Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LEAKNG
UNDERGROUND
STORAGE
TANK
CONTAMINANT
PLUME
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 1 of 9 5,057,227
4.
3.
O 2 4. 6 8 O 2 4 6 8 10
TOTAL BENZENE ADDED (mL) TOTAL BENZENE ADDED (mL)
FG. A FIG. B
OKEFENOKEE TAXODUM
6
5
O
O 2 4. 6 8 O 2 4 6 8
TOTAL BENZENE ADDED (mL) TOTAL BENZENE ADDED (mL.)
F.G. C F.G. D
LOXAHATCHE SAWGRASS
O 2 4. 6 8 10
TOTAL BENZENE ADDED (mL)
F.G. 1E
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 2 of 9 5,057,227
FG. 2C FIG. 2D .
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 3 of 9 5,057,227
6OO
5OO
4OO
3OO
2OO
1OO
O 2O 4O 6O 8O 1OO
FIBER CONTENT, PERCENT
FIG. 3A
O 2O 4O 6O 8O 1OO
FIBER CONTENT, PERCENT
FG. 3B
12O
11O
1OO
90
8O
7O
6O
O 2O 4O 6O 8O 1OO
FIBER CONTENT, PERCENT
F.G. 3C
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 4 of 9 5,057,227
6OO
2
2.
a 5OO
4OO
L
2
3OO
On 2OO
S
C
1OO
1O 20 3O 4O 5O 6O 7O 8O
BIREFRINGENCE, PERCENT
FG, 4A
CD
2
2
C
s
L
na
L
2
-
X
X
l
Cl
1O 20 3O 4O 5O 6O 7O 8O
BREFRINGENCE, PERCENT
FG. 4B
c 12O
2
2 O
C
1.
1oo
y 90
ly
O
8O
s 7o
l
C 6O
1O 20 3O 4O 5O 6O 7O 8O
BREFRINGENCE, PERCENT
FG. 4C
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 5 of 9 5,057,227
6OO
4.5O O
3 OO
2O O
1OO
2O 3O 4O 5O 6O
POROSITY, PERCENT
F.G. 5A
6O
5O
| 4O
3O
2O
1O
12O
2O 3O 4O
POROSITY, PERCENT
F.G. 5B
5O
11O
1OO
9O
8O
7O
6O
2O 3O 4O 5O
POROSITY, PERCENT
F.G. 5C
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 6 of 9 5,057,227
6OO
O
3OO
2O O
1OO
O 5 1O 15
ASH CONTENT, PERCENT
F.G. 6A
6O
|
5O
4O
3O
2O
1O
O 5 1O 15
ASH CONTENT, PERCENT
F.G. 6B
12O
|
11O
1OO
9O
8O
6O
O 5 1O 15
ASH CONTENT, PERSENT
FIG. 6C
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 7 of 9 5,057,227
6OO
2
a 5OO
L
or 4OO
2
2
3OO
of 20O
s
On 1CO
O 11 12 13 14
TOTAL GUAACYL LIGNENS, PERCENT
FG. 7A
CD
2
2
C
S
L
2
-
>
X
s
Ol
Ol
1O 11 12 13 14
TOTAL GUAIACYL LIGNINS, PERCENT
FIG. 7B
cd 12O
2
2
a 110
1OO
E. 9o
y
8O
O
H
isl 7O
- 6O
1O 11 12 13 14
TOTAL GUAACYL LIGNINS, PERCENT
FIG. 7C
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 8 of 9 5,057,227
OO
|
5OO
4. O O
3 OO
3 4. 5 6
TOTAL FURANS, PERCENT
FG. 8A
3 4 5 6
TOTAL FURANS, PERCENT
FIG. 8B
12O
|
11O
1OO
9O
8O
3 4. 5 6
TOTAL FURANS, PERCENT
FIG. 8C
U.S. Patent Oct. 15, 1991 Sheet 9 of 9 5,057 227
LEAKING
UNDERGROUND N22%;
STORAGE
TANK
CONTAMINANT
PLUME
FG. 9A
PEAT-FILLED
TRENCH
LEAKING
UNDERGROUND-Ng W
STORAGE
TANK
CONTAMINANT
PLUME
FG. 9B
LEAKING
!NESOUND INs.
TANK
CONTAMINANT e
PLUME MMOBILIZED
NUTRENT LAYER
FIG. 10A
PEAT MATERAL
LAYER
LEAKING
NEESFOUND IN
TANK
CONTAMINANT
PLUME
MMOBLIZED NUTRENT LAYER
FIG. 10B
5,057,227
1 2
compatible with the surrounding soil and topology, yet
METHOD FOR N-STU. REMOVAL OF capable of removing the undesired contaminants from
HYDROCARBON CONTAMINANTS FROM groundwater.
GROUNDWATER Peat has long been valued for many uses, particularly
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
as a fuel, in agricultural and horticultural uses, and as a
raw feed stock for a variety of chemicals. More re
This invention relates to a method for in-situ removal cently, the use of peat materials in environmental pollu
of hydrocarbon contaminants from groundwater. More tion control applications has been studied, as described,
particularly, this invention relates to a method for in 10 for example, in J. K. McLellan & C. A. Rock, "The
situ removal of hydrocarbon contaminants in aqueous Application of Peat in Environmental Pollution Con
solution from groundwater in which the groundwater trol: A Review', in International Peat Journal, vol. 1,
containing the hydrocarbon contaminants is contacted pp. 1-14 (1986). More particularly, the use of peat and
with a permeable barrier comprising a peat material. peat mixtures as an absorbent for the removal of surface
The permeable barrier captures the hydrocarbon con oil on the surface of the ground or water, typically
taminants contained in solution within the groundwater, 5 caused by an oil spill, has been previously disclosed. For
and the purified groundwater thereafter exits from the example: U.S. Pat. No. 4,778,602 (Allen) discloses the
permeable barrier. use of a chemically modified peat material as a filtering
Loss of gasoline and other petroleum-derived hydro medium and for the removal of oil from water surfaces
carbons from underground storage tanks, pipelines and by sprinkling the finely powdered filtering media on the
other facilities is one of the major sources of groundwa 20 oil-laden water surface; European Patent Application
ter contamination in the United States. There are cur
rently about 1.4 million underground tanks storing gas No. 075,384 discloses a process for preparing an oil
oline in the United States. It has been estimated that 10 absorbent peat material which comprises mixing peat
percent or more of these tanks may be leaking and con with an alkaline earth metal basic product, drying the
taminating groundwater supplies. 25 mixture, adding additional alkaline earth metal basic
Conventional technology for managing groundwater product to the mixture, and heating the mixture until
which has become contaminated with hydrocarbon the peat has the desired moisture content; and Canadian
contaminants such as petroleum products may be cate Patent No. 1,135,241 (Mackey) discloses a method for
gorized into four categories: (1) containment of the collecting oil from oil spills by applying diatonnaceous
contaminants using either physical barriers (i.e. slurry 30 earth and a buoyant material which may be peat to an
cutoff walls or sheet pilings) or hydraulic barriers cre oil spill on a water surface, the buoyant material acting
ated by a system of injection and pumping wells; (2) to cause the clay-like product created by the oil-soaked
pumping of the contaminated groundwater to a treat diatomaceous earth to float for eventual removal.
ment process at the surface, followed by disposal or However, leaking underground gasoline storage
reuse of the treated water; (3) removal of contaminated 35 tanks, pipelines and the like typically cause contamina
soil, with subsequent soil treatment or disposal; and (4) tion of a given groundwater stream by a mechanism
in-place stabilization of aquifer contaminants. Fre wherein the individual organic contaminants contained
quently, in practice, a combination of one or more of therein are in solution with the aqueous groundwater
these alternatives is used, e.g. excavation of the most stream. Thus, the requirements for removal of hydro
highly contaminated soil combined with a pump-and 40 carbon contaminants such as gasoline and its compo
treat process for contaminated groundwater. nents (e.g. benzene, toluene, and xylene) in solution
Although conventional groundwater restoration from groundwater are distinct from those where hydro
techniques are effective when properly designed and carbons such as oil are removed by absorption from
implemented, they continue to have numerous prob ground or water surfaces; i.e., the removal of hydrocar
lems associated with them. These include: (1) large 45
bon contaminants in aqueous solution from groundwa
amounts of water to be treated; (2) undesirable by-pro ter requires adsorption of the contaminants by an ad
ducts; (3) large and long-term disruption of the site; and sorbing medium capable of removing the contaminants
(4) extensive amounts of time required for complete site in aqueous solution from the groundwater.
restoration.
In view of the foregoing, it would clearly be advanta 50 It is one object of this invention to provide a method
geous to employ a method of removing hydrocarbon for in-situ removal of hydrocarbon contaminants such
contaminants from groundwater in-situ, thereby treat as gasoline and its components from groundwater, in
ing the groundwater and simultaneously avoiding many which groundwater containing hydrocarbon contami
of the problems attendant to the above-described meth nants in aqueous solution is contacted in-situ with a
ods. One in-situ technique for removing hydrocarbon 55 permeable barrier comprising a peat material. It is one
contaminants from groundwater which has been sug feature of this invention that the removal of hydrocar
gested is the use of a permeable barrier in-situ which bon contaminants from aqueous solution with the
allows passage of groundwater therethrough but inter groundwater is accomplished with greater efficiency,
cepts soluble contaminants, as disclosed, for example in lower capital costs, lower operating costs, and reduced
B. M. Thomson & S. P. Shelton, "Permeable Barriers: surface and other environmental disturbances in com
A New Alternative for Treatment of Contaminated parison with typical conventional techniques as previ
Groundwaters', in Proceedings of the Focus Confer ously described. Thus, the method of this invention
ence on Southwest Groundwater Issues, Association of advantageously has lower costs associated with it than
Groundwater Scientists and Engineers, pp. 441-53 (Al conventional means of removing hydrocarbon contami
buquerque, N.M. 1988). However, the makeup of such a 65 nants in aqueous solution from groundwater, and in
permeable barrier is critical in the in-situ removal of addition advantageously avoids large disruptions of
hydrocarbon contaminants from groundwater, in that ground surfaces, as well as the use of large quantities of
the material employed must be relatively low in cost, water, which often are difficult to obtain, and may
5,057,227
3 4
themselves become contaminated, posing further prob bly 80% or less, more preferably 60% or less, a guaiacyl
lems of treatment and disposal. lignin pyrolysis product content of preferably at least
It is another object of this invention to provide a 10%, more preferably at least 12% and a furan pyrolysis
method for in-situ removal of hydrocarbon contami product content of preferably at least 0.1%, more pref.
nants such as gasoline and its components from ground- 5 erably at least 2%.
water, in which hydrocarbon contaminants in aqueous In one preferred embodiment of this invention, a
solution are removed by contacting the groundwater groundwater stream containing hydrocarbon containi
in-situ with a permeable barrier comprising in series a nants is contacted in-situ with a permeable barrier com
combination of an immobilized nutrient layer and a peat prising a peat material, wherein the permeable barrier is
material layer, with the permeable barrier positioned 10
substantially perpendicular to the groundwater stream positioned
ter stream
substantially perpendicular to the groundwa
incident thereto. In another preferred em
incident thereto. It is another feature of this invention
bodiment of this invention, a groundwater stream con
that the immobilized nutrient layer enhances the natural taining hydrocarbon
degradation of the hydrocarbon contaminants, and any contaminants is contacted in-situ
contaminants which are not degraded in the immobi- 15 with a permeable barrier which comprises in series an
lized nutrient layer are adsorbed by the peat material immobilized nutrient layer and a peat material layer, the
layer, thus advantageously avoiding large disruptions of permeable barrier being positioned substantially per
ground surfaces and the use of large quantities of water. pendicular to the groundwater stream incident thereto,
It is yet another object of this invention to provide a with the groundwater stream first contacting the immo
method for in-situ removal of hydrocarbon contami- 20 bilized nutrient layer and thereafter contacting the peat
nants in solution in groundwater in which the ground material layer. The immobilized nutrient layer may
water is contacted in-situ with a permeable barrier com typically comprise one or more components selected
prising a peat material, wherein the peat material is from the group consisting of limestones, clays, iron
characterized by having ash content, birefringent or oxides, coals, soils, and fly ashes.
ganic content, fiber content, guaiacyl lignin pyrolysis 25 This invention is advantageous over conventional
product content and furan pyrolysis product content methods for removing hydrocarbon contaminants in
values within a specified range, and thus is more effec aqueous solution from groundwater streams in that it
tive in removing hydrocarbon contaminants in solution avoids the use of large amounts of water, it avoids the
with groundwater than other peat materials not charac production of undesirable by-products, it avoids large
terized by having such values. It is yet another feature 30 and long-term disruption of the particular site, and its
of this invention that a peat material characterized by avoids the large costs typically associated with tech
having such values of the above-described parameters,
as specified herein, advantageously adsorbs hydrocar niques such as removal of contaminated Soil and/or
bon contaminants such as gasoline and its components pumping of contaminated groundwater to a treatment
process.
in aqueous solution in groundwater. 3S
It is yet another object of this invention to provide a BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
method for in-situ removal of hydrocarbon contami
nants in solution in groundwater, in accordance with FIGS. 1A-1E depict experimental results obtained
this invention, wherein naturally occurring peat materi for benzene absorption for various peat materials.
als are employed in the permeable barrier having the 40 FIGS. 2A-2D depict experimental results obtained
contaminant-laden groundwater stream incident for adsorption for various hydrocarbon compounds and
thereto. It is yet another feature of this invention that various peat materials.
naturally occurring peat materials may be employed in FIGS. 3A-3C depict experimental results obtained
the permeable barrier of this invention, thus advanta for various peat materials for hydrocarbon compound
geously avoiding the use of chemically treated peat 45 adsorption vs. peat material fiber content.
materials, which are typically more expensive and less FIGS. 4A-4C depict experimental results obtained
readily available than naturally occurring peat materi for various peat materials for hydrocarbon compound
als, and which may have other attendant problems asso adsorption vs. peat material birefringence.
ciated with their use in-situ. FIGS. 5A-5C depict experimental results obtained
50 for various peat materials for hydrocarbon compound
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
adsorption vs. peat material porosity.
This invention is directed to a method for in-situ
removal of hydrocarbon contaminants from groundwa forFIGS. 6A-6C depict experimental results obtained
various peat materials for hydrocarbon compound
ter, where the contaminants are in aqueous solution adsorption vs. peat material ash content.
with the groundwater. The method of this invention 55
comprises contacting in-situ groundwater containing forFIGS. 7A-7C depict experimental results obtained
various peat materials for hydrocarbon compound
hydrocarbon contaminants in aqueous solution there adsorption vs. peat material guaiacyl lignin pyrolysis
with such as gasoline and its components with a perme
able barrier comprising a peat material. It has been product content.
found that naturally occurring peat materials character- 60 FIGS. 8A-8C depict experimental results obtained
ized by having values within a specified range for cer for various peat materials for hydrocarbon compound
tain parameters are particularly effective in recovering adsorption vs. peat material furan pyrolysis product
such hydrocarbon contaminants. More particularly, the COItent.
naturally-occurring peat material preferably employed FIGS. 9A and 9B, respectively, depict cross-sectional
in this invention preferably has an ash content of 25%. 65 and plan views of one embodiment of this invention.
or less, more preferably in the range of 5-25%, a bire FIGS. 10A and 10B, respectively, depict cross-sec
fringent organic content of preferably 80% or less, tion and plan views of another embodiment of this in
more preferably 60% or less, a fiber content of prefera vention.
5,057,227
5 6
As used in this description and in the appended claims,
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED peat material comprises both naturally occurring and
EMBODIMENTS chemically treated or modified peat materials, although
The method of this invention comprises contacting, naturally occurring peat material which has not been
in-situ, groundwater containing hydrocarbon contami- 5 chemically treated or admixed with otter reagents is
nants such as gasoline in aqueous solution with a perme- particularly preferred.
able barrier comprising a peat material. To determine the efficacy of the use of various types
As used in this description and in the appended of peat materials in this invention, peat samples with
claims, the term "hydrocarbon contaminants' refers to different compositions were tested for their capacities
organic contaminants which are typically associated 10 to extract pure hydrocarbons (benzene, toluene, m
with groundwater pollution due to the leakage of un- xylene) as both emulsions in water and in saturated
derground storage tanks, pipe lines and the like, and solution in water. These peat samples were subjected to
which are in solution with the groundwater stream or detailed chemical and physical analyses, prior to being
body which is treated in accordance with this invention. tested so that it could be established, which, if any of
Accordingly, ordinary absorption techniques such as 15 these measured compositional parameters correlated
those typically employed in methods for the removal of with extraction capacity.
surface oil contamination from ground surfaces and The peat samples utilized in these tests are shown in
water surfaces are ineffective in the hydrocarbon con- Table 1. These consisted of: 1) a highly decomposed,
taminated groundwater systems to which the present Taxodium-Persea, woody peat from the Okefenokee
invention relates. In one particularly preferred embodi- 20 Swamp of Georgia; 2) a moderately decomposed, Nym
ment, "hydrocarbon contaminants' refers to the com- phaea-Sagittaria peat from the Loxahatchee National
ponents of fuel compositions such as gasoline and the Wildlife Refuge in Florida; 3) a moderately decom
like, including benzene, toluene, xylenes, ethers, organ- posed, spruce-woody dicot peat from Minnesota; 4) a
ic-based fuel additive compositions, and other organic moderately decomposed, grass-sedge-fern peat from the
constituents of motor fuel compositions such as gasoline 25 Loxahatchee National Wildlife refuge in Florida; 5) a
and the like. Such compounds typically contaminate moderately decomposed Nymphaea-Sagittaria-grass
groundwater streams due to leakage from underground sedge peat from the Okefenokee Swamp of Georgia;
storage tanks and/or pipelines. and 6) a relatively undecomposed, Sphagnum peat from
As used in this description and in the appended Maine. The hydrocarbons used for testing consisted of
claims, the term "peat material" refers to an accumula- 30 HPLC grade toluene, benzene, and 99% anhydrous
tion of partly decomposed plant material, which may m-xylene (obtained from Aldrich Chemical Company
vary in consistency from a fibrous matted material to a Inc.).
TABLE
Types and Source Locations of Peat Samples Tested
SAMPLE DOMINANT BOTANICAL ASTM CLASS BY
DESIGNATION LOCATION COMPONENTS FIBER CONTENT
Oke. Tax. Okefenokee Swamp, GA Taxodium (cypress) & Sapric
Persea (bay)
Lox. Nym. Loxahatchee Wildlife Nymphaea (waterlily) & Henic
Refuge, FL Sagittaria (arrowhead)
Min. Hemic Minnesota Spruce & Woody Dicots Hemic
Lox. Sawgrass Loxahatchee Wildlife Grass-sedge, fern, Helic
Refuge, FL Nymphaea
Oke. Nyn. Okefenokee Swamp, GA Nymphaea, Sagittaria, Hemic
Grass-sedge
Maine Sphag. Maine Sphagnum (peat moss) Fibric
ASTM Standard Classification of Peat Sanples by Laboratory Testing (D4427-84)
highly decomposed mud. Peat material typically con- A number of physical property parameters were de
tains both organic matter derived from the decomposed termined for each of the peat samples tested. These
plants and inorganic or mineral matter derived from so parameters consisted of bulk density, fiber content, pH,
both the decomposed plants and from clay and sand porosity, and birefringence. The values obtained for
which has either been washed or blown in during the each peat sample are set forth in Table 2.
TABLE 2
Physical Properties of Peats
BIREFRIN
BULK FIBER GENT
DENSITY CONTENT pH POROSITY ORGANIC
SAMPLE DESIG. (g/cm) (area %) (in water) (area 26) (area %)
Oke. Tax. 0.123 17.5 3.14 36 20
Lox. Nym. 0.069 40.0 7.94 37 52
Minn. Hemic 0.124 55.5 4.78 29 48
Lox. Sawgrass 0.076 48.0 6.65 41 43
Oke. Nym. 0.078 50,0 4.53 52 54
Maine Sphag. 0.083 80.5 4.29 48 78
TABLE 4
Inorganic Chemical Composition of Peats
(wt.% of whole peat sample by XRF-modified from Raymond et al.)
SAMPLE
DESIGNATION Si Ti Al Fe Mn Mig Ca Na K P
Oke. Tax. 5.4 0.02 0.30 0.11 tr 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.05
Lox. Nym. 0.7 0.01 0.20 0.36 tr 0.10 1.66 0.05 0.02 0.02
Minn. Hemic 2.8 0.04 0.63 0.72 tr 0.10 0.60 0.06 0.16 0.05
Lox. Sawgrass 0.5 0.01 0.16 0.20 tr 0.29 2.40 0.04 0.02 0.02
Oke. Nym. 5.1 0.01 0.21 0.20 0.3 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02
Maine Sphag. O. tr. 0.06 0.03 tr 0.20 0.09 0.02 0.01 0.02
trace
45
50
55
60
65
. . . UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION
Page 1 of 2
PATENT NO. : 5,057, 227
DATED ; October 15, 1991
NVENTOR (S) : Arthur D. Cohen
It is certified that error appears in the above-identified patent and that said Letters Patent is hereby
corrected as shown below:
On the Title page;
In Section (56), References Cited on page 1 the U.S. and
foreign patent documents and articles cited by the Examiner
on Form PTO-1 449 in the Office Action dated December 26,
1990, as set forth below, were omitted and should be
included:
Attest:
MICHAEL K. KIRK