Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rico make decisions, the social worker in Puerto Rico in 1947, a tolleague
from a nearby town referred a case to her
worker encounters attitudes, that she still remembers vividly. It ex-
li f e-styles, and economic and social emplifies a principle as vital today as it was
32 1 MARCH 1973
Social Work in Puerto Rico 1 33
tions for the social work profession today. studies showed that 6 percent of all families
Are people free to choose? When should so- receiving economic assistance in St. Paul,
cial workers intervene? Should they be faith- Minnesota, were consuming more than half
ful always to the principle of self-determina- the community's social welfare services.
tion? These families—later known as "multiprob-
What does "determination" mean? The lem," "hard-to-reach," "hard-core," needed
SOCIAL WORK
34 1 RODRIGUEZ
"At present the average monthly public assistance payment per recipient
is $13.55 in Puerto Rico compared with $118.35 for the United States
as a whole. It barely covers 45 percent of the basic needs in the
these doctrines try to cope with man's feel- erty of the people, and relationships with
ings of alienation and powerlessness. 12 the United States, (2) geographic limita-
Although many persons find it increas- tions, and (3) the development of social
ingly difficult to make decisions under pres- work under governmental auspices.
ent-day conditions, social workers must These areas are not mutually exclusive.
strive to give them maximum opportunity to In fact, they often overlap. In many in.
do so, thus helping them to perceive their stances, points of view expressed represent
value as human beings, feel a greater sense inferences derived from the author's profes-
of mission in life, and enhance their social sional experience, but they may serve as a
functioning. It is important, however, that starting point for more rigorous research.
those in the social work profession remem-
ber the right of a human being to his pri- COLONIZATION
vate life. They must be sure that they are
not intruders, but rather liberating agents Puerto Rico was colonized by Spain under
for a fuller life. Social workers have been a suppressive regime characterized by the
accused of being invading agents because hacienda system, which tended to destroy
of their application forms, questionnaires, the inlanders' initiative. The peaceful In-
telephone and tape-recorded interviews, dians inhabiting the island were over-
photographs, and other means of gathering whelmed by the Spanish conquerors.
data for records or research studies. 13 In 1898, with a newly granted autono-
The growing concern about the principle mous charter, Puerto Rico switched
of self-determination in the United States abruptly to colonial status under the United
has increased the author's long-time interest States. The island and mainland cultures
in this subject. If on the mainland, which clashed: one Catholic, traditional, and
is highly esteemed for its democratic con- agrarian; the other Protestant, liberal, and
victions and its liberty, there are problems industrial. In 1917 the Jones Act granted
in applying this concept to social work prac- American citizenship to the Puerto Rican
tice, it might be wise to review and revise people. Its provisions also allowed more
its application to social work practice in money for the island's economic activities
Puerto Rico. The author touched on this and for programs of social welfare.
issue in an article about the changing In 1946, Senior, director of the Social Sci-
role of social workers on the island. 14 The ence Research Center of the University of
present paper explores the issue further and Puerto Rico, urged the U.S. government
suggests a substantial revision in applying to "end our colonial system in Puerto Rico
the principle. at the earliest moment possible." He stated
Self-determination in Puerto Rico must that Puerto Ricans were second-class citi-
be viewed from a different perspective than zens, whose civil liberties were directly de-
that used on the mainland. Three main pendent on congressional action, not on the
factors account for this: (1) the historical Bill of Rights or the Constitution. He also
development of the island, which includes criticized the United States for the appar-
the effects of colonization, the extreme pov- ent lack of a public policy for Puerto Rico,
MARCH 1978
Social Work in Puerto Rico 1 35
pointing out that "national policies were activity—did not exceed fourteen cents an
applied in some cases whether or not they hour. 19 Life expectancy was 46 years. 20
fit the local circumstances, where in others Apathy and indolence contributed to the
there is discrimination against the is- prevailing state of misery. Add to such con-
land." 15 It was not until 1952 that P.L. ditions long colonization, passivity, and se-
600 and a referendum granted Puerto Rico clusiveness, and one can see why many in
SOCIAL WORK
36 1 RODRIGUEZ
MARCH 1973
Social Work in Puerto Rico 1 37
SOCIAL WORK
38 1 RODRIGUEZ
right. Attitudes like these might lead the lack of self-determination. A popular
worker to have false expectations about the Puerto Rican saying: "El que no tiene
client's participation. Many times the cli- padrinos no se bautiza" (He who has no
ent has not fulfilled promised planning by godparents will not be baptized) explicitly
the time he comes to his schedeled appoint- recognizes this dependence on others.
ment. This has been a common experience Another important factor related to the
MARCH 1973
Social Work in Puerto Rico 1 39
cies and programs. They can no longer (New York: Family Service Association of America,
evade the vital issues. They have been en- 1959), p. 34.
dowed with a privilege not available to 7. Bradley Buell et al., Community Planning for
Human Services (New York: Columbia University
past generations—the privilege of living Press, 1952).
in a decisive period for Puerto Rico, in a
8. See, for example, Saul Bernstein, "Self-deter-
situation in which it is possible for them to
SOCIAL WORK
40 1 RODRfGUEZ
19. Harvey S. Perloff, Puerto Rico's Economic 25. Rosa C. Marin, "Necesidades de Personal en
Future (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, los Programas de Bienestar Social," Revista Hu-
1950), pp. 10-11. manidad, Graduate School of Social Work, Univer-
sity of Puerto Rico, 1 (December 1967), pp. 35-39.
20. Charles T. Goodsell, "Administración de una
Revolución," (Rio Piedras, P.R.: University of 26. Stycos, op. cit., p. 573.
Puerto Rico Press, 1967), p. 15. 27. Rexford Guy Tugwell, "Dignidad and Its
MARCH 1973