around Rs 30 Lacs per ML, Sin
Page 1 of WTP Lacs Administration building and mach
43 SOR Reference for rate rooms are already built up at a red
considered to be given. rate of Rs 22 Lacs per ML has bee
Since the WTP is using adopted.
some units of old WTP
whether reduced rates are
applicable? If so detailed
rate analysis may be
provided.
Since, this Rate is inclusive
of SCADA and PLC as per
item description, the
provisions in Estimate for
Instrumentation. Automation
and Scada on page 31/32 of
43 for new WTP part shall
be rechecked and corrected.
3 Estimate for
Providing
Proposed Rising
Mains
Page 2 of Excavation Hard rock considered as The strata in excavation has been a
43 70%. Bore log data to be as below:
attached in DPR for the basis (i) All type of soil : 30%
considered for strata. L (ii) Ordinary Rock : 40%
section of rising main to be (iii) Hard Rock : 30%
provided. The above % is based on the obser
made and local enquiry about the o
excavation done during the laying
laying of pipe line in the past.
Page 4 of Item 11 No 350 dia. proposed for This is the weiged average width a
43 Deduction of Rising main. depth of the trench for diff. sizes o
pipe qty 350 Please give details of
mm dia dimensions considered for
finding out qty as
0.664x0.591.

Page 5 of Item 19 Plunger References for rates may be RUIDP Approved Rates
Sr. Referen Details Observation Compliances
No. ce Of Observations
43 valve given. Tonk Project
Approved makes may be
mentioned.
Page 6 of Item 20,21,22 References for rates may be Updated in Revised Report
43 given
Page 6 of GRAND It should be for Rising Main Updated in Revised Report
43 TOTAL instead of FOR
DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM
4 Estimate for
Providing
Proposed
Internal Water
Distribution
System Using
HDPE & DI
pipe
Page 9 of Pipe length 167.96 km pipe length is Distribution Designs and Estimate
43 provided whereas per been updated in the revised DPR.
modeling, the length is The new development are not kn
155.497 Km as per sheet 95 present and it is proposed to take l
of 107 Table 32, Adding dia. 10% extra.
10% for all diameters cannot
be justified. The additional
length should have been
marked on drawing and
hydraulic designs should
have been done for entire
system. In fact, as the
distribution system layout is
to be developed for 2045, the
terminal pipelines can be
laid later on.

Estimate is done
considering, DI Pipes
1,20,752 M (71%) And
HDPE pipes are
considered 47210 M (29%)
for total 167692 M.

Whereas Hydraulic
modeling/Design is done
considering DI Pipes -10254
M(6.6%) and HDPE pipes
145254 M (73.4%)and total
155499 M.

It is stated that the variation

Sr. Referen Details Observation Compliances
No. ce Of Observations
is proposed considering,
town has 20%-30% rock
strata and excessive traffic
on some road stretches,
considering possible damage
to pipes due to recurrent
excavation.

The Hydraulic design should

be done for proposed type of
pipes and exact area maps
where DI pipes are proposed
should be marked justifying
the provision..

The revisions in designs

and estimates may be
required which may
reduce estimated cost.

Page 11 of Scour valve There is no provision of It is revised accordingly.

43 chambers scour valves but chambers
are provided. Please clarify.
5 Page 14 of Estimate for Quotations for market rates Market rates already submitted to
43 Providing to be attached with Estimate. HQ.
Consumer RAs to be attached. The No.
Meters And of Proposed HSCs to be
House Service confirmed, considering
Connections RUIDP has recently done the
project in which HSCs are
also considered.
6 Estimate for References for rates adopted List attached in revised estimate
Pumping to be mentioned with Item
machinery and No., Page No.
Other Spare parts are considered at
Electromechani 25% cost.
cal Equipments List of spare parts may be
given. For Market rates,
quotations may be attached.

7 Estimate for References for rates/R.A.s LS rates given after Market Survey
Construction and details for L.S. rates Rate Analysis
Of New may be attached with
Pumping estimates.
Stations, Other
Buildings,
Campus
Development
Sr. Referen Details Observation Compliances
No. ce Of Observations
Works,
Boundary Wall
Around New
Campuses And
Repair/Rehabil
itation of
Existing Pump
Houses
8 Rehabilitation Details of qty calculations Attached in revised estimate
of SE, Ex. En, and references for rates to be
AEN & Other provided
Existing
Buildings
9 Estimate for Quotations for market rates Attached in Updated estimate
Instrumentatio to be attached
n. Automation
and Scada
10 Estimate for References for rates to be Updated in revised estimate
Construction provided.
Of 11/.43 KV
Electric
SubStation
And Dedicated
Power Feeders
11 Estimate for References for rates to be Market Rate
Rehabilitation provided.
Work at
CHAPI
HEADWORKS