PENDING COMMENTS ON MEPF( 40 Nos)
Services : PHE(14 Nos)
Sr. Design Basis Report./
No. Drawing
in flushing water however in father STP Treated water is available ,
General Comments for DBR
1 BMS system.
( To be add in DBR )
be directly connected with flushing pipeline. Tentative drawing for
in flushing water however in father STP Treated water is available ,
Drawing no. S-263/P/CC/028
2 access STP treated water will be available then it will be provided
Drawing no. S-263/P/CC/029
be directly connected with flushing pipeline. Tentative drawing for
Provide Garbage shaft should be 1500mm x 800mm in all
floors till terrace level.
3 Two vertical chutes each of 500 mm dia has been shown in Provide Garbage shaft should be 1500mm x 800mm in all
AWCS - Drawing
Provide Drawing - AWCS routing, plan & setioOkl details along
with tunnel section and levels
4 Provide Drawing - AWCS routing, plan & setioOkl details
5 DBR / Page No. 121 / 122
Comments from PDA (14-03-2023)
Source of flushing water is also provide by GIFTCL for flushing
purpose uses , at preset GIFTCL is provide domestic water for use
it is provided by GIFTCL. Need to incorporate piping work for
flushing water distribution. Schematic drawing to be part of DBR.
Kindly provide the Motorized valve in water inlet from GIFTCL
which should operate according to the level of UG Tank and
control by developer's BMS. This should automatically open and
close based on tank level and prevent any over flow from the
tank. To control the same, tank shall be equipped with Level
transmitter, Level switch (Hard wired with Motorized Inlet valve)
and Mechanical protection (Over flow protection). Along with
that, At present GIFT is providing only domestic water. In future if
access STP treated water will be available then it will be provided 3) Connection to GIFT SCADA will be provided through
to developer at tunnel end and for that developer has to make
necessary arrangement. At present developer have to connect
their flushing tank with domestic water pipeline having valve
arrangement. So in future when STP treated water if available can 5) UV and online monitoring system will be provided as per
the arrangement is attached herewith for the ready reference.
The UG Tank Level transmitter, Level switch and Motorized Valve
Open/Close feedback sigOkl shall be connected to GIFTCL SCADA
network for monitoring purpose only.
Specification regarding AWCS system are not provided in the DBR.
Kindly incorporate as per the ready reckoner of solid waste
Please provide UV System and Online water parameter
Monitoring System ( For TDS/PH/HARDNESS/Turbidity ) for
domestic water distribution line.
1. Please add UV System and online metering system in domestic
line distribution at terrace level.
2. Any specific reason for flushing booster pump at terrace level.
3. Please incorporate pipe MOC with grade.
4. Source of flushing water is also provide by GIFTCL for flushing
purpose uses , at preset GIFTCL is provide domestic water for use
it is provided by GIFTCL. Need to incorporate piping work for
flushing water distribution.
Kindly provide the Motorized valve in water inlet from GIFTCL
which should operate according to the level of UG Tank and
control by developer's BMS. This should automatically open and
close based on tank level and prevent any over flow from the
tank. To control the same, tank shall be equipped with Level
transmitter, Level switch (Hard wired with Motorized Inlet valve)
and Mechanical protection (Over flow protection). Along with
that, At present GIFT is providing only domestic water. In future if
to developer at tunnel end and for that developer has to make
necessary arrangement. At present developer have to connect
their flushing tank with domestic water pipeline having valve
arrangement. So in future when STP treated water if available can 6) The diameter of uptake pipe is specified in the submitted
the arrangement is attached herewith for the ready reference.
The UG Tank Level transmitter, Level switch and Motorized Valve
Open/Close feedback sigOkl shall be connected to GIFTCL SCADA
network for monitoring purpose only.
Specification regarding AWCS system are not provided in the DBR.
Kindly incorporate as per the ready reckoner of solid waste
Please provide UV System and Online water parameter
Monitoring System ( For TDS/PH/HARDNESS/Turbidity ) for
domestic water distribution line.
5. Please add irrgation line .
6. Tank filling pipe dia need to incorporate.
Basement Floor Plan
Response from ATOMEP (06-04-2023)
1) Schematic drawing is incorporated in DBR.
2) Distribution arrangement as per GIFTCL philosophy is
incorporated in schematic.
4) AWCS Specifications to be followed as per GIFTCL
ready reckoner.
GIFTCL ready reckoner.
1) Refer response in comment number 11.
2) Refer response in comment number 43.
3) Refer response in comment number 9.
4) Refer response in comment number 11.
5) The proposed landscape areas are very nomiOkl.
Distributory supply will be planned from nearest flushing
line as the landscape water requirement has been
incorporated in the water demend sheet.
schematic layouts.
the drawing as per the GIFTCL guideline.
Refer response in comment number 33.
Use Varifocal Camera in Corridor instead of Dome
Camera
PDA REPLY-17.04.2023
1. Noted.
2. Noted.
3 Noted.
4. Noted
5.Noted.
Noted.
floors till terrace level in drawing
Communicated to GIFTCL
along with tunnel section and levels
Communicated to GIFTCL
1. As per above clraity , Flush valve is used for the project hecne
Please change the dual flush cistern to flush valve .
2. Material Selection : Please check below remark and update
table accordingly.
For Water Supply :
a) Add Note : All Pipe dia as per NB Size.
b) CPVC SDR11 upto 50mm and Above 50mm Sch40 or sch80 As
per your calculation to be update.
c) Again check upvc sch80 Pipe for OHT Application. GI / PPR
Pipes is okay from our side.
d) Please add PPR-C Pipes grade
e) Hot Water Line to be insulated. Add description for the same.
f) Add jointing method Pipes.
For DraiOkge System :
a) Please mention grade of SWR Pipes .
b) SWR Pipes Availble upto 160mm. Please check for upper dia
MOC , As per drawing 300mm dia pipes shown in basement
lines.
c) Please add PP Pipes EN/IS Code .
d) PPR Pipes not recommeded for draiOkge application or
Please mention IS Code.
e)" Basin, shower, etc. waste pipes up-to p-trap / floor trap /
stack" For this Please check SWR Pipes available in 40mm
Response from ATOMEP (27-04-2023) PDA Reply_15-05-2023
Point 1 & 2:
The description related to the Water Distribution arrangement is
not properly marked in the DBR, Few Keywords are missing in it
(refer to page no. 105 of 160).
&
Ok
Also, the mentioned water schematic drawing in DBR is not
visible/readable at all. Instead of the entire layout, developer
should mention the portion only that has been provided by GIFTCL.
(Tentative drawing of the arrangement has been Shared with you
multiple times in the previous mail)
Point 4: Comment number 11 is related to DBR & this comment is
related to Water schematic Layout & Drawing.
In the received Autocad file of Water schematic Layout, you have
mentioned the required details outside the layout. GIFTCL has
Ok provided the drawing to you for reference only, based on that
Developer has to mark all the mentioned components (level
Transmitter, Level Switch, Motorized & manual valves) of the water
schematic at the respective locations (such as underground water
tanks and main incoming pipeline).
Noted
Noted
1.Water Supply Pipe MOC Not update as per comments.
2. Drainage MOC not update complelty as per comments. Please
1. Writeup udated. correct.
2.Material and valve PN rating updated 3. What is PPMD ?
4. Valve description is change completely as per earlier comments. eleminated, however probability of multiple small pipe
Please add proper description of each type of valve.
Response from ATOMEP (23-05-2023) PDA Reply_05-06-2023
Previously closed comment reopened. Schematic and
description has been updated as per the GIFTCL Provide revised drawing as per comments dated 15.05.2023
reckoner.
Previously closed comment reopened, typical
connection layout has been detailed as per GIFT
Provide revised drawing as per comments dated 15.05.2023
ready reckoner. Typical connection details are
sufficient for understanding.
Please provide the revised drawing as per the mail
communication dated 17.05.2023. Mail is attached herewith for
your reference.
Ok
Please provide the revised drawing as per the mail
communication dated 17.05.2023. Mail is attached herewith for
your reference.
Ok
To standardize the MOC, we have provided the
currently in-use materials. However, if better piping
materials are available in the future then the same
maybe explored and taken into consideration.
Water Supply point:
a) Add Note : All Pipe dia as per NB Size.: Page 122
last point
b) CPVC SDR11 upto 50mm and Above 50mm Sch40
or sch80 As per your calculation to be update: Sch40
for >50mm pipes
c) Again check upvc sch80 Pipe for OHT Application.
GI / PPR Pipes is okay from our side : GI has been
finalised.
d) Please add PPR-C Pipes grade: PPR-C has been
eliminated.
e) Hot Water Line to be insulated. Add description for Water Supply Points :
the same: Individual geysers are planned with a) Noted.
B) Noted. We recommeded Use Sch 80 fitting along with Sch 40
concealed pipes.
Pipes instead of Sch40 fitting for better strenght .
f) Add jointing method Pipes: Will be finalised after
c) Noted
material selection. d) Noted.
E) Noted. Insulation to be considered or not , Please confirm.
Drainage Point:
F) Material Type already mentioned in DBR
a) Please mention grade of SWR Pipes: SWR pipes hecne jointing Method is part of DBR.
has been eleminated. Drainage Points :
b) SWR Pipes Availble upto 160mm. Please check for a) Noted.
upper dia MOC , As per drawing 300mm dia pipes
b) Explaination not clear and not acceptable. "probability of
shown in basement lines: SWR pipes has been
multiple small pipe will be evaluated at the procurement
stage based on material availability."
will be evaluated at the procurement stage based on c) PP Pipes showing in DBR as a drainage MOC. Please check and
material availability. correct the statements.

5 DBR / Page No. 121 / 122
6 Drawing no. S-263/P/CC/021
Drawing No. S-263/P/CC/029 & 028
7 5.UV system has been updated with online monitoring
8 Drawing No. S-263/P/CC/001
9 Drawing No.S-263/H/CC/025
10 DBR / Page No. 107
11 DBR / Page No. 109
12 DBR / Page No. 107
13 DBR / Page No. 119
14 DBR / Page No. 120
Sr. Design Basis Report./
No. Drawing
1 HVAC layout
2 Page 23 - DBR
3 Page 28 - DBR
Use Varifocal Camera in Corridor instead of Dome
Basement Floor Plan
Description
General Comments Incorporate Staircase pressurisation
Developer to submit the PHE performance sheet at
100%, 75% , 50% and 25% load condition and
temperature & flow as per the DBR for approval.
Please clarify which staircase will be pressurised and There are Two Staircases in each of two towers, One Fire Tower
which will be naturally ventilated.
b) CPVC SDR11 upto 50mm and Above 50mm Sch40 or sch80 As
per your calculation to be update.
c) Again check upvc sch80 Pipe for OHT Application. GI / PPR
Pipes is okay from our side.
d) Please add PPR-C Pipes grade
e) Hot Water Line to be insulated. Add description for the same.
f) Add jointing method Pipes.
For DraiOkge System :
a) Please mention grade of SWR Pipes .
b) SWR Pipes Availble upto 160mm. Please check for upper dia
MOC , As per drawing 300mm dia pipes shown in basement
lines.
c) Please add PP Pipes EN/IS Code .
d) PPR Pipes not recommeded for draiOkge application or
Camera
Please mention IS Code.
e)" Basin, shower, etc. waste pipes up-to p-trap / floor trap /
stack" For this Please check SWR Pipes available in 40mm
/50mm.
f) Please correct "PVC Formcore SN8 to IS : 16098- Part-01 or
Stoneware or RCC NP3 confirming to IS: 783 or DWC (Double
Wall Corrugated) SN8 confirming to IS: 16098- part-02" instead
of " PVC SN8 or Stoneware or RCC confirming to IS: 783 or DWC
(Double Wall Corrugated) confirming to IS: 16098"
g) Please add All type Pipes IS Code and jointing method.
For Valves :
1. Please check Avaibility of Gun metal Valve Accoridngly to dia
range.
2. Please add strainer in list.
Control valve missing in vertical line distribution level from ring
main. Please add.
1. Required Control Valve in all vertical distibuiton line from ring
main distribution.
2. Add Tank filling system on Motorized valve basis . Also check
tank filling riser Pipe dia with respect to time hours of filling.
3. Please mention pressure rating on each floor to under stood
what pressure availble on each zone .
4. Air release valve missing at terrace level.
5. UV with online water mointoring parameter unit to be show
in commercial line distribution.
Along with that, at present GIFT is providing only domestic
water. In future if access STP treated water will be available
then it will be provided to developer at tunnel end and for that
developer has to make necessary arrangement. At present
developer have to connect their flushing tank with domestic
water pipeline having valve arrangement. So in future when STP
treated water if available can be directly connected with
flushing pipeline. Tentative drawing for the arrangement is
shown for the ready reference.
1. Please provide section for Connection with GIFTCL Sewage
Chamber.
Please proivde exterOkl storm water network showing
connection details with GIFTCL Storm water network.
Comments from PDA (10-03-2023) Response from ATOMEP (06-04-2023)
Noted & incorporated.
It will be submitted after the vendor / OEM is finalized
Staircase is Pressurized while another is Naturally Ventilated.
1. Writeup udated.
2.Material and valve PN rating updated
Control valve has been proposed in all vertical shafts
1. Control valve has been proposed in all vertical shafts
2. Tank filling system has been updated as per GIFTCL
3. Pressure calculations has been added seperately.
4. ARV has been added
GIFTCL UDAS connection plan has been submitted
GIFTCL UDAS connection plan has been submitted
Services : HVAC (3 Nos)
PDA REPLY-17.04.2023
If natural ventilation considered , cross ventilation to be
considered for staircase
Required at this satge.
PHE's generally does not perform at part loads below
30% due to reduction in velocity creating laminar flow
conditoon across the plates. Hence part load
performance is required for review.
If natural ventilation considered , cross ventilation to be
considered for staircase.
Please mention the same in DBR & drawings.
1.Water Supply Pipe MOC Not update as per comments.
2. Drainage MOC not update complelty as per comments. Please
correct.
3. What is PPMD ?
4. Valve description is change completely as per earlier comments. eleminated, however probability of multiple small pipe
Please add proper description of each type of valve.
Required control valve in each zone vertical line.
1. Required control valve in each zone vertical line.
2. Update in schematic .
3. Noted
4. Not update. Please update schematic & plan
5. Noted.
Provide sewer disposal location & IL drawing
Provide storm disposal location & IL drawing
Please add Population criteria for first and 2nd floor for
Commercial Block.
3 m2/Person occupancy only for ground floor level as per NBC-
2016
Please add flow rate of fixtures as per IGBC .
Response from ATOMEP (27-04-2023)
Planned as per natural ventilation & accordingly Fire NOC received.
It will be submitted after the vendor / OEM is finalized
Planned as per natural ventilation & accordingly Fire NOC received.
eliminated.
e) Hot Water Line to be insulated. Add description for Water Supply Points :
the same: Individual geysers are planned with a) Noted.
concealed pipes.
B) Noted. We recommeded Use Sch 80 fitting along with Sch 40
f) Add jointing method Pipes: Will be finalised after Pipes instead of Sch40 fitting for better strenght .
c) Noted
material selection. d) Noted.
E) Noted. Insulation to be considered or not , Please confirm.
Drainage Point:
F) Material Type already mentioned in DBR
a) Please mention grade of SWR Pipes: SWR pipes hecne jointing Method is part of DBR.
has been eleminated. Drainage Points :
b) SWR Pipes Availble upto 160mm. Please check for a) Noted.
upper dia MOC , As per drawing 300mm dia pipes
b) Explaination not clear and not acceptable. "probability of
shown in basement lines: SWR pipes has been
multiple small pipe will be evaluated at the procurement
stage based on material availability."
will be evaluated at the procurement stage based on c) PP Pipes showing in DBR as a drainage MOC. Please check and
material availability. correct the statements.
c) Please add PP Pipes EN/IS Code: PP pipes has been d) Noted.
eleminated. e) Noted. PPMD Full form to be added for easy understanding of
d) PPR Pipes not recommeded for draiOkge type of Pipe.
application or Please mention IS Code.: PPR pipes f)Update the IS CODE As "16098-Part-02"
has been eleminated. g) Part of DBR. Please add.
e)" Basin, shower, etc. waste pipes up-to p-trap / Noted pressure rating of Pipes.
floor trap / stack" For this Please check SWR Pipes Noted.
available in 40mm /50mm.: PPMD pipe available for Noted.
lower size. Noted.
f) Please correct "PVC Formcore SN8 to IS : 16098-
Part-01 or Stoneware or RCC NP3 confirming to IS:
783 or DWC (Double Wall Corrugated) SN8
confirming to IS: 16098- part-02" instead of " PVC SN8
or Stoneware or RCC confirming to IS: 783 or DWC
(Double Wall Corrugated) confirming to IS:
16098" :DWC (Double Wall Corrugated) confirming to
IS: 16098 has been finalised
g) Please add All type Pipes IS Code and jointing
method.: will be finalised after material selection.
For valves pressure rating has been mentioned.
3) PPMD is mineral-filled polypropylene pipe.
4) Each type of valve detail will be part of BoQ.
1. Point not update in this submission or prevuious submission.
We clearly mentioned , required control valve in each zone
vertcial downtakes and as per schematic , only upper booster
Valves have been considered and already provided in pump zone showing control valve in vertical distribution system.
the schematic layout. Please update and submit revised drawing.
1. Point not update in this submission or prevuious submission.
We clearly mentioned , required control valve in each zone
vertcial downtakes and as per schematic , only upper booster
pump zone showing control valve in vertical distribution system.
Please update and submit revised drawing.
1) Already updated in the previous submission. 2. Noted. Please add in actual schematic instead of adding as a
2) Updated. legend form.
3) Closed 3. closed.
4) Already updated in the previous schematic. 4. Noted and closed.
5) Closed 5. Closed
Invert level connections are already mentioned in the
submitted drawing as well as GIFTCL UDAS drawing. Provide revised drawing as per comments dated 15.05.2023
Invert level connections are already mentioned in the
reported drawing as well as GIFTCL UDAS drawing. Provide revised drawing as per comments dated 15.05.2023
Adopted population criteria is on conservative side
only.
Required calculation as per blue book or Some standard basic
not on conservative side basis.
Please update water demand calculation as per standards and
code. If any code not given then you adopt some assumption as
per standard practice.
Decision on the selection of fixtures (and its flow
rates) will depend on GREEN building planning and
point availability from other services. Flow rate and
selection of fixtures will be finalised on procurement Flow rate and pressure to be maintained as per IGBC during
stage. procurement stage however Please add flow rate and presurre
rating Table of fixture as per IGBC in DBR to ensure all pipe
design to be design as per mentioned flow rate criteria .
Update the water demand calculation
1. We are okay with CPVC Pipes for Internal and vertical
disatribution however for regarding fittings for above 50mm ,
We recommded Sch80 fitting along with sch40 Pipes.
2. Below ground Pipes MOC, Please add sch40 for Above 50mm.
3. Irrigation Pipes , We recommeded UPVC sCH40 or 80 Pipes
instead of CPVC.
1. Please correct the rating of UPVC QUICK FIT Pipes , Clasee IV
is 8KG/CM2 Pipes and Table showing 10KG/cm2.
2. Above 200mm dia drainage pipe MOC to be added for both
Sewer and Storm line which Pipes suspended in basment area.
PDA REPLY-15.05.2023 Response from ATOMEP (20-05-2023) PDA REPLY-03-06.2023
Kindly elaborate the reply and clarify for which stair natural
ventilation considered? And for which stair mechanical
Noted & accordingly Fire NOC received. pressurisation considered? Becacuse in the drawing at
DBR page no 35 showing mechanical some of place pressurisation shown and at some of place
pressurisation for stair. Also for above levels ,if it is missing and not shown.
natural ventilation considered , cross ventilation
to be considered for staircase
Partload performance data of Sondex & Alfa Laval at
Required at this stage. Developer can submit two 25%,50%,75% & 100% for 850 TR PHE submitted, we
,three OEM part load performance sheets confirm to provide data for final selection during
As per the DBR ,PHE capacity is 550 TR. Kindly submit
procurement stage.
the details accordigly.
Kindly elaborate the reply and clarify for which stair natural
ventilation considered? And for which stair mechanical
Noted and as discussed during last joint meeting, Fire NOC received. pressurisation considered? Becacuse in the drawing at
The staircase ventilation/ pressurization shall be as some of place pressurisation shown and at some of place
per NBC  2016. it is missing and not shown.
 Services : ELECTRICAL(6 Nos)
Sr. Point no./
Comments from PDA (07-03-2023) Response from ATOMEP (06-04-2023) PDA REPLY-17.04.2023 Response from ATOMEP (26-04-2023) PDA REPLY-15.05.2023 Response from ATOMEP (20-05-2023) PDA REPLY-05-06-2023
No. Drawing No.

3 and 4.5 Bhk. Distribution wiring as per the 3-phase

It is mandatory to take 3 phase connection for 3 We have considered 3 phase connection for 4.5 BHK and As already commented earlier, it is mandatory to take 3
Pl. share Apartment detail load sheet with connected connection and Metering arrangement in Metering panel will
1 DBR PAGE-48 power. Also Please share the excel sheet of the total As the conneted load is above 6KW, developer need to & 4.5 BHK and shops. The flats below 3 BHK Shops. For 2 & 3 BHK, wiring / electrical installation to be phase connection for 3 & 4.5 BHK and shops.Accordingly
Refer load sheet for each type of apartment. be as per the requirement with single phase and 3-phase.`
load calculations. arrange the wiring w.r.t 3-phase. may take 1 phase connections. Accordingly done as per 3 phase connections and Meter shall be 1 please update in the DBR, SLD and load calculation
At intial stage we provide 1 phase meter for 3 & 4.5 BHK unit,
please update in the DBR and SLD. phase. Panel design considered as 3 phase connection. sheet , wherever required.
Meter panel design suitable for 3 phase.

Since the demand load is 392 KW, as per the

regulations developer need to take the HT
connection for common area load. Developer has
to consider 33KV transformer with necessary
equipments to cater the load for common area.
GIFTPCL shall provide the single feed at HT 1. GIFTPCL shall provide the single feed at HT(33KV) for
As the load observed for the common area is 550KW,
(33KV) upto the developer's premises for common area load. Pls correct it SLD.
developer has to install the 33KV transformer with Noted, refer updated details.
PL. CONIFRM PHE / HVAC LOAD WITH HVAC/PHE common area load, subjected to the application 2. Please indicate the location of the proposed
2 S-263/LPS/CC/004 SLD Noted and Load is checked with HVAC and PHE requirement. necessary equipments to cater the load for common 560 KW is connected load and demand load is 392KW. In future if LT connection available upto 400 KW for
TEAM and payment of requisite charges. Also in CSS in the drawing. 3. Also The
area. Developer has considered the space provision for common area then we will consider LT meters.
addition, GIFTPCL shall provide the single feed transformers within the building should comply the
the transformer in the basement plan during DP stage.
at LT (415 V) upto the developer's main LT regulations as per Annexure-I.
panels to cater the load for EVs, flats etc..,
subjected to the application and payment of
requisite charges.
Accordingly, please update in DBR
and SLD.

As per earthing report earhing strip laid 60 cm depth

3 S-263/LPS/CC/001/002
, All staircase lighting on Emg. Power , Pl. mark All common area Load considered on Backup power During
basment layout burried , as per drawing laid on floor pl. clerify , in earthing
Maintance power socket , Emergency. Power socket are not required, provision will be provided ok closed.
in DB. layout earth pit detil for copper bonded rod / legand shows
plate earthing pl. clerify

4 S-263/LPS/CC/001/002
NO LIGHT ON UPS POWER / DURING POWER ups panel o/g feeder 1ph / 3ph pl. mention in SLD / As per
All common area Load considered on Backup power During
basment layout Emg. Lighting not shown FAILURE TILL BACK UP POWER START TOTAL Noted and updated. OK CLOSE SLD passage / lobby lighting add in UPS panel / stariase
Emergency. We will apply for backup power accordingly.
DRAKNESS IN BUILDING lighting not shown in UPS panel pl. clerify

As per earthing report earhing strip laid 60 cm depth

APFC size to be mentioned in the SLD and share the burried , as per drawing laid on floor pl. clerify , in earthing
5 SLD Noted and updated in the SLD. Share the APFC and earthing calculations. Refer APFCR & earthing calculation.
calculation also. layout earth pit detil for copper bonded rod / legand shows
plate earthing pl. clerify

what is design voltage drop / what achive not mention in

6 SLD Cable voltage drop calculation sheet is required. Please share the voltage drop calculations in formula not shown in excel file , pl. share excel file with
Sheet attached. sheet / recommanded cable sizing base on connected Noted. Voltage drop calculation in excel already provided.
excel with formulae, for review. formula
load , not on max demand

Services : ELV(3 Nos)

Sr. Design Basis Report./ Comments from PDA (15-03-2023)
Description Response from ATOMEP (06-04-2023) Comments from PDA 17-04-2023 Response from ATOMEP (26-04-2023) Comments from PDA 08-05-2023 Response from ATOMEP (17-05-2023) Comments from PDA 03.06.2023
No. Drawing DBR/DRAWINGS

All IBMS (Intelligent Building Management System)

systems need to be connected mandatory to GIFT C-4
and the developer has to extend inputs to our closed
systems at C-4
1 MEPF-DBR IBMS Systrem

Refer comment response in point number 3. Noted

The developer needs to lay the dual cable tray from

two diverse path to take the fiber optic coming from closed
the Gift tunnel entrance to their telecom room.
Noted OK
2 MEPF-DBR Gas Leak detection system is not mentioned anywhere Noted and submitted
Gas Leak detection system in DBR? Please confirm closed closed
3 MEPF-DBR Video door phone system is not mentioned anywhere in As per developer’s requirement, we have not considered Video door phone.
Video door phone DBR? Please confirm Noted & Closed. Noted & Closed.

Services : FFTG(14 Nos)

Sr. Design Basis Report./
Description Comments from PDA (10-03-2023) Response from ATOMEP (06-04-2023) PDA REPLY-17.04.2023 Response from ATOMEP (26-04-2023) PDA REPLY-03-05-2023 Response from ATOMEP (22-05-2023) PDA REPLY-02-06-2023
No. Drawing
Architecture drawing shared separately, we will submit the
1 General Please add fire doors locations and rating. Is part of Architectural plan. 2 hour fire rated door has been considered. Please provide the Architectural Drgs showing Attached arch set Architectural Drgs are not attached. Updated drawings to be provided
Locations & Rating of Fire Doors. same again.
2 Basement - 2 & 1 Please mark the travel distances to exits. Travel Distances are exceeding the Limits. Please see Noted and Necessary changes done to achieve required
Separate drawing attached for ease of understanding. Travel Distances Drgs are not updated. Arch drawing updated and Travel distance will be updated. Updated drawings to be provided
the attached Drgs. tranvel distance.
Please check the distance between boundary &
3 Basement - 2 & 1 Noted and updated Noted Info.
sprinkler location Noted & Take care during execution also.

Fixed Type Hose Reel can not be accomodated in 550

mm. Hose Reel Length will be 550 to 650 mm.Also Noted, The shaft wall will be modified such that necessary
Please check the depth of Hose cabinets since it is The clear space available with Fire cabinet door of max 50 mm frame, Please review the Installation of Risers and Tappings Please take care in operational & Execution point
4 Basement - 2 & 1 difficult to accommodate within 450 mm. space will be available. The same will be taken care in GFC of Noted Info.
the available space is about 600 mm, sufficient for fire hose reel. of view.
for Hydrant Valve etc. Maintanence will be challenge wall.
since all Risers are installed back side of Access Door
which is 550 to 600 mm. Please review once again.
Please check the access door width of the shaft 600 Please take care in operational & Execution point
5 Basement - 2 & 1 Noted and updated Noted and will be update Note Info.
mm. It is difficult to operate in case of emergency. Still Drgs are with 600 mm Access Doors. of view.
Please show the compartmentation and water curtain Water curtain nozzle has been provided. Compartment has been marked Done & Closed for Water Curtain. Travel Distances are
6 Basement - 2 & 2 Noted and updated Travel Distances Drgs are not updated. Arch drawing updated and Travel distance will be updated. Updated Drgs not Received.
nozzles. on drawing showing travel distance. exceeding the Limits. Please see the attached Drgs.
Fire pump room planned in 2nd basement need to This has been approved by CFO at the time of Pre NOC and basement Fire pump room must comply with Clause no. 5.1.2.2
7 Basement - 2 & 3
have direct access from ground level. construction is in progress based on the same. ( Fire fighting pump house ) as per NBC 2016
GIFT to confirm.
Please distribute the Sprinklers as per Zoning and take
8 Basement - 2 & 4 care that sprinklers are not tapped from One Zone to Noted Info.
other zone.
9 Basement - 2 & 5 Please check no.of Pump Sets shown in Pump Room Noted Info.
and rectify.
Refuge area to be connected with fire tower, without
having the occupants requiring to return to the These layout has been approved during DP and fire NOC has been
10 Fourth floor to Terrace Refuge area to be provided as per NBC 2016
building space through which travel to the area of received on the same. At this stage no further change possible.
refuge occurred.
GIFT to confirm.
Travel distances to be marked from exit staircase to Travel Distances are exceeding the Limits. Please see
11 General Refer response in comment number 19. Noted and updated Travel Distances Drgs are not updated. Arch drawing updated and Travel distance will be updated. Updated Drgs not Received.
remote point. the attached Drgs.
Distance between Deflector of Sprinklers and Ceilng
12 Typical Details should be followed as per IS 15105-2021, Clause No: Noted and updated Please ensure during execution. Noted Info.
9.21.6.
13 Typical Details Non Return Valve shown for Stad post. Is it required? Noted and updated. Not Updated. Plz update
Please consider Gate Valves instead of Butterfly We had considered BFV valve in Pump room. during
14 Valves inside the Pump Room. All other areas construction / tender stage will try for Gate valve and if Please consider Gate Valves only in Pump Room.
General you may use Butterfly Valves. feasible we will use gate valve or Use BFV valve.
 Services : ELV(3 Nos)

GIFT Remarks on 05.06.2023

Developer need to follow the GIFT residential building

IBMS guidelines .
Also,Developer need to be submit the IBMS
compliance sheet in line with GIFT IBMS residetial
building guidlines.

This need to be show in drawings.

This need to be incorporate in DBR in details and
submit for review.
This need to be incorporate in DBR in details and
submit for review.

Services : FFTG(14 Nos)

GIFT Remarks on 05.06.2023