Professional Documents
Culture Documents
After serving for about 18 years, Haldor Topsoe design S-200 basket was replaced in 2009 with a new
S-300 basket. The changeout was completed within the scheduled time and proved to be a successful
project as both the production and efficiency were appreciably higher than the design figures.
In 1992, in the high pressure Synthesis loop of a 1,000 MTPD ammonia plant of Haldor Topsoe design
a new S-200 basket was installed to upgrade the design capacity of the unit to 1,220 MTPD. By year
2008, the production demand from the converter had increased to more than 1350 MTPD thus
warranting a change of catalyst and better design. Catalyst activity had decreased and was causing a
high loop pressure i.e. 269 kg/cm2g (3826 psig). Meticulous planning and execution of the project,
including catalyst services in an inert atmosphere, resulted in significant lesser time to execute the
change-out. This paper describes various steps taken to minimize the change-out time without
sacrificing the safety of personnel and equipment. Commissioning was also a unique experience
starting from catalyst reduction till the converter optimization with the help of simulation tools. New S-
300 was able to produce 1,492 MTPD ammonia apart from significant reduction in the energy
consumption.
Introduction
Plant-II was commissioned in March 1993 with
Process Description
Ammonia Converter
The ammonia converter internals consisted of an
Ammonia-I plant is a conventional Haldor
Haldor Topsoe designed S-200 basket installed
Topsoe design of the late seventies, featuring
in 1991 as a part of the plant revamp, replacing
high steam to carbon ratio (3.75), hot potassium
the original S-100 converter basket.
carbonate system for carbon dioxide removal and
ammonia synthesis loop operating at high
The catalyst loaded in 1991 required replacement
pressure.
owing to deteriorated performance with respect
It consisted of desulfurization, conventional to lower conversion efficiency and higher
reforming and high and low temperature shift approach to equilibrium after 18 years of
conversion sections in the front-end. The carbon satisfactory performance. In order to gain
dioxide removal section utilizes the Benfield maximum benefit of plant outage owing to
technology from UOP, which was up-rated to catalyst change-out, replacement of S-200 with
Benfield Lo-Heat process in 2004, followed by a S-300 was also synchronized.
methanation reactor.
The synthesis loop operates at a very high Study for Three-Bed Basket
pressure of 267 kg/cm2g (3798 psig). All the The 3-bed concept with cooling between the
major compressors i.e., process air, synthesis gas catalyst beds gives high conversion for each
and ammonia refrigeration are centrifugal converter pass; since for each bed the achievable
compressors driven by steam turbines. conversion is limited by the equilibrium of the
ammonia synthesis reaction. The pressure drop is
A simplified process flow diagram of the slightly higher but is outweighed by advantage
Ammonia-I plant is presented in Figure 1. of higher conversion and lower loop pressure.
An added advantage is that the synthesis gas
chilling duty is shifted from the ammonia
refrigeration circuit to the synthesis loop water
cooler because of higher ammonia concentration
at the converter outlet. The synthesis loop
operation at milder conditions leaves room for
possible future capacity increase. Thus the
ammonia converter with a 3-bed converter
basket was indeed found to be an attractive
option.
Figure 1: Ammonia-I Process Flow Diagram
Selected Basket
Operational History Haldor Topsoe S-300 radial flow converter
basket was selected for installation in the original
The plant started production in 1982 and had the
ammonia synthesis converter pressure shell,
distinction of achieving the design capacity in
The committed execution schedule offered by Maintenance shutdowns are a key part of the
CR-Asia was better than others, with a saving of annual budget of fertilizer plants and plant
turnaround timing by 37 hours. Some salient downtime contributes the major chunk of this
features of CR-Asia equipment are given below: cost. Each activity of the S-200 basket
replacement job was given a special
High capacity vacuum units; one in operation consideration to reduce this plant downtime cost
and second as standby without jeopardizing safety and quality of the
Two stage continuous operation cyclone job. Some breakthrough ideas were emerged,
separation unit such as dismantling the S-300 basket outside
Metallic unloading pipes to avoid melting / pressure shell prior to plant shutdown. While it is
damage owing of hot pyrophoric catalyst a conventional practice to install the complete S-
Separate cyclone based dust removal system 300 basket inside the pressure shell and then
Rigging Plan
An overhead crane of 50 tons is installed on the
top of Ammonia Converter. This built-in
resource can be utilized for rigging of basket
internals within limited distance. This crane was
insufficient tor installation of the entire
assembled S-300 basket at 50.5 tons. Using a
truck mounted crane to insert S-300 basket
inside pressure shell was risky because of limited
space available on Convertor top. The Figure 6: IHEs Removal Platform
dismantling of S-300 basket outside the pressure
shell resolved this matter. By dismantling the
basket, the largest lift load (comprised of the Special Fixture for Shell Drilling
basket and 3rd bed cartridge), was reduced to 32
tons: well within safe limits of over head crane. Drilling of 8 holes of 20 mm (0.79 inch)
diameter (M20 metric) in the pressure shell were
Bed No Catalyst, m3
S-300 Installation and Catalyst Loading 1st [Upper] 6.3
2nd [Middle] 6.3
The new S-300 basket was installed inside the
3rd [Bottom] 17.1
original pressure shell and loaded with HTAS
Table 3: Catalyst Details
pre-reduced ammonia synthesis catalyst (KM1R)
using proprietary HTAS loading method.
Screening of the catalyst was done to remove
dust using two conveyer systems with vibrating
screens directly discharging into the loading
bins.