Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Evaluator:
Start Time: End Time: Total Time:
4. Poise, posture, body language: Student presents him/herself as Student shows signs of Student appears very Student is unable to
confident, comfortable and in charge. nervousness or discomfort, but nervous or excessively complete the
they do not distract from the casual so as to seem presentation.
content of the presentation. indifferent.
5. Did the student make good use of A/V fully supported or complimented A/V is used and adds to the A/V is not actively used. A/V is not used.
audio or visual aids? the presentation. presentation.
6. Presentation is 15 minutes: 15 minutes is fully used. Presentation was 13-14 minutes Presentation was 10-12 Presentation was less than
long. minutes long. 10 minutes long or over 18
minutes
7. Did the student arrive on time? Student arrived on time and was well Student was on time, but seemed Student was 1-3 minutes late Student was 3 or more
Were they prepared with all prepared. unorganized. or slightly unprepared. minutes late or totally
supplies? unprepared.
Points for Presentation Technique: Technique _______ Content ______ Total Points: _______
\\Hs-data-2\Department\VPDocs\2012-2013\Seniors\CE Rubric.doc
~ Part 2 ~ Exceeds Standards Pass Needs Improvement Not acceptable
Presentation Content: 3 2 1 0
1. Did the student use an attention Attention grabber was highly Attention grabber was appropriate Attention grabber was Attention grabber was
grabber and an overview? effective, followed by concise and somewhat inspiring. Overview present, but not inspiring. missing. Overview was
overview. was effective. Overview was skeletal. missing.
2. Did the student use 6-9 pieces 8 – 9 pieces were used and clearly 6 – 7 pieces were used and 3 - 5 pieces were used and Less than 3 pieces were
from portfolio to support the supported the presentation. adequately supported the did not adequately support used. Main ideas and
presentation? presentation. the presentation. support were absent.
3. Did the student address “Who Question is answered in a highly Question is answered in a Question is not completely Question is not addressed
Am I”? competent and fluent fashion. competent fashion. answered, or is very vague. or answered.
4. Did the student address “Where Question is answered in a highly Question is answered in a Question is not completely Question is not addressed
Am I Going?” competent and fluent fashion. competent fashion. answered, or is very vague. or answered.
5. Did the student address “How Will Question is answered in a highly Question is answered in a Question is not completely Question is not addressed
I Get There?” competent and fluent fashion. competent fashion. answered, or is very vague. or answered.
6. Was there a logical flow of ideas in Presentation followed a logical path Presentation followed an Presentation organization Presentation was
the presentation? with clear transitions from one idea to organized path with some was not clearly evident, no disjointed and
another. transitions linking parts. clear transitions evident. unorganized.
7. Was there a personal element tied Personal element was a quality Personal element was suitable for Personal element was neither Personal element was not
into the presentation? match for the presentation. the presentation. enhancing nor distracting appropriate for the
from the presentation. presentation.
8. Did the student reflect on his/her Student reflected on the experience Student reflected on community Student reflected on Student did not include
community service experiences? service with adequate detail. community service with community service
minimal detail.
9. Did the student include reference Student reflected on his/her 13-Year Student reflected on his/her 13- Student reflected his/her 13- Student did not reflect on
to his/her 13-Year Plan? Plan with detail and clarity. Year Plan with adequate detail. Year Plan with minimal detail. his/her 13-Year Plan in
presentation.
10. Were the main ideas supported Main ideas were clearly presented Main ideas are evident, but Main ideas are difficult to Main ideas and support are
by accurate and appropriate details? and strongly supported by accurate support is detect, support is absent. absent.
and appropriate detail. not strong.
11. Did the student include a Student’s summary demonstrates Student’s description of learning Student’s description of Student’s description of
reflection of what he/she learned in authentic learning. demonstrated some authentic learning consisted of an learning was missing
their 4 years in high school? learning. overview of tasks completed.
12. Did the student end with an Student’s conclusion had an effective Student’s conclusion had a logical Student’s presentation was Student simply stopped.
effective conclusion? ending that connects the components ending that connected the abrupt and lacked clear
of the presentation. components of the presentation. closure.
13. Did the student use fluency and All questions were answered in a Most questions were answered in Few questions were Student was unable to
competency while responding to highly competent, appropriate and a competent, appropriate fashion. answered in a competent, respond to the questions.
questions from the panel members? fluent fashion. appropriate fashion.
\\Hs-data-2\Department\VPDocs\2012-2013\Seniors\CE Rubric.doc