Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. What is a Work of Art? Traditional Approaches and Fish’s Theory of Interpretive Communities
3. To be able to do that, we must already know what objects are work of art, what objects are not.
4. If we can do that, we have already had the knowledge of what art is.
- authorial/artistic intention-problems:
- certain artworks were clearly not intended as such (e.g. the Venus of Millendorf)
- canon – problems:
- authoritarian
- highly debatable
- hermeneutic circle
- values
- symbols
- interpretive strategies
- tradition
- canon(s)
- …
- consensual
- liable to changes
- not absolute
High Culture: +
- non-canonized
Mass Culture: --
- negative influence
Popular Culture: +
- empowering
2. The Basics of Poetry: Rhyme, Meter, Tropes and Figures
⋆Rhyme:
⋆Meter:
∙The basic unit of poetic meter is the foot, which is composed of a particular number and order of stressed and unstressed
syllables.
x x pyrrhic
∙1 foot: monometer
∙2 feet: dimeter
∙3 feet: trimeter
∙4 feet: tetrameter
∙5 feet: pentameter
∙6 feet: hexameter
∙When noting down the meter of a poem, feet are separated by vertical lines:
∙Breaks and stops in the poem are indicated by slanted lines: / or // or /// (depending on the length of the pause)
∙ If the break is at the end of the line, the line is an end-stopped line (otherwise a run-on line)
Sound:
∙ Repetition: the same words or longer units used more times, creating a peculiar effect
∙ Rhyme: the repetition of the sound or sounds at the end of words, usually (but not necessarily) at the end of the poetic
line
∙ Eye-rhyme: a pairing of words that only looks like rhyme, but does not work as such when read aloud
∙ Alliteration:
b) the significant repetition of the same (or related) initial, medial or final consonants
Simile: a figure of speech comparing two dissimilar things. The comparison is often shown by “as” or “like”
Metaphor: a compressed simile. The two unlike things are not compared, but identified.
vehicle – what the original subject is identified with connecting verb – the verb connecting the tenor and the
vehicle, often “to be”
Time is money.
Personification: a thing, an abstraction or an animal is represented as a person, or distinctively human features are
attributed to them
Metonymy: a change of names; calling something as something else which is closely associated or connected with it. The
ground is not similarity, but contiguity.
Synesthesia: combining two sensory inputs into one picture in a way that one is describing the other.
Oxymoron: a figure of speech combining two contradictory terms, thereby forming a paradoxical relation.
Allegory: a type of extended metaphor, used to represent abstract ideas or principles by concrete characters, figures or
events that are typically associated with those abstract qualities.
Anaphora: a scheme in which the same word or phrase is repeated at the beginning of successive lines or sentences.
In time the flint is pierced with softest shower. Thomas Kyd, Spanish Tragedy
The Fox and the Crow
A Fox once saw a Crow fly off with a piece of cheese in its beak and settle on a branch of a tree. "That's for me, as I am
a Fox," said Master Reynard, and he walked up to the foot of the tree. "Good-day, Mistress Crow," he cried. "How well
you are looking to-day: how glossy your feathers; how bright your eye. I feel sure your voice must surpass that of other
birds, just as your figure does; let me hear but one song from you that I may greet you as the Queen of Birds." The Crow
lifted up her head and began to caw her best, but the moment she opened her mouth the piece of cheese fell to the ground,
only to be snapped up by Master Fox. "That will do," said he. "That was all I wanted. In exchange for your cheese I will
give you a piece of advice for the future:
And God said, Let the earth bring forth the living creature after his kind, cattle, and creeping thing, and beast of the earth
after his kind: and it was so. And God made the beast of the earth after his kind, and cattle after their kind, and every
thing that creepeth upon the earth after his kind: and God saw that it was good.
Genesis 1:24-25
Epizeuxis: a figure in which the same word is repeated consecutively for emphasis.
“Rhett, Rhett, Rhett! If you go, where shall I go? What shall I do?”
“that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the
survival and the success of liberty” (JFK)
“He was a bag of bones, a floppy doll, a broken stick, a maniac.” (Jack Kerouac, On the Road)
3. The Basics of Formalist and Structuralist Analysis (de Saussure, Jakobson, Barthes), Key Terms in Narratology
(Chomsky: competence)
(Chomsky: performance)
Language pre-exists thought = there is no thinking before language. Thus, the fundamental characteristics of language
determine our thinking.
The value of a signed is assigned to it by its role/position in the system, and that only. What makes a signifier a signifier
is that it is not another signifier, and not any kind of connection with a signified concept.
context (1)
message (6)
∙ The originator of meaning, and the proper object of analysis is the text itself. (NOT the Author's Intention, NOT the
historical context, etc.)
∙ Types of narration:
∙ Antagonist: the character who is acting against the interests of the protagonist
∙ Donor: a character who gives an object to the protagonist, without which it would be impossible to reach his/her goal
⋆Roland Barthes - Introduction to the Structural Analysis of Narratives
!(asi to nejpřehlednější, co jsem na netu mohl najít-bohužel nemohu zcela ručit za věrohodnost, avšak projížděl jsem to i
s jednou vědeckou prací a ten diagram odpovídá
http://www.pierregander.com/phd/courses/narratology/barthes.html)
Barthes, R. (1996). Introduction to the structural analysis of narratives. In S. Onega, & J. A. G. Landa (Eds.),
Narratology (pp. 45-60). New York: Longman.
In this article Roland Barthes outlines a structural theory of narrative - inspired by structural linguistics, the Prague
School, Russian formalism, and structural anthropology - that is a grammar capable of accounting for every conceivable
narrative.
He proposes that one should study the structure of narratives, and that, he claims, can only be found in the narratives
themselves. He proposes that one looks at how linguistics have done, and study structures beyond the sentence.
Narratives, as an example of structures of meaning, can be studied on different levels of description. Terms acquire
meaning not in isolation, but in relationship with other terms, on the same level, and on different levels. Narratives are a
hierarchy of instances. Barthes describes three levels: functions (bottom level), actions (middle level), and narration (top
level), summarized in this diagram:
narrative communication
narrative situation
catalysers (complementary)
Functions are the smallest unit of narrative, something that may not have meaning directly but which acquire meaning in
combination with other units, on the same level or on a higher level. Functions can in some cases be shorter than the
sentence, even parts of a word. A unit can belong to more than one class. Informants and indices can combine freely. A
catalyser implies the existence of a nuclei to which it can connect. Nuclei are bound together by a relation of solidarity. A
sequence is a logical succession of nuclei bound together by a relation of solidarity. Sequences can be included in other,
larger sequences, still on the 'functional' level.
Actions is the level of characters. Characters in the narrative are classified, not in terms of psychological essences, but
according to their participation in actions. Actions often have two sides. For instance 'Giving' has a Donor and a
Receiver. Example of actions are desire, communication, struggle.
The narrational level include narrative communication (author, narrator, and 'reader') and narrative situation ("the set of
protocols according to which the narrative is 'consumed'." (p. 58)). Here is included different styles of representation,
'point of view', coded signs of narrative ('once upon a time', etc.).
4. Psychoanalytic Criticism: Freud, Lacan and Kristeva
⋆Sigmund Freud
-fears
-traumas
-one‘s actions are more influenced by unconscious factors than by his or her rational decisions
∙ dreams
-latent content – the part of real importance, unfortunately not available for study
-the latent content appears in the manifest content, but only symbolically, through two basic processes:
- condensation: two or more unconscious elements combine to make up a complex image or situation
-displacement: the emotion or desire is directed towards another, usually indifferent thing or person
-sexuality, as well as fears and desires appear early on in the psychological development of the child (no innocent child)
-at first the child is one with the mother, and experiences his/her separation from her as a trauma
∙ Oedipus complex:
- sees and/or hears the parents having sex, and misidentifies it as the father‘s aggression and violence
- at some point, sees that his mother does not have a penis
- connects these two unconnected facts, and believes that his father cut his mother‘s penis off, to punish her
- concludes that if he continues the rivalization between himself and the father, his will be cut off, too
- thus, he accepts the father‘s absolute power and decides to get a mother, rather than the mother
⋆Jacques Lacan
-the child first realizes that he is not one with the mother when he sees himself in the mirror
-unfortunately, he is wrong:
-one‘s realization of his identity cannot happen without having a knowledge of some language
- thus, identity and subjectivity is only possible following the conditions provided by language
- that name is never one‘s own in the sense of having chosen by one
- it is partially directly provided by the father (last name), partially chosen by him (first name)
- no thinking or meaningful human activity is possible without using language (cf. Ferdinand de Saussure)
- language can be conceived as a collection of utterances by individuals
- in the moment a child learns to speak, he is forced to participate in the Symbolic Order, and unconsciously obey its
rules
⋆Julia Kristeva: (from Julia Kristeva: Live Theory, John Lechte, Maria Margaroni)
- she commends Lacan for showing how the place of the third-that is, the father who will be put to death by Oedipus- is
the place of the symbolic
- following Lacan, she emphasizes the connecting, mediating value of the paternal space, which she too separates from
the Freudian super-ego
- like Lacan, she places herself among the disciples of the “dead” father→ for it is only he, she insists, who (in the death)
will open up the subject to the realization that there is no signifier that is not lacking
-yet, there is certainly an inverse side in the mirroring relation between father and daughter
-the place of the Third is not only the symbolic but also the symbolic(43)
-Kristeva´s return to Oedipus is accompanied by an investigation of its limits, which is, in her view, precisely what has
been left out in traditional psychoanalysis
-according to Kristeva, the Freudian tradition has the advantage of having underscored the structuring role of Oedipus
and the phallus. →but it perhaps has the disadvantage of having done so without indicating forms of modification,
transgression and revolt vis-á-vis this order
-Kristeva demonstrates an equal concern for the latter as she does for the former→her acknowledged debt to the father
remains inseparable from a more archaic bonding
Rethinking of Oedipus
-in contrast to both Freud and Lacan, her aim is to reconceptualise the production of post-Oedipal subjectivity in light of
a double debt: to the father as well as the mother
5. Gender Studies and Queer Studies in Literary and Cultural Criticism: Rich, Butler, Laqueur
Gender roles
- a set of:
- values
- attitudes
- behavioral models
- responses
- …
- role models
- family
- church
- peer groups
⋆Queer Theory:
- the word „queer" in queer theory has some connotations (odd, gay), particularly its alignment with ideas about
homosexuality
-queer theory insist that all sexual behaviours, all concepts linking sexual behaviours to sexual identities, and all
categories of normative and deviant sexualities, are social constructs, sets of signifiers, which create certain types of
social meaning
-follow gay/lesbian and feminist theory in rejecting the idea that sexuality is an essential category
-sexuality is a complex array of social codes and forces, forms of individual activity and institutional power, which
interact to shape the ideas of what is normative and what is deviant at any particular moment→ then operate under the
rubric of what is “natural”, “essential”, “biological”, “god-given”
- underacting: androgyny
-gender as the identification with one sex, or one object (like the mother), is a fantasy, a set of internalized images, and
not a set of properties governed by the body and its organ configuration
- gender is a set of signs internalized, psychically imposed on the body and on one´s psychic sense of identity→ gender
is thus not a primary category, but an attribute, a set of secondary narrative effects
-gender is an act, a performance, costumes rather than a core aspect of essential identity
Making Sex:
- "female" reproductive organs are the turned-out versions of the "male" ones
- the actual drawings are accurate → not because of the lack of knowledge, simply a different interpretation
"Scientific" Evidence:
- development of organs caused not directly by the genes, but the presence or absence of a hormone → possibility of
divergence
- hermaphroditism:
- transexuality
- Fa'afafines in Samoa
- an American poet, essayist and feminist. She has been called "one of the most widely read and influential
poets of the second half of the 20th century“
- Rich argues that heterosexuality is a violent political institution making way for the "male right of physical,
economical, and emotional access" to women
- She urges women to direct their energies towards other women rather than men, and portrays lesbianism as
an extension of feminism
-Biologically men have only one innate orientation--a sexual one that draws them to women--while women
have two innate orientations, sexual toward men and reproductive toward their young
-he uses eight characteristics of male power in archaic and contemporary societies (from the essay “The Origin of the
Family by Kathleen Cough) as a framework
1) to deny women [our own] sexuality - by means of clitoridectomy and infibulation; chastity belts;
punishment, including death, for female adultery; for lesbian sexuality, …
2) or to force it [male sexuality] upon them-by means of rape (including marital rape) and wife beating; father-
daughter, brother-sister incest, idealization of heterosexual romance in art, literature, media, …
3) to command or exploit their labor to control their produce-by means of the institutions of marriage and
motherhood as unpaid production; the horizontal segregation of women in paid employment, …
4) to control or rob them of their children - by means of father-right and "legal“ kidnapping, enforced
sterilization, systematized infanticide, …
5) to confine them physically and prevent their movement - by means of rape as terrorism, keeping women off
the stress, prescriptions for "full-time" mothering; enforced economic dependence of wives…
6) to use them as objects in male transactions - use of women as "gifts, arranged marriage; use of women as
entertainers to facilitate male deals,…
7) to cramp their creativeness - sexual exploitation of women by male artists and teachers; the social and
economic disruption of women's creative aspirations…
8) to withhold from them large areas of the society's knowledge and cultural attainments- sex-role
stereotyping that deflects women from science, technology, and other "masculine" pursuits…
-The effect of male-identification means:
internalizing the values of the colonizer and actively participating in carrying out the colonization of one's self and one's
sex. . . Male identification is the act whereby women place men above women, including themselves, in credibility,
status, and importance in most situations, regardless of the comparative quality the women may bring to the situation....
Interaction with women is seen as a lesser form of relating on every level.
(Gough does not perceive these power-characteristics as specifically enforcing heterosexuality; only as
producing sexual inequality) (from Zeno´s UDKS link)
- The characteristics show that society has forgotten that it is necessary (in order to function) to include women in both
public and private spheres
- the ignorance of a female’s choice in sexuality has caused her position in society to be thought of as less, and more
importantly, secondary to that of a man
- a recurring point that Rich points out is the destruction of lesbian experiences in history (misplacement of documents,
or destroying them in general) has led to a society in which having a lesbian experience, or being a lesbian all together is
seen as ‘the other’ and unacceptable to most men and women
-Rich argues that part of the lesbian experience is an act of resistance: specifically, a rejection of the
patriarchy and the male right to women
-at certain points in history, homosexual men and lesbians have shared a social existence, and acknowledged a
common fight against society –> but to treat the lesbian experience as a version of male homosexuality is to
discard it, denying the female experience and the realities it brings, falsifying lesbian history
-Rich holds that compulsory heterosexuality denies women of their own sexuality and comfortability in exploring their
bodies and those of others
-she claims that compulsory heterosexuality produces such myths as that of the vaginal orgasm
-that serves to imply that only a man can sexually satisfy a woman (by delivering a vaginal orgasm), and hence that
serves to prevent women from having relationships with other women!
6. Ideology, Discourse and Subjectivity: Althusser and Žižek
Louis Althusser, "Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses" in Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays (1971)
- Repressive State Apparatuses (RSA): prisons, the police, criminal justice system, mental hospitals, etc.
- Ideological State Apparatuses (ISA): schools, religions, legal systems, stories and myths, etc.
Ideologies Ideology
specific structural
historical eternal
differing unchancing
content form fo
- gives the illusion that we can freely choose and that we are in charge
- "Ideology is a 'representation' of the Imaginary Relationship of Individuals to their Real conditions of existence"
- the material relations of capitalist production are alienating –> people make up stories to deal with reality
- ideology is not some fiction about the real world, but fiction about our relation to that "real world"
- ideology makes subjects out of concrete individuals –> no subject without ideological positioning
2. We are always and already subjects in ideology. Others' beliefs are illusory, ours are true.
1. What is a Work of Art? Traditional Approaches and Fish’s Theory of Interpretive Communities
-Identification by M. Heiddeger (running in a circle)
-Stanley Fish (+High and Low Culture)
-Meter (basic unit: foot- Types of lines based on the number of feet-1. monometer, 2. dimeter, etc…)
3. The Basics of Formalist and Structuralist Analysis (de Saussure, Jakobson, Barthes), Key Terms in Narratology
-Ferdinand de Saussure (Sign = signifier + signified)
-Roman Jakobson (model of communication)
-Roland Barthes (structural analysis of narratives)
-basics of narratology
5. Gender Studies and Queer Studies in Literary and Cultural Criticism: Rich, Butler, Laqueur + Cixious
-Gender roles
-queer theory (all sexual behaviours are social constructs)
-Judith Butler (gender troubles)
-Thomas Laqueur (Sex as a Social Construct)
-Adrienne Rich (Compulsory Heterosexuality and Lesbian Existence-lesbian experience is an act of resistance:
specifically, a rejection of the patriarchy and the male right to women)