Compliance Sheet .10.20

LARSEN & TOUBRO LIMITED
WATER & EFFULENT TREATMENT IC
Lot 1: Construction of Works of Water Supply Production and Distribution Network Improvements with house service connections for nonrevenue water reduction and continuous water supply and Providing Sewer Network with
PROJECT
House connections, and construction of Sewage Treatment Plant and all allied Works and operation services of the entire system for 10 years at Sirohi” (RSTDIP/SHR/01).
Compliance for Comments on Basic Engineering Package Process, Flow diagram, Layout Plan, Hydraulic flow diagram for 1.7 MLD STP at Sirohi
SUBJECT
(Ref. no. :PMCBC/RSTDSP/246 DATED 03.10.2020)
Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply
1 Document is not undersigned and stamped by the contractor. Noted and shall be incorporated
Verified Contour plan was missing and shall be enclosed with the revised
2 Noted and shall be submitted
submission
Finished ground level shall be finalized as per the actual site condition and High FGL is finalised based on actual contour, NGL & HFL at site. The plinth level of buildings are
3
flood level (HFL) of the area. maintained above HFL as per tender document.
Layout shall be furn ished with at least 3 different proposals along with their
4 merits and demerits i.e. cost impact on construction and during O&M. Layout We have selected the most optimal layout for Construction and operational feasiblity.
proposed is not arranged in sequence.
It has been pointed out from the layout plan that DG and transformers are
5 located at the backside of the campus. It is suggested to be located near the Noted and shall be incorporated
entrance to reduce the cabling cost.
HFL of the disposal point shown in hydraulic flow diagram along with its distance
6 HFL is verified from the site office with respect to the actual data
from the proposed site shall be verified from site office.
Invert level and diameter of the incoming sewer shall be verified with the Invert level and diameter of incoming sewer has been verified and inline with the approved sewer
7
approved sewer network drawings. It should be shown on drawing. network drawing. Same will be incorporated in Layout.
For alignment of incoming sewer, kindly refer drawing no. LE200451-M-WW-SW-LA-1068 - Layout
8 Alignment plan of the incoming sewer shall be shown in the drawing. plan of sewer network for sirohi zone 2. However direction of incoming sewer will be shown in the
Layout.
Alignment of the pipe for reuse by gravity from TEER and disposal from TESR to Noted and will be incorporated. Detailed arrangement will be shown in Overall Piping Layout
9
disposal point inside the plant shall be marked on drawing. LE200451-M-WW-SW-PA-1532
Boundary wall and fencing has been shown in the drawing, it shall be verified
finalized at site as per the site requirement. It is suggested to provide the The boundary wall is provided for complete STP layout. Nearby surroundings shall be incorporated in
10
boundary for the entire campus. Nearby surroundings shall be mentioned on the the Layout key plan.
drawing as far as possible for better feasibility and understanding of the site.
Approach road to treated effluent pump house, grit separator, SBR basins has
11 Appropriate access shall be provided in the Layout
not been provided. kindly provide the same.
Incorporating city map in the key plan will not be legible. However nearby sorroundings will be
12 Key plan shall be revised and location of the plant shall be shown on city map.
incorporated in key plan
Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

#
LE200451-P-WW-SW-BE-2101, REV.- A
PROJECT
SUBJECT
13 Toilet has been shown with metering room, kindly provide it with guard room. Noted and shall be incorporated
14 Landscaping layout, road and drain layout shall be submitted separately. Confirmed
LE200451-P-WW-SW-BE-2101, REV.- A
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PF-2102, REV.- A
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103, REV.- A Advanced type Ultrasonic flow meter shall be used for the measurement of open channel flow, it uses
Channel mounted Ultrasonic flow measuring meter has been considered instead
LE200451-P-WW-SW-HF-2104, REV.- A the principle of calculating the flow based on the velocity of the stream multiplied by the area of
15 of parshall flume. kindly clarify and submit the relevant documents as per the
wetted surface. This principle gives as a best accuracy as well as suited for small capacity STP
description mentioned in the BEP writeup.
plants.Technical data sheet shall be submitted seperatly .
The sludge de-watering machine (Volute Screw Press) rotates at very low speed (3 RPM - 5 RPM)
Volute press is considered for 20 hours working while as per contract agreement
16 without any trouble for continuous running of 20 hours. Also, in previous Rajasthan projects BGH job
it is to be 16 hrs. kindly clarify.
and SAB - (RUDSICO), 20 hours of operation is considered.
Kindly refer below documents for BEP of STP-SPS which will be submitted separately .
LE200451-M-WW-SW-DC-1521 - Hydraulic Design Calculations for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
Design calculations of receiving chamber, coarse screen channel and Wet well
LE200451-M-WW-SW-DC-1522 - Pump Head Calculations for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
17 has not been furnished with submission, kindly provide the same to finalize the
LE200451-M-WW-SW-PI-1523 -Piping & Instrumentation Diagram for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
plant design and drawings in totality.
LE200451-M-WW-SW-HF-1524 -Hydraulic Flow Diagram (HFD) for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
Design calculation of the SBR technology provider vendor is not enclosed with
Design calculations of SBR Technology provider shall be submitted once vendor is finalized. Same
18 the submission, this may lead to change in hydraulics, sizing of the units. Kindly
methodology was adapted for Jhunjhunu 7 MLD RUIDP project - LE160978
furnish the same with the revised submission.
It has been found in the process calculation that at various locations you have
Provided Liquid depth can be more than arrived value, since arrived value 0.1 m is very less as per
19 assumed the SWD more than the arrived calculations.For instance kindly check
Standard engineering practise and will be difficult for fixing the sluice gate, etc.,
page no. 28, liquid depth arrived 0.10 m and liquid depth Provided 0.30m
List of mechanical units, civil units and piping schedule will be finalized during
20 Confirmed
detail engineering and as per vendor data.
Kindly denote Main Pumping Station instead of Sewage Pumping Station as per Since there are no technical specifications mentioned especially for MPS in NIT, the
21
Contract Specifications to maintain the clarity. terminology of STP-SPS has been adopted. However it will be updated as MPS.
Velocity in u/s channel - approach velocity at average flow at page no. 26 is

22 Noted and shall be corrected
incorrect, kindly check and correct the same.
Volume of fecal sludge is mentioned 6 KLD in the proposal while the basis of the Based on the population and septage generation, fecal sludge load is considered. HRT of sludge sump
quantity calculation is not shown and its volume is also not considered while is 6 hours which is more than the requirement based on the operating hours of Volute press (for 20
23
arriving the volume of sludge sump. Also clarify the tanker will be capable to hours operation of volute press, 4 hours sump shall be sufficient). Remaining 2 hours shall cater 6 KLD.
pump it at this level. Same shall be corrected in process flow diagram. Pumping to the sludge sump will be done with the help of suitable pumping arrangement.
The SBR invert level is fixed 1.2 m from NGL & foundation is provided at a depth of 1.5m from NGL . As
Invert level of SBR basins is considered 1.2 m below FGL, kindly check and ensure
per soil investigation report at 1.5 m itself N value is greater than 100 & recommended SBC is 550
24 that the minimum depth of foundation as per technical specifications will be
kN/m2 which is very high compared to required SBC , so it is suggested to provide foundation at 1.5 m
provided.
from NGL itself to avoid rock excavation.

#
PROJECT
SUBJECT
Thickness bar is considered 2 mm for Fine screen while as per contract As per approved vendors recommendation 2mm thickness shall be sufficient for step screens. We had
25
specification it should be 3 mm, kindly clarify. also excuted the same in other projects
As per contract specifications staff quarter is to be proposed at STP plant, kindly

26 Noted and incorpoarted if land is available or accomdated in intergrated building
provide the same and update the drawings accordingly.
26 All works shall be in line of contract specifications and under BOQ item no. 367. confirmed
27 Other observations are marked on documents with Red. Noted and responded seperately.

#
Lot 1: Construction of Works of Water Supply Production and Distribution Network Improvements with house service connections for nonrevenue water reduction and continuous water supply and Providing Sewer
PROJECT
Network with House connections, and construction of Sewage Treatment Plant and all allied Works and operation services of the entire system for 10 years at Sirohi” (RSTDIP/SHR/01).
SUBJECT
The contractor have not considered any raw sewage quality monitoring analyzers at the inlet Analyser are installed at oulet to check the performance of the STP as per contract. At inlet daily
1
to the STP. testing shall be carried out at laboratory.
The contractor have shown motorized valves at the inlet chamber and the distribution
chamber.
2 Noted and shall be incorported
These valves are to be interfaced to the PLC/SCADA system, therefore the interlock for
these valves shall also be shown on the P&IDs.
The contractor have shown FIT 103 at the inlet channel to the SBR intermediate Channel / Ultrasonic type flow transmitter has been provided. Same shall be mentioned in
3
Distribution, but the type of flow meter have not been mentioned. document.
The contractor have shown Motorized Butterfly Valve MBVF -001 to MBVF - 004 in the
4 air-line to SBRs, but the interlocks for the same have not been described and mentioned in Noted and shall be incorported
the P&ID.
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, REV.-
The contractor have mentioned the piping system as "DI", for common delivery of Treated
A Electromagnetic flow meter shall be installed on flanged DI pipes. The common header of the
5 Effluent pumps, the contractor may require to provide MS line for installation of
treated effluent pumps can be retained as DI pipes.
Electromagnetic flow meter for a certain length, the same shall be mentioned in the P&IDs.
The contractor have not shown any Flow measurement thickened sludge, effluent
6 As per process design, flow meters are not required.
recirculation as per the contract specifications.
The contractor have not considered level switch in the sludge sump as per Cl. 6.6.4.4, Table We have considered level transmitter for the purpose of continuous level measurement of the sump.
7 8, Instrumentation Schedule provided in the Employer's Requirements of the contract For tripping purpose required no. of relays shall be considered in the level transmitter same will
agreement. cater the purpose of level switch also.
The contractor shall furnish the details of interfacing the vendor package equipment like
8 Noted and the same shall be furinished once vendor package items are finalized .
chlorination system, screens, volute press etc.
The contractor shall also furnish the control and operation philosophy for the pumping Operation and control philosophy shall be submitted as separate document which is mentioned in
9
station for reference. DCI document as LE200451-I-WW-SW-CP-5026
The contractor shall submit the Functional Design Specification (FDS, Sequence of
10 Operation) in-line with Cl. 6.6.5.5. mentioned In the Employers Requirements of the Confirmed
contract agreement

#
PROJECT
Compliance for Comments on Basic Engineering Package - LE200451-P-WW-SW-BE-2101, REV.- A

SUBJECT
Sr. No Reference Page No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply
Page No. 6
1 Average annual rainfall in sirohi is 73.23cm Already mentioned in the description 1.1, Site description in page no. 5
2 Page No. 7,12,13,14 Recycle flow to be specified Noted and shall be incorporated
Kindly mention main pumping station instead of STP - Sewage Pumping Since there are no technical specifications mentioned especially for MPS in NIT, the terminology of STP-
3 Page No. 10,12,22
Station (SPS) SPS has been adopted. However it will be updated as MPS.
Check and confirm with approved sewer network - incoming sewage pipe dia Noted and confirmed as per drawing no LE200451-M-WW-SW-LA-1068 - Layout plan of sewer network
4 Page No. 10
to SPS inlet chamber from sewer network. for sirohi zone 2
Check and confirm with approved sewer network - invert level of incoming Noted and confirmed as per drawing no LE200451-M-WW-SW-LA-1068 - Layout plan of sewer network
5 Page No. 10
sewage pipe dia to SPS inlet chamber from sewer network. for sirohi zone 2
Capacity of Wet well has been designed as per Clause No. 4.6.6 of Chapter 4 CPHEEO Manual. This
retention time is considering a cycle time of 15 mins for the peak flow pumping which ensures that pump
tripping is as per manufacturer's recommendations.
6 Page No. 11 Wet well: Capacity at average flow = 20 min
A retention capacity of 20 mins at average flow will lead to a large volume which might result in siltation
and deposition inside the wet well.
Store standby pumps shall be used during maintenance (if required) of installed raw sewage submersible
7 Page No. 11 SS : standby pumps in MPS shall be installed pumps. However, space provision has been considered for accomodating the store standby pumps inside
the wet well in future.
8 Page No. 13, 53 Bar spacing : 6 mm As per addendum - 3 dated 10.05.2019, reply Sl.no.33 and Table 14 - bar spacing is 5 mm
As per approved vendors recommendation 2mm thickness shall be sufficient for step screens. We had also
9 Page No. 13, 53 Bar thickness : As per contract specifications 3 mm
excuted the same in other projects
Open channel ultrasonic flow meter: Kindly provide reference and
10 Page No. 14 Technical data sheet shall be submitted seperatly .
specification of this instrument
11 Page No. 17 Kindly mention the type of diffusers proposed Retriavable type of diffusers are considered. Same will be updated
Chain pulley block of suitable arrangment for lifting for TESR Pump house to Weight of pumps installed in TESR will be less and will not need frequent maintenance. Monorail with
12 Page No. 20
be Motorised arrangement manual chain pulley block will be sufficient for handling of these pumps;

#
PROJECT
Compliance for Comments on Basic Engineering Package - LE200451-P-WW-SW-BE-2101, REV.- A

SUBJECT
Sr. No Reference Page No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply
FSM area has already been incoprtaed in stp capacity.

Capacity of fecal sludge is not added in arriving the capacity of sludge
HRT of sludge sump is 6 hours which is more than the requirement based on the operating hours of Volute
13 Page No. 20 sump(check calculations). Also the basis of 6 KLD capacity shall be
press (for 20 hours operation of volute press, 4 hours sump shall be sufficient). Remaining 2 hours shall
furnished.
cater 6 KLD.
The angle mentioned are for arriving the area enclosed within the CCT outer wall and SBR outer wall.
14 Page No. 32 Angle mentioned in process calculations to arrive area of CCT and TESR
Accordingly area is arrived.
15 Page No. 32 Size of CCT and TESR - mentioned as Length as per layout Noted and shall be incorporated
16 Page No. 32 Excess sludge to sludge sump shall be finalized as per the vendor submission Confirmed
17 Page No. 33 Freeboard for Sludge sump - as per HFD, please mention Noted and shall be incorporated
Capacity of fecal sludge is not included in sludge sump and tanker will be
18 Page No. 33 capable to pump it at this level. Kindly clarify and mention the detailed Already replied for sump volume and fecal handling. Kindly refer reply to point no.23 in overall comments
calculation of fecal sludge.
Same shall be provided in the separate drawing which is mentioned in the DCI : Alignment plan & L-
19 Page No. 38 Kindly confirm at site - Length of disposal
section of effluent disposal line: LE200451-M-WW-SW-PL-1077.
20 Page No. 38 Decanting depth - Submit as per technology provider Noted and shall be submitted after vendor finalization
21 Page No. 39 TWL of CCT - at start to be mentioned Noted & shall be updated
As per technology provider and contract specification for the following items:
1. Air blower for SBR
2.Diffuser for SBR aeration system
22 Page No. 54 3.Pipe diffuser for anoxic zone of SBR Confirmed
4.Decanter
5.RAS pump
6.SAS pump

#
Lot 1: Construction of Works of Water Supply Production and Distribution Network Improvements with house service connections for nonrevenue water reduction and continuous water supply
PROJECT and Providing Sewer Network with House connections, and construction of Sewage Treatment Plant and all allied Works and operation services of the entire system for 10 years at Sirohi”
(RSTDIP/SHR/01).
Compliance for Comments on Process Flow Diagram - LE200451-P-WW-SW-PF-2102, REV.- A

SUBJECT
1 LE200451-P-WW-SW-PF-2102, REV.- A Stamp and signature of contractor and CMSC/PIU Noted and shall be incorporated
2 LE200451-P-WW-SW-PF-2102, REV.- A Consultant : PMCBC & CMSC - 02 Noted and shall be incorporated
# Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

(RSTDIP/SHR/01).
Compliance for Comments on Plant Layout - LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103, REV.- A

SUBJECT
1 Stamp and signature of contractor and CMSC/PIU Noted and shall be incorporated
2 Consultant : PMCBC & CMSC - 02 Noted and shall be incorporated
Location of STP on city map. Kindly revise it Incorporating city map in the key plan will not be legible. However nearby sorroundings will be
3
accordingly. incorporated in key plan
4 Admin Building units - mention area All room dimensions are already specified
Kindly refer below documents for BEP of STP-SPS which will be submitted separately .
LE200451-M-WW-SW-DC-1521 - Hydraulic Design Calculations for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
5 STP - SPS calculations not submitted LE200451-M-WW-SW-DC-1522 - Pump Head Calculations for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
LE200451-M-WW-SW-PI-1523 -Piping & Instrumentation Diagram for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
LE200451-M-WW-SW-HF-1524 -Hydraulic Flow Diagram (HFD) for 1.7 MLD STP-SPS
Provide approach road for collection of screening

6 Appropriate access shall be provided in the Layout
material
7 Provide approach road for collection of grit Appropriate access shall be provided in the Layout
8 Approach for this area shall be shown in drawing. Appropriate access shall be provided in the Layout
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103
9 Toilet in metering room to be shifted to guard room Noted and shall be incorporated
10 Diameter of Plinth - TEER Diameter of plinth in TEER is 11.9 m.
11 Provide contours Noted and shall be submitted

WATER LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103
& EFFULENT TREATMENT IC
(RSTDIP/SHR/01).
Compliance for Comments on Plant Layout - LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103, REV.- A

SUBJECT
Mark alignment of disposal line from TESR and reuse Noted and will be incorporated. Detailed arrangement will be shown in Overall Piping Layout
12
line from TEER LE200451-M-WW-SW-PA-1532
All the units shall be interconnected as per contract

13 Noted and shall be taken care
specifications
Same shall be provided in the separate drawing : Alignment plan & L-section of effluent disposal
14 Mark the location of disposal point of treated effluent
line: LE200451-M-WW-SW-PL-1077. Kindly refer DCI
15 Mention the source of potable water for campus Borewell shall be done for potable water
Provide/Mark the location of rain water harvesting

16 The location shall be provided in storm water layout in separate drawing
structure
Kindly ensure and rectify if there is any existing

17 Noted and same shall be ensured
underground and overhead utilities

(RSTDIP/SHR/01).
Compliance for Comments on Piping and Instrumentation Diagram- LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, REV.- A

SUBJECT
1 Check the tag list it must be DLT Noted
2 Mechanical fine bar screen channel (1W + 1S) Noted and incoporated
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, Sheet 1 of 5
3 Mechanical Grit Seperator Units (1W + 1S) Noted and incoporated
4 Mention flow measuring device Channel type flow meter is considered for checking the Instantaneous and Totalized flow
5 LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, Sheet 2 of 5 Provide vendor drawing for SBR basins Same shall be submitted once vendor is finalized.
6 Not mentioned in Index Noted and incoporated
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, Sheet 3 of 5
There is no overflow chamber in HFD. Only Outfall chamber is shown separately at disposal point.
7 Show separate overflow chamber as per HFD
The overflow chamber with weir shown inside TESR is not for outfall chamber
8 LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, Sheet 4 of 5 MOC of polymer - chemical lines - HDPE CPVC shall be more compatible for chemical lines than HDPE
As per SBR vendor for type/capacity for:

1. Air blower
9 Confirmed
2. Return Activated Pumps
LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, Sheet 5 of 5 3. Surplus Activate Pumps
NOTES: All works will be in line of contract

10 Confirmed
specifications

Lot 1: Construction of Works of Water Supply Production and Distribution Network Improvements with house service connections for nonrevenue water reduction and continuous water supply and
PROJECT Providing Sewer Network with House connections, and construction of Sewage Treatment Plant and all allied Works and operation services of the entire system for 10 years at Sirohi”
(RSTDIP/SHR/01).
Compliance for Comments on Hydraulic Flow Diagram - LE200451-P-WW-SW-HF-2104, REV.- A

SUBJECT
1 Stamp and signature of contractor and CMSC/PIU Noted and incorporated
2 Consultant : PMCBC & CMSC - 02 Noted and incorporated
3 LE200451-P-WW-SW-HF-2104, REV.- A NGL provide as per contour plan Confirmed
4 HFL - shall be verified HFL is verified from the site office with respect to the actual data
Shall be verified at site and distance b/w STP location and

5 Noted and shall be taken care
disposal point

Compliance Sheet .10.20

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Compliance Sheet .10.20

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

LARSEN & TOUBRO LIMITED

WATER & EFFULENT TREATMENT IC

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

Velocity in u/s channel - approach velocity at average flow at page no. 26 is

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

As per contract specifications staff quarter is to be proposed at STP plant, kindly

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Basic Engineering Package - LE200451-P-WW-SW-BE-2101, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Page No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Basic Engineering Package - LE200451-P-WW-SW-BE-2101, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Page No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

FSM area has already been incoprtaed in stp capacity.

Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Process Flow Diagram - LE200451-P-WW-SW-PF-2102, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

# Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Plant Layout - LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

2 Consultant : PMCBC & CMSC - 02 Noted and shall be incorporated

Provide approach road for collection of screening

10 Diameter of Plinth - TEER Diameter of plinth in TEER is 11.9 m.

11 Provide contours Noted and shall be submitted

# Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Plant Layout - LE200451-P-WW-SW-PP-2103, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

All the units shall be interconnected as per contract

Provide/Mark the location of rain water harvesting

Kindly ensure and rectify if there is any existing

# Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Piping and Instrumentation Diagram- LE200451-P-WW-SW-PI-2105, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

1 Check the tag list it must be DLT Noted

3 Mechanical Grit Seperator Units (1W + 1S) Noted and incoporated

6 Not mentioned in Index Noted and incoporated

As per SBR vendor for type/capacity for:

NOTES: All works will be in line of contract

# Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

Compliance for Comments on Hydraulic Flow Diagram - LE200451-P-WW-SW-HF-2104, REV.- A

Sr. No Reference Document No. CONSULTANT COMMENTS L&T's Reply

1 Stamp and signature of contractor and CMSC/PIU Noted and incorporated

2 Consultant : PMCBC & CMSC - 02 Noted and incorporated

3 LE200451-P-WW-SW-HF-2104, REV.- A NGL provide as per contour plan Confirmed

Shall be verified at site and distance b/w STP location and

# Sensitivity: LNT Construction Internal Use

You might also like